_I~_     _   _ ____               _ ~__
                       _ __~___1_~~_^11__
                                       _I_ II__   __   ~~   ~_   __ __

        ANNUAL REPORTS, WAR DEPARTMENT
                FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 1909




                   REPORT OF THE

       CHIEF OF ENGINEERS
            U. S. ARMY

                           1909
                      IN THREE PARTS

                        PART I




                       WASHINGTON
                GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE
                           1909
                 ANNUAL REPORT
                        OF THE




CHIEF                OF ENGINEERS,
           UNITED STATES ARMY.




                      1909.


9001-ENG 1909   1
    WAR DEPARTMENT.

      Document No. 351.

Office of the Chief of Engineers.


2
                                       REPORT
                                                 OF


   THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                           UNITED            STATES           ARMY.




                                              WAR DEPARTMENT,
                                 OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                                   Washington, September   1909.                     29,
  SIn: I have the honor to present for your information the follow-
ing report upon the duties and operations of the Engineer Depart-
ment for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909.

       OFFICERS OF THE CORPS                                   OF ENGINEERS.

   The number of officers holding commissions in the Corps of Engi-
neers at the end of the fiscal year was 183, a net increase during the
year of 11.
   Since July 1, 1908, the Corps of Engineers has lost 4 of its officers-
Col. Thomas W. Symons, who was retired from active service on July
28, 1908, upon his own application, under the provisions of section
1243, Revised Statutes, after more than thirty-seven years' service;
Col. Richard L. Hoxie, who was retired from active service on August
7, 1908, under the requirements of the act of Congress approved June
30, 1882, and placed upon the retired list of the army with rank
of brigadier-general, under the provisions of the act of Congress
approved April 23, 1904; Col. Milton B. Adams and Col. Ernest H.
Ruffner, who were retired from active service April 11, 1909, and
June 24, 1909, respectively, under the requirements of the act of
Congress approved June 30, 1882. There were added to the Corps
of Engineers during the fiscal year, by the assignment of graduates
of the United States Military Academy, 15 second lieutenants, whose
commissions date from June 11, 1909.
   On the 30th of June, 1909, the distribution of officers of engineers
according to their duties was as follows:
Chief of Engineers, in command of the Engineer Department, etc.............                        1
Assistants to the Chief of Engineers. ... ......      ...........          ..................      7
River and harbor work and The Board of Engineers .......................                           1
River and harbor work, The Board of Engineers, and the Light-House Board.                          1
River and harbor work, The Board of Engineers, and fortifications............                      1
River and harbor work........- ......... ........ ..........                  ........ ........   15
River and harbor work and fortification work...............................                       18
River and harbor work and light-house duty......................-........                          8
4                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                  U. S. ARMY.

River and harbor work, fortification work, and light-house duty.............                                                            6
River and harbor work and chief engineer officers, military departments ......                                                          6
River and harbor work, fortification work, and Washington Aqueduct- .....                                                         .     2
Engineer secretary to the Light-House Board...-........................-...                                                             1
On duty on and under the Panama Canal Commission .......................                                                               13
At Engineer School, Washington Barracks, D. C., and with troops stationed
  there-------------...................................-----.....--...--....-------..--.......-------.---------.......                22
On duty at the service schools, Fort Leavenworth, Kans ........... ..........                                                          3
With the government of the District of Columbia ...                                            . . . . . .. . . . ...  . . . . .. .    3
River and harbor work, fortification work, light-house duty, and command of
    engineer troops in the Hawaiian Islands.                              ...............          ..................                  1
On duty with troops at Fort Leavenworth, Kans.....- .............-..------....---                                     .....            14
Public buildings and grounds, District of Columbia ...........-----...............                                                      1
Fortification work and chief engineer officer, Philippines Division....... ..                                                           1
Assistant chief engineer officer, in charge of military mapping, Philippine
  Islands...........-----------..---.....---........-------...---....--..------------..............--------------                       1
On duty at the Army War College.................................--------...-----------......                                            1
On the General Staff........................................................                                                            1
On duty at the United States Military Academy..........                                              .................                 10
On leave of absence-----................--..............................----------------------------------..-----....                   1
Fortification work in the United States............----------------..----------...................-----                                 2
On duty with troops in Hawaiian Islands...................................                                                              4
On duty with troops in and en route to the Philippine Islands ..............                                                           11
Road work in Alaska ......................................................
                    Roadwor
                        lasa      ---------------------
                                   in                                               -------------------------                          1
                                                                                                                                        1
Superintendent of the State, War, and Navy building ........................                                                            1
On duty with troops at Vancouver Barracks, Wash............................                                                             4
In charge of the improvement of the Yellowstone National Park-..............                                                            1
Fortification work in the Philippine Islands-....--.............---...----...                                .                          1
On duty with United States cavalry team, national match-:.-                               -
                                                                                          ......      _..-..                            1
On survey duty in the Yosemite National Park ..............................                                                             1
Absent, sick------........-------..........----------------...................---..--------....---.........                             2
On graduation leave of absence--.........-------..............-----.....-------------.............-------                              15

          Total......---------......---------...........-------------------------------..                                             183
   The above table shows that out of a total of 183 officers, only 48,
or approximately 26 per cent, were on duty wholly under the con-
trol of the Chief of Engineers; 23, or 12 per cent more, were per-
forming some duty under the control of the Chief of Engineers, while
at the same time performing other duties under various other branches
of the Government; while 93, or 50 per cent of the entire corps, were
on duty entirely detached from the control and supervision of the
Chief of Engineers; in addition, 15 were on graduation leave from
the United States Military Academy, 2 were absent sick, and 1 was
on leave of absence granted by the military authorities.
   With regard to the character of the duties performed, 44 officers
were engaged on nonmilitary duty exclusively; 77 on military
duty exclusively; while 36 were performing both military and non-
military duty. The diversified character of the duties assigned to
the Corps of Engineers is well shown by this table.
   As pointed out in my last annual report, the duties devolving
upon the Corps of Engineers are increasing year by year. The corps
is now charged with the construction and repair of fortifications;
the superintendence and execution of works of river and harbor
improvements; the construction and repair of light-houses in the
United States, Alaska, and Hawaii; the water supply, municipal
engineering, care of public buildings and grounds, and a share in the
government of the capital city of the United States; the improve-
ment of the Yellowstone National Park; the survey of the northern
and northwestern lakes; the mining and d6bris commission of the
State of California; the chairmanship and majority membership of
              OFFICERS OF THE CORPS OF ENGINEERS.


the Panama Canal Commission and the execution of work under
this commission; all of which involve the expenditure of many
millions of dollars annually; and, in addition, various other duties,
such as the command of three battalions of engineer troops, the
supervision of military engineering, reconnaissance and survey work
in the several military departments, road work in Alaska, a geodetic
survey in the Philippine Islands, attendance at the War College,
instruction in the service schools and at the Military Academy,
membership in the General Staff, duty on various important boards,
and extensive surveys connected with proposed river and harbor
work and with the land defense of our seacoast fortifications.
   There is every reason to believe that this increase in the demands
upon the corps will continue. Interest in the improvement of the
waterways of the country is increasing, and the demand for the
inauguration of large projects is becoming continually more press-
ing. The intracoastal waterway survey, the extensive surveys of
the Ohio River, the investigation for an improved channel in the
Mississippi River, besides a large number of preliminary examina-
tions and surveys ordered by the river and harbor act of March 3,
1909, throw additional burdens upon the corps, already charged with
many and varied works of improvement, while the Panama Canal
continues to claim the services of more than 7 per cent of its officers.
   Along with the increasing demands of nonmilitary work has grown
the demand for officers and men to perform the strictly military
duties of the corps. Engineer officers and troops are now engaged
in making extensive military surveys in the Departments of the
East, the Columbia, and California, and in the Philippines and in
Hawaii, and calls for similar services have come from other points.
Fortification work is actively in progress in the Philippines and in
Hawaii, as well as in this country. The General Staff, the command
of the engineer troops, the War College, the service schools, and the
Military Academy all continue to demand their quota of the corps.
   The increasing demands of these various classes of duties, both
military and nonmilitary, have been met by increasing the duties
and responsibilities of individual officers, and the assignment of extra
work to many officers already overburdened. In several cases, it
has become necessary to combine, under one head, two engineer
districts, each of which is of sufficient importance and complexity
to require the undivided attention of one officer. In several cases,
a single officer is in charge of important river and harbor work, of
light-house construction, and of fortification work, diverse duties,
each requiring its own special knowledge and forms of procedure.
In addition, these officers are called upon to serve on various impor-
tant boards, entailing, in many cases, not only executive work, but
a large amount of individual research. Under these circumstances
it is growing more and more difficult for the officers of the corps to
devote to each of the various works in their charge the proper amount
of detailed consideration and study. It has also become necessary
to largely diminish the former practice of assigning young officers to
duty in the various engineer districts as assistants to older officers,
in order that they may, by observation and practice, become fitted
to assume charge of important construction work in their turn. It
has become necessary, in several cases, to assign to the responsible
charge of an engineer district a young officer who has had no previous
6        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S. ARMY.

experience on such work. Similarly, engineer companies have been
left for long periods under the command of young second lieuten-
ants only a year or two out of the Military Academy, for want of
captains who could be assigned to their command.
   Since 1897 the authorized strength of the Corps of Engineers has
been three times increased. Prior to that year the authorized
strength was 109 officers of all grades, this having been the organiza-
tion since the year 1866. In 1898, to meet the demands of the war
with Spain, the authorized strength was increased to 127. By the act
of February 2, 1901, the second increase was authorized, adding 33
officers to the authorized strength; but at the same time the number
of engineer troops was increased from one battalion of 4 companies,
to three battalions of 4 companies each, demanding the services of
30 additional officers with the new battalions. The new troops thus
absorbed practically the entire authorized increase in the number of
officers; and as the increase in officers was confined to the grades of
captain and lieutenant-5 in the former, and 28 in the latter grade-
whereas the troops required the assignment of 2 additional majors
and 8 additional captains to command the new battalions and corn-
panies, the practical result of the increase was a diminution of 5 in
the number of officers of experience available for construction work.
This effect was emphasized by the fact that as the Corps of Engi-
neers is, by law, recruited entirely from graduates of the United States
Military Academy, it proved impossible to obtain, at once, the full
number of officers to fill the newly created positions, so that the net
result of the legislation was an immediate and considerable diminu-
tion in the number of officers of all grades below that of lieutenant-
colonel available for assignment to construction work. By the act
of April 23, 1904, the corps was increased to its present authorized
strength of 188 officers. The same difficulty was at first experienced
in filling the original vacancies created by this act, but this has now
been largely overcome, and hereafter the corps may be kept at full
strength.
   Each of the increases mentioned above was immediately absorbed
by the increased duties, which had been the reason for the increase,
or which had accompanied it. There are now 183 officers holding
commissions in the Corps of Engineers, as compared with 111 on June
30, 1897; but the number of officers now on duty under the exclusive
control of the Chief of Engineers is but 48, as compared with 71 in
1897; while the number of officers now on duty beyond the control
of the Chief of Engineers is 93, as compared with 27 in 1897. In addi-
tion, 23 officers are now performing some duties under the Chief of
Engineers and some under other authority, as compared with 12 in
1897. The net result has been an actual and substantial decrease in
the number of officers available for carrying on the river and harbor
and other construction work of the corps, which has increased enor-
mously in this period of 12 years. This effect is largely due to the
increase in the strictly military duties of the corps. In 1897 18 officers
were engaged solcly on duties of this character and 47 upon such
duty in addition to nonmilitary duties, while in 1909 77 officers were
engaged on military duty exclusively, and 36 others were performing
military duty in addition to other work.
   Under these circumstances, I repeat the recommendation made in
my last report that the authorized strength of the corps be increased
                          ENGINEER TROOPS.                             7
by at least 60 officers, this increase being absolutely necessary to pro-
vide a proper organization of the corps for carrying on the work now
devolving upon it. As stated in my last year's report, this increase
should be effected in the grades above that of second lieutenant, the
present authorized number of second lieutenants being sufficient for
the performance of duties properly assignable to officers of that grade.
A bill originating in the River and Harbor Committee of the House
of Representatives was introduced at the last session of Congress,
providing an increase of 60 officers, distributed among the grades in
such a manner as to make the proportion of field officers in the Corps
of Engineers approach more closely to that in the other permanent
staff corps, adding to the corps 5 colonels, 6 lieutenant-colonels, 19
majors, 17 captains, and 13 first lieutenants.
   This increase in the number of officers in the corps is regarded as
absolutely necessary to meet the existing conditions in time of peace.
In the event of war with a first-class power, the full number of officers
recommended will be necessary for the proper discharge of the military
duties of the Corps of Engineers, embracing military reconnaissance
and mapping, laying out of camps, the planning and superintendence
of defensive and offensive works by the troops, the construction and
repair of military roads, railroads, and bridges, demolitions, siege
works, and the construction and repair of seacoast fortifications. In
time of peace this full number of officers will be profitably engaged in
the direction and execution of public engineering works, thereby not
only affording a well-trained and well-regulated organization for the
conduct of these works, but, at the same time, perfecting themselves
in the principles of engineering and the practice of administration
under government methods and accounting, and thus preparing
themselves for greater usefulness in war. If provision is made for the
payment of engineer officers, while engaged on river and harbor work,
from the appropriations for such works, the increase above recom-
mended will be attended by no increase in the appropriations for the
support of the army. The increase over the present authorized
strength should be extended over a period of about five years, by pro-
viding that only about one-fifth of the original vacancies created shall
be filled in each year, thus effecting a gradual expansion and avoiding
the difficulties inherent in the immediate entry and assimilation of so
large an amount of new material.

                      ENGINEER         TROOPS.

   The increase in officers referred to above is the number considered
necessary for properly carrying on the work now devolving upon the
Corps of Engineers, and takes no account of a possible increase in the
number of engineer troops. In my last annual report, I pointed out
the fact that any further increase in the engineer troops should be
accompanied by a corresponding increase in officers, in order to avoid
the necessity for withdrawing from construction work the necessary
officers for duty with the additional battalions, which has heretofore
so handicapped the civil work of the corps. It is understood that this
subject is under consideration by the General Staff, and that this body
will recommend, in due time, an appropriate organization of engineer
troops, with suitable provision for both officers and men.
8        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,          U.   S. ARMY.

   The necessity for an increase in the number of engineer troops was
recognized during the calendar year 1907 by the issuance of General
Orders, No. 199, War Department, September 25, 1907, putting the
engineer troops on a war basis, and authorizing the recruiting of the
companies to the full war strength of 164 men. For reasons explained
later in this report, it has been found difficult to raise these companies
to their full authorized strength.

    NONCOMMISSIONED             OFFICERS       OF   ENGINEERS.

    In my last report I recommended the establishment of certain
higher grades of noncommissioned officers in the Corps of Engineers,
comparable to those in certain other branches of the service, stating
my reasons for this recommendation. The experience of another
year has only emphasized the necessity for some such measures as
were then recommended, in order that the engineer troops may con-
tinue to attract and to hold the class of men necessary for the proper
execution of the varied works which they are called upon to perform.
The extensive military surveys in this country and in the island pos-
sessions, the proper handling of explosives, photography and map
reproduction, drafting, the supervision and direction of working par-
ties, both of troops and of civilian labor, the thorough practical
knowledge of fieldworks, military bridges, ponton bridges, demo-
litions, military mining, and road construction, all of which fall
within the duties of engineer troops, demand long and careful train-
ing, combined with technical skill in the mechanical trades, and
presuppose a high grade of enlisted men. This grade of men
is no longer attracted to the engineer troops. The work of this
branch of the service is arduous, and pay and opportunities for
advancement are no longer such as to attract the best men. Engi-
neer troops are expected and required to perform all the usual
post duties, to be well trained in infantry maneuvers and in rifle
practice, to understand the handling of horses and mules, and in
addition to be thoroughly trained in their own special technical
duties. Men about to enlist are guided largely in their choice of
a branch of the service by the relative opportunities of advance-
ment offered in the several branches, as well as by the relation
between the character of the work and the compensation received.
If the engineers are to continue to attract the grade of men needed
to properly perform the duties of this branch, they must offer oppor-
tunities of advancement at least equal to those of the other tech-
nical branches of the service, such as the Coast Artillery and the Signal
Corps. Under present conditions, not only do the better and more
intelligent class of men hesitate to enlist in the engineers, but the
engineers are subject to a steady drain of their best men, through
refusal to reenlist on discharge, through discharge by purchase, and
through transfer to other branches of the service, where easier service
is rewarded by almost equal pay. It is believed that if the efficiency
of the engineer troops is to be kept up to the high standard demanded
and expected of them these conditions must be remedied by increas-
ing the opportunities of promotion for good men and by the creation of
additional higher grades as a reward for special excellence. As
the technical duties of engineer troops require the frequent detach-
ment of small parties, or of individuals, for special duties, or for the
supervision of working parties, the exact proportion between the
            NONCOMMISSIONED       OFFICERS OF ENGINEERS.                 9
number of privates, corporals, and sergeants, based upon the number
of squads and sections in the company, is not applicable. Further-
more, the care of the ponton trains, tool wagons, mules, and horses
of mounted sections requires wagoners, artificers, saddlers, black-
smiths, and farriers.
   The number of cooks allowed to an engineer company should also
be increased, as the number now authorized-two for a company of
164 men-is too small for the performance of their duties. This
number is the same as is allowed to a company of 65 men in the cav-
alry and infantry, to a company of 109 men in the Coast Artillery
Corps, and to the peace strength of 100 men in an engineer company.
In the field artillery (light), three cooks are allowed to a battery of
133 men, and in the field artillery (horse), three cooks to a battery
of 150 men, while in the provisional organization of a signal corps
company, four cooks are allowed to 150 men. This latter number
is regarded as necessary for an engineer company of 164 men, espe-
cially in view of the fact that detachments of considerable size are
often separated from the company on special service requiring the
services of a cook with each detachment, as well as at.the headquarters
of the company.
   The designation of the present grade of "private, second class,"
should be changed to "private," as the description "second class" is
distasteful to the men, and is unnecessary to distinguish this grade
from that of "private, first class." This change would also empha-
size more clearly the fact that appointment as private, first class, is a
promotion in grade, and not merely an increase in pay.
   I therefore recommend the following changes in the organization
of the enlisted personnel of the Corps of Engineers:
   That there be added to the noncommissioned staff of each battalion
1 battalion commissary-sergeant, 1 color-sergeant, and 1 train-
sergeant, with the rank and pay of the present battalion sergeants-
major, and 1 trumpeter-corporal with rank and pay of corporal of
engineers.
   That there be added to each company of engineers 10 sergeants,
first class, with the rank and pay of sergeants, first class, in the Signal
Corps, and electrician-sergeants, first class, in the Coast Artillery
Corps; 2 mechanics, 2 wagoners, 2 farriers, 1 blacksmith and 1 saddler,
with the rank and pay of corresponding grades in the Coast Artillery
Corps and in the cavalry; and that the first sergeants and company
quartermaster sergeants have the rank and pay of sergeants, first
class.
   That the number of sergeants in each engineer company be in-
creased to 22, the number of corporals to 26, and the number of cooks
to 4; that the number of privates, first class, be reduced to 36, and
that the designation of the grade now designated as "private, second
class," be changed to "private," and the number reduced to 54, thus
leaving the total strength of the company at 164 men, as at present.
   I repeat my recommendation of last year, that there be established
in the Corps of Engineers a grade to be known as "Military overseer,"
or "Enlisted specialist," with the rank, pay, and emoluments now
authorized by law for master electrician in the Coast Artillery Corps,
and master signal electrician; that the authorized number of such
military overseers be 100, and that they be assigned to duties and
stations upon the recommendation of the Chief of Engineers; one to
be habitually stationed at each seacoast fort, as foreman of engineer
10         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

construction and working parties, in lieu of the civilians now employed
for these purposes; and the remainder to be assigned to duty with
the various engineer companies, for the performance of work requir-
ing special skill. Appointment to this grade should be reserved for
men especially expert in topography, drafting, photography, lithog-
raphy and map reproduction, demolitions, road building, military
mining or field engineering, or specially qualified as overseers on
construction work, and should be regulated by the same rules and
procedure as are now prescribed for appointment to the grades of
master electrician in the Coast Artillery Corps and master signal
electrician.
                 THE BOARD          OF    ENGINEERS.
   The regulations for the government of the Corps of Engineers pro-
vide for a Board of Engineers, consisting of not less than three officers
designated by the Chief of Engineers, with the sanction of the Sec-
retary of War. This Board acts in an advisory capacity to the Chief
of Engineers upon important questions of engineering. One of its
principal duties is to plan or revise the projects for permanent forti-
fications of the United States.
   During the fiscal year the Board has reported upon various sub-
jects connected with fortification work.
   A statement of the composition of this Board during the last fiscal
year will be found in its report.
   (See Appendix No. 1.)
                         FORTIFICATIONS.
  The scheme of national defense upon which work was in progress
between 1888 and 1906 was based primarily upon a report submitted
January 16, 1886, by the Endicott Board. On January 31, 1905, the
President organized a board, with the Secretary of War as president,
to review the projects for the United States and for the insular pos-
sessions, to indicate the localities where defenses are most urgently
needed, and to determine the character and general extent of the
defenses, with their estimated cost. This Board is known as the
National Coast Defense Board. The Board submitted its final report
February 1, 1906.
  Permanent seacoast defenses have been installed at the following
localities in the United States:
1.   Kennebec River, Maine.             14. Charleston, S. C.
2.   Portland, Me.                      15. Port Royal, S. C.
3.   Portsmouth, N. H.                  16. Savannah, Ga.
4.   Boston, Mass.                      17. Key West, Fla.
5.   New Bedford, Mass.                 18. Tampa Bay, Florida.
6.   Narragansett Bay, Rhode Island.    19. Pensacola, Fla.
7.   Eastern entrance to Long Island    20. Mobile, Ala.
        Sound.                           21. New Orleans, La.
8.   New York, N. Y.                    22. Galveston, Tex.
9.   Delaware River.                    23. San Diego, Cal.
10.   Baltimore, Md.                     24. San Francisco, Cal.
11.   Washington, D. C.                  25. Columbia River, Oregon and Wash-
12.   Hampton Roads, Virginia.                 ington.
13.   Cape Fear River, North Carolina.   26. Puget Sound, Washington.
   In accordance with the ,report of the Board above mentioned addi-
tional defenses are to be cbnstructed at some of these points and also
at the entrance to Chesapeake Bay as soon as funds are provided by
Congress.
                                                                     FORTIFICATIONS.                                                                                               11

  Appropriations for construction of gun and mortar batteries have
been made as follows:
  Act of-                                                                                         Act of-
August 18, 1890 .......     $1,221,000.00                                                       May 7, 1898 .....       ....... $3, 000, 000.00
February 24, 1891........       750, 000. 00                                                    July 7, 1898.............        2, 562,000.00
July 23, 1892... . . . . ..     500, 000. 00                                                    March 3, 1899. ........          1, 000, 000. 00
February 18, 1893----...         50, 000. 00                                                    May 25, 1900...-........ 2, 000, 000.00
August 1, 1894-.........        500, 000. 00                                                    March 1, 1901 .........          1, 615, 000. 00
March 2, 1895        -....
                   -....        500, 000.00                                                     June 6, 1902............         2, 000, 000. 00
June 6, 1896............. 2,400, 000.00                                                         March 3, 1903........... 2, 236, 425. 00
March 3, 1897-.... _ . ...   3, 841, 333. 00                                                    April 21, 1904............          700, 000. 00
Allotments from the ap-                                                                         May 27, 1908. .. ........           300, 000. 00
  propriation for "N a-                                                                         March 3, 1909 .......        ...      5, 064. 00
  tional defense," act of
  March 9, 1898. ... _....   3, 817, 676. 02                                                                Total.............. 28, 998, 498. 02
  The following table shows the present status of permanent work
completed or in progress with funds already provided:
                                                                                                                                                  Total
                                                                                                                                                 number                    Provided
                                                                                                                                                carried by                  for by
                                                              Calibers.                                                                         scheme of              appropria-
                                                                                                                                                National                 tions
                                                                                                                                                  Coast                 made by
                                                                                                                                                 Defense               Congress.
                                                                                                                                                 Board.
12-inch mortars......-----..---........------------....------------------............-----------.................--.......                                  464                     376
16-inch rifle...--------------------...........---------------............------------..........................-----------............                       1 ..........
14-inch rifles............................................................                                                            .......                19.
12-inch
10-inch rifles---------------------------------------------------------.....................................................................
        rifles...................................................................                                                                           138
                                                                                                                                                            139                     107
                                                                                                                                                                                    133
8-inch rifles... .......-. ..-..-..........                           --------..............                              -.-......             -..             72                   70
6-inch rapid-fire guns..............................................                      ........... .........                                             191                     175
5-inch rapid-fire guns................................ ....            ...........................                                                           53                      53
4.7-inch and 4-inch rapid-fire guns ...............................................                                                                          38                      38
3-inchrapid-fire  guns .....................................                          .......................                                               284                     254

   The defensive requirements of our seacoast may be subject to
change to meet new requirements due to changes in commercial and
naval vessels, but for present conditions the National Coast Defense
Board scheme is sufficient. It carried an estimate amounting to
$10,836,400 for emplacement construction (not including electrical
light or power or land for sites). Appropriations to date, since the
submission of the report of the Board, aggregate $305,064, leaving
$10,531,336 to be appropriated for these purposes.
   Congress at its last session provided a special appropriation of
$5,064 to cover the cost of Engineer Department changes in an em-
placement to enable the Ordnance Department to substitute for an
existing carriage of old and experimental type, one that is uniform
with the other two carriages emplaced in the same three-gun battery.
This work is well under way and its early completion is expected.
   At the close of the fiscal year the status of emplacements for which
funds have been provided by Congress is as follows:
                                                                                                    12-inchs.       12-inch.          10-inch.              8-inch.             Rapid-
                                                                                                    mortars.                                                                     fire.
Guns mounted ...................................                                         ....                 376        a 105         b 126                         c 97         d 434
Ready for armament ..........................                                       .......         ..........- ..........                 7                            2           e83
Under construction--------............---------------.....           ............                   .....----                2 ---.....                   ...                         4-----
         Total .....................................                                                       376              107                 133
                                                                                                                                                 -    I
                                                                                                                                                                      99
                                                                                                                                                                      --    I       521
                                                                                                i           '

aIncluding 2 guns on hydraulic lifts, now dismounted.
b Including original experimental 10-inch carriage, now dismounted.
cIncluding 26 which have been dismounted since the war with Spain, 3 which are now temporarily
mounted, and 3 which have been dismounted for emplacement elsewhere.
d One temporarily.
eExcluding 70 6-pounders not requiring permanent emplacements.
12                 REPORT            OF      THE       CHIEF           OF ENGINEERS,                      U.       S.   ARMY.


     At the close of the previous fiscal year there were reported mounted:

                                   12-inch           12-inch.         10-inch.          8-inch.           Rapid-
                                  mortars.                                                                     fire.

                                      376               105               126               94                 406



  A comparison of the last two tables shows an increase during the
year in guns actually available for service of 3 8-inch guns and 28
rapid-fire guns.
  The following table shows that the Engineer and Ordnance de-
partments have worked in harmony, the number of gun carriages
and emplacements being the same except where extra carriages are
needed for purposes other than seacoast defense:

                                                                                                                          Total         Total
                                        Type of gun or carriage,                                                        carriages     emplaee-
                                                                                                                        provided.     provided.


12-inch mortar carriages, model 1896.....------..---....---------.........--------------............--..                     a 298               296
12-inch mortar carriages, model 1891-....------..----------------------.................................----------.           b 85                80
12-inch disappearing carriages, L. F., model 1901...............-................                                               13                13
12-inch disappearing carriages, L. F., model 1897...-.......                              ...................                   35                35
12-inch disappearing carriages, L. F., model 1896-..-............................                                               27                27
12-inch gun-lift carriages, altered to nondisappearing.......-.....-..- .......-...                                              2                 2
12-inch gun-lift carriages, model 1891, -.....-........ ................-.........                                              c2               d2
12-inch nondisappearing carriages, model 1892................................                                                   28                28
10-inch disappearing carriages, A. R. F., model 1896......-......................                                                3                 3
10-inch disappearing carriages, L. F., model 1901................................                                               12                12
10-inch disappearing carriages, L. F., model 1896................................                                               74                74
10-inch disappearing carriages, L. F., model 1894 -.....                                    -...............-..-.....          e35                35
10-inch nondisappearing carriages, model 1893-..............-...................                                              f10                  9
8-inch disappearing carriages, L. F., model 1896----------............--------.................            -------------         38             g 41
8-inch disappearing carriages, L. F., model 1894 -...                      .........          .................               h 26              g 25
8-inch nondisappearing carriages, model 1892-----..----..........------...............------------------.....                     9               k9
15-inch smoothbore carriages altered for 8-inch rifles...........................                                                21              121
6-inch disappearing carriages, model 1905-........................................                                                4                4
6-inch disappearing carriages, model 1903.....................................                                                   90               90
6-inch disappearing carriages, model 1898-----......-------.........---------..............            ---------------           29               29
6-inch rapid-fire (Vickers Son & Maxim), pedestal mounts ..-...................                                                   8                8
6-inch rapid-fire, pedestal mounts, model 1900 - ---...-..- ......-...........-.....                                             45               44
5-inch balanced-pillar mounts, model 1896-......................................                                                 32               32
5-inch pedestal mounts, model 1903-..........                      ...............................                               21               22
4.7-inch rapid-fire (Armstrong pattern), pedestal mounts-..-.....................                                              i 34               33
4.7-inch rapid-fire (Schneider pattern), pedestal mounts.........                                      ....-...........           1              m1
4-inch rapid-fire (Driggs-Schroeder), pedestal mounts---..-..-...................                                                 4                4
3-inch balanced-pillar mounts -------.......-----.........--------------..............................-----------------..    n 118             o 114
3-inch casemate mounts ----... _...........          ......................................                                       2                2
3-inch pedestal mounts, model 1902...                 .....-----------------------------------------                             60               60
3-inch pedestal mounts, model 1903 .----------------------------------------                                                   i 79               78
2.24-inch rapid-fire field carriages and rampart mounts-...--- - -                                 ...
                                                                                                - -..        -...-               70      (p)

  a Two at Sandy Hook Proving Ground.
  b One in use at West Point; 4 in storage.
  c One has been altered for use at Proving Ground.
  d Armament dismounted.
  e One carriage is the original experimental one for this caliber of gun, and has been put out of service
at the instance of the Coast Artillery Corps.
  f One at Sandy Hook Proving Ground.
  g One emplacement originally built for experimental carriage altered to receive a carriage of model 1896.
  h One carriage is the original experimental one for this caliber of gun, and has been put out of service.
   4 One at Sandy Hook Proving Ground.
  j One at West Point and 1 at Sandy Hook Proving Ground.
  k Five temporary; armament removed from 3.
   z Temporary; armament removed from 20.
  m Temporary; armament removed.
  n Two at Sandy Hook Proving Ground; 4 at Watertown Arsenal.
  o Two without armament.
  P Movable mounts.
                            FORTIFICATIONS.                            13
   Modernizing older emplacements.-The fortification appropriation
act approved March 3, 1909, provided the sum of $100,000 for mod-
ernizing older emplacements. This sum is being applied in continu-
ing the installation of mechanical devices to facilitate the supply of
ammunition from the magazines to the loading-platform level, such
mechanical devices being considered absolutely necessary by the
artillery to permit the utilization of the full possibilities of the rapid
rate of fire possessed by modern ordnance.
   Much remains to be done to place the older batteries in satisfactory
condition for efficient operation; powder hoists in gun emplacements,
widening loading platforms, electric wiring of emplacements to place
fire-control instruments on the gun carriages, and platform lighting
are the main items. Detailed estimates have been prepared for the
work of the above classes still required in the United States; the
aggregate of the estimate is $966,100. An estimate of $500,000 for
this work was prepared by the Chief of Engineers, but by direction
of the Secretary of War this item was omitted from the estimates
finally submitted by the Chief of Engineers.
   Fire control at fortifications.-The fortification appropriation act
approved May 27, 1908, provided the sum of $270,256 for this pur-
pose, to be distributed in the discretion of the Secretary of War
among the Engineer and Ordnance departments and the Signal Corps.
Of this amount the sum of $129,456 was assigned to the Engineer
Department. Engineer work is now in progress with these funds,
and the close of the present working season will show substantial
progress on the work intended to be accomplished therewith.
   The fortification appropriation act approved March 3, 1909, pro-
vided the sum of $247,055 for this purpose, of which amount the
sum of $20,000 has been assigned to the Engineer Department to
enable important work to be completed pending the distribution of
the entire amount of the appropriation. Plans and estimates are in
course of preparation for Engineer Department work desired to be
accomplished under this appropriation, and it is expected that the
remainder of the appropriation will be distributed among the con-
struction and supply departments concerned and work therewith be
begun before the end of the working season.
   An estimate of $1,275,858 to cover the work of the Engineer and
Ordnance departments and the Signal Corps under this head for the
next fiscal year was prepared by the Chief of Coast Artillery; it is
understood that in the estimates finally submitted this item has been
reduced to $200,000.
   Electrical installations.-The National Coast Defense Board esti-
mated that $5,216,031 would be required to furnish the necessary
electrical equipment for the defenses of the United States in addition
to the current required for searchlights.
   The fortification act of May 27, 1908, provided the sum of $348,888
for this purpose, and the act of March 3, 1909, the sum of $100,000.
With these funds electric plants are being procured and installed
at posts where the requirements are most urgent.
   For continuing the installation of this equipment at the defenses
where the Chief of Coast Artillery states they are most needed an
estimate of $534,718 was prepared by the Chief of Engineers, but this
item was omitted from the estimates finally submitted.
14       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,          U.   S. ARMY.

   Sites forfortifications.-Duringthe fiscal year ending June 30, 1907,
a site was acquired at Boston, Mass., a part of the purchase money
being withheld, in accordance with the terms of the sale, until a wall
separating the tract acquired from adjacent ground has been built
by the city of Boston. During the past year the construction of the
wall was completed and the remainder of the purchase money paid.
   The question of the defense of San Pedro, Cal., was considered by
the General Staff and a report submitted thereon and transmitted
to Congress by the President on January 14, 1909. In submitting
the report to the President the Secretary of War recommended that
the sum of $400,000 be appropriated during the current session of
Congress for the acquisition of the necessary land. For the acquisition
of the land the sum of $250,000 was appropriated in the act of March
3, 1909. A careful investigation has been made of the land which
must be acquired for the defenses projected and the garrison therefor
and the amount which will be required for its acquisition. As a
result of this investigation it is found that more than the $400,000
originally estimated will be required for this purpose. Under the
provisions of existing law (33 Stats., 497), the entire tract required for
the accommodation of the garrison and defensive works must be pro-
cured at one time. The $250,000 already appropriated is therefore
held pending any further action in the matter which may be taken
by Congress.
   Searchlights.-After much experimental work and the practical
test of use under regular service conditions, a satisfactory type of
searchlight has been developed and forty have been contracted for
under appropriations carried in the fortification appropriation act
approved May 27, 1908, and their construction is well advanced.
The deliveries of the generating sets contracted for under the appro-
priation in the act approved March 2, 1907, have continued and are
nearly completed; they have proved satisfactory.
   The fortification appropriation act approved March 3, 1909, carried
an appropriation of $210,000 for the purchase of additional lights and
their installation, and contracts for the apparatus will be awarded
in the near future.
   To carry on the work of installation, in accordance with the recom-
mendations of the Chief of Coast Artillery, the Chief of Engineers
prepared an estimate for the next fiscal year amounting to $897,000.
This item was, however, by direction of the Secretary of War, reduced
to $50,000 in the estimates finally submitted by the Chief of Engineers.
   Preservation and repair of fortiications.-The modern works of
defense now constructed represent an expenditure of approximately
$28,000,000 for engineering work alone. For the preservation and
repair of these works during the present fiscal year there was appro-
priated the sum of $225,000, less than 1 per cent of the cost of con-
struction. These extensive works contain much costly machinery
and ordnance material and must be kept properly painted and
repaired to be effective when needed. The $225,000 appropriation
of the act of May 27, 1908, was not sufficient to keep the essential
features of the fortifications in satisfactory condition for an entire
year, and a large proportion of the appropriation of a like amount
carried in the fortification appropriation act approved March 3, 1909,
has already been devoted to urgently necessary work, and practically
                                   FORTIFICATIONS.                                        15
the entire amount of the appropriation has been similarly pledged.
Much desirable and necessary work is now awaiting future appro-
priations.
  An estimate of $300,000 for preservation and repair is submitted,
and it is strongly recommended (in the interest of economy and effi-
cient service) that this amount be appropriated.
  Repair and protection of defenses of Charleston, Pensacola, Mobile,
and New Orleans.-Forrepairs and sea walls at these localities, ren-
dered necessary by storms, the following estimates were submitted
to Congress in 1906:
Charleston, S. C., for the construction of the sea wall necessary for the pro-
  tection of Fort Moultrie ...............................................          $225, 600
Pensacola, Fla., for building sea walls for the protection of the sites of the
  fortifications and of the necessary post buildings at Forts Pickens and
  McRee---------..........................                                            907,100
Pensacola, Fla., for repair and restoration of batteries and other structures
  appurtenant to the defenses of Pensacola, and for retaining walls to pro-
  tect the batteries from floods .......................................              109, 355
Mobile, Ala., for repair and restoration of batteries and other structures
  appurtenant to the defenses of Mobile, and for rebuilding sea walls and
  groins for protection of the sites of the fortifications of the garrison posts.. 1, 089, 500
New Orleans, La., for rebuilding and strengthening the levees for protection
  of the site of the defenses and the garrison post at Fort St. Philip.......         139, 800
   At the last three regular sessions of Congress appropriations were
made covering the estimates for Charleston, Mobile, and Pensacola
and providing $100,000 for the levees at Fort St. Philip, but authority
to initiate the proposed protective levees for the last named in their
entirety was not given. A portion of this reservation is therefore
protected and the balance abandoned to overflow until further funds
are available. Floods are higher than formerly, due to the building
of levees below the forts.
   To complete the protection of the Fort St. Philip reservation, an
estimate of $40,000 was prepared by the Chief of Engineers, but, by
direction of the Secretary of War, was omitted from the estimates
to be submitted to Congress.
   At Charleston, Pensacola, and Mobile the work is under way and
progressing satisfactorily, and it is believed will be satisfactorily
completed within the estimates.
   Supplies for seacoast defenses.-Owing to the large number of elec-
tric installations supplying power and 'light in seacoast batteries,
funds have been appropriated annually for "tools and electrical and
engine supplies for use of the troops for maintaining and operating
light and power plants in gun and mortar batteries." This appro-
priation is designed to enable the Engineer Department to comply
with the regulations of the War Department for the supply and service
of the batteries. Requisitions are made upon the Chief of Engineers,
through the district engineer officers, and authorized articles are pur-
chased and issued by district engineer officers with as little delay as
possible. This system has proved eminently satisfactory to the gar-
risons.
   The amount appropriated for this purpose in the act approved
March 3, 1909, was $40,000.
   As the earlier electric plants become worn with use, and as addi-
tional plants are installed from time to time, the demands upon the
funds for the purchase of these supplies increase, and while great
16       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S. ARMY.


economy was exercised during the past year in the use of the $40,000
appropriated by the act of May 27, 1908, for general purchases, con-
siderable difficulty was experienced in providing sufficient funds to
all districts for the purchase of absolutely necessary supplies, and
even greater difficulty is anticipated in procuring the supplies essen-
tial for the service during the current fiscal year.
   The sum of $45,000 is estimated as necessary for the procurement
of the regular electrical supplies for the next fiscal year, especially in
view of the numerous installations being provided for battery lighting
and power and for searchlight service.
   Reserve lights.-A satisfactory form of reserve electric lantern has
been produced as the result of exhaustive tests. To supply these lan-
terns in sufficient quantities to all batteries now in service an esti-
mate of $19,500 was submitted last year. An appropriation of
$10,000 for the purpose was contained in the appropriation act of
March 3, 1909, and a contract covering that sum has been entered
upon.
   An estimate of $9,500, the unappropriated balance of the original
estimate, was prepared by the Chief of Engineers, but, under iistruc-
tions from the Secretary of War, this item has been omitted from the
estimates finally submitted by the Chief of Engineers.
   Sea walls and embanlcments.-The sum of $50,000 was appropriated
for this purpose by the fortification appropriation act approved
March 3, 1909. This amount is being applied to such work only as
becomes urgently necessary for the protection of the defensive
works.
   Based upon detailed estimates prepared by district engineer officcrs,
an estimate of $164,775 was prepared by the Chief of Engineers for
the construction of sea walls and embankments at a number of locali-
ties on the Atlantic, Gulf, and Pacific coasts, where needed to protect
the defenses. Under instructions from the Secretary of War, how-
ever, this item has been omitted from the estimates finally submitted
by the Chief of Engineers.
   Sea walls, defenses of Galveston, Tex.-The defensive works at Gal-
veston were unavoidably in most exposed positions, and the level of
the lands surrounding the batteries was greatly lowered by the storm
of September 8, 1900. Work of reconstruction and repair of the
Galveston defenses is now completed under the appropriation con-
tained in the fortification act approved March 1, 1901. With the
funds so provided, and in accordance with the plans before Congress
when that appropriation was made, each individual battery has been
made secure against any similar storms which are likely to occur in
the future.
   For building a sea wall and filling up the reservation at Fort Crock-
ett to a height above storm tides the sums of $591,046.25 and $158,-
953.75 were appropriated in the sundry civil appropriation acts of
April 28, 1904, and June 30, 1906, aggregating $750,000. Under
these appropriations the work at Fort Crockett is now practically
completed.
   For similar work at Fort Travis the sum of $440,000 was provided
in the fortification appropriation act approved March 3, 1909. The
plans for this work have been completed, and actual operations will
soon be begun.
                           FORTIFICATIONS.                           17
   Similar protection is required at Fort San Jacinto if this fort is to
be garrisoned. There are certain claims to portions of this reserva-
tion adverse to the title of the United States. Until all clouds upon
the title of the United States are removed no money should be
expended on this reservation.
   Preservation and repair of torpedo structures.-A large number of
new torpedo-defense structures have been completed, and a number,
in addition, are approaching completion. The appropriations made
to date for building torpedo structures aggregate $2,403,000.
   Situated as they are at exposed locations on the Atlantic, Gulf,
and Pacific coasts, the requirements for the maintenance of these
structures are considerable. The appropriation act of March 3, 1909,
contained an item of $20,000 for this purpose. This sum is being
applied to such minor repairs as are found from time to time to be
most urgently necessary, but in view of the very large number of
these structures and the necessity of frequent repainting and minor
repairs to prevent marked deterioration in the buildings, this sum
has sufficed for only such work as was most urgently necessary. The
Chiefiof Engineers prepared an estimate of $50,000 for this purpose,
but, by direction of the Secretary of War, this item was reduced to
$20,000 in the estimates finally submitted by the Chief of Engineers.
   Submarine mines.-While the operation of torpedo defenses is the
duty of the Coast Artillery Corps, the building of structures required
in connection therewith is under the charge of the Engineer Depart-
ment.
   To complete the engineer structures for the torpedo defenses
recommended by the National Coast Defense Board, except at the
entrance to Chesapeake Bay and at Galveston, Tex. (where, owing
to the present status of the defenses and garrison posts, it is not con-
sidered advisable to build the torpedo structures immediately), an
estimate of $189,964 was prepared by the Chief of Engineers in
accordance with the request of the Chief of Coast Artillery, but, by
direction of the Secretary of War, this item was omitted from the
estimates as finally submitted by the Chief of Engineers.
   The sum of $100,000 provided in the fortification act of March 3,
1909, is being applied in accordance with the artillery scheme.
   Batteries in insular possessions.-The first appropriation for this
purpose was contained in the fortification act approved April 21, 1904,
and additional appropriations have been made in each of the five suc-
ceeding years, the aggregate amount appropriated to date being
$5,051,200 (including $250,000 the expenditure of which has been
assigned to the Chief of Ordnance). With these appropriations bat-
teries have been constructed at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, and con-
struction work is now in progress at Honolulu and Pearl Harbor,
Hawaii, and Manila and Subic Bay, Philippine Islands.
   The defense of the important harbors of the insular possessions has
been specially considered by the National Coast Defense Board, and
any funds appropriated for batteries will be applied in accordance with
the general projects of that board.
   An estimate of $112,200 for additional batteries in the Hawaiian
Islands, called for by the report of the National Coast Defense Board,
was prepared by the Chief of Engineers, but, by direction of the Sec-
retary of War, was omitted from the estimates finally submitted by
     9001-ENG 1909-2
18       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

the Chief of Engineers. For the Philippine Islands an estimate of
$1,319,000 was prepared, of which amount $450,000 was included to
cover the Engineer Department portion of an authorization of
$600,000 contained in the act approved March 3, 1909, which will be
needed to carry on work already under way under the appropriation
carried in said act.
   Electrical installations, insular possessions.-The National Coast
Defense Board estimated that $788,713 would be required to furnish
the necessary electrical equipment for the defenses of the insular pos-
sessions, in addition to the current required for searchlights.
   Toward the installation of this equipment the sum of $238,292 has
thus far been provided by Congress, $34,469 for the Hawaiian Islands
and $203,823 for the Philippine Islands, of which $14,469 for the
Hawaiian Islands and $88,823 for the Philippine Islands were carried
in the act approved March 3, 1909. Work under these appropriations
is now in progress. For the continuation of this work in the Philip-
pine Islands in accordance with the plans of the National Coast De-
fense Board, an estimate of $127,346 is submitted.
    Fire control in insular possessions.-The fortification act of March
3, 1909, provided $250,000 for this purpose, which sum was available
for the work of the Engineer and Ordnance departments and the
Signal Corps. Of this appropriation the sum of $207,000 is being
applied to the work of the Engineer Department.
   An estimate for the continuation of this work was prepared by the
Chief of Coast Artillery, amounting to $250,000; in the estimates
finally submitted this item was reduced to $200,000.
   Searchlights, insular possessions.-For this purpose the sum of
$227,500 was appropriated in the act of May 27, 1908, $47,500 for the
Hawaiian Islands and $180,000 for the Philippine Islands, and the
sum of $66,000 for the Hawaiian Islands was carried in the act ap-
proved March 3, 1909. These funds are being applied to the pur-
pose for which appropriated. To complete the searchlight projects
for the batteries thus far authorized in the Hawaiian Islands the Chief
of Engineers prepared an estimate of $40,100, but, by direction of the
Secretary of War, this item was omitted from the estimates finally
submitted by the Chief of Engineers. For necessary searchlights for
use with batteries already authorized in the Philippine Islands, an
estimate of $139,200 is submitted.
    Submarine mines, insular possessions.-The sum of $129,000 was
appropriated in the fortification act of May 27, 1908, for the construc-
tion of torpedo structures for the defense of the Hawaiian Islands.
Work is now being prosecuted with these funds.
    Procurement of sites, insular possessions.-For the procurement of
land or rights pertaining thereto in the Philippine Islands the sum
of $5,000 was provided by the fortification act of May 27, 1908, and
the additional sum of $12,000 by the act of March 3, 1909. Con-
demnation proceedings were instituted for the acquisition of the land;
a decree has been rendered by the court, and final proceedings,
including payment of the awards, are now in progress. It is expected
that the title to all the tracts will be in the United States before the
close of the current calendar year.
    Preservation and repair of fortifications, insular possessions.-A
number of the batteries authorized by Congress for the insular
possessions have been completed and are being operated by the
                                             FORTIFICATIONS.                                                             19

troops. Minor repairs, painting, etc., are from time to time neces-
sary and have heretofore been met from balances of funds appro-
priated for construction purposes. The approaching completion of
work at certain localities and the exhaustion of construction funds
render provision for such work necessary in the future. The Chief
of Engineers prepared estimates of $900, $1,500, and $14,000 for
this purpose for the defensive works at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, in
the Hawaiian Islands, and in the Philippine Islands, respectively,
but, by direction of the Secretary of War, in the final preparation
of the estimates by the Chief of Engineers the items for Guantanamo
Bay and for the Hawaiian Islands were omitted.
  Preservation and repair of torpedo-defense structures in the insular
possessions.-In order to provide for the maintenance in proper con-
dition of the numerous structures already erected in connection with
torpedo defense in the Philippine Islands, an estimate of $1,000 is
submitted. An estimate of $500 for a similar purpose in the Hawaiian
Islands was prepared by the Chief of Engineers, but, by direction of
the Secretary of War, this estimate has been omitted.
   Supplies.for seacoast defenses, insular possessions.-Under appro-
priations heretofore made by Congress a number of electric plants
have been installed in the defensive works in the Philippine Islands,
and in order that the necessary supplies and materials may be fur-
nished for their operation and maintenance, as for similar plants in
this country, an estimate of $5,000 is submitted. For the same pur-
pose in connection with plants installed and to be installed in the
Hawaiian Islands, the Chief of Engineers prepared an estimate of
$1,000, but, by direction of the Secretary of War, it was omitted in
the preparation of the final estimates by the Chief of Engineers.
   The following money statements show the condition on June 30,
1909, of all general appropriations under which operations were in
progress at the close of the fiscal year:
                                    " GUN AND        MORTAR BATTERIES."


                                           For battery construction.

July 1, 1908, balance unallotted...........................                                ..... .......        $313, 226.34
March 3, 1909, appropriated. ...........   .............................                                           5, 064.00

                                                                                                                 318, 290. 34
June 30, 1909, net allotments during fiscal year .......                      ..............                     309, 371. 18
July 1, 1909, balance unallotted... ..............                        ..........              ......           8, 919. 16
July 1, 1909, amount pledged....................                            .........              ......          8, 919. 16

                                   For modernizing older emplacements.

July 1, 1908, balance unallotted..... ..........        .............                                       .   $167, 296. 36
March 3, 1909, appropriated .............. .............                                .......      ....        100, 000. 00
                                                                                                                 267, 296. 36
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year .........                               ...                 194, 966. 36
July 1, 1909, balance unallotted ...............................                                                  72, 330. 00
July 1, 1909, amount pledged...............                   .....................                               72, 330. 00
20          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                            "FIRE    CONTROL AT FORTIFICATIONS."

July 1, 1908, balance unallotted-- ..    ---................-....-... --      $42, 699. 04
September 17, 1908, assigned to Chief of Engineers from the act of May
  27, 1908           .............      ....................        .......---129,456. 00
June 9, 1909, assigned to Chief of Engineers from the act of March 3,
  1909 (partial assignment) ........................... ...............        20, 000.00
                                                                                          192, 155. 04
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year-...................                  192, 129.08
July 1, 1909, balance unallotted ................. ....................                         25. 96
July 1, 1909, amount pledged .......................................                            25.96

              "ELECTRICAL      INSTALLATIONS      AT SEACOAST FORTIFICATIONS."


July 1, 1908, balance unallotted...-
                                  -                ------ .........
                                       ................                                  $348, 387. 00
March 3, 1909, appropriated--...-  ----------------------------------                     100, 000. 00
                                                                                          448, 387.00
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year... ......                  .         409, 873. 11
July 1, 1909, balance unallotted ............. ............ ........                       38, 513. 89
July 1, 1909, amount pledged ......................................                        38, 513. 89

                         "SEARCHLIGHTS        FOR HARBOR DEFENSES."


July 1, 1908, balance unallotted ...............................                         $246, 901. 00
March 3, 1909, appropriated-......-...... .....................                           210, 000. 00
                                                                                          456, 901. 00
June 30, 1909, net allotments during fiscal year.......... ...........                    194, 915. 84
July 1, 1909, balance unallotted ........... .....................                        261, 985. 16
July 1, 1909, amount held for installing lights and for purchase of new
  ones.............................................................                       261, 985.16

                 c"SITES FOR FORTIFICATIONS         AND SEACOAST DEFENSES."


July 1, 1908, balance unallotted.-..-- ..---- .....-----.-.-....-.-.-$169, 604. 67
March 3, 1909, appropriated.. -......-.......... ..................   250, 000. 00

                                                                                          419, 604. 67
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year                             .
                                                                       -..............     45, 353. 57

July 1, 1909, balance unallotted.....................---------------------------------    374, 251. 10
July 1, 1909, amount pledged...------------------------------------                       315, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available. .............
                                         .  ............                   . ... .         59, 251. 10

                    "PRESERVATION        AND REPAIR       OF FORTIFICATIONS."


July 1, 1908, balance unallotted.--------------..........---------.............----------.......... $216, 639. 00
March 3, 1909, appropriated....------------.............---------------.......      ----------- 225, 000. 00
                                                                                          441, 639. 00
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year ...................                  439, 542. 21

July 1, 1909, balance unallotted.....................................                        2,096.79
July 1, 1909, amount pledged ....................................                            2,096.79

                                 C"PLANS   FOR FORTIFICATIONS."


March 3, 1909, appropriated........................................                         $5, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year................                         5, 000. 00
                                      FORTIFICATIONS.                                                   21
                           c SUPPLIES FOR SEACOAST DEFENSES."

July 1, 1908, balance unallotted.....................................                          $44, 510. 04
March 3, 1909, appropriated..............-.........................                             40, 000. 00
                                                                                                84, 510. 04
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year. .................                         84, 272. 34
July 1, 1909, balance unallotted and available ..................                 .....             237. 70
                                        For reserve lights.
March 3, 1909, appropriated ........    .... ........... _.          .-
                                                                   -....                       $10, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year-...................                        10, 000. 00

                             " SEA WALLS AND        EMBANKMENTS."


July 1, 1908, balance unallotted..-.................   .........         .....                 $17, 044. 89
March 3, 1909, appropriated ...........................       ..-..........                     50, 000. 00
                                                                                                67, 044. 89
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year...................                         53, 605. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available for emergencies during fiscal year......                        13, 439. 89

                "PRESERVATION       AND REPAIR      OF TORPEDO          STRUCTURES."


July 1, 1908, balance unallotted.....-..................-............                           $2, 921. 20
March 3, 1909, appropriated...-...-.................................                            20,000. 00
                                                                                                22, 921. 20
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year...................                         21, 031. 05
July 1, 1909, balance unallotted and available....... -......                ........            1, 890. 15

                "cCASEMATES, GALLERIES, ETC., FOR SUBMARINE MINES."

July 1, 1908, balance unallotted .....................................                         $74,124. 14
March 3, 1909, appropriated .-.............. .......................                           100, 000. 00
                                                                                               174, 124. 14
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year.               -      --.............     147, 486. 20
July 1, 1909, balance unallotted .............................  ....                            26, 637.94
July 1, 1909, amount pledged........-...-.........................                              26, 637. 94

                        "FORTIFICATIONS      IN   INSULAR   POSSESSIONS."


                              For construction of seacoast batteries.

July 1, 1908, balance unallotted.--.-....... ......................
                                                        _            $1, 390, 391.40
March 3, 1909, appropriated (for Hawaiian Islands)..................     337, 200. 00
March 22, 1909, assigned to Engineer Department by the Secretary of
  War from act approved March 3, 1909 (for Philippine Islands).....      750, 000. 00

                                                                                             2, 477, 591. 40
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year.... .............                       1, 647, 277. 68

July 1, 1909, balance unallotted...-..-...._.....................                   ....       830, 313.72
July 1, 1909, amount pledged .....................................                             830, 313. 72
22            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                        For electrical installations.
July 1, 1908, balance unallotted .   -....-........
                                                 ................ $127, 574. 00
March 3, 1909, appropriated ------........-----.....----------------.............
                                                                   103, 292.00
                                                                                                       230, 866. 00
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year...............-...                                180, 221. 28
July 1, 1909, balance unallotted and available ...                                     . . . ...
                                                                           . . . . . . ..               50, 644. 72

                                               For searchlights.
July 1, 1908, balance unallotted ..................................                                   $227, 290.00
March 3, 1909, appropriated.......................................                                      66, 000.00

                                                                                                       293, 290. 00
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year...................                                 12, 235. 69

July 1, 1909, balance unallotted ...................................                                   281,054.31
July 1, 1909, amount pledged ..-................................                                       281,054.31

                         For casemates, galleries, etc., for submarine mines.

July 1, 1908, balance unallotted..................................                                    $128,767.84
June 30, 1909, refundments during the fiscal year ...................                                    3, 642. 81

July 1, 1909, balance unallotted ..........................                          ........ 132, 410. 65
July 1, 1909, amount pledged ...................................                              128,767.84

July 1, 1909, balance available.................                      ................                   3, 642. 81

                                       For sites, Hawaiian Islands.

July 1, 1908, balance unallotted..................................                                    $114, 428. 01
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year....... ........                                   114, 424. 27

July 1, 1909, balance unallotted....................                             .............                3.74
July 1, 1909, amount pledged .....................................                               ..           3.74

                                      For sites, Philippine Islands.

July 1, 1908, balance unallotted..................................                                      $5,000.00
March 3, 1909, appropriated......................................                                       12, 000.00
                                                                                                        17, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year...................                                 14, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, unallotted balance..................                         .............                 3, 000.00
July 1, 1909, amount pledged .......................                              .........                  50.00

July 1, 1909, balance available................                ... .............                         2, 950. 00

                            "FIRE CONTROL IN          INSULAR        POSSESSIONS."


July 2, 1908, assigned from act of May 27, 1908 ......................                                 $75, 000.00
March 31, 1909, assigned from act of March 3, 1909 .................                                   207, 000. 00
                                                                                                       282, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, net allotments during the fiscal year.................                                  281, 500. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unallotted ...............................                                            500. 00
July 1, 1909, amount pledged...................................                                             500. 00
                                                               ENGINEER                    DEPOTS.                                                         23
                     Estimates of appropriationsrequiredfor 1910-11 for fortifications.

                                                                                                          As originally pre-
                                                                                                           pared by Chief of             As finally submitted.
                                                                                                           Engineers.
                                                                                                     -I                             -I
Gun and mortar batteries, for modernizing older emplace-
  m ents....    .     .....................                         ................                                    $500,000                               0
Electrical installations at seacoast fortifications...                                 ........                          534,718                               0
Searchlights for harbor defenses.............                                      ..........   .                        897,000                        $50,000
Preservation and repair of fortifications. ...                                ...........                                300,000                        300, 000
Repair and protection of defenses of New Orleans, La......                                                                40,000                               0
Plans for fortifications ..........................................                                                        5,000                          5,000
Supplies for seacoast defenses .........                         ..............                            $45,000                         $45,000
    For reserve lights .....                .........................                            .            9,500                              0
                                                                                                                          54, 500                        45, 000
Sea walls and embankments... .. ........................                                  .....                          164,775                               0
Preservation and repair of torpedo structures................                                                             50,000                         20,000
Casemates, galleries, etc., for submarine mines ...........                                                              189,964                               0
Fortifications in insular possessions:
    For seacoast batteries-
          Hawaiian Islands ..............................                                                   112,200                               0
          Philippine Islands......                     .....                            ...               1,319,000                      1,319,000
    For electrical installations, Philippine Islands.......                                                 127, 346                       127, 346
    For searchlights-
          Hawaiian Islands ...................................                                               40,100                              0
          Philippine Islands.................................                                               139,200                        139,200
    For preservation and repair of fortifications at the follow-
       ing localities-
          Guantanamo Bay, Cuba ............................                                                     900                              0
          Hawaiian Islands ...........................................                                        1,500                              0
          Philippine Islands.............................                                                    14,000                         14,000
    For preservation and repair of torpedo structures at the
       following localities-
          Hawaiian Islands ................                  ..................                                 500                              0
          Philippine Islands. ........................                               ....                     1,000                          1,000
    For supplies for seacoast defenses at the following locali-
       ties-
          In the Hawaiian Islands ................                            .........                       1,000                              0
          In the Philippine Islands.....                          ..............                              5,000                          5,000
                                                                                                                       1,761,746                      1, 605,546

         Total...........................                                  ............                                4,497,703                      2,025,546




ENGINEER DEPOTS AT WASHINGTON BARRACKS, DIS-
TRICT OF COLUMBIA, FORT LEAVENWORTH, KANSAS,
AND VANCOUVER BARRACKS, WASHINGTON.

Officers in charge: Depot at Washington Barracks, Lieut. Col.
William C. Langfitt, Corps of Engineers; Depot at Fort Leaven-
worth, Maj. Thomas H. Rees, Corps of Engineers, until August. 10,
1908, and Maj. Clement A. F. Flagler, Corps of Engineers, since
that date; Vancouver Barracks, Capt. Elliott J.                                                                                 Dent, Corps of
Engineers.
                                 ENGINEER DEPOT,                                 WASHINGTON                        BARRACKS.


   This depot is the repository for part of the military bridge equipage
of the army; for miscellaneous military engineering tools, supplies,
and materials of all kinds, and for astronomical, surveying, drafting,
and reconnaissance instruments and supplies used by the army and
by officers of the Corps of Engineers on public works, both military
and civil. It purchases and issues military engineering tools and
supplies and serves particularly as an exchange for engineer instru-
ments of all kinds, receiving them from the army or public works,
caring for them while in store, causing to be made the necessary
repairs, reissuing them when required, and, so far as limited appro-
priations will permit, making purchases of such items as can not
be supplied from store.
24.     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U. S. ARMY.

   The general work of the depot consisted of care of the property
on hand, purchase of new articles, and shipment to troops of supplies
as needed, and constructing ponton equipage. The work this year
is believed to have exceeded that of any previous one as shown by
the total weight of supplies shipped from the depot.
   The old building used for various shops of the depot, being on
part of the reservation assigned to the War College, was demolished
by the Quartermaster's Department, and as the shops are the most
essential part of the depot a new building should be provided for
immediately.
   There is no available place on the post for the storage of the
various wagons pertaining to the bridge trains, and the space avail-
able for the storage of miscellaneous lumber and bridge material is
far too small. These imperative needs of the depot should be
attended to at an early date. Roughly estimated, the construction
of such a shed for the protection of ponton wagons and other heavy
bulky ponton material, and for protecting all sorts of lumber used
at the depot for various purposes would cost about $15,000.

              ENGINEER DEPOT,     FORT LEAVENWORTH.

  This depot is the repository for part of the military equipage of
the army. The general work of the office and storehouse consisted
of care of property on hand, the purchase of supplies, occasional
shipments to troops, and repair of instruments issued to the battalion
of engineers there stationed, and the keeping of the depot accounts
and records.
  The shop was in operation from July 1 to 25, and from October 1
to June 30. Most of the work consisted of repairs to the old ponton
chess and tool wagons at the depot, and to other equipment damaged
by wear in the service. A number of trestles, paddles, drawing
tables and stools, skiffs, sap tools, pickets, and other minor articles
of equipment were also made. With the exception of the ponton
wagons, 13 chess wagons, 2 tool wagons, 1 reserve ponton, the advance
guard pontons, and 500 13-foot chess, all property carried on the
depot return is in good condition and fit for field service.

             ENGINEER DEPOT,     VANCOUVER    BARRACKS.

   During the year a ponton train consisting of the principal items
of one division advance and one division reserve equipage was trans-
ferred from the engineer depot at Fort Mason, Cal., to this depot.
Considerable work in overhauling the equipage was done. New
balk and chess were made from material on hand and all old balk
were tested to a fiber stress of approximately 4,000 pounds per
square inch.
   The details of the operations of the depots will be found in the
reports of the officers in charge.
                                 ENGINEER                EQUIPMENT              OF TROOPS.                              25
                                                 ENGINEER DEPOTS,               1909.

                                                             Incidentals.
Amount appropriated in the army appropriation act of May 11, 1908..... $11, 500.00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year...................... 10, 664. 68
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                                         835. 32
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities......................................                                     835. 24
Balance to revert to Treasury ..............                                   ............     ..........          .   08
                                                            Instruments.
Amount appropriated in the army appropriation act of May 11, 1908.....                                       $5, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year......................                                       4, 724. 78
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...-....-..             ..........................                              275. 22
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities----------------------.......-----------................                   275. 22
ESTIMATES       OF APPROPRIATIONS REQUIRED                                FOR THE ENGINEER      DEPOTS FOR 1910-11.

For incidental expenses of the depots, including fuel, lights, chemicals,
  stationery, hardware, machinery, pay of civilian clerks, mechanics,
  and laborers, extra-duty pay to soldiers necessarily employed for periods
  not less than ten days as artificers on work in addition to and not strictly
  in the line of their military duties, such as carpenters, blacksmiths,
  draftsmen, printers, lithographers, photographers, engine drivers, tele-
  graph operators, teamsters, wheelwrights, masons, machinists, painters,
  overseers, laborers, repairs of, and for materials to repair, public build-
  ings and machinery, and unforeseen expenses .......................              $20, 000. 00
For purchase and repair of instruments, to be issued to officers of the Corps
  of Engineers and to officers detailed and on duty as acting engineer offi-
  cers for use on public works and surveys ................           ............  10, 000. 00
        Total..........................................................                                      30, 000. 00
    (See Appendixes 2, 3, and 4.)

               ENGINEER                            EQUIPMENT                          OF      TROOPS.

   By act of Congress approved May 11, 1908, the sum of $72,500 was
appropriated for the procurement of ponton material, tools, instru-
ments, and supplies required for use in the engineer equipment of
troops in the field, and $343.76 was received during the year by
settlements and deposits for property transferred, sold, and lost,
making the total amount available $72,843.76. Of this sum $66,326.81
was allotted for disbursement at Washington Barracks, $4,750 at
Fort Leavenworth, $53 at Havana, $200 at Honolulu, $850 at Van-
couver Barracks, and $658.80 at headquarters Philippines Division.
The sum of $5.15 unallotted and 39 cents balance from allotment to
Vancouver Barracks, a total of $5.54, reverted to the Treasury.
   With these funds engineering supplies were obtained for the
various military divisions and departments in the United States,
insular possessions, and Cuba; engineer troops were supplied, so far
as possible, with the company equipment called for by General
Orders, No. 9, Office of the Chief of Engineers, 1906; and the pur-
chase and issue of reconnaissance outfits and intrenching tools to
military posts and organizations required by General Orders, No. 113,
War Department, 1906; General Orders, No. 73, War Department,
1907; and General Orders, No. 221, War Department, 1907, were
continued.
26      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   All supplies required by General Orders, No. 221, War Department,
1907, were purchased and delivered, except where the retention of
the intrenching tool equipment by organizations had been requested
until their return to the United States.
   At Washington Barracks considerable additions were made to
the ponton and bridge equipment, 16 chess wagons under contract
at close of the last fiscal year were delivered, and 50 ponton and 3
tool wagons were contracted for and will be completed in August,
1909. At the close of the fiscal year, practically 2 divisions of
reserve ponton equipment and 2 divisions of advance ponton equip-
ment were completed, with the exception of ponton and tool wagons.
These, however, are now under contract. Sixteen chess wagons
and 1 battery and forge wagon still required will be obtained from new
appropriations. Eight wooden ponton boats and other ponton
materials were constructed.
   At Fort Leavenworth one Rees experimental tool wagon was
completed in July and was reported upon December 31, 1908. White
pine lumber and other supplies were purchased for the construction
of additional reserve and advance guard pontons. All of this material
has been delivered, except the white pine lumber, and it is expected
that it will be delivered in time to begin work on the new boats in
November.
   At Vancouver Barracks tools and supplies were purchased for
fitting out tool wagons for 1 advance and 1 reserve division with
the exception of a few minor articles and the item of canvas. Some
oak lumber was purchased for replacing parts of carriages. Tools,
photographic supplies, explosives, lumber, etc., were also purchased
for the use of the engineer company stationed at Vancouver Barracks.
   The army appropriation act of March 3, 1909, provides $90,000
for engineer equipment of troops for the fiscal year 1910. Expend-
itures from this fund will be made for the purchase of various recon-
naissance instruments, drawing materials, photographic supplies,
intrenching tools, etc.; purchase of 35 chess carriages, 20 ponton
carriages, and 4 tool wagons for the ponton trains, and to purchase
of material and manufacture of boats, balks, chess, and other articles
pertaining to ponton equipage; to continue investigations looking
to improvement of ponton material, and making necessary repairs
and renewals to intrenching tools; for experimental development
of searchlight for field use, power plant for engineer trains, and new
forms of equipment developed from time to time.
   At the rate permitted by past appropriations, the work of supply-
ing the army with engineer equipment will take several years for
completion. In certain lines of material, definite amounts and
specifications have now been adopted and will probably not be
changed in the near future. In addition, there are many items of
equipment, such as field searchlights, new forms of ponton material,
traction for engineer pack trains, etc., on which much development
is still needed.
                         CONTINGENCIES, PHILIPPINE ISLANDS.                                              27
                              ENGINEER       EQUIPMENT OF TROOPS,               1909.


Amount appropriated in the army appropriation act of May 11,
                                                                        $72, 500. 00
  1908..........---------------------................----------........----
Amount received during year by settlements and deposits in
  payment for property transferred, sold, and lost...........                343. 76
                                                                                     $72, 843. 76
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year .....................               51, 730. 28
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                           21,113.48
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                       21,107.94

Balance to revert to Treasury...................                      ....................             5.54
    (See Appendixes 2, 3, and 4.)

    CIVILIAN ASSISTANTS TO ENGINEER                                                          OFFICERS.

  By act of Congress approved May 11, 1908, the sum of $25,000
was appropriated for civilian assistants to engineer officers serving
on the staffs of division, corps, and department commanders to
enable them to secure the services of surveyors, draftsmen, photog-
raphers, master laborers, and clerks during the fiscal year 1909.
These funds have been applied to the purpose for which appropriated;
the sum of $24,950.31 was expended during the fiscal year 1909, and
a balance of $49.69 reverted to the Treasury.
  Owing to a marked increase in the mapping work required in the
Philippines, and to an increase in the number of chief engineer offi-
cers in the United States due to the abolishment of the geographical
divisions and the assignment of a chief engineer officer to each mili-
tary department, additional funds were required for this purpose,
and the army appropriation act approved March 3, 1909, contained
an item of $40,000 for civilian assistants during the fiscal year 1910.
This sum has been apportioned among the various military depart-
ments in the United States and the Philippines Division, and will all
be required for the operations of the chief engineer officers therein.
  An estimate of the same amount, $40,000, for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1911, has been submitted.

CONTINGENCIES,                         ENGINEER DEPARTMENT,                                      PHILIP-
                                         PINE ISLANDS.

   In the prosecution of work of great importance in the Philippine
Islands, in remote and inaccessible localities, the operations of the
Engineer Department have been embarrassed by the lack of funds
of wide applicability and limited restrictions as to expenditure.
Owing to the circumstances under which the work must be per-
formed, an appropriation of this character is essential to its satis-
factory prosecution. In accordance with directions from the Sec-
retary of War, an estimate of $5,000 has been submitted for this
purpose.
28              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.

   Appropriations.-The funds with which the works for the improve-
ment of rivers and harbors were prosecuted during the past fiscal year
were derived from the appropriations made by the river and harbor
acts approved March 2, 1907, and March 3, 1909, the sundry civil acts
approved March 4, 1907, May 27, 1908, and March 4, 1909, from such
appropriations as have been provided by other general acts and by
special acts of Congress, and from the available balances of former
appropriations.
   The following works are provided for by permanent appropria-
tions: Removing sunken vessels; operating and care of dredge boats
on upper Mississippi River; removing obstructions in Mississippi
River; gauging waters of the Mississippi River and its tributaries;
examinations and surveys at South Pass, Mississippi River; mainte-
nance of South Pass channel, Mississippi River; operating snag boats
on Ohio River; operating and care of canals, etc.; support and main-
tenance of the Permanent International Commission of the Congresses
of Navigation.
   Status of works.-Statements derived from the reports of the offi-
cers in charge of the various works, and given herewith, set forth the
condition of each improvement and the extent of the work performed
during the past fiscal year.
   Expenditures.-The total amount actually expended under the di-
rection of the Chief of Engineers in connection with the improvement
of rivers and harbors during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is
as follows:
Rivers and harbors (general, including examinations, surveys, and
  contingencies)--------....-----------------....--.....--........-----.....---..............----.                   a $31, 525, 076. 39
Removing sunken vessels ..........                               ........ ..................                                  49, 828. 85
Operating snag and dredge boats on upper                                    Mississippi        and       Illinois
  rivers--........------.....-----.........--------------..----------------------------............................           25, 000.00
Removing obstructions in Mississippi River...............---.....                                                            100, 021. 03
Gauging waters of the Mississippi River and its tributaries ........                                                           8, 888. 49
Maintenance of South Pass channel, Mississippi River ..-..........                                                           119, 449. 77
Examinations and surveys at South Pass, Mississippi River ........                                                             9, 050. 00
Operating snag boats on Ohio River..-----------------..........-------------..................                                36, 391. 95
Operating and care of canals, etc------------......--------......................-----------...                           1, 700, 458.77
Prevention of deposits in New York Harbor-.........--.........                                                   ...          85, 706. 17
Mississippi River Commission-----.....--....................--------------------------.....                             b 3, 052, 675. 30
California D4bris Commission (expenses)..                                         --
                                                                                  --............         .......              14, 269. 69
Permanent International Commission of the Congresses of Naviga-
  tion---------...-----..........----------------------------------------......................................                3, 860. 50
International Waterways Commission-..--.------....-..-----..- -                                             ..                22, 255. 71
Commission on waterway connecting Chesapeake and Delaware
  bays-----...... ...........                    ............          ....    ..... .............                                352. 67
                                                                                                                  36, 753, 285. 29
     This amount does not include the following:
Enlargement of Governors Island, New York Harbor .-...........                                                        $188, 533. 83
Reclamation of Quarantine Island, Honolulu, Hawaii .............                                                              2. 75
Piers, Hampton Roads, Jamestown Exposition .....................                                                         1, 086. 40
                                                                                                                        189, 622. 98

   a Includes $594.33 omitted from statement of expenditures for fiscal year 1908.
  b Does not include $10,000 allotted from "Emergencies in River and Harbor Works,"
and $8,338.68 under "Gauging Waters of the Mississippi River," included in first
statement.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           29
   Expenditures have also been made as follows, from funds con-
tributed by States, municipalities, and private parties:
Contributed by citizens of St. Joseph, Mo., for improvement of Missouri
  River......................                                                                                  $4,179.85
Contributed by Twin City Rapid Transit Company and city of St. Paul,
Minn., for construction of bridge over Mississippi River at Fort Snell-
ing ............................                     ...... .....       ......... ...............             95, 905. 09
Contributed by State of Washington for improvement of Snake River,
Wash..-               -------------------------------------------------....                         ---.      26, 786.75
Contributed by State of Washington for improvement of Columbia River
above Celilo, W ash..................................................                                         11, 840. 34
Contributed by railroad companies for improvement of Missouri River at
Elwood, Kans --------------------------------............----------------                                     13, 290. 61
Contributed by railroad companies and private interests for improvement
of Puyallup Waterway, Tacoma, Wash..........                                   ................         ..    61, 557. 50
Contributed by citizens of Dallas, Tex., for improvement of Trinity River,
Tex .. .. ..............................                         ...... ....     .......           .....       6, 316. 52
Contributed by Cape May Real Estate Company for improvement of Cold
  Spring Inlet, N. J......................................                            .............             2, 800.41
Contributed by State of Rhode Island for improvement of Pawtucket
  River, R. I........................................................                                          19, 933. 24
Contributed by certain citizens of Oregon, for improvement of Coos
  Bay................................................................                                          21, 270. 41

                                                                                                              263, 880. 72
   Estimates.-The following estimates are submitted by the Chief
of Engineers for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911:
Under continuing contracts, including Mississippi River Commission. $9, 194, 428. 00
Rivers and harbors (general, including examinations, surveys, and
  contingencies).....-........                                       . 27, 038, 037. 00
Under California Debris Commission (expenses) .....................         15, 000. 00
Prevention of deposits in New York Harbor-..........................       100, 250. 00
   Engineer divisions.-The engineering works in charge of this office
are arranged in divisions, and officers of the Corps of Engineers were
assigned as division engineers to overlook these works, as follows:
  East of the Rocky Mountains: Northeast Division, Col. John G. D.
Knight; Eastern Division, Col. D. W. Lockwood; Southeast Division,
Col. Dan. C. Kingman; Gulf Division, Col. E. H. Ruffner to August
31, 1908, Lieut. Col. L. H. Beach since August 31, 1908; Central
Division, Col. Winm. T. Rossell; Lakes Division, Lieut. Col. W. L.
Fisk; Western Division, Col. W. H. Bixby. West of the Rocky
Mountains: Pacific Division, Lieut. Col. John Biddle; Northern
Pacific Division, Lieut. Col. John Biddle, temporarily in charge.
  Preliminary examinations and surveys.-The river and harbor act
of March 3, 1909, provides for preliminary examinations and surveys
of certain localities, and the duty of making the same has been as-
signed to boards of engineers and to officers of the Corps of Engineers
in charge of the various engineering districts. Specific reference is
made in the following pages to reports already received and trans-
mitted to Congress concerning Point Judith Pond, R. I.; Newark
Bay, N. J.; Point Harbor Channel, N. C.; Waverly Creek, S. C.; Indian
River, Fla.; Pine Island Sound, Fla.; New River, Fla.; Arkansas
River at Douglas, Ark.; Blackfish Bayou, Ark.; Little Black River,
Ark. and Mo.; and Feather River, Cal., to Marysville. Reports con-
cerning the other localities will be duly submitted when received.
30                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                           S. ARMY.

Itemized statement of expenditures during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, under sec-
  tion 14 of the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, submitted in compliance with the
  requirements of said law.

                               Number, designation, and time employed.                                                   Rate.        Amount.


One assistant engineer, April 24 to June 30..................                          .....             ......       p. a. $3, 600     $670. 00
One law officer, March 26 to June 30. ...........             ...        ..        ..      .............              p. a. 2, 500       659. 72
One draftsman, April 7 to June 30..-..........           .....        .........       ....... ...........             p. a. 1,800        420.00
One clerk, May 6 to June 30.......................................................                            ...     p. a. 1,400        213. 90
One carpenter, March 24 to May 15 (45 days)-.-.............                      ......         ..............          p. d. 4. 00      180. 00
Three laborers, March 23 to April 13 (17$ days each).........................
One laborer, March 23 to April 1 (8$ days)....        -..............                 ...........
                                                                                                               ....
                                                                                                                ...
                                                                                                                        p. d. 1. 50
                                                                                                                        p. d. 1. 50
                                                                                                                                          80. 43
                                                                                                                                          12. 56
One laborer, April 3 to April.13 (8$ days). ....           ..........................                                   p. d. 1. 50       12. 37
Four laborers, April 21 to April 26 (4$ days each) .................................                                    p. d. 1. 50       26. 24
        Total...........----        ------------------
                                 .......---                             -------------------------------............                    2,275.22



IMPROVEMENT                           OF        RIVERS AND HARBORS                                      IN        THE       PORTLAND,
                                                    MAINE, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Lieut. Col. Geo. A. Zinn, Corps of
Engineers. Division engineer, Col. John G. D. Knight, Corps of
Engineers.
   1. Lubec Channel, Maine.-This channel lies between the eastern
extremity of the State of Maine and Campobello Island, Canada.
   Originally the depth was about 5 feet at mean low tide and 2 feet
at low water of spring tides. At and near low tide vessels were unable
to navigate the passage and were obliged to take a route about
10 miles longer, through Canadian waters, to reach Lubec, Eastport,
Calais, Pembroke, and other ports in Maine on the St. Croix and
Pembroke rivers.
   A project was adopted in 1879 which, as subsequently modified, pro-
vided for a channel 275 feet wide, increasing to 300 feet in the bends,
and 12 feet deep at mean low tide. This project was completed in
1890, practically as proposed, at a cost of $168,954.68.
   The present project was adopted August 18, 1894, and its object
was to widen the then existing channel to a least width of 500 feet, at
an estimated cost of $150,000. The amount expended on the work of
the existing project up to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1909, was $138,478.30. At the latter date the channel had been
dredged to the full projected width and depth contemplated by the
project of 1894. The work will probably be reasonably permanent,
but examinations will have to be made from time to time, when oppor-
tunity offers, to determine this question.
   The maximum draft that can be carried is about 11.5 feet at mean
low water; the mean variation in tide level is 18.2 feet. The channel,
which is about 3 miles long, connects the roads above with the Atlantic
Ocean, and is the convenient and direct approach to Lubec, Eastport,
and St. Croix River from the westward. It is an international pas-
sage, and the benefits from the improvement are almost entirely gen-
eral. As the tidal currents are very strong and dense fogs prevail a
large part of the time, the widening of the passage decreases the
chances of stranding and collision.
   It is impracticable to make a definite statement covering the navi-
gation using the channel, but the tonnage for the calendar year 1908,
for the town of Lubec, at the head of the passage, is given as 56,370
tons, having an estimated value of $1,400,000, the chief items being
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              31
canned goods (principally sardines), fish, and coal, in the order
named. The chief effect on freight rates probably arises through the
competition afforded by a direct line of steamers to Portland and
Boston, the railroads giving the public lower rates to points having
water lines of transportation.
  For reports on examinations and surveys see page 279, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, and page 616, report for
1891.
  There were no expenditures during the fiscal year 1909.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................... . .............. $11, 567.02
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................... 11, 567. 02
  (See Appendix A 1.)
   2. Breakwater from Mount Desert to Porcupine Island, Bar Har-
bor, Me.-The object of the breakwater is to protect the wharves of
Bar Harbor and the anchorage in front of the town from the heavy
seas of southerly gales.
   The act of August 11, 1888, made an appropriation for commenc-
ing the work. The project was modified in 1893 as to length of
breakwater, and now provides for a structure of riprap stone, ex-
tending from Porcupine Island 2,500 feet in a westerly direction to
a point about 600 feet from the low-water line on Mount Desert
Island. The top of the breakwater is to be at the level of mean high
tide, 20 feet wide, and the side slopes such as the rock assumes-
about 1 on 1. The estimate of cost was based on the expectation
that 382,000 tons of stone would be required, and was placed at
$420,200.
   The expenditures to June 30, 1909, were $219,559.61. There was
no work in progress during the fiscal year 1909, the expenditures
practically representing payments for contract work completed the
previous year.
   The breakwater has been built to full section for a length of about
1,859 feet, leaving about 641 feet yet to be constructed; the total
quantity of stone deposited to the present time is 211,534 tons.
   The tonnage for the calendar year 1908 is reported as about 332,000
tons, with an estimated value of $4,774,890. The great increase in
quantity is explained as chiefly due to the erection of several large
brick and stone buildings, the materials for which were received by
water.
   The beneficial effects resulting from the portion of the breakwater
already built in protecting the wharves at Bar Harbor and the anchor-
age basin, which is extensively used by costly pleasure craft during
the summer season, are appreciably felt, but in order to secure
the desired protection at high water of spring tides it may be found
necessary to raise the breakwater to a height of about 6 feet above
mean high tide. The mean range in tides is 11.5 feet.
   The benefits to navigation are general in providing a harbor of
refuge, and local in making it possible for boats to land at the wharves
at all times with safety. The only convenient method of transpor-
tation to and from Bar Harbor is by boat.
   The new appropriation estimated for is to be applied in extending
the breakwater, in accordance with the project.
   For report on examination and survey, see Annual Report of th6
Chief of Engineers for 1887, page 481.
32        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                 S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................     $13, 997. 30
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment......................... .................................... 13, 556. 91

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..........................    ..........      440. 39
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 200, 200. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
                                                                       50,000.00
   July 1,1909...------...............................----------------------
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
     (See Appendix A 2.)
   3. Harbor at Sullivan Falls, Maine.-Sullivan River has a length
of about 6 miles and is the outlet of a large bay. About midway of
its length a point of land projects to such extent as to reduce the
width to about one-fourth that immediately above and below, and at
this place the slope and velocity are such that the locality is termed
"Sullivan Falls." The bottom is ledge, the higher portions forming
dangerous obstructions to navigation. Hatchers rock, about midway
of the narrow channel at the falls, had originally only about 6 inches
of water over it at mean low tide. The mean range in tides is 11.5
feet.
   Under a project set forth in report of the district engineer dated
December 10, 1870, and under appropriations based thereon, the sum
of $35,000 was expended in removing three old piers, in excavating
the obstructing ledges at the falls to a depth of 7 feet at mean low
tide, and in replacing spindles on two rocks near the mouth of the
river. This work was completed in 1875 and was of material benefit
to navigation.
   The present project is that referred to in the river and harbor act
of June 3, 1896, as the "approved project," and published in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1891, page 619. It pro-
vides for removing Hatchers rock and two other points of ledge to a
depth of 10 feet at mean low tide, at an estimated cost of $35,000.
   The expenditures under the existing project to June 30, 1909, were
$14,870.64, and the operations consisted in removing the entire area
of Hatchers rock and about five-sixths of ledge "C" to a depth of 10
feet at mean low tide. About 70 per cent of the work covered by the
project has been completed.
   To complete the present project the remaining part of ledge "C,"
containing about 67 cubic yards in situ, and ledge "B," containing
255.3 cubic yards in situ, will have to be removed.
   The improvement not only increases the navigable depth, but also,
by removing the cause of eddies and cross currents, has added to the
length of time at each high and low tide during which vessels may
pass through the rapids with safety.
   Vessels can not use the channel at low stages except when the tide
is slack. This occurs after the tide has flowed about 2 feet, at which
time vessels drawing 11 feet can pass through safely.
   The improvement may be regarded as permanent.
   The commerce for the calendar year 1908 is given as 59,300 tons,
with an estimated value of $64,150. It is nearly all granite. The
improvement is reported as affecting freight rates by improving the
channel, but definite figures in this respect are not available.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             33
  It is proposed to apply the new appropriation estimated for in
continuing the rock excavation in accordance with the project.
  For reports on examinations and surveys, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1871, page 836; and page 619, report for 1891.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..........................................................     $129. 36
June 30, 1909, carried to the surplus fund ................................                     129. 36
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                    20, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement.................................... 10, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
    (See Appendix A 3.)
  4. Union River, Maine.-The navigable portion of the river extends
from the head of Union Bay to the foot of the falls at Ellsworth, a
distance of about 34 miles:
   Before improvement the channel was obstructed by a large deposit
of slabs, edgings, and sawdust near Ellsworth, which practically sus-
pended navigation except at high tide, by projecting ledges in the
Narrows about three-fourths of a mile below the wharves at Ells-
worth, by bowlders at several points along the channel, and by a
broad, flat bar of sawdust and mud at the mouth.
   The first project for the improvement of the river is contained in
the report of the district officer dated June 30, 1867, and provided for
erecting beacons, removing sunken ledges and bowlders, and dredging
mill waste near Ellsworth, so as to secure a depth of 3 feet at mean
low tide, this being the available depth on the bar at the mouth of
the river. This improvement was completed in 1873 with an expendi-
ture of $30,000.
   A survey was made in 1889 under the provisions of the act of 1888,
and a new project was submitted with a view to obtaining a depth of
6 feet at mean low tide from the wharves at Ellsworth to deep water
in the bay. This depth was to be obtained by dredging mill waste
near Ellsworth, by removal of ledge in the Narrows, and by dredging
across the bar at the mouth of the river. To maintain the improved
depth at the latter point, the same project provided for the construc-
tion of a training wall to concentrate the ebb flow in the channel.
The project is described on page 462, Part 1, Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1890, and was estimated to cost $225,000.
   The act of June 3, 1896, appropriated $15,000 for improving the
river, by dredging, and as $145,000 represented the estimated cost
of the dredging operations under the project submitted in 1890, that
sum was adopted as the estimated cost, and the project was taken
to cover the dredging only. Serious movements of the mill waste in
the river obliterated some of the work; some modifications were
afterwards made; and in 1902, when funds were practically exhausted,
the results secured were a channel depth of 6 feet at mean low tide
up as far as the vicinity of Ellsworth and a channel 4 feet deep at
mean low tide at the latter locality. Expenditures under this
project were $142,601.36.
   In 1908 an examination indicated that there had been some
shoaling at the mouth of the river, and to a greater degree near
Ellsworth. In the other portion of the river the work had practically
        9001-ENG 1909---- 3
34          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

maintained. The erection of a new large dam at the head of navi-
gation rendering it unlikely that any more material would come down
from the deposits above, in April, 1909, an allotment of $15,950 was
made from the appropriation for preservation and maintenance of
river and harbor works provided by the river and harbor act of March
3, 1909, for the purpose of restoring the conditions of 1902. The ex-
penditures under the latter allotment have been $103.19. The work
was advertised, and a contract is now being made with a view to com-
pleting the dredging during the present working season.
   The mean range of tide is 10 feet. At mean low tide only about
1 foot can be carried to the wharves at Ellsworth. The dam near
Ellsworth is without a lock, and navigation is limited to that point.
There is some logging on the river above, but it is no longer extensive.
   The commerce by water for the calendar year 1908 is reported as
8,660 tons, chiefly coal, cooperage, and lumber. The estimated
value of the commodities is placed at $57,119. It is stated that, while
receipts and shipments by water have been decreasing in the last
few years, the business for 1908 was unusually small, and that the
shipments for the first half of 1909 will probably exceed those for
the entire year 1908.
   For reference to reports on examinations and surveys, see page 30,
Annual Report for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....................................-.. $2, 512. 65
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.. ...............    ...................      .......   . 15, 950. 00
                                                                           18, 462. 65
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement ............. .... .....-.....  .... .... --..............      217. 20
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................         18, 245. 45
     (See Appendix A 4.)
   5. Bagaduce River, Maine.-This is a small stream that empties into
Penobscot Bay at Castine, Me. The upper part of the river divides
into two branches, one called Northern Bay and the other South Bay.
Northern Bay, near South Penobscot, is a shoal sheet of water of about
700 acres area, the bottom of which for the greater part is bare at
low tide. Before improvement there was a narrow channel from
Bridges Point to Bowden's wharf, which had a depth of less than 2
feet and was obstructed by ledges and bowlders near Winslows Island.
The South Bay is obstructed by ledges at Johnsons Narrows. Mean
rise and fall of tide, 9.8 feet.
   The approved project is understood to be that published at page
398 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1888. Its
object is to secure a channel 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean
low tide from Bridges Point, Northern Bay, to Bowden's wharf, at
an estimated cost of $45,000. The same project provides for remov-
ing a small quantity of rock in the channel at Johnsons Narrows, at
an estimated cost of $1,875. All work done has been in accordance
with this project. About one-third of the work covered by the
project may be said to have been completed.
   The expenditures to June 30, 1909, were $28,000. At that date
there had been made, by dredging and the removal of rocks and
bowlders, a channel 40 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean law tide.,
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                               35
except at Winslows Island, where a depth of only 4 feet has been
secured. The total length of channel is about 4,000 feet.
   The improvement has been regarded as of doubtful public value.
   There were no expenditures during the fiscal year 1909, and there
was no work in progress.
   From the mouth of the river at Castine to the head of navigation,
in Northern Bay, is about 9 miles.
   The tonnage for 1908 is given as 117,795 tons, but this includes the
business of Castine, at the mouth of the river. The commerce for
that part of the Bagaduce covered by the project for improvement is
put at 29,030 tons, the chief commodities, in weight, being bricks,
clay, lumber, wood, and grain, with a total estimated value of about
$400,000.
   The new appropriation recommended is for continuing the excava-
tion of the channel at Winslows Island.
   For reports on examinations and surveys, see Annual Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for 1888, page 398; 1893, page 724; and 1898,
page 842.
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ $18, 875. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
   30, 1911, for works of improvement... ...............       ....       5, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897.
  (See Appendix A 5.)
  6. Penobscot River, Maine.-Except the dredging of a sawdust bar
opposite High Head, near Bucksport, Me., the improvements have
been confined to a stretch of about 32 miles of the river at and below
Bangor. Before improvement this part of the river was obstructed
by ledge, bowlders, and mill waste to such extent as to afford a safe
available depth of only about 6 feet at extreme low tide. The mean
range in tides is 13.1 feet.
  The head of navigation is at Bangor; from thence to the head of
the bay is about 27 miles.
  The first project was approved August 22, 1870, and called for a
depth of 12 feet at lowest tides for a width of 150 feet over 3 miles
of river at and below Bangor. There was expended $198,300.
  In 1884 a project was adopted for widening the channel at Bangor
and for certain improvements in the river below, near Crosbys Nar-
rows. An addition was afterwards made providing for a 22-foot
depth between Bucksport and Winterport. After a survey, ordered
by the act of September 19, 1890, the project was modified and
extended so that it included a depth of 11 feet at extreme low tide
for a width of 360 feet in Bangor Harbor; to widen, straighten, and
deepen the channel near Crosbys Narrows and near Sterns mill to a
depth of 12 feet at extreme low tide, and to secure a channel depth
of 22 feet at mean low tide between Bucksport and Winterport. The
estimated cost of the entire work was placed at $440,000. March 3,
1899, the project was again extended by providing for removal of
ledge in front of the Boston and Bangor Steamboat Company's
wharf at Bangor and for deepening the basin of Kenduskeag stream
at its junction with the Penobscot, and $28,000 was appropriated
for the work. The results aimed at by the project of 1884 and the
subsequent additions are regarded as practically accomplished, and
36             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                     S. ARMY.

the cost has been $169,500, a total expenditure down to this time of
$367,800.
   By the act of March 2, 1907, Congress adopted a further project for
an additional width at Bangor, varying from 100 to 300 feet, for a
length of nearly 2,000 feet, the depth to be 11 feet at extreme low
tide (14 feet at mean low water). The estimated cost of this work
is $130,000. The amount expended on the work of the existing
project to June 30, 1909, is $1,724.01. The work has been placed
under contract, and at the close of June, 1909, a considerable area
had been worked over, and about 6,000 cubic yards of material, scow
measurement, had been taken up, but as the area has not yet been
swept to determine whether or not the full depth has been secured,
accurate information as to the real progress is not available.
   The least depth over the area now being excavated is about 9 feet
at mean low tide, but the prevailing channel depth at Bangor is 14
feet. Elsewhere in the river the depth is greater. While Bangor,
where there is a dam without a lock, is the head of navigation, the
river above is extensively used for floating logs down from the upper
waters.
   The tonnage for calendar year 1908 is given as 552,332 tons, of
which 267,400 tons was coal and 150,000 tons lumber. The value of
receipts and shipments is estimated at about $3,411,925.
   For list of examinations and reports see page 32, Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
                                          GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................                                $8, 500. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...............................                                    8, 500. 00

                                                   AT BANGOR.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..........................        ...... $128, 891. 31
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for vorks of improve-
  ment ..........................................................              615. 32

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..............               .......................          128, 275. 99
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                           200. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available...................................                             128, 075. 99

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                          124, 900. 00
    (See Appendix A 6.)
   7. Rockland Harbor, Maine.-The wharves are located on the
shores of three coves, formed by two projecting points of land on the
western side of the harbor, known as Crocketts Point and Atlantic
Point. The general direction of the wharf frontage is north and
south, and the length of frontage is about 800 feet. Before improve-
ment depths in front of the wharves increased very slowly. All the
wharves except those at the end of Crocketts Point and Atlantic
Point extended only a short distance beyond the low-water contour, a
high mean range in tide, which at this point is 9.6 feet, being relied
upon to give access to moderate and light draft vessels at high tides.
The entrance to the harbor from the east has a width of about 9,000
feet.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                         37
   Before improvement the anchorage in front of the wharves, vessels
lying at the wharves, and the wharves themselves were endangered
by heavy seas during easterly gales.
   The first improvement undertaken was to render it a safe harbor
of refuge for coastwise shipping, and incidentally also to protect the
wharves as far as possible from heavy seas. To accomplish this a
project was adopted in 1881 in which two breakwaters were con-
templated, one extending south from Jamesons Point, the other a
detached breakwater nearer to and opposite the principal wharves
in the town, both to be raised in the first instance to the level of
mean tide, but with the expectation that a further raising would be
necessary as experience might dictate.
   In 1886 this project was amended so as to raise the height of the
breakwater at Jamesons Point to the level of mean high tide. In
1890 it was again amended so as to eliminate the detached break-
water and to provide for extending farther south than was first
contemplated the breakwater at Jamesons Point.
   By the act of June 3, 1896, Congress adopted a project for dredging
the inner harbor in the vicinity of the wharves to depths ranging
from 4 feet to 13 feet at mean low tide and for removing two danger-
ous ledges, one occupying a central position in the harbor, which was
to be cut down to the depth of 22 feet at mean low tide; the other,
less centrally located, was to be removed to a depth of 14 feet. The
estimated cost was $402,000. By the same act this project was com-
bined with that for the breakwater as one project, and authority was
given for completing the whole under the continuous-contract system,
at an estimated expenditure of $1,036,000.
   The appropriations for the above work have aggregated $925,500.
The total of expenditures to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1909, is $920,025.79. As a result the project has been completed,
subject to any work that may be needed from time to time until the
slopes of the breakwater, which is about 4,140 feet in length, have
assumed a condition of definite permanence. The benefits resulting
are that the breakwater affords a safe and extensive anchorage and
harbor of refuge. The removal of ledges has increased the available
anchorage area, and the dredging affords access to the wharves by
vessels of greater draft.
   There was no work during the fiscal year 1909. The business by
water for the calendar year 1908 amounted to 493,950 tons, of which
235,000 was lime and 100,000 tons coal. The value of the commodi-
ties has been estimated at $2,494,580. It is impracticable to definitely
state the direct effect on freight rates. Aside from the advantage
arising from competitive water transportation freight charges by
water have been subject to reduction through economies made pos-
sible by the use of larger vessels.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................      $5, 474. 21
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................    5, 474. 21
   (See Appendix A 7.)
   8. Sasanoa River, Maine.-Originally this stream was much ob-
structed in the vicinity of Upper Hell Gate. The channel at and
near that place was crooked and narrow and was obstructed by dan-
38        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, IT. S. ARMY.

gerous ledges, the shoalest of which had not more than 3 feet of water
over it at mean low tide.
   Between 1.870 and 1881 the sum of $45,500 was appropriated, and
the navigation was much improved by rock excavation, dredging,
and the construction of a small jetty.
   By act of June 3, 1896, a new project was adopted for widening
the channel at Upper Hell Gate to 125 feet, with a depth of 12 feet
at mean low tide, by ledge excavation; for dredging to the same depth
at Carletons ledges, and for constructing a small jetty at the Camp
Ground, at an estimated cost of $19,000, which amount was appro-
priated by the same act. This project. was completed in 1898 at a
cost of $11,987.69.
   The present ,project, submitted by the Board of Engineers for
Rivers and Harbors February 7, 1907, is to increase to a width of not
less than 140 feet the channel 90 feet wide made under the first proj-
ect through the ledges southeastwardly of Upper Hell Gate, and to
remove Flat rock, all to the depth of 12 feet at mean low tide. This
project was adpoted by the act of March 2, 1907, which contained an
appropriation of the entire estimated cost, viz, $44,000.
   Expenditures under the existing project to June 30, 1909, have
been $33,788.90.
   During the fiscal year the work of excavating ledge was continued,
and the project of 1907 was completed. The Sasanoa is a tidal river
or thoroughfare, about 9 miles in length, connecting the Kennebec
River at Bath, Me., with Sheepscot River. It is the usual route of
travel to Booth Bay Harbor, a place of considerable importance, and
in the summer the travel is much increased by the large number of
summer residents at Squirrel Island and other resorts in that vicinity.
It is navigable throughout its entire length and has about 12 feet
depth at mean low tide over the shoalest parts. The mean range of
tide in the vicinity of the last improvement is about 8.5 feet. The
work recently completed has resulted in giving practically a straight
channel 140 feet wide where the width was formerly 90 feet. By
reducing the current it has made the straight channel easily navigable,
while before it was regarded as difficult, and vessels used a crooked
channel to the westward of Green Island, where there was less cur-
rent. The increase in discharge capacity and elimination of some of
the cross currents has improved the conditions in the westerly
channel also.
   The business for 1908 is given as 3,896 tons, having an estimated
value of $274,195. The number of passengers carried was 73,537.
   The effect on freight rates can not be stated in a definite way, but
the improvement permits the use of larger vessels necessary to accom-
modate the increasing travel and renders the passage less dangerous.
   For reports on examinations and surveys see Annual Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for 1867, page 499; 1895, page 953; for map,
report for 1880, page 334.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................................. $37, 769. 13
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment ...............................................................    27, 558. 03
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................            ....   10, 211. 10
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..........................              100. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available......................................1.10, 111. 10
     (See Appendix A 8.)
                ilVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      39

    9. Kennebec River, Maine.-Before improvement the main chan-
nel of the river between the foot of Swan Island and Gardiner was
obstructed by shoals near Beef rock, with only 10 feet of water at
mean low tide, by dangerous sunken ledges in Lovejoy Narrows, by
a shoal below South Gardiner, with only 8 feet on it at mean low
tide, and by a ledge at Nehumkeg Island. The steamboat channel to
the west of Swan Island (at Hatchs rock) was obstructed by a shoal
over which there was only 72 feet of water, and the channel between
Gardiner and Augusta, a distance of 6-2 miles, was obstructed by
shoals which gave a navigable depth of only 31 feet in low summer
tides.
   Appropriations for minor improvements were made at various
times between 1827 and 1852.
   In 1866 a project was begun for improving the upper part of the
river, with a view to obtaining a channel 7 feet deep and 100 feet
wide at low water. This project, with modifications, was completed
in 1877, and resulted in obtaining a channel 10 feet deep at mean low
tide and not less than 100 feet wide as far up as Gardiner, and a depth
of 6 feet at low tide and width of 100 feet from Gardiner to Augusta.
    The channel west of Swan Island, being obstructed by shoal water
 (8 feet at mean low tide) and a too narrow channel at the head of
the island, by shoal water at Hatchs rock, below Richmond, and by a
very narrow channel 30 feet wide at the foot of the island, was im-
proved by dredging in 1881-1883, so as to give a channel 175 feet wide
and 11 feet deep at the foot of the island and a channel of about 80
feet width and 10 feet depth at Hatchs rock and the head of the
island.
    The river and harbor act of 1886 provided for a new survey of the
river from Bath to Augusta. This survey was made in 1887, and a
project embracing dredging, rock excavation, and contraction works
was submitted for the further improvement of the river. In 1892 this
project was revised to secure depths as follows: Thirteen feet at mean
low tide as far up as Sands Island, 12 feet thence to Hinckleys shoal,
above Gardiner, and 10 feet thence to Augusta, at an estimated cost of
 $388,500. This project was approved August 19, 1892, and was essen-
tially completed in 1898.
    The improved channel obtained under the above projects suffered
some loss of available depth by the deposits brought down by freshets.
This shoaling was most marked in the stretch of 6 miles of river
between Gardiner and Augusta, the further improvement of which
was provided for by the river and harbor act approved June 13,
1902, which appropriated $40,000 and authorized a continuing
contract for the completion of the project. The last project is
published at page 1121 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1900, and proposes a widening of the channel from Gardiner
to Augusta to 125 feet and a cleaning out of the old dredged channel
and its further deepening to 16 feet at mean high water, or 11 feet at
mean low water.
    The total estimated cost of the project of 1902, which was $81,000,
has been appropriated, and the project was completed November 28,
1908.
    The total of expenditures under the above projects is $50,411.03.
    A project for improvement between the mouth and Gardiner was
adopted by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, and is designed
40           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                           U.   S. ARMY.

to obtain, by dredging and ledge excavation, channels through the
shoals between the foot of Swan Island and Gardiner at least 150
feet wide and of such depths that for a vessel passing up the river
at the usual speed on the flood tide and timed to reach Gardiner at
high water the available depth would at no point be less than 20.5
feet. The depth over ledge is to be 1 foot greater than this. Two
training walls are to be repaired and one of them lengthened 700 feet.
The cost of the project is estimated at $275,000.
   The act of 1907 placed the project under the continuing contract
system, and by that and subsequent acts $231,500 has been appro-
priated, leaving $43,500 yet to be provided.
   Expenditures to June 30, 1909, under the project of 1907 have
been $72,298.82. Operations during the last fiscal year are regarded
as new work, and have included the extension and repair of jetties,
under contract, which has been completed. The work of dredging,
under contract, was also continued throughout the year, except for
the winter season, and about 32 per cent of that work has now been
accomplished. The ledge excavation has recently been placed under
contract, and that work also has been commenced. All the work
necessary for completion of the project is now under contract.
   While some advantage arises from increased depths as the work
advances, the measure of such will be limited until further progress
has been made.
   The mean rise and fall of tides at Bath is 6.9 feet; at Gardiner,
5.1 feet; at Augusta, 4.3 feet. Augusta is the head of navigation
and is about 44 miles above the mouth of the river. Above that
point the stream is practically devoted to water power and lumber-
ing operations. Over the shoalest part of the river between the
mouth and Gardiner, which is the portion covered by the existing
project, about 12 feet can be carried at mean low tide.
   The commerce for 1908 amounted to 377,238 tons, chiefly ice, coal,
and lumber, having an estimated value of $1,379,962.50. It is
expected that a considerable increase will be shown next year, as
last winter more ice was harvested than for a number of years.
   While the use of the river for transportation purposes has some
value in a competitive way, the principal effect on freight rates is
due to the increased depths which permit the use of larger vessels
and larger cargoes in handling such commodities as coal, ice, and
lumber, which demand cheap transportation.
   It is proposed to apply funds asked for in continuing the im-
provement of the river from the mouth to Gardiner under existing
contracts.
   For reports on examinations and surveys see Annual Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for 1867, page 488; 1881, page 479; 1888, page
412; 1892, page 541; and 1900, page 1121, and House Document No.
321, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session.
                                     GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .........................                     ............. $12, 500. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during the fiscal year for works of
  improvement ...............................         .... ...................                10, 833. 51

June 30, 1909, carried to the surplus fund..........................                          1, 666. 49
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   41
                                 BETWEEN GARDINER              AND AUGUSTA.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended- ......................            ........                         36, 691. 30
June 30, 1909, amount expended during the fiscal year for works of
  improvement ...................        .... ...... ..... ... ..... ..........                      36, 691. 30
                                    FROM THE MOUTH TO GARDINER.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............   ...................          $150, 945.05
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909 -----......---. 70, 000. 00
                                                                                                    220, 945.05
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  m ent ............................................................                                 61, 743.87

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended                 -.....-...........................                 159, 201.18
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................                             15, 572. 39

July 1, 1909, balance available .........................                             ...........   143, 628.79

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. .............                                167, 867. 51
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. .......                              43, 500. 00
   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
     1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
    July 1, 1909.................................................                                   43, 500. 00
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
    June 4, 1897.
    (See Appendix A 9.)
   10. Portland Harbor, Maine.-The entrance to the main part of the
harbor of Portland, or the anchorage, has always been good, but
before improvement the approach to the inner harbor was obstructed
by a shoal known as the Middle Ground, over which the depth was
only from 8 to 10 feet at mean low tide, while between it and Stam-
ford ledge the greatest available depth was only 16 feet. The best
part of the wharf front was exposed to swell from the main entrance,
which sometimes made it dangerous for vessels to lie at the docks, and
along this front the depth was in some places as shallow as 4 feet.
   The first work of improvement undertaken by the Government was
the construction of the breakwater. This was begun as early as 1836.
It was completed in 1874.
   The work of deepening the harbor was begun under the act of Con-
gress of 1868, the plan of improvement being to excavate a channel
300 feet wide and 20 feet deep at mean low tide through the southern
slope of the Middle Ground and to remove the bar off the Grand
Trunk Railroad wharves to the same depth.
   The project was modified in 1870 so as to provide for a channel 400
feet wide, and again in 1871 so as to provide for a channel 500 feet
wide. In 1872 further modifications were made by including in the
project the dredging of Back Cove and the dredging of the inner
harbor up to the harbor commissioner's lines to a depth of 16 feet at
mean low tide. The project, modified as above described, excepting
some dredging in the inner harbor, was completed by 1876. Between
1881 and 1885 the Middle Ground was removed to a depth of 21 feet
at mean low tide.
   A further deepening of a portion of the harbor to 29 feet at mean
low tide was next begun under the project of 1886. To this was sub-
sequently added, in 1890, a small amount of dredging in the upper
part of the harbor.
42       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

   In 1894 the project was extended to cover the widening of the upper
part of the 29-foot area and the dredging of a channel 25 feet deep to
connect the deep water in the lower part of the harbor with deep
water in the upper part. This work was completed in 1894.
   By the act of June 3, 1896, Congress adopted a project for dredging
to 30 feet at mean low tide over the greater part of the harbor, at an
estimated cost of $770,000, and included in the project the further
improvement of Back Cove at a combined estimate of $946,250. The
same act appropriated $20,000 for beginning work, and authorized
the making of a contract for its completion.
   The latter project was completed in 1902, at a cost which was about
$253,000 less than the estimate. By the sundry civil act of March 3,
1905, Congress authorized an amendment to the project by which the
30-foot channel was to be continued up Fore River as far as the Boston
and Maine Railroad bridge, a channel of entrance to Back Cove
dredged to the same depth, the width in each case to be about 300
feet, and a small area on the south side of the harbor, in front of the
old dry dock, also to be dredged.
   Expenditures to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909,
have been $1,512,388.59-$576,477.05 under former projects and
$935,911.54 under the existing one. All the projects have now been
accomplished, including the amendment of that of 1905, which was
completed in September, 1908. Appropriations have been made to
the extent of the authorization of 1896; all expenditures have been
for new work.
   There are no silt-bearing streams emptying into Portland Harbor,
and the improved depths obtained under the project will be prac-
tically permanent. The maximum draft that can be carried to the
wharves in Portland Harbor at mean low tide is 30 feet and to the
wharves in Back Cove about 11 feet. The mean range in tide is 8.8
feet.
   Two principal advantages have followed this large improvement.
A large and well-sheltered deep-water anchorage has been created
under the shelter of the breakwater, and the trans-Atlantic vessels
can arrive and depart from their docks at the lowest stages of tide.
   The portion of the harbor in which most of the dredging has been
done is the lower part of so-called Fore River. This river is crossed
by four bridges. Going up the harbor these are: (1) Portland
bridge; (2) bridge of the Boston and Maine Railroad, Eastern Divi-
sion; (3) Vaughan bridge, belonging to city; (4) bridge of Boston
and Maine Railroad, Western Division. Portland bridge has a draw
65 feet wide and admits vessels of the largest class coming to Portland.
The next bridge has a draw opening of 60 feet, and the city of Port-
land has recently reconstructed the third bridge with openings of not
less than 60 feet. The improvements in the bridges and the new
channel afford great relief to the coal trade and other deep-draft
cormerce, which was formerly much hampered and retarded by lack
of room and sufficient water.
   The commerce for 1908 is given as 2,932,517 tons, of which more
than one-half was coal. The value of the commerce is estimated by
the shippers as $86,054,108.99.
   It is impracticable to make a definite statement as to the effect of
the improvement on freight rates, but a large trans-Atlantic business
has been greatly helped, and the capacity of the harbor has kept
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   43

pace with the increase in size and draft of vessels used in the coal
traffic, with the accompanying saving in cost of transportation.
   For reports on examinations and surveys, see Annual Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for 1886, page 541; 1893, page 735; 1901, page
1009, and House Document No. 445, Fifty-ninth Congress, first
session, and No. 896, Sixtieth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................                                $42, 228. 30
                           --
Received from sales ........................................                         .......             6. 00

                                                                                                   42, 234. 30
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ................  ...................... ............   ...........                         31, 886. 84

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ........................        .............                     10, 347. 46
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .............................. ........                           37. 50
July 1, 1909, balance available .....-............                   ..   .....   ...... ......    10, 309. 96
    (See Appendix A 10.)
   11. Saco River, Maine.-In its original condition Saco River had
a very winding course, with abrupt bends and narrows, which, with
its sunken rocks and ledges, presented many difficulties of naviga-
tion. The depth on the bar was only 2 feet at mean low water.
   The original projects appear to have been
   (1) From 1824 to 1827, for the erection of piers, placing beacons and
buoys, and removing obstructions near the entrance to the harbor.
Under this project 12 piers of timber and stone were built, 10 in the
river to mark sunken rocks and to facilitate navigation by sailing
vessels, and 2 outside the mouth designed, but without success, to
create a channel through the bar. The construction and maintenance
of these works cost, 1824-1827, $12,000.
   (2) Adopted by the act of June 23, 1866, to construct a breakwater
2,915 feet long connecting the two outside piers, and to repair the
river piers and improve the channel. Under this project, completed
in 1874, the channel in the river and through the bar was improved,
and a breakwater built on the north side of the channel 4,200 feet
long and 10 feet high above mean low water, at an expense of
$162,271.75.
   The existing project is the consolidation by the act of September
19, 1890, of the project adopted in 1884 for repairing the breakwater,
extending it 2,200 feet to Sharps ledge, building a stone jetty on the
south side of the channel, and dredging between the jetties, at an esti-
mated cost of $356,500; and the project adopted in 1886 for improv-
ing the river to Saco, 5 miles above its mouth, to the depth of 6 feet
at mean low water, estimated to cost $50,000, amounting to $406,500.
About 43 per cent of this project has been completed, i. e., all except
the extension of the breakwater to Sharps ledge, which is estimated
to cost $200,000 and upon which no work has been done. In order to
maintain the desired depth the extension of this breakwater will be
necessary to stop the influx of sand from the north. Possibly the full
extension proposed will not be required.
   To June 30, 1909, there had been expended on the consolidated
project $172,258.37. The depth on the bar at the mouth of the river
is about 31 feet at mean low tide. The depth of 6 feet in the river
above appears to have been maintained.
   The mean range of tides is 8.8 feet.
44         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                     U.   S. ARMY.

   The head of navigation is at Saco and Biddeford, on opposite sides
of the river, to which towns, about 5 miles above the bar, the river is
navigable in fact. The stream above is devoted to water-power
development and a small amount of lumbering.
   The commerce for 1908 amounted to 44,074 tons, chiefly coal, of an
estimated value of $216,517. The freight rates on coal are probably
affected by the existence of water transportation, but it is believed
that with a greater depth, permitting the use of larger vessels, a
reduction in rates could be had which would operate to greatly
increase the tonnage.
   It is proposed to apply the appropriation recommended to extend-
ing the breakwater toward Sharps ledge, with the view of securing
greater depth over the bar at the mouth of the river.
   A description of the harbor and of the earliest improvement is
published in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1866,
page 188. The present project for improvement at the river's mouth
is published in the report for 1884, page 484, and for improving the
river above the bar in the report for 1886, page 552.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................. ............. ........        $5, 241. 63
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................            5, 241. 63
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 200, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
    July 1, 1909...............------------------------------------------------. 40, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
    4, 1897.
   (See Appendix A 11.)
   12. Cape Porpoise Harbor, Maine.--Originally the harbor had a
depth of about 13 feet at mean low tide, but for a small area only,
and the entrance was obstructed by a bar on which there was only
about 10 feet of water at mean low tide. The anchorage was too
small to accommodate the craft seeking the harbor for refuge only,
aside from the local commerce.
   Under a project adopted March 3, 1899, a channel of entrance 200
feet wide and 16 feet deep at mean low tide and an anchorage area
about 3,000 feet long, 600 feet wide, and 15 feet deep at mean low
tide were secured by the close of the fiscal year 1902, under an outlay
of $72,501.15.
   A new project was adopted by the act of March 2, 1907, to deepen
and straighten the outer entrance channel, which was narrow and
crooked, so as to give a depth of 18 feet at mean low tide for a width
of 200 feet. The estimated cost was $46,000, and that amount was
appropriated by the act of 1907. The amount expended on the
existing project to the close of the fiscal year 1909 is $43,692.80.
The work consisted entirely of ledge excavation. At the close of
the last fiscal year about 80 per cent of the area had been drilled and
blasted. On the 4th of December, 1908, the work was completed,
giving a straight outer entrance channel about 190 feet wide and
18 feet deep at mean low tide. The total excavation amounted to
3,999 cubic yards, measured in place. It was done under contract.
   The mean range of tide is 8.8 feet.
   No commercial statistics have been obtained, but the commerce
amounts to about 50,000 tons, chiefly bricks, clay, and coal.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 45
   While the improvement may incidentally have an effect on freight
rates, the principal benefit consists in straightening and making easier
a crooked entrance, difficult and dangerous in fog and storm.
   For reports on examinations and surveys see Annual Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for 1895, page 583; for 1899, page 1050, and
Hbuse Document No. 191, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......-............   ................. a $44, 436. 57
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment .............................................     ...............   42, 129. 37
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended---.............             ......................                2, 307.20
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities... .................................                            102. 13

July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................                               a 2, 205. 07
    (See Appendix A 12.)
   13. Harbor at Isles of Shoals, Maine.-The most protected anchor-
age at Isles of Shoals, known as Gosport Harbor, lies between Star
Island on the south and southwest, Cedar Island on the southeast,
and Smuttynose Island on the north and northeast. At mean low
water its anchorage of about 32 acres had a depth of 18 to 48 feet and
none of its entrances less than 24 feet.
   The original project of March 3, 1821, appears to have been to
rebuild the small breakwater on the north side of Haleys Cove, pro-
jecting westerly from Smuttynose Island to Cedar Island, directly
protecting Gosport Harbor from easterly storms.
   The amount expended on the original project prior to operations
under the existing project was $13,251.61.
   The existing project, adopted by the act of June 13, 1902, is to con-
struct a breakwater on the base of the breakwater that was built
under the project of 1821 between Smuttynose and Cedar islands, the
upper part of which throughout its length had been demolished down
to the level of 1 feet above mean low water, at an estimated cost of
$30,000.
   The amount expended on the work of the existing project to June
30, 1909, is $28,201.60, all for improvement, with which the break-
water between Smuttynose and Cedar islands has been completed to
the height of 15 feet above mean low water, completing the project.
   The mean range of tides is 8.6 feet.
   The commerce benefited by the improvement is inconsiderable, but
the harbor is of value as a harbor of refuge in the open sea 6 miles off
the coast.
   The tonnage for 1908 is given as 2,208 tons, with an estimated
value of about $65,000.
   A report of a survey of the Smuttynose Island breakwater is
published in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1875,
Part 2, page 421. A description of the harbor, with survey and
estimate for the new breakwater, is given in the Annual Report for
1900, page 1172.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................                          $1, 798. 40
June 30, 1909, carried to the surplus fund .....................                      .........    1, 798.40
    (See Appendix A 13.)
  a Balance of appropriation of June 6, 1900, amounting to $7,498.85, not considered
applicable under existing project.
46        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,               U.   S. ARMY.

   14. Cocheco River, New Hampshire.-Appropriations amounting to
$10,060, made from 1829 to 1837, inclusive, had been applied to the
reduction of obstructions in the natural channel prior to the sys-
tematic improvement of this river, begun in 1870, when it was found
to have a good channel not less than 6 feet deep at mean low water
from its confluence with the Piscataqua River to the Lower Narrows,
about 1I miles below the lowest bridge at Dover. Above the Lower
Narrows the channel was obstructed by ledges and shoals upon which
at mean low water the depth was from 6 inches to 2 feet. The
original project for systematic improvement, adopted by the act of
March 3, 1871, was to obtain a channel 40 feet wide and 4 feet deep
at mean low water from the Lower Narrows to the head of navigation
at Dover. Under the original and amended projects completed in
1888 the amount expended prior to operations under the existing
project, including the expenditures from 1829 to 1837, was $170,060.
   The existing project, adopted by the act of September 19, 1890, is
to obtain a channel 60 to 75 feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean low
water (in rock 50 feet wide and 7 feet deep) from the mouth of the
river to the head of navigation, at an estimated cost of $175,000. By
the act of June 13, 1902, this project was extended to include the
restoration of the channel in the Lamprey River, which, from 1881-
1883, under specific appropriations, had been dredged at mean high
water 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep to the Lower Narrows and 40 feet
wide and 11 feet deep to the wharves at Newmarket, N. H.
   To June 30, 1909, there has been expended on the existing project
for improving Cocheco River, $137,000, as follows: Cocheco River,
for improvement, $119,089.93; for maintenance, $9,642.54; for Lam-
prey River, for maintenance, $8,267.53. As a result the channel in
Cocheco River has been completed except over a small portion about
3,500 feet below Dover, where some additional ledge excavation may
be necessary, the basin at Dover and the channel near the mouth,
where shoaling had occurred, have been redredged, and the channel in
Lamprey River has been restored to the full authorized dimensions.
   The maximum draft that can be carried in Cocheco River is 6 feet
at mean low tide, and in Lamprey River 11 feet at high tide.
   The mean range of tide is 6.8 feet.
   The head of navigation is at the lowest bridge in Dover, to which
point, 3 miles from its confluence with the Piscataqua River and 13
miles from the sea, the Cocheco River is navigable in fact.
   The commerce for 1908 amounted to 169,408 tons, consisting
largely of cement, bricks, clay, coal, and lumber, with an estimated
value of $813,880. It is reported that the effect of the improvement
has been to reduce freight rates and to keep railroad rates down.
   The original project, adopted in 1871, is published in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1871, page 858; the existing
project, adopted in 1890, in the Annual Report for 1890, page 475.
A map of Cocheco River in the vicinity of Dover may be found in the
Annual Report for 1885, page 474.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............................. .......      $4, 711.00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended................................. ......    4, 711.00
     (See Appendix A 14.)
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              47
   15. Harbor of refuge at Little Harbor, New Hampshire.-In its
original condition the entrance to Little Harbor was but 3 feet deep
at mean low water, and its anchorage ground, 650 bjr 125 feet in area
and 9 feet in depth at mean low water, was exposed to the full force
of the sea.
   The original, which is also the existing project, adopted by the act
of August 5, 1886, extended by act of August 11, 1888, and as reduced
in 1894, is to obtain a channel 3,000 feet long, 100 feet wide, and
12 feet deep at mean low water, and an anchorage basin of the same
depth 40 acres in area, and construct two breakwaters at the entrance,
at an estimated cost, as revised in 1894, of $145,000.
  To June 30, 1909, the amount expended on the existing project is-
for improvement, $133,227.33; for maintenance, $3,121.74; total,
$136,349.07, with which the project has been completed; but it may
be necessary to do some work on the breakwaters from time to time.
  The maximum draft over the shoalest part of the improved channel
and basin is 11 feet at mean low water. The mean range of tides is
8 feet.
  The commerce benefited is inconsiderable, and the improvement is
designed to afford a harbor of refuge for yachts and coastwise vessels.
   The original project is published in the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1882, page 507; the modifications, with map of the
harbor, in the report for 1887, page 470.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................      $8, 650. 93
June 30, 1909, carried to the surplus fund ...............................     8, 650. 93
   (See Appendix A 15.)
   16. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructingor endangering navi-
gation.-A contract has been made for removal of the wreck of the
schooner Annie L. Henderson, which was burned and sunk in about
15 feet of water at mean low tide, in Bangor Harbor, Penobscot River,
Maine. The wreck is due to be removed during July, 1909.
   The schooner J. H. G. Perkins was wrecked and sunk in the entrance
to Cape Porpoise Harbor, Maine. It was removed in December, 1908,
at a cost of $54.65.
   (See Appendix A 16.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
            HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

  Reports on preliminary examinations and surveys required by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities within
this district were duly submitted by the district officer. They were
reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant
to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in documents
as indicated:
   1. Preliminaryexamination and survey of Camden Harbor, Maine.-
Reports dated October 21, 1907, and October 7, 1908, respectively,
are printed in House Document No. 1117, Sixtieth Congress, second
session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of $20,000 is
presented.
48       REPORT OF THE CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS, U.    S. ARMY.

   2. Preliminary examination and survey of Pepperells Cove, Maine
(an arm of Portsmouth Harbor, Maine and New Hampshire), with a
view to its deepening and the removal of a ledge.-Reports dated August
21, 1907, and October 6, 1908, respectively, are printed in House
Document No. 1081, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for
improvement at an estimated cost of $158,400 is presented.
   3. Preliminaryexamination and survey of Isles of Shoals, Maine and
New Hampshire, with a view to the construction of a breakwater.-Re-
ports dated September 6, 1907, and September 28, 1908, respectively,
are printed in House Document No. 1122, Sixtieth Congress, second
session. A plan for building a breakwater between Cedar and Star
islands at an estimated cost of $40,000 is presented.
   4. Preliminary examination and survey of Penobscot Bay, Maine,
with a view to the establishment of a harbor having a depth of 25feet, or
sufficient to meet the demands of commerce.--Reports dated October 25,
1907, and November 5, 1908, respectively, are printed in House
Document No. 1166, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan of
improvement at an estimated cost of $38,000 is presented.

IMPROVEMENT      OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE BOSTON, MASSA-
                       CHUSETTS, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Lieut. Col. Edward Burr, Corps
of Engineers, having under his immediate orders First Lieut. Ulysses
S. Grant, 3d, Corps of Engineers. Division engineer, Col. John G. D.
Knight, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Newburyport Harbor, Massachusetts.---Prior to specific appro-
priations for Newburvport Harbor funds applicable to Merrimac
River, of which it is the estuary, were devoted to removing a sand bar
and constructing a breakwater at the river's mouth, 1828 to 1836, and
to removing obstructing ledges, piers, and wrecks, 1870 to 1880. In
its original condition the outlet of the Merrimac River, which be-
tween Plum Island and Salisbury Point was 1,000 feet wide and 30
feet deep at mean low water, was obstructed by a sand bar, nearly a
mile outside, through which, in 1880, a narrow channel about 7 feet
deep at mean low water was maintained by the current of the river.
   The original project adopted by the act of June 14, 1880, which is
the existing project, is to create at the outer bar a permanent channel
1,000 feet wide and at least 17 feet deep at mean low water, by con-
structing two converging jetties, projecting, one from the north shore
2,910 feet, the other from the south shore 1,500 feet, their outer ends
1,000 feet apart, which, with the protection of the beach in their vicin-
ity, was estimated in 1881 to cost $365,000. The direction of jetties
and shore protection was modified in 1883, and in 1882 the partial
closing of Plum Island Basin with a timber dike about 800 feet long
and 51 feet above mean low water was added to the project, increasing
the cost (as estimated in 1884) to $375,000. In 1884 a modification of
the project provided for extending both jetties 610 feet parallel to the
axis of the channel, and in 1886 for increasing that extension to
1,000 feet, increasing the cost of the work, as estimated in 1897, to
$599,547.49.
   To June 30, 1909, the amount expended on this project was $396,-
652.79, of which $9,379.66 was for maintenance. In addition, $500
was expended in 1901 for removal of North rock under authority of
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                              49
act of March 3, 1899. The expenditure for maintenance in the fiscal
year 1909 ($1,557.87), was applied to retopping the outer end of the
north jetty. By way of refundment, $795.31 was recovered from a
failing contractor.
   With the expenditure for improvement, the north jetty has been
completed for a total length of 2,868 feet and the south jetty com-
pleted except for a distance of 30 feet at its outer end; the Plum
Island Basin has been closed with a timber dike 817 feet long, 5- feet
high above mean low water, except near the middle, where a weir 150
feet long and 2 feet above mean low water was left temporarily, and
two sand catchers, respectively 480 and 572 feet in length, have been
built in rear of the south jetty. Both jetties are 15 feet wide on top,
which is in a plane 12 feet above mean low water, and have slopes of
1 on 2 on the seaward face and 1 on 1 on the shoreward face. The
project is about 80 per cent completed.
   June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that can be carried over the
bar at mean low water is 12 feet. The mean range of tides is 7.7 feet.
   The commerce of the harbor, chiefly coal, amounted in 1907 to
209,896 tons, and in 1908 to 251,239 tons. Of the latter amount
113,840 tons were reshipped to points on the Merrimac and Powow
rivers.
   It is reported that the improvement made has reduced freight rates
25 cents per ton, and that if the projected depth of 17 feet at mean
low water be obtained over the outer bar it would still further reduce
the freight rates 15 to 25 cents per ton.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure in the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1911, will be applied to the further extension of the
north jetty.
   The original project as reported by a Board of Engineers, with
map of the harbor, is published in Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1881, page 502; the modifications in jetties and shore
protection, in reports. for 1883, page 437, and 1884, page 494; the
parallel extension of the jetties, with map and additional estimate, in
report for 1897, page 825, and a survey of the bar and entrance, in
report for 1905, page 802.
   A survey and map of the bar and entrance, with estimate for re-
moving obstructions in the mouth of the river, are published in
House Document No. 339, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended       ................                ...........           $14, 781.21
Amount recovered from failing contractor. ............................                            795. 31

                                                                                              15, 576. 52
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ......................                           $11, 876. 13
    For maintenance of improvement ......................                       1, 557. 87
                                                                                              13, 434. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................                              2, 142. 52

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 209, 369. 28

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909..................           .........................                         75, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897.
   See Appendix B 1.
        9001-EN 1909----4
50          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,      U.   S. ARMY.

   2. Merrimac River, Massachusetts.-In its original condition the
Merrimac River had a practicable channel 7 feet deep at mean low
water from its mouth 9 miles to South Amesbury, but besides being
narrow and crooked the channel was obstructed by ledges, bowlders,
and shoals.
   The original projects appear to have been-
   (1) For improving the bar at the mouth of the river, by erection
of piers or other works, adopted by act of May 23, 1828; subsequently
improved under separate project for "Improving harbor at Newbury-
port, Mass."
   (2) For the improvement of the river above the mouth, by the
removal of the remains of a dam at the upper falls and of a rock at
the lower falls, of Gangway rock in Newburyport Harbor, and a
wreck near the mouth of the river.
   Upon the original and modified projects, prior to operations under
the existing project, there were expended: Upon the project of 1828,
$67,466.72, and upon the project of 1870, as largely extended by the
acts of June 23, 1874, and June 3, 1896, $187,000; total, $254,466.72.
   The existing project, adopted by the act of March 3, 1899, is to
obtain a channel 7 feet deep at mean low water, 150 feet wide,
from Newburyport 141 miles to Haverhill, at an estimated cost of
$171,442.70.
   The amount expended on the existing project to June 30, 1909, is
$117,989.48, of which $2,564.71 was applied to maintenance of im-
provement, and 10 cents derived from sales. With this expenditure
the channel has been completed to the full projected depth and width.
   The commerce of the river is chiefly in coal distributed to the cities
and towns along its banks, and amounted in 1907 to 98,442 tons, and
in 1908 to 113,840 tons. The improvement of the channel is reported
to enable the delivery of coal by water at rates 35 to 50 cents per ton
less than by rail.
   The head of navigation is at the hat factory, one-half mile above
the railroad bridge at Haverhill, to which point the stream is navi-
gable in fact, 171 miles above its mouth in Newburyport Harbor.
   June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that can be carried at mean low
water over the shoalest part of the improved channel is 7 feet, except
just below Rocks Bridge, where it is reduced by small bowlders to
about 5 feet.
   The removal of these bowlders is in progress.
   The mean range of tides is, at the mouth of the river, 7.7 feet, and
at Haverhill Bridge 4.6 feet, at low-water stage of the river.
   The project of 1870-1874 is published in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1869, page 421; as extended in 1874, in report
for 1876, page 165; as extended in 1896, in report for 1896, page 616;
and the existing project adopted in 1899, in report for 1897, page 865.
   The report of a survey, with estimate of cost to deepen the channel
to 9 feet at mean low water, is published in Annual Report for 1904,
pages 872-878.
  An examination for a channel 12 feet deep to Haverhill (unfavor-
ably reported), and a survey and estimate for removing obstructions
at the mouth of the river (favorably reported), made in 1906, are
published in House Document No. 339, Fifty-ninth Congress, second
SOSSIORI.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                               51
   Reports of examination and survey, with map, for a channel 14
feet deep from the mouth of the river to Haverhill, by providing locks
and dams, are printed in House Document No. 2, Sixty-first Congress,
first session.
   The project having been completed, it is proposed to apply the
appropriation recommended to the maintenance of the improved
channel.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. . .    .......           .................         $3, 142. 58
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909. ........-..............    ......................           ....... 10, 000. 00
                                                                                                                    13, 142. 58
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement .......----...........................------------------------------..........-----------.....------.    1, 131. 96
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                                               12,010. 62
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................                                               760.75
July 1, 1909, balance available..................                             ..         ....   ............        11, 249.87
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...........                                       ....         2, 675. 92
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
    pended July 1, 1909................................................  10,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
    4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix B 2.)
   3. Essex River, Massachusetts.-In its original, condition Essex
River had a channel not less than 6 feet deep at mean low water from
its mouth in Ipswich Bay for a distance of about 21 miles; but thence
for 2 miles to the head of navigation in fact at the railroad bridge
at Essex, the channel was narrow, crooked, and shallow, having a
greatest continuous depth of 1.7 feet, navigation being further im-
peded by bowlders obstructing the channel.
   The original project, adopted July 13, 1892, which is also the ex-
isting project, is to obtain a channel 4 feet deep at mean low water
and 60 feet wide to the head of navigation, at an estimated cost of
$25,000; modified, March 23, 1899, by limiting the improvement to
the channel below the bridge at Essex, which had been rebuilt with-
out a draw.
   To June 30, 1909, the amount expended was $23,463.93, of which
$21,759.21 was for improvement and $1,704.72 for maintenance.
   Although the completion of the channel up to the highway bridge
at Essex was reported February 2, 1901, complaint was made in 1905
of an obstruction in mid-channel, and in June, 1905, a group of sev-
eral bowlders, about 1,300 feet below the head of navigation and
within the scope of the approved project, was removed at an expense
of $300.
   For the restoration of the channel $5,000 was appropriated by the
act of March 2, 1907, and in accordance with a proviso in the same
act the State of Massachusetts has appropriated and paid to the
Secretary of War an additional $5,000, and the consolidated appro-
priation is being applied to the restoration of the channel by the
removal of shoals,
52            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                           U.   S. ARMY.


   The maximum draft that can be carried, June 30, 1909, over the
shoalest part of the locality under improvement is reported to be
about 2 feet. The mean range of tides is 8.8 feet.
   No freight is carried on the river, but the improvement is for the
purpose of permitting the exit of about 30 fishing schooners which
are built annually on the river, each of about 125 tons register, at an
average cost of $12,000.
   The project, with map and report of survey, is published in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1891, pages 676-678.
   The report of a preliminary examination of the river, made in
1905, is printed in House Document No. 68, Fifty-ninth Congress,
first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................       ..............      $7, 850. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement..............................................                . ..  1, 313. 93

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..........................       . ........               6, 536. 07
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....................................                    125.74

July 1, 1909, balance available........................................                   6, 410. 33

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .................                   5, 991. 74
     (See Appendix B 3.)
   4. Harbor of refuge, Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Massachusetts.-In
its original condition this bay, whose southerly shore extends about
2 miles westerly from the point of Straitsmouth Island, and thence
about 2 miles northerly to Andrews Point, had a good holding ground
of sand mixed with mud, and a depth of 71 to 15 fathoms at mean
low water, but was fully exposed to easterly, northeasterly, and north-
erly gales. The original project, adopted by the act of July 5, 1884,
was to build a breakwater consisting of a mound of rubblestone to the
grade of 22 feet below mean low water, 40 feet wide on top, to be sur-
mounted by a masonry wall, and to extend from Averys ledge a little
west of north 3,600 feet to Abners ledge, thence 5,400 feet north-
westerly in the direction of Andrews Point, covering an anchorage of
about 1,377 acres.
   This project, with the cross section of the breakwater as modified
by a Board of Engineers February 13, 1900, is the existing project,
the breakwater to consist of a mound of rubblestone built to the grade
of 12 feet below mean low water, where it will have a width of 117
feet, its harbor slope to be 1 on 1, its seaward slope 1 on 1 up to 25
feet below mean low water, and 1 on 2 thence to the top, 12 feet below
mean low water; the rubble mound to be surmounted with a core of
rubblestone, to be faced with selected stone to be laid horizontally on
the sea face, to weigh not less than 8 tons each and to be laid with a
batter of 1 on 2, and on the harbor face to weigh not less than 3 tons
each and be laid with a batter of 1 on 1; to be surmounted at grade 17
above mean low water with a single course of capstones, whose upper
surface shall be 22 feet above mean low water; at an estimated cost
 (as revised in 1900) of $6,904,952.25.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, authorized a continuing
contract for this work to the extent of $100,000 in excess of the appro-
priations then made. This sum has since been appropriated.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                       53
   The amount expended under the existing project to June 30, 1909,
not including outstanding liabilities, is $1,587,918.01, all for improve-
ment. From sale of property $1 was derived. With this expenditure
2,052,935 tons of rubblestone has been placed in the substructure of
the breakwater, and its condition is approximately as follows:
   In the southern arm for a length of 3,530 feet the mound of rubble-
stone has been completed up to the grade of 12 feet below mean low
water, with the full width of 117 feet prescribed in the project; the
rubble core of the superstructure has been built to the height of mean
low water, 2,990 feet, and to the height of 5 feet above mean low
water for 540 feet farther.
   In the western arm for a length of 2,500 feet from the angle the
mound of rubblestone has been likewise completed to the full height
(12 feet below mean low water) and full width (117 feet) projected,
except for a small bench on the inner slope 13 feet deep and 17 feet
wide; a rubble core of the superstructure has been built to the height
of mean low water for 2,100 feet and to the height of mean high water
for 400 feet.
   The superstructure on the southern arm of the breakwater was
commenced in 1908 and at the close of the working season of that year
had been completed for a distance of 97 feet, extending in a north-
erly direction toward the junction with the western arm. Although
no storms occurred of unusual severity, an examination made at the
close of the winter season disclosed evidences of insufficiency of the
superstructure built in accordance with the approved plan, the stone
in the lower courses of the wall having been drawn outward. By
authority of the Chief of Engineers the construction of a new section
300 feet in length has been undertaken, in which the substructure
will be built up to the grade of mean low water where it will have a
width of 81 feet, its harbor slope to be 1 on 1, its seaward slope 1 on 1
up to 25 feet below mean low water, and 1 on 2 to the top at mean low
water; the rubble mound to be surmounted with a core of rubblestone,
to be faced with selected stone to be laid horizontally on the sea face,
to weigh not less than 8 tons each and to be laid with a batter of 1
on 1, and on the harbor face to weigh not less than 3 tons each and
be laid with the same batter; to be surmounted at grade 17 above
mean low water with a single course of capstones, whose upper sur-
face shall be 22 feet above mean low water; the seaward face to be
protected with an apron of heavy rubblestone to the height of mean
high water, with a slope of 1 on 2.
   Of the quantity of rubblestone required in the substructure, 41 per
cent has been deposited, which is approximately 31 per cent of the
quantity required for both substructure and superstructure.
   The depth of water is ample for the largest vessels; the mean range
of tides is 8.6 feet.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to extending the
superstructure of the breakwater.
   The improvement is chiefly of value in providing refuge for coast-
wise vessels, especially towed barges, which are frequently and sud-
denly in urgent need of shelter in fog and snowstorms.
   For description of Sandy Bay and original project, see Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, pages 565-577. For cross
54         REPORT OF THE         CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.            S. AR1VIY.

section, details of construction, and increase in cost, see report of
Board of Engineers, Annual Report for 1900, page 1186.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ........     ......  ...  .......           $213, 828. 44
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909....             75, 000. 00
                                                                                288, 828.44
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement.......................................................              126. 745. 45
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................            162, 082. 99
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................         5, 166. 76
July 1, 1909, balance available.........................     .............      156, 916. 23
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................   131, 802. 50
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... 5, 154, 952. 25

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909-    - . - . - .-         -.     .
                                                       ----.... . .             500, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897.
     (See Appendix B 4.)
  5. Harbor at Gloucester, Mass.-In its original condition this
harbor, which had a depth sufficient for the largest ships, contained
several very dangerous submerged rocks and was entirely without
protection against the sea and against heavy swells from the south.
  The original project, adopted by the act of June 10, 1872, appears
to have been for removal of five rocks, at an estimated cost of
$10,606.20.
  Under the original and modified projects the rocks were removed,
Harbor Cove was dredged to the depth of 10 feet at mean low water,
and the water front for a distance of 3,900 feet northeast from Fort
Point was dredged to a depth of 15 feet at mean low water from the
15-foot contour to the wharf front, upon which there was expended
prior to operations under the existing project approximately $86,000.
  The existing project adopted by the act of August 18, 1894,
provided for the construction of a breakwater from Eastern Point,
over Dog bar, to Round Rock shoal at an estimated cost of $752,000;
and the act of June 13, 1902, authorized the termination of the
breakwater at Cat ledge and the application of any remaining balance
"toward the work of removing Round rock," at a reduced estimate
of $416,083.43. Under that authority the breakwater was com-
pleted in 1905 as far as Cat ledge. Upon a subsequent examination
of Round rock shoal it was found that the cost of removing it to
the level of the surrounding bottom, exceeding $800,000, was dis-
proportionate to the probable benefits to navigation. The project
has been reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors,
which recommends return to the original project of 1894 for a break-
water from Eastern Point to Round Rock shoal, and its views are
concurred in. The total cost of this extension is estimated at
$354,000.
   The breakwater consists of a mound of rubblestone 31 feet wide at
the top at mean low water, surmounted by a superstructure extending
17 feet above the grade of mean low water, formed by two dry walls
of heavy split stone, inclosing a core of rubblestone, capped by heavy
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       55
stones, forming a top course 10 feet in width, the slopes of the rubble
structure being on the harbor side 1 on 1.3, on the seaward side 1 on 3
to grade 12 below mean low water, and 1 on 1.5 thence to the bottom.
   The amount expended under the existing project to June 30, 1909,
not including outstanding liabilities, is $411,979.67 (all for improve-
ment except $200,83 expended in current fiscal year for restoring
capstones in maintenance of breakwater), with which 231,756 tons
of stone have been put in place, completing, in 1905, to Cat ledge,
the breakwater of the projected dimensions.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean low
water over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement is 10
feet in Harbor Cove, 15 feet along the wharf front, and 30 feet in the
anchorage under the breakwater.
   The mean.range of tides is 8.9 feet.
   The commerce in 1904 amounted to 263,526 tons, in 1906 to 275,888
tons, and in 1908 to 209,074 tons, of which latter 65,000 tons was coal
and 141,000 tons fish and salt. About 80,000 passengers were carried
to and from this port by steamer.
   A description of the original project is published in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1871, page 870, and its modifica-
tions, with map, in the report for 1887, page 500.
   The adoption and the commencement of work under the existing
project are reported upon in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1895, page 610.
   Reports on examination and survey with map of the harbor, with
a view to removal of ledges, will be found in House Document No.
1112, Sixtieth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                 $5, 843. 84
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ..........................                  $1, 539. 68
    For maintenance of improvement ......................                    200. 83
                                                                                        1, 740. 51
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                   4,103.33
    (See Appendix B 5.)
  6. Harbor at Beverly, Mass.-In its original condition this harbor
had a practicable channel 18 feet deep at mean low water from Monu-
ment bar beacon about 1 mile to its head, about 600 feet below the
highway bridge, sufficient for the commerce of the harbor and of its
three tributary streams, called, respectively, North River, Essex
Branch, and Beverly Creek; but the channel, which is circuitous in'its
passage through the shoals at the entrance, was found, in 1900, to be
"of insufficient width for safe navigation by heavy vessels."
  The original project, adopted by the act of June 13, 1902, was to
widen the channel from Monument bar beacon to a point about 200
feet east of Rams Horn beacon to a width of 200 feet, with a depth of
18 feet at mean low water, at an estimated cost of $10,000. Upon the
original project, prior to operations under the existing project,
$8,272.10 was expended, with which the channel was enlarged to the
dimensions authorized, except at three points, where the width was
restricted by ledges to 106 feet.
  The existing project, adopted by the act of March 2, 1907, is to
obtain, by dredging and rock excavation, a channel 18 feet deep at
56           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                         S. ARMY.


mean low water, not less than 250 feet wide at the bend for a distance
of about 3,200 feet from Bar beacon to Lobster rocks beacon, includ-
ing the removal of the middle ground, and not less than 200 feet wide
from Lobster rocks beacon to the lower end of the draw pier at the
highway bridge, at an estimated cost of $40,000. In addition to
$1,727.90 available, $38,500 was appropriated. By way of refund-
ment, $122.24 was received as damages from the surety of a failing
contractor under the previous project.
   To the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, $18,972.99 has
been expended on this project, all for improvement, with which all
the dredging necessary to complete the project has been done. But
the channel has a least width of only about 165 feet near bar beacon,
and the removal of the remaining ledges at this and three other locali-
ties will shortly be accomplished.
   The maximum draft that can be carried on June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement is
18 feet. The mean range of tides is 9 feet.
   The commerce of Beverly Harbor consists chiefly of coal and build-
ing materials, amounting in 1906 to 138,862 tons, and in 1908 to
223,933 tons, of which 137,000 was coal.
   It is expected by those locally interested in shipping that the com-
pletion of the project will effect a substantial reduction in freight
rates, which to this time have not been appreciably affected by the
improvement in progress.
   The report of a survey of this harbor is published in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1890, page 524. The project of
1902, with report of survey, is in the Annual Report for 1901, page
1065.
   The existing project, with report of survey and map, is published
in House Document No. 916, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...-......................         ........ $21, 432. 55
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment ............................................................                55.40
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................              21, 377. 15
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                6, 669. 80
     (See Appendix B 6.)
  7. Harbor at Lynn, Mass.--An area of shoals extends from the
wharves at Lynn 21 miles southerly to the sea. It is protected from
the sea by the peninsula of Lynn Beach and Nahant.
   In its original condition three narrow and crooked channels, in
which the depth was but 6 feet at mean low water, extended from the
wharves to the sea.
   The original project, defined in the report of a board of engineers
dated April 10, 1884, and as modified in 1888, was to dredge a chan-
nel 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water from the sea (at
White rocks), a distance of 3,300 feet to a deep basin opposite Little
Nahant, and from the basin nearly opposite Sand Point, a distance of
6,900 feet to a point 400 feet inside the harbor line, and an anchorage
basin 500 feet by 300 feet and 10 feet deep at mean low water; the
upper part of the channel to be maintained by occasional dredging,
the lower part by a training wall joining the land at Little Nahant,
at an estimated cost of $182,000.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                         57
   The amount expended on this project was $122,063.56, all for
improvement, with which the entire channel and the anchorage basin
as prescribed in the project were completed.
   The existing project, adopted by the river and harbor act of June
13, 1902, is to dredge the channel 200 feet wide from the sea to the
anchorage basin and the anchorage basin itself to the depth of 15 feet
at mean low water, at an estimated cost of $162,937. Under this
project to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, $164,373.44
has been expended, all for improvement, with which the projected
channel has been completed.
   No work was done and none required during the past year in the
maintenance of the improvement. The expenditure shown in the
money statement was for dredging completed during the preceding
fiscal year.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, over the
shoalest part of the locality under improvement is 15 feet at mean
low water. The mean range of tides is 9.3 feet.
   The commerce of the harbor benefited by the improvement consists
chiefly of coal, lumber, and building materials, of which about 353,362
tons was carried during the year. The deepening of the channel to
15 feet enables the smaller or medium size barges to carry full car-
goes of coal to the wharves at all stages of the tide and barges of the
greatest draft during the higher stages.
   It is reported by local commercial interests that the cost of trans-
portation was reduced 25 cents a ton by deepening the channel to 10
feet, and further diminished by increasing the depth to 15 feet, but
that the full benefit of the improvement will not be realized until the
channel and turning basin have been widened as recommended in
House Document No. 948, Sixtieth Congress, first session, saving
pilotage and towage charges.
   The original project approved by the Secretary of War April 21,
1884, is in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884,
page 524, and the map of the harbor at page 532.
   The existing project was published in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1901, page 1093.
   Reports on examination and survey for a channel 300 feet wide and
basin 500 feet square, both 15 feet deep at mean low water, are
printed in House Document No. 948, Sixtieth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....                                                       .
                                                                       ........................ ..... ... $11, 931. 72
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment..................................................................                                     6, 931. 72

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.................................                                         5, 000. 00
    (See Appendix B 7.)
   8. Mystic and Malden rivers and Mystic River below the mouth of
Island End River, Massachusetts.-(a) Mystic River.-In its original
condition the Mystic had a practicable channel 6 feet deep at mean
low water, extending to Dennings Landing, 3.9 miles above its
mouth in Boston Harbor, and 4 feet deep at mean low water about
2,000 feet farther.
   The original project for improvement, adopted by the act of July
13, 1892, which is also the present project, is to make the channel 100
feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water from the Boston and
58        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                 S. ARMY.

Maine Railroad (Western Division) bridge up about 1 mile to the
first turn above Denning's wharf; and thence 2 miles to the head of
navigation at Medford, 4 feet deep at mean low water, gradually nar-
rowing from 100 feet to 50 feet at the upper end, at an estimated cost
of $25,000.
   The amount expended to close of the fiscal year, June 30, 1909, is
$28,794.88, with which the projected channel was completed in No-
vember, 1906.
   The maximum draft that can be carried, June 30, 1909, at mean
low water is 6 feet up to the first turn above Denning's wharf, and
thence to the head of navigation 4 feet. The mean range of tides is
9.8 feet.
   The head of navigation is the upper limit of that part of the
channel under improvement, at the stone bridge at Medford, to which
point, 6 miles above its confluence with the Charles River in Bos-
ton Harbor, the stream is navigable in fact.
  The commerce benefited by this improvement, chiefly coal, amounted
in 1907 to 23,791 tons and in 1908 to 18,229 tons. It is reported
that as the smallest barges go out of use the improvement will per-
mit barges of the lightest draft remaining in service to deliver coal
at Medford without the expense of lightering, which would be about
50 cents per ton.
   A report, with map of the survey of Mystic River and description
of the project, is in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1891, page 674.
  Report of an examination of the river, with a view to its improve-
ment to the upper limits of the city of Somerville, ordered by the
act of March 3, 1905, is printed in House Document No. 144, Fifty-
ninth Congress, first session.
  The appropriation asked for will be applied to maintenance of
the improvement.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................      $8, 200. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......-........-........--......            8, 200. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909-....         -.--.      .           ...-                (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Malden River.-In its original condition the Malden had a
practicable channel 4 feet deep at mean low water, extending only
2,000 feet above its confluence with the Mystic.
   The original project, adopted by the act of August 2, 1882, was to
make the channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean high water
to the Charles Street Bridge, about 1.8 miles above its confluence
with the Mystic, at an estimated cost of $35,000.
   The amount expended on the Malden River under the original
project and prior to operations under the existing project was $10,000,
in obtaining a channel with a least width of 50 feet and 70 feet at
turns, with a depth of 12 feet at mean high water from the mouth to
the Medford Street Bridge at Malden, a distance of        miles.11
   The existing project, adopted by the act of July 13, 1892, is to
dredge a channel 12 feet deep at mean high water, 100 feet wide to
                  a See consolidated money statement on page 60.
                      RIVER AND        HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                         59

the Medford Street Bridge, 1.6 miles above its confluence with the
Mystic, and 75 feet wide about 1,200 feet farther to the Charles Street
Bridge, at an estimated cost of $37,000.
   The amount expended under the existing project to June 30, 1909,
is $51,424.24 (including $36,437.85 for maintenance), with which in
1897 a channel was completed 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean
high water up to the Medford Street Bridge. The local officer has
reported the river above this bridge to be unworthy of improvement
by the United States at this time. The expenditure for maintenance
in the fiscal year 1909 was applied to redredging the channel to the
full projected depth and width from the Medford Street Bridge for
a distance of about 3,600 feet downstream.
   The maximum draft that can be carried at mean high water, June
30, 1909, through the improved channel is 12 feet. The mean range
of tides is 9.8 feet.
   The head of navigation is at the Medford Street Bridge at Malden,
to which point the stream is navigable in fact, 1.6 miles above its con-
fluence with the Mystic River.
   The commerce amounted in 1907 to 88,575 tons, and in 1908 to
69,422 tons, chiefly coal. The improvement is reported to enable
the smallest barges, or larger barges with partial cargoes, to deliver
coal at Malden, saving the cost of lightering-50 cents per ton.
   A report of the survey of Malden River and description of the
original project is on page 532, Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1881.
   The modifications of the project are stated in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 1191.
   The existing project is described on page 672, Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1891.
   The appropriation asked for will be applied to maintenance of the
improvement.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................ ...................... $11, 210. 89
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement ...................................................... 10, 635. 13

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................       ................      575. 76

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909--..----------...........--...........
                                          ---------------------------         (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Mystic River below the mouth of Island End River.-Island
End River is 1 miles above the mouth of the Mystic, at the navy-
yard in Charlestown, and 2,700 feet above the Chelsea drawbridge
over the Mystic.
   In its original condition the Mystic up to Island End River had a
narrow channel 14.4 feet deep at mean low water, but so narrow above
the drawbridge as to be barely practicable.
   The original project, adopted by the act of March 3, 1899, which is
also the existing project, is to dredge a channel 25 feet deep at mean
low water and 300 feet wide, embracing 1.7 miles of the Mystic,
extending from its mouth to a point 800 feet above Island End River,
at a cost estimated in August, 1899, at $267,547.50 (reduced estimate).
                     a See consolidated money statement on page 60
60           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                 S. ARMY.

   To June 30, 1909, $116,189.89 (all for improvement, except
$10,281.92 for maintenance) had been expended in obtaining a
channel 25 feet deep at mean low water, with a minimum width of
150 feet off the East Boston wharves, 200 feet wide thence to Chelsea
Bridge, and 300 feet from Chelsea Bridge to a point just above the
confluence of the Island End River.
   With funds appropriated by the act of March 2, 1907, the dredging
below Chelsea bridge will be completed in conjunction with the
dredging in the same locality for the 35-foot channel of Boston
Harbor.
   The commerce of the river, which in 1901 amounted to 1,430,650
tons, had increased to 3,715,805 tons in 1908, a gain of 160 per cent
in seven years. About three-fourths of all the freight carried on the
river is coal.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, over the
shoalest part of the locality under improvement is at mean low water
25 feet. The mean range of tides is 9.6 feet
   Reports of examination and survey made in 1908, with map, for
a channel 30 feet deep at mean low water from the mouth of Island
End River to Chelsea Bridge, are printed in House Document No.
1086, Sixtieth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............             ...         ..................   $19, 815. 23
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ...............................                              19, 815. 23
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts.................                         17, 847. 36
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                       141, 824. 30

                                           CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................. ...                        $39, 226. 12
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement........................................................                          10, 635.13

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                         28, 590. 99

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .................                        17, 847. 36
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                       141, 824. 30
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909............................          .......... a20, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix B 8.)
   9. Harbor at Boston, Mass.-In its original condition the head-
lands and islands were without protection against the sea, which
was extensively eroding them. Dangerous rocks obstructed the ap-
proach and entrance from Nantasket Roads to the lower main ship
channel through the Narrows. That channel was 23 feet deep at
mean low water, with a least width of 150 feet. The upper main ship
channel from President Roads to Boston had a least depth of 18 feet
at mean low water, with a least width of 100 feet. The channel from
President Roads to Broad Sound in the ocean had a least depth of
29 feet at mean low water, with a least width of 200 feet.
  a For Mystic and Malden rivers only, no estimate being submitted for Mystic River
below mouth of Island End River.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     61
   The original project, adopted by the act of March 2, 1825, was "for
the preservation of the islands in Boston Harbor, necessary to the
security of that place," and until 1866 all expenditures, amounting
to $546,526.10, appear to have been applied to that purpose in the
building and repair of sea walls. The amount expended upon them
since 1866 can not be accurately stated.
   The project for the improvement of the harbor adopted by the
act of March 2, 1867, was (as modified) to make the main ship chan-
nel from Nantasket Roads to Boston 23 feet deep at mean low water,
600 feet wide through the Narrows to President Roads, and 1,000 feet
wide from President Roads to Boston.
   To this project of improvement were added, from time to time,
minor channels within or tributary to the harbor, since completed
with allotments from the appropriation for Boston Harbor, known
as Nantasket Beach channel, Nix Mate channel, Jeffries Point chan-
nel, Chelsea Creek, Charles River, and Fort Point channel.
   Under the original project for sea walls and supplemental project-
for the channels above named there has been expended for improves
ment and maintenance to June 30, 1909, $2,612,747.31, exclusive of all
expenditures upon the five existing projects (three for the main
channels and two for tributary channels), with which expenditure
3.75 miles of sea walls were built, protecting the most exposed head-
lands and islands, the subordinate channels described in the preced-
ing paragraph (except Charles River) were completed, and a channel
obtained 23 feet deep at mean low water from Nantasket Roads to
Boston, with a least width of 625 feet in the Narrows and 850 feet
between President Roads and the city. From sales of property
$124.95 has been derived.
   The expenditure for general improvement during past year was
for engineering expenses in connection with contract for dredging in
Fort Point channel.
   The amount requested for general improvement will be applied to
necessary repairs to sea walls and maintenance of improvements here-
tofore made in the tributary channels of the harbor.
   The existing projects for improvement of the main channels are-
   1. Adopted by the river and harbor act of July 13, 1892: To widen
the main ship channel, from Nantasket Roads to Boston, to 1,000 feet,
and to deepen it to 27 feet at mean low water, at an estimated cost of
$1,250,000, subsequently increased to $1,488,751. Project completed.
   2. Adopted by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1899: To
widen the Broad Sound channel to 1,200 feet, and to deepen it to 30
feet at mean low water, at an estimated cost of $455,000. Project
completed.
   3. Adopted by the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902: To
provide channels 35 feet deep at mean low water, 1,200 feet wide from
the navy-yard at Charlestown and the Chelsea Bridge and Charles
River Bridge to President Roads, and 1,500 feet wide from President
Roads through Broad Sound to the ocean, at an estimated cost of
$7,994,000 in round numbers. This estimate differs from any made in
the project quoted in the act as the basis of the appropriation, owing
to the different width of the channels adopted. (To avoid a large
amount of rock excavation the 35-foot channel from President Roads
to Broad Sound is in a different location from the 30-foot channel.)
62      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.


   Under the project of July 13, 1892, to June 30, 1909, the amount
expended was $1,472,606.29, of which $58,215.30 was for maintenance,
and $10 derived from sales. With the total amount expended under
this project the upper and lower main ship channels from Boston to
President Roads and from President Roads to the sea have been
dredged to the width of 1,000 feet and depth of 27 feet at mean low
water. In the upper main ship channel the full width and depth are
available. In the lower main ship channel the available width of
the 27-foot channel is contracted by shoals to 650 feet. The maxi-
mum draft that can be carried at mean low water, June 30, 1909,
over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement is 27 feet.
A map of the project is in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1894, page 554.
   Under the project of March 3, 1899, to June 30, 1909, the amount
expended was $385,200, all for improvement, with which a channel
1,200 feet wide and 30 feet deep at mean low water was dredged from
President Roads to Broad Sound, embracing the dredging of
965,383.9 cubic yards of sand, gravel, and clay and 198.864 cubic
yards of bowlders, and the removal of 156 cubic yards of ledge. The
maximum draft that can be carried at mean low water, June 30, 1909,
over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement is 30 feet.
The project is published in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1898, page 886.
    Under the project of June 13, 1902, continuing contracts to the
amount of $3,600,000 were authorized by the act of that date, and
pursuant thereto a channel of the full projected depth, but 540 feet
wide, from the navy-yard, Charles River Bridge, and Chelsea Bridge
to President Roads, and 675 feet wide from President Roads through
Broad Sound to the ocean, was begun in 1903 and is now nearing
completion. By the act of March 2, 1907, Congress authorized
the completion of the 35-foot channel to the full projected widths,
appropriating $500,000 for the purpose and authorizing contracts
to the amount of $3,894,000 additional, of which $2,694,000 remains
to be appropriated. Under this authorization a single contract for
all the dredging required to complete the channel has been let and
work was begun on October 28, 1907. Contracts for rock excavation
will be let from time to time as ledge may be uncovered by the
dredging.
    To June 30, 1909, the amount expended, not including outstanding
liabilities, was $3,861,860.91 ($58.59 was derived from sales), all for
improvement. The work accomplished to the end of the fiscal year
in the upper main ship channel was the dredging of 10,677,441 cubic
yards of mud, sand, gravel, and clay; 18.642 cubic yards of bowlders;
and the excavation of 28,725 cubic yards of ledge (excluding 3,025
cubic yards of ledge nearly removed, but which work has not been
accepted for payment); and in Broad Sound channel the dredging of
2,790,619 cubic yards of mud, sand, gravel, clay, hardpan, and cobble-
stones, and 88.248 cubic yards of bowlders. The total amount of
material dredged is 13,468,060 cubic yards, and of rock excavated is
28,725 cubic yards, or about 60 per cent in volume of all the dredging,
and 25 per cent of all the rock excavation, required under the project.
The yardage expressed refers to scow measurement except for rock
excavation, which is situ measurement. The dredging necessary to
                    RIVER AND      HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                             63
obtain the channels of partial width described in the preceding para-
graph and begun in 1903 is about 96 per cent completed, and the
removal of the ledge from this partial width is about 98 per cent com-
pleted. No continuous channel with the depth of 35 feet at mean
low water has yet been obtained.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to dredging and
rock excavation under continuing contracts.
   A map of the project is published in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1903, page 768.
   The mean range of tides is 9.5 feet at Boston light and 9.6 feet in
the upper harbor.
   The foreign exports and imports for the port of Boston during
the calendar year ending December 31, 1908, amounted in value to
$173,475,517, being an increase of $106,788,996 over the valuation in
1867, when the systematic improvement of the channels was begun.
   As to the effect of the improvement on freight rates, the general
manager of the principal foreign steamship lines entering this port
states that about thirty years ago steamers were employed with a
loaded draft of 20 feet to 24 feet; twenty-two or twenty-three years
ago, of 25 to 26 feet; fourteen years ago, 27 or 28 feet; ten years
ago, 28 feet 9 inches; later, 31 feet, and recently one of 33 feet 101
inches. He states, generally-
that freight rates, caused by the larger class of steamers being used, are about 50 per
cent less than they were some fifteen or twenty years ago, when very much smaller
steamers were engaged in the trade.
   Tributary channels.-(a) Charles River.-In the original condition
of the 9 miles of natural channel of this river, from its mouth to the
dam at the head of navigation at Watertown, the depth at mean low
water, from the mouth 4 miles to the Western Avenue Bridge, was
not less than 7 feet, except in several places, covering about 11 miles,
below Brookline Bridge, where the depth varied from 4Z to 7 feet.
From Western Avenue Bridge 22 miles to the Arsenal Street Bridge
the depth was 4 feet. Thence 1~ miles to the dam it varied between
0 and 91 feet.
   The original project, adopted by the act of June 14, 1880, which is
also the existing project, is to widen and deepen the natural channel
so that at mean low water it shall be from its mouth to Western
Avenue Bridge 200 feet wide and not less than 7 feet deep; thence to
Market Street Bridge 80 feet wide and 6 feet deep; thence to the dam
60 feet wide and 2 feet deep; at an estimated cost of $125,000.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $57,500, all for improve-
ment, with which the channel has been completed as prescribed in the
project up to the Arsenal Street Bridge (now called also Western
Avenue Bridge). The project has been 40 per cent completed.
   The head of navigation is at the dam at Watertown, the upper limit
of that part of the channel under improvement, to which point, 9
miles above its confluence with Mystic River in Boston, the stream is
navigable in fact.
   The improvement made by the United States lies wholly above the
West Boston (Cambridge) drawless bridge, completed in 1907, which
precludes the passage of all masted vessels. The tidal basin has now
been converted by the State of Massachusetts into a fresh-water lake
with dam and lock; almost the entire river front has been acquired
64        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,              U.   S. ARMY.

for park purposes; and on the section of the river under improvement
all but three commercial wharves have been extinguished. The
depths in the sections of channel improved by the United States,
above and below Western Avenue Bridge, are 13.4 feet and 14.4 feet,
respectively, at the permanent level in the basin above the dam.
Whenever required by the Secretary of War the State of Massachu-
setts will increase these depths 2.2 feet, as far as Brackett's wharf,
in compensation for the decrease in depth at high water resulting
from the establishment of this permanent basin level. The com-
merce benefited by the improvement consisted in 1907 of 83,335 tons,
and in 1908 of 90,213 tons all coal, the improvement enabling the
delivery at wharves on the river without breaking cargoes at Boston,
saving the cost of one handling and the greater cost of transportation
from Boston by rail.
   The district officer is of opinion that so much of the existing project
as provides for a channel from Brackett's wharf to Market Street
Bridge, a distance of about 1,300 feet, and from Market Street Bridge
to the dam at Watertown, is unworthy of prosecution by the General
Government. This opinion is concurred in. The river and harbor
act of September 19, 1890, appropriated $20,000 for continuing im-
provement of Charles River-
Provided, That no expenditure of said twenty thousand dollars shall be made until
the draws in the Arsenal Street and Market Street bridges shall be made to conform
to the projected channel without cost to the United States.
   The Arsenal Street Bridge has been altered to conform to the pro-
jected channel, and as the Market Street Bridge is above the limits
to which it is now believed that the channel should be extended, it
was recommended that Congress authorize the expenditure of the
$20,000 appropriated in 1890 in obtaining a channel of the pro-
jected width and depth to Brackett's wharf and in maintaining the
Charles River improvement. These funds, however, were carried
to the surplus fund pursuant to section 10 of the sundry civil act
approved March 4, 1909, and no further work in connection with the
improvement of the river is contemplated until additional action is
had by Congress through the appropriation of the necessary funds,
or otherwise.
   The improvement of Charles River by the State of Massachusetts
has been carried on under authority of permits issued to the Charles
River Basin Commission by the Secretary of War under dates of
May 18, 1904, and October 5, 1904. These permits authorized the
construction of the dam at the site of old Craigie Bridge and of the
necessary appurtenances thereto for maintaining at a level not less
than 7.4 feet above mean low water the pool to be formed upstream
from the dam. In connection with the dam the State was required
to construct a lock with a clear width of 45 feet and a length of 350
feet between gates, the lower sill of the lock being 17 feet below mean
low water and the upper sill being 13.6 feet below mean low water,
or 21 + feet below pool level. It is also required that the Charles
River Basin Commission, or its successor, shall operate the lock at its
own expense as a free public waterway of the United States. The
permits above mentioned also require that the commission shall
maintain in the Charles River from the head of the 35-foot channel
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      65
at Charles River Bridge to the dam and lock such depth and width
of channel as may be necessary for the commerce of the river and as
may be specified by the Secretary of War; that it shall dredge and
maintain in the basin, from the head of the lock to the channel in the
river, a channel 100 feet wide and 18 feet deep at mean low water,
in a location to be approved by the Secretary of War; and that the
commission shall, whenever called upon to do so by the Secretary
of War, deepen by 2.2 feet the channel 80 feet wide called for by the
present approved project for the improvement of the Charles River
by the United States, known as the project of June 14, 1880, the said
deepening to extend as far as Brackett's wharf. Under the authority
contained in these permits the Charles River Basin Commission has
completed the lock and has carried forward the work on the dam to
such a point that the river is closed thereby and is maintained at the
designed pool level. The other work necessary to comply with the
terms of the two permits is not completed at the present time or is
awaiting the exercise of the discretion vested in the Secretary of War.
   A full description of the project, together with map of the river,
showing the progress of the improvement to this date is on page 512,
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884.
    (b) Fort Point channel.-In its original condition the mid-channel
depth was 12 feet at its mouth and 16 feet thence to the Federal Street
Bridge, excepting at the draw in the Congress Street Bridge, where it
was 14.5 feet at mean low water.
    The original project, adopted by the act of August 5, 1886, which is
also the existing project, is to dredge a channel 175 feet wide and 23
feet deep at mean low water from the entrance about 4,190 feet to
near Federal Street Bridge, at an estimated cost of $100,000, reduced
in 1887 to $78,750.
    The total cost to the United States was $70,541.33 (including
 $9,219.10 for maintenance), with which the improvement was com-
pleted in November, 1907. In the execution of this work there were
dredged, in 1897, 94,211 cubic yards, and, in 1907, 157,940 cubic
yards; total, 252,151 cubic yards.
    The removal of the Mount Washington Avenue Bridge across the
channel, pursuant to the order of the War Department, necessitates
the dredging of its site to the authorized channel dimensions, which
work is in progress at the date of this report.
    The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean low
water over the shoalest part of the improved channel is 23 feet. The
mean range of tides is 9.6 feet.
    The head of navigation is the southern extremity of South Bay, at
Massachusetts avenue, Boston, Mass., to which point, about 2 miles
from the entrance to the channel in Boston Harbor, the channel is
navigable in fact.
    The commerce benefited by this improvement consists of coal,
sugar, building materials, and miscellaneous merchandise, which
amounted in the calendar year 1906 to 1,416,671 tons, in 1907 to
1,443,686 tons, and in 1908 to 1,251,390 tons.
    For a description of the project see Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1888, page 452.
      9001-ENG 1909-5
66            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                 PROJECT FOR GENERAL               IMPROVEMENT.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.........................................                                    $75, 079. 23
Receipts from sale....-............................................                                                 2. 70
                                                                                                              75, 081. 93
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement-----------....------------...........-----......                      $14. 33
    Carried to surplus fund ................        .................                          20, 000. 00
                                                                                                              20, 014. 33

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ..................                ..................                        55, 067. 60
July 1, 1909, outstanding libailities ......................................                                   4, 720. 15

July 1, 1909, balance available....................                       ..................                  50, 347. 45

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                                           534. 26
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...................................       ...... ..... a75, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                               PROJECT OF 1892 FOR 27-FOOT CHANNEL.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................                           .................               $33, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.................                                  .............              33, 000. 00

            PROJECT OF 1899 FOR 30-FOOT CHANNEL THROUGH BROAD SOUND.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................                                          $69, 800. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...... ..........                               ..........       .....        69, 800. 00

                               PROJECT OF 1902 FOR 35-FOOT CHANNEL.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............................              $1, 382, 771. 02
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.... 1, 200, 000. 00
Receipts from sales.................... ...............        ......... ..     .      2. 70
                                                                                                         2, 582, 773.72
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement------.....................--...........................-                                     1, 144, 576. 04

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .............................................              ..      ..   1, 438, 197. 68
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.....................                     ............                 427, 601. 37

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................                                .............     1, 010, 596. 31

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..... .......                                      2, 299, 747. 44
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                                    2, 694, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..... ...   .................................                                      1, 200, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897.
     (See Appendix B 9.)

  a At the time this estimate was prepared and submitted to the Secretary of War it
was expected that certain balances of appropriations for improvement of Boston Har-
bor would necessarily be covered into the surplus fund of the Treasury under the
requirements of section 10 of the sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909. These
balances having been retained under authority of joint resolution approved June 25,
1909, this estimate may now be reduced to $25,000 without detriment to the work
involved.
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                 67
   10. Dorchester Bay and Neponset River, Massachusetts.-Dorches-
ter Bay is at the mouth of Neponset River, in Boston Harbor. The
present controlling depth at mean low water in the bay up to Commer-
cial Point, at the mouth of the river, is 13 feet; thence up the river to
the highway bridge at Neponset, 1 miles above its mouth, it is 8 feet,
and from said bridge up to Milton Mills, 4 miles above its mouth and
at the head of navigation, it is 34 feet.
   The original project, which is also the existing project, adopted by
the act of March 2, 1907, is to obtain by dredging a channel 175 feet
wide and 18 feet deep at mean low water through Dorchester Bay
and the mouth of the river to Commercial Point; and 100 feet wide
and 15 feet deep at mean low water in Neponset River from Com-
mercial Point to the Neponset highway bridge; estimated to cost
$125,233.34.
   The act of March 2, 1907, appropriated the full amount of the
estimate, with the proviso:
  That no part of this sum shall be expended until the Secretary of War shall have
received satisfactory assurance that the improvement of that portion of the Neponset
River described in said House document [No. 83, 59th Cong., 2d sess.] which lies
above the project herein adopted shall be made and hereafter maintained by the
State of Massachusetts or other agency without expense to the Government of the
United States.
   The improvement contemplated under this proviso is to secure a
channel 6 feet deep from Neponset highway bridge to Milton Mills,
100 feet wide between the said bridge and the Granite bridge, 75 feet
wide thence to Godfrey's wharf, and thence 50 feet wide for a farther
distance of 250 feet.
  The legislature of Massachusetts by the following resolves, approved
by the governor June 24, 1907, and March 5, 1908, respectively, has
given assurance satisfactory to the Secretary of War that the im-
provement of the river above Neponset bridge will be made and here-
after maintained by the State of Massachusetts:
  That there be allowed and paid out of the treasury of the Commonwealth a sum
not exceeding thirty-four thousand two hundred and seventy dollars and forty-four
cents to be expended under the direction of the harbor and land commissioners in
the improvement of that part of the Neponset River which lies above the Neponset
highway bridge: Provided, however, That no part of said amount shall be so expended
until the United States shall have completed the improvement of Dorchester Bay
and the Neponset River to a point at the aforesaid Neponset highway bridge.

   That the conditions set forth in the act of Congress known as the river and harbor
act approved March second, nineteen hundred and seven, which require that no
part of the sum appropriated by Congress by said act shall be expended until the
Secretary of War shall have received satisfactory assurance that the improvement
of a certain part of the Neponset River above the improvement provided for by the
said act of Congress shall hereafter be maintained by the Commonwealth of Massa-
chusetts or other agency, without expense to the Government of the United States,
are hereby accepted, and the said conditions shall be observed by the Common-
wealth in accordance with the terms of the act of Congress aforesaid.
   The amount expended on this project to June 30, 1909, is $45,159.80,
all for improvement, with which the 15-foot section of channel
between Commercial Point and the Neponset highway bridge has
been dredged to the authorized dimensions; and work upon the
18-foot section has been begun. The amount of material dredged
during the past fiscal. year was 301,306 cubic yards. The mean
range of tides is 9.6 feet.
68            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                         S. ARMY.

   During the calendar year 1907 the total commerce of the bay and
river was 349,764 tons, and in 1908 337,397 tons, of which 70,218
tons was carried to Milton above the limits of the improvement under-
taken by the United States.
   The purpose of the improvement is to permit the delivery at the
localities concerned of freight, principally coal at the lowest freight
rates, by providing a depth of water necessary to accommodate ocean-
going barges.
   The head of navigation is at Milton Mills, to which point 4 miles
above the mouth of the river the stream is navigable in fact.
   The project for the improvement of the bay and river, with report
and map of survey, is published in House Document No. 83, Fifty-
ninth Congress, second session. The report of an examination of this
river made in 1892 is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1893, page 800; and the report of an examination and
survey in 1897, in the Annual Report for 1897, page 876.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-........ .........................        $125, 192.52
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.. .....................  ......   ... ..... ....... ...............   45, 119.32

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                  80, 073. 20
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .-................................              11, 737. 54

July 1, 1909, balance available ..................................                    68, 335. 66

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..............                  36, 572. 68
     (See Appendix B 10.)
   11. Weymouth River, Massachusetts.-(a) Weymouth Fore River.-
In its original condition the channel had a depth of 18 feet at mean
low water with a least width of 300 feet up to a point about 1 mile
below Weymouth Fore River bridge, at Quincy Point, the 18-foot
channel extending 3,400 feet above that point, but too tortuous for
safe navigation of large vessels. In the remaining 1,800 feet to the
bridge the channel, when surveyed, was 150 feet wide and 13 feet deep
at mean low water, but, before the adoption of the project, had been
increased without expense to the United States to the width of 200
feet and depth of 15 feet at mean low water. Above the bridge the
channel was 12 feet deep at mean low water for a distance of 2,200
feet, 6 feet deep with a practicable width a distance of 4,000 feet
farther, and 3 feet deep a distance of 7,000 feet farther; but the chan-
nel was too narrow to be practicable.
   The original project, adopted by the act of September 19, 1890, was
to obtain in Weymouth Fore River for a distance of 7,000 feet below
the head of navigation a channel with the uniform depth of 6 feet
at mean low water with the width of 100 feet to near Weymouth
Landing, 80 feet thence to Braintree Bridge, and 50 feet thence 950
feet above that bridge, at an estimated cost of $40,000. The amount
expended under that project was $42,750 (including $2,750 for
maintenance), with which, except for four small ledges uncovered by
dredging, there was dredged and maintained to 1906 a channel of the
full projected dimensions, the future maintenance of which devolves
upon the State of Massachusetts under acts of Congress and the legis-
lature of Massachusetts, printed on pages 824 and 825 of the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                69
   The existing project, adopted by the act of March 3, 1905, embraces
only that portion of the river extending from its mouth in Hingham
Bay about 3-1 miles up to Weymouth Fore River bridge at Quincy
Point, and is to dredge a channel about 1 mile long, 300 feet wide, and
18 feet deep up to that bridge, at an estimated cost of $57,500.
  The amount expended on this project is $55,000, all for improve;
ment, with which the authorized channel has been completed.
  The expenditure for the fiscal year given in the money statement
was for dredging completed during the preceding year.
  The maximum draft that can be carried through the portion of
the river embraced in this improvement is 18 feet at mean low water.
The mean range of tides is 9.5 feet.
  The head of navigation is 2.7 miles above this improvement at East
Braintree, to which latter point the navigable length of Weymouth
River from its mouth is 6.2 miles.
  The freight carried on the river amounted in 1904 to 95,843 tons,
and in 1908 to 173,649 tons, of which more than 87 per cent was coal.
The increased depth obtained is of importance chiefly to the Fore
River Ship Building Company, which builds at its extensive plant at
Quincy Point large passenger and freight steamers, cruisers, and
battle ships up to 20,000 tons. This company states that while no
direct reduction in freight rates has been realized, the improved chan-
nel has proven of greater value and benefit in permitting the entrance
of larger barges loaded with coal and lumber and the passage of ves-
sels of greater draft between the harbor and the shipyards on the
river.
  The original project of improvement (above Weymouth Fore
River bridge) is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1890, page 522. A report of the survey of the river (below
Weymouth Fore River bridge) is printed in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1904, pages 891-898.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....                ..-.. . ........ . ...............         $4, 465. 80
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment---..-----------...-----------------------................-------------...........------
                                                                                         ......   , 965.80
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................                  ..........   ..........     2, 500.00
   (b) Weymouth Back River.-In its original condition Weymouth
Back River had a practicable channel not less than 200 feet wide and
not less than 12 feet deep at mean low water from its confluence with
Weymouth Fore River, 8,000 feet to the wharf of the American
Agricultural Chemical Company, except on its bar, 400 feet across,
one-fourth of a mile above its mouth, where the depth was 11 feet,
and except the 2,000 feet next below that wharf, where the depth
gradually shoaled from 12 feet to 6 feet at mean low water.
  The original project, adopted by a proviso in the act of August 18,
1894, which is also the existing project, is to dredge in Weymouth
Back River a channel, 12 feet deep at mean low water, 200 feet wide
through the bar, and to extend the channel, 12 feet deep at mean low
water and 200 feet wide, 2,200 feet, to the w~harf of the American Agri-
cultural Chemical Company, at an estimated cost of $22,000.
  The amount expended on this project is $22,000 (including $1,521.32
for maintenance), with which the chanm el has been dredged to the
dimensions authorized by the project. After the completion of the
70          REPORT OF THE CHIEF                 OF ENGINEERS,           U.   S. AR1VY.

improvement, by the application of the remaining funds in mainte-
nance during the fiscal year 1908 the full depth of channel previously
dredged was restored with the width of 175 feet through the bar near
the mouth of the river and 180 feet thence to the head of the improve-
ment. The present deficiency in width is due to deterioration of the
portion of the channel dredged in 1897, and the amount estimated as
a profitable expenditure for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, will
be applied to restoring the full width of the improved channel.
   The maximum draft that can be carried at mean low water over the
shoalest part of the locality under improvement is 12 feet. The mean
range of tides is 9.4 feet.
   The head of navigation is about 4 miles above the bar at the mouth
of the river, and about 3 miles above the wharf of the Chemical Com-
pany, which is the upper limit of the improvement.
   The commerce benefited by the improvement comprised, in 1907,
169,756 tons, and in 1908 170,064 tons, of which about seven-eighths
was raw and manufactured fertilizer products.
   A report of the survey of Weymouth Back River is printed in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1891, page 683.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement.............................. $5, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                          CONSOLIDATED.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................                    $4, 465. 80
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment---.......               -- ........ ........
                    ...........--                            .... ..     ........... ...... 1, 965.80

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.--......................................                   2, 500. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.....-----------------------------------------a                        5, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix B 11.)
  19. Hingham Harbor, Massachusetts.-In its original condition the
channel leading to Hingham, south of Ragged and Sailor islands, was
very narrow and crooked and obstructed by sunken rocks and shoals,
over which the least depth was 4 feet at mean low water, while the
available width of channel was but 30 feet.
  The original project, adopted by the act of March 3, 1875, was to
widen and deepen the natural channel by dredging and blasting to
the width of 100 feet and depth of 8 feet at mean low water from
deep water near the head of the harbor to the steamboat wharf, a
distance of about 2,500 feet, at an estimated cost of $11,000. This
improvement was completed in 1884, with the expenditure of
$9,316.58, all for improvement, allotted from the appropriation for
improving harbor at Boston, Mass.
  The existing project, adopted by the act of August 5, 1886, and
completed in 1893, is to deepen the improved channel 100 feet wide
to 10 feet at mean low water and remove a mid-channel ledge, in the
lower channel between Chandlers and Ragged islands, at an estimated
                                 a For Weymouth Back River.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      71
cost of $18,750. By the act of March 2, 1907, without previous esti-
mate, $10,000 was appropriated for redredging the channel, and by
the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, the unexpended balance
of this appropriation was "made available for redredging and im-
proving the channel."
   In accordance with the desire of local commercial interests, active
steps toward the application of this appropriation have been sus-
pended awaiting action by Congress to make the funds available for
extension instead of maintenance and improvement of channel here-
tofore improved.
   To June 30, 1909, $19,327.72 (including $327.72 for maintenance)
has been expended under the existing project.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, over the
shoalest part of the locality under improvement is 8 feet at mean
low water. The mean range of tides is 9.5 feet.
   The commerce benefited by the improvement consists of coal and
building materials, of which 12,370 tons was received during the
calendar year 1908, slightly less than the freight reported received
in 1883; but the line of Boston passenger steamers which at the time
the improvement was made landed at the pier at the head of the
improved channel has long since been discontinued.
   The original project, with survey of the harbor, is in the Annual
Report, Chief of Engineers, for 1875, Part 2, page 417. A report of
the survey upon which the present project is based is in the Annual
Report for 1885, page 555, and a map of the harbor in the report for
1888, page 456.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................   $9, 672. 28
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................      9, 672.28
   (See Appendix B 12.)
   13. Harbors of Plymouth and Provincetown, Mass.-(a) Harbor
at Plymouth.-In the original condition of the harbor the channel
and low-water line were about 2,500 feet from the wharf at Ply-
mouth. Long Beach, between the harbor and the ocean, was, for the
most part, low and narrow, and liable to inroads by the sea that would
injure or destroy the harbor.
   All projects and expenditures prior to 1875 appear to have been for
the construction of works for the preservation of the beach.
   The original project for the improvement of the channel, adopted
by the act of March 3, 1875, was to dredge a channel, 100 feet wide
and 6 feet deep at mean low water, through the flats from the channel
in the inner harbor to Long Wharf in Plymouth, at an estimated cost
of $28,000.
   Prior to operations under the existing project, $198,859.22 had been
expended in preserving Long Beach and in dredging under the project
of March 3, 1875, as modified, which resulted in obtaining a channel
150 feet wide and 9 feet deep and a basin directly in front of the
town wharves 866 feet long, 150 feet wide, and 9 feet deep. Of this
amount $60,727.52 was expended for maintenance.
   The existing project for the protection of the beach, adopted by the
act of March 3, 1899, is to strengthen the sections of beach damaged
by the great storm of November, 1898, and to restore Eel River to its
former course, discharging into the head of the harbor, from its
course into the sea, to which it was changed by the storm. The
estimated cost was $95,700.
72            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                  U.   S. ARMY.

  The amount expended on the work of improvement under the
existing project to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is
$73,437.28, with which 11,843 linear feet of rubblestone dike was built
on Long Beach, which has resulted in strengthening the beach by the
accretion of a large volume of sand and beach shingle; Eel River was
restored to its former course, and 536 linear feet of stone dike was
built to prevent the river from being again turned into the sea. In
addition to the aforesaid amount expended under the present project,
$3,954.42 has been expended for maintenance in redredging the turn-
ing basin, which had been dredged at the wharves under the project
of March 3, 1875.
  By way of refundment, $4,530.12 was collected as damages from the
surety of a failing contractor.
   In the report of January 20, 1899, submitting the project with esti-
mate of cost, it was said:
  The following estimate for this work should be considered approximate only, for the
reason that further changes are likely to occur before the work can be accomplished,
which changes may materially increase or diminish the amount of work necessary to
restore the beach to a safe condition.
   The accretion of the beach before the stone dike was built materi-
ally diminished the cross section of a considerable part of it, and per-
mitted its extension to protect other places where further erosion has
occurred.
   It is proposed to apply the appropriation recommended to main-
tenance of improvement.
   The commerce consists chiefly of coal and lumber, of which 33,354
tons was received in 1906 and 39,860 in 1908.
   It is reported by the harbor master at Plymouth that the improve-
ment of this locality by the United States has effected a saving of 50
cents per ton in freight rates.
   The maximum draft that can be carried, June 30, 1909, at mean low
water, over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement is 7.5
feet.
   The town of Plymouth at its own expense has undertaken to
restore and deepen to 10 feet at mean low water the channel and basin
completed by the Government.
   The mean range of tides is 10.1 feet.
   The original project for dredging is published in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1874, Part 2, page 348. The project of
1899 is printed in the report for that year, page 1089. A map of the
dredged channel and basin is printed in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1888, page 460.
   Reports of examination and survey, with a view to the construc-
tion of a rubblestone breakwater from Long Beach along the crest
of Browns Island, are printed, with map, in House Document No.
1168, Sixtieth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................                          $8, 270. 94
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................                    .................         8, 270. 94
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 20, 700. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909         ..
                             --....     .. . ...    . .    ........... ...10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                RIVER AND IARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     73
    (b) Harbor at Provincetown, Mass.-This is an important harbor
of refuge in the bight at the extremity of Cape Cod.
   In its original condition the width and depth of its entrance and
the depth of its anchorage were ample for the largest vessels, but
actual or threatened inroads by the sea across the low and narrow
part of the cape east of the town, and at intervals along about 1-
miles of the narrow beach southwest of the town, were a serious
menace to the harbor.
   The original project, adopted by the act of May 20, 1826, was "for
the preservation of the point of land forming Provincetown Harbor."
   The project from 1826 continuously to this date has been, by build-
ing dikes and groins and by other sand-catching devices, to arrest the
erosion and promote the accretion of the barrier of beach and sand
dunes which protects and preserves the harbor.
   Work during the past year consisted in extending southerly the
bulkhead at Abel Hill dike a distance of 48 feet; minor repairs to the
bulkhead were also made.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $215,395.99, all applied
to improvement.
   The preservation of the harbor, whose importance as a harbor of ref-
uge requires no elaboration, depends upon the maintenance of the bar-
rier from Abel Hill to Long Point as a protection against westerly and
southwesterly seas. Since the commencement of the improvement
it has been sought to maintain this barrier by means of timber struc-
tures of temporary character, designed to catch and hold the sand
moved by the sea and wind. Although in the vicinity of and below
Wood End they have been partially successful in accumulating sand
moved by the wind, for the greater part of the distance between Abel
Hill and Wood End they have failed in the long run to accomplish
their purpose, and now for a considerable part of this distance there
exists between the ocean and the harbor only a light, sand-filled,
wooden bulkhead, built on the beach whose crest is below the level of
spring tides. The failure of these works may be attributed to absence
of any great quantity of wind-driven sand, and to the inability of
light timber structures to withstand the inroads of the sea. As a
result of storms of recent winters, a portion of the beach is now in
such a condition that temporary expedients can not be relied upon or
expected to hold it through another winter of average westerly storms.
For the security of the harbor a rubblestone dike is required across
House Point Island flats from the vicinity of Stevens Point to a
point northeasterly from Wood End Light, as shown in a general
way on the map at page 576 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1886, estimated to cost $135,000, and to this purpose
the appropriation asked for will be applied. It is recommended that
provision for the entire work be made at one time, either by a single
appropriation or by the continuing-contract system.
    The maximum draft that can be carried to the anchorage is ample
for the largest vessels.
    The balance available will be applied to works of protection for
preserving and strengthening the beach that preserves the harbor.
    A description and plan of works are in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1876, 1879, 1886, and 1897, pages 181, 273,
574, and 878, respectively.
74            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                          S. ARMY.


  The commerce of this port is a small factor in this improvement
compared with the preservation of this very excellent and important
harbor of refuge.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................... $7,167. 13
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment------.......
                 --..                                                      400. 15
                                                         ---------------...............
                     ..---------------..................-------.......----....--

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                     6,766. 98
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                    5. 43

July 1, 1909, balance available ........................................                   6, 761.55
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
                                                                          135, 000.00
  July 1, 1909---........................-------------------------.......----
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.
                                                CONSOLIDATED


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................                        $15, 438.07
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment............................................               ........................      400. 15

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..........................................               15, 037. 92
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ......................     ...........                    5. 43
July 1, 1909, balance available...................................                        15, 032. 49
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                  20, 700. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
   the balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ..............................     145, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix B 13.)
   14. Channel between North and South Hero islands, Lake Cham-
plain, Vermont.-By the original project, adopted by the act of July
4, 1836, this channel, sometimes called "The Gut," was deepened by
dredging to 8 feet at mean low water. The work was completed in
1839, at a total expense of $21,000.
   In 1881 it was found by survey that the channel, about 1 miles
long, had an average depth of 10 1 feet, with sufficient width, except
that it was obstructed at its western entrance by a bar through which
the channel was 40 feet wide and 7 feet deep, and at its eastern
entrance by a bar through which the channel was 100 feet wide and 8
feet deep.
   The existing project, adopted by the act of August 11, 1888, is to
obtain a channel 150 feet wide and 10 feet deep at both entrances, at
an estimated cost of $14,300. The dredging was done in 1889 and
the channel reported as completed.
   Since 1897 it has been reported that the western entrance to the
passage was obstructed by a dangerous bowlder in mid-channel and
that the channel was 1 to 4 feet shoal and 25 feet narrower than the
project prescribed. A survey of the channel made in January, 1906,
in connection with the complaint that the bridge of the Rutland
Railroad Company is an unreasonable obstruction to navigation
through the channel, shows that the channel has shoaled to the depth
                 RIVER   ANDP HARfl3OR IMPROVEMENTS.                   75
of approximately 7 feet at low lake level. Under an order of the
Secretary of War requiring that company to restore and maintain the
authorized channel dimensions, in lieu of altering its bridge, the
restoration of the channel was accomplished in 1908.
   To June 30, 1909, the amount expended under the existing project
is $10,000, appropriated by the act of 1888.
   This channel is the main water connection between the commer-
cial channel on the western side and Swanton Harbor and St. Albans
Bay on the eastern side of the lake, and is generally used by steam
and sailing vessels plying in that part of the lake, but the amount of
commerce benefited by the improvement can not be accurately stated.
Two steamers, carrying freight and considerable numbers of passen-
gers, each pass through this channel twice daily during the season of
navigation.
    The existing project with report of survey, is published in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 3299.
    Report upon the examination of this channel, with a view to its
further improvement, will be found, with map, in House Document
No. 1109, Sixtieth Congress, second session.
    15. Harbor at Burlington, Vt.-Before improvement there was
ample depth of water along the docks and wharves, but they were
without protection against wind and seas from Lake Champlain. In
the greatest exposure during the prevalent northwesterly gales the
wind has a sweep obliquely across the lake of about 10 nautical miles.
    The original project, adopted by the act of July 4, 1836, was to
build a breakwater parallel with the shore and about 1,000 feet from
the docks and wharves.
    Under the original and modified projects the amount expended for
construction prior to the adoption of the project of 1886 was
 $501,811.07, with which 3,551 feet of breakwater was built.
    The existing project, adopted in 1886, is to extend the breakwater
1,500 feet (500 feet northerly and 1,000 feet southerly), at an esti-
mated cost of $150,000; enlarged in 1894 and 1902 to embrace repairs
and replacing the crib superstructure (4,157 feet) with one of stone
or concrete, at a cost estimated at $173,750, a total of $323,750.
    In the execution of this work it developed that through deteriora-
tion of the timber cribs, the substructure on the lake face of the break-
water for a distance of 1,165 feet is in a serious condition as to
stability. A rubble mound extending the full height of the sub-
structure cribs, estimated to cost $52,000, should be built without
delay to support and protect the lake face of the substructure.
    Under the existing project there was expended to June 30, 1909,
 $238,261.34, of which $59,738.69 was applied to extending the break-
water 606 feet (364 feet northerly and 242 feet southerly), making
the total length of the structure 4,157 feet. The remainder, $178,-
522.65, was applied to repairs and completing the rebuilding of 3,240
feet of superstructure, including $34,555 expended in repairing por-
tions of the substructure thereunder, the necessity for which repairs
could not be foreseen until the old superstructure was removed.
From sales there was derived $146. The extension is 40 per cent
and the rebuilding of the superstructure 78 per cent completed.
    During the year 327 linear feet of concrete superstructure of the
breakwater were built and repairs made to 124 linear feet of the
foundation of the superstructure thereof.
76          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                          S. ARMY.

   The extreme variation of level of water surface is 61 feet and the
usual variation about 4 or 5 feet.
   Of the appropriation asked for, $52,000 will be applied to the con-
struction of a rubble protection for the substructure of a portion of
the breakwater, and $34,555 to rebuilding the superstructure in
accordance with the project of 1902. This latter sum was expended
for repairs to the substructure or foundation, which had to be made
prior to the erection thereon of said superstructure, and was defrayed
from funds designed for continuing the rebuilding of the super-
structure.
   The commerce amounted in 1904 to 107,421 tons, and in 1908 to
249,174 tons, of which, in 1908, nearly 80 per cent was lumber.
   A description of the existing project for repairs and maintenance
may be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1901, page 1072, and a description and history of the work in the
Annual Report for 1897, page 3296.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................                     $32, 993. 90
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.....................................................                      27, 754. 24
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                    5, 239. 66
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ a124, 555.00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...........          .........................   .. b 86, 555. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix B 14.)
  16. Narrows of Lake Champlain, New York and Vermont.--In its
original condition the 15 miles of this waterway extending from the
northern terminus of the Champlain Canal, at Whitehall, northerly to
Benson Landing, Vt., had a narrow and tortuous channel not more
than 9 feet to 10 feet deep on the shoals at low water.
  The original project, adopted by the act of August 5, 1886, was to
obtain, by dredging and by a small amount of rock excavation, a
channel with a least width of 150 feet and depth of 12 feet at low
water from Whitehall to deep water below Benson Landing, a dis-
tance of 15 miles. On the original project (as extended in 1890 to
widen and straighten the middle reaches of the channel) the amount
expended prior to operations under existing project was $63,500.
  The existing project, adopted by the act of March 3, 1899, is to
widen the channel and restore it to the depth of 12 feet at mean low
a Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project:
  Improvement-Extension of breakwater 900 feet (project of 1886), bal-
    ance............................................................................       $90,000
  Maintenance (project of 1902)-Expenditures for repairs to substruc-
    ture or foundation prior to rebuilding the superstructure............                   34, 555

                                                                                          124, 555
b Appropriation recommended for maintenance of improvement:
  Repairs to substructure already made (see preceding note) ...........                     34, 555
  Rubblestone protection for substructure..................................                 52, 000

                                                                                            86, 555
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                      77
water in five localities; also to provide fenders for protecting barges
from collision with the rocky banks of the channel at Puts rock, the
Narrows, and Pulpit Point, at an estimated cost of $22,500.
   To June 30, 1909, the amount expended under the existing project
was $24,615, including $615 for maintenance, with which the project
has been completed. The only work carried on during the fiscal
year consisted of surveying the channel to determine the location
and extent of shoaling which was reported to have taken place.
Available funds will be applied to maintenance of the improvement.
   To June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that can be carried over the
shoalest part of the locality under improvement is 12 feet at low
water. The extreme variation of level of water surface is 61 feet,
and the usual variation about 4 or 5 feet.
   From the foot of the canal at Whitehall to the head of Lake Cham-
plain at Crown Point the navigable length of the Narrows is 37
miles. From Whitehall navigation is continued to the Hudson River
and Erie Canal by the Champlain Canal, which is 65 miles long,
from the southern extremity of the Narrows at Whitehall to Troy,
N. Y.
   The commerce consists principally of coal, pulp wood, building
material, and general merchandise, and amounted in 1907 to 724,529
tons, and in 1908 to 565,414 tons.
   The original project, with report and map of the survey of the
channel, is published in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1885, pages 2312 and 2315, and the existing project in the Annual
Report for 1897, page 3302, and 1898, page 1046.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                 $4, 985. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...............      ......................   .........................     600. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                     4, 385. 00
   (See Appendix B 15.)
   17. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navi-
gation.-(a) Wreck of steamer City of Birmingham, in Boston Harbor,
Massachusetts. This steamer was sunk in Boston Harbor on Novem-
ber 4, 1907, on the southerly side of the 27-foot channel and about
1,800 feet northwesterly from Castle Island. The removal of the
wreck was completed November 19, 1908, under formal contract, at
a cost of $13,200.
   (b) Wrecks in Narrows of Lake Champlain, New York.-Wrecks of
18 canal boats and 2 steamers were found to be dangerous obstruc-
tions to navigation. Contract for their removal has been let, and
work is in progress at the date of this report.
   (See Appendix B 16.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
            HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports on preliminary examinations and surveys required by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities
within this district were duly submitted by the district officer. They
were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors,
78      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U. S. ARMY.

pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in
documents, as indicated:
   1. Preliminary examination and survey of Mystic River, Massa-
chusetts, with a view to the construction of a channel 30 feet deep from
the mouth of Island End River to Chelsea bridge.-Reports dated
June 19, 1907, and May 2, 1908, respectively, are printed in House
Document No. 1086, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for
improvement at an estimated cost of $172,000 is presented.
   2. Preliminary examination of Lake Champlain, Vermont, to im-
prove navigation in connection with the breakwater at Burlington,
the channel known as " The Gut" between Tromps Point, South Hero
Island, and Bow Arrow Point, and the harbor of St. Albans, and sur-
vey of the harbor of St. Albans.-Reports dated November 25, 1907,
and July 28, 1908, respectively, are printed in House Document
No. 1109, Sixtieth Congress, second session. The first two localities
(breakwater at Burlington and dredging at "The Gut") were not
considered worthy of further improvement by the United States;
for the third locality (harbor of St. Albans) a plan of improvement
at an estimated cost of $5,000 is presented.
   3. Preliminaryexamination and survey of Gloucester Harbor, Massa-
chusetts, with a view to removing ledges.-Reports dated October 24,
1907, and October 31, 1908, respectively, are printed in House
Document No. 1112, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for
improvement at an estimated cost of $51,000 is presented.
   4. Preliminary examination and survey of Plymouth Harbor,
Massachusetts, with a view to the construction of a rubblestone break-
water, extending from Long Beach easterly along the crest of Browns
Island.-Reports dated November 20, 1907, and September 8, 1908,
respectively, are printed in House Document No. 1168, Sixtieth
Congress, second session. The locality is not considered worthy of
improvement by the United States at the present time.
   5. Preliminary examination and survey of Merrimac River, Massa-
chusetts, with a view to providing by locks and dams a channel 14 feet
deep from the mouth of the river to the railroad bridge at Haverhill.-
Reports dated November 30, 1907, and November 30, 1908, respec-
tively, are printed in House Document No. 2, Sixty-first Congress,
first session. The locality is not considered worthy of improvement
in the manner contemplated by the act.

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE NEWPORT, RHODE
                    ISLAND DISTRICT.

   This district was in the temporary charge of Maj. Harry Taylor,
Corps of Engineers, to October 6, 1908, and in the charge of Lieut.
Col. James C. Sanford, Corps of Engineers, since that date. Division
engineer, Col. John G. D. Knight, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Harbors at Hyannis and Nantucket, Mass.-These works were
consolidated by the river and harbor act of 1902.
   (a) Harbor of Refuge at Hyannis, Mass.-The harbor of Hyannis
lies on the south shore of the peninsula of Cape Cod and about 15
miles to the westward of the heel of the cape, and is an important
harbor of refuge.
   This harbor before improvement was an open roadstead, exposed
to southerly storms. About 8 feet at mean low water could be car-
ried to the wharf of the New York, New Haven and Hartford Rail-
road Company.
                   RIVER    AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                               79
    In the years 1827-1838 a breakwater 1,170 feet long was constructed
of riprap granite, covering an anchorage of about 175 acres, the
entrance to which has a depth of about 15.5 feet.
   Between the years 1852 and 1882 extensive repairs were made,
increasing the width of the base of the breakwater and the size of
the stone forming its sides and top.
   The sum of $123,431.82 had been expended at this harbor prior
to operations under existing project.
   The project of 1884 provided for dredging to 15.5 feet at low
water about 36 acres area north of the existing breakwater, so as to
increase the deep-water anchorage by that amount, all at a total
estimated cost at that time of $45,743.20, increased $30,568.94
in accordance with the report of December 2, 1899, by the river
and harbor act of June 13, 1902, making the total estimated cost
$76,312.14.
    At the adoption of this project the 15.5-foot depth anchorage
covered only about 47 acres, and the 36 additional acres to be
dredged carried a depth of from 7 to 15.5 feet of water at low water.
    The total amount expended at this locality to June 30, 1909, was
$197,298.79, none of which was applied to maintenance. The 1884
project had been completed and two cuts, each 25 feet wide and 13
feet deep at mean low water, had been dredged in the channel
leading to the wharf of the New York, New Haven and Hartford
Railroad Company.
    The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 3 feet.
    The principal value of this harbor to commerce is as a harbor of
refuge for coasters and fishing vessels. The actual commerce of
the place is, in general, lumber and other building materials, coal,
and fish, aggregating in the last calendar year 21,100 tons, valued
at $219,600.
    A survey will be made to determine whether deterioration has
taken place and work of restoration is necessary.
    For reference to former reports in which more extended informa-
tion may be found, see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1905, page 75.
Amount received from bondsmen of failing contractor ....................... $500. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improvement.  11. 04
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...       ..............................   .   488. 96
   (b) Harbor of refuge at Nantucket, Mass.-This harbor is the only
one between the harbors of Marthas Vineyard (Vineyard Haven and
Edgartown) and Provincetown, a distance of 100 miles, except the
small harbor of Hyannis, on the north side of Nantucket Sound. It
has a considerable area, with a depth of water in excess of 12 feet, and
the object of the improvement is to make it a harbor of refuge for
vessels plying between ports north and south of Cape Cod. Inci-
dentally it forms a commercial harbor for the island of Nantucket,
and it is the only one on the island. So far as known it has never
been used to any extent as a harbor of refuge.
   In its original condition the channel entrance was obstructed by a
bar 1.5 miles in width, on which there was only 6 feet of water at
mean low tide, the channel being very crooked and subject to changes
in location. Between 1829 and 1844 an ineffectual attempt was made
to dredge a channel through the bar; $45,734.75 was expended prior
to beginning operations under the existing project.
80       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S. ARMY.

   The present project, adopted in 1880 and modified in 1885, pro-
vides for the construction of two jetties, one on each side of the
entrance, and for dredging when necessary in order to obtain a
channel depth of from 12 to 15 feet at low water. Estimated cost,
$375,000, exclusive of cost of dredging.
   The amount expended on the existing project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, exclusive of outstanding liabilities,
was $387,823.48, of which $7,210 was expended in repairs to the west
jetty, $6,312.90 to the east jetty, and $50,000 in dredging.
   About 79 per cent of the whole project has been completed. No
works of improvement or maintenance have been in progress during
the fiscal year. The expenditures were for survey, care of property,
and collection of commercial statistics.
   About 83 per cent in length of the west jetty and 90 per cent of the
east jetty have been constructed. A channel 200 feet wide and 12
feet deep at mean low water was dredged between the jetties during
the working season of 1905.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 3 feet. During an
unusually severe storm in December, 1896, a breach was made
through the Haulover Beach between the ocean and the head of the
harbor. The breach remained open until the spring of 1909, when
it closed from natural causes.
   A survey of the jetty channel made in June, 1909, shows that
considerable scour has taken place throughout most of the dredged
channel, but that a bar about 400 feet wide has formed just outside
of the end of the east jetty over which there is a minimum depth of
10.7 feet, which is now the greatest depth that can be carried into
the harbor at mean low tide.
   A large portion of the 3,955 feet of the west jetty, built prior to
1884, has been damaged somewhat by storms and ice and, having no
core of small stone, allows considerable sand to pass through it. This
should be repaired so as to be as sand tight as possible and raised to
its original height. It is estimated that $30,000 will be required to
complete the repairs in addition to the estimated cost of the project.
   The approved project for this work contemplates building two
converging jetties and the excavation by dredging of so much of the
channel as may not be deepened by the tidal scour. The estimate of
the cost of the approved project was $375,000 for the jetties alone.
But the height above low water was left to be determined by expe-
rience, and it will be some years before the work can be considered as
complete. Owing to the exposed situation, the character of the
bottom, and the effect of ice, $13,522.90 of the appropriation for
construction is properly chargeable to maintenance, for which no
special allotment was made. Dredging, which was included in the
project but not in the estimate, had been postponed year by year to
observe the action of the jetties, but $50,000 for the purpose of
dredging was first applied from the appropriation of March 3, 1905.
The dredged channel, now about 200 feet wide and 12 feet deep at
mean low water, should be increased in width from the deep water
off Brandt Point in the inner harbor to the deep water outside the
jetty entrance, and the estimate for completion includes $50,000 for
that purpose, making a total increase in the estimated cost of $100,000
on account of dredging.
   Further work under the project will consist in raising the incom-
plete portions of both jetties as may be required, and deepening and
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   81

widening the dredged channel, with a view to the extension and
maintenance of the benefits to be derived from the improvement.
It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable expendi-
ture to deepening and widening the channel by dredging and to
enlarging and strengthening such portions of the jetties as may be
necessary.
   The entire commerce of Nantucket is carried on at this harbor,
amounting in 1908 to about 26,840 tons, valued at $1,000,600,
consisting largely of general merchandise, lumber, coal, forage, grain,
and live stock.
  The effect of this work will be to afford a place of refuge easy of
access and free from storms for coasters and fishing vessels.
   For reference to reports containing more detailed information, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 76.
July 1, 1908. balance unexpended ....----------.......-------...........-------.......-------..    $2, 024. 31
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909....................          ...          ......................                   20, 000. 00
                                                                                                   22, 024. 31
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.-.....-........................ $354. 29
    For maintenance of improvement..--..---.......... ........ 166. 75
                                                                                                        521. 04
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ........-............................                             21, 503. 27
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities_.................... ................                             60. 02

July 1, 1909, balance available.....................                      ....   .......... ...    21, 443. 25
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                             101, 312. 90
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909...................................                               80, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                               CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....................................                               $2, 024. 31
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  M arch 3, 1909.......................................................                             20, 000. 00
Amount received from bondsmen of failing contractor                       ......................        500. 00
                                                                                                   22, 524. 31
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.... .............         ................                $365. 33
    For maintenance of improvement. ........................                            166. 75
                                                                                                        532. 08

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ..................................                                21, 992. 23
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .................................                                  60. 02

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                             21, 932. 21

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ a 101, 312. 90
IAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909                                       a 80, 000. 00
                                                                        a................................
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix C 1.)
                            a For harbor of refuge at Nantucket, Mass.
         9001-EN        1909-6
82        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                 U.   S. ARMY.


   2. Harbor at Vineyard Haven, Massachusetts.-Vineyard Haven is
a deep indentation on the northern shore of Marthas Vineyard Island,
on the southern side of Vineyard Sound.
   The headlands on either side of the entrance to the harbor were
gradually wearing away and the adjacent parts of the harbor were
shoaling. The mean range of tide is 1.7 feet.
   The existing project of 1888, as modified in 1889, provides for the
protection of the "Chops" (or headlands) from erosion and the inter-
vening harbor from being filled with the eroded material, the whole
to be done by means of stone sea walls and jetties built along the
beach in front of the bluffs at both headlands. The total cost was
estimated in 1889 at $60,000, the whole of which has been appro-
priated.
   The sum of $55,387.35 had been expended on this work up to June
30, 1909, by which there had been built a series of riprap jetties and
sea wall, which appear to have afforded the needed protection.
   No works of improvement were in progress during the past fiscal
year.
   This harbor, being at present the most accessible refuge for the
immense fleet of coasting vessels plying between points north and
south of Cape Cod, is more extensively used than any other on the
southern coast of New England.
   For reference to former reports giving more extended information,
see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 77.
   Further work at this harbor will depend upon the action taken by
Congress upon the report of the Board of Engineers provided for in
the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, and printed at page 949 of
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904. Such further
work would be for the extension of benefits.
   The commerce for 1908 was about 16,820 tons, valued at $916,610,
consisting chiefly of coal, general merchandise, grain, forage, fish, and
lumber.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................   $4, 612. 65
June 30, 1909, covered into surplus fund, United States Treasury.......... 4, 612. 65
     (See Appendix C 2.)
   3. Woods Hole channel, Massachusetts.-Woods Hole channel is a
waterway or strait connecting Buzzards Bay and Vineyard Sound
through the so-called "Great Harbor," lying near the southwestern
part of Cape Cod, Massachusetts. Little Harbor lies to the east of
Great Harbor and is separated from it by Parkers Neck.
   Before improvement in the strait the channels were crooked and
obstructed by bowlders, and the velocity of the currents at certain
stages of the tide was from 5 to 7 miles per hour. The site of the
wharves and basins of the United States Fish Commission and
Revenue-Marine Service was a submerged point of land from the
shore of Great Harbor.
   The original project of 1879 provided for making a channel through
the bar at the entrance to Little Harbor and widening and deepening
the channel through the strait. The project of 1883, extended in
1884 and 1886, provided for the construction of retaining walls on
shore, a stone pier, and a wooden wharf, mainly for the use of the
United States Fish Commission and incidentally for the use of other
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  83
branches of the public service, all of which work had been completed
prior to 1889.
   The amount expended on the original and modified projects prior
to beginning operations on the existing project was $113,599.92, by
which the entrance to Little Harbor had been dredged to 10 feet
depth and a direct channel 9 feet deep had been dredged through the
strait. The retaining walls, stone pier, and wooden wharves at the
United States Fish Commission had also been built and repaired.
   The existing project, that of June 3, 1896, provides for deepening
the channel through the strait to 13 feet at mean low water and
widening the same to 300 feet, with a branch channel of same dimen-
sions leading from the strait toward the wharves; estimated cost,
$396,000.
   The amount expended on the existing project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, exclusive of outstanding liabilities,
was $163,321.53, resulting in the practical completion of the project.
The work done during the fiscal year consisted in blasting away a
small point of rock near the easterly end of the main channel which
could not be removed by dredging. It is believed that a clear passage
of 13 feet depth at mean low tide now exists through the strait by
both channels; but a further survey is needed, which will be made as
soon as possible, and any other shoals found will be removed.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 4 feet at the Buzzards
Bay end of the channel and 1.65 feet at the Vineyard Sound end.
   The improvement has resulted in greatly lessening the danger to
vessels passing through the straits and in rendering it possible for
larger vessels to pass through, thereby saving about 10 miles in
distance if bound from the east to New Bedford and about 19 miles if
bound for Wareham.
   The prices at which contracts have been let for this work have been
much less than the original estimates, and the relative proportion of
the large bowlders to the smaller and lighter material less than the
estimated amount based on previous work, so that the project will
be completed for much less than the amount originally estimated.
   The commerce of Woods Hole in 1908 was about 61,200 tons,
mostly coal and fish, valued at $838,000.
   No account was kept of vessels passing through the strait and not
stopping at Woods Hole.
   For reference to reports containing more extended information, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 79.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended --------------------......--....................--------........ $80, 179. 89
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.........................................................                                    13, 501.42

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                  66, 678. 47
July 1., 1909, outstanding liabilities..................................................594.51
July 1, 1909, balance available........................................                          66, 083.96
   (See Appendix C 3.)
  4. Harbors of New Bedford and Fairhaven, Mass.-New Bedford
Harbor is an estuary of Buzzards Bay, at the mouth of the Acushnet
River, the Fairhaven side of the harbor being called "Fairhaven
Harbor."
84        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                    S. ARMY.

   Before improvement the channel had a depth of 12.5 feet at mean
low water. The improvement of this harbor has been carried on
under a number of distinct projects, the first being the removal of a
wreck and dredging the sand bar formed by it in 1836-1839, on which
$10,000 was expended. The projects of 1874 and 1877 provided for
a channel 300 feet wide and 15 feet deep at mean low water from
the deep water just above Palmers Island to the wharves of New
Bedford. This work was completed in 1877 at a cost of $20,000.
   This was followed after 1887 by various projects in which the con-
trolling depth was 18 feet at mean low water and comprised chan-
nels 200 feet wide from Buzzards Bay to New Bedford, about 150
feet wide along the city wharf front above and below the New Bed-
ford and Fairhaven bridge, an anchorage area about one-half mile
long and 600 feet wide on the northerly side of the main channel
between New Bedford and Fairhaven, and a channel 250 feet wide
leading from the anchorage area through the draw in the bridge to
the wharves above, with a turning basin above the bridge. The total
cost of the 18-foot projects, which were completed in 1906, was
$137,709, making a total of $167,709 expended prior to the adoption
of the existing project.
   The existing project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, and provides for dredging channels 25 feet deep at
mean low water, 300 feet wide from Buzzards Bay to the north end
of Fish Island, just above the New Bedford and Fairhaven bridge,
with a turning basin above the bridge, and an anchorage area of about
114 acres, 25 feet deep, between New Bedford and Fairhaven, at an
estimated cost of $527,000. An appropriation of $100,000 was made
and contracts authorized in the additional sum of $200,000, which
has since been appropriated for prosecuting the work. Section 3 of
the river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909, contained the fol-
lowing provision modifying the project of 1907:
   Improving harbors of New Bedford and Fairhaven, Massachusetts: The authoriza-
tion for the improvement of said harbors contained in the river and harbor act of
March second, nineteen hundred and seven, is hereby extended so as to include the
extension of the basin north of Fish Island, now being dredged under the adopted
project, southward between the harbor lines to the bridge between New Bedford and
Fish Island, and the extension of the twenty-five foot channel along the New Bedford
front from its terminus, as contemplated by the present project, northerly between
established harbor lines to said bridge: Provided, That a contract or contracts for such
improvement can be made within the limit of cost authorized by the said act of
March second, nineteen hundred and seven.
   At the adoption of the existing project 18 feet depth of water was
available for vessels to reach the wharves of New Bedford, but the
channel was too narrow, the anchorage small, and the depth insufficient
to accommodate the commercial demands of the port.
   The amount expended on the existing project up to the close of
the fiscal year endi:g June 30, 1909, was $273,850.33, exclusive of
outstanding liabilities, by which the work of dredging under a con-
tinuing contract was continued throughout the fiscal year. The
turning basin and channel above the drawbridge and the channel
leading from the anchorage area to the drawbridge for a width of
about 200 feet have been practically completed; a considerable por-
tion of the anchorage area has been deepened to 25 feet, and a channel
135 feet in width has been dredged from Buzzards Bay to the auchor-
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 85
age area, but both the dredged portion of the anchorage area and
the latter channel contain shoals still to be removed.
   About 23 feet of water at mean low tide can now be carried from
Buzzards Bay through the harbor to the drawbridge, about 3 miles,
and to the harbor line below the bridge. Through the bridge about
18 feet can be carried, and 25 feet from the bridge through the
turning basin, about 0.2 mile. A farther distance of about 2 miles
up the Acushnet River is navigable, with a natural depth of from 6
to 15 feet of water.
   The mean range of tide is about 4.2 feet.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure to the widening and deepening of the channel and enlarging
the anchorage area by dredging to the full projected dimensions.
The additional work proposed is in part necessary to make the
improvement available and also for the extension of benefits.
   The commerce of the harbor in 1908 amounted to about 1,511,885
tons, consisting mostly of coal, building materials, general merchan-
dise, and cotton, valued at $41,091,124.
   The effect of the deep water on commerce is the use of deeper
draft vessels than formerly, larger cargoes, and a consequent reduc-
tion in water freight charges.
   For reference to reports containing more detailed information, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 81.
   The report of the survey of New Bedford and Fairhaven harbors,
dated May 18, 1906, upon which the existing project is based, is
printed as House Document No. 271, Fifty-ninth Congress, second
session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................                         $209, 789. 05
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
                                                                      ----------------- 183, 639. 38
  ment-------........-------..----......-------....-----..--...---..............................

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                          26, 149. 67
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................              ................         18, 978. 62

July 1, 1909, balance available.......................................                            7, 171.05

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .................                           3, 621. 83
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                         227, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909...-----------------------------------------------                               227, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.
    (See Appendix C 4.)
   5. Sakonnet Harbor, Rhode Island.-Sakonnet Point is a rocky
headland on the eastern side of the mouth of Sakonnet River, and
lies about 6 miles east of Newport. This point in connection with
Churchs Cove forms an anchorage known as Sakonnet Harbor.
Before improvement this harbor was protected from storms from
the northeast, south, and southeast by the mainland, but was exposed
to westerly storms. In 1827 a project was prepared for a break-
water 400 feet long at this point, and about 200 feet of this was built
at that time. The project of 1899 provided for prolonging the old
breakwater out to a rock nearly north of it and raising the whole to
86           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

a height of 8 feet above mean low water. This project was com-
pleted in 1900 at a cost of $25,000.
   The existing project, adopted by the act of March 2, 1907, provides
for the removal of a rock from the harbor to the depth of 8 feet
at mean low water at an estimated cost of $10,000.
   The amount expended on the existing project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $9,002.50, exclusive of out-
standing liabilities, by which the removal of the rock was completed.
   No further work is contemplated.
   For more detailed information, see Annual Reports of the Chief of
Engineers for 1889, page 649; 1895, page 749; 1897, page 935; 1901,
page 1126, and for the report on preliminary examination and survey
upon which the existing project is based, page 1148 of the same
report for 1901.
   The commerce of this harbor in 1908 amounted to about 4,974
tons, consisting largely of coal and other fuel, general merchandise,
grain, and forage, valued at $380,016.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended--. -----------...............-------......------------........... $9, 983. 49
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.. ...........  ........... .................              ... .................              8, 985.99
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                 997.50
     (See Appendix C 5.)
  6. Taunton River, Masscchusetts.-This river rises in Norfolk
County, Mass., and empties into Mount Hope Bay at Fall River.
   In its original condition the channel was narrow and obstructed
by bowlders and from Berkley Bridge to Taunton the depth was in
places not more than 5 feet at mean high water. A vessel of 30 tons
burden was as large as could go up to Taunton. From 1870 to 1879
$63,000 was appropriated and expended to secure 9 feet depth at
high water. This work was completed in 1879.
   The existing project, adopted June 14, 1880, provides for the widen-
ing and deepening of the river so as to secure a channel of at least 12
feet depth at high water, with 100 feet width from its mouth up to
Berkley Bridge (above Dighton) ; thence 12 feet depth with 80 feet
width (100 feet width at bends) up to Briggs shoal; thence 11 feet
depth with 80 feet width up to the "shipyard;" thence with 11 feet
depth with 60 feet width up to Weir Bridge, Taunton; all at a total
cost estimated in 1893 at $125,000, all of which has been appropriated.
   The amount expended on the existing project up to June 30, 1909,
exclusive of outstanding liabilities, was $134,316.36, by which all
projected work had been practically completed and the shoals offering
the greatest obstruction to the navigation of the river had been re-
dredged several times. About $28,316.36 of the above amount has
been expended in the maintenance of the channel. Vessels of 11 feet
draft can reach Taunton at high water, but at some points the 11-foot
channel is very narrow. It is estimated that $5,000 every four years
will be required to maintain the channel.
   The head of navigation is about 1 mile above Weir Bridge, 14 miles
above Fall River. No portion of the river above Weir Bridge has
been improved.
   The mean range of the tide is about 51 feet at Dighton and 3.4 feet
at Taunton.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                           87
   The expenditures during the fiscal year were for the removal of a
shoal opposite the stove-lining works at the lower end of Weir village,
and a few obstructing bowlders at points farther down the river.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable expend-
iture to dredging in such portions of the river as may shoal by freshets
or otherwise.
   The tonnage of 1908 was about 74,323 tons, mostly coal and other
fuel and minerals, valued at $359,008.
   Further work on this river will be for the maintenance of benefits
secured by the improvement.
   For reference to reports giving more extended information, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 82.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended       -................
                                                   ........               $4, 989.45
                                                               ............
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..................  .......... .... ...........   ........ 5, 000.00
                                                                          9, 989.45
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement ........................... ....................... 4, 305. 81
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ........................................    5, 683. 64

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909--. . .... ...............        ......    .........   5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix C 6.)
   7. Salconnet River, Rhode Island.-Sakonnet River is an arm of the
sea between the island of Rhode Island and the mainland, extending
from the ocean to Mount Hope Bay, around the head of Rhode Island.
Before improvement it was obstructed near its upper end by a cause-
way, known as the "Stone Bridge," extending across it. This cause-
way had two openings, one covered by a draw, but both the draw
opening and the passage through it were of insufficient width, and the
waterway of insufficient depth for the needs of commerce, in addition
to which the causeway offered such obstruction to the ebb and flow
of the tides that the currents through the openings made the passage
dangerous even to boats of such dimensions as could pass through
them under ordinary circumstances.
   The existing project, adopted June 3, 1896, provides for increasing
the width and depth of the channel through the draw opening in the
proposed new Stone Bridge, to be built by the State of Rhode Island,
so as to secure a channel through the opening 100 feet in width and 25
feet deep at mean low water, estimated to cost $40,000.
   Due to delay in securing necessary legislative action by the State
of Rhode Island with reference to rebuilding Stone Bridge, no work
had been done and no funds expended prior to May, 1905, when pre-
liminary steps were taken for the widening and deepening of the
channel. The work was completed October 3, 1905.
   The amount expended on the existing project up to June 30, 1909,
exclusive of outstanding liabilities, was $38,426.95, by which the
work of enlarging the channel was completed.
   While the passage of this point is greatly improved by the in-
creased depth and width, the velocity of the current has not been
88           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                 S. ARMY.

materially reduced. The new drawbridge, which is of the bascule
type, is now completed.
   No further work is contemplated under the approved project.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..------------..---------......-----.......................-------- $1,573.05
June 30, 1909, amount covered into surplus fund, United States Treasury..                         1, 573. 05
     (See Appendix C 7.)
   8. Pawtucket (Seekonk) River, Rhode Island.-This river is the
upper portion of the Providence River, the navigable portion extend-
ing from Pawtucket to Providence, a distance of 4 mi'ies. Before
improvement the channel in the river was narrow and had a ruling
depth of about 5 feet at mean low water. Between 1867 and 1.873
$52,000 was appropriated to dredge the channel to 7 feet depth.
This work was finished in 1876. T he project of July 5, 1884, pro-
vided for deepening the river so as to secure a channel of at least 12
feet depth at low water with 100 feet width from its mouth, at Provi-
dence, up to Grant & Co.'s wharf at Pawtucket, and thence 12 feet
depth with 40 feet width, through a ledge rock for a short distance
farther, to Division Street Bridge, the head of navigation, all at a
total cost estimated in 1883 at $382,500, of which $284,000 has been
appropriated.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, modified this project
so as to provide for straightening that portion of the channel between
Tenmile River and Bucklins Island. The project, with its modifi-
cation, has been completed, with an expenditure of $282,444.91.
The total expenditures prior to the adoption of the existing project
were $334,444.91.
   The existing project, adopted by the river and harbor act of March
3, 1905, provides for deepening the channel to 16 feet at mean low
water with 100 feet width and a channel through the ledge rock at
Pawtucket of 16 feet depth at mean low water and 50 feet wide, at an
estimated cost of $237,875.
   The appropriation of $35,000 made by the act of 1905 was applied
to excavating a channel through about 200 feet in length of ledge
rock.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, contains the following
item:
   Improving Pawtucket River, Rhode Island: Completing improvement, one hun-
dred and thirty-five thousand five hundred and eighty-four dollars: Provided,
That no part of this sum shall be expended unless the further amount of sixty-seven
thousand seven hundred and ninety-two dollars shall be provided by the State of
Rhode Island or other agency, and made subject to the order of the Secretary of War
in such manner as he may direct, to be expended under his direction upon said project
for its completion.
The general assembly of the State of Rhode Island passed an act
making this appropriation, but-
   Provided, That requisition for one-half of said sum shall be made on or after the
first day of July, A. D. 1908, and requisition for the remainder of said sum shall be
made on or after the first day of July, A. D. 1909, by said Secretary of War.
  In accordance with the provisions of the act of March 2, 1907,
separate contracts were entered into for all of the rock excavation
and dredging required for the completion of the project.
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                   89
  Section 3 of the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, modified
this project as follows:
   Pawtucket River, Rhode Island: Any balance remaining unexpended after the
completion of the work provided for under the existing contracts for improving the
Pawtucket River, Rhode Island, may be used in deepening the channel of the river
to eighteen feet, and in increasing the widths thereof at such places between Paw-
tucket and Providence as may best subserve the interests of commerce: Provided,
That the work herein authorized shall not be undertaken until the consent of the
State of Rhode Island shall have been given for the application to this purpose of
the portion of said balance heretofore contributed and pledged by the said State.
   In accordance with this act the general assembly passed the
following resolution on April 2, 1909:
   Whereas the Congress of the United States has by law enacted that the appropria-
tions or authorizations for appropriations heretofore made with reference to the Paw-
tucket River, Rhode Island, may, in the discretion of the Secretary of War, and upon
the recommendation of the Chief of Engineers, be diverted or applied upon modified
projects for said Pawtucket River, as follows, viz: Any balance remaining unex-
pended after the completion of the work provided for under the existing contracts for
improving the Pawtucket River, Rhode Island, may be used in deepening the chan-
nel of said river to eighteen feet, and in increasing the widths thereof at such places
between Pawtucket and Providence as may best subserve the interests of commerce:
Provided, That the work herein authorized shall not be undertaken until the consent
of the State of Rhode Island shall have been given for the application to this purpose
of the portion of said balance heretofore contributed and pledged by said State.
   Be it therefore resolved, That the consent of the State of Rhode Island is hereby given
for the application to the said purpose of the portion of the balance of the appropria-
tion herefore contributed and pledged by the State of Rhode Island for said improve-
ments of said Pawtucket River.
   During the year 393,477 cubic yards of sand, gravel, clay, and
mud, 70.581 cubic yards of bowlders exceeding in dimensions 1 cubic
yard each, and 2,140.59 cubic yards of rock were removed.
   The amount expended on the existing project up to June 30, 1909,
exclusive of outstanding liabilities, was $70,890.08, by which about
three-quarters of the 16-foot channel, 100 feet wide, has been dredged
and about one-half of the channel through the rock has been exca-
vated.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 5 feet.
   The effect of the work thus far done on the new project is to afford
a channel 16 feet deep to Phillipsdale, about 2 miles below Paw-
tucket, and to facilitate the handling of vessels in Pawtucket Harbor,
but the full benefit of the 16-foot channel will not be experienced
until the project is completed.
   It is proposed to expend the sum of $20,000, estimated as a profit-
able expenditure for maintenance for the fiscal year 1911, in removing
such shoaling as may have occurred in the completed portion of the
channel.
   The total amount of commerce on this river is 422,370 tons, chiefly
coal, fish, oysters and oyster shells, and building materials, valued
at $3,483,932.
  For reference to report containing more extended information, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 84. Reference
to report on preliminary examination ordered by the river and harbor
act of March 3, 1905, will be found on page 92 of the report for 1906.
90            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                            S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                      $141, 320.99
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ...       ..........
                -.....      ....... ..... .. ...................... ......                  45, 052. 39

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..............                  .......................     96, 268. 60
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                   12, 682. 95

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                      83, 585. 65

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                        29, 444. 68

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909.................... ..... ............  ..........                  20, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix C 8.)
  9. Providence River and Harbor and NarragansettBay, and Green
Jacket shoal, Rhode Island.-(a) Providence River and Harbor and
Narragansett Bay.-The object of this improvement is to furnish a
wide and deep channel for foreign and coastwise commerce from the
ocean to Providence and to provide a deep-water anchorage for that
harbor.
  Before the improvement of the river in 1853 the available low-
water depth was limited to 4.5 feet. Between 1852 and 1873, $59,000
was expended in securing first 9 feet and then 12 feet depth of channel.
  The approved project of 1878, as modified in 1882, provided for
deepening the river and deepening and widening its anchorage basins
so as to secure a channel of at least 25 feet depth at low water with
300 feet width from the deep water of Narragansett Bay up to Provi-
dence, R. I., and so as to secure anchorage basins of 20 feet depth
with 600 feet width, 18 feet depth with 725 feet width, 12 feet depth
with 940 feet width, and 6 feet depth with 1,060 feet width from Fox
Point to Fields Point, all at a total cost estimated in 1882 at $675,000.
This project was completed in 1895.
  Another project originating in the river and harbor act of June 3,
1896, provided for securing a ship canal 400 feet wide and of a depth
of 25 feet at mean low water from Sassafras Point, in Providence
Harbor, through Providence River and Narragansett Bay by the
most direct route practicable to the ocean by way of the "Western
Passage," so called, at an estimated cost of $732,820. This project
was put under the continuing-contract system and the amount
expended on the work up to the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1908, exclusive of outstanding liabilities, was $476,210.28, by
which the channel 400 feet wide and 25 feet deep had been completed
from Sassafras Point to the deep water of Narragansett Bay by the
Western Passage.
   Under date of June 11, 1904, the Chief of Engineers authorized the
use of $2,000 of the balance remaining on hand of the appropriation
for securing a channel through the Western Passage of Narragansett
Bay for the removal of certain obstructing rocks in Dutch Island
Harbor, Rhode Island.
   The total amount expended on projects previous to the existing
project was $1,174,700.87.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                       91
   The existing project, adopted by the river and harbor act of June
13, 1902, provides for an enlarged anchorage area of 25 feet depth,
extending the full width of the harbor from Fox Point on the north
to Long Bed and Sassafras Point on the south, including the area
known as Green Jacket shoal, at an estimated cost of $607,778.
This project was enlarged by the river and harbor act of March 2,
1907, so as to include an area of uniform width and 25 feet deep to
the eastward of the main ship channel, between Long Bed and Kettle
Point, for which $90,750 was appropriated, making the total esti-
mated cost $698,528. The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905,
placed this work under the continuing-contract system.
   The amount expended on the existing project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $676,739.85, by which all
approved projects have been completed.
   The effect of the works of improvement under the existing project
is to provide an anchorage area in Providence Harbor of about 288
acres witr 25 feet depth, except that in some of the earlier portions
of the work there has been some slight shoaling. The area improved
includes all of Providence Harbor lying between Fields and Kettle
points on the south and Fox and India points on the north, limited
by the harbor lines on the east and west, except a triangular area
containing about 27.5 acres in the southeast corner of the harbor,
concerning which an estimate of the cost of removal was submitted
February 4, 1908, and printed as House Document No. 919, Sixtieth
Congress, first session, and a strip along the western side of the
southern portion of the harbor containing 32.8 acres, the survey of
which was authorized by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
   The only work contemplated is that of maintenance of the existing
project, and it is proposed to apply to this purpose the existing
balance and the allotment of $15,000 made from the appropriation
of March 3, 1909.
   It is proposed to apply the sum of $30,000, estimated for main-
tenance for the fiscal year 1911, to the maintenance of the anchorage
area and of the channel leading from Providence Harbor to deep
water in Narragansett Bay.
   For reference to reports containing more extended information,
see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 85.
   Reference to reports of examination and survey made in pur-
suance of act of March 2, 1907, will be found on page 97 of the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
   The commerce of Providence Harbor in 1908 was about 3,379,574
tons, chiefly coal, general merchandise, and fish, valued at $93,309,495.
    (b) Green Jacket shoal.-This shoal was in that part of Provi-
dence River which constitutes the harbor of Providence. It lay off
the wharves on the south front of the city and occupied a part of the
harbor that is required for anchorage purposes, covering an area of
about 18 acres between the 15-foot curves and about 30 acres in all.
    In its original condition the shoal in many places carried only 1
foot of water and was a very troublesome obstruction.
   The project for the removal of this shoal was adopted August 5,
1886.
    The sum of $104,250 was expended on this work up to June 30,
1904, by which 23.8 acres out of the original 30 of this shoal had
92            REPORT OF THE CHIEF                        OF ENGINEERS, If.                 S. ARMY.

been dredged to-25 feet depth, and a 16-foot depth had been secured
over the central and largest portion of the shoal, in addition to a
20-foot depth in the main channel, making an important addition to
the anchorage facilities of Providence Harbor.
   In the river and harbor acts of June 13, 1902, and March 3, 1905,
provision was made for the removal of the remaining portions of this
shoal in connection with the project for an enlarged anchorage area
in Providence Harbor, and all of the remaining portions of the shoal
were removed under the appropriations made by these acts.
   There has been some shoaling over those portions of the area
dredged prior to this year, which probably extends along the eastern
side of the recently dredged anchorage area.
   The effect of the improvement is stated in connection with the
report on Providence Harbor.
   For reference to reports containing more extended information see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 85.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended                                  --------- .. -----------
                                                            ---............                                . $126, 130. 80
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
                                                                                                    -------- 15, 000.00
  March 3, 1909...-------..........-------...............---------------....----.....--......-------...
Received from sale of material .......................................                                               2. 77
                                                                                                          141, 133. 57
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of im-
  provement .. ..... .......... .. .... ..... ........ . ...........                                      104, 342.65

July 1., 1909, balance unexpended ..           -...........        ....................                     36, 790. 92
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................                                         41.76
July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................                                         36, 749.16
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance
   unexpended July 1, 1909................................    ..........                                   30, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix C 9.)
  10. Harbor at Newport, R. 7.-This harbor is at the main entrance
to Narragansett Bay, and throughout the year it serves as an easily
accessible harbor of refuge to foreign and coastwise commerce.
  Before improvement the capacity of the inner harbor was limited
by shoals, and it was not adequate to the number and size of the
vessels seeking it for refuge. The southern or main entrance was
obstructed by a bar which stretched out from Goat Island and the
northern entrance by a sharp, rocky spit near Rose Island, and the
general business wharves of the city could not be reached at low tide
by vessels drawing more than 8 feet. The mean tidal range is about
3.75 feet. Between 1873 and 1875, $28,500 was appropriated to secure
12 feet depth in the harbor. This work was completed in 1876.
   The project adopted in 1880 and modified in 1882, 1883, 1884, 1890,
and 1895 provided for widening and deepening the channel from
Narragansett Bay into Newport, so as- to secure 15 feet depth at
mean low water with at least 750 feet width; for the extension of the
13-foot depth and 10-foot depth anchorage basins, and for dredging a
channel 10 feet deep along the state harbor line southward to opposite
the gas company's wharf; for the partial cutting off of the shoal spit
at the southern end of Goat Island; for the construction of jetties on
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                               93
the western shore of Goat Island, so as to protect the end of this
island from erosion and to prevent the drift of sand, etc., around the
island into the adjacent parts of the harbor and channel; and for the
removal of Spindle rock, a sharp, rocky spit near Rose Island; all at a
total cost estimated in 1895 at $206,200.
   The amount expended on the original and modified projects prior to
operations under the existing project was $244,695.71, by which the
projected work was completed.
   The existing project, adopted by the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907, provides for dredging a channel 750 feet wide and 18 feet
deep at mean low water around the southerly end of Goat Island and
northward through the harbor, in accordance with House Document
No. 121, Fifty-eighth Congress, second session, for the extension of
the 13-foot anchorage area southward to the harbor line and the
removal of Nourmahal rock in Brentons Cove off the Fort Adams
shore, to a depth of 18 feet, in accordance with House Document No.
438, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session, at a total estimated cost of
$250,900, which has been appropriated. The work has been carried
on under a continuing contract.
   The amount expended under the existing project up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $185,041.08, by which the
project was completed, with the exception of the removal of some
areas of ledge rock which were uncovered in dredging in the southern
part of the harbor.
   It is proposed to apply the existing balance to the removal of those
portions of the ledge which form the most dangerous obstructions.
   As the improvement of this harbor has progressed there has been a
large increase in the size and number of vessels using it. The com-
merce for 1908 was about 200,530 tons, principally fish, coal, and
general merchandise, valued at $9,246,164.
   This includes freight passing through the harbor, but destined for
other ports. It has become one of the most important harbors of
refuge on the southern New England coast, and is much used as a
point for breaking up and making up tows for coal barges and for the
transshipment of fish.
   For reference to reports containing more extended information, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 87.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......... ....-....... .......                 $120, 192.70
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909 ......            53, 800. 00
                                                                                172, 992. 70
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment......................................................................    107,979.30

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................             66, 013.40
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................          4, 774. 34

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................            61, 239. 06
    (See Appendix C 10.)
   11. Harbor of refuge at Point Judith, Rhode Island.-Point Judith
is the southeastern extremity of the township of South Kingston,
R. I., and marks the southwestern entrance to Narragansett Bay.
A long ledge, known as "Squid Ledge," projects over a mile from the
shore in a direction south by east about 1.5 miles west of the point.
94       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S. ARMY.

This location was dangerous for vessels to pass during a storm,
especially for the light-built barges transporting coal from New York
Bay points to Narragansett Bay.
   The existing project of September 19, 1890, provides for the
construction at this point of a natural harbor of refuge nearly a
square mile in area, by means of two stone breakwaters. The main
breakwater, built partly on Squid Ledge, is approximately V-shaped,
facing outward in a direction about south by west, and lying at a
considerable distance from the shore. Eastward of the main break-
water a detached breakwater, nearly parallel to the line of the eastern
arm of the main breakwater prolonged shoreward, was planned to
shelter the eastern entrance, so as to give protection against easterly,
southerly, and westerly storms, the mainland itself forming a pro-
tection on the north, all at a total cost estimated in 1889 at $1,250,000.
This project was modified by the report of a Board of Engineers con-
vened to consider and report upon the construction of this harbor,
which was approved November 16, 1896, and provided for raising
the crest of the eastern arm and extending the western arm to its
originally projected length, at an estimated cost of $444,311, and
deferring the construction of the easterly detached breakwater as a
part of the main project until the completion of the main break-
water should demonstrate its necessity or otherwise. The river and
harbor act of June 13, 1902, made a further modification by pro-
viding for the construction of the easterly detached breakwater and
continuing it to the shore, at an estimated cost of $196,193 for the
detached breakwater and $187,558.80 for the shore extension. A
further modification was made by the act of March 2,1907, authorizing
an extension seaward of the easterly breakwater at an additional
estimated cost of $186,248.20, making the total cost of this break-
water $570,000 and a total estimate for the project and its modi-
fications of $2,264,311.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, provided for the further
extension of the easterly breakwater under the continuing-contract
system, appropriating $100,000 therefor and authorizing the expendi-
ture of an additional $170,000 (appropriated by the sundry civil act
of May 27, 1908) for its completion. Under date of May 11, 1907,
a continuing contract was entered into for this extension. Work
under this contract was commenced June 15, 1907, and it was com-
pleted January 11, 1909, and leaves an easterly opening into the
harbor 1,200 feet in width. About $8,443.35 was expended during
the year in repairs to the main breakwater.
   The sum of $1,793,823.78 had been expended on this work up to
June 30, 1909, of which $14,860.67 was for maintenance. By this
expenditure the main breakwater had been built to a total length of
6,970 feet with a height of 10 feet above mean low water, and the
easterly breakwater had been completed for a distance of 2,240 feet
out from the high-water line on shore to about 30 feet depth of water.
   Before the construction of the breakwater the area inclosed
within the lines upon which it has been built and the shore was
about 640 acres, of which 390 acres has over 25 feet of water and
198 acres additional over 18 feet. The 18-foot area and the whole
water-covered area has since been considerably reduced by shoaling
in the western part.
   Proceedings for the condemnation of land required for the shore
end of the breakwater are in progress. The decree condemning the
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               95
land to the uses of the United States was entered on May 26, 1906,
and the commission to assess the land damages viewed the land
May 23, 1907. A hearing was held before the commissioners at
Narragansett Pier on August 14, 1907, and at Providence, R. I., May
27 and 28, 1909.
   About 79 per cent of the approved project with its modifications
has been completed. The result of the improvement has been to
create a harbor of refuge fairly suitable for sailing vessels and
steamers, though the holding ground is poor, but not well suited for
tows of barges, on account of the narrowness of the entrances, the
direction of the entering courses with respect to that of the worst
seas and the fact that the central part of the area is obstructed by a
dangerous reef.
   About 30 feet can be carried at mean low water into the eastern
and from 18 to 19 feet into the western entrance. The mean range
of tide is 3.1 feet.
   Seven hundred and fifty-five vessels used the harbor during the
fiscal year, of which 192 belonged to the contractor for construction
and maintenance of the breakwaters. Of these 755, there were 301
schooners, 149 sloops, 64 steamers, 11 yawls, 117 tugs, and 113 barges;
but 101 of the tugs and 91 of the barges belonged to the contractors.
   The storms of the winter of 1908-9 accompanied by high tides
damaged the breakwaters to some extent, which will be repaired
with funds in hand.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, provided for an ex-
amination with a view to further improvement of the harbor. The
report of this examination was printed as House Document No. 911,
Sixtieth Congress, first session, in connection with which matter
House Document No. 935, Sixtieth Congress, first session, contains
certain papers relating to Point Judith Harbor of Refuge, bearing
upon its importance and the necessity for a landing pier at that place.
No estimate is submitted for further work on the existing project for
this locality pending action by Congress on the modified plan of
improvement contained in the report of examination just mentioned.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................... $193, 049. 99
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.................................    ................... 10, 000. 00
Amount allotted from emergency appropriation by river and harbor act
  approved March 2, 1907...............  ......... ..................   10, 000. 00

                                                                                                213, 049. 99
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ............................                       $158, 386. 81
    For maintenance of improvement.......................                          8, 443. 35
                                                                                                166, 830. 16

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                             46, 219. 83
July 1., 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................                .............             52. 50

July 1, 1909, balance available .........................................                       46, 167. 33

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                         444, 311. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909..................................   ............                       20, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
     June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix C 11.)
96       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U. S. ARMY.

  12.  Entrance to Point Judith Pond, Rhode Island.-Point Judith
Pond is a shallow salt pond, lying in the rear of the sandy beach of the
Rhode Island shore, just west of Point Judith. Before improvement
it was frequently cut off from the ocean.
   The improvement desired at this place by the people of the neigh-
borhood is the widening and deepening of the present opening into
the pond and the extension of jetties for the maintenance of such
opening.
   The State of Rhode Island and the town of South Kingstown are
making the opening into the pond.
   No general project for the improvement of this channel has been
formed. The appropriations of $7,500 made in 1892, $2,500 in 1894,
and of $2,000 in 1905 were expended in extending and strengthening
the western jetty, originally built by the State, for the expenses of the
Board of Engineers authorized by river and harbor act of June 13,
1902, and for surveys.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, provides $8,000 for
" continuing improvement and for maintenance," "which amount
shall be expended for dredging."
   In 1905 the excavated channel through the beach proper was about
3,000 feet long and carried a navigable depth of about 6 feet, but for
a like distance beyond this point there was practically no navigable
depth at low tide, there being a wide sand bar crossed by irregular
streams rarely carrying as much as 1 foot of water. On the pond side
of this bar there was about 5 feet depth. The difference of level
between the pond and the ocean, together with the relatively small
sectional area of the channel, is such as to create very strong cur-
rents. No dredging through this bar would be permanent without
some auxiliary directing works to control the flow of the current.
An appropriation of $6,000 was made at the 1907 session of the Rhode
Island general assembly, and it was expected that the use of the com-
bined appropriations might result in some benefit to the work, but
the threatened cutting away of the sand behind the westerly jetty at
the entrance to the pond made it necessary to use the state money
in an effort to check this wash.
   In the spring of 1909 it was found that a portion of the bar at the
inner end of the channel had been carried farther into the pond, leav-
ing a crooked channel through it, and still leaves a bar at the inner
end of the new channel with about 3 feet of water on it at mean low
water.
   The mean range of tide is 3.1 feet.
   No part of the 1907 appropriation for dredging of $8,000 has as yet
been used.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1909, were $12,000, resulting in
improving the entrance to the extent stated above. The locality is
not deemed worthy of further improvement at present.
   The commerce of the pond is very small and consists mainly of
oysters caught in the Point Judith Pond, which are shipped by rail.
   A report of the preliminary examination of this waterway was
submitted April 13, 1909, in accordance with the provisions of the
river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, reference to which will be
found on page 100 of this report.
                     RIVER AND      HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                               97
   For reference to reports containing more extended information,
see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 90.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..........................      ....    ....   $8, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................................         8, 000. 00
   (See Appendix C 12.)
   13. Harbor of refuge at Block Island, Rhode Island.-This island
is about 14 miles east of the eastern end of Long Island, and about
10 miles distant from the nearest point of the mainland.
   The object of the improvement was to furnish a harbor of refuge
for medium-draft vessels engaged in foreign and coastwise com-
merce.
   Before the construction of the present harbor Block Island had no
harbor at all.
   The mean tidal range is about 3 feet.
   Between 1870 and 1876, $285,000 was appropriated for a break-
water on the eastern side of the island for a harbor for medium-
draft vessels, this work being completed in 1878. Between 1880 and
1882, $25,000 was appropriated for dredging an inner basin and the
protection of the shore next to the breakwater, this work being com-
pleted in 1884. In 1884, $15,000 was appropriated for additions to
the breakwater, this money being so spent and the work completed
in 1884-85.
   The project of 1884, as modified in 1888, provided for the con-
struction of a harbor of refuge consisting of an inclosed inner harbor
800 feet square, protected by an L-shaped breakwater, for small ves-
sels, and an exterior harbor for larger ones, protected by the original
breakwater, at a total cost estimated in 1888 at $75,000. This
project was practically completed in 1893.
   The total expenditure prior to commencing work on the existing
project was $400,575.17.
   The existing project of June 3, 1896, provides for raising the entire
breakwater to proper height and stopping sand leaks between certain
points and dredging the main inner harbor to a depth of 10 feet, at
an estimated cost of $83,985.
   At the adoption of the present project this harbor was neither
large enough nor well enough protected for the proper harborage of
the craft seeking refuge at this place during storms and bad weather.
   The sum of $118,172.39 had been expended on the existing project
up to June 30, 1909, of which $17,983.47 was for maintenance. By
this expenditure the entrance to the inner harbor, which had shoaled
up from the drift of sand, had been partially dredged to a depth of
12 feet and redredged to a depth of 10 feet several times. The north
wall of the inner harbor had been strengthened and repaired and the
existing project completed. The accumulation of sand along the
inner side of the original breakwater, as noted for a number of years,
continues, and $12,500 was allotted from the appropriation made by
the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, for maintenance.
   No work of improvement or maintenance was carried on during the
year beyond a survey of the harbor and receiving proposals for redredg-
ing portions of the harbor which had shoaled since the previous work.
The improvement provides an anchorage of about 17 acres, with a
least depth of 10 feet at mean low water, 10 acres of which is within
       9001-NG 1909-7
98            REPORT OF THE CHIEF                       OF ENGINEERS,               U.   S. ARMY.


the walls of the inclosed inner harbor. The commerce of this harbor
amounts to 11,861 tons, chiefly fish and general merchandise, valued
at $591,873.
   Reference to reports of an examination and survey made in pursu-
ance of the act of March 2, 1907, will be found on page 97 of the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers, U. S. Army, for 1908.
   For reference to reports containing more extended information, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 91.
   Further work awaits action of Congress on the project submitted
in compliance with the provisions of the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..........................          ........  $719. 42
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909............................................................. 12, 500. 00
                                                                                                         13, 219. 42
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement-------.......---...----..-----...................               $132. 08
    For maintenance of improvement............................                                143. 73
                                                                                                              575. 81
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...........................------........                                12, 643. 61
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....................---- .....----.........                              50. 06
July 1, 1909, balance available----------.........................-------------------......---..         12, 593. 55
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1,1909..--------------......--------.........----..........--------.......---------.......... 12, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix C 13.)
  14. Great Salt Pond, Block Island, Rhode Island.-The Great Salt
Pond is located about the center of Block Island and contains an
anchorage area of 150 acres for vessels drawing 18 feet and over.
The work of converting the pond into a harbor of refuge by making
a channel through the beach on the west, connecting it with deep
water in the ocean, was started by the State of Rhode Island and the
town of New Shoreham.
  The channel, under the existing project of June 3, 1896, as modified
in 1900, is to be 600 feet wide and have a central depth of 25 feet for
a width of 150 feet, sloping gradually to 12 feet in a width of 504
feet, the channel seaward to be protected on the south by a jetty
extending to 350 feet beyond the original 18-foot contour and on the
north by a jetty about 1,200 feet long, and the sides of the channel
where it passed through the original beach to be protected by stone
revetments and sand fences, at a total estimated cost of $305,000.
   At the time the work commenced under the General Government
a channel of varying width and depth had been dredged with the
money appropriated by the State and town, which would permit of
12-foot draft being carried in.
   The south jetty had been built out 837 feet, and a north jetty 250
feet long had also been built, but at a distance of 720 feet from the
south jetty instead of 600 feet, as called for in the adopted project.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is about 3 feet.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $198,979.89 had been expended by the General
Government on the existing project, of which $9,943.24 had been
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                     99

used for maintenance and repair. By this expenditure the south
jetty had been extended 439 feet beyond the originally projected
length, making a total of 1,691 feet from the initial point on shore.
Some damage done by a severe storm in the spring of 1900 had been
repaired. The 25-foot deep channel 150 feet wide had been completed,
and a cut 23 feet deep and 30 feet wide had been made on either side
of it, that on the northerly side of the channel going but about half-
way through. The 18-foot depth had been dredged to a width of 300
feet.
   During the last fiscal year a survey of the entrance has been made.
The dredge Gedney, transferred to this district in the latter part of
June, was engaged two days in dredging sand that had accumulated
in the channel.
   There remains to complete the existing project the construction of
jetties as planned and dredging to secure the widths and depths pro-
jected, and the appropriation asked for will be applied to this work.
   The work required to complete the existing project is for the pur-
pose of extending the benefits of the improvement.
   The commerce of this harbor amounts to 10,458 tons, chiefly of fish
and general merchandise, valued at $636,425. During the summer
season a large number of passengers is carried to Block Island through
this harbor.
   Provision was made in the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909,
for a preliminary examination and survey of the inner harbor of the
Great Salt Pond, report of which will be submitted as soon as possible.
   For reference to reports containing more extended information, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 92.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................. ....................           $8, 848. 59
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......................................................           12, 500. 00
                                                                                 21, 348. 59
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.............................          $7, 688. 48
    For maintenance of improvement .........---...............         140. 00
                                                                                  7, 828. 48

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................           13, 520. 11
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities............................. .........         946. 33

July 1, 1909, balance available........................................   12, 573. 08
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 105, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909------------...--------..----------------------------.     105, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897.
   (See Appendix C 14.)
  15. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangeringnavi-
gation-Schooner Harry Messer, Steamer Horatio Hall, Schooner Jennie
French Potter.
   (a) Schooner Harry Messer, a three-masted wooden schooner, was
sunk on the northeast part of Handkerchief Shoal, Nantucket Sound,
Massachusetts. Removal commenced February 10, 1909; completed
March 1, 1909. The total cost of removal was $898.99.
  (b) Steamer Horatio Hall was sunk in collision in Pollock Rip Slue,
eastern entrance to Nantucket Sound, March 10, 1909. Work of
100      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S. ARMY.

removal commenced April 12 and was completed June 28, 1909. The
total cost of removal was $3,441.56.
   (c) Schooner Jennie FrenchPotter, a five-masted wooden schooner,
was sunk on Half Moon Shoal, at the eastern end of Horse Shoe Shoal,
about 1 miles north, northeast of Cross Rip Light-Ship, Nantucket
Sound, Massachusetts. The wreck was reported as a dangerous
obstruction to navigation and removal recommended June 28, 1909.
   (See Appendix C 15.)
EXAMINATION    MADE   IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND HARBOR             ACT
                      APPROVED MARCH 3, 1909.

  Report dated April 13, 1909, on preliminary examination of Point
Judith Pond, Rhode Island, and the entrance thereto, with a view to
obtaining a navigable depth, required by the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1909, was duly submitted by the district officer. It was re-
viewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant
to law, and was transmitted to Congress and printed in House Docu-
ment No. 79, Sixty-first Congress, first session. The locality is not
considered worthy of improvement at the present time by the General
Government in the manner proposed.
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
            HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports on preliminary examinations and survey required by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities within
this district were duly submitted by the district officer. They were
reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant
to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in documents
as indicated:
   1. Preliminary examination and survey of New Haven Harbor, Con-
necticut with a view to determining whether a greater depth is needed, also
the rocks in Morris Cove.-Reports dated May 15, 1907, and July 31,
1908, respectively, are printed in House Document No. 1159, Sixtieth
Congress, second session. Two plans of improvement are presented,
estimated to cost $68,000 and $212,000, respectively.
   2. Preliminary examination qf Connecticut River between Hartford,
Conn., and Holyokce, Mass.-Report dated October 31, 1908, is
printed in House Document No. 1311, Sixtieth Congress, second ses-
sion. The locality is not considered worthy of improvement by the
General Government on account of the cost being out of proportion
to the probable benefits.
  IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE NEW LONDON,
                  CONNECTICUT, DISTRICT.
  This district was in the charge of Maj. Harry Taylor, Corps of
Engineers. Division engineer, Col. John G. D. Knight, Corps of
Engineers.
  1. Pawcatuck River, Rhode Island and Connecticut.--The navi-
gable part of the Pawcatuck River extends 5 miles from Westerly,
R. I., to its outlet, in Little Narragansett Bay, through the northern
part of which a navigable channel extends 2 miles to Stonington
Harbor, Connecticut, through which Long Island Sound is reached.
  Before improvement the channel of the river was crooked and
obstructed by numerous shoals, on some of which there was 1 to 14
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              101
feet of water, and the greatest depth that could be carried through
the bay channel was 4 feet.
   The original projects, that of 1871 for the river channel and that
of 1879 for the channel across the bay, provided for depths of 5 and
7 feet and widths of 75 and 200 feet, respectively. The expenditure
on the original projects was $97,500.01.
   The present project, adopted in 1896, provides for a channel 10
feet deep from Stonington, Conn., to Westerly, R. I., with a width
of 200 feet from Stonington to Avondale, R. I., a distance of about 4
miles; a width of 100 feet from Avondale to the lower wharves at
Westerly, a distance of about 3 miles, and a width of 40 feet between
the upper and lower wharves of Westerly, a distance of about one-
half mile, at a total estimated cost of $200,361.60. The river and
harbor act of March 3, 1905, authorized the use of $1,000 of the appro-
priation for the improvement of the Pawcatuck River in the removal
of obstructions at Watch Hill, at the southeastern part of the Little
Narragansett Bay. The greater portion of the obstructions was re-
moved in January and February, 1906, at a cost of $865.82.
   On this project $72,094.96 had been expended to June 30, 1909,
therewith completing the section 40 feet wide along the wharves of
Westerly, extending the 100-foot channel downstream 1,800 feet,
making a channel through Little Narragansett Bay 100 feet wide
and 10 feet deep and extending the 100-foot channel upstream to
within 2,000 feet of the channel extended downstream from Wes-
terly. Of this amount $15,080.41 was applied to maintenance.
The project is about 25 per cent completed.
   The maximum draft, which could be carried June 30, 1909, was 10
feet in the bay channel, 7 feet in the river, and 6 feet near Watch
Hill. The mean rise of tide is 2.6 feet at the mouth of the river and
2.3 feet at Westerly.
   The effect of the improvement is to permit coal, lumber, and build-
ing material to be delivered in vessels at Westerly, and to ship there-
from granite in vessels instead of by rail, thus giving water competi-
tion for these materials, with a resulting benefit in the reduction of
freight rates.
   The available balance and the appropriation asked for will be
applied toward maintenance and the completion of the project.
   The reported tonnage for 1908 was 59,037, valued at $303,775.53.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................  $25, 459.74
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment......................................................              19, 554. 71

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-.....................................         5, 905. 03
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.....................................     5, 772.25

July 1, 1909, balance available ...................     ..................        132.78

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................            100.00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ .138,      342. 01

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909-                 .............
                                               -..-..             .....        15, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix D 1.)
102        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                       U.   S. ARMY.

   2. New London Harbor, Connecticut.--New London Harbor, which
comprises the lower 3 miles of the Thames River, has a navigable
width of one-quarter to 11 miles and depth of 26 feet or more in the
main channel from Long Island Sound to the railroad drawbridge
which crosses the river above the New London dock front. This
channel, especially opposite New London, follows the east bank.
Between it and the city docks is a nearly level area having a general
depth of 10 to 15 feet. Before improvement part of the docks were
accessible to vessels of 16 to 18 feet draft at high tide only.
   The original and present project, adopted by the act of June 13,
1902, provides for dredging and maintaining a ship channel 400 feet
or more in width, 23 feet deep, and about 6,000 feet long. This chan-
nel leaves the deep water of the river opposite Fort Trumbull on the
west side, skirts the water front of the city, including that of Win-
throp Cove, to the Central Vermont Railroad bridge and the east side
of the Central Vermont dock, and joins the natural deep channel at a
distance of about 4,000 feet upstream from the point of beginning.
The estimated cost of the improvement was $145,000, and $1,000 per
annum for maintenance. For map see House Document No. 392,
Fifty-sixth Congress, first session.
   Ulp to June 30, 1909, $141,400 had been expended on the project.
   The project dredging was completed under a continuing contract
in October, 1904. This completed the project except at two small
areas of ledge rock in the Fort Trumbull-Shaws Cove arm of the chan-
nel, where there were depths of about 18 feet, and at a part of a city
pipe sewer crossing the middle of the dredged channel, where the least
depth was 21.6 feet. The rock in the channel was removed in 1907.
A draft of 23 feet can be carried to opposite all the principal docks.
The additional work proposed is to maintain the improvement.
   The effect of this improvement has been to materially reduce
freight rates.
   The mean range of tide is 2.6 feet.
   Under a modification of the existing Thames River project, adopted
in 1892, Shaws Cove, a branch of New London Harbor, has been
dredged to 12 feet.
   The reported tonnage of this port for the year 1908, principally
coal, building material, oil, and steamboat freight, and exclusive of
that pertaining to Shaws Cove and Thames River, was 746,967, val-
ued at $12,753,777.83.
   Reference to reports on examination and survey made in pursuance
of act of March 2, 1907, will be found on page 122 of report for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..... ................................               $5, 919. 41
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...    ...... ..-......        .......-...... $319. 41
    Carried to the surplus fund.............................-           . 3, 600. 00
                                                                                      3, 919. 41

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.........--...---..... -..........-..-             .   2, 000. 00
   (See Appendix D 2.)
  3. Thames River, Connecticut.-This is a tidal stream from Nor-
wich, Conn., the head of navigation, to Long Island Sound, a dis-
tance of 15 miles. For 4 miles below Norwich the natural depths
were 6 feet or more at low water with widths of 400 to 1,000 feet. Be-
low this point depths were 13 feet or more and widths 800 to 3,000
feet.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                    103
   The original project, adopted in 1836, provided for a channel 11
feet deep at low water, to be secured by dredging and building dikes.
On this project $40,300 had been expended when, in 1839, work was
stopped, the project not having been completed.
   The existing project, adopted June 23, 1866, and modified in 1879,
1882, 1888, 1892, and 1907, is to dredge and build training walls to
secure a channel 200 feet wide with depths of 20 feet from New
London to Allyns Point and 14 feet thence 5 miles to Norwich; also
to dredge Shaws Cove at New London to a depth of 12 feet. Esti-
mates of cost were $473,870 for construction and $9,500 annually for
maintenance.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $472,151.76 had been expended on this project
and its modifications, of which $32,308.57 had been applied to main-
tenance. The project had been completed, except that part of the
channel between Allyns Point and Norwich was somewhat deficient
in width. Mean range of tide is 2.6 feet at New London and 3.1 feet
at Norwich.
   The balance on hand and the appropriation recommended will be
applied to maintenance of the improvement.
   Commerce at Allyns Point is coal, and at Norwich and intermediate
landings it is mainly coal, lumber, cotton and wool, and steamboat
freight. The reported tonnage for 1908 was 443,395, valued at
$2,265,350.51, including 22,561 tons, valued at $121,380.50, for Shaws
Cove commerce.
   The work done has reduced the cost of transportation by enabling
freight to be brought in vessels of 16 and 18 foot draft instead of
8-foot draft. The river commerce of the present day could not be
carried except for the increased depths thus obtained.
   The modification of project adopted by act of March 2, 1907, is
printed in House Document No. 265, Fifty-ninth Congress, second
session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................                   ............ $29, 434. 69
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ............................................................               13, 986.45

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................                  -
                                                              .........-   -.....   15,448. 24

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909..        ..................................     . 10, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix D 3.)
   4. Connecticut River between Hartford, Conn., and Holyoke, Mass.-
This portion of the river is 34 miles long, and is naturally divided
into three distinct sections. From Hartford to the foot of Enfield
Rapids, 10 miles, the river has a gentle slope, with a sandy, shifting
bottom; from the foot to the head of Enfield Rapids, 51 miles, the
total fall at low water is 32 feet, and the bed of the river is largely
rock; from Enfield Falls to Holyoke, 18 miles, the river is of moderate
width, gentle slope, fair depth, and stable bottom.
   In its original condition the lower section had a navigable depth of
2 feet or less at low water; the second section could be navigated up-
stream only with great difficulty and only by boats of shallow draft;
the third section was navigable by boats drawing 4 to 5 feet of water.
104          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S.                                         ARMY.

   At Enfield Rapids a canal with locks 80 feet in length and 18 feet
in width, designed for boats with draft of about 3 feet at low water,
has been constructed by private enterprise as part of a water-power
development scheme.
   Prior to June 30, 1898, $93,059.70 was expended in the construction
of wing dams and dredging to provide a temporary improvement
below Enfield Rapids, and in extensive surveys and examinations
which were made with a view to permanent improvement of the whole
stretch from Hartford to Holyoke.
   No work of improvement has been carried on in this section of the
river since 1886.
   A complete history of the improvement of this section of the river,
up to that date, with maps and plans, is given in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1878, pages 248-391.
   Examinations and surveys with a view to future permanent im-
provement have been made under the river and harbor acts of June
3, 1896, June 13, 1902, and March 3, 1905. The Board appointed by
authority of the last-named act suggested three plans of improvement
other than those which had been already reported upon. One of these
plans provided for dredging, the use of wing dams and training walls,
and rock excavation from Hartford up to a point above the mills at
Windsor Locks; thence by a new lock and the upper portion of the
existing canal, and thence to Holyoke, at a cost of $1,465,600. This
plan was approved by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Har-
bors, provided that all rights claimed to be infringed by this work
should be ceded to the United States without cost. The amount ex-
pended on this survey was $22,838.47.
   The appropriation of March 2, 1907, was for the purpose of inves-
tigation and further examination, in accordance with the recommen-
dation of the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors referred to,
to determine what rights might be infringed and if they could be
obtained without cost to the United States. A report of the result
of this examination is printed in House Document No. 1311, Sixtieth
Congress, second session. The company claiming the rights declined
to cede them without payment.
   To June 30, 1909, the amount expended from the appropriation of
March 2, 1907, was $313.55.
   No permanent benefit has resulted from the work thus far done.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended . .....................................                                $6, 951. 21
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For maintenance of improvement .........................                                $103. 23
    Carried to the surplus fund .................                     .........            1, 846. 26
                                                                                                         1, 949. 49

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................                           ............           5, 001. 72
    (See Appendix D 4.)
  5. Connecticut River below Hartford, Conn.-The part of the river
under improvement is 50 miles long from Long Island Sound to
Hartford. Beyond Hartford the river is navigable, by means of a
small private canal at Windsor Locks, Conn., 34 miles to Holyoke,
Mass., although the navigation is limited by reason of low fixed
bridges and the inadequacy of the canal. Before beginning improve-
ment below Hartford the available depth over Saybrook bar at the
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      105
mouth of the river was 7 feet, and thence to Hartford at the shoalest
of the river bars about 5 feet.
   The original project, adopted in 1836, provided for the removal of
the Saybrook bar by dredging. Up to 1843 an 11 to 12 foot channel
had been dredged 50 feet wide and 1,500 feet long, at a cost of
$23,471.57. No further work was done until 1870, by which time the
dredged channel had been nearly obliterated by storms and freshets.
  A project for permanent improvement was adopted in 1870 and
modified in 1873 and 1880, under which two jetties were built at Say-
brook bar and dikes constructed at Hartford and Glastonbury bars;
but operations under this project have been abandoned.
  The existing project, adopted in 1887 and modified in 1890, pro-
vides for maintaining the navigable channel by completing two jetties
at Saybrook bar to a height of 5 feet above high water, with top
width of 6 feet and side slopes of 1 on 1; raising the training wall,
nearly 3,700 feet long, at the Hartford bars as may be found necessary
by experience, but not to exceed 15 feet above low water; dredging
the channel between the jetties to 12 feet depth and width of 400 feet
and maintaining the channel by annual dredging at the various river
bars to about 10 feet depth at mean low water and to a width as near
100 feet as practicable, at an estimated cost-
Completing Saybrook jetties..------..--------------------..........................----.......------....--    $60, 000
Dredging channel between them...---------.........------...----....--------..........------------...--.....    20, 000
Raising Hartford dike-..-.....- ..... ............. .........                               ...............    50, 000
        Total..............----................---------------....------------------------------.......       130. 000
and $10,000 annually for dredging for maintenance.
   For scope and history of the modifications, see pages 120 and 121,
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900.
   The act of June 13, 1902, authorized an expenditure of $1,000 for
removal of obstructions at mouth of Salmon River, a tributary to the
Connecticut River.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $590,300.24 had been expended on this im-
provement, of which $338,157.62 had been applied to maintenance.
The project is about 50 per cent completed.
   The maintenance of the river-bar channels by annual dredging has
been held paramount in the project. A channel 200 feet wide and 12
feet deep at mean low water, which has been dredged through Say-
brook bar between the jetties, has been well maintained by the jetties,
and annual dredging at the river bars has generally kept a half-
width channel open so that Hartford-New York steamers and barges
drawing from 9 to 11 feet, according to the river stage, have been
but little detained, and then only at summer low river and before
completion of the annual dredging. The maximum draft which
could be carried at mean low water over the shoalest river bar on
June 30, 1909, was 10 feet. The mean rise of tide is 3.6 feet at Say-
brook jetties and on low river 1.5 feet at Hartford.
   Sketches of the Connecticut River from Hartford to Rocky Hill
and of Saybrook bar are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1885, page 636. The river from the Sound to Hart-
ford is shown on Coast Survey charts 253-256.
   The reported tonnage for the year 1908 amounted to 515,581 tons,
mainly coal, lumber, building materials, and miscellaneous steamboat
freight, valued at $14,001,989.
106         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The work done has reduced freight rates to Hartford and lower
river ports materially, and has also greatly facilitated the delivery of
coal and other freight. Without the improvements there could be
but little freight traffic on the river.
   The available balance and the additional appropriation asked for
will be applied to maintenance and continuing work on the approved
project.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................... .         . $32, 976. 50
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ....................................................    15, 000. 00
                                                                                             47, 976. 50
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement- ..................         .........            $13, 815. 77
    For maintenance of improvement .....................                       12, 762. 54
                                                                                             26, 578. 31

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. .................            .............                 21, 398. 19
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. .                                    ......
                                                            -. -.--....---......         .    4, 885. 51
July 1, 1909, balance available .. ............       ...     ....   ...............         16, 512. 68
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. .-                                     8, 227. 45
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                      95, 665. 68
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909...---...........    ----.....  .   .                      42, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix D 5.)
   6. Harbor of refuge at Duck Island Harbor, Connecticut.-Duck
Island Harbor is a bay on the north shore of Long Island Sound about
7 miles west of the mouth of the Connecticut River and midway be-
tween the harbors of New London and New Haven.
   The project for this improvement, adopted by the act of September
19, 1890, provides for the construction of three riprap breakwaters of
3,000, 1,750, and 1,130 feet length, respectively, inclosing and shelter-
ing an area of about 115 acres, with two entrances. The project
height of the breakwaters is 10 feet above low water, with crown of
10 feet and slopes of 2 on 3 outside and 1 on 1 inside. The estimated
aggregate cost is $463,540. For map see Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1887, page 644, and House Document No. 398,
Sixtieth Congress, first session.
   To June 30, 1909, $116,309.25 had been expended, of which $5,-
334.10 was for maintenance, and 2,697 linear feet of the west break-
water had been built, but with reduced cross section, extending west-
wardly from Duck Island to a low-water depth of 17 feet. The mean
rise of tide is 3.8 feet.
   No estimate is submitted for further work on the existing project
for this locality, pending action by Congress on a modified plan of
improvement contained in House Document No. 398, Sixtieth Con-
gress, first session, based on examination and survey authorized by
the river and harbor act approved March 2, 1907.
   The project is about 25 per cent completed. The commerce to be
benefited by this improvement is the passing commerce of Long
                         RIVER AND         HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                 107

Island Sound, which may find it necessary or convenient to seek
shelter at this locality. Its value can not be satisfactorily estimated.
   During the year 1908,1,003 vessels were reported as having anchored
in the harbor, which, in its present condition, affords but a very small
percentage of the shelter it would if completed.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................................           $3, 892. 75
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................          3, 892. 75
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 349, 540. 00
   (See Appendix D 6.)
   7. Branford Harbor, Connecticut.-Branford Harbor consists of
three distinct parts: The outer harbor, approximately 1 mile wide
and three-quarters of a mile deep; the inner harbor, about half a mile
in diameter, separated from the outer harbor by a series of rocks,
the principal ones of which are known as "The Mermaids;" and the
river, which empties into the inner harbor from the northeast. The
natural low-water depths when improvement began were: At the
outside of the outer harbor, 15 to 16 feet, gradually shoaling to 8
feet near "The Mermaids;" through the inner harbor from "The
Mermaids" to the mouth of the river, 7 to 8 feet; up the river for a
distance of 1 mile, nearly to the lower docks, 12 feet or more. From
the lower to the upper docks the channel gradually shoaled and nar-
rowed so that the controlling depth was less than 6 feet and the width
25 to 50 feet. At the upper dock the stream is crossed by an earthen
causeway, in which there is a small drawbridge which is rarely
opened, although the stream is navigable for small craft to a fixed
bridge about one-half mile above. Since the adoption of the present
project a very general and uniform shoaling of 1 to 2 feet has taken
place in the inner harbor, so that the controlling depth between "The
Mermaids" and the mouth of the river, the shoalest place in the
channel, was only about 6 feet.
   The original and present project, adopted by the act of June 13,
1902, and modified by the act of March 2, 1907, provides for an
82-foot channel 100 feet wide in the upper part of the river between
the lower and upper docks and through the shoals at the mouth of
the river, at an estimated first cost of $13,000.
   This project was completed July 30, 1907, at which time channels
of full project dimensions had been dredged from the 8 -foot curve
in the lower harbor through the inner harbor to the mouth of the
river, and in the upper portion of the river from below the lower
docks upstream to the upper docks.
   This work greatly facilitates navigation, and the effect of the im-
provement has been to reduce freight rates.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, from the
entrance of the harbor to the head of the proposed channel was about
7 feet at mean low water in the lower harbor and 84 feet in the river.
The mean rise of tide is about 6.5 feet.
    For report of survey upon which the present project is based, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1901, page 1189 et seq.
Reference to reports on examination and survey made in pursuance
of act of March 2, 1907, will be found on page 122 of report of 1908.
    The amount expended on this project to June 30, 1909, was
 $11,221.63, of which $1,684.18 was for maintenance.
108             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                             S. ARMY.

   The commerce of this harbor is mainly coal, molding sand and clay,
iron, and lumber. The tonnage reported for 1908 amounted to
20,669 net tons, valued at $100,362.80.
   The available balance and the appropriation asked for will be ap-
plied to maintenance of the improvement.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................................                                          $1, 851. 69
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement.........................................................                                                  73.32

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ----...........---------..........------------...........--------...             1, 778.37
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities------------------------......................---............----------..        20. 67
July 1, 1909, balance available.....----------.....---..........------------------...........
                                                                                    ------- 1, 757.70
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909-------------------------------------------...                                              2, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix D 7.)
   8. New Haven Harbor, including West River, Connecticut.-New
Haven Harbor is formed by a bay on the north side of Long Island
Sound, which extends inland about 4 miles and is from 1 to 2 miles
wide. Mill and Quinnipiac rivers, navigable for about 1 and 3 miles,
respectively, above their mouths, empty into the head of the harbor
from the northeast. The original available low-water depth from the
wharves to Cranes bar, one-third way down the harbor, was 9 feet;
thence to Fort Hale, halfway down, it was 16 feet or over. Below
Fort Hale was a broad bar of soft mud extending across the channel,
with available depth of 13 feet. The harbor entrance was partly
obstructed by several sunken rocks. In Quinnipiac River the avail-
able low-water depth was about 4 feet, and in the west branch of Mill
River about 5 feet to the head of the present projected improvement.
Above this point both rivers are for the most part available for
navigation only at high tide. The entire east branch of Mill River
ran nearly bare at low tide.
   In 1870 a project was adopted for removal of sunken rocks at the
harbor entrance. This work was not continued after 1875, when the
harbor breakwaters were first proposed. In 1871 the project was
extended to include deepening the harbor channel, the proposed depth
and width being modified from time to time as appropriations were
made until 1899, when the project provided for a channel 16 feet deep
and from 400 to 700 feet wide from Long Island Sound to the head
of the harbor and for a dike to contract the channel across Fort Hale
bar, at a total estimated cost from'beginning of $348,000. This
project was nearly completed, the deficiencies being in the length of
channel arm of the dike, which was about two-thirds the projected
length, and in the width of the channel across Fort Hale bar, which
was only 200 feet wide. The total amount expended on these projects
was $325,695.66.
   The project adopted by the act of March 3, 1899, provided for a
channel 20 feet deep, 400 feet wide, and 4 miles long from Long
Island Sound to Canal dock; thence of same depth, 300 feet wide,
one-half mile to Tomlinson Bridge; three anchorage basins below
Tomlinson bridge of 20, 16, and 12 feet depths; a channel up the
Quinnipiac River 200 feet wide and 12 feet deep to Grand avenue;
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     109
and a channel up the Mill River 12 feet deep and 200 feet wide to the
junction of the two branches above Chapel street, and thence 12 feet
deep and 75 feet wide up each branch to Grand avenue. The act of
March 3, 1899, making the first appropriation for this project, limited
it to the portion below Tomlinson Bridge, but the act of June 13, 1902,
authorized the extension to the part above Tomlinson Bridge, pro-
vided the cost should not exceed $345,000, the amount authorized by
the act of 1899. The above project, including the improvement of the
Quinnipiac and Mill rivers, except that part of the Quinnipiac River
between Ferry street and Grand avenue, was completed April 26,
1904, mainly under continuing contract, and a channel 8 feet deep and
50 feet wide dredged in the Quinnipiac River between Ferry street
and Grand avenue. The total appropriated for the project adopted
by the act of 1899, exclusive of maintenance, amounts to $280,073.90,
being less than the authorized cost of the project by $64,926.10.
   For reference to maps and further details regarding the harbor and
projects, see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1904, page 94.
   West River lies between the city of New Haven and the town of
West Haven. The head of navigation is at a railroad bridge about
one-half mile upstream from the Kimberly Avenue Bridge. About
500 yards below this drawbridge the river widens into a shallow bay
and joins New Haven Harbor south of Oyster or City Point. The
natural channel, about 2,000 yards long through the middle of the
bar, carried less than 3 feet at its shoalest part. A channel leading
from the harbor to docks at Oyster Point had a controlling depth of
4.5 feet, but between Oyster Point and the channel along the West
Haven docks was a wide flat nearly bare at low tide.
   The project adopted by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905,
for improvement of West River, provided for a 9-foot channel, 100
feet wide, from the downstream corner of the 16-foot anchorage
basin of New Haven Harbor, via Oyster Point and the dock frontage
of West Haven, to Kimberly Avenue Bridge, at a cost of $38,500, and
$500 for annual maintenance.
   The report of survey of West River is published at page 996 and
following, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1904, and the
survey map is printed in House Document No. 73, Fifty-eighth Con-
gress, second session.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, consolidated the im-
provement of West River with that of the main harbor, of which the
former is a branch.
   The amount expended on the existing project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $350,025.07, of which $38,318.86
was for maintenance. Of the amount reported expended on existing
project $38,500 was expended on West River prior to its consolidation
with the general project.
   The project of 1899 for the main harbor is about 80 per cent com-
pleted and the channel in West River contemplated by the project
of 1905 completed.
   The maximum draft which could be carried June 30, 1909, through
the main channel to Tomlinson bridge was 19 feet at mean low tide;
above Tomlinson bridge the maximum low-water draft which could
be carried up Mill River to Grand Avenue bridge was 12 feet in both
branches; up Quinnipiac River to Ferry Street Bridge 12 feet, and
from Ferry Street Bridge to Grant avenue a little more than 6 feet;
110           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

and up West River to Kimberly avenue 9 feet. The mean rise of tide
is 6.5 feet at entrance to the harbor and 6.6 feet at Tomlinson bridge.
   The work done has enabled deeper-draft vessels to use the harbor
than was formerly possible, with the resulting reduction of freight
rates due to the larger vessels and increased facilities for handling
freight made possible thereby.
   The commerce of New Haven harbor is mainly in coal, steamboat
freight, shellfish and shells, lumber, steel billets, and pig iron. The
reported tonnage for the calendar year 1908 was 1,921,123 tons,
valued at $98,233,543.22.
   The available balance and the appropriation asked for will be ap-
plied to maintenance and to continuing the approved project.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended... .......     -.........---- .......... ...                    $2, 083. 44
Amount allotted from emergency appropriation, river and harbor act
  approved March 2, 1907--                    . --..........
                                                   .....        ....        .                     3, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...........................................................                       20, 000. 00
                                                                                                 25, 083. 44
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ............ ... ........... ..............            --- ....
                                                          .............--                         5, 230. 27

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................                       ....... .........   19, 853. 17
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                            83. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                            19, 770. 17

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..--................                        10, 668. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                           64, 926. 10
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909.............................................  40, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix D 8.)
  9. Breakwaters at New Haven, Conn.-The original and existing
project for this work, authorized by act of March 3, 1879, and ap-
proved January 31, 1880, and modified by act of September 19, 1890,
in accordance with plans given in Annual Report of the Chief of En-
gineers, 1889, page 678, is to make a harbor of refuge at the entrance
to New Haven Harbor by constructing four breakwaters one 3,300
feet long, extending from Southwest ledge to Quixes ledge; one 5,000
feet long, extending from a point 1,000 feet north 54 ° east from Lud-
ington rock, in a direction south 54 ° west across the rock; one about
4,200 feet long, extending northwesterly from a point 6,000 feet south
540 west from Ludington rock, and one about 1,200 feet long, extend-
ing southwesterly from Morgan Point on the east side of the harbor
entrance-the cross section of all these breakwaters to be 12 feet wide
on top and 6 feet above mean high water, with outer slope 1 on 2
and inner slope 1 on 1. The estimated cost from the beginning, in
1880, was $2,151,134. The anchorage which will be sheltered by the
breakwaters exceeds 2,000 acres, of which over 500 acres has depths
of 20 to 28 feet, and the remainder is 9 to 20 feet deep. The mean
rise of tide is 6.5 feet.
   For original report on project, see Annual Report of Chief of En-
gineers, 1880, page 449 et seq., and for modification of project and
maps showing the location of the breakwaters as contemplated under
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       111

the existing project see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1889, page 678 et seq.; 1890, pages 624 and 625, and 1896, page 702.
   At the close of the fiscal year the breakwater from Southwest ledge
to Quixes ledge had been completed 3,450 feet long; 4,450 feet of the
Ludington rock breakwater had been built, but with steeper slopes
than called for by the project, and work was in progress on the west
breakwater, which had been extended a total distance of 2,850 feet,
of which the first 2,655 feet from the easterly end was very nearly
completed and the remainder was about 5 feet below low water.
The project is about 75 per cent completed.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $1,004,455.11, of
which $8,751.91 was for maintenance.
   The commerce now benefited and to be further benefited by this
work is mainly the passing commerce of Long Island Sound. The
projected breakwaters provide also an outer anchorage for vessels
bound to and from New Haven and help to protect the entrance to
New Haven Harbor proper from seas and to diminish channel filling.
For the calendar year 1908 some 5,630 vessels sought refuge behind
the breakwaters. The additional work proposed is for extension of
benefit to commerce.
   The available balance and the appropriation asked for will be
applied to continuing construction of the west breakwater and to
maintenance.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, authorized continuing
contracts for the prosecution of this work to the amount of $250,000,
all of which has now been appropriated; such a contract was entered
into June 11, 1907. Work under this contract was begun September
4, 1907, and was in progress at close of fiscal year.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................                     $170, 070. 45
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment...... ..................................................................           45, 525. 56

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..................................                       124, 544. 89
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...............................                      23, 008. 35

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                   101, 536.54

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............     81, 153. 61
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... 1, 030, 885. 91
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
    July 1, 1909---                                                     ........   --    100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
    (See Appendix D 9.)
  10. Milford Harbor, Connecticut.-This harbor is on the north
shore of Long Island Sound, and consists of a broad, open bay, from
the head of which a small tidal stream extends nearly a mile inland
to the head of navigation. The original depth on the bar in the bay
at the mouth of the river was less than 2 feet. In parts of the river
the channel ran nearly bare. The mean rise of tide is about 6.2 feet.
  The original project, adopted under the act of June 23, 1874, pro-
vided for a riprap breakwater 890 feet long from Welchs Point, on
the east side of the mouth of the harbor, protection of the bluffs
on the east shore from erosion by means of small stone jStties, a jetty
112      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

on the east side to maintain the river-bar channel, and dredging a chan-
nel 4 feet deep and 100 feet wide across the bar, the whole estimated
to cost $85,000. Thts project was modified in 1878 and 1879 to pro-
vide for extending the. 4-foot channel 60 feet wide upstream to the
town dock and for a training dike off Burns Point, on the west side of
the river channel, nearly at right angles to the east-side jetty. The
project thus modified was completed in 1880, except that the outer
breakwater was not built, being deemed unnecessary in view of the
provision of a harbor of refuge at New Haven. Under the act of
June 14, 1880, a project was adopted for the extension of the 4-foot
channel, 40 feet wide, upstream to the Straw Works wharf, and under
the act of August 2, 1882, a revised project was adopted which pro-
vided for a channel 8 feet deep and 100 feet wide across the bar and
upstream to Merwin's dock, at estimated cost of $11,000.
   In 1891 these projects were reported as completed and no further
work necessary, except maintenance of jetties and dredged channels.
It was stated in July, 1895, that as a result of private dredging there
was a clear channel across the bar 12 feet deep and nowhere less than
80 feet wide. On the previous projects $45,500, and for surveys
$1,600, were expended.
   For further details regarding former projects see Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1893, page 929, and for report on which
present project is based see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1900, page 1357 et seq. For map see House Document No. 280,
Fifty-sixth Congress, first session.
   The existing project, authorized by act of June 13, 1902, for com-
pletion at a cost of $15,000, consists in dredging and maintaining a
channel across the bar and through the lower harbor, 100 feet wide
and 10 feet deep, to Merwin's wharf, with an anchorage basin of same
depth of about 5 acres area on the east side of the channel between
the long dike and the harbor line, and a channel through the upper
harbor from Merwin's wharf to the Straw Works wharf, 90 feet wide
and 6 feet deep. The estimated cost for maintenance was $1,000
biennially. The first cost of the improvement was subsequently
ascertained to be $25,000. The amount expended on this project
to June 30, 1909, is $23,673.46, of which $23.84 was for maintenance.
   The 6-foot channel has been extended upstream to a point about
500 feet above the town dock, a portion of the anchorage basin, about
2 acres in area, adjacent to the 10-foot channel, dredged, and a basin,
1.6 acres in area, dredged on the opposite side of the channel opposite
Merwin's wharf. Owing to ledge rock it was impracticable to com-
plete this project within the estimate. The work done facilitates
navigation in the lower part of the harbor, and the extension of the
6-foot channel to the town dock renders it practicable to land cargoes
of coal at this dock, which it was formerly extremely difficult to do.
The development of the anchorage basins greatly relieves congestion
in the lower part of the harbor, due to the anchoring of small pleasure
craft and oyster schooners in that portion of the harbor.
   The available balance and the appropriation asked for will be
applied to maintenance of the improvement.
   On June 30, 1909, a low-water draft of 9 feet could be carried over
the bar and up as far as Merwin's wharf, thence 6 feet draft to a point
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                     113
about 500 feet above the town dock, and thence draft of about 21 feet
can be carried to the Straw Works dock. No navigation is practicable
above this dock.
  The commerce of this harbor consists almost entirely of oysters,
shells, coal, and fertilizer, the former predominating. The reported
tonnage for the calendar year 1908 amounted to 28,587 tons, valued
at $411,533.22.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended . ---------------------------------   ..........  $1, 329. 28
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement ..    .........   -          -.....-.............. .................       2. 74
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended . .............         ..............        ...   1, 326. 54
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.....................         ...                              2,000. 00
                                                               ------ -- --.................
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix D 10.)
   11. Housatonic River, Connecticut.-This is a rapid river running
southward through Massachusetts and Connecticut, emptying into
Long Island Sound east of Stratford Point, about 5 miles east from
Bridgeport Harbor. At Derby, 13 miles from its mouth, it receives
the discharge of the Naugatuck River. Derby and Shelton are at the
head of navigation. About a mile above there is a large power dam
across the Housatolic River; above the pool of this dam the river is
rocky and shoal.
   The original depth on the worst bars in the river (6 in number)
was from 3.5 to 4.5 feet. There was also a bar across the river mouth,
with about 4 feet depth.
   The original project for improvement, adopted under the act of
March 3, 1871, provided for a jetty at Sow and Pigs reef; removing
Drews rock; a breakwater at the mouth of the river, and making a
channel 7 feet deep, 200 feet wide through the bar at the mouth and
150 feet wide in the river, at total estimated cost of $404,9,1. In 1887
the estimates were revised, and a modification of the project proposed
a breakwater or jetty at the mouth of the river 5,750 feet long, ex-
tending about south-southeast from Milford Beach 3,250 feet; thence
parallel to and 500 feet from the channel 2,500 feet farther, to the
12-foot curve in Long Island Sound, the inner arm of the jetty to be
3 feet above mean low water, top width 6 feet, side slopes 1 on 1; the
outer arm to be 6 feet above high water, top width 12 feet, outer slope
1 on 2, inner slope I on 1; and a channel 7 feet deep, 200 feet wide at
the outer bar, and 100 feet wide through the river, at a total estimated
cost of $202,000, and $4,000 annually for maintenance, all in addition
to amount already expended. This modification was adopted under
the act of August 11, 1888, and work on the breakwater was begun
July 10, 1889. In 1893 the project was further modified to provide
for building a small dike in the river below Stratford.
   For maps see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1882,
page 616, and for reports on various surveys and projects see Annual
Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1871, page 781; 1887, Part 1,
page 607; 1888, Part 1, page 554.
       9001-ENG 1909-8
114          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                  S. ARMY.

   The present project for improvement is the project of 1871, subse-
quently enlarged or modified as above, and the estimated cost from
the beginning is $275,500.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $272,450 had been expended on this project,
of which $73,751.03 had been applied to maintenance. At that date
the project was completed, except that the dike below Stratford was
not built to the full projected length and the outer arm of the break-
water was only about 4 feet high above high water, 5 feet wide on
top, and the side slopes much steeper than called for by the project.
A channel of project dimensions had been dredged from the mouth of
the river to Derby, but had deteriorated from the action of spring
freshets and been redredged from time to time.
   On June 30, 1909, 7 feet draft at mean low water could be carried
across the outer bar and thence to Derby. The mean rise of tide at
Derby is 4.2 and at the mouth of the river about 6.3 feet. The work
done has enabled vessels to enter the lower river in safety instead of
waiting for high tide in an exposed situation outside. A large part
of the commerce could not have been carried on without the improved
channel. The navigable channel to Derby materially reduces freight
rates at that and adjacent towns, as otherwise all freight would have
to be handled by rail and with no competition.
   The commerce is largely in coal. A considerable quantity of oys-
ter shells is shipped from near the mouth of the river. The reported
tonnage for the calendar year 1908 was 77,895, valued at $378,980.52.
   The available balance and the appropriation asked for will be ap-
plied to redredging at the bar channels, where needed, and in continu-
ing work on the breakwater.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..---......----------............----------............--------$9, 976.78
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...------------......---------.....------------------............--..............--- 5, 000.00
                                                                                                  14, 976. 78
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement--------.......-----...................... $9, 501. 33
    For maintenance of improvement.......................                  475.45
                                                                                                   9, 976.78

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended---------........-----..------................-------..------..... 5, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..--------......------...........-----------.....------------1. 65
July 1, 1909, balance available...--------.................----------------------------            4, 998.35

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts-..    ...........-..                         4, 900. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--.-. .-.. -                        76, 325. 58
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909..-----------.......--------------------......................   45, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix D 11.)
   12. Bridgeport Harbor, Connecticut.-This consists of a shallow
bay, about 1 mile wide at the mouth and 12 miles long, into the ex-
treme northwest corner of which empties the Poquonock River, a
small tidal stream navigable for about 1 mile, and into the northeast
corner another small stream about three-fourths of a mile long, known
as Johnsons River. Midway between these two streams is Yellow
                 RIVER AND HARBOR     IMPROVEMENTS.                115
Mill pond, a tidal basin about 1 mile in length. Black Rock Harbor,
now considered part of Bridgeport Harbor, lies about 24 miles to the
westward. Both harbors are inner portions of a large bay of Long
Island Sound lying between the eastern part of Stratford Point and
Fairfield reef. Black Rock Harbor is about one-half mile wide at the
mouth and 1 mile long, with two branches at its head, the east one a
mile long, known as Cedar Creek, and the west one about three-fourths
of a mile long, known as Burr Creek.
   The original low-water depths were as follows: On the bar at the
mouth of Bridgeport Harbor, about 5 feet; in the Poquonock River,
from 2 to 5 feet; in Johnsons River, nearly bare in upper half; Yel-
low Mill pond, generally bare; in Cedar Creek, 2 to 4 feet; and in
Burr Creek, nearly bare.
   Congress appropriated $10,000 in 1836 and an equal amount in
1852 for improving the main Bridgeport Harbor. These sums were
expended in dredging near the mouth of the harbor, making channels
60 to 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep or more at low tide. The depth
did not prove permanent. In 1871 and at various times thereafter the
original project was enlarged to afford a 15-foot main-harbor channel,
a 12-foot channel 200 feet wide in Yellow Mill pond to Stratford
avenue, a 9-foot Poquonock River channel, a 12-foot anchorage, and
to protect the harbor entrance by two breakwaters, all estimated to
cost $285,000. This project was completed in 1898, except as to
capacity of the 15-foot channel.
   The amount expended on the projects above named was $317,848.50.
  At Black Rock Harbor, between 1836 and 1838, $21,550 was ex-
pended in building a sea wall across a breach in the southern part of
Fayerweather Island. In 1884 a project was adopted for protecting
the upper part of Black Rock Harbor by a breakwater about one-half
mile long between Fayerweather Island and the mainland and for
making a 6-foot channel 80 feet wide in Cedar Creek. The channel
had been made, the breakwater built to full length, but with reduced
cross section, and the project was considered as completed July 1,
1894. Subsequently repairs were made on the old sea wall on Fayer-
weather Island. The amount expended for Black Rock Harbor as a
separate improvement was $72,900.
   For details of original projects and their modifications see Annual
Reports of the Chief of Engineers, 1902, pages 133 and 134, and 1903,
pages 116 and 117.
   In the act of March 3, 1899, Congress adopted a project for Bridge-
port Harbor which provided, at an estimated cost of not exceeding
$300,000, for-
   First. The main channel, 18 feet deep, 300 feet wide from the outer
bar to the inner beacon, thence 200 feet wide to the lower or Stratford
Avenue Bridge across the Poquonock River.
   Second. Three anchorage basins: One 18 feet deep, 500 feet wide,
and 2,000 feet long adjoining the main channel on the west above
the inner beacon; one 12 feet deep, 500 feet wide, and 900 feet long
adjoining the main channel on the west between the 18-foot anchorage
and Naugatuck wharf, and one 12 feet deep at east side of channel
between the steel works point and the lower bridge.
   Third. Poquonock River channel, from the lower bridge to the
head of navigation, about 1 mile, 12 feet deep and 100 feet wide.
116     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

   Fourth. Yellow Mill channel, from the main channel to the head of
Yellow Mill pond, about 1 mile, 12 feet deep and 100 feet wide.
   Fifth. Johnsons River channel, from the main channel to the head
of navigation, about 11 miles, 9 feet deep and 100 feet wide.
   Sixth. Black Rock channel, from the head of Black Rock Harbor
to the junction of Cedar and Burr creeks, thence up each of these
creeks to the head of navigation, with lengths, respectively, of 1J
miles and one-half mile, 9 feet deep and 100 feet wide.
   Seventh. The repair and maintenance of the outer and inner break-
waters of the main channel, and the one connecting Fayerweather
Island with the mainland as now built, and the construction and
maintenance of shore protection on Fayerweather Island to check the
shifting of the beach.
   An appropriation of $50,000 was made in the act cited and a con-
tinuing contract authorized, under which work was begun July 9,
1900, and carried on, with many interruptions and delays, until Jan-
uary 1, 1906, at which time the contract was 61 per cent completed.
On account of the unsatisfactory progress this contract was annulled
May 10, 1906, and the work relet. Work under the new contract
was commenced July 25, 1906, and completed May 17, 1907, complet-
ing the project as authorized in 1899, except a section of Burr Creek,
the inner end of Yellow Mill channel, and the inner end of Johnsons
River, where, on account of ledge rock, the full project dimensions
of the channels were not obtained.
   The amount expended on this project to June 30, 1909, was
$233,912.50, of which $33,026.91 was applied to maintenance, making
the total expended on all projects prior to that now existing $624,661.
   The act of March 2, 1907, authorized the extension of the project to
include an anchorage basin 22 feet deep, 1,280,000 square feet in area
opposite the inner breakwater, deepening the main entrance channel
to 22 feet as far as the inner end of the 22-foot anchorage basin, an
additional 12-foot anchorage basin 608,600 square feet in area north-
west of the 22-foot basin, and two breakwaters for the protection of
the deep anchorage basin, at an estimated cost of $463,000. The
act appropriated $113,000, and authorized continuing contracts in
the additional sum of $350,000 for completing the work authorized.
Of this amount $210,000 is yet to be appropriated.
    Reports of examination and survey containing the enlarged project
are printed in House Documents Nos. 275 and 521, Fifty-ninth Con-
gress, second session.
    Contracts for the completion of the work authorized by the act
of March 2, 1907, have been made. The breakwaters and the 12-
foot anchorage basin have been completed and the deepening of the
main channel commenced.
    The amount expended on the project of 1907 to June 30, 1909,
was $131,067.78, of which $2,943.64 was applied to maintenance.
    The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1908, through
the improved channels at mean low tide is about 18 feet through the
main channel from the outer end to the lower bridge; in the Poquo-
nock River, about 11 feet; in the Yellow Mill channel, 12 feet; in
Johnsons River, 9 feet; at Black Rock, 9 feet to the head of naviga-
tion in both branches of Cedar Creek; in Burr Creek, about 7 feet
to its head. The mean rise of tide is 6.5 feet.
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                117
   The balance on hand and additional appropriations will be applied
to completing the project and to maintenance.
   The work done has greatly facilitated the navigation of the harbor
and made the present commerce possible and materially reduced
freight rates.
   The commerce of this harbor is chiefly in coal, lumber, iron, build-
ing material, petroleum products, oysters, and general merchandise.
Tonnage reported for calendar year 1908 was 890,895 tons, valued at
$37,572,196.20.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................................          $107, 108. 13
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......-..-----............................................   10, 000. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909..... 100, 000. 00

                                                                                217, 198. 13
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    Deposited with Treasurer of United States..............          $218.04
    For works of improvement...-...............          ........ 73, 493. 27
    For maintenance of improvement .....................           2, 943. 64
                                                                                 76, 654. 95

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................            140, 453.18
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................         11, 503. 01

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................       .............       128, 950. 17

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..............            107, 709. 62
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........          210, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
  expended July 1, 1909........................................20,                  000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix D 12.)
   13. Norwalk Harbor, Connecticut.--This harbor consists of the
tidal part of Norwalk River extending from Norwalk, the head of
navigation, to the river mouth, about 3 miles, and of an outer or main
harbor lying between Norwalk Islands and the mainland. South
Norwalk is on the west bank, about 12 miles below Norwalk. The
original depth in the river up to South Norwalk was about 5 feet;
between there and Norwalk the river bed was nearly bare at low tide.
   The sum of $80 was expended in the year 1829 in making a survey
of the harbor in accordance with the act of Congress approved March
2 of that year.
   The original project, adopted under the act of June 10, 1872, and
modified by the terms of the act of June 14, 1880, provided for a chan-
nel 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep from the outer harbor to South Nor-
walk, and thence 6 feet deep to Norwalk. This project was considered
completed in 1892 at a cost of $83,000, although portions of the chan-
nel between Norwalk and South Norwalk were only 60 feet wide.
The act of August 18, 1894, appropriated $15,000 for improving the
inner harbor, and indicated the points where work was to be done.
In accordance therewith a project was adopted for removing to 6 feet
depth the shoal at Ferrys Point, below Norwalk, and, if funds per-
mitted, for widening with depth of 9 feet the bend at Keysers Island,
118            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U. S. ARMY.

near the river mouth. This project was completed in 1897 at a cost
of $15,000. A project adopted by the act of June 3, 1896, provided
for a channel 10 feet deep and 150 feet wide from the outer harbor to
South Norwalk, widening two points near the entrance, and the
maintenance of this channel and the 6-foot channel between South
Norwalk and Norwalk, at estimated first cost of $62,000, and $2,000
annually for maintenance. This project was completed October 3,
1905; the amount expended on it was $36,833, of which $15,516.89
was expended for maintenance.
   The present project, adopted by the act of March 2, 1907, provides
for the restoration of the channel 10 feet deep and 150 feet wide to
South Norwalk, for a channel 8 feet deep of a general width of 100
feet from South Norwalk to Norwalk, and for a channel 6 feet deep,
2,900 feet long, of a general width of 75 feet, to the docks at East
Norwalk, and for maintenance of these channels, at an estimated first
cost of $65,500, and $8,000 per annum for maintenance.
   Channels of the full dimensions called for by this project were com-
pleted September 19, 1908. The amount expended on this project
to June 30, 1909, was $52,963.43, of which $8,858.41 was expended
for maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried at low water June 30,
1909, to the South Norwalk docks was 10 feet, to the Norwalk docks
8 feet, and to the East Norwalk docks 6 feet. The mean rise of tide
is 7.1 feet.
   For reference to reports and maps regarding this harbor and
former projects, see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1904, page 103. For present project, see House Document No. 262,
Fifty-ninth Congress, second session.
   The available balance and the appropriation asked for will be
applied to maintenance of the improvements.
   The commerce of this harbor is mainly in coal, oysters, lumber,
wood pulp, building material, and general merchandise, and on all
these items the improvement has effected a material reduction in
freight rates. The reported tonnage for calendar year 1908 amounted
to 199,465 tons, valued at $19,359,751.28.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.. ....---                                                                    $36, 268. 99
                                                                                                   ..... ....-............
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
      For works of improvement......   .....................                           .. $25, 236.09
      For maintenance of improvement ........................                                  496. 33
                                                                                                               25, 732. 42
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended                         -...-....................    ...........              10, 536.57
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.....--------..............--------------..------------............            21.52

July 1, 1909, balance available-............                     ...............          .........        .   10, 515.05
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   191.1, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..................    .............................                                       8,000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix D 13.)
    14. Harbors at Fivemile River, Stamford, Southport, Greenwich,
and Westport, and Saugatuclc River, Connecticut.-(a) Fivemile
River Harbor.-This is a tidal inlet about 1 mile long and from 100
to 1,000 feet wide. The natural low-water depth at the mouth was
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             119

about 3 feet, shoaling to zero about halfway up the harbor and to
about plus 2.5 feet at extreme head. The original and present proje:t
of improvement, adopted under authority of the act of August 11,
1888, provides for a dredged channel 8 feet deep and 100 feet wide,
extending up the harbor about 6,000 feet from its mouth. The esti-
mated cost from the beginning, as revised in 1894, was $45,000.
   For further details regarding this harbor, see page 192, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1901.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $39,790.44 had been expended on this project,
of which $4,300 had been for maintenance. At that date a channel
of project dimensions had been dredged about 5,400 feet up the har-
bor and thence about 200 feet farther with project depth and widths
of 25 to 75 feet. No dredging has been done above this point. About
82 per cent of the project is completed.
   The maximum draft that could be carried to the upper end of the
improved channel is 7 feet, and no navigation is possible beyond
this point except at high tide, when a draft of from 4 to 4- feet ca,n
be carried about 1,400 feet farther to the head of navigation. The
mean rise of tide is 7.2 feet.
   The future appropriations will be applied toward maintenance and
completion of the project by widening the channel to project dimen-
sions and extending it upstream as funds permit.
   The commerce of this harbor is mainly confined to the oyster in-
dustry, which could not be carried on to its present extent without
the improved channel. Traffic reported for calendar year 1908
amounted to 21,986 tons, valued at $353,009.50.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended_.....-......                   ..........            .......... _ $210.06
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ..........-------------...........-------------....----.                 $0.50
    Amount transferred to Stamford Harbor................. ... 209. 56
                                                                                                    210. 06

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.....--               ...... . 9, 300. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance.................                            (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Starmfbrd Iarbor.-This consists of a bay on the north shore
of Long Island Sound and of two tidal inlets known as the east and
west branches, extending to the head of navigation at the city of
Stamford. The original depth in the west branch was from 1 foot
to 3 feet, gradually increasing in the bay to a depth of 12 feet. The
east branch was originally a small marshy creek, deepened by private
dredging to a depth of about 8 feet and which had shoaled so that
when work was begun by the Government in 1892 the available depth
was only about 6 feet.
   The original project, adopted under authority of the river and
harbor act of 1886, was for a 5-foot channel 80 feet wide to the head
of the west branch. This was considered completed in 1892 after an
expenditure of $20,000, the channel being 5 feet deep and 100 to 140
feet wide at the bends, but only from 50 to 70 feet wide for the last
thousand feet at the upper end.
                      a See consolidated money statement on page 123.
120            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                           U.     S. ARMY.

   The present project, adopted under authority of the act of July 13,
1892, provides for a channel in the west branch 7 feet deep, 150 feet
wide, and about 1- miles long, with a basin of same depth between
harbor lines at the head of the harbor, and in the east branch, as
approved October 5, 1892, a channel 9 feet deep and 100 feet wide
for a length of about 8,535 feet and 50 feet wide for about 1,200 feet
farther to the head of the harbor. The estimated cost was $123,500.
A modification to give increased width at upper end of east branch
was approved February 12, 1901.
   For reports on surveys and projects, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers, 1884, Part 1, page 672; 1891, Part 1, page 849;
1893, page 954 (map, p. 956).
   Up to June 30, 1909, $128,260.53 had been expended on this project,
of which $32,511 had been for maintenance. At that date the channel
in the east branch had been completed to full project dimensions; the
channel in the west branch had been dredged to project dimensions
from its outer end to the south end of the basin; a portion of the
south end of the basin completed and a channel with a general width
of 125 feet dredged along both sides and across the upper end of the
basin. The available depth which could be carried June 30, 1909,
to the extreme head of the west branch was 7 feet and 9 feet through
the east branch channel to its head. The mean rise of tide is 7.4 feet.
   The appropriation asked for will be applied toward maintenance
and completion of the project.
   The commerce of this harbor consists mainly of coal, lumber, stone,
sand, clay, ores, and steamboat freight. The reported tonnage for
calendar year 1908 amounted to 343,810 tons, valued at $10,439,840.34.
The improvements made have rendered it possible for the steamers to
run on schedule time and to enter the harbor at any stage of the tide,
which they were unable to do previously, and have materially reduced
freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................               $12, 087. 01
Amount transferred from Fivemile (River Harbor) .-...- -----. $209. 56
Amount transferred from Greenwich Harbor----.....-- - -..-------.........-- 939.97
                                                                                     1, 149.53
                                                                                                                   13, 236. 54
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment----------..........---------......----....-------..... ------........-----.......-----........--------...   13, 236.54

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .........                                           28, 900. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance.................(a)
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Southport Harbor.-This is a tidal part of Mill River at town
of Southport, about 1 mile long and averaging less than 100 yards
wide. The original depth was probably less than 2 feet at the en-
trance to the harbor, shoaling to about plus 1 foot at the upper end.
Work was begun in this harbor by the Government in 1829 and pros-
ecuted with various intermissions until 1878. During this time a
dike inside and breakwater or jetty outside were built, and a channel
60 feet wide and 4 feet deep dredged across the outer bar. In 1878 a
                           a See consolidated money statement on page 123.
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                 121

project was adopted for dredging a channel 100 feet wide and 4 feet
deep across the bar and upstream 1,200 feet from the outer end of
the jetty, and thence in a bifurcated channel to the nearest docks.
In 1882 this project was reported as substantially completed,
$31,587.23 having been spent since the beginning of work in 1829.
   The present project, adopted by act of June 13, 1902, is to dredge
a channel 6 feet deep through the outer bar to the upper docks 100
feet wide to the turn above White Rock, and thence in two branches,
each 60 feet wide; to repair the breakwater and to remove two points
of ledge from the channel to a depth of 7 feet. The original esti-
mated first cost of this improvement was $13,200, and for yearly main-
tenance $300, to be expended biennially, but on account of the devel-
opment of two additional outcroppings of ledge during the dredging
it became evident that this estimate would be greatly exceeded before
the work could be completed, and in 1906 the estimated cost was in-
creased to $15,111 for this work.
   For further details regarding this harbor and its former projects,
see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1897, page 986.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $20,348.51 had been expended on this project,
of which $1,677.53 had been for maintenance. At that date a channel
of project depth and 75 to 100 feet width had been dredged to the
turn above White Rock, and thence with full depth and widths of 40
to 60 feet up the east branch and along the dock front for about 200
feet; two points of ledge rock had been removed, and the breakwater
repaired. About 65 per cent of the project is completed.
   The maximum draft that can be carried through the improved por-
tion of the channel is 6 feet. Above this point, where no dredging
has been done, a draft of 3 to 42 feet can be carried to the upper docks
at low tide. Above the upper end of the projected channels the har-
bor is navigable only at high tide and for a distance of about half a
mile. The mean rise of tide is 6.6 feet.
    The improved channel permits vessels of not exceeding 6 feet draft
to enter the harbor without being compelled to wait outside the bar
in an exposed situation for the tide to rise.
    The appropriation asked for will be applied toward maintenance
and completing the project.
    The commerce of this harbor consists mainly of farm produce, gen-
eral merchandise, oysters, and coal. The reported tonnage for cal-
endar year 1908 amounted to 6,821, valued at $66,060.
    The effect of the improvement on freight rates, if any, is not known.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended........................   ...............   $1, 942. 09
Amount transferred from Greenwich Harbor .............................          459. 51
                                                                              2, 401. 60
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.. ............... ........ ..... $2, 100. 50
    For maintenance of improvement........--.................     301. 10
                                                                              2, 401. 60

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 13, 111. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance...............             (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                    a See consolidated money statement on page 123.
122            REPORT OF TIHE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                   U.   S. ARMY.


   (d) Greenwich Harbor.-This is a shallow bay about 2 miles
east from the New York state line, extending about a mile north-
ward from Long Island Sound. The original low-water depth was
about 6 feet to the lower docks. Above this point it shoaled rap-
idly to 3 feet 1,000 feet above and to about plus 2 at the head of the
harbor. The original and present project, adopted in the act of
June 3, 1896, is to dredge a channel 90 feet wide from the mouth of
the harbor to the causeway at its head, a distance of about a,mile, to
be 9 feet deep to the steamboat dock and 6 feet deep above, the upper
end to be enlarged to form a turning basin. The estimated first
cost was $20,000. Page 860, Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers, 1895, gives report of examination upon which the project is
based. Up to June 30, 1909, $21,090.60 had been expended on this
project, of which $4,073.41 had been for maintenance.
   This project was completed September 23, 1905. The work done
has. enabled vessels to enter the harbor with 9 feet draft at low tide,
thus permitting the regular steamer to make trips without waiting
for tide. Above the steamboat dock a draft of 6 feet can be carried
at low tide to the head of navigation. The mean rise of tide is 7.5
feet.
   Map of survey made in June, 1908, with reference to need of main-
tenance and the location and identification of harbor lines was com-
pleted during the fiscal year.
   The appropriation asked for will be applied to maintenance of the
improvement.
   The commerce of this harbor consists mainly of coal, lumber, build-
ing material, and general merchandise. The reported tonnage for
calendar year 1908 amounted to 76,160, valued at $9,778,000.
   The effect of the improvement on freight rates, if any, is not
known.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...------...-----................----------------------..........         2, 188. 82
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for main-
  tenance of improvement---------------........-------....---................                 $512.42
Amount transferred to-
   Stamford Harbor------------------------...........................----.....   $939. 97
  Southport Harbor--..------.......--------.......------.....------.....          459. 51
  Westport Harbor------------................----------.......-----......--.      270. 99
                                                                                             1, 670. 47
                                                                                                          2, 182. 89
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended--------...............                                          -------    5. 93
                                                                                            .-----------------------....
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...--------------------------------------------                                        (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (e) Westport Harbor and Saugatuck River, Connecticut.-For de-
scription of these localities and statement of work under original
project of 1826, and its modifications to about 1871, see Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1901, page 189. The total amount
expended for the same is $19,444.
   The present project, adopted in 1892, originally provided for a
channel 4 feet deep and 60 feet wide up to Westport, at an estimated
cost of $10,000.
                         a See consolidated money statement on page 123.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                        123
   As a result of a survey authorized by the act of August 18, 1894,
the project was modified in 1896 to provide for repairing the Cedar
Point breakwater, removing a ledge opposite Stony Point, or dlredg-
ing around it, and removing bowlders from the channel, at an esti-
mated cost of $8,000, and the total estimated cost was in consequence
increased to $18,000.
   A sketch of this river and harbor is printed in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1894, page 670, and report of the sur-
vey authorized in 1894 is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1896 and, with map, in House Document No. 67,
Fifty-fourth Congress, first session.
   The total amount expended on the present project up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $15,270.99, of which
$109.44 was for maintenance. The 4-foot channel had been completed
to Westport, head of navigation, with width generally of 60 feet, the
ledge opposite Stony Point removed, and the Cedar Point breakwater
repaired and extended. About 70 per cent of the project is com-
pleted. The mean rise of tide is about 7 feet.
   Completion of the project requires further removal of bowlders
and dredging to full project dimensions at the channel opposite West-
port. Improvements made have rendered navigation of the river
practicable at less than half-tide stages by vessels plying there.
   Future appropriations will be applied to maintenance and the com-
pletion of the project.
   The commerce comprises coal, lumber, farm produce, and steam-
boat freight. The reported tonnage for calendar year 1908 was
11,504, valued at $43,655.
   The effect of the improvement on freight rates, if any, is not known.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................... ........
                                                            ........$1,849. 22
Amount transferred from Greenwich Harbor..............             .   . -.    ....       270. 99
                                                                                       2, 120. 21
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement............................. $2, 107. 69
    For maintenance of improvement--------....-----.............-----------. 12. 52
                                                                                       2, 120. 21
Amount (estimated) required for completion of exising project..........                3,000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance ...............                    (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of.sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                       CONSOLIDATED.

                                           .
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...........-   ...........-....... $18, 277. 20
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement. ........................... $17, 445. 23
    For maintenance of improvement .........-..............    826. 04
                                                                                      18, 271. 27
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended--           ---..............
                                                   .   ...-.....-             ...           5.93
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........               54, 311. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...........                                         48, 411.. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix D 14.)
                   a See consolidated money statement on this page.
124      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S. ARMY.

   15. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangeringnavi-
gation- Wreck of Schooner Menawa.-This vessel, loaded with lath,
was in collision on July 18, 1908, with U. S. S. Mayflower and seriously
damaged. On July 27 the schooner was towed into New Haven har-
bor by the U. S. tug Apachee and left in a position dangerous to navi-
gation. Circular proposals were issued for the removal of the wreck,
the bid of Reed & Farrar, $376, accepted. A portion of the cargo
was recovered and the removal of the wreck completed in October,
1908.
    Wreck of lighter, name unkcnown.-This vessel, originally a wooden
sloop about 70 feet long, was abandoned about six years ago and
left on the mud flats on the west bank of the Poquonock River,
Bridgeport Harbor. The hulk gradually slid out to a point where it
became an obstruction to navigation. Proposals for the removal of
the wreck were issued in April, 1909, the bid of the T. A. Scott Com-
pany (Incorporated), $290, accepted, and the wreck entirely removed
in May, 1909.
    (See Appendix D 15.)
IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE FIRST NEW YORK,
                   NEW YORK, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Col. John G. D. Knight, Corps of
Engineers, to January 15, 1909, in the temporary charge of Col.
D. W. Lockwood, Corps of Engineers, from January 15 to February
19, 1909, and in the charge of Col. W. M. Black, Corps of Engineers,
since the latter date. Division engineer, Col. John G. D. Knight,
Corps of Engineers.
   1. Port Chester Harbor, New York.-This harbor, situated at the
boundary between the States of New York and Connecticut, consists
of the tidal part of Byram River and of a bay at its mouth opening
into Long Island Sound. The depth in the river before improvement
was 1 foot, and Salt rock, in the river, and Sunken rock, in the bay,
were considered to be dangerous obstructions.
   The original project for this improvement was adopted in 1872 and
modified in 1884 and 1888. It proposed to remove Salt rock to 9 feet
below mean low water, to build a breakwater from Sunken rock to
Byram Point, and to dredge and maintain a channel to the Port
Chester wharves, at a total cost of $57,000. Up to 1899, at a total
cost of $52,000, this project had been completed, except the dredging
in the upper harbor.
   The existing project, approved March 3, 1899, provides for a chan-
nel 12 feet deep at mean low water and 70 feet wide from deep water
in the bay up to the town wharf, at Fox Island, and thence 9 feet
deep and 60 feet wide to the steamboat wharf, the work to be done by
dredging and rock removal. Estimated cost, $25,000. By act of
1907 the project was extended to include removal of ledges of rock
opposite the southerly point of Fox Island.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $34,348.95 had been expended on the present
project; of this amount $11,348.95 was for maintenance. There was
received from sale of maps $0.75.
   Expenditures during the year were for surveys and office expenses.
   About 92 per cent of the work proposed under the present project
has been completed and has resulted in making a channel of the
projected width and depth, except at and above Fox Island, where
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                            125

the width is reduced by ledges of rock the removal of which it is
estimated will cost $15,750. A project for the further improvement of
the harbor is printed in House Document No. 1165, Sixtieth Con-
gress, second session. Should this project be adopted, the removal of
these ledges under the present project will be unnecessary. Conse-
quently no fiscal year estimate is submitted for continuing work on the
existing project, pending action by Congress on the new plan of
improvement now before it for consideration.
  The dredged channel has shoaled to a considerable extent.
  The available funds and the additional appropriation recommended
are to be applied to maintenance.
  The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water is estimated at 10 feet up to the town wharf; thence 51
feet to the steamboat wharf, and above the steamboat wharf 2 feet.
Mean range of tides 7.4 feet. The head of navigation is at a fixed
bridge at Mill street, about 900 feet above the steamboat dock. The
total length of navigable channel from Long Island Sound to the
bridge is about 12 miles.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this harbor, mainly in
coal, building materials, manufactured goods, and farm produce, as
obtained from the best available information, are as follows:

           Year.                Tons.        Value.                    Year.        Tons.       Value.


1898.....................   140,000       $4,936,000    1904.....................   255,000     $4,590,000
1899 ...................... 169,500        6,256,000    1905.....................   293,000      7,365,000
1900......................  181,000        7,269,500    1906.....................   265,000      6,870,000
1901......................  327,500        9,118.000    1907.....................   275,000      7,405,000
1902....................... 237,000           900,000(?)1908.....................   265,000      7,355,000
1903....................... 240,000        3,940,000


   The commerce of this harbor has increased with the improvement.
So far as has been ascertained, the improvement of this harbor has
brought about a reduction in freight rates.
   Detailed description of this improvement is printed in Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 1084, and 1900, page 1378.
Sketches of the river and harbor are printed in Reports of the Chief
of Engineers for 1885, page 658, and for 1889, page 716.
   Report upon examination and survey of Port Chester Harbor,
made in 1907-1908, and map of the locality are printed in House
Document No. 1165, Sixtieth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                          $5, 611.82
Received from sales ...................................................                               . 75
                                                                                                5, 612. 57
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of im-
  provement.....................................              ......... ....                      460.77
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                          5, 151.80
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.........................                  ............        28.00
July 1, 1909, balance available.....................................                            5, 123. 80
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                       15, 750. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.............................................        10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix E 1.)
126          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                               U.   S. ARMY.

   2. Mamaroneck Harbor, New York.-This harbor, situated on the
north shore of Long Island Sound, consists of a narrow inlet opening
into a shallow broad bay. Before improvement, the channel to the
old steamboat wharf, half a mile up the inlet, had a depth of 5 feet
at mean low water, gradually decreasing to 1 foot at the upper
wharves. Various rocks at or near the mouth of the inlet obstructed
navigation.
   The present project, approved August 2, 1882, and modified April
27, 1899, provides for the removal of Round rock to a depth of 4 feet
and Bush rock and Inner Steamboat rock to a depth of 7 feet at
mean low water, and for making a channel 7 feet deep at mean low
water and 100 feet wide from the harbor entrance to the upper
wharves. Estimated cost, $43,000.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $40,000 had been expended on this work; of
this amount $4,628.50 was for maintenance.
   About 82 per cent of the work proposed under the project has been
completed, and has resulted in making a channel with a uniform depth
of 7 feet at mean low water and a width of from 70 to 100 feet from
the harbor entrance to the turn at Hog Island, and thence 100 feet
wide to the upper wharves. The channel has probably deteriorated
to a considerable extent.
   The appropriation recommended is to be applied toward complet-
ing the improvement and to maintenance.
  The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1908, at mean
low water is probably less than 7 feet. Mean range of tides, 8 feet.
The head of navigation is at a fixed bridge just above the upper
wharves. The total length of navigable channel from Long Island
Sound is about 1 mile.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this harbor, mainly in
coal, building materials, and manufactured goods, as obtained from
the best available information, are as follows:

            Year.                Tons.      Value.                  Year.                Tons.      Value.

                       29,0958482,092 1904....... ...............
1896.........................                                                            49,589$859,242
                           51,673
1897.........................              877,180      1905.......................54,944           201,398(?)
1901 ........................ 20,705  51,59s(?) 1906--....................------------------- 15,756 131,000
1902 ........................ 48,495  75,000(?) 1908...--..-               .......  ........  38,540 1,020,225
1903......................... 26,230 337,000


   It is not known that freight rates have been affected by this im-
provement, but it has facilitated the transportation, especially of coal
and building materials.
   Detailed description of this improvement can be found in Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 1381. Sketch of harbor is
printed in Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1903, page 859.
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... $7, 628. 50
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance ................                             6,500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix E 2.)
                                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                 127
   3. Larchmont Harbor, New York.-This harbor, situated on the
northwest shore of Long Island Sound, 4 miles distant from New
York City limits, is about half a mile wide and five-eighths of a mile
long. It is exposed to easterly and southerly storms. Two sub-
merged rocks (Umbrella rock and Huron rock) formerly obstructed
the entrance, which has a depth of 18 feet, gradually dimishing toward
the head of the bay.
   The original project for this improvement, adopted September 19,
1890, provided for building two breakwaters to protect the anchorage
ground, one to extend from Umbrella rock to Umbrella Point and
the other from Huron rock to Long Beach Point, at an estimated
cost of $105,000. Work under this project was suspended in 1891
after the first appropriation of $5,000 had been expended in com-
mencing the two breakwaters.
   The present project, adopted March 3, 1899, provides for building
a breakwater extending southwardly 1,440 feet from the 6-foot curve
off Long Beach Point and for the removal of Huron rock to a depth
of 14 feet at mean low water. Estimated cost, $108,000. The project
was extended by act of 1907 to include removal of ledges adjoining
Huron rock.
   To June 30, 1909, $65,666.16 had been expended on the existing
project, all for improvement.
   There were no operations during the year, the disbursements hav-
ing been in part payment of office expenses and of the cost of a sound-
ing, boring, and sweeping scow.
   About 60 per cent of the work proposed under the present project
has been completed, and as a result the breakwater has been built to
full projected section to a length of 1,410 feet, and Huron rock and a
portion of the adjoining ledge removed to depths of 14 and 12 feet,
respectively.
   The available funds are sufficient for completing the improvement
and will be applied to this purpose and for maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, over the
shoalest part of the entrance channel at mean low water is estimated
at 18 feet. The general depth of the anchorage area of the harbor
is from 6 to 12 feet at mean low water. Mean range of tides, 7.4 feet.
The harbor is about half a mile wide and extends rather more than
half a mile inland. It is a basin with no definite channel.
   The harbor has but little commerce. It is mainly used by the
Larchmont Yacht Club, by coasting and fishing vessels for night
anchorage, and as a harbor of refuge.
   Local freight rates are thought not to have been affected by the
improvement.
   Detailed description of this improvement is printed in Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 1383. A sketch of the harbor
is printed in Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1903, page 860.
                                                                                        ------- $21, 377. 02
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.-----...........................---------------------....
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment....---------......----..............--------------.................----------------......-----------...........    1, 138. 14

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended----------------------..........                              .......------------.....   20, 238. 88
    (See Appendix E 3.)
  4. Harbor at Echo Bay, New York.-This harbor is on the north
shore of Long Island Sound, 2 miles distant from New York City
128           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                   S. ARMY.


limits. It is landlocked, except toward the southeast, and has a good
anchorage. Nearly all of the water transportation of the town of
New Rochelle is carried on through this harbor.
   The original project for improvement, adopted in 1875, provided
for the removal of two ledges, known as Start rock and Sheepshead
reef, to 7 and 9 feet depth at mean low water, respectively, at an esti-
mated cost of $38,955.38.
   Prior to 1902 the sum of $22,000 had been appropriated, with which
Start rock was reported wholly and Sheepshead reef partly removed
to the projected depths, and a channel 40 feet wide and 4 feet deep at
mean low water was dredged from Beauford Point to within 300 feet
of the head of the harbor.
   The project adopted by the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902,
contemplated the completion of the original plan by the removal of
the remainder of Sheepshead reef and Start rock, at an estimated cost
of $17,000. This work was completed September 25, 1903, at a total
cost of $8,546.68.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, directed an examination
to be made of Long rock, with a view to its removal, and authorized
the expenditure of any balance remaining from previous appropria-
tions for this purpose. The removal of such part of the rock to 6
feet below mean low water as the available funds ($8,453.32) would
permit was authorized by the Secretary of War August 21, 1906. Of
this amount $8,412.92 was expended to June 30, 1908, leaving a bal-
ance of $40.40 in addition to the amount appropriated March 2, 1907.
As a result of this expenditure the channel at Beauford Point (Hud-
son Park) was deepened to 6 feet at mean low water with a width of
100 feet.
   The present project, adopted March 2, 1907, provides for complet-
ing the removal of Long rock, at a total estimated cost of $10,000.
Up to June 30, 1909, $8,409.40 had been expended, completing
the project, and resulting in the removal of an obstruction which had
caused considerable damage to vessels using the channel at Beauford
Point.
   The available funds are to be applied to maintenance if found
necessary.
   The maximum draft that could be carried to Beauford Point on
June 30, 1909, is estimated at 6 feet at mean low water. The general
harbor anchorage ranges from 9 to 18 feet at mean low water. The
                                                  -
mean range of tide is about 7 feet. The head of navigation is at a
wharf about 1,500 feet above Beauford Point. The harbor is about
one-fourth mile wide and one-third mile long. The total length of
navigable channel extending beyond the deep water of the harbor is
about one-fifth of a mile.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this harbor, mainly in
coal, building materials, and manufactured goods, as obtained from
the best available information, are as follows:

             Year.                   Tons.     Value.                  Year.             Tons.     Value.

1902.----...........   .........      99,000    $500,000                               270,460
                                                             1906........................          $2,789, 208
1903. -----.....       ....    ...   129,400   1, 434, 000   1907.............  .. . 269,135        2, 545, 535
1904-.... ..-.........--      .- .   151,200   1,647,500     1908............. .......   244,750    2,092,500
1905....-..---......--.--      ..    193,650   2,071,800
                              RIVER AND             HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 129
  Commerce has been materially benefited and freight rates have
probably been reduced by this improvement.
  For detailed description of work see Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1900, page 1429. A sketch of the locality is printed in
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1903, page 862.
  Report upon examination and survey of Echo Bay Harbor, and
map of the locality are printed in House Document No. 1118, Sixtieth
Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended                          -----...........------........---------------............. $12, 040. 40
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment....--.---.----------..........--..........----------------..............---------....--------............       8, 409.40

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...............                               ...........        .......          3, 631. 00
    (See Appendix E 4.)
  5. Bronx River and East Chester Creek, New York.-(a) Bronx
River.-This stream empties into a shallow bay three-fourths of a
mile long, and seven-eighths of a mile wide, having a navigable chan-
nel with low water depth of 3 feet, and which opens into the East
River north of Hunts Point. The navigable part extends from its
mouth to West Farms, a length of about 24 miles. At this point it is
crossed by a dam. The natural depth at the mouth was 4 feet at
mean low water, and decreased ascending the stream to less than 1
foot at the head of navigation.
  The project for improvement, adopted by the act of June 3, 1896,
provides for making a channel 4 feet deep at mean low water and
100 feet wide from the mouth to Barlow street (now Falconer street);
thence to Dongan street (now Garrison avenue) 60 feet wide, and
thence to the head of navigation 50 feet wide, the work to be done
by dredging and rock removal. Estimated cost $85,985.
  Up to June 30, 1909, $67,437.03 had been expended on the project
for improvement. There was received from sales of maps $0.65.
  About 80 per cent of the work proposed under the present project
has been completed and has resulted in a channel from the mouth to
the turn east of the gas works with depths of from 3 to 6 feet at mean
low water and with a diminishing width of from 100 to 50 feet, except
at Westchester avenue where slightly reduced by a ledge of rock.
Above this point the channel remains as previously reported. As
shown by a recent survey, the dredged channel has deteriorated to a
considerable extent.
   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended
are to be applied to continuing the improvement and to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, over the
shoalest part of the channel at mean low water from the mouth to the
turn east of the gas works is about 21 feet; above this point, 1 foot.
Mean range of tide is 6.6 feet at mouth and 6 feet at West Farms.
The head of navigation is at a dam just beyond the dye works. The
total length of navigable channel is about 3 miles.
          9001-ENG 1909--9
130            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                S. ARMY.

   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this river, mainly in
coal, cotton goods, drugs for dying purposes, ice, and building mate-
rials, as obtained from the best available information, are as follows:

             Year.                  Tons.        Value.                          Year.                        Tons.          Value.

1897........................ 139,310              $526, 025                             181,093
                                                              1905........................                                    $820,482
1899 ........................         171,300    1,985,700    1906............... ..... 341,538                              1,720,097
1902 ..............           ......
                                 .... 153, 137     500,0001907........................ 382,957 1,807,317
1903.....................              77,710     536,400     1908.......................                     401,433        2,017,500
1904 ........................        42,286        196,642


  The river has an extensive and growing commerce as shown above.
This commerce is mainly carried on barges of from 20 to 35 feet width,
towed by tugs. Just complaint is made of the interruptions and
delays to traffic owing to the impossibility of tows passing each other
in the narrow channel and at points of even passing a barge moored
to a wharf. Due to the slight depth found, all movement of vessels
must be made at high-water stages.
  Details of improvement can be found in Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1897, page 1093, and for 1900, page 1389. A sketch
of a part of the stream is printed in Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1904, page 1016.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............................                 $41, 548. 63
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment........................................................................ 29, 485. 01

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........................                                          .......                12, 063. 62
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities................................                                                 ..       172. 77

July 1, 1909, balance available ..............                      ....                    .................              11, 890. 85

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ....                                      .......            6, 485. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909. ..........          ............  .                                                       (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) East Chester Creek.-This is a small tidal stream emptying
into East Chester Bay. It was originally navigable at high tide for
vessels drawing 7 feet as far as Lockwoods, a distance of 2-4 miles.
   The project for improvement, adopted March 3, 1873, provided
for a channel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep, mean high water, from
deep water in East Chester Bay to a point 3,000 feet above Lock-
woods. Estimated cost, $136,500; subsequently reduced to $124,000,
as modified in 1891.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $115,500 had been expended on the project;
of this amount $25,408.78 was for maintenance. There was received
from the sale of maps $2.
   The project has been completed and has resulted in making a
channel 9 feet deep at mean high water and 100 feet wide from
East Chester Bay to Town dock; thence to Lockwoods somewhat
less than 100 feet wide; and thence to a point 3,000 feet above
Lockwoods, 100 feet wide. The channel above Lockwoods had
                         a See consolidated money statement on page 131.
                                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           131
deteriorated to such extent that the expenditure under the last
appropriation resulted in restoring only about 75 feet in width in
this section of the creek to its projected depth. Considerable shoaling
has also occurred in the channel below Lockwoods.
   The appropriation recommended is to be applied to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried over the shoalest part
of the channel on June 30, 1909, is estimated at 9 feet at mean high
water in mid-channel. Mean range of tides is 7.1 feet. The head
of navigation is at the upper end of the artificial channel. The total
length of navigable channel is about 21 miles.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this creek, mainly in
coal, building material, and miscellaneous freight, as obtained from
the best available information, are as follows:
                  Year.                      Tons.       Value.                     Year.                        Tons.        Value.

1895..........                 ...........    94,928    $2,199,186   1905......            ................      206,275     $1,755,850
1899 .......                 .............   286, 428    1,957,224   1906.........................               282,655      3,063,360
1902...         ..................            99,750       870,500   1907.........................               354,019      1,954,254
1903 ....................                    104,655       572,800   1908....................                    273,369      2,864,000
1904....................                     146, 955      963,263


   The effect of this improvement has been to increase the number of
firms carrying on business along this stream. So far as has been
learned this improvement has made no change in freight rates, but
commerce has greatly increased.
   For detailed reports see Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1897,
page 1089, and 1904, page 1016. A sketch of the stream is printed
in Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 1016. For refer-
ences to reports on examinations and surveys, see Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1904, pages 112 and 1061.
   Report upon examination and survey of East Chester Creek is
printed in House Document No. 1250, Sixtieth Congress, second
session.

Received from sales during the year..............                                             .. .............                  $2. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.                   ......................................
                                                .......                                                                           2. 00
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...........................                                                ........         2. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
   for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909........................................................                                                           (a)
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                                          CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................... $41, 548. 63
Received from sales................... . ...... ........ . ...................... 2. 00
                                                                                                                            41, 550. 63
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..................................................................                                                    29, 485. 01
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................................                                                     12, 065. 62
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities........................................                                                   174. 77
July 1, 1909, balance available.....................                                   ................                     11, 890. 85
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                                                    6,485. 00
                                   a See consolidated money statement on this page.
132                    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                           U.   S. ARMY.

  Amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909...        .......................
                                              -.                           $26, 485. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
      (See Appendix E 5.)
   6. Harbors at Port , Jefferson, Mattituckc, Huntington, Glencove,
FlushingBay, and CanarsieBay, New Yorlc.-(a) Port Jefferson lar-
bor.-This is a large and deep inland bay, situated on the north
shore of Long Island, and connected with Long Island Sound by a
narrow entrance.
   Before improvement the channel depth outside the entrance was
but 4 feet at mean low water, whereas the depth in the harbor was
12 feet and more, at low tide, up to within 300 feet of the wharves
of Port Jefferson village.
   The first project for improvement was adopted in 1871, and com-
pleted in 1883, at a total cost of $79,000. Two jetties were built to
shelter the inlet channel, one east of the inlet, 1,390 feet long, and
one west, 940 feet long, both of scant cross section. A channel 8
feet deep at mean low water and 100 feet wide was dredged through
the inlet and shoal outside.
   The existing project for improvement, adopted September 19,
1890, and modified August 18, 1894, provides for dredging a channel
through the harbor entrance 12 feet deep and 200 feet wide, to be pro-
tected by extending and enlarging the previously built jetties. Esti-
mated cost, $145,000.
  Up to June 30, 1909, $97,156.35 had been expended on the present
project; of this amount $5,929.64 was for maintenance.
   About 67 per cent of the work proposed under the present project
has been completed, and has resulted in making a channel 12 feet
deep at mean low water, and 200 feet wide, and in completing the
east jetty to its full projected section for a distance of 1,550 feet,
except at the shore end, where it is covered by sand. The west
jetty is 940 feet long, with scant cross section. No work has been
done on this jetty under the present project. The dredged channel
has maintained its projected depth during the past year.
   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended
are to be applied to continuing the improvement and to dredging
for maintenance if found necessary.
   The maximum draft that could be carried over the shoalest part
of the channel June 30, 1909, is probably 12 feet at mean low water.
Mean range of tides at entrance, 7 feet; at Port Jefferson wharves,
6.2 feet. The total length of navigable channel from Long Island
Sound to Port Jefferson wharves is about 2 miles. The harbor is
about 2 miles long and three-fourths of a mile wide.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this harbor, mainly in
coal, building materials, farm produce, fish, and general merchandise,
as obtained from the best available information, are as follows:

                 Year.          Tons.    Value.                Year.                      Tons.        Value.

1898 .....................     24,940    $360,200     1905......   .............          19,650(?)    $565,700(?)
1899...................   42,130        2,145,940    1906.....................           118,705      2,544,900
1903..................... 46,670          776,000    1907.....................            95,455      1,066,665
1904.....................  8,832(?)        90,424(?) 1908...................             127,230      1,536,000
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                        133
   Freight rates have probably been reduced as a result of this
improvement.
   For detailed report see Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900,
page 1393. A sketch of Port Jefferson Harbor is printed in Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 866.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......... . ...........................                             $15, 208. 78
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment-----...---......-------.......---------.....--...---..........                                  12, 808.78
                                                                      ..............------------------------------....

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................                           ..............          2, 400. 00

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                               51, 373. 29

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909.... ...-...-      ....         .........-..   ......                                        (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
   (b) Mattitucc Harbor.-This harbor is a tidal inlet extending in
a southerly direction from Long Island Sound to the village of Matti-
tuck, Long Island. One mile above the mouth a tide milldam with
gates and fixed bridge has been built across the stream. Before im-
provement the entrance was obstructed by a shifting sand bar, rising
to within from 1 to 2 feet below the mean low-water plane; thence up
to the milldam the depth was from 2 to 7 feet at low tide; and above
the latter 6 feet at high tide.
   The project adopted by the act of June 3, 1896, provides for a
channel 7 feet deep at mean low water from the entrance to the dam
and 7 feet deep at mean high water above the dam to the village, the
width to be 80 feet, except near the mouth, where it is increased to
100 feet; the entrance channel to be protected by two parallel jetties,
400 feet apart, extending out to the 9-foot curve. Estimated cost,
$83,000.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $56,258.82 had been expended on the project;
of this amount, $3,700 was for maintenance. There was received
from sales of maps $4.35.
   About 68 per cent of the work proposed under the project has been
completed, resulting in building the west jetty to full projected sec-
tion for a length of 680 feet, extending out to the 10-foot contour;
the east jetty to full projected section for a length of 775 feet, ex-
tending out to the 7-foot contour; and in dredging a channel at the
entrance 7 feet deep at mean low water, 100 feet wide, and about
1,400 feet long, thence a distance of about 400 feet, the same depth
and 80 feet wide; and thence a distance of about 2,000 feet, the
same depth and 60 feet wide.
   The harbor is now used as an anchorage by a number of oyster ves-
sels which have recently commenced operations in this vicinity.
   A recent survey has shown the necessity of extending both jetties
into deeper water and of connecting the inner end of the west jetty
with the shore above high water. It is also shown that the volume
of dredging required to complete the channel to the milldam is ap-
proximately 63,000 cubic yards in excess of the amount estimated
in 1891 when the project was submitted. To complete the project
                        a See consolidated money statement on page 139.
 134          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                    U.    S. ARMY.

as far as the dam, located about 14 miles below Mattituck, an ex-
penditure of $53,200 will be required in addition to the funds now
available.
   It is recommended that the improvement be extended beyond the
milldam only after the local authorities have removed the dam and
replaced the fixed bridge by a bridge with draw spans.
   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended are
to be expended in continuing the improvement and in maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, over the
shoalest part of the unimproved channel below the milldam at mean
low water is about 1 feet; above the milld am the least depth is
about 6 feet at mean high water. The head of navigation is at the
village of Mattituck. The total length of navigable channel from
Long Island Sound to the milldam is about 1 mile; thence to Matti-
tuck about 1I miles. The mean range of tides outside the entrance
is 4.8 feet, and below the milldam, which before dredging in the en-
trance was 2.2 feet, is now 4.4 feet.
   The commerce consists principally of coal, building materials,
fruits, farm produce, and general merchandise, and was reported in
1904 as amounting to 56,602 tons, valued at $2,041,766. The com-
merce by water during the calendar year 1908, mostly in fish and farm
produce, amounted to 1,100 tons, valued at $22,000. As a result of
the improvement several thousand acres of oyster beds have been
recently established in the vicinity, the boats used in the industry
finding a safe harbor in the river.
   No change in freight rates has yet resulted, the work not being
sufficiently advanced.
   For detailed description of this work see Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1891, page 843, and 1897, page 1095.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-..................................... $39, 314. 38
Received from sales ...................................................                                          1.50
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......------------------------....------...........----------...........---..--.....----... 6, 000. 00
                                                                                                        45, 315. 88
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ............................                               $17, 013. 35
      For maintenance of improvement .........................                            3, 557.00
                                                                                                        20, 570. 35

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................                                    24, 745. 53
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..... ...............................                               4, 726.07

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................-....-.........                                    20, 019.46

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..................    12, 173. 90
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... a 53, 200. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909...----------...---........-----...........--------------                 (b)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (c) Huntington Harbor.-This harbor is a narrow tidal estuary
extending inland from Huntington Bay, Long Island, in a southerly
direction for a distance of about 2 miles.
   a Revised estimate of cost of completing that part of the project below the mill dam.
   b See consolidated money statement on page 139.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      135
   Before improvement it had a natural available depth of nearly 8
feet, mean low water, for a stretch of 11 miles from the entrance
southward, thence gradually decreasing to zero toward the head of
the harbor.
   In 1872 the first project was adopted, under which in 1873 a shoal
at the harbor entrance was removed and a channel 2,200 feet long,
130 to 150 feet wide, and 8 feet deep at mean low water was dredged
up to the town landings at a total cost of $22,500. In 1884 this chan-
nel had completely filled up.
   The present project, adopted September 19, 1890, provides for
dredging and maintaining a channel 8 feet deep at mean low water
and 100 feet wide up to the upper wharves, to be protected by piling,
if necessary. Estimated cost, $32,000.
   Up to June 30, 1908, $38,000 had been expended on this project;
of this amount $8,510.94 was for maintenance.
   The present project is completed, except as to the dredging or pile
construction necessary to maintain the channel. For purposes of
maintenance the channel has been dredged 200 feet wide in lieu of
pile protection. The dredged channel has deteriorated to a con-
siderable extent.
   The appropriation recommended is to be applied to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1908, over the
shoalest part of the improved channel is estimated at about 8 feet
at mean low water in about mid-channel; less depth than is reported
to exist over a bar at the harbor entrance.
   Mean range of tide, 7.2 feet. The head of navigation is at a cause-
way about one-third of a mile above Town dock. The total length
of navigable channel from Huntington Bay to the causeway is about
2 miles.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this harbor, mainly in
coal, farm produce, building material, and miscellaneous merchandise,
as obtained from the best available information, are as follows:

              Year.              Tons.    Value.                      Year.                   Tons.      Value.

1897 ........................    23,584    $473,109    1904............................        94,950   $2,818, 250
1899.......................      46,500     605,000    1906...............            .....   105,212    2,774,850
1900 .........................   45,600     768,000    1907...........          ..........     96,196    1,901,061
1901 ......................      52,000     875,800    1908....................                38,316       413,218
1903.........................    66,000   1,086, 000



   This improvement has resulted in a material reduction in freight
rates.
   For detailed description see Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1897, page 1100. A sketch of the upper part of the harbor is printed
in the Annual Report for 1904, page 1023.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement.............................                                      (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (d) Glencove Harbor.-This harbor is a small tidal inlet on the
east side of Hempstead Harbor, Long Island. Its channel is about
                        a See consolidated money statement on page 139.
136       REPORT OF THE        CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

2 feet deep at mean low water and a bar at the entrance has a foot
less of depth. Before improvement vessels waiting for tides to enter
the harbor were exposed to storms from the north and northwest.
   The existing project, adopted August 11, 1888, and revised June
22, 1895, provides for the construction of a breakwater in Hempstead
Harbor extending from the northwest corner of Glencove dock west-
southwesterly toward Motts Point, so as to shelter the anchorage
outside of Glencove Harbor. The breakwater is to have a length of
2,000 feet and to be built to a height of 3 feet above high water, with
a top width of 5 feet. Estimated cost, $135,000.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $72,000 had been expended on the project, all
for improvement.
   About 53 per cent of the work contemplated under the project
has been completed and has resulted in building 1,564 feet of the
breakwater to full projected section.
   The present length of breakwater appears to afford sufficient pro-
tection to vessels seeking shelter from storms in this vicinity, and its
further extension therefore seems to be unnecessary.
   The maximum depth in the anchorage behind the breakwater is
estimated at 21 feet at mean low water. Shoaling is reported to have
occurred in the vicinity of the wharves and landings at the inner end
of the breakwater. Mean range of tides, 7.7 feet. The head of navi-
gation is at the southern extremity of Hempstead Harbor, about 3
miles from the breakwater.
   The commerce of the harbor is chiefly coal, and amounted to 8,549
tons, valued at $40,515, in 1904, and to 7,062 tons, valued at $18,000,
in 1906.
   This improvement has no immediate effect on freight rates.
   For details of improvement see Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1897, page 1103. A map is printed in Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1889, page 728.
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project............. $63, 000
   (e) Flushing Bay.-Flushing Bay is on the north shore of Long
Island, about 14 miles by water from the Battery, New York City.
The bay is about 1 mile wide and 2 miles long, the depth in the orig-
inal channel being not much greater than elsewhere in the bay.
Before improvement the controlling depth up to Flushing was 3.9
feet at mean low water.
   The existing project, adopted March 3, 1879, and modified Sep-
tember 19, 1888, and June 9, 1891, provides for building a dike 4,663
feet long on the west side of the channel to protect it from filling and
for making and maintaining a channel 6 feet deep at mean low water
up to the lower bridge at Flushing. Estimated cost, $173,500.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $160,761.19 had been expended on the proj-
ect. During progress of work it has been repeatedly necessary to
redredge some parts of the channel, so that it is not possible to state
exactly what part of above sum was used for maintenance. The
expenditure to June 30, 1909, for maintenance is estimated at
 $13,132.24.
   The project has been completed except as to removing a small shoal
below Broadway Bridge, and to making such slight changes in the
outer end of the dike as to make it less of an obstruction to naviga-
                           RIVER         AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       137
tion. There is now a channel having a least depth of 6 feet at mean
low water, and 200 feet wide up to Broadway Bridge, except as to
the above-mentioned shoals. Thence to Main Street Bridge of the
Long Island Railroad Company the channel is 100 feet wide and not
less than 6 feet deep at mean low water. The whole of the dike is in
bad condition, and all of the outer end, 1,606 feet long, with the ex-
ception of a few scattering piles and stones, has been carried away
by storms and ice. Dike construction was discontinued in 1891.
   The available funds are to be applied to making such slight changes
in the dike as may be necessary to make it less of an obstruction to
navigation, and to completing the improvement, and the additional
appropriation recommended is to be applied to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, from East
River to just beyond the Main Street Railroad Bridge at mean low
water is estimated at 6 feet. Mean range of tides, 7.1 feet. The
head of navigation is 1 mile above Strong's causeway. The total
length of the navigable channel is about 54 miles.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of Flushing Bay, mainly
in coal, building materials, dyewoods, and miscellaneous merchan-
dise, as obtained from the best available information, are as follows:

             Year.                  Tons.         Value.                    Year.                     Tons.         Value.

1897...............        ......... 163,395     $1,449,438   1904.......................                        142,996 $2,599,488
1899.........................          158,755    1,534,937   1905........................                       142,274 2,656,650
1901.................................. 200,473    4,196,406   1906----------........----....--..........-------- 273,312  3,937,444
1902 .....................             186,000    1,613,100   1907........................                       232,911 2,537,825
1903 .....................             110,100      960,750   1908 ........................                      126,455  1,774,900



  This work has facilitated transportation, but no appreciable effect
on freight rates has been ascertained.
  For detailed description of improvement, see Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1897, page 1106. A map is printed in the Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1903, page 868.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................... ...............         $2, 809. 68
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement............................... $1, 138. 63
    For maintenance of improvement ..-.......      ...........      432. 24
                                                                             1, 570. 87
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..............................                                                   1, 238. 81
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
    pended July 1, 1909..            .           .......         ..                                                  (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (f) Canarsie Bay.-This bay forms the northwest part of Jamaica
Bay at Canarsie Landing. The original depth from the landing to
Big channel was 4.2 feet and to Island channel 1.3 feet at mean low
water.
   The project for this improvement, adopted June 14, 1880, and
subsequently enlarged in 1889 and 1896, provides for the construc-
tion of two dikes and dredging between them where necessary to
                         a See consolidated money statement on page 139.
138         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                           S. ARMY.

secure a channel 100 to 150 feet wide and 6 feet deep, connecting the
steamboat dock at Canarsie with Big channel, Jamaica Bay; also
for a channel 4 feet deep and about 50 feet wide, running in a south-
westerly direction from Canarsie Landing to Island channel, and
for a channel 5 feet deep and 50 feet wide, running in a northeasterly
direction to Gophel channel. Estimated cost, $88,000.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $72,807.46 had been expended on the project;
of this amount $2,935.10 was for maintenance.
   The work of improvement under the project has been completed.
The dredged channels have deteriorated somewhat, and the dikes are
in poor condition.
   The available funds are to be applied to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, over the
shoalest part of the channel at mean low water is estimated at 6 feet
in the main channel; in about midchannel, 22feet in the West Branch;
and 3 feet in the East Branch. Mean range of tides, 4.7 feet. The
total length of navigable channel is about 1 mile. The head of nav-
igation is at Canarsie Landing.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this improvement,
mainly in building materials, fertilizers, fish, and coal, as obtained
from the best available information, are as follows:

           Year.                Tons.       Value.                 Year.         Tons.    Value.

1896.........................   50,000  $427,375 1905 ...............   ......    95,460 $1,714,022
1901..-..-...................  450,000 2,000,000 1907.......................     127,515    413,784
1904--.-...-..-.... ....   ... 124,594 1,861,008 1908.................   ...     240,075 1,125,290



   The commerce in Jamaica Bay has been greatly benefited by this
improvement. Transportation has been developed, but no reduction
of freight rates has been ascertained.
   Pending action by Congress upon a plan for improvement of
Jamaica Bay, submitted in compliance with river and harbor act
of March 2, 1907, it is recommended that no appropriation be made
for improvement or maintenance of the channel of Canarsie Bay,
which bay opens into Jamaica Bay.
   Details as to this improvement may be found in Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1897, page 1114. A sketch of Canarsie Bay is
printed in Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 1026.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..-......
                                       ....       ................. . .. $3, 033. 84
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement.................     ......................................       91. 30

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                      2, 942. 54
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          139
                                                   CONSOLIDATED.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended----------...........-------.........-------..............------.               $60, 366. 68
Received from sales-........------...........................................
                                    ------------------------------------------                                         1. 50
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.. - -...-----------------------.................................------------------..---....---.   6, 000. 00
                                                                                                             66, 368. 18
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...-.........................                                  $30, 960. 76
    For maintenance of improvement. ...... .. .. .... ......                                 4, 080. 54
                                                                                                             35, 041. 30

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......--------------...........-----....------.............                 31, 326. 88
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities......----...........-----------------------.......------.....           4, 726. 07

July 1, 1909, balance available...... ....................-----------------------------------.               26, 600. 81

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. . . . . . . ....... 12, 173. 90
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-.......... 167, 573. 29

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909.. .....        -..........-....... ... 46, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix E 6.)
   7. East River and Hell Gate, New York.-East River, a tidal strait
separating New York City from Long Island, extends from the Bat-
tery to Throgs Neck, a distance of about 16 miles. In its original
condition it was obstructed by rocks and reefs, especially in the part
known as Hell Gate.
   The improvement of this waterway was commenced in 1852, under
a project prepared in 1848, which contemplated the removal of rocks
at Hell Gate and Diamond Reef. The amount expended under this
project was $33,861.59.
   The existing project for improvement, adopted in 1868, and modi-
fied in 1870, 1874, 1884, 1889, 1891, and 1899, provides for the removal
of rocky obstructions from the channel between the Battery and
Baretto Point to depths varying from 18 to 26 feet, and for the con-
struction of sea walls and dikes where necessary to guide the tidal
currents. The cost of the work was estimated at $5,639,120. This
is the estimated cost for removal of reefs and rocks only at Hell
Gate, Diamond and Coenties reefs, and Man-o'-War rock. But
from time to time other obstructions have been removed with the
approval of higher authority, though no addition has been made
to the estimated cost of the project. The locations of these obstruc-
tions are reported below. To these works should be added the con-
struction of a crib between Great and Little Mill rocks, and the
dredging of channels connecting the main channel with the posts of
Davids Island and Fort Totten. The cost of this extra work, extend-
ing over a period of twenty-seven years, is $575,416. The amount
required to complete the project is therefore increased in this report
by that amount, less $335,466, not required under the estimate for
removing Man-o'-War rock, or a net increase of $239,950.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $4,883,519.97 had been expended; of this
amount $4,308,005.95 had been expended on the present project for
140                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                      U.    S. ARMY.

improvement; $98.02 was for maintenance, and the balance, $575,416,
on the works above enumerated not included in the original project.
There was received from sales of condemned property and maps
$1,336.25.
   About 73 per cent of the work proposed under the present project
has been completed and has resulted in the removal to the contem-
plated depths of Diamond reef, off Governors Island; Coenties reef, off
Coenties slip; Third street reef; Pilgrim rock, off Twentieth street;
Charlotte rock, off Hunters Point; Man-o'-War rock, off Thirty-
ninth street; Hallets Point, Ways reef, Shell Drake, and Scaly rock,
in Hell Gate; North Brother Island reef; reef off Barretto Point; and
in the partial removal of the following:

                                                                                                                            Least            Least         Least
                                                  Localities.                                                              original         present      proposed
                                                                                                                            depth.           depth.       depth.


                                                                                                                            Feet.        Feet.             Feet.
Battery reef ............................                                                                        ....
                                                                                       .................................      12. 8 12. 8 to 26+                   26
Reef off South Ferry slips .......                              .............................                                  17. 0   19     to 26+               26
Shell reef off Tenth to Nineteenth streets .........................                                                  .         7. 5             13                18
Ferry reef off Thirty-fourth street.                               ....         ......        ........ ..............           7                24                26
Middle reef (including Flood rock, Gridiron, Hen and Chickens, and
Negro Heads) ....................................................                                                           + 6                 18. 3             26
Frying Pan reef .....................................................                                                          11                18                26
Pot rock ............           . ....          ............... .............                 .... ............               20                 22. 8             26
Heel Tap ............................................................                                                         12. 1              20. 5             26



   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended
are to be applied to making a resurvey of such part of the present
project as may be necessary, including any ledge or ledges of rock
near to the westerly shore, in completing the removal of Pot rock,
and Frying Pan reef, nearly all of Middle reef, and in removing
parts of obstructions above enumerated as not completed.
   The maximum draft that could be carried at mean low water June
30, 1907, through the main channel from the Battery to Long Island
Sound is estimated at 26 feet. The length of this waterway is about
16 miles. The range of tide south of Hell Gate is from 4 to 5 feet,
and east of it from 5 to 7 feet.
   The traffic in East River is very great, and is intimately connected
with that of New York Harbor proper. It is impracticable to show
what proportion belongs to East River, especially as the heaviest
coastwise traffic is carried on in vessels which do not enter or clear at
the custom-house.
   The improvement of the river has been of great benefit to both
local and through traffic, which is very large in amount; its effect
on freight rates can not be determined.
   Attention is invited to the report of the district engineer relative
to the desirability of removing obstructions in the channel between
South Brother Island and Lawrence Point and of increasing the
present depth of about 18 feet over Middle Ground to 26 feet; and
to providing a channel of 26 feet between North and South Brother
islands. These suggested improvements are deemed worthy of
consideration.
   Report upon an examination and survey of the river between
North Brother and South Brother islands, and map of the locality,
are printed in House Document No. 1084, Sixtieth Congress, second
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             141
session. Preliminary report of resurvey of East River and Hell Gate
is printed in House Document No. 1187, Sixtieth Congress, second
session.
   Detailed description of this improvement is printed in the Reports
of the Chief of Engineers for 1868, page 741; for 1874, Part 2, page
164, and for 1897, page 1026.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................                              $384, 462. 44
Received from sales ...................... ............................                                   50
                                                                                               $384, 462. 94
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.. .. .........................................................                            83,305.21
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                           301, 157.73
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.---------.......--..............-------.......----...       9, 237. 66
July 1, 1909, balance available................................                         ....   291, 920. 07
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................     161, 662. 04
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......... 1, 031, 390. 59
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
  30, 1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.......................        ...... .............                       300, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
    (See Appendix E 7.)
   8. Harlem River, New Yorlk.-The Harlem River and Spuyten
Duyvil Creek, both included in the improvement, are two waterways
of a joint length of about 8 miles which join at Kingsbridge, N. Y.,
and separate Manhattan Island from the mainland. The narrow
channel at their junction was obstructed by a ledge of rocks awash at
low tide.
   Before improvement the Harlem River had an available depth of
10 feet at mean low water from the East River to Morris dock, except
at Highbridge, where it was only 6 feet deep. From Morris dock to
Fordham Landing there was a crooked channel 7 feet deep, and above
the latter place the river could be used only by the smallest class of
vessels. Spuyten Duyvil Creek, from Kingsbridge to the Hudson,
had a depth of 4 feet.
   The original project for improvement, adopted in 1874, provided
for the removal of old bridge piers, Candle Factory reef, and bowl-
ders at various places near the East River to a depth of 12 feet, the
cost of the work being estimated at $167,875.56. In furtherance of
this project $21,000 was expended.
   The existing project, adopted June 18, 1878, and modified October
7, 1886, provides for a continuous channel 400 feet wide and 15 feet
deep from the East River to the Hudson River, except about 1,300
feet north of Highbridge, where the width was made 375 feet, and
at the rock cut through Dyckmans Meadow, where the width was
reduced to 350 feet and the depth increased to 18 feet. Estimated
cost, $2,700,000.
   On June 30, 1909, $1,530,824.50 had been expended on the present
project, all for improvement. There was received on account of
reimbursements for damages to government property $108.97, and
from the sale of maps $2.10.
142          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                             U.   S. ARMY.

   About 57 per cent of the work proposed under the present project
has been completed, resulting in making a channel 15 feet deep at
mean low water and width of about 400 feet from Willis Avenue
Bridge to the Madison avenue permanent bridge except immediately
north of the easterly pier of the Second Avenue Bridge, where ledge
rock projects above the improvement plane; thence to One hundred
and forty-fifth Street Bridge the same depth and 250 to 300 feet in
width; thence to Macombs Dam Bridge the same depth and 150 feet
in width. The available depth through the westerly draw channel
at Macombs Dam Bridge is about 12 feet; the channel through the
easterly draw opening is not navigable, being obstructed by a rocky
ledge which projects above the low-water plane to within a short
distance of the rest pier. Below Willis Avenue Bridge between One
hundred and twenty-second and One hundred and twenty-sixth
streets, the channel of 15 feet depth is about 100 feet wide; both
above and below this section of the river the width rapidly increases
to 400 feet and over. In 1907 a channel 15 feet deep and 150 feet
wide was dredged from Macombs Dam Bridge to the Hudson River;
it is probable that since this work was completed the channel has
been narrowed by the filling in of material from the sides. The rock
cut through Dyckmans Meadow has been completed.
   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended
are to- be applied to continuing the improvement at and east of
Macombs Dam Bridge.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, through
the channel from East River to Hudson River at mean low water is
estimated at 15 feet, except through the channel at Macombs Dam
Bridge, where the depth is but about 12 feet.
   The mean range of tides in Harlem River as determined in 1907
is as follows: At Mill Rock, 5 feet; Willis Avenue Bridge, 5.1 feet;
Macombs Dam Bridge, 4.7 feet; Broadway Bridge, 3.8 feet; Spuyten
Duyvil Bridge, 3.7 feet. The total length of water way is about 8
miles.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this river, which is
general in character, as obtained from the best available information,
are as follows:

         Year.              Tons.        Value.                Year.               Tons.        Value.

             ........... 7,533,594 $203,707,376 1906....................I 11,385,649 (?)$104,359,757
1895..........
1903..................... 6,910,386 282,186,100 1907.....................   12,385,507 313,380,743
1904..................... 9,130,763 231,384,004 1908...................... la43,
                                                                               768,658 410,100,000
               --
1905........ ......  ...  9,998,021 270,210,309

  a Increase due to failure in past on the part of large transportation interests to respond to requests in
past years for statistics.

  The principal benefit derived from the improvement has been in the
way of increased facilities for handling shipments, which make a
material saving in the cost of transportation.
  Detailed description of this improvement is printed in Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for 1887, page 665, and 1897, page 1019.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                              143
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............................                                                 a $98, 500. 14
Collection damage to drill scow Hudson ...........................               .                                       67. 80
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909... ...................................             ......... ...                                   22, 000. 00
                                                                                                                  120, 567.94
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment --...---.-----------------.......---------..---.......------....... ----------...............----           84,281.37
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...-....                         ..............                   . ....           36, 286. 57
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...----..                ----...--..... --               ------........--      8, 252. 80
July 1, 1909, balance available......... ........                                    ............                  28, 033.77
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ---......- ...       11, 919. 40

IAmount
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 1, 133, 000. 00

         that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1,1909 ..... ..... ........... . ...............   .............--                                         300, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
I June 4, 1897.
    (See Appendix E 8.)
   9. Newtown Creek, New York.-This creek, an inlet of the East
River, extending inland between Kings and Queens counties, N. Y.,
for a distance of about 4 miles, had a natural depth varying from 12
feet at the mouth to 4 feet at the head of navigation.
   The original project, adopted in 1880 and modified in 1884, pro-
vided for a channel 240 feet wide and 21 feet deep from the mouth to
the Vernon Avenue Bridge; thence to the head of navigation on both
branches or channels decreasing from 175 to 100 feet in width and
from 18 to 10 feet in depth. The cost of the work was estimated at
$255,500. In carrying out this project $197,500 was expended.
   The existing project, adopted June 3, 1896, is to secure a uniform
channel, 125 feet wide and 18 feet deep, from the East River to the
head of navigation in the creek and in English Kills at the Metro-
politan avenue bridges, at an estimated cost of $450,000. This esti-
mate was subsequently reduced to $228,000.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $221,364.88 had been expended on the project.
Of this amount $21,420.31 was for maintenance.
   About 94 per cent of the work proposed under the present project
has been completed, resulting in a channel of the projected width and
depth, with the exception of some widening at the entrance. The
dredged channel has deteriorated to a considerable extent.
   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended
are to be applied to completing the improvement and to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried over the shoalest part
of the channel June 30, 1909, at mean low water is probably not more
than 16 feet. The mean range of tides is about 4Z feet. The total
length of navigable channels is about 4 miles. The head of naviga-
tion in the creek and kills is at the Metropolitan avenue bridges.
a Error of 50 cents in report for year ending June 30, 1908; sale of maps credited to
Hudson River should have been credited to Harlem River.
144         REPORT OF THE CHIEF                              OF ENGINEERS, U.                     S. ARMY.

   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this creek, mainly in
coal, building materials, oil, and general merchandise, as obtained
from the best available information, are as follows:

         Year.              Tons.            Value.                      -   Year.                   Tons.        Value.

1903...................  2,675,025       $90,535,640 1906..........    .......                      2,803,380    $214,714,751
1904.................... 3,771,726       108,313,377 1907.................                          3,108,374     175,229,346
1905.....................3,428,404       130,812,974 1908. ...       ........                       4,181,528     229,994,000



   The increased depth resulting from this improvement has greatly
benefited commerce.
   Freight rates have been reported as greatly reduced by this im-
provement. It is difficult if not impracticable to ascertain details;
but the large and valuable commerce of this water is the best index to
the effect of the improvement.
   Detailed descriptions of this improvement are printed in the Reports
of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, page 760, and 1900, page 1411.
A sketch of the locality is printed in Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1904, page 1034.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................                          .....................           $19, 828. 54
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ..............................                                       $1, 335.11
    For maintenance of improvement .......................                                         1, 458. 31
                                                                                                                  2, 793.42

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........                    ..........................                         17, 035. 12
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                                             63.41
July 1, 1909, balance available .................                    .       ..................                  16. 971.71
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..             .............................                                    ......     10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix E 9.)
   10. Wallabout channel, New York.-This channel consists of a
waterway extending in a half circle around the inside of the island
known as Cob dock, which lies in Wallabout Bay, a slight indenta-
tion of the East River, off the United States navy-yard at Brooklyn,
N. Y., and is part of the United States property. Wallabout channel
connects with the East River east and west of Cob dock.
   The channel is separated into two parts, called the "east" and
"west" channels, by a stone causeway which connects the mainland
with Cob dock. The east channel, which is about 2,000 feet long and
from 250 to 350 feet wide, and had available depths of from 16 to 20
feet along the line of deepest water, diminishing to 5 feet along the
sides, is the part embraced in the approved project for improvement.
   The existing project, adopted in 1899, is to secure a depth of 20
feet at mean low water and widths ranging from 230 to 350 feet from
the entrance of the channel to the timber causeway; practically to
the stone causeway constructed northward of the timber causeway.
   The channel was secured in accordance with the project in 1900, at
a cost of $18,173.69.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                        145
   Up. to June 30, 1909, $19,923.62 had been expended on the proj-
ect. Of this amount, $1,749.93 was expended in resurveying the
locality for the purpose of determining the amount of work necessary
to restore the channel to its projected dimensions.
   The available funds will be applied to the restoration of the channel.
The maximum draft, at mean low water, that could be carried over
the shoalest part of the channel June 30, 1909, is probably not more
than 18 feet. Mean range of tides 4 feet. Total length of navigable
channel is about one-half mile. The head of navigation is at the
causeway.
   The commerce of Wallabout channel, mainly in coal, sugar,
sirups, ice, lumber, and produce, amounted in 1897 to 340,300 tons,
valued at $16,008,000; and in 1908 to 937,384 tons, valued at
$4,444,600.
   A detailed description of this improvement is printed in the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1899, page 1242. A sketch of
the locality is printed in House Document No. 50, Fifty-fifth Con-
gress, third session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended--------....................-----...---------...-----------........ $21, 826. 31
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement---....--.........................-------------------------.............--....----------------...--. 1, 749. 93

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                                      20, 076. 38
    (See Appendix E 10.)
   11. Browns Creek, New York.-This is a narrow stream which
empties into Great South Bay, Long Island, near Browns Point. It
had originally a depth of from 1 to 3 feet at low water, a bar at the
mouth having less than 1 foot.
  The project for improvement, adopted September 19, 1890, pro-
vides for a channel 100 feet wide and 4 feet deep, to extend from deep
water in the bay up to Sayville highway bridge, and to be protected
at the entrance by jetties on both sides. Estimated cost, $46,000.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $31,301.86 had been expended on the project,
of which amount $6,301.86 was for maintenance.
   There was received from the sale of maps $1.38.
   About 54 per cent of the work proposed under the project has been
completed, resulting in the building of two jetties at the entrance and
in the dredging of a channel 100 feet wide and 4 feet deep at mean
low water for a distance of 3,200 feet from the entrance. Because of
shoaling this dredged channel was redredged in 1905 to 4 feet depth
at mean low water for a distance of about 1,200 feet from the end of
the jetties.
   The west jetty is 492 feet long and the east jetty 438 feet long, both
with top width of 3 feet at 1 foot above high water, and both partly
covered at the shore end by accretion. They are in bad condition.
   Disbursements during the year were in payment of office expenses
and of the cost of an examination of the locality.
   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended are
to be applied to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried over the shoalest part of
the dredged channel at mean low water June 30, 1909, is about 21
feet; mean range of tides, 1 foot. The head of navigation is at the
Sayville highway bridge, about 11- miles from the mouth.
         9001-ENG 1909----10
146                    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                      S. ARMY.

    Because of rapid deterioration, due mainly to the inflow of mud
from the marshes bounding the channel, $6,204.83 has already been
expended in redredging, and the jetties, built only to about one-third
of their projected lengths, are in a very bad condition.
    The total cost of completing the project will be much greater than
the original estimate, and if the channel, which is now only 3,200 feet
long and requires redredging, is extended upstream, the expenditure
for maintenance will increase proportionately.
    Considering the limited number of vessels using this creek for
transportation purposes, the cost of improving and maintaining the
entire length of the creek to Sayville, and completing the break-
waters as projected, would be out of proportion to the benefits to be
derived therefrom. It is therefore recommended that future appro-
priations be made, not for extending the improvement, but only for
maintaining the present dredged channel.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this creek, mainly in
coal, building materials, and fish, as obtained from the best available
information, are as follows:

                    Year.        Tons.      Value.                        Year.                     Tons.      Value.

1898 .........................    10,700    $213,800    1904..... ..............                    24,000      $807,075
1899 ........................     11,642     251,350    1905.....................                   51,675     1,811,195
1901 .......................      17,025     454,500    1906..........            ............      29,675       983,880
1902.....................         17,630     299,300    1907....................                    34,975     1,043,865
1903 .....................        20,380     609,450    1908...................                     25,240       924,780



  This improvement has resulted in providing a harbor for fishing
boats, but has had no appreciable effect on freight rates.
  Details in reference to this work appear in Reports of the Chief of
Engineers for 1897, page 1111, and for 1900, page 1417. A sketch of
the creek is printed in Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1894,
page 710.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                                       $4, 795. 17
Received from sales.................................................                                               1. 38
                                                                                                              4, 796. 55
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement.................. ................................................                                    97. 03
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ............................                                        ....     4, 699. 52
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                                      16, 301. 86
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 ..............................................                                         3, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
      (See Appendix E 11.)
  12. Great South Bay, New York.-The first project, adopted Sep-
tember 19, 1890, provided for the improvement of the Patchogue
River, a small inlet extending from Great South Bay, Long Island,
to the village of Patchogue. This stream had, before improvement,
a depth of 2 feet. The project provided for a channel about 5,000
feet long, 60 feet wide, and 6 feet deep, to be protected at its mouth
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                    147
against westerly storms by a jetty 1,700 feet long. Estimated cost,
$40,000. On June 30, 1902, there had been expended on this work
$40,000, and the project was completed.
   The present project, adopted June 13, 1902, provides for dredging
a channel from Fire Island Inlet, which connects Great South Bay
with the ocean, to Patchogue, on Patchogue River. From the inlet
to the central basin in Great South Bay the channel is to be 10 feet
deep at mean low water and 200 feet wide. From the central basin
to Patchogue the channel is to be 8 feet deep and 100 feet wide at
mean low water. Estimated cost $66,000, and $2,000 annually for
maintenance.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $66,813.93 had been expended on the project,
of which amount $6,993.11 was for maintenance. There was received
from the sale of maps $2.92. About 90 per cent of the work con-
templated under the present project has been completed, resulting
in a channel 200 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water in the
bay, except at bars "A" and "B;" and in the completion of a chan-
nel 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep at mean low water in the river.
Considerable shoaling has occurred in the latter.
   Expenditures during the past fiscal year were for payment of con-
tractor's retained percentages, examination of channel conditions,
printing, advertising, etc.
   A recent examination of Patchogue River has shown that to main-
tain the channel at a minimum of cost the present west jetty should
be extended to at least the 7-foot contour in the bay; an easterly
jetty should be built out from the shore to the same contour; and the
channel should be redredged throughout its length to the projected
depth of 8 feet below mean low water. The estimated cost of this
work is $75,000, in addition to the funds now available. Further
details concerning this item are given in the report of the district
officer.
   The available funds and the additional appropriation recom-
mended are to be applied to maintenance, by dredging, leaving it for
Congress to decide whether the jetties shall be built to aid in main-
taimnng the project depth as proposed by the district officer.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, over the
shoalest part of the channel from Fire Island Inlet to central basin
was 8.5 feet and in Patchogue River 5 feet.
   Mean range of tides, 1 foot. The head of navigation in Patchogue
River is at a fixed bridge at Division street, Patchogue. The total
length of navigable channel from Fire Island Inlet to Patchogue is
about 17 miles and to Belleport 22 miles.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this locality, mainly
in coal, lumber, and fish, as obtained from the best available informa-
tion, are as follows:

              Year.                     Tons.        Value.                 Year.                Tons.      Value.

1898.. -..........          ........... 255,200    $3,702,000     1904........................   257,879    $4,037,130
1899 --......--..................       266, 800    3, 808, 500   1905........................   224, 526    3, 871,850
1900.........................           274,100     3,919,000     1906........... .........      232,500     4, 014,000
1901 .....................              281, 39     4,025,000     1907.....................      224,108     3,903,723
1902.......................             257,500     4,000,000     1908 ....................      195,000     3,320,000
1903........................            258,500     3,995,000
148                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                          U.     S. ARMY.

   The effect of the work has been to facilitate commerce. No reduc-
tion in freight rates has been ascertained.
   For details as to improvement see Patchogue River, Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 1108; for 1901, page 1249, and for
1903, page 134. A sketch is printed in Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1903, page 876.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...............
                                             .                             ..          ................                   $4, 018. 24
Received from sales ....                           ..        ..........                                                         1. 47
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1909----................---------------------------------------------                                            3, 000. 00

                                                                                                                           7, 019. 71
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
   improvement..................................                          ..........                      ..   .   ....      830. 72

                                                                                                                           6, 188. 99
IAmouLt
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................

          that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909 .................................................                                                 5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix E 12.)
   13. Hudson River, New Yorl.-The portion of this river which is
now under improvement is the stretch beginning at the State dam at
Troy and extending downstream to Coxsackie, a distance of 28 miles.
In its natural condition the channel was narrow and crooked, with a
navigable depth of 4 feet between the State dam and Albany, of
feet between Albany and New Baltimore, of 11 feet between New
                                                                                                                                  71
Baltimore and Coxsackie, and of 12 feet or more below Coxsackie.
   The original project for improvement, adopted in 1834, modified
in 1852 and again in 1866, had for its object the securing of a navigable
channel of sufficient width and 9 feet deep between Troy and Albany,
and 11 feet deep between Albany and New Baltimore. In carrying
out this work $1,667,938 was expended.
   The existing project, adopted July 13, 1892, and modified March
3, 1899, provides for a 12-foot channel 150 feet wide from the State
dam to the foot of Jacob street, Troy; thence gradually increasing in
width to 400 feet at the foot of Broadway, Troy; thence 400 feet wide
to Coxsackie. This work was estimated to cost $4,343,863. The act
of March 3, 1905, authorized the expenditure, in the discretion of the
Secretary of War, of $85,000 of the amount appropriated by that act
for improving Hudson River, for the removal of Stonehouse bar,
opposite New Baltimore. Forty thousand two hundred and eighty-
eight dollars and forty-two cents has been expended on this work.
The same act authorized the expenditure of not exceeding $10,000 in
providing a channel for access to the harbor of Tarrytown, all of which
amount has been expended under this authority. The act of March 2,
1907, authorized the expenditure of $5,000 in removing the bar and
deepening the channel at the mouth of Schodack Creek. Under this
authority $4,432.37 was expended.
   On June 30, 1909, $3,740,335.60 had been expended; of this
amount $3,705,202.14 had been expended on the present project, of
which $313,497.48 was for maintenance; and the balance, $54,720.79,
on the works above enumerated not included in the project. There
was received from sales of maps $86.52; from sale of typewriter
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   149
$35; from repayments $10.06; from reimbursements on account of
removal of obstructions from the channel, $78.10.
   About 85 per cent of the work proposed under the present project
has been completed, resulting in a navigable channel of not less width
than 190 feet, and maximum depth of 12 feet at mean low water from
Coxsackie to the Delaware and Hudson Company's bridge at Troy,
N. Y., except at the New York Central and Hudson River Railroad
Company's freight bridge at Albany, where the channel through the
draw spans is contracted to a maximum of 90 feet; and a depth of 11
feet and width of 75 feet from the Delaware and Hudson Company's
bridge to within 900 feet of the sloop lock at the State dam. The
depth over the miter sill of the sloop lock is 41 feet.
   The range of the tides in seasons of moderate rain varies from 2.55
feet at the State dam, 2.89 feet at Broadway, Troy, 2.84 feet at Al-
bany, to 3.69 feet at Coxsackie, being an increase in elevation of high
water of about 0.5 foot at Albany and at the foot of Broadway, Troy.
The head of navigation for the tidal portion of the river is at the
State dam, 153 miles from the Battery in New York City. The total
length of navigable channel under improvement is 28 miles.
   For results of previous tidal observations, reference is made to the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 998, and 1900, page
1490.
   The commerce within the limits of the improvement, mainly in
general merchandise, farm products, building material, fuel, and ice,
amounted to 3,325,360 tons, valued at $75,664,748 in 1906, to
2,881,168 tons, valued at $66,853,731 in 1907, and to 2,945,921 tons,
valued at $120,421,651 in 1908.
   The effect of the improvement has probably been to reduce freight
rates.
   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended
are to be applied to continuing the improvement and to maintenance.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .........          ..................... _             a $196, 689. 19
Received, sale of maps, $35.02; sale of property, $35 .-........-.......                         70. 02
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909......-........    ..-.........    .....                          ......
                                                                     -............          39,000.00
Received by collection...................                        ...............
                                               ........................                           4.45
                                                                                                     235, 763. 66
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..........................                            $145, 772. 44
    For maintenance of improvement .-...-.............                              34, 310. 58
                                                                                                     180, 083. 02

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......... ...........-...........                                    55, 680. 64
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ---------................-------------......------..-...---.    18, 688.53

                                                                -------------
July 1, 1909, balance available...-------.......-----....-----------..........                        36, 992.11

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. ..............                                  3, 152. 90
Amount (estimated) required for co hpletion of existing project---....-....                          951, 408. 17

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909. .........        ...........                                  350, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix E 13.)
a Error of 50 cents in report for year ending June 30, 1908; sale of maps credited to
Hudson River should have been credited to Harlem River.
150                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                              U.    S. ARMY.

   14. Saugerties Harbor, New York.-Saugerties Harbor is the name
applied to the mouth of Esopus Creek, which empties into the Hudson
River from the west, about 100 miles above New York City, which
creek is navigable at high water for a distance of about 6,000 feet
from deep water in the Hudson River. Above the steamboat land-
ing, which is a distance of about 4,500 feet from deep water, there is
little traffic. The original depth over the bar was 3 feet at mean low
water, which had been increased to 7 feet by dredging done by the
State of New York in 1885-86.
   The original project, which contemplated securing a permanent
channel 7 feet deep at mean low water and 100 feet wide, at an esti-
mated cost of $52,000, was adopted in 1884, modified in 1887, and
completed in 1892, with an expenditure of $42,000. To June 30, 1902,
$15,000 had been expended for maintenance.
   The existing project, adopted June 13, 1902, provides for a channel
12 feet deep at mean low water and 200 feet wide from deep water
in the Hudson River to the steamboat landing, at an estimated cost
of $44,685, with an estimated annual expenditure of $2,500 for
maintenance.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $44,137.98 had been expended on the present
project; of this amount $19,064.99 was for maintenance. There was
received from the sale of maps $1.10.
   About 56 per cent of the work proposed under the present project
has been completed, resulting in widening and straightening the nav-
igable channel of 12 feet depth where Barclays Point and Powder-
house reefs have been removed, and in making a fair channel from
the mouth of the harbor to the steamboat landing.
   The expenditure for maintenance is mainly due to restoring the
channel above the reef, where, owing to the breaking of the dam a
short distance above the head of navigation in the summer of 1902
and the consequent release of a large quantity of mud and silt retained
by it, the channel had been reduced in width and depth so as to be
practically closed to the navigation by large boats; and to the relief
to navigation along the wharves on the north side of the channel,
where extensive shoaling had taken place, apparently as the result of
the removal of the rock off Barclays Point.
   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended
are to be applied to continuing the improvement, and to maintenance.
   The maximum draft at mean low water that could be carried June
30, 1909, is estimated at 101 feet, for a minimum width of 50 feet.
The mean rise and fall of tides is about 4 feet. The head of naviga-
tion is at a point about 1,600 feet below the dam. The total length of
navigable channel is about 1i miles.
   The tonnage and the value of the commerce of this harbor, mainly
in building materials, manufactures, fuel, and general merchandise, as
obtained from the best available information, are as follows:

                  Year.        Tons.          Value.                    Year.                  Tons.     Value.


1901 ......................     67,473 ..........          1905........... ........             81,600   $1,598,000
1902 ......................     66,500                     1906......        ....      ..--.    83,300    1,606,200
1903...................        112,677 . .....      ,      1907...    ................          95,400    1,873,000
1904.......................    113,200    $18,832,195(?)   1908...                             114,000    2,070, 500
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          151
  The effect of the improvement, according to the best information
available, is to reduce freight rates during the season of navigation.
  Details in reference to this work appear in Reports of the Chief of
Engineers for 1895, page 910, and 1900, page 1518. A sketch is
printed in Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 1046.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................................... $16, 141.87
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ......................................................... ......  12, 278.75

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                           3, 863.12
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                      15, 749. 99
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ..........................       15, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix E 14.)
   15. Harbors at Rondout and Peekskill, New York.-(a) Rondout
Harbor.-This harbor issituated at the mouth of Rondout Creek,
on the west shore of the Hudson River, 90 miles above New York City.
The creek, which is navigable to Eddyville, 3 miles from its mouth,
was the most easterly section of the Delaware and Hudson Canal until
that waterway was abandoned several years ago. Before improve-
ment was begun under the adopted project a depth of 7 feet at mean
low water had been obtained as a result of work done by private
parties.
   The original project, adopted June 10, 1872, provided for a channel
14 feet deep at mean low water and 100 feet wide, at an estimated
cost of $172,500, and was completed in 1880 at a total cost of $90,000.
Since then the expenditures have been for maintenance.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $140,928.63 had been expended on the project.
Of this amount $50,928.63 was for maintenance.
   The above expenditure has resulted inmaking a channel 12) feet
deep at mean low water and not less than 100 feet wide.
   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended
are to be applied to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried through the channel
June 30, 1909, was 13 feet at mean low water, with a least width of
channel of about 75 feet. The mean rise and fall of tides is 4 feet.
The head of navigation is at Eddyville. The total length of navigable
channel is about 3 miles.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this harbor, mainly in
general merchandise, building materials, fuel, and ice, as obtained
from the best available information, are as follows:

          Year.               Tons.        Value.                Year.            Tons.        Value.

1904................ ...     1, 469, 000 $41,065, 000 1907....................   1,255, 000    $5, 025, 000
1905....................     1,325,000    46,112, 500 1908..................       438,000      2,075,000
1906...................         998,524    5,640,900
152          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                             U.   S. ARMY.

   The effect of the improvement has probably been to keep the
freight rates down during the season of navigation.
   Detailed description of this improvement is printed in Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for 1880, page 494, and for 1895, page 913.
A sketch of the harbor is printed in Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1903, page 1884.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................... $10, 838. 73
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .........................................................   8, 467. 36

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                              2, 371. 37
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...-------------------------------------------(a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Peekskill Harbor.-This harbor is an indentation on the east-
ern shore of the Hudson River, about 46 miles above New York City,
about five-eighths of a mile long and 11 miles wide, having before
improvement a controlling depth of about 5 feet at mean low water,
except near the wharves in Peekskill, where it was about 6 feet.
   The original project for improvement, adopted June 3, 1896, pro-
vided for a dredged channel 10 feet deep at mean low water and 100
feet wide from deep water in the Hudson River north of the village
to deep water south of it, following generally the contour of the
shore, at an estimated cost of $50,000. The project was completed
in 1899, at a cost of $19,400.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $28,222.26 had been expended on the project;
of this amount $8,822.26 was for maintenance.
   Disbursements during the year were mainly in part payment of
office expenses.
   The channel was restored to its projected depth and width in 1907.
It is probable some shoaling has occurred since then.
   The available balance and the additional appropriation recom-
mended are to be applied to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried through the channel
June 30, 1909, at mean low water is probably less than 10 feet. Mean
range of tides about 3 feet. The total length of channel is 1 miles.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this harbor, mainly in
general merchandise, building material, and fuel, as obtained from
the best available information, are as follows:

            Year.                Tons.      Value.                 Year.               Tons.      Value.

                       81,265$3,751,9851907........................
1904.......................                                                            107,963      $733,766
1905.............. ......  74,546               748
                                           1,134,    1908a................         .   226,533     4,984,046
1906...................... 88,500            659,864

      a Increase mainly due to the receipt of more complete statistics for 1908 than for previous years.

  A slight reduction in freight rates has been reported.
  Detailed description of this improvement is printed in Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for 1895, page 999, and for 1897, page 1016.
  A sketch of the harbor is printed in Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1903, page 885.
                       a See consolidated money statement on page 153.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           153
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............                          ......................... $285. 48
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provem ent.............................................................                               7.74
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....--...-     ...-...
                                        -------........--......                                                     277. 74
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
   for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909..-....-...             ----------------                                                              (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                                     CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended........................................... $11, 124. 21
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement -----..----...------......--....----------.......-------...-----...........------...---... 8, 475. 10

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-----..----...--........                                                       2, 649. 11
                                                                                       .--------------------.............
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909..................................-------------------------------------------.............   6, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix E 15.)
   16. Wappinger Creek, New York.-Wappinger Creek is a small
stream, which empties into the Hudson River from the east about
one-half mile below the village of New Hamburg, N. Y.; it is naviga-
ble from its mouth for a distance of about 2 miles to the works of the
Dutchess Company, which are located just below the falls and at the
head of navigation. The entrance to the creek is through a draw-
bridge over which passes the New York Central and Hudson River
Railroad. The depth before improvement did not exceed 6 feet,
and the width of channel varied from 25 to 75 feet.
   The original project for improvement, adopted September 19, 1890,
provided for a channel 8 feet deep at mean low water and 80 feet
wide, at an estimated cost of $13,000. The project was completed
April 30, 1892, at a cost of $13,000, and resulted in making a chan-
nel of the projected width and depth.
   The expenditures during the past fiscal year were for resurvey of
the creek, examining new drawbridge, etc.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $18,849.34 had been expended on the project;
of this amount $5,849.34 was for maintenance.
   To maintain the channel width and depth as projected repeated
redredging is necessary. A recent survey of the creek from its mouth
to the falls shows that shoaling has occurred to such extent the expend-
iture of the balance of funds available for this work would not result
in a material benefit to navigation. It is therefore proposed to delay
further work until additional funds are made available by act of
Congress.
   During the past year the New York Central and Hudson River
Railroad Company completed the erection of a new draw of 40 feet
horizontal clearance a short distance south of the old draw span, and
connected the. new location with the channel improved by the United
States by dredging to a depth of 8 feet at mean low water, except
                           a See consolidated money statement on this page.
154           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                    U.   S.   ARMY.


for a few minor obstructions in the draw opening which have yet to
be removed by the railroad company.
   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended
are to be applied to maintenance.
   The greatest draft that can be carried, June 30, 1909, at mean low
water, from deep water in the Hudson River to the head of naviga-
tion is about 7 feet. The mean rise and fall of tides at the mouth of
the creek is about 3.3 feet. The total length of navigable channel is
about 2 miles.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this creek, mainly in
cotton goods, clothing, building material, and fuel, as obtained from
the best available information, are as follows:

            Year.                  Tons.       Value.                     Year.               Tons.          Value.

1904........................       56,927 $7,955,975 1907.......................              44,493    $445,765
1905 .....................         49,562 4,872,903 1908 .....................                41,574 a 6,990,600
1906 .....................         46,194   572,399

     aIncrease due to more accurate returns from interested parties for 1908 than for 1906 and 1907.


   It is reported that commercial interests have been greatly bene-
fited by the improvement, but no reduction in freight rates has
resulted therefrom.
   Details in reference to this work appear in the Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1893, page 1024. A sketch is printed in the Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 1051.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................  .................    $3, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement..............................        .............. ......  1, 349. 34

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.. ...................................                                      1, 650. 66
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ................                .....................                    16. 71

July 1, 1909, balance available ......................................                                .1,     633. 95

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.....         ..................................... 5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix E 16.)
   17. Tarrytown Harbor, New Yorkc.-This harbor is located on the
east shore of Hudson River, about 28 miles above New York City,
where the river is several miles wide. The channel is bordered on
both sides by extensive flats, that on the east side measuring about
three-eights of a mile from the main wharf to the 12-foot depth in
the river. The general depth in the harbor is about 41 feet at mean
low water.
  Before improvement two channels of about 6 feet depth led up to
main wharf.
  The original project for improvement, adopted March 3, 1905,
provides for a channel along the wharf front of the harbor and con-
necting it north and south with deep water in Hudson River, to
be 12 feet deep at mean low water, and 150 feet wide along the
                     RIVER ATD HIARBOR 1IPROVEMENTS.                                   155

wharf front; and 100 feet wide in the northerly and southerly con-
nections with the Hudson River. Estimated cost, $26,000, increased
in 1907 to $35,491.68, and $1,000 or $2,000 biennially for main-
tenance.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $23,226.27 had been expended on this project,
all in improvement. About 65 per cent of the work proposed under
the project has been completed, resulting in a channel 100 feet wide
and 12 feet deep, at mean low water, in the southern arm; 100 feet
wide and 10 to 12 feet deep along the wharf front except opposite
Husted's dock, where it is only 60 feet wide; 60 feet wide and 12 feet
deep for 350 feet in length of the eastern end of the northern arm,
and 60 feet wide but of less than 12 feet depth for a farther distance
of 100 feet in the northein arm. It is probable that the dredged
areas have shoaled to an appreciable extent.
   The available funds and additional appropriation recommended
are to be applied to continuing the improvement and to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried in the dredged channel
June 30, 1909, at mean low water, from deep water in the Hudson
River south of Tarrytown to Husted's wharf in Tarrytown, is esti-
mated at 12 feet, and from deep water in the Hudson River north of
Tarrytown to the same wharf at 6 feet. Mean range of tides is about
31 feet. The total length of projected channel is about 1 miles.
   The tonnage and value of the commerce of this harbor, mainly in
general merchandise, coal, and building materials, as obtained from
the best available information, are as follows:

         Year.            Tons.     Value.              Year.            Tons.     Value.

1905......................71,201 $1,830,092 1907................... 86,076  $3,641,915
   - ...--
1903._        ...--  ..
                 ..---    79,714    384,979(? 1908.....------------...............
                                                                    71,325   3,648,856



   A slight reduction in freight rates has been reported as resulting
from the improvement.
   Detailed description of this harbor is printed in Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1889, page 800, and 1900, page 1520.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.............................       ......... $3, 985. 88
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement ....      ....... .....................................        ....... 1, 212. 15

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................               2, 773.73
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project............         9, 491. 68
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 .........................         ... . 12, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix E 17.)
  18. Coney Island channel, New Yorkc Harbor.-This channel lies
immediately south of Coney Island, at the southwestern extremity of
Long Island, New York, and is one of five channels which cross the
bar that separates New York lower bay from the ocean. A channel
500 to 560 feet wide and 14 feet deep at mean low water was dredged
156          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                           VU.
                                                                          S. ARMY.


in 1900, and in 1905 this channel was redredged to a width of 400
feet. When surveyed in 1906, the least depth on the western-of two
bars in the channel was about 12 feet at mean low water and about
16 feet on the eastern bar.
   The present project for improvement, adopted March 2, 1907,
provides for dredging a channel 20 feet deep at mean low water
and 600 feet wide, with side slopes of 1 on 3 from deep water in the
lower bay to deep water in the Atlantic Ocean at an estimated cost of
$168,300, and $20,000 annually for maintenance.
   This improvement was intended to diminish the congestion of and
danger in the main channels in the lower bay by directing there-
from light-draft steamers and sailing vessels, long tows, and excursion
vessels plying between New York and Coney Island or Rockaway
Inlet.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $52,547.39 had been expended on this project,
all in improvement. There was received $36.67 on account of re-
payment and 33 cents from the sale of maps. About 31 per cent of the
work proposed under the project has been accomplished, resulting
in making a channel through the western bar 20 feet deep at mean
low water and 340 feet wide. The channel dredged in 1907 has been
entirely filled in, as shown by a survey made in June, 1908. The
contract for this work was terminated August 27, 1908, before its
completion; nothing has been done in the way of improvement since
the termination of this contract. The indications are that the annual
cost of maintenance may be as much as $50,000 or $60,000, one-third
or more of the estimated cost of dredging the channel. Since the
cost per cubic yard for dredging in this locality, if done by a govern-
men t seagoing dredge, will probably be not more than about one-
third of the cost by contract, it is proposed to resume this work as
soon as such seagoing dredge can be assigned thereto.
   The maximum draft that could be carried over the shoalest part of
the channel June 30, 1909, at mean low water is estimated at 121
feet. The mean range of tides is about 4.6 feet. The total length of
projected channel is about 11 miles.
   The commercial interests using this channel are those of the city
of New York and other cities whose commerce passes Sandy Hook.
It is impracticable to state what proportion of this commerce uses
Coney Island channel.
   It is not expected that the dredging of this channel will affect
freight rates. The channel is desired principally as a means of free-
ing the regular channel from use by tows entering and leaving New
York Harbor.
   A report upon the examination and survey of Coney Island channel
and map of the locality are printed in House Document No. 442,
Fifty-ninth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................   $160, 171. 36
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..............................................................       24, 381. 75

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................               135, 789. 61
    (See Appendix E 18.)
  19. Removing sunkcen vessels or craft obstructing or endangering
navigation.-(a) Wreck of scow (name unknown).-This scow was
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    157
sunk in East Chester Bay off Wire Creek. Reported to the depart-
ment June 29, 1908, and an allotment of $241.50 for its removal was
made July 3, 1908. Removal was completed July 13, 1908, at a
total cost of $241.50.
   (b) Wreck of schooner H. T. Hedges.-This schooner was sunk
about June 1, 1908, in East River, New York, opposite Whitestone,
N. Y. Reported to the department June 29, 1908, and an allotment,
of $994.50 for its removal was made July 7, 1908. Removal was
completed July 13, 1908, at a total cost of $994.50.
   (c) Wreck of barge Kate.-This barge was sunk about June 23,
1908, in Bronx River, New York, about opposite One hundred and
seventy-second street. Reported to the department by telegraph
July 6, 1909, and an allotment of $400 for its removal was made on
the same date. Removal was completed July 14, 1908, at a total
cost of $373.
   (d) Wreck of schooner (name unknown).-This schooner was sunk
about June 1, 1908, in Long Island Sound, about one-half mile off Pea-
cock Point, Long Island, N. Y. Reported to the department July 6,
1908, and allotments amounting to $275 for its removal were made
July 9 and July 24, 1908. Removal was completed July 28, 1908,
at a total cost of $259.
   (e) Wreck of barge (name unknown).-This wreck consisted of a
portion of a wrecked barge endangering navigation in Hudson River
at Albany, N. Y. The wreckage was removed at a total cost of
$48.50, and an allotment of this amount was made August 20, 1908,
for defraying the cost of removal.
   (f) Wreck of schooner Winslow Morse.-This wreck was first re-
ported September 5, 1908. The owner was, upon his request, given
an opportunity to raise the vessel, but being unsuccessful, was com-
pelled to abandon her. Removal by the United States was recom-
mended April 30, 1909, and an allotment of $375 for this purpose
was made May 4, 1909. Removal was completed May 20, 1909, at
a total cost of $375.
   (g) Wreck of barge Bessie.-This barge was sunk in the Hudson
River, New York, at Verplancks Point, and was reported to the de-
partment May 5, 1909. An allotment of $600 for its removal was
made May 20, 1909. Removal was completed June 7, 1909, at a
total cost of $530. The balance of the allotment, amounting to $70,
is to be turned in to the credit of the Treasurer of the United States
after payment of outstanding liabilities has been made
   (See Appendix E 19.)
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS MADE IN   COMPLIANCE WITH              RIVER
          AND HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

  Reports on preliminary examinations and surveys required by
the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities
within this district were duly submitted by the district officer. They
were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors,
pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in
documents as indicated.
  1. Preliminary examination and survey of East River, New York,
between North Brother and South Brother islands, with a view to ob-
taining depths of 20, 22, and 24 feet.-Reports dated April 9, 1907,
158     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,       U.   S. ARMY.

and April 30, 1908, respectively, are printed in House Document
No. 1084, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for improve-
ment is presented for securing channels for each of the depths named
in the act, namely, 20, 22, and 24 feet, estimated to cost, respec-
tively, $216,100, $485,990, and $750,262.
   2. Preliminary examination and survey of Echo Bay, New York.-
Reports dated April 24, 1907, and September 14, 1908, respectively,
are printed in House Document No. 1118, Sixtieth Congress, second
session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of $22,110
is presented.
   3. Preliminary examination and survey of Port Chester Harbor, New
York, with a view to obtaining a depth of 15 feet with corresponding
width.-Reports dated August 20, 1907, and October 31, 1908, are
printed in House Document No. 1165, Sixtieth Congress, second
session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of $188,000
is presented.
   4. Resurvey of East River and Hell Gate, New York, including any
ledge or ledges near to the westerly shore.-Report dated November
13, 1908, is printed in House Document No. 1187, Sixtieth Congress,
second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of
$1,733,000 is presented.
   5. Preliminary examination and survey of East Chester Creek, New
York, with a view to obtaining a depth of 12 feet.-Reports dated
August 24, 1907, and November 30, 1908, respectively, are printed
in House Document No. 1250, Sixtieth Congress, second session.
A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of $103,000 is pre-
sented.
   6. Preliminary examination and survey of the waters of Jamaica
Bay, including entrance to said bay at Rockaway Inlet and those waters
having their outlet in Dead Horse Inlet, etc.-Reports dated August
3, 1907, and January 30, 1909, are printed in House Document No.
1488, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan is presented for
improvement at an estimated cost to the United States of $7,430,000,
provided additional work contemplated by the project is undertaken
and executed by local authorities and the expense thereof borne
by them.

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE SECOND NEW YORK,
                   NEW YORK, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the immediate charge of Brig. Gen. W. L.
Marshall, Chief of Engineers, U. S. Army, to July 22, 1908, and of
Col. S. W. Roessler, Corps of Engineers, since that date, having under
his immediate orders Capt. Hubert L. Wigmore, Corps of Engineers,
since October 11, 1908. Division engineer, Col. D. W. Lockwood,
Corps of Engineers.
   1. 'New York Harbor, New York.-There are at present two
channels of approach to New York Harbor, the Main Ship-Bayside-
Gedney channel and the new Ambrose channel.
   Main Ship-Bayside-Gedney channel.-Before improvement by the
United States, this channel carried a depth of 23.7 feet across the
outer bar at mean low water, and about the same depth across three
other shoals between the bar and deep water in the harbor. A large
proportion of the commerce of the port, carried in vessels of greater
draft, could cross these shoals only at or near high water.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     159
   The project for the improvement of the outer portion of this
channel, known as Gedney channel, was approved by the Secretary
of War, December, 1884, under the provision of the river and harbor
act of 1884, and in 1886 was extended to cover the whole of the main
entrance. It provided for dredging a channel 30 feet deep at mean
low water, and 1,000 feet wide, between the sea and deep water at the
Narrows. The estimated cost was $1,490,000 for dredging 4,300,000
cubic yards. The work was substantially completed in October, 1891,
by the dredging of 4,875,079 cubic yards.
   The maintenance of this route has been carried on under a project
approved November 15, 1892, under the provision of river and harbor
act of July 13, 1892. The total expended in maintenances for the
period of seventeen years since completion of project in 1892 is
$687,897.28. The cost has been increasing from year to year and the
present estimated amount required for maintaining the channel to
full width and depth is $100,000 per year. It would not have been
below this for several years if the channel had been kept its full width
of 1,000 feet. The amount expended in original excavation was
$1,518,024.52.
   These expenditures have resulted in maintaining a channel 30 feet
deep at mean low water for a width of 1,000 feet or over, except on
the Main Ship channel where the width has varied from 600 to 800
feet.
   The work of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, has consisted in
the removal of 73,681 cubic yards of mud and sand from the west side
of the Main Ship channel where the accretions are continuous and
greatest, due to the set of the tidal current across the course of the
channel. Bayside and Gedney portions of the channel are further
seaward and more nearly true with the tide currents and require
comparatively little dredging to maintain the full width and depth.
   The length of that part of New York Harbor included in the limits
of the project (from Atlantic Ocean to the Battery, New York City)
is 221miles. The dredging has extended over about 8 miles of this
route. The mean rise of tide is 4 feet.
   Ambrose channel.-Ambrose channel (formerly known as East chan-
nel) had an original available depth of 16 feet at mean low water and
was used only by towboats, scows, and very light draft vessels. By
the terms of the river and harbor act of 1899 a project was adopted
for making an entrance to New York Harbor by this channel, to be
2,000 feet wide and 40 feet deep at mean low water. It involved an
estimated excavation of about 42,500,000 cubic yards of material for
a length of 7 miles of channel. The work was authorized to be done
under a continuing contract at a cost not exceeding $4,000,000.
Under the act of March 3, 1903, two United States dredges were built
to supplement the contract work, which was far behind the required
rates. In October, 1906, the contractor abandoned the work, and
the river and harbor act of 1907 authorized the building of two more
United States dredges, at the same time changing the authorized
limit of expenditure to $5,148,510. The sum of $324,510 is yet to be
appropriated under the contract authorization.
   To July 1, 1909, $4,197,932.47 has been expended in building four
dredges and in excavating 42,911,791 cubic yards of sand, mud, and
stones. (For details of dredge construction see Appendix H 10.)
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, four United States
dredges were continuously engaged upon this work, excavating
160      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

10,786,638 cubic yards of sand and mud; and under contract for re-
moving old stone dumps from the channel, 6,889 cubic yards of stones
mixed with sand were taken out.
   Ambrose channel has now a depth of 40 feet at mean low water,
with width of about 1,000 feet. It is easily navigable at mean low
tide for ships of 37 feet draft going at moderate speed, and has a
maximum high water capacity of 44 feet. The project is regarded
as about three-quarters completed.
   This channel was first buoyed for navigation in September, 1907,
and regulations were issued by the Secretary of War, under authority
of law, restricting its use to daylight navigation by ships of 29 feet
draft or over, or of 600 feet length or over. As the improvements
progressed it became practicable to remove most of this restriction,
and under authority of act of Congress of March 3, 1909, regulations
were issued permitting use of the channel by day or night by all
steamships or steamers not having tows, regardless of size. This was
promptly made use of and now the channel is used by practically all
of the transatlantic lines and many of the others.
   Removal of submerged reef in North River, near Pier "A," Mlan-
hattan.-By the river and harbor act of 1905 the removal of a rock in
North River near pier 1 was authorized, and funds were provided by
withdrawing $20,000 from the Ambrose channel appropriation, in
addition to $25,000 similarly diverted by joint resolution of Congress
approved July 1, 1902. A contract was entered into for the entire
removal of the rock to 40 feet depth, at cost of $40,000; the whole
area of the rock had been drilled and blasted, and 363 cubic yards
of rock removed up to August 11, 1908, when the contractor with-
drew his plant and failed to resume work until the contract expired
by limitation. A new contract was entered into to complete the
work of removal, under which about 60 cubic yards of solid rock have
been taken out. The total amount expended on the rock to July 1,
1909, is $5,712.45.
   The foreign exports and imports for the port of New York during
the year ending June 30, 1908, amounted approximately to 12,541,419
tons, valued at $1,613,031,266, being an increase over the valua-
tion of 1886, before improvement of the entrance was begun, of
 $772,754,574. The entire cost of the improvement of New York
Harbor up to date is less than 1 per cent of the increase in valuation
of foreign commerce alone for this port since the improvement began,
and less than one-half of 1 per cent of the present annual value of for-
eign commerce.
    No statistics of local and coastwise domestic commerce are kept.
    It is impossible to estimate the effect of the improvement upon
freight rates. During 1908, 124 different ships, drawing 27 feet or
more, made 484 trips outward and 137 trips inward. Prior to the
improvement none of these ships could have crossed the bar to enter
or leave the harbor except at extreme high tide or after lightering.
    Further details of the harbor and improvements are printed in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 1031.
    A general description of the harbor, of the different channels, of
the main entrance, and of the projects for improvement is printed
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1901, pages
1285-1287. A map of the harbor is printed in the Annual Report for
1903, page 914.
                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                161
                                               GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended--------.....-----.........---..----------------..................                    $58, 189. 49
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909-------...-----...------------.............--------........------.................---.....------..     100, 000. 00
                                                                                                                      158, 189. 49
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement-----...-------...-------.....---.....---.--.----------...--.......------......                           59, 586. 77

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......---...------..-...................
                                               ----------------------                                                  98, 602. 72
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance
  unexpended July 1, 1909..........................................                                                   150, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                                   AMBROSE CHANNEL.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............--.. . ....................                                             a$793, 653. 23
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909 ........                                               627, 000. 00
Received from sale of property and maps ................... .............                                                  b52. 70
                                                                                    1, 420, 705. 93
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For construction of dredges .....-.....................           $345, 958. 34
    For works of improvement..........                 ..............  480, 428. 32
    Deposited to credit of Delaware River appropriation....             11, 163. 07
    Transfer settlements.................................                     3. 68
                                                                                       837, 553. 41

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .............................                                           .......      583, 152. 52
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. .....................................                                           34, 325. 31

July 1, 1909, balance available ...............                               .....................                   548, 827. 21

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                                              324, 510. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpendod July 1, 1909:
    For works of improvement...........................$324, 510. 00
    For maintenance of improvement. ..................      195, 490. 00
                                                                                                                      520, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                           OBSTRUCTION IN NORTH RIVER.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.............................                                                         $39, 708. 75
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ..............................................................                                                      421. 20

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................                               .....................                  39, 287. 55
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ........                         .......................                          2, 080. 20

July 1, 1909, balance available.....................................                                                   37, 207. 35

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..................                                               35, 367. 80
     (See Appendix F 1.)

  a Includes $182.04 in the hands of Major Deakyne for dredge construction.
  b Includes $15.50 received by Major Deakyne for sale of property in connection
with dredge construction.
          9001-ENG 1909-                 11
162     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

   2. Channel in Gowanus Bay, New York Harbor, New York--Bay
Ridge and Red Hook channels.-These channels lie along the east shore
of the upper bay, New York Harbor, and with Buttermilk channel
form an easterly channel between the Narrows and East River,
separated from the main channel by a broad shoal off Gowanus Bay
and by Governors Island.
   Bay Ridge and Red Hook channels had a natural low-water depth
of 7 to 12 feet and were available only for a limited harbor commerce.
   The original project, adopted in 1881, provided for making these
channels 18 feet deep and 200 feet wide, and was subsequently modi-
fied to make the depth 26 feet and width of 800 feet in Bay Ridge
channel and 400 feet. in Red Hook channel. This was completed in
1899 at a cost of about $1,090,000.
   The existing project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
1899, which provided for making Bay Ridge and Red Hook channels
40 feet deep at mean low water and 1,200 feet wide. The work was
authorized to be done under a continuing contract at a cost not ex-
ceeding $2,500,000, of which $491,000 remains to be appropriated.
Such a contract was entered into in 1899 for excavating about
22,000,000 cubic yards of material and completing the project. Work
was begun in 1900 and prosecuted until November, 1906, generally at
rates of progress less than required by the original contract. Novem-
ber 24, 1906, the last of the dredges was withdrawn from the work;
the plant had been sold by the contractors, and the new owners re-
fused to continue dredging. The contractors failed to resume work
when called upon, and the contract was annulled February 20, 1907.
   The river and harbor act approved March 2, 1907, authorized the
prosecution of the improvement of these channels with a view to
obtaining first a depth of 35 feet and subsequently the full depth of
40 feet and width of 1,200 feet, in accordance with the project adopted
in 1899. A new contract for continuing work under the project
with the funds available was thereupon entered into in 1907 and com-
pleted in April, 1909.
   Under this later project, up to June 30, 1909, $1,615,435.93 has
been expended in dredging 14,449,116 cubic yards of sand and mud,
which is about 66 per cent of the amount estimated to complete the
project. In its present condition Bay Ridge channel has an avail-
able depth of 35 feet at mean low water, with width of 1,000 to 1,060
feet, except at the arm toward Gowanus Creek, where the harbor
lines converge. Red Hook channel has 30 feet available depth for a
width of 1,000 feet.
   The total length of channel covered by the improvement is 41
miles; the mean rise of tide is 41 feet.
   During the year ending June 30, 1909, 799,727 cubic yards of sand
and mud were dredged, widening Bay Ridge channel, removing
shoals, and extending it to its junction with Gowanus Creek, and in
widening Red Hook channel to 1,000 feet width and 30 feet depth.
   With funds now available, a contract is about to be entered into
for widening Bay Ridge channel to 1,200 feet, with 35 feet depth;
widening Red Hook channel to 1,200 feet, with 30 feet depth, and
deepening the latter to 35 feet for such width as is practicable with
the funds, estimated about 350 feet. Future appropriations will be
applied to deepening Bay Ridge channel to 40 feet and to widening
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       163
the 35-foot depths in Red Hook channel to 1,200 feet width and to
making the channel 40 feet deep, the dimensions contemplated in
the project adopted by Congress.
   Since the failure of the original contract for completion of the
present project it has been evident that no prices can be obtained
which would permit of completing the whole within the limit of
authority of 1899. A survey has been made upon which a new esti-
mate for completion has been prepared, amounting to $1,450,000.
   The commerce of this part of the port of New York consists of
coffee, sugar, cotton, coal, and miscellaneous freights, chiefly from
foreign ports. In 1908 it amounted to approximately 4,287,900 tons,
of an estimated value of $221,488,000.
   Further details concerning these channels are contained in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1899, page 1266.
   House Document No. 337, Fifty-fourth Congress, second session,
contains a report upon a survey of these channels, with map showing
locations and depths as existing in 1897. (See Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1897, p. 1177.)
   The effect of the improvement projected is undoubtedly to lower
freight rates; these rates depend so largely upon the amount of busi-
ness in hand and upon competition that it is impracticable to sepa-
rate the effect of the improvement upon rates. A notable effect has
been the growth of foreign commerce and the class of ships which
carry it, many of which could not have entered Bay Ridge channel
before its improvement.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................                     $262, 361. 01
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.....                      310, 000. 00
                                                                                          572, 361.01
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement..........................................     .......                         178, 769.14

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......               ...          ...................     393, 591. 87
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.............................                         45, 970. 20

July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................                       347, 621. 67
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                  1, 450, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 ..................................     ........                    315,000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897.
    (See Appendix F 2.)
   3. Enlargement of Governors Island, New York Harbor, New York.-
The project for this entire work, adopted under the terms of the sun-
dry civil act of 1901, which made appropriations for beginning opera-
tions, included an addition of about 82 acres to the area of the island
by inclosing with a bulkhead part of the shoal southwest of the
island and filling the inclosure, the building of a wharf on the north
shore and dredging to a depth of 26 feet in front of the wharf, and
the erection of buildings. The work of enlargement, including con-
struction of a wharf and dredging, all estimated to cost $1,100,000,
was assigned to the Engineer Department. By a modification of
164          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                     S. ARMY.

the project adopted in April, 1902, the enlargement was to be ex-
tended southwest over the shoal to reclaim an additional area of
about 19 acres, making the total area of the enlargement about 101
acres. This may necessitate an increase in the estimate of cost to
cover this work, and construction of about 600 feet of sea wall around
it, and the preparation of the sand embankment for growing grass
by covering it with clay and loam; but the amount can not be defi-
nitely stated pending a determination of the details of the plan.
   Work was begun in August, 1901, and up to June 30, 1909,
$885,248.90 has been expended.
   During the fiscal year 1,124,388 cubic yards of filling material was
delivered in the inclosure, of which 638,339 yards were placed above
mean low water in the embankment, under a contract completed in
June, 1909; minor repairs were made to the sea wall; and a light and
fog bell were maintained at the southwest curve of the sea wall.
   The entire work done to June 30, 1909, consists in building a pile
wharf, with a T head, 370 feet long, dredging the approaches 26 feet
deep, laying intercepting sewers, building 6,795 linear feet of riprap
bulkhead to inclose the area of enlargement, and upon the bulkhead
building 6,775 linear feet of masonry sea wall, and in building an
embankment to cover 80 acres above low water.
   The sea wall is completed, except a gap of 350 feet clear width,
left to permit bringing in material for the embankment.
   The available funds will be applied to completing sea wall and
embankment construction.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................... $328, 287. 53
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......    75, 000. 00
                                                                                                    403, 287. 53
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment.........------.................................................----...---------------.       188, 533. 83

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..---..                    -..- -.....--
                                                        - ..-         --..- ....----......--.....   214, 753. 70
   (See Appendix F 3.)
   4. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navi-
gation- Wreck of steamship Finance.-This ship, belonging to the
Panama Steamship Company, sunk November 26, 1908, north of
Bayside channel, as result of a collision in a dense fog.
   The wreck was marked with a gas buoy during winter, and when
the season made work in this locality practicable a contract was
entered into for removal of the wreck for the sum of $23,950, under
which work is in progress.
    Wreck of steamship Daghestan.-This British ship, outward bound,
collided with another ship on December 18, 1908, and after floating
several hours sunk in 65 feet of water about 3 miles outside the
harbor entrance. The obstruction was marked with gas and bell
buoys.
   On May 28 a contract was entered into for removal of so much of
the wreck as necessary to make a clean depth over it of 50 feet at
mean low water, for the sum of $33,700.
   Removal is about to begin.
    Wreck of barge Win. H. Connor.--This barge, in tow, collided with a
schooner near the entrance to the harbor on or about April 22, 1909;
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    165
she was towed to the edge of the channel and grounded in 22 feet of
water.
   A contract for her removal is about to be made at cost of $3,000.
   The total amount expended during the fiscal year for the removal
of wrecks was $129.45.
   (See Appendix F 4.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE THIRD NEW YORK,
                    NEW YORK, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Col. D. W. Lockwood, Corps of
Engineers, division engineer, eastern division.
   1. PassaicRiver, New Jersey.-This river is a stream of consider-
able size, rising among the highlands in the northern part of New
Jersey and flowing in a generally easterly and southerly course into
Newark Bay. It is navigable from its mouth to Passaic, a distance
of about 16 miles, where navigation is cut off by the Dundee Water
Power and Land Company's dam. In its natural condition the
navigable depth to Newark was about 7 feet at mean low water; from
Newark to Passaic it was about 3 feet.
   The first project for improvement, adopted by the river and harbor
act of June 10, 1872, was for providing a channel, by diking and
dredging, from Newark to Passaic from 6 to 7 feet deep and from 50
to 200 feet wide, the first cost being estimated at $123,924. This
was subsequently increased to $193,822.
   The second project was for improving the river below Newark and
was authorized by the river and harbor act of June 14, 1880, at an
estimated cost of $353,875. It proposed a channel 200 feet wide and
10 feet deep at mean low water up to Center Street Bridge, Newark.
   The two projects were consolidated by the river and harbor act of
July 13, 1892, the estimated cost of the improvement being $547,697.
   The amount expended under this consolidated project up to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $499,779.68, of
which $389,61.0 was used in carrying out the projects and $110,169.68
for maintenance.
   Existing projects: That adopted by the act of June 13, 1902, in
accordance with the report submitted in House Document No. 401,
Fifty-sixth Congress, first session, provides for making a channel from
Staten Island Sound through Newark Bay and the said river to the
Montclair and Greenwood Lake Railroad bridge 12 feet deep to the
Nairn Linoleum Works, and 10 feet deep from that point to the said
railroad bridge, a total distance of 10.8 miles. The estimated cost
was originally $296,000, but was subsequently increased, additional
funds having been appropriated by the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1905, and may now be stated at $323,274.60. Work under
this project was authorized to be done under continuing contracts,
the total amount of the contract authorization being now appropriated.
The yearly cost of maintenence is estimated at $10,000. The amount
expended on this project up to the close of the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, was $279,822.63.
   By the passage of the river and harbor act approved March 2, 1907,
a project has been adopted which provides for making a channel 16
feet deep at mean low water, 300 feet wide from deep water in Newark
166     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.


Bay to the Nairn Linoleum Works, 9.7 miles, thence 200 feet wide
to the Montclair and Greenwood Lake Railroad bridge, 1.1 miles, in
accordance with the report submitted in House Document No. 441,
Fifty-ninth Congress, second session, estimated to cost $1,216,775.
The act provides for an expenditure of $850,000 for prosecuting the
work, of which $385,000 is yet to be appropriated under continuing-
contract authorization. The amount expended on this project to
the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $262,775.40.
   The projects of 1902 and 1907 for the lower part of the river include
or supersede the part of the old project below Newark, but leave
in force the part above Newark which is included between the Mont-
clair and Greenwood Lake Railroad bridge and the city of Passaic, a
distance of 6 miles, as stated under head of "first project" above.
Up to June 30, 1909, $209,953.14 had been expended on this part of
the project, of which $150,734 was expended for the project and
$59,219.14 for maintenance work. The annual cost of maintenance
is estimated at $5,000. This project is practically completed, a
depth of 6 feet at mean low water and width of about 100 feet having
been obtained.
   During the past fiscal year dredging has been carried on under
three contracts:
   1. Under project of June 13, 1902, operations consisted in dredging
under a continuing contract with P. Sanford Ross (Incorporated),
86,547 cubic yards of material being removed. Work was in prog-
ress at the beginning of the year, and the contract was completed
on December 5, 1908, when the total amount of material removed
was 707,897 cubic yards.
   2. Under project of June 13, 1902, operations consisted in dredging
under contract with the International Contracting Company, 2,468
cubic yards of material being removed. Work was in progress and
contract nearly completed at.the begininng of the year. The con-
tract was completed on July 8, 1908, when the total amount of
material removed was 157,502 cubic yards.
   Channels of 12 feet depth and 200 feet in width have been com-
pleted from Newark Bay to the Nairn Linoleum Works, and of 10
feet depth and about 200 feet width to the Montclair and Greenwood
Lake Railroad bridge. This project is nearly completed. There
remains a little widening to be done just below the said railroad
bridge.
   3. Under project of March 2, 1907, operations consisted in dredg-
ing under a continuing contract. Dredging was in progress at the
beginning of the year, at which time 779,708 cubic yards of material
had been removed from Newark Bay and Passaic River, and the
16-foot channel had been carried through the bay and lower end of
the river with width of about 150 feet for an aggregate distance of
about 4 miles. Dredging was continued through the year, and
1,069,748 cubic yards of material were removed. The 16-foot chan-
nel was widened and nearly extended to the Center Street railroad
bridge, Newark, a distance of about 8 miles from the beginning of
the work in Newark Bay, with widths of from 150 to 200 feet.
   The maximum drafts that could be carried June 30, 1909, were as
follows: Sixteen, 12, and 10 feet, as above stated, below the Mont-
clair and Greenwood Lake Railroad bridge, and 6 feet from that
                          RIVER AND HA1RBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                        167
bridge to the city of Passaic. Mean range of tides: At mouth of
river, 4.7 feet, and at Passaic, 2.5 feet.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance and the amount esti-
mated as a profitable expenditure to continuation and maintenance
of the improvement in accordance with the adopted projects.
   The commerce of this river is mainly in building material, iron ore,
fertilizers, coal, and general merchandise, and amounted to 2,037,363
tons in 1900, to 2,009,356 tons in 1901, to 2,494,312 tons in 1902, to.
2,356,511 tons in 1903, to 2,567,942 tons in 1904, to 2,567,000 tons in
1905, to 2,577,188 tons in1906 and 1907, valued at $167,113,305, and
in 1908 to 2,110,959 tons, valued at $171,612,700, including the com-
merce of Hackensack River, which passes through Newark Bay.
Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short
tons.
   This improvement is necessary to the great industrial interests, and
has reduced freight rates $1 a ton on coal and building materials, and
its continuance isnecessary to the successful carrying on of the busi-
ness of this locality.
   Details as to this improvement may be found in the Annual Reports
of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, pages 770-774, and for 1900, pages
177, 1530-1550.
   Reference to reports of examinations and surveys is noted in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, page 156. Report
upon preliminary examination of Newark Bay, ordered by river and
harbor act approved March 3, 1909, was made on April 23, 1909.
   Maps showing mouth of river and Newark Bay are printed in the
Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1882, page 686, and 1887,
page 766, and maps of the river in the vicinity of and above Newark
are printed in House Document No. 401, Fifty-sixth Congress, first
session, and of the full length of the bay and river under improvement
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 1030.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................... $292, 123. 25
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 200, 000. 00
Received from sale of maps during the year.............    ..................  30. 30
                                                                                          492, 153. 55
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...........................                   $192, 069. 71
    For maintenance of improvement...................                             2. 60
                                                                                          192, 072. 31

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                     300, 081. 24
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..................................                    55, 194. 01

July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................                       244, 887. 23

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts...............                      378, 243. 77
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                   751, 775. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for work of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909......................................................                      150, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
    (See Appendix G 1.)
168     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S. ARMY.

   2. Arthur Kill, or Staten Island Sound, and channel between Staten
Island and New Jersey.-(a) Arthur Kill, or Staten Island Sound,
New York and New Jersey.-This is a waterway about 12 miles long,
which, together with the lower end of Newark Bay, 2 miles long, and
the Kill van Kull, 3 miles long, forms the inland waterway between
upper New York Harbor and Raritan Bay. The section now con-
templated under this improvement consists of the 14 miles of channel
between Kill van Kull and Raritan Bay. The original depth through
the Arthur Kill, or Staten Island Sound, at mean low water was 15
feet and upward, in a channel 100 to 1,000 feet in width. Through
the lower end of Newark Bay the navigable channel depth was about
14 feet at mean low water, the result of an improvement commenced
in 1874 and continued up to the present time. In the present project
the new channel was cut through the flats to the southward of the
original channel on which the depth was 1 to 2 feet at mean low
water.
   Projects: Sections of this waterway have been under improvement
by the United States under the titles of "Channel between Staten
Island and New Jersey," adopted in 1880, superseding the project of
1874, and "Arthur Kill," adopted in 1888. The former provided for
a depth of 14 feet and width of 400 feet through the lower part of
Newark Bay, and the latter for the removal of Steep Point, in order
to straighten the channel to the southwestward of the Baltimore and
Ohio Railroad bridge.
   Details and references as to these projects are printed in current
report under the head of "Channel between Staten Island and New
Jersey," which project is still in force.
   The existing project for this improvement, adopted by the river
and harbor act approved June 13, 1902, provides for making and
maintaining a channel from Kill van Kull to Raritan Bay, New York
and New Jersey, by means of dredging and diking, 300 feet wide
and 21 feet deep at mean low water, at an estimated cost of $696,000,
and $5,000 for annual cost of maintenance. Work under this project
is authorized to be done under continuing contracts, $91,000 of the
authorization still remaining to be appropriated. The amount
expended on the project to June 30, 1909, was $446,924.43; of this
amount $22.10 was derived from the sale of maps.
   Operations during the past fiscal year consisted in dredging, under
a continuing contract, approved by the Department on October 27,
1903, upon which work was commenced on December 2, 1903. Dur-
ing the year 593,926 cubic yards of material were removed from
several sections of the channel between Shooters Island and Carteret.
About six-sevenths of the dredging contemplated by this project has
been completed, and the 21-foot channel has been dredged through
the waterway, with widths of about 300 feet. Shoaling in the upper
p art of the channel, particularly in the vicinity of Corner Stake
light, has reduced the depth to about 18 feet at mean low water.
This will be redredged under contract in force and in progress.
   The maximum draft that could be carried through the waterway
on June 30, 1909, was 18 to 20 feet at mean low water. Mean range
of tides, 5 feet.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure to rock removal in continuing the improvement and to
dredging for maintenance in accordance with the adopted project.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                          169
   The freight carried through this waterway consists of oil, coal,
ores, clay products, chemicals, fertilizers, grain, machinery, manufac-
tures, and general merchandise, and amounted in 1899 to 11,311,991
tons, in 1900 to 11,047,633 tons, in 1901 to 11,651,300 tons, in 1902
to 14,517,079 tons, in 1903 to 11,512,420 tons, in 1905 to 11,721,861
tons, valued at $265,193,813, in 1906 to 16,574,840 tons, valued at
$355,579,817, in 1907 to 14,948,077 tons, valued at $245,032,666,
and in 1908 to 15,995,231 tons, valued at $239,395,113. Tonnage
reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.
   It appears from inquiry that no estimate can be made of the exact
effect of the project on freight rates, except to the local commerce.
The rates on this have been reduced by this improvement, and will
be further reduced when the improvement has advanced to the extent
of providing a practicable navigable channel of 21 feet.
   References to reports of examinations and surveys are noted in the
Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 137, and
for 1907, pages 157 and 158.
   Report on preliminary examination of Arthur Kill at the westerly
side of Buckwheat Island is printed in House Document No. 533,
Sixtieth Congress, first session, and in Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1906, page 167.
   Maps of this work are printed in House Document No. 393, Fifty-
sixth Congress, first session, and in the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1905, page 1034.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................... $113, 558. 05
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909 ...... 150, 000. 00
Received from sale of maps during the year ...............................         5. 80
                                                                             263, 563. 85
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of im-
  provement........................................................          105, 465.48

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................       158, 098. 37
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................    31, 365. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................        126, 733. 37
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................         83, 982. 94
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........       91, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
    For works of improvement ..........................     $30, 000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement.......................    10, 000. 00
                                                                              40, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Channel between Staten Island and New Jersey.-This channel
is an inland waterway, about 17 miles long, connecting New York
Harbor with Raritan Bay. It consists of the Kill van Kull, connect-
ing the upper bay with Newark Bay, and the Arthur Kill, connecting
Newark Bay with Raritan Bay.
   The natural depth through the channel was 15 feet or more, except
for a distance of about 14 miles in Newark Bay, where there was a
shoal with a crooked channel 9 feet deep, bordered by flats with
depth of about 2 feet of water. The improvement of the "channel
between Staten Island and New Jersey" consists in the deepening of
the channel across this shoal.
170     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S.   ARMY.

   The first project, adopted by the river and harbor act of June 23,
1874, was for making this channel from 14 to 16 feet deep, at an esti-
mated cost of $443,211. The only work done under it was the build-
ing of 2,237 linear feet of diking, at a cost of $50,000.
   The second and existing project was adopted in 1880, which, with
subsequent modifications, proposed to dredge through the shoal a
channel 400 feet wide and 14 feet deep at mean low water, the cost
being estimated at $210,000.
   A supplemental project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
August 11, 1888, which had for its object the removal of the point of
land known as "Steep Point," for the straightening of the channel
to the westward of the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad bridge. This
work was carried on under the title of "Improvement of Arthur Kill,
New York and New Jersey," 1888-1895. The cost was estimated at
$26,500, and the work was completed in 1895, at a cost of $25,401.30.
This modification of the project brought the total cost of the im-
provement up to $286,500.
   The river and harbor acts of June 3, 1896, and June 13, 1902, ex-
tended the project to include the dredging of a channel in Lemon
Creek, on Staten Island, at a cost of $5,000 and $5,000, respectively.
   This extension increased the total estimated cost of the improve-
ment from the beginning to $296,500. Annual maintenance is esti-
mated at $10,000.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, on the project, with
its additions and modifications, was $308,829.84, which was applied
to diking, to dredging a channel 14 feet deep and 400 feet wide
through the shoal in Newark Bay, to removing Steep Point, and to
dredging a channel in Lemon Creek 8 feet deep at high water and
from 35 to 50 feet wide; $206,635.08 has been expended in carrying
out the project and $102,194.76 for maintenance. The work con-
templated under this project has been completed.
   No work was done during the fiscal year, the expenditure being
for expenses connected with harbor line hearing; the channel was
reported to be in good condition, the result of dredging in the seasons
of 1906-7.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance and the amount
recommended as a profitable expenditure to the maintenance of the
improvement.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, through
the channel between Staten Island and New Jersey was about 14
feet at mean low water, and in Lemon Creek about 6 feet at mean
high water to the head of navigation, a distance of about one-half
mile from the mouth. Mean range of tides, 5 feet.
   The freight carried through this channel consists of oil, coal, ores,
clay products, chemicals, fertilizers, grain, machinery, manufac-
tures, and general merchandise, and amounted in 1899 to 11,311,991
tons, in 1901 to 11,651,300 tons, in 1902 to 16,266,574 tons, in 1903
to 14,129,678 tons, in 1905 to 14,339,120 tons, valued at $325,625,465,
and in 1906 to 17,097,799 tons, valued at $396,266,084. No report
has been received since 1906. A part of the commerce now passes
through the new "Arthur Kill channel," which has been dredged
south of the old channel and Corner Stake light.
   The commerce of Lemon Creek as given by the last report in 1907
has an estimated value of $435,000; number of vessels in use, 50 to
75, draft 3 to 6 feet, with a valuation of $145,000.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          171
  This is a connecting channel and no estimate can be made of the
exact effect on the rates of freight, but it is known that the present
commerce could not be carried on without this improvement.
  Further details as to this improvement may be found in the Annual
Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1887, Part 1, page 743; for
1890, page 843; for 1896, page 775; for 1897, pages 1130-1132, and
for 1900, page 1525.
  Reference to reports on examinations and surveys are noted in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, page 160.
Maps of this improvement are printed in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1881, page 696; 1889, pages 820-822; 1890,
page 844, and 1905, page 1036, and in House Document No. 393,
Fifty-sixth Congress, first session. Map of Lemon Creek is printed
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 1036.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended                        -.....--..... ...............-- ..... $2, 703. 56
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement       ..............................................                                 33.40

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                         2, 670. 16

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909....................................                20, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                              CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...........      ........................      $116, 261. 61
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 150, 000. 00
Received from sale of maps during the year ...........................    ....         5. 80
                                                                                           266, 267. 41
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .........................                    $105, 465. 48
    For maintenance of improvement...                  ...............           33. 40
                                                                                           105, 498. 88

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended........................................                   160, 768. 53
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.......................................                31, 365. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                      129, 403. 53

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .............                         83, 982. 94
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                     91, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
      For works of improvement............................       $30, 000. 00
      For maintenance of improvement ...................          30, 000. 00
                                                                   . .                      60, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix G 2.)
   3. Woodbridge Creek, New Jersey.-This creek is a small, crooked
tidal stream, about 5 miles long, running through flat marshes for
most of its length and emptying into the west side of Arthur Kill, or
Staten Island Sound, 2 miles north of Perth Amboy, N. J.
   It is navigable for 21 miles above the mouth to a point where it
is crossed by a highway bridge without a draw. The width of the
creek below this bridge is about 100 feet. In its original condition
172     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

this stream was obstructed at its mouth by a bar having a least depth
of 9.8 feet at high water, and by two shoals just inside the mouth.
From these shoals a good 12-foot channel existed to above Anderson's
brickworks, seven-eights of a mile from the mouth, above which
point, however, many shoals occurred, although a narrow 8-foot chan-
nel existed as far as Salamander dock, 1- miles from the mouth.
   First project: A survey of the navigable part of this creek was
made in 1878, reference to which is made on page 139 of the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, and a project for its im-
provement was adopted by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1879.
This project provided for forming a channel 12 feet deep at mean
high water and 80 feet wide from the mouth of the creek to the Sala-
mander dock at an estimated cost of $13,800, which amount was in-
creased in 1884 to $29,000. Work on this improvement was carried
on under appropriations made from 1879 to 1882, amounting to
$19,000, which was expended without completing the project, and was
suspended in 1883, and in 1900 the channel had relapsed to its origi-
nal condition.
   The existing project, adopted by the river and harbor act of June
13, 1902, contemplates obtaining a channel 8 feet deep at mean low
water, with a bottom width of 50 feet, by dredging, from Arthur
Kill to Salamander dock, at an estimated cost of $35,000 for the im-
provement and $3,000 annually for maintenance. Reference to this
project, and of the examination and survey upon which it is based, is
contained in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904,
page 139.
   The amount expended on the work of existing project up to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $42,329.64, of which
$30,822.70 was used in carrying out the project and $11,506.94 for
maintenance. No work was done during the fiscal year. Project for
the expenditure of the allotment of $6,000 for maintenance, act of
March 3, 1909, was approved March 19. The work was advertised,
and proposals were opened on June 8. A contract for dredging was
in course of preparation at the close of the year. At the close of the
last work, January, 1908, the channel was practically restored to
proposed dimensions and the project completed. Expenditures were
for office expenses and contingencies.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, over the
shoalest part of the channel was 6 to 7 feet at mean low water. The
mean range of tides is 5 feet.
   The commerce of this creek, mainly in clay, brick, tile, coal, tin
scrap, steel scrap, and building materials, amounted in 1887 to
126,000 tons, in 1898 to 176,000 tons, in 1903 to 155,751 tons, in 1904
to 165,313 tons; in 1905 to 160,194 tons, valued at $1,018,198; in
1906 to 167,392 tons, valued at $1,128,237; in 1907 to 151,671 tons,
valued at $1,071,548; and in 1908 to 163,120 tons, valued at $791,700.
Tonnage heretofore reported in gross tons; reported this year in
short tons.
   It appears from inquiry that freight rates have been reduced as a
result of this improvement.
   It is proposed to apply the sum estimated as a profitable expendi-
ture to maintenance of improvement.
                               RIVER        AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       173
   Maps of the creek are printed in House Document No. 282, Fifty-
sixth Congress, first session, and in Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1905, page 1036.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................   ..................                                               $928.16
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act ap-
  proved March 3, 1909...................................... ....         ......                                       6, 000. 00
                                                                                                                       6, 928. 16
June 30, 1909, amount expended during -fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement------...----...------..................................---------------------------------------........     507.80
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...............                                  ......................               6, 420. 36
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909............. .......                       . ........                                            6,
                                                                                                                       8.........
                                                                                                                          000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix G 3.)
   4. Raritan Bay, New Jersey.-This bay is a large body of water
lying between the southern end of Staten Island and the New Jersey
shore. Its greatest width north and south is about 5 miles and its
greatest length east and west is about 7 miles. The Raritan River
empties into it at its west end, between Perth Amboy and South
Amboy, and the Arthur Kill, or Staten Island Sound, extends north-
ward, connecting it with Newark Bay.
   This bay had naturally a fairly straight channel, 11 feet deep, to
South Amboy. The line of the deepest water, however, followed the
Staten Island shore from Perth Amboy to Seguine Point, where it
was separated from deep water in the eastern part of the bay by a
shoal 1.5 miles broad, with a minimum depth of 14.5 feet.
   The original and existing project, adopted March 3, 1881, and ex-
tended September 19, 1890, and June 3, 1896, provides for dredging
channels 300 feet wide and 21 feet deep from Seguine Point to deep
water in the bay, a distance of about 1.5 miles, through two shoals
opposite Wards Point, 0.4 and 0.6 mile long, respectively, and from
South Amboy to deep water near Great Beds light, a distance of
about 1.5 miles. The estimated cost of the work is $507,875.
    Reference to reports on examinations and surveys are noted in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, pages 140 and 1158.
    The amount expended on the work up to the close of the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909, was $560,954.53, of which $297,314.45 was
used in carrying out the project and $263,640.08 for maintenance.
Of this amount $3 was derived from the sale of maps. The project
has been completed, and the only work now contemplated is mainte-
nance of the improvement.
    Operations during the fiscal year consisted in dredging under con-
tract for maintenance. Work was in progress at the beginning of the
fiscal year, and was continued until August 1, when the contract was
completed. The amount of material dredged during the year was
48,936 cubic yards, making the total amount removed under the con-
tract 105,990 cubic yards.
    Project for expenditure of the allotment of $20,000, act of March
3, 1909, was approved on March 19. Examinations of the channels
174           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                      S. ARMY.

were made, and preparation of specifications for maintenance dredg-
ing was in progress at the close of the year.
   It is proposed to apply the amount recommended as a profitable
expenditure for maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, through
the Wards Point, South Amboy, and Seguine Point channels was about
20 feet at mean low water. Mean range of tides, 5 feet.
  The commerce of the bay is mainly in coal, brick, refined lead and
copper, bullion, clay products, and general merchandise, and amount-
ed in 1901 to 4,722,048 tons, in 1902 to 5,453,122 tons, in 1903 to
4,484,152 tons, in 1905 to 5,296,986 tons; in 1906 to 6,432,245 tons,
valued at $114,358,610; in 1907 to 7,424,414 tons, valued at
$139,228,344; and in 1908 to 8,729,748 tons, valued at $136,550,115.
Tonnage heretofore reported in gross tons; reported this year in
short tons.
   It appears from statements of the shipping interests of the great
railroad terminals that the improvements have resulted in a great
reduction of towing rates and a proportionate reduction of freight
rates, owing to the greater quantity of coal that can be carried and
towed through these channels over that which was carried before the
improvement was made.
   Further details of this improvement are printed in the Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, pages 787-789. Maps are
printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905,
page 1038.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............     .................. $24, 787. 52
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act ap-
  proved March 3, 1909 .......................        ......................... 20, 000. 00
                                                                      44, 787. 52
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...............        ...........................      23, 239.05
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                         ..   21, 548. 47
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................                    .................              4. 80
July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                            21, 543. 67
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.....................................         .......                         40, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix G 4.)
   5. Keyport Harbor, Matawan Creek, Raritan, South, and Elizabeth
rivers, Shoal Harbor and Compton Creek, and Cheesequake Creek,
New Jersey.-(a) Keyport Harbor.-This harbor is situated at the
mouth of Matawan Creek, on the south side of Raritan Bay, 5 miles
east of the mouth of Raritan River, and it consists of a bay about
1 mile broad.
   There was no distinct natural channel in the harbor, the available
depth to the wharves being less than 4 feet at mean low water. A
6-foot channel had been dredged at private expense before the United
States assumed charge of the improvement, but it had shoaled again
to 3 feet.
   The original and existing project, approved August 2, 1882, with
subsequent modifications (1884), contemplates dredging a channel 8
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                        175
feet deep at mean low water about 4,700 feet long and 200 feet wide
from Raritan Bay to the steamboat dock at Keyport, at an estimated
cost of $40,475. Reference to report on examination and survey is
noted in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904,
page 141.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $68,197.39, of which
sum $30,500 was used in carrying out the project and $37,697.39 for
maintenance. A channel of the required length and nearly the pro-
posed width was completed in 1883-84. Recent appropriations have
been insufficient to maintain projected dimensions. The improve-
ment may now be considered as about half completed.
   Under an allotment of $8,705.97 from the consolidated appropria-
tion, act of March 2, 1907, a contract for dredging was in force and
preparations for beginning work were in progress at the beginning of
the year. Dredging was commenced on July 9, and the contract was
completed on August 26. The amount of material removed was
19,878 cubic yards. The channel was restored to 100 feet width and
8 feet depth for about one-half its length. The remainder of the
channel had a depth of about 7 feet at mean low water.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, to the
Keyport wharves was about 7 feet at mean low water. Mean range
of tides, 4.9 feet.
   The commerce of this harbor is mainly in farm products, fertilizers,
coal, lumber, fish, shellfish, and miscellaneous freight, and amounted
to 67,500 tons in 1899, to 45,000 tons in 1901, to 62,000 tons in 1903,
to 70,000 tons in 1904, to 86,821 tons in 1905, valued at $2,202,105, in
1906 to 229,377 tons, valued at $3,074,060, including the commerce
of Matawan Creek, in 1907 to 160,925 tons, valued at $3,275,305,
and in 1908 to 123,724 tons, valued at $3,146,800. Tonnage reported
heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.
   The effect of this improvement has been to greatly reduce freight
rates, especially in the marketing season.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance, and the amount esti-
mated as a profitable expenditure, for the completion and mainte-
nance of the improvement in accordance with the adopted project.
   Further details as to this work are printed in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, pages 1147-1148. Map is printed
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 1040.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................                  $9, 662. 14
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ........     ....       ... ...........              ... ............  5, 000. 00
                                                                                        14, 662. 14
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement............................................................................  8, 678. 56

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..........................................              5, 983. 58

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                9, 975. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909... .........            .....  ......                    (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                      a See consolidated money statement on page 183.
176     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

   (b) Matawan Creek.--This creek is a small tidal stream in the
eastern part of New Jersey which discharges into Raritan Bay at
Keyport Harbor. It is navigable up to the bridge of the New York
and Long Branch Railroad, about 2 miles above its mouth.
   In its natural condition the mouth was obstructed by a mud flat,
through which a narrow and crooked 3-foot channel existed. Above
this flat there was a 4-foot channel for a mile and beyond a narrow
3-foot channel extending nearly up to the head of navigation at
Matawan.
   The original and existing project for improving this stream, by
dredging a 4-foot channel 100 feet wide from the mouth to Winkson
Creek, about 1 mile, and thence 75 feet wide to the railroad bridge
at Matawan, was adopted March 3, 1881. The cost was estimated at
$33,120. Reference to report on examination and survey is noted in
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 141.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $56,480.31, of which
$21,000 was used in carrying out the project and $35,480.31 for main-
tenance. About two-thirds of the work proposed under the project
has been completed, and a channel has been dredged the required
distance with widths of 50 to 100 feet, but this channel has greatly
deteriorated.
   Dredging under contract was in progress at the beginning of the
year, at which time 1,258 cubic yards of material had been removed
near the mouth of the creek. The contract was completed on August
26. The total amount of material, mud and sand, removed in main-
tenance work during the fiscal year was 7,036 cubic yards. The
total amount dredged under the contract was 8,294 cubic yards.
   Project for expenditure of the allotment of $3,000, act of March
3, 1909, was approved March 20. Dredging for maintenance was
advertised and proposals were received on June 8, 1909, and at the
close of the year a contract for the proposed work was in preparation.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was about
3 feet at mean low water. Mean range of tides, 4.9 feet.
   The commerce of this creek is in brick and fireproofing, fertilizer,
farm produce, and general merchandise, and amounted to 51,000
tons in 1899; to 60,000 tons in 1901; to 61,500 tons in 1903; to 29,600
tons in 1904; to 58,471 tons in 1905, valued at $203,955; in 1906 to
128, 181 tons, valued at $717,505; in 1907 to 40,900 tons, valued at
$163,500; and in 1908 to 10,167 tons, valued at $38,265. Tonnage
heretofore reported in gross tons; reported for this year in short tons.
    The effect of this improvement has been to greatly reduce rates of
freight, especially in the marketing season. Recent appropriations
have been insufficient to maintain the channel in the upper part of
the creek, where the market boats load.
    It is proposed to expend the available balance and the amount
estimated as a profitable expenditure for completion and maintenance
of the project.
    Further details as to this improvement may be found in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 1145. Map is printed
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 1042.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                   177
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......                      ...................... $5, 887. 05
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ............................................                         3, 000. 00

                                                                                     8, 887. 05
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement..............................................                            5, 562. 97
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................                    3, 324. 08
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 12, 120. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ..............................      ...              (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Raritan River.-This river is a moderate-sized stream flowing
through the central part of the State of New Jersey and emptying
into Raritan Bay at Perth Amboy. It is navigable to New Bruns-
wick, N. J., a distance of 12 miles, where it is the eastern terminus of
the Delaware and Raritan Canal.
   In its natural state the channel to New Brunswick was obstructed
by several extensive shoals, on which the depth was from 64 to 84
feet at mean low water.
   The sum of $13,963, appropriated in the years 1836 and 1837, was
expended in removing obstructions from the river at New Brunswick.
   The existing project for improvement, adopted June 18, 1878, with
subsequent modifications, provides for a channel 200 feet wide and
10 feet deep from the mouth to the Delaware and Raritan Canal ter-
minus at New Brunswick, including a south channel between Crab
Island and Kearney's dock, with a length of about 21 miles, width
of 100 feet, and depth of 5 feet at mean low water, to be obtained
by dredging, diking, and rock excavation, the cost being estimated
at that time at $2,093,662. Recent and improved methods for doing
such work have made it probable that this estimate will not exceed
$1,035,000. Reference to reports on surveys with estimates is given
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, page 166.
   The amount expended upon the existing project up to the close of
the fiscal year ended June 30, 1909, was $730,306.94, of which
$659,192.32 was used in carrying on the work and $71,114.62 for
maintaining that already done; of this amount $1.15 was derived
from sale of condemned property. About two-thirds of the work
contemplated under the project has been completed, and the follow-
ing work has been accomplished under the project: A channel 10 feet
deep has been made from the mouth to the Delaware and Raritan
Canal terminus at New Brunswick, the section through and below
the reef at Whitehead's dock having a width of 200 feet and the
section above the reef a width of 100 feet. South channel has been
dredged to the projected depth and width for a length of about
4,000 feet. Five dikes have been built to maintain the channels.
   No work was done during the fiscal year. At the close of the year
contract for dredging for maintenance was in course of preparation
under allotment of $10,000 from the appropriation made by the
                 a See consolidated money statement on page 183.
        9001-ENG 1909-12
178          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                          U.   S. ARMY.

river and harbor act of March 3, 1909. Expenditures were for a
survey of the south channel, as authorized, and for office expenses
and contingencies.
   At the close of work of 1908 the river was open to 10-foot naviga-
tion at low water.
   It is proposed to apply the amount recommended as a profitable
expenditure to continuing and maintaining the improvement.
   On June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that could be carried to the
head of navigation was 8 to 10 feet at mean low water. Mean range
of tides: At mouth of river, 5.1 feet; at New Brunswick, 5.56 feet.
   The commerce of this river is principally in coal, ores, refined cop-
per, lumber, building materials, and general merchandise, and
amounted in 1901 to 1,266,950 tons; in 1902, to 1,228,791 tons; in
1903, to 1,020,420 tons; in 1905, to 605,197 tons; in 1906, to 736,666
tons, valued at $17,377,645; in 1907, to 725,690 tons, valued at
$32,678,472; and in 1908, to 918,302 tons, valued at $26,401,439.
Tonnage heretofore reported in gross tons; reported for this year in
short tons.
   It appears from numerous letters received that this improvement
has resulted in a very material reduction of freight rates.
   Details as to this improvement may be found in the Annual Re-
ports of the Chief of Engineers for 1892, page 881; for 1896, page 780;
for 1897, page 1136; and further information is contained in the
report for 1900, page 1505.
   Maps of the river are printed in Annual Reports of the Chief of
Engineers for 1885, page 760, and for 1905, page 1044.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................. ...            .......... ....         $835. 77
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act ap-
  proved March 3, 1909...........................................                       10, 000. 00
                                                                                        10, 835. 77
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.....................-..............................916.                           14

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                   9, 919. 63

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 373, 392. 68

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909......         .........      ...........                (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (d) South River.-This is a small stream in the central part of
New Jersey, which discharges into the Raritan River about 8 miles
above its mouth. Before improvement by the United States a pri-
vate canal about three-fourths of a mile long had been dredged from
near Washington, on the South River, to Sayreville, on the Raritan
River, which shortened the sailing course about 2 miles.
   The depth in the canal was about 3.5 feet and in the river about
2.5 feet as far as Oldbridge, at the head of navigation, 6.3 miles
above the canal.
   The first project for this improvement was adopted March 3, 1871,
and provided for dredging a channel 6 feet deep at mean low water
                       a See consolidated money statement on page 183.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    179
up to the Washington wharves, at an estimated cost of $13,653.
This was completed in 1874, at a cost of $20,000.
   The existing project, adopted June 14, 1880, provides for correct-
ing the canal outlet and for obtaining, by dredging and diking, a
channel 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep to Washington, 1.5 miles above
the mouth; thence 6 feet deep to Bissetts, 3.7 miles above the
mouth; thence 4 feet deep to Oldbridge, 6.3 miles above the mouth,
at the head of navigation. The cost was estimated at $194,695,
but was reduced in 1892 to $176,695. References to examinations
and surveys are contained in the Annual Reports of the Chief of
Engineers for 1904, page 143, and for 1907, pages 166 and 175.
   The amount expended on the present project up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $115,663.84, of which
$89,336 was used in carrying on the work and $26,327.84 for main-
tenance. About one-half of the work contemplated under the
project has been completed. Below the wharves at the village of
South River or Washington a channel from 50 to 75 feet wide and
8 feet deep has been dredged and the projected dikes have been
built. Above Washington the improvement accomplished is shown
in report of work for fiscal year of 1908.
   No work was done during the fiscal year. At the close of the
year contract for dredging for maintenance was in course of prepara-
tion under allotment of $5,000 from the appropriation made by the
river and harbor act of March 3, 1909. Expenditures were mainly
for office expenses.
   The maximum draft that could be carried to South River or
Washington on June 30, 1909, was about 6 feet, thence to within
340 feet of Bissetts, 5 to 6 feet at mean low water. Mean range of
tides: At canal, 5.34 feet; at Oldridge, 4.57 feet.
   Large brickyards established along the banks of the river give it
a commercial importance out of proportion to its size.
    The commerce is principally in brick, sand, clay, coal, fertilizer,
and general merchandise, and amounted in 1899 to 343,202 tons; in
1901, to 328,186 tons; in 1902, to 387,246 tons; in 1903, to 333,890
tons; in 1904, to 392,626 tons; in 1905, to 260,204 tons, valued at
 $1,046,208; in 1906, to 226,227 tons, valued at $972,550; in 1907, to
118,549 tons, valued at $477,530; and in 1908, to 99,197 tons, valued
at $472,013. Tonnage heretofore reported in gross tons; reported
for this year in short tons.
    The improvement has caused a great reduction in freight rates,
and it appears probable that the rates will be further reduced when
the improvement reaches the upper stretches of the river. From
reliable information received it appears that as a result of this
improvement a reduction in freight rates. on fire brick by rail to
Boston of from $3.25 to $2 per ton has been made. The freight
rate by rail to New York is $1.60 per ton; by water it is 75 cents
per ton.
    It is proposed to apply amount estimated as a profitable expendi-
ture and the available balance to continuing and maintaining the
improvement in accordance with the adopted project.
    Details as to this improvement may be found in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, pages 784-785.
180        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                    S. ARMY.

  Reference to preliminary examination and plan and estimate of
cost of improvement of Old South River may be found in Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, page 175.
  Sketches of South River are printed in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1882, page 678; 1885, page 764, and 1905,
page 1046.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................           $751. 91
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..........   ..................................                 5, 000. 00
                                                                                5, 751. 91
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement........................         .....................               236.12

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................            ...........        5, 515. 79
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........      87, 359. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909 .................   ............... .....      (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (e) Elizabeth River.-This is a small stream in the eastern part of
New Jersey which discharges into the Arthur Kill at Elizabethport.
Before improvement by the United States its width varied from 50
to 90 feet, and it had a high-water depth of 4 feet at the head of
navigation at Broad street, Elizabeth, about 24 miles above its mouth.
   The original and existing project, approved March 3, 1879, consists
in dredging a channel 60 feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean high water,
at an estimated cost, revised in 1881, of $43,160.
   The amount expended on this work to June 30,1909, was $59,648.87,
of which $27,000 was used for carrying out the project and $32,648.87
for maintenance. About three-quarters of the work contemplated
under this project has been completed. A channel 7 feet deep at
mean high water and from 30 to 60 feet wide has been dredged from
the mouth to Bridge street, Elizabeth.
   Operations during the fiscal year consisted in dredging under con-
tract for maintenance between Summer Street Bridge and the New
York and Long Branch Railroad bridge, Elizabeth. Ten thousand
seven hundred and twenty-three and three-tenths cubic yards of mud
and silt were removed and the channel restored to width of 60 feet
for a length of 3,540 feet.
    The maximum draft that could be carried to Bridge street, Eliza-
beth, about one-fourth mile below the head of navigation at Broad
street, on June 30, 1909, was about 5 feet at mean high water. A
depth of 7 feet could be carried through the lower part of the river to
Summer street. Mean range of tides: At mouth, 4.7 feet; at Bridge
street, Elizabeth, 3.4 feet.
    Under existing conditions as stated in the district officer's report
for 1908, no further appropriation is recommended.
    The commerce of the river is in coal, building materials, and mis-
cellaneous freights. It amounted to 21,650 tons in 1895, to 28,865
tons in 1897, to 29,495 tons in 1901, to 40,250 tons in 1902, to 36,336
tons in 1904, to 28,887 tons in 1905, valued at $247,717; in 1906 to
                   , a See consolidated money statement on page 183.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                           181
43,255 tons, valued at $352,784; in 1907 to 20,053 tons, valued at
$87,322; and in 1908 to 31,825 tons, valued at $190,298. Tonnage
reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.
  It appears from statements received from shippers that there has
been a reduction in freight rates, probably due to this improvement.
  References to reports on examinations and surveys are noted in
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 143.
  Details in reference to this improvement may be found in the
Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, page 778, and
1897, pages 1134 and 1185. Map is printed in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 1048.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ........................................... $8, 410. 61
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of im-
  provement...........................................................        8, 115.03

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ........................................        295. 58
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 16, 160. 00
   (f) Shoal Harbor and Compton Creek.-This harbor is on the
south shore of Raritan Bay, 5 miles from Sandy Hook. Compton
Creek is a narrow stream emptying into it. The natural harbor is
inside the mouth of the creek, where the depth is from 3 to 6 feet at
mean low tide. The creek is navigable for about 1 mile above its
mouth, where it is crossed by a railroad bridge without a draw. One-
fourth of a mile above its mouth it is crossed by a highway draw-
bridge.
   The entrance to this harbor was originally obstructed by a broad
flat shoal on which there was a depth of less than 1 foot at mean low
tide, the distance between the deep water in the creek and the 4-foot
depth in the bay being about one-half mile.
   The original and existing project, adopted September 19, 1890,
proposes a channel 4 feet deep connecting Compton Creek with Rari-
tan Bay, the width to be 150 feet in the bay and 75 feet in and near
the mouth of the creek, the channel through Shoal Harbor to be pro-
tected by a dike if necessary, at an estimated cost of $64,130.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $45,502.81, of which
sum $17,000 was applied to carrying out the project and $28,502.81 for
maintenance. About three-fifths of the dredging contemplated
under this project has been completed and a 4-foot channel 75 feet
wide has been dredged through Shoal Harbor, connecting Raritan
Bay with Compton Creek.
   Nothing in furtherance of the improvement was done during the
past fiscal year. The expenditure was for traveling expenses.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1908, in the
improved channel through Shoal Harbor and Compton Creek to the
drawbridge was 4 to 5 feet at mean low water. No soundings have
been made this season. Mean range of tides, 4.5 feet.
   The commerce of this locality in farm and fish products, fertilizers,
and general merchandise amounted to 180,000 tons in 1901, to
48,790 tons in 1902, to 65,175 tons in 1903, to 28,570 tons in 1904, to
34,340 tons in 1905, valued at $1,198,200; in 1906 to 34,538 tons,
valued at $1,167,920; in 1907 to 62,895 tons, valued at $1,809,380;
and in 1908 to 82,262 tons, valued at $1,510,210. Tonnage hereto-
fore reported in gross tons; reported for this year in short tons.
182          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                               U.     S. ARMY.

   It appears from statements received from shippers that there has
been a reduction on coal freights of 40 per cent, on manure from 40
to 50 per cent, and on fish 20 per cent, as a result of this improvement,
and if the improvement is not continued the rates would be very much
advanced.
   Reference to report of examination and survey is noted in the
Annual.Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, page 169.
   Further details as to this improvement may be found in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 1150. Map is printed
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 1050.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...........................
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
                                                                         .............
                                                                      $1, 249.64
  improvement.............. .......................................         1.88

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                           1, 247.76
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.                   . ..........   47, 130. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909. .       .................. .........                            (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (g) Cheesequake Creek.-This is a small stream in the eastern part
of New Jersey which discharges into Raritan Bay, about 2 miles east
of South Amboy. Before improvement by the United States the
available navigable depth in the creek was 1 feet at mean low water
over the shoals, the distance from the entrance to the upper limit of
navigation being 3. miles.
   The existing project was adopted June 14, 1880, and provided for a
new outlet, 5 feet deep, from the creek into Raritan Bay, at right
angles to the shore line through a beach which put across the mouth
of the creek from the right bank, and which had forced the outlet
nearly one-half mile to the westward. This was to be obtained by
dredging and constructing parallel jetties of stone, 200 feet apart, on
each side of the dredged channel; the old outlet was to be closed by a
pile dike, and a channel, 4 feet deep and from 50 to 100 feet wide, was
to be dredged from the mouth to the head of navigation, 3- miles up
the creek. In this distance two dikes were to be built, and a new
channel to be made through the marsh was to cut off a bend in the
creek. Stump Creek, a tributary stream emptying into the creek near
its mouth, was to be improved by dredging a channel 50 feet wide and
3 feet deep.
   The cost was estimated at $75,279, which was revised in 1885 to
$90,000.
   Reference to survey and estimate are noted in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 152.
   The amount expended on the present project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $49,352.28, of which $40,000
was used in carrying out the project and $9,352.28 in maintenance.
About four-ninths of the work contemplated under this project has
  a At the time the estimates for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, were prepared
and submitted to the Secretary of War, no item was included for Shoal Harbor and
Compton Creek. After further consideration the district engineer officer recommends
an estimate of appropriation for the year 1911 of $47,130 toward completing the improve-
ment at this locality and $10,000 for maintenance.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                           183
been completed, and the work accomplished consists of the construc-
tion of the two parallel stone jetties at the mouth, the dredging of a
5-foot channel between them connecting the creek with the 5-foot
curve in Raritan Bay, and the construction of the pile dike closing
the old outlet.
   During the fiscal year nothing in furtherance of the improvement
was done; the channel has deteriorated but little since the last work
in 1907.
   The improvement has not advanced sufficiently to affect freight
rates. It is proposed to expend the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure in continuing the work of improvement and for main-
tenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried through the mouth of
the creek on June 30, 1909, was about 5 feet; mean range of tides,
5.1 feet.
   The commerce of the creek is principally in fertilizer, sand, brick,
clay, and farm produce, and amounted in 1886 to about 50,000 tons;
in 1905 to 45,500 tons, valued at $146,050; in 1906 to 83,648 tons,
valued at $625,000; in 1907 to 89,500 tons, valued at $263,100; and in
1908 to 79,520 tons, valued at $209,550. Tonnage heretofore re-
ported in gross tons; reported for this year in short tons.
   Further details as to this improvement may be found in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1886, page 763.
  -Sketches of Cheesequake Creek are printed in the Annual Reports
of the Chief of Engineers for 1882, page 680, and in 1905, page 1051.
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... $50, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance.... ..........            (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                            CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....................................       $26, 797.12
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act ap-
  proved March 3, 1909...........................................            23, 000. 00
                                                                             49, 797. 12
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ................................................               23, 510. 70
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................           26, 286. 42
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........     596, 136. 68
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909..................................    b188, 095. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
    June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix G 5.)
  a See consolidated money statement on this page.
   b At the time the estimates for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, were prepared
and submitted to the Secretary of War no item was included for Shoal Harbor and
Compton Creek. After further consideration the district engineer officer recommends
an estimate of appropriation for the year 1911 of $47,130 toward completing the im-
provement at that locality and $10,000 for maintenance. Had these amounts been
included with the others at the time when originally submitted, the total for the
combined works in this consolidated item of appropriation would have been increased
from $188,095 to $245,225.
184     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S. ARMY.

   6. Shrewsbury River, New Jersey.-This river is a large tidal basin
in the eastern part of New Jersey, and consists of two bays, each hav-
ing an area of about 3 square miles, and known, respectively, as the
North Branch (or Navesink River) and the South Branch, and a
channel called the main stem, which unites the two branches at their
eastern ends and extends northwardly to the outlet at southeast end
of Sandy Hook Bay. The river is navigable on the North Branch to
Red Bank, 8 miles from the mouth, where it is crossed by three bridges
without draws, and on the South Branch to Branchport, 9 miles from
the mouth; also to Little Silver, Oceanport, Parkers Creek, North
Long Branch, and Monmouth Beach, on the several arms of the South
Branch.
   The part of the river which has been under improvement by the
United States consists of the main stem, the North Branch to Oceanic,
5 miles from the mouth, and the South Branch to the vicinity of Sea-
bright, about 51 miles from the mouth. The bays above Oceanic and
Seabright had sufficient water to accommodate navigation.
   Before any improvement was begun by the United States the avail-
able depth to Oceanic, on the North Branch, was 3 feet, and to Sea-
bright, on the South Branch, it was 2 feet; the depth in the main
stem was 4 feet. For details see Annual Report of the Chief of En-
gineers for 1886, page 756.
   By act of Congress of August 30, 1852, $1,500 was appropriated
for and expended upon a survey to ascertain the extent of a break
through the beach between the Shrewsbury River and the ocean, but
no work of improvement was begun.
   First project: By act of Congress of July 11, 1870, a survey of the
river was ordered. The report on this survey described a bar across
the river nearly opposite the Navesink lights and four smaller bars
above, and recommended deepening them by dredging, at an esti-
mated cost of $14,000. The work was completed under appropria-
tions amounting to $19,000, made in 1871 and 1873, and a new shoal
near Lower Rocky Point was also dredged. The dredged channels
did not long maintain the improved depth (6 feet at low tide).
   Existing project, with modifications: The river and harbor act of
1875 provided for a survey of the "North and South branches of the
Shrewsbury River, New Jersey." The project provided for dredging
at Upper and Lower Rocky Point and a training dike at the entrance
to the North Branch, at a total estimated cost of $18,000. This sum
was appropriated by the river and harbor act of 1878, but before
beginning the work it was decided to make a new and more detailed
survey of the river. This survey was made in 1878, and the report
presented a plan for improving both branches of the river and main
stem to obtain a channel of 6 feet depth at mean low water, with a
width of 300 feet in the main stem and of 150 feet in each of the
branches, by dredging and constructing pile dikes or training walls.
At this time the available depth in the main stem was found to be
5.4 feet at mean low water, in the North Branch 3.5 feet, and in the
South Branch, at the entrance, 2.6 feet, practically suspending all
navigation in the latter channel. The plan was referred to a Board
of Engineers, and with slight modifications was approved by it Feb-
ruary 12, 1879. It provided for the construction of seven pile dikes
and for dredging at seven different shoal points, at a total estimated
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   185
cost of $142,086. This project was adopted March 3, 1879. No
essential modification of this project has since been made. Nine
dikes have been built and the shoals have been dredged and redredged
frequently in order to maintain the proposed depth of 6 feet. Owing
to the change in diking and to the cost of dredging being generally
greater than originally estimated, it was found necessary in 1881,
1883, and 1887 to add to the estimate for the completion of the whole
work. The existing project for improvement, therefore, is the proj-
ect of 1879, with the modifications indicated above, and proposes to
secure a channel of 6 feet depth at mean low water, with width of
300 feet up to the junction of the North and South branches and
with a width of 150 feet in those branches, by means of dredging and
diking, at an estimated cost (including appropriation of 1878 applied
to this project) of $234,062.
    The sum expended under the existing project to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $358,166.08, of which $195,-
393.95 was for carrying out the project, $157,772.13 for maintenance,
and $5,000 for the survey made in 1903. Of the total amount ex-
pended, $1.25 was derived from sale of a map. The project is com-
pleted, dredging and dike repairs being required for maintenance of
channels. Operations during the fiscal year consisted in dredging
under contract for maintenance. The amount of material removed
during the year was 36,404 cubic yards. At the close of work October
13, 1908, the channels had been practically restored to projected
dimensions.
    The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, through-
out the limits of the improvement was 5 to 6 feet at mean low water.
Mean range of tides: Outer bar, 5 feet; Highlands bridge, 3 feet;
Seabright bridge, 1.3 feet.
    The commerce of the river, mainly in coal, farm products, ferti-
lizer, and general merchandise, amounted in 1889 to 906,000 tons;
in 1902 to 657,000 tons; in 1903 to 761,000 tons; in 1904 to 780,290
tons; in 1905 to 1,768,500 tons, valued at $8,215,000; in 1906 to
1,668,500 tons, valued at $7,235,000; in 1907 to 1,718,125 tons,
valued at $6,629,750; and in 1908 to 1,854,160 tons, valued at $6,-
270,000. Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this
year in short tons. The passenger traffic is important, the number
of people carried by the Patten Line, South Branch, in 1902 being
264,635; in 1903, 277,257; in 1904, 266,157, and in 1905, 310,367.
    It is proposed to apply the amount recommended as a profitable
expenditure to maintenance of the improvement in accordance with
the project.
    It appears from reports received from the Merchants Steamboat
Company and the New York and Long Branch Steamboat Company
that freight rates have been lowered, and maintained, as results of
the improvement by the United States; also that the commerce has
increased, and that the improvement tends to keep the freight rates
down.
  Further details in reference to this work may be found in the
Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, page 797, and
1900, page 185.
  Report upon survey of 1852 was made in October, 1853, and refer-
ences to further examinations and surveys may be found in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, pages 145-146.
186          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                         U.   S. ARMY.

   Sketches of Shrewsbury River are printed in the Annual Reports
of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, 1881, 1882, 1887, 1890, 1891, 1892,
1893, and 1905, page 1054, and maps of the whole river are printed
in House Document No. 123, Fifty-eighth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..-............   ... .............. $14, 932. 71
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act ap-
proved March 3, 1909. .............................................                   20, 000. 00
Received from sale of maps during the year ................                   ....           6.00

                                                                                       34, 938. 71
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement .........  .................................   ..............              14, 097. 54

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                   20, 841. 17
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 . ..........................................     20, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix G 6.)
   7. Manasquan River, New Jersey.-This is a small stream in the
eastern part of New Jersey which empties into the Atlantic Ocean
about 26 miles south of Sandy Hook; in its natural condition the
low-water depth for several miles above the mouth varied from 4 to 6
feet. The outlet, however, was obstructed by a shifting sand bar, on
which the depth did not exceed 11 feet. After severe storms this
outlet was sometimes entirely closed, remaining so until sufficient
fresh water had accumulated in the river above to force an outlet into
the ocean.
   A project for its improvement, adopted by the river and harbor act
of March 3, 1879, based on examination and survey as printed in
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, pages 463-466,
contemplated obtaining a permanent outlet for the river nearly at
right angles to the shore, with a depth of 6 feet at mean low water;
also dredging a channel in the lower river to the same depth. The
estimated cost was $52,120. Work was suspended in 1883, after
three appropriations, amounting to $39,000, had been expended on
the improvement in the construction of two training dikes 1,515 and
475 feet long, respectively.
   The existing project, approved March 3, 1899, with subsequent
modifications, which is a modification of the original project, contem-
plates obtaining an outlet 6 feet deep for the river, and also in deep-
ening the channel just above the mouth to the same depth, at an
additional cost of $18,300 over the amount expended and on hand,
making the total estimated cost of the improvement $59,300, to
which should be added $1,075 expended for maintenance. Refer-
ences to examinations and surveys are noted in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 147.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $41,054.11, of which
 $39,000 was used for carrying out the project and $2,054.11 for
maintenance.
   This improvement, under present project, is about half completed.
   During the past fiscal year no work was done on this improvement.
Expenditures were for traveling expenses.
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                         187
   No further appropriation is recommended until the question of the
usefulness of expenditures under the project has been decided.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1908, was about
2 feet at mean low water. No soundings have been made this sea-
son. Mean range of tides, 2.4 feet.
   The commerce of the inlet is small. The river is used principally
by small fishing craft; also by pleasure boats during the summer
season.
  The improvement has not advanced to a condition which would
affect the rates of freight. It is stated that there will be a reduction
when the entrance is made navigable.
   Detailed descriptions of this improvement and histories of the
work and maps are printed in the Annual Reports of the Chief of
Engineers for 1880, Part 1, pages 547-556; 1882, Part 1, page 701;
1898, page 1070, and 1905, page 1056.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended                       ..............................   $4, 961. 92
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ..............................................                                 16. 03
June 30, 1909, carried to surplus fund of the Treasury....................               4, 945. 89
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                14, 375. 00
    (See Appendix G 7.)
   8. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navi-
gation- Wreck of deck scow N. D. Shultz in Passiac River at Pennsyl-
vania Railroad wharf on the north side of the river near its mouth.-
This wreck was reported in August, 1908, as a dangerous obstruction
to navigation when one side broke off and lighting at night and mark-
ing by day were discontinued. It was previously reported as sunk at
the wharf of the Pennsylvania Railroad Company, but was not then
considered such an obstruction as contemplated by section 19 of
river and harbor act of March 3, 1899.
   The sum of $800 was allotted by the department on November 21,
1908, for the removal of this wreck. It was removed by the wreck-
ing plant of John F. Baxter, under public notice dated November 28,
1908, for the sum of $792.
   The wreck was deposited in the yard of the contractor at Weehaw-
ken. Nothing of value was found upon it.
   (See Appendix G 8.)

EXAMINATION          AND SURVEY MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
                      HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 3, 1909.

   Report dated April 23, 1909, on preliminary examination of Newark
Bay, New Jersey, with a view to securinga channel along the eastern shore,
required by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, was duly sub-
mitted by the district officer. It was reviewed by the Board of Engi-
neers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant to law, and was transmitted to
Congress and printed in House Document No. 80, Sixty-first Congress,
first session. The locality is not considered worthy of improvement
by the General Government in the manner indicated.
188     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE PHILADELPHIA,
                PENNSYLVANIA, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Maj. Herbert Deakyne, Corps
of Engineers. Division engineer, Col. D. W. Lockwood, Corps of
Engineers.
   1. Delaware River, New Jersey and Pennsylvania.-Trenton, the
head of natural and actual navigation of the Delaware River, is about
30 miles above the upper end of the port of Philadelphia. In its
original condition this stretch of river was obstructed by several
shoals. Between Bordentown and Trenton, a distance of about 5
miles, a narrow and circuitous channel existed which carried only
from 3 to 6 feet at mean low water. At Kinkora bar, about 9 miles
below Trenton, there was a shoal carrying 7 feet, and at Fivemile
bar, opposite the upper part of Philadelphia, a shoal crossed the
Pennsylvania channel, carrying only 3 to 4 feet at mean low water.
There was, however, a depth of 13 feet past Fivemile bar in the New
Jersey channel south of Petty Island.
   Below Philadelphia the river in its original, condition presented
obstructions at Mifflin bar which reduced the depth at mean low water
to 17 feet, at Schooner ledge and Cherry Island flats to 18 feet, at
Bulkhead shoal and Baker shoal to about 20 feet, and at Duck Creek
flats to about 20 feet. The lower end of Duck Creek flats is 56 miles
below Philadelphia.
   In that part of the Delaware River between Trenton, N. J., and
Bridesburg, Pa., efforts in the past have been directed toward reliev-
ing commerce from the obstructions which exist in the upper 9 miles
of the river and toward deepening the channels across Perriwig and
Kinkora bars.
   Previous to 1885 the efforts to improve the river between Philadel-
phia and the bay were confined to dredging, except at Schooner ledge,
where solid rock was removed. The work was done under appropria-
tions for special localities, and also under general appropriations for
the Delaware River below Bridesburg.
   A Board of Engineers, convened by direction of the Secretary of
War for the purpose of considering the subject of the permanent
improvement of Delaware River and Bay, recommended, in a project
dated January 23, 1885, and adopted in that year, the formation of
a ship channel from a point opposite Philadelphia and about mid-
way between the American Ship Building Company's yard and the
Gas Trust wharf to deep water in Delaware Bay, having a least
width of 600 feet and a depth of 26 feet at mean low water. The
formation of such a channel was to be secured, except at Schooner
ledge, where rock would have to be removed, by regulating the tidal
flow by means of dikes, with recourse to dredging where necessary,
as an aid to such contracting and regulating works. The estimated
cost of obtaining a channel of the above dimensions was about
$2,425,000, which covered the estimated cost of the permanent im-
provement of the Delaware River between the upper part of Phila-
delphia and deep water in the bay. The annual cost of maintenance
was estimated at 10 per cent of the original cost for dredging and
1 per cent of the original cost for dikes. This estimate of cost did
not include the improvement of Philadelphia Harbor, which was a
separate project.
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                      189
   With appropriations aggregating $3,935,000 there was completed
between 1888 and 1898 a project for improving the harbor between
Philadelphia, Pa., and Camden, N. J., which provided a channel
depth of 26 feet at mean low water from Christian street, Philadel-
phia (Kaighn Point, N. J.), up to the Pennsylvania Railroad bridge
at Fishers Point, N. J. In 1906 an allotment of $10,000 was made
for redredging shoal places within the limits of this improvement,
from the emergency appropriation contained in the river and harbor
act approved March 3, 1905. Final report on the completion of this
project is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1899, page 1330, and an account of the work done under the emer-
gency allotment in the Report for 1907, page 1100.
   In the river and harbor act approved March 3, 1899, Congress
adopted a new project for the improvement of the river, providing
for the formation of a channel 600 feet wide and 30 feet deep from
Christian street, Philadelphia, to deep water in Delaware Bay, at an
estimated cost of $5,810,000. This project superseded the project of
1885. At the time of adoption of the new project the 26-foot chan-
nel, with widths varying from 200 to 600 feet, had been formed from
the upper part of Philadelphia Harbor to the bay, except at the fol-
lowing-named localities: Tinicum Island shoal, depth from 23.6 feet
to 26 feet over a distance of about 4,200 feet; above Schooner ledge,
depth from 24 feet to 26 feet over a distance of about 4,800 feet;
from below Marcus Hook to Bellevue, depth from 23 to 26 feet over a
distance of about 13,500 feet. These distances are measured on the
range lines. The distances measured between the 26-foot curves on
the lines of deepest water were much shorter.
   Part of the 26-foot channel above Marcus Hook, Pa., was dredged
by the city of Philadelphia under the supervision of this office, with
money appropriated by the city of Philadelphia.
   At the same time there was between Trenton and Philadelphia a
channel 6 feet deep at mean low water through Perriwig bar, a depth
of 7 feet in the eastern channel at Bordentown, a channel 81 feet deep
through Kinkora bar, and a channel 26 feet deep over the whole
width through Fivemile bar.
   The total amount expended on the 26-foot project since its adop-
tion, in 1885, was $1,532,688.81, of which about $200,000 is estimated
to have been applied to maintenance. In addition to this expenditure
the following sums were expended since the adoption of the 26-foot
channel, in 1885, and previous to adoption of the existing project, on
special localities on the river under appropriations made for the
purpose:
Channel across Smiths Island bar, between Philadelphia, Pa., and Cam-
den, N. J...........................................................              $30, 000. 00
Between the upper part of Philadelphia, Pa., and Trenton, N. J........              37, 500. 00
Rebuilding and enlarging dike at junction of Schuylkill and Delaware
rivers ...............................................................              3, 000. 00
Removing rock ledge opposite Petty Island............................               69, 463. 26
Expenses of Board of Engineer officers on project for channel 30 feet deep
and 600 feet wide ...............................                      ..... ....   7, 000.00
       Total.......       ....................................                    146, 963.26
  The entire amount expended on the improvement of Delaware
River from 1836 to June 30, 1909, under appropriations for general
190            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                           U.    S. ARMY.

river improvement, special localities, Philadelphia Harbor, and allot-
ments from appropriations for emergencies in river and harbor works,
was $13,420,754.23, of which $184,505.80 was expended on the part
of the river between Trenton and Philadelphia, and $188,109.51 for
maintenance under the existing project.
   Work under the existing project below Christian street was com-
menced under an appropriation of $300,000 contained in the river
and harbor act of March 3, 1899, and has been prosecuted under this
and subsequent acts. Under the provisions of this act $69,463.26
was applied to removal of rock ledge opposite Petty Island, $7,000 to
the expenses of the Board of Engineer officers on project for a 30-
foot channel, and the balance, $223,536.74, under the existing project.
   The river and harbor act approved March 2, 1907, appropriated the
sum of $895,000 for completing this improvement and authorized the
letting of contracts to the extent of $500,000 additional for main-
tenance of the dredged channel, this amount to be available, how-
ever, for use in completion of the project. Of this appropriation the
sum of $40,000 is to be applied to maintenance of the dredged water-
way in Philadelphia Harbor above Christian street, Philadelphia.
Of the sum of $500,000 authorized by the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, $375,000 was appropriated in the sundry civil act
approved May 27, 1908, and the balance, $125,000, was appropriated
in the sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.
   The river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909, appropriated
$390,000 for maintenance of the dredged channel from Philadelphia
to Delaware Bay, including Philadelphia Harbor.
   Up to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, the sum
of $6,383,671.61 was expended on the work of the existing project
in surveys, in dredging at Duck Creek flats, Baker shoal, Salem Cove
flats, Deep Water Point, Cherry Island flats, Schooner ledge rock
area, Tinicum and Mifflin bar shoals, and in the construction of bulk-
heads for the reception of dredged material and to act as training
walls to direct the currents.
   At Baker shoal the work of bulkhead construction has resulted in
the completion of 30,627 linear feet of structure. At Cherry Island
flats the work of bulkhead construction has resulted in the comple-
tion of 4,535 linear feet of structure. The work of dredging under
the 30-foot project has resulted in the formation of a channel 30 feet
deep at mean low water and 600 feet wide, having the following ap-
proximate lengths through the various shoals:
                                                                                                                         Feet.
Duck Creek flats............ ....-- ............                           ... ......... ..................             43,   000
Baker shoal..---..---------...--------........-...--..---........------....------.....--...-..---.....--------.....     20,   500
Salem Cove flats.................                                 ....................................                  12,   500
New Castle flats-.......................................................                                                28,   000
Cherry Island flats------............              ..... .........               ..... ...........          .........   25,   500
Edgemoor, Delaware, to the south line of Pennsylvania, including Marcus
  Hook bar-- ........--........................--------......----......-------.....--.....-----------........           30, 000
  The work of rock removal at Schooner ledge is now about 99 per
cent completed.
  The greatest draft of water that could be carried at mean low
water on June 30, 1909, over the shoalest part of the river below
Philadelphia, was about 23.9 feet on center line of channel on Cherry
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     191
Island light-house range, near the mouth of Christiana River, Del-
aware. The material in the channel at this locality is very soft mud.
    It is proposed to apply the available funds to completion of the
project and maintenance of the dredged channel. This will include
widening of the channel beyond 600 feet at the bends below Phila-
delphia, completion of rock removal at Schooner ledge, and surveys,
engineering and office expenses under the general project, the work
to be done by contract or by hired labor and government plant, as
may be to the best interests of the United States.
    In 1905 the State of Pennsylvania and the city of Philadelphia
appropriated sums aggregating $750,000, to be expended in accordance
with the general project on that part of the river between the south
line of Pennsylvania and the city of Philadelphia. This money was
to be expended by the city of Philadelphia, and the work to be done
was to be under the supervision of the United States engineer officer
in charge of the improvement.
    Under date of July 27, 1906, the United States entered into an agree-
ment with the city of Philadelphia whereby government plant should
be placed on the work in sections 7 and 8 and operated under the
direction of this office; all cost of the work to be paid by the city of
Philadelphia. The city also entered into a contract with the American
Dredging Company, under date of October 27, 1906, for the dredging
of the entire channel to full width and depth in sections 6-A, 6-B,
and 9, for a lump sum in each case.
    Work under the above agreement with government plant in sec-
tions 7 and 8 has resulted in a channel through Tinicum Island flats
30 feet deep and 600 feet in width, and a channel through Mifflin bar
shoal 30 feet deep and 600 feet wide.
    The contract dredging has resulted in a channel 30 feet deep and
600 feet wide through section 6, subsections A and B, on Schooner
ledge range, and through section 9, to Christian street, Philadelphia.
    The original work on the channel 30 feet deep and 600 feet wide is
now practically completed from Christian street, Philadelphia, to
deep water in Delaware Bay, except on Schooner ledge rock area,
where a few scattering points of rock remain to be drilled and blasted
off. It is estimated that only about 330 cubic yards of ledge rock
remains to be removed, consisting of widely scattered points project-
ing from 0.1 foot to 1 foot above the plane of 30 feet mean low water.
This work is being pushed as rapidly as is practicable, but from its
nature is necessarily tedious.
     For 1890 the total foreign freight movement of the Delaware River
was estimated at 2,923,994 tons and the total domestic freight move-
ment at 8,433,276 tons; total, 11,356,270 tons. For 1908 the total
foreign freight movement was estimated at 5,083,487 tons and the
  total domestic freight movement at 18,940,408 tons; total, 24,023,895
  tons.
     The deepening of the channel below Philadelphia increases the
  number of deep-draft vessels trading with foreign ports. The estab-
  lishment of existing lines has resulted in lower import and export
  rates. The maintenance of a deep channel from Philadelphia to the
  sea also affects the rates at other ports by keeping up the competition
  between them and this port. No exact figures can be given which
192                      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                                  U. S. ARMY.

will show the amount that freight rates have been lowered by the
improvement.
  Itis proposed to apply the amount estimated for expenditure during
the fiscal year 1911 to maintenence of improvement by dredging and
repair of regulating works.
                                                                         COIMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

   The following statement concerning the foreign commerce of the Delaware River
for the years ending December 31, 1907 and 1908, is compiled from the reports of the
Board of Trade of the city of Philadelphia:

                                                                      Articles.                                                                                   1907.                1908.


                                                                     IMPORTS.                                                                                     Tons.                Tons.
Drugs and chemicals...........                                   ........................................                                                         144,717               132,723
Hemp, jute, flax, and their fabrics......................................                                                                                          36, 257               26,095
Iron, manufactured.............................................................                                                                                    31,396                13,545
Iron ore...........................................                                                    ..................                                         600,598               585,126
Sugar...........................................................                                                                                    ..            200,370               199,978
Miscellaneous....................                                      .......          ........................                                         .        787,182               593,548
            Total..................                                     ...................................                                                     1,800,520             1,551,015
                                                                     EXPORTS.
Coal ..........................................................................                                                                                   930,599               799,862
Grain and flour................... .............................................                                                                                  581,013               683,716
Petroleum and products..................                                                    .         .............        .........            ........        1,124,673             1,188,277
Miscellaneous...............                                             ....................................................                                   1,420,431               860, 617
           Total.................................................................                                                                               4,056,716             3,532,472


   The following statement concerning the domestic and coastwise commerce of the
Delaware River for the years ending December 31, 1907 and 1908, has been compiled
from returns made by shippers, consignees, and carriers:


                                                                                                                           1907.                                            1908.
                                          Articles.
                                                                                                              Tons.                    Value.                  Tons.                 Value.


                                         ARRIVALS.
Chemicals......                     ......................................                                   312,560              $4,825,498                     221,795             $3,938,315
Coal.......................................                                                                  715,493               2,553,793                     684,684              2,593,165
Lumber...........................................                                                            961,347              10,588,854                    729,562               7,844,366
Sand..........................                                      .............                         2,345,398                1,283,131                  1,910,510               1,045,988
Miscellaneous ......................................                                                      4, 827, 537            781, 240, 860                4, 496, 646           577, 842, 375
            Total..................................                                                       9,162, 335             800, 492,136                8, 043, 197            593, 264, 209

                                     DEPARTURES.
Chemicals..........................................                                                        119,385                2,344,170                      95,508              2,175,450
Coal......................................                                                               7,877,432               30,764,762                  7,150,315              27,854,154
Fertilizers....................................                                                            114,736                2,303,720                     129,013              2, 818,753
Iron, manufactured.                        ....         ...............                                     20,096                  485,198                      13,320                 400,000
Miscellaneous ...........                       .................                                        4,132, 309             573,344,187                  3, 509, 055           469, 721, 940

             Total..........................                                               .....        12, 263, 958              609, 242,037               10, 897, 211           502,970,297
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           193
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-. .......... . .. ......-........... a$803, 279. 89
June 30, 1909, credited to appropriation during fiscal year: Sales of
  blueprints, $22.47; account services U. S. dredge Delaware in New
  York Harbor, $11,163.07; account of judgment in case of libel filed
  in U. S. district court for New Jersey against coal barge Alaska as
  damages sustained by the United States by reason of sinking by the
  barge of a scow belonging to the Engineer Department, $1,400; ac-
  count proceeds of sales of condemned property, $604.43 -.........      13, 189. 97
Amount appropriated by river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909.     390, 000.00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.....     125, 000. 00
                                                                                      a 1, 331, 469. 86
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ........................                     $652, 969. 05
    For maintenance of improvement............... ......                   179, 399. 34
                                                                                          b832, 368. 39
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..... . . ..... .......................                   a499, 101. 47
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ...............................                    a 104, 294. 64
July 1, 1909, balance available.....................               .............           394, 806. 83
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. .............                       141, 475. 80
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
  expended July 1, 1909.......................................                             200, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix H 1.)
   2. Perriwig bar, Delaware River.-The project for this improve-
ment was adopted March 2, 1907, and provides for dredging a channel
7 feet deep at mean low water, with a bottom width of 200 feet, in
three straight stretches through Perriwig bar, between Trenton and
Bordentown, at estimated cost of $50,000. This sum was appro-
priated in the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, for completing
the improvement.
   The plan of proposed improvement is printed in House Document
No. 852, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
   This work was completed during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1908, at a cost of $49,527.99, and has resulted in the formation of a
channel through the bar 7 feet deep at mean low water and about
6,000 feet long, with a bottom width of 200 feet. The total ex-
penditures to June 30, 1909, amounted to $50,000.
   This improvement has enabled the steamship companies to con-
tinue their service and maintain the present low freight rates between
Philadelphia and Trenton. Otherwise these steamers would neces-
sarily have been withdrawn, and the only means of communication
between the two cities would have been by railroad, on which the
freight rates are much higher than by water.
   During the past fiscal year a survey of the dredged channel was
made, which showed that only a small amount of shoaling had
  a This amount includes a balance of $1.5.67 remaining from an allotment of $10,000
for Philadelphia Harbor from the emergency appropriation made in the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1905.
   bThis amount has been reduced by $903.85, which latter will be restored to this
appropriation on account of payments made for the Isthmian Canal Commission.
       9001BENG 1909-13
194             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                            U.    S.   ARMY.


occurred. Expenditures during the past year were in payment of
expenses of this survey and of outstanding liabilities incurred during
the year 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................        $640. 34
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ...................................... ................ .... 1, 500. 00
                                                                                                                         2, 140. 34
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment...........------------..--...-....----......-------......--------...-------------....------.......----........      640. 34

July 1,1909, balance unexpended....................................                                                      1, 500. 00
     (See Appendix               1{ 2.)
   3. Bordentown bar, Delaware River.-Under date of April 20, 1908,
an allotment of $500 was made by the Secretary of War from the
emergency appropriation of $300,000, carried by the river and
harbor act approved March 2, 1907, for a survey to determine the
work necessary to restore the channel for navigation. An additional
allotment of $9,500 was made from the same appropriation under date
of June 8, 1908, for dredging under the project.
   The project provides for a channel 7 feet deep at mean low water,
with a bottom width of 200 feet, or as near that width as the funds
will permit, in two straight reaches through Bordentown bar.
   The work was completed during the past fiscal year and has resulted
in a channel 7 feet deep, with a bottom width of 160 feet, and a
length of 3,600 feet. The total cost of this work, including the sum
of $270.67 expended on the survey, was $10,000.
   This improvement has given relief to steamers running between
Philadelphia and Trenton, and has enabled them to pass over the bar
at all stages of the tide.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated for expenditure during
the fiscal year 1911 to maintenance of improvement by dredging.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................                                                    $9, 743. 91
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, in                                          restoration of
  channel ................................................................                                               9, 743. 91

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement ..............................                                                   5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix 1H 3.)
   4. Sewer shoal, near Trenton, N. J.-Under date of May 12, 1909,
an allotment of $15,000 was made by the Acting Secretary of War
from the emergency appropriation of $500,000 provided by section 2
of the river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909, to be applied to
dredging a channel through the shoal known as "Sewer shoal," near
Trenton, N. J., 7 feet deep at mean low water, with a bottom width
of 200 feet, or as near that width as the funds will permit.
   Dredging is in progress under an emergency contract dated June 1,
1909, with the American Dredging Company. At the end of the
fiscal year about 40 per cent of the work was completed.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                              195
Amount allotted from appropriation for emergencies in river and harbor
  works, act of March 3, 1909, for maintenance of improvement.......... $15, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year ....................         5. 80
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................                      ...................        14, 994. 20
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................                                324. 17
July 1, 1909, balance available...................                               ................   14, 670. 03

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                              14, 000. 00
    (See Appendix H 4.)
   5. Ice harbor at Marcushook, Pa.-In 1785 the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania built two wharves upon crib piers at Marcushook for
the convenience of commerce. In 1829 an appropriation was made
by Congress for repairing the piers and improving the harbor.
   In 1866 a project was adopted for a harbor in Delaware River to
protect vessels against moving ice. The old work at Marcushook
was utilized as far as possible. The amount expended from 1866 to
June 30, 1909, was $219,000. Since 1899 all expenditures have been
for repairs and maintenance. The last amount appropriated for the
work was $5,000, by act of September 19, 1890.
   The harbor covers an area of 12 acres, of which about one-half has
a depth of 12 to 18 feet and the other half 18 to 25 feet at mean low
water. The protection consists of the old landing piers and seven
detached piers, having foundations of wooden cribs filled with stone,
the superstructures being faced with cut stone. The detached piers
are in need of minor repairs.
   During the past fiscal year repairs were made to the mooring posts
and other parts of the piers.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated for expenditure
during the fiscal year 1911 to maintenance of improvement by the
repair of superstructure of ice piers.
   Rules for the use of the landing piers were approved by the Acting
Secretary of War under date of April 29, 1904.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.........................................                              $37. 54
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year....................    ..                             37. 54
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
    for maintenance of improvement ..................................                                   600. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix H 5.)
   6. Iron pier in Delaware Bay, near Lewes, Del.--The original
project for this work proposed the construction of a landing pier
about 1,700 feet in length, extending from the shore south of the
breakwater into Delaware Bay, to a depth of 22 feet at mean low
water, the pier to consist of a substructure of wrought-iron screw
piles, surmounted by a timber superstructure. The work was com-
menced in 1871, and completed, except as to superstructure, in 1880.
   The work done to June 30, 1890, resulted in the construction of
1,155 linear feet of pier 21 feet in width and 546 linear feet 42 feet
in width, or a total length of 1,701 feet. The depth of water at
196        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                         U.   S. ARMY.

the outer end of the pierhead was about 21 feet at mean low water.
Since its construction the pier has been repaired and cared for by
the United States.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1909, were $385,339.40. Of
this amount $27,000 was applied to the maintenance of the im-
provement.
   The right to use the pier for railway purposes, granted in the act
of July 15, 1870, has never been and doubtless never will be exer-
cised, as the pier has not sufficient strength to support the weight
of modern freight engines. It is therefore impossible to obtain any
assistance from the railroad company in maintaining and repairing
the structure.
   During the past fiscal year no work was in progress.
   The pier is of great use for the purposes of the government engi-
neer, light-house, and quarantine services. It is of very great
value to vessels frequenting the breakwater harbor in winter, when
the harbor is packed with floating ice, rendering the anchorage dan-
gerous. At such times vessels eagerly seek its shelter and protection.
The unexpended balance of $820.60 was carried to the surplus fund
on June 30, 1909.
   The mean range of tide at the pier is 4.5 feet.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated for expenditure
during the fiscal year 1911 to maintenance of improvement by
repair of pier.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................               ..........            $820. 60
June 30, 1909, amount carried to surplus fund.... . . . . .. ...... . . ... . . . . .    820. 60
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
                                                              ....
   1911, for maintenance of improvement...---------------------------                   1, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix H 6.)
  7. Delaware breakwater, Delaware.-The final report of the local
officer upon this work was submitted June 19, 1899, and is printed in
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1899, page 1346.
   The depths in the protected anchorage vary froni 11 to 18 feet at
mean low water, and the harbor is available for vessels drawing up to
about 16 feet.
   The amount expended on this work up to June 30, 1909, was
$2,806,479.06. No portion of this amount has been applied to main-
tenance.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1903, a survey of the break-
water harbor was completed as a part of a survey of the national har-
bor of refuge.
   The mean range of tide is 4.5 feet.
   The unexpended balance of $875.64 was carried to the surplus fund
on June 30, 1909.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................ ......................                  $875. 64
June 30, 1909, amount carried to surplus fund .............................               875. 64
    (See Appendix H 7.)
  3. Harbor of refuge, Delaware Bay, Delaware.-The project for the
construction of this harbor, which was adopted and provided for under
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      197
the continuous-contract system in the river and harbor act of June 3,
1896, includes the construction of a breakwater on the line of least
depth along the eastern branch of the shoal known as the "Shears,"
and the construction of a row of ice piers across the upper end of the
harbor to protect it from ice descending the bay, at a total cost not to
exceed $4,665,000.
    No expenditures were made on this improvement previous to June
30, 1896.
    Up to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, $2,238,205.34
had been expended in the construction of the breakwater and ice
piers.
    No part of this amount was applied to the maintenance of the work.
    During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1904, the sum of $338.43 was
expended on a survey of the harbor.
    The breakwater was completed on December 11, 1901. The super-
structure of the breakwater has a length of 7,950 feet and the sub-
structure a length of 8,040 feet, measured on the low-water line.
    A project for the construction of 10 ice piers was submitted on April
5 and approved April 23, 1900. This work was commenced during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1901, and completed November 22,
1902. Seventy-one thousand three hundred tons of stone was de-
posited in the work.
    A project for the construction of additional ice piers was sub-
mitted under date of June 7 and approved June 30, 1902. Work
under this project was begun August 4, 1902, and completed June 19,
1903. Thirty-seven thousand six hundred and seventy-three tons
of stone was deposited, completing 5 ice piers.
    A report was submitted under date of November 19, 1902, contain-
ing project and estimates for further protection of the harbor. A
further report on this subject, containing a detailed project and esti-
mate of cost of the proposed extension of the breakwater at this har-
bor, was submitted under date of November 14, 1903. Both reports
and the recommendations of the Board of Engineers for Rivers and
Harbors are published in House Document No. 548, Fifty-eighth Con-
gress, second session, and also contained in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1904, pages 1215-1225.
    The great value of this harbor to commerce is due to its location.
It is about equidistant from New York, Philadelphia, and the capes of
Chesapeake Bay (the ocean entrance for the ports of Baltimore, Nor-
folk, and Newport News), and is therefore an especially convenient
port of call for the entire commerce of the North Atlantic coast. It
is now largely used by vessels awaiting orders to ports for discharge or
loading. During the year ending December 31, 1908, 1,035 vessels
 (not including small craft) called at this harbor.
    By the construction of the breakwater the usefulness of this anchor-
age has been greatly increased, not only as a port of call but also as a
harbor of refuge. Vessels bound from northern to southern op-from
southern to northern ports are able to go to sea in doubtful weather
with the assurance of finding ample protection at the Delaware capes
if overtaken by storm.
    Details as to this improvement may be found in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 1216. A map is printed in
House Executive Document No. 112, Fifty-second Congress, first
session.
198         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                           S. ARMY.

  The mean range of tide is 4.5 feet.
  The unexpended balance of $1,128.66 was carried to the surplus
fund on June 30, 1909.
  It is proposed to apply the amount estimated for expenditure during
the fiscal year 1911 to maintenance of improvement by the repair of
detached piers.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ............   ..................          ........   $1, 128. 66
June 30, 1909, amount carried to surplus fund...........................                1, 128. 66
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement.............-................                   8, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix H 8.)
  9. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navi-
gation.-(a) Wreck of schooner Eden in Delaware River, close to Tinicum
Island range.-This wreck being considered a dangerous obstruction
to navigation, its removal was authorized under date of February
25, 1908. A contract for the removal of this wreck was entered into,
but the contractor abandoned the work before its completion.
  The wreck was removed by plant belonging to the United States
and hired labor, the work being completed on September 14,1908.
The total cost of its removal was $413.68.
   (b) Wreck of a houseboat in Delaware River off the wharf at Fort Mott,
N. J.-This wreck being considered a dangerous obstruction to navi-
gation, its removal was authorized under date of June 2, 1908. The
removal of this wreck was completed on July 10, 1908, plant belonging
to the United States and hired labor being employed in the execution
of the work. The total cost of its removal was $301.65.
   (c) Wreck of schooner-riggedflat boat John A. Lingo in Delaware
River, near Finns Point, N. J.-This wreck being considered a dan-
gerous obstruction to navigation, its removal was authorized on April
12, 1909. The work of removal was completed on April 19, 1909, by
the use of plant belonging to the United States and by hired labor.
The total cost of its removal was $200.
   The total amount expended during the past fiscal year upon re-
moval of wrecks was $915.33.
   (See Appendix H 9.)

EXAMINATION          AND SURVEY MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
                    HARBOR ACT, APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.


   Reports dated April 20, 1907, and March 20, 1908, respectively, on
preliminary examination                and survey of Neversink and Delaware
rivers, New York, with a view to the removal of bars and other
obstructions at and near the mouth of the Neversink River, and of
the Delaware River at and near the mouth of the Neversink River,
required by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, were duly
submitted by the district officer. They were reviewed by the Board
of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors pursuant to law and were trans-
mitted to Congress and printed in House Document No. 1164, Sixtieth
Congress, second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      199
cost of $61,392.50 is presented, of which amount an item of $6,612.50
for removal of a rock ledge, known as "Sims Clip," is regarded as
chiefly benefiting raft navigation and should be borne by the United
States, provided the balance of the work, estimated to cost $54,780,
is provided for by State and local interests.
IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE WILMINGTON, DEL-
                     AWARE, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Maj. C. A. F. Flagler, Corps of
Engineers, to July 31, 1908; in the temporary charge of Maj. Herbert
Deakyne from July 31 to Sept. 15, 1908, and in charge of Capt.
L. H. Rand, Corps of Engineers, since the latter date. Division Engi-
neer Col. D. W. Lockwood, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Cooper Creek, New Jersey.--This creek enters the Delaware
River in the city of Camden, just above Cooper Point. It was navi-
gable at mean high water for a distance of 9 miles from its mouth for
vessels drawing 5 feet, and for the first 5 miles for vessels of 11- feet
draft. The mean range of the tide at the mouth is about 6 feet. For
a distance of 1Z miles from the mouth the width of the stream aver-
aged about 80 feet at low water and about 120 feet between the banks,
and the channel in its original condition had a depth at mean high
water of from 12 to 15 feet, except at one place where the depth was
9 feet.
   The project for this improvement was adopted in the river and
harbor act of June 3, 1896, and is printed in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1895, page 1102. It provides for the forma-
tion, by dredging, of a channel 70 feet wide at bottom and 18 feet
deep at mean high water from the mouth of the creek to Browning's
Chemical Works and a channel of the same dimensions through the
bar just outside the mouth-in all, a distance of about 9,000 feet.
The estimated cost, including contingencies, is $35,000.
   The river and harbor act of June 3, 1896, appropriated $37,000 for
completing this improvement, of which $2,500, or as much thereof as
might be necessary, was to be expended in rebuilding the dike on the
government reservation in the Delaware River at Woodbury Creek.
   The sum of $2,500 was expended in rebuilding the dike at Wood-
bury Creek referred to, and the channel in Cooper Creek was dredged.
This dredging resulted in the formation of a channel extending from
the mouth to the Camden Iron Works, 7,500 feet long, 50 to 70 feet
wide, except at the bridges, where the widths are 30 feet, and 18 feet
deep at mean high water (12 feet at mean low water). At State
street the depth made was only 14 to 15 feet on account of a city
water main crossing the stream at that depth. Further operations
were suspended to await the lowering of this pipe by the city.
   In 1906; to meet the wants of the traffic in the creek, the channel
was dredged between the State Street Bridge and the 12-foot contour
in Delaware River to a depth of 12 feet at mean low water and a width
of 70 feet.
   The water pipe at State street was lowered in September, 1907, but
no work has been done on the improvement since for want of suffi-
cient funds. The expenditure during the -ear was for examination
and supervision expenses.
200          REPORT OF TH:E CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                    S. ARMY.

   About 65 per cent of the projected work is completed.
   Under date of April 21, 1909, the Chief of Engineers allotted $5,000
from the appropriation made by the river and harbor act of March 3,
1909, for preservation and maintenance of river and harbor works,
and approved project for expenditure of available funds, and bids
for the dredging to be done thereunder will soon be opened.
   The maximum drafts that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water were 12 feet from the Delaware River to the Federal
Street Bridge, thence 9 1 feet to Camden Iron Works, and thence 6
feet to Browning's Chemical Works. The stream is navigable nearly
to Medford Branch of Pennsylvania Railroad, a distance of 9 miles.
   The expenditure during the year was for examination and super-
vision expenses.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $31,058.90, exclusive of
the $2,500 expended in rebuilding dike at Woodbury Creek. Of this
amount $5,382.80 was for maintenance.
   The commerce for the calendar year 1908, reported by the Camden
Board of Trade, was 221,205 tons, valued at $1,807,633.
   The effect of the improvement made in this stream on freight rates
has been to reduce them by permitting larger vessels to be secured
for long voyages than was formerly possible. The railroad rates to
points in the United States east of Cape Cod are 25 per cent higher
than by water.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below to complete
the project dimensions of the channel above the State Street Bridge
and to maintain the improvement by dredging. This will extend the
benefits of the improvement.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................... $3, 499. 32
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river a id harbor act approved
  M arch 3, 1909............. ..... ...                ........        ..... ............. .... ..... 5, 000. 00
Received from sales ....................................................                                 100. 00

                                                                                                     8, 599. 32
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement.......... ......... .. ... ..... .... .....      ........... .....                           58. 22

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...............               ......     .   ..............        8, 541. 10

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                            5, 131. 18
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909.......................        ....... 11, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix I 1.)
   2. Mantua Creek, New Jersey.-Mantua Creek is a stream flowing
into the Delaware River at a point about 10 miles below the terminal
and ferry of the Pennsylvania Railroad at Camden, N. J.
   In its original condition it was navigable at high water for a dis-
tance of one-half mile above its mouth to the phosphate works of the
I. P. Thomas & Sons Company for vessels of 13 feet draft; thence 31
miles farther, to Paulsboro, for vessels drawing 9 feet; thence 3k miles
to Parkers Landing for tugs and barges drawing 6 feet, this being the
head of steam navigation; thence 4.1 miles to Mantua, 11) miles above
the mouth, small boats and barges of 3 to 4 feet draft passed up on
the tide. The navigable portion is generally bordered by low ground,
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    201
protected from overflow by earthen banks. The general course of the
stream is tortuous, and its navigation was much obstructed by bars,
sharp bends, and the upper portion by stumps and overhanging trees.
The stream, on account of its flat watershed, is subject to only mod-
erate freshets, which seldom exceed 2 to 3 feet above tide water. The
range of tide is 6 feet at the mouth, 4.5 feet at Paulsboro, 3.4 feet
at Berkley, and 2 feet at Mantua, which is the head of navigation.
The low-water width near the mouth averaged 160 feet, decreasing
to about 100 feet at Paulsboro. Above Paulsboro the width decreased
to 88 feet at Parkers Landing, and near Mantua to 50 feet.
   The approved project for the improvement, which was adopted by
Congress in river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, contemplates the
dredging of a channel 100 feet wide on the bottom and 12 feet deep
from the 12-foot contour in the Delaware River, through the marsh to
the phosphate works, a distance of 2,200 feet; thence 80 feet wide on
the bottom and 8 feet deep to Paulsboro, 6,300 feet, making a chan-
nel nearly direct by cutting off three bends; thence to Parkers Land-
ing, near Berkley, 3 miles, with one cut-off 60 feet wide and 7 feet
deep; and the dredging of a cut-off 350 feet long, 50 feet wide, and 3
feet deep, 9,000 feet above Berkley; also the removal of overhanging
trees above Berkley and the construction of jetties on both sides at
the mouth of the creek. The estimated cost of this improvement is
$145,030. Such lands and rights as were considered necessary for the
cut-offs were purchased in September, 1900, at a cost of $8,000.
   Between 1901 and 1905 the channel between the phosphate works
and Paulsboro was dredged to the project dimensions and the three
cut-offs made as planned, and a channel 12 feet deep at mean low
water dredged direct from the 12-foot contour in the Delaware River
to the phosphate works, cutting off the old mouth, the width made
being 110 feet across the flats and 100 feet at the upper and lower
ends of the dredging.
   For the protection of the channel at the mouth a jetty 754 feet in
length was constructed in 1907, on the east side of the channel, and a
j tty 579.5 feet on the west side, and a dike, 524 feet long, to close
the old mouth of the river.
   During the fiscal year 1909 the channel was dredged to a depth of
13 feet at mean low water and a width of 100 feet from the 12-foot
curve in the Delaware River to the upper end of the I. P. Thomas &
Sons' fertilizer works, thence 9 feet deep and 80 feet wide to the
highway bridge at Paulsboro, and thence a distance of 12,000 feet
8 feet deep and 60 feet wide, these depths including 1 foot for over-
depth allowed under the contract. The portion of this work below
the Paulsboro highway bridge was maintenance work.
    About 55 per cent of the projected work has been done.
    The amount expended on the improvement to June 30, 1909, is
 $96,707.35, of which $93,707.35 is on the present project, and of this
latter $7,203.18 was for maintenance.
    The maximum drafts that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water over the part of the creek under improvement are
12 feet to the phosphate works, thence 8 feet to Paulsboro, and
thence, for 12,000 feet, 7 feet. The stream is navigable for small
craft for about one-half mile above Mantua.
    It has been impracticable to obtain commercial statistics for the
entire river, but the receipts by water at Mantua during the calendar
202         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                UT. S. ARMY.

year 1908 were 35,250 tons, valued at $214,225. This is but a small
fraction of the entire traffic.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, provided for a prelimni-
nary examination and survey of Mantua Creek, "with a view to
continuing improvement to the head of navigation," and the survey
is now in progress.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below on the
construction of the project channel above Paulsboro and on the main-
tenance of the improvement below Paulsboro by dredging and jetty
repairs. This will extend the availability of the stream for navigation.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......---...............         ..-...........             $13, 167. 16
Received from sales ..... ............ .... ........... ........            ..........           100. 00
                                                                                            13, 267. 16
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement. ............................. $5, 221. 33
    For maintenance of improvement......................_ 7, 203. 18
                                                                                             12, 424. 51

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-......-....-._.....            .......-..               --... a 842. 65
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.-.........                    57, 783. 18
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvemnent and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909..................................                         31,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix I 2.)
   3. Raccoon Greelc, New Jersey.-This creek rises in Gloucester
County, flows in a northwesterly direction, and empties into the Dela-
ware River at a point nearly opposite Marcushook, Pa. A pre-
liminary examination and survey of Raccoon Creek was made in
1899, and a report, with estimated cost of improvement, is printed in
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, pages 1590-1598.
   It was navigable at high water for a distance of 1 miles above its
mouth to Bridgeport for vessels of 9 feet draft, thence 31 miles
farther to Springer's wharf for vessels drawing 7 feet, and thence
4- miles to Swedesboro, the head of steam navigation for boats and
barges having a draft of 4 feet. Above Swedesboro the stream was
narrow, shoal, and very crooked. The navigable portion, when it
left fast land, wound through meadows lying 2 or 3 feet above low
water, which, except for the 2 miles immediately below Swedesboro,
were generally protected from overflow by revetted earthen banks.
Navigation was much obstructed by bars and a few sharp bends.
    The range of tide varies from 6 feet at the confluence with the
Delaware River to 4.9 feet at Swedesboro, where it is considerably
influenced by winds and freshets.
    The approved project, adopted by river and harbor act of June 13,
1902, proposes the formation of a dredged channel 7 feet deep and
75 feet in width at mean low water from the mouth for a distance
of la miles to Bridgeport, thence a channel of the same depth and
60 feet wide to Springer's wharf, and thence a channel 5 feet deep
at mean low water and 40 feet in width to the head of navigation
  a In addition to this balance the sum of $7,000 is made available by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, but not yet allotted.
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                            203
at Swedesboro, 9 miles from its mouth, together with the widening
of the channel around sharp bends, at an estimated cost of $102,135.
   Between 1903 and 1906 a continuous channel was dredged to the
project dimensions from the mouth to the highway bridge at Swedes-
boro, except widening at bends and the construction of the cut-off
at Molonox shoal.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $15,000
for continuing the improvement and for maintenance, and authorized
a sufficient amount thereof to be applied to the making of a cut-off
at Molonox shoal, with proviso that no expenditure should be made
thereon until the land needed therefor should have been deeded to the
United States free of expense. This title has been acquired and con-
tract entered into for making the cut-off. Work under this contract
was begun on May 13, 1909, and to the end of the fiscal year a length
of 3,370 feet of channel had been completed. The maintenance
expenses were for supervision and examination.
   The amount expended on the improvement to June 30, 1909, is
$26,271.30, of which $3,246.76 was for maintenance. Of the former
amount $25,514.07 was on the present project.
   The maximum drafts that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water were 7 feet from the Delaware River to Bridgeport,
6 feet to Springer's, and 4 feet thence to Swedesboro.
   The improvement of the stream has so far had no marked effect
upon freight rates. Perishable freight is now expeditiously carried
and bulky freight by water costs only about half that by rail. The
execution of the work has altered the stream by increasing the tidal
range in the upper waters about 1 foot and, therefore, to effect the
provisions of the project, it is necessary to do additional dredging to
secure the low water depth contemplated. About one-half of the pro-
jected work has been done.
   The commerce of the creek during the calendar year 1908, as re-
ported, was 92,268 tons, valued at $879,150.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below in obtaining
the project depth on the new mean low water level, in widening the
bends, and in maintenance; all in extension of benefits to navigation.
July 1, 19(8, balance unexpended.......................                  ............      $23, 941. 69
Received from sales ......................................                     ...........      100. 00

                                                                                            24, 041. 69
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...........................                       $2, 021. 66
    For maintenance of improvement .....................                          191. 33
                                                                                             2, 212.99

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                      21, 828.70
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....-... ................ ............             .    1, 980. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available_.................      ....................                 19, 848.70
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts...............                        14, 700.00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                      57, 326. 33
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...............................                           15, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix I 3.)
204      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

   4. Salem River, New Jersey.-In 1872 the upper part of this river
was separated from the lower part by a dam and was connected with
the Delaware River by a canal forming two independent streams with
mouths about 10 miles apart.
   Prior to the adoption of the present project $17,209.34 had been
expended on improvement of this stream, of which $10,000 was ap-
plied to work in Salem Cove, at the natural mouth below Salem, with
which a channel 8 feet deep and 100 feet wide at low water was
obtained, and $7,209.34 to improvement of the upper river in the
formation of a channel 6 feet deep and 50 feet wide at mean low
water up to Hoxies Landing.
   Report of survey on which the present project is based is printed
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 1245,
and report thereon by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors
is printed in River and Harbor Committee Document No. 12, Fifty-
ninth Congress, second session.
   The existing project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, which appropriated $29,000 for completion of the im-
provement. It provides for dredging the lower river below Salem
100 feet wide and 9 feet deep at mean low water, amplifying at the
bends so as to permit the passage of vessels 200 feet long from Dela-
ware River up to the highway bridge over Little Salem Creek, in-
cluding the removal of the stony bars in front of the city wharves and
at the bend above the brickyard. The estimated cost of this work, as
given by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors in report of
January 16, 1907, is $29,000, subsequently increased to $38,600.
   After an examination of the channel proposals were invited in July,
1907, for the required dredging, but as only one bid was received, at
27.5 cents per cubic yard, which was considered excessive, it was
rejected. Proposals were again opened in May, 1908, under more
favorable conditions, the lowest bid received this time being 19.9
cents per cubic yard.
   In the examination above referred to it was found that the amount
of material to be excavated to obtain the project channel dimensions,
with an allowance of 1 foot for overdepth dredging, would be con-
siderably in excess of that given in the report of survey of 1897, and,
upon recommendation of the Chief of Engineers, the Secretary of
War, in accordance with section 2 of the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, authorized the expenditure of the available funds to
the excavation of a channel of such dimensions as could be secured
thereby.
   Accordingly a contract for dredging was entered into and com-
pleted April 30, 1909. The channel was dredged to a depth of 10
feet, including one foot for overdepth made under the contract, and
a width of 100 feet from the 9-foot curve in the Delaware River to
the 9-foot depth in Salem River, a distance of 7,350 feet; and from
the lower part of Little Salem River to the Covered Bridge, a sta-
tionary structure, a distance of 2,920 feet, the channel was dredged
to a depth of 9 feet at mean low water and a width of 75 feet, resulting
in a channel 9 feet deep at mean low water from the Delaware River
to the Covered Bridge, the head of navigation at Salem, a distance
of about 4 miles, the width being 100 feet in the Delaware River
to inside the mouth of Salem River, widening to 200 feet at the
beacon, and thence 75 feet to Salem. The maintenance expense
was for examination and supervision.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          205

   About 80 per cent of the projected work has been done.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water over the part of the river under improvement between
Salem and the Delaware River was 9 feet, the rise and fall of tide
being 6 feet.
   The amount expended on the improvement to June 30, 1909, is
$45,273.89, of which $28,064.55 is on the present project, of which
$357.22 was for maintenance.
  The commerce for the calendar year 1908 was 121,658 tons, valued
at $3,063,051. The effect of the improvement on freight rates has
not been reported, but it has facilitated and expedited shipments of
fruits and other perishable merchandise.
   In view of the fact that the approved project can not be completed
with the funds appropriated on the original estimate for completion,
recommendation is made below for an additional appropriation of
$9,957.22 to complete the project, and for the necessary funds to
maintain the channel, all of which will extend the benefits resulting.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. .... ........................                    ....... $28, 063. 11
Received from sales ...................................................                         100. 00

                                                                                             28, 163. 11
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..............................                    $26, 770. 44
    For maintenance of improvement.. ......................                        357. 22
                                                                                             27, 127. 66

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                    al, 035. 45
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..-------......-----...----........................
                                                                   ----------------           13. 20

July 1, 1909, balance available.....-------------------------..............-----------....    1, 022. 25

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project............                    9, 957. 22

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909- ........ ......................       14, 600. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix I 4.)
  5. Alloway Creek, New Jersey.-This is a tidal tributary of the
Delaware River, flowing westerly in the southwestern part of New
Jersey, its mouth being about 50 miles below Camden, N. J. In its
original condition the creek was obstructed between its mouth and
Quinton, a distance of about 10 miles, by shoal areas in the upper
half of the stream, which reduced the low-water depths to from 1.3
to 4 feet. The mean range of tide is 6 feet at the mouth and 4 feet
at Quinton, the head of navigation.
   The original project of 1889 proposed the formation by dredging
of a channel 6 feet deep at mean low water and 60 feet wide from
Quinton to a point about 1,000 feet above upper Hancock Bridge;
thence a channel of the same depth and 75 feet wide to a locality
known as the "Square," where the work was to be supplemented by
a dike. At a locality known as the "Canal," in addition to a chan-
nel of the last-named dimensions, the width of the stream was to be
increased to about 150 feet between its low-water lines. The project
  a In addition to this balance the sum of $5,000 is made available by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, but not yet allotted.
206        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                S. ARMY.

was modified on December 10, 1896, so as to provide for a dike formed
by a single row of piles above upper Hancock Bridge. This modifi-
cation did not increase the originally estimated cost of the work,
which is $25,000.
    Channels from 40 to 75 feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water
have been dredged at various localities, and dikes 300 and 404 feet in
length, respectively, have been constructed at the "Square" and
above upper Hancock Bridge. The channel has been dredged not
less than 75 feet wide and 6 feet deep from the mouth to a point
one-half mile below Hancock Bridge, and thence 60 feet wide and
6 feet deep to the upper end of a shoal just above Hancock Bridge,
a distance of 4.92 miles. This work extended to January, 1908.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $5,000
for continuing improvement and maintenance, and authorized a suffi-
cient amount thereof to be applied to the construction of a cut-off at
Fosters Bottle, with the proviso that no expenditure should be made
thereon until all land needed for such cut-off should be deeded to the
United States free of expense. During the past fiscal year this title
was obtained, and under a contract the cut-off at Fosters Bottle was
made, and resulted in a straight channel through it of a minimum
depth of 7 feet at mean low water and a bottom width of a least 75
feet, 1 foot overdepth and side slopes having been allowed in accord-
ance with the contract. This completed the contract.
   The amount expended on the improvement to June 30, 1909, is
$28,875.84, of which $7,478.11 was for maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, to
Quinton, was 4 feet.
   The commerce of the creek consists of miscellaneous articles, such
as coal, sand, lumber, agricultural products, etc. The tonnage for
the calendar year 1908 was 18,490, valued at $658,125.
   The freight rates are reported to have been lowered by reason of
the improvement of the creek, but to what extent is not stated.
Larger boats are enabled to enter and depart, and shipments have
been facilitated very much by avoiding delays in waiting for tides.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below in main-
tenance of the improvement by dredging, which will extend the bene-
fits of the improvement.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..............-........................ $5, 032. 87
Received from sales ..................................................       100. 00
                                                                            5, 132. 87
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  m ent ................ ....                  ... ...................
                          ......................                            4, 908.71

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................      a 224. 16

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........     200. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1,1909................................................       7, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix I 5.)
  aIn addition to this balance the sum of $5,000 is made available by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, but not yet allotted.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      207
   6. Cohansey River, New Jersey.-In its original condition this river
or creek was navigable to Bridgeton, 19 miles above the mouth,
through a tortuous channel of ample depth. The obstructions to
navigation were found at Bridgeton, where the city gas and water
mains were laid at a depth of only 4 feet below low water, and at the
mouth, where the river discharged into Delaware Bay across a soft
mud bar without any well-defined channel. At Bridgeton there is a
fixed bridge known as the Nail Works Bridge, and just above the
bridge is a milldam which limits the tidal basin of the stream.
   Prior to adoption of the present project $36,000 had been expended
in dredging a channel 7 feet deep at mean low water 70 to 90 feet
wide to the Broad Street Bridge, 40 feet wide above to the Commerce
Street Bridge, thence 4 feet deep to the Nail Works Bridge.
   The present project is printed in House Document No. 645, Fifty-
ninth Congress, first session, and was adopted in the river and harbor
act of March 2, 1907. It provides for dredging a cut 100 feet wide
and 7 feet deep at mean low water at the mouth, and for dredging a
channel to the same depth in the river from Stony Point to the Nail
Works Bridge, the widths to be 100 feet to Broad Street Bridge,
thence 75 feet to the Commerce Street Bridge, and thence 60 feet to
the Nail Works Bridge, at an estimated cost of $55,800, which is the
amount appropriated.
   The range of tides at the mouth is about 51 feet, and at Bridgeton
is nearly 7 feet, which was practically all the available depth along the
wharves of the town.
   The gas and water mains obstructing the channel at Bridgeton
having been removed, the channel was dredged between August, 1907,
and February, 1908, from deep water at Stony Point to the nail
works, the depth made being 8 feet at mean low water-which in-
cluded 1 foot for overdepth allowed under the contract-100 feet
wide to Broad street, 75 feet wide thence to Commerce street, and 60
feet wide thence to the Nail Works Bridge.
   No work was done during the past fiscal year. The expenditures
were for inspection and supervision expenses.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water over the locality under improvement was 7 feet to
head of navigation except that only 5 feet draft was available over the
bar at the mouth.
   No work can be done at the mouth until title has been secured to a
tract of land needed for a cut-off. Negotiations for the transfer to
the United States of this land free of cost have been in progress for
some time, but owing to legal obstacles have not yet been consum-
mated.
   The amount expended on this improvement under the present
project to June 30, 1909, is $23,156.67, of which $52.78 was for main-
tenance. About 40 per cent of the projected work has been done.
   The commerce for the calendar year 1908 is reported to have been
51,817 tons, valued at $371,600.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below in main-
tenance of the improvement to extend the benefits and to make them
available at all stages of the tide.
208          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                U.   S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................                             $32, 696. 11
Received from sales .. ............ ......... ....... ............. .......                             100. 00
                                                                                                    32, 796. 11
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement---------------.......------------------..........----------.......-------.........         52.78
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                             a 32, 743. 33
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 ..........   ....................................                               6, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix I 6.)
   7. Tuckerton Creek, New Jersey.-This is a tidal stream flowing
into Little Egg Harbor, on the Atlantic coast, northeast of Atlantic
City. A preliminary examination and survey of the creek were
made, and a report recommending its improvement is printed in
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, pages 1612-1615.
   The original low-water depth at Tuckerton, the head of naviga-
tion, was 15 inches, which increased gradually to 4 feet at the mouth
of the creek, a distance of 2 miles. From the mouth of the creek
across the flats to Gaunts Point, seven-eighths of a mile, the low-water
depths were 2 to 2 feet. The mean tidal range is 2 feet.
   The existing project, adopted by the river and harbor act of June
13, 1902, contemplates the dredging of a channel 6 feet deep at mean
low water and 80 feet wide from Gaunts Point, seven-eights of a
mile, to the mouth of the creek; thence a channel of the same depth
and 75 feet wide, 1 mile, to Parkers Landing; thence a channel of
the same depth and 60 feet wide, five-eighths of a mile farther, to
West Tuckerton Landing; thence a channel 5 feet deep at mean low
water and 60 feet wide for three-eighths of a mile to just above Scow
Landing, and thence a channel 3 feet deep at mean low water and 40
feet wide for one-eighth of a mile to the milldam at Tuckerton, together
with the widening of the channel at sharp bends; the channel across
the cove between the mouth of the creek and Oyster Bed Point to
be supplemented, if necessary, by a revetment wall along its north-
ern side. The estimated cost of the work, including contingencies,
is $61,380. Under authority contained in the river and harbor
act of March 3, 1905, the Secretary of War authorized the location
of the channel at the mouth to be changed so as to lead it in a south-
southeast direction directly to the deep water at the head of March-
elder channel instead of to Gaunts Point.
   The channel has been dredged to the project widths from the
mouth of the river to a point 2,100 feet below the milldam at Tucker-
ton, the depth made being 6 feet at mean low water, except the upper
581 feet, which was dredged to 5 feet at mean low water. This
completed about one-half of the project.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $12,000
for continuing the improvement, and a project for the expenditure of
the appropriation was duly approved by the Chief of Engineers.
  a In addition to this balance the sum of $6,000 is made available by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, but not yet allotted.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     209
This included dredging of the cut from the mouth of Tuckerton
Creek to the Marchelder channel. It was then found, however, that
dredging along that line would destroy several oyster beds held and
owned by private parties under leases from the State of New Jersey,
and it was therefore concluded to defer operations until this matter
could be adjusted.
   Under date of December 16, 1907, the chief of the bureau of shell
fisheries of the State of New Jersey advised this department that
all objection to the proposed dredging had been removed, and there-
upon contract for the dredging was entered into. The contract pro-
vided for dredging a straight channel from deep water of March-
elder channel, off Parkers Island, across the flats of Little Egg Harbor,
to the mouth of Tuckerton Creek, passing through the point on
the southwest side of the mouth, and then dredging, as far as the
available funds would permit, the upper river, the depths to be 5
feet at mean low water from Marchelder channel to Scow Landing,
and thence 3 feet to the milldam.
   The contractor's plant arrived at the lower end of Marchelder
channel on June 19, 1908, and to the end of July only 1,048 cubic
yards of material had been dredged, and no work was done there-
after. On September 10, 1908, the contract was annulled. New
proposals for the dredging were opened October 30, 1908, but as the
prices bid were excessive the bids were rejected.
    The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, provided $2,000 for
maintenance of this improvement, and proposals were then invited
for dredging with the entire amount available, but no bid was received.
Proposals were again invited upon revised specifications and these
are to be opened July 8, 1909.
    The maximum drafts that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water over the locality of the improvement were 2 feet
from the milldam to Scow Landing, 4 feet thence to West Tucker-
ton, 51 feet thence to Parkers, 6 feet thence to the mouth, and
thence 24 feet to the head of Marchelder channel.
    The amount expended on the improvement to June 30, 1909, is
 $24,846.43, of which $2,215.15 was for maintenance.
    The commerce reported for the calendar year 1908 is 26,609 tons,
valued at $1,192,898.
    The improvement of Tuckerton Creek is not yet sufficiently advanced
to show any material decrease in freight rates. Shipments from
distant points have, however, been increased and facilitated, although
lumber-laden vessels still are obliged to await tides at the flats at
the mouth of the creek.
    As the project progresses it is believed that cost of maintenance will
decrease.
    It is contemplated to expend the funds recommended below in
dredging for restoring and maintaining the present channel and in
completing the work under the approved project to render the
improvement available.
     9001-ENG 1909--14
210             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                         S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended........................... -.....- . $12, 033. 09
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act ap-
  proved March 3, 1909 ................. ......--................       2, 000. 00
                                                                                                                            14, 033. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.................................------------------------------------........--------....--------------............      879. 52

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .-...........               ............ ............                                      13, 153. 57
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..-..........-..-.......-............                                                     118. 81
July 1, 1909, balance available ...............                                ......          .................            13, 034. 76
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ..........                                                   27, 380. 00
"Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909....................................... 31, 380.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix I 7.)
   8. Cold Spring Inlet, New Jersey.-This is a new work. The
locality is on the coast of New Jersey, about 3 miles east of the city
of Cape May. Within the inlet there was originally a natural basin
about 6 feet deep and 60 acres in area. In the throat of the inlet the
depth was 29 feet at mean low water and on the outside bar there
was a minimum depth of 3.5 feet at low water about one-half mile
out. There was no commerce.
   Improvement of the locality was begun by private parties to en-
large the basin inside the inlet to about 500 acres in area, with a
depth of 30 to 40 feet; and to complete the plan for a safe land-
locked harbor for commerce and refuge the General Government has
undertaken to provide a suitable connection between it and the deep
water in the ocean, so as to make the harbor accessible to seagoing
vessels.
   The plan of improvement adopted by the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, contemplates providing an entrance channel 25 feet
deep at mean low water by construction of parallel jetties 750 to 850
feet apart and dredging between them, at an estimated cost of
$1,311,000. The adoption of this project was conditional upon the
contribution of $100,000 toward the improvement by local authori-
ties or private parties. This contribution was made by deposit on
February 28, 1908, with the assistant treasurer of the United States
at Philadelphia, Pa., of $100,000 to the credit of Maj. C. A. F. Flagler,
Corps of Engineers, the district engineer officer, by the Cape May
Real Estate Company.
   All the requirements of the act of 1907 relative to conveyance of
land, etc., have been carried out and the deeds of conveyance to the
United States approved by the Department of Justice.
   The dredging of the harbor is a little more than one-half com-
pleted; no work is in progress at present. By an instrument dated
December 9, 1908, supplemental to an agreement executed June 25,
1907, the time for the completion of the inner harbor by the Cape May
Real Estate Company is extended to September 30, 1910.
   The report of survey upon which the plan of improvement is based
is printed in House Document No. 388, Fifty-ninth Congress, second
session.
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  211

   On October 3, 1907, proposals were opened for the required jetty
work and award made to the lowest bidder, the Seacoast Construction
Company, of New York. This company, however, failed to execute
the contract required, and later, upon evidence that it had been
merged into the Breakwater Construction and Engineering Company,
a contract, dated January 18, 1908, was entered into with that com-
pany on the bid submitted by the Seacoast Construction Company,
the work to be commenced within sixty days and completed within
two years and two months after notification of approval of the con-
tract, which was received by the company on April 20, 1908.
   The United States work at this point is under a continuing-con-
tract appropriation; the balance of the authorization remaining to
be appropriated is $379,800.
   Work under the contract was begun at the site on July 29, 1908,
by the Breakwater Company, the legal assignee and successor of the
Breakwater Construction and Engineering Company, and to the end
of the fiscal year about 29 per cent of the contract work had been
done. In the west pile, brush, and stone jetty and in the wing of that
jetty the piling had been placed, and in the pile, brush, and stone
wing of the east jetty 369 piles had been driven. About 75,079 net
tons of stone had been deposited in the east and west jetties.
   Under date of May 13, 1909, the Acting Secretary of War approved
supplementary articles of agreement entered into with the Break-
water Company for the omission of the lower wales and the substitu-
tion of brush in place of stone to a varying height of from half tide to
high water for the purpose of deflecting and directing the tidal cur-
rent and facilitating the work of scouring a channel through the bar
of sufficient depth to allow the passage of barges of stone for filling
the jetty, in consideration of which the Breakwater Company allows
the United States a rebate of $1,170 and a deduction of $1.75 for each
cubic yard of stone replaced by brush.
   The range of tide at the inlet is 41 feet.
   The amount expended on the improvement to June 30, 1909, is
$120,246.37, of which $2,800.41 was from funds contributed by the
Cape May Real Estate Company.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................... $628, 979. 58
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 284, 000. 00

                                                                            912, 979. 58
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ...............................   .........  .............. ....... a102, 025. 95

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................                       ...............    810, 953. 63
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....... ........               ...........     ........     43, 160. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available- ...................      -.......    .......-                  b 767, 793. 63
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                            486, 930. 00

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                          379, 800. 00
   (See Appendix I 8.)
           a United States funds, $99,225.54; private contribution, $2,800.41.
           bUnited States funds, $712,766.77; private contribution, $55,026.86.
212      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

    9. Wilmington Harbor, Delaware.-The harbor of Wilmington,
Del., is in the Christiana River and includes a length of about 4 miles
above its mouth at the Delaware River. It also includes the navi-
gable portion of the Brandywine River (2 miles), which flows into
the Christiana River at a point about 14 miles above its mouth.
    Previous to 1836, when the first appropriation for the improvement
of the Christiana River was made, the low-water depth at the en-
trance to this stream was about 8 feet. The minimum depth in
the channel in the portion of the river below Third Street Bridge,
Wilmington, was 8 feet. This depth was increased in 1836 by dredg-
ing to 10 feet below low water, and under projects of 1871 and 1881
to 12 and 15 feet, respectively.
    The present project is based upon a survey made in 1895 and
adopted in river and harbor act of June 3, 1896. It provides for
the formation, by dredging, rock removal, and construction of dikes,
of a channel in the Christiana River 21 feet deep at mean low water
from that depth in the Delaware River to the pulp works, a distance
of about 4 miles, and thence diminishing to a depth of 10 feet at
mean low water to the draw pier of the Philadelphia, Baltimore and
Washington Railroad cut-off bridge No. 4, the width at bottom vary-
ing between 250 feet at the mouth and 200 feet at bridge No. 4. The
project further provides for the removal of shoals from bridge No. 4
to Newport to a depth of 7 feet at mean low water. This project was
completed in 1906. The depth made over the rock ledges just above
and below the Third Street Bridge is about 211 feet.
    Further work contemplated is for maintenance of the improvement.
    Under an act of the legislature of the State of Delaware approved
March 9, 1901, authorizing and requiring the city of Wilmington to
contribute to the extent of 10 per cent of the amount expended by the
United States Government, for the improvement of Wilmington
Harbor, the sum of $4,400.54 was expended by the city of Wilmington
in October and November, 1906, in dredging the channel between the
Third Street Bridge and the Market Street Bridge, resulting in a con-
tinuous channel 75 feet wide and 17 feet deep at mean low water
between the points named, and connecting them with the channel
dredged by the General Government. This work was done under the
supervision of the local United States engineer officer.
    The city of Wilmington also, under the state law above referred to,
appropriated the further sum of $6,567.41 as its contribution for the
fiscal year 1909 for the improvement of Wilmington Harbor, but this
money has not been expended or turned over for expenditure to the
local United States engiieer officer, as required by the state act,
although readiness to expend it was expressed by him. This appro-
priation lapsed on June 30; an equal amount has similarly been appro-
priated for the fiscal year 1910, but no indications of its transfer or
other expenditure have become manifest, although the local United
States engineer officer has brought to the attention of the city author-
ities the urgent necessity therefor.
    In 1907 slight repairs were made to the jetties at the mouths of the
Brandywine and Christiana rivers.
    Under contract completed July 16, 1908, the channel was dredged
to a depth of 19 feet and a width of 250 feet from the 18-foot depth in
Delaware River to a point about 1,200 feet above Lobdells Canal, and
200 feet wide and 19 feet deep at mean low water from a point opposite
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      213

Harlan & Hollingsworth's dry dock to a point about 150 feet above
Market Street Bridge; and under a contract completed in November,
1908, the channel was dredged to a depth of 19 feet and width of 100
feet from the Pennsylvania Railroad cut-off bridge No. 3 to the mouth
of the Brandywine, and from Third Street Bridge to Market Street
Bridge to a depth of 18 feet and width of 100 feet, the depths made
including 1 foot for overdepth allowed under the contract.
   On April 2, 1909, the Chief of Engineers allotted $40,000 from the
appropriation made by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909,
for preservation and maintenance of river and harbor works, and
contract has been made for dredging with the available funds
Work under this contract was begun on June 11, and to the end of
the fiscal year a length of 3,325 feet in the lower part of the river had
been dredged to a depth of 19 feet at mean low water and a width of
150 feet.
   On June 30, 1909, the condition of the channel was as follows:
From the Delaware River to the Christiana light a depth of 17 feet
at mean low water for a width of 150 feet; thence to Lobdells Canal
11 feet at mean low water for a width of from 100 to 250 feet; thence
to Fourth street wharf 18 feet for a width of 90 to 180 feet; thence
to Third Street Bridge 10 feet for a width of 200 feet; thence to
Market Street Bridge 15 feet for a width of 200 feet; thence to
Harlan & HTollingsworth Corporation's dry dock 18 feet for a width
of from 100 to 150 feet; thence to the pulp works 12 feet for a
width of about 80 feet; and thence to Newport 6 feet for a width of
about 80 feet.
   Between July 10 and 17, 1908, eighteen stumps and logs and parts
of two wrecks were removed from the channel of the upper Chris-
tiana River above Churchman's bridge, at a cost of $265.98, with an
allotment approved by the Secretary of War June 12, 1908, from
the appropriation for emergencies made by the river and harbor act
of March 2, 1907.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water over the part of the river under improvement was
13.5 feet to the pulp works and 6 feet thence to Newport. The
stream is navigable to about one-fourth mile above the village of
Christiana, or 152 miles from the mouth. The tidal range at the
mouth is slightly over 6 feet and at Christiana village about 3.6 feet.
    The amount expended on this improvement from 1836 to June 30,
1909, is $994,403.96.' Of this amount $592,282.75 was expended
on the present project, of which $148,631.12 was for maintenance.
This is exclusive of $500.69 expended from appropriation for emer-
gencies in removal of obstructions from the channel above Church-
man's bridge.
    The tonnage of the leading articles shipped to and from the port of
Wilmington in the calendar year 1908 is reported to have been
738,403 tons, valued at $61,026,414.
    The shipbuilding industry on the river is quite extensive, the
records of the Department of Commerce and Labor showing that,
with the exception of Philadelphia and Newport News, Wilmington
has the largest steel shipbuilding output on the Atlantic coast for the
ten years ending June 30, 1905.
    The harbor improvements do not directly affect freight rates on
light-draft boats to any extent. Shipments thereon made by water
214            REPORT OF THE CHIEF                           OF ENGINEERS, U.                    S. ARMY.

range about 25 per cent lower in rate than by rail, but much more in
deep-draft vessels, of which there are many, covering shipments to
and from the manufacturers and shipbuilding plants.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below in main-
tenance of the improvement in restoration of an 18-foot channel on
project widths in the lower harbor and restoration of project depths
and widths in the upper harbor to Newport, and in repairs to the
superstructure of the north jetty at the mouth of the Christiana
River, all in extending the benefits to navigation.
                                             GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

                                                                               ------------------ $34, 142. 53
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.........-----------..----.........................
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act ap-
  proved March 3, 1909.........................------------......--------...............------------------           40, 000. 00
Received from sales-----------------------------------------------..................................................     426. 26
                                                                                                                   74, 568. 79
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement------.............-------------.........--------......------..................-------------         25, 077. 68
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...-----------...----------------......................-----......               49,491. 11
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities -....-..-...... ............                       ...-.....                 4, 500. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available.............                        ........................               ..     44, 991. 11

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                                            30, 500. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance
   unexpended July 1, 1909..........................................                                              280, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                 EMERGENCIES IN             RIVERS       AND HARBORS.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................                                               $1, 015. 19
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
   improvement...-----------------..........--.............-----------..........---.------..--.....------------       265. 88

June 30, 1909, amount returned to Treasury to credit of appropriation....                                              749. 31
    (See Appendix I 9.)
   10. Appoquinimink, Murderkill, and Mispillion rivers, Delaware.-
(a) Appoquinimink River.-At the time of the adoption of the pres-
ent project there was a mean low-water depth of 2 feet at the entrance
into Delaware Bay, and the shoalest depth inside the river was 4
feet. The most serious obstructions to the navigation of the river
were the many bends in the lower and middle sections.
   The approved project is based upon a survey made in 1889, and
adopted by Congress in river and harbor act of September 19, 1890.
It provides for a channel 8 feet deep at mean low water, having a
width of 80 feet from the bridge at Odessa to New bridge, near Town-
send's wharf, a distance of 34 miles, and a width of 100 feet from
this wharf to the mouth of the river, a distance of 5 miles. The esti-
mated cost of the improvement is $39,963.
   A history of the work done up to June 30, 1905, may be found in
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, pages 175-176.
   With $5,500 allotted by the Secretary of War in 1905 from the
appropriation made by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, for
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                215
improving Appoquinimink, Murderkill, and Mispillion rivers, a, cut-
off was made through the neck of land on the left bank of the river
leading to Fennimore's (or New) bridge, about halfway between the
mouth and Odessa. This cut-off shortened the channel distance by
2,272 feet, the distance between Odessa and the 7-foot contour in
Delaware Bay being now about 64 miles.
   Under the provisions of the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907,
the Secretary of War, on March 20, 1907, approved an allotment of
$6,400 for expenditure on this improvement. Of this amount $5,000
pertained to the act referred to and the remainder was funds per-
taining to former allotment. With these funds the channel has been
dredged to not less than 7 feet deep at mean low water and 50 feet
wide between Odessa and the mouth. No work was done during the
year. The expenditure was for supervision expenses.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water in the river was 61 feet, and across the flats at the
mouth 4 feet. The range of tide is 6 feet at the mouth and 32 feet
at Odessa.
   The stream is navigable for small craft to Noxentown milldam,
about 4 miles above Odessa, making the navigable portion of the
stream 10} miles long now.
   The amount expended on the improvement to June 30, 1909, is
$41,182.65, of which $9,140.24 was for maintenance.
   About three-fifths of the work on the project has been completed.
   The commerce of the river for the calendar year 1908 is reported to
have been 30,975 tons, valued at $1,942,325.
   The freight rates, it has been reported, remain about the same, but
the passenger business has increased in consequence of the improve-
ment of the river.
   Under date of June 29, 1909, the sum of $5,000 was allotted from
the appropriation made by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909,
to be applied to the maintenance of the improvement, and to utilize
the available funds bids for dredging operations will be opened soon.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below in com-
pleting, to project dimensions, the channel of the river and in main-
tenance work, for an extension of the benefits to navigation.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ---.................--.....--                      ....--
                                                                               ------......----...                $1, 422. 77
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909-----....--------...............-----------------...........-------------...........----..........  5, 000. 00
Received from sales ....................................................                                              150. 00
                                                                                                                        6, 572. 77
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement..................................................-----------------------------------------------------.        8. 51

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................                                ....................                  6, 564. 26


IAmount
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........
           that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909 . .............
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
                                                                                                                        7, 400. 00


                                                                                                                          (a)
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                           a See consolidated money statement on page 219.
216     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U. S. ARMY.

    (b) Murderkill River.-This river is a tidal stream and a tributary
of Delaware Bay and flows through Kent County, Del. Its navigable
portion is about 9 miles long. The condition of the river was fair for
the greater part of its length, the average width and depth being 90
and 6 feet, respectively. Outside the junction with Delaware Bay,
however, there was a serious obstruction-the flats, which are nearly
bare at low tide and extend for nearly a mile from the shore. The
average rise and fall of the tide at the mouth is 4.6 feet and 2 feet
at Frederica.
   In 1881 an examination of this river was made and a project sub-
mitted for its improvement. No appropriation was made by Con-
gress, however, as the river was at that time in the hands of an
improvement and navigation company chartered by the State. This
company had expended about $10,000 in rectifying the many bends of
the river by cutting straight canals and in dredging a narrow cut
across the flats at the mouth. The latter slowly filled up again.
   Under the provisions of the river and harbor act of September 19,
1890, a survey was made, and report thereon is printed in House
Executive Document No. 21, Fifty-second Congress, first session.
   The project for improvement, which was adopted in the river and
harbor act of July 13, 1892, is for a 7-foot low-water channel, 80 feet
wide from the town of Frederica, at the head of navigation, to the
mouth of the river, 8 miles, and 150 feet wide from the mouth, across
the flats outside to the 7-foot curve of depth in Delaware Bay, the
cut at the mouth to be protected by forming an embankment of the
dredged material on each side, the estimated cost being $47,550.
   Dredging for original work and for maintenance has been done at
different times since 1893. A history of operations to June 30, 1905,
will be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905,
pages 177-178.
   With funds derived from the river and harbor appropriations of
March 3, 1905, and March 2, 1907, and emergency appropriations of
1905 and 1907, the river has been dredged at various points and
across the flats at the mouth, resulting in a channel not less than 50
feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water from Frederica to the
6-foot curve in Delaware Bay.
   About 50 per cent of the project has been completed.
   With an allotment of $3,000 from the emergency appropriation
provided by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, the channel
was redredged in 1908 across the flats at the mouth and in the river,
resulting in a continuous channel at least 6 feet deep at mean low
water and at least 50 feet wide from Frederica to the 6-foot curve in
Delaware Bay.
    The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water in the part of the river under improvement is 5 feet
from Frederica to the mouth and 5 feet across the flats to Delaware
Bay.
    Under date of May 1, 1909, the sum of $7,000 was allotted from
the appropriation for preservation and maintenance made by the
river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, and on July 2, 1909, proposals
are to be opened for dredging therewith at the mouth and in the river.
    The amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909, is
 $50,279.01, of which $26,918.23 was for maintenance.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               217
   The commerce of the river, which is quite varied, is reported for
the calendar year 1908 as 29,478 tons, valued at $1,158,800.
   As to the effect of the improvement of this stream upon freight
rates, it is reported that rates by water are 25 to 50 per cent lower
than by rail, and that in winter, when the boats can not run, the
railroad increases its rates.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below in dredg-
ing the channel to full project dimensions as far as possible and in
maintenance work for the purpose of extension of benefits.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................-.................... $3, 674. 85
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act ap-
  proved March 3, 1909...................................... ..... .... 7, 000. 00
                                                                                                 10, 674.35
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for mainte-
  nance of improvement....-----......---------------------.............------..... $2, 941. 38
Returned to credit appropriation for emergencies in river and
  harbor works-.............         ......   ............................              61.49
                                                                                                  3, 002.87
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................................                          7, 671. 98
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 23, 264. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ......----..............................                         (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Mispillion River.--This river is a tidal stream which enters
Delaware Bay about 17 miles northwest of Cape Henlopen. It is
navigable for about 13 miles. The mouth of the river was greatly
obstructed by a flat foreshore without a channel. Vessels could enter
and depart only at high water, the tidal range being about 4 feet.
   The river from Milford, the head of navigation, to the mouth was
improved by the General Government between the years 1879 and
1889; $17,000 was expended in making a channel 40 feet wide and
6 feet deep at mean low water. Its further improvement was car-
ried on to November, 1906, under a project adopted in the river and
harbor act of July 13, 1892. This resulted in a channel 40 feet wide
and 4 feet deep at mean low water from Milford to the mouth and
50 feet wide and 5 feet deep thence to the 5-foot contour in Delaware
Bay; and two jetties at the mouth, one, the north jetty, extending
from the east bank of the river a length of 1,645 feet, and the other,
the south, or Green Point, jetty, extending from Green Point, just
below the mouth of Cedar Creek, a distance of 1,100 feet, 500 feet of
the outer end being parallel to and 100 feet distant from the axis of
the dredged channel, and 200 feet from the north jetty.
   The present project was adopted in the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, and is based upon the report printed in House Docu-
ment No. 102, Fifty-sixth Congress, second session. This provides for
dredging the channel 6 feet deep at mean low water and 60 feet wide,
increasing to 75 feet at sharp turns, from Milford to the mouth and
thence 4 feet deep and 150 feet wide across the flats, and the construc-
tion of a jetty along the south side of the channel, at an estimated cost
of $87,065.
                      a See consolidated money statement on page 219.
218             REPORT OF THE CHIEF                          OF ENGINEERS,                 U.      S. ARMY.

   From the appropriation made by the act of March 2, 1907, for im-
proving the Appoquinimink, Murderkill, and Mispillion rivers, Dela-
ware, $40,000 was allotted for the Mispillion, with which an extension
has been built to the south jetty, 2,200 feet long, parallel to and 100
feet distant from the axis of the channel, and extending in a south-
easterly direction into a natural depth of 2 feet at mean low water
on the flats of Delaware Bay. Under a contract for dredging which
was completed in July, 1908, the operations resulted in a channel not
less than 5 feet deep at mean low water and 50 feet wide from the
4-foot curve in Delaware Bay to the light-house, and not less than 6
feet deep and 40 feet wide thence to the electric light works in the
town of Milford. The depth made includes 1 foot overdepth made
under the contract.
   About 35 per cent of the project has been completed.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water was 5 feet in the river and 21 feet across the flats at
the mouth. The tide rises 41 feet at the mouth and 31 at Milford.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $115,935.83. Of this,
$37,545.76 is on the present project, of which $4,339.80 was for
maintenance.
   Under date of June 17, 1909, the sum of $7,000 was allotted from
the appropriation for preservation and maintenance of river and
harbor works in the act of March 3, 1909, and it is intended to dredge
the channel at the mouth and in the river at an early day.
   The commerce of the river for the calendar year 1908 is reported
to have been 171,034 tons, valued at $5,107,350.
   The effect of the improvement on freight rates is stated to be quite
marked, a reduction of an average of 25 per cent being reported; in
addition, better and increased transportation facilities are afforded.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below in building
1,700 feet of jetty, completing the south jetty to its project length of
5,000 feet, in dredging the channel within the river and across the
flats at the mouth to full project dimensions, and in maintaining the
channel for the purpose of extending the benefits and making them
more available.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                                              $6, 794. 04
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act ap-
  proved March 3, 1909.....-------------.............----------------.....--...........----.......                  7, 000. 00
                                                                                                                   13, 794. 04
June .30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement..............................................-------------------------------------------------....    4, 339. 80

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.........---------------------.....................----------......                 9, 454. 24
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .............          ... .... ................                                  26. 40

July 1, 1909, balance available-.........................                                 ..    ...........         9, 427. 84
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                                           51, 404. 80
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ..              .                                                               (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                           a See consolidated money statement on page 219.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           219
                                                CONSOLIDATED.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................... $11, 891. 66
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act ap-
  proved March 3, 1909 ..............................................                19, 000. 00
Received from sales of property ..........................            ..............     150. 00
                                                                                               31, 041. 66
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for mainte-
  nance of improvement.................................... $7, 289. 69
Deposited to credit appropriation for emergencies in river and
  harbor works .............................................    61. 49
                                                                                                7, 351. 18
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                          23, 690. 48
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                         26. 40
July 1, 1909, balance available .................                 ..       .................   23, 664. 08
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                       82, 068. 80
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909...................................   85, 725. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix I 10.)
   11. St. Jones River, Delaware.-Before the channel was improved
the least practicable low-water depth of water to Lebanon, 12 miles
above the mouth, was 4 feet, and thence to Dover, 9 miles farther up
the river, only 2' feet.
   The original project, made in 1880, was for a 3-foot low-water
channel, 100 feet wide across the bar at the mouth, protected by a
jetty, at an estimated cost of $35,000. The project was modified in
1884 so as to include the removal of shoals in the river to a depth of
6 feet at mean low water. Improvements were not begun until 1885.
The proposed channel within the river was reported as nearly com-
pleted at the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1888, $25,000
having been expended.
   A modification of the project for the improvement of the entrance
was submitted and approved in March, 1889. This modified project
provided for a cut across the bar at the mouth from the 6-foot depth
inside the river to the corresponding depth outside the bar, the width
of the cut to be 100 feet, of which 50 feet in the center was to be
dredged to a depth of 6 feet, the remainder to a depth of 3 feet below
mean low water. The material was to be deposited on either side of
the cut to form training dikes, the outer ends of the dikes to be
strengthened with pile revetments. It also provided for a new cut-off
across a very sinuous bend in the upper river about 1 mile below Leba-
non, near Wharton's fishery. This was substantially completed in
1890. Subsequent operations have been for maintenance.
   With funds provided by general and emergency river and harbor
acts, dredging has been done at various times between 1889 and June
30, 1905. A history of these operations will be found in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, pages 181-182.
   Operations with funds provided by the river and harbor acts of
March 3, 1905, and March 2, 1907, resulted in a continuous channel
from Lebanon to Delaware Bay of a minimum depth of 6 feet at mean
220          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                    U. S. ARMY.

low water and a width of 40 feet in the river and 50 feet across the
flats at the mouth.
   With an allotment of $3,000 made from the appropriation for emer-
gencies in river and harbor works, the channel was dredged in June
and July, 1908, from the mouth to the 6-foot curve in Delaware Bay
and at various points in the river, resulting in a channel 6 feet deep
at mean low water from Delaware Bay to Lebanon, which has been
for years considered the head of navigation for large vessels, the
width made being 40 feet in the river and 50 feet across the flats at
the mouth.
   The amount expended on the improvement to June 30, 1909, is
$63,519.94, of which $22,019.94 is for maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water between Lebanon and the mouth was 51 feet and
across the flats 5 feet.
   The range of tide is 4 feet at the mouth, 2 feet at Lebanon, and
1.6 feet at Dover, the head of navigation, 17 miles from the mouth.
   The commerce of the river for the calendar year 1908 is reported
to have been 235,313 tons, valued at $4,486,778. It is stated that
the improvements made have reduced freight rates by one-fourth
to one-half, besides increasing shipments, especially fruits, which now
reach the market in less time and in fresher condition.
   A survey of this river was made from its mouth to Dover in 1908,
and report thereon will be found in House Document No. 1116,
Sixtieth Congress, second session.
   Under date of June 11, 1909, the sum of $7,000 was allotted from
the appropriation made by the act of March 3, 1909, for preservation
and maintenance of river and harbor works, and proposals will be
opened July 2, 1909, for expenditure of a part of this money in dredg-
ing at the mouth and at places which have shoaled in the river.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below in dredging
for maintenance of the improvement in an extension of benefits.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....          ...........................         $3, 008. 23
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...................................................................  7, 000. 00

                                                                                   10, 008. 23
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of im-
  provement.........................................................                2, 971. 67

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................            .............    7, 036. 56
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance
  unexpended July 1, 1909 .............................      . ............         6,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix I 11.)
   12. Smyrna River, Delaware.-This river was formerly known as
Duck Creek. It is a tidal stream flowing easterly into the Delaware
River at a point about 26 miles south of Wilmington, Del. The navi-
gable portion of the river was originally about 9 miles long; the mini-
mum mean low-water depth over shoal places was 2- feet in the river
and 4 feet at the bar where it enters the Delaware River. The mean
range of tide at the mouth is nearly 6 feet, while at Smyrna Landing
it is about 3 feet.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      221

    In 1878 a project was made for the improvement of the whole river,
including the channel across the bar at the mouth. By direction of
Congress the improvement of the bar was commenced first, and during
the following four years three appropriations, aggregating $10,000,
were expended in dredging a channel 100 feet wide and 8 feet deep at
mean low water across the bar. The dredged channel soon filled up
again.
   A new project was adopted in the river and harbor act of August
11, 1888, with a view of obtaining a channel of 7 feet depth through-
out, width of 60 feet in the river and 100 feet at the bar, the channel
over the bar to be protected by a stone jetty. The estimated cost of
the improvement was $90,698.40. Of this $37,365.20 was for dredg-
ing and $53,333.20 for the jetty. This act made the first appropria-
tion for work on the project and was, by its terms, to be applied to
dredging only. The subsequent appropriations for continuing the
improvement have also been applied to dredging.
    The entire length of the channel, except at the mouth of the river,
was dredged in parts at various times between 1888 and 1900 to the
approved dimensions.
    In 1904 the channel was dredged to a width of 50 feet and a depth
of 6 feet at mean low water from the 6-foot curve just inside the mouth
to the 6-foot curve in Delaware Bay, and in 1905, with an appropria-
tion of $15,000 made by the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, as
modified by the act of March 3, 1905, two cut-offs were made extend-
ing from just below Limekiln wharf to the turn just above Brick store
wharf, an aggregate length of 4,795 feet. Some shoals in the river
and the channel across the flats at the mouth also were dredged, result-
ing in a channel 7 feet deep at mean low water from Smyrna Landing
to the 7-foot curve in Delaware Bay, the widths being 60 feet through
the cut-offs, not less than 50 feet in the river, and 100 feet across the
flats at the mouth. This work at the mouth completed the dredging
required under the approved project.
    In 1906 and 1907 the channel in the river was dredged, resulting in
a channel width not less than 50 feet nor less than 6 feet depth from
Smyrna Landing to the 6-foot depth in Delaware Bay, except in the
Cherry Tree reach, about halfway between Smyrna Landing and the
mouth, where the depth was only 5 feet; and in May and June, 1908,
the channel was dredged from inside the river at the mouth to the
7-foot depth in Delaware Bay to a depth of not less than 7 feet at
mean low water and a width of 100 feet. This depth included 1 foot
overdepth allowed under the contract.
     No work was done during the past fiscal year. The expenditures
were for payment of outstanding liabilities and supervision expenses.
    The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water was 5 feet in the river and 6 feet across the flats at
the mouth. The navigable length was about 10 miles.
     The amount expended on the improvement to June 30, 1909, is
 $71,295.45. Of this amount $61,295.45 is on the present project, of
which $16,210.67 was for maintenance.
     The commerce for the calendar year 1908 is reported to have been
203,080 tons, valued at $5,047,000.
     A survey was made of the river in 1907, and a report thereon will
be found in House Document No. 815, Sixtieth Congress, first session.
222          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                             U.   S. ARMY.


   Under date of June 9, 1909, the Chief of Engineers allotted $6,500
from the appropriation for preservation and maintenance of river and
harbor works made by the act of March 3, 1909, and proposals are
to be opened on July 2, 1909, for its expenditure in redredging the
cut across the flats at the mouth and certain shoals which have formed
in the river.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below in dredging
for maintenance of improvement in extension of benefits.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......------------------....--...--..................... $----------2,        282. 16
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909--------..------..........................------------...................---------------... 6, 500. 00
                                                                            8, 782. 16
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement ..................... ...... .. .... ............. ............ 2,269.98

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                            6, 512. 18
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909----------------------------..---------------7, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix I 12.)
   13. Broadkill River, Delaware.-In its original condition the depth
of water in the river was from 3 to 4 feet at the numerous shoals
which impeded navigation. The depth at the mouth was from 12 to
2 feet at low water.
   Prior to the adoption of the existing project $35,000 was expended
in providing a channel within the river 6 feet deep and 40 feet wide
at low water from the mouth to Milton, the head of navigation.
   The existing project was adopted in the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, and is based upon report and estimate submitted in
House Document No. 214, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session. It
provides for the establishment of a permanent entrance at the mouth
of the river by dredging a channel from the 6-foot curve in Delaware
Bay to the same depth in the river and constructing a jetty on the
north side of this channel. The estimated cost of the project is
$33,330.
   The range of the tide is 4.1 feet at the mouth, 3.6 feet at the draw-
bridge, and 3.4 feet at Milton.
   The act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $33,330, the amount esti-
mated for the establishment of a permanent entrance at the mouth of
the river, including the construction of a jetty on the north side of the
channel. The title papers conveying to the United States the land
required for the cut to be made across Lewes Cape have been ap-
proved by the Department of Justice; the jetty across Lewes Cape
and Lewes Sound from the 6 to 7 foot depth in Delaware Bay to the
high-water line in the marsh of Lewes Sound on its western side, a
total length of 1,263 feet, was completed in November, 1908; and a
channel 6 feet deep and 150 feet wide at bottom was dredged from
the 6-foot depth in Delaware Bay to the same depth in Lewes Sound.
This work was done under contract.
   Under date of October 20, 1908, the Secretary of War allotted
 $4,500 from the emergency appropriation and on December 16, 1908,
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                   223
a further sum of $3,200, to be applied to the restoration of a portion
of the jetty, which was becoming undermined, and $7,282.67 thereof
was applied to the work, which was completed in April, 1909. In
addition, a fender wale was placed under the wale pieces for a length
of 1,104 feet, for the protection of the jetty from passing boats, at a
cost of $250.
  The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water over the cut under improvement, was 4 feet. The
whole of the projected work has been completed.
  The effect of the improvement on freight rates by water has not
yet been reported.
  The amount expended on the improvement to June 30, 1909, is
$75,658.61, of which $40,658.61 is on the present project. Of the
latter amount, $7,532.67 was expended for maintenance.
  The commerce during the calendar year 1908 is reported to have
been 35,122 tons, valued at $750,825.
  Under date of June 28, 1909, the sum of $3,000 was allotted from
appropriation made by river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, for
preservation and maintenance of river and harbor works, to be ap-
plied to the maintenance of the improvement, and with the available
funds work at the mouth of the river will be commenced soon.
   It is proposed to expend the funds recommended below in dredging
and repairing the jetty for the maintenance of the improvement at
the mouth to extend the benefits and to make the improvement more
completely available.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................        ..............       $25, 669. 73
Allotted from emergency appropriation, river and harbor act March 2, 1907.            7, 700. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation made by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..........   ................   ........... ........        ........   3, 000. 00
Received from sales of river and harbor property.......................                  100. 00
                                                                                 36,469. 73
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
                                                                         465. 67
    For works of improvement.............---.....----.......... $----------------25,
    For maintenance of improvement -----------....................... 7, 532. 67
Returned to credit of appropriation for emergencies in river
  and harbor works ......................................                167. 33
                                                                                 33, 165. 67

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended........................................              3, 304. 06
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................... ..................            42. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available...................           ..............   ...-    3, 262. 06

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909 .......       ........................................                10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix I 13.)
   14. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering
navigation.-During the past fiscal year wrecks were removed and
examined as follows:
   Wreck of schooner Florence I. Lockwood, lying sunk in channel off
the end of the town of Chincoteague, Va.-It was removed at a cost of
$885.02.
224     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,          U.   S. ARMY.

    Wreck of steamship Gulf Stream, lying sunk in the Atlantic Ocean at
entrance to Hereford Inlet, New Jersey.-It was removed at a cost of
$1,567.49.
   Wreck of barge Homeward Bound, lying sunk in Mantua Creek,
New Jersey.-It was removed at a cost of $312.80.
   Wrecks of barges Sally and Bennie, lying sunk in Oldmans Creek,
New Jersey.-They were removed at a cost of $453.61.
   Wreck of schooner Adeline Townsend, reported to be off the capes of
Delaware, within the 3-mile limit.-It having been ascertained upon
investigation that this wreck was not a menace to navigation, the
work of removal was not undertaken, and no expenditure was made
from the permanent indefinite appropriation.
   Wreck of steam yacht Viva, lying sunk in Absecon Inlet, New Jer-
sey.-It was removed at a cost of $155.20.
   A sunken barge (name not given) was reported three-fourths of a
mile from shore off Ocean City, N. J., by commanding officer of reve-
nue cutter Mohawk, and the Secretary of the Treasury was informed
August 8, 1908, that the War Department would be pleased to have
it destroyed by a vessel of the Revenue-Cutter Service, at expense
of the War Department. No further report received.
   The expenditures during the year amounted to $3,374.12.
   (See Appendix I 14.)
EXAMINATIONS AND SUoRVEYS MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE RIVER
          AND HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports on preliminary examinations and surveys required by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities
within this district were duly submitted by the district officer. They
were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors,
pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in
documents as indicated:
   1. Preliminary examination and survey of Oldmans Creek, New Jer-
sey.-Reports dated May 29, 1907, and October 3, 1908, respectively,
are printed in House Document No. 1083, Sixtieth Congress, second
session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of $89,500
is presented.
   2. Preliminary examination and survey of St. Jones River, Dela-
ware, from its mouth to Dover.-Reports dated April 26, 1907, and
April 8, 1908, respectively, are printed in House Document No. 1116,
Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for improvement at an
estimated cost of $181,425 is presented.
IMPROVEMENT      OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN               THE   BALTIMORE,
                      MARYLAND, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Maj. W. E. Craighill, Corps of Engi-
neers. Division engineer, Col. D. W. Lockwood, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Patapsco River and channel to Baltimore, Md.-Before opera-
tions were begun by the United States a controlling depth of 17 feet
was available, with a mean range of tide of a little over 1 foot. Ves-
sels over that draft were obliged to lighter portions of their cargoes
about 14 miles below to permit them to reach the wharves of the city.
There were pockets where deeper water prevailed, but these were
unconnected by any channel, natural or artificial. Under the original
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     225
project, dated April 15, 1853, for a channel 22 feet deep at mean low
water and 150 feet wide, the Fort McHenry channel was dredged,
extending from the limits of the city of Baltimore 'to a point just
below Fort Carroll, and the Brewerton channel from this point to
deep water of Chesapeake Bay off Swan Point. The cost was
$390,000.
   In 1871 the project was enlarged to a width of 400 feet at the lower
end of the channel, diminishing to 250 feet at its upper end, with a
mean low-water depth of 24 feet. Meantime it had been found that
the portion of the Brewerton channel which was swept across by the
current of the Susquehanna River was continually obstructed by sedi-
mentary deposit. This led to a search for a better location for a deep
channel which could be made and maintained by dredging and the
natural currents. This was found in the position of the resultant of
the two great forces made by the currents of the Susquehanna and
Patapsco rivers. The new channel had also the advantage of being
shorter by several miles, and for this reason and the very much
diminished sedimentary deposit the cost of maintenance was much
lessened. In 1892 a project for 27 feet depth at mean low water, with
a width of 600 feet in the straight sections and over 1,200 feet in the
angles, was completed. At the same time the portion of the Brew-
erton channel between the upper end of the present cut-off and the
point of intersection of the Brewerton and Craighill channels was
abandoned because of the sedimentary deposit from the Susquehanna
sweeping across it and to shorten the channel still further and lessen
the cost of maintenance. The act of June 3, 1896, authorized the
increase of the depth of the channel to 30 feet at mean low water,
with a bottom width of 600 feet, widened at the angles, and with side
slopes of 3 base to 1 vertical. This was completed May 22, 1903, and
has since been maintained. The amount expended on original and
modified projects prior to operations under existing project is
$4,776,269.48, of which $32,797.72 was for maintenance.
   The existing project, adopted by Congress March 3, 1905, provides
for a channel 35 feet deep at mean low water and 600 feet wide at
bottom, with side slopes of 3 base to 1 vertical from Fort McHenry to
deep water in Chesapeake Bay above Sandy Point light-house and
through the shoals opposite York Spit, at an estimated cost of
$3,465,000. This project was extended by the act of March 3, 1909,
to include the widening of the Fort McHenry division near its inter-
section with the Curtis Bay channel, so as to provide an anchorage
basin 600 feet wide and about 3,500 feet long with project depth,
within the limit of the original estimate. Dredging began July 5,
1905, and has resulted in a channel of the project dimensions from
Fort McHenry to deep water in Chesapeake Bay and in the eastern
half of the section opposite York Spit. The anchorage basin in the
Fort McHenry division is just begun. In the western half of the
York Spit channel a least depth of 32-1 feet has been obtained. An
appropriation of $500,000 was made in the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, and work was authorized under continuing contracts
for completion to an additional amount of $1,715,000, all of which
has been appropriated. Proposals for this work were opened July 1,
1907, and a continuing contract made for completing the project.
An additional contract for the Fort McHenry channel widening was
entered into June 12, 1909. Work under contract has been in prog-
     9001-ENG 1909--15
226          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

ress during the fiscal year with the result that the section near Balti-
more was completed. The eastern half (or 300-foot width) of York
Spit channel was also completed and opened to navigation in
November, 1908; and work on the Fort McHenry channel widening
was commenced.
   The amount expended on the existing project to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is $2,428,450.33.
   The draft that can now be carried to Baltimore, the head of navi-
gation, a distance of 11 miles from the mouth of Patapsco River and
171 miles from the mouth of Chesapeake Bay, is 35 feet at mean low
water. The length of dredged channel in Patapsco River and Chesa-
peake Bay above Sandy Point is about 20 miles; opposite York Spit,
about 42 miles.
   The tonnage movement of the port has been as follows:
Fiscal year ending June 30-                 Tons.         Fiscal year ending June 30-                           Tons.
     1889 ..........--..........         3, 243, 017          1900 ...........-........                      7, 941, 580
    1890 ....................            4, 237,361           1901 .........-------------....-----....       8,055,017
    1891.....................            4, 495, 469          1902 ....................                      7, 529, 870
    1892 ...................             5, 224, 042          1903. ...................                      7, 736, 447
    1893....................             4, 607,176           1904...... ..............                      7, 334, 241
    1894. ...................            4, 752, 946          1905 ....................                      7, 510, 713
    1895. ...................            4,794,964            1906. ...................                      8,277,098
     1896 ....................           5, 363, 894          1907 ....................                      8, 448, 203
     1897 ...................            6, 868, 120          1908. ...................                      8, 441, 034
     1898 ............ .......           7, 339,405           1909 ...................                       7, 436, 273
     1899 ....................           6, 843, 620
  The statistics of the port for the past fiscal year are illustrated
briefly by the following statement:
Value of commerce; coal, coke, grain, flour, iron, steel, etc........... $101, 497, 626. 00
Dutiable imports have decreased ................................           $4, 261, 706. 00
Free imports have decreased .........................................      $1, 193, 062. 00
Domestic exports have decreased ...............................        .. $12, 283, 164. 00
Tonnage (foreign and coastwise) has decreased, tons.. ...-............          1, 004, 761
Duties collected have decreased. .................................                                       $1, 298, 939. 02
Duties on merchandise in bond have increased ....................                                             $5, 570. 38
Duties on merchandise in bond with and without appraisement have
increased ..................... ...... ........ .. ...............                                      $1, 372, 655. 99
  The effect of the present project upon freight rates can not be
ascertained until work is fully completed, but as some of the vessels
trading with the port are not now able to load to their full capacity the
tendency should be toward cheapening rates when means are provided
to enable them to carry full cargoes and to enable other vessels of
greater capacity to trade with the port.
   References to reports of examinations and surveys are to be found
on page 180 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................                                        $941, 755. 99
Repaid on account of filling in swamps at Fort Howard, Md ............                                       16, 830. 33
Account of sales at auction......           -.
                                      ......................        ..........                                     5. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......                                        965, 000. 00
                                                                        1, 923, 591. 32
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment ....... ............... .. ......................   ............ 867, 276. 13
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                                       1, 056, 315. 19
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .................................                                        3, 501. 35
July 1, 1909, balance available..............                        .....----...    ..........           1, 052, 813. 84
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..............                                          302, 068. 44
    (See Appendix J 1.)
                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                   227
   2, Channel to Curtis Bay, in Patapsco River, Baltimore Harbor,
Maryland.-With a mean range of tide of a little over 1 foot, there
was a controlling depth of 20 feet at mean low water in 1893, when
the first improvement was undertaken by the United States. The
original project was dated July 15, 1892, and was for a channel 27
feet deep at mean low water and a bottom width of 150 feet, at an
estimated cost of $85,000. Fortl thousand dollars of the estimate
was appropriated, and with this total expenditure the channel was
first made 25 feet deep for the project width and then dredged to 27
feet deep for a width of 70 feet in the axis of the 150-foot channel.
That project was never completed. It was superseded by a project
in the river and harbor act approved June 13, 1902, for deepening
the channel to 30 feet and widening it to 250 feet, and authority was
granted to make continuing contracts to complete the work. The
estimated cost was $196,000.
   A continuing contract was approved, and under it dredging was
commenced March 5, 1903, and the project completed November 30,
1903.
   The amount expended on existing project to June 30, 1909, was
$196,012.52, of which $3,329.16 was for maintenance in partially
removing some shoaling. This was done under contract. The sum
of $9,000 was allotted from the appropriation for preservation and
maintenance of river and harbor works contained in the act of March
3, 1909, for restoring the channel to project dimensions.
   A contract dated June 8, 1909, was entered into for this work and
the work commenced. The $10,000 asked for will be applied to main-
tenance of the channel where shoaling occurs, the additional work
being necessary to make the improvement available to full project
dimensions.
   Curtis Bay is the mouth of Curtis Creek, which is navigable in fact
5- miles above the head of the channel contemplated by the existing
project, but a maximum draft of 281 feet at mean low water can be
carried June 30, 1909, over the shoalest part of the locality under
improvement, which is a distance of 2- miles.
    It is stated that the improvement has lowered rates upon freight,
but the amount of reduction has not been ascertained.
    References to reports on examinations and surveys are to be found
on page 180 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
    This bay is in the collection district of Baltimore and the statistics
are attached to the report for that harbor.
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909----------......----...................--------------------........     $9,000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
                                                      ---------------------
  improvement----------...........-------------.....-...........................     12. 52

                                                                             8, 987. 48
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended- .........--------------....------......-----....
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.... ............... ..................     29. 34

July 1, 1909, balance available .............. ........                 ................    8,958. 14
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts.................                      7, 920. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...............................................                      10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix J 2.)
228        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                         U.   S.   ARMY.

    3. Harbor of southwest Baltimore (Spring Garden), Md.-No work
was done by the United States before the existing project, but the
city of Baltimore dredged a channel from the main ship channel to
the foot of Eutaw street, which had a controlling depth of 15 feet at
mean low water. The average rise of the tide is a little over 1 foot.
In response to a resolution of the House of Representatives an esti-
mate was furnished March 7, 1.896 (printed in Annual Report for
  1896, p. 1006), of the cost of deepening the channel to a depth of 27
feet. It was for a channel 100 feet wide on the bottom, with side
slopes of 1 on 3, from the main ship channel near Fort McHenry to
the foot of Eutaw street, with a turning basin 400 feet by 400 feet near
the upper end, at an estimated cost of $314,000, which is the existing
project. Five thousand dollars was appropriated June 3, 1896, but
it was deemed inexpedient to start the work with that small sum.
June 13, 1902, $88,000 was appropriated and authority granted to
enter into contracts for the completion of the work. A continuing
contract was made for the completion of the project, and it was com-
pleted April 4, 1905. The sum of $314,000 was expended under the
project for improvement, in addition to which $6,512.52 was expended
for maintenance. Thirty-four thousand dollars was allotted from the
appropriation for preservation and maintenance of river and harbor
works, contained in the act of March 3, 1909, for restoring the channel
to project dimensions as far as possible. A contract dated June 8,
  1909, was entered into and operations begun. The sum of $34,000
more is required to entirely remove shoaling. This channel was
dredged in very soft material, where silt has been slowly accumulating
for many years. The cost of maintenance for a number of years will
.probably continue to be large, but after the side slopes have flattened
out sufficiently it is thought that the cost of maintenance will be
much reduced.
    The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean low
water over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement is 27
feet at the lower end and about 16 feet at the upper end.
    The stream is navigable in fact to Baltimore, Md., which is 14 miles
from the mouth of Patapsco River and 174 miles from the mouth of
Chesapeake Bay. The length of the channel dredged under the exist-
ing project is 4 miles. It is stated that the improvement has some-
what lowered freights, but the amount of reduction has not been
ascertained.
    The commercial statistics of the port of Baltimore include this
harbor.
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
                  -----------------------------------------------.
  March 3, 1909........    ............   .........                  $34, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement---------...............-------------....---............------12.52
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended       --  ---------..........................------------------       33, 987.48
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...----------...............-------------.............-----------      14.00
July 1, 1909, balance available...-..........        ........ ................         33, 993. 48
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                 29, 700. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909         - -..........................
                               ....                                    .               34, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix J 3.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      229
    4. Elk River, Maryland.-Before improvements were commenced
there was practically no navigation above Cedar Point. The original
project, dated June 23, 1874, was for a channel 6 feet deep at low
water, or 8 feet at high water, from Cedar Point to Elkton, the head
of navigation, and in the Little Elk as far as Bennett's wharf. The
mean range of the tide is 2 feet. Such a channel was estimated to
cost $36,000 if 75 feet wide and about $25,000 if 50 feet wide, cheap
dikes being required for regulating the banks and to provide a place
behind which to deposit the material dredged from the shoals. The
first work was done in 1874, when $5,000 was expended in building a
dike and dredging to a width of 25 feet and a depth of 6 feet at mean
low water in front of it and for about 300 feet below. Two years
later the channel was made 40 feet wide from the bridge at Elkton to
about one-half mile below. In 1884 a channel was completed 80
feet wide through the bar near the mouth of the Little Elk River
and 70 feet wide thence to the bridge at Elkton, the depth being 7
feet at mean low water. In 1893 a channel 100 feet wide and 8 feet
deep from deep water below Cedar Point to the bridge at Elkton was
completed. The expenditure on the original and subsequent projects
has amounted to $46,500.
    The channel had shoaled, and in a report on a survey made in 1899
 (printed on pp. 1668-1669, Pt. 2, Annual Report of the Chief of En-
gineers for 1.900) it was proposed to restore the channel to 8 feet depth
at mean low water and 100 feet wide from deep water below Cedar
Point to the bridge at Elkton, at an estimated cost of $16,665, with
an annual cost of 82,500    for maintenance. The river and harbor act
of June 13, 1902, adopted this project, and appropriated $16,665 for
the work. This appropriation was practically expended in dredging
in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1903. The project width of 100
feet could not be made, as the river was found to have shoaled very
much since the survey in 1899, on which the appropriation was based.
    The existing project adopted by the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907, is for a channel 6 feet deep at mean low water and 100 feet
wide from Elkton to Cedar Point, at an estimated cost of $16,802.77.
The act appropriated $18,803 for its completion and maintenance. A
contract was entered into and the project completed in March, 1908.
Nevertheless extensive shoaling has already taken place and it is
doubtful whether the project can be maintained without annual
dredging to an extent much greater than was anticipated. The sum
of $10,000 is now required.
    The sum of $10,000 was allotted from the appropriation for preser-
vation and maintenance of river and harbor works, act March 3, 1909,
for maintenance and a contract for the work is about to be entered
into.
    The amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909, is
 $83,968, of which $63,165 was on previous projects, $16,439.24 on
present project, and $4,363.76 for maintenance. The amount
expended during the fiscal year was for payment of retained per-
centages on contract work and part of office expenses.
    The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the river was 31- feet. The stream
is navigable, in fact, to Elkton, Md., which is about 16 miles from the
mouth of the river. It was stated that the improvement has mate-
rially reduced freight rates.
230          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                        S. ARMY.

    Reference to a report on a survey is to be found on page 182 of the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904. Reference to
report on preliminary examination and survey of the river, required
by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, will be found on page 214
of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906.
   The commerce of the river for the calendar year 1908 is reported
to be 42,880 tons, consisting of vessels built, cord wood, lumber, fer-
tilizer, hay, and flour, valued at $258,847. Two steam tugs and 171
schooners and barges are reported as plying in the river.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................    $1, 770. 67
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ..................    ................................... 10, 000. 00
                                                                                    11, 770. 67
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment .............................................................                 1, 770. 67

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................              10, 000. 00
  mount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  -1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 .....         ................................... 10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix J 4.)
   5. Susquehanna River above and below Havre de Grace, Md.-The
original governing depth was 5 feet at mean low water. The mean
range of tide is 21 feet. The channel above Havre de Grace was nar-
row and subject to ice gorges. The original project is dated February
22, 1853, and was for a channel 12 feet deep and 100 feet wide, at an
estimated cost of $59,000. Improvements have been in progress since
1853, and up to August 22, 1882, when the existing project was
adopted, $97,390 had been expended upon them. The existing proj-
ect is to give a channel 200 feet wide and 15 feet deep at mean low
water below Havre de Grace and to remove the shoal opposite Watsons
Island (which is above Havre de Grace) to a depth of 8 feet at the
same stage of the tide, at an estimated cost of $168,000. The amount
expended on that project to June 30, 1909, is $113,184.42, and has
resulted in dredging a portion of the channel below Havre de Grace
to a depth of 15 feet at mean low water and removing the shoal oppo-
site Watsons Island, completing about three-fifths of the approved
project.
   The operations during the year resulted in extending the channel
to project dimensions for about 4,000 feet.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the channel under improvement
is 12 feet. The stream is navigable in fact to Port Deposit, Md.,
which is about 5 miles above the mouth of the river. The improve-
ment has made no appreciable difference in freight rates. It is pro-
posed to apply funds asked for in continuing work on the project.
   Three steamers and 40 sailing vessels and barges are reported as
plying in the river, the commerce being valued at $473,933. The
tonnage of the river is reported to be as follows: 1905, 135,293; 1906,
73,815; 1907, 85,212, and for 1908, 37,936, consisting of lumber,
cement, salt fish, granite, stoves, castings, etc
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     231
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................                .......... .. $19, 969. 97
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment       ...................
             -..                 ......................................                19, 654. 39
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ..................................                                       315.58
Amount (estimatd) required for completion of existing project .......                                  54, 500. 00
IAmount  that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909----------------.....-------............--------------------------......................... 54, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.
   (See Appendix J 5.)
   6. Harbors at Rockhall, Queenstown, Claiborne, and Cambridge,
and Chester, Choptank, Warwick, Pocomoke, La Trappe, and Manokin
rivers, and Tyaskin Creek, Maryland-G(a) Rockhall Harbor and
inner harbor at Rockhall.-In 1894 the controlling depth at Rockhall
Harbor was 5 feet, with an average range of tide of 1.1 feet. With
an appropriation of $16,000, made June 3, 1896 (the first for this
work), a project was carried out in 1897-98 for dredging a cut 80
feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water from the 10-foot curve
in Swan Creek Inlet to the 10-foot depth in Chesapeake Bay, and a
channel 100 feet wide and 10 feet deep from that depth in Swan
Creek Inlet to the old pier at Rockhall. A turning basin, embracing
the old and new piers, was also dredged.
   In accordance with the river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, an
examination was made of Rockhall Harbor and the inner harbor at
Rockhall, report on which is printed in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1900, pages 1670-1672. The project then
proposed is dredging a channel 12 feet deep and 150 feet wide from
Chesapeake Bay to Swan Creek Inlet, across Swan Point bar, and
12 feet deep and 150 feet wide from Swan Creek Inlet to the wharf
at Rockhall, at a cost estimated in 1899 to be $43,065 and $9,208
every two years for maintenance.
   The river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, adopted this project,
which is the existing one. The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907,
appropriated $60,000 for improvement of rivers and harbors on east
shore of Chesapeake Bay, and $14,383.97 was allotted for this work.
   Work under this allotment was completed during the present fiscal
year, and resulted in completing the channel from the 12-foot contour
in Swan Creek Inlet to the wharf at Rockhall, the turning basin to
project dimensions, and in giving an 8-foot channel 70 feet wide for
a distance of 2,240 feet across Swan Point bar. The unit price
of dredging has exceeded that assumed in the original estimate.
The estimated cost of project was increased May 13, 1907, to $60,386.81.
   The amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909, is
 $55,713.72, of which $16,600 was on a previous project and $537.54
for maintenance, consisting in the removal of a shoal in the inner
harbor.
   About two-thirds of the project has been completed. It is pro-
posed to apply the funds asked for to completing the project.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the channel across Swan Point
bar is about 5 feet and in the inner harbor 12 feet, to which point
the improvement is navigable in fact. The harbor is a bay making
232         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                          U.   S. ARMY.

in from Chesapeake Bay and is navigable in fact to Rockhall pier,
which is about one-fourth mile above the mouth of Rockhall Harbor.
  Two steamers and 65 sailing vessels and barges are reported as
plying in the harbor, the commerce being valued at $1,678,870.
The tonnage for the fiscal year 1909 was 17,703, consisting of lumber,
coal, canned goods, poultry, and live stock, fish, oysters, and general
merchandise.
   It is stated that the improvement has had no appreciable effect
on freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................               .......... ...... $14, 239. 59
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ......................... ..........          ...................... ....     .. 14, 139.99
July 1, 1909, balance unexpen led ................           ....-. ............            99. 60

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                21, 711.03
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909------------.......----...............................................     (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
   (b) Queenstown Harbor.-Before 1871 the controlling depth in
this harbor was 6 feet, with a range of tide of about 2 feet. Between
that year and 1880 it was improved under a project dated January 2,
1871, and a channel 100 feet wide at bottom and 8 feet deep at mean
low water was made. In 1897, with $5,000 appropriated for continu-
ing the improvement, a channel was dredged to 81 feet at mean low
water and 100 feet wide from Chester River to the inner harbor, to
which point the bay is navigable in fact, and in 1900 a shoal extend-
ing from a point 138 feet above the lower light down for a distance
of 950 feet was dredged to a depth of 8 feet and a width of 80 feet.
   The river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, provided that the im-
provement should be made in accordance with the report submitted
and printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900,
pages 1673-1676. The project therein submitted contemplates in-
creasing the dimensions of the channel so as to make them 10 feet
deep and 200 feet wide, at an estimated cost of $23,100.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $60,000
for improvement of rivers and harbors on east shore of Chesapeake
Bay, and $4,975.70 was allotted for this work.
   A contract for expenditure of funds was entered into and dredging
completed in the winter of 1907, advancing the project to that extent.
Funds asked for are intended to continue the project and for mainte-
nance. Owing to the insufficient appropriations, the work has been
prolonged and the cost of maintenance is added to the original esti-
mate. The unit price of dredging has exceeded that in the original
estimate. The estimated cost of project was therefore increased
May 13, 1907, to $25,886.35.
   The amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909, is
$40,572.39, of which $20,269.14 was on the existing project, and
$1,303.25 for maintenance. The money expended during the fiscal
year was for payment of retained percentages on contract work and
                    a See consolidated money statement on page 243.
                                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                   233
proportion of office expenses. About four-fifths of the project has
been completed.
   The entire channel has been dredged to a depth of 10 feet, but the
maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean low
water over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement was
9 feet.
   Six steamers and 175 sailing vessels and barges are reported to ply
in the harbor. The tonnage of the harbor is reported to be as fol-
lows: 1900, 12,373; 1901, 11,328; 1902, 18,769; 1903 (only partial
statistics could be obtained), 3,889; 1904, 19,144; 1905, 19,421;
1906, 19,808; 1907, 20,202; 1908, 22,220, valued at $1,169,716, con-
sisting of lumber, coal, agricultural products, canned goods, poultry
and live stock, fish, oysters, and general merchandise.
  The harbor is a bay making from the Chester River and is navigable
in fact to Queenstown, which is about one-half mile above mouth of
harbor. The improvement has made no perceptible difference in
freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended----....---------.............------------.............--------...                             $721. 15
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment............................................................----------------------------------------------------------    711. 34

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...............                                   ........             ...-.........             9. 81



IAmount
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project............ 5, 607. 40

           that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
                                         ---------------------------------
    balance unexpended July 1, 1909.....................................
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
                                                                                                                                (a)
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Claiborne Harbor.-Claiborneis on the eastern shore of Chesa-
peake Bay, about 6 miles east from Bloody Point light-house. No
improvement there had ever been made by the United States pre-
vious to the existing project. The controlling depth was 9 feet at
mean low water, with a mean range of tide of about 2 feet.
   The act of June 13, 1902, adopted the existing project, which pro-
vides for dredging a channel 12 teet deep at mean low water and 300
feet wide from the 12-foot contour in Eastern Bay to the railroad
pier in the harbor, a distance of about 1,900 feet, and thence shore-
ward along the south side of the pier to a width of 195 feet for a
length of 500 feet, at an estimated cost of $17,490, and a further
sum of $2,500 for an extension of the existing jetty should it be
found necessary.
   The jetty extension is now deemed necessary to preserve the north
side of the channel to project dimensions from the current from Eastern
Bay around Tilghmans Point, which, passing over the sand flats, car-
ries material into the dredged channel at the outer end of the present
jetty. The scour has been considerable in the last few years and
has eroded Tilghmans Point, which formerly acted as a deflector, to
such an extent as to render jetty extension necessary for the main-
tenance of the channel.
   A 12-foot depth at mean low water was dredged with variable
widths in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1904. The river and harbor
                             a See consolidated money statement on page 243.
234         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $60,000 for improvement of
rivers and harbors on east shore of Chesapeake Bay, and $3,440.24
was allotted for this work. A contract for expenditure of funds
was entered into and dredging finished in the spring of 1908, which
resulted in restoring the channel to dimensions left in 1905. Funds
asked for are for completion of project. About three-fifths of the
project has been completed.
   There was allotted during the fiscal year the sum of $12,000 from
appropriation for emergencies in river and harbor works, act March
3, 1909, to be applied to restoring the project channel which has
seriously deteriorated, and contract is about to be entered into.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the channel is 8 feet. The
amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $20,307.29, of which $4,996.80
was for maintenance.
   The money expended during the fiscal year was for payment of
retained percentages on contract work and proportion of office
expenses.
   Owing to insufficient appropriations the work has been prolonged
and the cost of maintenance is added to the original estimate. The
unit price of dredging has exceeded that in the original estimate.
The estimated cost of project was therefore increased May 13, 1907,
to $27,408.30.
   Claiborne is at the head of navigation in Claiborne Harbor, and
is the western terminus of the Baltimore, Chesapeake and Atlantic
Railway. It is about one-half mile from the mouth of the harbor.
   Three steamers and 71 sailing vessels and barges are reported to
ply in the harbor.
   The tonnage of the harbor is reported to be as follows: 1903,
89,549; 1904, 90,435; 1905, 93,603; 1906, 91,957; 1907, 93,794; 1908,
103,173, valued at $7,975,500, consisting of agricultural products,
canned goods, poultry and live stock, lumber, coal, and general mer-
chandise. The improvement has made no appreciable difference in
freight rates. Reference to a survey is to be found on page 185 of
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............          ...... .......... .........   $310. 49
Amount alloted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....................       ...........................            12, 000. 00
                                                                                                12, 310. 49
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ...................................                     $310. 49
    For maintenance of improvement ..........................                           3. 70
                                                                                                   314. 19

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended............             ........   ..............              11, 996. 30

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 14, 597. 81

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909........    ...........................................                              (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897.
                      a See consolidated money statement on page 243.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                       235
   (d) Cambridge Harbor.-This harbor is on the eastern side of the
Choptank River, about 20 miles above its mouth, and Cambridge is
the head of navigation at the mouth of the harbor. In 1870, before
operations were commenced, there was a controlling depth of 4 feet,
with a mean range of tide of about 1.7 feet. The improvement of the
harbor was commenced in 1871 with a project submitted in March
of that year for an entrance way of 100 feet in width and to provide
sufficient harbor accommodations of a depth of 10 feet at mean low
water. The estimated cost was $36,000. The sum of $10,000 was
appropriated March 3, 1871, and work begun. On this and succeed-
ing projects $50,237 was expended to June 30, 1896, resulting in a
channel 150 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean low water from that
depth in the Choptank River to the railroad wharf, a distance of
nearly a mile. The inner harbor below the bridge had been dredged
over its whole irregular area to a depth of 10 feet, and the part of the
harbor above the bridge for a distance of 750 feet had been dredged
to a depth of 8 feet and a width of 215 feet. A survey was made in
1896 (printed in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1897,
p. 1297), and the improvements then recommended were for a 12-foot
low-water channel 150 feet wide from the 12-foot curve in the Chop-
tank River to a point 500 feet outside the Baltimore, Chesapeake and
Atlantic Railway Company's steamboat wharf, and from this point
gradually widening to the harbor line at the wharf; from the steam-
boat wharf to Mill wharf to increase the width an average of 200
feet, with a depth of 8 feet, making an anchorage basin; increasing
the width of the lower harbor 40 feet on the north side and widening
the upper harbor an average of 360 feet along the channel already
dredged to a depth of 8 feet. The estimated cost of the project was
$8,120. It is the existing one.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $60,000
for improvement of rivers and harbors on east shore of Chesapeake
Bay, and $1,531.63 was allotted for this work. A contract for ex-
penditure of funds was entered into and dredging under it finished
in the summer of 1907, resulting in advancing part of the 8-foot
project and removing some shoals in the 12-foot part of the project.
   The amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909, is
 $57,846.78, of which $50,237 was on previous projects and $244.76
for maintenance.
   Owing to insufficient appropriations the work has been prolonged
and the cost of maintenance is added to the original estimate. The
estimate of cost of project was increased May 13, 1907, to $13,858.25.
The project is about five-eighths completed. All funds are intended
to be applied to continuation and maintenance of the project. The
money expended during the fiscal year was for payment of retained
percentages on contract work and proportion of office expenses.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the channel below the bridge was
10 feet, and about 8 feet above as far as the channel has been dredged.
   Six steamers and 152 sailing vessels and barges are reported to ply
in the harbor, the commerce being valued at $2,227,659. The ton-
nage of the river is reported to be as follows: For the year ended
May 1, 1909, 66,703, consisting of grain, lumber, coal, fertilizer, canned
goods, fish and oysters, and agricultural products. The improvement
has made no appreciable difference in freight rates.
236        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                             S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....................................                  $189.11
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improvement.             146. 46

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.    ....................................                 42. 65
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.. ........              6, 450. 58

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909 ..-.....                        ...---------------                        (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897.
   (e) Chester River, Maryland, from Crumpton to Jones Landing.-
Before operations were undertaken on this part of the river vessels at
low tide drawing 6 feet of water could reach Crumpton, 33 miles above
the mouth, and from that point to Jones Landing (to which point the
stream is navigable in fact), 61 miles, the controlling depth was 3
feet, with a mean range of tide of 2.4 feet. The project for improve-
ment, adopted by the river and harbor act of September 19, 1890, is
for a 6-foot low-water channel from Crumpton to Jones Landing, at
an estimated cost of $12,750, increased in 1896 to $14,250, and still
later to $19,562.50. There has been but one project for this section
of the river.
   Before the adoption of the present project there had been appro-
priated for this river $41,000, of which $2,958.54 was carried to the
surplus fund on June 30, 1909.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $60,000
for improvement of rivers and harbors on the east shore of Chesapeake
Bay, and $2,417.36 was allotted for this work. A contract for ex-
penditure of funds for maintenance was entered into and dredging
for maintenance under it finished in the winter, restoring project
dimensions from Crumpton to Ford's wharf.
   The sum of $5,000 was allotted from the appropriation for preser-
vation and maintenance of river and harbor works, act March 3, 1909,
for maintenance, and a contract for the work is about to be entered
into.
   The amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909, is
$23,264.36, of which $5,604.88 was for maintenance. The project is
completed.
   The money expended during the fiscal year was for payment of
retained percentages on contract and proportion of office expenses.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the river was 4 feet.
   Six steamers and 175 sailing vessels and barges are reported to ply
in the river, the commerce being valued at $3,917,210. The tonnage
of the river is reported to be as follows: 1906, 48,199; 1907, 49,162;
1908, 54,078, consisting of lumber, poultry and live stock, fish and
oysters, canned goods, agricultural products, and general merchan-
dise. The improvement has made no appreciable difference in freight
rates.
   It is proposed to apply funds asked for to removing shoals that
have formed in the channel since it was dredged.
                   a See consolidated money statement on page 243.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                              237
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................                                                    $252.30
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909-----..---.......------------------------.............--------................---------------.................. 5, 000.00

                                                                                                                    5, 252. 30
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improvement.                                           252. 30

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .............                           ....................               ....    5, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909- .       -----------------------------------------                                                (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (f) Ohoptanlk River, Maryland.-Before improvements were begun
in i879 the depth of water in the channel between Denton and Greens-
boro varied from 2 to 8 feet, with a mean range of tide of about 2
feet. Navigation, carried on by small sailing vessels, extended to
only 3 miles above Denton. Upon the remaining 5 miles to Greens-
boro, the head of navigation, all freight had to be transported upon
scows. Greensboro is about 46 miles above the mouth of the river.
   A project for improvement was made in 1880 for an 8-foot low-
water channel 75 feet wide, at an estimated cost of $79,000. At the
close of the fiscal year 1903 the project channel had been completed,
except for a distance of about 1 mile at the upper end, but there has
been some shoaling since.
    The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $60,000
for improvement of rivers and harbors on east shore of Chesapeake
Bay, and $9,662.55 was allotted for this work. A contract for ex-
penditure of funds was made and dredging under it completed in 1908
and resulted in completing the project except for a distance of about
1,200 feet. About one twenty-fifth of the project remains to be done.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the channel under improvement
was 7 feet.
   The amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909, was
$80,502, of which $4,344.69 was for maintenance. The amount
expended during the fiscal year was for payment of retained percent-
ages on contract and proportion of office expenses.
    Six steamers and 251 sailing vessels and barges are reported as
plying in the river, the commerce being valued for the past calendar
year at $17,743,390. The tonnage of the river is reported to be as
follows: 1903, 208,367; 1904, 210,447; 1905, 212,725; 1906, 208,496;
1907, 212,661; 1908, 233,916, consisting of lumber, coal, canned goods,
poultry and live stock, fish and oysters, agricultural products and
general merchandise. The improvement has made no appreciable
difference in freight rates.
    It is proposed to apply the funds asked for to completing the proj-
ect and maintenance.
                           a See consolidated money statement on page 243.
238            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                         U.    S.    ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................                              ....................                $1, 445. 28
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment...--------..............--------------------------.......-------...........................---------.....---  1, 399. 73

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......-................                                      ..........             45. 55
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-...........                                        2, 797. 14
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909....        ....... .. .   ...............                                         (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (g) Warwick River, Maryland.-This river, formerly named Sec-
retary Creek, is in Dorchester County, eastern shore of Maryland, and
flows into the Choptank River, one of the largest tributaries of Chesa-
peake Bay. It is a small tidal basin 2 miles long, with no fresh-water
influx at the head, and was originally only 4 feet deep. The average
rise of tide is 2 feet. The original project for the stream is dated
January 20, 1880.
   Before the adoption of the present project about $12,000 had been
expended in the improvement of this river--$6,000 by the General
Government and the remainder by private parties. The existing proj-
ect for improvement, based upon a survey in 1891 (printed in Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1891, p. 1219) and adopted by
the river and harbor act of July 13, 1892, provides for a channel 100
feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water from the 10-foot depth
in Choptank River to Secretary Landing, at the head of the river in-
cluding a turning basin at the latter point, at an estimated cost of
$18,600. The project was completed in July, 1903, but shoals formed
rapidly.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $60,000
for improvement of rivers and harbors on east shore of Chesapeake
Bay, and $3,493.87 was allotted to this work. A contract was entered
into and the dredging finished under it in the summer of 1907, restor-
ing the project dimensions from the turning basin to Cedar Point.
Funds asked for are intended to be applied to maintenance.
   The sum of $3,000 was allotted from the appropriation for preser-
vation and maintenance of river and harbor work, act March 3,
1909, for maintenance, and a contract for the work is about to be
entered into.
   The amount expended on present project to June 30, 1909, is
$21,402.87, of which $5,362.05 was for maintenance. The money
expended during the fiscal year was for payment of retained per-
centages on contract and proportion of office expenses. The maxi-
mum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean low water
over the shoalest part of the channel under improvement was 9 feet.
   Six steamers and 80 sailing vessels and barges are reported as plying
in the river, the commerce being valued at $3,441,826. The tonnage
of the river is reported to be as follows: 1903, 65,206; 1904, 65,858;
1905, 66,631; 1906, 60,027; 1907, 61,225; 1908, 67,346, consisting
of lumber, canned goods, poultry and live stock, fish and oysters,
agricultural products and general merchandise.
   The improvement has made no appreciable difference in freight
rates.
                                a See consolidated money statement on page 243.
                              RIVER        AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       239
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................-----------------------------------                 $571. 05
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909- .--- --..................................................                                            3, 000. 00
                                                                                                                      3, 571. 05
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.................................................---------------------------------------------------..     571. 05
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended . . .............                              ..     ......     ..........          3, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909. -...                                                                                            (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (h) Pocomolce River, Maryland.--This river has been under im-
provement by the General Government since 1878, the original
project being dated November 19, 1878. In 1879 and 1880, $12,500
was expended on work below Snow Hill, chiefly in the rectification
of the channel and in giving increased width, the depth being 7 feet
at mean low water. In 1888, with an appropriation of $8,000, a cut-
off was made through the low neck of land forming four abrupt
bends just below Snow Hill. At the close of these operations there
was a channel not less than 80 feet wide and 7 feet deep between
Snow Hill and Shad Landing, a distance of about 43 miles.
   The existing project adopted by the river and harbor act of June
3, 1896, is based upon a survey made in 1894-95 (printed in Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1895, p. 1167) and is for dredg-
ing the channel between Snow Hill and Shad Landing to a depth of
9 feet at mean low water and a width of from 100 to 130 feet, at an
estimated cost of $14,000. The mean range of tide is 2- feet. Snow
Hill is the head of navigation on this stream and is about 28 miles
above the mouth. With funds provided from 1897 to 1904 the chan-
nel was dredged to the project dimensions.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $60,000
for improvement of rivers and harbors on east shore of Chesapeake
Bay and $2,298.60 was allotted to this work. A contract for expend-
iture of funds for maintenance was made and dredging under it
finished in June, 1908, removing three shoals.
   The sum of $2,500 was allotted from the appropriation for preser-
vation and maintenance of river and harbor works, act March 3,
1909, for maintenance, and a contract for the work is about to be
entered into.
   To the end of the fiscal year $37,341.60 has been expended for the
improvement of this river, of which $20,500 was on previous projects
and $2,570.87 for maintenance. The money expended during the
fiscal year was for payment of retained percentages on contract and
proportion of office expenses. The project is completed and the
additional work required is for maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the channel under improvement
was 7 feet.
   Three steamers and 88 sailing vessels and barges are reported as
plying in the river, the commerce being valued at $4,986,058. The
tonnage of the river is reported to be as follows: 1903, 245,568; 1904,
                            a See consolidated money statement on page 243.
240        REPORT OF THE CHIEF                 OF ENGINEERS, U.                     S. ARMY.

246,223; 1905, 67,165; 1906, 65,710; 1907, 67,024; 1908, 73,727,
consisting of lumber, coal, cord wood, canned goods, poultry and
live stock, agricultural products, and general merchandise.
   The improvement has made no appreciable difference in freight
rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.        ...............................                         $2,219. 35
Amount allotted from appropriatiml oy river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1909 .................................................                                 2, 500. 00
                                                                                                  4, 719. 35
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .....................................................                              2, 219.35

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...............                     ............   ..........    2, 500. 00
    (i) La Trappe River, Maryland.--This stream, formerly known
as Dividing Creek, has a length of about 3 miles and is a tributary
of Choptank River. The head of navigation is at Trappe Landing.
The controlling depth prior to 1893 was 4 feet, with a mean range of
tide of 2 feet, but was afterwards increased to 8 feet by dredging,
under private subscription. The original project, which is the exist-
ing one, was adopted by the river and harbor act of July 13, 1892,
and is for a channel 150 feet wide and 11 feet deep at mean low
water across the bar at the mouth and for a width of 75 feet and a
depth of 8 feet inside thi bar as far as Trappe Landing, with a turn-
ing basin at the latter point, at an estimated cost of $7,250, subse-
quently increased to $9,750. The project has been completed and the
additional work required is for maintenance.
    The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $60,000
for improvement of rivers and harbors on east shore of Chesapeake
Bay, and $2,135.39 was allotted for this work. A contract was made
for expenditure of funds for maintenance and dredging under it was
finished the last month of 1907, restoring turning basin to project
dimensions.
    The sum of $3,000 was allotted from the appropriation for preserva-
tion and maintenance of river and harbor works, act March 3, 1909,
for maintenance, and a contract for the work is about to be entered
into.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $11,252.89, of which
 $3,289.02 was for maintenance. The money expended during the
fiscal year was for payment of retained percentages on contract and
proportion of office expenses.
     The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the channel was 7 feet. Three
steamers and 83 sailing vessels and barges are reported as plying in
the river, the commerce being valued at $962,646, consisting of
lumber, coal, canned goods, poultry and live stock, agricultural pro-
ducts, and general merchandise.
     The tonnage of the river is reported to be as follows: 1903, 11,466;
  1904, 13,601; 1905, 13,848; 1906, 13,588; 1907, 13,859; 1908, 15,244.
     The improvement has made no appreciable difference in freight
rates.
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                    241
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................              ............  $224. 20
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........      ........................................              3, 000. 00
                                                                                   3, 224.20
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .................................................                      224.20
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended........           ...........................     3, 000. 00
    (j) Manokin River, Maryland.-Before improvements were com-
menced in 1891 the depth of water at the mouth of the river at the
so-called "Mud flats" was between 1 and 2 feet at low tide. These
flats are about 2 miles wide and make navigation impossible except
at high water, thereby rendering the upper part of the river, which
has a very fair depth and w idth, almost useless for extensive shipping
purposes. The average rise of tide at the flats is 2.6 feet. Princess
Anne is the head of navigation and is about 12 miles above the mouth
of the river.
    The project was adopted by the river and harbor act of September
19, 1890, and is based upon a survey made in August and September,
1889. (Report printed in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1890, p. 961.) It provides for a channel 6 feet deep at mean low
water and 100 feet wide from Locust Point to Sharps Point, a dis-
tance of about 2 miles and embracing the section called the "Mud
flats," at an estimated cost of $30,000.
    From 1891 to 1900 dredging on the whole project was done at vari-
ous times as funds became available. At the close of these opera-
tions there was a channel 6 feet deep from Sharps Point to about a
mile above Dashiells Creek and a slightly less depth to the steamboat
wharf above, and at the mouth soundings taken over the area formerly
dredged showed a range of depth from 4.5 to 7.3 feet. No work was
done afterwards until that of the autumn of 1905, which consisted in
removing shoals that had formed, and resulted in a controlling depth
of but 3 feet.
    The creation and maintenance of a channel across the mud flats at
the mouth of this river is a work of some difficulty and uncertainty
under the method adopted, which was originally considered as ten-
tative only and the best that the commercial importance of the project
would justify. Funds have not been available for adequate main-
tenance and the channel has deteriorated rapidly. The estimate of
cost of project was increased May 13, 1907, to $42,103.99. The river
and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $60,000 for improve-
ment of rivers and harbors on east shore of Chesapeake Bay, and
 $9,160.69 was allotted for this work. A contract for expenditure of
funds was made and dredging under it completed in June, 1908.
     The amount expended on the improvement to June 30, 1909, is
  $36,407.69, and $2,000 additional was expended on the upper river,
  which is not included in the existing project. The amount expended
  for maintenance was $8,511.13. About two-thirds of the project is
  completed. The money expended during the fiscal year was for pay-
  ment of retained percentages on contract and proportion of office
  expenses.
     The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
  low water over the shoalest part of the channel at the mouth was
  3 feet.
        9001-ENG 1909-16
242            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U.   S. ARMY.


  It was impracticable to procure commercial statistics. The im-
provement had made no appreciable difference in freight rates.
  It is proposed to apply the funds asked for toward completing the
project.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................... $5, 377. 92
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment------..----.....----.......--------..-----..............-----------...........------------.......-----.... 5, 352. 42

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................                                  ...... .......             25. 50
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 14, 181. 93
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, '1909.--------.......................................................                                  (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897.
    (kc) Tyacskin Creek.- This stream is also known as Wetipquin
Creek, or River. It is a small tributary of Nanticoke River, having a
length of about 5 miles. The controlling depth in the creek was 8
feet, but on the bar at the mouth it was but 3 feet at mean low water,
with an average rise and fall of the tide of 3 feet. A survey was
made in 1899 (report printed in Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1900, p. 1681). The existing project, which is the original
one, was adopted by the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, and is
for a channel 9 feet deep at mean low water, with a width of 120 feet,
at an estimated cost of $13,200. Under a survey made in January,
1906, the estimate of cost of completion of this project, with a suitable
turning basin added, is $6,462.39.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $60,000
for improvement of rivers and harbors on the east shore of Chesa-
peake Bay, and $6,500 was allotted to complete this work. A contract
was made for completion and dredging was finished, as far as funds
permitted, in the spring of 1908. The channel was completed to the
project depth and width, but owing to shoaling since the survey and
estimate were made in January, 1906, the turning basin was left at
a controlling depth of 7 feet at mean low water, which is ample for
present needs. Funds asked for are intended to be applied to com-
pleting turning basin and maintenance of project.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $16,556.32, of which
$2,443.91 was for maintenance and $3,954.41 on project as modified
by estimate of January, 1906. The project is about two-thirds com-
pleted. The money expended during the fiscal year was for payment
of retained percentages on contract and proportion of office expenses.
    The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the improvement was 8 feet and
the turning basin 7 feet.
    Three steamers and 36 sailing vessels and barges are reported as
plying in the creek, the commerce being valued at $78,710. The ton-
nage of the creek is reported to be as follows: 1903, 784; 1904, 796;
1905, 856; 1906, 945; 1907, 967; 1908, 1,064, consisting of lumber,
canned goods, poultry and live stock, agricultural products, and gen-
eral merchandise.
                         a See consolidated money statement on page 243.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                     243
   The improvement has made no appreciable difference in freight
rates.
   Reference to reports on examination and survey required by the
river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, will be found on page 214 of the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............  .....................                  $909. 24
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  m ent .............................................................                     807. 56
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                      101. 68
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........-               2, 406. 30
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ................................                      (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                            CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................... $26, 459. 68
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ................................................      25, 500. 00
                                                                                       51, 959. 68
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .............................             $23, 120. 29
    For maintenance of improvement ......................                 3, 018. 30
                                                                                       26, 138. 59
July 1,1909, balance unexpended .........................................              25, 821. 09
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........               67, 752. 19
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909................................                      80, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix J 6.)
   7. Nanticoke River, Delaware and Maryland.-This river is a tidal
stream, its headwaters consisting of numerous branches rising mainly
in the northern section of Sussex County, Del. The river flows in a
southwesterly direction into Tangier Sound, Chesapeake Bay, and
the interests for the improvement of the river center at Seaford, the
head of navigation, 36 miles from the mouth, where the range of tide
is about 3.4 feet.
   The river and harbor act of August 18, 1894, appropriated $5,000
for improving Broad Creek River, Delaware, a branch of Nanticoke
River, and provided that as much of it as might be necessary should
be used for the removal of the bar extending from the railroad bridge
at Seaford toward the mouth of Nanticoke River. With this appro-
priation the channel was dredged where necessary to a width of 100
feet and a depth of 9 feet at mean low water from the south side of
the railroad bridge at Seaford to a point 8,000 feet below. A previous
appropriation for the Nanticoke River in 1886 was, in accordance
                      a See consolidated money statement on this page.
244        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                       U.      S. ARMY.


with the terms of the law, applied to Broad Creek River up to
Laurel.
   The existing project for the improvement of the Nanticoke River
is based upon a survey made in 1895 (printed in Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1895, pp. 1165 to 1167) and is for a channel
9 feet deep at mean low water and 100 feet wide, the width to be
increased to about 150 feet at sharp turns of the channel, the improve-
ments to be extended to within 100 feet of the county bridge, where
the proposed channel is to widen out fan-shaped at an estimated cost
of $13,000. The project is completed and the additional work re-
quired is for maintenance.
   A contract for expenditure of funds for maintenance was made and
dredging under it finished in May, 1908.
   The sum of $2,000 was allotted from the appropriation for preserva-
tion and maintenance of river and harbor works, act of March 3, 1909,
for maintenance, and a contract for the work is about to be entered
into.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $15,000, of which
$5,000 was on a previous project and $4,429.26 for maintenance.
The money expended during the fiscal year was for payment of
retained percentages on contract and proportion of office expenses.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the channel was 8 feet.
   Three steamers and 105 sailing vessels and barges are reported as
plying in the river, the commerce being valued at $7,740,155. The
tonnage of the river is reported to be as follows: 1903, 119,038; 1904,
120,229; 1905, 121,769;- 1906, 119,348; 1907, 121,733, and for
calendar year ended May 1, 1909, 132,842, consisting of lumber, coal,
canned goods, poultry and live stock, fish and oysters, agricultural
products, and general merchandise.
   The improvement has made no appreciable difference in freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended........................             ............. $302. 99
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ....................................................               2, 000. 00
                                                                                      2, 302. 99
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .....................-------..... ..........................              302.99

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................         .................          2, 000. 00
   (See Appendix J 7.)
  8. Broad Creek River, Delaware.-This is a tributary of the Nanti-
coke River, and in 1881 the controlling depth was 12 feet, with a
mean range of tide of 3 feet. In 1889 a channel 6 feet deep at mean
low water and 50 feet wide had been dredged under project dated
February 4, 1880, from Bethel to Laurel, the head of navigation,
about 7 miles from the mouth of the river, at a cost of $35,000.
The existing project, adopted by the river and harbor act of July 13,
1892, is for a channel 70 feet wide and 8 feet deep at mean low water
between Bethel and Laurel, at an estimated cost of $15,000. The
projected channel was dredged except for a short distance at the
upper end, where it was reduced to 60 feet in width to secure the
stability of some wharves. Contract was entered into and dredging
under it finished in June of 1908, removing shoals above andl for a
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                        245
distance of about 1,000 feet below the railroad bridge at Laurel.
The appropriation requested is intended to be applied to main-
tenance.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $16,500, of which
$1,500 was for maintenance. The money expended during the
fiscal year was for payment of retained percentages on contract,
and proportion of office expenses. The project is completed and the
additional work required is for maintenance.
   The sum of $2,000 was allotted from the appropriation for preser-
vation and maintenance of river and harbor works, act March 3,
1909, for maintenance, and the contract for the work is about to
be entered into.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water, over the shoalest part of the channel is reported to be
7 feet.
   One steamer and 34 sailing vessels, power boats, and barges are
reported as plying in the river, the commerce being valued at
$444,512. The tonnage of the river for the year ending May 1, 1909,
is reported to be 28,480, consisting of fertilizer, lumber, canned
goods, flour and feed, shooks and crates, agricultural products, and
general merchandise.
   The improvement is reported to have made a reduction of 25 per
cent in freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................     $1, 400. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ......................................................  2, 000.00

                                                                            3, 400. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .....................................................         1, 400.00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..................................          2, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.........          .................................   2,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix J 8.)
   9. Wicomico River, Maryland.-The portion of the river at and
just below Salisbury, which is the head of navigation and 23 miles
from the mouth, has been under improvement by the United States
since 1872, under project dated April 15, 1871. The average rise and
fall of tide is 3 feet. At that time the navigable channel, with a
minimum depth of 8 feet at low water, extended to a point within 2
miles of Salisbury. The extreme upper portion, as far as the mill-
dam in the heart of the town, was quite shoal, and has an average
depth of only 18 inches at low tide. Between 1872 and 1885 a
channel 75 to nearly 100 feet wide and 7 feet deep at low water was
dredged from deep water below to the drawbridge in the town, at
a cost to the Government of about $50,000.
   The existing project, based upon a survey of the river made in 1889
(printed in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1890, pp.
947-950), provides for a channel 9 feet deep at mean low water,
from that depth below to the drawbridge at Salisbury, the width to
246          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


be from 100 to 150 feet, at an estimated cost of $23,200. At the
time this project was adopted there existed a 7-foot low-water chan-
nel from 75 to 100 feet wide to Salisbury. The project has been
completed and the additional work required is for maintenance.
   Contract for maintenance was entered into and dredging under it
finished in the spring of 1908, restoring dimensions of the upper part
of the channel.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $87,516, of which
$50,000 was on previous projects and $7,442.24 for maintenance.
The money expended during the fiscal year was for payment of re-
tained percentages on contract and proportion of office expenses.
   The sum of $5,000 was allotted from the appropriation for preser-
vation and maintenance of river and harbor works, act of March 3,
1909, for maintenance, and a contract for the work is about to be
,entered into.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the channel under improvement
was 8 feet.
   Two steamers and 82 sailing vessels and barges are reported as
plying in the river, the commerce being valued at $15,449,526. The
tonnage of the river is reported to be as follows: 1903, 197,306; 1904,
199,279; 1905, 202,510; 1906, 198,451; 1907, 202,416: 1908, 222,657,
consisting of lumber, coal, canned goods, poultry and live stock, fish
and oysters, agricultural products, and general merchandise. The
improvement has made no appreciable difference in freight rates.
   Reference to reports on examination and survey of the river re-
quired by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, will be found on
page 215 of the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906.
   It is proposed to apply the appropriation asked for in restoring the
channel to project dimensions below Williams's wharf.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................................    $244. 58
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909.............................................................    5, 000.00
                                                                                       5, 244. 58
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement...................................................244.                          58

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................................               5, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909------------......................-------------------------------------- 5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix J 9.)
   10. Crisfield Harbor, Maryland.-This harbor is situated at Somers
Cove, Little Annemessex River, which at this point is an estuary of
Tangier Sound, on the east side of Chesapeake Bay. It is the prin-
cipal port of the collection district of eastern Maryland. Crisfield is
the head of navigation of the harbor and is 1 mile from its mouth.
The length of the navigable portion of the harbor is 1I miles. Origi-
nally the harbor had a controlling depth of 81 feet at mean low water
for a width of 400 feet, with a mean rise and fall of tide of 2.6 feet,
but this was not deemed adequate for the commerce of the port. The
original project adopted by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1875,
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 247
was for a channel 266 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean low water
from above the railroad wharf to a point known as the second angle,
opposite Somers Cove light, and from that point to deep water below

,on
a channel of the same depth 425 feet wide, and in addition a basin
    both the rnorth and south sides of the railroad wharf 12 feet deep,
at an estimated cost of $37,317.50. The work was completed May,
1876.
   The act of March 3, 1905, authorized a survey, which was made in
December, 1905, the report thereon being printed in House Document
No. 783, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session. The existing project,
adopted by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, is to restore the
channel formerly dredged and to restore and widen the anchorage
basin, at an estimated cost of $37,706.62, and an annual cost for main-
tenance of $800. The estimated cost of the project was increased
April 17, 1909, to $47,762. The river and harbor act of March 2,
1907, made an appropriation of $37,707. A contract was entered
into and work under it completed in June, 1909. The project is
about three-fourths finished. To June 30, 1909, $35,254.52 has been
expended on existing project.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the channel under improvement
was 12 feet. Funds asked for will be applied to completing the
project.
   Eight steamers and 536 sailing vessels and barges are reported as
plying in the harbor, the commerce being valued at $8,221,918. The
tonnage of the harbor is reported to be as follows: 1906, 30,265;
1907, 30,738; 1908, 102,982, consisting of lumber, canned goods,
poultry and live stock, fish and oysters, agricultural products, and
general merchandise. The improvement has made no appreciable
difference in freight rates.
   A report on a survey of this harbor is to be found beginning on
page 105, Part 2, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1875.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................    $37, 660. 57
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.............................................................       35, 208. 09

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended........---------------.............-----------------......         2, 452. 48
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities................. ...............                         .       154. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available .............                     -..-.....
                                                                       ...-      ...........        2, 298.48
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                           10, 055. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909..------------------.....................................................            10, 055. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.
      (See Appendix J 10.)
   11. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navi-
gation.-During the past fiscal year the following wrecks were re-
moved: Schooner J. E. Watkins from Chesapeake Bay, Maryland,
near Sevenfoot Knoll, at a cost of $220, and the schooner Alethea
fiom Rock Creek, Maryland, at a cost of $400. The total amount
expended was $620.
248     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.        S. ARMY.

EXAMINATION   AND SURVEY MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH           RIVER AND
              HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports dated May 9, 1907, and January 7, 1908, on preliminary
examination and survey, respectively, of Tuclcahoe River, Maryland,
with a view to obtaining an increased depth from Wymans wharf to
the town of Hillsboro, required by the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907, were duly submitted by the district officer. They were re-
viewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursu-
ant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in House
Document No. 1160, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for
improvement at an estimated cost of approximately $15,600 is pre-
sented.

IMPROVEMENT     OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE WASHINGTON,
                DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the temporary charge of Capt. E. J. Dent,
Corps of Engineers, to July 18, 1908; in the charge of Maj. Spencer
Cosby, Corps of Engineers, from July 18 to December 22, 1908, hav-
ing under his immediate orders Capt. E. J. Dent and First Lieut.
W. T. Hannum, Corps of Engineers; in the charge of Maj. J. J. Mor-
row, Corps of Engineers, since the latter date, having under his imme-
diate orders Lieutenant Hannum.         Division engineer, Col. D. W.
Lockwood, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Potomac River at Washington, D. C.-Before improvement the
Virginia channel was obstructed by two bars. The upper bar ex-
tended upstream from Long Bridge to about one-half mile below
Easby Point, and the ruling depth on this bar was 8 feet. The lower
bar was near Giesboro Point and had a ruling depth of 14 feet. The
ruling depth in the Washington channel was 10 feet. Georgetown
Harbor was obstructed by several dangerous rocks. The flats, which
extended to the edge of the Virginia channel, were largely bare at low
water and were an active agent in spreading malarial and other dis-
eases. In 1849, $1,500 was appropriated for a survey of the river. Of
this sum $1,208.61 was expended and the balance of $291.39 covered
into the surplus fund of the Treasury.
   Between June 11, 1870, and March 3, 1881, the sum of $290,000 was
appropriated by Congress for the improvement of the harbors of
Washington and Georgetown. The project under which this last-
mentioned sum was expended is not definitely stated, although it is
understood that it provided for dredging channels 16 feet deep and
200 feet wide through the Georgetown and Washington channels, and
for the removal of the most dangerous rocks obstructing navigation in
the harbor of Georgetown to a depth of 20 feet.
   The existing project for the improvement was adopted August 2,
1882, and has for its object the improvement of the navigation of the
river by widening and deepening its channels, the reclamation of the
flats by depositing on them the material dredged from the channels,
the freeing of the Washington channel of sewage, and the establish-
ment of harbor lines. To effect these, the project provided "that the
channel depths * * * should be sufficient to accommodate the
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     249

largest draft vessels that can be brought up to Arsenal Point" (the
projected depth was not stated in feet, but by the above-imposed con-
dition was at that time limited to 20 feet at low tide, whereas the rul-
ing depth in the Potomac River below Washington has now been
increased by dredging to 24 feet at low tide), that the flats be re-
claimed to a height of 3 feet above the flood plane of 1877 (which,
although the highest recorded freshet at that time, was exceeded by
about 3 feet by the flood of 1889), and for a tidal reservoir to be pro-
vided with automatic inlet and outlet gates. A training dike on the
Virginia shore extending downstream from Analostan Island was
added to the project in 1890. The project also provided for the re-
building of Long Bridge and for the interception of all sewage dis-
charged into the Washington channel, but neither of these works
was included in the estimated cost of the improvement, which was
$2,716,365. The estimate as revised in 1897 is $2,953,020.
   The amount expended on the work of the existing project to June
30, 1909, was $2,758,564.56, of which $475,356.81 has been applied
to maintenance since March 3, 1899. The following sums have been
obtained from other sources than appropriations: Received from
sale of blueprints, 50 cents; of condemned property, $212.83; total,
$213.33.
   The expenditure resulted in the dredging of a channel 20 feet deep
and 550 feet wide through the bar above Long Bridge, in increasing
the width of the natural channel just below Long Bridge by 50 to
500 feet, and in deepening it to 20 feet; in dredging a channel 350
feet wide and 20 feet deep through the bar in the Virginia channel
near Giesboro Point; in dredging the Washington channel to a width
of 400 feet and a depth of 20 feet; in dredging between this naviga-
tion channel and the wall of the adjacent reclaimed area to a depth
of 12 feet; in dredging at the junction of the Washington and Vir-
ginia channels; in dredging the tidal reservoir (111 acres) to a depth
of about 8 feet, and restoring this depth to its area; in several times
redredging cuts 20 feet deep through bars which had re-formed by
freshet action in the Virginia and Washington channels; in the
completion of and repairs to the reservoir outlet; in the construction
of about 98 per cent of the combined inlet gates and bridge for the
tidal reservoir; in the construction of 35,289 linear feet of sea wall,
of which 8,876 linear feet has been taken down and relaid; and in the
building of 5,965 linear feet of training dike, containing about 21,218
cubic yards of stone.
   The area of land reclaimed by these operations is 628 acres (or,
including reservoir, 739 acres), which, by act of March 3, 1897, was
declared to be a public park, under the name of "Potomac Park."
   The amount of material dredged, deposited on the park, and paid
for under the various contracts is about 13,893,756 cubic yards. It
is estimated that in addition about 3,000,000 cubic yards of material
have been dredged under contract and deposited on the park, but
not paid for, owing to its having been excavated outside the specified
limits.
   In additon to the foregoing, a large amount, estimated at 915,000
cubic yards, of clean desirable earth has been deposited upon the
park by private parties working under permits.
250      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S. ARMY.

    The entire project is now about 90 per cent completed.
    The work of maintenance during the year consisted in finishing
the dredging in the Virginia channel and tidal reservoir, in making
additions and repairs to sea wall, in care of property, and in repairs to
plant, etc., and in general maintenance of the improvement.
    The work on the project during the year consisted in continu-
ing the building of the combined inlet gates and bridge for the
reservoir.
    The project for the improvement of the Potomac River at Washing-
ton provides for a flushing basin, with automatic gates at the inlet and
outlet, so arranged that at each oscillation of the tide the basin or
tidal reservoir will be filled during flood tide from the Virginia chan-
nel and emptied to the level of low water during the ebb tide into the
Washington channel.
    In order to provide for a highway connecting the park drives
on each side of the inlet to the tidal reservoir, an appropriation of
 $25,000 was made by act of Congress approved May 27, 1908 (sundry
civil appropriation act), to defray the additional expense involved
in widening the proposed inlet gates and constructing a road across
them.
    The plans provide for a structure with automatic gates to close
during the ebb and open during the flood tide, with curtain gates
to be closed when the Potomac River is heavily charged with sedi-
ment, with a lock for the passage of small water craft, and with a park
highway over the top. The structure will rest upon a pile founda-
tion and will be of concrete or reenforced concrete throughout.
A consulting architect has been employed to design the ornamental
features, and a consulting mechanical engineer to assist in the design
of the gates and operating machinery.
    During the fiscal year 1908 preliminary surveys and- current obser-
vations were made, general plans were prepared and approved by the
Chief of Engineers, nearly all of the necessary construction plant
was repaired and erected, the entire foundation was dredged, and
about one-third of the bearing piles were driven.
    During the present fiscal year the remaining foundation piles were
driven, the foundation surrounded by a wooden sheet-pile cofferdam,
and concrete piers and superstructure carried up to its present con-
dition. Excluding the installation of the automatic curtain and lock
gates, the bridge is estimated to be 98 per cent completed.
    The furnishing and emplacing of piles was done under a formal
contract, and a contract is in force for the furnishing and installation
of lock and curtain gates.
    All other construction has been done by day labor under the direc-
tion of this office, materials being purchased in accordance with
regulations.
    In addition to $25,000 appropriated by the sundry civil act, ap-
proved May 27, 1908, there has been expended from the appropria-
tion for improving Potomac River, approved March 2, 1907, for the
-construction of the combined bridge and inlet gates $81,382.77, which
includes the cost of the relocation and construction of 380 feet of sea
wall. Two hundred and ninety additional feet of sea wall formerly
laid up dry were reconstructed and laid up in mortar.
    The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the Washington channel was 21
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 251
feet. For the Virginia channel it was 18 feet. The mean range of
tide is about 3 feet.
   The Potomac River is navigable to the foot of Little Falls, 32miles
above Georgetown, but the Aqueduct Bridge, which crosses the river
at Georgetown, 113 miles above the mouth of the river, has no draw
and limits the navigation of large steamers and masted vessels.
   The principal articles of commerce are sand and gravel, coal, lum-
ber, ice, cord wood, stone, oils, oysters, bricks, coke, and general
merchandise. The receipts and shipments during 1908 amounted to
about 760,737 tons and were estimated to be worth about $7,843,130.
   The benefits to navigation from the improvement made have been'
marked. Vessels of much deeper draft than those formerly used are
now engaged in this trade, and it is understood that freight rates have
been materially reduced.
   It is proposed to apply the funds on hand and the additional ap-
propriation recommended toward completion of the tidal gates,
reconstruction of about 10,000 linear feet of damaged sea wall,
dredging in the Washington channel, and prosecution of the project.
   The additional work proposed is for the purpose of extension of
benefits and for the maintenance of the improvement in a serviceable
condition.
   Maps of the locality may be found in each Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers since 1877, with the exception of those for 1879,
1882, 1893, 1905, 1906, 1907, and 1908.
   Reference to the report on the examination and survey of Potomac
River at Washington, D. C., will be found on page 194 of the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
                                     IMPROVING      POTOMAC RIVER.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..............                     ...................            $192, 970. 99
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
                                                                                             ------ 25, 000. 00
  March 3, 1909......................----------------..............------......-----.....--.......
Received from sale of condemned property ...........................                                     123. 80
                                                                                                   218, 094. 79
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement............................                         $67, 589. 65
    For maintenance of improvement .....................                          91, 856. 37
                                                                                                   159, 446. 02

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                58, 648. 77
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..............................                  ......         5, 353. 38

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................                 ..     .......      -...    53, 295. 39

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                               13, 924. 27
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........                            611, 376. 81

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909---..-......   .     ...... .....                             180, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                    TIDAL    GATES, POTOMAC PARK.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................................................. $25, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment......................................................              ....... 25, 00. 00
    (See Appendix K 1.)
252          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                               U. S. ARMY.

   2.Potomac River below Washington, D. C.-The Potomac River
below Washington, D. C., is generally a wide and deep body of water,
having the characteristics of a tidal estuary rather than of a fluvial
stream.
   Prior to improvement 24-foot navigation was obstructed by seven
shoals, over which the depth ranged from 191 to 23 feet at low tide.
Several of these shoals were long and formed serious obstructions to
navigation by deep-draft vessels.
   The present, which is also the original, project for this improve-
ment was adopted March 3, 1899. It provides for the improvement
of the waterway by dredging channels 24 feet deep and 200 feet wide
through all obstructions to 24-foot navigation below Washington,
D. C., at an estimated cost of $176,000.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $185,000, of which
about $31,164 was applied to maintenance.
   As a result of this expenditure, channels 24 feet deep and at least
200 feet wide have been dredged through all the shoals, and 1,484,362
cubic yards of material has been excavated.
   No work was done during the fiscal year ended June 30, 1909.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water over the shoalest part of the locality under improve-
ment was 24 feet. The mean range of tide varies from about 1.6
feet at the lower shoals to about 2.8 feet at the upper. Georgetown,
113 miles above the mouth of Potomac River, is the head of navi-
gation for large vessels.
   The principal articles of commerce are sand and gravel, coal, lum-
ber, ice, oils, naval ordnance and.supplies, cord wood, brick clay,
stone, fertilizer, oysters, bricks, phosphate rock, coke, paving blocks,
railroad ties, asphalt, potash salt, and general merchandise. The
receipts and shipments during 1908 amounted to about 1,442,900
tons, and were estimated to be worth about $21,093,800.
   As far as known the work done has had no material effect upon
freight rates.
   The work provided for under the present project has been com-
pleted, and no further appropriation is required therefor.
   Maps of the locality may be found in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1890, 1900, 1902, and 1903.
   For reference to the reports of the examinations and surveys of
Potomac River below Washington, D. C., see page 197 of the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, and House Document No.
859, Sixtieth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................                 ................    $1, 000.00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                        1, 000. 00
    (See Appendix K 2.)
  3. Anacostia River, District of Columbia.-Before improvement
the ruling depth from the mouth to the Navy-Yard Bridge was about
18 feet, the channel affording this depth being narrow and tortuous.
  An allotment of $20,000 for work in the Anacostia was made from
the appropriation of September 19, 1890, for improving Potomac
River at Washington. Under this allotment channels 20 feet deep
and about 200 feet wide were dredged through shoals near the foot of
South Capitol street and opposite Washington Barracks. This
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   253
dredging was completed in May, 1892, at a cost of $18,536.94, and
the balance, $1,463.06, was applied to the present project.
   The present project for this stream was adopted June 13, 1902, and
provides for the improvement of the portion of Anacostia River
below the Navy-Yard Bridge by dredging a channel 20 feet deep for
a width of 400 feet, the depth then gradually decreasing to 6 feet at
the bulkhead lines, and by depositing the dredged material on the
adjacent flats to an average elevation of 7 feet above low tide, the
reclaimed area to be surrounded by an earthen embankment to a
height of 14 feet above low tide, protected by a masonry sea wall,
and provided with suitable drainage through the embankment, all
at an estimated cost of $1,218,525.
   The amount expended on the existing project to June 30, 1909,
was $267,288.15, of which $6,481.10 was applied to maintenance.
As a result of this expenditure, a channel 20 feet deep at mean low
water and at least 380 feet wide has been secured for a distance of
9,300 feet upstream from the mouth of the Anacostia, i. e., up to
upper limits of the navy-yard. The quantity excavated to date
amounts to 1,894,320 cubic yards, in addition to which 214,803 cubic
yards has been dredged by other departments of the Government
and by private parties under permits from, but without cost to, this
office.
    A riprap wall has been built to a height of 4 feet above mean low
water for a distance of 4,900 feet along the left bulkhead line, and
2,900 linear feet of it has been raised to 5 feet. This wall contains
27,367.1 cubic yards of stone, 4,023.1 cubic yards of which was
placed during the fiscal year 1909. It will temporarily serve to
retain dredged material and will ultimately form the foundation for
the projected masonry sea wall.
    Seven hundred and ninety-one piles of the old dismantled wharf
opposite the navy-yard have been removed.
    Incidental to the improvement of the channel about 150 acres of
flats have been filled by the deposit of excavated material to an
average height of 5 feet above low tide. Harbor lines have been
established from the mouth of the river up to Pennsylvania Avenue
Bridge.
    The work of improvement for the fiscal year 1909 consisted in
channel dredging and work incidental thereto, and amounted to
 $80,302.37. The work of maintenance for the fiscal year consisted
in raising the riprap mounds which had settled, and work incidental
thereto, and amounted to $6,481.10.
    The entire project is now about 25 per cent completed.
    The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, over
the shoalest part of the locality under improvement was 20 feet.
The mean range of tide is about 3 feet.
    Anacostia River is navigable for large vessels to the Navy-Yard
Bridge, for tugs and small vessels to Pennsylvania Avenue Bridge,
and for small scows and lighters to Bladensburg, Md., respectively,
2, 24, and 8- miles above its mouth.
    The principal articles of commerce are sand and gravel, naval
ordnance and supplies, brick clay, stone, coal, oils, paving blocks,
and cord wood. The receipts and shipments during 1908 amounted
to about 283,272 tons, and were estimated to be worth about
 $4,187,866.
254           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                           U.    S. ARMY.

   The improvement already made has been of benefit to navigation
and has resulted in the diversion of considerable traffic from the
Washington channel, where conditions were rapidly becoming con-
gested. It is not known that any reduction in freight rates has resulted
from the work done.
   It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation recommended
toward dredging, reclaiming the fiats, and completion of the project.
   The additional work proposed is for the extension of benefits.
   Maps of the locality will be found in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1903, 1904, 1905, 1906, and 1909.
   Reference -to reports upon examinations and surveys of this river
will be found on page 198 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1904.
   A report relative to the title to Anacostia flats is printed in House
Document No. 194, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..- .                          --........................... $97, 958. 38
Amount alloted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909................................................                               10, 000. 00
                                                                                              107, 958. 38
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.............................                      $80, 302. 37
    For maintenance of improvement ......................                        6, 481. 10
                                                                                               86, 783. 47

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                         21, 174. 91
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.......-- ............... ...........                      3, 936.08

July 1, 1909, balance available.......................................                         17, 238. 83
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                          3, 861. 34
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                      936, 543. 04
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909...................................      230, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix K 3.)
   4. Breton Bay, Maryland.-Breton Bay, a tidal estuary of the
Potomac River, is about 61 miles long and well landlocked. Fifteen
feet of water can be carried up the bay for a distance of 4 miles. At
the time of the adoption of the project for its improvement, 10-foot
navigation in Breton Bay was obstructed by a shoal commencing 5
miles above the mouth and extending to Leonardtown, at the head of
the bay. The least channel depth over this shoal was 5 feet at low
tide.
   The original project for improvement, adopted in 1878 and modi-
fied in 1886 and 1890, provided for dredging a channel 150 feet
wide and 9 feet deep from the 9-foot contour in Breton Bay to the
Leonardtown wharf, with a turning basin for steamboats at the
wharf 400 feet wide and 600 feet long, at an estimated cost of $30,000.
   From June 18, 1878, to September 19, 1890, nine appropriations,
aggregating $37,500, were made. This sum was applied to dredging
214,229 cubic yards of material. The work called for by the original
project was completed in 1891.
                RIVER AND   HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                  255
   The present project for this improvement was adopted June 13,
1902, and contemplates the dredging of a channel and turning basin
10 feet deep, the channel to have a minimum width of 200 feet and
the turning basin to be 400 feet wide and 600 feet long. The esti-
mated cost of the project is $36,480.
   The Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors considered this
project and recommended, in report dated September 22, 1903, that
$6,000 be expended at the earliest practicable date in providing a
channel 10 feet deep and wide enough to accommodate the boats now
trading in this stream, including a turning basin of ample dimensions
at Leonardtown wharf, $4,000 to be applied to new work and $2,000
to maintenance.
   It was the opinion of the Board that the expenditure of $4,000
every four years thereafter would be enough to maintain a sufficient
turning basin and a channel at least 100 feet wide and wider at the
turn, all of a 10-foot depth.
   The amount expended under the present project to June 30, 1909,
was $12,220.63, of which about $1,797.08 was applied to main-
tenance. As a result of this expenditure, there has been dredged a
channel from Leonardtown wharf to deep water in Breton Bay 150
feet wide, 10 feet deep, and 6,100 feet long, with a turning basin at
its head of the same depth, 275 feet wide, and about 500 feet long.
The width of the channel is increased to about 220 feet at the turn at
Buzzard Point. The project as recommended by the Board of
Engineers for Rivers and Harbors is completed except for main-
tenance.
   The total amount of material dredged from the channel under the
present project is about 57,000 cubic yards. The work of main-
tenance done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, consisted
of surveys, advertisement, and other incidental expenses to the
dredging contemplated for the next fiscal year, amounting to $297.08.
The work of improvement consisted of closing up the account for
dredging done during the fiscal year 1907, amounting to $485.65.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low water, over the shoalest part of the locality under im-
provement was 10 feet. The mean range of tides is about 1.7 feet.
Leonardtown, 6 miles above the mouth of the bay, is the head of
navigation.
   The principal articles of commerce are oysters, railroad ties, cord
wood, lumber, grain, tobacco, farm produce, coal, bricks, fertilizer,
and general merchandise. The receipts and shipments during 1908
amounted to about 9,592 tons and were estimated to be worth about
$272,533. The number of passengers carried is about 2,000 a year.
   The improvement has been of great benefit to shippers in this
vicinity, but as far as known there has been no material reduction in
freight rates.
   No further appropriation is at present required.
   Maps of the locality may be found in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1887 and 1889.
   For reference to reports on examinations and surveys of this local-
ity, see page 199 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1904. For report of Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors
referred to above, see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1903, page 1045.
256          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                             U.    S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..........................................                       $562. 10
Amount appropriated by river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909 .....                         4, 000. 00
                                                                                                 4, 562. 10
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.. ...................................                    $485. 65
    For maintenance of improvement.- ..................                    ........    297. 08
                                                                                                   782. 73
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...-...............                 ..................   ...    3, 779. 37
    (See Appendix K 4.)
   5. York, Mattaponi, and Pamunkey rivers, and Occoquan and
Carters creeks, Virginia.--(a) York River.-Prior to improvement
24 feet could be carried up York River for a distance of 32 miles, to
Potopotank bar, over which the ruling depth was 181 feet. West
Point bar, the only other obstruction to navigation, had a least depth
of 15- feet.
   The project for this improvement, adopted June 14, 1880, and
revised in 1884 and 1887, provides for dredging channels 22 feet
deep at mean low water and 400 feet wide through the bars, and for
the construction of a dike along the right bank at West Point bar
to maintain the channel, at a total estimated cost of $308,800.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $258,685.04, of which
$30,761.81 was applied to maintenance subsequent to March 3, 1899.
This expenditure has resulted in a dredged channel 105 feet wide and
22 feet deep at Potopotank, and another 22 feet deep and 160 to 260
feet wide at West Point bar. A training dike 10,142 feet long has
been constructed at West Point bar, of which 4,818 linear feet has
been rebuilt and 3,474 linear feet has been repaired. The total
amount of material dredged from the channels is about 1,160,100
cubic yards.
   The entire project is now about 60 per cent completed.
   The work of maintenance during the fiscal year consisted in re-
building the dike, repairs to plant, and miscellaneous incidental work.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low tide over the shoalest part of the locality under improve-
ment was about 19 feet. The mean range of tides is about 3 feet.
York River is navigable, throughout its entire length of 41 miles, to
West Point at its head.
   The principal articles of commerce are lumber, oysters, cord wood,
tobacco, railroad ties, farm produce, ship timber, piles, and general
merchandise. The receipts and shipments during 1908 amounted
to about 178,445 tons, and were estimated to be worth about $7,222,846.
   The work done has been of much importance to commerce, and it
is understood that freight rates have been somewhat reduced.
   It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation recommended
to the repair of the dike and to redredging the channels.
   The additional work proposed is for maintenance of work already
done.
   Maps of the locality may be found in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1886, 1887, and 1894.
   For reference to report on examination and survey of York River
see page 201 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       257
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ........
                                       -         .....   . .... . ...........   $6, 806. 59
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.. .................-      ...... .......  .....    ... ........ 23, 000. 00
                                                                                                             29, 806. 59
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement----...---...------.......----......-------...-----------------.....--......----......           8, 619.77
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...........---------------------------------.......                         21, 186. 82
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities             -............................                  ...     .    1, 894. 28
July 1, 1909, balance available.. ...                -
                                                    ..-.-....---   ....-..        .    . .....   .....       19, 292. 54
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts---..-----------..........    7, 138. 69
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- .- ..          .. 59, 689. 95
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 .....                                                                                     (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Mattaponi River.-The Mattaponi River is navigable for small
steamers and vessels from its mouth to Aylett, about 39 miles above,
and navigable for small lighters and rafts from Aylett to Monday
bridge, 16 miles farther. At the time of the adoption of the project
the obstructions to 51-foot navigation below Aylett consisted of 7
bars, upon which the ruling depths at low tide varied from 2.4 to 3.8
feet. Above Aylett there were numerous bars, but no work upon
them has been proposed. The river was also obstructed by snags,
wrecks, and overhanging trees.
   The original project for improvement, adopted June 14, 1880, pro-
vided for the removal of snags, wrecks, and leaning trees below Mon-
day bridge, and the improvement of the bars below Aylett, so as to
give a depth of 51 feet at low tide and a channel width of 40 feet, at
an estimated cost of $34,059. This project was extended by the terms
of the river and harbor act of July 13, 1892, which provided for the
removal of snags as far up as Guineas bridge, near Milford station,
on the Richmond, Fredericksburg and Potomac Railroad. The esti-
mated cost of this, which is the present project, is $72,100.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $51,790.84, of which
$18,022.34 has been applied to maintenance since March 3, 1899.
This expenditure resulted in the removal of snags, logs, and over-
hanging trees from the river between the mouth and Monday bridge,
and in keeping the river below Aylett free from such obstructions;
in constructing 2,297 linear feet of dike at Robinson bar, and in
dredging channels of the full projected dimensions through Line Tree,
Latan6, Robinson, Presque Isle, Sales, Walker, and Jones bars. The
total amount of material dredged from the channels is about 69,613
cubic yards. The entire project is now about 35 per cent completed.
   The work of maintenance during the fiscal year consisted of dredg-
ing, of snagging the river, and of engineering and miscellaneous
incidental office expenses.
   The maximum draft that could be carried at mean low water over
the shoalest part of the channel June 30, 1909, was 3 feet at Walker
bar. The mean range of tide is about 3.5 feet.
                    a See consolidated money statement on page 262.
         9001--ENG 1909--17
258           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                U.      S. ARMY.

   The principal articles of commerce are lumber, cord wood, farm
produce, railroad ties, ship timber, piles, and general merchandise.
The receipts and shipments during 1908 amounted to about 95,069
tons, and were estimated to be worth about $1,329,548.
   The work done has been of considerable benefit to commerce, and
it is understood that not only have shipments been facilitated, but
that freight rates have been somewhat reduced.
   It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation recommended
to dredging, dike construction, and to snagging.
   The additional work proposed is partly necessary to make the im-
provement available, partly for the extension of benefits and partly
for the preservation of work already done.
   Maps of the locality may be found in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1887, 1888, and 1890.
   For reference to reports on examinations and surveys of this local-
ity, see page 212 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1904.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................  $10, 588.16
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ......    ...................................             7, 500. 00
Amount received by transfer and allotment ............................  a 9, 181. 31
                                                                                                     27, 269. 47
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..............................                             $4, 009. 58
    For maintenance of improvement. ............   ......                              15, 769. 42
                                                                                                     19, 779. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ..................................                                  7,490. 47
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................                                350. 08

July 1, 1909, balance available......             .....     ................        .........   ..    7, 140. 39
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                             30, 841. 03
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 19090...........           .    .........                                 (b)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Pamunkey River.-At the time of the adoption of the project
for the improvement of Pamunkey River, a draft of 7 feet could be
carried at low tide to Buckland bar, 381 miles above its mouth.
Between this bar and Bassett Ferry, a distance of 8 miles, there
were four bars, the ruling depths on which varied from 2-1 to 5 feet.
Besides these bars the river was obstructed by wrecks, logs, snags,
and overhanging trees.
   The original, which is also the existing, project for the improve-
ment of this river was adopted June 14, 1880, and amended in 1885
and 1908. It contemplates securing a channel 7 feet deep and 100
feet wide between Bassett Ferry and the mouth of the river, this
result to be obtained by dredging and the construction of dikes, the
latter being also designed to secure the dredged material deposited
   a $5,981.31 net allotment from appropriation of March 3, 1905, for emergencies in
river and harbor works; $2,200 transferred from Occoquan Creek; $1,000 transferred
from Carters Creek.
   bSee consolidated money statement on page 262.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   259

behind them. The wrecks, snags, logs, and trees obstructing navi-
gation are also to be removed. The estimated cost of the revised
project is $55,000. It is estimated that an expenditure of $5,000 is
now required for maintenance, in addition to the work which can be
done with available funds, and that in future the cost of maintenance
will be $4,000 every four years.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $34,263.57, of which
$4,073.99 was applied to maintenance after March 3, 1899. This
expenditure has resulted in dredging channels 100 feet wide and
7 feet deep through Buckland bar, 70 feet wide and 7 feet deep
through Hogan bar, and 95 feet wide and 6 to 7 feet deep through
Skidmore bar; in the construction of 1,478 linear feet of sheet pile
dikes at Spring and Skidmore bars; in the construction of 14 perme-
able spur dikes, aggregating in length 2,332 linear feet, at Buckland
and Hogan bars; in removing parts of eight wrecks, and in removing
snags and similar obstructions from about 50 miles of river and keep-
ing it free from such obstructions. The total amount of material
dredged from the channels is about 24,485 cubic yards.
   The entire project is now about 55 per cent completed.
   The work of improvement done during the fiscal year consisted
of dredging, and construction of permeable spur dikes and the inci-
dental expenses thereto were $5,754.97. The work of maintenance
done during the fiscal year consisted of resnagging the lower 50 miles
of river and its incidental expenses were $1,201.94.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low tide over the shoalest part of the locality under improve-
ment was 5 feet. The mean range of tide is about 3-1 feet. Bassett
Ferry, 47 miles above the mouth of the river, is the head of naviga-
tion for vessels drawing 5 feet and navigation by small lighters and
rafts extends about 15 miles above.
   The principal articles of commerce are lumber, cord wood, rail-
road ties, ship timber, piles, and grain. The receipts and shipments
during 1908 amounted to about 49,107 tons and were estimated to
be worth about $559,516.
   The work done has been of benefit to commerce, and it is under-
stood that not only have shipments been facilitated, but freight
rates have been reduced.
    It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation recommended
to dredging, snagging, and dike construction, as provided for by the
approved project.
    The additional work proposed is necessary to make the improve-
ment available, and for maintenance and preservation of the work
already done.
    Maps of the locality may be found in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1887, 1888, and 1890.
    For reference to the report on an examination and survey of Pa-
munkey River, see page 213 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1904.
260            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U.       S.   ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended........--.............................                                       $8, 093. 34
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......................................................                                         7, 500. 00
                                                                                                              15, 593. 34
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.......   ....... ................                                  $5, 754. 97
    For maintenance of improvement ....-..................                                       1, 201. 94
                                                                                            -                  6, 956. 91

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....---.-----------------------...........--------.................           8, 636.43
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities------................-----------------......--...---------........           75.42

July 1, 1909, balance available--------.......---------...........--------------------.........                8, 561.01

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                                      16, 173. 99

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909-----......... .      ..........  ......                                       (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (d) Occoquan Creek.-In 1872 navigation in Occoquan Creek, a
tributary of the Potomac River, was obstructed by three bars, over
which but 1.2 feet could be carried at low tide. Aside from these
obstructions the creek was amply wide and deep at low tide for vessels
drawing up to 5 feet.
   The original project for improvement, adopted March 3, 1873, and
modified in 1879, provided for dredging channels 100 feet wide and 5
feet deep through the bars below the town of Occoquan, and the
construction of a dike at Sand bar, at an estimated cost of $25,000.
Four appropriations were made from 1873 to 1878, aggregating
$25,000, and in 1880 the improvement was regarded as completed.
   The existing project for this stream, adopted September 19, 1890,
and extended by act of March 2, 1907, contemplates the dredging
of channels 6 feet deep through the five bars obstructing 6-foot navi-
gation below the town of Occoquan. These channels are to be 100
feet wide, except through the outer bar and the lower 2,000 feet of the
bar next above it, where the channel is to be 150 feet wide. Dikes are
to be constructed at the upper three bars. The estimated cost of the
project as modified is $64,000.
   The amount expended under the existing project to June 30, 1909,
was $50,797.97, of which $14,713.63 was applied to maintenance sub-
sequent to March 3, 1899. As a result of this expenditure, channels
of the full projected dimensions have been dredged through all of the
bars and redredged where shoaling occurred, and 1,696 linear feet of
dike has been constructed at Occoquan bar and Sand bar and repaired
where injured by freshets and ice.
   The total amount of material dredged from the channels is about
341,145 cubic yards. There has been placed in the dikes about 6,475
cubic yards of stone.
   The entire project is now about 60 per cent completed.
   The work of maintenance during the year consisted in an inspec-
tion and miscellaneous office work.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement
                           a See consolidated money statement on page 262.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      261
was 6 feet. The mean range of tide is about 2 feet. The town of
Occoquan, 6 miles above the mouth, is the head of navigation.
   The principal articles of commerce are railroad ties, building sand,
piles, cord wood, lumber, grain, farm produce, coal, and flour. The
receipts and shipments during 1908 amounted to about 25,958 tons,
and were estimated to be worth $101,931.
   The work done has been of great benefit to navigation in this creek,
and it is understood that not only have shipments been facilitated,
but freight rates have been materially reduced.
   It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation recommended
to construction of dikes and maintaining the channels of the project.
   The additional work proposed is for the purpose of extension of
benefits and maintenance of the work already done.
   For reference to reports on examinations and surveys of this local-
ity see pages 202 and 203 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1904 and page 237 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1906.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................... $4,188. 24
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909....------------------.....................-----------------------....------....--........... 1, 000.00
                                                                                                          5, 188. 24
Amount transferred to Mattaponi River................................                                     2, 200. 00

                                                                                                          2, 988. 24
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.....---------........................----------------. $1, 285.77
    For maintenance of improvement.......-----...................                       401. 03
                                                                                                          1, 686. 80
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                                   1, 301. 44


tAmount
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 26, 614. 22

          that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909... .......       .............    ....                                    (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (e) Carters Creek.-Before improvement the entrance to Carters
Creek, a tidal estuary of the Rappahannock River, was obstructed by
a bar over which but 10- feet could be carried at low tide, and naviga-
tion was rendered difficult near Gallyhook Point within the creek by
the projection of this point into the channel, which was about 12 feet
deep at low tide.
   The original, which is also the exisiting, project for this improve-
ment was adopted'June 13, 1902, and provides for dredging a chan-
nel at the mouth to afford a navigable depth at low tide of 15 feet,
with a width of 200 feet, including necessary widening at Crab Point,
for the construction of a jetty for the protection of this channel, and
for the dredging of a channel 12 feet deep and 100 feet wide at Gally-
hook Point, at a total estimated cost of $35,700.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $28,525.63, $128.08 of
which was applied to maintenance. As a result of this expenditure a
channel 200 feet wide and 15 feet deep has been dredged through the
bar at the mouth of the creek. The bar at the end of Crab Point has
                       a See consolidated money statement on page 262.
262           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                      U.    S. ARMY.


been dredged to a depth of 15 feet within the channel limits. A chan-
nel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep has been excavated at Gallyhook
Point. A stone jetty 742 feet long has been constructed at the mouth
of the creek. Harbor lines have been established. The total amount
of material dredged from the channels is 65,893 cubic yards. There
has been placed in the jetty 1,507 cubic yards of stone. The entire
project is now completed.
    The work of maintenance during the year consisted in an inspection
and miscellaneous office work.
    The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low tide over the shoalest part of the outer bar was 15 feet, and
at Gallyhook Point was 12 feet. The mean range of tide is 1.5 feet.
Irvington, about 1 miles above the mouth of the creek, is the head
of navigation for large steamers, while small sailing vessels drawing
up to 5 feet can ascend about 1 mile farther.
    The principal articles of commerce are fish, oysters, lumber, coal,
guano, fish oil, wood, bricks, ice, farm produce, canned goods, and
general merchandise. The receipts and shipments during 1908
amounted to about 58,825 tons and were estimated to be worth
 $941,275. There is a good passenger trade in Carters Creek, which
is also an important harbor of refuge.
    The work done has been of considerable benefit to commerce, but
as far as known has had no effect upon freight rates.
    The work contemplated in the project being completed, no further
appropriation is asked for at present. It is anticipated that an
appropriation of about $5,000 .every eight years will be required for
maintenance.
    For reference to the report upon an examination and survey of
'Carters Creek, see page 206 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1904.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................... $1, 526.15
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.............. ......... ...........................    1, 000.00
                                                                                                          2, 526. 15
Amount transferred to Mattaponi River.....--..........................                                    1, 000. 00
                                                                                                          1, 526. 15
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...-............................. $335. 22
    For maintenance of improvement............................ 128. 08
                                                                                                            463. 30

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........................                                 ...........    1, 062. 85
                                                CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ............................      .......... $31, 202.48
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......------.............................................      40, 000.00
Amount received by allotment--.....   ---..... .............. ..............    5, 981.31
                                                                                                         77, 183. 79
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.............................                                 $11, 385. 54
    For maintenance of improvement....     .....-....... .. .. .                           26, 120. 24
                                                                                                         37, 505. 78
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-----....--..-----..............---------------......----.....--...      39, 678.01
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..........-.....                ...................                  2, 319.78
July 1, 1909, balance available....-.........                     ..-         ....        .......-..     37, 358. 23
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              263
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..............       $7, 138. 69
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 133, 319. 19

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909 .......            ................  100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix K 5.)
  6. Nomini Creek, Virginia.-Before improvement the navigation
of Nomini Creek, a tributary of the Potomac, was obstructed by a
bar at its mouth over which but 3 feet could be carried at low tide.
Except for this bar a draft of 8 feet could be carried to Nomini
Ferry, 4 miles above the mouth, and 5 feet could be carried 2 miles
farther to the head of navigation.
  The project for this improvement, adopted March 3, 1873, and
modified in 1879, 1885, 1888, 1890, 1897, and 1908, provides for a
channel through the bar 150 feet wide and 9 feet deep, with a jetty
about 2,370 feet long at the mouth. The finally revised estimate of
cost is $105,000.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $82,686.52, of which
$4,008.71 was applied to maintenance subsequent to March 3, 1899.
As a result of this expenditure the channel has been dredged to a
depth of 9 feet at low tide, with a width of 140 to 150 feet, and re-
dredged, and 2,110 linear feet of jetty has been constructed. The
total amount of material dredged from the channel is about 136,000
cubic yards. There have been placed in the jetty about 6,014 cubic
yards of stone and 3,000 cubic yards of oyster shells. The entire
project is now about 85 per cent completed. No work of mainte-
nance was done during the fiscal year ended June 30, 1909. The
work of improvement consisted in the extension of the jetty and
miscellaneous office expenses, amounting to $3,757.83.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low tide over the shoalest part of the locality under improve-
ment was 9 feet. The mean range of tide is 1.8 feet.
   The principal articles of commerce are farm produce, lumber, cord
wood, fertilizer, grain, railroad ties, oysters, canned goods, fish, and
general merchandise. The receipts and shipments during 1908
amounted to about 22,760 tons and were estimated to be worth about
$944,150.
   The work done has been of substantial benefit to navigation, and
it is understood that freight rates have been considerably reduced
and shipments much facilitated.
   It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation recommended
to the extension and maintenance of the jetty, and redredging the
channel to obtain the required width.
   The additional work proposed is for the purpose of extension of
benefits and for the preservation of the work already done.
   A map of the locality may be found in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1889.
   For reference to a report on an examination and survey of Nomini
Creek, see page 207 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1904.
264             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                               U.    S.    ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................                                                     $71.31
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 .-------------------------------------------------....................................................   4, 000. 00
                                                                                                                         4, 071. 31
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment. --..................------..................................--....                                               3,757.83
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended----...--------........--.....--..              ...............                            313.48
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....----------................------------.......-----------......                    122.30
July 1, 1909, balance available ........................                                     .....   ..........            191. 18
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ....---......----.....  101. 40
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 26, 008. 71
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909........-----------.....-----.................---------------. 10,000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix K 6.)
   7. Rappahannock River, Virginia.-The lower portion of the
Rappahannock River is generally a wide and deep body of water,
having the characteristics of a tidal estuary rather than of a fluvial
stream.
   The obstructions to navigation before improvement was undertaken
consisted of 9 bars in the upper portion of the river between Tap-
pahannock and Fredericksburg, over which the ruling depths were
from 4 to 10 feet. Seven of the bars were in the 12 miles of river
below Fredericksburg. Of these bars Fredericksburg bar, with a
least depth of 4 feet, and Spottswood bar, 4 miles below Fredericks-
burg, with a least depth of 6 feet, caused the most delay to steam-
boats and vessels.
   The project for this improvement, adopted March 3, 1871, as modi-
fied in 1879 and in 1905, provides for securing a channel 12 feet deep
and 100 feet wide between Fredericksburg and Port Royal and 12
feet deep and 200 feet wide between Port Royal and the mouth of the
river, this result to be obtained by dredging and the construction of
dikes, the latter being also designed to secure the excavated material
deposited behind them.
   The total estimated cost of the revised project was $363,288.86,
exclusive of work properly chargeable to maintenance and estimated
in 1905 to cost $38,500. The project on which this estimate was based
was adopted by Congress by act approved March 2, 1907. This act
authorized an expenditure of $90,000 in excess of the amounts therein
and theretofore appropriated. This makes the limit of cost of the
revised project $393,633.12, including all necessary work properly
chargeable to maintenance on June 30, 1907. The contract authoriza-
tion of $90,000 has since been appropriated. The estimated annual
cost for further maintenance is $10,000.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $464,156.27, of which
$100,985.78 has been applied to maintenance since March 3, 1899.
The sum of $59,933.18 was expended prior to March 3, 1899, in re-
dredging freshet deposits and in repairs to dikes.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     265
   The following sums have been obtained from other sources than
appropriations: Damages recovered from contractor's sureties,
$1,000, and proceeds of sale of property, $110; total, $1,110. This
sum had not been expended at the close of the fiscal year.
   The expenditure has resulted in the completed improvement of 13
and in the partial improvement of 7 bars between Fredericksburg
and the mouth of the river by means of dredging and rock excava-
tion, construction of dikes, and removal of two wrecks which ob-
structed navigation. About 1,098,530 cubic yards of material has
been dredged, 1,537 cubic yards of rock excavated, 33,495 linear
feet of dikes constructed, 8,290 linear feet of dikes repaired, 915
linear feet of riprap dike constructed, and 1,655.8 cubic yards of riprap
stone used.
   The entire project is now about 90 per cent completed, but it is
estimated that $10,000 per annum is required for maintenance. The
work carried on during the year resulted in completing all the dikes
called for by the approved project, in completing channels to the
full projected dimensions through 13 bars, in partially completing
channels through 3 bars, protecting spoil-banks from freshet erosion,
and in other miscellaneous work. The incidental expenditure was
$65,020.51, of which $14,079.73 was applied to maintenance. Dredg-
ing was carried on under a continuing contract.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement
was about 9 feet. The mean range of tide is about 3 feet. Fredericks-
burg, 106 miles above the mouth, is the head of navigation for steamers
and barges. Falmouth, 3 miles farther up, is the head of navigation
for small scows, lighters, and launches.
   The principal articles of commerce are railroad ties, lumber, farm
produce, grain, cord wood, fertilizers, flour, canned goods, coal,
manufactures, and general merchandise. The receipts and ship-
ments during 1908 amounted to about 395,842 tons, and were esti-
mated to be worth about $6,485,797.
   The work done has been of benefit to commerce, and it is under-
stood that freight rates have been reduced.
   It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation recommended
toward the maintenance of dredging, of dike construction, of work
already done, and work that will be completed with funds now in
hand.
   At Fredericksburg bar new deposits of sand are formed by each
recurring freshet, and shoaling is also constantly taking place,
though less rapidly, at some of the lower bars. This explains the
estimate of $10,000 being required annually for maintenance.
   Maps of this locality may be found in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1880, 1881, 1883, 1886, 1887, 1888, 1890, 1906,
and 1909.
   For reference to the report on an examination and survey of Rap-
pahannock River, see page 208 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1904, and for the report of the survey submitting the
revised project, see page 1110 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1906.
266           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                      U.    S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................... $95, 203.24
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
   March 3, 1909...---------...............................................                              15, 000.00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909 .......                                   32, 000. 00
                                                                                                        142, 203. 24
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.............................                                 $50, 940.78
      For maintenance of improvement                      --.....-....-..... 14, 079. 73
                                                          --..-.
                                                                                                         65, 020. 51
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                                   77, 182. 73
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities --...-
                                           ------
                                           ....          ..--
                                                          ..--.
                                                   .....--..--                                               791. 33

July 1, 1909, balance available------------................------.........------------..---....--....    76, 391.40
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..................                                  58, 403. 67
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.-........                                  7, 332. 27
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
  expended July 1, 1909...-                                           . 30, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix K 7.)
  8. Urbana Creek, Virginia.-Before the improvement of Urbana
Creek, a tributary of the Rappahannock, a bar existed outside the
mouth, over which but 6Z feet could be carried at low tide, and there
was a shoal within the creek with a ruling depth of 7 feet.
  The project for this improvement, adopted March 3, 1879, and
modified in 1883, 1888, and 1897, provides for dredging a channel
150 feet wide and 10 feet deep through the outer and inner bars,
with a turning basin of the same depth at the head, for a series of
spur dikes at Bailey Point, and for a stone jetty to protect the cut
through the outer bar. The final revised estimate of cost is $70,000.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $43,319.78, of which
$10,989.48 has been applied to maintenance since March 3, 1899.
As a result of this expenditure there has been dredged a channel 10
feet deep and 150 feet wide through the outer bar, a channel 10 feet
deep and 150 feet wide through the inner bar, and a turning basin 10
feet deep at the steamboat wharf. These channels have been re-
dredged where shoaling had occurred.
   Harbor lines have been established. Seven hundred and eighty-
three linear feet of jetty has been constructed. The total amount of
material dredged from the channel is about 144,300 cubic yards.
There has been placed on the jetty about 1,095.4 cubic yards of stone.
   The work during the fiscal year consisted in entering into a contract
for the extension of the jetty, in a survey, in an inspection, and in
miscellaneous office work, the incidental expenditure thereto being
$180.37, which was applied to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, at
mean low tide over the shoalest part of the locality under improve-
ment was about 10 feet. The mean range of tide is 1.5 feet. The
town of Urbana, at the mouth of the creek, is the head of navigation
for steamers and large vessels, while small vessels ascend the stream
for a distance of 3 or 4 miles.
   The principal articles of commerce are lumber, oysters, cord wood,
excelsior, coal, farm produce, canned goods, railroad ties, bricks,
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            267
pickles, manufactured clothing, fertilizer, and general merchandise.
The receipts and shipments during 1908 amounted to about 29,000
tons, and were estimated to be worth $991,503.
   The work done has been of benefit to commerce, and it is under-
stood that freight rates have been reduced.
   Work on this improvement was suspended between 1903 and 1907
pending the result of legal proceedings instituted by the Government
to secure the removal of part of a wharf which projected into the
proposed channel and which had been built in violation of the pro-
visions of the act of March 3, 1899.
   The wharf was finally altered in accordance with the requirements
of the War Department.
   It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation recommended
to the extension and maintenance of the jetty, the construction of a
spur dike at Bailey Point, and the redredging of the outer bar.
   The additional work proposed is partly for the extension of benefits
and partly for the preservation of the work already done.
   For reference to the reports on examinations and surveys of Urbana
Creek, see page 210 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1904.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....................................                                               $360. 59
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909....................... ...............................                                             4, 000.00
                                                                                                                   4,360.59
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.......-----..............................---------------------------------------.........-----....     180.37
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................                                   ..............-
                                                                                            -                      4, 180. 22

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .................    2, 640. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 33, 489. 48
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909---------------........----------.........------................... 17,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix K 8.)
   9. Harbor at Milford Haven, Virginia.-Milford Haven is a tidal
estuary of Chesapeake Bay, about 4 miles long and from one-half to
1 mile wide. The depth in the channel ranges from 6 to 15 feet,
and in the portion navigated by steamers is generally 9 feet or more.
The haven has two entrances, one at the northwest end from Hills
Bay, an arm of Piankatank River, and another at the southeast end,
from Chesapeake Bay. Both entrances are obstructed by bars. The
southeast entrance is exposed, and as the bar has a ruling depth of
but 3 feet is seldom used. The bar which obstructed the northwest
entrance had, before improvement, a ruling depth of 8 feet. A bar
also existed within the haven between Cricket Hill and Callis wharves,
with a ruling depth of about 8 feet.
   The project for this improvement, adopted March 3, 1899, and
modified in 1902, provides for securing channels 10 feet deep by a
minimum width of 200 feet through both bars, viz, at the northwest
entrance and between Cricket Hill and Callis wharves, at an estimated
cost of $17,500.
268          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                U.   S. ARMY.

   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $20,475.16, $113.65 of
which was applied to maintenance. The sum of $3,032.97 was recov-
ered as judgment from a failing contractor. As a result of this
expenditure channels of the full projected dimensions have been
dredged through both bars, and a jetty 333 feet long has been con-
structed to maintain the outer channel.
   For reasons given in his report herewith (Appendix K 9) the dis-
trict officer recommends that the existing jetty be extended about
800 feet at an estimated additional cost of $10,000, as an aid in main-
taining the dredged channels. This recommendation is concurred in
by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors and by the Chief
of Engineers.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low tide over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement was
10 feet. The mean range of tide is about 1.3 feet. The haven is
navigable throughout its entire length by vessels drawing 6 feet, and
Fitchett's wharf, about 3 miles above the northwest entrance, is the
highest point reached by the large steamers.
   The principal articles of commerce are oysters, fish, crabs, farm
produce, fertilizers, piles, hay and feedstuffs, lumber, building mate-
rials, flour, ice, and general merchandise. The receipts and shipments
during 1908 amounted to about 32,570 tons, and were estimated to be
worth about $908,600.
   The work done has been of considerable benefit to commerce and
navigation. Freight rates have, however, been advanced.
   It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation recommended
to the maintenance of the completed channels of the project by
dredging.
   The additional work proposed is for the purpose of extension of
benefits and maintenance of the work already done. It is antici-
pated that an appropriation of about $4,000 every eight years will
be required for maintenance.
   For reference to reports on examinations and surveys of this
locality, see page 211 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1904.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................                               $171. 46
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    Carried to surplus fund.---...... ................               ............        $57.81
    For maintenance of improvement...............                       ..............   113. 65
                                                                                                    171.46
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of imnprovement-......          ....................... d3, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix K 9.)
  a In addition to this amount the sum of $10,000 could be profitably expended in
extending the jetty, if authorized by Congress.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     269
    10. James River, Virginia.The original condition of the James,
before its improvement by the General Government was begun in
1870, was as follows:
    The ruling depth to the lower city line of Richmond was 7 feet at
mean low water. This depth obtained on Rocketts reef, immediately
below Richmond, and on Richmond bar, 2 miles below. Some 15
miles lower down, in Trents reach, was a shoal on which there was a
depth of only 8 feet. This, however, ceased to be an obstruction in
January, 1872, when the 5-mile reach in which it was situated was cut
off by the opening of Dutch Gap Canal.
   In addition to the above natural obstructions there were, in the 10
miles of river below Richmond, wrecks in the channel at Chaffins
Bluff and Graveyard reach, and obstructions placed during the civil
war at Warwick bar and Drewry Bluff, consisting at each locality of
a military bridge, lines of stone cribs, and sunken vessels. In addi-
tion to all these obstructions, the channel between Richmond and
Trents reach was in many places narrow and tortuous.
   Between Trents reach and City Point, a distance of 18z miles, the
ruling depth was 13 feet, which obtained near Varina or Aikens Land-
ing. Between City Point and the mouth of James River the ruling
depth was 15 feet, existing at Harrisons bar and Goose Ilill flats, then
43 and 76 miles, respectively, below Richmond.
    It was contemplated in the original project, adopted in 1870, to
secure a channel having a depth of 18 feet at high tide and a width of
180 feet. The amount expended prior to the adoption of the present
project was $763,000, which includes $23,000 appropriated in 1836
and 1852.
    The project under which the improvement is now being carried on
was adopted July 5, 1884. It provides for the formation by means
of regulation works and excavation of a channel between the mouth
of the river and the lower city line of Richmond, having a depth of
22 feet at mean low tide, and a width from the mouth to City Point
of 400 feet; thence to Drewry Bluff of 300 feet, and thence to Rich-
mond of 200 feet, at a total estimated cost of $4,500,000.
    The act of June 13, 1902, provided for extending the improvement
from the lower city line of Richmond to the head of navigation at the
docks, at an additional cost of $724,943.15. The work proposed
under this extension consists of excavating a channel about 3,300 feet
long and 200 feet wide, with a depth of 22 feet at mean low water.
    By act of March 3, 1905, the original project was further extended
to include the excavation of a turning basin at Richmond, by increas-
ing the width of the proposed improved channel to 400 feet for a
length of 600 feet, the depth to be 22 feet, at a cost not to exceed
$150,000. This makes the total estimated cost of the improvement
$5,374,943.15.
    The amount expended on the present project to June 30, 1909, was
$1,799,033.13, of which $57,799.86, expended subsequent to March 3,
1899, was for maintenance. This item of maintenance includes the
cost of dredging sand deposited in the channel by the river during the
execution of the work in excess of the quantity originally estimated;
also repairs to jetties.
    The improvement of the river has been chiefly confined to the upper
reaches, where the water was shoalest, and consequently where the
270     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMIVY.

greatest benefits to commerce would be obtained. The exceptions to
this were the dredging of shoals at Harrisons bar, Swans Point, and
Goose Hill flats to a depth of 18 feet.
   The project is estimated to be about one-third completed.
   The result of the work of improvement is a channel between Hamp-
ton Roads and the city wharf at Richmond, Va., having, with few
exceptions, a width of not less than 100 feet and a depth of 18 feet at
mean low water. The exceptions are Rocldanding shoal, about 89
miles below Richmond, with a depth of 16.1 feet; Dancing Point
shoal, about 60 miles below Richmond, with a depth of 16- feet, and
Willis, Varina, and Deep Bottom reaches, about 9 miles, 16 miles,
and 18 miles, respectively, below Richmond, the respective ruling
depths on which are 16.8, 17, and 17 feet.
   The work of maintenance during the year consisted in redredging
the channel at Warwick bar, about 4 miles below Richmond.
   The maximum draft that could be carried at low water on June
30, 1909, between the city wharf at Richmond and the mouth of the
river was 16.1 feet.
   The mean tidal range varies for different parts of the river, being
approximately as follows: 2 - feet at Fort Monroe, 1.85 feet at James-
town, 3 feet at City Point, 31 feet at Dutch Gap, and 4 feet at Rich-
mond.
   The channel length of the James River from Hampton Roads to
the head of navigation at Richmond, Va., is 103.8 miles.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance of funds to enlarging
the channel for about 11 miles from a point 800 feet below the
city line of Richmond, and for some 1,600 feet from a point about
21 miles below the same line, and to dredging and jetty work at
Willis, Kingsland, Varina, and Deep Bottom reaches, situated from
about 9 to 18 miles below Richmond.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance of
improvement by dredging; also to enlarging channel between Rich-
mond, Va., and the mouth of Appomattox River, by dredging and
extending existing regulation works, excavating a channel through
Dancing Point shoal, 300 feet wide by 22 feet deep at low water, and
excavating a channel through the south side of Rocklanding shoal,
400 feet wide by 22 feet deep at low water, for the extension of
benefits.
   The commerce of the river for the calendar year of 1908 amounted
to 256,298 tons at Richmond, Va., and 205,970 tons for landings
below, or an aggregate of 462,268 tons, a decrease of about 17 per
cent from the tonnage of 1907. The value of the freight trans-
ported amounted to $29,329,589.
   The decrease in tonnage in 1908 from that of 1907 is, to some
extent, attributable to the traffic in the latter year having been
increased on account of the Jamestown Exposition.
   The principal articles of commerce comprised coal, coal oil, cord
wood, lumber, fertilizer, and brick.
   The improvement of the river has been beneficial in lowering rail-
road freight rates and in reducing the cost of river transportation.
   Reports on examinations and surveys are found in Senate Execu-
tive Document No. 1, Thirty-third Congress, first session, Part 2,
1853, page 389, and in Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers of
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                    271
1875, page 74; of 1878, page 459; of 1882, page 870; of 1887, page
873; of 1890, page 996; of 1896, page 1010; and of 1900, page 1754.
   More extended information concerning the improvement is con-
tained in Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers of 1871, pages
603 to 605; of 1882, pages 870 to 887; and of 1900, pages 1757 to 1760.
   Maps of James River are contained in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1876, 1900, and 1904, and in House Document
No. 234, Fifty-sixth Congress, first session.
                                  GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..............................                .             $228, 118. 75
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ...................                   ........................                     10, 000. 00

                                                                                                  238, 118. 75
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ........................                       $140, 871. 44
    For maintenance of improvement...................                          3, 447. 94
                                                                                                  144, 319. 38

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................                  .................               93, 799. 37
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ............            .................                     1, 310. 42

July 1, 1909, balance available.....      . ..............            ................            92, 488. 95

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ... ........                              56, 129. 64
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                       3, 539, 910. 51
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
   the balance unexpended July 1, 1909...............              ... _                      500, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                       TURNING       BASIN.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................                        ......      $329. 63

June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improvement.                           329. 63
   (See Appendix K 10.)
   11. Construction of piers, Hampton Roads, Jamestown Exposition.-
The original project was adopted by act of Congress, approved
June 30, 1906, and provided for the construction, from plans fur-
nished by the Jamestown Exposition Company and approved by the
Secretary of War, of two piers extending from the exposition grounds
into the waters of Hampton Roads, the piers to be connected at their
outer ends by an arch sufficiently high to permit small craft to enter
under it into a basin or harbor to be dredged to a sufficient depth to
accommodate boats drawing not more than 10 feet at mean low tide,
at a total cost not to exceed $400,000.
   This project was modified by act of Congress approved February
9, 1907, which provided, in addition to the work described above, for
dredging a channel from deep water in Hampton Roads to the
government piers at the Jamestown Exposition, and for dredging in
Bush Creek to accommodate the needs of the life-saving exhibit, at
a cost not to exceed $65,000.
272       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                             U.   S. ARMY.


   Actual construction work on the piers was begun during December,
1906, and was pushed continuously from that time until completed
in September, 1907.
   The total amount expended was $447,669.44.
   On September 14, 1907, the piers were transferred to the James-
town Exposition Company, in accordance with the terms of the act
of Congress.
   The balance of appropriations, amounting to $17,330.56, reverted
to the Treasury on October 26, 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ... ............. ......         ... ..-.          $18, 416. 96
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year............ .........               1, 086. 40

Reverted to the Treasury............    .......   . .. ...................              17, 330. 56
   (See Appendix K 11.)
   12. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering
navigation-(a) Wreck of pile driver in the Pamunkey River, Virginia.-
By letter dated May 11, 1908, Mr. H. T. Faunt Le Roy reported
the existence of a sunken pile driver at Cumberland Landing on the
Pamunkey River at a point where the river was narrow and currents
unfavorable, the wreck thus constituting a "great menace to
navigation."
   Subsequent correspondence and examinations established the fact
that the party responsible for this wreck was Mr. E. Wilkinson, of
West Point, Va. The wreck was removed by Mr. Wilkinson on
July 7, 1908. The incidental cost of the inspections was $25.
    (b) Seven wrecks on the flats of the Anacostia River.-Seven aban-
doned coal barges, canal boats, etc., have been beached for several
years on the flats of Anacostia River, near the outlet of James Creek
Canal. Two of these barges were floated on high water during
May, 1908, across the Anacostia River and lodged on the riprap
wall of the area to be reclaimed.
   In order that the remaining five barges should not under like
circumstances be floated and become a menace to navigation, their
destruction was authorized. The barges were burned to the water's
edge, and the two that had lodged on the riprap wall were placed on
the area to be reclaimed.
   The cost of the work was $50.
    (c) Wreck of barge in Alexandria Harbor, Virginia.-During the
examination of the harbor of Alexandria certain persons stated
that in their opinion the wreck of a barge was the cause of the
shoaling along the water front of Alexandria, Va. The work was
done after public notice and written acceptance between June 15
and August 6, 1908. Nothing of value was obtained.
   The cost of removal and incidental expenses were $1,000, of which
amount $75.33 were expended in the fiscal year 1908.
    (d) Wreck of schooner E. G. Irwin, off Point Lookout, at the mouth
of Potomac River, Maryland.- This wreck was reported on September
15, 1908, to be a menace to navigation, and this report was confirmed
by an examination. The work was done by government plant and
hired labor between November 11 and 21, 1908, at the cost of $700.
    The total expenditure during the year on the removal of wrecks in
this district was $1,699.67.
    (See Appendix K 12.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     273
EXAMINATION AND SURVEY MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE RIVER
          AND HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports dated July 26, 1907, and October 14, 1908, on preliminary
examination and survey, respectively, of Potomac River at Alexandria,
Va., with a view to the removal of a bar recentlyformed, required by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, were duly submitted by the
district officer. They were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for
Rivers and Harbors, pursuant to law, and were transmitted to
Congress and printed in House Document No. 1253, Sixtieth Congress,
second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of
$116,000 is presented.

IMPROVEMENT      OF   RIVERS    AND   HARBORS      IN   THE   NORFOLK,
                        VIRGINIA, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Maj. Joseph E. Kuhn, Corps
of Engineers. Division engineer, Col. Dan C. Kingman, Corps of
Engineers.
   1. Harbor at Norfolk and its approaches, Virginia.-(a) General
improvement.-In its original condition the main channel of this
harbor was at mean low water navigable by vessels of 20 feet draft
as far as the navy-yard, on the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth
River, while in the Eastern Branch of this river there was a channel
15 feet in depth at mean low water as far as the Campostella bridge.
These channels were of varying width.
   The original project of improvement was adopted in 1878, revised
in 1885, and amended in 1890, 1898, and 1905. It included the attain-
ment of a channel from 500 to 700 feet wide and 25 feet deep at mean
low water from Hampton Roads to the navy-yard, a branch channel
22 feet deep at the same stage of the tide to the Campostella bridge
on the Eastern Branch, and, within the limits of the first-named
channel, a channel 450 feet wide and 28 feet deep at mean low water
from deep water in Hampton Roads to the navy-yard. There has
also been included in the project the excavation of an anchorage at
the mouth of the Western Branch, having an area of 56 acres and a
depth of 25 feet at mean low water, and the dredging, to the depth of
28 feet at mean low water, of the area between the western edge of
the main channel and a line 75 feet outside of the established pierhead
line, along the railroad docks at Pinner Point. The cost of all this
work was estimated at $1,623,790.98.
   The existing project of improvement is the original project modified
from time to time as stated above, under which the first appropria-
tion for work was made August 14, 1876.
   To June 30, 1909, there had been expended on this existing project
$1,669,862.63, of which sum $51,052.16 was for work of maintenance.
The sum of $24.71 has been derived from the sale of property and
blueprints.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year was in payment of
outstanding liabilities due for new work at the close of the fiscal year
1908, and for expenses of an examination made of the area dredged
in that fiscal year.
   On June 30, 1909, the project is about 99.5 per cent completed, the
only work remaining to be done being the dredging of a strip 20
     9001-ENG 1909-18
274       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                           S. ARMY.

feet wide and 2,600 feet long from the south side of the channel in
the Eastern Branch between the Norfolk and Western Railroad and
Campostella highway bridges, for which purpose the estimate for com-
pletion has been increased by $5,000.
   On June 30, 1909, the main channel of the harbor was available at
mean low water for vessels of 28 feet draft as far as the navy-yard,
which is located about 10 miles from deep water in Hampton Roads.
The Eastern Branch channel is available at mean low water for ves-
sels drawing 22 feet as far as the Campostella bridge, about 11 miles
from deep water in Hampton Roads. The normal range of the tide
is 2.7 feet.
   The Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River is navigable as far as
the Albemarle and Chesapeake Canal locks, a distance of about 11
miles above the confluence of the Eastern and Southern branches of
this river. The Eastern Branch is navigable for about 5 miles above
this confluence. From this confluence to deep water in Hampton
Roads the distance by the main river is about 9 miles.
   For the calendar year 1908 the water-borne shipments aggregated
about 11,746,746 tons, valued at about $843,563,326. The chief
products handled are coal, cotton, fertilizer, lumber, and agricultural
products. The improvement has made Norfolk an important ship-
ping point for bituminous coal from the West Virginia fields, and a
new railroad, the Virginian, recently completed, commenced loading
cargo and bunker coal at its pier on the Elizabeth River in April last.
   It has not been found practicable to ascertain what effects, if any,
the improvement has had on freight rates.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, will be applied in removing a small shoal
west of the Norfolk and Western Railway bridge across the Eastern
Branch, and in completing the project by dredging between the
Norfolk and Western Railway and Campostella bridges.
   For more extended information and maps, see Reports of Chief of
Engineers for 1880,page 815; 1885, page 1018; 1887, page 969; and
1893, page 1323. For reference to examinations and surveys, see
Report of Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 238.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................                $3, 863. 38
Received from sales during fiscal year .................................                  3. 50
                                                                                     3, 866. 88
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment....................................................................           3, 863. 38

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......-......   ....................                    3. 50

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........            5, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909........ .. . ...............            10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (b) Hospital Point.-The land of this point is the property of the
United States, and a part of the grounds used by the Navy Depart-
ment as a site for a hospital. The main channel of Norfolk Harbor
passes in front of and close to this point.
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                               275
   The project for this work, adopted in 1902, required the cutting off
of 450 feet of the point, the construction of a sea wall and wharf, and
the dredging of the area on both sides of the old point. The depth
to be secured in the dredging was to be the same as that of the har-
bor-25 feet at mean low water. The estimated cost of the work was
$193,957, all of which has been appropriated.
  On June 30, 1909, the expenditures had amounted to $193,957,
and had resulted in the completion of the project. Of the amount
expended, $6,392.39 was applied toward maintaining the project
depth.
  During the fiscal year dredging was done over a portion of the
shoaled area south of the point.
  The amount required in the fiscal year 191.1 will be applied to
dredging the balance of the shoaled area to the project depth..
  The statements in the previous section of this report regarding the
character and volume of the commerce affected by the improvement
of Norfolk Harbor, and as to the tidal range, state of navigability
of the harbor, and the effect of the improvement on freight rates,
apply to this section also.
  A report upon an examination of this work will be found at page
964, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1889; and in the
report for 1897, page 1335 et seq., full details of the project, with
maps explanatory thereof, are given.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......... .........................     $6, 392. 39
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement...........................................................  6, 392. 39
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement.................. ............      5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Thirty-foot channel.-As noted in section (a) above, the exist-
ing ship channel affords a 28-foot navigation, 450 feet wide, from
Hampton Roads to the junction of the Southern and Eastern branches.
   Under a project adopted March 2, 1907, the existing ship channel
is to be deepened to 30 feet and to be given a width of 600 feet from
Hampton Roads to Lambert Point and 800 feet from Lambert Point
to the junction of the Eastern and Southern branches of the Elizabeth
River. This project also includes the removal of the shoals at the
mouth of the Eastern Branch to a depth of 25 feet and a width of
500 feet. The estimated cost of the project is $1,132,000.
   The expenditures to June 30, 1909, have amounted to $261,281.62.
   The sum of $16.15 has been received from sales.
   During the fiscal year dredging was continued under the above-
stated project on the sections of the channel between Lambert Point
and Craney Island light, and the dredging of the sections between
Craney Island light and Bush Bluff light-ship and between Lambert
and Pinner points was started. At the close of the fiscal year work
was still in progress on all of the above-mentioned sections.
   This project is in progress under a continuing-contract authoriza-
tion, for which the sum of $525,000 still remains to be appropriated.
   On June 30, 1909, the project was about 40 per cent completed.
The work accomplished consisted in the removal of the shoals at the
mouth of the Eastern Branch and the partial excavation of the new
276          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                  S. ARMY.

30-foot channel between Pinner Point and Bush Bluff light. Work
on the new 30-foot channel has not yet progressed sufficiently to
determine its effect upon commerce. Vessels have recently departed
at high tide drawing 31 feet.
   The statements contained in section (a) above regarding the char-
acter and volume of commerce, tidal range, and state of navigability
of the channel apply to this section also.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, will be applied to dredging under the
existing project for the purpose of extending the benefits of the
improvement.
   Reports, with maps, upon examinations of this improvement will
be found in House Documents Nos. 373 and 381, Fifty-ninth Con-
gress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................... $318, 234. 09
                                                                             16. 15
Received from sales during fiscal year--..----------.......------......------......
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909 ......200, 000. 00

                                                                               518, 250. 24
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  m ent.................---............. .......... ......
                                                       .... ...... ......      172,515. 71

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended............ ..... .................. 345, 734. 53
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.................................... 17, 169. 56

July 1, 1909, balance available..--------...                                   328, 564. 97
                                                     -------.......-..- ...-....
                                               -------....

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts... . . ..   . .. . . 330, 249. 78
                                                                  --- -- 525, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project--..-
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1,1909.....------------------------------------------------
                                    ..........                                 150, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
   (See Appendix L 1.)
   2. Western branch of Elizabeth River, Virginia.-The channel of the
river, when the project for improvement was adopted, was 12 feet
deep at mean low water and from 50 to 300 feet wide.
   The project adopted June 3, 1896, provided for obtaining, by dredg-
ing, a channel 200 feet wide and 20 feet deep at mean low water for a
distance of about 1 mile from deep water in Norfolk Harbor. The
estimated cost was $45,000, all of which has been appropriated.
   Up to June 30, 1909, the sum of $44,671.65 has been expended on
this improvement, the result being the completion of the project.
   It is proposed to utilize the available balance in maintaining the
improvement.
   A draft of 19 feet at mean low water can be carried in the improved
channel. The average rise and fall of the tide is 2.7 feet.
   This stream is navigable for small sailboats to farms situated about
9 miles from its mouth.
   The commerce in the main consists of manufactured lumber, ore,
and farm products. For the calendar year 1908 it is reported to have
amounted to 1,830,617 tons, valued at $44,892,006.
   It has not been found possible to ascertain what effect, if any, the
improvement has had upon freight rates.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMIPROVEMENTS.                                                              277
  For reference to list of reports on examinations of this stream, see
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 240.
  The balance of funds available will be applied to maintaining the
channel by dredging.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended---------...---....---------....--------..............------....                         $328. 35
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909...............---------.----....---.......--------.............---------------................--------------- 5, 000. 00

                                                                                                                     5, 328. 35
June 30, 1909, turned into surplus fund..........----------------.....--............                                    328. 35
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                                                   5, 000. 00
    (See Appendix L 2.)
  3. Hampton Roads, Virginia.-Before improvement, vessels of more
than 25 feet draft could not reach Newport News on account of the
shoal in Hampton Roads, known locally as "Middle Ground bar."
  Under an item in the act of June 13, 1902, provision was made for
dredging a channel through the Middle Ground bar 500 feet wide and
30 feet deep at mean low water. The estimated cost of the work was
$225,000.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $228,572.10 had been expended on the work,
$3,572 of which was for maintenance. The project had been com-
pleted.
   During the fiscal year dredging was in progress, and at its close had
not been completed. The purpose of this work is to give the section
of the channel originally dredged its project depth over the required
width, shoaling having occurred on the easterly side of its northern
end.
   On June 30, 1909, vessels of 30 feet draft could navigate the chan-
nel safely. The average tidal range is 2.5 feet.
   The head of navigation via this channel is at Richmond, Va., on the
James River, a distance of about 105 miles up the river.
   The amount of commerce when the improvement was undertaken
in 1902 amounted to 2,663,669 tons. For the calendar year 1908 it is
reported to have amounted to 6,354,774 tons, valued at $432,472,181.
The bulk of the tonnage is in coal and grain.
   It has not been found practicable to ascertain what effect, if any,
the improvement has had upon freight rates.
   It is proposed to expend, under an existing contract, the available
balance in maintaining the project depth and width of channel for
the purpose of keeping the improvement available.
   For reference as to reports on examinations and surveys, see Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 240.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. .......................                            .... ........      . $12, 416. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement---..-...........---------.----------------............--......----------...........--....     3, 488. 19

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended -...-.... --......------------..............----........                            8, 927.90
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities............  . ...... ............. ....                                       2, 508. 42

July 1, 1909, balance available.......                           --...............   -     ...........               6, 419. 48

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................                                                4, 234. 95
    (See Appendix L 3.)
278         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                              U. S. ARMY.


   4. Nansemond River, Virginia.-The original channel of this stream
permitted it to be navigated at mean low water by vessels drawing
not more than 5 feet. The depth was increased to 8 feet at the same
stage of tide under appropriations made between 1873 and 1878 at a
cost of $37,000.
   The project under which the work has been carried on until recently
was adopted August 11, 1888, and called for a channel 100 feet wide
from Suffolk, the head of navigation, to the Western Branch, while
from the latter place to Town Point its width was to vary from 200
to 400 feet. The depth to be obtained throughout was 12 feet at mean
low water. This improvement was estimated to cost $152,500.
   At present it is contemplated to provide a channel only 80 feet wide
and 12 feet deep at mean low water between Suffolk and Town Point,
which is now deemed ample for the commerce of the stream.
   Up to June 30, 1909, the expenditures under the project of 1888 and
its modification have amounted to $54,767.71, of which amount
$14,090.60 has been applied to maintenance. The channel between
Suffolk and the Western Branch has been dredged to 80 feet in width
and 12 feet in depth at mean low water, and a turning basin has been
excavated at the former place. The project is about 67 per cent
completed.
   Work on maintaining the channel in the vicinity of the mouth of
the Western Branch was done under a contract for dredging in that
section of the river during the fiscal year.
   At the close of the fiscal year a boat drawing 11 feet at mean low
water could reach Suffolk, the head of navigation, 18 miles above the
mouth of the river. The tidal variations are about 3 feet at Town
Point and 3.8 feet at Suffolk.
   The commerce of the stream consists principally of lumber, agricul-
tural products, and merchandise. In 1890 it is reported to have
reached about 220,000 tons. For the calendar year 1908 it is reported
to have amounted to 132,292 tons, valued at $3,651,525.
   It has not been found practicable to ascertain what effect, if any,
the improvement has had upon freight rates.
   The small balance unexpended and the amount estimated as a
profitable expenditure for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, will be
applied toward maintaining the improvement.
   For reference to list of reports of examinations and surveys, see
Report of Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 241.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended---.....--------                                ---  --------..
                                                                          ----..-.....          $5, 039. 84
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement............................................................                        4, 807. 55

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..............                              ..........
                                                                       ............                232. 29

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                        10, 269. 50

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
  expended July 1, 1909 -............................................. 5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix L 4.)
  65. Pagan River, Virginia.-Originallythe shoals in this stream
limited the draft of vessels to 6 feet at mean low water. Under a
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                       279
project adopted in 1880 the sum of $10,000 was expended in dredging
a channel 60 feet wide and 8 feet deep at mean low water through
three shoals between the mouth and Smithfield, Va.
   The project upon which was based the appropriation of $10,870 in
the act of June 13, 1902, provided for obtaining a channel from
Smithfield to the mouth of the river 80 feet wide and 8 feet deep at
mean low water. The estimated cost was $28,870. This project was
modified by the act of March 3, 1905, which authorized the expendi-
ture of the balance remaining of the appropriation of 1902 in securing
a channel not less than 40 feet wide and of such depth as might be
obtained without exceeding said balance. In the project submitted
under the above-cited provision of law it was stated that the unex-
pended balance would provide such a channel 10 feet in depth at
mean low water.
   Up to June 30, 1909, the expenditures had amounted to $10,671.01,
and the project had been completed.
   There is now a navigable channel 40 feet wide and 10 feet in depth
at mean low water from the mouth of the river for a distance of about
9 miles to Smithfield, the head of navigation. The average range of
the tide is 2.6 feet.
   The commerce is handled by numerous small schooners and sloops
and two regular steamers, and consists largely of peanuts and oysters.
   The commerce of this stream has averaged about 100,000 tons a
year, but has varied considerably from year to year, according to
whether conditions have or have not been favorable to the produc-
tion of peanuts and oysters. For the calendar year 1908 it is reported
to have amounted to 84,108 tons, valued at $14,100,400.
   It has not been found practicable to ascertain what effect, if any,
the improvement has had upon freight rates.
   Reports upon examinations and surveys of this river will be found
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1875, Part 2, page
156, and for 1901, page 1174; also in House Document No. 397,
Sixtieth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................      $198. 99
June 30, 1909, amount covered into surplus fund .......................    198. 99
   (See Appendix L 5.)
   6. Appomattox River, Virginia.-(a) General improvement.-The
original channel in this river was narrow and tortuous, and numerous
shoals prevented vessels drawing more than 61 feet from navigating
it at mean high water.
   The original project, which is also the existing project, was adopted
in 1871 and revised in 1893. The project as revised covers the attain-
ment and maintenance of a channel 80 feet wide and 12 feet deep at
mean high water between Point of Rocks and Petersburg. The cost
of providing this channel was estimated at $471,920 and its mainte-
nance at $10,000 annually.
   On June 30, 1909, the sum of $465,288.76 had been expended
toward the improvement and the sum of $52,434.97 for maintenance.
   The amount reported as expended during the fiscal year was
applied to improving by dredging the channel between Petersburg
and a point about 41 miles below and in maintaining the channel by
removing shoals formed by the freshet of 1908. The project is about
completed and future work will be toward maintenance.
280            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                          S. ARMY.

   At the present time the channel of the river is available at high
water for vessels of about 9 feet draft, the normal range of the tide
being about 2.6 feet. The head of navigation is Petersburg, Va.,
about 11 miles from the mouth of the river.
   The commerce consists of lumber and miscellaneous products. In
1890 it amounted to about 20,000 tons. It gradually increased until
in 1900 and 1901 it amounted to about 150,000 tons. Since then it
has decreased, and for the calendar year 1908 it is reported to have
been 31,830 tons.
   It is proposed to expend the balance now available in removing
material brought down by freshets and deposited in the navigable
channel of the river. This work is required to render the navigable
channel available in the interests of commerce. Work will be com-
menced early in the next fiscal year, a contract having been awarded
for the work.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, will be applied toward the removal of
material deposited in the navigable channel by freshets, for the
purpose of maintaining the improvement.
   An examination of this stream was made in 1852, to which refer-
ence is made in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1870,
page 68. A survey was made in 1870 and the report published in
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for that year, com-
mencing at page 68. An examination, with plan and estimate, was
made in compliance with act of March 2, 1907, and the report will
be found in House Document No. 952, Sixtieth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................                                          $49, 192. 23
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909---...........-----.--...............................------------------------------........--..    5, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation for emergencies in river and har-
  bor works, act of March 2, 1907...................... ...                                              -...... 10, 000. 00
                                                                                                         .....

                                                                                                              64, 192. 23
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For maintenance of improvement ........--....--
                                          --          .........     $43, 917. 66
    Repaid to appropriation for emergencies in river and
      harbor works-....... ............. .... ...........       ...   6, 800. 00
                                                                                                              50, 717. 66

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...........-.........................                                     .   13, 474. 57
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities-.....-- -.............-
                                                    -             .........
                                                              ...--                                            3,171. 55

July 1, 1909, balance available.............                       ....................         .......       10, 303. 02

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. - --...............                                     4, 633. 65

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909------------..--------------------------.......                                           5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) At Petersburg.-The project for the work contemplated is not
to provide a navigable channel, but to excavate a new channel into
which to deflect the river, and thus overcome the trouble experienced
by the deposit of sediment in the navigable channel of the river in
the neighborhood of Petersburg.
  The project for this work, which was adopted June 13, 1902, con-
templates the excavation to mean low water of a cut from 200 to 300
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                               281

feet wide and 2 miles long and the diversion of the river into the
said cut by means of a dam built across the present channel at the
head of the harbor of Petersburg, and includes the construction of
bridges for the highways and railway crossing the new channel and
other incidental work. The estimate for the work was $200,000,
which amount has been provided.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, authorized a contract
for the completion of the diversion work at a cost of $60,000, yet to
be appropriated.
   At the close of the fiscal year 1909 the sum of $186,199.88 had
been expended, all of the land needed has been purchased, the high-
way and railway bridges have been built, the new cut excavated,
except where rock was encountered, and the dam across the Appo-
mattox River built to a height of 9.5 feet above diversion low water.
The expenditures during the fiscal year were applied to payment for
work done under contract. The project is completed as far as avail-
able funds permit.
   It has not been found possible to ascertain what effect, if any, the
improvement has had upon freight rates.
   The balance of funds will be applied to completing the work under
the adopted project, provided funds are appropriated for the addi-
tional work of excavating rock and earth, revetting banks, raising
levee, and raising height of dam. The amount estimated for mainte-
nance will be applied to repairing and revetting levee.
   The commerce to be affected by the improvement contemplated is
the same as that mentioned in the preceding section, and all general
statements made therein apply equally well to this section.
   A report upon an examination and survey will be found in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1882, page 907. An-
other report, with a map, will be found in the Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1889, page 957. Other reports will be found in the
Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1893, page 1345, and
for 1901, page 1467.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................     $64, 818. 41
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.........................  ............. ........................ 51, 018. 29

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................     .................   13, 800. 12

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........      60, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
    For works of improvement ..........................     $60, 000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement ...................         5, 000. 00
                                                                             65,000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June, 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix L 6.)
   7. Harbor at Cape Charles City, Va.-The harbor proper is land-
locked and covers an area of 10 acres, and it and the exposed chan-
nels leading thereto had, before the beginning of the work, a depth of
12 feet at mean low water.
  The project was adopted in 1890 and requires the dredging of a
channel through Cherrystone Inlet and bar 100 and 200 feet wide,
respectively, and 16 feet deep at mean low water, the dredging of an
282           REPORT OF THE CHIEF                    OF ENGINEERS,      U. S. ARMY.

entrance channel 100 feet wide of the same depth, and dredging over
the entire area of the protected and inclosed harbor to a depth of 14
feet at mean low water. Jetties of stone were to be constructed for
the protection of the channel leading into the basin. This work was
estimated to cost $142,340.
   The expenditures to June 30, 1909, amounted to $119,033.71, and
resulted in the dredging and redredging of one-half of the inner harbor
to the proper depth and the excavation of channels of the required
dimensions through the inlet and the entrance to the basin and the
construction of 875 feet of the north jetty and 232 feet of the south
jetty. The north jetty is 1,625 feet in length, but 750 feet of this was
built without expense to the United States. Of the amount expended,
$13,360.16 was applied to maintenance. The project is about 85 per
cent completed.
   On June 30, 1909, a vessel drawing 12 feet could enter the harbor
at mean low water. The docks within the landlocked harbor are
about 3 miles from the 16-foot contour in Chesapeake Bay at Cherry-
stone bar. The range of the tide is about 2.5 feet.
   The commerce consists mainly of miscellaneous freight, agricul-
tural products, fertilizer, and some oysters and fish. At the begin-
ning of the improvement the annual commerce was about 400,000
tons. For the calendar year 1908 it is reported to have amounted to
1,811,731 tons, valued at $45,293,275. It has not been found prac-
ticable to ascertain what effect, if any, the improvement has had
upon freight rates.
   The available balance and amounts estimated for will be applied
to dredging under the adopted project, and in maintaining the im-
provement for the benefit of existing commerce.
   For more extended information, see Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1890, page 975.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                   $30, 401. 11
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.......... ................                  $11, 074. 66
    For maintenance of improvement. ....................                  13, 360. 16
                                                                                         24, 434. 82

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                        5, 966. 29

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                 30, 700. 16

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909................           ...........   25, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix L 7.)
   8. Waterway from Norfolk, Va., to the sounds of North Carolina.-
This waterway extends from Norfolk, Va., via the Southern Branch
of the Elizabeth River to Deep Creek, thence through the Dismal
Swamp Canal to South Mills, N. C., and from the latter point through
Turners Cut to the Pasquotank River, to Albemarle Sound, and thence
to Pamlico Sound by Croatan Sound.
  The draft which could be carried through this waterway at the
time of the adoption of the project for improvement was limited to
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                             283
21 feet at mean low water, owing to the deterioration of the Dismal
Swamp Canal, which originally had had a depth of about 6 feet.
   The project, adopted March 3, 1899, provides for the dredging of
channels in Deep Creek, Turners Cut, through a shoal in the Pas-
quotank River near Ship Yard bar, and through a bar in Croatan
Sound near Croatan light. All these channels, except the last named,
were to be 100 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water. The
Croatan channel was to be 200 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean low
water. For the protection of these channels sheet piling was to be
driven where necessary. The estimated cost of this work was
$274,310.
   Up to June 30, 1909, the sum of $251,196.46 had been expended
on the project and $9,090.91 on its maintenance. The project has
been completed, and the additional work required is for maintenance.
   The amount reported as expended during the fiscal year for main-
tenance was applied toward expenses of inspections of the water
route made from time to time, dredging in Deep Creek, Virginia, and
removing sunken obstructions in the Pasquotank River, North
Carolina.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, will be applied toward removal of obstruc-
tions and toward dredging for the purpose of maintaining the improve-
ment.
   On June 30, 1909, vessels drawing 10 feet of water can at mean
low water navigate through all sections of the route which have been
improved by the United States. The canal which extends from
Deep Creek to South Mills, is maintained at the expense of a private
corporation, which tries to keep it available for vessels of 10 feet
draft, but on June 30, 1908, the limiting depth for the entire route
was only 9 feet, owing to the existence of shoal places in the canal.
Deep Creek is the only tidal portion of the improvement, and there
the rise and fall averages 3 feet. In the other sections the water
level changes according to the direction and velocity of the wind.
The route is about 67 miles in length.
   The commerce for the calendar year 1908 is reported to have
amounted to 319,573 tons, valued at $5,613,700. The main items
of commerce are coal, fertilizer, timber, and farm products.
   It has not been found practicable to ascertain what effect, if any,
the improvement has had upon freight rates.
   For list of reports of examinations and surveys, see Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 246.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............................        ........... $4, 820. 40
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ................. ...................................              2, 237. 77
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................................           2, 582. 63
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.......................................       1, 107.22
July 1, 1909, balance available........................................            1, 475. 41
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 .................           ....      ........ ..........   5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix L 8.)
284     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   9. Inland water route from Norfolk, Va., to Albemarle Sound,
North Carolina, through Currituckc Sound.-This route extends from
Norfolk, Va., to Albemarle Sound, via the Southern Branch of the
Elizabeth River, Albemarle and Chesapeake Canal, North Landing
River, Currituck Sound, Coanjock Bay, North Carolina Cut, and
North River. The canal and cut mentioned are now controlled by a
pivate corporation.
   This route had originally a good 5-foot mean low-water channel,
but navigation was obstructed by snags, sunken logs, and overhang-
ing trees. Sharp bends added to the other difficulties of navigation.
   Until the act of September 19, 1890, the work of improvement was
carried on under several separate projects, upon which a total of
$240,169.69 had been expended. By that act all these projects were
consolidated.
   The present project, adopted September 19, 1890, provides for
obtaining a channel 80 feet wide and 9 feet deep at mean low water
through the whole extent of the waterway to be improved by the
United States, at an estimated cost of $306,667.08, including the pre-
vious expenditures above mentioned. The project is considered as
complete, the additional work required being for maintenance. Since
September 19, 1890, and up to June 30, 1909, the sum of $61,987.64
has been expended upon this improvement and $33,234.30 upon
maintenance.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year were applied to mainte-
nance.
   The work consisted in keeping the waterway clear of sunken
obstructions.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, will be applied in maintaining the im-
provement by keeping the various channels clear of logs, snags, and
similar obstructions, and in redredging parts of the channel through
Currituck Sound where these have deteriorated.
   The channels through the various portions of the route are now
from 60 to 80 feet wide and have a depth of 9 feet at mean low water.
The draft of vessels which can pass through the route at mean low
water on June 30, 1909, is 9 feet. The route is about 67 miles long.
   There is no lunar tide in any portion of the route, except in the
Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, where the average rise and
fall is 2.7 feet. In the other sections the water level varies according
to the velocity and direction of the wind, for which an allowance of
0.5 foot is made, but severe storms may cause an elevation or de-
pression of 2 feet or more.
   The commerce has varied considerably since the route was opened
to navigation. The highest reported was for the calendar year 1890,
when it amounted to 403,111 tons. Since that time it has decreased
considerably, and for the calendar year 1908 it amounted to 133,081
tons; value not known. The principal items of shipment consist of
coal, fertilizer, and timber products.
   The gradual decrease in the commerce of the route is due to the
depletion of the forests and the consequent decrease in timber ship-
ments.
   It has not been found possible to ascertain what effect, if any, the
improvement has had upon freight rates.
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                      285
  Considerable difficulty is experienced in keeping this waterway free
from obstructions by logs dropped from rafts due to the improper
construction of the rafts, and, in the absence of any adequate laws
permitting the Engineer Department to control the construction of
rafts, it has been found impossible to prevent the frequent occurrence
of these obstructions.
   For references as to examinations and surveys, see Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 247.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............   ..................    $1, 827.16
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909................... .........-.....   ...................  1, 500. 00
                                                                                     3, 327. 16
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ........................... .........   ................               1, 478.10

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........---    .......      ................       1, 849.06
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 ..                                                 10, 000. 00
                                                                       ..........
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix L 9.)
   10. Perquimans River, North Carolina.-Before work was begun
navigation was obstructed by numerous stumps just below the town
of Hertford, N. C., which limited the draft of vessels to 7 feet.
   The first appropriation for the Perquimans River was made in
1876, and was based on a project to provide a channel 200 feet wide
with a depth of 91 feet at mean low water through a stumpy reach
near Hertford, N. C., and the amount provided ($2,500) was expended
in obtaining said channel, which was completed in 1877.
   The existing project, adopted by Congress March 3, 1905, was to
provide a channel 200 feet wide and 9 feet deep at mean low water
through the stumpy reach about 800 feet below Hertford, N. C., at
an estimated cost of $11,250.
   To June 30, 1909, $11,168.06 had been expended, and all the work
contemplated has been completed.
   On June 30, 1909, vessels drawing 9 feet can, at mean low water,
reach the town of Hertford.
   There is no lunar tide in the river, the level of the surface of the
water varying according to the direction and velocity of the wind.
The average difference in elevation is about one-half foot, but storms
may cause a difference of as much as 2 feet or more. The head of
navigation is at Newby's bridge, about 26 miles from the mouth of
the river.
   An estimate in 1902 placed the commerce at about 36,000 tons,
and for the calendar year 1908 it is reported to have amounted to
13,100 tons, valued at $660,000. The principal items of freight
transported were lumber, logs, fertilizer, and cotton seed.
   It has not been found practicable to ascertain what effect, if any,
the improvement has had upon freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................................     $81.94
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.........................................               81. 94
   (See Appendix L 10.)
286            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                          S. ARMY.


   11. Blackwater River, Virginia.-In its original condition this
stream afforded a natural channel of 7 feet depth, but navigation was
difficult owing to the existence of obstructions and sharp bends.
   Between 1878 and 1882 Congress appropriated a total of $14,000
for the improvement of the stream, to consist of the removal of logs,
snags, overhanging trees, and the removal of sharp bends. Opera-
tions ceased in 1884, from which time no work was done upon the
river to 1908.
   The existing project was adopted March 2, 1907, and provides for
the clearing of the stream of the existing obstructions so as to afford
a condition of easy navigation. The estimated cost of the project is
$8,000, all of which has been appropriated.
   To June 30, 1909, there had been expended $2,144.33 on the exist-
ing project, which is completed, and $988.26 has been expended for
maintenance. During the fiscal year work was confined to mainte-
nance in removing sunken obstructions. The available balance will
be expended in maintaining the improvement as may be found nec-
essary from time to time.
   The sum of $15 has been received from sales.
   On June 30, 1909, vessels drawing 7 feet can navigate the river.
The river is a tideless stream, and the only fluctuations in the water
level are those due to freshets, which usually do not exceed 3 to 4
feet. The river is navigable from the railroad bridge at Franklin,
Va., to its mouth, a distance of about 13 miles.
   During the calendar year 1908 the commerce amounted to 5,390
tons, valued "at $862,400. The principal items consisted of agricul-
tural products, timber, and fertilizer.
   It is impracticable to state what effect, if any, has been made by
the improvement upon freight rates.
   For more extended information, see Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1875, part 2, page 161, and report of an examination printed
in House Document No. 177, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ----..................................                                       $5, 855. 67
Received from sales during fiscal year...................................                                          15. 00

                                                                                                               5, 870. 67
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.............................................   ....... ..                                          988.26

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended----------.....................--------------..........---------               4, 882. 41
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..---------......------..---.....---.................-------------....        23.40

July 1, 1909, balance available--..-------------------...------........---..-----.........                     4, 859. 01
    (See Appendix L 11.)
   12. Meherrin River, North Carolina.-Inits original condition this
stream afforded a navigable channel about 80 feet wide and 7 feet
deep from its mouth to the town of Murfreesboro, N. C. The chan-
nel was tortuous and badly obstructed by logs, overhanging trees, and
a few shoals.
   In the year 1882 Congress appropriated $5,000 toward the improve-
ment of the river, the improvement to consist in the removal of the
obstructions to navigation, and operations were carried on from time
to time in the years 1883 to 1886, inclusive. The total expenditure
amounted to $4,584.53.
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                287
   The existing project was adopted by Congress March 2, 1907. It
provides for the removal of existing obstructions in the nature of
sunken logs, overhanging trees, and a few shoals, so as to render navi-
gation easy. The estimated cost of the project is $6,000, all of which
has been appropriated.
   To June 30, 1909, there had been expended on the existing project
$1,932.88, which is completed. The sum expended for maintenance
is $1,412.42. During the present fiscal year the maintenance work
was confined to the removal of sunken obstructions. It is proposed
to expend the available balance in maintaining the improvement as
may be found necessary from time to time.
   The sum of $10 has been received from sales.
   On June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that could be carried with
safety was 7 feet. The river is a tideless stream, but freshets cause
variations in the water level of 3 to 4 feet. The head of navigation is
at Murfreesboro, 11 miles above the mouth of the river.
   During the calendar year 1908 the commerce of the river aggregated
8,690 tons, valued at $1,086,700. The principal items of shipment are
timber products and general merchandise.
   It is impracticable to state what effect, if any, the improvement has
had on freight rates.
   For more extended information,see Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1882, page 1114, and report of examination printed in House
Document No. 137, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................         ..   $4, 067. 12
Received from sales during fiscal year .................----................          10. 00
                                                                                  4, 077. 12
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement...................................................                  1, 412. 42

July 1, balance unexpended ........................           ................    2, 664. 70
   (See Appendix L 12.)
   13. Roanoke River, North Carolina. Originally the navigable
channel to Indian Highland bar, 67 miles above the mouth, was 10
feet deep at mean low water, and thence to the town of Weldon, which
is 129 miles from the mouth, the minimum depth was 2- feet at the
same stage.
   The project, adopted in 1871, contemplates a channel with a least
width of 50 feet from Hamilton to Weldon, 5 feet deep at mean low
water, and the removal in the lower portion of the river, below the
former point, of such obstructions as may be necessary to accommo-
date vessels navigating North Carolina sounds. The estimated cost
of the work was $269,000.
   The expenditures to June 30, 1909, amounted to $240,005.42, of
which amount $11,315.19 has been expended in maintenance and
$1,355 was received from sales. The project is about 80 per cent
completed. The channel obstructions have been removed, and a
channel depth of 4 feet at mean low water over the projected width
has been provided between Hamilton and Weldon. On June 30,
1908, vessels drawing 81 feet could go as far as Hamilton, and beyond
that point, to within a short distance of Weldon,.4 feet could be carried
at mean low water. A bar is forming at the mouth of the river, due
2 88          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                        U.     S.   ARMY.

to deposits brought down by freshets, and this has somewhat dimin-
ished the depth that could otherwise be carried to Hamilton. The
upper river is subject to heavy freshets, which cause the only varia-
tion in the level of the water surface. Weldon, situated about 129
miles from the mouth, is the head of navigation.
   The only work done during the fiscal year was in the nature of
maintenance and consisted in the removal of sunken and overhead
obstructions.
   The commerce has varied considerably since the improvement was
undertaken, the maximum amount of freight transported having been
in 1891, when it was 376,181 tons. Since then it has decreased, and
for the calendar year 1908 it was reported at 78,775 tons, valued at
$1,402,080. The principal item of shipment is timber.
   The depletion of the forests and the development of railroads in
the territory tributary to the river have served to reduce the volume
of water-borne freight in recent years.
   It has not been found possible to ascertain what effect, if any, the
improvement has had upon freight rates.
   The balance available and the amount estimated for will be applied
in maintaining the improvement by keeping the channel clear of
logs, snags, and similar obstructions.
   For reference to reports of examinations and surveys, see Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 249.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                                     $3, 962.48
Received from sales during fiscal year-------......---...--------.....---..---.........---------....             3. 25

                                                                                                            3, 965. 73
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .........---......--...................................                                       1, 616.15

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.. -............                          -................                 2, 349. 58
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ............                                41, 925. 88

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...-                                                5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix IL 13.)
   14. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangeringnavi-
gation--(a) Wreck of Haze.-This sloop sunk in James River, Virginia,
about 1 mile northeast by north from Nansemond River light. Its
removal was authorized July 14, 1908. The wreck was removed dur-
ing the month of July, 1908, by private parties free of expense to the
United States.
   (b) Logs, Mackey Creek, North Carolina.-Theselogs sunk in the cut
approaching Mackey Creek, North Carolina. Their removal was au-
thorized January 27, 1909. The logs were removed during the month
of February, 1909, at a cost of $252.62.
   (c) Wreck of Bismarck.-This schooner sunk in Hampton Roads,
Virginia, about 1 mile from Pig Point light-house. Its removal was
authorized April 15, 1909. The wreck was removed during the
month of April, 1909, at a cost of $250.
   (See Appendix L 14.)
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                           289

EXAMINATION MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE RIVER AND HARBOR ACT
                   APPROVED MARCH 3, 1909.

   Report dated May 12, 1909, on preliminary examination of Point
Harbor channel, North Carolina, required by the river and harbor act
of March 3, 1909, was duly submitted by the district officer. It was
reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant
to law, and was transmitted to Congress and printed in House Docu-
ment No. 78, Sixty-first Congress, first session. The locality is not
considered worthy of improvement by the General Government.

IMPROVEMENT                  OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE WILMINGTON,
                                NORTH CAROLINA, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Capt. Earl I. Brown, Corps of Engi-
neers. Division engineer, Col. Dan C. Kingman, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Scuppernong River, North Carolina.-Fromthe mouth to Co-
lumbia is 5 miles; to Spruill's bridge, 23 miles.
  Before work was commenced on the river there was only about 5
feet across the bar at its mouth. The upper portion was obstructed
by logs, snags, stumps, overhanging growth, and abrupt bends, per-
mitting navigation by small vessels only.
   The original project, adopted in 1876, was to dredge the bar, make
cut-offs at sharp bends, and remove obstructions so as to obtain a
channel 60 feet wide and 9 feet deep at low water up to Spruill's
bridge.
   The present project, adopted by act of June 13, 1902, provides for
dredging a channel 3,400 feet long, 150 feet wide, and 9 feet deep at
mean low water across the bar at the mouth of the river, at a cost of
$14,000.
   The project is about 70 per cent completed.
Expended prior to 1902 on previous project....................      .... $8, 000. 00
Expended on present project up to June 30, 1909:
   For improvement .............................             $11, 500. 00
   For maintenance .......................................     4, 001. 32
                                                                          15, 501. 32

      Total ..................................................................   23, 501. 32
   There was no work done during the fiscal year 1909. The expen-
ditures, $31.35, were for outstanding liabilities of the previous fiscal
year and for travel expenses incurred in an examination of a bridge
at Columbia.
   At the close of the fiscal year 1909, the conditions so far as known
are a channel 9 feet deep at mean low water, 90 feet wide for 2,700
feet of its length, and 130 feet wide for 700 feet of its length across
the bar at the mouth of the river; thence to Cross Landing, 14 miles
above, a good open channel of 7 feet at mean low water, free from
obstacles; thence to Spruill's bridge, 9 miles farther, 7 feet at mean
low water but the river in many places is narrow and crooked and
obstructed by overhanging trees on the banks and by logs and snags
in the channel.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance, together with $2,500
allotted from act of March 3, 1909, for preservation and maintenance
      9001-ENG 1909-19
290         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                         U.      S. ARMY.

of rivers and harbors and the additional appropriation recommended
to the completion of the project and to maintenance.
   This is a nontidal stream with no slope, the oscillations of the sur-
face being controlled by the winds.
   Spruill's bridge, 23 miles from its mouth, is the head of navigation,
to which point 7 feet can be carried at mean low water.
   The commerce for 1908 amounted to 12,515 tons, valued at approxi-
mately $215,200, a decrease of 56,115 tons below last year. The
principal falling off was caused by the completion of the Norfolk and
Southern Railway to Columbia and the discontinuance of the steam-
boat line between Columbia and Edenton.
July 1,1908, balance unexpended. ..........................                ........... $1, 530. 03
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...............---- .... ..................................              2, 500. 00

                                                                                         4, 030.03
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ................  ........ .... ..... . ........... ......                    31. 35
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................                  ................      3, 998. 68
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909......................................        .......               2, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix M 1.)
   2. Fishing Creek, North Carolina.-When improvement began the
stream was badly obstructed by masses of fallen timber, overhanging
trees on banks, logs and snags in channel, and was navigable by rafts
only a few miles above the mouth.
   The original project of 1889 was to clear the stream of logs, snags,
trees, etc., up to Bellamy's mill. It was amended in 1896 to limit the
work to that part below the Wilmington and Weldon Railroad bridge,
and this amended project was completed in 1901. The sum of
$22,715.10 was spent on this project, which has been finished.
   Amount expended on present project up to June 30, 1909, for main-
tenance, $2,534.90.
   The lower 6 miles of the stream was cleared of obstructions in
1909.
   It is not navigable above Beech Swamp on account of its tortuous
course and rapid current. Below that point it is navigable during
the higher stages about eight months annually.
   The stream is reported by those interested in its navigation to be
in poor condition to Beech Swamp, being badly obstructed by fallen
trees, logs, and snags. Between Beech Swamp and the railroad bridge
the condition of the stream is unknown, but it is presumably bad.
The owners of the vessels navigating this stream report that there
are so many obstructions that it is unsafe to navigate unless the water
is at least 2 feet higher than the stages at which it was safe to navi-
gate just after the stream had been cleared out.
   The present head of navigation is Beech Swamp, 17.5 miles from
its mouth, to which about 2 feet can be carried during about three
months of the year.
                   RIVER AND HARBOR         IMPROVEMENTS.                      291

  The water surface varies from a minimum depth of 6 inches at low
water to 10 feet during the high freshet stages.
  The commerce for 1908 amounted to 1,694 tons, valued at $29,851,
showing a gain over that for 1907 of 203 tons. It consisted principally
of cotton seed, cotton-seed meal, fertilizers, timber, etc.
  The effect of the improvement on railroad and boat rates can not be
definitely stated; but the stream when opened to navigation affords
an outlet to farm products, timber, lumber, etc., which have no other
outlet except by wagons.
  References: Annual Reports for 1890, page 1179; 1893, page 1377;
1900, page 1796; 1905, page 1203.
   It is proposed to apply the appropriation recommended to the
maintenance of the natural channel as far as Beech Swamp.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................      $347. 12
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ................................................               347. 12

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement ...............................    1, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix M 2.)
   3. Pamlico and Tar rivers, North Carolina.-(Oneriver, called the
Pamlico below Washington, N. C., and the Tar above that point.)
Distance from Washington to Greenville, 22 miles; to Tarboro, 49
miles; to Fishing Creek, 56 miles; to Little Falls, 88 miles; to Rocky
Mount, 89 miles.
   Prior to its improvement, which was begun in 1876, the Pamlico
River (that portion of the stream below Washington) was obstructed
by war blockades, sunken logs, snags, stumps, and sand shoals.
   The governing low-water depths were 5 feet to Washington and
perhaps 1 foot to Tarboro, the navigation to which place was practi-
cable during freshet stages only. About 3 feet could be carried to
Tarboro during about eight high-water months per year.
   The original project for the improvement of the river below
Washington was that submitted in December, 1875 (Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1876, p. 361), and adopted by Congress
August 14, 1876, and had for its object to provide 9 feet at low water,
from Washington to its mouth, by dredging and the removal of piles
and obstructions at an estimated cost of $28,050. In the project
proper the proposed draft to be provided was not specified, but work
under the project was devoted to securing 9 feet at mean low water.
Under this project the sum of $18,000 was appropriated, of which
$17,877.12 was expended; the remainder, $122.88, was transferred to
the improvement of the Pamlico and Tar rivers, when the improve-
ments were combined in 1880.
   The Tar River (that portion of the stream above Washington),
prior to improvement, was obstructed by sunken logs, piles, wrecks,
stumps, snags, and trees in the channel, and overhanging trees along
its banks. The original project for this portion of the stream was
that of 1879 (Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879,
p. 700) for the removal of obstructions between Washington and
292         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                     U.   S. ARMY.

Tarboro at an estimated cost of $10,000. An appropriation of $3,000
was made for this purpose in 1879, of which $2,867.27 was expended,
leaving a balance of $132.73, which was transferred to the joint
improvement.
   In 1889 the project was extended to clear the natural channel
above Tarboro, 34 miles, to Little Falls, and the estimate was increased
$16,200, making the total estimate $92,200.
   The present project is that of 1875 (for Pamlico River), and of
1879, 1889, and 1907 (for Tar River), somewhat modified to secure a
channel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep at mean low water to Washing-
ton; thence a channel 60 feet wide and 4 feet deep at low water for
22 miles farther, to Greenville; thence a channel 60 feet wide and 20
inches deep at low water for 26 miles farther, to Tarboro; thence
to keep clear of obstructions the natural channel 34 miles farther,
to Little Falls, 2 miles below Rocky Mount, N. C.
   The project as modified by act of March 2, 1907, changed the depth
between Washington and Greenville from 3 to 4 feet at mean low
water, at an estimated cost of $3,800.
   The work for the year was for maintenance and consisted in remov-
ing the worst obstructions from the channel between Washington
and the mouth of Fishing Creek, and making surveys of the shoals
immediately below Greenville, and also in the vicinity of the Norfolk
and Southern Railway bridge at Washington.
Expended prior to 1876 on previous projects ...........................                            $15, 000.00
Expended on present project to June 30, 1909:
   For improvement ................................               ....             $149, 875. 33
   For maintenance ........................................                          23, 485. 42
                                                                                                   173, 360. 75

       Total...........................          ....................--........                    188, 360.75
   The project of 1875, with its various modifications, is completed,
and at the beginning of the fiscal year there was a channel to Washing-
ton 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep at mean low water; thence to
Greenville a channel 60 feet wide and 4 feet deep at low water, which
is in good condition except for a small amount of snagging required.
The dredged cuts below and above Washington have slightly deteri-
orated during the year.
   Above Greenville the river has deteriorated for lack of maintenance
and is navigable only during freshet stages of variable duration,
extending over six or eight months of the year.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance, together with the
appropriation recommended, to maintenance of the improvement,
both above and below Washington.
   The stream is nontidal. Below Washington the only surface
variations of importance are due to the wind, with an extreme range
of 3 feet under normal conditions. Long protracted easterly or
westerly winds sometimes cause variations of 7 or 8 feet. The
variations of the upper portion of the river are affected by freshets
only.
   The head of navigation is Dunbar's bridge, 108 miles from the
mouth.
   The commerce for the year 1908 amounted to 353,429 tons, valued
at approximately $7,909,369 (a decrease as compared with 1907 of
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                         293
74,959 tons). It consisted principally of cotton, cotton-seed products,
grain, potatoes, wood, timber, lumber, fertilizer, and general mer-
chandise.
  The tendency of the improvement is to keep down freight rates.
  References: History and maps, Annual Reports, 1890, page 1114;
1891, page 1347; 1896, pages 161 and 1101, and 1907, page 267.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ---..------....................------------..........------... $1, 542. 40
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909............................................................- 5, 000.00
Amount received as rent during fiscal year..............................                            125.00

                                                                                                 6, 667.40
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement..............................    ....................                              1, 667. 40

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................                             5, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911 for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..................................................  10, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See appendix M 3.)
   4. Contentnia Creek, North Carolina.-Distance from the mouth
to Snow Hill, 312 miles; Speights bridge, 502 miles; Stantonsburg,
63 miles.
   Previous to improvement this stream was obstructed throughout
its entire length by fallen timber, sand shoals, and overhanging
growth, and was navigable for shallow-draft craft during only the
higher freshet stages of about three to six months of the year.
   The original project of 1881 was to clear the stream of these ob-
structions, so as to obtain from its mouth to Stantonsburg, 63 miles, a
depth of not less than 3 feet during the higher stages, about nine
months of the year, at a cost estimated in 1888 at $77,500.
   The project of 1881 as extended in 1894 included maintenance
below Snow Hill, and was again extended in 1899 to include main-
tenance from Stantonsburg to the mouth. The project has been
completed, and additional work required is for maintenance.
Amount expended up to June 30, 1909:
   For improvement .......................      .................    ........                  $64, 394. 56
  For maintenance............................................................                   10, 096. 33

        Total ........................--..........                       ...............   -    74, 490. 89
   The work of the year consisted of maintenance by snagging between
the mouth of the creek and the twenty-fourth mile post and between
the thirty-fifth and forth-second mile posts.
   At the close of the fiscal year the creek between its mouth and
Snow Hill was in fair condition and could be navigated during six
months of the year by boats drawing 3 to 4 feet, depending upon the
rainfall. Snow Hill, 312 miles from its mouth, is practically the
head of navigation, although during the higher stages of water boats
can ascend the stream to Speights bridge, 502 miles from its mouth.
   The portion of the stream between Snow Hill and Fools Bridge, 102
miles above, is now being resnagged, the upper 7 miles having been
294           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                       S. ARMY.

completed, and the remaining 34 miles will be completed with funds
now in hand.
   The stream is subject to freshets rising 15 feet above low water at
Snow Hill and Stantonsburg.
   The commerce for the year 1908 amounted to 18,800 tons, valued
at approximately $516,712. It consisted principally of cotton,
cotton-seed meal, timber, lumber, fertilizer, general merchandise, etc.
   The effect of the improvement on railroad and boat rates can not
be definitely stated, but the stream when opened to navigation affords
an outlet to farm products, timber, lumber, etc., which have no other
outlet except by wagon.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance and the appropriation
recommended to maintenance below Speights bridge.
   References: Annual Reports, 1881, page 1009; 1890, page 1118;
1896, page 1103.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                                    $1, 713. 46
Amount received as rent during fiscal year...............................                                    125. 00
                                                                                                          1, 838. 46
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year," for maintenance of
  improvement........................ .................................                                   1, 027.35

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                        811. 11
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ......................                    .............               361. 91

July 1, 1909, balance available ......................................                                      449. 20

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
    pended July 1, 1909.......................                      ...... ..        .......... ......    2, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix M 4.)
   5. Neuse and Trent rivers, North Carolina.-(a) Neuse River.-
Distance from Newbern to Contentnia Creek, 32 miles; to Kinston,
50 miles; to Whitehall, 74 miles; to Goldsboro (Wilmington and
Weldon Railroad bridge), 94 miles; to Smithfield, 150 miles.
   There is considerable uncertainty as to the conditions existing prior
to 1878, when improvement by the Government was begun. Before
the civil war, and probably for some time afterwards, light-draft
steamers made more or less regular trips as high up as Smithfield, but
the low-water depth probably did not exceed 2 feet, and the stream
was obstructed by snags and after the civil war by war blockades.
(See Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, p. 240.)
   The original project of 1871, as extended in 1878-79 and 1880 and
continued to date, provides for an 8-foot navigation up to Newbern
during the entire year, 4 feet to Kinston, and during nine months of
the year 3 feet to Smithfield, by the removal of war obstructions,
dredging, jettying, and snagging, at a total estimated cost of $374,000;
extended in 1902 to include dredging a channel 300 feet wide below
Newbern and 200 feet wide at Newbern, to a depth of 8 feet at dead
low water, in accordance with report and estimate printed in Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 1427, at an estimated
additional cost of $59,081.25. Since its adoption this additional esti-
mate has been reduced to $24,000.
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           295
  In 1902 the improvement of this river was combined with that of
the Trent.
Amount expended on foregoing projects to June 30, 1909:
   For improvement-...............................................       $331, 144. 77
   For maintenance........  .............. ...............  ............   23, 107. 69
      Total..-----..----------...........-------------..........----------.............   354, 252.46
   The expenditures for the year were $8,106.94, of which $3,721.10 was
for maintenance, which consisted of snagging between Newbern and
Seven Springs, and $4,385.84 was for improvement, which consisted
of dredging at Union Point shoal, and at a shoal in the western chan-
nel, about 2 miles above Newbern.
   As a result of the expenditures to date the channel at and below
Newbern has been completed to project width and depth, all war
blockades have been cleared away, and the natural channel has been
cleared to Smithfield, 150 miles above Newbern. No attempt has
been made to maintain the stream above Waynesboro Landing (Golds-
boro), 984 miles above Newbern. At low water 8 feet can be carried
to Newbern, 4 feet to Village Creek, 25 miles above, 2.5 feet to the
mouth of Contentnia Creek, 31- miles above Newbern, and 1 foot to
Kinston, 50 miles above Newbern, above which point the river is not
navigable on stages of less than 2 to 3 feet.
   A channel known as the "Western channel," immediately above
Newbern, has been cleared to a depth of 4 feet at mean low water,
and is now being dredged to a depth of 4 feet at dead low water.
   The channel of the river between Newbern and Seven Springs, near
Whitehall, is in good condition.
   The practical head of navigation is Waynesboro Landing, about
136 miles from the mouth of the river.
   The stream is nontidal. The variation of the water surface below
Newbern is due entirely to the influences of the wind. The maximum
range is 3.3 feet during severe northwest winds to 8 feet during
violent northeast gales. The upper river is subject to freshets, which
rise 17 feet at Smithfield, 18 feet at Waynesboro Landing, and 20 feet
at Kinston.
   The funds on hand are to be used for maintenance and in securing
the project depth of 4feet between Newbern and Kinston by dredging.
   It is not considered practicable to carry out the project above New-
bern as it now stands for any reasonable amount of money, but the
appropraition recommended will be applied toward securing 4 feet
to the mouth of Contentnia Creek and 2 feet thence to Kinston by
jetties, training walls, and dredging where necessary, and toward
maintenance of the improvement.
   The commerce of the year amounted to 384,418 tons, valued at
 $7,083,720. It consisted of grain, timber, lumber, fertilizers, general
merchandise, etc. One of the causes of the falling off of the com-
merce is the discontinuance of the line of steamers between Newbern
and Belhaven.
   Freight rates are materially lessened by reason of the improvement.
   References: See Annual Reports of 1879, page 71; 1900, pages
268 and 1802; 1901, page 1545.
296           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                   U.    S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ...............         ..................                           $11, 718. 48
Amount received as rent during fiscal year ............................                                     250. 00
                                                                                                        11, 968. 48
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..............................                              $4, 385. 84
     For maintenance of improvement ........................                             3, 721. 10
                                                                                                         8, 106. 94
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                                  3, 861. 54
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................                                 1, 662. 80
July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                                    2, 198. 74
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                               72, 500. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909.... .............................                                        (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Trent River.-Distance from the mouth at Newbern to Pol-
loksville, 18 miles; to lower Quaker bridge, 27 miles; to Trenton, 38
miles. Its original condition was a channel of 6 feet depth to Pol-
loksville, and the stream was fairly clear to lower Quaker bridge,
above which point it was badly obstructed.
   The original project of 1879 (see Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1879, p. 711) was to secure 3 feet depth at low water
to Trenton; extended in 1886 to obtain 8 feet depth through Foys
flats; extended in 1889 to clear out obstructions to upper Quaker
bridge, 40 miles above Trenton. The sum of $64,262.64 was ex-
pended on this project and its modifications.
   In 1896 the project of 1879 was amended to provide for the main-
tenance of a channel only 30 feet wide and 3 feet deep from Newbern
to Trenton, at an annual estimated cost of $2,500. This was extended
in 1902 to include dredging at Newbern to 8 feet depth at dead low
water from harbor line to channel, at an estimated cost of $24,000
additional. The existing project, therefore, is to dredge to 8 feet
dead low water at Newbern and maintain a channel 30 feet wide and
3 feet deep at low water to Trenton. In 1902 the improvement of
this river was combined with that of the Neuse. This project has
been completed.
   By joint resolution approved March 4, 1907, authority was given
to expend such portion of the appropriation made in river and harbor
act of March 2, 1907, as may be necessary for securing a channel 6
feet deep over Foys flats in the Trent River, about 4 miles above
Newbern. This work has been done.
Amount expended on existing project up to June 30, 1909:
   For improvement .................................................                                   $25, 817. 78
   For maintenance....................................................                                  18, 378. 61

        Total .......................                    ..      ....................      .........   44, 196. 39

                          a See consolidated money statement on page 298.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                    297
   The expenditures for the year were $5,205.64, of which $2,079.17
was for improvement and $3,126.47 for maintenance.
   The work of the year resulted in obtaining a depth of 6 feet at dead
low water over Foys flats, as outlined in joint resolution approved
March 4, 1907, and in maintaining the channel between Newbern and
Trenton. The project is completed, except for maintenance.
   The improvement above Trenton has been abandoned.
   Between Trenton and Newbern a 4-foot channel exists and the
stream is in good condition. The maximum draft that can be carried
June 30, 1909, to Trenton, 38 miles above the mouth, which is the
head of navigation, is 4 feet.
   Near the mouth the water level varies about 3 feet under normal
conditions, according to the prevailing winds. Long protracted
easterly or westerly winds sometimes cause a variation of 7 or 8 feet.
At Trenton the stream is subject to freshets of about 5 to 15 feet
during the winter months.
   The commerce for the year 1908 amounted to 237,240 tons, valued
at approximately $4,847,611, showing a decrease, compared with 1907,
of 31,136 tons, valued at $7,217,867. This falling off in volume of
commerce is directly attributable to the abandonment of a line of
steamers formerly operated by the Norfolk and Southern Railway
Company between Belhaven and Elizabeth City, after this company
had built a railroad connecting these points.
   The commerce carried consisted principally of fertilizers, general
merchandise, machinery, timber, lumber, etc.
   The effect of this improvement on freight rates is not known, but
it affords transportation facilities to the town of Trenton, which has
no other means except by wagon.
   References: Annual Reports, 1879, page 711; 1900, pages 268 and
1802; 1901, page 1545.
   The available balance and the appropriation asked for will be
applied to maintenance of the improvement.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ......................................                                $8, 608. 61
Amount received as rent during fiscal year. .............................                                   375. 00
                                                                                                         8, 983. 61
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ..............................                               $2, 079. 17
    For maintenance of improvement ........................                                3, 126. 47
                                                                                                         5,205.64

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                    3, 777. 97
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                                   825. 22

July 1, 1909, balance available ........................                    ...........            .     2, 952. 75
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909....        ......................................                                   (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                        a See consolidated money statement on page 298.
298          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                            CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-....-..............................                        $20, 327.09
Amount received as rent during fiscal year. ..-......................                            625. 00
                                                                                             20, 952. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ................................                 $6, 465. 01
    For maintenance of improvement. .. .. .................                    6, 847. 57
                                                                                             13, 312. 58

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                            7, 639.51
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities... ..-................              ............        2, 488.02

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................                ...........              5, 151.49

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                    72, 500. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909. . ..         .........               .                    33, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix M 5.)
  6. Inland waterway from Pamlico Sound to Beaufort Inlet, North
Carolina.--Distancefrom     the 10-foot mean low-water contour in
Adams Creek (a tributary of the Neuse River) to the head of Adams
Creek is about 7 miles; from the head of Adams Creek across the
country to the head of Core Creek is about 3 miles; from the head of
Core Creek to the mouth of Core Creek is about 4 miles; and the dis-
tance from the mouth of Core Creek to the 10-foot depth at mean low
water in the Newport River is about 4 miles, making the total dis-
tance over which dredging will be required about 18 miles.
  At the time of the adoption of the existing project a low-water
depth of about 5 feet could be carried from the 10-foot contour in
Adams Creek to near its head; from the head of Adams Creek to the
head of Core Creek is across dry land; from the head of Core Creek
to its mouth the creek is practically bare at low water, and from the
mouth of Core Creek to the 10-foot contour in Newport River the
low-water depth formerly averaged about 6 feet.
  The present and only project, adopted by act of Congress approved
March 2, 1907, contemplates securing, by dredging, a channel 10 feet
deep at low water from Pamlico Sound to Beaufort Inlet via Adams
and Core creeks, said channel to have a minimum bottom width of 90
feet through dry land with side slopes of 1 to 20,a minimum bottom
width of 125 feet with side slopes of 1 to 3 through narrow parts of
the creek and river portions, and a minimum bottom width of 250
feet with side slopes of 1 to 3 in wide parts of creeks and sounds, at
an estimated cost of $550,000.
   Amount expended on project for improvement to June 30, 1909,
$101,012.90.
   The work of the year consisted of laying out and superintending
the work, purchasing 227.45 acres of land for the right of way, remov-
ing under contract 1,250,827 cubic yards of material from the pre-
scribed cross section, completing 34,182.3 feet of channel, which
varies in width from 90 to 250 feet, and starting the work of the
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                              299
construction of a steel highway bridge over Core Creek under con-
tract.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, authorized continuing
contracts for completing the project in the sum of $350,000, of which
$45,000 is yet to be appropriated.
   The funds in hand will be used in completing the waterway, and
the additional appropriation recommended will be applied to work of
maintenance.
   References: Pages 1393 and 1394, Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1904, and House Document No. 84, Fifty-ninth Congress,
second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....   .......................      $358, 253. 18
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 135, 000. 00
                                                                                               493, 253. 18
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment................................................................89,                           266. 08

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                         403, 987. 10
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...............                    ...................    48, 611. 97

July 1, 1909, balance available ..................................                             355, 375. 13

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. .............                           279, 868. 49
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                         45, 000. 00

Imount    that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 ..........................................                               20, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix M 6.)
   7. Waterway between Newbern and Beaufort, N. C. (via Neuse
River, Clubfoot Creek, Glubfoot and Harlowe Canal (private), Har-
lowe Creek, and Newport River).--Distances: Newbern to Clubfoot
Creek, 20 miles; thence to Clubfoot and Harlowe Canal, 6 miles;
thence to Harlowe Creek, 3.2 miles; thence to Newport River, 34
miles; thence to Beaufort, 7 miles.
   The first appropriation for this work was made by the river and
harbor act of 1882, which provided that $5,000 from the appropria-
tion for Neuse River and a like sum from the appropriation for Beau-
fort Harbor should be "applied to the improvement of the line of
inland navigation from Newbern to Beaufort Harbor."
   No estimate or project for said improvement had at that time been
made, but in October, 1883 (Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1884, p. 1067), an estimate was prepared which contem-
plated a channel 80 feet wide and 9 feet deep, at an estimated cost
of $883,580, exclusive of the cost of a tide lock and of the canal com-
pany's franchise and property.
   The available funds being totally inadequate for this improvement,
the project adopted in 1884 for the expenditure of said funds con-
templated a channel 30 feet wide and 5 feet deep at mean low water,
the estimated.cost being $92,000.
   This project of 1884 constitutes the existing project.
   All work of improvement has been confined to the natural channels
in Clubfoot and Harlowe creeks and Newport River.
300        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                   U.   S. ARMY.

Amount expended on existing project to June 30, 1909:
   For improvement ........................................ ......        .. $29, 739. 84
   For maintenance............................................................7, 260. 16

      Total ...................................................                   37, 000. 00
   The expenditures during the year were for clearing the obstructions
from Clubfoot and Harlowe creeks.
   The governing depth in Harlowe Creek was increased several years
ago to the project depth of 5 feet, but for lack of maintenance had
decreased to about 1 foot in 1905. During the fiscal year 1907 the
shoal at the mouth of the creek was redredged to the project depth,
but another shoal of less consequence was left inside the creek. The
channel in Clubfoot Creek had never been dredged until the fiscal
year 1906. Some snagging, etc., had been done in both creeks, but no
work in the canal connecting the two creeks has ever been done by
the Government, since said canal is owned by a corporation.
   The dredged cut at the mouth of Harlowe Creek has deteriorated
considerably since its completion, but on account of the dredging done
in Clubfoot Creek during the fiscal year 1906 and in 1907 those por-
tions of the waterway under improvement are, on the whole, in better
condition now than ever before, although there are many complaints
of logs, etc., obstructing the private canal.
   The controlling depth at mean low water is now from 2 to 2Z feet,
the shoalest place being near the mouth of Harlowe Creek; but at
high water about 4 feet can be carried, shoalest water being in the
canal.
   No additional appropriation is recommended for the maintenance
of this waterway, as after the inland waterway from Pamlico Sound
to Beaufort Inlet is completed the present route via Clubfoot and
Harlowe Canal will not be required.
   The commerce for the year 1908 amounted to 35,433 tons, valued at
approximately $1,699,042, showing an increase over the commerce
for 1907 of 6,903 tons. This commerce consisted principally of
cotton, cotton seed, oysters, clams, timber, lumber, and general
merchandise.
   References: Annual Reports, 1884, page 106; 1890, page 1130; and
1896, page 113.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................          .....
                                                             .... .............     $722. 39
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...............         ....
                              . ..........     ...........................            722. 39
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 55, 000. 00
   (See Appendix M 7.)
   8. Harbor at Bea fort, N. C.-When improvement (begun in 1836)
was resumed in 1881, the erosion at Fort Macon and Shackelford
points was causing serious deterioration of the inside channels and
threatening deterioration of the bar channel. The governing low-
water depth is said to have been 15 feet on the bar and 2 feet at
Beaufort, N. C.
   The original project is that of 1881, to stop erosion at the inlet
 (Fort Macon and Shackelford points) by jetties and to provide a
channel 200 feet wide and 9 feet deep at ordinary low tide to Beau-
fort, and a channel 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep from Beaufort to
the 6-foot contour of the channel leading up North River, estimated
to cost $82,103.38, increased in 1885 to $159,000, when the project was
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                  301

modified by reducing the channel to Beaufort to 100 feet and its
depth to 5 feet at mean low water and eliminating the channel east
from Beaufort. In 1887 the estimate for the above work was further
increased to $163,000.
   The project was again modified in 1890, the project depth of the
bulkhead channel being increased to 7 feet. The project as modified
was completed.
   The amount expended under the original project as modified was
$148,843. To the above amount should be added $5,000, appropriated
July 4, 1836, making the total cost up to the completion of the origi-
nal project $153,843.
   The existing project of 1896 includes the maintenance of jetties
and sand fences at Fort Macon and Shackelford points and the main-
tenance of the 7-foot channel across Bulkhead shoal and thence to
the wharves at Beaufort. The object of the jetties and sand fences
is to protect the land on the opposite sides of the inlet, thus prevent-
ing the inlet from shifting and deteriorating.
   The jetties have been successful in preventing the inlet from widen-
ing and shifting, but deterioration of the depths obtained in the
main channel is quite rapid, due to the fact that the inlet is still too
wide to enable its tidal discharge to keep the channel scoured out to
the proper depth.
    The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, authorized a sufficient
amount of the appropriation made therein to be applied to repairing
existing jetties at Fort Macon Point and constructing additional
jetties and shore protection.
   The amount expended on present project for maintenance to June
30, 1909, was $30,601.99.
   The expenditures of the year were for building and maintaining
sand fences at Fort Macon and Shackelford points and for restoring
the dredged channels in front of Beaufort and across Bulkhead shoal
to 100 feet width and 7 feet depth at mean low water.
    A draft of 7 feet at mean low water can now be carried to the
wharves at Beaufort.
    It is proposed to expend the available balance and the appropria-
tion recommended in maintaining the dredged channels, building and
maintaining sand fences at Fort Macon and Shackelford points, and
possibly in repairing and building rock jetties at these points should
erosion Increase.
   The tide rises 2 feet at Beaufort and 3 feet at the inlet.
   The commerce for the year 1908 amounted to 46,178 tons, valued
at approximately $2,137,369.
   The maintenance of this channel tends to prevent the rise in freight
rates by allowing the larger vessels to reach the wharves at Beaufort.
   References: Annual Reports, 1881, page 1013; 1893, page 1457;
1896, page 1115; 1899, page 1498, House Document 1454, Sixtieth
Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................            $14, 057. 47
Amount received as rent during fiscal year .............................               375. 00
                                                                                   14, 432. 47
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .................................................................    10, 152. 46
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.........................................           4, 280. 01
302            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                             S. ARMY.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.............................................   . $5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix M 8.)
  9. Beaufort Inlet, North Carolina.-When improvement began in
September, 1905, there was a minimum depth on the bar of approxi-
mately 12 feet at mean low water.
  The original project, which is also the existing project, is printed
on page 1415 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1904 and was adopted by Congress in 1905. It contemplates a chan-
nel 300 feet wide, 20 feet deep at mean low water, across the bar, to be
obtained by dredging, at an estimated cost of $45,000.
Amount expended on existing project to June 30, 1909:
   For improvement..-------------------.......-------................----..-----.......----.......------.      $44, 484. 24
   For maintenance..................................................                                                439. 36
         Total--.....---------------------.......................---------....--------------------..........    44, 923. 60
   The work to date hs consisted of tlh necessary surveys, etc., and
the dredging of 426,630 cubic yards of material from the bar channel
in 1906 and 1907. The result of this work was an increase of the
minimum depth on the bar from 10.8 feet at mean low water when
work began to about 20 feet on June 30, 1907, the minimum width of
the 20-foot channel being about 200 feet. This channel has dete-
riorated during the past two years, the minimum mean low-water depth
on June 30, 1909, being only 13 feet. The tide rises 3 feet at the inlet.
    About 65 per cent of the project is completed.
    There was no work done during the fiscal year.
    It is proposed to expend the available balance and the appropria-
tion recommended in restoring the dredged channel to the project
depth, and obtaining the project width.
    The commerce for the year 1908 amounted to 20,575 tons, valued
at $700,625, and consisted principally of fish, lumber, cross-ties, and
general merchandise.
    Compared with the commerce for 1907, this shows a gain of 4,706
tons, or nearly 33 per cent.
    The effect of this improvement will be to lessen freight rates by
affording water transportation for products which have hitherto been
dependent entirely upon railroads.
    This work is designed to provide a deep-water outlet to the ocean
for the inland waterway, Pamlico Sound to Beaufort Inlet, North
Carolina.
    References: Annual Reports 1881, page 1009; 1890, page 1118;
  1896, page 1103.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended          ..................................     $5, 203. 07
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
   March 3, 1909 .........................             - ........................ 15, 000. 00
                                                                                                                 20, 203. 07
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
   improvement............................................     ...........                                           126. 67

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                            20, 076. 40
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                            303
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
pended July 1, 1909....           -.......................................... $15, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix M 9.)
   10. New River, North Carolina, including inland waterways be-
tween Beaufort Harbor and New River and between New. River and
Swansboro.-The act of March 2, 1907, combined these three im-
provements under this new heading.
   (a) New River.-Appropriations amounting to $50,000 were made
for the river in 1836, 1837, and 1838, after which no further appro-
priations were made until 1882, when $5,000 was appropriated.
Another appropriation of $5,000 was made in 1884; but since these
amounts were considered too small to justify undertaking the im-
provements, no work was done until 1886, when still another appro-
priation, of $10,000, was made.
   When improvement began in 1886, the governing low-water depth
was 4 feet for a distance of 23 miles to Jacksonville, and the channel
included two circuitous parts around Wrights Island and Cedar Bush
Marsh.
   The original project of 1886 was to dredge a cut 4 feet deep and
100 feet wide through Wrights Island and a second cut 4 feet deep
and 150 feet wide through Cedar Bush Marsh. Both were com-
pleted, but the Cedar Bush Marsh cut deteriorated at the upper end
and was abandoned, and the project of June 18, 1894, to obtain 4 feet
depth around Cedar Bush Marsh by dredging and an experimental
timber training wall was adopted and successfully carried out. The
additional work required is for maintenance.
   The act of March 3, 1905, authorized the balance from the project
of 1894 to be expended in rebuilding the dike hitherto constructed.
This was done, and the dike is now permanent.
Amount expended since civil war on previous projects. .................        $20, 442. 35
Amount expended on present project of 1894 (as amended to date) up to
June 30, 1909:
   For improvement ....................................                 ......   9,186. 39
   For maintenance (including rebuilding dike) ......................            3, 413. 40
      Total ......................................................               33, 042. 14
   The expenditures during the year were for office expenses.
   It is proposed to apply the existing balance and the appropriation
recommended to maintenance.
   The project depth of 4 feet has twice been obtained and twice lost
through lack of maintenance. The project depth now exists, although
the channel is quite narrow near the head of the marshes. The tidal
range at the inlet is about 31 feet and at the head of the marshes
about 1 foot. The head of navigation for all practical purposes is
Tar Landing, 3 miles above Jacksonville and 26 miles from the mouth
of the river, to which a present depth of 4 feet can be carried. The
depth on the bar at the mouth of the river is now 4 feet, but varies
from time to time.
   The commerce for 1908 amounted to 4,487 tons, valued at $189,360.
It consisted principally of timber, fish, cotton, cotton seed, and gen-
304         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                 S. ARMY.

eral merchandise. The decrease from last year is due principally to
the shutting down temporarily of the sawmills at and near Jacksonville.
   In its present condition this stream probably has very little effect
on freight rates in general, but it affords transportation for products
which would otherwise have no means of transportation except by
wagon. If the bar and channel were sufficiently improved to justify
a line of steam vessels between Wilmington and Jacksonville, freight
could probably be carried to the latter point much more cheaply than
at present.
   References: Annual Reports, 1882, page 1117; 1886, page 992;
1891, page 1380; 1899, page 1501, and 1907, page 277.
July-l, 1908, balance unexpended .................................               ..... $1, 963. 55
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement... ........................            ...........................             5. 59
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................             ...............          1, 957. 96
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909............               .. .    .........                     ....     (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (b) Waterway between New River and Swansboro, N. C.-This
waterway is a part of the waterway between Beaufort Harbor
and New River (see pp. 1124-1127, Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1889), but in 1890 two separate appropriations were
made-one for the "Inland waterway between Beaufort Harbor and
New River" and the other for the "Waterway between New River
and Swansboro," and hence separate reports are made for the two
improvements, although one embraces the other.
   This waterway is about 22 miles long and originally consisted of
tortuous tidal channels winding through the marine marsh, which
extends from Swansboro to New River, between the mainland on
the one side and the barrier beach or "banks" (which separates it
from the ocean) on the other. In the vicinity of the four inlets
communicating with the ocean the width of the waterway was sev-
eral hundred feet and its depth from 12 to 15 feet, while between
them its width diminished to about 12 feet in places and its depth
to 6 inches at ordinary low water.
   The original and existing project, adopted in 1889, is to enlarge
the waterway by dredging to a minimum width of 40 feet and min-
imum depth of 3 to 4 feet at mean high water, at an estimated total
cost of $43,000.
   Until June 13, 1906, no work except a survey made in April and
May, 1901, had ever been done on this waterway, for the reason that
an act of the general assembly of North Carolina, ratified February
13, 1889, had incorporated the Wrightsville and Onslow Navigation
Company, with the exclusive right to navigate said waterway, as set
forth in House Executive Document No. 26, Fifty-second Congress,
first session (p. 1147 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1892).
    On February 6, 1905, however, a paper was obtained from the two
survivors of the four parties named in the charter of said Wrightsville
                      a See consolidated money statement on page 307.
                                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  305
and Onslow Navigation Company, in which paper it was declared
that the privileges and franchises granted in said charter had never
been exercised and that said privileges and franchises had "to all
intents and purposes been surrendered and abandoned."
  All obstacles in the way of government improvement having been
thus removed, work was begun as soon as plant for the purpose could
be spared from other more pressing work.
Amount expended on existing project up to June 30, 1909:
  For improvement ....          ......................................                                 $20, 825. 00
  For maintenance ..............................                       ...................                  800. 00
        Total .............................................................                                21, 625. 00
   The expenditures for the year were $3,952.14.
   Dredging operations were carried on between August 16 and
December 4, 1908, using government plant and hired labor. As a
result of this work the project depth now exists throughout the
entire waterway. There are, however, several places where the
project width has not been secured. It is estimated that the project
is about 80 per cent completed.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance and the additional
appropriation recommended to the maintenance of the present
dredged cuts and in obtaining the project width.
   The rise and fall of the tide varies from 2.2 to 4 feet in the neigh-
borhood of the inlets to about 1 foot at the points most distant from
the inlets.
   The commerce of 1908 amounted to 5,208 tons, at an approximate
value of $238,735. It consisted principally of cotton, fish, oysters,
clams, and fertilizers. This can not be taken as an indication of
the amount of commerce that will utilize the waterway now that the
proposed improvement has been made, for the difficulty and delay
incident to navigation were formerly so great that commerce naturally
sought other routes.
   The improvement of this waterway will probably have no direct
effect upon freight rates, but it will afford means of transportation
for large quantities of timber, lumber, and miscellaneous products
that nowv have no outlet except by wagon or by the smallest draft
boats.
   References: For description of this waterway see Annual Reports
for 1892, page 1146, and 1893, pages 1399 and 1400.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................                                          $202. 14
Amount transferred from waterway, Beaufort Harbor to New River.......                                       3, 500. 00
Amount alloted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909....................................................                                         4, 000. 00
Amount received as rent during fiscal year ............................                                        250. 00

                                                                                                            7, 952. 14
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...............................                                  $3, 652. 14
    For maintenance of improvement .........................                                     300. 00
                                                                                                            3, 952. 14
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                       4, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 26, 000. 00

         9001-ENC 1909-                    20
306       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                U.   S. ARMY.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ....................................      (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (c) Waterway between Beaufort Harbor and New River (i. e., portion
between Beaufort and Swansboro).-Distance from Beaufort to
Swansboro, 30 miles, with access at Swansboro to the Atlantic Ocean
through Bogue Inlet.
   When improvement began in 1886 the governing low-water depth
was 18 inches to Swansboro.
   The original project is that of 1885, to provide a channel 100 feet
wide and 3 feet deep at ordinary low water between Beaufort Harbor
and Swansboro, estimated to cost $6,000. This estimate was in-
creased in 1887 to $50,000 and again increased in 1892 to $71,040.
   No project was adopted originally for the part.beyond Swansboro,
but in 1889 a separate project for a channel 40 feet wide by 3 or 4
feet deep over this portion of the waterway was adopted, the esti-
mated cost being $43,000. The act of 1890 made a separate appro-
priation of $5,000 for this portion of the route, designating it as the
  Waterway between New River and Swansboro."            (See pp. 1376-
1378, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1891.)
   The project is about 85 per cent completed.
   The amount expended on present project to June 30, 1909, for
improvement is $51,832.56.
   No work was done during the fiscal year, the expenditures being
for office expenses.
   At the close of the fiscal year 1907 the project depth of 3 feet pre-
vailed throughout the entire length of 30 miles between Beaufort
Harbor and Swansboro, the dredged channel being 100 feet wide
(project width) through one shoal 980 feet long, 60 feet wide through
six shoals aggregating 24,696 feet in length, and 40 feet wide through
another shoal 874 feet long.
   It is reported that no shoaling of any consequence has taken place
in the past two years, and hence the above conditions may be taken as
the conditions prevailing June 30, 1909.
   The tide at Beaufort Inlet at the eastern end of this waterway and
at Bogue Inlet (the western end of the portion improved under
appropriations for waterway between Beaufort Harbor and New
River) has a range of about 3 feet. Where the tides meet in Bogue
Sound the range is only about 1 foot.
   The commerce during the calendar year 1908 amounted to 27,372
tons, valued at $1,097,205. The commerce consisted chiefly of
lumber, shingles, etc., fish, oysters and clams, rosin and turpentine,
miscellaneous farm products, fertilizers, and general merchandise.
   It is proposed to use the balance of funds remaining unexpended
and the appropriation recommended in maintenance and in increas-
ing the width of the dredged cuts to the project width of 100 feet.
   References: Annual Report, 1885, page 1133; 1891, page 1378;
1892, page 1141; 1893, page 1397; 1894, page 1034; 1896, page 1117;
1897, page 1398.
                 a See consolidated money statement on page 307.
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       307

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. .-.-..........-......................           $4, 167. 64
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ...........................................             .........  1, 000. 00
                                                                                                             5, 167. 64
Amount transferred to waterway between New River and Swansboro, N. C.,
during fiscal year.........................................................                                 3, 500. 00
                                                                                                             1, 667. 64
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ..............................................................                                                20
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................................                            1, 667.44
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                                    16, 040. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ................         ...........-- ..                                   (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                               CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................  $6, 333. 33
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1.909 . ....................................................  5, 000. 00
Amount received as rent during fiscal year.......... .................      250. 00
                                                                                                            11, 583. 33
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ...........................                                      $3, 652. 14
    For maintenance of improvement........................                                        305. 79
                                                                                                             3, 957. 93
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...............                            .....................            7, 625. 40
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. . ........                                  42, 040. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...............             .............. 25, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix M 10.)
  11. Northeast and Black rivers, and Cape Fear River above Wil-
mington, N. C.-(a) Northeast River.-Distance from mouth to Ban-
nerman's bridge, 48 miles; to Hallsville, 88 miles; to Kornegay's
bridge, the head of navigation, 103 miles.
  The original condition when improvement began was a channel
badly obstructed by logs, snags, and overhanging trees. The river
was navigable to Bannerman's bridge, with governing low-water
depth of 6 feet.
  The original project of 1889 is still in force, and includes the clear-
ing of the natural channel for small steamers to Hallsville and for
pole boats to Kornegay's bridge at an estimated cost of $30,000.
   Additional work proposed is for maintenance only, the project
having been practically completed.
Amount expended on present project up to June 30, 1909:
  For improvement .....                        ................................                          $10, 687. 96
  For maintenance.............................................                                            11, 801. 08
        Total...................                 ...............              .............                 22, 489. 04

                         a See consolidated money statement on this page.
308          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                              S. ARMY.

   The work done during the year consisted of snagging for main-
tenance and part construction of new hull for snagboat H. G. Wright.
   As the result of the expenditures to date the channel has been kept
cleared, except when it has been impracticable on account of low
water or for other causes for the plant to work. Six feet of water
can be carried to Bannerman's bridge and 3 feet to Croom's bridge
during all stages of the water.
   From Croom's bridge to Kornegay's bridge, the head of navigation,
the river is so shallow that navigation is practicable only when the
water is up. This is liable to occur at any time, but during the sum-
mer low stages usually prevail.
   The minimum low-water depth to Bannerman's bridge is 6 feet; to
Croom's bridge, 3 feet; to Hallsville, 0.5 foot; to Kornegay's bridge
(the head of navigation), 0.1 foot.
   With the available balance it is proposed to maintain the natural
channel to Hallsville.
   The additional appropriation recommended is for maintenance.
   There is a tidal range of about 2 feet at the mouth of this stream,
which decreases to nothing at or a short distance above Bannerman's
bridge. The upper portion is subject to freshets of from 8 to 12 feet.
   The channel is at present badly obstructed by snags, etc., above
the seventy-fifth milepost and is partially obstructed below that point.
   The commerce for 1908 amounted to 101,861 tons, valued at ap-
proximately $1,618,730. It consisted principally of timber, naval
stores, fertilizers, general merchandise, cotton, and miscellaneous
farm products.
   The commerce is handled on a few boats that make some attempt
at regular trips and on a large number of rafts, flats, etc. Hence it
is impossible to estimate the commerce with much accuracy.
   References: Annual Reports, 1885, page 1123; 1890, page 1181;
1895, page 1389; 1896, page 1122, and 1907, page 282.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .---------------------------------........... $3, 023. 62
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ....................................................            6, 000. 00

                                                                                               9, 023. 62
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ....................................................                             1, 769. 33

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                             7, 254. 29
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................            .............                155. 01

July 1, 1909, balance available ................................                     .......   7, 099. 28

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..... ........................................                             (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Black River.-The original condition when improvement began
was a natural channel cleared fairly to Point Caswell and roughly
to Lisbon, with governing low-water depths of 4 feet to Point Caswell,
2.5 feet to Haws Narrows, and 1.5 feet to Lisbon.
                       a See consolidated money statement on page 311.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 309

   The original project of 1885 included clearing the natural channel
and banks to Lisbon and the cutting off of a few sharp points at
bends. It was amended in May, 1893, by omitting that part of the
river above Clear Run, and, as amended, was completed September
20, 1895.
   The existing project of 1894 is to maintain the natural channel to
Clear Run, at an estimated cost of $2,000 per annum.
Amount expended to June 30, 1909:
  On previous project mentioned above .............................. $12, 358. 40
  On present project, for maintenance............................... 10, 103. 18
        Total.......................                     ............................                   22,461. 58
   The expenditures during the year resulted in the removal of the
worst obstructions between the mouth and Clear Run.
   The result obtained by the expenditures to date has been a cleared
channel whenever funds were available, permitting navigation to
Point Caswell, 24 miles above the mouth, at all stages, and to Clear
Run, 66 miles above the mouth, at stages of 1.5 feet or higher above
low water, the governing low-water depths at present being 5 feet to
Point Caswell, 2.5 feet to Haws Narrows, 32 miles above the mouth,
and 1.5 feet to Clear Run. There is no steamboat navigation above
Clear Run. Lisbon, 74 miles from the mouth, is the head of naviga-
tion. The low-water stages prevail usually from May to August,
inclusive; during the rest of the year the stage is about 5 to 8 feet
higher, but the periods of high and low water are by no means the
same every year. No further work, excepting maintenance, is now
proposed.
   It is proposed to expend the available balance for maintenance of
the natural channel up as far as Clear Run, and the appropriation
recommended is for further maintenance as required.
   The commerce during 1908 amounted to 45,998 tons; estimated
value $958,409. It consisted principally of timber, general merchan-
dise, naval stores, fertilizers, cotton, and other farm products.
   The commerce is handled on a few boats, which make some attempt
at regularity, and on a large number of rafts, flats, etc., whose trips
are altogether irregular. Hence it is impossible to get the commer-
cial statistics with even fair accuracy.
   References: For history, see Annual Report for 1896, page 1125.
For report on examination, see Annual Report for 1907, page 281.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................................  . $3, 178. 77
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.................................................      4, 000. 00
                                                                                                         7, 178. 77
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement................................................     ...                                      897. 01
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                     6, 281. 76
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .................                                 .............       407. 65
July 1, 1909, balance available.....................................                                     5, 874. 11
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 ...                                                                                  (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                            a See consolidated money statement on page 311.
310       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                  S. ARMY.

   (c) Cape Fear River above Wilmington, N. C.-The original con-
dition when work began was a channel badly obstructed above Kellys
Cove by logs, snags, etc., and with governing low-water depths of 4
feet to Kellys Cove and 1 foot to Fayetteville.
   The original project of January 26, 1881, was to clear the river to
Fayetteville and obtain a continuous channel by jettying and dredg-
ing, estimated in July, 1893, to cost $275,000 for a channel 4 feet deep
to Elizabethtown and 3 feet deep to Fayetteville. It is about 30 per
cent completed.
   The existing project, adopted by act of June 13, 1902, is to obtain,
by canalizing, a low-water depth of 8 feet to Fayetteville, at an esti-
mated cost of $1,350,000.
   In consequence of this new project the former project has been
abandoned, excepting for the maintenance of the natural channel,
pending the construction of locks and dams.
Amount expended on project of 1881 to June 30, 1909:
   For improvement... ............................................ $134, 436. 96
   For maintenance .................................... ...........20, 060. 81

    Total-------------------------...................                 154,497.77
                              ..---------...------..--...............--------...
Amount expended on project of 1902 to June 30, 1909, for improvement.  14, 682. 23
      Total ..................   ...............   ........ ............   169,180.00
   The work done during the year consisted in removing obstructions
in the river between the twenty-sixth and twenty-seventh mile-
boards caused by the caving of banks, in the partial construction of a
new hull for the snagboat H. G.Wright for use on this and neighboring
streams, inspection, and office work.
   The additional appropriation asked for will be devoted to continu-
ing the work of maintenance by open-channel work.
   At present the low-water depths are 8 feet to Kings Bluff, 38 miles
above Wilmington; 2 feet to Elizabethtown, 73 miles above Wil-
mington; and 2 feet to Fayetteville, 115 miles above Wilmington.
Fayetteville is the head of navigation. Low-water stages prevail
from two to four months during each summer, and freshets, which
raise the water level from 15 to 50 feet at Fayetteville (the effects
lower down being less marked), usually occur as often as once a month
during the rest of the year. They do not occur with any regularity,
however.
   The commerce for 1908 was estimated at 137,620 tons, estimated to
be worth $3,960,235.
   Locks and dams.-The act of June 13, 1902, appropriated $50,000
for the purchase of sites for locks and dams. A careful survey, con-
suming more than eleven months' time, was made for the purpose of
locating the sites. This survey has been completed, the sites tenta-
tively located, a number of borings made at each site, the locations
approved, and prices obtained on all the lands necessary.
   The balance of this appropriation for lock and dam improvement,
$35,317.77, has been covered into the surplus fund, in accordance
with section 10 of the sundry civil act of March 4, 1909.
   Abstracts of the titles were made and turned over to the United
States district attorney for examination. The titles to the land needed
at lower site were approved and the land purchased.
    Owing to the fact that Congress has directed a reexamination of
this river, with a view to a possible modification of the project, the
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   311
purchase of the other land has been delayed, as its purchase may not
be required.
   No estimate is submitted for further work on the existing project
for locks and dams, pending action by Congress on the modified
plan for this improvement contained in House Document No. 890,
Sixtieth Congress, first session, which is based on the reexamination
authorized by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907.
   The expenditures to June 30, 1909, on said project for surveys,
other preliminaries, and purchasing land at lower site, amounted to
$14,682.23.
  The expenditures for the year were for inspection and office
expenses.
  References: Annual Reports for 1872, page 742: 1881, page 1018:
1901, page 1559; and 1904, page 1493.
       CAPE FEAR       RIVER ABOVE      WILMINGTON       (OPEN    CHANNEL            IMPROVEMENT).

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...                      ................................ $7, 371. 56
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement. ............................................................                3, 205. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                                 4,166. 56
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....................................                               500. 62
July 1, 1909, balance available .....................             ..       ................           3, 665. 94
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...---------------------------------------------                                   (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                            CONSOLIDATED.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................                            $13, 573.95
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..---..----------..-----------..--............-------------------.........---..  10,000. 00
                                                                                                     23, 573. 95
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement......-................. ..........     . .................                              5, 871. 34
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                               17, 702. 61
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities............-.........................                           1,063.28
July 1, 1909, balance available.................                       ..................            16, 639.33
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.......----       .-...................-......       14, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.  -


                CAPE    FEAR   RIVER ABOVE        WILMINGTON, LOCKS              AND        DAMS.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...- ...--....---              --...-----....-....
                                                               --....                               $35, 526. 11
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.......... -- ....               ---........... $208.34
    Covered into the surplus fund-..............--- ...-- ...-        ... 35, 317. 77
                                                                                                     35, 526. 11
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 1, 300, 000. 00
  (See Appendix M 11.)
   12. Cape Fear River, North Carolina, at and below Wilmington.-
The condition of the river prior to the opening of New Inlet (which
seems to have occurred during an equinoctial storm in 1761) is rather
                       a See consolidated money statement on this page.
312     REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,       U.   S. ARMY.

uncertain, but old maps indicate that there was a low-water depth of
14 feet across the bar at the mouth, the least depth between Wil-
mington and the mouth being 7.5 feet. There is also some uncer-
tainty as to the conditions in 1829, when the improvement was first
undertaken by the United States, but the most reliable information is
that there was then about 7 to 7.5 feet at low water in the river, about
9 feet in Baldhead channel, 9 feet in the Rip channel, and 10 feet at
New Inlet. Work on the bar was first begun in 1853, at which time
the bar depths at low water were 7.5 feet in Baldhead channel, 7
feet in Rip channel, and 8 feet at New Inlet, the governing low-water
depths in the river having been increased to 9 feet.
   The original project of 1827 was to deepen by jetties the channel
through the shoals in the 8 miles next below Wilmington. This
project resulted in a gain of 2 feet available depth. The project of
1853 was to straighten and deepen the bar channel by dredging, jetty-
ing, diverting flow from the New Inlet, and closing breaches in Zekes
Island. This project was incomplete when the civil war began.
   After the civil war the first project was that of 1870, to deepen the
bar channel by closing breaches between Smiths and Zekes Islands,
with the ultimate closure of New Inlet in view. The project of 1873
included that of 1870, and in addition the dredging of the bar chan-
nel and closing of New Inlet. The project of 1874 was to obtain by
dredging a channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep at low water up to
Wilmington. The project of 1881 was to obtain by dredging a chan-
nel 270 feet wide and 16 feet deep at low water up to Wilmington.
These projects had been practically completed in 1889.
   The project adopted September 19, 1890 (see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1889, p. 1132), is to obtain a mean low-water
depth of 20 feet and a width of 270 feet from Wilmington to the
ocean, at an estimated cost of $1,800,000. This project was modified
by act of June 13, 1902, to authorize the construction of mooring
dolphins at Wilmington at a cost of $30,000, and to provide for the
removal of obstructions at mouth of Brunswick River, at an esti-
mated cost of $1,000. The project was modified by the river and
harbor act of March 2, 1907, which provides for continuing improve-
ment in accordance with report submitted in House Document No.
545, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session, for completion of the 20-foot
project to the projected width, by dredging and the excavation of a
mooring basin in lieu of constructing mooring dolphins at Wilming-
ton, involving a reduction in the estimate of cost to $1,392,750, in-
cluding removal of obstructions at mouth of Brunswick River. The
act also authorized improvement to such depth in excess of 20 feet as
appropriations for the work may permit, due regard being given to
the difference in tidal oscillation at the upper and lower portions of
the improvement, and authorizes so much as may be necessary of the
funds available to be applied to repairing the New Inlet and Swash
Defense dams. The cost of these repairs is estimated at $165,000.
Annual maintenance is estimated to cost $65,000.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated the sum
of $165,000 for improvement and authorized an additional expendi-
ture of $250,000, all of which has since been appropriated, and the
river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, provided an additional appro-
priation of $300,000 for this improvement.
   No contracts for improvement have yet been made.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                    81S
                                                        EXPENDITURES.

Prior to civil war (including balance transferred) ....................               $363, 228. 92
Since civil war on prior projects.......................................... 2, 102, 271. 93
On existing project to June 30, 1909:
    For improvement................................ $1, 430, 798. 54
    For maintenance .................      .............                447, 729. 45
                                                                                     1, 878, 527. 99
       Total.....................................................                   4, 344, 028. 84
   On September 17, 1906, a storm of extreme violence very materially
injured Swash Defense and New Inlet dams throughout their entire
length and wholly destroyed Swash Defense dam in several places.
   The total results obtained on the project up to the end of the fiscal
year may be summarized as follows:
   From the ocean to the lower end of Reaves Point Shoal there is a
22-foot mean low-water channel with a least width of 150 feet. At
Reaves Point the channel is 20 feet deep and 270 feet wide, and from
Reaves Point to Wilmington there is a channel 22 to 24 feet deep of
varying widths. The repairs to Swash Defense dams are about 60
per cent completed.
    The average rise of the tides is 41 feet at the ocean bar, 31 feet at
Keg Island, and 21 feet at Wilmington.
    The distance from the ocean bar to Wilmington is 30 miles, and the
river is navigable 115 miles farther up to Fayetteville, the head of
navigation.
    The additional work proposed with funds on hand and the addi-
tional sum requested is toward the prosecution of the project and
maintenance during the progress of the improvement.
    The commerce of the year 1908 amounted to 864,071 tons, valued
at $49,753,175.
   The commerce consisted principally of cotton, cotton-seed meal,
naval stores, manufactured lumber, shingles, fertilizers, fertilizer
material, coal, gum logs, cross ties, and general merchandise.
    As a result of the improvement, vessels coming to Wilmington are,
much larger than formerly, the average tonnage in 1886 being 421,
while in 1908 the average was 1,345. This increase in tonnage has
caused a corresponding decrease in freight rates on shipments by water.
    References: For special descriptions, see Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1873, page 44; 1887, page 1047; 1895, page
1335; 1896, page 1131; 1901, page 1552, and 1907, page 287.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................         $280, 071. 30
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909....................................................        300, 000. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 100, 000. 00
Amount received from sales during fiscal year ...........................       250. 37
                                                                                         680, 321. 67
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..........................                  $202, 865. 56
    For maintenance of improvement......................                  60, 000. 00
                                                                                        a 262, 865. 56,

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................                ........
                                                                             ...... 417, 456. 11
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..........................................      17, 076. 36.
July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                   b 400, 379. 75

a Exclusive of $1,000 expended in work at Fort Caswell for the Quartermaster's
Department, for which this appropriation is to receive reimbursement.
b Includes the $1,000 reimbursement due from the Quartermaster's Department.
314       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
   the balance unexpended July 1, 1909..........................       $500, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix M 12.)
   13. Shallotte River, North Carolina.-Before improvement was
begun the channel depth on the ocean bar was about 3 feet at low
water and 7 feet at high water. From the bar to a point 21 miles
above there is a 5-foot low-water channel; the next 1 miles was badly
obstructed by mud flats and oysters rocks, over which there was about
1 foot depth at low water. From this point to the town of Shallotte,
8 miles farther up, the river was narrow and crooked and the low-
water depth varied from 2 to 12 feet.
   Act of Congress approved March 2, 1907, appropriated $3,000 to
be expended on this river. This appropriation not being based on
any previous project, the project submitted to and approved by the
Chief of Engineers for the expenditure of the funds available became
the project.
   This project is to dredge a channel 35 feet wide and 4 feet deep
at low water, following the best water along the western shore, be-
tween a point 21 miles above the inlet and a point 4 miles above the
inlet.
   Active work of improvement began June 22, 1908, and the proj-
ect was completed August 8, 1908. The amount expended on
project to June 30, 1909, was $3,000, all of which was for improve-
ment.
   The river is tidal, there being a rise and fall of tide of approxi-
mately 3 feet at the town of Shallotte, which is the head of schooner
navigation.
   At mean low water a draft of 4 feet can now be carried to Old Still
Landing and 2 feet about 2 miles farther up to the town of Shallotte,
which is practically the head of navigation.
   The commerce for the year 1908 amounted to 4,190 tons, valued at
$227,569, and consisted principally of general merchandise, naval
stores, etc.
   The volume of commerce reported for 1908 shows a decrease of
over 50 per cent compared with that of 1907. It is not believed,
however, that there has been such a falling off as is indicated, but that
the amounts reported for 1907 by the parties interested were more
than that actually carried. It is therefore believed that the commerce
reported for 1908 is more nearly correct.
   The effect of the proposed improvement on freight rates is not
known, but the stream affords an outlet to products, which have no
outlet except by wagon.
   Reference: See Annual Report 1890, page 1184, and 1907, page
1252.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................... $2, 843. 17
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works if improve-
  ment..............................................................    2,843.17
   (See Appendix M 13.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     315

   14. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering
navigation.--An allotment of $100 was made from this appropriation
on December 26, 1907, for removing two wrecks opposite the western
end of the military reservation of Fort Caswell, N. C., near the mouth
of the Cape Fear River, North Carolina.
   At the close of the fiscal year no work had been done. The expen-
diture during the year amounted to $25.52.

EXAMINATIONS    AND SURVEYS MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
               HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports on preliminary examinations and surveys required by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities
within this district were duly submitted by the district officer. They
were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors,
pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in
documents as indicated:
   1. Preliminary examination and survey of New River, North Caro-
lina, with a view to obtaining a depth of 5 feet from its mouth to Jack-
sonville.-Reports dated September 11, 1907, and June 22, 1908,
respectively, are printed in House Document No. 1085, Sixtieth Con-
gress, second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost
of $6,700 is presented.
    2. Preliminaryexamination and survey qf Beaufort Inlet and Harbor,
North Carolina,with a view to securing a channel depth of 25 feet across
the bar.-Reports dated July 23, 1907, and October 1, 1908, respec-
tively, are printed in House Document No. 1454, Sixtieth Congress,
second session. The locality is not considered worthy of improvement
by the General Government to the extent of providing a channel
depth of 25 feet across the bar.
   3. Preliminaryexamination and survey of Trent River, North Caro-
lina, with a view to obtaining8 feet of waterfrom Newbern to Trenton.-
Reports dated August 27, 1907, and October 3, 1908, respectively,
are printed in House Document No. 1471, Sixtieth Congress, second
session. A plan for obtaining and maintaining a navigable depth of
4 feet up to Trenton at an estimated cost of $15,000 is presented.

  IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE CHARLESTON,
                SOUTH CAROLINA, DISTRICT:

   This district was in the charge of Capt. E. R. Stuart, Corps of Engi-
neers, to July 13, 1908; in the temporary charge of Col. Dan C.
Kingman, Corps of Engineers, from July 13 to July 24, 1908; in the
charge of Capt. E. M. Adams, Corps of Engineers, from July 24,
1908, to June 2, 1909, and in the temporary charge of Capt. Earl
I. Brown, Corps of Engineers, since June 2, 1909. Division engineer,
Col. Dan C. Kingman, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Waccamaw River, North Carolina and South Carolina, and
Little Pedee River, South Carolina.-(a) Waccamaw River.-In 1880
this stream was navigable for 12-foot-draft boats at all stages of
water from Georgetown, 23 miles, to Bull Creek, and at high water 4
miles farther, to Bucks lower mills; thence for 7-foot-draft boats, at
high water, 22 miles farther, to Conway; thence it possessed an
obstructed channel for 3-foot-draft boats, at ordinary winter water, 68
316             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                              U.   S. ARMY.

miles, to Reeves Ferry; thence an obstructed channel, with 3 feet at
high water, for 30 miles, to Lake Waccamaw.
  The project of improvement, adopted in 1880, provides for a chan-
nel 12 feet deep at all stages of water, with 80 feet bottom width from
the mouth of the river to Conway, thence a cleared channel to Lake
Waccamaw.
   The original estimated cost was $29,370, which was revised in 1885
and increased in the annual report of that year to the present figure,
$138,400. In the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1886,
page 170, maintenance is estimated at $4,000 per year after comple-
tion of improvement.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $143,552.79. The
river had been cleared of snags to a distance of 128 miles above the
mouth, and this portion of the river had been frequently resnagged as
appropriations permitted, 46,201 snags, etc., having been removed
since June 30, 1884. Some work had been done toward increasing the
original depth on eight shoals below Conway. As nearly as can be
determined from the records, about $75,977.81 had been expended in
originally snagging the lower 128 miles of the river and in construct-
ing pile and plank dikes at eight shoals, and $35,435.11 in main-
tenance.
   Dredging was begun in 1903 to obtain a 6-foot channel below Con-
way and to straighten the river by cutting through the worst bends.
The expenditure during the year was for continuing this work at
Thoroughfare Cut-off; the total amount of material removed during
the year was 23,731 cubic yards, and the aggregate to June 30, 1909,
139,500 cubic yards.
   The approved project is about 85 per cent completed.
   The available depths reported as now existing do not differ greatly
from the original depths. At mean low water about 12 feet can be
carried to Bucksville, 34 miles above the mouth; 6 feet to Conway,
50 miles; about 2 feet to Wortham's bridge, 97 miles. At high
water large side-wheelers can go to Red Bluff, 74 miles, and small
boats to Reeves Ferry, 117 miles.
   Lake Waccamaw, 147 miles above the mouth, is the head of navi-
gation.
   The usual variation in water level is about 7.5 feet at Conway, 50
miles above the mouth, and about 12 feet at Star Bluff, 84 miles
above the mouth.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to dredging and
snagging.
   The tidal influence at low water extends 97 miles above the mouth.
                                               Commercial statistics.


               Year.                   Tons.      Value.               Year.              Tons.   Value.


1902.....................              141,686   $1,844,019 1906.....................     244,920 $3,720,000
1903......................             143,813    1,884,700 1907....................      295,135 4,050,550
1904 ...........           .........   190,435    2,119,040 1908.......................    93,743  3,258,677
1905-........................          207,630    2,665,917
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMEN TS.                                             317
   The vessels engaged in traffic on this river are steamers and tug-
boats of from 10 to 550 tons, seagoing schooners of from 300 to 500
tons, pole boats, rafts, etc. The additional work proposed is neces-
sary to make the improvement available.
   No new line of transportation was established during the year.
   For references to examinations and surveys, see page 246, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1904.
   It has been found impossible to obtain information concerning the
effect of the improvement on freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......                               ..........................   $2, 491. 71
Receipts, account of sales .............................................                                 20.01
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1909 ........................ ................................                             4, 000. 00
                                                                                                     6, 511.72
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.........................................................                                      2,344.50

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                 4, 167. 22

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 28, 800. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
    balance unexpended July 1, 1909 .....                                                               (.............................
                                                                                                        (a)
  Submitted in compliance with requirement of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Little Pedee River.-The river in its original condition was
much obstructed by snags and overhanging trees and by 10 bridges
without draws. In places it was divided into several branches, in
none of which was there a good channel.
   Under the plan of improvement adopted in 1.888 it is proposed to
snag the river and close unnecessary branches, providing for steam-
boat navigation up to the mouth of Lumber River, 65 miles, and for
pole-boat navigation 48 miles farther, to Little Rock, at an estimated
cost of $50,000.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1909, were $25,074.01. The
river had been well snagged up to the mouth of Lumber River and
roughly cleared for pole-boat navigation to Little Rock. No work
had been done toward increasing the original depths. As nearly as
could be determined from the records, about $19,549.99 had been
expended in originally snagging the river, and about $5,524.02 in
maintenance. About 50 per cent of the project has been completed.
   There were no operations during the year. Expenditures shown,
$21, were for repairs to plant.
   The aggregate number of obstructions removed since beginning of
the improvement in 1888 is 31,718.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to snagging por-
tions of the river as yet untouched and to work of maintenance.
   The available depths now existing do not probably differ greatly
from the original depths. No permanent improvement can be effected
toward increasing the maximum draft over the shoals without con-
siderable dredging, which was not provided for in the original
project. The usual variation in water level at Gilchrist Bridge, about
65.5 miles above the mouth, is about 9.5 feet.
                            a See consolidated money statement on page 318.
318            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                  Commercial statistics.

              Year.                  Tons.          Value.               Year.                    Tons.     Value.

1891..........................            4,614      $52,760   1900........................   23,780         $173,500
1892........................ 7,115                    92,964   1901........................   51,460          399,000
1893........................              6,153      101,535   1902......................   . 57,050          416,000
1894.................        .........    8,375      114,600   1903...........................77,750          560,500
1895........................             12,438      117,470   1904 ....................      83,100          645,000
1896........................17,050                   198,500   1905........................   87,985          663.650
1897.........................            13,162      100,400   1906........................   18,880          389,500
1898.......            ................. 11,900      105,750   1907........................   14,513          243,250
1899............................         16,685      144,787   1908.......................... 11,992           97,290



   Vessels ply on the river as far as Gallivant's bridge, 47 miles above
its mouth; the river is probably navigable at its mean low-water
stage for boats with 3-foot draft as far as Gallivant's bridge. The
head of navigation is Little Rock, 113 miles above the mouth. No
new line of transportation was established during the year.
   The balance on hand will be spent in maintaining the channel.
   For outline map of river, see page 1214, Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1890. For preliminary examination and survey, see
page 1111, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887.
   It has been found impossible to obtain information as to the effect
of the improvement on freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................... $1, 646. 99
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...................................................           21.00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................                             ..............            1, 625. 99
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 23, 300.00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909.. .............................                                            (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                                   CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                 $4, 138.70
Receipts, account of sales ...........................                 ..............       20. 01
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....    ........                  .......
                                              .....       ...........     ............  4, 000. 00
                                                                                                           8, 158. 71
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement . ...........          .......                   .......         $2, 344.50
    For maintenance of improvement .......................                                         21.00
                                                                                                           2, 365.50

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ...............................                                          5, 793. 21

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......... 52, 100. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909.................................       44, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix N 1.)

                         a See consolidated money statement on this page.
                                  RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                         319

   2. Lynch River and Clark Creek, South Carolina.-Lynch River
is a tributary of the Great Pedee River, into which it flows a few
miles above Smiths Mills at a point about 65 miles above the mouth
of the Great Pedee River. Shortly above this point a branch of
Lynch River, known as Clark Creek, leaves it, and, flowing about
7 miles, empties into the Great Pedee River about 101 miles below
the mouth of Lynch River. The mouth of Lynch River was com-
pletely filled with drift coming in from the Great Pedee River, thus
forcing all traffic to come down Clark Creek. Its upper end was also
choked by this drift.
   The project of improvement adopted in 1888 provided for roughly
clearing a channel in Clark Creek, to afford an outlet for Lynch
River. The estimated cost was $7,500. The money was appropriated
from 1888 to. 1892, inclusive, and was expended in roughly clearing a
channel 40 feet wide and 3 feet deep. As no further appropriations
were made, the channel filled up and no permanent improvement was
effected.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $2,000
for improving Lynch River and Clark Creek by the removal of logs
and snags. The adopted project provides for removing obstruc-
tions, as far as these funds will allow, to permit the passage of rafts
through the lower end of Clark Creek through a small connecting
stream between Clark Creek and Lynch River, known as Lawrence
Cut, and through Lynch River.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, under the existing project
was $1,225.67.
   During the year no work was done on account of high stage of
water and small balance available.
                                                        Commercial statistics.

Year.                                                                                                        Tons.    Value.

1906   Outward freights, logs .......................................................                       3,552      $13,000
1907   Outward freights, logs.....................................                      .................   1, 500      15,000
1908   Timber .......................................................................                       2,000       25, 000



   There is no other commerce on this stream.
   There is no navigation, save by rafts.
   For map of Clark Creek, see page 1204, Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers, 1890. For reports of examinations of Lynch River, see
Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1881, page 1038; 1893,
page 1532; and 1900, page 1877.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                                                 $629. 75
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                                                 629.75
    (See Appendix N 2.)
   3. Great Pedee River, South Carolina.-The river in its original
condition was dangerously obstructed by logs everywhere. Boats
drawing 9 feet of water were able to reach Smiths Mills, 52 miles
above the mouth. Those drawing 31 feet could get 54 miles farther
up at low water to Little Bluff, or at high water to Cheraw, 167 miles
from the mouth.
320           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                          U.     S. ARMY.

   The project of improvement adopted in 1880 provides for a thor-
oughly cleared 9-foot navigation to Smiths Mills and a 3 -foot navi-
gation to Cheraw at all stages of water.
   The original project contained no estimate of cost. From 1880 to
1886, inclusive, $47,000 was appropriated. In the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1886, page 170, it was estimated that
 $70,000 in addition to this $47,000 would complete the improvement,
and that $5,000 a year would be required for maintenance.
   A project for the improvement of the upper river (the 64 miles
between Cheraw and the bridge of the Wilmington, Columbia and
Augusta Railroad) was adopted in 1902. (See Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1901, p. 1607.) This project provides for
obtaining, by snagging and dredging, a cleared channel, with a least
depth of 32 feet at mean low water, at a cost of $118,300; and the
work was placed in the continuing-contract class. This total amount
has been appropriated.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1909, were $256,873.48.
   The river had been well cleared of snags from the mouth to the
Wilmington, Columbia and Augusta Railroad bridge, 103 miles,
and less thoroughly snagged between the bridge and Cheraw, 48,466
snags, etc., having been removed since June 30, 1884..
   As nearly as could be determined by the records, about $78,919.13
had been expended in originally clearing the river of snags and in
preliminary examination and survey made in 1900, $104,793.28 in
dredging, and about $73,161.07 in maintenance.
   The expenditures during the year were for operation of dredge and
snag boats, for prosecuting the improvement, and for maintenance in
the removal of 142,445 cubic yards of dredged material and 3,733
obstructions.
   About 99 per cent of the approved project for the upper river has
been completed up to June 30, 1909. The contemplated depth (31
feet) has been attained on the upper portion of the river.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to redredging and"
snagging for maintenance of the improvement from the mouth of the
river up to Cheraw.
   At mean low water 8 feet can be carried to Smiths Mills, 52 miles
above the mouth, and about 3 feet to Cheraw, the head of naviga-
tion, 167 miles above the mouth.
   The usual variation in water level is 16.4 feet at Smiths Mills and
34.2 feet at Cheraw.
                                            Commercial statistics.

            Year.                 Tons.       Value.                      Year.                          Tons.      Value.


1891..........................    62,344    $1,367,330    1900.......................                    154,727    $2,645,560
1892........................      92,471     1,401,038    1901 .......................                   188, 912    2,811,080
1893 ........................     94, 661    1,166, 874   1902. ......................                   152,008     1,328, 970
1894 ........................     91,025     1,169,070    1903.......................                    153,014     1,338,759
1895.........................    106,115       893,430    1904 ...................               ..      162,566     1,507,181
1896 ........................  .229,964      1,325,250    1905.......................                    148,869     1,618,551
1897........................     114,177     1,167,914    1906.......................                    175,250     1,751,475
1898 ........................     75,280     1,228, 885   1907. .......................                  229,898     1,957,388
1899........................     134, 072    1,692,709    1908. .........               ... ..........    48, 690    1,559, 543



   The vessels engaged in traffic on this river are steamers of 400 tons
and less, seagoing schooners, pole boats, rafts, etc. No new line of
transportation was established during the year.
                        RIVER AND IARBOR IlPROVEMENTS.                                             321

   One steamer which formerly ran to Cheraw was discontinued.
   For references to examinations and surveys, see page 249, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
   It has been found impossible to obtain information as to the effect
of the improvement on freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..-..... .......... ......                   ............... $42, 387. 62
Receipts, account of sales.............................................                            19.96
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.................---....................                 ..... ... ........    10, 000. 00
                                                                                             52, 407. 58
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...............................                  $10,119.72
    For maintenance of improvement ........................                   23, 841. 38
                                                                                             33, 961. 10
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                      18, 446.48
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.....................................                   1, 119.57
July 1, 1909, balance available.....................                 .....   ...........     17, 326.91
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909---------------------------------.....---------30, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix N 3.)
   4. Winyah Bay, South Carolina.-This large bay is connected with
the ocean by a passage between the shores of North and South islands
2 - miles long, 1 mile wide at the bay, three-fourths mile wide at the
gorge, and 11 miles wide at the ocean, or southeasterly, end of North
Island. Through the passage, which trends north-northwest and
south-southeast, there was a bold channel 36 feet deep at the bay,
retaining a depth of not less than 20 feet until about 3,000 feet south-
erly from the end of North Island and of not less than 15 feet to a
point about 1 mile south of the island, where the channel divided into
two. One of these two channels, known as Main channel, continued 31
miles farther, through extensive shoals, to the 18-foot contour in the
ocean. This channel was south-southeast and in alignment with the
main channel through the straits. The other, known as Bottle chan-
nel, after flowing about 2,500 feet southeasterly, 1,500 feet easterly,
and about 3,000 feet northeasterly, reached the 18-foot contour in the
ocean at a distance of about 1 miles in a direction from the point of
separation from the main ship channel almost at right angles with
the direction of that channel and of the channel through the passage.
At mean low water the depth on the crest of the bar was variable in
both channels and about 7 to 9 feet in Main channel and 6 to 8 feet in
Bottle channel. The mean range of tide is 3 feet.
   The present project, adopted in 1889, provides for the construction
of two jetties, springing, respectively, from North and South islands
and converging toward the bar, the jetties to consist of mattress foun-
dation and a superstructure of large riprap stone raised to a height
of 6 feet above mean low water, the south jetty to extend due east
across the bar and the north jetty to converge toward it, so as to pro-
duce the necessary contraction on the bar. The depth to be secured
is 15 feet at mean low water. The river and harbor act of June 3,
        9001-ENG 1909-21
322              REPORT OF THE CHIEF                              OF ENGINEERS, U.                    S. ARMY.

1896, authorized the completion of the work under continuing-con-
tract system, at a cost not exceeding $1,996,250, in addition to the
$20,000 appropriated by the act. The entire amount has been appro-
priated by sundry civil acts since that date. The project was extended
by the river and harbor act approved June 13, 1902, to permit dredg-
ing at the shoal places in Winyah Bay, between the entrance and the
city of Georgetown, S. C., over which the least channel depths might
at any time be less than at the entrance to the bay, provided that
the expenses of this dredging, added to that of improving the entrance
to the bay, should not exceed the total amount authorized under the
continuing-contract system.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1909, were $2,491,909.33, of
which $428,750 was appropriated prior to June 3, 1896. Of this
amount $6,252.36 was derived from miscellaneous sources, such as
rent of dredge, auction sales, etc. For maintenance, $93,791.79 has
been spent. The jetty work, which since June 3, 1896, had been under
a continuing contract, had been completed. The north jetty extends
a distance of 11,139 feet from the shore end, with crest from 41 to 6
feet above mean low water, except the outer 100 feet, which is sub-
merged. The south jetty extends a distance of 21,051 feet from the
shore end, with crest at heights varying from 10 feet above mean low
water at the inner end to nothing at the outer end. The stone super-
structure has practically no top width. A stone mound, 50 feet long,
30 feet wide, and 12 feet above low water had been constructed to
mark the outer end of the south jetty. The seagoing suction dredge
  Winyah Bay has been built, and this dredge and the similar dredge
Charleston have removed 1,553,271 cubic yards of material from the
entrance channel and 1,179,274 cubic yards of material from the east-
ern channel in upper Winyah Bay and Sampit River shoal. Spur
dikes have been built to protect the South Island beach. A mud dike
has been built from the high land on South Island to the high land
near the Santee River to prevent the tides from cutting around the
shore end of the south jetty, and the stonework of the jetty has been
extended about 2,600 feet by a work of sheet piling covered with mud
to connect with this dike.
   The approved project was practically completed by June 30, 1909.
Slight shoaling has occurred during the year in portions of the channel
where the depth is slightly less than 15 feet; these shoal places will
be removed during the coming fiscal year.
    The appropriation recommended will be applied to dredging for
maintenance of the improvement.
                                                      Commercial statistics.

                 Year.                       Tons.       Value.                     Year.                      Tons.   Value.


1891........................                 261,370 $8,071,600      1901.......................               247,989 $8,457,906
1892........................                 271,986 ..........          .......................               387,471 9,310,682
1893 .........................               268,640 ............    1903 ............           .........     368,502  9,359,581
1894...........                .. ........   293,822 ............    1904........................              369,774  9,546,843
1896............... ...........              171,059     6,228,350   1905........................              363,916 10,401,879
1897.........................                149,374     5,817,950   1906........................              392,770 10,139,751
1898.........................                125,003     5,587,880   1907-........................             382,915 9,432,575
1899 .........................                20,587     6,337,853   1908.....................             .   283,470  8,078,583
1900 .........................               129,639     6,749,433
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                    323

   The vessels using the entrance channel are steamers of 1,850 tons
and less and sailing vessels of various kinds. The freight carried is
principally lumber, naval stores, and general merchandise. There
are three lines of steamships plying between Georgetown and north-
ern ports. The water rate on lumber, the chief export, had decreased
from $5.50 per thousand feet B. M. in 1892 to $4.12- in 1905, but it
has since advanced to $6.
   For references to examinations and surveys see page 250, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................    $48, 339. 81
Receipts, account of sales, etc ........................................       65. 29
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909. ....................                     ....    ............         ............      15, 000.00

                                                                                                         63, 405. 10
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .............................                                $24, 615. 40
    For maintenance of improvement ......................                                  24, 381. 38
                                                                                                         48, 996. 78

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                    14, 408. 32
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities         -.................. '....             ...   ..........      1, 720. 26

July 1, 1909, balance available                                        ....-..
                                                                  -..............     .............      12, 688. 06
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
    pended July 1, 1909 ...............................................                                  40, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix N 4.)
   5. Mingo Creek, South Carolina.-To June 30, 1897, $17,000 had
been expended on improvement to provide steamboat navigation up
to Williams Landing and pole-boat navigation at high water up to
the head of navigation by snagging and clearing the banks.
   Deterioration having occurred, the sum of $300 was allotted from
the emergency appropriation provided by the river and harbor act
of March 2, 1907, of which $257.75 had been expended during the
fiscal year 1908, for removing the worst obstructions to navigation.
   No work was done during the past year. The small amount
available was held for removing obstructions blocking or seriously
interfering with navigation.
   It is proposed to apply the appropriation recommended to snag-
ging to maintain the channel.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................                                    $42. 25
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended............................................                                 42. 25
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...........................................       1, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix N 5.)
  6. Santee, Wateree, and Congaree rivers, and Estherville-Minim
Creek Canal, South Carolina.-(a) Santee River and Estherville-
Minim Creek Canal.-This river in its original condition was consid-
erably obstructed at all stages of water by sunken logs and snags.
324           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                             S. ARMY.

Its bar entrance was narrow, crooked, and shifting, with only about
4 feet of water at low tide, and so situated as to be difficult and expen-
sive to improve.
   The original project, adopted in 1880, contemplated providing an
outlet for the river into Winyah Bay by constructing a canal from
the river through Mosquito Creek into the bay. On this project
there was expended $99,750.
   The present project, adopted in 1889, contemplates providing a
more satisfactory outlet into the bay by cutting a canal 70 feet wide
and 6 feet deep at mean low water from the Estherville plantation to
Minim Creek and for snagging the entire river. The estimated cost
is $350,000, not including the amount expended under the original
project.
   The total expenditures under the present project to June 30, 1909,
were $241,902.26, of which about $57,316.52 was for maintenance;
of this, $32.50 was derived from sales at auction, etc. All the ex-
penditure during the year was for maintenance, and consisted of the
removal of 34,024 cubic yards of material and 54 stumps and logs
from the canal, widening and deepening same. The first cut of the
canal had been made entirely through, and this had been widened
through a portion of its length. From the Santee River proper 1,818
obstructions had been removed.
   The approved project is about 84 per cent completed.
   Except at the Winyah Bay end, where on account of the softness
of the banks the width has been reduced to 40 feet, the canal is 50
feet wide and 6 feet deep. The mean rise of tide at the canal is about
3 feet. The least available depth in Santee River is about 4 feet at
low water. The usual variation in water level at the Atlantic Coast
Line bridge, about 54 miles above the mouth, is about 19 feet, and
at its junction with the Wateree and Congaree rivers, 143 miles above
the mouth, about 20 feet. The river is navigable its entire length.
  During the year the construction of a suction dredge was completed,
for which the appropriation for this stream bears a part of the cost.
For this there was an expenditure of $4,217.67. For dredging in the
canal $10,784.21 was expended.
  The appropriation recommended will be applied to widening the
Estherville-Minim Creek Canal, and to removing obstructions from
Santee River.
   The additional work proposed is necessary to make the improve-
ments available and for extending the benefits.
                                         Commercial statistics.

             Year.               Tons.       Value.                     Year.                         Tons.     Value.


1891.........................    100,255 82,743,000    1900........................                   179,090   $2,622,200
1892.... .....................   110,523  2,775,800    1901_.. ....-.-             . ....-        .   204,375    1,809,000
1893 ........................    124,182 2,679,600     1902 ..............                .......     215,600    1,882,500
1894 ........................    115,428  2,375,000    1903..-----------------------....  ......      220,900    1,840,000
1895 .........................   117,690  2,224,800    1904........................                   242,800    1,652. 500
1896.........................    134,135  2,204,600                                  ....
                                                       1905 ..-----------------------.......          329,350    1,485,000
1897.........................    134,206  2,159,940    1906........................                   427,300    1,830,000
1898............ .............   112,205  2,203,800    1907........................                   474,750    1,735,000
1899 .........................   154,327  2,679,100    1908 ........................                   70,590    1,172,169
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           325

  The vessels using the river and canal are steamers of from 10 to 500
tons, small sailing craft, pole boats, rafts, etc.
  For references to examination and surveys and other information
concerning the work see page 252, Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers, 1904.
  It has been found impossible to obtain information as to the effect
of the improvement on freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............- .....                                     ....-........       .. $21, 132.12
Receipts, account of sales--------------------------.....-----------------                                             76. 05
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909--....-----..-------------------.......... .------------............---------.......--........      5, 600. 00
                                                                                                              26, 808. 17
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    Transferred to allotment for Congaree River.............. $5, 000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement .......................    15, 001. 88
                                                                                                              20, 001. 88

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                                          6, 806. 29
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities--... --..-... - - --......---...-
                                                                    -....                                           27. 60

July 1, 1909, balance available ......................                               .............        .     6, 778.69

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 109, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909....................................                                            (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Wateree River.-In its original condition this stream had a
low-water depth of from 3 to 4 feet from its mouth, 67 miles, to
Camden. The lower 14 miles was completely blocked at all stages of
water by logs, snags, etc., and at moderate stages by the bridges of
the South Carolina and the Wilmington, Columbia and Augusta
railroads, then without draw spans; thence to Camden navigation
was possible, but dangerous, except during high water. Its com-
merce was practically nothing.
   The present project of improvement, adopted in 1881, provides for
safe and unobstructed 4-foot navigation for steamers from Camden
to the mouth, at an estimated cost of $60,000.
   The appropriation of September 19, 1890, completed the estimate
for the project, but appropriations have since been made for main-
tenance. The work is one of snagging and dredging, and as snags are
continually lodging, it is not susceptible of completion. Snagging
work should be done annually in order to keep the channel open.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1909, were $140,699.45. To
June 30, 1900, the river had been kept fairly clear of obstructions from
the mouth to Camden. Work was suspended in 1899, and was resumed
in May, 1907, a snag boat having been built for this stream. All the
expenditures during the year were for maintenance.
   Snagging was done during the year and a total of 1,871 obstructions
were removed.
   Toward the construction of a suction dredge an expenditure of
 $4,100 was made under contract for machinery; for machinery for a
snag boat there was expended $8,665.25 under contracts.
                          a See consolidated money statement on page 329.
326              REPORT OF THE CHIEF                          OF ENGINEERS, U.                S. ARMY.

   The appropriation recommended will be applied to snagging and
dredging for maintenance of the improvement.
   The additional work proposed is necessary to make the improve-
ment available.
   So far as known the available depths now existing do not differ
greatly from the original depths. The usual variation in water level
is about 17 feet at a point about 4 miles above the mouth, and about
28.5 feet at Camden, 67 miles above the mouth.
   The river is navigable from the mouth to Camden.
                                                   Commercial statistics.

                Year.                    Tons.       Value.                  Year.                    Tons.        Value.


1891 ........................              1,005      $51,210    1900........................                    93,024 $155,000
1892 ........................              2,244       86,040    1901............------........-------------.... 10,417   50,000
1893 ...............           .. ....     6,242      117,729    1902........................                    42,575   92,500
1894 ........................             18,075       94,334    1903...................--------------     ...   41,050   87,000
1895 .........................            21,697      127,565    1904------------.......................---      15,600   29,700
1896 ........................             35,002      233,525    1905...      ....................               22,000   41,000
1897.........................             43,770      202,800    1906...---------------------                    16,200   81,000
1898 ........................             83,568      274, 050   1907--------...--.....................-------------
                                                                                                                 56,400  564,000
1899 ........................            109,170      272,200    1908------------...............--------......   35,720  182,669



   Rafting is the only business done on this river. No new line of
transportation was established during the year.
   For references to examinations and surveys see page 253, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1904.
   It has been found impossible to obtain information as to the effect
of the improvement on freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                                      $46, 042. 98
Receipts, account of sales ............................................------------------------------------        9. 51
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909................ ..... ........ ........................                                      14, 300. 00
                                                                          60, 352. 49
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ........................................... ............... 39, 242. 43
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ............-.  ............--........                                        21, 110. 06
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....-..............................                                        5, 217. 04

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                                           15, 893. 02

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..................                                          1, 005. 97

  Amount that can be profitably expended' in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
    pended July 1, 1909......          .      .                  - - -----
                                                         --.-------                                                   (a)
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Congaree River.-In 1886 this stream in its original condition
had a low-water depth of 3 to 4 feet from its mouth to the railroad
bridge at Columbia, thence 1 foot low-water depth 2 miles farther
to its head. The navigation of the lower 49 miles was blocked at all
stages of water by the South Carolina Railroad bridge and by sunken
logs, snags, and overhanging trees. The navigation of the remaining
2 miles was prevented by swift currents and numerous rock ledges
and bowlders. Its commerce was nothing.
                               a See consolidated money statement on page 329.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     327
   The project of improvement adopted in 1886 proposes to secure a
thoroughly cleared 4-foot navigation over the lower 49 miles at all
stages of water and a cleared channel through the rock ledges and
bowlders above at an estimated cost of $54,500. This project was
modified in 1899, when a lock and dam was authorized for extending
steamboat navigation through these ledges and bowlders in the river
from Gervais Street Bridge, Columbia, to Granby. The open-channel
work above Granby was thus eliminated for the time being. Appro-
priations for the lock and dam were made, amounting to $250,000,
$25,000 of which, by authority of Congress, was allotted for the
open-channel work. The lock and dam had been completed with
the $225,000, and considerable work done in clearing the channel
between the lock and the city of Columbia.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, contained the following
proviso in appropriating for this stream: "And the limits of the
improvement of the Congaree River shall be extended to include that
part of the said river included in the project from Gervais Street
Bridge, Columbia, to Granby, South Carolina." Under this author-
ity the work on the entire length of the river will be prosecuted under
allotments from appropriations for improving Santee, Wateree, and
Congaree rivers and the Estherville-Minim Creek Canal, South
Carolina.
    In 1905 a survey of the river between the lock and dam and the
mouth of the river, made to determine what additional work was
required to form a 4-foot channel at all stages of water, showed that
in addition to clearing the river of obstructions by snagging, dredging
was also required, and that the estimated cost of the project should
be increased accordingly. To obtain and maintain this channel
would cost $20,000 a year for four years, after which a yearly expendi-
ture of $10,000 would probably suffice.
   The total expenditures for open-channel work to June 30, 1909,
were $132,241.80. The channel had been thoroughly snagged from
the mouth to Granby, 2 miles below Columbia. A total of 17,057
obstructions had been removed below Granby. Dredging had been
carried on, removing 157,143 cubic yards of sand and pebbles.
Work had been in progress of clearing the channel above the lock.
As nearly as can be determined from the records about $70,855.14
has been applied to work of maintenance.
    Snagging was done during the year and a total of 707 obstructions
were removed. During the year approximately 730 tons of rock
was removed. This rock excavation made it possible for steamers
to land at the foot of Senate street, Columbia, S. C.
    Under allotments from the emergency appropriation provided by
the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, made November 12, 1908
 ($5,125), and February 17, 1909 ($1,800), derrick A was operated forty-
six days in removing snags, dragging channel, dredging stone from
the rock cut, etc., to restore the channel depths above the lock;
about 393 tons of stone were removed; the dredge Congaree removed
from the channel 134,462 cubic yards of sand, and a 6-inch pump
was operated eighteen days pumping sand from the channel. The
expenditures from these allotments were $5,843.66, and were ren-
dered necessary by the extraordinary flood in the Congaree River
which occurred in August, 1908.
    It is thought that to secure safe and certain navigation of the
portion of the river above Granby it will be necessary to reconstruct
328            REPORT OF TI-HE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U.     S. ARMY.

the dam, so as to raise the pool level 2 feet, at an estimated cost of
$50,000.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to work of im-
provement in removing bars and obstructions between the mouth
and Columbia.
   The usual variation in water level at a point 2 miles above the
mouth is about 24.3 feet and at Columbia about 33.2 feet. Columbia
is the head of navigation and is distant 51 miles from the mouth.
                                             Commercial statistics.

             Year.                  Tons.       Value.                      Year.                       Tons.       Value.

1891 .......................         2,401       $47,840     1900.......................                121,363      $197,000
1892............... .........        3,686        62,025     1901 .......................                14,583        70,000
1893 ....................      ..    2,781        71,125     1902....................               .    58,075       123,500
1894 ........................        7,974        40,760     1903 .........               . .......     114.310       271,400
1895 .......................         8,993        45,700     1904........................                43,035        93,900
1896........................        18.307       178,900     1905.......................                 34,350       252,000
1897.........................       40,857       110,100     1906.....................                   35,522       821,100
1898 .........................      81,362       201,700     1907.......... ...........                  73,833     1,234,000
1899..........................      88,696       191,700     1908.....................                   22,122       506,994


   A steamboat line between Columbia and Georgetown, S. C., has
been established. Connection is made at Georgetown with steamers
for New York, Baltimore, and Charleston. Boats are now landing at
foot of Senate street, Columbia, S. C., the present head of navigation.
A reduction of from 22 to 30 per cent in freight rates from Columbia
to New York (difference between rail and water transportation) has
been effected by the improvement.
   For preliminary examination and survey, see page 1140, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885. For outline map of river,
see page 1194, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1889.
   For project for construction of lock and dam, see page 1182, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1896.
   Reference to report on examination made in compliance with the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, will be found on page 323 of
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                         $26, 487. 33
Receipts, account of sales............................................                                9. 51
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....................................................                            28, 100. 00
Transferred from allotment for Santee River ............................                         5, 000. 00
Allotment (emergency appropriation of March 2, 1907):
    November 12, 1908 ............................................                               5, 125.00
    February 17, 1909 ................                          ..............................   1, 800.00
                                                                                                                  66, 521. 84
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement. ..............   ..................................                                                36, 572. 79

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.. ....................... .............  ..                                      29, 949. 05
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....................................                                             847. 70

July 1, 1909, balance available.........................................                                          29, 101. 35

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
    balance unexpended July 1, 1909.................     .........   ...                                             (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                         a See consolidated money statement on page 329.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            329

                                                    CONSOLIDATED.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....                     .-........            .           ...........       .       $93, 662. 43
Receipts, account of sales---............................-----------------------------                  -                  95.07
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909----...... ...................                                                      .               . 48, 000. 00
Allotted (emergency appropriation of March 2, 1907):
    November 12, 1908 .........                                   .....-------------------------------------------     5, 125. CO
    February 17, 1909 .....--------..-----------...........-----------........--------------...............            1, 800.00

                                                                                                                 148, 682. 50
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement----------..--------.............-------------------......... .......-----..---..........            90, 817.10
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.                      .. ............ ......................                    57, 865.40
July 1, 1.909, outstanding liabilities                  ..... ........         ...............         .......    6, 092.34

July 1, 1909, balance available...-............. .                            .....    .............             51, 773.06

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts.................        1, 005. 97
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-.......... 109, 000.00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1.911., for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
   the balance unexpended July 1, 1909...--..-----.........-----------.........------.... 64, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix N 6.)
   7. Operating and care of lock and dam across Congaree River, near
Columbia, S. C.-This service is provided for by the permanent indefi-
nite appropriation for operating and care of canals and other works
of navigation, under the provisions of section 4 of the river and
harbor act of July 5, 1884, as amended and reenacted by section 6 of
the river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909.
   The operation and care of the lock and dam across the Congaree
River have been provided for by allotments from this appropriation
since April 7, 1906. The expenditures during the fiscal year were
$10,480.68; the total expenditures have been $21,284.19.
   A special emergency allotment of $4,175 was made February 18,
1909, to repair damages caused by extraordinary flood of August, 1908.
   (See Appendix N 7.)
   8. Inland waterways between Charleston Harbor, South Carolina,
and opposite Mc Clellanville.-These waterways consist of a series of
creeks, sounds, rivers, and bays, which afford a route sheltered for the
most part from the sea by the numerous islands which form the outer
coast line. The route is tidal throughout, the range of tide varying
from about 4.6 to 5.3 feet. It is now obstructed by a number of shal-
low reaches and narrow, crooked passages, particularly at points
where the tides meet. The passage across Bulls Bay, besides being
very shallow, is much exposed. The present commerce is compara-
tively small, as only very small vessels can get through without exces-
sive delays.
   The plan of improvement adopted in 1902 provides for a channel
between Charleston Harbor and opposite McClellanville 4 feet dleep
at mean low water and 60 feet bottom width, at an estimated cost of
$125,290. The project was modified by the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, to provide for a branch of the channel to Morrisons
Landing in McClellanville. The new channel will partly follow the
present channels and will partly lie in cuts across the marsh to avoid
crooked and dangerous sections. It will pass to the northward of
330                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                 U.   S. ARMY.

Bulls Bay. A revised estimate made during the fiscal year 1908,
based upon work already done, shows that to complete the improve-
ment there will be required $66,000 in addition to the amount origi-
nally estimated.
  The total expenditures to June 30, 1909, were $122,052.01. A
contract was let in 1905, under which there was removed 158,441
cubic yards; a second contract was made during the present fiscal
year for continuing the work, and under this there has been removed
297,264 cubic yards, making a total of 455,705 cubic yards, which is
about 64 per cent of the approved project.
  The appropriation recommended will be applied to prosecution
of the improvement by dredging between Grahams Creek and
McClellanville.
  The improvement can have no effect on freight rates until the
project shall have been completed.
  For references to reports of examinations and surveys, see page
256, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
                                             Commercial statistics.

                    Year.          Tons.       Value.                       Year.               Tons.        Value.

1903 .......................       33,344      $579,520    1906.......................          49,440       $797,747
1904........................        39,064      573,770    1907 .....................           36,230        921,675
1905........................        58,421      608,761    1908 .....................            32,388      1,146,240


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................                                  $47, 805. 28
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1909...............................................                                              5, 000. 00
                                                                                                          52, 805. 28
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ...........................................................                                        44,567. 29
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.. ..............................                                          8, 237. 99
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                                  66, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909 ...      .............................................                                     66, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
      (See Appendix N 8.)
  9. Charleston Harbor, South Carolina.--There were originally
four channels across the bar, the deepest having about 12 feet depth,
at low water. Commerce was then using the Pumpkin Hill channel,
about 3 miles south of the present jetty channel. Where the present
jetty channel is situated there was then the Swash channel, with a
best depth of 101 feet of water, too crooked for safe use. The
natural channels were shifting in position and variable in depth.
  The original project, adopted in 1878, provided for establishing
and maintaining, by means of two jetties and auxiliary dredging, a
low-water channel of not less than 21 feet depth across the bar. The
Swash channel was selected for improvement. The estimated cost
was $3,000,000.
   In 1888 it became necessary to modify the height of the crest line
of the jetties and to revise the estimate. This increase in the esti-
mate was largely due to the fact that money had been appropriated
                                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 331

so slowly that reasonable contract prices could not be obtained.
The annual appropriation up to that time had been only 51 per cent
of the original estimate. In the revised project the jetties were
increased in height and length, but no change was made in their posi-
tion or distance apart. The revised estimates were $4,380,500 if the
jetties were brought up to low-water level throughout, and $5,334,500
if brought up 3 feet higher. The former estimate was adopted by
Congress in the river and harbor act approved July 13, 1892.
   The present project, adopted by the river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1899, provides for obtaining a channel at the entrance to
Charleston Harbor not less than 26 feet deep at mean low water
(mean range of tide about 5.2 feet) and 600 feet wide, by constructing
a large seagoing suction dredge, at a cost not exceeding $150,000,
and operating her, together with the existing dredge Charleston, for
three years. The estimated cost of constructing the new dredge and
operating it, as above, was $285,000. Of this amount $175,000 had
been appropriated prior to the enactment of the river and harbor act
of June 13, 1902, which made available an additional sum of $208,000,
increasing to $383,000 the amount authorized for the project for the
new dredge and its operation. The entire amount authorized has
been appropriated.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1909, were $4,653,057.59, includ-
ing about $2,500 expended at Sullivans Island and $10,000 at Mount
Pleasant; of this sum $7,823.23 was derived from miscellaneous
sources, such as rental of dredge and auction sales. Of this amount,
$4,640,557.59 had been expended on the original projects and on
maintenance.
   Dredging during the year provided the-full project width. A
good channel exists of not less than 26 feet at mean low water and
at least 600 feet wide throughout the whole length of the improved
portion, although a slight shoaling occurred in the outer portion
during the year. The mean tidal range is 5.2 feet.
   The operations during the year were for maintenance.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, authorizes the Secretary
of War, in his discretion, to cause the new dredges employed on this
work to be utilized, at such times as they are not employed in dredg-
ing on the outer bar, for dredging in the channels between said outer
bar and the city of Charleston.
   For references to examinations and surveys and to projects see
page 257, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                        Foreign commerce.

                                             Aggre-                                                 Aggre-
                 Year.                      gate reg-    Value.               Year.               gate reg-    Value.
                                             istered                                               istered
                                              tons.                                                 tons.


1889 ........................                211,203 $16,744,951 1899.......................       174,525    $6,385,168
1890........................                 224,962 16,041,397    1900........................    150,631    11,170,910
1891..........................               274,149 23,110,664    1901......................      141.003     5,276,757
1892...............           ...........    169,379 11,829,607    1902........................    219,069     7,095,294
1893 ........................                193,336 11,940,129    1903........................    142,196     5,237,119
1894........................                 208,169 11,560,372    1904.......................     146,966     6,100,295
1895........................                 140, 938 10, 586, 326 1905.......................     106, 351    3, 337, 038
1896.........................                158,325 11,785,846    1906.......... .............    132,400     4,165,567
1897.........................                226,750 12,106,763    1907......................      174,219     6,036,866
1898.........................                214,180 10,956,250    1908 .......................    187,044     6,969,606
332                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                     S. ARMY.

                                 Commerce through Charleston Harbor, ocean entrance.

                                                                                                                                    Total im-
                                                            Year.                                                                  ports and             Value.
                                                                                                                                    exports.


                                                                                                                                              Tons.
1901 .....................................                                       ......................................                      784,812   $29,454,515
1902. ...........................................................                                                         .................. 822,845    34,746,997
1903.....................................................................................                                                    685,903    47,659,427
1904. ....................................                                                                                                   880,596    49,994,894
1905.............................                             . ...                 .....................................                    858,016    51,631,040
1906..           . ....................................................................                                                      835,360    56,301,096
1907        ....           ..................................................................                                                722,338    56,138,444
1908. ......................................................... 651,232                                                                                 61,444,244



  Regarding effect on freight rates since improvement began in 1878,
the only change that seems due to the improvement is a lowering of
about 121 cents per ton on business done by coastwise sailing vessels.
  The additional work proposed is for maintenance.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................... ............  $17, 312. 87
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...................................................   25, 000. 00
                                                                                                                                                   42, 312. 87
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ................................................                                                                                     12, 047. 23
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.........................                                                                   .........              30, 265. 64
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................                                                                            3, 247.09

July 1, 1909, balance available................                                                            .
                                                                                                      ........ .........                               27, 018. 55
     (See Appendix N 9.)
   10. Removing sunken vessels or craft, obstructing or endangering
navigation.-For making examination of the wreck of the steamer
Housatonic, near the entrance to Charleston Harbor, with a view to
its removal, allotment of $800 had been made June 1, 1908. During
July the examination was made at a cost of $395.85 and the removal
of the wreck recommended at an estimated cost of $12,000. This
sum was allotted September 14, 1908, and contract made January 18,
1909, in the sum of $3,240; contract was approved February 16, 1909.
The wreck was removed by breaking it up with dynamite and raising
the broken pieces. About 4 tons of old iron was so removed. The
expenditures during the fiscal year were $826.57; none were made
during the preceding year. The contractor had not been paid.
   Cambusdoon.-The hulk of the old bark Cambusdoon, which was
floating in the harbor at Charleston, a menace to navigation, was
removed at a cost of $416.75.
   Leonora.-For making an examination of a wreck in Beaufort
River, South Carolina, an allotment of $50 was made August 5, 1908;
the examination was made at a cost of $34.69; the wreck was found
to be that of a small schooner, the Leonora, and its removal at an
estimated cost of $700 was recommended. Allotment for this purpose
was made September 28, 1908. Contract was made for the removal
of the wreck in the sum of $400. The wreck was removed and placed
in a small creek where it would not interfere with navigation. Ex-
penditures for this work were $440.83.
                RIVER AND HARBOR     IMIPROVEMENTS.              333
    Wreck in Great Pedee River, South Carolina.-Forthe removal of a
sunken gunboat in Great Pedee River, South Carolina, an allotment
of $2,000 was made October 19, 1908. No work had been done on
account of high stage of water. No expenditures were made.
   Sunken caisson, Port Royal Naval Station, S. C.-On December 9,
1908, allotment of $2,000 was made. On March 10, 1909, a further
allotment of $2,600 was made for the removal of an old caisson which
had been sold at the Port Royal Naval Station and which the pur-
chaser had partly dismantled and abandoned, after sinking at the
naval station wharf. This wreck was removed during the months of
January and February and deposited where it would not interfere
with navigation. The expenditures for this were $4,305.26.
   (See Appendix N 10.)

EXAMINATION   AND SURVEY MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
              HARBOR ACT, APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports dated April 18, 1907, and June 5, 1908, on preliminary
examination and survey, respectively, of Great Pedee River, South
Carolina,from Georgetown to Pedee Station, required by the river and
harbor act of March 2, 1907, were duly submitted by the district
officer. They were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers
and Harbors, pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and
printed in House Document No. 1162, Sixtieth Congress, second ses-
sion. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of $53,000 is
presented.

EXAMINATION   MADE   IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND       HARBOR ACT,
                     APPROVED MARCH 3, 1909.

   Report dated April 22, 1909, on preliminary examination of Wa-
verly Creek, South Carolina,from its mouth to Waverly Mills, required
by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, was duly submitted by
the district officer. It was reviewed by the Board of Engineers for
Rivers and Harbors, pursuant to law, and was transmitted to Congress
and printed in House Document No. 72, Sixty-first Congress, first ses-
sion. The locality is not considered worthy of improvement by the
General Government.
  IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE SAVANNAH,
                   GEORGIA, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Col. Dan C. Kingman, Corps of
Engineers, division engineer, Southeast Division, having under his
immediate orders since April 6, 1909, Capt. W. P. Stokey, Corps
of Engineers.
  1. Savannah Harbor, Georgia.-This covers the estuary of the Sa-
vannah River from the upper limits of the city of Savannah to the
ocean bar, a distance of 26 miles, measured along the channel. In
1873 the channel was in places not more than 9 feet deep at mean low
water.
  The first appropriation for the improvement of this harbor was
made in 1826, and had reference to the removal of natural and
334     REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.      S. ARMY.

artificial obstructions, but the first comprehensive plan of improve-
ment is dated February 11, 1853. Another, for the removal of obstruc-
tions, is dated about 1871.
   A later plan of improvement is dated August 28, 1873, and was
supplemented March 19, 1879. It contemplated the establishment
of a channel from the city to the sea, practicable at high tide for
vessels drawing 22 feet of water. This project was replaced by an
enlarged one (January 16, 1882, Annual Report of the Chief of En-
gineers for 1882, Appendix J 4) contemplating the same channel
depth. The amount expended under these projects up to June 30,
1890, was $1,850,528.53.
   The project in force up to June 13, 1902, adopted in 1890, provid-
ing for a mean high-water depth of 26 feet from the city to the sea,
is printed as part of Appendix 0, Annual Report of the Cflief of
Engineers for 1890. The channel depth contemplated by it was
reported as having been obtained at the end of the fiscal year 1896.
While the project depth was literally obtained, the channel was very
crooked and of much less than the project width.
   A supplemental plan of improvement was submitted December 7,
1894, providing for a detached extension of the Oyster Bed training
wall, for the purpose of sheltering the anchorage in Tybee Roads, as
well as for protecting the ship channel over the outer part of Tybee
Knoll against the destructive action of heavy storms. This project,
which is printed as part of Appendix M 1 of the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1895, was authorized by act of Congress
of June 3, 1896, its estimated cost being $992,250. This work was
never finished, the contract having been annulled in 1899, when less
than one-third of the proposed work was accomplished. The same
act authorized the completion of work for improving the inside route
from Savannah, Ga., to Beaufort, S. C., at an additional cost of
$106,700, and dredging for maintenance in Savannah Harbor, and
the sum of $1,005,000 was appropriated to complete these works.
   The amount expended under the project of 1890 up to June 30,
1896, was $3,460,049.99, of which $974,504.88 was for dredging and
$2,356,720.10 for contraction work. There had previously been ex-
pended $1,850,528.53, giving a total of $5,310,578.52. Between June
30, 1896, and June 30, 1902, $712,918.84 was expended on the modified
26-foot project, of which $84,850.98 was for maintenance.
   From the time of the reported completion of the project of 1890,
in July, 1896, until June 30, 1902, extensive dredging was done, both
for maintenance and as part of the modification of the project.
   On June 13, 1902, Congress adopted a project which provided for
the establishment of a channel from the Old Waterworks (2 miles
above Savannah) to the ocean, 28 feet deep at mean high water, with
bottom widths of 350 to 500 feet, to be accomplished by dredging
and the raising of all existing training walls between Savannah and
Tybee Roads. It also provided for the construction of mooring dol-
phins at two points in the harbor-the "Bight" and Venus Point.
The estimated cost of the work was originally $1,567,791. This
amount was increased by $210,000 by the act of Congress approved
March 3, 1905. This project will be found printed in House Docu-
ment No. 123, Fifty-sixth Congress, second session, and also in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1901, page 1723.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    335
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, called for a resurvey of
Savannah Harbor, Georgia, with plans and estimates of cost, with a
view to securing a channel to the sea 26 feet deep at mean low water.
The survey was made and the plans and estimates prepared, and will
be found printed as House Document No. 181, Fifty-ninth Congress,
first session. This project was not adopted by Congress in its en-
tirety, but the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated
$300,000, and in addition authorized continuing contracts in the sum
of $700,000 (all of which has now been appropriated) for prosecut-
ing the improvement and for maintenance, in accordance with the
plans of the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, as set forth
in the House document just referred to. The recommendation of
the Board was that the improvement should be undertaken in a ten-
tative manner, with the object of first securing across the bar the
maximum depth within the limits fixed by Congress that can be
maintained by dredging alone, a 21-foot channel first to be dredged
and then gradually deepened until the limit fixed by economy of
maintenance is reached. The act authorized such raising and ex-
tending of dikes, jetties, and other contraction works as may be
necessary at a cost not to exceed $300,000, and the purchase of a
pumping dredge of the stationary type at a cost of $125,000. The
increased depth gained upon the bar is to be carried up the river by
dredging at such a rate as will insure the same navigable depth as
is maintained on the bar.
   The amount expended under the 28-foot project (mean high water)
up to June 30, 1908, was $1,643,282.29; of which $214,043.28 was for
maintenance. The sum of $672.25 was derived from sales of gov-
ernment property and deposited to the credit of the appropriation.
   The expenditures to June 30, 1909, under the tentative project
adopted March 2, 1907, amounted to $633,404.34, of which $124,103
was for maintenance, and $119,676.21 was disbursed by Maj. J. C.
Sanford and Maj. Herbert Deakyne, Corps of Engineers, on account
of the construction of the dredge provided for by the project. The
sum of $8 was received from the sale of blueprints of the plans of the
dredge, and $94.28 from sales of condemned property. Details of
the dredge construction will be found in Appendix H 9, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908, and in Appendix H 10 of
this report. The total amount expended for the improvement of
Savannah Harbor up to June 30, 1909, was $8,300,183.99. A total
of $1,075.94 was received from sales of condemned property and of
blueprints. The sum of $500 was deposited to the credit of the ap-
propriation by the clerk of the United States circuit court for the
southern district of Georgia. The expenditure of this sum has se-
cured and maintained the various objects had in view in projects
heretofore stated, and with the net result of securing a navigable
channel not less than 22 feet deep at mean low water from the wharves
of Savannah to Tybee Roads, and not less than 24 feet thence to
the sea.
  The mean rise and fall of the tide on the outer bar is 7 feet; on
Tybee Knoll, 6.8 feet; and at the upper limit of the harbor, 6.4 feet.
  During the fiscal year the three United States dredges removed a
total of 1,048,846 cubic yards of material for the advancement of
the project. Of this, about 110,000 cubic yards was upon the ocean
336      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

bar, 707,000 cubic yards in the roads, 61,000 cubic yards on the
Knoll, and 171,000 cubic yards on the middle ground near the quar-
antine station. Ten thousand one hundred and forty-one and forty-
four one-hundredths tons of rock and 912.15 cubic yards of brush
fascines were used by D. Power & Co. in completing their contract
for raising dikes and training walls, and 14,969.74 tons of rock were
used by Roderick G. Ross in his contract for raising and strengthen-
ing the North Long Island and Cockspur Island training walls.
Work under this last-named contract is still in progress. The Simons-
Mayrant Company completed their contract for reopening the
Screvens Ferry route by dredging, at a total cost of $2,574.40. They
also completed supplementary contract for dredging in Mud River
Cut, where 5,624 cubic yards of material were removed. These
things, i. .e., the work at Screvens Ferry and Mud River Cut, form
no part of the improvement of Savannah Harbor, but were rendered
necessary in consequence of regulating works built in the harbor.
   In addition to the above, the United States dredges removed
691,203 cubic yards of material from the river above quarantine sta-
tion, depositing the same at Venus Point, from whence about 380,000
cubic yards had been pumped ashore at the close of the year. The
remainder is still to be rehandled. This last dredging was primarily
for the purpose of maintenance and was the only maintenance work
that was done during the year, but it was found, by comparing the
present condition in the river with that of three years previous, that
a substantial advance has been made toward the 26-foot project
 (mean low water). As careful an adjustment as can be made between
the two indicates that $57,591 worth of work has been done for main-
tenance during the year.
   All of the money authorized for the tentative project has been
appropriated, but it is not yet all expended. It will be, however, by
the 30th of June, 1910. For a detailed report of what has been accom-
plished in this experiment, attention is invited to the report of the
district officer, Appendix O 1, herewith.
   Briefly, the results indicate very clearly that a channel 26 feet deep
at mean low water can be readily secured, at a cost within the esti-
mate, across Tybee bar and through the roads, and also that it can be
maintained at very moderate expense, and that the 26-foot depth
can be carried up the river to the upper limit of the city at a cost
within the estimate given in the 1905 project. In short, that the
project can be carried out within the original estimate and that it
gives every promise of being reasonably permanent and easily main-
tained. It is estimated that it will cost $1,545,000, in addition to
funds now available, to complete the project. It is recommended
that the project be adopted with a view to its completion by the 30th
of June, 1914, the appropriation to be made in four annual install-
ments, the first three of $400,000 each and the last in an amount suf-
ficient to make up the balance.
   It is proposed to expend the balance on hand and the additional
appropriation recommended in maintaining and carrying forward, as
authorized, the general project of 1905, printed as House Document
No. 181, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session, with only such slight
modifications as to the extent of dikes and training walls to be raised
and strengthened as experience may indicate to be desirable and nec-
essary. The additional work proposed is for extension of benefits.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                337

   The estimate submitted for the fiscal year 1911 is for maintenance
only, leaving it for Congress to decide to what extent it proposes to
further prosecute the work of improvement at this locality.
   In 1872 the tonnage of vessels arriving and clearing at Savannah
Harbor was reported to be somewhat more than 1,000,000 and the
total value of imports and exports about $34,000,000. In 1890 the
total tonnage was reported to have increased about 2,000,000 and the
value of imports and exports to $152,000,000. For the calendar year
1908 the total amount of freight received and shipped at the port was
3,899,361 tons, valued at $167,941,267. The commerce consists prin-
cipally of naval stores, fertilizers, produce, iron, cotton, lumber, and
general merchandise.
   Attention is invited to a detailed discussion of the commerce of
Savannah Harbor contained in Appendix O 1 of this report.
   The effect of the improvement upon freight rates since 1896 has
been a reduction of from 30 to 50 per cent, according to the nature of
the commodity.
   A list of Reports of the Chief of Engineers and executive docu-
ments, in which the various projects, examinations, surveys, maps,
etc., are printed may be found on page 272 of the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1905. A map of the harbor, showing con-
ditions on June 30, 1906, will be found in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1906, opposite page 1192.
    Reference to report on resurvey of the harbor required by the river
and harbor act of March 3, 1905, will be found on page 311 of the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..............-......     .......... _ a$376, 051.89
Amount received from sales of government property .. . . . ...........         57. 38
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.....      400, 000. 00
                                                                                                776, 109. 27
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .....-................                   -      248, 562. 74
    For maintenance of improvement .....-.....      ......                    57, 591. 00
                                                                                               b 306, 153. 74

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................                     .............             469, 955.53
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. -...........................                              44, 473. 30

July 1, 1909, balance available .........-.......                         -...............      425, 482. 23

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts                         -.............      62, 162. 64
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909. .-..................    -.............     .                          200, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix O 1.)
   2. Savannah River below Augusta, Ga.-This river is navigable
from Savannah to Augusta, Ga., a distance of 202 miles. Previous
to improvement there were numerous shoals in the river, with less
than 3 feet at summer low water, the other obstructions consisting of
overhanging trees, snags, and sunken logs. The aggregate length
                         a Includes $12,306.36 for construction of dredge.
                         b Includes $6,974.57 for construction of dredge.
        9001-ENG 1909--22
338     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

of river upon which there was less than 5 feet was about 9,800 feet,
divided up into 10 shoals, and the controlling depth was about 2)feet.
   The original project, submitted December 22, 1880, provided for
securing a 5-foot channel, 80 feet wide, by means of removal of
snags, trees, sand bars, etc., and protection of banks, at a cost of
$91,000.
   Under this project there was expended, prior to operations under
the existing project, $93,480.09.
   The existing project, adopted in 1890, provides for the establish-
ment of a navigable steamboat channel 5 feet deep at ordinary sum-
mer low water between the cities of Augusta and Savannah, to be
accomplished by removing sand and gravel bars, regulating portions
of the river, revetting caving banks, closing incipient cut-offs, and
removing snags and logs from the channel and overhanging trees
from the banks of the stream.
   The total estimated cost of this improvement, in round numbers,
was $332,000, on the supposition that funds would be regularly and
adequately supplied, besides $3,000 to $5,000 annually for mainte-
nance.
   The amount expended upon the work under the existing project
up to June 30, 1909, was $405,195.96 (of which $46,742.50 was for
maintenance), which, added to the amount previously expended,
gives a total expenditure for this work of $498,676.05.
   A .total of $655.77 has been received from sales of unserviceable
property and deposited to the credit of the appropriation.
   The work done under the present project has resulted in the
removal of great numbers of snags and stumps from the river chan-
nel and the cutting of numerous overhanging trees on the banks.
Sand bars have been removed by means of training dikes and shore
protection at 11 localities. A great deal of work, however, remains
to be done, principally in the upper 30 miles of the river, where
there are sand shoals with only 3 feet of water over them. A great
many snags also require removal.
   All work done during the fiscal year was for maintenance and con-
sisted of the following:
   Two thousand one hundred and sixty-four snags and 154 stumps
were removed from the channel and 95 logs and 3,198 overhanging
trees cut on the banks of the stream. Temporary relief was ren-
dered to navigation by the dragging of heavy anchors back and forth
across Tweedys sand bar by the snag boat Tugaloo. Assistance was
rendered by the snag boat to the river steamer Two States, which sunk
in the channel at Augusta, the work done enabling the owners to
raise the boat and prevent it becoming a total wreck and a serious
obstruction to navigation. A sunken lighter which obstructed navi-
gation was also removed. Repairs and alterations to the snag boat
were in progress at the close of the fiscal year.
   The proportion of the approved project accomplished up to June 30,
1909, was about 75 per cent.
   At the close of the fiscal year the project depth of 5 feet can be
carried from Savannah to Augusta, except at two or three places
near Augusta, where the controlling depth at an ordinary stage of
summer low water is 3 feet. The river very rarely goes below 3
feet and rises more than 30 feet in times of floods, frequently standing
for long periods at several feet above summer low water. Existing
                              RIVER AND             HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                              339
training and shore protection dikes are in a generally fair condition,
except in the case of those at Tweedys bar, some of which are in
need of extension and repair.
   In the upper 30 miles of the river the banks in many places cave
more or less with every high freshet, and the problem of obtaining
and maintaining the project depth has been treated in full in the
report of the survey above referred to.
   It is proposed to applythe available balance and additional appro-
priation recommended toward keeping the channel cleared of snags
and similar obstructions, and in repairing existing training and
shore protection dikes and constructing others where necessary.
The additional work proposed is for extension of benefits.
   Prior to the improvement the commerce was small, but its quantity
unknown. The total commerce of the river during the calendar year
1908 amounted to 48,274 tons, valued at $5,425,800. It consists
principally of cotton and cotton-factory products, naval stores,
fertilizers, and general merchandise. There was also rafted down
the river during 1908 about 15,000,000 feet b. m. of timber, valued at
about $150,000.
  The effect of the improvement upon freight rates has been a
reduction of from 30 to 50 per cent, according to the nature of the
commodity.
  A list of Reports of the Chief of Engineers and of executive docu-
ments, in which projects of improvement, maps, etc., are printed, may
be found on pages 274 and 275 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1905.
  Report on examination and survey of the Savannah River, for
30 miles below Augusta, will be found printed as House Document
No. 962, Sixtieth Congress, first session. Report on examination
and survey of Savannah River at Augusta, ordered by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, will be submitted to Congress at its
next session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................... $17, 504. 76
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....................................................    25, 000. 00

                                                                                                                 42, 504. 76
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement----....----------..----........-----------...............------...---............-----------....   12, 025. 04
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-----------..--.......---.....-------...--------.......--........                30, 479. 72
                                                     --
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ---...............--         ..--
                                                                  --.......--        ........                     4, 923. 89
July 1, 1909, balance available........................................                                          25, 555. 83
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909..................................                                             30, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix O 2.)
  3. Savannah River above Augusta, Ga.-This portion of the
Savannah River is navigable only by pole boats from the locks, 7
miles above the city of Augusta, to Petersburg, a distance of 48 miles.
In its original condition the river at low water was navigable only
with great difficulty, on account of shallow water, obstructing logs, etc.
340     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The original project of improvement, submitted February 8, 1879,
provided for a 3-foot channel, 30 feet wide, from Augusta, Ga., to
Trotters shoals and the removal of snags, trees, etc., to the Tugaloo
River, at a cost of $45,000.
   Under this project there was expended, prior to operations under
the existing project, $39,000.
   The existing plan of improvement, adopted by Congress July 13,
1892, provides for the establishment, between Petersburg and the
locks, of a downstream channel 12 to 25 feet in width and navigable
during ordinary summer low water for pole boats drawing 2 feet and
of an upstream channel navigable for pole boats drawing 1.3 feet of
water. This is to be obtained by removing logs and overhanging
trees; excavating rock, sand, or gravel, and with excavated materials
raising crests of ledges; constructing training walls, to increase flow
of water through sluices. The total estimated cost is $33,000.
   The total amount expended under the present project up to June
30, 1909, was $24,004.40, which, added to that previously expended,
gives a total for this work of $63,004.40. No funds have been
expended for maintenance.
   The work accomplished under this project has given a downstream
channel about 2 feet deep and an upstream channel of the project
depth. In many places, however, these channels are difficult to navi-
gate and are capable of greater improvement.
   The proportion of the approved project accomplished up to June
30, 1909, was about 60 per cent.
   Authority has recently been granted to a private company to con-
struct a dam across the Savannah River about 20 miles above the
dam at Augusta, to be 60 feet high and provided with locks of suffi-
cient size to pass an ordinary river steamboat. The pool formed by
this dam will drown out the principal shoal on that portion of the
river now under improvement, and when this dam is completed and
the lock ready for operation, a new survey should be made and a new
project prepared to conform to the new conditions.
   The work of the year was for improvement and consisted in the
removal of 52 snags, 111 logs, and 52 cubic yards of loose rock from
the channel and cutting 294 overhanging trees from the banks, and
the placing of 440 cubic yards of rock in repairing existing dams.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance and the additional
appropriation recommended toward the removal of obstructions and
the widening and deepening of the channel.
   The additional work proposed is for extension of benefits.
   In 1876-77 about 2,000 tons of freight went upstream and about
12,000 bales of cotton came down.
   Complete figures for the commerce of 1908 was unobtainable for
the reasons set forth in Appendix O 3. It is probable that such
commerce did not differ greatly from the customary amount for the.
past eight years, which averaged 2,995 tons, valued at $169,780.
   The commerce consists of cotton, grain, fertilizers, hay, cord wood,
and general merchandise, and is carried on exclusively by pole boats.
   The effect of the improvement has been to render navigation safer
and easier, but it is impossible to determine whether it has caused any
reduction in freight rates.
   A list of reports of the Chief of Engineers and of executive docu-
ments containing the projects of improvement, maps, etc., may be
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IIMPROVEME                        TS.                 341
found on page 276 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1905.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..............   ................... $2, 710. 83
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of
  improvement ............................... ....................... 1, 715. 23
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...-----...------------------...-------..........------..     995. 60
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                   8, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for work of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909......... .................. ......... 3,000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix O 3.)
   4. Harbor at Darien, and Doboy bar, Georgia-(a) Darien Har-
bor.-This harbor is navigable from its mouth to the town of Darien,
a distance of 13 miles.
   In its original condition it was obstructed at seven points by shoals,
with mean low-water depths of from 6Z to 101 feet. Between the
shoals there was nowhere less than 12 feet at mean low water.
   There was expended on this harbor in 1879 for dredging $8,000,
without any project having been recommended or adopted.
   The project for the improvement of this harbor, adopted in 1885,
contemplates the establishment of a navigable channel 12 feet deep at
mean low water between Darien and Doboy at an estimated cost of
$170,000. Work was not begun under this project until 1891. The
total amount expended under it up to June 30, 1909, was $157,365.96
(of which $20,572.75 was for maintenance), which, added to the
amount previously expended, gives a total for this work of
$165,365.96. The work done under the present project has resulted
in a navigable channel 12 feet deep at mean low water from Darien to
Doboy. The project was reported as completed July 11, 1905.
   No work was done during the fiscal year, no funds being available.
   On June 30, 1909, the controlling depth in the harbor was 10 feet
at mean low water, shoaling having occurred at several places since
the project depth of 12 feet was obtained in July, 1905. The mean
rise and fall of tide is from 6.5 feet at Darien to 7 feet at the entrance.
   The additional work proposed is for maintenance only.
   The total tonnage for 1878 was estimated at about 200,000 and the
value of exports at between $600,000 and $700,000. The commerce
consists almost entirely of timber, and in 1908 the total shipments
amounted to 33,856,228 feet, valued at $501,312. In addition there
was 55,485,000 feet rafted through the harbor to Sapelo and to
Savannah. The local freight handled at the port during 1908
amounted to 3,000 tons, valued at $180,000.
   The improvement of this harbor has rendered it possible to ship
lumber from Darien, which before was impracticable, and has caused
a reduction in freight rates of about 15 per cent.
   A list of the Reports of the Chief of Engineers in which the proj-
ect of improvement, history of the work, etc., are printed may be
found on page 277 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1905.
    By act of Congress approved June 13, 1902, this work was consoli-
dated with Doboy bar, Georgia.
342      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                 S. ARMY.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement. .........................     . $10, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Doboy bar.-In 1888, $5,795.40 was spent in harrowing and
water-jet work on this bar without result. In its original condition
there was about 12 feet at mean low water in the old channel, which
was very crooked, so that the entrance was not much used.
   The project for its improvement, adopted by act of Congress of
March 3, 1899, provides for creating a channel by dredging 24 feet
deep at mean high water and 300 feet wide, estimated to cost $70,000.
The proposed channel is some distance north of the old channel.
   The amount expended under the project up to June 30, 1909, was
$49,134.04, which, added to the amount previously expended, gives
a total expenditure for this work of $54,929.44. No funds have been
expended for maintenance.
   By act of Congress approved June 13, 1902, this work was consoli-
dated with Darien Harbor.
   No work was done during the fiscal year.
   The work which has been done under the existing project secured
a channel across the bar 150 feet in width, with a controlling depth
of 12 feet at mean low water, but this channel was never marked or
used, and a recent examination shows that it has shoaled until it only
affords a depth of 7 feet at mean low water. The mean rise and fall
of the tide is 7 feet.
   Practically no advancement has been made toward the completion
of the project and it is quite doubtful if the desired improvement at
this bar can be effected by dredging alone, except at great cost. None
of the natural or artificial channels across the bar appear to have any
stability. Extensive sand shoals lie to the north and south of the
entrance to the sound, and the material composing them is easily
transported by the littoral currents, which are very strong in this
vicinity under the influence of northeast or southeast winds.
   The buoyed channel across the bar, which does not follow the line
where dredging was done, affords a depth of about 11 feet at mean
low water and has a bad turn in it. An examination made recently
under unfavorable circumstances indicates that a better and straighter
channel can be found affording a depth of 12 feet. If this fact is
verified by a more complete examination, the Light-House depart-
ment will be advised so that, if deemed proper, the buoys may be
shifted to mark what appears to be the best water.
   No additional work is proposed and no appropriation is recom-
mended.
   The commerce interested in this bar consists of lumber received
from the Altamaha River and its tributaries, the bulk of which is
now shipped from Sapelo Sound and St. Simons Sound, north and
south, respectively, of Doboy bar. During the calendar year 1908
2,379,228 feet of lumber, valued at $46,200, crossed the bar.
   A list of the Reports of the Chief of Engineers and of executive
documents in which projects, maps, and history of the work are
printed, may be found on page 278 of the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1905.
    (See Appendix O 4.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     343
     5. Altamaha, Oconee, and Ocmulgee rivers, Georgia.-These three
improvements were consolidated by the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907.
     (a) Altamaha River, Georgia.-This river is formed by the junction
of the Oconee and Ocmulgee rivers. At a point some 25 miles from
its mouth the river branches, and the river traffic reaches the ocean
'by two routes-one by the north branch by way of Darien, and the
other by the south branch to where it intercepts the inside waterway,
which passage is taken to Brunswick.
     Before improvement the Altamaha River was obstructed by rock
ledges, sand bars, snags, sunken logs, and overhanging trees. The
low-water depths at some points did not exceed 1 foot.
     The original project of improvement, submitted in 1875, contem-
plated a channel 4 feet deep and 80 feet wide from Macon to Darien
by the removal of sand bars, rock shoals, snags, overhanging trees,
etc., at a cost of $162,000.
     Under it and its modifications there was expended up to June 30,
1890, $64,776.59.
     The existing project of improvement, adopted by Congress in 1890,
provides for the establishment of a channel 3 feet deep at summer low
water throughout the river above Darien. This is to be accomplished
by removing rock shoals and sand bars, building deflecting dikes, and
closing incipient cut-offs, removing snags and sunken logs from the
channel and overhanging trees from the banks of the stream, and re-
vetting caving banks. The total estimated cost of the improvement
is $129,000, provided funds are regularly and adequately supplied,
besides from $3,000 to $5,000 for annual maintenance.
     The amount expended on the work under the present project up to
June 30, 1909, was $94,059.68 (of which $17,188.64 was for main-
tenance), which, added to the amount previously expended, gives a
total expenditure for this work of $158,836.27.
     A total of $111.50 has been received from proceeds of sales of un-
serviceable property and deposited to the credit of the appropriation.
     This expenditure has resulted in the removal of two rock shoals,
six sand bars, numerous snags, sunken logs, stumps, and overhanging
trees, and the straightening of the river at several points by cut-offs.
     The river is navigable from the forks to Darien, a distance of 131
miles, and to where it reaches the inside waterway. The lower section
of the river is affected by the tides. The worst shoal is at Coupers
bar, which at low water has only about 3 feet of water, but by waiting
on tides 5 feet can be had at this place. The controlling depth
above the tidal range is about 2 feet at summer low water. The
river is subject to freshets, and in the upper sections the freshet
height at times goes 20 feet above the low summer stage. The lower
section is bordered by low swamp lands, and the freshets rise from 5
to 10 feet over the banks.
    'The work done during the year for maintenance consisted of the
removal of 209 snags and 10 stumps and the cutting of 406 over-
hanging trees. Work for improvement consisted of the completion
of a training wall at Oglethorpe Bluff and the removal of a false point
  at Buggs Suck.
     The proportion of the approved project accomplished up to June
  30, 1909, was about 80 per cent.
844          REPORT        OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                        U. S. ARMY.


   It is proposed to apply the available balance and the additional
appropriation recommended in removing snags, stumps, and over-
hanging trees, in removing sand bars and rock shoals, and in repairing
old works of improvement.
   The additional work proposed is for extension of benefits.
   The commerce of the river before the improvement was begun was
reported to have amounted to about 100,000 tons annually, valued at
about $1,000,000. During the calendar year 1908 it amounted to
13,700 tons, valued at 1,110,000. There was also rafted down the
river during the same period 45,855,000 feet b. m. of timber, valued
at $614,950.
   As nearly as can be determined, the effect of the improvement has
been to cause a reduction of from 25 to 40 per cent in freight rates.
   A list of Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers and of executive
documents containing projects of improvement, history of the work,
maps, etc., may be found on page 279 of the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1905.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                            $10, 639. 32
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909......................................... ........................... ............  10, 000. 00
                                                                                                  20, 639. 32
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .....-....................... $1, 204. 09
    For maintenance of imbrovement ........................ 1, 160. 00
                                                                                                   2, 364. 09

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................... 18, 275. 23
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....
                                          ..............................   782. 35

July 1, 1909, balance available....................                      ................         17, 492. 88
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project............                        94, 160. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909-....................... ......                                     (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Oconee River, Georgia.-The head of navigation on this river is
Milledgeville, Ga., 147 miles from the mouth, though at present this
point can only be reached during high stages of the river.
   The river is navigable also for a distance of 17 miles between the
Georgia Railroad bridge (54 miles above Milledgeville) and the
northern boundary of Greene County. Between Milledgeville and
the Georgia Railroad bridge, above, the river is obstructed by obsta-
cles, both natural and artificial, and is incapable of improvement
except by an expensive system of locks and dams. At ordinary stages
the river is at present only navigable to a point about 25 miles above
Dublin, Ga., a distance of 104 miles from its mouth. In its original
condition this river was used principally for navigation at high
stages. At low water there were numerous shoals and snags, there
probably being less than 2 feet on many sand bars and rock ledges.
   The original project was submitted January 29, 1875, and provided
for the removal of snags, overhanging trees, etc., cutting off points,
and making cut-offs, at a cost of $10,150.
                          a See consolidated money statement on page 348.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    345
   Under this project and its modifications there was expended, pre-
vious to the commencement of operations under the existing project,
the sum of $44,822.18.
   The existing project of improvement was adopted by Congress
September 19, 1890. It provides for the establishment of a navigable
channel 3 feet deep at ordinary summer low water from Milledgeville
to the mouth. This is to be accomplished by removing rock shoals
and sand bars, revetting caving banks, and closing incipient cut-offs,
removing snags and logs from the channel and overhanging trees
from the banks of the stream. The cost of improvement is esti-
mated at $171,000, besides from $3,000 to $5,000 for annual mainte-
nance. The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, authorized the
expenditure of $3,000 of the amount appropriated to be applied to
cleaning out the river from the Georgia Railroad bridge to the north-
ern boundary of Greene County, Ga., thus bringing this short section
under improvement.
   The amount expended under the present project up to June 30,
1909, was $150,421.27 (of which $15,944.47 was for maintenance),
which, added to the amount previously expended, gives a total
expenditure for this work of $195,243.45.
   A total of $648.77 has been received from sales of unserviceable
property, which was deposited to the credit of the appropriation.
   As a result of this expenditure numerous snags and logs, bowlders,
and overhanging trees have been removed, several cut-offs opened and
others closed, six training dikes and one spur dam and 800 lineal feet
of shore protection built, and five rock shoals and several sand shoals
removed below Milledgeville. Between the Georgia Railroad bridge,
above Milledgeville, and the northern boundary of Greene County
the most troublesome obstructions have been removed from the
channel and numerous overhanging trees and logs cut on the banks.
   Work done during the fiscal year for maintenance consisted of the
removal of 3,278 snags and 3 stumps from the channel and the cut-
ting of 8,010 overhanging trees and girdling of 49 large trees on the
banks.
    For improvement, 100 cubic yards of rock were removed from the
channel at Devils Elbow and 450 cubic yards of earth dredged from
the shoal at Steamboat bight; shore protection and a training dike
were constructed at Fish Trap shoals and 350 cubic yards of stone
quarried for use in proposed dike work.
    On June 30, 1909, the controlling depth at ordinary summer low
water between the forks and Dublin was about 3 feet, though the
channel is very crooked and too narrow for easy navigation. Between
Dublin and the Central of Georgia Railway bridge, 25 miles above,
the controlling depth was 2.5 feet, and between the latter point
and Milledgeville, 2 feet. From the Georgia Railroad bridge, above
Milledgeville, to the northern boundary of Greene County, the con-
trolling depth was 2.5 feet. This river occasionally falls below these
depths and frequently rises to 20 feet above them.
    The proportion of the approved project accomplished up to June 30,
1909, was about 85 per cent.
    It is proposed to apply the available balance and additional appro-
priation recommended toward the removal of snags and stumps from
the channel and the cutting of overhanging trees from the forks to
Milledgeville; the removal of rock and sand shoals between the forks
346           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                  S. ARMY.

and the Central of Georgia Railway bridge, 25 miles above Dublin;
in making repairs to existing dikes and protecting caving banks; and
in closing incipient cut-offs and opening others wherever found
advisable.
   The additional work proposed is for extension of benefits between
the forks and Milledgeville. No additional work above Milledgeville
is proposed.
   No reliable statistics of the commerce of the river before the
improvement was begun are available. During the calendar year
1908 the amount of freight carried on the river between the forks and
Milledgeville amounted to 19,000 tons, valued at $247,000. There
was also rafted on this portion of the river during 1908, 17,390,000
feet b. m. of timber, valued at $258,000.
   As nearly as can be determined the effect of the improvement has
been to cause a reduction of from 25 to 40 per cent in freight rates.
   A list of the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers and of
executive documents containing the various projects, map, history
of the work, etc., may be found printed on pages 280 and 281 of the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended---------------......-----------.......----.................----... $12, 645.51
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.................................................                                     15, 000. 00
                                                                                                   27, 645. 51
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement............................                            $5,000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement.......................                            4, 490. 19
                                                                                                    9, 490. 19

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....              ........................ ......
                                               .....                                               18, 155.32
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................        ..                  1, 840. 89

July 1, 1909, balance available.......           ....   .. ..............        .............     16, 314. 43


IAmount
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........
         that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ....       . .... 0...............
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
                                                                      .
                                                                                                   88, 332. 00


                                                                                                      (a)

  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Ocmtulgee River, Georgia.-In its original condition this river
was used for navigation chiefly at high stages. At low water there
were numerous shoals and snags, there probably being less than 2
feet on many sand bars and rock ledges.
   The head of navigation on this river is Macon, a distance of 202
miles from the forks.
   The original project was submitted in 1875 and provided for a
channel 80 feet wide and 4 feet deep at low water, to be accomplished
by the removal of sand bars, rock shoals, snags, overhanging trees,
etc., from Macon to Darien, at a cost of $162,000.
   The amount expended under this project and its modifications prior
to operations under the existing project was $79,390.73.
                       a See consolidated money statement on page 348.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    347
   The existing project of improvement, adopted by Congress Sep-
tember 19, 1890, provides for the establishment of a navigable chan-
nel 3 feet deep at ordinary summer low water from Macon to the
river's mouth. This is to be obtained by removing rock shoals and
sand bars, closing incipient cut-offs, revetting caving banks, and
removing snags and logs from the channel and overhanging trees
from the banks of the stream.
   The cost of the improvement as given in the project of 1890 is
estimated at $210,000, provided funds are regularly and adequately
provided, besides from $3,000 to $5,000 for annual maintenance.
   The amount expended under the present project up to June 30,
1909, was $278,367.49 (of which $27,483.76 was for maintenance),
which, added to the amount previously expended, gives a total of
$357,758.22.
   A total of $802.26, received from sales of unserviceable property,
have been received and deposited to the credit of the appropriation.
   The work under the present project has resulted in a navigable
channel from the forks to Macon. A great deal of work, however,
remains to be done between Hawkinsville and Macon.
    Work done during the fiscal year for maintenance consisted of the
removal of 1,229 snags and 167 stumps from the channel, and the
cutting of 944 overhanging trees and 89 logs on the banks; the repair-
ing of training walls near Macon and at Tillman's bar and Hollings-
worth Ferry, and the overhauling and repair of plant. Assistance
was rendered by the snagboat Oconee to the sunken steamer Small,
which prevented it becoming a wreck and thereby seriously obstruct-
ing navigation. For improvement, shore-protection dikes were con-
structed at Mansfield's place and Newton's place, aggregating 1,346
feet in length; a training wall 511 feet long was constructed at
Newton's place; the Atwood jetty, near Macon, was extended 155
feet; Dike No. 3, near Macon, was extended 130 feet; 499 cubic
yards of earth and 933 cubic yards of stone removed from Taylors
Bluff shoals, near Hawkinsville; surveys were made of Oaky Bluff
shoals and at two other localities, with a view to their improvement,
and a temporary pile driver, 2 temporary barges, and 4 portable
shacks for quartering laborers, constructed.
    On June 30, 1909, the controlling depth between the forks and a
point 3 miles below lHawkinsville was about 3 feet at ordinary
summer low water, and between the latter point and Macon it was
about 2 feet. The river occasionally falls a foot below the ordinary
summer stage and frequently rises 20 feet above.
    The proportion of the approved project accomplished up to June
30, 1909, was about 95 per cent.
    It is proposed to apply the available balance and additional appro-
priation recommended in the removal of logs, snags, stumps, and
overhanging trees, in the removal of rock and sand shoals, maintain-
ing existing training dikes and shore protections, and in the construc-
tion of additional dikes and shore protection where necessary, and
in the closing of incipient cut-offs and opening others wherever
deemed advisable.
    The additional work proposed is for extension of benefits.
348          REPORT OF THIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                 U.    S. ARMY.


  No reliable statistics of the commerce of the river before improve-
ment was begun are available. In 1908 the freight carried on the river
amounted to 18,700 tons, valued at $900,000. Besides this,
26,007,000 feet b. m. of timber was rafted down the river, valued at
$288,800.
   As nearly as can be determined, the effect of the improvement has
been to cause a reduction of from 25 to 40 per cent in freight rates.
A list of the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers and of execu-
tive documents containing the various projects, history of the work,
maps, etc., may be found printed on page 282 of the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1905.
   Reference to report on examination of the river ordered by the
river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, will be found on page 311 of
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906.
   The emergency river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, called for an
examination and survey of the Ocmulgee River between Macon and
Hawkinsville, with a view to its improvement by locks and dams,
and, in addition, for a general survey of the Altamaha River system,
of which the Ocmulgee forms a part.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................                   $17, 479.35
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ..      -................ ........        .. ....... ........ ........  15, 00. 00

                                                                                                    32, 479.35
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement-----....----....--------............--------....        $12, 583. 63
    For maintenance of improvement ....................                                7, 351. 68
                                                                                                    19, 935. 31

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                                 12, 544.04
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities . ..        -..................           .............        1, 162. 99
July 1, 1909, balance available......----------------------.......---------.........-----.....      11, 381.05
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909..................................                                    (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                               CONSOLIDATED.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................................                 $40, 764.18
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 . -......... .............          .................... ........  40, 000. 00

                                                                                                    80, 764. 18
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement. ...........................                            $18, 787. 72
    For maintenance of improvement......................                              13, 001. 87
                                                                                                    31, 789. 59

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................                                 48, 974.59
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .......... .... ....................                           3, 786. 23
July 1, 1909, balance available...................................                                  45,188.36


                       a See consolidated money statement on this page.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                           349
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... _ a $182, 492. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909.................... .............         90, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix O 5.)
   6. Club and Plantatior creeks, Georgia.-A project for dredging
a canal 7 feet deep at mean low water, with a bottom width of 50
feet, to connect these two creeks and thus provide an inside route
between the Altamaha River and its tributaries and Brunswick
Harbor for use of light-draft river boats and timber rafts, will be
found printed as House Document No. 159, Fifty-eighth Congress,
second session. Besides the dredging of the canal, the project pro-
vides for the straightening of Plantation Creek and for dredging in
both Club and Plantation creeks where necessary to give a channel
7 feet deep at mean low water. The estimated cost of the work is
$40,700. This project was adopted by act of Congress approved
March 2, 1907, which appropriated $20,000 toward its completion.
    No work has yet been done. Portions of the route cross marsh
land owned by private individuals and the city of Brunswick, Ga.,
and no provision was made in the act for the purchase of a right
of way.
    During the previous fiscal year a legal title was secured, without
costs to the United States, from the city of Brunswick for that portion
of the desired right of way owned by the city. During the past fiscal
year efforts have been continued to secure the necessary legal title
from the owners of the balance of the marshland through which it is
desired to dredge the proposed canal, the written permits obtained
from the attorneys of these parties the year previous having been held
by the Judge-Advocate-General of the army to be insufficient.
    At the close of the year the consent of all owners of the desired
right-of-way to execute the necessary grants to the United States,
free of cost, had been obtained, with the exception of one part' owner,
with whom negotiations were in progress.
    It is proposed to apply the available balance and additional appro-
priation recommended to the completion of the project, as soon as a
valid right of way is obtained.
    Reports of examination and survey are printed on page 1669 of
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................      $20, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................        20, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........     20, 700. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909.....    ...   ....................     ..........  ....   b20, 700. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897.
    (See Appendix O 6.)
  a Does not include Ocmulgee River.
  b If new project for inside water route between Savannah, Ga., and Fernandina,
Fla., (H. Doc. No. 1236, 60th Cong., 2d sess.) be adopted, this estimate may be omitted
350     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S. ARMY.

   7. Brunswiclk Harbor, Georgia.-rrevious to June 13, 1902, the
appropriations for the improvement under the Engineer Department
were for the inner harbor only, consisting principally of the removal
of a shoal in East River, opposite the lower part of the city. The
act of Congress approved June 13, 1902, provided also for the im-
provement of the bar, which work had theretofore been carried on
by direct contract between Congress and a private individual, at a
cost of $270,000.
   The harbor is navigable from the city of Brunswick to deep water
beyond the bar, a distance of 13 miles, and also for 1 mile up Academy
Creek, and up Turtle River to the Southern Railway wharves.
   The original project of improvement, dated April 29, 1876, pro-
vided for the construction of a jetty at the city front and dredging, at
a total cost of $69,000.
  Under this project and its modifications there was expended, prior
to operations under the existing project, the sum of $190,000.
   The project in force up to June 13, 1902, was adopted by Congress
in 1894. It provided for the maintenance of a navigable channel 15
feet deep at mean low water by keeping the existing works in repair
and by dredging. The act of June 3, 1896, provided for the improve-
ment.of Academy Creek. The cost of maintaining a channel depth
of 15 feet at mean low water was estimated at $1.5,000 per annum.
   There had been expended under this project up to June 30, 1902,
$34,817.25, all of which had been for maintenance.
   Including $10,000 spent in 1836 for dredging, the total amount
expended up to June 30, 1902, on the inner harbor was $234,817.25.
   The act of Congress approved June 13, 1902, adopted a project
providing for a navigable channel 21 feet deep at mean low
Brunswick inner harbor, at a cost of $120,000, and for a channel
                                                                 waterin
across the outer bar 19.3 feet deep at mean low water (26 feet at
mean high water), at a cost of $40,000. It also provided for dredging
in Academy Creek at not to exceed $5,000. This project was com-
pleted in July, 1905, and expenditures since have beenfor maintenance.
  The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, authorized the expendi-
ture from the amount therein appropriated of $5,000, or so much
thereof as might be necessary, for maintaining in Academy Creek,
immediately in front of and adjacent to the wharves thereof, to the
Old Altamaha Canal a depth equal to the controlling depth on the
shoals at the lower end of the city in East River, provided that no
money should be expended inside harbor lines theretofore or there-
after established in said creek. With these funds a channel was
dredged with a depth of 18.5 feet at mean low water and a width
ranging from 50 to 90 feet.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1907, under the project approved
June 13, 1902, was $193,062, of which $19,596.82 was for mainte-
nance. This, added to the amounts previously expended, gives a total
expenditure for the work up to June 30, 1907, of $697,879.25.
   The result of this expenditure has been the accomplishment of a
navigable channel throughout the inner harbor 21 feet deep at mean
low water and of a channel across the outer bar 19.3 feet deep at
mean low water (both 26 feet at mean high water); also of a narrow
channel in Academy Creek above mentioned.
   A new project was adopted by the act of Congress approved March
2, 1907. This project will be found printed as House Document No.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      351
407, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session. It provides for creating
and maintaining throughout the inner harbor (embracing Turtle
River from the Southern Railway docks to its junction with Bruns-
wick River, Academy Creek from Aiken's wharf to its junction with
East River) and the outer harbor (embracing the outer bar, the
navigable channel throughout the entrance to St. Simons Sound,
and up Brunswick River to Brunswick Point) channels having a
depth of 30 feet at mean high water, with widths varying from 150
feet in Academy Creek to 400 feet across the outer bar, to be accom-
plished mainly by dredging; but the extension of the existing train-
ing wall in East River and the construction of two spur dikes is also
authorized. The estimated cost of the work is $496,650, with a
yearly cost of maintenance not exceeding $33,250.
   Congress in adopting this project appropriated the sum of $146,650
for the work and authorized contracts covering labor and materials
necessary for its completion at a cost not to exceed $350,000 addi-
tional, all of which has been appropriated.
   The amount expended under the present project up to June 30,
1909, was $369,245.25, and resulted in the dredging of a channel in
East River, opposite the city of Brunswick, about 8,500 feet in length,
350 feet in width, and 30 feet in depth at mean high water, except for
two small areas on the extreme eastern edge of the channel composed
of refractory material and which was not required to be removed
under the contract in force; the dredging of a channel about 4,700
feet in length, 150 feet in width, and 30 feet in depth at mean high
water, in Academy Creek; the dredging of a channel in Turtle River,
opposite Buzzards Island, about 3,500 feet in length, 300 feet in width,
and 30 feet in depth at mean high water, except at one point on the
upper shoal where refractory material was encountered; the removal
of 124,420.9 cubic yards of material from the shoal opposite Bruns-
wick Point, and the removal of 1,170,066.5 cubic yards from the
channel across the outer bar.
   During the fiscal year dredging operations were continued under
two contracts and resulted in the removal of 349,160.1 cubic yards
of material from the inner harbor, 114,267.5 cubic yards from the
shoal opposite Brunswick Point, and 713,211 cubic yards from the
channel across the outer bar.
   Work was in progress at the close of the fiscal year, and the allot-
ment will suffice to complete the project.
   The total amount expended for the improvement of Brunswick
Harbor up to June 30, 1909, was $1,067,124.50.
   The proportion of the present project accomplished to June 30,
1909, was 85 per cent for the outer bar, 75 per cent for the shoal oppo-
site Brunswick Point, and 90 per cent for the inner harbor.
   The controlling depth on the bar, from the basin inside to the bell
buoy, a distance of about 3 miles, is 30 feet at mean high water.
From the bell buoy to deep sea outside, a distance of about 1 mile,
the controlling depth is 28 feet at mean high water, and dredging over
this portion is now in progress. At Brunswick Point the controlling
depth is 28 feet at mean high water, and dredging over this portion
is now in progress; in East River, 30 feet; in Turtle River, upper
shoal, 27 feet, lower shoal, north of center range, 29 feet, and on
center range and to the south of same, 24.5 feet. The general depth
in East River and Turtle River is 30 feet, and these lesser depths are
352        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                         U.    S. ARMY.

simply a few high points of refractory material for the removal of
which a new contract will be made, funds being available for the pur-
pose. In Academy Creek, owing to rapid shoaling since the comple-
tion of dredging, there is now at the entrance a narrow channel on
one side of the shoal with a depth of 26.5 feet, and upon the other
side of the entrance a similar channel with only 22 feet; elsewhere
the controlling depth is 30 feet at mean high water.
   The mean rise and fall of tide on the bar is 6.6 feet, at Brunswick
Point 7 feet, and at the city of Brunswick 7.1 feet.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance and additional appro-
priation recommended in carrying out the approved project and main-
taining the improvement. The additional work proposed is for exten-
sion of benefits.
   Before improvement in 1880 the annual commerce of Brunswick
Harbor amounted to about 100,000 tons, valued at $1,700,000. The
total commerce of the port for the calendar year 1908 amounted to
1,200,000 tons of freight, valued at $39,892,165.     The commerce con-
sists principally of cotton, lumber, cross-ties, naval stores, and general
merchandise.
   The effect of the improvement has been to cause a reduction of
ocean-going freight rates on lumber of 25 per cent and on naval stores
of 30 per cent. It has also permitted the regular line coastwise freight
steamers to enter and leave the port regardless of the tides, thereby
avoiding much loss of time.
   A list of the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers and of docu-
ments containing the various projects, maps, history of the work, etc.,
may be found printed on page 284 of the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1905.
   Reference to report on survey of Brunswick Harbor, inner and
outer, provided for by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, will
be found on page 312 of Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1906.
   Pursuant to a requirement in the river and harbor act of March 2,
1907, an investigation has been made relative to the control and use
of wharfage privileges at Brunswick Harbor, and report thereon was
duly transmitted to Congress and printed in House Document No.
326, Sixtieth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................... $352, 693. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......     47, 000. 00
                                                                                      399, 693. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment............................... .. ...........................                  260, 167. 50

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................                  139, 525. 50
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities--....-----.....................--.......         30, 238. 40

July 1, 1909, balance available     -........   .........   ......   ...........      109, 287. 10

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. .............                   43, 044. 85
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909..............................................                    60, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix O 7.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     353
   8. Inside water route between Savannah, Ga., and Fernandina,
Fla.-Thisroute consists of a series of bays and tidal sloughs, making
a connecting waterway not exposed to rough water except at a few
points in stormy weather. The waters forming the route are shown
on Coast Survey charts Nos. 156 and 157. It is navigable from
Savannah, Ga., to Fernandina, Fla., Brunswick, Ga., and Darien,
Ga. The distance from Savannah to Fernandina is 160 miles.
Touching at Darien en route increases this by about 20 miles and at
Brunswick by about 12 miles.
   The project of improvement was adopted in 1892 and provides for
the establishment of a channel 7 feet deep at mean low water. This
is to be accomplished by the improvement of Romerly Marsh, Mud
River, Little Mud River, and Jekyl Creek. The estimated cost of the
improvement was $105,000, provided the entire sum be made available
at one time.
   The total amount expended under this project up to June 30, 1909,
was $128,352.47 (of which $63,842.53 was for maintenance), which,
added to the amount expended for Jekyl Creek and Romerly Marsh,
$71,108.77, makes a total of $199,461.24.
    The original estimate for the improvement of this route was com-
pleted with the appropriation of $41,000 made by the river and har-
bor act of March 3, 1905, but the improvement was still unfinished.
This resulted from the small appropriations made, extending the
work over a very long period, as fully set forth in a report of the
district officer printed on page 1208 of the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1906. The river and harbor act of March 2,
1907, provided for a resurvey of the waterway to determine the best
route for further improvement. Report of this resurvey, with esti-
mate of cost, is printed as House Document No. 1236, Sixtieth
Congress, second session.
   All work done during the fiscal year was for maintenance, and
consisted of the dredging of a total of 88,401.6 cubic yards of material,
under contract, from shoals at the mouth of St. Augustine Creek, in
the Florida Passage, Little Mud River, Frederica River, Jekyl Creek,
and Cumberland Dividiings, and the raising and extending of the
training wall near the head of Jekyl Creek and the raising of the
jetty near the mouth of this creek. Work was in progress at the
close of the fiscal year.
    The completion of the work at Skidaway Narrows (see report here-
with) has made this an integral part of the inside route, shortening
the distance by 6 miles between Savannah and Fernandina and
rendering further work by the way of Parson's cut unnecessary.
This makes the proportion of the approved project accomplished up
to June 30, 1909, 90 per cent, and Skidaway Narrows should here-
after cease to be regarded as an independent work, but be treated as
a portion of the inside route.
    On June 30, 1909, the controlling depth between Savannah and
Fernandina was 6 feet at mean low water, by way of the new route
through Skidaway Narrows, except at the mouth of Mud River,
where the controlling depth was 5 feet. By way of the old route
through Parson's cut the controlling depth was 2 feet. By waiting
on the tides, however, at Parsons cut, Skidaway Narrows, and Mud
River a navigation in excess of 7 feet could be carried by either route
     9001-.NG 1909--23
354        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                       U.    S.   ARMY.

between Savannah and Fernandina. The mean rise and fall of the
tide varies at different localities from 6.5 feet to 8 feet.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance and additional appro-
priation recommended toward restoring and maintaining a 7-foot
navigation, at mean low water, throughout the entire route.
   The additional work proposed is for extension of benefits.
   The value of the commerce passing over this route was estimated
in 1890 at between $200,000 and $300,000 per annum. During the
calendar year 1908 the commerce amounted to 60,000 tons of freight,
valued at $2,300,000. There was also rafted on this route during
1908, 58,985,000 feet b. m. of timber, valued at $787,500. Little, if
any, of this commerce passed over the whole extent of the route.
   It is impracticable to determine the effect of this improvement
upon freight rates, as at present the different portions of the route
are used locally, and comparatively few vessels engaged in commerce
pass over the entire length of it.
   A list of the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers and of
documents containing the various projects, maps, history of the work,
etc., may be found printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1905, page 285. Report of a resurvey of the route
will be found printed as House Document No. 1236, Sixtieth Con-
gress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ........................   ..... ...... $24, 478. 20
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909................................. ..........   ......... 25, 000. 00
                                                                                      49, 478. 20
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .    ...... ........ ............ ....  .. ..............               17, 830. 67
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..-.................         ................        31, 647. 53
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities................ .................                3, 810. 90
July 1, 1909, balance available ...-        --.........   . .   ......    .....       27, 836. 63
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................                  1, 945. 45
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.............................................                    25, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix O 8.)

   9. Skidaway        Narrows, Georgia.-In its                  original condition the
narrows was a narrow, tortuous waterway, formed by two creeks
which united at their heads at the meeting place of the tides, con-
necting Burnside River with Skidaway River. In its natural con-
dition it was navigable only at high water by small sailboats and
launches.
   The approved project of improvement was adopted by the river
and harbor act of March 3, 1905, and will be found printed in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, pages 1680-1684.
This project contemplated the establishment of a navigable channel
6 feet deep at mean low water and 75 feet wide at bottom, connecting
Burnside River with Isle of Hope (or Skidaway) River, the route of
such channel to be through the marsh and hammock land to the west
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                    355
of the narrows. Subsequent developments made it necessary to aban-
don this route, principally on account of the difficulty in obtaining
the desired right of way through private property. A new route,
following practically the course of the narrows, was adopted. The
estimated cost of the improvement by the new route is $55,000.
   The amount expended up to June 30, 1909, was $55,000.
   With the $20,000 appropriated by the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1905, a channel with a bottom width of 60 feet and a depth
of 5 feet at mean low water was provided over the worst portion of the
adopted route, making it available for commerce at high water.
   Dredging operations were continued under contract during the
fiscal year until November 20, 1908, resulting in the removal of
113,633 cubic yards of material. This work, with that previously
reported, accomplished a channel 6 feet deep at mean low water,
with a bottom width of 75 feet in the straight portions and 90 to 200
feet at the bends, from deep water in Skidaway River to deep water
in Burnside River, and completed the improvement.
   The completion of this improvement makes it a portion of the inside
route between Savannah and Fernandina, and no further appropri-
ations are recommended for it. The funds necessary for its proper
maintenance are included in the estimate submitted for the inside
route.
    The controlling depth on June 30, 1909, was 6 feet at mean low
water.
    The mean rise and fall of the tide at this locality is 8 feet.
    For commercial statistics, see report on inside water route between
Savannah and Fernandina, of which Skidaway Narrows forms a part.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................................... $20, 404. 81
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.......................................................................... 20, 404. 81
   (See Appendix O 9.)
   10. Cumberland Sound, Georgia and Florida.-In its original con-
dition the available depth of the entrance varied from 11 to 12.5 feet
at mean low water. The point of crossing the bar was subject to very
great changes in location, moving in a series of years as much as 1
miles. The distance from the outer bar to the city of Fernandina,
Fla., is about 6 miles.
   The project of improvement submitted in 1879 and revised by a
Board of Engineers in 1891 provides for the construction of two low
jetties from the shores on opposite sides of the entrance and extend-
ing seaward across the bar upon lines so directed that the ends will
be parallel to each other and about 3,900 feet apart. These jetties
were intended to establish a low-water channel across the bar not less
than 19 feet in depth. The cost of the improvement was originally
estimated at $2,071,023, and as modified at $1,606,500, for the com-
pletion of low jetties, and at $2,079,500 if high jetties were found
necessary. There was expended under this project $932,500.
   The present project, which was adopted by act of Congress of
June 3, 1896, provides for the establishment of a channel across the
bar 19 feet deep at mean low water by the construction of two jetties
of stone, resting on a foundation of brush mattresses, on the same line
as those in the previous project, the scour between the jetties to be
aided by dredging, if necessary, the total cost of the improvement, at
356     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the time of this project, to be $2,350,000, exclusive of amounts pre-
viously appropriated.
    The amount expended under this project up to June 30, 1909, was
$2,439,947.53 (of which $340,063.13 was for maintenance), which,
added to the amount previously expended, gives a total expenditure
for this work of $3,372,447.53.
   A total of $8.90 received from sale of unserviceable property has
been received and deposited to the credit of the appropriation.
    By this expenditure two stone jetties have been constructed and a
seagoing dredge provided, which together have produced a navigable
channel with a minimum width of 400 feet and a controlling depth of
24.5 feet at mean low water, or 5.5 feet more than called for by the
project.
   All work done during the fiscal year was for maintenance and con-
sisted of the raising and repairing of the South jetty, between sta-
tions 8800 and 11350, by the placing of a total of 29,697.57 tons of
stone. The jetty between these stations was raised so that its crest
was brought up to mean high water. The outer end of the jetty was
aproned for about 350 feet with small stone, and this aproning was
extended for about 100 feet beyond the outer end of the completed
work. A survey of the entrance to Cumberland Sound was made
and the results plotted.
    The present ship channel, as marked by the ranges, has a con--
trolling depth of 24 feet at mean low water, because of a slight ad-
vance of the lower point of Pelican shoal, but by slightly changing the
courses run 2 or 3 feet could easily be added to the navigable depth.
    The mean rise and fall of tide is 6 feet.
    The project for the improvement of Cumberland Sound was re-
ported as completed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1905, page 1287.
    It is proposed to apply the available balance and additional appro-
priation recommended toward raising the low places in the north and
south jetties to high-water mark, filling voids and openings in the
north jetty, and constructing mounds at the outer ends of both jetties,
and for such repairs to the dike on Cumberland Island and such
dredging in the jetty channel as may become necessary.
    The additional work proposed is for extension of benefits.
    As Cumberland Sound merely constitutes the ocean entrance to
Fernandina Harbor the commerce is practically the same as that for
Fernandina, and since the harbor of Fernandina is now a special work
of improvement the commerce is given under that head.
    The effect of the improvement has been to cause a reduction in
freight rates of from 25 to 40 per cent.
    This work has heretofore been mentioned in the law as "Cumber-
land Sound," but the sole object of the improvement is to afford a
deep entrance to the harbor of Fernandina, Fla., and this is what it
accomplishes. An appropriation has been made for the improvement
of the harbor of Fernandina, and had reference only to the inner por-
tion of the same. It would be better hereafter to unite these two
works under one head and refer to them as Fernandina Harbor,
Florida.
    A list of the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers and of execu-
tive documents containing the various projects, history of the work,
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 357
maps, etc., may be found printed on page 288 of the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1905.
   Reference to reports on examination and survey of Fernandina
Harbor, ordered by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, will be
found on page 312 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1906. Map showing conditions June 30, 1908, will be found opposite
page 1356, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................... $100, 930. 14
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....................................................    20, 000. 00

                                                                                                   120, 930. 14
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement. ............................ ............  ...........                               85, 868. 77

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.-----.....-----..............------------.....---------........    35, 061. 37
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                              148. 33

July 1, 1909, balance available ......................                     ...............          34, 913. 04

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
  expended July 1, 1909..............................         ...........                           50, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix O 10.)
   11. FernandinaHarbor, Florida.-Aswill be seen from Coast Sur-
vey chart No. 453, the lower end of Amelia River forms a deep basin
opposite the city of Fernandina, which portion of the river is known
as Fernandina Harbor. The lower end of the harbor connects with
Cumberland Sound and is 2 miles from the bar. The harbor is about
1,300 feet in width at the entrance and about 2 miles long. It em-
braces about 160 acres of well-sheltered anchorage ground, with a
depth greater than 25 feet at mean low water, but is somewhat
obstructed by small shoals. Above this basin there exists a shoal
some 4,000 feet in length, with low-water depths over same ranging
from 14 to 18 feet. Above this shoal the river separates into two
estuaries, which carry deep water for about 2 miles.
   A project providing for such extensions of the depth and width of
the channel in front of the town of Fernandina as will meet the
requirements of commerce will be found printed as House Document
No. 388, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
   The improvement proposed consists in dredging a channel with
widths varying from 400 to 600 feet and depths from 20 to 24 feet at
mean low water, in front of and to a short distance above (southwest
of) the city of Fernandina. The estimated first cost of this work is
$115,000, with $15,000 at periods of every two or three years for
maintenance after completion.
   This project was adopted by act of Congress approved March 2,
1907, which appropriated $115,000 for its completion.
   Work under the project was begun September 14, 1907, and com-
pleted July 28, 1908. During the fiscal year a total of 46,341 cubic
yards of material were removed under contract, completing the proj-
ect. The engineer building at Old Town, Fernandina, was repaired.
   On June 30, 1909, the controlling depths in the channel fronting
the city of Fernandina were those contemplated in the adopted
358             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OP ENGINEERS,                                         T.    S. ARMY.

project. Very little shoaling has taken place since the project was
completed. Soundings indicate some caving in the sides with the
depth on the edges of the channel slightly diminished.
  The mean rise and fall of the tide is 6 feet.
  The amount expended up to June 30, 1909, was $109,398.09.
  The project was completed July 28, 1908.
  It is proposed to expend the available balance and additional
appropriation recommended in maintaining the improvement.
  The additional work proposed is for extension of benefits.
  Attention is invited to the recommendation in the report on Cum-
berland Sound that that work and Fernandina Harbor be united
under one title and be hereafter reported upon as one work.
  Before the improvement of Cumberland Sound (in 1879), which
constitutes the ocean entrance to Fernandina Harbor, the annual in
and out bound tonnage at Fernandina was about 300,000, and the
value of imports and exports estimated at about $2,500,000. The
commerce of the port during the calendar year 1908 amounted to
550,000 tons, with a value of $9,274,000. The chief articles of
export are lumber, phosphate rock, and naval stores.
  The effect of the improvement of Cumberland Sound has been to
cause a reduction in freight rates of from 25 to 40 per cent. It can
not now be said what further effect the improvement of Fernandina
Harbor will have upon these rates.
  A map showing conditions June 30, 1908, will be found opposite
page 1358, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-------------------....------...........................----....--.. $29, 907. 02
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment----.......-----------------.....----......................-------------...-..----....------..---.............
                                                                                                                 --- 24, 305. 11
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.................                     ...... .............              .          5, 601. 91
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..---..---------..-----......--.................-----------.....-----.            50. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available ----------------------..............-------......--------..                        5, 551. 91
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...........-----------------------------------------.                                      10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix O 11.)
RESURVEY MADE                    IN    COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND HARBOR                                          ACT AP-
                                        PROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Report dated October 5, 1908, on resurvey of the inside water route
between Savannah, Ga., and Fernandina, Fla., with a view to deter-
mining the best route of said waterway, required by the river and
harbor act of March 2, 1907, was duly submitted by the district
officer. It was reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and
Harbors, pursuant to law, and was transmitted to Congress and
printed in House Document No. 1236, Sixtieth Congress, second
session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of $237,700
is presented.
                lIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEM1VENTS.                   359
IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE JACKSONVILLE,
                   FLORIDA, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Lieut. Col. Lansing H. Beach,
Corps of Engineers, to July 31, 1908, and of Capt. G. R. Spalding,
Corps of Engineers, since that date. Division engineer, Col. Dan C.
Kingman, Corps of Engineers.
   1. St. Johns River, Florida.-This work includes the improvement
of the bar at the river mouth and the improvement of the channel
from the bar to Jacksonville, a distance of 27.5 miles. Before im-
provement there was a varying channel across the bar, sometimes 5,
sometimes 7 feet deep, and shifting in location through a north and
south range of 1 mile. Between the bar and Jacksonville the channel
had a least mean low-water depth (at Dames Point) of 11.5 feet.
   The range of tide is 5.22 feet at the bar, 4.3 feet at Mayport, 1.8
feet at Dames Point, and 0.8 foot at Jacksonville.
    The first project of improvement, adopted in 1879, contemplated
a channel 15 feet deep at mean low water from Jacksonville to the
ocean. This was to be obtained by dredging and building training
walls in the river and by building two stone jetties converging upon
the bar, 1,600 feet apart at their outer ends. Under this project the
sum of $1,417,000 was expended. As a result the bar channel was
fixed and deepened to 13 feet, and the river channel was deepened to
16.5 feet.
    The present project, adopted in 1896 and modified in 1903, con-
templates a channel from Jacksonville to the ocean 300 feet wide and
24 feet deep, except at Dames Point, where the width was to be 400
feet and the depth 25 feet, this channel to be obtained by dredging
and building training walls in the river and by raising and extending
the jetties. The estimated cost was $2,109,750, increased in 1908 to
$2,176,750, of which $67,000 remains to be appropriated.
    The funds appropriated have been expended in building a sea-
going suction dredge (St. Johns) and a river dredge (Jacksonville),
in dredging with the plant thus provided and by contract, in building
training walls, and in raising and extending the jetties at the en-
trance. The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $2,255,489.80,
of which $175,175.99 was for construction of a seagoing dredge and
 $227,933.39 for work of maintenance. The result has been the com-
pletion of the channel contemplated by the project, excepting through
the shoals at Trout Creek and at White Shells. At the first place
the channel is only about 230 feet wide, the remaining 70 feet being
obstructed by rock and soft material.
    At White Shells the channel is narrowed about 60 feet by a ledge
of coquina rock and has filled in until its width is not more than 150
feet. Shoaling occurred in Browns Creek cut and in Fulton cut, re-
quiring work of maintenance. In these localities the United States
dredge Key West removed from the channel 153,067 cubic yards of
material at a cost of $10,000, restoring projected depths through these
cuts to a width varying from 150 to 300 feet. Shoaling at Mile Point
cut and at White Shells cut has occurred and contract has been en-
tered into for dredging at these localities under the allotment of
 $300,000 for the maintenance of this work made from the appropria-
tion of $8,185,750 in the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
360      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

Under this same allotment contract has been entered into for raising
the outer 1,500 feet of the north jetty and filling in critical points in
the middle section of that jetty and along the south jetty.
    On account of the shoaling at Mile Point and White Shells, the
projected depth of 24 feet at mean low tide is not available, it being
reduced to 22 feet at Mile Point, but practically a channel having
a least available depth of 24 feet does exist, since the increased tidal
rise at the shoal localities over that in the upper portion of the
river compensates for the decreased depth at low tide.
   The increased length and draft of the ships now entering the port
of Jacksonville indicates that widening is needed at several bends
in the channel, notably at the upper end of Fulton Reach and Browns
Creek and. at the New Berlin bend. The increased size and speed
of the combined passenger and freight steamers plying this river
has caused a considerable washing of banks at several places in the
river and indicates the necessity of bank revetment at these points
and of increased height of some sections of the'training walls.
    The channel between the jetties has maintained itself remarkably
during the year, indicating that the jetties may be relied upon to
do their work with efficiency if properly maintained.
    The channel over the outer bar continues to increase in cross
section, especially in depth, indicating that a depth over the present
projected one could probably be maintained were the channel through
Wards Bank trained and concentrated by dredging. It is believed
that to properly continue their present efficiency, the north jetty
should be restored throughout to its projected height and section
and that the south jetty should be also raised to its original height
for at least one-half its length.
    The district officer estimates that the sum of $200,000 will be
required for restoring the jetties to their original cross section where
indicated as being desirable; that $85,000 will be required for main-
tenance by dredging and widening at bends and for necessary bank
protection, a total of $285,000, in addition to the sum of $67,000
required to complete the channel at Trout Creek shoal. The project
is 97 per cent completed.
    The river and harbor act of 1909 provided for a survey of this
river with a view toward adopting a more extended project. Should
report on this survey lead to the adoption of a new project, the
estimate for maintenance would be materially changed.
    Were it not for the improvement, freight rates from Florida to
northern points would be 50 per cent greater than they are.
    The St. Johns River is navigable in fact from the mouth to Lake
Washington, a distance of 276 miles, but for deep-draft vessels only
as far as Jacksonville, 27.5 miles. The head of steamboat navigation
is Lake Poincett, 252 miles from the mouth.
    The estimated value of the commerce for 1908 is $60,000,000.
    Tonnage by years: 1898, 494,474; 1899, 816,477; 1900, 649,221;
1901, 700,179; 1902, 903,191; 1903, 1,052,076; 1904, 1,000,316; 1905,
1,406,647; 1906, 2,455,101; 1907, 2,485,610; 1908, 1,589,126.
    The decrease in tonnage over that given for the years 1906 and
1907 isdue, inlarge part, to the decided falling off in lumber ship-
ments caused by the general conmercial depression existing through-
out the country. In other respects than that of actual tonnage the
commercial activities of the port have largely increased, due to the
improved channel. The first shipment of phosphate rock, amounting
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           861
to 1,600 tons, was made during December, 1908, and charters have
already been made for a shipment of a least 200,000 tons of this
product during 1909.
   During 1908 the following transportation lines were established
to this port:
   The Gans Line and Burg Line to German ports, and the Logan
Line to Liverpool; the Merchants and Miners' Line have made
Jacksonville their southern terminus, giving triweekly sailings to
Baltimore and Philadelphia; the Jacksonville and Tropical Steam-
ship Line, plying between Jacksonville, Fla., and Habana, Cuba.
  To properly estimate the value of the commerce of the port is
very difficult, as the value of merchandise shipments, the most valu-
able portion of the commerce, is known only to the consignees. The
more valuable shipments, such as cotton, merchandise, tobacco, etc.,
have increased in spite of the general business depression, so con-
siderably as to almost if not quite balance the falling off in the lumber
trade. It is believed, therefore, that the estimate of $60,000,000 for
the value of the commerce is not too large for the last year.
   During the first six months of 1909 the foreign commerce of this
port amounted to $1,366,453.08, as against $353,670.10 for the
same months of last year, and the net tonnage of ships entering
and clearing during the months of April and May amounted to over
500,000 tons.
   The port statistics for the year are accurate, having been carefully
compiled by a thoroughly efficient man employed by the Jacksonville
Board of Trade solely for that purpose.
  More detailed information may be found in Reports of the Chief
of Engineers as listed on page 329 in Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1907.
  It is proposed to expend the available balance in prosecuting the
work of raising the jetties and maintenance dredging under contract
and with hired plant.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to widening the
channel at turns and critical points, to shore protection, and to mainte-
nance of jetties. T his work is required to make the improvement
available to the class of traffic invited by the depth of channel.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.........------......------------....----...                ----.........---..    $1, 304.50
August 21, 1908, allotted from emergency appropriation, act of March 3,
  1905-.................----------.....---------...........................                                       10, 000.00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....------------------.....................--------------------.........--............-------... 300, 000.00
                                                                                                -------------
Receipts from sales------.....----..................-------------........----------------..........                     7.70
                                                                                                               311, 312. 20
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ....-----.--...---.....------...............------------------....----....------.........-----    11, 671.75
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended--..---..................-------------------..--...--...-----......            299, 640. 45
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.............................                              ......              154. 20




tAmount
                                                                     -------- 299, 486. 25
July 1, 1909, balance available------......----------.......-----------........
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                                        67, 000. 00
              that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  S1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909.......- ........  ....... ...........                                       250, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundrv civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix P 1.)
362            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                       S. ARMY.

   2. St. Johns River, Florida, opposite the city of Jacksonville.-The
project for improving the St. Johns River from Jacksonville to the
ocean provides for a channel 24 feet deep. Between the channel and
the pierhead lines at the city of Jacksonville the depths are in many
places considerably less than 24 feet. A project for securing a depth
of 24 feet at mean low water from the existing channel to the pierhead
line on the left bank of the river, between the Florida East Coast
Railway bridge and Hogans Creek, was adopted by the river and har-
bor act of March 2, 1907. The estimated cost (raised in 1908) is
$586,500.
   Work upon this project began October 1, 1907. The work, as far
as available funds permit, is nearly completed, the contractor now
being engaged in clearing up after the dipper dredge.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $309,998.61, of which
$3,500 was expended for purchase of a site for a warehouse and
wharf for the plant engaged on the St. Johns River work, and $1,105.82
for surveys necessary to relocation of harbor line monuments.
   Upon completion of the present contract the entire work will be
about 60 per cent completed. The result has been a deepening to
about 24 feet over the area between the Florida East Coast Railway
bridge and the lower Clyde Line docks, but the clear depth has not
yet been secured.
   The average rise and fall of tide is 0.8 foot, although under special
conditions the river sometimes rises to a height of 3 feet above mean
low water.
   For commercial statistics and other general information, reference
is made to the current report and summary on improvement of St.
Johns River, Florida.
   The work so far completed has, it is believed, had an advantageous
effect on freight rates, as it has permitted deeper draft vessels to
reach the wharves, thus obviating the necessity of lightering to
midstream.
   It is proposed to apply the amount which is estimated as a profitable
expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to the completion of
the project which is necessary to extend the benefits over the entire
frontage contemplated.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................... $259, 149. 12
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment................-----........... ........ .... . ....... ..... ...... 197, 647.73

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.........-----------.................-------------.....-----...         61, 501. 39
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..--....------..............-----------------.....--------.....    30, 799. 51

July 1, 1909, balance available..-------.......----.....--------------------......---..                 30, 701. 88

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ---....--...      ...                             13, 648. 20
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- .-.-.-.                                215, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909 .----------------------------------------------                                         215, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.
    (See Appendix P 2.)
                    RIVER AND      HA1RBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                          363
   3. St. Johns River at Orange Mills flats, Florida.-The object of
this work is to obtain a 13-foot channel at mean low water from
Jacksonville to Palatka. Before improvement there were four
shoals, all near Orange Mills, of less depth than 13 feet. These were
Forresters Point shoal, least depth 11.6 feet; Orange Mills flats, 9.8
feet; Racey Point shoal, 10.1 feet; and Tocoi shoal, 11.1 feet.
   The mean range of tide is 0.9 foot. The annual variation of water
stage is about 3 feet.
   The project, adopted in 1893, is to dredge a channel 200 feet wide
and 13 feet deep through the shoals named. The estimated cost
 (increased in 1906) is $185,000.
   The total expenditure up to June 30, 1909, was $119,156.50. The
result has been the formation of a channel 13 feet deep, 160 feet wide,
through Orange Mills flats and Forresters Point shoal and 120 feet
wide through Racey Point and Tocoi shoals.
   The project is about 64 per cent completed.
   The river is navigable to Lake Washington, a distance of 276 miles.
The head of steamboat navigation at present is Lake Poinsett, 252
miles from the mouth of the river.
   The existence of the St. Johns waterway has probably had an
important effect in keeping down freight rates, but the increase of
the channel to 13 feet has not, so far as known, caused any changes
in rates.
    This channel, however, permits light-draft schooners to load at
Palatka with cypress lumber from the large mills at that place, and a
diminution in depth in the channel, requiring lightering of this mate-
rial to Jacksonville, would, it is thought, raise the freight rates.
Difficulty in navigating this channel is being experienced, due to
insufficient width at angles and to the fact that it is not sufficiently
marked.
   The money expended during the fiscal year was for examination
of the channel and for engineering and contingencies.
   For more detailed information see Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1898, pages 1344-1348; for 1901, page 1738; for 1904,
pages 1690-1691.
    For examination and survey ordered by river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, see House Document No. 1111, Sixtieth Congress,
second session.
   The commerce of the upper St. Johns is chiefly in lumber, shingles,
building material, and general merchandise.
   Tonnage by years: 1898, 25,866; 1899, 122,074; 1900, 171,500;
1901, 67,500; 1902, 137,950; 1903, 269,610; 1906, 559,838; 1907,
273,070; 1908, 347,764.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to widening existing
channels, completing the project. The additional work proposed is
for the purpose of extension of benefits.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended........... .-..    .
                                                    .............  ....--... $1, 493. 50
June 10, 1909, allotted from emergency appropriation, act of March 3, 1905. 3, 000. 00
                                                                               4, 493.50
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment................ ......................... .........................       650. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended- .       -          -     ....--
                                                             --
                                               -.................   ......    3, 843. 50
864       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                  S. ARMY.

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........
                                                                 -       $65, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909.........    ..........................................      65,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.
   (See Appendix P 3.)
   4. Volusia bar, Florida.-The object of this improvement is to
secure a channel 5 feet deep through the bar of that name at the head
of Lake George, and from that lake to Lake Monroe. Before im-
provement the channel at this locality was very crooked, with a low-
water depth varying between 3.5 and 4.5 feet.
   The project, adopted in 1879 and modified in 1882 and 1887, pro-
vided for the construction of two converging jetties and for dredg-
ing, in order to secure a depth of 5 feet at mean low water, at an
estimated cost of $25,000.
   The project was completed in 1887 and additional work required
is for maintenance. As shoaling is continual, it has been found neces-
sary to dredge from time to time in order to maintain the requisite
depth.
   The total expenditure up to June 30, 1909, was $45,838, of which
$20,838 was for work of maintenance. As a result there is now a
channel from Palatka to Sanford having a least depth of 5 feet at
mean low stage.
   During the year $1,840 was expended from an allotment from the
appropriation for emergencies act of March 2, 1907, for the repair of
the guiding pile dikes at Volusia bar, the old structures having, on
account of their dilapidated condition, become a menace to navigation.
   On March 17, 1909, an allotment of $5,000 was made from the
appropriation provided by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909,
to be applied to the maintenance of this improvement. No work
had been done under this allotment at the end of the fiscal year.
   The head of steamboat navigation is Lake Poincett, 252 miles
from the mouth.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to maintenance of
existing channels.
   The usual variation of water level is 2 feet; the extreme variation,
31 to 5 feet.
   The existence of the St. Johns waterway has probably had an im-
portant effect in keeping down freight rates, but the increase of the
channel depth to 5 feet has not, so far as known, caused any change in
freight rates.
   The river is navigable in fact to Lake Washington, a distance of 276
miles from its mouth.
   For more detailed information see Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1896, pages 1313-1314; for 1897, page 1550; for 1905,
page 1296.
   The commerce of this portion of the river is chiefly in grain, fer-
tilizers, ship stores, vegetables, and general merchandise. The esti-
mated value of the commerce for 1908 is $3,000,000.
                                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                     365

  Tonnage by years: 1898, 21,959; 1899, 26,358; 1900, 31,511; 1901,
32,437; 1902, 53,678; 1903, 55,922; 1904, 60,347; 1905, 111,162; 1906,
412,703; 1907, 66,005; 1908, 66,690.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended a ......... ........... ...................                           $2. 00
September 30, 1908, allotted from emergency appropriation, act of March 2,
  1907 ................................................................                             1, 840. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909..................................................................                         5, 000.00

                                                                          6, 842.00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement.......................................................        1, 840.00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................................                             5,002.00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909........-.....      .    ............................          6, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix P 4.)
   5. Oklawaha River, Florida.-Before improvement this river was
obstructed by snags, accumulation of drift, and overhanging trees.
   The project, adopted in 1891, was to clear the river of obstructions,
so as to give a navigable channel 4 feet deep at mean low stage from
the mouth to Leesburg, a distance of 94 miles, at an estimated cost
of $26,000. This was modified by the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907, which provided for removing obstructions and deepening the
channel to 6 feet at mean low water from the mouth of the Oklawaha
to the head of Silver Springs Run at an estimated additional cost of
$15,000. This project is printed in House Document No. 782, Fifty-
ninth Congress, first session.
   Up to June 30, 1909, the total expenditure under this project was
$38,894.41, of which $16,292.12 was for work of maintenance.
   As a general result, there is a fairly well-cleared channel 6 feet deep
for the first 32 miles of the stream, a practicable channel 4 feet deep
at ordinary low stages of the river to Silver Springs Run, 53 miles
from the St. Johns River, and a channel 3 feet deep at ordinary stage
of water to Leesburg, 94 miles from the mouth. Leesburg is the head
of steamboat navigation.
   Silver Springs Run, 54 miles long from the Oklawaha to its head
at Silver Springs, affords the best channel of the entire route.
   As a result of the expenditure for maintenance, several shoal places
have been dredged and many snags and overhanging trees removed.
   The original project is believed to be about 55 per cent completed,
but owing to the fact that logs and snags are carried by freshets into
the stream or moved from the sides into the channel, more work will
have to be done that can be estimated from examination or survey.
   During freshets the water sometimes rises to a height of 4 feet
above its normal stage.
   The improvement has had no appreciable effect upon freight rates.
    The commerce concerned is small.                                          The boats using the river are
chiefly excursion steamers, which run during the winter months. One
steamer, however, runs regularly during the entire year and affords
the only means of communication for the adjacent country.
           a Refundment of overpayment made in fiscal year ending June 30, 1908.
366          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                        S. ARMY.

   A considerable revival in interest in this stream is noticeable among
the business men at Leesburg, which is situated at the head of navi-
gation, and at Ocala, which is situated 6 miles from the head of Silver
Springs Run, and it is quite probable that the completion of the
project would have a very decided effect on railroad rates. The river
is navigable in fact to Lake Apopka, 130 miles.
   Tonnage by years: 1898, 4,481; 1899, 4,291; 1900, 4,847; 1901,
4,530; 1906, 9,298; 1907, 9,129; 1908, 80,279.
   On March 17, 1909, the sum of $4,000 was allotted from the appro-
priation of $8,185,750 provided by the river and harbor act of March
3, 1909, to be applied to the maintenance of this improvement. No
work had been done under this allotment at the end of the fiscal year.
The amount expended was for examination of the channel and for
engineering contingencies.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to making certain
cut-offs, dredging shoals, and removing snags and overhanging trees
in the lower river, and in deepening shoal places in the upper river.
The additional work proposed is for the purpose of extension of
benefits and for maintenance.
   For further information see Report of Chief of Engineers for 1896,
pages 1314-1316; for 1905, page 1298.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...            -............... ............... .....    $189. 64
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...............................                  ....................... 4, 000. 00
                                                                                        4, 189. 64
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...................................................                           84. 05
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                     4, 105. 59


IAmount
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 18, 208. 07
          that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909...................................
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
                                                                          20, 710. 00

   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix P 5.)
   6. Indian River, Florida, between Goat Creek and Jupiter Inlet.-
Indian River is a narrow sound between the coast and an outlying
fringe of islands. Before improvement the ruling depth was 2.5 feet.
The tide is negligible.
   The project adopted in 1891 provides for a continuous channel be-
tween Goat Creek and Jupiter Inlet 5 feet deep at mean low water
and at least 75 feet wide in the straight reaches, with as much greater
width as may be required in the turns. The estimated cost is $44,000.
   The total expenditure up to June 30, 1909, was $57,878.09, of which
$21,191.23 was for maintenance. As a result a channel was obtained
5 feet deep and nowhere less than 50 feet wide between Goat Creek
and Pecks Lake.
   The project is about 80 per cent completed.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to deepening and
widening existing channels, completing the project, and to work of
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       367
maintenance. The additional work proposed is to make the improve-
ment available.
   During the year an examination disclosed that, due to the fact that
the spoil banks from dredging were submerged and the channel
unmarked, boats were continually grounding on the spoil banks and
breaking them down and shoaling the channel. To prevent this, and
as an aid in maintenance dredging, substantial channel marks were
established. Maintenance dredging is required at several places where
not over 4 feet of water exists, which is the maximum depth which
can be carried June 30, 1909.
   The improvement has had no effect on railroad freight rates, as the
stream has no connection with a deep-water port. The river is much
used by those engaged in vegetable and fruit culture as a line of com-
munication between packing houses and the nearest railroad station,
thus causing a very considerable saving to the producer. The river
is an important link in the inside passage along the east coast of Flor-
ida and is much used by launches and an auxiliary schooner trading
between Lake Worth and Jacksonville. The length of navigable
channel under improvement by the Government is 77 miles. The
stream, or, more properly, the sound, is navigable in fact, partly
through private canals, from St. Augustine to Key West, a distance of
490 miles.
   It has been impracticable to secure trustworthy statistics of this
commerce, but it is very considerable.
   For history, description, and project see Report of Chief of Engi-
neers for 1896, pages 1318-1320; for 1905, page 1299; for 1906, page
1220.
   Jupiter Inlet.-This inlet having closed again, an allotment of
$2,000 was made June 8, 1909, from the appropriation of $300,000 pro-
vided by the emergency river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, to
restore the opening. Work under this allotment will begin shortly
after the close of the fiscal year.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $1,500.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................................................... $3, 642. 26
July 27, 1908, and June 8, 1909, allotments ($2,000 each) from emergency
  appropriation, act of March 3, 1.905.... . ....... ..... ..................                                 4, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909----.......--.....--------------------------..-----..........................-----.....------. 4, 000.00
Receipts from sales......................... ...........................                                           5.00

                                                                                                           11, 647.26
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for mainte-
  nance of improvement ......-----------............------------.........---.......... $5, 505.73
Refunded to credit of emergency appropriation................. 2, 000. 00
                                                                                                            7,505.73

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................                                       .........   4, 141. 53
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..................................                                       550. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available ..............                        ......................                3, 591. 53
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                                   9, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909...............................          13, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix P 6.)
368     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

   7. Biscayne Bay, Florida.-Before improvement, Biscayne Bay
was navigable for boats drawing less than 3 feet of water. There
was a channel, excavated at private expense, 12.5 miles long with a
least depth of 10.5 feet, from Miami to the Atlantic Ocean near Cape
Florida. The tidal range in the bay is about 1 foot.
   The river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, adopted in part a plan
proposed by a Board of Engineer officers appointed in accordance
with a provision in the river and harbor act of March 3, 1899. This
plan contemplated a channel 18 feet deep from the wharves at Miami
to the sea by way of a line entering the sea at a point about 4,000
feet north of Norris Cut, and a refuge basin of same depth, 1,200
feet long and 400 feet wide, in some suitable place, this channel to be
protected by one or two jetties, as might be found necessary. The
estimated cost of the entire improvement was $1,493,743. (See H.
Doc. No. 662, 56th Cong., 1st sess.) The act of 1902 appropriated
and authorized an expenditure of $300,000 for part of this work, and
provided that the Florida East Coast Railway Company should con-
struct, at its own expense, a basin 1,600 feet long and 500 feet wide
adjacent to the wharves at Miami and the channel from said basin
to the east side of the proposed refuge basin on the east side of the
bay; that the amounts appropriated 'and authorized by Congress
should be expended in constructing and protecting the portion of the
channel extending to the sea from the terminus of the channel to be
constructed by the railway company, of such approximately uniform
depth and of such widths as would best serve the interests of naviga-
tion and as could be constructed with the funds appropriated and
authorized. The act further provided that before any part of the
appropriation should be expended the said railway company should
enter into a contract with the United States for the performance of
its part of the work.
   The act of March 2, 1907, modified the project by prescribing a
width of 100 feet for the dredged channel, and by providing for a
jetty on the southern side of the entrance. The total estimated cost
of the work authorized by Congress is $546,000, all of which has been
appropriated.
   The total expenditure up to June 30, 1909, was $363,720.58, of
which $9,759.17 was for emergency work of maintenance by the con-
struction of shore revetment.
   As a result there is an available channel 10 feet deep across the
bay, the two jetties are completed, and the progress on the necessary
rock excavation in the channel between the jetties promises a com-
pletion of the present project during the next fiscal year.
   During the year the steamers operating between Jacksonville and
Habana made Miami a port of call.
   The project is about 60 per cent completed. The channel is not
open to navigation.
   A description of the bay, with report and recommendations of a
Board of officers, may be found in Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1900, pages 1986 to 2013.        (See also Report for 1905, pp.
1300-1302.)
   Tonnage by years: 1899, 18,089; 1902, 8,390; 1903, 13,319; 1904,
16,788; 1905, 40,700; 1906, 56,405; 1907, 106,010; 1908, 151,280.
    It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to maintenance.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR                  IMPROVEMENTS.                   369
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................... $265, 580. 62
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......     27, 000. 00
                                                                                      292, 580. 62
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ..                ..
                 -............ ........ ............ ............. .........          100, 541. 55
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                 192, 039. 07
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities------
                                      ...--.............. ----...............          12, 780. 26
July 1, 1909, balance available .........................           ......   ......   179, 258. 81
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts...............                   80, 198.07
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..............................................                   10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix P 7.)
   8. Harbor at Key West, Fla., and entrance thereto.-The entrance
referred to is the northwest channel. While Key West Earbor
accommodates vessels drawing about 27 feet, the ruling depth over
the northwest bar, before improvement, was 10.5 feet at mean low
water. The mean tidal range is 2.6 feet.
   The project adopted in 1889 contemplated a channel 17.feet deep
at mean low water. This was to be secured by building two stone
jetties, one to the northeast and one to the west of the channel, con-
verging toward the bar, and by dredging, if necessary. The esti-
mated cost of the east jetty was $500,000.
   The act of March 2, 1907, modified the project by authorizing con-
tinuance of work on the existing jetties or the building of training
walls, in the discretion of the Secretary of War.
   The total expenditure up to June 30, 1909, was $667,273.40, of
which $2,274.44 was for removing reefs from the main ship channel
and $10,000 for maintenance. As a result, the east jetty has been
built up to a height of 3 feet above mean low tide for a distance of
5,642 feet, the remaining 5,712 feet being at a level of about 5 feet
below mean low tide. The west jetty is about 20 per cent com-
pleted and in its present incomplete state is of very little value.
   A channel of 17 feet now exists over the outer bar and has been
well protected and maintained for two years. The channel across
the flats to the southward is in its original state and the ruling depth
over this flat, rather than the depth over the outer bar, limits the
usefulness of the channel.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance to dredging to secure
17 feet of water throughout the channel.
   An act of Congress approved May 28, 1908, authorized the ex-
penditure of $5,000 for the purpose of removing certain reefs from
the main ship channel from the appropriation for improving this
harbor. Of this amount $2,274.44 has been expended, four heads
having been removed to a depth of 30 feet by blasting. Further
work under this allotment has been postponed until the completion
of the sweeping operations which the Coast and Geodetic Survey has
now underway for the purpose of locating unknown heads.
        9001-ENa 1909-24
370           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                      U.      S. ARMY.

   It is believed that with funds in hand the channel can be main-
tained to the present authorized depth.
   The existence of the northwest channel has an important effect
upon freight rates between Key West and Tampa.
   The commerce is chiefly in cattle, fertilizers, tobacco, sponges,
and general merchandise.
   Tonnage by years: 1898, 72,968; 1899, 130,713; 1900, 30,594; 1901,
18,863; 1902, 14,146; 1903, 134,043; 1904, 174,305; 1905, 132,744;
1907, 189,258; 1908, 218,692.
   For further information see listed references on page 335, Report
of Chief of Engineers for 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..............................          $192, 583. 83
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..................................................                  147, 303. 76

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .                      -.................................              45, 280. 07
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities -.................................                                    577. 84

July 1, 1909, balance available ..................................                                      44, 702. 23
    (See Appendix P 8.)
   9. Kissimmee River, Florida.-Beforeimprovement the Kissimmee
River was tortuous, shallow, and obstructed by snags and overhang-
ing trees.. At ordinary stages the least depth was about 2 feet, and
in dry seasons navigation was altogether suspended. Canals had
been made through some of the worst bends by private enterprise.
   The project adopted June 13, 1902, provided for a channel 30 to
60 feet wide and 3 feet deep at ordinary low-water stages in the Kis-
simmee River (including the connecting canals and lakes) from the
town of Kissimmee to Fort Bassinger, and for a channel 25 feet wide
and 3 feet deep in Istokpoga Creek. The estimated cost of the im-
provement was $24,220.90.
   The total expenditure up to June 30, 1909, was $27,138.72, of
which $6,362.64 was for maintenance. The project is completed.
   The result has been a deepening of the channel to a depth of 3 feet
from the town of Kissimmee to Fort Bassinger, at ordinary stages
of the river, and the clearing of Istokpoga Creek.
   The town of Kissimmee is at the head of navigation. The stream
is navigable in fact to the Gulf of Mexico, via Lake Okechobee and
Caloosahatchee River, a distance of 309 miles. During periods of
extreme drought the river is navigable for launches only, but during
eight months of the year steamboat navigation is possible.
   The commerce of Kissimmee River is in lumber, cattle, fish, naval
stores, fruits, vegetables, and general merchandise.
   Tonnage by years: 1901, 3,670; 1902, 9,655; 1903, 10,652; 1904,
2,863; 1905, 9,911; 1906, 10,111, 1908 (estimated), 10,000.
   The improvement of the stream has lowered freight rates on the
supplies handled 75 per cent. There is no rail communication to the
country adjacent to this stream, the only other line of supply being
by wagon line over poor roads.
   Failure to maintain the stream in its present improved state would
be no less than a calamity to those living in the lower Kissimmee;
valley.
   During the year $2,703.10 has been expended in clearing away
overhanging limbs, in closing subsidiary channels, and in dredging.
   On June 30, 1909, there is an available channel having a depth of
24 inches, barely sufficient for the steamboats operating on the stream,
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       371
   For reference to examination and survey, see page 289, Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
  The appropriation recommended is for maintenance of the improve-
ment. The work proposed is to make the improvement available for
the ensuing year.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................    .............      $2, 785. 38
May 21, 1909, allotted from emergency appropriation, act of March 3, 1905.      600. 00
Receipts from sales....................................        ............      26. 00
                                                                                      3,411. 38
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ...................................... ....... .............. ............     2, 703. 10
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................... . ..............                 708. 28
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities................ ...................               300. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available ......     ......        ..-... .
                                                        ...         ...............     408. 28
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909. .     ..........    ............................   10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix P 9.)
   10. Orange River, Charlotte Harbor, and Caloosahatchee River,
Florida.-These works were consolidated by the act of June 13, 1902.
    (a) Orange River.-Before improvement the least depth was 2.5
feet at mean low water, and the channel was obstructed by snags and
overhanging trees.
   The project, adopted June 13, 1902, provides for a channel 50 feet
wide and 4 feet deep at mean low water from the mouth of the river
to the head of navigation. The estimated cost was $2,500.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $4,000, of which $2,000
was for work of maintenance. No work was done during the past
year.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to maintenance.
   There is now a navigable channel 50 feet wide and 4 feet deep at
mean low water from the mouth of the river to the head of naviga-
tion, excepting in the upper portion of the river the full channel
width could not be obtained on account of the river width being less
than 50 feet.
   The mean rise and fall of the tide is 1 foot. The annual variation
of water level on account of freshets is about 2 feet. The maximum
draft that can be carried at mean low water is 4 feet.
   The head of navigation is the iron bridge at Buckingham, about 5-
miles from the mouth of the river.
   The commerce of Orange River is in fruits, vegetables, fertilizers,
lumber, and general merchandise. The value of the commerce for
the year 1907 was $277,669.34.
   Tonnage by years: 1896, 1,250; 1902, 7,155; 1903, 8,555; 1904,
3,099; 1905, 2,074; 1906, 6,258; 1907, 4,002; 1908,3,936 .
   The freight rates are practically the same as before the improve-
ment was made.
   For references to examinations and survey, see page 291, Report of
Chief of Engineers for 1904, and page 369 of Report of Chief of Engi-
neers for 1908.
372        REPORT OF THE CHIEF             OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S.   ARMY.

Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909 . .. .......................................................    $600. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................     600. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
   for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909 ......................................          .......... ........   (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Charlotte Harbor and Caloosahatchee River from Puntarasa to
Punta Gorda.-This project was completed in 1903. The amount
expended is $106,000. No work was done during the past year.
   (c) Caloosahatchee River between Puntarasa and Fort Thomp-
son.-Before improvement there was a navigable channel with a least
depth of 5 feet at mean low water from Puntarasa to Fort Myers, and
thence with a least depth of 3.5 feet to Fort Thompson. The upper
river was obstructed by snags and overhanging trees.
   The project, adopted in 1882 and modified in 1886 and 1888, pro-
vided for a channel 100 feet wide and 7 feet deep at mean low water
from the mouth to Fort Myers, for a channel 4 feet deep at mean low
water across the shoal at Beautiful Island, and for snagging and
cutting trees on the upper river.
   The project was completed in 1901, at a total cost of $33,600; the
results contemplated were obtained.
   Since that tinie $7,554.44 has been expended in work of main-
tenance. As a result there is a channel 4 feet deep from Fort Myers
to Fort Thompson at ordinary stages of water. No work was done
during the past year, the amount expended being for contingencies.
   On May 12, 1908, the Secretary of War allotted the sum of $3,000
from the emergency appropriation ($300,000) of the river and har-
bor act of March 2, 1907, for maintenance operations, consisting of
dredging shoals, removing snags, and trimming overhanging trees.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, was
7 feet from the river entrance to Fort Myers and thence 4 feet to
Fort Thompson, 59- miles above the mouth. The mean rise and
fall of tide at the river entrance is 1.6 feet. During freshets the
water level in the upper reaches of the river rises considerably.
   The Kissimmee River, Lake Okechobee, Caloosahatchee River, and
San Carlos Bay form a continuous waterway, navigable in fact. from
the head of navigation on the Kissimmee River to the Gulf of Mexico,
a total distance of 309 miles. From its mouth, in San Carlos Bay,
to its source, in Lake Okechobee, the Caloosahatchee River is 84
miles long.
   The commerce of Caloosahatchee River is in fruits, vegetables,
fertilizers, and general merchandise. The value of the commerce for
the year 1908 was $375,000.
   Tonnage by years: 1899, 33,101; 1900, 22,737; 1902, 27,895; 1903,
27,576; 1904, 12,255; 1905, 9,577; 1906, 22,265; 1907, 4,467; 1908,
8,064.
   No change in the nature of the commerce has resulted from the
improvement. The freight rates are practically the same as before
the improvement was made.
                   a See consolidated money statement on page 373.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                               373

  References to reports on examinations ordered by the river and
harbor acts of March 3, 1905, and March 2, 1907, will be found on
page 332 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906,
and on page 369 of report for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................................                                                 $3, 031. 24
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909.........------------------..........----....--.....------------........--------.....------.....---.....-----.     400. 00

                                                                                                                      3, 431. 24
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement-....-.............................                                         $31. 24
    For maintenance of improvement ...........................                                           54. 44
                                                                                                                           85. 68

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................                                     ................           3, 345. 56

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
    pended July 1, 1909.~... -.....                -----------                                                           (a)
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
    June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                                      CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................             $3, 031. 24
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ..............................            .... .. ............. ....  1, 000. 00
                                                                                                                      4, 031. 24
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..................................                                           $31. 24
    For maintenance of improvement -------..............----..........                                    54. 44
                                                                                                                           85. 68

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                                               3, 945. 56
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...        .......................................                                              5, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
    June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix P 10.)
   11. SarasotaBay, Florida.-Beforeimprovement there was a nav-
igable channel in Sarasota Bay with least depth of 5 feet at mean
low water, except at two shoals, where the depths were 4.3 and 3.5
feet, respectively. Little Sarasota Bay had a channel with a least
depth of 1.2 feet at mean low water, except at one shoal which was
bare at low water.
   The project, adopted in 1889, provides for a channel 100 feet wide
and 5 feet deep at mean low water from Tampa Bay to Sarasota at
an estimated cost of $17,500.
   The sum of $10,000 had been expended under this project when it
was modified (in 1896) to include a channel 75 feet wide and 3 feet
deep in Little Sarasota Bay from Sarasota to Caseys Pass. The esti-
mated cost of completion of the entire project was $45,000, making a
total estimate of $55,000, subsequently increased to $70,000.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, provided for continuing
improvement from Tampa Bay to Venice. Venice is about 2 miles
southeasterly from Caseys Pass.
                            a See consolidated money statement on this page.
374       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                   U.   S. ARMY.

   The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $58,035.25, of which
$13,077.18 was for work of maintenance.
   The project, as modified by the river and harbor act of March 2,
1907, is about 61 per cent completed.
   As a result there is a channel 50 feet wide and 5 feet deep at mean
low water from Tampa Bay to Sarasota. From Sarasota to Caseys
Pass the channel is 3 feet deep at mean low water, and varying in
width from 50 to 75 feet.
   The maximum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, was 5
feet to Sarasota, and thence to Caseys Pass, 2 feet. Mean rise and
fall of tide is 1.5 feet.
   The length of the 5-foot channel from Tampa Bay to Sarasota is 20
miles, and the 3-foot channel from Sarasota to Venice is 18 miles.
   Venice is the extreme southerly point of the channel and may be
given as the head of navigation in fact.
   During the winter season, when by far the largest shipments are
made, the prevailing winds decrease the mean level of the water in
the bay by over a foot. This fact would indicate the desirability of
a revision of the project with a view to securing a greater depth with,
if necessary, a reduction in width. The river and harbor act of
March 3, 1909, provided for a survey of this waterway with a view to
securing a revision.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, includes $10,000 for maintenance, which
is necessary to keep this improvement available, and $25,000 which is
necessary to complete the project by widening, thus extending pres-
ent benefits.
   The commerce of Sarasota Bay is in naval stores, fruits, vegetables,
fertilizers, fish, lumber, and general merchandise. The value of com-
merce for the calendar year 1908 was $1,300,000.
   Tonnage by years: 1899, 9,424; 1902, 4,313; 1903, 4,755; 1904,
25,479; 1905, 8,556; 1906, 12,010; 1907, 13,350; 1908, 54,700.5.
   The freight rates have been lowered 25 to 50 per cent, depending on
freight classification, since the improvement was undertaken.
   For reference to examination and survey, see page 293, Report of
Chief of Engineers for 1904.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..............        ......................        7. 50
November 2, 1908, allotted from emergency appropriation, act March 2, 1907.     3, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........        .............................................    5, 000. 00
                                                                                8, 007. 50
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement...........---..........................................--...        3, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................          5, 007. 50

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 25, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909---.................................... 35, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix P 11.)
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    375

   12. Manatee River, Florida.-Before improvement there was a
least depth of 9 feet at mean low water over the bar at the river
mouth; thence to Palmetto the least depth was about 6 feet; thence
to Bradentown about 3 feet; thence to Ellenton 7 feet; thence to
Rocky Bluff 6 feet; thence to Rye 1 feet.
   The project for the improvement of this river was adopted in 1882
and contemplated a channel 100 feet wide and 13 feet deep from
Tampa Bay to Shaw and McNeills Points. This project has been
modified as follows: In 1886 to provide for a channel 100 feet wide
and 8 feet deep to Manatee, and in 1897 to provide for a cut-off to
Terraceia Bay. The river and harbor act of 1907 provided for the
completion of the project modified by providing for a channel 100
feet wide and 9 feet deep from Shaw and McNeills Points to Rocky
Bluff and thence 4 feet deep and 75 feet wide to Rye.
   The total estimated cost of the entire work was $130,520.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, appropriated $10,000
for maintenance of the improvement.
   To June 30, 1909, there has been expended $123,826.43, of which
 $19,540.80 was for maintenance. With this expenditure a channel 12
feet deep and 60 feet wide was dredged across the bar at the mouth
in 1883-84. This channel has since been practically obliterated.
    A channel 9 feet deep and 100 feet wide has been secured to Rocky
Bluff and thence 75 feet wide and 4 feet deep to Rye, and a cut-off
channel 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep has been secured to Terraceia
Bay.
    Operations during the fiscal year consisted in maintenance work
in Terraceia Cut-off, in the channel from McNeills Point to Braden-
town, and in the section from Rocky Bluff to Rye, and in improve-
ment work between Bradentown, Rocky Bluff, and Rye.
    The project is 70 per cent completed.
    It is proposed to expend the available balance for completion of
the project between Tampa Bay and Shaw and McNeills Points and
in maintenance.
    No proper estimate for maintenance can be made until a careful
survey and investigation has been made to determine the possibility
of maintaining a 13-foot channel over the bar at the mouth of the
river. This examination will be undertaken in the survey ordered
by the river and harbor act of 1909.
    A maximum draft of 9 feet can be carried to Rocky Bluff, 6 feet
through Terraceia Cut-off, and 4 feet to within 3 miles of Rye.
    Mean rise and fall of tides at Manatee River entrance is 1.6 feet.
The annual variation of water surface in the upper river on account
of freshets is about 3 feet.
    The head of navigation is Rye, and length of the navigable channel
is 20 miles. The stream is navigable, in fact, a further distance of
about 2 miles.
    The commerce of the river is in fruits, vegetables, fuller's earth,
lumber, naval stores, and general merchandise.
    Tonnage by years: 1898, 23,800; 1899, 43,542; 1900, 55,162; 1902,
34,495; 1903, 44,367; 1904, 46,517; 1905, 49,644; 1906, 88,153.
    Freight rates have not materially changed as a result of the
improvement.
376            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S.                                           ARMY.

  For report of examination and survey made in 1902, see pages
1749-1756, Report of Chief of Engineers for 1904.
  It is proposed to apply the available balance to dredging in order
to complete the project, and to maintenance.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended --.......-.-... ...........-....... $62, 264. 45
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....   --.............                          ...................
                                                              .........          10, 000. 00
                                                                                                          72, 264. 45
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ..................       .........                            $42, 132. 48
    For maintenance of improvement ....-...................                                  3, 897. 60
                                                                                                          46, 030. 08

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended... ......--.....   ..    ........    ...                                 26, 234. 37
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...---------------------------------                                  2, 997. 80

July 1, 1909, balance available-.........................-----------------------------------..            23, 236. 57
   (See Appendix P 12.)
   13. Tampa Bay, Florida.-Before improvement the least depth
between the Gulf of Mexico and Port Tampa was 13 feet.
   The first project, adopted August 11, 1888, contemplated a channel
200 feet wide and 20 feet deep at mean low water from Tampa Bay to
Old Tampa Bay. The estimated cost was $63,000. Prior to this
work was carried on in connection with improvement of Hillsboro
Bay.
   The total expenditure under all these projects was $130,000.
   The present project was adopted March 3, 1899. It provided for a
channel 27 feet deep at mean low water from the Gulf of Mexico to
Port Tampa, 500 feet wide across the bar and 300 feet wide in the bay,
a channel of full width and 24 feet deep to be first secured, and sub-
sequently deepened. The estimated cost was $750,000.
   This project was modified March 3, 1905, by Congress authorizing
the Secretary of War to expend the balance remaining to the credit
of this improvement in securing a channel 26 feet deep with sufficient
width and by providing that no expenditure should be made until
the owners of the terminals at Tampa Bay should by valid contract
agree that the wharfage charges at such terminal should be submitted
for approval to the Secretary of War. A schedule of such charges
was approved by the Secretary of War on October 26, 1906.
   The amount expended under this project, as revised, to June 30,
1909, was $607,460.81, including contingent expenses and completion
of the United States dredge Key West.
   It is proposed to expend the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure for fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in dredging for
maintenance to keep the improvement available.
   Operations during the year consisted in dredging under contract
and by government plant in prosecution of the project, which is 80
per cent completed.
   The maximum draft that can be carried at mean low water is 24-
feet. Mean rise and fall of tide at Tampa Bay entrance is 1.5 feet
and at Port Tampa 2 feet.
   The head of navigation for 242-foot draft is Port Tampa, 35 miles
from deep water in the Gulf of Mexico. Tampa Bay is navigable in
fact over its entire area.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                               377
   The commerce is in phosphate, lumber, coal, crude petroleum,
tobacco, grain, and general merchandise. The value of the commerce
for the year 1908 was $14,821,838.68.
   Tonnage by years: 1896, 276,638; 1898, 236,136; 1899, 238,305;
1900, 350,761; 1901, 416,503; 1902, 462,703; 1903, 435,867; 1904,
591,181; 1905,604,131; 1906,838,378; 1907,885,202; 1908,1,314,104.
  The freight rates have been lowered 20 per cent on phosphate ship-
ments since the improvement was undertaken.
  For report of examination and survey of Tampa Bay, see Report of
Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 1596 et seq.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................            $93, 659. 21
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....    .......                     .--.........................  20, 000, 00

                                                                         113, 659. 21
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ....................................................... 91, 095. 56

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................... ............          22, 563. 65
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................        1, 700.00

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................             20, 863. 65
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance
  unexpended July 1, 1909..........................................               18,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix P 13.)
   14. Hillsboro Bay, Florida.-Beforeimprovement the channel from
deep water in Hillsboro Bay to the city of Tampa was narrow and
tortuous, with least depth of about 4 feet at mean low water.
   The first project, adopted in 1880, provided for a channel 9 feet
deep at mean low water, 150 feet wide in the bay and 200 feet wide
in Hillsboro River. In 1888 the proposed depth was reduced to 8
feet. This project was practically completed in 1893, at a cost of
$80,000.
   A second project, adopted March 3, 1899, contemplated a channel
12 feet deep at mean low water, 150 feet wide in the bay and 200 feet
wide in the river, from the 12-foot contour in the bay to a point 100
feet south of the Lafayette Street Bridge in Iillsboro River. The
estimated cost was $300,000. The total expenditure under this
project was $275,000. The project was completed, except that the
width in a small part of the bay channel was only 110 feet.
   A new project adopted March 3, 1905, provided for a channel 20
feet deep at mean low water and 150 feet wide from the lower bay to
the mouth of Hillsboro River, with a turning basin at inner end 450
feet wide and 1,050 feet long, at an estimated cost of $448,350. The
work was completed on February 29, 1908. The full depth was
obtained in the channel excepting in the northwesterly end of the
turning basin, where there is a minimum depth of 16.8 feet at mean
low water, over a small area where ledge rock is found.
   During the fiscal year ended June 30, 1909, the three turns in chan-
nel were widened, the turning basin restored to its original depth,
and a dolphin constructed near westerly edge of turning basin.
378          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                   U.     S. ARMY.


  The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, under this project was
$448,642.60, of which $37,628.07 was for maintenance. The amount
derived from miscellaneous sources was $207.05.
  The result of this work has been to make Tampa a terminal point
for two railroads and a point of call for freight and passenger steamers
plying between Gulf and Atlantic ports.
  The maximum draft that can be carried at mean low water through
Hillsboro Bay to the head of the turning basin, 360 feet from the
mouth of Hillsboro River, is 20 feet. Mean rise and fall of the tide
in Hillsboro Bay is 2.2 feet.
  The head of navigation for 20-foot draft vessels is Hendry &
Knights Garrison dock at Tampa, which is situated on a channel
connecting with the turning basin that was dredged by private
capital. The head of navigation is 41 miles from deep water in the
Gulf of Mexico. Hillsboro Bay is navigable in fact over its entire
area.
  The commerce of Hillsboro Bay is in cigars, coal, fertilizers, grain,
lumber, phosphate, and tobacco. The value of the commerce for
the calendar year 1908 was $16,145,504.
  Tonnage by years: 1898, 32,070; 1899, 87,740; 1900, 96,029; 1901,
131,208; 1902, 169,844; 1903, 228,252; 1904, 274,399; 1905, 307,460;
1906, 450,056; 1907, 520,629; 1908, 560,281.
  During the fiscal year, with an allotment of $1,000 made from the
emergency appropriation of March 2, 1907, the usual channel depths
in the river to Lafayette Street Bridge were restored.
  The freight rates by water were lowered about 10 per cent during
the last calendar year, and have been lowered about 35 per cent since
the improvement was undertaken.
  For references to examinations and surveys see page 295 of Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, and House Document No. 1121,
Sixtieth Congress, Second session.
  It is proposed to expend the available balance and the additional
appropriation recommended for maintenance of the project.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................... $37, 548. 50
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......................................................                             10,000.00
December 15, 1908, allotted from emergency appropriation, act of March
  2, 1907--------.....-------............--.--..-------------.....-------------.......--.....--.    1, 000.00
Receipts from sales .....................................                               ..........      16. 45

                                                                                                     48, 564. 95
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ............................                             $36, 628. 07
    For maintenance of improvement ...................                                  1, 000. 00
                                                                                                     37, 628.07

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...............................                   .                  10, 936. 88
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..----........... ......... ........ ......                        100. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available................                     ....................             10, 836. 88

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909............              ....................................                 10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harr a act of 1899.
    (See Appendix P 14.)
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           379
   15. Crystal, Anclote, and Suwanee rivers, Florida.-These works
were consolidated by the act of June 13, 1902, and included Manatee
and Withlacoochee rivers. The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905,
made separate provision for Manatee River, and the act of March
2, 1907, made separate provision for Withlacoochee River.
   (a) Crystal River.-Before improvement the channel from the
Gulf of Mexico to the town of Crystal River was tortuous and shal-
low, the least depth being 2.7 feet at mean low water. The entrance
to the river was obstructed by reefs and sand bars.
   The project, adopted June 13, 1902, contemplates a channel 60
feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water from the Gulf to the
town of Crystal River. The estimated cost was $84,647.46.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $23,482.40, of which
$2,700 was for completion of the dredge Florida.
   The project was completed on December 6, 1906.
   The maximum draft that can be carried at mean low water is 2.7
feet. Mean rise and fall of the tide is 2.3 feet.
   The town of Crystal River is at the head of navigation, and the
length of the navigable channel is 9 miles.
   Maintenance work is needed in this river, and it is proposed to
undertake this work with government dredge at an early date with
the balance available.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure during fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, will be needed for maintenance during
that fiscal year in order to keep the improvement available.
   The commerce of Crystal River is in lumber, pencil cedar, oysters,
fish, and general merchandise. The value of the commerce for the
year 1908 was $1,250,000.
   Tonnage by years: 1902, 1,785; 1903, 725; 1904, 6,875; 1905, 7,474;
1906, 8,291; 1907, 7,888; 1908, 48,742.
   The freight rates have been lowered 10 per cent since the improve-
ment was undertaken.
   For references to examinations and surveys, see page 296 of Report
of Chief of Engineers for 1904, and page 369 of report for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                            $1, 730. 05
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ....................................................                              3, 000. 00
                                                                                                 4, 730. 05
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement ..........................                                 .......................         5. 73

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                             4, 724. 32

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 ................................... ......... a 2, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Anclote River, Florida.-Before improvement the channel be-
low Tarpon Springs was narrow and tortuous and obstructed by
shoals. The least mean low-water depth was 2 feet.
                       a See also consolidated money statement on page 381.
380          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                      U.    S. ARMY.

   The project, adopted March 3, 1899, contemplates a channel 100
feet wide and 6 feet deep at mean low water from Anclote anchorage
to Sponge Harbor, and thence 4 feet deep at mean low water to the
county bridge at Tarpon Springs. The estimaged cost was $51,500.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $37,150.50. There is
now a channel 6 feet deep and 100 feet wide from the mouth of the
river to Anclote, and 4 feet deep and 100 feet wide, thence to the
county bridge at Tarpon Springs. The projected width of channel
over the outer shoals in Anclote anchorage has not yet been secured
and the amount estimated as a profitable expenditure during fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, it is proposed to expend in securing a full
width of channel at this point. This is necessary in order to make
the full improvement available.
   The maximum draft that can be carried at mean low tide to Sponge
Harbor is 6 feet, to the county bridge at Tarpon Springs is 4 feet.
   The mean rise and fall of tide at Anclote River entrance is 2 feet.
The head of navigation is the county bridge at Tarpon Springs. The
length of the navigable channel is 5 miles.
   The commerce of Anclote River is in sponges, lumber, naval stores,
and general merchandise.
   Tonnage, by years: 1899, 1,441; 1900, 1,000; 1903, 2,138; 1904,
8,310; 1905, 31,050; 1908, 5,215.
   The freight rates have been lowered about 20 per cent.
   The project was 72 per cent completed at end of the fiscal year.
   For reference to examination and survey, see page 297 of Report
of Chief of Engineers for 1904.
   It is proposed to expend the available funds in dredging in con-
tinuation of the improvement.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................................        $16, 345. 94
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ........................................................   5, 000. 00
                                                                                                        21, 345. 94
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ............................                                $15, 240. 21
    For maintenance of improvement.-------..........------.............                    1, 256. 23
                                                                                                        16, 496.44

July1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................................                                 4, 849.50
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities---..--....----...-----............--------...........             1, 632.45

July 1, 1909, balance available ................               ..................                   .    3, 217. 05

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                                14, 500. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909 ....................------------------------------------------------ a14, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  S1897.
   (c) Suwanee River, Florida.-Before improvement the channel in
the Suwanee River was narrow and tortuous and obstructed by a
bar at the entrance and by bowlde.s, soft rock shoals, snags, and
overhanging trees. The least depth at mean low-water stage was 15
inches.
                   a See also consolidated money statement on page 381.
                          RIVER AND HIARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              381
   The project, adopted in 1879, provides for a channel 150 feet wide
and 5 feet deep from the mouth to Rollands Bluff (75 miles) and
thence 60 feet wide and 4 feet deep to Ellaville (60 miles). This is
to be secured by dredging, building wing dams, and snagging. The
estimated cost is $65,158.
   The total expenditure up to June 30, 1909, was $69,451.72, of which
$9,203.96 was for maintenance.
   The project was 92 per cent completed on June 30, 1909.
   As a result, there is now a channel 5.8 feet deep at mean low water
and 50 feet wide from the Gulf of Mexico to a distance of one-half
mile above the mouth of the river, and thence to Rollands Bluff a
channel 5 feet deep at mean low water and 100 feet wide. From Rol-
lands Bluff to Beesons shoal, 21 miles below Ellaville, there is a chan-
nel 4 feet deep at mean low water and varying from 30 to 100 feet
in width.
   Full channel width has not, however, been secured through the
shallow entrance to Suwanee Bay, and it is proposed to expend the
available funds for this widening, completing the project, and in
maintenance. This work is for the purpose of making the improve-
ment fully available.
   The maximum draft that can be carried at the river entrance is
about 4 feet.
   Mean rise and fall of tide at Suwanee River entrance is 2.4 feet.
The annual variation of the water surface in upper river on account
of freshets is about 5 feet.
   The village of Ellaville is at the head of navigation. Length of
the navigable channel is 135 miles.
   The commerce of Suwanee River is in lumber, naval stores, and
general merchandise. The value of the commerce for the year 1908
was $287,500.
   Tonnage, by years: 1898, 106,346; 1899, 76,878; 1904, 7,658; 1907,
25,705; 1908, 11,590.5
   The improvement has had no effect on freight rates. Only three
steamers now operate on the river occasionally.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................            $7, 074. 80
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment .......................................................................     789. 62

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...........................................       6, 285. 18

                                               CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended........................................ $25, 150. 79
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...................................................         8, 000.00

                                                                                  33, 150. 79
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...........................            $16, 035. 56
    For maintenance of improvement.......................            1, 256. 23
                                                                                  17, 291. 79

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................             15, 859.00
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................................. ....       1, 632.45

July 1, 1909, balance available.................................                  14, 226. 55
382       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                     S. ARMY.

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......... $14, 500. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909.----......--............. ..... .......... 16, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix P 15.)
    16. Withlacoochee River, Florida.-Before improvement the en-
trance to the Withlacoochee River was crooked and obstructed by
reefs. The least depth at mean low water was about 3 feet. Vessels
loaded and discharged at an anchorage (called the loading pool)
about 9 miles from the entrance. Inside the mouth there was a
depth of 7 to 8 feet as far as Inglis, a distance of 9 miles.
    The original project, adopted in 1879, provided for a channel hav-
ing an available depth of 2 feet during about half the year from the
mouth of the river to Pembertons Ferry, a distance of 77 miles, and
was completed in 1892, at a cost of $24,403.62. A balance of $296.38,
together with $5,000 from the consolidated appropriation made by
the river and harbor act of 1902, was applied to the construction of
the dredge Florida.
    A project adopted June 13, 1902, provided for straightening the
channel from the loading pool to the river mouth and deepening it
to 8 feet, and for work of maintenance.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1907, was $30,000.41. As a
result a channel was obtained with a least depth of 7.8 feet at mean
low water and a least width of 60 feet through the most obstructive
shoals.
    A good deal of dredging has been done by the Port Inglis Terminal
Company, under permission granted by the Secretary of War.
    The present project, adopted by the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907, provides for a channel 100 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean
low water from Port Inglis to the anchorage in the Gulf of Mexico,
at an estimated cost of $215,400 and $5,000 annually for mainte-
nance. The act authorized continuing contracts for completing the
work in the sum of $150,000, all of which has been appropriated.
Work under this project began April 11, 1908, and at the end of the
fiscal year the project was about 20 per cent completed. The amount
expended on present project to June 30, 1909, was $47,619.
    The head of steamboat navigation is at the county bridge, about 2
miles below Istachatta, or 76 miles above the mouth. The river is navi-
gable, in fact, to Dobes Fish Hole, about 112 miles above the mouth.
    It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable expend-
iture in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to maintenance in
order to keep available the improvement secured under both old and
new projects.
    The mean rise and fall of tide at Withlacoochee River entrance is
2.8 feet. The annual variation of water surface in the upper river
on account of freshets is about 6 feet.
    Length of the navigable channel from the loading pool in the Gulf
of Mexico to Port Inglis, at mouth of the river, is 9 miles; thence up
the river to Inglis, 9 miles; thence to Pembertons Ferry, 68 miles.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                383
   The commerce of Withlacoochee River is in phosphate, lumber,
coal, iron pyrites, and general merchandise. Port Inglis, at mouth
of the river, is a subport of entry. Vessels ply regularly from the
anchorage basin off the river entrance to European ports with cargoes
of phosphate.
   The value of commerce for 1908 was $2,000,000.
   Tonnage, by years: 1899, 4,941; 1900, 2,550; 1902, 74,047; 1903,
115,269; 1904, 123,369; 1905, 249,884; 1906, 181,226; 1907, 206,509;
1908, 198,610.
   The freight rates have been reduced about 30 per cent since the
improvement was begun.
   It is proposed to expend the available funds for dredging.
   For improvement of the river, see Report of Chief of Engineers
for 1904, pages 298-299 and 1710-1711.
   For report on preliminary examination and survey authorized by
the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, see House Document No.
483, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................   ........  $164, 210.31
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......   50, 000. 00
                                                                              214, 210. 31
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment-----..........................................................-        46,429.31

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..-....- ..............................       167, 781.00
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.....- .......-...-..-..............-.    11, 635. 27
July 1, 1909, balance available..........-------.......          ---------- 156, 145. 73
                                                             .-----------------..........
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..................       142, 256.45
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.....................................       ......        12, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix P 16.)

   17. Removing the water hyacinth from Florida waters.-Before
improvement many Florida rivers, especially the St. Johns and its
tributaries, were badly obstructed by packs of hyacinths. The first
project, adopted March 3, 1899, provided for the construction of a
boat and booms and for destroying the water hyacinths by crushing,
The estimated cost was $36,000, plus an undetermined amount for
annual expenditure. Nothing was done under this project, as expe-
rience in Louisiana showed that destruction by crushing was imprac-
ticable.
   In 1902 a new project was adopted, providing for the destruction
of the hyacinths by any means whatsoever. The plan adopted under
this project was to spray the plants with an arsenical compound.
The estimated cost was $50,000 per annum.
   Under this project the sum of $84,977.97 was expended. A steamer
was purchased and fitted up for spraying, and the main stream of
the St. Johns River and a number of tributaries were cleared of
hyacinths.
384          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                     S. ARMY.


   The act of 1905 modified the project by prohibiting any process
injurious to cattle. The plan consequently adopted is to close inlets,
sloughs, etc., with booms, to break up the packs with a suitable boat,
and propel them into the current in order that they may float away.
   Work during the year was done on Black Creek, Peters Creek, High-
land Park Canal, and Norris Cut, tributaries of the St. Johns River,
at Volusia bar, in Kissimmee River, Orange River, and Withlacoo-
chee River, Florida.
   The total expenditure up to June 30, 1909, was $113,432.34. In
addition to the information obtained as a result of exhaustive experi-
ments, the St. Johns River and many of its tributaries, most of the
Kissimmee River, and Orange River were cleared of hyacinths, in so
far as they formed an obstruction to navigation.
   It is expected that the available balance will be expended in remov-
ing the hyacinth from the navigable streams of Florida.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to continuing work of
removing water hyacinths. The additional work proposed is for the
purpose of extension of benefits.
   For further information see Reports of Chief of Engineers listed
on page 346 of the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, and
see also pages 1333-1334 of the report for 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................    $18, 158. 20
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.................................................................    5, 173. 74
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended---------..........----------...---...------..........---...        12, 984. 46
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..--------.....-------------------...........--------.......       729. 94

July 1, 1909, balance available-----.............................-------------------------------.   12, 254. 52

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                           Indefinite.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909--.......-.                                 10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix P 17.)
  18. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangeringnavi-
gation.--On June 17, 1908, the sum of $700 was allotted for the
purpose of removing the wreck of an abandoned phosphate dredge
and washer and a cluster of piles in Hillsboro River. A contract
was entered into with the Edwards Construction Company, of Tampa,
Fla., July 29, 1908, for the removal of these obstructions. Work
began August 27 and was completed September 29, 1908. The cost
of the work, including incidentals, was $450.
   On December 7, 1908, the sum of $1,500 was allotted for the
removal of the wreck of the schooner Addie F. Cole from the channel
leading to Anclote anchorage, Florida. A contract was entered
into with C. S. Washington, of Tampa, Fla., January 30, 1909, for
the removal of this wreck. Work began February 12 and was com-
pleted February 19, 1909. The cost of the work, including inci-
dentals, was $730.84,
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    385
   On January 22, 1909, the sum of $1,000 was allotted for the removal
of the wreck of an old stern dock in Man-of-War Harbor, near Fleming
Key, Key West, Fla. The work was done by hired labor, using a
leased outfit. The removal of the wreck began May 3 and was com-
pleted May 13, 1909. The cost of the work, including incidentals,
was $1,000.
   On April 21, 1909, the sum of $700 was allotted for the purpose of
removing sunken logs, etc., from the Hillsboro River. The necessary
outfit was leased and work began May 3 and was completed May 13,
1909. One hundred and fifty-four pieces of obstruction, consisting
of logs, timber, etc., were removed. The cost of the work, including
incidentals, was $700.
   The total expenditures during the year for removing the above-
mentioned obstructions was $2,880.84.
   (See Appendix, P. 18.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS MADE IN        COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
            HARBOR ACT APPROVED         MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports on preliminary examinations and surveys required by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities
within this district were duly submitted by the district officer. They
were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors,
pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in
documents as indicated:
   1. Preliminary examinations of St. Johns River, Florida,from Jack-
sonville to Sanford and from Sanford to Lake Harney, and of survey of
St. Johns River from Palata to Sanford and from Sanford to Lake
Harney.-Reports dated June 3, 1907, and October 1, 1908, respec-
tively, are printed in House Document No. 1111, Sixtieth Congress,
second session. Two plans of improvement are presented, viz, from
Palatka to Sanford at an estimated cost of $109,000, and from San-
ford to Lake Harney at an estimated cost of $20,600.
   2. Preliminary examination and survey of Hillsboro Bay, Florida,
from the turning basin to the head of the estuary in the direction of
Ybor.-Reports dated July 16, 1907, and April 7, 1908, respectively,
are printed in House Document No. 1121, Sixtieth Congress, second
session. In view of the wording of the act it has been impracticable
to reach a definite conclusion as to the advisability of undertaking
this improvement.
   3. Preliminary examination and survey of Estero Bay, Florida.-
Reports dated August 12, 1907, and October 5, 1908, respectively, are
printed in House Document No. 1189, Sixtieth Congress, second
session. The locality is not considered worthy of improvement at
the present time.
   4. Preliminary examination and survey of Clearwater Harbor and
Boca Ciega Bay to Tampa Bay, Florida.-Reports dated August 5,
1907, October 5 and October 27, 1908, respectively, are printed in
House Document No. 1190, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan
for improvement at an estimated cost of $59,000 is presented.
     9001-E G 1909--25
386     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

   5. Preliminary examination and survey of St. Lucia (Lucie) Inlet,
Florida.-Reportsdated July 19, 1907, and October 1, 1908, respec-
tively, are printed in House Document No. 1312, Sixtieth Congress,
second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of
$1,400,000 is presented, provided local interests contribute a share
of the expense of the necessary work.

EXAMINATIONS    MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND HARBOR ACT
                    APPROVED MARCH 3, 1909.

   Reports on preliminary examinations required by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, of the following localities within this
district were duly submitted by the district officer. They were re-
viewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant
to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in documents
as indicated:
   1. Preliminary examination of New River, Florida, with a view to
securing a depth of 20 feet of water at the cut-off near the mouth, with
jetties to protect the same.-Report dated April 16, 1909, is printed in
House Document No. 70, Sixty-first Congress, first session. The lo-
cality is not considered worthy of improvement by the General Gov-
ernment in the manner proposed.
   2. Preliminary examination of Indian River, Florida, from Fort
Pierce to Sewalls Point.-Report dated March 31, 1909, is printed in
House Document No. 75, Sixty-first Congress, first session. The lo-
cality is not considered worthy of improvement by the General Gov-
ernment at the present time.
   3. Preliminary examination of Pine Island Sound, Florida,from
Wulfert bulkhead to Blind Pass, thence along the western side of said
sound to Captiva bulkhead.-Report dated April 14, 1909, is printed
in House Document No. 77, Sixty-first Congress, first session. The
locality is not considered worthy of improvement by the General
Government at the present time.

IMPROVEMENT     OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE MONTGOMERY,
                      ALABAMA, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Capt. H. B. Ferguson, Corps of
Engineers; division engineers, Col. E. H. Ruffner, Corps of Engineers,
to August 31, 1908, and Lieut. Col. Lansing H. Beach, Corps of
Engineers, since that date.
  1. East Pass and Carrabelle bar and harbor, Florida.-The town
of Carrabelle is situated at the mouth of Carrabelle River, which
empties into St. George Sound. The river forms the inner harbor
and along the water front its channel varies from 9 to 14 feet in
depth, with a minimum width of about 100 feet.
  Dog Island anchorage, a protected portion of St. George Sound,
showing a 4-fathom depth over a considerable area, forms the outer
harbor. Between the 10-foot contours in the inner and outer harbors
there is a bar about 6,000 feet wide, which originally had a minimum
low-water depth over it of 32 feet to 4 feet.
  Dog Island anchorage is connected with the Gulf of Mexico by
East Pass, which originally had limiting low-water depths of about
17 feet on the outer bar and 16.5 feet on the inner bar.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      387
   The approved project for Carrabelle bar and harbor, Florida,
adopted June 3, 1896, provides for dredging a channel 10 feet deep
and 100 feet wide from Dog Island anchorage, St. George Sound, to
the city of Carrabelle, at a cost estimated in 1900 at $47,300, in addi-
tion to appropriations already expended on the project amounting to
$22,399.54. By act of Congress approved June 13, 1902, this project
was extended to include the improvement of East Pass by dredging
a channel across the bar 20 feet deep and 150 feet wide, and closing
an opening in Dog Island, at an estimated cost of $27,450. This
part of the project is compjeted.
   By act of Congress approved March 2, 1907, the project was
further extended to include a channel 18 feet deep and 100 feet wide
from the 18-foot contour in the outer harbor to a point opposite the
beacon situated about 1,000 feet up the river from its mouth, with a
suitable turning basin, but the size of the basin was not fixed by
Congress, and the estimated cost of the extension of the project has
not been determined.
   The amount expended up to the close of the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, was $148,866.15, of which $21,704.08 was expended
prior to estimate of 1900, and about $46,110.98 has been applied to
maintenance.
    The channel at the mouth of the river has been partially dredged
from time to time. During 1906 it was completed to a width of
100 feet and a depth of 10 feet from the wharves at Carrabelle to a
point 1,400 feet south of the red beacon, and also widened 100 feet
at the turn opposite Timber Island, but it shoaled at the inner end.
During the past fiscal year a channel 100 feet wide and 10 feet deep
has been completed from the wharves at Carrabelle to site of pro-
posed turning basin.
   The maximum draft that could be carried through the channel to
the inner harbor on June 30, 1909, was 10 feet.
    The shoaling of this channel is believed to be due largely to storm
action, and it should be protected to the eastward. This will be
largely accomplished by the work which the Georgia, Florida and
Alabama Railway Company is to undertake.
    In 1904 the channel across the outer bar was deepened by dredging
from about 17 feet to 20 feet, and across the inner bar from about
16.5 feet to 17.5 feet, this limiting depth being confined to a short
distance.
    During the past fiscal year a channel across the outer bar was
dredged 150 feet in width and 20 feet in depth. The maximum
draft that could be carried through this channel on June 30, 1909,
was 201 feet.
    The ordinary range of the tide is about 2 feet.
    The commerce of the port of Carrabelle consists principally of
timber, naval stores, dressed and kiln-dried lumber, shingles, fish,
oysters, and general merchandise, and for the year ending June 30,
1909, is estimated at a valuation of $475,025.
    With the work done a substantial reduction in ocean rates is
expected, due to increased draft and improved facilities for lighterage,
and a further reduction on freight handled by rail should result from
the completion of the project for turning basin and 18-foot channel
thereto, and the improvements projected by the Georgia, Florida
and Alabama Railway Company in connection therewith.
388           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to completing
the 18-foot channel and turning basin, and in maintenance to keep
the improvement available.
   Reference to reports on examinations and surveys of this harbor
will be found on pages 333 and 355 of Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1906.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....................................   $48, 8692. 62
Allotment from emergency appropriation, act of March 2, 1907..........    9, 861. 35
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........................................................  15, 000. 00

                                                                                          73, 553. 97
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ...........................                  $43,729. 75
    For maintenance of improvement .....................                   24, 624. 94
                                                                                          68,354. 69

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                  a 5, 199. 28
July, 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...............................          ....       2, 466.51

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                    2, 732.77
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909-...-..-.... ........-.......   ..... b 35, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix Q 1.)

   2. Harbor at Apalachicola Bay, Florida.-The town of Apalachi-
cola lies at the mouth of the Apalachicola River, and the deep water
along the river front forms the inner harbor.
   At the mouth of the river, between the inner harbor and the
3-fathom anchorage area in Apalachicola Bay, there is a bar of which
the original width between 8-foot contours was 7,000 feet and the
minimum depth of water 3.5 feet. Across this bar the lumber exported
is lightered either to the 3-fathom anchorage in Apalachicola Bay or
through Bulkhead shoals to the anchorage of Carrabelle, 25 miles dis-
tant. The 3-fathom anchorage area is entered via West Pass, where
originally the depth was about 13 feet. The original depth over Bulk-
head shoals was less than 4 feet.
   The original project, adopted June 14, 1880, provided for dredging
a channel 100 feet wide and 11 feet deep through the bar at the mouth
of the river, the width of cut to be increased to 200 feet if the results
justified this enlargement.
   This project was amended September 19, 1890, to include dredging
a channel 9 feet deep and not less than 100 feet wide across the Bulk-
head shoals.
   Upon this project as amended has been expended $154,000, of
which $100,000 has been applied to maintenance in repeated dredging
of the cut across the bar at the mouth of the river. The channel
  a In addition to this balance the further sum of $15,000 is made available by the
river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, but not yet allotted.
   b The item of $20,000 for dredge construction may be omitted if the improvement
of St. Andrews Bay, Fla., is not authorized.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     389

through Bulkhead shoals, dredged in 1891-2, remains practically
unchanged, with a minimum depth of 8 feet at mean low water.
   Prior to the adoption of any project of record in this office $18,700
was expended on this improvement-1833-1839-but the object and
results of such expenditures are unknown.
   By act approved March 3, 1899, a new project was adopted, which
provided for a channel 100 feet wide, 18 feet deep at mean low water,
through the West Pass along the northern shore of St. George Island
and across the bay to the water front of Apalachicola, estimated to
cost $350,000, and $20,000 or $30,000 annually for maintenance of
completed work.
   The amount expended on this project was $130,679.26, of which
about $90,000 was for maintenance.
   By act of Congress, approved March 2, 1907, a new project was
adopted by which the previous project was amended so as to provide
for a channel across the bar at the mouth of the Apalachicola River
not less than 100 feet wide and 10 feet deep at mean low water and
a channel not less than 150 feet wide and 18 feet deep through Link
channel and West Pass to the Gulf of Mexico, at an estimated cost of
$85,000, and $17,500 annually for maintenance after completion.
    During the last fiscal year the channel 10 feet deep and 100 feet
wide across the bar at the mouth of the river was completed. For
protection of this channel from westward-moving silt, a bulkhead to
the east of it was completed during the fiscal year. The length of
this bulkhead is 6,900 feet.
    About 75 per cent of the project is completed.
    The amount expended on this project up to the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909, was $84,871.68, of which $19,359.64 was
for maintenance of project of 1899.
    The hurricane of September 26-27, 1906, seriously damaged the
channel across the outer bar at West Pass by extending the shoal at
the western end of Sand Island across the dredged cut, filling it and
forcing this part of the channel farther to the west.
    The ordinary range of the tide is about 2 feet.
    The commerce of this port is in timber, cotton, naval stores, staves,
a large quantity of dressed and kiln-dried lumber, shingles, laths, and
miscellaneous freight, and for the year ending June 30, 1909, is esti-
mated at a valuation of $712,538.
    On June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that could safely be carried
through the West Pass entrance to the lower anchorage behind St.
George Island was about 14 feet, and the maximum draft that could
be carried across the bar at the mouth of the river was about 9 feet.
    Reference to reports on examinations and surveys of this harbor
will be found on pages 335 and 355 of Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1906.
    It is proposed to apply the appropriation asked for to continuing
improvement and for maintenance to keep the improvement available.
    The portion of the project now completed gives greatly increased
facilities to the commerce of this port and a substantial reduction in
freight rates on coastwise commerce. The exact amount of this
reduction and the reduction on foreign commerce can not yet be
stated.
390            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................... $20, 361. 50
Amount allotted from appropriation by. river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...............................................           20, 000. 00

                                                                                                     40, 361. 50
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .............................                           $11, 052. 80
    For maintenance of improvement ........................                             9, 359. 64
                                                                                                     20, 412. 44
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..............                 .......................               19, 949.06
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.......-----------..--------................---------........       696. 17
July 1, 1909, balance available ..................................                           .....   19, 252. 89
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                             25, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...............................         a 60, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix Q 2.)
   3. Apalachicola River, Florida, including the Cut-off and Lower
Chipola River, Florida, and the Upper Chipola River from Marianna
to its mouth. (a) Apalachicola River, the Cut-off, and Lower Chipola
River.-From the junction of the Chattahoochee and Flint rivers to
the Gulf of Mexico (Apalachicola Bay) the Apalachicola River has
a length of about 137 miles and a low-water slope of about 3 inches to
the mile. The width varies from 150 to 300 yards and the available
depth was originally 6 feet at low water, except where obstructed by
snags and sunken logs.
   The confederate authorities obstructed the channel at a point
about 47 miles above the mouth, causing the river to break through
by a channel known as Moccasin Slough into the River Styx, the
latter a tributary entering the Apalachicola a few miles below the
confederate obstructions. Moccasin Slough was very narrow and
tortuous and much obstructed by logs, snags, etc., and the former
channel has gradually filled up.
   About 55 miles above the mouth steamboats may leave the river
and, after passing through the Cut-off, Lower Chipola River, and Lee
Slough, reenter it about 17 miles farther down, thus making many
landings of much greater importance than those upon the correspond-
ing part of the main river, which includes Moccasin Slough, above
mentioned.
    The original project adopted by the act of June 23, 1874, contem-
plated securing a channel 100 feet wide and 6 feet deep at low water
by the removal of snags and overhanging trees and widening and
straightening Moccasin Slough and the Elbows, at an estimated cost
of $80,333.
    The act of September 19, 1890, adopted an addition to the project,
providing for the clearing of a channel 60 feet wide and 5 feet deep
through the Cut-off, Lee Slough, and the Lower Chipola River, at a
cost of $7,500.
  aThe item of $20,000 for dredge construction may be omitted if the improvement
of St. Andrews Bay is not authorized.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    391

   The amount expended on work under this project since 1874 to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $106,485.72. In
addition there was expended between 1828 and 1831, $13,000, for
which no project is of record. These expenditures have improved
Moccasin Slough sufficiently for present purposes and maintained the
river reasonably free from snags and other obstructions and enabled
steamboats to make use of the Cut-off, Lower Chipola River, and Lee
Slough either by day or night. An available depth of 6 feet has
been secured in the Apalachicola River and 5 feet in the Cut-off,
Lower Chipola River, and Lee Slough. The Cut-off and Lee Slough
have been widened also at the narrowest places so that steamboats
can pass through readily going downstream and can pass upstream
with little difficulty, but the channel in Lee Slough is still very
crooked, with some sharp bends that require easing, and the steam-
boats prefer the main river on the up trip. It is estimated that the
project is about 85 per cent completed.
   The work was done with the plant belonging to the Chattahoochee
and Flint river improvements, and comprised cutting overhanging
timber, removing snags and logs, blasting out cypress stumps, and
widening the slough and Cut-off by clearing the points of timber and
dredging them off, depositing the dredged material in the deep holes
or upon the banks.
   During the fiscal year work has been confined to the maintenance
of the improvement and a small amount of permanent work in the
Cut-off and Lee Slough.
   Variation of the water level is from 0 to 30 feet at Chattahoochee
River bridge.
   This river is navigable throughout its entire length of 137 miles.
   As the country bordering on the Apalachicola River is largely
dependent upon the river for the transportation of its supplies and
products, this improvement is essential to the development of this
section, but in the absence of any basis of comparison the effect upon
freight rates can not be determined.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance and the funds recom-
mended to maintenance of Apalachicola River proper by removing
annual accumulation of snags, and to continue straightening and
widening the Cut-off as above to make the improvement available.
   The commerce of the river consists chiefly of cotton, naval stores,
general merchandise, saw logs, and timber for export, and is so com-
bined with that of the Chattahoochee, Flint, and Upper Chipola riv-
ers that a separation is impossible. The commerce of all these streams
has increased from about $4,000,000 in 1899 to about $12,000,000 in
1909. For detailed statistics see report on Flint River improvement.
   For reference to reports of examinations of this river see Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 337.
   (b) Upper Chipola River, Florida,from Mariannato its mouth.-
The river from Marianna to the head of the Dead Lakes has a gen-
eral low-water depth of 5 feet and width varying from 60 to 200 feet,
but is greatly obstructed by rock shoals, snags, and overhanging
trees. Three bridges also form obstructions, their headways above
low water being 17, 16, and 15 feet, respectively.
   At Look and Tremble shoal, about 45 miles above the Dead Lakes,
there is a fall of 5 feet in 40 over rock bottom. At Sister Islands,
392     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,       U.   S. ARMY.


between this shoal and the Dead Lakes, the main channel of the
river is very tortuous and obstructed by mud bars over which there
is less than 2 feet at low water. The channel through the Dead
Lakes, which is considered part of this improvement, has plenty of
water, but was obstructed by snags and large cypress stumps and
trees.
   The approved project, adopted by act of March 3, 1899, provides
for clearing a low-water channel 3 feet deep and 60 feet wide from
Marianna to the foot of the Dead Lakes, estimated to cost $41,000,
exclusive of necessary plant, which would comprise a snagboat,
drilling barge, and dump scow.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $20,000. In 1904
$5,000 was applied to the river above Sister Islands. Snags, logs,
and overhanging trees were removed, and a channel blasted through
the rock reefs from Marianna to Look and Tremble shoal; wing
dams were built below some of the shoals, and below Look and
Tremble shoal, down as far as Sister Islands, snags, logs, and
overhanging timber were removed, as well as available funds per-
mitted. From the lower end of the Dead Lakes for a distance of
35 miles a channel 60 feet wide was cleared of obstructions by
removing logs, overhanging trees, cypress stumps, and knees.
During the year snagging was done from the Dead Lakes to Look
and Tremble shoal. Very little benefit has been derived from the
expenditure above Look and Tremble. shoal, except to timber
industry, but the work done below the shoal and in the Dead
Lakes has been of great benefit, as there are many turpentine stills
below this shoal, giving a considerable commerce on this portion
of the river, and in the Dead Lakes a large commerce in towing logs.
    The variation of the water level is 0 to 14 feet.
    Two feet is the maximum depth at low water over the shoalest
part of the river below the shoal Look and Tremble. The actual
head of navigation at ordinary low water is Braxton's landing,
40 miles above the foot of the Dead Lakes. The river is in fair
condition to Look and Tremble shoal.
    About 50 per cent of the project is completed.
    The commerce of this stream consists principally of naval stores,
round and square timber, lumber, and other miscellaneous freights,
the value of which is included in the combined commerce reported
under Flint River improvement.
    The section of country below Look and Tremble shoal has no
railroads, and depends largely upon this river, the reduction in
freight rates being the lessened haul to river as compared to Apa-
lachicola River or railroads to the north and west.
    It is proposed to apply the available balance and the funds
recommended to dredging and regulation of channel at Sister
Islands bar and to removal of snags and overhanging trees in
remainder of river. This work is necessary to make the improve-
ment available.
    The territory through which the stream flows is heavily timbered
with long-leaf yellow pine and cypress, which is now being rafted
down this stream in large quantities. The total amount of this
traffic is reported as approximately 10,000,000 feet b. m. per
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               393
annum, and is included in the valuation of timber and lumber
exports for Apalachicola Bay and Carrabelle, Fla.
  For reference to report of examination of this stream, see Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 338.
                                      APALACHICOLA RIVER.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ........................................                 $977. 50
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement .......     .............. ........ .....           .........................  786.74
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ........................              ....   .............         190.76
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
   for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909..................................................                                    (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                        LOWER CHIPOLA RIVER.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended........................................ $5, 265.92
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ..............................    $2, 000.00
    For maintenance of improvement ......................       3, 182. 44
                                                                           5, 182. 44

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                 83. 48
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                          3, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...........   .... ......   ...........                           (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                        UPPER CHIPOLA         RIVER.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................... $3, 589. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.......................................................      3,589.00

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 30, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement ..... ......         .....  ..                               (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                              MAINTENANCE.

Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909............................................................ $13, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of im-
  provement .........................................................         4, 009. 96
July 1, balance unexpended .....................................                               .   8, 990. 04

                       a See consolidated money statement on page 394.
394         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                    S. ARMY.

                                        CONSOLIDATED.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.                        ..............................
                                                         ....                           $9, 832. 42
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......................................................                  13, 000. 00
                                                                                                  22, 832.42
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement. ...................... .....                          $2, 000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement.......................                           11, 568.14
                                                                                                  13, 568. 14
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................          .....................                 9, 264: 28
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.-..........                        33, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909---.......-.-...-.--.....-.-........  10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix Q 3.)
   4. Flint River, Georgia.-Originally this river was navigable at
low water from its mouth to Bainbridge, a distance of 36 miles, for
boats drawing 3 feet, but the channel was narrow, crooked, and
greatly obstructed by logs, snags, and overhanging trees. Above
Bainbridge the channel was so obstructed by rock shoals, loose rock,
and bowlders that there was no navigation except on a rise of 5
feet, when steamboats could run to Albany, 105 miles above the
mouth. Above Albany to Montezuma, 182 miles from the mouth,
the channel was so obstructed by sand and rock shoals, bowlders,
snags, logs, and overhanging trees that the river was not navigable at
a low-water stage.
   The original project called for a channel 100 feet wide and 3 feet
deep at extreme low water from the mouth of the river to Albany, Ga.,
at an estimated cost of $184,862.
   This project was extended in 1879 to give a channel for light-draft
steamers at moderate stages of water from Albany to Montezuma by
the removal of logs, snags, and overhanging trees, cutting through
rock reefs, and deepening sand bars by contraction works, at an addi-
tional cost of $15,000.
   The amount expended up to the close of the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, was $281,711.41, practically all being for permanent
work. As a result of the work done, the river is now navigable
throughout the year from Albany down to a point about 7 miles
below Newton, 40 miles, and from Bainbridge to the mouth, 36 miles,
there being a good channel with 3 feet available at low water through-
out these sections. The project is about 70 per cent completed.
   Between Bainbridge and Newton, for a distance of 29 miles, the
river is navigable for light-draft boats only, and the channel is nar-
row and still much obstructed by bowlders and rock reefs. Con-
siderable work has been done between these points, and operations
for the next few years will be confined to this portion of the river.
When the improvement of this section has been completed the river
will be open to navigation at low water from its mouth to Albany, Ga.
   The section between Albany and Montezuma, 77 miles, is still
much obstructed, although it has been repeatedly cleared of snags
and similar obstructions m accordance with the project.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                             395
   The water level varies from 0 to 40 feet.
   During ordinary low water Albany, Ga., is the head of navigation,
but in periods of extreme low water, such as occurred during the fall
of 1904, interruptions occur in the section between Bainbridge and
Newton.
   The commerce consists pricipally of cotton, naval stores, provi-
sions, general merchandise, saw logs, and timber for export. Several
very large saw mills are located at Bainbridge, but no record of the
amount of lumber manufactured is kept, as shipments are made by
rail. A large part of the saw logs-used by these mills comes down
the river. The commerce of the lower part of this stream is so com-
bined with that of the Chattahoochee and Apalachicola rivers that
it is impossible to give a statement in regard to it. The commerce
of that part above Bainbridge is estimated to be about 2,800 tons,
valued at $100,000.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance and the funds recom-
mended toward making the improvement below Albany fully avail-
able by widening the channel in many places between Bainbridge
and Newton, and removing many obstructions to secure the width
of 60 feet and the depth of 3 feet now available in the section above.
   This work is largely permanent rock work, and its completion will
greatly benefit the section of country between Albany and the mouth
of the river. There are many turpentine stills in operation on the
river which depend upon the water transportation for their products
and supplies.
   The effect of the improvement on freight rates, if any, can not be
determined.
   For reference to reports of examination of this improvement, see
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 340.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............................................ $9, 638. 18
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........................................................      25, 000.00
                                                                         34, 638. 18
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment....................   ......................       ...........    10, 349.59

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..............................     ..... ....   24, 288. 59
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....- ....... .......................     1, 494. 24

July 1, 1909, balance available. -.......-..........................            22, 794. 35

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........        37, 500. 00
Amount tihit can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, fo. works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance ; nexpended July 1, 1909....-----............................   25, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix Q 4.)

  5. Chattahoochee River, Georgia and Alabama, below Columbus.--
Columbus, Ga., is 223 miles above the junction of this river with the
Flint River and 360 miles above the mouth of the Apalachicola
River, formed by the confluence of the Chattahoochee and Flint.
Originally boats drawing 22 inches were able to reach Columbus for
about nine months each year, but navigation was difficult and dan-
396      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

gerous by day and impossible by night, owing to the large accumu-
lation of logs, snags, and overhanging trees, and to sand, rock, and
marl shoals obstructing the channel.
   The project for the improvement, adopted in 1873, provided for a
low-water channel 100 feet wide and 4 feet deep from Columbus, Ga.,
to Chattahoochee, Fla., at the junction of the Flint, which was to be
obtained by the removal of logs, snags, and overhanging trees, cut-
ting through the rock and marl shoals, and scouring out sand bars
by works of contraction and shore protection. The estimated cost
of this work from Chattahoochee, Fla., to Eufaula, Ala., 139 miles,
was $145,247, but no estimate of cost for that part between Eufaula
and Columbus was ever made.
   The amount expended on this work to the close of the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909, was $723,643.33, largely expended in main-
tenance, removing the annual influx of obstructions brought in from
caving banks. The project is about 80 per cent completed in the
upper section above Eufaula and about 10 per cent in the lower
section.
   No increased depth, except in the upper part of the river, has been
gained; but by removing the logs, snags, and overhanging trees,
removing the sand, gravel, marl, and rock reefs, and regulating the
channel immediately below Columbus, the river has been kept open
to navigation. As nearly all the land along the banks of the river
and its tributaries has been gradually cleared, each rainy season has
brought increasing quantities of sand into the river, filling the
original river bed with shifting sand and gravel bars and greatly
changing its regimen. Four feet draft can be carried at ordinary low
water, but at extreme low water scant 3 feet is the maximum draft
that can be counted upon.
   Below Eufaula, Ala., the river is now in a fair condition, with an
available low-water depth of 3 - feet, but between Eufaula and
Columbus there are a number of bars and isolated obstructions which
cause trouble, particularly at extreme low water. The most serious
of these obstructions was a series of sand bars, formed in the river
from the wharves at Columbus down to Mary Freemans bar, 3 miles
below, which made it impossible for steamboats to reach Columbus,
and the head of navigation during the period of extreme low water
was therefore Mary Freemans bar.
   During the last few years more liberal appropriations have per-
mitted a more vigorous prosecution of work, and considerable prog-
ress has been made on the permanent improvement of the river. In
addition to maintaining the river free from snags and obstructions,
the channel for a distance of 32 miles below Columbus has been regu-
lated by a system of jetties, and the most serious bars in the upper
river have been kept open by dredging where necessary. As a result
of this work, Columbus has become the head of navigation, and boats
are able to reach there at all times except during unusually low
water, such as occurred in the fall of 1904, putting a stop to all navi-
gation.
   A large number of other sand bars and shoals between Columbus
and Eufaula still need improvement, the regulating works already
built require repairs and maintenance, and the annual accumulation
of snags and other obstructions must be removed from the river
throughout its length.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IVIPROVEMENTS.                                                  897
   It is proposed to apply the funds available and the appropriation
recommended to this work, the regulating works to be extended down
the river from the foot of the present permanent improvement.
   The variation of the water level is 0 to 47 feet at Columbus.
   The commerce of this stream consists of cotton, cotton seed, ferti-
lizers, grain, naval stores, provisions, hardware, and general merchan-
dise, and is so combined with that of the Flint and Apalachicola
rivers that a separation is impossible. It is given under the report of
the Flint River as 121,717 tons, valued at $12,000,000.
   The effect of the improvement has been to give to Columbus and all
other points on the river water rates, or a material reduction over rates
to all-rail points, but the exact amount of reduction can not be stated.
   For reference to report of examination of this river, see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 341.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......-............................                                $81, 196.50
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 . . ....................................................                             115, 000. 00
                                                                                                     196. 196. 50
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ............................                             $45, 000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement ...........            ..........                   36, 909.05
                                                                                                      81, 909. 05

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                                   114, 287.45
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .................................                               13, 634. 62

July 1, 1909, balance available.          ................                .........    .........     100, 652. 83

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...........................      ....   115, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix Q 5.)
   6. Choctawhatchee River, Florida and Alabama.-The Choctaw-
hatchee River is 162 miles long from Newton, Ala., to its mouth, in
Choctawhatchee Bay, an arm of the Gulf of Mexico.
   Originally the river was impassable during low water for about 10
miles below Newton, due to marl reefs and fish-trap dams, and for
the remaining 152 miles to the mouth it was much obstructed by
snags, logs, overhanging trees, and sand and gravel bars.
   The project for the improvement, as amended in 1890, contemplates
the creation of a low-water navigable channel throughout by remov-
ing logs, snags, and overhanging trees, by excavating rock and marl
shoals, and by contraction works and shore protection, at an esti-
mated cost of $112,832.
   The amount expended on this river under the existing project
(i. e., since 1874) up to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1909, was $187,455.97, of which the greater part has been expended
in maintenance. The expenditures prior to 1874 amounted to
$12,876.62
   The project has been completed and the additional work required
is for maintenance.

a Item of $40,000 for dredge may be omitted, thus reducing this estimate to $75,000.
398           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The following results have been accomplished:
   A channel 40 feet wide and 3 feet deep has been blasted through
the marl shoals below Newton to the lower end of these shoals above
Pates Landing. The river has been partially cleared of snags and
other obstructions from Pates Landing to Geneva, but above Pates
Landing to the foot of the shoals it is impassable at lower stages
of water. A fairly navigable channel 31 feet deep at low water
was secured by snagging and works of regulation from Geneva to
Caryville, but is again much obstructed. The remainder of the lower
river has repeatedly been cleared of obstructions, but is at present
much obstructed, except the section below the mouth of the Holmes
River, which is in fair condition. A channel 75 feet wide and 6 feet
deep at mean low water was dredged through the bar at the mouth
of the river (Cypress Top).
   The actual head of navigation at low water on June 30, 1909, was
the mouth of the Holmes River, 33 miles above the mouth of the
river. The minimum draft that could be carried to this point was
about 3 feet, but the draft is at least 1 foot greater, except at Sandy
reach, where trouble has recently developed.
   The effect of the improvement on freight rates, if any, can not be
stated.
   The additional appropriation recommended will be applied to
removal- of obstructions for maintenance of improvement below
Geneva.
   There is no commerce on the river above Geneva, with the possible
exception of a small movement of logs. Below Geneva there is a
large commerce in logs and hewn timber, and five steamers ply
between Pensacola and Vernon on the Holmes River.
   The commerce on this stream is mainly saw logs, timber, naval
stores, and general merchandise, reported at a valuation of $2,211,651
for the calendar year 1908.
   For reference to reports on examination of this river, see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 343.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................... $5, 869. 43
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ........     ......................................     5, 000. 00

                                                                                    10, 869. 43
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement .........................................................                5, 025. 40

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......       .......-       ...............-....... 5, 844. 03
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.. .....      ............................         522. 33

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................           .    5, 321. 70

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909....      -......... .....- .......- ........ ...........      5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix Q 6.)
  7. Holmes River, Florida, ,from Vernon to its mouth.-Holmes
River empties into the Choctawhatchee River about 40 miles above
the mouth of the latter. It is a wide and deep stream to the town of
Vernon, 25 miles above its mouth, but was originally obstructed by
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                     399
sunken logs, fallen timber, and overhanging trees, and was only
available for navigation by small sailing craft and barges, which
occasionally made trips up to Vernon.
  The present project for the improvement of the stream provides
for making a navigable channel by removing logs and snags from
the river and overhanging trees from its banks from the mouth up
to the town of Vernon.
  The total amount expended on this improvement up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 13, 1909, was $16,085.38, of which
$13,160.95 was upon Holmes River and $2,160.80 upon Lagrange
Bayou.
  The project has been completed and additional work required is for
maintenance.
  The operations during the year consisted in snagging for mainte-
nance of the channel to Vernon, the head of navigation.
  The importance of this improvement has greatly increased in the
last few years, and five steamers are now engaged in the large and
growing trade between Vernon and Pensacola.
   The commerce of the stream consists of cotton, turpentine, rosin,
molasses, honey, and miscellaneous articles, the value of which in
1908 was $640,000.
   For reference to report of examination of this stream, see Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1882, page 1308.
   As this river is the only means of transportation in that section,
there is no basis for comparison and the effect of the improvement on
freight rates can not be stated.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................         $678. 25
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ............................................................ 2, 000. 00
                                                                                          2, 678. 25
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement...... ....................................................                      763. 63

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                   1, 914. 62
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................                     438.24

July 1, 1909, balance available.......................................                   1, 476. 38

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909............                                                            2, 000. 00
                                                         .....-------------------------------------------------.
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix Q 7.)
  8. Blackcwater River, Florida.-The original project for this im-
provement was adopted March 3, 1899, and provided for securing a
channel 9 feet deep from Milton, Fla., to Pensacola, Fla., at an esti-
mated cost of $20,000. Under this project $5,000 was expended,
and a channel of the required depth secured in the river proper.
  The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, fixed the width of the
channel at 100 feet and the estimated cost of completion at $15,000.
  With funds appropriated by this act an 8-inch suction dredge and
other plant necessary for doing the work were repaired and dredging
was commenced in East Bay near the beacon, about 2 miles below
Robinsons Point, and a channel about 80 feet wide and not loss than
400          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

9 feet deep was dredged for a distance of 4,470 feet toward Robin-
sons Point. This cut has improved the worst part of the channel and
increased the available depth over the improvement about 1 foot,
and it is estimated that the approved project is about 40 per cent
completed. In the execution of this work it has been found that the
area to be dredged over is much larger than indicated by the avail-
able charts of the improvement, possibly due in part to fill which has
taken place since the surveys for the charts were made. To secure a
channel 9 feet deep and 100 feet wide over the remaining shoals
within the wide limits covered by the improvement is estimated to
require $20,000 in addition to funds available. It is to be noted that
in the report upon which the present project is based the doubtful
character of the original estimate was recognized and the possibility
of a considerable increase was clearly foreseen.
   The total amount expended on this improvement up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $19,733.32, of which
about $5,000 was for maintenance. The expenditure during the
year was in payment of outstanding liabilities of the preceding year
and incidental expenses.
   The maximum draft that could be carried over the improvement at
mean low water on June 30, 1909, was 8 feet. The usual variation
of water surface is 2 feet. The head of navigation is at Milton,
about 4 miles above the mouth of the river proper.
   The effect of the improvement on freight rates, if any, can not be
stated.
   It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation recommended
to completion of the project and its maintenance thereafter.
   The commerce of this stream consists of timber, lumber, naval
stores, and general merchandise, having an estimated value of $2,076,-
000 per annum. The dry dock at Bagdad and marine railway at
Milton both do a large business, which would be materially increased
by the completion of the project. Lumber brought by rail is stored
in the bayou near Milton and taken to Pensacola via this river.
   For reference to report of examination of this improvement, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 345.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............ ............................. ..     $270.03
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.....................................................                   3.35
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........................................         266. 68
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. .....................................        31. 82
July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................            234. 86
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........        20, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 .        ..........      :............. 25, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix Q 8.)
  9. Harborat Pensacola, Fla.-The available depth across the inner
bar at the entrance to this harbor in 1879, previous to any work of
improvement, was 19.5 feet, the width of the channel being contracted
by the encroachment of the Middle Ground shoal to the southward.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     401
The harbor entrance and channel way were also obstructed by wrecks,
and the western shore line in the vicinity of Fort McRee was cutting
away rapidly, almost the whole of the old Fort McRee washing away
before the erosion was stopped.
   The project of 1877 considered only the removal of the wrecks;
that of 1878 called for the removal of these wrecks and for making
a survey to determine further recommendations for improvement.
The project of 1881 provided for dredging a channel 300 feet wide
and 24 feet deep at mean low water for the temporary relief of navi-
gation, and also for protecting the shore line near Fort McRee, with
a view to preventing further injurious changes. Dredging under this
project was carried on at various times between 1881 and 1893, and
at the close of the dredging operations in August, 1893, the available
channel was 225 feet wide and 24 feet deep at mean low water. Two
groins, one 360 feet and the other 220 feet long, were completed in
1890 and still serve to hold the shore line near Fort McRee.
    In 1891 a special Board of Engineers presented a project for open-
ing a new channel across the Caucus shoal, following the direction of
the ebb current, by means of two jetties, assisted by dredging, if
necessary. In 1895 a second special Board of engineers recommended
that no change be made in the project of 1891, but that dredging be
tried, using one of the hydraulic dredges belonging to the United
States to open up a channel 26 feet deep at mean low water and as
wide as practicable on the line of deepest water across the Caucus
shoal and approximately on the line of the axis of the jettied channel
proposed by the Board of Engineers in 1891. In December, 1895,
this channel was opened by the U. S. dredge Gedney to a width of
120 feet and depth of 24 feet at mean low water. It has a length of
about 10,000 feet across Caucus shoal and is now known as the Caucus
channel.
    In 1896 the same Board that recommended the first amendment to
the project of 1891 submitted a second amendment providing for the
expenditure of all funds available in continuing the work of dredging
across the Caucus shoal and for building a dredge and opening the
channel across the Caucus shoal 30 feet deep at mean low water to a
width of at least 300 feet, with such side slopes as the material would
assume, if sufficient funds were made available by Congress. Until
a channel should be opened by dredging across the Caucus shoal, as
above proposed the Board recommended that the construction of the
jetties for its maintenance be not considered.
    The river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, extended this project
to "securing a channel depth of 30 feet at mean low water, from the
Gulf of Mexico to the dock line at the east end of the city of Pensa-
cola. "
    The amount expended on these projects to June 30, 1905, was
 $725,956.94. The work done comprises the removal of the wrecks
obstructing the channel, dredging a large amount of material from
the inner bar, opening and redredging a 30-foot channel across the
Caucus shoal, and the protection of the shore line from erosion by the
construction of two groins near old Fort McRee.
    The river and harbor act approved June 13, 1902, appropriated
 $220,000, of which $150,000 might be used in constructing a seagoing
suction dredge. This dredge, the Caucus, was built and turned over
to the district in August, 1905. The same act modified the project,
which now provides for dredging a channel 30 feet deep and 500 feet
     9001--ENG 1909-26
402          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                      U.    S. ARMY.


wide from the Gulf of Mexico to the dock line at the east end of the
city of Pensacola. There is no approved estimate of the cost of this
project. Under this amended project there has been expended for
dredge construction $172,221.27 and for the improvement $259,-
995.39, of which about $175,000 has been applied to maintenance.
   The project is about 33 per cent completed.
   The dredge Caucus commenced dredging September 18, 1905, and
at the close of the present fiscal year had removed a total of 2,039,138
cubic yards of material. This work has restored the channel to its
original dimensions and widened it, and removed the shoaling due to
the storm of September, 1906, so that on June 30, 1909, the minimum
width of channel having a depth not less than 30 feet at mean low
water was approximately 300 feet.
   From July 1, 1908, to October 11, 1908, the Caucus continued
dredging. On October 11 she was docked at the Pensacola Navy-
Yard for annual repairs. Owing to lack of funds she was sent to
Carrabelle, Fla., after repairs were completed, returning to Pensacola
June 1, 1909, since which time she has been at work with one pump,
on account of pump shaft being broken.
   The maximum draft that could be carried over the improvement
at mean low water on June 30, 1909, was 30 feet, and the ordinary
range of the tide is about 1.1 feet.
   The commerce of this port is very large. For the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1903, the foreign exports were reported as $13,741,540, no
record of the coastwise exports being available; in 1904, as $15,-
893,456; in 1905, exports as $15,295,067, and imports as $985,840;
in 1906, exports as $18,432,931, and imports as $386,377; in 1907,
exports as $20,229,414, and imports as $618,363; in 1908, exports as
$20,322,649, and imports as $675,503; in 1909, exports as $16,306,056,
and imports as $1,188,925.
   The completion of the project will give greatly increased facilities
to the large commerce of Pensacola, but will not materially affect
freight rates.
   It is proposed to apply the appropriation recommended in dredging
operations toward completion of the project and maintenance of
the project depth.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................               $38, 333. 11
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..................          ........-.........     .. ....:...110,000.00
                                                                                        148, 333. 11
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement............................                 $10, 000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement .........................              25, 971.24
                                                                                         35, 971.24

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ...............................                     . 112, 361. 87
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..... ..................               .......       3, 121. 54

July 1,1909, balance available...................................                       110, 240. 33

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
    balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ..............................                       90, 000. 00
" Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix            Q 9.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     403

    10. Escambia and Conecuh rivers, Florida and Alabama.-These
two names apply to one and the same stream, which flows through a
heavily timbered country in southern Alabama and western Florida
into Escambia Bay, an arm of Pensacola Bay. The change of name
occurs at the boundary line between the two States. The timber from
this district is brought down the river and forms a large part of all
that is exported from Pensacola. Originally the river was much
obstructed by snags, marl reefs, and sand bars, and a bar at its mouth,
where the rafts are made ready to be towed to Pensacola, prevented
the entrance of tugs and seriously interfered with navigation.
    The first appriopriation for the improvement of this river was
made in 1833, and prior to the adoption of the present project $5,000
was expended in removing obstructions. A subsequent appropriation
of $5,500, made in 1836, was returned to the surplus fund in 1838.
No further appropriations were made until 1880.
    (a) General improvement.-The present project, as originally
adopted June 14, 1880, provided for the improvement of the river
from its mouth to Indian Creek, Alabama, an estimated distance of
293 miles, by the removal of snags, logs, and overhanging trees, by
excavating rock shoals, by works of contraction and shore protection,
and by dredging a channel 150 feet wide and 51 feet deep at mean low
water through the bar at the mouth, all at an estimated cost of
 $87,430, but the recent adoption of a separate project for the Conecuh
River has, in effect, fixed the upper limit of the improvement as the
mouth of Patsaliga Creek. The project has been completed and ad di-
tional work required is for maintenance.
    The amount expended on this project to June 30, 1909, was
$153,101.94, largely for maintenance. These expenditures have kept
the river fairly free from snags, opened the channel across the bar at
the mouth from time to time, and greatly facilitated the rafting and
towing of timber; but, due to lack of funds in recent years, the river,
which in 1900 was practically free from obstructions from its mouth
to near the mouth of Patsaliga Creek, again became so much ob-
structed as to seriously interfere with the rafting at low-water stages.
During the year the stream was cleared of obstructions for a distance
of 162 miles.
    It is proposed to apply the appropriation recommended in snag-
ging and dredging toward maintenance of the improvement.
    Reference to reports of examination of this improvement will be
found on pages 348 and 349 of the Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1906.
    (b) Conecuh River.-By act of Congress, approved March 2, 1907,
a project was adopted for completing the improvement of the Cone-
cub River from the mouth of Patsaliga Creek to the State line be-
tween Florida and Alabama by removal of bowlders, snags, and rock
shoals, in accordance with report submitted in House Document No.
159, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session, at an estimated cost of
 $31,000.
    For work under this project a plant consisting of a quarter boat
and two working barges has been constructed. The field work com-
menced July 22, 1907. During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909,
92 miles of river was worked over, 34 miles being new work. Funds
now available will be sufficient to complete the project for this
404          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

section of river. Subsequent maintenance can be more conveniently
and logically provided for under the general project.
   The actual head of navigation during ordinary stages of the river
is at the mouth of Patsaliga Creek, about 195 miles above the mouth
of the Escambia River.
   Commerce consists of timber floated in rafts, the value of which
in 1908 is estimated at $3,863,000.
   Work now completed influences the transportation of timber on
170 miles of river, which has been greatly facilitated, admitting of
rafting on stages of water some 3 feet less than formerly. The
freight per thousand by rail from River Falls, a point 3 miles below
Patsaliga Creek, to water is $1.50; by river, it is 75 cents.
                                        GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................                      $7, 913. 86
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.................................                    ........ ...........  5, 000. 00

                                                                                            12, 913. 86
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement...................................    ..............                            6, 656. 37

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................................                       6, 257.49
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities......................................                   1, 735. 17

July 1, 1909, balance available. ......................................                       4, 522. 32

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.......                            .     ........... . L 5,000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                              CONECUH RIVER.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..... .............................                         $21, 518.33
Received from refundment of overpayment.........................                                    .10
                                                                         21, 518. 43
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment............................................      ............ ....10, 877.76

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-.....................................                      10, 640. 67
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...........................................                863.89

July 1, 1909, balance available..              ................           ...............     9, 776.78
    (See Appendix Q 10.)
   11. Alabama River, Alabama.-This river is formed by the junc-
tion of the Coosa and the Tallapoosa, 11 miles below Wetumpka, on
the Coosa River, and from this junction to its junction with the Tom-
bigbee to form the Mobile it constitutes a 312-mile link in a water-
way 815 miles long, from the Oostenaula and Coosawattee rivers,
Georgia, to the Gulf of Mexico.
   The river was originally so obstructed by logs, snags, and over-
hanging trees, and shoals, many with depths of but 2.5 feet, that
during the low-water season navigation was practicable by day only.
Long detentions were frequent at many of the shoals below Selma,
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    405
and when the water was unusually low traffic was suspended between
Selma and Montgomery for three or four months in the year.
   The original project, adopted in 1878, for the improvement of
this stream provided for securing a low-water channel 4 feet deep and
200 feet wide by removing snags, logs, and overhanging trees; by
constructing works of regulation, and by dredging, all at an estimated
cost of $229,741. On this project $185,000 was expended, principally
in snagging operations and the construction of works of contraction.
These expenditures greatly improved the condition of the channel,
freeing it from obstructions, and secured a low-water depth of 4
to 5 feet.
   In 1891 the original project was amended to provide for a low-
water channel 6 feet deep, which was to be secured in the same gen-
eral way as contemplated in the original project, and the estimated
cost was placed at $386,251, provided that at least $100,000 should be
appropriated annually and $10,000 a year thereafter for maintenance.
The project is about 30 per cent completed.
   Under this project there has been expended to June 30, 1909,
$488,009.09, largely for maintenance, but until recently appropria-
tions have been very small and the channel has been deteriorating,
work on the river being confined to the operations of the snag boat.
During the last three years the plant has been thoroughly overhauled
and materially increased.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, contemplated securing
a continuous channel not less than 4 feet deep in the Alabama River
by open-channel work, and as the benefits to be derived from the
improvement are very great, funds should be provided for the vigor-
ous prosecution of work.
   Operations during the year consisted in snagging, dredging, and
construction of contraction works at various points.
   During the year the maximum draft that could be carried to Mont-
gomery at low water was about 3 feet, but as the boats operating on
this river draw from 4 to 6 feet, the boats came only to Selma till
high water.
   It is proposed to apply the appropriation recommended in snag-
gmg, dredging, and construction of contraction works in furtherance
of the project and in maintenance of the improvement.
   The actual head of navigation at ordinary low water is Wetumpka,
on the Coosa River, and the variation of the water level is from 0 to
59 feet at Montgomery.
   The commerce of this stream is important, consisting principally
of cotton, cotton seed, fertilizers, grain, lumber, shingles, naval
stores, staves, and a large quantity of miscellaneous freight of all
descriptions, the value of which for the year 1908 is estimated at
$9,000,000. This, however, is but a part of the freight movement
that is affected by the improvement, for the actual shipments by
water have been relatively small, and, with a river improved for con-
tinuous navigation, it is estimated that at least 100,000 tons of the
present all-rail freight movement would either go by river or at river
rates, and the resulting saving would be very large. In addition,
improved facilities would render possible an actual reduction in rates
on freight now carried by river.
   For reference to reports of examinations made of this river, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, pages 349 and 350.
406            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                     U.    S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                                      $170, 389. 22
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909-----------..--....---------............--------.........---------..........-------.........  110,000.00
                                                                                                          280, 389. 22
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement............................ $60, 000.00
    For maintenance of improvement ..................--
                                                     -- .. 64, 348. 31
                                                                                                          124, 348. 31
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-- ---..................................--
                                                          --.                                             156,040.91
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities......----     ..
                                                ---......--..   ..
                                                              -----.... ......                             14,975.00
July 1, 1909, balance available.......                               ...
                                                            -..-.......           ..............          141, 065. 91
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909........-.....................                                        90, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix Q 11.)
   12. Coosa River, Georgia and Alabama.-The Coosa is formed at
Rome, Ga., by the junction of the Oostenaula and Etowah rivers,
which have their sources in northern Georgia. The Oostenaula is
formed by the junction of the Coosawattee and Connesauga rivers, 56
miles northwest of Rome. The Oostenaula above Rome, Ga., and its
tributary, the Coosawattee, are navigable for light-draft boats during
nine months of the year for a distance of about 105 miles, but the
Etowah and the Connesauga are not navigable.
   The Coosa River has always been navigable for light-draft boats
from Rome, Ga., to Greenport, Ala., an estimated distance of 162
miles, and this part of the river is of such a character as to make
its improvement by works of contraction and channel excavation
entirely practicable, except at Horseleg shoals, near Rome, Ga., where
a lock of low lift will be ultimately required.
   From Greenport, Ala., to Wetumpka, Ala., a distance of 142 miles,
locks and dams are required in conjunction with works of contraction
and channel excavation to provide for navigation.
    From Wetumpka to the junction of the Tallapoosa River the river
is navigable at all seasons.
    The ordinary variations of the water surface are, at Rome, Ga.,
0 to 30 feet; at Greenport, Ala., 0 to 15 feet; at Wetumpka, Ala., 0 to
50 feet.
    The improvement of these rivers is provided for under the two
following projects (for reference to report upon proposed modifica-
tions of projects for improving the Coosa River, see Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, p. 326):
    (a) Coosa River between Rome, Ga., and East Tennessee, Virginia
and Georgia Railroad bridge.-The original project for the improve-
ment of the Coosa River contemplated the opening of a continuous
water route of transportation from the Mississippi River to the
Altantic Ocean by way of the Ohio, Tennessee, Coosa, Etowah,
Ocmulgee, and Altamaha rivers, with canals from the Tennessee to
the Coosa and from the Etowah to the Ocmulgee. This was desig-
nated as the "southern route."
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    407
   Various examinations and estimates for the improvement of parts
of this section of river have been made from time to time up to the
adoption of the existing project, September 19, 1890. This project,
as modified by act of Congress of July 13, 1892, formed a part of a
plan submitted in 1875 for a proposed waterway from the Mississippi
to the Atlantic via the Tennessee River, and provides for a crib and
timber lock 200 by 32 feet and a 3-foot lift, with excavation for a
4-foot channel between Rome, Ga., and Wills Creek in Alabama, at a
total estimated cost of $180,000; for three locks between Greenport
and Dam 4 (Whisenant and Ten Island shoals), 210 feet long, 40 feet
wide, and an extreme low-water depth of 4 feet on miter sills,
together with a 3-foot channel between Locks 1 and 3, at a total esti-
mated cost, including accessory dams and dikes, of $155,616.23; for
five locks and dams from and including Dam 4 to the East Ten-
nessee, Virginia and Georgia Railroad bridge, the locks to have an
available length of 280 feet, width of 52 feet, and an extreme low-
water depth of 6 feet over the miter sills, together with a connecting
channel 100 feet wide and 4 feet deep at extreme low water, at a
total estimated cost of $1,160,491, or at a total cost for the entire
improvement of $1,496,107.23. About 21 per cent of the project has
been completed.
   To June 30, 1909, there has been expended on this section of the
Coosa $1,101,016.88, of which $577,316.88 has been expended upon
the existing project and $523,700 prior to its adoption. The work
accomplished is as follows, of which expenditures about 10 per cent
has been for maintenance:
   Locks 1, 2, and 3, Coosa River, commenced prior to 1890, have
been completed. They are situated, respectively, 0.68 mile, 3.86 miles,
and 5.24 miles below Greenport, Ala., and have available lengths of
175 feet and widths of 40 feet.
   Lock and Dam 4 (25.89 miles below Greenport), commenced since
the adoption of larger dimensions above mentioned, has, together
with its appurtenances, been under construction, with desultory
appropriations, since 1886, but still incomplete.
   Channel improvement has been extended as far down as Dam 4, and
navigation is now possible to this point, except at extreme low water,
when interruptions occur a short distance above Dam 4.
    During the past fiscal year work was confined to the improvement
and maintenance of the channel between Rome, Ga., and Dam 4,
Alabama, and to care of the large amount of plant on hand. Provi-
sion should be made for further improvement and maintenance of
this channel.
    On June 30, 1909, the maximum. draft that could be carried at
ordinary low water between Rome, Ga, and Dam 4 was 3 feet, except,
at Horseleg shoal, 11 miles below Rome, over which but 2 feet can be
carried until a lock is constructed at this point. Survey and esti-
mate for this lock have been submitted.
    It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation recommended
toward further improvement and maintenance of the channel between
Rome, Ga., and Dam 4, Alabama.
    The improvement has resulted in a reduction in railroad rates
between points on the river and either Rome or Gadson of not less
than 50 per cent, water rates controlling all shipments to and from
the country contiguous to the river.
408          REPORT        OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                             S. ARMY.

  The commerce of this portion of the Coosa consists principally in
cotton, cotton seed, fertilizers, timber, lumber, staves, grain, and
miscellaneous articles, amounting, for the year 1908, to 24,189 tons,
valued at $2,500,000. Lumber and logs valued at $73,000 were also
reported as moved.
   (b) Coosa River between Wetumpka and East Tennessee, Virginia
and Georgia Railroad bridge.-On account of the numerous rapids
this part of the river has never been navigable.
   The original project for the improvement of this section of the
river adopted September 19, 1890, as the result of a survey made in
1889 and modified by Congress July 13, 1892, contemplates slack-
water navigation and provides for the construction of 23 locks and
dams of varying lifts, of an available length of 280 feet and width
of 52 feet, with 6 feet over the miter sills, no lift of lock to exceed 15
feet. In addition, the channel is to be cleared of various rock reefs and
points so as to give a least depth of 4 feet, all at an estimated cost
of $5,106,422. About 4 per cent of the project has been completed.
   There has been expended on this project to June 30, 1909,
$401,372.22, of which about 2' per cent has been for maintenance,
which has resulted in the construction of the lowest lock of the series,
known as "No. 31," excepting the dam and grates, the excavation of
the channel between this lock and the one next above, and the prepa-
ration of data and plans for additional locks and dams, but these
data are still incomplete. As yet no benefit has been derived from
this improvement, and its value is entirely dependent on the com-
pletion of the entire system.
   Provision should be made for the care of the property belonging to
the improvement.
                                             CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended -..-.-..-.......                    ..... ......--......       $30, 530. 68
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909--------......--......-----------...------------------------................      40, 000. 00

                                                                                                 70, 530. 68
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...........................                          $21, 906.79
    For maintenance of improvement....................                             5, 000. 00
                                                                                                 26, 906. 79

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                               43, 623. 89
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..-.............-...-...-...........                         3, 204.91

July 1, 1909, balance available         ........... ..........................                   40, 418. 98

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........ 6, 059, 913.00
SAmount  that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
                                                --
   the balance unexpended July 1, 1.909......--..........     ...........                        60, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix Q 12.)
   13. Operating and care of canals and other works of navigation on
Coosa River, Georgia and Alabama.-Locks 1, 2, and 3 were open to
navigation on June 30, 1890, and have been operated continuously
since, except during such periods as it was necessary to close them
for repairs and for a period of ten days in February, 1895, when the
canal between Locks 2 and 3 was frozen over.
                RIVER   AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                  409

   The amount expended to the end of the fiscal year ending June 30,
1909, was $185,015.43.
   The expenses of operating and care of Locks 1, 2, and 3, and Dam
4 during the fiscal year have been paid from the permanent indefinite
appropriation provided for by section 4 of the act of July 5, 1884,
as amended and reenacted by section 6 of the river and harbor act
approved March 3, 1909.
These expenses amounted to $5,218.84, exclusive of liabilities out-
standing on June 30, 1909, of $167.09.
   (See Appendix Q 13.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
            HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports on preliminary examinations and surveys required by
the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities
within this district were duly submitted by the district officer.
They were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Har-
bors, pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed
in documents as indicated:
   1. Preliminary examination and survey of Alabama and Coosa
rivers, Alabama, between Montgomery and Wetumpka.-Reports dated
November 15, 1907, and October 8, 1908, respectively, are printed
in House Document No. 1089, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A
plan for improvement at an estimated cost of $36,000 is presented.
   2. Preliminary examination and survey of Goosa River at Horseleg
shoals, near Rome, Ga., with a view to the construction of a lock and
dam.--Reports dated September 4, 1907, and October 8, 1908, re-
spectively, are printed in House Document No. 1115, Sixtieth Con-
gress, second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost
of $241,039 is presented.
   3. Preliminary examination and survey of Coosa River, Georgia and
Alabama, with a view to locating and constructing Dam No. 5, in the
State of Alabama.-Reports dated September 4, 1907, and October 8,
1908, respectively, are printed in House Document No. 1421, Sixtieth
Congress, second session. A plan of improvement at an estimated
cost of $134,000 is presented.
   4. Preliminary examination and survey of St. Andrews Bay, Flor-
ida.-Reports dated November 15, 1907, October 10, 1908, Novem-
ber 5, 1908, and March 1, 1909, respectively, are printed in House
Document No. 12, Sixty-first Congress, first session. A plan for
improvement at an estimated cost of $203,560 is presented.

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE MOBILE, ALABAMA,
                        DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Maj. Henry Jervey, Corps of Engi-
neers, having under his immediate orders First Lieut. W. G. Caples,
Corps of Engineers, to August 5, 1908. Division engineers, Col.
E. H. Ruffner, Corps of Engineers, to August 31, 1908, and Lieut.
Col. Lansing H. Beach, Corps of Engineers, since that date.
  1. Mobile Harbor,Alabama.--This channel originally had minimum
depths of 5 feet through Choctaw Pass and 8 feet through Dog River
410     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,          U.   S. ARMY.

bar, at mean low water, the available draft to Mobile, via Spanish
River, being limited to the latter depth.
  The improvement of the channel of Mobile Harbor has been pro-
gressive. Between 1826, the date of the first appropriation for this
work, and 1857 a channel 10 feet deep was dredged through the shoals
in Mobile Bay up to the city of Mobile. Between 1870 and 1876 this
depth was increased to 13 feet, the channel being dredged to a width
of 300 feet through Choctaw Pass and 200 feet through Dog River
bar.
   In 1880 a project for a channel 17 feet deep and 200 feet wide was
adopted, and appropriations between 1878 and 1886 were applied to
the formation of a channel of these dimensions.
   In the river and harbor act of August 11, 1888, a project for secur-
ing a channel 23 feet deep was adopted this project being modified
by the river and harbor act of September 19, 1890, so as to provide
for the formation of a channel 23 feet deep and with a top width of
280 feet from the Gulf of Mexico to the mouth of Chickasaw Creek,
above the city of Mobile. Work upon this channel was completed in
1896, subsequent appropriations, up to and including that made by the
sundry civil act of July 1, 1898, having been applied to its maintenance.
    The total amount expended on these projects was $3,648,630.60, of
which about $115,000 is estimated to have been applied to maintenance.
    The existing project for the improvement of Mobile Harbor pro-
vides for the formation of a channel 23 feet deep and 100 feet wide
at bottom, with appropriate slopes, from the entrance of the bay to
the mouth of Chickasaw Creek, at an estimated cost of $1,640,000,
and the removal of sunken obstructions from Mobile Harbor at such
times as the latter work may be authorized. This project was adopted
by the river and harbor act approved March 3, 1899, and was modified
by the acts of June 13, 1902, and March 3, 1905.
    The work of forming a 23-foot channel in Mobile River and Bay
under this project was commenced in 1899, and under two continuing
contracts, during the progress of which 12,402,956 cubic yards of
material, scow measurement, was removed up to November 11, 1903,
an uninterrupted channel of the projected depth and from 55 to 150
feet width was formed within the limits of the project.
    After the storm of September 27, 1906, the channel shoaled in
places to as little as 17 feet. Under a contract the worst of the shoal-
ing was remedied at a cost of approximately $100,000, 1,109,410
cubic yards of material being removed.
    The work of removing sunken trees, logs, timbers, and other dan-
gerous obstructions from the channel of Mobile Harbor has been
prosecuted when necessary with funds allotted for that purpose.
    The existing project was modified by the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, so as to include the completion of the work proposed
by the existing project at an estimated cost of $560,000, and the prose-
cution of operations to provide increased depth progressively as may
be possible with appropriations of $100,000 annually for a period of
five years.
    The construction of a dredge was authorized. All of the $560,000
has been appropriated. Of this amount $10,000 was applied to
the removal of sunken obstructions from Mobile Harbor, $545,000
was allotted to work of dredging and nearly all so applied, and
 $5,000 to the preparation of plans for a dredge. It was proposed
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              411
to apply $200,000 of this money to the construction of a dredge,
but the administrative act approved May 28, 1908, contained the
following provision:
  SEC. 7. That the whole or any part of the amount heretofore authorized to be
appropriated for the construction of a dredge for Mobile Harbor, Alabama, with
the exception of five thousand dollars for the preparation of plans for said dredge,
may be used for dredging said harbor, and the Secretary of War, in his discretion,
may enter into a contract or contracts for the performance of the work.
   The funds are therefore being applied to dredging, except the
$5,000 for dredge plans.
   The modification of project is printed in House Document No. 647,
Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
   To June 30, 1909, there was expended on the existing project as
modified $1,777,528.49, of which $551,166.03 was applied to work
of maintenance.
   The work of dredging under contract dated July 10, 1907, approach-
ing completion at the end of the last fiscal year, was completed in
July, 1908, leaving depths of from 23 to 25 feet throughout the chan-
nel, except where shoaling had occurred in the lower end.
   Plans for a dredge were completed.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year there was a small amount of
dredging to be done to complete the contract then in force, and the
work was finished by the removal of 23,533.4 cubic yards of material
over a distance of 3,100 feet between Chickasaw Creek and Bea-
con 22, in July, 1908.
   Under date of February 1, 1909, another contract was made
for dredging in Mobile Harbor in the application of the funds men-
tioned in the administrative act above quoted from, which funds
were appropriated by the act of March 4, 1909, and up to June 30,
1909, 74,321 feet of channel was worked over under this contract,
removing about 2,145,000 cubic yards of material, the width of cut
being from about 85 to about 125 feet, the purpose of the work being
to widen the channel sufficiently to afford 23 feet depth for a width
of 100 feet at bottom, and to form appropriate side slopes. The
location of this work was from Beacon 10-A to Beacon 8, from
Beacon 6-A to 1,635 feet south, and from 150 feet south of Bea-
con 6 to Beacon 2. There is about 8,000 feet of channel yet to
be dredged.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year there was a small balance
available for removing obstructions from the harbor, and with this
a little work was done in July, 1908. Work was resumed in April
of this year, with an allotment of $10,000 from the river and harbor
act of March 3, 1909. The total work during the fiscal year con-
sisted in removing 355 logs, snags, and stumps from that part of
the channel needing this work most. Operations are still in progress.
   From the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, there was allotted
 $100,000 for dredging work in Mobile Harbor.
   The funds available will be applied to work of dredging in Mobile
Harbor and to the removal of sunken obstructions in maintenance
of the improvement. With future appropriations work will be
continued under the approved project.
   On June 30, 1909, the maximum low-water draft that could be
carried over the shoalest part of the dredged channel was between
23 and 24 feet at mean low water. The average range of tide is
1 feet.
412            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Mobile River is navigable for vessels of about 14 feet draft up as
far as its head, 45 miles above Mobile.
   Detailed information with reference to the work accomplished
under the existing project is contained in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1901, page 1810, and 1904, page 1803.                                                             A
reference to the report of the survey upon which the project is based
is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904,
page 324.
   The combined commerce, foreign and domestic, using Mobile Har-
bor during 1908 aggregated 1,838,101 tons, valued at $58,507,433.
Cotton, lumber, timber, breadstuffs, and hog products are the princi-
pal articles of export, and bananas and sisal grass the most important
of imports.
   The effect of the project has been to give Mobile an average reduc-
tion of about 20 per cent on rail freight rates from Atlantic sea-
port cities and to afford direct water freight rates from Mobile to
foreign ports.
                                            GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................                                          $160, 238. 54
June 30, 1909, receipts from sales ....................................                                             408. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......                                           200, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909---------......-----..-----............--------........-------.........---------.....----.....  100, 000. 00
                                                                                                                460, 646. 54
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .....    .                                 $100, 00. 00
                                                     ------..............----...
                                     ............------.......
    For maintenance of improvement--------                                175, 424. 50
                                                                                                           a 275, 424. 50

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................---- --------................                                185, 222. 04
                                                -----....................
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities --..............--                                                         74, 545. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available ......-............                    ------        ...        ----
                                                                                               .....------. 110, 677. 04

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..............                                              4, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                                            77, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909. ......................                                                          (b)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                           REMOVING         OBSTRUCTIONS.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended                 .--........                                                  $1, 413. 59
                                                                  ......................-------------------------------
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..--------------.........------------------................----------------................     10, 000. 00
                                                                                                                 11, 413. 59
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.................---------------------------...........----------.....-----...--........-.......     2, 655. 25

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended............-.........................                  8, 758. 34
                                                                             ---.......
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities -- .......----......-- ..----....-.....--            455. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available-.-                       .. .                         . 8, 303. 34
                                                     . ---------------------------------


  a Not including $55.56 spent for the Isthmian Canal Commission and subsequently re-
turned tothe appropriation; also not including $17.35, refundment of an overpayment.
  b See consolidated money statement on page 413.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     413
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909..............................................                                        (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                               CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .-- ......
                                       -----                    ----... -- ---------......         .. $161, 652. 13
June 30, 1909, receipts from sales....................................
                                            ------------------------                                        408. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 200, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
                                                                                     --------- 110, 000. 00
March 3, 1909...-------------.......-------.....-----...........--------------...................
                                                                                                       472, 060. 13
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement. .. . ...   ..................                      $100, 000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement ....................                            178, 079. 75
                                                                                                       278, 079. 75

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                   193, 980. 38
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..................................                                 75, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available....              ..   ............          ...... .....     ...       118, 980. 38

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts...    .......                                      4, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                                   77, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909. ..............            .   .......                               210, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix R 1.)
   2. Mobile bar, Alabama.-Mobile bar is located in the Gulf of
Mexico off the entrance to Mobile Bay. This bar had a depth of 23
feet at low water over ample width before any work of improvement
was commenced upon it. This depth accommodated all the traffic
of the Mobile Bay ship channel, but was not sufficient to permit of
the utilization of the deep anchorage in lower Mobile Bay beyond
the southern limit of the dredged cut leading to the city of Mobile.
   The original and existing project for this improvement was adopted
in the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, and provides for the for-
mation of a channel 30 feet deep at low water and 300 feet wide
across Mobile bar, at an estimated cost of $91,250. This work of
improvement formed a part of the Mobile Harbor project until
March 3, 1905, when, by the river and harbor act of that date, it was
made a separate project, and the limit of cost was increased to
$100,000.
   Up to June 30, 1909, the sum of $156,443.49 had been expended on
this improvement, of which about $66,443.49 was applied to main-
tenance.
   During the fiscal year the U. S. dredge Charleston was engaged
about all of her working time removing shoals and increasing the
depth and width of this channel. The depth now ranges from 30 to
35 feet at mean low water, except on two shoals near the eastern
side of the channel, where the least depth runs as low as 22 feet.
The project is about 90 per cent completed.
                       a See consolidated money statement on this page.
414          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The maximum draft that can be carried through the channel at
mean low water is about 30 feet, and the average range of tide is 1.1
feet.
   Available funds and future appropriations will be applied to com-
pleting the project and its maintenance and to keeping the dredge
Charleston in repair.
   For commercial statistics and effect of improvement on freight
rates, see report on Mobile Harbor.
   A reference to the report of the survey on which the existing project
is based can be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1904, page 324.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................                           $25, 081. 63
June 30, 1909, receipts from sales..................................                                     4. 55
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909-...-....-----...........---------------------...............----.................  23, 000. 00
                                                                                                   48, 086. 18
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..............................                           $7, 000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement.................. .....                           24, 525. 12
                                                                                                   31, 525. 12

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................                   ...................         16, 561.06
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ........-.........
                                                      --                 ...............            8, 500. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available.......................                     ..............           8, 061.06
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909....-.............................     18, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix R 2.)
   3. Black Warrior, Warrior, and Tombigbee rivers, Alabama--(a)
Black Warrior River.-This name refers to that portion of the War-
rior River above Tuscaloosa. Originally this part of the river was
practically closed to navigation on account of shoals at and above
Tuscaloosa.
    The original project for the improvement was adopted in 1887,
the object being to obtain a channel for barges of 6 feet draft at low
water all the year round between Tuscaloosa and Daniels Creek, 141
miles above, by means of five locks and dams, at an estimated cost
of $741,670.
    Locks 10, 11, and 12 were built by hired labor and have been com-
pleted and opened for traffic since November, 1895.
   Lock No. 13 was completed in May, 1905. The river and harbor act
of March 3, 1899, provided for the construction of this lock, and
extended the upper limit of the improvement to the junction of the
Mulberry and Locust forks of the river, 461 miles above Tuscaloosa.
    The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, authorized the con-
struction of Locks 14, 15, 16, and 17, leaving Locks 18, 19, and 20
to be provided for. It was subsequently decided to build two 21-foot
lift locks (Nos. 16 and 17) instead of three 14-foot lift locks, on
Squaw shoals, thus reducing the number of locks in the slack-water
system necessary to carry the improvement up to the Mulberry and
Locust forks from 20 to 19.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      415

   The completion of four locks on this river has resu'lted in affording
6-foot navigation to the site of Lock 14, from Tuscaloosa, 12 miles.
Locks 14 and 15 are being built under contract dated December 23,
1907. These two locks and dams are about 55 per cent completed,
and lock-tenders' houses have been built at both locks.
   Under date of November 28, 1908, a contract was made for the
construction of Lock and Dam No. 16 and lock-tender's house.
Camp houses have been erected, and a railroad is being built to the
site of the lock, but actual work on the lock has not yet been com-
menced.
   Gates for Locks 14 and 15 were built during past fiscal year, and
are stored at Tuscaloosa shops; valves and special irons completed
and delivered at sites; contract work continued through the year,
about 50 per cent of the work being accomplished since July 1, 1908;
sites for Locks 16 and 17 purchased; plans and specifications pre-
pared for Lock 17, also plans for Locks 18 and 19.
   The total amount expended on the Black Warrior River to June 30,
1909, including cost of surveys, etc., was $1,226,383.53, none of
which was applied to maintenance.
    Recent appropriations have been made for locks and dams on the
Black Warrior, Warrior, and Tombigbee rivers as one slack-water
system, and for statement of total figures for project see report (c)
Tombigbee River.
    The improvement of the Black Warrior River between Tuscaloosa
and Daniels Creek is based upon the report of a board of engineers,
dated April 2, 1887, and published in the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1887, page 1302.
    For commercial statistics, see report on operating and care of locks
and dams, page 423 of this report.
    (b) Warrior River.-This name refers to that portion of the War-
rior River below Tuscaloosa. Originally logs, snags, and overhanging
trees rendered navigation impossible at low water and dangerous at
boating stages. The minimum depth of channel was about 1 foot and
the minimum width about 60 feet.
    The original project for the improvement, adopted by the river
and harbor act approved March 3, 1875, contemplated deepening the
channel by jetty construction and the removal of snags and overhang-
ing trees. The amount expended on this project from 1880 until the
adoption of the present project was $319,388.30. Prior to 1880 appro-
priations aggregating $88,000 were expended on the Warrior and
Tombigbee rivers jointly, and an account of this work may be found
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 1679.
    The present project, adopted by the river and harbor act of March
3, 1899, for the construction of six locks and dams (Nos. 4-9, inclu-
sive, of the Black Warrior, Warrior, and Tombigbee system), with a
total lift of 60 feet, and to afford a channel for barges of 6 feet draft
at mean low water all the year round between Demopolis and Tusca-
loosa, has been completed. The last three locks built (Nos. 4, 5, and
6) were commenced under contract in May, 1903, but after abandon-
ment of work by the contractors on December 31, 1904, they were
completed with hired labor and were opened for traffic during the
past fiscal year.
416      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,          U. S. ARMY.

   The total amount expended on improvement of Warrior River
under the existing project to June 30, 1909, was $2,086,445.12, of
which $13,691.24 was applied to maintenance.
   For commercial statistics, see report on operating and care of locks
and dams.
   The report of the survey upon which the present project is based
is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1890.
   (c) Tombigbee River from the mouth to Demopolis (construction of
locks and dams).-The original condition of the navigable channel
of this section of the river was such as to permit of steamboat navi-
gation during high stages of water only, lasting about six or eight
months of the year. The minimum width of the channel was about
100 feet and the minimum depth about 2 feet.
   For project, amount expended, etc., see report on maintenance of
channel, Tombigbee River from the mouth to Demopolis.
   The amount expended on work of lock and dam construction under
the existing project to June 30, 1909, was $722,033.76; for construc-
tion of dredge, $40,030; and for construction of lock houses, $10,315.16.
   The river and harbor act approved March 3, 1905, made an appro-
priation of $100,000, and provided for the further appropriation of
$781,466, to be applied to the completion of Locks and Dams Nos. 1,
2, and 3, Warrior and Tombigbee rivers, Alabama, and of Lock No.
1, Tombigbee River, and the construction of Lock No. 2, Tombigbee
River. It was also provided that of these sums $40,000 might be
expended for the construction of a dredge and $30,000 for the con-
struction of lock houses necessary for the operation of locks and dams
in the Black Warrior, Warrior, and Tombigbee rivers.
   The full amount authorized by this river and harbor act was subse-
quently appropriated. Provision was made in the river and harbor
act of March 2, 1907, for the construction of Lock and Dam No. 3.
   During the past fiscal year Lock and Dam No. 1 were completed
and opened to traffic, with hired labor. At Locks Nos. 2 and 3 work
was continued under contract dated December 4, 1907, consisting
principally of clearing and grubbing, building cofferdams, excavation,
and delivering materials and plant. Valves and special irons were
built at the Tuscaloosa shops and delivered to the contractor at the
lock sites. Steel gates for these locks were also built at the same
shops and are stored there ready for delivery.
   About 16 per cent of the work has been done at Lock No. 2 and
about 8 per cent at Lock No. 3.
   During the year the 12-inch hydraulic dredge Humphreys was com-
pleted and is in operation. Contract was made for an additional lock
house at Lock No. 2, and it is about 90 per cent completed.
   For commerce during the calendar year 1908, see report on Tom-
bigbee River, mouth to Demopolis, and reference is also had to report
on operating and care of locks, which furnishes statistics for the fiscal
year.
   General.-Recent appropriations for slack watering the Black
Warrior, Warrior, and Tombigbee rivers have been made for one
system of locks and dams, so that this is now considered one project,
and work is in progress on the same under continuing contract authori-
zation in river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of which $312,000
remains to be appropriated. The estimated total cost of this work,
exclusive of maintenance, is now $7,393,219.31. The increase in this
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       417

estimated total cost over that contained in the Annual Report for
1908 is due to the fact that the amounts required for the completion
of Locks Nos. 1, 4, 5, and 6, finished during the past fiscal year with
hired labor, proved to be considerably larger than had been estimated,
especially in the case of the first-named lock, where it was necessary
to maintain a heavy force to insure completion of the dam before
high water. The closure of the dam was made November 18, 1908.
Also, experience has shown that the present type of guard cribs is too
light. It is proposed to substitute a crib of wider base at Locks Nos. 1,
2, and 3, Tombigbee River, in place of those originally planned, and
to reduce the intervals between successive cribs guarding the upper
approaches to these locks, in order to facilitate the handling and
entrance of boats.
   The following statement shows the total figures for this project:
Total estimated cost of project, including $13,691.24 applied to main-
  tenance of work..-...--............-..........   ..................              $7, 406, 910. 55
Total amount appropriated, received from sales, etc., to June 30, 1909. 5, 294, 910. 55
    Amount authorized but not yet appropriated-.........                $312, 000 '
    Amount required, but not yet authorized or appro-
       priated....................................                   . 1, 800, 000 -             -
                                                                                      -   2, 112, 000. 00
The following division shows the proposed application of the required $2,112,000:
For completing all locks and dams.................       ..............  $1, 947, 000. 00
For dredging between locks, necessary to obtain 6-foot depth_.........       100, 000.00
For construction of additional lock houses...........................         25, 000. 00
For removing snags and overhanging trees (original work)............          30, 000.00
For building fishways in dams at Locks Nos. 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, and 13.      10, 000. 00
       Total amount required that has not yet been appropriated......                     2, 112, 000. 00

The following shows the disposition of the amount appropriated, re-
  ceived from sales, etc., to June 30, 1909, in all_..................... 5, 294, 910. 55
    Applied to work of lock and dam construction,
       including surveys........-..    ....... .......... _ $4, 021, 171. 17
    Cost of dredge...................................            40, 030. 00
    Cost of lock houses to June 30, 1909...............          10, 315. 16
     Snagging work (maintenance) ..................         ..   13, 691. 24

       Total....................................                .............    ..       4, 085, 207. 57

       Balance unexpended June 30, 1909. ............              ...........            1, 209, 702.98
   It is therefore proposed to apply available funds and future appro-
priations to the completion of locks and dams on the Black Warrior
and Tombigbee rivers, the performance of dredging, removal of
snags and overhanging trees, etc., as indicated in the foregoing state-
ment, the work immediately proposed, however, being the completion
of Locks and Dams Nos. 2 and 3, Tombigbee River, and Nos. 14, 15,
and 16, Black Warrior River, and the commencement of Lock No.
17, Black Warrior River, all under contract.
   The work of lock and dam construction thus far accomplished has
had a marked effect on traffic. Through packet service from Mobile
to Tuscaloosa, which had been abandoned for many years, was
resumed during the past fiscal year, and four towboats, with a num-
ber of barges, have been in use on the upper river during the past win-
ter. Just what effect the all-year-round 6-foot navigation will have
when obtained can not be definitely stated as yet, but it is expected
to cause a great reduction in freight rates between the mining sec-
tion of Alabama and the Gulf of Mexico.
        9001--ENG 1909-----27
418           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                             LOCKS AND DAMS.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................                   $807, 031. 47
June 30, 1909, receipts from sales..............................    ....                     575.42
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909....                   1, 000, 000. 00
                                                                                     1.,807, 606. 89
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement .....................................     .............                   a 617, 588. 75

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended................        ............              . 1, 190, 018.14
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities................................             ..    61, 300. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available..................................                    1,128, 718.14

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..-..........                  1, 398, 408. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                2, 112, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
  30, 1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
    pended July 1, 1909..........                          ....................   . b 1, 100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
                                                LOCK HOUSES.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................                       $19, 684. 84
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                       19, 684. 84
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts.............                        1, 792. 00

                                                CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............    ...................                 $826, 716. 31
June 30, 1909, receipts from sales....... ..... .... .. ..............                       575. 42
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909....                   1, 000, 000. 00
                                                                                     1, 827, 291. 73
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement...... .............................     .............                       617, 588.75
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................          ..............         1, 209, 702. 98
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..........   ...........      ............          61, 300. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available ........................................              1, 148, 402. 98

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .............                  1, 400, 200. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project . .....               2, 112, 000. 00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.........................................         cl, 100, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897.
   (d) Tombigbee River from the mouth to Demopolis (maintenance of
channel).-The original condition of the channel of this portion of
the river was such as to permit of steamboat navigation during high-
water stages only, lasting about six or eight months of the year. The
  a Not including $12.50 expended for United States Weather Bureau and subse-
quently returned to appropriation; also not including $65.47 expended for Isthmian
Canal Commission, to be returned to appropriation.
  b Of this amount $312,000 is for continuing contract work authorized by the river
and harbor act of March 2, 1907.
   c Of this amount $312,000 is for continuing contract work authorized by the river and
harbor act of March 2, 1907.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    419
minimum width of the channel was about 100 feet and the minimum
depth 2 feet, at mean low water.
   The original project for the improvement of this stream, as adopted
in 1871, contemplated the removal of snags and other obstructions
in the channel of the river and the widening and deepening of the
existing channel through various shoals, at an estimated cost of
$21,500. The project adopted in 1879 was to afford a channel of
navigable width and 4 feet deep at ordinary low water from the
mouth to Demopolis, a distance of 185 miles, by the removal of snags,
logs, and overhanging trees, and the improvement of the worst bars
by dredging.
   Prior to commencement of work under the existing project there
was applied to channel work on this section of river $249,542.48.
   The earlier projects for the improvement of this section of Tom-
bigbee River were superseded by the project adopted in the river and
harbor act of September 19, 1890. The project adopted at that time
provided for securing a channel 6 feet deep at low water between the
mouth and Demopolis by the construction of locks and dams and bank
revetments, and by the removal of logs, snags, and other obstructions.
The cost of this project was originally estimated at $508,808.98, but
in 1897 after $330,000 had been appropriated for the work, the esti-
mate was increased, the additional cost of completion being then
placed at $600,000.
    By the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, the formation of a
6-foot channel below Demopolis by constructing locks and dams was
made a part of the project for securing 6-foot navigation in the Black
Warrior, Warrior, and Tombigbee rivers, Alabama. Information in
regard to work accomplished on the Tombigbee River under this
project and the expenditures made in connection therew--ith will be
found in the section of this report immediately preceding.
    Under previous projects this section of the Tombigbee River has
been repeatedly cleared of snags, dikes have been constructed, dredg-
ing has been done at the worst bars, and the channel made navigable
for steamboats at low stages of the river. The existing project for
maintenance of the improvement of the Tombigbee River from the
mouth to Demopolis was adopted by the river and harbor act of June
13, 1902, and contemplates the maintenance of the existing channel
by the removal of logs, snags, and other obstructions from the stream,
and by the repair of dikes.
    The amount expended on work under the existing project up to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $51,332.17, all of
which was applied to maintenanrce. All work under this project has
been performed with the United States plant and hired labor, and the
channel of the stream has been maintained in a navigable condition.
    During the past fiscal year the snag boat Demopolis worked over
about 162 miles of this section, below Lock No. 1, removing 1,028
obstructions from the channel and doing a small amount of bank
work. In addition, the wreck of an old sunken snag boat was re-
moved.
    The new snag boat Tombigbee was received and fitted up, and will
commence work as soon as the water falls low enough. Part pay-
ment for this boat was. made from this appropriation, and part cost
of completing dredge for use on this and other rivers was also paid.
420           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U.   S. ARMY.

   It is proposed to apply available funds and future appropriations
to maintenance of the improvement by snagging, dredging, and con-
struction of jetties. Two snag boats will be kept at work here.
   The Tombigbee River is navigable for steamboats as far up as
Columbus, Miss., a distance of 341 miles above its mouth, and for
rafts as far up as Walkers Bridge, Miss., a farther distance of 169
miles. This stream is nontidal except in its lower reaches. Floods
at Demopolis rise at times to a stage of 60 feet above low water.
   Detailed accounts of this improvement are contained in the Annual
Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, page 1437; 1897, page
1685; and 1900, page 2202.
   Commerce on this section of river in 1908 amounted to 300,081
tons, valued at about $4,529,739. The project results in affording
cheap water rates between Mobile and points along the lower Tom-
bigbee River.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................                            ...............         $21, 933.13
June 30, 1909, receipts from sales.................................-----------------------------------....      137.80
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..............................................                                      ....... 10, 000. 00
                                                                                                        32, 070. 93
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement..........-----.........................................                                   22, 416. 30

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ----....................--------------.......----------...-----.        9, 654. 63
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities......--------.......-----..-----.....-----......----.....--...     1, 304. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available..-..........                     .   ..       .......--    ........       8, 350. 63

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-.
  pended July 1, 1909...........--------------------  -------------      26, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (e) Tombigbee River from Demopolis, Ala., to Columbus, Miss.-
The original condition of this section of the river was such as to admit
of navigation only during high-water stages. The channel was
obstructed by shoals, logs, and overhanging trees, the minimum
depth being 1 foot at mean low water, and the minimum width of chan-
nel 70 feet. The improvement of the Tombigbee River between
Demopolis and Columbus was commenced under the project of 1871,
which contemplated the improvement of this stream by the removal
of snags and other obstructions in the river and the widening and
deepening of existing channels through various bars. In 1879 this
project was modified so as to provide for the formation of a channel of
navigable width and 3 feet deep at low water from Demopolis to
Columbus, this section forming a part of two different improvements.
  Prior to adoption of the present project, $63,382.98 was expended
on this section of the river.
  The present project for improvement of this section of Tombigbee
River, adopted in 1890, provides for securing a channel 6 feet deep
at low water from Demopolis to Columbus, a distance of 156 miles,
by snagging, tree cutting, bank revetment, bar improvement, and the
construction of locks and dams, at a cost originally estimated at
$779,400. In 1897 the construction of locks and dams was estimated
to cost $2,000,000. This project was adopted by the river and har-
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.
                                                       S                                                    421

bor act of September 19, 1890, but no provision has yet been made by
Congress for commencing the work of lock and dam construction.
The fall of the river from Columbus to Demopolis is about 108 feet.
   The total amount expended on the work under the existing project
up to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $178,295.38,
of which about $77,838.49 was applied to maintenance. These ex-
penditures have resulted in the formation of a clear channel within
the limits of the project available for light-draft boats on a 2-foot
rise above low water and in the partial maintenance of this improve-
ment. Work has been prosecuted by means of United States plant
and hired labor.
   During the fiscal year about 68 miles of river were worked over
with the snag boat Vienna, upstream from Demopolis, when inter-
rupted by high water. Overhanging trees were cut and pulled back,
and 1,588 logs, snags, and stumps were removed from the channel.
This part of the river can be navigated by steamboats most of the
year.
   For efficient work on this section, a self-propelling snag boat is con-
sidered necessary, and the cost of such a boat has been included in
estimate of amount required.
   It is proposed to apply available funds and future appropriations
to the work of maintaining the improvement by the removal of snags,
trees, and other obstructions brought into the channel by freshets.
The maximum height of these freshets at Columbus is 40 feet.
   The commerce on this section of the river for the calendar year
1908 amounted to about 15,202 tons, valued at $531,128.
   This project results in affording water rates from Mobile to points
on the Tombigbee River above Demopolis for several months each
year.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-------.........-----------.........------------.....           $9, 687.94
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
                                                                        ---------------- 5, 983. 32
  improvement------.........-------.............------.........--------------..................

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended --------.............-------------...................-------------     3, 704. 62
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.. -----...------.......---------.............---------...-----.      570. 00
                                                                       --------- 3, 134. 62
July 1, 1909, balance available.----..........----------------------..--.........

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909. -.... ........      ............................... 26, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (f) Tombigbee River from Columbus to Walkers Bridge, Miss.-
Prior to 1902 this improvement was divided into two sections, one
from Columbus to Fulton, 144 miles, and the other from Fulton to
Walkers Bridge, 25 miles, for which appropriations were made
separately.
   The original condition of the river was such that navigation was
impossible except at high water, and difficult even at that stage,
owing to the logs, snags, and overhanging trees which obstructed the
channel. The minimum depth in the channel was about 1 foot at
mean low water and the minimum width was 50 feet.
   The project for the improvement of the river above Columbus
was adopted in 1873, and provided for obtaining a good high-water
422     REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,       U.   S. ARMY.

channel by the removal of obstructions, at an estimated cost of
$35,000. This project was completed in 1882, at a cost of $27,293.65,
since which time operations have been directed toward maintaining
the improvement. The first specific appropriation for the portion
of the river between Fulton and Columbus was made in 1892, this
money, together with subsequent appropriations, being applied to the
maintenance of a high-water channel.
   The project for improvement of the river from Fulton to Walkers
Bridge was adopted in 1888, and provides for securing a high-water
channel by the removal of logs, snags, and overhanging trees, at an
estimated cost of $11,000, and for the maintenance of the same at
an annual cost of $1,500. This project was adopted by the river
and harbor act of August 11, 1888, and was completed in 1891, at a
cost of $6,517.19.
   The total amount expended on these projects up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $77,725.20, of which amount
$43,914.36 had been applied to maintenance. United States plant

 'The
and hired labor have been employed on this work.
        limited amount available for work on this section of the river
for a number of years has limited operations to short stretches of
river in worst condition, but it is desired to make the operations more
extensive, maintaining two working parties in the field instead of one,
with a view to getting over the entire section in one working season.
   During the past fiscal year no work could be done until June
17, 1909, owing to lack of money. On this date work was com-
menced just below Fulton, Miss., working downstream. About 18
miles of river was worked over during the balance of the month,
though the river was a little too high for thorough work and parts of
this stretch may have to be worked over again at a lower stage;
102 obstructions were removed from the river, in addition to bank
work. These operations are being carried on with funds allotted
from the appropriation of March 3, 1909.
   As a result of the work done on this section of Tombigbee River it
has been possible to bring large rafts of logs and timber down on a
rise of a few feet above low water, but the freshets here range from
20 to 40 feet during the high-water season and many obstructions are
brought into the stream by these floods, rendering it necessary to
remove such obstructions each season in order to keep the channel
open. This part of the river is nontidal.
   It is proposed to apply available funds and future appropriations
to the work of maintaining a high-water channel within the limits of
the improvement.
   A reference to reports on surveys upon which .a portion of this
project is based is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1905, page 340.
   The commerce on this section of the river during the calendar year
ending December 31, 1908, amounted to 22,834 tons of logs, valued at
$120,181.
   Funds for work on this part of the river are allotted from the appro-
priation for Tombigbee River, Demopolis to Columbus.
   This project has no effect on freight rates.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           423
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................                                             $71. 14
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........................................................                                            3, 000. 00
                                                                                                                   3, 071.14
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement-------...------............................................--------------------------------------.     129.29

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended................................       ....... 2, 941. 85
July 1,.1909, outstanding liabilities--......................................---330. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available.............                              ....            ...--..........          2, 611.85
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.............-----------------------------------------.. 10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix R 3.)
   4. Operating and care of locks and dams on Black Warrior and Tom-
bigbee rivers, Alabama.-(a) Lock 1.-This lock is about 110 miles
above Mobile, and was opened for traffic on September 6, 1908,
though all construction work was not completed on that date. On
December 1, 1908, its operation and care became a charge under the
general law of July 5, 1884.
   During the past year a movable boom has been constructed above
the lock to prevent lodgment of drift during high water; tanks for
supplying drinking water were installed; some dredging was done in
lock chamber and approaches; system of lighting lock was installed;
and some stone delivered for extending riprap bank protection.
   (b) Lock 4.-This lock is near Demopolis, Ala., about 231 miles
above Mobile. Construction work was completed and the lock
opened for traffic on December 1, 1908. At that time its operation
and care became a charge under the general law of July 5, 1884. The
lock has been used regularly for traffic whenever the water was too
low for boats to pass over the dam. Lock-tender's house has been
painted, fence built around reservation, riprap bank protection ex-
tended, and some stone delivered for further work on bank protection.
   (c) Lock 5.-This lock is about 246 miles above Mobile. Construc-
tion work was completed and this lock opened to traffic September 1,
1908. At that time its operation and care became a charge under
the general law of July 5, 1884. Lock-tender's house has been
painted, fence built around reservation, riprap bank protection ex-
tended, and considerable filling placed below dam.
   (d) Lock 6.-This lock is about 267 miles above Mobile. Construc-
tion work was completed and the lock opened for traffic on October 1,
1908. At that time its operation and care became a charge under
the general law of July 5, 1884. Fence has been built around reserva-
tion, riprap bank protection extended, stone filling placed below dam,
and derrick stone delivered to be placed on dam apron during the
next low-water season. Flood deposit has been dredged from lock
approaches.
   (e) Lock 7.-This lock is about 282 miles above Mobile. Contract
work was completed and the lock turned over to the United States
November 7, 1903. At that time its operation and care became a
charge under the general law of July 5, 1884.
424     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S.   ARMY.

   The lock was opened for traffic November 27, 1903, and has been
used regularly since. During the past year one of the guide cribs on
upper approach was undermined and turned over. All of the stone
and part of the timber for replacing this crib with a larger one have
been delivered. Flood deposit has been dredged from lock and
approaches.
    (f) Lock 8.-This lock is about 298 miles above Mobile. Contract
work was completed and this lock turned over to the United States in
December, 1902. On January 1, 1903, its operation and care became
a charge under the general law of July 5, 1884. On account of delay
in erecting the gates, damage to timber floor by upthrust, and a large
leak which developed under abutment, this lock was not opened for
traffic until October 13, 1903. Since that time it has been used
regularly, except twenty-six days during 1904, when it was closed for
repairs, and four days in 1906, when upper approach was filled with
drift and saw logs. No work except operating and care has been
done during the past year.
    (g) Lock 9. This lock is about 315 miles above Mobile. Contract
work was completed and the lock turned over to the United States in
December, 1902. On January 1, 1903, its operation and care became
a charge under the general law of July 5, 1884. This lock was opened
for traffic in October, 1902, and has been used regularly since. During
the past year some stone has been filled below dam to check erosion,
flood deposit dredged from locks and approaches; bridge on wagon
road to lock has been rebuilt, and some repairs have been made to
riprap bank protection.
    (h) Locks 10, 11, and 12.-These locks and dams are near Tusca-
loosa, Ala., about 362 miles above Mobile, and overcome the Tusca-
loosa Falls with their combined lift of 29 feet.
    They were finished and opened for traffic in November, 1895, and
on July 1, 1896, their operation and care became a charge under the
general law of July 5, 1884. During the past year 1,949 tons of
quarry waste have been filled above these three dams to prevent
leakage, and flood deposit has been dredged from the locks and
approaches.
     (i) Lock 1.-This lock is about 9 miles above Tuscaloosa, and
about 370 miles above Mobile. Contract work was completed and
the lock turned over to the United States in May, 1905. Erecting
the gates was completed and the lock opened for traffic on July 4,
1905, when its operation and care became a charge under the general
law of July 5, 1884. During the past year some dredging was done
in lower approach to lock, and wreck of an old coal barge was blasted
and removed from channel below lock.
     (j).-During the past year, in addition to work on locks, the worst
snags were removed from about 52 miles of river. Channels were
dredged through three of the worst bars on the river. One new
work barge has been built. Gasoline towboat Sylph has been rebuilt.
Snag boat R. C. McCalla, which was built under contract and partly
paid for from this allotment, was completed and delivered at Mobile.
This boat was put in commission on the Black Warrior River on
May 20, and is now at work removing numerous snags and trees that
caved from the banks during the recent high-water season. Pipe
line and pontoons for new 12-inch hydraulic dredge have been fitted
up and this dredge used in clearing flood deposit from lock ap-
                 RIVER   AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   425
proaches. New gasoline engine installed on launch Mamie K.
Four barges hauled out on ways and thoroughly repaired. Dredging
machinery moved off wooden hull and fitted up on steel barge.
Building cabin on this hull is now in progress. Wooden hull that had
been used for dredge pulled out on ways and repaired and fitted up
as a quarterboat. Derrick boat hauled out on ways and repairs to
same are now in progress.
   To June 30, 1909, the amount expended on this work was
$433,917.29.
   The total expense during the year, for operating, repairs, etc., for
the 11 locks, was $90,776.78.
   The commerce passing through the locks during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909, amounted to 1,102 tons cement, 6,177 tons
coal, 4,771 tons corn, 5,291 tons cotton, 2,530 tons cotton seed, 2,414
tons fertilizer, 72,128 tons logs, 3,632 tons lumber, 10,148 tons staves,
28,393 tons stone, 13,350 tons sand and gravel, and 15,178 tons
miscellaneous freight.
   In addition to the traffic through the locks there was considerable
traffic in coal, cement, and contractors supplies on the pool above
Lock 13, and some coal traffic in the pool between Locks 12 and 13.
There is also a very large traffic in logs, timber, general merchandise,
cotton, sand, and gravel on the river below Lock 1.
    (See Appendix R 4.)
   5. Pascagoula River, Mississippi.-Before this improvement was
commenced the channel through the bar at the mouth of the river
had a least depth of 3 feet at mean low water, while inside the mouth
for a distance of 10 miles upstream the river was navigable for
vessels of 6 feet draft. Appropriations for this work of improve-
ment were made in 1827, 1828, and 1852, but there is no record of
the work accomplished with those funds.
  The first extended project for the improvement of this stream was
adopted in 1880 and contemplated securing a channel 7 feet deep and
200 feet wide across the bar at the mouth of the river. This project
also included some snagging work on the river above Moss Point,
which is described in the report on the improvement of the Pasca-
goula, Leaf, and Chickasahay rivers, Mississippi. The project for a
7-foot channel was practically completed in 1884, the total amount
expended in securing such a channel, including the appropriations
made between 1827 and 1852, amounting to $74,500.
   In 1886 a new project was adopted, which provided for securing a
channel 12 feet deep at low water, with a navigable width between
Mississippi Sound and Moss Point. Under this project a depth of 9
feet across the entrance bar was first obtained, while subsequently a
channel 12 feet deep and 80 feet wide was dredged from Moss Point
to the mouth of the river, and a 12-foot channel across the bar at
the mouth was partially completed. These operations required the
expenditure of $95,000, including the expenditure of about $8,000
applied to dredging work in Horn Island Pass in 1897, or a total of
$169,500 under both projects.
   The present project for the improvement of Pascagoula River was
adopted in the river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, and provided
for the formation of a 12-foot channel from a point in Dog River
3 miles above its mouth down the Pascagoula River to the 12-foot
426          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                               U.    S. ARMY.

contour in Mississippi Sound, 150 feet wide above and 300 feet wide
below the railroad bridge at Scranton, Miss., at an estimated cost of
$317,600, including the formation of a 20-foot channel through cer-
tain shoal spots in the Horn Island anchorage.
   Work under this project was in progress between September, 1899,
and February, 1902, during which time an uninterrupted 12-foot
channel was obtained within the limits of the project in Pascagoula
River, while a 20-foot channel was formed through the shoal areas in
Horn Island anchorage.
   The river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, modified and extended
the existing project so as to provide for a channel 17 feet deep instead
of 12 feet from 3 miles above the mouth of Dog River to Mississippi
Sound, at a total cost of $1,050,222, exclusive of the Horn Island
improvement.
   The total amount expended on the existing project up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $674,651.13, excluding the
expenditure of about $88,000 on the work performed at Horn Island.
Of this amount $155,081.14 was applied to maintenance. Work
under the project is about 60 per cent completed.
   During the past fiscal year contract work was carried on here,
removing 442,556 cubic yards of material from about 22,579 feet of
channel, and dredging operations were also carried on with the U. S.
dredge Barnard, this dredge removing 586,353 cubic yards of material
from 12,647 feet of channel, all dredging being to more than 17 feet
depth at mean low water. About one-fourth of this work was original
dredging and the balance for the purpose of maintenance.
   The available draft is now 18 feet at mean low water. The average
range of tide is 1~ feet.
   It is proposed to apply the available balance and future appropria-
tions toward the completion of the project and maintenance of the
improvement.
   A reference to the report of the survey upon which the existing
project is based is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of En-
gineers for 1904, page 334. An account of this improvement is con-
tained in the Annual Reports for 1902, page 2211, and 1904, page 1828.
   The commerce of the harbor for the calendar year 1908 amounted
to 1,184,569 tons, principally logs, lumber, and naval stores, valued
at $7,216,460.
   This project results in effecting a reduction in rail freight rates
between Scranton, Miss., and seaboard cities of the Atlantic coast, and
also in affording direct water freight rates on lumber from Moss Point
and Scranton to foreign ports.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................                                              607.33
                                                                                                           $------------------
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...----------..........------.......................---------------.....------..------.....  75, 000. 00
                                                                                                 200, 607. 33
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
                                                                    ---
    For works of improvement....--------......------.............---...           30, 622.00
    For maintenance of improvement........--..... ... ----         .....          90, 036. 46
                                                                                                 120, 658. 46

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-..................................                               79, 948. 87

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                           330, 000. 00
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                  427
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909........
                                            _       ...     .... ... ...... $100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix R 5.)
   6. Pascagoula, Leaf, and Chickasahay rivers, Mississippi.-(a)
Pascagoula River (above the mouth of Dog River).-Before this im-
provement was commenced navigation was impossible on this sec-
tion of Pascagoula River except during periods of high water. The
minimum width of the channel was 60 feet and the minimum depth
was 1 foot at mean low water, the stream being very much obstructed
by snags and logs. The first project for this improvement, which was
adopted in 1880, in addition to providing for dredging work at the
mouth of the stream, described in the report on the improvement of
Pascagoula River, Mississippi, contemplated the improvement of the
river by the removal of snags and overhanging trees. Under this
project the river was cleared of obstructions between 1882 and 1884,
at a cost of $15,000. In 1886 the existing project for this improve-
ment was adopted. This project provided for the maintenance of the
channel above the mouth of the river by removal of obstructions from
the stream from time to time, but was modified in 1899, the extent of
the improvement being limited at that time to the section of the river
above Dog River, about 100 miles. The total amount expended on
the existing project to June 30, 1909, was $29,380.97, all of which was
applied to maintenance.
   No work was done on the river during the past fiscal year, the ex-
penditures being in payment of part of the cost of a new sternwheel
snag boat and of a small amount of office expenses. The new snag
boat built will be occupied most of its time on the Tombigbee River,
where she is operating now, and while she can be operated on Pasca-
goula River, she is not suitable for the work on Leaf and Chickasahay
rivers. So it is proposed to apply available funds and those estimated
for fiscal year 1911 for the Pascagoula, Leaf, and Chickasahay rivers
 (see consolidated money statement) to the construction of a small
self-propelling snag boat especially suited to the work on these three
rivers, and to the operation of this boat in maintenance of the im-
provement. This, it is considered, will be much the most economical
and efficient plan for maintaining the three channels.
   On June 30, 1909, the Pascagoula River was navigable at low water
for boats of 5 feet draft as far up as Cedar Creek, 55 miles, while
above this point to the head of the river light-draft navigation was
possible on a slight rise above low water.
   The Pascagoula River is nontidal, except in its lower reaches.
   The report of the examination upon which the improvement was
originally based is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1879, page 835.
   The commerce originating on Pascagoula River above the mouth of
Dog River during the calendar year 1908 amounted to 290,327 tons,
principally logs, naval stores, and general merchandise, valued at
$1,807,500. In addition to this, the combined commerce of Chicka-
sahay and Leaf rivers passed over this stream.
   This project has no effect on freight rates.
   Available funds and future appropriations will be applied to part
payment on snag boat and in continuation of snagging operations.
428             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                         U.    S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended                      ----------..............--- -------.................-------... $9, 446. 53
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of im-
  provement....----------...---------........---................--------------.....---------------.............       6, 077.50

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                                             3, 369. 03
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
     pended July 1, 1909....--------------------------------------------                                              (a)
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
     1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Leaf River.-Originally it was impracticable to navigate this
river on account of snags, logs, and overhanging trees obstructing the
channel. The minimum width of the stream was 100 feet and the
minimum depth was 2 feet at mean low water. The original project
for this improvement was adopted in 1890, its purpose being to afford
a channel for high-water navigation from Bowie Creek to the mouth
of the river, a distance of 75 miles, by the removal of obstructions and
overhanging trees. This project was completed in 1897 at a cost of
$11,019.04, since which time expenditures have been in the direction
of maintaining the improvement.
   No work was done during the fiscal year, the expenditures being
applied to part payment for construction of a self-propelling snag
boat, now employed on Tombigbee River. With the funds now
available and those estimated for 1911, it is proposed to pay part of
the cost of a small snag boat to be built for Pascagoula, Leaf, and
Chickasahay rivers, and to maintain the improvement.
   The total amount expended on this improvement up to June 30,
1909, was $23,146.01, of which $12,126.97 was applied to maintenance.
   On June 30, 1909, the river was available for rafting on a fair rise
above low water, being used to a very limited extent for any other
form of navigation.
   For reference to the report upon which this project is based and
to descriptions of the improvement, see the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 337.
   The commerce of Leaf River during the calendar year 1908
amounted to 213,300 tons, principally logs and timber, valued at
$636,000.
   This project has no effect on freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................... $3, 416.49
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of im-
  provement....... ........ ........   ..... ......    ........  ......... 1, 062.50

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended........----..........                                 .....       .......         2, 353. 99
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
    pended July 1, 1909...--------------------------------------------                                                (a)
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Chicasahay River.-The original condition of this river was
such that it was navigable for small rafts only during high water,
and even navigation of this character was troublesome and dangerous.
The minimum width of the channel was 50 feet and the minimum
depth 6 inches at mean low water, the river being badly obstructed
by logs and snags.
                          a See consolidated money statement on page 429.
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       429

   The original project for the improvement was adopted by the river
and harbor act of September 19, 1890, and provided for obtaining a
high-water channel from the mouth of the river up to Shubuta, Miss.,
a distance of 130 miles, by the removal of obstructions from the chan-
nel and overhanging trees from the banks. The river and harbor act
of June 3, 1896, modified this project by limiting the improvement to
that part of the river between the mouth and Bucatunna, Miss., about
75 miles. The project further provided for the maintenance of the
improved channel. The project, as modified, was completed in the
latter part of 1896, at a cost of $12,399.73.
   The existing project was adopted in the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1905, and provides for maintaining the channel in Chicka-
sahay River from the mouth to Bucatunna, Miss., by the removal of
logs, snags, and other obstructions from the waterway, in order to
keep the river in navigable condition for rafting at high-water stages,
at an annual cost of $2,500. A reference to the report of the exami-
nation upon which this project is based is printed in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 346.
    No expenditures were made during the past fiscal year.
   With available funds and the amount estimated for 1911 it is pro-
posed to maintain the improvement, including the payment of part
cost of a small snag boat suitable for the work on these streams.
    The total amount expended on the improvement up to June 30,
1909, was $24,877.46, of which $12,477.73 was applied to maintenance.
    This stream is nontidal, and its condition on June 30, 1909, was
such that it could be used by flatboats and rafts on a rise of 6 or 8
feet up as far as Shubuta, Miss., though considerably obstructed.
    The improvement has had no effect on freight rates.
    The commerce of this river during 1908 amounted to 180,125 tons
of logs and timber, valued at $923,000.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..---......-----........-------...................----------------- $372.54
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..--------...--............---------....-------------..........---. 372.54
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 ..      ...------                                            (a)
                                                               -----.......................................--
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                                 CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................------------------------............... $13,235. 56
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of im-
  provement----------...--------..............--------------------......................---------.....-----... 7, 140. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...........                                                                 6,095.56
                                                                              ....--------------------------........
                                                                                            --------

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 . .............................................                                     27, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix R 6.)
                        a See consolidated money statement on this page.
430     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S. ARMY.

   7. Horn Island Pass, Mississippi.---The channel through the bar
had before improvement a depth which increased through natural
causes from 14 or 15 feet in 1853 to about 18 feet in 1886, and has
been available at low water since the latter date for vessels up to a
draft of slightly less than 18 feet at mean low water.
   Under the appropriations for improving Pascagoula River, Missis-
sippi, carried by the river and harbor acts of August 18, 1894, and
June 3, 1896, provision was made for the removal of the bar in Horn
Island Pass, and in conformity with this provision a channel with a
least depth of 20.5 feet (19.5 feet referred to the existing datum), and
with a width of 200 feet, was dredged through the Horn Island bar.
The total cost of this work was $7,682.40, but the benefit of the im-
provement was soon lost through shoaling.
   Under the appropriations for Pascagoula River and Horn Island
Harbor carried by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, and the
sundry civil act of June 6, 1900, an amount estimated at about $88,000
was applied to dredging a 20-foot (19 feet present datum) channel at
certain shoal areas in the Horn Island anchorage basin, the work
being in progress between 1899 and 1901.
   The existing project for the improvement of Horn Island Pass pro-
vides for the formation of a channel 21 feet deep at low water, 300 feet
wide through the outer bar, and 200 feet wide elsewhere in the pass,
at an estimated cost of $40,480, and $9,000 annually to preserve the
improvement. The project was adopted by the river and harbor act
of March 3, 1905, which carried an appropriation of $40,480 for the
work, subject to the condition "that a contract or contracts can be
made at a sum not to exceed the unit price of 11 cents per cubic
yard, or such work can be performed by a government dredge."
   The proposed dredging work was advertised under date of May 16,
1905, but no bids for its execution were received in response to this
advertisement. Since that date the work has been performed by the
U. S. dredge Charleston, completing the project and maintaining the
same.
  No work has been done at Horn Island Pass during the past fiscal
year, the last work being in April, 1908. The expenditures have
been applied in part payment for extensive repairs to the Charleston,
which dredge will be used during part of the ensuing fiscal year in
removing shoals that have formed in Horn Island Pass since the
last work done here, in maintenance of the improvement. A small
amount of office and engineering expenses have also been paid from
this appropriation.
   Available funds and future appropriations will be applied to main-
tenance of the present channel through the pass, including part cost
of keeping in repair United States dredge for use on this and other
outer bars in the district.
   The report upon which this project is based is printed: in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 1863.
   The available low-water depth through the pass is about 21 feet,
and the average range of tide is about 1.1 feet.
   Commerce using the Horn Island Pass channel during the calendar
year 19.08 amounted to about 500,836 tons of lumber and timber,
valued at about $4,526,960.
  This improvement in connection with the improvement of Pasca-
goula River results in effecting a reduction in rail freight rates be-
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               431
tween Scranton, Miss., and seaboard cities of the Atlantic coast, and
in affording direct water freight rates on lumber from Moss Point and
Scranton to foreign ports.
   The total amount expended under the existing project up to June
30, 1909, was $50,249.71, of which about $9,768.71 has been applied
to maintenance.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended -----........--..
                                           -------... --                  $3, 493. 43
                                                         .......---...---...
                                                             ---
                                                            ---......
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.........   -................ ......                ...... 12, 000. 00
                                                         -...........

                                                                     15, 493. 43
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
                                                                      4, 263. 14
  improvement---------------................--------....----.....-----.....

                                                                            11, 230. 29
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ----...---....................-----.........---
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.............................. .......  2,000. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available-----....----.............-------------------------.....-----....   9, 230. 29

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
                                                                          9, 000. 00
   pended July 1, 1909-------------------------------------------.............
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix R 7.)
  8. Harbor at Biloxi, Miss.-This channel originally had a mini-
mum depth of 4 feet. The original project for its improvement was
adopted in 1882 and contemplated the formation of a channel through
Deer Island flats to connect Biloxi Bay with the Back Bay of Biloxi,
at an estimated cost of $35,000. The channel thus proposed was to
have a depth of 8 feet at low water with a width sufficient for navi-
gation.
   In 1884 this project was changed so as to provide for deepening the
channel from Mississippi Sound to the wharves at Biloxi from the
existing depth of 4 or 41 feet to 8 feet over a width of 150 feet, the
estimated cost of this work being $55,000. The work of dredging
was commenced in September, 1887, and the project was finally com-
pleted in August, 1893, at a cost of $44,382.27.
   Since that time funds have been applied to the maintenance of the
improvement.
   No work was done here during the past fiscal year, the expendi-
tures being in payment of part cost of building new hull for U. S. S.
Chickasaw, and some travel expenses incurred while inspecting the
improvement. The last dredging at this locality was completed in
May, 1908, and considerable shoaling, especially near the edges of
channel, has taken place since.
   Available funds and future appropriations will be applied to
maintaining a channel 8 feet deep and as great a width as possible,
not exceeding 150 feet.
   The commerce of the harbor during the calendar year 1908 con-
sisted principally of lumber, rosin and turpentine, fish and oysters,
and general merchandise, amounting to 217,550 tons, valued at
$2,361,150.
   The total amount expended on this improvement up to June 30,
1909, was $71,586.44, of which $27,204.17 was applied to work of
maintenance.
432            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                          S. ARMY.

  The maximum low-water draft that can be carried through the
channel is now about 8 feet, and the range of tide is about 11 feet.
  A reference to the report upon which the present project for this
work of improvement is based is printed in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 337.
  The project has little or no effect on freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-----....--..---...---.......-----------------...--...............--------   $1, 298. 61
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provem ent.....................................  .......  ......-.......                                      502. 78

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...----------------..................-------------....-------..                 795. 83

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909---------................---------------------------------. 10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix R 8.)
   9. Harbor at Gulfport and Ship Island Pass, Mississippi.--Origi-
nally no channel existed between Ship Island Harbor and Gulfport,
Miss. The depths on the site of the channel ranged from 19 to 81
feet, and over the site of the anchorage basin they varied from 81 to
21 feet, at mean low water.
   The existing project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1899, which authorized the Secretary of War to enter into
contract for dredging a channel 300 feet wide and 19 feet deep at
mean low water from the anchorage basin at Ship Island Harbor, on
the Gulf of Mexico, to Gulfport, Miss., and to construct at the end
of this channel next to the shore an anchorage basin of similar depth
and not less than 2,640 feet by 1,320 feet in area. This act also
authorized the Secretary of War to contract for the maintenance of
this channel and anchorage basin for a term of five years after their
completion for the sum of $10,000 annually.
   Contract was entered into in 1901 for dredging the channel and
anchorage basin, the work to be completed within two years from
April 21, 1901, for $150,000, and for the maintenance of the channel
and basin for a term of five years after completion for the sum of
$10,000 per annum. Work was commenced on April 16, 1901. By
joint resolution of Congress approved June 14, 1906, it was provided
that the channel and basin should be accepted as dredged, and that
$150,000 should be paid the contractor for the work, the channel and
basin having been dredged to the approximate depth and width re-
quired in the contract. The payment was made. The period of
maintenance commenced June 14, 1906.
   The river and harbor act approved March 2, 1907, appropriated
$100,000 for continuing the improvement and maintenance of the
anchorage basin at Gulfport and channel therefrom to the anchorage
or roadstead at Ship Island, also Ship Island Pass between Ship and
Cat islands, Mississippi, and authorized the Secretary of War to annul
that portion of the contract entered into February 20, 1901, with
Spencer S. Bullis, relating to the maintenance of a channel and anchor-
age basin between Ship Island and Gulfport. The annulment of this
contract was effected by a supplemental agreement approvetd by the
Secretary of War June 11, 1907.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    433
   The report of the survey upon which the improvement of Gulfport
Harbor and Ship Island Pass, Mississippi, was originally based is
printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1899, page
1787. Reports of another examination and survey of this locality
are printed in House Document No. 184, Fifty-ninth Congress, second
session.
   Prior to the act of March 2, 1907, appropriations were made sepa-
rately for Gulfport Harbor, Mississippi, and Ship Island Pass, Missis-
sippi. Under an appropriation of $40,000, carried by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1899, the channel through Ship Island Pass
was dredged from its original depth of 21 feet to the projected depth
of 26 feet and 300 feet width. These depths were 20 feet and 25 feet,
respectively, referring to present datum.
   The channel through Ship Island Pass has shoaled to as little as
22 feet in some spots. None of the funds appropriated March 2,
1907, were applied to this part of the work.
   Of the $170,000 provided by the river and harbor act of March 3,
1909, for Gulfport Harbor and Ship Island Pass, it is proposed to
apply $160,000 to maintenance work in the Gulfport channel and
basin, and. $10,000 to similar work at Ship Island Pass, using the
dredge Barnard for the former work and the dredge Charleston for
the latter. Future appropriations will be similarly applied.
   During the past fiscal year the Barnard was employed most of her
time on the work at Gulfport, removing 1,589,620 cubic yards of
material, place measurement, from the channel. This dredge and
attendant plant was maintained in good repair. The gross cost of
the work of the Barnard, including repairs to plant, inspection, etc.,
was $59,128.79, or 3.72 cents per cubic yard.
   Part of cost of repairing the Charleston was paid from Ship Island
Pass funds.
   The channel and basin at Gulfport have been maintained at pro-
jected dimensions, except in some spots where the depth is less than
19 feet, but the material composing the bottom is soft and vessels
drawing 20 feet navigate the channel at mean low water, and those
drawing as much as 22 feet use it at high tide. The range of the
tide is about 14 feet.
   During the time dredging work was in progress under contract
with Spencer S. Bullis, allotments amounting to $24,199.85 were made
from the permanent indefinite appropriation, act July 5, 1884, to
cover the expenses of inspection, superintendence, and surveys.
Of the amount allotted, $22,449.76 was applied to the purpose for
which intended and the balance turned back into the Treasury.
   The commerce of Gulfport Harbor and Ship Island Pass during
the calendar year 1908 amounted to 473,327 tons, principally lum-
ber, naval stores, and cotton, valued at $5,684,500.
   This project results in effecting a reduction in rail freight rates
between Gulfport and seaboard cities of the Atlantic coast and in
affording water freight rates from Gulfport to foreign ports.
   The total amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909,
was $338,541.42, of which $132,645.69 was applied to maintenance.
Of the above amount, $297,711.69 was applied to Gulfport harbor and
channel and $40,829.73 was used on Ship Island Pass.
     9001-EN G 1909-28
434           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                           S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................  $28, 866. 86
June 30, 1909, receipts from sales......................................      101.00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..---------------------------------------------..-- . 170, 000. 00
November 9, 1908, allotted from emergency appropriation, act of March
  2, 1907............................................................     10, 000.00

                                                                                                    208, 967. 86
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement--................----.........................................                               60, 262. 64

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                                 148, 705. 22
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                              10, 500. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available ....................                          ............         . 138, 205. 22

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909...................................   129, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix R 9.)
   10. Wolf and Jordan rivers, Mississippi.-The least depth on the
bar at the mouth of Wolf River is something under 3 feet, and on the
bar at the mouth of the Jordan River it is not quite 4 feet.
   The present and only project was adopted by the river and harbor
act of March 2, 1907, and provides for the formation 6f a channel 7
feet deep and 100 feet wide at bottom, with side slopes of 1 on 6,
across the bar at the mouth of each of the streams named, from the
7-foot curve of depth in the river to the 6-foot contour in Bay St.
Louis, at a cost of $30,000 for completing the work and $5,000 per
annum thereafter for maintenance. After reaching the 6-foot con-
tour in the bay the material becomes so soft that a draft of 7 feet
can easily be carried through it.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1908, a channel 8 feet deep
and 100 feet wide was dredged from the 6.7-foot curve through the
bar to the 5.3-foot curve at the mouth of Wolf River, and at the
mouth of Jordan River from the 6.7-foot curve through the bar to
the 5.5-foot curve, completing about 95 per cent of the project.
   During the past fiscal year no work was done here, but there was an
expenditure of $500 as part payment for the new U. S. S. Chiclcasaw.
   The channels have maintained themselves very well. Some shoal-
ing has taken place in Wolf River, but as the shoals do not run
entirely across the channel dredged the available depth remains
about the same.
   A mean low-water draft of 7 feet can be carried through either
channel and the average range of the tide is 11 feet.
   Additional appropriations, when made, will be applied to main-
tenance.
   The report of the examination and survey upon which the project
is based is printed in House Document No. 917, Fifty-ninth Congress,
first session. For previous reports of examinations, reference is made
to the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1893, pages 1787
and 1789.
   The commerce on these rivers during the calendar year 1907
amounted to 55,387 tons of lumber, rosin, turpentine, and general
merchandise, valued at $931,412.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                           435

   The improvement has been of immediate and considerable local
benefit. The work is too recent to determine its effect on freight
rates, but it is believed to have little, if any, such effect.
   The total amount expended on this improvement up to the close
of the past fiscal year was $29,195.19, none of which was applied to
maintenance.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................................       $1, 304. 81
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ...............................................................            500. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..........................................      804. 81
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 ................................................ 10, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix R 10.)
   11. Pearl River below Rockport, Miss.-The limits of this improve-
ment originally extended from the mouth of the river to Jackson, a
distance of 313 miles. By act of Congress of April 21, 1900, the con-
struction of.a fixed highway bridge across Pearl River at Rockport
was legalized. This point thereby became the head of navigation
on the lower river for boats of any considerable size and the upper
limit of the project. However, the bridge at Rockport is reported to
have been washed away in February, 1906. The distance from Jack-
son to Rockport is 67 miles.
   Prior to improvement the condition of the river was such that it
was not navigable except during high-water stages, and even then
navigation was difficult and dangerous.
   The original project for this improvement was adopted in 1880,
and provided for a channel of navigable width and 5 feet deep at low
water, by the removal of snags and sunken trees from the river bed
and overhanging trees from the banks, at an estimated cost of
$95,940. This project having been found to be impracticable, it was
modified in 1885 so as to provide for a 2-foot channel at low water
throughout this section of the river, at an estimated cost of $145,940.
   With past appropriations the river has been improved until it
became navigable for light-draft boats on a slight rise up as far as
Monticello, about 211 miles above the mouth. Above Monticello the
river has never been navigable except on a rise of 7 feet or more.
   Appropriations between 1899 and 1'907 were applied to the main-
tenance of the lower 100 miles of river. The project has been about
33 per cent completed.
   The work of equipping the snag boat Pearl with propelling ma-
chinery was completed. During the year the snag boat Black Warrior
was hauled out and her hull extensively repaired, without which work
she could not have lasted another season. During the time when
water was low enough for work these two boats removed 2,355 logs,
stumps, and snags from the river, besides cutting and pulling back
overhanging trees and doing other bank work. The total distance
worked over was 188k miles of river. This work has resulted in
opening the channel for navigation by light-draft boats up as far as-
Columbia, 155 miles above the mouth.
436          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                S. ARMY.

   The total amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909,
was $193,824.29, of which $79,900.55 was applied to maintenance.
   The redredging of the 9-foot channel at the mouth of East Pearl
River, as recommended in House Document No. 328, Sixtieth Con-
gress, first session, should, it is believed, be considered a separate
improvement, and none of the money for Pearl River below Rock-
port should be applied to it.
   It is proposed to apply available funds and future appropriations
to the prosecution of snagging work in completion of the project and
maintenance of the improvement.
   This river is nontidal except in its lower reaches.
   The report upon which the project was originally based can be
found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, page
879. Extended information can be found in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1896, page 1454.
   The commerce of this part of Pearl River during the calendar
year 1908 amounted to 21,744 tons of logs and timber, valued at
$239,696.
   The project has little effect on freight rates, but when completed
it is believed will cause a material reduction in these charges.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ............................                  . $24, 201. 26
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ....................................          ................    15, 000. 00
                                                                                               39, 201. 26
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..............................                       $8, 798. 74
    For maintenance of improvement ......................                         8, 815. 42
                                                                                               17, 614. 16

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ........................               .....     ... ....    21, 587. 10
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .... .............................                        3, 500. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available................................                                18, 087. 10
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                        67, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...............................         30, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix R 11.)
   12. Pearl River between Edinburg and Jackson, Miss.-The orig-
inal condition of this section of Pearl River was such that navigation
was impossible, except during high water, and even at high stages
it was difficult and dangerous. The minimum width and depth of
the channel was 40 feet and 1 foot, respectively, between Carthage
and Jackson, while above Carthage the channel had a minimum
width of 30 feet and a minimum depth of 3 inches, at mean low water.
This improvement was formerly divided into two sections, for which
appropriations were made separately. The original project for the
section from Jackson up to Carthage, 101 miles, as adopted in 1879,
contemplated obtaining a clear channel of navigable width and 5 feet
depth at low water, at an estimated cost of $21,000. In 1886 this
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           437
project was modified so as to provide for a channel 2 feet deep, this
depth being considered sufficient for the needs of navigation, and at
the same time the estimate of cost was increased to $50,000. Work
under this project was completed in 1893, at a total cost of $26,014.98,
since which time funds have been applied to maintenance.
   The original project for the part of the river from Carthage up to
Edinburg, a distance of 25 miles, was adopted in 1884 and provided
for the formation of a high-water channel for use during six or eight
months of the year, at an estimated cost of $13,464, and for the
maintenance of same at an annual cost of $500. The work of im-
provement under this project was completed in 1890 at a cost of
$5,857.08, subsequent appropriations being applied to the work of
maintenance.
   The river and harbor act approved June 13, 1902, made one ap-
propriation for this section, since which it has been considered as a
single improvement and appropriations made accordingly.
   During the past fiscal year snagging operations were carried on in
this section of Pearl River from July 17 to December 10, 1908, when
high water interrupted, and from June 1 to 30, 1909. During this
time 40 miles of the river were worked over, and in addition to the
bank work, such as cutting some overhanging trees, pulling back
others, trimming bushes and leveling stumps, there were removed
from the river channel 1,845 logs, snags, and stumps. The improve-
ment has been maintained and is available for light-draft navigation
during high-water season. For efficient work a small nonpropelling
snag boat is needed here, and the cost of such a boat has been included
in amount estimated as needed for this improvement.
   Up to June 30, 1909, the total amount expended on this improve-
ment was $65,986.53, of which about $34,114.47 had been applied
to maintenance.
   The report of the survey of Pearl River from Carthage to Jackson,
upon which the present project was based, is published in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, page 880, and the report
of the survey of the river between Edinburg and Carthage, upon
which the present project was based, is printed in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page 1287.
   During the calendar year 1908 the commerce on this section of
Pearl River was 418 tons of general merchandise, valued at $18,000.
   The improvement has had no effect on freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............................            ........ $2, 449.69
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909............. .....    .......... ..................  . ........   ....... 3, 000. 00

                                                                     5,449.69
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement................................................        2,136.22

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....--.....                .........   .....................   3, 313. 47
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................                ..........  ......      450. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available..................................... ....                      2, 863.47
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended, July 1, 1909..................................................5,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix R 12.)
438          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                         S. ARMY.


   13. Dredgefor harbors on coast of Mississippi.-The river and har-
bor act of March 2, 1907, authorized the Secretary of War, in his dis-
cretion, to construct a dredge for use in said harbors and the channels
adjacent thereto, at a cost not exceeding $200,000, of which amount,
in case such dredge were constiucted, $25,000 should be taken from
the appropriation for Gulfport Harbor and $50,000 from the appro-
priation for Pascagoula River. These amounts were transferred
to the credit of the dredge, and the balance of its proposed cost,
$125,000, was appropriated by the sundry civil act of May 27, 1908.
   The Secretary of War on April 24, 1908, authorized the construc-
tion of this dredge.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year the design of the dredge was
about 90 per cent completed and that of attendant plant about 66
per cent. During the past fiscal year these plans were completed
and approved and, after advertising for proposals, contracts were
made for the dredge, which will be called the "Pascagoula," at a
cost of $144,000, and for pontons for the pipe line for $9,120.22,
both to be delivered at Scranton, Miss. The tug Tuscaloosa was
also purchased at a cost of $21,500. Other items of plant have been
ordered, such as pipe for the pipe line, and attendant launch and
coal barge. The dredge is over 80 per cent completed and the pon-
tons over 70 per cent. It is .expected that the Pascagoula will
start from Baltimore, where she is being built, for Scranton, Miss.,
about the 20th of July, 1909.
   The total amount expended on this work to June 30, 1909, was
$116,115.13.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................           $200, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, receipts from sales.....................................                  2. 10
                                                                                     200, 002. 10
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement.....    -............................ .......... .........               116, 115. 13

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                 83, 886. 97
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...........-..................... ...            32, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available ..................................                    51, 886.97

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..............                  38, 020. 22
    (See Appendix R 13.)
   14. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering
navigation.-On May 25, 1906, an allotment of $3,800 was made
from the indefinite wreck appropriation for the purpose of removing
an old sunken dry dock from Mobile River at the foot of Selma
street, Mobile, Ala. A former allotment was made for the removal
of this old dock in 1893, but funds became exhausted before any
great part of the work had been accomplished.
   With the allotment of May 25, 1906, the wreck was completely
removed, exhausting the allotment. The work was finished in
December, 1908.
   (See Appendix R 14.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      439

EXAMINATION    AND SURVEY MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
               HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports dated October 21, 1907, and October 1, 1908, on prelimi-
nary examination and survey, respectively, of Biloxi Harbor, Missis-
sippi, with a view to extending and deepening the channel into the harbor
and around the eastern end of the peninsula into the sheltered waters of
Back Bay, were duly submitted by the district officer. They were
reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursu-
ant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in House
Document No. 1088, Sixtieth Congress, second session. The locality
is not considered worthy of further improvement by the General
Government at the present time in the manner proposed.

IMPROVEMENT      OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE NEW ORLEANS,
                       LOUISIANA, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Col. E. H. Ruffner, Corps of Engi-
neers, division engineer, Gulf division, to August 20, 1908, and of Lieut.
Col. Lansing H. Beach, .Corps of Engineers, division engineer, Gulf
division, since that date, having under his immediate orders, from
August 29, 1908, to February 26, 1909, First Lieut. Wildurr Willing,
Corps of Engineers, and First Lieut. R. R. Ralston, Corps of Engi-
neers, since January 6, 1909.
   1. Southwest Pass, Mississippi River.-On February 17, 1898, Con-
gress allotted $10,000 from the appropriation for closing crevasse in
Pass a Loutre, Mississippi River, for the purpose of a survey and
report by a Board of Engineer officers upon the practicability of
securing a channel of adequate width and 35 feet depth at mean low
water of the Gulf of Mexico throughout Southwest Pass, Mississippi
River. The survey was completed in 1898 and report submitted on
January 7, 1899. This report is printed in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1899, page 1863.
   The item in the river and harbor act approved March 3, 1899, mak-
ing appropriation for improving outlet of the Mississippi River pro-
vided for the appointment of a Board of Engineers to prepare a
project for a channel 35 feet in depth throughout Southwest Pass and
appropriated $20,000 for expenses of the Board. The Board of Engi-
neers appointed under provisions of this act submitted a report and
project on January 11, 1900. The report is printed on pages 2287-
2302 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900.
   The project of the Board contemplated securing a channel 1,000
feet wide and 35 feet deep at mean low water throughout the South-
west Pass by dredging; the construction of two jetties to main-
tain the channel; the construction of sills across Cubits Gap, The
Jump, and Baptiste Collets Canal; the closing of all minor out-
lets below the forts; the construction of a dredge in addition to the
one provided for by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, and
the sundry civil act of June 6, 1900, under appropriation for improve-
ing outlet of the Mississippi River; other necessary plant, such as
tugboats, barges, tracks, buildings, etc., and the purchase of land at
the shore ends of the jetties; the whole estimated to cost $6,000,000,
and $150,000 additional per annum for maintenance.
440      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

   This project was adopted by the river and harbor act of June 13,
1902, which authorized material modifications in the plans of the
jetties, and they are now located as shown on the map printed with
Appendix S 1 of this report.
   The original project for the expenditure of the funds appropriated
for this work contemplated the construction of a dredge, dredging,
purchase of land, and construction of two jetties to be built of mat-
tresses and stone with concrete superstructure.
   All of the land below or south of Pilottown, on the east bank, and
all that below the United States reservation on the west bank of
Southwest Pass, containing about 1,275 acres, were acquired on July
10, 1903, for use in connection with the work.
   Contract was entered into July 16, approved July 31, 1903, for
construction of the two jetties. The laying of foundation mats in
the east jetty was commenced on December 31, 1903, and in the west
jetty on August 30, 1904. The work under this contract was com-
pleted on January 5, 1908.
   On account of the advance of the crest of the bar at Southwest
Pass since the date of the survey of 1898, on which the estimates for
this improvement were based, it became necessary to make provision
for increasing the length of the jetties to correspond with this advance.
This was done by supplemental contract dated July 18, 1905, the
increased cost of the jetties on this account being estimated at
$465,000. June 30, 1909, the jetties were completed; sills across
Cubits Gap, The Jump, and additions to sill across the head of Pass a
Loutre completed; coaling station and wharf at Burrwood completed;
steel frame building 30 feet by 240 feet completed, and machines and
ice plant installed therein now in operation.
   Nine of eleven principal outlets from Southwest Pass into adjacent
bays were closed by sheet-piling dams and five minor outlets closed.
   The construction of 16 dwellings and one office building was com-
menced May 5, and is still in progress.
   Dredging by contract was completed December 24, 1908, and that
by government dredges continued.
   By act of May 28, 1908, Congress authorized the use of funds from
this appropriation in dredging shoals in the river between Cubits Gap
and Iead of Passes, when necessary to secure a depth of 35 feet with
a practical width. The sum of $3,500,000 had been appropriated,
and the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $1,000,000
additional, and authorized contracts to the further amount of
$1,500,000, which was appropriated by sundry civil acts of May 27,
1908, and March 4, 1909. The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909,
appropriated $275,000 and authorized that the sum of $600,000,
or as much as may be necessary of the funds appropriated and author-
ized, be applied, in the discretion of the Secertary of War, to the
construction of a suitable dredging plant.
   In September, 1904, the available depth at mean low water was
8 feet.
   In June, 1909, there was an available depth of 35 feet throughout
the Pass except as follows: On the bar, a distance of 2,500 feet
between the 35-foot contours, with least depth of 22 feet; at mile 18,
a distance of 300 feet, with least depth of 34 feet; at mile 13, a dis-
tance of 2,500 feet, with least depth of 26 feet.
  'Usual variations of water surface, 1.5 feet.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                               441
   The length of Southwest Pass from its head to the present sea
ends of the jetties is 19 miles.
   The amount expended on this work to June 30, 1909, was
$4,590,604.99.
   The amount of money available and pledged and not covered by
contracts at the end of the fiscal year is about sufficient to cover the
cost of dredging with two dredges, expenses of administration and
inspection, and reasonable contingencies. As recognized by the Board
on Southwest Pass in its report of January 11, 1900, and as since
borne out by experience, this work is "one more than ordinarily liable
to special difficulties which do not admit of calculation, such as the
effect of storms, unfavorable foundations, and uncertain action of
the river current," and the amount of funds available for contingen-
cies should be unusually large.
   It is proposed to apply the additional appropriation asked for to the
prosecution of dredging operations, by contract and otherwise, as
may be found most economical and advantageous to the United States,
with a view of obtaining a minimum depth of 35 feet at mean low
tide, as contemplated by the original project; to the removal of the
Eads sill at the head of the pass; to the construction of the plant that
will be necessary in the maintenance of the improvement, and to the
payment of other expenses pertaining to the general work of im-
provement under the approved project.
   Rules and regulations for the navigation of Southwest Pass, Mis-
sissippi River, were prescribed May 29, 1909, by the Secretary of
War, in pursuance of the provisions of section 5 of the river and
harbor act approved March 3, 1909, to take effect and be in force on
and after July 1, 1909.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ........................................ $1, 672, 845. 32
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...........................          ..........         ........ 275, 000. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.....             330, 000. 00
Miscellaneous receipts deposited to the credit of the appropriation
  during fiscal year....................................       ...........        2, 745. 03
Transferred by Treasury Department from appropriation for repairs
  and incidental expenses of light-houses, 1909, on account of coal fur-
  nished to the Light-House Department by the Engineer Corps......                   245. 10
                                                                              2, 280, 835. 45
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement......................................................               615, 682. 16
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................          1, 665, 153. 29
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.........................................34, 056. 75
July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................           1, 631, 096. 54
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................            56, 751. 03
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........        a 600, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
   30, 1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive
   of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909..................           ...      b 950, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix S 1.)
  a This amount is estimated to construct a dredge to be used in completing the
existing project, also to be used in maintenance of the improvement.
  b Of this amount $600,000 is for continuing contract work authorized by the river
and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
442     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

   2. Maintenance and improvement of South Pass channel, Missis-
sippi River.-The act of Congress of March 3, 1875, amended by acts
of June 19, 1878, and March 3, 1879, made provision for the construc-
tion by James B. Eads, or his representatives, of jetties and other
works in South Pass to secure and maintain a channel 26 feet in depth
through the pass, and through the jetties at the mouth of the pass a
channel "twenty-six feet in depth, not less than two hundred feet in
width at the bottom, and having through it a central depth of thirty
feet without regard to width." A contract was made for the mainte-
nance of such channel for a period of twenty years.
   On January 28, 1901, this contract expired, and the work of main-
tenance is being continued under the provisions of the emergency
river and harbor act of June 6, 1900, which provides that at the ter-
mination of the contract with the representatives of the estate of
James B. Eads, deceased, the Secretary of War shall take charge of
and maintain the channel, jetties, and auxiliary works at South Pass,
for which a sum not to exceed $100,000 per year is appropriated until
otherwise provided by law.
   Additional appropriations amounting to $315,000 have since been
made for the purchase of land at South Pass, for dredging, and for
other necessary expenses to maintain the channel with the utmost
efficiency. By act of May 28, 1908, Congress authorized the use of
funds from this appropriation in dredging shoals in the river be-
tween Cubits Gap and Head of Passes, when necessary to secure a
depth of 35 feet, with a practical width.
   Dredging operations have been carried on with United States plant
and the jetties and auxiliary works have been maintained in good
condition by the addition from time to time, as required, of willows,
stone, piles, and waling timber.
   The lands along both sides of South Pass from Head of Passes to
the Gulf, containing about 6,994 acres, together with the buildings
thereon, were acquired by purchase July 8, 1903, the price paid being
 $35,000.
   Experience has shown that in order to maintain the channel with
the utmost efficiency and to meet the demands of the commerce of the
port of New Orleans the amount of the annual appropriation au-
thorized by the act of June 6, 1900, should be increased. If other
funds than the $100,000 provided by the act of June 6, 1900, had not
been available during the past fiscal year it would have been neces-
sary to suspend dredging operations and the work of maintaining the
channel would have been considerably curtailed. During the period
that it is necessary to keep South Pass open to navigation, or until
the commerce is diverted through Southwest Pass by the opening of
that channel to navigation, the annual appropriation should be at
least $180,000. It is believed that after the Southwest Pass is opened
to navigation the work of maintaining the channel through South
Pass may be discontinued.
    The sum of $1,028,412.26 was expended on this work from January
29, 1901, to June 30, 1909.
                                  RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                          443

   Comparative statement of receipts and shipments for eight years for the port of New
                                      Orleans, La.

                                                                                                                  Change in tonnage from
                                                                                                                     previous year.
                                       Calendar year.                                               Tons.

                                                                                                                   Increase.       Decrease.


1901.......................                     .........................................       ........ 4,213,869      1,440,224 ...........
1902....................           .........................................                             3,385,686 ...............          828,183
1903........... ..................                   ....................................                3,062,506............              323,180
1904... ........ ............................................... 2.853,926............                                                      208,580
1905...............................................................                                      3,478,976          625,050 .......    ..
1906............... .......................................                                              4,023,156          544,180 ..
1907 ............... ......................................                           ...............    3,527,097 ............             496,059
1908...... ... ......................................................                                    3, 088, 472 ..........             438,625



   Since the United States took charge of the maintenance of the chan-
nel, January 29, 1901, there has been a general increase in the availa-
ble navigable depth of 3 feet, the maximum draft that could be carried
on June 30, 1909, being 29 feet.
   The usual variation of level of water surface is from zero at the
mouth to 2) feet at the head of the pass, due to the stage of the river,
and from 1.1 feet at the mouth to 0.7 foot at the head, due to tide.
   No detailed data or statistics are at hand showing the effect on
freight rates of the increased depth of channel. The number of deep-
draft steamers has increased, and, being able to carry full cargoes, the
earnings and business of the port of New Orleans have increased and
the freight rates decreased. The magnitude of the commerce of the
port of New Orleans is best illustrated by the tabulated commercial
statistics above. These figures are necessarily incomplete, as it
is impracticable to secure statements covering all the receipts and
shipments for any given period. It may be safely assumed, however,
that the total greatly exceeds that shown in the above comparative
statement.
                                       APPROPRIATION               FOR FISCAL YEAR 1908.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............................                                                                  $14, 189. 18
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year ...................                                                             3, 789. 18

June 30, 1909, amount reverted to the Treasury during fiscal year.......                                                          10, 400. 00

                                       APPROPRIATION FOR FISCAL YEAR 1909.

July 1, 1908, amount appropriated by emergency river and harbor act of
  June 6, 1900 ...................                        .......................... $100, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement ....................................................                     89, 300. 60

July 1, 1909, balance unexpendcl. ..............................                                                                   10, 699. 40
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.. . ..............................                                                            2, 563. 90

July 1, 1909, balance available .................................                                                                   8, 135. 50

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .............                                                                 8, 135. 50

                                       APPROPRIATION, ACT OF MARCH 2, 1907.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................                                                             $15, 802. 17
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year .. ..............                                                               3, 517. 17
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                                                                12, 285. 00
444            REPORT         OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                              U.    S. ARMY.

MAINTENANCE          OF SOUTH PASS CHANNEL,                   MISSISSIPPI       RIVER (1909)            (SUNDRY   CIVIL
                                            ACT OF MAY 27, 1908).
July 1, 1908, balance available. ...............................               $50, 000. 00
Transferred by Treasury Department from appropriation for repairs and
  incidental expenses of light-houses, 1909, on account of services ren-
  dered by Engineer Corps in making repairs to light-house wharf and
  beacon .....................................................................       97. 45
Transferred by Treasury Department from appropriation for collecting the
  revenue from customs, 1909, on account of services rendered by the
  Engineer Corps in driving piles at customs wharf, Port Eads, La......              44. 10
                                                                                                            50, 141. 55
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement ................................................                                              22, 983. 03
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.................................                                           27, 158. 52
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...............-------------------------.........--------.......        9, 908. 52
July 1, 1909, balance available .................................                                           17, 250. 00

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..............                                        17, 250. 00

                 MAINTENANCE           OF SOUTH PASS CHANNEL, MISSISSIPPI RIVER.


Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act of March 3,
  1909 .............................................................            a$80, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available. ............................        ..........   80, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance
   unexpended July 1, 1909..........................           ....... .. a 80, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix S 2.)
   3. Examinations and surveys at South Pass, Mississippi River.-
The act of Congress approved March 3, 1875, required examinations
and surveys to be made at South Pass, Mississippi River, and reports
upon the depth of water and width of channel secured and maintained
from time to time in said channel, together with such other informa-
tion as the Secretary of War might direct. Under the terms of the
acts of August 11, 1888, and June 13, 1902, an annual appropriation
of $10,000 is made available for this work. By act of May 28, 1908,
Congress authorized the use of funds from this appropriation in
dredging shoals in the river between Cubits Gap and Head of Passes
when necessary to secure a depth of 35 feet, with a practical width.
   Up to January 29, 1901, the work of making examinations and
surveys at South Pass was carried on under the provisions of the
acts of March 3, 1875, and August 11, 1888.                                                From January 29,
1901, to June 30, 1902, examinations and surveys were made with
funds appropriated by act of June 6, 1900, for maintenance of South
Pass channel.
   Since June 30, 1902, under the act of June 13, 1902, repeated sur-
veys have been made of the shoaler localities in South Pass. Com-
plete surveys of the jetty channel and of the channel beyond the ends
of the jetties to deeper water in the Gulf were made each month
during the fiscal year. A detailed annual survey was made of the
14 miles of channel from the main river to deep water in the Gulf.
            a This amount exclusive of regular annual appropriation of $100,000.
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                              445
  Discharge measurements were made of each of three passes during
high water.
  The expenditures during the year amounted to $9,050, for services.
  The total amount expended upon this work to June 30, 1909, was
$331,272.97. These figures can not be taken as being absolutely
accurate, because the records prior to the act of June 13, 1902, are
somewhat confused and do not seem to have been kept in sufficient
separate detail to show the exact expenditure for surveys in the
early years of this improvement.       The amount given may be
accepted as within a few dollars of the actual expenditure.
Statement of expenditures on account of appropriationfor examinations and surveys at
  South Pass, Mississippi River, from July 1, 1908, to June 30, 1909, inclusive, made
  in compliance with the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902.
Services------------...------.......----...----..............----------------------$9,050.00
                           APPROPRIATION FOR FISCAL YEAR 1908.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended                   ...........................                $1, 050. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ....................................                             ........        1,050. 00
                           APPROPRIATION FOR FISCAL YEAR 1909.

July 1, 1908, amount appropriated by river and harbor act, June 13, 1902,
  for fiscal year 1909 ............................................       $10,000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year....................       8, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ............................                          ....    2, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................          ....................           2, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, total cost of operations during fiscal year ....................                10, 000. 00
Amount available for expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in
addition to the balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...............     .. a 10, 000. 00
   (See Appendix S 3.)
   4. Bayou Plaquemine, Grand River, and Pigeon bayous, Louisi-
ana.-Priorto 1867 the largest steamboats could pass through Bayou
Plaquemine into Grand Lake and other connecting water routes,
but at that time the police jury of Iberville Parish closed the bayou
by means of a dam, shutting out the waters of the Mississippi.
Grand River and Pigeon bayous were obstructed by snags, logs,
overhanging trees, and sand bars.
   The present project is based upon legislation by Congress, accord-
ing to project and estimate submitted February 11, 1887, and pro-
vides for dredging a channel in Bayou Plaquemine 60 feet wide and
6 feet deep from deep water up to the Plaquemine dike, construct-
ing a lock to connect the bayou with the Mississippi River, securing
the mouth of the bayou from further caving, and removing obstruc-
tions from Grand River and Pigeon bayous; total estimated cost,
$1,708,250, subsequently increased to $1,740,000.
   The project of 1887 was modified on April 10, 1899, to allow for
dredging Bayou Plaquemine to a depth of 10 feet and a width of
125 feet.
   The protection of the bank of the Mississippi River at the head
of the bayou was added to the improvement in 1888, and in act of
  a This amount is the regular annual appropriation authorized by the river and
harbor acts of August 11, 1888, and June 13, 1902.
446     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.


July 13, 1892, the improvement of Grand River and Pigeon bayous
was also incorporated therein.
    The act of June 3, 1896, authorized continuing contracts to be
made to complete the project of improvement not to exceed
$1,173,250, exclusive of the amounts therein and previously appro-
priated. Of this amount $1,160,000 was subsequently appropriated.
By act of March 3, 1905, $35,000 was appropriated for maintenance
of improvements, and contracts not to exceed $100,000, exclusive of
the amounts theretofore appropriated, were authorized for complet-
ing improvement. The latter amount was appropriated by sundry
civil act of June 30, 1906.
    The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $100,000
"for construction of a dredge and maintenance."
    The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, appropriated $50,000
for maintenance.
    Contract for the rectification of Bayou Plaquemine under the modi-
fied project of April 10, 1899, was made July 15, 1899. To June 30,
1909, 520,460 cubic yards of material were removed in accordance
with the terms of the contract. In addition, 16,500 cubic yards
was removed under supplemental contract from a portion of the
channel which had shoaled. A partial channel was dredged through
portions of the bayou up to the dike at the bayou approach to the
lock, and work was suspended on June 27, 1905, until the lock should
be opened to navigation. Work of dredging was resumed at the
river end of the lock April 30, 1909.
    An allotment of $75,000 was made from the appropriation of 1888
for securing the bank of the Mississippi River at the head of the
bayou. Five submerged spur dikes, placed at intervals of about 900
feet, with intervals protected by revetment, were completed in 1894.
These dikes and revetments form a continuous protection 1,400 feet
long below the site of the lock and 1,200 feet above, with an interval
of 500 feet opposite the lock site left for excavating the necessary
channel to the lock. On November 30, 1901, and January 29, 1902,
two mattresses, 400 by 600 feet and 400 by 450 feet, respectively, were
sunk in the river and heavily loaded with stone for protection of the
banks near the proposed approach to the lock.
    In 1891 a project for the construction of a lock was submitted, but
the funds available were insufficient to warrant its commencement at
that time. The Board of Engineer officers appointed to prepare plans
and specifications estimated the cost of the lock at $700,000. Revised
plans and specifications for the construction of the lock and ap-
proaches were approved October 27, 1897, and December 2, 1897, re-
spectively, and a continuing contract for the work was made May 28,
1898. The work was commenced in August, 1898. Under this
contract the floor and walls of the lock were completed, and miter
sills, inlet pipes, and snubbing hooks placed. By direction of the
Chief of Engineers the contract was annulled upon payment of the
retained percentages and other items, aggregating $24,236.41. Re-
vised plans for construction of lock gates and of the approaches to
the lock, including excavation and fill, were approved on June 11,
1903.
    For the approach to the lock 1.25 acres of land on the north side
and 0.31 acre on the south side were purchased August 24, 1900, for
$7,500.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      447
   A protection levee was built, under contract, from the northeast
corner of the lock to connect with the main levee system in front of
the lock. The work was completed August 8, 1902.
   The contract for the lock gates was completed May 5, 1906, the
gates being accepted on that date.
   The contract with the Otis Elevator Company, dated November 18,
1899, for furnishing and erecting operating machinery and power
house was completed August 31, 1906. The total cost of the work
under this contract was $114,000.
   A contract was made February 13, 1905, for constructing pro-
tection levee and making a portion of the fill behind the lock walls.
The work was commenced in March, 1905, and was completed Janu-
ary 28, 1907. The total quantity of material placed under this con-
tract was 39,940 cubic yards, costing $23,564.60.
   A contract was made June 6, 1905, for construction of the approach
at the bayou end and part of the approach at the river end of the
lock. Work under this contract was commenced on October 10, 1905,
and was completed in February, 1908. Under this contract there
were excavated and placed behind the lock walls 65,729 cubic yards
of material; 2,131 35-foot piles and 1,690 50-foot piles were driven;
9,855 cubic yards of concrete were placed in approach walls; 11 snub-
bing posts were placed; the total contract cost was $120,485.35.
   A contract was made August 7, 1906, for excavation and con-
struction of river approach and back fill of lock. Work under this
contract was commenced in September, 1906, and at the end of the
fiscal year a total of 14,600 cubic yards of earth had been moved
from the old levee and placed in the protection levee at river end;
33,688 cubic yards of earth had been excavated and placed behind the
lock walls, and 11,744 cubic yards had been excavated from the river
approach and spoiled; 1,311 50-foot piles had been furnished and
1,100 driven; 2,643 cubic yards of concrete had been placed in
approach walls, and 4,100 cubic yards of sand and gravel had been
furnished. The total amount earned by the contractor was $72,382.88,
of which $13,428.48 was expended during the fiscal year 1909.
    By supplemental agreement dated September 28, 1908, the work
of building river approach walls, and the work of driving piles, except
two pile clusters, was stopped.
    For maintaining the dredged channel through Bayou Plaquemine
and Grand River and for removing sediment from the lock chamber
the construction of a dredge was authorized by river and harbor act
of March 2, 1907. In the estimate for this work it was proposed to
expend $60,000 for the dredge and to operate same for two years at
 $15,000 per year; contingencies, $10,000.
    A board appointed in May, 1907, to examine and report concerning
this improvement recommended that the back filling behind lock and
wing walls should be completed as soon as possible; that while it was
being placed the lock walls should be tied together with steel rods
and turnbuckles, and that as soon as the back filling was completed
the lower lock gate should be calked and the lock filled with water
a.nd left so for at least a month, after which the lock should be emptied
and the gates readjusted.
    No proposals were received when bids for back filling were first
opened, September 16, 1907. Placing of tie-rods was completed in
October.
448              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                    S. ARMY.

   The Board was reconvened and renewed its recommendations that
the back filling be completed as soon as possible, and recommended
that additional tie-rods be placed in the vicinity of the quoins and
gate recesses; also that a further appropriation of $50,000 be secured,
if possible, for the completion of the lock and appurtenances.
   On March 8, 1908, a supplemental contract was made with W. O.
Burton & Co. for the back filling, which was commenced March 17
and completed April 28. A total of 24,203 cubic yards was placed,
at a cost of $22,992.85.
   On February 24, 1908, a contract was made with A. Baldwin & Co.
for the extra tie-rods and turnbuckles, delivery to be completed
March 17. The turnbuckles were not delivered until April 25, when
the back filling was practically completed, and therefore the extra
rods were not placed.
   The calking of the lower gate was completed May 11, and pumping
water into the lock commenced next day. It soon became apparent
that the leakage under, around, and through the gate was so excessive
that the dredge could not alone fill the lock, and two 18-inch siphons
were installed. Later a cut was made in the levee and two 15-inch
and one 18-inch pi:e -laced therein in order to allow direct flow of
water from the Mississippi River into the forebay of the lock. On
June 9 the depth of water in the lock was 43 feet, and this depth was
maintained during the month for the water test recommended by the
Board of Engineer officers.
   This test was completed July 10, 1908, and the lock was unwatered,
cleaned, and the gates readjusted. Water was let into the lock from
the bayou on March 5, 1909, and from the river on March 12.
   The sum of $1,704,224.45 had been expended on this improvement
to June 30, 1909, including $1,000 withdrawn by the Chief of Engi-
neers June 20, 1901,'for office expenses, and $43.06, Treasury settle-
ments April 13, 1908, and February 23, 1909, for transportation,
and also including $32,318.15 expended in back filling and testing
the lock in accordance with the recommendations of the Board of
Engineers. Of the total amount it is estimated $17,371.66 was
applied to the maintenance of the improvement.
   The amount estimated for expenditure in the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1911, is intended for maintenance of channel depths in the
bayou by dredging and snagging.
                     Comparative statement of receipts and shipmentsfor ten years.

                                                                                                            Change in tonnage from
                                                                                                                previous year.
                                    Calendar year.                                             Tons.
                                                                                                              Increase.       Decrease.

1899 ................................                                  .......................          111,750        22,449 ....
1900..............                    ...............................................                    88,543 ...............           23,207
1901................................................................                                    283,000       194,457 .. ....
1902.............................. ................................                                     292,000          9,000 ............
1903... .........................         .............                                                 302,500        10,500 ...........
1904 ........ .........................                                                                 318,000        15,500...........
1905..... .... ....... ....................                                         .................. 706,000        388,000 ............
1906............... .........................                                        ...................
                                                                                                     .  572,000 ............ 134000
1907.............................                 ..... ................................                534,744 ............              37.256
1908..... ......... ............                  .............................                 ....    553,916        19,172 ..
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       449

   On page 441, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908,
reference is made to reports on examinations and surveys of this
stream.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............                 .................. a $275, 775. 83
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 .................     ...............................                 50, 000. 00
                                                                                    325, 775. 83
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ............................      b $70, 000. 28
    June 30 1909, amount reverting to Treasury and de-
      posited to the credit of the appropriation for operating
      and care of canals, etc .......................                 169. 13
                                                                                      70, 169. 41
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................              255, 606. 42
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................             15, 453. 34
July 1, 1909, balance available......................................               240, 153.08
July 1., 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................              140, 431. 05
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance
   unexpended July 1, 1909.......-...........--..--.................                  10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1907, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix S 4.)
   5. Bayou Teche, Louisiana.-Bayou Teche is an important com-
mercial stream of southern Louisiana, and finds its outlet into the
Gulf of Mexico through Atchafalaya River. Prior to improvement
it had a depth of 8 feet to St. Martinville, La., but navigation was
rendered dangerous by numerous obstructions. Above St. Martin-
ville the bayou was navigable by steamboats during high water. The
project of 1870 provided for removal of obstructions from the head
to the mouth of the bayou. Work under this project was carried
on from 1870 to 1886, the stream being cleared of logs, snags, wrecks,
overhanging trees, and a number of bars. The improvement was not
permanent and other obstructions formed.
   The project of 1891 provided for the removal of obstructions be-
tween St. Martinville, La., and the mouth of the bayou, a distance of
about 80 miles. Work under this project has been carried on since
1891, obstructions being removed as appropriations were made.
   The project was modified by the river and harbor act approved
March 2, 1907, with a view to obtaining a 6-foot navigation to
a Balance unexpended from appropriations for improving Bayou
  Plaquemine......                                  ...........................    $273, 093. 98
Balance unexpended from appropriations for operating and care of
  canals, etc ..................................................                       2, 681. 85

       Total balance..................    .........................                  275, 775. 83

bAmount expended from appropriations for improving Bayou Plaque-
  mine:
   As per vouchers...................................              $67, 483. 20
   Treasury settlement ....            ...........................        4. 36
                                                                                      67, 487. 56
Amount expended from appropriation for operating and care of canals,
etc......                        ..........   ................      ..                2.............
                                                                                       2, 512. 72

                                                                                      70, 000. 28
       9001-ENG 1909---29
450                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                              S. ARMY.

Arnaudville, in accordance with the report submitted in House Docu-
ment No. 527, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session, at an estimated
cost of $111,000, by dredging, removal of snags, etc., and construction
of a lock. The expenditure for a 6-foot navigation to Arnaudville
is contingent upon all lands necessary for lock and dam purposes and
canal feeders being deeded to the United States free of cost and upon
the United States being secured against possible claims for damages
resulting from the overflow of lands by reason of the lock and dam
improvement or from the draining of Spanish Lake.
   To guarantee the United States against any claims for overflow,
bonds were issued by municipalities in St. Martins Parish to the
amount of $10,000, but it was decided by the Acting Judge-Advocate-
General that such bonds w:re invalid. An effort was made to secure
bonds from responsible bonding companies, but bonds in perpetuity
could not be obtained. The conditions of the act are now under
consideration by the Judge-Advocate-General and Engineer Depart-
ment, and it is probable that some way of fulfilling the requirement
will be decided upon to permit the work to be started.
   Proportion of the project completed: To June 30, 1909, no work of
construction had begun. The maximum draft that can be carried is
4 feet. The variations of water level between high and low water is
12 feet (exceptional floods not included).
   A deed of the land required for lock and canal feeders was forwarded
to theAttorney-General for opinion as to the validity of title. It was
returned approved April 23, 1909, and was recorded May 1, 1909, in
Book No. 70, pages 559-563, at St. Martinville, in the parish of St.
Martin, La.
   To June 30, 1909, $97,567.76 had been expended upon this work,
of which $10,733.46 was for maintenance and $4,293.53 for expenses
of resurvey of the bayou and $82,540.77 for works of improvement.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was about
4 feet. The usual variation of level of water surface is not defi-
nitely known.
   The bayou is navigable to St. Martinville, 75 miles from its mouth.
The effect of the project on freight rates is not positively known.
   It is proposed to apply the appropriation recommended to dredging
shoals and removing obstructions in the channel as far up as the
proposed site of the lock, 3 miles below St. Martinville, La., and
to removal of snags, overhanging trees, and other obstructions above
that point and the construction of the lock and dam.

                           Comparative statement of receipts and shipmentsfor ten years.

                                                                                                                          Change in tonnage from
                                                                                                                              previous year.
                                             Calendar year.                                                    Tons.

                                                                                                                           Increase.       Decrease.


1899.............................................................                                              272,975 ..........     ...          13,116
1900 ..............                  ...................                  ..   ..................              212,109 ............                60,866
1901..........................                    .............................                     ........   335,583        123,474 .........
1902......................                                     ..........    ...................               404, 454         68,871...........
1903.............                         .....................................             .............      450,542          46,0 8 ...........
1904.... .......        ......          ..................................                                     362,706 ............           87,836
1905................................................................                                           701,243         338,537 ........
1906........        ..................................... .......                                              706,091            4,848.
1907...................        ........................... ....... .........                                   580,216 ............         125,875
1908.....................................................................                                      515,679 ............           64,537
                                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                    451
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....... ................ ...........    a $130, 510. 72
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909............................       .................. ..      5, 000. 00
                                                                                              135, 510. 72
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement .........................................           .....       ........           a 1, 578. 48

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................              ................            a 133, 932. 24
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .........         ...............           ........          150. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available........-....-........ ..                ............          133, 782.24
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                          40, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
   the balance unexpended July 1, 1909 .....................        ......                      60, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix S 5.)
   6. Inland waterway from Franklin to Mermentau, La.-The proj-
ect for this waterway was adopted by Congress March 2, 1907,
and provides for a channel 5 feet deep and 40 feet bottom width, with
appropriate side slopes. The channel proposed was to run from
Bayou Teche near Franklin, La., to Cote Blanche and Vermilion bays
by a dredged canal and existing drainage canals or bayous, thence
up Schooner Bayou, thence by a dredged canal to White Lake; across
White Lake, thence by a dredged canal to Grand Lake and across this
lake to Lake Misere, west of the Mermentau River, at an estimated
cost of $289,292, with an estimated cost for maintenance of $20,000
per year. The construction of a lock at a suitable point between
Vermilion Bay and White Lake has been found necessary for the
purpose of regulating the flow through the canal with a view to
preventing damage to rice lands by reason of contamination of the
waters of White Lake by salt water.
   The act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $89,292, and contracts were
authorized to complete the project not to exceed $200,000, all of
which has since been appropriated.
   Under the general project the right of way must be furnished with-
out cost to the United States.
   The proposed waterway must cross the right of way of the Southern
Pacific Railroad, and a bridge for the service of the railroad will be
necessary. The War Department has decided that the cost of this
bridge must be borne by the United States.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $14,183.02, for inspec-
tions of the various routes and for surveys and dredging.
   The available balance and the appropriation recommended for the
fiscal year 1911 will be applied to completion of dredging and main-
tenance of improvement, in accordance with the.adopted project.
   The report on the examination of the inland-waterway channel is
printed in House Document No. 640, Fifty-ninth Congress, second
session.

   a These amounts include expenditures from and balance unexpended of allotment
of $500 made January 11, 1908, from emergency appropriation of March 2, 1907:
Improving Bayou Teche................................................    $1, 540. 77
Emergency..........................................................           37. 71
452          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                              S. ARMY.

   A change of the route between Vermilion Bay and the Teche was
authorized by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
   The field work on preliminary examinations and surveys for deter-
mining the best route for this section of the canal were completed on
June 11, but the selection of the route for this portion of the canal
is so intimately connected with that for the deeper canal, for which
Congress authorized a survey by the river and harbor act of March 3,
1909, that it must necessarily be practically determined by the latter.
It would be poor policy to locate the 5-foot canal on a line which would
not permit its subsequent enlargement to the 9-foot canal proposed.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................... $182, 377.08
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 100, 000. 00
Receipts from sales of blueprints during fiscal year ....................                           5. 50

                                                                                             282, 382. 58
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .........................   . $7, 262. 44
    Amount withdrawn through Treasury settlement........         5. 66
                                                                                               7, 268. 10
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                       275, 114. 48
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                        796. 32

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                        274, 318.16
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                         66, 976. 88

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909................             ..-------------------------------------    25, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix S 6.)
  7. Mouth and passes of Calcasieu River, Louisiana.-Priorto im-
provement there existed a depth of 6 feet over the outer bar at the
entrance to Calcasieu Lake. The lake was 15 miles in length, with
a depth of 6 feet. The depth of water over the inner bars was 31
feet, and from the upper bar to Lake Charles, La., the river was not
less than 8 feet deep.
   Under the original project of 1872, with the modification of 1881,
a channel 8 feet in depth, 70 feet wide, and 7,500 feet in length was
cut through the inner bars during 1874, 1882, and 1883; but this
channel having shoaled to 31 feet, it was redredged in 1886, under
the project of that year, and a plank revetment to provide against
refilling was commenced. The noncompletion of this revetment
caused the refilling of the channel. There was expended on this
project $54,158.86.
   The project adopted by the act of September 19, 1890, provides
for the redredging of a channel 8 feet in depth through the inner bars
and revetting this channel, to construct parallel jetties of brush and
stone at the entrance to the outer pass, and to dredge a channel
between these jetties to a depth of 12 feet, if necessary. The total
estimated cost of the jetties was $600,000.
   Under this project the revetment was completed in August, 1893.
A channel 8 feet deep and 50 feet wide, connecting deep water in
Calcasieu Pass and Lake, was dredged in 1894, 1895, and 1898. Con-
atruction of the east jetty was carried on in 1894, 1895, and 1896,
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     453

and of the west jetty in 1897. In 1900 the foundation of the west
jetty was extended 1,000 feet, making its total length 3,200 feet.
   By May, 1905, the channel, dredged to a depth of 8 feet in 1903
through the inner pass, had shoaled to less than 4 feet, and the
revetment placed for protection of this channel had almost entirely
disappeared.
   The channel through the outer pass between the jetties had a
depth at low tide of about 10 feet, which is ample for the present
needs of navigation, considering the condition of channel through the
inner pass.
   Under the project for expenditure of amount appropriated by act
of March 3, 1905, a survey was made from the mouth of the river to
the outer pass; the channel at the inner pass was redredged to a
depth of 7 feet and width of 100 feet for a length of 24,000 feet; the
channel at the mouth of the river was redredged to a depth of 7 feet
and width of 100 feet for a length of 10,000 feet; the entire channel
through the lake was marked by creosoted pile clusters, 54 in number,
at intervals of 1,500 feet; and the revetment at lower end of lake
 (inner pass) was rebuilt for a length of 8,230 feet. Dredging and
marking channel were completed, under contract, August 25, 1906,
and repairs to revetment April 6, 1907.
   Project for maintenance of the improvement was adopted in act of
March 2, 1907.
   It is proposed to apply available funds toward the construction of
a combined dredge and snag boat and to the operation of the dredge
for the maintenance of the authorized depths in the channels at the
mouth and passes of the river. On June 30, 1909, this boat was
three-fourths completed.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $636,477.99. Of this
amount $582,319.13 has been expended under the present project,
of which it is estimated that $120,577.81 was applied to maintenance;
$0.45 was derived from refundment of overpayment, and $2.50 from
sales of blueprints. The expenditures during the past fiscal year were
for collection of commercial statistics, construction and inspection of
boat.
    The approved project provides for a channel depth of 8 feet through
the bars at the head and foot of the lake, but the maximum depth in
the lake is only about 7 feet. On June 30, 1909, the maximum draft
that could be carried at mean low water through the shoalest part of
the channel in Lake Calcasieu was 6 feet, and the usual variation of
the water surface is about 1 foot.
   The head of navigation in the Calcasieu River is at Jones Bluff,
about 58 miles above its mouth, or 28 miles above Lake Charles, La.,
the depth in the channel being not less than 12 feet. The river
empties into Calcasieu Lake, the length of the navigable channel
through which is about 17 miles. Calcasieu Pass is about 6 miles
long and connects Calcasieu Lake with the Gulf of Mexico, the least
depth in the channel being about 10 feet.
   The only information obtained as to the effect of the project on
freight rates is statements from the secretary of the state railroad
commission and from the general freight agent of the Southern
Pacific Railroad, that Lake Charles and other points on this river
enjoy benefits in the way of reduced freight rates, due to the fact that
they are situated on navigable water.
454            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                     S. ARMY.

  The amount estimated for expenditure in the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1911, is intended for maintaining the authorized depths by
dredging, and necessary repairs to accessory structures.
                 Comparative statement of receipts and shipments for ten years.

                                                                                                          Change in tonnage from
                                                                                                              previous year.
                                                                                             Tons.
                                                                                                            Increase.       Decrease.

Year ending May 31, 1899 ................                ......................               174,651     ............            15, 366
Calendar year-
    1900..............                 ................             ........................... 139.580 ..                ....
    1901.............................................                                              139,045 ............                535
    1902.....          ...........................................                                 148,483            9,438.........
    1903.........................................                                   .......... .   194,155          45,672 ..........
    1904..............................................                                             226,216          32,061...........
    1905........................................................                                   295,067          68,851 ...........
    1906 ........................................................                                  314,235          19,168 ...
    1907..................                   . ........................................            355,795          41,50 ...........
    1908. ..........                                               .........................
                                                  .................................          ..... 360,252            4,457 ...



   On page 402, Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1906, refer-
ence is made to previous reports on examinations and surveys of this
river.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. .................................     $24, 928.78
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 .......................................................   8, 000. 00

                                                                                 32, 928. 78
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of im-
  provement ........................................              ..................4, 903. 82

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                                                   28, 024. 96
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ......................................                                                  486.93

July 1, 1909, balance available....................................                                                       27, 538.03

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................                                                       3,413. 34
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909....................................................                                                   8,000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897. and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix S 7.)
   8. Bogue Chitto, Chefuncte River, Bogue Falia, Tickfaw River and
tributaries, Amite River, and Bayou Manchac, Louisiana. (a) Bogue
Chitto.-Originallynavigation on this stream was impeded by snags,
logs, and overhanging trees throughout its entire length, except dur-
ing very high stages of water. The minimum width of channel was
80 feet and the least depth of water 3 feet.
   The present project, adopted in 1890, provided for securing and
maintaining a channel 3 feet deep from the mouth of the river to
Alford's bridge, near Summit, Miss., a distance of about 100 miles,
by closing the west mouth and several small run-out bayous, and
by the removal of obstructions and overhanging trees, at an estimated
cost of $55,000.
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              455

   Owing to the inadequacy of appropriations it has been possible to
carry the above project only as far as Cross River, about 80 miles,
which distance had to be cleared periodically to maintain the improve-
ment. On June 30, 1900, the condition of the river permitted of navi-
gation by light-draft boats from the mouth of the river to Cross River.
Subsequent operations have been for maintenance.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $27,842.54, of which
amount it is estimated $12,929.94 was applied to maintenance.
   Bogue Chitto is navigable in fact for a distance of about 84 miles
from its mouth. The only advantage derived from the expenditures
for improvement of the stream was the facilitating of the rafting of
logs and timber. The maximum draft that could be carried on June
30, 1906, was about 2 feet. The usual variation in level of the water
surface between high and low water is about 11 feet. The secretary
of the railroad commission of Louisiana has stated that points on this
stream have no reduction in freight rates on account of water com-
petition.
   The commerce consists mainly of the rafting of logs and timber for
the surrounding sawmills. No boats ply regularly on this stream.
   Bogue Chitto is not considered worthy of further improvement, the
results accomplished by previous expenditures being sufficient for the
needs of the commerce on the stream, and in compliance with section
7, river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, discontinuance of appropria-
tions is recommended. There were no operations during the year.
   On page 394, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, ref-
erence is made to reports on examinations and surveys of this stream.
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........   $30,000.00
   (b) C'hefuncte River and Bogue Falia.-Priorto improvement of
Chefuncte River, a bar, with a depth of only 4 feet of water, ob-
structed the entrance to the mouth of the river. From this point to
its junction with the Bogue Falia, a distance of 10 miles, the river
was from 300 to 800 feet in width, with a channel of 15 feet in depth,
navigable for steamers and sailing vessels, but obstructed by snags
and overhanging trees. Above this point the stream is not navi-
gable.
   Bogue Falia was navigable for small steamers from point of junc-
tion with the Chefuncte to Grants Landing, 4 miles above; for sail-
ing vessels drawing 5 feet or less, to Covington, 2 miles farther;
obstructed by snags and overhanging trees. Not navigable beyond
Covington.
   The original project of 1880 provided for dredging through the
bar at the mouth of the Chefuncte River, and for the removal of all
obstructions between its mouth and Covington on the Bogue Falia,
at an estimated cost of $5,460. It was modified in 1884 to permit
of the construction of a breakwater to protect the channel dredged
across the bar at the mouth of the Chefuncte River. Estimated
cost, $1,500.
   For an account of the improvements under original project and
modification, see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1896,
page 1485. Subsequent operations have been for maintenance.
   It is proposed to apply the available funds toward the construction
of a combined dredge and snag boat and to the operation of said
boat for the removal of bars and such snags, logs, and overhanging
456              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                 TJ. S. ARMY.


trees as interfere with navigation between Covington and the mouth
of the river. On June 30, 1909, this boat was three-fourths com-
pleted.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $16,970.06, of which
$10,470.06 was applied to maintenance. The expenditures during
the past fiscal year were for commercial statistics, construction and
inspection of boat.
   On June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that could be carried over
the bar at the mouth of the Chefuncte River was 7 feet, the expendi-
tures for improvement having resulted in an increase of 2 feet in
depth and 60 feet in width. The head of navigation is Covington on
the Bogue Falia, about 16 miles by river from Lake Pontchartrain.
The upper part of the stream is so crooked that boats 200 feet long
can run only 12 miles up the river and boats 110 feet long only 15
miles. The variation in level of water surface between high and low
tide is usually about 1 foot, although winds may make a variation
of as much as 3 feet.
   The only information obtained as to the effect of the project on
freight rates is a statement from the secretary of the state railroad
commission that Covington has reduced rates on account of the
navigation on that river. The amount estimated for expenditure in
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, is intended for dredging and
snagging operations and maintenance of improvement.
   On page 395, Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1906, refer-
ence is made to previous reports on examinations and surveys of
these streams.
                     Comparative statement of receipts and shipments for ten years.

                                                                                                                             Change in tonnage
                                                                                                                              from previous year.
                                                                                                                 Tons.

                                                                                                                              Increase.      Decrease.

Year ending May 31. 1899................                          .   ....     ....................               97,789 ...........                1,716
Calendar year-
    1899.............................                         .                .................                 156,500 .................
    1900...................................                                  .....................                86,856 ............              69,644
    1901.......................                                         ......................                    92,874               6,018.........
    1902...............................-                                ...-----              -...............   100,768            7,894 ............
    1904-.......................................................                            -184,099                              83,331 ..........
    1905......................................                                        ...................        222,494          38,395 .........
    1906...........                      .....................................                                   235,727          13,233    ............
    1907........                       .............................................................             221,177 ............                14,550
    1908-.......................................................                                                 247,887          26,710 ......


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.............................               ........ $8, 264. 02
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........................................ ..........................    2, 000. 00
                                                                                                                                            10, 264. 02
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement................ ............................................                                                                    4, 428. 09

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................................                                                                      5, 835. 93
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...............................                                                                            505. 54

July 1, 1909, balance available .........................................                                                                     5, 330. 39

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................                                                                            846. 67
                            RIVER A1ND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          457
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...............................................--------------------------------------------   (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Tick faw River and tributaries, Louisiana.-These streams the
Tickfaw, Blood, Natalbany, and Ponchatoula rivers-had a 9-foot
channel, navigable for steamers and schooners for an aggregate dis-
tance of 38 miles, but obstructed by snags, logs, and overhanging
trees.
   The original project, adopted in 1881, provided for the removal of
obstructions as far as appropriations would permit; estimated cost,
$10,230. The existing project is for maintenance of improvement,
and under these two projects the work has been carried on since 1881.
   All obstructing deadheads were removed from the channel from the
mouth of the Tickfaw River to Springfield on the Natalbany, and a
channel was dredged across a point, which had been a serious obstruc-
tion to navigation, just above Springfield.
   It is proposed to apply available funds toward the construction of a
combined dredge and snag boat and to the operation of this boat for
the removal of bars and such snags, logs, and overhanging trees as
interfere with navigation. On June 30, 1909, the boat was three-
fourths completed.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $18,583.61, of which
it is estimated $10,468.12 was applied to maintenance. The expendi-
tures during the past fiscal year were for collection of commercial
statistics, construction, and inspection of boat.
   On June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that could be carried over
the bar at the mouth of the Tickfaw River at mean low water was 6
feet. There is at all times water enough in the river to accommodate
a draft of 10 feet. The usual tidal variation of level of water surface
is about 6 inches, but winds effect a variation of from 1 to 2 feet.
   Tickfaw River is navigable in fact to Kemps Landing, about 18
miles from its mouth in Lake Maurepas; Blood River to S. Tuckers
Landing, about 4 miles; Natalbany River to the parish bridge just
above Springfield, La., about 12 miles; Ponchatoula River to Wades-
boro, La., about 5 miles. The expenditures for improvement have
been confined to the removal of snags, logs, and other obstructions.
   No railroad reaches these streams at any point where navigable
and there is no competition in freight rates.
   The amount estimated for expenditure in the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1911, is intended for dredging and snagging operations and
maintenance of improvement.
   On page 397, Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1906, refer-
ence is made to previous reports on examinations and surveys of
these streams.
                          a See consolidated money statement on page 460.
458                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                                      S. ARMY.

                            Comparative statement of receipts and shipmentsfor ten years.

                                                                                                                                                   Change in tonnage
                                                                                                                                                   from previous year.
                                                                                                                                    Tons.

                                                                                                                                                  Increase.       Decrease.

Year ending May 31, 1899....                            ..............                      .....               .....
                                                                                                           .......                     52,961 .................           22,681
Calendar year-
    1899........................................................                                                                       9,300.........         ..........
    1900........................................................                                                                      55,540 ............                 23,700
    1901.....................                           ..................................                                            56,464              924 ...........
    1902...........................................................                                                                   45,632 ............                 10,832
                                                      ......
    1904............. ........... ........................... 86,302       40,670 .........
    1905.. ............... .........                      ... 45, 429 ............
                                 ..............................                             40,873
    1906........................                                         .      ........................                               34,690 ...............             10,739
    1907................................                                     ...........        ...............                        44,350           9,660 .........
    1908..............                  ........          ..........            .........       ....       ..... ...... ......         41,101    .............             3,249


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................ ....................    $6, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ........................................................  2, 000.00

                                                                                                                                                                  8,000.00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .................................................                                                                                                   4, 426.15
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                                                                                            3, 573. 85
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                                                                                          505. 54

July 1, 1909, balance available ...........                                                                  ............................                         3, 068. 31

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts...................                                                                                             846. 66
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909............................................                                                                                                    (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (d) Amite River and Bayou Manchac, Louisiana.-Prior to im-
provement the Amite River was navigable for small steamers for a
distance of 45 miles from its mouth and Bayou Manchac for a dis-
tance of 10 miles, but both streams were obstructed by snags, logs,
and overhanging trees.
   The original project, as adopted in 1880 and modified in 1883 and
1888, provided for the removal of obstructions in Bayou Manchac
from Hope Villa to the Amite River and in the latter stream to
Lake Maurepas (its mouth), at an estimated cost of $31,760.
   Amite River was improved for a distance of 42 miles from its
mouth and Bayou Manchac for a distance of 10 miles from its junc-
tion with the former stream. A turning basin was made at the upper
limit of improvement in Bayou Manchac.
   The work of maintenance has been carried out under the project of
1892 and subsequent projects.
   The improvement is not considered permanent, as snags and logs
will continue to accumulate and bars will continue to form at the
mouths of the streams, thus obstructing navigation.
   It is proposed to apply the available funds toward the construction
of a combined dredge and snag boat and to the operation of the boat
                                        a See consolidated money statement on page 460.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     459
for the removal of bars and such snags, logs, and overhanging trees
as interfere with navigation. On June 30, 1909, this boat was three-
fourths completed.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $46,924.22, of which it is
estimated $22,023.50 was applied to maintenance. The expendi-
tures during the past fiscal year were for collection of commercial
statistics, construction, and inspection of boat.
   On June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that could be carried at
mean low water over the bar in Lake Maurepas at the mouth of the
river was 6 feet. The usual tidal variation at mouth of river is 6
inches; the level of water surface in Bayou Manchac varies as much
as 6 feet. Amite River is navigable in fact to the mouth of Bayou
Manchac, a distance of 42 miles, and Bayou Manchac is navigable to
Hope Villa, a distance of 10 miles.
   The only information obtained as to the effect of the project on
freight rates is a statement from the secretary of the state railroad
commission that Hope Villa, on Bayou Manchac, has been granted a
special tariff, with rates lower than normal ones.
   The amount estimated for expenditure in the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1911, is intended for dredging and snagging operations and
maintenance of improvement.
   On page 398, Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1906, refer-
ence is made to previous reports on examinations and surveys of
these streams.
                  Comparative statement of receipts and shipments for ten years.

                                                                                        Change in tonnage
                                                                                        from previous year.
                                                                             Tons.

                                                                                       Increase.     Decrease.

Year ending May 31,1899..........................................             60,305       5,556 .........
Calendar year-
                                             ....
    1899......................................     ..............       59,850 ....
    1900.................................................  ..........   25,400 ...........     34,450
    1901.............. ..........................................69,918             44,518 ...........
    1902............  .........................................   ..... 44,694 ............    25,224
    1904................................. ....................... 120,851           76,157 ..........
                                                                        43,371............
    1905.....................................................................................  77,480
    1906............................. ....... .................... 50,669            7,298 ..
    1907................................................................45,552 ............     5,117
    1908....................                                            43,558.............
                          ---............................................                       1,994


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................................            $20, 211. 33
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3,1909....................................                            1,000.00
                                                                 ............................
                                                                                                   21, 211. 33
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...................................   .................                                4, 641.54

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                                16, 569. 79
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                             505. 54

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                            16, 064. 25
460            REPORT           OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                     U.     S. ARMY.

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..................                                              $3, 430. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.....-------------------------------------------(a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                                      CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended--.....-------.........------...........----------..-------......                    34, 475. 35
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..--------------....-------.............-........-----------..................---------------......    5, 000. 00

                                                                                                                     39, 475. 35
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ................. ............ . ...   ..........-  ...                                                13,495.78

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                                              25, 979. 57
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...........................................                                     1, 516. 62

July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................                                                  24, 462.95

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................                                                 5, 123. 33
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.....................................         .......                                           10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix S 8.)
   9. Channel, bay, and passes of Bayou Vermilion, and Mermentau
River and tributaries, Louisiana-(a) Channel, bay, and passes of
Bayou Vermilion.-Prior to improvement the upper 12 miles of
Bayou Vermilion was only 2 feet deep, and its lower portion, through
the bay and passes, not less than 51 feet deep, and had a width varying
from 100 to 400 feet. The channel, however, was obstructed by snags,
logs, and overhanging trees.
   The original project, adopted in 1880, provided for the removal of
snags and for dredging at an estimated cost of $9,900. A modified
project, adopted in 1892, provided for securing a navigable depth of
5 feet up to the railroad bridge near Lafayette, La., and for the
erection of guide piling to mark the channel from the mouth of the
bayou to Vermilion Bay, a distance of about 5 miles, at an estimated
cost of $25,000. Project for maintenance was adopted in 1905.
   The improvement is not considered permanent, as obstructions will
continue to form and must be periodically removed.
   It is proposed to apply the available funds toward the construction
of a combined dredge and snag boat and to the operation of said boat
for the removal of bars and such snags, logs, and overhanging trees
as interfere with navigation. On June 30, 1909, the boat was three-
fourths completed.
   Operations were carried on by the steamer Hyacinth between June
11 and 18, 1908, for the removal of snags and other obstructions below
Abbeville, La.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $40,784.16, of which
amount $30,884.16 has been expended for maintenance. The ex-
penditures during the past fiscal year were for collection of commer-
cial statistics and construction and inspection of boat.
                            a See consolidated money statement on this page.
                                                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               461
  On June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that could be carried over
the bar at mouth of Bayou Vermilion was about 3 feet and in the
upper part of the stream 22 feet. The usual tidal variations at mouth
of bayou is about 1 foot and in upper part about 18 inches.                                                                     The
bayou is navigable to D. O. Broussard's landing, about 20 miles above
Abbeville, La., or 46 miles from mouth, although it is obstructed by
snags and logs.
   The only information obtained as to the effect of the project on
freight rates is a statement from the secretary of the state railroad
commission that at Abbeville there are lower rates than to inter-
mediate points, on account of its being located on navigable water.
  The amount estimated for expenditure in the fical year ending
June 30, 1911, is intended for dredging and snagging operations.

                               Comparative statement of receipts and shipments for ten years.

                                                                                                     Change in tonnage from
                                                                                                         previous year.
                                                                                           Tons.

                                                                                                     Increase.       Decrease.


Year ending May 31, 1899 ...................................                                14,969        6,107 ..........
Calendar year-
     1900................                 .................................. ........       21,150        6,181 .........
     1901 ...............................                    .........................      31,385       10,235.........
     1902............................................                   .          .....    37,000        5,615 .......
     1903..........................................................                         15,157 .............                21,843
     1904...................................  ...................                           29,326        14,169 ..
     1905.......................
                             ..................................                             28,092 ............                  1,234
     1906..................................................                      ..         32,025        3,933    ..........
     1907.......................................      ..................                    37,515      5,490 ..
     1908         ....................................................   .......            26,589 ............                 10,926



   On page 399, Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1906, refer-
ence is made to previous reports on examinations and surveys of this
stream.
   Reports on preliminary examination and survey to Lafayette with
a view to obtaining 6 feet of water, required by act of March 2, 1907,
were submitted on January 21 and August 10, 1908, and are printed
in House Document No. 1218, Sixtieth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ............................           $7, 029. 56
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 . . . ..................................................  2, 500. 00

                                                                                                                      9, 529.56
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement...................... .... ..........................                                                  4, 713. 72

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                                                  4, 815. 84
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................                                                486.93

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                                                4, 328.91

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                                                     817. 50

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 ..      ........      ....................                                                           (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
     1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                          a See consolidated money statement on page 463.
462      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

     (b) Mermentau River and tributaries, Louisiana.-Prior to im-
provement these streams had depths varying from 7 to 30 feet. The
channel through Grand Lake was 6 feet deep, and the depth at the
mouth of the river was about 13 feet. The width varies from 70 feet,
near Viterboville, to 350 feet at Lake Arthur. The channel was
crooked and obstructed by snags and logs.
     The original project of 1892 provided for the removal of obstruc-
tions in the upper river and the construction of brush dams in the
lower river to remove existing mud flats. The estimated cost was
 $23,615.25.
     With the appropriations of 1892, 1894, and 1896 operations were
carried on from December, 1892, to December, 1899, and 38 miles of
the channel, from the lower end of Lake Arthur downstream, was
cleared of obstructions; two brush dams, 2,500 and 3,000 feet in
length, respectively, were built in Mud Lake, and a channel 8 feet in
depth and 50 feet in width was cut across the flats in Mud Lake and
maintained as the exigencies of navigation required.
    An examination made in July, 1906, showed that Bayou Nezpique,
the principal tributary, was obstructed with snags and logs and that
dredging would probably be required for maintenance of the channel
through Grand Lake and Lower Mud Lake. Operations were com-
menced in Bayou Nezpique with a hired plant on August 21, 1906,
and were completed on October 6, 1906. All obstructing snags and
'logs were removed from the channel for a distance of 21 miles below
Viterboville, La.
     It is proposed to apply the available funds toward the construction
of a combined dredge and snag boat and to the operation of this boat
for the removal of such bars, snags, logs, and overhanging trees as
interfere with navigation. On June 30, 1909, this boat was three-
fourths completed.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $32,504.13, of which it
is estimated that $15,787.65 was applied to maintenance. The expend-
itures during the past fiscal year were for collection of commercial
statistics, construction and inspection of boat.
    On June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that could be carried over
the flats in Lower Mud Lake, the shoalest place in the channel, was
4 feet at mean low water. The usual variation of the level of water
surface in the lower reaches of the river is about 11 feet, and the
extreme variation is about 21 feet. Mermentau River is navigable
throughout its whole length to about 2 miles above Mermentau, a dis-
tance of about 70 miles; Bayou Nezpique, the principal tributary, is
navigable to Viterboville, La., a distance of about 25 miles above the
head of the Mermentau River; Bayou Plaquemine Brule and Bayou
des Cannes are each navigable for distances of about 10 miles, and
Bayou Queue de Tortue for about 12 miles.
     The only information obtained as to the effect of the project on
freight rates is a statement from the secretary of the state railroad
commission that at Mermentau there are lower rates than at inter-
mediate points, on account of its being located on navigable water.
    The amount estimated for expenditure in the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1911, is intended for dredging and snagging operations.
                                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                             463
                             Comparative statement of shipments and receipts for ten years.


                                                                                                                                    Change in tonnage
                                                                                                                                   from previous year.
                                                                                                                   Tons.

                                                                                                                                 Increase.         Decrease.

Year ending May 31, 1899...................................                                                          22,236             3,586.........
Calendar year-
     1900.         .........................                                    ..................                   27,034 ...................
     1901             ...........................................................                                    29,291              2,257
     1902..........................................................                                                  50,326           21,035 .........
     1903 ..........................................                                                                 63,690          13,364 ..........
     1904................................                                                 ...................        45,866 ............           17,824
     1905.........                 ..........                     ...............................                    42,413 ............            3,453
     1906........ ...............................................                                                    61,634          19,221 ..
     1907 ...................................................................                                        49,756 .............          11,878
     1908................................                                      ........................              44,382 ...............         5,374



   On page 401, Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1906, refer-
ence is made to previous reports on examinations and surveys of this
stream.
   Reports of examination with plan and estimate of cost of improve-
ment of Bayou Plaquemine Brule, required by act of March 2, 1907,
were submitted December 19, 1907, and February 8, 1908, and are
printed in House Document No. 789, Sixtieth Congress, first session.
   The act of March 3, 1909, calls for a preliminary examination of
Bayou Queue de Tortue, report on which will be submitted for
transmission to Congress at its next session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.. .................................              $18, 068. 53
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 .......................        .................     .... .......   1, 500. 00

                                                                                                                                                  19., 568. 53
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...................................................                                                                                  4, 657.41

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                                                                            14, 911.12
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .................................                                                                               486.93

July 1, 1909, balance available ...................                                                             ................                  14, 424. 19

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                                                                              3, 500. 84

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...........        .................................                                                                            (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                                                                     CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............................    $25, 098. 09
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ................................................      4, 000. 00

                                                                                                                                                  29, 098. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year. for maintenance of
  improvement .......................................................                                                                              9, 371.13

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended................................                                                                                  19, 726.96
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                                                                             973. 86

July 1, 1909, balance available.........................                                                                 ..........               18, 753.10

                                   a See consolidated money statement on this page.
464        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................    $4, 318. 34
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...............................................      6,000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix S 9.)
   10. Homochitto River, Mississippi.-The Homochitto enters the
Mississippi River from the east about 25 miles below Natchez. For
the first 3 miles from that point it is designated as the "Narrows"
and for a distance of 12 miles farther as "Old River." A prelim-
inary examination, made in 1896, showed that the Narrows had a
depth of 5 feet at low water and a width of 150 feet, except for a
distance of about 1 mile, where the stream is very narrow and shoal.
This narrow and shoal portion was obstructed by snags and logs.
Old River was about 1,000 feet wide and about 2 feet in depth over
the shoalest places at low water. It was clear of obstructions.
Above Old River the Homochitto River had a navigable depth of
about 8 feet and a width of about 150 feet for a distance of about 45
miles, but it was thickly obstructed by snags, logs, and overhanging
trees.
   The act of March 3, 1899, appropriated $16,000 for the removal
of obstructions between the mouth of the river and the Yazoo and
Mississippi Valley Railway bridge, a distance of about 60 miles, and
a project for the work was approved April 18, 1899.
   Work under this project was commenced November 27, 1899, and
continued until August 13, 1900, resulting in the improvement of
the channel for a distance of about 18 miles and a width varying
from 60 to 200 feet. Subsequent operations have been for main-
tenance. It is proposed to apply the available funds toward the
construction of a combined dredge and snag boat. On June 30,
1909, this boat was three-fourths completed.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $18,291.53, of which
$2,809.86 was applied to the maintenance of the improvement. The
expenditures during the past fiscal year were for construction and
inspection of boat.
   The Homochitto River is navigable, in fact, during periods of high
water in the Mississippi River for a distance of about 18 miles, above
which point it would be navigable for a farther distance of about 42
miles except that it is thickly obstructed with snags, logs, and over-
hanging trees. The maximum draft that could be carried June 30,
1909, over the bar at lower end of Old River, the shoalest part of
the locality under improvement, was about 2 feet at mean low water.
The 5 miles of channel above Old River, which was cleared of ob-
structions in 1903, has again become badly obstructed by snags.
   The usual variation in level of the water surface between high and
low water is about 30 feet, the high-water period usually lasting about
three and one-half months. No point on the river where the channel
has been improved is reached by a railroad, and the project has there-
fore no effect on freight rates.
   No detailed commercial statistics for the calendar year 1908 were
available. Circular letters and blank forms for furnishing statistics
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          465
were sent out, but no replies were received. The commerce consists
mainly in the rafting of timber.
   On page 393, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906,
reference is made to previous reports on examinations and surveys.
   Reference is invited to report on preliminary examination made in
accordance with river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, printed in
House Document No. 692, Sixtieth Congress, first session. For the
reasons given therein, this river is considered not worthy of further
improvement by the United States at the present time, and in com-
pliance with section 7, river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, discon-
tinuance of appropriations is recommended.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended                       -.................. .......... ........ $6, 313. 10
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...................................................                                  604. 63

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................................                       5, 708. 47
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabiliti-c ......................................                      126. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                       5, 582. 47

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..................                      1, 500. 00
    (See Appendix S 10.)
   11. Bayou Lafourche, Louisiana.-Bayou Lafourche is an outlet of
the Mississippi River, forming a junction with that stresam 70 miles
above New Orleans. It is about 105 miles long and flows into the
Gulf of Mexico. In its original condition it was obstructed by logs,
snags, and overhanging trees. The project of 1879 provided for the
removal of such obstructions to improve low-water navigation. Work
under this project was carried on until 1885, with appropriations ag-
gregating $30,000.
  The project of June 11, 1886, provided for the construction of a lock
to connect the bayou with the Mississippi River and for dredging a
channel 75 feet wide and 5 feet deep at mean low water of the Gulf,
at an estimated cost of $450,000 and $8,000 annually thereafter for
maintenance. Work under this project was confined to dredging to
maintain low-water navigation, the appropriations at any one time
being insufficient to warrant the commencement of the lock and the
exigencies of commerce not permitting a suspension of the dredging.
  The project of 1886 was modified on September 23, 1896, and held
in abeyance the construction of the lock, restricting operations to
dredging to maintain low-water navigation, at an estimated cost of
$25,000 per annum.
   Dredging operations have been in progress since 1896, but the im-
provement is not permanent, as sand bars form each year after the
subsidence of floods in the Mississippi River.
   The amount expended on this work up to June 30, 1909, was
$258,085.17.
   The navigation of Bayou Lafourche is at present obstructed by a
dam placed across the head of the bayou at its junction with the
Mississippi River by levee boards of the State of Louisiana, under
authority of the act of Congress approved June 13, 1902. The time
for the removal of this dam was extended to January 1, 1910, by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907.
         9001-EN        1909----30
466         REPORT      OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                      S. ARMY.

   The depth of water in the bayou is practically the same as last year,
which was at mean low tide 31 feet at the mouth, the usual variation
of the water surface being between one-half and 1 foot. The bayou
is navigable its entire length by flatboats and log rafts, but, as stated
above, connection between the bayou and the Mississippi River is at
present cut off by a dam.
   The commerce of this bayou is carried principally by small gasoline
boats that ply between New Orleans and points along the bayou by
way of Barataria Canal.
   The effect of the project on freight rates is not definitely known.
   It is proposed to expend the amount requested either in dredging,
should the dam be removed, or in expenses of superintendence, in-
spection, etc., should the lock be built by the state levee boards, and
in dredging.
               Comparative statement of receipts and shipments for ten years.

                                                                            Change in tonnage from
                                                                                previous year.
                         Calendar year.                            Tons.

                                                                             Increase.    Decrease.


1899.......                                                     .  157,
               ........................................................258 ............    49,258
                                                                   210,315     53,057.........
1900--------------------......---........-----------.........---------------...--..........--------
                                                                   137,357 ............    72,958
1901.........---------...........----------..------------....--------....---....................---
                                                                   132,745 ............      4,612
1902..........-------..............................................--------------------------------
1903....................... .................. ....................94,351 ............     38,394
1904............................  ................................ 66,839 ...........      27,512
1905............................................................. 94,320       27,481......
1906....................... ..................................... 59,092............       35,228
1907.......................... ........        ................... 46,
                                                                    41......
                                                                      413 ........ .... 12,679
1908......6......... ............................................   64,914     18,501.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...........     ......................                  $1, 914. 83
June 30, 1909, amount carried to the surplus fund ....................               .     1, 914. 83

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.....     ....................................      15, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix S 11.)
   12. Removing the water hyacinth from waters in Louisiana and
Texas.-Under the provisions of the sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
a Board of Engineer officers, appointed to investigate the extent of
obstruction to navigation in the streams of Florida and Louisiana
and to determine a method of checking the growth of or removing
the water hyacinth, recommended the construction of boats fitted
with crushing machinery and the use of log booms as adjuncts to the
boats. (See Annual Reportof theChief of Engineers for 1899, p. 1615.)
   Under the act of March 3, 1899, $25,000 was appropriated for the
purchase of a boat, $1,000 for the construction of log booms, and
$10,000 for operating expenses.
   A boat purchased and fitted with machinery for crushing the
hyacinths was operated in Bayou Plaquemine and contiguous streams
from July, 1900, to June, 1901, when funds were exhausted. Ap-
proximately 188,800 square yards of plants was removed.
   A boom, with a suitable gate to permit of the plants floating out
with the tides and toprevent their return, was constructed and placed
at the mouth of Bayou Teche, Louisiana.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    467
   Act of June 13, 1902, permitted the destruction of the plants by
chemical means or otherwise, and the boat was fitted with special
machinery designed for spraying the plants with a chemical compound.
Operations were carried on in this manner from September, 1902, to
May, 1903, and from August to October, 1903. Approximately
522,750 gallons of the compound was sprayed over an area estimated
at 3,509,024 square yards of hyacinths.
   Bayou Plaquemine and contiguous streams were, at date of cessa-
tion of operations (October 26, 1903), practically free from hyacinths.
   The steamboat Ramos began spraying operations July 8, 1904.
When the season's operations were terminated, the following streams
were effectively cleared of all obstructing hyacinths: Bayou Plaque-
mine, Grand River, Bay Natchez, Bayou Goddell, Belle River, Bayou
Long, Bayou Grossetete, and Bayou Choctaw. Booms for controlling
the hyacinths were placed in Bayou Plaquemine, at mouth of Bay
Grossetete, at the head of navigation in Bayou Grossetete, and
across Bayou Choctaw. During the summer months a watchman is
maintained at the Bayou Plaquemine boom, whose duty it is to require
all rafts and boats to clear themselves of hyacinths before passing
through.
   The act of March 3, 1905, appropriated $40,000 for the removal of
the water hyacinths from the navigable waters of the State of Texas
and Louisiana, and projects, approved April 28 and May 15, 1905,
provided for continuance of spraying operations in the Plaquemine-
Morgan City water route and for the outfitting of a second boat for
operations in the Calcasieu River, Louisiana, and in the Sabine and
Neches rivers, Texas.
   Operations were resumed in Bayou Plaquemine April 8, 1905, and
were continued until October 31 in this and connecting streams named
above, at which date the condition of the streams between Plaquemine
and Morgan City was sufficiently satisfactory to warrant the suspen-
sion of further spraying operations for the season. During the entire
season a new chemical compound was used, which gave excellent
results at greatly diminished cost. In the season's work a total of
227,292 gallons of chemical compound was used, at a cost for chem-
icals of $1,098.66. At the price paid in previous seasons for chemical
compound this quantity would have cost $6,818.76. There was there-
fore a saving of over $5,700, which will pay the operating expenses of
the Ramos and of the hyacinth booms for a season. It is estimated
that each gallon of chemical destroyed approximately 10 to 12 square
yards of hyacinths.
   The steamboat Hyacinth (except the hull, which was purchased)
was built and equipped by hired labor at the engineer depot at New
Orleans at a total cost of $8,900.
   During the fiscal year 1907 spraying operations were carried on in
the streams of the Plaquemine-Morgan City route, resulting in clear-
ing the streams of all obstructing hyacinths. Cow Bayou, a tributary
of the Sabine River, Texas, and Bayou des Allemands and contiguous
streams, which were completely blocked by hyacinths, were cleared.
   In October, November, and December, 1906, the Ramos sprayed in
Calcasieu River, in English Bayou, a tributary of the Calcasieu, and in
BayouVermilion, but the season was too far advanced for good results.
   During the working season of 1906 265,409 gallons of chemical
compound was sprayed, at a cost of $0.0051 per gallon raw. During
468                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the fiscal year ending June 30, 1908, operations were carried on in
Bayou des Allemands, Bayou Barataria, Bayou Vermilion, and in
the streams of the Plaquemine-Morgan City route.
  During the working season of 1907 507,622 gallons of chemical
compound were sprayed, at a cost of $0.0055 per gallon raw, and in
1908, to June 30, 124,236 gallons, at a cost of $0.0041 per gallon raw.
  During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, the Hyacinth worked
in Bayou Vermilion, Little Bayou, Bayous Blue, Des Allemands,
Boeuf, Grand, Barataria and Teche, destroying and removing hya-
cinths from these streams.
  In addition to the usual watchman at the Plaquemine Bayou, one
was also hired to operate a temporary boom in Bayou des Allemands.
  During the working season of 1908, 281,956 gallons of chemical com-
pound were used at a cost, raw, of $0.0040 per gallon.
  During the season of 1909, 17,291 gallons have been used at a cost,
raw, of $0.0034 per gallon.
  The steamboat Hyacinth underwent extensive alteration and re-
pairs from November 19, 1908, to May 24, 1909.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $122,746.34.
  The amount estimated for expenditures in the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1911, is intended for operating boats for spraying plants
and the installation of booms and hire of watchmen for their opera-
tion and maintenance.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............                                    ..................             a$9, 627.   21
February 24, 1909, amount allotted from appropriation for emergencies in
  river and harbor works, act of March 2, 1907...........................                                            5, 000.   00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..---------------..-----.....----..........-------............-----------------....................  20, 000.   00
Miscellaneous receipts from sales of property, etc., deposited to the credit
  of appropriation.................................................                                                     138.   00
                                                                                                                 34, 765. 21
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement........................................................                                            b11, 782. 56

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended_.....................................                                          c22, 982. 65
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ..................................                                            692. 06

July 1, 1909, balance available...........................................                                       22, 290. 59

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ......... ....                                         40, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix S 12.)
   a Balance unexpended as shown by Annual Report for 1908 was $10,127.21. This
was an error due to the fact that no deduction was made in said report to cover the sum
of $500, which was allotted on November 4, 1907, by the Chief of Engineers to the
Galveston, Tex., district for Buffalo Bayou. The corrected balance on July 1, 1908,
was $9,627.21.
b Amount expended from appropriation for removing water hyacinths, etc. $9, 765. 21
Amount expended from appropriation for emergencies, etc ...............        2, 017. 35
                                                                                                                  11, 782. 56
c Balance unexpended, appropriation for emergencies, etc. ...... ....... ..  2, 982. 65
Balance unexpended, appropriation for removing the water hyacinths min
  Louisiana and Texas...............................................        20, 000. 00

                                                                                                                 22, 982. 65
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    469
EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
            HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports on preliminary examinations and surveys required by
the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities
within this district were duly submitted by the district officer.
They were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Har-
bors, pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed
in documents as indicated:
   1. Preliminary examination, with plan and estimate of cost of
improvement, of Bayou Teirebonne, Louisiana, with a view to obtaining
6 feet of water.-Reports dated July 13, 1907, and November 29, 1907,
respectively, are printed in House Document No. 1163, Sixtieth
Congress, second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated
cost of $50,000 is presented, provided any land needed for extra
width of channel. or depositing dredged material shall be first deeded
to the United States free of cost.
   2. Preliminary examination and survey of Bayou Vermilion,
Louisiana, to Lafayette, with a view to obtaining 6 feet of water.-Re-
ports dated January 21, 1908, and August 10, 1908, respectively, are
printed in House Document No. 1218, Sixtieth Congress, second
session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of $22,660
is presented.

IMPROVEMENT     OF RIVERS AND HARBORS           IN   THE GALVESTON,
                       TEXAS, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Capt. John C. Oakes, Corps of
Engineers. Division engineers, Col. E. H. Ruffner, Corps of Engineers,
to August 31, 1908, and Lieut. Col. Lansing H. Beach, Corps of Engi-
neers, since that date.
   1. Galveston Harbor, Texas.-Galveston Harbor originally em-
braced an anchorage area of over 1,960 acres, of which 1,500 acres
had a depth of more than 20 feet, 1,300 acres had a depth of more
than 24 feet, and 460 acres had a depth of more than 30 feet.
   The entrance was obstructed by two bars, known as the inner and
outer. The natural depth on the inner bar was about 9 feet and on
the outer bar about 12 feet. These shallow depths prevented all
but the lightest-draft vessels from using the harbor and necessitated
the lighterage of cargoes to the larger vessels anchored in the deep
water beyond the outer bar.
   Prior to 1874 the projects for improving the harbor related to
dredging operations on a small scale.
   The project for the permanent improvement by jetties was adopted
in 1874 and modified in 1880 and 1886. Previous to 1886, $1,478,000
was expended, with an additional sum of $100,000 subscribed by
the city of Galveston in 1883.
   The 1886 project provided for a certain depth of 25 feet and a
possible depth of 30 feet by constructing jetties to a height of 5 feet
above mean low tide and extending them to the 30-foot contour in
the Gulf and supplementing the action of the tidal scour by dredg-
ing. The estimated cost of this revised project was $7,000,000.
   The expenditures under the above projects resulted in 1900 in a
depth of 26 feet at mean low tide on the outer bar, an increase of 14
470     REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

feet since work began, and a depth of 26 feet at mean low tide on the
inner bar, an increase of 16 feet during the same period.
   The south jetty extended 35,603 feet and the north jetty extended
25,907 feet. The amount expended on this project was $7,041,684.42,
of which $97,687.85 was for maintenance of the improvement.
   The hurricane of September 8, 1900, damaged the jetties to a
considerable extent, and a Board of Engineer officers estimated the
cost of repairing the same at $1,500,000. (Annual Report Chief of
Engineers, 1901, p. 2018.) Appropriations under this estimate com-
menced June 13, 1902.
   The act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $300,000 and authorized
continuing contracts for prosecuting the work to the amount of
$700,000 additional, all of which has since been appropriated. In
pursuance of the discretion vested in him by this act, the Secretary
of War approved a project for expenditure of the funds appropriated
and pledged in obtaining a depth of 30 feet by repairing the jetties,
by jetty extension, and by dredging, including construction of a new
dredge.
   For more extended information see House Document No. 340,
Fifty-ninth Congress, second session, and River and Harbor Com-
mittee Document No. 11, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session.
   The new dredge Galveston commenced work November 24, 1908,
and the jetty extension and repairs of the jetties have continued
during the year and are about 92 per cent completed. Maintenance
by dredging has been carried on by the U. S. dredges Galveston and
Comstock.
   From June 13, 1902, to June 30, 1909, $2,102,512.12 have been
expended in accordance with modified project, including $507,901.26
for dredging, $372,256.10 for construction of new dredge Galveston,
and $3,443.72 for survey authorized by act of May 27, 1908.
   The old wharf of the state quarantine department of Texas, located
in Galveston Bay, which had been abandoned and was in a wrecked
condition, also the load of stone of an old jetty barge near the chan-
nel south of Fort Point, were removed.
   The project depth of 30 feet has been completed.
   The sundry civil act of May 27, 1908, provided for a survey of
Galveston Harbor as a whole for a comprehensive plan for further
improvement. Report was made in December, 1908.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, for maintenance
by the operation of the dredges.
   The outer-bar channel, where dredging is done, weather permitting,
had at the beginning of the fiscal year 27 feet at mean low tide.
The last survey in June, 1909, shows a channel depth of 30J feet, an
increase of 21 feet during the past year. With the exception of one
stretch of less than 1,000 feet, there is a fine navigable channel of
32 feet from within the inner bar across the outer bar to deep water.
   The inner bar has disappeared, leaving a ruling depth of 36 feet
at mean low tide. This result has been accomplished by the Gal-
veston channel current, aided by the Comstock, which worked on the
inner bar when it was too rough for it to work outside.
   Mean tide fluctuations on outer bar, 2 feet; inner bar, 1.64 feet;
Galveston channel, 1.12 feet. Including Galveston channel, 1,738
acres now have a depth of 24 feet and over, and 888 acres have a
depth of 30 feet and over.
                            IVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  471

   All the commerce for Galveston channel, Texas City channel, Port
Bolivar channel, Galveston ship channel, and Buffalo Bayou, which
comes in from the Gulf or passes out to the Gulf, whether coastwise
or foreign, passes through the jetty channel.
  A board of engineer officers in its report of December 19, 1902,
stated that a conservative estimate of the value to the country of
the present improvement at Galveston is more than $10,000,000
per annum. This benefit is probably, at the present time, more than
double that amount annually.
  A map of the last survey of the outer bar is submitted herewith.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................                .................. a $720, 345. 16
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.................................................                       200, 000.00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.....                     70, 000. 00
Proceeds of sales of charts of Galveston Bay............................                     28. 00
Proceeds of sales of contact prints................................                         ....          b 1. 04
Proceeds of sales of old boilers of dredge Comstock....................                                1, 200. 00
Proceeds of sales of condemned property........  ..................                                       156. 58
                                                                                                     991, 730. 78
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year
    For works of improvement ........................ ... $314, 065. 24
    For construction of dredge-...-..-....-..- ............ c 306, 033. 51
    For maintenance of improvements .................-- ... 101, 675. 77
                                                                                                     721, 774. 52

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended............                     ........................          d 269, 956. 26
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...........................                    .....          e 59, 321. 33

July 1, 1909, balance available ...............                       ...................            210, 634. 93

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                                 52, 003. 32
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvements, in addition to the balance
  unexpended July 1, 1909........................................... 9 250. 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix T 1.)

  2. Galveston channel, Texas.--This is the channel passing along the
wharf front of the city and connecting the same with the jettied en-
trance channel.
  Galveston channel inside the inner bar had originally a depth vary-
ing from 20 feet at Fort Point to 30 feet off Twentieth street, and
again to 20 feet off Thirty-second street. The width of the channel
between the 18-foot contours was about 600 feet. The inner bar had
originally a 9-foot depth, but conditions gradually became better until
the outer bar, with about 12-foot depth, became the controlling factor.
  a The unexpended balance, as given in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1908, should have included $67,750 in hands of Major Deakyne for dredge con-
struction.
   b Includes 54 cents received by Major Deakyne for blueprint of dredge.
   c Amount expended by Major Deakyne for construction of dredge.
  d Includes $5,453.90 in hands of Major Deakyne.
   e Includes $4,750 for construction of dredge.
  f Includes $4,516 for construction of dredge.
  g Since the preparation of this report and estimate the Galveston jetties have been
damaged by the storm of July 21, 1909. The local officer estimates that the additional
sum of $100,000 will be required to make the necessary repairs.
472             REPORT OF THE CHIEF                           OF ENGINEERS,                  U.       S. ARMY.

All vessels drawing over 12 feet had to complete their cargoes by
lightering after crossing the bar.
   Appropriations by the United States Government for the channel
began in 1902, when $100,000 was appropriated for improving the
channel in accordance with the report submitted in House Document
No. 264, Fifty-sixth Congress, second session. The act of March 3,
1905, authorized the construction of a dredge, Col. A. M. Miller, at a
cost not to exceed $125,000.
   The act of March 2, 1907, modified the project by providing for the
extension of the channel from Fifty-first street to Fifty-sixth street,
at an estimated cost of $129,310. (See H. Doc. No. 768, 59th Cong.,
2d sess.) The adopted project therefore contemplates the excavation
of a channel 30 feet deep and 1,200 feet wide from the inner bar to
Fifty-first street and the extension of said channel 700 feet wide from
Fifty-first street to Fifty-sixth street.
   The estimated cost of the project as modified is $1,714,310.
   The U. S. dredge Col. A. M. Miller moved during the fiscal year
858,587 cubic yards of material in widening and maintaining the
channel, of which 700,330 cubic yards was new work and 158,257
cubic yards was maintenance.
   The project is 58 per cent completed, giving a channel approxi-
mately 1,325 feet wide opposite the proposed immigrant landing sta-
tion just within the inner bar, 900 feet wide and 25 to 33 feet deep to
a point opposite Twenty-ninth street, and 750 feet wide and 25 to 35
feet deep to the end of the present wharf frontage.
   The total amount expended on the work of existing project up to
the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, for dredging and dike
construction was $719,576.19, of which $55,827.84 was for mainte-
nance of the improvement.
   Vessels drawing 281 feet can now come to the wharves at mean low
tide.
   The Monomoy left this port August 31, 1908, drawing 28 feet and 2
inches, the Irada on October 9, 1908, drawing 28 feet, and the Rowan-
more on November 21, 1908, drawing 28 feet and 6 inches.
   Variation of level of water surface is about 1 foot.
   The foreign trade, as given by the customs office, for the port of
Galveston for the calendar year 1908 amounted as follows: Foreign
exports, valued at $202,152,984; foreign imports, valued at
$5,516,822; total, $207,669,806.
   Partial statistics for coastwise trade were furnished by the secretary
of the Galveston Chamber of Commerce and other interested parties
as 900,497 tons, valued at $218,388,000.
   The following is a comparison of foreign export values credited to
ports in the United States on the Gulf of Mexico in the government
records for a period of six years :a

                       Fiscal year.                            Galveston.      New Orleans.            Mobile.       Pensacola.


1902-3.........................................                          $103,145,623$147,056,230     $12,618,443    $13,744,544
1903-4..................................... 144,920,127                                 148,006,606    16,826,671     15,891,834
1904-5 ...........................                               .......  126,085,590   149,866,358    18,071,982     15,340,265
1905-6......................                    ......         ........   166,240,813   149,901,013    21,712,544     18,440,122
1906-7..........       ...............          ..............            236, 277, 727 169,897,311    24, 463,696    19,218,433
1907-8....................          ........       .......     161,020,933       159,357,584          27,979,831       20,332,649

  a Data furnished by Judge A. J. Rosenthal, special deputy collector, United States customs service.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     473
   The value of foreign exports credited to the port of Galveston for
the fiscal year 1896-97 amounted to $59,334,343, and for the fiscal
year 1906-7 to $236,277,727, or about four times the amount for
1896-97. The gain from 1902-3 to the end of 1906-7 amounted to
129 per cent. During the year 1907-8 there was a decrease in value
of commerce handled through this port, amounting to $34,124,743.
   A sufficient depth and width of channel is a necessary supplement
to the deep water between the jetties to enable the vessels to reach
the wharves. The work of the past year has put the channel in
better condition for service than ever before, but with the increasing
length of the vessels now entering the harbor the necessity for the
full width of channel between harbor lines (1,400 feet) is becoming
very marked.
   It is proposed to apply the balance available on June 30, 1909, to
the extension of channel and dike to opposite Fifty-sixth street, and
the additional appropriation recommended in operation of the United
States dredge for widening the present channel and for maintenance.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................... $60, 543. 89
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3,1909....................................................... 200, 000. 00
Proceeds of sales of contact prints.....-........................... ...        60
Proceeds of sales of condemned property ...............................    179. 17
                                                                                                       260, 723. 66
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.............................                               $27, 743. 42
    For maintenance of improvement .......................                                7, 202.09
                                                                                                        34, 945. 51

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                                 225, 778.15
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                              5, 009. 75

July 1, 1909, balance available ...............                        ...................             220, 768.40
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 825, 137. 84
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, in addition to
   the balance unexpended July 1, 1909...........................          200, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix T 2.)
  3. Channel from Galveston Harbor to Texas City, Tex.-The natural
depth over the line of this channel was from 4 to 8 feet. During 1895
and 1896 a channel 16 feet deep was dredged by the Texas City Ter-
minal Company at an expense of $146,000. At the time of the
adoption of the present project this channel had shoaled to its natural
depth.
  The river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, provided for deepening
the channel north of Pelican Island from Galveston Harbor to Texas
City, Tex., to a depth of 25 feet and a width of 100 feet at the bottom
at a cost not to exceed $250,000.
  The full amount had been expended on the work under this ap-
propriation up to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1905,
the Texas City Company paying the expenses of superintendence,
inspection, etc. The channel was dredged 100 feet wide on the bot-
tom and 25 feet deep from Texas City wharves to 25 feet of water in
Galveston Harbor, a distance of 34,000 feet.
474       REPORT OP THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                     U.      S. ARMY.

   In addition to the amounts mentioned above, the Texas City Com-
pany, according to figures furnished by them, expended $148,906.98
in completing channel, $172,734.58 in digging turning basin and slip,
and in 1906 removed 698,222 cubic yards at a cost of $16,028.61 in
maintaining channel.
   This channel was redredged by contract completed September 19,
1907, for a distance of 17,590 feet from the wharf at Texas City,
1,001,147 cubic yards being removed.
   During the past fiscal year 273,284 cubic yards of material have
been removed by United States dredges in maintaining the channel.
   The total amount expended by the United States to June 30, 1909,
is $285,960.34, of which $35,960.34 was expended in maintaining the
channel.
   The amount of fill since project was completed to end of last fiscal
year was 1,337,700 cubic yards, and the fill from June 18, 1907, to
May 17, 1909, amounted to 1,371,500 cubic yards, making total fill
to date of 2,709,200 cubic yards.
   Variation of water surface is about 14 feet.
   The ruling depth on May 17, 1909, was 12 feet, but owing to the
softness of the silt, ships drawing 17 feet can pass through the channel.
   The effect of the project on freight rates has been very beneficial
during the past year owing to the establishment of a new line of
steamers from New York to Texas City, thereby breaking up the rate
agreement that had existed between the old lines between New York
and Galveston.
   The tonnage for the port of Texas City, Tex., for the calendar year
1908, as furnished by the Texas City Terminal Company, of Texas
City, is as follows: Foreign exports and imports, 59,072 tons, valued
at $3,403,960; coastwise domestic, 96,927 tons, valued at $18,201,566;
total 155,999 tons, valued at $21,605,526.
   It is proposed to expend the available balance and the additional
appropriation recommended in maintaining the present channel.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................... $.34, 480. 51
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........................................................... 50, 000.00
Proceeds of sales of contact prints......................................         . 40

                                                                                   84, 480. 91
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ..........................................................           10, 440. 65

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................    ..............              74, 040. 26

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, in addition to the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909............          .............................           50, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix T 3.)
   4. Channel to Port Bolivar, Tex.-The river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, appropriated $50,000 for obtaining a channel 150
feet wide and 25 feet deep, with increased width at wharf, from Gal-
veston Harbor to Port Bolivar.
   This channel extends from the Gulf and Interstate Railway trans-
fer wharf southerly to Bolivar Roads, a distance of 4,275 feet.
                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                475
   During the fiscal year 269,929 cubic yards of material was removed
by contract, making a total of 517,927 cubic yards of material removed
from this channel. The remains of a sunken dredge boat near Bolivar
Point was removed. A slip and wharf were constructed by the Gulf
and Interstate Railway Company of Texas, and the port was opened
for commerce June 14, 1909.
  The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low tide over the shoalest part of this channel is 19 feet.
  Variation of water surface is about 14 feet.
   The channel is used for tugs and barges in the transfer of freight
cars to and from Galveston, and facilities are now available for ships
to load and discharge at the Bolivar wharf.
   Amount expended on existing project to close of fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, $48,710.75.
   The project is completed.
   Commercial statistics received from the Gulf and Interstate Rail-
way Company of Texas show the commerce passing through Bolivar
channel to be more than 50,000 tons, valued at $5,578,705.
   No marked effect on rates have been noted due to this work.
   The available balance and the appropriation recommended will
be expended for maintaining the channel and widening the turning
basin in front of the wharves.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.............                          ......... ................     $31, 126. 49
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......................................................                                 50, 000.00

                                                                                                       81, 126. 49
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  m ent ...............................................................                                29,837.24
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                  51, 289. 25
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, in addition to the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...............................................      50, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix T 4.)
   5. Galveston ship channel and Buffalo Bayou, Texas.-The ship
channel in Galveston Bay and Buffalo Bayou are two links in the
waterway connecting Houston with deep water in Galveston Bay,
the other links being the San Jacinto River and the Morgan Canal.
   In their natural state these two waterways had a depth of from
4 to 8 feet, of various widths. The earlier projects for their im-
provement, adopted in 1871, 1877, 1881, and 1892, provided for a
channel 100 feet wide and 12 feet deep. Dredging was carried on
for a number of years, furnishing a channel sufficient for the charac-
ter of vessels then navigating these channels.
   In 1892 the Government purchased the Morgan Cut and Canal,
5.43 miles long, for $92,316.85.
   The amount expended on original projects prior to operations
under existing projects was as follows:
Ship channel in Galveston Bay (including the purchase of Morgan Cut
and Canal, $92,316.85).................-.........................     ..                           $800, 328. 16
Buffalo Bayou, Texas.................   ................... ..........                               210,137. 64
        Total.....................................................                                  1, 010, 465. 80
476         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                   U.   S. ARMY.

  The existing project, adopted in 1899 (p. 1515, Annual Report
Chief of Engineers, 1898), as modified in 1905 (p. 1495 et seq., Annual
Report Chief of Engineers, 1905), is as follows:
For completing channel to head of Long reach, including turning basin
  600 feet in diameter, 25 feet deep, side slopes 1 on 2, division 1 (bay),
  1 on 3 in divisions 2 and 3 (river), least radius 2,500 feet, 150 feet on
  bottom in division 1 (bay), 100 feet on bottom in divisions 2 and 3
  (river)            -   ------------------------------------..---.         $3, 170, 000
26,000 feet of dike revetment-........... ...............................        40, 000
One hydraulic dredge-..-.. ...   .....    . .............................       150, 000
Engineering and contingencies (about 10 per cent).......... .......             340, 000
    Total....     ................................................                              3,700,000
Amount available December 1, 1904...................                       ...............         150, 000
Balance required.............................           .........................               3, 550, 000
  The act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $200,000 and authorized
continuing contracts for prosecuting the improvement in the sum of
$200,000, all of which has been appropriated.
  Of the $200,000 appropriated March 2, 1907, $50,000 was expended
for the restoration of the channel from foot of Main street, Houston,
to head of Long reach.
  By contract and United States dredges 3,717,209 cubic yards of
material have been removed from the different divisions during the
past fiscal year, of which 2,725,496 cubic yards was for maintenance
and 991,713 cubic yards for improvement. Snagging operations
have been carried on in the upper stretches of the bayou.
  During the fiscal year the channel in the open bay has filled in
generally throughout its entire length to an amount of 1,812,000
cubic yards. The channel in the bayou has not filled appreciably
during the fiscal year, due to absence of freshets. Since the beginning
of 1905 a fill of 8,178,000 cubic yards has taken place.
   The amount expended on the existing project up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $2,082,668.63, of which
$228,852.10 was for maintenance.
   The project is about 50 per cent completed.
   The usual variation of level of water surface is, division 1 (bay
division), lower bay, 1.3 feet; upper bay, 0.5 foot; and divisions 2
and 3 (river divisions), less than one-half foot. In times of flood
rises of 12 or more feet occasionally occur in Buffalo Bayou.
   The maximum draft that can be carried on June 30, 1909, at mean
low tide is, from Bolivar channel to Red Fish, 10 feet; thence to Mor-
gan Point, 14 feet; thence to head of Long reach, 16 feet; thence 8
feet to foot of Main street, Houston. The channel has been dredged
throughout to a depth of 18 feet, including the turning basin.
   The effect of this project on freight rates is unknown and is inde-
terminate because of a railroad rate differential in favor of Houston,
authorized by the railroad commission of the State of Texas.
   The wharfmaster at Houston reports the tonnage carried on the
bayou during the calendar year 1908 as 602,734, valued at $28,318,621.
It is given in detail in Appendix T 5 of this report.
   For number of vessels passing through Morgan Canal, see report
on operating and care of Morgan Canal, Appendix T 7 of this report.
   It is proposed to expend the available funds and the amount esti-
mated as a profitable expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1910,
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          477
toward completing work now under way, including easing bends to
2,500 feet radius, maintenance toward a more uniform depth, repair
of pile and brush dike in upper bay, and snagging operations through-
out the bayou.
   If progress is to be made toward the completion of the project
depth, 25 feet, throughout this channel, more liberal appropriations
must be made for the work, as the cost of maintenance is increasing
yearly as increased depth is obtained.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.........             ....................           $260, 398. 15
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909           -----------------------------------------                   100, 000. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.....                    55, 000. 00
Proceeds of sales of contact prints.................              ........... ......         8. 50
Proceeds of sales of condemned property ..........................                         289. 98
                                                                                          415, 696. 63
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ..........................                 $154, 185. 52
    For maintenance of improvement ....................                   76, 567. 45
                                                                                          230, 752. 97

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................................                   184, 943. 66
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.................................                     23, 434. 04

July 1, 1909, balance available.....................                    ............      161, 509. 62

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..............                        17, 707. 61

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                  2, 800, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, in addition
  to the balance unexpended July 1, 1909.............................                     300, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of river and harbor act of'1899.
   (See Appendix T 5.)
  6. Removing the water hyacinths from Texas waters.-On August 9,
1907, water hyacinths were discovered in Buffalo Bayou, Texas, and
vicinity, and an allotment of $500 was made on November 4, 1907,
to destroy them to prevent them from becoming an obstruction to
navigation.
  Under United States supervision, the city of Houston, Tex., re-
moved practically all hyacinths from Buffalo Bayou by hired labor.
  Total amount expended on this work up to the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909, was $35.26.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................... $474. 73
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improvement. 9. 99

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                          464.74
   (See Appendix T 6.)
   7. Operating and care of Morgan Canal, Texas.-A custodian was
stationed at the canal during the past fiscal year.
   A statement contained in the report of the local engineer officer
shows the items of expenditure, which amounted to $360, exclusive
of liabilities outstanding, amounting to $30.
478          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                    U.      S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................                                         $390. 00
Amount allotted June 23, 1909........................ .................                                         360.00
                                                                                                                750. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improvement.                                    360. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .............-- -            .......            ................               390. 00
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ........-..............                             .........   ......     30.00

July 1, 1909, balance available ...........              ..............................                         360. 00
   (See Appendix T 7.)

   8. West Galveston Bay channel, Texas, and mouths of adjacent
streams, including Trinity River, Anahuac channel, Cedar Bayou,
Chocolate Bayou, and Bastrop Bayou.-This project embraced the
improvement of the following localities: West Galveston Bay, the
Galveston and Brazos Canal, Double Bayou, mouth of Trinity River,
Anahuac channel, East Bay Bayou, Turtle Bayou, Clear Creek,
Dickinson Bayou, Chocolate Bayou, Bastrop Bayou, Oyster Creek,
and the mouths of adjacent streams. (Annual Report Chief of
Engineers, 1900, p. 2438, et seq.)
   Prior to March 3, 1899, the improvement of West Galveston Bay
channel, mouth of Trinity River, and Cedar Bayou had been inde-
pendent. At that date they were consolidated with the other works,
except Anahauc channel, which was added by act of March 3, 1905,
and Chocolate and Bastrop bayous, which were added by the act of
March 2, 1907. The Brazos River, between Velasco and Richmond,
which was included in the improvement for a time, is now covered
by a separate appropriation and has been transferred to the Dallas
district. The estimated cost of the modified project is $248,646.34.
   The object of this improvement, in part, is to obtain and maintain
a navigable channel depth of from 4 to 6 feet across the bars at the
mouths of the streams and bayous from deep water in the bay to
deep water in the bayous.
   The improvement is intended to develop a light-draft inland navi-
gation which will afford cheap transportation by light-draft steamers
and barges to the coast country of Texas.
   As the West Galveston Bay channel and Galveston and Brazos
River Canal have been included in the "Inland waterway on the
coast of Texas," and appropriated for under that heading, allotments
for these works under this appropriation have ceased.
   About five-sixths of the project has been completed.
   The effect of these improvements has been generally to decrease
freight rates to all points reached by the channels improved.
   It is proposed to apply the balance available and the appropriation
recommended in dredging and snagging, for maintenance, and in
opening up bayous emptying into the Galveston bays, in accordance
with approved project.
   More and larger boats, especially power boats with schooner hulls,
have been built to utilize the improvement.        Most of the points
reached are settlements not on railroads, and the improvements are
of great importance to their commercial life.
                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          479
  The amount expended on these improvements under present project
to June 30, 1909, has been as follows:
Channel across Hanna reef.......................                                 ......................              $697.08
Double Bayou ....                .............................................                                    13, 193. 99
Anahuac channel           ...............................................                                         12, 100. 00
Mouth of Trinity River.................................................8,                                             636.18
Cedar Bayou ......................................................                                                11, 946. 23
Clear Creek....................... .......................                                           .........    10, 497. 16
Dickinson Bayou..................................................                                                 12, 105.45
Bastrop Bayou.......................... ...........................                                                9, 920. 22
Chocolate Bayou.................................                               ......................              6, 542.04
Dredge Gen. H. M. Robert----............-------------...............----------..............   -------------      67, 992. 51
Dredge Capt. C. W. Howell......................................                                                   15,000.00
         Total........................                                .........   ................               168, 630. 86
  (a) Channel across Hanna reef (East Bay Bayou).-This is a chan-
nel across Hanna reef, connecting lower Galveston Bay, East Bay, and
East Bay Bayou, and is on the direct line of the inland waterway project.
The natural depth was 2 feet at mean low tide.
  Amount expended on work of existing project up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, $679.08.
  During the year 5,773 cubic yards of material was removed, making
a channel 6 feet deep, 40 feet wide on the bottom, and 955 feet long.
Maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, is about 4 feet at
mean low tide.
  Variation of water surface, about 1 foot.
  It is estimated that 500 tons of vegetables comes out of East Bay
Bayou via Moodys and Ladys passes, and that about 250 tons of
general merchandise returns.     There is also some fish and oysters
carried through these passes, but the present shallow channel pre-
vents any extensive business being carried on.
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...---------------..-----...........-----------....................---------------................ $2,000.00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment .............        .....        ....             ............... .......... ... ..........                   15. 17

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                                             1, 984. 83
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .........................................                                    1, 144.89

July 1, 1909, balance available ......................................                                      ..        839. 94

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                                            (a)

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 19090................................                                                  (a)
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Double Bayou.-The navigation of this bayou was obstructed by
a bar which prevented boats drawing over 2 feet of water entering
the bayou.
   The amount expended on work of existing project up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, $13,193.99, of which $6,240.79
was applied to maintenance, exclusive of $2,711.40 deposited by
private parties.
                           a See consolidated money statement on page 486.
480          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                   S. ARMY.

   This expenditure resulted in the excavation and maintenance of a
channel 6,450 feet long, 60 to 80 feet wide, and from 5 to 7 feet deep
across the bar and into the bayou.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water is 7 feet.
   The variation of water surface is about one-half foot.
   This bayou within a half mile of its mouth divides into east and
west branches, the east branch being navigable for 12 miles and west
branch for 8 miles from mouth, making a total of 191 miles.
  The commerce through this channel, as given by Burt H. Collins,
for the calendar year 1908, amounted to more than 5,000 tons of
produce, mainly rice and merchandise, valued at $269,000.
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...................    .. ........................          $5, 000.00
Proceeds of sales of condemned property ..................................      89. 46
                                                                                                5, 089.46
Transferred to Dickinson Bayou, Texas ................................                              89. 46

                                                                                                5, 000.00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement......................... ...... ..... .. ..... .........                          2, 644. 84

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...... ..                    . ...........        ..........    2, 355. 16
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                      2, 088. 22
July 1, 1909, balance available .................                ..... ........     .........     266. 94

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                         (a)

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, in addition to
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909....            ..................                           (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Anahuac channel.-The original depth of this channel was
about 3 feet.
   Amount expended on work of existing project up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, $12,100, of which $6,124.99 was
for maintenance of channel.
   The expenditure resulted in the excavation and maintenance of a
channel 16,013 feet long, 80 feet wide, and 7 feet deep from 6 feet of
water in Trinity Bay to 8 feet of water in Browns Pass.
   Maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean low
tide is 42 feet.
   Variation of water surface is about one-half foot.
   This channel is used by United States mail boat, and as there is
no railroad communication with the adjacent country, all produce
and supplies pass through this channel. Rice is the principal agri-
cultural product.
   This channel is navigable for 3 miles from the 6-foot contour in
Galveston Bay to Anahuac.
   Commercial statistics received show the commerce to be more than
15,000 tons, valued at $780,000.
                     a See consolidated money statement on page 486.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          481
Amount alloted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909.....---.......----------------------...........------------....................-----.....-----........ $4, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................                             ..................              4, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- .........                                         (a)
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909 .....................................                                          (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (d) Mouth of- Trinity River.-This river empties into Galveston
Bay through several mouths or passes, opposite each of which a bar
existed on which the depth of water did not exceed 31 feet at mean
low tide.
  Under earlier projects, adopted June 18, 1875, and amended
May 4, 1899, dredging and snagging were done, the west jetty at
Middle Pass completed to a length of 7,359 feet, and a channel 100
feet wide by 5 feet deep secured at a cost of $75,900. The channel sub-
sequently shoaled to a ruling depth of 34 feet, and at present Browns
Pass leading to the Anahuac channel is the one used and under
improvement.
  Amount expended on the work of existing project up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, $8,636.18, of which $4,995.74
was applied to maintenance.
  Under present project a channel 80 feet wide and 6 feet deep was
dredged a distance of 5,700 feet and a log jam removed from the pass.
  Maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean low
water, 4 feet.
  Variation of water surface is about one-half foot.
  During the calendar year 1908, lumber, rice, etc., valued at
$599,430, passed through this channel in addition to miscellaneous
supplies.
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
   March 3, 1909....................................................     $1, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................... .............. 1, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                                         (a)

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...................................                                             (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (e) Cedar Bayou.-Cedar Bayou discharges into the northwest
corner of Galveston upper bay at a point about 14 miles below the
mouth of the San Jacinto River, and distant 28 miles from Galveston.
  The original project for this improvement was adopted September
19, 1890, and consisted in deepening the channel over the bar by
dredging, so as to afford a depth of 5 feet at mean low tide, and
protecting the dredged channel by brush and stone walls or jetties.
The amount previously expended on this project was $32,150.
  After crossing the bar a least depth of 9 feet can be carried up the
bayou for a distance of 17 miles.
                   a See consolidated money statement on page 486.
          9001-ENG 1909-31
482            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                          U.   S. ARMY.


  Under present project the jetties were repaired by filling the lowest
places and gaps with riprap, and a channel 8 feet deep, 80 feet wide,
8,690 feet long was dredged from the 8-foot depth inside the bayou
across Cloppers bar and connecting with the 8-foot depth in San
Jacinto Bay.
   During the fiscal year 9,375 cubic yards of material was removed
in maintaining the channel.
   Amount expended on existing project to close of fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, $11,946.23, of which $5,009.08 was applied to main-
tenance.
   Maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, 6 feet. This
stream is navigable to Needle Point, head of navigation, a distance
of 20 miles from the mouth.
   The rise and fall of tide is about one-half foot, except during
freshets.
   It has been impossible to obtain the commercial statistics of the
effect of this improvement. One boatman reports taking out 24,000
tons brick, valued at $120,000, and 18,000 tons sand, valued at
$18,000, during the calendar year 1908. Rice and other agricultural
products, together with supplies for the adjacent community, are
carried through this channel, there being no railroad facilities within
convenient distance.
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........-------------------------------..........----------------.                                   $5, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement--------....-....-..---.......................................----------------------------------------      60. 71

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......... ...... ......................                                           4, 939. 29
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities........................................                                     1, 063. 62

July 1, 1909, balance available................- ......                             ...    ..............         3, 875. 67

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                                            (a)

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909-......................-----------..                                               (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (f) COlear Oreelc.-Clear Creek empties into Galveston upper bay
from the west. It was obstructed at its mouth by a narrow sand bar,
on which the depth did not exceed 2 feet. For a distance of 2 miles
above the mouth the ruling depth is 8 feet. It then broadens into a
lake 3 miles long and 1z miles wide, having, before improvement, an
average depth of 1 feet. Above the lake the prevailing depth is
from 8 to 12 feet.
   Private parties have at various times dredged through the bar at
the mouth into Galveston Bay, and during 1907-8 the U. S. dredge
Captain C. W. Howell dredged a channel 22,847 feet long, 40 feet
wide, and from 4 to 6 feet deep. At present there is across this bar
a channel about 40 feet wide with a least depth of 4 feet at mean low
tide.
   Amount expended on existing project to close of fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, $10,497.16, of which $7 was applied to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low tide over the shoalest part of the locality is 4 feet.
                             See consolidated money statement on page 486.
                            Ca
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                483

   This stream is navigable to Friendswood, at the head of navigation,
a distance of 20 miles, except that same is obstructed 10 miles from
its mouth by Galveston County road bridge and Galveston, Houston
and Henderson Railway bridge and 14 miles from its mouth by
Davis bridge. During the past year the bridges have been modified
so as to provide a 24-foot opening.
   Variation of water surface is three-fourths foot.
   No commercial statistics have been obtained.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................                      $51.87
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909 ......................................            . ........................ 4, 000. 00
                                                                                                     4, 051.87
Transferred to Dickinson Bayou.................................                             ......       51. 87
                                                                                                     4, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement...........................................................                                    7. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                                  3, 993. 00
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. .........                        -......
                                                                          ........-......               671. 05

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                                3, 321.95
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project............                             (a)
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
   for works of improvement and for maintenance, in addition to the balance
   unexpended July 1, 1909 ........................             .                                      (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (g) Dickinson Bayou.-Dickinson Bayou empties into Galveston
lower bay about 20 miles northwest of the city of Galveston. Navi-
gation was obstructed by a bar at its mouth with 21 feet of water
on its crest. After crossing the bar a depth of 10 feet can be car-
ried up the bayou for 20 miles or more, and a depth of 6 feet for a
distance of 25 miles from its mouth.
   During the past year the U. S. dredge Captain C. W. Howell exca-
vated a channel from 6 to 6 feet deep and about 60 feet wide over a
distance of 19,100 feet through the shoal water of the bay and to
deep water in the bayou.
   Amount expended on existing project to close of fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1909, $12,105.45, of which $5,823.12 was applied to
maintenance.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low tide over the bar is 5 feet.
   This stream is navigable 10 miles from mouth to Galveston,
Houston and Henderson Railway bridge for tugs and schooners.
The same class of vessels could navigate to a point 25 miles from
the mouth on removal of county and railway bridges.
   Variation of water surface is 1 foot.
   Partial information received shows the commerce passing through
this channel to be more than 1,400 tons, valued at $28,600.
                        a See consolidated money statement on page 486.
484           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.............................                         ........   $717. 67
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...... ................................................                      ... 4, 000. 00
Transferred from Double Bayou.........................................                              89.46
Transferred from Chocolate Bayou .....................................                             987. 78
Transferred from Clear Creek.......................                    -...
                                                                       ...............        ..    51. 87

                                                                              5, 846. 78
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement....--.......... ..... ...... ...... ................... ....... . 5, 823. 12

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ........................................                           23. 66
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .......................................                        4. 95

July 1, 1909, balance available-.........................                       ......   .....      18. 71

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project............                         (a)

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, in addition to the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909.....................................                             (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (h) Bastrop Bayou.-Bastrop Bayou empties into Bastrop Bay,
which is part of west Galveston Bay. The mouth of the bayou is
5 miles northwest of San Luis Pass and had a long shallow approach
with only 10 inches of water on the bar. For 2 miles above the
bar the water is shallow, averaging about 2 feet. Above that point
there is, in general, a depth of 10 feet, but this depth was reduced by
three shoals of a total length of about 3 miles with a depth of 2 feet.
The stream can be navigated for a distance of 20 miles from its
mouth.
  A channel 400 feet long, 35 to 40 feet wide, and 4 feet deep was
cut through the shell reef at the entrance to Bastrop Bay by the
U. S. dredge and snag boat Gen. S. M. Mansfield in 1906 at a cost
of $269.42, this amount being subscribed by interested parties.
  During 1907 the U. S. dredge Captain C. W. Howell cut a channel
18,765 feet long, 40 feet wide, and 4 to 5 feet deep up the bayou
beyond three small shoals obstructing navigation.
  Amount expended on work of existing project to close of fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909, $9,920.22.
  The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low tide over the shoalest part of the locality is 3 feet.
  Variation of water surface, 1 foot.
  No commercial statistics have been obtained.
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1909......................... ........... ...... .................. $4, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...........................       ...........                    4, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities......................................                         604. 13

July 1, 1909, balance available ..................................                               3, 395. 87

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...........                          (a)

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909...............................                                   (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                        a See consolidated money statement on page 486.
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       485

   (i) ChocolateBayou.-ChocolateBayou empties into Chocolate Bay,
an arm of West Galveston Bay, about 12 miles north of San Luis Pass.
At its mouth there is a bar with 3 feet of water on its crest. Above
this bar the depth varies from 7 to 15 feet for 50 miles from its mouth.
   During the fiscal year the U. S. dredge Captain C. W. Howell re-
moved 98,904 cubic yards of material, making a channel 51 feet deep,
40 feet wide, and 21,000 feet long from 5 feet of water in West Galves-
ton Bay through Chocolate Bay to 5 feet of water in Chocolate Bayou.
   Amount expended on work of existing project to close of fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909, $6,542.04, of which $29.82 was applied to
maintenance.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean low
tide over the shoalest part of the locality is 5 feet.
   Variation of water surface, 1 foot.
   This channel is used regularly by light draft vessels a distance of 24
miles from its mouth to Liverpool. It is also navigable for 15 miles
beyond Liverpool and navigation could be extended farther were it
not for the overhanging timber along the banks.
   No commercial statistics have been obtained.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................                   ..............   $7,168.95
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909......................................................                  4, 000. 00

                                                                                       11, 168. 95
Transferred to Dickinson Bayou, Texas................................                      987. 78

                                                                                       10, 181. 17
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.......................................      $6,181. 17
    For maintenance of improvement ........................                  29. 82
                                                                                        6, 210. 99

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................                    3,970.18
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...........................................          422.43

July 1, 1909, balance available............................................             3, 547. 75

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                  (a)

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, in addition to the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ..................................                     (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                              DREDGE CAPTAIN C.       W. HOWELL.

Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ....................................................... $15, 000.00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement......................................................      15, 000. 00

                                         UNALLOTTED.

Amount unallotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....................                        .................... $2, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..............................                    2, 000. 00
                    a See consolidated money statement on page 486.
486           REPORT OF THE CHIEF                          OF ENGINEERS,      U.    S. ARMY.

                                                       CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.................... .................                             $7, 950. 28
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909................................................ .. ...                             50, 000. 00
Proceeds of sales of condemned property...............................                                  89. 46

                                                                                                   58, 039. 74
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.............................. $6, 196. 34
    For maintenance of improvement......................... 23, 565. 49
                                                                                                   29, 761. 83

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                             28, 277.91
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                          5, 999. 29

July 1, 1909, balance available..........................................                           22, 278. 62

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                            59, 646. 34

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, in addition to
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909................................ 110, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (j) Channel in West Galveston Bay.-See Inland waterway on the
coast of Texas.
   (k)Galveston and Brazos River Canal.-See Inland waterway on
the coast of Texas.
   (See Appendix T 8.)
   9. Inland waterway on the coast of Texas.-The river and harbor
act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $133,829, and authorized the
Secretary of War to enter into contract for materials and work to
the extent of $300,000, all of which has since been appropriated.
   This project embraces the improvement of the following localities:
West Galveston Bay and Brazos River Canal; channel from Aransas
Pass to Pass Cavallo, including the Guadalupe River to Victoria;
Turtle Cove channel from Aransas Pass to Corpus Christi, Tex.
   The object of the improvement is to obtain and maintain a navi-
gable channel depth of 5 feet in a canal along the coast of Texas,
utilizing the lagoons lying between the islands and the mainland.
The improvement will develop a light-draft inland navigation which
will afford cheap transportation by light-draft steamers and barges
to the coast country of Texas.
   More and larger boats with auxiliary gas engines have been built
to utilize the improvement. Most of the points to be reached are
settlements which railways can not afford to develop, but the im-
provements are of great importance to their commercial life.
   The project is about 70 per cent completed.
   No reduction of freight rates due to this improvement has been
noticed.
   Amount expended under this appropriation to June 30, 1909, has
been as follows:
West Galveston Bay and Brazos River Canal........................                                 $124,   383.   29
Aransas Pass to Pass Cavallo.....................................                                   45,   362.   81
Guadalupe River ...................                 .................                  ........     68,   258.   60
Turtle Cove channel ... .......            ................................                        122,   107.   64

        Total.......................................                           ...........         360,112.34
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    487
   It is proposed to apply the balance available and amount estimated
as a profitable expenditure in dredging, snagging, etc., in accordance
with approved project.
    (a) West Galveston Bay and Brazos River Canal.-Previousto 1908
these channels were carried under another appropriation-viz, "West
Galveston Bay channel, Texas, and mouths of adjacent streams, etc."
    West Galveston Bay.-This is a body of water covering about 39
square miles and lies between Galveston Island and the mainland.
It extends from Galveston Bay to the west end of Oyster Bay and
is connected with the Gulf of Mexico by San Luis Pass at the west-
ern extremity of Galveston Island and with the Brazos River by the
Galveston and Brazos Canal. The minimum depth of the bay was
from 21 to 3 feet.
   The project adopted July 13, 1892, and modified in 1896, contem-
plated a least depth of 5 feet, at an estimated cost of $28,998.80.
   The work done resulted in a channel 100 feet wide and 3 to 31 feet
deep from Galveston Bay to the Galveston and Brazos River Canal.
Beacons were also erected to define the channel. The channel sub-
sequently shoaled to 18 inches in places.
   Amount expended, including maintenance, to close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1907, $35,059.69.
   The maximum draft that can be carried at mean low tide June 30,
1909, is 3 feet.
    For report of examination upon which new project is based see
House Document No. 640, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session.
   From records kept by the Gulf, Colorado and Santa Fe Railway
Company of vessels passing through the draw of its bridge across
West Galveston Bay during the calendar year 1908, 5,054 vessels
used the waters of West Galveston Bay.
   The U. S. dredge Gen. H. M. Robert was engaged during the year
in deepening and straightening channel. Up to April 17, 1909, a
channel 8 feet deep, 80 feet wide on bottom, was dredged for a dis-
tance of 8,800 feet, at which time the dredge was destroyed by fire.
A channel was also cut under drawbridge and old piling removed.
    Galveston and Brazos River Canal.-This canal was originally
dredged by the Galveston and Brazos Navigation Company. The
original cut was 10 miles long (made in 1851-1853), 100 feet wide at
bottom and 6 feet deep. Steamboats from 145 to 175 feet long
and from 28 to 30 feet wide used the canal, carrying from 550 to
1,200 bales of cotton.
   The United States purchased the canal in December, 1902, at a
cost of $30,000. The canal when acquired by the United States
was badly obstructed with snags, drift, and silt.
   Previous to June 30, 1907, the canal had been dredged for practi-
cally its entire length to a depth of 3 feet at mean low tide and width
of from 35 to 40 feet. The bank had been reinforced at various points
by brush.
   The length of the canal from west end of Oyster Bay to Brazos
River is 8 miles; ruling depth, 3 feet. The canal connects with
West Galveston Bay by a dredged channel across Oyster and Bas-
trop bays and a new cut across Mud Island, shortening the old route
3 miles.
   Amount expended, including maintenance, on the canal up to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1907, was $67,307.66, of which
488          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                         U.   S. ARMY.

$30,000 was for purchase of canal and $3,203.97 applied to mainte-
nance.
  The existing project, combining this channel and West Galveston
Bay channel under one appropriation, was adopted by the river and
harbor act of March 2, 1907, and provides for a channel 40 feet wide
and 5 feet deep, at an estimated cost of $151,529 and $20,000 annually
for maintenance.
  The U. S. dredge CaptainC. W. Howell has been engaged during the
year in deepening the channel to 5 feet, with 1 foot over depth, 60
feet wide, for a distance of 36,910 feet.
  A pile-and-brush dike was built across Oyster Creek, where it had
cut through south bank of canal. A new boom was constructl at
the entrance to the canal into the Brazos River.
  The canal is practically completed.
  The combined project is about 70 per cent completed.
  Amount expended on existing project to close of fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, $124,383.29, of which $20,000 was for maintenance
of the improvement.
  The total amount expended on the West Galveston Bay and
Brazos River Canal project to June 30, 1909, is $226,750.64, of
which $30,000 was for the purchase of the canal and $24,589.31 for
maintenance.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low tide over the shoalest part of the channel, which is in West
Galveston Bay, is 3 feet.
   Variation of water surface is about 1 foot, except at time of Brazos
River overflow and northers.
   No commercial statistics have been obtained.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............................                         $93, 193. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909............................................................32, 000. 00
Proceeds of sales of condemned property.............................................             26
Proceeds of sales of contact prints-.....................              ...............        1.00
Collected from Postal Telegraph Cable Company for digging trench for
  cable ..............................................................                      500. 00
                                                                                       125, 694. 26
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment...............................................................                   66, 045.81

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ........................    .........                  59, 648. 45
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..-.................................                   676.45

July 1, 1909, balance available ....................................                    58, 972. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project............              20, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, in addition to
   the balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...................    ..     .......               (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (b) Channel from Aransas Pass to Pass Cavallo.-This channel
was originally developed by the State of Texas and private parties
and was the old United States mail route between Indianola and
Corpus Christi. In 1875 vessels drawing not over 3 feet could navi-
gate the channel.
                        aSee consolidated money statement on page 491.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             489
  The project, as adopted by act of March 2, 1907, contemplates a
depth of 5 feet, 40 feet wide, from the entrance at Aransas Pass to
Matagorda Bay, a distance of about 63 miles, at a cost of $68,850.
  The contract for dredging this channel was continued during the
year and is now about 90 per cent completed.
  Amount expended on existing project to close of fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, $45,362.81.
  The maximum draft that can be carried at mean low tide over the
shoalest part of the proposed route is 4 feet.
  Variation of water surface, about three-fourths of a foot.
  No commercial statistics have been received.
  Report of examination is printed in House Document No. 640,
Fifty-ninth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................   $57, 538. 58
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909................................................      40, 000. 00
                                                                                               97, 538. 58
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ........    ....................................................                        37, 050. 44
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...........................                   ..........       60, 488.14
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                     4, 513. 41

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                      .   55, 974. 73

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................                          12, 500. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...........                                                                 (..................(a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) GuadalupeRiver, bay section.-This channel connects the mouth
of the Guadalupe River with the channel from Aranses Pass to Pass
Cavallo. For the first 8 miles there was 6 feet of water, shoaling
to 4 feet at the twelfth mile, then through a flat with about 2 feet to
the mouth of the river at the sixteenth mile.
   Variation of water surface, about three-fourths of a foot.
   The project contemplates a navigable waterway 5 feet deep and
40 feet wide at a cost of $30,000.
   During the year 145,983 cubic yards of material have been removed,
giving a channel 5 feet deep and 40 feet wide for a distance of 15
miles. The project is about 85 per cent completed.
   River section to Victoria, Tex.-The Guadalupe River empties into
San Antonio Bay, 16 miles from the inland waterway on the coast
of Texas. Its width varies from 90 feet at main entrance at mouth,
increasing to 140 feet 52 miles above its mouth. The depth varies
from less than 3 feet over shoals to 20 feet at bends. Thick over-
hanging trees, numerous snags, and sunken logs, together with rafts
of recent formation, are found in the lower river. The river was
formerly navigated to Victoria., 52 miles from its mouth, but owing
to rafts navigation has been abandoned in recent years.
   The project contemplates the removal of rafts, snags, etc., and the
dredging of shoals to 5 feet, at a cost of $62,700.
                        a See consolidated money statement on page 491.
490           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                        U.    S. ARMY.

   During the year the U. S. combination snag boat and dredge
Guadalupe removed 53,065 cubic yards of material and several miles
of snags and rafts, clearing the river from Victoria at mile 52 to
mile 14. There has been no uniform depth obtained by this work,
as the dredge has excavated only sufficient depth to enable it to
proceed down the river, as the first work to be done was the removing
of rafts, snags, etc.
   Amount expended on existing project to close of fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, $68,258.60.
   From report received from P. R. Austin, 1,150 bales of cotton and
250,000 feet of lumber, together with a considerable quantity of
other supplies and products, have been transported over the part
of the river at present navigable.
   Report of examination is printed in House Document No. 336,
Fifty-ninth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................... $33,799.97
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909------------
                  .........-----------....---...............-------------..............----....-------....... 50, 000.00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909....... 32, 000. 00
                                                                                                            115, 799. 97
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  m ent ............................................................                                            41,358.02
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ...................................                                           74, 441. 95
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                                       14, 672. 13

July 1, 1909, balance available-.................                         ........-..............               59, 769. 82

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. ...............                                           5, 500. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, in addition to the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909..----------............------....--..-----------------------..................... --      (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (d) Turtle Cove channel between Aransas Pass and Corpus Christi.-
This is a natural depression between Harbor and Mustang Islands
connecting at high tide the waters of Aransas and Corpus Christi bays.
It is about 13,500 feet long and 2,000 feet wide, with approximate
depth of 11 feet below mean low tide.
   Variation of water surface is about 1 foot.
   The project contemplates a channel 81 feet deep at mean low tide
and 75 feet wide at the bottom, at a cost of $123,750.
   During the year 923,068 cubic yards of material was excavated,
making a channel 8 to 9 feet deep and 75 feet wide on the bottom,
from 9 feet of water in Aransas Pass Gorge near the town of Tarpon
to Corpus Christi Bay, a distance of 31,400 feet.
   The project has been completed.
   Amount expended on existing project to close of fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, $122,107.64.
   The maximum draft that can be carried at mean low tide over the
          part of this locality is 81 feet.
shoalest pat
   For report of survey, see House Document No. 338, Fifty-ninth
Congress, second session.
                           aSee consolidated money statement on page 491.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          491
  One small steamboat and several schooners use this channel in
transporting freight between Galveston and Corpus Christi.
  This channel not having been opened to navigation until April,
1909, practically no freight has been carried through same as yet.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ...................................                                      $100,   411. 28
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..-----.....---------...--..........------.....---------.......--------..---------.........   10,   000. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1.909-......                                       23,   000. 00
Proceeds of sales of contact prints ..................................
                                                     ---------------------------------                              12. 75
                                                                                                           133, 424. 03
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ..................... ............................... ..............                               121, 768.52

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....---------......----....-------...---...........-----------...           11, 655. 51
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, in addition to the balance
   unexpended July 1, 1909..........................................                                           (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                                  CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-. ------------..                         ------. --......-  -     . $284, 942. 83
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909---------.....--.---------------...................-------------------....----.....    132,000.00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......                                   55, 000. 00
Proceeds of sales of condemned property.....-.-.........................                                        26
Proceeds of sales of contact prints ..............                    .....................                 13. 75
Collected from Postal Telegraph Cable Company for dredging trench for
  cable..............................................................                                      500. 00
                                                                                                          472, 456. 84
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ......................... ................      ...............                                     266, 222. 79
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                       206, 234. 05
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ..............................                            .....      19, 861. 99

July 1, 1909, balance available. .....................                          ..............             186, 372.06

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                                      18, 000. 00

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. .........                                   20, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, in addition to
   the balance unexpended July 1, 1909...........................
                                                  --                    100, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix T 9.)
    10. Operating and care of West Galveston Bay and Brazos River
Canal, Texas.--A boom tender was stationed during the year to
tend the boom at the entrance to the canal into the Brazos River.
                         a See consolidated money statement on this page.
492           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                     U.    S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................-..........          ..........                 $211. 56
Amount allotted June 24, 1909-........................ ..................                              38. 44
                                                                                                     250. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment .................................................................                              120. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ........................................                            130. 00
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ......-----... ..             --........................        10. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available .........................................                            120.00
    (See Appendix T 10.)
    11. Mouth of Brazos River, Texas.-The mouth of the river was
originally obstructed by a bar, the crest of which was about three-
eighths of a mile from the shore line, and the channel across afforded
a variable depth of water for navigation of not over 8 feet at times
(in October, 1874, only 2 to 3 feet), being subject to changes due
to winds, tides, and stages of water.
    The orginal project was adopted in 1880 for the improvement of
the channel over the bar by the use of jetties. The work was sus-
pended in 1889. The amount expended on original project prior to
operations under existing project was $142,098.43, and an additional
sum of $5,000 for a board of engineers to ascertain character and
value of improvements made by the Brazos River Channel and Dock
Company.
    After suspension of work by the United States the improvement
of the mouth of this river was undertaken by the Brazos River
Channel and Dock Company, which constructed two parallel jetties
560 feet apart. The northeast jetty was extended 4,708 feet long
and the southwest 5,018 feet. In 1899 this company complied with
the conditions of an act of Congress requiring a transfer to the United
States of the jetties and auxiliary works; also a release of all rights
and privileges conferred upon said company by its charter or by the
act of Congress approved August 9, 1888, to charge or collect tolls
for the use and navigation of said river. From the transfer of the
works until the adoption of the present project the United States
spent $88,524.13.
    The Brazos River Channel and Dock Company's map shows that
in March, 1889, there was a channel depth of 6 feet before the work
began, and later, in March, 1896, there was 20 feet. The company
measured their depth from a plane of "average flood tide," or mean
high water, 1.3 feet above the United States standard of mean low
tide. The channel width is about 440 feet. The depth of channel
varies with storm conditions and frequency of river floods from 12
to 20 feet.
    The existing project (act June 13, 1902) is to repair and strengthen
the jetties, construct spur dikes and bank protection, and to dredge
a channel 18 feet deep and 150 feet wide. The estimated cost,
 $250,000, was increased by $175,000 after the hurricane of Septem-
ber 8, 1900. The project is completed except for dredging necessary
to obtain and maintain the channel.
    As the result of an examination authorized by the river and harbor
act approved March 2, 1907, the Board of Engineers for Rivers and
Harbors arrived at the conclusion that for the present no further
improvements should be made at the mouth of the Brazos River and
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                   493

that work under the existing project should be confined to the main-
tenance of the jetties, and this opinion is concurred in by the Chief
of Engineers. (See H. Doc. No. 1087, 60th Cong., 2d sess.)
   It is proposed, therefore, to apply the balance available to main-
tenance of the jetties.
   The amount expended on the work of existing project up to close
of fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is $218,205.58.
   The latest information shows a minimum depth on the bar of 16
feet at mean low tide.
   Mean range of tide 1.77 feet.
   So far as known no vessels carrying freight have used this channel
during the year.
   So far this improvement has had little or no effect on freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....---................................      $17, 435. 52
Proceeds of sales of condemned property......-........................                . 16

                                                                              17, 435. 68
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..............................................................                5. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-.................   .......   ...........    17, 430. 68
   (See Appendix T 11.)
   192. Aransas Pass, Texas.-Aransas Pass is on the south coast of
Texas, 175 miles southwest of Galveston and 125 miles north of the
Rio Grande, and is the outlet of Aransas Bay into the Gulf of Mexico.
The area of the bay is about 80 square miles. It is connected with
Corpus Christi Bay on one side and with the Mesquite, St. Charles,
and Copano bays on the other.
   The depth over Aransas bar has varied greatly-from 9 feet in
1852, 9 feet in 1871, 7 feet in 1875, to 81 feet in 1887.
   For projects and work done by the United States Government
and private corporations at Aransas Pass, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1898, page 1527 et seq.
   Amount expended on the original and the modified government
project prior to operations under the Aransas Pass Harbor Company's
project was $540,477.65, exclusive of $9,938.93 subscribed by the
citizens of Rockport and Corpus Christi, Tex., and $5,000 appro-
priated for Board of Engineers to ascertain character and value of
improvements of Aransas Pass Harbor Company.
   The last appropriation had been expended in accordance with the
project prepared by Maj. O. H. Ernst, Corps of Engineers, in 1887
(printed on pp. 1313 to 1315 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1888). This project called for two parallel jetties and
the revetment of Mustang Island.
   Under the provisions of the river and harbor act of March 3, 1899,
the Aransas Pass Harbor Company, under date of March 27, 1899,
released and surrendered all rights and privileges theretofore granted
to it by Congress, including the jetty constructed at the entrance of
the pass.
   The river and harbor act of June 13, 1902 appropriated $250,000,
and provided-
that the work at this harbor shall be confined to the completion of the north jetty
in accordance with the design and specifications of the Aransas Pass Harbor Company,
and in continuation of the work theretofore carried out on said jetty by said company,
494       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                   U.   S. ARMY.

and to such additional work as may be necessary for strengthening such jetty, and for
the removal of such part of the old government jetty and any other hard material
which may interfere with the formation of a channel by the natural action of the
currents.
And the act of March 3, 1905, provided for continuing the improve-
ment, with the proviso-
that the amounts herein appropriated and authorized shall be applied to the comple-
tion of the project in accordance with the design and specifications of the Aransas Pass
Harbor Company, and in continuation of the work heretofore done, and to such addi-
tional work as may be necessary for strengthening the jetty.
   Work was completed in accordance with the above-mentioned spec-
ifications June 11, 1906, at a cost to the Government of $546,703.10.
   After the completion of the north jetty, in accordance with the
above-mentioned specifications, the channel became steadily worse,
approaching dangerously near the jetty and showed a matked ten-
dency to break through the interval between the inner end of the
jetty and the shore. The minimum depth in the thalweg was 161
feet at the time of the last survey before beginning work on the new
project, but the thalweg was in places directly over the foot of the
jetty and there was a navigable channel 6 feet deep of only 100 feet
wide, the 6-foot contour having approached to 100 feet from the
foot of the jetty. The 12-foot contour approached to within 75 feet
of the foot of the jetty, and therefore the 12-foot channel was too
close to jetty to be navigable for any vessel of that depth.
   A secondary channel, 600 feet wide and 6 feet deep, broke through
the gap between jetty and shore with the result that for all practical
purposes the channel was on the north side of the jetty instead of
the south side, as intended by the plan adopted by the Aransas Pass
Harbor Company.
   The existing project, adopted by the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907, provides for improvement in accordance with plans sub-
mitted by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors in its
report of December 22, 1906, printed in River and Harbor Committee
Document No. 5, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session. This project
provides, in the main, for a south jetty parallel to the general direc-
tion of the existing jetty and the extension shoreward of the north
jetty to connect with St. Josephs Island, and later the extension of
both jetties. The estimated cost of the work, including $100,000 for
a dredge, is $1,288,699.50.
   The act of March 2, 1907, authorized the expenditure of $490,000,
and contract was entered into December 24, 1907, and was com-
pleted June 23, 1909. Under this contract the north jetty was con-
nected with the shore and extended across St. Josephs Island, and a
south jetty was started and extended 3,000 feet.
   The act of March 3, 1909, authorized the Secretary of War to enter
into contract to the extent of $350,000 for new work, and appro-
priated $100,000 for maintenance for repairs to the old north jetty.
A new contract for work to be paid for by the amount above men-
tioned has been entered into, but work has not yet begun.
   As soon as the gap between the north jetty and shore was closed
conditions began to improve, and at the end of the fiscal year the
channel had widened and deepened so that there now exists a 6-foot
channel 430 feet wide, a 12-foot channel 275 feet wide, and the
18-foot contours have approached to within 375 feet of each other.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR                    IMPROVEMENTS.                                      495
The conditions are changing rapidly, the improvement noted having
taken place during the last five months.
   The amount expended on the work of revised project up to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $484,122.62.
   The usual range of tide is 1.1 feet across the bar.
   The work done is not believed to have had any effect on freight
rates as yet.
   During the calendar year 1908 there was carried from and to the
wharves of Corpus Christi, Tex., through Aransas Pass, Tex., 5,802,000
pounds of miscellaneous freight and 3,570 bales of cotton.
   The balance available and the appropriation recommended will
be applied toward extending and maintaining the jetties in accord-
ance with the approved project.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................                                          $373, 348. 45
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....-------------------------------..............----------------............................  100, 000. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......                                            90, 000. 00
Proceeds of sales of condemned property ......-......................                                                 1. 00
Proceeds of sales of contact prints ................................                                                  2. 40
                                                                                                           563, 351. 85
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment...................................     ........................                                     453, 396.77

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                                         109, 955. 08
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................                                        402. 85

July 1, 1909, balance available...................................                                         109, 552. 23

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                                   a 350, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, in addition to the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.....
                         .    ..................................       a 350, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.
    (See Appendix T 12.)
   13. Harbor at Brazos Santiago, Tex.-The navigable depth over the
bar before the improvement started was usually from 6 to 8 feet at
mean low water.
   The project for the improvement of this harbor, adopted in 1881,
contemplated the construction of two jetties extending out into the
Gulf of Mexico about 1,500 feet apart, one, the south or Brazos
Island jetty, to be 3,630 feet long, and the other, the north or Padre
Island jetty, to be 2,940 feet long. Work was suspended on this
improvement in October, 1884, and the subject of the new improve-
ment was reported on by The Board of Engineers. The cost of an
improvement to consist of two parallel jetties placed about 1,100
feet apart was estimated at $1,130,000. Adding previous expendi-
ures of $188,590.23 to this estimate makes the revised cost of the
improvement $1,318,590.23. Appropriations ceased in 1888 and no
work has been performed on the entrance channel since that time.
No permanent increased depth was obtained over the bar.
   During the fiscal year 1905 a channel 70 feet wide on the bottom,
with a least depth of 10 feet, was excavated from deep water inside
  a This amount applies to only such work as Congress has specifically authorized to be
completed under continuing contract.
496          REPORT        OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                       U. S. ARMY.


the bar in a straight line across the Laguna Madre to the railroad
wharf at Isabel, Tex., a distance of 12,000 feet; also a turning basin
400 feet long by 300 feet wide and 10 feet deep.
   Prior to dredging this channel and turning basin there was a nat-
ural channel permitting boats drawing 51 to 6 feet to navigate across
the Laguna Madre from the bar to the railroad wharf at Isabel, Tex.,
at high tide. With the channel and turning basin completed, light-
draft steamers and sailing vessels that could get over the bar could
proceed direct to the railroad wharf at Isabel, Tex., and unload, in
place of being lightered off Brazos Island.
   This channel has shoaled in places to less than 6 feet at mean low
tide. The tidal range is from 1I to 2 feet.
   The amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909, was
$247,913.81.
   The latest information gives 71 feet as the minimum depth on the
bar.
   No commercial statistics have been obtained.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-....................... ...............                  $5, 586. 22
June 30, 1909, amount covered into surplus fund of the Treasury........                    5, 586. 22
   (See Appendix T 13.)
    14. Construction of sea wall, embankment, and fill along the front of
Fort Crockett Reservation, Galveston, Tex., and constructing sea wall
from Thirty-ninth street to the west line of Forty-fifth street, in the city
of Galveston.-The sundry civil act approved April 28, 1904, con-
tained an item for the protection of the sea front of the Fort Crockett
Reservation, and appropriated $591,046.25 for the purpose.
    By sundry civil act approved June 30, 1906, an additional amount
of $158,953.75 was appropriated for completing the work.
    Construction of the sea wall and riprap embankment along the
western boundary of the reservation was completed October 18,
1905.
    This work was carried out in accordance with report of Board of
Engineers, dated December 19, 1902. See Appendix W 13, Report
of Chief of Engineers, 1903.
    The work of filling and sodding the reservation and behind the
sea wall between Thirty-ninth and Forty-fifth streets was completed.
    A retaining wall along the north and east sides of the reservation
was completed. The reservation is now surrounded by retaining
walls.
    The amount expended on existing project to June 30, 1909, was
 $702,338.69.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.............   ........        .....  $143, 596. 17
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement................................        ............ ......   95, 934. 86

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                    47, 661. 31
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                     101. 42

July 1, 1909, balance available...............................................            47, 559. 89
    (See Appendix T 14.)
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                  497
EXAMINATIONS    AND SURVEYS MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
               HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports on preliminary examinations and surveys required by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities
within this district were duly submitted by the district officer.
They were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and
Harbors, pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and
printed in documents as indicated:
   1. Preliminary examination and survey of Pass Cavallo-Port Lavaca
channel, Texas.-Reports dated March 20, 1908, and May 28, 1908,
respectively, are printed in House Document No. 1082, Sixtieth Con-
gress, second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost
of $10,000 is presented.
   2. Preliminary examination of the mouth of Brazos River, Texas,
with a view to determining what further improvements, if any, should
be made thereon.-Report dated February 6, 1908, is printed in House
Document No. 1087, Sixtieth Congress, second session. No further
improvements are considered necessary at the mouth of the Brazos
River at the present time.
   3. Preliminary examination and survey of Colorado River, Texas,
with a view of obtaining a navigable channelfrom its mouth as far up
as practicable.-Reportsdated October 21, 1907, October 28, 1908,
and November 9, 1908, respectively, are printed in House Document
No. 1211, Sixtieth Congress, second session. The locality is not con-
sidered worthy of improvement by the United States at the present
time.
   4. Preliminary examination of Arroyo Colorado, Texas, with a view
to obtaining a channel 8 feet or less in depth from Harlingen to deep
water at Point Isabel.-Report dated May 11, 1908, is printed in House
Document No. 1216, Sixtieth Congress, second session. The locality
is not considered worthy of improvement by the United States at
this time.
   5. Preliminary examination of Pass Cavallo-Port O' Connor channel,
Texas, with a view to establishing a harbor.-Report dated April 7,
1908, is printed in House Document No. 1217, Sixtieth Congress,
second session. The locality is not considered worthy of improve-
ment by the General Government at the present time in the manner
proposed.

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE DALLAS, TEXAS,
                       DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Capt. W. P. Wooten, Corps of
Engineers, to August 14, 1908, and of Capt. A. E. Waldron, Corps of
Engineers, since that date. Division engineers, Col. E. H. Ruffner,
Corps of Engineers, to August 31, 1908, and Lieut. Col. Lansing H.
Beach, Corps of Engineers, since that date.
  1. Johnsons Bayou, Louisiana.-This stream empties into Sabine
Lake, Texas, and was the water outlet, in fact the only outlet, for
the product of a rather thickly settled and fertile country. Prelimi-
nary survey made in 1897 showed a minimum depth of channel of 12
feet, and only 21 feet over the bar at the mouth of the bayou at mean
low water.
     9001-ENG 1909-32
498          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                  S. ARMY.

   The project of April, 1899, provided for dredging a 6-foot channel
through the bar at the mouth of the bayou of such width as the
appropriation ($2,500) would permit.
   This work was completed during December, 1899, and a channel 6
feet deep and 60 feet wide secured.
   No work has been carried on since 1899, none being considered
necessary, and the unexpended balance of the appropriation, $238.65,
was carried to the surplus fund in the Treasury on June 30, 1904.
   The total amount expended on the original project was $2,261.35.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $2,500 for
this improvement and an examination of the bar at the mouth of the
bayou was made, but the district officer reported this stream to be
unworthy of further expenditure for either improvement or mainte-
nance by the United States.
   The amount expended on this examination was $46, leaving an
unexpended balance of $2,454. In November, 1908, an additional
examination was ordered, and made at a cost of $86.50, which re-
sulted in a recommendation by the district officer that the available
balance, $2,367.50, be expended in dredging a channel across the
bar, using the U. S. dredge Port Arthur. This recommendation has
been approved, and the dredging will be done as soon as the dredge,
which is now undergoing repairs, is available. Report on examina-
tion of this stream will be found on page 1790, Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1897.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................--------------------------------- $2, 454. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement-----------..........................--------------------------------...------.......... 86. 50

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended................ ...                  ..... . . . . . ..   ...   2, 367. 50
   (See Appendix U 1.)
   2. Mouths of Sabine and Neches rivers, Texas.-Prior to improve-
ment there was 3 feet of water over the bar at the mouth of the
Sabine River, and 3 feet over the bar at the mouth of the Neches
River. Dredging was carried on at the mouth of the Sabine River
in 1880 and 1895, and a channel 60 feet wide and 7 feet deep secured.
At the mouth of the Neches River dredging was carried on in 1880,
1889, and 1895, and a channel 50 feet wide and 5 feet in depth for a
length of 8,000 feet was obtained. Funds were exhausted before
deep water in Sabine Lake was reached. In 1897 the channel at the
mouth of the Sabine River still afforded a depth of 7 feet, while the
channel at the mouth of the Neches River had shoaled to 4 feet.
   The act of March 3, 1899, appropriated $10,000 for improving the
mouths of these streams, the appropriation to include the expense of
reexamination of the proposed channel through Sabine Lake by a
Board of Engineer officers.
   The Board constituted in compliance with this act submitted, on
August 11, 1899, a report on the proposed channel through Sabine
Lake.
   The project approved July 14, 1899, provided for dredging from
deep water in Neches River to deep water in Sabine Lake. Under
this project an 8-foot channel 7,829 feet in length was dredged from
the 7-foot contour in Sabine Lake. A part of the appropriation was
expended in deepening the channel across the bar at the mouth of the
Sabine River.
                                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                                       499

     The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, adopted a project for
dredging a channel 100 feet wide and 9 feet deep from the mouths of
Sabine and Neches rivers to the mouth of Taylors Bayou, through
Sabine Lake at or near its western shore, as outlined in a report
printed in House Document No. 634, Fifty-eighth Congress, second
session, at an estimated cost not to exceed $536,500, with the follow-
ing provisions:                          "That the channel may, in the discretion of the
Secretary of War, be constructed through the land near th% lake for
any part of said route" and "that the right of way is furnished with-
out expense to the United States."
   Work under this project was begun March 1, 1906, and completed
February 20, 1908, having been badly delayed on account of difficul-
ties in securing the right of way.
     The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, authorized the exten-
sion of the channel at its southern end to a junction with the Port
Arthur Canal and the widening of the canal in front of Port Arthur.
Work on the extension was begun April 8, 1908, and was completed
May 23, 1908.
     Total length of completed canal from Port Arthur Ship Canal to
mouth of Sabine River is 84,660 feet, or practically 16 miles. (See
p. 1546, Appendix, report of 1908.)
  The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $463,783.62, of which
$9,925.29 was expended on original and modified projects prior to
the operations under the existing project.
  During the fiscal year trespass notices were placed along the line
of the canal; a number of floating obstructions were removed from
the channel; an office building constructed at Port Arthur bordering
on the canal; and 61 mooring piles driven in vicinity of office.
                                     Comparative statement of shipments and receipts.
                                                                   NECHES RIVER.

                                                                                                                               Change in tonnage from
                                                                                                               Tons.               previous year.

                                                                                                                                Increase.          Decrease.

Calendar year-
      1902..............                        .............                                                    145,740...................
     1903-----....--...----....--..----------------------------------                                            151,672               ,932...........
     1904.......................................................      .                                          161,516              9,844 .........
     1905-..........................................................-                                            173,504             11,988.............
     1906.........................................................                                               178,656               5,152 ...........
     1907....--..-------...----...-----.........-....-------------..----...........--..........-.....               150, 040 ............                  28616
     1908.........................----------------------------....... --------------------......................... 156,204               6,164   ......

                                                                    SABINE RIVER.

Year ending May 31-
   1897.......................................................                                                  245,364 ............                       25,893
   1898-------.....--...                  ---...........-----------------------------------                     275,506           30,142 ...
   1899--------..--....-----...............------------..............-----------.................---------..    270, 642 .........                          4, 864
Calendar year-
      1899407,372------------------------------------------------                                                     32                137,730 ..
      190--------............................----------------------------.........------------........               34072,372     ............       375,224
      1901-------------.............---..--..-..----------------------------.....................................   459,909            427,761
      1902--------.....----.........-------.............................................                            413,174............                46,735
      1903....... .............................................                                             ....... 325,761 ....            ..... ...  87,413
      1904.......................................................                                               292,184 ............             33,577
      1905..........................................................                                            198,210 ..........               93,974
      1906.......................................................                                               409,870        211,660 ..........
      1907..........................................................                                            405,172 ...........               4,968
      1908........................................................                                              308,825 .............                      96,347
                                                           SABINE-NECHES CANAL.

Calendar year 1908......................                                     .................                  110,992 ............ ............

                                           a Incomplete; full statistics could not be obtained.
500               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                         U.     S. ARMY.

  For reference to reports of examinations and surveys see Annual
Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 406, and 1908, page
486.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ............ .... ..    . ........    $87, 721. 60
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement...-----.---.............................................   5, 001. 62
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. .            -..-.........                            -         -
                                                                                 - ...-............                82, 719. 98
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities--... .............                           .......          .........          218. 40
July 1, 1909, balance available ........................................                                           82, 501. 58
     (See Appendix U 2.)
   3. Operating and care of Port Arthur Canal, Texas.-This service is
provided for by the permanent indefinite appropriation for operating
and care of canals and other works of navigation, under the provisions
of section 4 of the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, as amended
and reenacted by section 6 of the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
   Under the provisions of an act of Congress approved June 29,
1906, there was conveyed to the United States, free of cost, the Port
Arthur Canal, the lumber basin, and the turning basin, together with
a strip of land along the canal. The deed of conveyance from the
Port Arthur Channel and Dock Company was accepted by the Secre-
tary of War on December 13, 1906, from which date the canal became
a public water of the United States. Cession of jurisdiction over
the property was executed by the governor of the State of Texas on
February 27, 19J)7.
   The Port Arthur Canal was built by a company interested in estab-
lishing a port somewhat removed from the Gulf, and was dredged to
a depth of 25 feet. A dredge which was operated in maintaining the
canal for over three years has been purchased by the United States.
   A survey of the canal was completed May 10, 1907, and the fol-
lowing table gives a summary of the condition of the canal upon its
acceptance by the United States:
                                                                                 AverageWidth be-
                                                                            Average      tween     Maximum          Minimum
                                                              Length.         toP     20-foot con-  depth.           depth.
                                                                                         tours.

                                                                  Feet.      Feet.        Feet.         Feet.         Feet.
Canal.....................................                         37,600        200              80       25.1           23.5
Turning basin..........           ...   ............                1,800        625             530        27.1          23.7
Lumber basin.....................                      ....   .     1,200        160             100        26.2          23.1


  The depths above given are referred to mean low Gulf level, and
the usual variation of the tide is 1 feet.
  Operations during the year have consisted in dredging shoal places
in the canal to a depth of 26 feet for a distance of 13,900 linear feet,
and making extraordinary repairs to the U. S. dredge Port Arthur.
The turning and lumber basins having shoaled considerably, authority
was granted to hire outside dredging plant to do necessary dredging
in these two basins. Contract was entered into on June 29, 1909, for
dredging about 220,000 cubic yards therein at a cost of 10- cents per
cubic yard, work to commence not later than August 1, 1909.
  The maximum usable depth in the canal on June 30, 1909, was
24 feet.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      501
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $66,009.18 exclusive
of outstanding liabilities, of which $21,097.36 was expended during
the past year.
  There were moved on this canal during the calendar year of 1908
1,174,415 tons of miscellaneous freight, consisting principally of crude
petroleum and its refined products, cotton, lumber, and general mer-
chandise, valued at $21,405,118.
   (See Appendix U 3.)
   4. Harbor at Sabine Pass, Tex.-Prior to improvement there were
depths of 18 and 17 feet, respectively, over the two bars in Sabine
Pass, opposite the town of Sabine and opposite Fort Point. These
bars were about 200 feet long. Throughout the other portions of the
pass the least mean depth was 25 feet.
  Beyond the shore line at the entrance to the pass there existed a
bar about 3 miles wide between the interior and exterior 18-foot
bottom curves, over which there was not more than 6 feet of water
at mean low tide. Channels 12 and 15 feet deep were dredged
through this outer bar during 1878 and 1880, under the project of
1873, at a cost of $325,000, but they soon refilled.
   The project of 1882 provided for the construction of parallel jetties
at the entrance of the pass, 1,800 feet apart and about 4 miles in
length from shore line to deep water in the Gulf, and for dredging the
channel between these jetties if necessary. This work was designed
to provide a channel of practicable width and a depth of 25 feet at
an estimated cost of $3,177,606.50.
   Construction of the jetties began in 1883, and under successive
appropriations has been carried on since that date.
   The river and harbor act of 1896 authorized contracts for the com-
pletion of the project, limiting the cost to $1,050,000, all of which has
been appropriated.
   Under contract approved June 22, 1897, the east jetty was com-
pleted for a length of 21,818 feet, riprap work only was completed
for a length of 682 feet, and foundation only for 2,600 feet. The west
jetty had a length of 15,560 feet, of which 1,490 feet was only riprap
work and 4,950 feet was foundation only. About 3,000 feet of previ-
ous work was capped.
   Dredging in the channel was carried on, under contract, in 1897,
1898, and 1899, the depth being increased to 25 feet and the width
to 100 feet. The channel was again dredged in 1900 and 1901, with
an allotment of $8,000 from the emergency appropriation of June 6,
1900.
   Under the act of March 3, 1899, $150,000 was appropriated for
straightening, widening, and otherwise improving the harbor by the
removal of oyster reefs and flats between the United States life-
saving station and a point opposite the United States light-house.
The work was completed April 18, 1903.
   Act of June 13, 1902, appropriated $25,000 for widening and
straightening the main ship channel and increasing its depth from a
point 1,000 feet north of the life-saving station to the entrance of the
Port Arthur Canal in accordance with report published in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1901, page 1915. This work
was completed February 27, 1903, and the channel depth was
502               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                      U.    S. ARMY.

increased to 25 feet at mean low water for an average width of
400 feet.
   The act of June 4, 1897, appropriated $100,000 for the construction
of a dredge (the Sabine), which was completed January 14, 1901.
   Since this date the dredge has worked in the channel between the
jetties seventy-five months and eight days and removed a total of
3,233,335 cubic yards. The remainder of the time she was either
absent undergoing repairs or was engaged in emergency work at
South Pass, Mississippi River.
   The creation of the channel contemplated by the project has been
completed. The existing project is for maintenance of a channel
depth of 25 feet to be accomplished by dredging and the restoration
of the jetties to a height of about 4 feet above mean low tide at an
estimated cost of $1,016,573.
   The act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $160,000 for continuing
improvement and for maintenance and authorized contracts for
materials or work to the amount of $200,000, which has been appro-
priated and expended in repairing the east jetty for a distance of
13,800 feet, 113,893.31 tons of riprap stone being used for this lepair
work, the contract being completed December 19, 1908.
   Allotment of $200,000 was made from the appropriation act of
March 3, 1909, to continue this improvement, and for maintenance.
   Operations during the year have consisted in repairing east jetty
and dredging channel between the jetties.
  .At favorable stages of the tide vessels have gone out during the
year drawing 251 feet. The usual variation of the tide is 14 feet.
By continued work the dredge Sabine is able to maintain only a very
narrow channel of about 24 feet depth, and additional work is badly
needed toward building up the low portions of the jetties to a height
of about 4 feet above mean low tide.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $4,129,896.83, of
which $325,000 was expended on previous projects. Of the amount
expended on the present project it is estimated that $290,497.03 has
been applied to maintenance of improvement.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure in the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1911, namely $300,000, will be applied to continuing
the work of raising and repairing jetties and dredging in the channel.
                                    Comparative statement of shipments and receipts.

                                                                                                                                      Change in tonnage
                                                                                                                                     from previous year.
                                                                                                                       Tons.

                                                                                                                                    Increase.      Decrease.

Year ending May 31-
   1897-----------------------------------------------..                                                                87,632          38,746.........
   1898....-..--..-------....----------------------------------........................................----....        238,400         150,768..........
   1899----....----------------........................------------------------.........----.......                    326,982          88,582 .........
Calendar year--
   1899.-.              .. -------------------------------------------                                                 326,494 ............                 488
   1900....................                        .......................................                             217,489 ............             109,005
   1901------........----------.................-----------....----          .....-----------................ .... .   150,087 ............              67,402
   1902..... .....................                          ...........................                    .....       689,688         539,601 .........
   1903.....--------..--............................-------------------------------...........------...........   1,315,248              625,560 .........
   1904......................................-------------------------------................----------------      1,792,371              477,123 ........
   1905.....-..-- .............................---------------------------------........-----------................1,779,954      ............             12,417
   1906 .......... .................................................
                                     .                      .          1,904.389     124,435
                  -----
   1907................................................--.
                                      ..--                             1,848,159 ............ 56,230
   1908...................--....................................-..... 1,802,307 ............ 45,852
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       503
   Of the tonnage moved during the calendar year 1908, 65 per cent
passed through Sabine Pass on its way to or from the Port Arthur
Canal.
   It would appear that the result of the improvement at Sabine Pass
had had a marked effect in decreasing the freight rate on shipments
to the seaboard, as the State railway commission has given Sabine
and Port Arthur a low rate, called a differential, of 7 cents per hun-
dred on first-class freight from Beaumont to Sabine or Port Arthur,
applying on all freight from interior points in Texas to Sabine or
Port Arthur. This was done merely to equalize the rate, or differ-
ential, from Houston to Galveston, and was done only when it was
shown to the commission that Sabine and Port Arthur were deep-
water exporting points. It amounts to this: That all freight from
interior Texas points for export through Sabine or Port Arthur pays
the regular tariff rates to Beaumont, plus but 7 cents first-class
freight, to be then hauled to Sabine, though the regular tariff from
Beaumont to Sabine is 20 cents.
   On page 407, Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1906, ref-
erence is made to previous reports on examinations and surveys of
Sabine Pass.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................     $194, 622.28
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909. ....       10, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.................................................          200, 000. 00
Collected in suit United States v. Charles Clarke & Co..................       302. 93
Received from sale of blueprints.......-..............................           3.50

                                                                                                         404, 928. 71
Reverted to Treasury .........................                          ....................               1, 194. 56

                                                                                                         403, 734. 15
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...........................                                $177, 424. 62
    For mainitenance of improvement......................                                27, 657.47
                                                                                                         205, 082. 09

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                    198, 652. 06
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.....................                             ...............     1, 334. 08

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                                    197, 317.98

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ a 456, 573. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909.................................                                       300,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix U 4.)
   .5.Brazos River, Texas, from Old Washington to Waco.-The profile
of this section of river shows an alternating series of steep and gentle
slopes, not navigable, above Hidalgo Falls.
   a This amount is the difference between the original estimate and the sum of the
subsequent appropriations which have been applied to the work contemplated by it.
Owing to the fact that as favorable prices have not been obtained as were expected, the
figures now given are probably not a correct estimate of the further amount that will be
required to complete the project. This matter will receive consideration, with a view
to reporting a revised estimate to Congress, in connection with an examination now
being made of this locality or in the next annual report.
 504         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                              S. ARMY.

   In the river and harbor, act of March 3, 1905, an examination of
this section was ordered and a provisional appropriation for its
improvement was made. In the act of March 2, 1907, a further
appropriation was made, in accordance with a project submitted in a
report published in House Document No. 705, Fifty-ninth Congress,
first session. This project contemplates securing a navigable depth
of 4 feet for four months and 31 feet for six months of the year by
constructing eight locks and dams and 103 miles of open-channel
work, at a total cost of $2,915,000. It is not clear to what extent the
project outlined therein may be regarded as adopted by Congress in
appropriating for the work, and thus far it has been assumed that the
Government is committed to the construction of only one lock and
dam at an estimated cost of $300,000.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, authorized continuing
contracts in the sum of $150,000, in addition to amounts already
appropriated for the completion of the lock and dam at Hidalgo Falls,
which amount has been appropriated.
   From the amount of money appropriated by river and harbor act of
March 3, 1909, the sum of $75,000 was allotted. This allotment was
required in addition to the $300,000 to repair flood damages and to
construct bank protection to prevent further erosion at site of the
lock.
   On June 30, 1909, $233,830.04 had been expended on the con-
struction of lock and dam at Hidalgo Falls.
   During the fiscal year $85,244.40 has been expended in completing
the construction, by hired labor, of the lock, with the exception of lock
gates, controlling valves, maneuvering devices, and also in the
placing of bank protection and repairing flood damages.
   No work on the project has been done except the building of the
lock and dam at the foot of Hidalgo Falls, which work is about 55
per cent completed, so that no change has been made in this stretch
of the river.
   Should this portion of the river, as well as that below Old Wash-
ington, be properly improved, there is no doubt that the improve-
ment would cause a great reduction in freight rates throughout the
contiguous country.
   If it is the intention of Congress to continue the improvement by
the construction of additional locks and dams, money should be pro-
vided in sufficient amount to enable the improvement to be carried on
more rapidly than it has been in the past.
   For reference to reports of examinations and surveys see Annual
Report of Chief of Engineers for 1907, page 452.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................    $101, 414. 36
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......        50, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
r March 3, 1909 .............................................                75, 000.00
Received from sale of blueprints.........................................         7. 75
                                                                                            226, 422. 11
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment         ..........................................................................    85, 244. 40
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                       141,177.71
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities... ................. ........                           6, 255. 81

July 1, 1909, balance available..................................                           134, 921. 90
   (See Appendix U 5.)
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                    505
    6. Brazos River, Teras, from Velasco to Old Washington.-This
section of the river has a width of from 200 to 400 feet. It has good
depth from the mouth to near the head of tide water above Columbia
 (mile 36). It is navigable for light-draft boats throughout its length
for about eight months in the year.
    The original project for this improvement was adopted June 3,
1896, and contemplated the removal of snags and overhanging trees
and dredging troublesome shoals between Velasco and Richmond only.
The sum of $5,000 was expended on this project.
    In the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, the improvement from
Richmond to Old Washington was undertaken. In the act of March
3, 1905, this improvement was continued from Velasco to Old Wash-
ington. The project on which these appropriations were based (see
Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1901, p. 1974) contemplated the
improvement of the river by open-channel work between the mouith
and Old Washington, at a cost of $225,000.
   Amount expended on work of existing project up to June 30, 1909,
was $216,864.51.
    The operations during the year consisted in constructing and
repairing jetties, removing obstructions by snagging, and repairing
plant. Below mile 110 (or 10 miles above Richmond) a depth of
4 feet for approximately eight months in the year has been obtained
between Velasco and Richmond. The project in this part of the
river is about 90 per cent completed. From Richmond to Old Wash-
ington no work of any consequence has been done during the year,
the project being about 50 per cent completed. Over this section a
depth of 4 feet is available for navigation by boats having consider-
able power during rises of from 1 to 2 feet. No commerce of any note
has developed, nor can any be expected until the Brazos River is
improved from its mouth up to Waco, or until the territory about
the lower portion is given over more to agriculture than it is now.
   The distances of the various places mentioned in the above report
from the mouth of the river are as follows: Velasco, 5 miles; Colum-
bia, 35 miles; Richmond, 99 miles; Rosenberg, 108 miles; Old Wash-
ington, 254 miles; Navasota Lock, 259 miles; Waco, 424 miles.
   The improvement has so far caused no effect on freight rates.
   The available balance, as well as the $55,000 requested for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, will be used to build the new snag
boat Waco and in keeping plant in operation on open-channel work.
   For reference to reports of examinations and surveys, see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, page 453.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................           $54, 326. 78
Amount transferred from Galveston district account of repairs to dredge.. 15, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.. ...........................................................  25, 000. 00
Received from sales ...................................................             18. 00
                                                                                       94, 344.78
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .............................              $16, 328. 96
    For maintenance of improvement ...................                    4, 862. 33
                                                                                       21, 191. 29

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................                      73, 153. 49
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...............................                   3, 079. 43

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                  70, 074. 06
{Amount
506      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                      U.   S. ARMY.

         that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909---........-......      .......       .....   $55, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1907, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix U 6.)
   7. Trinity River, Texas.-.The river in its upper reaches is a narrow
stream with a low-water depth insufficient for even light-draft navi-
gation. Its banks are generally high and quite stable, making it
particularly susceptible to improvement by canalization.
   The river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, adopted a project for
the improvement of this stream in accordance with a report submitted
in House Document No. 409, Fifty-sixth Congress, first session. (See
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, p. 2348.) This
project contemplated improvement to provide a 6-foot navigation
from Dallas to the mouth, a distance of 511 miles, by open-channel
work and a system of locks and dams.
   The original estimate of cost of this improvement was $4,550,000.
The portion of this applicable to section 1 ($350,000) was afterwards
raised to $918,000 in a report from a board of engineers appointed to
examine into the cost. (See Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1904, p. 2021.)
   The amount expended on this improvement up to June 30, 1909,
was $430,541.40.
   Four locks and dams in section 1 have already been provided for by
Congress. The money for Nos. 1, 2, and 6 has already been appro-
priated, and funds have been appropriated and authorized for No. 4
and for a lock and dam at Hurricane shoals, which is in section 2, and
of the authorization, $85,000 is yet to be appropriated.
   During the year, Lock and Dam No. 1 was practically completed,
and during March, 1909, the contractor moved his force to the mouth
of Parsons Slough and commenced work on the dam at this place.
The construction of these two dams is covered by one contract.
About 65 per cent of work on dam at Parsons Slough has been
completed.
   The contractor who has the contracts for the construction of Locks
and Dams Nos. 2 and 4 has done very little work during the year,
except remodeling plant, excavating, and placing cofferdam.
   Work on Lock and Dam No. 6 has progressed more favorably this
year, and about 60 per cent of the contract has been completed.
   For the reasons given in the local officer's report it has been found
necessary to increase the estimate for Locks and Dams No. 4, in
section 1, and at Hurricane shoals, in section 2. He states that
approximately $85,000 will be needed in addition to the $85,000 now
covered by continuing-contract authorization and not yet appro-
priated, making the total further amount that will be required to be
appropriated to complete these works $170,000 and that this addi-
tional $85,000 should be provided for by cash appropriation or con-
tract authorization.
   Lock No. 1 is at McComas Bluff, 13 miles below Dallas; the dam
at Parsons Slough is 22 miles below Dallas; and Locks Nos. 2, 4, and
6 are 23, 30, and 42 miles, respectively, below Dallas.
   Snagging operations were continued on the lower river.
   The expenditures made in cleaning the river have resulted in no
increased depth, but the removal of snags and drifts has made the
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                         507
stream safer to navigate at medium and high stages. There is no
navigation of account above Liberty other than the rafting of logs.
   Owing to the fact that the river is not yet navigable to Dallas, the
only place at which it can come into active competition with the rail-
roads, no effect on freight rates has been produced. Inasmuch as the
leading trunk lines of this section are crossed by the river at Dallas,
there can be no doubt that when the river is made navigable to this
point it will result in a considerable reduction and an immense saving,
not only in local, but also in interstate freight rates in this section.
   For references to reports of examinations and surveys see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 431.
   If it be decided to prosecute this project further, provision should
be made in the shape of increased appropriations.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................                                            $488, 877. 64
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 19C9-. . ...                                          125, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ......--------------------------------------------............................................   75, 000. 00
Received from sale of blueprints -.........--------.......-- -----........----..........                              11.00

                                                                                                           688, 888. 64
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..................       .........                           $107, 026. 86
    For maintenance of improvement ....................                                    12, 996. 14
                                                                                                            120, 023. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....----------................-----.........------------...                568, 865. 64
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.          -----------................---.......-- .....                2, 921.76

July 1, 1909, balance available........................                           ..............            565, 943.88

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. ..............    367, 712. 31
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ a 1.70, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ..........      ................. b 183, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix U 7.)
   8. Operating and care of Lock and Dam No. 1, TrinityRiver, Texas.-
On March 1, 1909, Lock and Dam No. 1 was placed under the appro-
priation for operation and care. After the first few operations of
the lock a defect was discovered under the lower gates. Upon exami-
nation it developed that this was not due to any fault of the con-
tractor, and authority for its repair was approved. Considerable
work has been done on these repairs, but final completion has been
prevented by small rises in the river.
   A telephone has been installed at Lock and Dam No. 1.
   There has been expended up to June 30, 1909, $3,518.71.
   (See Appendix U 8.)
   9. Cypress Bayou, Texas and Louisiana.-Duringthe period of the
great raft in Red River the bottom lands of Cypress Bayou were
  a This estimate pertains only to the locks and dams, the construction of which has
been specifically authorized by Congress.
  b Of this amount $85,000 is for continuing contract work authorized by the river
and harbor act of March 2, 1907, and $98,000 for open-channel work.
508     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

flooded-became lakes-and afforded a navigable route from Red
River, near Shreveport, La., to Jefferson, Tex., 65 miles. Work
by the United States for the improvement of this route commenced
in 1872, and from 1872 to 1879 $94,000 was appropriated for the pur-
pose. The funds were expended for dredging and straightening
the channel, removing stumps, snags, and logs, and cutting leaning
timber. This work was completed in 1880, but on account of its
temporary nature appropriations and allotments aggregating
$39,701.33 were made for maintenance.
    The removal of the raft. and the subsequent closure of outlets and
construction of levees down the right bank of Red River from the
hills in Arkansas to near Shreveport, La., cut off the water supply
of the lakes, which, in conjunction with the quicker drainage result-
ing from the lowering of the bed of Red River, gradually caused
them to dry up. In consequence the period of navigation shortened
from year to year until 1897, when boats from Red River ceased
plying altogether.
    The existing project is practically for maintenance by cleaning and
clearing the bayou and lakes between Jefferson, Tex., and Moorings-
port, La., of snags and other recurring obstructions.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $142,824.28 for im-
provement and maintenance and $12,613.05 for surveys. The work
of maintenance so merges into the work of improvement that it is
difficult to state just what portion of the expenditures was for main-
tenance and what for improvement.
    The water supply of the drainage basin of the lakes has been re-
duced so greatly and the channel of Red River above Shreveport
has lowered so much that steamboats now can cross Albany flats, at
foot of the lake, only at rare intervals during exceptionally high
stages of Red River or after heavy rains in the drainage basin of the
lakes.
    The work of removing obstructions now in progress has rendered
navigation safer between Jefferson and Mooringsport and has con-
sequently caused some increase in the quantity of such local naviga-
tion. This navigation by giving access to a competing railroad has
resulted in keeping freight rates somewhat below those existing in
neighboring sections.
    From August, 1908, to February, 1909, the quarter boat was en-
gaged in removing obstructions to navigation between Jefferson,
Tex., and Mooringsport, La. The remainder of the time the boat
was out of commission on account of high water and lack of funds.
    The amount estimated for maintenance of improvement during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, is for continuing the work of
cleaning the channel of obstructions to navigation.
    For references to reports of examinations and surveys see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 432, and House Docu-
ment No. 220, Sixtieth Congress, first session, which gives report
of examination made of- "Caddo Lake with a view to determining
advisability of constructing a dam at the foot of said lake on the
waterway connecting Jefferson, Tex., with Shreveport, La."
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                    509
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ..................................... $3, 638. 02
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..........   ..................................           6, 000. 00
                                                                                                          9, 638.02
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment .........       ........................................                                           3, 374.02

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......             ............................                          6, 264. 00
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................                             ..     ........       82. 19

July 1, 1909, balance available .................                    .......................              6,181.81
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 .....-...-..            ...........        ........ 5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix U 9.)
   10. Red River between Fulton, Ark., and Denison, Tex.-This part
of the river was originally navigable for small boats during high
stages only. The river at low water is a stream from 100 to 200 feet
wide in the bends, winding in a shifting channel between banks which
are frequently several hundred yards apart. The low-water depth
varies from 1.5 to about 4 feet. The banks are covered with trees
constantly caving into the river and forming snags and drifts.
   The original appropriation for work above Fulton was made
August 5, 1886. The project contemplated improving only high and
medium stage navigation by removing snags and drift. Previous to
the existing project no work was provided for above the mouth of
the Kiamichi River. The amount expended under previous projects
is $33,500.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, entered upon a project
for the improvement of the river between Fulton, Ark., and Denison,
Tex. The project contemplates the removal of drift and snags,
clearing the banks of timber in danger of caving into the river, and
closing chutes and cut-offs where necessary. No estimate of cost has
been made.
   At the close of the fiscal year June 30, 1909, $182,737.06 had been
expended on this project, of which amount $10,189.66 was expended
on survey of river between Fulton, Ark., and mouth of Washita
River, Oklahoma.
   During the year the snag boat C. A. Culberson and 3 quarter boats
have been engaged in snagging operations. The 62 miles above
Fulton over which the C. A. Culberson has worked shows an increas-
ing depth. With the snags removed, the river seems to be cutting
itself a deeper and more stable channel.
   The survey of the river between Fulton, Ark., and the mouth of
the Washita River, Oklahoma, which was commenced in March, 1908,
was completed during the year, and report made to the Chief of
Engineers.
   Beyond the rafting of logs and timber there has been no commerce
of any value on this section of the river.
   When this section of Red River is opened to regular navigation a
very material reduction in both local and through freight rates to
points in north Texas and Oklahoma must necessarily result.
510           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                U.    S. ARMY.

  To secure a stable improvement will require a continuance of work
for a number of years. The available funds and additional appropri-
ation recommended will be applied to continuing the work now under
way of removing obstructions and bank clearing.
  For references to reports of examinations and surveys see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 433.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................          ...........  $70, 848.30
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909. ........................             ... .... ..   .......... 40, 000.00
                                                                                                    110, 848. 30
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...........................                             $48,797.71
    For survey........................------ ................                         4, 787. 65
                                                                                                     53, 585. 36

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                               57, 262. 94
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....      ..... ....          .............        ........    2, 282. 76
July 1, 1909, balance available.......................................                               54, 980. 18
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909...........--           -............. 100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix U 10.)
   11. Sulphur River, Texas and Arkansas.-Sulphur River for about
150 miles from its mouth is from 150 to 200 feet wide, with navigable
depths, except for a few shoals. The banks are as a rule firm and
stable. The stream is, however, badly obstructed by snags and
sunken logs.
   In 1896 and 1897 the sum of $2,488.99 was expended on snagging
operations.
   The existing project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, and contemplates improvement of 150 miles of the
river above the Red River by dredging and operation of a snag boat,
at an estimated cost of $36,000, assuming that a United States boat
is available. Operations during the year consisted in removal of
snags and other obstructions by means of a quarter boat.
   At the close of the fiscal year $16,968.81 had been expended on this
project.
   Owing to the poor navigable condition of the stream at present no
commerce of any account has developed. As the stream drains a
very rich section of the country it is expected that it will be exten-
sively used when improved, and that some reduction in freight rates
will result.
   It is proposed to expend the available funds and the additional
appropriation recommended in clearing the river of obstructions and
dredging where necessary.
   For reference to reports of examinations and surveys see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, page 457.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            511
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................................                                           $27, 860. 84
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.--------..--...--...........--- ...............--------------------------.....---------------.............   8,829.65
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..------...---------....................------------------.......              19, 031.19
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................                                           430. 30

July 1, 1909, balance available .........................                               ...............        18, 600. 89
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..............................-----------------------------------------.............      15, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix U 11.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE VICKSBURG, MIS-
                    SISSIPPI, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Capt. Clarke S. Smith, Corps of
Engineers. Division engineer, Col. Wm. H. Bixby, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Red River, below Fulton, Ark.-This improvement was under-
taken by the United States in 1828, and between 1828 and 1841 more
than $425,000 was appropriated for removal of the great Red River
raft. When work commenced the raft was 92 miles long, extending
from Loggy Bayou, 65 miles below Shreveport, La., to Hurricane
Bluffs, 27 miles above. A channel was opened through this obstruc-
tion, but, owing to failure of appropriations between 1841 and 1852,
additional raft formed. In 1852 $100,000 was appropriated, and in
1857 the agent in charge reported the route opened but not completed,
with recommendation for appropriations of $50,000 a year for com-
pletion and maintenance. The total amount expended from 1828 to
1857 was $529,831.90. The sum of $3,545.60 was carried to the sur-
plus fund. Nothing further was done for fifteen years, and in that
long interval the results of much of the former work were lost.
   When work was resumed, in 1872, the river above Shreveport, La.,
was closed by a raft 32 miles long, which was growing constantly.
Below Shreveport the enlargement of an outlet through Tones Bayou
was depleting the main channel and threatening its closure to naviga-
tion. At Alexandria, La., the falls were impassable at low stages.
Navigation was difficult and dangerous at all places and at all times.
The channel shifted frequently, and at flood the river overflowed the
entire raft region. Both above and below Sherveport the bed of the
river was a mass of sunken logs and stumps. The banks were heavily
timbered and each flood caused them to cave or slide.
   The project entered upon in 1872 contemplated opening navigation
through the raft and closing Tones Bayou outlet. Under the river
and harbor act of 1878 the removal of wrecks, snags, and other
obstructions below Shreveport was commenced, and the act of 1879
authorized the same kind of work above the raft to Fulton, Ark.
Work was carried on under three distinct appropriations until 1882,
when it was combined in a general appropriation for continuing the
improvement from Fulton, Ark., to the Atchafalaya River, Louisi-
ana, with a provision for work at Alexandria, La. The river and
harbor acts of 1884 and 1890 contained provisions for closing Sale and
512      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Murphy outlet, Louisiana; the acts of 1888, 1892, and 1894 author-
ized expenditures for improvement of Cypress Bayou, Bayou Dor-
cheat, and Sulphur River, tributaries of Red River; the act of 1902
provided for improvement of the channel at Shreveport, La., and the
act of 1905 contained a provision for further improvement of the
channel at Alexandria, La.
   The project was amplified in the river and harbor act of July 13,
1892, to include the systematic clearing of the banks to remove the
source of drift and snags; continuing snagging operations and the
removal of jams and raft; dredging tow-heads and shoals; construct-
ing a substantial system of levees to fix the course of the river, either
alone or by cooperating with riparian States; the closure of all out-
lets that deplete the river; the fixing of caving banks to confine the
river to the selected channel, and the prevention of injuries to regi-
men by new cut-offs or outlets. The nature of the improvement
requires that it be continued for many years, and no estimate for
completion is given on this account.
   The amount expended from 1872 to the close of the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1909, including $5,560.37 derived from sales, was
$1,833,983.33, with the following chief results:
   The channel cleared through the great raft in 1872-73 opened to
navigation 188 miles of river above Shreveport to Fulton. Subse-
quent work secured the complete removal of the raft, prevented
formations of the same nature, increased the width of the river 100
feet or more, and there now flows in the course laid out for it in the
old raft region a broad and deep river, safe for navigation at all but
the lowest stages. The survey of 1908 showed that the bed of the
river in the old raft region above Shreveport had lowered in places as
much as 25 feet. Incidentally the removal of the raft drained the
fertile valley and reclaimed thousands of acres of productive lands.
Tones Bayou outlet is closed by a heavy earthen dam, connected with
the line of levee above and below it, and the main channel, for a time
called "Little River," has widened and scoured until navigation of
the stretch is uninterrupted at low stages. All of the chief outlets
along the right bank above Tones Bayou to the Arkansas-Louisiana
line, 89 miles, have been closed with dams by cooperation with the
State of Louisiana and local levee districts. Work at Alexandria
Falls rendered them naviagble at all stages. The channel was deep-
ened from 2 to 52 feet at the lower falls and to 6 feet at the upper
falls, lengthening the period of navigation about two months. Per-
sistent snagging operations, repeated from year to year, have kept
the river open and enabled steamboats to make regular trips, the river
from the Atchafalaya to Fulton ordinarily being open for boats of
3-foot draft at stages about a foot above zero of the Shreveport gauge.
The maximum draft that can be carried at mean low water is 3 feet to
Montogmery, La., 162.5 miles above the Atchafalaya; 2 feet to
Shreveport, 320.5 miles, and 2 feet to Fulton, Ark., 508.6 miles. The
range between low and high water at the several gauge stations is as
follows: Fulton, Ark., 35.65 feet; Shreveport, La., 41.2 feet; Alex-
andria, La., 45.5 feet, and Barbre Landing, Louisiana (head of
Atchafalaya River), 52.72 feet. Much of the work performed neces-
sarily has been in repetition from time to time, and the items of
improvement and maintenance are so closely allied that the cost of
each can not be given separately.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     513
   At present steamboats seldom run above Fulton, Ark., but at high
stages the river is navigable in fact to Denison, Tex., 292 miles above
Fulton and 800 miles above the Atchafalaya River.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, work for maintenance
of the improvement was continued as follows: Operations of snag
boats, supplemented by those of shore parties during the period of low
water, extended over the river between the head of Atchafalaya
River, Louisiana, and Fulton, Ark., and unusually heavy work was re-
quired on account of the extraordinary flood of 1908, which disturbed
the regimen and deposited many snags in the river. In Bossier Parish,
La., 9,051 linear feet of levee, containing 124,126 cubic yards of
embankment, was built to prevent further breaches in the levee line
at that locality, and 50,700 cubic yards of levee embankment were
built in Lafayette County, Ark., to aid in closing the Spirit Lake Out-
let. A resurvey of the river was made from mouth of Sulphur River,
Arkansas, to head of Cane River, Louisiana, 190.5 miles. Plans were
under preparation for the construction of a hydraulic dredge, required
for the relief of navigation at shoal places during low water.
   To maintain what has been accomplished and to gradually secure a
more stable improvement will require a continuance of work for many
years. The estimated cost is $75,000 a year, or biennial appropria-
tions of $150,000, exclusive of extraordinary demands for new plant
that will arise from time to time.
    Notwithstanding the facilities for quick transportation afforded by
railways, the commerce of Red River until recent years has consisted
of large shipments of cotton, cotton seed and its products, lumber,
staves, timber, etc., with heavy return freights of general merchandise
and plantation supplies.
   The commerce and navigation reported for eighteen years showed
great variations, due to the changing crop conditions, occasional
periods of extraordianry low water during the busy season, and other
causes, ranging in quantity from 66,376 to 279,946 tons per annum,
with estimated values of from $1,506,500 to $9,185,000. The average
for the eighteen years was 123,244 tons, valued at $4,359,900. To this
should be added the commerce from Ouachita River, entering Red
River at the mouth of Black River, the average of which was 178,070
tons, valued at $6,229,560, making a total of 301,314 tons, valued at
 $10,589,460.
   In 1908, however, there was a marked decline of navigation above
the mouth of Black River and the commerce reported in that stretch
only amounted to 36,288 tons, valued at $198,240.
   The project has effected a reduction of freight rates on all com-
modities.
    For more extended information respecting the work performed,
reference is invited to the report and illustrations at page 1909 of the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1893, and to the subsequent
reports of the district officers. Maps of Tones Bayou, Bayou Pierre,
etc., were published in the reports of 1882, page 1542, and 1885, page
1490. An index sketch of the basin of Red River and diagrams show-
ing the limits of high and low water were published in the report of
1891, page 1956, and the report of 1892, page 1587. Maps of the river
at Shreveport were published in the reports of 1887, page 2682, and
1893, page 1921. Map of the river at Alexandria was printed in
House Document No. 462, Fifty-sixth Congress, first session,
      9.QO-   G 1909   3%
514          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                             U.   S. ARMY.

   References were given in the Annual Report of 1904 to reports of
examinations and surveys, with page numbers at which they may be
found. (See Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1904, pp. 385 and 386.)
Report of an examination of Boyce Landing, Red River, Louisiana,
made in 1907, was printed in House Document No. 219, Sixtieth Con-
gress, first session.
   The available funds will be applied to continuing the improvement
and to maintenance.
   The estimated amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, in addition to the balance unexpended July
1, 1909, will be applied to the operation of snag boats and further work
on the existing approved project. This additional work is for main-
tenance and the extension of benefits.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................                        $197, 193. 60
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 . ........
                     .             ................ .........      . ........ ........      65, 000. 00
Amount received from sales of property...........................                               143.40
Amount transferred from appropriation for relief of sufferers from cyclone
  in certain southern States. .............................                ..............   a2, 443. 87


June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  provement....................................................
                                                                                         imn-
                                                                                           264, 780. 87

                                                                                            78, 203. 83

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended................ .......                    ..........     186, 577.04
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.. ................................                     3, 819. 30

July 1, 1909, balance available_...-...-........ -....................                     182, 757. 74

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909................................                           75, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix V 1.)
  2. Cane River, Louisiana.-Cane River is one of the abandoned
channels of Red River, left out on the westward by cut-offs about
1825 and 1849, and is about 75 miles long from Red River near Grand
Ecore to Red River near Colfax. It is made up of pools, bayous, and
swamps, and interrupted by deposits considerably higher than the
average stage of the main river.
  Under the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, $2,500 was expended
for the removal of snags, stumps, caved-in and leaning trees, and
some rock, obstructing high-water navigation. This work freed the
channel of obstructions to a great extent, increased the navigable
depth, and enabled steamboats to make quicker trips at high stages.
Operations were then discontinued. Section 5 of the river and harbor
act of March 3, 1905, declared Cane River to be not a navigable water
of the United States, but this section was repealed by act of Congress
approved June 29, 1906.
   February 27, 1909, the Secretary of War authorized an allotment
of $2,000 from the emergency appropriation provided by the river
  a This is a refundment of actual expenditures made by two snag boats in June and
July, 1908, while temporarily employed by the Quartermaster's Department, and the
amount, therefore, is not included in the total amount expended for the improvement
of Red River,
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                         515
and harbor act of March 2, 1907, to be applied to restoration of the
channel; the shipping interest having reported that the last flood of
Red River caused the banks to cave, and in places so filled the stream
with trees as to prevent navigation.
  The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $2,922.13, of which
$422.13 was applied to maintenance and restoration of the channel
under the recent allotment. At high stages small steamboats from
Red River ascend Cane River from Colfax to Natchitoches, transport-
ing the products of the country, the principal shipments being cotton
seed for mills along Red River.
   In June, 1909, work was performed for the removal of obstructions
in the lower 40 miles of Cane River, restoring the stream to fairly
good navigable condition during the periods of high water. Nothing
further is recommended at the present time.
   For information respecting the work performed under the act of
1884 reference is invited to the reports of 1885, page 1495; 1886, page
1349; and 1887, page 1452.
   Reports of examinations were published in the reports for 1884,
page 1366, and 1891, page 2022, the latter also having been printed in
House Executive Document No. 184, Fifty-first Congress, second ses-
sion.
February 27, 1909, amount allotted from the emergency appropriation pro-
  vided by river and harbor act approved March 2, 1907- -.....                                   .
                                                                                        - - --------           $2, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement .......---------------....................----------------------------...............---------....     422. 13

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended          -.............-.......................                             1, 577. 87
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................                    .................             1,433.78

July 1, 1909, balance available.......................................                                          144. 09
    (See Appendix V 2.)
   3. Ouachita and Black rivers, Arkansas and Louisiana.-The im-
provement of Ouachita River by the United States commenced in
1871. At that time navigation was much obstructed at all stages by
snags, sunken logs, wrecks, leaning and caving trees, etc., and the
greater part of the river was unnavigable at low water on account of
numerous rock, gravel, and sand bars.
   The project of 1871 contemplated temporary improvement from
Trinity, La., to Arkadelphia, Ark., by removal of snags, etc., and
by dredging the worst bars. In 1872 a project was adopted for locks
and dams to give 4 feet depth from Trinity, La., to Camden, Ark.,
but was abandoned two years later. The project under which work
continued after 1874 contemplated the removal of snags, logs, wrecks,
leaning timber, etc., obstructing navigation below Camden, Ark.
The 56 miles known as Black River, below Trinity to Red River,
Louisiana, was added to the project in 1884. The amount expended
on the original and modified projects prior to operations under the
existing project was $614,802.19.
   The existing project, besides a continuation of snagging work, con-
templates the construction of eight locks and movable dams to afford
a navigable depth of 61 feet from the mouth of Black River, Louisi-
ana, upstream to a point 10 miles above Camden, Ark. (360 miles),
as set forth in House Document No. 448, Fifty-seventh Congress,
first session (Report Chief of Engineers, 1902, p. 1435). The
516     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

change of site of Lock and Dam No. 2, referred to in last year's report
(Report Chief of Engineers, 1908, p. 490), will eliminate Lock and
Dam No. 1 from the project. The latter was adopted in part by
provisions of the river and harbor acts of June 13, 1902, and March 3,
1905, authorizing continuing contracts for building Lock and Dam
No. 4, near Monroe, La., and Lock and Dam No. 6, near Roland Raft,
Ark., completing the survey for locks and dams, and maintenance of
prior work. The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, authorized
continuing contracts for the construction of Lock and Dam No. 2,
near Catahoula shoals, Louisiana, and Lock and Dam No. 8, near
Franklin shoals, Arkansas.
   The amount expended under the existing project to June 30, 1909,
was $516,802.10 (including $1,750.26 derived from sales). Of this
amount $11,786.73 has been applied to completion of survey and
$122,471.29 to maintenance.
   A contract for building Locks and Dams Nos. 4 and 6, let Septem-
ber 7, 1904, provided for their completion by December 31, 1906, but
this time limit was waived. Work commenced October 28, 1904,
but abnormally high-river stages-limited the time of actual construc-
tion to two hundred and ten working days during the fiscal years 1905,
1906, 1907, and 1908. Previous gauge records for fourteen years,
from July, 1890, to July, 1904, showed the yearly average working
stage (below 10 feet on the Monroe gauge) to be one hundred and
forty-one working days. On June 30, 1908, the condition of the
work was as follows: On the basis of work done, Lock and Dam No.
4 about 20 per cent completed, Lock and Dam No. 6 about 8 per cent
completed. On the basis of work done and material delivered, Lock
and Dam No. 4 is about 31 per cent completed, and Lock and Dam
No. 6 about 11 per cent completed. Nothing further was done by
the contractors, and their contract was terminated by an agreement
dated October 22, 1908, under which the contractor's plant, material,
and buildings were transferred to the United States. Construction
work at Lock No. 4 was undertaken at once by hired labor, but the
date on which the contract was terminated, the condition of the plant
and cofferdam left by the contractor precluded the hope of accom-
plishing any important amount of permanent construction during
the low-water season of 1908. Barges, machinery, camp buildings,
etc., were repaired, and as soon as the necessary plant could be pre-
pared, the work of reenforcing the cofferdam made necessary by
scour in the river was commenced and continued during the remainder
of the season. Since the termination of the low water in February,
1909, further work was continued in preparing plant, buildings, and
material for active operations during the coming low-water period.
   Proposals for building Lock 6 were advertised for two months, but
only one bid was received, aggregating $213,190.50, upon the esti-
mates of quantities used for canvassing bids. The price bid for con-
crete work, which is the controlling factor, was considerably in excess
of the corresponding unit price in the contract of 1908 for Lock 2 and
after reserving from the appropriation the amount necessary for com-
pleting Lock 4 without the dam, the balance available was insuffi-
cient to cover the cost of the construction contemplated at Lock 6
and the bidder declined to perform a less amount of work at his unit
prices. Paragraph 10 of the sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909,
rendered funds which it was expected to employ for work at Lock 6
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    517
not available, but this difficulty was removed by Congress and infor-
mation relative thereto furnished the district officer June 28, 1909.
   On account of the longer time required for construction of Locks
and Dams 4 and 6 than originally estimated, due to the failure of the
contractors to complete their contract, together with the scour which
has taken place in the river at Lock and Dam No. 4 coincident with
this delay, and on account of additions to the original designs thought
necessary to secure the work, etc., the amount estimated as required
to complete the existing project as far as it refers to these two locks
and dams has been increased $439,000.
   Proposals for building Lock and Dam No. 2 at Harrisonburg, La.,
were advertised for two months, and two bids for the work were
received; but they exceeded the sum authorized for construction of
both lock and dam, and a contract was made August 7, 1908, with the
lowest bidder, to build the lock alone at an estimated cost of
$296,694.50, exclusive of engineering and contingencies. This con-
tract provides for completion of the lock within two hundred and
fifty working days during which natural conditions are such as to
permit work inside of the cofferdam. The contractor commenced
work promptly and erected camp buildings, assembled plant, and
commenced the construction of the cofferdam. The latter work
was continued as the river stage permitted until February 6, when the
round piling therefor had been driven and the upper line of waling
placed with the exception of a 60-foot gap left for the passage of
barges. During the remainder of the year the contractor continued
preparations for further work during the coming low-water season.
   At Lock No. 8 work by hired labor, which was commenced in Decem-
ber, 1907 (see Report for 1908, p. 1570), was continued and the
mound, the machine shop, and all camp buildings except an auxiliary
cement storehouse at the concrete-mixer platform were completed.
On June 30, 1909, the cofferdam, except a gap of 40 feet at the lower
outer corner, and excavation for the lock foundation were practically
completed. A considerable amount of material for permanent con-
struction, including round and sheet piling, sand and gravel, cement
and embedded metal had been procured and further preparations
made for proceeding with permanent construction.
    During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, snagging work for
maintenance extended from the mouth of Black River, Louisiana, to
Camden, Ark., 350 miles upstream, with greatly beneficial results,
and about 5,141 cubic yards of mud and gravel were excavated from
the channel at Catahoula shoals, Louisiana, in making a cut 60 feet
wide and 450 feet long. This work increased the depth from about
40 inches to near 9 feet.
    Besides the slack-water improvement the work heretofore done has
consisted chiefly of the removal of snags, logs, wrecks, leaning tim-
ber, tree slides, etc., for the purpose of maintaining navigation and
the improvement of Catahoula shoals, a rock and gravel bar about
20 miles above Trinity, La., where the available depth at low water
was increased from 15 to 40 inches. At moderately high stages, or
for six to seven months of the year, New Orleans steamboats ascend
the river to Camden, Ark.; at medium stages they run to Monroe,
La., but during the periods of low water Harrisonburg, La., 72 miles
above Red River, is considered the head of navigation, though small
local packets make trips between points on the river above. The
518     REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.       S. ARMY.

maximum draft that can be carried at mean low water is 3 feet to
Harrisonburg, La.; 1 feet to Monroe, La., and 8 inches to Camden,
Ark. The range between high and low water at the several gauge
stations on Ouachita River is as follows: Camden, Ark., 44.2 feet;
Monroe, La., 48.6 feet; Riverton, La., 51.3 feet, and Jonesville, La.,
54.1 feet. Camden, Ark., is considered the head of navigation, but
at high stages the river is navigable in fact to Arkadelphia, Ark.
   The commerce of Ouachita River and its tributaries is considerable
and consists of shipments of cotton, cotton seed, lumber, staves, saw
logs, and miscellaneous articles, with return freights of general mer-
chandise and plantation supplies. Most of the cotton is shipped to
New Orleans, and large quantities of staves for export are sent to
that city. The volume of commerce, as reported for nineteen years,
ranges between 73,679 and 313,863 tons per annum, with values
estimated at $3,243,200 to $10,234,250. The average is 176,968 tons,
valued at $6,220,150. The variations are due to crop yields, the
uncertainty of navigation, droughts, and other causes, and the im-
provement by locks and dams is for an extension of benefits by afford-
ing navigation to Camden the year round.
   The project has effected a reduction of railroad rates from New
Orleans to Monroe, La., and points below to meet the steamboat
rates. The territory above Monroe was opened to railroad traffic a
few years ago, but the lines as yet have not met the water rates.
During periods of navigation the rate on cotton from Monroe to New
Orleans is $1.25 per bale, but when navigation is suspended this
rate is advanced to $1.75 per bale. Railroad rates from Monroe, La.,
to inland towns, as a rule, are greatly in excess of those to points
where there is water competition.
   For more extended information respecting this improvement, refer-
ence is invited to the Report of 1895 (p. 1887) and to subsequent
reports of the district officers.
   An index to reports of examinations and surveys was published in
the Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1904, page 389..
   The estimated amount of $513,000 that can be profitably expended
in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in addition to the balance
unexpended July 1, 1909, will be applied to continuing construction
of locks and dams; to removing obstructions, including snags, over-
hanging trees, drift, etc.; and to maintaining and operating snag and
dredge boats. This additional work is necessary to make the improve-
ment available and for maintenance and the extension of benefits.
   The short working season on Ouachita River, the alluvial nature of
the river bottom, which requires the use of piling for foundations in
lock and dam structures, the necessity of obtaining detailed informa-
tion as to the character of the underlying material, and the desira-
bility of making tests, plans, and local surveys render it advisable to
have funds available for expenditure in preliminary work at lock and
dam sites proposed in the general project for improvement other than
those for which funds have been provided. Such a provision would
expedite the work when funds for construction are provided and
would permit of an economical arrangement for labor and plant. It
is recommended that $8,000 be provided for these purposes.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             519

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..........          .....................                  $664, 245. 11
Amount received from sales of property ...........          .............  ...                    177. 65
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...                            176, 135. 00
Amounts allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...........................         .. .....................                  160, 000. 00
                                                                                           1, 000, 557. 76
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ..........................                    $166, 286. 55
    For constructing snag boat.......................                        13, 592. 18
    For maintenance of improvement...-..................                     21, 664. 06
                                                                                             201, 542. 79
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. .................................                          799, 014. 97
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities_............................                 ....       18, 812. 52

July 1, 1909, balance available...................                    ................       780, 202. 45

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..............                          302, 904. 32
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project a ......                      603, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...............       .............                    513, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix V 3.)
   4. Bayou Bartholomew, Boeuf River, Tensas River and Bayou
Macon, and Bayous D'Arbonne and Corney, Louisiana and Arkan-
sas.-These streams are tributaries of Ouachita River and are not
navigable at low stages. The works were consolidated by the river
and harbor act of June 13, 1902. The improvements are all of the
same character, i. e., the removal of snags, wrecks, leaning timber,
etc., to lessen the danger and lengthen the period of navigation.
Drift, sliding and caving banks, and the rapid growth of vegetation
constantly add obstructions.
   (a) Bayou Bartholomew, Louisiana and Arkansas.-Before im-
provement this stream was navigable for light boats about three
months of the year. In 1880 an examination showed that passage-
way for steamboats was much obstructed.
   The project adopted March 3, 1881, contemplated removing
obstructions between the mouth and Baxter, Ark., 182 miles.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $66,866.97. The
project practically was completed in 1897 to McComb Landing, Ark.,
the present head of navigation, 141 miles, at a cost of $45,873.53.
This work resulted in safer navigation, increased the period to about
six months of the year, enabled boats to make trips in half the time
formerly required, and reduced freight rates about 50 per cent. There
being no demand for navigation above McComb Landing, subsequent
expenditures were for maintenance, and $20,993.44 has been applied
to that purpose.
   Operations for maintenance during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1909, extended from the mouth to Point Pleasant, La., 28.7 miles,
and put that part of the stream in fair navigable condition.
  a Estimated cost of completing Locks and Dams Nos. 4 and 6, $439,000, and Locks
and Dams Nos. 2 and 8, $164,000.
520            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                            S. ARMY.

   The commerce consists of shipments, of cotton, cotton seed, staves,
saw logs, etc., with return freights of general merchandise and plan-
tation supplies. Much of the trade has been diverted to railroads, as
the stages of the bayou frequently are not coincident with the needs
of transportation. The commerce for nineteen years ranges between
a maximum of 49,299 tons in 1891 and a minimum of 1,502 tons in
1907, the average being 12,000 tons, valued at $307,640.
   The available funds and the estimated amount that can be profit-
ably expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, will be applied
to removal of snags, overhanging trees, drift, etc., for maintenance.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................................$2, 020. 49
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909......-------------------..------.........---------...----.......---------........--...... 4, 000. 00
                                                                                                                  6, 020. 49
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement-----........-...--.-------------------...................---....--.----...-.........------------.   1, 887. 46

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ........-.............                                 -.. ............          4, 133. 03
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1,1909......... ....................................                                                 (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Boeuf River, Louisiana.-Before improvement this river was
navigable to Point Jefferson, 151 miles, but passage was difficult and
dangerous on account of overhanging timber and snags and logs in
the channel.
  The project adopted March 3, 1881, contemplated removing these
obstructions to 'afford safe navigation at high stages to Wallace
Landing, La., about 170 miles above the mouth. Under the river
and harbor act of 1886 a supplemental project was entered upon for
the closure of three outlets near Point Jefferson to confine the flow
to the main channel.
  The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $68,243.53. The
original project was completed in 1896 at a cost of $40,992.84. Since
then $21,808.91 (including $27.75 received from sales) has been
expended for maintenance. In 1887-88, by uniting with planters
whose lands would be protected from overflow, the outlets near Point
Jefferson were closed by earthen dams, the proportion of the cost
borne by the United States having been $5,441.78.
  The work put the stream in safe navigable condition at stages high
enough to permit steamboats to cross the bars and, when completed,
enabled them to save thirty-six hours' time on a trip.
   The closure of the outlets gave immediate benefit to navigation by
concentrating the flow to the main stream, lengthening the period of
navigation, and causing the bars to scour. The dams, however, were
destroyed in 1890, during an overflow from Mississippi River, caused
by crevasses in the levees near the headwaters of Boeuf River, and
funds for their restoration have not been provided.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, snagging work and the
removal of leaning trees, etc., extended from the mouth upstream to
                           a See consolidated money statement on page 523.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             521
Point Jefferson, La., 150.8 miles, and the chief obstructions of this
character were destroyed for the time.
   The commerce consists of shipments of cotton, cotton seed, staves,
etc., and return freights of general merchandise and plantation sup-
plies, and for nineteen years ranges between a maximum of 11,261
tons in 1897 and a minimum of 545 tons in 1903, the average being
5,459 tons, valued at $232,400.
   The available funds and the additional amount estimated for the
fiscal year 1911 will be applied to maintenance by the removal of
obstructions, including snags, overhanging trees, drift, etc. This
additional work is for extension of benefits.
   Navigation is rendered more difficult on account of the outlets at
Point Jefferson, and additional interest in the project for again closing
them is maintained through the necessity of draining Bayou Lafourche
Basin, into which the outlets flow, to permit development of a rich
tract of land containing 220,800 acres, much of which has been con-
verted into a swamp and all of which is seriously affected by flood
water from Boeuf River.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................... $5, 518. 59
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.................................................         4, 000.00
Amount received from sales of property ...............................       27.75

                                                                                                 9, 546. 34
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.......................................    ..............                           3, 362.12

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........           ...... ..........        ........   .....   6, 184.22
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                          145. 90

July 1, 1909, balance available..........-..              .   .....   ....   ........      ..    6, 038. 32

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the. balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.... .....- ......-.........    ....................                          (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Tensas River and Bayou Macon.-Before improvement these
streams were navigable at high stages, but the passage of steamboats
was difficult and dangerous on account of leaning timber and numer-
ous snags, logs, stumps, etc., in the channel.
   The project adopted March 3, 1881, contemplated removing obstruc-
tions in Tensas River from its mouth to Dallas, La., 138 miles.
Bayou Macon, the chief commercial branch of Tensas River, was
added under the same head of appropriation by river and harbor act
of 1884, and the project contemplated the same kind of work from its
mouth to Floyd, La., 112 miles.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1909, were $58,527.75. The
project for Tensas River was completed in 1898 to Westwood Place,
81 miles above the mouth, the present head of navigation, at a cost of
$11,947.02, and the project for Bayou Macon to Floyd was completed
in 1899 at a cost of $23,915.42. Lane Ferry, about 20 miles above
Floyd, is the head of navigation in Bayou Macon. The sum of
$22,665.31, including $27.75 derived from sales, has been expended
for maintenance. The work put the two streams in fairly good
                       a See consolidated money statement on page 523.
522             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

navigable condition at medium and high stages. Upper Tensas
River above Westwood Place practically is unnavigable by reason of
leaning timber and obstructions in the channel, and there has been
no recent effort to induce a resettlement of the abandoned plantations
along its banks or to secure a continuance of the improvement to
Dallas.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, work for maintenance
was continued and consisted of the removal of snags, leaning trees,
etc., obstructing navigation of Tensas River between Westwood
Place and its mouth. No work was performed in Bayou Macon.
   The commerce consists chiefly of shipments of cotton, cotton seed,
staves, etc., and return freights of plantation supplies. In nineteen
years it has ranged between a maximum of 29,957 tons in 1905 and a
minimum of 2,649 tons in 1893, the average being 15,187 tons, valued
at $612,340.
   It is proposed to apply the available funds to maintenance, and the
additional estimate for the fiscal year 1911 to the removal of obstruc-
tions, including snags, overhanging trees, drift, etc. This additional
work is for maintenance and extension of benefits.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..------..--.............----------..---------------.............                        $3, 912. 99
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909--....---.----------------...............---........-------............--------------......---...... ---- 5, 000. 00
Amount received from sales of property. ..................                                              .............         27. 75

                                                                                                                      8, 940. 74
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement........................ .........................                                                       3,940.74

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................                                      ................              5, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 ...........       .................................                                               (a)
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (d) Bayous D'Arbonne and Corney, Louisiana.-Before improve-
ment navigation of these streams was difficult and dangerous on ac-
count of the leaning trees and the number of snags, stumps, etc., in
the channel.
  The project adopted July 5, 1884, contemplated removing the
obstructions between the mouth of Bayou D'Arbonne and Stein Bluff
on Bayou Corney, 402 miles upstream. The river and harbor act of
1892 authorized an extension of work up Bayou Corney 162 miles to
Cobb Landing, and the act of 1894 provided $1,000 for removing
obstructions in the Little D'Arbonne Branch.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $23,974.95, and resulted
in greater safety to navigation. The work practically was completed
in 1896 at a cost of $18,000. Subsequent expenditures for mainte-
nance have amounted to $4,974.95, and $1,000 was expended for
improving Little D'Arbonne Branch.
   No work was done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, as
the stages were not favorable since the allotment was made for its
continuance.
  The commerce consists of shipments of cotton, cotton seed, etc.,
and return freights of plantation supplies. It varies considerably,
                            a See consolidated money statement on page 523.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                523

and during thirteen years ranged between a maximum of 36,272 tons
in 1907 and a minimum of 682 tons in 1903, the average being 11,369
tons, valued at $317,420.
   The estimated amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, and the balance unexpended July 1, 1909,
will be applied to removal of obstructions, including snags, over-
hanging trees, drift, etc. This additional work is for maintenance
and extension of benefits.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................     .............        $125. 05
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909. ............... ..................... ...................... 2,000.00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................................                                              2, 125. 05
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.............-------------------------------..................-------------...................       (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   A condensed history of the work performed in Bayou Bartholo-
mew, Boeuf River, and Tensas River and Bayou Macon will be found
in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, pages 1601-1613,
and of that performed in Bayous D'Arbonne and Corney in the Re-
port of 1895, page 1914. Subsequent reports of the district officers
refer only to the yearly operations.
   An index to reports of examinations and surveys was published in
the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 391.
   There is no record of freight rates on Bayou Bartholomew and
works consolidated with it available for making a comparison of the
effect of the improvement. In a general way it may be stated that
the rates have been greatly reduced; in fact, the traffic is no longer
sufficiently lucrative to support the class of boats formerly plying
on this stream, but it is now carried by smaller boats. This is largely
due, however, to the competition by the railroads, and now boats ply
only where the river is the only shipping route.
                                                     CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended                   ............................... $11, 577. 12
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909---...---...................................................         15, 000. 00
Amount received from sales of property ................................                  55. 50
                                                                                                                      26, 632. 62
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.................................................................                                         9, 190. 32

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.................................                                                     17, 442. 30
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                                                145. 90


IAmount
July 1, 1909, balance available....................................... .
           that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.......      ...................................
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
                                                                          16, 000. 00
                                                                                                                      17, 296. 40




   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix V 4.)
                          a See consolidated money statement on this page.
524     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.


   5. Mouth of Yazoo River and harbor at Vicksburg, Miss.-The
shifting bar at the former mouth of the Yazoo was the most serious
obstruction to navigation of that river and its tributaries, a system
comprising about 800 miles of navigable waterways. At low stages
steamboats were prevented from entering or leaving the river with-
out lightering their cargoes across the bar, and it frequently happened
that the outlet was entirely closed to navigation throughout the busi-
est season of the year.
   Prior to 1876 the city of Vicksburg possessed the most commanding
site and the finest harbor on the Mississippi River. There was deep
water along the city front, and the entire width of the river was
available for steamboats at all stages, with not less than 25 feet depth
in any part of the harbor. The cut-off of April 27, 1876, and subse-
quent shoaling of the old channel from the river to the front of the
city, practically destroyed the harbor, which became unnavigable
except at high stages.
   The original project for improving Vicksburg Harbor was entered
upon under the river and harbor act of June 18, 1878. The first work
consisted of revetting the rapidly caving bank at Delta Point, La.,
opposite Vicksburg, the continued recession of which was increasing
the distance from the harbor to the river channel. The river and
harbor act of August 2, 1882, placed the work under the Mississippi
River Commission, and the revetment at Delta Point was continued
until 1900. No work has been done since. Some caving has occurred
above the upper end of the revetment, which is protected by a hard
point, but there appears to be no immediate danger of flanking. The
amount expended at Delta Point was $389,486.08.
   When Vicksburg Harbor was placed under the Mississippi River
Commission in 1882, a project was adopted for dredging a basin 1,700
feet long by 300 feet wide in front of the city, with a canal 150 feet
wide to connect it with the river. Dredging under this project
amounted to 250,035 cubic yards in 1883, when discontinued. It was
resumed in 1888, under a slightly modified project, and continued
until 1893. During the latter period the dredging amounted to
1,729,994 cubic yards, making a total of 2,080,029 cubic yards of exca-
vation. In 1888 pile dikes were built at the north end of the basin
and along the west side of the canal, aggregating 6,800 feet in length.
The expenditures for Vicksburg Harbor were $442,724.77, which,
added to the amount expended at Delta Point, makes a total of
 $832,210.85. The improvement of Vicksburg Harbor was transferred
to the Engineer Department under a provision of the river and harbor
act of August 18, 1894.
    The existing project, adopted by Congress in the river and harbor
act of July 13, 1892, contemplated opening a new mouth or outlet for
Yazoo River from its original mouth on Old River (9.8 miles above
the former outlet to the Mississippi) through deep water down the
wrong end of Old River, thence across a neck of low land between Old
River and Lake Centennial and around the head of De Soto Island
and down the east arm of Lake Centennial to the Mississippi River,
entering it upon the channel side at Kleinston Landing.
    Lake Centennial is the old bend of the Mississippi River cut-off in
1876, and De Soto Island, prior to the cut-off, was the Louisiana
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   525
peninsula, around which the river flowed. The estimate of cost-
$1,500,000-was revised in 1893 and reduced to $1,200,000.
   The work was completed in 1905 at a cost of $1,179,210.87. Subse-
quent expenditures for maintenance amount to $34,788.58. The new
outlet was opened in the spring of 1903; uninterrupted navigation of
Vicksburg Harbor has been maintained for six years, and the new
mouth of Yazoo River has been open to boats of 6 feet draft at mean
low water. The extreme range between high and low water at Vicks-
burg is 59 feet, but the usual variation is about 45.3 feet.
   The chief features of this work were the purchase of 1,155.54 acres
of land for right of way of the main cut from Old River to Lake Cen-
tennial; the clearing and grubbing of the entire route; the excavation
by dredging of 6,229,281 cubic yards of earth in opening the new
outlet, of which about 934,000 cubic yards was used for building a
dam, above ordinary low water, across the west arm of Lake Centen-
nial from mouth of the main cut to head of De Soto Island, and con-
structing a levee containing 429,677 cubic yards from mouth of the
canal at Kleinston westward along West Pass bar (which separates
the west arm of Lake Centennial from Mississippi River) to within
about 4,500 feet of King Point.
   The work performed during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909,
was for maintenance, principally for repairs and protection of the
West Pass levee. Expenditures of $40,000 for revetment of West
Pass levee on the lake side, to protect it from wave wash, and to
replace decaying wooden bulkheads, and $4,000 for surveys, were
authorized and allotments for the purposes were made under section 1
of the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909. The revetment was
partially built in April and May, 1909, 1,194 squares having been
paved. It will be completed during the fiscal year 1910, and the
surveys will be made during the period of low water.
   The annual commerce of Yazoo River, its tributaries, and Vicks-
burg Harbor, as reported for seven years, varied between 222,792 and
441,765 tons, the estimated values of which ranged from $6,801,000
to $13,272,000 per annum. The average of the commerce was 321,594
tons per annum, and the average value $8,753,650.
    Maps of the work at Delta Point have been published in Annual
Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1883, 1884, 1888, 1889, 1893,
and 1900: Maps of Vicksburg Harbor accompany the reports of
1878 (p.644), 1883, 1884, 1888, 1890, and 1893. Maps showing work
under the existing project for diverting the mouth of Yazoo River,
etc., accompany the reports of 1893, 1894, 1901, and 1902. Fifteen
photographs were printed in the report for 1900.
    The estimated amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, will be applied to maintenance by dredging
in Old River.
526           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                           U.   S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................              ...................     $7, 844.71
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909. ..-. - ....... .. ................     ....... ...................      ... 44, 000. 0(1

                                                                         51, 844. 71
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of im-
  provement.........................................................     21, 844.16
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                   30, 000.55
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities................................                         402.31
July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                   29, 598. 24
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...........................................         8,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix V 5.)
   6. Yazoo, Tallahatchie, Coldwater, and Big Sunflower rivers, and
Tchula Lake, Mississippi.-Theseimprovements were consolidated by
river and harbor act of June 13, 1902. The same kind of work is
required in all, i. e., the removal of wrecks, snags, stumps, tree slides,
sunken logs, leaning timber, etc., for maintenance of navigation.
   (a) Yazoo River.-Before improvement the period of navigation
was limited to high stages on which steamboats could pass the wrecks
of gunboats, steamers, and raft sunk during the civil war. The chan-
nel was much obstructed also by snags, stumps, tree slides, leaning
timber, etc.
   The project entered upon March 3, 1873, contemplated removing
obstructions to give ease and safety to navigation. Subsequent acts
of Congress provided for continuing the improvement and for main-
tenance. There is no practical distinction between improvement and
maintenance, as floods, sliding and caving banks, and the rapid
growth of vegetation along alluvial streams of this kind constantly
add obstructions and render a continuance of snagging operations
necessary in the interest of safe and uninterrupted navigation.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1909 (including $203.26 derived
from sales), was $404,508.94, which has resulted in safe and uninter-
rupted navigation from mouth to head of the river the year round
for more than twenty-five years. Steamboats of 31 feet draft navi-
gate the river at mean low water without serious difficulty.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, snagging operations,
etc., for maintenance, extended over the entire river.
   The range between high and low water at Yazoo City is 40.8 feet.
It is proposed to apply the available funds to continuing work for
maintenance of the improvement.
   The estimated amount that can be profitably expended in the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, in addition to the balance unexpended
July 1, 1909, will be applied to removal of obstructions, including
snags, overhanging trees, drift, etc., and the maintenance and opera-
tion of snag and dredge boats. This additional work is for mainte-
nance and extension of benefits.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                         527
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..............                   ...  ..........           $65, 059.18
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.............        ..................................                       10, 000. 00
Amount received from sales of property ...................                        .........       92. 80

                                                                                            75,151.98
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For constructing snag boat. .............      .........    $12, 363.17
    For maintenance of improvement ..............       ....... 20, 094. 49
    Amount transferred to Tallahatchie and Coldwater rivers.      1, 500. 00
                                                                                            33, 957. 66
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................                           41, 194. 32
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities............... .......................                    813. 92

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                       40, 380. 40
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909............................................                             (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Tallahatchie and Coldwater rivers.-Before improvement Tal-
lahatchie River was navigable to Sharkey, about 65 miles above its
mouth, for six months of the year, but passage was difficult and dan-
gerous on account of the number of obstructions in the channel and
along the banks, and the wreck of the ocean steamship Star of the
West, sunk February, 1863, 8 miles above the mouth. Above Sharkey
the growth of leaning timber was so dense and the channel so
obstructed by snags, etc., that that part of the stream practically was
unnavigable. The same conditions continued up the Coldwater
River.
   The project entered upon March 3, 1879, contemplated removing
obstructions in Tallahatchie River from the head of Yazoo River to
the mouth of Coldwater River and up the Coldwater about 80 miles
to Yazoo Pass. Work in the Coldwater River was abandoned in
1881, but was resumed under a provision of the river and harbor act
of March 3, 1905.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909 (including $40 derived from
sales), was $84,031.36, and the work performed permits steamboats
of 3 feet draft to run to Sharkey the year round and into Coldwater
River at moderately high stages.
   Marks, on Coldwater River, is considered the present head of navi-
gation, and boats rarely run above that place.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, work for the removal
of obstructions in Tallahatchie River was continued between Minter
City and Yazoo River, 68" miles, benefitting navigation materially.
   Work in Coldwater River extended from its mouth upstream to
Yazoo Pass, but was not thorough on account of interruptions and
unfavorable conditions caused by high stages.
   Operations for maintenance will be continued with the available
funds.
                       a See consolidated money statement on page 531.
528           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                   U.      S. ARMY.

   The estimated amount that can be profitably expended during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in addition to the balance unex-
pended July 1, 1909, will be applied to the removal of obstructions,
including snags, overhanging trees, drift, etc., and the maintenance
and operation of snag and dredge boats. This additional work is for
maintenance and extension of benefits.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................                                            $2, 411. 89
Amount transferred from allotment for Yazoo River .........                                  ........          1, 500. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1909 ............................................. ......... 10, 000. 00
Amount received from sales of property .............................                                 ......        40. 00

                                                                                                              13, 951. 89
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...................................   .......... ........                                        4, 943.25
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ....................................                                         9, 008. 64
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................               .................                       1, 127. 85
July 1, 1909, balance available .-................                     .......         ...........             7, 880. 79
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...........................................                                                (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) TallahatchieRiver above mouth of Coldwater River to Batesville.-
To comply with requirements of river and harbor acts of 1880, 1881,
and 1882, a total expenditure of $10,000 was made to clear this
stretch of obstructing trees, stumps, and snags, after which work was
discontinued by the United States. Commerce was revived in 1904,
and, after the worst obstructions had been removed by popular sub-
scription, about 2,100 tons of stave and spoke billets and other
freight, valued at $100,000, was transported by steamboat.
   The project entered upon March 2, 1907, contemplated an expendi-
ture of $2,000 a year for a series of years to put the river in such
condition that boats plying the lower Tallahatchie can safely run to
Batesville for five to seven months of the year, eventually the cost
of maintenance to be reduced to $1,000 per year.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $13,824.89.
The work was resumed in May, 1907, after a lapse of twenty-five
years, and was continued downstream to the mouth of Coldwater
River. The chief obstructions to navigation were removed and the
stretch placed in fairly good navigable condition. The cost of this
maintenance was $3,824.89; and the work proved heavier and more
difficult than was anticipated.
   No work was performed during the fiscal year 1909 for lack of
funds during the period of low water.
 " The recent allotment and the estimated amount that can be
profitably expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
will be applied to the removal of obstructions, including snags,
overhanging trees, drift, etc., and the maintenance and operation of
snag and dredge boats. This additional work is for maintenance
and extension of benefits.
                         o   See consolidated money statement               on page 531.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVE1VENTS.                              529
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............................                     $175. 11
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ...............................................................   5, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................            5, 175. 11
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.............................................                 (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor of 1899.
   (d) Big Sunflower River.Before improvement this stream was
navigable about six months of the year, but was obstructed by snags,
sunken logs, sand bars, and shoals; navigation was impeded by lean-
ing timber, and at many places the channel was so choked with ob-
structions and so narrow that it afforded passage for the smallest
craft only.
   The project entered upon March 3, 1879, contemplated the removal
of obstructions between the mouth and Clarksdale, about 180 miles,
and the building of inexpensive pile and brush wing dams to scour
depths of about 40 inches at the bars. Prior to the building of the
Mississippi River levees, and since, when crevasses in the levees
occurred, this stream carried large quantities of overflow water and
its section was increased thereby. In this enlarged bed the normal
river at low stages now flows between secondary banks and, as a rule,
the main banks are not overtopped by floods, except near the mouth,
where the flood height is affected by backwater from the Mississippi.
   On account of the changed conditions, the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, placed the upper limit of improvement at the mouth
of Hushpuckena River, about 30 miles below Clarksdale; authorized
a continuation of the work of removing obstructions below that point,
and an improvement of the lower section, below Baird, about 87
miles, with a view to obtaining a navigable depth of 3 feet by means
of the closure of outlets and more extensive contraction works. The
estimates of cost for work below Baird were $75,000 for the necessary
closing dams, about $10,000 per year for five years for continuation
of the open-river work, and $5,000 per year thereafter.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $166,375.20. The cut-
ting of leaning timber, removal of channel obstructions, and the
building and renewal of wing dams at the bars maintained naviga-
tion in the lower 100 miles of river, and enabled boats of 30 inches
draft to run to Woodburn, about 77 miles above the mouth, at mean
low water. Faisonia, about 100 miles above the mouth, is considered
the head of navigation. A contract was entered into November 12,
1907, for closing the chutes in lower Big Sunflower River, requiring
118,755 cubic yards of levee embankment, and the work has now
been completed.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, operations for main-
tenance continued during the period of low water, between the mouth
of Big Sunflower River and a point 4 miles above Baird, and con-
sisted of the removal of snags, leaning timber, etc., obstructing nav-
igation and the construction and repair of wing dams at shoal places.
   The contract for closing the chutes in lower Big Sunflower River
was completed February 20, 1909.
                       a See consolidated money statement on page 531.
         9001-ENG 1909--34
530           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   It is proposed to apply the nvailable funds and the additional ap-
propriation recommended to a continuance of snagging operations
and the building and repair of wing dams where required.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................... $85, 478. 68
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
                                                                              ------------- 48, 853. 88
  improvement---------......------..--------.....................-------------..................
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.---....  ............   ..................                           36, 624. 80
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..-..................................                             1, 582.17

July 1, 1909, balance available-.................                          ................           35, 042. 63
IAmount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...................................                                   (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (e) Tchula Lake.-This is an arm of Yazoo River, about 60 miles
long, and east of Honey Island, in Holmes County. Before improve-
ment it was obstructed its entire length by a network of snags;
heavy leaning timber, and a thick growth of brush along both banks.
   The project adopted March 3, 1881, contemplated removal of the
obstructions to prolong the navigable period and to permit light-
draft steamboats to pass through the lake earlier in the cotton season.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $31,962.09. The ork
was practically completed and the stream put in safe navigable con-
dition in 1895 at an expenditure of $21,000. Since 1902 $10,962.09
has been expended for maintenance.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, work for maintenance
extended from the head of the lake do nstream about 35 miles to
near Black Bayou, and consisted of the removal of snags, leaning
trees, etc., obstructing navigation.
   The available funds .ill be applied to continuing work for mainte-
nance.
   The estimated amount that can be profitably expended during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in addition to the balance unex-
pended July 1, 1909, will be applied to the removal of obstructions,
including snags, overhanging trees, drift, etc., and the maintenance
and operation of snag and dredge boats. This additional ,.ork is for
maintenance and extension of benefits.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................... $4, 290. 65
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........................................................   5, 000. 00

                                                                         9, 290. 65
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of im-
  provement.....---.................. ... ........ ... ................. 3, 252. 74
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................                         ..................    6, 037. 91
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.. ................................                                   80. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                                  5, 957. 91
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.............................................                                       (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                         a See consolidated money statement on page 531,
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                531
   The chief shipments of Yazoo River and tributaries are cotton,
cotton seed, staves, timber, etc., with return freights of general mer-
chandise and plantation supplies. The commerce of eighteen years
ranges between 102,098 and 544,503 tons annually, with values esti-
mated at $2,840,000 to $9,198,000, the average being 241,573 tons,
valued at $5,590,330.
   Freight rates on cotton by boat are about 50 per cent less than by
rail; on cotton seed about 333 per cent less. Live-stock shipments by
boat cost about one-third of the railroad rates, and grain, flour, meal,
and provisions shipped by boat cost about 50 per cent less than by
rail. To inland points the railroad rates are largely in excess of boat
rates for the same distance. Large quantities of timber are rafted
which could not be reached by rail.
   A resume of the work performed in Yazoo, Tallahatchie, and Big
Sunflower rivers is given in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1896, pages 1613, 1626, and 1630. A r6sum6 of work in Coldwater
River is given in the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1885, page
1518. Subsequent annual reports of the district officers give each
year's operations only.
   An index to reports of examinations and surveys was published in
the Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 397. Reports of
examinations of Tallahatchie River above mouth of Coldwater to
Batesville, and of Big Sunflower River, made in 1905, were printed
in House Documents Nos. 147 and 667, Fifty-ninth Congress, first
session. Reports of an examination and survey of Big Sunflower
River from near Baird to mouth of lHushpuckena River, made in 1907
and 1908, were printed in House Document No. 1251, Sixtieth Con-
gress, second session.
                                   CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................... $157,415. 51
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..-.........-....   ..      .....................       30, 000. 00
Amount received from sales of property...............................      132. 80
                                                                            187, 548. 31
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For constructing snag boat............................ $12, 363. 17
    For maintenance of improvement.....................     77, 146. 36
                                                                             89, 507. 53

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................... 98, 040. 78
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities --......--                        3, 603. 94
                                          ..---- ---.......-----..................

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................   ...............    94, 436. 84
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ..................................         57, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix V 6.)
  7. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navi-
gation.-Duringthe fiscal year the wreck of the steamer J. A. Townes
was removed from Yazoo River at a cost of $118.86. The cost of
the work was afterwards paid by the owners of the vessel and the
amount received, $118.86, was deposited in the Treasury to the
credit of miscellaneous receipts.
532       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                 S. ARMY.

EXAMINATION      AND SURVEY MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
                 HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports dated October 16, 1907, and October 20, 1908, respectively,
on preliminary examination and survey of Big Sunflower River,
Mississippi, from near Baird to the mouth of the Hushpuckcena River,
etc., required by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, were duly
submitted by the district officer.        'I
                                     hey wvere reviewed by the Board
of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant to law, and were
transmitted to Congress and printed in House Document No. 1251,
Sixtieth Congress, second session. The locality is not considered
worthy of improvement at the present time in the manner proposed.

IMPROVEMENT        OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE LITTLE ROCK,
                         ARKANSAS, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Capt. W. D. Connor, Corps of Engi-
neers, to October 31, 1908; of Capt. G. R. Lukesh, Corps of Engineers,
from October 31, to December 7, 1908; and of Maj. M. L. Walker,
Corps of Engineers, since the latter date. Division engineer, Col.
W. H. Bixby, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Arkansas River, Arkansas.-In its original condition the channel
of the river was greatly obstructed by shifting sand bars and numer-
ous snags in its lower reaches, and by gravel and rock shoals and
some snags in its upper reaches. Navigation was difficult and uncer-
tain at medium and low stages, and during periods of extreme low
water was impossible.
   Prior to act of Congress approved June 13, 1902, the work on
this river was carried on under two general projects-one entitled
"Removing obstructions in Arkansas River, Arkansas and Kansas,"
the other "Improving Arkansas River, Arkansas."
   The original project for "Removing obstructions in Arkansas
River, Arkansas and Kansas" (act July 3, 1832), was to remove snags
and wrecks. Subsequently this project was enlarged to include re-
moving bars by wing dams, and many of the appropriations were
made for this work in combination with other rivers. By act of
March 3, 1879, Congress adopted an additional project-that of
improving the river between Fort Smith, Ark., and Wichita, Kans.,
by removing the snags and rocks and constructing dams at some of
the worst shoals. Later these projects were merged into one, making
the project extend from the mouth of the river to Wichita. Under
these projects there was expended to June 30, 1902, $968,256.81.
   The original projects for "Improving Arkansas River, Arkansas,"
were local and had in view the permanent improvement of the river
at Fort Smith, Van Buren, Dardanelle, and Pine Bluff. By act of
August 11, 1888, Congress adopted a general project, namely:
   That the Secretary of War shall expend the appropriation under this head with
reference to the final improvement of this river as contemplated in the Report of
the Chief of Engineers for the year ending July first, eighteen hundred and eighty-
five, and as authorized in the act for the improvement of rivers and harbors approved
August fifth, eighteen hundred and eighty-six, and in House Executive Document
Numbered Ninety, Forty-ninth Congress, first session; said methods to be applied
as the Secretary of War may direct at such points between Wichita, Kansas, and
the navigable mouth of the Arkansas River at its junction with the Mississippi River,
as he may deem for the best interest of commerce.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   533
   The "said methods" referred to in the act were "to remove rock
and gravel reefs by blasting and dredging, to contract the channel
by dikes and dams, permeable or solid, of such construction as the
local conditions require, and to hold the channel so obtained by
revetment where necessary." The improvement authorized by the
act covers 771 miles, while estimates have been rendered for 708
miles, thus making the estimated cost of the improvement under
this project indefinite. Act of August 18, 1894, authorized the
operation of snag boats under this head in addition to similar opera-
tions under the project "Removing obstructions in Arkansas River,
Arkansas and Kansas." To the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1902, there had been expended under the general project for im-
proving Arkansas River, Arkansas, $903,311.93 for original construc-
tion, $314,119.14 for maintenance, and $63,397.32 for operating snag
boats, making the total amount $1,280,828.39.
   Act of Congress approved June 13, 1902, merged these two general
projects into one, which makes the existing project in substance:
"The improvement of the river from its mouth to the head of naviga-
tion by snagging operations, by dredging operations, and by contrac-
tion works, holding the improved channel by revetment where neces-
sary." No definite estimate of cost can be given.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, made available for main-
tenance of this improvement amounts previously appropriated for
work in vicinity of Redfork levee or set apart for dredging. The act
provided also for an examination of the river to Muskogee, Ind. T.,
by a Board of Engineers, with a view to devising a plan for further
improvement, and made a conditional appropriation for work at Pine
Bluff, if deemed by the Board to be necessary in the interest of
navigation. Funds from this appropriation were applied to work in
pursuance of the Board's recommendation, and report on the subject
will be found on pages 538 and 539 of this report under the heading
"Arkansas River at Pine Bluff and White River at Augusta Narrows,
Arkansas."
   To June 30, 1909, there had been expended under the consolidated
project for Arkansas River $227,795.57, of which $169,204.29 was
for operating snag boats, $38,121.28 for operating a hydraulic dredge,
and $20,470 for maintaining works of permanent improvement.
The total expenditures under all projects to June 30, 1909, is
$2,476,880.77, of which $1,200,858.42 is for operating snag boats,
$38,121.28 is for operating a hydraulic dredge, $903,311.93 for
original construction of works of permanent improvement, and
$334,589.14 for maintenance of those works. Other expenditures
on this river are shown in this report under the headings "Arkansas
River at Pine Bluff and White River at Augusta Narrows," page
538 of this report, and "Arkansas River at Pine Bluff," page 539 of
this report. After expending $1,237,901.07 in the construction and
maintenance of works, the permanent improvement of the stream
was abandoned before completing the project. Snagging operations
have improved the channel in the permanent reaches; in other
localities the improvement has been temporary and must be repeated
from time to time.
    Fort Gibson, on Grand River, 2 miles above its mouth and 463
miles from the mouth of the Arkansas River, is the head of steam-
boat navigation. The duration of the navigable periods of the river
varies greatly in different years. Occasionally there are periods of
534               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                   U.       S. ARMY.

very low water, when navigation will be suspended throughout the
length of river, and then there will be times when it is possible to
maintain 3-foot navigation through to Fort Gibson all the year.
Generally the maximum draft that can be carried at ordinary low
water is 3 feet from the mouth of the river to Pendleton (42); 2 feet
from Pendleton (42) to Swan Lake (80); 1 feet from Swan Lake
(80) to Webbers Falls (430); and 1 foot from Webbers Falls (430) to
mouth of Grand River (461). The periods of navigation by steam-
boats are of about the following averages:

                                                                                                                    Months a      Months a
                                                                                                                year for 4-       year for 2-
                                                                                                                foot draft.       foot draft.


Mouth to Swan Lake (80 miles)......                      -.................................       -        .               5.             10
Mouth to Little Rock (174 miles) ...............                            .....................                          5...            9
Mouth to Grand River (461 miles) ...             .................................                              .      .   4               8



   The range between extreme high water and extreme low water at
Fort Smith, Ark., is 35.5 feet; at Little Rock, Ark., 28.5 feet; and
at the mouth of the river where the stages are controlled by those of
the Mississippi the extreme range is 53.7 feet.
   The operations of this fiscal year consisted in snagging operations,
and in dredging operations with a hydraulic dredge borrowed from
the Mississippi River Commission. The snag boats Arkansas and
0. B. Reese operated below Spadra (290), removing 2,217 snags from
the channel, cutting 22,038 trees on caving banks, and breaking up
9 drifts. A chopping party working between Fort Smith (369) and
mouth of Grand River (461) removed 912 snags, cut 320 trees, and
destroyed 35 drift piles. The hydraulic dredge Gamma was operated
at three localities, but the principal work was done at Rob Roy (99).
Here the main channel of the river had left the draw spans of the
railway bridge and only a secondary channel behind a middle bar
afforded a passage for boats through the draw openings of the
bridge. The dredge opened this secondary channel, and notwith-
standing this unfavorable condition the dredged channel has re-
mained open to the close of this fiscal year, but for fifteen days
 (October 10-24) during the lowest water period of this fiscal year
the dredged cut did not afford a navigable channel. The dredged cuts
made at the other two localities were obliterated in the freshet of
October 25-November 3, 1908. Because of having to return the
borrowed dredge to the Mississippi River Commission about the 1st
of August each year there has been no opportunity in the two
seasons it has been operated in this river to fully try out its work
during low-water periods; but judging from such dredging as has
been done it appears that by such operations much material aid can
be given to navigation by lengthening the navigable periods of the
river. The district officer recommends that two dredges be pro-
vided for the river below Little Rock, 174 miles.
    The Muskogee-Oklahoma Packet Company, which was organized
for the purpose of operating a boat line between Fort Smith and
Muskogee, built a boat but did no business during the year. The
Little Rock Packet Company has been organized for the purpose of
operating a boat line out of Little Rock. It has purchased two boats.
The Arkansas River Packet Company became bankrupt during the
                                        RIVEIR AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                             535
year and the Memphis and Pine Bluff Packet Company has taken its
place.
                                             Commercial statistics, year ending May 31.

                   Year.                          Tons.     Value.                       Year.                        Tons.      Value.


1894.........................                     63,563   $2,846,395   1902........................                   40,557 $1,630,297
1895 .. ......................                    50,498    2,380,420   1903-........................                  86,068  2,389,020
1896.............               ...........       54,261    2,408,720   1904.......................                    92,041  2,078,893
1897 .........                ...............     66,077    1,657,218   1905.................... .                     86,458  1,636,930
1898.. ...............                    .....   58,578    1,626,756   1906 .........       . ...        ........    103,214  1,512,719
1899.............. ...........                    68,057    2,470,131   1907.....-.. ...                  .........   104,593  2,192,531
1900.........................                     75,654    2,078,940   1908..........              ..............    103,919  2,150,269
1901........................                      71,998    2,623,797   1909 ............               ...........    92,455  2,122,105


   Rafted saw logs floated with the current made up 60 per cent of
the commerce reported and represent 6 per cent of the estimated
value. Plantation products and supplies and timber products made
up the steamboat commerce. It does not appear that the improve-
ment of the river in late years has had any marked effect on intra-
state freight rates, either by water or by rail. In 1900 and 1901 the
improvement of the river reached its highest state of development.
Since that time the permanent works have been permitted to deterio-
rate, and the snag boats working alone have not been able to extend
the development any. The intrastate rail rates are controlled by a
state railway commission and are based on a "standard distance
tariff," and the river is not taken into consideration in making this
tariff. This statement applies to all the rivers in the State of
Arkansas.
   The balance available July 1, 1909, will be expended in snagging
operations. The amount estimated for the fiscal year June 30, 1911,
is for snagging operations, procuring additional plant, and maintain-
ing permanent works at Pine Bluff. The " additional plant" referred
to is a small snag boat to cost $30,000 for use in the upper Arkansas,
but for reasons stated by the district officer this expenditure can be
postponed until a further need of the boat is shown. The district
officer states that there is a permanent need for a revetment plant on
this river for use in maintaining works alrea.dy built as well as for use
in preventing cut-offs. He makes no estimate of the cost of a suit-
able plant, presumably withholding such estimate until Congress
takes some action upon the reports of the several preliminary exami-
nations that have been ordered for this river.
   References to the principal examinations and surveys of this river
are given on page 401 of the Annual Report for 1904.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................                                                         $53, 397. 85
Receipts from sales.................................................                                                                9. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
   March 3, 1909 ..................................................                                                            35, 000. 00
                                                                                                                              88, 406. 85
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
   improvement .........................................               a 48, 970. 05
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..............................                                                                39, 436. 80
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ......................                                                 ........          8, 620. 43
July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                                                      30, 816. 37


                                          a Snagging $33,805.34; dredging, $15,164.71.
536       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                 S. ARMY.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909. ..                                             a $81, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix W 1.)
   2. White River, Arkansas.-In its original condition this river was
much choked by logs, snags, and drift in its lower reaches, and in its
upper reaches-i. e., above Jacksonport-by gravel shoals, bowlders,
and some snags.
   The original project (act of March 3, 1871) was to remove snags
and similar obstructions, the work being combined with similar work
on Black and Little Red rivers. Act of June 23, 1874, extended the
improvement to Forsyth, Mo., the project being to remove snags and
bowlders and to contract the water width at shoals. During the
period 1873-1884 the snagging operations on the lower river were in
connection with similar work on St. Francis River, while the improve-
ment above Jacksonport was under appropriations confined to that
portion of the stream. The act of July 5, 1884, was the first inde-
pendent appropriation for the river as a whole. It readopted and
consolidated into one the separate projects and provided for a survey
with a view to the permanent improvement of the river from Forsyth,
Mo., to the mouth. The project of 1888 (Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1888, p. 1406) was to deepen the water on shoals by
contracting the channel, and to remove rocks, bowlders, and snags
from the channel, the object being to obtain a channel 5 feet deep at
low water from the mouth to Newport and 2 feet deep thence to
Buffalo shoals, at an estimated cost of $105,815, with an additional
amount of $8,000 a year for two or three years for snagging. For
reasons 'given in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1891, page 2049, the estimates were inadequate to accomplish the
object. The act of July 13, 1892, appropriated $53,815 to complete
the project, and an additional sum of $21,185 to be expended "in the
discretion of the Secretary of War." These funds and those appro-
priated since have been expended on the lines of the project of 1888,
with the addition of dredging on the shoals. The act of March 3,
1899, adopted a lock-and-dam project for the improvement of this
river above Batesville, thus reducing the scope of the former project
to improving the river from the mouth to Batesville by contracting
the channel, by removing rocks, bowlders, and snags, and by dredging.
   It is not practicable to state the expenditures on this river when the
work was carried on in connection with other rivers. From the
separate appropriations for the whole river, or for reaches of it, to
the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, there had been
expended $448,003.13. Of this amount $362,801.57 had been
expended on projects prior to March 3, 1899, and $85,201.56 had
been expended on maintenance of channel below Batesville.
   In a few instances the contraction works above Jacksonport gave a
slight increase in channel depth, but on the whole there was not
enough improvement in the channel to be of any material benefit to
navigation; the dredging between Jacksonport and Batesville in fiscal
a This amount may be reduced by $30,000 for reasons given in text above and in
Appendix W 1.
                                         RIVER AND ITARBOt IMPROVEMENTS.                                                               537

year 1898 made a channel 3 feet deep during one low-water season,
but the dredging has not been continued, no plant being available;
the snagging operations make the natural depths of the stream avail-
able during the low-water season in which the snagging is done. The
winter and the spring floods following bring other obstructions into
the stream; hence snagging operations are needed every year.
   Forsyth, Mo. (505 miles above the mouth), is the head of steam-
boat navigation. From its mouth to Jacksonport, 264 miles, the
river is generally spoken of as being navigable at any time for boats
of not over 3-foot draft. Between Jacksonport and Batesville, where
Lock No. 1 of the upper White River improvement is located, the
low-water channel depths are approximately 16 inches.
   The range between extreme high water and extreme low water
below Dam No. 1 at Batesville is 35.5 feet; at Jacksonport, 34.4 feet;
at Clarendon, 32.5 feet; and at the mouth of the river 53.7 feet.
   On page 1668 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1896 there is given the location of all the principal works built for the
improvement of this river. Report of survey from Forsyth, Mo.,
to the mouth, with plans for improvement, is given in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1888, page 1406.
   The snagging operations this fiscal year consisted in operating the
snag boat Quapaw three and one-half months and the snag boat
C. B. Reese one and a half months between the mouth of the river
and Lock No. 1, near Batesville, Ark. By these operations 771 snags
were removed, 30 drifts broken, and 2,826 trees cut.
   The balance available July 1, 1909, and the amount estimated as
being needed during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, will be ap-
plied to maintenance and operation of snag boats.
                                              Commercial statistics, year ending May 31.

                   Year.                            Tons.         Value.                        Year.                     Tons.     Value.


1895.........................                        73,759 $2,494,377 1903........................                       140,013     $882,225
1896.........................                        74,882  2,056,991 1904........................                       193,498    1,021,778
1897.......--------------..................          73,962  2,435,814 1905............               .........           134,588      770,689
1898..-------...........---------.......--------.   102,337  1,415,013 1906 .............                      ........   100,083      766,138
1899........--------------....--..........          117,891  1,619,351 1907............. .......                          127,812      830,659
1900 .........................                      134,696  2,244,222 1908---.............---......-----------.....      161,246      962,508
1901 .........................                      148,574  1,700,355 1909 .........          ..............             134,200      671,230
1902.........................                       184,066  1,242,438


  Forest products made up the bulk of the commerce. Twenty-
eight per cent of the commerce reported was rafted saw logs floated
with the current.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............................                     $18, 031. 87
Receipts from sales.............   ....................................                    17.60
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........................                      .......................  16, 000. 00

                                                                                                                                  34, 049. 47
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ....................................................                                                                11, 107. 90

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.................................                                                                 22, 941. 57
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...............                                                .............         ....       618. 22

July 1, 1909, balance available....................................... .                                                          22, 323. 35
tAmount
538       REPORT OF THE CHIEF          OF ENGINEERS,      I.   S. ARMY.

         that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.....-....................       ........ .. . .. $17, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix W 2.)
   3. Arkansas River at Pine Bluff and White River at Augusta Nar-
rows, Arkansas.-Statement of original condition of river, range
and floods, commercial statistics, etc., will be found in reports for
improving Arkansas River, Arkansas, and for improving White
River, Arkansas.
   The Board of Engineers appointed pursuant to requirement of the
river and, harbor act of March 2, 1907, recommended the construction
of a levee and revetment at Augusta Narrows, on White River, and
the construction of a levee along Vaugine Neck, opposite Fine Bluff,
on the Arkansas River, and that such amount of the $100,000 ap-
propriated by that act as was not needed for those works be reserved
for repairs or for further work that might be found necessary. T'he
works recommended by the Board have been completed, and the
balance of the appropriation not used on those works has been made
available for use in repairing and restoring the revetment works
along the town front of Pine Bluff, the major portion of those works
having been destroyed by two freshets that occurred in October and
November, 1908. For use in connection with that balance, $20,000
was allotted from the emergency funds provided by river and harbor
acts of 1905 and 1907. Ihe work done under this balance and the
allotments was that of building 3,100 linear feet of subaqueous mat-
tress, 120 feet wide, from State street to Kentucky street, and pav-
ing 1,800 linear feet from Tennessee street to Kentucky street.
Citizens of Pine Bluff, through a local organization, and the county
court of Jefferson County built 1,283 linear feet of subaqueous mat-
tress from State street up to Dike No. 3. These organizations also
did some temporary high-water protection work during the duration
of the two freshets in an effort to arrest the caving and prevent the
destruction of buildings along the caving bank.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, made a direct appro-
priation for work at Pine Bluff, and further report of work done at
that place during the fiscal year will be found under the heading
 "Arkansas River at Pine Bluff," (p. 539 of this report).
   To June 30, 1909, the expenditures under this heading have been
 $114,405.74, of which $15,586.66 was for Augusta revetment,
 $10,186.05 for Augusta levee, $55,175.22 for levee along Vaugine
Neck, and $33,457.81 for maintenance and restoration of works at
Pine Bluff. Two thousand and forty-three dollars of the $20,000
allotted from emergency river and harbor acts were returned to the
Treasury.
    The balance on hand July 1,1909, will be expended in payment of
outstanding liabilities.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                         539

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ................... ..............  . $80, 590. 32
Amount allotted from emergency river and harbor acts of 1905 and 1907... 20, 000. 00

                                                                                          100, 590.32
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For maintenance of improvement. .......................        $6, 000. 00
    For works of improvement.............................. 88, 996.06
    Returned to Treasury to credit of emergency appropria-
      tion act, 1907 . ........ .... ...........   ...............  2, 043. 00
                                                                                           97, 039. 06
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...........................        ..........              3, 551. 26
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...... ...-...    ......................               3, 551.26
   (See Appendix W 3.)
   4. Arkansas River at Pine Bluff, Ark.--This work is that of com-
pleting the restoration of 9,200 linear feet of revetment work
that was built along the town front of Pine Bluff in fiscal years
1892-1896 and which was destroyed during freshets in October and
November, 1908. The rebuilding of this revetment was begun under
the appropriation title "Arkansas River at Pine Bluff and White
River at Augusta Narrows, Arkansas." The work done under this
title-"Arkansas River at Pine Bluff"-this fiscal year was that of
building 1,000 linear feet of channel mattress, 120 feet wide, and
grading and paving 250 linear feet of bank, and taken in connection
with that done under the combined appropriation just mentioned
and that done by the citizens of Pine Bluff makes at the close of
the fiscal year 5,383 linear feet of channel mattress built and 2,050
linear feet of bank completely paved.
   The expenditures under this head to June 30, 1909 were $4,522.16.
   The balance available July 1, 1909, will be expended in completing
the restoration of the revetment along the town front of Pine Bluff.
   For commercial statistics, physical characteristics of the river, and
estimate for fiscal year 1911 see "Arkansas River, Arkansas."
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909... ........        .... ..................................... ........ $97, 200. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment..........       .............................................                     4, 522.16

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                    92, 677. 84
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................                .............    13, 236. 84

July 1, 1909, balance available.......................................                     79, 441.00

July 1, 1909, ampount covered by uncompleted contracts..................                    7, 360. 00
    (See Appendix W 4.)
   5. Upper White River, Arkansas.-Earlier works on this portion
of White River were made under appropriations for improving White
River, Arkansas, and have been fully reported upon under that head.
   The original condition of the river and previous projects for its
improvement are also reported there.
   The existing project, adopted March 3, 1899, is based on a report
printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1897,
page 1992, and is to provide slack-water navigation from Batesville,
Ark., to Buffalo shoals, 89 miles, by 10 fixed dams with concrete
locks. The locks are to be 175 feet between hollow quoins and 36 feet
540           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                   U.   S. ARMY.

wide, with a depth of about 4 feet on the lower miter sills. The esti-
mated cost is there given as $1,600,000 for the 10 locks and dams.
   To the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, there have been
expended on this work $813,195. Three locks and dams have been
built and are operated under the indefinite appropriation for "Oper-
ating and Care of Canals and other Works of Navigation."
   A board of engineers appointed pursuant to requirement of the
river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, to consider this project reported
the construction of further locks and dams not desirable. This report
is printed in House Document No. 150, Fifty-ninth Congress, first
session.
   Forsyth, Mo., 204 miles above Batesville, is the head of steam-
boat navigation. The channel depths over the shoals in the unim-
proved part of the river are small, being only 8 to 10 inches during
lowest waters. The range between high and low water at Buffalo
City, the head of this project, is about 45 feet. Below Dam No. 1, at
Batesville, this range is 35.5 feet.
   For commercial statistics, see report on "Operating and care of
locks and dams, Upper White River, Arkansas."
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................... ..............                            $4, 641. 64
Receipts from sales ....................................................                                6. 69
                                                                          4, 648. 33
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment. ......................................................           a4, 134. 80

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended            -......................................                 b 513. 53
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                            513.53
    (See Appendix W 5.)
   6. Operating and care qf Locks and Dams Nos. 1, 2, and 3, upper
White River, Arkansas.-These locks and dams were built with funds
derived from appropriations for improving upper White River,
Arkansas. The available length of the locks is 147 feet, available
width is 35 feet, and depth over the miter sills at normal pool levels
is 5 feet. Lock and Dam No. 1 was placed under this appropriation
on January 16, 1904; Lock and Dam No. 2, on February 16, 1905,
and Lock and Dam No. 3, on February 1, 1908.
   The high-water mark of May, 1898 (before the dams were built) is
22 feet above the crest of Dam No. 1, 18.4 feet above the crest of
Dam No. 2, and 25.2 feet above the crest of Dam No. 3. The high-
est stages reached by the river since the dams have been completed
were 20 feet above the crest of Dam No. 1 and 18.2 feet above the crest
of Dam No. 2, on May 8, 1907. Since the completion of Dam No. 3
there has been no extreme high water. The lowest stages this fiscal
year were 0.1 foot above the crest of Dam No. 1 and 0.3 foot above
the crests of Dams Nos. 2 and 3, on November 20, 1908.
   The expenditures during this fiscal year were for ordinary oper-
ating expenses of the locks and for some minor repairs to structures
and plant.
   The total amount expended under this head to June 30, 1909, is
$132,109.17, of which $17,448.03 was expended this fiscal year.
               a Lock and Dam No. 3.
               b Lock No. 1, $214.50; Lock No. 2, $83.75; Lock No. 3, $215.28.
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            541
                           Commercial statistics, year ending May 31.

                                    Lock No. 1.           Lock No. 2.                  Lock No. 3.             Freights
                                                                                                               that did
             Year.                                                                                             not pass
                                  Lock-
                                  ages.      Freights.   Lock-
                                                         ages.     Freights.        Lock
                                                                                    ages.          Freights.   tlock.


                                   Number.     Tons.    Number.      Tons.       Number.             Tons.      Tons.
1904...........................      a 115       8,320 .. .7,335
1905............................       244       8,771       b60      4,163 ....................                   5,000
1906............................       246       7,306       183      8,692 .........                  .....       2,496
1907..............................     191       6,798       263      9.431 ...................                    1,283
1908 ...... ..................         249      13,746       661     22,077           c126            4,337        7,533
1909......................             190       4,427       549     14,143             310           7,162        5,143

          a Four months.             b Three and one-half months.                      c Five months.

   (See Appendix W 6.)
   7. Cache River, Arkansas.-In its original condition this river was
much obstructed by snags, drift, and overhanging timber. The low-
water depth on the controlling shoals was 6 to 8 inches.
   The original project, adopted by the act of August 11, 1888, was to
remove logs, snags, and overhanging timber from the mouth to River-
side (102 miles). The amount expended on this project was $9,000.
   The river and harbor acts of August 18, 1894, and June 3, 1896,
each authorized the Secretary of War to expend $2,000 of the White
River appropriations on this stream. The funds obtained from those
acts and from subsequent ones have been expended in maintenance of
channel below James Ferry, 79 miles above the mouth of the river,
by snagging operations.
   To June 30, 1909, there had been expended on this work $19,984.36,
of which $9,000 was for work under the original project and $10,984.36
was for maintenance of channel.
   The operations have been of material benefit to commerce in length-
ening the navigable periods by rendering the natural depths of the
stream available for navigation purposes.
   Gray's bridge, 95 miles above the mouth of the river, is considered
the head of steamboat navigation, but the river is not navigable to
that point all the year, the ruling depth in the channels over the
shoals throughout the river being only 8 to 10 inches during lowest
water. During high-water seasons rafts are run from 100 or more
miles above Gray's bridge. In the vicinity of James Ferry (79 miles
above the mouth of the river and the upper limit of snagging opera-
tions now) the range between high and low water is about 15 feet.
Because of backwater from White River this range is increased to 24
feet at Rock Island Railway bridge and to 32 feet at the mouth of the
river.
   Reports of the more recent preliminary examinations of this river
are given in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887,
page 1547, and in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1895, page 2037.
542                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                          Commercial statistics, year ending May 31.

                  Year.                        Tons.    Value.                        Year.                        Tons.     Value.


1895 .........................                 12,603    $25,494      1903........................                 16,843     $109,681
1896.........................                  20,748     62,483      1904 ............               .........    15,865       49,601
1897.........................                  34,990    108,460      1905-...          .............-             11,660       29,860
1898.........................                  10,193     36,635      1906 ............             .........      10,942       31.777
1899............               . ...........    7,667     52,936      1907.........            - ...... ..         13,050       39.225
1900.........................                  11,215     29,961      1908...............                .....     21,173       59,254
1901.........................                  10,374     30,100      1909 ...........            .........         9,420       36,150
1902 .........................                 15,676     40,301



     The tonnage reported this year was made up of rafted saw logs and
barged railway ties.
   The balance available July 1, 1909, and the additional appropria-
tion recommended will be expended in snagging operations for main-
tenance of channel.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ........................................... $2, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ..............  ....................................          3, 000.00
                                                                                                                            5,000.00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement......--.............. ................ ..................                                                     1, 984. 36

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......                              ........         ....................                   3, 015. 64
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.....                         .................                 ........     ......        15. 64

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                                                       3, 000.00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.....        ......................................                                                   3, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
      (See Appendix W 7.)
  8. Black and Currentrivers, Arkansas and Missouri.-Priorto fiscal
year 1905 the work on these rivers was provided for under separate
appropriation titles. The works were consolidated by river and
harbor act of March 3, 1905.
   (a) Black River.-In its original condition this river below the
mouth of Cu rent River had, at ordinary low water, a controlling
depth of 2 to 21 feet on the shoals, but this was not available on
account of snags and similar obstructions. Above the mouth of
Current River navigation was practically impossible at ordinary low
stages, and no rafting was possible above the Arkansas and Missouri
state line.
   The original project, adopted by act of June 14, 1880, contemplated
removing logs, etc., cutting down shoals by means of wing dams, and
closing some of the most troublesome sloughs. The estimated cost
was $80,800. The only modification of the project has been that of
changing the estimate to $8,000 a year for maintenance. The district
officer recommends that this be increased to $18,000 for the two
streams.
   To June 30, 1909, there had been expended on this work $165,859.24.
   Poplar Bluff, Mo., 239 miles above the mouth of the river, is the
head of navigation. All-the-year navigation has been made possible
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     543
to this place for boats of not over 18 inches draft. Boats of not over
21   feet draft can navigate this river below the mouth of Current
River, 116 miles, during the lowest waters, and this portion of the
river is generally spoken of as being navigable for 3-foot boats at any
time.
   The range between high and low water at Poplar Bluff is 19 feet.
This difference decreases below Poplar Bluff, and in the flat lands to
the southward it averages about half of this, being 8.5 feet at Corning
bridge, 70 miles below Poplar Bluff. After passing to below head of
Little River the difference between high and low water increases, and
at Pocahontas, 129 miles below Poplar Bluff, the difference is 26.5
feet, and at the mouth of the river it is 34.4 feet.
   The operations during this fiscal year consisted in snagging opera-
tions carried on by the hand-propelled snag boat Riverside working
between Poplar Bluff and the mouth of Current River and the snag
boat Quapaw working below the mouth of Current River. By these
operations 1,344 snags were removed from the channel, 1,816 trees
cut, and 15 drifts broken up.
   The report of the examination upon which the present project for
the improvement of Black Riv-er is based is given in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1880, page 1326.
    (b) Current River.-The original condition of this stream was such
that no steamboat navigation above the mouth of Little Black River
was attempted except when the river was at high stages. Below Lit-
tle Black River navigation was suspended when the river was below
medium stage. The natural depths were not available on account of
snags and leaning trees.
   Although the United States made some improvements to this
stream in 1873, and again in 1832 and 1883, the regular improvement
of it was not undertaken until act of Congress of August 18, 1894,
adopted a project for its improvement from Van Buren, Mo., to the
mouth by snagging operations and by contracting the channel at the
worst shoals by wing dams, at an estimated cost of $10,000. The
appropriation of June 3, 1896, completed the amount originally esti-
mated for the completion of the project, and all operations since then
have been under estimates for maintenance. No wing dams have
been built, all operations having been confned to snagging.
    To June 30, 1909, there has been expended on this river $41,463.71,
$7,000 of which was in the early work mentioned above, leaving
 $34,463.71 as the amount expended on the existing project. Of this
latter amount, $24,463.71 was for maintenance.
    Reference to the preliminary examination of this stream and to a
subsequent examination of it is given on page 408 of Annual Report
for 1904.
    Van Buren, Mo., 94.5 miles above the mouth of the river, was taken
as the head of navigation when the earlier projects for this river were
adopted. Small gasoline boats occasionally ply the river that far up,
and rafts are run over the entire river, but Pitmans Landing, near the
state line between Arkansas and Missouri and 41 miles above the
mouth of the river, is generally spoken of as the head of steamboat
navigation. Boats can not reach that point, however, during low-
water seasons, the low-water depths of the river being as follows:
Three feet from the mouth to Blunts (Johnsons Landing), 25 miles;
2 feet from Blunts to mouth of Little Black River, 7 miles; and 16
544          REPORT         OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                             S. ARMY.

inches from mouth of Little Black River to Pitmans Landing, 9
miles. From Pitmans Landing to Doniphan, 12 miles, the head of
the work done by snag boats now, the low-water depths are about
12 inches.
   The range between high and low water at Van Buren is about 16
feet, and this range does not vary much until below the mouth of Lit-
tle Black River, when the range increases to 19 feet.
   During this fiscal year the snag boat Riverside (hand propelled)
worked over the river below state line, 42 miles. Six hundred and
sixty-six snags were removed from the channel and 1,463 overhanging
trees were cut.
                                           Commercial statistics.

                                                                       Black River.       Current River.
                    Year ending May 31-
                                                                    Value.      Tons.     Value.      Tons.

1895....--------.............--..----...............................   $------------------------------------1,085,415
                                                                                                   132,433 $362,447   31,205
1896---------................------------................................--------------------------
                                                                                           891,437 111,278   227,291  29,867
1897................---------------------..................................------------------------
                                                                                         1,704,799 111,611   581,528  17,078
1898------...-------.......---............----------------...........--------------------..........
                                                                                           788,640 115,612   306,216  52,417
1899----------.............------...---------................................----------------------
                                                                                           529,336 83,404    239,869  43,050
                                                                                           966,961 129,698
1900......................................................----------------------------------------.          578,834  65,043
                                                                                           989,635 185,714
1901...--------..---..--.....------...................................-----------------------------          234,555  64,102
1902 ...........................               . ....-...................                  919,767 166,213   165,766  37,185
1903..................-----....-----..........-----------------...............             695,649 138,181   142,899  45,309
                                 --------------------------------------- 1,092,648 191,285
1904....---------..........................................                                                  139,119  55,573
1905-----------------................................-----------------.................  1,004,299 144,065   409,297  74,048
1906..--------------------------....................-----------------..............--------........139,384   152,216  47,704
1907------..........----------..........--..--------------------------------.......................
                                                                                           692,968 107,914   226,655  48,486
1908...............------...-----.......--..----------..--.....----------...............   517,905 140,826   115,398  27,696
                                                                                           439,355 86,070
1909.....------------...--------......................................-----------------------------           36,802  10,735



  Logging and kindred industries furnished the bulk of the commerce.
Of the commerce reported this year 54 per cent of that on Black River
and 6 per cent of that on Current River was rafted saw logs and rail-
way ties.
  The balance available July 1, 1909, will be expended in snagging
operations. The amount estimated as being needed during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, is for maintenance of channel by snagging
operations.
                                                BLACK RIVER.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............................................. $6, 020. 42
Receipts from sales..................................................               3.00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.................................................              12,000.00
                                                                                                   18, 023. 42
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement................ ........... .... ..........................                             5, 142.16

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................................                            12, 881. 26
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ......................................                           486.11

July 1, 1909, balance available ....................................                               12, 395. 15

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.............................................                                   (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                         a See consolidated money statement on page 545.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                545
                                              CURRENT RIVER.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................... $1, 966. 16
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909............ ..........       .....................     6, 000. 00
                                                                                                     7, 966. 16
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement ...............    ....  ...........................                                     1, 594. 87
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ............................                                        6, 371. 29
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .......................                            ........         4. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                              6, 367. 29
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.....            ...................................                             (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                               CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..............           .....             .......... $7, 986. 58
Receipts from sales............................                 ................             3.00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..........................................                              18, 000. 00
                                                                                                    25, 989.58
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement...........................................................                               6, 737. 03

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................                           ..............          19, 252. 55
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .................                   ....... ..........            490. 11
July 1, 1909, balance available ..........................................                          18, 762. 44
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 ...                         .      ............. . . 19, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix W 8.)
   9. St. Francis and L'Anguille rivers, Arlcansas.-(a) St. Francis
River.-In its original condition this stream was not navigable above
Lesters Landing at any stage; between Lesters Landing and Marked
Tree navigation was possible at high stages only, and below Marked
Tree it was difficult at medium and lower stages and impossible at
extreme low water.
   The original project, adopted by act of March 3, 1871, contemplated
improvement from the mouth to Wittsburg by snagging operations.
For the period 1873-1882 the appropriations were made for this work
in connection with White River, Arkansas. By act of June 14, 1880,
appropriation was made for improving the river from Wittsburg to
Lesters Landing, the project for the expenditure of this appropria-
tion being to cut a channel through "The Lake" and clear the river
of obstructions by snagging operations. Appropriation made by act
of July 5, 1884, was the first separate appropriation for the entire
                  a See consolidated money statement on this page.
         9001-ENG 1909-35
546       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                  S. ARMY.


river. The act did not state the limits within which it was to be
applied. Under it snagging operations were carried on to the town
of St. Francis, Ark., and several of the sloughs or side channels were
closed. When the improvement of St. Francis River, Missouri, was
begun (act of August 11, 1888), Kennett, Mo., was taken for the
upper limit of this work, making the existing project-
removal of logs, drifts, and snags from the channel, and overhanging timber from
the banks from the mouth to Kennett, Mo., and closing the chutes and sloughs in
the Sunk Lands, so as to make the river navigable at high stages to Kennett, Mo.,
at medium stages to Marked Tree, and at low stages to a point 30 miles below Madison,
Ark., the estimated cost being $8,000 annually.
   (b) L'Anguille River.-By acts of June 18, 1878, March 3, 1879,
and June 14, 1880, a total of $17,000 was appropriated for snagging
operations on L'Anguille River to Marianna. This was finally ex-
pended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1887. Act of June 13, 1902,
revived this work and included it with St. Francis River.
   There has been expended on these rivers to June 30, 1909, $121,-
562.03. This amount, however, does not include the expenditures
on St. Francis River while it was combined with White River, as
those expenditures can not be determined.
   By the early operations the St. Francis River between Wittsburg
and Lesters Landing was improved to such an extent that boats could
reach the latter-named place on the same stage as they could the
former. By subsequent operations the period of navigation below
Wittsburg was lengthened about two months, and above Lesters
Landing a fair high-water channel was made. The improvements
thus made below Wittsburg have been maintained. No effort is being
made to maintain those above Marked Tree, the commerce on that
portion of the river not warranting any expenditures at this time.
During periods of low water neither stream is navigable, there not
being sufficient depth of water over the shoals. Marianna is the head
of navigation on L'Anguille River. The head of navigation on St.
Francis River is near Wappapello, Mo., about 100 miles above Ken-
nett, Mo., the upper limit of the portion of the river covered by this
project. Lying between Kennett, Mo., and Foot of Lake, 80 miles
below, are the Sunken Lands of the St. Francis, one vast swamp,
through which the river flows in several channels, none of which is
well defined and all of which are more or less obstructed and fre-
quently blocked. Lesters Landing is 34 miles above Foot of Lake
and is the practicable head of navigation on the St. Francis River in
Arkansas. Boats can pass between it and Kennett, Mo., only during
high stages, and then only with great difficulty.
   The range between high and low water of St. Francis River at Les-
ters Landing is about 3 feet. This increases to 16 feet at Marked
Tree, and this range is probably the maximum that would exist at
any point below there were it not for the backwater from the Missis-
sippi River. At Madison the extreme range is about 33 feet, and at
the mouth of the river it is about 55 feet.
   Reference to examination and survey of these rivers with a view to
improvement by means of locks and dams is given on page 410 of
Annual Report for 1904. Reference to report of examination of St.
Francis River from its mouth to St. Francis, Ark., will be found on
page 460 of Annual Report for 1906.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                             547
   During this fiscal year the hand-propelled snag boat A. B. John-
son worked over St. Francis River between its mouth and Marked
Tree, 171 miles. Nine hundred and ninety-nine snags were removed
from the channel, 5,055 trees cut, and 10 drifts broken up.
                                 Commercial statistics, year ending May 31.

             Year.                    Tons.          Value.                   Year.                      Tons.       Value.


1894.........................  19,763                  $98,375    1902........................            85,831      $269,190
1895......... ...... .....     38,107                  321,439    1903........................            88,035        294,495
1896 ......................... 67,740                  401,457    1904........................           119,172        423,469
1897 ......................... 97,348                1,117,891    1905...........               ......
                                                                                              ......     142, 098       590,560
1898.........................  23,819                  237,481    1906................        .......    137,319        472,257
1899.........................  27,892                  315,459    1907.......................            151, 015       833,397
1900........................   45,065                  194,237    1908.......................            286,820     1,376,757
1901 ........................  57, 102                 272, 609   1909........................           160, 057    1, 148, 855



   Fifty-four per cent of the commerce reported was rafted saw logs
floated with the current.
   The balance available July 1, 1909, will be expended in snagging
operations. The amount estimated as being needed during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, is for maintenance of channel by snag-
ging operations.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............................                                                 $6, 777. 97
Receipts from sales...............................                             ....................                      3.00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1909............ ......................................                                                   9, 000. 00

                                                                                                                 15, 780. 97
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...........................................       .  ......                                           5, 102. 47
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended................................                                                 10, 678. 50
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                                          517. 12

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                                            10, 161.38
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...        ........................................                                            9, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix W 9.)

EXAMINATION               AND SURVEY MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
                          HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports dated September 13, 1907, and September 30, 1908,
respectively, on preliminary examination, with plan and estimate of
cost of improvement, of Saline River, Arkansas, from the mouth of
the same north to Turtle bar, on said river, with a view to dredging
and other work, required by the river and harbor act of March 2,
1907, were duly submitted by the district officer. They were reviewed
by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant to law,
and were transmitted to Congress and printed in House Document
No. 1212, Sixtieth Congress, second session. An estimate of cost
of improvement, amounting to $5,400, is presented.
548     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

EXAMINATION OF ARKANSAS RIVER UP TO MUSKOGEE AND AT PINE
  BLUFF; RED RIVER BETWEEN FULTON, ARK.,      AND MOUTH OF
  WASHITA RIVER; AND WHITE RIVER AT AUGUSTA NARROWS, ARKAN-
  SAS, MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND HARBOR ACT APPROVED
  MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports dated May 27, 1907, December 30, 1907, and March 27,
1909, by a Board of Engineers, of examinations of Arkansas River
up to Muskogee and at Pine Bluff; Red River between Fulton, Ark.,
and mouth of Washita River; and White River at Augusta Narrows,
Arkansas, required by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, were
duly submitted and were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for
Rivers and Harbors, pursuant to law. The reports were trans-
mitted to Congress and printed in House Document No. 71, Six.ty-
first Congress, first session. Plans for improvement are presented
as follows:
    (a) Arkansas River from the mouth to Little Rock at an estimated
first cost for plant of $300,000, and $100,000 annually for maintenance;
    (b) Red River between Fulton, Ark., and the mouth of the Washita
River, estimated to cost $160,000 for the first two years and $50,000
annually thereafter for maintenance; and
    (c) Arkansas River at Pine Bluff and White River at Augusta
Narrows. The work proposed by the Board being considered as
required in the interests of navigation, the sum of $100,000 condition-
ally appropriated by the act of March 2, 1907, became available for
the work and was applied to the improvement of these localities.

EXAMINATIONS MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND HARBOR ACT
                 APPROVED MARCH 3, 1909.

   Reports on preliminary examinations required by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, of the following localities within this
district were duly submitted by the district officer. They were re-
viewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant
to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in documents
as indicated:
   1. Preliminary examination of Arkansas River at Douglas, Ark.,
with a view to determining what improvements are necessary in the
interest of navigation.-Report dated April 2, 1909, is printed in
House Document No. 69, Sixty-first Congress, first session. No
improvement at Douglas is considered necessary in the interest of
navigation beyond that contemplated by existing project.
   2. Preliminary examination, with plan and estimate of cost of im-
provement, of Blackfish Bayou, Arkansas,from its mouth to Fifteenmile
Bayou.-Reports dated April 3, 1909, and May 17, 1909, respectively,
are printed in House Document No. 73, Sixty-first Congress, first
session. An estimate of cost amounting to $9,500 is presented.
   3. Preliminary examination of Little Black River, Arkansas and
Missouri.-Report dated April 20, 1909, is printed in House Docu-
ment No. 74, Sixty-first Congress, first session. This stream is not
considered worthy of improvement by the General Government.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    549
IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE ST. LOUIS, MISSOURI,
                         DISTRICT.

   This district was in the temporary charge of Capt. G. R. Lukesh,
Corps of Engineers, to September 30, 1908, and in the charge of Col.
W. H. Bixby, Corps of Engineers, division engineer, western divi-
sion, since that date.
   1. Removing snags and wrecks from the Mississippi River below the
mouth of the Missouri River.-When this work was originally begun
the navigation of the river was seriously obstructed by numerous
snags, logs, etc., which had lodged in the channel, and to which
additions were made with each rise of the river. A large number of
wrecked flatboats, barges, steamboats, and other river craft also
obstructed the navigable channels, and menaced life and property.
   For the removal of these obstructions appropriations were made as
early as 1824. The project adopted consisted of building boats suit-
able for removing snags, logs, drift heaps, wrecks, etc., and operating
them whenever the stage of river was favorable and funds were avail-
able, and in cutting trees from caving banks to prevent their falling
into the river and becoming obstructions to navigation.
    The existing project is a continuation of the plan adopted in 1879,
when the first specific appropriation for removing snags, wrecks, etc.
from the Mississippi River was made by the river and harbor act
approved March 3 of that year. Specific appropriations or allot-
ments were made for this work each year thereafter, except 1883,
1885, and 1887, but by section 7 of the river and harbor act of August
11, 1888, a continuous annual expenditure of $100,000, or as much
thereof as might be necessary, was authorized for the maintenance
of this service, and this amount has been available each year since
to the present time. The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909,
makes so much of this appropriation, as the Secretary of War may
deem necessary, available for the removal of snags and other floating
and sunken obstructions in the Atchafalaya and Old rivers from
their junction with the Mississippi and Red rivers down the Atcha-
falaya River as far as Melville, La.
    No modification of the project has been made since its adoption,
the plan being continuous, and new obstructions being brought down
by each flood in the river. So much of the continuous appropriation
as may be required each year will be applied to their removal.
    The amount expended upon this work prior to June 30, 1872, can
not now be ascertained, for the reason that during that time and to
March 3, 1879, appropriations were made in lump sums, principally
under the title "Improvement of Mississippi, Missouri, and Arkansas
rivers," to be applied to the several streams as their needs or the
terms of the law required. The available records do not show the
amount applied to each stream.
    The approximate amount expended from July 1, 1872, to June 30,
1880, was $493,437.23, and the definitely known amount expended
from July 1, 1880, to June 30, 1909, was $2,203,977.85, making the
total of approximate and known expenditures to date $2,697,415.08.
    From March 28, 1868 (the earliest date of available record of work
done), to June 30, 1909, 96,364 snags were pulled, 81 wrecks and 636
drift piles were removed, and 444,070 trees were cut, greatly improv-
ing the river and lessening the dangers of navigation.
550     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   During the fiscal year in review two steel-hull snag boats were
engaged in removing such obstructions between the mouth of the
Missouri River and New Orleans, La., a distance of about 1,270
miles, and 4,526 snags were destroyed, 27 drift piles and 23 wrecks
were removed, 2,406 trees were cut, and 13,068 miles patrolled.
   In addition to this work part of the funds appropriated for the
removal of obstructions was expended in the partial removal of Bea-
ver Dam rock, an obstructive and dangerous rock lying in mid-
channel about 1 mile below Commerce, Mo. A beginning was made
upon this work (which can only be done economically at low and
favorable river stages) during the preceding fiscal year (1908), when
about one-sixth of the drilling and blasting were completed. During
the past fiscal year as much more was done, so that about one-third
of the whole is now accomplished. Work will be continued at each
low-water season as opportunity offers and funds are available, until
the entire rock is removed to the plane desired.
   For information as to the commerce benefited by work under
this appropriation, reference should be made to the commercial sta-
tistics in the report upon improving the Mississippi River between
the Ohio and Missouri rivers and in the reports of the Mississippi River
Commission and the district officers thereunder. The amount ex-
pended during the year was $100,021.03.
    (See Appendix X 1.)
   2. Mississippi River between Ohio and Missouri rivers.-In its orig-
inal condition, prior to any improvement, the navigable channel of
this section of the Mississippi River had a natural depth in many
places of only 31 to 4 feet at low water. The main channels were
divided by islands and bars, which formed chutes, sloughs, and sec-
ondary channels, through which a considerable part of the volume of
the flow was diverted to the detriment of navigation.
   The first systematic effort to improve this condition was begun by
the Federal Government in 1872, and was continued for a number of
years as appropriations were made, the works of improvement con-
sisting of dikes and dams of brush and stone, to confine the low-water
volume in the vicinity to a single channel, and of revetments to hold
and preserve the banks where it was thought necessary or advisable.
   The project followed in later years and up to the present time has
been practically that adopted in 1881, approved by letter of the
Chief of Engineers dated March 31, 1881, contemplating the confine-
ment of the flow of the river below St. Louis to a single channel hav-
ing an approximate width of 2,500 feet at bank-full stage, the natural
width in many cases being a mile or more at mean high water, this
result to be secured by closing sloughs and secondary channels and
by building out new banks where the natural width is excessive,
using for the purpose permeable dikes or hurdles of piling to collect
and hold the solid matter carried in suspension or rolled on the bot-
tom by the river, the banks, both new and old, to be revetted or
otherwise protected where necessary to secure permanency. Modi-
fications of the project in the river and harbor acts of 1896 and 1902
provided that, pending the completion of the permanent improve-
ment, the low-water channel should be improved each season by the
use of dredges and other temporary expedients.
                 ITVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMiENTS.                 55

   Under the provisions of the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902,
and special resolutions of the Committee on Rivers and Harbors of
April 25, 1903, the special engineer board considered and submitted a
report upon the conditions, best methods of work, and cost of a suit-
able channel in this part of the Mississippi River. This report, under
date of November 12, 1903, recommended a channel which would
have at low water at least 200 feet width with 8 feet depth from
Cairo to St. Louis, and with 6 feet depth from St. Louis to the mouth
of the Missouri, to be secured by side contraction works and shore
protection, assisted by dredging, the permanent construction work
to cost about $20,000,000, in addition to all expenditures already
made, and its maintenance to cost about $400,000 per year; and,
with a view to the prompt execution of such project, this report fur-
ther recommended an immediate appropriation of $450,000 for addi-
tional dredging plant and $250,000 per year for three years' operation
of the same, together with $300,000 per year for permanent construc-
tion works and temporary expedients until the results of such
dredging should be known and should allow a revision of the project.
The river and harbor acts of March 3, 1905, and of March 2, 1907,
appropriated or authorized contracts and work to the amount of
$1,450,000 for the new plant and for its operation for five years
(1906, 1908 to 1911), and the latter act provides that the sums now
available shall be expended in the operation and maintenance of
dredging plants already constructed and in temporary expedients of
channel regulation connected with such operation, and in mainte-
nance and repair of the permanent works already constructed, and
that such portion of the $250,000 per year as is not necessary for
the above work may be expended in construction of permanent works
of channel regulation. The dredging has required annually so much
of this appropriation that only about $30,000 to $50,000 per year
has been available for the less urgent work. The action of Congress
up to the present time has therefore followed the recommendations
of the Board's report of November 12, 1903, except that it has allowed
only a small portion (about $150,000 total during four years) of the
appropriations to be used upon the repair and maintenance and
new construction of permanent works instead of $300,000 per year
recommended therefor by the 1903 Board for the years of experi-
mental dredging. The results of the dredging work above author-
ized and done now show that the 1881 project, as revised by the 1903
Board, needs no further revision other than to add urgent recom-
mendations for annual appropriations large enough to allow of the
completion of the $20,000,000 project within a reasonable term of
years. This view is also confirmed by the recent report of the spe-
cial Board on Examination and Survey of the Mississippi River
from the Lakes to the Gulf, dated March 20, 1909, which virtually
recommends the early completion of the 1881 project as indorsed
and modified by the 1903 Board, and which puts its cost at about
$21,000,000 ($1,000,000 being added to compensate for the deterio-
ration of permanent works during recent years while their repair has
been prevented by lack of recommended appropriations).
   Continuing contracts for $250,000 for the year commencing July
1, 1910, are already authorized by the act of March 2, 1907, to be
provided for in the next sundry civil act; but in addition thereto
552     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S. ARMY.

the $300,000 per year for repair, maintenance, and new construction
of permanent works recommended by the 1903 Board, after increase
to $400,000 to partially compensate for deficiencies since 1903, should
also be authorized for the coming year to provide for checking fur-
ther serious destruction and depreciation of existing works.
   The object of the previous and present plans of improvement is
to obtain and maintain a minimum depth at standard low water
of 6 feet from the mouth of the Missouri to St. Louis and of 8
feet from St. Louis to the mouth of the Ohio.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $12,718,126.03,
exclusive of $180,000 allotted by acts to projects for improvement
between the Illinois and Missouri rivers, including Alton Harbor.
   The result of the expenditure of this amount has been the partial
permanent improvement of the entire extent of the river from St.
Louis to Cairo, and during recent years practically the maintenance
of the depths required.
   The new appropriation asked for is the estimated expenditure
for one year only, and should be increased by authorization under
continuing contracts for other years by at least the same sum annu-
ally until a new plan is authorized by Congress.
   It is proposed to expend the new appropriation asked for in dredging
and in such temporary and permanent improvements as may be
necessary and authorized by law.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909,
was $341,824.44, and includes $213,932.76 expended for dredges and
dredging, the remainder going to the care of plant and to the main-
tenance and repair of existing works of revetment, which had been
much damaged by the action of the river and were urgently in need
of such work. The total amount thus far expended for temporary
channel improvement is $1,422,541.32, much of which has been for
dredging plant that is now on hand and available for future work.
The approximate value of this dredging plant is $509,890.42, having
been considerably augmented by the completion and addition of
the two new dredges referred to.
   This improvement has probably had a beneficial influence on
freight rates, as the rates to localities reached by water are well
known to be lower than those remote from this advantage, but an
accurate estimation of such effect is impracticable.
   During the past year there was maintained a channel depth of 8
feet during the entire season when the river was unobstructed by ice,
except for short periods at several places the depths were 7 feet
until dredges could be brought into action upon these shoals, when
the required depth was quickly obtained; and at two places, Chain
of Rocks and Grand Tower, where 7 feet was the maximum obtained,
due, at the former to the location of the channel across the solid
rock, and at the latter to the natural silting up and closing of the
chute east of Grand Tower Island, forcing the boat channel to the
west of that island over a bar of gravel and small bowlders which
could not be moved by the suction type of dredges in use.
   The river at St. Louis reached a high-water stage of 26.9 feet
above standard low water (4 feet St. Louis gauge) on July 1, 1908,
and a low-water stage of 5.4 feet below standard low water on Janu-
ary 12, 1909.
                                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 553
   With the present appliances and such others as are authorized
for the temporary improvement of low-water channels and for works
of permanent improvement, it is expected that a navigable depth
of about 8 feet can be maintained between St. Louis and Cairo during
all stages of river open to navigation.
                                       Recapitulationof commercial statistics.

                                                                    1905.         1906.        1907.           1908.

                                                                    Tons.         Tons.         Tons.          Tons.
Receipts and shipments at St. Louis ..................               370,425       416,855      368,075          365,920
Transferred by ferries at St. Louis .................             6, 684, 949   7, 374, 978   8, 905,542      5, 600,765
Shipped from landings between St. Louis and Cairo....                 69,729        62,238        65,467           8, 173
      Total ..................................                    7,125,103     7,854,071     9,339,084       5,974,858


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................                                     $376, 703. 86
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909..                                        250, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, miscellaneous receipts .............................                                      23, 232. 22

                                                                                                           649, 936. 08
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance
  of improvement ................ .................................                                    a 341, 843. 07
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.................................                                      b 308, 093. 01
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..............................                                        16, 519.03

July 1, 1909, balance available ...............................                                        b 291, 573. 98

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....                               c 17, 501, 654. 55
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
  30, 1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclu-
  sive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909..................                                        d 250, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix X 2.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE ROCK ISLAND,
                   ILLINOIS, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Maj. C. S. Riche, Corps of Engi-
neers. Division engineer, Col. W. H. Bixby, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Operating snag boats and dredge boats on upper Mississippi
River and tributaries.-Bythe river and harbor act of August 11, 1888,
provision was made for securing the uninterrupted work of snag
boats and dredge boats on the upper Mississippi River under a per-
manent appropriation, the sum so expended not to exceed $25,000
annually.
   a Deduct $18.63 expended in June, 1909, on account of inspections for the Isthmian
Canal Commission, which had not been refunded at the end of the fiscal year, leaving
net amount of $341,824.44 expended upon the improvement.
   b From this amount deduct $10,000, allotment carried to the surplus fund June
30, 1909.
   c Project of 1881 as modified in 1905.
   d This estimate refers only to the work which Congress has specifically provided
for under the continuing-contract authorization of March 2, 1907, and is the full
amount allowed by said authorization. For the reasons given in the text of this
report the appropriation of the additional sum of $400,000 is recommended
554     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

   By river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, the annual appropriation
for operating snag boats on the upper Mississippi River was made
available for similar purposes on the Illinois River from its mouth
to Copperas Creek.
   By river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, the annual appropriation
for operating snag boats was also made available for similar pur-
poses on the Minnesota River and other tributaries of the upper
Mississippi River, now or heretofore improved by the United States.
This act extends the snag-boat jurisdiction on the Illinois River from
Copperas Creek to La Salle, and on the Minnesota, the St. Croix,
Chippewa, Wisconsin, Black, Galena, and Rock rivers.
   During the past fiscal year the snag boat David Tipton (formerly
Colonel A. Mackenzie) was employed from July 1 to November 12,
1908, and from April 3 to June 30, 1909, in removing snags and other
obstructions, and otherwise assisting the interests of navigation in
the Mississippi River between Minneapolis and the mouth of Missouri
River, in the Illinois River from its mouth to La Salle, and in the
Minnesota River.
   The U. S. dipper dredge Vulcan was employed from July 9 to the
middle of August in removing obstructions in front of St. Paul, and
at several other localities between St. PalJ and Fountain City.
   The total amount expended for snag-boat service to June 30, 1909,
was $1,049,584.
   The total quantity of freight transported on the upper Mississippi
River during the calendar year 1908 was about 2,581,857 tons and
the ton-miles 227,761,355; in 1907, 3,919,440 tons, and 532,899,223
ton-miles.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909,
was $25,000.
   (See Appendix Y 1.)
   2. Mississippi River between Missouri River and Minneapolis,
Minn.-Between Missouri River and St. Paul, Minn.-Under this
head is carried on the improvement of through navigation and also
such special harbor or levee work as is provided for by Congress.
Systematic work was begun in 1878, and such good results have been
secured as to demonstrate that with a continuance of operations under
liberal appropriations the low-water channel of the Mississippi River
between St. Paul and the Missouri River can be made sufficiently
deep, available, and permanent to satisfy the demands of commerce.
   The original condition of the channel between the Missouri River
and St. Paul was such that in low stages the larger boats were unable
to proceed farther upstream than La Crosse or Winona, and in many
seasons at points much lower down their progress was checked or
seriously hindered.
   The original project for the improvement, adopted in 1879, pro-
posed the contraction of the channel or waterway by means of wing
and closing dams to such an extent as, by means of the scour caused,
to afford a channel of sufficient width and of a depth of 41 feet at low
water. There was expended under the original project and the pro-
visional modified project of 1897 to June 30, 1909, $12,104,097.72,
of which about $750,000 was applied to maintenance. At that date,
and for many years previous, the condition of the channel was such
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     555
as to permit the passage of the largest river boats at very low stages
to St. Paul. It should be noted that of the amount above stated,
$1,058,000 has been expended for harbors and levees not connected
with through channel improvement, and that there is still available
for these purposes $5,105.01.
   The existing project, for the purpose of ultimately securing and
maintaining a depth of 6 feet, was adopted by Congress March 2,
1907, and is given in full with detailed estimate in House Document
No. 341, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session. It provides for fur-
ther contraction of the channel, for auxiliary dredging, for a lateral
canal at Rock Island Rapids and deepening Des Moines Rapids
Canal, for repairs to existing work and for maintenance during con-
struction. The estimate of cost, which does not include work be-
tween St. Paul and Minneapolis, is $20,000,000, provided it be com-
pleted within twenty years, and for care and maintenance after com-
pletion, $300,000 per annum. The said act appropriated $500,000,
and authorized contracts for prosecuting this work to the amount of
$1,500,000 additional, of which $500,000 is yet to be appropriated,
and limited the cost of work for each year to $500,000 for three
years. To June 30, 1909, the amount expended on this project was
$911,420.62.
    During the past year work has been carried on by hired labor and
use of government plant in vicinity of Alma and Pine Island, between
Minneopa and La Moille, at Richmond Island, in vicinity of North
Buena Vista, Guttenberg, and Eagle Point, at Rock Island Rapids,
in vicinity of Gilberts Island, at Atlas Island and Hickory Chute, and
under formal contract in Cassville Chute and Guttenberg channel,
above New Boston, at Benton Island, and in vicinity of Buzzard,
Hadley, Fabius, and Armstrong islands. At all localities where
work was performed good results were obtained.
    With the expenditure during the past year an increased depth was
obtained at several localities. Needed repairs were made to dams
and shore protections that were broken, settled, or otherwise damaged.
    The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, from the
Missouri River to St. Paul, 658 miles, at mean low water (stage 1.5
above extreme low water) was, as nearly as could be ascertained, 4.5
feet. During the past year, on account of prevailing high stages of
the river, there has been at no point less than 7 feet (except for about
four weeks in September) except at the Des Moines Rapids Canal.
    The navigation interests are important, although mush less than
in former years, owing to the gradual decrease of the handling of logs
and manufacture of lumber. The amount of freight carried during
the season of 1908 was about 2,581,857 tons, having an approximate
valuation of $33,295,531, the tonnage being about 34 per cent and
the valuation 9 per cent less than in 1907. The number of ton-
miles was 227,761,355.
    The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure is to be used in
the continuation of improvement work in accordance with the 6-foot
project adopted by Congress, March 2, 1907, for the purpose of exten-
sion of benefits of navigation. It is the estimated expenditure for
one year only.
    An instance of the effect of river improvement and water competi-
tion on freight applying to that portion of the Mississippi River in
556           REPORT OF THIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

question, taken from a report of the Upper Mississippi River Improve-
ment Association, is here given:
A comparison of freight rates between points having water competition and an inland
                                       point.

                                                                                           Classes.
         From-                      To-              Miles.   Route.
                                                                          1.       2.         3.       4.     5.

St. Louis.............. St. Paul..........              573   Rail....    $0.63   $0.521    $0.42     $0.26   $0.21
    Do.....    .....      ....    do............ .      729   Boat...    . 40       .34       .27       .17     .14
    Do..........     ....      Oklahoma........         543   Rail....     1.30    1.09       .97       .84     .67



   While it is not claimed that river improvements are solely respon-
sible for the great difference in freight rates above shown, it is well
known that wherever water competition exists, whether by river,
canal, or lake, its effect on freight rates is always beneficial to the
public, and that so long as the navigation of the Mississippi River is
feasible, and largely in proportion to its feasibility, such benefits will
accrue, even if but little river commerce is actually carried on.
   It is noted that the rate charged by the railroads on both banks of
the river on freight from St. Louis to St. Paul is about 50 per cent
greater than that charged by steamboats, and that the railroad rate
to an inland point having no water competition, but at about the
same distance, is more than 200 per cent greater. The same ratio
prevails for less distances.
   General Freight Agent Lusk, of the principal line of steamers on
the upper Mississippi, the Diamond Jo, says:
   With the improvement of the river there would be a large increase in the freight
traffic, for frequently during the past season by refusing heavy freight shipments we
could run our steamboats to St. Paul and take care of the passenger traffic, but on
account of the low water our earnings from freight were materially decreased.
   From information furnished by lumbermen and raft-boat owners
it is learned that the rate per ton-mile on logs and lumber floated
down the river to various points ran from one-half mill to 1 mills,
the average rate being about 1 mill ($0.001).
   The lowest rate by rail for lumber in carload lots between upper
Mississippi River points, ascertained from actual shipments by this
office from St. Paul to Fountain City, Rock Island, and Keokuk is
6 mills per ton-mile. This indicates a saving in freight by river of
5 mills per ton-mile, or $982,21.5 on the logs and lumber moved dur-
ing 1908.
   A classification of the freight carried by steamboats in 1908 was
found impracticable, but on the least favorable showing in above
table the saving was $0.07 per 100 pounds for 600 miles, or $0.00233
per ton-mile, which amounts in round numbers to $66,770. It is to
be remembered that benefit also accrues to the public in the reduc-
tion, due to the river, of rates on freight carried by rail, the amount
of which freight, although not definitely known, is thought to be
much greater than that carried by boats. Were the improvement
of the river to be abandoned and no further navigation practicable,
the loss to the public during each year, on the basis of the rates to
inland points, would be several millions.
                             RIVER AND              IHARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                            557
   The continued prosecution of the improvement to a greater extent
than in recent years seems advisable, in order that the condition of
the river for through navigation may be maintained and more rapidly
improved. It is not anticipated that any further material reduction
in freight rates on the adjacent railways will thus be had, but there
would otherwise be danger that any lessened efficiency of the river
for navigation would soon result in an increase in freight rates, and
the volume of freight that might thus be affected is so great that a
very small increase on these rail rates would annually exceed in total
amount the recent annual appropriations for the portion of the
Mississippi River in question.
   For constructing, repairing, and revetting the Flint Creek to Iowa
River levee and for protecting adjacent river bank there has been
expended to June 30, 1909, $310,000. During the past year an
additional allotment of $10,000 having been made in the sundry
civil act of May 27, 1908, the shore protection at Crutchfield Prairie
was repaired and extended 1,692 feet and 1,500 linear feet of shore
protection was constructed in section 6 on the Iowa River. This
levee runs from a point about 7 miles up the Iowa River down the
west bank of that river and of the Mississippi River to Flint Creek
near Burlington, Iowa.
   For dredging Quincy Bay there has been expended to June 30,
1909, $129,481.36, and for Quincy Bay and bar at Quincy $26,178.21
additional. No work was done under this allotment during the year,
and the unexpended balance is $640.81.
   For the construction of a harbor of refuge below Davenport, Iowa,
there has been expended to June 30, 1909, $13,068.05, for raising and
repairing the dam at the head of Rockingham Slough and for dredging,
sinking cribs, and driving piles. No work was done during the year.
   For the channel and harbor at Hannibal, Mo., there has been ex-
pended to June 30, 1909, $59,762.67. No work was done during the
past year.
   For the harbor at Muscatine, Iowa, there has been expended to
June 30, 1909, $43,148.60. No work was done during the past year.
   For the harbor of refuge at Pepin, Wis., on Lake Pepin, there has
been expended to June 30, 1909, $25,500. During the year the pier,
the construction of which had been delayed for several years by high
water, was completed.
   For dredging at harbors and landing places, under allotments
amounting to $100,000, there has been expended to June 30, 1909,
$78,000. Satisfactory work was done during the past year at Red-
wing, La Crosse, Eagle Point, Cassville, Prairie du Chien, Moline,
Quincy, and Hamburg.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................                                           $640, 693. 37
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909-.........-------..........--..................-----------------------.....------......---     500, 000.00
Miscellaneous receipts.............................................                                                511. 75
                                                                                                            1, 141, 205. 12
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement ...................................................                                               645, 920. 52

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................                                           495, 284. 60
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................                                       40, 017. 80
July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................                                           455, 266.80
558          REPORT OF THE CHIEF                          OF ENGINEERS, U.     S. ARMY.

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..............     $80, 935.92
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... 18, 500, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.................................                      .......   a 500, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
   (See Appendix Y 2.)
   3. Operating and care of Des Moines Rapids Canal and dry dock.-
During the past fiscal year the Des Moines Rapids Canal was open
for navigation two hundred and forty-nine days, during which time
there passed through it 1,180 steamboats and 261 barges, carrying
34,242 passengers, 7,878 tons of merchandise, and 2.500 bushels of
grain. Th~ve also passed through the canal 600,000 feet b. m. of
lumber, 10;903,000 feet of logs, 100,000 shingles, and 100,000 laths.
This statement is about the same as that of the previous year, but
is of little value, as, on account of high stages of water, most of
the traffic passed over the rapids instead of through the canal.
   The draft afforded by the canal is 5 feet at extreme low water,
which may be increased to 6 feet at high stages. There are three
locks having an available length of 325 feet and width of 78.5. The
minimum width of the canal prism at water surface is 200 feet.
   The dry dock was in constant use during the entire year.
   The cost of operating and care of the canal is provided for by
an indefinite appropriation made by act of July 5, 1884, as amended
and reenacted by section 6 of the river and harbor act of March 3,
1909.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1909, amounted to $1,347,203.88
of which $43,185.70 was expended during the past year.
   (See Appendix Y 3.)
   4. Mississippi River at Moline, Ill.-The river and harbor act of
March 3, 1905, adopted a definite project for improving Mississippi
River at Moline by excavating a channel 250 feet wide and 4 feet
deep at low water from the city of Moline to the head of the so-called
arsenal dike above the city, and a similar channel connecting with
the main river by means of a lock and dam at the foot of Benhams
Island opposite the city, at an estimated cost of $386,000 and
$10,000 annually for operation, care, and maintenance.
   The entire amount of the estimate has been appropriated.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $372,825.42.
   The lock was practically completed and opened to navigation
December 23, 1907.
   Some work was done in removing rock from the upper approach
and in dredging mud and sand near head of Arsenal Island.
   For reference to the approved project, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 429.
   a This estimate is for the full amount of the approximate annual expenditures
for this work fixed by Congress in the continuing-contract authorization of March 2,
1907. It is noted that at this rate from thirty-five to forty years will be required to
complete the existing project. In his report herewith (Appendix Y 2) the district
engineer officer recommends that the next fiscal year appropriation be $1,500,000,
and his opinion, that prosecution of this improvement is advisable to a greater extent
than has been authorized in recent years, is concurred in.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               559
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................      $16, 030. 30
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.......................-------...........----.........................   2, 855.72

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                             13, 174.58
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities --   ----...........--        ----......---..............       217.80

July 1, 1909, balance available ..............            .......       ....    ...........       12.956.78
    (See Appendix Y 4.)
   5. Operating and care of Mississippi River improvement at Moline,
Ill.-This lock, which admits boats to Moline and also forms a link in
the 6-foot channel improvement of Rock Island Rapids, was for-
mally opened to navigation December 23, 1907. During the past
fiscal year the lock was in use 259 days, during which time there
passed through it 2,713 boats and 1,132 barges, carrying 46,693 tons
of freight and 43,112 passengers. As the lock was in operation only
a portion of the previous year, no accurate comparison of traffic can
be made.
   The draft afforded by the lock is 6 feet at extreme low water. It
has an available length of 325 feet and width of 80 feet.
   The cost of operating and care of Moline lock is provided for by
an indefinite appropriation made by act of July 5, 1884, as amended
and reenacted by section 6 of the river and harbor act of March 3,
1909. The expenditures to June 30, 1909, amounted to $14,799.03, of
which $10,000 was expended during the past year.
    (See Appendix Y 5.)
   6. Operating and care of Milan section of Illinois and Mississippi
Canal, Ill.-This portion of the canal is 4 miles in length, sur-
mounting a fall of 18 feet, and was formally opened to navigation
April 17, 1895. During the past fiscal year the canal was in use 260
days, during which time there passed through it 1,756 boats and 745
barges, carrying 12,512 tons of freight and 9,336 passengers.
   The commercial traffic was about the same as that of the previous
year.
   The draft afforded by the canal is 7 feet.
   The locks, 3 in number, have a length of 170 feet between miter
sills and a width of 35 feet. The cost of operating and care of the
canal is provided for by an indefinite appropriation made by act of
July 5, 1884, as amended and reenacted by section 6 of the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909.
   The expenditures to June 30, 1909, amounted to $128,730.38, of
which $19,700 was expended during the past year.
    (See Appendix Y 6.)
    7. Illinois and Mississippi Canal: Improvement of Rock River
pool.-With funds provided from the appropriation for construction of
the canal during 1908, suction dredge Geyser was employed for one
week removing sand to the amount of 4,274 cubic yards from the
lower approach to Lock 29 and in Anderson Chute. Drill boat 103
and dipper dredge Ajax were employed from September 1 to Novem-
ber 20, 1908, in blasting and removing rock between Lock 29 and
Anderson Island and at Hilliers Island. In this work about 3,959
cubic yards of rock and 3,165 cubic yards of sand were removed.
560      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.       S. ARMY.

Buoys and channel marks were placed and- considerable snagging
done.
  In 1909 work was resumed in April with drill boat 103 and dredge
Ajax and was carried on to June 30 at IHilliers Island and below
Lock 29. The project for improvement from Lock 29 to Hilliers
was changed to give a width of 200 feet and to throw the channel to
the south of Andersons Island.
  The amount expended on this improvement is $42,399.29, and
during the year $22,399.29.
   (See Appendix Y 7.)
  8. Operating and care of Galena River improvement, Illinois.-This
improvement, consisting of a lock and dam in the Galena River, was
purchased by the United States in March, 1894, under provisions of
the act of September 19, 1890, at a cost of $100,000.
  During the past fiscal year the lock was open for navigation 235
days, in which time there passed through it 4,750 steamboats,
launches, and barges, carrying 16,093 passengers and 15,166 tons of
merchandise, which traffic is four times as great in merchandise and
about 70 per cent greater in boats than the previous year.
   The draft that can be carried at extreme low water is 2 feet, as
limited by the depth on the lower miter sill of the lock, which has an
available length of 280 feet and width of 52 feet.
   The cost of operating and care of the improvement is provided for
under an indefinite appropriation made by act of July 5, 1884, as
amended and reenacted by section 6 of the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1909, and the amount expended to June 30, 1909, is
$81,407.44, of which $4,500 was expended during the year.
   (See Appendix Y 8.)
      IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE ST. PAUL,
                     MINNESOTA, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Maj. Francis R. Shunk, Corps of
Engineers Division engineer, Col. W. H. Bixby, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Mississippi River between St. Paul and Minneapolis, Minn.-
This section of the Mississippi River, from the Chicago, St. Paul,
Minneapolis and Omaha Railway bridge in St. Paul to Washington
Avenue Bridge in Minneapolis, is 11.4 miles long. Before improve-
ment, boats drawing 3 feet could go up at ordinary low water as far as
the mouth of the Minnesota River, 2.66 miles above the Chicago, St.
Paul, Minneapolis and Omaha Railway bridge. From the Minne-
sota River to the present site of Dam No. 2, a distance of 6.56 miles,
there was a channel about 2Z feet deep, but on account of the velocity
of the current upstream freighting was difficult and unprofitable.
From this point to the Washington Avenue Bridge, a distance of 2.18
miles, the depth was not more than 2 feet at ordinary low stage, and
the velocity such as effectually to prevent navigation. Before 1894
work was done in this part of the river under allotments from the
appropriations for "Improving the Mississippi River from the land-
ing on the west bank below the Washington Avenue Bridge, Minne-
apolis, to the Des Moines Rapids."       A total amount of $59,098.70
was thus expended in dredging, bank protection, and construction of
wing dams. As a result considerable improvement was made in the
navigable reaches, but the limits of navigation were not extended.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMVPROVEMENTS.                               561
   In 1894 a separate project was adopted for the Mississippi River
between St. Paul and Minneapolis. It provided for two locks and
dams: One (No. 1) just above the mouth of Minnehaha Creek, and
3.68 miles above the Minnesota River, to have a lift of 13.3 feet; an-
other (No. 2), 2.88 miles above No. 1 and 2.18 miles below Washing-
ton Avenue Bridge, Minneapolis, to have a lift of 13.8 feet. The lock
chambers were to be 80 feet by 334 feet, and the depth on the lower
miter sills 5 feet at low water.
   This project was modified by the act of March 2, 1907, which re-
quires a channel depth of 6 feet instead of 5 feet. This will make
it necessary to increase the lifts of the two dams, and to take meas-
ures for increasing the depth on the lower miter sill of Lock No. 1
to 6 feet at low water; but funds for this work have not as yet been
provided by Congress.
   The river and harbor act approved March 3, 1899, authorized the
completion of Lock and Dam No. 2, together with Lock and Dam No.
1, under continuing contracts or otherwise, at a total cost, for both
locks and dams, of $1,166,457. An increase in the limit of cost to
$1,466,000 was authorized by the river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1905. This act authorized continuing contracts for the
completion of the work in the sum of $299,543, of which $59,543 still
remains to be appropriated.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30, 1909, was
$1,149,453.47, of which $2,792.43 was for maintenance.
   Lock and Dam No. 2 is now completed and has been in operation
since May, 1907. Lock No. 1 is completed, except some backfilling,
lock gates, and maneuvering machinery, but no work has yet been
done on Dam No. 1. The whole project is about 75 per cent completed.
   Until the completion of Lock and Dam No. 1, the work can not
have much beneficial e'ffect on the navigability of the river.
   The river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909, provided for the
examination of the river with a view of modifying the project. The
item is as follows:
  Mississippi River, from St. Paul to Minneapolis, with a view to modification of proj-
ect to provide for increased depth and utilizing the surplus water for development of
power: Provided, That if any modification of the present project be deemed advisable
by the Chief of Engineers, no work thereon shall be performed inconsistent with such
proposed modifications. The Chief of Engineers shall submit various practical alter-
native plans with the advantages of each.
   A Board of Engineers, consisting of Maj. Charles S. Rich6, Maj.
Francis R. Shunk, and Maj. Charles S. Bromwell, has been appointed
to consider and report upon the proposed modification.
   The usual variation of level of water surface is about 8 feet, with
a maximum variation of about 16 feet.
   The head of navigation for large boats now is the mouth of the
Minnesota River, 2.7 miles above the Chicago, St. Paul, Minneapolis
and Omaha Railway bridge in St. Paul. The reach from the mouth
of the Minnesota River to Minnehaha Creek, a distance of 3.3 miles,
is regularly used by light-draft excursion boats.
   At the present time the principal commerce is the passage of logs,
loose and rafted. During the calendar year 1908, 77,000,000 feet
b. m. of logs, approximately 350,000 tons, with an estimated value of
$1,694,000, was floated down the river. The excursion business
amounts to about $15,000 per annum.
      9001-ENa    1909-----36
562         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                              S. ARMY.


  The construction of the two locks and dams will develop a passen-
ger traffic between St. Paul and Minneapolis, and is expected to re-
duce the freight rate on flour and grain shipped from Minneapolis.
  It is proposed to expend the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure during the fiscal year 1911 in completing Lock and
Dam No. 1.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................                       $167, 423. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 180, 000. 00
Miscellaneous receipts ..........................                               .......
                                                                   ........ .. .........        17. 70

                                                                                          347, 440. 70
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..................... .......................................                       88, 056.69

July 1, 1909; balance unexpended ............         ......................              259, 354. 01
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..-.-................              ...............     1, 958. 54

July 1, 1909, balance available.--..-.............._ .........                ........    257, 425. 47

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                     59, 543. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909..............................    ....     ............                      59, 543.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
   (See Appendix Z 1.)
   2. Operating and care of Lock No. 2, Mississippi River between St.
Paul and Minneapolis, Minn.-This lock and dam were completed
in 1906, and their maintenance and operation have been provided
for since July 1, 1907, by allotments from the appropriation for
"Operating and care of canals and other works of navigation."
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $7,405.28.
   Lock and Dam No. 2 is the first of a series of two between St.
Paul and Minneapolis, Minn., the object of which was to provide
slack-water navigation over the stretch of river between Minnehaha
Creek and the Washington Avenue Bridge, Minneapolis, Minn.
No. 2 is the upper one of the series and was constructed first because
navigation on the section above was difficult and hazardous under
the most favorable conditions, and virtually impossible at low stages
of the river.
   Since the completion of this lock and dam the river above is
navigable up to Washington Avenue Bridge, Minneapolis, for boats
drawing 5 feet. Until Lock and Dam No. 1 are completed, how-
ever, the full benefit of Lock and Dam No. 2 can not be felt, since
the river between the two locks is very difficult of navigation in its
present condition.
   During the year 77,000,000 feet b. m. of logs passed the dam.
The weight of these logs was about 350,000 tons and their value
about $1,694,000.
   (See Appendix Z 2.)
   3. Reservoirs at headwaters of Mississippi River and Mississippi
River between Brainerd and Grand Rapids, Minn.-Under this title
are included two entirely separate improvements, which are separately
considered:
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     563
   (a) Reservoirs at headwaters of Mississippi River.-These works
are intended to improve navigable depths on the Mississippi River
above Lake Pepin. Before improvement the river was subject to
fluctuations of level between wide limits and was often unnavigable
at low stages.
   The project adopted in 1880 called for the construction of forty-one
reservoirs in Minnesota and Wisconsin to collect surplus water from
the precipitation of winter, spring, and early summer, and release it
systematically during low water so as to benefit navigation on the
Mississippi River. The estimated cost, exclusive of land and flowage
easements, was $1,809,083.
   In compliance with act of Congress of August 5, 1886, the Chief of
Engineers, in 1887, recommended that the reservoirs originally con-
templated on the St. Croix, Chippewa, and Wisconsin rivers be not
constructed. Subsequent acts of Congress have been in accord with
this recommendation, and the project is considered as modified to the
extent recommended. (See Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1887, pp. 1681 et seq.)
   The act of March 2, 1907, authorized the construction of a reservoir
at Gull Lake, Minnesota, at an estimated cost of $70,000, provided
that the necessary land and flowage easements be acquired without
cost to the United States. About one-third of the flowage rights
required have been deeded to the United States and the rest are in
process of condemnation by private parties for the United States.
The same act authorized the reconstruction of Sandy Lake dam,
without a lock for steamboats, at an estimated cost of $75,000.
This provision was amended by section 5 of an act (Public, No. 153)
approved May 28, 1908, by striking out the words "without a lock
for steamboats."
   The total expenditure up to June 30, 1909, was $1,513,160.21, of
which $638,732.56 was for original construction, $484,298.73 for
renewal and maintenance, $153,393.11 for acquisition of land and
flowage rights, including surveys, and the remainder for operating
expenses, damages, and contingencies.
    The sum of $258.65 has been received on account of refundments
and the sale of material.
    Five timber dams were built, at Lake Winnibigoshish, Leech Lake,
Pokegama Falls, Pine River, and Sandy Lake. The first four have
been rebuilt in concrete, and the building of a new concrete dam at
Sandy Lake is now in progress.
    Title to 6,122 acres of land has been acquired, and flowage rights
on 9,553 acres, including 283 acres for the proposed Gull Lake
Reservoir.
    Since 1898 operations have been confined to the completion, renewal,
and repair of existing works, surveys, and acquisition of necessary
land and flowage easements.
    The expenditure as a whole has resulted in benefit during the low-
water season to the navigable portions of the Mississippi River from
Cass Lake, Minn., to Lake Pepin, and incidentally in the mitigation
of the floods in the river above St. Paul. The chief benefit has prob-
ably been to commerce on the Mississippi River from St. Paul down.
    The effect on freight rates has been considerable, both on the upper
river and below St. Paul. Without the reservoirs steamboat trans-
564          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                         S. ARMY.

portation would scarcely be possible during low water between Brain-
erd and Grand Rapids, and freight would have to be carried by
wagons at great expense. It is a fact that railroad freight from St.
Paul to St. Louis, a distance of 600 miles, is only 5 per cent higher
than the rate from St. Paul to Chicago, 400 miles; and that steamboat
freight rates to river points below St. Paul are in general about one-
third lower than those of the railroads. Some portion of this reduc-
tion is doubtless due to the reservoirs.
    (b) Mississippi River between Brainerd and Grand Rapids, Minn.-
By act of June 13, 1902, this improvement was added to the project
for reservoirs. Work of snagging, bowlder removal, etc., had been
done on this part of the river under a project (now expired) for
"Improving Mississippi River above the Falls of St. Anthony." The
present project contemplates continuation of such work. No esti-
mate of cost has been adopted.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $19,000.96 had been expended. As a result
the channel between Brainerd and Grand Rapids was greatly improved
by removal of snags, overhanging trees, bowlders, etc. The maxi-
mum draft that can be carried at low water on the Mississippi River
above Brainerd depends upon the manipulation of the reservoirs.
The amount of water discharged varies with the requirements of
navigation, but a depth of 4 feet could probably be maintained
throughout the low-water season if necessary. The usual variation
in level is about 10 feet. Cass Lake, 283 miles above Brainerd, is the
head of navigation.
   There are three steamboats and several launches operating on the
Mississippi River between Brainerd and Grand Rapids. During the
season of 1908 these boats carried about 1,500 tons of miscellaneous
freight, of an estimated value of $100,000, and about 1,700 passengers.
In addition to the above about 255,000,000 feet b. m. of loose logs
and rafts of hard wood, poles, and pulp wood were floated over this
section of the river. The combined weight of the last two items was
about 1,150,000 tons and the value about $5,100,000.
   There are no railroads paralleling the portion of the river under
improvement, and inhabitants of the adjacent country are dependent
upon the river as a means of transportation. The work of improve-
ment has given a safer and more commodious channel, and has
doubtless kept down freight rates on the river.
   Under the whole project no additional appropriations are needed
for expenditure during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911. It is
proposed to expend the available funds in building a lock at Sandy
Lake, building dikes, etc.
                                          GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended------...--......---------............................ $109, 884. 51
Amount derived from sales.........   .. ...                         ........--- ....
                                                         -...........              -25.00
                                                                                       109, 909. 51
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment...............................................................                   46, 382. 87

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                   63, 526. 64
July 1, 1909, outstandin liabilities....................................                    696. 15

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                   62, 830. 49
                            RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          565

                                RECONSTRUCTION OF SANDY LAKE DAM.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................       .................... $42, 672. 55
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.--............-...... .... ..........      ........................    36, 658.15
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-.....           ....... ......                                   -..............     6, 014. 40
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities... .................................                                               460. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available................. .........                                  ..       .........        5, 554.40

                              CONSTRUCTION          OF GULL LAKE             RESERVOIR.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................                  ......... $69, 412. 68
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment........... .... . ..... ..... ...................................                356.24
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                                69, 056. 44
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...... -............-.................                                                7.00

July 1, 1909, balance available...................................                                                   69, 049. 44

                                                  CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................                                 .......           ....   $221, 969. 74
Amount derived from sales ...........................................                                                   25. 00
                                                                                                                    221, 994. 74
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ..................................................................                                            83, 397.26

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended------------.......---.................------------.......--------..                138, 597. 48
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ..................................                                             1, 163. 15
July 1, 1909, balance available -...............                    .....................                           137, 434. 33
   (See. Appendix Z 3.)
   4. Operating and care of reservoirs at headwaters of Mississippi
River.-Before 1894 the expenses of operation were paid from the
appropriations for construction. By act of August 18, 1894, the
"care, preservation, and maintenance" of the reservoirs were in-
cluded under the appropriation for "Operating and care of canals
and other works of navigation." Annual allotments have since been
made from that appropriation.
   The care, preservation, and maintenance of the reservoirs include
repairs to dams, dikes, buildings, roads, telephone lines, etc., and the
payment of salaries to dam tenders and gauge readers.
   The reservoirs are operated mainly with a view to the improve-
ment of navigation on the Mississippi River, but with due regard
to other legitimate interests. Incidentally they are of great benefit in
mitigating floods and in regulating the flow of water for power
purposes. No definith schedule can be determined beforehand, but
the following are the general rules observed in operation:
   (a) The discharge must not, by operation of the reservoirs, be re-
duced below the normal low-water flow of the streams affected. This
rule is necessary in the interest of manufacturers.
   (b) When logs arrive in the reservoirs they must be sluiced through.
Transportation of logs by floating is a form of commerce and the
main form of commerce on the streams affected by the reservoirs. It
is dangerous to the dams to allow accumulations of logs, so that they
must be sluiced through even in times of flood.
566     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.           S. ARMY.

   (c) The winter flow is so regulated as to make room for 39,000,-
000,000 cubic feet of water at the end of winter. This is the amount
ordinarily'to be expected in the spring floods.
   (d) From the spring thaw until the dry season of summer (ordi-
narily until about July 10) as much water is retained in the reser-
voirs as possible, subject to rules (a) and (b).
   (e) When the gauge at St. Paul has fallen nearly to 3 feet (which
reading indicates a channel depth at St. Paul of 5 feet) water is
released so as to keep the gauge at this reading. If there is not
enough water for this purpose, then the greatest constant depth pos-
sible is maintained.
   (f) When, during the low-water stage, there is not sufficient depth
for the steamer plying between Aitkin and Grand Rapids and the
quantity of water in the reservoirs is sufficient, enough water is re-
leased, on request, to make a trip possible. This use of the reservoirs
is occasional.
   The total amount expended up to June 30, 1909, was $279,137.46,
of which $27,932.08 was expended during the past year. As a result
the river has been maintained during the summers of most years at a
navigable stage in its upper portion and from St. Paul to Lake
Pepin. Flood heights in the Mississippi have been reduced, often by
several feet, and the benefit to manufacturing interests, due to the
more uniform flow, has been very great.
   For capacities of reservoirs, maps of region, and comparison of
rainfall and run-off, see Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers
for 1896, page 1841, and for 1905, page 1678. For break in Pine River
reservoir, see Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1896,
page 1844, and for 1897, page 2144. For diagrams showing how
much water had been stored each year in each reservoir, see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, Part 4, page 2798. For
distribution of liabilities incurred during the fiscal years 1898 to 1905,
see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, pages 1676-
1677. For report of Board of Engineers upon matters connected
with the operation of the reservoirs, see Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1906, Part 2, page 1443.
   (See Appendix Z 4.)
   5. St. Croix River, Wisconsin and Minnesota.-Before improvement
the ruling low-water depth on the bars above Lake St. Croix was 2
feet. In Lake St. Croix the channel was in most places 8 to 10 feet
deep, but narrow and tortuous.
   The project was adopted in 1875, and amended as to estimates of
cost in 1882 and 1889. By act of June 3, 1896, the improvement of
the harbor and water front of Stillwater was added to the project.
   The end sought was to provide a commodious channel 3 feet deep
at low water from Taylors Falls to the Mississippi River, a distance
of 52.3 miles, and to give adequate harbor facilities at Stillwater.
This was to be done by means of dredging in Lake St. Croix and at
Stillwater and by dredging and contraction works above Lake St.
Croix. The estimate of cost, as finally modified, was $136,700. The
project was completed in 1900.
   Since that time work of maintenance has been done. The appro-
priations have not been sufficient to accomplish all that was desired,
                    RIVER AND IHARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              567
and the channel above Lake St. Croix has deteriorated so as to be
scarcely navigable at low stages. This deterioration is mainly due to
the choking of the river by snags and sunken logs.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $147,694.86, of which
the amount spent since 1900, $16,285.36, was for maintenance only.
   Regular appropriations of $3,600 per annum are needed for the
maintenance of this improvement.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at low
water was 3 feet at and below Stillwater. Above Stillwater it was
not more than 2 feet. Taylors Falls, about 52 miles from its mouth,
is the head of navigation on this stream. The usual variation of
level of water surface is about 6 feet.
   The commerce of this river is chiefly in logs, which are floated
loose to Stillwater, Minn., and rafted below that place. About
84,000,000 feet b. m. of loose logs were floated during the season of
1908, their weight being about 378,000 tons and their value about
$1,848,000. About 43,000,000 feet b. m. of logs and manufactured
lumber, 4,000,000 laths, and 6,000,000 shingles were rafted below
Stillwater, 10 steamboats being engaged in these operations. One
steamboat made daily trips during the season between Osceola and
Taylors Falls, Minn., carrying passengers and a little freight, but no
information could be obtained of the amount of business done. No
freight to speak of has been carried on the river in recent years. The
work done has had no effect on freight rates.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable expendi-
ture in fiscal year 1911 to dredging and the repair of wing dams, such
work being necessary to make previous improvements available.
   Reports on examinations of this river have been published as fol-
lows: Ordered by act of June 23, 1874, Executive Document No. 75
(part 6), Forty-third Congress, second session; report dated January
26, 1880, Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1880, page 1661;
ordered by river and harbor act of September 19, 1890, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1891, page 2218; ordered by
river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1900, page 2837; ordered by river and harbor act of
March 3, 1905, House Document No. 686, Fifty-ninth Congress, first
session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................... $397. 74
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..........................................     ............. 3, 600. 00

                                                                             3, 997.74
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ................................................... .....        727. 60

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................... 3, 270. 14
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.................. ... ........
                                                                ........   585. 29

July 1, 1909, balance available ..-..................... ................ 2, 684. 85
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
                                                                          4, 000. 00
   pended July 1,1909.................................-----------------------
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix Z 5.)
568     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

   6. Minnesota River, Minnesota. Before improvement the ruling
low-water depth at the entrance to Minnesota River was not more
than 2 feet. From the mouth to Shakopee, a distance of 23.7 miles,
there was a least low-water depth of 7 feet, and from Shakopee to
Little Rapids, 11.8 miles, a least depth of 3 feet. From Little
Rapids to Mankato, a distance of 78.2 miles, the river was navigable
only at the higher stages. Above Mankato navigation was possible
only at very high water. Along the entire course the channel was
obstructed by bowlders, snags, and overhanging trees.
   The project, adopted in 1867, provided for the removal of snags,
bowlders, etc., from Yellow Medicine River to the mouth, a distance
of 237 miles. The estimate of cost was $117,000. In 1893 the project
was modified to include the construction of a low-water dam across
the mouth of the river at Pike Island, and the excavation of a new
channel through Fort Snelling Chute at the head of Pike Island.
When the Minnesota River is low, the Mississippi River, at the head
of Pike Island, is ordinarily higher than the Minnesota, and the
object of the dam and new channel was to raise the level of the Min-
nesota at and near Little Rapids during low stages as well as to pro-
vide a better entrance. The estimated cost of the new work was
$10,000. The project was completed in 1895. Work done since that
time has been in maintenance of the channel at the mouth.
   By act of June 13, 1902, $2,500 was appropriated for the removal
of the dam at Pike Island, should the Secretary of War in his discre-
tion so determine. The dam was removed in 1908.
   Amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $139,438.02, of which
$7,938.77 was for maintenance of existing improvements.
   Appropriations since 1896 have been very small and irregular and
have all been applied to the maintenance of the improvement at the
mouth of the river, for which purpose they have not been sufficient.
   Regular appropriations of $2,000 per annum are needed for the
maintenance of this improvement.
   The maximum draft that could be carried to Shakopee June 30,
1909, at low water was 5 feet, great improvement in the navigable
depth at the entrance having resulted from the removal of the dam at
Pike Island.
   Little Rapids, 36 miles from the mouth, may be considered the
head of navigation at present, although at high stages navigation is
possible to Le Sueur, 88 miles from the mouth.
   The stream is at present used chiefly by excursion steamers and
small pleasure launches. A small freight boat ran between St. Peter
and Mankato during the season of 1909, but no statistics could be
obtained.
   The Minnesota River has as yet had no effect on freight rates, as
until this season vessels of commercial size have not been able to
enter it.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure in fiscal year 1911 to dredging the river from its mouth to
about 2 miles above.
   For historical sketches see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1879 and 1894, pages 1182 and 1725, respectively.
   For description and physical characteristics see Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1875, page 381. Reports of examinations have been
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                             569

published as follows: Executive Document No. 76, Forty-third Con-
gress, second session; Executive Documents Nos. 249 and 1335, Fifty-
third Congress, second session; Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1895, pages 2206 and 2208; Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1897,
page 1834; Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 2834;
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 2260; House Docu-
ument No. 493, Sixtieth Congress, first session.

                                REMOVING DAM NEAR MOUTH.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..-.....-  .......    ...........                               ...          $.. 500. 00
                                                                                                             $2,
Amount carried to the surplus fund of the Treasury- -. . ~.-..                        -.....                     -21. 32
                                                                                                              2, 478.68
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  m ent .................................... ...........................                                      2, 478.18
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................                 ...................                           .50
                                                   .
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities................    ..........             ..........                          . 50

                                  REMOVING BAR AT MOUTH.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended----  ..................................               $1, 894. 93
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.............. .......        ................-           .............  2, 000. 00

                                                                                                              3, 894. 93
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement............................... ..................  .........                                      1, 354. 77

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.--........ .......-...............                                    ...    2, 540. 16
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 ...............................................   2, 200.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                         CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended---.... ............-.......             .......... $4, 394. 93
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........     ............................................             2, 000.00

                                                                                                              6, 394. 93
Amount carried to the surplus fund of the Treasury ...............                              ....              21. 32

                                                                                                              6, 373.61
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
   For works of improvement............................                             $2, 478. 18
   For maintenance of improvement.......................                              1, 354. 77
                                                                                                              3, 832. 95

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.................                         ........ ..........                2, 540. 66
fAmount   that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...............................................    2,200. 00
iSubmitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix Z 6.)
   7. Red River of the North, Minnesota and North Dakota.-Under
this project are included the improvement of the Red River of the
570       REPORT OF THE CHIEF         OF ENGINEERS,      U.   S. ARMY.

North, Minnesota and North Dakota, and of Red Lake River, Minne-
sota.
   Before improvements the ruling depth at low water in the Red
River of the North from the Canadian frontier to Grand Forks, a
distance of 143.5 miles, was 2 feet, and from Grand Forks to Moor-
head, 155 miles, 1.5 feet. From Moorhead to Breckenridge, 97 miles,
navigation was possible only at the higher stages. The river was
obstructed by snags, overhanging trees, etc.
   Red Lake River from the head of Red Lake to Thief River Falls,
a distance of 135 miles, had a low-water depth of at least 3 feet in
most places, but was obstructed by a bar at the mouth of the lake and
by bowlders between Thief River Falls and High Landing, a dis-
tance of 35 miles, so that the ruling depth was 1.5 feet.
   The project for the Red River, adopted in 1878, provided for
dredging and removal of obstructions from Breckenridge to the in-
ternational boundary, and the construction of a lock and dam to over-
come the fall at Goose Rapids, the whole being with a view to obtain
channels as follows:
  Breckenridge to Moorhead, 97 miles, a channel capable of being navigated during
high and medium stages of water.
  Moorhead to Grand Forks, 155 miles, a channel 50 feet wide and 3 feet deep at
low water.
  Grand Forks to the northern boundary line, 143.5 miles, a channel 60 feet wide
and 4 feet deep at low water.
   The estimated cost was $364,598.17. This project was modified as
follows: In 1883 the estimated cost was increased to $398,598.17. In
1887 the proposed lock and dam at Goose Rapids was dropped from
the project and the estimate reduced to $252,598.37. In 1893 the
estimate was increased to $310,320.
   The improvement of Red Lake River was added to the project in
1896. It was proposed to provide a depth of 3 feet by dredging and
removal of bowlders from Thief River Falls to the head of Red Lake.
The amount authorized by Congress to be spent on this work was
$9,000. The total estimate for both rivers is therefore at present
$319,320.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $339,542.81, of
which $37,129.21 was for maintenance. The sum of $159.50 has been
returned to the appropriation by the sale of condemned material.
   As a result of these expenditures some improvement was made in
the few years subsequent to 1878 in the upper section of the river.
No work has been done in this section in recent years because there
has been no navigation. In the middle section the project was com-
pleted, except for 13 miles, in 1894. Since that time the river above
Bellmont, N. Dak., has been obstructed by unauthorized bridges
which do not permit navigation. In the lower section the project
was completed in 1902.
   Since the shoals in this river constantly recur, annual work of
maintenance is necessary. The funds supplied not having been suf-
ficient to maintain depths contemplated by the project, the navigable
depth of the middle section is now 2 feet and of the lower section 3.5
feet. Nothing beyond work of maintenance has been done in recent
years; this has been confined to dredging the worst bars in the vicin-
ity of Grand Forks, N. Dak. The expenditure of at least $7,500
annually would be required to keep the navigated portions of the
river in condition.
                       RIVER     AND     HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                  571
   On Red Lake River work has been confined to the removal of snags,
bowlders, and similar obstructions from the channel. No work has
been done since 1900, and in 1905 the floating plant used for this
work was sold by authority of the Secretary of War.
   The actual head of navigation on the Red River of the North is
Bellmont, N. Dak., about 180 miles by river from the international
boundary. The usual variation of water surface is 25 feet; the maxi-
mum variation 49 feet.
   Red Lake River is navigable from Thief River Falls to the head
of Red Lake, a distance of 135 miles. Below Thief River Falls the
river is not navigable. The usual variation of level is about 3.5 feet;
the maximum variation about 6 feet.
   Red River is regularly used during the summer season by 2 steam-
boats and 12 barges. During 1908, 12,026 tons of wheat were carried
from river points to Grand Forks for transfer to railroads.
   Four steamers and 1launch make use of the Red Lake River, car-
rying passengers and small amounts of freight. About 60,000,000
feet b. m. of logs were floated down Red Lake River during the season
of 1908, their weight being 270,000 tons and their value $1,320,000.
   In addition to the above about 400 tons of miscellaneous freight
and about 1,000 passengers were carried.
   Rates on the Red River steamers are from 70 to 50 per cent less than
the railroad rates between common points.
   This project has no apparent effect on railroad freight rates.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure for the fiscal year 1911 in dredging near Grand Forks, N. Dak.
   For physical characteristics see Annual Reports of the Chief of
Engineers for 1874, page 295; 1875, page 370; 1878, page 730; 1879,
page 1192. For plans of improvements see Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1874, page 297; 1879, page 1191; 1881, page
1757. For revisions of projects see Annual Reports of the Chief of
Engineers for 1883, page 1450; 1887, page 1712. For description of
large landslide caused by Northern Pacific Railroad embankment, see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1898, page 1831. Ref-
erences to reports on examinations ordered by the river and harbor
acts of March 3, 1905, and March 2, 1907, will be found in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, Part 1, page 483, and in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908, Part 1, page 542.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................                       $5, 024. 80
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......... ........... ... .................. .....                         7, 500. 00
                                                                                          12, 524. 80
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement..................................................                            5, 785. 11

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ..-...................             ...........     ..    6,739. 69
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ......... .. ........................                  701. 18

July 1, 1909, balance available..-....-................              .........     ...     6, 038. 51
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.....      ......................................                     7, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix Z 7.)
572           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                              U.   S. ARMY.

    8. Warroad Harbor and Warroad River, Minnesota.-Before im-
provement there was a good natural harbor of moderate depth at the
mouth of Warroad River. Between the harbor and the river there
was a bar having a least depth of 3.5 feet at ordinary lake stage (7.2
feet on the gauge) and between the harbor and the lake a bar having
a least depth of 5 feet at ordinary lake stage. The channel of the
Warroad River from the harbor to the steamboat landing (about 1
mile) was deep but tortuous.
    The river and harbor act of 1899, as amended by the act approved
June 6, 1900, appropriated $3,000, or so much thereof as might be
necessary, for improving the mouth of Warroad River, Minnesota.
Nothing was done under this appropriation beyond making an ex-
amination and survey.
    The present project was adopted in 1902, and provided for building
a dredge and dredging in the harbor a channel sufficient for boats
drawing 7 feet of water. The estimated cost was $45,000. This proj-
ect was modified in 1905 so as to provide for a channel 100 feet wide
and 7 feet deep from the inner end of the harbor channel to the boat
landing at Warroad, with a turning basin for boats at the inner end, at
an estimated cost of $35,000. The total estimate is therefore $80,000.
    The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $84,854.93, of
which $16,532.97 was for work of maintenance. As a result the turn-
ing basin was completed, the inner channel dredged for a distance of
4,000 feet to a width of 100 feet and a depth of 9 feet at ordinary
stage, and for a distance of 1,800 feet to a width of 200 feet and a
depth of 9 feet. The outer channel had been dredged from the harbor
to the lake, a distance of 5,400 feet, to a width of 200 feet and a depth
of 12 feet. The maximum draft that can be carried is 8 feet at a stage
of 7.2 feet on the lake gauge. This is sufficient for any boat now using
the Lake of the Woods.
   The head of navigation on Warroad River is at the steamboat land-
ing, about a mile above the mouth.
   The bars in this harbor are formed by wave action, and constantly
recur. Annual dredging is therefore necessary for maintenance. It
is estimated that $4,000 should be expended each year in work of
maintenance.
   During the season of 1908 the commerce amounted to 2,600 tons of
miscellaneous freight. Boats using the harbor carried about 7,700
passengers. The value of the business done could not be obtained.
   This improvement has no effect on railroad freight rates. There
are no railroads in competition with steamers on the lake.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................................                        $1, 839. 64
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ...   -...... .............          .....................      ........ 4, 000.00
Amount allotted from emergency appropriation, river and harbor act
  approved March 2, 1907.................          ............................           4, 000.00

                                                                                               9, 839. 64
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...............................                       $1, 200.00
    For maintenance of improvement .......................                         1, 904.00
                                                                                               3, 104. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                          6, 735.64
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ...................................                        727.86

July 1, 1909, balance available.......................................                         6, 007.78
    (See Appendix Z 8.)
                          RIVER. AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    573
   9. Survey of Otter Tail Lake and Otter Tail River and Red Lake
and Red Lake River, Minnesota, and of Big Stone Lake and Lake
Traverse, Minnesota and South Dakota. The river and harbor act
approved June 13, 1902, provided for the continuation of these sur-
veys, which were ordered by Congress with a view to the construction
of reservoirs for the improvement of the navigation of Red River of
the North and Minnesota River.
   Preliminary reports were submitted in April, 1900, and are printed
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, pages 2828-
2836. A final report was submitted August 11, 1903, and printed in
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 2260
et seq.
   Amount expended on all projects to June 30, 1909, $17,293.28.
   It is proposed to reserve the available funds for the purpose of
making hydrological observations during the next flood affecting
these localities.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................   $8, 206.72
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................    8, 206.72
   (See Appendix Z 9.)
   10. Gauging Mississippi River at or near St. Paul, Minn.-This
work is provided for by allotment from the permanent annual appro-
priation of $9,600 made by the river and harbor act of August 11,
1888, as amended by section 9 of the river and harbor act of June 13,
1902, for the purpose of securing the uninterrupted gaugings of the
waters of the Mississippi River and its tributaries. No gaugings were
made until the fall of 1899. Since then gaugings have been made as
frequently as the funds available would permit and the conditions
justified the expenditure. For location of gauges see map facing
page 1832, Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1898.
   Tables showing relation of rainfall to run-off in the Mississippi
Valley above St. Paul are printed on page 2169, Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1897. The slope of the Mississippi River between
Minneapolis and St. Paul is shown in the Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1900, page 2823.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $7,702.53.
   (See Appendix Z 10.)

IMPROVEMENT              OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE KANSAS               CITY,
                               MISSOURI, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Maj. E. H. Schulz, Corps of
Engineers. Division engineer, Col. W. H. Bixby, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Missouri River.-General improvement.-The Missouri River
has been navigated by steamboats since 1819; first boat to Council
Bluffs, 1819; first to mouth of the Yellowstone, 1832; first to head of
navigation, Fort Benton, Mont., 1859. The length of navigable
river from Fort Benton to mouth is 2,284.8 miles. Some portions of
the river above the Great Falls are also navigable.
   The original condition of the river was, and to a great extent the
present condition is, one of alternate pools and bars. The low-water
depth over bars is about 3 feet and the width of the river at such
places is from one-third to 1 mile. In the deep reaches the width
574      REPORT OF THE CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS,   U.   S. ARMY.

is 800 to 1,500 feet and the low-water depth in such places is often
over 12 feet. Generally speaking, the navigable low-water depth of
unimproved river is 3 feet and of high water only 9 feet. The navi-
gable depth does not increase as rapidly as the water height, since the
bars rise with the stage of river. The river is also encumbered with
snags, which, however, are getting fewer, due to constant snagging
operations.
    No project for the improvement of the river as a whole has been
adopted.
    Government work on the river in the matter of removal of snags
began as early as 1838 and continued thereafter, under annual appro-
priations (for the most part made jointly for the Ohio, Mississippi,
Missouri, and sometimes the Arkansas rivers), with occasional inter-
missions,. for the next forty years. Prior to 1878 one or two small
appropriations had been made for general improvement, but it was
with the act of June 18 of the latter year that appropriations began
on a large scale.
    The work prior to 1884 was carried on under separate districts.
    A project for the river from Sioux City to the mouth was adopted
in 1884, the improvement to consist of rectification, revetment, and
snagging. In 1890 the project was modified by systematic improve-
ment of the first reach, from Jefferson City to the mouth.
    From 1884 to 1890 the work on the entire river was under the
Missouri River Commission. After 1890 that portion above and
including Sioux City, Iowa, was under a separate district until 1902.
Since the discontinuance of the Missouri River Commission the works
on the entire river have been consolidated under one district.
    The greater part of the work on the portion of the river below
Sioux City has been done by the Missouri River Commission, report-
ing to the Chief of Engineers. The commission was constituted by
act of Congress of July 5, 1884, and was abolished by the river and
harbor act of June 13, 1902.
    On the portion of the river above Sioux City the work has been
done under the immediate charge of officers of the Corps of Engi-
neers, except during the period from 1884 to 1890, when it was in the
charge of the Missouri River Commission. The effort of the com-
mission in its work below Sioux City was to accomplish a continuous,
progressive control of the river, contracting it where necessary, giv-
ing the channel proper direction, and securely holding it in place.
Work in this direction was done in the vicinity of Kansas City and
on the first reach of the river, which extends from near Jefferson City
to the mouth. On 45 miles of this reach a continuous channel of not
less than 6 feet in depth at low water was obtained on what was
originally one of the worst parts of the river, in the vicinity of the
mouth of the Osage. In addition to forming a channel, much new
land was formed and much land protected from destruction by the
river. The greater part of the funds appropriated for expenditure
under the direction of the Commission was not applicable to the
comprehensive plan of improvement adopted, and about one-third of
it was diverted to work at separate localities.
    On the upper portion of the river the work originally consisted
mainly in improving the shoals and rapids on the so-called "Rocky
River" from Fort Benton downstream for 150 miles. In recent
years it has largely been limited to ohannel regulation and bank
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     575
protection at the following points: Williston and Bismarck, N. Dak.;
Pierre, Yankton, and Elk Point, S. Dak.; and Sioux City, Iowa. Two
ice harbors have been established, one at Rockhaven, N. Dak., the
other in the mouth of the Big Sioux River, just above Sioux City.
   Works of channel regulation have also been built in the Long Pool,
or the reach of the river from the crest of the Great Falls to Cascade,
and a small amount of open-river work in the steeper stretch from
Cascade to Stubbs Ferry.
   In addition to the foregoing work a fleet of snag boats has been in
operation clearing the channel of snags and other obstructions on the
portion of the river where boats have been running. This work is
considered to be directly beneficial to navigation.
   The total of appropriations for the river, and of receipts from
other sources, from the mouth to Sioux City, including snagging,
beginning with the act of June 18, 1878, is $9,402,833.25.
   The total of the appropriations and of receipts from other sources
for improvements of the upper river, including snagging, beginning
with the act of August 14, 1876, is $2,288,807.47.
   The total of appropriations for improving Missouri River from
mouth to Fort Benton, Mont., $555,000.
   Grand total of all appropriations and receipts from other sources,
$12,246,640.72.
   Total expenditures on account of examinations, surveys, and con-
tingencies, rivers and harbors, $1,031.65.
   The total expenditures for all purposes have been $11,604,800.19.
   The result of these expenditures has been to demonstrate the possi-
bility of regulating the river in such manner as to make it navigable
for a channel of commerce; that the cost of such regulation would be
very great, and that no permanent good to navigation can be accom-
plished by appropriations for specific localities not so connected as to
form part of the systematically improved reaches. The result of the
expenditures at separated localities has been beneficial locally by pro-
tecting the banks and forming good navigable water fronts and in-
cidentally preserving private property from the ravages of the river,
but has given little, if any, encouragement to through navigation.
   At the localities under improvement an effort has been made to
maintain the existing and prevailing depth of channel. The least
depth at mean low water over the shoalest part at the localities under
improvement is not less than 6 feet. The usual variation of level of
water is about 19 feet at Kansas City, 8 feet at Fort Benton, and 25
feet at St. Charles.
   The maximum draft June 30, 1909, at mean low water from Kan-
sas City to mouth is 4 feet, from Kansas City to Sioux City 31, and
from Sioux City to Fort Benton 3 feet. The head of navigation is
Fort Benton, 2,285 miles above the mouth. Above this point rapids
begin, which at Great Falls are a series of falls, the aggregate fall
being 500 feet. Above Great Falls, there is a navigable depth prac-
tically to Three Forks.
   The effect of the improvement has been to equalize and keep down
freight rates, the actual river rates being about 60 per cent of the
railroad rates.
   A condensed description of the works on the river executed under
the supervision of the Missouri River Commission is given in the
576         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                        S. ARMY.

Commission's last annual report (Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1902, Supplement).
   A condensed description of the work above the Great Falls will be
found in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1899,
pages 385-386, and in later annual reports; and of the work on the
river between Fort Benton and Sioux City in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1902, pages 382-385.
   A complete survey of the river has also been made, in part by the
Commission and in part by officers in charge of the districts on the
upper portions of the river, and has been published in 83 maps,
scale 1 inch to the mile.
   The river formerly carried an active commerce, which at one time
had been entirely diverted to other channels. This commerce now
shows healthy signs of reviving.
   Commerce has increased greatly on the lower river from Kansas
City to the mouth during the season of 1908. Two boats regularly
ran from Kansas City to St. Louis, each making a round trip every
eight to ten days, and averaging a round trip cargo of 600 tons.
There is also a boat running from Jefferson City to St. Louis, and
several boats plying between Osage River and St. Louis. A million
dollar boat line is now being organized at Kansas City for the pur-
pose of placing a modern boat service upon the river from Kansas
City to St. Louis, with proper wharfage and terminal facilities.
   Increased commerce and use of the river is also observed in the
upper river in the vicinity of Bismarck, N. Dak., and above to the
mouth of Yellowstone River.
   The character of upstream cargoes is merchandise and general
supplies; downstream, grain and stock.
   Amount of freight carried on the Missouri River from mouth to Sioux City, Iowa.
Calendar year-                         Tons.       Calendar year-                         Tons.
    1897........................---   391, 029         1903....-...................     750,291
    1898.--.....................      319,   793       1904........................     455,000
    1899...... ..................     263,   114       1905........................     343,435
    1900........................      277,   306       1906........................     573, 348
    1901......................        569,   666       1907.....----...--............   843,863
    1902............. ..........      410,   527       1908........................     541,144

        Amount of freight carriedon the Missouri River above Sioux City, Iowa.
Calendar year-                                     Tons.  Calendar year-                       Tons.
    1887.......--................. 13, 961                    1898..........--............... 26, 896
    1888----......--..-------------.............. 12, 895     1899......................... 23, 041
    1889--------.........................         16, 723     1900.....-................... 27, 179
    1890---..--.---------..........-------....... 14, 072     1901......................... 37,340
                                                  14, 211
    1891......-------....---------.......-----.......         1902......................... 31,070
    1892.............. .....-.... 17, 292                                             ------- 37, 994
                                                              1903..-.....------......-------.......
    1893 ---...................... 19,481                     1904---------------------.............
                                                                                              28,951
    1894.        -.-...........   .......... 37, 936                                          52, 956
                                                              1905----------------..................
                                                  21,264
    1895-...--------------....--........----.......           1906......................... 43, 987
    1896......................... 10,368                      1907......................... 45, 123
    1897---------------------.........................
                                                  17,105      1908............ ..........     17,517

  Previous reports.-For reports of examinations and surveys above
Sioux City, see page 71, list of preliminary examinations and surveys,
Document .No. 421, Fifty-Seventh Congress, second session. The
examinations made above Sioux City were generally for local points.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                    577
For reports below Sioux City, see page 110, same document. For
list of projects, see pages 182 and 184, same document.
   A report covering the entire stretch from Sioux City to the mouth
was made February 2, 1881, by Major Suter, found in Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1881, page 1649.
   There is no existing project, except the use of such limited funds as
have been appropriated since 1902 for purposes of snagging and
emergency dike and revetment work. A new project and estimate
of cost for improvement for 6-foot and 12-foot channel from Sioux
City to Kansas City and Kansas City to mouth, called for by act of
Congress March 2, 1907, was submitted April 30, 1908, and trans-
mitted to Congress. (See H. Doc. 1120, 60th Cong., 2d sess.)
   During the past year work has been in the main confined to repair
work and snagging. New work was done as follows:
   Extensive dike work was completed at Elwood, Kans., to prevent
the river from leaving St. Joseph, Mo., and to protect banks and rail-
road bridge at Elwood. Half the cost of this work ($50,000) was
contributed by the railroads concerned.
   Dike construction was also done at Mokane, Mo., Atherton, Mo.,
and Elwood, Kans. At Williston, N. Dak., 3,075 feet of revetment
was placed at a cost of $11,416.30 to the Government, the Great
Northern Railway and the city of Williston furnishing the rock and
brush, estimated at $25,000.
   Extensive revetment work was also done by the Wabash Railway
and by the Chicago and Northwestern Railway below Sioux City, and
by the Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul Railroad Company above
Sioux City.
   A public hearing was held at Omaha, Nebr., on September 11, 1908,
on the subject of harbor lines, approved by the Secretary of War
June 5, 1909.
   The act of March 3, 1909, for preservation and repair of river and
harbor works, appropriated the following:
Missouri River, mouth to Fort Benton:
    Plant and boat yards ...........                             ..........................                $155,000
    Dikes and revetments ............................................                                       400,000
   Preliminary examinations of certain localities are being made in
compliance with the act of March 3, 1909, reports on which will be
submitted to Congress at its next session.
   By act of Congress, February 16, 1909, the Secretary of War was
authorized to establish harbor lines on the Kansas River at Kansas
City, Kans., and preparations for this work are now being made.
   The amounts estimated as profitable expenditure for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1911, will be applied to snagging and repair and con-
struction of dikes and revetments, being for maintenance of improve-
ment as well as extension of benefits.
IMPROVING MISSOURI RIVER FROM STUBBS FERRY, MONTANA,                                          TO SIOUX CITY, IOWA.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................      .............        $5, 804. 69
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.............................. $1,437. 72
    For maintenance of improvement---......................           1, 959. 58
                                                                                  3, 397. 30

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ........................                                        ......   2, 407. 39
       9001-ENG 1909-37
578           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

             IMPROVING MISSOURI RIVER FROM MOUTH TO SIOUX CITY, IOWA.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................... $17, 955. 95
Amount received from sale of maps-------....-------.....----........--------.....
                                                                            16. 37
Amount received by deposit Isthmian Canal Commission. ..............        61. 23
Amount received by overpayment of vouchers .........................        24. 63
                                                                                                                   18, 058. 18
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement.......--........ ............--...... ......................                                            15, 352. 73

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ..................................                                                2, 705. 45
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                                              690. 95
July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................                                                  2, 014. 50
                                     IMPROVING MISSOURI RIVER.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .. ................................ $231, 859. 20
Received from services rendered by snag boats ........................     399. 49
Received from overpayment of vouchers .............................         23. 40

                                                                      232, 282. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement............................ $77, 976. 65
                                                          83, 406. 44
    For maintenance of improvement. -----------................--..
                                                                      161, 383. 09

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-..-................................                                               65, 293. 04
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. .................................                                           13, 453. 36

July 1, 1909, balance available... ..............                     ...................                          41, 839. 68
    EMERGENCIES IN         RIVERS     AND    HARBORS      (MISSOURI          RIVER          AT ELWOOD, KANS.).

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................$18, 970. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement--....................................................------   9, 968. 81

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........................................                                           9, 001. 28
                 IMPROVING MISSOURI           RIVER     AT ELWOOD (CONTRIBUTIONS).

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. .....-- ..............................        - -- $13, 320. 31
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment................................         .....         ..................  ..   13, 290.61

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                                   29.70
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .................................                                       ..        29.70
IMPROVING       MISSOURI RIVER FROM MOUTH TO FORT BENTON,                                   MONT.,          PRESERVATION
                     AND MAINTENANCE            OF RIVER AND           HARBOR WORKS.

Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
                         -$555,-000.
  March 3, 1909 .. --..............................................                                                         00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment--...................................................................                                          2, 525.47

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ................................                                                 552, 474. 53
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..............                            ..........
                                                                                .....          ..........           26, 413. 02

July 1, 1909, balance available.... .........               ..   .................                     ...         526, 061.51

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1,1909......... .............................                                                     350, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix AA 1.)
                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            579
   2. Osage River, Missouri.-A history of the work of improvement
on this river, from the adoption of the original project in 1871 to the
end of the fiscal year 1900, was published in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 4944.
   The original condition was one of alternate pools and shoals.
   The work has been carried on under two projects-that of open-
channel improvement, by the construction of cross and wing dams, in
addition to dredging and removal of obstructions to navigation, such
as snags, etc., and the construction of a lock and dam 7 miles above
the mouth of the river.
   The removal of obstructions under the first project contemplates
maintenance. The obstructions will form anew, and while the cross
and wing dams have a degree of permanency, they must receive fre-
quent repair and extension to keep up their efficiency.
   The amount expended by the General Government upon both proj-
ects up to June 30, 1909, is $800,939.82.
   During the past year work on the general river has consisted in
dredging, snagging, and repairs to longitudinal and cross dikes.
   By act of March 2, 1907, the sum of $10,000 was appropriated for
general improvement, and $68,000 was appropriated for continuing
construction of Lock and Dam No. 1, with authority for contracts
to the additional amount of $160,000, all of which has been appro-
priated for completion of the lock and dam.
   The sundry civil act of March 4, 1909, appropriated $60,000 for
the completion of the lock and dam.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, appropriated $10,000
for the Osage River, for maintenance of general open-river improve-
ment.
   During the past year work has consisted in additional protection
to the piers Nos. 6, 7, 8, and 9, and weirs 7, 8, 9, and 10. The gap
between piers 1 and 6 is to be closed by a chanoine wicket dam, 36
feet of which has been completed.
   During the past year work has been completed on the lock and
dam as follows:
   Protection of the foundation of the outer lock wall. Protection of
the foundations of piers 7, 8, 9, and 10. The foundation of the dam
throughout was reinforced by a deposit of 3 feet of concrete tamped
around piling and up to floor for weirs.
   Twelve air tanks installed in each of the four weirs in sections 7, 8,
9, and 10 and a 2-inch air pipe with flexible joint connected with
each weir.
   Thirty-six linear feet of the chanoine dam foundation completed.
   Expenditures during the year:
Labor and services.....................                            ..............................                  $32,172. 10
Material........................................................                                                    16, 527.75
Freight........ ....................                             ...................              ..............     3, 301.01

                                                                                                                    52, 000. 86
  The work now in progress contemplates the completion of the
chanoine dam foundation and installation of the wickets and even-
tual replacing of the wooden lock gates with steel ones.
   The funds on hand and available will be applied to the completion
of Lock and Dam No. 1, and to maintenance.
580         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                 S. ARMY.

   It is proposed to use the amount that can be profitably expended
in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in addition to the balance unex-
pended July 1, 1909, for works of improvement, and for mainte-
nance of general improvement, including snagging, dredging, and
repairs to dikes.
   The head of navigation is Warsaw, Mo., 172 miles above the
mouth. Prior to improvement light-draft boats had to abandon
their trips because of shoals; the same boats now ascend to the head
of navigation without interference.
  The improvement has only influenced freight rates by affording
shippers a regular means of transportation by boat.
  Previous reports.-Preliminaryexaminations August 22, 1884, and
December 10, 1886. Reports of surveys December 28, 1870, Febru-
ary 11, 1875, February 13, 1879, April 21, 1881, January 9, 1890,
November 9, 1900. Project adopted in 1871; snagging, dredging,
and wing dams modified in 1890 by one lock and dam near mouth.
  Report on preliminary examination and survey, made in compliance
with act of March 2, 1907, was made January 21, 1908 (H. Doc. 960,
60th Cong., 1st sess.)
                             Amount offreight carriedon the Osage River.

Calendar year-                                  Tons.    Calendar year-                             Tons.
     1895 .....................                76,706        1902. ..................                   . 95,194
     1896.....................                 72,393        1903 .......................                 38,501
     1897......................                71,247        1904 ..................----------------      35,746
     1898......... ....          ...........   84, 286       1905 ............... ....... 8, 678
     1899.....................                 76,702        1906....................... 20,506
     1900 ......................               96, 144       1907 .- .....-------..........--....         31,601
     1901.........................             72,339        1908..-----------------................---. 30, 606
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................... $152, 357. 50
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......................................................................... 10, 000.00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909........                    60, 000. 00
                                                                                              222, 357. 50
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
   For works of improvement .............................                       $3, 362.05
   For maintenance of improvement ...................                     ...   64, 603. 44
                                                                                               67, 965. 49

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                         154, 392. 01
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.............................                             18, 499. 94

July 1, 1909, balance available...................................... ...                     135, 892. 07

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ...............       ....     .... ....                     20, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix A A 2.)
  3. Gasconade River, Missouri.-This river is similar to the Osage,
consisting of alternate shoals and pools. The project for the improve-
ment of this stream, adopted in 1880, consisted in the removal of
snags and logs from the channel and of leaning timber from the
banks of the river, where necessary, and the construction of wing
dams and training walls to concentrate the flow of water upon the
shoals to increase the depth over them.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                         581
   From the nature of the project, which contemplates maintenance
and relief from year to year and the removal of obstructions which
are constantly forming anew, no definite time can be fixed for its com-
pletion. The improvement must therefore be continuous.
   During the past season the boating channel was cleared of snags
and wreck heaps and all overhanging trees were trimmed or felled.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, appropriated $15,000
for the Gasconade River for maintenance of general open-river
improvement.
   The total of the appropriations and of receipts from other sources
for the improvement of Gasconade River, beginning with the act of
June 14, 1880, is $126,624.31.
   The amount expended under the project to June 30, 1909, is
$110,894.19.
   The only influence the improvement has had upon freight rates is
to afford shippers a regular means of transportation by boat.
   It is proposed to use the amount that can be profitably expended in
fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in addition to the balance unex-
pended July 1, 1909, for works of improvement in continuing present
project, which is indefinite, including plant to carry on work, and for
maintenance of existing works.
   The head of navigation is Arlington, Mo., and the number of navi-
gable miles is 107. Prior to improvement light-draft boats were
compelled to abandon their trips because of shoals; the same boats
now go to the head of navigation without interference.
                         Amount offreight carried on the Gasconade River.

Calendar year-                                  Tons.       Calendar year-                       Tons.
    1895 .....................                 47,544           1902 ....................       44,380
    1896 ....................                  46,294           1903......................      10, 788
    1897 ..-....................               30,515           1904 .....................      14, 791
    1898.......................                30, 981          1905 ..--....................   29,837
    1899 ......................                24,259           1906.......................     27, 604
    1900 ......................                51, 580          1907............... .........   50, 083
    1901 ..--.......... ...........            19, 460          1908.......................     28, 887

   Previous reports: Reports of previous surveys, February 14, 1873,
Annual Report Chief of Engineers, page 479, 1873; February 11,
1880, Annual Report Chief of Engineers, page 1462, 1880; June 30,
1896, Annual Report Chief of Engineers, page 3800, 1896. Notes on
river also found on page 3539, Annual Report Chief of Engineers,
1898.
   Report on preliminary examination and survey, made in compli-
ance with act of March 2, 1907, was made February 24, 1908 (H.
Doc. 829, 60th Cong., 1st sess.).
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. .........                     .................... $2, 158. 16
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..........    .....................................                   15, 000. 00
                                                                                           17, 158. 16
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement....................................................                           1,428. 04

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended--........................................                 15, 730. 12
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...-.................................                  1, 156. 64

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                      14, 573.48
582       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909........      .......    ..    ........... $20, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix A A 3.)
  4. Fort Riley Military Reservation, Kans.-The sundry civil act of
March 4, 1909, appropriated $25,000 for bank preservation at Fort
Riley, Kans., as follows:
  Fort Riley Military Reservation, Kansas: For the preservation of the bank line of
Republican River in front of the Fort Riley Military Reservation, by revetment and
such other work as may be necessary to protect the said reservation from damage by
erosion, twenty-five thousand dollars, to be immediately available.
  Preliminary examination has been made and project will be sub-
mitted and work begun as soon as the present high water subsides.
Amount appropriated by the sundry civil act of March 4, 1909........... $25, 000. 00
Amount expended during the fiscal year................................        19. 32
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended--..-.-...... ..... ............      .....   24, 980. 68
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.....................................         11. 34
July 1, 1909, balance available ....................    ..................    24, 969. 34
   (See Appendix A A 4.)

EXAMINATION AND SURVEY MADE IN    COMPLIANCE   WITH                              RIVER
          AND HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports dated June 4, 1907, and April 30, 1908, on preliminary
examination and survey, respectively, of Missouri River from the
mouth to Sioux City, Iowa, required by the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, were duly submitted by the district officer. They
were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors,
pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in
House Document No. 1120, Sixtieth Congress, second session. The
estimated cost of improvement with a probability of providing more
than 6 feet, and not less than 10 feet, is $50,000 per mile, and it is
believed that no plan of improvement of less scope than complete
and continuous control of the river, at least as far as Kansas City,
should be undertaken. This will require about ten years and appro-
priations at the rate of not less than $2,000,000 annually should be
assured. The question of advisability of undertaking such a project
is left, however, for determination by Congress.

  IMPROVEMENT          OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE NASHVILLE,
                           TENNESSEE, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Maj. Wm. W. Harts, Corps of Engi-
neers, having under his immediate orders to April 4, 1909, Capt. A. B.
Putnam, Corps of Engineers. Division engineer, Col. Wm. T.
Rossell, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Obion and Forked Deer rivers, Tennessee.-The river and harbor
act of June 13, 1902, authorized the joint improvement of the Obion
and Forked Deer rivers.
  (a) Obion River.-This stream is situated in northwestern Ten-
nessee. It is formed by the junction of its North and South forks
                      RIVER AND HARBOOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  583
about 6 miles northeast of Obion, which is considered the head of
navigation for steamers and other craft, and it flows in a general
southwesterly direction about 75 miles, entering the Mississippi
River some 5 miles below the Missouri and Arkansas state line. It is
probable that rafting and logging are feasible as far up as 25 miles
above Obion.
   In its original condition the obstructions on this river were almost
wholly drift, snags, and overhanging trees, which made navigation
difficult and uncertain.
   The original project was based on a survey made in 1891, and was
adopted by the river and harbor act of July 13, 1892. The scope of
the work was to obtain 3-foot navigation at low water by means of
open-channel work, at an estimated cost of $50,000. After an ex-
penditure of $15,795.01 this project was modified in June, 1897, to
one for maintenance, so as to keep the river free from such obstruc-
tions as would prevent navigation at medium and high stages, at an
estimated annual cost of $2,500.
   In 1903 the annual expenditure recommended for maintenance of
the Obion and Forked Deer rivers combined was reduced from $4,500
to $2,250. (See Annual Report for 1904, p. 2351.)
   Appropriations and allotments aggregating $29,400 have been
made for the Obion River, of which $28,395.62 have been expended
under the present project to June 30, 1909.
   No work was done during the past fiscal year. The funds expended
were applied to maintenance of the floating plant.
   The expenditures have resulted in temporary improvements to the
channel, lessening the dangers to navigation at medium and higher
stages from Obion, Tenn., to the mouth of the river. The naviga-
bility of the Obion River depends largely on the stage of water in the
Mississippi. Navigation is not practicable at low stages.
   For the calendar year ending December 31, 1908, the reported
commerce on this stream amounted to 8,684 tons, having an estimated
value of about $51,415, consisting almost wholly of timber products;
passengers carried, 100.
   For additional details of the Obion River, see the account of its
survey in the Annual Report of 1891, page 2992. The effect of the
improvement on freight rates is not believed to be important and can
not readily be ascertained.
   The district officer expresses the opinion, for reasons stated in his
report, that further appropriations under this project are not war-
ranted.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............              .          .............. $1, 213. 21
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement ........................          .............   ..................          208. 83
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ...........                 .-.. ......        ......         .   1, 004. 38
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...........         .        ....--- .......              .       13. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available--       -                  . ..
                                              --.............            ........   .........         991. 38
   (b) Forked Deer River.-This stream is formed by the junction of
its North and South forks about 8 miles southwest of Dyersburg, and
flows thence in a general southwesterly direction about 21 miles,
entering the Obion River about 31 miles from the Mississippi. Dyers-
burg is considered the head of navigation on the North Fork. Jack-
son, Tenn., 95 miles above the mouth, was formerly considered the
584          REPORT         OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                 S. ARMY.

head of navigation on the South Fork, but in recent years navigation
appears to have been limited to the lower portion of this stream. It
is probable that rafting and logging can be carried on to a distance
of 25 miles above Dyersburg.
   In their original condition the main stream and its branches, the
North Fork and South Fork, were greatly obstructed by snags and
drift. The original project may be said to have been adopted by the
river and harbor act of August 2, 1882, and was based on a report of
an examination of South Fork, dated December 16, 1880. This
project was subsequently modified by extension to include the North
Fork and main stream until appropriations aggregating $25,000 were
made and expended. The operations proposed were open-channel
work, by which it was sought to maintain a satisfactory channel all
the year round. This project was set aside in view of the fact that
the result aimed at could not be accomplished by this method.
   The present project for maintenance, based on the provisions of the
act of March 3, 1899, provided for the removal of surface obstructions
from the Forked Deer River and its navigable branches (North and
South forks), at an estimated annual cost of $2,000. In 1903 the
annual expenditure recommended for maintenance of both the Obion
and Forked Deer rivers was reduced from $4,500 to $2,250. (See
Annual Report for 1904, p. 2351.) Under this project appropria-
tions and allotments aggregating $12,600 have been made, of which
$11,766.37 has been expended to June 30, 1909. The expenditures
have resulted in temporary improvements to the channel, lessening
the dangers to navigation at medium and higher stages. The navi-
gability of the Forked Deer River depends largely upon the stage of
water.in the Mississippi. Navigation is not practicable at low stages.
   No work was done during the past fiscal year. The funds expended
were applied to the maintenance of the floating plant.
   For the calendar year ending December 31, 1908, the reported
commerce on this stream amounted to 16,165 tons having an esti-
mated value of about $35,150, and consisting almost wholly of timber
products. Passengers carried, 300.
   For references to sundry examinations and surveys of the Obion
and Forked Deer rivers, see the Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1908, page 553. For the report of the survey of the South Fork
of the Forked Deer River dated January 22, 1908, see House Docu-
ment No. 945, Sixtieth Congress, first session.
   The effect of the improvement on freight rates is not believed to
be important and can not readily be ascertained.
   This river has been combined with the Obion in the work of im-
provement, and they have ordinarily been considered together in
making appropriations of funds.
  The district officer expresses the opinion, for reasons stated in his
report on Obion River, that further appropriations under this project
are not warranted.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance             of im- $985. 17

  provement ........................................                                   151.54

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................        ...... 833. 63
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.......................................      11. 50

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                822. 13
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               585
                                            CONSOLIDATED.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............     .....................     ... $2, 198. 38
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement-......................................            ....     .......... 360. 37

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......                ... ................ ...........           1, 838. 01
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................            ......................              24. 50

July 1, 1909, balance available-................. ..                    ...........        ....   1, 813. 51
    (See Appendix B B 1.)
   2. Cumberland River, Tennessee and Kentucky.-The Cumberland
River rises in eastern Kentucky, on the western slope of the Cumber-
land Mountains, flows in a tortuous course of about 688 miles through
eastern Kentucky, middle Tennessee, and western Kentucky, and
discharges into the Ohio River near Smithland, Ky. From Burnside,
Ky., the head of steamboat navigation, to Smithland, Ky., the dis-
tance is 518 miles by the river, 203 miles being in the State of Ken-
tucky and 315 miles in the State of Tennessee.
    (a) Below Nashville (193 miles).-From 1830 to 1840 the legisla-
tures of Tennessee and Kentucky made several appropriations for
the improvement of the navigation of the Cumberland River, but
little benefit to the general condition of the river seems to have been
accomplished. The Cumberland Navigation Company was incor-
porated by the State of Tennessee in 1846 for improving the "navi-
gation of the Cumberland River below the town of Nashville by means
of a system of locks and dams," but nothing effective was done to
carry out the proposed improvement.
   In its original condition this section of the river was considerably
obstructed by rocky ledges, conglomerate, gravel, and sand bars, snags,
and other surface obstructions, on account of which navigation was
rendered very uncertain.
   From July 17, 1832, to July 7, 1838, Congress made five appropria-
tions for improving the Cumberland River, Tennessee and Kentucky,
aggregating $155,000, $20,000 of which was to be expended below
Nashville and $135,000 on the river generally, but all the appropria-
tions for the above period were expended below Nashville, to improve
the worst localities.
   Between 1838 and 1871 no appropriations for this river were made.
The original project (open-channel work), which provided specifically
for operations on this section, was adopted by the river and harbor
act of March 3, 1871, based on project submitted January 20, 1871.
The work proposed was as follows: To excavate the bars and rock
ledges in order to get an additional depth of water; to contract the
waterways in places in order to get the requisite depth; to remove
snags and bowlders from the main channel; and to restrain tributary
streams in well-determined channels at their junction with the river.
    To increase the depth of water at the shoals in Kentucky Chute at
the junction of the Cumberland with the Ohio River, a Board of
Engineer officers in 1888 recommended the construction of a dike near
Smithland, Ky., at an estimated cost of $129,600. The river and
harbor act of September 19, 1890, allotted $30,000 from the appro-
priation for improving Cumberland River below Nashville, to be
expended in improving the mouth of the river, as recommended.
586     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Appropriations aggregating $305,000 were made and expended, thus
completing the above project. The expenditures under the old
project have resulted in lengthening the season of navigation by giving
an increased depth at low water combined with greater security in
the passage of obstructions.
   The present project for improving the Cumberland River below
Nashville was adopted July 13, 1892, by the river and harbor act of
that date. It contemplates the extension of the lock and dam system
of the upper river over a considerable portion of the river below Nash-
ville by the construction of 7 locks and dams, commencing at or near
Harpeth shoal (Lock A) and ending at Big Eddy shoal (Lock G);
the locks to be 52 feet wide and 280 feet long, with lifts varying from
82 to 111 feet and aggregating some 70 feet. The project also includes
the improvement of the Kentucky Chute, at the mouth of the river,
as recommended by the Board of Engineer officers in 1888, the neces-
sary channel work below Lock G, and the removal of surface obstruc-
tions, snags, logs, etc., below Nashville. The total estimated cost of
the entire improvement is $1,964,500. (Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1894, p. 1806.)
   Under this project appropriations and allotments aggregating
$450,000, which, with receipts from sales and other receipts, $986.30,
makes a total of $450,986.30.
   The total expenditures under this project to June 30, 1909,
amount to $440,745.61, of which sum about $20,897.60 have been
applied to maintenance.
   These expenditures have resulted in the periodical removal of
snags and other surface obstructions from the navigable channel, the
protection of the bank of a part of Cumberland Island in Kentucky
Chute at the mouth of the river, and the completion and placing in
operation of Lock A, November 26, 1904, whereby 6-foot navigation
has been afforded all year round for a distance of 38.8 miles above
the lock. The season of profitable navigation from the Ohio River
to Nashville has been prolonged by forty-five to ninety days, depend-
ing on the stage of water, making it now average eight months annu-
ally. Lock A is 41.4 miles below Nashville.
   The Cumberland River below Nashville is usually navigable for
all steamboats plying on it for six months in each year; for boats not
drawing over 3 feet, from six to eight months, and for boats draw-
ing 16 inches or less, the whole year. General navigation, however,
is practically closed for several months each year during low water.
As a general rule, when the stage is below 21 feet, navigation is closed;
between 2 - feet and 5 feet, it is uncertain, and above 5 feet, good.
A table is given on page 390 of the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1902, showing the stages at Burnside, Carthage,
Nashville, and Clarksville for the years 1898-1902.
   No work of improvement was carried on during the past fiscal
year.
   The funds expended were applied to the cost of the survey for
locks and dams authorized by the act of March 2, 1907.
   For references to detailed reports and maps and to the report of
the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors concerning the fur-
ther improvement of the Cumberland River see the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1908, page 555.
   A preliminary report of the survey ordered by the act of March 2,
1907, is printed in House Document No. 758, Sixtieth Congress,
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                 587
first session. The final report is printed in House Document No.
1481, Sixtieth Congress, second session.
   In these reports the district officer recommends the further im-
provement of the Cumberland River below Nashville by the con-
struction of the necessary locks and dams. This recommendation
was concurred in by the division engineer, Board of Engineers for
Rivers and Harbors, and the Chief of Engineers.
   Attention is invited to the recommendation of the district officer
in the appendix to this report that the necessary funds for the com-
mencement of the work be appropriated at the earliest date prac-
ticable. This recommendation is concurred in.
   The reported commerce for the calendar year 1908 was 259,734
tons, having an estimated value of about $4,621,197; passengers
carried, 33,000. The tonnage consisted principally of timber and
farm products, and general merchandise.
   It is reported that the Tennessee Central Railroad, which parallels
the Cumberland River from Nashville to Clarksville, had rates in
force before the completion of Lock and Dam A of from 18 to 26
cents per 100 pounds, and since this lock was put in operation these
rates have been reduced above the lock to from 6 cents to 12 cents per
100 pounds.
   The quantity of grain handled by the local steamboats has in-
creased considerably since the completion of Lock A and a new line
of steamboats, the Tyner Line, has been operating during the boat-
ing season.
   It appears from reliable information that the cost of transport-
ing grain by river to Nashville is about 8 cents per 100 pounds from
points below Evansville on the Ohio River, while it is 15 cents per
100 pounds by way of river to Henderson or Uniontown, Ky., and
thence by rail to Nashville, or a saving of about 7 cents per 100
pounds by all river transportation. Within the past year freight
rates by rail have advanced 12 to 20 per cent on every class of mer-
chandise going south out of Nashville, while into Nashville it appears
that the tariff has not been advanced. There is little doubt that
the competition offered by the Cumberland River, even in its present
condition, is the cause of the favorable rates into Nashville.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure in the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, will be applied to necessary maintenance.
The funds are needed for maintaining the river in a navigable condi-
tion. No estimate is submitted for further work on the old or
existing project for improvement by locks and dams pending action
by Congress on the new plan for slack water improvement referred
to above.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................              $8, 731.44
Cash allowance received from Underwood Typewriter Company.......                    12. 25
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.................................................               10, 000. 00
                                                                               18, 743. 69
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for survey.........          8, 503. 00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................            10, 240. 69
July 1., 1909, outstanding liabilities................ .....................         6. 95

July 1, 1909, balance available.................. ............                 10, 233.74
588       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                    U.   S. ARMY.

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........$1, 549, 818. 81
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909 ....     ............................   ..........    10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Above Nashville (357 miles).-This section extends from Nash-
ville to the mouth of Rockcastle River. In its original condition it
was considerably obstructed by rock reefs, ledges, snags, etc., which
greatly impeded navigation between Nashville and Burnside (about
325 miles), while above Burnside the Smith shoals formed a serious
obstruction to navigation at practically all stages.
   The original scheme of improvement above Nashville, as modified
and extended, contemplated open-channel work from Nashville, Tenn.,
to Cumberland Ford (Pineville, Ky.), 497 miles, at an estimated
cost of $374,764, and was based on projects submitted January 20,
1871, and February 8, 1872.
   The first appropriation, specifically applicable to the Cumberland
River above Nashville, was made by the act of August 14, 1876.
   This open-channel scheme of improvement, or old project, resulted
in giving increased depths at several of the principal obstructions,
thus securing a longer and safer period of navigation. Under this
project and its modifications appropriations aggregating $346,000
were made and expended.
   The project for the canalization of the Cumberland River above
Nashville, based on reports of an examination and survey in 1882
and 1883, was adopted by the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886.
   This scheme of improvement provided for the construction of 22
locks and dams below Burnside, Ky., and 6 locks and dams at Smith
shoals, above Burnside, the intention being to provide a comaplete
system of lockage from Nashville, Tenn., to Rockcastle River, so as
to afford a channel depth of 6 feet, the locks to be 52 feet wide and
280 feet long, with lifts varying from 10 to 12 feet, at an estimated
cost of $8,500,000.
   On February 16, 1905, the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Har-
bors reported on the project of canalization as follows:
   The Board is of the opinion that the regulation of the river and * * * the
completion of Locks and Dams 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 above Nashville, so as to carry the
improvement of the river from its mouth to Carthage, Tenn., is worthy of being con-
tinued by the United States, but that the construction of the locks and dams proposed
between Carthage and Burnside, except No. 21, now under contract, is not at present
justified by the commerce involved.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, adopted the modified
project for completing the improvement in accordance with this
report by providing for the completion of Locks and Dams Nos. 3,
4, 5, 6, and 7 at an additional expenditure of $550,000, thus reducing
the cost of the project as modified to $2,769,000, increased in the
report for 1908, page 1690, to $2,854,000. The act appropriated
$150,000 and authorized continuing contracts in the further sum of
$400,000 for completing the project. The entire amount so author-
ized has now been appropriated.
   For the statement concerning the annulment of the contract for
constructing Lock and Dam No. 21 see the Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1908, page 1689.
                RIVER AND    HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                  589
   The district officer, in the appendix to this report, recommends
that an additional sum of $85,000 be appropriated to finish the work
at Lock 21, as experience shows that it will be impossible to build
the dam and do the necessary work of bank protection and paving
within the present estimate of cost. His recommendation is con-
curred in.
   Attention is invited to the district officer's further recommendation
in this connection, however, that no such appropriation be made
for the completion of this work unless the town of Burnside, which is
in the vicinity of the proposed lock and will derive the greatest
benefit from the improvement, furnish adequate terminal facilities
by reserving for all time, by appropriate legislative action, a portion
of its water front, and devote it exclusively to the accommodation of
river commerce upon such terms as will be reasonable and just to the
public.
   Under the project of canalization appropriations and allotments
aggregating $2,779,000 have been made; $493.15 have been received
from recoveries, sales, etc., making a total of $2,779,493.15. Of
this amount about $42,036.95 is chargeable to maintenance, leav-
ing $2,737,456.20 applicable to works of improvement. The total
expenditures under this project to June 30, 1909, amount to
$2,378,110.47, of which sum about $31,564.15 was applied to
maintenance.
   These expenditures have resulted in an improved channel way by
the periodical removal of snags and other surface obstructions; the
completion and operation of Lock and Dam No. 1 (2.5 miles below
Nashville); Lock and Dam No. 2 (9 miles above Nashville); and
Lock and Dam No. 3 (26 miles above Nashville); the completion of
the masonry required for locks and abutments of dams Nos. 4, 5, 6, and
7 (44.7, 72, 89, and 106.6 miles, respectively) above Nashville; the
purchase of sites for abutment at Lock No. 8 (125.2 miles above
Nashville); and for Lock and Abutment No. 22 (320.2 miles above
Nashville); the selection of sites for the locks of the Smith shoals
system; the letting and partial execution of the contracts for the
construction and erection of the gates for Locks 3 to 7, and for Lock
21; the partial construction of Lock No. 21; the purchase and delivery
of the lumber for Dam No. 5; and contingencies pertaining to the
entire improvement.
   The Cumberland River is navigable usually from Nashville to
Burnside, Ky., 325 miles, for steamboats drawing not more than 3
feet from four to six months of each year, and for boats of greater
draft from two to three months. The fall is 223 feet, or about 8
inches per mile.
   From Nashville to Caney Fork River (Carthage, 116 miles) the
river is navigable for steamboats of 2 feet draft from six to eight
months, and for those of greater draft four or five months. Steam-
boats of lio'ht draft can ascend to Burkesville, 236 miles above Nash-
ville, for from five to seven months and larger boats four or five
months.
   The head of navigation is Burnside, Ky., for steamers and other
craft. This section is considered navigable for rafting and logging
for about 35 miles above Burnside.
590        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                        S. ARMY.

   Lock No. 1 was placed in operation November 26, 1904. The
completion of this lock affords a good harbor at Nashville, where a
number of new boats and barges were put in commission as a result of
this improvement.
   Lock No. 2 was put in operation on October 9, 1907, and Lock No. 3
was placed in operation on October 15, 1908. The completion of
these three locks gives a 6-foot navigation the year round for a
distance of about 47 miles above Nashville.
   The early completion of the work at Locks Nos. 4, 5, 6, and 7, where
the more expensive masonry parts have already been built, is
regarded of great importance, as this is necessary to make the
improvement available and will provide a permanent channel for
navigation from Nashville to Carthage and the Caney Fork River.
When these locks are in operation the effect of the project on freight
rates will be more fully apparent.
   The expenditures during the past fiscal year were applied to the
completion of placing Lock No. 3 in operation; erecting the lock
gates under contract at Locks Nos. 4 and 5; partial construction of
Dam No. 5; purchase and delivery of the materials preparatory to the
construction of the guard walls at Locks Nos. 6 and 7; quarrying stone
for dams; letting of the contract for the delivery of the timber for
Dam No. 4; construction of two lock houses at Lock No. 3; construc-
tion of floating plant and temporary buildings for shops and quarters
at Locks Nos. 6 and 7; construction of Lock No. 21 and contingencies
pertaining to the entire improvement.
   The amount expended for maintenance during the past fiscal year
was applied to the purchase of material for a snag boat.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable expen-
diture in the fiscal year 1911 as follows: Eighty-five thousand dollars
to the work of placing Lock No. 21 in operation, and $10,000 to main-
tenance of improvement. The funds are needed to make the improve-
ment available for the needs of commerce and for maintaining the
channel of the river in a navigable condition.
   The commerce on the Cumberland River above Nashville for the
calendar year 1908, as nearly as could be ascertained, aggregated
246,260 tons, having an estimated value of about $8,745,289; pas-
sengers carried, 8,635. The tonnage consisted mainly of timber and
farm products and general merchandise.
   For references to surveys see page 495, Annual Report of Chief of
Engineers, 1906.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................              $399, 049. 59
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.... .....   .   .      ....            .............. ...........   10, 000. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909-...... 250, 000. 00
Cash allowance received from Underwood Typewriter Co............                         17. 25
                                                                                   659, 066. 84
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...........................            $257, 469. 88
    For maintenance of improvement..................... .                214. 28
                                                                                   257, 684. 16
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................              401, 382. 68
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................................-...          25, 153. 34
July 1, 1909, balance available.......................................        ..   376, 229. 34
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                               591
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................     $43, 488. 70
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........     85, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
    For works of improvement.......................... a $85, 000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement .....................    10, 000. 00
                                                                           95, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix B ,B 2.)
  3. Operating and care of locks and dams on Cumberland River.-
Four locks are now in operation: Lock A, the first of the series below
Nashville, and Locks 1, 2, and 3 of the series above Nashville.
  They have an available length of 280 feet, a clear width of 52 feet
between walls, and a depth of 62 feet on miter sills at low water,
except at lower miter sill of Lock A, where the present low-water
depth is only 1 foot. This depth will be increased to 61 feet by the
construction of the next lock below.
  The first allotment from the indefinite appropriation of July 5,
1884, for the operation and care of these locks was made June 26, 1905.
  During the calendar year 1908 the traffic past Lock A was about
104,743.9 tons; past Lock No. 1 about 102,651 tons; past Lock No.
2 about 187,553.4 tons; past Lock No. 3 about 3,658.2 tons since it
was placed in operation in October, 1908.
  A special allotment of $9,000 was made for the purchase of a pump
boat for pumping out the lock pits when they fill up with material.
This vessel will be constructed at Muscle Shoals Canal, and is expected
to be placed in commission early next fall.
  The funds expended were applied to the repair of Dam A with
concrete, and to the expenses of operating and care of lock gates,
buildings, and grounds.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $60,977.41, of which
$31,801.58 were expended during the past fiscal year.
   (See Appendix B B 3.)
  4. Caney Fork River, Tennessee.-This stream lies in the central
part of Tennessee. After a course of about 200 miles, wholly in the
State, it empties into the Cumberland River at Carthage, Tenn.,
about 116 miles above Nashville. It is the largest tributary of the
Cumberland River.
  In its original condition the principal difficulties were found to be
rock reefs, gravel and sand bars, and a crooked and shallow channel
greatly impeded by surface obstructions.
   No work was done by the United States prior to that begun under
the present project. The present project, adopted June 14, 1880, is
based on the report of 1879, and an extension of the project is based
on the report of 1886. It provides for improving the 92 miles of
river from Franks Ferry, the head of navigation, to its mouth,
Carthage, Tenn., by removing the surface obstructions, building riprap
  a An appropriation of this amount is recommended by the district officer and the
Chief of Engineers, subject to certain important conditions set forth on page 589 of
this report.
592       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                  S. ARMY.

dams and training walls, so as to obtain sufficient water for safe
navigation during boating season for steamboats drawing not more
than 3 feet, at an estimated cost of $45,228. (Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1887, p. 1767.)
   Rafting and logging does not appear to be practicable above
Franks Ferry.
   Under the project referred to, appropriations aggregating $28,000
have been made and$12.25 received from other sources, and $27,839.83
expended to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909.
   From August, 1880, when the first work was done, to August, 1891,
when the last work was done, $25,000 was expended. The results
were an improvement of the channel at a 3-foot stage from Franks
Ferry to the mouth of the river. The improvement, however, was not
permanent and can not be made so under the present project. The
additional work required is therefore practically for maintenance.
   No appropriations were made from 1890 to 1905, and no work was
done for upward of seventeen years.
   The funds expended during the past fiscal year were applied to
clearing the channel of the river of surface obstructions and care of
plant.
   In view of the meager benefits resulting, it is not believed that
future appropriations are warranted under this project.
   The effect of the improvement on freight rates is not believed to
be important and can not be readily ascertained.
   The commerce on the Caney Fork River for the calendar year 1908,
as nearly as could be ascertained, aggregated 16,480 tons, having an
estimated value of $79,013.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................... $1, 533. 69
Cash allowance received from the Underwood Typewriter Company.......         12. 25
                                                                              1,545. 94
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.....--- ....... ...... ......... .........-- --..............   1, 373. 52

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................            172.42
   (See Appendix B B 4.)

SURVEY OF CUMBERLAND    RIVER, TENNESSEE AND KENTUCKY,
  MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND HARBOR ACT APPROVED
  MARCH 2, 1907.

   Report dated January 18, 1909, on a survey of Cumberland River,
Tennessee and Kentucky, below Nashville, with a view to the con-
struction of locks and dams in that portion of the river heretofore
surveyed in which no locks and dams have been constructed, re-
quired by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, was duly sub-
mitted by the district officer. It was reviewed by the Board of
Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant to law, and was trans-
mitted to Congress and printed in House Document No. 1481, Six-
tieth Congress, second session. A plan of improvement is presented
which has in view the construction of three more locks and dams,
(D, E, and F) to complete the system of six in all, the estimated
cost of which is $1,905,688.80.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     593
IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE CHATTANOOGA,
                  TENNESSEE, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Maj. Wm. W. Harts, Corps of
Engineers, having under his immediate orders to April 4, 1909,
Capt. A. B. Putnam, Corps of Engineers. Division engineer, Col.
Wm. T. Rossell, Corps of Engineers.
                     TENNESSEE RIVER     SYSTEM.

   The Tennessee River is 652 miles long. It is formed by the junc-
tion of the French Broad and Holston rivers, 4.5 miles above Knox-
ville and 188 miles above Chattanooga, and flows into the Ohio at
Paducah, 464 miles below Chattanooga. Together with its principal
tributaries it forms a system of internal waterways capable of being
navigated more than 1,300 miles by steamboats. In addition to this,
its tributaries are still further navigable by rafts and flatboats for a
distance of more than 1,000 miles, thus making a system of navigable
waters about 2,350 miles in length, with a drainage area of about
44,000 square miles.
   The river is navigable the entire year from the mouth to Riverton,
Ala. Just above Riverton a lateral canal about 8 miles long is now
under construction past the Colbert and Bee Tree shoals, and the
Muscle Shoals Canal now surmounts the Big Muscle and Elk River
shoals.
   Under the act of April 26, 1904, as amended by act of January 7,
1905, a lock and dam to be built mainly by private parties are pro-
jected at Hales bar, designed to form a pool extending 33 miles
upstream to Chattanooga.
   Local boat lines have headquarters at the principal towns along the
river. There is no through trafic covering the entire length of the
river, the longest regular boat service being found between Chatta-
nooga and Paducah when the stage of water permits.
   The amount so far appropriated and allotted for the Tennessee
River and the canals thereon is $8,541,337.15; amount received
from other sources, $2,461.95, making the total received $8,543,799.10.
Of this the sum of $1,122,882.26 has been allotted for operating,
care, and repair of the Muscle Shoals Canal from November, 1890,
when it was opened to navigation, to June 30, 1909.
   Freight rates are said to be already considerably lowered by this
project, but there is no information available indicating to what
extent they will be affected by its completion.
   1. Tennessee River.-The improvement has been carried on in
three sections under separate appropriations.
   (a) Above Chattanooga, Tenn. (188 miles).- In its original con-
dition this part of the river was obstructed by rock reefs, bowlders,
gravel bars, and snags. The depth of water on the bars varied from
10 to 30 inches at low water, and in some places the current was as
great as 6 miles an hour. The average slope is 0.956 foot per mile,
with average low-water discharge varying from about 3,000 cubic
feet per second at Knoxville to about 6,000 cubic feet per second at
Chattanooga.
   The present project, adopted by Congress in act of August 18, 1894,
is to obtain by training walls, wing dams, and dredging a low-water
     9001-ENG 1909--38
594     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

channel 3 feet deep from Chattanooga to the mouth of the French
Broad River, at an estimated cost of $650,000. Up to June 30, 1895,
the sum of $328,255.83 had been expended under a previous project,
and there remained 55 obstructions having less than 3 deet depth at
low water. A revision of the estimate in 1907, on a basis of present
unit prices, places the cost of the existing project at $1,709,000.
   Appropriations and allotments under the present project amount
to $352,014.63, and the receipts from sales, etc., have been $155.70;
making a total of $352,170.33. The total amount expended under
the present project to June 30, 1909, is $307,841.29, including $13,-
915.16 for maintenance.
   Operations in recent years have been mainly concentrated at the
formidable series of obstructions extending from Caney Creek shoals
(about 98 miles above Chattanooga) downstream for a distance of
about 8 miles. The projected works in that vicinity are well ad-
vanced toward completion, and a marked increase in channel depths
has been obtained.
   The work done in the past fiscal year comprised dredging and dike
construction at Caney Creek shoals and dike construction at Little
River shoals (12 miles below Knoxville). Operations were sus-
pended in October, owing to the exhaustion of funds. In January,
1909, under an allotment made for the purpose, some work was
undertaken at the latter place with a view to the reduction of objec-
tionable current velocities due to the incomplete stage of the im-
provement. The funds expended for maintenance during the fiscal
year were applied to this emergency work at Little River shoals and
to the construction and repair of floating plant needed in the work
of preserving the navigable condition of the channel.
   The new wooden-hull steam tender Chilhowee, built under contract
at a cost of $10,000, was launched in August, 1908.
   The maximum draft that can be carried at mean low water over
the shoalest place in this section is about 18 inches. The extreme
flood oscillations range from about 40.5 feet at Knoxville to about 58
feet at Chattanooga.
   The commerce reported on this portion of the river during the cal-
endar year 1908 amounted to about 621,500 tons, valued at about
$3,187,620; the principal items in order of value being marble, general
merchandise, logs, and grain.
   A map of this section of the river is printed in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1876, page 710, and an account of its
survey in the report of 1893, page 2333.
   It is proposed to apply the amount given as a profitable expendi-
ture in the fiscal year 1911 to maintaining the navigable waterway
by the removal of minor channel obstructions and the repair of exist-
ing works of regulation, and to continuing improvement under the
existing project for the purpose of extending the benefits already
secured.
   No active operations were carried on in the Little Tennessee River
during the fiscal year. The total expenditures for its improvement
up to June 30, 1909, amount to $5,510.09. Owing to the slight use
made of this tributary, it is believed that further allotments from
appropriations for the upper Tennessee River should not be made
for it for several years, and no sum is therefore given as a profitable
expenditure in the fiscal year 1911.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                    595

                          TENNESSEE RIVER ABOVE                             CHATTANOOGA.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .-----...................----------------------------. $35, 049. 41
Received    from sales    ._.            .-----.------------------.--.-...-..                                               2.85
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1909-- ....----------------------------------------------                                                 50, 000. 00
Allotment from emergency act of March 2, 1907- ..------.---.---..--.                                                 1, 270. 46
                                                                                                                    86, 322. 72
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...........................                                       $35, 049. 41
    For maintenance of improvement ....................                                         6, 944. 27
                                                                                                                    41, 993. 68

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..... .........-........                                           ......           44, 329. 04
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities--..-.. -.----.-.-- ---...                                       -.......       2, 461. 29
July 1, 1909, balance available---------------.....------------.....--------........                                41, 867.75
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                           1, 080, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909 .................         ... ..........                                        160, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                   LITTLE TENNESSEE                             RIVER.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended--....                   ..       ...                                                 $1, 489. 91
                                                                                  ................------------------------------
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. .                     ...............-           -                -......             1, 489. 91
   (b) Chattanooga, Tenn., to Riverton, Ala. (238 miles).-In its
original condition the channel from Chattanooga to Browns Ferry
was obstructed by bars, bowlders, reefs, and rocky projections. Navi-
gation was possible during six to nine months annually. Between
Browns Ferry and Florence were the Muscle shoals obstructions,
which could be crossed only at unusually high water. Between Flor-
ence and Riverton the Colbert and Bee Tree shoals prevented naviga-
tion for six months in the year.
   The average slope is 1.5 feet per mile from Chattanooga to Scott
Point (17.5 miles), thence 0.4 foot per mile to head of Muscle Shoals
Canal (158 miles), thence 2.73 feet per mile to Riverton (62.5 miles),
with average low-water discharge varying from about 6,000 cubic
feet per second at Chattanooga to about 10,000 cubic feet per second
at Riverton.
   Under a former project the Muscle shoals section was improved, at
a cost of $3,191,726.50, by some channel work at Little Muscle shoals
and by the construction of a lateral canal in two divisions, one on
the left bank about 3.5 miles long, with 2 locks, around the Elk River
shoals, and the other on the right bank, about 14.5 miles long, with 9
locks, around the Big Muscle shoals. This work was done mainly
from 1875 to 1890, under a project adopted originally in 1868.
   Expenditures aggregating $595,532.74 have been made in the
improvement of the open river at various localities between Chatta-
nooga and Riverton under a former project, dating back to 1868,
which contemplated securing a least depth of 3 feet at low water in
the improved channels.
   The existing projects for the improvement of this section are three
in number. The first authorizes the construction by private parties
596     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S. ARMY.

of a lock and dam at Hales bar, about 33 miles below Chattanooga,
which will form a pool extending above Chattanooga with a depth of at
least 6 feet at low water, the parties doing the work being granted the
use of the water power produced by the dam for a period of ninety-
nine years. The United States is to prepare the plans, supervise the
construction, and provide the gates, valves, operating machinery, and
other appurtenances of the lock, at a total cost now estimated at
$214,720. The project was adopted by act of April 26, 1904, amended
 (as to location of the work) by act of January 7, 1905.
   The second project, adopted by act of March 2, 1907, provides for
open-channel work to secure a depth of 5 feet at low water (in accord-
ance with project submitted in H. Doc. No. 50, 57th Cong., 1st sess.)
from Scott Point to Lock A, covering the stretch of 145 miles between
Hales bar and the Muscle Shoals Canal, the revised estimate placing
the cost of the work at $1,231,000.
   The third project provides for the improvement of Colbert and Bee
Tree shoals, near the downstream limit of this section, by the con-
struction of a lateral canal about 8 miles long, with one lock of about
26 feet lift, at an estimated cost of $2,847,009.70. The original proj-
ect was approved by the Secretary of War on November 28, 1890,
and its last modification on June 12, 1905.
   The appropriations and allotments under the present projects for
the improvement of this section-aggregate $2,547,644.24, and in addi-
tion the sum of $550.97 has been received from other sources, making a
total of $2,548,195.21, of which the sum of $2,213,759.36 has been
expended to June 30, 1909.
   These expenditures have resulted in the preparation of plans for
the Hales Bar lock and dam, the purchase of the metal work to be
incorporated in the lock masonry, the letting of the contracts for the
construction and erection of the upper and lower lock gates, the con-
struction of a quarter boat for the United States inspecting force, and
the supervision of the entire work, at a total cost of $47,283.80; in
the partial improvement of the open-river channel at various points
between Chattanooga and Riverton, notably at Allens bar, and the
construction of floating plant needed to carry on advantageously the
work of open-river regulation, at a cost of $108,404.96, including
$3,048.70 for maintenance; and in the partial construction of the
Colbert Shoals Canal, including the completion of the masonry of the
lock, the construction of the concrete river wall, the excavation of
about 90 per cent of the canal prism, the letting of a contract for the
upper and lower lock gates, the erection of the lock houses, and the
carrying out of minor incidental work by hired labor, at a total cost
of $2,058,070.60.
   The Muscle Shoals Canal provides a permanent depth of 5 feet,
except in its approaches, where additional work will be required to
secure this depth at low water, the improvement never having been
fully completed at these points.
   The maximum draft that can be carried at mean low water over
the shoalest place between Chattanooga and Riverton is about 2
feet. The extreme flood oscillations range from about 69 feet at the
Suck, 12 miles below Chattanooga, to about 10 feet at Lock No. 4 of
the Muscle Shoals Canal.
   The improvements at Hales bar and Colbert shoals will not be
available for navigation until the works are completed.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMIENTS.                    597
   At Hales bar the expenditures during the past fiscal year were
applied to the letting of a contract for the lower gates, to the con-
struction of a quarter boat for the United States inspectors, and to
the cost of supervising the contract work of building the lock and
dam. The concrete work is about 20 per cent completed, and about
35 per cent of the rock excavation and 68 per cent of the earth exca-
vation had been accomplished up to the close of the fiscal year. In
the annual report for 1908 (p. 564) the additional sum of $101,750 was
estimated to be required for the completion of the work with which
the United States is chargeable in connection with this improvement.
The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, carried an authorization of
one-half of this amount, but no part thereof has yet been appropriated.
   The funds expended during the fiscal year for open-channel work
between Chattanooga and Riverton were applied to dredging at
Allens bar, a serious obstruction between Hobbs Island and Gunters-
ville, to dike construction at Chunn bar, and to the construction and
repair of floating plant. Proposals were solicited for furnishing the
machinery and fittings for a dipper dredge to be employed in this
section of the river. Four bids were received, and the contract was
awarded in the sum of $19,850.
    In the appendix to this report the district officer gives his reasons
for recommending an increased appropriation for open-channel work.
His recommendation is concurred in.
   The principal work done at Colbert shoals in the past fiscal year
comprised excavation in the lower portion of the canal prism (three-
fourths of the work that remained to be done having been accom-
plished), the construction of the final portion of the concrete river
wall, and the erection of the necessary lock buildings. In addition
to these contract operations, hired-labor work was continued during
the year, the expenditures therefor having been applied to the
paving of four waste weirs, the placing of the remaining portion of
the toe wall for an embankment 1,650 feet long on the river side of the
canal, the completion of the additional masonry required to bring
the lock walls to the requisite height under the modified project, the
construction of a road from Riverton to the lock and along the south
bank of the canal, sodding portions of the canal slopes, and other
minor operations. A contract was entered into for furnishing and
erecting the upper and lower lock gates.
   The district officer recommends in his report an additional allot-
ment of $150,000 for completing the Colbert Shoals Canal. His
recommendation is concurred in.
   The sum given as a profitable expenditure in the fiscal year 1911
at Hales bar will be applied to the procurement by contract of the
electrical machinery and equipment for operating the gates and
valves, to providing lock houses, office, roads, walks, etc., to grading
grounds, etc., and to the expenses of supervision and inspection.
   It is proposed to apply the amount recommended for open-channel
work, $360,000, to dredging and dike construction at shoal places
between Chattanooga and Riverton, to providing a suitable working
plant for this section of the river, and to maintenance of the existing
channel, the object of the proposed work being to extend the benefits
already secured from open-river improvement, and in addition to
render available the important advantages to be derived from the
opening of Colbert Shoals Canal to navigation.
598           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The sum estimated as a profitable expenditure for the fiscal year
1911 at Colbert and Bee Tree shoals, $150,000, is to be applied to
riprapping the banks of the canal where necessary, to purchasing
and installing under contract the guard gates, filling valves, and
operating mechanism of the lock, and to contingent expenses.
   The commerce carried on the river between Chattanooga and
Florence in the calendar year 1908 amounted to about 202,450 tons,
the estimated value of which is given as $8,115,735. The most
important items were general merchandise, cotton, and timber
products.
   For references to details of the river from Chattanooga to Riverton,
see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page 456.
                                       HALES BAR LOCK AND DAM.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..............-...................... -                              $85, 539. 75
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ......................--..............................                                 15, 000. 00
                                                                         100, 539. 75
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ................... ...............
                                         ... .......... .... ... ...--....19, 835. 26

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .............-.......................                                 80, 704.49
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities-------...------..-----...---..............--.....-....----.          186. 38

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                                  80, 518. 11

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts.................                                51, 828. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                               101, 750. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909........................................................a                              101, 750. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
                                            OPEN-CHANNEL          WORK.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................                                 $176, 270. 78
Received from sales.................................................                                       18. 78
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909....................................................                                     5, 000.00

                                                                                                      181, 289. 56
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment....................   .....................................                                     77, 977. 10

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                 103, 312. 46
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                              13, 992. 75

July 1, 1909, balance available....................................                                    89, 319. 71

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                               1, 031, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909............................                                     360, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

  a Of this amount $50, 875 is for continuing contract work authorized by the river
and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEM1VENTS.                                              599
                                 COLBERT AND        BEE TREE       SHOALS.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............                        ...................      $376, 160. 74
Received from sales..................................................                                472. 80
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909. . ...                           120, 000. 00
                                                                                                    496, 633.54
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment-----....------....---..........----------..                                               . 346, 214. 64
                                                   --.............------..----...--..............--

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................--------------------------------           150, 418. 90
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...............          .    ..............                38, 161. 65

July 1, 1909, balance available ...........               --....   ....   ...............        112, 257.25

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .................                           88, 385. 08
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                          639, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
                          ..------------------------
  July 1, 1909------------------------...                                                        150, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
    (c) Below Riverton, Ala. (226 miles).-This section of the river
lies below most of the large tributaries, and the slope being uniform
and moderate and the width nowhere excessive it affords unusual
facilities for navigation. The ruling low-water depths were orig-
inally about 3.5 feet over the lower 196 miles and 2 feet in the remain-
ing portion. The average slope is 0.34 foot per mile, and the low-
water discharge is about 10,000 cubic feet per second. In 1896
there were 49 localities having less than 5 feet depth at low water,
and several other shoals have since developed.
   The existing project, originally adopted September 19, 1890, and
subsequently extended in its scope by the acts of August 18, 1894,
and March 3, 1899, is to obtain, by dredging, a channel not less
than 5 feet deep and 150 feet wide, and to protect Livingston Point
and Tennessee Island from erosion with a view to preserving the
port of Paducah, Ky.
   The appropriations and allotments for this section amount to
$397,197.74, and sums aggregating $838.49 have been received
from other sources, making a total of $398,036.23.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $376,325.93,
including about $57,197.05 for maintenance.
   This expenditure has resulted in the completion of the work at
Livingston Point and Tennessee Island at a cost of $77,367.65; in
the removal of snags and the dredging of about 1,127,660 cubic yards
of gravel at about 31 localities, thus removing the worst obstruc-
tions below Hamburg; and in the maintenance of the working plant
employed in this section. The results of the dredging operations
appear to be fairly permanent at about two-thirds of the places
improved. The work done in the season of 1907 has been of unusual
value.
   The smallness of the balance available during the working season
of 1908 and the high stages of the river that prevailed after funds
became available from the enactment of March 3, 1909, rendered it
impracticable to carry on any field operations during the fiscal year.
The expenditures for the year (including the amount applied to
600        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                  S. ARMY.

maintenance) were incident to the construction and repair of floating
plant and the purchase of supplies, preparatory to commencing the
season's work.
   The maximum draft that can be carried over the shoalest p]ace
in this section at mean low water is about 3 feet. The extreme
flood oscillations range from about 48 feet at Johnsonville to about
55 feet at Paducah.
   The commerce carried on the river between Florence and Paducah
during the calendar year 1908 amounted to about 552,560 tons, the
estimated value of which is given as $10,636,445; the principal items
in order of value being general merchandise, railroad ties, peanuts,
and cotton. Railroad ties formed the most considerable item in
point of tonnage.
   In the appendix to this report the district officer gives his reasons
for recommending an increased appropriation for this section, and
his recommendation is concurred in. It is proposed to apply the
amount estimated as a profitable expenditure in the fiscal year 1911
to maintenance of the existing waterway and to channel improve-
ment at the shoal places offering the greatest obstruction to naviga-
tion. The work proposed will result in an extension of the benefits
already secured, and will, moreover, serve an important purpose in
rendering more fully available the improvement to be effected by
the canal at Colbert and Bee Tree shoals, now nearing completion.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................           $4, 373. 53
Received from sales...................................................             512.70
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.. .................................................-   .       25, 000.00

                                                                               29, 886. 23
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
   For works of improvement..............................        $4, 873. 53
   For maintenance of improvement.......................          3, 302.40
                                                                                8, 175. 93

July 1909, balance unexpended......................................            21, 710.30
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................        3, 432. 76

July 1, 1909, balance available ....................    .................      18, 277.54

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909........ .........         ............. 150, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix C C 1.)
  2. Operating and care of Muscle Shoals Canal, Tennessee River.-
For details of this canal and of its operation and care, also dimensions
of locks, aqueduct, and drift sluice, see pages 2440-2446, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1901, with corrections given on
page 1729 of report for 1902.
  The canal was opened to navigation in 1890. It is in two sections,
aggregating about 18 miles in length, and has 11 locks. A railroad
nearly 15 miles in length is operated in connection with the mainte-
nance of the canal.
  Fifteen streams empty into the canal, none of them very large.
Bars are constantly forming opposite their mouths and also at the
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    601
entrances to the canal. A bucket dredge is kept on the canal in order
to remove these bars as fast as they form.
   The freight transported through the canal in the calendar year 1908
amounted to about 12,537 tons, the estimated value of which was
$1,097,140. The number of lockages made, exclusive of those of
government craft, was 1,227.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $1,119,803.80, of
which the sum of $53,443.56 was expended during the year.
   (See Appendix C C 2.)
   3. French Broad and Little Pigeon rivers, Tennessee.-The French
Broad River is one of the largest tributaries of the Tennessee. It
rises in North Carolina, flows in a generally northwesterly direction,
and finally unites with the Holston River in the State of Tennessee,
about 4.5 miles above Knoxville, to form the Tennessee River. It
has a drainage area of about 5,600 square miles. Leadvale, Tenn.,
about 70 miles above the mouth, has generally been considered the
head of navigation in Tennessee, and it is not believed that rafting or
logging is practicable to any great extent above this point. An
isolated portion of the river in North Carolina, between Brevard and
Asheville, was under improvement for several years from 1877 to
1882, and $43,000 was expended in removing obstructing bowlders,
fish traps, and snags, and in dredging and constructing wing dams at
Cherokee, Big Buck, and other shoals.
   In its original condition the river was obstructed by rock reefs,
sand and gravel bars, and by bowlders, snags, and overhanging trees,
and numerous islands in the river divided the water and diminished
the depth in the navigable channels. There were 41 shoals obstruct-
ing navigation below Leadvale. The average slope below Leadvale
is about 2.3 feet per mile, and the low-water discharge at Leadvale
is reported as about 2,000 cubic feet per second.
   The Little Pigeon River is formed by the junction of its east and
south forks at Sevierville, Tenn., and flows in a northerly direction
for about 5 miles, emptying into the French Broad about 29 miles
above its mouth. The Little Pigeon is navigable at ordinary stages
only about 2 miles above its mouth (to Catlettsburg), and thus prac-
tically amounts to an additional landing on the French Broad. In
its original condition this portion of the river was obstructed by a
bar at its mouth.
   The present project, adopted June 14, 1880, provides for open-river
work on the French Broad to secure a navigable channel at low water
from the mouth to Leadvale sufficient to permit the passage of boats
drawing about 2.5 feet, at an estimated cost of $150,000, and for the
removal of the bar at the mouth of the Little Pigeon.
   To June 30, 1909, $147,000 had been appropriated and allotted for
this improvement in both North Carolina and Tennessee, and $503.01
had been received from other sources, making an aggregate of
 $147,503.01.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, for work in the State of
Tennessee was $98,637.91, of which $8,085.16 was for maintenance.
This expenditure has been applied to the improvement of 15 shoal
places in the French Broad, the maintenance of the navigable channel,
and the removal of the bar at the mouth of the Little Pigeon.
602            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                           S. ARMY.


   No active operations were carried on during the fiscal year, owing
to insufficient funds. The expenditures were in connection with
preparing and equipping the plant required for the coming season's
work of maintenance.
   The maximum draft that can be carried over the shoalest place at
mean low water is probably about 18 inches. The extreme flood
oscillation is about 30 feet, ordinary floods having a range of about
10 to 15 feet. Steamboats rarely go above Dandridge, 46.5 miles
above the mouth, and all the improvements are below this place.
   The commerce carried on this river during the calendar year 1908
amounted to about 26,930 tons, valued at about $397,360.
   For details of the French Broad see the report of survey in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 3018. An
examination of the Little Pigeon is reported in the Annual Report
for 1891, page 2287.
   The direction of traffic on these streams is not parallel to rail lines.
The effect of the improvement on railroad rates, therefore, would be
indeterminate, though doubtless important.
   The district officer recommends, in view of the commercial impor-
tance of the French Broad River, that a biennial appropriation of
$10,000 be made for maintenance of the improvement. His recom-
mendation is concurred in. It is also recommended that an appro-
priation of $18,000 for works of improvement be made for the fiscal
year 1911, the work proposed being for the extension of benefits
already obtained under the existing project.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................... $3, 177. 52
Received from sales--......----..............................................
                          -------------------------------------------              1. 05
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..---......---............--................................   5, 000. 00
                                                                                                              8, 178. 57
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement---........-------.--------------..---......-..--...----.....--------------............-......   2, 313. 47
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................................                                       5, 865. 10
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities........ ..............................                                     175. 68

July 1, 1909, balance available................ ....                            ...........--.....             5, 689.42

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                                       61, 515. 64

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909......... ..- ... ..-...-... .....       28, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix C C 3.)
  4. Clinch, Hiwassee, and Holston rivers, Tennessee.-(a) Clinch
River.-This river rises in the Cumberland Mountains in Virginia,
and, after following a southwesterly course, empties into the Tennes-
see River at Kingston, 104 miles above Chattanooga. It drains an
area of about 5,000 square miles. Its average slope below Clinton
(60 miles from the mouth) is about 1.3 feet per mile. The ordinary
low-water discharge at Clinton is about 900 cubic feet per second.
There are about 193 miles of the river in the State of Tennessee.
  In its original condition the channel was obstructed by rock reefs,
sand and gravel bars, bowlders, snags, and overhanging trees.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          603
   The present project, adopted in 1880, provides for channel excava-
tion, removing surface obstructions, and the construction of wing
dams and training walls, so as to secure a navigable channel 2 feet in
depth at ordinary low water from the mouth of the river to Clinton,
about 60 miles, and of 1.5 feet in depth from Clinton to Haynes (or
Walkers) Ferry, about 66 miles. From Haynes Ferry to the State
line, a distance of about 67 miles, it is proposed simply to remove the
loose rock and bowlders, reduce the rock ledges, and remove snags,
overhanging trees, and similar obstructions, so as to assist raft and
flatboat navigation at the stages at which the river is ordinarily used.
   The sums thus far appropriated and allotted for this stream amount
to $54,825.43, and $1.10 additional has been received from sales,
making the total receipts $54,826.53.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $54,401.12. This
has been applied to reducing reefs, removing surface obstructions,
and building wing dams and training walls, whereby the use of the
river has been rendered practicable at stages 2 to 3 feet lower than
before the improvement was begun. The expenditures of the past
fiscal year were in connection with a public hearing and the inspec-
tion of certain bridges.
   The town of Clinton has been reached by small steamboats, and is
regarded as the practicable limit of steamboat navigation. Rafts
are transported from points at least as far upstream as Speers Ferry,
Va., 201 miles from the mouth.
   The commerce reported on the Clinch River for the calender year
1908 consisted of 64,410 tons of logs rafted, valued at about $386,460,
and about 900 tons of farm products carried between Harriman, on
the Emory River, and Tennessee River points, a distance of 4.5
miles on the Clinch. Statistics of the traffic arriving at and depart-
ing from Kingston, Tenn., were not compiled separately from the
commerce of the Tennessee River, as this town is situated so near
the mouth of the Clinch as to make it virtually a Tennessee River
port.
   For reasons given in his report the district officer recommends the
suspension of appropriations for this stream for the present.
   For survey of this river see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1901, page 2542.
   There is no information available indicating the extent to which
freight rates are affected by this improvement. It seems safe to say
that it will necessarily be slight until the time arrives when changed
conditions shall have warranted the adoption of a plan for the radical
improvement of this stream.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................ .................           $527. 62
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improvement. 102. 21
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                          425. 41
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                       28. 84
July 1, 1909, balance available.......               ...... .....................   ..........   396. 57
   (b) Hiwassee River.-The Hiwassee River rises in the mountains
of western North Carolina and northern Georgia, flows in a north-
westerly direction, and enters the Tennessee River about 35 miles
above Chattanooga. Its largest tributary is the Ocoee River, which
enters it from the south about 35 miles from its mouth. The Hiwassee
drains an area of about 2,725 square miles. Its average slope below
604     REPORT OF THE CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS, U.    S. ARMY.

the Ocoee is about 0.93 foot per mile. The low-water discharge at
the mouth of the Ocoee is given as about 950 cubic feet per second.
    On examination, made in 1874, the channel was found to be
obstructed by rock reefs, gravel bars, shags, and overhanging trees.
    The original project of improvement, based on the examination
of 1874, was for a navigable channel 40 feet wide and 2 feet deep at
ordinary low water to Savannah Ford, about 41.6 miles from the
mouth of the river, to be secured by excavation of rock reefs and
gravel bars and construction of wing dams. Expenditures under this
project amounted to $36,427.07.
   The present project, based on a survey made in 1899, contemplates
the development of a channel of not less than 116 feet width and 30
inches mean depth between the mouth of the river and the mouth of
the Ocoee River by use of spur dikes, training walls and submerged
sills, bank protection, and dredging, at an estimated cost of $71,125.
There were sixteen shoals having less than the desired depth at low
water.
    This project was adopted by the river and harbor act of June 13,
1902.
    Under the present project $74,855.33 has been received from ap-
propriations and allotments and $8.23 from sales, making a total of
$74 863.56.
    The amount expended on the present project to June 30, 1909,
was $67,044.18. This has been applied to maintenance of the navi-
gable channel and to work of improvement at Blackbird, Ackerman,
Hogwallow, Rogers, Mathews, Agency, and Bunker Hill shoals, the
most serious obstructions between Charleston and the mouth. In
the past fiscal year channel work was carried on at each of these
localities, mainly by dike construction and dredging. A new steam-
boat for this work, built under contract at a cost of $10,000, was
launched in August, 1908.
    The maximum draft that can be carried over the shoalest place at
mean low water is about 2 feet. The extreme flood oscillation at
Charleston, 19 miles above the mouth, is about 32 feet, but ordinary
floods do not exceed about 15 to 18 feet. Small boats of about 100
tons capacity can navigate the river eight months in the year. Sa-
vannah Ford, 7 miles above the mouth of the Ocoee River, has at
times been reached by steamboats, and is usually regarded as the
head of navigation; although at present steamboat traffic does not
extend above Charleston. Rafting and logging are not considered
practicable above Savannah Ford.
    The commerce on the Hiwassee River reported for the calendar year
1908 amounted to about 6,330 tons, valued at about $176,160. It
consisted principally of farm products and general merchandise.
    For report o survey see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1901, page 2458.
    There is no information available indicating the extent to which
freight rates will be affected by this improvement. It will probably
be slight.
    All the funds called for in the estimate of the present project have
been appropriated. In order to maintain the improvement in an
effective manner $10,000 should be appropriated biennially for main-
tenance, and this amount has been estimated for as a profitable ex-
penditure in the fiscal year 1911.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                  605
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............................      $39, 263. 95
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ..........    .......................................   5, 000. 00
                                                                                      44, 263. 95
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment...................................................................             36,444.57
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                  7, 819. 38
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....................................              2, 022.51


IAmount
July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................
          that can be profitably expended in fiscal year, ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.........        ..................................
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
                                                                                       5, 796. 87


                                                                                      10, 000. 00

  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (c) Holston River.-The Holston River is formed by the junction
of its north and south forks at Kingsport, Tenn., and flows thence
about 142 miles in a southwesterly direction and unites with the
French Broad 4.5 miles above Knoxville to form the Tennessee River.
It drains an area of about 3,811 square miles. It has an average
slope of about 2.5 feet per mile and a minimum discharge of about
650 cubic feet per second.
   In its original condition the channel was obstructed by rock reefs
and ledges, bowlders, snags, and overhanging trees. The present
project, adopted in 1902, provides for the removal of channel obstruc-
tions and cutting overhanging trees from the mouth to Kingsport,
at an estimated cost of $5,000.
   Up to June 30, 1909, $6,017.17 has been allotted for this stream
under the existing project, and $5,699.76 expended. The expendi-
tures have resulted in clearing the channel of some of the most
troublesome obstructions between the mouth and Ridleys shoals, a
a distance of about 137 miles.
   No operations were carried on during the fiscal year, the amount
expended having been applied to the payment of telegrams.
   There is no regular upstream navigation of the river. Occasionally
a small steamboat runs up 30 to 60 miles from the mouth at times of
high water.
   The commerce reported for the calendar year 1908 consisted of
about 12,210 tons of logs rafted, the value of which was estimated
at about $61,050.
   For report of survey, see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1901, page 2518.
   Railroad rates are not believed to be at all affected by work car-
ried on under the present project, which is practically for mainte-
nance only.
   For reasons given in his report the district officer states that further
improvement of this stream is not warranted at the present time.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................                      $318. 05
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement........................................ .            ................          . 64

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................               ..       317. 41
606           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                S. ARMY.

                                               CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................                            $40, 109. 62
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..............................................................................     5, 000. 00
                                                                                                 45, 1.09. 62
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.......................... ... $36,444. 57
    For maintenance of improvement........................    .102. 85
                                                                                                 36, 547.42

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                             8,562. 20
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                         2, 051.35

July 1, 1909, balance available.....................................                              6, 510. 85

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909............................           ........... a 10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix C C 4.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE FIRST CINCINNATI,
                     OHIO, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Col. Wm. T. Rossell, Corps of Engi-
neers, division engineer, central division.
   1. Ohio River (general open-channel improvement).-This work was
commenced by the General Government in 1827, when low-water
navigation over many of the bars and shoals was impossible for
commercial purposes; but the improvements made and maintained
since then have provided fairly convenient channels at such places
for a profitable light-draft local freight and passenger service during
low-water periods.                 The difference in level of water surface of the
river varies; at Cincinnati, nearly midway between the head and
mouth of the river, the average annual range during the past thirty
years is 48.4 feet.
   The project under which operations have been carried on has been
a continuous and progressive one, the principal features of the work
being the removal of snags, rocks, and wrecks from the general chan-
nel; the direct improvement of bars and shoals, by dredging and rock
excavation; the construction, repair, and maintenance of low dikes
and dams to concentrate and direct the flow of water in improved
channels; bank protection and the construction and repair of levees
where required in the interest of navigation; the construction, repair,
and maintenance of ice piers and harbors; miscellaneous improve-
ment, including surveys, establishment, care, and record of water
gauges, establishment of harbor lines, regulation of encroachment and
deposits on the banks of the river or in its channel, and the super-
vision of construction of bridges across the river. The length of
river through which the work extends is but little short of 1,000 miles,
and the total expenditure in this district by the Government during
the eighty-two years it has been in progress, exclusive of liabilities
outstanding June 30, 1909, is $7,168,726.37.
                                           a For Hiwassee River,
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMVIENTS.                   607
   The principal operations of the year were as follows: The U. S.
dredges Ohio and Oswego excavated 215,953 cubic yards of gravel,
sand, etc.; 62.8 tons of rock, and 107.85 tons of snags; and the hired
dredging plants excavated 80,626 cubic yards of gravel, sand, etc.;
3.75 tons of snags, and 1,100 feet b. m. wreckage. This dredging has
resulted in improvement of the channel, making a depth of 5 to 6
feet below low water at Wills Creek, Jonathan Run, Wheeling Creek,
Jenny Lind, Connoconneque, and Falling Run bars, Big Blue River
Islands, Big Blue River, Fivemile, Fourmile, Peckenpaugh and
Fulton bars, Troy reach, The Cabbage Patch, Rockport, Ind.,
Puppy Creek dike, Yellow Bank Towhead, Head of French Islands,
French Islands, Vannada reef, Indian Hill, Flint Island, Evansville
Harbor, Henderson dike, Caseyville, Ky., Tradewater and Walkers
bars, and Sisters Island.
   The installation of boilers, machinery, etc., on the combined
hydraulic and grapple dredge Indiana, under contract of June 22,
1908, was completed with the exception of the thirty-day trial test,
which was prevented by high stage of river. An electric-light plant,
the plumbing, etc., and an ice plant were installed, and the necessary
outfit, ponton pipe line, etc., purchased.
   A contract was entered into on October 6, 1908, for construction
of concrete dam at Browns Island; no work was done, but plant is
at site ready to begin operation as soon as stage of water permits.
    On the concrete dam at head of Marietta Island, under contract
dated October 14, 1907, the following work was done and material
placed: 9,208.8 cubic yards excavation, 80 cubic yards earth filling,
177 piles, 13,329 pounds of iron tie rods, etc.; 3,626.46 cubic yards
large and 2,827 cubic yards small stone; 2,763.08 cubic yards con-
crete, and 301 barrels extra cement.
   Repair and bank protection to dikes opposite Evansville, Ind.,
under contract dated September 22, 1908, was carried on and com-
pleted, consisting of the following: 3,310 cubic yards grading, 190
cubic yards riprap stone removed and replaced, 1,413.97 cubic yards
new riprap stone placed.
   Work of constructing loose stone dike at head of Grand Chain, Ill.,
under contract of October 14, 1907, was carried on when stage of
river permitted, as follows: 3,175 cubic yards of small stone care-
fully placed and 6,034 cubic yards of small stone roughly placed.
   Work on dikes at Mound City, Ill., under contract of June 14,
1905, was carried on and completed. The total work done under
this contract is as follows: Small stone, 12,589.042 cubic yards; large
stone, 628 cubic yards; excavation, 585 cubic yards.
    The work on Great Miami embankment, under contract of Decem-
ber 19, 1907, was carried on and completed. The total work done
under this contract is as follows: Earth fill, 20,362 cubic yards; con-
crete, 19,597- square yards.
    Supervision was had of established harbor lines at Steubenville,
Ohio, Wheeling, W. Va., Ironton, Ohio, and Cincinnati, Ohio. Maps
of tentative harbor lines at East Liverpool were prepared and ap-
proved and a public hearing ordered; and maps of the Cincinnati
harbor lines, showing the location of marking posts and witnesses to
the same, were prepared.
608                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                   U.     S.    ARMY.

   Twenty-five permits were issued to cover the construction of gas,
water, and oil pipe lines; overhead cables; tramway; intakes; trestle;
bank protection; derrick, and pavilion.
   Supervision was had of permits for all miscellaneous and bridge
constructions below the Pennsylvania state line.
   The nature of the Ohio River is such that its improvement, whether
by canalization (locks and dams) or open channel, can not bring full
benefit to navigation interests until the improvement shall have
become more continuous than past appropriations have permitted.
The unimproved portions afford less depth of channel than the im-
proved sections and limit the available draft for the whole river to
that required for passing its shoalest parts. Dredging and snagging
operations will be required at many places, even should a more or
less complete system of canalization be finally adopted, and for open-
channel improvement continuous work and simultaneous operations
will be absolutely necessary to produce effective results. The gov-
ernment plant should be largely increased in order that any great
amount of work may be accomplished during the comparatively short
periods to which effective operations must be limited each year on
account of unfavorable river conditions. Several light-draft tow-
boats, barges, and derrick boats for dike construction and removing
rocks or other obstructions are all urgently needed before anything
approximating satisfactory progress can be expected.
   The available depth in the Ohio River varies greatly with the fluc-
tuation in river stages. During the fiscal year the available depth
has been below the average. This was due, however, to a long-
continued drought in the fall of 1908.
   The fluctuations in river stages are indicated by the following
readings from characteristic river gauges:

                                                                         Highest.       Date.           Lowest.            Date.        Range.

                                                                             Feet.      1909.            Feet.             1908.        Feet.
Dam No. 6 ....................................                                 32.2    Feb. 25              0.8       Sept. 28,30....     31.4
Wheeling, W. Va. ...............................                               33.9    May 3                 .0       Sept. 30-Oct 9.     33.9
Parkersburg, W. Va ..........................                                  36. 7   Feb. 27               .0       Sept. 28, Oct.      36. 7
                                                                                              S17-24.
Point Pleasant, W. Va............                      .............           42.6    Feb. 27                  .2    Oct. 2.........      42.4
Portsmouth, Ohio...............................                                49.8    Mar. 1                  1.4    Oct. 4, 5......      48.4
Cincinnati, Ohio...........           ...................                      54.6    Feb. 28                 2. 5   Oct. 6, 7......      52.1
Louisville, Ky. (head).............................                            39.2    Feb. 27                 2.2    Dec. 4. ......       37.0
Evansville, Ind.................................                               43. 2   Mar.     2              1.3    Oct. 11-16.....      41.9
Paducah, Ky..................                         ................   .     44.5    Mar. 5, 6               1.0    Oct. 20........      43.5
Cairo, Ill.........................................                            46.8    Mar.      6             4.3    Oct. 17-19....       42.5



   The available depth in channel may be considered 1 foot greater
than gauge readings from Pittsburg to Louisville and 2 feet greater
from Louisville to Cairo.
   During the fiscal year no work was done to increase the available
depth, but work was confined to the removal of snags and other ob-
structions and increasing the width of narrow low-water channels,
thus bettering navigable conditions.
   No estimate can be given of the effect of the improvement thus far
made on freight rates. In this connection reference is made to the
Report of Ohio River Board (H. Doc. No. 492, 60th Cong., 1st sess.),
in which statements are made of present and prospective commerce
and the effects of improvements on freight rates, etc.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           609

   In order to provide for navigation during comparatively low-water
periods in winter, many of the existing dikes and dams will require
to be kept in a state of repair, as the movable dams can not safely be
operated during a time of even light-running ice, although properly
protected steamboats may be able to navigate at such time. The
severe losses to floating craft during recent years have shown the
importance of maintaining certain of the harbors of refuge afforded
by existing ice piers and the providing of others at carefully selected
localities.
   The commerce of the river during the past year, so far as indicated
by statistics that the engineer officer in charge of the river has been
able to obtain, was as follows: General merchandise, coal, etc.,
8,498,754 tons, at an estimated value of $59,491,278; passengers,
3,960,965.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended              ..... ....-..-........-.
                                         -.......                                $582, 693. 75
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.---....--...............................................          150, 000. 00
Received from sales, etc ...............     .... ................     ... .....       224. 92
                                                                                             732, 918. 67
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.........-       .................. $283, 897. 25
    For maintenance of improvement..... .................         21, 760. 00
                                                                                             305, 657. 25

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........       ........-.......- -              ...   .    427, 261. 42
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.... ...............          ..............              3, 604. 74

July 1, 1909, balance available..-..............................-                       ..   423, 656. 68
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. ..............                         90, 741. 39
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ........                      Indefinite.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909..........................                                  500, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix D D 1.)
   2. Lock and Dam No. 37, Ohio River.-The river and harbor act
approved June 13, 1902, authorized the construction of this dam, at a
cost not to exceed $1,050,000, and the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907, authorized the expenditure of $100,000 in excess of amounts
theretofore appropriated or authorized, "provided that the said lock
and dam shall be constructed with a view to a navigable depth of nine
feet." The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, further increased
the authorizarion for this work by $150,000, making a total of $1,300,-
000. Of the continuing-contract authorizations, $150,000 is yet to be
appropriated.
   Work was carried on from July 1, 1908, to December 19, 1908, under
very favorable conditions, and included the completion of lock cham-
ber, lock walls (excepting the raised platform on lower pier head), lock
gates, upper guide wall, filling and paving of esplanade, construction
of sewers and catch basins, laying of air pipes, 552 linear feet of navi-
gable pass with its wickets, etc., and the Kentucky abutment of dam.
Work on the warehouse and power house, both of brick, terra cotta,
concrete, and tile construction, was carried on during the season of
         9001-ENG 1909--39
610           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U.   S. ARMY.

1909, with the result that both are now nearing completion. The
following work was done and material placed during the year: 1,280
linear feet of cofferdam (20 feet wide); 108 temporary piling; 29,757
cubic yards ordinary excavation; 5,979 cubic yards deposit excava-
tion; 2,140 cubic yards rock excavation; 6,673 cubic yards ordinary
filling; 547 cubic yards stone filling; 20,463 cubic yards concrete
masonry; 10,430 square yards brick paving; 775 linear feet open gut-
ter; 22 catch basins; 2,120.7 linear feet sewers; 42,758 feet b. m. oak
timber; 6,980 feet b. m. white pine timber; 8,522 feet b. m. yellow
pine timber; 322 feet b. m. cypress timber; 407,144 pounds cast iron;
947,385 pounds wrought iron and steel; 87,272 pounds steel castings;
2,277 pounds bronze; 316 pounds Babbitt metal; 2,228 linear feet
3-inch, 4-inch, and 8-inch iron pipe; three 4-inch valves; one 4-inch
cross; eight 4-inch elbows; 193 pounds brass pipe; 84 piles.
   Under provisions of contract, 879,094 pounds of ironwork were
delivered at the site and partial payment made thereon. Twenty-two
thousand two hundred and thirty-eight and three-quarter barrels of
American Portland cement were delivered during the year, and 24,165
barrels were used on the work, there being some left over from last year.
   Under supplemental contract with the contractor, dated October 1,
1908, 1,291 cubic yards of concrete facing were placed on various slope
walls in lieu of stone originally provided.
   Under supplemental agreement with the contractor, dated August
28, 1907, the work of lowering the tracks of the lower gates of lock and
slightly modifying the gate itself was completed, the following work
being done and material placed: Lowering gate track and Poiree dam
and raising top of gate; removing and replacing gate tracks, cover
plates, and I-teams ($835); 548.91 cubic yards concrete removed;
476 cubic yards rock excavation; 713 cubic yards concrete masonry
replaced; 5,296 pounds ironwork; 1,669 pounds tug levers and rods;
38 linear feet stopwater (jam) pipes; 529 holes drilled in old ironwork;
1,526 feet b. m. white pine timber; 268 feet b. m. oak timber.
   The total expenditures on account of work to June 30, 1909, exclu-
sive of outstanding liabilities, is $766,512.67.
   It is proposed to apply the funds asked for the fiscal year 1911 for
Lock and Dam No. 37, Ohio River, toward completion of navigable
pass, bear traps, buildings, machinery, and other appurtenances of
the lock and dam necessary to its operation.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..............................-..-..  $469, 492. 13
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909-...... 230, 000. 00
                                                                                                      699, 492. 13
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment--------------
         .----------.................................--------...-----..............--------.......    316, 004. 80
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended                                                               ---
                                       ---------...............-------..........---------.........    383,487.33
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities........... ....               ...... ............                   711. 11
July 1, 1909, balance available ..................                       .. ...........       -..... 382, 776. 22
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..............                                  269, 784. 60
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.... -...                               150, 000.00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909---..-....----.                                                                         150, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
1 4, 1897.
    (See Appendix D D 2.)
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    611
   3. Operating snag boats on the Ohio River below the Pennsylvania
state line.-The condition of the channel way of the Ohio, the neces-
sity for continuous snag-boat work, and the benefits accruing there-
from to river commerce are plainly shown by the yearly reports of
obstructions removed, which obstructions, if permitted to remain,
would make navigation highly dangerous at ordinary stages and
hazardous at any time.
   The project for removing obstructions by a properly equipped snag
boat was put in operation in 1876, the boat having been completed at
a cost of $125,125.24, and the expense of operating having been borne
by appropriations for improving Ohio River until 1890. The river
and harbor act of September 19, 1890, provided $25,000 yearly for
this purpose, and the act of June 3, 1896, increased the yearly appro-
priation to. $50,000.
   The amount expended on this work during the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, was $34,090.98, the total expenditures up to the close
of the present fiscal year, exclusive of outstanding liabilities, being
$613,224.04. For report upon operation of snag boats on the Ohio
River in the State of Pennsylvania, see page 623, following.
   As far as practicable the removal of obstructions is carried on
whenever permitted by the stage of water and the absence of danger-
ous ice; and during the last fiscal year the regular Ohio River snag
boat E. A. Woodruff was in active service from July 1 to December
14, 1908, and from May 14 to June 30, 1909, traveling 4,098.25 miles
and removing the following obstructions: 1,357 snags, aggregating
5,277.78 tons; 6 rocks, measuring 527.5 cubic feet; 1 cofferdam; 294.71
cords drift; and 57 wrecks, comprising 29 coal barges, 8 .coal boats,
1 fuel barge, 1 wharf boat, 1 model barge, 1 tie barge, 2 pump boats,
1 gravel barge, 2 flatboats, 1 cinder barge, 1 sand barge, and the
remains of 9 steamboats. One steamboat wreck was removed by hired
dredge.
   The snag boat Woodruff is a powerful and finely equipped vessel
that does admirable service during moderate stages of water, but can
do little or nothing when the river is at a stage of less than 4 feet,
though it is at such stages that snagging operations should be prose-
cuted most advantageously.
   It is extremely important that snagging operations should be
extended to cover these low-water periods, and to this end it is recom-
mended that the yearly appropriation for snagging, as provided for
by the act of June 3, 1896, be increased to $100,000 for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, the additional $50,000 to be used in the
building and equipment of one light-draft combination snag and
derrick boat, adapted for use at even extreme low-water stages. This
boat would form a part of the regular snagging plant, and would be
operated from the yearly appropriation made for that purpose.
    (See Appendix D D 3.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE PITTSBURG, PENN-
                   SYLVANIA DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Maj. H. C. Newcomer, Corps of En-
gineers, having under his immediate orders the following-named offi-
cers of the Corps of Engineers: Capt. A. E. Waldron to August 7,
1908, Capt. E. M. Adams to July 24, 1908, and First Lieut. Lewis M.
612      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

Adams the entire year. Division engineer, Col. Wm. T. Rossell,
Corps of Engineers.
   1. Monongahela River, West Virginia.-The Monongahela River is
formed by the junction of the Tygarts Valley and West Fork rivers,
about 1 mile south of Fairmont, W. Va., and flows in a generally
northerly direction about 128 miles to its junction with the Allegheny
River at Pittsburg, Pa. The improvement of the portion in West
Virginia is considered to extend down the river as far as Lock No. 8
at the mouth of Dunkards Creek, Pennsylvania, about 4 miles north
of the Pennsylvania State line, or a total distance of about 41 miles.
   Navigation on this portion of the river in its original condition was
impeded at high water by swift currents, the fall per mile being about
2 feet. At low stages it was obstructed by shoals and numerous
gravel and rock bars. Steamboat navigation was practicable at high
stages as far upstream as Morgantown. Occasionally a boat could
go as far upstream as Fairmont, and downstream navigation of flats
and small rafts was practicable at medium and high stages.
   The original project for this portion of the Monongahela River was
adopted in 1872, and contemplated the construction of Locks and
Dams Nos. 8 and 9. This project was completed on November 8,
1899, with the result that boats drawing 5.2 feet of water could navi-
gate the river at low water as far upstream as Morgantown, W. Va.,
the river having previously been slack watered from its mouth to
Lock No. 8 by the Monongahela Navigation Company. The amount
expended under this project was $436,900.
   The existing project, adopted by Congress July 13, 1892, provides
for the construction of six locks and dams, Nos. 10 to 15, inclusive,
between Morgantown and Fairmont, W. Va., at an estimated cost of
$1,275,000. Appropriations aggregating this amount have been made,
and the sum of $107,463.86 was recovered from surety company on
contract of C. I. McDonald for failure to complete Locks and Dams
Nos. 10 to 15.
   The amount expended under this project up to close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909, was $1,314,440.38, including $21.64 re-
ceived from sales.
   The condition of this work on June 30, 1909, was as follows:
   Nos. 10 to 15, inclusive.-The locks and dams proper were com-
pleted and assigned to "Operating and care of canals," etc., in Jan-
uary, 1904. The lock houses and outbuildings have been completed,
the lock grounds graded, and additional protection provided by
strengthening the abutments and raising and lengthening the lower
guide walls. Some further work is required on one of the abutments
and the construction of one upper guide wall.
   The completion of these six locks and dams extended slack-water
navigation about 28 miles, from Morgantown to a point on the West
Fork River 4 miles above Fairmont, W. Va., with a minimum navi-
gable depth of 7 feet. The improvement should enable the people of
the territory affected to transport coal, general freight, etc., almost
uninterruptedly to market.
   The greatest recorded flood height is 40 feet at Morgantown. Or-
dinary flood heights average about 22 feet on this portion of the river.
   Traffic on this portion of the river is not heavy, but it has mate-
rially increased over that originally existing there. A line of packets
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                              613
plies the river between Pittsburg and Fairmont, and towboats op-
erate as necessity requires. Since the opening of the locks there has
been some development of coal mines and the shipment of coal by
water in small quantities.
  A statement of commerce and of the effect of the project on freight
rates, so far as known, is given in the report for operating and care
of locks and dams on Monongahela River, page 616.
   References to more extended information, reports of surveys, etc.,
are given on page 467 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1905.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....--------------.............-------.......----------......   $68, 045. 12
June 30, 1909, amount carried to surplus fund............... ...........                            1, 392. 35

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended -----......------......------..........----------...---..        66, 652.77
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................                              678. 60
July 1, 1909, balance available.......------.....----------------------.....--.---......           65, 974. 17
   (Appendix E E 1.)
   2. Monongahela River, ,Pennsylvania. The improvement of this
part of the river is considered to extend from Pittsburg to the mouth
of Dunkards Creek, a distance of 87.5 miles. In its original condition,
prior to 1840, it was navigable for steamboats only at high stages.
A downstream navigation for light-draft flats and rafts was practi-
cable at high and medium stages. The average fall per mile is about
0.9 foot and the minimum discharge about 160 cubic feet per second.
   In 1833 Congress provided for a survey of the river from Pittsburg
to Brownsville, a distance of about 57 miles. This survey was not
followed by an appropriation for improving the river, and the legis-
lature of Pennsylvania, by act of March 31, 1836, incorporated and
authorized the Monongahela Navigation Company to improve the
river from Pittsburg, Pa., to the Virginia state line, a distance of
91.5 miles. This company built seven locks and dams, producing
slack water from Pittsburg to within 2 miles of the West Virginia
state line.
   The river and harbor act of June 3, 1896, authorized and directed
the Secretary of War to institute and carry to completion proceedings
for condemnation of all the property and appurtenances of the com-
pany. The property was acquired by the United States on July 7,
1897, at a cost of $3,761,615.46.
   The amount expended on original and modified projects prior to
operations under existing project was $3,769,073.88, including the
purchase money.
   The existing project, adopted in 1899, with subsequent modifica-
tions (see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, p. 515),
provides for the enlargement and improvement of Lock No. 6 and
some additional structures at Lock No. 3, for the rebuilding of Locks
Nos. 2, 3, and 5, using in each case two parallel chambers, each 56 by
360 feet, and fixed concrete dams with movable tops, and for the
acquisition of necessary land and construction of certain improve-
ments at Locks Nos. 5 and 6; all at a total estimated cost of $2,194,605.
   The amount expended up to the end of fiscal year ending June 30,
1909, was $1,906,205.90.
614     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.


   Work is being carried on under continuing contract appropriations
at new Lock No. 5, all the funds authorized for this work having been
appropriated.
   The condition of work on June 30, 1909, was as follows:
   Lock and Dam No. 2.-The lock, power house, guard and guide
walls, with the exception of upper 105 feet of upper guide wall, were
built under contract. The abutment and dam were built by hired
labor. The river lock has been in operation since August 15, 1905,
and the land lock since March 5, 1906.
   The existence of cross currents at this lock renders it necessary to
extend the upper guide wall upstream and the middle wall down-
stream to provide safe and convenient access to the locks, and an
estimate of $43,000 is included in this report to cover the cost of the
work.
   Lock and Dam No. 3.-The lock, guard and guide walls, the power
house, power plant, and two lock-keepers' houses were built under
contract. The abutment and dam were built by hired labor, the
whole work being complete except for the raising of the upper sill of
the river lock. The river lock was placed in operation May 20, 1907,
and the land lock October 23, 1907.
   Lock and Dam No. 5.-The contractors for the lock have completed
the land and middle walls and the lower guide wall, and have nearly
completed the river wall and upper guide and guard walls, only a
small portion of their work remamining to be done. The abutment
was built by hired labor, and work was well under way on the founda-
tions for the first section of the dam, representing about 220 feet in a
total length of 555 feet.
   Locks Nos. 3 and 6, and floating plant.-All of the necessary struc-
tures at Lock No. 3, and the improvements contemplated at Lock
No. 6 have been nearly completed. All of the floating plant provided
for in the existing project, consisting of a dredge and two dump scows
and repair steamer with snagging appliances, has been completed and
put in service. The necessary land has been acquired at Lock No. 6.
   The greatest recorded flood height is 44 feet at Brownsville. Ordi-
nary flood heights average about 30 feet on this portion of the river.
   The traffic of the river is hampered and restricted by insufficient
capacity and inconvenience at some of the old locks. This will not
be overcome until the enlargement of Locks Nos. 1, 4, and 5 has
been accomplished.
    A statement of commerce and of the effect of the project on freight
rates, so far as known, is given in the report for operating and care
of locks and dams on Monongahela River, page 616.
    It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to the extension of
upper guide wall upstream and of middle wall downstream at Lock 2
 ($43,000).
    It is very important that this old Lock No. 4, built many years
ago with dimensions that are now inadequate for the growing com-
merce of the river, should be rebuilt at the earliest practicable date,
and it is therefore recommended that authorization be also given
for the amount required to complete this work ($527,000), so that
it may be carried on under continuing contract. This amount is
                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                               615

larger than the estimate given in House Document No. 209, Fifty-
eighth Congress, second session, the increase being necessary because
of increased unit costs, etc.
   A list of references to reports of examinations and surveys and
other items of interest concerning this river are given on page 469 of
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905.

                                                  REBUILDING LOCK 2.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................... .                                                 $3, 770. 42
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                                   3, 770. 42

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                 43, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909-----.......-------------------------------------------.............................................   43, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
                                                   REBUILDING LOCK 3.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................                                              $19, 489.03
Amount received from sale of condemned property....................                                                        313. 77
                                                                                                                       19, 802. 80
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.          -.... ..... ...... ...
                .-...                   ... ..-........... .. .. ........ .....                                         7, 192.06

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................      .....................                                           12, 610. 74
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.......-............................                                                   18. 67

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                                                 12, 592.07

                                                   REBUILDING LOCK 5.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended........................ ............ $537, 406. 91
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 200, 000. 00
Amount received from sale of blueprint maps........................           4. 45
                                                                                                                      737, 411. 36
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement------... --..... .......... ............... ............                                                  472, 261.51

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                                                265, 149.85
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..----..........---------..........--                       --...........----     68, 762. 81

July 1, 1909, balance available----------..                                      --------.........--.
                                                                  ----..--..........                                  196, 387. 04

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts.................                                                 62, 267. 45

                                                      LOCKS 3, 6, ETC.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                                                 $3, 803. 93
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                                                   3, 803. 93

                                                      LOCKS 5 AND            6.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................                                                     $3, 700. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement-----------------.....----------.......--.....------------.....--------------..............                     13.75

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                                    3, 686. 25
616          REPORT         OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                 U.   S. ARMY.

                                               CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...........  .....................    .. $568, 170. 29
Amount received from sale of condemned property..-...............              313. 77
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909 . ....     200, 000. 00
Amount received from sale of blueprint maps......... ...............             4. 45
                                                                                      768, 488. 51
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment............................ ... ...... .............. .........                479, 467. 32

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended---...             ---..............
                                                  ---         --      -----
                                                                     ....         .    289, 021. 19
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities--..-.---...---....--.-..----..-.---        .      68, 781. 48
July 1, 1909, balance available ................................-...                  220, 239. 71

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. ...   .....                      62, 267. 45
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........               a 43, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1,1909 ........                                                a 43, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
   (See Appendix E E 2.)
   3. Operating and care of locks and dams, Monongahela River.-
Statements of the original condition of the Monongahela River are
contained in the summaries for Monongahela River, West Virginia
and Pennsylvania. The slack-water system of the Monongahela
River comprises 15 locks and dams. Locks Nos. 1 to 4, inclusive,
are double locks; 5 to 15 are single locks. A table giving the dimen-
sions of the locks, lengths of dams, and other data is given in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, page 1691.
   The dams extend slack water to a point on West Fork River 4
miles above Fairmont, W. Va., or a total distance of about 131 miles
above the mouth of the Monongahela River at Pittsburg. Control-
ling depths at normal pool stages on the sills at the different old
locks below Morgantown vary from 4 to 6.7 feet; on the new locks
above that place they are uniformly 7 feet. During low stages of
water depths of 7.5 to 8 feet are maintained below Dam No. 6 by
placing flashboards on the dems.
   Locks Nos. 1 to 7, inclusive, have been under operation and care
since July 7, 1897, when they were purchased from the Monongahela
Navigation Company; No. 8 since November 8, 1889; No. 9 since
1879; and Nos. 10 to 15, inclusive, since January, 1904.
   The total amount expended for operating and care to June 30, 1909,
was $2,675,692.40. The amount expended during the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909, was $231,966.81.
   Under the provision of section 6 of the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1909, a special allotment of $329,045 was made from the
permanent indefinite appropriation for operating and care of locks
and other works of navigation, for beginning the reconstruction
of Lock and Dam 1, and preparations for this work are under way.
   The amount expended under this allotment in the fiscal year 1909
was $9,208.10.
                                          a For Lock No. 2 only.
                RIVER   AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    617
   Necessary repairs were made to the locks and dams and floating
plant, and the locks were operated throughout the year, except when
closed for limited periods for repairs, or on account of floods or ice.
   The total number of lockages at the 15 locks for the calendar year
1907 aggregated 66,105, giving a total commerce through individual
locks amounting to 27,388,211 tons and 188,248 passengers. Much
of this commerce, of course, moved through several locks. Taking
only the aggregate of the greatest items of the different kinds of
freight passing up and down at any single lock, plus the coal mined
and shipped in pools 1 and 2, which amount is manifestly less than
the real movement of commerce, the total commerce of the Monon-
gahela River for the year amounted to 9,667,229 tons and 28,164
passengers.
   The effect on freight rates of the slack-water system of the Monon-
gahela is very great. This is true for all manner of products, and
particularly so for coal. For an average haul of 50 miles on the
Monongahela River the price of coal delivered by river is $1.25 per
ton, as compared with $1.40 per ton delivered by rail, making the
river freight rate 15 cents per ton cheaper. As the haul increases
the advantage of the river advances rapidly. As an example, the
river freight rate on coal to a point 12 miles below Pittsburg is 2.5
mills per bushel, or 6.25 cents per ton, in barge-load lots, while the
rail freight rate to the same point is 40 cents per ton, a difference
in favor of river of 33.75 cents per ton. The effect on freight rates
beyond the above, due to the rebuilding of Locks and Dams Nos. 2 and
3, will not be felt until the enlargement of Locks Nos. 1, 4, and 5 is
accomplished, when larger cargoes will be towed by steamers and
the freight rate reduced accordingly.
   (See Appendix E E 3.)
   4. Allegheny River, Pennsylvania, open-channel worc.-The Alle-
gheny River rises in northern Pennsylvania and flows northwestward
into New York, and thence in a southerly direction into Pennsylvania
to its junction with the Monongahela River at Pittsburg. The aver-
age fall per mile of the navigable portion is about 2.2 feet and the
minimum discharge at Pittsburg is about 1,440 cubic feet per second.
In its original condition the Allegheny River abounded in obstructions,
such as bowlders, snags, islands, bars, and wide-spreading shoals, all
of which rendered navigation at best hazardous and practicable only
at such high stages of water as would enable craft to clear the obstruc-
tions.
   The present project was adopted in 1878 and 1880 and contemplates
the removal of the bowlders and snag obstructions and the construc-
tion of low dams and dikes to close secondary channels and concen-
trate the low-water flow on shoals.
   The amount expended under this project to June 30, 1909, was
$263,624.52, fully one-half of which was applied to maintenance.
   The work that has been done enables navigators to operate safely
on stages from 2 to 3 feet lower than formerly.
   The present condition of the channel is generally satisfactory, hav-
ing been largely cleared of the more objectionable obstructions, but
to maintain its condition it is necessary to remove any bowlders or
618         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                    U.   S. ARMY.

snags brought in by the tributaries or carried along by ice and
freshets, and to make occasional repairs to the dikes and dams.
   The greatest recorded flood height is 36.6 feet at Herr Island dam.
Ordinary flood heights average about 30 feet.
   Except on the lower 25 miles of the river the principal traffic is
the downstream transportation of timber and lumber rafts, new
coal-boat bottoms, barges and flats, usually loaded with tan bark,
lumber, posts, railroad ties, and other timber products, and the
towage of gravel, stone, sand, etc. Steamboating is not now con-
ducted to any material extent above Kittanning.
   The annual commerce of the river above slack-water improvements
in course of construction is about 200,000 tons, extending over 230
miles from Tarentum, Pa., to Olean, N. Y.
   The effect of the work on freight rates is not very noticeable, as
the depth of water has not been increased, but the hazard of boating
has been greatly decreased.
   It is proposed to apply the $5,000 estimated as a profitable expendi-
ture for the fiscal year 1911 to maintenance of the existing channel
and works of improvement.
   More detailed information, reports of surveys, etc., are given in the
following Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers: 1899, page 2411;
1902, page 1901; and 1905, page 1862.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ....                  ............. $.............
                                                                      $2, 290. 80
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........................... ............  ............  1, 000. 00
                                                                                 3, 290. 80
June 30, 1909, amount expended for maintenance of improve-
  ment during fiscal year ....................................    $915. 32
June 30, 1909, amount carried to surplus fund................... 1, 375. 48
                                                                                 2, 290. 80
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......-----..................             ...   1, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, in addition to the balance
  unexpended July 1, 1909                       .... .....--............... 5, 000. 00
                                 -...........-....
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix E E 4.)
   5. Allegheny River, Pennsylvania, construction of locks and dams.-
Prior to the completion, in 1885, of the Davis Island dam in the
Ohio River, 5 miles below its head, it was impossible to navigate
the Allegheny River with steam craft of lightest draft during low-
water periods, which frequently continued for months at a time.
Since then a navigable depth of 8 feet has been afforded by that dam,
when raised, to Garrison ripple, 2 miles up the stream.
   The present project for lock and dam construction, originally
adopted in 1890 and subsequently extended in 1896, provides for the
construction of three locks and dams, extending slack water from the
mouth at Tarentum, a distance of 25 miles. Dam No. 1 is movable,
of Chanoine type, with bear-trap weirs. Dams Nos. 2 and 3 are both
fixed, the former being built of concrete on pile foundation and the
latter of crib construction. The lock chamber at No. 1 is 55 feet by
286 feet 2 inches; at Nos. 2 and 3, 56 feet by 289 feet 6 inches.                    The
                RIVER   AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   619

estimated cost of the work is $1,658,226.63, including $210,000 for
restoration of dam, etc., at Dam No. 3. In addition $95,000 will
be required to cover the restoration of bank at Dam No. 3, made
necessary by the flood of 1907, and the payment of damages to private
property resulting from the failure of the abutment.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $1,658,804.47; of this
amount $10,000 was expended for maintenance.
   The condition of the work on June 30, 1909, was as follows:
   Lock and Dam No. 1 (Herr Island), about 1 miles from the mouth.-
This work was built under contract and has been in operation since
January 1, 1903.
   The dam was first raised June 2, 1903. One double lock-masters'
house has been built under contract.
   Lock and Dam No. 2 (Aspinwall), 7 miles from the mouth.-The lock
has been built under contract and has been in operation since Novem-
ber 10, 1906. The abutment and dam have been built under con-
tract, with the exception of a portion of the abutment, which was built
by hired labor.
   Lock and Dam No. 3 (Springdale), about 17 miles from the mouth.-
The lock was built under contract and has been in operation since
September, 1904. The abutment and dam were built under con-
tract. In January, 1907, during a moderate flood stage, the abut-
ment failed and a portion of the dam had to be blown up to limit the
resulting damage to private property. The abutment and dam have
been rebuilt and the bank partly restored by hired labor.
   Two lock houses have been built under contract.
   Some dredging will be required in each of the three pools to secure
the projected minimum depth of 7 feet.
   The greatest recorded flood height is 36.6 feet at Herr Island dam.
Ordinary flood heights average about 30 feet.
   For the calendar year 1908 the commerce reported on that part of
the river under the improvement for slack-water navigation was
536,129 tons of freight and 9,636 passengers.
   The completion of these locks and dams will be of immense benefit
to the manufacturing plants along the banks of the Allegheny River
within their reach, by reason of connecting them with the harbor of
Pittsburg and with the coal fields of the Monongahela River.
   The effect of the project on freight rates is given in report on op-
erating and care of locks and dams on Allegheny River.
   In addition to the funds appropriated by the river and harbor act
of March 2, 1907, for repair and reconstruction of Dam No. 3, an
estimate of $95,000 is submitted by the district officer as the further
amount required for restoration of the bank at the abutment of Dam
No. 3 and for the payment of damages to private property resulting
from the failure of the abutment in January, 1907. All of the claim-
ants, except two with whom satisfactory agreements could not be
made and whose claims, estimated at $365.25, have not been included,
have signed agreements binding themselves to accept reasonable sums
in full payment of their claims. These amounts aggregate $46,767.21,
including 6 per cent interest for one year to cover delay in payment
not contemplated in the agreements, and the remaining $48,232.79 is
needed to restore land that was washed away. An appropriation of
the amount ($95,000) required for this purpose is recommended for
the favorable consideration of Congress.
620              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                           U.     S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............               ............    ....... $96, 464. 19
Amount received from sale of condemned property....---...........----.....                        137. 85
Amount received from sale of blueprint maps------.........------....------------............--        . 60
Amount received by transfer .....      .....- .... .........................                   5, 000. 00
                                                                                                                    101, 602. 64
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
   ment..............------.....---------   ....           ......------
                                                   ..----------     ...-------.... ..--------........------......    96, 845.48

July 1,1909, balance unexpended-----...----...........----------.....----.........---------------...                  4, 757.16
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................                                              1, 326. 10
July 1, 1909, balance available-- --...........                                                                -- 3,431.06
                                                                                          .........-------------------------------.

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. ...............                                                  825. 00
    (See Appendix E E 5.)
   6. Operating and care of locks and dams, Allegheny River, Pennsyl-
vania.-Statement of the original condition of the Allegheny River
is contained in the preceding summary for Allegheny River, Penn-
sylvania.
   Locks Nos. 1, 2, and 3 were under the appropriation for operat-
ing and care all the year. Dimensions of locks and other data
are given in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, page
1705.
   Dam No. 1 is movable and was the first to be completed in the series
of three authorized by Congress for the Allegheny River; its pool pro-
vides a navigable depth of 5 to 6 feet for a distance of about 5.5 miles.
Dams Nos. 2 and 3 are both fixed, the former being built of concrete
on pile foundation and the latter of crib construction. Dam No. 2
forms a pool about 10 miles long, while Dam No. 3 extends slack
water about 8 miles farther to the projected site of Dam No. 4 at
Natrona.
   Lock No. 1 has been under operating and care since January 1,
1903; No 2 since November 10, 1906, and No. 3 since November 29,
1904.
    The total amount expended for operating and care to June 30, 1909,
was $257,549.80. The amount expended during fiscal year 1909 was
$37,839.51.
    The locks and dams were operated throughout the year as occasion
required.
    The traffic through locks and dams, Allegheny River, during the
calendar year 1908 was as follows: Lock and Dam No. 1, 374,310
tons and 7,578 passengers; Lock and Dam No. 2, 138,440 tons and
1,507 passengers; Lock and Dam No. 3, 23,379 tons and 551 pas-
sengers. The tons represent short tons of 2,000 pounds.
    The operation of the locks and dams on the Allegheny River, pro-
viding a system of slack-water navigation in connection with Pitts-
burg Harbor, will tend to give manufacturing plants in this section
the benefit of the cheap river rates on coal and other supplies. This
benefit, however, can not be realized to any considerable extent until
the low bridges on the lower Allegheny River are raised sufficiently to
remove the very serious obstruction to navigation that they now
present.
     (See Appendix E E 6.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    621

   7. Construction of locks and dams in Ohio River, Pennsylvania
(40.5 miles).-The Ohio River, Pennsylvania, in its original condi-
tion had a low-water channel depth varying from 1 foot at Pittsburg
to 2 feet at the Ohio State line, the average slope being about 1.25
feet per mile and the minimum discharge at the head about 1,600
cubic feet per second. Under the original project for open-river
improvement, work was conducted on this portion of the river at a
number of shoals.
   Under the original project for lock and dam construction, adopted
in 1875, Dam No. 1 was begun in 1877 and completed in 1885, at a cost
of $940,000. The present project, in its original form, was adopted
by Congress September 19, 1890, and, with subsequent modifications,
provides for the construction of Locks and movable Dams Nos. 2, 3, 4,
5, 6, and 7, so as to secure a navigable depth of 9 feet in the pools
formed thereby, the locks to have available dimensions of 110 by 600
feet, at a total estimated cost of $6,321,376. Appropriations aggre-
gating $5,369,376 have been made, and $15,684.74 has been realized
from other sources. The sum of $75,000 additional will be required
to place the grounds at Locks Nos. 2-5 in suitable condition.
   The amount expended under present project to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $5,356,309.79.
    The work was done partly under continuing-contract system, and
the total authorization has been appropriated.
    The condition of work on June 30, 1909, was as follows:
   Locks and Dams 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 were all practically completed. The
dams were first raised on the following dates: No. 1, October 7, 1885;
No. 2, November 12, 1906; No. 3, June 25, 1908; No. 4, June 30, 1908;
No. 5, November 21, 1907; No. 6, August 17, 1904.
   Lock and Dam No. 7.-The site for this work has been secured and
plans are partly made. No field work of construction has been done
on account of lack of funds.
   The completed dams, Nos. 1-6, inclusive, give continuous slack
water, when raised, from Pittsburg to Merrill, Pa., a distance of about
28.9 miles.
   The greatest recorded flood height is 34.2 feet at Davis Island dam.
Ordinary flood heights average about 28 feet on this portion of the
river.
   A statement of commerce and of the effect of the project on freight
rates, so far as known, is given in the report for operating and care of
locks and dams, Ohio River, page 624.
    It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable expen-
diture for the fiscal year 1911 to the completion of necessary work on
the lock grounds at Locks Nos. 2, 3, 4, and 5 ($75,000), which includes
filling in the grounds now much below grade and the construction of
concrete paving.
   The work of constructing Lock and Dam 7 is most urgently needed
in order to utilize more effectively the improvements already made
on the upper Ohio River, the portion of the river immediately above
that location being specially suited for harborage purposes, and it is
recommended that authority be given to complete it under the con-
tinuing contract system. No estimate for the existing 6-foot project
is included amongst those submitted for the fiscal year 1911, pending
action by Congress on the new plans now before it for providing
9-foot navigation (see H. Doc. No. 492, 60th Cong., 1st sess., in which
622            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

the estimated cost of Dam No. 7 in the 9-foot project is given as
$1,094,800).
   Reference to more detailed information, reports of surveys, etc.,
are given on page 522 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1906.
                                          DAMS NOs.         2,   3,   4,    AND 5.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...-----------....---......-------....---......--........-----.               $18, 919.77
Amount received from sale of condemned property -..............-..--                        .                      324. 90
Amount received by transfer of public property-.........-..   -          ..- .      .....-.                        250. 00
Amount received on account of judgment against E. J. Hingston-.......                                           5, 062. 60
                                                                                                                   24, 557. 27
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment........---------..------..                                                        ------------.............. 2, 841.92
                                  ----...........------------.. --.............----------...

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended--..----....--------..................-----........-------------..             21, 715. 35
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities_...................................                                           10. 10
July 1, 1909, balance available..------------.....-------.......-----------......--....----.                   21,705.25
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                                       75, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909------------------------------------.....-------------75, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897.
                                    DAM NO. 6.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................. ...............                                       .
                                                                                                       ...   $8, 069. 30
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
                          ...---...........-------------....------....--------------------...........
  ment----....................-----------                                                             .... -     133.36

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-.......................................                                         7, 935. 94

                                                      DAM NO.          7.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...............               ....   ........        $4, 755. 38
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.. ---.. ...................... ...... ..---------.. ..-- ....----..........--      18. 18

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...............                             ...       ....   .......            4, 737. 20

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                      a 952, 000. 00

                                                    CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended... ...................                .........                              $31, 744. 45
Amount received from sale of condemned property ...................                                                324. 90
Amount received by transfer of public property .......................                                             250. 00
Amount received on account of judgment against E. J. Hingston......                                             5, 062. 60
                                                                                                                37, 381. 95
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ....................... ................     .................                                            2,993.46

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................                                               34, 388. 49
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...............................                                                 10. 10

July 1, 1909, balance available .................................                                               34, 378. 39

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                                      1, 027, 000. 00


                          a For 6-foot project, see page 621 (last paragraph).
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                              623
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909............------------------------------------------------                                     $75, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
   (See Appendix E E 7.)
   8. Dredging Ohio River, Pennsylvania.-An allotment of $20,800
was made June 12, 1905, from the appropriation of $300,000 made by
act of March 3, 1905, for the general unimprovement of the Ohio River,
for the removal of the bar in upper approach to Lock No. 6. This
bar was removed by the excavation of 35,161 cubic yards of material
at a contract cost of 19 cents per cubic yard. On August 30, 1905, a
reallotment of $10,350 from the allotment for dredging pool No. 6
was made for dredging in pools Nos. 3 and 4, Ohio River. Under this
allotment the channel at Whites riffle, above Lock No. 3, was straight-
ened out, and the bar immediately below Lock 3 was removed. The
total amount of material handled was 48,917 cubic yards.
   The amounts expended on these works to June 30, 1909, are as
follows:
Dredging pools Nos. 3 and 4----...-----------...............-----------------.....-----......                     $6,475.24
Dredging pool No. 6---------....------...------......--...........------------.............--------........        8, 693.16
          Total..-------------------------------........----------...........                                     15, 168.40

                                            DREDGING POOLS 3 AND 4.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................... . $3, 858. 55
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment-----------..... --...............----------------------------.....----..........-----..............------......
                       - --...                                                                                         1, 533. 79

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..............                                    ............... ....            2, 324. 76

                                                  DREDGING POOL 6.

                                      -
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.........           --........--.        ....-----------...........-----..           $806.84
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended---...---------..--------............------------..........----.....                  806. 84

                                                     CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended --.........--............................... $4, 665. 39
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..--------- -----------------------........---------...........------...................--------............... 1, 533. 79

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                                             3, 131. 60
  See Appendix E E 8.)
   9. Operating snag boats on Ohio River in the State of Pennsyl-
vania.-The project adopted July 27, 1905, provides for the removal
of snags, wrecks, and similar obstructions in portion of the Ohio
River in the State of Pennsylvania. This work was carried on under
allotments made from the permanent appropriation for operating
snag boats on Ohio River.
   The amount expended on this work to June 30, 1909, is $7,369.91,
of which $2,300.97 was expended during the past fiscal year.
   There were removed during the year one coal boat and one barge.
   (See Appendix E E 9.)
624      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,          U. S. ARMY.

   10. Operating and care of locks and dams, Ohio River, Pennsyl-
vania.-Statement of the original condition of the Ohio River in
Pennsylvania is found on page 621 of this report.
   Locks and Dams Nos. 1 to 6, inclusive, were under the appropriation
for operating and care during the whole fiscal year. The dams are all
movable and are the first ones to be completed in the series that is
projected for the improvement of the Ohio River. The dimensions
of the locks, with other data, are given in Annual Report for 1907,
page 1715 et seq.
   Dam No. 1, at Davis Island, was designed to give a depth of 6 feet
in Pittsburg Harbor, which has since been increased to 10 feet over
certain portions of the harbor by dredging. Dams Nos. 2 to 6, inclu-
sive, are designed to give navigable depths of 9 feet in their respective
pools. The aggregate length of these pooled portions of the river is
28.9 miles.
   These locks and dams were placed under operating and care, as
follows: No. 1, October 7, 1885; No. 2, October 13, 1906; No. 3,
February 1, 1908; No. 4, February 1, 1908; No. 5, November 21,
1907; No. 6, August 3, 1904.
   The total amount expended for operating and care to June 30,
1909, was $785,964.15. The amount expended during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909, was $119,954.97.
   Dam No. 1 was up during the fiscal year 3 times, aggregating 219
days; Dam No. 2, 3 times, 222 days; Dam No. 3, 3 times, 222 days;
Dam No. 4, 4 times, 205 days; Dam No. 5, 3 times, 219 days; and
Dam No. 6, 4 times, 219 days.
   The locks were operated as occasion required and necessary repairs
made for maintenance of the works.
   The traffic for the calendar year 1908, as measured by the com-
merce through Lock and Dam 1, amounted to 3,060,835 tons of
2,000 pounds.
   The effect of the project on freight rates has been partly discussed
in the report for operating and care of locks and dams, Monongahela
River.
   Davis Island dam, forming as it does the pool of Pittsburg Harbor,
has lent its great part to the general effect on freight rates to and
from Pittsburg. The effect on rates of the operation of Dams Nos. 2
to 6, inclusive, should be felt locally for all supplies coming from Pitts-
burg Harbor, and to some extent also for through traffic, since they
will increase from 25 to 50 per cent the number of days in the year
on which tows may be moved down the river from Pittsburg.
   The great future benefit of the above project will be felt only when
the slack-water system is extended far enough down the Ohio River
to permit continuous navigation during all but the winter season.
This improvement, it has been estimated, will cause a saving in freight
rates over the present rail rates on such produce as coal, iron, steel,
sugar, timber, molasses, tobacco, etc., of over 3 mills per ton-mile
to the 8,000,000 people living in territory commercially contiguous
to the Ohio and Mississippi systems.
   (See Appendix E E 10.)
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     625
   11. Harbor at Pittsburg, Pa.-This harbor comprises that portion
of the Ohio River lying above Davis Island dam, a length of 4.7
miles; that portion of the Allegheny River lying between its mouth
and Aspinwall, a length of 7 miles, and that portion of the Monon-
gahela River lying between its mouth and McKeesport, a distance of
15.5 miles; total length of harbor, 27.2 miles. That portion of the
harbor most used as such, and called the lower harbor, lies between
the Davis Island dam and Dam No. 1 of the Allegheny and Monon-
gahela rivers and measures 8 miles of river. In its original con-
dition the lower harbor depths were from 3 to 4 feet on natural mean
low river, and very often still lower stages caused suspension of
navigation.
   Since the completion of Davis Island dam, in 1885, the maximum
draft which could be carried over the shoalest place was scant 8 feet
at pool stage. Parts of the channel and harbor are from 10 to 12
and from 16 to 20 feet in depth. The average widths of the harbor
at pool-full surfaces are: On the Ohio, about 1,100 feet; on the
Allegheny, about 930 feet, and at different parts of the Monongahela,
from 750 to 950 feet. The capacity of the harbor is impaired by
shoal places and high dumps projecting from the banks. The use
for harbor purposes of that portion of the harbor in the Allegheny
River above the Sixth Street Bridge is practically nullified by the
low bridges on that part of the stream. The clear heights of these
bridges above their respective pool surfaces are from 27 to 35
feet. The least height, with chimneys down, of the packets that ply
between Pittsburg and points on the Ohio, Kanawha, and Muskingum
rivers is 45 feet. The average height of the Ohio River towboats,
with chimneys down, is 44 feet. The height of a suitable packet for
the Allegheny River is about 33 feet, and of a suitable towboat, about
28 feet. The result is that practically none of the coal and iron or
steel products intended for southern shipments have been loaded or
harbored in the Allegheny River. The removal of the Union Bridge
at the mouth of the river has opened up this portion of the harbor
as far as the Sixth Street Bridge, a distance of about one-half mile.
    In 1858 the State of Pennsylvania, through a board of commis-
sioners, made a detailed survey of the rivers at and near Pittsburg
and laid down on the maps high and low water lines intended to
define the banks and limit the use of the same by riparian proprietors.
These lines were referred to stone monuments on the ground. No
means, however, were provided for preserving the monuments nor
for preventing filling in the river beyond these lines.
    In 1894 a board of engineer officers recommended certain harbor
lines for the harbor of Pittsburg, from the Davis Island dam to
Brilliant, Allegheny River, and to Homestead, Monongahela River.
The recommended lines generally followed the actual banks as they
existed at that time. These lines were approved by the Secretary of
War January 29, 1895. An extension of these lines on the Monon-
gahela River from Homestead to McKeesport was approved by the
Secretary of War April 3, 1902.
    The original project for improvement was adopted by the river
and harbor act of March 3, 1899, and provided, with subsequent modi-
     9001-ENG 1909-40
626        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                 U.    S. ARMY.

fications made during the progress of the work, for dredging a chan-
nel through the lower harbor (below dams No. 1 on the Allegheny
and Monongahela rivers) where needed 10 feet deep at pool and 500
feet wide below Smithfield Street Bridge, Monongahela River, and
of less width above this bridge and in the Allegheny River, limited
by lines from ends of channel spans of the adjoining bridges, except
at the Pan Handle railroad bridge, where the dredged channel, under
modified project, was to have a width of 570 feet, including two
channel spans; for raising the old riprap dam across Brunot Island
back channel, Ohio River; for removing abandoned structures and
unauthorized and obstructive fillings projecting from the banks
beyond the harbor lines; for marking of harbor lines, and for
inspecting and patrolling the harbor. Appropriations aggregating
$110,662.90 were made and expended on this work.
   The existing project provides for maintenance of the harbor at an
annual estimated cost of $10,000. The amount expended under this
project to June 30, 1909, was $39,894.74.
   The greatest recorded flood height is 35.5 feet at Pittsburg. Ordi-
nary flood heights average about 28 feet.
   The principal commercial uses of the harbor are the mooring of
coal fleets awaiting a rise in the Ohio for proceeding to destination
on that river or on the lower Mississippi, the mooring of timber rafts
and boat bottoms coming down the Allegheny River on rises, the
delivery of coal and other materials to mills, furnaces, steel plants
and yards, and the accommodation of the several packet lines plying
on the three rivers and whose routes terminate at the harbor. Be-
sides coal, considerable quantities of steel rails, cotton ties, sheet
iron, wire, nails, etc., are shipped by barges to the lower river
markets.
                                     Commercial statistics.


      Calendar year.         Products.     Paersn-            Calendar year.             Products.    Passen-
                                            gers.                                                      gers.


                                Tons. a                                                    Tons. a
1900.........................  8,141,451   884,415   1905............ ..........         12,269,020    603,716
1901 .........................10,916,489   817,800   1906 ............         .......   12,927,975    271,450
1902..........................12,252,405   996,500   1907 ...............     .......    14,395,816    533,280
1903....................      12,240,360   702,269   1908....................             9,090,146    267,043
1904.........................  9,373,448   604,477

                                            a 2,000 pounds.

   The improvement of this harbor is so closely connected with the
slack-water system of the rivers emptying into it that it might well be
said that, as far as effect on freight rates is concerned, this project is
one and the same as the projects for the improvements of said rivers.
   It is proposed to apply the $10,000 estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure for the fiscal year 1911 to the maintenance of the harbor
in accordance with the approved project.
   References to reports of establishement of harbor lines and projects
for maintaining this harbor are given in Annual Reports of the Chief
of Engineers for 1905, page 474, and 1906, page 520.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                627
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................... $1, 901. 69
Amount received from sale of blueprint maps............................       5. 65
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......................................................   4, 000. 00
                                                                      5, 907. 34
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...............  ..................................     2, 749. 39
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..............             .....   ...................          3, 157. 95
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....-          ..........           ......        -.......     44. 99
July 1, 1909, balance available --...      ................                  -........         3,112. 96
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 ...............................................    10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix E E 11.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE WHEELING, WEST
                   VIRGINIA, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Capt. F. W. Altstaetter, Corps of
Engineers. Division engineer, Col. Wm. T. Rossell, Corps of En-
gineers.
   1. Locks and dams in Ohio River between the Pennsylvania state
line and Cincinnati.--A general description of the Ohio River is con-
tained in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, page
2062. The system of improvement of this river by movable darns
was approved by Congress in the act of March 3, 1875 (construction
of dam at Davis Island-first dam below Pittsburg). The act of
September 19, 1890, provided for the construction of a dam at or
near Beaver, Pa., known as No. 6. The above represent practically
the original projects for the slack-water system of the Ohio. The
original project for Dams Nos. 8 to 18, inclusive, is contained in
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1899, page 2361, and
that for Dams Nos. 19 and 26 in Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1902, page 1867.
   Congress, in the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, made pro-
vision for 9-foot navigation in the pools formed by Dams Nos. 2, 3,
4, 5, and 6, and for an examination of and report on the river by a
board of engineers with regard to the method and means of im-
provement which will meet the demands of traffic, present and pro-
spective. This report is contained in House Document No. 492, Six-
tieth Congress, first session.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, made provision for a
navigable depth of 9 feet at Dams Nos. 8, 11, 13, 18, and 26, and
for increased cost as follows: Dam No. 8, $1,211,845; Dam No. 11,
$1,158,343; Dam No. 13, $1,286,778; Dam No. 18, $933,000; and
Dam No. 26, $1,200,000. An increased depth at Dam No. 19 has not
been authorized and the estimate of cost remains at $950,000.
   When the dams are completed they will provide a navigable depth
of 9 feet at intervals between Pittsburg, Pa., and Gallipolis, Ohio.
628         REPORT         OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                           U. S. ARMY.

  The amount expended on the dams mentioned below to June 30,
1909, is as follows:
Dam   No. 8................ . .... ........ .........                        ............... $743, 527.42
Dam   No. 11...............................................................                            710, 108.56
Dam   No. 13....................................................                                     1,064, 234. 70
Dam   No. 18-..........................................                         ..........             769, 173. 55
Dam   No. 19...........                ......................         ...........         .........     54, 007. 20
Dam   No. 26....................................                 ..................                 . 111, 899. 35
       Total..........         --.........            .    .............           ........      3,452, 950. 78
  The following is a statement of the condition of the works:
  Dam No. 8.-The lock and guide walls are completed. Three
hundred and fifty linear feet of the navigable pass next to the lock
was completed and work on the second section of the pass is well
underway. A contract was entered into for completing the dam, but
no permanent work was placed.
  Dam No. 11.-With the exception of paving the esplanade the
work provided for under contract for building lock and guide walls
was completed. The navigable pass was practically completed
except the removal of the cofferdam. A contract was entered into
for completing the dam and preparations made for beginning work.
  Dam No. 18.-The lock and dam were completed, lock gates
placed, and power house built. Contracts have been entered into
for furnishing and installing the machinery required for operating
the lock and dam.
  Dam No. 18.-The lock and dam were completed and the lock
gates placed. Owing to failure of the contractor the dam was com-
pleted by hired labor. A power house is building under contract.
Contracts have been entered into for furnishing and installing the
machinery required for operating the lock and dam.
  Dam No. 19.-The abutment for the dam was completed and a
contract entered into for constructing 500 feet of navigable pass.
Preparations were made for beginning work on the pass.
  Dam No. 26.-Work at this site is being carried on by hired labor.
The abutment for the dam was completed and preparations made
for constructing lock and dam. The cofferdam for this work is well
underway.
  Conditions for construction work were unusually favorable during
the first half of the fiscal year, although there were times when the
moving of floating plant was interfered with due to extreme low
water.
  Continuing contracts have been authorized for carrying on the
work at Dams Nos. 8, 11, 13, 18, and 26. The total amount of the
authorization for each of Dams Nos. 8 and 11 has been made avail-
able. The balance of the authorization remaining to be appro-
priated is as follows:
Dams Nos. 13 and 18.................. ...................................                              $175, 000
Dam No. 26......................... ....................................                                 555, 000
   The canalization of this section of the river is not far enough
advanced to benefit navigation and therefore has had no effect on
freight rates.
   For commercial statistics, see reports for improving Ohio River and
operating and care of Davis Island Dam.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR                 T
                                                            IMPROVEMENTS.                                      629
  To carry on the work without interruption, funds should be made
available as follows:
  At No. 11 .- For lock keepers' houses, Poiree dams, dredging, etc.
These items can not be provided for from the funds now available.
  At No. 19.-For continuing work on dam and constructing lock
and guide walls.
  At No. 26.-For continuing construction of lock and dam.
                                                 DAM NO.      8.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.. .-.....-..-.....
                                              --.......... --                                           356, 832. 54
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909- ....                                    364, 000. 00
                                                                                                        720, 832. 54
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement.---------........------........................................
                                   ----------------------------                                         252, 514.96
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...---.........       ......------------------------ .                 468, 317. 58
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...-............-         - - - - ----........                          895. 58
July 1, 1909, balance available......_..........--......                          . . ...           .   467, 422. 00
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts---... ----   -...                                  67, 381. 17
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-..---.                                   a 65, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..............................................   a65, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
                                                DAM NO. 11.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended---.....................-------------------------.. $511, 356. 25
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 300, 000. 00

                                                                        year, for works of im-          811, 356. 25
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal
  provement-----..-.........................---------------------------
                                                                     ....................               363, 121. 81
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-...--. .....--...-...- .......                                 .-- .   448, 234.44
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................--                         --
                                                                                -..........                  936. 62
July 1, 1909, balance available ................................                              ...       447, 297. 82
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts...........- ..                                     86, 956. 64
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...-...                                   b 74, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909......................................      ..   b 74,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897.

   a Due to the fact that, since the date of preparing this estimate and submitting the
same to the Secretary of War, favorable bids have been received for certain parts of
this dam, more work can be undertaken with the funds now available, and it is be-
lieved that further appropriation for Dam No. 8 is no longer necessary.
   b Due to the fact that, since the date of preparing this estimate and submitting the
same to the Secretary of War, favorable bids have been received for certain parts of
this dam, more work can be undertaken with the funds now available, and it is be-
lieved that the amount of this estimate for further appropriation for Dam No. 11 may
be reduced to $48,000.
630          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                               DAM NO. 13.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. .................................   $314, 050. 56
Amount transferred from allotment for Dam No. 18...................      6, 000. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909 ......  160, 000. 00
                                                                                            480, 050. 56
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement....    ...........   ...........................                                331, 458.64

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ....................................                      148, 591.92
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.......-.-...........................                    1, 987. 26

July 1, 1909, balance available....................                                ...
                                                                           ..........       146, 604. 66

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts............ ..                          4, 665.70
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                         (a)

                                               DAM NO. 18.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......  ....    ......    ........ ..                     $293, 648. 33
Amount transferred to allotment for Dam No. 13 ......--.-..-..........                        6, 000. 00
                                                                                            287, 648. 33
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......                         60, 000. 00
Amount received from sales................................... .......                         1, 337. 93
                                                                                            348, 986. 26
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement ................ ..--............. ...... ....... ......                        229, 821. 88

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....-...............................                       119, 164. 38
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................ ....................                   2, 998.42

July 1, 1909, balance available ...............                    .....-...............    116, 165. 96

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                        26, 264. 95
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                         (a)
                                               DAM NO.      19.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................                        $206, 128. 68
Amount received from sale ...........................................                            252. 90

                                                                                            206, 381. 58
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement................................ .....................                            35,135. 88

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                       171, 245. 70
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ........................             ...-......            764.08

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                       170,481.62

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .............                         111, 305. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project... ....                      725, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909 .....................................   .............. 400, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897.

  a The balance of the continuing-contract authorization for Locks and Dams Nos.
13 and 18 is $175,000; but it is now expected to complete these works with the funds
available without further appropriations.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                             631
                                                DAM No. 26.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............................................ $326, 025. 93
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 300, 000. 00

                                                                              626, 025. 93
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..................................................................       92,925.28
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................         533, 100. 65
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................       10, 956. 66
July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................           522,143.99

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................          53, 206. 43
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........        555, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for work of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909......... ...................................     ........      300,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
                                               CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................................... $2, 008, 042. 29
Amount received from sales..............................................  1, 590. 83
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.... 1, 184, 000. 00
                                                                            3,193, 633.12
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement.....................   .... .........................           1, 304, 978.45

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................        1, 888, 654. 67
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...............................           18, 538. 62
July 1, 1909, balance available ..................................          1, 870, 116.05

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..............            349, 779. 89
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......       1, 594, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
  30, 1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
  expended July 1, 1909 ........................................             a 839, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
   (See Appendix FF 1.)
  2. Little Kanawha River, West Virginia.-A description of the
original condition of the river and its availability for purposes of
commerce are given in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1875, page 740.
   The original project provided for removing rocks, snags, and over-
hanging and fallen trees above Burning Springs, W. Va., at a cost of
$7,300, as adopted by Congress on August 14, 1876. The act of Con-
gress of June 14, 1880, made provision for the construction of a lock
and dam about 2 miles above Burning Springs. This lock was
opened to navigation on December 2, 1891, and has since been main-
tained under the indefinite appropriation for operating and care of
canals and other works of navigation. Funds are appropriated from
   a Due to the fact that, since the date of preparing this estimate and submitting the
same to the Secretary of War, favorable bids have been received for certain parts
of Dams Nos. 8 and 11, more work can be undertaken with the funds now available,
and it is believed that this estimate of $839,000 may be reduced to $748,000.
632     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

time to time for maintaining the present channel by the removal of
obstructions which have re-formed.
   Congress, in the act of March 3, 1905, provided $75,000 for the pur-
chase and $88,000 for the repair of Locks and Dams Nos. 1-4, owned
by the Little Kanawha Navigation Company, the project for which
is contained in House Document No. 309, Fifty-eighth Congress,
second session, as given in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1904, page 2607.
   Of the $81,000 made available by act of March 2, 1907, $79,500 is
for the improvement of the structures purchased from the Little
Kanawha Navigation Company, as set forth in detail on page 534 of
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906; $1,000 for
maintenance of improvement above Burning Springs; and $500 for
making a preliminary survey for a lock and dam above Lock No. 5.
The survey has been completed.
   An allotment of $30,000 for completing the repairs to Locks Nos.
1 and 3 was made from the amount appropriated by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $405,665.70, of which
$2,554.23 was applied to maintenance, $75,000 to acquisition,
$114,129.13 to repair of Locks and Dams Nos. 1-4, and $500 to survey
above Lock No. 5 ($186.10 was received from sale of unserviceable
property).
   A small force was employed during October, 1908, in removing
obstructions from the channel between Creston and Grantsville, a
distance of 76 miles. Work done under War Department permits
was inspected.
   Repairs to Lock and Dam No. 2 were completed, and the lock at
No. 3 repaired. New guide cribs were built at Locks Nos. 3 and 4,
and a spur dike built at Lock No. 1. Obstructions were removed
from the pools. The land required at Locks Nos. 1 and 4 was pur-
chased, and steps taken to procure that required at Locks Nos. 2
and 3.
   The maximum draft which can be carried at mean low water over
the shoalest place in that section of the river under maintenance
of improvement is 6 inches. During high water steamboats run to
Glenville, 102 miles from the mouth. The head of gasoline-boat and
push-boat navigation is Burnsville, 120 miles from the mouth; rafting,
however, extends some miles above.
   Slack-water navigation extends from the mouth of the river to
Creston, W. Va., a distance of 48 miles, and provides a depth of 4
feet. Owing to the poor condition of the structures purchased from
the Little Kanawha Navigation Company, this depth has not been
maintained during the low-water season, as the repairs provided for
have not been completed.
   Between Creston and Burnsville the high-water mark ranges from
28 feet at Creston to 24 feet at Burnsville. During very dry seasons
there are only a few inches of water on the shoals. The highest stage
reached during the year was 25.45 feet at Lock No. 5.
   A statement of the commerce is contained in the report for operat-
ing and care of locks and dams on Little Kanawha River, West
Virginia. (See p. 634 of this report.)
   Gasoline boats which formerly plied above Lock No. 5 are now
running to Parkersburg. Some new gasoline boats have been built.
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                            633
   Until the extensive repairs contemplated at Locks and Dams Nos. 1
and 3 are completed, river navigation will not have a decided effect
on freight rates by rail. The rates by river were reduced in an amount
equal to the tolls charged by the navigation company since the Gov-
ernment assumed control of Locks Nos. 1-4.
   It is estimated that $500 can be profitably expended during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, for maintaining the channel above
Burning Springs, W. Va., by removing obstructions which re-form
from time to time.
   Reports on an examination of the river between Lock No. 5 and
Burnsville and on the locks and dams "not owned by the Govern-
ment" are contained in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1904, pages 2597 to 2617.
   Report on survey for a lock and dam above the location of existing
Lock No. 5, required by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907,
is printed in House Document No. 917, Sixtieth Congress, first session.
   The river arrnd harbor act of March 3, 1909, provides for an exami-
nation of the "Little Kanawha River with a view to the modification
of the existing system of locks and dams and its further improve-
ment," and report thereon will be submitted to Congress at its next
session.
                                   ABOVE    LOCK NO.         5.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................................                   $1, 208. 66
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .................................. ...................                         641.13

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..........            ...........           ...........      567. 53
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.....         ..................................                       500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                     PURCHASE     AND   REPAIR   OF LOCKS NOS.             1-4.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................................                   $7, 951. 10
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ...............................  ................                         30,000. 00
                                                                                          37, 951. 10
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment................ ....... .......   ............. ...................                 7, 878. 87
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended--..................          .................           30, 072. 23
July 1, 1909, outstanding hliabilities.................. ....... ...........                  727.43

July 1, 1909, balance available     ......... .....                       ........
                                                                     .......              29, 344. 80

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..............                        4, 643.02

                            BETTERMENTS,      LOCKS NOS.            1-4.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......         ..........................       $65, 738. 28
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
                   -..
    ment--...................-    ...... .........         ..........-..........  12, 439. 64
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended----....---...........................                    53, 298. 64
July 1, 1909, outstanding habilities.....................................                    160. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available.......................................                    53,138. 64
634        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                       S. ARMY.

                                      CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................... $74, 898. 04
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ..........................................               30, 000. 00
                                                                                   104, 898. 04
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.......--......................         $20, 318. 51
    For maintenance of improvement ......................                641. 13
                                                                                    20, 959. 64
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.--....................................            83, 938. 40
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................              887. 43

July 1, 1909, balance available..... .........................................     83, 050.97

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..............                 4, 643.02

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909............         ......................                       500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix F F 2.)
   3. Operating and care of locks and dams on Little Kanawha River,
West Virginia.-The lock and dam known as "No. 5" was built
under the appropriation for improving the Little Kanawha River,
West Virginia, being a part of the original project as given in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1875, page 740.
   Locks and Dams Nos. 1-4 were purchased from the Little Kanawha
Navigation Company and transferred to the Government on Novem-
ber 1, 1905.
   The five locks and dams provide slack-water navigation for a
distance of 48 miles from the mouth.
   The total amount expended in operating and care of these works
to June 30, 1909, is $72,636.39, of which $10,338.43 was expended
during the past fiscal year.
   A table of the important features, giving location, year when fin-
ished, etc., of the locks and dams, is contained in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1903, page 1720.
   Navigation was suspended through Lock No. 3 seventy-five days
on account of repairs, and sixty days on account of low water. At
Lock No. 5 navigation was suspended ninety-seven days, seventy-
four days of which were due to low water.
   The repairs to Locks Nos. 1 and 3 are provided for under improv-
ing Little Kanawha River, West Virginia. Those to Lock and Dam
No. 2 were completed, and its operation and care is therefore a charge
under the indefinite appropriation. Repairs were made to the lower
step of Dam No. 4 and to gate valves and dam of Lock No. 5.
   With the exception of the dam and guide cribs at Lock No. 5,
Locks and Dams Nos. 2, 4, and 5 are in good condition. The dam
and guide cribs at No. 5 require rebuilding. However, it is not
thought that this work will be necessary during the coming fiscal
year.
   During the calendar year 1908 the commerce that passed Lock
No. 5 amounted to 49,707 tons, of which 42,172 tons consisted of
timber products (saw logs, ties, etc.) and 76 tons of coal.
   (See Appendix F F 3.)
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          635
   4. Kanawha River, West Virginia.-A description of the condition
of the river, the projects, and the general work accomplished (the
locks and dams being in operation) are contained in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 490.
   The amount expended under the original project is $50,000; that
expended under the present project to June 30, 1909, is $4,181,501.89
($2,949.15 was received from sales, etc.).
   Plans are nearly completed for guide walls for upper approaches
to Locks Nos. 4 to 11, and considerable progress made on plans for
snag boat and quarter boat for use on this river. Work under this
appropriation was suspended, however, due to the provisions con-
tained in-section 10 of the sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909,
and no other work was undertaken during the year, although under
authority of joint resolution approved June 25, 1909, the balance
of this appropriation was again made available.
   For reasons stated in the appendix the district officer recommends
the reconstruction of the ice pier at the mouth of the river at an
estimated cost of $24,000.
   The maximum draft that can be carried at the shoalest part of
the slack-water system at mean low water is 6 feet. The highest
stage reached during the year was 16 feet at Charleston; the lowest
0.3 foot at the falls. Loup Creek shoal, about 90 miles from the
mouth of the river, is the head of navigation for steamboats and
other craft.
   For commercial statistics, see report for operating and care of
locks and dams on Kanawha River, West Virginia (below).
   The improvement of this river having been gradual, it is difficult
to give the exact effect the improvement has had upon freight rates.
There is no doubt, however, that freight rates, where transporta-
tion by water is available, are regulated thereby. A reduction in
the passenger rate by railroads has materially decreased the num-
ber of passengers traveling on the Kanawha River packets.
   A report of the examination of the unimproved section of the river,
about 4 miles between Lock No. 2 and Kanawha Falls, is contained
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 2587.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..-------------.....---......--.......-------------.............              $46, 583. 98
Amount received from sale .......-..........                        -     ....... ....         ........             58. 40
                                                                                                               46, 642. 38
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment--------........----------......                                          ..-... .............-------
                                       -........-----..-....----.... --. ----............                       3, 331. 98

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-...-............-.--                                .....      .......        43, 310. 40
   (See Appendix F F 4.)
  6. Operating and care of locks and dams on Kanawha River, West
Virgimna.-Under the projects for improving the Kanawha River,
ten locks and dams were built, two fixed dams and eight movable
(Chanoine type), extending slack-water navigation for a distance
of 90 miles from the Ohio River. The maintenance of these works
is provided for by the indefinite appropriation for operating and
care of canals and other works of navigation.
   The location of each lock and dam and the year in which com-
pleted are given in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1899, page 428.
636     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

   A table of important features, giving available lengths and widths
of locks, lengths of passes, etc., is contained in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1903, page 1724.
   The total amount expended in operating and care of these works
to June 30, 1909, is $975,698.94, of which $100,915.32 was expended
during the past year.
   Navigation was practically continuous throughout the year,
except at Lock No. 3, where it was suspended eight hours by high
water, and at Locks Nos. 4 and 5, where it was suspended thirteen
and fifteen days, respectively, on account of repairs.
   The repairs made during the fiscal year 1909 to keep the struc-
tures in good condition were more extensive than for any previous
year. This is due to the number of years the locks and dams have
been in service, part of the system having been completed in 1880.
   The commerce for the calendar year 1908 amounted to 1,035,401
tons, with a valuation of $4,243,619. Of the foregoing there were
965,000 tons of coal and 38,274 tons of timber products, valued at
$820,250 and $165,260, respectively.
   (See Appendix F F 5.)
IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE SECOND CINCIN-
                  NATI, OHIO, DISTRICT.

    This district was in the charge of Lieut. Col. J. G. Warren, Corps
of Engineers, having under his immediate orders to August 28, 1908,
First Lieut. Arthur Williams, Corps of Engineers. Division engineer,
Col. Wm. T. Rossell, Corps of Engineers.
    1. Muskingum River, Ohio.-The original condition of the water-
way and its availability for purposes of commerce are given in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, Part 1, page 488.
For more extended information reference is also made to the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, Part 1, page 477.
    The original project, adopted August 11, 1888, provided for the
construction of a lock at Dam No. 9, Taylorsville, Ohio, and the
reconstruction of Lock No. 10, Zanesville, Ohio. The repair and
extension of the levee above Dam No. 10, Zanesville, Ohio, was
added by the act of July 1, 1898. Raising the crest of Dam No. 9
and building four lock houses was added by the act of June 13, 1902.
    With the exception of the reconstruction of a lock at Zanesville-
which was indefinitely postponed and the money originally appro-
priated for it diverted to other purposes-all of this work has been
completed. The amount expended prior to operations under exist-
ing project is $137,339.45.
    The existing project, adopted March 3, 1905, provides for the rais-
ing of the crest of Dam No. 3; building a lock master's dwelling at
Lock No. 10, and rebuilding Lock and Dam No. 11. The first two
items have been completed, and Lock and Dam No. 11 was partially
constructed under contract.
    The amount expended under existing project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is $114,915.65.
    The miter-sill depth at pool level is the controlling mean low-water
depth of the system; this is 6 feet at Locks Nos. 1 to 10 and 7 feet
and 9 feet, respectively, for the lower and upper sills at Lock No. 11.
                              RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     637
   The present head of slack-water navigation is 84 miles above the
mouth of the river. The pool to be formed by the construction of
Dam No. 11 will extend the navigable head about 7 miles. At ordi-
nary high stages the stream is navigable for light draft boats to its
head, at Coshocton, Ohio, 107 miles above its mouth at Marietta,
Ohio.
   The usual variation in the level of water surface is 38 feet at Lock
No. 1 and 24 feet at Lock No. 10.
   The commercial statistics are reported under the head of operating
and care of locks and dams on Muskingum River (see below).
   It is believed that this improvement has had no material effect on
freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-----.....------...-------...........---------..............---- $136, 128. 54
Received from sales---.....--------.....................................-------------------------------------. 54. 45

                                                                                                                136, 182. 99
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for works of improve-
  ment--.......------------------......                                                                   ...
                                                                  .........--------------........... -------
                                        --.. --.........----------........                                       83,521.41

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended................---------------------------------                                52, 661. 58
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...----------------------------------                                           161. 96

July 1, 1909, balance available........--------------------.......---------...-----.                             52, 499. 62

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts-................                                           38, 131. 00
   (See Appendix G G 1.)
   2. Operating and care of locks and dams on Muskingum River,
Ohio.-The original condition and scope of this improvement is de-
scribed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1901,
Part 1, pages 485 and 486. For more extended information refer-
ence is also made to the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1904, Part 1, page 478.
   Under allotments from the indefinite appropriation for operating
and care of canals and other works of navigation there had been
expended up to June 30, 1909, a total sum of $1,818,650.29, and an
additional sum of $17,190.44 in building a protection wall at Zanes-
ville and altering certain bridges at Taylorsville and Marietta, Ohio.
The amount expended during the year ending June 30, 1909, was
$52,858.39.
   The principal work has been dredging bars and channels; making
repairs to locks and dams and their appurtenances, lock houses and
grounds, and floating plant; rebuilt, in timber, above pool level,
both leaves of the upper gates at Lock No. 1; replaced the wooden
guide crib below the land wall of lock, 30.5 feet in length, with a
reenforced concrete retaining wall; replaced guard crib below the
river wall, 25 feet in length, with concrete wall, and repaired lower
apron and crest of dam at Lock No. 2; replaced guide piling below
the land wall of lock; reconstructed, with reenforced concrete, timber
guard crib below the river wall of lock; reconstructed, in concrete,
the wooden storehouse and waiting room at Lock No. 3; resheeted
the lower apron of dam over 23 feet of its length; repaired and com-
pleted the plumbing in lock master's dwelling, and replaced flood-
damaged woodwork of the exterior and interior of dwelling at Lock
No. 4; replaced timber guide crib 61 feet in length, below the land
638     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

wall of lock, with a reenforced concrete retaining wall; resheeted 61
feet of the crest, 5 feet of the slope, and 20 feet of the lower apron
of dam at Lock No. 5; repaired discharge valve in land wall of lock;
restored elevation of dam by raising crest from 2 to 14 inches over
100 feet of its length at Lock No. 6; reconstructed, in concrete, con-
duit, and completed about 85 per cent of the repairs to the left bank
of the canal at Lock No. 7; repaired discharge valve in river wall of
lock; restored, with rubblestone, the embankment at lower end of
terreplein of lock at Lock No. 8; repaired and restored canal em-
bankment at Lock No. 9; extended, with reenforced concrete, the
revetment of canal bank above the land wall of lock about 100 feet;
reconstructed, with reenforced concrete, the revetment of the right
bank of canal at Lock No. 10; the tentative harbor lines established
at Zanesville, Ohio, were approved by the Secretary of War under
date of June 25, 1909.
   The total commerce for the calendar year 1908 was approximately
54,000 tons, valued at $1,900,000, and 44,000 passengers.
   (See Appendix G G 2.)
   3. Big Sandy River and Levisa and Tug Forks, West Virginia and
Kentucky.-For more extended information concerning the early
history of this improvement, reference is made to the following
Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers: For the year 1875, pages
756-769; for the year 1904, Part 1, page 479, and for the year 1905,
Part 1, pages 488-489.
   In their original condition this river and its forks were much
obstructed by rocks, bars, snags, and leaning trees. During the
low-water period of each year navigation was practically suspended.
   The original project was adopted July 18, 1878, and provided for
the removal of rocks, snags, and overhanging trees from the Big
Sandy River and its forks. The construction of a lock and fixed
dam below the junction of the two forks and near Louisa, Ky., was
added by the act of June 14, 1880, and in 1891 was modified to admit
of the construction of a movable instead of a fixed dam.
   The work of clearing the forks of obstructions is carried on from
year to year as funds are made available.
   The amount expended on original and modified projects prior to
operations under existing project, exclusive of maintenance on
Levisa and Tug Forks, was $380,590.66.
   The existing project, adopted March 3, 1899, contemplates carry-
ing slack water from the Ohio River to Pikeville, on Levisa Fork,
and to the mouth of Pond Creek, on Tug Fork, by the construction
of 21 locks and dams, at an estimated cost of $4,725,000. Of these
locks and dams 10 are proposed for the Levisa Fork, 8 for Tug Fork,
and 3 for the main river. The survey made for this improvement
developed the fact that only 2 locks and dams would be required
for the main river.
   The raising of the crest of Dam No. 3, at Louisa, Ky., was added
by the act of June 13, 1902, at an estimated cost of $35,000.
   The improvement at the mouth of the Big Sandy River by the
construction of regulating works was added by the act of March 3,
1905, at a cost of $40,000.
   The construction of a steel service bridge at Lock No.. 1, Big Sandy
River, was added by the act of March 2, 1907, at a cost of $7,000.
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                           639
  The amount expended on the work of the existing project up to
the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was as follows:
Big Sandy River, general improvement, including maintenance........ $955, 502. 44
Levisa Fork, maintenance............ ...... .... ....... ..........   32, 192. 41
Tug Fork, maintenance..... ... ....... ...... ............ .......... 31, 284. 06
   And at that date all work of this project applicable to the main
river, Catlettsburg to Louisa, was completed, with the exception of
the steel service bridge at Lock No. 1, which has been deferred for
reasons set forth on page 606 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1908.
   Lock No. 1, Tug, and Lock No. 1, Levisa, fork, have been com-
pleted, and Dam No. 1, Tug Fork, under contract dated July 22,
1908, and Dam No. 1, Levisa Fork, dated July 29, 1908, were partially
completed.
   With the exception of the service bridge at Lock No. 1, which is
provided for by a specific appropriation, the work is being carried on
under the continuing-contract system, and the balance of the authori-
zation remaining to be appropriated is $25,000. This amount, in
addition to the unexpended balance on June 30, 1909, can be profit-
ably expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in the exten-
sion of benefits by the construction, and partial completion of the
accessories, of Dam No. 1, Tug Fork, and Dam No. 1, Levisa Fork.
   In connection with the work under contract for constructing Dam
No. 1, Tug Fork, and that covered by contract for constructing
Dam No. 1, Levisa Fork, unforeseen conditions have presented them-
selves which will materially increase the cost of completing these
works. Quicksand has been encountered, which will greatly increase
the amount of excavation and deposit and, in addition to the authori-
zation of $25,000 contained in the river and harbor act of March 3,
1909, an additional appropriation of $25,000 is recommended, that
amount being considered necessary to complete the work as originally
contemplated and to provide a maneuvering boat at each lock,
estimated to cost $5,000 each.
   An additional appropriation of $3,000 is recommended for the
construction of a steel service bridge at Lock No. 1, Big Sandy River,
the appropriation of $7,000 contained in river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, being deemed insufficient for reasons explained on
page 606, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
   For reasons stated in the appendix to this report, the district
officer considers a small dredging plant necessary for the operation
and maintenance of this improvement, and estimates the cost of
same at $20,000. It is recommended that funds be appropriated
for the construction of this plant.
   Three locks and dams on the Big Sandy River have been com-
pleted and opened to navigation. They provide a minimum depth
of 6 feet on their lower miter sills, except at Lock No. 1, Catletts-
burg, Ky., where the depth on the lower miter sill depends upon
the stage in the Ohio River, and is uncertain and will remain so
until a dam is placed in the Ohio River immediately below Catletts-
burg.

  The minimum draft that can be carried over the shoalest portions
of the forks at mean low water is uncertain and changeable, and
can not be definitely stated owing to the constant movement of the
640         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

bottom and the fact that the obstructions naturally renew them-
selves.
  It is deemed advisable that provision should be made for the
necessary surveys to locate sites and for acquisition of land required
for additional locks and dams, to be constructed under the adopted
project, in order to avoid delays incident to such work after appro-
priations for actual construction have been made.
  Commercial statistics are reported under the head of operating
and care of locks and dams on Big Sandy River, West Virginia and
Kentucky (see below).
  The Big Sandy River is navigable by steamer from Catlettsburg,
the mouth of the river, up to Louisa, Ky., a distance of 27 miles,
and from there to Chapman, Ky., on Levisa Fork, a distance of 9
miles, and to Saltpetre, W. Va., on Tug Fork, a distance of 4 miles.
For pole boats, rafts, etc., the head of present navigation is taken at
Pond Creek on Tug Fork and at Pikeville on Levisa Fork.
  It is believed that the work thus far accomplished on this improve-
ment has had no material effect on freight rates.
   Reference to report on examination made in compliance with act
of March 2, 1907, will be found on page 612, Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..............                ....................         $271, 583. 26
Received from sales....----...----.............................................                    25. 50
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
                         -
  March 3, 1909.............     ...........        .......................                   50, 000.00
                                                                                             321, 608. 76
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement......-....-..........-                      .. $172, 096. 64
    For maintenance of improvement. ..................                            245. 27
                                                                                             172, 341. 91

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...-.......................                      ......     149, 266. 85
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. .........-......           ..........    ........       1, 427.75
July 1, 1909, balance available....-.........           .......---...........                147, 839. 10

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..--.........                           119, 473. 66
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... .3,                    705, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909......                  .......
                                  ............--      ..... .............                   a 28, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897.
    (See Appendix G G 3.)
   4. Operating and care of locks and dams on the Big Sandy River,
West Virginia and Kentucky.-For more extended information ref-
erence is made to the following Annual Reports of the Chief of Engi-
neers: For the year 1904, Part 1, page 481, and for the year 1905,
Part 1, page 490.
   Under the allotments from the indefinite appropriation for opera-
ting and care of canals and other works of navigation there has been
  a Of this amount, $25,000 is for continuing contract work authorized by the river
and harbor act of March 3, 1909, and $3,000 for completing steel service bridge at
Lock No. 1, Big Sandy River.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR    IMPROVEMENTS.               641
expended up to June 30, 1909, a total sum of $123,889.94. The
amount expended during the year ending June 30, 1909, was
$42,152.51.
   The principal work has been clearing the channels and lock ap-
proaches of snags and other obstructions; making repairs to locks,
lock gates, operating machinery, dams, lock houses, and floating
plant; installed butterfly valves in upper lock gates; sodded slope
back of land wall of lock at Lock No. 1; constructed one new lock
house at Lock No. 2; completed the following works, which were
undertaken last year: Constructed bank protection below abutment;
constructed new steel lock gates and new storehouse at Lock No. 3.
The following new plant was purchased: One gasoline launch; 1
pump for use in cleaning deposits from lock walls, etc.; 1 push boat;
and machinery for equipping new machine shop at Lock No. 3.
   The total commerce for the year 1908 was approximately 111,168
tons, valued at $762,714.88, and 447 passengers.
   (See Appendix G G 4.)
   5. Kentucky River, Kentuckcy.-For more extended information,
reference is made to the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
the year 1906, Part 1, pages 541 and 542. At the time the United
States assumed control of the Kentucky River the improvement that
had been made by the State of Kentucky, which included five locks
and fixed dams, was found to be in a dilapidated and almost worth-
less condition. Portions of Dams Nos. 1 and 2 on the lower part of
the stream were gone entirely, so that navigation was suspended.
   The original and existing project was adopted in 1879 (Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, pp. 1398-1422) and pro-
vides for repairing and rebuilding the five old locks and dams, remov-
ing snags, logs, and other obstructions, and extending 6-foot slack-
water navigation from the mouth of the river to the Three Forks, a
distance of about 261 miles.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $3,094,100.81.
   The result of this expenditure was the repair and the rebuilding
of five old locks and dams constructed by the State; the construction
of Locks and Dams Nos. 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, and 11; the purchase of sites
for these and for Locks and Dams Nos. 12, 13, and 14, and the partial
construction of Locks and Dams Nos. 12 and 13; construction of dam
at Beattyville, Ky., and survey to determine the amount of damage
by flowage to private property by reason of the construction of these
works.
   This work is being carried on under the continuing-contract system
and the total amount authorized for this improvement has been
appropriated.
   The present unexpended balance will become exhausted with the
completion of Lock No. 13, with the exception of a possible balance
of $50,000; in addition thereto an appropriation of $165,000 will be
necessary for the construction of the dam and abutment.
   The estimated cost of Lock and Dam No. 14 is $415,650, not pro-
vided for in any existing legislation.
   The construction of Locks and Dams Nos. 9 and 10 has caused
damages to the highways of Madison County by backwater in Tates
Creek and Otter creek. Tates Creek enters the Kentucky River
     9001-ENG 1909-41
642     REPORT   OF THE CHIEF     OF ENGINEERS,   U.   S. ARMY.

about one-half mile above Lock 9. There is a county road crossing
this creek a few hundred feet above the mouth, which is the principal
outlet for a large number of residents dwelling on the left-hand side
going up this creek. Since the construction of Dam No. 9 this cross-
ing has been rendered useless. In order to restore the crossing, a
bridge will have to be constructed. From estimates already ob-
tained it is thought that a suitable bridge can be built for approxi-
mately $3,500, and an appropriation of this amount is therefore rec-
ommended. Otter Creek is situated one-half mile below Ford, Ky.,
and one-half mile above Dam No. 10. Since the construction of this
dam the county road running along this creek has been rendered im-
passable. This road meets the Richmond and Boonesboro (Ky.)
turnpike and is the principal outlet for a large number of families
scattered along this creek. For the purpose of restoring this road to
public traffic an appropriation of $2,500 is recommended. This work
constitutes an item of contingent expense that was not foreseen when
the estimate of cost of constructing these locks and dams was pre-
pared, and an appropriation of $6,000 to cover the cost of the addi-
tional work indicated is a proper charge to this improvement and
should be provided in addition to sums heretofore authorized.
   The greatest draft which can be carried at mean low water from
Lock No. 1 to a point 2 miles above Irvine, Ky. (a distance of 220
miles), which is at present the head of slack-water navigation, is
5.5 feet. Above this point no boats can run at a low stage.
   Ordinary low-water depth through Lock No. 1 and to the Ohio
River, 4 miles below, is 6 feet or more, but at extreme low water
only about 21 feet can be carried over the lower sill of Lock No. 1.
The usual variations of level of water surface are from 23 to 40 feet
and occasionally much more.
   The old locks, Nos. 1 to 5, inclusive, built by the State, have 145
feet available length and 38 feet width. The new locks, from No. 6
up, have available lengths of from 146 to 148 feet and are 52 feet in
width.
   The principal commerce of the river is timber, much of it loose logs,
and the improvement is rather detrimental to this than otherwise.
The logs are damaged in passing the dams, and in their turn cause
much damage to the works-are a prolific source of snags and of
discouragement to any steamboat traffic that might develop.
   Commercial statistics in detail are given in the report for operating
and care of locks and dams on Kentucky River (see Appendix G G 6).
   The unexpended balance and appropriation recommended will be
applied to construction of Locks and Dams Nos. 12 and 13 for exten-
sion of benefits.
   There are not likely to be any decided changes in the volume or
character of the commerce benefited until the improvement is carried
to the head of the river, where it is hoped that coal lands may be de-
veloped and the product shipped by river. The development of
coal lands, with the resulting traffic, is the specific purpose to which
the expenditure will be applied. It is believed that the project has
so fax had no material effect on freight rates.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                          643
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended -.......    ... .. ................ $544, 881.44
Received from sales--...----------------------------------------------      168. 00
Amount appropriated for sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909_......
                                                                  _    210, 000.00
                                                                                                                755, 049.44
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement -------------....--.--.....------......-------..........------------.......----.....------.......   166, 660.97
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended--......................-------------------------------. 588, 388. 47
                                                    - ..
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities-...-. ...-.-...--        ........-......                910. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available--------...---................-------------..........
                                                                  --------------                                587, 478. 47
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................ 496, 152. 33
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing projcet .....--....
                                                                       655, 650. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
                                                                       165, 000.00
   July 1,1909..----------...............-------------------..............---
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
   (See Appendix G G 5.)
   6. Operating and care of locks and dams on Kentucky River, Ken-
tucky.-At the time the United States acquired possession of the five
locks and dams on this stream, in 1880, navigation, then extending
for a distance of 87 miles upstream, was practically suspended on
account of deterioration of the works. These five locks and dams
were built by the State of Kentucky in 1836-1839, and from 1880 to
1885 were extensively repaired by the United States under appro-
priations for improving Kentucky River, Kentucky. Since then
extensive repairs have been made under the indefinite appropriation
of 1884 for operating. and care of canals, etc., and Locks and Dams
Nos. 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, and 11 have been constructed. Additional infor-
mation will be found in the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers
for 1906, Part 1, page 543, and for 1907, Part 1, pages 568-569.
   Under allotments from the indefinite appropriation for operating
and care of canals and other works of navigation there has been
expended up to June 30, 1909, a total sum of $1,771,957.14. The
amount expended during the year ending June 30, 1909, was
$135,750.95.
   The principal work has been dredging bars and channels; making
repairs to locks, lock gates, operating machinery, dams, lock houses,
and floating plant; constructing, inconcrete, 255 feet of crest of dam,
raising the height of dam 1 foot; constructing timber grillage be-
tween piers near lock entrance; reconstructing 150 linear feet of
apron at toe of dam at Lock No. 1; replacing decayed timber and
washed out riprap stone in upper guide crib; rebuilding, in timber,
upper abutment crib at Lock No. 2; reconstructing, in concrete, 220
linear feet of downstream face of dam; rebuilding, in concrete, upper
abutment crib at Lock No. 3; renewing worn-out and torn-off sheeting
of dam, and repairing derrick at coal tipple; removing lower river
crib preparatory to reconstructing same; commencing the reconstruc-
tion of dam at Lock No.4; replacing worn-out and torn-off sheeting
of dam at Lock No. 5; constructing 1,650 feet wire fence around
grounds and repairing gates at Lock No. 6; reconstructing in con-
crete, lower river crib; rebuilding upper guide pier and repairing
644     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.


valves at Lock No. 7; reconstructing, in concrete, lower river crib;
placing derrick stone at toe of dam at Lock No. 8; placing backing
behind new dam at Lock No. 9; protecting abutment from scour
at Lock No. 10; constructing, under contract, one additional dwelling
at Lock No. 11; under contract dated September 25, 1908, the new
towboat (with snagging appliances) Kentucky was constructed and
placed in commission June 3, 1909; this contract involved the pur-
chase of the U. S. steamer General O. M. Poe for the sum of $1,000;
an additional towboat was placed under contract under date of April
1,1909; extensive repairs were made to dredge No. 1, derrick boat No.
2, and three barges under an emergency contract; U. S. dredge No. 2
(old) was sold, under date of November 18, 1908, for the sum of
$750, and new dredge, No. 2, was completed under contract for the
machinery only, the hull being built by the United States. The
following new plant was purchased: One No. 4 Gates crusher; one
35-horsepower boiler, and one Emerson steam pump.
   The total commerce for the year 1908 was approximately 318,565
tons, valued at $5,001,470, and 11,546 passengers.
   (See Appendix G G 6.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE LOUISVILLE, KEN-
                     TUCKY, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Capt. Harry Burgess, Corps of
Engineers, to September 3, 1908; of Capt. Lytle Brown, Corps of En-
gineers, from September 3, 1908, to April 27, 1908; and temporarily
in the charge of Lieut. Col. J. G. Warren, Corps of Engineers, since
the latter date. Division engineer, Col. Win. T. Rossell, Corps of
Engineers.
   1. Falls of the Ohio River at Louisville, Ky.-Improvements under
this title have included the enlargement of the basin immediately
above the locks of the Louisville and Portland Canal, the enlargement
of the head of the canal, and straightening, deepening, and controlling
the water flow in the Indiana Chute channel.
   The work of enlarging the basin above the canal rocks was com-
pleted in 1893.
   The original conditions at the other localities are more conveniently
and fully described under separate headings, as follows:
   Head of Louisville and Portland Canal.--Previous to 1883 the ap-
proach to the canal at its upper end, above the Louisville Bridge
Company's bridge at Fourteenth street, was so narrow as to consti-
tute a source of much expensive delay to the large quantity of traffic
which came down the river on ordinary rises. The canal proper from
Ninth to Fourteenth streets was only 100 feet wide and curved be-
tween the two points, so that progress was slow and accidents frequent
and unavoidable. The greater part of the dike marking the north
side of the approach to the canal was submerged when the river
reached a stage of 8.4 feet, upper canal gauge, and at stages of 9 feet
or more a strong current set out from the shore, thus carrying many
vessels against the dike and, at high enough stages, over it onto the
rock ledges. This approach was 1,800 feet long and varied in width
from 400 feet at the upper end to 100 feet opposite Ninth street. Its
area was wholly insufficient for the required breaking and rearrange-
ment of tows preparatory to entering or leaving the canal.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                    645
   Indiana Chute.-This is the main channel of the river by which
commerce passes over the falls when the stage of water is such as to
permit navigation via that route. Originally it was very crooked,
with swift currents and whirls, filled with dangerous rocky points
projecting from the sides and bottom, and it could be navigated only
at stages of 11 feet or more, upper canal gauge. Even at such stages
the services of special skilled pilots of long local experience and hav-
ing intimate knowledge of the channel conditions were essential for
reasonably safe passage through it.
   Projects.-The original project for the enlargement of the head of
the Louisville and Portland Canal was adopted in 1883 and proposed
the enlargement of the canal, beginning at a point a short distance
below the railroad bridge at Fourteenth street and extending east-
wardly to the cross dam, so as to not only straighten and widen the
canal proper, but also provide ample space for the necessary rear-
rangement of tows about to enter or leave the canal. This was
slightly modified in 1885, so far as the location of the new north wall
was concerned. A revision of the project was made by a Board of
Engineer officers January 28, 1890, and approved by the Chief of
Engineers January 31, 1890. This revision modified the area for-
merly proposed to be excavated and determined the number and
kinds of structures, etc., to be erected. As approved, it provided for
enlarging the canal on its northerly side from a point 725 feet below
the railroad bridge at Fourteenth street, where the width.of the canal
was abruptly increased from 90 feet to 210 feet. This latter width is
then gradually increased through a distance of nearly 2,800 feet to 325
feet at the head of the canal proper, at which point the enlargement
is expanded into a capacious basin or harbor 1,200 feet wide and
practically parallel to the Kentucky shore. The structures proposed
were a new retaining wall on the north side of the canal, a movable
dam about 800 feet long, a fixed dam extending from the movable
dam at the westerly end of the basin to the south abutment of the
movable dam in the Middle Chute opening of the cross dam, the exca-
vation of rock within designated limits to the same grade as the canal
bottom, the construction of certain walls and slope revetment on the
south side of the canal, and the removal of the old structures within
the limits of the proposed enlargement. Under date of March 31,
1899, a further modification of some of the details of the project was
considered by a Board of Engineer officers and their recommenda-
tions approved by the Chief of Engineers April 8, 1899. These later
modifications, together with the work outlined in the report ap-
proved January 31, 1890, constitute the existing project toward the
completion of which operations are now directed. The totals of
estimates under the original project and the several revisions are as
follows:
Project of 1883, page 1539, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
  for 1883............................................................... $1, 335,   363. 00
Revision approved January 31, 1890, page 2217, Annual Report of the
  Chief of Engineers for 1890 ......................................          710,   230. 40
Modification approved April 8, 1899, page 2545, Annual Report of the
  Chief of Engineers for 1899..............................................300,      391. 92
A revision of the latter estimate was made November 13, 1900, ap-
  proved by the Chief of Engineers November 17, 1900, and amounted
  to ...............................................................          398,   359. 12
646            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                         U.   S. ARMY.

   The foregoing relates particularly to the improvements at the
head of the Louisville and Portland Canal.
   Prior to January 31, 1890, there was no specific comprehensive
project for the systematic improvement of the Indiana Chute channel,
although much work, consisting of the removal of some of the more
dangerous rock ledges, had been done under estimates and allotments
from appropriations for improving Ohio River. On the date just
mentioned the project submitted by a Board of Engineer officers for
the radical improvement of this chute was approved by the Chief of
Engineers. This project had for its object the widening and deepen-
ing of the channel by rock excavation to specified grades within cer-
tain limits and the control of water flow in the channel by means of
dikes, etc., so as to make this channel available for descending navi-
gation drawing 6 feet at stages of 8 feet, upper canal gauge. How-
ever, only a part of the work necessary for the purpose in view was
included in the estimate accompanying the report of the Board, it
being stated:
  As the exact knowledge of the results of that work [i. e., the work estimated for
in the Board's report] would be of great importance in fixing the details of location
and cross section of the additional works that will be required, it would be as well
to leave the determination of the additional work above the bridge to a later day.
   The estimates for work on this chute since the adoption of a spe-
cific project therefor are as follows:
Project approved January 31, 1890.........-..... ......                                           .$138, 610. 97
                                                                                    ...............
Modification approved April 8, 1899 ...........                        .................     ....      74, 320. 98
Revision of estimate approved by the Chief of Engineers November 17,
  1900---------------........--------------.....................------------------...---
                                                                                    ....--.....       129, 651. 99
  A consolidation of the projects for the enlargement at the head of
the canal and the improvement of the Indiana Chute was authorized
by the Chief of Engineers June 28, 1897, and since that date funds
have been provided for work at both localities under one title of
appropriation.
  Work under that part of the project relating to the Indiana Chute
having been completed, a Board of Engineer officers was assembled to
determine, as anticipated in the project of 1890, what further work
was essential to provide the requisite depth necessary to facilitate the
passage of traffic through this channel. The report of the Board was
submitted December 16, 1901, and approved by the Chief of Engi-
neers December 30, 1901. The items of additional work found to be
necessary to produce the desired result and the estimated cost thereof
are as follows:
Submerged dam at Whirlpool Point (large stone), 2,500 cubic yards, at $3... $7, 500
Raising movable dam north of canal wall ..................................               2, 500
Removing old dam and building movable dam, 1,000 feet, at $75............ 75, 000
Longitudinal contracting dikes (concrete), 22,300 cubic yards, at $12 .......          267, 600
Submerged dams below bridge (concrete), 3,000 cubic yards, at 20........ 60, 000
Rock excavation, 3,200 cubic yards, at $3.50.............................               11, 200
Contingencies, 1.0 per cent . . .......................           ....................  42, 380

         Total ...................          ..........      ..........................              ....   466,180
                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               647

   For this latter work the Board prescribed the order in which it
should be done, and stated that it was possible that a part of the work
might become unnecessary if certain results were produced by the
submerged dam at Whirlpool Point, and in that event about $125,000
would probably be saved from the estimated cost.
   Subsequently, in House Document No. 492, Sixtieth Congress,
first session, the Ohio River Board recommended the omission of all
of the foregoing items, except that for removing the old dam and
building a movable dam at the head of the falls, and in lieu of such
omitted items proposed the following to increase the facilities for
passing the falls:
   (1) To widen the narrow portion of the canal to 170 feet, thus permitting the pas-
sage of a down-bound tow of loaded coal boats and an up-bound tow of empty coal
boats, each tow 3 abreast; (2) to construct a new single-lift concrete lock south of and
by the side of the present lock, available dimensions of the chamber to be 85 feet by
600 feet, thus permitting the passage at one lockage of 9 coal boats, or 12 coal barges;
(3) to create a pool above the falls with elevation of pool surface at 412.004 (9 feet on
upper canal gauge), by the replacing of the wooden dam between Middle and Indiana
chutes by a Boul6 dam with crest at 412.004, which work is already provided for and
under way, and by the construction of the sections of dam recommended by the
district engineer officer in the project approved by the Chief of Engineers on December
28, 1903, with crests at 412.004 instead of 411.004, recommended therein, this height
of crest being desirable for either a 6-foot or a 9-foot slack-water navigation, or even if
the river is not further improved by the slack-water method; (4) to remove the rock
necessary to complete the widening of the basin at the head of the canal contemplated
by the present approved project; (5) to reconstruct the three sections of Boul6 dam
just north of the head of canal with crest at 415.704, instead of crest at 412.504, as
provided for in present project, thus eliminating the cross current across the head
of the canal, which current now makes it very difficult for tows to enter the canal at
stages between 8 and 12.7 feet. It is proposed to leave the crest of the present fixed
concrete dam at 411.004 to serve as a fixed weir for the low-water discharge of the
river.
    All elevations are in feet above mean tide at Sandy Hook, N. J.
    The estimated cost of the work proposed by this Board is as follows:
Widening canal to 170 feet, etc..........................................                               $673,   000
New lock and appurtenances........................................                                       773,   000
New dams....... . ..............             ..... .............             ...................         240,   000
Reconstructing Bould dam at head of canal.............................                                    31,   000
Removal of rock in basin ....................                    .........................                43,   000

         Total......................                   ..............                 ..............   1, 760, 000
   Of this estimate the act of March 2, 1907, provided for the com-
pletion of the third, fourth, and fifth items; in view of which it
would appear that former estimates have been superseded or sus-
pended by the latter, which are therefore adopted in this report.
   The funds provided by the appropriation of March 2, 1907, are
being applied to the removal of rock in the enlargement at the head
of the canal, and to the reconstruction of the Boul6 dam immediately
north of the north wall of the canal, the construction of 500 feet of
Boul6 dam in Middle Chute, about 1,000 feet of Boul6 dam between
Middle and Indiana chutes, 648 feet of Chanoine dam in Indiana
Chute, and about 600 linear feet of concrete dam between Indiana
Chute and the north bank of the river. The height of these sections
of the dam is such as will afford a minimum depth of 9 feet upstream
to Madison, Ind., and a minimum depth of 6 feet on the lower miter
sill at Lock No. 1, Kentucky River.
648           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                       S. ARMY.

  Following is a brief synopsis of expenditures under the allotments
and projects summarized above:
Expended from allotments, 1881, to January 31, 1890.................                                $116,049. 80
Expended under project of 1883, for enlargement of head of canal, to
  January 31, 1890.................................................                                   347,380. 68
Reserved, Office Chief of Engineers, United States Army-.............                                    1, 874. 20
Expended under project for enlarging canal basin at locks-...-...-.- _                                133, 000. 00
Expended under revised project of January 31, 1890, to June 30, 1897:
   On enlargement at head of canal..................... $298, 856. 35
   On Indiana Chute channel ......................... 103, 602. 81
                                                                                                      402, 459. 16
Expended under appropriations for enlargement at head of canal and
  Indiana Chute, in accordance with project of January 31, 1890, to
March 31, 1899.......--.................. ......... ........
                                                            .........                                 208, 659. 75
Expended under appropriations for enlargement at head of canal and
  Indiana Chute, in accordance with the modified project of March 31,
  1899 (approved April 8, 1899)..---------.....................................                       459, 075. 27
Expended under the project recommended by the Ohio River Board..                                      229, 005. 95
      Total...----------................................---------------------------------------..   1, 897, 504. 81
  Expenditures during the fiscal year were for work as follows:
Office expenditures and miscellaneous........................-----------------------------...... $4,627.51
Boule dam, section No. 5 --..         .................. ................. 17, 616. 24
                               ----.....
Boul6 dam, sections 6, 7,8, and 9---........-----------...........---------...--..               24, 459.16
Chanoine dam, section No. 10...-- .........--                   ----...............---           47,786. 13
                                                                                 .....----------......
Concrete dam, section No. 11-------..-------.....---.........................---                 13, 542. 54
Removal of rock----------------..............--------........---------......                     18, 646.59
      Total----------------------.....----..........                               126, 678.17
                                                       ................---------------------........
   The results derived from the expenditures to date for those por-
tions of the work completed have been of marked advantage to traffic
and greatly facilitate its movement. The enlargement of the basin
immediately above the new locks was completed in 1893 and increased
the width of the canal at that locality from 90 feet to 215 feet through-
out a distance of 800 feet. At the head of the canal the work of
enlargement has been entirely completed from a point 725 feet below
the Fourteenth Street Railroad Bridge to a point 2,800 feet above that
bridge. Beyond this point, in the basin east of the north canal wall,
the excavation to grade within the prescribed limits is about 97 per
cent completed, a clear width of 415 feet excavated to grade being at
this date available.
   In Indiana Chute above Fourteenth Street Bridge the channel
width has been increased from 200 feet to 400 feet, and all rock within
these limits excavated to the grades prescribed in the project. At
Wave rock and Willow Point all excavation and the dikes have been
completed. The depth of water over Wave rock and Willow Point
approximates very closely the depth anticipated-i. e., 8 feet when
there are 8 feet on the upper canal gauge. But that result was not
attained for the upper portion of the chute; however, it can now
be navigated with ease by heavy-draft coal boats at stages of 11.5
feet, or more, upper canal gauge.
   It is proposed to apply the amount recommended as a profitable
expenditure in the year ending June 30, 1911, in preparatory work
connected with the further items of improvement recommended by
the Ohio River Board and not yet appropriated for-i. e., procuring
the necessary additional land needed for the enlargement of the canal,
preparing data, etc., with a view to advertising the work for contract.
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVE1VIENTS.                              649
  In the money statement of last year's report the "Amount (esti-
mated) required for completion of existing project" was given as
$429,215.99, which was merely the balance from the older estimates
which have been superseded by that of the Ohio River Board, as
hereinbefdre mentioned. Therefore it would appear that instead of
bringing forward the balance of the old estimates, the balance of
that Board's estimate should be substituted therefor, and this has
been done in the following statement.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................        $211, 672.22
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement .....................-............ ........ ...... ......        126, 678.17

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................    84, 994. 05
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities- ...........-- --.......--         1, 744. 82
                                                          ----------.............
July 1, 1909, balance available ................   ........   ..-........     83, 249. 23
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 1, 446, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909............................................             50, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897.
   (See Appendix H H 1.)
   2. Operating and care of Louisville and Portland Canal.-This
canal was constructed by a private corporation, acting under a
charter granted by the Kentucky legislature in 1825, and subsequent
acts of the same body extending the time for completion and increas-
ing the capital stock. It was completed and the first boat passed
through it December 22, 1830. At that time there were three com-
bined lift locks, each with a lift of about 83 feet, a width of 50 feet,
and length of 200 feet. The width of the canal proper was from 64
to 68 feet at normal stages, with a depth of nearly 3 feet at extreme
low stages of the river. There was no dam at the head of the canal.
The United States became a stockholder in the corporation in 1826,
and gradually increased its holdings until all of the outstanding stock
and bonds passed into its possession.
   In 1860 an enlargement and extension of the canal which included
new locks was begun under the corporate management, and resulted
in the width of the canal being increased to 90 feet, with three basins,
or passing places, and the construction of two new combined lift locks
with a total lift of about 26 feet. Each of the chambers of the new
locks has a width of 80 feet and an available length of 350 feet. The
new locks were opened to navigation February 6, 1872.
   The United States assumed charge of the work of enlargement of
the canal and construction of a dam at the head of the canal subse-
quent to the allotment of funds for that purpose in 1868, but the
operation of the canal and collection of tolls remained under control
of the corporate management until June 11, 1874, upon which date
the entire control of the canal was assumed by the United States,
pursuant to the act of Congress of May 11, 1874, which provided
that the canal should be held "free of all tolls and charges, except
such as are necessary to pay the current expenses of said canal
and keep the same in repair." Tolls were entirely abolished after
650           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                           S. ARMY.

midnight, July 1, 1880, and since that date the expenses of operation
and maintenance of the canal have been borne directly by treasury
funds made available by the act of March 3, 1881, and the indefinite
appropriation for "Operating and care of canals and other works of
navigation," act of July 5, 1884, as amended and reenacted by section
6 of the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
   The general project for operation and care of the canal by expendi-
tures under allotments from these acts contemplates the operation
of the canal locks, the operation of the dredging plant to keep the
canal clear of deposit brought into it by high water, and the repair
of existing structures, so as to maintain the whole system in good
serviceable condition. The funds are provided under estimates sub-
mitted annually at the beginning of each fiscal year and allotments
therefor.
   The approved project, estimate, and allotment for the fiscal year
1909, in addition to the provisions for ordinary current repairs, sup-
plies, miscellaneous work of maintenance, operation of locks and
dredging plant, included items for resetting 625 linear feet of coping
on the north wall of the basin at the locks and repaving an area of
about 1,742 square yards at that point; also amounts sufficient for
the completion of two steel barges and two wooden dump scows.
The estimate for the year amounted to $114,027.59, and the funds
thereunder made available July 15, 1908.
  In reporting the total of expenditures made in connection with this
work it seems best, for the purpose of clearness in showing the general
application, to subdivide the total to date into amounts for each
period indicated, as follows:
From allotments and appropriations, September, 1868, to June 30,
  1882, for completion of new locks, enlargement of canal, and
  for cross dam at head of canal, payment of bonds, etc............---... $1, 463, 200. 00
From tolls collected by United States, June 11, 1874, to midnight
  July 1, 1880, for operation and maintenance .......................                            417, 069. 38
From allotments from act of March 3, 1881, for operation and mainte-
  nance ..................---------------------------........................................    214, 062. 91
From allotments from act of July 5, 1884, for operation and mainte-
  nance ........           -.............. . ..........................            ........   2, 133, 565. 82

        Total.........--------------------------.............-------------.....---...........-------.   4, 227, 898.11
   The amount expended during the past fiscal year is $90,196.94.
   The canal is available to commerce at all stages of the river less
than 12.7 feet, upper canal gauge, and affords free navigation around
the falls of the Ohio River at stages of water when the passage there-
over can not be made by the open-river channel.
   The zero of the upper gauge corresponds to reference 35 and the
bottom of the canal at its head to reference 34, canal datum. The
lowest recorded reading of the upper gauge is 1.7 feet; the highest
reading on the same gauge is 46.7 feet.
   Under the regulations prescribed by the Secretary of War for the
use, administration, and navigation of this canal the maximum draft
of vessels that can be passed through the canal is limited to the depth
of water above zero of the gauge at the time the boat enters the canal.
   References to more extended information concerning original con-
dition, purchase, and progress of the improvement of this canal are
given on page 491, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
   For a comparative statement of commerce, see the report on this
work by district officer.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   651

   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, 4,652 boats, barges,
and small craft passed through the canal, carrying 963,327A tons
freight. During the same period 1,308 boats, barges, and small
craft passed over the falls via the open-river channel, carrying
360,6051 tons of freight, thus making the aggregate that passed
Louisville via both routes 5,960 boats, barges, and small craft, and
1,323,9331 tons of freight.
   (See Appendix H H 2.)
   3. Wabash River, Indiana and Illinois.-At the time the United
States began the work of improving this river it was badly obstructed
by bars, accumulations of snags, rocky reefs, and numerous secondary
channels or cut-offs, which lessened the flow of water through the
main channel. Navigation was impracticable except at high stages
of water. A lock and dam has been built at Grand Rapids by the
Wabash Navigation Company and a few improvements made at other
places, also by private enterprise; but as none of them was of a sub-
stantial character, they rapidly deteriorated and became useless.
   The original project and outline of improvements proposed is
found in the report of Maj. G. Weitzel, Corps of Engineers, January
4, 1872, page 472, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1872.
The first appropriation for work under this project was made by
Congress June 10, 1872. This project proposed the improvement of
the river from its mouth to Lafayette, Ind., by special works at 12
designated localities, the construction of a new lock and dam at
Grand Rapids, and the general work of snagging and dredging. The
estimated cost of the work proposed amounted to $312,672.62. Work
at various places other than those mentioned in the project has been
added from time to time, but no general revision of the original esti-
mate has been made.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1881, made separate appro-
priations for work above Vincennes and for work below Vincennes,
thus dividing the original project, and subsequent to that date funds
have been provided separately for each section.
   From the commencement of the work, in 1872, to March 31, 1881,
the expenditures, all of which were for work below Vincennes,
amounted to $324,845.44. Those for work since that date are given
under their respective headings, as follows:
    (a) Below Vincennes.-Subsequent to 1881 work was continued
under the original project, but the estimates were modified from time
to time as necessity therefor arose, as in the cases for the dam for
closing the New Harmony Cut-off, the lock and dam at Grand Rapids,
etc. Levee work at Grayville, Ill., was added in 1887, and completed,
as proposed, at a cost of $25,000. In 1898 a plan and estimate
amounting to $50,000, for additional work at New Harmony was
approved, but at the same time it was urged that if the improvement
of the river was to be continued the old project should be abrogated,
a comprehensive survey of the river made, and a new project formu-
lated, based upon data furnished by the survey and of sufficient scope
to meet existing needs of commerce. The survey was authorized and
funds therefor provided by the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902.
The report on the survey, proposed plan for improvement, estimate
of cost, and action taken in connection therewith may be found on
652       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                   S. ARMY.

page 2729, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904. The
aggregate of the items of the original estimate applicable to this part
of the river and of the several subsequent estimates constituting the
estimate of cost of existing project adopted by Congress is $755,000.
   The expenditures to March 31, 1881, amounted to $317,845.44, in
addition to the $7,000 paid to extinguish the franchise of the Wabash
Navigation Company and acquire their property, those for the levee
work at Grayville from 1887 to 1892, $25,000, and those for other
work since 1881 on this part of the river, $365,111.76, or an aggregate
of $714,957.20 for work below Vincennes to June 30, 1909.
   Previous to 1885 a fairly go6d channel for boats having a draft not
exceeding 2 to 3 feet was maintained, but as the river and harbor act
of July 5, 1884, made specific appropriation for a lock and dam at
Grand Rapids, near Mount Carmel, Ill., the suspension of operations
elsewhere became necessary, in view of the fact that the funds avail-
able since that date were not sufficient to complete the lock and dam,
and at the same time maintain the former works for bank protection
and to concentrate the water flow and clear the channel of obstruc-
tions. Consequently the work formerly done deteriorated rapidly,
the structures being destroyed by ice and high water or rendered
useless by the water cutting its way around them. The channels,
cut through rock reefs and shoal places, became choked with snags,
stumps, and bowlders, thus leaving the river without any permanent
improvement excepting that resulting from the lock and dam at
Grand Rapids. Through navigation at low water is impracticable.
Boats drawing 20 inches can pass from Mount Carmel to Vincennes
(a river distance of about 34 miles) at all stages, but can reach Mount
Carmel, 92.7 miles from the mouth of the river, only when the gauge
at the lock reads 7.5 feet or more.
   Commercial statistics will be found in the report for operating and
care of lock and dam at Grand Rapids, Wabash River (Appendix
H H 4).
   References to more extended information are given on page 494,
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1904.
   It is not believed that the improvement has had any influence upon
freight rates.
   There is at present no approved comprehensive project and estimate
in force for the improvement of this river, and as a result of a recent
preliminary examination none is recommended until the dam in the
Ohio River creating the pool in that river at the mouth of the Wabash
River shall have been determined upon and completed.
   In view of these facts and the further fact that no appropriation for
this river has been made since June 13, 1902, and that the small
unexpended balance has been covered into the surplus fund of the
Treasury, no further report for the sections of river "Above Vin-
cennes" and "Below Vincennes" will be submitted until additional
appropriations become available for work on this river.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................         $42.54
June 30, 1909, amount carried to the surplus fund of the Treasury ............    42. 54
   (b) Above Vincennes.-At the time this section of the river became
the object of separate appropriations there had been no revision of
                   RIVER AND      HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                         653
the estimate in the original project for the improvement of the river
from its mouth to Lafayette. Under the project matured after the
appropriation had been made (see Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1881, p. 2001), and subsequent modifications, the esti-
mates to June 30, 1908, amounted to $95,500.
   The expenditures on the work of existing project to June 30, 1909,
amounted to $95,254.87.
   The funds available during the past sixteen years have not been
sufficient to maintain the former works for channel rectification and
to keep the river clear of snags, bars, and similar obstructions.
During the more recent years not enough funds have been available
for snagging purposes alone. Therefore it can not be said that any
permanent improvement of this section of the river has been effected
or that navigation is practicable, except at high stages of water.
   The only commercial statistics available are those collected at the
lock at Grand Rapids. (See Appendix H H 4.) References to more
extended information may be found in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 495.
   No further report will be submitted.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..      ................. ................ . $245.13
June 30, 1909, amount carried to the surplus fund of the Treasury.......... 245. 13
   (See Appendix H H 3.)
  4. Operating and care of lock and dam at Grand Rapids, Wabash
River.-This lock and dam was built from funds derived from appro-
priations for improving Wabash River, Indiana and Illinois, and
opened to navigation in November, 1893. The available length of
the lock is 214 feet; width, 52 feet; depth on lower miter sill at low
water, 3.5 feet; depth on upper miter sill at normal pool stage, 5.08
feet. At such stage the pool above the lock affords slack-water navi-
gation about 12 miles, and the maximum draft that can be carried is
about 2 feet. Conditions beyond the pool are mentioned in the
report for improving Wabash River, Indiana and Illinois.
   The expenses of operating the lock were paid from the appropria-
tions for improvement of the river until March 1, 1897, since which
date they have been paid from annual allotments from the indefinite
appropriation for "Operating and care of canals and other works of
navigation," act of July 5, 1884, as amended and reenacted by sec-
tion 6 of the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
   The first and subsequent annual projects proposed the operation of
the lock and the maintenance of it and the appurtenant structures in
good serviceable condition. The expenditures under these projects
to June 30, 1909, amounted to $34,880.06.
   The project for the fiscal year 1909 provided for the operation of the
lock, ordinary current repairs, and the replacing of old wooden guide
and protection cribs, dredging the lock chamber and entrances
thereto, and backing the dam, at an estimated cost of $38,218.50,
which amount was made available by the allotments of July 17, 1908,
and October 7, 1908.
   The amount expended during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909,
not including outstanding liabilities, is $2,452.66. A contract for
the construction of the new walls, dredging, etc., was entered into
654      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

June 2, 1909, but work thereunder had not begun at the close of the
fiscal year.
    During the past fiscal year 1,494 boats, barges, etc., and 5,121 tons
of freight passed the lock.
    A comparative statement of traffic and commerce passing the lock
during the past twelve years will be found in the report on this work
by the district officer.
    (See Appendix H H 4.)
    5. White River, Indiana.-Originally this tributary to Wabash
River was badly obstructed by rocky reefs, remains of old structures,
and a very great number of snags. It could be navigated only at high
stages of water.
    The original project is based upon the report of "examination of
White River and its forks in Indiana," submitted December 31, 1878.
The first appropriation for the improvement was made in the act of
March 3, 1879. In this act the work of improvement was limited to
"White River, Indiana, from Wabash River to Portersville, and to
the falls on the West Fork, according to Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers, without constructing locks and dams." A minimum depth of
2 feet at low water was sought. In 1886 the estimate was reduced.
The river and harbor act of August 18, 1894, provided for a resurvey
of the river.
    Subject to the modifications mentioned, the original project con-
stitutes the existing project of this date. The estimate of cost is
 $120,000. The amount expended to June 30, 1909, not including
outstanding liabilities, is $119,311.58. As a result of these expendi-
tures the lower 13 miles of the river is navigable all the year for boats
having a draft not exceeding 3 feet. Above this, to the junction of
the two forks, boats drawing 18 inches can navigate for about six
months of the year. Low-water navigation on the forks is imprac-
ticable even for the smallest boats. This information is derived from
the report on the resurvey made in 1895-96, since which date oper-
ations have been suspended, the funds available not being sufficient
for either work of improvement or maintenance of former structures
for controlling the flow of water and bank protection or to keep the
channel clear of snags.
    No statistics as to the volume or character of commerce moved on
this river during the past year are available.
    The report upon the resurvey of the river (Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1897, p. 2483) contains data concenring the
volume and character of commerce that would be benefited by or
involved in the further improvement of the river. This report also
contains estimates of cost of improvement under alternative plans
and a recommendation that "the further improvement of the White
River should be postponed until the improvement of the Wabash has
been such as to afford an outlet for any traffic which may then be
developed on White River."
     References to more extended information concerning this river
may be found in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904,
page 497.
    Expenditures during the year amounted to $15.40 and were for
mileage on account of an inspection trip made by the district officer.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              655
   Work. under the old project was completed several years ago, and
at present there is no comprehensive project and estimate in force for
the improvement of this river. In view of this fact, together with
the recommendation contained in the report upon the survey of the
river, previously mentioned, and the fact that no appropriation for
this river has been made since June 30, 1896, and the balance of that
appropriation has been covered into the surplus fund of the Treasury,
no further report will be made until additional appropriations become
available for work on this river.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended--..-.............. .....................    $703. 82
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improvement.   15. 40
June 30, 1909, amount carried to the surplus fund of the Treasury..........    688. 42
   (See Appendix H H 5.)
   6. Green River, above the mouth of Big Barren River, Kentucky.-
Originally this part of Green River was much obstructed by snags,
large bowlders, and overhanging trees. Dam No. 4, Green River,
afforded slack water for about 18 miles above the confluence of Green
and Barren rivers. The fall in that part of the river above slack
water and below Mammoth Cave, Ky., a distance of about 29 miles,
was approximately 27 feet.
   The original project is that submitted under date of August 11,
1891 (printed in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1891,
p. 2481). It proposes the extension of slack-water navigation from
the upper limits of pool No. 4 to Mammoth Cave by the construction
of two locks and dams at an estimated cost of $361,346.40 for both.
No revision of the project and estimate has been made except as pro-
vided by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, for work of
snagging and clearing banks of Nolin River, which will be affected by
slack water from Dam No. 6, Green River, for which $5,000 has been
appropriated.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, exclusive of outstanding
liabilities on that date, is $365,093.03.
   As a result of these expenditures, Locks and Dams Nos. 5 and 6
have been completed and opened to navigation, thus extending slack
water to Mammoth Cave, Ky., and through a part of the rich min-
eral district bordering the river which previously had no conveniently
accessible transportation route.
   Commercial statistics are given in the report for operating and care
of locks and dams on Green and Barren rivers, Kentucky (Appen-
dix H H 7).
   References to more extended information may be found in Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 498.
   Report of examination of the river from Lock No. 6 to Munford-
ville may be found in House Document No. 377, Fifty-ninth Con-
gress, first session.
   Sufficient data are not available upon which to determine the effect
of the improvement on freight rates, if any.
   No work was in progress during the year. The balance available
is being held to meet awards in condemnation proceedings which
have been instituted for the procurement of land for a roadway from
the abutment site to the nearest public highway.
656       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,               U.   S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................... $580. 17
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................... 580. 17
   (See Appendix H H 6.)
   7. Operating and care of locks and dams on Green and Barren
rivers, Kentucky.--The original system of slack-water navigation on
these rivers, including 4 locks in Green River and 1 lock in Barren
River, with a total length of pools of approximately 200 miles, was
completed by the State of Kentucky in 1841. The State retained con-
trol and management of the system until 1868, when it was leased to
the Green and Barren River Navigation Company for a term of thirty
years. The act of the Kentucky legislature, approved February 20,
1886, ceded the entire system to the United States upon condition
that the unexpired portion of the lease to the navigation company be
purchased by the United States. The river and harbor act of August
11, 1888, appropriated $135,000 "for the purchase of the improve-
ments known as the Green and Barren river improvements." The
deed from the Green and Barren River Navigation Company relin-
quising all their rights, privileges, etc., having been duly approved
by the Attorney-General of the United States, and the purchase
money paid to said company, the Government assumed control of the
river, the improvements therein, and the property formerly owned by
the State December 11, 1888.
   The condition of the improvements and of the rivers at that date
was as follows: Lock and Dam No. 1, Green River, required many
repairs. The walls-of Lock No. 2 were cracked and in bad condition
generally, the land wall especially so, it being held in position by
anchorage-to cribs filled with stone; the river wall had yielded out-
ward. Lock No. 3, Green River, was broken entirely, the river wall
having yielded outward and fallen into the river. Lock and Dam No.
4, Cren River, was in fairly good condition, with the exception of
needed repairs to the quoins and gates. The walls of Lock No. 1, Bar-
ren River, were so badly cracked that a part of one of them, the land
wall, leaned toward the lock chamber about 6 inches and was liable to
fall at any time. The entrances to the locks were obstructed with
deposit and the pools with great numbers of snags, overhanging trees,
etc.; the appurtenant structures at the locks and the lock tenders'
dwellings were in bad condition and inadequate. No snagging or
dredging plant was available.
   Excepting the funds for rebuilding Lock No. 2, Green River, which
were provided by specific appropriations, the funds for the restoration
of former structures, the operation of the locks, and maintenance of
the system in good navigable condition have been provided by allot-
ments from the indefinite appropriation for "Operating and care of
canals and other works of navigation," act of July 5, 1884, as
amended and reenacted by section 6 of the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1909, under estimates submitted annually at the beginning
of each fiscal year. The first project for work on these rivers under
the latter act was approved January 4, 1889, and proposed the res-
toration, so far as practicable, of the former structures to good
serviceable condition, the construction of new ones where required,
the operation of the locks, the removal of snags, landslides, and
deposit from the entrances to the locks, etc., and such has been the
general object of each subsequent annual estimate and project.
                                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                                  657
   In addition to the items for the usual work of operation and main-
tenance, the project and estimate for the fiscal year 1909 provided
for new upper gates of steel and new upper miter wall of concrete
at Lock No. 1, Green River; renewal with concrete of above-water
portions of sections 1, 3, 4, and 5 of the upper river crib, and install-
ing new valves in Lock No. 2, Green River; renewal of above-water
portion of upper river crib at Lock No. 3, Green River; new upper
gates of steel and new upper miter wall of concrete at Lock No. 4,
Green River; completion of repairs to floor, etc., of Lock No. 5,
Green River; bank protection at Lock No. 6, Green River; renewal
with concrete of lower land crib at Lock No. 1, Barren River, and
completion of new hull for snag boat, and various repairs of less impor-
tant nature to the other structures and floating plant. The estimate
for the fiscal year amounted to $138,337.26, which was made avail-
able by the allotment of July 15, 1908.
   Expenditures during the fiscal year, not including outstanding
liabilities June 30, 1909, amounted to $114,195.26.
   The aggregate expenditures under the project of January 4, 1889,
and subsequent annual projects to June 30, 1909, is $1,484,113.36.
   The result of these expenditures is the thorough repair of the sev-
eral locks of the former system and their appurtenant structures,
and the restoration of through navigation in the pools from Lock
No. 1, Green River, to Bowling Green, Ky., on Barren River, a dis-
tance of 172 miles, for boats not exceeding 35 feet in width, 138 feet
in length, and draft not exceeding 5 feet.
   At extreme low water in the open river below Lock No. 1, Green
River, there is a depth of only 1 foot on the lower miter sill of that
lock, which is located 8 miles above the mouth of the river. The
system now includes 7 locks and dams, Locks Nos. 5 and 6, Green
River, having been built from funds provided by specific appropria-
tions.
   Following is a synopsis of traffic and commerce through the locks
during the fiscal year:

                                                                                                                                        Boats.   Freight.


Green River:                                                                                                                                       Tons.
   Lock   No. 1........................                              ........ ....................................                      4,479      383,581
   Lock   No. 2 .....................................................................                                                   2,485      251,671
   Lock   No.3.......................................................................                                                   2,674      197,4774
   Lock   No. 4.......................................................................
          No.5--------------------------------------------------------------21,64                                                       2,661    7 122,5084
                                                                                                                                                   8,477


   Lock No. 5.....................                                  ............             ........................................   1,487      88,350
   Lock No. 6.......................................................................
                            -------------------------------------------------------                                                     1,471      46,883
Barren River, Lock No. 1.............................................................                                                   1,939      30,7871



   A comparative statement of the traffic and commerce on these
rivers will be found in the report on this work by the district officer.
   References to more extended information may be found in Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 500.
   (See Appendix IH H 7.)
   8. Operating and care of lock and dam on Rough River, Kentucky.-
This lock and dam was built with funds provided in appropriations
        9001-ENG 1909-42
658     REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.       S. ARMY.

for improving Rough River, Kentucky, and opened to navigation
December 12, 1896. The lock has an available length of 123 feet,
width of 27 feet, and depth on upper miter sill at normal pool stage
of 6.8 feet. At such stage the pool above the lock affords slack-
water navigation 211 miles to a short distance above Hartford, Ky.,
for boats with draft not exceeding 4 feet.
   The expense of operating the lock was paid from the appropriation
for improvement until June 30, 1897; since that date the expenses of
operating, care, etc., have been borne by the indefinite appropriation
for operating and care of canals and other works of navigation, act of
July 5, 1884, as amended and reenacted by section 6 of the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, the funds being made available by allot-
ment for projects and estimates submitted annually at the beginning
of each fiscal year.
   The project for the fiscal year 1909 proposed to operate the lock
and maintain existing structures in good serviceable condition, keep
the pools clear of snags, and remove deposits from the lock and ap-
proaches thereto, at an estimated cost of $1,508; which amount was.
made available by allotment July 17, 1908.
   Expenditures during the year amounted to $1,328.64, exclusive of
outstanding liabilities June 30, 1909.
   The amount expended from July 1, 1897, to June 30, 1909, is
$10,963.80.
   Traffic through the lock during the past fiscal year included 575
boats of various kinds, carrying 21,332 - tons of freight.
   A comparative statement of traffic and commerce on this river
during the past eighteen years will be found in the report on this
work by the district officer.
   (See Appendix H H 8.)
IMPROVEMENT      OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE DULUTH, MINNE-
                          SOTA, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Lieut. Col. Graham D. Fitch,
Corps of Engineers.   Division engineers, Col. W. L. Fisk, Corps of
Engineers.
   1. Harbor at Grand Marais, Minn.-This harbor is an elliptical
bay, whose major axis is about one-half mile and whose minor axis is
about one-fourth of a mile in length. It has an opening on the south
side, which was originally about 1,000 feet in width. Before improve-
ment there was a maximum depth of 14 feet over a very limited area,
the general average depth being only 8 or 9 feet. (Depths are
referred to mean low water.) It is the only harbor of refuge on the
north shore between Agate Bay and the international boundary
line, a distance of 125 miles.
   The approved project of April, 1879, is to build two breakwater
piers, each 350 feet long, from the east and west points of the bay, or
one pier 700 feet long from the east point, and dredge an anchorage
area of about 26 acres to a depth of at least 16 feet, all at an esti-
mated cost of $139,669.40. For reasons explained in the report of
the local officer (Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1898,
p. 2217), this estimate was increased to $163,954.63.
   Two breakwaters, each 350 feet long, have been constructed from
the east and west points of the bay, the work being completed on
August 13, 1901.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              659
   The amount expended on the project up to the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909, not including outstanding liabilities, was
$166,316.52, of which about $5,379.84 was for maintenance. The
work done has resulted in a more protected harbor and a 16-foot
anchorage area of about 26 acres.
   The expenditures during the year were for incidental expenses
and contingencies.
   The minimum mean low-water depth over the shoalest part of the
locality under improvement is 15 feet.
   The usual variation of water level extends from about 0 to +1
foot above low-water datum.
   The commerce of the port has increased from 25 entrances and
clearances, made by 4 tugs and 5 schooners, with 60 tons of cargo,
valued at $6,000, in 1878, to 1,250 clearances and entrances, all
steamers, with 41,125 tons of cargo, valued at $1,253,574, in 1908.
   The value of the commerce of the harbor from 1878 to 1908, both
inclusive, is estimated at $10,615,608.
   The freight tonnage in 1908 was 15 per cent less than in 1907.
   The total expenditures by the Government for this harbor to date
are 1 per cent of the value of the vessel freight received and shipped
during the period covered by these expenditures.
   The annual expense of government operations at this harbor, con-
sisting of maintenance, interest, and depreciation, is approximately
$8,232. This amounts to $0.20 per ton of vessel freight for the year
1908, and to 0.66 per cent of the value of this freight. Further
details of these comparisons may be seen in Table 4, Appendix I I 1,
of this report.
   Effect of project on freight rates: There are no railroads running
to this harbor, and the only means of transportation is by water, so
that no comparison can be made with railroad charges.
   In the original condition of the bay a small commercial business
could have been transacted by means of tugs or other vessels of small
draft at risk of exposure to storms, and logs could have been rafted to
other ports on the lake, also at risk of loss, to be sawed into lumber;
but the present commerce of this port could not have been carried on.
   The United States improvements have therefore been an indispen-
sable agency in the development of business where none previously
existed, and this may be of greater value and importance than a sim-
ple reduction of rates.
   The available balance and the appropriation recommended will be
expended for repairs and maintenance as necessity arises.
   For reports of examinations and surveys, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 559, where references are given;
also page 648 of Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................... ..................... $6, 079. 02
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement..............................                                    45.54

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................      6, 033. 48

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..............................................        2, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix II        1.)
660     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

   2. Harbor at Agate Bay, Minnesota.-This harbor, situated on the
north shore of Lake Superior, 27 miles northeast of Duluth, Minn., is
an important shipping port for iron ore and lumber and a harbor of
refuge.
   Before improvement there was ample depth for navigation, with
18 feet or more at mean low water over the greater portion of the
harbor, but the harbor was exposed to storms from the southwest
and to reverse swells from severe northeast storms.
   The approved project of January 4, 1887, was to construct two
breakwater piers on a line toward each other from the eastern and
western points of the bay, to be 1,000 and 900 feet long, respectively,
leaving an opening of 1,340 feet between their extremities and inclos-
ing an area of 109 acres.
   In 1899 the total ultimate length of the easterly breakwater was
increased by 50 feet.
   The original estimate of cost was $213,000, which was increased to
$244,208 (see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1887) on
account of higher prices.
   The amount expended on the approved project up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, not including outstanding lia-
bilities, was $250,896.78, of which about $16,839.25 was applied to
the maintenance of the improvement.
   The amount expended during the year was for incidental expenses
and contingencies.
   The project was completed on November 1, 1901, and fulfills very
effectually the purpose for which it was designed.
   The depth at the entrance is over 50 feet, and vessels drawing 20
feet can reach the ore docks in safety.
   The usual variation of water level extends from about 0 to about
+ 1 foot above low-water datum.
   The commerce of the port has increased from 174 arrivals and
clearances of vessels in 1885, with 263,437 tons of freight, valued at
$876,613, to 2,034 arrivals and clearances in 1908, with 6,688,602
tons, valued at $16,941,624.
   The total value of the commerce of this port from 1887 to 1908,
both years inclusive, is $204,511,992.
   The total expenditures by the Government for this harbor to date
are one-eighth of 1 per cent of the value of the vessel freight re-
ceived and shipped during the period covered by these expenditures.
   The annual expense of government operations at this harbor, con-
sisting of maintenance, interest on cost.of improvement, and depre-
ciation, is approximately $14,808. This amounts to $0.002 per ton
of the vessel freight for the year 1908 and to 0.87 per cent of the
value of this freight, and is one-ninth of 1 per cent of the saving in
the cost of transportation on this freight by water as compared with
rail rates. Details of these comparisons may be seen in Table 4,
Appendix I I 2, of this report.
   Effect of project on freight rates: It is estimated that the saving
in cost of transportation by water as compared with that by rail for
the receipts and shipments of this harbor is approximately $1.94 per
ton, which amounts to about $13,000,000 for the year 1908. This is
three-fourths of the value of the receipts and shipments for the same
year. The government improvements have been an indispensable
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           661
aid to this commerce. (See the following report for harbor at Duluth,
Minn., and Superior, Wis.)
  The available balance and the appropriation recommended will be
expended for repairs and maintenance.
  For reports of examinations and surveys, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 561, where references are given.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................      ................... $5, 906. 62
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ..............................         ..... ..................      16. 71
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                             5, 889. 91
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.............................................-------------------------------------------..   2, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix I I 2.)
   3. Harbor at- Duluth, Minn., and Superior, Wis.-Previous to the
Annual Report of 1897 this harbor was reported on under the separate
heads of Duluth, Minn., and Superior, Wis., respectively.
   The act of June 3, 1896, unified these harbors under the above title
and provided for continuous contracts for its improvement to the
amount of $3,130,553.
   This harbor consists of the Duluth Canal, the Wisconsin Entrance,
Superior Bay, Allouez Bay, St. Louis Bay, and St. Louis River to the
limits of the cities of Duluth and Superior, about 20 miles from the
original natural entry, which before improvement was obstructed by
shifting bars with but 9 feet of water over them. The bays were
broad expanses of shallow water, averaging only 8 or 9 feet, except
along a natural channel through them where the depth was greater,
but variable. Depths given in this report are referred to low-water
datum, which is a mean low-water level.
   The project adopted by the act of March 3, 1881, previous to the
present one, was for 16-foot navigation. This was practically com-
pleted July 1, 1897, and resulted in giving a good 16-foot navigation
through the natural or Wisconsin Entry, through the artificial
Duluth Canal, over the Duluth Basin of 104 acres, along and parallel
to the principal dock lines of Duluth and Superior in Superior and St.
Louis bays, and up the St. Louis River to New Duluth, near the head
of navigation of the river, with well-defined channels of from 85 to
300 feet in width.
   The amount expended on the project of March 3, 1881, and projects
prior to operations under existing project was $1,548,183.
   The present project, authorized by the act of June 3, 1896, and by
the modifications of August 14, 1896, and May 9, 1901, provided for
the widening and deepening to a navigable depth of 20 feet of the
existing channels, for new channels in Allouez Bay and St. Louis
River, for extensive turning and anchorage basins of a navigable
depth of 20 feet at the junctions of two or more channels, for widen-
ing the Duluth Canal, and for rebuilding the piers at the Duluth
Canal and Wisconsin Entrance and finishing them off with concrete
superstructures built of monolithic blocks.
662     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The estimated cost of the work was $3,130,553, but this referred
only to the deepening of the channels and basins by dredging. This
has been done at much less than the estimated cost, permitting the
purchase of lands to the extent of $106,561.19, the rebuilding of the
Duluth Canal piers at a cost of over $650,000, including price of land,
and leaving a balance of about $275,000 toward the rebuilding of the
piers at the Wisconsin Entrance, under construction from 1903 to 1906.
   Further modified by project adopted by act of June 13, 1902, at
Superior Entry, Wisconsin, with all-concrete construction, increasing
the original estimate by $650,000.
   The present project has been further modified and enlarged by the
act of March 2, 1907, in accordance with the report submitted in
House Document No. 82, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session, which
provides for excavation of the lake approach to the Duluth entrance
to 30 feet for a width of 300 feet, at a cost of $10,000, and the follow-
ing work at Superior Entry: (a) Building a concrete revetment pier
on the north side of entrance, similar to one already built in 1904, on
the south side under the project before present modification, these two
revetments 500 feet apart and terminating near the lake shore of Wis-
consin Point; (b) building two converging breakwaters from the
shore out to the 30-foot depth, with an opening of 600 feet on line
with the axis of the inner entrance, to be of rubble mound construc-
tion, terminating in a crib and concrete pier at outer end and a pile
pier at inner end; (c) dredging between the breakwaters to form a
channel 600 feet wide and 30 feet deep, and further dredging to form
a stilling basin; (d) dredging channel between revetments to a depth
of 24 feet; (e) protecting the shore line by riprap; and (f) widening
the Superior front channel inside the harbor; estimated to cost
$1,703,000. The said act also provided for additional dredging near
the draw span of the Northern Pacific Railroad bridge at an esti-
mated cost of $55,500.
   The present project has been further modified and enlarged by the
act of May 28, 1908, which provides for the expenditure of moneys
heretofore appropriated for the harbor for dredging inside the Du-
luth entrance, in accordance with a report in House Document No.
221, Sixtieth Congress, first session. This report recommended the
enlargement by about 209 acres of the anchorage area of the Duluth
Basin, by dredging to a depth of 22 feet, low-water datum, an esti-
mated amount of 4,590,000 yards, at a cost of $550,800. These sev-
eral modifications have a combined estimated cost of $2,319,300, and
together with the first estimate of $3,130,553 makes a total estimated
cost of $5,449,853 for the present project and its modifications.
   The amount expended on the existing project to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, exclusive of outstanding liabilities,
was $4,392,972.83, of which $466,030 was expended for maintenance.
   Operations during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, include the
following:
   The extension of the Duluth Harbor Basin, authorized by act of
May 28, 1908, was commenced July 8, 1908, and vigorously prosecuted
by the contractors until the close of the season, six dipper dredges
being employed at one time. The work was resumed on the opening
of navigation in 1909, and is now in progress. The results accom-
plished to June 30, 1909, are the dredging of 1,716,567 yards at a con-
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    663
tract cost of $180,239.54, giving a depth of 22 to 24 feet, extending
the area of the basin by 66 acres, and giving a total area in the basin
to date of about 237 acres. This is new work. The present contract
will be completed before the end of this season, with a total contract
cost of about $200,000, which is expected to increase the area to a
total of about 245 acres.
   Enlargement of    East Gate Basin.-Private dredging of sand for
dock filling was carried on for a number of years at the easterly side
of the East Gate Basin (near the Interstate bridge), under permits
from the Secretary of War and the supervision of the district officer.
About 850,000 yards of sand were thus removed without cost to the
United States, and enlarged the turning basin by about 39 acres,
but left an uneven bottom, obstructed by shoals. To render this
area available for navigation the shoals have been removed by the
United States, between the dates of June 25, 1908, and August 11,
1908. The amount dredged was 99,966 yards, at a contract cost of
$11,995.92, and gave a depth of 21 to 25 feet. This is new work, and
adds much to the safety of navigation in the approach to the bridge.
   Removal ofshoals.-Dredgingfor the removal of shoals from several
of the channels of this harbor was commenced June 22, 1909, and at
the close of the fiscal year amounted to 43,904 yards, and a contract
cost of $5,927.04. This work is expected to be completed in July,
1909, at a total cost of about $20,000, and will give a good navigable
depth of more than 20 feet. This work was for the purpose of
maintenance.
   Superior Entry improvement.-During the fiscal year operations
were in progress which nearly completed the north concrete revet-
ment; contract work on the construction of the north rubble mound
breakwater was prosecuted; a quantity of riprap was removed from
the old channel a.nd placed in the south rubble mound breakwater
by United States plant; timber cribs for the seaward ends of the
two breakwaters were completed, and will be sunk in place later;
a trench has been excavated in the lake for the cribs, some of the
bearing piles for these cribs have been driven and cut off; a number
of concrete footing blocks have been built to be placed on the cribs;
a new steel tug has been completed; and additional plant has been
constructed by the United States for use on construction work. The
cost of the foregoing operations was $298,447.30, of which $23,467.78
was for administration. The foregoing is new work.
   The work done under the existing project up to the close of the
past fiscal year has been as follows:
   The dredging of channels and basins, which was in operation for
six seasons under continuous contract and completed in 1902, re-
moved 21,697,243 yards of material, and gave 17 miles of dredged
channels from 120 to 600 feet in width, and basins for anchorage
and for turning at the junctions of channels and in the vicinity of
bridges of an aggregate area of about 360 acres, all of a depth of 20
feet or more at low water. Since then the lake approach to the
Duluth Canal has been deepened to 30 feet or more for a width of
330 feet. The lake approach to the Superior Entry has been deepened
to 30 feet or more for a width of 350 feet. Channels have been
widened in St. Louis Bay to adapt them to the reconstructed spans
of the Northern Pacific bridge, which have recently been enlarged
and altered in position.
664     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.           S. ARMY.

   The East Gate Basin has been .enlarged to the extent of 39 acres,
as stated elsewhere, giving increased facilities for the passage of
vessels through the Duluth-Superior bridge, and for turning from
the Rice Point channel to the Superior Front channel.
  The Duluth Harbor Basin is being extended in order to provide
for much-needed anchorage facilities. The projected amount of
such extension, as recommended by the Board, is 209 acres. On
June 30, 1909, there had been 66 acres dredged, which is about 31
per cent accomplished of the entire amount.            The government
harbor line in front of Minnesota Point has been moved inshore to a
distance of 750 feet by the Secretary of War in order to provide the
room necessary for this extension of the basin.
   The maintenance of these channels has been kept up by the removal
of shoals, and a maximum draft of 20 feet at mean low water could
be carried through any and all of them on June 30, 1909. The usual
variation of water level extends from about 0 to +-1 foot above low-
water datum. The head of navigation is at the foot of the rapids
just above the village of Fond du Lac, on the St. Louis River, about
20 miles from Lake Superior.
   All the land necessary for the widening of the Duluth Canal has
been acquired by deed of gift, purchase, or condemnation, at a cost of
$53,919.05.
   The land needed for the improvement at the Wisconsin Entrance,
the mouth of the Nemadji River, and a marshy island in the St.
Louis River, was obtained by condemnation proceedings, at a cost of
$42,79.5.94.
   A small parcel of land at the end of Grassy Point and certain lands
in Spirit Lake were purchased, at a cost of $3,146.20.
   A site for a, boat yard on Minnesota Point, near the Duluth Canal,
was acquired by purchase and condemnation, at a total cost of $7,200,
and the vacation of a portion of a street was effected through the city
authorities, which was found necessary in order to carry out a proper
system of improvement. This property has now been improved by
building a bulkhead and a landing pier, dredging a slip, filling the
yard with sand, moving the four government buildings, which had
been occupying leased ground at the foot of Seventh avenue, and by
fencing in, paving a roadway, and surfacing and seeding for grass.
The cost of this improvement has been about $17,750.
   New piers were built for the Duluth Canal. These piers have been
equipped with 67 iron lamp-posts, and the city furnishes the electric cur-
rent for lighting the same during the season of passenger travel by lake.
   Concrete walls inclosing the government lands at the Duluth Canal
were built and the tracts filled to grade, requiring the deposit of about
50,000 cubic yards of material.
   The construction of an engineer building on the government land
north of the canal for offices and a watchman's house has been com-
pleted, at a cost of about $25,000. On May 1, 1906, the rented office
rooms were given up and the new building occupied. It is a substan-
tial building, conveniently near the harbor and United States vessel
yard, and well adapted to office purposes. The parking of the canal
grounds and the const.ruction of additional concrete walls to protect
the grounds from flooding by storms have been completed.
  At the Wisconsin Entrance (known also as the Superior Entry)
the replacing of the old piers by new ones of concrete construction
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    665

was begun in 1903. About one-half of the south pier was completed
in 1904. A description of the method of construction may be seen in
Appendix A A A, page 3779, of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1904. During the following two years but little was
accomplished in the way of construction at the Superior Entry on
account of the destruction of protective works by storms. Work on
the concrete piers was ordered discontinued by the Chief of Engineers
August 21, 1906, pending the consideration of a report by a board of
engineers.
   Work on the modified project, in accordance with the act of March
2, 1907, was commenced in the spring of 1907, and has been in progress
since that time. The results accomplished are stated in detail else-
where in this report and in the annual reports for previous years. Up
to June 30, 1909, about 44 per cent of this projected improvement
has been accomplished.
   The lake commerce of this port, Duluth-Superior, during the last
season of navigation (1908) amounted to 23,797,162 tons (of 2,000
pounds), valued at $223,114,320, and from the beginning of improve-
ments by the Government in 1867 to 1908, inclusive, the vessel freight
entering and departing has amounted to 265,979,134 tons (of 2,000
pounds), valued at $3,103,779,620.
   It is believed that the tonnage of Duluth-Superior Harbor is now
exceeded by that of but two ports in the United States-New York
and Philadelphia.
   The vessel freight of Duluth-Superior Harbor for 1908 was 57 per
cent of the amount which passed the Sault locks the same year.
   For a comparison between the cost of improvements and the
volume of commerce, it may be stated here that the total amount of
money expended by the Government on the improvement of this
harbor from the commencement of work in 1867 up to June 30, 1909,
is $5,941,155.83. The vessel freight received and shipped at this
port during the same period was 265,979,134 tons, and its market
value was $3,103,779,620. From this it appears that the cost of
government improvements has been less than one-fifth of 1 per cent
of the value of the freight transported.
   The annual expense of government operations at this harbor, con-
sisting of maintenance, interest on the total cost of improvements to
date, and depreciation, is approximately $284,852. This annual
expense, when compared with the commerce of the harbor, amounts
to about 1 cent for each ton of the vessel freight for the year 1908.
Compared with the value of the commerce the annual expense
amounts to about one-eighth of 1 per cent of the value of the ves-
sel freight for the same year. For a further comparison it appears
that the annual expense is only about one-half of 1 per cent of the
saving in cost of transportation by water as compared with rail rates,
on the same freight for the year 1908. Further details may be seen
in Table 4, Appendix I I 3, of this report.
   Effect of project on freight rates: It may not be possible to give
exact figures showing the effect of the improvements of this harbor
on freight rates, but the following statements have a bearing on the
question:
   The average rate on freight passing through St. Marys Falls canals
in 1908 was 0.69 mill per mile per ton, and the average haul was 842
miles, as shown by the official records. If the same freight had been
666        REPORT OF THE CHIEF                OF ENGINEERS,          U.   S. ARMY.


carried by rail, the rate would probably have been as much as 3 mills
per ton-mile, making a difference of 2.3 mills per ton-mile.
   Assuming this difference to apply to freight for Duluth-Superior
Harbor, and that the average haul is 842 miles, the saving in cost of
transportation by water would be $1.94 per ton, and for the 23,797,162
tons received and shipped at this harbor in 1908 the saving in cost
amounts to about $46,000,000 in that one year.
   The saving in cost of this large sum has, of course, been made pos-
sible by the government improvements, not only at this harbor, but
at St. Marys River and at other points between here and the Lake
Erie ports, and it is not known just how much of the above saving
should be credited to the Duluth-Superior improvements. It is evi-
dent, however, that with any reasonable proportion of such saving in
transportation accredited to the improvements at this harbor, which
form an essential and necessary part of the whole waterway, the cost
of such improvements must be only a small fraction of the saving in
freight rates effected thereby.a
   The foregoing saving to shippers is based upon a comparison of
existing rates of transportation by water and rail. In addition to
this it should be said that the rail rates are reduced or kept down by
the competition of the waterway, and in that way a further saving in
transportation is effected. The two modes of transportation having
developed contemporaneously during the last half century, it would
be hard to say what the railroad rates would be if the Great Lakes
waterway with its government improvements did not exist, but there
is hardly room for doubt that they would be materially higher.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure in fiscal year
ending June 30, 1911, consists of the following items:
(a) Dredging to complete anchorage basin at Duluth, Minn., this work
  being for the extension of benefits....................................... $350, 800.00
(b) Continuing improvements at the Superior Entry, the work proposed
  being necessary to make the improvement available, as follows:
    For completion of concrete superstructure to the breakwater heads of
      north and south rubble mound breakwaters .....................                   50, 500. 00
    For completing north and south rubble mound breakwaters........                   255, 530. 00
    Removal of old timber cribs....................................................    19, 000.00
    Dredging north side of inner channel as shown on sheet 3 (Report
      of Board of Engineers approved April 5, 1907) ................                   64, 368.00

                                                                                      389, 398. 00
    Administration and contingencies, 20 per cent.....................                 77, 879. 60
                                                                                      467, 277.60

       Grand total for improvement.................................                   818, 077.60
(c) For maintenance.................................................                   25, 000. 00
        Total for improvement and maintenance .......................                 843, 077. 60

   a A similar saving in freight rates applies to other harbors in the Duluth district
which have railroad connections and where harbor improvements executed by the
Government (or in part at private cost) have opened up these harbors to interlake
navigation and commerce. The above-named amount of saving in cost of transporta-
tion, $1.94 per ton, will be considered as also applying approximately to the harbors
of Agate Bay, Ashland, Ontonagon, Marquette, Marquette Bay, Grand Marais (Mich.),
and the local harbors of the Keweenaw waterway, subject to more or less error, accord-
ing to different local conditions, such as the class of freight, its destination, number
of competing railroads, facility of handling freight by boat and by rail, etc. (See
Table 4, Appendix I I 3, of this report.)
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               667
   With regard to the maintenance of improvements in this harbor,
it is believed that this could be advantageously provided for by an
annual allotment.
   With 49 miles of harbor frontage, 17 miles of 20-foot channels,
and the handling of over 23,000,000 tons of freight in the past year,
tLere is necessity for the closest inspection, by a special patrol pro-
vided with a steam tug, to prevent injurious deposits, encroachments
of wharves and other private structures, the enforcement of rules
regarding the rafting of logs, the anchorage of vessels, the opening
of draws, and the care of United States property. These, with the
discovery and removal of shoals, repairs to government piers, the
care of parks, and the collection of complete and reliable commercial
statistics, which has already proven of great value, it is thought could
best be cared for by congressional action authorizing allotments or
appropriations to be made on estimates submitted.
   For reports of examinations and surveys of Duluth-Superior
Harbor, see the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906,
page 565, where references are given. See also Annual Report for
1907, Appendix J J, page 1833, and Annual Report for 1908, page
648.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................                             $762, 735.72
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 . ..................      ...... ......................                         470, 000.00
                                                                                              1, 232, 735. 72
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement....................   ...                        $487,488.05
    For maintenance of improvement..................                            40, 0O0. 00
                                                                                                527, 488. 05
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......------------------------........---.................     705, 247.67
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.--..        ...........................                    20, 984. 36
July 1, 1909, balance available-----------------------------............------.......           684, 263. 31
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts........ ....                               170, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ......                         1, 043, 799. 20
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
   30, 1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive
   of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ........................                              843, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix I I 3.)
   4. Harbor at Port Wing, Wis.-The harbor of Port Wing, formed
by the mouth of Flag River, is situated on the south shore of Lake
Superior, about 33 miles from the head of the lake.
   Before improvement the depth at entrance was small and variable.
It was 2 or 3 feet at times, and at other times the entrance was closed
entirely.
   Previous to government operations the harbor had been improved
by private parties to some extent. The entrance had been jettied, but
imperfectly and with only partial success, and dredging was necessary
every spring for removing a sand bar. Within the harbor much
dredging had been done to accommodate the lumber business.
   In accordance with the provisions of the act of Congress approved
March 3, 1899, a report upon a survey of this harbor with a project
for its improvement was submitted on November 20, 1899.
668     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, t.          S. ARMY.

   This project provided for the construction of two parallel piers of
piling, filled in with slabs and topped with large rock. These piers
were to be located 200 feet apart and to be 800 feet and 825 feet long,
respectively. A channel 150 feet wide and 15 feet deep was to be
dredged between the piers and for 500 feet along the slough. The
estimated cost of the improvement was $44,992, increased in 1908
to $56,539, on account of underestimate for dredging in the original
estimate.
   By act of Congress approved June 13, 1902, the project was
adopted; the village of Port Wing conveyed to the United States
without cost 7 acres of land at the harbor entrance needed for the im-
provement, and the work of improvement was commenced in 1903.
   The amount expended on this work to the close of the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909, exclusive of outstanding liabilities, was
$46,991.66, of which $5,689.71 was for maintenance.
   Operations during the year consisted in dredging for the removal
of shoals, between the dates of April 22 and May 3, 1909, 7,015
yards at contract cost of $1,245.16. This partially removed the
shoals and opened a narrow passage which would accommodate any
vessels wishing to do business there. The dredge then proceeded
to the work of removing shoals elsewhere, and later will return and
complete the dredging of shoals at Port Wing.
   The following results have been accomplished: The two entrance
piers built, with lengths of 800 and 601 feet, respectively; 45 feet of
pile revetment at the inner end of the east pier; dredging which gave
an entrance channel 15 feet deep at low water, 100 feet wide, and
extending from deep water in the lake through to a distance of 200
feet inside of the inner end of the east pier; a portion of the turning
slip, extending 70 feet to the east, past the inner end of the east pier,
with a width of 80 feet and a depth of 14 to 16 feet; a pile revetment
100 feet long at the inner end of the west pier, and maintenance of
improvement by dredging of shoals and repairs to the piers.
   A maximum draft of 14 feet can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest portion under improvement. The usual
variation of water level extends from mean low water (low-water
datum) to 1 foot above datum. The entrance piers have been
effective in reducing shoaling very materially.
   Private dredging extended a navigable channel to a distance of
about 2,500 feet southerly from the entrance, and this improvement
marked the limit of navigation on Flag River. This stretch of river
has been redredged from time to time by private enterprise, and the
lower portion has an available depth of probably 14 feet for a short
distance from the entrance, while the upper portion is now badly
shoaled.
   The vessel freight of this harbor was 64 arrivals and departures,
with 31,127 tons (of 2,000 pounds), valued at $305,000, in 1901, and
288 arrivals and departures, with 23,100 tons (of 2,000 pounds),
valued at $312,941, in 1908.
   The freight tonnage in 1908 was but 22 per cent of that for the
previous year, owing to the general business depression.
   The total freight of this port for the six years 1903 to 1908, inclu-
sive, since the date of commencement of government improvements,
was 299,294 tons of 2,000 pounds.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  669
   The total expenditures by the Government for this harbor to date
are only 1i per cent of.the value of the vessel freight received and
shipped during the period covered by these expenditures.
   The annual expense of government improvements at this harbor,
consisting of maintenance, interest, and depreciation, is approxi-
mately $3,426. This amounts to 1 cent per ton of the vesesi freight
for 1908, and to 11 per cent of the value of this freight. Further
details may be seen in Table 4, Appendix I I 4, of this report.
   Effect of project on freight rates: This harbor has only water
transportation for the movement of its freight, and for this reason no
comparison can be made with freight charges by railroad.
   The construction of a harbor here has been an essential factor in
the development of the commerce of Port Wing. There was no com-
merce to mention previous to these improvements. In 1907 it
amounted to nearly a million dollars.
   The principal sawmill of this place, which had shut down in June,
1905, as noted in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1905, page 1990, resumed operations in the spring of 1907, with a
prospect for continuous work for many years. Other timber
products and a good brownstone quarry add materially to the vessel
business.
   A revised estimate gives $15,237 as the amount required for com-
pleting the approved project. Details may be seen in the report of
the district officer for 1908.
   It is proposed to expend the sum recommended to be appropriated
for this harbor for the completion of the project, consisting mainly
of dredging to give full dimensions of channels, and for maintenance
in removing shoals and for repairs to the entrance piers. These ex-
penditures will result in an extension of the benefits to navigation.
   A more detailed description of the harbor may be seen in House
Document No. 114, Fifty-sixth Congress, first session, and in Bulletin
No. 18, Survey of the Northern and Northwestern Lakes, page 75.
   For reports on examinations and surveys, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 568, where references are given.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended----------....---.........------------.............----......---....      $0. 34
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909.............................................................                                 5,000.00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................................                                5, 000. 34
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities......................................                               100.00

July 1, 1909, balance available.....................................                                   4, 900.34

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................... 4, 400. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...-...... 15, 237. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year en:: :          30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance,         c.   of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909.................................... 20, 237.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix I I 4.)
  5. Harbor at Ashland, Wis.-Ashland Harbor is located at the
head of Chequamegon Bay, and originally had no protection from
670     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.


the waves which rolled into the bay nor from waves generated within
the bay itself by storms.
   The natural depth at the entrance, and through the bay up to
the vicinity of the present harbor line along a large part of the city
front, was at least 19 feet at mean low water, requiring no dredging
except for private slips, but for the southwest part of the city front
shoaler water is found, which required the dredging of a public
channel in front of the harbor line.
   The original project, approved December 7, 1888, and modified
February 9, 1889, was for the constructing of a pile, slab, and rock
breakwater 8,000 feet long, and for dredging a channel in front of the
wharves of the city.
   The original estimates of cost were, for dredging, $65,540; for
breakwater, $165,760.
   The act of March 3, 1899, added to this project by authorizing an
extension of the breakwater to the shore, thus requiring the ultimate
construction of 10,200 feet of breakwater. The emergency river and
harbor act of June 6, 1900, provided that the appropriation already
made should be expended in building a shore spur 4,700 feet in length
from a point 2,600 feet east of the prolongation of the present break-
water and parallel thereto. This again changed the project, adding
greatly to the total length of breakwater to be constructed and largely
to the total expense.
   The total amount expended on this project and its modifications up
to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, not including out-
standing liabilities, is $456,820.22, of which amount $261,555.06 has
been applied to the maintenance of the improvement.
   Under this project and its two modifications there have been con-
structed 7,454 feet of breakwater on the original line and 842 feet on
the line fixed by the act of June 6, 1900.
   Of the 7,454 feet on the original line 91 feet is detached and uncom-
pleted work near shore and 7,363 feet is completed breakwater in one
piece.
   The pile, slab, and rock breakwater on the original line is in very
poor condition, and has required large expenditures for maintenance.
   The work of revetting this structure with riprap so as to form a
permanent rubble-mound breakwater, with the old structure for a
hearting, was begun in May, 1903, and has continued with more or
less work each year up to the present date, under three successive
contracts. Under each of these contracts the plant was small and
the rate of progress rather slow, but the low prices obtained under
competitive bids compensated in a measure for the greater length of
time required. A diagram showing the method of reenforcing the
breakwater may be seen in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1905, page 1992.
   Operations for the fiscal year consisted in the continuation of the
work of revetment of the breakwater, on the above described plan,
from July 1, 1908, to November 18, when the existing contract
was completed. The results accomplished during this period was
the revetment of a linear distance of 1,623 feet of the breakwater,
which required the placing of 43,116 tons of rock, at a contract cost
of 99 cents per ton, or $42,684.84. This work is for maintenance.
   On June 30, 1909, the total distance revetted was 6,905 feet,
which is 94 per cent of the entire length of the present breakwater.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      671
   The work done gives a protected area of about 1,600 acres and
affords safe anchorage and dockage for a distance of 3 miles along
the city front.
   The usefulness of the breakwater was in evidence when the north-
east storm of September 2-3, 1905, caused considerable damage to the
village of Washburn, across the bay from Ashland, breaking in 10 of
the doors of the large flour shed of the Northwestern Railway Com-
pany and cutting away the embankment of the railroad approach,
while the numerous docks along the Ashland Harbor front under the
protection of the breakwater escaped injury. This storm seriously
damaged the breakwater itself along the portions which had not been
strengthened by the rock embankment.
   Dredging by the Government in the years 1897, 1903, and 1907
constructed a channel which has a length of 5,760 feet and extends in
front of the existing wharves of the city where the original depth of
water was not already sufficient for navigation. This channel now
has a width of 80 to 120 feet for a depth of 20 feet or more at mean
low water and a somewhat greater width for an 18-foot depth. The
width is not as great as it should be.
   The dredgings from this channel have been deposited alongside the
government breakwater to form an earth embankment and lessen the
amount of rock required for the revetment.
   Easterly from the dredged channel the natural depth of the bay in
front of the harbor line is a little more than 19 feet at mean low water
and sufficient for the present needs of commerce.
   The usual variation of level of the water surface is from about 0 to
 + 1 foot, referred to mean low water.
   The commerce of this port carried by vessels consists principally of
iron ore and lumber exported, and coal, mineral oil, and general mer-
chandise imported. (With the commerce of Ashland are included
the towns of Washburn and Bayfield, unless otherwise stated.)
   The commerce has increased during the twenty-two years the har-
bor has been under improvement by the United States from 892 ar-
rivals and clearances, with cargo tonnage of 1,400,000 tons (of 2,000
pounds), in 1887, to 1,490 arrivals and clearances, with cargo tonnage
of 3,658,530 tons (of 2,000 pounds), valued at $17,738,143, in 1908.
The total commerce from 1887 to 1908, inclusive, is estimated at
73,607,250 tons (of 2,000 pounds), valued at $526,624,067, exclusive
of logs towed in rafts.
   The total expenditures by the Government for this harbor to date
are only one-eleventh of 1 per cent of the value of the vessel freight
received and shipped during the period covered by these expendi-
tures.
   The annual expense of Government improvements at this harbor,
consisting of maintenance, interest, and depreciation, is approxi-
mately $23,605 and amounts to $0.006 per ton of the vessel freight
for 1908 (for Ashland alone), to one-tenth of 1 per cent of the value of
this freight, and to one-third of 1 per cent of the saving in the cost of
transportation on the same freight, by water as compared with rail
rates. Further details of these comparisons may be seen in Table 4,
Appendix I I 5, of this report.
   Effect of project on freight rates: The estimated saving in cost of
transportation by water over that by rail is $1.94 per ton, which is
more than $6,000,000, for the business of this port in 1908. (See
672        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                            U.     S. ARMY.


also page 633 of Annual Report of Chief of Engineers for 1908, and
Table 3 of Appendix J J 5.)
   The protection to the commerce of Ashland alone afforded by gov-
ernment improvements is fully stated in another part of this report.
   The extension of the breakwater for a distance of 637 feet to the
west, as required for completion to the projected length of 8,000 feet,
has been delayed for some years past in order to strengthen the por-
tion already built. It is now believed that the execution of this ex-
tension should be taken up at once. The district officer has submitted
an estimate for this extension (see Appendix I I 5), in which the de-
tails of the original plan are changed so as to substitute for the original
piles and slabs a rubble mound, resting on a fill of earth from dredgings
deposited without cost to the United States, the rubble mound to be
built of rough quarried stone, and of simple construction, and to be
terminated at the west end by a pierhead built of timber, rock, and
concrete, for a landing and for a suitable finish to the breakwater, and
to provide a base for a light-house and fog signal. The cost of this
extension is estimated at $50,172. The original estimate, for the pile
and slab construction, was $25,811, but at current prices this would
be increased to $64,974, so that the proposed modification in detail is
a desirable one on account of both permanency and economy. It has
accordingly been adopted by this office.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure in fiscal year
ending June 30, 1911, will be applied as follows:
For improvement to widen channel to 200 feet .............................     $25, 000
For extending breakwater 637 feet (in part) ----------
                                              ............-...........-----.. . 35, 000
       Total for improvement .....................          .........        ...   ..........      60, 000

For maintenance and contingencies (in addition to unexpended balance) ....                          5, 000
  The additional work proposed is for the purpose of extension of
benefits to navigation and commerce.                      Additional details regarding
the work proposed may be seen in Appendix I I 5.
  References: Map in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1903, page 1812. Lake Survey chart of the Apostle Islands, including
Chequamegon Bay, catalogue No. 962. Lake Survey Bulletin No. 18,
page 41. For reports on examinations and surveys, see Annual Re-
port of Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 570, where references are
given.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, authorized a preliminary
examination of "Ashland Harbor, with a view to widening the channel
to four hundred feet, or to such width as may be deemed suitable for
the needs of commerce." Report thereon will be submitted to Con-
gress at its next session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                  $64, 412. 84
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909. . .................     ........-            ............ ...... ...... 25, 000. 00

                                                                                                89, 412. 84
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement . .......................--------------------------------------------.              56, 733. 06

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                           32, 679. 78
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              673
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............    $25, 000.00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 311, 500. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ..............      .................    65, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix I I 5.)
   6. Harbor at Ontonagon, Mich.-The entrance to Ontonagon River,
which forms the harbor, had but 6 or 7 feet deptha in 1867, at which
time the project for securing 12 feet depth by building parallel piers
on either side of the mouth, extending to the 18-foot curve of depth
in Lake Superior, and dredging a channel between the piers, was
adopted. Estimated cost, $363,770. The west pier was built to a
length of 2,675 feet and the east pier to a length of 2,315 feet. This
brought the outer end of the west pier very nearly to the 18-foot
curve of depth, as proposed.
   As far as new work is concerned the project has been completed
since 1889, and since then expenditures have been only for keeping
a 12-foot channel open by dredging and for the repairs to the piers.
   The amount expended on this improvement up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, not including outstanding liabili-
ties, is $378,279.26, of which sum $93,478.02 has been spent for
maintenance of the improvements.
   Operations during the last fiscal year were for maintenance, by
the dredging of shoals from the entrance. This dredging was done
in May and June, 1909, to the extent of 39,257 yards, at a contract
cost of $7,027. Work not completed at date of this report. This
dredging has made a narrow channel through the bars which had
formed, giving a depth of 15 feet or more for a width of 40 to 50 feet,
from the lake and through the piers and up to the north end of the
lumber dock on the west side of the harbor. About 13 feet is the
available depth up to the north end of the Commercial Dock, on the
east side of the harbor.
   The amount of dredging done from year to year since the com-
pletion of the project for maintaining a 12-foot depth through the
entrance is shown in tabular form in Appendix I 1 6. From this it
will be seen that the amount of shoaling previous to 1905 was gen-
erally small, but that for the last five years it has been abnormally
great. The cause of this recent shoaling is not fully understood, but
a discussion of the subject may be seen in House Document 444,
Sixtieth Congress, first session, pages 3-5. The floods which bring
down the sediment do not occur every year, as a rule, but provision
should be made for relieving the situation when they do occur.
   The usual variation of water level extends from 0 to + 1 foot above
low-water datum.
   In 1867 there were 449 arrivals and departures, with 5,000 tons
of cargo, and in 1908 there were 366 arrivals and departures, with
13,049 tons (of 2,000 pounds) of cargo, valued at $254,022.
                  a The datum plane for these depths is not known.
       9001-ENG 1909-43
674           REPORT          OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                  S.   ARMY.

   The commerce of this port since the commencement of operations
by the United States is estimated at 2,808,052 tons (of 2,000 pounds),
valued at $75,365,517.
   The amount of freight received and shipped in 1908 was greater
by 78 per cent than in 1907, but in value of freight it was 26 per cent
less than in 1907.
   The total expenditures by the Government for this harbor to date
are one-half of 1 per cent of the value of the vessel freight received
and shipped during the period covered by these expenditures.
   The annual expense of government operations at this harbor, con-
sisting of maintenance, interest, and depreciation, is approximately
$19,314. This amounts to $1.48 per ton of vessel freight for the
year 1908, to 7.6 per cent of the value of this freight, and is 76 per
cent of the saving in the cost of transportation on this freight by
water as compared with rail rates. Details of these comparisons
may be seen in Table 4, Appendix I I 6.
   Effect of project on freight rates: The estimated saving in cost of
transportation by water over that by rail is $1.94 per ton, or $25,315
for the lake commerce of this port in 1908. As the former condition
of the river was unsuited to navigation, this saving in freight rates
may be considered as effected by United States improvements.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure in fiscal year
ending June 30, 1911, will be applied as follows: For maintenance,
consisting of dredging for the removal of shoals, repairs to piers, and
administration, $10,000.
   The work proposed is for the purpose of making the improvements
available and for extension of benefits to navigation and commerce.
   References: For reports on examinations and surveys, see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 571, where references
are given; also page 647 of Annual Report for 1908.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, authorized a preliminary
examination of Ontonagon Harbor. The questions under considera-
tion are (a) whether the project should be modified so as to provide
for deeper dredging of the entrance channel, and (b) how far to extend
the government dredging within the inner harbor. Report thereon
will be submitted to Congress at its next session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................   $831.76
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........... ..............        .....................   20, 000.00
                                                                                                                 20, 831. 76
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement....................................--------------------------------....-------------............      983.02
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...............................                                            . 19, 848. 74
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................... 10, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..........................--     ................. 10, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix I I 6.)
  7. Waterway across Keweenaw Point, from Keweenaw Bay to
Lake Superior, Michigan.-This work was formerly reported on as
                 RIVER AND      HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                  675
the Portage Lake and Lake Superior canals, across Keweenaw Point,
Michigan.
   In accordance with the provisions of the river and harbor act of
September 19, 1890, the United States purchased and assumed the
charge and care of these canals on August 3, 1891.
   At the time of the purchase by the United States there was a very
poor 13-foot navigation; a the channel was narrow and crooked, with
many sharp bends; it was poorly marked and lighted; the entrance
piers were in a very bad condition; the revetments were decayed or
entirely gone, and there was a tax on the commerce through the
canals in the shape of a tonnage charge.
   The original project, adopted January 24, 1887, was-
   1. For a 16-foot channel of 70 feet bottom width from bay to lake.
   2. A renewal of the canal revetments.
   3. A reconstruction of the piers at the Lake Superior entrance and
their extension to 30 feet depth of water.
   4. The extension of the pier at the Keweenaw entrance to a 20-foot
depth of water.
   5. At the proper time to increase the channel depth to 20 feet, with
a corresponding width, which should not be less than 120 feet.
   The sum expended in the purchase of the canals, lands, etc., and on
items 1 and 2 of the original project was $850,000.
   The act of June 3, 1896, authorized continuing contracts to com-
plete items 1, 2, 3, and 4 of the above project to the amount of
$1,115,000.
   By modification approved March 15, 1898, the width and depth
were to be increased to 120 feet and 20 feet, respectively, as originally
contemplated.
   The total amount expended on the original project and its modifi-
cations up to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, not in-
cluding outstanding liabilities, was $1,338,431.39, of which about
$39,000 was expended for maintenance.
   The entire project, including the modification for 20-foot depth and
120-foot width, was completed at a cost of only $45,000 in excess of
the estimate for the 16-foot depth, or $715,000 less than the estimated
cost of the larger project.
   The expenditures during the year were in payment of dredging done
in June, 1908.
   As a result of government improvements (together with the
earlier private improvements) this waterway has a clear width of
120 feet and a clear depth of 20 feet at low water datum (mean low
water) throughout its entire length, and with a greater width on bends
in the channel.
   The available balance of the appropriation for improvement was
intended for renewal of the old revetments, but it is believed that those
remaining may not need renewal, and the money will be held until
the necessity shall be demonstrated.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, through
the waterway is 20 feet at mean low water.
   The usual variation of water level extends from about 0 to + 1 foot,
referred to low-water datum.
              a The plane of reference for this depth is not known.
676      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

   Certain important additional improvements have been recom-
mended for this waterway, as follows:
   A harbor of refuge near the lower or easterly end of the waterway,
somewhat similar to the one known as Lily Pond at the upper or
westerly end, where vessels can find facilities for mooring and lying in
safety during heavy weather. A preliminary examination, together
with surveys, plans, and estimates, had been duly authorized and
reported. The report was printed in House Document No. 325, Sixtieth
Congress, first session, and attention is invited to same.
   An improvemrient to the upper entrance to the waterway has been
recommended by the district officer and concurred in by the divi-
sion engineer, namely, to deepen the stilling basin-that is, the pro-
tected area just within the breakwaters-by dredging out the shoal
portions to a minimum depth of 22 feet within a radius of about
1,700 feet from the outer opening between the breakwater ends and
removing the outer portions of the old timber revetment piers, which
are located at the entrance from the stilling basin to the canal proper,
to within 200 or 300 feet of the shore line and about 1,700 feet from
the outer opening from the lake. This would give more room for
vessels, which is much needed in making the entrance during heavy
winds in order to right themselves after passing the outer entrance
and head for the channel between the revetment piers.
   At present the distance from the outer entrance to the channel is
so small (about 1,280 feet) and the deep water in the stilling basin
is so narrow that vessels experience trouble in making the inner
entrance during storms. Since the completion of the breakwaters in
1902 nine vessels have gone on the bottom within the outer entrance
on that account, and five of these vessels required assistance from
the life-saving crew. The proposed improvement would be of great
value to navigation, and is worthy of careful consideration.
   During the navigation season of 1908 the commerce through the
waterway amounted to 959,738 short tons of freight, valued at
$45,072,212. There were also 10,229 passengers carried.
   This commerce is the through commerce of the waterway only.
The local commerce, or commerce between ports within the water-
way and points outside, amounted to 1,304,176 short tons, valued
at $32,251,686. Previous to 1907 the through and local commerce
was combined, therefore no comparison is made of the commerce of
1908 with previous years.
   There was also a small local business between the ports on the
waterway (Houghton, Hancock, Dollar Bay, Lake Linden, Hubbell,
and Chassell) not included in the foregoing, the amount of which is
not known.
   Effect of project on freight rates: Based on the above commerce,
the estimated saving of $1.94 per ton in freight rates by water over
railroad rates amounts to two and one-half millions of dollars. This
business would not be possible except for the improvements to this
waterway, which the Government has either executed itself or paid
for by purchase.
   This waterway also serves a useful purpose as a harbor of refuge,
and is much used by vessels bound up or down doing business at the
head of the lake, particularly during the stormy season in the fall of
the year. As many as 46 vessels have been tied up at one time at
Lily Pond waiting for weather. By lessening the danger and risks
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      677
of navigation in this manner, to whatever degree, makes this water-
way to that extent a factor in the reduction of cost of transportation.
   For reports on examinations and surveys, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 574, where references are given;
also House Document No. 325, Sixtieth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .. . .....                              ........        .............      $4, 543. 18
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment-----------------.....--------..........--..-----............---------------.....-------.............  2, 736. 89
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........................................                                1, 806. 29
    (See Appendix I I 7.)
    8. Operating and care of waterway across Keweenaw Point from
Keweenaw Bay to Lake Superior, Michigan.-Duringthe fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1909, the sum of $12,000 from the permanent indefinite
appropriation of July 5, 1884, as amended and reenacted by section
6 of the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, was expended in repairs
to the breakwaters, in dredging, in superintendence and general opera-
tion of the canals, guarding against encroachments on the channels by
private parties and corporations, on surveys and mapping of the water-
way, the collection of commercial statistics, the cutting of trees from
government lands adjoining the waterway which had been burnt over
in the season of 1908, and of additional green timber, to the number
of 1,804 logs altogether, of hemlock and other timber, the sawing of
these logs into timber, planks, and lumber, amounting to a total of
162,618 feet b. m., for use in repairs to government works on the
waterway, etc.
   An allotment of $16,000 from the same source for the same pur-
pose has been made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.
   To June 30, 1909, $194,207.64 had been expended on this work.
   For further details see report on this work by the district officer.
   (See Appendix I I 7.)
   9. Harbor at Marquette, Mich.-This harbor, which had a natural
depth of 18 feet or more at mean low water, afforded no protection to
vessels from easterly or northeasterly storms, and projects were
approved in 1867 and 1887 for the construction of a breakwater com-
posed of cribs filled with rock and projecting from the shore into the
bay a distance of 3,000 feet. This breakwater was finished in 1894
practically as projected, but since its commencement extensive
repairs have been made to the superstructure.
   The amount expended up to the commencement of operations upon
the new project was $469,732.44.
   A project for a concrete superstructure was approved February 27,
1890. Its estimated cost was $232,936.71.
   Work on this concrete superstructure was begun in the spring of
1895, and it is now built to a length of 2,920 feet, which is 97 per cent
of the entire length. It is 100 feet short of the end of the old break-
water, and all that remains to complete the existing project is to build
a pierhead and connect it with the finished work.
   The amount expended on the new project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, not including outstanding liabilities,
was $200,111.85, of which $19,769.83 was spent for maintenance.
   The expenditure during the year was for incidental expenses and
contingencies.
678      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,          U.   S. ARMY.

   The work done has resulted in the protection of the ore, coal,
lumber, and commercial docks from storms, and has shown the
efficiency of the concrete breakwater.
   A preliminary examination and a survey of Marquette Harbor and
vicinity, "with a view to ascertaining whether further harbor of
refuge facilities are needed, and if so, at what point," authorized by
the river and harbor act approved June 13, 1902, were made by the
district officers, who express the opinion that greater refuge facilities
are needed in this vicinity; that Marquette Harbor is the best place
for such improvement; and that the additional shelter should be
secured by extending the present breakwater for a distance of 1,500
feet, at an estimated cost of $303,000. The reports on this subject
were transmitted to Congress by the Secretary of War December 16,
1903, and printed in House Document No. 161, Fifty-eighth Congress,
second session. They are also printed in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1904, Appendix I I, page 2786. The docu-
ment is accompanied by a map of the harbor.
   If provision be made by Congress for this extension, no pierhead
will be required at the present end of the breakwater, but before be-
ginning the extension the regular form of concrete superstructure
would have to be continued over the gap of 100 feet which now re-
mains. This would cost $6,000, and the money could be taken from
the funds now held in reserve for further improvement ($21,391)
awaiting the decision of Congress on this matter.
   Between the breakwater and the ore docks to the west there is
generally from 20 to 30 feet of water, except at the northerly 400
feet of the harbor, where the depth at low-water datum is only 14 to
18 feet. This shallow water makes it difficult for vessels doing busi-
ness at the ore docks at the north end of the harbor, besides somewhat
restricting the area available for harbor of refuge purposes, and at
least a portion of this area should be dredged to a clear depth of 21
feet at low-water datum.
   For the maintenance of the breakwater the sum of $10,000 should
be appropriated biennially.
   The usual variation of water level extends from 0 to + 1 foot above
low-water datum.
   The vessel commerce of this port was 780 arrivals and clearances
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1872, with a registered tonnage
of 370,000 tons, and 316 arrivals and clearances in 1908, carrying
904,979 short tons, valued at $5,039,917.
   The total commerce from 1867 to 1908, inclusive, is estimated at
25,001,977 short tons, valued at $139,494,336.
   The total expenditures by the Government for this harbor to date
are one-half of 1 per cent of the value of the vessel freight received and
shipped during the period covered by those expenditures.
    The commerce of the neighboring harbor of Marquette Bay, 3 miles
distant, is also benefited by the improvements at Marquette, as vessels
working at Marquette Bay have to run to Marquette for protection
in time of severe storms.
   The combined commerce of the two ports thus benefited consisted
of 601 arrivals and clearances in the calendar year 1908, with
1,644,088 net registered tonnage, and 2,000,222 tons of freight received
and shipped, valued at $7,697,898.
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                  679
   The total commerce of these two ports from the commencement of
government improvements in 1867 to 1908, inclusive, is estimated at
43,169,572 short tons, valued at $187,592,411.
   The annual expense of government operations at this harbor, con-
sisting of maintenance, interest, and depreciation, is approximately
$37,775. This amounts to $0.04 per ton of vessel freight of Mar-
quette for the year 1908, to three-fourths of 1 per cent of the value
of this freight, and is nearly 2 per cent of the saving in the cost of
transportation on this freight by water as compared with rail rates.
Details of these comparisons may be seen in Table 4 of Appendix I I 8,
of this report.
   Effect of project on freight rates: Taking the estimated saving in
cost of transportation by water over that by rail as $1.94 per ton, as
per Table 4 of this report, and the amount of vessel freight in 1908
as 1,027,715 tons (exclusive of the business done at Presque Isle),
makes a total saving of about $2,000,000 for the one year. This may
be said to have been affected by government improvements, as lake
commerce could not otherwise be transacted at that locality.
   It is proposed to expend the appropriation recommended and the
available balance (except $21,391 held in reserve for further im-
provement) for maintenance.
    For reports of examinations and surveys, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 576, where references are given.
    The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, authorized a preliminary
examination of Marquette Harbor, and report will be submitted to
Congress at its next session. This investigation was called for with
a view to determining the advisability of changing the direction of the
extension of the breakwater recommended under the act of 1902, but
not yet appropriated for, and removing some shoal areas by dredging.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......... .........                      ........ $28, 306. 18
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement ................     .......................................               561. 78

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................                  27, 744. 40
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909......        ............................                    10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix I I 8.)
   10. Harbor of refuge, Marquette Bay, Michigan.-Marquette Bay,
also known as Presque Isle Harbor, is a small bay within the city
limits of Marquette, north of Marquette Harbor, and distant 3 miles
therefrom.
   The bay is about 1 miles long and extends into the shore about
one-half mile. The natural depth over the greater part of this area
was from 18 to 20 feet at low water, and dredging by the United
States has not been considered necessary.
   Before improvement the locality was fully exposed to storms from
the east and northeast, and comparatively little shipping was done.
   A resolution of Congress, approved March 20, 1896, directed the
Secretary of War to make a survey and submit an estimate for a
breakwater in this bay. The results of this survey, with estimates
680      REPORT OF THE CHIEF       OF ENGINEERS,    U.   S. ARMY.

amounting to $20,000 for breakwater 500 feet long and $50,000 for
construction of one 1,000 feet long, are published in House Document
No. 318, Fifty-fourth Congress, first session.
   The project adopted by the act of June 3, 1896, is to build a break-
water 1,000 feet in length off Presque Isle Point.
   This breakwater was built to its full length in the years 1897-1900.
   The act of Congress approved June 13, 1902, provided that a por-
tion of the appropriation for Marquette Harbor "not exceeding seven
thousand five .hundred dollars may be expended in connecting the
Presque Isle breakwater with the shore."
   Under this provision the gap between the breakwater and shore was
closed, in the fall of 1902, by a timber pier 216 feet long and 100
linear feet of shore revetment constructed.
   No additional work is proposed except for maintenance.
   The total amount expended on the project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, not including outstanding liabili-
ties, was $57,758.16, of which $2,701.82 was expended for mainte-
nance. The expenditures during the year were for contingencies.
   The work done has enabled vessels to lie at the ore pier and other
docks in the vicinity in ordinary weather and moderate storms, and
shipping has increased greatly.
   This harbor is largely used for commercial purposes, but not as a
harbor of refuge.
   Vessels drawing 19 feet can reach the ore pier at mean low water.
   The usual variation of water level extends from 0 to + 1 foot above
low-water datum.
   The lake commerce of this port in 1897 amounted to 1,100 arrivals
and departures, with 1,095,243 tons of freight. In 1908 the lake com-
merce amounted to 285 arrivals and departures, with 972,507 short
tons of freight, valued at $2,657,981.
   The total commerce from 1897 to 1908, inclusive, is estimated at
18,167,595 short tons, valued at $48,098,075.
   The total expenditures by the Government for this harbor to date
are one-eighth of 1 per cent of the value of the vessel freight received
and shipped during the period covered by these expenditures.
   The annual expense of government operations at this harbor, con-
sisting of maintenance, interest, and depreciation, is approximately
$3,528. This amounts to $0.004 per ton of vessel freight for the year
1908, to one-third of 1 per cent of the value of this freight, and is less
than one-fifth of 1 per cent of the saving in the cost of transportation
on this freight by water as compared with rail rates. (See Table 4,
Appendix I I 10, of this report.)
   Effect of project on freight rates: The saving in cost of transporta-
tion by water of 1908 freight over the cost by rail, at the estimated
figure of $1.94 per ton, as in Table 4 of this report, amounts to
 $1,886,664. This was made practicable by the government break-
water at this locality. This harbor, as already stated, is not used for
purposes of refuge, and it may be questioned whether its freight busi-
ness could not have been transacted at Marquette, only 3 miles dis-
tant, where the Government had already constructed a harbor.
    It is proposed to expend the available balance, together with the
appropriation recommended, on repairs to the breakwater.
    For reference to reports on survey, see Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1896, page 307.
                   RIVER AND      HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                         681
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................     $902. 66
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement.- .................   ......... ......... ............. ..... 160. 82

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. .    -............
                                                   ......
                                                        ..............       741. 84
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909      ---------------------------------..---------- 2, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix I I 9.)
    11. Harbor of refuge at Grand Marais, Mich.-Originally the
entrance to this harbor was obstructed by a bar having but 9 feet
depth of water upon it at low water. The project for its improve-
ment, adopted August 5, 1881, and modified December 21, 1894, has
for its object a deep and safe channel into the harbor, making it a har-
bor of refuge. This object is to be attained by building parallel piers
500 feet apart, projecting into the lake to a depth of 22 feet, and dredg-
ing out an 18-foot channel between them, connecting the deep water of
the lake with that of the harbor, and by closing up the natural en-
trance, 5,770 feet in width, by a solid pile dike, driven with a slope
toward the waves and strongly braced. The proposed length of each
pier was 1,800 feet. The estimated cost of the entire project was
$484,000. The west pier has now reached a length of 1,912 feet, the
east pier 1,545 feet, and the pile dike is completed.
    This dike was built in 1895-1897 to close the natural entrance, to
protect the harbor from storms, and prevent the movement of sand
into the harbor. The expected formation of a sand beach along the
line of the dike is partially realized, but much of the dike is still
exposed to the heavy seas and to damage by ice.
    The amount expended on the project up to the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909, not including outstanding liabilities, was
 $468,979.73, of which $113,094.44 was expended for maintenance.
    About 3,600 feet of the pile dike was repaired and strengthened
between September 1, 1904, and August 6, 1906, under two contracts,
at a total cost (including administration) of nearly $54,000.
    It is hoped that no further work than this will be necessary on the
dike, but it is possible that the riprap will settle into the sand bottom
by the action of waves and require additional rock.
    Dredging was done in July and August, 1908, for removing shoals
from the entrance channel, to the amount of 93,933 yards, at 18- cents,
or $17,612, which gave a depth of 18 to 21 feet at mean low water and
a width of 200 to 300 feet. Repairs to the entrance piers were made
in May and June, 1909, at a cost of $484.49, and some extensions to
the sand fences west of the entrance were made at nominal cost.
 (Details in Appendix I I 10, of this report.)
    The usual variation of water level extends from 0 to + 1 foot above
low-water datum.
    In front of the entrance to the harbor the 22-foot curve of depth
has advanced lakeward between 500 and 600 feet since the project
for improvement was adopted, and this fact will entail some addi-
tional expense for pier extension to deep water. This would now
require an addition of 450 feet to the west pier and 794 feet to the
east pier. This would bring the total cost of these extensions up to
 $149,280-about $103,879 more than the original estimate. It is
682          REPORT OF THE CHIEF                    OF ENGINEERS,           U.   S. ARMY.

hoped, however, that the original estimate will finish the west pier.
This would stop the movement of sand from the west into the chan-
nel, and it is possible that the extension of the east pier would not
then be necessary.
   The commerce of this port has increased from 1,910 tons in 1887 to
1,769 arrivals and clearances, with 54,525 short tons of freight, valued
at $2,539,780, in 1907. In 1908 there were 874 arrivals and clear-
ances, with 45,006 short tons, valued at $1,319,658, showing a
decrease of 17 per cent in freight and 48 per cent in valuation from
1907.
   The total commerce from 1880 to 1908, inclusive, is estimated at
1,435,790 short tons, valued at $24,357,304.
   The total expenditures by the Government for this harbor to date
are nearly 2 per cent of the value of the vessel freight received and
shipped during the period covered by these expenditures.
   The annual expense of government operations at th;s harbor, con-
sisting of maintenance, interest, and depreciation, is a.pproximately
$25,253. This amounts to $0.56 per ton of vessel freight for the year
1908, also to about 2 per cent of the value of this freight, and is about
29 per cent of the saving in the cost of transportation on this freight
by water as compared with rail rates. (Details of these comparisons
may be seen in Table 4, Appendix I I 10, of this report.)
   Effect of project on freight rates: Estimated saving by water trans-
portation as against rail, $1.94 per ton, amounting to $87,312 for the
lake commerce of 1908. With the original condition of the harbor
this shipping could not have been carried on, and the above-men-
tioned saving in cost of transportation is a result of the project for
improvement.
   It is proposed to expend $8,599 of the available balance, together
with the sum recommended for works of improvement ($45,401.68),
making a $54,000, in building the west pier of the entrance out to the
22-foot depth of water, a distance of 450 feet. The remainder of the
available balance, together with the sum of $40,000 estimated for
maintenance of improvement, will be expended for repairs to piers
and the dike and for dredging, as occasion requires.
   For reports on examinations and surveys, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1906, page 579, where references are given.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..--..................................-- $36, 890. 96
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...................................................... 20,147. 37

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ........................................                   16, 743. 59

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                    45, 401. 68

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909........--------------------------.... a 85, 400. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

  a Since the preparation of this estimate, further consideration of existing conditions
leads to the conclusion that possibly the project depth of 18 feet may be as efficiently
and more economically maintained by dredging alone than by further extension of
the piers. Hence, it is believed that this estimate may be reduced to $40,000 for
maintenance only, leaving the question of extending the piers to be determined after
further experience.
   (See Appendix I I 10.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR      IMPROVEMENTS.                683
   12. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering
navigation.-The steamer Alex Nimick, wrecked September 21, 1907,
on the south shore of Lake Superior, proving an obstruction to navi-
gation, its removal was authorized.
  Contract was entered into June 20, 1908, for this work, which was
carried on during the whole season until October 28, 1908, when a
severe storm destroyed the contractor's plant. Operations then
stopped and were to be resumed in the spring of 1909, as soon as
weather conditions would permit. At the end of June the contractor
was still awaiting the arrival of his working plant. Parts of the
wreck still remain above the 20-foot depth.
  The sum of $600 was allotted for this work, of which $50.86 were
expended to June 30, 1909, for inspection and contingencies.
  The amount of the contract liability is $500, leaving $49.14 balance
unexpended July 1, 1909.
   The steamer Sevona ran on a rocky shoal near Sand Island light,
Lake Superior, September 1 and 2, 1905, and became a total wreck.
   The owners removed a large portion of the wreck, but it was after-
wards found that portions had only 11 feet of water over it, making it
an obstruction to navigation. Its removal so as to increase the avail-
able depth of water over it for small craft was authorized.
   The sum of $1,500 was allotted for the purpose. On June 28 the
U. S. steamer Vidette, with United States labor and material, left for
the work, which was in progress at the close of the fiscal year.
   (See Appendix I I 11.)
IMPROVEMENT      OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE MILWAUKEE,
                       WISCONSIN, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of the following officers of the Corps
of Engineers: Maj. W. V. Judson to March 17, 1909; in the tem-
porary charge of Maj. Thos. H. Rees from March 17 to April 5, 1909;
and in the charge of Maj. C. S. Bromwell since the latter date.
Division engineer, Col. W. L. Fisk, Corps of Engineers.
   General statement with reference to datum plane at all harbors on
western shore of Lake Michigan.-The plane of reference or datum
plane to which all depths hereinafter stated are referred is a plane
581.63 feet above mean tide at New York City, or the mean level of
Lake Michigan for the years 1860-1875.
   1. Manistique Harbor, Michigan.-The original depth at the mouth
of the Manistique River was 8 feet. By private enterprise 3,000 linear
feet of slab piers had been built and a channel dredged to a depth of
11 feet before any appropriation was made by the Government.
   The original project, adopted in 1880, provided for increasing the
depth of the channel to 13 feet below datum for a width of 150 feet by
dredging. The amount expended on this project was $3,955.05.
   The present project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1905, and provided for pier construction, breakwater exten-
sion, and dredging to a depth of 19 feet below datum; estimated cost,
$270,000 (see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, p. 525).
   In accordance with a provision in the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907, a modification of this project was approved by the Secretary
of War April 3, 1908. The modification consists mainly in swinging
the inner end of the proposed west pier to the westward, thereby pro-
viding a stilling basin, and in extending the east breakwater about
684           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                          S. ARMY.

90 feet farther westward than at first provided; estimated cost,
$338,462.
  Neither of the foregoing estimates includes the acquisition of land
and existing structures required in connection with the proposed work,
which have been transferred to the United States without expense.
  The amount expended on the work of existing project up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $7,761.80, none of which
was applied to maintenance.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for dredging, pier
removal, crib construction, and general supervision in furtherance
of the existing project.
  About 2 per cent of the approved project has been accomplished.
No practical result in the way of increased depth or width has been
obtained as yet. The maximum draft that could be carried June 30,
1909, was about 15 feet. The usual mean annual variation of level of
water surface is about 1 foot.
  A dam across the Manistique River, located about 1 mile from the
mouth of the harbor, constitutes the head of navigation.
   Commercial              statistics for               1908.-Arrivals of vessels, 44; ship-
ments and receipts, 54,685 net tons. The approximate valuation of
the exports and imports could not be ascertained.
   The commerce affected by the project is in lumber, coal, and gen-
eral merchandise. Car ferries call at this harbor during the entire
year. The volume of commerce which will be benefited is consider-
able. No change in the nature of the commerce has as yet resulted.
   It is believed that the project will have a material effect in con-
trolling freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, and
ore, both locally and for transshipment.
   It is proposed to expend the available balance in the construction
of revetment at mouth of Manistique River, as provided by the proj-
ect, and in dredging. It is proposed to apply the amount estimated
as a profitable expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to the
completion of the project. The additional work is necessary to make
the improvement available.
   For references to more extended information, and for report on
examination and survey, see Annual Report for 1904, Part 3, page
2869.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...........................              ....... $46, 816. 43
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment---...-----.......... ............ ...............................           2, 533. 28
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................               44, 283.15

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..................  42, 108. 32
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 288, 462. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909----................................-----------------------------------..........--------......... 288, 462. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897.
  (See Appendix J J 1.)
  2. Gladstone Harbor, Michigan.-The harbor of Gladstone is a
natural one, and the main channel is from 24 to 42 feet in depth.
The portion of this harbor under improvement was obstructed by
shoals.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                685
  The original project, which is the existing project, was adopted by
act of March 3, 1905, and provides for dredging to a depth of 21 feet
below datum of so much of the harbor as lies outside of a line drawn
perpendicular to the axis of the ore dock through its outer end.
Estimated cost $14,000.
  The amount expended on the work up to the close of the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909, was $7,527.76, of which $247.17 was applied
to maintenance.
  There have been no operations or expenditures during the fiscal
year.
  The approved project was completed in 1905; since then the
expenditures have been for maintenance.
  The maximum draft which could be carried June 30, 1909, was
about 21 feet. The usual mean annual variation of level of water
surface is about 1 foot.
   Commercial statistics for 1908: Arrivals of vessels, 317; shipments
and receipts, 558,098 net tons. The approximate value of exports
and imports could not be ascertained.
   The commerce affected by the project is mostly coal, grain, flour,
and general merchandise, and is general in character. A large
volume of commerce is affected by the project.
   It is believed that the project has a material effect in controlling
freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, and ore, both
locally and for transshipment.
   For report on examination and survey, see Annual Report for 1904,
Part 3, page 2861.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .... --................................ ... $6,472. 24
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................... 6,472.24
   (See Appendix J J 2.)
   3. Menominee Harbor and River, Michigan and Wisconsin. Prior
to act of June 13, 1902, the harbor and river constituted two works.
By this act they were consolidated.
   (a) Harbor.-Originaldepth of channel, about 5 feet; width, 200
feet. The original project, adopted in 1871, provided for two par-
allel piers, 400 feet apart, extending to the 16-foot contour in Green
Bay, and for a channel 15 feet deep between them, modified as fol-
lows: 1874, extending piers to 17-foot contour; 1890, increasing
depth to 17 feet; 1899, increasing depth to 20 feet. Amount ex-
pended on original and modified projects, $234,344.77.
    (b) River.-Original navigable depth, 5 feet. The original proj-
ect, adopted in 1890, provided for a channel 200 feet wide and 17 feet
deep, modified as follows: 1892, width at upper end reduced to 100
feet; 1896, formation of a turning basin 250 feet wide, 600 feet long,
17 feet deep at upper end of channel, and extending channel 425 feet
for a width of 75 feet. Amount expended on original and modified
projects, $114,414.15.
   (c) Harbor and river.-The existing project, adopted by act of
Congress approved June 13, 1902, provides for increasing the depth
to 20 feet, at an estimated cost of $60,000. Under a provision of the
act of March 3, 1905, the existing project was modified by omitting
therefrom the improvement of all that portion of the Menominee
River above and to the westward of Ogden Street Bridge.
686        REPORT OF THE CHIEF              OF ENGINEERS,      U.     S. ARMY.

   The amount expended on the work of existing project up to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $55,275.52, of which
amount $17,023.83 was applied to maintenance. Of this amount
$3,514.17 was derived from miscellaneous sources.
   There have been no operations during the fiscal year except taking
soundings in the harbor and river. The expenditures during the
fiscal year have been for taking soundings, repairs and purchase of
plant, and for general supervision.
   The existing project, as modified, was completed in 1903. Since
then the expenditures have been for maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, over the
shoalest part of the locality under improvement was about 171 feet.
The mean annual variation of level of water surface is about 1 foot.
   The Menominee River is navigable for a distance of about 2 miles
from its mouth.
   Commercial statistics for 1908.-Arrivals of vessels, 693; ship-
ments and receipts, 269,507 net tons. The approximate value of
the exports and imports for port of Marinette, Wis., is $2,358,396;
that for the port of Menominee, Mich., could not be obtained. The
volume of commerce, while large, is not increasing.
   It is believed that the project has a material effect in controlling
freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, and lumber,
both locally and for transshipment.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in repairs of piers and
dredging for restoration of channel.
   For references to more extended information, maps, and reports
on examinations and surveys, see Annual Report for 1904, page 519,
and 1908, page 669.
July 1].,1908, balance unexpended.............  .......................     $5, 944. 71
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3,1909..............    ...................................... ..........  4, 000. 00
                                                                                 9, 944. 71
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement ..........................................................           2, 044. 98

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..............           ................       7, 899. 73
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...........                                          20, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix J J 3.)
  4. Oconto Harbor, Wisconsin.-The original depth at the mouth
of the river, about 3 feet, was increased by private enterprise to 4
feet before work was begun by the United States.
  The original project, which is the existing project, adopted in 1882,
provided for extending the parallel slab piers built by the city of
Oconto to the 11-foot contour in Green Bay, and for a channel 100
feet wide and 9 feet deep extending up the Oconto River a distance
of about 2 miles, at an estimated cost of $150,000; modified in 1897
by abandoning the upper 3,800 feet of the channel; estimated cost
of modified project, $115,610.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                  687
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $92,730.65, of which
$8,161.18 was applied to maintenance.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for general
supervision.
   The 9-foot channel was practically completed in 1899.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1902, was about
7.5 feet. No soundings have been taken since then. Mean annual
variation in level of water surface is about 1 foot. For 1,000 feet
above the westerly end of the government improvement the Oconto
River has a navigable depth of about 3 feet.
   There is practically no commerce by way of the harbor. A 9-foot
harbor on Lake Michigan at this time is without value to commerce.
   It is believed that the project has no effect in controlling freight
rates.
   For references to more extended information, maps, and reports
on examinations and surveys, see Annual Reports for 1904, page 520,
and 1906, page 599.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................        $3, 420. 35
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement ............     ...... ....        .............................     151. 00

June 30, 1909, amount carried to the surplus fund of the Treasury .......       3, 269. 35
    (See Appendix J J 4.)
   5. Green Bay Harbor, Wisconsin.-This work consists of two im-
proved channels-first, from the mouth of Fox River northerly to
the 21-foot contour in Green Bay; second, Fox River below Depere
to the southerly limits of the city of Green Bay. The intervening
pool in Fox River, connecting these channels, has a natural depth of
from 25 to 40 feet and requires no improvement. The outer channel
was originally circuitous and narrow, with an available depth of 11
feet. The original navigable depth of the inner channel was also 11
feet.
   The original project for outer channel, adopted in 1866, provided
for dredging a channel 200 feet wide, 13 feet deep, and 8,800 feet
long, and for revetting about 650 feet of same at Grassy Island, mod-
ified as follows: 1872, straightening channel and increasing depth to
14 feet; 1874, depth 15 feet, length 11,600 feet; 1892, depth 17 feet,
length 16,500 feet; 1897, increasing width at entrance to 500 feet.
   The original project for inner channel, adopted in 1892, provided
for dredging a channel 150 feet wide and 13 feet deep, modified as
follows: 1896, increasing depth to 17 feet.
   These channels were completed by the expenditure of $405,945.18.
   The existing project, adopted by Congress by act approved June
13, 1902, provides for increasing the depth of the outer channel to
20 feet, at an estimated cost of $105,600. It also provides for main-
tenance of existing works.
   The amount expended on the work of existing project up to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $125,275.77, of
which amount $22,936.05 was applied to maintenance.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for dredging for
restoration of both outer and inner channels, for taking soundings, and
for general supervision.
   The approved project was completed in 1903. Since then all ex-
penditures have been for maintenance.
688          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                              U.      S. ARMY.

   The maximum c'ra"t that could be carried June 30, 1909, was about
19 feet in the outer channel and 114 feet in the inner channel. The
mean annual variation in level of water surface is about 1 foot. Con-
necting with the upper end of the inner channel at Depere, Wis., Fox
River is navigable by canals and slack-water navigation to Portage,
Wis., a distance of 156 miles.
   Commercial statistics for 1908.-Arrivals of vessels, 1,381; ship-
ments and receipts, 659,077 net tons. The approximate value of ex-
ports and imports could not be ascertained.
   The commerce of Green Bay is large and of a general character.
   It is believed that the project has a material effect in controlling
freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, and lumber,
both locally and for transshipment.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable expend-
iture in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in maintenance of channels
and existing works.
   For references to more extended information, maps, and reports on
examinations and surveys, see Annual Report for 1904, page 521.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....................................     .. $2, 688. 32
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909................. ....... ..... ... ......  ..............    12, 000. 00
                                                                                                  14, 688. 32
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.................-----------------...........---------
                                                                ....--------------...-....------- 4, 778. 38

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended... .... ....      ...........................                    9, 909. 94
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.           ..
                                        -..........       .. ... ...... ...........               1, 915.00

July 1, 1909, balance available.                     -..........
                                                           .........
                                                              -            ...........        .   7, 994. 94
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909---..----------------------.....    -----------------..40, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix J J 5.)
   6. Sturgeon Bay and Lalce Michigan Ship Canal, Wisconsin, and
harbor of refuge connected therewith.-Prior to act of June 13, 1902,
the canal and harbor constituted two works. By this act they were
consolidated.
   (a) Canal.-Inits natural condition Lake Michigan was separated
from Sturgeon Bay, an arm of Green Bay, by a neck of land about 1-
miles wide, having a maximum elevation above the lake level of about
28 feet. The Sturgeon Bay and Lake Michigan Ship Canal and Har-
bor Company, from 1872 to 1881, constructed across this neck a canal,
without locks or gates, 7,200 feet long, 100 feet wide at water surface,
and 14 feet deep, and in continuation of the canal dredged a channel
in Sturgeon Bay 6,100 feet long, of about same dimensions as the
canal. Of the 14,000 linear feet of canal banks, 8,437 feet was pro-
vided with pile revetments. The United States assumed possession
of the canal April 25, 1893.
   The original project, adopted in 1894, provided for building 6,000
linear feet of revetment, width between new revetments to be 160
feet, for building 2,000 linear feet of fender piling, and for a channel
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                         689
15 feet deep, modified as follows: 1896, provided for a width of
250 feet between revetments for the westerly 1,000 feet of the canal,
and for increasing width between revetments, whenever rebuilt, to 160
feet. The- original project as modified was completed during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1903.
   (b) Harbor.-Before the construction of this harbor was under-
taken the Lake Michigan entrance to the Sturgeon Bay and Lake
Michigan Ship Canal was entirely unprotected from storms from
northeast to southwest.
   The original project, adopted in 1873, provided for the construc-
tion of converging piers 850 feet apart at the shore line, and 250 feet
apart at outer end, inclosing an area of about 10 acres, which was to
be dredged to the requirements of navigation at that time, modified
as follows: 1879, provided for sheet piling the pile piers; 1880, pro-
vided for extending each pier 150 feet by detached cribs, thereby
increasing width of entrance to 335 feet, and dredging to a depth of
17 feet. The original project as modified was completed in 1884.
   The amount expended on the foregoing projects is $354,119.26.
   (c) Canal and harbor.-The existing project, adopted by act of
Congress approved June 13, 1902, provides for maintenance and for
increasing the depth of chancel to 21 feet from Lake Michigan to
Sturgeon Bay; estimated cost, $222,000. The river and harbor act
approved March 2, 1907, authorizes dredging in the vicinity of Hills
Point.
   The amount expended on existing project up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is $254,183.95, of which $19,115.28
was applied to maintenance. Of this amount $12,129.40 was derived
from miscellaneous sources.
   There have been no operations during the fiscal year except taking
soundings. The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for
dredging done during June, 1908, for taking soundings, for repairs of
plant, and for general supervision.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, between
Lake Michigan and Green Bay was about 20 feet. Mean annual
variation in level of water surface is about 1 foot. The existing
project is completed with the exception of a small amount of dredg-
ing at Hills Point. As a result of the expenditures the largest vessels
can now pass between Lake Michigan and Green Bay.
   Commercial statisticsfor 1908.-Number of vessels passing through
canal, 2,307; tonnage, 1,297,504 net tons. Estimated value of
cargoes, $18,261,455.15; decrease in value of cargoes in 1908 as
compared with 1907, $2,750,240.85.
   It is believed that the project has a material effect in controlling
freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, and lumber.
It is impracticable to estimate the amount of reduction in rates
thereby effected.
   For references to more extended information, maps, and reports
on examinations and surveys, see Annual Report for 1904, page 523.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................     $33, 577. 32
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ............................................................        2, 418.13

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................      31,159.19
    (See Appendix J J 6.)
       9001-ENG 1909-44
690     REPORT   OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,      U. S. ARMY.

   7. Operating and care of Sturgeon Bay and Lake Michigan Ship
Canal, Wisconsin.-Under an allotment from the indefinite appro-
priation of July 5, 1884, as amended and reenacted by section 6 of
the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, for operating and care of
canals and other works of navigation, there was expended during the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, $18,496.66.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $298,733.06, including
$1,545.91 miscellaneous receipts.
   Extensive repairs were made to the revetments. Minor repairs
were also made to the buildings and plant pertaining to the canal.
The premises in the vicinity of the office and watchhouses were graded
and otherwise improved, and the canal operated and cared for in ac-
cordance with the approved project.
   Navigation through the canal opened April 11, 1908, closed by ice
December 15, 1908, and resumed April 14, 1909.
   For commercial statistics, see report upon improvement of Stur-
geon Bay and Lake Michigan Ship Canal and harbor of refuge con-
nected therewith.
   (See Appendix J J 7.)
   8. Algoma Harbor, Wisconsin.-Previous to the improvement of
this harbor the depth of water at the mouth of the Ahnapee (or Wolf)
River was only 3 feet and the present harbor was not available for
purposes of commerce.
   The original project adopted in 1875 provided for the formation
of a small artificial harbor, connected with the lake by a channel 100
feet wide and 13 feet deep, by pier construction, dredging, and rock
removal, modified as follows: 1884, width of entrance increased to
200 feet by offset in each pier, main and detached piers to be con-
nected by guide piling; March 3, 1899, provided for extending the
13-foot channel, for a width of 50 feet, a distance of 800 feet by rock
removal and dredging, at an estimated cost of $19,266. The amount
expended on this project and its modifications to June 30, 1908, is
$201,681.46, of which $8,687.96 was for maintenance.
   The existing project, adopted by Congress by act approved March
2, 1907, provides for the construction of an outer harbor, with a depth
of 16 feet of water; estimated cost, $140,000, all of which has been
appropriated.
   The amount expended on the work of existing project up to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $104,908, of
which $12,538.54 was applied to maintenance.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for construction
of pier and breakwater inclosing the outer harbor, for dredging, for
repairs of such portions of the old pier as form part of the existing
project, for construction of survey boat, for repairs of plant, and for
general supervision.
   The existing project has been completed with the exception of a
small amount of riprap to be deposited along the breakwater and the
pier. A small outer harbor with a depth of 16 feet and an area suffi-
cient to permit of turning a vessel has been provided. It is under-
stood that steamers now call at Algoma regularly. The maximum
draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was about 15 feet. The
mean annual variation of water surface is about 1 foot.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                691
   Ahnapee River is navigable for a distance of about 2 miles from
its mouth for crafts drawing 4 feet, but there are no vessels plying
on it.
   Commercial statisticsfor 1908.-Arrivals of vessels, 320; shipments
and receipts by all ways of transportation, 165,098 net tons. Ap-
proximate value of exports and imports by all ways of transpor-
tation, $3,550,000. It is estimated by the mayor of Algoma that
about one-fourth of the shipments and receipts were by way of the
harbor.
   The volume of commerce benefited is small and of a local character.
It is believed, however, that the project is having an excellent effect
in controlling freight rates, but the present harbor has not been
available for a sufficient length of time to estimate the amount of
reduction in rates thereby affected.
   For reference to more extended information, maps, and report on
examination and survey, see Annual Report for 1904, page 524.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended... ................                     ..................       $118, 615. 23
Miscellaneous receipts ................        .......                   ......... ............         101. 55

                                                                                                   118, 716. 78
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.............................                         $70, 984. 69
    For maintenance of improvement .......................                          5, 000. 00
                                                                                                    75, 984. 69

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................                                   42, 732. 09
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                           1, 395. 31

July 1, 1909, balance available ....................................                                41, 336.78
   (See Appendix J J 8.)
   9. Kewaunee harbor, Wisconsin.-The original entrance to the
Kewaunee River was not more than 20 feet wide, with a depth of
about 3 feet at its shoalest point, and was obstructed by submerged
bowlders. The present harbor was therefore not available for pur-
poses of commerce.
   The original project for its improvement adopted in 1881, which
is the existing project, provided for an artificial entrance channel 15
feet deep, located about 2,000 feet south of the river mouth, protected
by two parallel piers 200 feet apart, and extending from the shore to
the 19-foot contour in the lake. Estimated cost, $200,000.
   The amount expended up to June 30, 1909, was $176,086.34, of
which amount $26,086.35 was for maintenance. Of this amount,
$462.86 was derived from miscellaneous sources.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for dredging
for restoration of channel, repairs of plant, and for general super-
vision.
   The present project was completed in 1898 at a cost of about
$150,000; since then all expenditures have been for maintenance.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was
about 151 feet. The mean annual variation in level of water surface
is about 1 foot.
   Cpnnecting with the westerly end of the improved channel Ke-
waunee River has a navigable depth of 4 feet for a distance of about
61 miles, but there is nc regular commerce on the river.
692          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                      S. ARMY.


   Commercial statisticsfor 1908.--Arrivals of vessels, 447; shipments
and receipts, 83,780 net tons. The commerce is quite large in volume
and is of a general character. A line of car-ferry steamers calls at
this harbor. The approximate value of the exports and imports
could not be ascertained.
   The project has a material effect in controlling freight rates, as the
car-ferry steamers form a lake-and-rail route between eastern and
western points. It is impracticable to estimate the amount of reduc-
tion in rates thereby affected.
   It is proposed to expend the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in repairs to piers and
dredging for maintenance of channel.
   For references to more extended information, maps, and reports
on examination and survey, see Annual Report for 1904, page 525,
and 1908, page 670.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................... $4, 995. 19
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........................     ............................. 5, 000. 00
Miscellaneous receipts............. ....................................      45. 42
                                                                                  10, 040. 61
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.............................. .....................                  2, 864. 09

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................              7, 176. 52

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..............           ........    .............  50, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix J J 9.)
   10. Two Rivers Harbor, Wisconsin.-The original depth of the
entrance to Twin rivers was from 3 to 4 feet and the present harbor
was not available for purposes of commerce.
   The original project adopted March 3, 1871, provided for the for-
mation of a channel of navigable width and 13 feet deep, connecting
Twin rivers with Lake Michigan by building parallel piers extending
to the 19-foot contour and dredging between them, at an estimated
cost of $265,588.80, modified in 1897, by terminating the piers at the
14-foot contour. The total amount expended on original and modified
project was $247,613.35.
   The existing project, adopted March 2, 1907, is a modification of
plan "A," printed in House Document No. 730, Fifty-ninth Con-
gress, first session, and provides for increasing the depth of channel
to 16 feet and for the construction of a stilling basin on the north
side of harbor. The sum of $90,000 was appropriated for the
purpose.
   The amount expended on the work of existing project up to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $62,957.35, of which
$21,379.83 was applied to maintenance.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for construction
of new pile pier, for dredging in channel and stilling basin, for repairs
of such portions of the old piers as form part of the' present project,
and for general supervision.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       693
   The new pile pier has been completed, the channel dredged to a
depth of 16 feet, the old piers thoroughly repaired, and about three-
fourths of the stilling basin has been dredged. The stilling basin
has already an appreciable effect on the harbor during storms. The
depth of channel has been increased about 3 feet.
  The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was about
15 feet. The mean annual variation in level of water surface is about
1 foot. East and West Twin rivers have a navigable depth of 7 feet
for a distance of about 3 miles and 7 miles, respectively, from the
harbor piers. There is no regular commerce on these rivers. For
many years they have been used by rowboats and for floating saw logs.
   Commercial statisticsfor 1908.-Arrivals of vessels, 238; shipments
and receipts, 58,315 net tons. Estimated value of exports and im-
ports, $296,087.
  The commerce of this harbor is small in volume and of a local
character. It is believed that the project has a considerable effect
in controlling freight rates not only on coal for local consumption
brought in by way of the harbor, but also affording Two Rivers the
rail rates accorded places at which water competition exists.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, is to be applied in purchasing stone for
riprap and pier filling and for dredging for maintenance of channel.
The additional work proposed is necessary for maintenance of the
harbor.
   For references to more extended information, maps, and reports
on examinations and surveys, see Annual Reports for 1904, page 526,
and for 1906, pages 599 and 645.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............................................ $75, 065. 16
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .................................... $33, 799. 01
    For maintenance of improvement ..........................      12, 736. 85
                                                                               46, 535. 86

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                      28, 529. 30
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.................................          ....   .       862. 02

July 1, 1909, balance available.......................................                     27, 667. 28

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .................                    15, 728. 48
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.......            ...........       ............................     5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix J J 10.)
   11. Manitowoc Harbor, Wisconsin.-The original depth of water
at the mouth of the Manitowoc River was about 4 feet at the shoalest
point, and the existing harbor was not available for purposes of com-
merce.
   The original project, adopted in 1854, provided for building par-
allel piers 220 feet apart and dredging between them to obtain a
channel 12 feet in depth connecting Manitowoc River with Lake
Michigan, modified as follows: 1881, provided for extending piers to
19k-foot contour and increasing depth to 19 feet at entrance and 15
694     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,          U.   S. ARMY.

feet at the shore line; 1890, provided for an exterior breakwater
400 feet long, 24 feet wide; 1896, provided for increasing depth of
channel to 20 feet and extending south pier 500 feet; 1902, provided
for extending the breakwater 400 feet. The original project as sub-
sequently modified was completed in 1903. The total amount
expended thereon, including maintenance up to the time of adoption
of present projects, is $454,666.79.
   The existing project, adopted by Congress March 2, 1907, provides
for maintenance of 20-foot channel and for the reconstruction of the
harbor by the removal of outer 500 feet of existing breakwater and
nearly all of the old parallel piers and by construction of new break-
waters and piers in accordance with report submitted in House Docu-
ment No. 62, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session, as modified by Board
of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors; estimated cost, $376,000.
   The amount expended under the existing project up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $397,146.04, of which
$162,897.56 was for maintenance.
    The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for breakwater
and pier construction, for dredging, construction of survey boat,
repairs of plant, and for general supervision.
    The work has been done under continuing contract appropriations,
and the balance of the authorization to be appropriated is $5,500.
    The existing project is completed with the exception of the rubble
mounds and a moderate amount of dredging. No increase in depth
has been obtained, but the present harbor affords greatly increased
protection to the entrance to the river, having an excellent stilling
effect during storms.
    The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was about
19y feet. The usual mean annual variation of level of water surface
is about 1 foot.
    Connecting with the western end of the government improvement,
Manitowoc River is navigable for a distance of about 1.8 miles.
    Commercial statistics for 1908.-Arrivals of vessels, 1,593; ship-
ments and receipts, 1,420,524 net tons. The approximate value of
the exports and imports could not be ascertained. The commerce
is very large in volume and of a general character. Two lines of car-
ferry steamers call at this harbor daily throughout the entire year.
    The project has a material effect in controlling freight rates, as the
car-ferry steamers form lake and rail routes between eastern and
western points. It is impracticable to estimate the amount of reduc-
tion in rates thereby affected.
    It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in building concrete
superstructure on north breakwater and on concrete caisson break-
waters and in dredging for maintenance of channel. The additional
work proposed is necessary for maintenance of the harbor.
    For references to more extended information, maps, and reports on
examinations and surveys, see Annual Reports for 1904, page 526,
and 1906, page 645.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          695
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..---------------..........----------.............------.. $326, 136.44
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ...........................                   $231, 072. 11
    For maintenance of improvement ...................                         17, 564.44
                                                                                            248, 636. 55
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................--                  .    77, 499. 89
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................                     8, 041.27

July 1, 1909, balance available .......-.......                   . ................        69, 458. 62
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. ..............                       14, 187. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                      5, 500. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909..........................................                          35, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix J J 11.)
    12. Sheboygan Harbor, Wisconsin.-The depth of water over the
bar at the mouth of the Sheboygan River originally did not exceed
7 feet, and the present harbor was not available for purposes of com-
merce.
    The original project, adopted in 1866, provided for extending the
piers built by the city and county of Sheboygan to the 13-foot contour
and dredging between them to a depth of 13 feet; modified as fol-
lows: 1873, for a deeper channel and pier extension; 1881, for ex-
tending piers to 21-foot contour and a depth of 19 feet at entrance,
diminishing to 15 feet at shore line; 1894, for increasing width be-
tween piers and for a channel 19 feet deep; 1899, for a breakwater
700 feet long; 1902, for extending both piers and increasing depth of
channel to 21 feet. The original project as modified was completed in
1904 with the exception of 100 feet of breakwater. The total amount
expended thereon, including maintenance, up to the time of adoption
of present project, is $575,099.44.
    The existing project, adopted by Congress March 2, 1907, provides
for maintenance of 21-foot channel and works incident thereto, for
extension of north breakwater, for a south breakwater, and for subse-
quent necessary extensions to each breakwater in general accordance
with type plan as set forth in report submitted in House Document
No. 62, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
    An estimate of the cost of a part of this project, amounting to
$253,000, was submitted December 13, 1906, and published in River
and Harbor Committee Document No. 3, Fifty-ninth Congress, second
session. The Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors in its report
on this project, published in the same committee document, stated
that it was the belief of the Board that the proposed plan "should be
held in abeyance until the completion of the proposed improvements
at Ludington and Manitowoc, and that the adoption of a new plan for
the improvement of any of these other harbors" (including Sheboy-
gan) "should be postponed until the efficiency of the work at these
two harbors is demonstrated." At the date of this report the work
at neither Ludington nor Manitowoc has been fully completed, and
it is believed that at the close of the present season the department
will be in better position than at present to submit further recom-
696          REPORT        OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                         U.     S. ARMY.

mendation in regard to the work now held in abeyance in consequence
of this report of the Board.
   Should it be decided, however, not to hold the proposed plan
further in abeyance, it is believed that the work of improvement
should in the immediate future be confined to extending the north
breakwater shoreward as recommended by the district officer.
   The amount expended under the existing project up to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $43,334.95, of which
$14,444.64 was for maintenance.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for extension of
breakwater, for dredging for restoration of channel, for construction
of survey boat, for repairs of plant, and for general supervision.
   It is estimated that not more than 5 per cent of the approved proj-
ect has been completed up to June 30, 1909. No result in the way
of increased depth or width has been obtained, but the extension to
the breakwater has somewhat diminished the disturbances in the
harbor during storms.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was about
19 feet. The usual mean annual variation of level of water surface
is about 1 foot.
   Connecting with the westerly end of the government improvement,
Sheboygan River is navigable for a distance of 1l miles.
    Commercial statisticsfor 1908.-Arrivals of vessels, 661; shipments
and receipts, 616,832 net tons. The approximate value of the exports
and imports could not be ascertained. The commerce of Sheboygan
is quite large and of a general character. It is believed that the proj-
ect has a material effect in controlling freight rates not only on coal
and other bulk commodities, both local and for transshipment, but
also in affording to Sheboygan the rail rates accorded places at which
water competition exists.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable expend-
iture in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in repairs of piers and break-
water, and in dredging for maintenance of channel. The proposed
work is necessary for maintenance of the harbor.
   For references to more extended information, maps, and reports on
examinations and surveys, see Annual Reports for 1904, page 527,
and 1906, page 645.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....      ..........................     $36, 250. 24
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........................................... ..............   5, 000. 00
                                                                                                   41, 250. 24
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ......................                                 $15, 519. 19
    For maintenance of improvement.................                             .    12, 345. 98
                                                                                                   27, 865. 17

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                            13, 385. 07
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                            330. 72

July 1, 1909, balance available .............................................                      13, 054. 35

Amount  that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
    pended July 1, 1909..............................                         ...........          65, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix J J 12.)
                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                       697
    13. Port Washington Harbor, Wisconsin.-The natural channel at
the mouth of the Sauk River was narrow, and at the shoalest point
had a depth of 1 foot. The present harbor was not available for
purposes of commerce.
   The original project, adopted in 1869, provided for a channel be-
tween parallel piers. 150 feet apart, extending from the shore to the
11-foot contour, and for a basin 600 feet long by 200 feet wide, inside
the shore line, modified as follows: June 7, 1877, extending piers to
15-foot contour and a second basin to the northward and nearly at
right angles to the first basin, the depth in channel and basins to be
13 feet. The original project, as modified, is the existing project.
Estimated cost, $181,527.17.
    The amount expended up to June 30, 1909, was $202,901.29, of
which $14,337.96 was for maintenance. Of this amount $68.25 was
derived from miscellaneous sources.
    The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for maintenance
of channel and for general supervision.
    The existing project was completed in 1895 at a cost of $188,563.33.
Since then all expenditures have been for maintenance.
    The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was about
12 feet. The usual mean annual variation of levels of water surface
is about 1 foot.
     Commercial statistics for 1908.-Arrivals of vessels, 1,277; ship-
ments and receipts, 32,988 net tons. The approximate value of the
exports and imports could not be ascertained. The commerce bene-
fited is small in volume and of a local character. It is believed that
the project has a considerable effect in controlling freight rates, not
only in coal for local consumption brought in by way of the harbor,
but also in affording Port Washington the rail rates accorded places
where water competition exists.
    It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in repairs of piers
and dredging. The work proposed is necessary for maintenance of
the harbor.
    For references to more extended information and for reports on
examinations and surveys see Annual Report for 1904, pages 528 and
2899.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............                     ................ $3, 022. 10
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909............... ....... .... ...  ............................          4, 000. 00
                                                                                       7, 022. 10
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement....... ............    .................. ......................             955. 14

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................         ......     6, 066. 96
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909........ ................             -
                                                  .....................   15, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix J J 13.)
698     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S. ARMY.

   14. Milwaukee Harbor, Wisconsin, including harbor of refuge.-
Milwaukee Harbor and the harbor of refuge, which were originally
separate works, were consolidated by the act of June 13, 1902.
   The original depth of water at the mouth of the Milwaukee River
was not more than 4 feet, and the present harbor was not available
for purposes of commerce; but the situation of the entrance, in a bay
protected from storms, except those from northeast to southeast, and
the 7 miles of interior river easily susceptible of improvement, have
made the problem of obtaining a harbor a relatively inexpensive one.
   The original project for the improvement of Milwaukee Harbor
was adopted in 1845-46, and provided for dredging the original
river mouth and protecting the entrance by parallel piers, modi-
fied as follows: 1852, provided for the formation of a channel 260
feet wide, and 13 feet deep, located 3,000 feet to the northward of
original mouth of the Milwaukee River, by dredging across the
overlapping point and protecting the channel by parallel piers, each
1,120 feet long; 1868, provided for extending each pier 600 feet; 1899,
provided for deepening the channel to 21 feet; 1902, provided for
concrete superstructure on 1,050 feet of the north pier; 1905, pro-
vided for completing concrete superstructure on north pier, a distance
of 600 feet.
   The original project for the harbor of refuge was adopted in 1881
and provided for a breakwater 7,650 feet long, including an opening
therein of 400 feet; the acts of 1902 and 1905 provided for concrete
superstructure on 3,450 feet of the northern end of the breakwater.
   These original projects as modified were completed in 1906. The
total amount expended thereon, including maintenance up to the time
of adoption of the present project, is $1,739,040.88.
   The act approved March 2, 1907, provides for maintenance of 21-
foot channel, rebuilding south pier, building 3,800 feet of concrete
superstructure on breakwater, and modifies the project by provid-
ing for an extension of the breakwater 1,000 feet. Estimated cost,
$592,000.
   The amount expended under the existing project up to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $448,224.54, of which
$342,375.56 was for maintenance.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for concrete
superstructure on breakwater, for breakwater extension, for rebuild-
ing south pier, for construction of survey boat, for repairs of plant,
and for general supervision. About 7,200 linear feet of concrete
superstructure has been completed. All the cribs for breakwater
extension have been sunk and the superstructure thereon has been
nearly completed. Work on the south pier has been commenced.
   The work is in progress under continuing contract appropriation,
authorizing an expenditure of $592,000, all of which has been appro-
priated.
   The approved project is practically completed with the exception
of the south pier, work on which has just been commence d.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was 21
feet. The mean annual variation of level of water surface is about
1 foot.
    Commercial statistics for 1908.-Arrival of vessels, 5,080; ship-
ments and receipts, 5,375,013 net tons. The approximate value of
the exports and imports could not be ascertained.
                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                               699

   Milwaukee stands among the leading lake ports in the extent and
value of its water-borne commerce. To Milwaukee 3,829,372 tons of
coal was brought in 1908, to be locally consumed or distributed to
points in the interior. By means of car ferries, which ply both win-
ter and summer, Milwaukee is connected with several railway sys-
tems terminating on the east shore of Lake Michigan.
   By reason of its excellent harbor the manufacturers and distrib-
utors of Milwaukee enjoy superior shipping facilities and low freight
rates, especially to and from eastern points. Many bulky articles,
such as coal, salt, sugar, etc., are transshipped from water to rail at
Milwaukee. The favorable effect of the harbor upon commerce is
widespread throughout several States lying to the westward.
   For references to more extended information and for reports on
examinations and surveys, see Annual Report of the Chief of En-
gineers for 1904, pages 529 and 530.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..........-......................... $467, 932. 86
Miscellaneous receipts................ . ............................      584. 53
                                                                            468, 517. 39
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement........................... $104, 560. 68
    For maintenance of improvement ...................... 175, 512. 93
                                                                            280, 073. 61

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....-................................       188, 443. 78
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....................................     9,987. 57

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................     178, 456. 21

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............       132, 821. 03
   (See Appendix J J 14.)
 " 15. Milwaukee (inner) Harbor, Wisconsin.-The original condition
of the rivers comprised in the inner harbor of Milwaukee is not defi-
nitely known. These rivers have been dredged, and a depth of about
21 feet below datum maintained therein, by the city of Milwaukee.
   The original project, which is the existing project, was adopted by
act of March 3, 1905, and provides for improving Menominee, Mil-
waukee, and Kinnickinnick rivers, which constitute the inner harbor
of Milwaukee. This project provides for the excavation of four
turning basins-one in the Menominee and three in the Kinnickin-
nick; the excavation of a channel 100 feet wide from the turning
basin in Menominee River to its mouth and 150 feet wide thence to
the harbor entrance; the excavation of a channel 100 to 150 feet
wide from the mouth of the Kinnickinnick to the uppermost turning
basin in that river, all channels to be 21 feet deep. The estimated
cost of this improvement is $318,581. The act in adopting the proj-
ect provided that no part of the appropriation therefor should be
expended unless the Secretary of War shall have satisfactory assurance
that the city of Milwaukee will comply with certain conditions.
Stated briefly, the city must donate the land for the turning basins,
must revert channels and basins wherever necessary, and must main-
tain the improvement after its completion.
   By act approved June 30, 1906, Congress authorized the Secretary
of War, in his discretion, to modify this project by omitting the turn-
ing basin at the head of navigation in the Kinnickinnick River.
700          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                        S. ARMY.


   By act approved May 28, 1908, Congress authorized the Secretary
of War, in his discretion, to enter into a contract or contracts for the
improvement of the Kinnickinnick River, as soon as the city of Mil-
waukee shall have complied with the foregoing conditions, so far as
they apply to the Kinnickinnick River, or any part thereof.
   There has been no expenditure under the existing project, no as-
surance having yet been offered that the city of Milwaukee will
fulfill all the conditions above mentioned.
   The work is to be done under continuing-contract appropriations,
and the balance of the authorization to be appropriated is $218,581.
   No portion of the approved project has been accomplished up to
June 30, 1909.
   The maximum draft which could be carried June 30, 1909, was
about 20 feet. The usual mean annual variation of water surface is
about 1 foot. The rivers are actually navigable as follows: Milwau-
kee River, about 2-4 miles; Menominee River, about 2 miles; Kin-
nickinnick River, about 21 miles.
   The commerce of Milwaukee has already been described in the
report relating to Milwaukee Harbor.
   It is believed that the project will have a material effect in con-
trolling freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, and
ore, both locally and for transshipment. It is impracticable to esti-
mate the amount of reduction in rates thereby effected.
   For report on examination and survey see Annual Report for 1904,
Part 3, page 2887.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...............................                 $100, 000. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................           100, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........             218, 581. 00
   (See Appendix J J 15.)
   16. Racine Harbor, Wisconsin.-The entrance to this harbor at the
mouth of Root River originally varied in depth from absolute closure
after storms to about 7 feet, and the present harbor was not available
for purposes of commerce.
   The original project, adopted in 1842-43, provided for a channel 13
feet deep between parallel piers 160 feet apart, modified as follows:
1866, provided for increasing depth to 16 feet and for extension of
piers; 1889, provided for increasing depth to 17 feet and for further
extension of piers; 1899, provided for widening channel and increas-
ing depth to 21 feet, for extending the south pier, and for a break-
water 600 feet long; 1902, provided for a change in the location and
direction of the breakwater. The original project as modified was
completed in 1905. The total amount expended thereon, including
maintenance up to the time of adoption of present project, is
$507,141.72.
   The existing project, adopted by Congress March 2, 1907, provides
for maintenance of 21-foot channel and works incident thereto, for
extension of north breakwater, for a south breakwater, and for sub-
sequent necessary extensions to each breakwater, in general accord-
ance with type plan as set forth in report submitted in House Docu-
ment No. 62, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
   An estimate of the cost of a part of this project, amounting to
$225,000, was submitted December 13, 1906, and published in River
                 RIVER AND   HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   701
and Harbor Committee Document No. 3, Fifty-ninth Congress, sec-
ond session. The Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors in
its report on this project, published in the same committee docu-
ment, stated that it was the belief of the board that the proposed plan
"should be held in abeyance until the completion of the proposed
improvements at Ludington and Manitowoc, and that the adoption of
a new plan for the improvement of any of these other harbors" (in-
cluding Racine) "should be postponed until the efficiency of the work
at these two harbors is demonstrated." At the date of this report
the work at neither Ludington nor Manitowoc has been fully com-
pleted, and it is believed that at the close of the present season the
department will be in better position than at present to submit fur-
ther recommendation in regard to the work now held in abeyance in
consequence of this report of the Board.
   Should it be decided, however, not to hold the proposed plan fur-
ther in abeyance, it is believed that the work of improvement should
in the immediate future be confined to extending the north break-
water shoreward, as recommended by the district officer.
   The total amount expended on the work of existing project up to
the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is $50,525.14. Of
this amount, $25,492.55 was for maintenance.
    The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for extension of
north breakwater, for maintenance of channel, for construction of
survey boat, and for general supervision.
   The breakwater has been extended about 200 feet, the channel
dredged, and minor repairs made to breakwater.
   It is estimated that not more than 5 per cent of the approved project
has been completed up to June 30, 1909. No result in the way of
increased depth or width has been obtained, but the extension to the
breakwater has somewhat diminished the disturbances in the harbor
during storms.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was about
19 feet. The usual mean annual variation of level of water surface is
about 1 foot. Connecting with the western terminus of the govern-
ment improvement, Root River is navigable for a distance of about
nine-tenths of a mile.
    Commercial statistics for 1908.-Arrivals of vessels, 1,344; ship-
ments and receipts, 745,032 net tons. The approximate value of the
exports and imports could not be ascertained. The commerce bene-
fited is quite large in volume and of a general character. It is believed
that the project has a material effect in controlling freight rates not
only on coal and other bulk commodities, both local and for trans-
shipment, but also in affording to Racine the rail rates accorded
places at which water competition exists.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in repairs of piers
and breakwater and in dredging. The work proposed is necessary
for maintenance of the harbor.
   For references to more extended information and reports on
examinations and surveys, see Annual Reports for 1904, page 531,
and 1906, page 645.
702            REPORT OF THE CHIEF                         OF ENGINEERS, U.                    S. ARMY.

July 8, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................... $35, 684. 04
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
   March 3, 1909--..........................................-----------------------------------------------      5, 000. 00
Miscellaneous receipts ................................                              .........        .......        50. 00
                                                                                                                40, 734. 04
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.............................                                   $18, 885. 91
    For maintenance of improvement ......................                                    13, 380.52
                                                                                                                32, 266. 43
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                                          8, 467. 61
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                                         351. 68
July 1, 1909, balance available .....................                                  ............              8, 115. 93
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance
  unexpended July 1, 1909......-------.......----...---------------------........................               80, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix J J 16.)
   17. Kenosha Harbor, Wisconsin.-The original depth of water at
the mouth of Pike Creek varied from nothing to 4 feet, and the
present harbor was not available for purposes of commerce.
   The original project, adopted in 1852, provided for a channel 13
feet deep between parallel piers 150 feet apart, modified as follows:
1866, provided for a navigable channel 16 feet deep; 1889, provided
for extending north pier 300 feet and south pier 600 feet, and for
channel 16 feet deep; 1890, provided for dredging in "The Basin;"
1899, provided for extending the south pier, increasing the width
between piers to 250 feet by rebuilding the north pier, building 600
feet to breakwater, and increasing the depth in channel and basin to
21 feet and 20 feet, respectively; 1902, provided for extending the
breakwater 100 feet shoreward. The original project as modified
was .completed in 1900, with the exception of 100 feet extension to
breakwater. The total amount expended thereon, including main-
tenance up to the time of adoption of present project, is $475,815.37.
   The existing project, adopted by Congress March 2, 1907, provides
for maintenance of 21-foot entrance channel, 20-foot basin, and exist-
ing works, and for an extension of 200 feet to the landward end of
the breakwater. Estimated cost, $22,000.
   The total amount expended on the work of existing project up
to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is $23,046.40.
Of this amount $14,350.18 was for maintenance.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for extension of
north breakwater, for dredging, and for general supervision.
   The foundation for breakwater extension is completed and the crib
has been built but not yet sunk in place. The channel and the basin
have been dredged.
   The approved project is completed with the exception of sinking a
crib in extension of breakwater and building superstructure thereon.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was about
19 feet. The usual mean annual variation of level of water surface
is about 1 foot.
   Connecting with the western terminus of the government improve-
ment, Pike Creek is navigable for a distance of about 2,500 feet,
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                 703
   Commercial statistics for 1908.-Arrivals of vessels, 359; shipments
and receipts, 58,545 net tons. The approximate value of the exports
and imports could not be ascertained. The commerce is not large
in volume and is chiefly of a local character.
   It is believed that the project has a considerable effect in control-
ling freight rates not only on coal for local consumption brought in
by way of the harbor, but also by affording Kenosha the rail rates
accorded places at which water competition exists.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in repairs of piers
and breakwater dredging. The work proposed is necessary for main-
tenance of the harbor.
   For references to more extended information and for reports on
examinations and surveys, see Annual Reports for 1904, page 532,
and 1906, page 645.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................               $33, 517. 92
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......................................                .............  10, 000. 00
                                                                                                    43, 517. 92
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement......-----------------...........---.............       $2, 613.57
    For maintenance of improvement .......................                           13, 301.00
                                                                                                    15, 914. 57

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................                                27, 603. 35
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                               101.53

July 1, 1909, balance available-----............................----------------------------..--.   27, 501. 82

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                              22, 578. 93
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909..-----------------------------------------25, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix J J 17.)
    18. Waukegan Harbor, Illinois.-Originally there was no navi-
gable channel or natural harbor at this place.
   An appropriation of $15,000 was made in 1852 "for the improve-
ment of the harbor and breakwater at Waukegan, Ill." The plan
adopted was the construction of a breakwater parallel to the shore in
about 20 feet of water and opposite the heads of two bridge piers in
the open lake, from which the commerce of the place was carried on.
One crib was placed in position but was carried away by a storm, and
the work was abandoned.
   The original project was adopted in 1880 and provided for an arti-
ficial harbor of sufficient capacity for local trade by inclosing an
area with pile piers, the entrance channel and inclosed area to be
dredged to 13 feet. The amount expended on original project prior
to commencement of operations under present project was $21 8,944.41
   The existing project, adopted by act of June 13, 1902, provides for
extending both harbor piers, building a breakwater, and increasing
depth of channel to 20 feet; estimated cost, $345,000, all of which
has been appropriated.
  The total amount expended in the work of existing project up to
the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is $400,981.38; of
704          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                            S. ARMY.

this sum $90,641.99 was for maintenance, of which amount $72.93
was derived from miscellaneous sources.
    The expenditures during the fiscal year have been for reconstruc-
tion of inshore end of south pier, and dredging for restoration of
channel, and minor repairs of breakwater, repairs of plant, and for gen-
eral supervision. The new south pier is practically completed, and
the harbor has been dredged.
    The approved project was completed in 1904. Since then all ex-
expenditures have been for maintenance.
    The maximum draft which could be carried June 30, 1909, was
about 19 feet. The usual mean annual variation of water level is
about 1 foot.
    Commercial statisticsfor 1908.-Arrivals of vessels, 660; shipments
and receipts, 217,009 net tons. The approximate value of the exports
and imports could not be ascertained.
    The commerce affected by the project is mostly coal and salt for
transshipment. Its volume is large and increasing.
    It is believed that the harbor is of great convenience to general
commerce, being a terminus of the Elgin, Joliet and Eastern Railway,
known as the Chicago Outer Belt Line. The harbor is in close con-
nection with all the railways entering Chicago.
    It is believed that the project has a considerable effect in controlling
freight rates on coal and other bulk commodities.
    It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in repairs of piers
and breakwater and dredging. The work proposed is necessary for
maintenance of the harbor.
   For reference to more extended information, maps, and reports on
examinations and surveys, see Annual Report for 1904, page 532.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................................$50,                          275. 37
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.................................                 ..... .................    5, 000. 00
                                                                                           55, 275. 37
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement. .......................    ......  ........................                 24, 628. 23

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                      30, 647. 14

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts.................                     16, 365. 62
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909....          .......    ........................                     10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix J J 18.)
   19. Fox River, Wisconsin.-The Fox and Wisconsin rivers, sepa-
rated at Portage, Wis., by a distance of only 2 miles, one flowing
into Lake Michigan, the other into the Mississippi River, were the
early means of communication between those waters. Through a
board of public works the State began and carried on the improve-
ment until 1853, when it was transferred to a private company. In
1872 the United States purchased from the Green Bay and Missis-
sippi Canal Company all of its property except the water powers,
water-power lots, and personal property.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  705
   The present project is that of a Board of Engineers, submitted
September 17, 1884, and modified May 14, 1886. It provides for
deepening and widening the channel of Fox River from Green Bay
to Montello to 6 feet depth and from Montello to Portage to 4 feet
depth, with a width of the river channel from Lake Winnebago to
Montello of 100 feet, and for the renovation of 12 old locks, at an
estimated cost of $602,000.
   Appropriations aggregating $593,750 have been provided for this
work, and a revision of the estimate indicates that $155,353.36 will
be required to complete it.
   The improvement of the Wisconsin River was abandoned in 1887.
   The amount expended by the United States on the improvement
of the Fox and YWisconsin rivers from 1839 (date of first appropria-
tion) to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, including
about $600,000 expended for flowage damages and $145,000 paid to
the Green Bay and Mississippi Canal Company for its property, was
$3,810,421.96, of which amount $591,161.39 was expended solely upon
the Wisconsin River.
   The works on Fox River now consist of 18 stone locks, 2 stone
guard locks and 8 composite locks, 13 canals, 16 permanent and 1
temporary dam, and various accessories, including lock houses, ware-
houses, a dry dock, levees, waste-weirs. culverts, retaining walls, etc.
The harbors of Stockbridge, Calumet, Miller Bay, and Brothertown,
Lake Winnebago, have been improved, and snags have been removed
and bars dredged in Wolf River, making a 4-foot channel 100 feet
wide to New London.
   The project depth of 6 feet below mean low water has for the most
part been obtained from Depere to Princeton lock, but the revision
of the estimate indicates that there is still a large amount of dredging
to be done in the levels between Eureka and Princeton lock, where
now but 5-foot depths obtain. The dredging of the 6-foot channel
between Princeton lock and Montello is now in progress, and the
next appropriation will be applied to this section. The district
officer recommends that no funds be expended for further work
above Montello, as that portion of the river is now regarded as
unworthy of improvement.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part of the improvement was 5 feet from
Depere to Berlin lock, 4 feet from there to mile post 64 (about 11
miles above Princeton lock) and 3 feet from mile post 64 to Portage,
the head of navigation on the Fox River.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................... $52, 558.37
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909-------------------------------.................----.................................. 20, 000. 00
Miscellaneous receipts ................................................                                     1. 65
                                                                                                  72, 560. 02
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment--..........----------------------........... ------------.....----------............       23, 880.52
                                                                                       .......-----....
                                                                                  --
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended - ...---..--- -- ---.........-----....---..............--          48, 679.50
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                            2, 674. 42

July 1, 1909, balance available............. ..                   .   .   ...............           46, 005. 08

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 155, 353. 36
        9001-ENG 1909-----45
706          REPORT          OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                U.   S. ARMY.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909........----------------------------------.........--.................................--------... $50, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.
   (See Appendix J J 19.)
   20. Operating and care of locks and dams on Fox River, Wisconsin.-
Under the allotment from the indefinite appropriation for operating
and care of canals and other works of navigation there has been ex-
pended during the year ending June 30, 1909, the sum of $52,940.17.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $1,407,405.74, including
$3,314.67 miscellaneous receipts.
   The principal work done has been dredging bars and channels;
making repairs to locks, dams, and canal banks, lock houses, dredges,
and boats; renewing the timber work and concrete top finish of Little
Kaukauna lock above low water; rebuilding the lower gates of Kau-
kauna third and fourth locks and the upper part of the gates of Apple-
ton first lock; rebuilding the sluice gates of Menasha Dam of steel, and
the construction of lock houses at Little Chute first and Combined
locks.
   The report of the district engineer officer in charge shows the items
of expenditures. Navigation was closed November 20, 1908, and
reopened April 12, 1909.
   For commercial statistics, see report of the district officer upon the
improvement of Fox River, Wisconsin.
   (See Appendix J J 20.)
   21. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangeringnavi-
gation.-Wreck of steamer Cecelia Hill at Eagle Harbor,Green Bay, Wis-
consin.-This vessel burned at Fish Creek, Wis., some two or three
years ago. The hull was subsequently towed to Horseshoe Island,
lying at the entrance to Eagle Harbor, Green Bay, Wis., and was per-
mitted to sink, thus forming an obstruction to navigation.
   The wreck having been abandoned by its owners, it was removed
by the United States on September 14, 1908, at a cost of 24 cents and
the vessel and its contents.
   (See Appendix J J 21.)
IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE FIRST CHICAGO,
                   ILLINOIS, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Col. W. H. Bixby, Corps of
Engineers, to September 30, 1908, and of Maj. Thomas H. Rees, Corps
of Engineers, since that date. Division Engineer Col. W. L. Fisk,
Corps of Engineers.
   1. Chicago Harbor, Illinois.-Before improvement (1870) this
harbor was limited to the lower end of Chicago River, with an en-
trance channel width of 400 feet, depth 13 feet, and annual com-
merce less than 3,000,000 tons. A brief history of this harbor
improvement prior to 1876 is given on pages 433 to 438, Part 2,
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1876, and a very full
description of the harbor in its improved condition is to be found on
pages 131 to 134, Bulletin No. 18 (1908), issued by the United States
Lake Survey Office, Detroit, Mich.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                       707
   The present project was adopted in 1870, modified in 1878, 1896,
1903, and 1905; that for present increased depth of dredging in outer
harbor being given by report of July 16, 1897 (p. 2791, Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1897), specifically adopted by act
of March 3, 1899; and that for repair of north pier being given by
report of July 14, 1903 (p. 1888, Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1903), adopted by act of March 3, 1905; such projects
including:
   (al) Breakwaters to form an outer harbor, with (a2) dredging
within the same for 20-foot draft (21 foot depth).
   (b) Exterior breakwater, with a harbor of refuge behind the same.
   (c) Dredging entrance to inner harbor or mouth of Chicago River
to same depth as outer harbor.
   (d) Maintenance; including (dl) the special repair of north pier
superstructure and (d2) some redredging outside the southern en-
trance to the basin.
   (e) Contingencies, including superintendence.
   For map of full improvement, see page 1888, Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1903.
    No preliminary examination reports appear to be on record as to
past improvements of this locality.
    A list of past survey reports will be found on page 600, Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1906.
    There has been expended on projects prior to 1870, $446,005, and
on the project of 1870, with its modifications, to June 30, 1909, the
sum of $2,106,687.37; total, $2,552,692.37.
   The operations during the year were: Completion of the concrete
superstructure over the north pier; completion of pile protection pier
at United States life-saving station and United States engineer boat-
house (one-half of the cost of which was paid for by the Life-Saving
Service); redredging the channel from the lake to Rush Street Bridge;
repairs to north end of easterly breakwater. All of the work above
mentioned is that of maintenance except the construction of the
small protection pier at the life-saving station.
    The uncompleted portions of the above project now are (a2) com-
pletion of dredging of the outer harbor basin for a 20-foot draft,
estimated July 16, 1897, at $509,960; (d2) reopening (dredging) of
the east (also called southern) entrance to the outer harbor basin;
 (d4) repair of outer harbor breakwater cribs and filling; (d5) repair of
exterior harbor of refuge breakwater; (e) contingencies, including
superintendence.
    At present the harbor entrance has a width of 470 feet at the river
mouth, with a least depth of 21 feet via Chicago River, and of about
16 feet via the basin entrance; and the harbor basin carries depths of
at least 19 to 20 feet over its outer half and of at least 8 feet over its
inner half; all these depths being referred to "Chicago city datum,"
or the so-called " low water of 1847," which is 579.83 feet above mean
tide, New York Harbor (Lake Survey revisions of 1907).
    The water level has a total variation of about 6.5 feet from highest
known to lowest known water, and an average of less than 1 foot
oscillation per day.
    Chicago outer harbor, being mainly a protection to Chicago River
entrance, has practically no commerce except that of the river, the
708           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                    U.    S. ARMY.

outer basin being used mainly by yachts and other small craft. The
lake commerce of this locality is at present diminishing and the har-
bor works, while formerly having added about 5,000,000 tons to the
river commerce, are now needed mainly to prevent a more rapid loss
of the 4,000,000 tons remaining.
   The existence of this improved harbor is considered to be of great
use in controlling freight rates.
   By act approved May 28, 1908 (Public, No. 153), any or all of the
then available balance for Chicago Harbor was made available, in the
discretion of the Secretary of War, for expenditure on the existing
project for Chicago River, and under this authority $193,000 of
Chicago Harbor funds has been transferred to Chicago River.
   The superstructures of the easterly and southerly breakwaters have
deteriorated to such an extent that rebuilding in concrete is now con-
sidered necessary, and the cost thereof is included in the amount that
can be profitably expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911.
   It is proposed to apply the available funds and those asked for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to the maintenance of existing works,
redredging the southern entrance to the outer harbor and rebuilding
in concrete the superstructures of the easterly and southerly break-
waters, meanwhile postponing the completion of the outer basin
dredging, which is not considered urgent.
   By the act of March 3, 1909, Congress ordered an examination to
be made of the rivers and harbors in the Chicago district for the pur-
pose of reporting a plan for a complete, systematic, and broad im-
provement of harbor facilities for Chicago and adjacent territory.
This report will be submitted to Congress at its next session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................                                $279, 426. 01
Amount transferred to Chicago River ..................................                                 193, 000. 00
                                                                                                        86, 426. 01
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement------.--------.....--...---.................----------.    $4, 678. 89
    For maintenance of improvement ...-...................                              45, 498. 03
                                                                                                        50, 176. 92
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended................                        .....................           36, 249. 09

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                237, 960. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909--.......----------------------------. 480, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix K K 1.)
   2. Chicago River, Illinois.-Before improvement by the United
States (1896) the river channel, as a result of municipal and private
improvements, was navigable for about 14-foot draft boats over widths
of about 200 feet throughout the length of the main river, about 1.5
miles, and of use by boats of 12 to 14 feet draft for lesser widths and
for about 5 miles farther length in the North Branch and about 5
miles farther length in the South Branch and forks. A good brief
history of river and harbor improvement at Chicago prior to 1876 is
given on pages 433-438, Part 2, Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1876, and a very full description of present conditions is to
be found on pages 134-144, Bulletin No. 18 (1908), issued by the
                                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             709
United States Lake Survey Office, Detroit, Mich. For maps of river
and turning basins, see pages 1892-1893, Annual Report, 1903.
   Past projects, from 1896 to 1902, provided for 16 feet draft through
this river. Under such projects 17 feet actual depth below city datum
was secured from the mouth of the river via South Branch and West
Fork to Ashland avenue (about 5.5 miles), via South Branch and
South Fork to the stock yards (about 6 miles), and via North Branch
to Belmont avenue (about 6 miles). (See p. 2974, Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1893; p. 2793, Report for 1897, and p. 3865,
Report for 1900, for full reports on history of improvement and
needs up to 1899.)
   The project of July 2, 1902, estimated cost $500,000, as specifically
covered by act of Congress June 13, 1902, provided for two large
turning basins (one in the North Branch and one in the South
Branch), to be dredged to 20 feet draft (21 feet depth). These turn-
ing basins have been completely dredged and partly docked, but will
need some annual redredging and probably some further dock revet-
ment.
   The river and harbor act, March 2, 1907, appropriated $300,000 for
improvement and maintenance of this river, such work being covered
by the survey report of November 14, 1899 (pp. 3865-3871, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900), and providing for dredg-
ing to 21 feet actual depth in mid-channel and to within 20 feet of
dock lines from Ogden slip at the river mouth to Ashland avenue on
the South Branch, to the Indiana State line bridges on the South
Fork, South Branch, and to Belmont avenue on the North Branch
(including also the canal around Goose Island, North Branch), all
originally estimated at $810,600. Project covering this work was
approved April 11, 1908, as follows:
(a) Dredging soft material, main river, North Branch (including canal),
      South Fork of South Branch, 1,472,000 cubic yards-..-.--------..                              -    $384, 000
(b) Excavation rock and hardpan in North Branch and South Fork, 105,000
      cubic yards-----------------------------------------------......                                    352, 800
(c) Superintendence and inspection...-------------------................-----------...-----.............   73, 800
                                                                                                        810, 600
the division of funds between dredging and excavation being subject
to modification during the progress of work.
   A list of past survey reports will be found on page 601, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906.
   Reference to reports on examination and survey of West Fork of
South Branch of Chicago River, ordered by the river and harbor act
of March 3, 1905, will be found on page 608, Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1.906. A new report on the same locality was
called for by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, and will be
submitted to Congress at its session.
  The head of navigation of the river and its branches, together with
a statement of its navigable lengths, are given in the following table:
                                                                                                           Miles.
Main river from end of piers to junction of branches .........................                              1.   58
South Branch to Ashland avenue..............---..........................-                                  4.   08
South Fork of South Branch to Chicago Junction Railway bridges .............                                1.   71
North Branch to Belmont avenue .........................................                                    5.   14
North Branch Canal (Goose Island Cut-off)........................-.........                                 1.   04
        Total............................................................                                  13. 55
710     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.                 '

   There has been expended on previous projects $929,899.14 (of
which $3,326.99 was for maintenance during the present fiscal year),
and on the present project, approved April 11, 1908, $309,266.97;
total, $1,239,166.11.
   The following work was accomplished during the year: 484 linear
feet of dock built in the South Branch turning basin; main river
deepened to project depth from Rush Street Bridge to the forks;
North Branch, including North Branch Canal, dredged to project
depth to 900 feet north of Clybourn place; South Fork, South Branch,
dredged to project depth from the South Branch turning basin at
Fuller street to the junction with its west arm. Nothing has been
expended for maintenance.
   At present the river, including both branches, slightly widened at
its narrowest parts by the United States and much widened in the
South Branch by the Chicago Sanitary District, has a least depth of
channel, as referred to Chicago city datum, of 21 feet from the lake
to the forks; thence in the North Branch 21 feet, including North
Branch Canal, to 900 feet north of Clybourn place, thence 8 feet to
Fullerton avenue, thence 7 feet to Belmont avenue; and in the South
Branch 21 feet to the junction with its west arm, except at Archer
avenue, where the city's water-pipe tunnel restricts the depth to 19
feet below hydraulic grade. (For general description of the sanitary
district projects, see p. 2097, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1902.)
   The water level has variations of about 6.5 feet from the highest
known to lowest known water, and an average of less than 1 foot per
day. The river has a current from the lake toward the Sanitary
District Canal varying from nothing up to about 3 miles per hour,
according to drainage diversion and lake seiches.
   The annual commerce is now reported at about 4,000,000 tons, the
principal items being grain, lumber, coal, and salt (a good deal of
commerce having, since 1897, gone to the Calumet River), and the
present further improvement is now mainly needed to prevent further
loss. There is quite a large local commerce carried in the Chicago
River by lighters, of which no official record is kept.
   The development of commerce on this river is greatly hampered
by the many obstructive bridges crossing the stream which are owned
by the city of Chicago.
   The existence of this improved river is considered to be of great use
in controlling freight rates.
   By act approved May 28, 1908 (Public-No. 153), any or all of the
available balance for Chicago Harbor was made available, in the
discretion of the Secretary of War, for expenditure on the existing
project for Chicago River, and under this authority $193,000 of
Chicago Harbor funds was transferred to Chicago River.
   It is proposed to apply the funds now available and further appro-
priations to the completion of the turning basins, to the securing of
the new 21-foot depth throughout the river, and to the maintenance
of existing works.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                    711
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..--.................................. $341, 847. 58
Transferred from Chicago Harbor.................-..................     193, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909----...................................... .............   5, 000. 00
                                                                               539, 847. 58
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement........-.............- ..- . $319, 508. 58
    For maintenance of improvement.-.....................    3, 326. 99
                                                                               322, 835. 57

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................           217, 012. 01
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities                    .............
                                                  -....................         13, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available-    ..........   ..   ...........   . ......   204, 012. 01

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..-...............        134, 609. 51
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project. ........       317, 600. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909-------------..     .
                                                    --.-..--       ....-  /332, 600. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix K K 2.)
   3. Calumet Harbor, Illinois.-This harbor is known on the Great
Lakes as South Chicago Harbor.
   Before improvement (1870) this harbor was limited to the lower
end of Calumet River and to the natural depths over the bar at its
lake mouth, the channel entrance having about 100 feet available
width, with about 4 feet depth. The annual commerce was practically
nothing in either harbor or river. A brief history of this harbor
improvement prior to 1876 is given on pages 441-444, part 2, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1876; and a very full descrip-
tion of present conditions is to be found on pages 124-125, Bulletin
No. 18 (1908), issued by the United States Lake Survey Office, De-
troit, Mich.
   This improvement was designed to furnish a safe and practicable
entrance to Calumet River and the port of South Chicago by the con-
struction of parallel piers 300 feet apart, projecting from the shore
into Lake Michigan, and by dredging between them.
   The work began in 1870, and all the projected work for 16 feet
draft was accomplished prior to June 30, 1896, resulting in the con-
struction of 3,640 linear feet of north pier and 2,020 linear feet of
south pier, and securing and maintaining a channel 16 feet deep and
of suitable width from water of similar depth in Lake Michigan to
the Calumet River at the roots of the piers, at a cost of $454,483.53.
   The present project, submitted February 21, 1896, and specifically
adopted by Congress by act of March 3, 1899 (including minor changes
submitted March 28, 1899, modified July 1, 1902, and approved by
Secretary of War July 11, 1902), provides for-
   (a) A breakwater 4,400 feet long, connected with the shore and
running due east into the lake, terminating in water 32 feet deep.
712      REPORT OF THE CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS, U.     S. ARMY.

   (b) An extension of this breakwa'ter 2,500 feet long in a south-
easterly direction from the end of the first.
   (c). The anchorage area sheltered by breakwater dredged to 20 feet
draft (21 feet depth).
   (d) South pier at the mouth of Calumet River extended 800 feet.
   (e) The Calumet River dredged to a width of 200 feet and 20 feet
draft (21 feet depth) for a distance of 2 miles from the mouth.
   (f) Maintenance and repairs.
   For text and map, including minor changes, see pages 2583-2588,
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, and page 2102 of
the report for 1902.
   A statement of past examination and survey reports will be found
on page 603, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906.
   There has been expended on previous projects $454,484.53, and on
the present project of 1896, adopted in 1899, $1,024,259.91, of which
$39,180.95 was for maintenance; total, $1,478,744.44.
   The operations during the year consisted of maintenance, consider-
able repair work having been made necessary by damage to break-
waters by storms.
   All original work of past and existing projects has now been com-
pleted, leaving since 1905 only its repair and other maintenance.
   At present the protected harbor behind the lake breakwater is
about one-half square mile in area, with 20 feet depth; and the pier
entrance to the river is of 300 feet width, with at least 20 feet channel
depth; all depths being referred to Chicago city datum. (See Chicago
Harbor report.)
   Recent soundings indicate that some shoaling has occurred in the
protected area. Considerable further damage has been done to the
breakwater structures by storms of the past winter. About 900 feet
of the north pier and about 300 feet of the south pier are in a very
dilapidated and rotten condition and must soon be rebuilt, as these
structures have now exceeded by several years the customary life of
such structures. When the rebuilding is done concrete construction
should be used.
   The water level has a total variation of about 6.5 feet from the
highest known to lowest known water, and an average of less than 1
foot oscillation per day.
   Calumet Harbor, being mainly a protection to Calumet River en-
trance, has practically no commerce except that of Calumet River,
although about half of the Illinois Steel Company's commerce, belong-
ing partly to the harbor and partly to the river and estimated here-
with, as usual, under Calumet River, belongs strictly to the harbor.
The harbor works are fully entitled to half the credit of all the com-
merce developed by the combined harbor and river improvements
since 1870, such development having now reached about 6,000,000
tons annually.
   The existence of this improved harbor is considered to be of great
use in controlling freight rates, and is claimed to save at least 50 cents
per ton over Chicago River rates, and more over the usual Calumet
 (South Chicago) railroad rates.
   It is proposed to apply the funds now available and the additional
appropriation recommended to the necessary repair and other main-
tenance of the works.
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMIENTS.                                                       718




July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................                                   ............... $110, 508. 37
June.30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of
  improvement..---............-----------------.......-----.......---..-------....--------------............. 22, 021. 81
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-                       --......       ..................
                                                                       -.....                              88, 486. 56
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 .......................                           a 100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix K K 3.)
    4. Calumet River, Illinois and Indiana.-Before improvement of
Calumet Harbor by the United States (1870), this river, while having
a navigable channel of about 100 feet width and 13 feet depth for
about 4 miles length, could not be reached from the lake by boats of
over 5 feet draft, because of the bar across its mouth; and its com-
merce was then practically nothing. At the time of the improve-
ment of the river itself (1884), the river had become navigable for 12
feet draft over widths of about 100 feet and a length of about 4 miles;
and for boats of 5 feet draft over widths of about 50 feet and lengths
from the river mouth of about 16 miles in the Grand Calumet and
about 14 miles in the Little Calumet. The commerce at that time
was, however, less than 500,000 tons. A good brief history of this
river and harbor improvement prior to 1876 is given on pages 441-
444, Part 2, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1876, and
a very full description of present conditions is to be found on pages
125-128, Bulletin No. 18 (1908), issued by the United States Lake
Survey Office, Detroit, Mich.
   The project for the improvement of this river, adopted by Con-
gress in 1884 and modified in 1886, contemplated securing a chan-
nel 200 feet in width and 16 feet in depth below low water in Lake
Michigan from the mouth of Calumet Harbor, Illinois, about 11 miles
upward, to a point one-half mile east of .Hammond, Ind. This
project was modified by the river and harbor act of June 3, 1896, for
Calumet Harbor, so as to provide for dredging the channel to 20 feet
depth from the mouth 2 miles southward (upward).
   The projects of 1884 to 1896, now ended, secured a permanent
channel of 200 feet width and 20 feet depth from the mouth of the
river about 2.5 miles upstream (including a small turning basin near
the mouth of the river), thence 16 feet depth about 3 miles farther,
except over short portions, where rock reduced the width to 85 feet
and the depth to 14 feet; and, in addition a temporary channel of
10 feet depth and 60 feet width, in the next 6 miles, up to a point on
the Grand Calumet one-half mile east of Hammond, Ind. (about 11
miles above the mouth).
   The present projects, adopted by act of March 3, 1905, provided
for a channel 200 feet wide and 20 feet deep from the mouth of the
river to One hundred and twenty-second street, and of the same width
and 16 feet deep from One hundred and twenty-second street to the
forks, with five turning basins, at a total estimated cost of $662,480.50,
  a This estimate may be reduced to $30,000, owing to the fact that joint resolution of
Congress approved June 25, 1909, authorizes the retention of a balance ($68,804.89) of
former appropriations for this work, which it was expected at the time this estimate
was prepared would be covered into the surplus fund of the Treasury under the pro-
visions of section 10 of the sundry civil act of March 4, 1909.
714     REPORT OF THE CHIEF       OF ENGINEERS,   U.   S. ARMY.

and $10,000 per annum for maintenance. (See p. 605, Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1906.) The construction of the turning
basins was made contingent upon the donation of the necessary land
to the United States free of cost.
   (For estimates in full, see pp. 2942-2949, Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1904; for map, see p. 1902 of the Report for
1903; also, for fuller details, see House Document No. 172, Fifty-
eighth Congress, second session.)
   For this work $712,500 has been appropriated, thus providing for
the entire project and allowing five years (1905-1910) of maintenance
at $10,000 per year.
   Under appropriation of August 18, 1894, for "above the forks,"
$5,050.75 is still available, but dredging has been discontinued because
of constant refilling.
   The act of June 13, 1902, authorizes the Secretary of War to accept
deeds, free of expense to the United States, for lands necessary to
make a proper channel 200 feet wide from the forks up to a point one-
half mile above Hammond, Ind. (a stretch of about 5.5 miles).
   A statement of past examination and survey reports will be found
on page 605, Annual Report, 1906, and reference to report on exami-
nation made in compliance with act of March 2, 1907, will be found on
page 681, Annual Report, 1908.
   There has been expended on previous projects $445,768.23, includ-
ing $41,718.98 for maintenance, and on the present project (adopted
in 1905) $413,702.31, of which $3,511.50 was for maintenance; total,
$859,470.54.
   The following work was accomplished during the year: Under
continuing-contract authorization the channel was dredged to a
depth of 17 feet and width of 200 feet from a point about 300 feet
below the Calumet and Western Railroad bridge for a distance of
about 3,200 feet. The excavation of turning basin No. 1, near
Ninety-third street, to 650 feet diameter and 21 feet depth was com-
pleted. Nothing has been expended for maintenance.
   Expenditures up to date have resulted in a channel of 21 feet depth
(Chicago datum) from the river mouth to One hundred and sixth
street, with 300 feet width at the harbor piers, diminishing to 200 feet
width at about Ninety-second street, retaining 200 feet width to One
hundred and sixth street (except at bridges); thence 20 feet depth
with 200 feet width to One hundred and eleventh street; thence 21
feet depth with 200 feet width to One hundred and fourteenth street;
thence 21 feet depth with 180 feet width to One hundred and twenty-
second street; thence 17 feet depth with 180 feet width to near the
Calumet Western Railroad bridge (near One hundred and twenty-
fourth street); thence 17 feet depth and 200 feet width to about 200
feet above the New York, Chicago and St. Louis Railroad bridge;
thence about 5 feet mid-channel depth and 100 to 150 feet river
width (undredged) to the forks, now under contract to be deepened
to 17 feet depth and 200 feet width; thence about 5 feet depth with
about 50 feet width (dredged prior to 1895 to 10 feet depth and to
60 feet width, but since partly filled up) to Hammond, Ind. One
turning basin has been dredged just above Ninety-second street with
650 feet least diameter and about 21 feet depth.
   The river is further navigable for 6-foot draft boats to Riverdale
on the Little Calumet, 12 miles from the river mouth. It can also be
                               RIVER AND                [ARBO5 IMPROVEMENTS.                                              715
used by light-draft launches, such as can pass under bridges, nearly
to Gary on the Grand Calumet, about 20 miles from the river mouth,
and to Blue Island on the Little Calumet, about 14 miles from the
river mouth, being stopped at that point by rapids.
   The water level has variations of about 6.5 feet from highest
known to lowest known water, and an average of less than 1 foot per
day. At dead low water the river is practically level from the lake
up to the junction of the Grand and Little Calumet. The current is
very slight except during freshet and lake seiches.
   Slow progress is being made in the acquisition of lands for widening
the river and for turning basins authorized by the acts of June 13,
1902, and March 3, 1905, respectively. All the land for turning
basin No. 1 has been acquired and the basin has been dredged. At
the close of the year negotiations were well under way toward the
acquisition of the necessary lands for turning basin No. 5 and it is
expected that the deeds for the same will be tendered early in the
coming year. It is reported that deeds will also be tendered for the
lands necessary for widening the river between the "Forks" and the
junction of the Little and Grand Calumet rivers, a distance of about
1.65 miles. Although Congress has authorized the Secretary of
War to accept such deeds for lands above the Forks, no appropria-
tion has been made for doing the work.
   The right of the Sanitary District of Chicago to reverse the flow of
Calumet River is still pending in the United States circuit court at
Chicago.
   The annual commerce has reached 6,000,000 tons, the principal
items being iron ore, grain, and coal. It is steadily increasing, and
new manufacturing plants are steadily occupying the river banks as
fast as the 20-foot depths are carried upstream.
   The existence of this improved river is considered to be of great
use in controlling freight rates, and is claimed to save at least 50 cents
per ton over Chicago River rates, and more over the usual Calumet
 (South Chicago) railroad rates.
   It is proposed to apply the funds now available and those asked for
for the year ending June 30, 1911, to continuing the enlargement
of the channel progressively upstream according to the 1903 proj-
ect, adopted by act of March 3, 1905, and to the construction of
the turning basins authorized under such project, as soon as the
land needed therefor be deeded to the United States, and for mainte-
nance.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................................    $357, 855. 46
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......   30, 000. 00
                                                                                                                    387, 855. 46
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment---...--.........-------------..................-----------.....-----.........--------..-----......--------    83,107.02

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................                                                 304, 748. 44

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts...--...----....--                                         .    58, 049. 70
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
  expended July 1, 1909-...-
                           ----------------------------------                                                        20, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix K K 4.)
716        REPORT OF THIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. AR1VY.

   5. Michigan City Harbor, Indiana.-The inner and outer harbors
were formerly separate works. They are now consolidated in conse-
quence of the requirements of the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902.
   Inner harbor.-This harbor has been under improvement by the
United States since 1836, under a project to dredge the mouth of
Trail Creek and to protect its entrance by piers about 100 feet apart.
Between 1866 and 1882 the scope of the improvement was gradu-
ally enlarged so as to include dredging the creek 120 to 150 feet wide
to the crossing of the Lake Erie and Western Railroad, a distance of
nearly 2 miles from the entrance, and including two small turning
basins, the banks being revetted by the local authorities or riparian
owners. Proposed depth of navigation, 15 feet. By authority of
the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, a third turning basin was
excavated at the lower bend of the inner harbor, at a cost of not
exceeding $25,000.
   Outer harbor.-Originalproject adopted in 1870, amended in 1880,
1882, and 1899; to construct a general harbor of refuge for vessels
which may be exposed to storms in the southeastern portion of Lake
Michigan. A revised project of 1899 contemplated the removal of
the then existing outer western breakwater; the extension of the
eastern harbor pier for a distance of 600 feet; the construction of a
new detached breakwater, at first to be limited to a length of 1,500
feet, to protect the harbor from westerly storms; and the closing of
the entrance to the outer harbor basin, involving the abandonment
of the old pier and breakwater structures inclosing the basin on the
north and east. Estimated cost of revised project of 1899, $282,150;
amended in July, 1903, $312,150.
   A good brief history of this river and harbor improvement is given
on pages 678-680, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908,
and a very full description of present conditions is to be found on
pages 169-170, Bulletin No. 18 (1908), issued by the United States
Lake Survey office, Detroit, Mich.
   By joint resolution of Congress approved May 13, 1908 (Public
No. 23), the Secretary of War was authorized, in his discretion, to
use any unexpended balance of money heretofore appropriated, or
that may be hereafter appropriated for the improvement or mainte-
nance of this harbor, for the rebuilding of the western revetment
upon a new alignment, with the view of widening the channel.
   In accordance with this authorization a new general project was
approved by the War Department under date of August 15, 1908,
and covers the following items of work:
Widening of inner harbor entrance (building of new pier, removal of old
  pier, and dredging between)...........................................    $72, 000
Redredging of inner harbor channel .......................................   50, 000
Original dredging, upper end of inner harbor...............................  16, 000
Completion of exterior breakwater ........................................   30, 000
Repair, maintenance, and supervision ...-................................    12, 000
      Total-------.......---------..........---------............--.-------------------.......................   180,000
   The act of March 3, 1909, appropriated $49,500, which it was
intended to apply on the items of approved project, but owing to
the extensive damage done by the severe storms of last winter it was
necessary to divert $39,500 of this amount toward necessary urgent
repairs to the harbor structures and other items of maintenance.
This sum of $39,500 so diverted should be replaced by future appro-
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                               717
priations in addition to the usual $10,000 per annum required for
maintenance. The district officer submitted an estimate amounting
to $50,000 for repairs to the outer breakwater alone, rendered neces-
sary by these storms, but a proper regard for other works throughout
the country and the limited amount provided by the emergency
clause of the act of March 3, 1909, made it inadvisable to allot more
than $20,000 for this purpose.
   There has been expended on previous projects $1,568,799.26, in-
cluding $249,670.49 for maintenance; and on the present project
(adopted in 1908) $12,947.37, all being for maintenance except $115.
   The following work of maintenance was done during the year:
Partial repairs were made to the piers and breakwaters; a thorough
examination was made of the harbor structures, and contracts were
entered into to repair some of the damage caused by the past winter's
storms; the gap in the easterly harbor pier was deepened to 6 feet;
the entrance channel was redredged; a contract was entered into for
the construction of a new westerly pier and for removal of old pier,
but up to the close of the year little progress was made on this work.
Negotiations were in progress with the authorities of Michigan City
for the acquisition of the land needed for widening the entrance of
the harbor, and the deeds therefor will probably be tendered early in
the coming year.
   All depths are referred to Chicago city datum (low water of 1847),
which is 579.94 feet above New York mean tide. The early im-
provements at this place were referred to the zero of the Michigan
City gauge, which is now found to be 581.64 feet above New York
mean tide or 3.12 feet above standard low water of lake survey charts.
   The head of navigation is at the upper turning basin, a distance of
about 2 miles from the end of the westerly pier. The depths vary
from 18 to 20 feet from the outer harbor entrance to Franklin Street
Bridge; thence from 13 to 14 feet to Eighth street; thence 4 to 5 feet
to upper turning basin.
   The annual commerce is now reported as 33,448 tons and consists
principally of lumber and salt and is steadily decreasing. The local
commerce, consisting principally of package freight between Michigan
City and Chicago, is steadily increasing, but no accurate record of this
tonnage is kept. The passenger travel (summer excursion) is in-
creasing rapidly. Information received as to the effect of the proj-
ect on freight rates is meager, but indicates that in a general way the
improvement has a tendency to reduce charges and secure advanta-
geous charters for shippers. The city is growing rapidly and steadily.
   The funds in hand and those asked for will be expended toward
the completion of the approved project and for maintenance and
contingencies.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...............                           ....    .. ........... $79, 464. 51
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
                                                                              ----------------- 49, 500.00
  March 3, 1909---........-------..------..................--------------......................
Amount allotted from emergency appropriation, river and harbor act of
  March 3, 1909..................       ........................................                  20, 000. 00
                                                                                               148, 964. 51
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..............................                         $115. 00
    For maintenance of improvement. ......................                       12, 832. 37
                                                                                                12, 947. 37
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .. ...............................                            136, 017. 14
718       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                      U.   S. ARMY.

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. ...............           $93, 300. 46
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........          95, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, in addition to
   the balance unexpended July 1, 1909............-... ......-..  ..... .        65, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix K K 5.)
   6. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering
navigation.- (a) Six wrecks of old vessels and scows in turning basin
No. 1, Calumet River, Illinois, near Ninety-third street.-Reported as
dangerous to small-boat navigation in this part of the river; they
were destroyed and the debris removed at a total cost to the United
States of $2,887.50.
   (b) Schooner David Dows, 6g miles N. 70 ° 30' E. from South Chi-
cago breakwater light-house.-Reported as a menace to navigation
by United States Lake Survey office, Detroit, Mich. The wreck was
destroyed and all d6bris removed to a least depth of 261 feet below
Chicago city datum at a total cost to the United States of $1,603.75.
   (c) Schooner S. A. Wood, in North Branch of Chicago River near
Fullerton avenue.-Reported as an obstruction to navigation by ves-
sel owners; was destroyed and d6bris removed from the river chan-
nel at a total cost to the United States of $796.90.
   (d) Steamer Eagle, in North Branch of Chicago River near Division
street.-Abandoned by owners; was raised and then towed out to
deep water in Lake Michigan, where it was burned and sunk at a
total cost to the United States of $1,181.83.
   (e) Hydraulic dredge Illinois, in Lake Michigan, about 2 miles east
of the foot of Thirty-first street, Chicago, Ill.-Abandoned by owners;
was destroyed and d6bris removed to a depth of about 27 feet below
Chicago city datum at a total cost to the United States of $699.91.

EXAMINATION, WITH PLAN AND ESTIMATE OF COST OF IMPROVEMENT,
  MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND HARBOR ACT APPROVED
  MARCH 2, 1907.

  Reports dated November 14, 1907, August 28, 1908, and Septem-
ber 23, 1908, respectively, on preliminary examination, with plan
and estimate of cost of improvement, of Indiana Harbor, Indiana,
with a view to determining whether improvement of the harbor is
advisable, required by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907,
were duly submitted by the district officer. They were reviewed by
the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant to law,
and were transmitted to Congress and printed in House Document
No. 1113, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for improve-
ment at an estimated cost of $62,000 is presented.

  IMPROVEMENT          OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE                          SECOND
                       CHICAGO, ILLINOIS, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Maj. C. S. Riche, Corps of Engi-
neers. Division engineer, Col. W. L. Fisk, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Illinois River, Illinois.-(a) Below Copperas Creek.-The project,
which contemplates the extension of slack-water improvement begun
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     719

by the State of Illinois from Copperas Creek lock to the Mississippi
River, and which includes the construction of two locks 350 feet long
between sills, 75 feet width of chamber, with 7 feet of water over sills
at low-water level of 1879, and dredging the channel where necessary
to obtain 7 feet depth at low water, was adopted in 1880.
   The lock and dam at Kampsville, Ill., 31 miles above the mouth of
Illinois River, has been completed and in use since 1894, and that at
La Grange, 79 miles above the mouth, since 1890.
   The State of Illinois, aided by the United States, has executed part
of the general project by the construction of locks and dams at Henry
and at Copperas Creek, completing, except dredging, that part of the
project between La Salle and the mouth of Copperas Creek, a distance
of about 90 miles, over which section the State of Illinois collects tolls.
   Harbor lines on both sides of the river at Peoria have been estab-
lished.
   The United States has expended on this work to June 30, 1909,
$1,539,805.93, of which $13,616.94 was expended during the fiscal
year in maintenance of plant and rebuilding same, dredging, snagging,
and supervision of the river and care of property and plant.
   The improvement of Illinois River has been in progress many years,
and the present navigable depth has obtained at ordinary stages of the
river for several years, during which freight rates in the vicinity have
decreased to some extent; but as freight rates generally have dimin-
ished during these years, it is impossible to state whether the effect
of river competition is shown in diminished railroad freight rates.
The closing of the river to navigation, however, would unquestionably
lead to a rise in freight rates on the adjacent railways, and as the
volume of freight affected would be large, a good navigable condition
should be maintained.
   There are many wagon bridges and railroad bridges across the river,
and at Peoria the troughs of large distilleries discharge into the
channel; these structures have been modified from time to time to
meet the demands of navigation.
   It is proposed to apply the available fund and the appropriation
recommended toward maintaining the navigable channel of 7 feet
depth, removing snags, dredging, care and repair and rebuilding
plant, and such local surveys as may be necessary from time to time.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................... $60, 728. 32
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement . . . ......................... $10, 000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement ......................      3, 616. 94
                                                                          13, 616. 94

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...............                      ... ............         ........    47, 111. 38
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                                    500. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available...............                        .........    ...........            46, 611. 38
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project... . ....                                 142, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909...................................     50, 000. 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) From Copperas Creek to La Salle.-The first appropriation
for this section of the river was made March 2, 1907, and the approved
720          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

project for its expenditure provides for securing the same navigable
conditions from Copperas Creek to La Salle as are planned for the
lower river, i. e., a channel depth of 7 feet at low water.
   Operations have consisted in snagging, supervision, and repairs
and additions to plant for dredging purposes; surveys have been
made to locate shoal points and bars. The stage of water has been
too high to render dredging either practicable or necessary. Work
on this section of the river is to be carried on with the same plant
used on the lower section.
   The amount expended on this work to June 30, 1909, is $12,997.41,
of which $4,604.67 was expended during the fiscal year.
   It is proposed to apply the available funds to securing and main-
taining a navigable channel of 7 feet depth, snagging, care, and
repair of property and plant, inspection and prevention of obstruc-
tions and encroachments, and such local surveys as may be necessary.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................     $41, 607. 26
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  m ent.............................     ....... .........................   4, 604. 67
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                           37, 002. 59
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...---.......----------..............-------------.........
                                                                                         -------     300. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available .........           ..-.......    .     ................       36, 702. 59
   (See Appendix L L 1.)
   2. Operating and care of La Grange and Kampsville locks, Illinois
River, and approaches thereto.-These locks and dams have been
maintained and operated under the indefinite appropriation provided
for in section 4 of the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, as amended
and reenacted by section 6 of the river and harbor act of March 3,
1909.
   (a) La Grange lock and dam.-This lock was open to navigation
the entire year except three weeks in January and two weeks in Feb-
ruary. There was expended during the fiscal year $6,892.17.
   (b) Kampsville lock and dam.-The lock was open to navigation
the entire year except three weeks in January and nine days in Feb-
ruary. The lock gates have been rebuilt. The number of boats pass-
ing the lock shows an increase during the year. There was expended
during the fiscal year $6,652.42.
   (See Appendix L L 2.)
  3. Illinois and Mississippi Canal, Illinois.-The object of the im-
provement is to furnish a link in a navigable waterway from Lake
Michigan to the Mississippi River at the mouth of Rock River, Illinois.
  The canal has been located on the Rock Island route, approved by
the Secretary of War October 27, 1888, as directed in the act of Con-
gress of August 11, 1888. It proceeds from the Illinois River at its
great bend, 14 miles above the town of Hennepin, Ill.; thence via
Bureau Creek Valley and over the summit to Rock River at the
mouth of Green River; thence by slack water in Rock River and a
canal around the lower rapids of the river at Milan to the Mississippi
River at the mouth of Rock River.
  The canal is to be at least 80 feet wide at the water surface, 7 feet
deep, and with locks 170 feet long and 35 feet width of lock chamber,
capable of passing barges carrying 600 tons (maximum) freight.
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                121
   A report upon the location, with detailed estimate of cost, of this
canal was submitted June 21, 1890, and is printed in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1890, page 2586.
   The river and harbor act of September 19, 1890, made the first
appropriation for the construction of the canal, and directed work
to be begun by the construction of one of the locks and dams in
Rock River.
   In accordance with this act work was begun in July, 1892, near
the mouth of Rock River, on the construction of a canal around the
lower rapids of the river, and since that date has been prosecuted as
rapidly as the appropriation of funds permitted.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, authorizes the Secretary
of War, in his discretion, to construct a fixed dam with movable crest
in Rock River, in lieu of the lock and dam at or near Sterling, Ill.,
provided for by the approved project, the said dam with movable
crest to be built from funds already appropriated or authorized for
the construction of the canal and to constitute a part of the project
for its construction.
   The river and harbor act of June 3, 1896, placed the work under
the continuing-contract system and limited the average amount of
contract liability to be incurred in any one fiscal year to $400,000.
There has been expended on this work to the close of the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909, $7,401,100.78.
   The result of this expenditure has been:
   First. The acquisition of the right of way for 4 miles around the
lower rapids of Rock River and the completion of 42 miles of canal
there, involving the construction of 41 miles of earthwork, 3 locks, 1
railroad and 2 highway swing bridges, 7 sluiceways and gates, 1 arch
culvert, 2 dams 1,392 feet long across the arms of Rock River, 3 lock-
keepers' houses, 1 small office building, a thorough riprapping of the
canal banks (not included in the original estimates), and construc-
tion by contract of Moline wagon bridge, at a cost of $25,000, which
was also not included in the original estimate.
   Second. The acquisition of right of way for the main line and
navigable feeder, completion of all railway and highway bridges,
locks, culverts, aqueducts; execution of all earthwork and completion
of dam and controlling works at head of feeder; construction of houses
for lockmen, overseers, and superintendent; and part of the necessary
blasting and dredging in Rock River pool.
   The canal was filled with water and formally opened to naviga-
tion October 24, 1907. Operating force has been organized and
since January 1, 1908, the work has been maintained under the in-
definite appropriation for operating and care of canals and other
works of navigation, the completion of construction work progress-
ing at the same time.
   The entire work embraced in the original project for the canal, as
modified by subsequent projects and plans as the work has progressed,
may be summarized as follows:
Surveys and location upon the ground.
Acquisition of right of way and fencing.
Construction of-
     95.8 miles of earthwork.
     67 highway bridges.
     9001--NG 1909-46
722          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Construction of-Continued.
     1 farm bridge.
     3 ponton bridges.
     8 railroad bridges.
     9 aqueducts.
     62 culverts.
     33 locks.
     9 sluiceways and gates.
     3 dams.
     46 houses.
     Outlet to Rock River.
     New highway on mile 16.
     Improvement of 8.5 miles of Rock River.
     Moline wagon bridge (not in original estimate).
   The work thus far completed may be summarized as follows:
  Surveys and location upon the ground.
  Acquisition of right of way and fencing.
  Construction of-
      95.8 miles of earthwork.
      67 highway bridges.
      1 farm bridge.
      8 railroad bridges.
      9 aqueducts.
      62 culverts.
      33 locks.
      34 sluice gates.
      3 dams.
      45 houses and part of 1 additional.
      New highway on mile 16.
      Moline wagon bridge.
      1 ponton bridge
      Part of dredging in Rock River.
      Emergency gates, mile 23.
   Miscellaneous work of revetting, grading, making towpath, ditching,
planting trees, etc.-The work remaining to be done consists of blasting
and dredging in Rock River pool, completing houses, grading,
strengthening banks, and miscellaneous items of finishing.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....................................      $178, 763. 18
Amount received during year . . ...... ................................      a 3, 534. 80
                                                                            182, 297. 98
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment. .....    ...............................................             81,537.39

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.................................           100, 760. 59
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .................................       3, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available ....................................         97,760.59

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909............   ...... ................  ..................    125,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
   (See Appendix L L 3.)
   4. Operating and care of Illinois and Mississippi Canal.--This
canal was formally opened to navigation October 24, 1907, and since
January 1, 1908, has been maintained under the indefinite appro-
priation of July 5, 1884, for operating and care of canals and other
works of navigation, as amended and reenacted by section 6 of the
river and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
      a Judgment in case Cogan & Pound, $3,000; sale of scrap iron, etc., $534.80.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     723
   Work has consisted in organizing forces, patrolling banks, repair-
ing and ditching, operating locks, maintaining and repairing struc-
tures, rebuilding telephone line, building barges, maintaining and
operating boats, remedying seepage conditions, removing sediment
and deposits, clearing d6bris, testing, seeding, and revetting banks,
installing telephone system, and repairing breaks. Rules and regu-
lations for the operation of the canal were approved by the Secretary
of War April 8, 1908. Several leases have been made with private
parties for tracts on the right of way for commercial purposes.
   It is too early to predict what the character or amount of com-
merce on the canal will be, or what its effect upon freight rates will
be. The section traversed is an agricultural country of great fer-
tility and well developed, with many and various manufacturing
interests of moderate size in the adjacent territory. The effect upon
freight rates which was hoped for from this canal when it was pro-
jected eighteen years ago has been largely realized from other causes,
among which competition among railroads and larger train loads
may be mentioned.
   There was expended on this work during the fiscal year the sum
of $170,398.93, exclusive of $5,284.22 outstanding liabilities June 30,
1909.
  (See Appendix L L 4.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE GRAND RAPIDS,
                   MICHIGAN, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Col. M. B. Adams, Corps of Engi-
neers, to March 1, 1909, and of Maj. Charles Keller, Corps of Engineers,
since that date. Division engineer, Col. W. L. Fisk, Corps of Engi-
neers.
  General statement as to the usual variations in the level of the lake
surface at all the harbors on the eastern shore of Lake Michigan.-
The level of the lake surface varies considerably from time to time.
At present its highest stage may be stated as about mean lake level,
and obtains from the end of June to the middle of August. Its lowest
stage is between 1.5 and 2 feet below mean lake level, and obtains
with slight change from early in November to early in April. All
depths at the various harbors in this report are referred to zero of
gauge, which is 581.63 feet above mean tide at New York, and is the
mean lake level above mentioned.
   1. St. Joseph Harbor and River, Michigan.-These were formerly
carried as separate works, but are now combined in consequence of a
provision in the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902.
   (a) St. Joseph Harbor.-This harbor is formed by the junction of
the St. Joseph and Pawpaw rivers and extends along the city front
of St. Joseph, and in its original condition had a natural width of 800
feet, which has been reduced to 300 feet by wharves built upon the
approved harbor lines. It has been under improvement by the United
States since 1836, previous to which time there was a narrow and
crooked channel with depths which varied from 3 to 7 feet. The
original project of 1836 is not clearly known. Up to 1866 there were
built 1,100 feet of north pier and 212 feet of south pier, which pro-
tected a cut through the narrow tongue of land to the north of the
old river mouth, the width between the piers being 240 feet, which
724      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

became 257 feet through subsequent repairs. In all, $162,113 was
expended upon this work. In 1866 the first definitely known project
was adopted, and this proposed the extension of the south pier 200
feet for the purpose of facilitating the creation of a direct channel
of 16 feet depth through the bar at the entrance. The project of
1866 was modified in 1874, 1875, 1880, and 1892, the changes having
reference principally to the length and direction of the two piers.
The Benton Harbor Canal, which is about 1 mile long and extends
from the upper part of the harbor to the town of Benton Harbor,
was taken over by the United States for the purpose of care, main-
tenance, and improvement in 1880. In all, there was expended upon
these various projects $503,113.23.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, adopted the present
project, which is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1898, pages 2496-2498. This project provides for an en-
trance channel 18 feet deep and for an interior channel 18 feet deep
and 150 feet wide along the city front of St. Joseph, while the Benton
Harbor Canal and the turning basin at the mouth of the St. Joseph
River were to be dredged to 15 feet, the north pier extended 1,000
feet, and the south pier, upon a line parallel with the north pier,
1,800 feet. The width was to be 330 feet at the entrance, narrowing
to 257 feet inside. The estimated cost of completion of the existing
project was given in the above report at $380,000.
    Up to June 30, 1909, there has been expended upon the existing
project $372,175.51, of which $69,082.13 was applied to maintenance.
    The operations during the fiscal year were all for maintenance,
and have been as follows: The channel between the piers and in the
interior harbor to the mouth of the Morrison channel was dredged to
a depth of 18 to 20 feet. Repairs were made to damaged portions
of the entrance piers, and 388.73 cords stone were placed in parts
of the piers where the filling was deficient. Great deficiencies of
filling still exist, and an arrangement for the delivery of about 830
cords additional stone has been made, the work to be done in the
next fiscal year.
   All new construction work and dredging to the proposed depth
and width under the approved project have been completed, and
present operations are confined to maintenance.
    The north pier and revetments measure 2,854 feet, 2,183.5 feet
being cribwork and 670.5 feet pile work. At the east end a wing 165
feet long connects it with the dock of the United States light-house
depot. The south pier is 2,623 feet long, 1,800 feet being cribwork
and 820 feet pile work. These structures are in fair condition, except
the 165 feet of wing at east end of north pier. Minor repairs to
decking and additional stone filling are needed.
    The completion of the approved project has resulted in a through
channel of largely increased width, depth, and general availability.
The channel is, however, subject to deterioration due to sand brought
down by the St. Joseph and Paw Paw rivers during the annual
floods, and has required and will continue to require repeated dredging
for its maintenance. The available depths on April 26, 1909, were
as follows: In the outer approach, 22 feet; between the piers, 19.7 feet;
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     725
in interior harbor from entrance piers to mouth of Benton Harbor
Canal, 18 feet; and in Benton Harbor Canal, 15 feet.
   The lake commerce during 1908 amounted to 145,913 short tons,
valued at $23,883,000, and was principally local in character. The
total number of passengers carried was 221,275, and the number of
entrances and clearances 1,265.
   The principal traffic benefited by this improvement is the trans-
portation of manufactured products, the fruit traffic, and the carrying
of passengers, including excursionists. All classes of traffic show
continuous growth. One line of steamers, during the summer,
runs from two to four boats daily, some of these being of great size,
and another line makes daily trips across the lake. The freight
rates to Chicago by rail are in about the proportion of 3:2 as compared
with vessel rates.
   The available balance of funds is sufficient for the probable amount
of required dredging and for the maintenance of the works in service-
able condition until June 30, 1911, and therefore no estimate for addi-
tional funds is presented.
   House Document No. 307, Fifty-fifth Congress, second session,
reproduces a map accompanying the present revised project, which
is not republished in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1898.
    (b) St. Joseph River.-This is a crooked stream, obstructed by
numerous shoals, with depth in channel crossings of from 24 to 30
inches. The intervening pools are generally from 4 to 8 feet deep.
The part under improvement is from the mouth at St. Joseph to
Berrien Springs, a distance of about 22 miles by river. The improve-
ment of this section to make a low-water channel 3 feet deep has been
in progress since 1889, and consists in removing snags and logs and
closing secondary channels, and in concentrating the flow at critical
points by dams of brush, logs, and stone.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $6,246.26, of which
$4,555.49 was for construction and $1,690.77 for maintenance, as a
result of which many of the worst places of the stream had been
improved to the required extent.
    Operations on the St. Joseph River usually comprise a small amount
of wing-dam construction, and the removal of overhanging trees and
snags by a force of hired laborers; no work was done on this river
during the past year, and inquiry from interested parties failed to
elicit the necessity for any. No appropriation is asked for improve-
ment, as the funds on hand are believed to be sufficient for the next
two years' operations.
    The traffic benefited by this improvement is a limited one, two
small steamers being employed to carry passengers (almost exclu-
sively summer tourists). No freight was carried in 1908. The num-
ber of passengers carried in 1908 was 19,812.
    The money on hand will be expended in maintenance and contin-
gencies.
    The effect of the improvement on freight rates is probably, during
the season of navigation, to cause a reduction of at least one-third.
726           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                        1.     S. ARMY.

                                              ST. JOSEPH HARBOR.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................ ......................                                     $21, 928. 74
Proceeds of sale of government property..---..---...----......................                                    65. 85
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1909-------      -----------------. .                -.....
                                                    ................                                          15, 000.00
                                                                                                              36, 994. 59
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement..---------........--.-------------------------------------..................................     7, 877.63

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................                               ...............          29, 116.96

                                              SAINT JOSEPH RIVER.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended----.......------..............---------------...--------.......              $1, 003.74
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................                       .................                   1, 003. 74

                                                  CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................... $22, 932. 48
Proceeds of sale of government property .....................-.-.....        65. 85
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909....................................................     15, 000.00
                                                                                                              37, 998. 33
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.........-.......-..................................                                              7, 877. 63

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                                            30, 120. 70
   (See Appendix M M 1.)
   2. South Haven Harbor, Michigan.-This harbor is situated at the
mouth of Black River. Improvements were begun in 1867, at which
time there existed a channel 7 feet deep and 85 feet wide between slab
piers. These piers had been built by residents of the vicinity, at a
cost of about $18,000. The banks of the river for 500 feet on each
side had a rough protection of close piling.
   The project of 1866, as modified in 1869, 1872, and 1888, provided
for constructing parallel piers and revetments 175 feet apart at the
mouth of Black River, with the object of procuring a channel 12 feet
deep and extending the navigable channel one-half mile up Black
River to the highway bridge by dredging.
   The act approved March 3, 1905, adopted a project for pier exten-
sion and dredging to a depth of 16 feet, at an estimated cost of
$279,370, and $10,000 annually for maintenance. (See H. Doc. No.
119, 58th Cong., 2d sess.) The law provided, however, that none of
the $50,000 appropriated for the improvement should be used, except
for maintenance of existing channels, until proper dock lines had been
established and suitable bulkheads built along these lines by the city
of South Haven or by the riparian owners, and the property lying on
the channel side of these dock lines had been deeded to the United
States free of cost.
   By joint resolution of Congress approved June 29, 1906, $10,000
of the appropriation of March 3, 1905, was made immediately avail-
able to afford a 16-foot depth in the channel. This sum was expended
prior to June 30, 1907.
   The act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $40,000 for this harbor, sub-
ject to restrictions similar to those imposed by the act of 1905.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                       727

   Unless the conditions precedent to the expenditure of the appro-
priations, March 3, 1905, and March 2, 1907, are complied with, fur-
ther operations must be restricted to maintenance of a 12-foot channel,
under the project of 1888, which, except for maintenance, has been
completed. Owing, however, to the possibility of one or more of the
riparian owners at the inner ends of the government piers complying
with the prescribed conditions, it is proposed to maintain a channel
depth of 16 feet between the piers and 18 feet over the outer bar, so
that the requirements of the act of March 2, 1907, on the Govern-
ment's part may be complied with immediately when such riparian
owners have met the requirements of the law on their part.
   The total expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $350,739.35, of which
$187,253.08 was expended for construction and $163,486.27 for main-
tenance. This expenditure includes the $10,000 made available by
joint resolution of Congress of June 29, 1906, but may otherwise be
properly assigned to the original project and its modifications, work
under the project of March 3, 1905, not yet having been commenced.
   The operations during the fiscal year were confined to completing
the dredging in the lower channel by the U. S. dredge Gillespie, begun
May 26, 1908. The work resulted in temporarily providing a depth
of 16 to 17 feet between the piers and of 18 to 20 feet outside of the
entrance. A contract was entered into March 27, 1909, for placing
additional stone in parts of the piers, where the filling is deficient, but
no work has yet been done.
   For reasons stated, no work has yet been done upon the present
project. The available depths on April 14-15, 1909, when soundings
were made, were 15.4 feet in front of the entrance and 14.6 feet be-
tween the piers and in the interior channel. Dredging for the resto-
ration of the needed width and depth of channel at the entrance and
inside will be begun early in July, 1909.
   The water-borne commerce at this port is practically all local in
character. In 1908 there were 466 entrances and clearances with
18,765 short tons of cargo, with an estimated value of $4,423,000.
   The project of 1888, restricting, as it does, the draft of vessels to 12
feet, imposes such limitations upon their size that the improvement
has to-day a diminished effect on freight rates. Until a uniform
depth of 16 feet has been made available, the use of the harbor will
be confined largely to passenger vessels carrying in addition small
quantities of perishable freight, such as fruit. Even in its present
unsatisfactory condition, vessel freight rates to and from Chicago are
13 per cent less than the corresponding railroad rates.
   The money on hand will be sufficient for the maintenance of the
improvement, and accordingly no additional appropriation for that
purpose will be needed for the year ending June 30, 1911, if only the
project depth of 12 feet in the inner harbor is to be maintained.
Should the conditions imposed by the river and harbor acts of March
3, 1905, and March 2, 1907, be complied with by local interests, how-
ever, the sum of $153,707, in addition to the funds now available,
could be profitably expended in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
in prosecutions of the 16-foot project provisionally adopted by said
acts.
   The Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, pages 3056-
3069, and House Document No. 119, Fifty-eighth Congress, second
728             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                   U.    S. ARMY.

session, contain in full the report relating to the existing project.
A map of the harbor is attached to the House document.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................                                               $63, 126.89
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement -----...------.........-----...------..........---------........-------------....---.....              a 4, 428. 77

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....                  -........                         .....................       58, 698. 12
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................                                    ................               898. 04

July 1, 1909, balance available ..................                                             ........... ...       57, 800. 08
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..............                                                   3, 598. 95
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                           248, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 .............................   b 153, 707. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix M M 2.)
   3. Harbor at Saugatuck, and Kalamazoo River, Michigan.-Before
the work of improvement was begun by the United States, in 1869,
this harbor, which is at the mouth of Kalamazoo River, had been
improved by local enterprise by the construction of slab piers 200
feet apart, the north pier being 500 feet long and the south pier 1,575
feet. The channel depth varied from 5 to 7 feet. The present proj-
ect for the old harbor at the mouth of the river was adopted in 1867
and amended in 1869, 1875, and 1882. At the old harbor there is a
north pier 715 feet long, which is entirely unserviceable; separated
from the pier by a long stretch of unprotected bank there is a north
revetment, partly destroyed and partly covered by sand. The south
pier is 3,863 feet long and is practically ruined. Frequent dredging
was required for maintenance of an 8-foot channel. Appropriations
after 1882 were too small to keep the piers in proper repair. To June
30, 1906, $207,785.92 had been expended, of which $90,231.99 was
for construction and $117,553.93 for maintenance, and as no further
expenditures will be made on old harbor, the balance unexpended
July 1, 1906, $9,453.08, was diverted to improvement of new harbor.
   The existing project for the new harbor was adopted by the river
and harbor a t of June 3, 1896. It provides for creating a channel
of 12 feet depth and navigable width by dredging the river for a dis-
tance of 1{ miles below Saugatuck, and thence making a new cut
from the river to the lake, entering the latter about 3,700 feet north
of the original mouth at the old piers. The original estimate for the
work was $150,000, but authority was granted on May 31, 1900, to
increase this to $250,000. The river and harbor act of March 2,
1907, authorized the maintenance of a harbor channel of sufficient
depth to allow the free use of the government dredge General Gilles-
pie, viz, 16 feet.
  a Exclusive of $2.83, refundment of overpayment, which has been deducted from
expenditures during the fiscal year.
  bAs explained in the text of the report, this estimate is recommended only upon
compliance by local interests with the conditions imposed by the acts of March 3, 1905,
and March 2, 1907.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     729

    To June 30, 1909, $273,783.23 had been expended under the exist-
ing project-$233,403.75 for construction' and $40,379.48 for main-
tenance.
    During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, the following work
was done (at a total cost of $22,670.27): The stone filling in the outer
700 feet of each pier was brought to the level of + 3 feet by the addi-
tion of 411.1 cords stone, and under the head of maintenance the
following work was done: By contract dredging between July 2 and
August 29, 1908, the channel outside of the entrance and between
the piers was dredged for a width of 60 feet to a depth of 16 feet, and
the government dredge was employed from September 5 to October
29 in increasing the width. At the end of that time the available
depth outside and between the outer piers was 16 feet and between
the revetments inside 15.2 feet. The plank walk on the projecting
piers was repaired, and a communication between the lake and the
river behind the south pier was closed with a dam of sand. The
available depths found April 9, 1909, were 15.6 to 17.1 feet in front
of the entrance, 13 feet between the piers, and 12.2 feet in the river
in a narrow channel. Dredging for widening the channel was begun
June 29, 1909.
    The works provided for by the approved project have been com-
pleted, and further operations will be confined to maintenance. The
maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, was 12.2 feet.
    The harbor is near a very prosperous fruit region, and the fruit
traffic has been its principal source of business. Saugatuck is but 8
miles south of Holland, with which it is now connected by a trolley
road, and about 17 miles north of South Haven. Holland and South
Haven both command other sources of business than the fruit traffic,
and bid fair to increase in importance through the fact that they are
termini of railroad lines.
    The vessel freight at this harbor for the calendar year 1908 was
4,885 short tons, valued at $342,000, and was entirely local in charac-
ter. The number of passengers carried was 4,636 and the total num-
ber of vessels arriving and departing was 662.
    It is reported that as yet the project has had no effect on freight
rates.
    The money on hand will be expended in maintenance and contin-
gencies. Some dredging in the inner channel will unquestionably be
required before June 30, 1911, and it is estimated that an appropria-
tion of $15,000 will be needed to cover this work.
    The Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, pages
2741-2743, and House Document No. 192, Fifty-fourth Congress, first
session, contain in full the report pertaining to the adopted project
for the proposed change in the location of this harbor. The House
document contains also a map of the locality.
    The act of Congress approved March 3, 1909, provides for making
a preliminary examination of "Saugatuck Harbor and Kalamazoo
River, with a view to securing increased depth to the town of Doug-
las." The examination has been made, and the report thereon will
be submitted to Congress at its next session.
730           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                               U.   S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................                                $23,040. 17
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 .------------..................---------....-----................----------------..  10, 00. 00

                                                                                                   33, 040. 17
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .............................                         $5, 843. 20
    For maintenance of improvement .......................                         16, 827. 07
                                                                                                  22, 670. 27
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                               10, 369. 90
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities-..-.. .........               ....... ............               10. 15
July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                             10, 359. 75
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts----...............
                                                               ---                                  5, 156. 25
SAmount   that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..................-...................      ........                         15, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix M M 3.)
   4. Holland Harbor, Michigan.-When improvement was begun in
August, 1867, by the United States there existed a narrow channel 51
feet deep between piers built of brush and of irregular cribs. These
had been constructed by the harbor commissioners of the adjoining
town of Holland.
   A project was adopted in 1867 and amended in 1873, 1879, 1884,
and 1892, this project providing in general terms for a channel 12 feet
deep between piers and revetments 160 feet to 213 feet apart. From
1867 to 1880 there were built by the United States piers and revet-
ments aggregating 1,854 feet on the north side and 1,691 feet on the
south side. Since the latter date there have been no additions to
these structures, except, in 1889, a length of 160 feet of pile pier on
the south side, designed to close a gap in the existing structure..
Upon this project there was expended up to March 3,1899, $304,217.30,
of which $127,597.50 was for maintenance. The end cribs of the
piers were wrecked by storms and they were removed in September,
1908. As a result, the length of the north pier at present is 1,808
feet and that of the south pier 1,639 feet.
   The present project was adopted in 1905 and modified in 1907.
It provides for a channel 16 feet deep,protected on the outside by two
converging piers 300 feet apart at the outer end and 740 feet apart at
the inner end, and on the inside by piers and revetments having a
clear distance of about 205 feet at the outer end and of 162 feet at
the narrowest place inside, the inner ends of the converging portions
to be connected with the old piers of the inner channel by stone-
filled pile structures. The project also provided for extensive repairs
of the existing works. The estimated cost was $240,000.
   From March 3, 1899, the date of adoption, to June 30, 1909, there
was expended on this project and its modifications $381,932.08, of
which $93,799.71 a was for maintenance.
   a $16,422.19 erroneously reported as expended for maintenance instead of for con-
struction in 1908 report has been corrected in 1909 report by reducing the total cost
of maintenance the above amount.
                 RIVER   AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   731
   The operations during the fiscal year were as follows: Under the
continuing contract of October 11, 1905, the construction of the two
converging pier extensions, 750 feet in length on the north side and
800 feet on the south side, was completed, as also the connecting pile
structures at their inner ends, with the exception of a small amount
of stone filling. The reconstruction of the interior north pier from
the shore line to the angle and the repairs of the south pier from the
shore line to the inner end were also completed, and the repairs of about
340 feet of the outer portion of the interior south pier are fairly well
advanced. All the above comes under the head of new work under
the present project. Under the head of maintenance, the wrecked
cribs at the outer end of the interior piers were removed and the new
ends of the piers were strengthened and protected with round piles,
connected.by means of wales and screw bolts with the main structures.
The channel at the entrance and between the interior piers to Black
Lake was dredged July 29-31, September 21-23, November 24 to
December 31, and again March 19 to April 26, the total quantity of
material removed measuring 99,846 cubic yards. All the funds
required for the completion of the continuing contract have been
appropriated.
   The approved project was very nearly completed on June 30, 1909.
   The uncompleted condition of the piers and revetments has here-
tofore interfered seriously with the maintenance of the required depth,
but better results may be expected hereafter. The maximum draft
upon the completion of dredging in April was 18.4 feet, and at the end
of the fiscal year 17 feet.
   This harbor is relatively an important one, being the terminus of
one of the lines of and one of the principal stations of the main line of
the Pere Marquette Railroad Company and the terminus of the
Grand Rapids, Holland and Chicago Electric Railway, which here
connect with a line of steamers. These during the season of naviga-
tion, when the condition of the harbor permits, run regularly to Chi-
cago. The passenger business is especially important, but there is
also profitable freight traffic.
   The vessel freight of this harbor has increased from 678 arrivals
and departures, with 16,430 short tons, in 1903, to 830 arrivals and
departures, with 165,155 short tons, valued at $53,480,000, in 1908.
The total number of passengers carried in 1908 was 86,700. The
commerce at this port is both general and local. Vessel freight rates
to and from Chicago are about 14 per cent less than the corresponding
railroad rates.
   The balance available after paying all contract liabilities and con-
tingencies will be about $30,000, of which $14,000 should be reserved
for maintenance by dredging and general repairs until June 30, 1911.
Past experience has shown that the converging or outer portions of
the piers are liable to damage by storms, and that precautions should
be taken to insure a permanent supply of riprap along them. Origi-
nally these piers were protected with about 2,000 cords of riprap,
which was specified to weigh not less than 500 pounds, and presum-
ably it weighed little more than this. For effective protection rip-
rap should weigh from three to ten tons, and will then be corre-
spondingly more difficult and expensive to place. Assuming that
2,000 cords of additional riprap may be needed, this will probably
732       REPORT OF THE CHIEF           OF ENGINEERS, TJ.          S. ARMY.

cost close to $20 per cord, or $40,000 in all, and therefore an additional
appropriation of $24,000 is estimated as needed for the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1911, to be charged to maintenance.
   The report upon which the present project is based is published in
full in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, pages
2950, 2951; and the Annual Report for 1905, pages 2176, 2177, con-
tains a drawing and description of the adopted plan.
  Information as to the effect of the improvement on freight rates
isdifficult to obtain, but it iscertainly not less than a reduction of 14
per cent, and may be more than this.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................... $173, 102. 89
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.......................... a $100, 796. 24
    For maintenance of improvement ...................      14, 589. 91
                                                                        115, 386. 15
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended-...... ...        ....................57, 716. 74
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..........         .......-------------------------------
                                                                                       754. 67
July 1, 1909, balance available........................................           56, 962.07
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. ..............             25, 080. 10
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909..............................................               24, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix M M 4.)
   5. Grand Haven Harbor, Michigan.-This harbor is at the mouth
of Grand River, the largest river in the State of Michigan. Before
any work had been done the natural depth at the mouth of the river
varied from 9 to 12 feet, with greater depths in the inner reaches.
   In 1857 the Detroit and Milwaukee Railroad Company (Grand
Trunk), whose western terminus is at the town of Grand Haven, built
a pile pier 3,185 feet long upon the south side of the entrance, and
also revetted, by means of close piles, portions of the bank upon the
north side of the river. In 1866, when work by the United States
was begun, the pile pier had been partly destroyed by fire and by
storms. The available depth was 13 feet.
   The present project was adopted in 1866 and amended in 1868,
1880, 1890, and 1892. It provides for the construction of parallel
piers and revetments 400 feet apart, with the object of creating an
entrance channel 18 feet deep at an estimated cost of $804,366.15.
The amendments to the original project did not materially change
its original purpose, the changes being principally in the proposed
length of the piers and revetments.
   To June 30, 1909, there had been expended upon the existing proj-
ect the sum of $881,068.12, of which $542,976.82 was for construction
and $338,091.30 for maintenance.
   Operations during the fiscal year have been for maintenance. The
south pier between stations 7 + 07 E and 6 + 04 W was substantially
repaired by contract, the work being completed June 25. Some
minor repairs by day labor were made to damaged portions of the
  a Exclusive of $5.83, refundment of overpayment, which has been deducted from
expenditures during the fiscal year.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      733
two piers. Under an emergency contract, work on refilling with
stone parts of the two piers and riprapping the interior portion of
the south revetment was begun in November and will be completed
in July, 1909. From October 19 to 22, December 14 to 17, and again
January 18 to 28, the government dredge deepened the channel
across the outer bar and also widened the river channel opposite the
Grand Trunk Railway dock, removing a total of 34,221 cubic yards
of sand.
   The proportion of the approved project completed to June 30,
1909, is 93 per cent, the linear extent of the structures so far built
being 3,538 feet in the north pier and 5,774 feet in the south pier.
The available depths on June 12-19 were 18.9 feet in front of and 21.6
feet in the southern approach to the entrance outside, 18.6 feet
between the outer end of the piers and 20 feet inside.
   Even when there is no extraordinary freshet in Grand River, a
central bar persists in forming from year to year beyond the entrance
to this fine harbor and seriously impairs.its usefulness. Consequently
it is fortunate that there is a government dredge at hand to promptly
furnish relief at any time.
   In order to complete the project 250 feet of pier extensions are
required at an estimated cost of $40,000.
   This harbor has for years been one of considerable importance. It
is the western terminus of the Detroit, Grand Haven and Milwaukee
branch of the Grand Trunk Railroad, in connection with which is run
throughout the year two lines of steamers to Milwaukee. In addi-
tion there is one line with regular and frequent scheduled trips to
Chicago. All three lines do a large passenger and a very consider-
able freight business, especially during the season of fair weather.
   The water-borne commerce at this port is mostly general in char-
acter, and has increased from 1,151 arrivals and departures with
155,854 short tons in 1900, to 1,538 arrivals and departures with
437,625 short tons of cargo, valued at $60,670,000, in 1908. The
local freight rates from Grand Haven to Chicago by vessel are about
14 per cent lower than the corresponding rates by railroad.
   Of the available balance $12,000 should be reserved for dredging
by the Gillespie in 1909, 1910, and 1911, leaving about $115,000
available for repairing portions of the two piers, which are in very
bad condition. The cost of completing this repair work was esti-
mated, on page 2043 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1908, at $168,000. This harbor is one of considerable importance
and the structures should be made thoroughly safe. Accordingly it
is estimated that the difference between the amount now available
for repairs and the above estimated total cost, namely, $53,000,
should be appropriated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911. No
estimate is submitted for pier extension, as at present it does not
appear to be necessary, and by proper use of the dredge Gillespie
may perhaps be avoided altogether.
   The latest map of this harbor is found in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1890, page 2650.
   The effect of the project on freight rates is at least the reduction of
14 per cent noted above.
   Report upon a preliminary examination of "Grand Haven Harbor
to east end of Fulton street, and including channel into Spring Lake"
    734            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                         S. ARMY.

    was made by the district officer under date of May 31, 1909, in
    accordance with the requirements of the act of Congress approved
    March 3, 1909. This report will be submitted to Congress at its next
    session.
    July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................                                         $69, 018. 80
    Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
      March 3, 1909.....------...-...------........----------........---------............------.........--------.. 100, 000.00
                                                                                                                 169, 018. 80
    June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
      improvement....--------..--...---....-----.............----------...---------...--.....---.........----a    25, 143. 85
    July 1, 1909, balance unexpended................................... 143, 874.95
    July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..-......... ..............--- ........ 162.15
    July 1, 1909, balance available----------................------------------..........
                                                                                  -------                        143, 712.80



    IAmount
    July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................
    Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ..........
              that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
       1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
       pended July 1, 1909......................................    ..... ..
     Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
                                                                                                                 14, 480.53
                                                                                                                 40, 000. 00



                                                                                                                  53, 000. 00

       1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
        (See Appendix M M 5.)
       6. Grand River, Michigan.-Before any work of improvement was
    done upon this stream the depth in the crossings over some of the
    bars did not exceed 2 feet.
       Between 1881 and 1886 the sum of $50,000 was expended in secur-
    ing, by dredging, narrow channels through these bars with a depth
    of about 4 feet. No further work was done until 1896, but even then,
    at the expiration of over ten years, traces of the dredged cuts were
    still apparent.
       The former project, upon which work was begun in May, 1897,
    was adopted by the river and harbor act of June 3, 1896, and is based
    upon a report upon examination and survey reprinted in Annual Re-
    port of the Chief of Engineers for 1892, pages 2369 to 2395. The
    project contemplated dredging a channel a distance of 38 miles from
    Grand Haven to Grand Rapids, with a depth of 10 feet and a width
    of 100 feet. The project also proposes the use of contraction works
    wherever necessary to increase the effect of the dredging or to render
    it more permanent.
       The original estimated cost of project adopted in 1896 was $670,500;
    but the project may be said to have been modified by act of June 13,
    1902, and the cost increased to not less than $774,000.
       The act of March 3, 1905, modified the former project by adopting
    the report submitted in House Document No. 216, Fifty-eighth Con-
    gress, second session, and by providing that no portion of the money
    appropriated shall be used in providing a turning basin in the city
    of Grand Rapids.
       The report referred to above recommends, on pages 4 and 5, that a
    channel of 6 feet depth and 100 feet width be adopted for the improve-
    ment. The estimate in the report for a 6-foot channel 100 feet wide
-     a Exclusive of $2.66, refundment of overpayment, which has been deducted from
    expenditures during the fiscal year.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    735
from Fulton street, in Grand Rapids, to Grand Haven, Mich., pre-
pared from data furnished by the district officer, is $327,000 in addi-
tion to available plant and funds. This, together with the sum of
$171,791.40 already expended toward the completion of a 6-foot
channel, makes the total estimated cost of the existing project
$601,791.40.
   To June 30, 1909, the sum of $421,500.66 had been expended in
dredging 2,648,293 cubic yards of sand, clay, cobblestones, etc., in
building 132,625 linear feet of training walls, and in the purchase
and maintenance of plant. This sum includes $32,459.85 expended
for maintenance of contraction works and $15,177.57 for mainte-
nance of completed 6-foot channel.
   All work upon the river is carried on by use of a plant belonging
to the United States operated by hired labor. During the year
operations have included widening the channel above the Lake
Shore and Michigan Southern Railway bridge and, with the exception
of two stretches aggregating a total length of 1,650 feet in which the
depth is 6 feet and the width is 40 to 100 feet, its completion below
that bridge. In addition the usual work of maintenance and repair
of channel structures and plant has been continued.
   The approved project has been practically completed and recent
work has been mainly redredging, i. e., maintenance.
   The available depths a year ago were stated as follows: Between
Grand Rapids and the mouth of Bass River there is a navigable
channel (in one short stretch of about 100 feet only the width of a
single dredged cut) with the following depths at extreme low water:
For about 21.1 miles, 6 feet; 1.5 miles, 5 to 6 feet; 0.8 mile, less
than 5 feet. At the present time there is a navigable channel from
Grand Rapids to Grand Haven 6 feet deep and 40 to 100 feet wide
(mostly 100 feet) except as follows: A distance of about 1,600 feet
with depth of 6 feet and width of 20 to 40 feet; a distance of about
2,500 feet with depth of 5 feet; and a distance of'about 700 feet
with a depth of 4 to 5 feet. The maximum draft that could be car-
ried June 30, 1909, from Grand Haven to Grand Rapids was 4.5 feet
below low water surface. Thus there is a total of 5,800 feet in which
the channel is dificient either in depth or in width to such an extent
as to offer a barrier to vessels of the maximum size adapted to the
facilities of the authorized project. These localities have in the past
been improved to afford the projected depth, but constant main-
tenance is required.
   The contraction works are in fairly good condition.
   The project is naturally one of constant repair and maintenance.
High water ordinarily occurs in the early spring, and is from 12 to 18
feet above low water in the neighborhood of Grand Rapids. In the
lower part of the river the difference between the high and low stages
becomes less, and at the mouth it is inconsiderable.
   The commerce involved must be stated as insignificant. A boat
line of two new boats (each 219 tonnage and 700 passenger allowance),
called the Grand Rapids and Lake Michigan Transportation Com-
pany, was put in operation three years ago between Grand Rapids
and Grand Haven, but failed to find business, and the boats have
been sold and removed from the river.
   With the exception of a gasoline boat, which is running between
Grand Rapids and Grand Haven, there is no commerce on the 23
736           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                      U.    S. ARMY.

miles of improved river between Grand Rapids and Bass River, but
below Bass River there are two small tugs engaged in towing gravel
to Grand Haven.
   At present there is an available balance of $40,874.52, which is
more than enough for such work as, in view of the limited commercial
use of the channel, seems justifiable during the years 1909, 1910, and
1911. No appropriation will therefore be needed.
   The improvement has no effect on freight rates, and it is improb-
able that it ever will have, since the better facilities afforded by the
competing interurban electric lines to Holland, Grand Haven, and
Muskegon have served to divert to them freight shipped by vessel to
and from Chicago, which might otherwise have been regarded as
peculiarly tributary to a line of steamers running between Grand
Rapids and Grand Haven and connecting at the latter place with
trans-lake steamships.
   Freight carried, calendar year 1906, 110,395 tons; 1907, 88,653
tons; and in 1908, 25,913 tons.
   Reference to report on examination made in compliance with act
of March 2, 1907, may be found on page 715 of report for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................................... ..                                   $68, 324. 64
Proceeds of sale of government property...............................                                         240. 00
                                                                                                           68, 564. 64
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement. ...........................  . $11, 849. 01
    For maintenance of improvement........................    14, 600. 14
                                                                                                           26, 449. 15

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                                      42,115. 49
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities -----------------------------....................................     1, 240. 97

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                                      40, 874. 52
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......... 149, 000. 00
   (See Appendix M M 6.)
   7. Muskegon Harbor, Michigan.-This harbor is the outlet of Mus-
kegon River, one of the largest in Michigan, which before emptying
into Lake Michigan expands into Muskegon Lake. The channel
between the lakes in 1867, before operations were begun by the United
States, was 3,000 feet long and about 12 feet deep, except at the
entrance, where the depth was 11 feet and the channel fluctuating.
By private enterprise the entrance had been protected by converging
slab piers.
   The original project was adopted in 1866 and amended in 1869,
1873, 1881, 1884, 1890, and 1892. To June 30, 1902, there had been
expended upon this project the sum of $526,293.36, of which
$388,218.42 was for construction and $138,074.94 for maintenance,
and there had been constructed a north pier and revetment 2,780
feet long and a south pier and revetment 4,402 feet long, protecting
a"channel varying in width from 308 feet at the entrance to 167 feet
inside and having a proposed depth of 15 feet.
   The existing project, adopted by the act of June 13, 1902, provides
for widening the channel to 300 feet and deepening it to 20 feet from
Lake Michigan to Muskegon Lake. This involved the removal of the
narrowing portion of the north pier and revetment, the reconstruc-
tion of the same on new line, the extension of both revetments to
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                      737
Muskegon Lake, and the outward extension of the two piers by an
aggregate amount of 550 feet. The estimated cost was $380,000.
   From July 1, 1902, to June 30, 1909, there was expended upon the
existing project the sum of $222,640.64, of which $137,660.80 was
for construction and $84,979.84 for maintenance.
   The operations during the fiscal year were as follows: The con-
struction of 1,200 feet of sheet pile revetment on the north side of
the channel, which was begun in the previous fiscal year, was nearly
completed in June, 1909, the only item remaining being the spiking
of part of the lower guide timbers. The contract dredging com-
menced May 4, 1908, for the removal of the interior portion of the
old north pier and the widening of the channel as far as the new
revetment then extended, was completed July 27, 1908. Dredging
under a new contract for widening and deepening the channel to the
present end of the north revetment and deepening it beyond to Mus-
kegon Lake was begun June 8 and is now in progress. All the above
operations come under the head of new work. Under the head of
maintenance, the U. S. dredge Gillespie was employed at the harbor
from August 1 to September 1, from October 30 to November 11,
from January 4 to 9 and January 25-26, and again from May 21 to
July 1, 1909, in maintaining and restoring the required depth. The
total quantity dredged by the Gillespie during the stated times was
167,344 cubic yards. An obstruction found by the Gillespie in mid-
channel opposite the life-saving station was removed by a dipper
dredge under special agreement.
   The present project is about 63 per cent completed.
   The length of the completed pier and revetment construction at
the present time is 4,150 feet on the north side and 4,710 feet on the
south side of the channel, and the maximum draft on June 30, 1909,
was 20 feet.
   Commerce at this port for 1908 comprised 1,131 entrances and
clearances with 115,269 short tons of cargo, valued at $13,522,000,
and was mostly local in character. The local freight rates from
Muskegon to Chicago by vessel are about 14 per cent lower than the
corresponding rates by railroad.
   There are 350 linear feet at the outer end of the north pier that
are 24 to 27 years old and in need of repairs above water.
   The completion of the project will require 550 feet of pier exten-
sion, the remainder of the dredging in the channel between the piers
so as to afford 300 feet width and 20 feet depth and the extension
of the revetments on the north side of the channel 1,100 feet to
Muskegon Lake, estimated to cost $124,750.
   The funds remaining available, after paying contract liabilities,
will be sufficient for repairing the defective portion of the north pier
and for dredging for maintenance by the Gillespie during the re-
mainder of the season of 1909. For maintenance of the improve-
ment until June 30, 1911, for completion of the sheet pile revetment
on the north side of channel to Muskegon Lake, for dredging the full
depth and width of interior channel, and for dredging at the entrance
by the U. S. dredge Gillespie, it is estimated that $70,000 should be
appropriated.
   During the season of navigation two lines of steamers regularly
use this harbor, which is a terminus of three important railroad lines.
Their business is a substantial one, and with increased facilities
     9001-ENG 1909---47
738           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                         U.    S. ARMY.

should grow considerably. A general freight and passenger business
is done, and in the summer months this is largely augmented by the
fruit and the resort traffic. Muskegon Lake itself is a magnificent
harbor, 5 miles long and about 1 miles wide, with depths varying
from 30 to 40 feet. When readily accessible, this will be an excellent
harbor of refuge.
   The Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1901, pages 3131-
3134, and House Document No. 104, Fifty-sixth Congress, second
session, contain in full a report upon which the approved project is
based. A map showing the harbor and the outlines of the above
project accompanies the document mentioned.
   It is reported that the project has had a marked influence in pro-
viding transportation facilities for commodities at reduced rates.
   A report upon a preliminary examination of Muskegon Harbor,
made in pursuance of the requirements of the act approved March 3,
1909, was submitted by the district officer under date of May 28,
1909, and will be transmitted to Congress at its next session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. . .................................   $90, 236. 65
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 .................       ..   ..........   .........   .. 22, 000. 00

                                                                                            112, 236. 65
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .........................                       $43, 154. 79
    For maintenance of improvement ......................                     16, 405. 86
                                                                                             59, 560. 65

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                           52, 676. 00
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...............................                  ..      4, 006.18

July 1, 1909, balance available .....................................                        48, 669. 82

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................     30, 685. 72
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 124, 750. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909...............................                            70, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix M M 7.)
   8. White Lake and Pentwater harbors, Michigan.-These harbors
were formerly carried as separate works, but are now consolidated in
consequence of a provision in the river and harbor act of June 13,
1902.
   (a) White Lake Harbor.-When the present project was adopted,
the natural outlet of White Lake, about 3,550 feet north of the pres-
ent entrance, afforded a channel 5 feet deep and 125 feet wide between
slab piers built by local enterprise.
   The approved project provided for the abandonment of the old
outlet and the creation of a new one, 12 feet deep and 200 feet wide
between piers and revetments. This project was adopted in 1866,
amended in 1873, 1884, and 1892, the present amended estimated cost
being $353,550. The various amendments to the original project have
not altered it materially, as they relate principally to the length of
the proposed piers and revetments. The provision in the act approved
March 2, 1907, that "the Secretary of War is authorized to dredge
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     739
the channel at Pentwater to the depth of 16 feet and to dredge the
channel at White Lake to sufficient depth to allow the free use of
the government dredge Gillespie," may be said to have changed the
project to one of 16-foot depth and 200 feet width between piers and
revetments.
   To June 30, 1909, there was expended upon the existing project
the sum of $351,032.40, of which $207,862.44 was for construction
and $143,169.96 for maintenance.
   There have been no operations at the harbor during the fiscal year,
and the expenditures have been for making the customary soundings
and for contingencies and for dredging by the Gillespie in last fiscal
year. An emergency contract for refilling parts of the piers with
stone was entered into July 1, 1908, but no stone has as yet been
delivered.. It is probable that the stone will be received soon.
   The proportion of the approved project completed to June 30, 1909,
is about 91 per cent. The existing constructions consist of a north
pier and revetment 1,715 feet long, and of a south pier and revet-
ment 1,953 feet long, and the natural depth of channel between them
is about 10 feet. Periodical dredging is necessary to secure and
maintain a depth of 16 feet. The maximum draft that could be
carried over the shoalest part of the channel at the end of the fiscal
year was 13 feet.
   In 1908 there was at this harbor 224 arrivals and departures, with
12,549 short tons of cargo, valued at $475,000, and entirely local in
character. The local freight rates by vessel from White Lake to Chi-
cago are about 14 per cent less than the corresponding rates by rail-
road.
   The harbor is but 10.5 miles north of Muskegon.
   After providing for the estimated cost of the stone to be delivered
under the outstanding contract, and without use of the $67,000 allotted
from the appropriation of March 3, 1909, for repairing the piers, the
remaining balance of available funds will be sufficient to pay for the
required dredging in 1909, for which bids will be invited early in July.
   The conditions at White Lake Harbor were made the subject of a
special investigation by the district officer, whose report was referred
for review by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and IHarbors. In the
opinion of the Board this harbor is not worthy of further improvement
by the General Government, and even the outlay necessary for main-
tenance and repairs would greatly exceed that warranted by existing
and prospective commerce. Concurring in the views of the Board
and in compliance with section 7 of the river and harbor act of March
3, 1899, it is recommended that further appropriations for White Lake
Harbor be discontinued. A brief statement of the reasons for regard-
ing the locality as unworthy of improvement may be found in Appen-
dix MM 8 of this report.
   However, pending action by Congress, providing for the definite
abandonment of the improvement, and since funds for maintenance
have been specifically provided, it is believed that dredging and minor
repairs to afford facilities for the existing commerce should be done,
and it is proposed to reserve $10,000 for repairs and $6,000 for dredg-
ing in 1910 and 1911 from the allotment made available from the
appropriation by the act of March 3, 1909.
   The last published map of the locality is contained in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page 1982.
740                    REPORT                   OF THE                   CHIEF               OF ENGINEERS,                       U. S. ARMY.

   (b) Pentwater Harbor.-Before work was begun at this harbor by
the United States there existed an irregular channel 4 feet deep and
75 feet wide between slab piers built by local enterprise.
   The existing project, adopted in 1867 and amended in 1873, 1884,
and 1892, provides for widening the old entrance to 150 feet and deep-
ening it to 12 feet, the sides being protected by piers and revetments.
Estimated cost was $327,713.40. The amendments to the original
project relate merely to the length of the proposed piers and revet-
ments and in no wise enlarge its original scope. The present project,
by reason of the provision in the act of March 2, 1907, contemplates
a channel 16 feet deep and about 150 feet wide, protected by suitable
piers and revetments.
   To June 30, 1909, there was expended the sum of $312,533.32, of
which $179,899.10 was for construction and $132,634.22 for mainte-
nance. There have been no operations during the past fiscal year,
and the expenditures were made for the customary soundings.
   The proportion of the approved project completed to June 30, 1909,
is about 85 per cent.
   The result is a channel 140 to 153 feet wide, whose natural depth is
from 9 to 10 feet, protected by a north pier and revetment 2,226 feet
long and a south pier and revetment 1,847 feet long. Periodical
dredging is necessary to secure the projected depth of 16 feet. The
maximum draft which on June 30, 1909, could be carried over the
shoalest point in the improved channel was 12.6 feet.
   The lake commerce at this port for 1908 consisted of 1,354 arrivals
and departures, with 2,431 short tons of cargo valued at $340,000 and
entirely of local character. The local freight rates by vessel to Chi-
cago are about 20 per cent less than the corresponding rates by rail-
road.
   The following table gives the vessel commerce of Pentwater Harbor
since 1900:

                                                                                                                                                       Increase
                                                                                                                     Freight      Freight
                                                                                                                                 shipped.     otal
                                                                                                                                            fight      decrease
                                                                                                                                                         over
                                              Calendar year.                                                        received.
                                                                                                                                            carried.   previous
                                                                                                                                                        year.


                                                                                                                      Tons.        Tons.     Tons.
1900..........................                                         .....................                           13,288      16,465    29,753..........
1901.........                          ... .......................................                                      1,000       5,070     6,070   -23,683
1902...........................................                                           ..............                (a)         (a)       (a)       (a)
1903.......................................................                                                             8,675      13,555    22,230 .
1904...                       ................                    .........................                             3,000      12,423    15,423 - 6,807
1905 ...................................................                                                 ........       1,128       1,712     2,840   -12,583
1906 ......             .......                 ...........               .......................                       2,175      11,238    13,413   +10,573
1907 ........................................................                                                              875      1,657     2,532   -10,881
1908....         .............               ......           .                     ..............                      1,051       1,359      2,410  -     122

                                                                                     a Not reported.

   This table shows that during the calendar years 1906, 1907, and
1908, the total vessel freight movement was about 18,355 tons, and
the records of this office show during the same years a total expendi-
ture by the United States of $19,024, or $1.04 for each ton of vessel
freight. The cost to the United States is evidently unjustifiably
great.
   The conditions at Pentwater Harbor were made the subject of a
special investigation by the district officer, whose report was referred
for review by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors. After
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                             741
considering the past, present, and prospective commerce of the
locality, the sum expended on its improvement, and the necessary
expense attending its future maintenance, the Board expressed the
opinion that it is not desirable for the United States to make further
expenditures for the improvement or maintenance of this harbor.
Concurring in the views of the Board and in compliance with section
7 of the river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, it is recommended
that further appropriations for Pentwater Harbor be discontinued.
   Since, however, funds for maintenance have been specifically pro-
vided and pending action by Congress providing for the definite
abandonment of the improvement, it is believed that dredging and
minor repairs to afford facilities for the existing commerce should be
done, and it is therefore proposed to reserve $10,000 for repairs and
$6,000 for dredging in 1910 and 1911 from the allotment made avail-
able from the appropriation by the act of March 3, 1909.
   The last published map of this locality is found in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page 1980.
                                               WHITE LAKE          HARBOR.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. .....................................  $7, 569.01
Proceeds of sale of government property--.....-......................... 1, 150.00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909........................... ............................. 16, 000. 00
                                                                                                                   24, 719. 01
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement ................................ .     ................ .......                                         1, 050. 11
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................................                                            23, 668. 90
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts-................... 2, 490.50
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......... 21, 720. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909--..       .....................................-------------------------------------------      (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                               PENTWATER HARBOR.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..........                          ..... .............                           $3, 355. 31
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....................................................                                               16, 000. 00
                                                                                                                   19, 355. 31
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...................................................                                                       68. 63

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended........................                                   .............           19, 286. 68

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                                           26, 400.00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909-...-                                                                                           (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

  a See consolidated money statement on page 742.
  b Exclusive of $1.33, refundment of overpayment, which has been deducted from
expenditures during the fiscal year.
742          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                           U.       S. ARMY.

                                             CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................      $10, 924. 32
Proceeds of sale of government property---.................................   1, 150. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......................................................       32, 000. 00
                                                                                                44, 074. 32
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ...........  ..... .......... ...... ... .... ...... ........                       1,118.74

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                         a 42, 955. 58

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..................                         2, 490. 50
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                        48, 120. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 ..............                 .. .............   .. ...    ... ....-    b 4, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix M M 8.)
   9. Ludington Harbor, Michigan.-This harbor is the outlet of Pere
Marquette River, which expands into Pere Marquette Lake before
emptying into Lake Michigan. In 1867, before improvement was
begun by the United States, the outlet from Pere Marquette Lake
to Lake Michigan had a length of 830 feet, protected by diverging
slab piers. The entering depth was 7 to 8 feet.
   The former project was adopted in 1867 and modified in 1885,
1889, 1890, and 1899. In its final form, as adopted by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1899, it provided for a through channel 183
to 285 feet wide and 18 feet deep, protected by the requisite piers and
revetments. The estimated amount required to complete the re-
vised project was $210,000. The development of the harbor has
been progressive, the changes in the original project affecting only
the length of the piers, their direction and the depth between them.
It may therefore be said that the estimated cost of completion of that
project is really the sum of the above amount and that previously
expended, or $591,055.91 in all.
   To June 30, 1909, the sum of $712,698.78 was expended upon the
original project and its subsequent modifications. Of the above,
$579,870.79 was expended for construction and $132,827.99 for main-
tenance. As a result of the above expenditure there now exists a
reasonably reliable 18-foot channel, protected by piers and revet-
ments. Annual dredging is necessary, however, to maintain a chan-
nel 18 feet in depth and of sufficient width.
   The present project, as adopted by the act of Congress of March 2,
1907, provides for an interior channel 18 feet deep, protected by
piers and revetments, and for an exterior basin, to be formed by two
breakwaters of crib construction, each 1,800 feet long, 400 feet apart
at the outer ends and diverging at an angle of 90 degrees, the inner
  a In addition to this amount, the sum of $69,000, made available by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, remains unallotted.
   b Since the preparation of this estimate these harbors have been made the subject
of a special investigation and report, as a result of which they are now regarded as
unworthy of further improvement by the United States. Pending the further action
by Congress in the premises, this estimate may be omitted.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    748
ends of the breakwaters to be connected with the shore by suitable
structures. The estimated cost of this project was $839,087. A
continuing contract for the construction of the breakwaters, not in-
cluding the shore connections, was entered into under date of De-
cember 10, 1907, the remaining work to be placed under contract at
a later date.
   The amount expended under the present project to June 30, 1909,
was $88,454.57, all of which was for new work.
   Under the continuing contract the following work was done during
the fiscal year: For the south breakwater five additional cribs, each
100 feet long, were built, six cribs were sunk on their pile foundations,
and the superstructure was completed for a length of 343 feet. For
the north breakwater the, construction of four cribs was completed,
two cribs were sunk, and the construction of the superstructure was
begun. Under the head of maintenance, the damaged inner end of
the north pier was repaired, and 590 linear feet of that pier was
strengthened with additional piles. The filling in parts of the south
pier was replenished. The channel between the piers was deepened
October 16-17 and again May 5-7 and May 17-19 by the govern-
ment dredge, the total quantity dredged being 14,830 yards. The
dredging in May was occasioned by the grounding on May 3 of the
deep draft coal barge New York. The Gillespie was at once ordered
to Ludington and the barge was released May 5.
   The existing project gives authority for entering into continuing
contracts to complete the improvement at a cost not to exceed
$839,087, of which amount $519,087 remains to be appropriated.
   The original project for the interior harbor is completed. The
proportion of the project of 1907 completed to June 30, 1909, is 16
per cent. The maximum draft that could be carried at the end of the
fiscal year was 19 feet.
   The water-borne commerce at this harbor has averaged for the
last ten years 1,329,878 short tons, and in 1908 it consisted of 3,528
entrances and clearances, with 1,416,560 short tons of cargo, valued
at $149,553,000, and was general in character. The local freight rates
by vessel to Chicago are about 29 per cent less than the corresponding
rates by railroad.
   Excluding contract obligations, but including the allotment of
$8,000 from the appropriation of the act of March 3, 1909, there is at
present available a total of $9,161.84 besides the amount necessarily
reserved for contingencies, and this amount is sufficient to pay for
needed dredging and incidental repairs during the remainder of 1909
and in 1910. During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, there may
be profitably expended the following:
For continuing improvement, as authorized, under continuing contract.... $300, 000
For maintenance by dredging........................................          5,000
For maintenance, incidental repairs, and contingencies ..................... 5, 000
      Total ..............................................................   310, 000
  The report upon which the project of 1907 is based is printed in
House Document No. 62, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
  This harbor is one terminus of the main line of the Pere Marquette
Railroad Company, which operates lines of car ferries from this
point to Manitowoc, Wis., and Milwaukee, Wis. Lines of passenger
and package freight steamers also make regular sailings to Milwaukee
744             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                      S. ARMY.

and Chicago. The business done by the car-ferry lines is of enormous
and constantly increasing importance in its effect upon freight rates
to and from the Northwest. It is desirable to give to the car-ferry
service the same assurance of regularity of schedule as exists in the
case of the ordinary railroad lines. At present difficulty is usually
experienced in the fall and winter months, due to the narrowing of
the channel by a shoal from the north. The car ferries are large and
unwieldy and require ample sea room. A narrow channel is therefore
impracticable, and to insure safety and regularity to the service re-
peated dredging is necessary, for which the United States seagoing
hydraulic dredge is now available.
  The effect of the improvement has been to create a class of traffic
which, in the absence of a deep and readily available channel, could
never have existed. There has thus been provided a shorter route for
the products of the upper Mississippi Valley, which has the additional
merit of avoiding the congestion usually existing on the railroads at
the south shore of Lake Michigan. Freight rates are believed to have
been materially reduced by this route.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................                                                       $161, 731. 67
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act of March 3,
  1909---------------------...........................................................--------------------------------....    8, 000.00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909........ 200, 000. 00

                                                                                                                       369, 731. 67
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...........................                                             $87, 428. 06
    For maintenance of improvement.......................                                             3, 567. 87
                                                                                                                      a 90, 995. 93

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...............................................                                    b 278, 735. 74
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .................................................                                      500. 15

July 1, 1909, balance available ............                                ...     ...................                278, 235. 59

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. .............                                                   251, 560. 11
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                                 519, 087. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
    For works of improvement.................          .........     000.00                       $300,
    For maintenance of improvement ...................           10, 000. 00
                                                                                                                      310, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix M M 9.)
  10. Manistee Harbor, Michigan.-In 1866, previous to the begin-
ning of work by the United States, the entrance to this harbor was
improved by slab piers, 100 to 150 feet apart, built by local enter-
prise, a navigable depth of 7 to 8 feet being thereby maintained.
  The project adopted in 1867 and amended in 1871, 1873, 1875, 1884,
1890, and 1892, provides for a channel of navigable width with a
depth of 15 feet, extending from Lake Michigan to Manistee Lake,
protected by piers and revetments at the entrance. The various
  a Exclusive of $226.17 expended account Isthmian Canal Commission, of which
$155.61 has been reimbursed.
  b Inclusive of $70.56 to be reimbursed by Isthmian Canal Commission.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     745
modifications of the original project merely extended its limits,
changed the proposed length of the piers, and the proposed depth
from 12 to 15 feet. Operations have been progressive, and no
work under any project not essential to its final form has been
done.
    To June 30, 1909, there had been expended $448,614.40, of which
$329,996.18 was for construction and $118,618.22 for maintenance.
    As a result of the above total expenditure to June 30, 1909, there
had been built 2,906 linear feet of north and 1,450 linear feet of south
pier and revetment, the width between the piers varying between 150
feet inside and 190 feet at the outer end of the south pier, which is
250 feet shorter than the north pier. The portion of the north
revetment occupied by the Manistee and Northeastern Railroad
Company, referred to in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1899, page 2940, still remains without repairs.
    The act approved March 2, 1907, changed the project by pro-
viding for improvement in accordance with the report submitted
in House Document No. 511, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session,
which contemplates securing a uniform depth of 18 feet, by dredging
to a depth of 20 feet, pier extension, revetment, and protection
works, at an estimated cost of $147,488, provided satisfactory
pledge is given that certain private and municipal work will be
completed within a reasonable time, that land for the improvement
will be donated, and that the United States will be protected from
claims for damages which may result from the work. No expendi-
tures have yet been incurred on account of the modified project,
approved March 2, 1907.
    The following is a summary of the operations during the past
fiscal year: Dredging under contract for widening the channel in
the river, begun June 22, 1908, was completed July 11, and the
channel at the entrance and through the outer bar was deepened
November 12-23 by the Gillespie to 20 feet. Under an emergency
contract, dated July 1, parts of the two piers were refilled with
stone, and on May 20 operations under contract were begun for
thoroughly repairing the north pier between stations 7+69 and
  12+38.7. All these operations come under the head of maintenance.
    Of the original project 95 per cent is completed, and, as already
stated, no work has yet been done upon the modified project of 1907.
The maximum draft which on June 30, 1909, could be carried was 15
feet.
     The vessel commerce at this port for the last ten years has averaged
  526,956 short tons, and in 1908 it amounted to 2,116 entrances and
  clearances with 428,084 short tons of cargo, valued at $17,411,000,
  principally local in character. Definite information as to the effect
  of the improvement upon freight rates could not be obtained, but
  the local freight rates by vessel from Manistee to Chicago are about
  30 per cent less than the corresponding rates by railroad.
     As the conditions precedent to beginning work under the project of
  1907 have not yet been met, the project of 1892 remains in force.
  After deducting outstanding obligations and contingencies, a balance
  of $11,228.44 remains available, which will permit dredging at the
  entrance by the Gillespie during two seasons and additional repairs
  when required.
746           REPORT OF THIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                           tJ. S. ARMY.

  During the year ending June 30, 1911, there may profitably be
expended for maintenance of improvement the following:
For repair of outer end of north pier ....................................                                             $2, 000
For incidental repairs    --------.............-----------------.......................------.............              5,000
For dredging at entrance by Gillespie ..............----------------------...............---------.......---.           5, 000
For dredging in upper reaches of channel by contract.........-...........                                              10, 000
        Total....----------...---------........-......--------...-----..---...----------....--.............----.       22, 000
   The commerce tributary to this harbor is derived principally from
the salt and lumber industries. The harbor is also a regular port of
call for one line of steamers plying from Chicago to points upon the
east shore of Lake Michigan, and a single steamer makes stated trips
from Manistee to Milwaukee. There are three railroads running into
Manistee, the Pere Marquette, the Manistee and Grand Rapids, and
the Manistee and Northeastern.
   Reference to reports on preliminary examination and survey,
ordered by the river and harbor act approved March 3, 1905, will be
found on page 644 of the report for 1906.
   The last published map of this locality is found in House Docu-
ment No. 511, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................     $29, 549. 27
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenence of im-
  provement-----........------...........................................   6, 138. 80

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..-..............................                                                   23, 410. 47
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .................................
                                               .                                                                        120. 25

July 1, 1909, balance available...........................................                                          23, 290. 22

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                                              10, 604. 86
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project---.........                                         122, 488. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.. .............................................                                               22, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix M M 10.)
   11. Harbor qf refuge at Portage Lake, Manistee County, Mich.-In
1879, when work was begun by the United States, there was a channel
4 feet deep and 130 feet wide between slab piers built by local enter-
prise.
   The approved project, adopted in 1879 and amended in 1881 and
1890, contemplates the construction of a harbor of refuge, with an
entrance from Lake Michigan 356 feet wide and 18 feet deep, pro-
tected by piers and revetments. Estimated cost, revised in 1897 and
1899, was $344,300.
   The modifications of the original project have in no way changed its
scope, so that essentially the project is to-day as when originally
adopted. All expenditures made up to the present time have con-
tributed to the completion of the project in its present form.
   To June 30, 1909, there had been expended the sum of $376,566.28,
of which $254,129.21 was for construction and $122,437.07 for
maintenance.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                        747
   There was no work of improvement carried on at this harbor during
the fiscal year. The expenditures were incurred for surveying
purposes.
   The approved project is completed as far as pier construction is
concerned, but the dredging to the proposed width and depth re-
mains as yet incomplete.
   The harbor structures are in good condition. The north pier, com-
prising 114 feet of pile work in wing at inner end, 1,235 feet of pile
work along channel, and 851 feet of cribwork, has a total length of
2,200 feet and projects 1,210 feet beyond the shore line. The south
pier, comprising 1,399 feet of pile work, including 17 feet of wing at
east end, and 901 feet of cribwork, has a total length of 2,300 feet and
projects 1,150 feet beyond the shore line.
   As shown by soundings made May 11-12, the maximum draft that
could be carried from Lake Michigan to Portage Lake, on June 30,
1909, was 17 feet.
   The vessel commerce at this harbor for 1908 was 480 arrivals and
departures with 3,441 short tons of cargo, valued at $147,000, and was
entirely local in character.
   This harbor is one practically destitute of local or through com-
merce, and, while it is doubtful whether a harbor of refuge here will
ever be of much service, no just conclusion can be drawn until a
channel of ample depth and width has been made available. Unless
this is done the larger class of vessels can not use the harbor and the
large expenditures already made will, to a considerable extent, be
useless. The only way to arrive at a satisfactory determination of
the question whether or not vessels will turn aside from the usual
vessel course in order to take shelter here is to complete the author-
ized project, and an estimate for this purpose and for maintenance is
accordingly presented. The balance at present available is about
$2,900, which will pay for a short period of dredging by the Gillespie
and for contingencies.
   The estimate of funds which can profitably be expended in the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911, is as follows:
For works of improvement: For dredging by contract .................                         $15, 000. 00
For maintenance of improvement:
    For dredging in 1910 and 1911.........................           ..            $6, 000
    For repairs and contingencies ............................                      5, 000
                                                                                              11, 000. 00

        Total .................        .........................................              26, 000. 00
The last published map of this locality is found in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page 1974.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                         $3, 008. 22
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement....................................................                                  74.50

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                            2, 933. 72

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                      15, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909...............................                              26, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix M M 11.)
748             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                              U.    S. ARMY.

    12. Arcadia Harbor, Michigan.-The act of March 3, 1905, appro-
priated $6,000 for the improvement of this harbor in accordance with
report submitted in House Document No. 194, Fifty-eighth Congress,
second session.
    While a plan was submitted for rebuilding the piers at a cost of
 $90,390, and annual maintenance and dredging at a cost of $5,200, the
plan that was recommended and approved was for maintenance of the
present channel by dredging only, at a cost of $3,000 annually for a
period of five years, at the end of which time, if a growth of the com-
merce had been manifested such as to warrent larger expenditures,
the plan for radical improvement by reconstruction of the piers could
be undertaken. At the time of the survey, September, 1902, the
depth was some 12 feet in a narrow and rather difficult channel, pro-
duced and maintained by repeated dredging at local expense, and
this depth was subject to considerable reduction during the usual
lowering of the lake surface in the months of October and April, so
that only 10 feet could be safely counted on as the navigable depth.
The piers terminate at the 10-foot contour.
    To June 30, 1909, there had been expended $12,038.75 for dredging.
    The channel was surveyed April 30 to May 6, 1909, and the avail-
able depth between the piers was found to be 6.2 feet.
    Dredging operations under contract were commenced June 8 and
-completed June 25, and resulted in restoring a channel 12 feet deep
and 50 feet wide from the inner lake to Lake Michigan. The dredged
material measured 13,888 cubic yards.
    The approved project is completed by reason of the expiration of
the authorized period of five years for maintenance by dredging.
The benefit resulting from the five year's dredging operations is not
of a lasting nature. The effect of each season's dredging was always
found entirely obliterated in the following spring, and it can not be
expected that a useful channel will be found in 1910. The maxi-
mum draft that could be carried on June 30, 1909, was 12 feet.
    The number of tons of various articles shipped and received and
the entrances and clearances of vessels from 1894 to 1901, inclusive,
are shown on page 576 in Report of Chief of Engineers for 1905.
    The vessel commerce at this harbor for 1908 was 2,975 short tons,
valued at $125,000, and entirely local in character.
    The act of March 3, 1909, carried an allotment of $3,000, being
the fifth and last installment under the project. For this reason
no estimate may now be presented to cover the needs of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1911.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended----.....---.........................--------------------------...                             $461. 52
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909---------.....-..------...-.....----..----------------------..............---.....................---------......... 3, 000. 00

                                                                                                                          3, 461.52
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement----..           ........
                   ---------------... --- -..............--       .....-- .                                                  500. 27
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended--............--------------------------------..                                          2, 961. 25
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities----......................--------------------------------                               69. 55
July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                                             ...     2, 891. 70

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts.................. 2, 700. 00
    (See Appendix M M 12.)
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     749
   13. Frankfort Harbor, Michigan.-In 1867, when the United States
began work of improvement at this harbor, which is the entrance to
Lake Aux Bees Scies, there existed an outlet about 750 feet north
of the present channel, affording a depth of 3 to 4 feet and width of
70 to 80 feet between slab piers, built by local enterprise.
   The project, adopted in 1866 and amended in 1868, 1879, and 1892,
provided for a new outlet, with channel 12 feet deep and 200 feet
wide, protected by piers and revetments. The estimated cost, revised
in 1897 in compliance with the river and harbor act of June 3, 1896, to
cover the cost of securing a channel 18 feet deep, was $413,659.85; fur-
ther revised in 1899 to $421,938.35. The changes in the original project
have been in effect merely extensions, so that the existing project
does not differ in kind from the original one. All expenditures may
therefore justly be regarded as pertaining to the present project.
   To June 30, 1909, there had been expended the sum of $443,710.61,
of which $321,508.20 was for construction and $122,202.41 for main-
tenance.
   The following is a summary of the operations during the fiscal year:
The contractors for the extension and repair of the south pier pre-
pared the foundation of the new crib by removing the shattered 40
feet of the old work and preparing the foundation for the additional
60 feet to be covered by the new crib and completed the construction
of the new crib. Most of this work was done before the close of the
working season of 1908. In the money accounts of this work it will
be assumed that 60 per cent of the total cost of this crib must be
assigned to new work and 40 per cent to maintenance.
   Under a contract dated March 1, for repairing the south pier
between stations 0 +89.6 and 1+86.6, operations began May 18, but
the only work accomplished to the end of the fiscal year was the
removal of the ruined old structure.
   Between October 3 and 15 the Gillespie deepened the outer ap-
proach to 20 feet. On March 12 the available depth outside was
found to be 18.5 feet, and between the piers 18.2 feet in a very
narrow and irregular channel. The Gillespie improved this condition
April 28 to May 15, the resulting depth being 19.3 feet. The total
quantity dredged at this location by the Gillespie during the year was
54,716 cubic yards.
   The approved project is about 95 per cent completed.
   The total expenditure above mentioned has resulted in the creation
and maintenance of a channel 18 feet deep, whose natural depth,
or depth to which the channel would probably shoal in a few years
without dredging, is 12 feet, the width being 200 feet. It is pro-
tected by a north pier and revetment 1,900 feet long and a south
pier and revetment 1,938 feet long, of which the outer 400 feet was
built by the Toledo and Ann Arbor Railroad Company. Dredging
from time to time will be required to maintain the depths needed for
navigation. The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909,
was 19 feet.
   Practically the entire commerce of this harbor is transacted by the
car-ferry lines of the Ann Arbor Railroad, which has its northern
terminus at this harbor. These car ferries run to Kewaunee and
Marinette, Wis., upon the west shore of Lake Michigan, and form a
highly important link in the through commerce between the North-
west and the Atlantic seaboard. The importance of maintaining
adequate facilities at Frankfort Harbor is manifest. This can be
750           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                          S. ARMY.

done with certainty only by repeated radical dredging. Pier exten-
sion unaccompanied by thorough dredging will not serve.
   The water-borne commerce at this port has averaged for the last
ten years 741,231 short tons, and in 1908 it amounted to 1,330
entrances and clearances with 563,332 short tons of cargo, valued at
$61,419,000 and for the most part general in character.
   The available balance at this harbor is nearly $10,000, which is
sufficient to pay for dredging by the Gillespie until June 30, 1911.
For the maintenance of the harbor structures until that time, an
appropriation of $6,800 is recommended and $13,200 should be
appropriated for the addition of 100 feet to the north pier to com-
plete the project.
   The last published map of this harbor is found in the Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1884, page 1973.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ..................................... $35, 696.54
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement........................................................     6, 968. 80

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                     28, 727. 74
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ................................                    160. 28
July 1, 1909, balance available. ........................................              28, 567.46

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. ...............                 18, 844. 54
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........               13, 200. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909        -...........
                                                   .........   ............            20, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix M M 13.)
   14. Charlevoix Harbor and entrance to Pine Lake, Michigan.--In
1868, when the first estimate for improvement was made, the avail-
able channel in Pine River between Lake Michigan and Round Lake
was 75 feet wide and 2 to 6 feet deep. Up to 1873 the local authori-
ties, with some assistance from the State, had constructed 468 feet
of cribwork in the north pier and 80 feet of cribwork in the south
pier, and the available depth was 6 feet. The first appropriation by
the United States was made in 1876, and actual operations upon the
lower channel were begun in the fiscal year 1878; the first appropria-
tion for the upper channel was made in 1882, and actual work begun
in 1885. The total estimated cost was $186,000.
   The original project, as proposed in 1868, and amended in 1876
and 1882, provided for a 12-foot channel from Lake Michigan to
Round Lake (lower channel), between piers and revetments, 100 to
150 feet apart, and from Round Lake to Pine Lake (upper channel),
between revetments, 83 feet apart. The following provision of the
river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, may be said to have extended
the scope of the original project: "Improving harbor at Charlevoix
and entrance to Pine Lake, Michigan: Continuing improvement,
twenty thousand dollars, to be first expended in obtaining a uniform
depth of channel from Lake Michigan to Pine Lake." The control-
ling depth of the lower channel in June, 1902, was 16.3 feet.
   The amount expended under the existing project (not including
outstanding liabilities) to June 30, 1909, was $205,727.37, of which
$80,205.04 was for construction and $125,522.33 for maintenance.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                           751
   No works of improvement have been in progress during the fiscal
year, and the amounts expended were for the payment of outstand-
ing liabilities, survey, and contingencies.
   About 70 per cent of the pier construction contemplated by the
approved project has been completed, the work remaining to be
done being the extension of the south pier by 200 linear feet. The
maximum draft that could be carried at the end of the fiscal year,
as shown by soundings made June 22-24, was 16.7 feet.
   The principal traffic tributary to this harbor is furnished by the
lumber industry, which has recently been growing greatly in impor-
tance. The sawmills are situated at Boyne and East Jordan, both
at the upper end of Pine Lake, the outlet for which is through both
channels. Due to the fact that many of the lumber-carrying vessels
do not clear at Charlevoix, the commercial statistics fail to disclose
the full traffic, which is, however, known to be considerably over
1,000,000 tons. Charlevoix is also a much-frequented summer resort,
and during the summer season two steamboat lines make regular
and frequent calls at this harbor. There is in addition a small amount
of local traffic. A depth of 17 feet at zero of gauge should be main-
tained to enable the larger class of vessels to transact their business
with economy..
   The lake commerce which cleared at this port for 1908 was 384
arrivals and departures, with 45,211 short tons of cargo, valued at
$2,643,000, and was principally local in character. As stated this
is considerably less than the true total.
   At present there is available a balance of $20,848.84, of which it is
proposed to apply $4,000 for the repair of the outer 200 feet of the
south pier and $8,000 to dredging when needed, and the balance will
be reserved for maintenance, for which purpose it will be ample. A
better sheltered entrance seems desirable, and for this purpose it
would be wise to complete the south pier as authorized, for which an
appropriation of $23,750 is recommended for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1911.
   The report upon a survey made with a view to obtaining a 16-foot
channel is published in full in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1897, pages 2953-2954, and is also printed with a map
in House Document No. 144, Fifty-fourth Congress, second session.
   Report of the examination authorized by the river and harbor act
approved June 13, 1902, has been printed as House Document No.
222, Fifty-eighth Congress, second session.
   Definite information as to the effect of the improvement on freight
rates could not be obtained.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....--.......-................... $18, 990. 12
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ...................................... .............. 6, 000. 00
                                                                              24, 990. 12
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement...........----..--.....................................--....      4, 097. 84

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................       20, 892. 28
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.......-...... .......................        43. 44

July 1, 1909, balance available ..........................................    20, 848. 84
752       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                   U.   S. ARMY.

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project- ..-........ $23, 750. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909.......-.                                                       23, 750. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.
   (See Appendix M M 14.)
   15. Petoskey Harbor, Michigan.-Before work at this harbor was
begun by the United States its landing pier was exposed to winds
coming from between west and northwest, and in high gales it was
dangerous to attempt a landing.
   A project was adopted in the river and harbor act of August 18,
1894, which provided for constructing a breakwater 600 feet long
about 600 feet west of the outer end of the landing pier and another
north of it 500 feet long, or as much longer as might be found neces-
sary to cover the landing from all dangerous seas. Work was begun
in 1896. Estimated cost was $170,000.
   In 1902 the west breakwater had been built for a length of 400
feet and the north breakwater for a length of 200 feet. Investiga-
tion having shown that the north breakwater was too near the wharf
and that the entrance between the two breakwaters was too narrow,
the project was modified under authority conferred by the act of
June 13, 1902, so as to provide for the removal of the north break-
water and the extension of the west breakwater, the final cost not to
exceed the amount estimated to complete the original project, viz,
$170,000.
   The amount expended under the original project and as modified
in 1902 up to June 30, 1909, has been $125,500, of which $118,239.40
was for new work and $7,260.60 for maintenance.
   There has been no work of improvement in progress during the
fiscal year; the sum of $8.34 was expended for contingencies.
   The breakwater as now existing has a total length of 1,345 feet,
consisting of 445 feet of stonework and 900 feet of cribwork. The
amount expended for construction constitutes about 70 per cent of
the estimated cost of the project.
   The lake commerce which cleared at this port for 1908 was 20
entrances and departures with 858 short tons of cargo, valued at
$212,000, entirely local in character.
   The stone portion of the breakwater is in bad condition, and for
the purpose of restoring its efficiency an appropriation of $5,000, for
maintenance, is recommended for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, as well as $15,000 for the addition of 100 feet to the break-
water, which it is believed will answer all local needs.
   Definite information as to the effect of the project on freight rates
could not be obtained.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended........  -............
                                                     ............ ..... $8. 34
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
                                                                         8.34
  improvement--..---------........---....-----.............................
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 56, 900. 00
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                             753
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance................ $20, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix M M 15.)
   16. U. S. dredge General Gillespie.a--This dredge is of the seagoing
suction type, and was built in 1904 for use at the harbors on the east
shore of Lake Michigan.
   Since March 1, 1909, the work of this dredge has been closely super-
vised and verified. Under extremely favorable conditions this boat
has been able to move a maximum of slightly more than 4,000 cubic
yards in eight hours of actual work, but the average at all harbors
and under all circumstances is about 3,000 yards per day of eight
hours.
   For dredging under precisely the same conditions in the past the
contract cost with dipper dredges has been as high as 25 cents per
cubic yard, and then work outside the piers was never possible until
about the 1st of June, whereas the Gillespie works in the most exposed
places at any and all seasons. The final average cost of her work for
the period considered is 7.618 cents per cubic yard, and this is believed
to fairly represent the cost of dredging under the conditions existing
in this district. When compared with the performance of similar
machines on the seacoast, the cost may seem high; but the circum-
stances under which this dredge is obliged to work-such as insuffi-
cient depth of water, etc.-affect unfavorably the final cost per unit.
   A description of the boat and a tabular statement of the results of
operating the Gillespie from March 19, 1909, to June 30, 1909, may be
found in Appendix M M 16 of this report.

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE DETROIT, MICHI-
                     GAN, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Lieut. Col. C. McD. Townsend,
Corps of Engineers, having under his immediate orders Capt. G. R.
Spalding, Corps of Engineers, to July 27, 1908. Division engineer,
Col. W. L. Fisk, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Ship channel connecting waters of the Great Lakes between Chi-
cago, Duluth, and Bufalo.-In its natural state the channel connecting
Lake Superior and Lake Huron was obstructed by the rapids of the
St. Marys River, and navigation through other connecting channels
was difficult and dangerous for boats drawing 8 feet. In 1855 the
State of Michigan completed a canal at Sault Ste. Marie, with locks
which were 350 feet long, 70 feet in width, and about 12 feet in depth
on the miter sills. Prior to the civil war the channels through Lake
George on the St. Marys River and through the St. Clair Flats at the
outlet of St. Clair River were deepened to 12 feet by the General
Government.
  When the construction of the Weitzel lock was undertaken, pro-
viding for a navigable depth of 16 feet, it became necessary to in-
crease channel depths not only at the localities above mentioned, but
      a The name of this dredge has been changed to the GeneralG. G. Meade.
      9001-EN o 1909--48
754      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

also at other localities on the St. Marys River and Detroit River.
These improvements were made under specific appropriations for
the localities where the work was required, as explained elsewhere
in this report under the heads of St. Marys River, Hay Lake, St.
Clair Flats, and Detroit River improvements.
    When in 1890 the construction of the Poe lock was undertaken,
providing for a depth over the miter sill of 21 feet at mean lake levels,
a deepening of the channel at other localities became necessary, and
the river and harbor act of July 13, 1892, authorized an expenditure
of $3,340,000 for a ship channel "twenty and twenty-one feet deep,
and a minimum width of 300 feet in the shallows of the connecting
waters of the Great Lakes," at localities not especially provided for
by the then existing appropriations.
    This project originally provided for improvements at eight local-
ities, i. e., (1) at Round Island shoals in the upper St. Marys River;
 (2) in Little Mud Lake, St. Marys River; (3) at Sailors Encampment,
St. Marys River; (4) in Mud Lake, St. Marys River; (5) at the foot of
Lake Huron; (6) at the mouth of the St. Clair River; (7) at entrance
to the Detroit River in Lake St. Clair, and (8) at the mouth of the
Detroit River. By 1897 channels 300 feet wide and 20 feet deep at
mean lake level, as determined by gauge readings up to the time of
the adoption of the project, had been secured at a cost of $2,212,000.
     The sundry civil act of June 4, 1897, authorized the expenditure
of the balance of the appropriation for the maintenance of the project
and its further extension to localities where recent surveys had
shown that greater depths were necessary. Since 1898, therefore, the
expenditures from the available balance of the appropriation have
been for widening and deepening the channels of the original project
and for the removal of isolated shoals, usually of small area, which
have been found to interfere with the safe navigation of the channel
by the larger and deeper draft vessels now in commission. The prin-
cipal additional works thus accomplished have been the widening of
channel at Round Island shoals and the removal of the Vidal shoals
in the upper St. Marys River, Squaw Island, and Sweet Point shoals
'at the mouth of the St. Marys River, Crab Island shoal in Detour
Passage, the shoal in the St. Clair River at the mouth of the Black,
the St. Clair Middle Ground shoal in the St. Clair River opposite the
city of St. Clair, and Squirrel Island shoal in the same river. In
addition a new channel west of Stag Island, St. Clair River, has been
opened by the removal of several shoals interfering with deep-draft
navigation, and considerable work in the Detroit River has been
done that was not contemplated in the original project.
     Since 1892 the levels of Lakes Huron, St. Clair, and Erie have been
almost continuously below the plane adopted as mean lake level at
the time of the authorization of the original project and, as a conse-
quence, the actual draft available throughout the improved channels
has varied from 17 to 19 feet. The slopes of the St. Marys River
have also been affected by the dredging of channels through it. On
account of these facts a new datum for the various improvements was
adopted in 1902. This new datum plane is that of the low water of
1895, which varies, as explained in the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1904, page 552, from 2 to 3 feet below the mean
lake levels. In addition to the annual variations in levels the mean
monthly levels may vary from 4 inches to 2 feet in a single year, and
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                         755
daily variations in the water surface may amount to 2 feet in variable
weather, or even to 6 and 8 feet in severe storms, on Lakes Superior
and Erie.
   The total expenditure on the improvements to June 30, 1909, was
$3,340,000. With this expenditure and specific appropriations for
special localities, channels not less than 300 feet in width, with depths
varying from 20 to 23 feet below mean lake levels, have been con-
structed, connecting the waters of the Great Lakes between Chicago,
Duluth, and Buffalo, as called for by the project.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, appropriated $25,000
for maintenance and surveys, and $63.14 were expended during the
fiscal year.
   The only work done during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909,
has been the making of surveys of Round Island Middle ground,
St. Marys River, and the enforcement of rules and regulations for
navigating Stag Island channel in St. Clair River.
   The amount of freight carried through the St. Marys River section
of the channel during the navigation season of 1908 was 41,390,557
freight tons, valued at $470,141,318, exclusive of local traffic amount-
ing to about 1,500,000 tons. Statistics of traffic through the St.
Clair Flats Canal indicate that 50,586,560 tons of freight passed
through this section, while that passing Detroit River amounted to
54,086,750 tons, valued at $614,425,480.
   It is believed that to attribute to the improvement in channels the
difference in freight rates of 1900 (1.18 mills per mile-ton) and 1908
(0.69 mills per mile-ton) would not exaggerate the effect of the im-
provement, especially in view of the fact that the greater permissible
draft has produced vessels of greater tonnage, the carrying capacity
of freight steamers having increased from 8,000 tons in 1900 to 13,000
tons in 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................  $1, 530. 45
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909 ..............................................................  25, 000.00
                                                                           26, 530. 45
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement............................. $1, 530. 45
    For maintenance of improvement ....................... ..  63. 14
                                                                            1, 593.59

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..................................         24, 936. 86
   (See Appendix N N 1.)
   2. St. Marys River at the falls, Michigan.-The St. Marys rapids
are about one-half mile wide and three-fourths of a mile long.
The fall ranges from 16 feet to 20 feet with varying stages of
water. The water surface, usually changing slowly, may have an
extreme range of 6 feet in a few hours, and the monthly mean eleva-
tion of the surface may change as much as 2 feet in one year, or 4
feet during forty years.
   Commercial navigation of the falls, or rapids, of this river at
Sault Ste. Marie was impracticable until 1855, when the State of
Michigan constructed a canal which provided a navigable channel
for vessels whose draft was 11.5 feet at mean stage of water, at a
cost of about $1,000,000, the proceeds of 750,000 acres of land granted
by the United States Congress. This improvement was completed in
756     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S. ARMY.

1855, the double-lift lock having tandem chambers 350 feet long and
70 feet wide, with gate openings of 70 feet arranged for 9 feet
average lift at each lock, and the canal being about 5,700 feet long,
with an available width of 64 feet and a top width of 100 feet. The
commerce in 1870 was about 540,000 tons per year.
   In 1870 the United States entered upon a project for increasing
the canal to at least 100 feet width, replacing the stone slope walls
with timber revetment piers, building a new lock, and providing
for 16 feet draft. This lock (now known as the Weitzel lock) was
opened to traffic in 1881, its single chamber being 515 feet long and
80 feet wide, narrowed at gate openings to 60 feet and arranged for
18 feet average lift. The cost of the work from 1856 to 1885, inclu-
sive, was $2,625,692, including $10,000 diverted from the 1864 Great
Lakes appropriation. A rapidly increasing commerce developed as
a result of these improvements.
   The project presented in reports dated October 18 and December
22, 1886, provided for building, on the site of the old state locks, a
new lock with a single lift of 16 to 21 feet, the chamber being 800
feet long by 100 feet wide, with 21 feet of water at mean stage on
the miter sills; also for deepening the canal and its approaches, all at
an estimated cost of $4,738,865. By authority of river and harbor
act of August 5, 1886, work under this project was begun, and the
essential features of the project were so far completed in 1896 as to
permit the new lock to be opened to navigation August 3 of that year.
This lock has since been known as the Poe lock. Later work has
consisted in completing the deepening of the canal and its approaches,
rebuilding and extending canal piers, grading and improving canal
grounds, etc.
   The river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, authorized the following
diversions from existing funds, namely, $20,000 for special improve-
ment at Sailors Encampment, $20,000 for salaries and expenses of the
International Waterways Commission, and $86,491.28, the amount
required to complete certain improvements at St. Clair Flats Canal,
for which existing funds pertaining to the latter work were insuffi-
cient. The act also provided for extending the work at the falls so as
to include widening and further improvement of the canal above the
locks, in accordance with the project submitted in House Document
No. 128, Fifty-sixth Congress, second session, but made no additional
appropriation therefor.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, authorized the expendi-
ture under continuing contract of $1,020,000 for widening canal as
proposed in project submitted in House Document No. 215, Fifty-
eighth Congress, third session. Of this $1,020,000 there remains to
be appropriated $25,000, and this amount can be profitably expended
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to be applied to rock and
earth excavation, concrete revetment walls, timber piers, filling, mov-
able dams, including head gates, and to superintendence and contin-
gencies, all in accordance with project above mentioned.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, adopted a project for the
construction of a new lock, with a separate canal, in accordance with
"plan 3," set forth in House Document No. 333, Fifty-ninth Congress,
second session, at an estimated cost of $6,200,000, of which $1,625,000
has been appropriated and the balance ($4,575,000) authorized to be
expended under continuing contract, but not yet appropriated.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                             757
   During the fiscal year the work of widening the present canal has
been continued and 287,163 cubic yards of earth and rock excavated
and 2,253 cubic yards of concrete placed in canal walls. A contract
for the construction of the superstructure of the movable dam was
executed May 8, 1909, but the delivery of the material has not been
commenced.
   Work on the new lock and canal has consisted in the construction
of the cofferdam around the lock pit and the excavation of 97,733
cubic yards on the site of the lock.
   The additional appropriation recommended will be applied to lock
excavation, pumping, lock masonry, machinery, gates, canal exca-
vation, engineering, office expenses, and contingencies.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1909, under present project for
general improvement are $5,021,258.45, of which amount $20,000 was
applied to Sailors Encampment, $1,704.22 to expenses of Inter-
national Waterways Commission, and $86,491.28 to the St. Clair
Flats Canal, leaving an unexpended balance of $745,871.74. The
balance of the $20,000 diversion ($18,295.78 not included in total ex-
penditures) for International Waterways Commission was trans-
ferred to the Commission.
   Expenditures to June 30, 1909, for new lock and canal were
$202,093.35, leaving an unexpended balance of $1,422,906.65.
   The commerce passing the falls during the navigation season of
1908, a period of seven months and twenty-five days, amounted to
41,390,557 tons of freight, valued at $470,141,318.      The number of
passengers reported during the same period was 53,287.
   More detailed information may be found in Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1886, pages 1792 to 1808, and for 1907, page
2034 (historical notes).
                                         CANAL     WIDENING, ETC.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................... $863, 491. 49
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 225, 000.00
                                                                      1, 088, 491.49
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement.......... ...............................................  a 342, 619. 75

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................           745, 871. 74
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities................................   ....    62, 533. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available ..................................             683, 338. 74

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts-...-...........          463,'758. 17
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..-......         25, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909........ .......................................                  25, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.

  a Includes the following accounts paid by Treasury Department:
Account of Duluth, South Shore and Atlantic Railway Company.......... $5, 985. 86
Account of Michigan Central Railroad Company.........................         13. 02
Account of Minneapolis, St. Paul and Sault Ste. Marie Railroad Company.      208. 20
Transferred to appropriation for survey of Northern and Northwestern
  Lakes for Poe lock drawings ........................................... 1, 044. 00

                                                                                 7, 251.08
758           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMIY.

                                         NEW LOCK AND CANAL.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................. $1, 145, 712. 20
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909....      425, 000. 00
                                                                               1, 570, 712. 20
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement ................................. ...................... . .....     147, 805. 55
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................             1, 422, 906. 65
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................            5, 164. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available ..................................             1, 417, 742. 65
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts...............                1, 772. 00
Amount(estimated) required for completion of existing project.......           4, 575, 000.00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909......................................    ..              1, 100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
                                               CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................................. $2, 009, 203. 69
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909....    650, 000. 00
                                                                               2, 659, 203. 69
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement......................................................                490, 425. 30
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................         2, 168, 778. 39
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................           67, 697. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................            2, 101, 081. 39
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts.............                465, 530. 17
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......          4, 600, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.......................................                   1,125, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
    (See Appendix N N 2.)
   8. Operating and care of St. Marys Falls Canal, Michigan.-The
former conditions and the results of the improvement are the same as
above stated for St. Marys River at the falls.
   The service of operating and care is provided for by the permanent
indefinite appropriation for operating and care of canals and other
works of navigation under the provisions of section 4 of the river and
harbor act of July 5, 1884, as amended and reenacted by section 6 of
the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
   The total expenditure on this account from 1881, when the Weitzel
lock was first put in service, to June 30, 1909 (excluding $8,663.55 out-
standing liabilities), amounted to $1,707,734.96, of which $106,514.26
related to operations for the fiscal year.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, the United States canal
was open to navigation two hundred and thirty-eight days, the closed
season being from December 14, 1908, to April 19, 1909, inclusive. A
total of 11,164 vessels, aggregating 25,481,838 registered tons, and
carrying 32,757,486 tons of freight and 23,101 passengers, passed
                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMVIPROVEMENTS.                                                               159
through the locks in 7,671 lockages. The Canadian canal at Sault Ste.
Marie, Ontario, open two hundred and thirty-nine days, made 3,894
lockages and passed 5,202 vessels, with an aggregate registered ton-
nage of 10,772,659, and carrying 14,748,113 tons of freight and 30,912
passengers. The combined traffic through the two canals amounted
to 47,505,599 tons of freight and 54,013 passengers.
   The principal items of freight during the past fiscal year through
both canals were: Iron ore, 29,993,864 tons; coal, 10,482,117 tons;
flour, 6,218,237 barrels; wheat, 102,602,007 bushels; other grain,
45,347,674 bushels; lumber, 487,779 M feet b. m.; and general mer-
chandise, 960,256 tons.
   Other statistics in relation to this traffic and commerce for the
calendar season of 1908 are summarized in the following statements:
Summary of St. Marys River commerce, via American and Canadian canals, during the
  calendarseason of 1908, viz, from April 21 to December 15, 1908, a period of two hundred
  and thirty-nine days.
Total freight carried, tons.............................................                                             $41, 390, 557
Total tons net register................................................                                               31,091,730
Total mile-tons...--.............................................                                                34, 853, 548, 177
Total valuation placed on freight carried ....................                                         .......     $470, 141, 318
Total amount paid for freight transportation ........................                                                $23, 903, 244
Total number of registered vessels using canals....................                                                            806
Total number of passages by unregistered crafts carrying freight ....                                                          286
Total valuation placed on registered vessels .......................                                               $111, 697,000
Total number of passengers transported ...................                                              ........           53, 287
Average distance freight was carried, miles.......................                                                             842
Average cost per ton for freight transportation ...................                                                         $0. 58
Average cost per mile per ton, mills...........                           ....................                                 .69
Average value per ton of freight carried ...............                                      .............                $11. 36
Time American canal was operated, days........................                                                                 231
Time Canadian canal was operated, days...............................                                                          239
Freight carried by-
    Registered vessels, tons ......... .... ......                                  ...........       ......          41, 368, 618
    Unregistered vessels, tons ................................                                                            21, 939
    American vessels, per cent...............                                  ................                                  93
    Canadian vessels, per cent...............................                                                                     7
Passengers carried by-
    American vessels, per cent.............................                                          .....                       39
    Canadian vessels, per cent.................................................                                                  61
Average number of vessels passing, per day, through--
    Poe lock------..................-------..........----------..-----.--..-.....--..----------..........--                      31
    Weitzel lock..........................................................                                                       20
    Canadian lock......------------........................................                                                      22
    Poe, Weitzel, and Canadian locks...............................                                                              76

                                          Freight traffic by calendar years.
                                                                                                        --
                                                      Tons.                                                              Tons.

                                                                                                             I
1881..................................     1,567,741               1895...................................               15,062,580
1882................................ 2,029,521                     1896...................................               16, 239, 061
1883.................................. 2, 267, 105                 1897.................................                 18,982, 755
1884...................................   2, 874,557               1898...................................               21, 234, 664
1885...............................       3,256,628                1899.................................                 25,255,810
1886.................................     4,527,759                1900..................................                25,643,073
1887.................................     5,494,649                1901...................................               28,403, 065
1888.................................     6,411,423                1902...................................               35,961,146
1889....................................  7, 516,022               1903-....................... .......                  34, 674,437
1890...................................   9,041,213                1904...............................                   31,546,106
1891..................................    8,888,759                1905..................---...........                  44,270,  680
1892.................................... 11,214, 333               1906...             ...........................       51, 751,080
1893...................................  10,796,572                1907.....................                       ..... 58,217,214
1894.............. .................     13, 195,860               1908..............................                    41, 390, 557
                                                         I                                                       __
760     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  For effect of channel improvement on freight rates, see remarks
under this head in report of ship channel connecting waters of the
Great Lakes between Chicago, Dutluth, and Buffalo.
  (See Appendix N N 3.)
   4. Hay Lake and Neebish channels, St. Marys River, Michigan.-
The original condition of this waterway included rapids and shoals
characteristic of St. Marys River, and though passable for small craft
having a draft of from 3 to 5 feet, the channel was not navigable in
a commercial sense, and the route of vessels through the St. Marys
River vas by way of Lake George. The water surface, usually vary-
ing slowly, may have a rise or fall of 2 feet during a severe storm,
and the monthly mean elevation of water surface may change as much
as 2 feet in one year, or 4 feet during forty years.
   The original project of 1882 contemplated the excavation of chan-
nels 17 feet deep and 300 feet wide through all obstructed portions
of the Hay Lake route by way of the Middle Neebish, but this project
was modified in 1886 to provide a depth of 20 feet and to widen
at angles and other critical places, at a total estimated cost of
$2,659,115, and the modified project was adopted by river and harbor
act of August 5, 1886. The work of improvement was commenced in
1883, under War Department approval of October 27, 1882, and by
1894 work had so far progressed that the route was opened to com-
merce June 7 of that year, though full width and depth of channel
had not been obtained, and since that time several shoals in the deep-
water section of the lake have been removed and the dredged chan-
nels have been widened at critical places.
   The river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, appropriated $500,000
and authorized work up to $4,000,000 more (all of which has been
appropriated) for improving Middle and West Neebish channels to
provide for the commencement and prosecution of the project out-
lined in the preliminary report of June 4, 1900 (Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1901, page 3200), and the river and harbor
act of March 3, 1905, appropriated $500,000 and authorized work up
to $750,000 more for improving Hay Lake and Neebish channels for
continuing this improvement, of which $40,000 still remains to be
appropriated.
   The part of the project outlined in the above-named reports rela-
tive to the river below the canal, which has been covered by these two
acts, is to provide a channel 1,500 feet wide from the Sault locks to
the upper entrance to Hay Lake; to widen and deepen the upper
entrance channel into Hay Lake so as to give a least width of 600
feet, with clear depth of 21 feet at low water; to excavate a new
channel having least width of 300 feet and low-water depth of 21
feet between Hay Lake and Mud Lake by way of the West Neebish;
and to deepen the Middle Neebish channel to give depth of 21 feet
at low water, leaving its width unchanged. The effect of the exe-
cution of this project will be to provide a clear navigable depth of 21
feet from St. Marys Falls Canal to Lake Huron, the least width being
300 feet where two channels are provided, one for upbound and
one for downbound boats, and 600 feet at all other places.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, on the Hay Lake and
Neebish projects combined was $7,865,066.37.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            761
   More extended information, with maps, may be found in Annual
Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1886, pages 1792-1808 (special
history), and 1895, pages 2866 and 3052.
   During the fiscal year the work on the West Neebish channel was
completed and the work of deepening the Middle Neebish channel
between Mud Lake and Hay Lake was continued, 1,112,851 cubic
yards of earth and rock having been removed.
   The funds on hand amount to $504,001.07, and $40,000 additional
will be needed for work during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
for the prosecution of the authorized improvements.
   For statistics of commerce and effects of channel improvements on
freight rates, attention is invited to remarks on these subjects in
report for operating and care of St. Marys Falls Canal, Michigan,
and ship channel connecting waters of the Great Lakes between
Chicago, Duluth, and Buffalo.
                                     MIDDLE AND WEST          NEEBISH              CHANNELS.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................                       ----            .........----.. $180, 859. 23
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement ..--------------------....--.......--------........-----------------............                 a128, 456. 27
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .-.................................                                            a 52, 402. 96
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..-...............................                                              820. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available-----------........-----------......-----------..........                          51, 582. 96
                                      HAY LAKE     AND NEEBISH                CHANNELS.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..............--------------..........------------....                          $620, 800. 56
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.....                                              395, 000. 00
                                                                                                               1, 015, 800. 56
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
   provement .....................                     ....    .........................                       b 567, 543. 34

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................                              ..................               c448, 625. 44
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ....-........                              ...-...............             91,044. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available ..................................                                               357, 581. 44

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ..............                                             389, 418. 50
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-..._                                     - ..      40, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
     July 1, 1909-----------------.........................................                                        40, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897.
     (See Appendix N N 4.)
  5. Cheboygan Harbor, Michigan.-This harbor is at the mouth of
the Cheboygan River, where there was an available depth of 6 feet in
1870, when the first project for improvement was made. The original
project called for a channel 200 feet wide and 14 feet deep, its sides
  a Of this amount $2,972.67 were expended for light-house work and are chargeable
to appropriation "West Neebish lights, St. Marys River, Michigan," leaving the net
expenditures $125,483.60, and balance unexpended $55,375.63.
   b Actual expenditures during the fiscal year were $567,543.34, which amount in-
cludes $369.65 chargeable to Isthmian Canal Commission for inspecting material;
deducting this latter amount from the total expenditures leaves $567,173.69, net
expenditures.
   c Includes $368.22 refunded by Isthmian Canal Commission.
762      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,          U. S. ARMY.

to be protected by pile revetment and piers, and the estimated cost
of the work was $395,335.
    Operations under this original project were confined solely to
dredging, which was carried to a depth of only 13 feet until 1880,
when the first of a series of projects which had for their object the
obtaining of a 15-foot channel was submitted, and as a result of the
work which was carried on under projects submitted in 1880, 1882,
1887, and 1888 a 15-foot channel was secured from the 15-foot contour
in the Straits of Mackinac to the State Road Bridge, having a width
of 200 feet from the Michigan Central Railroad dock out into the
straits and a width within the river available between piers. A turn-
ing basin, with clear 15 feet depth, was also provided in front of the
steamboat docks.
    There was expended on the original project $90,874.42, and $57,-
055.02 on the modifications begun in 1880.
    Entrance to the channel is marked by a light-house on a crib 40 feet
square, which was built in 1881.
    The present project was adopted in 1895, and provides for dredg-
ing a channel 18 feet deep below the datum plane 581.67 for a width
of 200 feet from the 18-foot contour in the Straits of Mackinac to the
outer end of the west pier and inside of that point between lines
parallel to and 25 feet from the piers to the State Road Bridge.
Operations under this project were begun in 1895, and by 1903 the
projected channel had been completed to within 900 feet of the upper
limit of the harbor, which section still remains to be dredged to
complete the project.
    It is believed that completion of the 18-foot channel for the above 900
feet will serve no useful purpose, as this part of the river is obstructed
by log booms and is not at present available or needed for the general
commerce of the harbor. If it is desired to complete the project, an
appropriation of $14,000 will be necessary.
    The river and harbor act approved March 2, 1907, directed the ex-
tension of the improvement from the State Road Bridge to the lock
in the Cheboygan River by a channel 8 feet deep and 60 feet wide,
the estimated cost of which was $10,797.60.
    Work on this extension was begun in October, 1907, and com-
pleted in August, 1908.
    The amount expended on the work of the existing project up to
the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is $41,378.33, none
of which has been applied to maintenance. It is proposed to expend
the funds on hand in restoring channel depths wherever necessary.
    The total length of the dredged channel from deep water in the
Straits of Mackinac to the State Road Bridge is 7,900 feet, and from
there to the lock is 3,820 feet. The maximum draft that can be car-
ried over the shoalest part of the channel is 17 feet to a point within
  900 feet from the State Road Bridge, 10 feet from that point to the
  bridge, and 8 feet from the bridge to the lock.
     Above the lock the river is navigable through what is known as the
  "Inland Route," through Mullet Lake, Indian River, Burt Lake,
Crooked River and Lake, a distance of 36 miles, for boats having a
  draft of from 4 to 5 feet.
     The commerce of the harbor consists mainly of logs, lumber, and
ties It amounted to 147,621 tons during the year 1908, and was
valued at $698,122. A number of large lake passenger steamers
stop at this port during the summer months.
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  763
   On account of the progressive nature of the improvement, the
effect upon freight rates has been gradual, and the precise effect is
therefore difficult of ascertainment, but there can be no doubt that
during the season of navigation the existence of the deep-water har-
bor at Cheboygan has had a very decided effect on freight rates.
   The Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1896 (pp. 2723, 2724)
summarizes the history of operations to June 30, 1896, and the Report
for 1895 (p. 2824) gives a map of the harbor.
   Reports of examinations and surveys are given in the Reports of the
Chief of Engineers, as follows: 1870, page 44; 1871, pages 183-186;
1880, page 2035; 1895, page 2825; 1897, page 2577; 1900, page 4012;
and reference on page 664, report of 1906.
                               Receipts and shipments by vessel.

      Calendar year.        Received.     Shipped.        Calendar year.              Received.     Shipped.

                                Tons.       Tons.                                 Tons.               Tons.
1893........... ............    155,898    285,189   1901...... ................ 161,771              252,727
1894................ .......... 76,554     227.346   1902.......................  177,231             262,553
1895 ........................   110,062    216,868   1903.......................   33,723             259,224
1896......................... . 163,362    362,011   1904........................24,815                   461
                                                                                                       106,
1897.......................     147,255    293,161   1905...... ............      419,171              114,188
1898......................      366,332    334,636   1906........................ 318,442              141,086
1899 ......................     152,689    352,214   1907.......................  444,557                 211
                                                                                                       149,
1900 .......................     44,237     59,536   1908........................  62,054               85,567



July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...........................       ...... $13, 478. 43
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ...........................................................          4, 286. 20
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................                ...............               9, 192. 23
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                          14, 000. 00
   (See Appendix N N 5.)
   6. Alpena Harbor (Thunder Bay River), Michigan.-The original
depth of water over the bar at the mouth of the Thunder Bay River
was only 7 feet. Local enterprise had secured a narrow channel 12
feet deep through the bar before work was undertaken by the Gov-
ernment in 1877, when, under the original project for the improve-
ment of this harbor, act of August 14, 1876, a channel 13 feet deep
and 200 feet wide was secured at a cost of $4,390.48. Shoaling hav-
ing occurred, in 1882 $15,000 was appropriated for redredging the
channel, and the project was modified so as to provide for an avail-
able depth of 14 feet.. The work was completed the following year
at a cost of $10,500, and $3,998.22 was expended in 1889 in redredg-
ing to 14 feet across the bar and 13 feet upstream. The amount ex-
pended on this project was $14,498.22.
   In 1890 the present project was adopted so as to provide for a
channel depth of 16 feet below the datum plane 581.5 and the exten-
sion of the improvement up the river about a mile to the vicinity of
the dam across the river at that point, with widths varying as follows:
200 feet at the 16-foot contour in Thunder Bay, thence tapering to
100 feet at the light-house crib, thence 100 feet to the Second Street
Drawbridge, thence 75 feet to the Minor Lumber Company's wharf,
thence 50 feet to the upstream limit of the channel improvement, the
estimated cost being $36,087.48. This project was completed in
 764                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

1893. The channel was redredged in 1899, and again in the summer
of 1907, a 16-foot depth being provided with a width of 140 feet
opposite the light-house, tapering to 100 feet at Second Street Bridge,
and to 60 feet for a farther distance of 2,100 feet.
   The amount expended on the work of the existing project to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is $36,215.86, of which
amount $14,915.39 has been applied to maintenance.
   The total length of dredged channel is 6,550 feet, a channel 2,250
feet long and 100 to 200 feet wide having been secured in Thunder
Bay, and 4,300 feet long in the river, with widths varying from 100
feet at the light-house crib to 50 feet at the upstream limit of the
improved channel. The maximum draft that can be carried over the
shoalest part of the channel June 30, 1909, is 13.5 feet. The river is
navigable to the upper limit of the improvement only, farther navi-
gation being interrupted by the dam across the river at that point.
   The piers at Alpena have been constructed of slabs and have here-
tofore been held in position by heavy piles of lumber. The timber
of this section of the country is rapidly being cut away and the lumber
stored is diminishing. As the lumber piles are removed it will be
necessary to add sufficient riprap to the outer ends of the slab piers
to prevent their destruction by wave action in Thunder Bay. The
removal of the lumber is, however, believed to be gradual, and the
appropriation recommended is for the purpose of maintaining the
piers and any dredging that may be necessary.
   The commerce of the harbor consists mainly of lumber, stone,
cement, coal, cedar posts and ties, hay and feed, and general mer-
chandise, and amounted to a total of 269,798 tons during the year
1908, valued approximately at $1,913,762.
   The effect of the improvement upon freight rates has been very
beneficial, as it is estimated that freight and passenger rates have
decreased almost one-half since the improvements were made.
  A detailed report of operations to that date will be found in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1891, pages 2765-2770,
and a map showing the locality in the Annual Report for 1889, page
2290.
   Reports of examinations and surveys are found in the following
Reports of the Chief of Engineers: 1871, pages 158-159, and for 1876,
page 106.
                                                    Receipts and shipments by vessel.

           Calendar year.                      Received.      Shipped.        Calenar year.         Received.    Shipped.


                                                    Tons.      Tons.                                  Tons.       Tons.
1893................ ...                             51,600    308,988 1901..
                                                               308,988                             62,131
                                                                       101......................51,600            169,442
1894.......... ..............                       102.700    363,291   1902........................ 60,213      193,201
1895.....           ..... ...........                35,957    269,203   1903........................   69,721     153,222
1896.........................                        94,067    255,687   190'.......................    51,722    150,381
1897.......................... .                     78,378    293,161   1905........................   73,331    200,785
1898 ............             ............           60,300    236,075   1906.........................  78,241    171,185
1899..............                   ...... .....    27,888    197,725   1907......................... 419,403    166,116
1900 .......................                         51,653    263,702   1908........ ................  42,035    227,763
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      765
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ........................................                                     $410. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
                                                                                    ........---- -----.......... 14. 56
  provement.........------..---..-....----- .......------------.............---------------
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................                       .........       ...........          395. 44
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909............................---------------------------------..--------............... 5,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix N N 6.)
   7. Saginaw River, Michigan.-The Saginaw River has a length of
about 22 miles, and is formed by the confluence of the Tittabawassee
and Shiawassee rivers. Prior to improvement the entrance to the
river was obstructed by a bar in Saginaw Bay, having a minimum
depth of about 9 feet. Between the mouth and Bay City the depth
varied from 15 to 30 feet. Thence to the head of the river the channel
was obstructed by a number of bars, having 7 feet of water.
   The original project for the improvement of this river was made
in 1866, and contemplated a straight channel 195 feet wide and 12
feet deep across the bar at the mouth. This was completed in 1869.
In 1874 the project was extended to include the improvement of the
river above Bay City. It included dredging a 10-foot channel across
the bars at East Saginaw and Carrollton, and the construction of a
pile revetment at the latter place. Later, similar improvements at
Zilwaukee bar, New York Works bar, and Willow Island were added.
The cost of the work under this project was $219,000.
   In 1882 the existing project was adopted, which provides for a
channel 200 feet wide and 14 feet deep from Saginaw Bay to and
along the front of Bay City, and thence a channel of same width, 12
feet deep, to the upper limits of the city of Saginaw, the datum plane
being 581.1; estimated cost, $546,000. By the river and harbor act
of August 5, 1886, the improvement of the west channel along West
Bay City was also added to the project.
   The work which was done during the succeeding years resulted in
securing a channel of the required depth, but of varying widths. On
account of the unstable condition of the channel, it was impossible
to complete the project as approved, it being necessary to devote
periodically a portion of the funds to restoring the depth through
bars in the river, which were formed by the spring freshets, thus
leaving insufficient funds to complete the improvement. During
1907 a complete survey of the river was made and plans were formu-
lated to complete the project as far as possible with the funds avail-
able. Work was begun in May, 1908, under two contracts, and work
under the last contract was still in progress at the close of the fiscal
year. A channel 14 feet deep and 200 feet wide was secured from the
mouth of the river to Portsmouth bridge in Bay City, and 12 feet
deep and 200 feet wide from that point to Michigan Central Railroad
bridge in Saginaw; thence to Center Street Bridge being made 150
feet wide and 12 feet deep. The portion from the Michigan Central
Railroad bridge to the head of the river has not as yet been com-
pleted to the project depth and width. A survey of the bar in the bay
was made during the month of May, 1909, and it was found that the
dredged channel had filled in considerably at the sides and that
766           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

dredging was necessary to restore the channel called for by the pro-
ject.  It is proposed to do the work by contract at an early date.
   The amount expended on the existing project to June 30, 1909, is
$703,156.52. In the past no attempt has been made to separate the
cost of maintenance from that of original improvement, so that it is
impossible now to separate these items.
   The available balance and the additional funds requested will be
expended for maintenance of the improved channel and the necessary
inspection and engineering.
   Saginaw River is navigable for a distance of 22 miles from the
mouth.
   The volume of commerce benefited by the improvement has been
decreasing, due to the decrease in the lumber trade in the Saginaw
Valley. The value of the commerce carried in 1908 is approximately
$3,735,203, and it consisted mainly of lumber, coal, stone, cement, and
salt.
   The precise effect of the improvement upon freight rates can not
be stated. It is undoubted, however, that freight rates, both to Bay
City and Saginaw, have been materially lowered by the existence of
the improved channel.
   More extended information can be found in the Annual Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for 1883, pages 1858-1868; 1885, pages 2138-
2150 (with maps) ;1890, pages 2724-2729, and 1892, pages 2454-2464.
   Reports of examinations and surveys are given in the Reports of
the Chief of Engineers, as follows: 1866, page 59; 1867, page 146;
1872, page 207; 1874, pages 206-209; 1875, page 289; 1878, page 1234;
1882, page 2332; 1893, page 2928; 1894, page 2244; 1895, page 2829;
1898, pages 2579, 2600, and 2604.
                                    Receipts and shipments by vessel.

      Calendar year.           Received.     Shipped.            Calendar year.             Received.     Shipped.


                                  Tons.         Tons.                                         Tons.         Tons.
1893........... .......... 651,163 1,069,298 1901......................       1,250,292                      694,741
1894 ..........    ...............        1,108,307 1902..................... 1,012,620                      106,409
                  ......
1895...............               391,751   347,146 1903....................   359,779                        17,999
1896...................... 471,106         240,496 1904.. ................. 264,066                           13,010
1897..................... 995,960           354,860 1905....................   227,226                        14,161
1898.......................    1,126,891   364,561 1906...................     274,245                        18,860
1899..........................    728,629  311,547 1907....................    254,897                        20,675
1900...........................   482,253  402,827  1908....................   243,491                        21,157


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...........                  ..... .. .......... .. $101, 715. 04
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..............................................                          25, 000. 00
                                                                                                        126, 715. 04
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..      ..............................                $54, 079. 82
    For maintenance of improvement. ..................                            a 27, 039. 90
                                                                                                        a81, 119.72

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                     45, 595. 32
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities................                         ...........                11, 340. 08

July 1, 1909, balance available....................................                                      34, 255. 24


a Includes $1.63 expended by Treasury Department, account of Pere Marquette
Railroad Company.
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              767

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............         $761. 60
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .........   25, 209. 00
[Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909...........      ............... ..   25, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix N N 7.)
   8. Sebewaing River, Michigan.-The original channel from Sagi-
naw Bay to the mouth of the Sebewaing River had an available depth
of scant 4 feet. The first improvement was made in 1875, under the
original project of that year, when a narrow channel 6 feet deep was
dredged from the 6-foot curve in Saginaw Bay to the mouth of the
river, and some dredging was also done within the river itself, by
which it was straightened and deepened to 6 feet, at a cost of $8,000.
   The project was modified in 1880, and $7,000 appropriated for
deepening the channel to 7 feet, the work being done in 1880-81.
   The existing project, adopted in 1896, provides for dredging the
entrance channel to a width of 100 feet and depth of 8 feet below the
datum plane of the survey of 1895, the length of dredged channel to
be about 15,000 feet; estimated cost $37,000; but no work was done
until the appropriation of March 3, 1899, became available. Con-
tract was made in 1899 to do the work, which was finished, as far as
available funds permitted, September 9, 1903, and resulted in secur-
ing a channel of the required length and depth, but with widths vary-
ing from 70 to 90 feet throughout the distance covered. The amount
expended on this improvement was $35,573.45.
   The work which was in progress at the beginning of the fiscal year
was continued until August 29, 1908, and resulted in providing a
channel about 75 feet wide with a minimum depth of 7 to 8 feet.
   The amount expended on the work of existing project to the close
of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is $43,992.67, of which amount
$8,419.22 has been applied to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water, over the shoalest part of the locality, is 6.5 feet. The
river is navigable to the docks at Sebewaing.
    The commerce affected by the improvement amounted in 1908 to
1,325 tons, and consisted mainly of lumber, gravel, fish, and coal.
The effect of the project upon freight rates can not be definitely stated,
but is considered insignificant.
    For reasons stated in his report the district officer does not con-
sider this stream worthy of further improvement.
    A map of the locality is given in the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1903, at page 1988.
    Reports of examinations and surveys are given in the following
Reports of the Chief of Engineers: 1873, pages 306, 307; 1875, page
290; 1879, page 170; 1880, page 2044; 1891, page 2804; 1893, page
2951; and 1895, page 2743.
768                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                       S. ARMY.

                                     Receipts and shipments by vessel.

            Calendar year.          Received.   Shipped.        Calendar year.         Received.   Shipped.


                                      Tons.      Tons.                                  Tons.       Tons.
1905 ......................             4,700     4,350    1907........................ 3,827           412
1906 ........................   .       5,740     4,075    1908........................   1,014         311


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.                          .........
                                                  ...-........         ......       ........ $2, 709. 99
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ..........     ...... ................                 ..............           2, 702. 66

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...........................                      ........             7. 33
      (See Appendix N N 8.)
   9. Harbor of refuge at Harbor Beach, Lake Huron, Michigan.-The
site for this harbor, selected in 1872 by a Board of Engineer officers,
is on the west shore of Lake Huron, 60 miles north of its outlet into
the St. Clair River, and the artificial harbor built there since then is
the only safe refuge on that coast from the foot of the lake to Tawas
Bay, 115 miles above.
   The work of construction was commenced in 1873 under a project
providing for three separate piers, or breakwaters, of cribwork filled
with stone, so located as to shelter a water area of some 650 acres on
the north, northwest, and west sides, and for deepening this area by
dredging where necessary. The estimated cost of the breakwaters
was $1,452,550, and they were completed in 1885 at a cost of
$970,716.40, including maintenance to that date.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, provided for commenc-
ing the work of rebuilding the superstructure of the main pier in con-
crete, and authorized the work to be inaugurated under the continu-
ing-contract system to the extent of $200,000. It was not, however,
until 1903 that a definite project for doing the work was decided
upon, and the first contract was let in August of that year. The
work was begun in June, 1904.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, directed an examination
to be made of the harbor, with a view to ascertaining what other
further improvements were necessary, if any, in order to make such
harbor of refuge suitable for the present demands of commerce. The
report, which was submitted to Congress June 16, 1906, and printed
as House Document No. 900, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session,
recommended the continuation of the rebuilding of the superstructure
of the main pier as begun, the rebuilding of the superstructure of the
north and south piers in concrete, the protection of the main pier
from wave shock by riprap, the closing of the north entrance to pre-
vent the entrance of littoral deposit, and the dredging and deepening
of the harbor to 21 feet and of the main entrance to 23 feet. The
estimate for the work recommended was $970,000, with an added sum
of $10,000 per year for maintenance and harbor police. By the river
and harbor act of March 2, 1907, $150,000 was appropriated for con-
tinuing this work.
    Under this plan for the repair and improvement of the harbor,
work on the main pier is been carried on continuously, and was
completed in September, 1908.
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           769
   The total amount expended to the close of the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1909, is $1,899,347.89, of which about $975,000 was applied
to the first cost of the sheltering breakwaters, which were completed
in 1885. Since that time there has been applied to maintenance
$924,347.89, which includes the construction of concrete super-
structure on main pier, the keeping of the wooden piers in repair,
dredging within the harbor, control and berthing of vessels entering
the harbor for shelter, and engineering supervision and general office
expenses.
   The available balance will be applied to covering the cost of the
necessary supervision of the harbor during the ensuing fiscal year;
also to such repairs to the timber structures as may become necessary.
   As a result of the expenditures made upon this harbor, there has
been created an artificial harbor of refuge, which has been used for
shelter during the past year by 697 vessels, with a total tonnage of
610,886 tons. The grand total of vessels that have found shelter
from 1877 to 1908, inclusive, is -37,464, the tonnage of which aggre-
gated 16,583,758. The vessels sheltered in 1877 averaged 289 tons
each, and those during the year 1908, 885 tons. The maximum draft
that can be carried into the harbor through the main entrance, mak-
ing allowance for the effect of moderate seas, is between 19 and 20
feet, and vessels having this draft may safely lie inside the main pier.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to continuing
reconstruction of the piers.
   More extended information can be found in the Annual Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for the following years: 1873, pages 292-298;
1877, pages 925-932 (with map); 1879, pages 1645-1648 (with map);
1881, pages 2270-2275; 1882, pages 2369-2372; 1885, pages 2151-
2157; 1886, pages 1829-1836.
   Reports of examinations and surveys are given in the following
Reports of the Chief of Engineers: 1870, page 46; 1871, page 44;
1872, pages 209, 211, and 218; 1895, page 2832; 1896, page 2730;
1897, page 3016; and reference on page 664, report of 1906.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............ ...................     $121, 616. 88
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...................    ..............................
                                   .....                               10, 000. 00
                                                                      131, 616. 88
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ................................................ 104,597. 56

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................---------------------------------   27, 019. 32
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities- .-..........       ..................                10, 689. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available. ................
                                                .........                ..    .......      16, 330. 32
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909..-.............................       275, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix N N 9.)
  10. Mouth of Blaclk River, Rouge River, and Monroe Harbor, Michi-
gan.-(a) Mouth of Black River.-An extensive bar and shoal exists
in the St. Clair River adjoining the mouth of the Black. The bar
        9001-ENG 1909-49
770        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                      U.   S. ARMY.


lies close to the American side and formerly obstructed the approach
to the Port Huron docks, while the shoal, forming a "middle ground"
nearly 50 acres in extent, crowded the main channel in a sharp curve
close to the Canadian shore.
   The original project submitted in 1871 contemplated the removal
of this bar and the middle ground to a depth of 15 feet, at an esti-
mated cost of $67,320. The work was begun in 1872 and completed
in 1878 at a cost of $56,500.
   The present project contemplates dredging to a uniform depth of
16 feet along the dock front of Port Huron from the 16-foot curve
above to the same curve below the mouth of the river, the plane of
reference being 579.6. Work was begun in May, 1889, and finished
in 1892, when authority was received to deepen the outer border of
the shoal adjacent to the main channel to 18 feet, and the work was
done. The amount expended on this work was $29,348.58. Opera-
tions since this time have been confined to maintenance, $12,008.31
having been expended for this purpose since the adoption of the
present project to June 30, 1909. The last dredging was done in
1907, when the 16-foot depth was restored.
   The available balance will be applied to dredging such portion of
the bar as may prove to be obstructive to navigation.
   As a result of the work heretofore done, through navigation for
vessels of moderate draft has been greatly facilitated, and entrance
into the Black River proper has been rendered possible for this class
of vessels. This, it is believed, has resulted in a reduction of freight
rates, the extent of which could not be ascertained.
   Reports of examinations and surveys are given in the following
reports of the Chief of Engineers: 1871, pages 177-180; 1887, page
2279; 1899, page 2992; 1900, page 3986.
   For receipts by vessel see "Black River at Port Huron," page 774.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............................................   $2, 643. 11
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................              2,643. 11
   (b) Rouge River.-This stream originally had a channel depth of
from 10 to 17 feet from its mouth to where the Wabash Railroad
Bridge crosses it,a distance of about 3 miles.
   Under the provisions of the river and harbor act of August 5, 1886,
a survey of the river was made and a project, dated August 25, 1888,
prepared for securing a channel depth of 16 feet with a width of 240
feet for a distance of 800 feet from the mouth, and thence with a
width of 100 feet to the Wabash Railroad Bridge, the plane of refer-
ence being 575. The estimated cost was $31,690.39. The work of
improvement was commenced in 1888 and completed in November,
1892, at a cost of $30,272.79.
   By joint resolution approved April 11, 1898, Congress authorized
an extension of the improvement, with depth of 13 feet, up to the
Maples road, a distance of about 1 miles above the Wabash Railroad
Bridge, limiting the expenditure to $5,000. The river was dredged
in 1900, the channel being made 50 feet wide.
   The project for this river was modified by act of March 2, 1907, so
as to provide an increase in depth from 16 feet to 21 feet between the
mouth of the river and the first bridge, a distance of about 1,400 feet;
estimated cost, 83,575.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    771

   During the season of 1907 the channel was deepened, in accordance
with the amended project, to 21 feet, from the mouth to the Solvay
Company's tunnel just below the Detroit connecting railroad bridge.
   In addition to this work, the channel depth of 16 feet was restored
to a point 11,550 feet above the mouth.
   Between May 3 and June 30, 1909, dredging was done under con-
tract and a narrow channel was dredged from the mouth of the river
to the Detroit United Railway dock.
   The funds recently appropriated for maintenance have only been
sufficient to open up a narrow channel. An estimate to fully restore
the channel depths and widths of the original project is submitted in
the report of the district officer. The appropriation recommended,
while considered sufficient for existing commerce, will only partially
accomplish this result.
   The amount expended on the work of the existing project, as
amended, to the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is
$72,640.68, of which $22,558.19 has been applied to maintenance.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, from the
mouth to the Solvay tunnel is 21 feet, from there to the Wabash
Railroad bridge 14 feet, from there to the Detroit, Monroe and
Toledo Railroad bridge 13 feet, and 10 feet to Maples road. The river
is navigable for vessels of light draft to the town of Dearborn, 15
miles above the mouth.
   The amount requested will be devoted to maintenance of the
channel.
   The receipts and shipments by vessel during the year 1908 amounted
to 277,746 tons, of which 118,825 tons were iron ore, 64,677 tons
lumber, and 30,080 tons pulp wood. The value of this commerce is
about $1,505,271.
   As a result of the improvement the area available for manufactur-
ing plants in the vicinity of Detroit has been greatly extended, and
these plants have been enabled to receive the raw materials which
they use without transfer or transshipment. As a consequence the
cost of the raw materials has been greatly reduced.
   The channel banks of this river are low and ill defined, and as not
only the banks, but also the bed, are composed of soft material
deterioration of the dredged channel is very rapid. While therefore
the growing importance of the industries which rely upon the use of
this channel renders it desirable that funds for periodical dredging
be provided, it also becomes necessary to demand that the owners
of the riparian property, whose value is greatly enhanced by the
improvement, shall be called upon to construct proper sand-tight
docks. Without such provision recent experience shows that the
channel is no sooner dredged than it at once begins to fill up from the
material sucked into the channel by the propellers of passing vessels.
While therefore the extent of the commerce demands additional
depth in the lower portion of the channel, future appropriations should
be coupled with the condition that no expenditure be made by the
United States until the channel banks within the limits of the improve-
ment have been properly docked.
   The effect of the improvement has been to reduce freight rates 30
to 50 per cent for firms actually using dockage on the river.
    Reference to report on examination ordered by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1905, will be found on page 664 of 1906
 772                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                              U. S.          ARMY.


report. More extended information may be found in Annual
Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1890 (pp. 2747-2749); 1899 (p.
3013); 1901 (p. 3155). Reports on examinations and surveys, report
for 1887 (p. 2275); 1898 (p. 2605).
                                      Receipts and shipments, by vessel, Rouge River.

            Calendar year.                     Received.    Shipped.             Calendar year.                    Received.     Shipped.


                                                 Tons.         Tons.
1893.......................                      73,732 ..........       1901........................               105,533           782
.1894........................                     47,106 ..........       1902.........................               56,701        10,000
1895.................... .....                  113,066        1,024     1903.................         ........     125,272        10,000
1896.........................                   120,590        2,905     1904. ......................               242,361         6,898
1897........................                    115,987        9,386     1905.........................              284,140 ..
1898........................                    117,486      10,259      1906 ........................              229,861         5,000
1899.........................                    92,631            763   1907........................               248,544         5,000
1900 ........            ..................     119,712        4.600     1908........................               267,746        10,000


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ...............                ...... .............   $529. 04
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
   March 3, 1909...........................        ......................              10, 000. 00
                                                                                                                               10, 529. 04
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
   improvement.................................................                                                                 6, 479. 72

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..................                                               .... ...............          4, 049. 32
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................                                                       2, 642. 32

July 1, 1909, balance available...................................                                                             1,407.00

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .................                                                          746. 79

   Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
     1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
    pended July 1, 1909.............................................(a)
   Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
    4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (c) Monroe Harbor.-The harbor of Monroe, Mich., is within the
mouth of the Raisin River at the western extremity of Lake Erie. In
its natural condition the river flowed into the lake through several
ponds and winding creeks. The depth of water at the deepest mouth
of the river in its natural condition did not exceed 5 feet.
    The original project for the improvement of Monroe Harbor was
adopted in 1834. It had for its object to dredge a new and direct
channel 100 feet wide and 10 feet deep from the lake across the marsh,
a distance of 4,000 feet, to the portion of the river ordinarily used as
a harbor, the protection of the entrance into the lake by parallel piers,
726 feet long and 20 feet wide, extending outward to a depth of 10
feet in the lake, and the protection of the sides of the canal by a
revetment. The estimated cost of the work, exclusive of dredging
machine, was $55,885. The work was practically completed in 1845,
a depth of 9 feet being obtained to a point just below the docks at
Monroe. Subsequently the city of Monroe further improved the
river channel by cutting a canal about 1,300 feet long, 100 feet wide,
and with a depth of from 13 to 16 feet, across a bend of the river.
                                  a See consolidated money statement on page 774.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                           773
Subsequent operations consisted in repairing and extending the piers,
repairing the canal revetment, and in dredging, by which a channel
200 feet wide and 13 feet deep, extending to deep water in the lake,
was obtained.
   In 1905 a double line of piling was driven connecting the south pier
to the shore, to prevent the lake from breaking through into the canal,
and some work was done in replacing rotten deck timbers.
   During the summer of 1908 general repairs were made to the piers,
placing them in fair condition.
   The total amount expended on this work up to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is $260,889.64, of which $110,000
was applied under the original project. It is impossible to separate
the portion of this total which has been applied to maintenance.
During recent years practically all expenditures have been made for
that purpose.
   The amount requested will be devoted to maintenance.
   The channel, beginning at the outer end, consists of the United
States canal, 4,000 feet long, with an available depth of about 11 feet.
Three thousand feet farther up the river the Monroe City ship canal
begins. This has a length of 1,600 feet and a depth of 10 feet. From
the upper end of this canal to the city wharves is 2,600 feet, with a
depth of 8.5 feet. The stream is navigable from the lake to the docks
at Monroe only, a distance of 2 miles.
   This harbor can not accommodate the larger class of vessels used
upon the lakes, and its commerce is not large, amounting in the year
1908 to 9,150 tons, valued at $75,000. Of this amount 8,000 tons
were sand, the major portion of the balance consisting of fish.
   The commerce of this stream is too small to have any effect what-
ever upon freight rates.
   The Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1880, pages 2083
to 2091, gives a detailed history of the operations up to that time.
   Reports of examinations and surveys are given in the following
Reports of the Chief of Engineers: 1866, page 29; 1868, page 145;
1872, pages 237-239; 1889, page 2338; 1893, page 3048; 1898, page
2689, and 1900, page 4020.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................................              $6,176.08
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement ... .............        ........ .......................... ..... 6,050. 45

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................................         125. 63

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 ...-                                                     (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                       a See consolidated money statement on page 774.
774        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                    U.   S. ARMY.

                                      CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................... $9, 348. 23
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909....................................................... 10, 000. 00
                                                                             19, 348. 23
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement ...........   ..... ...... ........ ...... ...... ...... ....... 12, 530. 17

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........        .......................         6, 818. 06
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..........................................   2, 642. 32

July 1, 1909, balance available..........................................         4, 175. 74

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .................             746. 79
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...............................................      21, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix N N 10.)
    11. Black River at Port Huron, Michigan.-In 1888, when the
original survey was made, the lower reach of the Black River, from
its mouth to the Grand Trunk Railroad bridge, 12 miles in length,
varied in width from 120 to 150 feet and had a depth of from 10 to
14 feet, except at a few points, where it was obstructed by bars hav-
ing only 81 feet of water over them. The improvement of this
stream was inaugurated by the river and harbor act of September
19, 1890, under a project which contemplated dredging to a navi-
gable depth of 16 feet from the mouth to the Grand Trunk Railroad
bridge, with widths varying from 75 feet to 160 feet, at an esti-
mated cost of $75,000. Operations were commenced in 1891 and the
dredging was completed June 30, 1894, at a cost of $34,698.65, includ-
ing an extension upstream of 1,800 feet to Washington avenue, au-
thorized by the act of July 13, 1892. The total length of the dredged
channel is 9,700 feet.
   Since the completion of the project considerable dredging has been
required to maintain the channel, particularly above the Grand
Trunk Railroad bridge, where experience and observation show that
the narrow dredged channel has no degree of permanence, the last
dredging being done in the spring of 1909, when the project depths
were restored from the mouth to Washington avenue.
   The amount expended for maintenance to June 30, 1909, has been
$20,584.91, making total expenditure since adoption of project
$55,282.91.
   As a result of the work done in this river a channel has been se-
cured 16 feet in depth, with widths varying from 75 feet to 160
feet, extending from the mouth to the Washington Avenue Bridge,
a total length of 9,700 feet. The maximum draft that can be car-
ried June 30, 1909, is 15 feet. The river is navigable a consider-
able distance above Port Huron.
   The amount requested will be applied to work of dredging to main-
tain the improved channel.
   There was received during the year 1908, 129,240 tons of freight,
valued approximately at $223,407. This consisted mainly of coal,
gravel, lumber, and pulp wood.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  775

   The effect of the improvement has been to reduce freight rates
upon approximately the number of tons received. It is doubtful
whether this improvement has any indirect effect upon railroad rates.
   More extended information will be found in the following Reports
of the Chief of Engineers: 1893, pages 2938-2939; 1894, pages 2251-
2252; 1898, pages 2586-2587.
   Report of examination and survey is given in the Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1889, page 2292; reports of minor surveys,
page 2993 of report for 1899, and page 3988 of report for 1900.
                                      Receipts and shipments by vessel.

        Calendar year.             Received.        Shipped.              Calendar year.     Received.    Shipped.

                                      Tons.          Tons.                                      Tons.       Tons.
1893........................              175,081      7,487    1901......................    120,018            100
1894..........................            116,535      4,413    1902.....................     123,677          2,600
1895..................................... 104,850      6,825    1903............... ......... 163,265 ..
1896........................              186,987      2,569    1904..........................197,044 ........
1897..................             ... ..  96,925      1,455    1905......................... 169,200 ..
1898...........................           151,606     16,595    1906........................135,695 .........
1899.........................             130,675     37,368    1907.......................168,152..
1900.........................             105,931         181   1908........................  129,240.........


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............................................                            $627. 94
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......................................................                                   4,000. 00
                                                                                                         4, 627.94
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ......................................... . . ..............                               2, 910. 85
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...                            .........................                1, 717. 09
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 .....................................       ...... 10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix N N 11.)
   12. Operating and care of St. Clair Flats Canal, Michigan.-This
canal consists of two dredged cuts through the St. Clair flats at the
mouth of the St. Clair River. These cuts have a width of about
300 feet each, and depth of 20 feet, and extend into Lake St. Clair
a distance of 17,460 feet. They are separated by a sand dike 100
feet wide, revetted by sheet piling for a distance of 7,221 feet, and
the east cut is protected from wave wash and sand drift by a similar
dike 50 feet wide.
   An historical sketch of the improvement is given on page 2882 of
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, and a descrip-
tion of recent work is given on page 694 of the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1907.
   The care and maintenance of the canal is provided for by the
permanent indefinite appropriation for operating and care of canals
and other works of navigation under the provisions of section 4 of
the river and harbor act of July 5, 1884, as amended and reenacted
by section 6 of the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
   Operations for the past fiscal year were of the same routine char-
acter as those carried on since the opening of the canal to commerce.
776               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                           S. ARMY.

A custodian has been present during the year to enforce canal regu-
lations and care for and repair the dikes.
    The expenditure to June 30, 1909, was $180,341.97,                                                                           excluding
$357 estimated outstanding liabilities.                                                The amount expended during
the year is $11,340.21.
  Freight traffic by calendar years:
                                                                                                                                 Freight tons.
1902...........-------------------------------.....------..................---..................-------------.........           41, 773, 998
1903.........---------------------....-----...........-------.......---................-----------------......----.....          41, 888, 134
1904..........-------.........................................--------------------------------------------.......------.......   38,044,929
1905---....---...------.......................---------------..---------------.................--..------------...........       51, 359,071
1906.............-------...-----------......-----.........----------.........------..........-----------........------.....      60, 589, 441
1907......-------------...................----------.......-----..............-------------.......-------------...--.            66, 271, 962
1908--.....--..------------------.......--------........-------.......---------.........--------........---.....                 50, 586, 560
  For detailed information of commerce, see statistics appended to
report of district officer for improving Detroit River, Michigan
(Appendix N N 14). For effect of improvement on freight rates, see
remarks in report on ship channel between Chicago, Duluth, and
Buffalo (p. 753, supra).
   (See Appendix N N 12.)
   13. Clinton River, Michigan. This stream empties into Anchor
Bay, in the northwesterly part of Lake St. Clair, and before improve-
ment had a channel depth of about 10 feet, except at several shoals,
over which but 5 or 6 feet could be carried, and a broad flat at the
mouth with a general depth of 3 to 4 feet.
   The first appropriation for the improvement of this river was
made August 30, 1852, and from that time to 1886 occasional appro-
priations, amounting in all to $25,500, were made and expended on
various dredging projects.
   In 1889 a project for the general improvement of the river was
adopted, to cover the entire river from the mouth to Mount Clemens,
8 miles upstream. This project called for an 8-foot channel, a pile
dike extending across the flat at the mouth to the 10-foot curve in
the bay, for revetments as needed above, and for closing the main
channel and making a straight cut through Shoemakers bend. The
estimated cost was $25,000, revised and amended in 1888 and 1889 to
$34,564. The project was completed in 1893 with the expenditure
of $34,546.26.
   Since the completion of the project there has been $20,125.21
expended for maintenance, making the total expenditure since
adoption of present project to June 30, 1909, $54,671.47.
   In 1908, an 8-foot depth was dredged between Market and Macomb
Street bridges. Periodical dredging is required for maintenance,
and the appropriation recommended will be so applied.
   As a result of the work done on this river, a channel 8 feet in depth
has been secured from the mouth to the city of Mount Clemens, a pile
dike has been built along the north side of the outer channel, and
revetments have been built where needed in the river above. TI e
present available depth throughout does not exceed 7 feet. Tl e
river is navigable for small boats a considerable distance above
Mount Clemens. The effect of the improvement on freight rates can
not be determined.
                                     RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                               777
   There were received and shipped during the year 1908, 27,567 tons
of freight, consisting mainly of coal, logs, lumber, and sand. This is
valued approximately at $150,000.
  More extended information is given in the following Reports of
the Chief of Engineers: 1893, pages 2942-2944, and 1894, pages
2254-2255.
   Reports of examinations and surveys are given in the Reports of
the Chief of Engineers as follows: 1872, page 214; 1876, Part 2,
page 549; 1880, page 2062; 1885, page 332; 1895, page 2838; 1899,
page 3001, and 1900, page 3996.
                                                  Receipts and shipments by vessel.

          Calendar year.                      Received.       Shipped.                 Calendar year.             Received.   Shipped.

                                                   Tons.           Tons.                                            Tons.       Tons.
1896.......................                         30,749                410   1903.......................          28,411 .........
1897.......................                         29,077   .........          1904.......................          22,878             257
1898. .. . .......          .........     .         29,085   ..........         1905........................         41,759             540
1899................ .......                        35,525   ..........         1906........................         25,616             284
1900..... ..................                        32,410                282   1907.......................          23,273           1,033
1901 ................              ........   .     36,925   ..........         1908....................     ..      27,395             172
1902.......................                         33,868    ..


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ...................................                                                         $835. 28
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement         ..................................................                                                        442.75

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                                            392. 53
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..........................................           10, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix N N 13.)
   14. Detroit River, Michigan.-Before improvement the shoalest
part of the channel through Detroit River was at Limekiln Cross-
ing, where the normal depth was from 12z to 15 feet over a bottom of
solid rock.
   The water surface, usually changing slowly, may rise or fall from
a few inches during many days of calm weather to about 4 feet during
severe storms and to about 6 feet during short, severe hurricanes, and
the monthly mean may change as much as 2 feet in one year, or 4 feet
in forty years.
   The first project of 1874 provided for a winding channel of at least
20 feet in depth, over 300 feet in width; modified in 1883 so as to
somewhat straighten such channel; in 1886 to give 400 feet width; and
in 1888 to give 440 feet in width. The general depth above and below
the Limekiln was 20 feet or more, but the bed of the river was studded
with large bowlders and rocky shoals, which limited the safe naviga-
ble depth to scant 15 feet through a distance of about 12 miles. Ac-
cordingly the project was modified and extended in 1892 so as to pro-
vide for the removal of all obstructive shoals between the city of
Detroit and Lake Erie, with a view to obtaining a through channel
with a least width of 600 feet and a navigable depth of 20 feet, at a
778     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U. S. ARMY.

total estimated cost of $1,554,500, as adopted by river and harbor acts
of July 13, 1892, and March 3, 1899, and as approved by the War
Department at various dates from 1892 up to July 3, 1899. There
has been expended on previous projects and modifications thereof
$1,554,500.
    The present project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
June 13, 1902, which provides for a channel 600 feet wide and 21 feet
deep from Detroit to Lake Erie. The estimate for the work was in-
creased (see the final report of the survey directed by the act of March
3, 1899, in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, pp.
2292-2296) to $3,750,000, and in accordance with this increase the
river and harbor acts of March 3, 1905, and March 2, 1907, authorized
the continuation of the improvement to the extent of $700,000 in addi-
tion to the $1,750,000 originally authorized. All of this money has
been appropriated, but there still remains to be provided for the work
$1,300,000. On November 12, 1904, this project was modified to per-
mit of slightly shifting the location of the proposed channel at Bar
Point shoals, mouth of Detroit River, without increasing the cost.
    The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, modified the present
project so as to provide for two channels-one for downbound, the
other for upbound vessels, past Bois Blanc Island. The second chan-
nel, called the Livingstone channel (plan B of the report on survey),
is to have a least width of 300 feet out to Bar Point, and 800 feet
thence to deep water in Lake Erie, with a least depth of 22 feet.
Work on this channel is authorized under continuing contracts to the
extent of $6,670,950, of which $1,095,950 is yet to be appropriated.
    More extended information may be found as follows: Annual Re-
ports of the Chief of Engineers for 1891, pages 2794-2801 (special
history); 1896, page 2758 (map), and 1904, pages 3140-3148; also
House Document No. 160, Fifty-eighth Congress, second session (main
channel to Wyandotte, Mich.), and House Document No. 266, Fifty-
ninth Congress, second session (ship channel connecting waters of the
Great Lakes).
    During the fiscal year work has been prosecuted along Limekiln
Crossing range and Hackett range in the Amherstburg channel,
and under four separate contracts, each covering one of the four sec-
tions of the Livingstone channel. About 70 per cent of the work of
improving the Amherstburg channel has been completed and 35 per
cent of the Livingstone channel.
    There has been expended to June 30, 1909, on the channel now desig-
nated as Plan "A," $3,827,683.76, of which amount $2,273,183.76 was
-applied to the present project, adoptedin 1902. The amount expended
for Livingstone channel is $2,407,417.01. None of these funds have
been applied to maintenance. Upon the completion of the work now
under contract and in progress on the channel via Amherstburg, that
part of the project will be practically completed, except for the sec-
tions along Ballards reef and Bar Point shoals. The work along Bal-
lards reef can not be advantageously done until the completion of the
entire Livingstone channel, but as section 4 of the Livingstone chan-
nel is now practically completed and open to navigation, work on
the Amherstburg channel in this vicinity, the Bar Point section north
of Detroit River light-house, will be commenced this season, and
 $250,000, in addition to available balance, can be profitably expended
for this work by June 30, 1911. There has been appropriated
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     779
$5,575,000 for the Livingstone channel, and $1,000,000, in addition
to available balance, can be profitably expended to June 30, 1911.
  The greatest draft which can be carried over the improved channels
June 30, 1909, was 22.04 feet, but this is subject to change consider-
ably, the mean monthly stage for November, 1908, having been 20.04
at this place-Ballards reef.
  For effect of channel improvements on freight rates see remarks
under this head in report of ship channel connecting waters of the
Great Lakes between Chicago, Duluth, and Buffalo (page 753).
                                    GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .............................      $307, 482. 29
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement...................................................       130, 666.05

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...... ........................                                    176, 816. 24
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....---. -..-.............               .........              38, 762. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available .................               ....      .............             138, 054. 24

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts. ...........                                     3, 222. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                            1, 300, 000. 00

"Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 .............      ...................                                        250, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
                                     LIVINGSTONE     CHANNEL.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ............   ..............                                   $2, 061, 181. 10
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act'approved March 4, 1909....                                3, 000, 000. 00
                                                                                                  5, 061, 181. 10
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement ............................................    ..........                            1, 893, 598.11

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended............................            .......                   3, 167, 582. 99
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .........         ...............                              535, 770. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available.. ...............                       .............             2, 631, 812.99

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                             3, 003, 168.00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                             1, 095, 950. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
   30, 1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909......................................                                      1, 000, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
                                           CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................                               $2, 368, 663. 39
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909....                                3,000, 000. 00
                                                                                                  5, 368, 663. 39
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement...............   ..........................                                           2, 024, 264. 16

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. ...............                        ..............           3, 344, 399. 23
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ......          ...................                 . ..       574, 532. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available..............                   ................                  2, 769, 867. 23
780           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U. S.      ARMY.

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...--...........                                  $3, 006, 390. 00
Amount(estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                                     2, 395, 950. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
   30, 1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...............................-----------------------------------.....----....    1,250,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
   (See Appendix N N 14.)
  15. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangeringnavi-
gation.-The following obstructions were completely removed during
the fiscal year:
Tug J. L. Higgie from channel in Rouge River, Michigan, total cost......... $300. 00
Steamer Eliza H. Strong, in Lake Huron, off Lexington, Mich., total expend-
  itures during fiscal year, $98.49; outstanding liabilities.........-------....... 843. 54
  The work of removal of wreck of schooner Harvey Bissell from
Alpena Harbor and of steamer Iron Age from Lake Erie will be under-
taken during the coming fiscal year.
   (See Appendix N N 15.)

IMPROVEMENT                 OF      RIVERS AND HARBORS                             IN THE           CLEVELAND,
                                         OHIO, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Lieut. Col. John Millis, Corps of
Engineers. Division engineer, Col. W. L. Fisk, Corps of Engineers.
   1. Toledo Harbor, Ohio.-The harbor of Toledo as at present
developed extends from the head of Maumee Bay about 7 miles up
the Maumee River.
   Originally, in the bay, the least depth was at ordinary lake level
8.5 feet, with a prevailing depth of 12 feet, while in the river the
minimum depths were 14 feet.
   In 1866 a project was adopted to dredge the channels of deepest
water in the bay to a depth of 12 feet. The project was amended
from time to time until 1887, when the old indirect channel had a
minimum depth of 15 feet.
   In 1887 a project was adopted for a straight channel through
Maumee Bay, with a depth of 17 feet and a bottom width of 200
feet. The estimated cost, including dikes or other channel protec-
tions, was $1,875,000.
   The project for a straight channel was amended in 1893 by increas-
ing the width of outer section, about 3 miles long, to 300 feet. Since
1892 the improvement has been extended to include the Maumee
River.
   The total amount expended on original and modified projects prior
to operations under existing project is $1,624,695.45.
   The present project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1899, and is described in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers, 1898, pages 2693 to 2705, inclusive. It provides for a
channel in the bay and river 400 feet wide and 21 feet deep to Fassett
Street Bridge, and 200 feet wide and 21 feet deep for the section above
the bridge, with a turning basin 500 feet wide at the upper end. A
dike was also to be constructed 1,000 feet in length between the
range lights in the bay. The estimated cost of the work was
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    781
$1,005,000. A continuing contract was authorized for its execution,
the limit of cost being fixed at $950,000.
   The work contemplated by this project has been completed with
the exception of the channel and basin above the Fassett Street
Bridge, where the channel has a width of only 100 feet.
   The total expenditure under the existing project to the close of
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $974,187.92, of which
amount $141,215.58 was for maintenance during the past six years.
   The deepening of the channel in the bay to the Wheeling and Lake
Erie Railroad bridge was done under contract, and the deepening
of the river above by the U. S. dredge Maumee. The dredging under
this contract was completed October 9, 1905, a total of 5,854,456
cubic yards having been removed.
   During the past year the U. S. dredge Burton excavated 145,760
cubic yards of material from the Maumee River between its mouth
and the Pennsylvania Railway bridge and 16,971 cubic yards of
material from the outer division of the bay channel, all at a cost of
$15,669.95.
   Dredging in the northerly 200 feet of the bay channel was carried
on under three contracts, all dated September 2, 1908.
   Under the first of these contracts 78,596 cubic yards of material
was removed from the inner division, the work being completed
November 4; 12,270 cubic yards additional was removed from this
division between November 5 and November 13 under a subsequent
agreement with the contractor.
   The second contract was for dredging in the middle division. The
amount removed was 80,727 cubic yards. The contract was com-
pleted November 13.
   The third contract was for dredging in the outer division; 69,508
cubic yards of material was removed up to November 14, when the
contract was completed.
   The result of these expenditures has been to create and maintain
a channel through Maumee Bay and River 400 feet wide and 20 feet
deep to Fassett Street Bridge, a distance of 15 miles, and to a width
of 100 feet and depth of 20 feet for 1 mile above this bridge. The
Maumee River is also navigable for launches to Perrysburg, 15 miles
above the mouth.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied toward mainte-
nance of existing channel to keep the improvement available.
   The usual variations in the level of the water surface during the
season of navigation range from 1 foot above to 2 feet below mean
lake level. Extreme fluctuations, due to wind, of 7.9 feet above to
7.1 feet below mean lake level have, however, been observed at Toledo.
   There has been a marked reduction in freight rates since the proj-
ect was inaugurated, but this has been due not only to the work at
this particular harbor, but to that at the other harbors along the
lakes and the improvements in the connecting channels, as well as to
other causes, and it is impracticable to determine how much of this
reduction is due to this particular improvement.
   The commerce of Toledo for the calendar year 1908 amounted to
3,946,819 tons, a decrease of 1,131,056 tons from that reported for
the calendar year 1907.
782           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                            U.   S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................... $73, 091. 80
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..................................................        45,000.00
                                                                                           118, 091. 80
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement............................................................                   71, 165. 17

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................                           46, 926. 63
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................                     1, 794. 88

July 1, 1909, balance available ...............................................             45, 131. 75

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
  expended July 1, 1909........................                  ....... 45, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix O O 1.)
   2. Port Clinton Harbor, Ohio.-The harbor of Port Clinton is
within the mouth of the Portage River. This river flows into Lake
Erie at a point about 13 miles by land and 22 miles by water west of
the city of Sandusky. In its natural condition the depth of water
on the bar at the mouth of the river rarely exceeded 5 feet at ordinary
lake level.
   The original project for its improvement was adopted in 1871 and
was slightly modified in 1872 and 1873. It provided for the construc-
tion of two parallel jetties extending outward from the mouth of the
river to a depth of 10 feet in the lake, at an estimated cost of $90,000.
These were built of timber and stone.
   The jetties were extended to a depth of 10 feet in the lake in 1883,
at which time the east jetty had been extended 2,180 linear feet
and the west jetty 1,948 linear feet. These lengths were thought
sufficient for the requirements of this harbor, and in 1894, at which
time a total expenditure of $71,949.86 had been made, it was recom-
mended that the remainder of the estimated cost of executing the
project ($21,000) be expended for necessary repairs.
   The project since 1894 has been one for maintenance, under which
$30,104.82 has been expended.
   The result of these expenditures has been to produce a channel
about 10 feet in depth, extending for one-half mile above the mouth
of the Portage River, which was the maximum draft that could be
carried June 30, 1909. A channel of 6 feet depth extends to Oak
Harbor, 12 miles above the mouth of the river.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance
to keep the improvement available.
   The project has had little effect on freight rates, as the commerce
of the port is small.
   No work under contract has been done at Port Clinton during the
year.
   The commerce of Port Clinton for the calendar year 1908 amounted
to 13,068 tons, an increase of 2,217 tons over that reported for the
calendar year 1907.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                            783
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................              ....     $0. 71
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 ........................        .       ...........................      2, 500. 00
                                                                                                 2, 500. 71
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement...................................................................................      55.39

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................................                          2, 445.32
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .......................................                        45.00

July 1, 1909, balance available .........................................                        2,400. 32

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909............        .........................  .. 1, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix O O 2.)
   3. Sandusky Harbor, Ohio.-The harbor of Sandusky is in the
lower part of Sandusky Bay, along the city front, the part nearest to
the lake being about 2 miles from the bar which divides the waters
of the bay from those of the lake. In its natural condition the depth
was only such as the bay afforded, which was about 10 feet along the
city front and from 9 to 12 feet thence to the lake, at ordinary lake
level.
    A long, flat sand bar divided the bay from the lake, this bar being
cut through by a channel from 1,000 to 2,000 feet in width near its
central portion. The southern part of the bar is called "Cedar
Point" and the northern "Sand Point." Between these two points
the currents between the bay and the lake had scoured out the chan-
nel to a depth of not less than 18 feet for a distance of a mile or more.
    The first appropriation was made for a survey in 1826, and the first
improvement was made in 1844, consisting in the construction of a
dam to close a breach across Sand Point. With this exception, all
the improvements made previous to 1896 consisted in deepening
natural channels and in making a new straight channel from the city
front to Cedar Point and in removing sand and bowlders from the
dock channel along the city front. Natural causes since 1826 have
washed away a greater part of Sand Point.
    In 1896 and subsequently the project was added to so as to provide
for the construction of parallel jetties of stone upon mattress founda-
tions extending from Cedar Point and Sand Point outward, with a
view to confining and directing the flow of water to and from the
bay. Provision was also made for the construction of certain spurs
and mattresses for the protection of the channel near Cedar Point
and at the point of the bar near the light-house.
    Under the original project thus modified there was expended
 $477,149.09.
    The present project, authorized by the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1899, is described in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1898, pages 2708 to 2716, inclusive. It provides for an
east jetty of stone upon brush mattresses extending from Cedar Point
about 5,000 feet into the lake; for a west jetty 5,500 feet long on the
opposite side of the channel, about 750 feet distant; for the protec-
tion of the crest of the bar and shore of Sand Point with a low dam
784     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S. ARMY.

of brush and stone, and for a deflecting dike for inner bar 1,500 feet
long and dredging to 17 feet. The estimated cost was $425,796, of
which $317,796 was for permanent works. By the river and harbor
act of June 13, 1902, the project was modified so as to provide for
dredging a channel 21 feet deep at mean lake level with a width of
400 feet in the approaches to the harbor front and 300 feet in the
harbor channel, at an estimated cost of $781,000, as described in the
Report of Chief of. Engineers, 1901, pages 3270 to 3277, inclusive.
The estimated cost of the entire project as revised in 1903 was
$1,135,000.
   The act of March 3, 1905, modified the project by omitting there-
from the excavation of rock other than that already provided for by
contract in the dock channel and fixed the limit of expenditures at
$815,000. Continuing contracts in excess of cash appropriations were
authorized by the same act to the amount of $480,000, of which
$130,000 remains to be appropriated. The act of March 2, 1907,
restored this work of rock removal to the project and appropriated
$125,000 for maintenance and continuing the improvement. In the
interim the city of Sandusky had removed considerable rock from the
channel.
   The total expenditures under the present project for improving
Sandusky Harbor to June 30, 1909, is $602,004.90, of which amount
$27,403.48 was for maintenance during the past six years. Prior to
that time the amounts expended for works of improvement and for
maintenance were so involved that it would be impracticable to sepa-
rate them.
   Under the appropriation of $125,000 in the river and harbor
act of March 2, 1907, a contract is in force for the removal of rock in
the dock channels. During the past year under this contract there
has been removed 93,387 cubic yards of material. A portion of the
rock removed was deposited in the extension of the east jetty, where
it can be used for the building up of this protection. The U. S.
dredge Burton worked in the outer channel from November 25 to
December 4, removing 16,907 cubic yards of material at a cost of
$1,055.92.
   The result of these expenditures has been to create a channel 300
feet wide and 212 feet deep through the outer bar, 400 feet wide
and 202 feet deep to the city front, and 160 to 300 feet wide and 20
feet deep along the city front to the Short Line docks, completing
99 per cent of the work now under contract. The project as a whole
is regarded as about 70 per cent completed.
   There is at present, however, some shoaling which reduces the
available width to a minimum of 200 feet through the outer bar and
to a minimum of 250 feet in the channel between the outer bar and
the city front.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance to
keep the improvement available.
   There has been a marked reduction in freight rates since the project
was inaugurated, but it is impracticable to determine how muchof
this reduction is due to this particular improvement.
   There is a general depth of 10 feet in Sandusky Bay to the mouth
of the Sandusky River, 14 miles above the city, and of 8 feet in the
river to Fremont, Ohio, 18 miles above its mouth, but there is prac-
tically no navigation above Sandusky, The usual variation in the
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      785
level of the water surface is the same as at Toledo, with extreme
fluctuations of 5 feet above and below mean lake level.
   The receipts and shipments at the harbor of Sandusky for the
calendar year 1908 amounted to 1,295,474 tons, a decrease of 944,387
tons from that reported for the calendar year 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............                 .......................                  $281, 416. 83
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement........            .................                      $65, 650. 80
    For maintenance of improvement ---.............------------........                  2, 728.02
                                                                                                        68, 378. 82

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                   213, 038. 01
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. .....-.... .....              ................            ..      8, 341. 22

July 1, 1909, balance available..-------------...------......--.....--------.....-----.                204, 696.79

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts . ..............         11, 167. 65
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project ...--------... 135, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909..........    ...................................                                 10,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix O O 3.)
   4. Huron Harbor, Ohio.-This harbor is situated at the mouth of
Huron River. In its natural condition the entrance was practically
closed by a sand bar.
   The first project for its improvement was adopted in 1826 and pro-
vided for the construction of two parallel jetties 140 feet apart, ex-
tending outward from the river banks. These jetties were lengthened
from time to time and repaired as required, and the channel was
finally deepened by dredging.
   The total amount expended upon these projects for all purposes of
construction and maintenance to June 30, 1905, was $269,789.07.
   The present project for the improvement of this harbor was author-
ized by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905. It is based upon a
survey, plan, and estimate called for by the river and harbor act of
June 13, 1902, and is published in full in the Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1904, pages 3209 to 3218, inclusive.
   It provides for rebuilding 580 feet of the west jetty, extending it 24t0
feet, and constructing a pierhead 50 feet square at its outer end; for a
second pierhead of the same dimensions and 300 feet easterly from it;
for a jetty or breakwater extending from this east pierhead to a point
on shore 1,200 feet easterly from the channel; for the removal of the
old east jetty; and for the dredging of the channel and a part of the
sheltered area to a depth of 21 feet below mean lake level.
   In the spring of 1904 it was necessary to make an allotment of
$40,000 from the river and harbor act of April 28, 1904, for the main-
tenance of this harbor. This money has been expended in rebuilding
about 490 linear feet of the shoreward end of the west jetty, which
was in such a ruinous condition that it threatened to give way and to
involve the destruction of the channel. This extension directly
advanced the project an(l diminished proportionally the amount
required for its comnpletion.
        9001--ENG 1909~-50
786          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                 S. ARMY.

   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, appropriated $68,500
and authorized contracts to be entered into for $200,000 more for the
completion of the new projects. Of this latter sum all but $3,000
has now been appropriated.
   The work contemplated in the latest project has been completed,
with the exception of a small amount of dredging in the sheltered area.
  The excavation necessary in connection with the execution of the
project and for maintenance of channel has been done during the past
year by the U. S. dredge Maumee; 65,986 cubic yards of material was
removed from the sheltered area, at a cost of $10,632.95.
   The amount expended under the existing project to June 30, 1909,
was $248,461.68, of which amount $10,471.31 was for maintenance.
   The result of these expenditures has been to obtain a channel 200
feet wide and 21 feet deep at mean lake level through the outer bar
and jettied channel for a distance of three-fourths of a mile. The
project is regarded as 99 per cent completed.
   A channel 8 feet deep extends to Milan, 8 miles above the mouth,
but there is practically no navigation on this part of the river.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance to
keep the improvement available.
   There has been a marked reduction in freight rates since the project
was inaugurated, but it is impracticable to determine how much of
this reduction is due to this particular improvement.
   The commerce for Huron Harbor for the calendar year 1908
amounted to 1,167,574 tons, a decrease of 1,153,881 tons from that
reported for the calendar year 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................... $57, 315. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.............................. $9, 599. 66
    For maintenance of improvement .......................   7, 165. 80
                                                                        16, 765. 46

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .............                    ............... ........   40, 549.63
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ................................                          442. 70

July 1, 1909, balance available........................................                      40,106.93

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909...........................................                              3,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix O             0 4.)
  5. Vermilion Harbor, Ohio.-Vermilion Harbor is at the mouth of
Vermilion River, which empties into Lake Erie about 20 miles east-
ward from Sandusky.
   The improvement of this harbor was first undertaken in 1836,
when an appropriation of $10,000 was made for the purpose. The
original project provided for parallel jetties extending outward to 12
feet of water in the lake. The jetties were built, but the current
only sufficed to maintain a channel of about 7 feet depth across the
bar at ordinary lake level.
  In the natural condition of the harbor there was only about 2 feet
of water at this place. Dredging was accordingly resorted to and
                       RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     787
the project enlarged to provide for a depth of 14 feet of water. This
involved the removal of rock, and the project was never fully exe-
cuted.
   The total amount of money expended on the original project is
$133,277.55.
   No work has been done under contract at Vermilion during the
past year.
  The amount expended on the existing project for maintenance to
June 30, 1909, was $29,964.13.
  The result of these expenditures has been to provide a channel 12
feet deep to the inner end of the piers. A channel of 8 feet extends
to the Lake Shore Railway bridge, one-half mile above. The water-
surface fluctuations are similar to those at Huron or Lorain.
  The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance
to keep the improvement available.
  The improvement has had little effect on freight rates, as the ton-
nage of the port is small.
   The receipts and shipments for the calendar year 1908 amounted
to 1,355 tons, a decrease of 254 tons from that reported for the
calendar year 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................                              ..................   $155. 82
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved March
  3, 1909..................          .........................................                        2, 000. 00
                                                                                                      2, 155. 82
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement................................    ......................                                   119.95

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                               2, 035. 87
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ............... ......................                                .40

July 1, 1909, balance available.........            ............................                      2, 035.47
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909................................................     1, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix O O 5.)
  6. Lorain Harbor, Ohio.-This harbor is within the mouth of Black
River, where it enters Lake Erie, 25 miles west of Cleveland. In its
natural condition the depth of water at the mouth of this river at
ordinary lake level did not exceed 3 feet, but the river itself was
navigable for a distance of 3 miles from its mouth for all vessels then
in use upon the lake.
  The first project, adopted in 1828, provided for the construction of
parallel piers 200 feet apart, running out to a depth of 16 feet in the
lake. This project was modified in 1873 and 1880. The piers have
been rebuilt and extended from time to time, to keep pace with
increasing requirements, and dredging has been resorted to to secure
a greater depth than the natural currents would afford. The amount
expended on this project was $292,202.88.
  The present project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1899. The project in detail is given in full in the Annual
Report of Chief of Engineers for 1898, pages 2718 to 2724, inclusive.
It provides for the construction of two rubble-mound breakwaters
788      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U. S. ARMY.

converging toward the lake, having an opening between them at
their outer extremities 500 feet in width and in prolongation of the
axial line of the jettied channel. It also provides for repairing the
jetties and for dredging the protected areas to a depth of 20 feet.
The estimated cost is $695,500.
   The total expenditure authorized by the river and harbor act of
March 3, 1899, was $650,000, but that amount not being sufficient to
secure the completion of the work at such prices as could be obtained
by advertisement, special authority was given in the river and harbor
act of June 6, 1900, to enter into contract for such portion of the
work as the funds available would allow, at a cost not to exceed a 10
per cent increase over the original estimates, and the funds required
therefor were appropriated in the river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1905, and sundry civil acts of March 3, 1905, and June 30,
1906. The act of March 2, 1907, authorized the expenditure of
$15,000 in dredging the easterly side of Black River from the inner
end of the easterly government pier to East Erie Avenue Bridge.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, provided for the expen-
diture of funds already appropriated or authorized for the extension
of the west arm of the breakwater to or toward the shore.
   Under various contracts the east and west piers have been entirely
rebuilt, two breakwaters have been built, the western one 1,800 feet
long, the eastern one 1,500 feet long, and pierheads have been con-
structed at the entrance of the outer harbor.
   There has been expended under the new project to June 30, 1909,
$652,637.40, of which amount during the past six years $27,971.58
was for maintenance. Prior to that time the amounts expended for
works of improvement and for maintenance were so involved that it
would be impracticable to separate them.
   With this expenditure a channel has been dredged to a depth of 20
feet between the piers and for 1,000 feet beyond. The east pier,
1,003.5 feet long, and the west pier, 1,765 feet long, have been entirely
rebuilt. The east pierhead and east breakwater were completed
August 4, 1908, providing a west breakwater 1,800 feet long and an
east breakwater 1,500 feet long, with pierheads at their outer
extremities.
   The U. S. dredge Maumee was engaged from July 17, to September
3 in dredging the easterly side of Black River from the inner end of
the government pier to the East Erie Avenue Bridge under a project
approved March 27, 1907; 41,760 cubic yards of material was removed,
at a cost of $4,901.91.
   The project is 95 per cent completed. A channel 21 feet deep
below mean lake level also extends up the river to the steel plant, 3
miles above the mouth, and is maintained by local authorities.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance to
keep the improvement available.
   The water-surface fluctuations are similar to those at Cleveland.
   There has been a marked reduction in freight rates since the project
was inaugurated, but it is impracticable to determine how much of
this reduction is due to this particular improvement.
   The commerce of Lorain for the calendar year 1908 amounted to
4,399,350 tons, a decrease of 331,070 tons from that reported far the
calendlar year 1907.
                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   789

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ............                ...................                  $154, 120. 84
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement..........................                             $28, 707, 80
    For maintenance of improvement.......................                            6, 968. 95
                                                                                                    35, 676. 75

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .............................                                     118, 444. 09
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ...................                   ..............              93. 51
July 1, 1909, balance available ....................                            ..... .....        118, 350. 58
IAmount  that can be profitably expended in f!bc xl year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909............................................5,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix O O 6.)
  7. Cleveland Harbor, Ohio.-Originally Cleveland Harbor was
simply the mouth of Cuyahoga River, in which the water was shoal
and sometimes the entrance was entirely closed to boats by the
sand. The first improvement was undertaken in 1825, and the
plan contemplated straightening the channel and making it perma-
nent by side jetties. The channel was dredged when necessary.
The total expenditure under this plan was $346,244.84.
   In 1875 a project was adopted for a breakwater of timber cribs in
5 fathoms of water. The west breakwater was commenced in 1876
and completed in 1883, a total length of 7,130 feet. The east break-
water was commenced in 1888 and continued at intervals until 1893,
when its length was 2,494.5 feet. In 1895 an opening of 200 feet was
made in the shore arm of the west breakwater as a sanitary measure.
   In 1896 Congress authorized the completion of the improvement
at a total estimated cost not to exceed $1,354,000, in accordance with
a project published in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1896, pages 2949 to 2953, inclusive. This project involved the com-
pletion of the east breakwater, covering an extension of about 3,000
feet; removing superstructure of the old west breakwater to a depth
of 2 to 3 feet below water level and replacing it with a superstructure
of concrete masonry; reenforcing the cribs below the masonry;
sheathing the face of the east breakwater; removing and rebuilding
the east and west piers and widening the mouth of the river. A
continuous contract for the work was authorized.
   In 1899 a project was prepared, and was authorized by the river
and harbor act of that year, for deepening the channel and sheltered
area by dredging to a depth of 21 feet. This project was enlarged by
the act of June 13, 1902, to permit the dredging to be carried to a
depth of 25 feet.          The estimated cost of the work was $478,400.                                  (See
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1899, pp. 3076 to 3078,
inclusive, for project, and p. 3061 for estimate as revised.)
  The river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, authorized a further
modification of the project by providing for improving and enlarging
the entrance to the harbor and for extending the breakwater east-
ward to Gordon Park, in the city of Cleveland, a distance of about
16,000 feet, at a total estimated cost of $4,481,456. This project is
described in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1901,
pages 3277 to 3299, inclusive. The act authorized an expenditure of
790     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S. ARMY.


$2,800,000, of which $100,000 is yet to be appropriated, but this
authorization was increased by $900,000 in the river and harbor act
of March 2, 1907, of which $600,000 is yet to be appropriated. This
act also appropriated $98,000 for the construction of a Government
dock at the foot of Erie street in the city of Cleveland, in accordance
with plan printed in House Document No. 270, Fifty-ninth Congress,
second session, contingent upon the consent of the Cleveland Yacht
Club, which holds a lease of this frontage.
   The existing project for improving Cleveland Harbor, Ohio, is
therefore a combination of those authorized by the acts of 1875, 1896,
1899, 1902, and 1907.
   There has been expended on this project to June 30, 1909, $5,523,-
698.53, of which amount $508,259.72 was for maintenance during
the past six years. Prior to that time the amounts expended for
works of improvement and for maintenance were so involved that
it would be impracticable to separate them.
   With this expenditure the mouth of the river has been widened,
the east and west piers rebuilt and capped with concrete, with the
exception of a small amount of jetty extension and dredging near
the mouth of the Cuyahoga River and south of the Lake Shore Rail-
way bridge, which has not been carried out because the United States
has been unable to obtain title to the land which would have to be
dredged away. The superstructure of the west breakwater has been
removed and replaced by concrete masonry, and the lake face of the
cribs protected with riprap. The old east breakwater has been re-
paired and extended as provided for in the project of 1896, with the
exception of about 270 feet, which, being a portion of the shore arm,
was not built on account of the modifications in the river and harbor
act of June 13, 1902, which rendered its construction unnecessary.
   The work at the new entrance was completed October 6. This
consists of two pierheads, two projecting breakwaters, and rubble-
mound protection for the old structure. The western division of the
east breakwater extension was completed October 27, 1908, the
eastern division is 85 per cent complete, and work under a contract
dated January 14, 1909, for the new extension eastward is 18 per
cent complete.
   Construction of the wharf at the foot of East Ninth street was com-
menced June 1, 1909.
   From 1899 to 1904, 766,928 cubic yards of material was excavated
in the harbor, at a cost of $115,000; but, as shown by the annual
report of the district engineer for 1904, the deposit which took place
over this area during this period has equaled or exceeded the amount
of material removed, and the work done therefore must be regarded
simply as mnaintenance work and not in advancement of the project.
   A contract for dredging in the basin was completed November 24.
Under this contract 801,628 cubic yards of material was removed.
   As a result of these expenditures a navigable channel 25 feet in
depth has been provided at the mouth of the river and a large outer
harbor constructed which is available for docks and anchorage. The
project as a whole is regarded as 80 per cent completed.
   The amount recommended to be appropriated will be applied to
building pierheads, east entrance, and shore arm of the east break-
water.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENT.                                                             791

   Cuyahoga River has a navigable depth of 20 feet to Jefferson street,
4 miles above its mouth, and 16 feet for 1 miles farther, and is main-
tained by local authorities.
   There has been a marked reduction in freight rates since the
project was inaugurated, but it is impracticable to determine how
much of this reduction is due to this particular improvement.
   The commerce for Cleveland Harbor for the calendar year 1908
amounted to 10,159,170 tons, a decrease of 2,713,278 tons from that
reported for the calendar year 1907.
   The usual variation in the level of the water surface during the
season of navigation is from 1 foot above to 2 feet below mean lake
level. Fluctuations due to wind are about 2 feet.
             UNDER       CONTRACTS, ETC., AUTHORIZED BY ACT OF JUNE 3, 1896.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .........................                                                    $45, 484. 84
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................................                                        45, 484. 84

                MAINTENANCE          (DREDGING)        AND CONTINUING IMPROVEMENT.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................. $104, 791. 17
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment .......................................................................... 47, 007.48
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                                         57, 783. 69
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities................................. ....                                         23. 96
July 1, 1909, balance available ......................                                 ..............          57, 759.73
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                        203, 000. 00

                                                 WHARF ROOM.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............          .................    $98, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..............    ..................         .......................
                                               .......                           57.08

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.........................                              ............            97, 942. 92
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..........................                         ............              171.20

July 1, 1909, balance available.......................................                                ...      97, 771.72

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts                           ..................             83, 735. 00

NEW ENTRANCE,          BREAKWATER EXTENSION, ETC., ACTS OF JUNE 13, 1902, AND MARCH
                                                     2, 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................                                          $672, 040. 99
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.....                                          337, 500. 00
                                                                                                            1, 009, 540. 99
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..........      ......................................                                                  472, 029.04

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................                                           537, 511. 95
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...................................                                       55, 194. 15

July 1, 1909, balance available ..............                       ...............             ..           482, 317. 80
792           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                  U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts-.... ........ $1, 010, 433. 09
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 1, 481, 456. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909...................                                     a 194, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
                                               CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.... ................
                                               --        ....... ..                            $920, 317..00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909 .....                            337, 500. 00
                                                                                               1, 257, 817.00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment................. .......................   ..... ...............                          519, 093. 60
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended............                  ....................
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................
                                                                                                 738, 723. 40
                                                                                                  55, 389. 31

July 1, 1909, balance available ......................                      ............   .     683, 334.09
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts................ 1, 094, 168. 09
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........ 1, 684, 456. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909...........        .................................     a 194, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.
    (See Appendix O O 7.)
    8. FairportHarbor, Ohio.-This harbor is situated at the mouth
of Grand River, 30 miles east of Cleveland. Before the improve-
ment was undertaken the depth across the bar at the mouth of the
river was variable.
   The first improvement was undertaken in 1825, and the original
project provided for the construction of parallel jetties of cribwork
filled with stone, placed about 200 feet apart and extending outward
across the bar and into the lake. The jetties were extended from
time to time until the west jetty attained a length of 2,370 feet and
the east jetty 1,765 feet from the original shore line. These jetties
have been repeatedly repaired and rebuilt as necessities required, and
the channel has been deepened and dredged many times.
    By the river and harbor act of June 3, 1896, the existing project for
this improvement was adopted. This project is described in the
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, pages 2956 to 2958, inclu-
sive, and provides for the construction of two breakwaters converging
toward the lake, the outer ends being in deep water, and sufficient
space being left between them to afford an easy entrance to the jettied
channel. The breakwaters were to terminate in pierheads 50 feet
square, the west breakwater to have a length of 2,050 feet and the
east breakwater 1,350 feet. The estimated cost of the work, includ-
ing dredging between the breakwaters to a depth of 20 feet, was
$510,000, which was revised to $585,000 in 1900. (See Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, pp. 4071-4072.)
  a Of this amount, $100,000 is under the continuing-contract authorization made in
the river and harbor act approved June 13, 1902, and $94,000 under act of March 2,
1907.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     793
   A further modification of the project occurs in the river and harbor
act of March 3, 1905, which provides that the westerly arm of the
breakwater may be extended to a point at or near the shore, the
expense thereof to be paid from the appropriations therein and there-
tofore made. The estimated cost of this extension was $120,000.
   The total expenditures to June 30, 1899, on the original project,
were $368,940.09.
   The river and harbor acts of June 13, 1902, and March 3, 1905,
provided not only for continuing existing project but for maintenance
of the old work. From the various appropriations since 1899 there
have been expended $196,167.25 in repairs to old piers and dredging.
With these funds 580 linear feet of the shoreward end of the east
jetty was completely rebuilt of timber cribs with a concrete top, and
570 linear feet of the west jetty was extensively repaired with tongued
and grooved piling below the water and with concrete and stone
above, and the outer portion of both jetties was protected below
water by a sheathing of hard-wood plank, and the wooden super-
structure was completely repaired.
   With the funds available for continuing the improvement, 828
linear feet of the shoreward end of the west breakwater, as pro-
vided for in the report of 1896, has been built, extending to the shore.
The work of extending the west breakwater 1,000 feet lakeward and
for the construction of a pierhead at its outer end is in progress
under contract. This work is about 65 per cent complete.
   There has been expended on the existing project to June 30, 1909,
$504,540.89, of which amount $125,358.32 was for maintenance
during the past six years. Prior to that time the amounts expended
for works of improvement and for maintenance were so involved that
it would be impracticable to separate them.
   The water surface variations are similar to those of Cleveland.
   The amount recommended to be appropriated will be applied to
building the east arm outer breakwater.
   The result of these expenditures has been to obtain a channel 20
feet deep at mean lake level across the bar at the mouth of the river
and to protect the entrance from westerly storms. The project is
regarded as about 55 per cent completed.
   There has been a marked reduction in freight rates since the
project was inaugurated, but it is impracticable to determine how
much of this reduction is due to this particular improvement.
   The commerce of Fairport Harbor for the calendar year 1908
amounted to 2,302,275 tons, a decrease of 1,021,220 tons from that
reported for the calendar year 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................................... $155, 614. 63
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909. ......................................................... 5, 000. 00
                                                                                                           160, 614. 63
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement....-----------------..............--.......------..           $74, 929. 20
    For maintenance of improvement .....................                                     2, 850. 26
                                                                                                            77, 779. 46

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended---------------.........----------........-------..............             82, 835. 17
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities---------------...------......................------------.........    13, 190 09

July 1, 1909, balance available.                   .............     ....       ..... ............          69, 645. 08
794          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .............         $61, 636. 82
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........      245, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909.............   ........................   ..............    245, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
  (See Appendix O O 8.)
   9. Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio.-This harbor is situated at the mouth
of the Ashtabula River 56 miles east of Cleveland. In its natural
condition the mouth of the river was obstructed by a bar upon which
the depth of water varied according to weather conditions. The
greatest depth on the bar that could prevail was 9 feet, at ordinary
lake level, this being the distance to the underlying rock near the
shore line.
   The original project for the improvement of this harbor was
adopted in 1826 and provided for the construction of two parallel
jetties extending outward into the lake. These jetties have been built
and repaired from time to time and extended farther into the lake,
and the channel has been deepened by dredging to meet the increas-
ing demands of commerce, the project being modified accordingly.
  The total amount expended on the original project was $565,192.27.
   The existing project was adopted under the authority of the river
and harbor act of 1896 and is described in the Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1895, pages 3122 to 3216, inclusive, and provides for
the construction of two breakwaters, each 1,500 feet long, and two
pierhead cribs, at an estimated cost of $465,000. This plan was
modified as explained in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1896, pages 2963 and 2964, to provide a west breakwater 1,800
feet long and an east breakwater 1,200 feet long.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1899, authorized a continuous
contract to be made for the construction of these breakwaters, at a
cost not to exceed $430,000.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, authorized the expendi-
ture of the unexpended balance on hand to the credit of the improve-
ment for the extension of the west breakwater to a point at or near
the shore, and the funds have been applied toward the prolongation
of the west breakwater 1,300 feet.
   Work under a contract for constructing the east and west break-
waters was completed August 17.
   Bids have been received for a further extension of the west break-
water and for necessary reenforcement to the timber crib portion of
that structure.
   The amount expended on the existing project to June 30, 1909, is
 $757,209.84, of which amount $20,897.77 was for maintenance during
the past six years. Prior to that time the amounts expended for
works for improvement and for maintenance were so involved that
it would be impracticable to separate them.
   The project is regarded as 95 per cent complete.
   In 1904 the Secretary of War, under authority of law, gave per-
mission to the Pittsburgh, Youngstown and Ashtabula Railroad Com-
pany to completely remove the west jetty and to replace the same by
a bulkhead 60 feet farther to the west, thus increasing the width of
the channel.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                          795

   A description of this improvement is contained in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908, page 758.
   In May, 1906, authority was also granted by the Secretary of War
to the Lake Shore and Michigan Southern Railway Company to make
certain improvements on the easterly side of the river. The railway
company has taken possession of the east pier and extended it north-
ward 720 feet; thence it is extended about 900 feet easterly; thence
southward, meeting the property of the railway company. The
inclosure, about 15 acres, has been filled to the level of the docks,
about 3,350 feet of crib dock has been completed, and a second fill of
20 acres to eastward has been built up. The government east
breakwater affords but partial protection to these new docks. The
railroad company has been authorized to extend the east breakwater
to protect, its docks. Work on this improvement was begun in June,
1906, and 1,100 feet of the breakwater is completed. The east basin
and slip have been dredged to a depth of 23 feet.
   As a.result of these expenditures the depth across the bar at the
mouth of the river has been increased to 20 feet and an outer harbor
has been provided. A 20-foot channel extends up the river 14 miles
above its mouth and is maintained by the local authorities.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance to
keep the improvement available.
   The water-surface variations are similar to those at Cleveland.
   There has been a marked reduction in freight rates since the proj-
ect was inaugurated, but it is impracticable to determine how much
of this reduction is due to this particular improvement.
   The commerce of Ashtabula Harbor for the calendar year 1908
amounted to 5,935,097 tons, a decrease of 5,899,483 tons from that
reported for the calendar year 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                     $145, 217. 24
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ..........................                     $62, 017. 88
    For maintenance of improvement. ....................                      2, 775. 11
                                                                                             64, 792. 99

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                       80, 424. 25
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                        182. 64

July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................                          80, 241. 61

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.............                               ........                    5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix O O 9.)
  10. Conneaut Harbor, Ohio.-Conneaut Harbor is at the mouth of
Conneaut Creek, 69 miles east of Cleveland. In its natural condition
the creek was obstructed by a bar at its mouth, over which the average
depth of water did not exceed 2 feet at ordinary lake level.
  The first improvement was undertaken in 1829, and consisted in the
construction of parallel jetties of timber cribs filled with stone. The
greatest depth obtained under this project did not exceed 12 feet.
796          REPORT OF THE               CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                U.    S. ARMY.

   No appropriations were made for this harbor from 1880 to 1892.
At the end of this period the jetties were in a decayed and ruinous
condition, and the channel had filled up with sand and silt, and had
practically reverted to its original condition. The harbor could only
be used by small sailing craft, such as were then engaged in fishing.
   In 1892 a project was prepared which provided for the construc-
tion of parallel jetties 200 feet apart and extending outward to a
depth of 17 feet in the lake, and appropriations under this project
were made to 1896.
   Expenditures on the early projects were $192,448.47.
   The existing project was authorized by the river and harbor act of
June 3, 1896, and is described in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1896, pages 2970-2972, inclusive. This project pro-
vides for the completion of the jetties to a depth of 17 feet in the lake,
and the construction of two detached breakwaters converging toward
the lake and designed to shelter the entrance to the jettied channel,
and for securing a navigable depth of 20 feet in the channel and
sheltered area. The estimated cost of the work was $610,000, ex-
clusive of maintenance.
   The total amount expended on the existing project to June 30, 1909,
is $644,424.48, of which amount $31,601.23 was for maintenance dur-
ing the past six years. Prior to that time the amounts expended for
works of improvement and for maintenance were so involved that it
would be impracticable to separate them.
   With these funds the project has been completed.
   From April 30 to May 22 the United States dredge Burton worked
at Conneaut restoring the channel to its usual depth and width, some
shoaling having occurred during the winter months.
   As a result of these expenditures the depth across the bar at the
mouth of the creek has been increased to 20 feet and an outer harbor
has been provided. A 20-foot channel extends up the creek one
and one-half miles above its mouth, and is maintained by local
authorities.
   The water surface variations are similar to those at Cleveland.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance to
keep the improvement available.
   There has been a marked reduction in freight rates since the project
was inaugurated, but it is impracticable to determine how much of
this reduction is due to this particular improvement.
   The commerce for Conneaut Harbor for the calendar year 1908
amounted to 6,468,064 tons, a decrease of 1,883,343 tons from that
reported for the calendar year 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                           $60, 394. 47
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .............................                       $18, 876. 19
    For maintenance of improvement ......................                          5, 841. 01
    For Isthmian Canal Commission ......................                             a807. 73
                                                                                                 25, 524. 93

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                            34, 869. 54
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...................................                            113. 27
July 1, 1909, balance available ...................................                              34, 756. 27


                                            a To be refunded.
IAmount             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.

          that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...............................................
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
                                                                                 797



                                                                            $5, 000. 00
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix O O 10.)
   11. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangeringnavi-
gation.-(a)Schooner Lillie.-This vessel while unloading gravel at the
east pier, Cleveland Harbor, north of the custom-house, was collided
with by another vessel, disabling her to such an extent that she was
beached immediately north and west of the Lake Shore Railway
bridge in such a position as to obstruct the movements of the draw
span. The wreck was immediately removed from this location by the
use of a tug, which hauled her clear of the draw. The cost of this
work was $40.15, paid from an allotment made August 14, 1908, under
provisions of section 20, river and harbor act of March 3, 1899.
   (b) Sand sucker Syracuse.-This sand sucker struck a sunken pile
in Swan Creek in Toledo Harbor, Ohio, turned turtle, broke in two, and
sunk in the channel, August 26, 1908. A dipper dredge was employed
to remove the wreck, which she did at a total cost of $340, paid from
an allotment for the purpose made October 30, 1908, under provisions
of section 20, river and harbor act of March 3, 1899.
   (See Appendix O O 11.)

IMPROVEMENT        OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE BUFFALO, NEW
                           YORK, DISTRICT.

  This district was in the charge of Col. W. L. Fisk, Corps of Engineers,
division engineer, Lakes Division, having under his immediate orders
First Lieut. W. L. Guthrie, Corps of Engineers, since March 23, 1909.
   1. Harbor at Erie, Pa.-Inits original condition the harbor of Erie
was nearly landlocked, the only entrance being at the east end through
a channel which was narrow and tortuous, variable in position, with
a depth of about 6 feet.
   The original project approved March 26, 1824, provided for closing
the eastern end of the harbor by means of a breakwater, in which
there should be an opening 200 feet wide, and for extending to deep
water in the lake two parallel piers, one on each side of the opening.
The project also included the necessary work of dredging to keep the
channel open, making the necessary repairs to existing structures,
and maintaining the Presque Isle Peninsula.
  The project was modified by the river and harbor act of March 3,
1899, to require the harbor basin and entrance channel to be dredged
to a depth of 20 feet at mean lake level, the north and south piers
to be provided with concrete superstructure and extended 500 and
1,000 feet, respectively, and, conditionally, as stated in House Docu-
ment No. 70, Fifty-fifth Congress, first session, four protection jetties
to be built along the outer shore of Presque Isle Peninsula.
  The estimated cost of completing the modified project was $377,000.
   At the beginning of the past fiscal year, under the modified project,
1,210 feet of wooden superstructulre on north pier had been replaced
with concrete; thie northl pier hlad been extended 510 feet and the
798                    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


south pier 500 feet; two protection jetties had been built; the channel
and basin dredged 20 feet deep, except the shoal area along the harbor
line, abreast and west of the public dock, which will be dredged this
season, and the wooden superstructure on all of the south pier (1,217
feet) had been replaced with concrete.
   During the fiscal year a further extension of the south pier, 500
feet, was completed; a survey of the entrance channel and harbor
basin was made. Specifications prepared and bids invited, to be
opened July 15, 1909, with a view to making contract for restoring
project depths. Project completed except maintenance; a further
dredging of harbor basin, and building two jetties on the north shore
of Presque Isle Peninsula, provided for conditionally.
   Work proposed for the ensuing fiscal year includes doing dredging
necessary to maintain the project depth in entrance channel and
basin, to maintain existing structures, and to protect Presque Isle
Peninsula when necessary, all for the purpose of making the improve-
ment available and for extension of benefits.
   The total amount expended on the harbor to June 30, 1909, was
$1,364,146.49. It is impracticable to separate the cost of construction
and maintenance. The project is about 95 per cent completed.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
lake level over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement
was 19 feet, and the usual variation of level of water surface is about
2 feet.
   The following table gives the total arrivals and departures, including
tonnage, for the past ten years:

                     Year.                    Number.    Tonnage.                 Year.            Number.     Tonnage.

1899........................                    3,200    3,961,794   1904......... ............      1,996      2,890,321
1900.......................                     2,709    3,403,312   1905.......................     2,632      4,134,459
1901 .......              ............    .     3,405    3,204,325   1906......................      2,579      4,477,764
1902 .......                ...........   .     2,809    3,873,734   1907.......................     2,927      5,504,896
1903 .........................                  2, 423   3,503,628   1908.......................     2,093      3,690,578



  For more extended information and photographs, see Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 4100 et seq., and for 1903,
page 2115 et seq.; for list of surveys, see page 3239, Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1897. Reference to report on exami-
nation made in compliance with act of March 2, 1907, will be found
on page 770 of report for 1908.
  A chart of Erie Harbor is issued in the series of charts of the Survey
of the Northern and Northwestern Lakes, index 332.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................                                        $113, 934. 64
June 30, 1909, receipts from sales ...................................                                 .           1. 33
                                                                                                             113, 935. 97
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement...................................................                                             45, 200. 18

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                                           68, 735.79
       (See Appendix PP 1.)
  2. Harbor at Dunkcirk, N. Y.-This is an artificially protected har-
bor lying in an indentation of the south shore of Lake Erie, between
                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                  199
Point Gratiot on the west and Battery Point on the east. The dis-
tance between these points is 9,600 feet, and the maximum breadth
of the indentation is 3,600 feet.
   The original depth of water was about 10 feet at mean lake level
and 15 to 16 feet to underlying rock.
   The project, approved November 30, 1870, provided for a detached
breakwater 2,860 feet long, one part of which, 2,300 feet long, was to
be nearly parallel with the shore; the other part, 560 feet long, to
be nearly parallel with the axis of the entrance channel.
   This breakwater and the pier already built, 1,410 feet long, were
to form the harbor, and the old channel was to be enlarged to 170
feet wide and 13 feet deep.
   The project adopted by Congress and provided for by the river
and harbor act of June 3, 1896, consisted in completing the break-
water as before planned by the addition of 360 feet to its eastern end
and adding the channel arm 560 feet long, and in addition thereto
dredging the entrance channel and a harbor basin, containing in all
about 65 acres, to a depth at mean lake level suitable for vessels
drawing 16 feet. This work was completed in 1898 at a total cost
of $389,060.55.
    The total amount expended on the harbor to June 30, 1909, was
 $983,014.22. It is impracticable to separate the cost of construction
and maintenance.
    During the fiscal year repairs to structures damaged by storm of
January 20, 1907, were completed at a total cost of $16,235.65.
    Work proposed for the ensuing fiscal year consists in placing the
structures in as good repair as practicable with the funds on hand.
    The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
lake level over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement
was 16 feet, and the usual variation of level of water surface is about
2 feet.
    Freight rates have not been affected by the project.
    The following table gives the total arrivals and departures, includ-
ing tonnage, for the past ten years:

               Year.                    Number.   Tonnage.                Year.                   Number.   Tonnage.

1899 .........................              192      82,783   1901.......................             117        5,128
1900........................                278     107,316   1905..................       ....       115        9,502
1901....................          ...       171      49,148   1906.......................             111       11,310
1902............................            143      33,435   1907........................             97        5,712
1903 ...      .......................       237      64,803   1908 .......................            117        3,422



  For more extended information and map, see Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1898, page 2748 et seq., and for reports of
surveys, see page 3127, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1896, and page 4150, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1900. Reference to report on examination made in compliance with
act of March 2, 1907, will be found on page 770 of report for 1908.
   A chart of Dunkirk Harbor is issued in the series of charts of the
survey of the Northern and Northwestern Lakes, index 318.
800        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                   U. S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....................................           $6, 236. 42
Amount allotted from appropriation          by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909-------
                 ..........---------------------------------------...---.        5, 000. 00
                                                                             11, 236. 42
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement---------...----...............................................
                           ---------------------------------------            4,033.26
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................            .....-........    7, 203. 16
   (See Appendix PP 2.)
   3. Harbor at Buffalo, N. Y.--Buffalo Creek was the original harbor
of the port of Buffalo. In its original condition the entrance chan-
nel from the lake was shallow and frequently closed by a gravel bar.
The original project for the improvement of this harbor was adopted
in 1826, and provided at first for the construction of piers on the north
and south sides of Buffalo Creek. Subsequently, a masonry sea wall,
5,400 feet long, was built along the lake shore south of the harbor
entrance, and a sand-catch pier of piles and stone, 879 feet long,
built out from the shore.
   Between 1868 and 1893 a detached breakwater, 7,600 feet long,
was built of timber cribs about a half mile distant from the lake
shore and parallel with it.
   A shore arm about 4,000 feet long was projected in 1874 to extend
to the south end of this breakwater, leaving an opening of 150 feet.
Work on this was in progress when it was wrecked by storm in 1893.
   A new project was adopted in 1895 on the recommendation of a
board of engineer officers and consisted of the abandonment of the
shore arm and the extension of the breakwater to Stony Point.
    The report of the Board and details of its plans are published in
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1895, page 3153 et
seq. The river and harbor act of June 3, 1896, added to the project
of the Board by providing for the construction of a farther length of
the sand-catch pier, extending it to the established pierhead line.
   The river and harbor acts of June 6, 1900, and June 13, 1902,
made special provision for deepening the entrance to Buffalo Harbor
and the city ship canal. The entrance channel has been dredged 23
feet deep at mean lake level for a width of 200 to 300 feet for 2,200
feet outward from outer end of north pier, 150 feet wide between the
piers to its inner end (junction ,of Buffalo River and city ship canal),
except over an area of rock at that point, where the depth is from 211
to 23 feet.
    The project now in force for the improvement of Buffalo Harbor,
adopted June 3, 1896, and modified by the emergency river and har-
bor act of June 6, 1990, and the river and harbor acts of June 13, 1902,
March 3, 1905, and March 2, 1907, is as follows:
    (a) To build an extension of the breakwater to Stony Point, leav-
ing the necessary openings for the convenience of commerce.
    (b) To extend the sand-catch pier to the established pierhead line.
    (c) To build an arm 1,000 feet long to the Stony Point section of
breakwater for the purpose of protecting the south harbor entrance.
    (d) To maintain existing structures by strengthening timber-
crib concrete portions and by making repairs and replacing the wooden
superstructure of the breakwater with concrete and stone when neces-
sary, and to maintain the north entrance channel 23 feet deep at
mean lake level.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    801
  (e) To dredge to a depth of 23 feet at mean lake level an area at
south end of harbor sufficient to provide access to canals of Lacka-
wanna Steel Company and Buffalo and Susquehanna Iron Company.
   (f) To remove to a depth of 23 feet a shoal outside the main or
north entrance to the harbor.
   Of the above, items (a) and (b) have been completed, (c) is now
in progress, (d) will be required indefinitely, (e) is completed, and
it is expected to complete (f) during the present season.
   During the fiscal year work on the south entrance arm has been
continuedl; about 750 feet is 70 per cent completed, and a contract has
been made for constructing the remaining 250 feet.
   Work of repairing damage by storm of January 20, 1907, to 1,910
feet of old breakwater has been continued during the fiscal year, and
fair progress made, 61 per cent completed.
   Work of removing shoals outside main entrance to harbor has
progressed very slowly and time limit for completion of contract
has been waived, the contractor to pay the extra expenses incurred
by reason of waiver. At the close of the fiscal year the work was
50 per cent completed. It is expected it will be completed this season.
   During the fiscal year 3,281 tons of heavy riprap stone was placed
on and along the Stony Point section-timber crib-at a cost of
$4,530.12.
   Work proposed for the ensuing fiscal year, for making improvements
available, and for extension of benefits, consists in continuing work
on south entrance arm, removing shoal outside of north entrance to
harbor, repairing timber portions of breakwater, and general main-
tenance of channels and structures.
   It is recommended that the project be enlarged to include the
removal of additional shoals outside the north or main entrance to the
harbor.
   The total amount expended by the United States on the improve-
ment of Buffalo Harbor to June 30, 1909, was $5,426,720.59. It is
impracticable to separate the cost of construction and maintenance.
   A good harbor has been obtained. The principal features are
north and south piers and the entrance channel between them at the
mouth of Buffalo Creek, in which most of the business of the port is
done, and the outer breakwater system, consisting of four sections of
breakwater of an aggregate length of 22,600 feet, inclosing an outer
harbor 4 miles long and over one-half mile wide. This breakwater
system comprises 8,894 linear feet of breakwater of timber-crib-
concrete type, 7,250 linear feet of stone or rubble-mound type, 723
feet of timber-crib-stone type, 1,910 linear feet of wrecked timber-
crib-rebuilding to timber-crib-stone type, and 3,823 feet of timber-
crib type.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
lake level over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement
was 20 feet. The usual variation of level of water surface is from 3
to 4 feet, with maximum variation much greater.
  The project is reported to have a material effect in controlling
freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, lumber, and(
ore.
   The commerce of Buffalo is large. During the year 1908 arrivals
and departures of vessels by lake and river aggregated in number
6,191 and in tonnage 12,003,968.
     9001-ENG 1909-51
802                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                               S.   ARMY.

   The arrivals and departures of canal boats by the Erie Canal were
4,482 in number, with a tonnage of 1,621,527.
   The principal receipts by lake and river were wheat, corn, flour,
oats, iron ore, lumber, copper, pig iron, glucose, lard, and pork. The
total receipts amounted to 7,526,615 tons.
   The shipments by lake were principally coal, sugar, salt, and cement,
and aggregated 4,652,259 tons.
   For comparison the following table is given, showing the arrivals
and departures by lake and canal and the tonnage for the past five
years:



                                                                                                            Lake.                    Canal.
                                            Year.
                                                                                                      Number.       Tons.    Number.      Tons.


1904 .................................                            .....          ........ ........      7,375   10,783,980     5,132        988,725
1905.........................                               ...........................                 7,950   12,090,153     4.902        985,861
1906 ......................................................                                             8,294   13,876,759     5,666      1,7769,919
1907..................                        ... ...............................                       8,205   14,518,233     5,014      1,942,455
1908 ...........................                                     .......... ..... .............     6,191   12,178,874     4,482      1,621,527



   Total shipments and receipts: 1907, 18,429,695 tons; 1908,
13,800,401 tons.
   For more extended information and maps and photographs, see
Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers since 1897, and for reports
of.surveys see page 3153, Report of Chief of Engineers for 1895, and
reference on page 703, Report of Chief of Engineers for 1906, printed
in full in House Document No. 240, Fifty-ninth Congress, first
session.
   A chart of Buffalo Harbor is issued in the series of charts of the
survey of the Northern and Northwestern Lakes, index 312.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ............................        .....         836. 28
                                                                             $..558,
June 30, 1909, receipts from sales and collections..........................       471. 80
Amount transferred from appropriation for Buffalo entrance to Erie Basin
  and Black Rock Harbor ....        ................................            3, 264. 44

                                                                                                                                     562, 572.52
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...........................                                                               $48, 067.19
    For maintenance of improvement .....................                                                              110, 134. 96
                                                                                                                                     158, 202. 15

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...............                                                             ....................     404, 370. 37

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .................                                                              236, 727. 16
      (See Appendix P P 3.)
   4. Lake Erie entrance to Black Rock Harbor and Erie Basin, New
York.-The adopted project contemplates the formation, by dredg-
ing and rock removal, of a channel 2,300 feet long, 400 feet wide,
and 23 feet deep at mean lake level, except where bed rock is found
at a depth of 22 feet, from Buffalo main entrance channel to Erie
Basin, and a branch channel and basin 1,920 feet long, 500 feet wide,
and 23 feet deep at mean lake level, to Black Rock Harbor, at an
estimated cost of $814,643. In its original condition there was a
depth of from 12 to 18 feet at mean lake level. The act of June 13,
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              803
1902, authorized the letting of a continuing contract in the sum of
$614,643, exclusive of amount appropriated, for completing the
work.
   The plan of improvement is printed in House Document No. 125,
Fifty-sixth Congress, second session, and in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1901, page 3345.
   The work was begun April 30, 1903, under a continuing contract
for the whole work, to be completed under certain conditions of
contract on or before December 31, 1906.
   The work was not completed on that date, and the time limit was
waived for a reasonable period, the contractor to pay the extra
expense incurred by reason of the extension of time.
   T
   'he work was completed December 31, 1908, at a cost of $814,643,
this being the total amount expended to June 30, 1909, for work of
improvement.
    T
      he maximum draft that could be carried over the shoalest part
of the locality under improvement at mean lake level June 30, 1909,
was 21 feet, and the usual variation of level of water surface from 3
to 4 feet, with maximum variation much greater.
    For commercial statistics, see report on Buffalo Harbor, New York.
    The locality is showxn on a chart of Buffalo Harbor and(l Niagara
River to the falls, issued in the series of charts of the survey of the
Northern and Northwestern Lakes, index 312, and on an index
map facing page 2142, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1903.
  Reference to survey is made on page 592, Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1900.
  rhe project, being auxiliary to the improvement at Buffalo, has
not, as a separate work, affected freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ............. ....................... $173, 028. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement .................................................           173, 028. 09
   (See Appendix P P 4.)
   5. Buffalo entrance to Erie Basin and Black Rock Harbor, New
York.-- T he first appropriation, $50,000, for this improvement
made March 3, 1899, and an appropriation of $191,701.25 was made
                                                                               was
June 6, 1900, to complete the v ork.
   The adopted project is to build a breakwater about 2,200 feet
long, covering and protecting the entrance to Erie Basin and Black
Rock Harbor and the lake front of Buffalo Harbor between the
State structures known as the "Erie Basin breakwater" and the
"Bird Island pier," which in their original condition were unpro-
tected from storms.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $238,436.81, of which
$236,278.10 was for constructing and $2,158.71 was for maintenance.
No money was expended during the past fiscal year as the project
is completed.
   The maximum draft that could be carried over the shoalest part
of the locality under improvement at mean water level June 30,
1909, was 20 feet, and the usual variation of level of water surface is
from 3 to 4 feet, with maximum variation much greater.
   For commercial statistics, see report on Buffalo Harbor.
804       REPORT     OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                S. ARMY.

   For more extended information, see Annual Reports of the Chief
of Engineers for 1897, page 3246 et seq., and for 1901, page 3324
et seq., and for report of survey see page 3246, Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1897.
   The locality is shown on a chart of Buffalo Harbor and Niagara
River to the falls, issued in the series of charts of the survey of the
Northern and Northwestern Lakes, index 312, and on an index map
facing page 2143, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1903.
   The project, being auxiliary to the improvement at Buffalo, has
not, as a separate i\ork, affected freight rates.
   This breakwater is the most northerly section of the breakwater
system protecting Buffalo Harbor. The river and harbor act of
March 3, 1909, reappropriated the funds on hand, for improving
harbor at Buffalo, N. Y., and the breakwater will hereafter be main-
tained, and reports made, under the latter appropriation.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................      $3, 264. 44
Transferred to Buffalo appropriation.........................................3, 264. 44
   (See Appendix P P 5.)
   6. Black Rock Harborand channel, New York.-Black Rock Harbor
is in reality a canal built along the east bank of Niagara River, sepa-
rated therefrom by Bird Island pier and Squaw Island, and having at
its lower end a lock of 5 feet lift, 36 feet wide by 200 feet long, and a
depth of 91 feet on miter sills at mean lake level. This harbor, or
canal, was separated from the Erie Canal by a wall of stone and earth,
and was constructed as a terminal for the Erie Canal.
   From 1829 to 1834 appropriations amounting to $52,098 were
made by the United States and applied to the construction of the
Bird Island pier or breakwater.
   The object of the present project is to provide a channel for deep-
draft vessels between Buffalo and Tonawanda around the rapids at
the head of Niagara River. This is to be accomplished by making a
channel 200 feet wide and 23 feet deep at mean lake level, joining at
the foot of Maryland street, Buffalo, the 23-foot channel completed
in 1908, the proposed channel to extend westerly and northerly,
through Black Rock Harbor and Erie Canal combined, to the present
lock, below which a ship lock of the requisite capacity is to be built,
the channel to extend from the foot of the ship lock through the
Niagara River to deep water above Tonawanda, 400 feet wide and
23 feet deep at mean river level. The estimated cost is $4,500,000.
The project contemplated a lock 600 feet in length and 60 feet in
width between quoins; but in order to accommodate vessels of the
largest size now in use and under construction which may desire to
use it the dimensions of the lock have been increased to 650 feet in
length and 70 feet in width.
    Report of survey is printed on page 3284 et seq. of report for 1904.
    Lands and structures needed in the prosecution of the work have
been granted to the United States by the State of New York.
    Continuing contracts were authorized by the river and harbor acts
of March 3, 1905, and March 2, 1907, in the sum of $2,700,000 (all of
which has since been appropriated) for prosecuting the project, and
such contracts have been made as follows:
   For the excavation of the southerly 6,400 feet, more or less, of the
channel, to be completed December 31, 1908.
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                       805
   For the excavation of the next northerly 3,400 feet, more or less, of
the channel, to be completed December 31, 1910.
   For the construction of concrete walls for the ship lock, to be
completed June 30, 1912.
   During the fiscal year the cofferdam for lock walls was completed,
unwatered, and excavation therein to bed rock nearly completed, and
channel excavation was continued under existing contracts.
   T[he total amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $991,390. The
project is about 20 per cent completed.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied toward payments
under existing contracts, to construction of lock gates and machinery,
and to further prosecution of the project, including construction of a
bridge at Ferry street, Buffalo, and the excavation of the east channel
of the Niagara River from the foot of the ship lock to the natural
deep water harbor 21 miles down stream. It is recommended that
the entire amount ($1,800,000) required to complete this project be
made available, $1,000,000 by cash appropriation for the year ending
June 30, 1911, and $800,000 by continuing contract authorization.
   'Ihe maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1900, at mean
lake level, over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement,
was 8 feet, and the usual variation of water surface is from 3 to 4 feet.
   The project, being auxiliary to the improvement at Buffalo, has
not, as a separate work, affected freight rates.
   The locality is shown on United States Lake Survey Chart No. 312.
   For commercial statistics see report on Buffalo Harbor and on
Tonawanda Harbor and Niagara River, New York.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................        $1, 469, 662. 35
June 30, 1909, receipts from sales ..... ........... ....... ... .........            1. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909....          1, 000, 000. 00
                                                                                                        2, 469, 663.35
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement.....................................................708,                                           633. 10

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................                                       1, 761, 030. 25
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                                   1, 451, 760. 75
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.......                                   1, 800, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
   30, 1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909.....................--------------------------------....--...---........---...   1, 000, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
   (See Appendix P P 6.)
   7. Tonawanda Harbor and Niagara River, New Yorlc.-In its
original condition the navigation of Niagara River from Lake Erie
to Tonawanda was obstructed by several reefs and shoals which
materially limited the draft of vessels traversing it, and the river in
some places had a very swift current. The water in the harbor
between Tonawanda Island and the mainland was shoal.
  The adopted project of April 11, 1888, as modified June 3, 1896,
and June 13, 1902, is to remove obstructions, so as to make a channel
400 feet wide and 18 feet deep at mean river level from Lake Erie
to the north line of North Tonawanda, including the dredging of
Tonawanda Harbor to a depth of 18 feet.
806          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                       U.   S.   ARMY.

   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, also appropriated
$3,000 for removing wreck of steamer Embury from Niagara River,
near Grand Island.
   The project is completed except at the Buffalo waterworks intake
pier, where the width of the channel is about 100 feet, and from the
Tonawanda Iron and Steel Company's docks to the north line of
North Tonawanda, where the depth is from 12 to 15 feet.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $661,671.45, all for
improvement.
   No work was done during the fiscal year; $7.30 expended for
traveling expenses.
   No work is proposed for the ensuing fiscal year.
   The commerce of Tonawanda is large. During the year 1908
there were entered and cleared 1,048 lake craft, with a tonnage of
742,408 tons. The receipts were principally lumber, iron ore, and
limestone, and aggregated 734,255 tons. The shipments from
Tonawanda are entirely by Erie Canal.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
water level, over the shoalest part of the locality under improvement,
was 15 feet, and the usual variation of level of water surface is 2 feet.
   A chart of Niagara River to the falls is issued in the series of charts
of Northern and Northwestern Lakes, index 312.
   It is reported that the project has a material effect in controlling
freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, groain, lumber, and ore.
   For reports of surveys see page 2066, Annual Report of Chief of
Engineers for 1888, and page 4155, report for 1900.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................... $30, 230. 68
June 30, 1909, receipts from collections.................................    49. 07
                                                                                       30, 279. 75
June 30, 1909; amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  im provem ent....................... ........ ......................                       7.30

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                     30, 272.45
   (See Appendix P P 7.)
  8. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navi-
gation.-The scow Trader sunk in Niagara River off the east shore of
Strawberry Island July 8, 1908, and was abandoned by her owners.
  Under allotment of $2,000 made August 18, 1908, the wreck was
removed at a cost of $830 and the balance of funds returned to the
Treasury November 16, 1908.
   (See Appendix P P 8.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE OSWEGO, NEW YORK,
                         DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Col. W. L. Fisk, Corps of Engi-
neers, division engineer, Lakes Division, having under his immediate
orders First Lieut. W. L. Guthrie, Corps of Engineers, since March
23, 1909.
   1. Harbor at Charlotte, New Yorlc.-This harbor is at the mouth of
the Genesee River. In its original condition vessels of more than
8 feet draft could not cross the bar.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                      807

   The original project of 1829 was to secure a channel 12 feet deep
across the bar by constructing parallel piers to confine and direct
the action of the spring freshets. The project of 1882 was to obtain
a depth of 15 feet by extending the two piers a total of 3,250 feet and
by dredging. After the piers had been extended 1,444 feet the project
was modified July 18, 1896, to preserve the depth by dredging ith-
out further extension of the piers for the present, and March 2, 1897,
                                                                                          u
it was again modified to obtain and maintain not less than 16 feet
and not more than 162 feet at low water (zero of Oswego gauge) in a
channel not more than 200 feet wide.
   The piers are nearly parallel, about 450 feet apart. The west pier
is 3,616 feet and the east pier 3,109 feet in length, projecting beyond
the shore line 2,230 and 2,200 feet, respectively. During the fiscal
year 812 feet of the east pier and 59 feet of the west pier received
concrete superstructure, making a total to June 30, 1909, of 1,532 feet
of east and 1,559 feet of west pier with concrete superstructure. The
entrance channel was maintained during the year. Project completed
except maintenance.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $750,987.25. It is
impossible to separate the cost of construction and maintenance.
   June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that could be carried in the
channel at low water xwxas 16 feet, and the usual variation of level
of water surface is 3 feet.
   The Genesee River is navigable for lake vessels for a distance of
about 21 miles above its mouth.
   It is reported that the project has a material effect in controlling
freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, lumber, and ore.
   The following is a statement of the commerce at this port during
the past ten years, in tons: 1899, 447,428;                               1900, 388,605; 1901,
549,207; 1902, 557,690; 1903, 569,169; 1904, 554,212; 1905, 597,996;
1906, 432,709; 1907, 701,916; 1908, 709,950.
   The work proposed for the ensuing fiscal year, to make the improve-
ment available, is to make necessary repairs to piers and to dredge
the channel when required, and the appropriation recommended
will be applied to this purpose, with the allotment of $9,000, made
from emergency funds May 24, 1909.
   For more extended information and map, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1881, page 2436.
   A chart of Charlotte Harbor is issued in the series of charts of the
survey of the Northern and NorthwiXestern Lakes, index 241.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................. . .................               $37, 166. 32
Allotted from emergency appropriation, act of March 3, 1905.............                9, 000. 00
Sales......... .......................................................                       4. 10
                                                                                      46, 170. 42
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.............................................. --- ..........             36, 500. 41

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                 9, 670. 01
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909---------------------------------...--------80,                   000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix Q Q 1.)
808        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   2. Harbor at Pultneyville, N. Y.-This harbor is at the mouth
of Salmon Creek, which empties into Lake Ontario in Wayne County,
N. Y. In its original condition the depth was only 20 inches.
   The original project in 1871 was to protect the approach to the
creek by building two piers in the lake, of timber cribs filled with
stone, and to dredge a channel from the 10-foot curve in the lake to
the mouth of the creek to a depth of 10 feet at low water, at an
estimated cost of $59,000.
   In 1875 the material to be dredged was found to be so hard that
the estimated cost was increased to $71,000.
   The project is completed, except that a depth of 8 feet instead of
10 feet was obtained, the effort to secure the latter having been
abandoned in 1900 on account of the difficult dredging.
   The piers are 220 feet apart in their parallel portions. The west
pier is 910 feet long and the east pier 572 feet long. The west pier
extends out in the lake 300 feet farther than the east pier.
   No work was done at this harbor between 1900 and 1907, there
being no funds available.
   An appropriation of $6,000 was made by the river and harbor act
of March 2, 1907, for work at this harbor, and project for general
repairs to piers, filling space between inner end of east pier and shore
with stone, and removing about 7,500 cubic yards sand, etc., from
channel was approved March 18, 1907.
   During the fiscal year minor repairs were made to the piers, at a
cost of $677.31.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $83,265.15, of which
$70,607.96 was for construction and $12,657.19 for maintenance.
The project is completed except maintenance.
   June 30, 1909, the maximum draft that could be carried in the
channel was 7 feet, and the usual variation is 3 feet.
   Salmon Creek is navigable but a short distance above the inner
end of the piers.
   The project has had no effect on freight rates.
   The commerce of Pultneyville, which is a village of about 300
inhabitants, is insignificant, there being only 6 arrivals and de-
partures, with a tonnage of 160, during the year 1908.
   Work proposed for the ensuing year is to make necessary repairs
to the piers.
   For more extended information and map, see page 2460 et seq.,
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1894.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....                    ..--..-.-...-----...----. $2, 412. 16
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement.......     .................................                               677.31

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................               1, 734. 85
   (See Appendix Q Q 2.)
   3. Harbor at Great Sodus Bay, New Yorlc.-In its original condi-
tion the channel connecting this bay with Lake Ontario was wide
and impracticable for vessels drawing over 8 feet.
   The original project of 1829 was to narrow the entrance by con-
structing two converging breakwaters and to secure a channel of
12 feet depth by building two parallel piers about 450 feet apart,
colmnnecting with the ends of the breakwater, and by dredging. The
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                        809
present project, of 1882, is to obtain a depth of 15 feet at low water
(zero of Oswego gauge) by extending the two piers a total of 1,100
feet and by dredging. After the piers had been extended 519 feet
to their present lengths-west pier, 1,580 feet; east pier, 1,294 feet-
the project was modified July 18, 1896, to restore and maintain the
channel 150 feet wide between the piers, flaring to 250 feet in the
lake, to the requisite depth of 15 feet at low water, by dredging,
without further extension of the piers for the present.
   The piers are 473 feet apart; east breakwater 1,651 feet long,
west breakwater 2,200 feet long. During the fiscal year repairs
were made to the piers to the extent necessary to prevent serious
damage by seas, and at the close of the year the work of tearing
out old timber superstructure on the piers and replacing it with
concrete was fairly started, the work being done by hired labor.
  The funds recommended to be appropriated for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1911, will be used to continue the concrete work,
to make the improvement available. The project is completed
except maintenance.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $502,586.91, of
which $94,335.11 was for maintenance.
   The minimum depth June 30, 1909, was 112 feet at low water
in a channel width of 150 feet, and the usual variation of level of
water surface is 3 feet.
   The project is reported to have a material effect in controlling
freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, lumber, and
ore.
  The following is a statement of commerce at this port for the past
ten years, in tons: 1899, 78,885; 1900, 84,379; 1901, 84,379; 1902,
26,726; 1903, 18,875; 1904, 30,797; 1905, 46,251; 1906, 58,905; 1907,
78,057; 1908, 73,989.
   For more extended information and map, see Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1881, page 2441 et seq.
  A chart of Great Sodus Bay is issued in the series of charts of the
survey of the Northern and Northwestern Lakes, index 234.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..-----........................----------------------.....----......         48,429.34
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement......-------..----.....--------...---------.....-.....................----------------........    3, 530.45

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended---........                       --.....   ..        ...............        44, 898. 89

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...------------------------------------------                                          55, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix Q Q 3.)
   4. Harbor at Little Sodus Bay, New York.I-Tn its original condi-
tion the channel connecting this bay with Lake Ontario was about
150 feet wide and 18 inches deep.
   The original project of 1854 was to protect the channel by build-
ing two parallel piers 250 feet apart across the bar to the 15-foot
curve in the lake and to connect them with the shore by break-
w,ters. In 1867 this project was modified to provide for dredging
to the depth of 12 feet. Iihe present project, of 1882, is to obtain
810       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S.                    ARMY.

a depth of 15 feet at low water (zero of Oswego gauge) by extending
the piers to the 15-foot curve in the lake, and by dredging.
piers had been extended 835 feet to the following lengths-west
                                                                                    'ihe
pier, 1,747 feet; east pier, 1,510 feet-when the project was modi-
fied June 29, 1898, to restore and maintain the entrance channel,
150 feet wide, to the requisite depth of 15 feet, by dredging, without
further extension of the piers for the present; and this was modified
by the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, to extend the east pier
300 feet.
   This extension was built-timber-crib substructure and concrete
superstructure-in 1904, making the present length of the east pier
1,810 feet.
   The west pier is 1,747 feet long; the east breakwater 1,680 feet
long; west breakwater, 469 feet long, but entirely buried in sand and
no longer maintained.
   During the fiscal year the work of replacing with concrete the
timber superstructure on the piers was continued slowly, the work
being hampered by high water. Three hundred and twenty-six
linear feet was completed. At the close of the year the U. S. dredge
Frontenac was employed in restoring project depth in the channel
betwceen the piers. The project is completed except maintenance.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to continuing the
work outlined above to make the improvement available.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $425,740.68, of which
$124,377.88 was for maintenance.
   The minimum depth over the shoalest part of the locality under
improvement, June 30, 1909, was 13 feet at low water in a channel
width of 100 feet, and the usual variation of level of water surface
is 3 feet.
   The project is reported to have a material effect in controlling
freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, lumber, and
ore.
  The following is a statement of commerce at this port for ten
years, in tons: 1899, 81,969; 1900, 59,511; 1901, 135,118; 1902,
52,543;   1903, 120,692; 1904, 137,258;       1905, 105,298;     1906,
103,991; 1907, 108,804; 1908, 153,474.
  Work proposed for the ensuing year, necessary to make the im-
provement available, consists in maintenance of channels and piers.
  For more extended information and map, see Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1881, page 2443 et seq.
  A chart of Little Sodus Bay is issued in the series of charts of the
survey of the Northern and Northwestern Lakes, index 227.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..--.................................... $61, 055. 06
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement....... ..................................................     17, 512. 01

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....       .......    ........................ 43, 543. 05
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909------------------....------------------------35,             000. 01
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix Q Q 4.)
                 RIVER AND   HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   811
   5. Harbor at Oswego, New York..-This harbor comprises the lower
part of Oswego River, a cove at its mouth, protected by a breakwater
now known as the inner breakwater, and an outer harbor formed by
an outer breakwater. In its original condition the harbor in the
Oswego River was navigable by vessels of light draft only, and the
cove had no protection against the lake seas.
   The original project of 1827 (completed in 1829) was to build
across the cove a breakwater of timber cribs filled with stone.
Between 1.830 and 1838 a superstructure of masonry was built on
500 feet of this breakwater. Between 1866 and 1869, $41,000 was
expended in dredging the harbor to the depth of 12 feet at extreme
low water. Between 1868 and 1870 a light-house pier           was
extending north 437 feet from the channel end of the breakwater.
                                                                   built,
In 1871 the project for an outer harbor formed by an outer break-
water was adopted, and in 1881 an outer breakwater was completed
having a lake face 4,870 feet long, a westerly shore return 916 feet
long, and an easterly return 246 feet long. In 1881 a project was
adopted to build an east breakwater, 248 feet of which was con-
structed in 1881 and removed in 1889. In 1885 and 1889 two spurs
to the outer breakwater, 100 and 150 feet long, respectively, were
built.
   In the acts of March 3, 1893, and August 18, 1894, special pro-
visions were made for extending the deep-water area of the harbor in
the mouth of the Oswego River by the removal of rock.
   The present project was adopted June 3, 1896, based on a special
report printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1895, page 3213, et seq, and as subsequently modified is, first, to build
an east breakwater 1,435 feet long, at an estimated cost of $197,000
 (acts of March 3, 1895, and June 3, 1896); second, to narrow the
breach made in the outer breakwater in 1884 from 175 feet to about
75 feet, at an estimated cost of $18,500; third, to widen and deepen
the inner harbor in the mouth of the Oswego River and to extend the
deep-water area farther upstream by rock excavation.
   There are 5,907 feet of outer breakwater and 1,993 feet of inner
breakwater and light-house pier, forming an outer harbor containing
140 acres and an inner harbor containing 9.35 acres (including the
Oswego River). The areas having a controlling depth of 14.5 feet at
low water are 40 acres in the outer harbor and 4- acres in the inner
harbor.
   Under maintenance there is required: The maintenance of the
outer breakwater and inner breakwater and light-house pier, the
maintenance of a depth of 15.7 feet at low water in the entrance
channel and in the outer harbor, and the maintenance of a depth of
15 feet at low water in the cove behind the inner breakwater and in the
harbor in the mouth of Oswego River.
   The plane of reference is low water (zero of Oswego gauge).
   The outer breakwater is difficult and costly to maintain.
   The river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, made an appropriation
for continuing repairs with timber under the method printed as plan
"B" on page 3368, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
Under this appropriation extensive repairs were made with timber
to the outer breakwater during 1905-6, and owing to extensive
812            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                           S. ARMY.

damage by storms were continued during the past fiscal year to pre-
serve parts damaged from complete destruction.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, made an appropriation
of $100,000 and authorized contracts to the extent of $100,000 addi-
tional, all of which has been appropriated, for reconstruction under
plan "A," printed on page 3368 of the Annual Report of tihe Chief of
Engineers for 1904, which contemplates a stone superstructure and
sea slope, at an estimated cost of $900,000. This work was begun
during the fiscal year 1908.
   The amount expended for all work to June 30, 1909, was
$2,211,564.70. It is impracticable to separate the cost of construc-
tion and maintenance. The project is completed except for mainte-
nance, which is being prosecuted under a plan specifically adopted
by Congress.
   The funds recommended to be appropriated for the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1911, will be used to continue the reconstruction of the
outer breakwater, to make the improvement available.
   June 30, 1909, the minimum depth at low water over the shoalest
part of the locality under improvement was 14 feet.
   The usual variation of level of water surface is 3 feet.
   The project is reported to have a material effect in controlling
freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, lumber, and ore.
   The following is a statement of the commerce of this harbor for the
past ten years, in tons: 1899, 716,753; 1900, 575,160; 1901, 565,052;
1902, 334,009; 1903, 733,734; 1904, 712,481; 1905, 724,502; 1906,
615,840; 1907, 728,090; 1908, 724,187.
   Work proposed for the ensuing fiscal year, necessary to make the
improvement available and extend its benefits, consists in dredging
on shoals as may be required in the outer harbor and entrance channel,
continuing the reconstruction of the outer breakwater under plan
"A," and repairs on timber structures when required. The appro-
priation recommended will be applied to this work.
  Report of survey of the outer breakwater is printed on page 3363
et seq. of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904.
  For more extend(ed information and map, see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1881, page 2451 et seq.
  A chart of Oswego Harbor is published in the series of charts of the
survey of the Northern and Northwestern Lakes, index 225, and an
index map facing page 2160 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1903.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................--.........--........                                    $82, 109. 89
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909-.....                                         100, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909------...---..-----.....--------....-------....---..........................-----------..-.   40, 000. 00
Sales ................    .....................                ...............                  ..........        11. 00
                                                                                                             222, 120. 89
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement..........--.........................----.................                                       66, 777. 94

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                         155, 342. 95

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts...............                                          38, 534. 51.
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                                      700, 000. 00
IAmount                      RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.

          that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909.............         ................... $200, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
                                                                                                                            813




  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix Q Q 5.
   6. Harbor at Cape Vincent, New Yorkc.-This harbor in its original
condition was an open roadstead on the St. Lawrence River, 2 miles
from Lake Ontario, and is a convenient location for vessels to lie
during storms, at night, anl in thick weather.
   The original project of 1896 was to build a breakwater, 1,600 feet
long, parallel to and 600 feet from the railroad wharf, at an estimated
cost of $320,000. On May 13, 1899, this project was modified to
build a breakwater parallel to and 500 feet from the railroad wharf,
1,550 feet long, of which length 150 feet, or so much thereof as
required, was to be a shore return at upper end, at an estimated cost
of $200,000. Nine hundred and ten feet of this breakwater, of which
50 feet is shore return, has been built. Further extension of the
shore return is not considered necessary. The project is about three-
fifths completed. No work was done during the fiscal year. There
was $128.62 expended for pay of watchman and for traveling
expenses.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was 127,279.79, of which
 $270.39 was for maintenance.
    The maximum draft that could be carried over the locality under
improvement at low water June 30, 1909, was 19 feet, and the usual
variation of level of water surface is 3 feet.
    The commerce of Cape Vincent is not large. This improvement is
intended to make a harbor of refuge for all craft plying between Lake
Ontario and the St. Lawrence River.
   The following is a statement of the commerce of this port, in tons,
for the years given: 1901, 4,209; 1902, 4,175; 1903, 15,666; 1904,
20,083; 1905, 21,750; 1906, 112,501; 1907, 21,946; 1908, 33,573.
    Work proposed for the next fiscal year is the continuationi of the
breakwater, and the amount asked for will be applied to this work
for the purpose of extension of benefits.
    For more extended information and map, see Annual Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 3286, et seq., and for 1903,
page 2162, et seq.
    The project has provided facilities that make navigation more safe
and thus affects freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................   ......                                              $848. 83
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .....................................................                                                       128. 62

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                                                      720. 21
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........... 72, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909-------------------------------------------------........................................................ 72, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897.
    (See Appendix Q Q 6.)
814     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

   7. Harbor at Ogdensburg, New York.- In its original condition
the low-water depth in this harbor was 9 feet in the upper entrance
channel leading to the Oswegatchie River, 10 to 12 feet in the two
lower entrance channels, and 6 to 12 feet along the city front.
   The original project of 1868 was to dredge the channels to the
depth of 12 feet and to build, if necessary, 5,500 linear feet piers, at
an estimated cost of $100,000. The piers were never built. The
          'St.
project of 1882 provided for dredging the upper entrance channel
from the        Lawrence River channel across the shoal to and into,
the mouth of the Oswegatchie to 16 feet, and the lower entrance
channels and channels along the city front to 15 feet at extreme low
water, at an estimated cost of $75,000. The present project (see
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1890, p. 2872) provided
for dredging all the channels to a depth of 16.5 feet below the zero
of the Ogdensburg gauge (15 feet below the zero of the Oswego
gauge), at an estimated cost of $158,950. The project was modi-
fied February 27, 1897, to deepen the two lower entrance channels
to 16 feet below the zero of the Oswego gauge, and by act of March 3,
1899, further modified to dredge 900 feet of the channel along the
front of Ogdensburg above Franklin street to but 14 feet below the
same zero, the projected depths of the upper entrance channel to and
into the mouth of the Oswegatchie River up to the bridge, and the
balance of the channel along the city front to remain 15 feet. The
dredging of all of the channels of the project was completed in July,
1903, but they are not stable, and frequent redredging is necessary
to maintain the required depths.
    The project is completed except maintenance.
    Work of redredging to restore project depths was nearly completed
at the close of the fiscal year, and as it will be completed with funds
on hand, no estimate is made for the next fiscal year.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1908, was $389,660.64, of which
 $118,296.99 was applied to maintenance of improvement.
    The maximum draft that could be carried over the improvement
at low water (zero of new Ogdensburg gauge corresponding to zero
of Oswego-gauge), June 30, 1909, was as follows: In the lower en-
trance channels, 16 feet; in the upper entrance channel, 15 feet; in
the channel along the city front above Franklin street, 14 feet; be-
low Franklin street, 15 feet. The usual variation of level of water
surface is 3 feet.
    The project is reported to have a material effect in controlling
freight rates on bulk commodities, such as coal, grain, lumber, and
ore.
    The following is a statement of commerce at this port for the past
ten years, in tons: 1899, 670,363; 1900, 646,248; 1901, 646,248;
1902, 837,025; 1903, 1,185,785; 1904, 898,257; 1905, 1,034,085;
1906, 1,056,100; 1907, 1,238,498; 1908, 856,714.
    For more extended information and map see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1881, page 2451, et seq. Reference to reports
on examination and survey made in compliance with act of March 2,
1907, will be found on page 779 of Report for 1908.
                              RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                           815
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ..                                   .. .......
                                                                -........                         ......     .... $55, 652. 22
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement------------....---......................--------------....................---------------------...   28, 374. 57
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended... .                            -.............   ..........                  27, 277. 65
                                                                                                         -.......

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..................                                          7, 205. 53
    (See Appendix Q Q 7.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE LOS ANGELES, CALI-
                    FORNIA, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Capt. Amos A. Fries, Corps of
Engineers, having under his immediate orders the following officers
of the Corps of Engineers: First Lieut. C. T. Leeds during the entire
year, and First Lieut. A. R. Ehrnbeck from January 7 to May 13,
1909. Division engineer, Lieut. Col. John Biddle, Corps of Engineers.
   1. San Diego Harbor, California.-SanDiego Harbor is just north
of the national boundary of Mexico and 482 nautical miles south of
San Francisco.
   The river and harbor act approved March 3, 1875, appropriated
$80,000 for the construction of a dike across the mouth of San Diego
River, causing it to empty into False Bay, and thus preventing San
Diego Harbor from being injured by the deposit of material brought
down during flood stages. This work was completed in 1876 at a
cost of $79,798.72, which, with the cost of repairs made up to the
time of adoption of the present project, brought the total expendi-
tures to $81,918.45. Further repairs to the dike have been made by
the city of San Diego.
   The project for the improvement of the harbor, adopted by the
river and harbor act approved September 19, 1890, provided for the
construction of a jetty on Zuninga shoal, at the entrance to the har-
bor; the maintenance of a channel 24 feet deep at mean low tide
and 500 feet wide through the "middle ground," and for repairs to
restraining dike. The jetty was to rise to the height of extreme high
water and to be about 7,500 feet long, with a view to producing a
depth of 26 feet at mean lower low water on the outer bar.
   At the time of the adoption of this project the governing depth
on the bar was 21 feet. Just inside the entrance was a middle ground
carrying but 17 feet of water. The main channel, lying to the west
of the middle ground, was of ample depth, but was difficult of navi-
gation on account of two sharp turns.
   The original estimated cost of this improvement was $394,400.
This estimate was increased in June, 1900, to $542,850. With this
amount the jetty was extended to its full contemplated length of
7,500 feet, a channel 26 feet deep and 271 feet wide (28 feet deep
over a width of 171 feet) was dredged across the outer bar, and a
channel 26 feet deep and 400 feet wide was dredged across the middle
ground. Later the channels through the outer bar and the middle
ground both shoaled to 24 feet deep. The amount expended on this
harbor up to the completion of this project was $625,214.94.
   The work done since the completion of the above project has been
the maintenance of the channel through the outer bar. Under con-
tracts, 15,625 cubic yards at 60 cents per yard and 37,750 cubic yards
816         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                            S. ARMY.

at 51 cents per yard was dredged and dumped at sea. A channel
225 feet wide and 28 feet deep over the east 100 feet and 27 feet deep
over the west 150 feet has been dredged. This channel has since
shoaled to 25 feet depth, which is the maximum draft that could( be
carried into the harbor at mean lower low water to June 30, 1909.
The average height of all high waters above the plane of reference is
4.8 feet. The average of the higher high tides is 5.5 feet.
   From the appropriation of $8,185,750, made by river and harbor
act of March 3, 1909, $30,000 has been allotted for maintaining the
channel through the outer bar. A contract will be entered into at an
early date for dredging 100,904 cubic yards of material at $0.2874
per yard. A channel 200 feet wide and 28 feet deep at mean lower
low water will be excavated.
   The amount expended on this project (maintenance) to June 30,
1909, is $29,866.99. Any additional appropriations for maintenance
will be expended in dredging the channels through the outer bar and
the middle ground.
   The commerce of this harbor was 250,866 tons for the calendar year
1908, a decrease of 3 per cent from that of the previous year. It con-
sists principally of lumber, general merchandise, and ore shipped.
The value of this commerce is estimated to be $11,191,460.
   The coastwise trade is carried in vessels d(rawing from 12 to 20 feet
of water, and is benefited but little by the improvement of the harbor.
The American-Hawaiian steamers, of 8,000 to 10,000 tonnage each,
enter this port once a month. 'These vessels draw about 26 feet of
water and carry 1,000 to 2,000 tons of freight per month for San
Diego. Freight for San Diego carried by the Panama steamers is
delivered by coastwise steamers from San Francisco. The American-
Hawaiian steamers and the Panama steamers have a rate from the
Atlantic ports to San Diego averaging about 30 per cent cheaper than
railroad rates. Foreign cements are received in this port in sailing
vessels drawing 22 and 23 feet of water.
   For references to reports on examinations and surveys, see Annual
Report of Chief of Engineers for the year 1904, page 632, and page
785 of report for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ................         .....................              $306.18
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.......    --...........- .......... .....   ..............      ........   30, 000.00

                                                                                           30, 306. 18
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ..................   ..    .................. ..... ....... .........            34. 85

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................................       30, 271. 33

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 ...... ..............................   ........... 30,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix R R 1.)
  2. Deep water harbor at San Pedro Bay, California.-The river
and harbor act of June 3, 1896, provided for the appointment of a
Board to determine upon the location of a deep-water harbor for
commerce and of refuge in Santa Monica Bay, California, or at San
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     817
Pedro, in the same State, the decision of a majority of the Board as
to location to be final. The Board was to make plans, specifications,
and estimates for said improvement. After the Board should have
rendered its decision and submitted its report the Secretary of War
was empowered to make contracts for the completion of the selected
harbor in accordance with the project of the Board, at a cost not
exceeding in the aggregate $2,900,000.
   In accordance wxith the provisions of this act a Board was appointed,
which submitted its report March 1, 1897, deciding in favor of San
Pedro Bay. The report of the Board is printed in Senate Document
No. 18, Fifty-fifth Congress, first session.
   The plan of the Board (the present project of improvement) was
to construct, to the eastward of Point Fermin, a breakwater about
8,500 feet long, or as much longer as could be constructed within the
authorized limit of cost, 82,900,000,    and it has been decided that a
breakwater 9,250 feet long should be built. In plan the breakwater
is to consist of two straight arms connected by a curve 1,800 feet in
length, of 1,910 feet radius. The westerly arm is to be 3,000 feet long,
pointing S. 72 ° E. (magnetic); the easterly arm, as extended, 4,450
feet long, pointing N. 54 ° E. (magnetic). A gap of about 1,850 feet
is to be left between the east shore of Point Fermin and the westerly
end of the breakwater.
    Originally San Pedro Bay was an open roadstead exposed to south-
easterly, southerly, and southwesterly winds. The effect of the
breakwater will be to afford a place of refuge, easy of access and
secure from storms, for vessels of the largest size. It will also shelter
the entrance to the inner harbor of San Pedro.
   On August 12, 1898. a, continuing contract was entered into with
Ieldmaier & Neu, of Chicago, Ill., for the construction of the break-
water, for $1,303,198.54. This contract was annulled on March 19,
1900, on account of unsatisfactory progress. Under this contract
86,610 tons of stone was placed in the foundation course, at a cost,
including inspection, of $51,537.43.
    On June 7, 1900, a continuing contract for completing the break-
water was entered into with the California Construction Company, of
San Francisco, Cal. The estimated cost of work under this contract,
using the quantities on which bids were convassed and the prices bid
for stone and concrete, and allowing 10 per cent for engineering ex-
penses and contingencies, is $2,613,100.66, in addition to expenditures
under the former contract.    T'his estimate is for a breakwater 8,500
feet long. The extension of the breakwater to 9,250 feet in length is
estimated to cost about $272,500 additional.
  The amount expended under the project up to the close of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909, is $2,726,697.46.
  Work was begun on the westerly end of the substructure. Up to
June 30, 1909, 2,204,909 long tons of stone, at $0.844 per ton, had
been deposited in the substructure under the present contract, and
the substructure was about completed for a distance of 9,174 feet.
Some stone has been dumped 128 feet farther, which is approximately
at the toe of the end slope of the completed breakwater.
  The superstructure was begun in October, 1902. To June 30,
1909, 222,038 long tons of stone had been placed in the superstructure,
at $3.10 per ton, and this, while partially completing it over a length
of 8,884 feet, is equivalent to 8,458 feet of completed work.
      9001-ENG 1909--52
818          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                    S. ARMY.

   The protected area is used by vessels which have to lighter a part
of their cargo or have to await a favorable tide before they can enter
the inner harbor. The effect of continuing work under the existing
project will be to improve the protection of the sheltered area and the
entrance to the inner harbor.
   The authorized cost of the project, $2,900,000, has been appro-
priated. The project is about 97 per cent completed. The available
balance will be expended in building up the breakwater to its full
project height under the contract.
   There are as yet no commercial wharves in the outer, or break-
water, harbor. The construction of bulkheads, etc., has been begun,
but little progress has been made owing to the financial stringency.
It is expected, however, that facilities for commerce will be greatly
developed during the coming year. For commercial statistics see
report on Wilmington Harbor.
   For references to reports on examinations and surveys see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for the year 1904, page 634, and
page 785 of report for 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .. .................................. $285, 871. 90
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.... 100, 000. 00
                                                                                                 385, 871. 90
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement.......................................... ................                           212, 569. 31

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                          173, 302. 59
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....            ..         ..................                27, 414. 38

July 1, 1909, balance available .................................                      .......   145, 888. 21

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .................                           94, 015. 18
   (See Appendix R R 2.)
   3. Wilmington Harbor, California.-Wilmingtonis situated at the
head of a small estuary which has its outlet in the Bay of San Pedro,
and is 393 nautical miles to the southward of San Francisco.
   Previous to the commencement of the improvement, in 1871, there
was a depth of less than 2 feet of water at low tide at the entrance.
   The original project, approved July 1, 1871, contemplated gaining
a depth of 10 feet at mean low tide. This depth was obtained in
1881, at a cost of $555,000, when a further project to increase depth of
channel to 15 feet at mean low tide by dredging a reef between the
jetties, raising existing works, and extending the jetties to 18 feet of
water in San Pedro Bay was submitted. This project was completed
in 1893, at a cost of $399,497.68.
   The river and harbor act of June 3, 1896, appropriated $50,000 for
improving the harbor in accordance with a project submitted in 1894
for a channel depth of 18 feet at mean low tide, at an estimated cost
of $392,725. Owing to certain provisos, however, this money was not
available without further action by Congress.
   The present project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
June 13, 1902, and contemplates providing a channel 20 feet deep and
400 feet wide from the outer harbor to the foot of the wharves, and
24 feet deep between harbor lines from the foot of the wharves to and
including a turning basin 1,600 feet in diameter just below Mormon
Island. It also provides for repairs to the east jetty and for the con-
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                       819
struction of a dike to divert the waters of the Los Angeles River from
Wilmington Lagoon. The same act made available the $50,000 ap-
propriated by the act of June 3, 1896.
   Changed conditions have rendered the building of the dike inad-
visable.
   The original estimated cost of the work called for by the present
project, including the procurement of a dredge, is $550,000. This
estimate has been increased to $663,000. The full amount of the esti-
mated cost has been appropriated.
   The amount expended under the existing project to June 30, 1909,
is $611,194.32, and the project is about 92 per cent completed.
   Repairs have been made to the east jetty at a cost of $3,700.
   A 20-inch suction dredge, with the necessary discharge pipe, float-
ing plant, etc., has been built at a total cost of $118,721.78. The
work of dredging the harbor began April 1, 1905, since which time
3,437,063 cubic yards of material has been dredged and deposited
behind bulkhead lines on Terminal and Smiths islands, or outside the
jetties, at a cost, including deterioration of plant, of $288,066.86, or
about $0.0838 per cubic yard. At the entrance to the harbor 355,785
cubic yards has been dredged under contract at a cost of $168,579.90
 (contract payments only), and between the entrance and the upper
end of the wharves 249,340 cubic yards has been dredged under con-
tract at a cost of $39,894.40.
   The entrance channel has been dredged to a width of 400 feet and
a depth of 21 feet. A channel 400 feet wide, with a least depth of 20
feet, has been dredged from the entrance to the lower end of the
wharves, and dredging to a depth of 25 feet has been done between
the wharves as far north as the turning basin just above Smiths
Island, a distance of about 5,000 feet. This depth of 25 feet, with a
width of 400 feet, has also been carried along the easterly and west-
erly sides of the turning basin, arid a cut 200 feet wide and 25 feet
deep to connect these side channels is being excavated around its
northern periphery.
    From the appropriation of $8,185,750 made by river and harbor
act of March 3, 1909, $20,000 has been allotted for operating govern-
ment plant toward completing the present project, removing any
shoalings that may be found to have occurred, and in caring for and
making repairs to the plant while being laid up awaiting further ac-
tion by Congress.
   For the calendar year 1908 the commerce of this port amounted
to 1,005,697 tons, a decrease of 10 per cent from the preceding year.
It consists principally of lumber, crude oil, and general merchandise
received, and of general merchandise and crude oil shipped. Its
value is estimated at $25,189,300.
   It is difficult to estimate accurately the effect of this improvement
on freight rates. The principal traffic of the harbor is in lumber
received from northern California, Oregon, and Washington, and
shipped inland by rail, and amounts for the calendar year 1908 to
nearly 1,000,000 tons. The water rate on lumber from Puget Sound
points to Los Angeles is about $5 per ton; the railroad rate, $12.50
per ton. Without the improvement of Wilmington Harbor, lumber
would have to be unloaded at exposed piers or brought to San Pedro in
vessels of light draft or lightered ashore. The saving in freight, lighter-
age charges, and insurance is large, but can not be definitely stated.
820           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                               U.    S. ARMY.

  For reference to reports on examinations and surveys, see Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for the year 1904, page 635, and
House Document No. 1114, Sixtieth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                             $117, 031. 92
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...............................-------------------------------------------....-----   20, 000.00
Receipts from sales ..........................................................                            35. 25

                                                                           137, 067. 17
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment...-----------........                                                64, 626. 67
                             ----------...- ----.......................----------...---......
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                             72, 440. 50
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                          1, 753. 72

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                            70, C86. 78

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909............---------...-----............................
                                                ------------------------                           45, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix RR 3.)
   4. San Luis Obispo Harbor, California.-San Luis Obispo Harbor
is 9 miles to the southward and westward of the town of San Luis
Obispo and 216 nautical miles from San Francisco.
   It is a bight of the coast about 18 miles long between Point San
Luis on the north and Point Sal on the south. Port San Luis (for-
merly Port Ilarford) is situated at its upper end, where a commercial
wharf has been maintained for many years. In 1907 commercial
wharves were also built at Avila and at Oilport, just easterly of
Avila. The latter wharf, however, was destroyed shortly after it was
built.
   Whaler reef, extending nearly half a mile to the southward and
eastward of Point San Luis, forms more or less of a natural break-
water, but during the winter season the landing was exposed to the
heavy swell caused by southerly gales.
   The original project was adopted by the river and harbor act of
August 11, 1888, and provided for the construction on Whaler reef of
a breakwater of rubblestone rising to mean lower low water and
extending from Point San Luis to Whaler Island and thence to a
point where the outer reef rises above high water. Exclusive of
Whaler Island, which is 245 feet long, the breakwater was to have a
length of about 1,736 feet, and its estimated cost was $284,898.
    'his project was modified January 17, 1893, to provide for raising
the structure to the height of 6 feet above mean high water, with a
top width of 20 feet and such side slopes as might be formed under
the action of the sea. The estimated cost was increased to $568,660.
This is the existing project.
   The amount expended on this work up to June 30, 1909, is
$321,461.36, and the project is 57 per cent completed.
   There has been placed in the breakwater 146,515 short tons of
stone.
   The breakwater has been built to full section from Point San Luis
to Whaler Island and for 765 feet beyond Whaler Island, and has
been partly built up for 795 feet farther, or a total distance of 2,141
feet, including the island. The partially protected area has an
                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                821

available depth of 20 to 33 feet at mean lower low water and there is
30 feet depth at the Port San Luis wharf. The mean rise of tide is
4.6 feet. The result has been to give increased security to vessels
in the anchorage and at the landing.
   The river and( harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated 863,660
and authorized continuing contracts for the completion of the work
at a cost not to exceed the additional amount of $200,000, of which
$110,000 remains to be appropriated.
   A continuing contract for completing the breakwater has been
entered into which provides for the delivery of 151,140 tons of stone
at $1.57 per ton, the amount necessary to complete the project.
Work was to have been begun May 1, 1908, but on account of the
shoaling of the channels at the quarry at Morro rock and the heavy
seas, no stone was delivered until August, 1908, and only 9,205 tons
until December, when work was suspended during the winter. The
shoaling has since increased so that it is now impossible to get a barge
near enough to the quarry to loa.d it. As this is the only available
quarry authority has been given the contractor to suspend work dur-
ing this working season, or until the channels should deepen suffi-
ciently to permit of the work being resumed.
   Further work under the project will afford increased shelter. The
unexpended balance and the $110,000 yet to be appropriated should
be applied to the extension of the breakwater to its full projected
   I
length and height.
     he commerce consists principally of lumber and general merchan-
dise received and grain and crude oil shipped. Its volume for 1908
is 1,071,469 tons, a decrease of 2 per cent from that of the previous
year. The value of this commerce is estimated at $7,698,024.
   It is impracticable to give definite figures relative to the influence
of the project on freight rates. Z he following, however, may throw
some light on the matter. ' he Union Oil Company pumps crude oil
through a 6-inch pipe from its well in the northern part of Santa
Barbara County, a distance of 40 to 45 miles, to the landing at Port
San Luis, and thence ships it in tank vessels to the Hawaiian Islands
and coast points. The Standard Oil Company also ships oil from this
port. The cost of delivery of oil in San 1Francisco is about 10 cents
per barrel, and the oil is sold there for from $0.90 to $1 per barrel.
The railway rate to San Francisco is about 60 cents per barrel.
   Reference to reports on examinations and surveys will be found in
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for the year 1904, page 636.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....-.............................. $122, 826. 10
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......   30, 000. 00
                                                                                                                       152, 826. 10
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.......................................................                                                           15, 626. 51
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                                                     137, 199.59
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                                                  224, 287. 34
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                                                110, 000. 00
IAmount   that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1,1909------------------------------------------------......................................................   100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
    (See Appendix R R 4.)
822      REPORT OF THE CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS,    U.   S.   ARMY.

EXAMINATION    AND SURVEY MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH               RIVER AND
               HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports dated April 24, 1907, and December 17, 1907, on prelimi-
nary examination and survey, respectively, of Wilmington fIarbor,
California, with a view to obtaining increased depth, required by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, were duly submitted by the
district officer. They were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for
Rivers and Harbors, pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Con-
gress and printed in House Document No. 1114, Sixtieth Congress,
second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of
$420,000 is presented.

   IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE FIRST SAN
             FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA, DISTRICT.

    This district was in the charge of Lieut. Col. John Biddle, Corps
of Engineers, division engineer, Pacific division.
    1. Oakland Harbor, California.-The original condition of San
Antonio estuary was as follows: It was a tidal arm of the Bay of
San Francisco, with a tidal prism of 156,000,000 cubic feet. This
filled and emptied itself with each coming tide. The tidal flow was
sufficient to maintain a natural channel depth over the bar, off the
mouth, of 2 feet at low tide. Within the estuary proper, where the
bends are pronounced, mid-channel depths of 20 to 23 feet at low
water and widths of 500 feet were found. Vessels drawing 5 to 8
feet could enter at high tide. The commerce in 1874 aggregated
154,300 tons.
    The original project was submitted in 1874 in compliance with an
act of Congress. The report, with project and estimate of cost, is
printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1874,
page 378. This project called for (a) two mid-tide training walls at
the entrance, (b) a tidal canal for flushing purposes about 1Z miles
in length to connect with tide water in San Leandro Bay, (c) a dam
at the entrance to San Leandro Bay, and (d) dredging a tidal basin
and then a channel to have a depth of 20 feet from the basin to San
Francisco Bay.    The estimated cost of the work was in round num-
bers $1,815,000.
   This was approved by Congress, and during the progress of the
work slight modifications were made from time to time. These con-
sisted of raising the training walls to full high-tide level; of increas-
ing the width of the tidal canal to 400 feet; of building three steel
bridges across the tidal canal; and of diverting the silt-laden storm
waters of Sausal Creek from the tidal canal by means of a separate
channel into San Leandro Bay.
   The present project was adopted before this project was completed.
Up to and including 1900, $2,450,600 had been expended on the origi-
nal project.
   In the river and harbor act of 1900 Congress provided for an
examination of Oakland Harbor with a view to its improvement west
of the tidal canal to meet the needs of present and prospective com-
merce. Three alternative plans and estimates for channel enlarge-
ment were submitted, estimated to cost, respectively, $646,293,
$1,687,818, and $968,203. This report, with estimates, is printed in
                 iIVER AND I-IARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   823
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1901, pages 3448-
3449.
    On June 13, 1902, Congress appropriated $100,000 and authorized
continuing contracts for $150,000 additional for the work, but failed
to specify to which of the above projects the funds were to be applied.
Contract was made to the extent of the money available and author-
ized for dredging work which was common to all of the above proj-
ects. By act of March 3, 1905, Congress specifically named project
No. 3, estimated to cost $968,203, appropriated $100,000, and author-
ized contracts for $250,000 additional for continuing the improve-
ment with a view to obtaining a channel 300 feet wide and 25 feet
deep from San Francisco Bay to Fallon street, Oakland.
    Project No. 3 calls for a channel from San Francisco Bay, 500 feet
wide and 25 feet deep at low water, to Chestnut street, Oakland;
thence 300 feet wide and 25 feet deep at low water to Fallon street;
thence 300 feet wide and 17 feet deep to tidal basin; thence 300 feet
wide and 12 feet deep around the tidal basin, and extension of south
jetty.
    In the act of March 2, 1907, Congress provided for the project No.
3, as recommended by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors
in report of January 11, 1907, printed in River and Harbor Com-
mittee Document No. 9, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session, but the
act extended the provisions of the project as follows:
     Extension of south jetty 500 feet, widening to 500 feet the channel
25 feet deep from San Francisco Bay to Fallon street, deepening to
25 feet the channel 300 feet wide from Fallon street to the tidal basin,
deepening to 17 feet the channel 300 feet wide around the north side
of the tidal basin to the tidal canal, and from the tidal canal along
the Alameda shore to Tenth avenue. The two preceding paragraphs
cover the final project. The estimate of cost is $1,468,203.
    The work is in progress under the continuing-contract system.
The full appropriation under contract authorization has been made.
In order to complete the improvement directed by Congress, an
additional amount of $500,000 is estimated.
     On June 30, 1909, at mean lower low-tide level, a channel 300 feet
wide and 25 feet deep has been made for a length of 25,000 feet
easterly from deep water in San Francisco Bay to the tidal basin at
Tenth avenue. From the bay to Chestnut street this channel has
a width of 400 feet with a depth of 20 feet in the additional 100 feet
width, and from Chestnut to Castro streets and from Harrison to
Fallon streets the channel has a width of 400 feet with 25 feet depth.
In the tidal basin there is a partly completed channel 300 feet wide,
17 feet deep on the north side from Tenth avenue to Fifteenth avenue,
a distance of 3,200 feet, the balance to the canal being 300 feet wide
and 6 feet deep. On the Alameda side there is a partly completed
channel 300 feet wide, 17 feet deep from Tenth avenue to Willow
street, a distance of 5,300 feet, and the balance to the canal 300 feet
wide and 6 feet deep. The range of the tides is 4.5 to 5.5 feet. The
navigable portion of the channel is about 32,000 feet in length.
Light-draft vessels can go a half mile farther east. The amount
spent on the existing project is $702,006.86. The project is about
haiH; completed.
     The money thus far spent has been practically all for extensions
in channel widths and depths for the benefit of commerce. There
824        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                   S. ARMY.

has been spent for the maintenance of bridges since the adoption
of present project $4,747.79. The sum of $5 has been received
during the year from the sale of an old typewriter. High Street
Bridge was destroyed by fire on May 21, 1909. Repairs will be
undertaken early in the coming year.
   It is difficult to estimate what increase of commerce is likely to
result from an increased depth and width of channel in Oakland
Harbor. At present about 64 per cent of the total tonnage of Oak-
land Harbor is overland freight transferred across the bay on ferry-
boats, which, when loaded with cars, draw only about 8 feet of
water. If improvement be continued it will permit the deeper
dralt vessels carrying to the city of Oakland coal, wood, coke, oil,
hay, grain, flour, lumber, building material, and sundries, which in
1908 amounted to 3,601,871 tons, valued at $142,808,120, and also
should induce a large increase in manufacturing industries on the
shores of this harbor.
   It is believed that the improvement has had no material effect
on freight rates. Passenger rates are 5 cents per trip, while all
other ferries charge 10 cents per trip.
   It is proposed to spend the funds available for dredging in accord-
ance with contract for extension of benefits.
   It is proposed to spend the funds estimated in continuing work
in accordance with project directed by Congress. This will be for
the extension of benefits. The amount asked for as maintenance
it is proposed to use for repairs of bridges and for dredging small
shoals that may develop, particularly at the mouth of the channel.
The original project (lid not provide for maintenance. It has de-
veloped that the bridges have to be maintained and that shoals
develop and must be dredged. This is in part due to the fact that
while the tidal prism remains the same as in the project of 1874, the
size of the channel is largely increased in the present project.
   In connection with this improvement a tidal canal connecting
San Leandro Bay with Oakland Channel was excavated by the
United States. This canal was intended for flushing purposes only
and no provision was made for operation of bridges over it which
are owned by the United States and are provided with draws. A
demand appears to have arisen for the opening of the canal to navi-
gation, as explained in the district officer's report, but the bridges
form an impediment to such use, and he recommends that they be
turned over to the local authorities, who have signified their willing-
ness to accept and operate them.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .......................................  $284, 454. 37
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909.....................................................        15, 000. 00
A mount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909....... 256, 000. 00
Amount received by reimbursement from Isthmian Canal Commission..                14. 21
Amount received from sale of old typewriter .............................         5. 00
                                                                              555, 473. 58
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ............................     $273, 472. 73
    For maintenance of improvement .....................            785. 50
                                                                              274, 258. 23
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...........................      .......     281, 215. 35
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.....................................     28, 416. 27
July 1, 1909, balance available...........................................    252, 799. 08
                    RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                825
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................. $187, 548. 10
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......... 500, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909...........................    ........   315, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix S S 1.)
   2. San Pablo Bay, California.-Before work was commenced there
was a shoal about 27,000 feet long, with a least depth of 19 feet at
low water, with a gradual increase of depth toward each end of the
shoal, where the depth was 30 feet. These depths extended from
1,000 to 1,500 feet in width, and outside of these widths there is a
gradual shoaling to each side of the bay. Ships going to and from
Port Costa warehouses, from which most of the grain raised in Cali-
fornia is shipped, and ships going to and from Mare Island Navy-
Yard, all passed over this shoal. In many cases it was necessary to
choose the time of high water to pass over the shoal with ships not
fully laden. All the commerce passing into and from the Sacramento
and San Joaquin rivers passes over this shoal. No project was
adopted or improvement made prior to the present project.
   Report on examination, with estimate, is printed in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 4260. The project
contemplates a channel 300 feet bottom width, 30 feet depth at low
water, and 27,000 feet long; estimated to cost $381,000, and about
$16,000 per year thereafter for maintenance. Congress adopted this
project on June 13, 1902.
   This work was completed February 6, 1906. A survey made in
April and May, 1907, showed that the channel had shoaled over four-
fifths of its length, this shoaling extending for one-half mile, so as to
give a depth of only 24 feet, and amounting to 1,000,000 cubic yards.
   A survey made in November, 1908, showed a fill above the 30-foot
plane since the dredging was completed of about 1,292,000 cubic
yar(ls, or over five-eighths of total that was dredged from the channel.
   The maximum available depth June 30, 1909, at low title is about
23 feet. The ordinary range of tide is from 3.5 feet to 6 feet.
   The amount expended on this project to June 30, 1909, is
$332,804.52.
   On June 8, 1908, a joint army and navy board appointed to consider
the approach from San Francisco Bay to Mare Island Navy-Yard
submitted to the Secretary of War a project for a channel through
San Pablo Bay 30 feet deep and 500 feet wide. The estimate was
made in connection with the improvement of Mare Island Strait and
can not be separated.
   Improvement is needed to permit naval vessels to reach Mare
Island Navy-Yard at all stages of the tide. It is not required by the
present commerce, and has had no effect on freight rates.
   The funds on hand will be used to make examinations and to dredge
any small shoal places that may develop.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................           ..........   $21, 079. 47
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement............................................................      715.58

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................         20, 363. 89
   (See Appendix S S 2.)
826     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

  3. San Joaquin River, California.-Before improvement the chan-
nel below Stockton was crooked and difficult to navigate, with a depth
of 6 feet and less at low tide. Above Stockton it was navigable only
at high water for a few months of the year and carried but little
commerce.
  The first examination and survey was made in 1875.      (See Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1875, p. 729.) In 1877 (see Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1878, p. 1302) a plan of improvement
was submitted to dredge shoal parts to 6 feet and to cut off sharp
bends. This project was modified from time to time. The present
project is generally to secure and maintain by dredging and by cut-offs
a channel 9 feet deep and 100 feet wide to Stockton, and one 4 feet
deep and 80 feet wide in Mormon Slough up to Miller's warehouse,
as well as a temporary improvement of the upper river by snagging,
dredging of bars, and partial closing of side channels. No definite
estimate has been made for this project. The work done has been
practically the use of such funds as were available to improve the
worst stretches in the river as they developed year by year. Eight
cut-offs have been made below Stockton by the United States and
several by the State of California. The dredged depths and cut-offs
have maintained themselves fairly well in the main river, but it has
been impracticable, on account of the large amount of debris brought
down by Mormon Slough, to maintain without continuous dredging
navigable depths in Stockton channel, which is about 11 miles in
length and on which the city of Stockton is situated.
   The total amount expended on the project up to June 30, 1909,
was $553,142.34.
   Navigation was kept open to Stockton the entire year. This
would, however, not have been possible had not the city of Stockton,
under permit of the War Department, constructed a dam near the
mouth of Mormon Slough, which intercepts temporarily the flow of
the slough, discharging it into the San Joaquin River above the
mouth of Stockton channel, after passing over a wide tract of land on
which most of the material carried is deposited.
   This unfavorable condition at Stockton channel will be largely
remedied by an intercepting canal, which is now under construction.
   The maximum depth that could be carried to Stockton at mean
low tide on June 30, 1909, was about 6 feet. The extreme tidal
range is about 3 feet; the freshet range about 12 feet. The distance
from Stockton to the mouth of the San Joaquin River is about 45
miles. At high water boats go occasionally to Hills Ferry, 150 river
miles above Stockton.
   The commerce of the San Joaquin River is reported by the two
large steamship companies and individual vessel owners as reaching
509,233 tons during the year 1908, valued at $21,716,334, exclusive of
the freight carried by the steam and gasoline launches plying between
Stockton and the many river islands which are under cultivation,
and which carry large amounts of supplies and produce, but of which
no accurate account can be obtained. Nearly all of this freight is car-
ried on the lower San Joaquin River below Stockton, the commerce
of the upper San Joaquin being small.
   The nature of the commerce has not been changed by these im-
provements. The improvements have undoubtedly had effect on
freight rates, though the amount can not be ascertained.
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      827
   Funds appropriated will be used in dredging and snagging for the
extension of benefits.
   On March 7, 1908, in accordance with act of Congress of March 2,
1907, a survey was ordered of this river and its tributary, Stockton
channel, from San Francisco Bay to Stockton, Cal., with a view to a
9, 12, and 15 foot navigation. The recommendation of the Board
of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors as concurred in by the Chief
of Engineers is for a channel 9 feet deep at low water and 200 feet
wide, with provision for two cut-offs and the purchase of certain lands,
so that if commerce develops a channel 15 feet deep and 300 feet
wide may be provided. The estimated cost is $240,000, and $25,000
a year for maintenance. (See House Document No. 1124, Sixtieth
Congress, second session.)
   The amount estimated as required for the fiscal year 1911 will be
used for maintenance of improvement, for dredging any shoal places,
and removing any other obstructions to navigation that may develop.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                                  $1, 733. 06
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 .....................         ............ ..................                          20, 000. 00
                                                                                                       21, 733. 06
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .................. .... ..................................                                    205. 40

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                  21, 527. 66
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909-- . .. . ...-----------------------------------................................... a35, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
l 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix S S 3.)
   4. Stockcton and Mormon channels, California.-The act of June 13,
1902, provided for the diversion of the waters of Mormon Slough
into the Calaveras River. Trhe project is printed in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1899, page 3189. Its estimated
cost was $255,016. The full amount has been appropriated and the
work is under construction. The act of 1902 required the city of
Stockton to furnish the right of way to the United States, which was
done.
   This work is being done under continuing contract appropriations
and the full balance of the authorization has been appropriated.
   This canal will, however, not entirely prevent d6bris from being
carried into Stockton channel from Mormon Slough. The south
bank of this slough above the canal is low and at high water over-
flows. Until this south bank is leveed, part of the high water dis-
charge of Mormon Slough will enter Stockton channel.
   The total amount expended on existing project up to June 30,
1909, is $57,883.30. Of this amount nothing has been spent for
maintenance of improvement and nothing has been received from
any sales, etc.
   During the year work has been carried on under two contracts,
one on the Calaveras section of the diverting canal and the other
  a This amount includes an item of $5,000 for maintenance of Stockton and Mormon
channels after completion of the improvement now in progress.
828          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, UT. S. ARMY.

on the canal section of the diverting canal. The work on the first
section was about four-fifths completed at the end of the fiscal year,
and the latter section was about one-tenth completed. The work
on both sections consists of clamshell dredging, dry work by land
dredges, building levees, embankments, and dams, and also raising
and extending old highway and railroad bridges, and building the
necessary new bridges in the path of the diverting canal.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..............  ....-..............         $222, 360. 31
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......           56, 079. 00
                                                                              278, 439.31
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ..................     .....................................            55, 927. 61
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................         222, 511. 70
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................................          4, 982. 82
July 1, 1909, balance available ........................................      217, 528. 88
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............         152, 877. 06
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance un-
   expended July 1, 1909....................._      ....................         (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix S S 4.)
   5. Mokelumne River, California.-The navigable portion of this
river is a tidal stream emptying into the San Joaquin River. It is
navigable for 20 miles above its mouth, and with its branches or
forks about 14 miles additional. It also connects with other navi-
gable sloughs forming the delta of the San Joaouin and Sacramento
rivers. Regular lines of steamboats go to New Hope Landing, about
14 miles above the mouth. Motor boats go above regularly and
steamboats go occasionally to the New Hope-Gait Bridge to bring in
supplies and take out the crops. Six feet at low tide is found as far
as Snodgrass Slough, 13 miles above the mouth. Above that are
found shoals 3 to 4 feet in depth. The tidal range is about 3 feet.
The difficulties of navigation have been mostly due to snags and over-
hanging trees.
     he first project was made in 1881 for their removal at an estimated
cost of $8,250. (See Annual Report, Chief of Engineers, 1882, p.
2637.) The project was enlarged in 1891 to include, beyond snagging,
the closing of a small canal and removing, by dredging, a tongue of land
opposite New Hope Landing. The estimated cost to put the river in
navigable condition was $7,100. (See Annual Report, Chief of Engi-
neers, 1891, p. 3135.) Appropriations were made in 1892 and 1894,
amounting to $5,000, and the work of closing canal and removing
point was completed. No appropriations were made between 1894
and 1905. Since then the amounts appropriated have been used for
maintenance by snagging, dredging small bars, and cutting off sharp
points. The balance now available will be applied, as above, for
maintenance.
   The total amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909,
was $20,392.24.
                    a See money statement for San Joaquin River, page 827.
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMIENTS.                                                       829
   The improvement has resulted in a reduction of freight rates. There
have been no records kept of the tonnage on this river. It is estimated
by various parties as between 50,000 and 100,000 tons. This is largely
carried by scow schooners on irregular trips. The steamboat company
operating on the river gives the amount of tonnage carried by its
steamers as 25,284 tons, at an estimated value of $1,800,000. The
imports are lumber, coal, live stock, and meichandise; the exports,
grain, flour, fruit, vegetables, and other produce.
   The amount estimated for the fiscal year 1911 will be used on dredg-
ing bars and snagging, for maintenance of improvement.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended--..................     ..................   $2, 625.76
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year for maintenance of im-
  provement ..--....-----........... ...................  ...............   .      18.00

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                                       2, C07. 76
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.....................-------------------------.....------------------.................   2, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix S S 5.)
   6. Petaluma Creek and Napa River, California.-(a) Petaluma
Creek.--his creek has a length of 16 miles and is an estuary of San
Pablo Bay. Its head of navigation is the town of Petaluma, a place
of about 4,000 inhabitants.
   Before improvement it was very crooked, dry in many places at
low tide, and could be navigated only at medium or high-tide stages.
  Project was made in 1880 for straightening the creek by making
cut-offs and dredging so as to obtain a channel 50 feet wide and 3
feet deep at low water, estimated to cost $25,868. (See Annual Re-
port of the Chief of Engineers for 1880, p. 2243.)                                          In 1892 the proj-
ect was extended to dredge the channel as deep as funds would per-
mit. Work has been                      (lone
                             under the project as funds were appro-
priated. The project was enlarged by the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907 (see H. Doc. No. 387, 59th Cong., 1st sess.), to provide
for dredging a channel 6 feet deep at low tide and 50 feet bottom
width from the mouth of the creek to McNears Canal, and 4 feet deep
and 50 feet wide thence to the head of navigation at Petaluma. ' he
additional cost of this work is estimated at $15,239, which was ap-
propriated March 2, 1907.
   Under contract completed October 21, 1908, a channel 50 feet
wide and 6 feet deep, mean low water, was dredged up to McNears
Canal, and 50 feet wide and 4 feet deep to head of navigation at
Petaluma.
   In March, 1909, it was found that, due to heavy floods, the channel
above McNears Canal had shoaled its entire length, and for 1 miles
below the canal had shoaled in several places. , ith funds available
an emergency contract was entered into April 1, 1909, and with
funds subsequently available a second emergency contract was made
May 24, 1909. Under these contracts, which were almost completed
June 30, a channel 3 to 4 feet deep was dredged from the lower part
of Petaluma City to within 2,000 feet of the head of navigation. It
is proposed to continue dredging so as to obtain dimensions of channel
in accordance with approved project in the near future.
830         REPORT OF THE CHIEF                    OF ENGINEERS,      U. S. ARMY.

   In October, 1908, complaint was made of shoaling in San Pablo
Bay across the flats at the entrance to Petaluma Creek. An exami-
nation was made and a survey found necessary to determine the
extent of shoaling. An examination was accordingly made over
an area of 2 miles wide and 5 miles long, and the examination
showed that the original channel across the flats was practically
obliterated, so that there was an available depth in the shoalest part
of only about 22 feet at the mean of lower low water. There is no
project to cover improvement at this place, which, being in San
Pablo Bay and exposed to the winds and waves, will be very costly.
   The maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part is 3 to 4 feet, except the upper
2,000 feet, where the creek is about dry at low water. Navigation is
carried on only at higher stages of the tide. The usual tidal range
is about 8 feet.
   The amounts available and estimated for the fiscal year 1911 will
be used for dredging and snagging, and are for maintenance.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $85,593.61.
   The amount spent on the existing project up to June 30, 1909, is
$17,785.09. Of this amount, $475 has been spent for maintenance
of improvement. Nothing has been derived from sales or other
sources.
   A new transportation line, the Petaluma Transportation Company,
has been established during the year. This company operates the
steamer Resolute between Petaluma and San Francisco.
   The commerce on Petaluma Creek is large.        he statistics have
been carefully collected by the Chamber of Commerce of Petaluma.
There are 2 steamers running regularly the whole year, and 1 for
about five months, besides over 60 schooners making trips more or
less regularly as they find freight. The exports and imports by the
river are given at 155,000 tons, valued at over $8,000,000. Com-
merce by railroad is given as 100,000 tons, valued at $4,500,000. It
is considered that water transportation has aided largely in the
development and prosperity of the contiguous country and has ma-
terially affected freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................... $13, 796. 34
Withdrawn from Napa River and allotted for Petaluma Creek...........     2, 000. 00
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 .....................................................   10,000.00

                                                                                       25, 796. 34
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
   For works of improvement....   .........................             $13, 675. 95
   For maintenance of improvement ......................                     475. 00
                                                                                       14, 150. 95

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                    11, 645. 39
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                  3, 483. 35
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909-.....                                                              (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                       a See consolidated money statement on page 832.
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     831

   (b) Napa River.-Before improvement this river had a low-water
depth of 5 feet for about 12 miles above the Mare Island Navy-Yard
and about 1 foot depth on the crest of the bars in the next 4 miles
of its length to the head of navigation in front of the town of Napa.
The ordinary range of tides is about 5 feet. Spring tides reach a
height of 7 feet.
   Project for the improvement was made in 1888, which contemplated
the dredging of the bars and cutting off projecting points of land so
as to obtain a channel 75 feet wide with a least depth of 4 feet at low
tide and to remove logs, snags, and other obstructions. The esti-
mated cost was $27,600. Examinations were again ordered by Con-
gress and made in 1896, 1899, and 1902. Report on the latter is
printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904,
page 3427.
   Navigation on the river is possible and profitable only at medium
and high stages of the tide. The existing project and old project are
identical.
   Work was begun in accordance with the project in 1889 and has
progressed since whenever funds became available.
   The total amount expended on this improvement to June 30, 1909,
is $37,177.64. Of this amount, $9,577.64 has been spent for main-
tenance of improvement. Nothing has been derived from sales or
other sources.
   ' he only work done during the fiscal year was, removing a large
snag from the draw of the bridge at Napa, and also removing some
old piles and stumps from the river. The total amount spent during
the fiscal year was $123 55.
   The heavy rains and floods of the past winter have caused con-
siderable shoaling in the channel, so that there is now not over 1
foot of water at low water over some of the bars. The exact condition
of the channel is not known and a survey will be necessary to de-
termine the amount of shoaling. Dredging will be necessary in this
channel within the next few months.
    TIhe maximum draft that can be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
low water over the shoalest part is 1 foot.
    The amounts available and estimated for the fiscal year 1911 will
be used for dredging and snagging, and are for maintenance.
   Freight rates are reasonable, due to the maintenance of navigation.
   T'he commerce of Napa River during the year 1908 amounted to
207,880 tons, the value not being given. This commerce was all
carried by the steamers and schooners of one transportation company.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................                                   $4, 875. 27
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...................... ................. .... ............                                 5, 000. 00

                                                                                                          9, 875. 27
                                                          - - .- -.
Withdrawn and allotted to Petaluma Creek, California ..- ....                               . -.... .     2, 000. 00
                                                                                                          7, 875. 27
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement...............---------------------................--------------------------.........--      123. 55
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended                 ... .   . .............        .....   ..........        7, 751. 72
832          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                           U.    S.   ARMY.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909_.-------- ----------         -       ------------- -                      (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                            CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...........---..........................                     $18, 671. 61
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1909 .........................................................                      15, 000. 00

                                                                                              33, 671. 61
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement.............................                     $13, 675.95
    For maintenance of improvement........................                         598. 55
                                                                                              14, 274. 50

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                        19, 397.11
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...------------------------------------------                           20, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix S S 6.)
   7. Humboldt Harbor and Bay, California.-A description and his-
tory of the work done at this locality is printed in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 4237.
   Before improvement the entrance to the harbor was obstructed by
a bar having channel depths of 12 to 15 feet. This channel was not
fixed in direction, and sometimes for weeks at a time vessels were bar
bound. Inside the harbor, in front of the towns of Eureka, Arcata,
and Hookton, the channels were very shoal.
   In 1881 project for deepening the channels in front of these towns
by dredging was adopted. (See Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1881, p. 2481.) The work was done by contract, was com-
pleted in 1884 at a cost of $80,884.69, and resulted in channels 200
feet wide and 12 feet deep in front of Eureka and 100 feet wide and 10
feet deep in front of Arcata and HIookton.
   In March, 1899; project was adopted for dredging a channel 15
feet deep, 200 feet wide, and 8,900 feet long in front of Eureka,
estimated to cost $50,000. Work was done by contract, and a (han-
nel of the dimensions contemplated was completed in March, 1901.
   By act of March 2, 1907, Congress appropriated for a project for
further improvement in accordance with report printed in House
Document No. 228, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session, which con-
templated enlargement of the channel in front of Eureka to a depth
of 18 feet and width of 300 feet for a length of 6,200 feet, at an esti-
mated cost of $83,000. This was completed October 2, 1908.
   In 1882 project for improving the entrance to the harbor was
adopted. It called for a low jetty, estimated to cost $600,000, which
was to be about 6,000 feet in length, to extend from the south spit
seaward. This was somewhat modified in 1888 and again in 1891, so
as to build nearly parallel high jetties, each about 8,000 feet in length,
                       a See consolidated money statement on this page.
                                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            833

to extend seaward to the crest of the bar. The estimated cost of the
work was $2,057,615.
   The work on the jetties was commenced in 1889 and was com-
pleted in August, 1899, at a cost of $2,040,203.35. It resulted in a
good channel, having a least depth of 28 feet at low water. A re-
survey, made in August, 1903, showed a channel through the entrance
having a least low-water depth of 31 feet. Since that time the chan-
nel has deteriorated. A bar has formed outside the entrance whose
longer axis is nearly at right angles to the former jetty channel. The
result is that vessels instead of going straight to sea, as formerly, now
make a sharp turn to the right, broadside to the sea, immediately on
passing the outer end of the north jetty.
   This bar varies in location, and at certain times of the year the
channel goes out nearly straight from the jetties, but with a decreased
depth. In good weather the depth of water in the channel is sufficient
for vessels entering and leaving the harbor. In rough weather it is
dangerous and difficult.
   The total amount expended on this work to June 30, 1909, is
$2,261,662.99. Of this amount, $83,000 has been spent for improve-
ment on the present project for the channel in front of Eureka.
Nothing has yet been spent for maintenance on this project. The
sum of $6 has been received from sale of unserviceable articles and
deposited to credit of the appropriation.
   On June 30, 1909, the depth of water at the entrance to the harbor
is about 20 feet at extreme low water. At the wharves at Eureka it
is about 181 feet. To Arcata the channel in shallowest part has
about 9.5 feet low water. There is no navigation to Hookton at
present. The tidal range is about 5.5 feet.
   Since the improvement the population of Eureka and vicinity has
increased from 7,000 to about 16,153 persons. The commerce has
increased. Deeper-draft vessels and more of them now run regu-
larly to Humboldt Bay.
   The following table shows the increase in the annual commerce
since 1885:

                                                     Passen-     ight.                                                Passen-   Freight.
                                                      gers.                                                            gers.

                                                               Tons.                                                             .Tons.
1885............                  ............         4,195   162, 614   1906-       --....... ...............        35,423     706,549
1895 ..........................                       11,514   236,378    1907-------.... ---------...---....
                                                                                                         ..........    32,617     834,634
1905 ..      ---..........         ..... ...... ..    32,748   616,753    1908..........................               31,537     601, 787



   The commerce for 1908 was about 500,000 tons exports, valued at
$8,678,000, and 104,000 tons imports, valued at $4,363,000. There is
a considerable decrease over the tonnage of 1907, which was given as
a total of about 834,000 tons. This is due largely to the dull state of
the redwood lumber market, which has affected all business. The
principal article of export is lumber, and of import, general merchan-
dise. The number of passengers was about 30,000. This will, of
course, decrease when a railroad is completed-to Eureka.
   A feature of the commerce is the increasing amount of lumber sent
to foreign ports and Hawaii. This amounted to 80,000 tons, carried
in 43 vessels.
             9001-ENG 1909-53
834             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                          U.    S. ARMY.

  The improvements have undoubtedly lessened freight rates in that
they have allowed larger vessels to enter harbor and decreased delays
due to the bar.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ..-...........................                                              . $91, 612. 80
Received from sale of augers, etc......................................                                                6. 00
                                                                                                                  91, 618.80
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..----------.........-------... -------.................--------........-------.............----------...   82, 666.79

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                              8, 952.01
    (See Appendix S S 7.)
  8. Removing sunken vessels or craft obstructing or endangering navi-
gation.-Duringthe month of August, 1908, the wreck of a clam-shell
dredge (no name) was removed from Sycamore Slough, a tributary of
the south fork of Mokelumne River, California, at a cost of $150.
   (See Appendix S S 8.)

EXAMINATIONS               AND SURVEYS MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
                          HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

    Reports on preliminary examinations and surveys required by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities within
this district were duly submitted by the district officer. They were
reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant
to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in documents as
indicated:
    1. Preliminary examination and survey of Suisun Channel, or Creek,
California.-Reportsdated March 18, 1908, and August 24, 1908, re-
spectively, are printed in House Document No. 1110, Sixtieth Con-
gress, second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost
of $25,000 is presented.
    2. Preliminary examination and survey of San Francisco Harbor,
California,with a view to removal of certain rocks.-Reports dated June
18, 1907, and September 22, 1908, respectively, are printed in House
Document No. 1119, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for
improvement at an estimated cost of $170,000 is presented.
    3. Preliminary examination and survey of San Joaquin River, Cali-
fornia, and its tributary, Stockton Channel, from San Francisco Bay to
Stockton.-Reports dated July 25, 1907, and October 6, 1908, respec-
tively, are printed in House Document No. 1124, Sixtieth Congress,
second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of
 $240,000 is presented.

EXAMINATION               AND SURVEY MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER AND
                          HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 3, 1909.

   Report dated March 31, 1909, on preliminary examination of
Feather River, California,from the mouth to Marysville, required by
the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, was duly submitted by a
Board of Engineers. It was reviewed by the Board of Engineers for
Rivers and Harbors, pursuant to law, and was transmitted to Con-
gress and printed in fouse Document No. 76, Sixty-first Congress,
                                  RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                             835
first session. The locality is not considered worthy of improvement
by the General Government in the interests of navigation
IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE SECOND SAN FRAN-
               CISCO, CALIFORNIA, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the immediate charge of Capt.Thos. H. Jackson,
Corps of Engineers, under a Board of Engineers appointed pursuant
to the provisions of act of Congress approved June 3, 1896. Divi-
sion engineer, Lieut. Col. John Biddle, Corps of Engineers.
   Sacramento and Feather rivers, California.-The first appropria-
tion by Congress was "for the improvement of the Sacramento and
Feather rivers, California." This appropriation was made March
3, 1875. At that time, due largely to the consequence of hydraulic
mining, the depth on some of the bars in the Sacramento River in
the 61 miles between its mouth, at Collinsville, and the city of Sacra-
mento was but 4 feet, as compared with the depth of 7 feet which
had previously existed. From Sacramento to Colusa, 91 miles, the
stream was in favorable condition for navigation by boats drawing
about 3 feet of water, but in the 110 miles from Colusa up to Red
Bluff navigation was, as it is yet, difficult at numerous places on
account of its changing and crooked channels, easily eroded banks,
bars, and rapids. Many snags are also brought into this portion of
the stream annually by high water. The bed of the Feather River
had also been so filled up with debris from the hydraulic mines drain-
ing into it and its tributaries that navigation in the 30 miles between
its mouth in the Sacramento and the head of navigation, at Marys-
ville, was practicable during the higher stages only, usually extend-
ing from December to June. The same is true at the present time.
   The present project for improvement (Reports of Board of Engi-
neers printed in the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for
1898, pp. 2944-2945, and for 1899, pp. 3171-3181) as adopted by the
act of Congress approved March 3, 1899, and by subsequent acts,
provides for obtaining and maintaining the following-named channel
depths in the Sacramento River, by continuing the work of remov-
ing snags and other obstructions, and by the construction of wing
dams to concentrate the flow at shoal places, at an estimated first
cost of $280,000 and an annual expense of $25,000:

                                                                                                                        Least chan-
                                                                                                                        nel depth
                          From-                                                To-                             Miles.    to be ob-
                                                                                                                        tained and
                                                                                                                          main-
                                                                                                                         tained.


                                                                                                                           Feet.
Mouth of river at Collinsville ...............         Sacramento-.....                     ..............         61              7
Sacramento ..              .........................   Colusa...       ...... ....................                 91              4
Colusa......................................           Red Bluff.........---- ..---- ...--------.....-----..      110              3
        Total........................................-------------------------------------                        262


   At the time the reports of the Board of Engineers above referred
to were submitted the permanent improvement of the Feather River
was not contemplated until the flow of sand and other mining detritus
from the Yuba, Bear, and other tributaries should be stopped or the
836          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                     S. ARMY.

commercial interests involved became greater. Several appropria-
tions have since been made, however, for the improvement of both
the Sacramento and Feather rivers.
   The sum of $943,286.62 was expended up to June 30, 1909, on both
streams in the construction of wing dams, construction and operation
of a snag boat and a snag scow, and the closing of several extensive
breaks in the levees.
   The expenditures have resulted in obtaining and maintaining the
projected channel depths in the Sacramento from its mouth up to
Colusa, and channel depths of 2 to 2- feet from Colusa up to Red Bluff.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909,
were for removing snags, cutting overhanging trees, dredging a
channel through a bar about 3 miles below the city of Sacramento,
and repairs to a snag boat.
   The following statement shows the present conditions for purposes
of navigation of the Sacramento and Feather rivers:

                                              Sacramento River.                           Feather River.

Maximum draft that can be          San Francisco to Sacramento, 7 feet; Sac-        Mouth of river to Marysville,
carried at low water.               ramento to Colusa, 4 to 5 feet; Colusa to       1 to 2 feet.
                                     Red Bluff, 2 to 2 feet.
Head of navigation      -......... Red Bluff................................ ....   Marysville.
Length, in miles, of naviga- Mouth to Sacramento, 61 miles; mouth to                Mouth to      Marysville,   30
ble portions.                       Colusa, 152 miles; mouth to Red Bluff,          miles.
                                     262 miles.



   The extreme variation of level of water surface at Red Bluff is
about 22 feet, at Collinsville about 8 feet. Tidal influence extends
up the Sacramento River to about the city of Sacramento.
   The Sacramento River is important as the means for transporting
both freight and passengers, steamboats plying regularly all the year
round between San Francisco and Colusa, 202 miles, and during
about seven months of each year (December to June) between San
Francisco and Red Bluff, 310 miles. The Feather River is navigated
at irregular times by light-draft steamboats from its mouth up to
Marysville.
   The freight carried on the Sacramento River during the year end-
ing December 31, 1908, was approximately 425,000 tons, consisting
principally of general merchandise and fruit upstream, and grain,
fruit, vegetables, cord wood, and brick downstream. Approximately
150,000 passengers were carried during the past year. The average
tonnage for the past thirteen years has been about 425,000. The
maximum tonnage carried was in 1892, when it amounted to 579,574
tons.
   Extensive areas of the land along the Sacramento River are under
a high state of cultivation. Practically all of the territory along the
river is dependent entirely upon the stream as a means of transpor-
tation for passengers and freight. In some instances the lower rates
of the steamboat lines are met by railroads between the few points
where the two meet in competition. Several new steamboat lines,
both freight and passenger, were established during the past year.
The traffic on the Sacramento is now handled by 41 steamboats, 50
gasoline boats and launches, and 36 barges, and, in the lower portions
of the stream, by a number of gasoline and sail schooners.
                        RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             837

   The existing project as adopted by Congress contemplates that
the sum of $25,000 will be provided annually for the improvement of
the Sacramento and Feather rivers. The $30,000 mentioned in the
appended money statement as a profitable expenditure in fiscal year
ending June 30, 1911, is necessary, in addition to the balance unex-
pended on June 30, 1909, to remove snags, bars, and other obstruc-
tions to navigation.
   More extended information concerning the Sacramento and
Feather rivers and their tributaries may be found in the document
and reports referred to in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1908 (pt. 1, p. 861) and in House Document No. 1123,
Sixtieth Congress, second session.
   Much of the country along a considerable portion of the Sacra-
mento, Feather, and San Joaquin rivers and their tributaries is sub-
ject to widespread overflow during the winter and spring months of
each year, the streams being unable to carry off the rainfall in the
valleys and foothills and the melting snow in the mountains. Unre-
stricted hydraulic mining in earlier years has contributed largely to
the difficulty by filling up the beds of the streams.
   The interests of navigation, the problem of flood control, and the
control and disposition of mine d6bris are all inseparably connected.
These matters are in charge of the California Debris Commission, and
that commission, in a report dated June 30, 1907 (printed in the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, pp. 2262-2269),
in which the various questions are considered, states that dredging
is considered the only feasible method of treatment.
                              SACRAMENTO      AND FEATHER RIVERS.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....................................                       $19, 693. 69
Amount received from sales...........................................                             30. 50
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909....--.......................                 ................ .. ........ . 25, 000. 00
                                                                                              44, 724. 19
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment...................................................................                     19, 724. 19

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                        25, 000. 00

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project...... Indeterminate.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909.........       ............... .... .... 30, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                         SACRAMENTO RIVER.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended...................................... $18, 658. 24
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment...............................................................    13, 123. 77

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...........................................                    5, 534. 47
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                     2, 673. 37

July 1, 1909, balance available................................                    ....   .    2, 861. 10

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts.................                         2, 861. 10
   (See Appendix T T.)
838     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,          U.   S.   ARMY.


EXAMINATION    AND SURVEY MADE       IN COMPLIANCE      WITH    RIVER AND
              HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2,          1907.
   Reports dated August 6, 1907, and October 10, 1908, on exam-
ination and survey, respectively, of Sacramento River, California,from
its mouth to Feather River, required by the river and harbor act of
March 2, 1907, were duly submitted by the district officer. They
were reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors,
pursuant to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in
House Document No. 1123, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A
plan for improvement at an estimated cost of $67,000 is presented.

IMPROVEMENT      OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE FIRST PORT-
                     LAND, OREGON, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Lieut. Col. S. W. Roessler, Corps
of Engineers, division engineer, northern Pacific division, to July 11,
1908, and of Maj. J. F. Mclndoe, Corps of Engineers, since that date,
having under his immediate orders Capt. Arthur Williams, Corps of
Engineers, since January 11, 1909. Division engineer, Lieut. Col.
John Biddle, Corps of Engineers, temporarily.
   1. Coquille River, Oregon.-The Coquille River rises in the Coast
Range and empties into the Pacific Ocean at Bandon, Oreg., about
375 miles north of San Francisco. Before improvement the channel
at the mouth skirted the south headland for some distance, as shown
on map opposite page 2682 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1882, and was shoal, shifting, and studded with dan-
gerous rocks. The depth over the bar was usually about 3 feet at
low tide and was available only for small coasting vessels.
   The original project for improvement was adopted in 1878, and
provided for the construction of two converging, high-tide jetties,
built of rubblestone, 800 feet apart, so located as to cause the river to
empty into the sea about one-half mile north of the original mouth
of the river, these jetties to run out to sea a sufficient distance to
create and maintain a channel 12 feet deep at low tide. In 1880 the
proposed depth of 12 feet at low tide was reduced to 10 feet; in 1888 it
was reduced to 8 feet, and under date of May 8, 1891, the plan was
changed to provide that the jetties should be 600 feet apart at their
outer ends instead of 800 feet.
   The amount expended on original and modified projects, prior to
operations under existing modified project, was $144,323.42, including
$6,883.90 for snagging and $15,000 for repairs and maintenance.
   The above changes, and the limitation of the length of the south
jetty to 2,700 feet and of the north jetty to 1,575 feet, by the act of
July 13, 1892, constitutes the latest approved project. The esti-
mated cost of the whole project, when completed, not including
expenditures for maintenance, was $306,200.
   The amount expended on the revised project to the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $206,063.22, of which amount
approximately $40,661.06 was applied to maintenance.
   The work accomplished during the year was the extension of the
north jetty to its projected length of 1,575 feet. The tramway was
extended seaward for a farther distance of 135 feet, and 8,587 tons of
                             RIVER AND HARBOR                   IMPROVEMENTS.                                                   839

stone were dumped into the jetty. Since the completion of the work
expenditures were applied to maintenance.
   The approved project is completed. There is now a channel of 10
feet at low water and of sufficient width to accommodate the small
coasting vessels which use it. The tide rises about 4.2 feet at Bandon,
near the mouth, and coasting vessels can ascend the stream to Coquille
City, about 25 miles above Bandon. Above Coquille City the chan-
nel is available for smaller craft for a farther distance of 12 miles, or
to Myrtle Point. Logging is carried on extensively on the head-
waters for distances of 30, 26, and 18 miles above Myrtle Point on the
north, south, and middle forks, respectively.
   The freight is loaded on small coasting vessels along the 25 miles
between Bandon and Coquille City, and is usually taken to San
Francisco. The total imports and exports during the calendar year
amounted to 68,426 tons, valued at $1,375,938. The exports consist
principally of lumber, live stock, and farm products, and the imports
of general merchandise, machinery, etc.
   The improvement accomplished increases the carrying capacity of
vessels and has the effect of reducing freight rates on all shipments,
as the ocean is the only available means of transporting the products
to market.
   No additional work is necessary to make the improvement avail-
able, and as the above project is completed no funds are required
therefor. The available balance will be applied to care of plant and
maintenance. A new project is printed as House Document No. 399,
Sixtieth Congress, first session, and if adopted the whole amount of
$27,840 should be appropriated.
   For further information as to the original and modified project,
reference is invited to the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1879, page 1806; 1892, page 2664; and 1897, page 3380. A report
of survey of 1907 is printed as House Document No. 399, Sixtieth
Congress, first session.
                                      Comnnparative statement of trafic.


        Calendar year.              Tons.           value               Calendar year.                           Tons.     Est.ed


1899................... ....        26,654    ...........    1904.....................                           60,944     $1,322,058
1900...............        ......   30,727     ..........    1905.....................                           45,455      1,105,750
1901 .....................          32,975   .............   1906..................                              67,288      1,119,716
1902 .....................          37,458   ...........     1907......             ...........          ....    60,504      1,367,634
1903 .....................          48,249                   1908.....................                           68,426      1,375,938



July 1, 1908, balance unexpended                .....................                             ............           $31, 013. 68
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement .............................                                            $25, 700. 00
    For maintenance of improvement. ....... .                         ........              .              700. 32
                                                                                                                          26, 400. 32

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                                                        4, 613. 36
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...............................                                                          55. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available ..................................                                                         4, 558.36
    (See Appendix U U 1.)
840      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S.   ARMY.

   2. Entrance to Coos Bay and Harbor, Oregon.-Coos Bay is a tidal
estuary on the Pacific coast, in Oregon, about 180 miles south of the
Columbia River: Next to Humboldt Harbor, in California, it is the
principal harbor between the mouth of the Columbia River and San
Francisco. Before improvement there was a channel across the bar
often of no greater depth than 10 feet at low water, and under the influ-
ence of the northwesterly winds and shifting sands the channel was
unstable and followed the west side of the north spit in a tortuous
course. At that time it was used by small coasting vessels.
   The original project was approved by the Secretary of War Novem-
ber 24, 1879, and provided for the construction of a jetty from a point
about 250 yards below Fossil Point on a line toward the east end of
Coos Head, the structure to be of wood and stone, or stone, as should
be found best. A total of $213,750 was expended on this project, and.
1,760 feet of jetty were constructed.
   The project now in force for increasing the bar depth to 20 feet was
adopted by act of Congress approved September 19, 1890. The esti-
mated cost was $2,466,412, and provided for the construction of a
north jetty 9,600 feet long, and a slightly converging south jetty 4,200
feet long.
   The expenditures on the present project to the end of the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909, amounted to $702,547.56, of which
$177,548.12 was for maintenance. In addition to this upward of
$50,000 has been expended on the inner harbor for a low-water depth
of 12 feet to the town of Marshfield. The amount derived from sales,
etc., is $264.04.
   No active operations were in progress under the project for jetty
construction during the year. The plant used during construction
was cared for, and during March and April the work of planting
Holland grass roots on the North spit for its reclamation was carried
on, a total of about 53 acres being planted.
   The commercial interests of Coos Bay raised a fund of $21,270.41,
with which the U. S. dredge Oregon was towed from Portland to Coos
Bay and operated from October 13, 1908, to April 30, 1909. Approx-
imately 320,000 cubic yards of material were dredged during that
time.
   Dredging with available balance of former appropriation, which
work was authorized by the act of March 3, 1909, was carried on from
May 1 to the end of the fiscal year, a total of approximately 90,000
cubic yards being removed from the shoals in the vicinity of Marsh-
field.
   This dredging has increased the depth over a part of the shoals, and
has been a great benefit to the boats using the channel from the bar
entrance to Marshfield.
   The project depth of 20 feet was obtained in 1894, when the north
jetty had been extended to a length of 9,520 feet. The south jetty
has therefore not been built, and the improvement has been made at
a fraction of the estimated cost. It has resulted in a permanent
channel of from 17 to 22 feet depth at mean low tide, close to and
parallel with the north jetty. The variation of the water levels on
account of the tide is about 4.8 feet. Ocean-going vessels ascend the
bay to the town of Bay City, immediately above Marshfield, and
about 14 miles from the mouth, above which point there is about 50
                               RIVER AND             HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                     841

miles of available navigation for boats of light draft. The logging
industry is very extensive, and is carried on throughout the whole
year, large quantities of logs being floated from the headwaters to the
mills along the bay.
    The principal products are coal, lumber, farm and dairy products,
live stock, woolen goods, and salmon. During the calendar year 1908
this amounted to 176,239 tons, valued at $3,161,015. The imports,
consisting of farm and mill machinery and miscellaneous merchandise,
amounted to 40,392 tons, valued at $3,916,125.
    The bay and ocean form the only means of transporting products
to outside markets, and the improvement has the effect of increasing
.the carrying capacity of vessels using the channel, with a consequent
decrease in freight rates.
    No additional work is proposed or necessary under the above
project.
    Further work at this locality will depend upon the action by Con-
gress on the new plan of improvement published in House Document
No. 958, Sixtieth Congress, first session, which provides for securing
such additional depth at the bar entrance as can be secured and main-
tained by dredging and without further jetty construction and for
the excavation of a channel within the bay 18 feet deep at mean lower
low water up to the town of Marshfield by means of the dredge Oregon.
Of this new work the further dredging of the inner channel is con-
sidered of primary importance. It is recommended that any pro-
vision made for the adoption of this new project carry with it a total
appropriation and authorization of not less than $400,000, $50,000 of
this to be applied to the operation within the bay of the dredge
Oregon and contingencies, and $350,000 to the purchase or construc-
tion of a new hydraulic seagoing dredge for work at the entrance and
the necessary operating and contingent expenses. Of the total
amount, $150,000 may be provided in the form of a contract authori-
zation to be carried in the sundry civil act which will be approved not
later than March 4, 1911.
    For reports on examinations and surveys reference is invited- to
the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1879, page 1791, and
1890, page 2936.
                                         Comparative statement of traffic.


              Calendar year.           Tons.          timated                     Calendar year.               Tons.     Estimated
                                                     value.                                                                value.

1899...................        .....   116,567   .   .   ..     ..   1904........................              136,958     3,557,984
1900 ....................              104,294 ............1905........................                        178,945     3,901,906
1901 ..... .................
1902........................
                                        97,500 ............1906.. .......
                                       122,232........
                                                                                   . ..
                                                      . . 1907........................
                                                                                                    .......    184,455
                                                                                                               167,562
                                                                                                                           5,900,017
                                                                                                                           6,400,000
1903........................                            . 1908........................
                                       135,178 --..........-                                                   216,631     7,077,140


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................... $23, 831. 05
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
                                                                          4, 115. 13
  improvement.............----------...........----------------------------

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..-................................. 19, 715.92
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.................................. .. 3, 900. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available-                 ....................                               ...............      15, 815. 92
       (See Appendix U U 2.)
842     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

  3. Coos River, Oregon.--Coos River is the principal tributary of
Coos Bay and empties into the bay at its head, opposite the town of
Marshfield. At a point 5" miles from its mouth the river divides
into two branches, known as the "North" and "South" forks, up
each of which tidal influence extends for about 8 miles. Before
improvement was commenced the small light draft-steamboats and
launches plying between Marshfield and the head of tide on each fork
experienced considerable difficulty in navigating on account of the
many snags, bowlders, etc., in the stream.
   The original and existing plan of improvement, based on the sur-
vey made in 1894 (Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1895,
pp. 3502-3505) proposed the removal of all snags and bowlders from
a selected channel, 50 feet in width, in the main river and on both the
North and South forks to the head of navigation. The estimated
cost was $5,000, but in 1898 it was stated in the annual report that
$3,000 additional would be required to complete the project, and in
1900 it was estimated that an appropriation of $1,500 every two
years would be required for maintenance.
   The amount expended on the project to June 30, 1909, was
$14,336.30, of which $6,336.30 has been applied to maintenance.
   No .work was done during the fiscal year, as the channel was in
fairly good condition and sufficient funds were not available to war-
rant repairing and putting the plant into commission.
   The project may be considered as completed, and the work done
has resulted in a safer and better channel for the small craft plying
the stream. The maximum draft that can be carried at low tide
over the upper reaches is about 1 feet. The range of tide is about
21 feet, so that boats drawing 4 feet navigate to the head of tide water
on both the North and South forks, a distance of about 14 miles above
the mouth. Logging from the extensive forests along the upper
reaches of this stream is one of the main industries, and the logs are
floated down to the booms in the lower reaches of the river and towed
to the mills along the bay.
   The valley is very fertile, and the commerce is mostly farm and
dairy products, logs, and lumber. The produce is carried in small
steamers to Marshfield, where it is loaded in ocean steamers and taken
to the San Francisco and Portland markets. This traffic amounted
during the calendar year 1908, including supplies, machinery, etc.,
received, to 36,697 tons, valued at $1,679,161.
   The maintenance of the improvement is a benefit to navigation,
and is essential to the economical and safe operation of steamboats.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure is for the pur-
pose of snagging and dredging for maintenance of the improvement,
and will be so applied.
   For reports on examinations and surveys reference is invited to
the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1893, page 3437,
and 1895, page 3502.
                                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                         843
                                      Comparative statement of traffic.


         Calendar year.             Tons.    Estiaed             Calendar year.           Tons.Estimated
                                              value.                                                 value.


1899....--..--..............--      a 70,007..........     1904..--------------------.    49,907 $1,033,758
1900......-..................b229,225 ............1905...                      44,398                1,179,974
1901........................   62,402-....        1906..--------------------. 35,537                 1,246,684
1902....................       46,000 ........... 1907------------------------ 42,073                1,613,948
                       28,109 ....
1903.........................                     ......   1908..........   ...........   36,697     1,79,161

  a Includes 21,852 tons of stone for the government jetty at the entrance to Coos Bay, Oregon.
  b Includes 170,400 tons of stone for the government jetty at the entrance to Coos Bay, Oregon.
  c Approximate.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................                            $1, 663. 70
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......................................                             1, 663.70
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 19090................................................                              3, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix U U 3.)
   4. Tillamook Bay and bar, Oregon.-Tillamook Bay is an inden-
tation of the Oregon coast, about 6 miles long and about 3 miles
wide, and lies about 50 miles south of the entrance to the Columbia
River. At low tide the bay inside the bar is a succession of sand and
mud flats, separated by several channels, which shoal to a low-tide
depth of about 1 or 2 feet. The bar at the entrance to the bay has
a controlling channel depth, generally, of about 14 feet at mean low
tide. Vessels drawing from 14 to 15 feet can reach Hobsonville, on
the north channel, a short distance inside the entrance. Originally
the controlling high-water depth between the ocean and the town
of Tillamook, on Hoquarten Slough, 12 miles from the entrance, did
not exceed 7 or 8 feet.
   The original project for the improvement was adopted by the river
and harbor act of August 11, 1888, and provided for a survey of
the entrance, and for the improvement of Dry Stocking bar and
Hoquarten Slough, by the building of pile dikes, at an estimated
cost of $5,200. The total amount expended on this project was
$5,700.
   The existing project adopted by the act of July 13, 1892, provided
for connecting the north and middle channels nearly opposite Bay
City, putting in dikes at Junction and Dry Stocking bars, and con-
templated a least depth of 9 feet at mean high tide from Hobsonville
to Tillamook City. The estimated cost was $100,000.
   The amount expended on the existing project at the close of the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $120,110.34, of which amount
$47,636.97 was applied to maintenance. There was received from
sales the sum of $20.
   Snagging and dredging operations were in progress during the sum-
mer and fall of 1908, were commenced again in June, and are still
in progress, with a view to maintaining the projected depth of 9 feet
to Tillamook City.
   All of the work contemplated by the project has been completed,
and, except as shoals are formed by each freshet, boats have experi-
enced little difficulty in reaching Tillamook City at high tide on a
 844         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                  U.     S. ARMY.

draft of 9 feet. The average range of tide is 6.2 feet. The head of
navigation for ocean-going vessels is at Tillamook City, about 12
miles from the entrance.
   Lumbering is one of the chief industries, and logging is extensively
carried on, most of the tributaries of Tillamook Bay being utilized
as a means of floating the logs down to tide water.
   The commerce on Tillamook Bay consists of lumber and dairy
products shipped to Portland and San Francisco, and general mer-
chandise brought in by coasting vessels. During the calendar year
this traffic amounted to 19,400 tons, valued at $1,098,990.
   There is no railroad connection with Tillamook Bay, but construc-
tion has been started on a projected line beginning at Hillsboro, just
west of Portland, and which is intended to connect the Southern
Pacific with a terminus on Tillamook Bay.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure is for mainte-
nance by dredging and snagging, and the work is necessary to make
the improvement available for vessels drawing 9 feet at high tide.
   For reports on examinations and surveys, attention is invited
to Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1888, page 2150;
1892, page 2742; 1898, page 3007; and 1903, p. 2239. The report
of survey made in 1907 is published as House Document No. 965,
Sixtieth Congress, first session.
                                  Comparative statement of trafic.


       Calendar year.            Tons.      Estied
                                            Esuied            Calendar
                                                              ce.      year                   Tons.Estimated
                                                                                                       value.




1899.......................      36,835 ............   1904...      ..................        13,823     $658,489
1900 ....................        17,640 ...........    1905......................             13,919       696,760
1901.........................    21,147 ...........    1906...          ..................    13,627       850,240
1902 .....................       24,883 ......         1907.... .................             22,917     1,246,710
1903.......................      16,862 ...........    1908.....................              19,400     1,098,990


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................            $2, 480. 83
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909 .................     ......................           ..........  5, 000. 00

                                                                                                       7, 480. 83
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement---.........---------.....................................                                2, 571.17

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                                  4, 909. 66
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..........................................                       2, 176. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available_....................                           ............            2, 733. 66
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909....--........ ...........--...............-         10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix U U 4.)
  5. Improving the various harbors on the coasts of Oregon and Wash-
ington by the construction and equipment of a dredging plant for use
thereon.-The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated
$100,000 for the construction of this dredging plant, and a contract
was entered into under date of January 24, 1908, for the construction
                           RIVER AND           HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                    845

of an 18-inch hydraulic dredge in accordance with plans and speci-
fications. The contract price was $79,340, not including equipment.
The total cost of the dedge was finally increased by the purchase of
equipment and extra parts to the full $100,000 appropriated. The
dredge hull is 120 feet long, 36 feet wide, and 11 feet deep. The
dredge was finished and turned over to the United States by Sep-
tember 10, 1908, and named Oregon. The amount expended on con-
struction of this dredge was $98,502.58.
   There being no government funds available for the operation of
the dredge, and dredging being very essential in the inner harbor of
Coos Bay, commercial interests in that vicinity petitioned the depart-
ment for permission to use the dredge in deepening the channel up to
the town of Marshfield. Permission was granted to use the dredge
without expense to the United States, and the dredge was towed to
Coos Bay and commenced operations in October.
   In crossing the bar at the entrance to Coos Bay some damage was
caused to the smokestacks and rigging, and after arrival at North
Bend she settled on a submerged pile, at low tide, and sunk. She
was afterwards raised, with some difficulty, and repaired.
   The dredge has proven a very capable and satisfactory piece of
plant. Details of her operations will be found in the report for im-
proving entrance to Coos Bay and Harbor.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended---...-----........-------....-------...---..........--------...  $65, 539. 73
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment----.....-----------------------------------------.......--............ .--------..........  64, 042.31

                                                                     .........
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....-------------------------......------.                       1,497.42
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities........----.........-----------------------.....---......    1, 497. 42
    (See Appendix U U 5.)
   6. Snake River, Oregon, Washington, and Idaho.-The portion of
the river under improvement extends from its junction with the
Columbia to Pittsburg Landing, a distance of about 216 miles. The
upper portion runs through a mountainous country and is much
obstructed by gravel shoals, ledges of bed rock, bowlders, and
numerous rapids. The country through which the river passes,
between Riparia and its mouth, is more open, but navigation is
difficult, owing to the swift current and numerous rapids. Some of
the channels through the rapids are narrow and crooked, and before
improvement were practically impassable at low water, owing to the
rocky ledges, gravel shoals, and bowlders. The Snake and Columbia
rivers, in early days, formed the natural highway for the traffic between
the inland empire and the Pacific coast, and navigation on the Snake
River, notwithstanding the difficulties, continued until the comple-
tion of the railroad to Riparia in 1882, after which boats abandoned
the river below that point.
   A detailed description of the river prior to, and during, the early
years of improvement will be found in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1880, page 2293, and 1891, page 3212.
   In 1877 a project was approved for removing reefs and bowlders
and for scraping gravel bars in the Columbia and Snake rivers
between Celilo, Oreg., and Lewiston, Idaho, a distance of 263 miles,
at an estimated cost of $132,000. Since 1882 operations on the Snake
River have been confined to the stretch above Riparia. In 1892 the
846     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U.   S. ARMY.

project was extended to include the improvement of the 7 miles of
river between Lewiston, Idaho, and Asotin, Wash., and the act of
June 13, 1902, further provided for extending the improvement to
Pittsburg Landing. The project now provides for completing and
maintaining the improvement between Lewiston and Riparia, with
a view to obtaining a low water depth of 5 feet, by means of blasting,
dredging, raking, and by contraction works, and for general improve-
ment up to Pittsburg Landing. The work between Riparia and
Pittsburg Landing is based on surveys made in 1900, 1902, and 1906,
between Riparia and Lewiston, between Lewiston and Imnaha River,
and between Imnaha River and Pittsburg Landing, at an estimated
cost of $23,000, $33,690, and $15,000, respectively.
    In 1907 the Washington State legislature appropriated $100,000
for expenditure between Riparia and the mouth. This action was
the result of a general disposition to revive navigation below Riparia
and utilize the State Portage road, which was built in 1905, around
the obstructions in the Columbia between Celilo and Big Eddy. The
project for this portion of the river, which was formulated for the
especial purpose of expending the above-mentioned appropriation,
is based on the survey made in 1897, and is a continuation of general
open river work.
    The amount expended on the original and modified projects to the
close of the fiscal year was $262,003.99, under the national appropria-
tion, and $74,164.06 under appropriation made by the State of
Washington.
    There has been received from miscellaneous sources, on account of
sales, $825.70.
    Operations during the past year have been carried on by the dredge
Wallowa, belonging to the United States, and by two drill scows
previously constructed under state funds. The dredge Wallowa
operated both above and below Riparia, the two drill scows being
confined to work below Riparia. Owing to severe weather and ice
gorges, both drill scows were wrecked in January, one being a total
loss, and the other picked up and towed back with little damage.
A total of 3,482 cubic yards of rock were removed from the different
reefs and rapids below Riparia, and 1,485 tons of stone were placed
in the dam at Slaughterhouse Rapids, just above Lewiston.
    The work done has resulted in providing a low-water channel
between Lewiston and Riparia of about 40 inches, in greatly improv-
ing the conditions above the latter point, and in making a safer and
more available channel below Riparia for all except extreme low
stages.
    The Snake River is in freshet during the summer months from
melting snow in the mountains, and during these freshets the varia-
tion of the water levels is usually about 20 feet. The head of naviga-
tion, during proper stages, is at Pittsburg Landing, about 216 miles
above the mouth, but only intermittent trips are made to that point,
regular traffic being carried on only as far up as Lewiston. There is
no logging or rafting on the Snake River, but logs are floated down
the Clearwater River to the mills near Lewiston.
    The Open River Transportation Company, a corporation organized
for the purpose of navigating the river, is now operating a line of
boats between Portland, Oreg., and Big Eddy, and have constructed
two powerful, light-draft boats, the Inland Empire and Twin Cities
                                         RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                                           847

for use on the upper river. These latter boats run between Lewiston
and Celilo, and exchange cargoes with the lower river boats by means
of the State Portage road between Celilo and Big Eddy.
   The Oregon Railroad and Navigation Company, which in former
years operated boats between Lewiston and Riparia, partially aban-
doned the use of the river on completion of their railroad along the
north bank to Lewiston during the past year, but owing to the keen
competition set up by the new line of boats they are again operating.
   The commerce transported on the Snake River during the fiscal
year amounted to 46,325 tons, and consisted principally of farm and
mill machinery, grain, fruit, and general merchandise, valued at,
approximately, $1,251,335.
   The reestablishment of water transportation between Lewiston and
Portland has resulted in a reduction in freight rates of about 20 per
cent between those points.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure for the next
fiscal year will be applied to the removal of obstructions, for mainte-
nance and improvement, and the proposed work is essential in order
to make the improvement available.
   For earlier reports on examinations and surveys, attention is
invited to Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1877, page
1036; 1882, page 2716; and 1885, page 2440. Reports of surveys
covering several sections now under improvement, with estimates
of cost, will be found in the annual reports as follows: Between
Riparia and the mouth, 1898, page 3013; between Riparia and Lewis-
ton, 1901, page 3525; between Lewiston and the mouth of Imnaha
River, 1903, page 2246; between Imnaha River and Pittsburg Land-
ing, 1906, page 1986.
Comparative statement of trafic carried on Columbia River above Celilo and on Snake
                     River during year ending December 81, 1908.

                                                                                                    Columbia                 Snake                      Estimated
                                    Calendar year.                                                 River above               River.         Total.      Est
                                                                                                        Celilo.


                                                                                                         Tons.                Tons.          Tons.
1899......                                         ..........
                            ............................                                              ....................                   45,654 ......
1900......................................................                                                                                   35,920 .........
1901...................................................................................                                                      36,723 ...........
1902........... .........                          ...........                                                                               37,824.. .
1903..........................................................                                ........................                       44,379..........
1904 .........      ...................                   .......          ....................................                              43,547      $1,798,677
1905.................................................................... .............                                                       28,380       1,191,960
1906. ..............             ....... ............         ......................                            ......       ..........      71,556       2,671,882
1907........ ... ..... ..................................                                                              7,776       39,228    47,004       1,880,300
1908....                   ................................                                           ..               1,349       46,325    47,674       1,296,750


                                                             FEDERAL APPROPRIATION.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.. .......................           .... $4, 258. 38
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909......----.... ..       .............................       5, 000.00
                                                                                                                                                         9, 258.38
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement...................................................                                                                                        3,892.26
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                                                                                     5, 366.12
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities........                                                        .....................                                  278. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available.................................                                                                                        5, 088. 12
848           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                U.    S. ARMY.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909 ........ .     .......................  $15, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                         STATE APPROPRIATION.


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended............-------------------------------...               $52, 622. 69
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..-----------........------------.....----..-----.........-----.......................  26, 786. 75
July 1, 1909; balance unexpended------------............---....-------------.........----.            25, 835. 94
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..-----............-----------...............-------------------     337. 00
                                           ----------------------------------- 25, 498.94
July 1, 1909, balance available.......................
    (See Appendix U U 6.)
   7. Columbia River and tributaries above Celilo Falls to the mouth
of the Snake River, Oregon and Washington.-This stretch of river is
124 miles long and can be navigated at favorable stages. It abounds
in rapids and shoals which are obstructed by projecting ledges,
isolated bowlders, etc. Before the days of railroads the Columbia
River formed the main highway for commerce between the inland
empire and tide water, but navigation was always more or less dan-
gerous, and was practically suspended in 1882 on account of the con-
struction of a line of railroad by the Oregon Railroad and Navigation
Company, which practically paralleled the south bank and reached as
far as Riparia on the Snake River, about 72 miles below Lewiston.
   The first project was adopted by act of June 10, 1872, and in 1877
was modified to include the improvement of the Snake River. This
project provided for the improvement of the most troublesome rapids
by the removal of obstructing reefs and bowlders, and in this work
approximately $120,000 was expended up to the time of the suspen-
sion of navigation in 1882.
   The existing project is based on the survey authorized by act of
March 3, 1905, and was adopted by act of March 2, 1907. It proposes
to facilitate navigation by the removal of obstructing bowlders and
ledges, and raking the gravel shoals in order to make safe and avail-
able the channel that now exists. In 1907 the State legislature of
Washington appropriated the sum of $25,000 for expenditure in the
vicinity of Umatilla Rapids, in order to expedite the work under the
general project.
   The amount expended on the present project to the end of the fiscal
year under the national appropriation was $83,653.51, and under the
appropriation by the State of Washington $25,000.
   With the drill scow previously constructed under funds appropri-
ated by the State of Washington the work of blasting out obstructions
at Umatilla Rapids was continued when conditions were favorable.
The stern-wheel steamboat under construction at the beginning of the
year was completed and equipped with drilling apparatus and appli-
ances for raking shoals and put into commission the latter part of
November. Work continued until May, when operations were sus-
pended owing to high water. During the year 1,047 cubic yards of
rock were removed from Umatilla, Biggs, and Homly rapids, and 537
drags were made at Biggs and Homly rapids.
                          RIVER AND          HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                    849

    The work accomplished has resulted in improving the channel
through some of the most troublesome shoals, mainly Umatilla and
Homly rapids, and has lessened, to some extent, the dangers that
previously existed. During the summer months the river is in
freshet, and the extreme variation of the water surfaces at that time
is about 34 feet above low water. The head of low-water navigation
for boats using this portion of the stream is at Asotin, on the Snake
River, 269 miles above Celilo, and approximately 473 miles from the
sea. On higher stages boats ascend the Snake River as far as Pitts-
burg Landing, a farther distance of about 70 miles. There is no log-
ging on this stretch of river.
    During the previous year there was but one small steamboat oper-
ating on the river between Celilo and the mouth of the Snake River.
During the past year the Open River Transportation Company con-
structed two light-draft, powerful steamboats, the Inland Empire and
Twin Cities, and these two boats are now being operated between
Celilo and Lewiston in conjunction with steamers between Portland
and Big Eddy. The cargoes are broken at Big Eddy and at Celilo
and are transported around the obstructions between these two points
by the State Portage road.
    The freight rates charged by these boats on shipments from Port-
land, Oreg., to Lewiston, Idaho, are on an average about 20 per cent
less than the rates charged for shipments by rail.
    The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure for the fiscal year
1911 is to be applied to extending the benefits by continuing the work
of removing obstructions. With the new plant now available, and
with ample funds to operate it, better results may be expected. It is
therefore essential that the whole amount be appropriated.
    A description of the early conditions will be found in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1877, page 1036, and the report
of examination and survey for present project is printed as House
Document No. 440, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session.
                                      FEDERAL APPROPRIATION.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.............               -............-..........     $85, 948. 90
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment---------................--.....-------------------------------------.............  49, 602.41

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..--------------------.............--....-------....-........   36, 346.49
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities -....................................                      2,080. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available........-..-.--.........-                       .....-.......    34, 266. 49

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........- . 280, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909......................................................                            90,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897.
                                         STATE APPROPRIATION.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-... ---..-..-   ----     --      - - - --- . $11, 840. 34
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment....................................................................     11, 840. 34
   (See Appendix U U 7.)
        9001-ENG 1909-54
850     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   8. Columbia River between the foot of The Dalles Rapids and the
head of Celilo Falls, Oregon and Washington.-The object of this
improvement is to overcome the obstructions in the 12 miles between
the foot of Threemile Rapids and the head of Celilo Falls. There
are four principal obstructions: Threemile Rapids, a crooked channel
1,500 feet in length, narrow and obstructed by rocks and currents;
Fivemile Rapids (The Dalles) where for 1 miles the river rushes
with great velocity between precipitous walls of basalt 150 to 300
feet apart; Tenmile Rapids, a similar gorge, but only one-half mile
in length; Celilo Falls, with a sheer fall of 20 feet. The total fall
is about 81 feet at low water and 60 feet at high stages. It can
not be navigated at any stage.
   The first project was adopted by act of August 18, 1894, and
contemplated the construction of a boat railway capable of trans-
porting boats of 600 tons. One hundred thousand dollars was
appropriated for purchasing the right of way and beginning con-
struction. The act of June 3, 1896, made an additional appro-
priation of $150,000. A preliminary examination and survey was
authorized by act of June 6, 1900, with a view to the construction
of a canal and locks. The report submitted under this act is printed
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1901, Part 5,
page 3502, and proposes the construction of a short canal and locks
around The Dalles, or Fivemile Rapids, and another around the
falls at Celilo, with intermediate river improvement, at an esti-
mated cost of $3,969,371. The amount expended on previous
projects prior to the adoption of the present project was $27,112.83.
   The existing project, as adopted by Congress in the act approved
March 3, 1905, provides for a continuous canal on the Oregon shore,
between the pool above Celilo and the pool below Fivemile Rapids,
with open river improvement at Threemile Rapids. As subsequently
modified in minor details, the canal will have a depth of 8 feet, width
of 65 feet at the bottom, and length of 81 miles, with 5 locks 300 feet
by 45 feet by 7 feet over miter sills, two of which will be located at
the lower end of the canal, one at Fivemile Rapids, one at Tenmile
Rapids, and one at Celilo Falls. As modified, the estimated cost will
be $4,845,000.
   The open river work at Threemile Rapids, which was included in
the project, has been previously considered completed, but investi-
gations in 1908, based on the complaints of steamboat men, make it
apparent that further work will be required in order to furnish a safe
channel at least 200 feet in width.
   There has been expended on the work at Threemile Rapids ap-
proximately $120,000, and it is estimated that the additional work
will cost about $45,000, thereby increasing the cost of the Threemile
Rapids section by about $15,000. It is believed this increased cost
will not necessitate any change in the estimated cost of the project
as a whole, on account of the large amount estimated for engineer-
ing, etc.
   The amount expended on the present project to the end of the
fiscal year was $642,355.20, of which $31,279.81 was applied to sur-
veying, preparing plans, etc., before its adoption. There has been
received on account of the sale of blueprints the total sum of $39.08.
   Under contract let in 1904, and completed in March, 1908, there
were removed 50,970 cubic yards of rock from the rocky ledges in the
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                   851
vicinity of Threemile Rapids, in order to give a channel at least 10
feet deep at low water, and from 200 to 250 feet wide. Additional
work may be necessary at this locality in order to provide a safe
channel for steamboats.
   Work has been in progress during the year under two contracts,
one for about 2,500 feet of canal at the upper end, and one for the
construction of a second section about 14,000 feet in length immedi-
ately below and adjoining the first section. At the close of the year
the former contract was nearly completed, and the latter contract is
about 35 per cent completed. At the close of the year work under
these contracts was entirely suspended, owing to the summer freshet,
and can not be resumed again until July or August.
   This work has been carried on under continuing contract appro-
priations, the sundry civil act of March 4, 1909, having appropriated
the sum of $164,000, which was the balance of the authorization
made by the act of March 2, 1907.
   With the completion of the contracts now in force, it might be
stated that the project is about 20 per cent completed, but no advan-
tages have been derived from the expenditures, except the benefit
furnished by the improvement at Threemile Rapids. The variation
of the water surfaces from extreme low water and extreme high water
is from 32 to 90 feet at different points. Boats are now operating
between Portland and Big Eddy, and between Celilo and Lewiston,
265 miles above Celilo on the Snake River, the cargoes being trans-
ported around the obstructions between Big Eddy and Celilo by the
State Portage Railroad, thus furnishing water competition to all
intermediate points on the river.
   The Open River Transportation Company, organized for the pur-
pose of operating boats in connection with the State Portage Rail-
road, has, during the fiscal year, constructed two steamboats with a
carrying capacity of about 250 tons each, and during the calendar
year 1908 they report the handling of approximately 4,056 tons of
merchandise, farm and mill machinery, wheat and farm products,
valued at approximately $207,685.
   The influence of this water transportation has resulted in the
reduction of freight rates between competitive railroad points up to
Celilo, and as the steamboat service on the upper river is increased a
still further reduction is anticipated. The benefits to be derived
from the improvement when completed, the country which will be
affected, and the probable resources to be developed are all described
in House Document No. 228, Fifty-sixth Congress, second session.
The irrigation projects now under way and contemplated should,
within a few years, increase the farm products and the resultant
traffic to very large quantities.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure will be applied
to further work under contract, and it is recommended that the work
be again placed on a continuing contract basis, with an authorized
expenditure of approximately $1,000,000 per year until the work is
completed.
   The Spokane, Portland and Seattle Railroad has completed its
bridges over the Columbia and Willamette rivers, giving entrance
to the city of Portland, and making a new transcontinental line along
the north bank of the Columbia, connecting with the Northern
Pacific at Kennewick, Wash.
852                     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U.          S. ARMY.

  For reports on examinations and surveys, reference is invited to
the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1875, Part 2, page
787; 1882, page 2690; 1890, page 3428; 1894, page 2664; 1901, page
3501, and 1904, page 3475.
Comparative statement of traffic handled by Oregon State Portage Railway between Big
                                 Eddy and Celilo, Oreg.


                    Calendar year.           Tons.    Estue.                    Calendar year.                 Tons.       Estimated
                                                       value.                                                                value.

1905.............             ....   .....    3,058    $185,800       1907-..---..        ~...... .......       4,600         $185,000
1906..........             ...............    5,414         227,900   1908........................               4,056         207,685


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended                  -----------------...........-----------................---..          $666, 765. 10
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.-. . .                                                    164, 000. 00
Received account sales ..........................                              ....................
                                                                                                ........                       24. 23

                                                                                                                         830, 789. 33
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement......-------------------------.............-------...-----..-------.....................                     250, 218. 28

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended                       --
                                          -----.............--------------...........--------.                           580, 571. 05
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................................                                                    38, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available--                       . ........-----------------....--.....                           542, 571. 05

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contractss.. . .........                                                   377, 173. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project........                                              3, 708, 392. 64
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
    July 1, 1909...................................              ...    1,000, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
    4, 1897.
       (See Appendix U U 8.)
   9. Canal at the Cascades, Columbia River, Oregon.-This improve-
ment embraces about 4 miles of the Columbia River where it passes
through the Cascade Mountain Range, and is contracted into a narrow
gorge with steep slopes and swift current. A fall of 24 feet at low
water in the upper 2,500 feet of the gorge creates a turbulent rapid
which effectually bars upstream navigation and renders downstream
navigation unsafe. The lower 4 miles of the gorge is swift, and before
improvement was unsafe by reason of the obstructing ledges and
bowlders.
   The original project was for a canal and locks around the falls.
It was adopted in 1877 and modified in 1886 and 1888, and included
the improvement of the rapids below the falls to secure a low-water
channel of 8 feet. The locks were to be about 462 feet long and 92
feet wide, with a low-water depth of 8 feet over the miter sills.
   The existing project is a modification of the original project, and
is based on report of the Board of Engineers, printed in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1895, page 3571. It provided
for utilizing the upper 426 feet of the uncompleted canal above the
lock gates as a second lock, and also in raising the protection work
of the canal walls as a safeguard against flood water. The estimated
cost of the original project was $2,544,545, and the later modifica-
tion $413,360.
                                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                                    853

   The amount expended on the original and modified projects to the
close of the last fiscal year was $3,819,875.63. There has been
received on account of sales the total sum of $11,629.48.
   No work was done during the fiscal year except to care for the
plant and buildings, as sufficient funds for construction work were
not available.
   The canal and locks were completed and opened to navigation in
1895. There yet remains the building of the land wall of the upper
lock, construction of three sets of steps, and completing the paving
and grading on the land side of the canal. Provision should also be
made for blasting out some obstructive ledges below the locks.
About 8 feet can be carried at low water through the locks. An
annual rise in the Columbia River takes place in May, June, or July,
and usually reaches a stage of 40 feet above low water. The head of
navigation for boats passing the locks is Big Eddy, about 4 miles
above The Dalles. No logs are rafted through the canal, but logging
is carried on extensively between Cascade Locks and The Dalles.
   The downriver commerce through the locks consists of wheat,
flour, miscellaneous grain, cattle, horses, wool, and country produce.
The amount of this commerce was 17,687 tons, valued at approxi-
mately $1,060,600. The upriver commerce is principally general
merchandise, machinery, and supplies, and during the year amounted
to 16,490 tons, valued at approximately $989,400.
   This improvement is a factor in regulating freight rates to all
points reached by steamers using the canal and locks.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure will be applied
to blasting out obstructions below the locks and in completing the
masonry work. The proposed work is not necessary to make the im-
provement available, but is essential in order to decrease the volu-
metric capacity of the upper lock, thus shortening the time of lockage.
   References to former reports are given on page 675 of the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905.
                                                              Comparative statement of traffic.

                                                                                                                                                            Number
                                        Fiscal year ending June 30-                                                              Tons.      Estimated
                                                                                                                                              value,           of
                                                                                                                                                            passen-
                                                                                                                                                             gers.

1900.........--........--...................................................--------------..                                     17,710 ............           30,639
1901...----..-....----.........................................----------------------------------------------.......----......   22,426............34,762
1902 .........                 ...... ..................................................                                         19,710 ............          52,720
1903----....-----........-------......----....------------------------------------------............................................. 36,181 ............      50,821
1904...........................................--------------------------------------......---------------...................         31,967 ............      76,971
1905....................................................................                                                              35,166 $2,286,125        64,403
1906----....-----....---------------------------....................................-----------------.......................          46,884    2,813,040     133,070
1907---.......----..-------...---...------------------------------------...............................................               53,770    3,226,200      89,239
1908...-------.........-----..-....---------------------------------.........................................-------........          54,954    3,297,240      86,615
1909.....-------.........................................------------------------------------------.......-------------............   34,168    2,050,000      70,482


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....                    .......      ................            $1, 489. 75
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement...------................---------------------------......------------..............     735. 90
                                                                         ---------------
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended----------------.....................................                                                                        753.85
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.............--------------------...................------..                                                             60. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available...............................                                                                                               693. 85
854            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                        U.    S. ARMY.

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... $199, 260. 00
SAmount    that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909...--------..--...........................-------------------------------...........-----....... 105, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897.
   (See Appendix U U 9.)
   10. Operating and care of canals and locks at the Cascades of the
Columbia River, Oregon.-The canal and locks around the obstruc-
tions in the Columbia River at Cascades, Oreg., were so far com-
pleted that they were opened to navigation on November 5, 1896,
since which time appropriations have been made under the general
work of improvement for further completing the walls and slope
pavement, grading, etc. A general description of the location,
dimensions, etc., is given in the preceding report.
   Since the opening of the locks more or less dredging has been re-
quired, especially at the upper entrance, where an accumulation of
sand and silt made navigation difficult at the lower stages of the river.
Dredging had been previously done to maintain an open channel at
the upper entrance, but no attempt had been made to entirely clear
the upper entrance of the material which had been deposited from
year to year.
   During the past year a dredging plant was fitted up, and after the
high-water period dredging operations were commenced and a total
of 27,347 cubic yards was removed, which practically cleared the
upper entrance of all deposits.
   There was expended during the fiscal year the sum of $15,953.83,
which was applied to dredging, to the installation of new cable
tightening gear, the purchase of a compressor plant for sand-blasting
outfit, and keeping up the usual repairs to the operating machinery,
grounds, and buildings.
   The total amount expended from the indefinite appropriation, on
account of operating, maintenance, repairs, etc., to the close of the
fiscal year was $114,600.71.
   The commerce through the locks during the fiscal year amounted
to 34,168.02 tons, valued at approximately $2,050,000. This com-
merce consisted principally of wheat, flour, miscellaneous grain,
cattle, horses, wool, country produce, general merchandise, etc., a
detailed statement of which is given in the district officer's report.
   (See Appendix U U 10.)
   11. Columbia River between Vancouver, Wash., and the mouth qof
Willamette River.-The city of Vancouver, Wash., is on the north
bank of the Columbia River, about 103 miles above its mouth, and
5 miles above the junction of thle Willamette and Columbia rivers.
Originally vessels drawing about 23 feet could ascend the Columbia
River to within about 2 1 miles of the city, where there was a bar over
which there was only about 9 feet at low water. This bar resulted
partly from an excess of width in the main river, and partly from a
diversion of a portion of the waters to the south side of Hayden
Island.
   The original project, adopted by the act of July 13, 1892, provided
for constructing a pile, brush, and rubblestone dike about 3,000 feet
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    855
in length, from the Oregon shore to the head of Hayden Island oppo-
site Vancouver, in order to stop the flow south of the island during
low-water stages, deflect it down the main channel, and scour out
the troublesome shoals. This project contemplated a depth of 20
feet or more, but this depth was not realized after the completion of
the dike.
   The existing project, adopted by act of March 3, 1905, is based on
the report of the district officer dated July 22, 1902, approved by the
Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, and provided for the
maintenance of a channel 20 feet deep at low water, and 150 feet
wide, by dredging. The estimate was $60,000 for original work, and
$10,000 yearly for maintenance of the channel and dike at the head
of Hayden Island.
   The total amount expended on the original and modified projects
to June 30, 1909, was $143,318.60, of which the sum of $45,786.44
was applied to maintenance.
   No work was in progress during the year except that of making a
survey of the shoals between the railroad bridge at Vancouver and
deep water below the lower end of Hayden Island. The survey was
made with a view to redredging the shoals, but a suitable dredge
could not be obtained for doing the work.
   The completion of the dike at the head of Hayden Island, and
revetting the bank to prevent erosion, caused considerable scouring
on the shoals below Vancouver, but only increased the depth about
1 foot. Under the modified project for dredging, the channel was
dredged in 1905 to the desired width and depth and again redredged
in the fall of 1906. The survey made in September, 1908, shows
that the channel had shoaled in places to 10 feet or less at low water.
The variation of the water surface at Vancouver, due to tidal influ-
ence, is about eight-tenths of a foot at low water. The annual
summer freshet, due to melting snow in the mountains, rises to a
height of about 20 feet above low water. Steamboats drawing 8
feet can navigate the river as far as The Dalles, about 210 miles from
its mouth, by passing through the locks at the Cascades.
   The deep-sea tonnage is principally lumber, but during the calen-
dar year 1908 no shipments were made from Vancouver.
   The Spokane, Portland and Seattle Railway Company has com-
pleted during the year their bridge across Columbia River at Van-
couver, and have trains running on their new road along the north
bank of the Columbia River as far as Kennewick, Wash., making
connections at that point with the Northern Pacific Railroad. The
maintenance of a 20-foot channel over the shoals below Vancouver
will allow of deep-sea vessels loading lumber cargoes at the Vancouver
mills and save lighterage charges that would otherwise be necessary.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure will be applied
to the maintenance of the projected depth and may be considered as
an extension of benefits.
   Previous reports on examinations and surveys will be found in the
Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1892, page 2865; 1896,
page 3264, and 1904, page 3497.
856       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                 U.   S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................... $9,986. 92
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909...........- ..-..............    ......
                                               ...                    . 5, 000. 00
                                                          . ...........
                                                                      14, 986. 92
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
                                                                          305. 52
  improvement...---------.....---...............----------------.........--
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................                     14, 681.40
                                                          ....... .........
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...... ..... .........            ................... 15,000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
  (See Appendix U U 11.)

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE SECOND                               PORT-
                 LAND, OREGON, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Lieut. Col. S. W. Roessler, Corps
of Engineers, division engineer, Northern Pacific division, to July 11,
1908, and of Maj. J. F. McIndoe, Corps of Engineers, since that date,
having under his immediate orders Capt. Arthur Williams, Corps of
Engineers, since January 11, 1909. Division engineer, Lieut. Col.
John Biddle, Corps of Engineers, temporarily.
   1. Willamette River above Portland, and Yamhill River, Oregon.-
The Willamette River rises in the Cascade Range, flows northerly, and
generally parallel to the coast line, and empties into the Columbia
about 12 miles below Portland and 100 miles from the sea.
   The Yamhill River is a tributary which has its source in the Coast
Range, flows in a northeasterly direction, and enters the Willamette
40 miles above its mouth.
   Prior to improvement both streams were obstructed by drift, snags,
rook ledges and rapids, and gravel shoals, which prevented navigation
during low-water stages. In early days the river formed the only
means of transportation, and carried large quantities of grain and
farm products to the Portland market, notwithstanding the difficul-
ties of navigation.
   Reference is invited to Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for
1876, page 654, and 1880, page 2280, for a description of the Willa-
mette River before improvement.
   The original project was adopted in 1870, the first appropriation
being made by the act of March 3, 1871. This project was modified
in 1878 and 1896, and provided for improvement by the removal of
snags and other obstructions, and the deepening of gravel shoals by
scraping and by contraction works. The modification of 1896 also
provided for the construction of a lock and dam in the Yamhill River
below Lafayette, at an estimated cost of $69,000.
   The total amount expended on the work prior to adoption of the
present project was $247,747.51.
   The present revised plan or project (see Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1904, p. 3529) provides for improvement below Cor-
vallis, with a view to obtaining, mainly by dredging, auxiliary dam
and revetment work, and by snagging, a low-water depth of 24 to 34
feet from Corvallis to Oswego, and a low-water depth of 12 feet thence
to Portland. The plan allows snagging above Corvallis to Harris-
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     857
burg, but above the latter point the channel is to be left as not worthy
of further improvement. The estimated cost of carrying on the work
was given as $213,500.
   The amount expended on the existing project to the close of the
fiscal year was $398,004.74, which includes $3,000 expended on the
Long Tom River, and $175,384.06 for maintenance.
   The work is carried on by use of government plant, consisting of a
combined dredge and snag boat, one dipper dredge, and one pile-
driver. During the past year snagging, dredging, and revetment
work was carried on from July 1, 1908, to November 30, and April,
1909, to June 30,1909, and different shoals were dredged between Cor-
vallis and Newberg. A total of 77,579 cubic yards of material were
removed from the channel, and a total of 730 snags were removed
from the channel and banks between Corvallis and Newberg, and re-
pairs were made to revetment and dikes at Wheatland, Independence,
and Five Islands.
   The work done on the Willamette River has greatly improved the
conditions, and, with annual maintenance, will furnish a navigable
channel at medium stages to Corvallis, 119 miles above Portland, and
during low water to Independence, 83 miles above Portland, and to
Dayton, on the Yamhill River, 8 miles above its mouth. The head of
navigation on the Willamette is Harrisburg, 152 miles above Portland,
but boats reach the latter point only on the higher stages.
   The work done on the Yamhill River has been the completion of
the lock and dam near Lafayette, about 8 miles above the mouth,
under project of 1896, and clearing the channel of obstructions.
   The head of navigation on the Yamhill River is McMinnville, 18
miles from the mouth, but boats seldom go above Dayton.
   The forests adjacent to the Willamette Valley produce large quan-
tities of logs, and most all of the tributaries are used for logging pur-
poses, for distances ranging from 20 to 45 miles. An annual log
drive takes place each spring on the Willamette, between the upper
river points and Newberg.
   The commerce consists of lumber, grain, hay, hops, potatoes, fruit,
and garden truck. This commerce, including general merchandise
and supplies received and logs towed, amounted, during the calendar
year 1908, to 403,148 tons, valued at $8,014,164.
   The falls of the Willamette at Oregon City, 12 miles above Port-
land, and around which a canal and lock were constructed in early
days by private capital furnishes a very large water power. This
water power and the locks are controlled by the Portland Railway,
Light and Power Company, and a charge of 50 cents per ton is made
for all traffic which passes through the locks. During the calendar
year this traffic amounted to 73,578 tons, not including large quanti-
ties of logs and timber. The falls furnish power for the main gen-
erating plant of the above company, also for large woolen, lumber,
and paper mills.
   The lands of the Willamette Valley are very rich and productive,
and the products are annually increasing. The river furnishes an
easy means of transportation, and carries a large proportion of these
commodities.
   The Southern Pacific Railway practically parallels the river on
each side, and the Oregon Electric Company is now operating an
electric line between Portland and Salem.
858            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                           U.      S. ARMY.

  Although the locks in the Yamhill River are little used, these
locks, together with the water transportation furnished by the
Willamette, are instrumental in reducing the freight rates on all
shipments from valley points.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure is to be applied
to construction of revetments, dredging, snagging, and making re-
pairs to existing works. The work is necessary to maintain the
available channel.
   For previous reports on examinations and surveys, attention is
invited to the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers as follows:
Willamette River, 1892, 1893, and 1896, pages 2840, 3529, and 3309,
respectively; Yamhill River, 1875, 1891, 1893, 1895, and 1904, pages
792, 3381, 3531, 3602, and 3569, respectively; canal and locks at
Oregon City, 1900, 1904, and 1905, pages 4368, 3559, and 2497,
respectively; opposite Salem, 1898, page 3051; opposite Albany, 1904,
page 3564.
                                        Comparative statement of trafic.


                                   Calendar year.                                           Tons.Estimated.         Psen-



1899........................ ....................                                  .......        ........117,782 ............ 50,738
1900...................................................................                                   182, 458 ............   47,324
1901-------------......                                                                              ...  191,901 ............   103,971
1902...--------------------------...                                                                      192,227 ........... 95,221
1903 .. ...- ......                 ..............           ........................................     236, 823                66, 510
1904.....................................--....---...........................---.......332,130                     $11,260,196    65,947
1905 ...................................................................                                  362,258 12,119,596      67,396
1906 ...................................................................                                  383,911      7,591,623  41,160
1907....................................................................                                  412,846      8,193,746  41,998
1908..................................................                         ..................         403,148      8,014,164  29,029


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                                            $19, 708.32
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909----------------.......---------..................-------------.................----..------.....  20, 000. 00
                                                                                                                39, 708. 32
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement ....    .................. ... ..........................                                         21, 960. 57

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                           17, 747.75
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.. .................                             ...............            2, 168.00

July 1, 1909, balance available                   ..............           .....................                15, 579.75

Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                                        103, 500. 00

  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
    balance unexpended July 1, 1909...... .........         .............                                       60, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix V V 1.)
  2. Operating and care of lock and darn in Yamhill River, Oregon -
The lock and dam are situated on the Yamhill River, 8 miles ab ve
its mouth, and 10 miles below the head of navigation, at McMinnville.
It was constructed under appropriation for improving Willamette
and Yamhill rivers, for the purpose of affording low-water navigation
to McMinnville. It was completed and opened to navigation in 1900.
                RIVER AND   HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                  859
   During the past fiscal year the lock has been open to navigation
except for 74 days during the fall and winter months, when it was
closed on account of high water. The total traffic through the lock
amounted to 986 tons of freight and 375 passengers. The freight
consisted largely of log rafts and pulp wood, and the passengers
were principally parties in small boats and launches, there being no
regular line of boats operating on the Yamhill River at the present
time.
   Steamer traffic has been practically abandoned since 1902, and
the reason given is that boats formerly operating on the Yamhill
River now find more profitable business on the Willamette. It is
claimed by steamboat interests that the uncertainty of lock opera-
tion during the freshet season makes it impossible to compete with
railroad rates.
   During the year there was expended in operating, care, and main-
tenance the sum of $1,188.66, and the total expended for the same
purpose to the end of the fiscal year 1909 is $37,371.87.
   (See Appendix V V 2.)
   3. Columbia and Lower Willamette rivers below Portland, Oreg.-The
portions of the rivers covered by this improvement include the 12
miles of the Willamette between Portland and its mouth, and 98
miles of the Columbia from the mouth of the Willamette to the sea.
The original condition of the channel from Portland to the sea was
such that only from 10 to 15 feet could be carried over shoal places
at low water. Numerous sand bars obstructed navigation by deep-
water craft, and on these bars the water was spread over an extended
area, so that the channels through them were comparatively narrow.
The value and availability of this waterway for purposes of commerce
are illustrated by the fact that Portland is one of the principal grain
exporting cities in the United States, the valley of the Columbia being
a natural outlet for the products of Oregon, Washington, and Idaho.
   Prior to the adoption of the project, dredging had been done for
temporary relief, and the sum of $221,780.46 expended for that
purpose. The original project was adopted in 1877, with a view to
obtaining a channel depth of 20 feet. In 1891 the project was
extended, with a view to obtaining a low-water channel of 25 feet,
at an estimated cost of $772,464, and the Port of Portland Commis-
sion, a corporation existing under the laws of the State of Oregon,
was granted permission to assist in the work. On the original and
modified project, exclusive of the amounts named above, there has
been expended the sum of $1,080,874.11. This does not include
any part of the expenditures which have been made by the Port of
Portland Commission.
   The present project was adopted by the act of June 13, 1902. It
is based on a survey made in 1900, which is printed in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, page 4418. The proj-
ect proposes a 25-foot channel, by the construction of controlling
works and by dredging. The estimated cost was $2,796,300, with
$175,000 as the cost of the new dredge and accessories.
   The total amount expended on this project to the end of the fiscal
year was $509,962.09. This amount does not include any portion of
the sum expended by the Philadelphia district for dredge construction,
860     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.


and it may be stated that all the expenditures have been applied to
maintenance. The total amount received from miscellaneous sources,
account of sales, is $623.78.
   The act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $300,000 for constructing
and operating a dredge. This dredge was constructed on the Atlan-
tic coast and was delivered at Portland April 21, 1909. The amount
expended on her construction, including expenses of voyage from
Philadelphia, Pa., was $303,543.86, and for details of the work see
Appendix H 10.
   The work in progress on the Columbia River during the year has
consisted entirely in dredging over some of the most obstructive
shoals. A total of 341,430 cubic yards of material was removed at
the different shoal places in the estuary of the Columbia with the
dredge W. S. Ladd. The Port of Portland Commission also operated
its dredges in the upper reaches when funds were available and when
dredging was required. The commission reports having removed a
total of 2,326,568 cubic yards during the year. The new dredge
Clatsop, constructed under the supervision of the Philadelphia (Pa.)
district, arrived at Portland the latter part of April. She was over-
hauled and commenced dredging on June 25, and to the close of the
fiscal year removed 16,504 cubic yards of material.
   Thus far none of the permanent works provided for in the project
have been constructed, as operations have consisted principally
in dredging, and no part of the project can therefore be considered
as completed. The maintenance of the channel has been of great
advantage to shipping, and there has been no time during the year
when a vessel could not safely load to a draft of 24 feet. The ruling
depth at mean low water, from Portland to the sea, is about 22 feet,
except at two places, Upper Sands and Taylor Sands, where the
depths are only 212 feet and 20 feet, respectively, but by taking
advantage of the tides vessels have experienced little delay.
    The head of deep-water navigation is at Portland, Oreg., on the
Willamette River, 110 miles above the mouth of the Columbia. Light-
draft boats ascend the Willamette for 150 miles, and by using the
state portage road between Celilo and Big Eddy cargoes of light-
draft boats, during high stages, reach Pittsburg Landing, a point on
the Snake River 537 miles above the mouth of the Columbia. The
Columbia and Willamette rivers, over this stretch, probably form the
greatest waterway for logging and rafting purposes in the United
States. Lumber and shingle mills are located along the banks, and
logs are floated down all the tributaries from points 20 to 90 miles
inland and towed to the different mills to be manufactured. During
the calendar year 1908, seven rafts of logs and piling timbers, aggre-
gating, approximately, 35,000,000 feet b. m., were made up in the
Columbia River and towed to San Francisco and southern California
ports.
    The export commerce consists principally of grain and lumber,
while the imports are composed principally of oriental products,
cement, coal, lime, sulphur, etc. The light-draft tonnage is chiefly
dairy, farm, and lumber products and miscellaneous machinery and
mercantile supplies.
                           IVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                              861
   The total commerce handled during the calendar year 1908
amounted to 4,615,372 tons, valued at approximately $70,509,475.
   It is not believed that the completion of the project will have any
effect on freight rates until greater depths are obtained over the bar
at the entrance to the Columbia River, thus allowing the use of ships
of greater draft and carrying capacity.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure is to be applied
to maintenance by dredging and making repairs to dikes and revet-
ments. The maintenance of the channel is essential, pending the
construction of permanent contraction works, the estimate for begin-
ning these works being deferred in order that projects of special
character, such as the Dalles-Celilo Canal and the purchase of the
private canal in the Willamette River at Oregon City, may be pro-
vided for by adequate appropriations or by authorization of contracts.
   The two channels around Swan Island, below Portland, originally
divided the current of the river to the detriment of both. A shoal
bar existed at the head of each channel. To remove that of the east
channel, a dike was constructed across the head of the west channel.
The east channel, which is used by all vessels, is very crooked at one
portion, and it is sometimes difficult to avoid collision between deep-
sea vessels and log tows. The latter are the main source of worry to
the deep-sea navigators in the Swan Island channel. There is a gen-
eral desire to have the west channel dredged out to a sufficient depth
to accommodate log tows. This improvement is deemed a necessary
one in view of the increasing commerce of this port. In making appro-
priation for the improvement of the ship channel, it is recommended
that so much of the money as may be necessary be authorized for
dredging out the west channel to such extent as may be necessary to
accommodate log tows. A gap 300 feet wide has been left in the dike
in the west channel to permit the passage of shoal-water boats.
   References to former reports are given on page 683 of the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905.
                                   Comparative statement of traffic.

           Handled by river ves-              Handled by seagoing vessels.          Handled by river and
                   sels.                                                              seagoing vessels.
Calendar
  year.
             antity. Estimated
           Quantity.   value.  Recipts.        .   Ship-
                                                   ments.    Total.    Estimated
                                                                        value.         antity. Estimated
                                                                                    Quantity.   value.


              Tons.                   Tons.         Tons.     Tons.                   Tons.
1899...... 1,489,708........              36,253 336,134      372,387.............    1,862,095 .........
1900......1,287,  582 ............        32,905 489,385      552,290 ........ ....   1,809,872.........
1901......1,534,780...........            29,548  639,736     669,284 .........       2,204,064...........
1902...... 1,567,336............145,514 985,912             1,131,426..........       2,698,762 .....
1903...... 1,596,220.....              . 173,006 659,178      832,184 .....         . 2,428,404.....
1904......1,905,451 $30,775,       609 229,833 548,495        778,328 $27,281,302 2,683,779 $58,056,911
1905......2,313,153 26,712,339 210,026 736,779                946,805 31,786,   607   3,259,958 58,498,    946
1906......2,331,121 26,377,        640   226,656 974,317    1,200,973 34,407,991 3,532,094 60,785,631
1907...... 2,586,964   31,583, 804       572,4411,092,276   1,664,717 45, 000, 000    4,251,681    76, 583,804
1908......2,927,041 27,509,475 586,2781,102,         053    1,688,331 43,000,000 4,615,372 70,509,475
862          REPORT OF THE OCHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                       S. ARMY.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...-------------------------------.                             a $146, 579. 90
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  M arch 3, 1909 ..................          ..............................                   .. b 100, 000. 00
Received account of sales.......................                           ..................             18.55

                                                                                                          246, 598. 45
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For dredge construction. ... ..............        ....                  . $123, 820. 48
    For maintenance of improvement ...................                           42, 949. 71
                                                                                                          166, 770. 19
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                                        79, 828. 26
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..........                    -               -..................    c5, 680. 49
July 1, 1909, balance available................                     .................                      74, 147.77
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....... 2, 498, 509.93

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
  30, 1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive
  of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909......... ..................                                      175, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix V V 3.)
   4. Mouth of Columbia River, Oregon and Washington.-Prior to the
commencement of the work of constructing the jetty in 1885 there
were from one to three channels across the bar, and these channels
varied from time to time both in location and depth. The depths
were from 19 to 21 feet at low water, while the location shifted
through nearly 180 ° between Cape Disappointment and Point
Adams.
   For a map of the locality and information regarding conditions
before improvement, attention is invited to the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1886, page 1976 et seq.
   The first project was adopted in 1884, and provided for the con-
struction of a low-tide jetty, 4- miles in length, extending seaward
from Point Adams, on the south side of the entrance, and terminat-
ing at a point about 3 miles south of Cape Disappointment. It was
to be built of rubble stone, with a foundation of brush mattresses.
This project was modified in 1893 to provide for raising the jetty to
high-tide level, and for building four groins from 500 to 1,000 feet in
length on the north side.
   The estimated cost was $3,710,000, and the jetty was completed
to a length of 4 miles in 1895, and increased the depth over the bar
to 31 feet. The total amount expended on the original project was
$1,968,753.14, prior to which $17,500 had been appropriated and
expended for survey, etc.
   The present project was formulated for the purpose of arresting
the shoaling process which commenced soon after the completion of
the work, the depth having decreased to about 28 feet in 1899, and
the location of the channel having shifted into an unstable posi-
tion 2 miles north of the 1895 channel. By 1902 the depths had
deteriorated to 21 feet at low water.

  a Including $94,779.82 withdrawn by Major Deakyne for dredge construction.
  b Eighteen thousand dollars allotted to Major Deakyne for dredge construction.
  c Includes $1,280.49 for dredge construction.
                 RIVER   AND HARBOR   IMPROVEMENTS.                 863
   The first appropriation for a new project was made by the act of
June 6, 1900, when $250,000 was appropriated for repairs, etc.,
pending a report to be made by a board of engineers. The report of
this board, which is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1903, pages 2275 et seq., constitutes the present proj-
ect, and provided for extending the jetty seaward a farther distance
of about 2-1 miles. Dredging was also recommended as a temporary
expedient, as well as the construction of a north jetty, should it be
found necessary at some future time, in order to secure the desired
depth of 40 feet, with a practicable width.
   The estimated cost of the south jetty was $2,260,000; of the north
jetty, $1,205,000; of remodeling and operating dredge, $250,000.
   The revised estimate, approved April 17, 1909, for a completion of
the south jetty was $3,529,300, and is based on a report made by the
district officer, recommending that the jetty enrockment be raised to
at least mid-tide level, and that its crest be given a width of not less
than 25 feet, in order to protect the trestle piling from early destruc-
tion by storms and teredo. The increased cost is due to the greater
amount of stone required, the increase in cost of materials, and the
heavy loss, during construction in previous years, due to destruction
of the trestle by winter storms and teredo. In some places the jetty
is being built in depths as great as 39 feet, and with 15 feet increase
in the width of its crest it becomes at once evident that an enormous
increase in the amount of rock is required.
   The act of March 3, 1909, contained an item of $200,000 for remod-
eling and operating the dredge Chinook, which was formerly the trans-
port Grant, and which has been laid up at the government moorings
below Portland, Oreg., for the past four years on account of the unsafe
condition of her boilers. It is proposed to install new boilers and cut
down her upper work, in order to reduce her displacement and draft.
The work is to be done under contract.
   There has been expended on the existing project to the end of the
fiscal year the sum of $4,564,249.20. The portion derived from
miscellaneous sources, account of sales, amounted to $1,428.39.
   The operations during the past year have consisted in extending
the jetty tramway a total distance of 3,960 feet seaward, and over
this distance, except the outer portion, the enrockment was brought
up to a height of 5 to 8 feet above mean low tide. The enrockment
over about 7,926 feet of previous years' extensions was also widened
and brought up to the same general elevation. The stone received
under contract and dumped on the jetty during the year amounted to
612,404 tons.
   Active operations were suspended from December 31, 1908, to
April 13, 1909, during which period the receipt of stone was discon-
tinued on account of inclement weather.
   At the close of the year an expert dredge designer had been assigned
from the Philadelphia district to the work of preparing plans and
specifications for the remodeling of the dredge Chinook.
   The work has been carried on under continuing contract for the
purchase of rock, but there is no balance remaining to be appropriated,
as the act of March 4, 1909, provided $250,000, which completed all
previous authorizations.
   The proportion of the project accomplished to the end of the fiscal
year is approximately 58 per cent, based on the revised cost.
864          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U.      S. ARMY.

   The advantage derived from the improvement has been the increase
of about 5J feet depth on the bar since the adoption of the project.
This is shown by the survey completed just at the close of the fiscal
year. A copy of the map is transmitted with the district officer's
report, and by referring to it it will be seen that, aside from an in-
crease in depth in the westerly channel of about 1 feet during the
year, there is a marked tendency, due to the scouring effect, to lessen
the distance between deep water on the inside and deep water on the
outside of the crest, besides a reduction in the total width resulting
in a well-defined channel with a least depth of 26- feet, as against 25
feet the previous year.
   The gradual movement of Peacock Spit to the north and west, and
the westerly movement of Clatsop Spit, are encouraging exhibits, and
indicate the controlling influence of the jetty as it advances.
   The variation of the level of water surfaces, due to tides, is about
7.4 feet. The head of navigation for deep-sea vessels crossing the bar
is at Portland, 110 miles above the mouth.
   The commercial statistics will be found with the report in improving
Columbia and Lower Willamette rivers, below Portland, Oreg. (p. 861).
   Deepening of the channel over the bar will admit of the use of ships
of greater draft and increased carrying capacity, and with larger ves-
sels frequenting the port it is reasonable to suppose that the charter
rates on deep-sea tonnage will be reduced, and may also reduce the
present rail rates on transcontinental shipments.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure for improve-
ment is for the purpose of extending the jetty seaward, with a view
to increasing the depths and extending the benefits already attained.
The $60,000 estimated for maintenance is for operating the dredge
Chinook, when the work of remodeling her has been completed.
   Reference to former reports will be found on pages 686-687 of the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................              ................       $1, 510, 123 06
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909................ ..........................                ........ .     700, 000. 00
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.......                    250, 000. 00
Received from sales ....................       ..............          ...........             37.05
                                                                                                   2,460,160.11
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of im-
  provement ......................... .........................                                    1, 015, 810. 06

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................                           ..........          1, 444, 350. 05
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...... .....                ..............        ......         151, 600. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available ....................................                               1, 292, 750. 05

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts..... .......                                    306, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project....                                 2, 013, 920. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
   the balance unexpended July 1, 1909 .....................           .                           1, 560, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
   June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix V V 4.)
                                          aFor south jetty only.
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     865
   5. Clatskanie River, Oregon.-The Clatskanie River rises in the
Coast Range and empties into the Columbia River 65 miles below
Portland, Oreg. Before it reaches the Columbia it winds, for 3
miles, through marshy low lands, and by a narrow, tortuous channel.
Before improvement the obstructions to navigation were a single
shoal with but 2 to 3 feet of water, and two sharp bends below the
town of Clatskanie.
   The original and present project was adopted by the act of March
3, 1899, and provided for dredging out the shoal and cutting off the
two sharp bends by means of dredging, at an estimated cost of
$13,000.
   There has been expended on this work, to the close of the fiscal
year, the total sum of $12,675.47, of which sum $868.10 was applied
to maintenance. There has been no work done during the past
year, as the amount available was not sufficient to accomplish any
results.
   A permit was granted to the Columbia Agricultural Company,
under date of January 5, 1909, to dredge across a bend near the
mouth for the purpose of diking some of the low land. This work
was commenced in June.
   All of the work contemplated under the present project was com-
pleted in 1902, and resulted in giving a depth of 5 feet over the
shoalest places, and in making the channel shorter by 4,050 feet
and easier of navigation. Clatskanie, a small town 3 miles above
its mouth, is the head of navigation, and at the close of the fiscal
year about 31 feet could be carried over the shoalest part of the
channel.
   The whole stretch of the river is tidal, with a variation of water
level, due to tides only, of about 5 feet. The backwater of the
Columbia, during freshet time, raises the river to a maximum height
of about 10 feet.
   The stream is used extensively for logging purposes, as there are
fine forests of fir, hemlock, spruce, and cedar along its banks, reaching
to the headwaters.
   The commerce of Clatskanie River consists principally of sawmill
products, farm and dairy products, and general supplies. During
the calendar year 1908 this commerce amounted to 46,382 tons,
valued at, approximately, $381,492.
   The Astoria and Columbia River Railroad crosses the valley
about 1 miles from the town of Clatskanie, but the greater portion
of the business is done by boat, because of the cheaper rates for
transportation. The commerce is handled by a boat making three
trips per week between the towns of Clatskanie and Portland.
   Since the completion of the improvement shoaling has taken place,
and the amount estimated as a profitable expenditure is for the pur-
pose of redredging the shoals and furnishing better facilities for the
increased commerce.
   The total amount estimated as a profitable expenditure should be
appropriated, owing to the fact that the balance remaining of the
old appropriation ($324.53) has been returned to the surplus fund,
as provided by section 10 of the act of March 4, 1909.
   For further information regarding this improvement, attention
is invited to the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1898,
     9001-ENG 1909-55
866                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                U.      S. ARMY.

page 3049, and House Document No. 134, Fiftieth Congress, first
session.
                                                     Comparative statement of traffic.


                                            Calendar year.                                                            Tons.         Estiated             Pen-
                                                                                                                                        value,             gers.

                                                                                                                                                        Number.
1899...........................................................................                                                     68,126 ............            5,210
1900....................................................................                                                            88,622 ............            5,305
1901.................................................................                                                               51,967. ..........             2,136
1902 .............................                                  ...................................                             23, 79Q ............           1,180
1903............. ...........                                 ...........                 ........                     ........
                                                                                                         ..................         25,765-............              494
1904.............................                                     ..................................                            18, 861      $444,210            525
1905.........................................                                                                                       16,408         612,970 ...
1906......................................................                                                       ............       10,339         216,630 .......
1907...............................................................                                                                 22,925         280,616           502
1908. .....                        ...........................................................                                  ... 46,382         381,492           422


July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ............ . . ........................ $324. 53
Reverted to the surplus fund, as provided by section 10 of act of March
  4, 1909............................................................... 324.53
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement. ........................... ........                                                                            500. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
      (See Appendix V V 5.)
   6. Cowlitz and Lewis rivers, Washington.-(a) Cowlitz River.-
The Cowlitz River rises in the Cascade Range, flows in a southerly
direction, and empties into the Columbia 64 miles above its mouth
and about 45 miles below Portland. Prior to improvement the rul-
ing depth to Toledo, 40 miles above the mouth, was about 14 inches
at low water, and the channel was crooked and obstructed by sand
bars, snags, and drift.
   The original and present project was adopted by the act of June
14, 1880, and provided for the removal of sand bars and other obstruc-
tions to a point about 50 miles above the mouth, at a cost of $5,000,
and an annual expenditure thereafter of $2,000 for maintenance.
   The expenditures to the close of the fiscal year amounted to
$51,528.01, of which $46,529.01 has been applied to maintenance.
   Operations during the past fiscal year consisted in clearing the
channel of some troublesome snags. The work was done in April, by
small boat and crew, by blasting.
   The project, except as to maintenance, has been completed. The
work done in previous years has resulted in furnishing a compara-
tively easy channel for boats running to Portland. The maximum
draft that can be carried over the shoalest places at the close of the
year is approximately 14 to 16 inches at low water. The usual varia-
tions of the level of water surfaces, due to tide, range from 4 feet at
the mouth to zero 9 miles up the stream. The extreme variation
on account of freshets is about 22 feet, except at the mouth, where
the country is open, allowing the water to spread over a large area,
The head of navigation for light-draft boats on the higher stages is
10 miles above Toledo, or about 50 miles from the mouth. Large
quantities of logs are annually floated down the river from the head-
waters, for a distance of 25 to 90 miles.
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                            867
   Kelso, 41 miles from the mouth, and having a population of about
1,500 people, is the principal town of the valley, and is the center of
a large lumber and shingle industry. Kelso and Castle Rock, another
small town about 20 miles from the mouth, are both on the main line
of the Northern Pacific Railway, and while some lumber products
are shipped by rail, the farm products are usually handled by the
river boats and marketed at Portland. The river is therefore a great
factor in regulating freight rates from these points to competing
points on the river. The traffic consists of lumber and farm products
and general merchandise, of which 53,309 tons were handled during
the calendar year 1908, valued at $1,934,982.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure is required to
maintain the channel and remove the obstructions which are brought
down the stream during freshet periods. Annual work is necessary
to make the improvement available.
   References to former reports will be found on page 689 of the
Annual Report for 1905. Report of survey made in October, 1908,
with estimate of cost of improvement, from the mouth to Castle
Rock, is printed in House Document No. 1167, Sixtieth Congress,
second session.
                                        Comparative statement of traffic.

                                                                                                     Estimated      Passen-
                                                                                                                     gers.
                                  Calendar year.                                          Tons.        value.


                                                                                                                                     Number.
1899................................. .............................                                 26,511 ...............
1900..................................................................                              17,279 ..........             ........
1901............................................................................................... 14,211          .........
1902................................................................                                15,932 ......... .........
1903.....................................................................                           41,515 ....               ...........
1904.............................................................................................   26,120 $1,069,020                      6,875
1905.............................................................................................   46,646      1,494,260                  6,000
1906............................................................................................... 56,109      2,055.460                  1,117
1907 ..........................................................................                .... 66,424      3,390,000                    759
1908.................................................                  ........ ..............      53,309      1,934,982..

  This statement does not include 187,734,187 feet b. m. (375,468 tons) of logs sent down this stream in
1908, having an estimated value of $1,126,404.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................... $1, 421. 67
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement .....................................................         299.68

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                                           1, 121.99
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909. ......................................                                                       (a)
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (b) Lewis River.-The Lewis River rises in the Cascade Range,
flows in a westerly direction, and empties into the Columbia River
about 14 miles below the mouth of the Willamette and 25 miles
below Portland. At a distance about 34miles from its mouth the
river separates into two branches, known as the North Fork and the
East Fork, of which the North Fork is the larger stream. The lower
reaches are affected by the tides and also by back water from the
                           a See consolidated money statement on page 869.
868      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

Columbia. Originally the channels were obstructed by snags, over-
hanging trees, and occasional shoals, but were navigable for small,
light-draft boats at proper stages to La Center on the East Fork and
Woodland on the North Fork.
   The original project was adopted in 1897 (see Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1897, p. 3473). It provided for the removal
of snags and obstructions, dike construction and dredging, with a
view to securing a depth of 6 feet in the main river and 4 feet on the
East Fork to La Center. The estimated cost was $20,460.
   The present project is the same as the original one, except that the
improvement of the North Fork was included in the river and harbor
act of June 13, 1902, for which no estimate of cost has been made.
   There has been expended on the original and modified project to
the close of the fiscal year the sum of $21,114.62.
   Operations during the year were confined to snagging and clearing
overhanging trees from the banks. The work was done in January,
and a total of 132 snags were removed from the channel and 169
trees cut from the banks. This work was done by the U. S. snagboat
Mathloma after completion of operations on the upper Willamette
River.
   The work done in previous years has resulted in a good channel for
boats plying between Portland and Lewis River points. The maxi-
mum draft that can be carried at normal stages to the forks is about
4 feet, and on the two forks to the head of navigation about 1 foot.
   The head of navigation on the North Fork has heretofore been con-
sidered at Woodland, but at the present time a small boat is making
three regular trips per week to Runyon, about 23 miles above Wood-
land.
   The variation of the water surfaces, due to tides, is from 2 feet at
the mouth to 1 feet at La Center, while at Woodland the tide has
no effect. The winter freshets vary from 15 to 20 feet in height,
except near the mouth, where the water spreads out over a large area,
and the conditions are such that regular boats from Portland reach
La Center during about three months of each year and Woodland
about nine months. Logs are floated down this stream for a distance
of 20 to 45 miles above the mouth.
   The Northern Pacific Railway, between Portland and Puget
Sound, crosses the river at Woodland, but the river carries the
greater part of the commerce from the valley, owing to the cheaper
rates of transportation and the better facilities for handling traffic by
water. The commerce consists principally of lumber, farm products,
and general supplies, and during the calendar year 1908 amounted
to 17,771 tons, valued at approximately $1,112,840. This does not
include large quantities of logs floated down the stream.
   The amount estimated as a profitable expenditure is required for
dredging and snagging. A large amount of sediment and numerous
snags are brought down by the freshets, which necessitates addi-
tional work each year to maintain the channel and make it available
for boats of light draft.
   References to former reports are given on page 690 of the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905.
                                      IlVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                                   869
                                                   Comparative statement of traffic.


                                           Calendar year.                                                        Tons.         Estimaed            Passen-
                                                                                                                                  value,             gers.

                                                                                                                                                              Number.
1899 .........            .................          ..................................                                  ........      6,549............. 12,351
1900.......................................................................................                                           12,38........14,129
1901. ..........           . ...... ...........................................                                                 ..... 17,277 ............ 15,532
    ...............
1.902                                   ........ ....................                                   ................              13,831--------
                                                                                                                                                 ............ 13,098
1903.......................                         ................                ............................                      29,033 --............13,058
1904...............                       ...................................................                                         27,245 9834, 492          12,885
1905...............................................................................                                                   26,554 1,067,733          29,026
1906.....................................................................                                                             19,024          960,120   16,614
1907. ...............................                                  ................................                               20,140 1,179,117          13,869
1908.... .............................................................                                                         .....  17,771 1,112,840          13,880

  This statement does not include 49,451,021 feet b. m. (98,962 tons) of logs sent down this stream in 1908,
having an estimated value of $296,706.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................... $3, 290. 42
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement--..--....   ..................... ...................... 1, 555. 04

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.........--.............................                                                                       1, 735. 38
IAmount  that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909..............................                                                                                   (a)
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                                                 CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................               $4, 712. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement.....................................                               1, 854. 72
                                                                  .....................

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..............................                                                                 ......          2, 857. 37
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
  balance unexpended July 1, 1909.................................                                                                             7, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
     (See Appendix V V 6.)
   7. Grays River, Washington.-Grays River is a tributary of the
Columbia River, emptying into Grays Bay, nearly opposite the town
of Astoria, Oreg. It rises in the Coast Range and flows through
dense forests until it reaches the lowlands bordering on the Columbia
River. It has been navigated for years with difficulty, owing
principally to numerous snags and logs and overhanging trees.
   The original and present project was adopted by the act of March
2, 1907, which appropriated $2,500 for the purpose of removing the
obstructions from the channel and cutting the overhanging trees
from the banks. The project for this work was based on a report
of the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, dated October 13,
1906, by which it was proposed to carry the improvement to the
head of navigation.
                                  a See consolidated money statement on this page.
870           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                       S. ARMY.

   The total amount expended on this work to the close of the last
fiscal year was $2,129.47.
   Operations during the year were carried on from September 1 to 25,
1908, with a small snagging crew using a gasoline launch. A total
of 195 troublesome snags were removed by the use of powder, of
which approximately 600 pounds were used. Scraping of the bars
between the mouth and the town of Grays River was also carried on
by means of a hoisting engine, from May 18 to June 9, and at the
close of the fiscal year there was a good, clear, and open channel to
the head of navigation.
   It may be stated that all of the work contemplated under the project
has been completed, and has resulted in furnishing a safe and easier
channel for small boats navigating the stream. The maximum draft
that can be carried to Grays River, a small town 8 miles above the
mouth, is about 3 feet at low water.
   The variation of water surfaces, due to tides, is from 5 to 8 feet.
   This stream is used extensively for logging purposes, logs being
floated from the headwaters, a distance of about 10 miles.
   The commerce of this stream consists principally of logs towed from
the lower portion of the stream to the mills along the Columbia, and
some farm products and supplies handled by a small boat plying
from Astoria. Statistics, other than 938,000 feet of logs towed, are
not available.
   The river is the only means of transportation, and aside from fur-
nishing easier navigation for the lightdraft boats using the channel,
it is not believed the improvement will have any tendency to reduce
the present rates of transportation.
   The winter freshets usually bring down snags and logs, and the
available balance, together with the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure, will be applied to the purpose of removing them, as may
be necessary.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................... $1, 386. 70
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement...................................................         1, 016.17
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ............................                              .......   370. 53
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities...............................                          ....   260. 15

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                              110. 38

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
    pended July 1, 1909... .                   ...........       .....................               500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix V V 7.)
   8. Gauging waters of Columbia River, Oregon.-The object of this
gauging is to obtain data for use in connection with the improvement
of the river and to supply information to persons interested in its
navigation.
   The self-registering gauge was established at Astoria in November,
1888, where it was kept in operation up to August, 1899, and then
moved to Fort Stevens, where it could be more economically main-
tained. A river gauge was also established at the mouth of the
Willamette River and daily records of the readings kept. In view of
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                             871
the benefit to commerce, the maintenance of these gauges is con-
sidered a worthy object.
   The amount expended on this work, principally for gauge readers,
up to June 30, 1909, was $8,649.94.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....... ..............    ............... $1, 470. 06
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provem ent .........................................................        120. 00
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................            -.   1, 350. 06
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................            10. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available .........................................         1, 340. 06
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909----------------------------..---------------1, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897.
    (See Appendix V V 8.)

EXAMINATION             AND SURVEY MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH RIVER                      AND
                       HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2, 1907.

   Reports dated January 11, 1908, and October 8, 1908, on prelimi-
nary examination and survey, respectively, of Cowlitz River, Wash-
ington, up to Castlerock, required by the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907, were duly submitted by the district officer. They were re-
viewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant
to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in House Docu-
ment No. 1167, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for im-
provement at an estimated cost of $22,000 is presented.

IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE SEATTLE, WASH-
                    INGTON, DISTRICT.

   This district was in the charge of Lieut. Col. H. M. Chittenden,
Corps of Engineers, to September 5, 1908, and of Maj. C. W. Kutz,
Corps of Engineers, since that date, having under his immediate orders
First Lieut. J. H. Earle since February 1, 1909. Division engineers,
Lieut. Col. S. W. Roessler, Corps of Engineers, to July 11, 1908, and
Lieut. Col. John Biddle, Corps of Engineers, temporarily, since that
date.
   1. Willapa River and Harbor, Washington.---Willapa Harbor con-
nects with the Pacific Ocean in the extreme southwestern part of the
State of Washington. Willapa River flows into the bay at its eastern
extremity, about 10 miles from the sea entrance to the harbor.
   South Bend, near the mouth of the river, the terminus of a branch
line of the Northern Pacific, and Raymond, about 3 miles above South
Bend, are the principal towns in that locality. Willapa is a small
town 10 miles above South Bend. North River is a stream flowing
into the bay from the north, and Nasel River is an arm making off
from the southeast part of the bay proper.
   Originally shoals existed in the river below Willapa, and there was
a log jam in North River.
   The original project adopted by act of July 13, 1892, contemplated
dredging 100 feet wide to a depth of 8 feet at low water through the
872                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                      U.   S. ARMY.


reef just below Willapa and the closing of side sloughs near South Bend
by means of dikes, with the object of increasing channel depths by
scour. This project was modified by act of March 2, 1907, which pro-
vided for dredging a channel 150 feet wide and 12 feet deep at mean
lower low water through the shoals between South Bend and Ray-
mond at an estimated cost of $25,000.
   Under acts of August 18, 1894, and March 3, 1899, removal of the
log jam in North River was authorized.
   The amount expended on original and existing project to close of
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was $61,008.70, of which $4,210.26
was applied to the maintenance of dikes and for inspection of obstruc-
tions to navigation.
   The dredging work authorized by act of March 2, 1907, was com-
menced November 15, 1907, and completed February 29, 1908. The
work was done by contract.
   The expsnditures during the past fiscal year were in connection
with the establishment of harbor lines and for inspections.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance of
existing channels and dikes.
   The best channel depth at mean lower low water is now about 16
feet to South Bend, 12 feet to Raymond, and about 6 feet to Willapa.
   The extreme variation of water levels is 14 feet, and the mean
variation is 9 feet.
   The North and Nasel rivers are navigable only for small boats of
light draft for a comparatively short distance above their mouths,
and this distance is extremely variable with the tides. The principal
business on these rivers is the rafting and floating of logs. The log
and lumber business on Willapa Bay and tributary streams is by far
the most important part of the water traffic.
                                                          Exports and imports.

            Calendar year.                      Tons.       Value.                 Calendar year.                   Tons.     Value.

1898 ...................                        32, 399     $374, 050   1904..................                       73,808    $389,377
1899.       ..        .................         51,150       755,682    1905...        ................              76,713     456,213
1900 ...              ................          42,090       266, 080   1906......................                  116,717   1,220,434
1901.................                   .....   39,538       229, 686   1907......................                  183,801   1,847, 810
1902.............................               51,999       402,050    1908......             ..............       214,812   2,347,253
1903......................                      74,475       446,800

  The direct effect on freight rates of the work done is not known
definitely.
  Reference to reports, etc., may be found in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1907, page 781.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................                                                          $511. 86
Received from sales...................................................                                                           1. 00
                                                                                                                               512. 86
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improvement.                                                   170. 06
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                                                          342. 80
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
    for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
    July 1, 1909 .......  ............   ...........................          5, 000.00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
      (See Appendix W W 1.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVE1MENTS.                   873
   2. Grays Harbor and bar entrance, Washington. Grays Harbor is a
large bay in the southwestern part of the State of Washington con-
necting with the Pacific Ocean. It has a total length from east to
west of 17 miles, and its greatest breadth north and south is 14 miles.
   A large part of the bay is occupied by tide flats, bare at low water.
At low tide the area covered by water is estimated at 30.6 square
miles, or less than one-third of the total area.
   A short distance within the harbor entrance are large areas afford-
ing anchorage for deep-draft vessels.
   The harbor entrance is between two low sandy peninsulas, which
are about 12,500 feet apart, measured between high-tide lines.
   Through this entrance there is a channel having a maximum depth
of 100 feet or more. A single broad waterway extends for more than
2 miles out to sea from the entrance, with depths gradually diminish-
ing to 30 feet. At the outer end of this deep waterway lies a bar
convex to the sea and extending each way to the sand spits on the
two sides of the harbor throat.
   Across the bar there was originally no good permanent channel,
but there were several variable, shifting channels having depths of
about 12 or 13 feet. The general average width of the bar between
the inner and outer 18-foot curves was one-half mile.
   The original project, adopted by Congress June 3, 1896, provided
for the control of tidal currents by means of a single jetty extending
                   1miles,
out to sea from the point on the south side of the harbor throat a
distance of about 3           with a view to improving and maintaining
the channel over the bar by scour. The jetty was to be of rubble-
stone, built above high-tide level. This project contemplated a
depth of 24 feet at mean low water.
   The estimated cost was $1,000,000. The act making the first
appropriation for this work authorized the making of a continuing
contract or contracts. In accordance with this authority a contract
for the entire work was entered into after due advertisement. Work
under this contract was commenced in March, 1898, and terminated
September 15, 1902. The jetty was constructed for a distance of
13,734 feet from the ocean high-water line. No construction work
on the south jetty has been done since.
   The project was enlarged by the river and harbor act of March 2,
1907, which provided for the construction of a jetty on the north side
of the harbor throat, extending out to sea about 9,000 feet from the
ocean high-water line, at an estimated cost of $600,000. The act ap-
propriated $200,000 and authorized continuing contracts for com-
pleting the project in the additional sum of $400,000, which amount
has been appropriated.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $1,343,075.28, of which
$7,235.72 was for maintenance and surveys.
   The work on the north jetty has been in progress since October 1,
1907. The necessary land for approach and operating plant was do-
nated to the United States by local interests. The trestle approach
to the jetty and the wharf and other features of the shore works were
built under contract, the work commencing on October 24, 1907, and
being completed March 31, 1908. A contract has been made for the
stone for the jetty, the other material being furnished under emergency
contracts or purchase in open market.
874              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U.    S. ARMY.

   During the fiscal year 7,376 linear feet of trestle were constructed,
and at the close of the fiscal year the trestle had been built to its pro-
jected length, 10,000 feet from the ocean high-water line. The mat-
tress foundation was placed the entire length of the trestle and 67,467
tons of stone were placed during the year. The enrockment for a dis-
tance of about 5,000 feet from the high-water line is 6- feet above the
plane of mean lower low water, and for the outer 5,000 feet of the
jetty the enrockment varies from 6 feet above to 10 feet below that
plane.
   A survey of the bar was made during May, 1909, and the controlling
depth was found to be 19 feet at mean lower low water.
   The original project for the improvement of the entrance to Grays
Harbor contemplated securing and maintaining a depth of 24 feet at
mean lower low water. The modified and existing project was adopt-
ed to assist in securing the depth contemplated by the original project
and to correct serious deterioration of the channel, which had oc-
curred. The funds appropriated for theconstruction of the north
jetty will be sufficient to complete it to the extent contemplated by
the modified project, but to secure the proposed depth of 24 feet it
will probably be necessary to extend the north jetty approximately
4,000 feet and raise thethe enrockment to the plane of high water.
   Reference is made to the report of a Board of Engineers published
in House Document No. 576, Fifty-eighth Congress, second session.
   The work of maintenance consisted only in care of the property.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
lower low water over the shoalest part of the channel was 19 feet.
   The extreme variation of water levels in the outer portion of the
harbor is 16.5 feet, while the mean variation is 8.4 feet.
   So far as known the improvement has not caused any reduction in
freight rates.
   The commerce benefited by the work consists at present principally
of exportation of lumber, carried in sail and steam vessels. This is a
large and important business.
                                                    Exports and imports.

         Calendar year.                 Tons.      Value.              Calendar year.                  Tons.         Value.

1898....... ....-           - . --...   168,468   $1,252,089   1904.. ..................                         495,495  $4,200,784
1899.........................           265,918    1,979,998   1905------..              --.........
                                                                             ----...-----.......                 579,759 5,552,166
1900-........................           259,692    2,077,037   1906--..---....------......-------........        614,854   7,735,954
                          ...
1901....-----------------......    ..   299,607    1,877,800   1907----------..      .....--------               747,725 8,862,687
1902.........................           527,047    3,601,163   1908... ..                .......------------------827,154 7,421,311
1903.        ..------------------       458,268    4,073,333

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......      .                              $430, 921. 61
                                                  ...........................
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909...... 100, 000. 00
Received from sales....................................... ............             3. 75

                                                                                                                530, 925. 36
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment......................     ......................................                                         243, 993.29

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................                                           286, 932. 07
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities....................................                                         3, 293. 56
July 1, 1909, balance available........................................                                         283, 638. 51
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts.................                                          266, 303. 73
    (See Appendix W W 2.)
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                    875
    3. Grays Harbor (inner portion) between Aberdeen and the entrance
to said harbor, and Chehalis River, Washington.-There are two main
channels traversing the inner or eastern part of Grays Harbor from
east to west-the North and South channels. There was also for-
merly a Middle channel connecting the North and South channels.
The South channel is shoal and is but little used. The North chan-
nel is used by all ocean-going vessels entering the harbor. There are
two shoals in the North channel, one about 21 miles below Hoquiam
and one between Hoquiam and Aberdeen. The ruling depth over
these shoals was originally 8 feet at mean low water. The channel
widths were ample.
    The Chehalis River is in the southwestern part of Washington. It
has a westerly course and empties into Grays Harbor Bay at its
eastern extremity.
    From the mouth to Montesano, 15 miles, there is about 10 feet of
water at high tide. From Montesano to Elma, 16 miles, there is
generally sufficient water for light-draft boats. There is practically
no navigation above Elma and no regular boats go above Montesano.
The river is used extensively for floating saw logs.
    The original project for the inner harbor, adopted by Congress
July 13, 1892, provided for the construction of piles, brush, and stone
dikes to partly close up the South and Middle channels and concen-
trate the flow of water in the North channel, thereby increasing the
depth of water by scour. The shoals above and below.Hoquiam
were to be dredged to a depth of 16 feet at half tide.
    The amount expended prior to operations under existing project
was $93,999.06.
    The original project for Chehalis River, adopted by Congress
August 2, 1882, contemplated the removal of snags and other obstruc-
tions which may accumulate in the portion of the river regularly
used by boats. The estimated cost is indefinite.
    The existing project adopted by the river and harbor act of March
2, 1907, provides for a channel 200 feet wide and 18 feet deep at mean
lower low water from Cosmopolis to deep water below Hoquiam, and
removing snags from the Chehalis River, at an estimated cost of
 $187,500. This plan is printed in House Document No. 507, Fifty-
ninth Congress, first session.
    Report on examination and survey of the Chehalis River, made in
compliance with the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, was
published in House Document No. 1125, Sixtieth Congress, second
session.
    To June 30, 1909, $252,864.77 had been expended under the above
project for Grays Harbor, inner portion, of which $20,440.38 was
applied to maintenance of dikes and for surveys.
    Two middle dikes and a protecting sill, with an aggregate length of
13,986 feet, had been constructed in the inner harbor, and six high-
tide dikes, with an aggregate length of 1,476 feet, had been con-
structed in the Chehalis River. The depth of water over the shoals
in the inner harbor was increased about 2 feet and over the shoals
in the Chehalis River from 2 to 7 feet, but these depths were not
permanent.
    The dredging work under the existing project was done by con-
tract. It was commenced December 16, 1907, and the total quantity
of material removed was 1,200,000 cubic yards. The quantity
876          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                             tU.S.   ARMY.


removed during the fiscal year was 300,000 cubic yards. The
contract was completed on August 24, 1908.
   The project was partially completed with the funds available, but
the channel secured is not of the full width contemplated by the act
of March 2, 1907. It is expected to obtain the full project width
by operating the new dredge Oregon with funds provided by the
river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, over the
shoals below Aberdeen at mean lower low water was about 18 feet.
   The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1907, at mean
low water at Montesano was about 5 feet.
   The tidal variation is 82 feet in the inner harbor and 7 feet in the
Chehalis River.
   The commerce benefited by this improvement consists very largely
of floating and towing logs and carrying lumber in sailing vessels and
steam schooners.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance of
existing works.
                                        Exports and imports.

       Calendar year.           Tons.       Value.            Calendar year.       Tons.      Value.

          ...................2,730
1898.....--                         $293,610 1904........................  5,637   $248,825
1899.........................2,232   352,316 1905---..                 -- 17,195
                                                       ...........--------------........
                                                                                    650.428
                             4,376
1900...............-------.........  132,157 1906 ........................11,567    773,574
1901.........................5,706   200,264 1907........................9,414      687,703
1902.........................3,529   157,532 1908......... .............. 38,004    595,718
1903.........................4,972   139,150



  No definite information of reduction of freight rates on account of
the improvement has been received.
  Reference to reports, projects, etc., may be found on page 785 of
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................... $92, 404. 73
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  M arch 3, 1909.................................. ................ .... 25, 000. 00
Received from sales ........................ ..............      ...........     27. 00

                                                                                           117, 431. 73
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment .........................    ................................                        88, 268. 56

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ....................................                       29, 163. 17

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909 ................ ......................    ........16, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix W W 3.)
  4. Puget sound and its tributary waters, Washington.-Most of the
channels of Puget Sound proper have ample depths for purposes of
navigation, but the extensive lumber and fishing industries in these
waters render it very important to maintain a general supervision
over the navigable channels, to regulate the construction of fish
traps, log booms, and other structures incident to these important
industries, and to prevent obstructions which are detrimental to
general navigation. A number of streams and rivers tributary to
                             RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                           877
Puget Sound are of great value to boat navigation, but they are all
liable to be obstructed by the d6bris generally found in streams
flowing through a heavily wooded country.
   All these streams are used to a greater or less extent for floating
logs and shingle bolts, and the towing of log rafts and timber pro-
ducts constitutes the main part of the commerce. The distance
upstream to which boats run is extremely variable, depending on
the stage of water and tide. Steamboat navigation on the Skagit
extends as far up as the mouth of the Sauk, but boats do not often
ascend above Hamilton or Birdsview. No survey has been author-
ized by Congress above Sedro Woolley, 25 miles above the mouth of
the river. On the Stilaguamish boats do not go above Florence, 6
miles from the mouth. The Snohomish is navigable for river boats
to the Forks, 22 miles, and the lower portion of one of its tributaries,
the Skykomish, is navigable at high stages. The Snoqualmie River
is navigable at a low-water stage for a distance of 30 miles from the
Forks, and at high stages for an additional distance of 20 miles.
On the Duwamish small boats go as far the junction of the White
and Black rivers, about 16 miles from the mouth. Under favorable
conditions they can go several miles up the White, and occasionally
boats pass up the Black into Lake Washington. On all these streams
the distances to which steamboat navigation actually extends are
generally less, and the distances over which towing and floating of
logs extend are greater than the distances above named. None of
these streams is closed in winter by ice. All are affected by the
tidal variation in Puget Sound, which is large and extremely irregular.
   The work of improvement consists in the maintenance of the navi-
gable channels by snagging and removing obstructions.
    Formerly works of improvement were carried on under specific
appropriations, but since the act of June 13, 1902, appropriations
have been made in the present general and comprehensive form,
except in cases of large local works. This method operates greatly
to the advantage and economy of the work.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was, $337,387.60.
   The act of March 2, 1907, provided for the removal of the rock in
the entrance to Roche Harbor at a cost not to exceed $30,000. The
work was begun October 1, 1907, under contract, and completed
April 17, 1908.
   The water traffic on Puget Sound and its tributary waters is very
large and rapidly growing. It includes vessels of about every type
and size in use throughout the world, but it is quite impracticable to
give in the form of concise statistics a condensed statement of the
amount and value of the commerce more or less directly benefited
by work under this appropriation. Statistics have been compiled
only for the tributary streams on which the snag boat has mostly
worked.
                                          Exports and imports.

        Calendar year.           Tons.      Value.            Calendar year.             Tons.     Value.

1898.........................    12,676     $539,406    1904........................      92,465   $1,790,823
1899 ........................    13,500      577,586    1905........................      86,412    1,817,048
1900.........................    35,066    1,324,926    1906..... .........        ...   167,197    1,898, 057
1901........-.................   30,155    1,499,420    1907......................       124,336    3,011,146
1902......................       61,794    2,324,980    1908.... ..      .............    44,922    1,659,930
1903......................       94,274    3,193, 458
878                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                    U.     S. ARMY.

   No definite information relative to effect of the work on freight
rates is available, but the increasing number of vessels engaged indi-
cates greater competition.
   Reports of examinations and surveys of the rivers of Puget Sound
are referred to in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904,
page 692.
   Reports on examinations and surveys of the Skagit and Snohomish
rivers under the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, were published
in House Documents Nos. 1188 and 1108, Sixtieth Congress, second
session.
   Reference to reports on the examination and survey of the Duwa-
mish River authorized by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905,
will be found on page 787 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1906.
   During the past.year the snag boat operated extensively in all parts
of the Sound, doing a large amount of work.
   The snag boat is no longer capable of serving the needs of the dis-
trict. It was built in 1882, the hull renewed in 1896, and it is now
in a condition that practically requires another renewal. It is not
sufficiently seaworthy to be safe in ordinary rough weather in the
Sound. A new plant is required, and it is proposed to provide a com-
bined snag boat and small suction dredge to do such work as is not of
sufficient magnitude to be undertaken by contract.
   There is a considerable amount of miscellaneous work in the dis-
trict that is paid from this appropriation, such as investigation of
harbor lines, bridges, obstructions, occasional surveys, gauge read-
ings, etc.
   The snag boat was in commission three hundred and thirty-five
days during the year and laid up undergoing repairs for a period of
thirty days.
   The following table shows the work accomplished on the streams
tributary to Puget Sound:

                                                                                             Number                        Number
                               Name of river.                                        Time.    of snags Length.             of trees          Length.
                                                                                             removed.                        cut.

                                                                                     Days.                    Feet.                           Feet.
Skagit...        .....................................                                 151      1,774         28,119               149         14,020
Snohomish --......-----------------------------------                                   90      1, 257        21, 122              224         12, 835
Snoqualmie... ....................                     .....................            67      1,494         22,289              248          13,200
Stilaguamish.................--------------------.............----------------...       19        207          2,596 ................
Swinom ish Slough                        -.......... -............. ............         8          5             156 ....................

         Total..........           -            ....
                                             -.-...                     ..........     335      4,737         74,282              621          40,055


   The Snoqualmie River was cleared of snags and made navigable
for small vessels for a distance of 30 miles. One gasoline vessel now
makes daily trips over that portion of the river, which it was impossi-
ble to do prior to the removal of obstructions by the snag boat.
                            RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                         879
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......... .................     ..... $23, 937. 30
Amount allotted from appropriations by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909---    --------------------------------------------- 25, 000. 00
Miscellaneous receipts...       -..................
                                            ..........................      126. 35
                                                                                                               49, 063. 65
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..-----------...........................---------------------------------...........--------........     21, 161. 75
                                                                                                           --...
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...-...-.......                ... .-.-....   27, 901. 90
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ............--
                                               ------..........------
                                                     ...              ----     5, 202. 02
                                                                           ---...
July 1, 1909, balance available......-.................                             ..............          22, 699. 88
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of the
   balance unexpended July 1, 1909-......-.......................... 120, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899
    (See Appendix W W 4.)
   5. Inspection of fish traps, etc., Puget Sound, Washington.-The
fishing industry on Puget Sound has rapidly developed during the
past few years, and it has now reached very large proportions. Until
four years ago the fish traps were placed with little or no regard to
the established aids to navigation or to the laws relative to structures
in navigable waters, but during the year 1904 the fishing companies
were brought to the adoption of a different policy. Since 1904 this
work has been done under allotments from the appropriation for
 "Examinations, surveys, and contingencies of rivers and harbors."
Under these allotments a tug was hired for the inspection of fish traps
from time to time as necessary. A tug was so engaged for two months
during the year.
   As a general rule all the fish-trap owners and fishing companies
now readily conform to the requirements that have been imposed for
the safety of navigation, and the federal supervision of the traps in
the interest of navigation is recognized locally as most necessary and
beneficial to the public interests.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $31,470.89, of
which $3,346.47 was expended during the year.
   Form of permit and rules relative to lights and fog signals were
published in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905,
pages 2558-2560.
   To carry out more effectively and economically the inspection of
fish traps and other obstructions to navigation an inspection boat
has been constructed for exclusive use in this work. The boat is 63
feet long, 11 feet 6 inches breadth of beam, and has a draft of 4 feet,
and is propelled by a 50-horsepower gasoline engine.
   (See Appendix W W 5.)
  6. Harbor of Olympia, Wash.-Olympia is situated at the extreme
southern point of Puget Sound at the head of Budd Inlet. The upper
end of this inlet is shoal. Shoal water extends northward from the
Fourth Street Bridge for a distance of 8,750 feet to a depth of 12 feet
at mean lower low water in Budd Inlet.- Originally nothing but
shallow-draft boats could reach the wharves near Fourth Street
Bridge, and those only at high tide.
880             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                              U.      S. ARMY.

   The original and existing project, adopted by Congress by act of
July 13, 1892, contemplates dredging a channel 250 feet wide and 12
feet deep at the mean of the lower low waters from the vicinity of the
Fourth Street Bridge to deep water in Budd Inlet.
   Near its inner end the channel has been widened to 500 feet, so as
to provide a turning basin for boats using it. The estimated cost is
$147,000.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $139,946.09, of which
$1,066.86 was for maintenance. The expenditures during the past
year were for inspections and the preparation of commercial statistics.
   The dredging of the channel and basin was completed in accord-
ance with the project under contract. The maximum draft that
could be carried through the channel and basin on June 30, 1907, at
low water was 12 feet. The maximum tidal variation is about 20
feet.
   The commerce of the harbor is of general character and is carried
on by ocean-going sailing vessels engaged in the lumber trade and by
a variety of the smaller classes of boats plying between the ports of
Puget Sound. Sufficient depth for seagoing vessels has not yet been
secured in the dredged channel and basin, though vessels of the
deepest draft can go as far as the entrance of the dredged channel,
and sailing vessels carrying lumber now reach wharves near the
entrance to the dredged channel at high tide and lie in a dredged
basin while loading.
                                                   Exports and imports.

         Calendar year.                  Tons.        Value.                  Calendar year.               Tons.    Value.

1898--------.....-......--...----.......------- 52,335 $1,203,226 1904.......................              20,152    $356,450
1899-----------......-.........--...--.....-----42,694      1,173,684  1905.......................         62,804   2,069,289
1900.......----..--........--      ........ 35,466             848,703 1906.. -           ....-..-..
                                                                                             -.....  .     82,024   2,363,433
1901-----....---..-----........-------..........44,559         951,435 1907-...........-..... ....         95,171   2,846,955
1902a-----.....------..---.......---..--..-----.......
                                                  ----------.....      1908.......................--.      51,140 2,737,708
1903--..---..---..--..-------.........--..      40,333         341,635

                                                        a Not obtainable.

  No definite information as to the effect on freight rates of the work
done isavailable.
  Description and map are published in Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1900, pages 4481 to 4483.
   Reports on examination and survey of Olympia Harbor are referred
to inAnnual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 694.
   Reference to reports on examination and survey authorized by the
river and harbor act of March 3,1905, will be found on page 787 of the
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ..................................... $7, 119. 47
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provem ent..................................... ......................     65. 56

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................                                                      7, 053. 91
                                                                                        ....................
    (See Appendix W W 6.)
  7. Tacoma Harbor, Washington.-At the southern end of the harbor
are extensive tide flats, which are bare at low water. Outside of
these tide flats the depth increases very rapidly up to depths of 200
                           RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                             881

feet or more, reaching depths as great as 600 feet at the mouth of
the bay, about 3 miles distant from the low water line at its
southern end. The principal water front of Tacoma is along the
southwestern shore of the bay. Harbor lines have been established
around the south end of the bay and along its western side. In order
to facilitate commerce several waterways extending into the flats or
tide lands have been laid out. One of these is known as the City, or
West, waterway. The harbor of Tacoma may be considered to embrace
all of Commencement Bay, including the waterways mentioned.
   The extreme tidal variation is some 18 feet; mean variation, 14.5
feet.
   The original and existing project for improvement of the City
waterway, adopted by Congress by the act of June 13, 1902, con-
templates dredging in the City waterway from deep water in Com-
mencement Bay to Eleventh street to a depth of 25 feet, from Elev-
enth street to Fourteenth street to a depth of 18 feet, and from
Fourteenth street to the south end of waterway to a depth of 15 feet
at extreme low water. The dredging was done under a continuing
contract.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $203,421.49, of which
$12,322.71 was for maintenance, inspections, and surveys.
   The City waterway has been completed according to the project,
and the prescribed depths could therefore be carried for the whole
length and width of the waterway on June 30, 1906.
   The act of March 3, 1905, provided for improvement of the Puyallup
waterway by dredging a channel 500 feet in width and 3,650 feet in
length from its northern end and to a depth of 28 feet at extreme low
water, in accordance with the report submitted in House Document
No. 520, Fifty-eighth Congress, second session, at an estimated cost
of $240,000. The same act appropriated $40,000 and authorized
continuing contracts for completing the project in the sum of $200,000,
which has been appropriated. The act requires that certain portions
of the necessary work shall be done without expense to the United
States, and that provision for permanent maintenance of the project
without expense to the Government shall be made.
   The conditions named in the said act have been complied with,
and a contract was let for the work October 3, 1907, and is now in
progress.
   The commerce to be benefited by this improvement is of a large
and extremely varied character, including that carried on by sound
and river types of boats, as well as that of the largest steam and
sailing vessels. A very important item is the export of grain, in
which the port of Tacoma exceeds all other ports on Puget Sound.
   Report on examination and survey of Puyallup River under the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, was published in House Docu-
ment No. 1107, Sixtieth Congress, second session.
                                          Exports and imports.

      Calendar year.             Tons.       Value.             Calendar year.        Tons.       Value.

1903.........................   1,715,085 $58,153,845    1906 ................   .   1,120,070   $48,253,383
1904 ...................        1,561,074 53,726,772     1907...                     1,570,396    54, 163,018
1905 ......................     1,844, 338 65, 613,183   1908...                     1,183,296    44, 694,148


         9001-ENG 1909--56
882       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                 U.     S. ARMY.

  No definite information is available as to the effect of the improve-
ment on freight rates.
  Work was begun under the contract December 26, 1907.
  During the year 855,000 cubic yards of material were excavated
and placed behind the bulkheads. The bulkhead work was about
75 per cent completed at the end of the year. About one-third of
the waterway has been dredged to full dimensions.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....... ......  ................... $210, 072. 09
                                             .....
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......   40, 000. 00
                                                                                250, 072. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement...................... ......        $37, 586. 24
    For maintenance of improvement ....................               907. 34
                                                                                 38, 493. 58

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.......--............................. 211, 578. 51
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ..................................   197. 97

July 1, 1909, balance available_.....-..-............................ 211, 380. 54
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts-..............            161, 400. CO
   (See Appendix W W 7.)
   8. Waterway connecting Puget Sound with Lakes Union and Wash-
ington, Washington.-Lakes Union and Washington are bodies of
fresh water near Puget Sound, in the immediate vicinity of the city of
Seattle. Lake Union is entirely within the city limits. The pro-
posed improvement originally contemplated a ship canal connecting
both lakes with the sound. There is no navigable connection at
present.
   A succinct history of the project and references to reports, etc.,
may be found on pages 791 to 793 of the Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1907.
   The only actual work done on the proposed waterway has con-
sisted of dredging a channel from the sound to the wharves at Ballard,
in Salmon Bay, and the excavation of a cut between Lake Union and
Salmon Bay, for the control of the water level in Lake Union. The
work was done under the river and harbor acts of June 3, 1896, and
March 3, 1905. It has resulted in a channel 50 feet wide and 16 feet
deep at low water from Puget Sound to a point 2,000 feet west of the
lock site. From this point to the lock site the channel is 75 feet wide
and 16 feet deep. From the lock site to the railroad trestles at the
eastern part of Ballard Harbor the channel is 75 feet wide and 10 feet
deep at low water. A turning basin ranging from 175 feet to 500 feet
in width has been dredged at Ballard.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $470,072.77. Of this
amount $22,992.93 was expended in maintenance and on improve-
ment of drainage of Lake Washington. The expenditures during the
past year were for operating outlet gates and general care of the right
of way.
    The present commerce benefited by the improvement of the chan-
nel to Ballard is the towing of logs to the mills at Ballard and the
export of lumber and shingles from that place. Logs are brought in
in rafts and lumber is loaded on sailing vessels and scows at the mills
and then towed to the open sound.
                RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                     883

   It has not been practicable to determine what effect the improve-
ment work has had upon freight rates.
   The maximum draft that could be carried to the wharves at Ballard,
June 30, 1909, at extreme low water, was 10 feet. The maximum
tidal variation is about 18 feet.
   Early in 1906 a movement was started for the construction of the
canal with local funds and to this end secured the passage of an act
of Congress, approved June 11, 1906, authorizing James A. Moore or
his assigns to construct a canal along the government right of way-
connecting the waters of Puget Sound with Lake Washington. This
act was modified by the act of March 2, 1907, so as to permit Mr.
Moore or his assigns to commute the work required under the pre-
vious act to excavation alone of a canal from deep water in Puget
Sound to deep water in Lake Washington, with a bottom width of 75
feet and a depth at mean low water of 25 feet. The same act di-
rected a survey and estimate of cost of a canal with a single lock and
a report as to what contribution, if any, local interests would make
toward its construction.
    To assist the United States through the agency of the Moore acts in
building a canal, the county of King voted a bond issue of $500,000
on September 12, 1906. These bonds were declared invalid by the
supreme court of the State. An attempt was made by the legislature
to remedy the defect, but its efforts were not upheld by the supreme
court.
    On March 13, 1907, the State legislature passed an act creating a
local assessment district, embracing territory that would be benefited
by the canal, and empowering the district to raise by taxation a sum
not exceeding 1 per cent of the taxable valuation of the county, and
to use the money so received to aid in constructing the canal. The
board of appraisement was appointed by the local United States dis-
trict judge, and the money is to be expended under the direction of
the United States engineer officer in charge of the local engineer dis-
trict. Under this act the district was duly formed by the necessary
action of the county commissioners, the board of appraisement was
appointed, and the work of making the assessment is completed.
The assessment has to be considered by the county commissioners
sitting as a board of equalization, after which it is subject to collec-
tion, either in cash or in issue of bonds. The board of county com-
missioners declined to act as a board of equalization and proceedings
were begun in the superior court to compel the commissioners to act.
The lower court rendered a decision against the contention of the
county commissioners and the case will be carried to the supreme
court of the State. The sum to be raised under the assessment act
is $1,075,000, which is intended to yield, after the cost of assessment
and collection and other incidental expenses are paid, the sum of
 $1,000,000 in aid of the canal.
    On March 17, 1909, the State legislature passed an act creating the
state shore land improvement fund and appropriated out of said fund
the sum of $250,000 to be expended in the construction of the Lake
Washington Canal, under the direction of the United States engineer
officer in charge of the local engineer district.
    The total local contribution now in view is, therefore, $1,250,000.
    A report on survey required by the river and harbor act of March 2,
1907, was published in House Document No. 953, Sixtieth Congress,
first session.
884                    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                              U.    S.   ARMY.

                                           Exports and imports.

             Calendar year.      Tons.       Value.               Calendar year.                  Tons.        Value.

1901 .........................   410,565    $2,002,950    1905.......... ..........               888,161     $4,588,198
1902....................         428,073     2, 432,401   1906...............              .      705,841      3,993,410
1903 .....................       524,500     2,219,000    1907......... .. ... .....              797,228      5,520,518
1904 .....................       584,079     2,520,785    1908_._...              ........        530,352      3,098,954


   NOTE.-The above includes only the present commerce of Ballard and Salmon Bay, Lake Union, and
Lake Washington.


   The loading of vessels with lumber has been largely facilitated by
the work done in Ballard Harbor. Formerly the lumber was taken
out by means of lighters to the vessels anchored in the Sound. Now
all but the largest vessels are brought to the mills to receive their
loads.
   The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance of
existing channels and care of outlet gates at Lakes Washington and
Union.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .........................              $1, 033. 73
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909..................................................        5, 000. 00
Received from sales....................................................        . 50

                                                                                                              6, 034. 23
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of im-
  provement..........................................          ..........                                     1, 106. 50

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended . .............     ...........                               ........       4, 927. 73
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.....   ...... .... ....                              .............          67.00

July 1, 1909, balance available............                     .......................                   .   4, 860. 73
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
   1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
   pended July 1, 1909...........................               ................ 5, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
    1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
       (See Appendix W W 8.)
  9. Everett Harbor, Washington.-At this harbor the southern part
of the water front has ample depth and is accessible for vessels of the
deepest draft. The northern portion was inaccessible on account of
the delta formation or tide flats off the mouth of the Snohomish River
and the whole water front was exposed to westerly storms.
   The original project was as follows:
   First, to excavate a harbor basin in the shallows and tide lands
adjoining deep water near the river's mouth; second, to dredge a
channel from this through the tide flats and the Old River mouth to
deep fresh water in the Snohomish River, this channel being designed
to bring fresh water to the harbor basin and to afford facilities for
navigation about the peninsula on the east; and, third, to protect and
maintain this harbor and channel across the tide flats by a bulkhead
interposed between them and the open waters of the Sound, the bulk-
head to act as a retaining wall for the material dredged from the
harbor.
  By authority of joint resolution of Congress approved April 23,
1902, the work in Old River was discontinued, the project for a fresh-
                                   RIVER       AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                         885

water basin was abandoned, and the further expenditure of the funds
has been for deepening and widening the harbor basin and channel
through the tide flats and repairing the bulkheads.
   The estimated cost of the improvements was $422,000, all of which
has been appropriated.
  The amount expended on project to June 30, 1909, was $417,577.77,
of which $2,867.73 was for maintenance and $3,000.90 for purchase of
quarry at Goat Island.
  A dike for the purpose of retaining the dredged material has been
built from the lower end of Smith's Island along the established bulk-
head line for a distance of 19,336 feet. At the southern end of this
work an outside bulkhead 200 feet from the other has been built for a
distance of 2,600 feet. These dikes have been repaired, raised, and
strengthened. The channel leading north from the basin had been
dredged to a depth of 6 feet at low water for a distance of 6,000 feet.
A channel in the Old River had been partly dredged for a distance of
11,600 feet downstream before this part of the work was discontinued
under the resolution of Congress above referred to.
   The harbor basin has been dredged for a length of 5,500 feet and for
a width of 400 feet and depth of 26 feet at mean low water.
   No work was in progress during the year.
   The maximum draft that could be carried through the dredged area
June 30, 1906, at low water was 26 feet. The tidal variation is
approximately 15 feet.
   The water traffic is varied in character and is carried on by seagoing
vessels and the various types of sound and river boats. Lumber
products, paper, and flour are the principal items of the export trade.
                                                     Exports and imports.

          Calendar year.                    Tons.      Value.                Calendar year.                      Tons.      Value.

1898 .......................                55.460    $2, 545,054   1904 .....................                   163,347    $3,342,215
1899 ........................               42,713     1,477,120    1905........................                 230,089     4,592,124
1900 .....................                  55,094     1,820, 561   1906 ....................                    159, 203    3,820,860
1901 .....             ..................   71,881     2,712,260    1907..........            ................   143, 710    4,725,700
1902.........................               85,263     4,024,584    1908 ....................                    167,667     7,116,547
1903........................1               79,394     2,510,417



   The effect of the completed dike as a breakwater and protection for
the wharves and mills abreast of it has been very beneficial, but the
channel and harbor basin dredged have not yet been utilized for com-
mercial purposes.
   So far as known, the improvement has not caused any reduction in
freight rates.
   Reference to reports, etc., may be found on page 795 of the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................      $4, 422. 23
June 30, 1909, amount carried to the surplus fund of the Treasury........ 4, 422. 23
     (See Appendix W W 9.)
  10. Swinomish Slough, Washington.-This slough affords an inland
sheltered passage for small vessels from Puget Sound proper north-
ward to Bellingham Bay and the Gulf of Georgia, and it is the only
means of communication to the town of La Conner, located on the
886              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                     U. S. ARMY.

slough. At the northern end the slough opens out through the mud
flats of Padilla Bay and on the south into Saratoga Passage through
the mud flats, forming the delta of the Skagit River. The total dis-
tance from deep water in Saratoga Passage to deep water in Padilla
Bay is about 11 miles. This waterway is of great importance to
traffic between Puget Sound and points north in giving an inside
passage for small craft in rough weather, and an outlet for the agri-
cultural and timber products from the surrounding country.
    The original and present project, adopted by Congress by act of
July 13, 1892, contemplates dredging a channel 4 feet deep in Saratoga
Passage across Skagit flats, through the shoals of the slough proper,
and across the flats of Padilla Bay to deep water, and building dikes
in Skagit Bay to control the tidal currents.
    The entire work done under this project was not entirely successful,
owing to insufficient knowledge of the conditions and the character
of the work required to meet them. The work of the last few years
has been of a more substantial character.
    The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $204,967.32, of which
 $31,233.45 was for maintenance.
    The dike work completed to date between La Conner and Saratoga
Passage is as follows: Pile, brush, and stone dike on the north side of
the channel from "Hole in the Wail" to opposite the west end of
Goat Island, 7,100 linear feet; on the south side of the channel from
the west end of Goat Island to deep water in Saratoga Passage, 3,650
linear feet; and from McGlinns Island to the mainland in the direc-
tion of La Conner, 3,500 feet.
    Dike work was completed on July 24, 1908, as far as available funds
would permit.
    The work accomplished has not had any effect on freight rates.
    The appropriation recommended will be applied to maintenance of
existing channels and dikes.
    A report on examination and survey of Swinomish Slough, upon
which the plan of improvement is based, is referred to in Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 699.
    A map showing parts of the improvement is published in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1900, opposite page 4488.
    The average tidal variation is about 8 feet.
                                                    Exports and imports.

          Calendar year.                 Tons.        Value.             Calendar year.            Tons.         Value.

1898......................                19,625      $882,345     1904......................         56,262      $1,539,094
1899........................              76,636     2, 028, 454   1905........................       48, 724       1,363,729
1900 .......................              74, 516    1,611,460     1906.....................          53,261        1,494,382
1901 ........           ..............   136,747     2, 991,330    1907.....................          46,289        1,582,666
1902 .....................                49,914     1, 472,847    1908a ....................     .......       ...
1908........................              51,399     1,473,197

                                                       a Not obtainable.
                                               RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                      887

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ....................................                                               $1, 387. 85
Amount allotted from appropriation by river and harbor act approved
  March 3, 1909-----------...........---------------------..........................-----......------......-----... 10, 000. 00
                                                                                                                             11, 387. 85
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ..................... ......................      -......... .... ...                                                  1, 355.17
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ............................                                               ..........       10, 032. 68
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909.......................................---------------------------------------...--.. 10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
       (See Appendix W W 10.)
  11. New Whatcom (Bellingham) Harbor, Washington. The local
name of the town at this place is now Bellingham.
  The mud flats in the harbor extend from the shore line to the
12-foot curve, a distance of 3,400 feet.
  A system of harbor lines for this harbor, approved by the Secre-
tary of War under date of June 3, 1892, provides for three water-
ways leading from deep water to the meander line.
   The original and existing project, adopted by Congress by the
act of June 13, 1902, contemplates dredging the Whatcom Creek
waterway to a depth of 12 feet at mean lower low water and 200 feet
wide from deep water as far as the railroad bridge, and to its full
width inside this bridge. The estimated cost is $80,000.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $57,673.98, of which
$1,092.05 was for maintenance and inspections.
  A channel 200 feet wide and 12 feet deep at low water, with turn-
ing basin at inner end, has been dredged under contract. The
channel extends the full length of the waterway, and the basin at
the inner end has full width of the waterway, 330 feet, and is 2,570
feet long.
  During the year no work has been in progress.
  The work contemplated by the project was completed at some-
what less than the estimated cost, and a larger amount of dredging
was done than was expected with the funds available.
  The maximum draft that could be carried June 30, 1909, at mean
lower low water over the full length of channel and turning basin
was 12 feet. The range of tide is about 12 feet.
                                                                            Exports and imports.

                                                                 Calendar year.                                     Tons.       Value.

1902............                    .......      ........................................................           87,118     $2,872,789
1903...............-.............................................................                                  101,989      1,835,486
1904..................... ...............                                 ............                             236,669      4,225,480
                                ...... ..........................
1905.........................................                                                                      254,240      4,690,936
1906.....        ..........     ...........................                                                        292,592       5,643,504
1907............................ ..............................                                                    319,613       7,209,796
1908....               ....                  .............................................                         133,355     a 1,762,295

                                                                a Incomplete returns only obtainable.
888          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The work has not yet produced any material effect on freight
rates so far as known.
   The commerce of this port is of a general nature, consisting largely
of lumber, shingles, and fish. Vessels of the deepest draft can go
as far as the entrance of the proposed dredged channel.
   Description of proposed work is published in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, pages 3478 to 3481.
   Reports on examination and survey are referred to in the Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 701.
   Report on examination and survey of Bellingham Bay, authorized
by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, was published in
House Document No. 1161, Sixtieth Congress, second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................    $2, 326. 02
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................    2, 326. 02
   (See Appendix W W 11.)
   12. Columbia River between Wenatchee and Bridgeport, Wash.-
The Columbia River between Wenatchee and Bridgeport, Wash., is
about 80 miles in length, has sufficient depth for all purposes of
navigation, and the only difficulties in the way of navigation are the
swift currents and rocks and reefs which occupy the channels.
   The project adopted by the river and harbor act approved August
18, 1894, for the improvement of the Columbia River between the
head of Rock Island Rapids and the foot of Foster Creek Rapids
included the part of the river between Wenatchee and Bridgeport,
and the amount expended on the original project was $8,005.20.
   The existing project, adopted by act of March 2, 1907, contem-
plates the improvement of the river between Wenatchee and Bridge-
port by the removal of rocks, bowlders, etc., and the construction of
dikes and wing dams, at an estimated cost of $42,000.
   Owing to the great range of the river between high and low water
and the short period at which it is at a stage low enough for prac-
ticable operations, it was not possible to take up more than one of
the several works embraced in the project.
   During the past year Chelan rock was drilled but not blasted. The
volume of rock to be removed is about 2,000 cubic yards and the
blasting will be done at the next low-water period.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $32,288.37, of which
$150 was for maintenance and inspections.
   The project is about 60 per cent completed.
   The variation in water surface is about 20 feet.
   The estimates originally submitted for this work were inadequate.
At Methow Rapids the cost exceeded the estimate by nearly $15,000,
and at Chelan the cost, when completed, will be about $9,000 in excess
of the estimate.
   To carry out the original project an additional appropriation of
$25,000 will be required.
   So far as known this improvement has not caused any reduction in
freight rates.
                                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                                                    889
                                                                    Exports and imports.

                                                         Calendar year.                                                                      Tons.    " Value.

1904.......................                  .......................................................                                         24,506    $2,251,590
1905.......................................                                                                                                  39,827     3,169,060
1906.............................................................................                                                            53,260     3,901,360
1907....---------..------.....----------...............................................................-----------------------------------   42,126     3,091,550
1908..............................................................................            -----------------------------                  54,527     3,368,119



  Report of a survey including this part of the Columbia River was
published in Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1895, pages
3534-3542.
  Report on examination and survey of the part of the river between
Wenatchee and Bridgeport was published in House Document No.
440, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session, and report on examination
and survey of the part of the river between Bridgeport and Kettle
Falls was published in House Document No. 16, Sixtieth Congress,
second session.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...............................     ....... $19, 930. 69
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ........................         ............................          10, 219. 06
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..           .................................                                                                        9, 711. 63
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .....................................                                                                               383. 50

July 1, 1909, balance available .................                                                               .......................                9, 328.13
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........                                                                              25, 000. 00
  Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
    1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
   July 1, 1909................................................                                                                                       25, 000. 00
  Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
    4, 1897.
      (See Appendix W W 12.)
   13. Okanogan and Pend Oreille rivers, Washington.-(a) Okanogan
River.-This river rises in Canadian territory, flows in a southerly
direction, and empties into the Columbia. The lower portion, for a
distance of 87 miles, lies in the northeastern part of Washington.
The lower portion has sufficient depth and width for light-draft
steamboat navigation for about four months each year, April to July,
inclusive, but it is obstructed in places by shoals and rocks, which
interfere with navigation during low water.
   The original and existing project, adopted by Congress by act of
March 3, 1899, contemplates rock removal, the construction of wing
dams, and snagging. By act of June 13, 1902, this work and that of
the Pend Oreille were consolidated.
  The estimated cost was $30,000 for the Okanogan. The amount
expended to June 30, 1909, was $38,044.25, of which $6,079.91 was
for maintenance.
   Work of removing rocks and bowlders, wing-dam construction, and
placing posts to assist vessels in hauling over rapids has been done
at various points over about 40 miles of the lower portion of the
river.
890           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                        U.   S. ARMY.

   Cables to assist vessels in passing the rapids were placed at seven
places on the Okanogan River.
   During the year no work was done on the Okanogan River, the
expenditures being in connection with inspection of the river and of
bridges crossing it.
   The extreme variation of water levels at the junction with the
Columbia is 37 feet; extreme variation 6 miles above said junction,
20 feet.
   The commerce of the river is carried on in small river steamers and
consists of general traffic.
                                              Exports and imports.

        Calendar year.               Tons.        Value.               Calendar year.                 Tons.        Value.

1899-----..------------------...........-....      1,733   $151,415 1904......................    .    1,636        $252,414
                                              -(a)
1900......---..---..---..-------------...........            (a)    1905.......................   .    1,184         228,675
                               --------
1901..-..-........-------------........              983 .....--    1906.....................     .    1,960         253,880
1902-----.......-----------...............--..     1,571    119,065 1907....................      .    2,040         400,100
1903..----------.......---------..............     6,317    458,705 1908..................        .    1,104         210,040

                                                   a Not obtainable.


  The freight rates on this river are believed to have been materially
reduced since the work started, but no definite information is avail-
able.
   Report on survey with description of the river and the plan of
improvement are given in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1898, page 3121.
    Report on examination of Okanogan River is published in Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1895, page 3475.
  No additional work other than that of maintenance is contem-
plated on this stream.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..................................... $1, 981. 79
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement............................................................... 31.46

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................................                                          1, 950. 33
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. --...................                         -.............           .        3.98

July 1, 1909, balance available .......................................                                           1, 946.35
  (b) Pend Oreille River.-This river forms the outlet of Pend Oreille
Lake, in the northern part of Idaho.
  The obstructions to navigation consist of rocks and shoals in Box
Canyon and in the section between this canyon and Albany Falls.
  The original and existing project, adopted by Congress by act of
March 3, 1899, contemplates the improvement of Box Canyon by the
removal of submerged rocks, the blowing off of projecting rocky
points, and the removal of submerged rocks between Box Canyon
and Albany Falls. The estimated cost was $30,000.
   A modified project, approved March 29, 1907, provides for dredging
to a depth of 6 feet at low water through the bars in the Pend Oreille
River between Newport and Box Canyon.
  The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $28,034.33, of which
$1,546.16 was for maintenance and inspections.
  Channels 75 feet wide and 6 feet deep at low water were dredged
through the upper and lower bars at Boundary Island. The quantity
                                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                        891

of material removed was 6,938.6 cubic yards. Work was suspended
on April 28, 1909, on account of high stage of river.
   Navigation through Box Canyon is possible except at high stage
of water, but the danger in going down through the canyon and the
expense of lining up are so great that river boats do not use it.
   The river is navigable throughout the year from Newport down to
Box Canyon, a distance of 54 miles, except occasional interruption
from ice. A channel depth of about 3 feet can be depended on.
   The extreme variation of water levels in the main river is from 17
to 20 feet; in Box Canyon the difference between extreme high and
extreme low water is 48 feet.
   The commerce consists of towing logs and general traffic carried on
by a number of small vessels. Heavy freight is carried mainly on
barges in tow.
                                             Exports and imports.

             Calendar year.          Tons.     Value.               Calendar year.                      Tons.       Value.


1899 .........................        2,617    $129,677    1904........................                 39.974      $358,45A
1900 .........................        1,921      97,125    1905........................                 54,733       462,814
1901.........................        13,917     134,280    1906 .........................               32,943       501,834
1902.........................        15,868     500,200    1907.         ...              .. ........    2,227       152,500
1903.........................        27,100     753,000    1908.         ...              .. ........   21,724       123,000


   No effect on freight rates directly attributable to the improvement
has been reported.
  Descriptions of the river and the plan of improvement are given
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1898, page 3124.
   Report of survey of the river is referred to in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, page 702.
  The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $20,000
for work on this river and the Okanogan. It is proposed to apply
this sum on the Pend Oreille River in dredging through the clay bars
between Newport and Box Canyon.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...........................        ...... $20, 077. 22
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment..................................................................     5, 606.13
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                                              14, 471.09
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ................                                           12, 877. 63
                                                CONSOLIDATED.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended................................                                                $22, 059. 01
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    For works of improvement ...........................                                        $5,606.13
    For maintenance of improvement ......                      ...........                 ..       31.46
                                                                                                                  5, 637. 59
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .......................                                                .... ...... 16, 421.42
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .......................
                                                         ...............                                                  3.98
July 1, 1909, balance available .........................................                                        16, 417.44
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts ...............                                            12, 877. 63
   (See Appendix W W 13.)
  14. St. Michael Canal, Alaska.-The St. Michael Canal is a channel
running from St. Michael Bay to a point on Norton Sound about 38
miles from the Apoon mouth of the Yukon River.
892             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                   U.    S. ARMY.

   The port of St. Michael is about 3 miles from the mouth of the
canal.
   The main part of the canal has sufficient water for the navigation of
river boats plying on the Yukon River. The eastern entrance to the
canal is, however, obstructed by shoals, and in the eastern portion
there are several sharp bends that could be turned with difficulty by
the larger river boats.
   The object of the improvement of the canal is to provide a shel-
tered passage to river boats between St. Michael and the mouth of
the Yukon River.
   The original and existing project contemplates dredging in the
South Branch a channel 100 feet wide to a depth of 6 feet at mean low
water at the entrance to the canal and the excavation of a cut of the
same dimensions across the first bends. The estimated cost was
$248,000. The project was adopted by the act of March 2, 1907, and
the full amount of the estimate has been appropriated.
   To June 30, 1909, there has been expended on the existing project
$62,047.55.
   The work is being done under a continuing contract and was begun
July 5, 1908, and continued until October 5, 1908, when it was sus-
pended for the season.
   A channel 3,400 feet long, 100 feet wide, and 6 feet deep was exca-
vated, and 37,297.8 cubic yards of material removed.
   The original estimate for this work was based on a unit price for
dredging of 50 cents per cubic yard, while the lowest bid received
was $1.45 per cubic yard.
   To carry out the original project would require an additional ap-
propriation of nearly double the amount heretofore appropriated.
   The district officer in his report recommends the modified project
for the work not now under contract, which will reduce the cost
about $275,000, but action on this modified project has been delayed
pending a personal investigation by the district officer.
   The additional funds asked for will be required for the prosecution
of the work during the season of 1910.
   The maximum draft that can at present be carried at low water
is 3 feet. The mean range of tide is 3- feet.
               Statement offreight between St. Michael and mouth of Yukon River.

         Calendar year.                Tons.     Value.              Calendar year.              Tons.        Value.

1897......................              5,270     $512,650    1903.............                   ........ 20, 000 $1,652, 891
1898......... ......         ...
                              ......   22, 117   2, 132,580   1904........................                 17,356   1, 316, 237
1899-....-..-...............           17,295    1,704,525    1905.........               -..............  25,855   2,220,830
1900........................           19,153    1,950,950    1906----......-------..........--------...   31,999   2,799, 187
1901-.....................--.          18,153    1,844,651    1907 .......................--------------------
                                                                                                           29,793   2,493,697
1902.....................              16,008    1,630,950    1908 ........................                23,785   2,090,400


   It is not expected that this improvement will have any effect on
freight rates.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..........................    ..... .... $245, 241. 43
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.....................     ............    .    ....    ............. 59, 288. 98
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........................                                     ....      185, 952.45
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..................................                                        621. 33
July 1, 1909, balance available...................................                                       185, 331.12
                   RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                              893
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts............... $176, 826. 38
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project......... 100, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
July 1, 1909-. --- --.. -........................- -.......             100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
4, 1897.
  (See Appendix W W 14.)

EXAMINATIONS AND SURVEYS MADE IN COMPLIANCE                    WITH RIVER AND
              HARBOR ACT APPROVED MARCH 2,                     1907.

   Reports on preliminary examinations and surveys required by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, of the following localities within
this district were duly submitted by the district officer. They were
reviewed by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant
to law, and were transmitted to Congress and printed in documents as
indicated:
   1. Preliminaryexamination and survey of Puyallup River, Washing-
ton, with a view to straighteningchannel and securing suitable depth to the
city of Puyallup.-Reports dated April 26, 1907, April 4, 1908, and
August 31, 1908, respectively, are printed in House Document No.
1107, Sixtieth Congress, second session. The locality is not consid-
ered worthy of improvement by the General Government in the man-
ner proposed.
   2. Preliminary examination and survey of Snohomish River, Wash-
ington, from its mouth to Lowell.-Reports dated April 19, 1907, and
March 31, 1908, respectively, are printed in House Document No.
1108, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for improvement at
an estimated cost of $280,000 is presented.
   3. Survey of Chehalis River, Washington, up to Montesano, by the
removal of bars.-Report dated March 31, 1908, is printed in House
Document No. 1125, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for
improvement at an estimated cost of $50,000 is presented.
   4. Preliminaryexamination and survey of Bellingham Harbor,Wash-
ington.-Reports dated April 27, 1907, and March 26, 1908, respec-
tively, are printed in House Document No. 1161, Sixtieth Congress,
second session. A plan for improvement at an estimated cost of
$92,250 is presented.
   5. Preliminaryexamination and survey of Skagit River, Washington,
up to Sedro Woolley.--Reports dated April 15, 1907, March 31, 1908,
and November 3, 1908, respectively, are printed in House Document
No. 1188, Sixtieth Congress, second session. A plan for improvement
at an estimated cost of $100,000 is presented.
RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS IN THE DISTRICT OF HAWAII.

  This district was in the charge of Capt. C. W. Otwell, Corps of
Engineers, to November 12, 1908, and of Maj. E. E. Winslow, Corps
of Engineers, since that date. Division engineer, Lieut. Col. John
Biddle, Corps of Engineers.
  1. Pearl Harbor, Hawaii.-Forhistory and project, see page 3433
of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1901. No work
was done during this year. The expenditures were for telegrams and
894          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                               U.   S. ARMY.


rubber stamp. There is no commerce yet in this harbor; no further
funds are required.
July 1,    1908, balance unexpended ........................                       ........   ....     $452.66
June 30, 1909, amount expended during the fiscal year, for maintenance of
  improvement--------.................--------------............------..-------.....................
                                                                            -----------------            29. 60
June 30, 1909, amount carried to the surplus fund.........................                              423.06
   (See Appendix X X 1.)
   2. Honolulu Harbor, Hawaii.-Thisharbor is situated on the south
coast of the island of Oahu. The entrance channel, through a coral
reef, and the harbor proper, were dredged from time to time by the
monarchical, republican, and territorial governments of Hawaii prior
to July 1, 1904. On this date there existed an entrance channel
having a minimum width of about 200 feet and a depth of about 35
feet at mean low water. The harbor proper had a general width of
900 feet. The water for about 200 feet immediately along the
wharves had a depth of from 30 to 32 feet. Elsewhere there was only
about 27 feet at low water. The bend at the light-house point was so
sharp as to make it somewhat difficult for large vessels to make the turn.
   Work on the present project was begun under an appropriation
by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1905, in accordance with a
general plan printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1905, page 2564, but the project as specifically adopted by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, is printed in House Document
No. 332, Fifty-ninth Congress, second session. It provides for an
entrance channel 400 feet wide and 35 feet deep at mean low water
from deep water at the entrance to the light-house point, for easing
the curve at the junction of the entrance channel and the inner
harbor by cutting off the light-house point, and for enlarging the
harbor proper so that it will have a general width of 1,200 feet and
a depth of 35 feet at mean low water, at an estimated cost of
$1,628,894.60.
   Between March 3, 1905, and May 27, 1908, $800,000 have been
appropriated for work under the approved project, or about 49 per
cent of the estimated cost of work under that project.
   Work under the above appropriations was stopped by practical
exhaustion of funds, on December 15, 1908. The following has been
accomplished:
   Dredging entrance channel, removing light-house point, and the
partial widening of the harbor proper. All this dredging was to a
depth of 35 feet at mean lower low water, a total of 1,910,023 cubic
yards having been excavated. The completion of the adopted proj-
ect is urgently required by commercial interests.
   On June 30, 1909, the sum of $794,838.79 had been expended, no
part of which was for maintenance.
   From July 1, 1908, to the cessation of work on December 15, 1908,
208,106 cubic yards of material were removed from the harbor and
deposited on shore. A careful survey was later made of the condi-
tion of the harbor. This survey showed shoaling to have taken place
at the following points: A general shoaling throughout the entrance
channel; a noticeable shoaling in the Nuuanu slip at the head of the
harbor; a slight shoaling in front of the wharves of the naval station;
and very slight shoaling in a few other localities.
   The maintenance of this harbor was provided for by the act of
March 3, 1909, in accordance with estimate of the Chief of Engineers,
                          RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                                                              895
which was printed in House Document No. 1462, Sixtieth Congress,
second session.
   The approved project is about 49 per cent completed. On June 30,
1909, there was a minimum depth in the entrance channel of about 33
feet; within the harbor proper there was, outside of harbor lines, a gen-
eral depth of 35 feet. The normal tidal oscillation is about 2 feet.
The head of navigation is the head of the harbor, about 2 miles from the
Light-House Department buoys marking the entrance to the harbor.
   The commerce between this port and ports not in the Hawaiian
Islands, for the calendar year 1908, amounted to approximately
600,000 tons, valued at $41,562,840. The commerce with other
ports of the Hawaiian Islands amounted to 320,158 tons, valued at
about $22,000,000.
   What effect the improvement of the harbor has had upon freight
rates can not be stated, but vessels are now able to enter and leave
the harbor with their full load draft.
   Should additional appropriations be made for this harbor, it is
proposed to expend the funds in widening the harbor in pursuance
with the approved project, so as to make it possible for vessels to enter
and leave at all hours of the day and night, instead of by daylight
only, as at present.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................             $368, 396. 35
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment....................... ............... .. ..........             ... ........ 363, 227.14
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..----..--------...---                       --                               a 5, 169. 21
                                                                                            --......----...................
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities-..-----............--        ..................------                                 .50
July 1, 1909, balance available ................................                                  ...       a 5, 168. 71
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project.........                                    828, 894. 60
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement and for maintenance, exclusive of
  the balance unexpended July 1, 1909--------...-........---...................                            500, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
   (See Appendix X X 2.)
  3. Reclamation of Quarantine Island, Honolulu, Hawaii.Forhis-
tory and project, see page 853 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1908. No work was done during this year. The ex-
penditures were in payment of outstanding liabilities.
  At the close of the fiscal year the sum of $20,000 had been expended,
exhausting the appropriation. No part of this expenditure was for
maintenance.
  For commercial statistics, see report for Improving Honolulu Har-
bor, Hawaii.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................................       $2. 75
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improvement.. 2. 75
   (See Appendix X X 3.)
  4. Harbor at Hilo, Hawaii.-Hilo Bay is practically a deep open
roadstead, protected to a limited extent by Blonde reef, but other-
wise exposed through the angle formed by lines drawn from Hilo
town to Kanaha and Keokea points-that is, from about north to
  aIn addition to this balance the sum of $25,000 is made available by the river and harbor act of March 3,
1909, but not yet allotted.
896          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                             U. S. ARMY.

north 74 ° east (magnetic). Strong northeasterly trade winds prevail
most of the time. These winds cause a choppy sea outside of Hilo
Bay and considerable swell in the bay, which at times makes it
unsafe for ships to lie at the existing wharves and renders loading
and unloading in the bay difficult. The heaviest seas, however,
come from the north during northerly and northwesterly storms,
and during this weather it is often impossible for ships to lie at the
wharves or even work in the bay.
   The present project, adopted by Congress March 2, 1907, consists
in constructing a rubble mound breakwater along Blonde reef to a
point on shore about 6,000 feet east of Cocoanut Island, at an esti-
mated cost of $1,700,000, as stated in House Document No. 407,
Fifty-ninth Congress, second session.
   As authorized in the act of March 2, 1907, the project as originally
stated in the above-mentioned House document has been modified
in a manner recommended on page 16 of the House document by
the elimination of the third, or shore, arm of the breakwater and
the extension of the middle arm of the breakwater to the shore.
   For map, see page 2316 of the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1908.
   Between March 2, 1907, and March 4, 1909, $400,000 has been
appropriated for work under the approved project, or about 23 per
cent of the estimated cost of the work under that project. Under
a continuing contract the actual construction of the breakwater
was commenced on September 12, 1908, and on June 30, 1909, a
total of 31,507 tons of stone had been placed, making a total of 766
feet of completed breakwater.
   On June 30, 1909, the sum of $71,000.86 had been expended, all
on the present project, and no part being for maintenance.
   The approved project is about 4 per cent completed.
   The commerce of this port for the calendar year 1908 was valued
at more than $16,000,000, and amounted to more than 184,000 tons.
   Work on this improvement has not been carried far enough to
have any effect on freight rates.
   It is proposed to apply the amount estimated as a profitable
expenditure in the fiscal year 1911 to continuing the work of con-
structing the breakwater. The additional work proposed is necessary
to make the improvement available.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ...................... ...............             $298, 274. 87
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.....                   100, 000. 00
                                                                                         398, 274. 87
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment.......................................................                             69, 275.73
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......... . ........................                    328, 999. 14
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................                      573. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available......................................                    328, 426. 14
July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts...............       301, 355. 44
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project-........ 1, 300, 000. 00
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
  30, 1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909 .. ................ ... ........................                   600, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
   (See Appendix X X 4.)
                 RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENTS.                       897
RIVER AND HARBOR IMPROVEMENT IN THE DISTRICT OF PORTO RICO.

   This district was in the charge of Maj. Charles L. Potter, Corps of
Engineers. Division engineer, Col. D. W. Lockwood, Corps of
Engineers.
   Harbor at San Juan, Porto Rico.-This harbor has a large area,
but, prior to work under the existing project, a small portion had
sufficient depth for modern shipping. With the exception of a
small area in the bend around La Puntilla, which had a depth of 30
feet, the available depths varied from 20 to 30 feet? All of these
depths are referred to mean low water. The usual range between
high and low water is about 1 foot. The existing project adopted by
the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, is to dredge an entrance
channel 600 feet wide from deep water outside to a point opposite
Morro Point; 500 feet wide from there to La Puntilla, both to be 30
feet deep, and both to be widened where they make the turn around
these points; and to dredge, east of La Puntilla, harbor areas amount-
ing to 398,600 square yards to a depth of 30 feet and 70,200 square
yards to a depth of 24 feet, all in accordance with House Document
No. 914, Fifty-ninth Congress, first session.
   The estimated cost of this improvement is $757,500, of which ths
act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $157,500, and authorized continu-
ing contracts for prosecuting the project in the sum of $600,000.
Of this amount the sundry civil acts of May 27, 1908, and March
4, 1909, appropriated $220,000 and $300,000, respectively, leaving
$80,000 to be appropriated.
   The amount expended on the existing project up to June 30, 1909,
is $315,636.54 for improvement.
   Work has been carried on under continuing contract at a cost of
19 cents per cubic yard (scow measurement) for soft material, and
$6.80 per cubic yard (place measurement) for coral rock, and under
supplemental contract, entered into February 6, 1909, whereby the
contractor was granted permission to dump in a remote portion of the
harbor, at a reduction in price of 5 cents per cubic yard for soft
material and 30 cents per cubic yard for coral rock, when weather
conditions were such as to render it unsafe for the scows to be towed
to sea.
   There have been removed during the last fiscal year 1,025,322 cubic
yards of soft material and 8,048 cubic yards of coral rock. Of these
amounts 209,259 cubic yards of soft material were dumped under
the supplemental contract at a saving in cost of $10,462.95.
   The result of the work has been to practically complete the areas
authorized east of La Puntilla (inner harbor); to nearly complete
the widening of the entrance channel at La Puntilla-only a small
portion next to the point, consisting largely of coral rock, remains; and
to commence work on the inner end of the entrance channel. The
contractor has also done a large amount of the necessary drilling on one
coral-rock shoal at the outer end of the entrance channel. This work
gives much relief in the harbor proper and around the difficult turn
at La Puntilla, but the draft that can be carried into the harbor is still
limited to 27 feet in the entrance channel which is now being dredged.
This depth will accommodate any commercial vessel entering San
Juan Harbor, but they need more width, which the project will amply
provide.
     9001-ENG 1909-57
898          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                       S. ARMY.

   No work was done by the United States prior to this project,
but some dredging was done by the Spanish Government.
   The amount estimated that can be profitably expended for works
of improvement during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, will be
expended in continuing dredging under the contract, which work is
necessary to make the improvement available. In the eighteen
months between the completion of the inner harbor and final com-
pletion of the contract there will undoubtedly be some fill, espe-
cially around La Puntilla. When the contractor removes his plant,
there will be hothing left nearer than the United States or Cuba that
can handle such work, and any fill which may occur meantime
should be removed before the plant gets away; hence the $20,000
for maintenance.
   Commercial statistics, as given in the appendix, were furnished by
the custom officials in San Juan, and are given in money value only.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.....-................................. $303, 341. 25
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909....... 300, 000. 00
                                                                                                   603, 341. 25
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ............................................................                                241, 477. 79

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                               361, 863.46
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................................                              48, 000. 00

July 1, 1909, balance available ........                    .........................              313, 863.46

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contracts .............                                313, 863. 46
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project .......                              80, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
    For works of improvement............................. $80, 000. 00
    For maintenance of improvement ....................      20, 000. 00
                                                                                                   100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix Y Y.)
         THE BOARD OF ENGINEERS FOR RIVERS AND HARBORS.

   Section 3 of the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, provided for
the organization, in the Office of the Chief of Engineers, by detail
from time to time from the Corps of Engineers, of a Board of five
engineer officers, whose duties shall be fixed by the Chief of Engineers,
and to whom shall be referred for consideration and recommendation,
in addition to any other duties assigned, so far as in the opinion of
the Chief of Engineers may be necessary, all reports upon examina-
tions and surveys provided for by Congress, and all projects or
changes in projects for works of river and harbor improvement there-
tofore or thereafter provided for. It is further the duty of the Board,
upon request to the Chief of Engineers, by the Committee on Com-
merce of the Senate, or the Committee on Rivers and Harbors of the
House of Representatives, in the same manner to examine and report
through the Chief of Engineers upon any projects heretofore adopted
by the Government or upon which appropriations have been made,
and to report upon the desirability of continuing the same or upon
any modifications thereof which may be deemed desirable. This pro-
vision of the law was extended by act of March 3, 1905, to require the
        THE BOARD OF ENGINEERS FOR RIVERS AND HARBORS.             899

Board, upon request of the committees of Congress specified above, to
examine and review surveys as well as projects provided for by acts or
resolutions prior to the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, and it
was further modified by the act of March 2, 1907, to include considera-
tion of any examination or survey made pursuant to any act or reso-
lution of Congress.
   Section 13 of the act of March 3, 1909, increased the scope of
preliminary examinations and surveys by providing that every re-
port therein ordered shall contain such data as it may be practicable
to secure regarding (first) the establishment of terminal and transfer
facilities, (second) the development and utilization of water power
for industrial and commercial purposes, and (third) such other sub-
jects as may be properly connected with such project. It further
provided that the investigation and study of these questions may,
upon review by the Board, "when called for as now provided by
law, be extended to any work of improvement now under way and
to any locality the examination and survey of which has heretofore
been, or may hereafter be, authorized by Congress." Section 6 of
the same act requires the Board to pass upon all modifications in
plan and location involved in the reconstruction of any lock, canal,
canalized river, or other work for the use and benefit of navigation,
for which expenditures are authorized by that section.
   During the past fiscal year the Board was composed of the following
officers of the Corps of Engineers: Col. D. W. Lockwood; Col. John
G. D. Knight, from October 21, 1908; Col. R. L. Hoxie, to July 14,
1908; Col. Smith S. Leach, from July 9 to September 16, 1908, and
from March 31, 1909; Lieut. Col. W. C. Langfitt, from September
16, 1908; Maj.. H. C. Newcomer, from December 21, 1908, to March
31, 1909; Maj. E. Eveleth Winslow, to October 21, 1908; Maj.
Spencer Cosby, from July 14 to December 21, 1908; and Maj. William
J. Barden.
   Under the provisions of the acts of March 2, 1907, and March 3,
1909, all reports submitted in compliance with those acts have been
referred to the Board for consideration and recommendation; in
addition, a number of subjects have been presented to it for report
in accordance with resolutions of the Committee on Rivers and
Harbors of the House of Representatives, and the Committee on
Commerce of the Senate. The reports rendered by the Board from
time to time in response to legislative action have been duly presented
to Congress. During the year the Board also gave consideration to
a number of other matters referred to it by the Chief of Engineers,
U. S. Army, for its views and recommendations.
   Details of the operations of the Board during the past fiscal year
will be found in Appendix Z Z.

              SEAGOING HYDRAULIC            DIEDGES.

  There are now 24 seagoing hydraulic dredges owned and operated
by the United States, and the following statement has been prepared,
showing in tabular form certain data in regard to each dredge and the
work accomplished by it during the past year. In estimating the cost
per cubic yard of material removed no allowance was made for a pro-
portionate share of office expenses or for depreciation, but includes
cost of all repairs and field supervision.
                                                 Performancesof United States seagoing dredgesfor the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909.

Name ............................................                       Gedney.                   Charleston.                             Chinook.           W. S. Ladd.               Cape Fear.           Gen. C. B. Comstock.


When built...........................--                                     1887.................      1891................ 1892................            1893.......---........ 1895............         1895.
Where built...---                      .--....----- .....                   Wilmington, Del ....       Brooklyn, N. Y..        Belfast, Ireland..... Portland, Oreg...... Philadelphia, Pa....              Perth Amboy, N. J.
                                     ....       .............               Wood..............         Wood............... Steel....               ........ Wood ...........       Wood.............        Wood.                       H
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        0
Hull material ....
Length                                     ................                 156 feet 6 inches ..... 122 feet 6 inches ..... 445feet....--......
                                                                      ..............                                                                        143 feet 6 inches....  131 feet 3 inches.....   177 feet.
Beam...........                                    .--------...- ..--- 36 feet 6 inches ...... 30 feet ..............          49 feet............          38 feet 4 inches...... 29 feet...........       35 feet 6 inches.
Depth.........                                                              15   feet   6  inches..... 12   feet.............. 30 feet    .............     12  feet.............. 17 feet...........       16 feet.                    0
Displacement......                    .............             tons.. 751................             517.............        5,590...............         750........ ..... 220 ............              764.
Speed,    light.....................                           knots..      7.7.................       7.2.................  ..-----.....--..----.          7 ....       ......... 8..............          9.5.
                                                         ....   do.... 6...................                                                                 4...................                            7.
Speed, loaded-.........----                                                                            6.................                                                          5....................
                                                                                                                                                                                                            1.                          0
Speed, dredging-----................----------do--.                         1.5..................      1.5................                                  0.5..................
Number and size of pumps .............                                      Two 15-inch......... One 15-inch......... Two 20.inch.........                  Two 15-inch.........   Two 10-inch.........     Two 15-inch.
Number of men in crew.....................                                  21 .. .................    20................                                   20................. 16.................         42.
Location of dredging ................                                       Main ship channel, Mobile, outer bar, Columbia Rive r,
                                                                                New York Harbor.            Ala.                  Portland, Oreg.
                                                                                                                                                            Harbor bars, Port- Cape Fear River,
                                                                                                                                                               land, Oreg.              N. C.
                                                                                                                                                                                                            Galveston
                                                                                                                                                                                                               Tex.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Harbor,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        z
Character of dredged material.............                                  Sticky mud, sand... Sand and mud .....                                          Sand...........        Sand and mud.......      Sand,    clay, shell, and

Average depth of dredging ... .........
Average load in bins .......-         cubic yards..
                                                           27 to 30 feet......... 26)feet...........
                                                           572............... 272..............
                                                                                                                                 i...
                                                                                                                             ................              ..........
                                                                                                                                                     21 feet
                                                                                                                                                     400 ................
                                                                                                                                                                          20 feet...............
                                                                                                                                                                          292.................
                                                                                                                                                                                                               silt.
                                                                                                                                                                                                            27.84
                                                                                                                                                                                                            646.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   feet.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        O


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        0
Material pumped per hour-............do....                319 ...............    346......        .......                                           467................. 237...............                457.
Average number of cubic yards dredged daily.               950........ .....      2,200...............                                               2,130............... 1,586................             6,420.                      yH




Total number of loads........... -        ...........      121..............      549 ............                                                   852................. 1,575.............                2,883.                      td
Total amount dredged.........cubic yards..                 69,241............. 149,309..........                                                     341,430............. 460,519 .............             1,860,620.                  en
Average distance to dump...........miles..                 9.........         .....       4- --    --..    -   .    ..   .
                                                                                                                                                     1................... 4 .................               13.                         en
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        02




Total number of days on which any dredg-                   73.........            .....   68....       ..........                                    160.............. 290.............                     290.
  ing was done.                                                                                                                                                                                                                         02




Total number of hours pumping..........                    217.................           432.................                                       730.................  1,937.............               4,073.
Time to pump one load....................                  1 hour 48 minutes...           47 minutes........                                         511 minutes ......... 1 hour 73 minutes...             1 hour 25 minutes.
Total number of hours dumping............                  69................             50....... ....                                             100.............. 191 .................                223.
Time to dump one load...................                   34 minutes..........           51 minutes.......... ......................                7 minutes........... 7 minutes...........              44 minutes.
Total number of hours going to and from                    218..................          102...:..............                                      303................. 1,149...............              1,000.
  dump.
Total number of hours going to and from                     189.                          2214....
                                                                                           214...............
                                                                                                 ................                                    171............ ...          250..................141.
wharf.
Total number of hours taking coal and water.               80..................6....                                                                        142.
                                                                                                                                         103..................
                                                                                                                      105.................
                                                                                            .............................
Total number of hours lost on account of                                                             ......
                                                           270................. 301....................                   .............. 25 ............... 358.
                                                                                                                  ... 76..........76
  weather.
Total amount of coal consumed..long tons..                                    739.....................................
                                                           754.................                                                                      1,055............... 1,996 ................         23,604 barrels.
Number of pounds of coal consumed per                      24.4............. 11.1........... ........      ............                              6.9.............     9.7..........          ....... 0. 53 gallons.
cubic yard of material dredged.
Cost per cubic yard, including all repairs....             $0.224..............           $0.1813..............                                      $0.0653...............       $0.0519..............     $0.0389.
Remarks.................................                    Worked 5 months;              Laid up 6 months, Now out of commis-                       Out of commission;       .                             Uses oil for fuel.
                                                             transferred to                 lack of funds; re- sion.                                  worked 9 months.
                                                             Newport, R. I.;                pairs.
                                                             being repaired.
Name .......................             .............            Winyah Bay.                     Benyaurd.           Sabine.              Cumberland.           Gen'l Gillespie.          Manhattan.


When built...............................                     1898.................   1900.................                             1902.................
                                                                                                                1901.....................                       1904.................   1904.
Where built................................                   Wilmington, Del.... Richmond, Va.....             New York, N. Y.... Belfast, Me..........        Sparrows Point, Md. Sparrows Point, Md.
Hull material..............................                   Wood............... Steel...............          Wood ...........        Wood...............     Steel .......     ..... Steel.
Length......          ......................                  141 feet.............   271 feet 6 inches .....   145 feet .............  200 feet .............. 177 feet.............. 288 feet.
Beam.................................                         31 feet.............    47 feet...............    35 feet............... 40 feet 8 inches ...... 38 feet............... 47 feet 6 inches.
Depth .............................                     ..    13 feet 6 inches ...... 23 feet.............      8 feet ................ 20feet............ 19 feet..............        25 feet.
Displacement........                     .   ....... tons..   466................. 2,006...............         600.................    1,451................   1,200...............    3,200.
Speed, light.....................knots..                      9....................   10................        8.33................    9.2................. 8.5..................      10.
Speed, loaded ......................... do....                7.........    ........   8 ....................   7.4 ................    7.2.............. 7.0 .................         8.
Speed, dredging-..........-........do....                                              S.------............     3.33..............      1 to 2................  1.5...............         to 4.
Number and size of pumps..................                    One 15inch.........          Two 20-inch........  Two 10inch.......       Two 18-inch.........    Two 15-inch......... Two 20-inch.
Number of men in crew ..................                      20...................        49.................  17.................. 34.................. 35....---............         55.
Location of dredging.......................                   Winyah Bay, S. C., Passes of the Missis-          Sabine Pass, Tex.... Savannah Harbor, Harbors Lake Mich- Ambrose                   Channel,
                                                                and Charleston                 sippi River, La.                            Ga.                    igan.                    New York Harbor.
                                                                Harbor, S. C.
Character of dredged material ............... Soft mud, sand, and Sand, mud, and silt. Soft blue mud....... Sand, mud, clay, and Sand and shell.....                                        Sand, gravel, and
                                                                coral rock.                                                                  gravel.                                           mud.
Average depth of dredging.................. 13 to 22 feet......... 32 feet ..............                          24 feet.............   23feet............... 20 feet .............       15 to 35 feet.
Average load in bins...........          cubic yards.. 276 ..................              1,865 ...............   195.................   891.................. 561.............. 2, 065.
Material pumped per hour............do...                     289...            .......... 588..................   459 .................. 670................. 516......... .... 862.
Average number cubic yards dredged daily.. 1, 445................                          7, 480..............    1,842...............   3,765.......... 2,850...............              9, 090.
Total number of loads.......................                  943.............             922.................    1,955.............     854................ 935 ................          1,208.
Total amount dredged.........cubic yards.. 260, 200..........                              1,718, 549 ..........   381,225.............   761,761............. 524,126............          2, 498, 457.
Average distance to dump...........miles.. 2. 66.....                           .........  2 ................      1.15..............     2.3.................  1............... 7.
Total number of days on which any dredging 182..............                               230 .................   207................ 202.................. 184..................          275.
  was done.
Total number of hours pumping...........                   .. 901 ..................       2,929..............    831............. ...    1,134...............  1,016..............         2,902.
Time to pump one load .............                       ... 57 minutes .........3 hours 10 minutes.. 25z minutes........                1 hour 20 minutes... 1 hour 5 minutes ....        2 hours 24 minutes.   t
Total number of hours dumping..........                  .....48 ................          136...............      163..................  173..---.............                             195.
                                                                                                                                                                115..------.............------
Time to dump one load......................                   3 minutes ...........7% minutes..........            5 minutes...........   12 minutes.........   72 minutes       .......... 9t minutes.           L
Total number of hours going to and from 583 ..................                             333............        570.................    446.................. 316............. 1,705.
  dump.
Total number of hours going to and from 262 ..................                             38 ................... 548...............      314.................. 151.................. 127.
  wharf.
Total number of hours taking coal and water. 46. 5.................                        228.................. 94...................    140................   408.................        29.
Total number of hours lost on account of 22................... 23.................                                290.................    48..................  398.................. 384.
  weather.
Total amount of coal consumed..long tons.. 728..................                           6, 331 .............   6, 344 barrels oil..... 2,909................ 3,262................ 10,787.
Number of pounds of coal consumed per 6. 27.................. 8. 25.................                              0.7 gallon oil ........ 8.55................  13.9...................     9.67.
  cubic yard of material dredged.
Cost per cubic yard, including all repairs..... 30. 0715_.............. $0.0628..............                     80.0677.............. $0.1147 ..............  $0.0878..............       $0.04.
Remarks ...........     ..........           .............    Repairing 1 inonth; Repairing 2 months. Repairing 1 month; Repairing 2 months. In winter quarters 2
                                                                laid up 32 months.                                   laid up 1 month.                             months.
                                                 Performances of United States seagoing dredges for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909-Continued.

Name.................                   ..................                         Atlantic.                           Key West.                           Savannah.                              Sumter.                             Burton.                              Caucus.

When built.........................                                          1904................ 1904............                                         1904-................                    1904................                    1905...............             1905.
Where built...........................                                       Sparrows Point, Md. Belfast, Me ........                                      Sparrows Point, Md. Petersburg, Va...... Sparrows Point, Md. Greenport, N. Y.                                                              tt
Hull material ................................                               Steel......--....--                    Wood         ..............            Steel...............                     Wood...............                     Steel...............            Wood.                     0
Length.............................                                          275 feet 7 inches .....                141 feet.............                  177 feet............. 200feet............ 177 feet.............                                                  200 feet.
Beam............           ....               ....            .........      47   feet    7   inches       ......   31   feet...............               38 feet..............                    41     feet...........                  38  feet..............          41 feet.
Depth.............                             ................              25 feet..............                  15 feet ..............                 19 feet 6 inches_...... 21 feet.............                                     19 feet............             20 feet.                  0
Displacement .....                     ..............                 tons.. 2.674..............                    498..................                  1,236.......--....... 1,650................                                      1,200    ...............        1,650.
Speed, light............--......knots..                                      10.................. 7....................                                    8....       ..............                                                       7.-----.............--------... 9.
                                                                      do.... 8 ....................                 5....................                  5.1................                      5.......               ..........       4...................            6.
Speed, loaded-....-................                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         1.
Speed, dredging...................do--.... 2 to 3. ..-                                              ........                                               1 to2 ...............                    1 to 2..............
Number and size of pumps ..................                                  Two       20-inch..                  . One       15-inch          .....       Two       15-inch          ._.....       Two          18-inch........    15-inch-2811..................
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Two                      ..     Two 18-inch.              C
Number of men in crew....................                                    57--------..............               23....................                 34................                       44................ 28.......----.....                                   34.
Location of dredging -.--- --...                                  --....     Ambrose              Channel,          Tampa             Bay      and   St.   Harbor              bars,          Sa-   Passes           of   the     Missis-   Harbors          Toledo     and Carrabelle and Pen-       O


                                                                                 New York Harbor.                       Johns River, Fla.                      vannah, Ga.                               sippi River, La.                      Sandusky, Ohio.                 sacola harbors, Fla.
Character of dredged                 material................                Sand,        mud,         gravel,      Sand           and         broken      Sand,      clay,       and    mud.       Sand,          clay,     and      mud.  Sand       and      mud......   Sand.                     00
                                                                                 and stone.                             shells.                                                                                                                                                                       0



Average depth of dredging.                            ....... .....        . 25 to 30 feet......... 23 to 26 feet......... 21 feet ..............                                                 .......................                   22 feet...........              27 feet.
Average load in bins..........cubic yards.. 2,090...............                                                    326.4...............                   784................. 844.................                                        689.................            905.
Material pumped                per    hour...         ..     ..       do.... 879.................                   285.................                   572.............                         366..................                   264...............              678.
Average number cubic yards dredged daily.. 9,500...............2,070 ...............                                                                       3,391................. 2,625...............                                      1,380 ...............           3,265.                    02
                                                                             1,275...............                   1,344................                                                                                                   330..................           556.                      02
Total  number           of   loads      ......................                                                                                             1,028     ..............                 342..................
Total amount dredged .........                          cubic yards.. 2,667,321                ...........          438,748 ..............                 807,236 .............                    288,852.............                    227,109............. 502,428.
Average distance to dump...- -... -                                  miles.. 6.......... ......... 0.608...............                                    3................... 3 ...................                                       6.4................. 2.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      iJ
Total number of days on which any dredging 281..................                                                    212...............                     238.............                         110.................                    164..................           154.                      Q
  was done.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           yH
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      02




Total number of hours pumping............ 3,036............                                                         1,538.15............                   1,410............                        790...............---                   863...............              745.
Time to pump 1 load ..................                                       2 hours 23 minutes.. 1.15 hours ..........                                    1 hour 22 minutes... 2 hours 18 minutes.. 2 hours 36 minutes.                                                    1 hour 20 minutes.
Total number of hours dumping............ 213 ....... ......... 167.5 ................ 150.................                                                                                    .    72.25               .............---                                    46.
Time to dump 1 load ...................                                      10 minutes .........                   0.12 hour...........                   8' minutes.......... 124minutes.......                                                                           5 minutes,                02
Total number of hours going to and from 1,775................                                                       437.5............... 616..................                                      282............. 647................                                    470.
  dump.
Total number of hours going to and from 140..............                                                           345-............... 317 ...............                                         182. ................                .. 81...................           305.
  wharf.
Total number of hours taking on coal and 912................. 2992............. 189..................                                                                                               73................ 48............... 112.
  water.
Total number of hours lost on account of 479........--.........                                                     11.....
                                                                                                                          --..............                 30 ..............                        11 ..................                   59.............. 68.
  weather.
Total amount of coal consumed...long tons.. 11,087......                                                     ......2,035.4          ..............       1 3,014 ................                   1,839 ...............                   2,174............... 2,706.
Number of pounds of coal consumed per 9.3...................... 10.4................                                                                       8.36...........                          14.25...............21.4................ 12.1.
  cubic yard of material dredged.
Cost per cubic yard, including all repairs.... $0.038...............                                                $0.091..............                   $0.07 ................                   $0.105............. $0.11............... $0.0784.
Remarks.......                      ..................                  ...                                                                           .    Laid up 1 month Worked 6 months; Winter quarters 4
                                                                                                                                                               overhauling.                              now undergoing                        months.
                                                                                                                                                                                                         repairs.
Name .............................                 ...                Delaware.              St. Johns.                   Navesink.                      Raritan.                            Clatsop.                Galveston.

When built................................                   1905................. 1905................          1908................. 1908.................   1908.................          1908.
Where built. ..............................                  Sparrows Point, Md. Greenport, N. Y....             Sparrows Point, Md. Sparrows Point, Md. Newport News, Va. Sparrows Point, Md.
Hull material..............................                  Steel..............   Wood...........               Steel ............     Steel................ Steel................ Steel.
Length.....................................                  315 feet ............ 205 feet .............        290 feet ............  290 feet ............. 180 feet .............        304 feet.
Beam .............            .................              52 feet.............. 41 feet..............         47 feet 7 inches...... 47 feet7 inches...... 38 feet ..............         51 feet.
Depth...................................                     22 feet6 inches...... 20 feet ............          28 feet .............. 28 feet..............  20 feet 6 inches...... 27 feet.
Displacement.........................tons..                  2,750................ 1,047 .............           2,929...............   2,929 ................ 1,100 ................        3,500.
Speed, light .......................... knots..              9 ................    9...................          10 ..................  10..................   10 ...................        11.
Speed, loaded......... ........                 do....       5.................... 5 .................           8................... 8 ..      -............  6....................         8.
Speed, dredging ...      ...........            do....                                  1....................    2 to3 ...............  2 to 3 ...........     1 to2 .............           1.
Number and size of pumps................                     Two 20-inch .... .... Two 18-inch........           Two 20-inch .......    Two 20-inch........ Two 18-inch.......               Two 20-inch.
Number'of men in crew .....................                  57.................   49...................         60 ................    60................... 34-------------...................
                                                                                                                                                                                             58.
Location of dredging ........................                Delaware River, Del. Passes of the Missis-          Ambrose Channel, Ambrose Channel,             Delaware               River,  Galveston Harbor,
                                                                                    sippi River, La.               New York Har-          New York Har-           Del., and Port-               Tex.                                O

                                                                                                                   bor.                   bor.                    land, Oreg.                                                       0
Character of dredged material ............... Sand, mud, gravel,                        Sand, mud, and clay.     Sand, gravel, mud.. Sand, stones, mud, Sand, mud, and clay. Sand, mud, and clay.
                                                                 clay, and broken                                                         debris.                                                                                   z
                                                                 stone.
Average depth of dredging ..................                 28 feet............. 30 to 35 feet .........        30 feet............   25 to 30 feet.........24 feet ..............                           29 feet.
Average load in bins.........cubic yards..                   3,170................ 637.............              2,530.............. 2,660................          846.................                      2,040.                0l
Material pumped per hour............do....                   871.................. 497.............              876...... .........   995 ..................       386..............                         707.
Average number cubic yards dredged daily..                   9,590 ...............3,160 .............            9,320 ..............  10,750...............        1,910 ................                    9,160.
Total number of loads....................                    647................. 1,059 .............            1,042..............   1,125................        115..................                     623.
Total amount dredged.........cubic yards..                   2,050,222 .........   670,584 ............          2,636,123 ........... 3,002,537       ............ 97,404 ...............                    1,272,659.
Average distance to dump..a... miles..                       6 ...     ........... 1....................                               72................           . .................                       1.
Total number of days on which any dredging                   214.................. 212.................          283.................. 279 .................        51                  ----...............   139.
  was done.                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Q
Total number of hours pumping ............                   2,356.........     ..      1,348............        3,010-...-..-.......             3,021...............    252..................               1,802.
Time to pump 1 load ....................                     3 hours 39 minutes..       1 hour 16 minutes...     2 hours 53 minutes..             2 hours 41 minutes.. 2 hours 10 minutes ..                  2 hours 54 minutes.
Total number of hours dumping .............                  121................        133................      200..................            197................     24..................                186.
Time to dump 1 load .......................                  11 minutes..........       7 minutes ..........     112minutes.........              102 minutes.........                                        18minutes.
Total number of hours going to and from                      826................        421..................    1,622...............             1,852  ................                                     265.
  dump.
Total number of hours going to and from                      22...................      198..................    185..................                                                  97.
                                                                                                                                                                     .....................
                                                                                                                                                  131..................                                                             U2
  wharf.
Total number of hours taking on coal and                     394 ...............        205............... 27................                     None, coaled Sun- ......................    103.
  water.                                                                                                                                            days.
Total number of hours lost on account of                     302 ..................   1 72...................
                                                                                                           312.............                       321................. ...................... 373.
  weather.
Total amount of coal consumed...long tons..                  8,045................      4,014 ................   10,652 ..............            10,854 ..............               ....        .........   27,373 barrels.
Number of pounds of coal consumed per                        8.8..................      13.3.................    9.1..................I           8.1.........................                 ........       0.915 gallon.
  cubic yard of material dredged.
Cost per cubic yard, including all repairs.....              $0.0413... .......  $0.11................ $0.041...............                       0.03865.............              $0.144............... $0.0588.
Remarks................          ...............             2 months repairing. Repairing 1 month.. ..........................                        .. ............               Put in commission     Put in commi ssi on
                                                                                                                                                                                      this year; 2 months    this year; operated
                                                                                                                                                                                      trials, 5 days regu-   7 months; uses oil
                                                                                                                                                                                      lar operations.        for fuel.
                                                         1                                                                                    i                                  I
904      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                           S. ARMIY.

EXAMINATIONS,       SURVEYS,      AND CONTINGENCIES                     OF RIVERS AND
                                   HARBORS.
  For examinations, surveys, and contingencies of rivers and harbors,
an appropriation of $350,000 should be made, as follows:
  For examinations, surveys, and contingencies, and for incidental
repairs for rivers and harbors for which there may be no special ap-
propriation; for expenses connected with the inspection of bridges
or other structures reported as obstructions to navigation, with the
service of notices and holding of hearings when required in such
cases, with the location of harbor lines under the act of March 3, 1899,
and with the examinations and reports by officers of the Corps of
Engineers, and by boards of engineers upon plans and sites for bridges
or other structures authorized by law to be built, and upon bills au-
thorizing bridges or other structures, reports upon which may be
called for by Congress; and for other expenses connected with the
performance of the duties which are, or may be, imposed by law upon
the War Department in the protection and preservation of the naviga-
ble waters of the United States.
      SUPERVISION            OF THE HARBOR OF NEW YORK.
   The supervisor of the harbor during the past year was Capt. Aaron
Ward, U. S. Navy.
   The office of supervisor of the harbor of New York was created by
act of Congress approved June 29, 1888, entitled "An act to prevent
obstructive and injurious deposits within the harbor and adjacent
waters of New York City, by dumping or otherwise, and to punish
and prevent such offenses." This act has been amended by section 3
of the act of August 18, 1894, entitled "An act making appropriations
for the construction, repair, and preservation of certain public works
on rivers and harbors, and for other purposes," by which amendment
the functions and powers of the officer have been greatly enlarged.
Additional duties are also conferred on the supervisor by section 2 of
the last-named act. The functions and powers of the supervisor have
been further extended by section 8 of act of Congress approved May
28, 1908, entitled "An act to amend the laws relating to navigation,
and for other purposes."
   Under the provisions of section 5 of the act of June 29, 1888, a line
officer of the Navy is designated to discharge the duties created by
the act, under the direction of the Secretary of War. On May 23,
1889, the Secretary of War directed that all communications in con-
nection with these duties should be addressed to him through this
office, and on February 1, 1890, he further directed that the powers
conferred upon him by the act should be exercised through the Chief
of Engineers.
   The report of Captain Ward for the past fiscal year is submitted
herewith as Appendix A A A.
   Estimates for the fiscal year ending June 80, 1911.-The estimates
of funds required for this service for the fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, are given in the above-mentioned report, as follows:
For pay of inspectors, deputy inspectors, office force, and expenses of
  office--------------                                                  $10,260. 00
       ................-----------...........-------.............----------
For pay of crews and maintenance of patrol fleet .................... 75, 000. 00
For renewing engines and boilers of steam tug Vigilant ................. 15, 000. 00
      Total.............................    .........................               100, 260. 00
                  CALIFORNIA DEBRIS    COMMISSION.                905
          CALIFORNIA         DEBRIS      COMMISSION.

   Unrestricted mining by the hydraulic process in California resulted
in enormous quantities of debris being washed down into the rivers
and natural water courses draining the western slopes of the Sierras.
Later on hydraulic mining was practically prohibited by the decisions
of the courts on account of injury to streams and the adjacent private
land.
   The act of Congress approved March 1, 1893, created the Califor-
nia Debris Commission, stipulating that the commission should con-
sist of three officers of the Corps of Engineers, appointed by the
President with the concurrence of the Senate. The same act pre-
scribed the duties of the commission, which are, first, the regulation
of hydraulic mining in the territory drained by the Sacramento and
San Joaquin river systems, so that mining by that method may be
resumed and carried on without injury to other interests in the State,
and, second, to mature and adopt plans to improve the navigability
of the above-mentioned rivers, to protect same from damage due to
mining debris, and to afford relief thereto in flood time.
   Regulation of hydraulic mining.-Up to June 30, 1909, the com-
mission received 852 applications for permits to mine by the hydraulic
process under the restrictions imposed by the act of Congress of
March 1, 1893, and granted permits in cases where means for properly
impounding the debris were provided by the applicants.
   Improvement and protection of rivers and flood control.-The Yuba
River, a tributary of the Feather, which in turn is a tributary of the
Sacramento River, was the first selected for treatment, this stream
being more filled with debris and carrying more detritus than all the
other tributaries of the Sacramento combined. The general project
for the treatment of the Yuba was printed in the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1900, part 8, page 5030. The estimated
total cost of this project was placed at $800,000. It was adopted by
act of Congress approved June 13, 1902. The estimated total cost
of the project has been appropriated-$400,000 by Congress and
$400,000 by the legislature of California, the appropriations by Con-
gress stipulating that one-half the cost of the work should be paid by
the State of California.
   The Yuba River project contemplates holding the great quantities
of mine d6bris now in that stream and tributaries, to prevent it from
being carried down into the Feather and Sacramento rivers, this to
be accomplished by restraining barriers, or dams, across the bed of
the Yuba, by a settling basin adjoining the river on the south, and
by training walls below.
   The amount expended by the United States on the existing project
for the work in the Yuba River up to June 30, 1909, was $297,745.27.
These expenditures were principally in payment of one-half the pur-
chase price of upward of 10,000 acres of land; in payment of one-
half the cost of the construction of portions of barriers, or dams, in
Yuba River, known as Nos. 1 and 2; of one-half the cost of excava-
ting a flood-overflow channel through the promontory on Yuba River
known as Daguerre Point; of one-half the cost of constructing a por-
tion of the proposed training walls to confine the flow of Yuba River
below Daguerre Point; and of one-half the cost of constructing a por-
tion of the proposed debris-settling basin on the south side of Yuba
River in the vicinity of Daguerre Point.
9086      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                   S. ARMY.

   The expenditures during the past fiscal year were in payment of
one-half the cost of constructing portions of the training walls and
portions of the proposed d6bris-settling basin in the vicinity of
Daguerre Point.
   In a special report dated June 30, 1907 (submitted to comply with
sections 5, 6, and 7 of the act of Congress of March 1, 1893), printed
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, pages 2262-
2269, the commission estimated that the restraining works already
constructed and remaining to be built under the present project for
the treatment of Yuba River would provide capacity for storing
60,000,000 cubic yards of debris in that stream. The commission
stated in this special report, however, that dredging was considered
the most feasible method to meet the requirements of all the interests
involved--navigation, protection from flood overflow, better drain-
age, and disposal and control of debris in the Sacramento and Feather
rivers, and submitted an estimate of $800,000 for beginning this work.
This estimate was submitted by the commission with the provision
that one-half should be appropriated by the State of California. The
State of California on March 1, 1909, appropriated $400,000 for this
purpose with the stipulation that-
   SEc. 2. This act shall become operative only upon condition that the Government
of the United States shall, under, by, and through the War Department, assume full
charge and control of all work to be done as provided by this act, and also upon condi-
tion that a like sum of four hundred thousand dollars be appropriated by the United
States for such work.
   The appropriation made by the State of California also contains
the provision that "the whole of such amounts appropriated by the
Congress of the United States and by the State of California shall
be expended under the direction of the Secretary of War and the
supervision of the Chief of Engineers."
   The commission reports that from surveys made and from other
surveys soon to be completed data will be available for use in prepar-
ing, during the ensuing year, a project for thorough control of the
rivers at all stages.
   The maintenance of navigation on the Sacramento and San Joaquin
river systems is important. Upward of 1,000,000 tons of freight and
300,000 passengers are carried annually by vessels of all classes plying
the Sacramento, San Joaquin, Mokelumne, and Feather rivers. The
freight consists principally of grain, mill stuffs, lumber, groceries,
fruit, vegetables, and general merchandise, and is carried principally
on barges towed by steamboats and on scow-schooners. About 45
steamboats, many barges, launches, and scow-schooners are engaged
in this trade.
   Much of the fertile country along the Sacramento and San Joaquin
rivers is without railroad transportation, owing to the expense and
difficulties of the construction and maintenance of railroads in a low-
land country which is subject to more or less widespread floods an-
nually. These fertile lands, great areas of which are under a high
state of cultivation, are protected ordinarily from overflow by ex-
tensive levee systems, constructed and maintained at great expense,
and the rivers are in many cases the only means of transporting
freight and passengers to and from most of this country. The lower
rates by river to some points which can also be reached by railroads
are in some cases met by the latter.
                              CALIFORNIA DEBRIS COMMISSION.                                              907

  The following statement shows the present condition for purposes
of navigation of the three principal streams comprising the Sacra-
mento and San Joaquin river systems:

                               Sacramento River.              Feather River.           San Joaquin River.


Maximum draft that         San Francisco to Sacra-        Mouth of river to         Mouth of river to Stock-
  can be carried at low     mento, 7 feet; Sacra-          Marysville, 1 to 2        ton, 6 feet; Stockton to
  water.                    mento to Colusa, 4 to 5        feet.                      Fire baugh,      a few
                            feet; Colusa to Red                                      inches.
                             Bluff, 2 to 2) feet.
Head of navigation.....    Red Bluff .................    Marysville............    Stockton   (Firebaugh, 4
                                                                                     months in year).
Length of navigable        Mouth to Sacramento, 61        Mouth to Marysville,      Mouth    to Stockton, 50
  portions.                 miles; mouth to Colusa,        30 miles.                 miles; mouth to Fire-
                            152 miles; mouth to Red                                   baugh, 200 miles.
                            Bluff, 262 miles.



  More extended information concerning navigation, flood control,
and the mine debris question in and along the Sacramento and San
Joaiquin rivers and their tributaries may be found in the document
and reports referred to in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1908 (pt. 1, p. 861), and in House Documents Nos. 1123 and 1124,
Sixtieth Congress, second session.
  The members of the commission during the past fiscal year were
the following officers of the Corps of Engineers, U. S. Army: Lieut.
Col. John Biddle; Maj. C. H. McKinstry, to June 7, 1909; Capt. Thos.
H. Jackson; and First Lieut. Charles T. Leeds, since June 7, 1909.
  The appended money statement for appropriation for restraining
mine debris in California includes only funds appropriated by Con-
gress, and does not include funds appropriated by the legislature of
California.

       APPROPRIATION        FOR EXPENSES          OF CALIFORNIA         DIEBRIS    COMMISSION,   1909.


July 1, 1908, amount appropriated by act of Congress approved May 27,
  1908.............................................        ................. $15, 000.00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year..................          a 13, 124. 85

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.................................                                  1, 875. 15
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................................                         1, 825.15

July 1, 1909, balance reverting to Treasury ..........................                                   50. 00

       APPROPRIATION         FOR EXPENSES         OF CALIFORNIA         DBRIS      COMMISSION,   1910.


Amount appropriated by act of Congress approved March 4, 1909......... $15, 000. 00
Amount (estimated) required for expenses of the California D6bris Com-
mission during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, in regulating hy-
draulic mining operations in the State of California, making examina-
tions and surveys for improvement of navigation, control and disposition
of mine d4bris, and control of flood waters as required by the act of Con-
gress approved March 1, 1893.............................................. 15, 000. 00

  a In addition there was expended during the year $2.09 from appropriation for fiscal
year 1907 and $1,142.75 from appropriation for fiscal year 1908.
908       REPORT      OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                S. ARMY.

          APPROPRIATION FOR RESTRAINING MINE         DIBRIS IN CALIFORNIA.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................          $132, 042. 54
Amount received from sales ............................................               503. 78
                                                                                 132, 546. 32
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ...........................................................                29, 659. 81

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................................            102, 886. 51
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities payable by United States.........            9, 955. 60

July 1, 1909, balance available ..................           .
                                                          ........ ........ .     92, 930. 91

July 1, 1909, amount of United States funds covered by uncompleted con-
  tracts.....--..--....... ........ ...... ..      ..................
                                                   ................                7, 043. 38
   (See Appendix B B B.)

EXAMINATION OF MISSISSIPPI RIVER WITH A VIEW TO PROVIDING
AND MAINTAINING A NAVIGABLE CHANNEL 14 FEET DEEP AND OF
SUITABLE WIDTH FROM ST. LOUIS TO THE MOUTH.

   Under the provisions of the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907,
a commission has been appointed to examine the Mississippi River
below St. Louis and report upon the practicability and desirability of
constructing and maintaining a navigable channel 14 feet deep and of
suitable width from St. Louis to the mouth of the river either by
open-channel improvement or by a canal or canals for part of said
route. The commission is also required by the act to consider in
this connection the survey of a proposed waterway from Chicago to
St. Louis heretofore reported upon (see H. Docs. No. 263, 59th Cong.,
1st sess., and No. 437, 59th Cong., 2d sess.), and also to report upon
any water power which may be created in the said section of the Mis-
sissippi River below St. Louis, as well as in the proposed waterway
from Chicago to St. Louis, and what steps, if any, should be taken to
cause the cost of improvement to be defrayed in whole or in part by
means of such water power or of lands which may be drained by
either of said waterways.
   The members of the commission are Col. W. H. Bixby, Corps of
Engineers, president, Mississippi River Commission; Lieut. Col.
C. McD. Townsend, Corps of Engineers; Lieut. Col. J. G. Warren,
Corps of Engineers; Mr. Henry B. Richardson, member of the
Mississippi River Commission, and Mr. Homer P. Ritter, member
of the Mississippi River Commission, with Capt. G. R. Lukesh, Corps
of Engineers, as recorder.
   Report dated March 20, 1909, was duly submitted and was reviewed
by the Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors, pursuant to law.
The report was transmitted to Congress and printed in House Docu-
ment No. 50, Sixty-first Congress, first session.
   The sum of $190,000 was appropriated by the act to defray the
expense of the survey, of which $177,065.02 had been expended to
June 30, 1909. The expenditure during the year amounted to
$65,040.19.
                       MISSISSIPPI RIVER COMMISSION.                            909
              MISSISSIPPI            RIVER COMMISSION.

   The Mississippi River Commission, constituted by act of Congress
of June 28, 1879, is in charge of the improvement of the Mississippi
River from Head of Passes to the mouth of the Ohio River, including
the rectification of Red and Atchafalaya rivers at their junction with
the Mississippi, the building of levees, and the improvement of the
several harbors for which specific appropriations have been made,
with the exception of the harbor of Vicksburg and the mouth of
Yazoo River. It is also charged with the survey of the Mississippi
River from Head of Passes to its headwaters, and with gauging the
river and its tributaries.
   The river and harbor acts of March 3, 1905, and March 2, 1907,
prescribed that the money therein appropriated and authorized to be
expended should be applied to the construction of suitable and neces-
sary dredge boats and other devices and appliances and in the main-
tenance and operation of the same, with the view of ultimately obtain-
ing and maintaining a navigable channel from Cairo down not less
than 250 feet in width and 9 feet in depth at all periods of the year,
except when navigation is closed by ice. They also authorized allot-
ments from such funds in the discretion of the Commission and upon
approval by the Chief of Engineers, to be applied to the water courses
connected with the river and the harbors upon it now under the
control of the Mississippi River Commission.
   Act of Congress approved June 4, 1906, provides that any funds
which have been, or may hereafter be, appropriated by Congress for
improving the Mississippi River between the Head of Passes and the
mouth of the Ohio River, and which may be allotted to levees, may
be expended under the direction of the Secretary of War, in accord-
ance with the plans, specifications, and recommendations of the Mis-
sissippi River Commission, as approved by the Chief of Engineers,
upon levees upon any part of said river between the Head of Passes
and Cape Girardeau, Mo.
   The act of March 2, 1907, provided for prosecution of the work
under continuing contract and authorized expenditures in the sum of
$6,000,000 (of which $2,000,000 yet remains to be appropriated), pro-
vided that this sum shall be used in improvement for not less than
three years, the work done each year to cost approximately
$2,000,000.
  The commissioners during the past fiscal year were Col. Winm. H.
Bixby, Corps of Engineers, president; Col. Win. T. Rossell, Corps
of Engineers; Lieut. Col. J. G. Warren, Corps of Engineers; Homer
P. Ritter, assistant, United States Coast and Geodetic Survey;
Robert S. Taylor, J. A. Ockerson, and Henry B. Richardson.
  Capt. G. R. Lukesh, Corps of Engineers, was on duty as secretary
to the Commission to November 30, 1908, and First Lieut. C. H.
Knight, Corps of Engineers, since that date.
   Estimate for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911.-The following
estimate of funds required for carrying on the works under its charge
for the year ending June 30, 1911, is submitted by the commission:
For continuing the improvement of Mississippi River from Head of Passes
  to the mouth of the Ohio River, including salaries and clerical, office,
  traveling, and miscellaneous expenses of the Mississippi River Com-
  mission.......................     ..................................   $4, 000, 000
910      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S.   ARMY.

  The estimate has been reduced in this office to $2,000,000, this
being the limit of expenditure at present authorized by Congress.
  The report of the commission on the operations under its charge
during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is submitted herewith as
Appendix P P P of this report.

PERMANENT INTERNATIONAL COMMISSION OF THE CONGRESSES OF
                      NAVIGATION.

   By act approved June 28, 1902, Congress appropriated the sum
of $3,000 per year for the support and maintenance of the Permanent
International Commission of the Congresses of Navigation and for
the payment of the actual expenses of the properly accredited national
delegates of the United States to the meeting of the Congresses and
of the Commission.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year the United States was repre-
sented on the Permanent International Commission of the Congresses
of Navigation by Brig. Gen. C. W. Raymond, U. S. Army, retired;
Mr. E. L. Corthell, civil engineer; Lieut. Col. H. F. Hodges, Corps of
Engineers; Lieut. Col. J. C. Sanford, Corps of Engineers, and Mr.
John Bogart, civil engineer. On the permanent executive committee
of that Commission it was represented by General Raymond as the
principal representative and Mr. E. L. Corthell as the substitute.
The representation on the Commission and on the executive com-
mittee has remained unchanged during the year. Colonel Sanford
attended a meeting of the Commission held at Brussels, Belgium,
May 17, 1909; also a meeting of the executive committee held May
15, 1909, neither of the regular members representing the United
States being able to be present.
   The expenditures during the year from the appropriation made by
Congress amounted to $3,860.50, and have been for the expenses of the
American Section in attending its meetings and of the delegate to the
meeting of the Permanent International Commission of the Congresses
of Navigation, for the maintenance of the executive office of the
American Section, for the printing and distribution of circulars issued
by the Section, and for the support and maintenance of the com-
mission, to which the United States contributes $1,000 per annum.

            ESTABLISHMENT          OF HARBOR LINES.

  Under authority given to the Secretary of War in section 11 of
the river and harbor act approved March 3, 1899, harbor lines have
been established during the past fiscal year at the following localities,
under dates as indicated:
  East side of Hudson River, between Adams street and Burden Iron
Works, Troy, N. Y., approved March 13, 1909; Red Hook Point,
Brooklyn, N. Y., modification approved March 19, 1909; Arthur
Kill, between Buckwheat Island and Morse Creek, N. J., approved
October 8, 1908; Delaware and Schuylkill rivers at Philadelphia, Pa.,
approved September 4, 1908; Absecon Inlet, Atlantic City, N. J.,
approved January 23, 1909; Curtis Bay, Baltimore Harbor, Md.,
south side, approved May 25, 1909; Potomac River at Alexandria,
Va., approved June 1, 1909; Mobile River at Pinto Island, approved
            RULES AND REGULATIONS GOVERNING         CANALS.         911
February 13, 1909; Missouri River at Omaha, Nebr., approved June
5, 1909; Monongahela River from Brownsville near Lock No. 5 to
Lock No. 6, at Rices Landing, Pa., approved June 5, 1909; Alle-
gheny River, Pennsylvania, from Lock No. 2 to upper end of Bril-
liant Pumping Station, modification approved September 5, 1908;
Ohio River from Dam No. 3, at Glen Osborne, Pa., to Dam No. 5,
near Rochester, Pa., approved May 29, 1909; Muskingum River above
and below Lock and Dam No. 10, at Zanesville, Ohio, approved June
25, 1909; Duluth-Superior Harbor in front of Minnesota Point, Minne-
sota and Wisconsin, approved September 21, 1908; Manitowoc River
at Manitowoc, Wis., approved July 6, 1908; Inner Harbor of San Pedro,
Cal., approved unconditionally July 29, 1908; San Francisco Bay,
California, between point San Pablo and Castro Rocks, modification
approved lMay 22, 1909; Swinomish Slough at La Conner, Wash., ap-
proved October 9, 1908; Kahului Harbor, Hawaii, approved April
22, 1909.

RULES AND REGULATIONS GOVERNING THE NAVIGATION OF CANALS,
                          ETC.

    Section 4 of the river and harbor act of August 18, 1894, as amended
by section 11 of the river and harbor act of June 13, 1902, delegates
to the Secretary of War the duty of prescribing such rules and regu-
lations for the use, administration, and navigation of any or all canals
and similar works of navigation that now are or that hereafter may be
owned, operated, or maintained by the United States as in his judg-
ment the public necessity may require; and he is also authorized to
prescribe regulations to govern the speed and movement of vessels and
other water craft in any public navigable channel which has been im-
proved under authority of Congress whenever in his judgment such
regulations are necessary to protect such improved channels from in-
jury or to prevent interference with the operations of the United
States in improving navigable waters or injury to any plant that may
be employed in such operations. Such rules and regulations have
been established during the past year for the following-named locali-
ties:
   Tampa and Hillsboro bays, Florida; Apalachicola Harbor, inner
channel, Florida; Southwest Pass, Mississippi River, La.; Port Arthur
Ship Canal, the Sabine-Neches Canal and part of Taylors Bayou,
Texas; Buffalo Bayou, Texas; Duluth-Superior Harbor, Minnesota
and Wisconsin; St. Clair River, Michigan; Columbia and Willamette
rivers, Oregon; San Juan Harbor, Porto Rico, channel leading to.

RULES AND REGULATIONS         GOVERNING     THE OPENING OF DRAW-
                              BRIDGES.

  Section 5 of the river and harbor act of August 18, 1894, provides
that it shall be the duty of all persons owning, operating, and tend-
ing the drawbridges then built or which might thereafter be built
across the navigable rivers and other waters of the United States to
open or cause to be opened the draws of such bridges, under such rules
and regulations as in the opinion of the Secretary of War the public
interests require, for the passage of vessels and other water craft.
Such rules and regulations have been established during the past
912      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

year by the Secretary of War for certain drawbridges over the fol-
lowing-named waterways:
  Spa Creek, between Annapolis and Eastport, Md.; Mackeys Creek,
North Carolina; Galena River, Illinois; St. Croix River, Wisconsin and
Minnesota; Kalamazoo River between Douglas and Saugatuck, Mich.

RULES AND REGULATIONS FOR THE NAVIGATION OF STREAMS ON
WHICH THE FLOATING OF LOOSE TIMBER AND SACK RAFTS OF TIM-
BER AND LOGS IS THE PRINCIPAL METHOD OF NAVIGATION.

   Under the provisions of act of Congress approved May 9, 1900, "An
act authorizing the Secretary of War to make regulations governing
the running of loose logs, steamboats, and rafts on certain rivers and
streams," the Secretary of War has prescribed rules and regulations
for the navigation of the "Inland route," so called, and connecting
waters between Cheboygan and Conway, Mich.

      STRUCTURES IN THE NAVIGABLE WATERS OF PORTO RICO.

  Act of Congress approved June 11, 1906, empowered the Secretary
of War, under certain restrictions, to authorize the construction, ex-
tension, and maintenance of wharves, piers, and other structures on
lands underlying harbor areas and navigable streams and bodies of
water in or surrounding Porto Rico and the islands adjacent thereto.
  Through a conference between the district officer and the governor
of Porto Rico a definite policy has been established and is followed
in connection with applications for privileges under this law, several
applications having been acted on during the year.

BRIDGING NAVIGABLE WATERS OF THE UNITED STATES.

   Plans and maps of locations of the following bridges proposed to
be erected under the authority of special acts of Congress have been
examined with a view to protection of the interests of navigation
and have been approved by the Secretary of War, as provided by the
acts, and the local engineer officers have been furnished copies of
the instruments of approval and drawings showing the plans and loca-
tions and charged with the supervision of the construction of the
bridges, so far as necessary, to see that they are built in accordance
with the approved plans:
   Bridge of Allegheny and Washington counties, Pa., over Monon-
gahela River at Monongahela city.-Plans and map of location of a
bridge at this place authorized by act of Congress approved April 3,
1908, were approved May 21, 1908, and modified drawings supple-
mental to those attached to original instrument were approved
July 5, 1908.
   Bridge of the Chicago, Indianapolis and Louisville Railroad Com-
pany, over Calumet River at Hammond, Ind.-Reconstruction of this
bridge was authorized by act of Congress approved February 20,
1908. Plans were approved July 29, 1908.
   Bridge of the Seaboard Air Line Railroad Company over Savannah
River at Hutchinson Island, Georgia.-Plansfor the reconstruction of
an existing bridge at this place were approved November 12, 1908.
                   BRIDGING OF NAVIGABLE    WATERS.               913
  Bridge of the city of Chicago over Calumet River at Ninety-second
street.-Plans for a bridge to replace an existing structure at this
place were approved November 12, 1908.
  Bridge of Okanogan County, Wash., over Okanogan River at Okano-
gan.-Construction of this bridge was authorized by act of Congress
approved May 20, 1908. Plans and map of location were approved
January 8, 1909.
   Bridge of the St. Paul Bridge and Terminal Railway Company over
Mississippi River at St. Paul, Minn.-Construction of this bridge
was authorized by act of Congress approved December 18, 1908.
Plans and map of location were approved February 16, 1909.
   Bridge of the Delaware, Lackcawanna and Western Railroad Company
over Delaware River near Columbia, N. J., and Slateford, Pa.-Con-
struction of this bridge was authorized by act of Congress approved
January 14, 1909. Plans and map of location were approved March
9, 1909.
   Bridge of Carter County, Mo., over Current River near Van Buren
Ferry.-Constructionof this bridge was authorized by act of Con-
gress approved February 1, 1909. Plans and map of location were
approved April 8, 1909.
   Bridge of the Iowa Central Railway Company over Mississippi River
at Keithsburg, Ill.-Reconstruction of this bridge was authorized by
act of Congress approved February 25, 1909. Plans were approved
April 12, 1909.
   Bridge of the Santee River Cypress Lumber Company over Santee
River near Ferguson, S. C.-Construction of this bridge was author-
ized by act of Congress approved February 6, 1909. Plans and map
of location were approved April 14, 1909.
   Bridge of the Chicago, Lake Shore and Eastern Railway Company,
over Calumet River near Gary, Ind.-Construction of this bridge was
authorized by act of Congress approved March 3, 1909. Plans and
map of location were approved April 26, 1909.
   Bridge of Behn Brothers over Condado Bay at San Juan, P. R.-
Construction of this bridge was authorized by act of Congress ap-
proved February 25, 1909. Plans and map of location were approved
April 29, 1909.
   Bridge of the Northern Pacific Railway Company over St. Louis
River (Grassy Point Bridge) between Duluth, Minn., and Superior,
Wis.-Construction of a bridge at this place was authorized by act
of Congress approved January 3, 1887. Plans for a bridge to replace
an existing structure at this point were approved May 10, 1909.
   Bridge of the North Coast Railroad Company over Columbia River
in Benton and Walla Walla counties, Wash.-Construction of this
bridge was authorized by act of Congress approved January 29, 1907.
Plans and map of location were approved May 13, 1909.
   Bridge of the city of St. Louis, Mo., over Mississippi River in that
city.-Construction of this bridge was authorized by act of Congress
approved June 25, 1909. Plans and map of location were approved
December 17, 1908. Modified plans were approved May 20, 1909.
   Bridge of the Brownsville and Gulf Railway Company over Rio
Grande River at Brownsville, Tex., and Matamoras, Mexico.-Con-
struction of this bridge was authorized by act of Congress approved
     9001-ENG 1909-58
914     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.        S. ARMY.

May 20, 1908, as amended by joint resloution approved May 22,
1908. Plans and map of location were approved May 21, 1909.
   Bridge of the Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Company over Savannah
River at Savannah, Ga.-Plans for the reconstruction of an existing
structure were approved May 21, 1909.
   Bridge of the Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company over Coosa
River at Gadsden, Ala.-Plans for reconstructing an existing bridge
at this place were approved June 16, 1909.
   Bridge of Manistee Township, Mich., over Manistee River at Manis-
tee.-Construction of this bridge was authorized by act of Congress
approved May 20, 1908. Plans and map of location were approved
August 15, 1908.
   Under the provisions of section 9 of the river and harbor act
approved March 3, 1899, bridges may be built over navigable waters
entirely within the limits of any State, under authority of legislative
enactments of such State, when the plans and locations of the struct-
ures are approved by the Secretary of War. Plans and maps of
locations of the following bridges proposed to be erected under these
provisions have been examined with a view to protection of the inter-
ests of navigation and have been approved by the Secretary of War,
and the local engineer officers have been furnished copies of the
drawings and instruments of approval and charged with the supervi-
sion of construction of the bridges, so far as necessary, to see that
they are built in accordance with the approved plans:
   Bridge of the Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Company over Scotts
Creek at Hospital and Pinnerpoints, Virginia.-Plansfor reconstruct-
ing an existing bridge at this place were approved July 6, 1908.
   Bridge of the Day Island Company over Day Island Waterway near
Tacoma, Wash.-Plans and map of location were approved July
15, 1908.
   Bridge of the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Company over Susque-
hanna River at Havre de Grace, Md.-Plans for the reconstruction of
an existing structure were approved July 27, 1908.
   Bridge of Atlantic County, N. J., over Inside Thoroughfare at Vent-
nor.-Plans for replacing an existing structure at this place were
approved July 30, 1908.
   Bridge of town of Handsboro, Miss., over Bayou Bernard at that
place.-Plans and map of location were approved July 30, 1908.
   Bridge of Warren County, Miss., over Big Black River at Ivanhoe
Ferry.-Plans and map of location were approved September 25,
1907. Modified plans were approved August 10, 1908.
   Bridge of the Congress Street Bridge Commission of Bridgeport,
Conn., over Poquonnocle River in that city.-Plans for a bridge to
replace an existing structure were approved August 12, 1908.
   Bridge of the Seattle Electric Company across East and West water-
ways in Seattle Harbor, Washington.-Plans and map of location
were approved August 15, 1908.
   Bridge of King County, Wash., over White River at Orillia.-Plans
and map of location were approved August 15, 1908.
   Bridge of the Seattle Electric Company over portage between Lakes
Union and Washington at Seattle, Wash.-Plans for this bridge were
approved August 17, 1908.
   Bridge of Perry County, Ark., over Fourche Le Fevre River near
Houston.-Plansand map of location were approved August 17, 1908.
                  BRIDGING OF NAVIGABLE      WATERS.                 915
   Bridge of Hudson County, N. J., across Hackensack River, at Newark
avenue, Jersey City.-Plans for rebuilding an existing structure at
this place were approved July 20, 1906, and plans supplemental
thereto were approved August 22, 1908.
   Bridge of Warren County, Miss., over Big Black River at Hankinson
Ferry.-Plans for rebuilding an existing bridge at this place were
approved August 22, 1908.
   Bridge of Harrison County, Miss., over Tchoutacabouffa River,
below Morris Ferry.-Plans and map of location were approved
August 27, 1908.
   Bridge of the Bath-Rowan Bridge Company over Licking River at
Farmers, Ky.-Plans and map of location were approved September
1, 1908.
   Bridge of the Logan and Southern Railway Company over Guyandot
River at Logan, W. Va.-Plans and map of location were approved
September 1, 1908.
   Bridge of the New Iberia, St. Martin and Northern Railroad Com-
pany over Bayou Teche, near Wyche Plantation, Louisiana.-Plans
and map of location were approved September 3, 1908.
    Bridge of the Montgomery Bridge Company over Kanawha River at
Montgomery, W. Va.- Plans and map of location for this bridge were
approved September 5, 1907. Map of new location was approved
September 8, 1908. New approval in name of Montgomery and
Cannelton Bridge Company and former approval canceled February
16, 1909.
    Bridge of Venango County, Pa., over Allegheny River at Oil City.-
Plans and map of location of bridge to replace an existing structure
were approved September 14, 1908.
    Bridge of the city of Chicago, Ill., over South Fork of South Branch of
Chicago River. Plans and map of location were approved September
14, 1908.
    Bridge of Muskegon County, Mich., over Muskegon River.-Plans
and map of location were approved September 18, 1908.
    Bridge of Snohomish County, Wash., over Stilaguamish River, near
Stanwood, Wash.-Plans and map of location were approved Sep-
tember 24, 1908.
    Bridge of the city of Ottawa, Ill., over Illinois River at that place.-
Plans and map of location were approved September 22, 1908.
    Bridge of Leake County, Miss., over Pearl River at Carthage.-Plans
for rebuilding an existing bridge at this place were approved Sep-
tember 30, 1908.
    Bridge of Quitman County, Miss., over Coldwater River near Dar-
ling. Plans and map of location were approved October 2, 1908.
    Bridge of Hernando County, Fla., over Withlacoochee River at
Istachatta.--Plans and map of location were approved October 8,
1909.
    Bridge of the Havre de Grace and Perryville Bridge Company, over
Susquehanna River at Havre de Grace, Md.-Plans for reconstructing
an existing bridge at this place were approved October 22, 1908.
    Bridge of the city of Green Bay, Wis., over Fox River at that place.-
Plans and map of location were approved October 26, 1908.
    Bridge of Lee and De Soto counties, Fla., over Caloosahatchee River
at Labelle.-Plans and map of location were approved October 28,
1908.
916      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Bridge of the New Orleans and Northwestern Railroad Company over
Tensas River, near Daniels Ferry, La.-Plans for rebuilding an exist-
ing structure at this place were approved October 29, 1908.
   Bridge of Jones County, N. C., over Trent River in said county.-
Plans for rebuilding an existing structure were approved October 30,
1908.
   Bridge of Essex County, Va., over Piscataway Creek.-Plans for
rebuilding an existing structure were approved November 4, 1908.
   Bridge of Kamiah Bridge Company, Limited, over Clearwater River
near Kamiah, Idaho.-Plans and map of location were approved
August 29, 1908. Modified plans were approved November 12, 1908.
   Bridge of Fairmount Coal Company over Redbank Creek, near New
Bethlehem, Pa.-Plans and map of location were approved November
12, 1908.
   Bridge of the city of Oswego, N. Y., over Oswego River in that city.-
Plans for reconstructing an existing bridge were approved November
17, 1908.
   Bridge of Cabell County, W. Va., over Guyandot River at Barbours-
ville.-Plans and map of location were approved November 17, 1908.
   Bridge of Bergen County, N. J., over Hackensack River at Hackensack
and Ridgefield Park.-Plans and map of location were approved
December 12, 1908.
   Bridge of the Grays Harbor and Puget Sound Railway Company over
Hoquiam River at Hoquiam, Wash.-Plans and map of location were
approved December 12, 1908.
   Bridge of Coos County, Oreg., over South Slough in that county.-
Plans and map of location were approved December 12, 1908.
   Bridge of the Pittsburg, Fort Wayne and Chicago Railroad Company
over Chicago River at Nineteenth street, Chicago, Ill.-Plans and map of
location for this bridge were approved April 17, 1907. Modified plans
were approved December 15, 1908.
   Bridge of Dade County, Fla., over North Fork of Miami River.-
Plans and map of location were approved December 17, 1908.
   Bridge of the Oregon and Washington Railroad Company over Colum-
bia Slough in Multnomah County, Oreg.-Plans and map of location
were approved December 23, 1908.
   Bridge of the Grays Harbor and Puget Sound Railway Company over
Chehalis River near Centralia, Wash.-Plans and map of location were
approved December 23, 1908.
   Bridge of the Union Pacific Railroad Company over Kansas River
at Kansas City, Kans.-Plans for rebuilding an existing structure at
this place were approved January 7, 1909.
   Bridge of the city of Milwaukee, Wis., over Milwaukee River at Michi-
gan street, that city.-Plans for a bridge to replace an existing structure
at this place were approved January 9, 1909.
    Bridges of the highway commission of the State of Washington over
Deception and Canoe passes connecting Whidbey Pass and Fidalgo
islands.-Plansand maps of location for these bridges were approved
January 9, 1909.
   Bridge of the Seattle Electric Company over Lake Union at Seattle,
  Wash. Plans and map of location of a temporary structure were
approved November 17, 1908. Change of location was approved
January 15, 1909.
                  BRIDGING OF NAVIGABLE WATERS.                    917
   Bridge of the city of New York over Hutchinson River (East Chester
Creek) at Boston Post-Road, borough of the Bronx.-Plans and map of
location for a temporary and a permanent bridge to replace an exist-
ing structure were approved January 15, 1909.
   Bridge of the Mount Desert Transit Company over Mount
Desert Narrows between Trenton and Eden, Me.--Plans and map of
location were approved January 25, 1909.
   Bridge of the city of Sheboygan, Wis., over Sheboygan River in
that city.-Plans and map of location for a bridge to replace an existing
bridge were approved January 26, 1909.
   Bridge of the Cleveland Terminal and Valley Railroad Company over
Cuyahoga River at Cleveland, Ohio.-Plansand map of location were
approved January 28, 1909.
   Bridge of Putnam County, Fla., over St. Johns River at Palatka.-
Plans and map of location were approved February 6, 1909.
   Bridges of H. H. Taylor, trustee, for Bellingham Bay and British
Columbia Railway Company, over Whatcom Creek and Sanalicum
Creek waterways, Bellingham Bay, Washington.-Plans and maps of
location were approved February 6, 1909.
   Bridge of the Illinois Central Railroad Company over Wolf River
near Memphis, Tenn.-Plans and map of location were approved
February 9, 1909.
   Bridge of Whatcom County, Wash., over new mouth of Nooksak River
 (Larrabee Slough) at Marietta.-Plans for reconstructing a bridge at
this place were approved March 11, 1909.
   Bridge of Chicago, Milwaukee and Puget Sound Railway Company
over Puyallup River at Tacoma, Wash.-Plans and map of location
were approved March 15, 1909.
   Bridge of Florida East Coast Railway Company over New River
near Fort Lauderdale, Fla.-Plans for reconstructing an existing
bridge at this place were approved February 8, 1909. Modified
plans were approved March 19, 1909.
   Bridge of King County, Wash., over Squak Slough (Sammamish
River) near Redmond.-Plans for rebuilding an existing structure
at this place were approved March 19, 1909.
   Bridge of Essex County, Mass., over Merrimac River between New-
buryport and Deer Island.-Plans for rebuilding an existing structure
were approved April 8, 1909.
   Bridge of the Manatee Bridge Company over Manatee River at
Manatee, Fla.-Plans and map of location were approved April 12,
1909.
   Bridge of the Pittsburg, Shawmut and Northern Railroad Company
over Allegheny River near Bullis Mills, Pa.-Plansand map of loca-
tion were approved April 13, 1909.
   Bridge of the city of Oswego, N. Y., over Oswego River at that city.-
Plans for reconstructing an existing bridge at this place were approved
April 15, 1909.
   Bridge of the town of Eden, Me., over channel between Bar Harbor
and Bar Island.-Plans and map of location were approved April 21,
1909.
   Bridge of Carteret County, N. C., over North River in that county.-
Plans and map of location were approved April 21, 1909.
918     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, UT. S. AR1VMY.

   Bridge of Illinois Central Railroad Company over Salt River at
West Point, Ky.-Plans for reconstructing an existing bridge at this
place were approved April 27, 1909.
   Bridge of the Peoria and Pekin Union Railway Company over
Illinois River at Peoria, Ill.-Plans and map of location were approved
April 29, 1909.
   Bridge of the Linn Creek Bridge Company over Osage River near
Linn Creek, Mo.-Plans and map of location were approved May 5,
1909.
   Bridge of Margaret A. Hill over Hook Creek between the city of
New York and Hempstead, N. Y.-Plans and map of location were
approved May 6, 1909.
   Bridge of Tillamook County, Oreg., over Tillamook River near
mouth of Trask River.-Plans and map of location were approved
May 14, 1909.
   Bridge of Essex and Hudson counties, N. J., over Passaic River
(Newark Plank Road Bridge).-Plans for reconstructing this bridge
were approved May 18, 1909.
   Bridge of Harry Churchill over Little Red River at Pangburn,Ark.-
Plans and map of location were approved May 22, 1909.
   Bridge of Bergen County, N. J., over Berry Creek at the Paterson
Plank Road.-Plans and map of location were approved May 22,
1909.
   Bridge of Catahoula Parish, La., over Little River at Jonesville.-
Plans for rebuilding an existing structure at this place were approved
May 29, 1909.
   Bridge of the Southern Pacific Company over San Francisco Bay
at Dumbarton Point, Cal.-Plans for this bridge were approved
November 24, 1906. Modified plans were approved June 2, 1909.
   Bridge of the Chicago and Northwestern Railway Company over
Fox River (Little Lake Butte des Norts) at Neenah, Wis.-Plans for
rebuilding this bridge were approved June 16, 1909.
   Bridge of the Chicago and Northwestern Railway Company over
Fox River at Neenah, Wis.-Plans for rebuilding this bridge were
approved June 16, 1909.
   Bridge of the Chicago and Northwestern Railway Company over
Fox River at Menasha, Wis.-Plans for reconstruction of this bridge
were approved June 16, 1909.
   Bridge of Burlington County, N. J., over Rancocas River at Bridge-
boro.-Plans for reconstruction of an existing bridge at this place
were approved June 21, 1909.
   Bridge of the Norfolk and Southern Railway Company over Albe-
marle Sound between Hornblower Point and Mackeys Creek, North
Carolina.-Modified plans for this bridge were approved June 23,
1909.
   Bridge of Galveston County, Tex., over West Galveston Bay at Gal-
veston.-Modified plans for this bridge were approved June 23, 1909.
   Bridge of San Joaquin County, Cal., over Mokelumne River at
Benson Ferry.-Plans and map of location were approved June 23,
1909.
   Bridge of the Louisa Coal Company over Levisa Fork of Big Sandy
River at Torchlight, Ky.-Plans and map of location were approved
June 25, 1909.
                 BRIDGES OBSTRUCTING     NAVIGATION.               919
   Bridge of Millers Creek Railroad Company over Levisa Fork of
Big Sandy River near mouth of Millers Creek, Kentucky.-Plans
and map of location were approved June 25, 1909.
   Bridge of the city of Portland, Oreg., over Willamette River.-Plans
for rebuilding this bridge were approved June 26, 1909.
  Bridge of the village of Park Falls, Wis., over North Fork of Flam-
beau River.-Plans and map of location were approved June 28, 1909.
   Bridge of the Louisville and Nashville Railroad Company over
Salt River at Shepherdsville, Ky.-Plans for reconstructing an exist-
ing bridge at this place were approved June 30, 1909.
   Bridge of the Colorado Southern, New Orleans and Pacific Railroad
Company over Atchafalaya River below Melville, La.-Plans for
altering an existing structure were approved June 30, 1909.

         BRIDGES       OBSTRUCTING          NAVIGATION.

   Under the requirements of section 18 of the river and harbor act
approved March 3, 1899, the Secretary of War notified the persons,
corporations, or associations owning or controlling certain bridges
obstructing navigation, after giving them a reasonable opportunity
to be heard, to so alter said bridges as to render navigation through
or under them reasonably free, easy, and unobstructed, specifying
in the notice the alterations required to be made and prescribing a
reasonable time within which to make them, as follows:
   Bridge of the Gulf, Colorado and Santa Fe Railway Company over
Pine Island Bayou, near Beaumont, Tex.-Notice dated July 7, 1908,
was served on the company July 16, 1908. Specified alterations to
be completed on or before six months from date of service of notice.
   Bridge of the Norfolk and Southern Railway Company over Lynn-
haven Inlet, Virginia.-Notice dated July 8, 1908, was served on the
company July 25, 1908. Specified alterations to be completed on or
before three months from date of service of notice.
   Bridge of Calhoun County, Fla., over Chipola River, near Clarksville,
Fla.-Noticedated October 6, 1908, was served on the board of county
commissioners on November 7, 1908. Specified alterations to be
completed on or before twelve months from date of service of notice.
   Bridge of the CharlestonBridge Company over Ashley River at Charles-
ton, S. C.-Notice dated January 25, 1909, was served on the company
February 5, 1909. Specified alterations to be completed on or before
eight months from date of service of notice.
   Bridge of Iberville Parish, La., over Bayou Plaquemine.-Notice
dated March 5,1909, to remove cofferdam around south pier was served
on the police jury of said parish. Specified removal to be completed
within thirty days from date of service of notice.
   Bridge of Kent County, Del., over Leipsic River at Leipsic, Del.-
Notice dated March 25, 1909, was served on the levy court of said
county April 13, 1909. Specified alterations to be completed on or
before September 1, 1909.
   Bridge of King County, Wash., over Sammamish River (Squak
Slough) below Bothel, Wash.-Notice dated March 25, 1909, was served
on the board of county commissioners April 5, 1909. Specified
alterations to be completed on or before October 1, 1909.
920     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S. ARMY.

   Bridge of the Atlantic Coast Line Railroad Company over Ashley
River at Bees Ferry, S. .- Notice dated March 30, 1909, was served
on the company April 12, 1909. Specified alterations to be completed
on or before six months from date of service of notice.
   Bridge of Galveston and Harris counties, Tex., over Clear Creek, near
League City, Tex.-Notices dated April 1, 1909, served on the commis-
sioners' courts of these counties April 12 and 14, 1909. Specified alter-
ations to be completed on or before June 1, 1909.
   Bridge of Duval County, Fla., over Pablo Creek, in said county.-
Notice dated April 21, 1909, was served on the board of county com-
missioners May 1, 1909. Specified alterations to be completed on or
before four months from date of service of notice.
   Bridge of counties of Charleston and Colleton, S. C., over Rantowles
Creek, South Carolina.-Notices dated May 11, 1909, served on the
county supervisors May 18, 1909. Specified alterations to be com-
pleted within four months from date of service of notices.
   Bridge of Kent County, Del., over Leipsic River (Martins Bridge), in
that county.-Notice dated May 19, 1909, was served on the levy
court of said county June 8, 1909. Specified alterations to be com-
pleted on or before October 1, 1909.
   Bridge of the city of Seattle, Wash., over Duwamish River West Water-
way.-Notice dated May 19, 1909, was served on board of public
works June 2, 1909. Specified alterations to be completed on or
before October 31, 1909.
   Bridge of the Northern Pacific Railway Company over the West
Waterway of Duwamish River at Seattle, Wash.-Notice dated May 19,
1909, was served on the company June 1, 1909. Specified alterations
to be completed on or before October 31, 1909.
   Bridge of the Seattle Electric Company over waterways at entrance of
Duwamish River at Seattle, Wash.-Notice dated May 19, 1909, was
served on the company May 28, 1909. Specified alterations to be
completed on or before October 31, 1909.
   Bridge of the city of Chicago over North Branch of Chicago River at
Indiana street.-Notice dated June 30, 1909, was served on the
mayor July 20, 1909. Specified alterations to be completed on or
before May 30, 1912.
   Bridge of the city of Chicago, Ill., over entrance to South Branch of
Chicago River at Lake street.--Notice dated June 30, 1909, was
served on the mayor of the city July 20, 1909. Specified alterations
to be completed on or before December 31, 1912.

STRUCTURES OTHER THAN BRIDGES IN THE NAVIGABLE WATERS
                 OF THE UNITED STATES.

  Pursuant to the provisions of sections 9 and 10 of the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1899, and of certain special acts of Congress,
numerous applications for permission to build structures of various
kinds other than bridges (such as dams, wharves, dolphins, booms,
weirs, etc.) in the navigable waters of the United States have been
examined with a view to the protection of navigation interests.
  Upon the recommendation of the Chief of Engineers, permits have
been granted by the Secretary of War for the erection of a number
of such structures, but specific reference is not deemed necessary
except in the following cases.
                             BRIDGES AT WASHINGTON,                    D. C.                          921
   Dam of Reuben Bollinger in Clinch River near Agee, Tenn.-Plans
and map of location were approved January 19, 1909.
   Dam of Spencer B. Newberry in Rock River at Grand Detour, Ill.-
Construction of this dam was authorized by act of Congress ap-
proved February 16, 1906. Plans and map of location were approved
February 4, 1909.
   Dam of Twin City Power Company in Savannah River near Prices
Island, South Carolina.-Constructionof this dam was authorized
by act of Congress approved February 28, 1908. Plans and map
of location were approved February 20, 1909.
   Dam of the Bedford Power Company across East Fork of White
River at Williams, Ind.-Plans and map of location were approved
February 27, 1909.
   Dam of, the Choctawhatchee River Light and Power Company in
Choctawhatchee River near Newton, Ala.-Constructionof this dam was
authorized by act of Congress of March 10, 1908. Plans and map
of location were approved March 9, 1909.
   Dam of the Ruth Trust Company across Willamette Slough near
Portland, Oreg.-Plansand map of location for a structure to replace
one built by the United States were approved May 12, 1909.

                                  MISCELLANEOUS.
[Public works not provided for in acts making appropriations for 'the construction, repair, and preservation
                                      of works on rivers and harbors.]

            BRIDGES AT WASHINGTON, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.

   Operations under this head were in the temporary charge of First
Lieut. E. J. Dent, Corps of Engineers, to July 18, 1908, in the charge
of Maj. Spencer Cosby, Corps of Engineers, from July 19, 1908, to
December 22, 1908, and in the charge of Maj. Jay J. Morrow, Corps
of Engineers, from December 23, 1908, to the end of the fiscal year,
with the exception of the highway bridge across Potomac River,
which was transferred to the office of Public Buildings and Grounds
September 12, 1908, under authority of the Secretary of War dated
September 1, 1908.
   1. Repair of the Aqueduct Bridge across Potomac River.-(a) Repair
of piers.-Congress by joint resolution approved July 1, 1902, enacted
as follows:
  That the Secretary of War be, and he is hereby, authorized to spend an amount not
exceeding three thousand dollars from the balance of appropriations made for the
reconstruction of pier number four of the Aqueduct Bridge, District of Columbia,
for the purpose of the examination of and immediate temporary repairs to the remain-
ing piers of said bridge in cases of need arising from flood or ice.
  The act of Congress approved March 2, 1907, making appropriations
for the expenses of the government of the District of Columbia for
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1908, contains the following item:
   And the unexpended balance, amounting to about fourteen thousand dollars, of
the appropriations for the reconstruction of piers numbered four and five of said
bridge is hereby reappropriated and made available for the periodical examination
of the remaining piers of the bridge and making of such repairs as may be found neces-
sary.
  Examinations by diver and such minor repairs as were found
necessary have been made from time to time. These examinations
have shown that there is in process a gradual deterioration of the
922         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                        S. ARMY.

masonry of the piers below the water line. The defects show usually
in the form of cavities caused by the dropping out, during freshets,
of one or more of the stones in or near the face. These cavities
have usually been repaired by filling them with concrete in bags,
deposited by a diver. In some instances the repaired portions have
been protected by placing riprap in front of them. In three of the
piers, Nos. 1, 4, and 5, the defects became so serious that this method
of repair was impracticable and new piers have been built to replace
the old ones.
   A thorough examination of all the old piers was made during
September, 1908. A number of large cavities were found, which
were repaired by filling them with concrete in the usual manner.
During October, 1908, heavy riprap was placed in front of some of
the largest of these patches and the piers were left in as good condition
as practicable.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended......................................                             $14, 956. 01
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year .....................                              1, 276. 08
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended. .......                 ...      ..................               13, 679. 93
  (b) Pier No. 1.-The District of Columbia appropriation act
approved March 2, 1907, contains the following item:
  AQUEDUCT       BRIDGE: For reconstruction of pier numbered one of the Aqueduct
Bridge across the Potomac River at Georgetown, District of Columbia, to be expended
under the direction of the Secretary of War, eighty thousand dollars.
   An examination made in January, 1907, showed this pier to be in
such condition that it was consideredV impracticable to repair it
satisfactorily.
   Plans and specifications for the complete removal of the pier and
the construction of a new and stronger pier in its place were prepared
and a contract for the work was entered into July 24, 1907. Work
under the contract was begun August 15, 1907, when dredging
around the pier was started. From about the first of September the
work was carried on continuously, except for delays due to freshets
and ice in the river during January and February, 1908, and to short-
age of materials at other times. The cofferdam and the false work
to support the superstructure of the bridge were finally completed in
March, 1908, and the removal of the old pier was begun. This work
was completed and the construction of the new pier commenced late
in April. The new pier is founded on the solid rock bottom of the
river and consists of a concrete base extending to about 7 feet below
the water line, and of ashlar masonry with concrete backing above
that elevation.
   The masonry work was completed and the bridge trusses lowered
to a bearing on the new pier in July, 1908. The removal of the cof-
ferdam and puddling material and the final cleaning up were com-
pleted in August, 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................                             $54, 800. 28
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year ....................                              40, 122. 50
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...............................                                   a 14, 677. 78
    (See Appendix C C C 1.)
  a Balance of $14,677.78 deposited in United States Treasury (reverted and dropped).
                                WASHINGTON AQUEDUCT.                                    923
   2. Highway Bridge across Potomac River at Washington, D. C.-
 (a) Construction.-All of the government work in connection with
the construction of the highway bridge and approaches was com-
pleted during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1908. A complete his-
tory of the project will be found in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for that and preceding years.
   On September 12, 1908, the unexpended balance of the appropria-
tion for construction, including the retained percentage on the con-
tract for paving the approaches, which was held under a five-year
guarantee clause, was turned over to the office of Public Buildings
and Grounds, under authority of the Secretary of War, dated Sep-
tember 1, 1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...    ....... ..........................       $4, 832. 24
September 12, 1908, amount expended ..................................               300. 60
September 12, 1908, balance unexpended and turned over to the office of
  Public Buildings and Grounds.......................................   4, 531. 64
   (b) Maintenance and operation.-In addition to the routine work
of operating the draw and policing the bridge and approaches, the
work of repairing and strengthening the timber fenders of the pivot
and rest piers at the draw, commenced during the last fiscal year,
was continued and minor repairs were made to portions of the
machinery.
   The bridge and approaches were transferred on September 12,
1908, to the office of Public Buildings and Grounds, under authority
of the Secretary of War, dated September 1, 1908.
      MAINTENANCE OF HIGHWAY BRIDGE ACROSS POTOMAC RIVER, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, 1908.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.......................................          $2, 052. 67
September 12, 1908, amount expended..................................             2, 032. 44

September 12, 1908, balance unexpended, reverted to Treasury...........                 20. 23
      MAINTENANCE OF HIGHWAY BRIDGE ACROSS POTOMAC RIVER, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, 1909.

Amount appropriated by act of May 26, 1908........................... $16, 000. 00
September 12, 1908, amount expended..--...........................      2, 499.11

September 12, 1908, balance unexpended and turned over to the office of
  Public Buildings and Grounds ...........-.............--...........            13, 500. 89
   (See Appendix C C C 2.)

MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR OF THE WASHINGTON AQUEDUCT, DIS-
TRICT OF COLUMBIA, AND WASHINGTON AQUEDUCT, DISTRICT OF
COLUMBIA, FILTRATION PLANT.

  Operations under this head were in the charge of Capt. E. J. Dent,
Corps of Engineers, to July 18, 1908; Maj. Spencer Cosby, Corps of
Engineers, July 19, 1908, to December 22, 1908, and Maj. Jay J.
Morrow, Corps of Engineers, from December 22, 1908, to the end of
the fiscal year. The last two officers had under their immediate
orders Capt. E. J. Dent, Corps of Engineers, from July 19, 1908, to
December 31, 1908, and Lieut. Warren T. Hannum, Corps of Engi-
neers, from November 17, 1908, to the end of the fiscal year.
  1. Washington Aqueduct, District of Columbia: (A) Maintenance
and operation of the Washington Aqueduct and its accessories.-Ap-
propriations for maintenance and operation of the Washington Aque-
924        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

duct are applied to the improvement, maintenance, and repair of
those parts of the water-supply system which are under the super-
vision of the Chief of Engineers. These are the masonry dam across
the Potomac at Great Falls, the works there for regulating the supply
to the conduit, the Conduit road from Great Falls to Washington, a
distance of about 14 miles, the conduit from Great Falls to the
Georgetown reservoir, a distance of about 12 miles, the three reser-
voirs for supplying the city, the tunnel, about 4 miles long, connecting
the Georgetown and McMillan Park reservoirs, the two bridges for
carrying the mains across Rock Creek, and other auxiliary works. A
description of these works may be found in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers, 1903, pages 2485-2487.
   The original project for construction of the Washington Aqueduct
was dated February 12, 1853, and published as Senate Executive
Document No. 48, Thirty-second Congress, second session. The
project provided for supplying the city of Washington with water
taken from the Potomac River at Great Falls, Maryland, about 14
miles above the city and 161 miles from the present filtration plant,
and with water from Little Falls Branch. Work was begun in 1853,
and in 1859 water from Little Falls Branch was supplied to the city
through the conduit. The first Potomac water was supplied to the
city in December, 1863.
    The water from Little Falls Branch became polluted and works for
excluding it were completed in 1895. The dam at Great Falls was
raised during 1896 and the capacity of the system increased to its
present extreme limit of 90,000,000 gallons per day, or, making
allowances for sudden increases in consumption, to a safe limit of
65,000,000 gallons. For a discussion of the capacity of the system, see
Annual Reports, Chief of Engineers, for 1897, pages 3991-4014, and
for 1906, pages 2093-2095, and Appendix D D D of this report.
   During the year the conduit between Great Falls and Dalecarlia
reservoir has been cleaned twice; the tunnel between Georgetown and
McMillan Park reservoirs were partially drained and repaired; some
repairs were made to the Conduit road; concrete wing walls were
built for strengthening the masonry at the north connection of
Dalecarlia reservoir, and the other structures were maintained in
good condition.
          WASHINGTON     AQUEDUCT, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, 1908-MAINTENANCE.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ...................................            $3, 624.79
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year .......................        3, 581. 59
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........................................        a 43. 20
        WASHINGTON AQUEDUCT,        DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, 1909-MAINTENANCE.

Amount appropriated by act approved May 26, 1908.................... $33, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year...................... 28, 770. 85
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..............................         .....    4,229. 15
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...............................            4, 229.15
  a Balance of $43.20 deposited in Treasury of the United States; reverted and
dropped.
                                     WASHINGTON                AQUEDUCT.                                 925

  (B) Purchase qf dredge for Dalecarlia reservoir.-The dredge was
purchased under contract, and final payment was made in April,
1908.
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                                a $2, 106. 10
   ( C) Increasing the water supply of Washington, D. G.-By act of
Congress approved May 26, 1908, $10,000 was appropriated for pre-
liminary investigations and surveys for increasing the water supply.
   The results of these investigations, with recommendations, were
made the subject of a special report to the Chief of Engineers by the
officer in charge, which report was submitted after the close of the
fiscal year, on July 8, 1909. Summarized, the report finds no present
necessity for construction of a new aqueduct, provided the measures
for prevention of waste are completed as rapidly as can be economic-
ally accomplished. Recommendations are made for the completion
within three years of the installation of meters in private services,
for the metering within one year of all government services, and for
the immediate construction of the coagulating plant, and remodeling
of reservoir for use therewith, as previously recommended.
INCREASING       WATER. SUPPLY           OF WASHINGTON,          D.   C.-PRELIMINARY        INVESTIGATIONS
                                                 AND SURVEYS.

Amount appropriated by act approved May 26, 1908 ...................                              $10, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during, fiscal year......................                            9, 109. 33
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended....................................                                    890.67
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities. ........................... .......                              890. 67
  (D) Dredging Dalecarlia reservoir.-By act of Congress approved
March 2, 1907, an appropriation of $16,000 was made for the removal,
by dredging, of about 134,000 cubic yards of sediment from Dalecarlia
reservoir.
  As all of the dredging necessary could not be accomplished during
the fiscal year 1908, Congress, by act approved May 26, 1908, pro-
vided that any unexpended balance under the appropriation for
dredging should continue to be available for the fiscal year 1909.
  The necessity for this dredging is explained on page 880, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
  Work under this appropriation, amounting to 110,590 cubic yards
of dredging, was completed, 64,210 cubic yards of material having
been dredged during the fiscal year 1909.
WASHINGTON           AQUEDUCT,         DISTRICT     OF COLUMBIA,          1908-DREDGING           DALECARLIA
                                                   RESERVOIR.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. . ....................................                               $642. 83
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year...............                             .......    642. 83
   WASHINGTON         AQUEDUCT,        DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA,           1909.-DREDGING        DALECARLIA
                                               RESERVOIR.
Amount reappropriated by act approved May 26, 1908................... $10, 872. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year ..................... 7, 245. 69
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                           ..      3, 626. 40
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities . ...............................                                 626. 40
July 1, 1909, balance available.............................                    .........          b 3, 000. 00

   a In Treasury United States; reverted and dropped.
   b Balance of $3,000 deposited in Treasury of the Uniited States; reverted and
dropped.
926          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                          S. ARVMY.

   (E) Riprapping sides of Dalecarliareservoir.-By act of Congress
approved March 2, 1907, $18,000 was appropriated for riprapping the
sides of Dalecarlia reservoir for a width of about 20 feet.
   Work was begun in July, 1907. During the present fiscal year
2,234 cubic yards of paving stone were quarried, and 4,230 linear
feet of slope paved for a width of 18 feet. Congress, by act approved
May 26, 1908, provided that any unexpended balance under the
appropriation for riprapping should continue to be available for the
fiscal year 1909. The work under this act was completed in Novem-
ber, 1908.
  WASHINGTON        AQUEDUCT,       DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, 1909.-RIPRAPPING              SIDES     OF
                                      DALECARLIA RESERVOIR.

Amount reappropriated by act approved May 26, 1908...................                        $4, 890. 69
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year---...-..-..............                     4, 890. 69
   (F) The necessity for completing the aqueduct system, including
the filtration plant, by the construction of works for preliminary
treatment of the water was discussed in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1908, pages 2365 to 2372. This necessity still
exists, and an estimate has been submitted for building this work.
   (G) In the spring of 1909 the Metropolitan Southern Railroad began
the construction of a railroad over the right of way through the
grounds of the Dalecarlia reservoir, granted by act of Congress
approved March 3, 1891. The regulations approved by the Secretary
of War in 1893 to govern the construction and maintenance of the
railroad, as published on page 4288, Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1893, were slightly amended in 1909 to meet present
conditions. The construction is being prosecuted in accordance with
these regulations under the supervision of the engineer officer in charge
of the Washington Aqueduct.
   As required by the regulations, the railroad company deposited with
the Treasurer of the United States $1,500, from which the cost of
necessary inspection of the railroad construction is being paid.
                                 .......
Deposited by railroad company-----            .-..--       .        ..--......       .....      $1, 500
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year . ........................                         35

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .....................................                           1,465
   The estimates for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, are as follows:
For operation, including salaries of all necessary employees, maintenance,
  and repair of the Washington Aqueduct and its accessories, including
  Conduit road, the McMillan Park reservoir, and the Washington Aqueduct
  tunnel, and also including the purchase and maintenance of a motor truck,
  horses, vehicles, and harness, and the care and maintenance of the stable.. $33, 000
For remodeling the storehouse and stable at Great Falls....................                    2, 500
For emergency fund, to be used only in case of a serious break requiring im-
  mediate repairs in one of the important aqueduct or filtration-plant struc-
  tures, such as a dam, conduit, tunnel, bridge, building, or important piece
  of machinery, all expenditures from this appropriation to be reported in
  detail to Congress--.....-.......- ........               .....---------.....--........      5, 000
For continuation of parking grounds around McMillan Park reservoir, for-
  merly known as Washington City reservoir. .-.... ....                                    -  10, 000
For remodeling the Georgetown reservoir and constructing works to provide
  for the preliminary treatment of Potomac water by means of a coagulant,
  and for each and every purpose connected therewith, to be available until
  expended.................................................                        .......   130, 000
                                 WASHINGTON AQUEDUCT.                                        927
For the purchase, installation, and maintenance of water meters to be placed
  on all services to United States buildings, reservations, or grounds, said
  meters to be purchased, installed, maintained, and remain under the
  observation of the officer in charge of the Washington Aqueduct ..........              $50, 000
   (See Appendix D D D 1.)
  2. Washington Aqueduct, District of Columbia, FiltrationPlant: (A)
Construction.-By act of Congress approved June 6, 1900, the sum of
$2,000,000 was appropriated-
   For establishing those portions of a filtration plant which are essential to the opera-
tion of either system of filtration adopted * * *
  By act of Congress approved March 1, 1901, the sum of $500,000
was appropriated-
  Toward establishing a slow filtration plant          *   *    *
  By these and subsequent acts of Congress there has been appropri-
ated for this work a total sum of $3,468,405.
  A description of the Washington Filtration Plant is given on pages
2101 to 2103, Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, U. S. Army,
1906.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year the work had been practically
completed. An experimental filtration plant, for studying the effi-
ciency of slow-sand filters when operated at various rates, was in-
stalled during the year.
   Final payment was made August 13, 1908, to Henry R. Worthing-
ton for the main pumping engines upon final test and acceptance,
thus completing the contract.
   No contract is now in force and the balance of the appropriation
stated below has been covered into the Treasury by the sundry civil
act approved March 4, 1909.
WASHINGTON AQUEDUCT, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA,                     FILTRATION PLANT-CONSTRUCTION.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended-..    ............. .................                 $53, 990. 73
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year ....................                  12, 891. 94
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ...................................                   41, 098. 79
July 1, 1909, balance available . . .....            ..... ...........     ..... ...   41, 098. 79
    Washington Aqueduct, District of Columbia, Filtration Plant: (B)
Maintenance and operation.-By act of Congress approved May 26,
1908, the sum of $82,000 was appropriated for maintenance and
operation of the Washington Aqueduct, District of Columbia, Fil-
tration Plant for the fiscal year 1909.
   The Washington Filtration Plant consists of a pumping station for
raising the water from the McMillan Park reservoir to the filters; of
29 filter beds of the slow-sand type, having an effective filter area of
1 acre each; of a filtered-water reservoir, having a capacity of about
15,000,000 gallons; of the necessary piping and valves for carrying
the water, controlling the rates of filtration, etc., of a sand-washing
and storage system, and of a laboratory for testing the water. The
filtration plant has been in continuous operation throughout the year
and the entire water supply of the city has been filtered. The bac-
teria have been reduced from an average of 389 per cubic centimeter
in the McMillan Park reservoir to an average of 21 in the filtered-
water reservoir. The average turbidity has been similarly reduced
928          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                        S. ARMY.

from 22 to 1 part per million. The actual number of bacteria in the
city water varied from 160 to 2 per cubic centimeter, while the num-
ber in the river water ran from 90,000 to 38. The actual average
reduction by months varied between 99.7 and 97 per cent.
   The work during the year consisted in cleaning and operating the
filters; in analyzing samples of water from the several reservoirs,
from each filter, and from taps in various parts of the city; in oper-
ating and keeping in repair the pumping station; in doing the
necessary clerical work connected with the office; and in conducting
experiments with a view to determining the results of different rates
of filtration. All work was done by day labor.
   The total quantity of water pumped to the filters during the year
was 22,435.16 million gallons, or an average of 61.47 million gallons
per day. During the year 24,683 cubic yards of sand were washed
and 23,487 cubic yards were replaced in the filters. While the quality
of the city filtered water was excellent for the greater part of the
year, there were several periods when the number of bacteria exceeded
what is considered by experts to be the proper standard for a filtered
water supply. The filtered water was unsatisfactory with respect to
turbidity for a considerable percentage of the time. This confirms
the experience of the three previous fiscal years and also the judgment
of the three experts as expressed in their report, dated February
18, 19.01, to the chairman of the Senate Committee on the District of
Columbia.
   The cost per million gallons filtered was $3.66.
   A more complete description of the Washington Filtration Plant
may be seen in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906,
pages 2101 and 2102.
   Attention is invited to that portion of the report of the officer in
charge for the fiscal year 1908 appearing on pages 2365-2372, Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908, which deals with the sub-
ject of preliminary treatment of Potomac water.
   In order that the city of Washington may at all times be supplied
with a water that is unexceptional both in quality and appearance,
it is recommended that works for preliminary coagulation be con-
structed, and estimates for this improvement are submitted.
   The following'estimate for the maintenance and operation of the
Washington Aqueduct, District of Columbia, Filtration Plant for the
year ending June 30, 1911, is submitted:
For care, including salaries of all necessary employees, maintenance, and
  operation of the Washington Aqueduct, District of Columbia, Filtration
  Plant, and for each and every purpose connected therewith ............    $86, 000
For the purchase of coagulant, estimated one year's supply ................   9, 000

       Total .....................................................                                       95, 000

MAINTENANCE,          WASHINGTON AQUEDUCT,                           DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA,   FILTRATION PLANT,
                                                                1908.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................                                  a $11, 369. 34
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year....................                                  9, 476. 73

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..............................................                       b 1, 892. 61

  a Six thousand dollars of the available balance under this head July 1, 1908, carried
to maintenance, Washington Aqueduct, District of Columbia, Filtration Plant, 1909.-
Parking grounds, Washington City reservoir.
  b Balance of $1,892.61 deposited in United States Treasury; reverted and dropped.
    PUBLIC BUILDINGS AND GROUNDS, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.                                          929
MAINTENANCE,        WASHINGTON        AQUEDUCT, DISTRICT          OF COLUMBIA,   FILTRATION    PLANT,
                                            1909.-GENERAL.

Amount appropriated by act approved May 26, 1908.................... $82, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year ...................... 71, 998. 56
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ......................................                     10, 001. 44
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................................                      10, 001.44
   (C) Parking grounds, Washington City reservoir.-By act of Con-
gress approved May 26, 1908, the sum of $6,000 was reappropriated
from the amount appropriated for the maintenance and operation
of the Washington Aqueduct, District of Columbia, Filtration Plant
for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1908.
   During the fiscal year 1909 the slope on the west side of First
street NW., between Bryant and Douglas streets, was graded and
sodded, and the work of grading the rough areas south of the dam
and on the west side of the reservoir was nearly completed. The
ground has no covering of soil and will not support a growth of either
grass or shrubs. It will, therefore, be unsightly in appearance until
it is covered with soil and the work of parking has been completed,
as described in the report of the officer in charge.
   It is recommended that an appropriation be made for continuing
this work, for which is submitted estimate under the general heading
of the Washington Aqueduct.
WASHINGTON        AQUEDUCT,       DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, 1908.-PARKING             GROUNDS,      WASH-
                                     INGTON CITY RESERVOIR.

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ......................................    . $273.79
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year.........................    273. 79
WASHINGTON        AQUEDUCT,      DISTRICT    OF COLUMBIA,       FILTRATION PLANT,   1909.-PARKING
                            GROUNDS,      WASHINGTON        CITY RESERVOIR.

Amount reappropriated by act approved May 26, 1908 ...................                      $6, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year...................                 ....     5, 527. 92
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended......................................                         472. 08
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities .......................................                  472.08
    (See Appendix D D D 2).
IMPROVEMENT AND CARE OF PUBLIC BUILDINGS AND GROUNDS, AND
  CARE AND MAINTENANCE OF THE WASHINGTON MONUMENT AND OF
  THE HIGHWAY BRIDGE ACROSS THE POTOMAC RIVER, WASHING-
  TON, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.

  Officers in charge: Col. Chas. S. Bromwell, U. S. Army, major,
Corps of Engineers, to March 16, 1909. Since that date Col. Spencer
Cosby, U. S. Army.
  Miscellaneous repairs were made in and about the Executive
Mansion, including considerable painting in the interior. The fur-
niture was regularly cared for. Repairs were also made to the
Executive Office building, to the President's stable, and to the green-
house structures and their heating apparatus.
  The care required to maintain them in good condition was extended
to the improved parks and small reservations. Three additional
park spaces were transferred to the Chief of Engineers by the Com-
missioners of the District of Columbia, and one reservation was trans-
ferred to the commissioners for street purposes. Two unimproved
         9001--ENG 1909--59
930     REPORT OF THE CHIEF      OF ENGINEERS,    U. S. ARMY.

reservations were improved. A macadam driveway was constructed
along north B street on the northern boundary of Potomac Park
between Virginia avenue and Twenty-first street, west, and land in
squares 63 and 89 was acquired by condemnation for continuing the
driveway through these squares. The river drive between the inlet
and Twenty-sixth street was completed by constructing the portion
from Easbys Point to Twenty-sixth street. Three thousand two
hundred and twenty-six feet of cement coping were constructed
around six reservations, and 2,664 square yards of asphalt footwalk
and 130 square yards of asphalt roadway were resurfaced. Some
of the macadam roadways in Potomac Park were treated with oil.
Work was commenced for lowering to street grade the main carriage
road formerly carried from Henry Park to Seaton Park over the
bridge across the railroad tracks on Sixth street. The temporary
use of the north half of reservation 113 by the Commissioners of the
District of Columbia for railroad purposes was relinquished and the
ground reimproved.
    At the Washington Monument a new cable was placed on the ele-
vator car, the wooden sheathing on the walls of the motor room was
replaced with glazed tile, and the engine in the power house was over-
hauled and repaired.
    At the propagating gardens the various greenhouse structures
were repaired as far as funds would admit. Nearly 690,000 plants
were propagated, of which about 649,000 were planted in the parks
and reservations.
    Two hundred and twenty-eight park settees were repaired and
1,110 painted; 1,048 cubic yards of stable manure were used upon
lawns and for mulching shrubbery and young trees. Iron post and
chain fences were erected around six reservations, and those around
two others were replaced by cement coping; 4,637 feet of water pipe
and 2,523 feet of drain pipe were laid.
    Inspections were made each month of the buildings occupied as
offices by the War Department, except State, War, and Navy Depart-
ment building, so far as their preservation, care, and safety were
concerned.
    The old station building of the Pennsylvania Railroad Company
at Sixth a.nd B streets NW., which was transferred to the War
Department by that company, was torn down and the material
removed.
    A portion of the old overhead wires of the departmental telegraph
line were replaced by underground cable.
    Repairs were made to the fender system of the highway bridge
across the Potomac River, District of Columbia, and portions of the
ironwork above the deck of the bridge were painted.
    The statues of Gen. Philip H. Sheridan, Henry Wadsworth Long-
fellow, and John Witherspoon, and the Stephenson Grand Army
memorial were erected and completed, and all but the latter unveiled.
The architectural portion and some of the bronze sculpture of the
Grant memorial were finished. A site was selected for the statue
of Commodore John Barry, and models were submitted in a compe-
tition for that statue; a new site was selected and contract entered
into for the statue of John Paul Jones; and progress was made on
the models for the Pulaski and the Von Steuben statues.
                            NORTHERN                  AND NORTHWESTERN       LAKES.                    931

  Attention is invited to the detailed report of the officer in charge
and to his estimates and recommendations for the fiscal year ending
June 30, 1910.
  The estimates are as follows:
For the improvement and care of public buildings and grounds in charge
  of the Chief of Engineers ....................................         ..... $398, 870
For compensations of persons employed by office of Public Buildings and
  Grounds ..............................................................         88, 150
Telegraph lines connecting Capitol with Departments; care and repair of
  existing lines ...............................................                         ...           1, 000
For contingent and incidental expenses of public buildings and grounds...                              1, 100
For care of Washington Monument and maintenance of elevator:
    Salaries of employees.............. .........................      , 820
    Fuel, lights, contingencies, etc ................................ 3, 000
                                                                                                     11, 820
For completing work for the erection of the memorial to Gen. Ulysses S.
  Grant...............................................                          ......... . ... ..   83, 000
For maintenance of highway bridge across Potomac River, District of
  Columbia...............................              ...........................                   16,000
For monument and wharf at Wakefield, Va., the birthplace of Washington:
  Repairs to wharf and cleaning up grounds, etc..........................                              7, 100
         Total ...........................................................                           607, 040
    (See Appendix EE E.)

NORTHERN AND NORTHWESTERN LAKES-CORRECTING AND ISSU-
ING CHARTS-SURVEYS-WATER LEVELS-PRESERVATION OF NIAG-
ARA FALLS.

   As early as 1816 local surveys of the Great Lakes for special pur-
poses were made by engineer officers, but the "Lake Survey" as a
systematic work was commenced in 1841. It was diligently prose-
cuted thereafter until 1882, when for a time extended field operations
were suspended. The correction, printing, sale and issue of charts
continued without cessation, however, the additions and corrections
being largely based upon local surveys and reports by engineer officers
in charge of the river and harbor improvements on the lakes.
   Systematic fieldwork was resumed in 1889, and has since been
prosecuted with increased vigor. In 1898 operations were extended
to include cognate work of observing and investigating the levels of
the Great Lakes and their connecting waters, with a view to their
regulation in the interest of commerce. The survey proper has from
the beginning been carried on under the War Department, being at
first conducted by the Chief of Topographical Engineers, and by the
Chief of Engineers after the consolidation of the Topographical
Engineers with the Corps of Engineers.
   The first regular appropriation for the Lake Survey was made in
1841, and annual appropriations followed with the single exception
of 1847. The appropriations to date for all purposes of the Survey
during the sixty-eight years of its existence aggregate $4,311,879, of
which $2,411.81 has reverted to the Treasury.
   A full account of the operations of the Lake Survey from May,
1841, to July 1, 1881, is contained in Professional Papers, Corps of
Engineers, U. S. Army, No. 24, which describes in detail the methods
of primary triangulation employed. The condition of lake naviga-
tion in 1841 is shown by the following extract:
   The Lake Survey was begun in 1841 under an appropriation of $15,000 made in May
of that year. At this time the country bordering on the lower lakes was already pretty
932        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                    U. S. ARMY.

well settled, and works for the improvement or formation of harbors had been com-
menced at most of the important points on Lakes Erie and Ontario. The upper lake
region was but thinly settled, and there were no good harbors on Lake Huron and but
one (the harbor of Chicago) on Lake Michigan. Settlers were, however, pouring in
rapidly, and there was even then a large and constantly increasing commerce between
the lake ports, especially from Buffalo to Detroit and Chicago. Communication with
Lake Superior could only be had by portage around the Sault Ste. Marie, but the great
mineral wealth of the country was attracting attention, and a survey for a ship canal
had been made in 1840 by officers of the Topographical Engineers. The lake com-
merce was carried on under many difficulties, which caused much loss of life and
property each year.
   There were no charts of the lakes except the Admiralty charts, compiled from the
surveys of Capt. H. W. Bayfield, of the royal navy (English), and these were not in
general use by the masters of American vessels. These charts were the results of rapid
reconnaissances, and although they showed the coast lines with an accuracy which is
remarkable considering the rough methods of surveying employed, they were of little
value as hydrographical charts of the American coast, because they showed the depths
of water in comparatively few places and but a small number of the many reefs and
shoals which are found along the lake shores.
   There were few light-houses and beacons to indicate the positions of dangers to navi-
gation, and, in the absence of charts, pilots were obliged to rely upon their own knowl-
edge, which was frequently only acquired by the vessels grounding on a shoal or
striking a hidden rock.
   The navigation of the lakes is attended with peculiar dangers, because, while violent
gales are frequent and the storms rival those of the ocean itself, a vessel is never more
than a few hours' run from the shore, and can not, as is generally the case at sea, drift
before the wind until the storm is over, but in a long-continued gale must be thrown
upon the shore, unless a port or harbor of refuge can be entered. In 1841 a vessel leav-
ing Chicago found no harboi or shelter in storms until the Manitou or Beaver islands
were reached, and after passing the Straits of Mackinac it was again exposed without
refuge on Lake Huron, except in the vicinity of Presque Isle, until the head of St.
Clair River was reached. In sailing from Chicago to Buffalo the greatest difficulties
were encountered in the vicinity of the Straits of Mackinac and in the west end of Lake
Erie on account of the many islands, shoals, and reefs found in those localities, and at
the mouth of the St. Clair River, at which no improvements had been made in 1841,
and where the channels were not only circuitous and narrow, but so shoal that vessels
in low-water seasons frequently were compelled to have their cargoes taken over the
bars in lighters.
    It was therefore with the double object of furnishing reliable charts to lake vessels
and of determining from the surveys the works of improvement which were necessary
to the prosperity of the lake commerce that Congress in 1841 directed a survey of the
lakes, and that annual appropiriations, with the single exception of the year 1847, have
since been made for carrying on the survey.
    During the first ten years of the Survey, while a general geodetic survey of the entire
chain of lakes was contemplated for the future, the actual operations were mainly con-
fined to surveys of special localities where improvements were called for or where the
navigation was difficult; and where the surveys were more extended they were little
more than reconnaissances. This course was masde necessary because the appropria-
tions were inadequate to the purchase of the finer instruments and the support of the
larger force necessary for more extensive and more exact surveys, and also because of
the pressing need of improvements at particular localities, for which preliminary
surveys were essential.
Originally the Lake Survey seems to have operated under projects
which implied the survey of the Great Lakes and their connecting
waters to the extent necessary for the preparation  charts needed    of
by a navigation whose greatest draft             was
                                          12 feet. With the increase
in vessel dimensions has naturally followed the creation of.channels
and harbors with progressively greater depths, and the Lake Survey,
under projects providing for the expenditure of annual appropria-
tions, has kept pace with the improvements in navigation and in
navigational facilities by a corresponding extension of the scope of
its operations.
   It is difficult to indicate the exact moment of transition from the
original projects which, as stated, provided for surveys and their
resulting charts adapted to a 12-foot navigation, to the recent proj-
               NORTIHERN    AND NORTHWESTERN         LAKES.             933
ects which correspond to present-day drafts of 18 to 20 feet; but, in
a general way, it may be said that the limitations imposed upon navi-
gation by the conditions at the falls of the St. Marys River have
seemed to fix the scope of the operations of the Lake Survey in the
open lakes and in the connecting rivers, while local projects for im-
provement have prescribed the limits of the survey work in lake har-
bors. The work of the Lake Survey has been continuous, and while
a general project for the future work has now been authorized, all
expenditures upon work done before the adoption of this project may
justly be regarded as contributing to its fulfillment. In other words,
none of the work of the past has been rendered futile by the changed
conditions of the present. On the contrary, the methods of the old
Lake Survey, and the high standards of accuracy and excellence
which then prevailed, have continued to characterize its present pol-
icy and operations; and the work of to-day extends the former work
to limits which were not anticipated by the most sanguine spirits of
former days.
   The present general project of the Lake Survey is stated in much
detail in the Annual Report for 1907, pages 844 to 850. This de-
scribes the work regarded as necessary in order to render the surveys
and the charts of the Lake Survey adequate to respond to all possible
future demands. This general project proposes the ascertainment
and charting of lake depths in all significant regions of the Great
Lakes to a plane 30 feet below the adopted low-water datum of the
open lakes and 25 feet below the corresponding datum in the chan-
nels of the connecting rivers, together with the completion of the
related operations of triangulation and precise leveling still needed to
control properly the areas under survey. In addition, this general proj-
ect provides for the extension of river-discharge measurements, for in-
vestigations of lake levels, and for magnetic surveys in and near main
vessel courses, while prompt examination of areas where obstructions
to navigation have been reported will be continued as heretofore.
   Assuming that adequate appropriations will be provided, it is esti-
mated that the completion of the above general project will, includ-
ing the work of 1909, require ten seasons' work; but, even after the
completion of this work, the maintenance of a reduced plant and
organization will be required for such small surveys as may be needed
to observe and verify natural changes and to investigate wrecks and
other artificial obstructions, while the revision and issue of charts is
a work absolutely without definite conclusion.
   The amount expended on all surveys made since its inception by
the Lake Survey may with propriety be regarded as the expenditure
under the present project. This amount is $4,172,661.77.*
   Assuming that the field work of the Lake Survey includes opera-
tions of triangulation, precise leveling, ordinary sounding, deep-sea
sounding, sweeping, hydraulic measurement, and magnetic observa-
tions, whose extent may with some certainty be fixed, on June 30,
1909, the state of the work was as follows: Triangulation was 76 per
cent completed; precise leveling, 64 per cent completed; ordinary
sounding, 51 per cent; deep-sea sounding, 15 per cent; sweeping, 15
per cent; hydraulic measurement, 83 per cent; and magnetic obser-
vations, 90 per cent completed on land and 2 per cent on water.
 * Amount stated in last paragraph on page 889, Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers, 1908, is in error.
934      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

   While these figures may be definitely given, the remaining and
most highly important function of the Lake Survey, namely, the
issue of charts, as previously stated, is continuing. In fact, each
year, with its increasing commerce, will increase the demand for and
the importance of these charts.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year three parties were in the field as
follows: The first party was engaged in sounding and sweeping at the
south end of Lake Michigan, the area which it was intended to cover
being that south of the parallel of latitude through Gross Point, Ill.
This important area, known in a general way to contain uncharted
shoals, has recently become of increasing consequence because of the
great development of the steel industry, not only at South Chicago,
but also at Indiana Harbor and at the newly built harbor of Gary.
The work of the party was successful in the highest degree. Between
July 1 and October 30, 1908, an area of 1522 square miles was covered,
of which 134 square miles was swept. Seventeen uncharted shoals
having depths at standard low water datum of less than 18 feet were
found, many of them directly in or very close to the vessel courses
to Indiana and Gary harbors. These shoals were found to extend 5
miles northeast from Indiana Harbor. These discoveries, being of a
capital character, were at once made the subject-matter of a special
press notice and of an inset chart in Supplement No. 3 to Bulletin
No. 18. In addition, two wrecks-those of the schooner David Dows
and of the Car-ferry Barge No.   2-were    later discovered in the same
area. Each had a draft of 181 feet at standard low water over it,
and both were therefore regarded as menacing to navigation and were
subsequently removed by the United States Engineer Office at Chi-
cago. Despite a season rendered peculiarly unfavorable by the
smoke of forest fires, which were at their worst during September and
October, this party covered a large area with great thoroughness. It
is especially notable that a single day's work with the wire sweep
covered 5.3 square miles, and that after July 1 a total of 134 square
miles was swept to a depth of 30 feet where not limited by bottom.
All obstructions found were charted so that this most important area
is now known with certainty.
   The second party was at the beginning of the year engaged in
sounding and sweeping in the Manitou Passage, the shoal which was
the special object of investigation being that upon which the steamer
Gary was damaged during the summer of 1907. Early in July this
shoal was found and was discovered to be a bowlder ridge immediately
in the vessel track, with a least depth of 17.3 feet at standard low
water. No other discoveries of importance resulted from the work
in the Manitou Passage, which was concluded on July 24, a total area
of 11.28 square miles having been sounded and swept after July 1.
At the conclusion of this work the party resumed the resurvey in the
Straits of Mackinac, which during the previous year had been ex-
tended from Manitou Paymen shoal through the South channel well
to the eastward of Cheboygan. This party was greatly hindered by
forest fires, which made it difficult to see the signals established for
the control of the hydrographic work. Up to November 8, 1908,
when operations were closed, the sounding and sweeping were com-
pleted practically to Nine Mile Point, the area sounded embracing
81.61 square miles, of which 40.86 square miles were also swept.
              NORTHERN AND N~ORTHWESTERN LAKES.                    935
   On July 16, 1908, a party took the field for the purpose of extend-
ing the primary triangulation of the Lake Survey from the south
side of Saginaw Bay to the southward with the incidental secondary
and tertiary triangulation needed to establish upon the shore of
Lake Huron the control needed for its resurvey. Up to December
23, 1908, when operations were discontinued, nine primary stations
had been occupied and the angles fully read. The subordinate work
had been extended to the neighborhood of Sherman, just south of
Harbor Beach, Mich., and everything was in condition for the rapid
extension of the work to the southward.
   On August 28, 1908, a party which had been engaged upon hydraulic
work on the Niagara River under an allotment from the act of June 29,
1906, left Buffalo for the St. Lawrence River, where, in view of the
unusually high stage of Lake Ontario, an opportunity not hitherto
available existed for extending the range of the observations of 1900
and 1901. Between September 21 and October 2, 26 separate dis-
charge measurements were made at stages which for the highest are
about one foot above the previous observations. In all the Lake Sur-
vey has now made 122 separate discharge measurements covering
stages on the Oswego gauge between 243.7 and 247.3.
   Upon the completion of this work the party returned to Buffalo,
and after completing certain unfinished work in connection with the
Niagara River observations, proceeded to Detroit, where it arrived
on October 28. From October 29 to December 20 the party was
employed in hydraulic work on the St. Clair River, at and near Port
Huron, whose object was, primarily, an inquiry into the permanence
of certain cross sections of the river which had been measured and
monumented in 1898 and 1899. In addition, discharge measurements
were made at the cross section (dry dock) used in the previous
hydraulic work upon this river, and also at a new cross section (gorge)
selected by this party with a view of comparing the results with those
at section dry dock. T he observations disclosed no measurable
change in the critical reach at the head of the river, and 22 measured
discharges in the new section gave results within from 1 to 2 per cent
of those derived from the equations deduced from the former hydraulic
work at section dry dock. In all 37 discharges were measured, and,
within its limits, the work of this party serves to prove that the river
is stable and the law of its flow well determined.
   During the present field season, five parties have taken the field
one of which has, at Niagara Falls, engaged in work described in a
subsequent part of this report.
   The first party has resumed the resurvey of the south end of Lake
Michigan. It is now engaged in sweeping in a difficult region close
to the Chicago breakwaters. Progress has therefore been somewhat
retarded. Up to June 30, 1909, in about one month of field work, 161
square miles were swept. A number of uncharted obstructions off
the harbor were discovered, and, as soon as their locations had been
definitely reported, their detailed description was published in press
notices and in a special bulletin.
   The second party has continued the resurvey of the Straits of
Mackinac and has in addition made an investigation of an obstruc-
tion reported to have been struck by the steamers Chicago and
Ogdensburg, in the Grays Reef Passage near Middle shoal. No
936      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U. S. ARMY.

obstruction was found at the reported locality and the chart is
believed to be entirely accurate. Up to June 30, 1909, this party
has occupied three stations of the system of water triangulation,
taken topography over 5 -miles of shore line, and sounded 29.2 square
miles, of which 7.8 square miles were also swept. Work is now in
progress east of Nine Mile Point.
   On June 10, 1909, a third party took the field for the purpose of
extending southward, between the Bass and Sister islands, the
resurvey of the west end of Lake Erie, which had been temporarily
suspended in 1907. Up to June 30, 1909, this party had swept 26.5
square miles immediately adjoining the work of 1907, to a depth of
28.5 feet.
   The fourth party has since April 12, 1909, been engaged in extend-
ing to the south the primary triangulation which had been discon-
tinued late in December, 1908. Up to the close of the fiscal year the
angles at three stations had been fully read, four new primary stations
erected on the American side, three on the Canadian side, three pri-
mary stations dismantled, and ten secondary stations erected. The
work is well under way and should be completed in September.
   The execution of the survey which terminated in 1882 involved a
great quantity of astronomic, topographic, and hydrographic work,
all of which was performed with a high degree of accuracy and skill.
The result was the preparation of a series of reliable charts for lake
vessels and the furnishing of a basis for works of channel improve-
ment upon the lakes themselves, and their connecting waters. 'This
original series consisted of 76 charts, all of which were printed in
black from copperplates.
   The extensive revision of the charts nowounder way has for its
object to show to date the changes, due to natural and artificial
agencies, which have taken place in the formerly existing conditions
as charted, and to furnish the additional information concerning the
greater depth which the present requirements of commerce demand.
   As a result of revisions, cancellations, and additions to the original
series, based on the later surveys, there are now in force 123 Lake
Survey charts, of which one is in black from old copperplate, 73
are lithographs in colors from copperplate transfers, 47 are litho-
graphs in colors from stone engravings, and 2 are photolithographs
in colors.
   The charts issued in colors have all depths of 18 or 21 feet and less
in blue, showing at a glance where vessels may proceed with safety,
and are considered by vessel men much preferable to the old style
printed in plain black and white. This new series of colored charts
is believed to constitute a distinct advance in chart construction and
printing, and meets with high favor from navigators and others.
   During the year the Detroit office has revised, transferred to stone,
and printed editions in colors from 14 copperplates, revised and
printed second editions in colors from 6 engravings on stone, and
engraved on stone and issued in colors 10 entirely new charts of the
regular series. For free supplemental issue 6 insets were prepared
by correction of and transfer from existing engravings. For other
government offices 23 maps and drawings were reproduced by
photolithography, new engravings, or transfers from engravings
furnished. In addition to the above, revisions of 7 copperplate
              NORTHERN AND      NORTHWESTERN LAKES.                937
charts and engravings on stone of 5 new charts of the regular series are
almost completed.
   Of the entire series of charts there had been issued in colors, 5 on
July 1, 1900; 12 on July 1, 1901; 30 on July 1,1902; 49 on July 1,
1903; 59 on July 1, 1904; 73 on July 1, 1905; 97 on July 1,1906;
110 on July 1, 1907; 117 on July 1, 1908; and 122 on July 1, 1909.
   Upon April 17, 1909, a project was approved covering definitely
the future chart work of the Lake Survey. In addition to providing
for the preparation of 26 new charts, this project covers the revision
of 39 old ones, so that thereafter all charts will be projected upon
the geodetic datum adopted in 1901, with soundings referred to the
planes of standard low water approved on March 16, 1909. The proj-
ect also provides for the discontinuance of 21 charts, regarded as
obsolete, and for publishing 31 of the less important harbor charts
as insets to the appropriate coast charts. With the termination of
this project, which is expected to require about six years, except for
necessary revisions and new editions, the publication of the series of
Lake Survey charts will have been completed, and, due to changes
and omissions already described, will then include 104 separate charts.
   Up to February 20, 1890, one full set of charts was issued free to
each United States registered vessel. Any additional charts fur-
nished such vessels and all furnished for other unofficial use were sold
at the uniform price of 30 cents each. On the date above mentioned
the free issue, except for official purposes of the Government, was
discontinued pursuant to law, and since then the charts have been
sold for all private and unofficial use at prices ranging from 5 cents
to 30 cents each, the price being intended in each instance to cover
only the cost of paper and printing.
   Charts may be purchased at the main office at Detroit, at the canal
office at Sault Ste. Marie, Mich., and at the United States engineer
office in Buffalo. Complete sample sets may be seen at the United
States engineer offices at Duluth, Milwaukee, Chicago, Grand Rapids,
Cleveland, and Oswego, enabling purchasers to select exactly the
charts they wish to order.
   From 1882 to June 30, 1909, a total sum of $35,003.11 was derived
from the sale of charts at offices where they were sold and deposited
in the United States Treasury.
   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, the number of charts
sold by the Detroit office was 14,048, and by the Buffalo office 3,128,
the aggregate sales being 17,176. The proceeds of the sales, amount-
ing to $2,686.05, were deposited to the credit of the Treasurer of
the United States. The Detroit office issued 3,229 charts for official
use and the Buffalo office 95, a total of 3,324. To date about 382,500
of these charts have been sold and issued for actual service.
   In addition to the field work above mentioned and to that upon
the charts, operations were continued under the present general
project for the exhaustive investigation of lake levels, this being in
continuation and extension of the project described in the Annual
Report for 1898, pages 3774-3776. The principal field work of the
year comprised lake-temperature observations and the maintenance
of 12 self-registering water gauges to supply an accurate, continuous
record of all changes in elevation of the water surface. Appendix
F F F 1 of this report gives a table of discharges of all the Great
938          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                       S. ARMY.

Lakes at the mean stage of each for the past forty-nine years, as
determined from the monthly means shown on the plate in the same
appendix. This work is now fully organized, methods of making
measurements and observations to the best advantage have become,
fixed and settled, and the results are of increasing importance, bear-
ing as they do on questions affecting international relations and
obligations, and on the propriety and advisability of the numerous
diversions under consideration.
   The preparation and issue of the series of bulletins, supplementary
to the charts, relating to the river and harbor improvements and
navigation of the Great Lakes was begun by this office in 1889, and
was transferred to the office of the Lake Survey, at Detroit, in 1902.
Of Bulletin No. 18, issued in April, 1908, and remaining current for
1909, about 2,700 copies (from an edition of 3,000) have been dis-
tributed to the marine interests, and requests for it are constantly
being received. These bulletins are revised biennially, with monthly
supplements during each season of navigation, and give the latest
and fullest descriptions of progress in river and harbor improvements
on the Great Lakes and their connecting waters, as well as significant
results of surveys in those waters made under the direction of district
engineer officers and of the Lake Survey. If deemed helpful, small
maps showing location of new shoals, changes in important channels,
localities hitherto uncharted, etc., are inserted in both bulletins and
supplements.
   The commerce affected by the operations of the Lake Survey and
depending upon the publication and constant revision of charts and
bulletins is practically the entire commerce of the Great Lakes. To
continue field and office operations at a rate commensurate with the
importance of the interests involved requires that appropriations
shall be of such amount as to permit the use of the entire plant to its
maximum capacity during the relatively short seasons available for
profitable work. It is therefore recommended that an appropriation
of $125,000 be made for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, and
that it be formulated as follows:
                 ESTIMATE FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1911.

  For survey of northern and northwestern lakes, including all necessary expenses for
preparing, correcting, extending, printing, and issuing charts and bulletins, and of
investigating lake levels with a view to their regulation, to be immediately available
and to remain available until expended, one hundred and twenty-five thousand
dollars.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .....................................             $129, 953.79
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act of March 4, 1909............                125, 000. 00
Collections credited to account:
     Work for account of preservation of Niagara Falls......           2, 008. 73
     Damage to gauge .................................                    . 15.00
     Refundment, account of overpayments............... ..                  13. 34
     Work done for other engineer districts.................           2, 613. 23
                                                                                      4, 650. 30
                                                                                    259, 604. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year:
    At United States Lake Survey office, Detroit.......... 122, 761. 82
    At Office of the Chief of Engineers ......................   36. 85
                                                                                    122, 798. 67

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ................................                   136, 805. 42
                  PRESERVATION OF NIAGARA      FALLS.              939

  A table showing the monthly water levels from July 1, 1907, to
June 30, 1909, at Marquette, Mich., on Lake Superior; Milwaukee,
Wis., on Lake Michigan; Harbor Beach, Mich., on Lake Huron; Cleve-
land, Ohio, on Lake Erie; and Oswego, N. Y., on Lake Ontario, will
be found in Appendix F F F 1.
   (See Appendix F F F 1.)

THE   CONTROL AND REGULATION OF THE WATERS OF NIAGARA
       RIVER AND THE PRESERVATION OF NIAGARA FALLS.

   The approved projects of operations under the various allotments
from the appropriation made by the act of Congress of June 29, 1906,
had for their purpose the determination of the effects of the diversions
authorized by that act, amounting to 15,600 cubic feet per second
on the American side, and on the Canadian side of water sufficient
for the development and importation into the United States of
160,000 horsepower, upon the navigable capacity of the Niagara
River, on its integrity and proper volume as a boundary stream, on
the level of Lake Erie, and on the scenic grandeur of Niagara Falls.
    The determination of these questions, so far as physically possi-
ble, involves surveys and measurements, of levels, of volumes of
discharges, of current velocities and directions, and of depths over
the crest of the falls. As these are operations of a character similar
to those ordinarily performed by the Lake Survey, upon the rec-
ommendation of the Chief of Engineers, the Secretary of War author-
ized the performance of the work involved therein by the Lake
Survey, and for this purpose successive allotments have been made,
of which two-one of $5,000 and another of $3,000-pertained to
the fiscal years 1907 and 1908. At the beginning of the present fiscal
year operations were in progress upon the work covered by the proj-
ect for the second allotment (that of $3,000 above referred to).
These operations had for their purpose the making of such additional
discharge measurements in the Niagara River as seemed necessary
in order to confirm or else to disprove the conclusion, derived from
the observations of 1907, that the increased diversions since 1898
had produced no measurable effect upon the level of Lake Erie.
This conclusion appeared so anomalous as to require confirmation or
explanation. From July 1 to August 7, 1908, sixty-eight discharge
measurements were made and the customary accessory gauge and
rating observations made. In addition, the erosible portion of the
discharge cross section, at the International Bridge, Buffalo, was
sounded, and it was found that spans 1, 3, and 4 had not changed
since originally measured in 1899, but that in span 2 there had been
an increase in mean depth of over 2 feet. This span, however, car-
ries only 2 2 per cent of the flow and the change is therefore of minor
consequence.
    A shut down of the plant of the Niagara Falls Power Company,
covering a large part of the period from 1.30 a. m., July 19, to 7.20
p. m. on August 2, 1908, afforded an unusual opportunity for testing
previous deductions concerning, and for ascertaining directly, the
effects produced by changes in the quantity of water diverted in the
Grass Island-Chippawa pool, and through the courtesy of the com-
pany full advantage was taken of this opportunity.
940      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

   Briefly summarized, the results of the operations of 1908 serve to
prove that while the increase in diversion since 1898 in the Chippawa-
Grass Island pool, amounting roughly to 7,000 cubic feet per second,
has produced no apparent effect upon the level of Lake Erie, this is
probably due to the fact that the lowering has been compensated
by the construction during the same period of the diversion works
of the Ontario Power Company below Chippawa. In the absence of
such compensation, the lowering due to the increased diversion
would have amounted to less than half an inch. This conclusion
is based upon the discovered relation between the volume of the
diversion in Chippawa-Grass Island pool at the falls and the dis-
charge of Lake Erie, which, as derived from study of gauge relations
and of the measurements during the shut down, shows that any
change in the volume of this diversion is accompanied by a change of
about one-tenth the amount in the flow at the International Bridge.
   In addition, the observations prove that the effect of increased diver-
sion in the above-named pool near the falls, by the American power
companies, is to reduce the height of the crest of the American Falls
by 0.02 foot for each 10,000 cubic feet so diverted, and that the diver-
sion of the full authorized amount-15,100 cubic feet per second-
will lower this crest 0.03 foot, or about three-eighths of an inch. Based
as it is upon the extensive observations subsequent to July 1, 1908,
this determination serves to modify very materially the result stated
in the annual report for 1908, on page 894, the latter being derived
from a shut down of a few hours only, during which the change at the
crest of the American Falls due to the shut down was coincident
with a rise in Lake Erie due to a southwesterly storm.
    While the lowering, due to the diversions of the American power
companies, may not in itself be noticeable, it is increased to 0.053
foot = 0.64 inch by the present diversion of the Ontario Power
Company. The combined lowering tends to uncover shallow portions
of the crest line of the American Falls. It is further accompanied
by greater, and consequently more harmful, effects both in the Ameri-
can rapids and at the easterly or Terrapin Point end of the Horseshoe
Fall. Terrapin Point is on the New York side of the boundary and,
as depths there are naturally slight, the loss of 2.5 inches in depth,
which is the total due to all existing diversions, is a matter of moment
in its relation to continuity of crest line. But it is on the Canadian
side of the boundary that the impairment of the falls is most serious.
At the Canadian end of the Horseshoe Falls, which is known to be
deficient in depth, the diversion of 15,100 cubic feet per second pro-
duces a lowering of about 4.8 inches, which is increased to 8.44 inches
by the present diversions of the Ontario Power Company, the Elec-
trical Development Company, the Canadian Niagara, Power Com-
pany, and the International Railway Company, whose total diversion
is now estimated at 10,950 cubic feet per second. The losses at Ter-
rapin Point and at the west end of the Horseshoe are relatively great
and, as a whole, the falls have unquestionably been seriously injured
by the diversions already made. Additional diversions, now under
way, will add to the damage.
    A full report upon the work under these allotments was submitted
upon November 30, 1908, and reference is invited to this for detailed
statements of ascertained gauge relations and of the effects of diversion
upon the rapids, upon the Horseshoe Falls, and upon the Niagara
River.
                          PRESERVATION             OF NIAGARA        FALLS.        941
   As a result of the discharge measurements made in the intake canal
of the Niagara Falls Power Company in 1907 the officer then in charge
of the supervision of the operations of the various power and trans-
mission companies, under their permits issued by the Secretary of
XWXar, imposed upon this company a limitation to such diversion as
might be necessary to generate not to exceed 65,000 electrical horse-
power, this limitation being derived from a consideration of the
power-house load curves covering the time of the discharge measure-
ments. Comparison served to show that this company generated
an electrical horsepower for each 0.123 cubic foot of water diverted,
and as the International Paper Company diverted directly from the
canal of the power company 700 cubic feet per second there remained
for the latter 7,900 cubic feet, corresponding roundly to 65,000 elec-
trical horsepower. The validity of the conversion coefficient for
forming switchboard readings into volume of water diverted, so far
as it applies to conditions actually existing at the time of the dis-
charge measurements, can not fairly be questioned, but as the two
power houses belonging to this company differ in the details of their
construction, with claimed higher mechanical efficiency in the newer
house, the officials of the company have asserted that under certain
entirely practicable conditions of operation the value of the conver-
sion coefficient will be found to be lower than the figures given.
    As any unduly high value of this coefficient serves as an unwar-
ranted restriction upon the output of the company and causes a con-
sequent financial loss, upon April 3, 1909, a project was presented
contemplating an exhaustive series of tests with discharge measure-
ments under all reasonable probable conditions of operation. Based
upon this project an allotment of $5,000 was made upon April 15, 1909,
and field operations were begun upon May 4, 1909. To June 30, 198
discharge measurements were made, covering 29 different distribu-
tions of the load. Final results are not yet at hand, but it is certain
that by restricting the number of generators in operation to 16,
with 6 or less in power house No. 1, the Niagara Falls Power Company
can generate 75,000 electrical horsepower and at the same time not
exceed a maximum diversion of 8,600 cubic feet per second.
    The permits now in force for the diversion of water from the
Niagara River and for the transmission of electrical energy into the
United States from Canada are summarized on page 895 of the Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
    To August 14, 1908, the supervision of operations under these
permits was performed by Maj. C. W. Kutz, Corps of Engineers.
Since that date the work of supervision has been performed by the
Lake Survey office. In discharging this duty occasional inspections
have been made at irregular intervals, and the detailed results of such
inspections have been duly reported to the Chief of Engineers. All
the companies concerned have, as disclosed by the inspections,
loyally observed the limitations of their corresponding permits.
Amount appropriated by act of June 29, 1906........................           50, 000. 00

July 1, 1908, balance unexpended....................................          40, 069.40
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year ...................          6, 592. 34

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..................................            33, 477.06
    (See Appendix F F F 2.)
942      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S.   ARMY.

IMPROVEMENT OF THE YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK, INCLUD-
  ING THE CONSTRUCTION, REPAIR, AND MAINTENANCE OF ROADS
  AND BRIDGES.

   Officers in charge, Capt. E. D. Peek, Corps of Engineers, July 1,
1908, to October 31, 1908; First Lieut. Arthur Williams, Corps of
Engineers, November 1, 1908, to March 3, 1909, and First Lieut.
Wildurr Willing, Corps of Engineers, March 4, 1909, to June 30, 1909.
   The Yellowstone National Park was set apart from the public do-
main and placed under the control of the Secretary of the Interior by
act of Congress of March 1, 1872. The sundry civil act of March 3,
1883, directed the construction and improvement of suitable roads
and bridges under the supervision of an engineer officer to be detailed
by the Secretary of War, and in July, 1883, an engineer officer was
designated accordingly. This was the beginning of systematic road
construction in the park. The previous work consisted of the opening
of such rough trails as the limited means permitted, but they were
temporary in character and of little or no value in the permanent plan.
Subsequent to the sundry civil act of August 4, 1886, the expenditure
for the improvement was transferred to the War Department, and it
has been in the charge of the Engineer Department, with the excep-
tion of the period from August, 1894, to March, 1899.
   At the outset the officer of the Corps of Engineers in charge adopted
a project (described in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1887, p. 3134) for a comprehensive system of substantial roads, which,
with the change of the act of Congress of March 3, 1891, is the basis of
the present system. The sundry civil act of June 6, 1900, directed
that the road extensions and improvements should thereafter be made
in harmony with a general plan to be approved by the Chief of Engi-
neers. Such plan was approved August 27, 1900, modified by author-
ity of the Secretary of War, dated July 22, 1901, and further modified
by approval of the Chief of Engineers, dated July 2, 1902. The sundry
civil act of June 28, 1902, recognized this project and provided for its
completion, and it was practically finished during the fiscal year end-
ing June 30, 1906. It comprises a belt line or main circuit which
reaches all of the important centers of interest, with side roads, bridle
trails, and four approaches leading from the park boundary to differ-
ent points on the belt line-in all, about 350 miles of road and about
125 bridges. The sum expended to June 30, 1909, including main-
tenance and repairs, is $1,850,426.45. It is estimated that not less
than $200,000 of this amount was expended in early work which has
since been replaced and does not form a part of the completed system.
Maintenance and repairs have cost about $572,757.28, leaving about
$1,077,669.17 for the cost of the permanent work. In addition, there
has been expended on work done for other departments the sum of
$850.95, for which the park appropriation has been reimbursed.
   The sundry civil acts of May 27, 1908, and March 4, 1909, provided
funds for the maintenance and repair of improvements, and projects
for the expenditure were approved July 1, 1908, and May 3, 1909.
The work of the past fiscal year under these projects included: General
repair and maintenance of the entire system, including the Cooke City,
East, West, and South roads; repairs to bridges; laying of tile and iron
culverts; the clearing of dead and fallen timber from the roadside 85
                              YELLOWSTONE               NATIONAL PARK.                        943

miles of road sprinkled; a number of pumping stations converted into
gravity tanks, and hydraulic rams installed; repairs to sprinkling
wagons, road graders, carts, and other vehicles; maintenance of trees,
shrubs, vines, and lawns. There was expended during the fiscal year
1909, for maintenance and repairs, $80,672.91, and on the East and
South roads of the forest reserve, $263.21.
   It is proposed to apply the $150,000 estimated as a profitable ex-
penditure during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, to work of main-
tenance and repair, together with the replacing of certain wooden
bridges with steel, and commencing the work of resurfacing the sys-
tem, including the purchase of the plant necessary therefor. The
work is necessary to keep the improvement available for use. As
stated in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, page
827, the park is now provided with a comparatively good single-track
road system, but the traffic has increased far. beyond expectation and
much additional work is required to insure comfort and safety. The
appropriations of the past five years have proven inadequate for main-
tenance, and if steps are not taken to solve the road problem men-
tioned in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1905, page
2814, the road bed will soon be in a poor and worn-out condition.
Rock-crushing machinery should be purchased, and there is urgent
necessity also of replacing certain worn-out wooden bridges with
steel, and of substituting walls of concrete or laid in mortar, for dry
retaining walls which have become dangerous. On account of the
more urgent necessity of this work, and because the clearing of a nar-
row road through the snow creates a natural channel, through which
the melting snow runs down the road, and causes serious erosion, it is
considered inadvisable to expend any part of the appropriation for
sprinkling, or for clearing the roads in the spring, until the roads,
bridges, and trails are put in good condition.
   More extended information relating to previous operations is pub-
lished in the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers as follows:
  1887,   page 3133. A r6sum6 of operations from 1883 to 1887.
  1900,   page 5420. A general resum6 covering the period 1872-1900.
  1900,   page 5441. The general plan approved August 27, 1900.
  1901,   page 3797. Modification of 1901 in the general plan of August 27, 1900.
  1903,   page 2444. General description and technical details of work.
  1905,   following page 2822. Map of tourist routes.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended..............................   ....... $63, 474. 68
Amount received from sales .....................................               51. 15
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909....... 65, 000. 00

                                                                                        131, 525.83
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year..........                ..........    80, 936. 12
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .................................                      50, 589. 71
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................                12, 036. 88
July 1, 1909, balance available ....................................                     38, 552. 83
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, for maintenance and repairs, in addition to the balance unex-
pended July 1, 1909 ...........................................      150, 000.00
    (See Appendix G G G.)
944           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                U.   S. ARMY.

                     ROAD TO MOUNT RAINIER NATIONAL PARK.

   Officers in charge, Lieut. Col. H. M. Chittenden, Corps of Engineers,
until September 5, 1908, and Maj. C. W. Kutz, Corps of Engineers,
since that date.
   Prior to the commencement of operations an inferior road led
into the park from the western boundary of the forest reserve to
Longmire Springs, a distance of about 10 miles, and rough trails
extended thence to the Camp of the Clouds.
  The sundry civil act of March 3, 1903, appropriated $10,000 for
a survey of the most practicable route for a wagon road into the
park and for commencing construction. An estimate of cost,
amounting to $183,000.50, was submitted to Congress March 22,
1904, and printed in House Document No. 631, Fifty-eighth Congress,
second session, and an appropriation for continuing construction
was made in the sundry civil act of April 28, 1904. The project
thus authorized by Congress and the one under which work is being
carried on contemplates the construction of a wagon road from the
western boundary of the forest reserve to the Camp of the Clouds,
a distance, of about 25 miles.
   The total amount appropriated to date is $215,000, of which
$17,216.23 were expended on surveys. The amount expended on
the work of the existing project up to the close of the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909, was $193,905.11.
   The work accomplished under the various appropriations to the
close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, is as follows:
Number of miles of road constructed and in use ...............................                 17. 7
Number of miles of road partially completed ................................                    4. 1
       Total................................................................                   21.8
   The report of the field work of the original survey made in 1903
is printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers, 1904,
page 4207. The general location of the proposed route is shown on
the map of the survey made in 1904 for a proposed additional road
into the park from the east, printed in House Document No. 283,
Fifty-eighth Congress, third session.
   To complete the road will require an additional appropriation of
$25,000, and that sum is included in the estimate submitted.
   The cost of road construction in Mount Rainier National Park is
dependent largely on the price of labor. The original estimate
was based upon the wages that were current in 1903. During the
period of construction wages increased from 20 to 331 per cent, on
account of which the latter portions of the road constructed were
necessarily of less width and consequently less safe than the portion
first constructed.
   With the funds requested it is proposed to widen the road built
in the season of 1909, and to provide guard walls at dangerous places.
This work is necessary to make the road safe and suitable for the
traffic that will probably use it.
       BUILDINGS, ARMY WAR COLLEGE AND ENGINEER                     SCHOOL.         945
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended ..................................... $52, 829. 57
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4,1909....... 25, 000. 00

                                                                              77, 829. 57
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ........................................                               56, 734. 68

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .........   :..........................      21, 094. 89
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities.... .......................              2, 333. 16

July 1,1909, balance available ..................................             18, 761.73
Amount (estimated) required for completion of existing project..........      25, 000. 00

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
July 1,1909................      ........   .........................        25,000.00
   (See Appendix 1H H H.)

                                  MAPS, WAR DEPARTMENT.

   With the $5,000 appropriated for this purpose for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909, a number of maps of maneuver grounds were
printed after surveys by engineer troops. A portion of the appro-
priation has also been applied to the equipment of the office of the
chief engineer officer, Philippines Division, with much needed
apparatus for the publication of maps in that division.
   These funds are also utilized in the publication of accurate maps
of our fortified harbors, which, under existing regulations, are required
for the use of the coast artillery.
   An estimate of $5,000 for this purpose has been submitted for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1911.

BUILDINGS, ARMY WAR COLLEGE, WASHINGTON, DISTRICT OF
COLUMBIA, AND ENGINEER SCHOOL, WASHINGTON, ])ISTRICT OF
COLUMBIA.

   Officer incharge, Lieut. Col. W. C. Langfitt, Corps of Engineers.
   The creation of the engineer post and school at Washington Bar-
racks was authorized by an act of Congress approved June 30, 1902,
based on an estimate prepared without funds available for the
preparation of detailed plans or for the making of borings, etc.
This estimate contemplated the utilization of a number of existing
buildings, and provided for construction of new buildings inclosing
approximately 4,000,000 cubic feet. A unit price of about 16 cents
a cubic foot of cubic space inclosed in buildings, all contingencies
included, was practically the basis of this original estimate. Further
development of plans for the engineer post, and for the War College
building authorized in the same act, led to the approval by the
Secretary of War of a transposition of the locations of the two, so
that the latter building now occupies the site originally planned for
the engineer post. This change led eventually to the abandon-
ment of the effort to utilize old post buildings, which, upon detailed
examination, proved also to be in such bad condition as to make
repairs expensive and not economical. These facts were reported
in general terms in the Annual Report for 1904, page 741, as well
        9001--ENG 1909----60
946       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                  U. S. ARMY.

as the fact that the subsistence department had utilized the post
for a distributing depot, which was not anticipated in the original
estimates. The army appropriation act approved June 12, 1906,
provided a chaplain for the Corps of Engineers, who has been assigned
to station at this post, and a commissary officer has been assigned
to permanent station here, both calling for additional quarters.
   In view of these and other similar minor changes, the cubic con-
tents of the buildings actually provided were increased by increasing
the number of buildings as far as funds would permit, actual con-
struction having been almost exactly the cost per cubic foot of
inclosed space as was estimated.
   The condition of the work at the close of the fiscal year was as
follows:
                      BUILDINGS, ARMY WAR COLLEGE.

  This work is entirely finished and the accounts all settled up.
For detailed history of this work, reference is made to the Annual
Reports of the Chief of Engineers for the years 1902, 1903, 1904,
1905, and 1906.

          BUILDINGS, ENGINEER          POST AND ENGINEER           SCHOOL.

  All appropriations made for this object up to and including the
act of March 2, 1907, have been expended and the accounts for
those appropriations have been finally settled up. For detailed
history of this project reference is made to the Annual Reports of
the Chief of Engineers for the years 1902, 1903, 1904, 1905, and 1906.
  The completion of stable at $1,700 as estimated for in last annual
report was provided for in act of March 3, 1909. The work will
be taken up immediately, and the funds provided will be sufficient
for the purpose.
   On December 22, 1904, the Secretary of War approved a general
lay out which, it is thought, completely meets the present needs of
the post and school; a drawing of this proposed post accompanied
the report of Captain Sewell published in the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1906. Additional buildings are shown on this
sheet; arranged in order of their immediate importance, and with
the estimated cost of each stated, they are as follows:
                                                                               Estimated
                                                                                  cost,
1. Engineer school and administration building, power house, and enlisted
     men's trade-school building........       ............................... $429, 000
      The school building to furnish accommodations for the following:
        Office of commandant of post and of engineer school.
        Office of secretary of school.
        Office of adjutant of the post.
        Office of sergeant-major with clerks.
        Office of clerks, with storage for records of post, and school.
        Office of engineer depot.
        Room for records and small supplies (stationery, etc.) for post, de-
          pot, and school.
        Office for orderlies and messengers.
        Office for telephone exchange.
        Printing office, for preparation of orders, blanks forms, lectures,
          pamphlets, etc.
         BUILDINGS,            ARMY WAR COLLEGE AND ENGINEER SCHOOL.                                                      947
                                                                                                                         Estimated
                                                                                                                            cost.
           Offices of instructors, department of civil                                    engineering.
           Offices of instructors, department                              of  military         engineering.
           Offices of instructors, department of electrical and mechanical en-
               gineering.
           Office for stenographers and clerks.
           Two class rooms for use of student officers.
           Lecture room.
           Library room for library.
           Model room for models of engineering structures and appliances.
           Photographic laboratory.
           Photo-lithographic laboratory.
           In basement-
                   Cement-testing laboratory.
                   Electrical laboratory.
                   Chemical and physical laboratory.
           Drafting rooms.
         Power house and enlisted men's trade-school building to contain:
           Heating and power plant.
           Electrical generators and other large apparatus.
           Machine shop.
           Carpenter shop.
           Blacksmith shop.
           Plumber shop.
           Masonry laboratory.
           Modeling room (molding sand).
2.   Completion of west barracks ......................................                                                   $40, 000
3.   Bachelor officers' quarters......................................................                                     70, 000
4.   Store sheds for lumber, coal, ponton material, wagons, etc..............                                              25, 000
5.   Observatory...                  .................................................                                       3,000
6.   Roads, walks, sidewalks, sewers, water supply, gas, electric distribu-
       tion ........................                           ..............................                          .. 25,000
7.   Six sets noncommissioned officers' quarters .......................                                                   66, 000
8.   One new stable ..............                              ..................................                         20, 000
9.   Chaplain's quarters ...............................                                           ...................     20, 000

         Total amount required .......................................                                                 698, 000
   An estimate of this amount is submitted. This estimate differs
from that submitted last year in the omission of item for completion
of stable, provided for as above indicated, and in omission of items
for hospital and hospital steward's quarters, it being understood
that existing regulations require these to be obtained through the
Medical Department-, which has the matter in hand.
   Fuller details of these new buildings and their objects are given
in the report of Captain Sewell, published as Appendix H H H of
the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906.
   It is recommended that Congress provide for these items at the
coming session, with a view to the early completion of the post and
school.
Amount appropriatedby act of-
  June 30, 1902...................................................                                                   $500,   000
  March 2, 1903.....................................................                                                  360,   000
  M arch 2, 1905.....................................................                                                 150,   000
  March 2, 1907............... .....................................                                                   32,   500
                                                                                                                   1, 042, 501
June 30, 1909, amount expended to date............................                                                 1, 042, 500
948               REPORT OF THE CHIEF                            OF ENGINEERS,   U.   S. ARMY.

CONSTRUCTION OF BRIDGE ACROSS MISSISSIPPI RIVER BETWEEN
   FORT SNELLING RESERVATION AND ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA.

   This work was in the charge of Maj. Francis R. Shunk, Corps of
Engineers.
   The act of Congress approved March 17, 1906, provided for con-
struction of a bridge over the Mississippi River connecting Fort
Snelling Reservation and St. Paul. The cost was not to exceed
$250,000, of which at least $100,000 was to be contributed by the
city of St. Paul, at least $25,000 by any electric railway company
receiving right of transit across the bridge, and such sum as the
Secretary of War might determine by any steam railway company
which might use the bridge.
   The sum of $100,000 was paid to the United States by the city of
St. Paul and the sum of $25,000 by the Twin City Rapid Transit
Company.
   The site of the new bridge is about 300 feet below the old Fort
Snelling bridge.
   The bridge was built under contract and was completed April 24,
1909. It was tested June 19, 1909, and formally accepted.
   The act of Congress approved March 4, 1909, appropriated $20,000
for the construction of approaches to the bridge. At the close of the
year the approaches were about 20 per cent completed.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, was $245,209.67.
   An estimate of $1,200 is submitted for the fiscal year ending June
30, 1911, as the amount required for maintenance and care of the
bridge, as follows: Services of a watchman, $600; painting, annual
repairs, renewal of wooden surfaces of roadway and foot-path, etc.,
$600.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended.................................... $220, 905. 09
Amount appropriated by sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909......   20, 000. 00
                                                                         240, 905. 09
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year, for works of improve-
  ment ............................... ........................ 216, 114.76

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..................................                              24, 790. 33
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ................................                            2, 399. 47

July 1, 1909, balance available ....................................                             22, 390.86

"Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1,
    1909......................................................                          . ....    1,200. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
   4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
    (See Appendix I I I.)

  RECONSTRUCTION                                 OF UNITED STATES         BRIDGE AT NIOBRARA,
                                                       NEBRASKA.

  This work was in the charge of Maj. Edward H. Schulz, Corps of
Engineers.
  Funds for this work were appropriated by act of Congress approved
April 30, 1908 (Public No. 104), Indian appropriation act, as follows:
  For the purpose of rewooding and repiling the present old bridge across Niobrara
River between the Santee and Ponca Reservations, Nebraska, supplying the same
                       MONUMENT AT CHALMETTE, LA.                             949
with new ice breaks, but using the iron work of the old combination bridge, the sum
of twelve thousand dollars, or so much thereof as may be necessary, the work to be
done under the direction and supervision of the War Department.
  In accordance with approval of the Secretary of War July 6, 1908,
the work was assigned to this office. Bids were invited and opened
September 21, 1908, and contract awarded to the Western Bridge
and Construction Company, of Omaha, Nebr.
  This work was commenced January 11, 1909, and finished and
accepted April 28, 1909.
Amount appropriated by act of Congress approved April 30, 1908, Indian
  appropriation act .................................................. $12,000.00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year ....................  11, 943. 11

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended .. ...........   ...................         56. 89
   (See Appendix J J J.)

ERECTION OF MONUMENT TO THE MEMORY OF THE AMERICAN
SOLDIERS WHO FELL IN THE BATTLE OF NEW ORLEANS IN THE
WAR OF 1812.

   This work was in the charge of First Lieut. Wildurr Willing, Corps
of Engineers, to August 22, 1908, and Lieut. Col. Lansing H. Beach,
Corps of Engineers, since that date.
   By act ofCongress approved March 4, 1907, Congress appro-
priated $25,000 for the completion of a monument to the memory of
the American soldiers who fell in the battle of New Orleans in the
war of 1812. The design of the monument was approved by the
Secretary of War May 17, 1907, and the work of construction and
disbursement of funds assigned to the Engineer Department. The
site of the monument is at Chalmette, La.
   The Chalmette monument was originally designed by Newton
Richards, whose plans were accepted by the Jackson Monument
Association in May, 1855. This design consisted of a plain shaft 142
feet high, resting on five steps, each 2 feet high and starting about 2
feet 6 inches above the natural surface of the ground; the shaft to be
16 feet 8 inches square at the base and 12 feet 6 inches at the top; the
base of the shaft to have on the four faces corniced projections sur-
mounted with sculptured emblems, one of these to serve as an en-
trance to a spiral stairway leading to a chamber at the top; the stair
to be lighted by small openings at regular intervals; both shaft and
base to be faced with marble.
   A contract for the erection of the monument was awarded in June,
1855, but the work was not completed.
   At the time Congress made the above appropriation no work had
1been done for over fifty years, it is said. The shaft was 56 feet 10
inches high, measuring from the top of the mound of earth about 12
feet 6 inches above the natural surface and about 185 feet in diameter
which had been placed around the monument to pfrotect the brick
foundation. The base was 16 feet 8 inches square outside and 10
feet 8 inches diameter inside; the top was 14 feet 11 inches square
outside and 9 feet 11 inches diameter inside.
   Under project approved July 6, 1907, it was proposed to remove
the mound of earth covering the base of the existing monument, to
extend the shaft on the original lines 24 feet 2- inches and to place
950       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                    S. ARMY.

thereon a pyramid 9 feet high, making the top of the monument
when completed approximately 100 feet above the natural level of
the ground. The entire shaft and base are to be covered with
marble. A spiral stairway, with iron steps supported by a central
brick pier and the brick lining of shaft, leads to an observation
chamber 9 feet 6 inches square in top of monument. There is to be
a bronze door at the entrance to the monument, bronze hand rails
on both sides of stairway, bronze grilles in the windows of observa-
tion chamber, and a bronze historical tablet on the wall of observa-
tion chamber.
   A contract for the construction of the monument was made with
M. P. Doullut, of New Orleans, on December 7, 1907, and the work
was commenced January 16, 1908.
   The monument was completed by the contractor in December, 1908,
and in March, 1909, transferred to the custody of the United [States]
Daughters of 1776 and 1812, as required by the act of March 4, 1907,
under authority of a letter from the Secretary of War dated March
5, 1909.
   The amount expended to June 30, 1909, is $25,000.75, of which
$750 was paid for preparation of plans, $23,383.32 to the contractor,
and $867.43 for miscellaneous expenses, inspection, etc.; $0.75 was
derived from sale of blueprints.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. .............       .....................   $12, 131. 19
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year ...................          12, 131. 19
   (See Appendix K K K.)

MONUMENT TO COMMEMORATE THE BATTLE OF KINGS MOUNTAIN,
                   SOUTH CAROLINA.

  This work was in the charge of Capt. Earl I. Brown, Corps of
Engineers.
  By act of Congress approved June 16, 1906, there was appropriated
$30,000 for the construction of a monument to commemorate the
victory of the American forces at Kings Mountain, South Carolina,
October 7, 1780. Plans for the monument had been approved by the
Secretary of War, and contract made for the construction of a monu-
ment 115 feet 3 inches high for the sum of $25,000, and work of exca-
vation for the foundation had been begun. During the year in the
continuation of this excavation it was necessary, on account of the
character of the material of this excavation, to go to a much greater
depth than originally estimated, thus increasing the cost of the con-
crete foundation, and it became evident that the monument origi-
nally contemplated could not be constructed with the funds available.
Supplemental contract was, therefore, made for the construction of
a monument 83 feet 6 inches high, with lightning conductor installed,
for the sum of $21,000. Under this contract work was then carried
on, and at the close of the year the shaft was completed to its full
height, lightning conductor installed, monument washed down, and
joints pointed, and the sculptured portion of the monument about 60
per cent completed.
                       MONUMENT AT MONTEREY,                            CALIFORNIA.             951
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended .................................         829, 310. 38
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year................. . . . . 20, 136. 34

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended ..........................                           ...   9, 174. 04
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ...............................                          177. 86
July 1, 1909, balance available................................                             8, 996. 18
July 1, 1909, covered by uncompleted contracts ........................                     7, 428. 70
    (See Appendix L L L.)

ERECTION OF MONUMENT AT MONTEREY, CALIFORNIA, TO COMMEM-
ORATE THE TAKING POSSESSION OF THE PACIFIC COAST BY THE
LATE COMMODORE JOHIN D. SLOAT, UNITED STATES NAVY.

   This work was in the charge of Lieut. Col. John Biddle, Corps of
Engineers.
   During the war with Mexico, on July 7, 1846, Commodore Sloat,
in accordance with instructions from our Government, landed a force
of sailors and marines at Monterey and took possession of California
in the name of the United States. In 1886 an organization composed
of Mexican war veterans, California pioneers, army and navy officers,
and others prominent in the affairs of the State, was formed for the
purpose of erecting a monument to Commodore Sloat, the organiza-
tion being known as the Sloat Monument Association.
   A site was procured on the military reservation of the Presidio of
Monterey, on the slope of a hill overlooking the Bay of Monterey.
Upon this site, which is unobstructed by trees or adjacent buildings,
a suitable foundation was laid and a base, or platform, for the pro-
posed monument was constructed, faced with stones which were con-
tributed by various counties of the State, military and civic organ-
izations. The base is 24 feet square and 6 feet high.
   The Congress of the United States, act of March 4, 1907, has appro-
priated $10,000 for the erection of a monument to Commodore John
Drake Sloat, U. S. Navy, at Monterey, Cal. A portion of this sum,
not to exceed $1,000, is to be devoted to procuring a suitable design
and other preliminary expenses, leaving about $9,000 for the actual
work, act of March 28, 1908.
   The amount expended on this base is unknown in this office.
   On May 19, 1908, the Chief of Engineers, U. S. Army, assigned to
Lieutenant-Colonel Biddle the duty of obtaining a suitable design
and erecting the monument. With the aid of the San Francisco Art
Institute and the Sloat Monument Association, a design was accord-
ingly made and has been submitted to the War Department, and was
approved by the Secretary of War on June 29, 1909.
   The total amount expended on the project to June 30, 1909, is
$333.45. Nothing has been derived from any miscellaneous sources.
   The work accomplished during the year consists of obtaining a suit-
able design and perfecting it and having it approved. Competitive
designs were obtained by offering three prizes of $250, $150, and $100,
respectively. The work of erecting the monument will be awarded the
winner of the first prize, and the work will be done under contract.
   The proportion of the project completed up to June 30, 1909, can
not be readily ascertained, but it consists of obtaining a suitable
952           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                   U.      S.       ARMY.

design, and the work left to be done is to erect the monument in
accordance with the design.
  No former reports have been made on the project.
July 1, 1908, balance unexpended. ....................      ...............                                $9, 998. 92
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year......................                                        332. 37
July 1, 1909, balance unexpended.....................                                  .........       .     9, 666. 55
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ..................................                                        250. 00
July 1, 1909, balance available.........................................                                     9,416.55
    (See Appendix M M M.)
MONUMENT TO COMMEMORATE THE BATTLE OF THE REVOLUTION
        FOUGHT AT POINT PLEASANT, WEST VIRGINIA.

  This work was in the charge of Capt. F. W. Altstaetter, Corps of
Engineers.
  The public building act approved May 30, 1908, appropriates the
sum of $10,000 to aid in the erection and completion of a memorial
structure at Point Pleasant, W. Va., to commemorate a battle of tihe
Revolution fought at that point.
   A contract was entered into February 5, 1909, for the construction
of the monument, the base for which was built. Some work was
also done on the six courses above the base, twQ courses being
completed.
Amount appropriated by public building act approved May 30, 1908......                                     $10, 000. 00
June 30, 1909, amount expended during fiscal year............. ...........                                   1, 000. 25

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..................                         ..............                    8, 999. 75

July 1, 1909, amount covered by uncompleted contract ..................                                      8, 500. 00
    (See Appendix N N N.)
                         OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS.

   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, the following-named
officers were on duty in this office as assistants: Col. Smith S.
Leach; Col. Frederic V. Abbot; Maj. James B. Cavanaugh; Maj.
William B. Ladue from January 21, 1909; Maj. William J. Barden;
Capt. Edward N. Johnston from September 1, 1908; First Lieut.
Richard C. Moore from November 19, 1908.
   I desire to express my appreciation of the very able and loyal
assistance I have received from the civilian employees of this office.
They are intelligent, conscientious, and efficient in the discharge of
their duties, and many of them have given to the Government the
best years of their lives; in some cases the entire wage-earning period
has been spent in the government service.
   Excepting in very rare instances the compensation received by this
worthy class of public servants has been entirely too small to permit
any provision being made by them for support in old age, and it would
be gratifying to see some action by Congress looking to the relief of
these employees as they become superannuated in the public service.
            Very respectfully,
                                                                           W. L. MARSHALL,
                                                             Chief of' Engitneers, U. S. Army.
    The SECRETARYI of WAn.
         APPENDIXES
               TO THE




REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                      IMY.
      TJNITED STATES AR



                              953
                       APPENDIXES
                               TO THE



   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,
                       UNITED STATES ARMY.



        THE BOARD OF ENGINEERS AND ENGINEER D~EPOTS,

                        APPENDIX No. i.


              REPORT OF THE BOARD OF ENGINEERS.

               THE BOARD     OF ENGINEERS,  ARMY BUILDING,
                                     New York City,,July 3,1909.
  Sin: I have the honor to submit the annual report recounting the
operations of The Board of Engineers for the year ending June 30,
1909.
  The following changes have taken place in the personnel of the
Board since the date of the last annual report:
  On July 2, 1908, Brig. Gen. W. L. Marshall was commissioned
Chief of Engineers.
   By paragraph 1, Special Orders, No. 26, War Department, Office of
the Chief of Engineers, July 21, 1908, Lieut. Col. Roessler, Corps
of Engineers, was made a member.
   By paragraph 22, Special Orders, No. 201, War Department,
August 28, 1908, Col. E. H. Ruffner, Corps of Engineers, was made a
member. On June 24, 1909, he was retired from active service by
operation of law.
  By paragraph 25, Special Orders, No. 232, War Department, Octo-
                      L. Wignore, Corps of Engineers, was assigned
ber 5, 1908, Capt. H. L.
to duty as recorder and( disbursing officer of the Board.
  As at present constituted, The Board of Engineers is composed of
Col. D. W. Lockwood, Corps of Engineers; Col. John G. D. Knight,
Corps of Engineers; Col. S. W. Roessler, Corps of Engineers; Lieut.
Col. E. B. Babbitt, Ordnance Department; Capt. H. L. Wigmore,
Corps of Engineers, recorder and disbursing officer; R ea r-A dmciral
Richard Wainwright, U. S. Navy, during consideration of defense of
coal depots only.
  The following division engineers are also members of The Board
of Engineers when matters pertaining to defensive works in their
respective divisions are under consideration: Col. William H. Bixby,
Corps of Engineers, western division; Col. William T. Rosseil, Corps
                                                             955
956     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,          U.   S. ARMY.

of Engineers, central division; Col. Dan C. Kingman, Corps of En-
gineers, southeast division; Col. W. L. Fisk, Corps of Engineers, Lakes
division; Lieut. Col. John Biddle, Corps of Engineers, Pacific division;
Lieut. Col. L. H. Beach, Corps of Engineers, Gulf division.
   The Board has considered the various subjects referred to it during
the past fiscal year by the Chief of Engineers.

  For the Board:
      Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                          D. W. LocKwooD,
                                       Colonel, Corps of Engineers,
                                              Senior Member of Board.
  The CHIEF   OF ENGINEERS,    U. S.   ARMY.
                        APPENDIX       No. 2.


           ENGINEER DEPOT, WASHINGTON           BARRACKS.



REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. W. C. LANGFITT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
        FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.



              ENGINEER    :DEPOT, UNITED STATES ARMY,
                                    WASHINGTON BARRACKS,
                                 Washington, D. C., August 2, 1909.
   SIR: I have the honor to forward herewith, in duplicate, Annual
Report for the Engineer Depot, Washington Barracks, D. C., for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909.
        Very respectfully,
                                         W. C.   LANGFITT,
                    Lieut. Col., Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.,
                                    In charge of Engineer Depot.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. AnMY.



    ENGINEER DEPOT,      WASHINGTON BARRACKS,        DISTRICT OF
                            COLUMBIA.

   The general work of the Engineer Depot consists of the care of all
the property on hand, the purchase of new articles, repair of older
ones, and the shipment to troops of supplies as they are needed.
The work of the depot has continued to increase during the year. It
is estimated that the total weight of supplies which were shipped from
the depot during the year was approximately 205,000 pounds.
                      STOREHOUSES   AND SHOPS.

   The old building used for the various shops pertaining to the depot
and for other purposes connected with the Engineer School, located
on grounds assigned to War College, was demolished by the Quarter-
master's Department, and as the shops are a most essential part of
the depot a new building to contain them should be provided for
immediately. The estimate for this building is included in the
report for the Engineer School.
   There is at the present time no available space on the post for the
storage of the various wagons pertaining to the bridge trains, and the
space available for the storage of miscellaneous lumber and bridge
material is far too small. These imperative needs of the depot
should be attended to at an early date. Roughly estimated, the con-
struction of such a shed for the protection of ponton wagons and
                                                              957
958        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                   U.   S. ARMY.

other heavy and bulky ponton material and for protecting all sorts of
lumber continuously used in the Engineer Depot for various purposes
would cost about $15,000.
                                      INSTRUMENTS.

   The Engineer Depot at Washington Barracks is the designated
repository for all kinds of surveying, astronomical, and reconnais-
sance instruments for all civil and military works -under the charge
of the Engineer Department. The depot is also charged with the
purchase and issue of various surveying and reconnaissance outfits for
other organizations in the army.
   During the year a large number of instruments were turned in to
the depot in various conditions, and a number of new ones were pur-
chased for the depot.
   Many of the instruments turned in to the depot were in poor con-
dition and had to be repaired, and some were sent to the depot for
the express purpose of being repaired. The total cost of these
repairs during the year was $2,873.84.
   Various surveying instruments were obtained by purchase during
the year, required to fill requisitions from officers on public works
and surveys. The total amount thus expended was $2,126.16.
   On account of the large demands upon the depot for instruments,
the amount appropriated for the purchase and repair of instruments,
$5,000, proved to be inadequate for the purpose.
   In addition, in many cases, instruments were, by authority of the
Chief of Engineers, purchased through the depot for use on various
civil works, the instruments and the bills for the same being sent to
the officers in charge of the works. The following were so purchased
and shipped to the officers calling for them: 37 engineer transits, 29
engineer levels, 21 level rods, 7 sextants, 2 tide gauges, 9 binocular
field glasses, 31          assorted   measuring tapes,       2 Universal drafting
machines, and a large number of various small surveying and recoln-
naissance instruments and drawing materials, involving a total
expenditure of approximately $15,000 for all the instruments so
purchased.
   Twelve engineer transits and three engineer levels were sent to the
depot for repairs by officers on 'river and harbor works, and were
repaired at a total expense of $496. The accounts were all paid by
officers in charge of river and harbor works.

          EQUIPMENT OF OFFICERS'            SCHOOLS, MILITARY POSTS.

   From the appropriation for this purpose the sumn of $:3,500was
allotted for expenditure through the engineer depot for the purchase
of certain drawing, surveying, and reconnaissance instruments.
With this allotment the following articles were purchased:
3 reconnaissance transits.                   13   sets drawing instruments.
5 engineer levels.                           10   German silver protractors.
3 level rods.                                10   drawing board!, 31 by 42 inches,
50 prismatic compasses.                      50   pace tallies.
50 cavalry sketching cases.                  30   assorted triangles.
75 service clinorneters.                     17 T squares.
50 box compasses.                            6 steel straightedges.
    APPENDIX 2.--ENGINEER      DEPOT, WASHINGTON        BARRACKS.   959
                 ENGINEER    EQUIPMENT   OF   TROOPS.

  This equipment is supplied to the army under provisions of Gen-
eral Orders, No. 113, War Department, 1906, and Nos. 73 and 221,
War Department, 1907, for artillery, cavalry, and infantry troops,
and General Orders, No. 9, Office of the Chief of Engineers, 1906, for
Engineer troops.
  These orders do not cover larger items such as bridge equipage,
siege materials, field searchlights, special map reproduction outfits
for divisions and armies, etc.
   Issues and receipts for repairs or exchange under the provisions of
the orders cited have been as extensive as the limited funds would
permit.   The service is as yet far from being fully equipped as
required by these orders. Equipping engineer troops especially has
been put off as much as possible in order to devote funds to supplying
the other branches.
  Under act of March 2, 1907, all supplies for the army required by
General Orders, 221, War Department, 1907, were purchased and
delivered except inthose cases where retention here has been requested
by organizations until their return from the Philippines, Alaska, etc.

                   PONTON AND BRIDGE EQUIPAGE.

   The ponton and bridge equipage on hand in the engineer depot
has been taken care of during the year, imany additions have been
made by purchase with the funds allotted from time to time by the
Chief of Engineers. Eight wooden ponton boats have been con-
structed in the engineer depot and were completed at the end of the
fiscal year; a number of experimental trestles have also been con-
structed during the year in the engineer department carpenter shop.
At the end of the fiscal year two divisions of reserve ponton equipage
and two divisions of advance guard equipage have been completed,
as contemplated in the Engineer Department Manual, with the fol-
lowing exceptions:
   (a) Twenty ponton wagons, which are now under contract; de-
livery of same is expected in the early part of the next fiscal year.
  (b) Three tool wagons, which are now under contract; delivery of
                          t
same is expected in the ea rl part of the next fiscal year.
   (c) Sixteen chess wagons; due to limited funds they could not be
provided for at the close of the fiscal year, but will be obtained from
new appropriations in the near future.
   (d) A battery and forge wagon, with complete outfit of tools; due
to limited funds this could not be provided for, but will be obtained
from new appropriations in the near future.
   Fifty ponton wagons were contracted for during the year, and under
the terms of the contract all will be delivered in September, 1.909.
On completion they will be distributed as follows: Twenty to Wash-
ington Barracks, D. C.; 20 to Fort Leavenworth, Kans.; 10 to Van-
couver Barracks, Wash.
  The 16 chess wagons under contract at close of last fiscal year were
completed and delivered at Washington Barracks, D. C.
  The three-section ponton boat (steel) w s tested at West Point and
very favorable report thereon submnitted. Further tests are proposed
960     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

both of this and the one-piece boat in comparison with the adopt ed
type.
   Three ponton train tool wagons of the new design were placed under
contract and will be delivered in August, 1909.
   The body for special tool wagon for engineer companies was sent
to Fort Leavenworth for comparative test during the season with one
designed there.
   A new form of suspension for trestle caps, designed by Lieut. R. R.
Ralston, Corps of Engineers, was tested and proved much better than
service type. It is thought worthy of adoption, together with a
deeper cap.
                           MISCELLANEOUS.

  The automobile field searchlight outfit under contract at close of
last fiscal year was finally delivered. Preliminary tests have shown
that the unit is very satisfactory, and will need but few modifications.
Full tests will be made during the coming year, as well as of types of
portable power plant and lights to go with it.
   In addition to the foregoing operations in the engineer depot,
considerable additional work was necessary in filling a number of
requisitions from the organized militias in the United States. All of
the issues made on these requisitions were duly authorized by the
Chief of Engineers, U. S. Army. The total sum of $9,060.50 was
involved in such purchases and issues, which amount was reimbursed
by Treasury settlements to the appropriations from which the pur-
chases were made.
                                  APPENDIX No. 3.


          ENGINEER DEPOT, FORT LEAVENWORTH, KANSAS.



REPORT OF MAJ. CLEMENT A. F. FLAGLER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
        FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.



                                         FORT LEAVENWORTH, KANS.,
                                                   July 7, 1909.
  SIR: I have the honor to inclose herewith, in duplicate, annual
report of the Engineer Depot, Fort Leavenworth, Kans., for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909.
       Very respectfully,
                                               C. A. F.   FLAGLER,
                              Major, Corps of Engineers,
                                        Commanding Depot.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

UNITED STATES ENGINEER DEPOT, FORT LEAVENWORTH, KANSAS.

                                     OPERATIONS.

   Office and storehouse.-The general work of the office and store-
house consists of the care of property on hand, the purchase of sup-
plies, occasional shipments to troops and repair of instruments,
issues to the battalion of engineers here stationed, and the keeping
of the depot accounts and records.
   Ten anchors and 27 oars of the reserve equipage were shipped to
the depot at Vancouver Barracks during the year.
   Shop.-The shop was in operation from July 1 to 25, and from
October 1 to June 30. Most of the shop work consisted of repairs
to the old ponton, chess, and tool wagons on hand in the depot, and
to other equipment damaged by wear in the service. One Rees
experimental tool wagon was completed in July and was reported
upon December 31, 1908. A number of trestles, paddles, drawing
tables and stools, skiffs, sap tools, pickets, and other minor articles
of equipment were also made. During the months of May and June
the work consisted mainly in installing machinery in and in fitting up
the new shop which is not yet quite complete.
   Under the allotment of March 11, 1909, white pine lumber and
other supplies have been purchased for the construction of addi-
tional reserve and advance guard pontons. All of this material
     9001-ENG   1909   ---   61                                      961
962     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

has been delivered except the white pine lumber, and it is expected
that that will be received in time to begin work on the new boats in
November.
                         STEAMER UNIQUE.

  Upon the approved recommendation of an inspector the boat was,
on June 2, sold at public auction for $300, and the proceeds deposited
to the credit of the Treasurer of the United States.

                     CONDITION OF PROPERTY.

  With the exception of the ponton wagons, 13 chess wagons, 2 tool
wagons, 1 reserve ponton, the advance-guard pontons, and 500
13-foot chess, all property carried on the depot return is in good
condition and fit for field service.
                        APPENDIX        No. 4.


     ENGINEER DEPOT, VANCOUVER BARRACKS, WASHINGTON.



REPORT OF CAPT. ELLIOTT J. DENT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, FOR THE
             FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.



                              VANCOUVER BARRACKS,        WASH.,
                                                  July 19, 1909.
   SIR: I have the honor to inclose herewith, in duplicate, annual
report of the Engineer Depot, Vancouver Barracks, Wash., for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1909.
       Very respectfully,                        E. J. DENT,
                             Captain, Corps of Engineers,
                                          In charge of Depot.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


UNITED STATES ENGINEER DEPOT, VANCOUVER BARRACKS, WASH-
                        INGTON.

   During the year a ponton train, consisting of the principal items of
one division advance and one division reserve equipage, were trans-
ferred from the Engineer Depot at Fort Mason, Cal., to this depot.
Under the allotment of March 29, 1909, for repairs to this equipage,
considerable work in overhauling the equipage was done, wagons
were overhauled and painted, 4 boats were recalked and 2 were
painted. New balk and chess were made from material on hand and
all old balk were tested to a fiber stress of approximately 4,000 pounds
per square inch.
   Under allotments of March 27 and 29, 1909, tools and supplies were
purchased for fitting out tool wagons for one advance and one reserve
division, with the exception of a few minor articles and the item of
canvas. Some oak lumber was purchased for replacing parts of car-
riages. Tools, a supply of explosives, photographic supplies, lum-
ber, etc., were purchased for use of the engineer company stationed
at this depot.
                                                                963
               RIVERS AND HARBORS, ETC.


                            APPENDIX A.



IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE PORTLAND, MAINE,
                        DISTRICT.



REPORT OF LIE UT. COL. GEO. A. ZINN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, OFFI-
CER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.

                              IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Lubec channel, Maine.                9. Kennebec River, Maine.
2. Breakwater from Mount Desert to     10. Portland Harbor, Maine.
     Porcupine Island, Bar Harbor,     11. Saco River, Maine.
     Maine.                            12. Cape Porpoise Harbor, Maine.
3. Harbor at Sullivan Falls, Maine..   13. Harbor at Isles of Shoals, Maine.
4. Union River, Maine.                 14. Cocheco River, New Hampshire.
5. Bagaduce River, Maine.              15. Harbor of refuge at Little Harbor,
6. Penobscot River, Maine.                   New Hampshire.
7. Harbor at Rockland, Maine.          16. Removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
8. Sasanoa River, Maine.                     structing or endangering navigation.



                           UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                      Portland, Me., July 15, 1909.
   SIR: I have the honor to transmit herewith annual report for the
fiscal year 1909 for river and harbor works in my charge.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                      GEO. A. ZINN,
                                       Lieut. Col., Corps of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                  Ai.

            IMPROVEMENT OF LUBEC CHANNEL, MAINE.

  The project has been completed, and there was no work during the
year.
                                                                       965
966               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                         APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriations to December 31, 1902 (see p. 260, H. Doec. 421, 57th Cong.,
2d sess.) ....................... ......     ............. .......... ...... $319, 000

                                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                       Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                                                                      Tons.
Bricks, clay, and cement.                                  ................................................                            1, 100
Canned goods-----------......................................-----------------------------------------.................              17, 500
Coal....--.------.--.-----...---...............-----......--......--------------.............----------.....------------..........    7,000
Fertilizer....--.......----....------.......---......------........--.-----......-----------------------....................              400
Fish---...-------.......--------.................-------------......------...........--------.........--..------------.........      15, 500
Grain, flour, hay, and straw..............................................                                                            3, 800
Iron and steel..-------------------------------------------------------.........................................................          250
Lime......------......-------.................................................--------.....                                               200
Lumber..............----..------.........------------.......................................                                              300
Molasses and sugar------......--------.............----------------------............--.............----------......                      220
Oil------------------......---.........................................-----------------------------..--------------..                 3,700
Provisions......--------....................................---------------------------------------........--------.........          3, 200
Salt---....--....................................................-------------------------------------------------...------...        2,500
Wood...........................---------...........--...----------------........----------------.................----------------.        700

           Total-------..............--------------------------------------------...........---                                       56, 370

               Arrivals and departures during calendar year ending December 31, 1908.

Steam, average draft 14 feet.-.........                .... ..................................                                            330
Sailing vessels, average draft 10 feet......--..................................                                                          520
Number of vessels built....................................................                                                                 3
Number of passengers landing and departing by water ......................                                                             4, 800




                                                                       A     2.

BREAKWATER FROM MOUNT DESERT TO PORCUPINE ISLAND, BAR
                   HARBOR, MAINE.

    There was no work during the year.
                                           Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of improve-
ment-     -     -     -    --......-..                           -         $50, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.



                                                         APPROPRIATIONS.

August 11, 1888.......----.......... $50, 000                                March 3, 1899................... $20, 000
September 19, 1890..............      50, 000                                March 2, 1907 ................... 30, 000
July 13, 1892...................      50,000
August 18, 1894................. 10, 000                                                Total....................                    220, 000
June 3, 1896................... 10,000
                            APPENDIX A-REPORT OF LIEUT.                                          COL. ZININ.                         967

                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                          Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                                                                    Tons.
Apples .....................................................                                     .              ....   .....   .        45
B eef ...................................................................                                                                         300
Bricks and clay .............................................                                                         ..............           2, 500
Canned goods............                                  ..........
                                                                   ..      ........ ........ ....................                                 300
Cement and lime--....--....................----------------------------------..................-----------............--                          750
Coal-----------------------......----................--------..................---------------....--...........---.....------...              15,000
Cotton and cotton goods....---....................                                                  ................             ...... .          50
Fertilizer------------------------...............................-------.......----------------------------..........................             200
Fish--------------................--...---.........----........-------.....---------..........----.----------------------...............          500
Grain, flour, hay, and straw...-.....-.............                                                 ..-.....................                 100, 500
General merchandise----------------.....-----......--........----.............------------...............--------...                          60, 500
Horses-------........................---------------............................................                                                  200
Ice .-------....----------...........--------------.......------............                                                                  30,000
Iron, steel, and machinery-.................                                          .........................                         ....      180
Lumber..............................................----------------------------------------------....----------...........                  100,000
Molasses and sugar..-----------..........---------...........-----------....-.....------........---..........---------                            400
Qil---------------------------....................................................................-------------------------------------           100
Potatoes---.......---...........--------------...---------------------------------------..........................................                500
Sand and        stone...............                          .     ......      .......         ...............               .....-- .....   20, 000
            Total..--------------............-------------------------------------.........--....                                  332, 025
                Arrivals and departures during calendar year ending December 31, 1908.

Number of passengers arriving and departing by water .-...............--                                                       . 125, 000


                                                                     A       3.

               IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT SULLIVAN FALLS, MAINE.

     There were no operations during the year and no expenditures.
                                              Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of improve-
ment---....-------.....--.------....--..-.............................................
                                   ---------------------------------------$10,000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.


                                                               APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1871-................... $10, 000                                   June 13, 1902 ..................                       $5, 000
June 10, 1872.................. 25, 000
June 3, 1896...................     5, 000                                             Total ....................                   50, 000
March 3, 1899-...................   5, 000


                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                           Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                                                                    Tons.
Coal......................................................................---350
General merchandise----------...............--......................................                                                    150
Lum ber .................................................................                                                               300
Stone.. ..........               -..... .......................................-........                                            58, 500
            Total-................                         ...... ........        ..       ......................                   59, 300
968            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                            U.    S. ARMY.

            Arrivals and departures during calendar year ending December 31, 1908.
Steamers, average draft about 12 feet..........-..............................                                                 15
Sailing, average draft about 12 feet............................................                                              117



                                                              A 4.

                           IMPROVEMENT OF UNION RIVER, MAINE.

   There was no work during the year.
   April 22, 1909, an allotment of $15,950 was made from the appro-
priation for preservation and maintenance of river and harbor
works provided by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, for
restoring the channel depths secured under a previous project.
The work has been advertised and contract awarded to Philip H.
Doyen, of South Portland, Me. On the basis of the estimated quan-
tities the contract will cover $13,755. It is due to be completed
during the present working season.
                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriations to December 31, 1902 (see p. 262, H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d
  sess.) .--------.................--------..-------...-...---.....---------------......----.....--..--.... $175, 000
Allotment April 22, 1909, act March 3, 1909, for preservation and mainte-
  nance of river and harbor works..                    ..................           ................... 15, 950

          Total.....         .............        ..           ........        .....      ................              190,950



                                              CONTRACT IN FORCE.

   Philip H. Doyen, of South Portland, Me.
   Dredging about 13,500 cubic yards at 17.5 cents; about 46,500 cubic yards at 24.5
cents.
   Not yet approved, to be commenced within thirty days after date of notification
of approval, and to be completed by December 31, 1909.



                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                 Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                                                            Tons.
Bricks and clay..................................................................                                                550
Coal..------....-.....-----..-...--......-------------------------------------............................................... 2, 800
General merchandise--------..........................------------...........-----------............------------......            481
Lumber and cooperage---------...............--------.........-----------........---.............-------...---..               3, 800
Oil-------.........------....---..........-................-----..----------....-.....-----...........-------...-------.....      12
Sand and gravel-...........                     ........... .. .........                ......       ..........   ........       200
Wood-----..........--..................--------.....--------.....----.--.........----......--............---------817
          Total...--.....--------------.........------------................-------------------                            8,660
              Arrivals and departures during calendaryear ending December 31, 1908.

Sailing vessels, average draft 10 feet.......................................                                                   75
                        APPENDIX A-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. ZINN.                                                                           969
                                                              A 5.

                       IMPROVEMENT OF BAGADUCE RIVER, MAINE.

    There were no operations during the year and no expenditures.
                                           Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of improvement. $5, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.



                                                     APPROPRIATIONS.

August 11, 1888.................. $3, 000                             March 3, 1899 ...................  $3, 000
September 19, 1890............... 4, 000                              June 13, 1902................. ... 3, 000
July 13, 1892-.---------............-------.... 5, 000
August 18, 1894..................               5, 000                              Total........                 ..... .......        28, 000
June 3, 1896...................                 5,000




                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                   Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                     Tons.
Apples ..............................................................                   20
Beef..................................................................--------------100
Bricks, clay, and cec_t---------...-------...................----------------.............---------------......... -11,                    300
Cattle-.............. . ........ ............... ..........................                                                       ..     3,500
Canned goods ..................     .............      ........      .......                              ............                     200
Coal......-- ---........................                    ....................................                                         3,500
Cotton and cotton goods...-----------------......-....................................-----------------                        800
Fertilizer ......... ....................................................                                                      200
Fish.........-------------------------........................................................                                 600
General merchandise...---.---...---....-----------...........--...----------------...................---......             27, 000
Grain, flour, hay, and straw.............................................                                                  17, 800
Iron, steel, and machinery............---                          ...............                     ...................  6,100
Lime...........................................................................-                                            6,000
Lumber and cooperage.......---.........................................                                                    28, 500
Leather and hides-----------------------------------------------.......................................................         25
Molasses and sugar................                                   .......................................                   300
Oil..--................................................................--------------------------                              800
Provisions.........------...................................................                                                4, 500
Salt..................-------...............................................150
Sand and stone-...--.....................................................                                                      400
Wood .....................................................................                                                  6,000

          Total.................----.....................                                          ............                        117,795

              Arrivals and departures during calendar year ending December 31, 1908.

Steamers, average draft 6 feet........ ..................                      .................  3, 000
Sailing vessels, average draft 61 feet........................................                    1, 800
Number of passengers arriving and departing by water ....................                        32, 000
   The foregoing statement includes the business done at Castine, at the mouth of the
river.
970               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                         S. ARMY.

                                                                      A 6.
                        IMPROVEMENT OF PENOBSCOT RIVER, MAINE.

   Operations during the year consisted in widening the channel at
Bangor under contract with Eastern Dredging Company, which cov-
ered the entire project. The work involves the removal of about
9,000 cubic yards of ledge and about 15,000 cubic yards of other
material, consisting of gravel, bowlders, etc., all measured in place.
The average cutting is about 2 feet, and the area is about 1,800 feet
long, with an average width of 190 feet. Work was commenced Sep-
tember 28, 1908, with a chisel machine for breaking up the material
to be removed, suspended during the winter, resumed May 5, 1909,
and continued down to the present time. On the 28th of May the
excavation of loosened material with a dredge was begun, and by the
close of the fiscal year about 6,000 cubic yards of material, scow meas-
urement, had been taken up; but as the area has not yet been swept
to determine whether or not the full depth has been secured, accurate
information as to the real progress is not at hand. About 5,000
square yards of the shoal have been worked over. The contract price
is a lump sum of $124,900.
   Expenditures during the year were $615.32.
                                                        APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriations to December 31, 1902 (see p. 261, H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d
sess.)................................................................      $376,300
March 2, 1907 ............................................................    130, 000

                                                                                                                                      506, 300


                                                   CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Eastern Dredging Company.
  Excavating about 9,000 cubic yards of ledge and about 15,000 cubic yards of other
material, measured in place.
  Lump price, $124,900.
  Approved September 5, 1908, work to be commenced by October 11, 1908, and
completed by October 10, 1911.


                                               COMMERCIAL                   STATISTICS.

                                                      Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                                                                           Tons.
Bricks and clay....................................................                                                                              450
Brimstone-................------------...................------......---.....----------------...............---------------------..                1
Cement and lime ......---.....                                .........................................                                       4,015
Coal..-.......---------------.........................----------------------................----................------------------          267, 400
Fertilizer-------------..............--......................................-------------------------------------...-----......              7, 140
Fish....---..-----------------------.............--------------...................---------------------...................                    1,032
General merchandise...................                                       ................                     ..................         35, 400
Grain..-------.....------------------------------------------------.....................................................-----...              3,050
Ice........-------..-----------------------------------------------------............................................................        50,000
Lumber---.--...------------.............----...................-------------------------..........---------......----..... 150, 000
O il...........................
Oil                                                                .....................
     ----------------------------------------------------------------                                             ...........         .....   5, 854
                                                                                                                                              5,854
Sand and stone------------------------.......---------..............................------------------...........                            18, 400
Salt-----..........-......................--------............-......................                                                         9,420
Wood .......................................                                                      ..........         ...... ............         170

          Total................................                                           ......          ..............              552, 332
                         APPENDIX A-REPORT OF LIEUT.                                            COL. ZINN.                                971
             Arrivals and departures during calendar year ending December 31, 1908.
Steam vessels, average draft about 13 feet-.--...-- - .--.. .--                 .--
                                                                           --..-----              -                                      2, 394
Sailing vessels, average draft about 13 feet------.........................------------------..--..                                      1, 152
Number of passengers landing and departing by water_..-... ... .-..........                                                            120, 500


                                                                   A      7.

                  IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT ROCKLAND, MAINE.

  There were no operations during the year, and no expenditures.
The project is regarded as completed, subject to any work that may be
needed from time to time until the slopes of the breakwater have
assumed a condition of permanence.
                                                      APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriations to December 31, 1902 (see p. 262, H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong.,
2d sess.)..........................--....................................------ $925, 500


                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                     Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                                                                         Tons.
Coal......................------.........................................---------------------------------------------------......     110,000
Cooperage.....----....----...----...------.........----------.....---.....---------...........------------------...............         15,000
Fish------..-----......-------------................-----..........-----............--------------........------------...........        3,400
General merchandise..............................                                                 .............           ....... _    100, 000
Lime...-------------.........-------------...............--------------.......-------......--................----------........        235,000
Lumber and ship timbers.........................-........... ...                                                               .....    10, 000
Oil......--------.----------......-.................-----------------.......-------------------------.............................       2,500
Salt--...............----..---------------------------------------------------................................................--..          550
Stone--............--------.........-----------------------------------------------...............................................      15,000
Wood-----........--------------..................-----------------....................-----------------....------..............          2, 500
          Total------.......--..---.....--..---...---------------------...-------..........-----. 493, 950

                                                                     1 2ber 31, 1908.
             Arrivals and departures during calendar year ending Decem

Steam vessels, draft from 6 to 20 feet...-...... . ..........................                                                            8, 390
Sailing vessels, draft from 6 to 20 feet------..-----...................-------------.......----..--....                                 4, 320
Number of vessels built during the year ............-----                ..................                                                   5
Number of passengers arriving and departing by water.. .................                                                               135, 149


                                                                     A 8.
                           IMPROVEMENT OF SNASANOA RIVER, MAINE.

  Operations consisted in rock excavation near Upper Hell Gate, in
continuation of the project, which was completed December 26, 1908.
The total quantity of material removed was 2,866 cubic yards
measured in place, of which 740 cubic yards were taken out during
the preceding year. It was done under a single contract; the price
was $9.50 per cubic yard..
   The expenditures during the year were $27,558.03.
   This work has given an additional width of 50 feet (the full width
is now 140 feet) to a channel which was difficult and dangerous
because of strong and irregular currents.
972             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                            U.    S. ARMY.

                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriations to December 31, 1902 (see p. 262, H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong.,
2d sess.) ........................................................................ $64, 500
March 2, 1907 .................        ........................   ..............     44, 000

     Total....... .. ................    . ...........................                                                   108, 500
  NOTE.-Of this amount, $7,012.31 was covered into the surplus fund.



                                              CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Frank W. Carlton, of Bath, Me.
  For excavation of 2,800 cubic yards submerged ledge.
  Price, $9.50 per cubic yard, place measurement.
  Dated July 16, 1907; approved July 24, 1907; to be commenced by August 15,
1907, and completed by November 1, 1908.
  Completed.


                                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                                                              Tons.
Apples....           ...............................................................                                               5
Beef------------....................................................................--------------------------------------26
Bricks, clay and clay pipe....--------....----......---..-----------...........--.......------.....----......                   465
Cattle-....---------....----------................................--------------.------..-.....----..............---------...    12
Canned goods----------.....--------......-----..............--------.................----------------...............--              7
Cem ent................ ....................... ................... .......  75
Coal----------------------------------------------------------               55
Fish ....................................................................   890
     Genralmerhaui~e---------------------------------------159
                                                                               ----------------
Grain, flour, hay, and straw.-----...---------...........................---------.............                                618
Lime.................................................                                                                           20
Lumber and cooperage--..---............----.........--.....-----......------------.----...---.....--...                        125

          Total--------........----.................-------------------------------------                                   3, 896

             Arrivals and departures during calendaryear ending December 31, 1908.

Steam, average draft 9 feet. ..............................................                                                2, 000
Sailing vessels, average draft 16 feet ..................................                                            .        379
Number of passengers arriving and departing by water .....................                                                73, 537



                                                              A 9.

                      IMPROVEMENT OF KENNEBEC RIVER, MAINE.

   Expenditures during the fiscal year 1909 for that portion of the
river between Gardiner and Augusta have been $47,524.81. The
work consisted entirely in dredging under a contract approved
October 24, 1907. The total quantity of material excavated under
this contract was 243,946 cubic yards, of which 102,171 cubic yards
were taken out during the fiscal year 1909. The price was 351 cents
per cubic yard, scow measurement. The contract was completed
November 28, 1908, and at the same time the project, which provided
for a channel 125 feet wide and 11 feet deep at mean low tide between
Gardiner and Augusta.
                      APPENDIX A-REPORT                         OF LIEUT.           COL. ZINN.                         973
   Expenditures during the fiscal year on that portion of the river
from the mouth to Gardiner have been $61,743.87.
   The entire project has been placed under contract, and embraces
three classes of work: Dredging; repair and extension of a riprap
jetty at Beef Rock shoal, and repair of a jetty at Upper Sands; and
rock excavation at Lovejoys Narrows.
   Dredging was continued throughout the year, except for the winter
season. The excavation for the year amounted to 109,958 cubic
yards, and about 32 per cent of the work covered by the contract has
been accomplished. The prices for the work vary, but most of the
dredging up to the present time has been in group No. 1, for which
the price is 351 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
   Jetty repair and extension was in progress until October 24, 1908,
when a contract with Rowe Brothers Company was completed.
During the year, 21,722 tons of stone were placed in the two jetties
and a stone masonry beacon was built at the outer end of each.
The stone cost 88 cents per ton and the beacons $6.50 per cubic yard
of masonry.
   The work at Lovejoys Narrows is to remove about 2,994 cubic yards,
place measurement, of rock, making a depth of 18 feet at mean low
tide. The cutting averages about 1.25 feet. Work was commenced
June 14, 1909, but as the contractor's operations have been limited to
drilling and blasting, it is impracticable to make a definite statement
of progress.
                                    Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of
  improvement................................................. ---------------------------                          $43, 500
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.


                                                APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriations to include June 3, 1896 (see p. 260, H. Doc. No. 421,
  57th Cong., 2d sess.)...............................................                                             $511, 445. 71
June 13, 1902.......................................................                                                 40, 000. 00
June 30, 1906 ..........................................                                            .........    .   15,000.00
March 2, 1907--------...---........---..-......-------------..............--------......-..---.....-------......     75,000. 00
March 4, 1907.. --....---........              ..............        ................... .......                     26,000.00
May 27, 1908............----.................................................                                        86, 500. 00
March 4, 1909.............................                                               ..............              70,000. 00
                                                                                                               823, 945. 71
   NOTE.-$368.19 carried to surplus fund.



                                           CONTRACTS             IN FORCE.

  Eastern Dredging Company.
  Dredging about 215,000 cubic yards of material between Gardiner and Augusta.
  Price, 35 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
  Approved November 27, 1905; to be commenced by January 5, 1906, and completed
by May 15, 1908 (waived).
  Contract completed.
974            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Eastern Dredging Company.
  Dredging about 396,000 cubic yards of material from the mouth to Gardiner.
  Prices:
      Group No. 1, 352 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
      Group No. 2, 41l cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
      Group No. 3, 412 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
      Group No. 4, 90 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
      Group No. 5, 442 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
      Removing bowlders (except in group No. 4), exceeding 5 tons each in weight,
         $8 per ton.
  Approved October 24, 1907; to be commenced by November 27, 1907, and completed
by October 28, 1910.

  Rowe Brothers Company.
  For placing about 30,000 tons of stone in jetties and building two masonry beacons.
  Prices, 88 cents per ton for stone, and $6.50 per cubic yard for masonry in beacons.
  Approved November 1, 1907; to be commenced by December 4, 1907, and completed
by March 4, 1909.
  Contract completed.

  Eastern Dredging Company.
  For excavating about 2,994 cubic yards of ledge at Lovejoys Narrows.
  Price, $19.30 per cubic yard, place measurement.
  Approved June 9, 1909; to be commenced by July 10, 1909, and completed by
July 9, 1911.



                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                            Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                                             Tons.
Cement............ ...................................................                                             971
Coal...........------.. ...................................................                       -----        93,116
Fertilizer.......------.......................................................                                  2, 386
General merchandise........................................................4, 290
Ice..............--------------..................................----................213, 698
Lumber........ .            ---..................     ----...................................                  44,396
Pulp wood.............................................................                        ....      ...... 17, 921
Salt...............------------------------...................................................---------460
         Total.........................                                      .................              377,238

            Arrivals and departures during calendar year ending December 31, 1908.

Steamers, average draft 15 feet.....................................                             .....        3, 000
Sailing vessels, average draft 15 feet.......- .. .....................                                          400
Number of passengers arriving and departing by water. .............                                 ....    101, 143



                                                       A io.

                    IMPROVEMENT OF PORTLAND HARBOR, MAINE.

   Dredging in Portland Harbor under the project of 1896 as amended
in 1905 was continued, under contract with Coastwise Dredging
Company, until September 17, 1908, when the work was completed.
The excavation during the fiscal year 1909 amounted to 52,052 cubic
yards, which was taken from the upper part of Fore River. The con-
tract price for this part of the work was 13- cents per cubic yard.
   The expenditures during the fiscal year have been $31,886.84.
The project is completed.
                         APPENDIX A-REPORT                               OF LIEUT.               COL. ZINN.                             975
                                                      APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriated to include August 18, 1894, including appropriations for
  Back Cove (see pp. 259 and 261, H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.) ..                                                     $692, 727. 05
June 3, 1896..................------------------------------.........----------------.....--.....--......                     20, 000. 00
June 4, 1897------......----...............----------------.....-------.............-----------............                  350, 000. 00
July 1, 1898..----..........----------------------........................................---------------------.             200, 000.00
March 3, 1901--------.........-------..........----------------.................--.....-----...........
                                                                                               -------------                  21, 000.00
March 3, 1905-------------.......----------...................------------------------.........................              100, 000.00
June 30, 1906.........................--------------------------------------------------                                      80, 000. 00
March 4, 1907--.....------------------------------------------------                                                          59, 000. 00
Receipts from sales...................---------------------------.....-----............----.......                                  9.00
          Total.................                          ........     ...........................                        1, 522, 736.05


                                                  CONTRACT IN FORCE.
  Coastwise Dredging Company.
  Dredging about 87,500 cubic yards, scow measurement, at 30 cents per cubic yard;
about 1,325,000 cubic yards, scow measurement, at 131 cents per cubic yard; with a
price of $10 per ton (2,000 pounds) for bowlders exceeding 5 tons each in weight.
  Approved September 18, 1905; to be commenced by November 20, 1905, and com-
pleted by January 7, 1908 (waived).
  Contract completed.


                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
                                                     Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                                                                       Tons.
Apples.........................................                                                                           .........       25, 191
Canned goods. ....                             .... ...................                                  ................                 17, 100
Cattle on hoof and beef .................                                   ...      ..............................                       14, 760
Cement, lime, brick, and clay............................................                                                                 40, 063
China clay..................                          ...........................................                                         10, 779
Coal.............-------------..----.......------------...........-----------------------------...............................         1,550,109
Cotton..-----...............--------..-----...--....---........................--------------------------.......                          13, 223
Fish.......---------------...........-----------............----....--..............-------------..-...------------..........             17,424
General merchandise.........---...                                ................................                               .....   409, 104
Grain, flour, and hay..................................................                                                                  303, 063
Ice...........----.-------...........--------------------------------------------------.............................................       7, 825
Leather and hides....................................................                                                                      4, 531
Lumber and cooperage............                             ......................                            .............              64, 139
Machinery and iron..................                               ...........              ........................                      12, 627
Molasses and sugar.....................................................                                                                   23, 190
Oil and oil cakes ..........................                                    ..... .............                   ..........          46, 232
Paper and rags....-----.---......-----......--...------..--...........----------.....................               ---------             47, 264
Provisions.-----------..----                             ---------------------------------------- 119, 608
Pulp wood--...                         .....            ...-----------------------------------------------------                          95, 575
Salt...-------- ----------------------------------------------------                                                                      12, 250
Sand and stone..---.......--------..--.......---------------...................---------................-------------                     10, 181
Sulphur-----. ..----------------------------------------------------                                                                      24, 818
Wood ........                 . ................................................-.....                                                    63, 461

           Total................------------.................................... 2, 932, 517
         Arrivals and departures during calendaryear ending December 31, 1908.
Steam:
     Foreign, draft 20 to 26 feet, tonnage unknown...--............--......                230
    .Coastwise, draft 12 to 18 feet, tonnage unknown .....................             13, 870
     Coastwise, draft 6 to 12 feet, tonnage unknown ......................                 280
Sailing vessels:
     Coastwise, draft about 20 feet, tonnage unknown......................                 191
     Coastwise, draft 12 to 18 feet, under 1,000 tons ...       ..................         536
     Coastwise, draft 6 to 12 feet, under 1,000 tons .......................            7, 244
     Barges, 15 to 29 feet, tonnage unknown..............................                  268
Number of passengers landing and departing by water ...................            1, 581, 991
976         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                              A II.

                    IMPROVEMENT OF SACO RIVER, MAINE.

   There were no operations during the year, and no expenditures.
                          Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of improve-
  ment.--------------------------------------------------------$40,000
  m ent ................................................................. $40,000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.


                                      APPROPRIATIONS.

1824 (not mentioned in appropri-                  August 11, 1888.-..-.......-.... $10, 000
  ation acts)...................           $5,000 September 19, 1890--------.........----..  65,000
Appropriated 1827-1872 (see p.                    July 13, 1892................... 25, 000
  262, H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong.,                   August 18, 1894-.............-.- . 10, 000
  2d sess.)...................            169,275 June 3, 1896................... 10,000
July 5, 1884-.................... 15, 000 March 3, 1899................-...                   5, 000
                                        - 12, 500
August 5, 1886.....------------.........-....
August 5, 1886................. 12, 500                                                     351, 775
August 11, 1888------....---...- ....... 12, 500
  NOTE.-In 1867 $3.25 was carried to surplus fund.



                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                    Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                        Tons.
Coal..........-------------------..----------.............--------------...           42, 986
                                                                            -----
General merchandise------------......................................................     288
Sand-....................----.........----------..--------------...........               800
       Total---------....------------......................---------------------------------. 44,074
          Arrivals and departures during calendar year ending December 31, 1908.

Steamers, average draft about 9 feet ......................     ................   2
Sailing vessels, average draft about 9 feet ..................................    34
Number of passengers arriving and departing by water........................ 10, 500


                                              A   12.

         IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT CAPE PORPOISE, MAINE.

   The excavation of submerged ledge to widen and straighten the
outer entrance channel was continued, under contract, until Decem-
ber 4, 1908, when the work was completed. At the beginning of the
year about 80 per cent of the area had been drilled and blasted. Dur-
ing the year the blasting was finished and the loosened material
removed. The total quantity of excavation was 3,999 cubic yards,
measured in place, and the price was $9.60 per cubic yard. A straight
entrance channel about 190 feet wide and 18 feet deep at mean low
tide has been secured.
   Expenditures during the fiscal year 1909 amounted to $42,129.37.
                         APPENDIX A-REPORT OF LIEUT.                                          COL. ZINN.                            977
                                                      APPROPRIATIONS.
March 3, 1899--------------------------------------------------...--..                                     $70, 000
June 6, 1900........................................------------------------------------------------------  10, 000
March 2, 1907...........................---------------------------------------------------- 46, 000

                          ----------------------------------------------------
          Total..................................                                                                                126,000



                                                 CONTRACT IN                  FORCE.

  Eastern Dredging Company.
  For excavating about 4,200 cubic yards submerged ledge.
  Price $9.60 per cubic yard, measured in place.
  Approved October 10, 1907; to be commenced by November 3, 1907, and completed
by October 28, 1908 (waived).
  Contract completed.


                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.                                "

    No statistics were obtained.


                                                                  A 13.

           IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT ISLES OF SHOALS, MAINE.

    There were no operations during the year, and no expenditures.
                                                      APPROPRIATIONS.
March 3, 1821...........--------------...................--------------------------.............---...--------.......---....      $2, 500
May 7, 1822.........-------------------------------...........-------...............----------.....--...............------....    11, 500
June 13, 1902..........--------------....--------........------...........--------........---------..........--------......       30, 000
          Total-----.....-----...........------------------------------------.........--------.....                              44, 000
    NOTE.--Amount carried to surplus fund, $748.39.



                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                   Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                                                                   Tons.
Canned goods--------------..............---------.......------.....------.......................---------....-.....------              5
Cement....................-------------------.------....------------------------------------........................................  25
Coal..............................-----------............-------..........-----..........----....-----....-------.                   50----------
Fish---....------..---------...............--------------------------------                                                          515
Flour---...................---------------------------.....................                                                          100
General merchandise......................--------......----------.------....----..----.......--.---........------                     25
Ice----......................------..........----...--------------.........                                                          500
Lumber-......-----------------------------------------.....................................................------------------.......  38
Provisions---................................-----------------............-                                                          300
Salt---...................---------------------.----.................................................                                200

          Total.......-----------------------..................-------------------------------. 2, 208
              Arrivals and departuresduring calendar year ending December 31, 1908.

Steam vessels, average draft 8 feet-........................................                                                          250
Sailing vessels, average draft 8 feet...----------- ---.                     - ----....--..--------.                                  800
Number of passengers landing and departing by water .......................                                                        9, 000
       9001-ENG 1909-       62
978               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                     A      14.

              IMPROVEMENT OF COCHECO RIVER, NEW HAMPSHIRE.

    There were no operations during the year and no expenditures.
                                                        APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriated to include August 11, 1888 (see p. 286, H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong.,
  2d sess.) ..............................................................................                             $170, 060
September 19, 1890.................................................                                                      25, 000
July 13, 1892...........................................................                                                 15, 000
August 18, 1894............................                                ........-..................                   15, 000
June 3, 1896-------..----..                                                                        ---------------
                            ..-----------........--....----.......................-----------...........                 15, 000
March 3, 1899...............                      .....            ..............................                   ..   20, 000
June 13, 1902....................................................                                                        30, 000
March 3, 1905 ....................                      . .........               ...........          . ..........      21, 711

           Total.............                            ..       ....................................                                   311, 771


                                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                       Receipts and shipments.
                                                                                                                                            Tons.
Cement, bricks, and clay.......................                                                                                               58, 000
                                                                                                                          ..........................
Coal .........................................................................                                                                50,000
General merchandise---------.................................................                                                                       538
Hay and straw..........................................                                                      .................                      300
Ice..........             ............            ...........               ............        .....................                           1,000
Lim e...........                 .... .. .................-----....                        ..........           ...............-                     75
Lumber.......................................................................                                                                 30, 000
                                                                 -------------------
Provisions-------..---..........................................................-------------                                                       295
Sand and stone .............                             ...........................................                                          20, 200
Wood .........                 ...................................................                                                              9,000
           Total.................                               ...................................                                       169,408
              Arrivals and departures during calendar year ending December 31, 1908.

Steam vessels, average draft 102 feet .........................................                                                                  115
Sailing vessels, average draft 102 feet.......................                                                  .............                    125


                                                                      A 15.

        HARBOR OF REFUGE AT LITTLE HARBOR, NEW HAMPSHIRE.

  There were no operations during the fiscal year and no expendi-
tures.
                                                         APPROPRIATIONS.

August 5, 1886... .............       $10, 000                               June 3, 1896 ...................                             $10, 000
August 11, 1888-.....-.......... 20, 000                                     March 3, 1899 ................                                12, 000
September 19, 1890 ............        40, 000                               June 13, 1902 ..................                              13, 000
July 13, 1892...................       30, 000
August 18, 1894...........      .....  10, 000                                           Total ...................                        145, 000


                                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

   There is no commerce. The vessels entering the harbor for refuge during 1908 are
reported as 6 coasters, 14 sailing yachts, 64 sloop yachts and fishing vessels, 3 tug-
boats, and 11 steam yachts. The average draft is given as 8 feet.
              APPENDIX A-REPORT OF LIEUT.             COL. ZINN.   979
                                     A i6.

REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDANGER-
                     ING NAVIGATION.

   The schooner Annie L. Henderson was a wooden vessel 140 feet
long, 32.9 feet wide, and 12.6 feet deep, built at Camden, Me., in 1880.
September 1, 1906, when nearly discharged of a cargo of coal at
Bangor, Me., the vessel caught fire and finally sank in about 15 feet
of water at mean low tide and burned to the water's edge.
   Being an obstruction to navigation, an allotment of $1,500 for
removal of the wreck was made August 7, 1908.
   A contract has been made for removal of the wreck, and the work
is expected to be done during July, 1909.
   The schooner J. H. G. Perkins was a small wooden vessel, 72 feet
long, 19.9 feet wide, and 7 feet deep, built in 1867. On October 3,
1908, it went ashore at the entrance to Cape Porpoise Harbor and
afterwards shifted into the entrance channel. The wreck was re-
moved in December, 1908. The cost was $54.65.


                           CONTRACT IN       FORCE.

  James F. Spellman & Sons, of Bangor, Me.
  For removing wreck of schooner Annie L. Henderson.
  Price, $937.50.
  Approved November 16, 1908; to be completed by July 26, 1909.
                              APPENDIX B.


IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE 
   BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS, DISTRICT.



REPORT OF LIE UT. COL. ED W. BURR, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, OFFICER
    IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.

                                 IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Harbor at Newburyport, Massachu-       10. Dorchester    Bay    and  Neponset
     setts.                                     River, Massachusetts.
2. Merrimac River, Massachusetts.         11. Weymouth River, Massachusetts.
3. Essex River, Massachusetts.            12. Harbor     at Hingham,    Massachu-
4. Harbor of refuge at Sandy Bay, Cape          setts.
     Ann, Massachusetts.                  13. Harbors at Plymouth and Province-
5. Harbor at Gloucester, Massachusetts.         town, Massachusetts.
6. Harbor at Beverly, Massachusetts.      14. Harbor at Burlington, Vermont.
7. Harbor at Lynn, Massachusetts.         15. Narrows of Lake Champlain, New
8. Mystic and Malden rivers and Mystic          York and Vermont.
     River below the mouth of Island      16. Removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
     End River, Massachusetts.                  structing or endangering naviga-
9. Harbor at Boston, Massachusetts.             tion.


                              UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                      Boston, Mass., July 8, 1909.
  SIR: I have the honor to transmit herewith annual reports on works
of river and harbor improvement in my charge for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                           EDW. BURR,
                                          Lieut. Col., Corps of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                     B i.

  IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT NEWBURYPORT, MASSACHUSETTS.
   There were deposited during the fiscal year 11,961 tons of rubble-
stone, of which 1,133 tons were for maintenance, used in retopping
the outer end of the north jetty, and 10,828 tons for the extension of
that jetty seaward.
   Of this stone 7,462 tons were deposited by Philip H. Doyen in com-
pletion of his contract of March 18, 1907. Under a supplemental
agreement dated August 14, 1908, the Breakwater Company depos-
ited 4,499 tons of stone in partial compensation to the United States
                                                                        981
982                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                  U.     S. ARMY.

for the loss and damage sustained through the failure of the Break-
water Construction and Engineering Company to complete its con-
tract dated May 1, 1906.
      The work under the three contracts above named was completed
on September 26, 1908, embracing the deposit (in 1907, 1908, and
1909) of 28,125 tons of rubblestone, with which 400 linear feet of the
north jetty was retopped, and that jetty extended 163 feet seaward.

                                                             Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of
improvement.. ...........................................               $75, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.,


                                                                                     APPROPRIATIONS.

June 14, 1880..............                                                   $50, 000. 00         June 3, 1896 ................ $16, 000. 00
March 3, 1881...........                                       ....              40, 000. 00       March 3, 1899................ 25, 000. 00
August 2, 1882...............                                                    40, 000. 00       June 13, 1902 ...............  30, 000. 00
July 5, 1884...............                                                      40, 000. 00       March 3, 1905................ 30, 000. 00
August 5, 1886_..............                                                    37, 500. 00       Damages recovered from fail-
August 11, 1888..............                                                    25, 000.00          ing contractor.............      795. 31
September 19, 1890 .........                                                     25, 000. 00
July 13, 1892................                                                    20, 000. 00             Total................. 399, 295. 31
August 18, 1894..............                                                    20, 000. 00



                                                                          CONTRACTS                IN FORCE.

   Contractor: Philip H. Doyen, South Portland, Me.
   Date of contract: March 18, 1907.
   Date of approval: April 2, 1907.
   Date of commencement: On or before June 1, 1907.
   Date of completion: On or before October 31, 1907. (Time limit waived.)
   For 21,600 tons rubblestone in north jetty at Newburyport Harbor, Massachusetts,
at $1.25 per ton of 2,000 pounds.
   Contractor: The Breakwater Company, of Ohio.
   Date of supplemental agreement: August 14, 1908.
   Date of approval: September 21, 1908.
   Date of completion: November 30, 1908.
   For 4,499 tons of rubblestone in north jetty, Newburyport Harbor, Massachusetts, in
partial compensation to United States for loss sustained through the failure of the
Breakwater Construction and Engineering Company to fulfill its contract dated May
1, 1906.


                                                                            COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.


                                                       Articles.                                               1905.          1906.         1907.          1908.
                                                                                                           I             I              I              I



                                                                                                                Tons.      Tons.            Tons.          Tons.
Coal...............                 .   ..........................................                             165,048    168, 049          206,971        247,802
Molasses...--.................................................---                                                               90                67           360
Petroleum products......                                      ..........................                           78....   1,836             2, 858         3,077
Pulp wood .....                              ......                  ...........................                   785 ........
                                                                                                                         I              I


           Total.................                                         ......................               165,833        169,975       209,896        251,239


  Of this freight, 112,393 tons coal, mostly in lighters, and 1,447 tons petroleum prod-
ucts were reshipped to points on Merrimac and Powow rivers in 1908.
                               APPENDIX B -REPORT                                         OF LIEUT. COL. BURR.                                            983
                                                                                   B        2.

                IMPROVEMENT OF MERRIMAC RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

  The removal of bowlders in the improved channel below Rocks
bridge was commenced just prior to the close of the fiscal year, with
plant hired under the contract with Nathaniel E. Gordon. Ex-
penditures shown in the money statement were for engineering
expenses including a study of hydraulic conditions of the river.
                                                  Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
  of improvement .....................................................    $10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.




                                                                   APPROPRIATIONS.
1828-1896 a...----------------------------------.............................                              ------- $255, 366. 72
March 3, 1899-----................-----------------..------.......................------------.....----------.......   40, 000. 00
June 13, 1902--------------------------------------------------....................................................... 40, 000. 00
March 3, 1905-........---------.........--------------..--..........-------.........-----.....------------..........   40, 000. 00
March 3, 1909b -------.....--------..-------......---.....................--------------...-............               10, 000. 00
Sale of government property-------....------...............------------.....--.....--------.........---                        . 10
             Total........----------------------------.....------.....------.....-------.....                                                       385, 366. 82

    NOTE.-In 1835 $900 was carried to surplus fund.



                                                              CONTRACT IN FORCE.

    Contractor: Nathaniel E. Gordon, of South Portland, Me.
    Date of contract: May 27, 1909.
    Date of commencement: Within 15 days after signature.
    Date of completion: October 15, 1909.
    For hire of plant for removal of bowlders at $36.50 per day.



                                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                                     Above Newburyport.

                                              Articles.                                                          1905.          1906.       1907.        1908.


                                                                                                                   Tons.       Tons.        Tons.        Tons.
Coal ......................               ......................                  .............                    87,539       68,827       96,910      112,393
Stone......----...----------------------------------.........---------------5,.............................................      5,000 ..........
Petroleum products........                          ............--..                   ..........             ...........-    . ..-- .         1,532       1, 447
Pulp wood..--.                                   -785                                                                         ............................
          Total..........................                      .........      ................                   88,324         73,827       98,442      113,840

   a For itemized statement, see House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second session, p. 268.
   bAllotment March 30, 1909, from general act.
984              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                              U.    S. ARMY.


                                                                B 3.
                  IMPROVEMENT OF ESSEX RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

  Under the contract with the Bay State Dredging Company, 10,355
cubic yards of sand, mud, and peat, and 5.69 cubic yards of bowlders
were dredged between March 18 and June 30, 1909, in the removal of
shoals in the improved channel.


                                                   APPROPRIATIONS.
July 13, 1892..-.......          .. ................. ..................... ..........                                      $5, 000
August 18, 1894----------.....------....---...............---------------..................---------....--------........     5, 000
June 3, 1896--------................----------------------------......-------------.........----..........                   5, 000
March 3, 1899.............---------------------....------......-------...........---------.......................--------   10,000
March 2, 1907..---..--..--------..--......----------............---------....----------......-.........---------..           5, 000

          Total...............------------....................---------------------------------------                       30,000



                                               CONTRACT IN                 FORCE.

   Contractor: Bay State Dredging Company, of Boston, Mass.
   Date of contract: December 28, 1908.
   Date of approval: January 26, 1909.
   Date of commencement: May 1, 1909.
   Date of completion: September 30, 1909.
   To dredge 30,000 cubic yards, at 382 cents per cubic yard.



                                            COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The principal industry of Essex, and the only one interested in the improvement of
the river, is vessel building. About 30 fishing schooners are built annually on the
river, each of about 125 tons register, at an average cost of $12,000.



                                                                B 4.
IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR OF REFUGE AT SANDY BAY, CAPE ANN,
                    MASSACHUSETTS.

   Between July 1 and November 25, 1908, there were deposited in
the substructure of the breakwater 83,382 tons of rubblestone,
completing the deposit of 300,000 tons under the contract of June 21,
1905, with the Federal Contracting Company. The stone was
deposited in the western arm of the breakwater, completing under
this contract 750 linear feet of substructure to the full cross section
prescribed.
  Under the contract with the Rockport Granite Company and
Pigeon Hill Granite Company, the superstructure on the southern
arm of the breakwater was commenced at a point 200 feet south of
the angle and was completed for a distance of 97 feet, extending in a
northerly direction toward the junction with the western arm.
                              APPENDIX B--REPORT OF LIEUT.                                                          COL. BURR.                    985
                                                 Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of improve-
ment..----------........................................................... $500, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.


                                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.

July 5, 1884 ..................                    $100, 000                             March 3, 1905..................     $100, 000
August 5, 1886...........             ......         100, 000                            June 30, 1906....-...........        100, 000
August 11, 1888------.....                     --.. 100, 000                             March 2, 1907.................       100, 000
September 19, 1890-..-..-..... 150, 000                                                  May 27, 1908----................---   25, 000
July 13, 1892...... .........-                       150, 000                            March 4, 1909-.................       75, 000
August 18, 1894................
                       -150.                              000                            Receipts from sales...........              1
June 3, 1896........----      .......-------------150, 000
March 3, 1899---                                     250, 000
                                     --..................                                             Total.................. 1, 750, 001
June 13, 1902................--------------.- 200, 000



                                                           CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

   Contractor: The Federal Contracting Company, of New York, N. Y.
   Date of contract: June 21, 1905.
   Date of approval: July 12, 1905.
   Date of commencement: Within thirty days after notification of approval.
  Date of completion: On or before June 30, 1907.
  For construction of breakwater: 300,000 tons of rubblestone, at 60 cents per ton
of 2,000 pounds.
  Contractor: Rockport Granite Company and Pigeon Hill Granite Company, Rock-
port, Mass.
     For construction of about 400 feet of breakwater superstructure.

                                                                                                                            Original       Supplemental
                                                                                                                            contract.        contract.

Date of contract...................---------------------------------------------........................................   May 9,1908      June 11,1909
Date of approval ..............................................---------------------------------------------....           May 19,1908     June 16, 1909
Date of commencement --------....................----------------------......................------.....                    In 20 days. Immediately.
Date for completion.................................. ..........                                           ............    Oct. 31,1909    Oct. 31,1910
Prices per ton of 2,000 pounds:
    Capstones.............................                                                                                        $7. 43          $7. 43
      Wall stones...------------------------------------------.......-----------                                                   5.88            5. 79
      Rubblestone in superstructure ---.........----------............----------------....---------- 1.98                                          1.98
      Rubblestone in substructure and apron ..............................................                                                         2.25
         Total amount of contract (estimated) ..............................                                                       $180,000. 00

  Supplemental contract, with above-named contractors, dated March 30, 1909,
approved April 27, 1909, for two concrete blocks at angle of superstructure of break-
water, 91 cubic yards at $14.50.


                                                                                 B 5.
       IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT GLOUCESTER, MASSACHUSETTS.

   In maintenance of the Dog Bar breakwater, 12 capstones were
reset in December, 1908. A survey of Round Rock shoal and of the
site for the extension of the breakwater was made in the fall of 1908.
986                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                               APPROPRIATIONS.
1823-1892a. ........            ....... $86, 000                                      April 28, 1904................. $100, 000
August 18, 1894. ......--.....           40, 000                                      March 3, 1905..................   50, 000
June 3, 1896................... 34, 000                                               June 30, 1906 .................   17, 083
March 3, 1899..................          40, 000
June 13, 1902. ................          75, 000                                               Total ..................                         502, 083
March 3, 1903......... . .....           60, 000


                                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.


                                           Articles.                                                 1904.        1906.           1907.           1908.


                                                                                                 Tons.   Tons.                    Tons.           Tons.
Coal ................................                                                          . 110,000 70,720
                                                                                 .......................                           64,238          48,932
Lumber .............................................. 12,000                                              22,258                    1,910           2,117
Brick--..... ..                     ....-......... .....                   -.........  .......     1,000     403                      500             800
Stone, sand, and gravel....................................                                        6,550   5,233                      272             437
Oil......................                           ...........................                    2,000   3,585                      407             527
Iron.......................................................                                       10,563     243                      183             250
Salt.............             .............................................                       34,385  51.172                  44,250           32,702
Fish and fishproducts........................................                                     51,765 107,784                  96,839           96,771
Wood...................... ........................                                                3,963   7,215                    4,462           3,512
Lime and cement .......................................                                               1,300               6................
Ice..........................................................325                                                                       781 ....
Fertilizer.................................................  ............... 860 209 764
Tar ....                                                    .................200
                                     .....................................................
                                                                                 750 250
Fishhooks......         ............... ..                    ..............................                          38 ..
Miscellaneous .........        ...........................................                           30,000       25,846    18,715                 22,012
         Total.........................................                                            263,526       275,888         233,516          209,074
Passengers carried................                         ........................                  85,000       80,000           80,000          80,000


                                                                                B 6.

          IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT BEVERLY, MASSACHUSETTS.

No work was done during the fiscal year. A contract has been
made for rock excavation to obtain the authorized channel dimensions.


                                                               APPROPRIATIONS.
June 13, 1902 ................................................                                                              ....... $10, 000. 00
March 2,1.907.......................................................38,                                                                  500. 00
Damages from surety of failing contractor ...............                                                        ................        122. 24

            Total......................................................                                                                       48, 622. 24



                                                          CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contractor: Johnston & Virden, Lewes, Del.
  Date of contract: October 1.4, 1908.
  Date of approval: October 26, 1908.
  Date of commencement: December 1, 1908.
  Date of completion: November 30, 1909.
  For rock excavation in Beverly Harbor, Mass., 581.5 cubic yards, at $11.47 per
cubic yard.

  a Authority: House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second session, page
267. No record is found of the expenditure of $6,000 appropriation of March 3, 1823.
                               APPENDIX B-REPORI                                      OF LIEUT. COL. BURR.                                                 987
                                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.


                                            Articles.                                                    1905.               1906.          1907.        1908.


                                                                                                         Tons.                Tons.         Tons.      Tons.
Coal ................................................                                                   108, 444             100, 613      119, 016    137, 256
Lumber .....................................                                         ......... ......     6,245                4,166         6, 139      4, 461
Oil ............................................................                                         32, 659              32, 288       47, 100     77, 487
Sand.............................................                                                         1,000                1,295         1,747       1,165
Stone.....                            ......................................................                                                 3, 420      1,200
Iron.........................................................                                                914                 500            197         867
Asphaltum. .....                        ..... ...... ...... ...........................                      600 ..             ......          800         792
Tar...                .............................................                                       ................                   1,015          500
Piles ...                  ................................................................                                                     144 ..
Miscellaneous .................................................                                              200 ....................                       205
             Total...................                                      ............... 150, 062                          138, 862      179, 578       223, 933

                                                                                B 7.

                     IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT LYNN, MASSACHUSETTS.

  No work was done, and none required, in the maintenance of the
improvement. The expenditure shown in the money statement was
for dredging completed during the preceding fiscal year.
                                                                APPROPRIATIONS.

1882-1896 a-...........................................................                                                                                $128, 500
June 13, 1902 ......................................................                                                                                     25, 000
March 3, 1905- -......... ........ .........                            ....                    ...... ........                  ............            40, 000
June 30, 1906...................................................                                                                          ......         97, 937
                Total............................................................                                                                       291, 437


                                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                            Articles.                                                    1905.               1906.          1907.        1908.


                                                                                                         Tons.                Tons.         Tons.        Tons.
Coal--............... .........................................                                         253, 421             276,108       316, 422      285, 818
Lumber.....................................................                                               3, 805               5, 585        3, 455        2, 994
Stone........................................................                                                271
Sand......................................................                                                8, 016              10, 978         9, 000       6,016
Oil......................                                                                                                                                  3, 534
Leather, shoes, groceries, and general merchandise .........                                             90, 648              51,113        37, 450       55, 000
            Total.........--........                    ---.......................                      356,161              343,784       366, 327      353, 362
Passengers carried between Lynn and Nahant.................                                             224, 890             143,581      183, 450       189, 969


                                                                                B     8.

IMPROVEMENT OF MYSTIC AND MALDEN RIVERS AND MYSTIC RIVER
   BELOW THE MOUTH OF ISLAND END RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

                                                              (A)      MYSTIC RIVER.

No work was done, and none required, upon the channel completed
November 1, 1906, in the Mystic River above the Boston and Maine
Railroad (western division) bridge.
  a For itemized statement, see House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress,
second session, page 267.
988                REPORT               OF THE          CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                 U.    S.    ARMY.


                                                Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
   of improvement...............................-------------------------------------------...---.                                   $10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                       (B)         MALDEN                RIVER.

       The Bay State Dredging Company, between June 30 and July 23,
1908, dredged 4,857 cubic yards of sand and mud, completing their
contract of May 23, 1908, for restoring to the full projected depth
and width the improved channel from Medford Street Bridge for a
distance of about 3,600 feet downstream. At the close of the fiscal
year a survey has just been completed to determine the condition
of the improved channel.
                                            Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exelusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
  of improvement----...---------...........------------.............---------..---...............---------...... $10, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


 (c)    MYSTIC RIVER BELOW                                   MOUTH OF ISLAND END RIVER,                                       MASSACHU-
                                                                              SETTS.


    Dredging operations for the completion of the 25-foot channel
below Chelsea Bridge were suspended during the fiscal year, the con-
tractor's plant being engaged under the same contract in dredging,
.in a different locality, the 35-foot channel of Boston Harbor.
                                                             APPROPRIATIONS.


                                                                                                                         Mystic
                                                                                          Mystic        Mald            River be-
                                      Act of-                                            River (up-     Rivenr.        low mouth         Total.
                                                                                           per).                        of Island
                                                                                                                       End River.


August 2, 1882-..--                    -    _                ----.       ----          .-. .- $10,000. 00                10,000.00
                                                                                                                        $....
July 13, 1892..----------------------------------                                $5,000.00                ............ 10,000. 00
                                                                                                5,000. 00----
August 18,1894---...............------------------------------                    5,000.00      5,000.00 ............ 10,000.00
June 3, 1896. .......-       .. ......    ................ ...                    5,000. 00     5,000.00 ----....
                                                                                                                ... .. 10,000.00
March 3, 1899 ....--------.         -------------------------- 2,500. 00                        2,500. 00 -.....-..-      5,000. 00
    Do              --------------------------------------------------------....                            50, 000. 00  50,000. 00
June 6, 1900 (emergency act)a.... ...........-----------           ..--... .......------...--.  5,000.00 ..........       5,000.00
June 13, 1902-------....-..-----..-..---------..............------------          1,000.00      5,000.00    19,000.00    25,000.00
March 3, 1905 .....................                            ............               10, 494. 88   12,500. 00      27,005. 12       50,000.00
March 2, 1907 . .............               ........          ............                b 8,000.00    12,000. 00      40,000.00        60, 000.00
        Total......-...............                          ..............               36,994.88     62,000.00      136,005.12       235,000.00

           a Allotment of July 19, 1900.                                      b Reserved in Treasury, not yet formally allotted.




                                                       CONTRACTS                    IN     FORCE.

   Contractor: Bay State Dredging Company, Boston, Mass.
   Date of contract: May 23, 1908.
   Date of approval: June 5, 1908.
                                   APPENDIX B--REPORT OF LIEUT.                                                                       COL. BURR.                                           989
   Date of commencement: Within ten days from notification (June 8, 1908) of ap-
proval.
   Date of completion: Within four months from commencement (expires October
18, 1908).
  For dredging 22,000 cubic yards, more or less, from Malden River, at 491 cents
per cubic yard.
   Contract completed July 23, 1908.
   Contractor: G. H. Breymann & Bros., Toledo, Ohio.
   Date of contract: July 17, 1907.
   Date of approval: August 20, 1907.
   Date of commencement: October 1, 1907.
   Date of completion: December 31, 1911.
   For dredging 120,000 cubic yards, more or less, at 22 cents per cubic yard, below
Chelsea Bridge, in conjunction with the dredging of 35-foot channel, Boston Harbor.


                                                                         COMMERCIAL SI'ATISTICS.

                                                   Mystic River above Western Division Bridge.

                                                     Articles.                                                                    1905.               1906.            1907.             1908.


                                                                                                                                  Tons.        Tons.          Tons.       Tons.
Coal...............................................................                                                               30,745        17,500          23,291     18,229
Stone.... .............                       .. ......         ..............................                                       348 ..........                 500 .
Iron . .............................................................                                                                 251 . ........................
           Total...................................................                                                               31,344              17,500           23,791              18,229


                                                                                       Malden River.

Coal    ...                            ......................................                                                     78,000 78,075                        76,920              61,775
Molding sand                     .........................................                                                          600--
Iron and steel ........................                                                                                               550
                                                                                                                                      550.................................
                                                                                                                                                  .       ...                   .   ........
Kaolin......................................................                                                                          440 .                   ..........
Hides and barks..............................................                                                                         100 .
Sand...............................                                                                                                         ...       12,74011, 655                            6,447
Tar oil...                   ...............................................                                                            ...         ...               ....                     1,200
           Total ..............                                      ...........................                                  79, 690             90,815           88, 575             69,422


                                                                                        Mystic River.
                                                [Commerce using 25-foot channel below Island End River.]


Coal...................                                         .......................                                   2,338, 940 2,682, 496 2,729,310 2,600,368
Lumber........                       .............................................                                          107, 621    202, 868   266, 815 238,743
Sand.................................................                                                                            750       52,740   17,361    9,621
Stone......................................................                                                                   1,628        38, 808   1,540   80,500
Grain......                   .....................................                                                          10,264        70,456   87,241   52,730
Cotton............                      ............................................                                        114, 497       77,145   74, 621 117, 850
Iron...........                         .         ...................................                                            801       16,002       180  15,995
Steel.......................................................                                                                              11,580     6,775        34
Oil....             ...........................................                                                       ...     5, 100        2,500    4,046   10,689
Chemicals and minerals .....                                                ..... ...............                             1,483
                                                                                                                              1......          962   2, 698      935
Brimstone................................                                                        ............                 2, 740 .........       3,478    2,631
Coal tar and products ........                                      ..........................                                6, 900       14, 925  17, 688  13,066
Logs.         .....                 ..........                         ..........................                            35,915        41,858   33,470   17,033
Cinder ...                           ....        .....................................                                       14,500        13,876   13,889   12,949
Wood....                        ..........................................                                                       250       16,585       860   1,153
Fertilizers.................                                              ........................                           49,393       47,842             39,240
Pulp wood....                            ..............................................                                                               21,246             4,470             11,456
Lime ...               ..................................................                                                                     ..          7,447         5,764                  4,289
Cement ....                    ...........................................                                                  ...         .                 5,864            28       .
Salt..               ...            ..............................................                                                                    30,490             3,340                 8,930
Plaster rock............................................                                                                           3,960                  3,804 .............
Hay................................................                                                              .......    ......            ...         3,110          1,865                 1,806
Piles.....7.....                           .           ..................                                                  ....................                          4,772                 3,579
Sugar...-...                         ........                .................................................                                                                                   250
Coke ...  ..........                                                                                                                                                                       4 0,404
                                                                                                                                                                                               4...........................
Miscellaneous.........................................                                                                        580,070               345,213           466, 252            351,554
           Total...................                                              ....................                      3,274,812 3,707,817 3,746,463                                3,715,805
Passengers carried ...................                                               ..................                            1,790                  7,067          9,186                 4,212
990                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                     B 9.
             IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS.
                                                THIRTY-FIVE-FOOT CHANNEL.
                                                           Progress of work.
                                 Work done in fiscal year 1909.                               All work to June 30, 1909.

                                                   Dredging.            Bowlders.                       Bowl-
         Division.                   Section.    Cubic        PriceCubic        Pri         cubic       cu          Remarks.
                                                yards.       Price.   yards.       ice.    yards.       yards.
                                                           Cents.
 ................... --
1--                                        1        83,166  20.0 ................          1,909,394..
                                           la       38,056  39.0 ................            583,082 .--....--.
  ..--.....-
2--                     ........           2        20,942  23.4 ................          1,898,880      11. 310   Completed.
                                           2a       13,519  40.0 ................            499,673 .
3 ...................                      3
                                           3a
                                                    30,307
                                                    52,418
                                                            23.5 ................
                                                            39.0 .---.- ----          _-
                                                                                           1,691,126 .
                                                                                             445,426      56.378
4 ...................                      4  ....    ....                         ----........
                                                            23.9 -----------........
                                                                                   ---- 1,878,636           7.332   Completed.
                                           4a       29,015  39.7     5.430          $12      453,908 31.870
5-----------------...................      5       729,828 22.0 ................             729,828 . ....--
                                       1   5a      242,270  40.0 .------......-----.....     331,453 ..
6-----------------...................      6       848,525 22.0 ................1,018,490..
                                       S   6a      168,458  40.0  ....---------........      168,458 .
7 --..................                f    7       814,979 22.0 ................           1,162,160. .. .
                                         1 7a      176,958  40.0 ................            176,958
8...................-J 8                            28,348  22.0 ................ 388,927 .
                                           8a      131,661   40.0 ................           131,661 ..
           Total..................              3,408,450 ........     5.430 ........     13, 468,060   106.890

  NOTE.-Sections 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 are above President Roads; sections la, 2a,
3a, 4a, 5a, 6a, 7a, and 8a are in Broad Sound.
      Under the contract of April 26, 1905, for excavating to the depth
of 35 feet at mean low water 16,555 cubic yards, embracing an area
of 2.7 acres of ledge rock in the upper main ship channel off Gov-
ernors Island, G. H. Breymann & Bros. removed 49 cubic yards
(scow measurement) of broken rock in reducing small points of
ledge projecting above the required grade, completing the contract
on August 28, 1908.
   Under the contract of July 11, 1907, for excavating nine groups
of ledges, amounting to 15,195 cubic yards, more or less, situ measure-
ment, drilling was commenced August 6, 1907, and to this date the
contractors, G. H. Breymann & Bros., have removed six groups of
ledges aggregating 12,185 cubic yards, situ measurement, and work
is in progress on the remaining three groups. The entire work to
be accomplished under this contract is approximately 98 per cent
completed.
                                                   TRIBUTARY CHANNELS.

    Charles River.-No work has been done on this improvement
during the fiscal year, for the reason that the terms embodied in the
item making the appropriation of $20,000 in the act of September 19,
1890, in respect to the rebuilding of certain bridges in the upper
Charles River by local authorities had not been complied with. This
appropriation was carried to the surplus fund pursuant to section 10
of the sundry civil act of March 4, 1909, and no further work in con-
nection with the improvement of the river is contemplated until
additional action is had by Congress through the appropriation of the
necessary funds, or otherwise. (See p. 64, Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for the current year.) From appropriations for
Boston Harbor $57,500 has been provided for this work, leaving
 $67,500 of the authorized cost of the project yet to be appropriated.
                    APPENDIX B--REPORT                     OF LIEUT.          COL. BURR.                       991
   Fort Point channel.--Under the contract with the Bay State
Dredging Company there were dredged 17,262 cubic yards of clay
and mud, in obtaining the channel dimensions authorized at the site
of the Mount Washington Avenue Bridge recently removed in com-
pliance with the order of the War Department.
                                         GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

                          Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
of improvement -...........................       .. ............... ..... . $75, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                       THIRTY-FIVE-FOOT          CHANNEL.

                                 Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of
improvement...................................-----------------------------------......---------.... $1, 200, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
June 4, 1897.

                                            APPROPRIATIONS.
March 2, 1825............      $52, 972. 56 June 18, 1878............         $55, 000. 00
March 19, 1828.........           2, 000. 00 March 3, 1879.............        50, 000. 00
May 23, 1828...........          87, 000. 00 June  14,  1880 ............      75, 000. 00
March 2, 1829_.........           7, 310. 54 March 3, 1881.............       100, 000. 00
March 2, 1831.............        5, 000. 00 August   2,  1882...-........     96, 500. 00
March 2, 1831.............       12, 390. 00 July 5, 1884-..............        5, 000. 00
February 24, 1832..               9, 000. 00 August 5, 1886....-.......        56, 250. 00
July 3, 1832...........          60, 000. 00 August   11,  1888...........    125, 000. 00
July 4, 1836..............       15, 000. 00 September 19, 1890 ......        145, 000. 00
July 7, 1838.............         7, 353. 00 July 13, 1892.............       300, 000. 00
March 3, 1841.............        1, 000. 00 August 18, 1894...........       200, 000. 00
March 3, 1841.............        1, 500. 00 June 3, 1896.............         70, 000. 00
August 31, 1842............       2, 000. 00 June 4, 1897.............        400, 000. 00
March 3, 1843.............       16, 000. 00 July 1, 1898..............       250, 000. 00
July 20, 1848_.............      40, 000. 00 March 3, 1899.............        75, 000. 00
August 30, 1852...........       30, 000. 00 March 3, 1899.........-...       163, 751. 00
July 2, 1864..............       40, 000. 00 June 6, 1900...--.........       317, 000. 00
July 2, 1864...............      10, 000. 00 March 3, 1901.............       133, 000. 00
February 28, 1865........         3,000.00 June 13, 1902............          100, 000. 00
February 28, 1.865........       20,000. 00 June 13, 1902 c ...........       600, 000. 00
June 12, 1866.............       50,000. 00 June 28, 1902 ............        175, 000. 00
June 12, 1866 ..........         75,000. 00 March 3, 1903 c ............      150, 000. 00
March 2, 1867.............     375, 000. 00 April 28, 1904...........         350, 000. 00
July 25, 1868 a............      43, 000. 00 March 3, 1905c ....... ..        970, 000. 00
April 10, 1869 a.........        82,170. 00 March 3, 1905.............        100, 000. 00
April 10, 1869 a...........      24, 750. 00 June 30, 1906 c ...........      600, 000. 00
July 11, 1870..........        100, 000. 00 March 2, 1907.............         50, 000. 00
March 3, 1871.............     100, 000. 00 March 2, 1907 c . .........       500, 000. 00
June 10, 1872 ............       75, 000. 00 March 4, 1907 c ..........       930, 000. 00
March 3, 1873.............      150,000. 00 March 4, 1909c ..........      1, 200, 000. 00
June 23, 1874.............      100,000. 00 Receipts from sales_......             193. 54
March 3, 1875 b ...........      90, 000. 00
August 14, 1876.......           50, 000. 00        Total.............. 10, 078, 140. 64
  NOTE.-From 1832 to 1872 $1,619.52 was carried to surplus fund; June 30, 1909,
$20,000 was carried to surplus fund.

    a Allotment. Date of allotments unknown.                                       c For 35-foot channels.
    b Excluding $10,000 allotted to Hingham Harbor.
992        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                              CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

                             THIRTY-FIVE-FOOT CHANNEL.

    Division 1.-Contract dated February 25, 1903: Breymann Brothers, of Toledo,
Ohio, contractors, to dredge 1,875,000 cubic yards, more or less, at 20 cents per cubic
yard, from section 1, and 570,000 cubic yards, more or less, at 39 cents per cubic yard,
from section la, total 2,445,000 cubic yards; approved March 12; to be commenced
by September 13, 1903; to be completed by December 31, 1907.
   Division 2.-Contract dated February 26, 1903: Morris & Cumings Dredging Com-
pany, of New York, N. Y., contractors, to dredge 1,875,000 cubic yards, more or less,
at 23.4 cents per cubic yard, from section 2, and 570,000 cubic yards, more or less,
at 40 cents per cubic yard, from section 2a, total 2,445,000 cubic yards; approved
March 12; to be commenced by September 13, 1903; to be completed by December
31, 1907.
   Division 3.-Contract dated February 25, 1903: George H. Breymann, of Toledo,
Ohio, contractor, to dredge 1,875,000 cubic yards, more or less, at 23.5 cents per cubic
yard, from section 3, and 570,000 cubic yards, more or less, at 39 cents per cubic yard,
from section 3a, total 2,445,000 cubic yards; approved March 12; to be commenced
by September 14, 1903; to be completed by December 31, 1907.
   Division 4.-Contract dated February 19, 1903: Eastern Dredging Company and
New England Dredging Company, of Boston, Mass., contractors, to dredge 1,875,000
cubic yards, more or less, at 23.9 cents per cubic yard, from section 4, and 570,000
cubic yards, more or less, at 39.7 cents per cubic yard, from section 4a, total 2,445,000
cubic yards; approved March 16; to be commenced by September 16, 1903; to be
completed by December 31, 1907.
   Divisions 5, 6, 7, and 8.-Contract dated July 17, 1907: G. H. Breymann & Bros.,
of Toledo, Ohio, contractors, to dredge 9,770,000 cubic yards, more or less, at 22 cents
per cubic yard, from sections 5, 6, 7, and 8, and 2,440,000 cubic yards, more or less,
at 40 cents per cubic yard, from sections 5a, 6a, 7a, and 8a, total 12,210,000 cubic
yards; approved August 20, 1907; to be commenced by October 1, 1907; to be com-
pleted by December 31, 1911.
   Contract dated July 11, 1907: G. H. Breymann & Bros., of Toledo, Ohio, contrac-
tors, to excavate 15,195 cubic yards, more or less, of ledge in Boston Harbor, Massa-
chusetts, at $21.74 per cubic yard situ measurement; approved July 22, 1907; to be
commenced thirty days after date of notification of approval; to be completed Decem-
ber 31, 1908.
   Contract dated April 26, 1905: G. H. Breymann & Bros., of Toledo, Ohio, contrac-
tors, to excavate 16,555 cubic yards of ledge in Boston Harbor, Massachusetts, at $16
per cubic yard situ measurement; approved June 2, 1905; to be commenced thirty
days after date of notice of approval; to be completed by December 31, 1906.
   Contract dated May 27, 1909: G. H. Breymann & Bros., of Toledo, Ohio, contractors,
to excavate 142.05 cubic feet of ledge in Boston Harbor, Massachusetts, for $1,950,
to be commenced within thirty days after signature; and to be completed on or before
August 15, 1909.
                                FORT POINT CHANNEL.


   Contract dated June 1, 1909: Bay State Dredging Company, of Boston, Mass., con-
tractors, to dredge 10,000 cubic yards from Fort Point channel, Boston Harbor, Massa-
chusetts. Price for dredging, 25.75 cents per cubic yard; for removing bowlders
weighing 3 tons or more each, $5 per cubic yard; to be commenced on or before June
15, 1909; to be completed on or before July 31, 1909.

                                     MISCELLANEOUS.


   Contract dated September 28, 1908: Trustees of Barristers Hall, Boston, Mass., con-
tractors, for rent of office rooms at Boston, Mass., at the rate of $250 per month; to be
commenced October 1, 1908; and to expire by limitation October 1, 1913.
   Contract dated December 10, 1908: Boston and Maine Railroad, Boston, Mass., con-
tractors, for rent of wharf at Boston, Mass., at the rate of $150 per month; to be com-
menced January 1, 1909, and to expire by limitation December 31, 1910, but may be
terminated by either party upon ninety days' notice in writing.
                          APPENDIX B-REPORT OF LIEUT.                                           COL. BURR.                           993
                                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statement concerning the foreign trade at the port of Boston is com-
piled from statistics and records of the Boston Chamber of Commerce and of the
collector of the port. It comprises only imports and exports and does not include
domestic, coastwise, and local traffic. Vessels engaged in the coastwise trade, unless
they have in their cargoes bonded merchandise to the value of $350 or more, are not
required by law to take out clearance papers, and no statistics of their carrying trade
are accessible.
                                                          FOREIGN TRADE.

    Comparative statement of quantity and value of exports and imports and of customs
                                        collected.


                                    Exports.                         Imports.                         Total.
       Year.                                                                                                                   Customs
                                                                                                                               collected.
                         Quantity.              Value.     Quantity.          Value.          Quantity.        Value.

                             Tons.                            Tons.                             Tons.
1867......................    $19,317,841...........                     $66,606,588$16,207,198.54
                                                    $47,288,747............
1903............        .....                                                                 75
                                                                         169,192,816 22,360,096
                          .....86,429,988.......... 82,762,828 ...........
1904.......................                                              174,135,076 23,102,087.97
                               87,866,428........... 86,268,648...........
1905..........            1,294,81593,797,887 974,712106,065,998                 26,208,144.20
                                                                       199,863,885
                                                               2,269,527
1906 ...........                            1,229,623110,333,970
                          1,365,78699,370,016                  2,595,409                 50
                                                                                 27,459,534.
                                                                       209,703,986
1907............ 1,337,019 104,610,9081,107,764 123,414,168 2,444,783 228,025,076 26,238,897.33
1908............ 1,064,445 84,353,536 979,976 89,121,981 2,044,421 173,475,517 22,562,253.32



   In addition, the in-transit and transshipment trade passing through the port of Bos-
ton (principally to and from Canada) amounted to $27,415,929, making the total
foreign trade through the port during the year 1908 $200,891,456, against $257,787,918
in 1907.
   The leading articles of import and export at the port of Boston for the calendar
years 1907 and 1908, with the value and quantity of each, were as follows:

                                                                  Exports.


                                                                                        1907.                             1908.

                                                                              Value.          Quantity.         Value.         Quantity.

                                                                                                Tons.                             Tons.
Meat and dairy products.........................                              $37,174, 166       200, 298      $28, 000, 150       150, 367
Breadstuffs...........                 ................           ......       12,306,374        615,268         8,341,912         476,139
Leather.................................                .......     ....       10,310, 089        22,840        11,775,278          30,467
Leather manufactures. ................                          ........        2, 069,934         1,627         1,972, 905             789
Animals............................................                            10, 593,892        89,814         8,769,338          67, 251
Cotton....................                         ........ ............       11,062, 874        47,189         6,172,488          29, 782
Cotton manufactures ..............................                              2,160, 957        11,575         2,321,964          12,448
Steel billets and rails...............................                             383, 027       15,201            327, 832        13, 710
Other iron and steel manufactures ............                             ..   5, 082,434      126,417          4,230, 995        106,166
Agricultural implements ...........................                                614, 987        5, 751           431, 008         3, 003
Rum.....................................                               ....     1,059,234          3,112         1,319,906           3,935
Wood.............                 ...................................              763,784        59,975            914,940         46,311
Wood manufactures ..............................                                1,131,737          7,314            762, 069         4,076
Paper, and manufactures ........................                     ......     1,000, 028        12,042            585, 016         4, 207
Rubber manufactures............................                                 1,128, 907         2, 656           637, 242         1,633
Apples ...........................................                                 796, 943       26, 810           648, 888        24, 046
Miscellaneous .....................................                             6,971,541       a89, 130         7,141,605        a 90,115
       Total.................................                              104, 610, 908       1,337, 019       84, 353, 536      1,064,445

                                                              a Approximate.
           9001-ENG 1909---63
994                  REPORT               OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                            S. ARMY.

                                                                          Imports.


                                                                                     1       1907.                                1908.


                                                                                   Value.            Quantity.           Value.           Quantity.

                                                                                                Tons.                                       Tons.
Wool ..............                    ....................                      $21,353,820      43,354             $13,645,642              36,700
Fibers and vegetable grasses ..................                                   10, 721, 509    73,567               8,421,683              82, 231
Fibers, and manufactures...................                                        7,929,906      44,602               5,300,500              37, 245
Hides and skins ..............                        ...............             14, 202, 574    32,218               8,926,103              30,778
Sugar...........................                            ...........            7,460,893     181, 586              7,992,874             175,662
Cotton........................                                    .........       16, 692, 701    42, 728             10,611,588              31,148
Cotton manufactures .......................                                        2,177,704       4,354               1,411,200               2,096
Chemicals, drugs, and dyes ..............                               ....       5,262,553      77, 700              3,896,711              56,442
Leather... ...............                                                         3,018,417       1,509               1,472,  967                734
Leather manufactures ......                         .............                     359,470          90                 227,764                 156
Iron and steel, and manufactures... ... .. .....                                   4,245,270      47,787               1, 377, 140            22, 895
Fruits and nuts.....---................ .. ....                                    2, 827, 515    84,286               2,362,555              86, 878
Fish ............             .............                     ..........         2,029,317      13,547               1,875,187              12,362
China and earthen ware-........ ..............                                        837, 539     2,094                  628, 696             1,572
Wood.               -.. .............................                              1, 228,201    247, 031                 963, 506           173, 268
Wood manufactures. .........................                                       1,519,579      26,336               1,611,253                30,835
India rubber, and manufactures...................                                  1,395,451       4,096                  502,411               2,213
Miscellaneous ............................                                        20,151,749   a 180, 879             17,894,201            a 196, 761
         Total....................                    ..............             123,414,168 1,107,764                   89,121,981            979,976

                                                                       a Approximate.

Passengers arriving from and departing for foreign countries by trans-Atlantic lines.

                                                                       Cabin passengers.                 Steerage passengers.
                           Year.                                                                                                               Total.
                                                            Inward. Outward.              Total.      Inward. Outward.            Total.


1902.......................................                       12,283        8,584     20,867        52,167       13, 815      65,982        86,849
1903............                  .................               15,511       10,544     26, 055       60,143       15, 547      75,690       101,745
1904 ................................                             13,604       10, 995    24,599        63,551       13,604       77,155       101,754
1905..........................                      ............. 15,092       10,758     25,850        57,184       18,672       75,856       101,706
1906........................                          ......... 18, 852        14,686     33,538        68,014       22,407       90,421       123,959
1907 ...............................                              19,479       12,639     32,118        71,813       27,163       98,976       131,094
1908...............................                               16, 296       9,946     26,242        31,654       31, 851      63,505        89, 747



  The steamer Arabic, of 15,801 tons and draft of 33 feet 10 inches, of the White Star
Line, Boston-Liverpool service, is the largest of the trans-Atlantic liners sailing from
this port.
                       Foreign entrances and clearances, 1908.

                                                          Entered from foreign              Cleared for foreign                       Total.
                                                                 ports.                           ports.
                          Class.

                                                         Number.            Tonnage.      Number.        Tonnage.         Number.         Tonnage.


American steam vessels .............                              77          170, 238          57         113,   301           134          283, 539
American sailing vessels.............                             40           12, 055          50          25,   936            90           37, 991
Foreign steam vessels...............                             946       2, 561,655          710      1, 812,   836        1, 656       4, 374, 491
Foreign sailing vessels............ ..                           292           57, 085         307          62,   825           599          119,910

          Total........................                        1, 355       2, 801,033        1,124      2, 014, 898          2, 479       4, 815, 931
                              APPENDIX B--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. BURR.                                                                    995
                                          Domestic and coastwise arrivalsand departures.

                                                                    Arrivals.                 Departures. a                    Total.

                         Class.
                                                            Number.           Gross       Number.         Gross      Number.         Gross
                                                                            tonnage.                    tonnage.                   tonnage.


Steamers............................    2,495                                5,792,960       2, 495     5,792,960        4,990      11,585,920
Sailing vessels .................... .. 1,164                                  924, 461      1, 164       924, 461       2, 328      1,848, 922
Tugs ...............................    2,119                                  747,200       2,119        747,200        4,238       1,494, 400
Barges...............................   3,337                                3,078,905       3,337      3,078,905        6,674       6,157,810
        Total..........................                           9,115     10,543,526       9,115     10,543,526       18,230     21,087,052

                                                                    a Approximate.

                                                                    Receipts of coal.
                                                                          [Gross tons.]


                                                                                        By sea.

                               Year.                                                                                 Total by      Total by
                                                                      Anthra-            Bitu-                         rail.       all routes.
                                                                       cite.            minous.


1904................................       1,961,785                                    2,948,268      4,910,053       158, 599      5,068,652
1905...............................        1,941,478                                    3,365,657      5,307,135        77,024       5,384,159
1906...................................... 1,630, 674                                   3,430,665      5,061, 339      116,256       5,177, 595
1907.......................................2,016,252                                    3,741,709      5,757,961       126,963       5,884,924
1908...................................    1,733, 112                                   3, 611, 271    5,344,383       105,656       5,450,039


                                                                      SUMMARY.

                                                                    Vessel movement.

                                                                  Foreign trade.             Domestic trade.                    Total.

                         Year.
                                                                Number.        Gross      Number.         Gross      Number.         Gross
                                                                             tonnage,                   tonnage.                   tonnage.


1902................................                              3,345      4,698,216       17,032    14,583,862       20,377      19,282,078
1903 ..............................                               2,973      5,119,468       18,632    16,839,578       21,605      21,959,046
1904................................                              2,688      4,800,868       17, 598   16,820,728       20,286      21,621, 596
1905 ...........................                                  2,904      4,980,410       18,132    17,874,916       21,036      22,855,326
1906.............................                                 2,966      5,395,119       17,286    18,549, 230      20,252      23,944, 349
1907 ..........                  ..................               2, 808     5, 148, 434     19,232    20, 522,948      22,040      25, 671, 382
1908...........................                     .........     2,479      4,815,931       18,230    21,087,052       20, 709     25,902,  983


                                          TRIBUTARY CHANNELS, BOSTON HARBOR.

                                                                     Charles River.
                                           [Above Cambridge Drawless Bridge (completed 1907).]
996                      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                          Fort Point channel.

                                              Articles.                                                       1905.              1906.              1907.            1908.

                                                                                                              Tons.              Tons.           Tons.               Tons.
Coal ..................................................                                                       964,162             928,967     1,069,998             1,007,694
Lumber........................................                                                                 74,358              80,503           75,575             28,417
Brick..............                                .....................               ....                    32,807              31,648           26,416              8, 055
Stone (granite)..............................                                          .....                   16,568               9,139           11,606              4,468
Sugar.           ----......              .........                 ----------........-                        141,500             165, 825        160, 000            145,000
Cotton ..........                       .......................                        ....                     2, 000              1,708 ...................
Wool...........................................................                                                 3, 300 ..
Steel..............................................                                                              1,080              1,490                 180..
Molasses.............................................                                                            4,650              3,571               4,700 .
Iron .................................................                                                           4,690              7,523               5,613           3,321
Oil...............................................--                       ...                .......           34,613             29,397                 200..
Salt.........                  ......            ..........................................                      8,800              7,420               1,000           2,500
Fish..............................................                                                           7,000                  7,802...................
Wood....................................................                                                     4,901                  4,628                5,521          4,805
Lime............................................................                                            16,785                 12,085              12,207           5,294
Cement...........................                                                     ..........            25,283                 22,779              24,618          11,726
Sand....                .......................................                                             33,133                 28,114              31,944          12,591
Gravel..................                                      ...................                             5,741                 7,415                7,508          5,552
Plaster...........................                            .......................                         1,232                    633                   363           445
Grindstones .......................................                                              .......................                                 1,527             630
Miscellaneous ........................................                                                      81, 311                66, 024               4, 710        10, 892
           Total ..........................................                                                  1,463,914       1,416,671           1,443,686          1,251,390

                                                                                              B Io.
IMPROVEMENT OF DORCHESTER BAY AND NEPONSET RIVER, MASSA-
                       CHUSETTS.
  Under the contract of May 13, 1908, Charles M. Cole dredged, dur-
ing the fiscal year, 301,306 cubic yards. The section of channel 100
feet wide and 15 feet deep at mean low water from Commercial Point
to the Neponset highway bridge was completed and the dredging of
the 18-foot section through the mouth of the river and in Dorchester
Bay was commenced.
                                                                              APPROPRIATION.

March 2, 1907..........................................................                                                                                            $125, 233
                                                                      CONTRACT                          IN   FORCE.

     Contractor: Charles M. Cole, Fall River, Mass.
     Date of contract: May 13, 1908.
     Date of approval: June 2, 1908.
     Date of commencement: Within thirty days from date of notification of approval.
  Date of completion: On or before December 31, 1909.
  For dredging about 455,000 cubic yards from Dorchester Bay and Neponset River at
17 cents per cubic yard.

                                                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                     Articles.                                                           1905.           1906.           1907.        1908.

                                                                                                                       Tons.            Tons.            Tons.        Tons.
Coal............-...--                         ...................................                           .....    252,661          240,762          267,793       261,850
Lumber.......... ...........................................                                                           24,915           26,043           23,615        21,535
Oil................................................                                                                    23,575           22, 311          33,157        34,458
Brick..........................................................                                                          6,949            9,088           4, 688        2,642
Lime........................................................                                                             1,488            2,307           2,107         2,168
Sand.........................................                                           ..................                  998           1,242           1,313         1,300
Sludge.......................................................                                                           15,000            9,000           9,000         5,000
Tar, oxide, etc.......                                .        ............................                              4, 340          21,833           6, 617        7,424
Miscellaneous .......................................                                                                    2, 010           1, 440          1,474         1,020
           Total.................                                      ........................                       331,936 334,026 349,764                         337,397

  Of this freight, in 1908, 69,089 tons of coal and 1,129 tons of lumber, total 70,218
tons, were carried above the Neponset highway bridge (the limit of the improvement
authorized by the United States) into the section of the river to be improved by the
State of Massachusetts.
                         APPENDIX B--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. BURR.                                                            997
                                                               B   II.

            IMPROVEMENT OF WEYMOUTH RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

                                           (A) WEYMOUTH FORE RIVER.

  No work was done and none required for the maintenance of
this improvement, which was completed June 6, 1907. The ex-
penditure shown in the money statement was for dredging com-
pleted during the preceding fiscal year.
                                           (B) WEYMOUTH BACK RIVER.

  For lack of funds no work was done upon this improvement during
the fiscal year.
                                          Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
of improvement .................................................... a $5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                      APPROPRIATIONS.

                                                      Weymouth Fore River.
1890-1902 b .............................................................. $42, 750
March 3, 1905.......... ....... --................... ......................                                               57, 500

          Total...........................................                                    ..................          100, 250
                                                      Weymouth Back River.
August 18, 1894.....---.....--
                            .......                     ............. .....$2, 500
                                    .........----.........
June 3,1896 .................................. .........  .. ........  ...... 10, 000
                               ........................
March 2,1907...................-------                   .................     9, 500

          Total..........                      .........      ......     ............................                     22, 000



                                                 COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                     Weymouth Fore River.

                                     Articles.                                         1905.            1906.    1907.     1908.


                                                                                       Tons.            Tons.    Tons.     Tons.
                                                           . 127, 496 115,
Coal.............................................................        819                                     156,790      373
                                                                                                                           155,
Lumber .....................................................  11,213   5,038                                      14,364    11,102
Lime.........................................................     260    200                                          50 ....
Brick.....   ...      ....................................        577    583                                         588      561
             ............................................
Sand and gravel                                                                            170             172      344        547
                                                          1, 641  1, 000..
Ties ..................................................................
Stone........................................................17,000..........5,960                                           4,596
Hay.............. ................. .....                    .................
                                                                    ......   1,276                                  165         45
Steeland iron.........................................................390                                                    1,310
Miscellaneous .................                      ............................          500             300      900        115

        Total...........................                                       158,857 124,388 179,551
                                                            ....................                                            173,649

  aFor Weymouth Back River.
  bFor itemized statement, see House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second session, p. 267.
998                    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                           Weymouth Back River.

                                                  Articles.                                                             1905.      1906.           1907.        1908.


                                                                                                                        Tons.      Tons.          Tons.         Tons.
Coal ...........                           ............................            8, 222   6, 637     8, 442                                                     7, 250
Pyrites                ----------------------------.......-------------------------- 6,661            11,860                                                     14,177
Raw and manufactured fertilizer products. .. .................                  136, 965  100, 861   149, 114                                                   146, 104
Rock .........................................................               .....         20,287 ..
Miscellaneous ....................................                      ....          746   2, 114        340                                                     2.527
           Total..........................                                      .   ................                    145, 933   136, 560       169, 756      170, 064



                                                                                         B        12.

                 IMPROVEMENT OF HINGHAM HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.

  No work was done during the fiscal year, the appropriation not
having been made available for the work desired.
                                                                          APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1875--.................. a $10, 000                                                           July 13, 1892..................... $3, 000
March 5, 1886..--------------................ 6, 000                                                   March 2, 1907................... 10, 000
August 11, 1888................               5, 000
September 19, 1890--...-..---......           5, 000                                                              Total...................                      39, 000



                                                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.


                                                  Articles.                                                             1883.      1906.           1907.        1908.


                                                                                                                        Tons        o
                                                                                                                                   Tns.            Tons.        Tons.
Coal............              ............        ......             .....           ..............         .........     9, 500    10, 000         10, 713       6, 000
Lumber.........                          .......... ...-----..........              .........       ..........            4, 875     4, 250           5, 000      5, 500
Cement and lime............ ...                                 ......... ......              .............                  413        180               300        320
Brick .....            ..... ......            ........................................                                   1, 250        480               300        550
Sand.........................                                      ...                                                                  300................

           Total ....................... ....                         .     .             ........
                                                                                             ............               16,038      15,210         16,313        12,370


                                                                                         B 13.

IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AT PLYMOUTH AND PROVINCETOWN,
                   MASSACHUSETTS.

                                                         (A) PLYMOUTH HARBOR.

       No work was done during the fiscal year.
                                                             Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
   exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
  provement ..........................................................          $10, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
  and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
      a Allotment from appropriation for Boston Harbor, to which appropriation $683.42
was restored.                     Date of allotment is unknown.
                      APPENDIX B-REPORT                            OF LIEUT.             COL. BURR.                            999
                                                  APPROPRIATIONS.

1824-1896 a-------------------------..................-------...---...--.....------...                              $191, 081. 90
March 3,1899---.......--------------...........-----------..................-------------.....---....--.....------.   85, 000.00
June 13, 1902.........--------------------------------------------------                                                 4, 000. 00
Damages from surety of failing contractor....---........------.............--- --....                                    4, 530. 12
        Total---------.....---..........................------------------------------.....---------..........---       284, 612.02

  NoTE.-From 1842 to 1859, inclusive, $90.16 were carried to surplus fund.



                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.


                                  Articles.                                          1904.        1906.         1907.        1908.


                                                                                    Tons.         Tons.         Tons.        Tons.
                                                         38,086
Coal ............................................................ 31,314                                        37,155         37,860
Lumber .......................................................
                                                          5,700    2,000                                         2,960          2,000
                                                                     5,000.......................
Stone-----....--............----------------.................--------....--------...-
Miscellaneous ................---- ...... ..... ....... ............  600            40           500 ..
      Total..................                          -    ................ 49,386                33,354       40,615         39,860

Number of passengers carried ..................                  .............       49,335        49,795       52,525         53,987




                                                                                                          Customs        Entrances
                                                                                                          collected.      and ces.ar-


                                                                    ...-----
1905.......--.................................................--......--..............50
                                                                          574.32
1906...........................................................................       58
                                                                                      72
1907..------------..----..-.....................................................-------------------
                                                                                      47
1908....-----.................................................................---------------------


  Passenger steamers from Boston land at Plymouth daily between June 15 and Sep-
tember 15 of each year.

                                  (B) HARBOR AT PROVINCETOWN.

  In January, 1909, the bulkhead at Abel Hill dike was extended
southerly 48 feet, and minor repairs to the bulkhead were made
during the spring of the same year.
                                     Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of
improvement..................................................... $135, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897.

  a For itemized statement, see House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress,
second session, page 269.
1000          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                   S. ARMY.

                                      APPROPRIATIONS.

May 19, 1826 ................        $3, 500. 00              June 18, 1878.... ........            $1, 000.00
March 2, 1829................         3, 500. 00              March 3, 1879_..............           1, 000. 00
March 2, 1831 ...............         2, 050. 00              June 14, 1880 ..............              500.00
March 3, 1832 ..............          4, 600. 00              March 3, 1881.... ..         ....      5, 000. 00
June 28, 1834 .............           4, 400. 00              August 2, 1882. ............           5, 000. 00
March 3, 1835_.......           ......4, 400.00               July 5, 1884. - ...........            2, 000.00
July 2, 1836.................         4,400.00                August 5, 1886..............           3,000.00
July 7, 1838................          4, 500.00               August 11, 1888.............            7,000.00
August 30, 1852...............        5, 000. 00              September 19, 1890..........           7, 500. 00
June 28, 1864 a_..............       30, 000.00               July 13, 1892...............           1, 500.00
June 23, 1866.................       43, 068. 44              August 18, 1894.............           1, 500. 00
July 28, 1866.................        8, 000. 00              June 3, 1896.................          1, 500.00
April 10, 1869 a...............       8,910.00                March 3, 1899..............           10, 000.00
March 3, 1871...............          6, 000. 00              June 13, 1902...............          11, 000. 00
June 10, 1872...............          5, 000. 00              March 3, 1905...............           5, 000. 00
March 3, 1873 ................        6, 000.00               March 2, 1907...............           5, 000.00
June 23, 1874.............            6, 000. 00
March 3, 1875.............            5, 000.00 Total. ..............    225, 828.44
August 14, 1876..............         4, 000. 00
  NOTE.-From 1828 to 1860, $3,665.47 was carried to surplus fund and not expended.
Authority: "Appropriations and Expenditures, 1789 to 1882," page 156.



                                 COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

   This is an important harbor of refuge, being the only harbor from Boston (52 miles
north) to Vineyard Haven (about the same distance south) that will admit large
vessels. The number of vessels following the route through Vineyard and Nan-
tucket sounds and along the eastern shore of Cape Cod is estimated (Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1904, p. 963) to be annually upward of 50,000, of which it
is reported that about 4,000 visit the harbor annually for shelter. The vessels are of
all sizes and descriptions, but it is to the smaller sailing vessels that it affords the
greatest protection.


                                                   B I4.

          IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT BURLINGTON, VERMONT.

   Under the contract with James E. Cashman, between July 1 and
October 29, 1908, 327 linear feet of concrete superstructure were built
and repairs made to 124 linear feet of the foundation of the super-
structure, completing the contract.


                              Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for mainte-
  nance of improvement..........        ..................................                        b $86, 555. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

a Allotments from general appropriations; dates of allotment unknown.
b Repairs to substructure already made.................................                                $34, 555
  Rubblestone protection for substructure ..............................                                52, 000

                                                                                                        86, 555
                                 APPENDIX B-REPORT OF LIEUT.                                                          COL. BURR.                   1001
                                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

1836-1884 a ................  $508, 480. 20                                                    June 13, 1902.............. $57, 750. 00
August 5, 1886..............    18, 750. 00                                                    March 3, 1905 ................ 20, 000. 00
August 11, 1888.............    35, 000. 00                                                    March 4, 1907.............     35, 000. 00
September 19, 1890.........     20, 000. 00                                                    May 27, 1908 ...............   16, 855. 00
August 18, 1894 .............   10, 000. 00                                                    Receipts from sales..........      1.46. 00
June 3, 1896...............     10, 000. 00
March 3, 1899..............     15, 000. 00                                                                    Total................         751, 981. 20
June 6, 1900 b..............     5,000.00
    NoTE.-In 1872, $6,669.13 was carried to surplus fund and not expended.



                                                                  CONTRACT IN FORCE.

    Contractor: James E. Cashman, Braintree, Mass.
    Date of contract: July 6, 1906.
    Date of approval: July 18, 1906.
    Date of commencement: July 1, 1.906.
    Date of completion: November 30, 1907.
    For repair of breakwater at Burlington Harbor, Vermont.
     Price:
              Removing old superstructure, $8 per linear foot.
              Concrete in place in parapet, $10 per cubic yard.
              Concrete in footing blocks, $10 per cubic yard.
              Concrete in decking, $11 per cubic yard.
              Stone blocks in coping of deck and under footing blocks on lake side, $10 per
                cubic yard.
              Timber and plank, $50 per 1,000 feet B. M.
              Tie-rods, 1 inches, in place, $7 each.
              Tie-rods, 1g inches, in place, $6 each.
              Use of plant, $8 per hour.
                                                                 COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
                                                                                      Freight.

                                                 Articles.                                                        1905.      1906.       1907.     1908.


                                                                                                                  Tons.      Tons.      Tons.      Tons.
Coal .......                 ..............                          .......................                       53,270     44, 775    41,310     41,008
Lumber ..........                         ................................                                         41, 049   180, 391   198, 866   195, 365
Stone.......................                              ................................                          2,300         840        700     2,254
Cement, plaster, etc ...........................................                                                    1,955      1, 304     1,558         450
Salt..----.....--..---..-..--..----------------------------------...................................--......        1,218        734        308      1,789
General merchandise -------------........-------...............----........--------........                         9, 854     8,754      7, 827     8, 308

          Total .........................................                                                         109, 646   236,798    250, 569   249,174


                                                                             Passenger line.

                                                                                                                Nvumber. N umber. Number. Number.
Arrivals at the port of Burlington ..............................                                                    738     676     716       709
Departures from the port of Burlington .....................                                                         738     676     716       709
Steamers in commission .....................................                                                           3       3       3          3
Trips made.............................................                                                               405        369        413        407
Passengers carried to and from Burlington ..................                                                      107, 538   118, 353   126, 356   127, 629


  The largest of the passenger steamers running from this port is 273 feet long and
68 feet beam. The service is operated only during the summer season of about four
months in each year.

  a For itemized statement, see House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress,
page 319.
  b Allotment of October 16, 1900.
1002                 REPORT                 OF THE                 CHIEF               OF ENGINEERS,                                U.     S.     ARMY.


                                                                                      B IS

IMPROVEMENT OF NARROWS OF LAKE CHAMPLAIN, NEW YORK AND
                       VERMONT.

  No work upon this improvement was done during the fiscal year.
A survey of the channel was made to determine the location and
extent of the shoaling which was reported to have taken place.

                                                                     APPROPRIATIONS.

1886-1892 a.....        ...   ...    ................................                                                                                                 $63,500
March 3, 1899 ...................... ......... ........                                                              ..       ......              .........             5, 000
June 6, 1900 b.............................................................1,                                                                                                   500
June 13, 1902......................--- ........--..         ..                                                .....................--....                              17, 500
March 3, 1905-.......---..............              .......                                                     .......................                                 2, 500
March 2, 1907...................                                            ...........            ........          ......              ...............                    2, 500

             Total............-...........--                                                            -..........................                                    92, 500



                                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.


                                                Articles.                                                            1905.               1906.             1907.            1908.


                                                                                                                       Tons.              Tons.       Tons.                 Tons.
Coal..............                    ................                          ..................                     170,600           162, 545   143,713                 152,089
Lumber and timber...................................                                                                   165, 544          179, 587   139,250                  125, 638
Iron and iron ore ...........................                                                                           95, 447           52, 358     29, 985                 28, 266
Wood........................................................................                                            16, 956           17, 685       1,000                  2, 797
Salt.. .             .. .. .........................................                                                          875             613           245                   506
Hay..........................................................--12,177                                                                     17,304        8,104                  2,233
Ice...-----------------------------------------............................................---..............---------------.....          12,858 ..........
Lime, cement, etc- -.... ...-- ...........                                   ....... ...........           .....        27, 517           30, 459     40,000           ..
Pulp wood........---.....--.......--....... ....................                                                       209,100           189, 025   347, 485                242,984
Miscellaneous ....                       ...................................                                  ...             401         13,617      14, 747                10, 901
          Total .............                  .....          .....       ....................                      698, 617             676, 051          724, 529         565, 414



                                                                                      B 16.
REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDAN-
                  GERING NAVIGATION.

    Wreck of steamer City qf Birmingham in Boston Harbor, Massa-
chusetts.-This steamer sunk in Boston Harbor on November 4, 1907,
on the southerly side of the 27-foot channel, and about 1,800 feet
northwesterly from Castle Island. She had been employed in the
passenger service between Boston and Savannah, had an iron hull,
and was 301 feet in length, 42 feet beam, 16.7 feet depth, gross ton-
nage 3,066. The wreck, lying within the channel limits, formed a
dangerous obstruction to navigation, and advertisement was pub-
lished for thirty days inviting proposals for its removal by the United
States. Of the two proposals received, one was rejected for lack of
guaranty and the other as excessive. Upon informal proposals, a
   a For itemized statement, see House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress,
second session, page 335.
   b Allotted July 31, 1900.
              APPENDIX B-REPORT OF LIEUT.             COL. BURR.           1003
contract was awarded to Alfred S. Sorensen, of Somerville, Mass.,
dated January 7, 1908, to remove the entire wreck by June 30, 1908.
Work was commenced on January 13, 1908, and completed Novem-
ber 19, 1908, at a total cost to the United States of $13,200.
   Wrecks in Narrows of Lake Champlain, New York.--Upon examina-
tion in October, 1908, wrecks of eighteen canal boats and two steamers
were found in a location dangerous to navigation of the Narrows and
Whitehall Harbor. After advertisement for thirty days, proposals
were received, and formal contract for their removal made with
Johnston & Virden, of Lewes, Del., dated February 19, 1909, the
work to be completed by August 31, 1909. Work was commenced
on March 12, 1909, and is in progress at the date of this report. The
amount expended during the fiscal year was $226.79 for office and
inspection expenses.
                            CONTRACTS     IN   FORCE.

  Contractor: Alfred S. Sorensen, Somerville, Mass.
  Date of contract: January 7, 1908.
  Date of approval: January 13, 1908.
  Date of commencement: Within ten days from date of notification of approval.
  Date of completion: June 30, 1908 (time for completion waived).
  For removing wreck of steamer City of Birmingham, Boston Harbor, Massachusetts,
for the sum of $15,000.
  Completed November 19, 1908.

  Contractor: Johnston & Virden, Lewes, Del.
  Date of contract: February 19, 1909.
  Date of approval: March 9, 1909.
  Date of commencement: May 1, 1909.
  Date of completion: August 31, 1909.
  For removing wrecks from Lake Champlain, New York and Vermont, for $3,440.
                             APPENDIX           C.


IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE NEWPORT, RHODE
                     ISLAND, DISTRICT.



REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. J. C. SANFORD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS,
OFFICER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 80,
1909.
                                IMPROVEMENTS.


1. Harbor at Nantucket, Massachusetts.    10. Newport Harbor, Rhode Island.
2. Vineyard Haven Harbor, Massachu-       11. Harbor of Refuge at Point Judith,
     setts.                                     Rhode Island.
3. Woods Hole channel, Massachusetts.     12. Entrance to Point Judith Pond,
4. Harbors at New Bedford and Fair-             Rhode Island.
     haven, Massachusetts.                13. Harbor of Refuge at Block Island,
5. Sakonnet Harbor, Rhode Island.               Rhode Island.
6. Taunton River, Massachusetts.          14. Great Salt Pond, Block Island,
7. Sakonnet River, Rhode Island.                Rhode Island.
8. Pawtucket (Seekonk) River, Rhode       15. Removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
     Island.                                    structing or endangering naviga-
9. Providence River and Harbor, and             tion.
     Narragansett Bay and Green Jacket
     shoal, Rhode Island.



                             UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                    Newport, R. I., July 19, 1909.
  SIR: I have the honor to forward herewith my annual report for
the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, for rivers and harbors in this
district.   *   *   *
        Very respectfully,                          J. C. SANFORD,
                                        Lieut. Col., Corps of Engineers.
  The   CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,       U. S. Army.


                                     C   I.

    IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AT HYANNIS AND NANTUCKET,
                     MASSACHUSETTS.

                         (A) HARBOR AT HYANNIS.

  For history and projects, see page 78 of this report.
  No works of improvement have been in progress during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909. Under date of November 21, 1908, the
Solicitor of the Treasury stated that $500 had been accepted in com-
promise of the suit of the United States v. James E. Payne and
                                                                       1005
1006                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Almanza J. Rose, sureties on the bond of Charles H. Latham, failing
contractor for work at Hyannis, brought November 3, 1905, for the
recovery of $3,065.15, damages, etc.                                                                            A project was submitted and
approved for the expenditure of this amount for the purpose of mak-
ing a survey of the harbor with a view to determining present con-
ditions, and for the collection of commercial statistics.                                                                             The survey
has not been made, as later instructions required the redeposit of the
funds to the credit of the appropriation.  Expenditures were for the.
collection of commercial statistics.
  Operations contemplated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-
A survey will be made.
                                     AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
Previous projects.....................................................                                      $123, 431. 82
Existing project:
    August 5, 1886...----.---..........................---------------------......-------. $10, 000. 00
    August 11, 1888...........----------...-.....--....-----...---.----....--------......       10, 000. 00
    September 19, 1890---..-------............--...--................                            8, 000. 00
    July 13, 1892................-------------------....-....---..........-------.......         6, 000. 00
    August 18, 1894-..........------..----------------------------...........................    3, 500. 00
    June 3, 1896.........................................                                        6, 000. 00
    March 3, 1899 .......................................                                     .  2, 162. 00
    June 13, 1902 (allotted July 30, 1902) .................                                    20, 000. 00
    March 3, 1905 (allotted March 29, 1905). ................                                    8, 173. 25
                                                                                                              73, 835. 25
                                                                                                                                              197, 267. 07
Received from sale of material.............................                                                                   ...........           20. 68

              Total .....................                                           ..-.............................                          197, 287.75
Received from bondsmen of failing contractor, January 18, 1909, act of
June 13, 1902................  ....................-----.... ...........                                                                              500. 00

             Total.................................................................                                                           197, 787. 75


                                                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The commerce arriving at and leaving Hyannis Harbor, Massachusetts, by water
during the calendar year ending December 31, 1908, is estimated as follows:
                   Commerce arriving at and leaving Hyannis Harbor, calendar year 1908.

                                                                                                                                     Tons.             Value.


Coal and other fuel. . .     ............      ....................                                 10, 000                                             $60, 000
Lumber and other building materials...... ...............................                           10,800                                              129,600
Fish, oysters, etc................................................---...............................300                                                  30,000
          Total.         ...........                             ................................................                     21,100            219,600
Increase over 1906...............................................................                                                         1, 000 ..
Number of passengers carried ...................................................                                                    ...       ......        900

    The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):


                                                         Character.                                                      Number. Greatest   Total
                                                                                                                                  draft.  tonnage.

                                                                                                                                      Feet.
Steamers......................................................                                                                24              16          3,000
Sailing vessels....... ..........................................                                                            320              10         42, 000
Barges.....                    .......                                                                                         0
                                                                                                                              10
                                                                                                                              1..........   15
                                                                                                                                            18..0.....................
                                                                                                                                                      8,000
Yachts, motor boats, etc................................................                                                     150          4-12           900
                         APPENDIX C-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. SANFORD.                                                                                        1007

                                                 (B) HARBOR AT NANTUCKET.

     For history and project, see page 79 of this report.
     Operations during the past fiscal year.-No works of improvement
have been in progress during the fiscal year. A survey of the jetty
channel was made in June, 1909.
   Operations contemplated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-IT
is proposed, with funds allotted from the appropriation of March 3,
1909, to remove the shoal formed at the outer end of the jetty chan-
nel.
                                                Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July, 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement .............................  $50, 000. 00
   For maintenance of improvement........................   30, 000. 00
                                                                                                                                                 $80, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                     AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
Previous projects.......................................................... $45, 734 75
Existing project:
    July 14, 1880....................................-------------......                   $50, 000. 00
    March 3, 1881..--....---...............................                                 25, 000. 00
    August 3, 1882........---- ..........................                         .. .....  25, 000. 00
    July 5, 1884....            ..........- .....................                   ......  10, 000. 00
    August 5, 1886..--......            ..... ........          ...... ...-........         15, 000. 00
    August 11, 1888....--..................... .............. 20, 000. 00
    September 19, 1890.....................................                                 25, 000. 00
   July 13, 1892....------.....................................                             25, 000. 00
   August 18, 1894......................................                                    25, 000. 00
   June 3, 1896...........................................                                  20, 000. 00
   March 3, 1899..............................                                     .......  20, 000. 00
   June 15, 1902 (allotted July 30, 1902) ..................                                15, 000. 00
   March 3, 1905 (allotted March 29, 1905)..................                                71, 826. 75
   March 2, 1907 .... .......              ..........           .................           42, 500. 00
   March 3, 1909 (allotted April 10, 1909).......... ........                               20, 000. 00
                                                                                                        409, 326. 75

            Total......................................                                                          ...............                 455, 061. 50

                                                      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
  The commerce arriving at and leaving Nantucket Harbor, Massachusetts, by water
during the calendar year ending December 31, 1909, is estimated as follows:
               Commerce arriving at and leaving Nantucket Harbor, calendar year 1908.

                                                                                                                                          Tons.           Value.

Coal and other fuel.....................................................                                                                   9,000            $48, 000
Other minerals and metals..............................................                                                                      100                 700
Lumber and other building materials ....................                                                      ....................... .    9,000          108,000
Grain and forage ..................                                         ....................................                             500            15,000
Live stock and products.....                             .....................................                                                40              8,000
Fertilizers................                .....      ..         ...                                                                          15
                                                                                                                                              1......................................
                                                                                                                                                                  400
Fish, oysters, etc...................................................                                                                         30              3,000
Freight carried by regular steamboat (distribution into classes not obtained)........                                                      8,175          817, 500
General merchandise and machinery................ ...............                                                                  ...          50             5, 000
      Total................ ...........       ...........................                                                                 26,910 1,000,600
Decrease under 1907.......1.......7...0......... ......................                                                                        ...
1008                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The apparent decrease in the commerce is believed to be due to a different method
of obtaining the statistics.
   Number of passengers carried, 42,072.
  The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):

                                                     Character.                                               Number.       Greatest         Total
                                                                                                                             draft,        tonnage.


                                                                                                                             Feet.
Steamers..............................................................                                                425          8         284,750
Sailing vessels ...........................................................                                            29         10          10,150
Yachts, motor boats, etc .............................................                                                725         11           6,000


                                                                                   C 2.
    IMPROVEMENT OF VINEYARD HAVEN HARBOR, MASSACHUSETTS.
     For history and project see page 82 of this report.
     Operations during the past fiscal year.-No works of improvement
were in progress during the past fiscal year.
                                                          AMOUNTS                  APPROPRIATED.
April 11, 1888.......................................................                          $25,000
September 19,1890 ..................................................................            10, 000
July 3, 1892................                ...........................................          7, 500
August 18, 1894...........                   .............................................       7, 500
June 3, 1896........................................................................... 7,000
March 3, 1899.................................................................................   3, 000

             Total .......                      ..............................................                                              60, 000
                                                           COMMERCIAL                    STATISTICS.

  The commerce arriving at and leaving Vineyard Haven, Mass., by water during the
calender year ending December 31, 1908, is estimated as follows:
         Commerce arriving at and leaving Vineyard Haven Harbor, calender year 1908.

                                                                                                                             Tons.          Value.

Coal and other fuel.........................................................................                                   4,635         $28,810
Lumber and other building materials ....................................                             .......                   1,400          17,000
Grain and forage ...........................                                  .. .................. .........
                                                                    ............                                               3,000          90,000
Live stock and products ....................................................                                                      30           6,000
Fertilizers .........       ....................................................                                                  10             300
Fish, oysters, etc .............             ............... ............................. ........                              300          30,000
Freight arrived by steamers (distribution into classes not obtained). ............                                             6, 945        694,500
General merchandise and machinery ...............................................                                                 500         50,000

      Total................................                                            ............................           16,820     916,610
Decrease under 1907............................                             ....   ....... ............................        3,130 ..........


  The apparent decrease in the commerce is believed to be due to a difference in
method of obtaining statistics.
  Number of passengers carried, 18, 780.
  The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):

                                                       Character.                                                 Number.   Greatest
                                                                                                                             draft.    Total
                                                                                                                                     tonnage.

                                                                                                                              Feet.
Steamers .............................................................                                      ...       600            18      180,000
Sailing vessels..........................................................                                           6,006            12    1,801,800
Barges...     ...................................................                                                   1,509            19      905,400
Yachts, motor boats, etc...                             .......................................                       125              8       3,000
                         APPENDIX                    C--REPORT OF LIEUT.                                       COL. SANFORD.                             1009
                                                                                 C 3.
         IMPROVEMENT OF WOODS HOLE CHANNEL, MASSACHUSETTS.

     For history and project see page 82 of this report.
  Operations during the past fiscal year.--A small shoal spot in the
eastern end of the main channel was blasted and is believed to have
been entirely removed.
  Operations contemplated for thefiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-It
is expected to make a further survey of both the channel through the
strait and that leading to the wharves.

                                                       AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
Previous projects...-... .......             ... ..........               ......-.              .... ....     $113, 500. 00
Existing project:
    June 3, 1896---------------------------.........-----.................-------................. $20, 000
    March 3, 1899.-.......... ...............................                                         20, 000
    June 13, 1902----------....-----..........------...........--------................               20, 000
    March 3, 1905-......------.......--------...-----------...........-----..-----.......---.. 70, 000
    June 30, 1906-----------........--------......--------..............-----------............ 100, 000
                                                                                                               230, 500. 00
     Total-----..............--------------.....................................
                                        --------------------------------                                                                          344,000.00
December 5, 1895, unexpended balance deposited to the credit of the
Treasurer of the United States........................-............                                                                                     400. 08
            Total-----------------------.........................--------------------.........--.......
                                                                                                   ------ 343, 599. 92

                                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The commerce arriving at and leaving Woods Hole, Mass., by water during the cal-
endar year ending December 31, 1908, is estimated as follows:
                      Commerce arriving at and leaving Woods Hiole, calendar year 1908.

                                                                                                                                          Tons.         Value.


Coal and other fuel .................                 ....        ..... ....................                     ..............               12, 000    $72, 000
Lumber and other building materials ..........................................      -                                       -       -.....     7, 000    140, 000
Grain and forage-----................------------------.............---------------................----------------................... -6,000            180, 000
Live stock and products ....---------------.........-------------........----...................---...........--------..---..-.                   300     60,000
Fertilizers ---------...-----------....................---------...............----------------....................-------------............     600       18, 000
Fish, oysters, etc----------...........................---------------------------------------------300                                                    18,000
General merchandise and machinery ......--------------------------------------                                                               35, 000      350, 000
      Total..-----.......................................................--------------------------------------------1,200...........         200   838,000
Increase over 1907........... ................ ............                                        ....... ...... ...---.........          34,100 .


   The above figures include local commerce, freight transshipped at Woods Hole,
freight carried through the strait and stopping at Woods Hole, and that using the
harbor for shelter.
   Number of passengers carried, 30,000.
   The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):


                                                    Character.                                                          Number.         Greatest          Total
                                                                                                                                         draft.         tonnage.

                                                                                                                                           Feet.
Steamers ................--------.........----------------------..........---------.....------..---..--..............         1,400                9      140,000
Sailing vessels..... .................................                            ........- ..............                      100                8        2,500
Barges........              ......        ....-........    ...-..--............---....              ---.......                     50              9       25,000
Yachts, motor boats, etc..."... . ....... ......- ............-.-. ...                                                 1        400               9        2,000

             9001-ENG 1909----64
1010           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                           U.    S. ARMY.

                                                            C 4.
  IMPROVEMENT OF NEW BEDFORD AND FAIRHAVEN HARBORS,
                    MASSACHUSETTS.
   For history and project, see page 83 of this report.
   Operations during the past fiscal year.-The work of dredging in
progress at the close of the last fiscal year under a continuing con-
tract with the Coastwise Dredging Company, of Norfolk, Va., as
shown in detail under "Contract in force" below, was continued
throughout the year, except for the period from February 1 to March
11, 1909, when the dredge was withdrawn on account of stormy
weather and ice. A second dredge was at work for about nine
months. During the year 880,746 cubic yards of mud, sand, and
gravel were removed from the harbor, together with 446.733 cubic
yards of bowlders, exceeding 1 cubic yard each in size, nearly com-
pleting the contract.
   Operations contemplated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-
It is proposed to complete the present contract and to dredge to 25
feet depth in front of the New Bedford wharves for a short distance
above and below the New Bedford and Fairhaven bridge, as author-
ized by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909, somewhat extend-
ing the dredged area beyond that contemplated in the original project.
                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of
  improvement........-----------------------------------------$227,                                               000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.


                                           AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
Previous projects:
    As shown in House Document 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second ses-
      sion..... ....... ............. .......................                                 ...........   a$159, 700
    March 3, 1905------...-.....---------...................---------------....------............--..----..    11, 000
      Total------------------.....-----------------.......-----------..........                                  170, 700
Existing project:
    March 2, 1907---...--...--....................------------------.......-------......-.. $100, 000
    May 27, 1908.................                         ...... .....................       200, 000
                                                                                                                 300, 000

      Total...........-------------------.......................----------------------.........------.........   470, 700
Received from sale of material .........................................                                                9

         Total .................................                        ...............         ...........      470, 709
                                                   CONTRACT IN FORCE.
   Contractor: Coastwise Dredging Company.
   Character of work: Dredging.
   Amount of work: About $270,000 worth, excluding contingencies.
   Rate per cubic yard: Twelve and seven-tenths cents.
   Date of approval: August 2, 1907.
   To commence: Within twenty days after date of notification of approval of the con-
tract by the Chief of Engineers.
   To complete: On or before December 31, 1909.
   This is a continuing contract.
a Includes item of $3,000, appropriated August 30, 1852, for survey of Tauntork
River and New Bedford Harbor,
                             APPENDIX C---REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. SANFORD.                                                                                                1011
                                                             COMMERCIAL                             STATISTICS.
  The commerce arriving at and leaving New Bedford, Mass., by water during the
calendar year ending December 31, 1908, is estimated as follows:
                       Commerce arriving at and leaving New Bedford, calendar year 1908.

                                                                                                                                                   Tons.              Value.

Coal and other fuel ..............       ......................                                                                ...         .      1,209,136      $7, 365,682. 43
Lumber and other building materials ...................................                                                                              33, 420         370, 642.80
Grain and forage--...................................................................                                                                   1,525         30,500.00
Live stock and products ......................................................                                                                             505        101,100.00
Fertilizers.....................................................................                                                                            97          3, 395.00
Fish, oysters, etc.............-...                           .                  -...
                                                                         .... .............     ..........            .............                     6, 418        440, 800.00
General merchandise and machinery ..-.........                                            .............................                             223, 974     22,146, 882.00
Cotton........................................................................                                                                       35, 297     10, 268, 240.00
Whale oil.................................................................................1,                                                              500         266, 482.12
Whale bone .....................................                                          ................                 ......     ......               13          97,500.00
      Total................                 ........................................................                                              1,511,885 41,091,124.35
Increase over 1907 ............................................................                                                                     322, 333 ..............


  Number of passengers carried, 271,811.
  The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):

                                                          Character.                                                                    Number.          Greatest   Total
                                                                                                                                                          draft,  tonnage.

                                                                                                                                                           Feet.
Steamers.................................................................                                                                      1, 927            18    1, 487,086
Sailing vessels ............................                                   ... .........         ...................                          341            18        44, 185
Barges .........-......- --.............. ........... .......................                                                                     907            21      907,000
Yachts, motor boats, etc .................................... ............                                                                     7, 500            15       75, 000


                                                                                           C 5.
                 IMPROVEMENT OF SAKONNET HARBOR, RHODE ISLAND.
   For history and project, see page 85 of this report.
   Operations during the pastfiscal year.-The work of removing a rock
from the harbor in progress at the close of the last fiscal year under a
contract entered into with Roy H. Beattie, of Fall River, Mass., as
shown in detail in "Contract in force" below, was continued until
July 28, when it was completed. A small additional rock close to the
original rock was discovered during the progress of the work and was
removed.
   Operations contemplated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-
No further work is contemplated.
                                                             AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
Previous projects (as shown in H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 312)... $25, 000
Existing project, March 2, 1907 .................................             10, 000
              Total.............................................................                                                                                        35, 000
                                                                   CONTRACT IN FORCE.
   Contractor: Roy H. Beattie.
   Amount and character of work: Removing rock No. 1, Sakonnet Harbor, to a depth
of 8 feet at mean low water.
   Rate: Lump sum of $7,600 for removal of the rock.
   Date of approval: May 14, 1908.
   To commence: Within twenty days after date of notification of approval of the con-
tract by the Chief of Engineers.
   To complete: Within three months after commencement.
1012                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                                 S. ARMY.

                                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The commerce arriving at and leaving Sakonnet Harbor, Rhode Island, during the
calendar year ending December 31, 1908, by water, is estimated as follows:

                  Commerce arriving at and leaving Sakonnet Harbor, calendar year 1908.

                                                                                                                                                      Tons.         Value.


Coal and other fuel...................................                                     ...............................                                146         $1,068
Other minerals and metals.........                       ... .....................          ...............                ...... ......                   33          1, 450
Lumber and other building materials ... ......                                       ..-.....-..-                ..... ..-.-....-....                      52          1,352
Grain and forage- ----.. ..-                             ------------------------------------------------                                              1,768          56, 576
Live stock and products............................................................                                                                       216         43,200
Fertilizers-------------------------------------------------------------...........................................................................        40          1,280
Fish, oysters, etc..................................................................                                                                      319         35,090
General merchandise and machinery.....--------------........--------------...................................                                          2, 400        240, 000

          Total .................                      .......             ....   ...     .....        ............        ..............              4,974         380,016


  Increase over 1907, 731 tons.
  Number of passengers carried, 21,000.
  The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):


                                                         Character.                                                                  Number. Greatest
                                                                                                                                              draft.                 Total
                                                                                                                                                                   tonnage.

                                                                                                                                                      Feet.
Steamers................................................................                                                                      460             9          225
Sailing      ...........................................................
       vessels                                                                                                                                 300            3           20
Yachts, motor boats, etc.................................................                                                                   1, 000            5          180


                                                                                        C 6.
                   IMPROVEMENT OF TAUNTON RIVER, MASSACHUSETTS.

   For history and project, see page 86 of this report.
   Operations during the past fiscal year.-Work under the contract
with the J. S. Packard Dredging Company, of Providence, R. I., for
dredging a shoal near the lower end of Weir Village, at the rate of 64
cents per cubic yard, and for removing bowlders from points farther
down the river, at the rate of $15 per hour, was commenced August
5 and completed September 8, 1908. The dredging was completed
August 31, and 4,270 cubic yards of sand, gravel, and mud were
removed. The dredge was occupied forty-one hours in the removal of
bowlders from the channel near Burts Turn.
   Operations contemplated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.--
It is proposed with funds allotted from the appropriation of March
3, 1909, to remove shoals that may be found to obstruct navigation.
                                                       Estimate of additional funds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
  of improvement..............           ..    .      ......................                                                                                      5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                        APPENDIX C--REPORT OF LIEUT.                                                    COL. SANFORD.                    1013
                                                    AMOUNTS                 APPROPRIATED.
Previous projects---------.........-----------------.............-----------..........--------.......              $63, 000
Existing project:
    July 14, 1880....--------------...................---------------.........-----------.............    $17, 500
    March 3, 1881...----------...................---------------.......-----------............---..-----. 25, 000
    August 2, 1882.........--------..---------................------------.......------------..........    25, 000
    July 5, 1884....--------..........------.........-----....----...................
                                                                         ------------------ 27, 500
    September 19, 1890----....-------......---------.................---------....--.........               7, 000
    July 3, 1892------..........--------..---------............----------....................----.          7, 000
    August 18, 1894--------...........---------..-----........--------...........----------...........      5,000
    June 3, 1896..-----------.........---------...................-------------.......----------........    5, 000
    March 3, 1899...........................--------------------------------........------..........        7, 000
    June 13, 1902..---------.......----------.....................-------------....-----------..........    5,000
    March 3, 1905-------.........----..............------------------.............---------....--...--..    5, 000
    March 23, 1909 (allotted March 29, 1909).......................                                         5, 000
                                                                                                                   140, 000
           Total--...-------................--------------...................-----------------------..........------..                  203, 000

                                         EMERGENCY CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contractor: J. S. Packard Dredging Company.
  Amount and character of work: Dredging and removing bowlders, $5,000 worth
of work, less contingencies.
   Rate: 64 cents per cubic yard.
   Date of approval: Not approved; emergency contract.
   To commence: Within twenty days after July 3, 1908.
  To complete: Within three months after July 3, 1908.



                                                    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The commerce arriving at and leaving Taunton River, Massachusetts, by water,
during the calendar year ending December 31, 1908, is estimated as follows:

                 Commerce arriving at and leaving Taunton River, calendar year 1908.

                                                                                                                             Tons.       Value.

Coal and other fuel ...............  ..............             ....                           .....               ..        58, 533
                                                                                                                             5.......    $270, 483
Other minerals and metals...        _ . ....        ...... .. ................................                               13,150        44, 925
Lumber and other building materials ......................                        ...........       ..............            2, 240       32, 000
General merchandise and machinery.................................................                                            -400         11,600
        Total............................................................                                                    74,323       359,008


   Decrease under 1907, 118,777 tons.
   The apparent decrease in the commerce is believed to be due to a difference in the
method of obtaining the statistics.
  The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):


                                                 Character.                                                      Number. Greatest   Total
                                                                                                                          draft.  tonnage.

                                                                                                                             Feet.
Steamers.............................................................                                                 222         71        6,660
Sailing vessels---.....---....-------------...-...-------.......--....------------...........--------.........         81         8        14,175
Barges-........------------.....------------... ----------------------------
                                                           ........                                                    141                 79,000
Yachts. motor boats, etc .................................          ........-----                                   9, 000        52      108, 000
1014             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                 U.     S. ARMY.

                                                                  C 7.
              IMPROVEMENT OF SAKONNET RIVER, RHODE ISLAND.

  For history and project, see page 87 of this report.
  Operations during the past fiscal year.-No works of improvement
have been in progress.
  Operations contemplated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-
No further work is comtemplated.
                                             AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
June 3, 1896...................................-----------------------------------------------................-----........       $20, 000
March 3, 1899 .... ............                     .................--.......                 ......... ...........               20, 000
          Total........... ...-...................                               ....     ........ .....            .......        40, 000



                                             COMMERCIAL                  STATISTICS.

  The following is a list of vessels passing through the draw of the "Stone Bridge"
over the Sakonnet River at Tiverton, R. I., during the calendar year ending December
31, 1908:
Steamboats--------.........................................--------------------------------...---------..............               2,684
Towboats ..........................................................-----------------------------------------------------......          44
Sailing vessels-------......---..........-------------..........-----------................-----------....-.....---......               44
Sailboats .----........-----..------------...-........-------..........................--------------..--------...........          1, 178
Barges...-----------.........-----....---------------------------------------..................................................         20
Miscellaneous----...............................-------...........--------------............------......---------------..               17

          Total.......-----.....-......----------------.-----------------------.....................                                3,987



                                                                   C 8.
IMPROVEMENT OF PAWTUCKET (SEEKONK) RIVER, RHODE ISLAND.

  For history and project, see page 88 of this report.
  Operations during the past fiscal year.-Proposals for dredging and
rock excavation were received July 22, 1908, and the contract for the
dredging awarded to J. S. Packard, of Providence, R. I., at the rate
of 141 cents per cubic yard, and for the rock excavation to John J.
Fitzpatrick, of Plattsburg, N. Y., at the rate of $6.66 per cubic yard.
  Work under the dredging contract commenced August 26, 1908,
and was continued through the remainder of the fiscal year excepting
between December 18 and April 6, when it was suspended. Up to
the close of the year, 393,477 cubic yards of sand, gravel, clay, and
mud, and 70.581 cubic yards of bowlders exceeding 1 cubic yard
each, were removed. The work of drilling and blasting the ledge rock
was commenced September 5 and continued throughout the remain-
der of the year excepting between January 18 and March 5, when
work was suspended; 2,140.59 cubic yards of rock were removed.
   Operations contemplated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-
It is proposed to complete the project with the modification author-
ized by the river and harbor act of March 3, 1909.
                          APPENDIX C--REPORT OF LIEUT.                                                      (COL. SANFORD.                     1015
                                             Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for mainte-
  nance of improvement....----------...............--------....-----...................------------ $20 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                 AMOUNTS                     APPROPRIATED.

Previous projects (as shown in H. Doec. 421, 57th Cong. 2d sess., p. 312). $336, 000. 00
Existing project:
    March 3, 1905 ........................................    $30, 000. 00
    March 2, 1907...----..................................... 135, 584. 00
                                                                            165, 584. 00
      Total---.... ..------------...--            ----------------------------...... 501, 584.00
Received from sale of material ... .....................--
                                                   -       -...           . ...            19. 59
             Total..........................                                ...........................                                    501, 603. 59
                                                       CONTRACTS IN FORCE.


                        Amount            Character of         Rate per
                                                                cubic                     Date of ap-
                                                                                           proval.T         To commence.
                         of work.
                Contractor.                  work.
                                                                   yard.

                              Cu. yds.
J. S. Packard..                545,000    Dredging....               $0.14;          Aug. 27,1908            In 30 days af-     Within 14 months
                                                                                                               ter notifica-     after notification,
                                                                                                               tion.             exclusive of De-
                                                                                                                                 cember, January,
                                                                                                                                  February,        and
                                                                                                                                 March.
John J. Fitz-                     5,500   Removal of                   6. 66        .... do............do.......                Within 10 months
  patrick.                                 ledge rock.                                                                           after notification,
                                                                                                                                 exclusive of De-
                                                                                                                                 cember, January
                                                                                                                                 February, and
                                                                                                                                 March.


                                                     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The commerce arriving at and leaving Pawtucket River, Rhode Island, by water
during the calendar year ending December 31, 1908, is estimated as follows:
                 Commerce arriving at and leaving Pawtucket River, calendar year 1908.

                                                                                                                                 Tons.        Value.

(Coal and other fuel.........     ........................                .........................                              366,366      $2,591,146
Other minerals and metals............................................. .................                                           7,845         130,490
Lumber and other building materials .........................................                                                     11,691         194,611
Fertilizers................. ................................. ......          ....          ..............                        1,053          22,609
Fish, oysters, and oyster shells ..................................................                                              35, 415         545,076
         Total........................                            ...............................                                422,370       3,483,932


  Increase over 1907, 133,462 tons.
  Number of passengers carried, 49,314.
 'The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):

                                          Character.                                                       Number.             Greatest draft.


Steamers...........................                                ...................                       2,356
Sailing vessels ........                   ..        ...........
                                                            .................                       ....         68
Barges......................                    .................                                              409   Not over 16 feet in any case.
Yachts, motor boats, etc.......................                   .......                                      400
Miscellaneous (mud scows, oil scows, etc.).. ....................                                              783
1016           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                      U.    S. ARMY.

                                                          C 9.
IMPROVEMENT OF PROVIDENCE RIVER AND HARBOR, NARRAGAN-
     SETT BAY, AND GREEN JACKET SHOAL, RHODE ISLAND.

   For history and project, see page 90 of this report.
   Operations during the past fiscal year.-Work under the contract
dated September 19, 1907, with the J. S. Packard Dredging Company,
of Providence, R. I., as shown in detail under "Contracts in force"
below, for dredging to a depth of 25 feet for a uniform width easterly
from the main channel between Long Bed and Kettle Point in Provi-
dence Harbor, which was in progress at the close of the last fiscal year,
was completed March 31, 1909, by the removal of some shoals which
had been left in the original dredging. During the year 152,261
cubic yards of mud were removed, making the net amount removed
under the contract 687,285 cubic yards.
   Work under the contract dated November 11, 1907, with the
Columbia Dredging Company, of New York, N. Y., as shown in detail
under "Contracts in force" below, for dredging the hard material of
Long Bed, both adjacent to the main ship channel and lying within
the southeasterly portion of the anchorage area, which was in progress
at the close of the last fiscal year, was completed November 5, 1908.
During the year 155,718 cubic yards of sand, gravel, and clay and
19.238 cubic yards of bowlders exceeding 1 cubic yard each were re-
moved, making the net amount removed under the contract 382,237
cubic yards of sand, gravel, and clay and 53.696 cubic yards of large
bowlders.
   Under date of November 24, 1908, a contract was entered into with
the J. S. Packard Dredging Company, as shown in detail under "Con-
tracts in force" below, for a small amount of additional dredging on
Long Bed in Providence Harbor. Work under this contract was
commenced December 17, 1908, and completed February 12, 1909.
There was dredged under this contract 64,954 cubic yards of sand,
gravel, and clay and 5.793 cubic yards of large bowlders.
   Operationscontemplatedfor the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910. All
approved projects for.Providence Harbor are completed. The only
work contemplated is that of maintenance.
                                  Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of imin-
provement----------------------------------
              ....................................................-------------.... $30, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.


                                       AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.

                 PROVIDENCE         RIVER      AND HARBOR AND NARRAGANSETT                        BAY.


Previous projects..........------.....................-------------------------...............----------.. $1, 174, 549.00
                                                     .....................
    Received from sale of material---------------------                                           $143.39
    Received by reimbursement from Col. W. R.
      Livermore.................. ... .. .............                                                 8.48
                                                                                                                    151. 87

                                                                                                        1, 174, 700. 87
                             APPENDIX C--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. SANFORD.                                                                                      1017
Existing project:
     June 13, 1902. ...................................                                                                 $100, 000. 00
     March 3, 1905......--....-------...----..............---------------...-------.....                                 100, 000. 00
     June 30, 1906------..........-----------....----....--.......-----------.........                                   305,000.00
     March 2, 1907------..............-------------------------........................                                   90, 750.00
     March 4, 1907----.........-----------------........----........------.......--..                                    102, 778. 00
     March 3, 1909 (allotted April 14, 1903)-...........                                                                  15, 000. 00
                                                                                                                                                   $713, 528. 00
         Received from sale of material ..........................                                                                  .....                  2. 77
             Total ................................                                               .....      ... ...          .........           1, 888, 231. 64
                                                             FOR GREEN                    JACKET          SHOAL.

As shown in House Document 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second
  session, page 312................ ...............................                                                                                     104, 250.00
             Total.......................................................----                                                                     1, 992, 481. 64


                                                             CONTRACTS IN FORCE.
  Contractor: Columbia Dredging Company.
  Work: Dredging.
  Approved: December 6, 1907.
  To commence: In twenty days after receipt of notice of approval.
  Date of expiration: June 30, 1908.
  Quantities: 30,000 cubic yards, at 22 cents.
  Contractor: J. S. Packard Dredging Company.
  Work: Dredging.
  Amount: $50,000 worth, less contingencies.
  Price per cubic yard: 7.3 cents.
  Approved: October 10, 1907.
  To commence: In twenty days after receipt of notice of approval.
  Date of expiration: June 30, 1908.
  Contractor: J. S. Packard Dredging Company.
  Work: About $12,000 worth of dredging, exclusive of cost of supervision and contin-
gencies.
  Price per cubic yard: 18.44 cents.
  Approved: Not approved; this is an emergency contract.
  To commence: Within twenty days after the receipt of notification of award.
  To complete: Within three months of time of commencement, exclusive of the
months of December, January, February, and March.


                                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
  The commerce arriving at and leaving Providence Harbor, Rhode Island, by water,
during the calendar year ending December 31, 1908, is estimated as follows:
             Commerce arriving at and leaving Providence Harbor, calendar year 1908.

                                                                                                                                          Net tons.        Value.

Coal and other fuel .............................                                           .................................             2, 506,602     $14, 501,232
Other minerals and metals..................                                      ......         ...... ..............        .......          41,724          616, 975
Lumber and other building materials..................                                                   ...       ...... ......      .        49,098          742, 694
Fertilizers.....................................................................                                                               1,053           22, 609
Fish, oysters, and oyster shells... -.......                                         ..............................                           49,779          723,585
General merchandise and machinery-.......... ............................                                                                    701, 563     70, 156, 300
Cotton..... ....................................................................                                                              29,755       6, 546,100
          Total...........                ......        ..    .................................                         ........          3,379,574       93,309,495


  Increase over 1907, 325,103 tons.
  Number of passengers carried, 871,284.
  The above figures include all commerce to and from Pawtucket passing through
Providence Harbor.
1018                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                                     S. ARMY.

  The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):


                                                                      Character.                                                                     Number.       Greatest
                                                                                                                                                                   depth.

                                                                                                                                                                     Feet.
Steamers...              .........................................                                    .............................                    6,293             24
Sailing vessels       ...............                              ................................                                   ............        211            26
Barges ............................................................................                                                                    1,275             25
Yachts, motor boats, etc ...........................................................                                                                   3, 500 ..



                                                                                       C      '0.

                   IMPROVEMENT OF NEWPORT HARBOR, RHODE ISLAND.

   For history and project see page 92 of this report.
   Operations during the pastfiscal year.-Work under the continuing
contract with the International Contracting Company, of New
York, N. Y., for dredging the channel through the harbor to a depth
of 18 feet at mean low water and a width of 750 feet, also for extend-
ing the 13-foot anchorage area southerly to the harbor line, all at
the rate of 22 cents per cubic yard, in progress at the close of the
last fiscal year, was continued until June 19, 1909, when the con-
tract was completed. During the fiscal year 322,712 cubic yards of
mud, sand, and clay and 415.304 cubic yards of bowlders exceeding
1 cubic yard each were removed, making a total under the con-
tract of 744,891 cubic yards of mud, sand, and clay and 482.304 cubic
yards of large bowlders.
   In the execution of this contract ledge rock was encountered in
the southern part of the harbor, which at some points projects above
the level of 13 feet depth at mean low water.
   The work of the removal of Nourmahal rock, in Brentons Cove,
Newport Harbor, under the contract with J. K. Sullivan, of Newport,
R. I., dated April 30, 1908, was completed in September, 1908.
   Operations contemplated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-
It is proposed to apply the existing balance to the removal of those
portions of the ledge rock which form the most dangerous obstruc-
tions.
                                                             AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
Previous projects:
     As shown in House Document 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second
       session, page 312 ............. ............................... $234, 841. 67
     March 3, 1905 (allotted March 19, 1906) .............. ........     10, 000. 00
                                                                                                                                                           244, 841. 67
Existing project:
     March 2, 1907 ..............................      ....... $85, 000. 00
     May 27, 1908-......................  .................... 112, 100. 00
     March 4, 1909-......................................... 53, 800. 00
                                                                                                                                                           250, 900. 00
Received from sale of material.................                                                                    ......................                        8. 52

               Total ......................................................... 495, 750. 19
                           APPENDIX 0---REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. SANFORD.                                                                                            1019
                                                              CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

   Contractor: The International Contracting Company. (Continuing contract.)
   Amount and character of work: About 582,000 cubic yards of dredging.
   Rate per cubic yard: Twenty-two cents.
   Date of approval: December 30, 1907.
   To commence: In twenty days after date of notice of approval.
   To complete: December 31, 1909.
   Contractor: J. K. Sullivan.
   Character of work: Removal of ledge rock to depth of 18 feet mean low water.
   Lump sum: $6,450.
   Date of approval: May 14, 1908.
   To commence: In twenty days after date of notice of approval.
   To complete: In three months.


                                                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
  The commerce arriving at and leaving Newport Harbor, Rhode Island, by water
during the calendar year ending December 31, 1908, is estimated as follows:
                   Commerce arriving at and leaving Newport Harbor, calendaryear 1908.

                                                                                                                                                      Tons.      Value.

Coal and other fuel ..  ..........................................                                                                                    122,879     $624, 046
Lumber and other building materials ..                 .............                              ..............................                       37, 313      63, 206
Live stock and products ..................                                         ...................................                                  1,748 1,008, 880
Fertilizers ...................  ....................                          ........   ....                                                             486       14, 580
Fish, oysters, etc...............................................................................                                                       9, 943      782, 127
General merchandise and machinery ............................................                                                                         34, 211   6, 753, 325
          Total..................                                            .        ..............................                                  200,530    9,246,164


  In addition to the local commerce given above an estimated amount of 2,041,293
tons, having an estimated value of $52,924,400, passed through the harbor and used it'
as a harbor of refuge. Total increase over 1907, 136,233 tons.
   Number of passengers carried, 242,573.
  The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):


                                                                 Character.                                                                          Number. totale.
                                                                                                                                                             tonnage.

Steamers .......                     .....               .................................................                                              2,214    4,966,800
      .....
Tugs........     . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . . . . ....                                     . . .               .   .   ..      1,674      239,385
Loaded barges.........................................................                                                                                  1,624    1,203,650
Light barges.................................................                                                  ..................                       2,441      976,900
Loaded schooners .................................................................                                                                        574       127,125
Light schooners........................                          .............................................                                          1,250       301,900
Steam yachts ...........                        ...............................                                          ..............                 2,029      553,475
Sailing yachts ........................................................                                                                                 1,659       113,950
Mud scows ...........................................................                                                                                   1,264    1,139,900



                                                                                      C       II.

                HARBOR OF REFUGE AT POINT JUDITH, RHODE ISLAND.
  For history and project see page 93 of this report.
  Operations during the past fiscal year.--The work of placing stone
in the eastern shore arm breakwater under the continuing contract of
the Sea Coast Construction Company, of New York, N. Y., in prog-
ress at the beginning of the fiscal year was continued until January
11, 1909, when the contract was completed.
1020             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   During the fiscal year 59,036.22 tons of stone were placed, making
a total under the contract of 111,100.07 tons.
   Under date of August 28, 1908, contracts were entered into for
repairing the main breakwater with E. S. Belden & Sons, of Hart-
ford, Conn., for furnishing and placing stone on the main breakwater,
and with the T. A. Scott Company, of New London, Conn., for the
use of lighter for replacing stone that had been displaced by the sea.
   Under the Belden contract 3,496.33 tons of stone were delivered
at $1.97 per ton, and under the Scott contract twenty-three days' work
were performed at $65 per day.
   The commissioners to assess the cost of the land condemned to
the uses of the United States at the shore end of the breakwater held
a hearing in Providence, R. I., May 27 and 28, 1909.
    Three small lights were maintained on the breakwater by the
Engineer Department.
    Operations contemplatedfor the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-
Only work of maintenance is contemplated at present.                                                               Further work
of improvement will depend upon the action taken by Congress upon
the project printed as House Document 911, Sixtieth Congress, first
session.
                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
provement.........--------.....-------------------------------------------........................................... $20, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                             AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
September 19, 1890----...---..-...-----...----..............-----------------.........------.......---..                    $75, 000. 00
July 13, 1892.........-------------......--..........---...............---............                                       75,000.00
March 3, 1893-------------------------------------------------.......................................................       100, 000.00
August 18, 1894..........---------------.....-------------...............---.....-----------------...............           100, 000. 00
March 8, 1895-----..---...............------------..--------.........--...------.......--......--.......   ---------        300, 000.00
June 11, 1896.......................................--------------------------------------...------------.........          300, 000. 00
                       --------------------------------------------------
June 4, 1897 .......................................................                                                        300,000.00
June 13, 1902.........-------.................----------------....---....-----...........------..-------....                100, 000. 00
March 3, 1905---..--....------------------------...........................----------------..................               100, 000. 00
June 30, 1906........................-------------------------...------.........-------------...............--              100, 000.00
March 2, 1907...........------.....----------------------........-----------------...............                           100, 000. 00
May 27, 1908---..-..---------------------------.............................----....---.............----------------...     170, 000. 00
March 2, 1907, allotted August 8, 1908-----........--------...................---------------.                               10,000. 00
March 3, 1909, allotted March 29, 1909---...............--                               -----....-----.........             10, 000. 00
      Total...-------------................------------............................---------------------......--          1, 840, 000. 00
Received from sale of material ......................................                                                              43. 61

                                                                                                                          1, 840, 043.61

                       CONTRACT IN FORCE (CONTINUING CONTRACT).

   Contractor: Sea Coast Construction Company.
   Character of work: Breakwater extension.
  Amount: About $260,000 worth.
   Rate per ton of 2,000 pounds stone in place: $2.18.
   Date of approval: June 5, 1907.
  To commence: In thirty days after date of notification of approval.
  To complete: In ten months after said date of notification, excepting the months
of December, January, February, and March, and period awaiting appropriations,
                        APPENDIX C-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. SANFORD.                                                                          1021

                                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
  The tonnage of vessels passing Point Judith, R. I., during the calendar year end-
ing December 31, 1908, is estimated as follows (based upon reports received from
Mr. Amos P. Tefft, keeper Point Judith life-saving station, Point Judith, R. I.):

                           Tonnage of vessels passing Point Judith, calendar year 1908.
                                                                                                                                   Gross tons.
Steamers (freight, fish, and passenger) .....                                 ..             .        ....            ...... . 9, 100, 000
Yachts (steam and sail)--.........---------------------------------------- . 1, 500, 000
Schooners (2 to 6 masts)---..---------.......----------------------------                                            ....        32, 100, 000
Ships, barks, brigs, barkentines, etc.- .................................                                                            200, 000
Sloops-------------....----...........----....---...---------------------------------------.....................................      50,000
Barges-------..------...........--------------...................-------............--------.....-------------..                  7,700, 000
          Total--......                    ------.............                -----..------........         ............          50, 650, 000
   No change from 1907.
   Number of vessels passing Point Judith during the hours of daylight in the calendar
year 1908 is estimated from the same reports as follows:
Schooners------.........----...----------........ 4, 840 Revenue cutters .................                               36
Steamers--------..           ---.................-----------.         5, 756 War vessels ......................          59
Barges............                      .............-- 7,050 Torpedo boats ....................                         44
Sloops.........---------------........---.......------2, 013 Government survey boats.........                            22
Brigs--------------........            ------.............-------.         5 Submarines......................            18
Barks.............--------------------.......------......-.               10 Government tugs ................            11
Ships-.........................                                            2 Navy transports ..................           2
Light-house tenders- -----... ---                                  -.     79 United States colliers          -..........  3

   It is estimated that one-half as many more passed during the hours of darkness.
Table of vessels entering and leaving Point Judith harbor of refuge during the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909, exclusive of the contractor's plant, each entrance and depar-
  ture being counted as one.

                                                                     Tugs.    Barges.Barges.
                                                                                        Schoon-
                                                                                          ers.              Sloops. Steam-Yawls.           Total.
                                                                                                                     ers.

                       1908.
July------------              --------------------------------.....                                   34          18        4        1          57
August----------                ------------..------                1        .21                                  68        4        2          96
September-           -....-.....-....--...... .....                 3          2                      23           3        7        3          41
October-...--------.---------------------                           2          1                      19           2        6        2          32
November.....-------------------.........- -----..........          3          8                      17           2        2 ........          32
December.--------------...
                       ..........--......         ..----....-- ...------------
                                                                       ......--..                     25           2        2 ........          29
                           1909.
January --...--------.. -.. -----------------------    ---                            -----           11 ......             1 .....             12
February...----------.....-----------------         1                                                  5         1          3 ........          10
March.-..-----------...----------------.            1                                  2              12         2          1 .......           18
April-...-----------------------.-------1             ......                                          28        17          5          1        52
May...---------.--.-------------------------        3                                  9              52        11         16          1        92
June----..----------------------                    1 ...                                             54       23          13          1        92

       Total..........................--                         .      16            22              301       149        64      11         563


  From the above table it appears that the harbor is comparatively little used by
tugs and barges, and its greatest use by other vessels is in the summer months.


                                                                         C    12.
   IMPROVEMENT OF ENTRANCE TO POINT JUDITH POND, RHODE
                         ISLAND.
    For history, see page 96 of this report.
  Operations during the past fiscal year.-No work of improvement
has been in progress during the past fiscal year.
1022            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Operations contemplated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-
No further work is contemplated.
                                            AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
July 13, 1892..............................                                  ...............         .........                       $7, 500
August 18, 1894.................................. ........................                                                            2, 500
March 3, 1905......                 .............         ............................                                                2,000
M arch 2, 1907.......... ...-.... .......................                            ...................                              8, 000
         Total........................ ....                           .........          ........................                    20, 000




                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  For commercial statistics for this locality, see report for improving harbor at Point
Judith, Rhode Island.


                                                                 C 13.

          HARBOR OF REFUGE AT BLOCK ISLAND, RHODE ISLAND.

  For history and project, see page 97 of this report.
  Operations during the past fiscal year.-Lights were maintained at
the entrance to the harbor during the year by the Engineer Depart-
ment.
  Proposals for dredging for maintenance were received June 28,
1909.
  Operations contemplatedfor the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-
Maintenance of depth in the harbor.
                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for mainte-
   nance of improvement-----------------------                                    ---------------....                   ..       $12, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.




                                            AMOUNTS APPROPRIATED.
Previous projects..........          ...........          .........................                                       ...   $401, 500. 00
Existing project:
    June 3, 1896....................                  ....................                                  $5, 000. 00
    March 3, 1899--................ .........................                                               10, 000. 00
    June 6, 1900 (allotted April 18, 1902) .................                                                 4, 500. 00
    June 13, 1902 .........---.........-----...................                                             30, 000. 00
    March 3, 1905..............---         ..........     ........      .......                             50, 000. 00
    March 2, 1907 ..........           ........... ........... ........                                     20, 000.00
    March 3, 1909 (allotted April 9, 1909) ...................                                              12, 500. 00
                                                                                                                                 132, 000. 00

    Total ........  ...............................................                                                              533, 500. 00
Amount returned to United States Treasury... ...............                                                        .........      2, 108. 83

         Total .......................................................                                                           531, 391. 17
                            APPENDIX C-R EPORT OF LIEUT. COL. SANFORD.                                                                                          1023

                                                           COMMERCIAL                          STATISTICS.

  The commerce arriving at and leaving Block Island Harbor, R. I., by water dur-
ing the calendar year ending December 31, 1908, is estimated as follows:

              Commerce arriving at and leaving Block Island Harbor, calendar year 1908.

                                                                                                                                                   Tons.       Value.

Coal and other fuel ..........................                                       ..........                  ... ........            .....      3,663       $35, 528
Lumber and other building materials....                                                                                                             1, 413       17, 360
Grain and forage-.- -.. ......................--...........                                                     .....-                                 475       16, 625
Live stock and products-                                      ...
                                                      --.......         .....-.......--.---....- .........---                                          40         8,000
Fertilizers.................--------------..-....------............---------------...-------------.....................------------.............      110         3, 300
Fish, oysters, etc....................................................................                                                              3,150       210,000
General merchandise and machinery ---.......---------........--------..........-------.............-----------......                                3,010       301,000
          Total..---------..----........--------------------.........--------......----------------11,861                                                        91,873..............


  No statistics were obtained in 1907.
  Number of passengers carried, 42,419.
  The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):


                                                        Character.                                                                 Number. Greatest              Total
                                                                                                                                            draft.             tonnage,

                                                                                                                                                   Feet.
Steamers........-----------------------------------------------------                                                                        310           9     88,810
Sailing vessels ...------------------------------------------------                                                                      2, 546        11        26, 660
Yachts, motor boats, etc                          ----------------------------------------                                               9,240          9        80,020


                                                                                      C 14.

IMPROVEMENT OF GREAT SALT POND, BLOCK ISLAND, RHODE ISLAND.

      For history and project, see page 98 of this report.
  Operations during the past fiscal year.-United States dredge
Gedney recently transferred to this district was engaged June 29
and 30 in dredging in the entrance to the Great Salt Pond; 1,751
cubic yards were removed during that time.
      Operations contemplated for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910.-
Maintenance of depth in the entrance channel, and dredging and
jetty construction as provided in the existing project.
                                                     Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of
improvement..............................-----------------------------------------. $105,000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
4, 1897.
                                                           AMOUNTS                     APPROPRIATED.
June 3, 1896..--...............-------------.................------------------...........-----------...........                                               $40, 0001
March 3, 1899-.--------------------------------......---------..........----.............---------------.........                                              50, 000
June 13, 1902---.........---------------....--.............-------------...----......-----.....------------...-----.                                           50, 000
March 3, 1905------..........----------------....-----.....-----......---........---------..---....---.............                                            30, 000
March 2, 1907...------..-----..............------------------.................------------.............------..........                                        30, 000
March 3, 1909 (allotted April 10, 1909)..................................                                                                                      12, 500

              Total .......................................................                                                                                    212, 500
i024               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                            U.   S. ARII&Y.

                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The commerce arriving at and leaving Great Salt Pond Harbor, Block Island, R. I.,
by water during the calendar year ending December 31, 1908, is estimated as follows:

Commerce arriving at and leaving Great Salt Pond Harbor, Block Island, calendar year
                                                                             1908.


                                                                                                                               Tons.       Value.


Coal and other fuel...2...0..7 ..                                                              07   15,925
                                                                                                     5....................................
Lumber and other building materials ...................................             .......    550   6,800
Grain and forage-----.....--....-------..............---------------....--.......................... 6,450
Live stock and products ................     .........        .................................. 85 20,000
Fertilizers            --------------------------------------.................-----------------------                               55         1,650
Fish, oysters,                                                             4, 800  320, 000
             etc..---------------.....---------.................--------------................-------
General merchandise and machinery .............................................                                                  2, 656     265, 600
       Total ..................................                                       .......................                   10, 458     636, 425


  No statistics were available for the report for 1908.
  Number of passengers carried, 104,499.
  The vessels entering and leaving this waterway are as follows (each entrance and
departure together being counted as one):

                                                                                                                              Greatest       Total
                                                  Character.                                                     Number.       draft       tonnage.


                                                                                                                               Feet.
Steamers.  .............................                                  .          ......................
                                                                                   .....                                485        18        199,248
Sailing vessels.............................                           ...........       .................           6, 620        18        155, 200
Yachts, motor boats, etc.....                        ..............................                                  4,720           172      34, 400


                                                                            C I5.
REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDAN-
                  GERING NAVIGATION.

    (a) Schooner Harry Messer was a three-masted wooden schooner
loaded with soft coal. She had sunk on the northeastern part of
"Handkerchief Shoal," near the eastern entrance to Nantucket Sound,
Massachusetts, in from 18 to 22 feet of water. Her dimensions were
153.7 feet length, 35.5 feet beam, and 15.8 feet deep, and of 627 tons
gross. The work of removal commenced February 10 and was com-
pleted March 1, 1909, to the depth of the surrounding bottom. The
total cost of removal was $898.99.
    (b) Steamer Horatio Hall, of 3,167 gross tons, was sunk in collision
with steamer H. F. Dimocle in a dense fog March 10, 1909, in about
26 feet of water, in Pollock Rip Slue, about 1 mile south by east from
the bell buoy on the "broken part of Pollock Rip." She was loaded
with a miscellaneous cargo. The wreck was reported as an obstruc-
tion to navigation March 29, 1909, previous to which date a part of
the cargo had been removed by the Boston Tow Boat Company,
under contract with the cargo underwriters. Allotment of $7,000 for
the removal was made April 2; work was commenced April 12 and
completed June 28, 1909. The total cost of removal was $3,441.56.
    (c) Schooner Jennie French Potter, a five-masted schooner, loaded
with coal. She had sunk on "Half Moon Shoal," the eastern end of
 "Horse Shoe Shoa," about 1i miles north-northeast of Cross Rip
            APPENDIX C-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. SANFORD.                     1025
light ship, Nantucket Sound, Massachusetts, in about 18 feet of water.
Her dimensions were 257.7 feet length, 44.3 feet beam, and 21 feet
depth, and of 1,993 gross tons.        The wreck was reported as a dan-
gerous obstruction to navigation and removal recommended June 28,
1909.
  All work of removal of wrecks was performed by the government
diver and outfit and a hired boat and crew.

                    EMERGENCY CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contractor: George W. Crowell.
  Amount and character of work: Furnishing schooner and equipment for removal of
wrecks, as may be needed.
  Rate: $20 per day.
  Date of approval: No approval required. Dated February 6, 1909.
  To commence: As required by the engineer officer in charge.
  To complete: One year after date.
      9001-ENG 1909--65
                                APPENDIX D.


IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE 
   NEW LONDON, CONNECTICUT, DISTRICT.



REPOR T OF LIE UT. COL. HARR Y TA YLOR, CORPS OFENGINEERS, OFFI-
  CER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.

                                  IMPROVEMENTS.

1.   Pawcatuck River, Rhode Island and       9. Construction of breakwaters at New
       Connecticut.                               Haven, Connecticut.
2.   New London Harbor, Connecticut.        10. Milford Harbor, Connecticut.
3.   Thames River, Connecticut.             11. Housatonic River, Connecticut.
4.   Connecticut River, between Hartford,   12. Bridgeport Harbor, Connecticut.
       Connecticut, and Holyoke, Massa-     13. Norwalk Harbor, Connecticut.
       chusetts.                            14. Harbors at Fivemile River, Stamford,
5.   Connecticut River, below Hartford,           Southport, Greenwich, and West-
        Connecticut.                              port, and Saugatuck River, Con-
6.   Harbor of refuge, Duck Island, Con-          necticut.
       necticut.                            15. Removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
7.   Branford Harbor, Connecticut.                structing or endangering navigation.
8.   New Haven Harbor, including West
       River, Connecticut.



                                UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                New London, Conn., July 19, 1909.
  SIR: I have the honor to transmit herewith annual report of the
works of river and harbor improvements in my charge for the year
ending June 30, 1909.
      Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                        HARRY TAYLOR,
                                              Lieut. Col., Corps of Engineers.
     The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.


                                       D i.

       IMPROVEMENT OF PAWCATUCK RIVER, RHODE ISLAND AND
                         CONNECTICUT.

  At the beginning of the fiscal year operations were in progress under
the contract made with The T. A. Scott Company (Incorporated) for
the restoration of the channel at Westerly, R. I., increasing the width
and depth of the channel across Little Narragansett Bay, and increas-
ing the width and depth of the river channel below Westerly as far as
available funds would permit. On September 10 a channel 100 feet
                                                                           1027
1028      REPORT OF THIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                U.   S. ARMY.

wide and 10 feet deep had been excavated from about 700 feet east
of Folly Beacon to deep water at the mouth of Pawcatuck River,
except at two places, one opposite Pawcatuck Point, the other about
600 feet easterly. Opposite Pawcatuck Point, for a distance of about
200 feet, numerous bowlders were found and a small ledge was uncov-
ered. At the second place, about 600 feet easterly, a ridge of bowlders
about 100 feet in length and 40 feet wide was found.
  March 27, 1909, an agreement was made with The T. A. Scott Com-
pany (Incorporated) for the removal of the ledge opposite Pawcatuck
Point, estimated to contain 54 cubic yards, and all material of what-
ever character within an area having a width of 75 feet and a length
of 100 feet along the channel, for the lump sum of $1,850. This work
was begun June 1, and was in progress at the end of the fiscal year.
   September 10, 1908, dredging was begun in the river at Avondale,
about 1 miles above the mouth. On June'19, 1909, the available
funds for dredging being nearly exhausted, work was suspended and
the dredge taken to the mouth of the river, where it was employed for
two days in an unsuccessful attempt to remove one of the hard shoals.
June 22 the dredge was withdrawn from the work. The river channel,
100 feet wide and 10 feet deep, had been excavated upstream for a
distance of about 6,800 feet. About 2,000 feet remains to be dredged
in order to connect with the dredging done in 1900.
   Opposite Certain Draw Point, in the middle of the channel, a
small ledge, estimated to contain 14 cubic yards, was uncovered.
The shoalest point found on this ledge was 8.2 feet. Just above
Pawcatuck Rocks, on the west side of the channel, another ledge or
cluster of bowlders was uncovered from 1 to 2 feet shoal.
   During the year 19,336 cubic yards of earth and 47.28 cubic yards
of bowlders were removed from Little Narragansett Bay, and 60,966
cubic yards of earth and 2.21 cubic yards of bowlders were removed
from Pawcatuck River, making a total of 62,426 cubic yards of earth
and 37.14 cubic yards of bowlders in the river and 58,987 cubic yards
of earth and 65.82 cubic yards of bowlders in the bay, or a grand total
under this contract of 121,413 cubic yards of earth and 102.96 cubic
yards of bowlders. A few scattering bowlders are yet to be removed
under this contract.
   A survey was made of nearly all the shore line from Stonington
Point to the mouth of the Pawcatuck River on the north side of the
bay, and of Sandy Point on the south side; also of the west side of
Pawcatuck River from the mouth to Davis' dock, and. on the east
side from the mouth to a point just below Pawcatuck Rocks 2
miles above the mouth. Soundings were closely taken along the
channel from Stonington Point across Little Narragansett Bay to
the mouth of Pawcatuck River and from there up the river about 3
miles to the end of the dredging.
                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
    For works of improvement..--................-....... -$12, 000.00
    For maintenance of improvement.......................       3,000. 00
                                                                       - $15, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                             APPENDIX D--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. TAYLOR.                                                                                        1029

                                                                         APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriations for previous projects a .....................................                                        $98, 400
June 3, 1896.......
June      1896                .............         ......        .........
                        ------------------------------------------------           ............ ........              15, 000
                                                                                                                      15, 000
March 3, 1899.........-------------------------...........................---........---------...........--------..  15, 000
June 13, 1902 ..........          .......    .................. ......................                                9,000
April 28, 1904 (allotted August 1, 1904) ..........................                                       .......     4, 100
March 3, 1905 (near Watch Hill) ..............................                                         ............ 1, 000
March 2, 1907..........----------------........-------------.............----                                        33,000
            Total.............................................................                                                                               175,500


                                                                   CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contractor: The T. A. Scott Company (Incorporated).
  Dredging and removing bowlders: Yardage indefinite.
  Date of contract: March 25, 1908.
  Date of approval: April 15, 1908.
  Date of beginning work: March 31, 1908.
  Date of expiration: January 16, 1909 (time limit waived).
  Rate per cubic yard: Dredging, 214 cents; bowlders exceeding 1 cubic yard,
each, $10.

                                 COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1908.

                       [Compiled from reports furnished by shippers and receivers at Westerly, R. I.]
                                                                       Receipts and shipments.

                                                                               Articles.                                                                    Quantity.

                                                                                                                                                             Net tons.
Coal...                        ..................................                            ..................................                                 50,039
Paving blocks..................                                                   ..........                                         ......                        2.................
                                                                                                                                                                 1,204
Lumber.........--...------.......................................................                                                                                5,220
Building material-.......-...1.......8..8....................................                                                                                    1,880
Miscellaneous---------..-........----..---...--...----..--....................---------------------.......------------...................--.......                 694
         Total..............................................................                                                                          ...       59,037


  Valuation of tonnage, $203,775.53.
   Number of passengers, 7,500.
   Increase of 5,737 net tons, or about 11 per cent, compared with amount reported
previous year, due to more coal reported handled. The increase is affected by con-
siderable decrease in tonnage of lumber reported handled.


                                                                                          D 2.

            IMPROVEMENT OF NEW LONDON HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

     No work of improvement was done during the fiscal year.
                                                                         APPROPRIATIONS.
June 13, 1902........................................................-----                                                                                   $25,   000
March 3, 1903..........................................................-                                                                                      60,   000
April 28, 1904..........................................................                                                                                      60,   000
March 3, 1905.....--......... .............                              ......... ....... ...............--                                         --        2,   000

             Total.................                                    .........................                   ................                         b 47, 000

   a See pages 353 and 354 of House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress,
second session.
   b Includes $3,600 carried to surplus fund.
1030                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                                 S. ARMY.

                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1908.

                                     [Compiled from reports furnished by shippers and receivers.]

                                                               Receipts and shipments.

                                                                        Articles.                                                                              Quantity.


                                                                                                                                                               Net tons.
Coal              ................................................................                                                                               230,233
Lumber.......              ...             ....................................................................                                      .......       11,015
Oil and empty barrels ..........................................................                                                                                   14, 489
Iron pipe ....................................................................................                                                                          99
Brick, cement, etc.........23...........                                                         .................................                                  8,623
Miscellaneous ..................................................................................                                                                    5,163
Steamboat freight.....................................                                                . ..................................                       477,345

         Total ................                                    ...........                           ..............................                           746,967


  Value of tonnage, $12,753,777.83.
  Number of passengers, 583,466.
  Increase of 19,596 net tons, or about 2 per cent, compared with amount reported
previous year, due to more brick, etc., miscellaneous and steamboat freight reported
handled. The increase is affected by a decrease in tonnage of all other articles
reported.
                                       [Furnished by collector of customs, port of New London.]
Value of imports .............                                ..............................                                                               $16, 880. 58
Duty on imports.....................................................                                                                                            843. 49
Foreign vessels:
    Entered...........                                ............................................--                                                                    3
    Cleared --------................                             .......................................                                                                4

             Total...--.                         ...........................................-                                                                           7

Coastwise vessels:
    Entered..........................................................                                                                                                   3
    Cleared...........................................................                                                                                                  2

             Total-.....                  ...         -....................................                                                  .....                      5

American vessels from foreign ports:
   Entered.......---------..................................................                                                                                            3
   Cleared......   ...-.................................................                                                                                                2

             Total.............                              ..          ................................                                                               5


                                                                                  D 3.
                        IMPROVEMENT OF THAMES RIVER, CONNECTICUT.
   Dredging was begun at Bartletts Crossover August 4, 1908, by the
Atlantic Dredging Company, of New York, under contract dated
March 25, 1908. By October 6 a channel had been dredged across
the shoal 200 feet wide and 20 feet deep. October 7 work was begun
on the shoal between Gales Ferry and Allyns Point and completed
November 7. A channel 200 feet wide and 20 feet deep was made.
November 9 the dredge was moved to the lower entrance of Bart-
letts Crossover for the purpose of widening the entrance on the west
side. The contract was completed November 20, 1908. Eighteen
thousand five hundred and eighteen cubic yards was removed between
Gales Ferry and Allyns Point, 56,965 cubic yards at Bartletts Cross-
over, and 7,885 cubic yards at the lower entrance, making a total of
83,368 cubic yards. The price paid was 14.3 cents per cubic yard.
   A survey was made and platted covering the area dredged.
                      APPENDIX D--REPORT OF LIEUT.                                     COL. TAYLOR.               1031
                                      Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
  of improvement..................................................        $10,000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                               APPROPRIATIONS.
Appropriations for previous proj-                                       August 5, 1886...............        $22, 500
                                $40, 300
  ect a .........................                                       August 11, 1888.............. 50, 000
June 23, 1866..................  10,000                                 September 19, 1890........... 20, 000
March 3, 1867. ..............    72, 000                                July 13, 1892_................. 30, 000
March 3, 1871................    15, 000                                August 18, 1894............... 12, 500
June 10, 1872.................. 10, 000                                 June 3, 18968.................. 12,000
June 18, 1878................    10, 000                                March 3, 1899. .........        ....  20, 000
March 3, 1879.................   12, 000                                June 13, 1902 ................        15, 000
June 14, 1880...............     22, 500                                March 3, 1905 .................       34, 100
March 3, 1881.................   30, 000                                March 2, 1907................         30, 000
August 2, 1882. ...............  35, 000
July 5, 1885...................  25, 000                                           Total.................... 527, 900


                                            CONTRACT IN                        FORCE.

   Contractor: Atlantic Dredging Company.
   Dredging: Yardage removed, 83,368.
   Date of contract: March 25, 1908.
   Date of approval: April 15, 1908.
   Date for beginning work: June 16, 1908.
   Date of completion: November 20, 1908.
   Rate: 14.3 cents per cubic yard.



                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1908.
                               [Compiled from reports furnished by shippers and receivers.]
                                              Receipts and shipments.

                                                      Articles.                                                 Quantity.

                                                                                                                Net tons.
Coal......................................................................................                        394, 352
Lumber...............................................--................................................. ....      21,858
Building material...................              ........................................                             950
Ground wood and wood pulp .........                 ............................................                       673
Paper stock.................................                                                              ..        4,264
Molding sand..........................................................................................                 560
Miscellaneous ...................... .. ....... ..............................................                         174
Steamboat freight...........................................................................                       20, 564
      Total................                   ..................................                  ...........    a 443, 395

   aIncludes 22,109 net tons of coal, 390 net tons of building material, and 62 net tons of miscellaneous mate-
rial due to Shaws Cove traffic, or a total of 22,561 net tons, valued at $121,380.50.
  Valuation of tonnage reported, $2,265,350.51.
  Number of passengers, 39,696.
  The tonnage reported shows a decrease of 70,703 net tons, or about 14 per cent, from
that reported for previous year.
   In 1908 the People's Steamboat Company, of Norwich, Conn., put on a new boat,
the Sight Seer, making two trips daily between Norwich, New London, Ocean Beach,
and Crescent Beach, carrying passengers and any freight which may be offered. The
steamer runs from the last week in June to the first week in September.

   aSee page 241 of House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second session.
1032        REPORT      OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                          S. ARMY.

                                              D 4.
IMPROVEMENT OF CONNECTICUT RIVER BETWEEN HARTFORD, CON-
         NECTICUT, AND HOLYOKE, MASSACHUSETTS.

   Report of an investigation made in compliance with the act of
March 2, 1907, was submitted October 31, 1908, and a report of a
preliminary examination made in compliance with the act of March
3, 1909, was submitted May 19, 1909.
   No work of improvement was in progress during the year.
                                     APPROPRIATIONS.

July 11, 1870. ................ $20, 000           June 13, 1902 (survey)............ $25, 000
March 3, 1871-................   20, 000           March 2, 1907 .................      5,000
June 10, 1872_................. 25, 000
March 3, 1873 ................   20,000                    Total.. ..................                130,000
June 14, 1880..................  15, 000


                                              D 5.
IMPROVEMENT            OF CONNECTICUT RIVER BELOW                             HARTFORD,                CON-
                                 NECTICUT.

   At the beginning of the fiscal year dredging operations were in prog-
ress for the maintenance of channels through the river bars. This
work was continued until October 17, 1908. Seventy-nine thousand
two hundred and seventy-five cubic- yards were removed during the
fiscal year at a cost of 11 cents per cubic yard.
   The dredging was done at the following places:
Hartford:                           Cubic yards.                                                Cubic yards.
    Upper bar...................         9, 626    Dividend bar.................                       5, 911
    Lower bar .....                     23, 960
                                ..--------------   Pistol Point bar. ..............                    2, 702
Clay banks bar. .... -....-....          7, 977    Mouse Island bar. ..............                    1, 179
Press Barn bar-................ 16, 312            Potash Shoal bar...............                     1, 928
Two Piers:
    Upper bar...........-....-..         3, 523           Total...-----.....------.....-----......    79, 275
    Lower bar......-....- ....  -        6, 157

  On May 20, 1909, a contract was made with the Hartford and New
York Transportation Company for the annual maintenance dredging
in the river bars, at 11 cents per cubic yard. Under this contract up
to June 30, 1909, 25,205 cubic yards had been removed as follows:
                                    Cubic yards.                                                Cubic yards.
Hartford lower bar............... 6, 595           Pistol Point bar...............                     5, 028
Press Barn bar..................  10, 546
Dividend bar.................... 3, 036                   Total...................               .. 25, 205

   The work of raising the Hartford dike with the U. S. lighter Panuco,
in progress at the beginning of the fiscal year, was continued until
December 9, 1908. Ten thousand three hundred and forty-five gross
tons of stone had been placed at the end of the season. The stone
was obtained from the Brainerd, Shaler & Hall Quarry Company, of
Portland, Conn., at a cost of 60 cents per gross ton, delivered on the
dock. The height of the dike at the beginning of work varied from
0.1 to 4.8 feet, with an average height of less than 2 feet above low
water. At the close of the season about 900 feet had been built to a
              APPENDIX D--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. TAYLOR.                        1033
height of between 9 and 10 feet and about 2,200 feet to a height of
between 6 and 7 feet.
   Hartford upper bar is opposite that portion of the dike raised to a
height of 9 to 10 feet. Last season it was necessary to dredge 9,626
cubic yards of sand to obtain a suitable channel over this bar, while
this season comparatively little dredging, if any, will be necessary.
Hartford lower bar, opposite that portion of the dike which was
raised to 6 and 7 feet, required the removal of 34,761 cubic yards of
sand last season.   Up to June 30 of the present season 6,595 cubic
yards of sand have been dredged and a good channel 50 feet wide
obtained. It is probable, however, that later this channel will be
increased in width to 100 feet, but the amount dredged will be small
as compared with the previous season's work.
  June 3, 1909, an open-market agreement was made with the Brain-
erd, Shaler & Hall Quarry Company for furnishing 3,000 gross tons of
large stone delivered on their dock at 60 cents per ton and for 3,000
gross tons of "hand dump stone" to be dumped onto the lighter from
chutes at 60 cents per ton. Work was begun with the Panuco June
11, 1909, and at the close of the fiscal year 308 tons of large stone and
1,127 tons of small stone, or a total of 1,435 tons, had been placed on
the dike, making a total of 11,780 tons for the year, or 13,962 tons
since the work of raising the dike was started September 19, 1907.
                         Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement ............................... $30, 000
   For maintenance of improvement .....................
                                                   ............ ..  12, 000
                                                                              $42, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                 APPROPRIATIONS.
Appropriations for previous                   April 28, 1904 (allotted August 1,
  projects a.................     $393, 670     1904).....................       $11,000
August 12, 1888.....-.-.-...- .. 10, 000      April 28, 1904 (allotted Novem-
September 19, 182,0........         12, 500     ber 10, 1904) .................. 1, 000
July 13, 1892......_ -.......       20, 000   March 3,1905--.....-............ 40, 000
August 18, 1894...........- ...     20, 000                                       40,000
                                              March 2,1907...------------...............
June 3,1896... ............... 20, 000        March 3,1909 (allotted March 17,
March 3,1899---.................    20, 000     1909)..............               15, 000
                                                                       ...................
July 6, 1900 (allotted   day  24,
  1902)........................      2,000         Total.................. 635, 170
June 13, 1902 ................      30, 000


                               CONTRACTS IN FORCE.
  Contractor: The Hartford and New York Transportation Company.
  Dredging: Yardage, 110,388.
  Date of contract: April 8, 1908.
  Date of approval: May 6,1908.
  Date of beginning work: May 25, 1908.
  Date of completion: October 17, 1908.
  Rate: 11 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
  a See page 338 of House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second session.
1034                     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                                               S. ARMY.

     Contractor: The Hartford and New York Transportation Company.
     Dredging: Yardage, approximate, 90,000.
     Date of contract: May 20, 1909.
     Date of approval: June 3, 1909.
     Date of beginning work: June 1, 1909.
     Date of expiration: October 31, 1909.
     Rate: 11 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.



                                     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1908.

                                                                          Receipts and shipments.

                                                                                  Articles.                                                                                    Quantity.

                                                                                                                                                                               Net tons.
Coal......................................................................                                                                                                       330,382
Brown stone, granite, feldspar, etc....................                                                       ....................................                                 31, 360
Lime, cement, brick, tile, and pipe ...                                          ..........................................                                               ..       13, 440
Lumber, poles, ties, piles, and wood.. ...............-......                                                                         ...................                          34, 720
Fertilizer-................................................                                                                                                    ........            16,800
Nail rod..............                                ........................................................                                                                      2, 785
Steamboat freight ...........................................................................                                                                                      86, 094
           Total.....................                                  ..........................................                                                                515,581


   Valuation, $14,001, 989.
   Number of passengers, 61,314.
   Decrease of 28,407 net tons, or about 5 per cent, compared with amount reported
previous year, due to less coal and stone reported handled. All other classes of
freight show an increase for the year.



                                                                                               D 6.

IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR OF REFUGE, DUCK ISLAND, CONNECTICUT.

   No contract work was done during the fiscal year. An inspection
of this breakwater made June 16, 1909, showed that the westerly half
of the breakwater has suffered considerably from wave attack since
the last work, which was in the nature of repairs, was done in the
fall of 1905. The damage done is probably due to the breakwater
never having been built to full contemplated cross section, and in a
number of places partial breaches have been made by the seas, sev-
eral of these breaks extending down nearly to high-water level and
in one or two cases to slightly below high water. In order to pre-
vent further deterioration and to render the breakwater serviceable
for the purpose for which it was built, it is proposed to expend the
available balance in repairing it by the delivery and placing of new
riprap stone and the replacing and trimming of some of the stone
now on the breakwater.
                                                                             APPROPRIATIONS.

September 19, 1890.....................................................                    $25, 000
July 13, 1892 .............................................................                 35, 000
August 18, 1894..........................................                   ..... ........  30, 000
June 3, 1896...................................................................... - 24, 000
June 6, 1900 (allotted January 3, 1901).................................                        202
March 3, 1905...                                                 .............................................................                                                    6,000
                Total..............................................                                               ................                                              120, 202
                     APPENDIX D-REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. TAYLOR.                                                                 1035
                                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

   Since February, 1907, the keeper of Duck Island light has kept a record of vessels
using this harbor, and his reports to this office show that during the calendar year 1908
1,003 vessels entered the harbor.


                                                               D     7.

             IMPROVEMENT OF BRANFORD HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

  No work of improvement was conducted during the fiscal year.
This project was completed July 30, 1907. Since that time consid-
erable shoaling has taken place in the inner harbor, between the
"Mermaids '" and the mouth of the river. A survey was made of this
portion of the harbor in July, 1908, which showed that the available
depth through this portion of the channel was then about 7 feet at
mean low tide, and it is not thought that much change has taken
place since then. The available depth in the river from the lower
wharves to the head of navigation is greater than from the "Mer-
maids" to the mouth of the river and is believed to be about 8 feet.
                                      Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
  improvement--.....---..--..--......---...........................--------    $2, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                   APPROPRIATIONS.
                                                               $5,000
June 13, 1902--------......---------........--------.....-------.......--....
                                                                3,000
March 3,1905.----------......---------........-..........------------......
                                                                5,000
March 2,1907-----.....---------......-------....------.....................
          Total-----...----..---........---------------...----------------------------......................                  13, 000

                        COMMERCIAL STATITICS                       1,
                                                                    OR     CALENDAR YEAR 1908.
                            [Compiled from reports furnished by shippers and receivers.]
                                                             Receipts.

                                                       Articles.                                                           Quantity.

                                                                                                                            Net tons.
Coal and coke ......................................--.........................................                                                      13,329
Sand and clay.......--------------...........--..---..----------............------------..........--                                                  4,580
Iron and ironore----------......-------...---...........---------...........--.......--------........              -------------------                1,410
Cast-iron pipe ..............------------------------------------------------------------------                                                         370
Lumber----..               ------------------------------------------------------------------                                                           851
         ----------....-...---------..---....---------------------............---------......................------------------.....................
Fertilizer                                                                                                                                               129

       Total....................                   ............................                                        20,669
                                                                                                     -----...---........


  Valuation of receipts, $100,362.80.
  No shipments reported for this year.
  The tonnage shows a decrease of nearly 35 per cent from that reported for 1907, a
decrease having taken place in all classes of freight except lumber.
1036        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                             D 8.
IMPROVEMENT OF NEW HAVEN HARBOR, INCLUDING WEST RIVER,
                     CONNECTICUT.
  The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, appropriated $10,000
for the maintenance of this harbor and also made this money avail-
able for the maintenance of the channel by way of Oyster Point to
Kimberly Avenue Bridge on West River.      This West River channel
was adopted by the act of March 3, 1905, as a separate project and
was completed September 5, 1906. After that the channel filled in
considerably by gradual silting and caving in of the banks, so that
complaints were received with regard to its insufficient dimensions. A
survey made in November, 1908, showed these complaints to be well
founded, and under date of December 31, 1908, a contract was entered
into with the Atlantic Dredging Company for restoring this channel to
project dimensions.          Work under this contract was begun March 3 and
completed April 24,1909. Thirty-one thousand two hundred and sixty-
four cubic yards of material were removed, and the channel was re-
stored to practically full project dimensions throughout its length.
   An examination made in the spring of 1909 having showed that the
Mill River channels and the 12-foot anchorage basin had seriously
deteriorated, bids were asked under date of May 15, 1909, for restor-
ing the channels and basin to project dimensions so far as available
funds will permit. The lowest bid, that of the J. S. Packard Dredging
Company, at 8.89 cents per cubic yard, was accepted.
  The harbor lines in the upper portion of the Quinnipiac River were
permanently located and marked on the ground and referred to true
meridian.
                           Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
  provement-------..............................---------------------------------------- $40, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
  and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                    APPROPRIATIONS.
Appropriations for previous                       March 3, 1905.............          $9, 000. 00
  projects a---...........-.... $326, 000. 00     March 3, 1905--..........           38, 500.00
March 3, 1899.- . ........        50, 000. 00     March 2, 1907-...-........-.        10, 000. 00
June 6, 1900- .....--
                    ---...        50, 000. 00     March 2, 1907 (allotted, No-
March 3, 1901.............        50, 000. 00      vember 30, 1908).. ......-          3, 000. 00
June 13, 1902............
                 ---              67, 000. 00     March 3, 1909 (allotted, April
March 3, 1903 .............       63, 073.90       23, 1909) ................         20, 000. 00
April 28, 1904 (allotted,
  August 1, 1904)...........       9, 000. 00            Total................... 695, 573. 90


                                  CONTRACT IN FORCE.
  Contractor: Atlantic Dredging Company.
  Dredging: Yardage, 31,264.
  Date of contract (emergency): December 31, 1908.
  Date of beginning work: March 3, 1909.
  Date of completion: April 24, 1909.
  Rate: 13.8 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.

  a See pages 239 and 240 of House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second
session.
                       APPENDIX D--REPORT                                        OF LIEUT.                   COL. TAYLOR.                          1037
                            COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1908.
                              [Compiled from reports furnished by shippers and receivers.]
                                                               Receipts and shipments.
                                                                       [In net tons.]

                                                                      Quinnipiac                         Mill River.
                                                                        River.
                Articles.                    Main                                                                                        West      Total
                                            harbor.                  Below Above Below       East West                                   River.
                                                                     Ferry Ferry Chapel Branch. Branch.
                                                                     street. street. street.

Coal.................           ...... 1,048,460.                   35,179 .....                             54,067       225,730         43,279 1,406,715
Lumber, lath, railroad ties,
  etc....................                64,860          ............        10,452                          ........ 2,285                3,578      81,175
Iron..........................                945 .....................                                                                                 945
Cast iron pipe ..............              2,595 .........................                                                ".......
                                                                                                                          . 306                        2,901
Steel billets .................                                                                                 290 .........                            290
Steel scrap ..............                                448 ..............                                 .................                           448
Flues and pipe..............
Partitions and partition
                                                    . .. -. - .. ..- . I.. .. .                              ........          22            334        356
  blocks....              ..........      ...........                                                                                         35          35
Fireproofing ............                                                                                                     224                        224
Oysters.....................                       28,543
                                                        2,029-                  14,752                                                    26,067      71,391
Oyster shells ....          ........                 9,338 15,048                                                                         29,156      53,542
Sand...................                   15,500                      9,045                                     515         1,369                     26,429
Fire clay, etc...........                    769                                                                                          3,988       4,757
Sea and fire sand.............                                                                                                            2,736       2,736
Enameled, hollow, and fire
   brick.... ............                     155                                                                             951            640       1,746
Stone....................                    553                                                            ........ 3,235                  224       4,012
Grindstones .............                 1,191                                                                                                       1,191
Cement.................                                                                                                1,721                 282       2,003
Plaster and gypsum.........                              248          5,264                                           1,966                 736       8,214
Ground wood pulp.......... ............ &                                                                         .... 395                              395
Fertilizer..........................     ... 148                                     336                                                   1,837       2,321
Fertilizing materials..........                                                                                                            3,500       3,500
Produce...................                                                                                                                   336         347
Petroleum products.........                          3,788     11-


                                                                                                                            8,261                     12,049
Miscellaneous .................                         6,012
                                                                                                                                                       6,012

     STEAMBOAT FREIGHT.

General merchandise.........                 180,349                                                                                                 180,349
Groceries.....         .........              16,800                                                                                                  16,800
Food products and fruit.....                   3,360                                                                                                   3,360
Butter, cheese, and eggs......                 1,680                                                                                                   1,680
Liquors....         ...........                3,360                                                                                                   3,360
Dry goods....          ..........              3,360                                                                                                   3,360
Hardware..............                         3,360                                                                                                   3,360
Iron, lead, etc.....          .....            5,040                                                                                                   5,040
Cartridges, guns, and shells...                6,720                                                                                                   6,720
Paints..................                       1,680                                                                                                   1,680
Rubber goods ............                      1,680                                                                                                   1,680
                                                     I                                      i            i            i              I      .
       Total............                   1,370,865 42,117                     79,624          10,452       54,872       246,465        116,728   1,921,123
         .. .                         i
  NOTE.-Of the tonnage reported for West River, 57,687 tons pertain to that part of the river known as
"Oyster Point," 35,898 tons to the section below Kimberly Avenue Bridge, and 23,143 tons to the section
above Kimberly Avenue Bridge.
                                               SUMMARY.


                                                                                                                            Tonnage.           Valuation.


Main harbor.........   ..       ..............                      ........  ......... .....1,370,865 $94,977,097.00
Mill River:
    East Branch ..........................................................                      54,872     191,596.25
    West Branch ...........................................................                    246,465     986,292.01
    Below Chapel street.....        ..... .................................                     10,452     194,105. 60
Quinnipiac River:
    Above Ferry street............             ..............................                   79,6 4     490,005.74
    Below Ferry street........ ...................................                              42,117     554,248. 40
West River:
    At Oyster Point........................           .................................         57,687     477,759. 50
     Below Kimberly Avenue Bridge......................................                         35,898     198,947. 50
    Above Kimberly Avenue Bridge .....................................                          23,143     163,491.22

       Total.....................                        ...          ...........................                           1,921,123          98,233,543.22
1038        REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                U.   S. ARMY.

  Number of passengers, 117,427.
  Two regular lines of steamers carrying freight and passengers each make daily trips
to New York. A freight line making daily trips to Bridgeport and New York was
established November 7, 1908.
  The tonnage for West River shows a decrease of 17.2 per cent from that reported in
1907, and the tonnage of the remainder of the harbor shows a decrease of about 15.2
per cent. The decrease is quite general in all classes of freight, but is particularly
noticeable in the steamboat freight, which decreased over 35 per cent. All portions
of the harbor show a decrease, but it amounts to the least in the West Branch of Mill
River, where it is only about 5 per cent.

                         [Furnished by collector of customs at New Haven, Conn.]
Value of imports..........................................................                               $331, 949. 46
Revenue receipts, duties on imports .............................                                         102, 682. 84
Foreign vessels:
    Entered. .....----................................................-----                                        24
    Cleared .....    ---.---........................  ... ....................--                                    9
            Total.. ..--.............                    --...................--.........-                         33

Domestic vessels:
   Entered...........--...............................-----..........---                                            2
   Cleared....... .......    ...........---........     ...................-                                       10
            Total...............................................                                                   12




                                                               D g.

CONSTRUCTION OF BREAKWATERS AT NEW HAVEN, CONNECTICUT.

  At the beginning of the fiscal year a continuing contract was in
force, but work was not actually in progress, for repairing the West
breakwater and extending it as far, not to exceed 2,400 feet, as the
authorized funds will permit. Delivery of stone under this contract
was begun September 4, 1907, and at the beginning of the fiscal year
had been suspended by the contractors since June 16, 1908, in order
to expedite work on the Point Judith breakwater, for which they
were also contractors. Work on the West breakwater at New Haven
was resumed August 7, 1908, and continued thereafter until Febru-
ary 8, 1909, when it was again suspended owing to unfavorable
weather and ice. Owing to lack of plant, work was not resumed
until May 12, 1909. It has been in progress since the latter date.
   During the fiscal year 41,703.74 gross tons of riprap stone were
delivered and placed, all being applied to the extension of the break-
water, which at the close of the year had been extended a total dis-
tance of 1,180 feet under the existing contract. Of the portion thus
built, the first 800 feet has been completed, the next 185 feet is from
85 to 95 per cent done, and the last 195 feet to average height of
about 5 feet below low water.
   The entire breakwater is now 2,850 feet long, including the unfin-
ished section, 380 feet long, at the outer end. It contains a total of
313,497.46 gross tons of stone, of which 141,006.46 have been placed
under this contract.
                      APPENDIX D--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. TAYLOR.                                                       1039
                                       Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of
  improvement................-                                        ....................                 $100, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
4, 1897.


                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.
March 3, 1879................... $30, 000                       July 13, 1892..............    ..                $120, 000
July 14, 1880..... ..          ..... .. 30, 000                 August 18, 1894........... ..                     125, 000
March 3, 1881......... ........ 60, 000                         June 3, 1896 ............        .                100, 000
August 2, 1882 ........              .... 60, 000               June 13, 1902 ...............                      44, 000
July 5, 1884 .................            40,000                March 2, 1907-...............                     100,000
August 5, 1886................. 75, 000                         May 27, 1908 .................                    150,000
August 11, 1888.........           ....   75, 000
September 19, 1890.............. 120,000                                  Total................... 1,129,000


                                               CONTRACT IN FORCE.
  Contractor: Sea Coast Construction Company.
  Placing stone in breakwater: Estimated at 225,000 gross tons.
  Date of contract: June 11, 1907.
  Date of approval: June 29, 1907.
  Date of beginning delivery of stone: September 4, 1907.
  Date of expiration: Indefinite.
  Rate: 99 cents per gross ton of stone in place.


                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1908.

                                       [Furnished by keeper of Southwest Ledge light.]
                           Vessels seeking refuge behind breakwaters during the year.

                                 East breakwater.         Middle breakwater.                 West breakwater.
      Month.                                                                                                          Total.
                          Steam- Sailing Barges. Steam- Sailing Bar     Steam- Sailing
                           ers.  vessels.         ers.  vessels.   ges.  ers.  vessels. Barges.

January...........               44       50        179    14      29                 54 ........    9          23        402
February........                 32       12        158    16      14                 77        4    6          29        348
March............                44       51        193    17      23                 64        3    11         24        430
April...........                 61      128        216    15      35                 71        1    14         25        566
May.............                 57      176        240    23       48                76      11     21          31       683
June.............                39       70        100    11       27                27      21     15          28       338
July.............                40      119        125    22       62                45      17     47          19       496
August .........                 34       99        106    17       53                62      23     49          67       510
September.......                 31       90        113    16       36                48       9     21          27       391
October.........                 38      105        141    20       29                40      10     23         28        434
November.......                  47       81        200    19       36                68      12     19         26        508
December........                 39       87        194    30       28                70      20     20         36        524
       Total......               506   1,068    1,965     220      420              702      131    255         363     5,630


  The above report shows that 1,078 less vessels, about 16 per cent, sought refuge
behind the breakwaters during 1908 than were reported as so doing during 1907, but
the number seeking refuge behind the West breakwater was 14 per cent more than was
reported the previous year, due doubtless to the increased protection afforded by the
extension of this structure.
  It is believed that the decreased number of vessels seeking refuge is mainly due to
the decreased number of vessels passing through the Sound during the past year,
and that this in turn was due to the general business depression. The total number
of vessels observed from Southwest Ledge light passing through Long Island Sound
and not entering New Haven Harbor was 121 per cent less during 1908 than during
1907, and the number of freight-carrying vessels, barges, and schooners thus observed
during the past year was 20 per cent less than during the previous year.
1040                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                             D io.

                   IMPROVEMENT OF MILFORD HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   No work of improvement was conducted during the fiscal year.
This project was practically completed August 23, 1905. An exami-
nation at the close of the fiscal year showed that some filling had
taken place near the outer end of the outer channel, so that the
available depth is about 9 feet, 1 foot less than project depth. The
inner channel still shows an available depth of 6 feet as far upstream
as the town dock, but with somewhat decreased width. There is
practically no navigation, except by very small pleasure craft, above
the town dock.
                                                 Estimate of additional funds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
  improvement...........................-----------------------------.................--------------$2,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.




                                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriations for previous projects a ........................................                                     $47,100
June 13, 1902..........-------------------..............---------------..--..---........-----------................... 15, 000
March 3, 1905........................................                                      ................            10, 000
      Total,105--------------------------------------------------------72100
      Total. ......................               ........................................                             72,100



                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1908.
                                     [Compiled from reports furnished by shippers and receivers.]
                                                                Receipts and shipments.

                                                                       Articles.                                    Quantity.

                                                                                                                    Net tons.
Oysters... --.... .... ................      .............       .......................... ........
                                                           ........                                                     13,140
Oyster shells.........................................................................................                   5,869
Coal..............-............................................        .......... .................                      4,668
Cord wood................................................                            ............................         224
Crushed stone ........... ................................. ...... ..........................                               728
Cem ent.. ............ .... ....................................... ... ........................                             95
Building material ........................................... ....... ........................... .....                      34
Cast-iron pipe .. -. ...           ..........                                                                            2, 429
Fertilizer-......14.....0.....................1,400
          Total....................                 ................                                                    28,587


  Valuation of tonnage, $411,533.22.
  Tonnage shows an increase of about 6.4 per cent above that reported for 1907, due
to the receipt of some cast-iron gas pipe, which is not a regular receipt.

    a See page 239 of House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second session.
             APPENDIX D--REPORT           OF LIEUT.   COL. TAYLOR.             1041
                                      D    If,

       IMPROVEMENT OF HOUSATONIC RIVER, CONNECTICUT.

   During the season of 1908 no dredging was necessary at the usual
bars in this river, which was in better condition than it has been for a
number of years. The only difficulty experienced by navigation was
in the vicinity of the dike below Stratford and was caused by a middle
ground working down across the channel. The previous season
dredging had been done at this point but it was found to be not per-
manent and it was decided to further extend the Stratford dike in
order to throw the current farther to the eastward and avoid a turn
where filling had taken place. This dike had never been built to its
full project length and hence its full benefit had not been felt. Con-
tract for this work was entered into September 16, and on September
23 work was begun and was completed December 8, 1908. Five
thousand five hundred and seventy-five and forty-six one-hun-
dredths gross tons of riprap stone were delivered and placed and the
jetty was extended 365 feet, making its total length from the inshore
end about 915 feet. The dike was built to height of about 9 feet at
mean low water, with top width of 4 feet and side slopes of 1 on 1. In
order to hasten the work of cutting by the current and to make the
new channel immediately available a channel of project depth of 7
feet, 50 feet wide, and about 700 feet long, was dredged across the
middle ground from the deep water below to the deep water above the
dike. This work was done under an open-market agreement at the
rate of 15 cents per cubic yard. Work was begun November 7 and
completed November 21, 1908, and 6,551 cubic yards were removed.
  When the season of 1909 opened the river as a whole was still in
very good condition but an examination showed that some filling had
taken place at several of the upriver bars, thereby reducing the avail-
able depth to about 6 feet and also the available width. It was also
found that the channel dredged the previous season in the vicinity of
the Stratford dike had partially filled in, but the cutting caused by
the extension of the jetty had been even more than was expected. A
careful study of the conditions in the vicinity of the dike, including
current observations, indicated that the location of the new channel
should be somewhat different from the one dredged the previous fall
in order to obtain the best results from the effect of the dike and it is
proposed to dredge a new channel at this point involving the removal
of about 7,000 yards. Contract for doing this dredging and also the
necessary maintenance dredging was entered into under date of June
14. Contract work under this contract had not been begun at the
close of the fiscal year.
                   Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement .............................   $37, 000. 00
   For maintenance of improvement........................     8, 000. 00
                                                                           $45, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
       9001-ENG 1909-66
1042               REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                        U.   S. ARMY.

                                                                  APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1871...............                                          $15, 000                  July 13, 1892 ................             $20, 000
June 10, 1872.........           ......                                15,000                   August 18, 1894................. 25, 000
March 3, 1873 .............       ...                                  10, 000                  June 3, 1896.... ............               25, 000
June 25, 1874.............                                             10, 000                  March 3, 1899........          .......      15, 000
March 3, 1875.................                                          5, 000                  June 13, 1902-........... ..                10, 000
June 18, 1878...............                                            5, 000                  April 28, 1904 (allotted August 1,
June 14, 1880 ......         .......                                    2, 000                    1904)...................             .... 3, 950
March 3, 1881_............. .                                           2, 000                  March 3, 1905..................10, 000
August 2, 1882 ........... .....                                        2, 000                  March 2, 1907-................... 20, 000
July 5, 1884....................                                        2, 500                  March 3, 1909.......... ... ...              5, 000
August 5, 1886...........           ......                              5, 000
August 11, 1888.................                                       35, 000                               Total....................                277,450
September 19, 1890............                                         35, 000



                                                            CONTRACT IN                                FORCE.

   Contractor: Edward A. Berry.
   Dredging: Yardage, 25,000.
   Date of contract (emergency): June 14, 1909.
   Date for commencement: June 24, 1909.
   Date of expiration: September 24, 1909.
   Rates:
       Dredging: 20 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
       Logs removed: $10 each.



                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1908.
                                   [Compiled from reports furnished by shippers and receivers.]
                                                               Receipts and shipments.

                                                           Articles.                                                              Quantity.          Valuation.

At Derby and Shelton, Conn.:                                                                                                       Net tons.
    Coal ...............................                                           ...........................                        59,465
    Sand........................                                            ..............................                                   1,165
    Brick..........................                                           ...........                  ........ ......................... 30
    W ood...........             ....................                                  ...........................                             207
       Total....                           ..........                  ................................                                60,867        $312,270.00

At Stratford, Conn.:
   Coal...............................................................................                                                  8,867
    Oysters.........................                                      ............................                                     13
    Oyster shells ............................................................                                                          6,720
    Railroad ties, piles, and cord wood ........................................                                                          700
    Brick .....                          ...
                                       ..........            ............................................                                 448
     Cement..............................                                                       .........................                 280

        Total.........                              .................................                                                  17,028          66,710. 52
        Grand total................                              ...........               ..        ....................              77,895         378, 980. 52


   The tonnage shows a decrease for the entire river of about 14.3 per cent from that
reported for 1907; the decrease at Stratford amounts to about 8.5 per cent and at
Derby and Shelton about 17.1 per cent, mainly in coal. Notwithstanding this
decrease the total freight traffic for the river is the largest reported, with the exception
of 1907, since 1901, at which time the present method of collection of these statistics
by direct reports from the shippers and receivers was adopted.
           APPENDIX D--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. TAYLOR.             1043
                                D   I2.

     IMPROVEMENT OF BRIDGEPORT HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   At the beginning of the fiscal year a contract was in force with the
estate of John Beattie, and delivery of stone had been begun July 31,
1907, for the construction of the breakwaters at the entrance to
Bridgeport Harbor, as provided for in the act approved March 2, 1907.
These breakwaters were completed September 23, 1908. During the
fiscal year 23,282.75 gross tons of stone were delivered and placed in
the west breakwater, which was extended channelward 1,010 feet.
The total amount of stone placed in these breakwaters under this
contract was 82,849.97 gross tons, of which 39,291.25 were placed in
the west breakwater, this being the total amount of stone contained
in this breakwater, and the remainder was applied to the extension
of the east breakwater, which was approximately 1,200 feet long at
the time of the adoption of the present project. After the conclusion
of work by the contractors lights were maintained on the outer of
both of these breakwaters by this department for about six weeks
until the light-house department assumed charge.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year a contract was in force with the
Maritime Dredging Company for dredging the 12-foot anchorage
basin authorized by the present project, but dredging had not actu-
ally been begun. Work under this contract was begun July 27 and
completed December 26, 1908. The total amount of material
removed under this contract was 150,619 cubic yards. The basin
was dredged parallel to the main channel, 300 feet wide, and extends
from the northerly end of the projected 22-foot basin to the 12-foot
Yellow Mill channel. Its average length is about 2,000 feet and its
area is about 600,000 square feet.
   Under date of February 15, 1909, contract was entered into with
the American Dredging Company for dredging the projected 22-foot
basin and deepening the main entrance channel to 22 feet, thereby
completing all work authorized by the present project. Work
under this contract was begun April 8, 1909, and was in progress at
the close of the fiscal year. During the fiscal year 144,923 cubic
yards were removed under this contract, all from the main entrance
channel, the westerly portion of which, from the northerly end
southerly for a distance of about 6,200 feet, had been dredged to full
depth and to width varying from 100 to 150 feet.
   An examination was made of the Poquonock River channel with
reference to need of redredging for maintenance and possibly in-
creased depth of project. Under permit from the Secretary of War
the reconstruction by the city of Bridgeport of the Congress Street
highway bridge across the Poquonock River was begun, and in
order to protect the interests of navigation a United States inspector
was detailed on this work for a considerable portion of the time.
The proper installation of various submarine cables in this harbor,
in trenches at a considerable distance below the project depth of
channel, has been secured during the fiscal year, the work being done
under supervision of a United States inspector.
1044          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                  Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for mainte-
nance of improvement............................................. $20,000.00.
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.




                                             APPROPRIATIONS.

Total appropriations for Black Rock Harbor, Connecticut, to August 18,
  1894 (see p. 238, H. Doc. No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.)................ $72, 900. 00
Total appropriations for Bridgeport Harbor, Connecticut, to December 31,
  1902 (see pp. 238 and 239, H. Doc. No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.)...... 468, 000. 00
March 3, 1905...--........1....................                                        .... ......             10, 000. 00
June 30, 1906..........................                     ........... ................. 72, 500.00
March 2, 1907...................                ...............     ......................                    113, 000. 00
March 2, 1907 (allotted January 1, 1908)............................. . al0, 000. 00
May 27, 1908.....--------------------------------------------------- 40,000.00
March 3, 1909 (allotted April 23, 1909) .....                   ...           ..-----------------------------  10, 000. 00
March 4, 1909......................................................... 100, 000.00

                                                                                                          896, 400.00
a Of this allotment $218.04 was returned to the Treasury..................                                     218. 04
         Total........         .. .........
                                      .. . . ..........
                                                      ..............                                  896,181.96
                                                                                                 .......




                                          CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

   Contractor: Estate of John Beattie.
   Placing 82,849.97 gross tons of stone in breakwater.
   Date of contract: June 25, 1907.
   Date of approval: July 11, 1907.
   Date of commencement: August 15, 1907.
   Date of completion: September 23, 1908.
   Rate: $1.17 per gross ton of stone in place.

   Contractor: Maritime Dredging Company.
   Dredging: Yardage removed, 150,619.
   Date of contract: June 1, 1908.
   Date of approval: June 15, 1908.
   Date of commencement: July 27, 1908.
   Date of completion: December 26, 1908.
   Rate: 10.65 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.

   Contractor: American Dredging Company.
   Dredging: Yardage, approximate, 1,278,000.
   Date of contract: February 15, 1909.
   Date of approval: March 10, 1909.
   Date of beginning work: April 8, 1909.
   Date of expiration (approximate): April 28, 1911.
   Rates:
       Main channel, 12 cents per cubic yard.
       22-foot anchorage basin: 81 cents per cubic yard.
                              APPENDIX D-REPORT OF LIEUT.                                                                                COL. TAYLOR.                                         1045
                                 COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1908.
                                        [Compiled from reports furnished by shippers and receivers.]
                                                                      Receipts and shipments.
                                                                         1        1Net                                                                                  1tens.
                                                                 Main             Poquo-
                    Articles.                                 harbor.              nock                   Yellow                      Johnsons            Cedar             Burr              Total.
                                                                                  River.                   Mill.                       Creek.             Creek.            Creek.
                                                                                         -         1             -                1                1I--     -- --       1     -1---I-------

                                                              Net tons.           Net tons. Net tons. Net tons.                                         Net tons. Net tons.                   Net tons.
Coal......................                                     135,391             229, 750  60,994      3, 360                                          105,788 10,080                        545,363
Lumber and railroad ties ...                                       983              34,524                                                                17,567                                53,074
Scrap and pig iron..................                                                 2,542   12,608                                                        6,769                                21,919
Cast iron pipe ....... ..                    ....        ........                   1,456                                                                                                        1,456
Billets, steel.......                   ...............                                                       40,706                                       17,089                               57,795
Pyrites.....................                                    ....                                                                                                        16,800              16,800
Scrap steel...............................................                                                                                                        601                             601
Scale, iron..............................                                                                             394                                                                         394
Sand and clay.............                                            267           5,733-                            477                                  13,934                               20,411
Oysters.........................                                 28, 569                                                                                                                        28,569
Oyster shells .................                                    4,944                                                                                                                         4,944
Brick.........................                                          71          1,904              ....          ......                                 4,615                                6,590
Stone (broken and building)....                                    9, 240                    47                                                             1,344                               10,631
Fluorspar and limestone...... ..                                     .....                    1,319                                                                                              1,319
Plaster and plaster product.. ..........                                            1,008 ..........                                                          728                                1,736
Petroleum products.........                       ...              1,120            5,422                                                                   4,043                               10,585
Fertilizer mats.............                          .......                                                                                               2,856                                2, 856
Manufactured fertilizer ........                                                                                                                              430                                   430
Brimstone .....................                                       348                                                                                   1,062                                1,410
Plumbago.........................                                                            672                                                                                                    672



                                                                                                                                                                 ;i.... . . . .
Oxide of iron ............................                                                    84                                                                                                       84-
Empty barrels.................                                          11                                                                                                                             11
Miscellaneous merchandise......                                         35                                                                                  2,093 ..........                     2,817
Steamboat freight ............                                100,428                                                                                                                          100,428
                                                                             -i      -             1---                       -   1-
                                                                                                                                   -     -   ---    1       --      -


           Total ....................                           281,407           283,142                     117,187                    3,360            178,919             26,880           890,895


                                                                                   SUMMARY.


                                                                                                                                                           Quantity.               Valuation.


                                                                                                                                                             Net tons.
Main harbor..... ..............................................                                                                                                    281,407        $33,046,117.02
Poquonock River................                                     .................................                                                              283,142          2,130,023.55
Yellow Mill ..........................                       ..................................                                                                  a 117,187            754,159.00
Johnsons Creek..............................................                                                                                                         3, 360            15,000. 00
Cedar Creek.................................................................                                                                                       178,919          1,561,896.63
Burr Creek ....                             ..........................................                                                                              26,880             65,000.00
          Total........                  ..........................                                            ......................                             890,895          37,572,196.20

a Of this amount, 16,436 net tons of coal were in Yellow Mill above the bridge, the balance being in Yellow
Mill below the bridge.

   Total number of passengers carried 197,945, of which 20,000 were transported back
and forth between the mainland and Steeplechase Island.
   A regular line of freight and passenger steamers, one or two boats, makes one to two
trips per day to New York. Another line, one boat, makes daily trips to Port Jefferson
throughout most of the year. A third line, one boat, carrying freight between New
Haven, Bridgeport, and New York and making daily trips was started November 7,
1908.
   The total freight traffic for the harbor shows a decrease of about 21 per cent from
that reported for 1907, chiefly in coal and steamboat freight, these two classes of
freight accounting for about 83 per cent of the decrease.


                                         [Furnished by the collector of customs at Bridgeport, Conn.]
Value of imports ..............................................................                                                                                                  $656, 735.00
Revenue receipts, duties on imports .............          .....................                                                                                                  207, 608. 53
Foreign vessels:
    Entered........................................................                                                                                                                                 45
    Cleared........................................................                                                                                                                                 35
                        Total.... ..                   .........        ... ..................................                                                                                      80
1046          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                   S. ARMY.

                                                    D 13.

           IMPROVEMENT OF NORWALK HARBOR, CONNECTICUT.

   At the beginning of the fiscal year that portion of the project below
the railroad bridge had been completed, and a contract was in force
and work had been begun March 21, 1908, for the completion of the
remainder of the project. This contract was completed September
19, 1908. During the fiscal year 66,757 cubic yards of ordinary mate-
rial, scow measurement, and 57,389 cubic yards of rock were removed
from the second division, and 13,275 cubic yards of ordinary material,
scow measurement, and 101,645 cubic yards of rock from the third
division. Of the material removed from the second division 34,203
cubic yards were actually removed and measured in scows, the mate-
rial being dumped in Long Island Sound, and the remainder of the
material from this division was pumped ashore behind sod levees on
the marshes on either side of the river. All ordinary material
removed from the third division was dumped in Long Island Sound
and actually measured in scows. In addition to the work done by
the United States under this contract, the New York, New Haven
and Hartford Railroad Company did a considerable amount of dredg-
ing under the supervision of United States inspectors for the better-
ment of the channel at the railroad bridge. This bridge is a swing
drawbridge, and heretofore only the westerly opening has been avail-
able, but now full project depth is available through both openings.
   After the completion of the above contract work complaints were
received with regard to some obstructive rocks in the basin at Nor-
walk. These rocks had slid into the basin after the dredging was
completed and were removed in April, 1909, by open market agree-
ment at cost of $250.
   The removal of two old wrecks of canal boats in the upper portion
of the harbor by the persons responsible for their being there was
secured.
                                     Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
  of improvement-------.......------....-----..-...-......--------..........---------................. $8, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                            APPROPRIATIONS.

Total appropriations for Norwalk Harbor, Connecticut, to December 31, 1902
  (see p. 240, H. Doc. No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.)...................... $123, 913
April 28, 1904 (allotted August 1, 1904).............................            7, 000
March 3, 1905..........                          ..............................  4, 000
March 2, 1907...........................................................        63, 500
        Total ........................                 ....................             ...........    198, 413
                             APPENDIX D--REPORT OF LIEUT.                                                                    COL. TAYLOR.                                         1047
                                                                  CONTRACT IN FORCE.

    Contractor: The International Contracting Company.
    Dredging and rock removal:
        Yardage removed-Rock, 163,624.
        Dredging, 153,744.
    Date of contract: August 27, 1907.
    Date of approval: September 12, 1907.
    Date of commencement: March 21, 1908.
    Date of completion: September 19, 1908.
    Rates:
        Second division, 16 cents per cubic yard.
        Third division, 30 cents per cubic yard.
        Rock removal, $10 per cubic yard.



                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1908.
                                       [Compiled from reports furnished by shippers and receivers.]

                                                                      Receipts and shipments.


                                                  Articles.                                                                                  Norwalk. Norwk.Total.


                                                                                                                      Net tons. Net tons. Net tons. Net tons.
Coal.....             .........................................                                                             60,938            15,680         3,186                79,804
Lumber .................................................                                                                     4,480             1,342 .........                     5,822
Oysters............................................                                                                         25,148 ..                                             25,148
Oyster shells.......................            .....................  13,839                 ........                                                                             3,839
Sand and clay .... ........................................             2,554         838 ...... ....                                                                              3,392
Building material ....... .....................                   ....  1,120.............................                                                                         1,120
Paper... ..............................
                                 .....                           .............................                         ..                      2,352           .......             2,352
Brick........  ........        .............................                                                                    896              224 ..........                     1,120
Ground wood pulp ................                            ..........................                                                    12,432 ..........                       12,432
Brimstone ...                                                                                                                  3....74.........................................
                                                                                                                               374....                                                374
Acid . ..............    ..............
                                  ..............          ................190 ....   ............                                                                                    190
Miscellaneous ............      ..........................          .. 1,120 2,016 ..........                                                                                      3,136
                ............................................
Steamboat freight                                                                                                           30,016            20,720        ..........             50,736
         Total................................................                                                          140,675                55,604             3,186           199,465


                                                                                VALUATION.
South Norwalk.................................                                              ..................................                                           $11,664,357.52
Norwalk........................                                                                  ....................................                                      7,680,994.66
East Norwalk.....                              ..........                             .........           ................................                                    14,399.10
        Total.......................                                                                ....................
                                                                                      ...................                                                     .....19,359,751.28

  Of the above amount 44,372 net tons were shipments.
  A line of freight steamers makes daily trips between Norwalk, South Norwalk, and
New York throughout the greater portion of the year. All Norwalk freight passes
through the main channel past South Norwalk. South Norwalk freight includes only
that received or shipped from South Norwalk.
  The total freight traffic of the harbor shows a decrease of about 14.2 per cent from that
reported for 1907. The traffic at South Norwalk decreased 10.9 per cent, at Norwalk
21.1 per cent, and at East Norwalk 22.3 per cent.

                                       [Furnished by the collector of customs at Bridgeport, Conn.]
Value of imports...................................................                                                                                                      $83, 584. 00
Revenue receipts, duties on imports ................................                                                                                                       9, 960. 48

Foreign vessels:
    Entered......................................................................                                                                                                     21
    Cleared ..............................              .....................................                                                                                          6
                      Total ............................................................ 27
1048      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                  S. ARMY.

                                        D x14

IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AT FIVEMILE RIVER, STAMFORD, SOUTH-
  PORT, GREENWICH, AND WESTPORT, AND SAUGATUCK RIVER,
  CONNECTICUT.
                        (A)   FIVEMILE RIVER HARBOR.

   No work of improvement was done. No complaints with regard to
the impairment of the project dimensions of this channel have been
received, but from past experience it is expected that considerable
narrowing and shoaling have taken place and redredging to project
-dimensions will doubtless soon be needed.
                       Estimate of additional funds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement ............................... $9, 300. 00
   For maintenance of improvement..................... .. . 2, 000. 00
                                                                           $11, 300. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                              (B)   STAMFORD HARBOR.

   At the beginning of the fiscal year a contract was in force and
work had been begun October 2, 1907, for the completion of this
contract so far as available funds would permit. Work under this
project was completed August 24, 1908. During the fiscal year 8,714
cubic yards of ordinary material and 222.49 cubic yards of rock were
removed from the basin at the head of the West Branch and 236
cubic yards of ordinary material from the East Branch channel.
Large bowlders and ledge rock were encountered in such unexpectedly
large quantities that it was found impossible with the available funds
to dredge as large an area as was expected. When the original
allotment of funds from the appropriation of March 2, 1907, for the
improvement of this harbor were exhausted the basin at the head
of the West Branch was not in proper condition to leave for any length
of time and hence authority was obtained for the transfer of $1,149.53
from the allotments for the improvement of Greenwich Harbor and
Fivemile River, where work was not urgently needed. With these
funds, and by open-market agreement with the same contractors
and at the same price, 991 cubic yards of ordinary material and 72.43
cubic yards of rock were removed from the basin at the head of the
West Branch. An obstructive shoal which had been discovered
after the completion of the contract work was also removed from
the East Branch, amounting to 50 cubic yards of ordinary material
and 9.53 cubic yards of rock. At the close of this last-described work
the entire East Branch and West Branch channels had been completed
to full project dimensions. In the basin at the head of the West Branch
a channel had been dredged to full project depth and varying in
width from 90 to 200 feet, entirely around the basin, the only portion
remaining to be dredged being an area about 800 feet long and 210
feet wide in the central portion and three small areas in the extreme
northwest and southwest corners and along the westerly side. It
             APPENDIX D--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. TAYLOR.                         1049
is estimated that the entire amount remaining to be removed from this
basin in order to complete the project does not exceed 50,000 yards.
                       Estimate of additional funds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement........-.................... $10, 000. 00
   For maintenance of improvement.....--.-............ ....  5, 000. 00
                                                                           $15, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                          (c) SOUTHPORT HARBOR.

   Under an open-market agreement with the Maritime Dredging
Company, an outcropping of ledge in the East Branch channel was
removed for the lump sum of $1,972, of which $459.51 was paid by
transfer of funds from allotment for Greenwich Harbor. Work under
this agreement was begun August 12, 1908, and completed September
10, 1908. That portion of the ledge within the limits of the channel
was removed to a depth of at least 7 feet below mean low water. The
amount of rock removed was estimated at about 157 cubic yards in
place and in addition to the rock about 141 cubic yards of ordinary
material were also removed.
   The breakwater having suffered considerably from wave attack, an
open-market agreement was made with Toole & Sunderlin. to repair
it. Work was begun October 30, 1908, and completed on the follow-
ing day. About 50 linear feet of breakwater was repaired by removing
the old stone and replacing it with concrete in which was imbedded
rubble. The coping stone was reset directly in the concrete. About
15 cubic yards of concrete were placed and 12 large coping stone were
removed and reset at cost of $300.
                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement .........................      $13, 111. 00
   For maintenance of improvement ......................     2, 000. 00
                                                                           $15, 111. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                           (D) GREENWICH HARBOR.

   No work of improvement was conducted during the year, the proj-
ect being completed under the appropriation of 1905.
   Map of survey made in June, 1908, with reference to need of main-
tenance and location and identification of harbor lines, was completed
during the fiscal year. This survey shows that only a small amount of
deterioration has taken place in the 9-foot channel and a project
depth of 9 feet is still available to the head of this channel. In the
6-foot channel above full project depth is still available to within 125
feet of the head, but considerable shoaling has taken place along the
easterly side of this channel which should be restored to full width as
soon as practicable.
1050       REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
of improvement ---------------...
                  ........             -------------------------------    $2, 000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

              (E)   WESTPORT HARBOR AND SAUGATUCK RIVER.

  At the beginning of the fiscal year work which had been begun
May 29, 1908, for the removal of the ledge known as "Lawrences
Rock" opposite Stony Point, was in progress. So far as quantity of
material was concerned the work was very nearly completed at the
close of the previous year, but owing to a number of small points
which had been left during the progress of blasting and the removal
of which was very difficult, the work was not completed until August
12, 1908. The rock was entirely removed to a depth of at least 7
feet and for the most part considerably more than that. The total
amount of rock removed was approximately 175 yards, place meas-
urement, the excess over the estimated quantity, 130 yards, being
due to the removal of material from below the required depth in the
process of blasting. The total cost of this work was $2,107.69, of
which $270.99 was paid by transfer of funds from allotment for
Greenwich Harbor.
                          Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement............................... $3, 000. 00
   For maintenance of improvement ........................ 2, 000. 00
                                                                                  $5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                    CONSOLIDATED.

                          Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement.......... ....................   $35, 411.00
   For maintenance of improvement-...--..---........     .... 13,000.00
                                                                                 $18, 411.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                   APPROPRIATIONS.

                                 FIVEMILE RIVER HARBOR.

August 11, 1888............     . $5, 000. 00   March 2, 1907.................   $7, 000. 00
September 19, 1890............ 5,000.00
July 13, 1892..................    5, 000. 00                                     40, 000. 00
August 18, 1894......... ...       2, 500. 00   Less amount transferred to
June 3, 1896................ 2, 500. 00           Stamford Harbor...........         209. 56
March 3, 1899 .................    2, 500. 00
June 13, 1902.............         4, 500. 00         Total..............         39, 790.44
March 3, 1905.................     6, 000.00
                      APPENDIX D--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. TAYLOR.                                                                           1051
                                                       STAMFORD              HARBOR.

Appropriations for previous projects (see p. 241 of H. Doc. No. 421, 57th
  Cong., 2d sess.)................................                                             .............. $20, 000. 00
July 13, 1892-------------------..........................-----------........----....-------.......--..----------....... 15, 000. 00
August 18, 1894.-------------------......................................................                                10,000. 00
June 3, 1896...........................................................                                                  10,000.00
M arch 3, 1899 .............                  ..............                ..........          ..................                     6,000.00
June 13, 1902.........---------------.............-------------......--............--------------......------......                   10,111. 00
March 3, 1905--..------..--....................-------------------...---.....................------------------.....                  18,000.00
March 2, 1907...............------------------------......--------------..................................                            58, 000. 00
Amount transferred from Fivemile River....................... $209. 56
Amount transferred from Greenwich Harbor- -..................                        --                      939. 97
                                                                                                                                       1, 149.53

          Total........................---------------------------------------.........                      ...........---------.   148, 260. 53
                                                       SOUTHPORT HARBOR.


Appropriations for previous projects (see p. 240 of H. Doc. No. 421, 57th
  Cong., 2d sess.)....................................................                                                   $31,587. 23
June 13, 1902......--------...--------............----------...................--------------......---------...            8, 889.00
March 3, 1905--------------------......---.............----------------....................-------------................   9,000. 00
March 2, 1907 ....................                       ......... .........................                               2,000.00
Amount transferred from 'breenwlch Harbor -.......-.....-....                                            ......               459. 51
          Total . .....................         .....          ...................                        ..............              51, 935. 74

                                                    GREENWICH HARBOR.

June 3, 1896------------------.....-----..............--------..............--....----....-----.....---...                            $6, 000.00
June 13, 1902 ....................................                                ................                                     6, 667.00
April 28, 1904 (allotted August 1, 1904)..............                            ................                                     2, 100.00
March 3, 1905-...... .. - ........ ....................................                                                                7,000. 00
M arch 2, 1907...... .......... ........................................                                                               1, 000. 00
                                                                                                                                      22, 767. 00
Less amount transferred to Stamford Harbor ...          .........-- .     . . $939. 97
                                                -....--
Less amount transferred to Southport Harbor-...-..           .- ..          . 459. 51
Less amount transferred to Saugatuck River and V'e                lpol-tihar-
  bor.................................        ........... ...........          270.99
                                                                                                                                       1,670. 47

          Total.......................................................21,096.53
                                   WESTPORT        HARBOR              AND SAUGATUCK                      RIVER.


Appropriations for previous projects (see p. 241 of H. Doc. No. 421, 57th
  Cong., 2d sess.) .................                        .. ........ .....................                        $19, 444.00
July 13, 1892--------------------...........----------......----------..............................---------....      7,000. 00
August 17, 1894--------..-...-----------.........-------......----.............------------...........-----....        3,000. 00
June 3, 1896------.....-----.....-----.....-----........--------.........-------..............---------------.......   3,000.00
M arch 2, 1907 ................. ........................................                                              2,000.00
Amount transferred from Greenwich Harbor..........................                                                        270. 99

          Total...........                ..........                       ............................                               34, 714. 99



                                               CONTRACT IN FORCE.

                                                       STAMFORD HARBOR.

   Contractor: Maritime Dredging Company.
   Dredging: Yardage removed, 167,789 cubic yards.
   Rock removal: 1,328.097 cubic yards.
   Date of contract: September 21, 1907.
1052                     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, 1.                                                                                        S. ARMY.

     Date of approval: October 5, 1907.
     Date of beginning work: October 2, 1907.
     Date of completion: August 25, 1908.
     Rates:
         Dredging, 25 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
         Rock removal, $10 per cubic yard, scow measurement.


                                    COM1\ERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR 1908.

                                            [Compiled from reports furnished by shippers and receivers.]

                                                                          Receipts and shipments.
                                                                      FIVEMILE RIVER HARBOR.


                                                                                   Articles.                                                                         Quantity.

                                                                                                                                                                     Net tons.
Oysters ...               ............            .............                     .............................                                                        18,04
Oyster shells ....................       ..................................................
                                       ......                                                                                                                             2,958
Lumber, coal, iron, etc....................................................                                  ...................                                            560
Gravel............... .......................................................................                                                                                336
Rubblestone...............................................................................                                                                                    84
           Total ............................                       .........................................                                               .....       21,986


  Valuation, $353,009.50.
  Tonnage shows an increase of about 91.5 per cent from that reported for 1907, and is
the largest amount reported since 1901, when the present method of collection by
direct reports from the shippers and receivers of material was begun.


                                                                               STAMFORD HARBOR.


                                                                                   Articles.                                                                         Quantity.

                                                                           EAST BRANCH.                                                                              Net tons.
Coal ........................................................................................                                                                            65,300
Lumber..........                                 ...............................................................                                                          7,181
Sand..... ........................                                    .........................................................                                           9,398
Stone ............    ..                                                               ..................................                                                 5,814
                                                                                                                                                                            8.................
Fire clay ............                                   ....... ..................................................                                                           11
Pig iron ......... ..... .........       ...... ........ ...................... .......................                                                                     456
Iron pipe...........               ......................................................                                                                                   212
Miscellaneous .....         ...      ................            ............             ..................................                                                426
Steamboat freight .................................................................................................                                                     201,600
           Total (of which 61,936 tons were shipments) .................                                                         ........................               290, 398
                                                                            WEST BRANCH.
Coal .........                   .................................................................                                                          ......       31,856
Sand.......................................................................                                                                                               3,248
Clay ........................                                               .....       ...............................................                                     516
Pig iron.............                                                        .
                                                                    ...........     ........                  ....................................                        3,405
Stone.....................................................................................                                                                                   168
Plaster...................................................................................                                                                                   224
Vitrified clay tile duct......... ..                              ...............................................                                                            224
Sulphur........................................                         .............................................                                                         30
Produce..............-..........................................................                                                                                              50
Various earths, ores, etc., for grinding .........................................................................                                                         9,537
Ground earths, ore, etc .........                      ......          ....          ...................................                                                .4,154
           Total (of which 4,154 tons were shipments) ........................................                                                                           53, 412

  Total tonnage for Stamford Harbor, 343,810.
  Total valuation for Stamford Harbor, East Branch, $10,104,350.10; West Branch,
$335,490.24=$10,439,840.34.
  Number of passengers carried, 10,000.
  The tonnage for the entire harbor shows an increase of about 20.4 per cent over
that reported for 1907; that in the East Branch shows an increase of about 24.4 per
cent and that in the West Branch shows an increase of about 2.2 per cent. The
                             APPENDIX D--REPORT OF LIEUT. COL. TAYLOR.                                                                            1053
amount of freight traffic reported for this harbor for 1908 is the largest reported since
1901, when the present method of collection by direct reports from shippers and
receivers was begun. During the past seven years the traffic has increased every
year but one--1905.
   Two regular lines of steamers, both landing in the East Branch, one carrying
freight and passengers and the other freight only, make daily trips to New York
throughout the year, with additional service of about three trips per week for about
three months.
                        [Furnished by collector of customs at Bridgeport, Conn.]
Value of imports....................................................             $24, 040. 00
Revenue receipts, duties on imports......................................... 1, 139. 04
Foreign vessels:
    Entered---........----................-------------------------------------------------.........................................                    6
    Cleared.........---------............----------------...----------------------------------.......................................                   3
            Total...........................................                                                                                            9


                                                          SOUTHPORT                     HARBOR.


                                                                Articles.                                                                      Quantity.

                                                                                                                                               Net tons.
Oysters------------..................-----------------------------------..................---------
                                                                                   2,253
Oyster shells .................................       ........-------------------------------------
                                                                                   1,891
Coal            ......................---------------------------------------------------------------...                                            2,464
Tiling ..............                   .........................---------------------------------------------------
                                                                                                     168
Merchandise....................................................................                                               .............             45
         Total...........--------------------------------------................------------------------
                                                                                       6,821


   Valuation, $66,060.
   Tonnage shows a decrease of about 14.6 per cent from that reported for 1907, almost
entirely in oysters. The amount of freight traffic reported for 1908 was the smallest
since 1902.


                                                          GREENWICH HARBOR.


                                                                Articles.                                                                      Quantity.

                                                                                                                                                Net tons.
Coal..............                               ................................                               ................                   22,400
Lumber...---..............                                          .........................................                                       3,360
Sand.......................................................8,960
Stone.....             ..... ... .... ..                       . ..................................................                                 6,720
Cem ent ......................................................................................                                                      4,480
Miscellaneous...------------------------------.-                    ....
                                                     ---------------.....   --.....                                                      .          3,360
Steamboat freight............... ........-..........-..-........... ..... .......                                                  ...             26,880
         Total--------------.....---------------------....----------...............--------------------
                                                                                      76,160


  Valuation, $9,778,000.
  A regular freight steamer makes triweekly trips to New York during about nine
months of the year and daily trips the remainder of the time.
  Tonnage of the harbor shows a decrease of about 16 per cent from that reported for
1907, chiefly in steamboat freight.
                   [Furnished by collector of customs at Bridgeport, Conn.]
Value of imports.... ...........................................                                                                              $6, 459. 00
Revenue receipts, duties on imports--.............               .......................                                                          511.84
Domestic vessels:
   Entered ..........................................................                                                                                   2
   Cleared...........................................................                                                                                   3

                                                                                                                                                        5
1054             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                        S. ARMY.

                            WESTPORT HARBOR AND SAUGATUCK RIVER.


                                                      Articles.                         Quantity.


                                                                                        Net tons.
Coal .........       .....................   .............................                 11,504'


   Valuation, $43,655.
   No shipments reported from this harbor this year.
   Tonnage shows a decrease of about 21.2 per cent from that reported for 1907, and is
the smallest amount reported since the present system of collection by direct reports
from the shippers and receivers was begun in 1902.



                                                                D 15.

REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDAN-
                  GERING NAVIGATION.

    Wreck of schooner Menawa.--This vessel, laden with about 1,000,000
lath, was in collision in July, 1908, with the U. S. S. Mayflower and
was nearly cut in two. Subsequently the wreck was towed in by the
U. S. tug Apache on July 27 and left at a point about 650 feet south-
southwest from the west end of the west breakwater at the entrance
of New Haven Harbor. In this position she was a serious menace to
navigation, and circular proposals for her removal were issued under
date of August 24, 1908. The proposal of Reed & Farrar, $376, was
accepted. Work was begun September 12, 1908, but owing to much
difficulty experienced in raising the wreck her removal was not
entirely completed until October 20, 1908. A portion of the cargo
was recovered, and the wreck, which was a total loss, was raised by
means of lighters and derrick scows, towed inside the harbor, and
finally placed on the flats about midway up the harbor and behind
the dike on the west side of the channel, entirely out of the way of
navigation.
    Wreck of lighter, name unknown.-This vessel, which was originally
a wooden sloop lighter about 70 feet long, name unknown, was lying
on the westerly side of the Poquonock River channel, Bridgeport Har-
bor, about 500 feet above East Washington Avenue Bridge. Over
six years ago the vessel was placed on the mud flats near here but
inside the United States harbor line, and from this position gradually
slid out to where she was lying at the time of removal. Although not
directly in the channel the wreck lay where it was an obstruction to
navigation and circular proposals were issued under date of April 12,
1909, for its removal. The proposal of the T. A. Scott Company
(Incorporated), $290, was accepted. Work was begun early in May
and completed on the 14th of that month. The wreck was broken
up by means of derricks, dynamite, and divers, and removed piece-
meal on derrick scows.
                                    APPENDIX E.


IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE FIRST NEW YORK,
                     N. Y., DISTRICT.


REPORT OF COL. W. M. BLACK, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, OFFICER IN
    CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 80, 1909.
                                       IMPROVEMENTS.

1.   Port Chester Harbor, New York.               10.   Wallabout Channel, New York.
2.   Mamaroneck Harbor, New York.                 11.   Browns Creek, New York.
3.   Larchmont Harbor, New York.                  12.   Great South Bay, New York.
4.   Echo Bay Harbor, New York.                   13.   Hudson River, New York.
5.   Bronx River and East Chester                 14.   Saugerties Harbor, New York.
       Creek, New York.                           15.   Harbors at Rondout and Peekskill,
6.   Harbors at Port Jefferson, Mattituck,                New York.
       Huntington, Glencove, Flushing             16.   Wappinger Creek, New York.
       Bay, and Canarsie Bay, New York.           17.   Tarrytown Harbor, New York.
7.   East River and Hell Gate, New                18.   Coney Island channel, New York.
       York.                                      19.   Removing sunken vessels or craft
8.   Harlem River, New York.                              obstructing or endangering navi-
9.   Newtown Creek, New York.                             gation.


                                    UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                       New York City, July 20, 1909.
   SIR: I have the honor to forward herewith annual report upon
works of river and harbor improvements in the New York first dis-
trict, in my charge, for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                   W. M. BLACK,
                                                        Colonel, Corps of Engineers.
     The   CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,             U. S. ARMY.


                                             E   I.

           IMPROVEMENT OF PORT CHESTER HARBOR, NEW YORK.

                OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 124 of this report.
   Proposals for dredging for maintenance were invited by advertise-
ment dated May 27, and opened June 28, 1909. The most advan-
tageous proposal received, and which was recommended for accept-
ance, was as follows:
For dredging, per cubic yard, scow measurement......................                       $0. 25
For removing bowlders, one-half to 3, cubic yards in size, per cubic yard, solid
  measurement ............................................................                  8.00
For removing bowlders, over 3, cubic yards in size, per cubic yard, solid meas-
  urement..................           ...............................................      12.00
                                                                                      1055
 1056                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   Disbursements were in payment of liabilities incurred in making
a survey of the river preliminary to advertising for proposals, in
part payment of office expenses, and in payment of the cost of mak-
ing an examination of a reported obstruction to navigation.
  A recent survey indicates that ledge rock exists in the upper
reaches of the river, in addition to that heretofore reported as
obstructing the channel at Fox Island. It is estimated that to com-
plete the existing project it will be necessary to remove 1,575 cubic
yards of rock at an estimated cost of $15,750.
                                                    Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909--................................----------------------------------------- .. $10, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                                      APPROPRIATIONS.

For former project (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 297) ........                                        $52, 000.00
For present project:
    March 3, 1899-----------....--..........-----....------........-----..........------.......$25, 000
    June 13, 1902...-----..--------...................--------------....-----.....----......                5, 000
    March 3, 1905--------.......-----..............------------.....---.....-----......---.....             3,000
    March 2, 1907............--------------.........................-----------......
                                                                                 ----------                 6, 500
                                                                                                                    39, 500. 00
Proceeds from sale of maps----...--..---.........                  .........---------------------------------.....         .75
             Total..............---------------------..-----..----------------.....--...---...                               91, 500.75



                                                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                         Vessels employed in trade in 1908.


                                                             Class.                                        m        Tonnage.       Draft.


                                                                                                                                    Feet.
Steam ers..................................................................                                2,200        15-400        5-11
Sailing vessels..............................................................                                250        10-600        2-14
Barges, etc--------..-...-....--------....------....------..........................----
                                                          1,200    50-800 3-14

    Passengers carried: A few excursions only.

                                                                    Freight handled, 1908.

                     Class.                             Tons.              Value.             Class.               Tons.         Value.

General merchandise........                             90,000 86,000,000           Minerals and products......     20,000        $600,000
Coal and other fuel...........                          50,000    256,000
Building and road material..                           105,000 505,000                   Total.................    265,000       7,355,000
                         APPENDIX E-REPORT OF COLONEL BLACK.                                                                 1057

                                                               E 2.

            IMPROVEMENT OF MAMARONECK HARBOR, NEW YORK.

                      OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

    For history and project see page 126 of this report.
    There being no funds available, there were no operations.



                                                  APPROPRIATIONS.
August 2, 1882..---------....-----.......................--------------------------..............------.....-----.... $15,000
July 3, 1896---------------.........-------------.............---------------.............-----------............            10,000
March 3, 1899----...-----..............------------------...................-------------......---------...........--..----.  7,000
June 13, 1902------.........-----------...................---------------...................------------..----------.......   6, 000
March 3, 1905......----------------------------..------------.............................--------------...                   2,000

          Total------------------................-------------------------............                                      40,000



                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                         Vessels employed in trade in 1908.


                                            Class.                                                    Trips
                                                                                                      made.   Tonnage.Draft.
                                                                                                              Tonnage.

                                                                                                                               Feet.
Tugs and steamers .............................                    ..........................           419           247         4-9
Barges................                                                          46    400-600
                                      ......................................................... 8-14


   Nlumber of passengers carried, 6,380.
   Pleasure boats using harbor, 171, valued at $389,845.

                                                  Freight handled, 1908.

             Articles.                  Tons.         Value.                     Articles.                    Tons.         Value.

General merchandise .......               8,000       $859,700 Ice.......................                         300          $1,200
Coal and other fuel..........            13,890          96,600
Building and road material..             16,350          62,725             Total.. ...............            38,540       1,020.225



                                                               E    3.

              IMPROVEMENT OF LARCHMONT HARBOR, NEW YORK,

                         OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 127 of this report.
   There were no operations during the year. Disbursements were in
part payment of office expenses and a proportional part of the cost
of a sounding, boring, and sweeping scow.
          9001--ENG 1909---67
1058             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

For former project (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 294).......... $5, 000. 00
For present project:
    March 3, 1899...........--         .......... ........................                              $50, 000
    June 13, 1902...----------........-----......----------..........-----........------.....-----.      10,000
    March 3, 1.905----------....................-------------------------......................-------.   5,000
    March 2, 1907...---..-.....--------......-----..--...............------------------.....-....        14, 000
                                                                                                                 79, 000. 00
         Total ...................                     ....... .....               ............                    ..........      ......     84, 000. 00
Received on bond of failing contractor ................................                                                                        6, 905. 04

         Total ......                   .... ...................................                  ..............                            . 90,905.04



                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  Number of vessels other than yachts entering harbor of refuge, or for the night,
during 1901 (estimated), 850.
  Draft of such vessels, 4-18 feet.
  Tonnage of such vessels, 100-500 tons.
                                Freight discharged in Larchamont Harbor in 1901.
Number of cargoes ........................                    .......................                                           .........             150
Amount in tons.............................................................                                                                       15, 500
                               Vessels owned by the Larchmont                           Y cht Club, 1901.
                                  [Draft, from 3 to 22 feet; tonnage, from 3 to 600 tons.]
Steamers.......................................................................86
Schooners.....................................--------..........................            51
Sloops....--.................................................................              160
Smaller boats..............................................................---.....66
          Total.........................................................                                                                             363
  No replies Were received in response to requests for commercial statistics data for
1908.


                                                                     E 4.
             IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT ECHO BAY, NEW YORK.

                        OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 127 of this report.
   Under contract with John & Joseph McSpirit, dated July 29, 1908,
the removal of Long Rock was completed October 31, 1908, by the
excavation and disposal of 724 ,% cubic yards of ledge rock to a depth
of 6 feet below mean low water.
   A proportional part of the cost of a sounding, boring, and sweep-
ing scow was paid from this appropriation.
                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

June 18, 1878.................. $10,000                                     June 13, 1902................... $17,000
March 3, 1879.................    3, 000                                    March 2, 1907...................  12, 000
June 14, 1880..................   3, 000
March 3, 1881................     3, 000                                                 Total..................                                  51, 000
August 2, 1882.................   3, 000
                             APPENDIX E-REPORT                                    OF COLONEL BLACK.                                              1059

                                                       CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Name of contractor: John & Joseph McSpirit.
  Date of contract: July 29, 1908.
  Date of approval: August 4, 1908.
  Date of commencement: September 10, 1908.
  Date of completion: June 10, 1909. Completed October 31, 1908.
  For the removal of about 725 cubic yards of ledge rock at $8.50 per cubic yard,
prism measurement, in place.
                                                    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                   Vessels employed in trade in 1908.

                                                      Class.                                                            Trips     Tonnage.         Draft.


                                                                                                                                                    Feet.
Tugs and steamers.........................................                                      ...............          4,000 ............          6-11
Sailing vessels..........            ....     .....        .... .......... ..................... ...........       ..      400          50-300       5-131
Barges, etc ........................                          ..... ..... ................              ..........         700        100-700        5-11


    Passengers carried, 25,000.
                                                           Freight handled in 1908.

                  Class.                         Tons.            Value.                            Class.                       Tons.           Value.

General merchandise........                       78,000       $1,100,000           Ashes, garbage, etc.........                  12,000            $5,000
Coal and other fuel..........                     70,000            350,000
Building and road materials..                     80, 000           502, 500                Total...               .......      244, 750         2, 092, 500
Farm products ..............                        4, 750          135,000


                                                                            E 5.

IMPROVEMENT OF BRONX RIVER AND EAST CHESTER CREEK, NEW
                        YORK.

                                         (A)     BRONX RIVER, NEW YORK.

                           OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 129 of this report.
   Under contract and supplemental agreement with John & Joseph
McSpirit dated July 29, 1908, and February 5, 1909, respectively,
the removal of two ledges of rock and overlying material, situated
at and immediately below the turn at the gas works, was completed
June 9, 1909, by the excavation and disposal of 2,577.56 cubic yards
of ledge rock, bowlders, gravel, sand, and mud, to a depth of 6 feet
below mean low water.
   A survey of the river from its junction with East River to the
head of navigation was completed.
   A proportional part of the cost of a sounding, boring, and sweep-
ing scow was paid from this appropriation.
                                             Estimate of additional funds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
    For works of improvement........................          ............ $6, 485
    For maintenance of improvement...............................          10, 000
                                                                                 ----$16, 485
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
1060               REPORT OF THE                          CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                        S. ARMY.

                                                           APPROPRIATIONS.
June 3, 1896 ...........................---------------------------------------------------------                                     . $10, 000.00
March 3, 1899---...------------------------------------------------------..
                                          .......                    ...............                                                     20, 000. 00
June 13, 1902 (allotment)--...--------------------------------------------                                                                5, 000. 00
March 3, 1905 (allotment).........................                    ..................              ...   21, 500.00
March 2, 1907 (allotment). ...............................                           ...... ......-. 23,000.00
Received from sale of maps...----.........------------.......................------------------.....------.         65
           Total---...................................-------------------------------------------.......------....                          79, 500 65

                                                       CONTRACT IN FORCE.

   Name of contractor: John & Joseph McSpirit.
   Date of contract: July 29, 1908.
   Date of approval: August 4, 1908.
   Date of commencement: September 10, 1908.
   Date of completion: August 10, 1909. Completed June 9, 1909.
   For the removal of 2,167.88 cubic yards of ledge rock and overlying material at
$8.50 per cubic yard, prism measurement, in place.
   Supplemental agreement with John & Joseph McSpirit was entered into February
5, 1909, for the removal of an additional 372 cubic yards of ledge rock and overlying
material, at $8.50 per cubic yard, prism measurement, in place, work to be completed
August 10, 1909. Completed June 9, 1909.

                                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                Vessels employed in trade in 1908.


                                               Class.                                                          No.     Trips
                                                                                                                       made.      Tonnage.       Draft.


                                                                                                                                                 Feet.
Tuos and steamers................................................                           ........            a2 .                                5-6
Sailing vessels....... ... ........ .........                  ...................                      ....           "...100        50-500        5-62
Barges, etc ...    ...........................................                                                         2, 722         80-425       4--6

                                                               a Trips not reported

                                                        Freight handled in 1903.

                 Class.                        Tons.           Value.                             Class.                         Tons.         Value.


General merchandise........     3, 000                         $225, 000        Ice ..     .1.. ...................                1, 000         $2, 500
Coal and other fuel ..........164, 3'5                          825, 000
Building and road materials. 230, 950                           900, 000                 Total ..............                    401, 433      2, 017, 500
Minerals and products......     2, 118                           65, 000



                                   (B)      EAST CHESTER CREEK, NEW YORK.

                           OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST                                                 FISCAL YEAR.

     For history and project see page 130 of this report.
     No operations were carried on, there being no funds available.
                                             Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
  provement.... ....      ~................                                 $......10,
                                                                                   000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                          APPENDIX E-REPORT                                  OF COLONEL BLACK.                                                 1061
                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1873................... $25, 000                                    June 13, 1902 (allotment).._...                                   $3,000
March 3, 1875_........ .......    12, 000                                    June 13, 1902 (allotment) ....                                    10, 000
June 18, 1878...................  10, 000                                    April 28, 1904 (allotment) ....                                    2, 500
March 3, 1879...................   3, 500                                    March 3, 1905 (allotment)-.......                                     3,000
June 14, 1880..................    3. 500                                    March 2, 1907 (allotment)......                                       6, 000
August 5, 1886..... .........     10, 000                                    Received from sale of maps.....                                               2
August 11, 1888 ................   5, 000
August 18, 1894...............    12, 000                                                 Total ...................                           115, 502
June 3, 1896...................   10.000




                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                         Vessels employed in trade in 1908.


                                              Class.




                                                   Freight handled in 1908.

                Class.                  Tons.               Value.                             Class.                           Tons.         Value.


General merchandise ........             19,151        51, 400, 000          Minerals and products ......                        12,762        $390,000
Coal and other fuel..........           136,046             680,000          Ashes, garbage, etc........._                        7,540           4,000
Building and road materials..            94,120             275,000
Manufactures ...........                  3,750             115,000                   Total....................                 273,369       2,864,000


                                                                     E 6.

IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AT PORT JEFFERSON, MATTITUCK, HUN-
  TINGTON, GLENCOVE, FLUSHING BAY, AND CANARSIE BAY, NEW
  YORK.
                                   (A)        PORT JEFFERSON HARBOR.

                         OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 132 of this report.
   Under contract with E. S. Belden & Sons dated July 31, 1907, for
extending the east jetty, 5,663 tons of stone were delivered during the
fiscal year, completing 80 linear feet of jetty to its full projected sec-
tion. Work under the contract was completed September 18, 1908.
                                   Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of improve-
ment...........................
  mlent------,----         -----    - ...............
                                          -    -  ......................
                                                   -    -    -   -   -   -  $10,000
                                                                              -   -   -    -   -   -    -   -   -   -   -   -     -   -   -    1   ,   0



Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897.
1062                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                   APPROPRIATIONS.

For former projects (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 297)......... $79, 000. 00
For present project:
    September 19, 1890...........................-------------------------------.......... $25, 000. 00
    July 13, 1892...............................                             ..........     10, 000.00
    August 18, 1894..-....-------..----..--....................-----------------...---...    7, 500. 00
                                                                        ------------ 7, 500.00
    June 3, 1896-----------------......---..............----------...................
    March 3, 1899--..........--....---------------------------.......................         7, 500. 00
    June 13, 1902 (allotment)-----------.............---...............                     10, 500. 00
    April 28, 1904 (allotment)......................                 ......     .       ...  2, 400. 00
    March 3, 1905 (allotment)...---------.....------....------..............                 8, 500. 00
    March 2, 1907 (allotment) ...-..............                           $24, 000. 00
    Transferred to allotment for Sag Harbor......                            2, 900.00
                                                                                            21, 100. 00
                                                                                                         100, 000. 00
      Total...................................................               179, 000.00
March 26, 1907, repaid to United States Treasury the unexpended balance
of allotment of $2,400, made from emergency act of April 28, 1904-..--..--.      443. 65
      Net amount appropriated...------------.........--------.........-----.........------..                                                              178, 556.35
Net amount appropriated for present project ............................                                                                                   99, 556. 35



                                                             CONTRACT IN FORCE.

   Name of contractor: E. S. Belden & Sons.
   Date of contract: July 31, 1907.
   Date of approval: August 30, 1907.
   Date of commencement: October 3, 1907.
   Date of completion: July 3, 1908. Time limit waived. Completed September
18, 1908.
   For extending the east jetty by delivery therein of 13,800 net tons of stone at $1.25
per ton.


                                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                       Vessels employed in trade in 1908.


                                                                           Class.made.                                                          Tonnage.          Draft.


                                                                                                                                                                   Feet.
Tugs and steamers ...----......----------...----.....-......----------------.......----.........-....                      -----         884      20-1,000           5-15
Sailing vessels--------------------------------------------------..............................................................          140      50- 100            4- 6
Barges, etc---------..---------..----------.....................................---------..-.....------------...........                  56      41-     200         4- 6
Miscellaneous craft--------------....--...-----......-------...........-----------...........................                            150


    Passengers carried, 33,926.
                                                                Freight handled in 1908.

                    Class.                            Tons.             Value                                 Class.                           Tons.            Value.

General merchandise.......                               6, 670          $500, 000         Farm products.............                            7, 800         $195, 000
Coal and other fuel..-~..-..                           7, 160             375,000          Fish....-...................                            500             25, 000
Building and road materials.                         104, 700             425, 000
Minerals and products.......                              100               1, 000                 Total. ........                 ...         127,230          1, 536, 000
Manufactures................                                300             15,000
                 APPENDIX E-REPORT OF COLONEL BLACK.                             1063

                             (B)    MATTITUCK HARBOR.

               OPERATIONS          DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 133 of this report.
   Under contract with the Maritime Dredging Company 84,514-
cubic yards of material were excavated and disposed of during the
fiscal year, making a total of 87,997.7 cubic yards removed under
the contract; and resulting in dredging a channel 7 feet deep at
mean low water, 100 feet wide and about 1,400 feet long at the
entrance; thence a distance of about 400 feet, the same depth and
80 feet wide; and thence a distance of about 2,000 feet, the same
depth and 60 feet wide.
   A number of steamers, dredges, and schooners have commenced
operations in the immediate vicinity of the harbor planting oysters
and distributing shells, and using the harbor for anchorage at night
and in stormy weather. It is reported that about $35,000 will be
expended this season in preparing oyster beds, and that a number
of houses are to be built along the creek for the storage and shipment
of sea products.
   Considerable delay has been experienced, from minor causes, in
prosecuting the work under this contract, due to the exposed loca-
tion at the entrance, the rapid tidal currents, and the slight depth
and narrow channel required, on account of which the plant used
had to be of a light character.
   In the light of increased information afforded by a recent survey
it has been decided to build the east jetty to a length of 1,000 feet
and the west jetty to a length of 800 feet, connecting its inner end
with the shore above the high-water level by a dike; to complete
the dredged channel as far as the milldam, about 14 miles below
Mattituck (the limit of the improvement named in the approved
project), and not to begin work above the dam until after the local
authorities shall have removed the dam and replaced the existing
fixed bridge by a drawbridge. The volume of dredging required to
complete the improvement according to the adopted project is now
found to be approximately 63,000 cubic yards in excess cf the amount
estimated in 1891, when the project was submitted. To complete
the improvement as far as the dam an expenditure of $53,200 will be
required in addition to the funds now available.
                         Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement       ...... ..-.... ........    ........ $25, 000
   For maintenance of improvement ..........................            3, 000
                                                                                 $28, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
 1064                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                            U.    S. ARMY.

                                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.

June 3, 1896-----------------------------------------------------                                                                ..        $10, 000. 00
March 3, 1899.............................------------------------------------------------         5, 000. 00
March 3, 1905 (allotment)...........-------------------------------------- . 20, 000. 00
March 2, 1907 (allotment)... .......                          ....        .......----------------------------------------
                                                                                                  40, 000. 00
March 3, 1909 (allotment)..................----------------------------------------                6, 000. 00
Received from sale of maps...------------------------------------------                                  4. 35
             Total.........-------------......                                                   .      ..........----------.........       81 004 35



                                                           CONTRACT IN FORCE.

Name of contractor: Maritime Dredging Company.
  Date of contract: December 24, 1907.
  Date of approval: January 15, 1908.
  Date of commencement: April 1, 1908.
  Date of completion: November 1, 1908. Time limit waived.
  For dredging 139,400 cubic yards of material at 233 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement; bowlders at $4 per cubic yard, solid measurement.

                                                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                      Vessels employed in trade in 1908.

                                                                                                                                      Number
                                                                  Class.                                                                of         Draft.
                                                                                                                                      vessels.a

                                                                                                                                                       Feet.
Steamers and tugs...................................................................                                                             2 .
Sailing vessels ....................................................................                                                            10       5-10
Miscellaneous craft ................................................................                                                            28 .

                                                           a Trips and tonnage not reported.

                                                              Freight handled in 1908.

                                                                  Class.                                                                Tons.     Value.


Farmproduce.........................................360                                                                                            $10,000
                        .......
Fish and shells....-.....                  ...................                                   ..................                       600        6,000
Fertilizer. -----................. .............. .....                                ...................    ........ .........          200        6,000
         Total ...............................                                                                                          1,100          22,000



                                                      (C) HUNTINGTON HARBOR.

                              OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

      For history and project see page 134 of this report.
      There were no operations, no funds being available.
                                                 Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
  improvement...          .     ............................................ $5, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                       APPENDIX           E--REPORT OF COLONEL BLACK.                                                    1065
                                                APPROPRIATIONS.

For former project (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 294)............ $22, 500
For present project:
    September 19, 1890-----------......---...---..----...-......----------.....--..........                $10, 000
    July 13, 1892----------..........................-----------------------------.......----....            5,000
    August 18, 1894..---------------...............----------...........--............-------------..---.    2,000
    June 3, 1896-----..............--...---....-----.............---------------........--------.            5, 000
    March 3, 1899---..----------------..........-------------------..................-----.....              7, 500
    June 13, 1902 (allotment) ...............-------------------....----------................-----.         2, 500
    March 3, 1905 (allotment)-.......-...                      ........................                      2, 500
    March 2, 1907 (allotment)---...-----...........---------................... --------------               3, 500
                                                                                                                -   38,000
      Total .........................                      ...                           .................          60, 500
      Total --------------------------------------------------------                                                60,500



                                         COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                      Vessels employed in trade in 1908.

                                                     Class.                                    Tripse
                                                                                               made.    Tonnage.          Draft.


                                                                                                                           Feet.
Tugs, steamers, etc..................           .................     ................            800             75+            6+


   Number of passengers carried, 8,000.
   Pleasure craft using harbor, 378, valued at $111,250.
                                               Freight handled in 1908.

             Class.                 Tons.         Value.                     Class.                     Tons.           Value.

General merchandise ........          1,397       $118, 485   Fruits and farm products...                3,500            $97, 000
Coal and other fuel..........        19,700         65, 412   Fish ................. ......                280             12,500
Building and road materials.         13, 332       114, 759
Minerals and products.....               107         5,062           Total .................            38, 316           413,218



                                        (D) GLENCOVE HARBOR.

                      OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

  For history and project see page 135 of this report.
  There were no operations, no funds being available.
  The present length of breakwater appears to afford sufficient pro-
tection to vessels seeking shelter from storms in this vicinity, and its
further extension seems therefore to be unnecessary.


                                                APPROPRIATIONS.

August 11, 1888.................$20, 000                       June 13, 1902 (allotment).......                          $6, 000
September 19, 1890...--........ 15, 000                        March 3, 1905 (allotment).......                           3, 000
July 13, 1892................... 10, 000
August 18, 1894..........    .... 10, 000                                Total ....................                      72, 000
June 3, 1896................       8, 000
 1066                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                S. ARMY.

                                                      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                    Vessels employed in trade in 1906.

                                                       Class.                                                          Trips     Tonnage.        Draft.


                                                                                                                                                 Feet.
Barges, etc .................................                          ..............................                       74           200       51-6


                                                                      Freight handled.

                                                           Articles.                                                             Tons.         Value.


Coal and other fuel ...............................................                                            ..............      7, 062       $18, 000


    Statistics not asked for since 1906.                                     No funds available.


                                                            (E)        FLUSHING                         BAY.

                            OPERATIONS                     DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 136 of this report.
   Under contract with the Maritime Dredging Company, dated July
25, 1907, 8 73 3o cubic yards of material were excavated and disposed
of during the fiscal year, making a total of 120,805-z cubic yards
removed under the contract. The work done has resulted in making
a channel 6 feet deep at mean low water and 200 feet wide from the
6-foot contour in the bay to Broadway Bridge, obstructed, however,
by a few large rocks lying close to the bank on the easterly side of the
channel at the turn immediately north of the bridge; thence to the
Main Street Bridge of the Long Island Railroad, 6 feet deep at mean
low water and 100 feet wide.
   Examinations were made of the creek with a view to locating
reported obstructions. None were found. Examinations were also
made of the creek and tributaries lying above the Main Street Bridge
in connection with proposed improvements by owners of property
situated on the water front.
                                                Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
   exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
   provement..---------------------.......-------------------------------.....  $3, 500
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
   and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                                APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1879......-..-...........                   $20, 000                             July 13, 1892_..................                    $10, 000
June 14, 1880.............                       ...  15, 000                             August 18, 1894.................                      4, 000
March 3, 1881----..------......-------..........      10, 000                             June 3, 1896.....-----..----.....--......             4, 000
August 2, 1882..........-..                            5, 000                             June 13, 1902 (allotment)-.......                     2, 000
July 5, 1884.............                    .. . 10, 000                                 March 3, 1905 (allotment).......                     10, 000
August 5, 1886---........                       ..    10, 000                             March 2, 1907 (allotment)......                      27, 000
August 11, 1888---.................                   15, 000
September 19, 1890.............. 20, 000                                                               Total....................              162, 000
                                APPENDIX E-REPORT                                        OF COLONEL BLACK.                                           1067
                                                          CONTRACT IN                          FORCE.

Name of contractor: Maritime Dredging Company.
Date of contract: July 25, 1907.
Date of approval: August 14, 1907.
Date of commencement: September 16, 1907.
Date of completion: June 16, 1908. Time limit waived. Completed July 9, 1908.
For dredging 127,000 cubic yards of material at 193 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement.



                                                       COMMERCIAL                         STATISTICS.

                                                      Vessels employed in trade in 1908.

                                                           Class.                                                            Trips     Tonnage.       Draft.


                                                                                                                                                       Feet.
Tugs and steamers ........................................................                                                      376       100-600        3-14
Sailing vessels....- ........................................................                                                    54       100-200        3-12
Barges, etc..............................                      .............................                        ......    1,126       200-887        4-11



                                                               Freight handled in 1908.

                   Class.                          Tons.              Value.                               Class.                     Tons.         Value.

Gefieral merchandise..--...                           2, 243      $1,100, 000           Ashes, garbage, etc...........                  3,300          $1, 700
Coal and other fuel. ...  -                          71,207            300,000
Building and road material..                         38, 107           150, 000                    Total...............               126, 455      1, 774, 900
Ice ...                                              11,598              23,200


                                                               (F) CANARSIE                         BAY.

                             OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 137 of this report.
   There were no operations during the year. Disbursements were
in part payment of office expenses and liabilities incurred in making
examinations in connection with reported obstructions to navigation.
   A report upon a survey of Jamaica Bay, New York, completed in
January, 1909, together with a plan and estimated cost of improve-
ment, was submitted January 30, 1909. Pending action by Congress
it seems inadvisable to make further appropriations for the improve-
ment of Canarsie Bay.



                                                                  APPROPRIATIONS.

June 14, 1880................. $10, 000                                                 June 13, 1902 (allotment). .....                            $5, 000
March 3, 1881 . ................   5, 000                                               March 3, 1905 (allotment).......                             2, 500
August 2, 1882 ..............      3, 000                                               March 2, 1907 (allot-
July 5, 1884 ....................  5, 000                                                      ment).................                   $4, 000
August 5, 1886................    10, 000                                                Transferred   to  allot-
August 11, 1888...............    10, 000                                                  ment for harbor at
September 19, 1890.                5, 000            -..........                           Sag Harbor, N. Y......                             750
July 13, 1892..................    5, 000                                                                                                             3, 250
August 18, 1894...............     2, 000
June 3, 1896 ................     10, 000                                                              Total..................                       75, 750
1068             REPORT OF                 THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                        U.    S. ARMY.

                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                              Vessels employed in trade in 1908.

                                                 Class.                                                        Trips.    Tonnage.         Draft.


                                                                                                                                           Feet.
Tugs and steamers........................................---------------------------------------------.           932        10-1,032       5-12
Sailing vessels -... ... .... ...-... ..                  .. ..............           .. ...... . .                44          40-C00       4-12
Barges, etc-----                                                                                  .       .     2,128         150600         57
Miscellaneous craft ......-----------------------------------------------                                          44    .

   Passengers carried, about 50,000.

                                                     Freight handled in 1908.

                Class.                      Tons.           Value.                         Class.                       Tons.           Value.


General merchandise ........                  8, 050          $80, 500      Fish....................                     10, 025        $310, 000
Coal and other fuel..... .....                7, 900           35, 000      Ashes, garbage, etc.........                 56, 900          65, 290
Building and road materials..               153, 750          600, 000
Minerals and products......-                  3, 450           34, 500              Total..............                 240, 075        1, 125, 290



                                                                      E 7.
       IMPROVEMENT OF EAST RIVER AND HELL GATE, NEW YORK.

                         OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 139 of this report.
   Under contract with R. G. Packard Company, dated May 29, 1908,
for completing the removal of Pot Rock, Frying Pan Reef, and
Middle Reef, in Hell Gate, N. Y., 125,2981" square feet in area A
and 105,870f4 square feet in area B in Middle Reef (see sketch) were
cleared of all obstructions to a depth of 26 feet below mean low
water.
   A survey of the river authorized by river and harbor act of March
2, 1907, was commenced.
   A proportional part of the cost of a sounding, boring, and sweeping
scow was paid from this appropriation.
   As the removal of the worst obstruction in the East River in the
vicinity of Hell Gate is nearing completion, thus providing a depth
in that vicinity of 26 feet, it is time steps were taken looking to the
removal of obstructions in the East River eastward of Hell Gate.
Those which are most prominent are shown on sketch printed in
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908 (p. 1047).
   Several well-founded complaints have been made as to minor
obstructions between South Brother Island and Lawrence Point,
about 2 miles east of Hell Gate, lying in a channel used by ferryboats
between Manhattan and College Point, craft going eastward to
Flushing Bay, and coal barges bound to Lawrence Point.
   Another serious obstruction to the navigation of the East River,
the subject of frequent complaints, is Middle Ground, situated in
mid-channel 1 miles east of Hell Gate, near the southern entrance
to Little Hell Gate and between Sunken Meadows and Lawrence
Point, with a channel width on either side of barely 350 feet. Its
removal has been frequently recommended by my predecessors and
      I       --                j                   ,,                     ,                                                                                                       ----                  I            ---               --                                      - --         --                                                                                       _                                                   r --
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             SOUTH    LINE OF                                                                      EAST 10 0"                      T.              P ROLONGED




                                                                                    . 28 ..
                                                                                   3,,7   * ,-.                                                                                         ",7
                                                                                                                                                                                          ,,                                    '       "




                                                    Z33   Z7-X
                                                     3.. .3+
                                                         .....
                                                           ,Zs:3
                                                             .oy               o9.4               3                                       2 9       asc3La


                                                                                                                                                             a27               a
                                                                                                                                                                                            ."3+ Jl'+
                                                                                                                                                                                                   +,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 93   s             .

                                                                  27 -             27/                            as        o                            4




                                                              28                 30o3.3                                                                       3
                                                                                                                                                             32
                                                                                                33o3                                            3,3o                  /            o
                                                                                                                                                                                       an

                                                                                                      N                              333 3!                                                     33+.....
                                                                                                                                                                                                      3                             !
                                          a     +a
                                                ,                        . e
                                                                      C333s/3a         s33            a,                                             a       c                     9              3s


                                                                                                ~                          es x,33                           ,        so               as

                               o33
                                   zn    .
                                               3o
                                               Z/.8 2033 zM.a
                                                                  as/.
                                                                             S         "
                                                                                            30
                                                                                              333 !
                                                                                             ""Za
                                                                                                 2/.9s
                                                                                                                      a"s'
                                                                                                                            30as3./
                                                                                                                       29.2 3                   G3a                .
                                                                                                                                                                 29.2              o
                                                                                                                                                                                   3/.3         z                         '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          3333
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          0
               CL
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ::33
                                                   09.                                                            zy       tas                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               99T.
                                                                                                                                                as
                                  .33333
                                                                                                                       1
                                                                                                                      33232
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    EAST                                         ST.
                                                                       288                            }                                                                            30                "       a

                                                                                                                                              33
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     02s




                                3333333        3 7.0 6 33
                                     Z9,338!33;3233333
                                                                                                 o3-.o                     '':2. 7o                      30           ; o2Z.433
                                                                                                                                                                            ,
                                                                                                                                                                           333                                       333
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         /G
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        .33

                                        21.4__3.33o
                                       !.-                  3332a
                                                        .. .oo
                                                    3 Z 38. 3 82
                                                    ,., ,.                                                                                .
                                                                                                                                                      g
                                                                                                                                                L.. 3 .. o             ' a
                                                                                                                                                                      "'
                                                                                                                                                                            ,,,3
                                                                                                                                                                                       ::
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   PROLONGED
                                              Z0______2____372x73


                               /3332333
                                        38,o              s2      ,,o,'!+o
                                                                      .333
                                                                               2374


                                                                                                  . z.
                                                                                           3,3333333
                                                                                                      33               23        1        t..,o0
                                                                                                                                     ,, Z,303533/.a
                                                                                                                                                         333e         as 8 ..
                                                                                                                                                                            3 ...
                                                                                                                                                                               /:"3



                                                                                                     3,                                                                                     38       Z733/33
                                   a          JA     23           aso          2       8                  .                                      9Z30                      a                                                z




                         as              &,       so s i33L
                                                      t  . 3)o.          a       29.ar          3,n           8.Z ,          soo3             Zr9G                                 33       8    s           '
                                                3331
                                                         339                                                                                                      ,
                                                                                                                                                                 "3.3
                                                                                                              J                  2,4o,                                                                           ;
                               "J                                                  o33                3                                   33,                                                            3
                                333                           Jig3         3       44                                  .Z's7 3            Z     i

                         33>                                          33.03333/3833333                                     333                       /3NO.R




          z    3 3~ ~
                          333           ~
                                       31
                                                3/
                                              o>2A        8
                                                          22                 3o,
                                                                         3433 333
                                                                                            8
                                                                                           aZ   46.6               "Zg 1'0           L![so7                  763
                                                                                                                                                                  33
                                                                                                                                                                                   0.
                                                                                                                                                                                            34!8




                                                                                 //
                                                                             33.?3                              3.73                                         3
                   3/4333233   270      o4q     a     L                                o7.      97
                                                                                                      333.t
                                                                                                         3384333
                                                                                                          a            o             c




                           3133               333                 e~a              :             33                        33            9      33           33             333



                               3          33
                                           3         .
                                                                       32 3oc

                                                                      .,                        388
                                                                                                                                                 63          335           33!
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   O
                                                                                                              33,,.                           33S4
                        3lo        3    s.J.9             3       .                               3303.7                         333 33                  8                 304                  2>o               L 0      33 5


                                                                       m                     39.                                                         3/03.2                                     333



                                                          s,/
                                3332S2j
                               334 33733
                                                                                 33.
                                                                                                      3            3        3 '3.
                                                                                                                                                                      330.0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   EAST                98T! S T.
                                          V033
                                           33330                                                                                         333                 S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  PROLONGED
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        WAR       D    E PAR TM EN T



                                                                                       3/.
                                                                  33 o                 o3        3"].3                                                       333,'.,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          UNITED   STATES       ENGINEER          OFFICE.    DISTRICT    NO.   1. NEW   YORK
                                                          3       Jo           273                                               25


                                         23 S2;33
                                       324

                        .338                          G
                                                     33333-3.3 333
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     POT ROCK                                 AND              FRYING                    PAN
                                   5.                         3
                                                                                       2i       .3333w 2
                                                                             333                  3                                                                                                                                                                 HELL               GATE,              NEW          YORK
                                                                      -8       37333                          Z             74                   Z.5             Z.


                                                                                                333
                         36                                                      ?,2             3.6Z9T                                                                                                                                                                                       SKETCH

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     SHOWING LOCATION               OF SHOALS         TO BE REMOVED      AND LIMITING    LINES

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     OF AREAS TO     BE CLEARED              OF OBSTRUCTIONS          UNDER SPECIFICATIONS

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      DATED       MARCH 14     1908                                                           UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE.   DISTRICT   NO. I

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            NEW YORK, N.Y.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  SCALE
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              TO ACCOMPANY ANNUAL REPORT     OF   o909
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       50         O      50     10       150           200 FEET

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          7                                                                                                                  COLONEL   CORPS OF   ENGINEERS U . S   ARMY.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             HLINE   OF            E. 9       T.-      ST.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  EAST                        97TLH ST.       PROLONGED

---                                                                            --                                                                                     --       -

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               THENORRISPETERS CO, WASHIGTON,D.   .   C
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             p7-

                                                                                                                                                             so a s                            at+                                                                                                                                                                                          ocSoT5Na                                                                                                      -




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             WAR         DEPARTME                          t
                                                                                                                                                                                               21                  8To                                                                                                                                                                                 -                                                                                                      p

                                            as37+ /
                                                                                                                                   4
                                                                                                                                   22         4              23                                                                       +

                                                             3
                                                                                                                           9.05+p+
                                                        +         304+                                                                                                         2o                         2                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           UNITED        STATES         ENGINEER              OFFICE.           DISTRICT            NO.           1. NEW    YORK
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      0




               oS                                   9




                                                        ,5
                                                                      +




                                                                 7+ +3+
                                                                                                                                              t.5     sq26o




                                                                                                                                                                                                                          3I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         os4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 A               I                                                                                                                                                           MIDDLE                                                                                                               REEF
                          So
                           30           +                                                                            22    429                                                          2n                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          a        **.23                           ue

                                                                                                                                        Hr                  a22

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      HELL GATE, NEW                                                   YORK
                                                                                                                                        22.                                                  39+                       05                         3a5+                                                                                                                                       2



33~iot          7+8
                      35.7+




                           214     1L~                               2o1
                                                                               2+Z58
                                                                                  6         326            23



                                                                                                                2.
                                                                                                               3.
                                                                                                                       67.+

                                                                                                                                   2O             4o
                                                                                                                                                                                   24          4.
                                                                                                                                                                                                   14                    .        24
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2o



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          oo.4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    3                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 SKETCH
                               acj                      237                                                                 oe
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    as   000C 0                                                                   SHOWING LOCATION OF SHOALS TO BE REMOVED AND LIMITING LINES
                           29      -4+                           52                                    3o
                                                                                                                 2   1.
                                                                                                                       o.
                                                                                                                     3253
                                                                                                                               o
                                                                                                                                                  2     4        2
                                                                                                                                                                               4.
                                                                                                                                                                               o             3.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     30  7oo




                                                                                              2.                        4+
                                                                                                                      032                                                                                           39
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    32                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            OF AREAS TO BE CLEARED OF OBSTRUCTIO00 UNDER SPECIFICATIONS
                           3024                                       24   4            L     22.o                                                                                                                                                4             9                                                    Son        +3                                                                                       +




                                                                           +            2c.          206                       2322           20                                                    1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   6+                         30          E+e                                                                                                                                                                                                A2                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             DATED MARCH 14                      1908
                    .4+
                                                    333                                                                                                     2Z1.4




                                    a24s            2?2.4                                   20   !

                                                                                                           .4s
                                                                                                               t4.9                                                         2z          9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        2o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Zf   .2                                                   r     22                       r                 i3




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    196      0"                              2.618.3                                                                                                                                                                        21

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2T"                                                                                                                SCALE

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Iso10
                                                                                                                                        21.6                                                                                                                                                                                  146                                                                                                                                                         27                                     tZ.24.6

                      29   4                                                                                                                                                                         216                                                                   9                                         5         25.0                                 71                                 07                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         50                  0                      50                            oo                                             200
                                                                                                                                                                                                   24         0                                               28.0              251                                                  27   5\\                                                                                                                     266.
                                                21.4                                                   21        S                        259



         303                                                 2   .91                                                       213                                                                                                            27          °                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    16                    2.




                                                                                        337+                     239.19.0 6                            29                          24.5            22 0
                                                                                                                                                                                                        2          24,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      oZo995
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        21.'7                                                                '1"G25.7                                                    '!       e



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          06a

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              a
                                                                                                                                                    2402.                                                                                                                           2
                                                                                                 '23       0         20.8




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        24.0                                                                          2.
                                                                                                                     32.8                                            22                              23       7                  23       0                     235


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   2'1.5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           26    1                   24           66
                                                                                                                                                          i9.5                                                                                                                          22.1




3030     7+
         5+
                    2&5

                           262 291




                                                                 29            on
                                                                                        23    i~9              220




                                                                                                                     So4           23.0
                                                                                                                                       L.                    2c)
                                                                                                                                                            2r




                                                                                                                                                                 33 3 1S 1
                                                                                                                                                                                        23     (5~            .2


                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2.4




                                                                                                                                                                                                                   28                              22.025.3

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         21.8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        2




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    138              44as                                 644   9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         232 26.   6    S    24  s     1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             2

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         a        o   24.1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      24
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      1

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     2        2                              E aL-ts
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            44
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               28TE T7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    NY
                                                                                                                                   ~25.5
                                                                                                           26.1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2,6
                                                    30"b+                                                                                                                                                                                                                           23                                                                                             25                           22           4           24            C'




                      30.7+
                                                                                                               30.6        t




                                                                                                                                                             30Q)2730.37.423.43
                                                                                                                                                            25.0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ,                          27.4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                302                      3


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             24
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 t


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Ir
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     25g25f


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               24.                         24.1


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         22
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ~9  2


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     3
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             2.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               6os                                       29,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     g74                                                                                                                                                       q3        3
                                                                           251
                                                                          29        5




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          18
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     6        80263                         2   28
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     3$ 04             25.6l
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 27                                   22    'S12                                            ato
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ~                                    2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              31                                        Z9"




         31    0+3097.0                     a       o2369.1!0
                                                      288B                          3
                                                                                              2ao              5.8         Z1.3



                                                                                                                                                      I
                                                                                                                                                  26.2.



                                                                                                                                                          5320.0c06
                                                                                                                                                                      30.               257'231               2

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             314
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         29   6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            21B                                   Z.C            *4



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      233
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           3L            24       6                     9



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      277                   .6                                                23                                                 3                         72            4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               297+7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               29'5          06
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  39.0g
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      3 2        8s.0
                                                                                                                                                                                                        ag                                        3                                                                                                                                                   8                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  9                                            37
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                23.                                       29,1

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  2

                                                                                            32                                                                                 27.0                           8                           3                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                26                               8 287                                                                                                                                 28 36o                         9         9
                           ?SS          q- 29           °                           24"tZ~j
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           25.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          3'9,,

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     5s03    2                                                               27 o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         30
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          s1
                                                                                                               29.1                      24.6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 5"1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   34.2                         36..54as
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         30.231           4                99                 Ea
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     a l    2.56

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           2                          3                     4o               5                                                                                                                                                                                 27 o
                    36              0

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      24+2                                                                                                                                               4                                                           s

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            tas1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  (/10                     z.5                        2
                      +
                                   505                                     7.1                        0.1                  .61
                                                                                                                                                                     23'1s'LC2.5
                                                                                                                                                                     22.7.3014
                                                                                                                                                                                                     2.1                  5                                                         7-.1        o
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    2    8                                            2$!                                                                    24                       25
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  28+1             2'92.7010
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               45                                                                                                                    246                                                                                              24
                                                                                                                      257



                                                                                                                     30.
                                                                                                                                    21                  2   257 °


                                                                                                                                                                                        31   Ii~
                                                                                                                                                                                             246                   3.0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          as 1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          268                                                                                  2,2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      25:



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          E 6                  2       .8        2"o             L       2               23                           2     4    5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    24,77
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            24 5

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  2   9 04.1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           25"?       2*7        g
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            28    o      5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              7.5




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           0.27.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  2




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      23 7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       2   8         S




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         6.5          29.1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        .    4

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             30"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     5.

                    27                      2           5        29        6            28.13

                                                                                                       2&&1                                            26'S                                        7'S    $




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              36++
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               2L7                          24.4         24.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 28 Z 03"                                                                                                                                                                                      1'   a7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       9
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ,       522G                                                              y                  23S                                         5                                       2    4
                                                                                                                                    27.


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2.2S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        33.9
                                   2.9--                                                      323                                                      3.3                     2.8                                 2.2            2.'724

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  304             25 4                     2.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       2 a"              67                                                                                 02523                                               c
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ES

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             4
         30.7+                                                             0,7+                                                                                                                                                                                      g     23.                      22       3                            7       0                                                                          2                                        28b                                                                                                                                                         5    72



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          .c                                                       26s2                                                                                                                                              26

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               27       S                                                .75                      '-7,}
                          32   6                            32   6
                                                                                                       33.0



                                                                                                                               6    .5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   as    4


                                                                                                                                                                                                                       55.                    o39f
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                26.4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             a       +g
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2   ,   0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      26.96



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             26"r
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     5                  55ts                                                                                             t
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          59
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       23     _    5GAY                                                                                                                        2955



                                                                                                                                                    31,380                                                          1.523                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    29.3              24.                                          28.         267                26                '                                                    28    -



                                                                                        5                                                                                      '                                                 38.1




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 27       3                                                        25'3.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         24.y




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               28.2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  30          5                                                     27;      y                 27.4                                                Z4.3                                                                      30   04



                           295                  e                                                    314                                  &426
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           25.0

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           28       3

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              9"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     25 42                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  29.4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    28.0                                 24.0


                                                                                                               Stea    b                                                    28.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               29.7


                                                                                                                                                       254                                                                   2                                                  2           Z                                                     25.021

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  27                  r                                     29      6;
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    21   I                                                      28   0
                                                                                                                                                                                               2$'O
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            3o   S

                                                                                                                               25.5                                                                                3     3            34.                      28"S                 29 5                                                                                                         Z     7                                      30


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        30   5




                                                                                                                                                                               %69                                                                Z8.7                               29         0                                                               28   68

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         5                     31'                29.8




                                                                                                                                         t!S                         631.6                                                                                6                 Z9                                                 21    529                                                                                                                                                                                                                     3




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          3t    2




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      EN
                                                                                                                       t6 4                                               2a                 27.6


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             30-7                                                                y/

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          304
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          30.


                                                                               2g   2                                                                   24, r                                                                                                                                                        30.1       +
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                OLONEL              CORS        OF                R                   ARMY.
                                                                                                                                                    28$                        23.                      29.0                                                  29.63                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  28




                                                                                                                                                                                                        31.1                          352




                                                                                                                 32                  127
                                                                                                                                       4                                  36.2
                                                                                                                                                                             o      +




                                                                                                                                                                                               269                                                7       .7360+




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             UN2ITEDSTATES ENGINEER OFFICE. DISTRICT NO. I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             UNITED          S       I   ATE     ENGINEER                OFFICE.         DSTRICT       NO        -I

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           NEW       YOR        .   NY.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            TO ACCOMPANY A?NUAL
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            TO ACCOMPANY' ANNUALRETO
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 REPORT                                           990.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                O1909.




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                OF    ENGINEERS              S    .5        ARM.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           i;OLONEL                 CORPS
                               APPENDIX E--REPORT OF COLONEL BLACK                                                                                  1069

is urged by mariners generally. A depth of 17i 8 feet has been
secured over this ground by work initiated in 1893.
   The channel between North Brother and South Brother islands is
proving insufficient in depth for existing needs. When this channel
was first contemplated, it was considered a possible channel for craft
of lesser draft, thereby relieving the main channel north of North
Brother Island. But this channel is becoming more and more con-
gested because of the establishment thereon of a terminal of the New
York, New Haven and Hartford Railroad. Within the past two
years this company has inaugurated a large increase in its ferry slips
at Oak Point, and steamers desiring to take the main channel are
forced occasionally to stop until tows of car floats are out of the way.
   The river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, directed a preliminary
examination and survey to be made (a report of both has been for-
warded) of the channel between these islands, with a view to obtaining
depths of 20, 22, and 24 feet. The act approved March 3, 1909, pro-
vides for an examination of the East River, including Little Hell
Gate, and the report and recommendations on this subject will be
submitted as soon as practicable.
   The following are the least depths, referred to mean low water, at
localities where improvement has been partially completed:

                                                                                                                                      Least     Least depth
                                                         Locality.                                                                   original     estdepth
                                                                                                                                     depth.     Je0,1909.


                                                                                                                                      Feet.        Feet.
Battery reef. .. . ...............................                   ................      ...      ...............                     12.8               12.8
Reef off South Ferry slips ........                ...................                      ......................                      17.0               18.0
Shell reef, off Ninth street..............                 .......................                  ... .......              ..          7.5               13.0
Ferry reef, off Thirty-fourth street................................                                               ..........            7.0               24.0
Middle reef, including Flood rock, etc ...............................                                              ..... ........     +6.0                18.3
Heel Tap .......................................                          ...........................                                   12.1               20.5
Frying Pan....                  ................. . ...............................                     ..............                  11.0               18.0
Pot rock .........................                               ...............................                                        20.0               22.8



                                                Estimate of additional funds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of improve-
  ment----..-.............---------------------------------------------------. $300, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.
                                                               APPROPRIATIONS.

By other than river and harbor acts prior to 1852............ $13, 861. 59
For former project (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.,
  p. 292)............. ............. .....................     20,000.00
                                                                                                                                                $33, 861. 59
For present project:
    July 25, 1868 (allotment)..----------.....--------..........--.                                                     85,     000. 00
    April 10, 1869 (allotment)---------.................----------------.                                              176,     841.45
    July 11, 1870--------------..............--..--------..................--------..                                  250,     000.00
    March 3, 1871..........-----------............-----------.....-----------..........                                250,     000. 00
    June 10, 1872.....................................                                                                 225,     000. 00
    March 3, 1873 ...............................                                   ......                             225,     000. 00
    June 23, 1874......................................                                                                214,     000. 00
    March 3, 1875.--.................                     ......................                                       250,     000. 00
    August 14, 1876....................................                                                                250,     000.00
                         ----------------------------------
    June 18, 1878....................................                                                                  350,     000. 00
    March 3, 1879..--------------..........................-------------...-------.....                                250,     000.00
    June 14, 1880.-----------------------.................--------.........--....                                      200,     000. 00
1070          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS. U. S. ARMY.

For present project-Continued.
    March 3,1881.....-...... ................... .........                                 $200, 000. 00
    May 4, 1882----------..........---..---.............--------------.........-------...     50, 000. 00
    August 2, 1882....-...................                         ..........         ....200, 000. 00
    July 5,1884.....----..        .............. ...-              ............ 360, 000. 00
    August 5, 1886.....--...           ..........         ................... 112, 500. 00
    August 11, 1888...-......              ..........               --................       250, 000. 00
    September 19, 1890. ............................... 200, 000. 00
    July 13, 1892-----------------------------------..........................              150. 000. 00
    August 18, 1894..----...------------------------------....................                75, 000. 00
    June 3,1896----....--...........---------------..--..........---------..                  60, 000. 00
    March 3,1899............-------------...--....-----................-----                250, 000. 00
    June 13, 1902 -...--.......................... ....-                                  .. 100, 000. 00
    March 3,1905...------------.....................................                   -200, 000. 00
    March 2,1907......-..-.......                 ............           .......... 250, 000. 00
                                                                                                          $5, 183,341. 45
Received from sales --................-.......--..-...--.......... 1, 336. 25
       Total...................................................                          5, 218, 539. 29



                                              CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

  Name of contractor: R. G. Packard Company.
  Date of contract: May 29, 1908.
  Date of approval: June 11, 1908.
  Date of commencement: July 6, 1908.
  Date of completion: June 15, 1910.
  For removal of all material to a least depth of 26 feet at mean low water, at 291 cents
per square foot of area, from areas in square feet, as follows:
      Middle reef, Area A.. ................................       ............ . 398,023
                    Area 13................................................ 139, 873
                    Area C---..---....----------..........-..--..........--------  43,621
      Frying Pan reef----.........--............------------------...........     158, 059
      Pot rock.....------------------...-------..................------------      39, 600
        Total....................... .....................               ...
                                                               ............                     779, 176
  Name of contractor: The New ILondon Marine Iron Works Company.
  Date of contract: September 11, 1908.
  Date of approval: September 22, 1908.
  Date of commencement: October 15, 1908.
  Date of completion: December 25, 1908. Completed December 24, 1908.
  For construction and delivery of wooden scow at a cost of $8,058.



                                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

The commerce of the East River is so intimately connected with that belonging to
New York Harbor proper that it is impracticable to make a separate statement of it.



                                                                  E 8.

                  IMPROVEMENT OF HARLEM RIVER, NEW YORK.

                     OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 141 of this report.
  Under contract with the Columbia Dredging Company, dated July
22, 1908, for dredging and rock removal, 215,801.9 cubic yards mud,
sand, gravel, etc., and 205.44 cubic yards of broken rock and bowlders
were removed during the year. This work resulted in securing a
depth of 15 feet at mean low water and width of about 400 feet from
                APPENDIX E-REPORT OF COLONEL BLACK.                           1071

Willis Avenue Bridge to the site of the Madison avenue permanent
bridge, except immediately north of the easterly pier of the Second
Avenue Bridge, where ledge rock prevented dredging to the projected
depth; thence to One hundred and forty-fifth Street Bridge the same
depth and 250 to 300 feet in width; and thence toMacombs Dam Bridge,
the same depth and about 150 feet in width. At and in the imme-
diate vicinity of Macombs Dam Bridge all dredgable material, includ-
ing broken rock, was removed, but this work did not improve channel
conditions through the draw openings. In order to secure the pro-
jected depth here it will be necessary to remove rocky ledges that pro-
ject above the improvement plane.
  At and below (south of) Willis Avenue Bridge considerable improve-
ment has resulted, but because of the existence of bowlders and sup-
posed rocky ledges in the channel between One hundred and twenty-
second and One hundred and twenty-fifth streets, the available chan-
nel width, with 15 feet depth at mean low water, is only about 100
feet; both above and below this section of the river the width rapidly
increases to 400 feet and over.
   In this same section of river a considerable area of hard material
was encountered on the easterly side of the projected channel, which
the contractor was unable to remove with the light plant he was using
in the work. The plant was accordingly removed from the locality
March 20, 1909, preliminary to placing a more efficient dredge on the
work.
   A suitable dredge commenced operations on May 3, 1908, but was
withdrawn on May 5, 1909, since which latter date no work has been
done under the contract. The contractor's attention has been called
to the necessity for completing the work, and it is understood that
he is making arrangements to resume dredging, with a suitable plant.
   No work under the contract was in progress on June 30, 1909.
   The following work was done by the use of government plant (drill
scow Hudson) and the hire of labor and purchase of material in open
market:
  Opposite Morris Heights: 251 cubic yards of bowlders drilled, blasted, and removed.
  At Second Avenue Bridge: 85j cubic yards of ledge rock drilled, blasted, and
removed. The projected depth has not yet been obtained here; overlying material
must first be removed before rock removal can be completed.
  Between One hundred and twenty-second and One hundred and twenty-sixth
streets: 1171 cubic yards of ledge rock, broken rock, and bowlders drilled, blasted,
and removed. Two pieces of piling removed.
   Surface blasting frequently proved to be the most economical
method of removing ledge rock in this locality. Much of the rock so
removed was scattered into deeper water in the immediate vicinity,
and therefore does not appear in the amounts above reported.
   Because of the congested river traffic the operations at and below
One hundred and twenty-sixth street were frequently interrupted by
collisions and the fouling of anchor lines.
   In addition to the above work a considerable area was examined
by sweeping and boring, and the location of such of the obstructions
as could not be at once removed was accurately determined.
   The drill scow was under repairs from July 21 to September 2,
1908, and again from October 21 to November 9, 1908. The repairs
in October-November were made necessary by the capsizing and
sinking of the scow while removing rock from the vicinity of Second
Avenue Bridge.
1072                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of improve-
ment............................................       ..................  $300, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897.


                                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.
June 23, 1874 (allotment) .................       -................ $11, 000
For former project (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 294). 10, 000
                                                                                                                                    $21, 000. 00
For present project:
    June 18, 1878..........................................                                                         300, 000
    March 3, 1879.........--       ....................                        ...........                          100, 000
    August 11, 1888-.........................................                                                        70, 000
    September 19, 1890....---...............................                                                        250, 000
    July 13, 1892---...--------......-----------..----..........................-----------...                      175, 000
    August 18, 1894..----------.........------..--..------.........-----............                                125, 000
    June 3, 1896-----...........---------.....----..................--------------------......                      125, 000
    March 3, 1899----..--..........-------------.........--------...........--------........                        100, 000
    June 13, 1902--........---------......--...........--------------....--..---------.......                        75, 000
    March 3, 1905......--.......---.................-----------------------..----------........                      75, 000
    March 2, 1907.................--..........................                                                      150, 000
    March 3, 1909 (allotment) ...............................                                                        22, 000
                                                                                                                                1, 567, 000. 00

                                                                                                                                1, 588, 000. 00
Received on account of reimbursements and sales ..................-.                                                                    111.07

            Total..--..-----...-----..-...-----------------........-------------------.....                                     1, 588, 111.07

                                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                     Vessels employed in trade in 1908.

                                                      Class.                                                   Trips.       Tonnage.      Draft.


                                                                                                                                           Feet.
Tugs and steamers......................................................23,085                                                    30-542     5-141
Sailing vessels.................                         ... ........................                      .        2,474       100-800     5-20
Barges, etc ...                 ..................................................                                 71,923      25-2,100     2-22
Miscellaneous craft ...................................................                                             2,178       3-1,000     2-12


    Passengers carried, 187,315.

                                                             Freight handled in 1908.

               Class.                         Tons.                Value.                       Class.                 Tons.          Value.


General merchandise....                     4,056,706         $200,000,000              Farm products ........          607, 100      $18, 250,000
Coal and other fuel-......                 13,575,301           50,000,000              Ice...          ........      6,120, 795       13,000,000
Building and road ma-                                                                   Ashes, garbage, etc.....      2,000,000            450,000
  terials ..............                   17,294,460            125, 000,000
Manufactures...........                         5,115                 150,000                Total..............     43, 768, 658     410,100,000
Minerals and products...                      109,181              3,250,000
                             APPENDIX E-REPORT OF COLONEL BLACK.                                                                        1073

                                                                         E     9.

                     IMPROVEMENT OF NEWTOWN CREEK, NEW YORK.

                         OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

    For history and project see page 143 of this report.
  A large bowlder lying in the entrance to the creek and projecting
above the improvement plane, also several obstructions endangering
navigation in the vicinity of Meeker Avenue Bridge, were removed
and disposed of.
  To complete this improvement some widening at the entrance to
the creek remains to be done, and with this in view a survey of the
entrance up to Vernon Avenue Bridge was completed in July, 1908.
It developed later that considerable shoaling had occurred above
this bridge, and the survey has accordingly been extended up to
the Metropolitan avenue bridges with a view to dredging this section
for maintenance.
                                             Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
improvement.......------...............--------------------...............................------------------------. $10,000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                           APPROPRIATIONS.

For former project (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 295).......... $197, 500
For present proj ect:
    June 3, 1896------..-------.......----.......----...........-------------------........------....... $30, 000
                                                                                              ------- 183, 000
    June 4, 1897--..............................---------------------------...------...........
    June 13, 1902 (allotment of May 20, 19041)...................                                             400
    March 3, 1905...........----------..................---------------------...........---------....      5, 000
    March 2, 1907-.--.-----..-.......-----..----...............------------.........----------...          5, 000
    March 4, 1907..--...---------------------........-----------..........-------.........                 5, 000
                                                                                                                  238, 400

           Total................--------------------------------------..........-...---------...                                       435, 900



                                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                 Vessels employed in trade in 1908.


                                                    Class.                                                        Tips.    Tonnage.      Draft.


                                                                                                                                         Feet.
Tugs and steamers....-.........................................                                       ... .....    8,057    15-2,000       4-21
Sailing vessels.......--.....--................                      ......-----..........-- .....--......         1,181    53-4,364       6-21
Barges, etc.    ..--...................                    ...... ..          ......................----          21,368    35-3,508      1-15
Miscellaneous craft ....................-... ...---                        ..      ...................               152   157-1,000      4--11


            9001--ENG 1909-68
1074            REPORT           OF     THE CHIEF                OF    ENGINEERS,                     U.           S. ARMY.


                                                 Freight handled in 1908.

              Class.                   Tons.            Value.                     Class.                              Tons.          Value.

General merchandise.......    363,677 $25,500,000                     Farm products...........                          70,832       $1,750,000
Coal and other fuel........ 1,316,294 5,250,000                       Fish ................      ....                   11,200          275,000
Building and road mate-                                               Ice ......................                        87,048          350,000
  rials ..................... 935,384   6,500,000                     Ashes, garbage, etc.........                      74,569           19,000
Manufactures .............     11,553     350,000
Minerals and products...... 1,307,971 190,000,000                           Total ............                        4,181,528    229,994,000



                                                                 E io.

             IMPROVEMENT OF WALLABOUT CHANNEL, NEW YORK.

                       OPERATIONS               DURING            THE PAST              FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 144 of this report.
   An examination having shown that considerable shoaling had
occurred in the dredged channel along practically the entire length
of Cob dock and the causeway, a survey of the locality was author-
ized and completed.
  Section 10 of the sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909, required
that-
   * * * all unexpended balances of appropriations which remained on the books
of the Treasury on the first day of July, nineteen hundred and four, except * * *
be carried to the surplus fund and covered into the Treasury * * *
  In compliance with this requirement the balance of funds in hand
was deposited to the credit of the Treasurer of the United States.
  No expenditures are to be made from the balance remaining unex-
pended pending a decision as to whether or not this balance is to be
carried to the surplus fund.
                                                     APPROPRIATION.

March 3, 1899...............                        ..........                   - --...........................                      $40, 000



                                           COMMERCIAL                  STATISTICS.

                                         Vessels employed in trade in 1908.
                                            Clas.                                                            Trips[

                                            Cls.                                                                   imade. Tonnage.      Draft.


                                                                                                                                         Feet.
Tugs and steamers.........................................................                                      365          32-175        4-12
Barges, etc....................................................................................               3,246        652,000         4-22


                                                Freight handled in 1908.

              Class.                    Tons.           Value.                      Class.                              Tons.         Value.


General merchandise ........                 732           $55, 000   Fish.......................                             25            $600
Coal and other fuel.........            857, 819        3, 000, 000   Ashes, garbage, etc.........                       13, 000           5, 000
Building and road materials.             25, 435          175, 000
Mineral and products........             40, 035        1,200, 000          Total.................                      937, 384      4, 444, 600
Farm products...............                 338            9,000
                           APPENDIX E--REPORT                              OF COLONEL BLACK.                               1075
                                                                  E     ii.

                     IMPROVEMENT OF BROWNS CREEK, NEW YORK.

                        OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 145 of this report.
   This work was combined with Patchogue River, New York, under
an advertisement dated August 17, 1908, inviting proposals for dredg-
ing, bids to be opened September 14, 1908. No bids having been
received in response to this advertisement, steps were taken to secure
proposals to do the work under open-market agreement, but so far
as could be learned all dredging plants located in the bay were fully
occupied on private work, and the amount of money available at the
time was insufficient to induce other contractors to move their plants
into the bay from outside points. Additional funds having since been
appropriated for removing shoals from the channel in Patchogue
River, proposals are again to be invited by advertisement.
   Disbursements were in payment of office expenses and of the cost
of an examination of the locality.
                                          Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
  provement ....--....-....                                               - . $3, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

September 19, 1890.............. $12, 000                                 March 3, 1905............... .. $3, 000. 00
July 13, 1892..---............
                        --        ----- 5, 000                            March 2, 1907..-...   ....... .. 5, 000. 00
August 18, 1894.----- ---..    ------   4, 000                            Received from sale of maps...         1. 38
June 3, 1896...................                             4, 000
March 3, 1899...................                             3, 000                  Total................... 36, 001. 38



                                              COMMERCIAL                   STATISTICS.

                                             Vessels employed in trade in 1908.

                                                Class.                                              Number.a   Tonnage.    Draft.


                                                                                                                           Feet.
Steamers and power boats..............................................                                    75       5- 50       3-6
Sailing vessels-----...--------------------------..........-----.....---....-------..............        140       3-100       2-7
Miscellaneous craft.....................................................                                  25       5-100       1-4

                              aNumber of vessels using harbor; number of trips not reported.

   Number of passengers carried, 5,000.
1076             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U. S. ARMY.

                                       Freight handled in 1908.

                Class.             Tons.    Value.                        Class.                       Tons.    Value.


General merchandise............       144    $2,030    Farm products ..........                   ..      250     $2,006
Coal and other fuel ............    1,200     7,800    Fish ........................                   20,000    800,000
Building and road materials...      1,550    31,950    Ice..............             ..........           600      3,000
Minerals and products.........        500    24,000
Manufactures ................       1,000    54,000              Total ...................             25,244    924,780



                                                E     12.

                 IMPROVEMENT OF GREAT SOUTH BAY, NEW YORK.

                         OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 146 of this report.
   Contract was entered into with J. M. Briggs dated May 21, 1906,
for dredging in Patchogue River and Great South Bay. The dredg-
ing in Patchogue River was completed October 31, 1906, 15,70516
cubic yards having been removed and disposed of; but when the con-
tractor was about to commence work in the bay on November 8,
1906, he was stopped by injunction. This injunction has been dis-
solved and the complaint dismissed, and the contract with J. M.
Briggs was terminated by supplemental agreement dated October
20, 1908.
    This work was combined with Browns Creek, New York, under an
advertisement dated August 17, 1908, inviting proposals for dredging,
bids to be opened September 14, 1908. No bids were received, nor
was there any response to subsequent invitations for proposals to do
the work under open-market agreement. (See report upon Browns
Creek, New York, p. 1075.)
    The last dredging in Patchogue River was done in 1906. A survey
made in 1908 showed that the dredged channel had shoaled so that
there was only about 5 feet of available depth at mean low water.
   An examination of the river bottom and of the bay beyond the
jetty at the entrance to the river was made in April, 1909. This
examination showed that but little change had occurred during the
period following the survey of June, 1908. The floor of the bay in
the vicinity of the river slopes gradually and evenly down from the
shore to a depth of about 8 feet at a distance of about 6,000 feet,
and the contours are very regular and are parallel to the shore line
excepting in the immediate vicinity of the jetty. Where the channel
of the river is protected by banks on the two sides the depth is fairly
well maintained, but where protected only on one side shoaling has
taken place. It is believed that without protection on both sides
from the shore to a point in the bay, where the proposed depth is
found, no dredged channel will maintain itself, and the results of any
dredging will be obliterated in about a year. Under these conditions
economy in the cost of maintenance, as well as the demands of com-
merce, require that the existing jetty be extended to at least the
7-foot contour in the bay; that a jetty be built on the eastern side
of the channel extending from the shore out to the same contour;
and that the channel be restored to its projected depth. The esti-
mated cost of this work is $75,000.
                                APPENDIX E-REPORT OF COLONEL BLACK.                                                         1077

      Without works of the above character the commerce of Patchogue
could have no assurance that the desired depth could be found at the
entrance to the river excepting for a short period immediately follow-
ing annual dredging.
   No dredging through the bars in Great South Bay is recommended
for the present.
                                                  Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
    For works of improvement ........................................       a $45, 000
    For maintenance of improvement ...................................  ..      5, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                                  APPROPRIATIONS.

For former project (see II. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 297)........ $40, 000. 00
For present project:
    June 13, 1902..----------------....................----------------..............---     $66,000.00
    March 3, 1905------...................................------------------------------....   2, 000. 00
    March 2, 1907...... .. ........                             -....................... 2, 000. 00
    March 3, 1909-................. ..... .................                                    3, 000.00
                                                                                                          73, 000. 00

                                                                                                                     113, 000. 00
Received from sale of maps.----...................                                       ...............                    2. 92
             Total............................                                         ..........
                                                                                 ...........                 ..... . 113, 002. 92



                                                             CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Name of contractor: J. M. Briggs.
  Date of contract: May 21, 1906.
  Date of approval: June 8, 1906.
  Date of commencement: June 26, 1906.
  Date of completion: Time limit waived to May 31, 1908, inclusive; work stopped
by injunction November 8, 1906. Injunction has been dissolved and case dismissed
during fiscal year 1908. Contract terminated by supplemental agreement dated
October 20, 1908.
  To dredge 20,000 cubic yards of material in Great South Bay and in Patchogue
River, at 35 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.



                                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                       Vessels employed in trade in 1908.

                                                      Class.                                        Trips.     Tonnage.     Draft.

                                                                                                                            Feet.
Tugs and power boats...........................................                               1,500-1,800          20- 70      3-5
Sailing vessels .......................................................                       6,500-7,500           8-300      3-8
Barges, etc .......................................................                                 3,000          30-100      2-5

                                    aIf additional work is authorized; for explanation, see text.
                                    bIf additional work is not authorized.
1078            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                  Freight handled in 1908.

              Class.                    Tons.        Value.                       Class.                   Tons.         Value.

General merchandise.......              34,000       $310, 000     Fish..--....................              6,000        $175,000
Coal and other fuel ......---           15, 000        85, 000                                         .         0        _
Building and road materials.           140,000      2,750,000              Total ..............            195,000       3,320,000



                                                            E 13.

                   IMPROVEMENT OF HUDSON RIVER, NEW YORK.

                       OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

    For history and project see page 148 of this report.
    The following was accomplished under contract:
Flagler & Vedder, under contract dated March 29, 1907:
Paving stone delivered:
    At Overslaugh Dike No. 2, 504.4 cubic yards, at $2.20 per cubic yard. $1, 109. 68
    At Small Island dike, 723.7 cubic yards, at $2.20 per cubic yard ...   1, 592. 14
    At Bath Crossover, 1,483.6 cubic yards, at $2.20 per cubic yard...... 3, 263. 92

      Total cost.............................................................                                           5, 965.74
The contract was completed September 16, 1908.
The Newburgh Dredging Company, under contract dated July 29, 1907:
Material dredged and removed from-                                                                                    Cubic yards.
    Coxsackie shoal .................................................                                                      27, 255
   Stonehouse bar...                                          .           ......................                           493, 695
   North Coeymans......................................                      ......                .............           11, 966
   Nulls Crossover--...................................                                            ..........    ......    19, 686
   Nine-mile tree.....................................................                                                     43, 342
   Castleton bar-....................................................-                                                     20, 443
   Cedar Hill bar..........                ..........................................                                      25, 458
   Stone Light shoal-...---------.....--------.....................----------....-----------............--....             55, 808
   Bogart Light shoal....................                                        ......................                    13, 703
   Douws Point Crossover -........................................                                                   ..    24, 762
   Bath Crossover..............                   .............. .................. ........                               76, 833
   Bath shoal-.................................                                     .......................                 4, 210
  At a total cost of $93,890.69.                                                                                        377, 071
  Work under this contract was still in progress on June 30, 1.909.
  R. P. Clarke Company, under contract dated April 7, 1908:
Square timber at Albany, N. Y., 21,512 feet b. m....................                                                    $602.33
Round piling at Albany, N. Y., 24,186 linear feet..... .............                                                 . 2, 267. 45
Round timber at Albany, N. Y., 2,400 linear feet ....................                                                     225. 00
      Total cost.....................................................................                                  3, 094.78
The contract was completed November 23, 1908.
William D. Fuller, under contract dated April 7, 1908-
Delivered on Cedar Hill dike, Section III:
    Rubblestone, 13 cubic yards...................             ..........................                                $18.07
    Quarry spalls, 44 cubic yards.............................                    ..........                              61.16

      Total cost....  ...................                     .......................                                      79. 23
Delivered on Overslaugh Dike No. 2:
    Rubblestone, 122 cubic yards.........                    .....................                                       169. 58
    Quarry spalls, 68 cubic yards-.....................................                                                   94.52

      Total cost.................................               ...........                                              264.10
Delivered on Beacon Island paved dike:
    Rubblestone, 47 cubic yards.... ...........................           ...                                              65. 33
                        APPENDIX E-REPORT OF COLONEL BLACK.                                               1079

Delivered on Overslaugh Dike No. 1:
    Rubblestone, 147 cubic yards ......................................                                   204. 33
    Quarry spalls, 122 cubic yards.......................................                                 169.58
      Total cost .......................................------..------............                               373.91
Delivered on Small Island dike:
    Rubblestone, 642 cubic yards------------------------------------........................................'    892. 38
    Quarry spalls, 2,664 cubic yards .-----------.........-----------......---.....                   ---     3, 702. 96
    Quarry refuse, 2,310 cubic yards---------..............................--------------------..--. 3, 210. 90

      Total cost ......... ......... ....      ........     .. ........ ..........---               .. 7, 806. 24
Delivered on Bath Crossover dike:
    Quarry spalls, 540 cubic yards.........-............................                                   750. 60
    Quarry refuse, 742 cubic yards...----------.....------..........................------------------. 1, 031.38

      Total cost---..--------.....-----..---..............----------------------........-------..... 1, 781. 98
Delivered on Patroons Lower Island dike:
    Rubblestone, 19 cubic yards. ..........................................                              26.41
    Quarry spalls, 6 cubic yards.................--........................                               8.34

      Total cost ...................................................------....-    34. 75
  The total expenditure under this contract was $10,405.54.
  The contract was completed November 24, 1908.
  J. Edward Ogden Company, under contract dated April 23, 1908:
Screw bolts, 5,921 pounds ..............................    .................... $147. 43
Washers, 702 pounds ........................................ ..................    17.48

      Total cost------...............--------......----..........------------                    164. 91
The contract was completed August 25, 1908.
Eugene C. Sickles, under contract dated August 10, 1908-
Delivered on Coxsackie Island dike:
    Rubblestone, 83 cubic yards.................................-....... $108. 32
    Quarry spalls, 104 cubic yards.......                ......        ............ ............ 135. 72
    Quarry refuse, 20 cubic yards.....................................                            26. 10
      Total cost ...................................................---..--------.                        270. 14
Delivered on Schodack (N. Y. S.) dike:
    Rubblestone, 3,323 cubic yards ..................................                                  4, 336. 52
    Quarry spalls, 3,513 cubic yards.....................................                              4, 584.45
    Quarry refuse, 843 cubic yards.......             .............................                    1, 100. 12

      Total cost ......................                 .........................                       10, 021. 09
Delivered on Cedar Hill dike, Section I:
    Rubblestone, 593 cubic yards .....................................                                      773. 87
    Quarry spalls, 783 cubic yards. ...........................                                 .......  1,021. 81
    Quarry refuse, 538 cubic yards--------..........------------.....................---------------..      702. 10

      Total cost-......................................... ......... .... 2, 497.78
  The total expenditure under this contract was $12,789.01.
  The contract was completed May 29, 1909.
  Richard Parrott, jr., under contract dated September 3, 1908: 2,999.6 cubic yards
paving stone delivered on Small Island dike, at a total cost of $7,588.99.
  The contract was completed December 9, 1908.
  The following was accomplished under open-market agreement
with-
  Ulster Davis:
Paving stone transferred to-
    Overslaugh Dike No. 2, 504.4 cubic yards, at 25 cents ..............     $126. 10
                                                                         .......
    Bath Crossover dike, 1,483.6 cubic yards, at 25 cents.................... 370. 90
    Small Island dike, 723.7 cubic yards, at 25 cents.......................  180. 93

        Total cost.......................................................                                 677. 93
1080               REPORT                OF       THE CHIEF                        OF ENGINEERS,                        U.      S.     ARMY.


Removal of snags, wreckage, etc., from the channel........-.................                                                                            $260. 65
  William D. Fuller:
Removal of snags, wreckage, etc., from the channel........-----..............                                                                              285. 30
Towing pile driver and dike material..--------------.......------............--------.....------........                                                   351. 50

   Albany Towing Company:
Towing pile driver and transferring dike material....--..........--.........                                                                               248. 50
  Hawley Miller:
4 days, 6 hours, and 26 minutes, at $150 per day of 12 hours, hire of dredge,
  filling Cedar Hill dike, Section I ...... .................................                                                                              880. 42
  William D. Fuller:
Furnishing and driving guide piles to mark submerged dikes in freshets:
    Pine piling, 262 linear feet, at 35 cents per linear foot ....-............                                                                             91. 70
                                                                      -
    Oak piling, 110 linear feet, at 42 cents per linear foot---..........       ......                                                                      46. 20

           Total cost.........................................................                                                                             137. 90

   Dexter Hunter:
Square timber delivered in Albany, N. Y., 5,256 feet b. m ..................                                                                               183. 96
   Total expenditures under open-market agreement, $2,826.16.
  The following was accomplished by the use of government plant,
the hire of labor, and the purchase of material and supplies in the open
market, on the following dikes:

                                                       Scho-     Castle-   Cedar                  Cedar
                                                        dack        ton    Hill,                  Hill,       Beacon Small Bath Over- Over-
         Nature of material.                           (N. Y.c-
                                                      (N. Y.
                                                                .).S.
                                                                      (N.Y.
                                                                  (Island Section
                                                                                                   tion
                                                                                                               a
                                                                                                              paved.
                                                                                                                     Island. Cross- slaugh slaugh
                                                                                                                                         over.    No.2. No.1.
                                                             S.).             .                    III.


Round piling...... linear feet..            14, 306      6, 125        1,508 ..                                                                     442  5, 316
Round timber.......... do...                     311 ........               71       32 ........                                 311 ............
Sheet piling........feet B. I..            23,229 ........           109,150 ...............                                 16,088       900 .......--     608
Square timber...........do..                52,281 ........            4,896        132 ..           .                        2, 142      200 2,980      1,490
Lumber------------................do....   32,880 28,130               2,020        240 ...                                                       2,259......
Tie-rods..............pounds..               3,449 ........           10, 000        68 ........                              4, 418 ............
Screw bolts.....-........do....               5, 364        154        1,615           2 ..-------......                         269 .......        196     103
Drift bolts and spikes.. do ....             3,932       1,200         4, 403          5 ........                                550 .......         29      30
Washers............             do...         1,840           74       1,238           3 ........                               244 .......          72      42
Handling paving.cubic yards...................                        .........----.......---........                         3,273 2, 535 1,375 ..
Laying paving. -square yards
Leveling stone...cubic yards......
                                         --...-    --.--       -..---
                                                                   ...
                                                                         ..- --,
                                                                                   ........
                                                                  .......................
                                                                                                      --------47              6,409 3,700 2,334
                                                                                                                         ............
                                                                                                                                                             ..
        Total...................                     137, 592         35, 683          134,901        482          47        34,154      7,335     9,687          7,589


    The cost of the above work was as follows:
                                                                                              Cedar
                                              Scho-
                                              SHho-          Castle-
                                                             Castle-             Cedar           ll ceas-Small
                                                                                                             Small
                                                                                                        IsHill,                       Bath        Over-       Over-
     Nature of material.                    dack(N. ton (N.                   Secti           Sec-   land Island                     Cross-      slaugh       slaugh
                                             Y. S.).                             iI.           tion
                                                                                               III. paved.                           over.        No. 2.      No. 1.


Round piling............. $815. 21                            $318.79 $103.15 ..........................-......                                  $41.45 $521.98
Round timber............     16.61                          .........        3.51..............$15.17                          ....................
Sheet piling.............    39.25                           ........    983.20 .............                   246.52        $46. 97 _.               ..   5. 40
Square timber............ 1,125.00                          .........    366.47 $8.00 .....                     232.77          21.46              83.26  36.75
Lumber..................    290. 87                         1,140.94 ..........................                        ...........                  2.75.......
Tie rods..  .............     2.84                          .........      28.00 ....... .......                 61. 85...................
Screw bolts--..............                       2.77 .........                   1. 37      .............     ........             . ...............              .51
Drift bolts and spikes..........                             ..      ....          17.82....... .......                15.06....................
Washers ...........................                                            ............................                                   ................
Handling paving....9........                                   ..      .        ...... _.............970.                  40 1,004. 06                585. 36.
Laying paving......                 .......            .......          ......          ............               7, 279. 60 3,875. 69 1,165. 28 ..
Leveling stone ...........                                   .........                                      14. 09 .
                                                                                ..... ...... ...... $.........
         Total...............2,292.55 1,459.73 1,603.52                                        8.00    14.09 8,821.37 4,948.18 1,878.10                           564.64


  The total expenditures by the use of Government plant was
$21,590.18.
                           APPENDIX E-REPORT                              OF     COLONEL BLACK.                                     1081

  The following table shows the widths and depths of the deepest navi-
gable channel, through bars and shoals, between Coxsackie and the
state dam at Troy, N. Y., at the end of the fiscal year, so far as
developed by soundings since the opening of navigation, and for the
previous year for comparison:

                                                                                                         1908.                  1909.
                                          Locality.
                                                                                                  Width. Depth. Width. Depth.


                                                                                                                                     Feet.  Feet.   Feet. Feet.
Coxsackie shoal .....................................................                                                                   150  11.5     600   12.0
Bronk Island shoal-...---..--------......................---------------.....--..--..............          ------------                 350  12.0     350   12.0
Stonehouse bar ----.....---------.......----...........-------..............----------...---.......------..                             200  12.0     175   11.0
Willow Island shoal--....----..........--------------................----------------................                                   400  12.0     400   12.0
New Baltimore bar----...-----.......................----------------------....------............-----.....                              400  12. 0    400   12. 0
Coeymans Crossover...................-------------.......-----------....--..---..--.......                                              400  12. 0    400   12. 0
Roah Hook to North Coeymans.......------...-----...............-----..--------........                                                  200  12.0     300   12. 0
Mulls Crossover------............................--------------------------------...........-........                                   200  11.5     250   12. 0
Nine-Mile Tree Crossover--------------------------------------..............................................                            300  11.0     330   12. 0
Castleton bar ............................-----------------------------------................---------                                  200  11.5     150   12.0
Cedar Hill bar--...---.....------..............................-----------------------...........----....                               210  11.0     180   12.0
Winnies bar_................................................                                                       .........            300  12.0     270   12.0
Stone Light shoal ............................................                            ......               ...........              100  11.5     207   12. 0
Beacon Island shoal ...............................................                                                                     500  12.0     400   12.0
Bogart Light shoal .............                               ..................................                                        50  12.0     200   12.0
Douws Point Crossover ............................................                                                                      250  11.5      50   12. 0
Cuyler bar. - .....        ..................................................                                                           250  12. 0    250   12.0
Passenger bridge:
    East draw.. .........................................................                                                               100  11.5     100   10.5
     West draw.............                         ..... --................................                                            100  12. 0    100   12. 0
                                -................................
    West fixed span................-                                                                                                    160  12.0     160   12.0
Freight bridge:
    West draw..-----......................................................                                                               65  12.0      90   12. 0
    East draw .. ......----------------- ----.......                           .... .          ...        .. ..........                  90  12.0      90   12.0
    East fixed span................                       --...--..             ..........................                              120  12. 0    120   12. 0
Bath Crossover........                       .......--------..................................                                          200  10.0     250   12.0
Bath shoal ....     ..         ........              ..--------------- .......         ......................                           300  12.0     300   12.0
Kellogg shoal........-                .........               .......                       .............                    .... I.... 200  12. O0   250   11. 5
Fishh.ouse shoal --.............                      .................                           ................                      220  12.0     170   12. 0
                 ------
Round shoal..........                    .......................                       .........          ........... ..                100  11.0     190   11.0
Covills Folly..................----------------------........................                                                           100  12.0     100   12. 0
Breaker Island-.......................................................                                                                  200  12.0     200   12.0
Van Buren bar............--......-------............ ................                                                                    75  12.0     100   12. 0
Washington bar...................                              ...-..............................                                       200  12.0     200   12.0
Front of Watervliet Arsenal . .......-                          ........................                         ..........             250  12.0     200   12.0
Arsenal to Congress street, Troy, N. Y....................................                                                              340  12.0     300   12.0
Congress Street Bridge:
    East draw..---.........---.....                          ------.....................................                                 80  12.0      80   12.0
    East fixed span -.........                            ...---------............................                                      150  12.0     150   12. 0
Congress street-Broadway.......        ----                   ................................                                          370  12. O0   200   12. O0
Broadway-Delaware and Hudson bridge.......                                                .......................                       100  12.0      70   12. 0
Delaware and Hudson bridge:
    Draw span.........................................................                                                                   40  10.0      45   10.0
    East fixed span-....... ------------------------------------------                                                                  100  12.0      50   12.0
    To Hoosick street. .                  -----------------------------------------. 100                                                     10. 5     75   11. 0
Hoosick street to Boutwells -.......--------------.------.....------..----.........-----..........                                      150  12.0      75   12.0
Boutwells to Middleburgh street-------..---..-------------..........................-------...                                           80   8. 5     75    8.5
Entrance to Sloop Lock----..-....-----------...........-------.......................              ----------------                      20   4. 5     20    4. 5



  The above depths refer to the plane of mean low water established
in 1876, except between the Delaware & Hudson Company's bridge
and the state dam at Troy, N. Y., where the plane established by
the tide records of 1899, after the dredging below the bridge had been
nearly completed, is used.
                                         Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement........................... $300, 000. 00
   For maintenance of improvement...................        50, 000. 00
                                                                                                                           $350, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
1082             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S.                                                             ARMY.

                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

For former projects (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.,                                             p. 294).... $1, 667, 938. 00
For present project:
    September 19, 1890 (balance)---..---..............---                           ...--.              $30, 600. 00
    July 13, 1892.............                    ..................                     .......        187, 500. 00
    March 3, 1893 .----...-..............----------------.........------------..                        500, 000. 00
    August 18, 1894 ..-------...----------............---------------...............                    145, 000. 00
    March 3, 1895..--..................................
                                   -----------------------------                                        500, 000.00
    June 11, 1896........................-----------------------..-----------.........                  480, 000. 00
    June 4, 1897---..--------------.............-------............----------.........                  475, 000. 00
                                                                           -----------
    July 1, 1898...---------......------..................---------..........                           160, 406. 56
    March 3, 1899 --------------------....--............------............---------......               100, 000. 00
    June 6, 1900......................................                                                  400,000. 00
    March 3, 1901 ....................................                                                  100, 000. 00
    June 13, 1902...----........---------...------------.....----.........----.                         225, 000. 00
    March 3, 1905---.................-----------------.....----............   ---------                 203, 300. 00
    March 2, 1907....-     -----------...............---------....-----......-------.....               250, 000. 00
    March 3, 1909 (allotment)............                                 -
                                                                      .............                      39, 000. 00
                                                                                                    -   ----------        -

                                                                                                                              3, 795, 806. 56
                                                                                                                              5, 463, 744. 56
Repayment to appropriation ............... ...............                                                     ..... ..                10. 06
Received from sales and reimbursements.. .......................                                                                      199. 62

          Total...........-........                           ...........................                                     5, 463, 954. 24



                                                      CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

                                                            Date of-

      Name of contractor.                                           Corn-                                             For-
                                         Con-           Ap-                        Comple-
                                                                   mence-           tion.
                                        tract.        proval.      ment.
                                   I     9 .      I                                           I
                                        1907.          1907.        1907.           1907.
    Flagler & Vedder.....              Mar. 29        Apr. 4       June 8          aNov. 8        Furnishing 10,000 cubic yards pav-
                                                                                                   ing stone, at $2.20 per cubic yard.
    The Newburgh Dredg-                July 29        Aug.    6    Sept. 7          (a) (b)       Dredging 487,800 cubic yards of ma-
     ing Co.                                                                                       terial, at 249 cents per cubic yard,
                                                                                                   scow measurement.
                            1908.                      1908.        1908.    1908.
    William D. Fuller..... Apr.                       Apr. 18      May 20 a Oct. 31               Furnishing 900 cubic yards rubble-
                                                                                                   stone, 4,000 cubic yards quarry
                                                                                                   spalls, 4,000 cubic yards quarry re-
                                                                                                   fuse, all at $1.39 per cubic yard.
    R. P. ClarkeCo ....             ... do.....       May     6    July      9 a Sept. 9          Furnishing and delivering square
                                                                                                   timber, piling, and round timber
                                                                                                   to the amount of about $3,474.04.
5   J. Edward Ogden Co.. Apr. 23                      May 15       July 16         Sept. 16       Furnishing and delivering bolts,
                                                                                                   spikes, etc., at 2/& cents per
                                                                                                   pound, to the amommt of about
                                                                                                   $473.10.
                                                                                     1909.
6   Eugene C. Sickles.....             Aug. 10        Aug. 18      Sept. 26        July 26        Furnishing and delivering 4,000 cu-
                                                                                                   bic yards rubblestone, 4,400 cubic
                                                                                                   yards quarry spalls, and 1,400 cu-
                                                                                                   bic yards quarry refuse, all at
                                                                                                   $1.305 per cubic yard in place on
                                                                                                   or in dike.
                                                                                    1908.
    Richard Parrott, jr..... Sept. 3              1Sept. 15 1Sept. 27              Dec. 17        Furnishing and delivering 3,000 cu-
                                                                                                   bic yards paving stone, at $2.53 per
                                                                                                   cubic yard.

a Time limit waived.
b Twelve months from August 7, 1907, excluding December, January, February, and March, unless
work is done in these months.

    Nos. 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7, contract completed.
                        APPENDIX E -REPORT                         OF COLONEL BLACK.                                               1083
                                              Freight handled in 1908.

            Class.                 Tons.          Value.                            Class.                         Tons.         Value.

General merchandise......          477, 983   $100, 307, 077      Manufactures--              -----...........      89, 761      $1,282,593
Coal and other fuel-.....          454, 087       2, 054, 931     Fruit and farm products..                        277, 279       9,639, 200
Building and road mate-                                           Ice.......................                       850,128        1,057, 042
rials...                         749,250
                  ..-----------------.            5,881,138
Minerals and products.....          47, 433          199, 670                 Total ..............               2, 945, 921    120, 421, 651


   Passengers carried, 1,288,721.

                                                           E 14.

           IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT SAUGERTIES, NEW YORK.

                     OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 150 of this report.
   Work under contract with P. Sanford Ross (Incorporated) dated
October 17, 1907, was completed December 4, 1908. During the
fiscal year 5,202 cubic yards of rock and overlying material were
removed and disposed of, making a total of 7,170 cubic yards removed
under the contract. This work resulted in the removal of Powder-
house reef to a depth of 12 feet below mean low water, thereby widen-
ing and straightening the channel at this point.
                                    Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement ....................................   $10, 000
   For maintenance of improvement..........................          5, 000
                                                                                                                                  $15, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                APPROPRIATIONS.

For former project (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 298)......... $57, 000. 00
For present project:
    June 13, 1902 .......................                 .................   $20,000
    June 13, 1902 (allotment-emergency)..................                   .   3, 000
    March 3, 1905........................................                       5, 000
    March 2, 1907..............................................                20, 000
                                                                                       48, 000. 00

                                                                                                                               105, 000. 00
Received from sales ..................................................                                                                i. 10

         Total..................                                ...........                           ..........               105, 001. 10


                                              CONTRACT IN                FORCE.

  Name of contractor: P. Sanford Ross (Incorporated).
  Date of contract: October 17, 1907.
  Date of approval: October 31, 1907.
  Date of commencement: December 1, 1907.
  Date of completion: September 1, 1908. Time limit waived. Completed Decem-
ber 4, 1908.
  For removing 640 cubic yards of rock and 6,800 cubic yards of covering material, at
$2.12 per cubic yard, prism measurement in place.
1084           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                    Freight handled in 1908.

             Class.                      Tons.            Value.                 Class.                    Tons.         Value.


General merchandise........                5, 500          $7, 000    Manufactures...............            40, 000    $1, 500, 000
Coal and other fuel..........              6, 000          30, 000    Farm products.. ..........              1, 000         20, 000
Building and road materials.              61, 500         513, 500
                                                                            Total..................        114, 000      2,070,500


  Passengers carried, 12,000.



                                                                 E I5.
IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AT RONDOUT AND PEEKSKILL, NEW
                       YORK.

                                               (A)     RONDOUT HARBOR.

                      OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

    For history and project see page 151 of this report.
  Under contract with William Parrott, dated April 6, 1908, for re-
pairing dike, the following material was delivered and secured in place
during the fiscal year:
5,031 linear feet pine piling, at $0.125 per linear foot...................... $628. 88
2,994 linear feet white oak piling, at $0.24 per linear foot --.....        --.....---.  ---       718. 56
22,003 feet b. m. square timber, at $55 per M feet b. m. - .......               --..
                                                                                 --     .--.    1, 210. 17
9,258 pounds tie-rods, at $0.035 per pound .............................                           324. 03
2,329 pounds screw bolts, at $0.04 per pound..............................                          93. 16
1,958 pounds driftbolts, at $0.04 per pound .................................                       78. 32
1,148 pounds washers, at $0.06 per pound...............................                             68. 88
325 linear feet wire cable, f inch in diameter, at $0.06 per linear foot ..... .                    19. 50
31 pounds wire staples, at $0.06 per pound..........                     ...... ................     1.86
862 cubic yards rubble stone, at $1 per cubic yard .....................                           862. 00
425 cubic yards quarry spalls, at $1 per cubic yard. ......................                        425. 00
        Total......................................................                                                     4, 430. 36
  The following material was delivered in dikes during the year under
open-market agreement with William Parrott:
922 cubic yards rubble stone, at $1.30 per cubic yard....................                                              $1, 198. 60
286 cubic yards quarry spalls, at $1.30 per cubic yard..........                                        .........          371. 80
        Total....................................                                          .......................      1, 570. 40
  Work under the above contract and open-market agreement was
completed September 5, 1908, and resulted in completing all neces-
sary repairs to the dike.
                                       Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
provement........                            ...........................      $3, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                       APPENDIX E-REPORT OF COLONEL BLACK.                                                        1085

                                               APPROPRIATIONS.

June 10, 1872..................   $10, 000                     July 13, 1892 ................                    $5, 000
March 3, 1873...................   20, 000                     August 18, 1894 .....-........                     5, 000
June 8, 1875 (allotment).........   1, 000                     June 3, 1896-................                      2, 500
August 14, 1876............... 30, 000                         June 13, 1902 (allotment).......                   2, 500
June 15, 1878..................    30, 000                     June 13, 1902 (allotment).......                   3, 800
August 2, 1882..................    2, 000                     March 3, 1905 (allotment).......                  15, 000
July 5, 1884_....................   1, 000                     March 2, 1907 (allotment).......                   3, 000
August 5, 1886................      2, 500
August 11, 1888.----.............   5, 000                              Total...................                143, 300
September 19, 1890...............   5, 000



                                            CONTRACT IN FORCE.

   Name of contractor: William Parrott.
   Date of contract: April 6, 1908.
   Date of approval: April 11, 1908.
   Date of commencement: May 14, 1908.
   Date of completion: December 14, 1908. Completed September 5, 1908.
   For repairing dikes at an estimated cost of $7,750.65.



                                              Freight handled in 1908.

             Class.                 Tons.        Value.                      Class.                  Tons.      Value.

General merchandise........   25, 000             $100, 000   Ice..........................           51, 000      $75, 000
Coal and other fuel..........200, 000              700, 000
Building and road materials. 162, 000            1,200, 000           Total................          438, 000   2, 075, 000


                                        (B)    PEEKSKILL HARBOR.

                      OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

  For history and project see page 152 of this report.
  There were no operations, the amount of funds available being
too small to do any dredging.
  Disbursements were mainly in part payment of office expenses.
                                   Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1901, for maintenance of
improvement........................----------------------------------.............------------...............----.. $3,000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                               APPROPRIATIONS.

June 3, 1896 ..........       ..... $10, 000                   March 2, 1907 (allotment).......                  $3, 000
March 3, 1899_..        ..... ....   10, 000
June 13, 1902 (allotment)........     3, 000                              Total ..................               28, 500
March 3, 1905 (allotment).......      2, 500
1086          REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                 OF ENGINEERS,                     U.       S. ARMY.

                                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                            Vessels employed in trade in 1908.


                                              Class.                                                     made.      Tonnage.        Draft.


                                                                                                                Feet.
Tugs and steamers --.......         ..    ............------------------------------------------- 2,152 115-500   5-12
Sailing vessels ...--------------------------------------------------                               180  65-150    4-7
Barges, etc------..---......................--------------------------.......-----------............348 115-500   6-12


  Passengers carried, 10,160.
                                                   Freight handled in 1908.

            Class.                         Tons.        Value.                            Class.                   Tons.        Value.

General merchandise.......                 158,860     $4,620,000       Farm products.-..........                      100           $2, 500
Coal and other fuel........-.               55,235        221,635       Ice .................            .......       100              250
Building and road materials.                 6, 861        51,612
Manufactures. ..............                     85         2,975                   Total................          226,533      4,984,046
Minerals and products. ....          ..      5,292         85,074


                                                                E i6.
              IMPROVEMENT OF WAPPINGER CREEK, NEW YORK.

                     OPERATIONS                    DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 153 of this report.
   During the past year the New York Central and Hudson River
Railroad Company has erected a new draw a short distance south of
the old draw span, and has connected the new location with the
channel improved by the United States by dredging to a depth of
8 feet at mean low water, except for the removal of minor obstructions
in the draw opening.
   A re-survey of the creek from the mouth to the falls shows that
considerable shoaling has occurred in the channel dredged by the
United States, especially in the upper reaches. Since it is not
possible to materially benefit navigation interests by the expenditure
of the balance of funds available for this work, it is proposed to delay
further work in Wappinger Creek until such time as additional funds
are made available by act of Congress.
                                          Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
  improvement............................................................................                                           $5, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
  and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.
September 19, 1890........                      ....................................                                         $13,   000. 00
June 13, 1902.......................................................                                                           1,   500. 00
March 3, 1905........................................................                                                          3,   000. 00
March 2, 1907...--------.................................................                                                      3,   000. 00
        Total ....................                         ......................................                             20, 500. 00
                              APPENDIX E-REPORT                                   OF COLONEL BLACK.                                           1087
                                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                   Vessels employed in trade in 1908.

                                                      Class.                                                       Trips.        Tonnage.     Draft.

                                                                                                                                                Feet.
Tugs and steamers ........................................................                                           2,064          21- 49       4-61
Barges, etc ...----------------------------------------------------                                                    265         200-250       4-8/o


   Passengers carried, 14,025.
                                                           Freight handled in 1908.

                  Class.                         Tons.            Value.                          Class.                     Tons.           Value.

General merchandise........                         3,221         $203, 145       Farm products ................                   340        $13, 800
Coal and other fuel....... ...                    21,355             76,070      Fish ..............             .......     .       1                30
Building and road materials.                       4, 400            28,095      Ice .............            ............          20                60
Manufactures .................                    11.000         6, 600, 000
Minerals and products.......                       1, 237            69, 400              Total ...............              41, 574         6,990, 600



                                                                             E   17.

                IMPROVEMENT OF TARRYTOWN HARBOR, NEW YORK.

                              OPERATIONS DURING                                  THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   For history and project see page 154 of this report.
   Under contract with Du Bois Brothers Dredging Company, dated
June 15, 1907, for dredging, work was commenced July 30, 1907, was
suspended November 30, 1907, on account of unfavorable weather,
and was not again resumed. The contract was terminated under
supplemental agreement dated August 21, 1908. The contractor
was paid for the removal of 84,615 }, cubic yards of material, this
amount representing the yardage removed under the contract after
making deduction for material illegally disposed of, and for over-
depth in dredging.
   When work was suspended in 1907, the southern arm had been
dredged to its full projected depth of 12 feet at mean low water and
width of 100 feet; the channel along the water front to a depth of 10 to
12 feet, and width of 100 feet; and the eastern end of the northren arm
12 feet deep and 60 feet wide for a distance of 350 feet, and a farther
distance of 100 feet 60 feet wide but of less depth than 12 feet. It
is probable that these dredged areas have shoaled to an appreciable
extent since the suspension of work in November, 1907.
                                               Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement ....................      ...      $9, 491. 68
   For maintenance of improvement ...................     ....  3, 000. 00
                                                                                                                                         $12,491. 68
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899,
1088                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                     U.    S. ARMY.

                                                               APPROPRIATIONS.
March 3, 1905...------------------------------------------------------...................................... -----                  $10, 000
March 2, 1907------------------------------------------------------------.                                                           16, 000

            Total----------------.....--------------........................-------------------------------....                      26,000



                                                       CONTRACT IN                       FORCE.

  Name of contractor: Du Bois Brothers Dredging Company.
  Date of contract: June 15, 1907.
  Date of approval: June 27, 1907.
  Date of commencement: July 29, 1907.
  Date of completion: November 29, 1907. Time limit waived to May 30, 1908,
inclusive. Contract terminated under supplemental agreement dated August 21, 1908.
  For dredging and removal of bowlders to the extent of $13,000. Dredging at 131
cents per cubic yard, scow measurement, and bowlders at $4 per cubic yard, solid
measurement.


                                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                    Vessels employed in trade in 1908.

                                                       Class.                                                  Trips    Tonnage.      Draft.


                                                                                                                                       Feet.
Tugs and steamers....                       ..........................................                           342       62-238        5-8l
Barges, etc ...     .................................................                                            402      109-509        5-8


                                                           Freight handled in 1908.

                  Class.                         Tons.             Value.                       Class.                 Tons.        Value.


General merchandise ........                       17,000       $3, 400,000          Minerals and products......        1, 077        $30, 266
Coal and other fuel..........                      34, 081          172, 122         Ashes, garbage, etc .........      1,250              825
Building and road materials.                       17, 917             45, 643
                                                                                           Total................       71,325       3,648,856


                                                                            E 18.

IMPROVEMENT OF CONEY ISLAND CHANNEL, NEW YORK HARBOR.
                              OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

  For history and project see page 155 of this report.
  Under contract with Morris & Cumings Dredging Company dated
July 26, 1907, for dredging, work was continued until July 21, 1908,
on which date 148,211.6 cubic yards of material had been excavated
and disposed of under the contract; of this amount 33,233.6, cubic
yards were excavated during the fiscal year.
  The contract was terminated under supplemental agreement dated
August 27, 1908.
  A survey made in June, 1908, of the area dredged in 1907, showed
that shoaling had occurred to such extent as to reduce the available
depth therein to practically the depth existing before any dredging
had been done. It is improbable that the proposed channel can be
maintained at a reasonable cost.
                     APPENDIX E-REPORT OF COLONEL BLACK.                                                   1089

                                             APPROPRIATION.
March 2, 1907......... .......-......... ... .. ....                      ........       ......... $188, 300. 00
                             ------------------------------------------
Repayment to appropriation.......................................                                           36. 67
Received from sale of maps--------......--------.....................-----------------...........----------   .33
        Total..---------.......-----...........------------------..-------------.............-------   188, 337.00



                                         CONTRACT IN              FORCE.

  Name of contractor: Morris & Cumings Dredging Company.
  Date of contract: July 26, 1907.
  Date of approval: August 1, 1907.
  Date of commencement: September 5, 1907.
  Date of completion: June 5, 1910. Terminated under supplemental agreement
dated August 27, 1908.
  For dredging 529,000 cubic yards of material at 27-1 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement.


                                     COMMERCIAL              STATISTICS.

  The commercial interests using this channel are those of the city of New York and
other cities whose commerce passes Sandy Hook. It is impracticable to state what
proportion of this commerce uses Coney Island channel.



                                                       E ig.
REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDAN-
                  GERING NAVIGATION.

   (a) Wreck of scow (name unkcnown).-This wreck was reported on
June 3, 1908, as obstructing navigation in East Chester Bay off
Wire Creek. No information could be secured as to the name of
the owner or date of sinking. Report was submitted June 29, 1908,
recommending its removal, and an allotment of $241.50 for this
purpose was made July 3, 1908.
   The lowest bid received in response to public notice was $229.
Removal was completed July 13, 19.08. The cost of removal, includ-
ing the cost of superintendence and inspection, was $241.50.
   Final report was submitted July 16, 1908.
   (b) Wreck of schooner H. T. Hedges.-This schooner was sunk on
or about June 1, 1908, in the East River, New York, opposite White-
stone, N. Y., and was abandoned by the owner. Report was sub-
mitted June 29, 1908, recommending its removal, and an allotment
of $994.50 for this purpose was approved July 7, 1908.
   The lowest bid received in response to public notice was $982.
Removal was completed July 13, 1908. The cost of removal, in-
cluding the cost of superintendence and inspection, was $994.50.
   Final report was submitted July 16, 1908.
    (c) Wreck of barge Kate.-This barge was sunk on or about June
23, 1908, in Bronx River, New York, about opposite One hundred
and seventy-second street, blocking navigation at this point. Under
date of July 3, 1908, the owner notified this office that he had aban-
doned the vessel. An allotment of $400 for its removal was re-
         9001-ENG 1909-69
1090    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,      U.   S. ARMY.

quested by telegraph July 6, 1908; this sum was allotted on the
same date.
   The lowest bid received in response to public notice was $343.
Removal was completed July 14, 1908. The cost of removal,
including the cost of superintendence and inspection, was $373.
   Final report was submitted July 16, 1908.
   (d) Wreck of schooner (name unknown).--This schooner sank about
June 1, 1908, in Long Island Sound, about one-half mile off Peacock
Point, Long Island. The name of the owner could not be learned.
Report was submitted July 6, 1908, recommending the removal of
the masts of the vessel, these being the only parts endangering
navigation, and allotments for this purpose amounting to $275
were made July 7 and July 24, 1908.
   The lowest bid received in response to public notice was $194.
Removal was completed July 28, 1908. The cost of removal,
including the cost of superintendence and inspection, was $259.
   Final report was submitted July 31, 1908.
   (e) Wreck of barge (name unknown).-This wreck consisted of a
portion of a wrecked barge which endangered navigation in the
Hudson River at Albany, N. Y. The wreckage was removed at a
cost of $48.50. An allotment of this amount for defraying the cost
of removal was made August 20, 1908.
   (f) Wreck of schooner Winslow Morse.-This wreck was first
reported to the Secretary of War September 5, 1908. Upon investi-
gation it was learned that the owner intended to raise the vessel,
but by letter of April 14, 1909, he stated that he had been unsuc-
cessful and was therefore compelled to abandon her. Removal of
the wreck was accordingly recommended by letter dated April 30,
1909, and an allotment of $375 for this purpose was made May
4, 1909.
   The lowest bid received in response to public notice was $280.
Removal was completed May 20, 1909. The cost of removal,
including superintendence and inspection, was $375.
   Final report was submitted May 29, 1909.
   (g) Wreck of barge Bessie.-This barge grounded near the east
bank of the Hudson River in the vicinity of the Empire Grove
Dock. It subsequently burned and sank in water varying from
3 to 22 feet in depth at low water, in about the narrowest part of
the Hudson River between Peekskill and Haverstraw bays. Re-
port was submitted May 5, 1909, recommending its removal, and
an allotment of $600 for this purpose was approved May 20, 1909.
   The lowest bid received in response to public notice was $474.
Removal was completed June 7, 1909. The cost of removal, in-
cluding the cost of superintendence and inspection, was $530.
   Final report was submitted June 10, 1909.
                           APPENDIX F.


IMPROVEMENT      OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE SECOND                      NEW
                       YORK, N. Y., DISTRICT.


REPORT OF COL. S. W. ROESSLER, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, OFFICER IN
     CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.
                              IMPROVEMENTS.


1, New York Harbor, New York.           4. Removing sunken vessels or craft
2. Bay Ridge and Red Hook channels,          obstructing or endangering navi-
     New York Harbor.                        gation.
3. Enlargement of Governors Island,
     New York Harbor.



                           UNITED STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                                        New York City, July 19, 1909.
  SIR: I have the honor to submit herewith annual report upon works
of river and harbor improvement in my charge for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                  S. W. ROESSLER,
                                            Colonel, Corps of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.          S. ARMY.


                                  FI.

        IMPROVEMENT OF NEW YORK HARBOR, NEW YORK.

   The title "Improvement of New York Harbor" has been applied
to the improvement of the channels of the main entrance from the sea.
  OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30,                 1909.

   Thirty-foot channel by way of Sandy Hook.-This channel, com-
pleted to 1,000 feet wide and 30 feet deep in 1892, has since been
maintained to the same depth, and as nearly as practicable to the pro-
jected width.
  The U. S. dredge Gedney continued work on the west side of Main
Ship channel below the West Bank light-house, from July 1 until
December 22, 1908, excepting about seven weeks in August and Sep-
tember, when she was withdrawn for general repairs. On December
23 she was laid up for the winter, having removed during the fiscal
                                                                   1091
1092           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                 U.      S. ARMY.

year 73,681 cubic yards of sticky mud, containing a little sand. The
total cost of operating the Gedney during this period, exclusive of
$5,000 for extraordinary repairs, was $13,860, being at the rate of
18.8 cents per cubic yard; or, deducting the time lost by these
repairs, about 134 cents.
  The Gedney's working time and lost time, July 1, to December 22,
1908, were as follows:
                                                                                                                               Days.
Actually at work parts of 77 days, equivalent to............................                                                    64. 5
Work prevented by weather (fog, storm, etc.).---.--...........................                                                  30. 5
Minor repairs ....--------------------------------------------------------                                                       2. O0
Extraordinary repairs......................................................                                                     39.5
Other causes, coaling, taking on supplies, etc .....-...-..-...                                      ..............             10. 5
Sundays and holidays .........               ...... ........             ............................                           28.0
         Total..................... ......................                                     ...................            175.0
   The Gedney is a wooden dredge about 22 years old, one of the
pioneers in the class of seagoing suction dredges. On account of
her small capacity (600 cubic yards), which requires frequent trips to
a dumping ground 9 miles away, she can no longer work in New
York Harbor with economy, although under other conditions she
should have five years or more of usefulness remaining. Therefore,
with approval of the Chief of Engineers, the Gedney was transferred
to the Newport, R. I., district, the transfer being made June 28, 1909.
   Ambrose channel.-The U. S. dredges Manhattan, Atlantic, Rari-
tan, and Navesink have worked in Ambrose channel during the
entire year, deepening the north and northeast half of the channel
(for 1,000 feet width) above buoy 12, the south half below buoy 8,
and the cross over between buoys 8 and 12; and in widening the
channel outside (east of) buoy 16. During the year these dredges
have removed 10,786,638 cubic yards of sand, depositing it in deep
water at distances from 5 to 12 miles from the dredging, averaging
about 7 miles.
   The total amount expended upon Ambrose channel during the fiscal
year is $480,428.32, of which $55,694.33 was paid for removal of
stone dumps, for work of dredge Delaware during previous year,
and for alterations in the new dredges Raritan and Navesink; the
rest, applied to expenses of removing 10,786,638 cubic yards, gives
actual cost as follows:
                                                                                                                Cents per cubic yard.
Dredging........................             $385, 081. 94 or ........................                                          3. 57
Surveys and examinations -----------
                                 ...........   26, 911. 98 or..........................                                           .25
Contingencies and supervision........          12, 740. 07 or..........................                                            12

         Total....................                       ...................................                                    3. 94

  In order to open a channel with safe navigable depth of 40 feet it
was necessary to remove some old stone dumps which lay near the
middle of the channel. This was done under contracts in July,
August, November, and December, 6,889 cubic yards of stone and
sand being taken out, at total cost of $35,739.91. Four other stone
dumps have since been removed by the United States plant, dredging
deep holes close by the shoals, and sinking the stones into them
with a water jet.
  The 40-foot channel is now from 950 to 1,600 feet wide through-
out the entire length of Ambrose channel, about 74 miles.
                                                                                                                                                                           A         Jq




                                         .   .   i        "-NeRTO
                                                          r
                                                            Nearc
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              AMBROSE CHANNEL
                    N"..

                O              fI                             iv             ,.   ._
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               NEW YORK HARBOR
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ,.            '..          r"
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 .. -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              J U LY I, 1909.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      SCALE.
                                                                                                                )N
                                                                                                                 PT             I
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    0 j 1000        '0OQ      53000        O      5d0L                               IO.0f0 Ft..

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             "                       ""   .




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 i



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              s

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             i




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ...
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     '.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   To accomopeay                  annualreport fryear               ending
                                                                                                                ,t                  ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     '   .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              "".

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ..                                               Jon,,e Jo, /SOS.

                                                                                                                                         "'   ""         <          ""- -'"                          "f"                                                          "                              ,,



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ,,   ,            't                                                   ,

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Colone/, Corps of ogineers, Us.A.

                                                                                                                                                     ,              't,"        " . .           ' . ' ". " . . .                      , .        "        ,         .     : ,
                                                                                                                                                                                 "        ,..                         -                     .o

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              "          ...                                                 Areas dre o'ed o 4do                     R.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  or greateroep h are shown
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         S                                                in soid co/or. Areas dreded 35 to 40f. deep are
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ndicated by hachurin.
HdSPTyAL I.%.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         r




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      "                                                            r       '"


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               "                +"                        .




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               M       S




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       '




                                                                                                                                                   °o.        ...          °"                   ..                        :/


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   "   r       "    "


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       M   y




                                                                                                                                                                                            d.-°      ..... /°-...:            ...1                                                                            "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         1




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                T1
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           "- "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ,tj                                  UJ
                                                                                                                       .                1.
                                                                                                                                         °"                                                                                                                                                                            r'
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        ."(Y4              '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                0)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       i' 2
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   '".   :-       -




                           WEST BANKU GH't       "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    S.
                                                                                                                                               *         *0
                                                               R
                                                     "
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               N'




                                                         '"    S         .        .
                                                                   ...                             -

                                                                                                       .1



                                                                         v                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      .1


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ,            14)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          :.                                      ",

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             .,

                                                                                                                           ,,




                                                                                       ,-,,.


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 '
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          "   t



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      i
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       •       .          \           --
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ..                                    I
                                                                                       '       .                                                                                                                             M~
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          :..L,                  e                '.\46
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              .                      t                                            .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ,gyp)     "        ,
                                                                                                   .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                "                    "I




                                                                                       .
                                                                                                            :



                                                                                           Z                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   ,,          ..

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Cw                                 C_
                                                              w"




                                                                                                                  ''

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    -,            ....       .
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              w                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    ....   .


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     THE NORRIS                   D
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              PETERSCO, WASHINGTON,   y
                     APPENDIX F-REPORT OF COLONEL ROESSLER.                                                     1093

   Rock off Pier A.-Removal of this rock to 40 feet depth was in
progress        at
             the beginning of the fiscal year under contract with
J. D. Miller. The contractor continued surface blasting and dredg-
ing until August 10, taking out 75 cubic yards of rock. He then
took his plant away and failed to resume work or to indicate any
intention of resuming. The time limit, which had been several
times waived with sanction of the Chief of Engineers, passed by
with no indication of a return to work and the contract expired by
limitation. The total amount of rock taken out under this con-
tract was 363 cubic yards.
   A contract for completion of removal of this rock was entered
into with the R. G. Packard Dredging Company under date of April
13, 1909; price, $37,450. The contractors removed by dredging
about 60 yards of rock already blasted, and found that much more
blasting was necessary in order to make the rock dredgeable. They
have built a drilling plant which is nearly ready for operation.
                                       PROPOSED            OPERATIONS.

  It is proposed to apply the funds available for maintenance to
removing shoals in channels already dredged, in order of urgency
and importance; to apply the funds for Ambrose channel to dredg-
ing to widen the 40-foot channel, at first below buoy 16, subse-
quently above that buoy to the 40-foot curve inside the bar; and to
apply the funds for removal of rock off Pier A to making a clear
depth of 40 feet over that obstruction.
  It is estimated that the following expenditures will become nec-
essary under the adopted project for improving Ambrose channel
between July 1, 1909, and June 30, 1911:
Operation of four dredges, Manhattan, Atlantic, Raritan, and Nasesink,
  two years each, at $120,000...........................................                                    $960,000
Surveys and contingencies..............................................                                       90, 000
        Total....................................---------------------------------------------.            1, 050, 000

                                          GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.


                                  Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for maintenance of improvement, exclusive of the balance unex-
  pended July 1, 1909-----------------------------------------............................................... $150,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                              AMBROSE       CHANNEL.


                                   Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement........................... $324, 510.00
   For maintenance of improvement......................    195, 490. 00
                                                                                                        $520, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
1094                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Appropriations for improving New York Harbor have been made
as follows:

                                                          Application.                                                                         Date.        Amount.


For Gedney and Main Ship channels, and maintenance, prior to December
  31, 1902, as per H. Doc. No. 421, 52d Cong., 2d sess., p. 295..............................                                                              $1,945,000.00
For maintenance, allotted from emergency appropriation.......               ........             June 6,1900                                                    1,500. 00
    Do....................................................................                       Apr. 28,1904                                                  15,000.00
    Do..................................................................                      ..... do-...-..                                                  15,000.00
    Do.                  ..................................................                                                          Mar.         3,1905       75,000 00
    Lo...................................................                                                                            Mar. 2,1907              125,000.00
    Do                ....................................................                                                           Mar. 3,1909              100,000.00
                                                                                                                                                           2,276,500.00
Received from other sources...........                                   .................................................                                     28,024. 52
       Total            ..............................................                                                       ...............                2,304,524.52

For East (Ambrose) channel, dredging......                                                     ......................               Mar.          3,1899    1,000,000.00
    Do....................................................                                                                           Mar.        3,1901       130,000.00
    Do...................................................................                                                            June       28,1902       150,000.00
    Do...................................................................                                                            Mar.        3,1903       733,000.00
    Do...................................................................                                                            Apr.       29,1904        50,000.00
    Do...................................................................                                                            M ar.       3,1905       715,510.00
    Do...................................................................                                                            June       30,1906       265,000.00
    Do...................................................................                                                            Mar.        4,1907       470,000.00
    Do...................................................................                                                            May        27,1908       683,490.00
    Do...................................................................                                                            Mar.        4,1909       627,000.00

        Total                ...............................................................                                                                4,824,000. 00
Amount diverted for removal of rock in North River, by joint resolution of
  July 1, 1902, and by river and harbor act of March 3, 1905.................                                                           ............           45,000.00
                                                                                                                                                                    00
                                                                                                                                                            4,779,000.
Received from other sources...............................................................                                                                      2,084. 99
                                                                                                                                                            4, 781, 084.99

For removal of rock in North River.......................................................                                                                      45,000.00


                                                                 CONTRACTS                           IN      FORCE.

  With Hite & Rafetto, of New York, N. Y., for furnishing bituminous coal for the
U. S. dredges Manhattan, Atlantic, Raritan, and Navesink. Date of contract, July 11,
1908; approved by the Chief of Engineers July 28, 1908. Date of completion, June 30,
1909. Quantity, about 48,000 tons. Price, $2.89 per ton.
  With R. G. Packard Company, New York, N. Y., for removing rock near Pier A,
North River, New York Harbor. Date of contract, April 13, 1909; approved by the
Chief of Engineers April 27, 1909. Time for completion, on or before June 8, 1910.
Contract price, $37,450.



                                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

   The following statement concerning foreign commerce of the port of New York
is compiled from the annual report of the Chamber of Commerce of the State of New
York for the year 1908-9. It comprises only imports from and exports to foreign
countries for the year ending June 30, 1908, and does not include domestic, coastwise,
and local traffic. Vessels trading with domestic ports do not take out clearance
papers, and no statistics of their carrying trade are accessible.
   The leading articles of import into the United States at the port of New York for
the year ending June 30, 1908, were sugar, tea, coffee, wool, cloths and dress goods,
leather and leather goods, tin, rubber, tobacco, and rope fibers, which, with other
miscellaneous imports, aggregated about 4,775,986 tons, valued at $805,962,734.
The value of such imports for all other ports of the United States for the same period
was $581,374,476.
   The leading articles of export were cotton, breadstuffs, and other provisions, oils,
tobacco, metals, and manufactures, which, with other items, amounted to abeut3
7,765,433 tons, valued at $807,068,532. The value of such exports for all other ports
of the United States for the same period was $1,184,058,940.
                     APPENDIX F-REPORT OF COLONEL ROESSLER.                                                 1095
Statement of the number and tonnage of vessels belonging to the port of New York June
                                                   30, 1909.


                                                                                              Number.     Tonnage.


Sailing                                                                            917
          vessels...................................................................   249,830
Steam vessels................................................................... 1,730 913,696
Canal boats.....................................................................   191  23,694
Barges.......................................................................... 1,524 407,266

      Total          .........................................................                  4,362           486
                                                                                                           1,594,


  From the records of the New York and New Jersey pilot commissioners' offices
the following data concerning deep-draft vessels crossing Sandy Hook bar have been
compiled for the calendar year 1908:

                                                                             Outward.                 Inward.

                                 Draft.                                 Number                 Number
                                                                                   Number                  Number
                                                                          sels.-   oftrips.      sels.     of trips.


34feetdraftand      over.............................................              2     18 ....
33 feet draft and   under 34........................................               2      2 ..
32 feet draft and   under 33........................13                                             2
                                                                                         24...............4  4
31 feet draft and   under 32......................................                20     34        2        14
30 feet draft and   under 31...0.............................                 .33        84        0         0
29 feet draft and   under 30....3.............................                    46    135        1         1
28 feet draft and   under 29..................................                    36     76       11        32
27 feet draft and   under 28.........               .........................     69    111       16        86
                              .........
      Total........................                                                     484    ........           137


  The total number of different ships of 27 feet draft or over is 124.
  The maximum draft of ships leaving the harbor in 1908 was 34 feet 7 inches; the
maximum draft entering was 33 feet 5 inches.
  Before improvement of the entrance to the harbor vessels drawing 27 feet could
cross the bar at extreme high tide only.



                                                       F 2.

IMPROVEMENT OF CHANNEL IN GOWANUS BAY, NEW YORK HARBOR,
     NEW YORK-BAY RIDGE AND RED HOOK CHANNELS.
              OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.

   Dredging was continued under contract of August 12, 1907, with
the Morris & Cumings Dredging Company until April 30, 1909, when
the contract was completed.
   During the fiscal year 799,727 cubic yards of mud and sand were
removed from the channels, making the total amount dredged since
the beginning of the contract 2,162,912 cubic yards. Of this total,
183,797 cubic yards were deducted for over-depths made by the
dredges. It is estimated that about 30 per cent of this amount
deducted will be paid for under a provision of the contract for allow-
ance for such back fill as occurs during the work.
   The result of this work has been to make Bay Ridge channel 1,000
to 1,060 feet wide and 35 feet deep at mean low water, nearly from
its lower end to Erie Basin bulkhead, about opposite Thirty-fifth
street, Brooklyn; above Thirty-fifth street to Gowanus Creek it was
1096              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                           U.    S. ARMY.

dredged to 35 feet, but the shoaling in this section is more rapid than
elsewhere and the present available depth is 33 feet. Red Hook
channel has been made 30 feet deep and 1,000 feet wide.
                                                   PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   With the available funds a cofltract has been entered into under
which Bay Ridge channel will be made its projected width of 1,200
feet, with 35 feet depth: Red Hook channel will be made its projected
width of 1,200 feet, with 30 feet depth, and its easterly part will be
further deepened to 35 feet for a width of 350 feet, as nearly as can be
now estimated.
   These channels are in the collection district of New York, of which
New York City is the port of entry. The nearest light-house is the
Statue of Liberty Enlightening the World, on Bedloe Island, about
1 miles west. The nearest work of defense is Fort Jay, Governors
Island, New York Harbor.
                                            Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, for works of improvement, exclusive of the balance unexpended
  July 1, 1909...................................................... $315, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897.
  Appropriations for improving Bay Ridge and Red Hook channels
have been made as follows:

                                             Application.                                             Date.        Amount.

For previous projects:
   Appropriations prior to 1899, as per H. Doc. No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.,
      p. 293, including $175,000 (estimated), applied to Buttermilk channel
        and Gowanus Creek channel........................................................                         $1,346,100.00

For present project of 1899:
    Dredging............. ..............................................                           Mar. 3,1899       100,000. 00
        Do...............................................................                          June 6,1900       262,000.00
        Do...............................................................                          M ar. 3,1901      140,000.00
        Do..............................................................                           June 28,1902      100,000. 00
        Do...............................................................                          M ar. 3,1903      272,000.00
        Do...............................................................                          Apr. 28,1904      175,000. 00
        Do...............................................................                          M ar. 3,1905      200,000.00
        Do..............................................................                           June 30,1906      250,000.00
        Do..............................................................                           Mar. 4,1907       200,000. 00
        Do...............................................................                          M ar. 4,1909      310,000.00

                                                                                                                   2,009, 000. 00
Received from other sources....................................................                                            27. 80
        Total................................................................                             ..               80
                                                                                                                   2,009,027.



                                                     CONTRACT IN                     FORCE.

   For excavating Bay Ridge and Red Hook channels, removing 2,337,000 cubic yards,
more or less, at 18.4 cents per cubic yard, measured in scows.
   Name of contractors: The Morris & Cumings Dredging Company, New York, N. Y.
   Date of contract: August 12, 1907. Approved by the Chief of Engineers August
24, 1907.
   Time of completion: Within nineteen and one-half working months.
  Contract completed: April 30, 1909.
                  APPENDIX F-             REPORT OF COLONEL ROESSLER.                                        1097
                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR THE CALENDAR YEAR 1908


                                                                                Sailings.     Cargo      Estimated
                                                                                            tonnage.      value.

Bay Ridge channel (Ninety-second to Twenty-eighth streets):
    Foreign receipts..................................................               314      785,906    $45,794,100
    Foreign shipments.............................................                   390    1,579, 281    96, 097, 400
    Domestic receipts.................................................              (a)       332,000      2,255,000
Red Hook channel, exclusive of Erie Basin...........................                (a)       100, 000     2,000, 000
Erie Basin............................................................               376    1,490,713     75,341,752
      Total..................      ...................     ...........-......      1,080    4,287,900    221,488,252

                                  a Domestic receipts, mainly from barges.

  In addition to the above, about 3,215,000 tons of domestic freight passed through
these channels to and from Gowanus Creek, of value estimated at $33,000,000.
  The amount and importance of commerce in this part of New York Harbor is increas-
ing with the increased channel facilities. This section is now the terminal of steam-
ship lines making regular trips to Central America, Brazil, Nova Scotia, Italy, Austria,
and Sweden, and of more or less regular sailings to China, East Africa, India, etc.



                                                         F 3.

   ENLARGEMENT                  OF GOVERNORS ISLAND,                            NEW YORK HARBOR,
                                        NEW YORK.

   This project was adopted under authority of the sundry civil act
of March 3, 1901, and consists in enlarging the island by reclaiming
land under water on the shoal southwest of the island, inclosing the
enlargement by a sea wall, building a dock on the north shore of the
island, and deepening the approaches to the dock and constructing
buildings for military uses.
   The parts of this work assigned to the Engineer Department were
the enlargement proper with sea wall, estimated to cost $885,000; the
new dock and refitting an old dock, estimated at $115,000, and dredg-
ing to the dock, estimated at $100,000; total estimated cost,
$1,100,000.
   The original plan of reclaiming 82 acres of land under water was
extended to 101 acres by approval of the Secretary of War. No new
estimate of cost has yet been made.
   OPERATIONS DURING THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING                                               JUNE   30, 1909.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year embankment construction was
in progress under a contract with Henry Steers (Incorporated); work
was continued until June 24, 1909. when the contract was completed.
During the year 1,124,388 cubic yards of material, scow measure-
ment, were brought into the inclosure, of which about 1,000,000
yards were from sand dredgings in the harbor and the rest from
street and cellar excavations in the city. This material was pumped
over into the embankment behind a temporary bulkhead thrown up
by the contractor to retain the embankment. Of the total amount,
638,339 cubic yards, prism measurement, were placed above mean
low water.
1098          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

   The total amount delivered under the contract was 2,305,623
cubic yards, measured in scows; the total amount placed above mean
low water was 1,236,089 cubic yards, prism measurement. The
result has been to build up to grade about 85 acres of land, 5 acres of
which overlap the old island on account of necessary changes of grade
and 80 acres on enlargement proper.
   The material is mainly sand, poorly adapted to raising grass, and
when dry very liable to blow about in heavy winds, creating a con-
siderable nuisance on the residence parts of the island. This will
be covered with a clayey loam or similar surface upon which turf
may be grown.
   During the year 22,216 tons of riprap were placed along the base
of the sea wall, covering a section about 3,200 feet long on the Hud-
son River side and 2,000 feet on the Buttermilk channel side, where
the yielding and erosion of the soft bottom seemed liable to affect
the foundation of the wall. The work was done under two contracts,
at prices of 48 cents and 30 cents, respectively, the total amount paid
being $7,924.26.
   A light and fog bell have been maintained during the year at the
southwest curve of the sea wall.
   A contract is about to be made for completion of the sea wall and
embankment.
                                             PROPOSED OPERATIONS.

   The sea wall and embankment will be completed with the availa-
ble funds, leaving a balance estimated at about $120,000, which will
be applied to covering the sand embankment with soil suitable for
growing grass. Whether the balance will suffice or not depends upon
the details of the plan of work, which are not yet decided upon.
   It is probable that from time to time additional riprap may be
required along the base of the sea wall, and it is possible that the upper
or coping course of the sea wall will ultimately require relaying, should
it settle materially.

                                                    APPROPRIATIONS.

  The appropriations made for this work, as far as relates to the
Engineer Department, are as follows:
Sundry civil act of March 3, 1901 ($260,000), allotted to Engineer
Department......................................................             $200,000.00
General deficiency act of July 1, 1902.................................        200, 000. 00
Sundry civil act of March 3, 1903.....................................         150, 000.00
Sundry civil act of April 28, 1904....................................         200, 000.00
Sundry civil act of March 3, 1905....................................          100, 000. 00
Sundry civil act of March 4, 1907.....................................         100, 000.00
Sundry civil act of May 27, 1908......................................          75, 000.00
Sundry civil act of March 4, 1909.....................................          75, 000.00
                                                                             1, 100, 000. 00
Received from other sources ...................................        ...             2. 60

        Total.......................................................         1, 100, 002. 60
              APPENDIX F-REPORT OF COLONEL ROESSLER.                           1099
                             CONTRACT IN       FORCE.

Building embankment, Governors Island, N. Y.:
    Name of contractor: Henry Steers (Incorporated), New York, N. Y.
    Date of contract: September 5, 1907.
    Date of approval: September 11, 1907.
    Date of completion: Thirty months after date of approval.
    Quantity: As stated in report.
    Price: Inner section, 17 cents per cubic yard; outer section, 22.6 cents per cubic
      yard.
    Contract completed: June 24, 1909.



                                        F4.

REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDAN-
                  GERING NAVIGATION.

   Steamship Finance.-The Finance, an iron steamship 295 feet
long, 38.4 feet broad, belonging to the Panama Steamship Company,
trying to pass out of New York Harbor in a thick fog, November 26,
1908, came into collision with the White Star Steamship Georgic,
and sank within a few minutes, lying in water 33 to 36 feet deep,
about 900 feet north of the center line of Bayside channel.
   The ship was formally abandoned by her owners early in January.
   On account of her exposed location it was impracticable to remove
her during the winter months, and the spot was so far north of the
channel course that it was deemed sufficient to mark it with buoys.
   Proposals for removal were received April 23, and on May 22 a
contract was entered into with Messrs. Johnston & Virden to remove
the wreck for the sum of $23,950, work to be completed in seven
months.
   The contractors began work May 26 and up to June 30 had taken
out all of the contents which were accessible without blowing off
the deck. This included about 200 sacks of mail, mostly second
class, which was turned over to the Post-Office Department.
   Work of removal is in progress.
   Steamship Daghestan.-The Daghestan was an iron steamship,
British register, 353.1 feet long and 45.1 feet broad. On December 18,
1908, about noon, during a slight fog, she came into collision with
the steamship Catalone, near the entrance to Gedney channel. She
drifted about for ten hours, and sank shortly before midnight in 65
feet of water about 7,100 feet southeast from the whistling buoy.
She was reported lying on her port side, with 18 feet of water over
her. Her cargo was said to be mainly wheat, for Mediterranean
ports.
   The Daghestanwas formally abandoned by her owners and under-
writers January 19.
   The wreck lay in a position very dangerous to ships entering the
harbor, and was promptly marked with gas and bell buoys, the
situation being too exposed to permit of work in winter.
   Proposals for removal were received May 6, 1909, and a contract
was entered into May 28 with Johnston & Virden, the lowest bidders,
to remove the wreck sufficiently to make a clear depth of 50 feet at
1100      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                 U.   S. ARMY.

mean low water, for the sum of $33,700; to begin on or before July
12, and to complete on or before January 12, 1910.
   Work of removal is about to be begun.
   Barge Win. H. Connor.-The Win. H. Connor was a three-masted
wooden barge, 210.4 feet long, 40.5 feet wide, built in 1877. On or
about April 22, 1909, she came into collision with a schooner near the
harbor entrance and was so badly damaged that she was sinking.
She was at once towed outside the channel and grounded in 22 feet of
water at a point about 2,000 feet from the inner end of Gedney
channel.
   Proposals have been received, and a contract was about to be en-
tered into for her removal at net cost of $3,500, when a severe storm
carried away part of her starboard side, making the conditions of the
wreck different.
   A new examination was made, as a result of which the lowest bidder
offered to reduce the price to $3,000, and a contract is about to be
entered into under which the removal will be begun early in July.

                           CONTRACTS IN       FORCE.

   For removal of wreck Finance. Name of contractor, Johnston & Virden. Date of
contract, May 22, 1909; approved by the Chief of Engineers May 28, 1909. Contract
price, $23,950. Work to be begun within twenty days after notification of approval,
and completed within seven months thereafter.
   For removal of the wreck Daghestan. Name of contractor, Johnston & Virden. Date
of contract, May 28, 1909; approved by the Chief of Engineers June 17, 1909. Contract
price, $33,700. Work to be begun within twenty days after notification of approval,
and completed within six months thereafter.
                              APPENDIX G.


IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE THIRD NEW YORK,
                      N. Y., DISTRICT.


REPORT OF COL. D. W. LOCKWOOD, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, OFFICER IN
     CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.

                                IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Passaic River, New Jersey.              5. Keyport Harbor, Matawan Creek;
2. Arthur Kill, or Staten Island Sound,         Raritan, South, and Elizebath rivers;
     New York and New Jersey, and               Shoal Harbor and Compton Creek,
     channel between Staten Island and          and Cheesequake Creek, New Jersey.
     New Jersey.                           6. Shrewsbury River, New Jersey.
3. Woodbridge Creek, New Jersey.           7. Manasquan River, New Jersey.
4. Raritan Bay, New Jersey.                8. Removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
                                                structing or endangering navigation.


                              UNITED STATES         ENGINEER      OFFICE,
                                   New York City, July 20, 1909.
  Sin: I have the honor to transmit herewith the annual reports
upon the works of river and harbor improvement under my charge
in northeastern New Jersey for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                     D. W. LOCKWOOD,
                                                Colonel, Corps of Engineers.
  The CHIEF     OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.



                                     G    I.

           IMPROVEMENT OF PASSAIC RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

  Detailed descriptions of this river and of the projects for its improve-
ment are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1900, pages 177 and 1530 to 1552, and a condensed history is con-
tained in current summary.
                OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   Dredging operations during the past fiscal year have been carried
on under three contracts, as shown by abstracts of contracts in force.
   1. Under the contract of P. Sanford Ross (Incorporated) work was
in progress at the beginning of the fiscal year. Dredging was con-
tinued under waiver of time limit to December 5, 1908, when the
contract was completed. One dredge was employed on the work,
and the dredged material was mostly dumped in a basin on the west
side of Newark Bay, whence it was pumped ashore for filling marsh
land, and the remainder was dumped at sea. The amount dredged
during the year was 86,547 cubic yards, and the total under the con-
                                                                          1101
1102                REPORT               OF       THE CHIEF                      OF ENGINEERS,                            U.          S.        ARMY.


tract 707,897 cubic yards. The amounts dredged and the locations
of the work are shown in the following table.
  2. Under contract of the International Contracting Company
dredging was in progress at the beginning of the fiscal year, when
155,034 cubic yards had been removed.                                                                      The work was continued to
July 8, 1908, under waiver of time limit, when the contract was com-
pleted. The amount dredged during the year under this contract
was 2,468 cubic yards. The total amount dredged under the con-
tract was 157,502 cubic yards. The location of work is shown in the
following table. One dredge was employed and the dredged material
was dumped in a basin on the north side of the river in "section 5,"
whence it was pumped ashore on the lowlands of the Pennsylvania
Railroad Company.
Table showing progress of dredging in PassaicRiver upon contracts in force and completed
and parts of sections dredged and completed under the project of June 13, 1902, for a
channel 200 feet wide and 12 and 10 feet deep at mean low water.

                       Sectional description.                                                                               Amount
                                                                                                                            dredged                Total         Propor-
                                                                                                                            in fiscal             amount          tion of
                                                                                                                              year               removed             section
                                                                                                                             ending                under              com-
                                                                                                                            June 30,             contract.           pleted.
                                                                                                                              1909.


          Deep water in Newark Bay                             Yards.                                                        Cu. yds.               Cu. yds.    Per cent.
                                                                             Kirk, Driscoll & Co...............                                     104, 759
            to Lehigh Valley R. R.                              3,500        P. S. Ross (Inc.)...............                                       255, 404                100
            bridge.
    2     Lehigh Valley R. R. bridge                             3, 000      Kirk, Driscoll & Co-...............                                     119,288                100
            to Newark and N. Y. R. R.
            bridge.
    3     Newark and N. Y. R. R.                                 1,230      ..... do................                   ..........                    105,184                100
            bridge to Newark Plank
            Road Bridge.                                         1, 4 0 0    - --do - - - - -- - - - -                          ----
    4     Plank Road Bridge to Penn-                             1,400      .....      o..............                . ..........                   32,751                 100
            sylvania R. R. freight
            bridge.
    5     Pennsylvania R. R. freight
            bridge to Jackson Street                             3,530   j... do    .......................                                          100, 473
                                                                     3,53 P. S. Ross (Inc.)..........                      ..........                181,139                100
            Bridge.
    6     Jackson Street Bridge to                                  660 ..... do.....                      ........        ..........                  7, 799               100
            Pennsylvania R. R. bridge,
            Market street.
    7     Pennsylvania R. R. bridge,                                                                                                                 18,248
            Market street to Center                                 660      Kirk, Driscoll & Co .......
                                                                             P. S. Ross (Inc.).                                                      25,598                 100
            Street R. R. bridge.
    8     Center Street R. R. bridge
            to Bridge Street highway
                                                                    530
                                                                            {Kirk, Driscoll & Co...
                                                                             P. S. Ross (Inc.).
                                                                                                                             .. .....           i    19,147
                                                                                                                                                     28,840                 100
            bridge.
    9     Bridge Street Bridge to Dela-                                      ..... do...................
                                                                                                                                                      11,185
            ware, Lackawanna and                                    260      International Contracting                                                                      100
            Western R. R. bridge.                                              Co.                                                                     8,066
   10     Delaware, Lackawanna and                                           P. S. Ross (Inc.)..........                                              15,198           ..       1
            Western R. R. bridge to
                                                                                                                                                       6, 800 }             100
                                                                     460     International Contracting
            Clay Street highway bridge.                                          Co.                                                                          ..                1
   11     Clay Street Bridge to New                                     P. S. Ross (Inc.)..........
                                                                 S430   International Contracting                                                      7,526
            York, Lake Erie and West-
                                                                                                                                                       7, 775 }             100
            ern R. R. bridge.                                            SCo.
   12     New York, Lake Erie and                                      IP. S. Ross (Inc.)..........                                                             ..              1
            Western R. R. bridge to                              1,100 International Contracting                                                      44,584 }              100
             Nairn Linoleum Works.                                      I Co.
                                                                                                                                                      64,494
   13     Nairn Linoleum Works to
            Montclair and Greenwood
                                                                        P. S. Ross (Inc.)........
                                                                 2,000 International Contracting                                 86,547              130,624 S                 90
                                                                                                                                     2, 468           70, 367
             Lake R. R. bridge.                                               SCo.
                                                                             Kirk, Driscoll & Co......                                               499,850
                    Total.................                      18,760       P. S. Ross (Inc.)....                               86,547              707,897
                                                                             International Contracting                               2,   468
                                                                                                                                                     157,502
                                                                               Co.


                                                                       Amount of contract.                                                                  Cubic yards.
Kirk, Driscoll & Co5.............................................................................                                                                    a500,000
P. S. Ross (Inc.).. ....- .         ....................................................................                                                             a707,000
International Contracting Co...................................................................                                                                      a 157, 600
                                                              a Contract completed.
                                     APPENDIX G--REPORT OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                                                    1103

   This project is completed, with the exception of the upper quarter
of section 13 (see preceding table), which was not dredged quite full
width. This section also requires redredging for maintenance.
   3. Under project approved March 23, 1907, for work authorized by
Congress by act of March 2, 1907: At the beginning of the fiscal year
work was in progress under a continuing contract with the Midland
Land and Improvement Company, and 779,708 cubic yards of mate-
rial, mud and sand, had been removed. Dredging was continued
during the year, and the amount of material, mud, sand, and gravel,
removed was 1,069,748 cubic yards, the work by months being as
follows:

                                      1908.                   Material.                              1909.                                   Material.

                                                              Cu. yds.                                                                         Cu. yds.
July .............................                             110,793                    ---------------------------................................30,660
August..............                         ....              106,425                  ...----------
                                                                                      Y-----                                                         32,074
September.... - - -- - - - -- - - - -                           66, 563                                 -- --- --- --- --- -- .
                                                                                                      --------                                       6 4 ,43 3
October.....         .......................                    96, 858                               --- -
                                                                                                     ----      -- --- - .--
                                                                                                              ---              -- ---              165 ,5 03
November...............................                         48,927                -..--------------------------                                143,584
December......            .................                     32,138                . ...............................                             171,790
                       _                                  i                i          _




   The minimum rate of excavation required under this contract is
50,000 cubic yards per month. Three to seven dredges have been
employed on this work, and the dredged material was mostly dumped
in a basin between the Plank Road Bridge and Pennsylvania Railroad
freight bridge (sec. 4 in table), whence it was pumped ashore for land
reclamation of the large marsh tract lying between and near the
mouths of the Passaic and Hackensack rivers. Two large pumps are
employed on this work. A small part of the material dredged, was
dumped at sea. The amount of material excavated and location of
work done during the year, also totals under the contract, are shown in
the following table:
Table showing progress of dredging in Newark Bay and Passaic River under the project of
   March 2, 1907,for a channel 16 feet in depth at mean low water, 300 feet wide to the Nairn
  Linoleum Works, thence 200 feet wide to the Montclair and Greenvood Lake Railroad
   bridge. Contract of Midland Land and Improvement Company, dated August 12, 1907.

                      Sectional description.                  I Amount
                                               I                       Total
                                                            dredged amount                     Propor-
                       Continuous.                          in fiscal dredged                  tion of
                                                           year end- under                     section                      Remarks.
                                                                                                com-
                                                   Length. ing June contract.                  pleted.
Sec-                           Location.                   30, 1909.
tion.
                                                                               Cu-lds             -ercet
                                                   Yards.        Cu. yds.      Cu. yds.    Per cent.
       1      Deep water in Newark Bay              3, 700        156,871      579, 321      75              Dredged full length and 150
               to Lehigh Valley R. R.                                                                         to 250 feet width.
               bridge.
       2      Lehigh Valley R. R. bridge             3,000        175,186      397,815          60           Dredged full length                       and
               to Newark and NewYork                                                                          about 150 feet width.
               R.R. bridge.
       3      Newark and New York                    1,230        185,379      281,273          95           Dredged full length                       and
                R. R. bridge to Newark                                                                        about 300 feet width.
                Plank Road Bridge.
       4      Plank Road Bridge to Penn-             1,400                                      40+-         Dumping basin. No esti-
               sylvania R. R. freight                             376,168      414,903......                  mate to be made until close
               bridge.                                                                                        of contract.
       5      Pennsylvania R. R. freight             3, 530       376,   168   414,2903         50           Dredged about 150 feet width
               bridge to Jackson Street                                                                       and nearly full length.
                Bridge.
1104           REPORT          OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                              S. ARMY.

Table showing progress of dredging in Newark Bay and Passaic River, etc.-Continued.

             Sectional description.
                                                   Amount
                                                               Total
                                                    dredged amount                                  Propor-
             Continuous.                            in fiscal
                                                                                                    tion of
                                                              dredged
                                                   year end- under                                  section                     Remarks.
                                                                                                       com-
                                           Length. ing June contract.                                pleted.
Sec-             Location.                         30, 1909.
tion.
                                                           -1-1                                                     1



                                            Yards.         Cu. yds.            Cu. yds. Per cent.
   6     Jackson Street Bridge to              660          91,217              91, 217       80                        Dredged nearly full length
           PennsylvaniaR.R.bridge,                                                                                       and 200 to 300 feet width.
           Market street.
   7     Pennsylvania R. R. bridge,              660           84,927             84,927                       60       Dredged for partial length
           Market street, to Center                                                                                      and width.
           street R. R. bridge.
   8    Center street R. R. bridge to            530........                                    .          .        -
           Bridge Street highway
           bridge.
   9     Bridge Street Bridge to Del-            260              ..        .................
           aware, Lackawanna and
           Western R. R. bridge.
  10     Delaware, Lackawanna and                460..                 ..   .........
           Western R. R. bridge to
           Clay    Street highway
           bridge.
  11     Clay Street Bridge to New               430........                            ..
           York, Lake Erie and
           Western R. R. bridge.
  12     New York, Lake Erie and               1,100....                      .......                 .
           Western R. R. bridge to
           Nairn Linoleum Works.
  13     Nairn Linoleum Works to               2,000................
           Montclair    and Green-
            wood Lake R. R. bridge.
               Total...............        S 18,960 1,069,748 1,849,456                             ....       ..



                                      Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of improve-
ment......--------------------------------------------------------         $150, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897.


                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.

For projects of 1872 and 1880:
    June 10, 1872-----------------------------------.......................................                         $25, 000.00
    March 3, 1873-----------------------------------......................................                           25,000.00
    June 23, 1874------------------------------------.......................................                         20, 000.00
    March 3, 1875- .----------------------------------....................................-                          20, 000. 00
    August 10, 1876----------------------------------....................................                            10, 000.00
    June 18, 1878-----------------------------------.......................................                          10,000.00
    March 3, 1879---------------------------------....................................---                              2,000.00
    June 14, 1880-----------------------------------.......................................                          32, 000. 00
    M arch 3, 1881......................................                                                             50,000.00
    August 2, 1882-----------------------...................-----------.............                                 50,000.00
    July 5, 1884-------------------------------------.......................................                          28,000.00
    August 5, 1886----------------------------------.....................................                            26,250.00
    August 11, 1888....................................                                                              35,000.00
    September 19, 1890------------------------------
                               ................................-                                                     45, 100. 00
    June 13, 1892 (projects consolidated)...............                                                             45, 000. 00
    August 18, 1894....................................                                                               15, 000.00
    June 3, 1896.....................................                                                                15, 000. 00
    March 3, 1899....................................                                                                15,000.00
              APPENDIX G-REPORT OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                  1105
For projects of 1872 and 1880-Continued.
    June 6, 1900 (allotment July 12, 1901)................       $1, 000. 00
    June 6, 1900 (allotment May 22, 1903) ...............        10, 000. 00
    June 13, 1902 (allotment Jan. 26, 1904, and June 15,
      1906) ......                     .----------.              10,000.00
                                                           ..........
    March 3, 1905 (allotment May 26, 1906)..............         12, 725.40
    March 2, 1907 (allotment Sept. 16, 1907).............. 17, 000. 00
                                                       519, 075.40
    November 28, 1902, returned to Treasury.............1, 000. 00
                                                                                $518, 075. 40
For projects of 1902 and 1907:
    June 13, 1902......................................        75, 000. 00
    March 3, 1903.......................................      100, 000.00
    March 3, 1905 ......................................       75, 000.00
    March 3, 1905 (allotment May 26, 1906) .............       27, 274. 60
    June 30, 1906......................................        46, 000. 00
    March 2, 1907 (allotment Sept. 16, 1907).............. 36, 000. 00
    March 2, 1907...................................          200, 000. 00
    May 27, 1908 ........ .........................      ....  65, 000. 00
    March 4, 1909.....................................        200, 000.00
                                                                                 824, 274.60

      Total......................................................              1, 342, 350.00
    June 30, 1909, received to date from sale of maps................          .       108.95

      Total................................          ......................    1,342,458.95



                                CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

  Name of contractor: P. Sanford Ross (Incorporated).
  Date of contract: November 12, 1904.
  Date of approval: November 26, 1904.
  Date of commencement: March 1, 1905.
  Date of completion: April 9, 1908; time of completion waived.
  Dredging about 707,000 cubic yards of material, at 19.8 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement, at a rate of not less than 25,000 cubic yards per month.
  Contract completed: December 5, 1908.
  Name of contractor: The International Contracting Company.
  Date of contract: November 14, 1906.
  Date of approval: November 20, 1906.
  Date of commencement: March 1, 1907.
  Date of completion: March 31, 1908; time of completion waived.
  Dredging 157,600 cubic yards of material, more or less, at 25 cents per cubic yard,
scow measurement.
  Contract completed: July 8, 1908.
  Name of contractor: Midland Land and Improvement Company.
  Date of contract: August 12, 1907.
  Date of approval: August 27, 1907.
  Date of commencement: August 28, 1907.
  Date of completion: Indefinite; dependent upon appropriations.
  Dredging about 4,177,110 cubic yards of material, at 161 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement.
      9001-ENG 1909--70
1106                     REPORT                  OF         THE CHIEF                           OF ENGINEERS,                         U.     S.     ARMY.

                                                                      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                   Freight received and shipped by water, 1908.


                                                                  Articles.                                                                 Short tons.             Estimated
                                                                                                                                                                      value.


Brick........................................................                                                                                     257,015.4          $1,855,700
Coal .......................................................................                                                                      233,207.5              888,845
Chemicals and colors...                                       ...........................................                                          71,265.6          12, 762,496
Cement, plaster, etc.......................................................                                                                        85,173.8              573,446
Grain. ........................................................                                                                                    17,822.6              435,790
Fertilizer...                  ...........................                                                  .................                      66,357.8           1,638,632
General merchandise...                                          ..........................................                                        290,592.9         113,600,760
Lumber......................................................                                                                                      216,566.6           3,110,122
Oils...                   .......................................................                                                                  51,551.3           1,366,703
Ores and metals...                                      ..............................................                                            146,121.9          29,870,327
Stone and sand............................                                                                 ..................                     358,873.7           3,052,262
Miscellaneous ..............................................................                                                                      196,880.3           1,727,239
To and from the Hackensack River. .........................................                                                                       119,529.8              730,378
           Total...............................................................                                                            a 2,110,959.2             171,612,700

                             a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.

Statement showing number of vessels of all kinds, by months, passing through the Newark
  Bay drawbridge of the Central Railroad Company of New Jersey for the year ending
  December 31, 1908.
        [Furnished by Mr. Joseph O. Osgood, Chief Engineer, Central Railroad Company of New Jersey.]


                                 Month.                                           Steamers.               Schooners.            Barges.    Sloops.        Launches.       Total.


January................................                                                    1,218                         14         663         17                1         1,913
February..............................                                                        411                         2         218         15 ............               646
March.................................                                                     1,044                         10         706         24               18         1,802
April..................................                                                    1,158                         46         831         62               74         2,171
May ....................................                                                   1,299                         66         876        126              396         2,763
June....................................                                                     376                         77         934        232              985         2,604
July...................................                                                    1,718                         97       1,037        272            1,406         4,530
August................................                                                     1,757                         69       1,139        276            1,486         4,727
September............................                                                      1,499                         70       1,076        242            1,022         3,909
October...                 ..........................                                      1,432                         63       1,161        156              538         3,350
November....1............                             ........                             1,299                         44       1,058         83              130         2,614
December...............................                                                    1,339                         61       1,083         53               50         2,586
            Total............................                                             14,550                       619       10,782     1,558               6,106      33,615


Statement showing number of vessels of all kinds, by months, passing through the Passaic
  River drawbridge of the Central Railroad Company of New Jersey for the year ending
  December 31, 1908.
        [Furnished by Mr. Joseph O. Osgood, Chief Engineer, Central Railroad Company of New Jersey.]


                         Month.                                    Steamers.             Schooners.               Barges.        Sloops.   Launches.           Rafts.     Total.


January.........................                                          1,299                         22              739          23                   6        11      2,100
February.......................                                             350                          6               189          6                   1 ....             552
March..........................                                           1,300                         21              810          43                   1         2      2,177
April...........................                                          1,831                         54              935          59    ..........              17      2,896
May............................                                           1,905                         59            1,128          82                  56        11      3,241
June...........................                                           2,009                         80            1,426         104                 106         7      3,732
July............................                                          2,347                         96            1,721         143                 267         2      4,576
August..........................                                          2,096                         64            1,510         123                 179 ........       3,972
September......................                                           1,831                         67            1,245         136                 123          1     3,403
October.........................                                          1,848                         78            1,467         119                  89          3     3,604
November.....................                                             1,720                         73            1,373          87                  23          5     3,281
December.......................                                           1,699                         79            1,172          60                  11          5     3,026
            Total......................                                  20,235                        699            13,715         985                 862        64     36,560
                  APPENDIX G-REPORT OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                                                             1107
Statement showing number of vessels of all kinds, by months, passing through the Hacken-
  sack River drawbridge of the Central Railroad Company of New Jersey for the year
  ending December 31, 1908.
    [Furnished by Mr. Joseph O. Osgood, Chief Engineer, Central Railroad Company of New Jersey.]



         Month.             Steamers.    Schooners.        Barges.     Sloops.        Launches.           Rafts.        bCat         Total.
                                                                                                                        boats.

January................          312                   9       252            3 ............                        3   ........         579
February...............           41 .............              36 ..................................                                     77
March..................          281                   5       274            2 ............................                             562
April. ..................        335                  26       265          17 ............................                              643
May ....................         358                  54       275          19                     360              7           3      1,076
June....................         351                  62       167          33                     461             16          19      1,109
July ....................        313                  71       165          52                     795             20          26      1,442
August.................          284                  37       157          66                     793             11          39      1,387
September..............          336                  47       175          34                     540             12          22      1,166
October................          349                  33       244          30                     410              4          15      1,085
November..............           292                  28       190            8                       94           11           4        627
December..............           232                  30       115            2....................                             2        381
      Total.............        3,484                402     2,315           266              3,453                84      130        10,134


  The commerce is carried on in sail and steam vessels, canal boats, and barges draw-
ing from 5 to 16 feet.
  The following statement of commerce entered at the United States custom-house,
port of Newark, has been furnished through the courtesy of the collector of customs,
Newark, N. J.
                             Vessels entered and cleared.

                                                                       Foreign.                         Domestic.                   Tonnage
                                                                                      -tax                                              col-
                                                               Entered.         Cleared.        Entered.            Cleared.        lected.


Year ended June 30,1908............................                     76              114                    6           1         $434.96
8 months ended Feb. 28, 1909......................                      41               60                    0           0          267.63



                                                 Value of exports.




                                                 Value oJ imports.
1108                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                   S. ARMY.

                                                                            G 2.

IMPROVEMENT OF ARTHUR KILL, OR STATEN ISLAND SOUND, NEW
  YORK AND NEW JERSEY, AND CHANNEL BETWEEN STATEN ISLAND
  AND NEW JERSEY.

                                 (A) ARTHUR KILL, OR STATEN ISLAND SOUND.

   Detailed descriptions of this waterway and the projects for its
improvement are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Eng-
neers for 1900, pages 178 and 1525 to 1530, and a condensed history
is contained in current summary.
                                OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the fiscal year dredging was in progress, under
contract of William H. Taylor, at which time a total of 2,373,622
cubic yards of material had been removed. Dredging under this
contract was continued during the year. The work was carried on
continuously without special interruption due to winter weather.
  The amount of material dredged during the fiscal year was 593,926
cubic yards, the work by months being as follows:

                                  1908.                              Material.                                   1909.                   Material.


                                                                     Cu. yds.I                                                           Cu. yds.
July ........         ...........................                     116,243    January..............................                     30,905
August ................                             ........   ...   113, 639    February. ..                .......................       22, 575
September ...                   .......................                81,688    March...                 ..........................       23,058
October ................................                               52,043    April...................................                  19,464
November .............................                                 28, 496   May...................................                    36,574
December .............................                                 36,798    June..................................                    32, 443



   The material was mud, sand, gravel, and clay, and it was mostly
dumped at sea; the remainder was used for filling at Governors
Island. One to three dredges have been employed on the work.
The amount and locations of work done during the year, as well as
that done under the contract to date, are shown in the table.
   This improvement is now open to navigation at low water for
vessels drawing 18 to 20 feet. Depths of about 18 to 22 feet and
widths of about 300 feet at mean low water have been made through
the entire length of the waterway to be dredged. Sections of the
channel dredged between Shooters Island and Chelsea Island have
shoaled and require redredging, particularly that section running
south of Corner Stake light. The redredging is now in progress. A
section near the Baltimore and Ohio bridge requires some rock
removal on the west quarter of the channel, but the east part of the
channel is completed, and vessels mostly use the east opening of the
bridge draw, which is 200 feet in width.
                     APPENDIX G-REPORT OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                                             1109
Table showing progress of dredging in Arthur Kill upon contract in force, and parts of
  sections dredged and completed under the project of June 13, 1902, for a channel 300 feet
  wide and 21 feet deep at mean low water.

             Sectional description.
                                                      Amount
                                                      dredged     Total               Propor-
            Continuous.                               in fiscal amount                 tion of
                                                     year end-  dredged               sections              Remarks.
                                                                 under                  com-
                                             Length. ing June contract.                pleted.
Sec-             Location.                           30, 1909.
tion.

                                               Yards.       Cu. yds.     Cu. yds.     Per cent.
   1  Shooters Island to a point                1, 450     ........       475,325           85     Dredged full    length   and
       600 feet east of Corner                                                                      width and      nearly   full
        Stake light.                                                                                depth.
   2 Thence to a point near                      1,833........            748, 430          93        Do.
       Staten Island ferryslip-
       Elizabethport.
   3  Thence to Baltimore and                    1,350 ..........         171, 579          55     Dredged full length and 200
       Ohio R. R. bridge.                                                                           to 300 feet width.
   4 Thence to a point near                      1,100          9,213     118, 249         100     Completed.
       wharf of National Tran-
       sit Co.
   5 Thence to a point 450 feet                     933       43, 069      92, 612         100        Do.
       below Buckwheat Is-
       land.
    6 Thence to center of Chel-                  1, 667      192,071      310, 357         100        Do.
        sea Island.
    7 Thence to a point 1,000 feet               1,667       179, 452     331, 376         100        Do.
        above Rahway River.
    8 Thence to a point near                     1,667        51,508      218,137           90 Dredged full        length   and
        Carteret.                                                                               depth and          nearly    full
                                                                                                width.
   9 Thence to a point near                      1, 667      118, 673     211, 503         100 Completed.
      Fresh Kills.
  10 Thence to a point near                      3,000                                             Section has natural required
      Port Reading.                                                                                 depth.
  11 Thence to a point near                      2, 333                   289,980          100 Completed.
      Sewaren (Story's flats).
               Total..............              18, 667      593,926    2,967, 548.


   Channel from Kill van Kull to section 1, length 600 yards, has required depth.
   Channel from section 11 to Raritan Bay, length 6,000 yards, has required depth.
                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement................................... $30, 000
   For maintenance of improvement...........................        10, 000
                                                                                                                       $40, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                     APPROPRIATIONS.
For present project:
    June 13, 1902......................................                                           $100, 000.00
    March 3, 1903........................................                                          150, 000.00
    March 3, 1905........................................                                           70, 000.00
    June 30, 1906......................................                                             50, 000.00
    March 4, 1907.......................................                                            85,000.00
    March 4, 1909.........................................                                         150, 000.00
                                                                                                                  $605, 000.00
June 30, 1909, received to date from sale of maps.....................                                                   22.80
        Total........................................................                                              605,022.80
 1110                    REPORT                  OF THE                    CHIEF OF                          ENGINEERS,                        U.     S.     ARMY.


                                                                       CONTRACT                         IN      FORCE.

  Name of contractor: William H. Taylor.
  Date of contract: October 14, 1903.
  Date of approval: October 27, 1903.
  Date of commencement: November 28, 1903.
  Date of completion: Indefinite; dependent upon appropriations.
  Dredging about 3,535,000 cubic yards of material, at 14.8 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement.


                                                                 COMMERCIAL                               STATISTICS.

                                                   Freight received and shipped by water, 1907.
[Statement by the Hon. Peter Bonnett, of Elizabeth, N. J., chairman of the joint waterways committee.]

                                                                                                                                                     Tons.
                                                         Articles.                                                                                                            Estimated
                                                                                                                                                                                value.
                                                                                                                                       Received.            Shipped.


Coal..........................................................................                                                                               7,664,929        $27,809,291
Ores and metals.........                                   ..........................................                                        115,603           119,077         52,950,000
Clay products.....................................................                                                                            28,366            73,727            579,294
Chemicals and fertilizers...........................................                                                                         159,042           104,128          4,815,022
Oils...............................................................                                                                           15,677            26,671          1,211,194
Machinery and manufactures......................                                                                 .......................
                                                                                                                              ...             74,104            63, 692        11,343,759
General merchandise............................................                                                                              291,006            52,158          3,681,993
           Total........................................................                                                                     683,798   8,104,382              102,390,553
                                                                                                                                           8,104,382...................

           Grand total...........................                                                ................                          8,788,180 ........                 ...........


                                                   Freight received and shipped by water, 1908.

                                                                                                                                              Short tons.
                                                     Articles.                                                                                                                Estimated
                                                                                                                                                                               value.
                                                                                                                                 Received.                 Shipped.


Coal........................................................                                 ..............                                                8,584,720. 5       $27,809,291
Ores and metals..............................................                                        129,475.4                                               133,366. 2        52,950,000
Clay products.................................................                                         31,769.9                                               82,574.2            579,294
Chemicals and fertilizers......................................                                      178,127.0                                               116,623.4          4,815,022
Oils..........................................................                                         17,558.2                                               29,871.5          1,211,194
Machinery and manufactures..................................                                           82,996.5                                               71,335.0         11,343,759
General merchandise..........                              .................................         325,926. 7                                               58, 416.9         3,681,993

           Total....................................................                                                               765, 853. 7    9,076, 907.7                102, 390, 553
                                                                                                                                 9,076, 907. 7 ....................
           Grand total............................                                     ...................                     a9,842,761.4           ..      ...       ............

                            a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.

  To the above must be added the commerce of the tributaries passing through the
Arthur Kill, amounting to 6,152,470 tons, valued at $137,004,560, making a grand
total of 15,995,231 tons, estimated value of $239,395,113, received and shipped.
                                                              Vessels engaged in above commerce.

                                                                                      Class.                                                    Number.              Draft
                                                                                                                                                                     when         Tonnage.
                                                                  Class.                                                                        of trips,           loaded.



                                                                                                                                                                     Feet.
Steamers..............................................................    11,893 5J-22 20-2,200
Sailvessels.............................................................. 19,965 5 -16 30-2,000
Barges..................................................                  81,078 5 -12 75- 500
Power boats............................................................. 100,000 1-6    1- 25

           Total........................................                                                .................                           212,936                       ..........
                   APPENDIX G-REPORT OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                                         1111
        (B) CHANNEL BETWEEN STATEN ISLAND AND NEW JERSEY.
   Detailed descriptions of this waterway and of the projects for its
improvement are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1897, pages 1130 to 1132, and a condensed history
is contained in the current summary.
                    OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

  No work upon this improvement was done during the fiscal year.
The project is completed. Maintenance dredging is usually required
every second year.
  The last work done was finished in August, 1906, at which time
the channel had the full projected dimensions of 400 feet width and
14 feet depth at mean low water.
                                   Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
  of improvement---------------------------------------------................................................... $20,000.00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                              APPROPRIATIONS.

June 23, 1874................. $50, 000                        July 13, 1892 a..................                 $5,000
August 14, 1876............        10, 000                     July 13, 1892...................                  15, 000
June 18, 1878.    ........   ..... 15, 000                     August 18, 1894 a................                  4, 500
June 14, 1880..................    29,000                      August 18, 1894.................                   6, 000
August 2, 1882..............       40, 000                     June 3, 1896 b..................                  13, 000
July 5,1884.................       10, 000                     March 3, 1899...................                  32, 000
August 5, 1886..............       15, 000                     June 13, 1902 b.................                  10, 000
August 11, 1888 a ..........       10, 000                     March 3, 1905...................                  10, 000
August 11, 1888.................   15, 000
September 19, 1890 a...........     7,000                               Total....................               311, 500
September 19, 1890............. 15, 000

                                       COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  This is a connecting channel, and the commerce includes part of that of Arthur
Kill, part of Raritan Bay and its tributaries, and about 25 per cent of the Passaic
River, and the information received is insufficient to make a statement of the ton-
nage and value of the commerce.
                                                  LEMON CREEK.

  The following commercial statistics for the year 1907 were furnished by Messrs.
Philip De Waters, John Van Wyk, and A. G. Marscher:
   Oysters, value, $325,000; clams, $35,000; coal, lime, cement, sand, etc., $75,000.
Number of vessels, 50 to 75; draft, 32 to 6 feet; tonnage, 10 to 100. In the fishing
season from 25 to 50 boats use the creek daily for anchorage. Valuation of boats
that navigate the creek, $145,000.

  a Appropriation for improving Arthur Kill, New York and New Jersey-removal
of Steep Point.
  b Includes $5,000 for Lemon Creek.
1112            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                 G 3.
             IMPROVEMENT OF WOODBRIDGE CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

    Detailed descriptions of this creek and of the projects for its
improvement                  are printed in                   the Annual Report of the Chief of
Engineers for 1900, page 1552, and a condensed history is con-
tained in the current summary.

                       OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

  No work upon this improvement was done during the fiscal year.
Project for the expenditure of the allotment of $6,000 from the
appropriation made by the river and harbor act approved March
3, 1909, was submitted on March 16 and approved on March 19.
Specifications for maintenance dredging were prepared, and ap-
proved on May 7. The work was advertised on May 22 and pro-
posals were opened on June 8. The bid of John & Joseph McSpirit,
the lower of two bids received, to do the work at 28 cents per cubic
yard, scow measurement, was accepted by approval of the Chief
of Engineers dated June 24, and preparation of contract was
commenced.
                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
  improvement ..........................................................    $6,000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                         APPROPRIATIONS.
For previous project:
    March 3, 1879------------------------------------------.................................................      $4,000
    June 14, 1880-------------------------------------------................................................       5,000
    March 3, 1881-------------------------------------------.................................................      5, 000
    August 2, 1882------------------------------------------................................................       5, 000
                                                                                                                            $19, 000
For present project:
    June 13, 1902...........................................-------------------------------------------..         10,000
    April 28, 1904 (allotment for survey, Sept. 1, 1904)----------                     ............--         -       250
    April 28, 1904 (allotment Nov. 18, 1904)--------------------.......................-                           7, 500
    March 3, 1905-------------------------------------------.................................................      6, 000
    M arch 2, 1907.................................................                                               19,000
    March 3, 1909 (allotment Mar. 19, 1909).........................                                               6, 000
                                                                                                                             48, 750

          Total for both projects............................................                                               67,750
                              APPENDIX G-REPORT OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                                                                                1113
                                                                      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                Freight received and shipped by water, 1908.

                                                     [Statement by merchants located on the creek.]

                                                                                                                                          Short tons.           Estimated
                                                                 Articles.                                                                                       value.


Received:
   Tin scrap..............................................................                                                                  17,920.0                $220,000
   Coal...............................................................24,640.0                                                                                        62,000
   Manure...                     .....................................................                                                            996. 8                 801
   Clay...--------------------------------------------------------20,160.0                                                                                            45,000
      Sawdust....                             ..-----------------------------------------------------                                           1,568.0                 4,000
      Stone..........               ....................................................                                                    15,579.2                  40,794
Shipped:
      Steel scrap---------------------------------------------------................................................................        11,200.0                 120,000
      Clay products------------------------------------------------------50,018. 24                                                                                  271,453
      Clay products........
      Clay...                                .....................................................                                             038.924
                                                                                                                                            2150,
                                                                                                                                            21,017. 92               271,6453
                                                                                                                                                                      27, 652

          Total....................................................                                                                      a163,120.16                 791,700

                        a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.

                                                            Vessels engaged in above commerce.


                                                                                                                                  Number           Draft
                                                                                     Class.of                                          trips.            hen       Tonnage.
                                                                                                                                                  loaded.

                                                                                                                                                    Feet.
Steamers...............................................................                                                                   606         5- 9         100- 200
Sail vessels..............................................................                                                                228            5-12       17- 345
Barges-------------------------------------------------------..................................................................           419            4-12      110-1,200

          Total...................................................                                                ...........          1,253.       ..     .- ..    ......


                                                                                               G 4.

                            IMPROVEMENT OF RARITAN BAY, NEW JERSEY.
  Detailed description of this bay and of the projects for its improve-
ment are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1897, pages 1142 and 1143, and a condensed history is contained in
the current summary.

                                OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   Dredging for maintenance, under contract with P. Sanford Ross
 (Incorporated), was in progress at the beginning of the fiscal year, at
which time 57,054 cubic yards of material had been removed. The
work was continued to August 1, when the contract was completed.
The amount of material mud and sand-removed during the fiscal
year was 48,936 cubic yards, which was dredged from the South
Amboy channel, restoring areas in same of 800 by 50, 1,600 by 50,
500 by 50, 2,100 by 100, and 1,100 by 50 feet between Great Beds
light and South Amboy wharves. The total amount removed under
the contract was 105,990 cubic yards, of which 26,974 yards were
removed from the Seguine Point channel, and the remainder, 79,016
yards, from the South Amboy channel. Approximate areas re-
dredged in Seguine Point channel, 1,000 by 100, 2,000 by 50, and 700
1114             REPORT OF THE CHIEF                                       OF ENGINEERS,   UT. S. ARMY.

by 100 feet, and in South Amboy channel, 4,300 by 50, 1,600 by 50,
500 by 50, 2,100 by 100, and 1,100 by 50 feet, with depths of 21 to 22
feet at mean low water. The excavated material was dumped at sea.
The plant employed consisted of one clam-shell dredge, one tugboat,
and several scows.
   Project for the expenditure of the allotment of $20,000 from the
appropriation made by the river and harbor act approved March 3,
1909, was submitted on March 16 and approved on March 19. This
project provides for making an examination of the dredged channels
and in dredging for maintenance. The examination has been made
and platted. As shoaling had been observed recently, the examina-
tion was carried across the reach between deep water south of Wards
Point and south of Princes Bay light. The examination shows that
the depths in this reach, which is about a mile in length, have shoaled
to from 19 to 20 feet, so that dredging through this reach is now
required in order to provide a channel of 21 feet depth through to
Perth Amboy and South Amboy. Specifications for dredging for
maintenance were in preparation at the close of the year.
                                           Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
   provem ent...........................................................                                         $40,000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                           APPROPRIATIONS.
Total appropriations to December 31, 1902 (see H. Doc. No. 421, 57th
  Cong., 2d sess., p. 288)................................................. $487, 500
M arch 3, 1905............................................................    50,000
M arch 2, 1907...........................................................     25,000
March 3, 1909 (allotment March 19, 1909).................................     20, 000
      Total-----------------.......................................------------------......----------.........   582, 500
June 30, 1909, received to date from sale of maps..........................                                             3

          Total.........................................................                                         582,503



                                                      CONTRACT IN FORCE.

   Name of contractor: P. Sanford Ross (Incorporated).
   Date of contract: April 25, 1908.
   Date of approval: May 5, 1908.
Date of commencement: May 22, 1908.
Date of completion: November 21, 1908.
Dredging about 105,263 cubic yards of material at 20.9 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement.
Contract completed: August 1, 1908.
                              APPENDIX G-REPORT OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                                                      1115
                                                                    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                  Freightreceived and shipped by water, 1908.
[Statement furnished through the courtesy of the Hon. D. C. Chase, and the collector of customs of the
                                    port of Perth Amboy, N. J.]


                                                             Articles.                                         Short tons.         Estimated
                                                                                                                                    value.


Received:
   Iron ore....                                ..................................................                  18,797. 0           $626, 547
   Asphalt...                                ...................................................                   51,265 8             143, 683
   Wire rods...                            ....................................................                        453 6             30,375
   Ammunition...                               ..................................................                       63.8             50, 600
   Sand....................................................................                                            145.6                 124
   Lumber...                             .....................................................                         835 5             15,445
   Bullion...........................................................                                              64,960.0          46,000,000
   Phosphate rock ..........................................................                                        3, 356. 6             8,500
    Plaster rock..... .........................................................                                     3,113.6               5,628
Shipped:
    Fireproofing...                                  ...............................................               23, 506. 6             94, 446
    Coal.....................................................................                                  5, 410, 963.0         19, 324,868
    Sand....                           ......................................................                          937.4                  795
    Clay.........................................................                                                   5,230.4               11,675
    Machinery.....                      ......................................................                          20.2               1, 530
    Refined lead and copper . . .                              ........................................            56, 000. 0        20, 000, 000
    Total....................................................5,639,649.1                                                             86,314,216
Commerce of South River, Raritan River, Cheesequake Creek, Keyport Harbor,
   Matawan Creek, and a small per cent of Arthur Kill that passes through
   Raritan Bay............................................................                                      3,090,099.0          50,235,899

           Total.................................................................                             a 8, 729, 748.1      136, 550,115

                          a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.

                                                             Vessels engaged in above commerce.

                                                                Class.                                    Number        Draft
                                                                                                           .oftrips,    when           Tonnage.
                                                                                                                   S   loaded.


                                                                                                                        Feet.
Steamers................................................................                                    2,709       54-22             25-2,200
Sail vessels.............................................................                                  19,020       2 -16              6- 500
Barges................................................................                                      3,911       1 -12             60- 700
Power boats............................................................                                    25, 600      1 - 7              1-   25
           Total..............................................................                              51,240..       ............



                                                                                           G5.
IMPROVEMENT OF KEYPORT HARBOR, MATAWAN CREEK, RARITAN,
  SOUTH, AND ELIZABETH RIVERS, SHOAL HARBOR AND COMPTON
  CREEK, AND CHEESEQUAKE CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

                                                                     (A) KEYPORT HARBOR.

  Detailed descriptions of this harbor and of the project for its
improvement are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of En-
gineers for 1897, pages 1147 to 1149, and a condensed history is
contained in the current summary.
1116          REPORT OF THiE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                          U.   S.   ARMY.

                        OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

   At the beginning of the fiscal year a contract dated June 20,
and approved June 29, 1907, was in force for the removal of about
20,000 cubic yards of material at 40 cents per cubic yard. Dredging
was commenced on July 9, and continued to August 3, when the
required amount of the contract was reported as removed. The
dumping basin was cleaned up as required, and after an examination
had been made of the dredged areas the contract was considered
as completed on August 26, 1908.
   The total amount of material removed under the contract was
19,878 cubic yards, and the total work done in restoration of the
channel consisted in making six cuts, each 30 feet wide, and 270,
500, 630, 740, 400, and 1,200 feet in length respectively, with depth
of 8 to 9 feet at mean low water between the Keyport steamboat
dock and the old wharf of the New York and Freehold Railroad.
The work done sufficed to restore the channel for about one-half
its length to width of about 100 feet and depth of 8 feet at mean
low water. The remaining half of channel has a depth of about
7 feet at mean low water. The material dredged (mud) was disposed
of by dumping it in a basin in Matawan Creek and pumping it ashore
on the south side of the creek below the turnpike bridge at Keyport.
The plant employed consisted of one bucket dredge, one pump
dredge, a tugboat and two dump scows, several pontoons, pipe
lines, etc.
   Project for the expenditure of the allotment of $5,000 from the
appropriation made by the river and harbor act approved March 3,
1909, was submitted on March 16 and approved on March 25, 1909.
Maintenance dredging was advertised on May 22, and proposals were
opened on June 8. The bid of John & Joseph McSpirit, the lower of
two bids received, to do the work at 28 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement, was accepted by approval of the Chief of Engineers
dated June 24. At the close of the year the preparation of a contract
for the work was in progress.
                                      Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
    For works of improvement....................................                     $9, 975
    For maintenance of improvement.............................                      10,000
                                                                                               $19, 975
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                   APPROPRIATIONS.
August 2,1882.............------------------------------------------------- $30, 475. 00
July 13, 1892.......---------------------------------------------------5,000.00
August 18, 1894.....------------.-------------------------------------5,000.00
June 3, 1896...----------------------------------------------------2,500.00
March 3, 1899.....---------------------------------------------------2,500. 00
June 13, 1902 (allotment Aug. 1, 1902)...----------------------------5,000. 00
June 13, 1902 (allotment May 31, 1904)........----------5,                       000.00
March 3, 1905 (allotment Aug. 12, 1905)---------....---.                      5, 000. 00
March 2, 1907 (allotment Mar. 20, 1907)..........................8,              705. 97
March 3, 1909 (allotment Mar. 25, 1909)..........................5,              000. 00

       Total........................................................                        74, 180. 97
                               APPENDIX G-REPORT OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                                                                                  1117

                                                                CONTRACT                   IN     FORCE.

  Name of contractor: J. M. Briggs.
  Date of contract: June 20, 1907.
  Date of approval: June 29, 1907.
  Date of commencement: May 18, 1908.
  Date of completion: August 17, 1908.
  Dredging about 20,000 cubic yards of material, at 40 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement. This contract also includes dredging in Matawan Creek, Raritan River,
and Shoal Harbor and Compton Creek, New Jersey.
  Contract completed August 3, 1908.


                                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                             Freight received and shipped by water, 1908.
[Statement by the New York and New Jersey Steamboat Company, and merchants located on the harbor.


                                                            Articles.                                                                   Short tons.            Estimated
                                                                                                                                                                 value.


Received:
    Oysters ...                        ....................................................                                                    5,908.0                 $365,000
   Coal.....---------------------------------------------------------                                                                         18,032. 0                  90,500
    General m erchandise....................... ...............................                                                               19,208.0                  681,500
    Fertilizer....-----------------------------------------------------..                                                                     19,600.0                   39,375
Shipped:
    Oysters-------------------------------------------------------...................................................................          4,648.0                  190,000
    Farm produce............................................................                                                                  33,952.8                1,633,960
    Fish and shellfish................. ........................................                                                              11,200. 0                 100,000
   Salt hay.................................................................                                                                   1,008.0                    8, 200
    Total........... -............................... ........................                                                               113,556.8                3,108,535
Commerce from Matawan Creek that passes through Keyport Harbor .........                                                                      10.167.4                   38,265

          Total-           -        -         --...................   ..................              .................                  a 123,724. 2                 3,146,800

                        a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.

                                                       Vessels engaged in above commerce.
                                                                                                                                 Number            Draft

                                                          Class.                                                                 of trips.        Iwhen               Tonnage.
                                                                                                                                                 loaded.


                                                                                                                                                    Feet.
Steamers......................                            .....................            ....-----------.....  .........          1,218            52- 9               20-200
Sailvessels----------------------------------------------------...............................................................        462            4 -13               15-150
Barges...--------                 ...-----------------------------------------------                                                  587            4- 7               100-500
Powerboats......................................................2,200                                                                                5                   20

          Total                --------------------------------------------------                                                   4467...........................
                                                                                                                                    4.467



                                                               (B)       MATAWAN                   CREEK.


  Detailed description of this creek and of the project for its improve-
ment are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1897, page 1145, and a condensed history is contained in the current
summary.
                               OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

  Dredging under contract was in progress at the beginning of the
year, when the amount of material removed was 1,258 cubic yards.
Work was continued to August 9, when the dredging was reported
as completed. It was found necessary to redredge the dumping
basin, also portions of the river near the basin which had been
1118            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                        U. S. ARMY.

shoaled by the operations of the pump. The work was finally accepted
on August 26. The amount of material, mud and sand, dredged during
the fiscal year was 7,036 cubic yards. Two cuts, each 30 feet wide,
one 450 feet and the other 600 feet in length, were made on the south
side of the channel, extending upstream from steamboat wharf, Key-
port, and two cuts, each 30 feet wide and 390 and 460 feet in length,
respectively, were made opposite and extending just below the wharf
of the Pennsylvania Clay Company above Winkson Creek. The depth
made was from 4 to 6 feet at mean low water.
   The total amount of material removed under this contract was
8,294 cubic yards, and the total work accomplished consisted in
making one cut 900 feet and one cut 450 feet long, each 30 feet wide
and about 5 feet deep, on the south side of the channel, extending
upstream from the Keyport steamboat dock, and in making two cuts
each about 30 feet wide and 390 and 460 feet in length, respectively,
opposite and just below the wharf of the Pennsylvania Clay Com-
pany. The material was disposed of by dumping it in a basin in the
river and pumping it ashore on the south side of the creek below the
turnpike bridge at Keyport. The plant employed consisted of one
bucket dredge, one pump dredge for disposal of material, two dump
scows, a tugboat, several pontoons, pipe lines, etc.
   Project for the expenditure of the allotment of $3,000 from the
appropriation made by the river and harbor act approved March 3,
1909, was submitted on March 16, and approved March 20, 1909.
The work of dredging for maintenance was advertised on May 22,
and proposals were opened on June 8. The bid of John & Joseph
McSpirit, the only bid received, to do the work at 28 cents per cubic
yard, scow measurement, was accepted by approval of the Chief of
Engineers dated June 24. At the close of the fiscal year the prepa-
ration of a contract for this work was in progress.
                                    Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement---------------------------................................... $12,120
   For maintenance of improvement.....................................                      6,000
                                                                                                                   $18,120
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                APPROPRIATIONS.
March 3, 1881--------------------------------------------.........................................................  $15,000.00
August 2, 1882---------------------------------------------........................................................   6,000.00
September 19, 1890....................................................                                                2, 500.00
July 13, 1892......................................................----------------------------------------------..   9, 620.00
August 18, 1894..............--------------------------------------------3, 000.00
June 3, 1896.....----------------------------------------------3,000. 00
March 3, 1899...........---------------------------------------------3,000.00
June 13, 1902 (allotment Aug. 1, 1902)----------------------------.................................                   3,000.00
June 13, 1902 (allotment May 31, 1904)..................................                                              3,000.00
March 3, 1905 (allotment Aug. 12, 1905)....                                            .                              3,000.00
March 2, 1907 (allotment Mar. 20, 1907)."...........--                                ....-- .        .......         6,000.00
March 3, 1909 (allotment Mar. 20, 1909).................................                                              3,000.00
     Total..........................................................                                            60,120. 00
January 3, 1905, returned to Treasury....................................                                          315. 61
         Balance.......................................................                                         59, 804.39
                              APPENDIX G--REPORT OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                                                               1119

                                                                   CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Name of contractor: J. M. Briggs.
Date of contract: June 20, 1907.
Date of approval: June 29, 1907.
Date of commencement: June 18, 1908.
Date of completion: August 17, 1908.
Dredging about 8,333 cubic yards of material, at 60 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement. This contract also includes dredging in Keyport Harbor, Raritan
River, and Shoal Harbor and Compton Creek, New Jersey.
    Contract completed: August 9, 1908.



                                                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                Freight received and shipped by water, 1908.
                                                [Statement furnished by the New Jersey Company.]


                                                                Articles.                                                     Short tons.        Estimated
                                                                                                                                                   value.


Received:
   Coal................                                                                      ...........................            6,720.0          $19,800
Shipped:
   Clay products...................                                   ...    ..............................                         3,447. 4          18, 465
          Total.........................................................                                                           10,167.4           38,265

                           a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.

                                                           Vessels engaged in above commerce.


                                                              Class.                                                   Number         Draft
                                                                            Class.                                         trips      when        Tonnage.
                                                                                                                                     loaded.

                                                                                                                                      Feet.
Sail vessels.............................................................                                                     14          10        100-150
Barges................................................................                                                         4          10        200-300
          Total......................................................                                                         18 I............


                                                                     (C) RARITAN                RIVER.

   Detailed descriptions of this river and of the projects for its
improvement, and revised estimates for its completion, are printed
in the Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, pages 1136
to 1139, and for 1900, page 1505, respectively, and a condensed
history is contained in current summary.
                               OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

  No work was done upon this improvement during the fiscal year.
Project for the expenditure of the allotment of $10,000 from the
appropriation made by the river and harbor act approved March 3,
1909, was submitted on March 16, and approved on March 20.
Specifications for dredging for maintenance of the channels were
prepared and approved on May 7, and the work was advertised on
1120            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

May 22, and proposals were opened on June 8.     The bid of P. Sanford
Ross (Incorporated), the lower of two bids received, to do the work at
30 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement, was accepted by approval
of the Chief of Engineers dated June 24, and preparation of contract
commenced.
                                     Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement-------------------------------................................... $50,000
   For maintenance of improvement..............................                                20, 000
                                                                                                                      $70, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                  APPROPRIATIONS.
For previous project:
    July 4, 1836 a........................................------------------------------------------ $7,000.00
    March 3, 1837 a-----------------------------------------......................................... -6, 963.00
                                                                                                                   $13, 963.00
For present project:
    June 18, 1878------------------------------------......................................... 200, 000.00
    March 3, 1879..........................................                                         60, 000.00
    June 14, 1880------------------------------------......................................... 100,000.00
    March 3, 1881-------------------------------------..........................................    25, 000. 00
    August 2, 1882------------------------------------.........................................     25,000.00
    July 5, 1884--------------------------------------...........................................   35,00000
    August 5, 1886------------------------------------.........................................     26, 250.00
    August 11, 1888-----------------------------------........................................      50,000.00
    September 19, 1890.....................................                                         50, 000.00
    July 13, 1892--------------------------------------..........................................   40,000.00
    August 18, 1894-----------------------------------........................................      20, 000.00
    June 3, 1896--------------------------------------..........................................    20,000.00
    March 3, 1899....------------------------------------- 20, 000.00
    June 13, 1902 (allotment Aug. 1, 1902)---------------..................-- 20, 000.00
    March 3, 1905 (allotment Aug. 12, 1905) ............... . . 22, 000.00
    March 2, 1907 (allotment Mar. 20, 1907)---.....                                      .        . 16, 975.42
    March 3, 1909 (allotment Mar. 20, 1909)..................                                       10, 000.00
                                                                                                                   740, 225. 42
     Total..........................................................                                               754,188.42
December 16, 1904, received from sale of condemned property ..........                                                   1.15
                                                             754,189.57
         Total...................................------------------------------

                                         a For New Brunswick Harbor.
                           APPENDIX             G-REPORT                    OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                   1121

                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                           Freight received and shipped by water, 1908.
      [Statement furnished by courtesy of the Hon. D. C. Chase and merchants located on the river.]


                                                  Articles.                                                    Short tons.      Estimated
                                                                                                                                  value.


Products ofthe forest...................................................12,035.5
Products of the mines and quarries......................................                                                   27,770.4
Products of the animals.............................................                                                          386.4
Agricultural         products. ............. ..... ........                                  .... ......... .......... ..     525. 3 2,538,600
Manufactures...                           ..................................................                               14,688.8
Merchandise and miscellaneous...........................................39,113.8
Coal.......................................                                                                                80,461.9    266,306
Copper bars containing silver and gold.....................................7,869.1                                                   2,107,800
Refined copper....................................................                                                         82,469.0 19,144,580
Brick.................................................................                                                ... 221,124.9    612,800
Clay products...............................................................                                              141,441.4    581,962
Clay and sand..............................................................                                               182,528.6    160,729
Oils..............                ...............              ... .........................................                1,495.2    210,000
Wall paper.................................................................                                                 2,421.4    208,700
Miscellaneous................................................................ .                                             4,773.4     97,949

    Total..... . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .                                        819,105.1      25,929,426
Commerce of South River that passesthrough Raritan River...............99,197.3                                                    472,013

       Total.....................                         ..............................              ....      a918,302.4      26,401,439

                       a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.

                                               Vessels engaged in above commerce.


                                                 Class.                                                Number          Draft
                                                              Class.of                                   trips,        when      Tonnage.
                                                                                                                      loaded.


                                                                                            Feet.
Steamers.................................................................             1,114   8-10                                  45-550
Sailvessels...............................................................         .. 1,355   6-14                                  30-500
Barges............----...........---------------------------------------------....... 2,458   6-12                                  60-700

                               ..........................................
      T otal....................                                                                             4,927 ....................
Vessels engaged in commerce of South River..............................                                       353     5- 9   100-500

       Total............................                                                                     5,280.



                                                      (D) SOUTH RIVER.

  Detailed description of this river and of the projects for its improve-
ment are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1897, page 1139, and a condensed history is contained in the current
summary.
                            OPERATIONS              DURING                THE              PAST   FISCAL YEAR.


  No work upon this improvement was done during the fiscal year.
Project for the expenditure of the allotment of $5,000 from the appro-
priation made by the river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909,
was submitted on March 16 and approved on March 26.                                                                       Specifica-
tions for maintenance dredging were prepared and approved on May
7, and the work was advertised on May 22, and proposals were opened
on June 8. The bid of P. Sanford Ross (Incorporated), the lower of
two bids received, to do the work at 30 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement, was accepted by approval of the Chief of Engineers
dated June 24, and preparation of contract was commenced,
           9001-ENG 1909--71
1122                    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                        UJ. S. ARMY.

                                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement................................... $40, 000
   For maintenance of improvement. ...........................      10, 000
                                                                                                                            $50, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                             APPROPRIATIONS.
For previous project:
    March 3, 1871.........................................                                        $15, 000. 00
    March 3, 1873..........................................                                          5, 000. 00
For present project:                                                                                            $20, 000. 00
    June 14, 1880-------------------------------------.........................................    40,000.00
    March 3, 1881----------------------------------..........................................---- 6,000.00
    August 2, 1882.........................................                                        10, 000.00
    August 5, 1886.....................................:...                                          5,000.00
    August 11, 1888------------------------------------........................................      5,000.00
    September 19, 1890---------------------------------.....................................         5, 000. 00
    July 13, 1892--------------------------------------..........................................    7,000.00
    August 18, 1894----------------------------------........................................--      5,000.00
    June 3, 1896..........................................                                           5,000.00
    M arch 3, 1899..........................................                                         5,000.00
    June 13, 1902 (allotment Aug. 1, 1902)..................                                         5, 000. 00
    March 3, 1905 (allotment Aug. 12, 1905)-.................-. 5, 000. 00
    March 2, 1907 (allotment Mar. 20, 1907).................-. 13, 178. 63
    March 3, 1909 (allotment Mar. 25, 1909).................                                         5, 000. 00
                                                                                                                121,178. 63

      Total for both projects.................   ........................                                                141,178. 63
June 30, 1908, received to date from sale of map.......................                                                        1.00

             Total.........................................................                                              141, 179. 63

                                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                  Freight received and shipped by water, 1908.
                                              [Statement by various merchants located on the river.]
                                                                                                                           Estimated
                                                                 Articles.                             Short tons.         Estvalue.

Received:
       Coal....................................................................                           2,644.32            $11,227
       Manure................................................................                            13,174.56             12,949
       Lime....................................................................                                224.00                200
      Iron...................................................................                                   336.00          5,000
       Brick...................................................................                                 112.00          1,000
       Coal dust...............................................................                              1,013.60           1,358
       Glass...................................................................                              2,240.00           8,000
    Miscellaneous...........................................................                                    56.00                500
Shipped:
       Brick....................................................................                         45,995.04            199,605
       Clay products...........................................................                          33,401.76            232,174
          Total.................................................................                        a 99,197.28           472,013

                           a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.

                                                            Vessels engaged in above commerce.

                                                                                                 Number     Draft
                                                                                                     rClass.ips
                                                                                                            when            Tonnage.
                                                                                                          loaded.
                                                                                                                 Feet.
Steamers............................................................                                     4            -5 8 150-200
Sail vessels.............................................................                               50           5-8      100-175
B arges...................................................................                             299           6-9      140-500
          Total.......................353...-.-.-3                                                                       .........
                         APPENDIX G-REPORT OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                        1123
                                                       (E)     ELIZABETH RIVER.

  Detailed description of this river and of the project for its improve-
ment are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1897, pages 1134 and 1185, and a condensed history is contained in
the current summary.
                          OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

  At the beginning of the fiscal year an emergency contract, dated
April 3, as authorized March 28, 1908, was in force with the United
States Fidelity and Guaranty Company, surety on the Morrison
Dredging Company of New Jersey contract, for completion of the
work, at the original contract price of 39 cents per cubic yard, prism
measurement. Dredging under this contract was commenced on
May 22 and was continued to June 17, 1908, when it was suspended
to change plant, and at the close of the fiscal year had not been re-
sumed. The total amount of material (mud and silt) removed was
then 7,322 cubic yards. Dredging under waiver of time limit was
resumed on December 24, 1908, and was continued to February 27,
1909, when the contract was completed. The amount of material
removed during the fiscal year was 10,723.3, and the channel between
Summer Street Bridge and the New York and Long Branch Railroad
bridge was restored to a width of 60 feet for a length of 3,540 feet.
Depth made was from 7 to 8 feet at mean high water.
   The total amount of material (mud and silt) removed under this
contract was 18,045.3 cubic yards, prism measurement, and the
channel was restored to width of 50 feet between South Street and
Summer Street bridges, a distance of 3,230 feet, and to a width of 60
feet between Summer Street Bridge and the New York and Long
Branch Railroad bridge, a distance of 3,540 feet. The material re-
moved was pumped ashore behind bulkhead on the north bank of
the river between Front street and the New York and Long Branch
Railroad. The plant employed on the work consisted of 1 bucket
dredge, 1 pump dredge, 3 scows, 1 tugboat, pontoon, and pipe line.


                                                              APPROPRIATIONS.
March 3, 1879.........................................................                             $7, 500. 00
June 14, 1880........................................................                               7, 500. 00
March 3, 1881.........................................................                              4, 000. 00
August 2, 1882........................................................                              8, 000. 00
September 19, 1890....................................................                              5, 000. 00
July 13, 1892.......................................................                                5, 000. 00
August 18, 1894.......................................................                              3,000. 00
June 3, 1896...............................................                       .   ...   ....    3,160.00
June 13, 1902- (allotment Aug. 1, 1902)..................................                           2,000.00
March 3, 1905 (allotment Aug. 12, 1905).................................                            5,000. 00
March 2, 1907 (allotment Mar. 20, 1907).................................                            9, 784. 45

            Total..........................................................                        59, 944.45
1124                     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                U. S. ARMY.

                                                                    CONTRACTS                         IN FORCE.

   Name of contractor: Morrison Dredging Company, of New Jersey.
   Date of contract: June 18, 1907.
   Date of approval: June 27, 1907.
   Date of commencement: September 10, 1907.
   Date of completion: March 9, 1908.
   Dredging about 20,512 cubic yards of material, at 39 cents per cubic yard, prism
measurement. Contract annulled on March 11, 1908. Final payment made on May
4, 1909.
   Name of contractor: The United States Fidelity and Guaranty Company.
   Date of emergency contract: April 3, 1908.
   Date of commencement: May 22, 1908.
   Date of completion: August 21, 1908. Time limit waived.
   Dredging about 18,040 cubic yards of material, at 39 cents per cubic yard, prism
measurement. Contract completed February 27, 1909.



                                                                     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                    Freightreceived and shipped by water, 1t'08.
                                                [Statement by various merchants located on the river.]


                                                                    Articles.                                                      Short tons.             Estimated
                                                                                                                                                             value.
                                                                                                                                                       i



Rece ived:
     Lumber..................................................................                                                            4,480.0               $36,000
     Brick ...........................................................                                                                   8,786.4                23,705
     land..............................................................                                                                  1,316.0                 1,110
     Diltar................................................................                                                              7,627.2                44,295
   C )il.................................................................
      oal.............................................1,321.6                                                                            1,275.68               17,085
                                                                                                                                                                 4,300:::::
   I Joal. ..                                                                                                                            1,321.6                 4,300
     !cid...                  ...................................................                           ::::::556.64                                         6,200
   AMiscellaneous...                                    ................................................                                    980.0                5,020
Ship ped:
            oaltar..........................................................                                                      3, 423. 84                    27,513
       C
             ..........
           Oil                          .-                                                                                -378.
                                                                                                                         "-....--         56                     5,070
       I Lumber................................................................                                                          1680.0                 20,000
                b:   .............
                :Total
             Total...........................................................             :: :: :: ::r: ::d       .........           31,825.9
                                                                                                                                    a31,825. 9                  20,29000
                                                                                                                                                               19
                                                                                                                                                               190, 298


                             a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.

                                                              Vessels engaged in above commerce.
                                                                                                                                              Draft

                                                                  Class.                                                      ofNumber        when            Tonnage.
                                                                                                                                             loaded.


                                                                                                                                               Feet.
Steamers.............................................................                                                               44           5 -10           50-200
Sail vessels.............................................................                                                          129           41-14           50- 56
Barges........................................................                                                        ....          65           4- 9           100-400
             Total............                               .....................................                                 238 ....................



                                        (F)         SHOAL HARBOR                                     AND   COMPTON           CREEK.


   Detailed descriptions of this locality and of the project for its
improvement are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1897, page 1150, and a condensed history is contained in
the current summary.
                                APPENDIX                       G0-REPORT                        OF       COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                     1125

                                  OPERATIONS                           DURING                  THE          PAST FISCAL         YEAR.


   Nothing in furtherance of this improvement was done during the
fiscal year.
                                                         Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement.......................................     (a)
   For maintenance of improvement................................      (a)
                                                                                                                                                                (a)
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                                           APPROPRIATIONS.

September 19, 1890...................................................                                                                               $5,000.00
July 13, 1892----------------------------------------------------..........................................................                          3,000.00
August 18, 1894........................................................                                                                              3,000.00
June 3, 1896----------------------------------------------------..........................................................                           5,000.00
March 3, 1899---------------------------------------------------..........................................................                           8, 000. 00
June 13, 1902 (allotment Aug. 1, 1902)..................................                                                                             8,000. 00
March 3, 1905 (allotment Aug. 12, 1905)................................                                                                              5, 000.00
March 2, 1907 (allotrent Mar. 20, 1907)..................................                                                                            9, 750. 57

               Total....................                                           ...................             ................                 46, 750. 57


                                                                     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                   Freight received and shipped by water, 1908.
[Statements furnished by Mr. Vernon S. Vail and Capt. Thos. W. Collins, of Port Monmouth, N. J., and
                                  others located on the waterway.]

                                                                   Articles.                                                      Short tons.         Estimated
                                                                                                                                                        value.

Received:
    Coal....................................................................                                                          14,582.40                $65,540
   Fertilizer...                           .................................................                                          10,080.00                 26,500
   Fish and clams....................................................28,000.00                                                                                 225,500
   Brick and lime.....................................................1,344.00                                                                                   7,000
   Manure................................................................                                                               6,720.00                 9,500
   Barrels.................................................................                                                                38.08                 1,020
   Miscellaneous ............................................................                                                             100.80                 1,780
Shipped:
   Fish scrap...............................................................                                                           1,030.40             28,000
   Fish oil ..                    .........................................................                                              504.00             24,700
   Fish and clams.........................................................                                                            19,824.00          1,120,000
   Fish grease.............................................................                                                               39.20                 670

           Total..............................................................                                         ....       a82,262.88             1,510,210

                          a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.

                                                             Vessels engaged in above commerce.

                                                                                    Clas.Number                                            Draft
                                                                                                                                  rClass.ips
                                                                                                                                          when           Tonnage.
                                                                                                                                         loaded.

                                                                                                                                           Feet.
Steamers...                             ...................................................                                       78         5 -7              140-360
Sail vessels ..............................................................                                                   17,100         2 -6                6- 90
Barges..................................................................                                                          61         1 -8              250-600
Power boats............................................................                                                       23, 400        1 -7                1- 25
           Total.......................                                                 ........................              40,639.              .........
  aAt the time the estimates for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, were prepared and submitted to the
Secretary of War no item was included for Shoal Harbor and Compton Creek. After further considera-
tion the district engineer officer has recommended an estimate of appropriation for the year 1911 of
$47,130 toward completing the improvement at this locality and $10,000 for maintenance.
1126                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                   U. S. ARMY.

                                                         (G) CHEESEQUAKE CREEK.

  Detailed descriptions of this waterway and of the projects for its
improvement are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1886, pages 763 to 765, and a condensed history is contained
in current summary.
                              OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

  This improvement was included in the consolidated appropriation
of $23,000 for maintenance work, as set forth in House Document
No. 1462, Sixtieth Congress, second session, made by the river and
harbor act approved March 3, 1909. An allotment of $2,000 was
recommended on March 16, but upon suggestion of the department
of March 20 the recommendation was modified to admit of doing
any required work under the appropriation for emergency work.
Up to the close of the fiscal year the necessity for such work had not
been apparent; therefore no allotment of funds had been requested.
                                                     Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement.................................. $25, 000
   For maintenance of improvement..............................       5, 000
                                                                                                                                 $30, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                APPROPRIATIONS.
June 14, 1880.......................................................                                                          $20, 000.   00
March 3, 1881.........................................................                                                          5, 000.   00
August 2, 1882..........         ..............................................                                                15, 000.   00
March 3, 1905 (allotment Aug. 12, 1905)............                             .................                               5, 000.   00
March 3, 1905 (allotment June 19, 1906).............................                                                            1, 000.   00
March 2, 1907 (allotment Mar. 20, 1907)..............................                                                           3, 604.   96
     Total..........................................................                                                           49, 604. 96
December 27, 1906, returned to Treasury..............................                                                              252. 68
             Balance......................................................                                                     49, 352. 28

                                                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                Freight received and shipped by water, 1908.
      [Statements furnished by Capt. John B. Collins, of Keansburg, N. J., and H. C. Perrine & Son.]


                                                              Articles.                                       Short tons.       Estimated
                                                                                                                                  value.

Received:
      Manure.................................................................                                      7,840. 0          $9,800
      Stone...................................................................                                        840.0               750
Shipped:
   Clay....................................................................                                       45,920.0           68,000
    Sand.....................................................................                                     17,920.0           16,000
    Produce ...................................................................                                    7,000.0          115,000
          Total..............................                                     .....................         a 79, 520. 0       .209,550

                         a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.
                             APPENDIX G-REPORT                                OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                          1127
                                                         Vessels engaged in above commerce.
                                                                                                Number       Draft
                                                           Class.                                     rtrips
                                                                                                         when
                                                                                                            loaded.
                                                                                                                           Tonnage.


                                                                                                              Feet.
Steamers .................................................................                          175          7-8          25-325
Sail vessels.............................................................                            20          6-7         100-150
Barges...................................................................                           200            6-7       150-300
          Total         ...................................................           ...........   395 ................


                                                                             G 6.
                  IMPROVEMENT OF SHREWSBURY RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

  Detailed descriptions of this river and of the projects for its
improvement are printed in the Annual Reports of the Chief of
Engineers for 1897, pages 1152 and 1155; for 1900, page 185, and a
condensed history is contained in current summary.
                               OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST                              FISCAL YEAR.

   Under appropriation of $10,000, act of March 2,. 1907, dredging
for maintenance was commenced on June 2, 1908, and was in progress
at the beginning of the fiscal year, at which time 7,861 cubic yards
of sand had been dredged from the Upper Cross-over, North Branch.
Work under this contract was continued until October 13, 1908,
when the contract was completed. The total amount of material
 (sand) dredged during the fiscal year was 36,404 cubic yards, of
which 5,114 yards were dredged at Upper Cross-over, North Branch,
1,851 yards near steamboat landing, south of Highlands Bridge,
main stem, and the remainder, 29,439 yards, at and near the bend
in the channel north of Island Beach, main stem, near the mouth of
the river.
   The total amount of material removed under this contract was
44,265 cubic yards, of which 12,975 yards were dredged at Upper
Cross-over, 1,851 yards at steamboat landing, south of and near
Highlands Bridge, and the remainder, 29,439 yards, at and near the
bend in the channel near the mouth of the river. The total work
done under this contract consisted in making six cuts each 35 feet
wide, three of which were 600 feet long, two 300 feet, and one 800
feet long, which sufficed to restore Upper Cross-over to projected
dimensions, in making four cuts each 35 feet wide, near steamboat
landing south of Highlands Bridge, three of which were 150 feet
long and one cut 100 feet long, and in making four cuts each 35 feet
wide and 1,370, 1,240, 1,200, and 350 feet in length, respectively,
on the north and west sides of the entrance channel, main stem, at
and near the bend at the mouth of the river. Depth made was
from 7 to 8 feet at mean low water. At the close of the season's
work the channels had been practically restored to projected dimen-
sions. The dredged material was disposed of by pumping it ashore
from the scows, on the west bank of the river near Seabright, and
at other points near the locality of the dredging. Plant consisted
of one scoop dredge, one pump dredge, a tug boat, several scows,
pontoons, and pipe lines.
1128                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                        tJ. S. ARMY.

  Project for the expenditure of the allotment of $20,000 from the
appropriation made by the river and harbor act approved March 3,
1909, was submitted on March 16, and approved on March 19, 1909.
Maintenance dredging under this project was advertised on May 22,
and proposals were opened on June 8. The bid of The Newburgh
Dredging Company, the lowest of three bids received, to do the work
at 262 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement, was accepted by
approval of the Chief of Engineers dated June 24. At the close of
the year a contract for the proposed work, with The Newburgh
Dredging Company, was in preparation.

                                                    Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
  improvement.........................................................-------------------------------------------------- $20,000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                                      APPROPRIATIONS.

Total appropriations to December 31, 1902:
    For previous project.................... .........................         $20, 500.00
    For present project
       (see House Doc. No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 289)............. 329, 000. 00
For present project:
    M arch 3, 1905.....................................................         20, 000.00
    March 2, 1907.....................................................          10,000.00
    March 3, 1909 (allotment Mar. 19, 1909)............................... ...  20, 000.00
      Total for both projects........................ .................   399, 500.00
June 30, 1909, received to date from sale of maps........................        7.25
           Total.....................................................                                                               399,507.25
                                                                     CONTRACT IN FORCE.

Name of contractor: John and Joseph McSpirit.
  Date of contract: May 8, 1908.
Date of approval: May 19, 1908.
  Date of commencement: June 2, 1908.
Date of completion: November 1, 1908.
Dredging about 44,285 cubic yards of material, at 28 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement.
Contract completed October 13, 1908.
                                                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                              Freight received and shipped by water, 1908.
[Statement by Merchants' Steamboat Company for North Branch of the river, and New York and Long
                  Branch Steamboat Company for South Branch of the river.]

                                                              Articles.                                             Short tons.      Estimated
                                                                                                                                      value.

Received:
    Miscellaneous...................................................                                                  1,036,000       $1,050,000
    Coal...............................................................                                                  22, 400         100, 000
    Lumber. ...                          .......................................................                             560          20,000
    Building material........................................................                                             16,800         750,000
Shipped:
    Miscellaneous...............                                .................................................       599,200          950,000
    Farm produce..........................................................                                              168,000        3,000,000
    Fish and shellfish........................................................                                           11,200          400,000
        Total.....................................................                                                   a 1,854, 160      6, 270, 000

                        a Tonnage reported heretofore in gross tons; reported this year in short tons.
                          APPENDIX G-EREPORT OF COLONEL LOCKWOOD.                                                                                                      1129
                                                             Vessels engaged in above commerce.
                                                                   Class.                                                          Number             Draft
                                                                                         Class.                                       trips       when
                                                                                                                                                 loaded.             Tonnage.


                                                                                                                                                      Feet.
      Steamers
Steamers...                     ......................................................                                              ~,7
                                                                                                                                     2,175            ~     5
                                                                                                                                                        42-52           U-7
                                                                                                                                                                       300-875
Sail vessels...                            .................................................                                             100            3J-5            25- 40
        Total................                                          ..................................                             2,275     ...        ...




                                                                                                 G7.

                 IMPROVEMENT OF MANASQUAN RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

  Detailed descriptions of this river and the project for its improve
ment are printed in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for
1898, page 1070, and a condensed history is contained in current
summary.
                                OPERATIONS DURING THE PAST FISCAL YEAR.

  Nothing in furtherance of the project has been done during the
year, pending decision as to the practicability of further work upon
this improvement with the funds available. Expenditures during the
year were for traveling expenses contingent on inspection of im-
provement.

                                                                                APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1879................... $12, 000                                                                   March 3, 1899 ..................                          $5, 000
June 14, 1880..................   20, 000
August 2, 1882..................   7, 000                                                                           Total.................... a 46, 000
September 19, 1890..............   2, 000

                                                                  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
[Statistics for 1908 have been requested, but have not been received. The following statement for 1905 was
                             furnished by W. K. Blodgett, Point Pleasant, N. J.]


                                                                            Articles.                                                            Tons.              Estimated
                                                                                                                                                                      value.

Received, fish..                  ...........................................                                        .        .... ..........             50            $2,000


                                                               Vessels engaged in above commerce.


                                                                               Class.                       Class                               of tips.
                                                                                                                                                Number                 when
                                                                                                                                                                       Draft
                                                                                                                                                of trips,             loaded.


                                                                                                                                                                       Feet.
Naphtha...............................................................                                                                                         10               3

  The commerce of this river is smal, owing to obstructions at the inlet. The river
is largely used by pleasure craft during the summer season, and the inlet is used to
some extent by small fishing boats.

          aOf this amount $4,945.89 was carried to the surplus fund of the Treasury
1130    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U. S. ARMY.

                                G 8.
REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDAN-
             GERING NAVIGATION: INDEFINITE.

    Wreck of deck scow N. D. Shultz in Passaic River at wharf of the
Pennsylvania Railroad Company.-This wreck was the deck scow
N. D. Shultz, owned by Mr. John Guinan, a pilot on one of the Erie
Railroad Company's ferryboats at New York, which, with a load of
earth, was sunk at the wharf of the Pennsylvania Railroad terminal
on the north side of the Passaic River near its mouth.
   It was first reported by one of our dredging inspectors at work in
that locality, and it was then out of the course of vessels, and was
lighted at night and marked by day, and it was reported that it was
the intention of the owner to raise it. Subsequently, about the last
of August, 1908, it was reported that one side of the scow had broken
off and that lighting and marking had been discontinued. At that
time the wreck was worthless and a menace to navigation, having
shifted toward the channel, which at that point is near the bulkhead.
   After satisfactory evidence had been received that the wreck had
been abandoned by the owner the matter was reported to the Chief
of Engineers on November 18, 1908, and an allotment of $800 for its
removal was requested, as it was considered such an obstruction as is
contemplated by section 19 of the river and harbor act approved
March 3, 1899, and should be removed. Under date of November
21, 1908, the above allotment was made for the removal of this wreck.
   Under public notice dated November 28, 1908, proposals for the
removal of the wreck of the N. D. Shultz were received on December
3, 1908, and the bid of John F. Baxter, the lower of two bids received,
to do the work for the sum of $792, was accepted. The time allowed
for the removal was fourteen days.
   The wrecking plant arrived on the work on December 9. A part
of a load of earth still remaining was first removed and placed on the
land, the wreck was then raised by means of pontoons and towed to
the yard of John F. Baxter, at Weehawken, where it was finally de-
posited. The side of the wreck which had been broken off was also
taken away at the same time and deposited with the main part of the
scow. The total time consumed in this work was fourteen days.
Nothing of value was found upon the wreck, and in accordance with
the terms of its removal it became the property of the contractor.
The payment for the work was made on December 29, 1908.
                               APPENDIX H.


IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE PHILADELPHIA,
                PENNSYLVANIA, DISTRICT.


REPORT OF MAJ. HERBERT DEAKYNE, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, OFFI-
                                                    1909.
  CER IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 8.30,

                                 IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Delaware River, New Jersey and             7. Delaware Breakwater, Delaware.
     Pennsylvania.                            8. Construction of harbor of refuge,
2. Perriwig bar, Delaware River.                   Delaware Bay, Delaware.
3. Bordentown bar, Delaware River.            9. Removing sunken vessels or craft
4. Sewer shoal, Delaware River.                    obstructing or endangering navi-
5. Ice harbor at Marcushook, Pennsyl-              gation.
     vania.                                  10. Construction of hydraulic dredges.
6. Construction of iron pier in DelawareI
     Bay, near Lewes, Delaware.



                      ENGINEER OFFICE, UNITED STATES ARMY,
                                   Philadelphia,Pa., July 20, 1909.
  SIR: I have the honor to transmit herewith the annual reports
for the works of river and harbor improvement of the Philadelphia
district, and of dredge construction in my charge, for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1909.
        Very respectfully,                          HERBERT DEAKYNE,
                                                  Major, Corps of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,           U. S. ARMY.


                                       Hi.

IMPROVEMENT OF DELAWARE RIVER, NEW JERSEY, PENNSYLVANIA,
                    AND DELAWARE.

  An account of this improvement is contained in the Annual Reports
of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, page 877; 1897, page 1192; 1898,
page 1075; 1899, page 1317; 1900, page 1557; 1901, page 1310; 1902,
page 1025; 1903, page 957; 1904, page 1181; 1905, page 1065; 1906,
page 1021; 1907, page 1079, and 1908, page 1121.
   Expenditures during the past fiscal year have been applied to the
following operations:
   1. Surveys.
   2. Excavation under contract of the 30-foot channel between Finns
Point and the south line of Pennsylvania and in maintenance.
   3. Improvement of Schooner ledge.
                                                                         1131
1132      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,      U.   S.   ARMY.

   4. Work of the United States dredging plant in excavation of the
30-foot channel and in maintenance.
   These operations will be described in the above order. The locali-
ties referred to and previous operations thereat are described in the
Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, pages 1075-1079;
1899, pages 1317-1322.
                             1. SURVEYS.

   During April and May, 1909, a survey was made of the dredged
channel from Christian street, Philadelphia, to Delaware Bay, a dis-
tance of about 56.5 miles, to determine the condition of the channel
and the amount of shoaling that had occurred. Surveys of various
sections of the river were made from time to time during the year as
information was required. The cost of these surveys was $7,553.01.
     Numerous surveys in connection with contract work in progress
between Finns Point and the south line of Pennsylvania, and in con-
nection with hired labor work at Schooner ledge, Tinicum Island
flats, Duck Creek flats, and contract maintenance work at Baker
shoal, have been made from time to time throughout the year. The
expenses of these surveys are charged to the work to which each
belongs.

2.   EXCAVATION UNDER CONTRACT OF THE 30-FOOT CHANNEL BETWEEN
        FINNS POINT AND THE SOUTH LINE OF PENNSYLVANIA.

    This part of the river is divided into section 3, subsections A and
B; section 4 and section 5, subsections A and B, and has w-ithin its
limits Deep Water Point shoal and Cherry Island Flats shoal.
    During the past fiscal year operations under the general project
have been in progress as follows:
    Under a project approved April 10, 1907, for the expenditure of
$895,000 appropriated by the river and harbor act approved March 2,
1907, for completing the improvement of the channel, contracts for
dredging have been entered into as follows:
    Under date of December 31, 1907, three separate contracts with the
American Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., for the excava-
tion and removal by dredging from the channel of the Delaware River
between Finns Point and the south line of Pennsylvania of the follow-
ing quantities of material from the localities stated, the work to be
commenced within thirty days after January 23, 1908, and to be
completed by June 30, 1908:
    Section 4, about 922,880 cubic yards, at 16 cents per cubic yard,
scow measurement.
    Section 5, subsection A, about 960,400 cubic yards, at 16 cents per
cubic yard, scow measurement.
    Section 5, subsection B, about 960,400 cubic yards, at 17 cents per
cubic yard, scow measurement.
    Work under the contract in section 4 was commenced on March 16,
1908, and was completed on June 29, 1908. The total net amount of
material removed under the contract was 813,847 cubic yards, scow
measurement.
    Work under the contracts in section 5, subsection A, and in section
5, subsection B, was commenced on March 16 and March 24, 1908,
                          APPENDIX H-REPORT                                OF MAJOR DEAKYNE.        1133
respectively, and was completed on August 31, 1908, the time for com-
pleting these contracts having been waived for a reasonable period.
The total net amount of material removed under the contracts was:
                                                                                               Cubic yards.
Subsection 5-A .........................................................                          739, 884
Subsection 5-B .........................................................                          714, 029
   The material removed under these contracts has been pumped ashore
between Edgemoor, Del., and the mouth of Christiana River, and at
Ridley Creek basin, near Chester, Pa., in basins provided by the
contractor.
   Under a project approved June 30, 1908, for the expenditure of
$375,000 appropriated in the sundry civil act approved May 27, 1908,
for improvement of the channel and for maintenance of improvement,
contracts for dredging have been entered into as follows:
   Under date of September 12, 1908, with the American Dredging
Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., for the excavation and removal by
dredging from the channel of Delaware River between Finns Point
and the south line of Pennsylvania, and for maintenance dredging
between the above-named points and at Baker shoal, section 1, the
following quantities of material from the localities stated, the work to
                               w
be commenced ithin thirty days after September 28, 1908, and to be
completed by December 31, 1908:
   Section 3, about 540,000 cubic yards, at 16 cents per cubic yard,
scow measurement.
   Section 5, subsection A, maintenance dredging, about 300,000 cubic
yards, at 15.8 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
   Section 1, maintenance dredging, about 1,120,000 cubic yards, at
13) cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
   Work under this contract was begun in section 1 and section 5, sub-
section A, on September 21, 1908, and in section 3 on October 29,
1908. The work in section 5, subsection A, was completed on Decem-
ber 15, 1908, a total of 231,165 cubic yards of material, scow measure-
ment, being removed. The work in section 3 was completed on Janu-
ary 4, 1909, the contract time of completion having been waived for a
reasonable time. The total net amount of material removed under
the contract from section 3 was 488,623 cubic yards, scow measure-
ment. The work in section 1 was completed on May 21, 1909, except
for some small shoals that may be developed by a survey which was in
progress at the end of the year. The time for completing the contract
has been waived for a reasonable period. The approximate net
amount of material removed from section 1 was 822,636 cubic yards,
scow measurement. The material dredged under these contracts has
been deposited at Repaupo basin, east of Chester Island, at Kelly
Point, N. J., and in Basin B, artificial island, Delaware River.
   Under two projects, as follows: (1) Approved March 17, 1909, for
the expenditure of $390,000 appropriated in the river and harbor act
approved March 3, 1909, for maintenance of the dredged channel; (2)
approved March 19, 1909, for the expenditure of $125,000 appro-
priated in the sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909, for complet-
ing the improvement of the channel, for widening bends, and for
maintenance of the dredged channel, a contract was entered into
under date of May 18, 1909, with the American Dredging Company,
of Philadelphia, Pa., for maintenance dredging at Baker shoal, sec-
tion 1, of about 1,000,000 cubic yards of material at 12.3 cents per
1134          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                   U. S. ARMY.

cubic yard, scow measurement, work to be commenced within thirty
days after May 28, 1909, and completed by October 31, 1909.
   Work under this contract was begun on May 29, and to the end of
the year about 297,000 cubic yards of material had been removed.
   This material is being deposited in Basin B, of the artificial island,
Delaware River.
   The work done under these contracts for original dredging has pro-
vided a channel 30 feet deep at mean low water and 600 feet wide
from Finns Point to the south line of Pennsylvania, completing the
channel from deep water in Delaware Bay to the south line of Penn-
sylvania. The work done under the contracts for maintenance
dredging has provided a channel 30 feet deep and 600 feet wide
through the shoal in section 5, and a channel 30 feet deep and 400 to
450 feet wide through Baker shoal.
   The amounts expended during the year under the foregoing con-
tracts are as follows:

                                                                                                                     Office ex-
                                                                                                                      penses,
                                                                                                                     surveys,
                                           Contracts.                                                 Payments.       superin-
                                                                                                                    tendence,
                                                                                                                      and in-
                                                                                                                     spection.

American Dredging Co.:
   Section 4, contract, December 31, 1907......................................                       $26,878.88      $1,726.61
   Section 5-A, contract, December 31, 1907 ...................................                        79,917.79       6,169.83
   Section 5-B, contract, December 31, 1907 ...................................                       102, 699.48      8, 034. 65
   Sections 1, 3, and 5-A, contract, September 12, 1908..........................                     201,185.86      19,665. 08
   Section 1, contract, May 18, 1909...........................................-..........73.60


   The total amount of material removed from the channel by the
United States under the general project up to June 30, 1909, under
contracts and by United States dredges, exclusive of the rock area at
Schooner ledge, and dredging paid for by the State of Pennsylvania
and city of Philadelphia, was 24,744,000 cubic yards, scow meas-
urement.
   The total amount of material removed from the dredged channel by
maintenance dredging, by United States plant and contract work
during the past year, was 2,608,000 cubic yards.
   Under a decision of the Comptroller of the Treasury, dated August
20, 1908, the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company was
allowed and paid for 174,171 cubic yards of material, forming a part
of the total quantity previously deducted as overdepth dredging
throughout the period of their contract dated August 3, 1905, for
dredging in section 3, subsection B. This quantity represents the
material dredged between the planes of 31 feet and 32 feet below
mean low water, making the total net amount dredged and paid for
under the contract 1,789,381 cubic yards, scow measurement. (See
Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908, p. 1123.)
                           3. IMPROVEMENT OF SCHOONER LEDGE.

  Operations at this locality were continued by the plant belonging
to the United States, authorized by the department July 29, 1903.
  The drill scow Gen. John Newton completed the main work of
blasting on June 15, 1908, the entire ledge area having been covered
              APPENDIX      H-REPORT OF MAJOR DEAKYNE.                        1135
in the operations of the Newton. The aredge Hell Gate and tug
Humphreys were engaged on other work during the year, as follows:
   September 7-11, dredging out the Billingsport Ferry dock, which
had shoaled from operations of the United States plant.
   September 12-14, removing the wreck Eden, on Tinicum Island
range.
   April 18-20, removing the wreck John A. Lingo at Salem Cove
flats.
   Dredges leased from the American Dredging Company, of Phila-
delphia, Pa., were used from time to time during the year whenever
they could be advantageously employed.
   The United States suction dredge Delaware was used on the rock
area and the areas immediately above and below the rock area from
December 28, 1908, to January 12, 1909, and from April 22 to June
29, 1909, and removed during this time 288,467 cubic yards of sand,
mud, and blasted rock.
   The drill scow Gen. John Newton and the combination derrick and
drill scow Rattler were employed during part of the year in sweeping
the rock area and blasting points of rock projecting above the plane
of 30 feet mean low water.
   Night work was continued throughout the year by all United
States plant and leased dredges working on Schooner ledge.
   The work done at Schooner ledge during the past fiscal year was
as follows:
Overlying material removed, including bowlders.............cubic yards.. a354, 956
Ledge rock removed..............................................do....     15, 498
  Since the commencement of operations at this locality the following
work has been accomplished:
Removal of overlying material, including bowlders.......... cubic yards..   a552, 345
Removal of ledge rock...........................................do....        35, 745
Holes drilled and blasted......................................number..        8, 088
Dynamite used...............................................pounds..         100, 337
  Part of the material removed by dredging was deposited behind the
bulkhead between Edgemoor, Del., and the mouth of Christiana
River, part in the dumping basin at Black's farm near Fort Mifflin, Pa.
  The amount expended on the field work at Schooner ledge during
the year was $111,991.02; surveys connected with the work, superin-
tendence, office expenses, and inspection, $12,456.87; on care and
repair of plant, $6,182.01; cost of constructing and equipping derrick
and drill scow, $7,187.28.
4. WORK OF THE UNITED STATES DREDGING PLANT IN EXCAVATION
             OF THE 30-FOOT CHANNEL AND MAINTENANCE.

   The United States self-propelling suction dredge Delaware was
operated under the direction of this office for the city of Philadelphia
from July 1 to July 12, 1908, the cost of her work being paid by the
city (see below). From July 13 to November 20, 1908, she was
engaged on maintenance work on Duck Creek flats. The shoal at
this locality extended for a distance of 25,000 feet, with a minimum
depth on the range line of 22.8 feet. The material was very soft,
  a Of this amount the Delaware removed 288,467 cubic yards, which included both
overlying material and ledge rock and could not be separated.
1136      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                 U. S. ARMY.


and it was found impossible to fill the Delaware's bins with solid
material; it was therefore thought advisable to pump directly over-
board on ebb tide, so that the light material would be carried by the
current to deep water in the bay. On flood tide the material was
held in the bins and deposited near shore opposite the lower end of
Liston range and back of the artificial island, where it could be
pumped ashore. Surveys made from time to time during the progress
of the work developed but slight shoaling at the upper and lower
ends of the original shoal. During the time the Delaware was engaged
on this work she dredged a channel through the entire length of the
shoal, with a width of from 200 to 400 feet, and a depth varying from
28 to 34 feet. Surveys made before and after the dredging showed
that 1,250,500 cubic yards of material had been removed after deduct-
ing the amount of shoaling that occurred as a result of her operations
at the upper and lower ends of the original shoal.
  During the remainder of the year the Delaware worked at the fl-
lowing localities:
  November 21 to December 14, and January 13 to 15, and June 30,
on Tinicum range.
   December 15 to 27 on New Castle range.
   December 28 to January 12, and April 22 to June 29, on Schooner
Ledge rock area.
   From January 16 to April 21, 1909, she was laid up for repairs,
being in dry dock at League Island from February 3 to April 21, 1909.
   The total amount of material removed by the Delaware during
the year is as follows:
                                                                           Cubic yards.
                                                                          120, 397
Tinicum range---------------------------------------------------............
                                                                       1, 250, 500
Duck Creek flats------------------------------------------------............
                                                                           16, 198
New Castle range--------------------------------------------------...........
Schooner Ledge rock area..............................................    288, 467
       Total........................   ................   ................ 1, 675, 562
  The expenditures on the dredge Delaware from the Delaware River
appropriation during the year in connection with her work have been:
                                                                        $77, 351.93
For operation-------------------------------------------------..............
Office expenses, surveys, superintendence, and inspection..............   2, 994. 15

       Total.........................................................       80, 346.08
  During the winter 1907-8 the sum of $11,163.07 was earned by the
Delaware while working in New York Harbor, and paid to the Dela-
ware River appropriation.
   The new United States self-propelling suction dredge Clatsop was
operated on the Delaware River under direction of this office from
September 8 to October 31, 1908. The Clatsop was built for the
Portland (Oreg.) district, and was used on the Delaware River tempo-
rarily pending her departure for the Pacific coast. From September 8
to 30, 1908, she was operated for the city of Philadelphia, the cost of
the work being paid by the city (see below). From October 1 to 27
she worked on Tinicum range, and from October 28 to 31 on Cherry
Island range, on maintenance work. Work was suspended on
October 31 and the Clatsop sailed for the Pacific coast on December 7,
1908. The total amount of material removed by the Clatsop while
working in this district was as follows;
                       APPENDIX H-REPORT                                  OF MAJOR DEAKYNE.         1137
                                                                                               Cubic yards.
Tinicum range---.......................-------------------------------------------------. 73, 979
Cherry Island range (maintenance dredging)...............................                  7, 116
       Total...........................................................                            81,095
  All of this material was deposited at Blacks Farm, near Fort
Mifflin, Pa., to be pumped ashore.
  The expenditures on the dredge Clatsop from the Delaware River
appropriation during the year in connection with her work have been:
For operation......      .............................................                          $2, 815.35
Office expenses, surveys, superintendence, and inspection...............                            105. 06
       Total..........................................................                           2,920.41
   The United States rehandling machine Cataract has been operated
throughout the year at Blacks Farm near Fort Mifflin, Pa., except
when laid up for the winter, rehandling material dredged from the
river by other machines.
   The United States rehandling machine Uncle Sam has been operated
at Blacks Farm during part of the year, and at Artificial Island and
Deep Water Point, N. J., in connection with maintenance work of
the dredge Delaware.
   The Cataract was operated for the city of Philadelphia from July 1
to 15, 1908, and the Uncle Sam was operated for the city of Phila-
delphia from July 1 to 15, and from September 1 to 30, 1908.
   The expenditures by the United States on these rehandling ma-
chines during the past year have been as follows:
Cataract:
    Field cost and operation.......................................                            $48,315.91
    Office expenses and superintendence.............................                             1, 819.04
       Total..........................................................                          50, 134. 95

Uncle Sam:
   Field cost and operation........................................                             15, 575.20
   Office expenses and superintendence..............................                                604.08
       Total.....................................................                               16, 179.28

IMPROVEMENT                  OF DELAWARE RIVER BY THE STATE                               OF   PENNSYL-
                              VANIA AND CITY OF PHILADELPHIA.

   Under the appropriations aggregating $750,000 made in 1905 by
the State of Pennsylvania and the city of, Philadelphia, to be ex-
pended under the direction of the city in accordance with the general
project of improvement of Delaware River, an agreement was
entered into, under date of July 27, 1906, with the city whereby
government plant should be placed on the work in sections 7 and 8
and operated under the direction of this office, all cost of the work to
be paid by the city. Work under this agreement was discontinued
on September 30, 1908, on account of the exhaustion of funds. The
following United States plant were engaged on the work during the
year:
   Dredge Delaware, Tinicum range, section 7, July 1 to July 12, 1908.
   Dredge Clatsop, Tinicum range, section 7, September 1 to Sep-
tember 30, 1908.
   Rehandling machine CataractJuly 1 to July 15, 1908.
       9001-ENG 1909--72
1138            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                              U. S. ARMY.

  Rehandling machine Uncle Sam, July 1 to July 15, and September
1 to September 30, 1908.
  The material removed during the year by the government dredges
under agreement with the city is as follows:
                                                                                             Cubic yards.
Tinicum Island shoal...................................................                         156, 346
   This work has resulted in a channel 600 feet wide and 30 feet deep
at mean low water through Mifflin bar and the shoal opposite League
Island, a distance of 14,000 feet, and a channel of the same depth and
from 550 to 600 feet wide through Tinicum Island shoal, a distance
of 18,000 feet.
   The total amount paid by the city through this office during the
year for this work, including office expenses, surveys connected with
the work, superintendence and inspection, and care and repair of
plant, was $23,899.03, making a total of $275,929.23 paid by the
city through this office since the date of the agreement-July 27, 1906.
   Under date of October 29, 1906, the city of Philadelphia entered
into a contract with the American Dredging Company for dredging
to full width and depth of proposed 30-foot channel in sections 6-A,
6-B, and 9 for a lump sum in each case. These sections, with sections
7 and 8, on which the above-mentioned government plant has been
employed, cover the entire length of the channel from the south line
of Pennsylvania to Christian street, Philadelphia. Under this con-
tract work was begun in April, 1907, and was completed in June,
1908. This work has resulted in a channel having a width of 600
feet through subsections 6-A and 6-B and through section 9. The
dredging has been done with a view to securing a depth of 30 feet at
mean low water.
   The material removed under the three contracts is as follows:
                                                                                             Cubic yards.
Subsection 6-A ......................................................                          826,533
Subsection 6-B ......................................................                          713,199
Section 9............................................................                        1,342,247
         Total...........................................................                    2, 881,979
  This was removed at the lump sum contract price of $430,400,
amounting to about 14.9 cents per cubic yard.
  The t'otal amount of material removed from the channel under the
general project by the city of Philadelphia, between the south line
of Pennsylvania and Christian street, Philadelphia, is 5,300,230
cubic yards, scow measurement. This includes the amounts dredged
by contract work and that removed by the United States plant and
paid for by the city of Philadelphia under the agreement dated July
27, 1906.
RETAINING               BANKS           AND         HYDRAULIC FILLS         AT FORT   DU PONT      AND
                                                     FORT DELAWARE.

  For description of work previously done see Annual Reports of
Chief of Engineers for 1904, pages 1184-1185; 1905, pages 1068-1069;
1906, pages 1024-1025; 1907, pages 1085-1086; and 1908, pages
1128-1129.
  The total amount of material, scow measurement, pumped ashore
to June 30, 1908, is: At Fort Delaware, 2,008,177 cubic yards; at
Fort Du Pont, 1,432,945 cubic yards.
  No work was done at these localities during the past year.
            APPENDIX   IH-REPORT OF MAJOR DEAKYNE.              1139
  CONSTRUCTION   OF A DEPOSITING BASIN     AT PEA PATCH    ISLAND.

  Under date of August 19, 1907, a project was submitted for build-
ing banks around Pea Patch Island, Delaware River, to provide a
depositing basin for material dredged from the channel of the river,
at an estimated cost of $23,000, to be paid from the appropriation
for improving Delaware River, Pennsylvania and New Jersey. The
project was approved October 12, 1907.
  Work of constructing the banks was begun about May 1, 1908, by
hired labor and the lease of a small dredge from the River and Harbor
Improvement-Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., and was completed on
October 31, 1908.
  This work has resulted in the formation of a depositing basin on
the northern part of Pea Patch Island covering an area of 157 acres,
with a capacity of 2,230,000 cubic yards.
  The amount expended on the construction of the banks during the
year was $14,052.63, making the total cost of constructing the banks
$16,882.56. Repairs to the banks were made during May and June
at a cost of $707.37.
             IMPROVEMENT    OF PHILADELPHIA HARBOR.

   The river and harbor act approved March 2, 1907, appropriated
certain sums for completing the improvement of Delaware River
below Christian street, Philadelphia, and for maintenance of the
dredged channel. In the estimate submitted of the amount that
could be profitably expended during the fiscal year ending June 30,
1908 (see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1906, p. 172),
the sum of $40,000 was included for maintenance of the dredged
waterway in Philadelphia Harbor above Christian street, Philadel-
phia. It is understood, therefore, that of the amount appropriated
under the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, the sum of $40,000
is available for maintenance work in Philadelphia Harbor. No
dredging has been done in the harbor during the past year.
  The river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909, appropriated
certain sums for maintenance of the dredged channel. Under a
project submitted March 10 and approved March 17, 1909, for ex-
pending this money, the work in Philadelphia Harbor is combined
with work under the general project below Christian street, Phila-
delphia.
     APPROPRIATIONS    FOR COMPLETION OF EXISTING PROJECT.

  The river and harbor act approved March 2, 1907, appropriated
$895,000 for completing the improvement under the general project
for a 30-foot channel, and authorized contracts for an additional
amount not exceeding $500,000 for maintenance of the dredged
channel, to be paid for as appropriations may from time to time be
made by law. The same act authorized the expenditure of a sum
not exceeding $200,000 of the amounts appropriated and authorized
in widening the channel at the bends therein below the city of Phila-
delphia, with a view to securing, so far as practicable, a channel of
equal safety and efficiency in all its parts.
1140           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                     U. S. ARMY.

   Of the $500,000 authorized in the river and harbor act approved
March 2, 1907, the sum of $375,000 was appropriated in the sundry
civil act approved May 27, 1908, and the remaining balance of $125,000
was appropriated in the sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.
   The river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909, appropriated
$390,000 for maintenance of the dredged channel from Philadelphia
to Delaware Bay, including Philadelphia Harbor.
                                              MISCELLANEOUS.

   On February 8, 1904, a libel was filed in the United States district
court for New Jersey against the coal barge Alaska, owned by the
Philadelphia and Reading Railway Company, for the recovery of
damages sustained by the United States by reason of the barge run-
ning into and sinking a scow belonging to the United States.
   A judgment was entered in favor of the United States on Novem-
ber 23, 1908, for $1,400, and the costs of the case amounting to
$100.80. On January 25, 1909, the sum of $1,400 of the amount was
credited to the appropriation, Improving Delaware River, Pennsyl-
vania and New Jersey.
   During the fiscal years ending June 30, 1908, and June 30, 1909,
the State of of Pennsylvania and city of Philadelphia appropriated
the sum of $1,717,610, for expenditure in dredging in the Delaware
and Schuylkill rivers, and the city of Philadelphia granted licenses
for the construction of 5 new piers and 7 bulkheads, and for the
enlargement of 4 existing piers, and issued permits for repairs to 72
piers and bulkheads, along the Philadelphia water front. Detailed
information with reference to these subjects is given in the appended
statement furnished by Mr. J. F. Hasskarl, assistant director, depart-
ment of wharves, docks, and ferries, city of Philadelphia, which he
has kindly prepared at my request.
   After the completion of the present project for a channel 30 feet
deep and 600 feet wide operations should be undertaken to secure
a greater width at the bends in the channel. A width of 1,000 feet
is considered sufficient at all of the bends except that between New
Castle range and the Deepwater Point range, where there is a change
of direction of 42 ° . This is the sharpest turn in the river and should
be widened to 1,200 feet. The work required to widen the bends as
outlined herein is the removal of about 2,600,000 cubic yards of
material, at an estimated cost of about $450,000. Some work has
already been done toward widening the bends, but an additional
appropriation will be necessary before the work can be completed.
                                   Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
of improvement------------------------------------------....................................................... $200,000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                      APPENDIX I1-REPORT OF MAJOR DEAKYNE.                                          1141
                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.
                                                    DELAWARE RIVER.

Total from 1836 to June 3, 1896, previous to adoption of existing project,
  as per House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second ses-
  sion, page 340 ..................................................                         $2, 972, 000. 00
March 3, 1899........................................                                           300,000. 00
June 6, 1900 ......................................................                             270, 500. 00
March 3, 1901.........................................                                           61, 500. 00
June 13, 1902 ....................................................                              600, 000. 00
March 3, 1903........... .....................................                          ...  1, 400, 000. 00
April 28, 1904......................................                                    ...  1, 000, 000. 00
March 3, 1905........................................                                           500,000. 00
June 30, 1906.....................................................                           1, 000, 000. 00
March 2, 1907........................................                                           895, 000. 00
May 27, 1908.........................................                                           375, 000. 00
March 3, 1909........................................                                           390, 000. 00
March 4, 1909...............                                  .........................         125, 000. 00

                                                                                            9, 889, 000. 00
Amounts received from other sources as follows:
   Sales condemned property....................................                                  1, 749.43
   Sales blueprints..............................................                                    56. 44
   Services United States dredge Delaware in other districts.........                           22, 182. 99
   Collected through United States district court, New Jersey, account
     damages done to scow of United States by barge Alaska of Phila-
     delphia and Reading Railroad Company.....................                                   1, 400.00
   Transfer United States property to other engineer districts (1907).                               20. 62

       Total .......................................................                        9,914,409. 48
Total amount appropriated on present project to June 30, 1909,
  $6,840,536.74.
                                                   Philadelphia Harbor.
Total to December 31, 1902, as per House Document
  No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second session, page
  310................................................   $3,940,000.00
March 3, 1905 (allotment)............................       10,000.00
                                                                                          a 3, 950, 000. 00

        Grand total.................................................                      13,864,409.48


                                            CONTRACTS IN FORCE.
   1. With the American Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., dated September
12, 1908, and approved September 28, 1908, for excavating and removing material
from the existing channel of Delaware River, in the locality designated as section 1,
for a width of about 300 feet and a depth of 30 feet at mean low water, and depositing
the excavated material above high water or in inclosed basins; estimated quantity of
material to be removed 1,000,000 cubic yards, scow measurement, at 13J cents per
cubic yard. Work to be commenced on or before October 30, 1908, and completed
by December 31, 1908. The time limit of the contract has been waived for a reason-
able period.
   2. With the American Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., dated May 18,
1909, and approved May 25, 1909, for excavating and removing material from the
existing channel of Delaware River, in the locality designated as section 1, for the full
width of the channel, 600 feet, and a depth of 30 feet at mean low water, and deposit-
ing the excavated material above high water or in inclosed basins; estimated quan-
tity of material to be removed 1,000,000 cubic yards, scow measurement, at 12.3 cents
per cubic yard. Work to be commenced on or before June 24, 1909, and completed
by October 31, 1909.
  a Of this amount $87.24 was carried to the surplus fund; $4,000 never withdrawn
from Treasury; $465.28 and $7.06 redeposited to credit of appropriations; total,
$4,559.58.
 1142                    REPORT                  OF THE                   CHIEF OF                     ENGINEERS,                             U.    S.     ARMY.


                                                                COMMERCIAL                             STATISTICS.

     The following statement concerning the foreign commerce of the Delaware River
for the years ending December 31, 1907 and 1908, is compiled from reports of the
Board of Trade of the city of Philadelphia:

                                                                                         Imports.

                                                                       Articles.                                                                              1907.            1908.

                                                                                                                                                                   Tons.       Tons.
Asphalt and asphalt blocks......9.......................................                                                                                              9,447       7,586
Cem ent........................................................................                                                                                       2,769          280
Chalk..........................................................................                                                                                     35,776       24,100
Clay............... ....                            .....................................................                                                           76,756       76,203
Coal tar, and pitch of...............................................                                                                                                 2,994       1,101
Cork and corkwood.........................................................                                                                                            1,830          101
Cotton and cotton fabrics...                                              ..........................................                                                14,703       12,306
Drugs and chemicals.............                                                    ....................................................                           144,717      132,723
Earthenware, china and stoneware.............................................                                                                                            471         350
Fertilizers...............................................................                                                                                            4,144      12,060
Fruits                 ............................................................                                                                             .34,747          51,378
Glass, and manufactures of....                                              .........................................                                                 5,871       4,795
Groceries and provisions..............................                                                                  .............                .              29, 052      27, 472
Hair, and manufactures of.....................................................                                                                                       17,298       3,698
Hemp, jute, flax, and their fabrics.....                                               ...................                                 .........                 36, 257     26,095
Hides and skins....5..............................................                                                                                                    5, 676     19,525
Iron:
      Manufactured..............................................................                                                                                    31,396        13,545
      Ore........................................................................                                                                                  600,598       585,126
      Pig...................................................                                                                                                       156,395        12,422
      Scrap........                                ..........................................................                                                                      1,491
Leather, and manufactures of .................................................                                                                                        4,982        3,298
Live stock and fowls...                                        ................................................                                                          299         302
Mineral water                   .....................                                              ......                       .       ..........                    2,626       3,588
Molasses...................................................                                                                                                          39,727       38,343
                          ..
Oil .............................       .       ..           .       ..           .       ..            .       ..            .       .       ..            ...     19,447        17,040
Ore, metals and manufactures of .............................................                                                                                         9,720       25,479
Plants and seeds........................................................                                                                                              2,086        2,484
Plaster of Paris, and plaster (crude)...........................................
Rags...........................................................................
                                                                                                                                                               86,97911,692
                                                                                                                                                                                  35,169
                                                                                                                                                                                  10,771
Salt....................................................................                                                                                            10,899        16,361
Silk, and manufactures of...                                        .............................................                                                         25           15
Stone, and manufactures of............                                                ...............................                                            .4,704            6,353
Sugar...............                           ..               ...........................................                                                        200,370       199,978
Sulphur:
     Crude..........................................................1,457                                                                                                               5
     Ore................................................................                                                                                           102,553       116,234
Tin...........................................................................                                                                                        1,139        1,066
Tobacco........................................................................                                                                                       1,214        1,351
Wines and liquors........................................................                                                                                             2,469           781
Wood pulp, paper, and manufactures of...                                                     ................................                                         1,800        9,532
Wood, and manufactures of.....................................................                                                                                      31,629        18,763
Wool and wool fabrics.............1...........                                                                                                                        5,557       10, 742
Miscellaneous...............................................................                                                                           ....         38,249        21,003

           Total....................................................                                                    .............                     [,1800,520           1,551,015



                                                                                        Exports.

                                                                   Articles.                                                                                 1907.             1908.


                                                                                                                                                             Tons.             Tons.
Beef, pork, and prod acts.......................................................                                                                              86,798             55,925
Bricks           ............................................................................                                                                     100                 30
Cars and locomotives..................................................                                                          ...........                       570                470
Coal.............. ............................................................                                                                              930,599            799,862
Corn and corn meal...                                          ...............................................                                                65,799             55,397
Cotton and cotton fabrics......................................................                                                                               12,825             13,196
Drugs and chemicals.........................................................                                                                                   5,687              1,900
Feed............. ...........................................................                                                                                 33,159             39,664
Fertilizers..................                                           ........................................                                               1,024              1,365
Flour.............. ...........................................................                                                                              581,013            584,865
Fruit..........................................................................                                                                                   189                 30
Glucose.....................................................................                                                                                   3,173                 840
Glue and glue stock.............................................................                                                                                   55                 31
Groceries and provisions........................................................                                                                              26,746             13,500
Gunpowder and explosives......................................................                                                                                   387                 303
Hides, leather, and manufactures of.............................................                                                                               2,460              1,910
                                    APPENDIX H-REPORT                                                      OF MVIAJOR DEAKYNE.                                               1143
                                                                            Exports-Continued.

                                                                  Articles.                                                                                 1907.            1908.


Iron:                                                                                                                                                     Tons.              Tons.
     Manufactured...                                       ................................................                                                 64, 655            54,460
     Pig..................................................................                                                                                   3,588              2,913
     Scrap......                       ..........................................................                                                              '45                 57
Live stock..............................................................                                                                                    38,548             18,485
Metals, other, and manufactures of...                                              .....................................                                     5,328              1,850
Molasses..........                .......................................................                                                                   23,622             23,595
Oats and oatmeal..................................................                                                                                           6,411              3,790
Oilceake .....                       ...........................................................                                                           121,090             79,719
Oil:
     Lubricating.................................................................                                                                          265,955         152,275
     Other....................................................................                                                                             155,166          75,526
Paraffin................................................................                                                                                    22,042          13,628
Petroleum, crude and refined ...                                          .........................................                                      1,124,673       1,188,277
Residuum...................................................................                                                                                268,821         207,979
Rosin and turpentine.........................................................                                                                               14,964          11,932
Seeds......                                  .......................................................                                                        20,935          12,000
Soap, tallow and grease...                                        ............................................                                              23,543          14,691
Stone, and manufactures of....                                        ..........................................                                                844            475
Tobacco.................................................................                                                                                      6,002          5,044
Wines and liquors...                                ...................................................                                                          90          1,622
Wood pulp, paper, and manufactures of.....................................                                                                                    7,370          9,051
Wood, and manufactures of..................................................                                                                                 84,505          55,280
Miscellaneous ..................................................................                                                                             47,935         30,535

           Total............................................                                                                  ..............             4,056,716       3,532,472


                       Passengers arrivingfrom and departingfor foreign countries by river.

                                                                                                                                                            1907.            1908.


Arrivals......................................................................                                                                               27,263            24,537
Departures...................................................................                                                                                13,423            12,081
           Total...........                                                         .......
                                                                                ........................                       ..............                40,686            36,618


      Comparativestatement of quantity and value of exports, imports, and revenue collected.

                                                                                                Exports.                                         Imports.
                                  Year.                                                                                                                                Revenue.
                                                                                 Quantity.                    Value.               Quantity.             Value.


                                                                                     Tons.                 Tons.
1899....................................                                           3,069,570 $67,044,250 1,270,440$48,241,016 $20,777,735
1900....................................                                           3,513,526 81,145,966 1,316,554 49,186,877 21,775,201
1901...................................                                            3,183,584 79,324,344 1,279,044 51,365,142 19,046,007
1902..................................                                             2,748,839  76,022,896 1,679,403 55,064,776 22,360,362
1903.....................................                                          2,378,307  73,184,394 1,561,052 55,516,052 21,020,331
1904..................................                                             2,552,065  66,539,909 1,057,348 53,852,194  17,997,700
1905..................................                                             3,267,439 70,645,103 1,365,245 67,913,822 20,022,804
1906..................................                                             3,800,995 88,276,315 1,732,935 72,137,678   20,505,545
1907..................................                                             4,056,716 106,570,527 1,800,520 80,693,327 21,044;374
1908.................................                                              3,532,472 95,533,079 1,551,015 57,407,933 16,963,929


                                                        Foreign entrances and clearances, 1908.

                            Class.                                              from foreign
                                                                        Enteredports.                                  Cleared for foreign
                                                                                                                             ports.                                 Total.


American:                                    Number.                                              Tons.             Number.                    Tons.      Number.            Tons.
   Steam vessels....................             90                                               202,306               58                     103,560       148              305,866
   Sailing vessels.............       ......     54                                                32,854               55                      48,985       109               81,839
Foreign:
   Steam vessels...................             916                                           2,034,868                      946         2,126,119            1,862      4,160,987
   Sailing vessels...................            70                                              50,803                       65            48,241              135         99,044

          Total........................                                       1,130           2,320,831                    1,124         2,326,905            2,254      4,647,736
1144               REPORT            OF THE CHIEF                  OF ENTGINEERS,                    UT. S. ARMY.

   The following statement concerning the domestic and coastwise commerce of the
Delaware River for the years ending December 31, 1907 and 1908, has been compiled
from returns made to this office by shippers, consignees, and carriers:


                                                                                    1907.                              1908.
                                 Articles.1
                                                                       Quantity.            Value.        Quantity.            Value.


                                       ARRIVALS.                               Tons.                        Tons8.
Asphalt. ..                     ..................................              10,450         $94, 050       8,937               $108,425
Bricks and terra cotta..........................                                21,037          64,936       21,751                 60,478
Chemicals........................................                              312,560       4,825,498      221,795              3,938,315
Clay.............................................                                 3,500          5,479        7,289                 41,762
Coal.............................................                              715,493       2,553,793      684,684              2,593,165
Coal tar..........................................                              25,000         150,000       32,507                268,632
Cotton.......                       ................................             7,500       1,500,000        6,000              1,200,000
Fertilizers..................................208,387                                         4,009,540      109,835              2,222,385
Grain...              ................................... 131,582                            2,960,595      106,410              2,669,222
Hay.........            .....................................                     3,917         22,642        2,589                 18,767
Ice......              ......................................                   30,729          42,860      115,558                145,611
Iron:
     Manufactured...                           ..........................       20,356          763,247      60,364              2,127,740
     Ore...                 ...................................                   3,000          24,000      24,032                144,192
     Pig .........            ..................................               108,502       2,129,648       44,993                814,833
Lumber...                          .................................           961,347      10,588,854      729,562              7,844,366
Manure .....                  ..................................               100,250          150,540      91,700                132,870
Oysters and fish...............................                                 22,940       2,215,000        9,950              1,791,000
Petroleum and products........................                                 795,852       8, 325,486     676,475              7,076,663
Pr Juce and fruit...                            ..........................      71,310       4,272,400       89,923              3,653,619
Railroad ties....                               ............................   215,966       1,109,780       95,103                401,498
Sand..........................................                               2,345,398       1,283,131    1,910,510              1,045,988
Stone:
     Building.....................................                               43,137       235,265    33,720                    148,730
     Paving....                        ..............................           82,000        164,000    30,000                    180,000
Sugar...                      ..................................               161,800     13,156,000   204,587                 18,164,200
Wood (cord)...                         ..............................           58, 670       234,680    84,838                    338,952
Miscellaneous...                            ............................     2,701,652    739,610,712 2,640,085                536,132,796
        Total...............                  ................           9,162,335        800,492,136      8,043,197           593,264,209
                               DEPARTURES.
Asphalt...........................................                             9,540      85,860     4,600                          42,000
Chemicals.........................................                           119,385   2,344,170    95,508                       2,175,450
Coal................................................                      7,877,432 30,764,762 7,150,315                        27,854,154
Coal tar...........................................                           12,000      18,000    11,165                          68,686
Fertilizers.........................................                         114,736   2,303,720   129,013                       2,818,753
Grain.............................................                            36,584   1,141,015    21,375                         543,508
Ice................................................                           18,713      27,813    12,500                          21,550
Iron:
    Manufactured.................................                             20,096     485,198    13,320                         400,000
    Pig............................................                            4,911      98,220     2,000                          20,800
    Ore...........................................                             4,000      32,000    13,000                          90,000
Lumber...........................................                             51,915     520,460    22,847                         228,470
Manure...........................................                             66,092      94,638    52,839                          56,514
Oysters and fish....                           ..........................    100,000   1,543,450    80,000                       1,348,250
Petroleum and products.........................                              683,058   9,661,828   558,493                       7,266,763
Produce and fruit.................................                            74,125   4,486,500    53,094                         601,685
Sand..............................................                           743,923     474,834   584,278                         362,747
Stone, building....................................                         207,209    1,033,070   109,295                         578,050
Sugar...                   ...................................                31,200   3,369,600    26,400                       2,851,200
Wood...                     ...................................               12,750     127,500    83,853                         335,412
Miscellaneous.....................................                        2,076,289  550,629,399 1,873,316                     455,306,305

                               ................. 12,263,958 609,242,037 10,897,211
        Total......................                                                                                            502,970,297



                         Passengers arriving and departingfrom Philadelphiaby river.

                                                                                                              1907.              1908.


Arriving                  ....................................................... 1,234,4771,437,686
Departing                  ......................................................1,237,926 1,437,086
        Total                  ...................................                ..................        2,472,403            2,874,772
                   APPENDIX H-REPORT                        OF MAJOR DEAKYNE.                                    1145
                    Domestic and coastwise arrivals and departures in cargo.

                                                                        1907.                          1908.
                          Class.                                                           ivas
                                                                         Dearturs.
                                                                   Arrivas.
                                                              Arrivals.  Departures.       Arrivals.     Departures.

Steamers...           ...............................           a 13,519       a 13,250     a 10,818             a 10,541
Sailing vessels.......................................             3,032       b 32,803     c26,778              c26,725
Canal boats and barges.................................         d37,160        d37,143      e29,728              e29,715
Rafts.................................................               141             73          144                  144
                                                                          I            I                Il'
      Total......................             ...........         53,852F 83,269              67,468              67,125

                                a Exclusive   of tug boats and ferryboats.
                                b Including   30,000 oyster boats (estimated).
                                c Including   24,000 oyster boats (estimated).
                                d Including   18,000 railroad lighters.
                                e Including   14,400 railroad lighters.

                                                 SUMMARY.

                                            Freight movement.

                                                              1907.                             1908.

                                                  Quantity.           Value.       Quantity.                  Value.

Foreign:                                            Tons.                  Tons.
   Arrivals..............................           1,800,520 $80,693,327 1,551,015                           $57,407,933
   Departures............................           4,056,716 106,570,527 3,532,472                            95,533,079
Domestic:
   Arrivals....    .......................          9,162,335 800,492,136 8,043,197 593,264,209
   Departures............................          12,263,958 550,629,39910,897,211 502,970,297
      Total............................... a27,283,529                       b24,023,895 1,249,175,518
                                                                  1,538,385,389

   a Of this total quantity 2,528,500 tons were carried on car floats between Philadelphia and Camden.
   bOf this total quantity 2,240,000 tons were carried on car floats between Philadelphia and Camden.

                                               Vessel movement.

                                                                         Foreign trade.         Domestic trade.

                                                                         1907.      1908.       1907.            1908.

                            ARRIVING.
Steam vessels       ..........       ....................................... 1,344 1,006 13,519                   10,818
Sailing  vessels... .......................................                   888         124  3,032              26,778
Canal boats and barges.........................................              2,218 ......     37,160              29,728
Rafts................................................................                           141                 144
                           DEPARTING.
Steam vessels................................................                   1,337 1,004 13,250                10,541
Sailing  vessels................................................                 912        120 32,803            26,725
Canal boats and barges .........................................                2,196.......... 37,143            29,715
Rafts..........................................................................                     73              144
      Total.........................           ...................        8,895      2,254 137,121 134,593


List of vessels, of 27 feet draft or over, entering and leaving the ports of New York and
                   Philadelphiaduring the year ending December 31, 1908.
1146                    REPORT                 OF        THE           CHIEF OF            ENGINEERS,                U.    S.   ARMY.


                                           EXPORTS                    OF          GRAIN    AND          PETROLEUM.

  The following tables give the amount of grain and petroleum
shipped from this port during the years 1907 and 1908, compared
with the shipments from other ports named:
                                                  Export of grain (wheat and corn) and oats.

                                                                                                         1907.                         1908.
                                              Port.

                                                                                                Bushels.         Per cent.      Bushels.       Per cent.


Philadelphia....                     ..............................                             21,219,899              11.1    18,728,653          12.4
Montreal....                   .................................                                29,628,162              15.4    27,790,012          18.3
Portland...                ...................................                                   6,290,441               3.3     6,846,127           4.6
Boston...                ....................................                                   18,402,182               9.6    11,901,317           7.8
New York....                     ................................                               50,427,289              26.3    32,268,477          21.3
Baltimore. ..                ..................................                                 28,013,451              14.7    20,432,247          13.5
Newport News....                     ..............................                              1,980,479               1.0     1,158,652             .7
Norfolk....            .....................................                                       194,987                .1       274,049             .1
New Orleans..........................................                                           12,437,149               6.4     8,133,961           5.3
Galveston...                 ..................................                                 15,851,416               8.2    16,243,375          10.7
Mobile....                 ....................................                                  2,167,835               1.1       601,963             .4
St. Johns (N. B.)......................................                                          3,317,928               1.7     1,146,636             .7
Port Arthur....                  ................................                                2,079,910               1.1     6,395,194           4.2
           Total...........................................                                  192,011,128                100.0   151,920,663        100.0



                                             Exports of petroleum (50 gallons to the barrel).

                                                                                                         1907.                         1908.
                                              Port.

                                                                                                Barrels.         Per cent.      Barrels.       Per cent.


New York...                             ..................................                       8,439,820              45.9    12,304,182          57.9
Philadelphia...                         ................................                         9,864,011              53.8     8,535,267          40.2
Baltimore............................................                                               55,359                .3       398,047           1.9
          Total...........................................                                      18,359,190           100.0      21,237,496         100.0



Vessels completed and under construction at the principal shipyards along the Delaware
                              River during the year 1908.


                                            Kind.                                          Completed Under con- Gross tons                  Approxi-
                                                                  Sduring                       year. struction.                           mate value.


Battle ships................................                                                             2                 2      63,825 $22,000,000
Light-house tenders...                         .......................                                   8                         6,936   1,600,000
Revenue cutters......................................                                                    5   ...........
                                                                                                                                   4,143    872,363
Torpedo destroyers........                     ...................                                                         3       2,149   1,300,000
Mine planters.....                         ..........................                                                      4       2,940     850,012
Steamers..................................                                                               3                 3      24,462   2,383,000
Ferryboat.............................................                                      .........
                                                                                                         2
                                                                                                                           1         145      32,044
Car floats.............................................                                                                   11      15,550    602,400
Barges.................................................                                                 11                13      21,542    816,100
Towing boats.........................................                                                    5                           800    125,000
Dumping scows....                            .........................                                   5 ..........      1       5,600      82,425
Yacht...                      .................................                                                                      217      88,209
                                                                                                         41               38.    18,09         3,71,5
          Total........................                                      ...........                41                38     148,309       30,751,553
                   APPENDIX           IH--REPORT OF MAJOR                     DEAKYNE.                    1147
                                     DEPARTMENT OF WHARVES, DOCKS, AND FERRIES,
                                                                       Philadelphia,Pa., July 9, 1909.
                                              MAMORANDUM.


  Showing the amount appropriated by the city of Philadelphia and State of Penn-
sylvania to the department of wharves, docks, and ferries, for improving Philadelphia
Harbor, and work done by that department; also improvements made by private
parties in Philadelphia Harbor from July 1, 1907, to June 30, 1909.


                                                                                 Permits
                                                            Licenses    granted issued for
Fiscal year.   Amounts appro-
                  priated.             Dredging
                                       Dredging done.
                                                done,         for construction repairs to
                                                              of private   piers    private    Surveys made.rsand
                                                              and bulkheads.       piers dbulk-
                                                                                    heads.

July 1, 1907,   By city of Phila-     Delaware River,       Pier enlarged,    1;          1   Delaware River, 5
  to June 30,    delphia,  $132,-      41,220   c ubi c       new piers, 2.                    shoals; Delaware
  1908.          506.55.               yards; Schuyl-                                          River, 30 docks.
                                       kill River, 1,530
                                       cubic yards.
July 1, 1908,   By city of Phila-     Delaware River,       Piers enlarged, 3;           71   Delaware River, 3
  to June 30,    delphia, $1,467,-     92,261   c ubic        newpiers,3; new                  shoals; Delaware
   1909.         610; by State of      yards; Schuyl-         bulkheads, 7.                     River, 40 docks;
                 Pennsylvan i a,       kill River. 28.074                                      survey of Schuyl-
                 $250,000; total,      cub i c yards;                                          kill from mouth
                 $1,717,610.            w o r k still in                                       to South Street
                                        progress on both                                        Bridge.
                                        rivers.


   Funds are now in hand for the construction of a modern double-deck pier at Dock
street, and additional funds will be appropriated in October for the construction of
a double-deck pier at Vine street. Plans are now in progress, and money in hand,
for widening Delaware avenue from South street to Christian street, and from Vine
to Laurel streets. Additional appropriation will be made in October, 1909, for dredg-
ing between the channel in the Delaware River and the pierhead lines, and for
dredging docks into which city sewers empty, and other docks.
   It is confidently expected that the city of Philadelphia will appropriate $2,000,000
in October or November, 1909, for the improvement of Philadelphia Harbor, by the
construction of one additional double-deck pier and for necessary dredging in the
Delaware and Schuylkill rivers. It has also been practically agreed upon by the
administration that liberal appropriations will be made annually for the maintenance
of all Philadelphia Harbor improvements, and that docks for trans-Atlantic trade will
be dredged to sufficient depth to accommodate the largest vessels that can come to
the port, thus taking advantage of and making full use of the improved channel in
the Delaware River.
                                                    JOSEPH F. HASSKARL,
                                                                                   Assistant Director.


                                                     H 2.
IMPROVEMENT OF DELAWARE RIVER AT PERRIWIG BAR, NEW JERSEY
                   AND PENNSYLVANIA.

   The approved project provides for dredging a channel 7 feet deep
at mean low water, with a bottom width of 200 feet, in three straight
stretches through Perriwig bar, at an estimated cost of $50,000. See
Annual Reports of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, page 181, and 1908,
page 1137.
   This work was completed in December, 1907. A survey of the
dredged channel was made during the past year. A very small
1148            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

amount of shoaling has occurred in the channel since the completion
of dredging.
  The river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909, appropriated
$1,500 for maintenance of this improvement. Under a project sub-
mitted March 10 and approved March 17, 1909, this amount is to be
expended in making such occasional surveys and examinations as
may be necessary to watch the condition of the river, and in the
supervision of the work of dredging sand from the river by private
parties to prevent injury to the channel and to secure benefit from
the sand-dredging operations wherever possible.
  During the past fiscal year the sum of $640.34 was expended in
payment of outstanding liabilities at the end of the preceding year
and the cost of a survey made in July, 1908, of the dredged channel.
                                                  APPROPRIATIONS.
March 2, 190.7 .................................................                           $50, 000. 00
March 3, 1909 .......................................................                        1, 500. 00
          Total.........................................................                    51,500.00


                                                             H 3.
IMPROVEMENT                    OF DELAWARE RIVER NEAR BORDENTOWN,                               NEW
                                         JERSEY.
   During the winter of 1907-8 a bar was formed in the Delaware
River near Bordentown, N. J., and extended entirely across the river.
The bar.-had from 3 to 5 feet depth at mean low water, and it became
impossible for the river steamers running between Philadelphia and
Trenton, N. J., to cross at low tide. These steamers draw about 6
feet. The range of tide at this point is about 4.5 feet.
   Under date of April 20, 1908, an allotment of $500 was made by
the Secretary of War from the emergency appropriation of $300,000
provided by the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, for a survey
at this locality to determine means of providing relief for commerce.
  A project for a channel in two straight reaches through the bar was
submitted under date of May 29, 1908, and approved June 8, 1908,
and a further allotment of $9,500 for dredging was made by the
Assistant Secretary of War under date of June 8, 1908.
  The approved project provides for a channel in two straight
reaches through the bar, having a depth of 7 feet at mean low water
and a bottom width of 200 feet, or as near that width as the available
funds will permit. The length requiring dredging is about 3,800feet.
   Under date of June 12, 1908, an emergency contract was entered
into with the American Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., for
dredging the required channel at 14                                     cents per cubic yard, place
measurement, the work to be commenced within six days after date
of contract and completed within thirty-six days after date of con-
tract. Dredging was begun                             on June 15, 1908, and completed on July
11, 1908. A total of 64,221                           cubic yards of material was removed and
placed on shore above high                            water.
   This work has resulted in                          the formation of a channel 7 feet deep at
mean low water with a bottom width of 160 feet, for a distance of
about 3,800 feet through Bordentown bar. The amount expended
during the past fiscal year under the project is as follows:
                      APPENDIX H-REPORT                 OF MAJOR DEAKYNE.                  1149
American Dredging Company, payments...........................                          $9, 312. 04
Surveys, inspection, and office expenses...............................                     431.87
       Total...............................                ..........................    9, 743.91
  This improvement has had no direct effect on freight rates between
Philadelphia and Trenton, N. J., and intermediate points, but it has
enabled boats to cross the bar at all stages of the tide and maintain
their regular service. The freight rates between Philadelphia and
Trenton are much lower by boat than by rail.
                                     Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
improvement .       .    .     .     .   .    .    .      ........         $5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                              APPROPRIATION.

March 2, 1907, allotments April 20 and June 8, 1908 .....................                 $10, 000

                                 EMERGENCY CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  With the American Dredging Company of Philadelphia, Pa., dated June 12, 1908,
for excavating and removing material in dredging a channel through the bar near
Bordentown, N. J., with a depth of 7 feet at mean low water and of such bottom
width not to exceed 200 feet as the available funds will permit, the excavated
material to be deposited above high water in places provided by the contractor and
approved by the Engineer, at the price of 141 cents per cubic yard, place measure-
ment. Work to be commenced within six days after date of contract and completed
within thirty-six days after date of contract. The estimated quantity of material to
be removed is about 80,000 cubic yards, place measurement.



                                                    H 4.

  IMPROVEMENT OF DELAWARE RIVER AT SEWER SHOAL, NEAR
                 TRENTON, NEW JERSEY.

   Between Trenton and Bordentown, about one-half mile below the
steamboat landing in Trenton, a shoal extended entirely across the
river carrying from 4 to 5 feet depth at mean low water. The steam-
boats running between Philadelphia and Trenton experienced much
difficulty in crossing this bar at low tide, and groundings were fre-
quent.
   Under date of May 6, 1909, a report was submitted on the condi-
tion of the river at this locality, and on May 12, 1909, the Acting
Secretary of War allotted the sum of $15,000 from the emergency
appropriation of $500,000 provided by section 2 of the river and harbor
act approved March 3, 1909, for relieving commerce at this locality.
   The project for this improvement provides for a straight channel
through the bar for a distance of 1,800 feet, with a (lepth of 7 feet at
mean low water, and a bottom width of 200 feet, or as near that
width as the funds will permit.
1150      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  Under date of June 1, 1909, an emergency contract was entered
into with the American Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa.,
for dredging the required channel at 35 cents per cubic yard, place
measurement, the work to be completed within seventy days after
date of contract.  Dredging was begun on June 5, 1909, and at the
end of the year was about 40 per cent completed.                      The dredged
material is being deposited on the New Jersey shore above the low-
water line.
  During the past fiscal year the sum of $5.80 was expended for inci-
dental expenses in connection with the work.

                                 APPROPRIATION.
Act of March 3, 1909 (allotment).......................................... $15, 000



                     EMERGENCY CONTRACT IN FORCE.

   With the American Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., dated June 1, 1999,
for excavating and removing material in dredging a channel not to exceed 200 feet
bottom width, and 7 feet deep at mean low water, through Sewer shoal, about one-
half mile below the steamboat landing at Trenton, N. J., the excavated material to
be deposited along the eastern shore of the river, opposite the channel to be dredged
above the level of mean low tide, at the price of 35 cents per cubic yard, place meas-
urement. Work to be commenced within ten days after date of the contract and
completed within seventy days after date of the contract. The estimated quantity
of material to be removed is about 40,000 cubic yards, place measurement.



                                        H   5.
IMPROVEMENT OF ICE HARBOR AT MARCUSHOOK,                          PENNSYLVANIA.

   An account of this improvement is contained in the Annual Reports
of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, page 920; 1900, page 1574; and
1904, page 1196.
   The protection works for this harbor consist of the old landing
piers and seven detached piers having foundations of wooden cribs
filled with stone, the superstructures being filled with cut stone.
   During the past year repairs were made to these piers by replacing
stones that had been moved out of place, and resetting the stone
mooring posts. The total cost of these repairs was $37.54.
                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
  provement............................................   ...................  $600
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                APPROPRIATIONS.

Total, as per House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second session. $219,000
                    APPENDIX H-REPORT OF MAJOR DEAKYNE.                             1151

                                                           H 6.
CONSTRUCTION                OF IRON PIER IN DELAWARE BAY, NEAR LEWES,
                                      DELAWARE.

   An account of this work is contained in the Annual Reports of the
Chief of Engineers for 1896, page 920, and for 1900, page 1574.
   During the past fiscal year no work has been done nor have any
liabilities been incurred.
                                     Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911, ex-
  clusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
  provemnent ...----------------------------------------------------- $1, 500
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                               APPROPRIATIONS.

Total, as per House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second ses-
  sion..............................................................      $386,160



                                                            H 7.

      IMPROVEMENT OF DELAWARE BREAKWATER, DELAWARE.

   An account of this improvement is contained in the Annual Reports
of the Chief of Engineers for 1896, page 922; for 1897, page 1214; for
1898, page 1094; for 1901, page 1323; and for 1905, page 1083.
   During the past fiscal year no work has been done nor have any
liabilities been incurred.
   The commercial statistics of the harbor at and in the vicinity of
this breakwater are given in connection with the report on the harbor
of refuge, Delaware Bay, Delaware.
                                               APPROPRIATIONS.

Total, as per House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second
  session ....--------------------------------------------------- $2, 807, 353.70
Received from sale of old building .................................         1.00

      Grand total...............................................             2, 807, 354.70



                                                            H 8.

    CONSTRUCTION OF HARBOR OF REFUGE,                                 DELAWARE BAY,
                       DELAWARE.

   An account of this improvement is contained in the Annual Reports
of the Chief of Engineers for 1897, page 1216; for 1901, page 1325; for
1902, page 1036; for 1903, page 970; and for 1904, page 1199.
   During the past fiscal year no work has been done nor have any
liabilities been incurred.
1152             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                U.   S. ARMY.

                                           Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
  provem ent ............................................................      $8, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
  and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.

                                                  APPROPRIATIONS.

Total, as per House Document No. 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second
  session........................................................... $2,239,334



                                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                        Arrivals at Delaware Breakwater during 1908.

                                                  Steamers.    Ships.       Barks.      Brigs.       Schooners. Barges.         Total.

For orders...........................                    79            2             11 ........            20 ..........           112
For harbor..........................                     19 ........                 12          1         503            384       919
In distress............................                   2 ........................                         1              1         4

      Total..........................                   100            2          23            1          524          385       1,035



                                                              H g.
REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDAN-
                  GERING NAVIGATION.

   (1) In August, 1908, the schooner Eden foundered during a gale.
The wrecked vessel was found lying close to the Tinicum Island
range, Delaware River. An examination was made and it was found
that the wreck was a dangerous obstruction to navigation; its
removal was therefore recommended. Under date of June 9, 1908, a
contract was entered into with Eugene Boehm, of Atlantic City,
N. J., for removal of all parts of the wreck and its contents from the
waterway for the sum of $872. The contract provided that in'the
work of removal the use of explosives would not be permitted. This
stipulation was made for the reason that bodies of some of the crew
of the wrecked vessel were supposed to be still in the wreck.
   The contractor made unsuccessful attempts to raise the wreck, and
finally abandoned the work.
   All parts of the wreck projecting above the plane of 30 feet mean
low water were removed by United States plant and hired labor, the
work being completed on September 14, 1908. The total cost of
removing the wreck was $413.68.
   (2) The commanding officer at Fort Mott, N. J., complained of a
wreck lying in Delaware River alongside of and obstructing access
to the wharf at that post. An examination was made and it was
found that the wreck was that of an unknown house boat sunk about
four years ago. Its removal was recommended. The work of
removal was done by United States plant and hired labor, the work
being completed on July 10, 1908. The total cost of removing the
wreck was $301.65.
                     APPENDIX IIH-REPORT OF MAJOR DEAKYNE.                      1153

   (3) In February, 1909, the schooner-rigged flat-bottom boat John
A. Lingo was wrecked in the Delaware River near Finns Point, N. J.
The wreck being considered an obstruction to navigation, its removal
was recommended.      The work of removal was done by United
States plant and hired labor, the work being completed on April 19,
1909. The total cost of removing this wreck was $200.


                                                      H io.

                      CONSTRUCTION OF HYDRAULIC DREDGES.
                                            Seagoing dredges.
    1. DREDGE FOR IMPROVING LOWER WILLAMETTE AND COLUMBIA
                            RIVERS, OREGON AND WASJIINGTON.

   For work previously performed under contract for a steel-hull,
single-screw suction dredge, see pages 1143 and 1144, Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, the dredge
was about 85 per cent completed and the greater portion of the outfit
for the dredge had been purchased.
   During the year the dredge was completed, given the specified
thirty days' trial in the Delaware River, and sent to Portland, Oreg.,
at which place she arrived April 21, 1909.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, including prepara-
tion of plans for the dredge, cost of construction, inspection, outfit,
and voyage of the dredge from Philadelphia, Pa., to Portland, Oreg.,
was $303,543.86.
   The dredge and its property were transferred to Maj. J. F. Mclndoe,
Corps of Engineers, on invoices and receipts under date of May 31,
1908.
                            Money statement.
Amount allotted...........     ..............................          $308, 200. 00
Received from sale of blueprints......................................         3. 20

                                                                           308, 203. 20

June 30, 1909, amount drawn, including $3.20 received from sale of blue-
  prints.........................................................          308, 203. 20
Amount expended to June 30, 1908................_...... $179, 723. 38
June 30, 1909, amount expended during the fiscal year..... 123, 820. 48
                                                                           303, 543. 86

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended...................................          4, 659.34
July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities..................................      1,280.49

July 1, 1909, balance available......................................        3, 378. 85

                                        CONTRACT IN FORCE.
   With the Newport News Shipbuilding and Dry Dock Company, of Newport News,
Va., dated July 6 and approved July 24, 1907, for the construction of one steel hull,
single-screw suction dredge for Columbia River, Oregon and Washington, at the price
of $234,500, delivered at Newport News, Va. Work to be commenced on or before
August 6, 1907, and be completed by June 27, 1908. The dredge was finally com-
pleted on August 22, 1908.
     9001-ENG 1909       73
1154          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                U. S.   ARMY.

    2.   DREDGES FOR IMPROVING NEW YORK HARBOR, NEW YORK.

   For work previously performed under a contract for two steel-hull,
twin-screw suction dredges, see pages 1144 and 1145, Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
  At the beginning of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, the dredges
had been completed and were at work in New York Harbor, but the
thirty-days' trial called for in the specifications had not been com-
pleted.
   During the year the thirty-days' trial was completed and the dredges
have continued at work.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, including preparation
of plans for the dredges, cost of their construction, inspection, and
outfits, was $762,278.05.
   The dredges and their property were transferred to Col. S. W.
Roessler, Corps of Engineers, at New York, N. Y., during the fiscal
year.                       Money statement.
Amount appropriated...............................- ...- ......  ......         $800, 000. 00
Received from sale of blueprints......................................                  4.00
Received from sale of condemned property.............................                  15. 50

                                                                              800, 019. 50
June 30, 1909, amount drawn............................ $770, 066.00
Received from sale of blueprints...........................          4. 00
Received from sale of condemned property................            15. 50
                                                                           -- 770, 085. 50
Amount expended to June 30, 1908....................... 416, 319. 71
Amount expended during the fiscal year ................     . 345, 958. 34
Deposited to credit of the appropriation...................     7, 807.45
                                                                            -    770, 085. 50

         3.   DREDGE FOR IMPROVING HARBOR AT GALVESTON, TEX.

   For work previously performed under a contract for one steel-hull,
twin-screw suction dredge, see Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers for 1908, pages 1145 and 1146.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, the con-
tract was about 52 per cent completed.
   During the year the contract was completed, the dredge taken to
Galveston, Tex., given the specified thirty days' trial, and has since
been at work.
   During the thirty days' trial the following defects developed:
   The air compressor for the fuel-oil system broke and was other-
wise unsatisfactory.
   The copper circulating pipe to the condenser and sea developed
holes, showing probably impure metal.
   The electric and search light wiring was found not to be in accord-
ance with the specified requirements.
   Part of these have been remedied and charged to the contractor,
and the remainder are to be remedied by the contractor.
   The propellers furnished with the dredge having been found to be
too small in diameter and pitch, two new wheels were bought at a
cost of $765.40.
   The drags furnished with the dredge being found not well adapted
to the material where the dredge works, three new ones of a different
type were purchased at a cost of $799.39.
                APPENDIX H---REPORT OF MAJOR DEAKYNE.                                 1155
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, including prepara-
tion of plans of the dredge, cost of construction, inspection, outfit,
supplies for its journey to Galveston, Tex., three new drags and two
new propellers, was $372,256.10.
   The dredge and its property were transferred to Capt. John C.
Oakes, Corps of Engineers, on invoices and receipts during the fiscal
year.
   In one of the payments made the contractors for construction of
the dredge, the sum of $4,750 was deducted by authority of the War
Department on account of an overpayment previously made the
same contractors by Maj. G. S. Bingham, Quartermaster, U. S.
Army, under a contract with the Quartermaster's Department for
the construction of the steamer General Joseph E. Johnston. It is
understood that the appropriations involved are to be adjusted by
the Treasury Department, and therefore the amount is carried as an
outstanding liability chargeable to the appropriation under which
the dredge was constructed.
                                  Money statement.
Amount allotted..........................           .............               $377, 700.00
Received from sale of blueprints.....................................                  10.54

                                                                                 377, 710. 54

June 30, 1909, amount drawn..........................           $377, 710.00
Amount remaining in Treasury from deposits amounting to
  $10.54 to credit of appropriation account sale of blueprints.          . 54
                                                                                 377,710.54
Amount expended to June 30, 1908 ....................             66, 222.59
June 30, 1909, amount expended during the fiscal year....        306, 033.51
                                                                                 372, 256.10

July 1, 1909, balance unexpended..................................                 5,454.44
    In Treasury, United States.........................         . 54
    In hand..........................................     5, 453.90

July 1, 1909, outstanding liabilities ....................       a 4, 750. 00
July 1, 1909, amount covered by existing contracts........         4, 516. 00
                                                                                   9, 266. 00
                               CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  With the Maryland Steel Cdmpany of Baltimore County, of Sparrows Point, Md.,
dated February 24 and approved March 21, 1908, for the construction of one steel
hull twin-screw suction dredge for Galveston Harbor, Texas, at the price of $357,500,
delivered at Sparrows Point, Md. Work to be commenced on or before April 4, 1908,
and be completed by December 24, 1908. The dredge was completed on October
15, 1903.
                                Nonseagoing dredge.
        4. DREDGE FOR IMPROVING HARBOR AT SAVANNAH,                             GA.

  For work previously performed under a contract for one nonsea-
going, steel-hull suction dredge, see pages 1146 and 1147 Annual
Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
  a This amount was deducted in one of the payments to the contractors for con-
struction of the dredge on account of an overpayment made by the Quartermaster's
Department. It is understood that the appropriations involved are to be adjusted
by the Treasury Department, as stated in the report,
1156      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                  U.   S. ARMY.

   At the beginning of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, the dredge
had been completed and delivered at Savannah, Ga., but the specified
thirty days' trial had not been completed.
   During the year the thirty days' trial was completed.
   The total amount expended to June 30, 1909, including prepara-
tion of plans of the dredge, cost of construction and dehlivery at
Savannah, Ga., inspection, and superintendence, was $119,676.21.
   The dredge was transferred on invoices and receipts to Col. Dan C.
Kingman, Corps of Engineers, during the fiscal year.
                                Money statement.
Amount limited in the appropriation.................................         $125, 000.00
Received from sale of blueprints......................................               8.00
                                                                              125, 008. 00
Amount drawn........................................       $120, 213.00
Received from sale of blueprints..........................         8.00
                                                                              120, 221.00
Amount expended to June 30, 1908......................        112, 701. 64
June 30, 1909, amount expended during the fiscal year....       6, 974. 57
Deposited to credit of the appropriation .................         544.79
                                                                -- -          120, 221.00


.
.


                                  APPENDIX I.


IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE 
    WILMINGTON, DELAWARE, DISTRICT.


REPORT OF CAPT. L. H. RAND, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, OFFICER IN
         CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.
                                      IMPROVEMENTS.

1.   Cooper Creek, New Jersey.              10. Appoquinimink, Murderkill, and
2.   Mantua Creek, New Jersey.                    Mispillion rivers, Delaware.
3.   Raccoon Creek, New Jersey.             11. St. Jones River, Delaware.
4.   Salem River, New Jersey.               ]12. Smyrna River, Delaware.
5.   Alloway Creek, New Jersey.             13. Broadkill River, Delaware.
6.   Cohansey River, New Jersey.            14. Removing sunken vessels or craft
7.   Tuckerton Creek, New Jersey.                 obstructing or endangering navi-
8.   Cold Spring Inlet, New Jersey.               gation.
9.   Wilmington Harbor, Delaware.


                        ENGINEER OFFICE, UNITED STATES ARMY,
                                   Wilmington, Del., July 19, 1909.
  SIR: I have the honor to inclose herewith annual report for the
works of river and harbor improvement in this district for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 1909.
       Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                                  L. H. RAND,
                                    Captain, Corps of Engineers.
     The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. Army.


                                           I I.
             IMPROVEMENT OF COOPER CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

   For the history of this        improvement, see the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for        1909, Part 1, page 199.
   No work has been done          during the past fiscal year. The expend-
iture was for examination         and supervision expenses.
   No contract in force.
                          Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending
June 30, 1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1,
1909:
   For works of improvement............................ $5, 072. 96
   For maintenance of improvement.......................     5, 927.04
                                                                           $11, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                                                           1157
1158           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                       U. S. ARMY.

                                                APPROPRIATIONS.
Present project:
    June 3, 1896........................................................                                    $37,000
    March 3, 1909 (allotment Apr. 21, 1909)...............................                                    5, 000
                                                                                                             42, 000
Received from sale of property............................................                                       100
     Total...............................................................                                    42,100
Expended in building dike at Woodbury Creek, N. J.......................                                      2, 500



     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                              Receipts and shipments.

                                            Class.                                              Quantity.   Value.

                                                                                                  Tons.
Receipts: Chemicals, pig iron, building materials, coal, ore, etc..................                97,000    $706,697
Shipments: Pipe, building materials, chemicals, etc...........................                    124,205   1,100,936

      Total receipts and shipments........................                       ............     221,205   1,807, 633


Vessels sailing and trading in Cooper Creekc, New Jersey (tonnage, draft, number of trips,
                                                          etc., not reported).
Barges.....................................................................           593
Sailing vessels..............................................................          57
Schooners...................................................................             2
Canal boats................................................................             37
Lighters...................................................................            84

       Total......................................  ........................ 773
  The foregoing statistics were compiled from statements furnished by the Camden
(N. J.) Board of Trade, which are incomplete.


                                                            I 2.

                 IMPROVEMENT OF MANTUA CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

  For the history of this improvement, see the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 200.
  At the close of the fiscal year 1908 a contract dated May 19 and
approved June 2, 1908, had been made with the American Dredging
Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., for dredging, at 15.7 cents per cubic
yard, place measurement. Work under this contract was begun
July 14, and continued to October 14, 1908, the time limit having
been waived by authority of the Chief of Engineers dated September
29, 1908. During this period the channel was dredged to a depth of
13 feet at mean low water and a width of 100 feet from the 12-foot
curve in Delaware Bay to the upper end of the I. P. Thomas & Sons'
fertilizer works; thence 9 feet deep and 80 feet wide to the highway
bridge at Paulsboro, and thence a distance of 12,000 feet, 8 feet deep
and 60 feet wide, these depths including 1 foot for overdepth made in
dredging under the contract, and side slopes of one on one. The
quantity of material removed is 70,000 cubic yards, measured in
place, and consisted of mud and sand. This was deposited upon the
meadows behind banks above the high-water line.
                            APPENDIX I-REPORT OF CAPTAIN RAND.                                                              1159
                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement (dredging)--------------------......................--.... $25, 000
      For maintenance of improvement..-............................                                          a 6, 000
                                                                                                                          $31, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                      APPROPRIATIONS.

Previous project, amount as per House Document 421, Fifty-seventh Con-
  gress, second session.....................................................                                          $3, 000
Present project:
    March 3, 1899..............................................------------------------------------------ $25,000
    June 13, 1902-------------------------------------------................................................  35, 000
    March 2, 1907-------------------------------------------................................................. 34,450
                                                                                                                      94, 450

                                                                                                                           97, 450
Received from sale of property............................-----------------------------------------.                           100

          Total...................................-----------------------------------------------------                  b97,550


                                                 CONTRACT IN FORCE.

   With American Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., dated May 19, and
approved June 2, 1908, for dredging, at 15.7 cents per cubic yard, place measurement,
the work to be commenced within thirty days after notification of approval of con-
tract by the Chief of Engineers, which was given June 5, 1908, and to be completed
within four months of such date of notification. Time limit waived by authority of
the Chief of Engineers dated September 29, 1908.


COMMERCIAL                  STATISTICS                FOR CALENDAR                 YEAR ENDING                    DECEMBER
                                                         31, 1908.
   No complete commercial statistics for Mantua Creek could be obtained, but the
receipts by water at Mantua were as follows:
750 tons brick---.....----...............................................--------------------------------------------.....     $3, 300
10,000 tons lumber------------------------------------------------...................................................... 150, 000
1,500 tons coal-----------------------------------------------------..........................................................  9, 375
15,000 tons manure------------------------------------------------.......................................................      39, 000
7,500 tons rough building stone---------------------------------------............................................             11, 250
500 tons dressed building stone---------------------------------------...........................................               1, 300

         Total.............................................................                                               214,225


                                                                    I 3.
                IMPROVEMENT OF RACCOON CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

  For previous history of this improvement, see the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 202.
  The title papers, including deeds, releases, etc., having been duly
recorded for the cut-off to be made at Molonox shoal, proposals for
a Dredging, $5,000; jetty work, $1,000.
  b In addition to this amount the sum of $7,000 is made available by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, but not yet allotted
1160            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                 U. S. ARMY.

the work were advertised for and opened March 26, 1909.                                       Contract
dated April 21, and approved May 3, 1909, was made with the Rick-
ards Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., at 11.8 cents per cubic
yard, place measurement, the work to be begun within thirty days
after date of notification of approval by the Chief of Engineers, which
was given May 6, 1909, and to be completed within six months after
starting work.                    Work was begun on May 13, and to the end of the
fiscal year 3,370 linear feet of the channel cut had been completed.
The quantity of material removed is 33,384 cubic yards, measured
in place.             This consisted of vegetable matter, clay, and mud, and
was deposited upon the adjacent banks above the high-water level.
                                         Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement................................... $10, 000
   For maintenance of improvement..............................      5,000
                                                                                                    $15, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

Previous project, amount as per House Document 421, Fifty-seventh Con-
  gress, second session..................................................... $3, 000
Present project:
                                                                     $15,000
    June 13, 1902------------------------------------------..................
    March 3,1905-------------------------------------------.................
                                                                      15, 000
    March 2,1907-------------------------------------------.................
                                                                      15, 000
                                                                              45, 000

                                                                                                     48, 000
Received from sale of property.........................................                                  100
        Total..............................................------------------........ 48,100


                                                  CONTRACT IN FORCE.

   With The Rickards Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., dated April 21, 1909,
and approved by the Chief of Engineers May 3, 1909, for dredging, at 11.8 cents per
cubic yard, place measurement, for the specified depth, and 5.9 cents per cubic
yard for overdepth up to 1 foot and side slopes of one on one; the work to be com-
menced within thirty days after date of notification of approval of contract by Chief
of Engineers, which was given on May 6, 1909, and to be completed within six months
after starting work.


    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                     Receipts and shipments.

                                                     Class.                            Quantity.     Value.

Receipts:                                                                                Tons.
   Coal, dimension stone, etc...................................................          26,000      $90,000
                                                                              55,367
    Fertilizers, lumber, etc........................................................                  482,400
    Grain, hay,potatoes, etc....................................................             588       30,500
     Total.........................................-............................. 81,955  602, 900
Shipments: Berries, garden truck, tomatoes, melons, etc ..........................10, 313 276,250

      Total receipts and shipments.............................................           92, 268     879,150
                                       APPENDIX I-REPORT                                            OF CAPTAIN RAND.                          1161
                                 Vessels sailing and trading in Raccoon Creek, New Jersey.


                                                Class.                                                     No.    Aggregate
                                                                                                                  tonnage.    Draft.     Remarks.


                                                                                                                              Feet.
Steamer.................................................                                                      1         100        4   Irregularly.
     Do--------------------------------------------.....................................................      1         100        6       Do.
Barges--------------------------------------------.....................................................      12       1,800        6       Do.
Sailing vessels---------------------------------------.............................................           4         660        7       Do.

          Total........................----------------------------------------18                                     2,660


    The foregoing statistics were furnished by Mr. Lewis M. Shoch, Swedesboro, N. J.



                                                                                         I 4.
                            IMPROVEMENT OF SALEM RIVER, NEW JERSEY.

  For the history of this improvement, see the Annual Report of
the Chief of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 204.
  At the close of the fiscal year 1908 a contract dated June 24 and
approved July 7, 1908, for dredging had been made with the Penn-
sylvania Dredging Company, of Camden, N. J., at 19.9 cents per
cubic yard, place measurement. Work under this contract was
begun on July 27, 1908, and completed April 30, 1909, the time
limit having been waived by authority of the Chief of Engineers
dated January 12, 1909.       During this period the channel was
dredged to a depth of 10 feet at mean low water and a width of
100 feet from the 9-foot curve in Delaware River to the 9-foot depth
in Salem River, a distance of 7,350 feet; thence upstream to Little
Salem River, a distance of 2 miles, no dredging was necessary, as
the natural depth and width were sufficient; and from the lower
portion of Little Salem River, opposite the factory of the Heinz
Company, to the Covered Bridge, a stationary structure, a distance
of about 2,920 feet, the channel was dredged to a depth of 9 feet
at mean low water and a width of 75 feet, resulting in a channel
9 feet deep at mean low water from the Delaware River to the Cov-
ered Bridge, the head of navigation, at Salem, a distance of about
4 miles, the width being about 100 feet in Delaware River to the
mouth of Salem River, widening to 200 feet at the beacon, and
thence 75 feet to the Covered Bridge. Allowance was made for 1
foot overdepth at the mouth in accordance with the contract. The
quantity of material removed is 121,640 cubic yards, measured in
place. It consisted of sand, mud, gravel, and clay. Of this, 16,703
cubic yards was deposited in the Stony Point bulkhead in the Dela-
ware River and the remainder on the meadows along Salem River
above the high-water line.
                                                       Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
    For works of improvement................................... $9, 600
    For maintenance of improvement............................   5,000
                                                                                                                                             $14, 600
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
   1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
1162                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEER'S, U. S. ARMVIY.

                                                                      APPROPRIATIONS.

Previous project, amount as per House Document 421, Fifty-seventh
  Congress, second session...............................................                                   a $18, 700
Present project, March 2, 1907-----------------------------------..........................................    29, 000
                                                                                                                                                      47, 700
Received from sale of property .............                                                  ......................                                      100
          Total............................................................                                                                          b 47, 800



                                                                CONTRACT IN FORCE.
  With Pennsylvania Dredging Company, of Camden, N. J., for dredging, at 19.9
cents per cubic yard, place measurement, the work to be commenced within thirty
days after notification of approval of contract, which was given July 9, 1908, and
to be completed within seven months after such notification. Time limit waived
under authority of Chief of Engineers dated January 12, 1909. Contract completed
April 30, 1909.


    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                     Receipts and shipments.

                                                                    Class.                                                           Quantity.       Value.
                                                                                                                                 I
Receipts:                                                                                                                                Tons.
    Fire clay, coal, wood, ice, ore, etc......................................                                    ......                  40, 750     $284,250
    Bricks, lumber, canned goods, etc...........................................                                                           9,075       273, 750
    Cattle, horses, fruit, grain, etc---------------------------------------...............................................               27, 635      811,351
    General merchandise........................................................                                                            8,140       537,000
       Total................................----------------------------------------------------.                           --            85, 600    1,906,351

Shipments:
    Canned goods, flour, wood, etc---------------------------------------..............................................                   13,300       831,800
    Cattle, fruit, hay, straw, etc.................................................                                                        7,158       173, 700
    Tomatoes and coal tar....................---.--....---.....-----.----...                                                              15,600       151,200
       Total.....................................................                                  ................                       36,058     1,156,700
       Total receipts and shipments.............................................                                                         121,658     3,063,051


                                 Vessels sailing and trading in Salem River, New Jersey.

                                                         Class.                         No.          Aggregate              Draft.               Remarks.
                                              .
                                          Class                                         N...         tonnage.                    .


                                                                                                                            Feet.
Steamer...............................................                                         1                      195       9 3 times per week.
    Do.............................................------------------------------              1                       61            6     Daily.

       Total............................---------------------------------.2                                       256

  In addition to the two steamers given above, there are numerous boats, of which no
record has been kept, for the transportation of oil, lumber, hay, oysters, shells, grain,
tomatoes, etc.
  The foregoing statistics were furnished by Mr. J. K. Waddington, Salem, N. J.

  a Of this amount $1,490.66 was carried to surplus fund.
  b In addition to this amount the sum of $5,000 is made available by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, but not yet allotted.
                             APPENDIX               I-REPORT OF CAPTAIN RAND.                                                 1163
                                                                      I 5.
                  IMPROVEMENT OF ALLOWAY CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

   For the history of this improvement, see the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 205.
   The title papers with recorded deed of land required for the cut-off
to be made at Fosters Bottle, authorized in the river and harbor act
of March 2, 1907, having been forwarded to the department, specifi-
cations for the work were approved by the Chief of Engineers Decem-
ber 9, 1908. After due advertisement, proposals were opened Decem-
ber 30, and contract dated December 31, 1908, made with The
Rickards Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., the lowest bidder,
at 9 cents per cubic yard, place measurement, for the prescribed
dimensions, and half that price for overdepth and side slopes, where
made, the work to be completed in ten weeks from date of contract.
Work under the contract was begun on January 8, and completed
February 3, 1909, and resulted in a straight channel through Fosters
Bottle of a minimum depth of 7 feet at mean low water and a bottom
width of at least 75 feet, one foot overdepth and side slopes having
been made. The length of the cut through the marsh is 1,070 feet.
The quantity of material removed is 42,188 cubic yards, measured in
place, and consisted of mud and vegetable matter. This was de-
posited on the adjacent marsh behind the dike protecting the marsh
from tidal overflow.
                                         Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
provem ent ............................................................    $7,000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                        APPROPRIATIONS.
Present project:
    September 19, 1890.................................................                                                       $6,000
    July 13, 1892---------------------------------------------...........................................................      3,000
    August 18, 1894-------------------------------------------.......................................................          3,000
    June 3, 1896----------------------------------------------.........................................................        3,000
    March 3, 1899---------------------------------------------.......................................................          3,000
    June 13, 1902---------------------------------------------........................................................         3,000
    March 3, 1905---------------------------------------------.......................................................          3,000
    March 2, 1907..............................-----------------------------------...----------..................              5,000
                                                                                                                              29,000
Received from sale of property-.............                                        ............             .............        100

          Total............................................................                                                  a 29, 100


                                                   CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  With The Rickards Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., dated December 31,
1908, for dredging, at 9 cents per cubic yard, place measurement, for making the pre-
scribed depths, and 4 cents per cubic yard for overdepth made not exceeding 1
foot and side slopes of one on one, the work to be commenced within ten days after
date of contract and completed within ten weeks after said date.
  a in addition to this amount the sum of $5,000 is made available by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, but not yet allotted.
1164                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.
                                                               Receipts and shipments.

                                                               Class.                                                              Quantity.       Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                             Tons.
      Coal, raw bone, tin plate, etc...             .......................................                                                3,175    $87, 625
      Solder and box lumber.. ...       .............................................                                                      3,060     46,500
      Miscellaneous merchandise...----------.----------------------------------1,000                                                                 50, 000
         Total........................................                                                                                . 7,235       184,125
Shipments:
      Canned goods..........................................................7,                                                               875    400,000
      Grain and hay........................................................3,180                                                                     54,000
      Miscellaneous merchandise....                     ............ .............................                                           200     20,000
         Total...................                               ........................................                               11,255       474,000
         Total reteipts and shipments.........................................                                                         18, 490      658,125

  The manufacture of glassware has heretofore been an important item.                                                                        The factory
was not in operation the past year.
                                   Vessels sailing and trading in Alloway Creek, New Jersey.

                                                Class.         Class                                   No.
                                                                                                       No.        tonnage.
                                                                                                                  Aggregate       Draft.       Remarks.


                                                                                                                                  Feet.
Steamer.................................................                                                     1              100       8 Triweekly.
Schooner.................................................                                                    1               75       6 Occasionally.
     Do..................................................                                                    1              100        7     Monthly.
     Do.....................................................                                                 1              150        8         D o.
Barge...................................................                                                     1              250        8     Occasionally.
Gasoline barge...........................................                                                    1               25        6     Daily.
          Total....................................                              ..........                  6              700

  The foregoing statistics were furnished by Mr. William Plummer, of the Quinton
Glass Company, Quinton, N. J.

                                                                                  I 6.
                      IMPROVEMENT OF COHANSEY RIVER, NEW JERSEY.
  For the history of this improvement, see the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 207.
  No work done during the fiscal year. No contract in force.
                                                         Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
provement....         .....................................................   $6, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
  and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                                   APPROPRIATIONS.
Previous project, amount as per House Document 421, Fifty-seventh Congress,
  second session......................................................      $36, 000
Present project, March 2, 1907............................................   55, 800
                                                                                                                                                    91, 800
Received from sale of property.............                                                          .........................                          100
              Total.....................................................                                                                           a91, 900
   a In addition to this amount the sum of $6,000 is made available by the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1909, but not yet allotted.
                               APPENDIX I-REPORT OF CAPTAIN RAND.                                                                     1165
     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                      Receipts and shipments.

                                                       Class.                                                         Quantity.       Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                 Tons.
   Coal, and wood for baskets..............................................                                                33,800     $192,800
   Fertilizers, sawed lumber, box boards, etc.......                           .....   ...................                  9, 400      91,000
   Corn, wheat, and hay ......................................................                                              5,392       48,800

     Total...................................................................                                               48, 592    332,600
Shipments: Baskets and tomatoes...............................................                                               3, 225     39, 000

        Total receipts and shipments.....................                              ........................ .          51,817      371,600


                          Vessels sailing and trading in Cohansey River, New Jersey.


                                       Class.                                          No.          Aggregate
                                                                                                    tonnage.                Remarks.


Schooners......................                                      ..............        10                1,177   2 to 4 trips a year.


   The steamers F. M. Riley and Howard and barge John Masters also come into the
river carrying coal and fertilizers.
   Steamers of a total of 300 tonnage and sailing vessels of a total of 3,100 tonnage
repaired during the year. One schooner of 40 tons and two schooners of 44 tons each
under construction.
   The foregoing is compiled from information furnished by various parties at Bridge-
ton, N. J.

                                                                          I 7.
                 IMPROVEMENT OF TUCKERTON CREEK, NEW JERSEY.

   For the history of this improvement, see the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1909, part' 1, page 208.
   At the close of the fiscal year 1908, a contract dated May 12 and
approved June 2, 1908, was in force with Charles P. Grim, of Phila-
delphia, Pa., for dredging, the work to be completed by October 5,
1908. The contractor's plant arrived at the lower end of Marchelder
channel on June 19 and to the close of that month was engaged in
digging out a channel to get to the location of the contract dredging.
Dredging under the contract began on July 8, opposite Parkers
Island, and continued with many interruptions, due to the con-
tractor's plant getting out of order, to July 28, after which no dredg-
ing was done. The channel was dredged to a width of 45 feet for a
length of 500 feet toward the mouth of Tuckerton Creek, the depth
made being 51 feet at mean low water, which included foot allowed
for overdepth dredging under the contract. The quantity of material
                                                                                                                      1
removed is 1,048 cubic yards, measured in place. This consisted of
mud and sand and was scowed away and deposited at the head of the
Story Island channel, as required by the contract. The contractor's
plant was removed from the work on August 20. Under date of
August 29 the contractor asked for an extension of time to complete
the contract, but by authority of the Chief of Engineers, dated Sep-
tember 4, 1908, the contract was annulled by letter to the contractor
and sureties dated September 10, 1908.
1166         REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

  The work was readvertised and proposals opened October 30, but
as the bids received were excessive in price the bids were rejected.
  Proposals were again invited, to be opened May 7, 1909, but none
received, and after revision of specifications, proposals have again
been invited, to be opened July 8, 1909.
                               Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement................................... $27, 380
   For maintenance of improvement.......................        ... 4, 000
                                                                                                    $31, 380
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                APPROPRIATIONS.
Present project:
    June 13, 1902...................................................... $12,000
    March 3,1905-------------------------------------------------...........12, 000
    M arch 2, 1907........................................................ 12,000
    March 3, 1909 (allotment Mar. 13, 1909)................................  2, 000

       Total.............................................................                            38,000



                                       CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  With Charles P. Grim, of Philadelphia, Pa., dated May 12, and approved June 2,
1908, for dredging, at 16.5 cents per cubic yard, place measurement, the work to be
commenced within thirty days after notification of approval of contract, which was
given June 5, 1908, and to be completed within four months after such notification.
Total amount, $10,800. Contract annulled September 10, 1908, by authority of
Chief of Engineers, dated September 4, 1908.



   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                         Receipts and shipments.

                                        Class.                                         Quantity.    Value.

Receipts:                                                         Tons.
                                                                   25,100 $1,210,000
   Oysters, clams, and fish.....................................................
   Fertilizers...     ..................................................... 400                        12,000
                                                                            200
   H ay........................................................................                         1,000

                                     ...........................
     Total.................................                                .........      25,700    1,223,000

Shipments:
   Coal, wood, lumber, etc         ... ..-.........
                                    -...          ........... ..................             209        1,898
   Agricultural products and miscellaneous supplies...........................               700       68, 000
     Total.........................      . . . ..................... .........."             .909      69,898

     Total receipts and shipments...........................       ..............         26,609    1,292, 898
                                   APPENDIX I-REPORT OF CAPTAIN                     RAND.               1167
                            Vessels sailing and trading in Tuckerton Creek, New Jersey.


                              Class.                No.     Aggregate.
                                                            tonnage.     Draft.              Remarks.


                                                                          Feet.
Schooners.................................             5           200        4
Sloops...................................             10           200        3
Catboats...............................              100           400        2l     In oyster and general mer-
Garveys................................              450         1,800        1i       chandise trade, etc. Days
Gunning and clam boats.................              150           300         13     not regular.
Power boats.............................              60           600   22 to 4

       Total...............................          775         3,500


  Power boats and steamers of a total of 666 tons, and sailing vessels of 463 total ton-
nage, repaired during the year.
  The foregoing statistics were furnished by Mr. Benjamin H. Crosby, Tuckerton, N. J.



                                                          I 8.

                IMPROVEMENT OF COLD SPRING INLET, NEW JERSEY.

   For the history of this improvement, see the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 210.
   At the close of the fiscal year 1908 contract was in force with the
Breakwater Construction and Engineering Company for construction
of jetties at Cold Spring Inlet, New Jersey. Later, upon reorganiza-
tion of the company, The Breakwater Company became, and was
recognized by the Comptroller of the Treasury as its legal assignee
and successor, and as such began work at the site on July 29, 1908,
and continued operations thereafter.
   Under date of May 12, 1909, supplementary articles of agree-
ment, dated March 23, 1909, were entered into with The Breakwater
Company. These were approved by the Chief of Engineers May 12
and by the Acting Secretary of War May 13, 1909, and provided for
the omission of the lower wales and the substitution of brush in place
of stone to a varying height of from half tide to high water for the pur-
pose of deflecting and directing the tidal current and facilitating the
work of scouring a channel through the bar of sufficient depth to
allow the passage of barges of stone for filling the jetty, in considera-
tion of which The Breakwater Company allows to the United States
a rebate of $1,170 and a deduction of $1.75 from the contract price
for each cubic yard of stone replaced by brush.
   To the end of the fiscal year the following work was done:
   In the pile, brush, and stone wing of the west jetty the driving of
piles, 300 in number, and the placing of waling and brush had been
completed, and 266 linear feet filled in with stone and completed.
   In the pile, brush, and stone portion of the west jetty pile driving
began September 5, 1908, and was completed April 17, 1909, 2,010
piles being driven in a length of 2,000 linear feet, and 4,010 feet of
top wales put in place, completing this part of the work, except for
brush and stone filling, on April 27, 1909. Brush was placed over a
length of 1,600 linear feet, but the storm of May 21 and 22 washed it
out in places and piled it up in other places, making it necessary
practically to relay all of the 1,600 feet. Pile tops were cut off for
a length of 1,690 linear feet, 40 feet of lower wale were placed at the
1168            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                  S. ARMY.


angle of the wing and jetty, 1 foot above mean low water, 20 feet
on the jetty and 20 feet on the wing, to strengthen the piling at the
angle before stone filling is placed, the depth of water at the angle
having increased to 10 feet at mean low water.
  In the west stone jetty the first load of stone was deposited March
24, 1909, and to June 30 about 23,681 net tons of stone had been
deposited.
   In the pile, brush, and stone wing of the east jetty pile driving be-
gan May 27, and to the end of the fiscal year 369 piles had been put
in place, 245 linear feet of upper wales bolted in place, and pile tops
cut off for a distance of 25 linear feet.
   In the east stone jetty the first load of stone was deposited August
21, 1908, and to June 30, 1909, about 51,398 net tons had been put
in place.
   In all, about 75,079 tons of stone have been placed in the jetties.


                                                   APPROPRIATIONS.

River and harbor act approved March 2, 1907............................. $311, 000
Sundry civil act approved May 27, 1908...................................     236, 200
Sundry civil act approved March 4, 1909.............................----..... 284, 000
      Total........................................................-----------------------------------------------------   831, 200
Contributed by Cape May Real Estate Company-----------------------...........................                              100, 000

          Total....................................-----------------------------------------------------                   931,200


                                               CONTRACT IN FORCE.

   With Breakwater Construction and Engineering Company, of New York, dated
January 18 and approved March 3, 1908, for jetty construction at Cold Spring Inlet,
New Jersey, The Breakwater Company legal assignee and successor, viz:
   Two hundred and eighty-five thousand tons stone, delivered in place in the stone
jetties, at $2 per ton of 2,000 pounds.
   Construction of 2,000 linear feet (including all material and labor) of pile, brush,
and stone jetty, at $16 per linear foot.
   Construction of 1,050 linear feet (including all material and labor) of pile, brush,
and stone wings, at $12 per linear foot.
   The work to be commenced within sixty days after date of notification of approval,
which was given April 20, 1908, and completed within two years and two months after
such notification.
   Supplementary articles of agreement with The Breakwater Company, dated March
23, 1909, approved by the Chief of Engineers May 12, and by the Acting Secretary of
War May 13, 1909, for omission of lower wale from pile, brush, and stone jetty, and re-
placing a quantity of stone by brush, The Breakwater Company, in consideration
thereof, to allow the United States a rebate of $1,170 for the omission of the wale and
$1.75 from the contract price for each cubic yard of stone replaced by brush.


                                                                 I 9.

              IMPROVEMENT OF WILMINGTON HARBOR, DELAWARE.

  For the history of this improvement, see Annual Report of the Chief
of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 212.
  At the close of the fiscal year 1908 work was in progress under a
contract with the Bowers Hydraulic Dredging Company, work under
which was completed on July 16, 1908. The quantity of material
removed in July was 17,870 cubic yards, and the entire quantity
              APPENDIX I--REPORT OF CAPTAIN RAND.                1169
removed under the contract was 350,194 cubic yards, measured in
place. The channel was dredged to a depth of 19 feet at mean low
water and a width of 250 feet from the 18-foot depth in Delaware
River to a point about 1,200 feet above Lobdells Canal, and 200 feet
wide and 19 feet deep from a point opposite the Harlan & Hollings-
worth Corporation's dry dock to a point about 150 feet above the
Market Street Bridge.
   Under date of July 17, 1908, an emergency contract was entered into
with The Rickards Dredging Company for dredging, at 19.5 cents per
cubic yard, place measurement, the work to be completed by Decem-
ber 17, 1908. Work thereunder was begun on August 10 and con-
tinued to November 30, 1908, when it was completed. During this
period the channel was dredged a length of 900 feet to a width of 100
feet and depth of 19 feet at mean low water from the Pennsylvania
Railroad cut-off bridge No. 3 to the mouth of the Brandywine, and
a length of 3,900 feet to a width of 100 feet and depth of 18 feet from
the Third Street Bridge to Market Street Bridge. These depths
included 1 foot overdepth allowed, where made, under the contract.
The quantity of material removed was 40,558 cubic yards, measured
in place, and consisted of sand and mud, which was placed behind
banks above the high-water line on meadows on the south side of the
river.
   Under date of April 2, 1909, the Chief of Engineers allotted $40,000
from the appropriation made by the river and harbor act of March 3,
1909, to be applied to the maintenance of improvement of Wilming-
ton Harbor and on the same date approved a project for the expendi-
ture of the available funds. This contemplates dredging at different
periods throughout the fiscal year, the depths and widths being
dependent upon the prices bid and the condition of the channel.
Proposals for the work were opened April 30, 1909. The lowest bid
was that of The Rickards Dredging Company, at 18 cents per cubic
yard, the work to be commenced in one hundred and eighty days,
instead of thirty days required by the specifications. As the public
interests required that the dredging be begun promptly, the next
higher bid, that of the American Dredging Company, which offered
to begin work within thirty days after notification of approval of the
contract, at 181 cents per cubic yard, place measurement, was
accepted by authority of the Chief of Engineers. Contract dated
May 11 and approved May 26, 1909, was accordingly entered into
with the American Dredging Company and notice of approval given
May 28, 1909. Work under this contract began on June 11, and to
the end of the fiscal year the channel was dredged to a width of 150
feet and a depth of 19 feet at mean low water from a point 75 feet
above Lobdells Canal to the Shellpot cut-off bridge No. 3, and from
a point about 300 feet below the inner end of the north jetty at the
mouth of the Christiana River for a length of about 600 feet up-
stream. The entire length of channel dredged is 3,325 feet. The
depth included 1 foot allowed under the contract for overdepth, where
made. The quantity of material removed is 32,280 cubic yards,
measured in place, and consisted of mud, which was deposited on the
Cherry Island marsh and on the north bank of the river above the
high-water line.
   Between July 10 and 17, 1908, under an emergency contract dated
June 30, 1908, entered into with Emil F. Petterson, of Wilmington,
     9001-ENG 1909-74
1170            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

Del., 18 stumps and logs and parts of 2 wrecks were removed from the
channel of the upper Christiana River above Churchman's bridge, at
a cost of $265.88, with an allotment approved by the Secretary of
War June 12, 1908, from the appropriation for emergencies made by
the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907.
                                         Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
  of improvement-.................................................---------------------------------------------a..     $280, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                  APPROPRIATIONS.

Previous projects, amount as per House Document 421, Fifty-seventh
  Congress, second session------------.............----------------.......                                    -
                                                                                                   ------..--.......... $384,606.00
Present project:
    June 3, 1896------------------------------------........................................         $20,000.00
    July 1, 1898------------------------------------....................................... 205, 846.00
    March 3, 1899 -----------------------------------......................................           45,000.00
    June 6, 1900-----------------------------------........................................          200,000.00
    June 13, 1902 -----------------------------------.......................................          50, 000.00
    March 3, 1905---- -------------------------------......................................           25, 000. 00
    March 3, 1905 (allotment Nov. 28, 1906) .............                                                 250.00
    March 2, 1907 .----------------------------------- 75, 000. 00
    March 2, 1907 (allotment Dec. 30, 1907) .............                                                 600.00
    March 2, 1907 (allotment June 12, 1908)------------..............--                                   650.00
    March 3, 1909 (allotment Apr. 2, 1909)------               .             ---.---...........---. 40, 000. 00
                                                                                                                         662, 346. 00
                                                                                   1, 046, 952. 00
                                                .
Received from sales of river and harbor property------ ---.---.--.--.--.---.............   667. 26

      Total- .....------------------------------------------------................................................- 1, 047,619. 26
Returned to the Treasury------------------------------------------...........................................            2, 474. 19
Returned to credit of appropriation for emergencies---------------...................-----.                                 749. 31


                                             CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

  With the Bowers Hydraulic Dredging Company, of Camden, N. J., for dredging
between the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad bridge and the Delaware River, at 15.9
cents per cubic yard, place measurement, the work upon the retaining basins to be
commenced within twenty days after notification of approval of contract and the
entire work completed within twelve months after such notification of approval.
Notification given June 10, 1907. Contract dated May 17 and approved June 6, 1907.
Time limit waived by authority of Chief of Engineers, June 24, 1908.
  Emergency contract with The Rickards Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa.,
dated July 17, 1908, for dredging at 19.5 cents per cubic yard, place measurement,
the work to be commenced within thirty days after acceptance of proposal, which
was July 17, 1908, and to be completed within five months.
  Emergency contract dated June 30, 1908, with Emil F. Petterson, of Wilmington,
Del., for removing 2 wrecks and 18 stumps and logs from the channel of the upper
Christiana River, Delaware. Work to be commenced within ten days from date of
contract and completed within sixty days from date of contract.
  With American Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., dated May 11, and
approved by the Chief of Engineers May 26, 1909, for dredging at 18) cents per cubic
yard, place measurement, overdepth, not to exceed one foot, half price, the work
to be commenced within thirty days after notification of approval of contract, which
was given May 28, 1909; work to be continued with funds available, until June 30,
1910, or until funds exhausted.
                             a Dredging, $190,000; repairs to jetty, $90,000.
                                              APPENDIX I-REPORT                              OF CAPTAIN RAND.                                                 1171
                                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The tonnage and value of the leading articles shipped to and from the port of Wil-
mington, by water, during the calendar year ending December 31, 1908, are as follows:
            Commercial statistics of the city of Wilmington, Del., for the calendar year 1908.

                                                                Articles.                                                                 Quantity.          Value.


                            DOMESTIC COMMERCE.a
Receipts:                                                                                                                                   Tons.
   Hides, ship timber, clay, coal, etc.   --..................................                                                              372,637     $24,809,206
   Chemicals, building materials, canned goods, etc .-.-------------------------                                                             11,846         661,196
   Agricultural products...---------------------------------------------                                                                    199,996       5,672,160
   Miscellaneous, not included above.... ------------------------                - -                                                         20,000       2,000,000
          Total receipts........................-------------------------------------------------604,479                                                 33,142,562
Shipments:
    Coal, quarry stone, clay, etc...-----------------------------------------42,013                                                                         432,963
    Manufactured products, leather, chemicals, iron supplies, machirnery, etc..... 35,831                                                                18,195,155
    Agricultural products...-----------------------------------------------           636                                                                   162,870
    Miscellaneous, not included above...------------------------------------       42,315                                                                 8,463,000
           Total shipments..........................--------------------------------------------I                                           120,795      27,253,988
           Total receipts and shipments, domestic..................................                                                         725,274      60,396,550
                                                         FOREIGN COMMERCE.b
Imports:
       Nitrate of soda...--------------------------------------------------                                                                  11,569            570,000
       Laths....                ..-----------------------------------------------------------                                                    930             2,300

            I,_U
Exports: t, ol
                Ttli-m
                . l., l ,o . ..  orts9
                                   ..    ..    ..    ..    ..    ..............
             Machinery..........................................................             ................
                                                                                                 - - --         - - --    - - .. .
                                                                                                                                             12L9

                                                                                                                                                623
                                                                                                                                                               572,300
                                                                                                                                                                57,564
           Total
           .ot                    exports,
                  imports and shipmen...
                 al..receiptsand.       .. forein
                                               o  .......................................
                                                  e i        ad .        rin-,---....-...
                                                                           ...                                      ...   ....    ...        13 129            629,864

           Total receipts and shipments, domestic and foreign.......................                                                        738,403      61,026,414

                                   a Furnished by the Wilmington Board of Trade.
                                   b Furnished by the United States collector of customs, Wilmington, Del.

                                              Vessels sailing and trading in Wilmington Harbor.
                                                   [Furnished by the Wilmington Board of Trade.]

                                                                                                  Registered
                                Class.                                          Name.              tonnage                Draft.                    Trips.
                                                                                                     each.

                                                                                                                           Feet.
Barges.............................. Various...........                                                          90            8   1 per day.
Schooners........................... .....
                                         do............                                                          55            6       Do.
       Do                            .....do............
               ............................                                                                     360           19   1 per month.
Naphtha launches or barges.......... .....do............                                                         14            3   15 per day 9 months in
                                                                                                                                     year.
10 harbor tugs.................                             ........        do.........               12 to 95            5 to 10 10 daily.
10 barges ........................                                      ... do............                 475                  8 1 weekly.
1 barge...                 ...................................                                              68                  4      Do.
1 schooner.........
1 barge............................
                                                                       Sandsnipe.........                   65                  6 2 per week.
                                                                       Seven.............                  170                  71 2 daily each way.
     Do............................                                    Nine..............                  140                  71     Do.
     Do..............................                                  Alice.... ..........                150                  72     Do.
     Do...............................                                 Century...........                  150                  71     Do.
     Do---------------------......................---........          Christiana.........                 200                  8      Do.
1 steamer...........................                                   Ulrica............                  205                  7 Daily.
     Do............................                                    Brandywine.....                     407                  8    32
                                                                                                                                       Do.
     Do..............................                                  City of Chester....                 611                  9      Do.
     Do..............................                                  Greensborough....                   250                  7  Every 2 or 3 months.
11 car floats-..........................
                         --------------------                          Various..........                   275                  6  Daily.
River tugs and steamers..............do...........                                                   50 to 100                  7  2 daily.
Sand barges...                   .....................                      do............                 300                  8 1 daily.
Yachts.........              ..........................                     do............           25 to 150            6 to 10 3 weekly, 9 months in
                                                                                                                                     year.
Dredges..................................do............                        250                                             10 1 per month.
Barges...........................................       .....
                                                            do......... 100 to 500                                        6 to 12 2 per month.

  Foreign vessels sailing and trading in Wilmington Harbor during the calendar year
1908, furnished by the United States collector of customs, port of Wilmington, Del.:
Eight vessels, aggregate tonnage, 18,003, and draft an average of about 18 feet.
1172                    REPORT OF THE                                   CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                      U.   S.   ARMY.


   In addition to the foregoing, there is invested in freight and passenger lines, domes-
tic, doing business in the harbor of Wilmington, approximately $1,500,000. These
lines carry freight valued at approximately $60,000,000 annually and about 600,000
passengers.
   There is invested in manufacturing and mercantile interests on the Christiana
River, all dependent upon the river's navigation facilities, fully $30,000,000. This
is exclusive of the investments on the Brandywine, tributary to the Christiana, and
which would amount to not less than $750,000.

                                                                                    Vessels built.

                                                                   Class.                                                             Wood.         Steel.        Tonnage.


Steam harbor lighters.......                   ................................................  ..         .   4                                                     1, 862
Lighter....                           ..........................................................    1.....                                                               350
Floating grainelevator........................................................ ....                       .     1                                                        632
Car floats...                    .........................................................          3        ....                                                     1,836
Dump scows.....                         .       . ..............                                    4 ........                                                        4,600
Coal barges............................................................3                                ...                                                           1,100
House barge.                                                                                                                               1-400
Steamere................................................................
Grain barge.................                                                          ............................-                        1            .51,760
                                                                                                                                                       .750
Steamers..."5                                                                                                                                                         1,680

           Total................................                                              ...........................                  13               10       13,210


                                                                                 Vessels repoaired.

                                                                       Class.                                                                  Number. Tonnage.


Steam tugs.......................................................................                                                                           12           313
Fishing steamers.................................................................                                                                            3           559
Steamships......................................................................                                                                            14       27,237
     D o....................                   ..........................................................                                      ..........           123,000
Sailing vessels and barges........................................................                                                                          9         3,725
Steam yachts.... -                              .........................................................                                                   5         2, 338
Power launches ...                           ...........................................................                                                    2              6
Steamboats..................................................................                                                                                5         2,062
Pilot boats:
     Steam ...........................................................................                                                                      2           718
     Sailing................                     .........................................................                                                  2           156
Light-ships.......................................................................                                                                          3           984
U. S.revenue cutter..............................................................                                                                           1           795
Barges. ...................................................................                                                                                 4         1,205
Light-house tender...........................................................                                                                               1           458
Ferryboat .......................................................................                                                                           1           656

           Total tonnage.......................................................................                                                                     164,212



                                  Vessels under construction.
     One barge, 350 tons.
     One scow, 1,000 tons.
     One steel-hull steam yacht, 180 feet long.
     One steel-hull steam yacht, 170 feet long.
     One steel-hull ferryboat, 100 feet long.
     One steel-hull ferryboat, 80 feet long.
     One steel-hull mine planter, 168 feet long.



                                                                                            I I0.
IMPROVEMENT OF APPOQUINIMINK, MURDERKILL, AND MISPILLION
                   RIVERS, DELAWARE.

                                                            (A)        APPOQUINIMINK                                    RIVER.

  For the history of this improvement, see the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 214.
  No work was done during the fiscal year. No contract in force.
                                      APPE3-DIX I-REPORT OF CAPTAIN RAND.                                                                                                 1173
                                                       Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement.................................        $7,400
   For maintenance of improvement............................6, 000
                                                                                                                                                                      $13, 400
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                                         APPROPRIATIONS.
Present project:
    September 19, 1890..............................................                                                    $5, 000. 00
    July 13, 1892...................................................                                                     5 , 000.00
    August 18, 1894----------------------------------------------....................................................    5,000.00
    June 3, 1896-------------------------------------------------......................................................  5 , 000.00
    March 3, 1899....................................................------------------------------------------------. 55,000.00
    June 13, 1902 (allotment July 30, 1902)---------------------------..............................                     3 ,000.00
    June 13, 1902 (allotment June 23, 1904)---------------------------............................. -4 , 000.00
    March 3, 1905 (allotment Apr. 18, 1905)...........................                                                   5, 500. 00
    March 3, 1905 (allotment Mar. 20, 1907)..............................                                                    100. 00
    March 2, 1907 (allotment Mar. 20, 1907).............................                                                 5 , 000.00
    March 3, 1909 (allotment June 29, 1909).............................                                                 5, 000.00

                                                                                                                                                                    47, 600. 00
                                     --------------------------------------
Received from sales of property...............................                                                                                                          150.00

      Total.........................................................----------------------------------------------------                                            47, 750.00
Returned to Treasury------------------------------------------------...................................................                                                   3.09


      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                       Receipts and shipments.

                                                                     Class.                                                                     i Quantity.              Value.


Receipts:                                                                                                                                           Tons.
      Coal-----------------------------------------------------------........................................................................            2,250             $13,500
      Fertilizers------------------------------------------------------...................................................................               6,400              96,000
      Potatoes---------------------------------------------------------....................................................................                290              11,600
      General merchandise....----------------------------------------------                                                                              6, 500            650,000
                                     -------------------------------------------------
          Total............................                                                                                                             15,440             771,100
Shipments:
      Canned goods.............................................................----------------------------------------------------                      1,950             122,850
      Agricultural products-butter, eggs,fruit, grain, poultry, etc---------------................. --                                                  10, 685            743, 625
      General merchandise.....................................................----------------------------------------------.                            2,900             304, 750

          Total.....................................................................                                                                     15,535          1,171,225
          Total receipts and shipments...........................--------------------------------------                                                  30, 975         1,942, 325


                                         Vessels trading in Appoquinimink River, Delaware.

                                               Class.                                                        No.          Aggregate
                                                                                                                          tonnage.              Draft.             Remarks.

                                                                                                                                                Feet.
Steamer................................................                                                            1                   115         6        Semiweekly.
   Do...................................................                                                            1              175              7       Transient.
     .....................................................
Tug ---------------------------------------------                                                                   1 ............                  6          Do.
Gasoline boat-------------------------------------............................................                     1                  125           6              Do.
   Do-------------------------------------------...................................................1   100 6l Do.
Barges-------------------------------------------..................................................  2 400 5  Do.

          Total.............................................                                                       7                   915..


    The above statistics were furnished by Mr. F. B. Watkins, Odessa, Del.
1174            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                  (B)      MURDERKILL RIVER.

   For the history of this improvement, see the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 216.
   At the close of last fiscal year work which had been begun on June
30, 1908, was in progress under a contract made with the Pennsyl-
vania Dredging Company for dredging at 9.4 cents per cubic yard,
place measurement. This work continued to August 8, when it was
completed, the time limit having been waived by authority of the
Chief of Engineers dated July 25, 1908. The channel was dredged
across the flats to the 6-foot depth in Delaware Bay, a length of 3,200
feet, and shoals were dredged in the river at Lindle's, Barren Island,
Lower Canal, Coles Cut, Godwins, Postles Landing, and at the steam-
boat wharf at Frederica, an aggregate length of 7,400 feet, resulting
in a continuous channel at least 6 feet deep at mean low water, and at
least 50 feet wide from Frederica to the 6-foot curve in Delaware Bay.
The entire quantity of material removed is 27,917 cubic yards, meas-
ured in place, and consisted of mud and sand, with some clay and
gravel at times. That dredged in the river was thrown over upon the
adjacent banks above the high-water line, and that dredged across the
flats was thrown over along the cut on the south side.
                                               Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June
30, 1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement................................... $15, 000
   For maintenance of improvement............................     6, 000
                                                                                                                $21, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                  APPROPRIATIONS.
Present project:
    July 13, 1892...................................................                                              $7,000. 00
    August 18, 1894---------------------------------------------................................................. a6,500.00
    June 3, 1896............................-------------------------------------------------.................     6,500.00
    March 3, 1899 ..-----------------------------------------------                                                5, 000.00
    June 13, 1902 (allotment July 30, 1902)..---------------------------2,000.00
    April 28, 1904 (allotment June 16, 1904)-------------------        .-------                                    5, 500.00
    March 3, 1905 (allotment Apr. 18, 1905)------------------------...........................-5,                     500.00
    March 3, 1905 (allotment Apr. 3, 1906)---------------------------............................                  3, 860.00
    March 2, 1907 (allotment Mar. 20, 1907)--------------------------...........................                   8,000.00
    March 2, 1907 (allotment Apr. 18, 1908)--------------------------...........................                   3,000.00
    March 3, 1909 (allotment May 1, 1909)----------------------------............................                  7,000.00
         Total ........................................................
                  -           - --                                      -                                   a59, 860.00
Expended at mouth of St. Jones River, Delaware......................                                          1, 500.00
Returned to Treasury................................................                                             409.01

                                                                                                               1, 909. 01
                                                    CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  With the Pennsylvania Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., dated May 20,
1908, for dredging, at 9.4 cents per cubic yard, place measurement, the work to be com-
menced within twenty days after date of contract and completed within two months.
Amount, $3,400. Time limit waived by authority of Chief of Engineers dated July 25,
1908.

a Of this amount, $1,500 was expended in removing shoal at mouth of St. Jones River,
Delaware.
                       APPENDIX I-REPORT OF CAPTAIN                                      RAND.                          1175
  COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR                                 YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31,                           1908.

                                            Receipts and shipments.

                                           Class.                                                   Quantity.         Value.

Receipts:                                                                    Tons.
                                                                               5, 760
   Coal, fish, oysters, phosphate, etc...........................................                                        $46,000
   Lumber, shingles, fertilizers, etc.............................................
                                                                               6,080                                     237,000
   Hay, Aorses, cattle, etc.....................................................463                                       36,100
   General merchandise.....----------------------------------------------      1,000                                     200,000
     Total....................................................................                         13,303            519,100
Shipments:
    Canned goods, baskets, etc.................................................
                                                                     2,850   170,000
   Agricultural products ................................................
                                                                   -      12,325                                         369,700
   General merchandise....----------------------------------------------                                1,000            100,000
     Total                                                                                             1,-----------------------------------------------
                                                                                                       16,175            639,700

     Total receipts and shipments ........................--------------------------------------.      29, 478        1,158, 800



                    Vessels sailing and trading in Murderkill Rileer, Delaware.
  There is a steamer with a tonnage of 293 and a draft of 6 feet trading in the Murderkill
River making two or three trips a week; also about one hundred motor boats.
  One steamer of 293 tons, and twenty sailing and motor boats of a total of 500 tons,
repaired during the year.
  The foregoing statistics were furnished by J. W. Townsend, secretary Frederica and
Philadelphia Steamboat Company, Frederica, Del.

                                         (c)   MISPILLION             RIVER.

   For the history of this improvement, see the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 217.
   At the close of the fiscal year 1908 operations were in progress under
contract with the River and Harbor Improvement Company for
dredging in the river and across the flats at the mouth. Only the
dredging of about 200 feet at New Wharf Landing and some dredging
at the mouth remained to complete the contract work. This was
completed on July 18, 1908, the quantity of material removed being
5,558 cubic yards, measured in place, consisting of mud and sand,
which was thrown over upon the flats on the south side of the cut.
The operations under the contract resulted in a channel not less than
5 feet deep at mean low water and 50 feet wide from the 4-foot curve
in Delaware Bay to the light-house, and not less than 6 feet deep and
40 feet wide thence to the electric light works in the town of Milford.
Along the south jetty the channel has a depth of from 5 to 6 feet and
a width of from 50 to 100 feet, due to scouring.
                                   Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement................................. a$44, 325
   For maintenance of improvement-dredging................7, 000
                                                                                                                -    $51, 325
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                               aJetty work, $20,000; dredging, $24,325.
1176                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                      S. ARMY.

                                                                    APPROPRIATIONS.
Previous projects:
    Amount as per House Document 421, Fifty-seventh Congress,
      second session.....     ..................................           $57, 850
    April 28, 1904 (allotment June 16, 1904)....................1,              800
    March 3, 1905-
        Allotment April 18, 1905.............................9,000
        Allotment March 24, 1906...               ........................  10, 000
                                                                                                                                               a $78, 650
Present project:
    March 2, 1907 (allotment Mar. 20, 1907).....................                                                                   40,000
    March 3, 1909 (allotment June 15, 1909)....................                                                                     7,000
                                                                                                                                                 47,000
          Total........................................-----------------------------------------------------                                    125, 650



                                                                 CONTRACT IN                    FORCE.

  Contract of River and Harbor Improvement Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., for
dredging, at 12.2 cents per cubic yard, place measurement, the work to be commenced
within thirty days after notification of approval of contract, which was given March 21,
1908, and completed by June 15, 1908. Time limit waived by authority of the Chief
of Engineers dated June 2, 1908.



    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                  Receipts and shipments.

                                                                 Class.                                                          Quantity.       Value.


Receipts:                                                                         . Tons.
    Raw bone, coal, phosphate rock, timber, etc............................          47,475  $527,750
Bricks, fertilizers, lumber, etc--------------..................................................
                                                                                     19,755   472,150
    Hay,horses, hogs, etc....----------------------------------------------           4,203   210,000
    General merchandise...            ...........................................    20,000 1,700,000
       Total..................................................                                                   ..........          91,433      2,909,900
Shipments:
    Cord wood, logs, railroad ties, etc....                               ................................                           30,185          73,000
    Baskets, canned goods, fruits, etc.....                .................................                                        30, 937      1,322, 500
    Berries, cattle, grain, poultry, etc......................................                                                      18, 479        801, 950
       Total..................................................                                                   ..........          79,601      2,197,450
       Total receipts and shipments......................................                                                           171,034      5,107,350



                              Vessels sailing and trading in Mispillion River, Delaware.


                                           Class.                                           Number. Aggnegate
                                                                                                    tonnage.                    Draft.        Remarks.


                                                                                                                                Feet.
Steamer..............................................                                                        1          132        6 Triweekly.
    Do..............................................                                                         1           140         6         Do.
    Do..............................................                                                         1          300          4   Irregular.
    Do..............................................                                                         1          150          7         Do.
Sailing vessels.....................................                                     --               6             610     5 to 7   Weekly.
                                                      10
       Total............................................                                                             1,332

  aReturned to Treasury, $159.93; transferred to Appoquinimink River, Delaware, improvement, $100.
                  APPENDIX I-REPORT OF CAPTAIN                 RAND.              1177
  Four wooden freight steamers, 1 sailing vessel, and 2 oil barges, draft from 5 feet to
7 feet and an aggregate tonnage of 1,430, built during the year.
  One steamer of 150 tons and one sailing vessel of 130 tons repaired during the year.
  One freight steamer of 300 tons, 8 feet draft, and 1 sailing vessel of 225 tons, 6 feet
draft, under construction.
  An additional freight steamer is to be put in service during the coming year.
  The foregoing statistics were furnished by Mr. J. Stanley Short, of Milford, Del.



                                         I II.
             IMPROVEMENT OF ST. JONES RIVER, DELAWARE.

   For previous history of this improvement, see the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 219.
   At the close of the fiscal year 1908 work was in progress under an
emergency contract dated May 11, 1908, with The Rickards Dredging
Company for dredging Smyrna and St. Jones rivers, Delaware.
Work under the contract on the St. Jones River continued to July 28,
1908, when it was completed, removing 16,832 cubic yards of material,
consisting of mud and sand. Under this contract the channel was
dredged from the mouth to the 6-foot depth in Delaware Bay, and in
the river at various points a total length of about 4,000 feet. The
widths made were 40 feet in the river and 50 feet at the mouth, with
side slopes of 1 on 1 and a depth of 7 feet at mean low water, which
includes 1 foot overdepth allowed by the contract. The amount
expended for this work was $2,971.67.

                          Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
  provem ent.......... ....................................................    $6, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
  and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                 APPROPRIATIONS.

Amount as per House Document 421, Fifty-seventh Congress, second ses-
  sion......      .................................................      $49,500. 00
March 3, 1905 (allotment Feb. 9, 1906).................................       150. 00
March 3, 1905 (allotment Mar. 9, 1906)..................................   9, 500. 00
March 2, 1907........................................................      3, 000. 00
March 2, 1907 (allotment Apr. 9, 1908)..................................   3, 000. 00
March 3, 1909 (allotment June 11, 1909).................................   7, 000. 00
      Total.........................................................          72, 150. 00
Returned to Treasury.................................................          1, 593. 50
1178                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                     CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Emergerncy contract of The Rickards Dredging Company, of Philadelphia, Pa.,
dated May 11, 1908, for dredging at 10 cents per cubic yard, place measurement, in
conjunction with dredging on Smyrna River, Delaware, the work to be commenced
May 31 and completed August 31, 1908. Total dredging St. Jones River, $2,700.
Completed July 28, 1908.


       COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                      Receipts and shipments.

                                                                     Class.                                                                             Quantity.     Value.

Receipts:                                                                                            Tons.
   Raw bone, coal, wood, fish, sand, etc...----------------------------------16,555                                                                                     $37,375
   Canned goods, fertilizers, lumber, etc.........                          ........................   29,348                                                           398,003
   Cattle, horses, hogs, and sheep..............................................                        1,360                                                           154,000
   General merchandise.......................................................                         100,000                                                         1,800,000

          Total-           -      -      -        -       -      -      -         -   -      --..............................................              147,263    2,389,378

Shipments:
       Cord wood, bricks, canned goods, fertilizers, etc.............................                                                                       7,170        239, 600
       Butter, cattle, fruit, etc....................................................                                                                      10,880        657,800
       General merchandise.......................................................                                                                          70,000      1,200,000
          Total-           -      -          -        -   ...................
                                                               -       -      -       --..................                 ..............                  88,050     2,097,400

          Total receipts and shipments............................................                                                                        235,313      4,486,778



                                  Vessels sailing and trading in St. Jones River, Delaware.


                                   Class.                                             Number.                tonnage.e                  Draft.                Remarks.


                                                                                                                                            Feet.
Steamer......................................                                                     1                   220                           6   4 to 6 trips a week.
   Do-----------------------------------.......................................                 10
                                                                                   2----------------------Do.
                                                                                                                    1,000                   4 to    6   Occasionally.
Tugs--------         ---------------------------.........................................
Schooners and sloops------------------------.........................             80            4,500         31 to 6                                       Do.
Gasoline launches--------------------------............................          50               500          3 to 6                                       Do.
          Total................................                                               143                   6,220


  The foregoing statistics were furnished by the Dover and Philadelphia Navigation
Company, of Dover, Del.


                                                                                          I 12.

                               IMPROVEMENT OF SMYRNA RIVER, DELAWARE.

   For previous history, see Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1909, Part 1, page 220.
   No work done during the fiscal year. No contract in force.
                                                          Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
provement----................................-............................. $7, 500
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                     APPENDIX I-REPORT                                      OF CAPTAIN RAND.                         1179
                                                                        APPROPRIATIONS.

Project of 1878, amount as per House Document 421, Fifty-
  seventh Congress, second session....................................                                           $10,000.00
Project of 1887:
    August 11, 1888.......................................-------------------------------------. $10, 000
    September 19, 1890.....................................------------------------------------. 5, 000
    July 13, 1892-----------------------------------------....................                            3,000
    August 18, 1894---------------------------------------...........................................     5,000
    June 3,1896------------------------------------------...................                              5,000
    March   3, 1899----------------------------------------.............................................  5, 000
    June 13, 1902----------------------------------------....................                            15, 000
    June 13, 1902 (allotment June 25, 1904)--------------------....................                       6, 000
    March 3, 1905----------------------------------------....................                             5, 365
    March 3, 1905 (allotment Apr. 19, 1906).....................                                          1, 600
    March 2, 1907...........................................-----------------                             2, 000
    March 2, 1907 (allotment Apr. 6. 1908)......................                                          2, 500
    March 3, 1909 (allotment June 9, 1909)................-....-..                                        6, 500
                                                                                                                  71, 965.00

                                                                         81, 965.00
      Total.........................................................--------
Returned to credit of appropriation.....................................  4, 157.37



      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                      Receipts and shipments.

                                                                   Class.                                            Quantity.      Value.


Receipts:                                                                                                               Tons.
   Raw bone, coal, iron ore, phosphate rock, etc......                        .................                           7,410       $85,700
   Canned goods, fertilizers, flour, millwork, etc...............................                                           8,928     225,000
   Butter, corn, wheat, oats, cattle, hogs, etc..................................                                          52,293     563,300
   General merchandise.......................................................                                              10,000   1,000,000

        Total.................................................................                                             78,631   1,874,000

Shipments:
    Railroad ties, ship timber, etc..............................................                                          76,520     290,000
   Canned goods, flour, millwork, etc...........................................                                           10,020     354,000
    Fruit, grain, cattle, poultry, etc.............................................                                        25,909   1,329,000
    General merchandise.......................................................                                             12,000   1,200,000

        Total...................................................................                                          124,449   3,173,000

        Total receipts and shipments............................................                                        203, 080    5, 047,000


                                   Vessels sailing and trading in Smyrna River, Delaware.


              Class.                        Number.             Aggregate
                                                                tonnage.           Draft.                      Remarks.


                                                                                    Feet.
Steamer................                                   1                  234        6   3 months triweekly; balance of year daily.
   Do.................                                    1                  100        6   3 months daily; balance of year irregularly.
Gasoline barge.........                                   1                  200        6   Irregularly.
   Do................                                     1                   50        6       Do.
        Total............                                4                   584


  In addition to the foregoing there are numerous tugs with barges and floats and a
number of schooners and other sailing vessels that trade in the river, of which no record
has been kept. These carry hay, wood, fish, oysters, lime, shells, etc.
  Steam and gasoline vessels of an aggregate of 200 tons and sailing vessels of an aggre-
gate of 100 tons repaired during the year.
  The foregoing statistics were furnished by Mr. A. E. Jardine, secretary, Philadelphia
and Smyrna Transportation Company, Smyrna, Del.
1180     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                  I 13.

         IMPROVEMENT OF BROADKILL RIVER, DELAWARE.

    For the history of this improvement, see the Annual Report of the
Chief of Engineers for 1909, Part 1, page 222.
    At the close of the fiscal year ending June 30, 1908, work was in
progress in the construction of a jetty on the north side of the new
entrance at the mouth and in making the new channel across Lewes
Cape. The jetty on section 2, extending from the high-water line of
Delaware Bay to the low-water line of Lewes Sound, a length of 468
feet, had been completed, and the work on section 1, extending out
into Delaware Bay from the high-water line, was well advanced.
This work was done under the contract of the Latta & Terry Con-
struction Company and operations thereunder were continued until
November 28, 1908, when it was completed, the time limit having
been waived under authority of the Chief of Engineers dated August
4, 1908. The length of jetty constructed is 250 linear feet of pile and
stone jetty in section No. 1, extending out from the high-water line
of Delaware Bay to the 61 to 7 foot depth; 468 linear feet of pile and
sheet pile jetty in section No. 2, extending from the high-water line
of Delaware Bay to the low-water line of Lewes Sound: and 545
linear feet of pile jetty filled with brush and stone in section No. 3,
extending out from the low-water line on the easterly side of Lewes
Sound across the sound to the high-water line in the marsh on its
western side-a total length of 1,263 feet. The amount expended
for this work during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was
$12,474.91.
    Under date of October 20, 1908, the Secretary of War approved an
allotment of $4,500 from the emergency appropriation made by the
river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, to be applied to the restoration
of a portion of the jetty which was becoming undermined; and
under date of December 5, 1908, an additional allotment of $3,200
from the same appropriation. After due advertisement, emergency
contract dated October 23, 1908, was made with the Tatnall-Brown
Company, of Wilmington, Del., for the expenditure of the first-
named allotment, and supplemental contract, dated December 16,
1908, approved by the Chief of Engineers January 13, and by the
Assistant Secretary of War January 14, 1909, for the second allot-
ment, at prices, in place, as follows: Forty-five foot piles, $8 each;
30-foot piles, $5.50 each; 20-foot piles, $4 each; 6-inch by 12-inch
wales, 18 feet long, $6 each; stone, $4.50 per cubic yard; brush, $5
per cord; drift bolts, 20 cents each; tie rods, including nuts and
washers, $1 each. Work was begun on November 6, 1908, and con-
tinued to April 1, 1909. During this period ten 45-foot piles were
driven, closing the 12-foot gap, one hundred and ten 30-foot piles,
seventy 20-foot piles, and 389 cords of brush, 571 cubic yards of
stone, etc., were placed in position, at a cost of $7,282.67. In addi-
tion to the foregoing, a fender wale was placed under the wale pieces
for a length of 1,104 feet, for the protection of the jetty from passing
boats, at a cost of $250, making the total cost of this work during
the fiscal year $7;,32.67.
    The dredging in progress at the close of the fiscal year ending June
30, 1908, was carried to completion on September 9, 1908, the time
                            APPENDIX I-REPORT OF CAPTAIN RAND.                                                                           1181

limit having been waived by authority of the Chief of Engineers
dated June 4, 1908, making a cut 6 feet deep at mean low water and
150 feet wide at bottom from the 6-foot depth in Delaware Bay to
the same depth in Lewes Sound, a length of 1,785 feet. The quantity
of material removed is 67,960 cubic yards, measured in place. It
consisted of sand, except at the Delaware Bay end, where it was
almost wholly mud; it was deposited partly on the Delaware Bay
flats, about one-half mile above the new mouth, and partly in Lewes
Sound, not less than one-half mile north of the jetty. The cost of
this dredging during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was
$12,990.76.

                                    Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
  improvement.......................................................--------------------------------------------------. $10,000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                    APPROPRIATIONS.

Project of March 3, 1873, amount as per House Document 421, Fifty-seventh
  Congress, second session.............................................-----------------------------------------.. $35,000
Present project:
       Act approved March 2, 1907                                                    --...................---..............   $33, 330
       River and harbor act approved March 2, 1907 (allot-
        ments)-
           October 20, 1908.................................. $4, 500
           December 5, 1908-----------------------------................................ 3, 200
                                                                                                                                7, 700
       Act March 3, 1909 (allotment June 28, 1909)...................                                                           3, 000
                                                                                                                                         44, 030
                                                                                                                                         79, 030
Received from sale of property-----.................-..........                                                                              100

          Total................................................------------------------------------------------------                    79, 130

Returned to credit of appropriation for emergencies in river and harbor
works----.......................................................-----------------------------------------------------.......            167.33



                                               CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

   Contract with Latta & Terry Construction Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., dated
September 11 and approved October 2, 1907, for construction of jetty, viz, section 1,
about 230 linear feet, at $20.20 per foot; section 2, about 500 linear feet, at $8 per foot;
section 3, about 650 linear feet, at $11.35 per foot; the work to be commenced within
thirty days and completed within eleven months after notification of approval by the
Chief of Engineers, which was given October 5, 1907. Time limit waived by authority
of the Chief of Engineers dated August 4, 1908.
   Contract with River and Harbor Improvement Company, dated November 7 and
approved December 2, 1907, for dredging (about 90,000 cubic yards) at 19.2 cents per
cubic yard place measurement, the work to be commenced within thirty days and
completed within four months after notification of approval by the Chief of Engineers.
Time limit waived by authority of the Chief of Engineers, dated June 4, 1908.
   Emergency contract with the Tatnall-Brown Company, of Wilmington, Del., dated
October 23, 1908, for reenforcing jetty, at following prices in place: Forty-five foot
1182          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                               U.     S. ARMY.

piles, $8 each; 30-foot piles, $5.50 each; 20-foot piles, $4 each; 6-inch by 12-inch
wales, 18 feet long, $6 each; stone, $,1.50 per cubic yard; brush, $5 per cord; drift bolts,
20 cents each; tie-rods, including nuts and washers, $1 each; the work to be com-
menced within fifteen days after date of contract and completed within one hundred
and twenty days from date of contract.
   Supplemental contract with the Tatnall-Brown Company, of Wilmington, Del.,
dated December 16, 1908, approved by the Chief of Engineers January 13 and by
Assistant Secretary of War January 14, 1909, for additional work and materials at the
same prices, the work to be commenced within ten days after notification of approval
of contract, which was given January 20, 1909, and to be completed within one hun-
dred and five days after said notification.



   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                    Receipts and shipments.


                                                    Class.                                                  Quantity.      Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                       Tons.
   Raw bone, coal, phosphate rock, etc.........................................                                   7,500    $142, 500
   Chem icals, fertilizers, hay,       etc.................................................
   General merchandise..........................................................
                                                                                                                  1,100
                                                                                                                    250
                                                                                                                             21,100
                                                                                                                             25,000
      Total      ..........................................................                                       8,850     188, 600
Shipments:
    Cord wood, logs, railroad ties, ship timber, etc...............................                              15, 640     50, 300
    Canned goods, fruit, flour, etc................................................                               9,075     447,000
    Butter, eggs, cattle, corn, wheat, etc......................................                                  1,557      64, 925
      Total......................................................................                                26,272     562,225
      Total receipts and shipments............................                            ...........            35,122     750, 825


                    Vessels sailing and trading in Broadcill River, Delaware.


                              Class.                                           Num-
                                                                               ber.   Aggre'ate
                                                                                      tos age.       Draft.          Remarks.


                                                                                                        Feet.
Steamer.............................................                              1         100              7 Twice a week.
Schooners............................................                             5         357         5 to 6 Once a week.
      Total...........................................                            6         457 ..


  Also numerous other vessels of which no record is kept.
  One wooden vessel, 100 tons and 5 feet draft, built, and steamers and sailing vessels
of a total tonnage of 600 repaired during the year.
  The foregoing statistics were furnished by Capt. James H. Palmer, of Milton, Del.



                                                                       1 14.
REMOVING          SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING                                                            OR ENDAN-
                           GERING NAVIGATION.

   Wreck of schooner Florence I. Lockwood, lying sunk in the channel off
the eid of the town of Chincoteague, Va. Under date of August 31,
1908, the Secretary of War approved an allotment of $2,000 for the
removal of the wreck of schooner Florence I. Lockwood, lying sunk in
the channel off the end of the town of Chincoteague, Va. After due
advetisement an emergency contract, dated September 25, 1908, was
made with the lowest bidders, Johnston & Virden, of Lewes, Del., at
              APPENDIX I-REPORT OF      CAPTAIN RAND.            1183
$690. Operations under this contract were begun on October 17 and
completed on October 22, 1908. The wreck was broken up by means
of dynamite and the debris placed ashore above the high-water line.
                                               $885.02.
The entire cost, including inspection, etc., was
   Wreck of the steamship Gulf Stream, lying sunk in the Atlantic Ocean
at the entrance to Hereford Inlet, New dJersey.-Under date of October
8, 1908, the Secretary of War approved an allotment of $4,000 for the
removal of the wreck of the steamship Gulf Stream, which was lying
sunk in the Atlantic Ocean at the entrance to Hereford Inlet, New
Jersey. After due advertisement an emergency contract, dated
November 6, 1908, was entered into with the lowest bidder, Eugene
Boehm, of Atlantic City, N. J., at $1,512. Work under the contract
was begun on November 13 and completed on November 20, 1908.
The wreck was completely broken up by means of dynamite. The
entire cost, including inspection, etc., was $1,567.49.
    Wreck of barge Homeward Bound, lying sunk in Mantua Creek, New
Jersey.-On November 4, 1908, the Chief of Engineers allotted $500
for the removal of the wreck of the barge Homeward Bound, lying sunk
in Mantua Creek, about 1 mile above the highway bridge at Paulsboro,
N. J., and after due advertisement emergency contract, dated Decem-
ber 1, 1908, was entered into with Eugene Boehm, of Atlantic City,
N. J., the lowest bidder, at $189. Work under the contract was begun
on December 7 and completed December 10, 1908. The wreck was
blown up by means of dynamite. A part of the wreckage was placed
ashore above the high-water line and the remainder taken away by
fishermen for use as firewood. The total cost, including inspection,
etc., was $312.80.
    Wrecks of barges Sally and Bennie, lying sunk in Oldmans Creek, New
Jersey.-Under date of December 17, 1908, the Secretary of War
approved an allotment of $600 for the removal of the wrecks of two
barges, named the Sally and Bennie, respectively, lying sunk in Old-
mans Creek, New Jersey. After due advertisement an emergency
contract, dated January 16, 1909, was entered into with Eugene
Boehm, of Atlantic City, N. J., the lowest bidder, at $342. Work was
begun on January 18 and completed January 30, 1909. The wrecks
were blown up by means of dynamite and the d6bris placed ashore
above the high-water line. The entire cost, including inspection, etc.,
was $453.61.
    Wreck of the Adeline Townsend off the Capes of Delaware.-Upon
report received by the Chief of Engineers from the Revenue-Cutter
Service that the wreck of the Adeline Townsend had been discovered
off the Capes of Delaware, "within the 3-mile limit," investigation
was made and report submitted thereon that the wreck would prob-
ably not be a menace to navigation and that she could not be defi-
nitely located; that the last seen of the wreck was when a mast was
removed by a local wrecker while it was lying in about 8 fathoms of
water; that various portions of the vessel had been brought in by
different wreckers and that it was probable that the wreck had
entirely gone to pieces. Under date of February 3, 1909, the Chief
of Engineers allotted the sum of $100 to defray the expenses of locat-
ing the wreck, if possible, and to ascertain whether or not it was a
menace to navigation; and on March 20, 1909, it was reported that
the wreck was not a menace to navigation. The $100 allotted was
therefore returned to the Treasury to the credit of the appropriation.
1184    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,        U. S. ARMY.

    Wreck of steam yacht Viva, lying sunk in Absecon Inlet, New
Jersey.-Under date of March 20, 1909, the Chief of Engineers
allotted $400 for the removal of the wreck of the steam yacht Viva,
lying sunk in about 8 feet of water in Absecon Inlet, New Jersey,
and about 150 feet from the mean low-water line. After due adver-
tisement, emergency contract dated April 12, 1909, was entered
into with the lowest bidders, Van Sant & Gandy, of Atlantic City,
N. J., at $69. Work under thecontract was begun on April 22 and,
after numerous delays on account of stormy weather, was com-
pleted on May 3, 1909. The wreck was blown up with dynamite,
and upon the conclusion an area over a radius of 350 feet from the
late site of the wreck was swept over thoroughly and no traces of the
wreck found. The entire cost, including inspection, etc., was $155.20.
   NOTE.--Wreck of sunken barge three-fourths mile from shore off
Ocean City, N. J.-Under date of August 3, 1908, the Secretary of
the Treasury transmitted to the Secretary of War a letter dated
July 31, 1908, from the commanding officer of the revenue cutter
Mohawk, reporting a sunken barge (name not given) three-fourths of
a mile from shore off Ocean City, N. J., and requesting authority to
destroy the derelict; and under date of August 8, 1908, the Secretary
of the Treasury was informed that the War Department would be
pleased to have the wreck destroyed by a vessel of the Revenue-
Cutter Service as proposed, the cost thereof to be paid by future
allotment from the appropriation provided by section 20 of the river
and harbor act approved March 3, 1899. No further information has
been received in the matter.
                               APPENDIX J.


IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE 
   BALTIMORE, MARYLAND, DISTRICT.


REPORT OF MAJ. W. E. CRAIGHILL, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, OFFICER
   IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.

                                IMPROVEMENTS.


1. Patapsco River and channel to Bal-        6. Harbors at Rockhall, Queenstown,
     timore, Maryland.                            Claiborne, and Cambridge, and
2. Channel to Curtis Bay, in Patapsco             Chester, Choptank, Warwick, Po-
     River, Baltimore Harbor, Mary-               comoke, La Trappe, and Mano-
     land.                                        kin rivers, and Tyaskin Creek,
3. Harbor of Southwest B a 1 t i m o r e          Maryland.
     (Spring Garden), Maryland.              7. Nanticoke River, Delaware a n d
4. Elk River, Maryland.                           Maryland.
5. Susquehanna River, above and be-          8. Broad Creek River, Delaware.
     low Havre de Grace, Maryland.           9. Wicomico River, Maryland.
                                            10. Crisfield Harbor, Maryland.



                                   STATES ENGINEER OFFICE,
                               UNITED
                                      Bltimore, Md., July 1, 1909.
  SIR: I have the honor to forward herewith the annual reports for
the year ended June 30, 1909, for the works of improvement of rivers
and harbors in my charge.
       Very respectfully,                  W. E. CRAIGHILL,
                                        Major, Corps of Engineers.
  The CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. Army.



                                       J   I.

IMPROVEMENT OF PATAPSCO RIVER AND CHANNEL TO BALTIMORE,
                       MARYLAND.

   Continuing contracts were in progress with the Maryland Dredging
and Contracting Company, dated July 5, 1905, for dredging hard ma-
terial in the sections of the channel near Baltimore, Md., at 20 cents
per cubic yard, and in the channel opposite York Spit, at 23 cents
per cubic yard, and with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting
Company, dated July 15, 1907, for dredging sections "A," "B,"
and "C," Patapsco River and Chesapeake Bay, at 84 cents per cubic
yard for section "A," 20 cents per cubic yard for section "B,"and23
cents per cubic yard for section "C."
      9001-ENG 1909-75                                                 1185
1186      REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                   U. S. ARMY.


    Work was continued in the York Spit channel under the contract
dated July 5, 1905, until December 16, 1908, with two suction
dredges. The contract was then completed, and from that date to
the close of thefiscal year, under the contract dated July 15, 1907, at
the same locality with the same plant, which, working day and night,
removed 1,163,660 cubic yards of material.
   The work on sections "A" and "B" near Baltimore was continued
under the last-mentioned contract with three clam-shell dredges and
one endless bucket dredge, section "A" being completed December
30, 1908, with the removal of 3,167,755 cubic yards of soft material.
Section "B" was completed June 5, 1909, with the removal of 612,929
cubic yards of hard material and 844- hours' time spent in the
removal of solid rock. Under a contract dated June 12, 1909, for
increasing width of Fort McHenry channel 600 feet for a length of
about 3,500 feet, near its intersection with the Curtis Bay channel,
89,318 cubic yards have been removed.
   The total amount of material removed during the fiscal year is
5,033,662 cubic yards, and 8444 hours spent in rock removal.
   With the completion of this project there will be an artificial
channel 35 feet deep and 600 feet wide from Baltimore Harbor to
deep water in Chesapeake Bay, a distance of about 19 miles, and a
natural channel averaging 2 miles wide with a least depth of 40 feet
and maximum depth varying to 20 fathoms down to the sea, excepting
at York Spit, where a dredged channel 35 feet deep and 600 feet wide
is provided for a distance of about 41 miles. The channel near Balti-
more has shown remarkable stability and requires comparatively
little expenditure for maintenance; the results obtained at York Spit
indicate that the channel there will be more expensive to maintain
than the one near Baltimore. If the record of a few years should
show that the York Spit channel can be readily maintained at small
cost, Baltimore will have an enviable position upon tide water. If
the consequent development of her commerce shall justify it, a
40-foot channel can then be as readily created and maintained.
   In compliance with directions from the Chief of Engineers a survey
of the dumping grounds in Chesapeake Bay was made in the fall of
1908 and report submitted in April, 1909, with the result that the
Secretary of War approved new areas to the eastward of the old
dumping limits.
   The following are the amounts and dates of appropriations for
improving harbor at Baltimore, Md., including Patapsco River and
Chesapeake Bay:
Total to December 31, 1902,                    March 4, 1907.................   $500,000
  from House Document No.                      May 27, 1908..................    750, 000
  421, Fifty-seventh Con-                      December 31, 1908, sale of
  gress, second session.......   4, 796, 030    public property...-........             5
March 3, 1905................       250, 000   March 4, 1909.................    965, 000
June 30, 1906...............        500, 000
March 2, 1907................       500, 000         Total................. 8, 261,035


                             CONTRACTS IN          FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 719,999 cubic yards of hard material in Patapsco River at 20
cents per cubic yard, and an estimated quantity of 1,552,779 cubic yards of hard
material off York Spit, Chesapeake Bay, at 23 cents per cubic yard, approved July 18,
1905; date of commencement July 5, 1905, and completed December 16, 1908.
                                  APPENDIX                     J-REPORT          OF MAJOR CRAIGHILL.                                  1187
   Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 8,516,470 cubic yards of soft material at 81 cents per cubic yard
from section "A" (Patapsco River), 508,348 cubic yards of hard material at 20 cents
per cubic yard from section "B" (Patapsco River), and 1,621,125 cubic yards of hard
material at 23 cents per cubic yard from section "C'" (off York Spit), approved July 26,
1907; date of commencement July 31, 1907, and of expiration January 29, 1910.
   Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 1,500,000 cubic yards of soft material at 5 cents per cubic yard
from Fort MclHenry channel (Patapsco River), approved June 19, 1909; date of com-
mencement June 17, 1909, and of expiration January 22, 1911.



                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 1909.

                                                                         Imports.

                                                     Year.                                        Free.           Dutiable.         Total.

1908........................................................                                  $13,179,310        $16,297,791       $29,477,101
1909........................................................                                   11,986,248         12,036,085        24,022,333
           Decrease..............................................                                1,193,062          4,261,706        5, 454,768


Imports in American vessels, 1909:
   Sailing.................................. .....................                                                                   $67, 586
   Steam ..........................................               .. ..........                                                      279, 743
Imports in foreign vessels, 1909:
   Sailing......................................................                                                                     387, 645
   Steam ........................................................                                                                23, 278, 549
   Imports in cars overland.......................................                                                                     8, 810

               Total.......................................................                                                      24, 022, 333
                                                        Domestic exports.
In American vessels, 1909:
     Sailing.......................................................                                                                 $137,446
     Steam .......................................................                                                                    46,757
In foreign vessels, 1909:
     Sailing.........................................................                                                                 31,458
     Steam ........................................................                                                              77, 259, 632

               Total.......................................................                                                      77, 475, 293
                                                                Principalarticles exported.

                              Articles.                             Quantity.                        Articles.                      Quantity.

                                                                      Tons.                                                           Tons.
Beef products..........................                                 1,843    Iron and steel........................                143, 017
Cattle..............9,395                                               9, 395   Oilcake...
                                                                                 Olcake.........................                        70, 474
Coal and coke.........................                                345,939    Oils...............................87,194
Copper...............................                                  58,722    Oleo oil and neutral lard..............              .14,363
Cotton, unmanufactured...............                                  27, 488   Paraffin and wax.....................                    4,967
Feed, animal... .....................                                  37,328    Rosin................................                    2,373
Flour, wheat.... ....................                                  94,080    Starch... ............................                      252
Grain...............................343,737                                      Tobacco.....-.....................36,771
Hog products.......................                                    25, 009   Wood and manufactures of............                   57, 500

Amount of duties collected in 1909....       .........................                                                        $3, 369, 877. 78
Miscellaneous customs receipts in 1909.............................                                                               128, 893. 31
               Total receipts in 1909........................................                                                  3, 498, 771. 09
Duties on merchandise in bond, 1909..............................                                                                132, 328. 50
1188              REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                             S. ARMY.

                                                    Summary of duties collected in 1909.
Imports and miscellaneous customs receipts.......................                                         83, 498, 771. 09
Duties on merchandise remaining in bond................:.........                                              132, 328. 50
Merchandise transported with appraisement.........................                                              11, 453. 11
        Total............................................                                ...........        3, 642, 552. 70

                                                          Statistical recapitulation.
Dutiable imports have decreased..............................                                             $4, 261,706. 00
Free imports have decreased.................................                                               1, 193,062. 00
Domestic exports have decreased...................................                                        12, 283, 164. 00
Tonnage (foreign and coastwise) has decreased, tons...................                                     1, 004, 761. 00
Duties collected have decreased...................................                                         1, 298, 939. 02
Duties on merchandise in bond have increased......................                                              5, 570.38
Duties on merchandise in bond with and without appraisement have
  increased..................................................                                               1, 372, 655. 99

                              Tonnage movement, years ended June 80, 1908 and 1909.

                                                                             July 1, 1907, to June     July 1, 1908, to June
                                                                                    30,1908.                  30, 1909.


                                                                            Number.        Tons.       Number.       Tons.


Foreign trade:
   Entered...............................................                         702    1,357,076         593      1,102,310
   Cleared...............................................                         738    1,456,797         588      1,107,526
Coastwise:
   Entered..............................................                        1,623    2,644,700        1,478     2,538,091
   Cleared...............................................                       2, 029   2,982, 461       1,828     2,788,346

     Total.......................................                               5,092    8,441,034        4,487     7,436,273


  Foreign and coastwise tonnage has decreased 1,004,761.
  There have been no new lines of transportation established nor any lines abandoned
during the year.


                                                                   J   2.

IMPROVEMENT OF CHANNEL TO CURTIS BAY, IN PATAPSCO RIVER,
              BALTIMORE HARBOR, MARYLAND.

  Dredging for maintenance was commenced June 21, 1909, and
suspended on June 26, removing troublesome shoals in the turning
basin, when the dredge was hauled off temporarily to do more urg-
ent work in the Spring Garden channel under the same contract;
16,429 cubic yards of material were removed.

                                                    Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for main-
  tenance of improvement...........................................                                              $10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of
  June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



  The following are the amounts and dates of appropriations for im-
proving channel to Curtis Bay, in Patapsco River, Baltimore Har-
bor, Maryland:
                       APPENDIX J-REPORT OF MAJOR CRAIGHILL.                                                                           1189
Total to August 18, 1894, from House Executive Document No. 421,
  Fifty-seventh Congress, second session............................                                                      $40, 000
June 13, 1902.....................................................                                                         50.000
March 3,1903--------------------------------------........................................-----------............. -146.000
March 3, 1909 (allotted March 29,1909)...............................                                                       9, 000

         Total...............................................-----------------------------------------------------                    245,000


                                                 CONTRACT IN FORCE.
   Contract with the Sanford and Brooks Company for dredging an estimated quantity
of 80,000 cubic yards of material at 91% cents per cubic yard, approved June 17, 1909;
date of commencement June 21, 1909, and of completion, December 19, 1909.


                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

   The statistics of the port of Baltimore include this harbor.



                                                                    J 3.
IMPROVEMENT                      OF HARBOR OF SOUTHWEST                                               BALTIMORE                   (SPRING
                                      GARDEN), MARYLAND.
   An examination shows considerable deterioration of the channel,
especially at the upper end. This channel was dredged in very soft
material, where silt has been slowly accumulating for many years.
The cost of maintenance for a number of years will probably continue
to be large, but after the side slopes have flattened out sufficiently
it is thought that the cost of maintenance will be much reduced.
Dredging was commenced June 26 and was in progress at the close
of the fiscal year. Thirteen thousand two hundred and fifty cubic
yards of material were removed.
                                       Estimate of additional funds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
  improvement.....-------------------------------------------------- $34, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


  The following are the amounts and dates of appropriations for
improving harbor of Southwest Baltimore (Spring Garden), Md.:
June 23,      1896-----------------------------------------------------...........................................................     $5,000
June 13,      1902-----------------------------------------------------...........................................................     88, 000
March 3,      1903----------------------------------------------------............................................................    221, 000
March 2,      1907-----------------------------------------------------............................................................     6, 500
March 3,       1909 (allotted March 29, 1909)....................................                                                      34, 000
          Total...............................                                .............................                           354,500


                                                  CONTRACT IN FORCE.

    Contract with the Sanford and Brooks Company for dredging an estimated quantity
of 300,000 cubic yards of material at 9,% cents per cubic yard, approved June 17, 1909;
date of commencement June 26, 1909, and of completion December 19, 1909.
1190                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                    S. ARMY.

                                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

    The statistics of the port of Baltimore include this harbor.


                                                                                              J 4.
                                  IMPROVEMENT OF ELK RIVER, MARYLAND.

    No dredging was done up to the close of the fiscal year.
                                                     Estimate of additional funds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
  improvement........................................................-------------------------------------------------- $10,000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                                          APPROPRIATIONS.

Total to December 31, 1902, from House Executive Document No. 421, Fifty-
  seventh Congress, second session.........................................          $63, 165
M arch 3, 1905.......................................          -....................   2, 000
M arch 2, 1907............................................................            18, 803
March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 29,1909)......................................           10, 000

              Total...................................                                                        ...................               93,968


                                                                    CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 89,068 cubic yards of material at 19 cents per cubic yard,
approved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June
26, 1909.

COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR THE CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                        Receipts and shipments.

                                                                        Class.                                                      Quantity.   Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                             Tons.
      Cord wood, etc...                                   .................................................                            36,754   $126,075
      Lumber, shingles, etc.......................................................                                                        150     2,250
          Total.......................................................................                                                 36,904    128,325

Shipments:
    Fertilizers...................................................................                                                      1,351    20,272
   Hay and flour, etc....                                  ...............................................                                125     2,250
      Vessels built .................................................................                                                   4,500    108,000
          Total.......................................................................                                                  5,976    130,522
          Total receipts and shipments.......................................                                                          42,880    258,847


                                        Vessels sailing and trading in Elk River, Maryland.
                               APPENDIX J-REPORT OF MAJOR CRAIGIIILL.                                                                                1191

                                                                                            J 5.
IMPROVEMENT OF SUSQUEHANNA RIVER ABOVE AND BELOW HAVRE
                   DE GRACE, MARYLAND.

    Dredging was commenced August 19, 1908, and completed October
14, 1908, removing 94,670 cubic yards of material.
                                                      Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of
improvement....         .............................................   $54, 500. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.


                                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

Total to March 3, 1881, from                                                                       July 13, 1892................... $4, 000
  House Executive Document                                                                         1879, allotment from general
  No. 421, Fifty-seventh Con-                                                                       appropriation for examinations
  gress, second session......... $97, 390                                                           and surveys, date unknown..                          500
August 2, 1882................25,     000                                                          August 18, 1894................                    4,000
July 5, 1884..................20,     000                                                          June 13, 1902.................                    10, 000
August 5, 1886..................6,000                                                              March 3, 1905...................                  10, 000
August 11, 1888...............10,000                                                               March 2, 1907..................                   20, 000
September 19, 1890..............   4, 000
                                                                                                               Total.................... 210, 890



                                                                  CONTRACT IN                            FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 94,731 cubic yards of material at 19 cents per cubic yard, ap-
proved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June 26,
1909.


   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                      Receipts and shipments.

                                                                      Class.                                                             Quantity.   Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                                  Tons.
   Lumber............................................................                                                                       13,376   $211, 800
     Sand.......................................................................                                                             6,850      3,31_3
     Cement----------------------------------------------------.......................................................................       4,500     27,000
     M iscellaneous..............................................................                                                              970     66,650
         Total.................................                            .....................                                            25,696    308,763

Shipments:
    Salt fish......................................................................                                                          2,540     62,100
     Granite...........................................................                                                                      8,671     15,350
     Stoves and castings..........                           .........................................                                         600     60,000
     Miscellaneous..............................................................                                                               420     27,720
        Total.....................                                                 .................................                        12,231    165,170

         Total receipts and shipments...............................................                                                        37,927 473,933
1192                   REPORT OF TIHE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, TU. S. ARMY.

                              Vessels sailing and trading in Susquehanna River, Maryland.


                                                  Class.                         Number.   Aggregate    Light        Loaded
                                                                                           tonnage.     draft,       draft.

                                                                                                        Feet.         Feet.
Steamers....................................................                           3          500            5             9
Sailing vessels..............................................                         15        3,000            5            10
Barges....................................................                            25       10,000            4            10



                                                                          J6.
IMPROVEMENT OF HARBORS AT ROCKHALL, QUEENSTOWN, CLAI-
  BORNE, AND CAMBRIDGE; OF CHESTER, CHOPTANK, WARWICK, POCO-
  MOKE, LA TRAPPE, AND MANOKIN RIVERS, AND OF TYASKIN CREEK,
  MARYLAND.

             (A)        ROCKHALL HARBOR AND                                INNER HARBOR AT ROCKHALL.

  Dredging was continued until December 22, 1908, removing 62,822
cubic yards; a total of 67,957 cubic yards of material were removed
under the contract.
                                                       Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of im-
  provem ent..........................................................     $21, 711.03
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.



                                                              APPROPRIATIONS.

Total to June 3, 1896, from House Executive Document No. 421, Fifty-
  seventh Congress, second session...................................... $16, 600.00
June 13, 1902 (allotted Sept. 17, 1902)...............................    12,000.00
March 3, 1905 (allotted May 15, 1905)...................................  12, 829. 35
March 2, 1907 (allotted Mar. 22, 1907)................................... 14, 383. 97

              Total....................................................                                          55, 813.32



                                                             CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 68,134 cubic yards of material, at 19 cents per cubic yard, ap-
proved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June 26,
1909.
                                APPENDIX J--REPORT OF MVIAJOR CRAIGIIILL.                                                           1193
                    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR THE YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.

                                                                      Receipts and shipments.

                                                                    Class.                                         Quantity.       Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                            Tons.
   Lumber....                 .....................................................                                      405         $12,150
   Coal.....       ..........................................................                                             540          4,320
   General merchandise, etc..................................................                                          7,500         675,000
         Total...........................................................                             ..........       8,445         691,470
Shipments:
    Agricultural products...               ............................................                                   810         32,400
    Canned goods...            ..................................................                                         940         75,200
    Poultry and live stock...                  ..........................................                              3,428         685,600
    Fish and oysters...                ...............................................                                 3, 460        138,400
    General merchandise, etc..................................................                                            620         55, 800
         Total...........................................................                             ..........       9,258         987,400
         Total receipts and shipments..............................................                                   17,703       1,678, 870



                                 Vessels sailing and trading in Rockhall Harbor, Maryland.




Steamers.......................................
Sailing vessels and barges.......                                    ...................



                                                          (B)          QUEENSTOWN           HARBOR.

     No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                                       Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement...............................   $5, 607.40
   For maintenance of improvement........................     3, 000.00
                                                                                                                            -$8,    607.40
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                                            APPROPRIATIONS.

Total to June 3, 1896, from House Executive Document No. 421, Fifty-
  seventh Congress, second session...................................... $19, 000.00
June 13, 1902 (allotted Sept. 17, 1902)...............................         12,000.00
March 3, 1905 (allotted May 15, 1905).................................          4, 606. 50
March 2, 1907 (allotted Mar. 22, 1907)........................................  4, 975.70
            Total.......................................................                                                        40, 582.20
1194          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                 U. S. ARMY.

                                               CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 23,569 cubic yards of material, at 19 cents per cubic yard, ap-
proved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June 26,
1909.


   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                    Receipts and shipments.

                                                    Class.                                             Quantity.         Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                   Tons.
   Lumber           ---------------------------------------------------------                                   690        $20,700
   Coal....----------------------------------------------------------                                          242           1,936
   General merchandise, etc....................................................
                                                                   4,597   413,730
     Total..............................---------------------------------------------------------             5,529        436,366

Shipments:
   Agricultural products...      .       ..------------------------------------------- 15,771 630,840
   Canned goods...     ---------------------------------------------------                597  47,760
   Poultry and live stock...-...................................................
                                                      ------------                        248  49,600
   Fish and oysters....--------------------------------------------------                  32   1,280
                                                                      43      3,870
    General merchandise, etc....................................................
      Total-- -      -   -   -   -                      ........................... ""--16,691
                                      --....................                                                               733,350
      Total receipts and shipments.............................................                              22,220      1,169,716


                  Vessels sailing and trading in Queenstown Harbor, Maryland.


                                     Class.                                      Number.        Aggregate     Light      Loaded
                                                                                                tonnage.      draft.      draft.


                                                                         Feet.    Feet.
                                                               6 2,260         6        81
Steamers----------------------------------------------..............................................
Sailing vessels and barges....................................
                                                             175 5,200         4      12



                                              (c)     CLAIBORNE            HARBOR.

   No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of
  improvement....------------------------------------------------ $14, 597. 81]
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.


                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

June 13, 1902 (allotted September 17, 1902)............................                                               $15, 000. 00
March 3, 1905 (allotted May 15, 1905)................................... 1, 863. 35
March 2, 1907 (allotted March 22, 1907)................................. 3, 440. 24
March 3, 1909 (allotted April 9, 1909).................................. 12, 000. 00

       Total.........................................................                                                  32, 303. 59
                                 APPENDIX J-REPORT OF MAJOR CRAIGHILL.                                                                                          1195

                                                                   CONTRACT               IN       FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 16,295 cubic yards of material, at 19 cents per cubic yard, ap-
proved June 28, 1907; date of commencement, July 29, 1907, and completed June 26,
1909.


      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                         Receipts and shipments.

                                                                     Class.                                                                Quantity.           Value.


Receipts:                                                                                                                                    Tons.
      Lumber.....................................................................                                                               2,950            $88,500
      Coal....................................--------------------------------------------------------11,805                                                      94,440
      General merchandise, etc...................................................                                                             81,562           7,340,580
          Total.......................................................                                       ............                    _ 96,317          7,523,520

Shipments
      Agricultural products..                        ..............................................                                             3, 433           137,320
      Canned goods.........................                                                                                 ......         .2,289                183,120
      Poultry and live stock....                       .............................................                                               528           105,600
      Fish and oysters..................................................                                                                     .     572            22,880
      General merchandise, etc...................................................                                                                   34             3,060
           Total........................................................                                                                        6,856            451,980
           Total receipts and shipments........................................                                                        i     103,173           7,975,500



                                Vessels sailing and trading in Claiborne Harbor, Maryland.

                                                   Class.                                                Number.        Aggregate               Libt           Loaded
                                                                                                                        tonnage.                draft.          draft.


                                                                                                                                                 Feet.           Feet.
Steamers................................................                                                         3                   1,740                7               9
Sailing vessels and barges...                            ............................                    .      71                   4,006                4              10



                                                              (D)         CAMBRIDGE                    HARBOR.

      No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of improve-
ment       ....................................................            $6,450. 58
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.


                                                                          APPROPRIATIONS.

Total to July 13, 1892, from House Executive Document, No. 421, Fifty-
  seventh Congress, second session....         .............................
June 13, 1902 (allotted Sept. 17, 1902) ................................
                                                                                                                                                         $50,3, 237.00
                                                                                                                                                                000. 00
March 3, 1905 (allotted May 15, 1905)...................................                                                                                      3, 120. 80
March 2, 1907 (allotted Mar. 22, 1907)...............................                                                                                         1, 531. 63
              Total.........................................................                                                                              57, 889. 43
1196                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contractiig Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 7,255 cubic yards of material at 19 cents per cubic yard,
approved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June
26, 1909.


                         COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR YEAR ENDING MAY 1, 1909.

                                                                     Receipts and shipments.

                                                                   Class.                                                                         Quantity.             Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                                              Tons.
    Grain .......................................................................                                                                        3,120            $72,800
    Lum ber....................................................................                                                                          9,000              90,000
    Coal........................................................................                                                                         8,585              48,925
    Cord wood...................................................................                                                                           750               2,000
    Fertilizers--------------------------------------------------------..................................................................                  700              10,500
    Tin cans....................................................................                                                                               70            5,775
    General merchandise, etc....................................................                                                                        13, 000         1,170, 000
        Total..........................................................                                                          ..........             35,225          1,400,000

Shipments:
    Agricultural products.......................................................                                                                         9, 884           395, 360
    Canned goods...............................................................                                                                          2, 345           100,500
    Poultry and live stock------------------------------------------------......................................................                             61            12,200
    Fish and oysters............................................................                                                                            190            38,129
    Oyster shells................................................................                                                                       11,700             14,000
    Fertilizers..................................................................                                                                        1, 200             18,000
    Flour, etc...................................................................                                                                           925            20, 900
    Box shooks-------------------------------------------------------.................................................................                     500             12,000
    General merchandise, etc-------------------------------------------...................................................                               2,198            197,820
    Miscellaneous----------------------------------------------------...............................................................                     2, 475             18,750
        Total-           -         -         -       -         -          -    --.....................................................                  31,478            827,659

       Total receipts and shipments............................................                                                                         66,703          2, 227, 659



                             Vessels sailing and trading in Cambridge Harbor, Maryland.


                                                 Class.                                                          Number.                 Aggregate       Light          Loaded
                                                                                                                                         tonnage.        draft,          draft.

                                                                                                                                                         Feet.            Feet.
Steam ers....................................................                                                                 6               2,461                 5              9
Sailing vessels and barges....................................                                                              152               3, 943                4             12


        (E)         CHESTER RIVER,                                   MARYLAND,                          FROM CRUMPTON TO JONES
                                                                                LANDING.

    No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                                     Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
  of improvement----------.....................................................------------------------------------ $3, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                 APPENDIX J-REPORT OF MAJOR CRAIGHILL.                                                                                       1197
                                                                          APPROPRIATIONS.

Total to August 2, 1882, from House Executive Document, No. 421, Fifty-
  seventh Congress, second session..................................... a $41, 000. 00
September 19, 1890...................................................                                                                                      5, 000. 00
July 13, 1892........................................................                                                                                      3,000.00
August 18, 1894-------------------------------------------------......................................................                                     1, 500. 00
June 3, 1896..........................................................                                                                                     1, 500.00
M arch 3, 1899........................................................                                                                                     3, 200.00
June 13, 1902 (allotted Sept. 17, 1902)................................                                                                                    5,402.00
March 3, 1905 (allotted May 15, 1905)..................................                                                                                    1, 245. 00
March 2, 1907 (allotted Mar. 22, 1907).................................                                                                                    2,417.36
March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 29, 1909)..................................                                                                                   5, 000. 00

             Total.........................................................                                                                            28, 264. 36



                                                                    CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 11,450 cubic yards of material at 19 cents per cubic yard,
approved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June
26, 1909.


      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                       Receipts and shipments.

                                                                     Class.                                                              Quantity.          Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                                   Tons.
      Lumber.............................................................                                                                     1,244            $37,320
      Coal.......................................................................                                                               785              6, 280
      General merchandise, etc....................................................                                                           16,157         1, 454,130
          Total..............................................................                                                     ....       18,186         1, 497, 730

Shipments:
   Agricultural products......................................................                                                               25, 223        1, 008, 920
   Canned goods.............................................................                                                                  1,267            101, 360
    Poultry and live stock.....................................................                                                               5,722         1,144, 400
    Fish and oysters..........................................................                                                                3,328            133,120
    General merchandise, etc...                          ..........................................                                              352            31,680

         Total.....................................                                          .        ..................                     35,892         2, 419, 480

         Total receipts and shipments..............................................                                                          54,078         3, 917, 210



                                    Vessels sailing and trading in Chester River, Maryland.


                                                   Class.                                                  Number.             Aggregate      Light          Loaded
                                                                                                                               tonnage.       draft.          draft.

                                                                                                                                              Feet.           Feet.
Steamers....................................................                                                               6        2,260              6               8j
Sailing vessels and barges..................................                                                         175            5,200              4             12


               a Of which $2,958.54 was carried to the surplus fund of the Treasury on June 30, 1909.
1198                REPORT OF TIIE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                  (F) CHOPTANK RIVER.

   No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                                      Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending
June 30, 1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1,
1909:
    For works of improvement............................... $2, 797.14
    For maintenance of improvement .......................        1, 500.00
                                                                           -$4, 297.14
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act
of June 4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of
1899.


                                                                        APPROPRIATIONS.

June 14, 1880................ $5,000.00 March 3, 1899..........-.....                    $8, 000.00
March 3, 1881 .                                5, 000.00 June 13, 1902 (allotted Sept.
                                 -.-............
August 2, 1882---...........                   5,000.00    17, 1902)- ...--........... -  3,000.00
July 5, 1884--------... --------- 5, 000.00 .March 3, 1905 (allotted May 15,
August 5, 1886................ 10, 000.00                  1905)..................... 7, 885.00
August 11, 1888---...-----------7, 500.00 March 2, 1907 (allotted Mar.
September 19, 1890..----------7,500.00                     22, 1907)................... 9, 662.55
July 13, 1892----------------................. 3, 000.00
August 18, 1894-------------...............    2, 000.00       Total.................. 80, 547. 55
June 3, 1896................. 2, 000.00


                                                                   CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 45,770 cubic yards of material, at 19 cents per cubic yard,
approved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June
26, 1909.

    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                       Receipts and shipments.

                                                                    Class.                                                          Quantity.    Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                             Tons.
    Lumber.............................................................6,196                                                                       $185,880
    Coal.....................................................................                                                           5, 660        45,280
    General merchandise, etc..................................................                                                        147, 946   13, 315,140

       Total...                   ...........................................                                   .............         159,802    13, 546, 300

Shipments:
   Agricultural products......................................................                                                         45,001    1,800,040
    Canned goods.............................................................                                                          17,725     1, 418,000
    Poultry and live stock......................................................                                                .         583        116, 600
    Fish and oysters....................                                        ......................................          .       2,200        88,000
    General merchandise, etc...................................................                                                         8, 605      774, 450
       Total........................................................                                                                   74,114     4,197,090

       Total receipts and shipments...................                                              ................                  233, 916   17, 743, 390


                               Vessels sailing and trading in Choptank River, Maryland.
                               APPENDIX J-REPORT                                               OF MAJOR CRAIGHILL.                                              1199
                                                                  (G) WARWICK                            RIVER.

    No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                                    Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
  of improvement ....---------------------------------------------- $3, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                                      APPROPRIATIONS.

Total to March 3, 1881, from House Executive Document No. 421, Fifty-
  seventh Congress, second session ..----------------------------------..................................                $6, 000.00
July 13, 1892---------------------------------------------------........................................................  6,000.00
August 18, 1894-------------------------------------------------......................................................    2, 000.00
June 3, 1896..........................................................                                                    2,000.00
March 3, 1899 .....................................................                                                                                .    .    2,000.00
June 13, 1902 (allotted Sept. 17, 1902) -                      - --.................................
                                                                                   --                                                                        4,000.00
March 3, 1905 (allotted May 15, 1905)-------------------------------..................................                                                       1,909.00
March 2, 1907 (allotted Mar. 22, 1907)....................................                                                                                   3,493.87
March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 29,1909)--------------------------------....................................                                                    3,000.00

            Total................................                                                                  ....................                      30,402.87



                                                                CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 16,549 cubic yards of material, at 19 cents per cubic yard,
approved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June
26, 1909.


       COMMERCIAL STATISICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                    Receipts and shipments.

                                                           Class.                                                                              Quantity       Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                                       Tons.
    Lumber..................................................................                                                                           521      $15,630
    Coal------------------------------------------------------------........................................................................           637        5,096
    General merchandise, etc....................................................                                                                  12,711      1,143,990

       Total.. . . . . . . . . ..             .............................
                                ....................                                                                                              13,869      1,164,716

Shipments:
    Agricultural products.......................................................                                                                  50,490      2,019,600
    Canned goods..............................................................                                                                     1,234         98,720
    Poultry and live stock.....................................................                                                                       67         13,400
                               ---------------------------------------------------
    Fish and oysters...........................................................                                                                      127          5,080
    General merchandise, etc...................................................                                                                    1,559        140,310
       Total........................................................                                                                              53,477      2,277,110
       Total receipts and shipments.............................................                                                                  67,346      3,441,826
1200                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                 Vessels sailing and trading in Warwick River, Maryland.




                                                                (II)       POCOMOKE                                RIVER.

    No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

Total to August 5, 1886, from House Executive Document No. 421, Fifty-
  seventh Congress, second session...................................... $20, 500. 00
June 3, 1896----------------------------------------------------......................................................... 5,000.00
M arch 3, 1899.......................................................                                                     3,000.00
June 13, 1902 (allotted Sept. 17, 1902)...............                                     ................               4, 800.00
March 3, 1905 (allotted May 15, 1905)--------------------------------.................................                    1,743.00
March 2, 1907 (allotted Mar. 22, 1907) .................................                                                  2, 298.60
March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 29, 1909)....................................                                                2, 500.00

            Total........................................................                                                                39,841.60


                                                                  CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 10,888 cubic yards of material, at 19 cents per cubic yard,
approved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June
26, 1909.

     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                     Receipts and shipments.

                                                                  Class.                                                    Quantity.      Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                     Tons.
    Lumber...................................................................                                                     898        $26,940
    Coal...1...                  ..            ...................................................                              1,616          12,928
    General merchandise, etc....................................................                                               31,287      2,815, 830

       Total...................................................................                                                33,801      2,855,698

Shipments:
   Cord wood, lumber, etc....................................................                                                  14, 698       440, 940
   Agricultural products......................................................                                                  9,358        374,320
   Canned goods...............................................................                                                 14,923      1,193,840
    Poultry and live stock......................................................                                                   343        68, 600
    Fish and oysters............................................................                                                    34         1,360
    General merchandise, etc...................................................                                                    570        51,300
       Total....................................................................                                               39,926      2,130,360
       Total receipts and shipments....                                     ....................................               73,727      4, 986, 058


                                Vessels sailing and trading in Pocomoke River, Maryland.
                              APPENDIX J-REPORT                                          OF MAJOR                     CRAIGIHILL.                             1201

                                                                (I)      LA TRAPPE RIVER.

   No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.
July
Juu  13, 1892 ..........................................................                                                                              $2,-500.00
      1, 189 ----------------------------------------------------
August 18, 1894 ......
                                                                                                                                                      $2,750.00
                                                                                                                                                       4, 750. 00
March 3, 1905 (allotted May 15, 1905) ..................................                                                                               1,867.50
March 2, 1907 (allotted Mar. 22, 1907) .................................                                                                               2, 135. 39
March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 29, 1909) ...................................                                                                             3,000.00
          Total..........................................................                                                                             14,252.89


                                                                CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 10,115 cubic yards of material at 19 cents per cubic yard,
approved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June
26, 1909.


   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                  Receipts and shipments.

                                                                  Class.                                                           Quantity.               Value.


Receipts:                                                                                                                               Tons.
    Lumber...................................................................                                                             1,823                $54,690
    Coal. ..                                                                                                                              17........................................................
                                                                                                                                          1,27                   10,176
    General merchandise, etc......                                      ...............................................                   7, 321               658, 890

       Total....................................................................                                                         10, 416                723,756

Shipments:
    Agricultural products..................                           ...............          ....................                       3, 798                151, 920
    Canned goods............................................................                                                                 812                 64, 960
    Poultry and live stock.....................................................                                                               34                  6, 800
    Fish and oysters....                      ................................................                                                27                  1,080
    General merchandise, etc..................................................                                                               157                 14,130

       Total....................................................................                                                          4,828                238,890

       Total receipts and shipments..............................................                                                        15,244                 962, 646


                              Vessels sailing and trading in La Trappe River, Maryland.

                                                 Class.                                                   Number.          Aggregate      Light              Loaded
                                                                                                                           tonnage.       draft.               draft.


                                                                                                                                           Feet.               Feet.
Steamers....................................................                                                          3          923                  5                    9
Sailing vessels and barges..................................                                                          83       2, 868                 4                    9


                                                                   (J) MANOKIN                    RIVER.

   No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                                     Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of
  improvement....        .............................................   $14, 181.93
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.
       9001-ENG 1909-       76
1202            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                 U. S.   ARMY.

                                                APPROPRIATIONS.
September 19, 1890...................................................                                                       $7, 500. 00
July 13, 1892----------------------------------------------------..........................................................  7, 500.00
August 18, 1894......................................................                                                        4, 000. 00
June 3, 1896........................................................---------------------------------------------------a. 4, 000.00
March 3, 1899........................................................                                                        1, 500.00
March 3, 1905 (allotted May 15, 1905)..................................                                                      4, 772.50
March 2, 1907 (allotted Mar. 22, 1907)..................................                                                     9,160. 69

          Total.................................                          ..........................                   38, 433.19



                                               CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 43,392 cubic yards of material, at 19 cents per cubic yard,
approved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June
26, 1909.


                                            COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

   These were asked for, but not obtained.



                                                (K) TYASKIN CREEK.

     No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                       Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement.............................. $2, 406.30
   For maintenance of improvement........................        1, 593.70
                                                                                                                        $4, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                   APPROPRIATIONS.

June 13, 1902 (allotted Sept. 17, 1902)....................................                                                  $8, 000
March 3, 1905 (allotted May 15, 1905).....................................                                                    2,158
March 2, 1907 (allotted Mar. 22, 1907).....................................                                                   6, 500

          Total...............................................................                                               16,658



                                               CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 30,789 cubic yards of material, at 19 cents per cubic yard,
approved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29, 1907, and completed June 26,
1909.

      a Of this amount $2,000 is for work in the upper river not covered by project.
                              APPENDIX J-REPORT                                           OF MAJOR CRAIGHILL.                                    1203
     COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31. 1908.

                                                                 Receipts and shipments.

                                                                 Class.                                                          Quantity.       Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                           Tons.
     Lumber........... ...........................................................                                                       34        $1,020
     Coal........ ..     .........................................................                                                       45           360
     General merchandise, etc....................................................                                                       531        47,790
        Total............................................................                                             .. .....          610        49,170
Shipments:
     Agricultural products...                         ..............................................                                    215         8,600
     Canned goods...                      ....................................................                                          199        15,920
     Poultry and live stock...                        ..............................................                                     17         3,400
     Fish and oysters............................................................                                                         9           360
     General merchandise, etc....................................................                                                        14         1,260

        Total............................................................                                             ...........       454        29,540
        Total receipts and shipments...............................                                              ..........           1,064        78,710


                                Vessels sailing and trading in Tyaskin Creek, Maryland.


                                              Class.                                                   Number.     Aggregate        Light        Loaded
                                                                                                                   tonnage.         draft.        draft.

                                                                                                                                     Feet.       Feet.
Steamers.................................................                                                    3           1,727               4            6
Sailing vessels and barges..................................                                                36           2,160               4            6



                                                                                     J 7.
IMPROVEMENT OF NANTICOKE RIVER, DELAWARE AND MARYLAND.

    No dredging was done during the fiscal year.

                                                                   APPROPRIATIONS.
August 18, 1894.........................................................a                                                                        $5, 000
,June 3, 1896.........................................................                                                                            3, 000
March 3, 1899.....................................................3,000
March 3, 1905................................................                                                                                     2,000
March 2, 1907................................................                                                                                     2,000
March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 29, 1909)...                                 ...........................                                             2, 000
           Total........................-.......................                                                                                 17,000



                                                              CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 9,473 cubic yards of material at 19 cents per cubic yard, approved
June 28, 1907; date of commencement, July 29, 1907, and completed June 26, 1909.

                      a See note to appropriation for Broad Creek River, Delaware.
  1204                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                              S. ARMY.

                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR YEAR ENDING MAY 1, 1909.

                                                                          Receipts and shipments.

                                                                       Class.                                                                Quantity.           Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                                        Tons.
       Lumber...................................................................                                                                   32,051         $320, 510
       Coal ........................................................................                                                               17, 683           88,415
       General merchandise, etc.......                                          ...................................                                61, 642       5, 547,780
          Total.....................................................................                                                              111,376        5,956,705

Shipments:
      Agricultural products.....................................................                                                                    9,375          375,000
      Canned goods...                    .................................................                                                          4,736          378,880
      Poultry and live stock.............                                  ...............................                                          2,097          419, 400
      Fish and oysters.. ....... ..................................................                                                                 1,245          249,000
      General merchandise, etc..................................................                                                                    4,013          361,170
          Total........................................................                                                                            21,466        1,783,450
          Total receipts and shipments.                                    ...................                        .................           132,842        7,740,155


                                  Vessels sailing and trading in Nanticoke River, Maryland.


                                                    Class.                                                            Number. Aggregate             Light        Loaded
                                                                                                                              tonnage.              draft,        draft.

                                                                                                                                                     Feet.         Feet.
Steamers...................................................                                                                          3   1,727              5             7
Sailing vessels and barges...................................                                                                    105     8,010              5             9



                                                                                               J 8.
                   IMPROVEMENT OF BROAD CREEK RIVER, DELAWARE.

     No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
  provem ent..............................................................  $2, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                                          APPROPRIATIONS.

Total to August 11, 1888, from House Executive Document No. 421, Fifty-
  seventh Congress, second session...................................   $35, 000
July 13, 1892. .............................................................                                                                                       5, 000
August 18, 1894.........................................................                                                                                         a 5,000
June 3, 1896.........................................................                                                                                              5,000
March 3, 1899.........................................................                                                                                             5,000
M arch 2, 1907...........................................................                                                                                          1, 500
March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 29, 1909)....................................                                                                                         2, 000
            Total.............................................................                                                                                   58, 500
   a This appropriation was applied to removing bar on Nanticoke River under the
terms of the appropriation.
                                  APPENDIX J-REPORT                                OF   MAJOR CRAIGHILL.                          1205

                                                                   CONTRACT        IN   FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 7,105 cubic yards of material at 19 cents per cubic yard, approved
June 28, 1907; date of commencement, July 29, 1907, and completed June 26, 1909.



                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR YEAR ENDING MAY 1, 1909.

                                                                       Receipts and shipments.

                                                                       Clhas.                                        Quantity.    Value.


Receipts:                                                                                                              Tons.
   Coal .........             .............................................................                                270      $1,590
   Fertilizers.................................................................                                          2,413      36,095
   Tin cans....................................................................                                              75      2,450
   Oyster shells................................................................                                         1,625       3,250
   Live stock..................................................................                                              20      4,000
   Lumber.................................................................... .                                         17,735     113,947
   General merchandise, etc....................................................                                          2,016     167,560

           Total......................................................................                                  24,154     328,892
Shipments:
    Vessels......................................................................              400                                  19,000
    Canned goods...............................................................                630                                  30,000
    Flour and feed...................................................................... ...   650                                  15,000
    Lumber....................................................................               1,000                                   5,000
    Grain.......................................................................               300                                  10,000
    Agricultural        products.......................................................        200                                   6,000
    Shooks and crates............................................................            1,036                                  20,720
    General merchandise, etc....................................................               110                                   9,900

           Total.................................................                                        .........       4,326     115,620

           Total receipts and shipments..............................................                                   28,480     444,512



                                 Vessels sailing and trading in Broad Creek River, Delaware.

                                                    Class.                                Number.     Aggregate        Light      Loaded
                                                                                                      tonnage.         draft.      draft.


                                                                                                                        Feet.      Feet.
Steamers...................................................                                       1          50              4            7
Sailing vessels..............................................                                    24       2,100            3-5         4-9
Power boats..............................................                                         2          20              3            4
Lighters...                   ...........................................                         6         400              3            5
Barges................................................                                      .     2       1,300              4            9



                                                                                J 9.
                           IMPROVEMENT OF WICOMICO RIVER, MARYLAND.

      No dredging was done during the fiscal year.
                                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
improvement........    ...............................................     $5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
1206                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                     U. S. ARMY.

                                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.

Total to July 5, 1884, from House Executive Document No. 421, Fifty-
  seventh Congress, second session........................................ $50, 000
September 19, 1890 .....................................................                                                        10, 000
July 13, 1892............................................................                                                        6, 500
August 18, 1894..........................................................                                                        3,000
June 3, 1896-------------------------------------------------------............................................................  3,700
June 6, 1900............................................................                                                             18
June 13, 1902 (allotted Sept. 17, 1902)....................................                                                      6,798
M arch 3, 1905............................................................                                                       5,000
M arch 2, 1907............................................................                                                       2, 500
March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 29, 1909)......................................                                                     5, 000

            Total.. . . ...................                                 .      ...............                     .................                    92, 516



                                                            CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 11,842 cubic yards of material at 19 cents per cubic yard,
approved June 28, 1907; date of commencement, July 29, 1907, and completed June
26, 1909.


      COMMERCIAL STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                 Receipts and shipments.

                                                                 Class.                                                                Quantity.           Value.


Receipts:                                                                                                                                   Tons.
   Lumber.....                       .             .             ..---------------------------------------------------                       36,285        $1,088,550
   Coal--...................................................................----------------------------------------------------.            20,867           166,936
   General merchandise, etc.................................................                                                                 79,869         7,188,210

         Total..............................---------------------------------------------------                                             137,021        8,443,696

Shipments:
   Agricultural products....                         ..-----------------------------------------                                             11,572          462,880
   Canned goods.....................................................                                                                         10,414          833,120
   Poultry and live stock----------------------------------------......................................................                         353           70,600
    Fish and oysters..................................................                                                                        1,150           46,000
    General merchandise, etc..................................................                                                               62,147        5,593,230

         Total................................               .              .          .             .             ..........               85,636         7,005,830

         Total receipts and shipments....................................                                                                   222,657        15,449,526



                               Vessels sailing and trading in Wicomico River, Maryland.

                                              Class.                                                     Number.          Aggregate           Light         Loaded
                                                                                                                          tonnage.            draft.         draft.


                                                                                                                                               Feet.         Feet.
Steamers....................................................                                                      2                1,548              5             64
Sailing vessels and barges....................................                                                   82                5,740              5             9
                              APPENDIX J-REPORT                                           OF MIAJOR CRAIGHILL.                          1207
                                                                                      J   Io.

                 IMPROVEMENT                                    OF CRISFIELD                      HARBOR, MARYLAND.

  Dredging was commenced March 16, 1909, and completed June 26,
1909, 179,982 cubic yards of material being removed.
                                                    Estimate of additional funds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of improve-
  ment...-----.----.......------------------------..                                                                                   $10, 055
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897.


                                                                        APPROPRIATIONS.

Total to March 3, 1875, from House Executive Document No. 421, Fifty-
  seventh Congress, second session--------------------------------.................................... $37,317.50
M arch 2, 1907..........................................................                                37, 707.00

          Total..........................................................                                                            75, 024. 50


                                                                 CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company for dredging an
estimated quantity of 178,612 cubic yards of material, at 19 cents per cubic yard,
approved June 28, 1907; date of commencement July 29,1907, and completed June 26,
1909.


   COMMERCIAL                       STATISTICS FOR CALENDAR YEAR ENDING DECEMBER 31, 1908.

                                                                     Receipts and shipments.

                                                                   Class.                                                Quantity.     Value.

Receipts:                                                                                                                   Tons.
    Lumber                         ................................................                                         .840         $25,200
    Coal.......................................................................                                                776         6,208
    General merchandise, etc..................................................                                              79,358     7,142,220

       Total....................................................................                                            80,974     7,173,628

Shipments:
    Agricultural products.....................................................                                               7,024       280,960
    Canned goods............................................................                                                 1,110        88,800
    Poultry and live stock....................................................                                                 202        40,400
    Fish and oysters..........................................................                                              11,847       473,880
    General merchandise, etc...................................................                                              1,825       164,250
       Total.........................................................                                                       22,008     1,048,290
       Total receipts and shipments........................                                     ......................     102,982     8,221,918


                               Vessels sailing and trading in Crisfield Harbor, Maryland.
1210     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

   The combined results of the dredging done during the fiscal years
1908 and 1909 were that 1,241,623 cubic yards of material were de-
posited on Potomac Park, 709,978 cubic yards from the reservoir and
531,645 cubic yards from the Virginia channel; that the entire area
(111 acres) of the reservoir was redredged to a least depth of 8 feet at
mean low water; that the entire length (7,000 feet) of the Virginia
channel was redredged to a least width of 400 feet and a least depth of 21
feet at mean low water; that the portion of Potomac Park lying west-
ward of the railroad embankment was raised to the required grade; and
that 11 wrecks and 22 snags,logs, etc., were removed from the reservoir.
    To accomplish the results as given above it was necessary, in addi-
tion to the contract with the Maryland Dredging and Contracting
Company, to make open-market agreements with this company for
dredging not provided for in their contract, to wit: Agreement No. 1,
dated August 10, for payment for 11,645 cubic yards of dredging in
the Virginia channel in excess of the amount covered by the contract.
Agreement No. 2, dated August 17, for the removal of a riprap mound
in the Tidal Reservoir, and a hard gravel lump in the Virginia channel,
which were not provided for by their contract. The removal of the
mound and lump was done thereunder by the dipper dredge Maryland
between August 26 and September 4. The excavated material,
amounting to (mound) 1,500 cubic yards and (lump) 3,200 cubic
yards, was put in scows and dumped behind the training dike for the
Virginia channel above the Long Bridge.
    The dredging required in the Washington channel at the new loca-
tion for the wharf and storehouse attached to this district was done
under open market agreement dated February 25, 1909, with the
Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company, by the hydraulic
dredge Mackenzie between April 2 and 5, 1909. The excavated
material, amounting to 4,970 cubic yards, was deposited on Potomac
Park in that vicinity.
                            CHANNEL DEPTH.

   the adopted project for this improvement does not specify the
depth to be obtained in feet, but provides that the channels shall be
of sufficient depth to accommodate the deepest draft vessels that can
be brought up to them. At the time of the adoption of the project
the ruling depth in the Potomac below Washington was 20 feet, and
all estimates for the improvement at Washington are based upon
this depth. On June 30, 1908, the least depth in the Washington
channel was 21 feet and in the undredged portion of the Virginia
channel was 18 feet. The least depth of channel in the lower Poto-
mac has now been increased by dredging to 24 feet at low tide, which
accordingly makes this the present projected depth for the improve-
ment at Washington. For this increase the present estimates, how-
ever, do not make provision, and no work with this depth in view will
be undertaken until it is authorized by Congress.
   The river was not frozen over at any time during the winter.
   The desirability of extending the advantages of increased depth in
the lower Potomac River at an early date, so that deep-draft vessels
may reach the navy-yard and wharves at Washington, is obvious.
The estimated additional cost of this important modification of the
project, which it is hoped will soon be authorized by Congress, was
stated on page 1151 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers
for 1905.
             APPENDIX K-REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                      1211
                COMBINED    INLET GATES AND BRIDGE.

   Preliminary surveys and current observations to determine the
character of the structure required were made during the summer and
fall of 1907. General plans were prepared during the winter and
were approved by the Chief of Engineers.
   Actual work in the field was begun in April, 1908.
   A description of the work done in the fiscal year 1908 is given on
page 1207 of the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908.
   To prepare the foundation dredging was carried to a level 16 feet
below mean low water. At mean low water there will be a depth of
7 feet of water at the site of the bridge. Piles, averaging 55 feet
in length, were driven to 10 feet below mean low water. The piles
were spaced so that the pressure on the piles from the superimposed
structure should be uniform throughout. A total of 1,184 piles were
driven, of which about 800 were placed during this fiscal year. A
cofferdam was built around the eastern half of the foundation, the
bottom leveled off with sand to - 12 feet and 5 feet of concrete placed
on top to seal the bottom. The water was then pumped out of the
dam and construction of the concrete piers was begun. While con-
crete construction was progressing on the eastern half the cofferdam
was completed around the western half and construction carried on
as in the eastern half, the two cofferdams being united into one, 176
feet by 72 feet, when the concrete bottom had been completed in the
west half.
   The lock and middle piers of each half of the bridge and the abut-
ments are built of a cellular construction above the level of mean low
water.
   On the river side and in each half of the bridge beyond the railing
and 5 feet below the level of the sidewalk, is located a platform,
approximately 9 feet by 52 feet, on which will be mounted the mechan-
ism for operating the four curtain gates located in openings 8 feet
wide. In rear of each curtain gate is a set of wooden gates of the
mitering type set to operate automatically. In the center of the
bridge is a lock 46 feet 8 inches long by 26 feet wide at each end of
which is a set of gates, one gate being stationary and the other con-
structed to roll behind the stationary gate, permitting an opening 12 feet.
   The roadway over the bridge is 25 feet wide and 184 feet long, with
sidewalks 7 feet 3 inches wide on each side. The railing on each side
of the bridge is of ornamental concrete between large concrete pedes-
tals at the ends and over the center of the bridge. In niches on the
sidewalk face of the two pedestals on the tidal basin side and at the
center of the bridge are placed ornamental bronze fountains, the waste
water from which passes through the pedestals to an ornamental
cast concrete head, from the mouth of which it drips over a cast con-
crete panel, both head and panel being on the basin face of the bridge.
   The curtain gates are intended to be closed only when the water
in the river is highly turbid, in order to prevent the silting up of the
tidal reservoir, and to exclude flood waters.
   The automatic gates are installed to open during flood tide and
close during ebb tide, forcing the water out of the basin through the
Washington channel.
   The floor system over the lock is removable to provide for the
passage into the tidal basin of large vessels, the need of which in
the tidal basin may be sufficient to justify the removal of the floor.
1212            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                          U. S.      ARMY.

   The construction of the bridge and gates necessitated the relocation
and construction of 497 feet of sea wall, of which 380 feet have been
completed. In addition to this it was decided that 515 feet of the
old sea wall, which had been laid up dry and had settled, should be
relaid in mortar and raised to a level of 6 feet above mean low water
to conform to new walls at the bridge. Of the 515 feet 290 feet of
the old seawall have been rebuilt.
   Excepting the installation of the lock, curtain, and automatic
gates, the work is now 98 per cent completed.
   The following are items of cost to the end of the fiscal year 1909:
Plant, erection, repairs, and additions to---------------------------............................... $11,010.74
Temporary structures (field office, cement shed, etc.)---------------.................. -- 2, 289.44
Cofferdam (construction, repair, and pumping) ..........................                                               13, 866. 30
Foundations (including concrete sealing)------------------------..............----................              ---    19, 317.43
Piers and abutments (-7 feet to +6 feet; to spring line of arches)-...---.....                                          8, 430. 85
Superstructure (including sidewalk and roadway)..-----------------......................                         --    25, 856. 16
Ornamental railings and pedestals----------------------------------.....................................                7,363.99
Surveys and observations.............................................                                                   1, 213. 53
Automatic gates, construction------------------------------------.......................................... -           1, 553.03
Tooling faces of bridge, railings, etc.....................................                                             4, 289.89
Superintendence and office expenses....................................                                                 6, 590. 92
Contingencies.....................................................---------------------------------------------------. 6, 558. 14
Sea wall:
     380 feet new wall, including foundation.............................                                               3, 676. 44
     290 feet old wall, rebuilding........................................                                              1, 305.00
      Total------------------..........................................................                          113,321.86
Outstanding liabilities included in above..............................                                            6, 939.09
          Total expended to June 30, 1909..................................                                      106, 382. 77

                                                  POTOMAC PARK.

   Congress, by act of March 3, 1897, declared the reclaimed flats a
public park. This extensive tract, amounting to 628 acres of land
and 111 acres of inclosed water area, is capable of being transformed
into one of the finest parks in the country.
   The dredged material heretofore cited under the head "dredging"
deposited during the fiscal years 1908 and 1909, amounting to
1,246,593 cubic yards, was placed on the following portions of Poto-
mac Park: Eighty-seven thousand four hundred and sixteen cubic
yards on the area between the reservoir and the approach to the high-
way bridge, 189,205 cubic yards on the area below the railroad
bridge, and 969,972 cubic yards on the area at and above the Seven-
teenth street sewer canal. In addition, about 200,000 cubic yards
of material was dumped and graded by private parties, under per-
mit, without cost to the United States other than inspection.
   The result of this deposit was that all the area of the park lying
westward of the railroad embankment, including the Seventeenth
street sewer canal and the small reservoir or bathing pool, has been
filled in to the established grade. This portion of the park is now
under the control of and in process of development by the office of
Public Buildings and Grounds; such parts as were not then under
control were turned over to said office on April 24, 1909.
   Incidental to turning over this portion of the park to the office of
Public Buildings and Grounds, it was necessary to provide for the
removal of the wharf and storehouse attached to this district and
located thereon at Easbys Point. Authority was granted by the
                               APPENDIX K-REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                                                                                    1213

department for such removal on February 16, 1909. The new loca-
tion thereby designated was about a 2-acre site adjacent to the
Washington channel and immediately below the railroad embank-
ment. Work was begun upon this project on April 2 and has since
been carried on in a dilatory manner, in order to utilize material taken
from the inlet gates and the force employed thereon and on the sea
walls without incommoding those works. To date, the piles and
capping required for the wharf have been placed and some grading
has been done. It is anticipated that the wharf, buildings, etc., will
be completed and in use within sixty days.
   The repairs to sea walls other than those cited under the heading
of "Combined inlet gates and bridge," were begun on November 13,
and suspended December 12, 1908. This work was resumed on April
15 and was prosecuted throughout the fiscal year. During the period
of November and December a force of 4 men was employed, a new
wall 100 feet long was thrown across the prior mouth of the old
Seventeenth street sewer canal, and all the repairs to the sea walls
of Potomac Park lying westward of the railroad embankment, except
to those adjacent to the inlet gates, were completed. Since April
15 an average force of 20 men has been employed, 1,300 linear feet
of old sea wall have been torn down, and 1,100 linear feet have been
rebuilt on the Washington channel boundary in the vicinity of the
railroad bridge. The building stone used for this work was furnished
under contract with the Columbia Granite and Dredging Corporation
and the cement under contract with the National Mortar Company.
Sand was obtained from the dredging deposit made on the par
   Under the provisions of the contract with the Maryland Dredging
and Contracting Company 3 wrecks and 3 logs, snags, etc., were
removed from the Tidal Reservoir, making a total of 11 wrecks and
22 logs, snags, etc., removed during the fiscal years 1908 and 1909.
Payment for their removal was made on the dredging estimates and is
so accounted for in the statement of expenditures.
                                                               EXPENDITURES.

   The total expenditure during the fiscal year was $159,446.02, dis-
tributed as follows:

                                                                                                       Improve-                Mainte-              Total
                                                                                                        ment.                  nance.

Dredging Tidal Reservoir, and incidental contract...-...-.-.                                       ..............             $28,617.06           $28, 617.06
Dredging Virginia channel, and incidental contract............                                         ...........             48, 870.25           48, 870.25
Dredging Virginia channel, and incidental open-market agree-
  ment dated August 10, 1908...-....-..............                                         .....  .............                  1, 226.83           1, 226.83
Dredging Tidal Reservoir and Virginia channel, and incidental
  open-market agreement dated August 17, 1908----...-----------------------4,202.17                                                                  4,202.17
Dredging Washington channel, and incidental open-market
  agreement dated February 25, 1909...-----------------------------------1,073.76                                                                    1,073.76
Construction of inlet gates----.. -----                          .---------------------- $66, 939.65                             1,305.00           68,244.65
Repairs to sea walls ..------                 ---------------------------------.---.-------                                      4,139.65            4,139.65
Building new wharf and incidentals............................----.----260.24                                                                            260.24
Care of property................................................                                                                    414.96               414.96
                                                                                                  ...........----------------------------------------------------...
R epairs to plant....           . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . .. .72.40                                                                  72.40
Inspection of dump for material deposited under permits.....................                                                        162.00               162.00
Maintenance of U. S. steamer General Warren----------------................. --                                 200.00              704.51               904.51
Engineering, contingencies, maintenance of office, and miscel-
  laneous ..-----------------------------------------------                                                     450.00              807.54            1,257.54
         Total---------..................-                                     .............             67, 589.65            91,856.37           159,446.02
1214           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                     APPROPRIATIONS.

   It is strongly recommended that in response to the popular demand
for better navigation facilities and for additional park space the ap-
propriations for this work be made on a scale which will insure the
completion of the entire project (including the increased channel
depth recommended) within a few years.
   For maintenance and for the removal of freshet deposits alone a
yearly expenditure of about $10,000 is required.
                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement.......................... $60,000.00
   For maintenance of improvement ....................     120, 000. 00
                                                                                 $180, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                     APPROPRIATIONS.

                                                         POTOMAC RIVER.

Previous projects (see H. Doc. No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 354).... a$291, 500.00
Present project:
    August 2, 1882..................................................              400, 000.00
    July 5, 1884.................................................                 500,000.00
    August 5, 1886..................................................              375, 000.00
    August 11, 1888.................................................              300, 000. 00
    September 19, 1890............................................                260, 000. 00
    July 13, 1892...................................................              200, 000. 00
    August 18, 1894................................................               150, 000. 00
    June 3, 1896 ...................................................              100, 000. 00
    March 3, 1899 (appropriated, $100,000; allotted June 3, 1899, Poto-
      mac River below Washington, $26,000)........................                 74, 000.00
    June 13, 1902 ..................................................               75,000.00
    April 28, 1904 (allotted June 10, 1904)............................            50, 000. 00
    March 3, 1905...................................................               50, 000. 00
    March 2, 1907...................................................              258, 000. 00
    March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 23, 1909).............................            25, 000. 00

       Total.......................................................     2, 817, 000. 00
      Amount received from sale of blueprints..........................              50
      Amount received from sale of condemned property...............            212. 83
         Total.......................................................           2,817, 213. 33

                                             TIDAL GATES, POTOMAC PARK.

May 27, 1908 .....................................................                 25, 000. 00
         Aggregate...................................................           3, 133, 713. 33
  a Of this sum $291.39 of the appropriation of 1849 was covered into the surplus fund
of the Treasury.
                APPENDIX K'-REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                            1215
                             CONTRACTS IN FORCE.
  Contractor: Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company, of Baltimore, Md., for
dredging.
  Amount: Tidal Reservoir, 600,000 cubic yards (30 per cent more or less); Virginia
channel, 400,000 cubic yards (30 per cent more or less).
  Date of contract: August 26, 1907.
  Approved: September 6, 1907.
  Date for commencement: November 9, 1907.
  Date for completion: May 9, 1909. Final payment was made January 27, 1909.
  Rate: Tidal Reservoir, 91 cents per cubic yard; Virginia channel, 10 cents per cubic
yard.
  Contractor: Carter and Clarke, of Washington, D. C., for furnishing and delivering
and driving piles (emergency).
  Amount: 71,500 linear feet, averaging 55 feet long.
  Date of contract: May 4, 1908.
  Date for commencement: May 24, 1908. Final payment was made September 10,
1908.
  Rate: Furnishing and delivering piles, 9 cents per linear foot; driving piles, 51
cents per linear foot.
  Contractor: Potomac Granite Company, of Washington, D. C., for furnishing and
delivering broken stone.
  Amount: 1,200 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: July 14, 1908.
  Approved: July 22, 1908.
  Date for commencement: Delivery as required.
  Date for completion: Delivery as required. Annulled October 27, 1908.
  Rate: $1.34 per cubic yard. Demurrage of $5 per day for scows held over 48 hours.
  Contractor: J. B. Kendall, of Washington, D. C., for furnishing and delivering
reenforcing steel.
  Amount: 60,000 pounds.
  Date of contract: July 11, 1908.
  Approved: July 22, 1908.
  Date for commencement: August 23, 1908.
  Date for completion: September 22, 1908. Final payment was made September 8,
1908.
  Rate: $0.0172 per pound.
   Contractor: L. E. Smoot, of Washington, D. C., for furnishing and delivering sand
and gravel.
   Amount: 3,800 cubic yards of gravel and 3,000 cubic yards of sand.
   Date of contract: July 11, 1908.
   Approved: July 22, 1908.
   Date for commencement: August 5, 1908.
   Date for completion: Delivery as required.
   Rate: Gravel, 65 cents per cubic yard; sand, 40 cents per cubic yard. Demurrage
of $5 per day for scows held over 48 hours.
   Contractor: National Mortar Company, of Washington, D. C., for furnishing, deliv-
ering, and piling cement.
   Amount: 7,000 barrels.
   Date of contract: July 8, 1908.
   Approved: July 15, 1908.
   Date for commencement: August 17, 1908.
   Date for completion: Delivery as required.
   Rate: $1.474 per barrel. Allowance for return of sacks: Serviceable, 71 cents;
repairable, 54 cents.
  Contractor: Columbia Granite and Dredging Corporation, of Washington, D. C., for
furnishing building stone. (Emergency contract.)
  Amount: 2,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: April 6, 1909.
  Date for commencement: On or before May 6, 1909.
   Date for completion: October 6, 1909.
   Rate: $2.20 per cubic yard.
1216                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                           U. S.    ARMY.

  Contractor: G. & W. Manufacturing Company, of New York, N. Y., for furnishing
and installing lock and curtain gates with operating mechanism.
  Amount: One set lock gates and 8 curtain gates.
  Date of contract: April 22, 1909.
  Approved: May 6, 1909.
  Date for commencement: May 30, 1909.
  Date for completion: September 10, 1909.
  Rate: $8,997.
                                                                 COMMERCIAL                    STATISTICS.

                                      Receipts and shipments by water, calendar year 1908.

                          Articles.                                        Quantity.                                    Articles.                     Quantity.

                                                                                Tons.                                                                     Tons.
Asphalt...............................                                            7,000        Plaster................................                            742
Coke.................................                                             4, 500       Sand and gravel......................                       236, 790
Coal....               ..........................                               236, 470       Stone................................                        34, 845
General merchandise..................                                           81,610        Building stone......................                   .      3, 000
Ice...................................                                           37,050        W ood................................                        31,200
Lumber.............................                                              51,113        Laths.................................                        2,848
Oil, gasoline, etc..............                 .......                        20, 683       Shingles.............................                         1,590
Oysters..............................                                                 10,500
Paving blocks........................                                                   796              Total...........................                  760,737


                                                      Arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1903.

                                                                        Class                                                             Number.       Gross
                                                                                                                                                      tonnage.

Steamers drawing 5 to 15 feet ...................................................                                                             1,525         600,000
Sailing vessels drawing 10 to 21 feet......                    ................................                                                 250         380, 000
Sailing vessels drawing 4 to 10 feet..........................                        .........................                               1,500         240,000
Barges and  scows  drawing  4 to 12   feet............................................                                                        3.700         550,000
Coal barges drawing 16 to 18 feet................................................                                                                28          30, 500

         Total.....................................................................                                                       .7,003          1,800, 500



                                                                                          K    2.

IMPROVEMENT OF POTOMAC RIVER BELOW WASHINGTON, DISTRICT
                     OF COLUMBIA.

                          WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE                                                                             30, 1909.

No work was done during the fiscal year and no expenditures were
made.
                                                                             APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1899 (by allotment June 3, 1899, from appropriation of $100,000 for
  improving Potomac River, etc.)...........                                     ......................................... $26, 000
June 6, 1900........       ....................................................                                            52, 000
M arch 3, 1901..........................................................                                                   98, 000
March 3, 1905.........................................................                                                     10, 000

            Total.............................................................                                                                            186,000



                                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
  No work having been done and no funds having been expended during the fiscal
year, commercial statistics were not gathered. However they are believed to be
the same as reported for the calendar year 1907, Annual Report of the Chief of Engi-
neers, 1908, page 1212.
                                                                                                                                                                                      10TIDAL                    9

                                                                                                                                                                                      RES ERVOIR
                                                                                                                                       POTOMAC                 PARK
                                                                                                                                            Under control of the                                 9
                                                                                                                                                                                                               9
                                                                                                                                   Public Buildings & Grounds Offic




                                                                                                                                                                                                          6
                                                                                                                                                                                13
                                                                             C                                                     I   4'                               "---i4-"                              3€: 6
                                                                                                                                                                          131/N14.. .:--- -------
                                                                                 - -- .              -          __    -__2     -       TF//NN        ,1-,                        10                     ,,r--        --..-          7

                                                                                   ---     i                                                                       1..24/77 2                ?                                       o
                                                                    0            ,,9     C e             - ... ....
                                                                                                         OToo
                                                                                                                                         . . . - ' ----
                                                                                                                                                     '".'           - .-- =_-- ',.: ......." -          R H30,1909
                                                                                                                                                                                                 U " ....    . "- .N .".""-,,,3.. ...13..

         POTOMAC RIVER,                                                                                                                                                    _ . .r.
                                                                                                                                                                                                 A
                                                          ""                                   ".                    . _ _ - "t'   . -   -. .     - r a _ -,   \
                         -   AT -
                                                                                                        R...
                                                                                                     .I E                .-___.•.... .. ,.
                                                                                                                                         ........
                                                                                                                                                .                                            A       _ A        D    t5      1 L         N
                 Washington
         Portion above R R.R.Bridge.                                             ARLIN GTON                                              6 o                                                     ALEXANDERS5LAND
"
"G                                 eetT
                        Scale of F""                                    -   "-   '"nnn              nn    7"     accompany Annual Reportfor theyearendng.ddng                                                 O 99
     0           1000        2000       .   V        -r        iv

          -4--    1                                                                                                                                                                                      N'




         LE6END         Channe/ Lines shown fthus         -
                                                                                                                                                                             Corps of Engin/ers,U. S. A.
                        18 ff.Contour ,,        77
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        PETE.RS
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                THENORRIS                  D C
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              CO.,WASHINOTON,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ,,                                           _                                                     __




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     C         -.       p



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    S                0

    utlet"-               0                                                    - -
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             \                          Govt.A5ylum                    1

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        for the Insanef
c       Ne1ocaio         y"rd&                               .                 t,                                                                                                 ,of




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         ...
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ,,/
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            " .....      .        ..          c




                                                                                                                                                                                       4Po
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 rcte"




        N w o. /..                       ...                           .                                                                       oP    \     o,                                                  23


                                                                           P             0    -r0                                       1200
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 4

         44'1
          2               26         .         26f2"-..i'-        -- -                   ".                                     • c,.          .-.                                               2-1       ,            \   \
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 e4      )

                               263                                                                                               "-                                         'o                                                             N                                                  "


                     \        ,
                                                           ....                4
                                                                                                     -. \"
                                                                                                             '
                                                                                                                 . .. 4 -
                                                                                                                     2
                                                                                                                                   --..                  2--        .. ,.
                                                                                                                                                                             *, *
                                                                                                                                                                             .-   :-
                                                                                                                                                                                             .                      X                                                                   0
                                                  r           ve/4/g                                                        P              z-=2                 ~


                                                                 POTOMAC                                                           RIVER,                      ao                       .              3                                                    \\Giboro Pt."
                                                                                                      + AT +                                                                                -s
                DE2S                           ,D                    Washington, D. C.                                                                                                  n                            25

                         x N                                     PorFtion below P.R.R.Bridge.                                                                                                                                            34-                ro.
                                                      S.                                        Scale of Feet.21
                                                       .0, .- g 500    0   5oo 1000 1500 2000                                                                               To accompan y Armn                      i /P'eporf for the year end/ng June 50, /909.
                                                                Chnrne/ 1e7s show5 thu--
                                                                                                    -LfEGENAD -
                                                                         I/         ft   Coytour                 "                                                                                                                             or.      Corp5 of                       Eng         neers, U. 5. A.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             THE  RIS Pt7L9S
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                NO?                           -Q
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Q:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               CO.,WAIH1N0TQN,
             APPENDIX K-REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                 1217
                                K3.
  IMPROVEMENT OF ANACOSTIA RIVER, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.

        WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30,         1909.
                             DREDGING.

  The dredging under contract with The Maryland Dredging and
Contracting Company, of Baltimore, Md., was begun August 19,
1909, and was prosecuted continuously day and night by the 22-inch
hydraulic dredge Mackenzie, except for delays incidental to this class
of work, until it was completed on January 6, 1909.
  This work resulted in straightening the channel and providing a
minimum width of 380 feet from the mouth to the upper limits of
the navy-yard; in the excavation of 26,696 cubic yards of hard and
729,170 cubic yards of soft material at the average rate of 410.5
cubic yards per hour, and in the reclamation of 150 acres of the flat
area to the height of about 2 feet above mean high tide. Three
wrecks and 9 snags were also removed and paid for under provisions
of the contract.
   This dredging has been of great benefit both to the General Govern-
ment and to the city of Washington.
   At the Washington Navy-Yard there has been established one of
the finest gun shops in the world, and large sums have been expended
in enlarging and increasing the facilities of the establishment. The
improvement of the channel has rendered this navy-yard more
readily accessible to a number of vessels of the navy.
   The trade and commerce of Washington are increasing, while the
wharf facilities along the Potomac front are inadequate for the
present traffic and afford little room for expansion. The improve-
ment of the Anacostia will give the needed additional wharfage room
and will afford abundant anchorage facilities, which do not now exist
in this vicinity.
   The dredging during the fiscal year in the channel of the Anacostia
River by other departments of the Government and by private
parties under permits and without cost to the United States Engi-
neer Department, amounted to 81,082 cubic yards. Of this the
Quartermaster's Department, between April 5, 1909, and May 29,
1909, excavated 31,048 cubic yards and deposited it upon the grounds
of the Washington Barracks Reservation.
   The total amount of material dredged from the channel to date is
about 2,109,123 cubic yards, of which about 214,803 cubic yards has
been done by private parties and other departments of the Govern-
ment.
   The ruling depth in the channel on June 30, 1909, was 20 feet at
mean low water.
                       ACQUISITION    OF LAND.

  Before the work under the existing project can be completed it
will be necessary for the Government to acquire a small parcel of
land at Buzzards Point (First and V streets, SW.). This land lies
channelward of the right bulkhead line and must be excavated to
that line. It is believed to be of but small value at the present
time and its early purchase is considered advisable.
     9001-ENG 1909--77
1218     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U.   S. ARMY.

                    FLATS AND RECLAIMED AREA.

   The greater part of the area of the Anacostia River now consists
of wide and extensive flats, which in summer and fall are covered with
a dense growth of eel grass and wild rice. While most of the sewage
formerly flowing into the stream has been turned by the new works
of the city into other channels, the sludge and other objectionable
matter which has been accumulating in the aquatic grasses for many
years past will, however, continue, if natural processes alone are
depended upon, to be for some time an unpleasant feature.
   The result of this insanitary condition is the prevalence of malarial
diseases in the portions of the city and District of Columbia which
border the Anacostia. The reclamation of the Potomac flats,
although not as yet entirely completed, has largely corrected the
insanitary condition along that front and gives promise of what may
be expected on the Anacostia. Although merely incidental to the
work of channel improvement, as affording the most convenient and
economical means of disposing of the excavated material, this
reclamation of the flats of the Anacostia below the Navy-Yard Bridge
will also render available for park or other purposes about 460 acres
of desirable land.
   About 150 acres have now been reclaimed by depositing thereon
1,894,320 cubic yards of material that has been dredged to date from
the channel under the direction of this office. The shore bordering
this area is owned either by the General Government (the United
States Hospital for the Insane Reservation) or by the city (the
reservation purchased for the outfall sewer).
   The remaining area to be reclaimed is bordered by shores owned
by private parties or corporations, and as its reclamation may bring
forth claims based on riparian or other rights vested in the shore
property, it is suggested that the acquisition by the General Gov-
ernment, or by the District of Columbia, of highway right-of-way
along the shore from the Navy-Yard Bridge to Giesboro Point is
very desirable and that action looking to such acquisition should be
taken at once.
   The type of sea wall for retaining dredged material which has been
adopted for this locality consists in a trapezoidal riprap mound
extending to mean low water from about 6 feet below and sur-
mounted by a masonry wall of trapezoidal section rising to an eleva-
tion of about 6 feet above mean low water. In order to construct
the sea wall a trench is first dredged to a depth of 6 feet below mean
low water with a bottom width of about 40 feet. In this trench
riprap is deposited until the top of the mound reaches 4 feet above
mean low water and the base has a width of about 23 feet. As the
river bottom is of soft mud, considerable settlement occurs in the
mound; as this progresses more riprap is added to maintain the
elevation of the top of the mound. When the riprap in place has
ceased to settle, its top is leveled off to the elevation of mean low
water and the masonry wall is constructed.
   The work of the fiscal year on the project for the sea wall con-
sisted in raising 2,900 linear feet of riprap mound to 5 feet above
mean low water by the placing of 4,023.1 cubic yards of riprap; in
redredging trenches, embanking and aligning the fill at its northwest
                                   APPENDIX K-REPORT                          OF MAJOR MORROW.                                1219

corner by the excavation and the embankment of 60,503 cubic yards
of material.
    The riprap was furnished and placed under contract with the
Columbia Granite and Dredging Corporation. The excavation was
done under open market agreement as follows:
    With John Miller, dated January 4, 1908, 21,975 cubic yards, at a
cost, including incidentals, of $2,198.12.
    With John H. Miller, dated March 3, 1909, 16,208 cubic yards, at a
cost, including incidentals, of $1,257.66.
    With the Miner Engineering Company, dated June 10, 1909,
22,320 cubic yards. The cost is an outstanding liability.
    The work of the year incidental to the reclaimed area consisted
in diverting the outlet of Stickfoot Branch by digging a ditch along
the shore of Poplar Point and from there carrying its flow through
a wooden flume to bulkhead line, and in repairing the wooden water
duct which had been placed under the fill for the purpose of fur-
nishing the United States Hospital for the Insane with river water.
This duct, broken by the unequal settlement of the superimposed
fill, cut off the river-water supply, which was restored after repairs
were made.
  The diversion of Stickfoot Branch and repairs to the water duct
were done by hired labor.
                                                                 EXPENDITURES.

   The total expenditures for the fiscal year 1909 were distributed
as follows:

                                                                                         Improve-          Maintenance.      Total.
                                                                                          ment.

Dredging in channel and incidentals..........................                              $77, 435.26 .      ..........    $77, 435.26
Dredging in trenches for, and embankment behind, riprap
  mounds....................................................                                  2,198 12        $1,633. 62      3,831.74
Raising riprap mounds and incidentals ...................................                                      3,028 20       3,028.20
Drainage of Stickfoot Branch..........................                                 .............              648.42        648.42
Repairs to water duct supplying river water to the United States
  Hospital for the Insane.......................................                       .............              570.86        570.86
Engineering, maintenance of office, contingencies, and miscel-
  laneous.....................................................                                    668 99           600.00     1,268.99
         Total...............................                           ............         80, 302.37        6, 481.10     86, 783.47



                                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.

   For the successful and economical prosecution of this improvement
large and continuous appropriations should be made, as was stated
in presenting the original estimates for the work. Upon this assump-
tion was based the estimated unit price for dredging, which is con-
siderably lower than the prices which have usually been paid for
such work on the Potomac, and if the appropriations are small and
made at irregular intervals the actual cost of the work will exceed
the estimated cost. One hundred and fifty thousand dollars can
profitably be expended each year in completing this improvement and
in hastening the benefits to be derived therefrom.
1220           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                       Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement...................................    $210, 000
   For maintenance of improvement............................       20, 000
                                                                                                          -   $230, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                     APPROPRIATIONS.
Previous projects:
    September 19, 1890 (allotment from appropriation for improving Poto-
      mac River).................................................... .....                                     $20, 000

Existing project:
    June 13, 1902.....................................................                                         150,000
    M arch 2, 1907.......................................................                                      127, 000
    March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 23, 1909) ...............................                                      10, 000

        Total...........................................................                                      a287, 000
        Aggregate.............................                             ............................        307,000


                                               CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

   Contractor: John Miller, of Washington, D. C., for dredging a trench and for filling
behind riprap wall. (Emergency contract.)
  Amount: Dredging trench, 7,000 cubic yards; filling behind riprap wall, 25,000
cubic yards.
   Date of contract: April 4, 1907.
   Date for commencement: April 9, 1907.
   Date for completion: Seventy days after notification to commence filling behind
riprap wall. Extended. Final payment was made on August 24, 1908.
   Rate: Dredging trench, 13 cents per cubic yard; filling behind riprap wall, 18 cents
per cubic yard.
   Contractor: John Miller, of Washington, D. C., for modifying price and quantity
of contract of April 4, 1907. (Supplemental contract.)
   Date of contract: December 16, 1907.
  Approved: December 19, 1907.
  Contractor: Maryland Dredging and Contracting Company, of Baltimore, Md., for
dredging.
  Amount: Soft material, 700,000 cubic yards; hard material, 21,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: August 26, 1907.
  Approved: September 6, 1907.
  Date for commencement: November 9, 1907.
  Date for completion (including dredging in Potomac River near Washington, D. C.):
May 9, 1909. Final payment was made on January 27, 1909.
  Rate: Soft material, 9 cents per cubic yard; hard material, 20 cents per cubic yard.
   Contractor: Columbia Granite and Dredging Corporation, of Washington, D. C.,
for furnishing and placing riprap stone.
   Amount: 5,000 cubic yards.
   Date of contract: April 19, 1909.
   Approved: April 28, 1909.
   Date for commencement: On or before May 19, 1909.
   Date for completion: September 19, 1909.
   Rate: $1.27 per cubic yard.
  aThe unexpended balance of allotment from appropriation of September 19, 1890,
$1,463.06, was applied to the existing project. Total for existing project, $288,463.06.
              WJ




         ()

                   /
     Q




                            Z0

                                                                                                                                                      .3


                                         2
                                                                            3
                       S4




                                                 3
                                                                                                                                                            4


                                         3

                                                                                                                                                                      -3
                                 3
                                                                                                                                                                4
                                                                       RE             AI
op   0.00



                                     4
                                                                                                           ANACO STIA RIVER,
                                                                                                                  AT-              --
                                                                                                                 Washington, D.C.
                                                                                                           Portion below Navy Yard Bridge.
                                                                                                                           5cale of Feet
                                                                                                                  500      0            500   1000   1500
                                                     ;I.       X            4-                                    f
                                                                                                                      To c ccompny
                                                                                                                      To    c omp   Annu/
                                                                                                                                  nyA      eortortffor
                                                                                                                                      nnul ep       or t/ryer      \,
                                                                                                                                                           h51eer etd/hg Julim
                                                                                                                                                                       June
                                                                                                                                                                          .\,\  ,_01909.
                                                                                                                                                                               /909
                                                           .       Q_-O.'"      LEGEND :-
                                                                                 4.
                                                                   -   ft.Con/ou; shown /thuis ....
                                                                   Chann/ L/ines,          57sh0own thus   .Z..
                                             Nip A/Pl Foundat/on /ony i5u//rh/ie'dL/e,ihown thus..                         .....
                                                                                                                                                                           THE                           DC
                                                                                                                                                                                     PETERS CO, WASHINGTON,
                                                                                                                                                                                 NORRS
                              APPENDIX K-REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                                                                                        1221
                                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
                                Receipts and shipments by water, calendar year 1908.

                        Articles.                                        Quantity.                               Articles.                            Quantity.

                                                                              Tons.                                                                     Tons.
Asphalt...............................                                          2,600       Paving blocks.........................                         4,400
Bricks..............................1,000                                                   Railroad ties..........................                          500
Brick clay... .......................                                           48,000      Sand and gravel......................                        129,600
Coal....             ..........................                                 10,765      Shingles...............................                           80
Laths..................................                                             550     Stone.................................                        24,540
Lumber................................                                           2, 526     W ood.................................                         6,300
Oil, gasoline, etc.......................                                       20, 018
Naval ordnance and supplies...........                                          32,393            Total...........................                       283, 272


                                            Arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1908.

                                                                     Class.                                                                Number.       Gross
                                                                                                                                                       tonnage.

Navy vessels drawing 10 to 21 feet..................................................                                                             23       20,000
Tugs drawing 6 to 10 feet...........................................................                                                         1,800        54,000
Sailing vessels drawing 4 to 15 feet..................................................                                                          140       28,000
Sailing vessels drawing 15 to 20 feet...........                                .................................................                 2        3,400
Barges and scows drawing less than 12 feet.........................................                                                          2,200       380,000
         Total              ..........................................................                                                       4,165       485,400



                                                                                         K 4.
                            IMPROVEMENT OF BRETON BAY, MARYLAND
                WORK              OF          THE             FISCAL                     YEAR   ENDED               JUNE             30,    1909.
   The work of the fiscal year consisted of an inspection, survey, the
preparation of specifications for dredging, and other miscellaneous
office work and the incidental expenditure thereto, amounting to
$297.08, was applied to maintenance.
   For the reasons stated in the district officer's report of the fiscal
year 1908, for Occoquan Creek, the contract for dredging with Charles
P. Grim, dated April 23, 1906, was annulled August 21, 1907. The
work provided for under this contract at Breton Bay had, however,
been completed, but other work contemplated in the contract was not
finished until the completion of work in the Pamunkey River on Octo-
ber 30, 1908. A statement of the account was then prepared and the
contract was closed by final payment made February 4, 1909. The
expenditure incidental thereto, amounting to $485.65, was applied to
improvement.
   Advertisement and specifications for dredging at Breton Bay, with
similar work on the Mattaponi and Pamunkey rivers, were prepared,
printed on June 3, and bids thereon will be opened on July 2, 1909.
                                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.

Previous projects (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 263)............. $37, 500
Existing project:
    June 13, 1902 (allotted Sept. 4, 1902).............................                                                                                  6, 000
    March 3, 1905.......................................................                                                                                 6, 000
    March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 23, 1909)................................                                                                               4,000

            Total.............................................................                                                                          16,000

            Aggregate...............................................-.                                                                                  53,500
1222            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                          U.    S. ARMY.

                                              CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  Contractor: Charles P. Grim, of Philadelphia, Pa., for dredging.
  Amount: 30,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: April 23, 1906.
  Approved: April 28, 1906.
  Date for commencement: June 29, 1906-extended.
  Date for completion (including dredging in Mattaponi and Pamunkey rivers and
Occoquan and Carters creeks, Virginia): June 29, 1907-extended.    Annulled August
21, 1907. Final payment was made on February 4, 1909.
  Rate: 19- cents per cubic yard.



                                             COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
[Furnished by Messrs. Enoch B. Abell, A. A. Lawrence, Francis B. King, and others, Leonardtown, Md.]
                          Receipts and shipments, by water, calendar year 1908.

                   Articles.                       Quantity.                         Articles.                     Quantity.

                                                       Tons.                                                        Tons.
Bricks...............................                      600      Ice...................................                 125
Canned goods..........................                      20      Iron.................................                  130
Cement and lime......................                      200      Live stock............................                 200
Coal .................................                     350      Lumber...............................                  600
Crabs................................                          50   Oil, gasoline, etc......................                 7
Farm produce.........................                      500      Oysters................. ............               1,600
Fertilizer.............................                    900      Railroad ties.........................                 770
Flour............... ...................                   150      Tobacco..............................                  400
General merchandise..................                      800      Wood.................................               1, 355
Grain.................................                     685
Hay .................................                      150            Total..........................               9,592


                                     Arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1908.
                                                                                                                     Gross
                                                Class.                                                   Number. tonnage.


Steamers drawing less than 7 feet................................................                             50        1,500
Steamers drawing between 7 and 10 feet...........................................                            312      284, 928
Sailing vessels drawing less than 10 feet...... ... ..     ...........................................       100        7, 000
Launches..........................     .............................................                          25           125
       Total........................................................................                         487      293,553


                                                               K5.
IMPROVEMENT OF YORK, MATTAPONI, AND PAMUNKEY RIVERS AND
         OCCOQUAN AND CARTERS CREEKS, VIRGINIA.

                                                 (A)     YORK RIVER.

               WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE                                                30, 1909.
   As soon as the United States plant completed dike construction in
the Rappahannock and Pamunkey rivers it was moved to York River.
The snag boat (convertible into a pile driver) with its complement of
scows and small boats, arrived from Pamunkey River on December
11 and after making the necessary preparation began the reconstruc-
tion of the West Point timber dike on December 17. The pile driver
and its complement of scows and small boats arrived from the Rap-
pahanock River on January 13, when it alsd was put to work.
   The reconstruction of the dike was thereafter prosecuted by the
two drivers until April 1, when, the snag boat was withdrawn for
                  APPENDIX K-REPORT                       OF MAJOR MORROW.               1223

snagging operations on the Mattaponi and Pamunkey rivers. The
work was greatly impeded by windstorms and the incidental high
seas, fully 20 per cent of the available working time being lost on this
account.
   The most severe storm of this period occurred on February 10, and
tore the quarter boat and pile driver from their moorings and beached
them several miles away therefrom. This storm also did considerable
damage to the dike then in process of rebuilding, about 150 feet being
lost. The plant was pulled off the beach at a high tide on February
23, having sustained no material damage, and the damage done to the
dike was subsequently repaired.
   The result of the work was the reconstruction of 3,192 linear feet
of dike. Two hundred and nine thousand, nine hundred and fifty-
nine feet B. M. of lumber used therein was furnished by Denmead
Brothers, under contract and open market agreements, and the
structural material was purchased under public notice.
                                 UNITED STATES PLANT.

  During the fiscal year the following government plant was in use:
One snag boat, 1 pile driver, 1 gasoline tow boat, 1 quarter boat, 3
scows, 6 small boats.
  The wooden hulls of all the floating plant required a coat of copper
paint to protect them against the teredo. This work was commenced
on June 26 and at the end of the fiscal year the pile driver and quar-
ter boat had been hauled out, repaired, and painted. Miscellaneous
other repairs to machinery, etc., were made during the fiscal year.
  The total expenditure during the fiscal year was $8,619.77, which
was applied to maintenance and divided as follows: Reconstruction
of West Point dike by government plant and hired labor, including
materials and incidental expenses, $8,355.94; repairs to plant, $83.37;
maintaining the services of the steamer General Warren, attached to
this office, $79.61; and miscellaneous, $95.85.
                             Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
improvement . -.... .. . . .. . .                  -..
                                            . . . . . ..              .
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
                                                                          . $25, 000

  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                      APPROPRIATIONS.

June 14, 1880.............. $10, 000. 00              Amount transferred to con-
March 3, 1881.....       ........     25, 000. 00      solidated appropriation un-
August 2, 1882.............. 25,000.00                 der act of June 13, 1902...      $167.03
July 5, 1884................. 20, 000. 00
August 5, 1886..............          18, 750. 00                                    246, 759. 95
August 11, 1888.............          30, 000. 00     March 3, 1905 (allotted July
September 19, 1890.......... 30, 000. 00               28, 1905)..................     3, 111. 91
July 13, 1892...............          35, 000. 00     March 2, 1907 (allotted Apr.
August 18, 1894..............         20, 000.00       1, 1907....................     7, 000.00
June 3, 1896................ 16, 000. 00              March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar.
March 3, 1899...........        ..... 10, 000. 00      23, 1909)..................    23, 000. 00
June 13, 1902 (allotted)......         2, 176. 98
June 13, 1902 (emergency                                      Total................ 279, 871.86
  allotment June 6, 1904)....          5, 000. 00

                                    246, 926. 98
1224                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                                CONTRACTS IN                FORCE.

  Contractor: Denmead Brothers, of West Point, Va., for lumber. (Emergency
contract.)
  Amount: 113,280 feet, b. m.
  Date of contract: September 19, 1908.
  Date for commencement: November 4, 1908.
  Date for completion: December 19, 1908. Final payment was made May 21, 1909.
  Rate: $18 per M feet, b. m.
  Contractor: R. P. Clarke Company, of Alexandria, Va., for lumber.                                                                   (Emergency
contract.)
  Amount: 401,050 feet, b. m.
  Date of contract: May 27, 1909.
  Date for commencement: June 26, 1909.
  Date for completion: November 27, 1909.
  Rate: $17.80 per M feet, b. m.
                                                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

[Furnished by Chesapeake Steamship Company, of Baltimore, Md., and B. E. Owens and J. W. Marshall,
                                      of West Point, Va.]

                                     Receipts and shipments by water, calendaryear 1908.

                          Articles.                                      Quantity.                     Articles.                           Quantity.

                                                                             Tons.                                                           Tons.
Canned goods..........................                                         2,743   Piles..................................                  3,000
Coal...      ............................                                      2,000   Railroad ties.........................                   3.500
Crabs.........      .........................                                    188   Ship timber.........................                     4,450
Farm produce........................                                           5,715   Tobacco.............................                     8,524
Fertilizer............................                                         8,265   Wood................................                    32,102
General merchandise..................                                         40,368
Lumber..............................                                           8,684         Total....      ..................                178, 445
Oysters...............................                                        58,906


                                                      Arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1908.


                                                                    Class.                                                       Number.    nage.ton-
                                                                                                                                           Gross


Steamers drawing from 4 to 15 feet...............................................                                                    260      404,560
Sailing vessels drawing from 10 to 14 feet.........................................                                                   22        8, 856
Barges and scows  ......................................................                                                              10        8,000
Launches...................                         .......................................                                        1,800        9,000
        Total.........................................................                                                             2,092      430,416



                                                               (B) MATTAPONI                 RIVER.

                     WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30,                                                                       1909.
   (a) Dredging at Walker bar, under emergency contract with the
Miner Engineering Company, in progress at the end of the last fiscal
year, was completed on July 10, by the hydraulic dredge which
worked continuously, with the exception of incidental delays. About
900 linear feet of channel-half the length of the bar-were dredged
to the full projected dimensions. About 6,370 cubic yards of material
were dredged from the channel and deposited ashore.
  The dredge was in operation one hundred and two hours, excavat-
ing on an average about 62 cubic yards per hour.
   The work of the last fiscal year with that of this fiscal year on the
channel through this bar consisted in dredging a channel 1,800 feet
                                    APPENDIX K-REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                                                                        1225
to the full projected dimensions and of the excavation of 9,922 cubic
yards of material, at the average rate of 50 cubic yards per hour.
This contract was closed by final payment made on December 19,
1908.
   (b) Redredging the lower section of Latan6 bar under contract
dated October 21, 1907, with the Miner Engineering Company, was
begun on July 11 and was completed on August 5, by the hydraulic
dredge which worked continuously, with the exception of incidental
delays. This dredging resulted in the completion of the lower 1,850
linear feet of channel to the full projected dimensions, by the exca-
vation of 8,800 cubic yards of material, which was deposited upon
the adjacent flats at least 500 feet from the channel.
   The dredge was in operation one hundred and sixty and one-half
hours, excavating on an average about 55 cubic yards per hour.
   This contract was closed by final payment made on August 19, 1908.
   (c) Dredging under open-market agreement with the Miner En-
gineering Company, dated July 24, 1908, resulted in the completion
of channels of the full projected dimensions through the following bars:

                                                                                                                   Com-      Length of
                                                                 Name.Begun.                                       leted      channel      Excavated.
                                                                                                                  Spleted    completed.

                                                                                                                             Linearfeet. Cubic yards.
Upper section Latand.....................................                                   Aug. 6 Aug. 14                        1,500         6,005
Robinson.................................................                                   Aug.        17        Sept. 11        3, 530       16, 209
Presque Isle......................                                       ................   Sept.       12        Sept. 19        1,250         6, 052
Sales.......                       ...................................                      Sept.       21        Sept. 24           650        2,656
Jones....................................................                                   Sept.       24        Oct. 9          1,850         7,811
          Total.............................................                                ...................                   8,780        38,733



   A small wreck and 54 snags were removed from the channel through
Jones bar by the contractor under the provisions of the agreement.
   The hydraulic dredge, also used on this work, was in operation con-
tinuously, except for incidental delays, for seven hundred and ninety-
seven hours, excavating on an average about 49 cubic yards per hour.
The excavated material was either pumped ashore or upon the adja-
cent flats, at least 500 feet from the channel. The account was closed
by final payment made on November 3.
   A reapportionment of funds from the combined appropriation of
the river and harbor act of March 2, 1907, for improving York, Matta-
poni, and Pamunkey rivers and Occoquan, Lower Machodoc, Nandua,
Aquia, and Carters creeks, Virginia, was made on the recommendation
of the district officer by the Chief of Engineers on July 23. This
reapportionment transferred $2,200 from the Occoquan and $1,000
from the Carters allotments, that had been previously made, to the
work of this improvement.
   An allotment of $10,000 from the emergency funds of the river and
harbor act of March 3, 1905, was also applied to this improvement, on
the recommendation of the district officer and the Chief of Engineers,
by the Secretary of War. Of this allotment $5,981.31 were expended
and $4,018.69 were returned to the Treasury.
   Snagging of the river by the United States snagboat and hired labor
was begun September 10, suspended on October 1, resumed on Janu-
ary 20, suspended February 2, and resumed on June 7, and was in
progress at the end of the fiscal year. During these periods 148 snags,
1226             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

logs, etc., and 355 overhanging trees were removed and secured
ashore.
  Between August 1 and 28 a survey of the river between Latand bar
and Ayletts, a distance of 51 miles, was made.
   The contract with Charles P. Grim, dated April 23,1906, and annulled
on August 21, 1907, for the reasons stated in the district officer's
report of 1908, for Occoquan Creek, was closed by final payment made
on February 4, 1909.
  Advertisement and specifications for dredging at Mattaponi River,
with similar work at Breton Bay and Pamunkey River, were prepared
and printed and distributed on June 2 and bids thereon will be opened
on July 2, 1909.
  The total expenditure during the fiscal year was $19,779, which
was divided as follows: Dredging under Miner's emergency contract
of October 3, 1907, and expenses incidental thereto (maintenance),
$3,062.22; dredging under Miner's contract of October 21, 1907, and
incidental expenses thereto (maintenance), $3,354.25; dredging under
Miner's open-market agreement of July 24, 1908, and expenses inci-
dental thereto, improvement, $4,000; maintenance, $8,111.60; snag-
ging (maintenance), $904.47; closing account of Charles P. Grim's
contract of April 23, 1906 (improvement), $9.58; and engineering,
clerical, and miscellaneous expenses (maintenance), $336.88.

                                           Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement................................... $20, 000
   For maintenance of improvement..............................      5, 000
                                                                                                                          $25, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                       APPROPRIATIONS.
June 14, 1880........................................................                                                       $2, 500.00
March 3, 1881.........................................................                                                       3, 300. 00
July 5, 1884..........................................................                                                       2, 500.00
August 5, 1886.........................................................                                                      5, 000.00
August 11, 1888........................................................                                                      3, 000.00
September 19, 1890.....................................................                                                      3, 000.00
July 13, 1892----------------------------------------------------..........................................................  4,000.00
August 18, 1894........................................................                                                      4, 000. 00
June 3, 1896..........................................................                                                       2, 500.00
June 6, 1900 (allotted June 30, 1903)....................................                                                       800.00
March 3, 1905 (allotted July 28, 1905)...................................                                                    5, 500.00
March 2, 1907 (allotted Apr. 1, 1907)...................................                                                     6, 500.00
March 3, 1905 (emergency allotment, Aug. 17, 1908, net)................. 5, 981.31
March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 23, 1909)..................................                                                     7, 500. 00

                                                                                                                       56, 081. 31
July 23, 1908, transferred from allotment for Occoquan Creek of April 1,
  1907..............................................................                                                     2,200.00
July 23, 1908, transferred from allotment for Carters Creek of April 1, 1907.                                            1, 000. 00

          Total.............................................................                                           59, 281.31
                                    APPENDIX K -REPORT                                             OF MAJOR MORROW.                                                 1227
                                                                   CONTRACTS                      IN      FORCE.

  Contractor: Charles P. Grim, of Philadelphia, Pa., for dredging.
Amount: 10,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: April 23, 1906.
Approved: April 28, 1906.
  Date for commencement: June 29, 1906, extended.
  Date for completion (including dredging in Breton Bay, Maryland, and Pamunkey
River and Occoquan and Carters creeks, Virginia): June 29, 1907, extended.
Annulled August 21, 1907. Final payment was made on February 4, 1909.
Rate: 291 cents per cubic yard.
Contractor: Miner Engineering Company, of Norfolk, Va., for dredging.
Amount: 8,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: October 3, 1907.
  Date for commencement: Not later than December 15, 1907.
Date for completion (including dredging in Occoquan Creek and Pamunkey River,
Virginia): October 1, 1908. Final payment was made on December 19, 1908.
Rate: 291 cents per cubic yard.
Contractor: Miner Engineering Company, of Norfolk, Va., for dredging.
Amount: 10,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: October 21, 1907.
Approved: October 25, 1907.
  Date for commencement: December 25, 1907.
  Date for completion (including dredging in Occoquan, Urbana, and Carters creeks,
Virginia): January 26, 1909. Final payment was made on August 19, 1908.
Rate: 35 cents per cubic yard.


                                                                    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                     [Furnished by B. E. Owens, West Point, Va.]

                                  Total receipts and shipments by water, calendaryear 1908.

                            Articles.                                        Quantity.                                     Articles.                              Quantity.

                                                                                  Tons.                                                                             Tons.
Farm produce.......................                                                  2, 600       Ship timber..........................                                   375
General merchandise...................                                               5,178        Wood...          ..........................                         23, 914
Lumber..............................                                                58,000
Piles.................................                                               2,000                 'Iotal..........................                           95,069
Railroad ties.........................                                                3,000


                                                                              Above Walkerton.

Farm produce.......................                                                       . 650   Ship timber........................                                      94
General merchandise.................                                                      1,295   Wood.............................                                    5, 979
Lumber..............................                                                 14,500
Piles..................................                                                 500                Total..........................                            23,768
Railroad ties...........................                                                   750


                                                   Total arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1908.


                                                                          Class.                                                                        Number. tonnage.
                                                                                                                                                                toasse.


Steamers drawing from 4 to 6 feet..................................................                                                                         150       19, 350
Sailii.g vessels drawing from 10 to 14 feet...........................................                                                                       61       15, 681
Sailing vessels drawing less than 10 feet................                                   .......................                           .......       147       14, 600
Barges, scows, etc......................       ............................................                                                                 310       79,310

          Total........................................................................                                                                     668      128,941
1228                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                         U.     S. ARMY.

                                                                            Above Walkerton.


                                                                       Class.                                  Number. tonnage.


Steamers drawing from 4 to 6 feet.................................................                                  86    11,094
Barges, scows, etc.................................................................                                150    30,000

        Total............................................................                       ............       236    41,094



                                                                (c)         PAMUNKEY RIVER.

                    WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30,                                                     1909.

   For the reasons stated in the district officer's report of 1908 for
Occoquan Creek, the contract with Charles P. Grim, dated April 23,
1906, was annulled August 21, 1907, and on October 3, 1907, an
emergency contract was entered into with the Miner Engineering
Company, of Norfolk, Va., for the completion of the work remaining
to be done under this annulled contract, at the prices that were in
effect thereunder.
   Dredging at Hogan bar, under this emergency contract, was begun
on October 19 and was completed on October 30 by the hydraulic
dredge, which worked continuously, with the exception of incidental
delays. This dredging resulted in the completion of 1,250 linear
feet of channel through the bar to a 70-foot width and to the full
projected depth, by the excavation of 8,885 cubic yards of material,
which was deposited ashore fully 50 feet back of the river bank.
Four snags were removed under the provisions of the contract. The
dredge was in operation 101 hours, excavating on an average about
88 cubic yards per hour. The contract was closed by final payment
made on December 19, 1908.
   With the completion of this work, all the work contemplated by
Grim's contract was finished, and final payment was made to Grim
on February 4, 1909.
   Nine permeable spur dikes at Hogan bar, aggregating in length
980 linear feet and containing 413 piles, and 5 at Buckland bar,
aggregating in length 1,352 linear feet and containing 681 piles,
were constructed by the government plant and hired labor between
October 17 and December 9. The piles used in these dikes were
furnished under contract with Andrew Miller, of Baltimore, Md.,
dated September 15, 1908. The delivery of the total quantity of
piles was made on October 14, and the contract was closed by final
payment made on October 26, 1908.
   The snagging of the river by government plant and hired labor
was begun on October 6th, suspended on October 15, 1908, resumed
on April 7, and completed on June 4, 1909. During the periods 100
snags, logs, etc., 208 overhanging trees, and the wreck of a vessel at
Garlicks Ferry were removed and secured ashore.
   Advertisement and specifications for dredging at Pamunkey
River, with similar work at Breton Bay, Maryland, and Mattaponi
River, Virginia, were prepared and were printed and distributed on
June 2, and bids thereon will be opened on July 2, 1909.
                      APPENDIX K-REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                                          1229
   The total expenditure during the fiscal year was $6,956.91, which
was divided as follows: Dredging under Miner's contract and ex-
penses incidental thereto (improvement), $2,803.05; constructing
permeable jetties and expenses incidental thereto (improvement),
$2,851.92; snagging (maintenance), $1,025.41; maintenance of
steamer General Warren, $141, and engineering, clerical, and mis-
cellaneous office expenses, improvement, $100; maintenance, $35.53.
                                Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement................................... $20, 000
   For maintenance of improvement..............................       5, 000
                                                                                                 $25, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                              APPROPRIATIONS.

June 14, 1880................... $2, 500                 March 3, 1905 (allotted July 28,
March 3, 1881.................... 2,500                   1905).......................... $3,400
August 2, 1882................... 2, 500                 March 2, 1907 (allotted Apr. 1,
August 5, 1886...................               5, 000     1907)...      ......            ---     5, 500
August 11, 1888_---...       -.   -3, 000                March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 23,
September 19, 1890--...             .......
                                     3, 000               1909)..---.........     .....            7, 500
July 13, 1892.................... 3,000
August 18, 1894..................   2, 000                     Total....................          42, 900
June 3, 1896....................     2,000
June 6, 1900 (allotted Apr. 28,
  1903).......................... 1,000



                                      CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

Contractor: Charles P. Grim, of Philadelphia, Pa., for dredging.
Amount: 8,000 cubic yards.
Date of contract: April 23, 1906.
Approved: April 28, 1906.
Date of commencement: June 29, 1906-extended.
Date for completion (including dredging in Breton Bay, Maryland, and Mattaponi
River and Occoquan and Carters creeks, Virginia): June 29, 1907-extended.
Contract annulled August 21, 1907. Final payment was made February 4, 1909.
Rate: 291 cents per cubic yard.
Contractor: Miner Engineering Company, of Norfolk, Va., for dredging.
Amount: 8,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: October 3, 1907.
  Date for commencement: Not later than December 15, 1907.
  Date for completion (including dredging in Occoquan Creek and Mattaponi River,
Virginia): October 1, 1908. Final payment was made December 19, 1908.
  Rate: 294 cents per cubic yard.
  Contractor: Andrew Miller, of Baltimore, Md., for furnishing and delivering piles.
(Emergency contract.)
  Amount: 20,034 linear feet.
  Date of contract: September 15, 1908.
  Date for commencement: October 5, 1908.
  Date for completion: October 25, 1908. Final payment was made October 26, 1908.
  Rate: 5* cents per linear foot.
1230                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                           U. S. ARMY.

                                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                      [Furnished by B. E. Owens, West Point, Va.]

                                 Total receipts and shipments by water, calendar year 1908.

                            Articles.                                          Quantity.                                Articles.                                 Quantity.

                                                                                 Tons.                                                                              Tons.
Grain ................................                                               514       Ship timber.........................                                    4,075
Fertilizer.............................                                                  150   W ood.... .............................                                 7,890
Lumber..............................                                               32,640
Piles ...............................                                    .           2,200               Total..........................                              49, 107
Railroad ties..........................                                              1, 638


                                                                             Above White House.

                                                                                 Tons.                                                                              Tons.
Grain ................................                                                   514   Ship timber.........................                                    4, 075
Lumber..........11,690                                                             11,690      Wood............................
                                                                                               Wood....2,                                                                   400
Piles ...............................                                               2,200-
Railroad ties..........................                                                  833             Total.........................                               21,712


                                            Total arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1908.

                                                                         Class.                                                                              tonnage.
                                                                                                                                                     Number. tosse.


Sailing vessels drawing less than 10 feet...         ..................................                                                                      54        6,080
Sailing vessels drawing more than 10 feet......................................                                                                              44       31, 040
Barges, scows, etc..................................................................                                                                         26        6,998
         Total..............................................................                                                               .......        124         44,118


                                                                             Above White House.

Sailing vessels drawing more than 10 feet..........................................                                                                           9        7,280
Sailing vessels drawing less than 10 feet...........................................                                                                  .      33        4,100
Barges, scows, etc..................................................................                                                                          9        3, 400
         Total........................................................................                                                                       51       14,780



                                                           (D)        OCCOQUAN                   CREEK.

                      WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR                                                        ENDED               JUNE 30,                    1909.
     The work of the fiscal year consisted of an inspection and miscel-
taneous office work and the expenditure incidental thereto, amount-
ing to $84.05, was applied to maintenance.
  The contract with Chas. P. Grim dated April 23, 1906, and an-
nulled on August 21, 1907, for the reasons stated in the district offi-
cer's report of 1908 for this locality, was closed by final payment
made on February 4, 1909.
  The expenditures incidental to closing the emergency contract
dated October 3, 1907, and the contract dated October 21, 1907, with
the Miner Engineering Company, were $316.98, applied to mainte-
nance, and $1,285.77, applied to improvement, respectively.
                       APPENDIX K-REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                                       1231
                                      Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ended June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement................................... $20, 000
   For maintenance of improvement..............................     5, 000
                                                                                               $25, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                   APPROPRIATIONS.

Previous projects (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 323)......... $25, 000. 00
Existing project:
    September 19, 1890..........               ...................................... 10, 000. 00
    July 13, 1892.................................................5,                      000. 00
    August 18, 1894...................................................                 5, 000. 00
    June 3, 1896..................................................                     2, 500. 00
    March 3, 1899................................................                      2, 500. 00
    June 13, 1902 (allotted Sept. 5, 1902).............................                2, 600.00
    March 3, 1905 (allotted July 28, 1905).............................5,                 971.44
    March 2, 1907 (allotted April 1, 1907)............................... 20, 000.00
    March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 23, 1909).............................                1, 000. 00

                                                                                             54, 571. 44
Amount transferred to consolidated appropriation under act of June 13,
1902...............................................................                            272.03

                                                                                             54, 299.41
July 23, 1908, amount transferred to Mattaponi River from allotment of
  April 1, 1907......................................................                         2,200.00
       Total....................................................                             52,099.41
       Aggregate.........................                          .......................   77,099.41


                                              CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

  Contractor: Charles P. Grim, of Philadelphia, Pa., for dredging.
  Amount: 30,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: April 23, 1906.
  Approved: April 28, 1906.
  Date for commencement: June 29, 1906-extended.
  Date for completion (including dredging in Breton Bay, Maryland, and in Matta-
poni and Pamunkey rivers and Carters Creek, Virginia): June 29, 1907-extended.
Annulled August 21, 1907. Final payment was made February 4, 1909.
  Rate: 17 cents per cubic yard.
  Contractor: Miner Engineering Company, of Norfolk, Va., for dredging.
  Amount: 25,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: October 3, 1907.
  Date for commencement: Not later than December 15, 1907.
  Date for completion (including dredging in Mattaponi and Pamunkey rivers, Vir-
ginia): October 1, 1908. Final payment was made December 19, 1908.
  Rate: 17 cents per cubic yard.
  Contractor: Miner Engineering Company, of Norfolk, Va., for dredging.
  Amount: 100,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: October 21, 1907.
  Approved: October 25, 1907.
  Date for commencement: December 25, 1907.
  Date for completion (including dredging in Urbana and Carters creeks and Matta-
poni River, Virginia): January 26, 1909. Final payment was made August 19, 1908.
  Rate: 16 cents per cubic yard.
1232                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                           U.   S. ARMY.

                                                                    COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                                   [Furnished by Mr. G. W. Hunter, Occoquan, Va.]

                                        Receipts and shipments by water, calendar year 1908.

                            Articles.                                         Quantity.                                  Articles.                   .     Quantity.

                                                                                  Tons.                                                                      Tons.
Cement...............................                                                        5   Lumber...............................                               850
Coal ..................................                                                     55   Oil, gasoline, etc......................                          15
Fertilizer.............................                                                    100   Piles..................                ..............          1,500
Flour................................                                                       90   Railroad ties............ ............                         3,500
General merchandise..................                                                       25   Sand and gravel......................                         17,500
Grain ................................                                                     900   Salt.................................                            100
Hay .................................                                                      300   W ood...............................                           1,000
Iron ..................................                                                      5
Lime .................................                                                      13             Total..........................                     25,958


                                                        Arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1908.


                                                                          Class.                                                             Number. tosse.
                                                                                                                                                     tonnage.


Steam vessels drawing less than 7 feet..............................................                                                                  62        6,000
Sailing vessels drawing less than 7 feet...........................................                                                                   30          768
Barges, scows, etc.................................................................                                                                  264       30,600
Launches.........................................................................                                                                     85          637

           Total........................................................................                                                             441       38,005



                                                                      (E)         CARTERS CREEK.

                       WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE                                                                               30, 1909.

  The work of the fiscal year consisted of an inspection and miscel-
laneous office work, and the expenditure incidental thereto, amounting
to $128.08, was applied to maintenance.
   For the reasons stated in the district officer's report of 1908, for
Occoquan Creek, the contract with Charles P. Grim, dated April 23,
1906, was annulled August 21, 1907. The work provided for under
this contract at Carters Creek had, however, been completed, but
other work contemplated in the contract was not finished until the
completion of dredging in the Pamunkey River on October 30, 1908.
A statement of the account was then prepared, and the contract was
closed by final payment made on February 4, 1909. The expendi-
ture thereunder, amounting to $335.22, was applied to improvement.
   An available balance of about $1,144 from the allotment of 1907
was left after completion of all the work called for by the approved
project, and $1,000 of this balance was transferred to the improve-
ment of Mattaponi River, Virginia, by the Chief of Engineers on
July 23, 1908.
   The project being completed, the funds hereafter required will be
for maintenance. No funds are required for the fiscal year 1911.
                         APPENDIX K-REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                                                               1233
                                                     APPROPRIATIONS.

June 13,      1902 (allotted Sept. 6, 1902, and Dec. 13, 1904) .-...-.-........ $10, 471. 83
March 3,      1905 (allotted July 28, 1905)..................................     9, 116.65
March 2,      1907 (allotted Apr. 1, 1907)------------....                 ..    10, 000.00
March 3,      1909 (allotted Mar. 23, 1909)...................................    1, 000.00
                                                                                                                       30, 588.48
July 23, 1908, amount transferred to Mattaponi River from allotment of
  April 1,1907.......................................................                                                   1, 000.00
         Total.........................................................                                                29,588.48



                                               CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

  Contractor: Charles P. Grim, of Philadelphia, Pa., for dredging.
  Amount: 17,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: April 23, 1906.
  Approved: April 28, 1906.
  Date for commencement: June 29, 1906-extended.
  Date for completion (including dredging in Breton Bay, Maryland, and Mattaponi
and Pamunkey rivers and Occoquan Creek, Virginia): June 29, 1907-extended.
Annulled August 21, 1907. Final payment was made February 4, 1909.
  Rate: 261 cents per cubic yard.
  Contractor: Miner Engineering Company, of Norfolk, Va., for dredging.
  Amount: 28,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: October 21, 1907.
  Approved: October 25, 1907.
  Date for commencement: December 25, 1907.
  Date for completion (including dredging in Occoquan and Urbana creeks and
Mattaponi River, Virginia): January 26, 1909. Final payment was made August 19,
1909.
  Rate: 27 cents per cubic yard.


                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                         [Furnished by H. E. Owen, Weems, Va.]

                           Receipts and shipments by water, calendar year 1908.

                    Articles.                         Quantity.                          Articles.                      Quantity.

                                                        Tons.                                                             Tons.
Bricks................................                    3,000 Ice........             ...........................               300
Canned goods.........................                     1,280 Iron.....------........--------................                 50
Cement...                 ........................            15Live stock............................                           60
Coal.................................                     7,000    Lumber..-. .....................-                         1,500
Crabs...............................                        220    Oil, gasoline, etc..........         ........             1,200
Farm produce........................                      1,750    Oysters... .........................                     16,000
Fertilizer.........................                       3,750    Piles.................................                    2,020
Flour................................                        550   Pickles........                   ...............      .       5
Fish for food...........................     50 Railroad ties.........................                                       1,000
Fish for fertilizer..................... 15,000 Salt.................................                                          500
Fish oil...     .......................     650 Ship timber..........................                                          200
General merchandise..................     1,430 Wood.................................                                        1,200
Grain................................. .                     70
Iay...................................                       25             Total..........................                 58,825

          9001-ENG 1909                   78
1234                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                              Arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1908.


                                                            Class.                                                              Number.        Gross.
                                                                                                                                              tonnage.

Steam vessels drawing less than 5 feet----------------------------------------...............................................       413           5,156
Steam vessels drawing from 5 to 10 feet.............................................                                                800         480,000
Sailing vessels drawing less than 5 feet..............................................                                            8,052          17,040
Sailing vessels drawing from 5 to 10 feet...                          ..................................                          1,000          70,000
Launches drawing from 1 to 3 feet............................................                                                     6,500          16,250
         Total..           ..         .     ..        .      ................................................                    16,765         588,446



                                                                                 K 6.
                                   IMPROVEMENT OF NOMINI CREEK, VA.

                   WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE                                                                   30, 1909.

  The extension of the jetty under contract and two open-market
agreements with the Chesapeake Stevedore Company, of Baltimore,
Md., was begun on June 5, and was completed on June 30. Under
the contract and one agreement 1,042 cubic yards of riprap were
placed on the outer or north end at the rate of $2.60 per cubic yard
in place, which extended the jetty in that direction 288 linear feet.
   By another agreement at the rate of $2.72 per cubic yard in place,
the inner or south end of the jetty was extended 266 linear feet, by
the placing of 298 cubic yards, completing the work which could be
done with the available funds.
  The total expenditure during the fiscal year was $3,757.83, which
was applied to improvement and divided as follows: Extension of
the jetty, including superintendence and inspection, $3,733.93;
clerical and miscellaneous incidental expenses, $23.90.

                                                 Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement................................... $6, 000
   For maintenance of improvement............................         4,000
                                                                                                                                          -   $10, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                             APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1873..................                                  $10, 000                August 18, 1894................. $5, 000
June 23, 1874..................                                    6, 000                June 3, 1896...................    2,500
March 3, 1875...................                                   5, 000                March 3, 1899................... 10, 000
March 3, 1879...................                                   2, 500                March 3,
                                                                   5, 000                March  3, 1905
                                                                                         March 2,
                                                                                                        ................... 4, 000
                                                                                                   1905-------------------45,000
                                                                                                   1907..................   5, 000
June 14, 1880..................
March 3, 1881................                                      2, 000                March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 23,
August 2, 1882..............                                       2, 000                  1909).......................     4, 000
August 11, 1888.................                                   5, 000
September 19, 1890.............                                    5, 000                                Total...................              83,000
July 13, 1892..................                                   10, 000
                                   APPENDIX K-REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                                                                               1235
                                                                    CONTRACT IN                     FORCE.

  Contractor: Chesapeake Stevedore Company, of Baltimore, Md., for constructing
and repairing riprap jetties.
  Amount: 300 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: June 2, 1909.
  Approved: June 16, 1909.
  Date for commencement: July 17, 1909.
  Date for completion (including construction and repair of riprap jetties in Urbana
Creek and Rappahannock River, Virginia): February 17, 1910.
  Rate: $2.60 per cubic yard.
                                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                           [Furnished by J. L. Healy, Templeman Cross Roads, Va.]

                                         Receipts and shipments by water, calendar year 1908.

                           Articles.                                         Quantity.                           Articles.                        Quantity.

                                                                                 Tons.                                                              Tons.
Bricks................................                                                 200      Live stock............................                   100
Canned goods........................                                                 1,260      Lime.................................                    100
Coal.................................                                                     100   Lumber..............................                     250
Crabs................................                                                     100   Oil, gasoline, etc......................                    50
Farm produce........................                                                 5,000      Oysters. ............................                  2,000
Fertilizer.............................                                              1,000      Salt..................................100
Flour.................................                                                    100   Ship timber..........................                    350
Fish...................................                                                   250   W ood.................................                 5,000
General merchandise...................                                                6,000
Grain.................................                                                    800          Total..........................                22,760


                                                       Arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1908.

                                                                         Class.                                                     Number.          Gross
                                                                                                                                                   tonnage.

Steamers drawing less than 10 feet of water.........................................                                                        260      138,580
Sail vessels drawing less than 10 feet of water......................................                                                       300       15,000
Barges and scows.................................................................                                                            35       70,000
Launches.........................................................................                                                           350        1,750

          Total........................................................................                                                     945      225,330



                                                                                           K7.

                   IMPROVEMENT OF RAPPAHANNOCK RIVER, VIRGINIA.

                               WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 1909.

                                                                                    CHANNELS.

  Dredging under contract with the Bowers Hydraulic Dredging
Company, of Camden, N. J., was begun by the hydraulic dredge
Bowers on July 2, 1908, on a 24-hour-per-day basis; on October 29,
1908, this basis was changed to a 12-hour-per-day rate, which was
maintained until April 20, 1909, when the dredge was withdrawn from
the work for repairs. During this period the Bowers was in operation
2,602 hours and excavated 211,823 cubic yards, at the average rate of
81.4 cubic yards per hour. The hydraulic dredge Maclcenzie resumed
the work on April 28, 1909, and to June 30, 1909, had been working
on a 24-hour-per-day basis. During this period the Mackenzie was in
operation 813.7 hours and excavated 249,607 cubic yards, at the aver-
age rate of 306.6 cubic yards per hour.
1236                    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                            U. S. ARMY.

      The details of the dredging done during the fiscal year are as follows:

                                                                                                    Completed to Length AmountDeposit
                                    Bars.                                            Begun.         full projected
                                                                                                      fullprojected nl 1fch on- exca-
                                                                                                                        exca-           posi
                                                                                                                                       location.
                                                                                                     dimensions.      vated.    vated.


                                                                                                                      Feet.   Use.yards.
Mangoright..............................                                           July    2,1908   Oct. 5,1908        8,300   121,033     X
Fredericksburg a............. .                          ...........               Oct.   12,1908   Apr. 5,1909        4, 600   83,451     Z
Pollock..........                         ..................                       Apr.    6,1909   Apr. 20,1909       1,000      7,339    Z
Nanzatico..........................                                                Apr.   28,1909   May 6,1909         2, 900    55, 933   X
Millbank...........................                                                May     7,1909   May 10,1909        2,200     18,150    X
Mount............              .........................                           May    11,1909   May 14,1909        1,700     13,935    X
Berry Plane............................                                            May    15,1909   May 17,1909           900     4,189    Y
Hop Yard...                     .......................                            May    18,1909   May 20,1909        1, 650    18,187   W
Arnolds.... ........................                                               May    21,1909   May 24,1909        1,800     11,283   W
Farley Vale.................                .          ..........                  May    24,1909   May 28,1909        1, 400    14,598    Z
Moss Neck.......................                                        ....       May    29,1909   June 3,1909        2,100     26,729    Z
Spring Hillb..............                                   ...................   June    3,1909   June 10,1909       1,700     17,217    Y
Hayfield..............................                                             June   11,1909   June 16,1909       1,900     24,946    Y
Hollywood....................                               .......                June   16,1909   June 21,1909          800     5,356   W
Castle Ferry....................................                         .....     June   21,1909   June 27,1909       2,400     19,084 Y and Z
Snowden..............................                                              June   28,1909   In progress...     1,500     20,000    Y
           Total........................................................                                              36,850   461,430

       a Partially completed; ruling depth, 102 feet.                                          b Partially completed; ruling depth, 11 feet.

     W. On the flats along adjacent shores.
     X. In the river to either side of the channel and at least 500 feet therefrom.
     Y. Upon the adjacent shores.
     Z. Within the area inclosed by dikes.

   It is anticipated that channels from Fredericksburg, Va., to the
mouth of the river, of the full projected dimensions, will be completed
in the near future under the present contract and an open market
agreement to be made for the excavation of some hard material not
provided for therein. This work will complete the project and will
give a ruling depth of at least 12 feet at mean low water throughout
the river.
   The ruling depths on June 30, 1909, were 9 feet in the 11-mile reach
of river immediately below Fredericksburg and 13 feet at mean low
water from there to the mouth.
   The freshets that occurred during the fiscal year were comparatively
slight. Their dates and height of crests are as follows: January 6, 9.5
feet; April 15, 11.8 feet; May 23, 8.5 feet; June 5, 8.6 feet; and June
14, 9.7 feet. The winter was extremely mild. The little ice which
was formed did not cause suspension of navigation nor dredging
operations.
                                                        MAINTENANCE                         OF CHIIANNELS.

  At the time the last modified project was submitted it was estimated
that the annual cost of maintenance would be $10,000. The greater
part of this expenditure will be required at Fredericksburg bar, which,
being near the head of tide water, received new deposits of sand with
each recurring freshet to such an extent that redredging is necessary
almost every year to maintain the channel in navigable condition.
  The cost of removing the deposits at this bar alone is estimated at
$7,500 per anmnm. An expenditure of $8,772.55 was made during the
year for restoring the projected dimensions to the channel through
Fredericksburg, Pollocks, Castle Ferry, and Farley Vale bars.
                                  APPENDIX K--REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                                                                                1237

                                                                                  DIKES.

   The 5,486 linear feet of dikes which were in progress of construc-
tion on June 30, 1908, at the various bars and which were fully
described in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1908,
page 1233, were completed in October, 1908. On September 1 the
United States snag boat, with its complement of men and floating
plant, was withdrawn from this work and transferred to snagging
operations on the Mattaponi River.
   The repairs to the old timber dikes were begun in October and
completed on December 26, 1908; 492 linear feet were repaired.
The government plant was transferred on January 8, 1909, to similar
work on the York River.
   The work on the riprap jetty for Farley Vale bar, which was in
progress under contract with J. H. Davis, of Fredericksburg, Va.,
on June 30, 1908, was continued until October 6, 1908, when the
amount of work specified in the contract was completed. The result
of this work was that the dike was extended 240 feet by the placing
of 404.4 cubic yards of stone, and that 37.4 cubic yards of stone were
placed along the front of timber dikes to strengthen them.
   The aggregate work for the fiscal years 1908 and 1909 under this
contract was the placing of 1,655.8 cubic yards of stone, of which
1,334.4 cubic yards constructed 915 linear feet of jetty, and 321.4
cubic yards were used to strengthen the timber dikes at other local-
ities.
   A contract was entered into with the Chesapeake Stevedore Com-
pany, of Baltimore, Md., on June 2 for the completion of this jetty.
To the end of the fiscal year no work was done thereunder; it is
anticipated, however, that it will be completed in the near future.
   The protection for the dredged spoils that were deposited within
the areas inclosed by the dikes against freshet erosion has been
prosecuted by a party of four or five men since January 12, 1909.
By June 30, 1909, 6,586 linear feet of wattling and 521 linear feet of
box drain had been built, 260 linear feet of box drain had been
repaired, and 6,734 willow slips had been planted.
                                                                       EXPENDITURES.

   The total expenditure during the fiscal year was $65,020.51, dis-
tributed as follows:

                                                                                                                 Improve-             Mainte-       Total.
                                                                                                                  ment.               nance.


Dike construction and incidentals..............................                                                     $4, 612.52     ..-- - - -       $4,612.52
Dike repairs and incidentals ..                   .......               ................                         ...                    $1,200.96    1,200.96
Jetty, Farley Vale, construction and incidentals................                                                     1,    .....                      , 499.48
Dredging channels, and incidentals...........................                                                       43,228.78           8,772.55    52,001.33
Protection of sand fills.................................................823.90                                                                         823.90
Construction of new wharf and storehouse at Potomac Park,
  Washington. D. C..........................................................                                                              100.75       100.75
Repairs to plant...                     ................................................                                                1,117.79     1,117.79
Care of United States property...                                      .......................................                            402.26       402.26
Maintenance of steamer General Warren, attached to this office.                                                        500.00             550.80     1,050.80
Engineering, maintenance of office, contingencies, and miscel-
laneous......................................................                                                      1,100.00            1,110.72     2,210.72
          Total.........................                       ....                         ...........           50,940.78            14,079.73    65,020.51
1238           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                   Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of
improvement----------                     .....-..                         $30, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                            APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1871-.....        ... ......            $15, 000   March 3, 1899.................. $15,000
June 10, 1872..................15, 000                      June 13, 1902..................  25, 000
March 3, 1873...-----------------. 15, 000                  April 28, 1904 (allotted June 6,
June 23, 1874..................                    7,000      1904)........................  25,000
March 3, 1875------------------...5, 000                    March 3, 1905..................  40, 000
August 14, 1876- --...                       ..   10,000    March 2, 1907..................  77, 729
June 18, 1878...----------------- 13, 500                   May 27, 1908...................  58, 000
March 3, 1879...................                  10,000    March 3, 1909 (allotted Mar. 23,
June 14, 1880...----------------- 25, 000                     1909)........................  15, 000
March 3, 1881................... 15,000                     March 4, 1909..................  32, 000
August 2, 1882----------------..................  17,000
July 5, 1884.................... 20, 000                          Total.................... 540, 229
August 5, 1886..................                  20, 000
August 11, 1888 ($15,000, of                                Damage recovered from contract-
  which $3,000 was for Urbana). 12, 000                       ors' sureties .................   1, 000
September 19, 1890-...........                    15, 000   Proceeds of sale of property.....      110
July 13, 1892................... 20, 000
August 18, 1894.................                  10, 000         Total....................     1, 110
June 3, 1896...................                    8, 000



                                        CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

  Contractor: J. H. Davis, of Fredericksburg, Va., for riprap stone. (Emergency
contract.)
  Amount: 1,600 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: August 19, 1907.
  Date for commencement: September 18, 1907.
  Date for completion: December 18, 1907. Final payment was made October 26,
1908.
  Rate: $2.10 per cubic yard.
   Contractor: Bowers Hydraulic Dredging Company, of Camden, N. J., for dredging.
   Amount: 523,000 cubic yards.
   Date of contract: January 29, 1908.
   Approved: February 7, 1908.
   Date for commencement: August 10, 1908.
   Date for completion: February 10, 1910.
   Rate: 14.9 cents per cubic yard.

  Contractor: Chesapeake Stevedore Company, of Baltimore, Md., for constructing
and repairing riprap jetties.
  Amount: 1,800 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: June 2, 1909.
  Approved: June 16, 1909.
  Date for commencement: July 17, 1909.
  Date for completion (including construction and repair of riprap jetties in Nomini
and Urbana creeks, Virginia): February 17, 1910.
  Rate: $2.40 per cubic yard.
                                                   RsqctO O.



                                                               BAR




                                             '   BAR


                                "2.



          Mansfield




      Smithfield.                      BAR
                         ! E3




                            BAR




                         TSWOOD BAR




Salead.   r




                                  $xnowdmn



                                  7

                                             BAR




                                                         Hollywood




                                                           .YWOOD          BAR




                                                                     HILL BAR




                                                                             12




                    ,ARLZYVALE




                                                                             ,                         \
                                                                                         .
                                                                                                                \             PARD
                                                                                             A,", , c ,                              .ARC

                                                                                              4MILEI                           SA




                                                                           IRAPPAHANNOCK RIVER
                                                                                                  VIRGINIA
                                                                             FROM     FREDERICKSBURG                       TO PORT ROYAL
                           Halewoed


                                                                                                             $tahdeMiles
                                                                       :28

                                                                     (KH+ Hjh wa/er shore lin re           is shown // us:
                                                                             12/i Con/our is shown /ras"
                                                                    \\ ~     o   avoidcrocudg sourndi gs re omdl ed.
                                                                              s/an ces he/ow RR.Ari e    fe/eerickshur are shown
                                                                                                  //ts: O MILTe.
                                                               J   Cbinnels c/rcdjeddcurinjthe ficalyear are shown /t~is:                          warn.




                                                           :30
                        PORT ROYAL
                                                        RIT CONWAY
                                                           To      accompany      Annualilporifor Ie         ear endi          ie3         /909.



                                                                                                   VA7M        aior Cops of          £nbeersg 1,SA.

                                                                                                                               TICSE OR~IS PETERS C4 WSIOIN   .0
                                       .LBANK               BAR


       rOn ROB2J4                      5730




                                                                             BAR.




                                                                    40




                                              ILE       S




                                            L E60
                                                                            BAR




                                       70




                                                                RAPPAHANNOCK RIVER
                                                                                                         VIR GINIA
                                                            r           .        .        OM PORT ROYAL TO ENTRANCE.
MILE

                                                                                                           Statute Mile.

                                                                    4        3        2    t   I06                         ~1.

                                                             SOUihAAs dre i feel and slow I,4e 4/A a/-mean iow wa/er
                                                            Hi4 A waler sore ike is sAown /Au-s:
                                                                    IV
                                                            121 con/our is. sown
                                                                              !: : luss.---      s"................... ........
                                                                                             sontz
                                                                                       .otu is                             -----




                                                                            DIs/ances            elow R R.ridje a!lFederkkskur      are s own
                                                                                                          1hus o file.
                                                                    Cha felae/S drej eddurkjt /k e fiscalyear are shown            Thus:   a-----




                                                                                                     4
                                9
                               %~ rt                ~           <




                                                to                                   o"
                           4     .e                  " 2


                       t




        °.. ........
                                 ..                         V

                                                                                          affl%Annual Aeodr/or IAeyear endzn           Jdune 30, /909.
                              APPENDIX                 K-REPORT                   OF      MAJOR               MORROW.                            1239

                                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

     [Furnished by Messrs. A. P. Rowe, J. M. Goldsmith, and W. D. Scott, of Fredericksburg, Va.]

                                 Receipts and shipments by water, calendar year 1908.

                        Articles.                               Quantity.                               Articles.                              Quantity.


                                                                      Tons.                                                                      Tons.
Bricks ...--                         .....-------------------------     2,000    Ice...--------------------------------                             1,560
Canned goods........................_                                   5,000    Lime ..        ...........................                         3,100
Cement.............................                                     1,100    Live stock--....... .                    ...............              400
Coal ....... ....................                                       3,600    Lumber--.............---------------...----------..........       94,500
Farm produce.......................                                    33,500    Oysters..-............-..............                              2,025
Fertilizer ........................                                    26,940    Pickles......................                     .........        2,500
Flour...............................                                    6,375    Railroad ties..........................                          131,092
Fish (food)             ..........    ......---..--..                      775   Wood..............---..............                               22,500
Fish (fertilizer) ........-....                   .. ....                  525   Sumac-.............-.................                                 300
General merchandise-----------.............--....----.                 27, 600
Grain------------------------...-                                      29,100             Total.........................                          395,842
Hay................-------------------------------                      1,350



                                              Arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1908.


                                                             Class.                                                             Number. tosse.
                                                                                                                                        tonnage.


Steamers drawing 8 to 11 feet..                        ..----------------------------------------------                  250        125,000
Sailing vessels drawing 8 to 11 feet.......................-----------------------------------------                  1,100         330,000
Barges, scows, etc., drawing 8 to 12 feet...............                            ........---------------------------------------
                                                                                                                         170        170,000
Launches drawing 1 to 3 feet .......-..........................                ....      .....-......-          -     1,000           5,000
         Total.............................----------------------------------------------------------                                2,520        630,000



                                                                            K 8.

                          IMPROVEMENT OF URBANA CREEK, VIRGINIA.

                    WORK OF THE FISCAL                                    YEAR        ENDED JUNE                           30, 1909.

   The work of the fiscal year consisted in an inspection, survey, con-
tract for extension of riprap jetty, and miscellaneous office work,
the expenditure incidental thereto amounting to $180.37, being ap-
plied to maintenance.
   A contract was entered into with the Chesapeake Stevedore Com-
pany, of Baltimore, Md., for the extension of the riprap jetty on June
2, 1909, but no work thereunder was done during the fiscal year.
                                               Estimate of additional funds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement .....................          ........... $12, 000
   For maintenance of improvement.. ......................               5, 000
                                                                                                                                          $17, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
1240                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                    U.   S. ARMY.

                                                                 APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1879.................. $5, 000                                        July 13, 1892_ ............ ..... $3, 000
June 14, 1880_..... ....-.......    2, 500                                     August 18, 1894.................     3, 000
March 3, 1881_......- ......      . 4, 000                                     June 3, 1896....................     3, 000
August 2, 1882.-....         ...  . 4, 000                                     March 3, 1899....................    3, 000
August 11, 1888 (included in an                                                March 3, 1905..........        .... 10, 000
  appropriation of $15,000 for                                                 March 3, 1909 (allotted March 23,
  Rappahannock River)..-....        3, 000                                       1909).......................... 4, 000
September 19, 1890...............   3, 000
                                                                                                 Total..................... 47, 500



                                                         CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

  Contractor: Miner Engineering Company, of Norfolk, Va., for dredging.
  Amount: 20,000 cqbic yards.
   Date of contract: October 21, 1907.
  Approved: October 25, 1907.
   Date for commencement: December 25, 1907.
   Date for completion (including dredging in Occoquan and Carters creeks and Mat-
taponi River, Virginia): January 26, 1909. Final payment was made August 19, 1908.
   Rate: 22 cents per cubic yard.
  Contractor: Chesapeake Stevedore Company, of Baltimore, Md., for constructing
and repairing riprap jetties
  Amount: 1,000 cubic yards.
  Date of contract: June 2, 1909.
  Approved: June 16, 1909.
  Date of commencement: July 17, 1909.
  Date for completion (including construction and repair of riprap jetties in Nomini
Creek and Rappahannock River, Virginia): February 17, 1910.
  Rate: $2.64 per cubic yard.


                                                            COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

[Furnished by J.W. Hurley, J. J. Fisher, C. S. Burton, R. A. Davis, J. S. Gressett, L. L. Tignor, and A. D.
                                      Alexander, of Urbana, Va.]

                                  Receipts and shipments by water, calendar year 1908.

                        Articles.                                 Quantity.                                     Articles.                         Quantity.


                                                                    Tons.                                                                          Tons.
Bricks.............................                                     300    Hay.................................                                        100
Canned goods.......................----                                 600    Ice....................................                                     575
Cement and lime ......................                                    80   Iron.................................                                       100
Clothing, manufactured................                                  150     Live stock ...........................                                      50
Coal.............................                                     1,000    Lumber-..........                             ............              7,500
Crabs...... .........................                                     5     Oil, gasoline, etc...... ...                        ........               400
Excelsior.............................                                   50     Oysters........................                                        8,000
Farm produce..........                               .........          500    Pickles-...                ..................                               100
Fertilizer.......                 ................                      505    Railroad ties.........................                                      800
Flour..................................                                 350    Salt ............                  ..... ..............                      25
Fish for food.............................                              100    Wood-........ .....                                    .........        3,000
General merchandise...................                                4, 650
Grain.......               .........................                     60                 Total..........................                           29, 000
                              APPENDIX K--REPORT OF MAJOR MORROW.                                                                                 1241

                                             Arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1908.

                                                            Class.                                                               Number. tosse.
                                                                                                                                         tonnage.

Steamers drawing more than 5 feet......                     .............................................                                 150       75,000
Steamers drawing less than 5 feet...................................................                                                      313        3,756
Sailing vessels'drawing from 5 to 10 feet..........                 ----.....----..-------....-----...--......----------.....             200       15,000
Sailing vessels drawing less than 5 feet .....- -                   -...............................                          .....    2, 500       12, 500
Barges and scows drawing less than 5 feet----......-------.....------.......-...-------.................-------------                      50        1,000
Barges and scows drawing from 5 to 10 feet..............-.........                                               ..... .........            2           800
Launches drawing from 1 to 5 feet .......             -.............................                               .. .........        8,000        24, 000

         Total--------.......................-------------------------------------                            ----.......             11,215       132,056



                                                                           K 9.

          IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT MILFORD HAVEN, VIRGINIA.

                   WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 1909.

   The work of the fiscal year consisted of an inspection and mis-
cellaneous office work and the incidental expenditure thereto, amount-
ing to $113.65, was applied to maintenance. The balance, $57.81,
remaining from the appropriation made by the river and harbor act
of June 13, 1902, was, pursuant to section 10 of the sundry civil act
of March 4, 1909, returned to the United States Treasury on May
17, 1909.
   Observations of conditions at the northwest entrance to the har-
bor, covering a period of about fourteen years, demonstrated that
Narrows Point had been eroded several hundred feet by the action
of northerly storms at flood tides. The observations also indicated
that the outer bar had been formed almost entirely by this action.
As it was believed that some severe storm, through such action, would
cause a serious shoaling in the completed channel, the district officer,
on April 21, 1909, submitted for approval a project to extend the
existing jetty, which was built during the fiscal year 1908, for the
protection of Narrows Point, by about 800 feet, at an estimated cost
of $10,000. This modification was approved by the Chief of Engi-
neers on May 6, 1909, the estimate of cost for the improvement being
thereby increased from $17,500 to $27,500.
                                              Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for mainten-
  ance of improvement..............................................                                                                         $3, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                                             APPROPRIATIONS.
March 3, 1899.....----............--------------..............-------------.........------...-..-.....-------.... $12, 500. 00
June 13, 1902-----.......------........--.........................................
                                             -------------------------------------                                  5, 000.00
                                                                                                                                               17, 500. 00
Amount of judgment recovered.....................                                                         ..............                        3, 032. 97
            Total.......................................................                                                                 a 20, 532. 97

               a Of which $57.81 was carried to the surplus fund on June 30, 1909.
1242                  REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                          U.    S. ARMY.

                                                            COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.
                                              [Furnished by Mr. Eugene Callis, Grinstead, Va.]

                                    Receipts and shipments by water, calendar year 1908.


                           Articles.                                 Quantity.                             Articles.                        Quantity.

                                                                         Tons.                                                                Tons.
Bricks...............................                                         300       Ice....................................                     200
Coal.........                      ....................                       100       Iron............................................             50
Crabs. .............................                 ............          1,000        Live stock...........................                        65
Farm produce .......                        ................                  500       Lumber....................... ...                        1, 000
Fertilizer ............................                                       600       Oil, gasoline, etc......................                   250
Flour..................................                                       500       Oysters.............................                     5,000
Fish for food...........................                                   5,000        Piles.....................             .........        15,000
General merchandise ......................                                 2, 005       Wood...............................                         300
Grain........ ....... .................                                       200
Hay.................................                                          500              Total.........................                   32,570


                                                  Arrivals of vessels, calendar year 1908.


                                                                     Class.                                                              Gross
                                                                                                                               Number. tonnage.


Steamers drawing less than 10 feet............ ..... .                 ................ .....                            ...          240      158,400
Steamers drawing 10 feet or more.......                                     ......................                                      8        4, 000
Sailing vessels drawing less than 10 feet ...       ... ..              ....................                                          200       50,000
Barges. scows, and launches...........        .......................................                                             18, 000       36,000
          Total...............                   ....          ......................                                             18,448       248,400


                                                                                 K Io.

                               IMPROVEMENT OF JAMES RIVER, VIRGINIA.

                     WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE                                                                30, 1909.

   Operations were carried on under two contracts with P. Sanford
Ross (Incorporated), approved February 12, 1906, and November
12, 1907, respectively.
   The work accomplished toward obtaining increased width of chan-
nel during the fiscal year consisted in enlarging about 3,800 linear
feet of channel having a depth of 18 feet at mean low water, as fol-
lows: Completing the widening of the channel for a length of 400
feet from its former width of 200 feet to 300 feet, to form a part of
the proposed turning basin; widening about 1,900 linear feet between
Jetties 14 and 20 from its former width of 150 feet to 200 feet; and
widening from its former width of 100 feet and more to 200 feet about
1,500 feet on Warwick bar, between Jetties 90 and 98.
   The work done toward obtaining increased channel depth con-
sisted in deepening to 18 feet the part of the turning basin referred to
above from its former depths of about 3 to 11 Zfeet; in deepening to
18 feet about 1,900 linear feet between Jetties 14 and 20-, for a
width of 50 feet, from its former depths of 6 to 16 feet; and 1,500
linear feet of channel on Warwick bar for a width of about 100 feet
from its former depths of 141 to 17.9 feet.
   Of the expenditures for the past fiscal year, $140,871.44 was for
works of improvement and $3,447.94 for maintenance.
             APPENDIX   K--REPORT OF   MVAJOR   MORROW.           1243
WORK UNDER     CONTRACT WITH P. SANFORD         ROSS   (INCORPORATED),
                  APPROVED FEBRUARY 12,      1906.

  At the beginning of the fiscal year the contract was about 93 per
cent completed. It was completed October 5, 1908.
   The work done in channel enlargement consisted in completing
the excavating to a depth of 18 feet below mean low water of a part of
the proposed turning basin 400 feet long by 100 feet wide, about
25 per cent of which had been completed during the preceding year,
and widening to 200 feet the 18-foot channel on Warwick bar about
42 miles below Richmond for a distance of about 1,500 feet.
   The plant employed consisted of two dredges, one using a clam
shell, the other a scoop bucket. Hard rock and mixed material
were excavated with the latter type of bucket. The former was used
for dredging sand on Warwick bar and finishing the channel at the
turning basin. Dump scows were used for transporting material
dumped at Jordans Point and deck scows for material expended in
revetting jetties. A drill scow was used for drilling and blasting
hard rock and for sweeping the channel while it was being finished
with the clam-shell dredge.
   The time lost in dredging from various causes was as follows:
   The scoop dredge, two days making repairs; the clam shell, one
day waiting for scows to be unloaded, two and one-half days on ac-
count of freshets, and about three daysmaking repairs.
   Subjoined are the quantities and cost of work done:
   Material excavated from channel, 10,124.63 cubic yards earth, at
29.63 cents per cubic yard, and 1,640.41 cubic yards hard rock at
$6.3579 per cubic yard. Excavated material conveyed from scows
to points of deposit, 1,818.26 cubic yards at 19.40 cents per cubic
yard. Excavated material transported on dump scows to vicinity
of Jordans Point, 8,037.31 cubic yards, at 18.86 cents per cubic
yard.
   The expenditures during the year on account of the several classes
of work were as follows: Earth excavation, $3,000.34; hard rock
excavation, $10,429.51; conveying excavated material from scows
to points of deposit, $352.69; transporting excavated material on
dump scows to vicinity of Jordans Point, $1,515.68.
   Of the above expenditures, $3,447.94 is chargeable to maintenance.
   Following is a description of the work in detail:
   Turning basin.-The proposed turning basin is to be situated in
front of the principal city wharves of Richmond near the head of
section 1. When completed it is to be 22 feet deep by 600 feet long
and 400 feet wide, and is to be formed by widening the channel. The
part of the work provided for under this contract consisted in widen-
ing the channel to 300 feet for a length of 400 feet with a depth of
18 feet.
   At the beginning of the fiscal year the excavation of about 25 per
cent of the part of the basin provided for in the contract was com-
pleted, and about 65 per cent well advanced toward completion. The
dredging of blasted rock was carried on with the scoop dredge from
July 1 to 13. Finishing was begun with the clam-shell dredge August
3 and completed October 3.
  The quantities excavated were: Earth, 2,462.54 cubic yards; hard
rock, 1,640.41 cubic yards.
1244     REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. AR1VIMY.

   Section 5.-The work provided for in this section consisted in widen-
ing the 18-foot channel on Warwick bar to 200 feet for a distance of
about 2,800 feet. At the close of the last fiscal year the section was
about 75 per cent completed. Dredging with a clam-shell dredge was
carried on continuously till August 1, when the section was completed.
The material dredged consisted of 8,037.31 cubic yards of earth.
WORK   UNDER    CONTRACT WITH P. SANFORD         ROSS   (INCORPORATED),
                   APPROVED NOVEMBER 12,        1907.
  At the close of the fiscal year the contract was about 82 per cent
completed, of which about 18 per cent had been completed during
the preceding fiscal year.
   The operations conducted embraced extending the regulation works
in the 51-mile reach below the city line of Richmond, and in Willis,
Varina, and Deep Bottom reaches, situated 9, 15, and 18 miles,
respectively, below the same line, to maintain a 200-foot width for
an 18-foot depth of channel, dredging in divisions 1 and 2 to enlarge
the 18-foot channel to the above width, and removing old wharf piles
in Warwick reach.
   The plant employed consisted of one scoop dredge, one clam-shell
dredge, eight deck scows (each carrying about 90 cubic yards of earth),
four dump scows (each carrying about 370 cubic yards of earth), one
steam drill scow, one land pile driver, and three flatboats for carrying
lumber and piling for jetty work.
   The time lost by the dredges was as follows: Scoop dredge, freshets,
six days; repairs, nineteen and one-half days; and waiting for scows to
be unloaded, thirty-four days. Clam-shell dredge, freshets, one day;
repairs, four and one-fourth days; and waiting for scows to be un-
loaded, one-half day.
   Following are the quantities and cost of different classes of work
performed:
   Material excavated from channel, 78,484.5 cubic yards of earth, at
41.43 cents per cubic yard, and 2,721.92 cubic yards of hard rock, at
$12.3953 per cubic yard. Excavated material conveyed from scows
to points of deposit, 20,542.3 cubic yards, at 30.15 cents per cubic yard.
Excavated material transported on deck scows below Jetty 134,
24,867.44 cubic yards, at 16.75 cents per cubic yard. Excavated
material dumped in the vicinity of Jordans Point, 28,589.07 cubic
yards, at 25.13 cents per cubic yard. Material placed in jetties: Pine
piles, 17,716 linear feet, at 39.08 cents per linear foot; oak piles,
2,849 linear feet, at 55.83 cents per linear foot; oak wales and strings,
60,795.03 feet b. m., at $54.7183 per M feet b. m.; pine sheet piling,
285,574.95 feet b. m., at $42.4345 per M feet b. m.; spikes, bolts, and
washers, 28,006.52 pounds, at 5.58 cents per pound. Removing 167
wharf piles, at $3.3501 per pile.
   The expenditures during the year on account of the several classes
of work were as follows: Earth excavation, $32,515.72; hard-rock
excavation, $33,739.13; conveying excavated material from scows to
points of deposit, $6,193.67; transporting excavated material on deck
scows below Jetty 134, $4,165.42; dumping excavated material in
vicinity of Jordans Point, $7,183.20; pine piles in place, $6,924.19;
oak piles in place, $1,590.73; oak wales and strings in place, $3,326.60;
pine sheet piling in place, $12,118.23; spikes, bolts, and washers in
place, $1,563.75; removing wharf piles, $559.47.
             APPENDIX K-REPORT       OF MAJOR MORROW.              1245
   Following is a description of the work in detail:
   Division 1.-The division extends about 7,500 feet downstream
from about 800 feet below the lower city line of Richmond. It is
proposed to widen the above length of channel 50 feet and upward
to the full projected width of 200 feet.
   Drilling and blasting rock was begun July 9, and carried on during
July, August, October, and November, 1908, and in July, 1909. This
branch of the work was practically completed.
   About 25 per cent of the initial dredging had been completed
during the last fiscal year. Dredging was carried on continuously
from July 15, 1908, to the close of the year, excepting from March 25
to April 15. The scoop dredge was used for the initial dredging until
April 30, when this class of dredging was completed. The clam-shell
dredge was used for initial dredging from October 3 to 9, and for
finishing channel from April 28 to June 30. About 30 per cent of
the area of channel to be improved was finished.
   The quantities of material excavated from the channel in division 1
are: Earth, 73,420.68 cubic yards; hard rock, 2,721.92 cubic yards.
   Division 2.--The division extends from Jetty 41 to Jetty 49, about
21   miles below Richmond. It is proposed to enlarge the 18-foot
channel in this division by dredging to the full prescribed width of
200 feet for a distance of about 1,600 feet.
   Dredging was carried on over the lower two-thirds of the section
from March 25 to April 15, to procure material better suited for
revetting some of the jetties than was then being dredged in division 1.
The material dredged consisted of 5,063.82 cubic yards of sand and
gravel.
   Jetty construction.-About 30 per cent of this branch of the work
was completed during the last fiscal year, and the work entirely com-
pleted June 26, 1909.
   The work, as proposed, involved the construction of 50 jetties
and extending channelward 40 jetties constructed prior to 1895,
aggregating about 7,800 linear feet, in the 51-mile reach below Rich-
mond, and the construction of 9 jetties and extending 3 of the exist-
ing jetties, aggregating 1,800 linear feet, in Kingsland reach. As
the channel in Kingsland reach had deepened by scour in conse-
quence of building up the existing jetties with rock excavated from
the channel, the jetties proposed for this locality for accomplishing
the above result were found to be unnecessary, and about the same
extent of work was done instead in Willis and Varina reaches, where
shoaling of the channel had occurred. An additional 1,036 linear
feet of jetty were constructed at Deep Bottom shoal, where a slight
shoaling had also occurred.
   The work done was as follows:
   Extending channelward 28 jetties and constructing 37 jetties,
aggregating 7,600 linear feet of jetty. All of the jetties were suffi-
ciently revetted with material excavated from the channel to protect
them against ice and freshets.
   Removing wharf piles.-The piles of an old wharf situated on the
left side of the improved channel in Warwick reach were removed in
July, 1908, and June, 1909.
   General.-Cross sections of the channel in the lower half mile of
the 5 {-mile reach below Richmond, sounded in April, show that the
extension of the new jetties constructed during the year at that
1246           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

locality have effected some improvement in deepening the channel
by scour, and correcting the direction of flow.
  Cross sections of the channel sounded between the new jetties on
Willis reach show improvement, but without restoring the original
depth of 18 feet.
  The steamer Chipeta was used in making inspections of the river
and sounding. The boat was inspected July 3. It was hauled out
on a marine railway at Norfolk in December, and slight repairs made
to the calking and the hull repainted. Slight repairs were also made
to the engine and condenser pump.
  There were six freshets during the year, ranging from 5.8 feet to
14.2 feet above low water at the United States engineer gauge.
                                     Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement..--........ ....................      $485, 000
   For maintenance of improvement ......................        .   15, 000
                                                                                                                      $500, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.


                                               APPROPRIATIONS.

Previous projects (see H. Doc. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess., p. 321)........                                        $763, 000. 00
Existing project:
    July 5, 1884...------------------------------------------------                                                 75, 000. 00
    August 5, 1886-----..............---------------...........---------.....---------.................            112, 500. 00
    August 11, 1888-----...... .............-..-...-                                   .......- ....-              225,000.00
    September 19, 1890.......--..-..                .........-..                 ............          ....        200, 000.00
    July 13, 1892......................... ....... ........ .........                                              200, 000. 00
    August 18, 1894----......----.....--------...--..--------..............-....-----...------------.........      100, 000. 00
    June 3, 1896.---.----...----.............--------------...-.....--...-------------------.................      120, 000. 00
    March 3, 1899........ .............                       ........- .........           .....      .......     150, 000. 00
    June 13, 1902......---........................................--....                                           300, 000. 00
    March 3, 1905.............................................................. .....                              200, 000. 00
    March 2, 1907............................................                                                      200,'000. 00
    March 3, 1909 (allotted April 20, 1909) ...........................                                             10, 000. 00

                                                                                                                 1, 892, 500. 00
Recei ved from sale of condemned property........................                                                        331. 83
Other receipts.......................................................                                                        .67

         Total...................................................................                                1, 892, 832. 50

         Aggregate.................................................                                   ... . 2, 655, 832. 50


                                            CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

  Contractor: P. Sanford Ross (Incorporated), of Jersey City, N. J., for dredging,
removing rock, and constructing and repairing jetties in James River, Virginia.
  Date of contract: January 29, 1906.
  Approved: February 12, 1906.
  Date for commencement: March 16, 1906-extended to April 15, 1906.
  Date for completion: June 16, 1908-extended to September 14, 1908. Final pay-
ment was made October 31, 1908.
  Amount and rate: 102,461 cubic yards earth excavation, at 272 cents per cubic
yard; 18,818 cubic yards hard-rock excavation, at $5.90 per cubic yard; conveying
                                 APPENDIX K-REPORT                     OF MAJOR MORROW.                                                1247
54,640 cubic yards excavated material from scows to points of deposit, at 18 cents
per cubic yard; transporting 1,000 cubic yards excavated material on deck scows
below Jetty No. 134, at 10 cents per cubic yard; transporting 60,000 cubic yards
excavated material on dump scows to vicinity of Jordans Point, at 172 cents per cubic
yard; 4,259 linear feet round pine piles, 10 to 30 feet long, in place, at 35 cents per
linear foot; 530 linear feet round oak piles, 25 to 35 feet long, in place, at 50 cents per
linear foot; 15,596 feet B. M. white oak wales in place, at $50 per M feet B. M.; 2,833
feet B. M. white oak stringpieces in place, at $50 per M feet B. M.; 75,888 feet B. M.
merchantable pine sheet piling in place, at $39 per M feet B. M.

   Contractor: P. Sanford Ross (Incorporated), of Jersey City, N. J., for dredging earth
and rock, constructing jetties, and removing piles in James River, Virginia.
   Date of contract: November 4, 1907.
  Approved: November 12, 1907.
   Date for commencement: On or before January 14, 1908.
   Date for completion: November 14, 1909.
  Amount and rate: 133,400 cubic yards earth excavation, at 37.1 cents per cubic
yard; 5,750 cubic yards hard-rock excavation, at $11.10 per cubic yard; conveying
31,000 cubic yards excavated material from scows to points of deposit, at 27 cents per
cubic yard; transporting 22,000 cubic yards excavated material on deck scows below
Jetty No. 134, at 15 cents per cubic yard; dumping 35,000 cubic yards excavated
material in vicinity of Jordans Point, at 222 cents per cubic yard; 25,200 linear feet
round pine piles, in place, at 35 cents per linear foot; 4,300 linear feet round oak piles,
in place, at 50 cents per linear foot; 75,700 feet B. M. oak wales, in place, at $49 per M
feet B. M.; 14,200 feet B. M. oak stringpieces, in place, at $49 per M feet B. M.; 377,700
feet B. M. merchantable pine sheet piling, in place, at $38 per M feet B. M.; 32,000
pounds spikes, bolts, and washers, in place, at 5 cents per pound; removing 175 wharf
piles, at $3 per pile.


                                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

                                 Receipts and shipments by water, calendar year 1908.

                                                                                       Points on James River other
                                                Port of Richmond, Va.
                                                                                          than Richmond, Va.
                                                                                                                                        Total
                    Articles.                                                      i
                                                                                                                                      tonnage.
                                                           Ship-       Amount. Receipts.              Ship-
                                             Receipts.    ments.                                     ments.           Amount.


                                               Tons.       Tons.        Tons.          Tons.           Tons.           Tons.           Tons.
Asphalt blocks, brick, etc.......               3, 834             3     3, 837           395          14, 353          14, 748         18,585
Canned goods.................                      485                      485                                                             485
Cattle.............................                                                          57                124         181              181
Cement, lime, etc...............                1,118           75        1,193          2,211                           2,211           3,404
Coal .........................                 45,818          209       46,027          2,387                  40       2,427          48,454
Cord wood ......................                2,058       10,752       12,810             406         27, 885         28,291          41,101
Fertilizer and fertilizer material.            24, 979       2,018       26,997          2,253                  30       2,283          29,280
Fish and oysters................                2,760           58        2, 818             73                224         297           3,115
Flour...........................                                                           404                  16         420              420
Gasoline.......................                 5, 216                    5, 216                  ..........                             5,216
Grain ........................                  4, 050                    4,050            769            4,918          5,687           9, 737
Groceries..................                                        9           9         1,197              120          1,317           1,326
Hardware....................                       88              3          91           230               19             249             340
Hay, straw, etc .................                 140                        140           671            1,115          1,786           1,926
Hogs..........................                                                              19               62              81              81
Horses..................                                                                   155               73             228             228
Ice .......................                                                                581    ..........                581             581
Logs....................                       18,645              4     18,640            255               3              258         18,907
Lumber .....................                      910            636      1,546            208        128, 518         128, 726        130,272
Oil.........................                   21,032 ..........         21,032            570               1              571         21,603
Peanuts.......................                                                              95            5,802          5,897           5,897
Potatoes........................ 54                                  1     55               47                 207          254             309
Railroad ties ..............                                     4,777  4,777                             6,420          6,420          11,197
Salt............................                  455    ..........       455               63                   3           66             521
Sand................... ...                    20,931    ..........    20,931
                                                                                           519                  25-                     20,931
Vegetables................                        581    ..........       581                                               544          1,125
Unclassified freight............               47,112          37, 487 84,599            1,496                 951       2, 447         87,046

          Total...................            200,266       56,032      256,298         15, 061       190, 909         205,970          462,268
                                         '                                                                                        '
1248          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                            S. ARMY.

                 Arrival and departure of vessels during the calendar year 1908.

                                                                                                                     Port of Richmond, Va.
                                                  Class.
                                                                                                                     Number.    Tonnage.

Steam, drawing 5 to 13 feet----------......-----------------------------------                                          1,109    1,039,022
Sail, drawing 4 to 16 feet-.... ....--      ........... -.... ........-  .. .                                             200       33,232
Barges, etc   ------------------..............................----------------------------------------                    488      181,016
      Total      ------------------------------------..........---...........................---------------------      1,797    1,253,270


Returns of arrivals and departures of vessels for points on James River below Rich-
mond, Va., are too incomplete for report.


                                                                K II.
CONSTRUCTION OF PIERS, HAMPTON ROADS, JAMESTOWN EXPOSITION.

              WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30,                                                                  1909.
  A description of the project and of the conditions existing prior
to commencement of the work was contained in the Annual Report
of the Chief of Engineers for 1908, page 261.
  A description of the piers and channel of approach was contained
in the Annual Report of the Chief of Engineers for 1907, pages 1195,
1196.
   The entire work was completed during the fiscal year 1908.
   The work of the present fiscal year consisted in an inspection of
the roof work, developing the fact that slight repairs were necessary.
The cost of these repairs, amounting to $14, was paid out of the
$1,000 retained from the final payment to the contractor in lieu of
a bond guaranteeing that the roof work would remain tight for a
period of one year after acceptance of the work; the balance of $986
was paid the contractor on October 22, 1908.
  The balance of appropriations, amounting to $17,330.56, reverted
to the Treasury on October 26, 1908.

                                                     APPROPRIATIONS.

Amount appropriated by act of Congress approved June 30, 1906........... $400, 000
Amount appropriated by act of Congress approved February 9, 1907.......    65, 000
        Total..................                                      ...............         ....................                465, 000


                                               CONTRACTS IN                      FORCE.

  Contractor: The Scofield Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., for construction of piers.
  Amount: $385,000.
  Date of contract: November 1, 1906.
  Approved: November 3, 1906.
  Date for commencement: November 3, 1906.
  Date for completion: May 2, 1907. (Liquidated damages of $100 per day for each
day after May 2, 1907.) Final payment was made October 22, 1908.
  Contractor: The Scofield Company, of Philadelphia, Pa., for dredging and changes
in approved plans. (Supplemental contract.)
  Date of contract: March 5, 1907.
  Approved: March 12, 1907.
             APPENDIX K---REPORT     OF MAJOR MORROW.            1249
                                K   12.

   REMOVING     SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING             OR
                   ENDANGERING NAVIGATION.

        WORK OF THE FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE          30, 1909.

    (a) Wreck of pile driver in the Pamnunkey River, Virginia.-By
letter dated May 11, 1908, Mr. H. T. Faunt Le Roy reported the
existence of a sunken pile driver in the Pamunkey River near Cum-
berland. He stated that the river was narrow at that point, that
vessels were often "set in" by the current just where this pile driver
was situated, and that it constituted a great menace to navigation.
   Subsequent correspondence established the fact that the pile
driver belonged to the Beach Park Company, represented by Mr. E.
Wilkinson, of West Point, Va., and that it was sunk about February
1, 1908. On June 9, 1908, Mr. Wilkinson made an attempt to raise
it, and succeeded in moving the wreck about one-half mile up-
stream, where it was left in midstream in navigable water, mostly
submerged at high tide and unmarked and unlighted.
    An allotment of $300 was requested on June 22 and granted on
June 26, 1908, providing for the removal of this obstruction. Steps
were taken to provide for lighting the wreck at night in case Mr.
Wilkinson failed to do so.
    No work was done during the fiscal year 1908 toward this removal,
but steps were taken to light and buoy it.
   An inspection made by this office on July 11, 1908, confirmed the
report made by Mr. Wilkinson under date of July 9, 1908, that "the
sunken pile driver has been floated and is now lying on the shore at
West Point, Va., entirely out of everybody's way."
    The total expenditure from the allotment, amounting to $25, was
incidental to two inspections. The balance remaining from the allot-
ment, amounting to $275, was returned to the Treasury on August
31, 1908.
    (b) Seven wrecks on the flats of the AnacostiaRiver.-Seven old coal
barges, canal boats, etc., formerly belonging to the Allegheny Com-
pany, had been beached for several years on the fiats of the Ana-
costia near the outlet of James Creek Canal. During a period of
exceptionally high water during May two of these barges floated
across the Anacostia, lodging on the riprap wall for the area to be
reclaimed. In order that the remaining five barges should not
under similar circumstances be floated and become a menace to
navigation it was thought advisable to destroy them. The Alle-
gheny Company disclaimed ownership, stating that they had been
sold to a Mr. Lee R. Payne. Mr. Payne stated that he had merely
been employed by the Allegheny Company to care for them.
    An allotment of $50 for their destruction was requested on June
23 and granted on June 26, 1908.
    These wrecks were burned to the water's edge on July 16, and the
two that lodged on the riprap wall were subsequently placed behind
the bulkhead line upon the area which is to be reclaimed.
    The incidental expenditure was the amount of the allotment--50.
     (c) Removing wreck of barge in the Potomac River at Alexandria,
  Va.-While the examination and survey of the harbor at Alexandria,
     900--ENG 1909--79
1250    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.         S. ARMY.

Va., was being made it was reported by local parties that the hull
of an old steamboat that had been converted into a barge had sunk
during the freshet of 1889 at the end of the dismantled wharf near
the outlet lock of the Chesapeake and Ohio Canal. Local parties
believed that the shoaling along the Alexandria water front was
largely due to the influence of this wreck.
   The Board of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors recommended, on
April 13, 1908, the immediate removal of this wreck so that its effect
on the Alexandria water front could be noted. In compliance with
this recommendation an allotment of $1,000 was made on May 11,
1908.
   An accurate survey of the vicinity was made between May 19 and
23, 1908, from which it was determined that the wreck consisted of an
old barge or scow lying abreast of the old Chesapeake and Ohio Canal
outlet locks; that it was between 150 and 200 feet long, by about 35
feet beam, and covered with mud to a depth of 1 to 4 feet, over which
there is 5 to 9 feet depth at mean low water.
   Proposals for the removal of this wreck were issued May 28 and
opened June 8. On June 9 the award was made to Thomas Banks
and Capt. J. Wanner, the lowest bidders, for the sum of $650.
   The work of removal was begun June 15 and was completed Au-
gust 6, 1908. The wreck was removed in portions, which were towed
and deposited behind the training dike for the Virginia channel above
the Long Bridge. Nothing of value was recovered.
   The total incidental expenditure was the amount of the allotment-
$1,000.
   (d) Wreck of schooner E. G. Irwin, off Point Lookout, at the mouth
of Potomac River, Maryland.-The secretary and manager of Rescue
Harbor No. 14, American Association of Masters, Mates, and Pilots, of
Baltimore, Md., reported, by letter dated September 15, 1908, the
existence of this wreck. It was ascertained by an examination made
by a representative of this office on October 15 that the wreck was
an obstruction to navigation, lying directly in the path of light-draft
vessels. It was submerged from 2 to 10 feet in water, having a
least depth of 16 feet at low tide. On October 22 a report was for-
warded to the Chief of Engineers, with the recommendation that an
allotment of $700 be made for its removal, and the removal was
authorized on October 26, 1908.
   The General Warren (steamer attached to this office) was dis-
patched to the site on November 11 and worked on the removal
under unfavorable conditions, high winds and heavy seas prevailing
most of the time, until November 21, when the wreck had been
blasted down with dynamite, 800 pounds being used, to the level of
the adjacent bottom of the river. The pieces coming to the surface
were placed ashore. Nothing of value was recovered.
   The incidental expenditure was the amount of the allotment-
$700.
                                APPENDIX L.


IMPROVEMENT OF RIVERS AND HARBORS IN THE 
   NORFOLK, VIRGINIA, DISTRICT.


REPORT OF MAJ. JOSEPHE. KUHN, CORPS OF ENGINEERS, OFFICER
   IN CHARGE, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1909.

                                  IMPROVEMENTS.

1. Harbor at Norfolk and its approaches,    9. Inland water route from Norfolk, Vir-
     Virginia.                                   ginia, to Albemarle Sound, North
2. Western Branch of Elizabeth River,            Carolina.
     Virginia.                              10. Perquimans River, North Carolina.
3. Hampton Roads, Virginia.                 11. Blackwater River, Virginia.
4. Nansemond River, Virginia.               12. Meherrin River, North Carblina.
5. Pagan River, Virginia.                   13. Roanoke River, North Carolina.
6. Appomattox River, Virginia.              14. Removing sunken vessels or craft ob-
7. Harbor at Cape Charles City, Virginia.         structing or endangering naviga-
8. Waterway from Norfolk, Virginia, to            tion.
     the sounds of North Carolina.


                      ENGINEER OFFICE, UNITED STATES ARMY,
                                        Norfolk, Va., July 19, 1909.
   SIR: I have the honor to transmit herewith my annual report upon
the works of river and harbor improvement in my charge during the
fiscal year ended June 30, 1909.
        Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
                                                     JOSEPH E.     KUHN,
                                                  Major, Corps of Engineers.
  The    CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,         U. S. ARMY.


                                        LI.

IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT NORFOLK AND ITS APPROACHES, VIR-
                         GINIA.

                         (A) GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

   During the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, no actual operations
were carried on.
   An examination of the areas dredged in the previous fiscal year was
made and the wharves and other structures recently erected were
added to the maps.
   The amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year 1911
will be applied to dredging in completing channel to projected di-
mensions between the Norfolk and Western Railway and Campo-
stella bridges, and to removing a shoal area west of the former bridge.
                                                                         1251
1252           REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                         U.   S. ARMY.

                                   Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement.... ....        ............................ $5, 000
   For maintenance of improvement. .............................          5, 000
                                                                                                                   $10, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
  and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                            (B) HOSPITAL POINT.

   Operations during the fiscal year were confined to maintenance in
dredging over part of the shoal area south of Hospital Point. This
work was done under a contract at the rate of 10.7 cents per cubic
yard, measured in scows. Work was commenced July 13, 1908, and
finished August 18, 1908, 55,978 cubic yards, scow measurement,
having been removed during that period, and towed to the authorized
dumping ground on Willoughby bank. The cost of the dredging,
related above, including contingent expenses, was $6,392.39.
   There 'still remains to be dredged a small area which has shoaled to
less than the project depth, and the amount required for expenditure
in 1911 will be applied to this purpose.
                                    Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
provement-----........-------.....--------........---------.....-...----.........-------..------------............... $5, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                      (c)    THIRTY-FOOT              CHANNEL.

  This is a new project, adopted by Congress March 2, 1907, and the
work thereunder is being done under a continuing contract.
  Under a contract with the Coastwise Dredging Company, work was
commenced on October 24, 1907, between Lambert Point and
Craney Island light on the new ship channel.
  This contract is a continuing one and covers an estimated yardage
of 7,600,000 cubic yards in a channel about 9 miles long from Sewall
Point to the junction of the Southern and Eastern branches. The
contract price is 7.3 cents per cubic yard, scow measure.
  The work accomplished during the year resulted in the excavation
of 2,425,468 cubic yards, scow measure, at the following localities:
Between Pinner and Lambert points, 527,256 cubic yards; between
Lambert Point and Bush Bluff light-ship, 1,776,771 cubic yards;
between Bush Bluff light-ship and deep water in Hampton Roads,
121,441 cubic yards. The depth of 30 feet at mean low water has been
secured in all sections except on the outside cuts in a portion of the
section between Lambert Point and Bush Bluff light-ship, where a
heavy bank is encountered in soft mud. For this reason the lower
part of this section may need to be gone over a second time to insure
the project depth.
                          APPENDIX TI-REPORT OF MAJOR KUHN.                                                           1253
  In the dredging thus far, soft mud, stiff mud, clay, sand and shells
have been removed. The larger percentage, however, has been soft
and stiff mud.
  The contractor has now employed on the work three dredging plants
and the rate of progress is above that required to complete the work
on time. The total quantity of material removed and deposited to
the close of the fiscal year was 3,350,003 cubic yards.
  The excavated material is towed to and dumped at the established
dumping ground on Willoughby bank, an average distance of about
10 miles.
  The cost of dredging and contingencies during the fiscal year was
$190,070.57.
                                    Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for works of
  improvement------...........-------------............---------------------------........................... $150, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
  4, 1897.


                                                APPROPRIATIONS.
Improving harbor at Norfolk, Va.:
    August 14, 1876..--..------..--.......------------............---------.......--.........---------..            $35, 000. 00
    June 18, 1878-----------------------------------------------..................................................   50, 000. 00
  . March 3, 1879..---....-----------.....----.......-----......--...----...................----------------------- 75,000.00
    June 14, 1880---..---------------......................--------........------------..--......-----......         50,000. 00
    March 3, 1881..------------...---.......---..---------
                                                       ....---..-............-----....-------..........---           75,000. 00
    August 2, 1882..------...-----------...............---------------..............------..------.- .               75, 000. 00
    July 5, 1884------------------------........................-----....-...........----------...-......--------    75, 000. 00
    August 5, 1886......-----.........................                                ..................            187, 500. 00
    August 11, 1888.................................................                                                 60, 000. 00
    September 19, 1890---................---..........................                                              150, 000. 00
      July 13, 1892...-------------...........................................--..                              150, 000. 00
   August 18, 1894.................-- ..............                             ...........       .......      100,000. 00
   June 3, 1896--....................................----------------------------------..--......------- .      100, 000. 00
   June 13, 1902..............---------------...------------......................------------............       30, 000. 00
   March 3, 1903.......--              .......         ........ .............              .........--...       183, 957. 00
   March 3, 1905---..-----..--...--..--......-------........----------............--------------............     40,000. 00
   March 2, 1907..................                                         --------------------
                                                          ....-------............----..............             319, 825. 00
   May 27, 1908----------... ---                      ---------------------------------                         125,000. 00
   March 4, 1909-..--..-------------------------------------------                     .200,                         000. 00
   Allotment of November 23, 1904, from act of April 28, 1904, for
     "Emergencies in river and harbor works"......................                                               30, 000. 00
Improving Elizabeth River, Virginia:
   July 7, 1898....--............ ....-                   -       ......--      -...---.....-                   360, 000. 00

       Total...-------------------------------------------------..........                                  2, 471, 282. 00
      Received from sales.............................................                                               40. 86

       Total .--...........................................--........... 2, 471, 322. 86
      Amount turned into surplus fund of the Treasury from appropriation
       of July 7, 1898...-----------------------------------------------         483. 58

         Aggregate.....................................................                                     2, 470, 839. 28


                                           CONTRACTS IN FORCE.
                                                    Hospital Point.
  With Norfolk Dredging Company, for dredging, dated July 3, 1908; date for com-
mencement, July 13, 1908; date for completion, November 13, 1908. Price: 10.7
cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.
1254                 REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                       Thirty-foot Channel.
  With Coastwise Dredging Company, for dredging, dated August 6, 1907; approved
August 22, 1907; date for commencing work, October 22, 1907; date for completing
work, April 22, 1912. Price: 7.3 cents per cubic yard, scow measurement.



                                                COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statistics relative to the commerce of the harbor of Norfolk, Va., dur-
ing the calendar year 1908, were compiled from statements furnished by parties
engaged in making shipments over this waterway:

               Articles.                    Amount.      Value.                 Articles.              Amount.     Value.


                                            Short tons.                                                Short tons.
Block, paving.............                      11,050    $265,200    Lumber...........         ....    1,763,021  $8,570,410
Cement...................                        6,012      44,600    Oil, creosote.......      ...        14,000     204,000
Chemicals.............                          69,860     912,900    Oil, mineral..............           48,000     128,160
Clay..................                          25,200      25,200    Oysters ...............              41,404     512,160
Coal.......................                  2,595,692   7,867,292    Pig iron.................            13,598     240,800
Coke.....................                      113,165     339,495    Piling...... ........                23,100      79,300
Coke------------------                           9,622     259,794    Plaster, land....-...                20,337     143,812
Cotton ...             ...........              47,300  10,400,000    Sand.................                50,000      25,000
Fertilizer......                ........       100,814   2,741,176    Steel rail............               37,995     897,499
Fish..................                              711     42,000    Ties........            ......        1,136       2,840
Flour---------------....................-           128      7,800    Wood                                 15,640      67,769
Gravel................                           2,712       3,104    Miscellaneous .........           6,259,348 807,781,753
Lime.....-----.....--..........                  1, 497     11,837
Logs---------------                            465,804   1,808,025           Total..............       11,746,746 843,563,326
Lumber, creosoted...                             9,600     181, 400


  The deepest draft vessel using the channel during the year 1908 was the steamship
Bethania, drawing 29 feet and 6 inches, loaded with general cargo.

                  Approximate amount offreight handled by water during various years.

                           Year.                       Quantity.                        Year.                    Quantity.


                                                            Short tons.                                                          Short tons.
1888..........---- ..........................                1,914,506  1899........... ...................                        6,260,284
1889....................................                     2,243,087  1900...............................                        5,538,051
1890..................................                       2,384,841  1901..........                      ....................   7,761,356
                                              -------------- 2,931,751 1902...........---........................
1891------..--..---.....------.....-.......-...........                                                                            7,853,108
                                                             3,427,189 1903--..-----..-..------------............--------....
1892..------------.....-----..........----.....------.......-----                                                                  9,478,900
1893 ..................                  ..................  3,584,727 1904........---      ...........................           10,780,972
1894---..---...----.......--....--.........------------....  4,545,049 1905........-----..........................10,914,378
                                                             5,013,185 1906...................................
1895---------..--.--....-----------.......-.......--...--..-...                                                                   15,662,080
                                                             5,986,636 1907.................................
1896--------..-...--....--------------...-....-.....--....--...                                                                   13,643,849
1897---..-..-..--..----....--........--.--...-----------...  9,430,526 1908-----...--.--..----...----.....--....-------------
                                                             6,510,201
1898...---.---.-------------..-.....--..............-----------.....



                                                                  L 2.

     IMPROVEMENT                            OF WESTERN BRANCH                      OF ELIZABETH RIVER,
                                                    VIRGINIA.

   No operations were carried on during the fiscal year, and no expen-
ditures were incurred.
   Since the completion of the project in 1897 the dredged channel has
undergone some deterioration, both in width and depth, and some
redredging is now necessary. This will be done with the amount of
funds available, if a favorable price can be secured.
                                APPENDIX aL-REPORT OF MAJOR KUIIN.                                                                         1255

                                                              APPROPRIATIONS.

June 3, 1896-----------------------------.................................---...................---------------------. $45, 000. 00
Preservation and maintenance of river and harbor works, act of March 3,
  1909 (allotment of Apr. 9, 1909).--..................................                                                  5, 000. 00
    Total.................-------------.............................-------------------------------------........--. 50, 000. 00
Amount turned into surplus fund of the Treasury from the act of June 3,
1896..........-------........----.....-----------..........---------.....                                               328. 35
           Aggregate...................................................                                                            49, 671. 65



                                                  COMMERCIAL               STATISTICS.

  The following statistics, showing the commerce on this river during the calendar
year 1908, were compiled from statements made by shippers:

              Articles.                    Amount.            Value.                   Articles.                    Amount.              Value.


                                          Short tons.                                                 Short tons.
Coal ......................                       849           $3, 396    Sulphur ore..............          267                             $1,735
Copper ore ..............                    22, 447           246, 917    Truck packages...........          165                              6, 000
Copper cinders ............                   18, 691           56, 073    Miscellaneous.............  1,782, 963                        44, 561,575
Copper concentrates ......                     2, 240           12, 880
Limestone........ ........                     1, 741             2, 176           Total.............                1, 830, 617         44, 892, 006
Oyster shells ..............                   1, 254             1, 254


                Approximate amount offreight handled by water during various years.

                         Year.                               Quantity.                            Year.                                 Quantity.


                                                             Short tons.                                                                Short tons.
1896...............................                             211,653    1903...................................1,225,709
1897 .................................                          244, 803   1904...................................                        1,173,439
1898....---............................--                       346,835    1905......                 ....................                1,323,657
1899.....--................................                     576,898    1906........................                     .........     4,189,795
1900 .....................                  ..............       (a)       1907................. ..... ..........                         2,487,113
1901.................--           .........      .........    1,383,105    1908.........             ......................               1,830,617
1902.........-------.........................                 1,058,488

                                                                a Not compiled.


                                                                       L3.
                    IMPROVEMENT OF HAMPTON ROADS, VIRGINIA.

  Under a contract 32,208 cubic yards, scow measurement, were
excavated during the fiscal year in dredging the northerly section of
the channel across Middle Ground bar to a depth of 30 feet at mean
low water, which section had shoaled considerably since it was
dredged in 1903. The excavated material was towed to and de-
posited at the authorized dumping ground on Willoughby bank, dis-
tant about 8 miles from the site of the work.
   The rate for the dredging done was 14.3 cents per cubic yard, scow
measurement, of material dredged and deposited, and the cost, in-
cluding contingent expenses, during the fiscal year, amounted to
$6,340.11.
1256                    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                             S. ARMY.

                                                                            APPROPRIATIONS.
June 13, 1902...--------.....------------------------------------------........                                                                               $10, 000
March 3, 1903--............................--------------------------------------------------.                                                                215,000
March 2, 1907.......................................-----------------------------------------------------                                                      12, 500
             Total.----------....--------.......----.......................................------------------------------.....                                237,500



                                                               COMMERCIAL                 STATISTICS.

  The following statistics were compiled from statements of shippers at Newport
News, which shows the traffic during the calendar year 1908 by way of Hampton
Roads to and from Newport News:

                                                                      Articles.                                                                Quantity.      Value.

                                                                          Short  tons. 10n97,6
                                                                            3,6248o
Coal ------------------------------------------------------------
Coal..  . .........................                                        3,662,489 $10,987467
Flour        ------------------------------------------------------------      31,725   1,776,600
Grain...------------------------------------------------------------                                                                                57,070     2,039,314
Miscellaneous ..................................................................                                                                2, 603,490   417,668, 800
          Total...................................           --------------------------------------------------
                                                                                                      -- 6,354,774                                           432,472,181



                    Approximate amount offreight handled by water during various years.

                                Year.                                        Quantity.                                   Year.                               Quantity.

                                                                            Short tons.                                                                      Short tons.
1901............                    ..........               ......          3,736, 443   1905.........           ....          .................              4,717,858
1902...--.............................                                  -    2,663,669    1906 ...........................                                     5,544,086
1903...............................                                          2,826,558    1907....                 ........................                    6,379,617
1904.................                      .................                 4,208,781    1908        .       ...........................                      6,354,774



                                                                                    L 4.

                          IMPROVEMENT OF NANSEMOND RIVER, VIRGINIA.

      Between November 17, 1908, and January 4, 1909, 23,797 cubic
yards of material, scow measurement, were removed under a con-
tract for dredging. The contract rate for the work was 15.4 cents
per cubic yard of material, scow measurement, excavated and de-
posited on the dumping ground opposite Newport News, Va., and
the total expenditure for the work was $4,794.
   The dredging was done in the vicinity of the Western Branch dike
in maintaining channel of the project width of 80 feet and depth of
12 feet at mean low water.
                                                        Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance
  of improvement..........................                ....................                                                                                  $5, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                           APPENDIX Lr--REPORT                                OF MAJOR KUHN.                                      1257
                                                    APPROPRIATIONS.

Amount appropriated for previous projects from 1873 to 1878 (see H. Doc. No.
  421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.). ..    ...... .....          .......................                            $37, 000
August 11, 1888.......    .... ............          .......................                        ......    10, 000
September 19, 1890...............................1..........                                  .....     ...   10, 000
July 13, 1892......................          .......... ...................                    ...........    10, 000
August 15, 1894...........................................................                                    10, 000
June 3, 1896................................              ..............                    ....     .....     5, 000
March 3, 1899...........                       .........      .       .....................           ..............
                                                                                                               5, 000
March 2, 1907--.. .....---------------------------------------------------                                     5, 000
        Total .............................................................                                                       92,000



                                            COMMERCIAL                   STATISTICS.


  The following statistics relative to the commerce of the Nansemond River, Vir-
ginia, during the calendar year 1908, were compiled from statements of parties making
shipments by the river:

          Articles.                Quantity.           Value.                       Articles.                 Quantity.          Value.


                                   Short tons.                                                               Short tons.
Barrels, truck............                 375            $10, 000      Lumber, manufactured...                 70, 614           $515, 300
Brick ..................              17, 778              39, 000      Oyster shells ............                   920             1, 150
Clay ....................             25, 200              10, 080      Miscellaneous ............              10,179           3,053, 700
Coal .....................              5, 876             19,155
Ice .......................                650              1,040               Total ..............             132,292         3,651,525
Lime, agriculture........                  700              2,100



            Approximate amount of freight handled by water during various years.

                      Year.                            Quantity.                                Year.                         Quantity.


                                                  Short tons.                                                                       Short tons.
1888.--..--........ ..... ......... ........         109,900             1900..................                               .....
                                                                                                                    ...........          16,693
1890...............---...........--.......     ..   217,338              1901 ..................................                       119,892
1891.............. ..............            ...      78,572             1902.............. ...........                   ........       50,950
1892.............   ......................           133,723             1903...................................                         36,127
1893................ ..............    .....          59,473             1904................ ............ .....                         22,119
1894.......... ........ ..........          ....      53,762             1905.       ..............................                      77,204
1895........... ................... 59,701                               1906.......................                       ..............91,063
1896........   ......................... 61,405                          1907............................ ..... .                      156,200
1897....................................              43,500             1908...................................                       132,292
1898....................................              31,796



                                                                  L 5.
                      IMPROVEMENT                       OF PAGAN RIVER, VIRGINIA.

   There were no operations and no expenditures during the fiscal
year. The project for this stream is completed, but maintenance
work will probably be required from time to time, as the channel
is very narrow and liable to deterioration.
1258                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                             APPROPRIATIONS.

Amount appropriated for previous projects from 1.880 to 1881 (see H. Doc.
  421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.) ......                     .- ..... ... ............... ........... $10, 000.00
June 13,           1.902
             ........................................................                             10, 870.00
      Total..................................................----------------------------------------------------.....                          20, 870.00
Amount turned into surplus fund of the Treasury from the act of June 13,
1902......-------------..............--.........................................                                                                   198.99

              Aggregate .....              ...      .......................                      .......................                        20, 671.01



                                                   COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statistics represent the commerce of Pagan River, Virginia, during
the calendar year 1908 and were compiled from statements furnished by shippers:

                Articles.                  Quantity.            Value.                       Articles.                         Quantity.          Value.

                                           Short tons.                                                                        Short tons.
Coal ......................                          400           $1, 500      Vehicles ...........             ........                  25          $7, 500
Horses ...................                            75           20, 000      Miscellaneous...               ...........            38, 508     11, 561, 400
Oysters ...................                          100           10, 000
Peanuts...................                       45, 000       2, 500, 000               Total...............                         84, 108     14, 100, 400


  The Old Dominion Steamship Company operates two steamers on this river as far
as Smithfield, Va., each making a round trip daily, except Sundays, from Norfolk, Va.
                     Approximnate amount of freight handled by water during various years.

                               Year.                          Quantity.                                    Year.                                 Quantity.

                                                              Short tons.                                                                        Short tons.
1901..........................                   .........       108,058        1905.........                          .................
                                                                                                             ..............                           82,207
1902 ...................................                          75,614        1906.............              ........ ..............                87,505
1903................................                             120,121        1907...................................                               89,289
1904................................                              85,078        1908................................                                  84,108



                                                                              L 6.
                       IMPROVEMENT OF APPOMATTOX RIVER, VIRGINIA.

                                                 (a) GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

   Operations have been in progress during the greater part of the
fiscal year under a contract with the Atlantic Dredging Company
for improving the existing channel from Petersburg to Point of
Rocks by dredging, and depositing the excavated material on shore,
partly in the existing levee pertaining to the diversion work, partly
in an extension of the latter, and partly in filling sloughs and low
places.
  Work on this contract was commenced September 1, 1908, having
been so timed that the diversion of the flow of the river into its new
channel should have been effected.
      Under the original and supplemental contracts for dredging the
channel the Atlantic Dredging Company removed 39,547 cubic yards,
               APPENDIX L--REPORT OF MAJOR KUHN.                     1259
place measurement, of material, rehandled same and deposited it in
levee, conforming to lines and grades, at 41 cents per cubic yard,
place measurement. Twenty-eight thousand seven hundred and fifty-
two cubic yards of material, place measurement, were removed and
deposited in levee, conforming to lines and grades, without rehandling,
at 31' cents per cubic yard, place measurement, and 12,912 cubic
yards, place measurement, were pumped ashore directly behind dikes
and sloughs at 19 cents per cubic yard, place measurement.
   At the end of August and beginning of September, a freshet of
unusual magnitude occurred, reaching such a height as to overflow
the right bank of the river immediately above the diversion dam,
resulting in the cutting of a new channel around the end of the dam,
doing considerable damage to the railroad yards and bringing a large
amount of additional deposit into the navigable channel, completely
filling the latter for some distance below the dam.
   Under a supplemental contract with the Atlantic Dredging Com-
pany, the bar below the dam, formed by the August-September, 1908,
freshet, was dredged out during September and October, 27,578 cubic
yards, place measurement, of material being pumped into the wash-
out, thus restoring original conditions. The price paid for this work
was 40 cents per cubic yard, place measurement.
    Under an allotment of $10,000 from the appropriation for "Emer-
gencies in River and Harbor Works," the break in the rear bank was
closed by the construction of pile trestle 150 lineal feet long and the
placing of 855 cubic yards of stone and 1,238 cubic yards of slag as
filling to close upstream end of break. This work cost $3,200. The
balance of the allotment was repaid to the above-mentioned appro-
priation.
    During the fiscal year the channel was excavated to 80 feet bottom
width and 12 feet depth at mean high water. Dredging operations
were carried on between the diversion dam and Rushmore dike about
41 miles below, over which reach there is now an available depth of
12 feet, save for one short bar about 1 mile below the city, which will
be removed during the ensuing fiscal year.
   A contract was entered into June 21, 1909, for further dredging on
the worst remaining shoals under the allotment of $5,000 made from
the act of March 3, 1909. With this it is proposed to remove the
short bar above referred to and open up the channel near Sunken
Island just above Point of Rocks.
    The diversion of the flow of the Appomattox River at Petersburg
has converted the former channel, which is destined to serve navi-
gation, into a dead arm, subject, however, to the ebb and flow of the
tide. This dead arm has a length of over 7 miles to Point of Rocks
and is subject to constant deterioration from deposits carried in by
small tributaries and the wash of the banks, as well as to the danger
of the diversion channel breaking through at low points.
                     Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
  provement------------.~..............----------------------.. $5, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
1260            REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS. U.                                                                  S. ARMY.

                                                     (B) AT PETERSBURG.

  This work is not directly a project for the improvement of an exist-
ing channel, but for a diversion of the course of the Appomattox
River into an ancient channel with a view to freeing the former chan-
nel, which is the channel of navigation, from the constantly recurring
deposits of sediment brought down by freshets.
   The work of diversion was let to the Atlantic Dredging Company
in 1904, and should have been completed October 3, 1906. Owing
to dilatory methods, insufficient capital and plant and to unforseen
difficulties incident to the work, the contract was not completed until
March 31, 1909.
   Under the above-mentioned and supplemental contracts, described
hereinafter, the contractor accomplished the work shown in the sub-
joined table, which also shows the cost of each class of work done
during the fiscal year.

                                                                                          Work              Quantity            Unit      Cost of
                                    Locality, etc.                                        done,             furnished.                    oricefiscal
                                                                                                                                         work,
                                                                                                                                         year 1909.


Section A:                                                                               Cu. yds.                Tons.
    Original contract....................................                                    46,042 .........                   $0. 40    $18,416.   80
    Supplemental contract ...............................                                    13,538      ....                       45      6,092.   10
    Original contract.................................                                        3,013           ....                  22        662.   86
Section B: Original contract............. ..... ..............                                  344............                  .18           61.   92
                                 ROCK FOR DAM.

Original and supplemental contracts:
    Large rock ........................          ..............                 .........            ..               1, 304     1. 70      2,216. 80
    Medium rock .........................................        .....................                                   771     1. 70      1,310. 70
    Crushed stone ...................   ........    .    ....... .........           .. ....... ....                  2,056      1. 90      3, 906. 64
      Total      ...........................                                                              ...................               32,667. 82



   The extraordinary freshet of August and September, 1908, did no
damage to the diversion works, but demonstrated that without a
more fully developed capacity the diversion channel would not be
adequate for safely carrying extreme floods. Owing to the existence
of rock in the diversion channel in the vicinity of the railroad bridge,
the removal of which was not covered by the contract for the diver-
sion work, the channel at this point is contracted and limits the
flood discharge.
   Pending the excavation of this rock, the diversion dam has been
left temporarily at a lower elevation than planned originally, to pro-
vide an additional channel for flood waters above the elevation 9.5
feet. The diversion levee as finished by the contractor has not
reached its projected height owing to settlement, shrinkage, and loss
of material in the discharge through the sluiceway. Without addi-
tional elevation, especially at the upper end, the levee will not be
safe against being overtopped in extreme flood rises.
   Under the river and harbor act approved March 3, 1909, authority
was granted for additional contracts not to exceed $60,000 for the
purpose of completing the diversion work. Surveys, plans, and
estimates for this additional work have been under way, and a con-
tract will be made during the ensuing fiscal year.
                   APPENDIX I---REPORT OF MAJOR KUHN.                                  1261
                          Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement...... ......................   $60, 000. 00
   For maintenance of improvement ........................   5, 000. 00
                                                                                  $65, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                     APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1871 ................     $50, 000. 00   March 2, 1907................. $50, 000. 00
June 10, 1872............... 40, 000. 00          "Emergencies in River and
March 3, 1873.............          30, 000. 00     Harbor Works:"
June 23, 1874 ...............       30, 000. 00       June 6, 1900 (allotment
March 3, 1875............... 30, 000. 00                of Sept. 23, 1903).......  5, 000. 00
August 14, 1876...........          30, 000. 00       April 28, 1904 (allotment
June 18, 1878..................     30, 000. 00         of Oct. 28, 1904)...... 12, 000.00
March 3, 1879.............. . 20, 000. 00             March 2, 1907 (allotment
June 14, 1880 ...............       20, 000. 00         of Sept. 1, 1908).......  10, 000.00
March 3, 1881................. 20, 000.00         "Preservation and Mainte-
August 2, 1882.............         35, 000. 00     nance of River and Harbor
July 5, 1884 ...............        25, 000. 00     Works: "
August 5, 1886............          18, 750. 00       Act of March 3, 1909 (al-
August 11, 1888...........          15, 000. 00         lotment of Apr. 10,
September 19, 1890.........         15, 000. 00         1909).................     5, 000. 00
July 13, 1892.................      15, 080. 00
August 18, 1894.......     .   ...   5,000. 00          Total...............  738, 330. 00
June 3, 1896............. ...        5, 000. 00   Repaid to appropriation for
March 3, 1899............ ....       5, 000. 00    "Emergencies in River and
June 13, 1902............... 32, 500. 00           Harbor Works"............    7, 131.70
March 3, 1903 .............        175, 000. 00
March 3, 1905.............. 10, 000. 00                  Aggregate.............   731, 198. 30



                                CONTRACTS IN FORCE.

                               (A)   GENERAL IMPROVEMENT.

  With the Atlantic Dredging Company, for dredging, dated June 8, 1908; approved
June 22, 1908; date for commencing work, August 1, 1908; date for completing work,
July 1, 1909 (time limit waived). Prices: For dredging, material rehandled and
deposited in levees conforming to lines and grades, 41 cents per cubic yard, place
measurement; material deposited in levees, conforming to lines and grades without
rehandling, 31 cents per cubic yard, place measurement; material deposited behind
dikes and in sloughs without rehandling, 192 cents per cubic yard, place measurement.
  Supplemental: With Atlantic Dredging Company, modifying provisions of above
contract as to dredging material of a different character than was to be removed under
said contract referred to above; dated September 11, 1908; approved by the Chief of
Engineers, United States Army, September 17, 1908, and by the Assistant Secretary
of War, September 18, 1908. Price: 40 cents per cubic yard, measured in place.
   Supplemental: With Atlantic Dredging Company, modifying provisions of above
contract as to elevation of levee requiring delivery of material to a greater height than
12 feet and generally to a greater distance than can be reached by a delivery pipe 1,000
feet long, as was contemplated under said contract referred to above; dated March 16,
1909; approved by the Chief of Engineers, United States Army, March 17, 1909, and
by the Assistant Secretary of War, March 18, 1909. Price: 41 cents per cubic yard,
place measurement.
   Emergency: With Atlantic Dredging Company, for dredging, dated June 21, 1909;
date for commencement, July 20, 1909; date for completion, October 20, 1909. Price:
25 cents per cubic yard, place measurement.
1262                   REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                                                       U.   S. ARMY.

                                                                     (B) AT PETERSBURG.

   With Atlantic Dredging Company, for dredging and building embankments, dam,
highway bridge, railroad bridge, piers, and flume, dated July 14, 1904; approved July
30, 1904; work commenced October 3, 1904; date for expiration, October 3, 1906 (time
limit waived). Prices: Section A, (a) 40 cents per cubic yard, measured in the cut;
(b) 22 cents per cubic yard, measured in the cut; section B, 40 cents per cubic yard,
measured in the cut; section C, (a) 50 cents per cubic yard, measured in the fill;
(b) 18 cents per cubic yard, measured in the cut; section D, 18 cents per cubic yard,
measured in the cut; rock for dam, $1.70 per gross ton for large, $1.70 per gross ton for
medium, $1.90 per gross ton for crushed stone; railroad bridge, piers, and abutments,
for concrete, $10 per cubic yard, measured in place; for coping, $20 per square yard of
horizontal area; for fill behind abutments, 40 cents per cubic yard, measured in the
fill; for highway bridge, $14,000; flume, $2,000; revetment, $1.50 per square yard.
   Supplemental: With Atlantic Dredging Company, modifying provisions of above
contract as to laying additional length of cast-iron pipe, dated March 3, 1908; approved
by the Chief of Engineers, United States Army, April 10, 1908, and by the Acting
Secretary of War, April 11, 1908. Price: $7.50 per lineal foot of pipe in place.
   Supplemental: With Atlantic Dredging Company, modifying provisions of above
contract as to supporting the pipe flume upon trestle bents, dated May 20, 1908;
approved by the Acting Chief of Engineres, United States Army, June 19, 1908, and
by the Assistant Secretary of War, June 29, 1908. Price: $150.
   Supplemental: With Atlantic Dredging Company, modifying provisions of above
contract as to furnishing and placing additional quantities of large rock, medium rock,
and crushed stone for dam, dated August 14, 1908; approved by the Chief of Engineers,
United States Army, August 20, 1908, and by the Secretary of War, August 25, 1908.
Prices: $1.70 per gross ton for large, $1.70 per gross ton for medium, and $1.90 per gross
ton for crushed.
   Supplemental: With Atlantic Dredging Company, modifying provisions of above
contract as to modification of the plans in lowering the height of the dam and for the
disposal of surplus material from section A at points more distant than originally con-
templated, dated December 12, 1908; approved by the Chief of Engineers, United
States Army, January 5, 1909, and by the Assistant Secretary of War, January 6, 1909.
Price: 45 cents per cubic yard, place measurement.



                                                           COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The statement below was furnished by Mr. William P. Atkinson, port warden,
Petersburg, Va., and represents the commerce on this stream for the calendar year
1908:

                                                              Articles.                                                                   Quantity.     Value.

                                                                                                                                      Short tons.
Bricks.....................    ......            .........        .......................................                                       525       $1,400
Coal ..........                 ..................................................                                                              600        3,600
Fertilizer....... ..............................................................                                                             10,000      150,000
Lumber..........................            ........           ........................                     ................                 15,680      184,800
Pulp and pine wood...............................................................                                                             5,025       25,400
          Total.....................                               ...................................                                       31,830      365,200



                                                                                      Vessels.


                                                            Class.                                                                  No.      Average    Average
                                                                                                                                              draft.    tonnage.

                                                                                                                                               Feet.     Tons.
Steam .....................................................................                                                           48            6         40
Sail.........................................................................                                                         13            7        110
Barges and lighters .....................................................                                                             67          5-7        440
                                APPENDIX Ir--REPORT OF MAJOR KUHN.                                                                                 1263
               Approximate amount offreight handled by water during previous years.

                         Year.                                Quantity.                                   Year.                               Quantity.


                                                             Short tons.                                                                     Short tons.
1888.................                       ...............               30,626  1900...............                     ...      .... .........         155,745
1889------------------..--.........-----..............-------..........   26,121  1901...................................                                 145,509
1890-------...----...----..-------.....................-----...           21,693  1902..................................                                  100,648
1891....--------.....---....-------...--..................
                                                 -------------            26,275  1903----................------------------.....----------............   103,628
1892---------------....------...........-----...................          25,218 1904...................................                                   42,337
1896................---------------------------------.................... 81,318  1905---------...............------------------------..................   53,282
1897....---------------...------..........-----------...........          84,031  1906-..................................                                  30,438
1898-------......------------..----...........------------....            95, 941 1907. .................................                                (a)
1899..............---------------..................--------------------   (a)     1908-.................................                                   31,830

                                                                   a Not obtained.

                                                                          L 7.

     IMPROVEMENT OF HARBOR AT CAPE CHARLES CITY, VIRGINIA.

   The dredging in progress at the close of the last fiscal year was
continued until January 26, 1909, when the contract was completed.
Dredging was carried on at three localities, 3,964 cubic yards of mud,
sand, and shells, scow measurement, being removed from the inner
harbor, 17,965 cubic yards of clay and sand from the point at the
turn into the channel of Cherrystone Inlet, and 53,487 cubic yards of
fine and coarse sand, scow measurement, from the channel of Cher-
rystone Inlet. The dredging done at the two first-mentioned local-
ities was for improvement under the adopted project. The work
last mentioned was to maintain channel previously dredged to
adopted project dimensions.
   The contract price for all the work was 212 cents per cubic yard
of material, scow measurement, removed and deposited, and its total
cost was $20,150.13.
                                            Estimate of additionalfunds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909:
   For works of improvement...........................$17, 340. 00
   For maintenance of improvement .....................      7, 660. 00
                                                                                                                                          $25, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                                            APPROPRIATIONS.

September 19, 1890............. $25, 000                                         March 3, 1905....................... $25, 000
July 13, 1892 ....... ............ 10, 000                                       March 2, 1907................... 25, 000
March 3, 1899................... 20, 000
June 13, 1902................. 20, 000                                                       Total..................                             125, 000



                                                       CONTRACT IN                     FORCE.

   With L. M. Lewis, for dredging, dated February 17, 1908; approved March 7, 1908;
date for commencing work, May 11, 1908; date for completing work, January 11, 1909
(time limit waived). Price: 21l cents per cubic yard, scow measurement,
1264                    REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U.                                                                       S. ARMY.

                                                               COMMERCIAL                STATISTICS.

The following statement represents the commerce of the harbor at Cape Charles
City, Va., during the calendar year 1908, and was prepared from statements supplied
by lines and individuals handling the freight:

                                                                  Articles.                                                         Quantity.      Value.

                                                                                                                                    Short tons.
Merchandise and products                                ...............            ..                              ............      1,811,731    $45,293,275


                 Approximate amount of freight handled by water during the various years.

                               Year.                                      Quantity.                                        Year.                  Quantity.

                                                                          Short tons.                                                             Short tons.
1890..................................                                        390,207   1900....................................                  (a)
1891...........         . ....         .....         ....      ........       319,164   1901...................................                    940,646
1892 .............................                                            341,269   1902--------------.........--.....................
                                                                                                                            ------------------  1,031,598
1893.... ..........................                                           393,352   1903...................................                 1,155,952
1894..........                 ...........................                    427,723   1904...................................                 1,404,146
1895................................                             ---          455,269   1905..................................                  1,512,798
1896........... . ........................                                    487,004   1.906................................                   1,723,635
1898.........................                      ..............             569,894   1907...............................                     2,121,301
1899.........                .......... ................                      591,298   1908...........--           .......        ............ 1,811,731

                                                                              a No statement.

                                                                                   L 8.

IMPROVEMENT OF WATERWAY FROM NORFOLK, VIRGINIA, TO THE
               SOUNDS OF NORTH CAROLINA.

   The work on this improvement during the fiscal year consisted in
dredging and the removal of sunken obstructions.
   Under a contract 15,816 cubic yards of mud, clay, and sand were
removed from the Deep Creek section, in maintaining the adopted
project width and depth of channel from a point 500 feet below the
Deep Creek locks to a point 2,400 feet below them. The work was
done by an hydraulic dredge, the material being pumped ashore.
The work was still in progress at the end of the fiscal year. The
price paid for the work was 17 cents per cubic yard, place measure-
ment, of material removed and pumped ashore, and the total cost of
the work was $3,388.04.
   Between April 10 and 20, 1909, the snag boat Roanoke sounded
and worked over the reach of the Pasquotank River from Elizabeth
City to the mouth of Turners Cut, North Carolina. The obstruc-
tions located and removed consisted of 20 logs, 12 stumps, 2 piles,
and 30 snags, which were deposited at convenient places on the bank
of the river. The cost of that work was $304.80.
                                                      Estimate of additional funds required.

Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for mainte-
  nance of improvement.......................       ...................... $5, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4,
  1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.
                                       APPENDIX L-REPORT OF MAJOR KUHN.                                                                                  1265
                                                                   APPROPRIATIONS.
March 3, 1.899------...............................----------------------------------------------..        $25, 000
June 6, 1900......................----------------------------------------------------- 200, 000
March 3, 1901--................................--------------------------------------------------- . 29, 870
March 3, 1905...........................................................                                     3, 000
March 2, 1907--.......................................----------------------------------------------------   5, 000
             Total----.....------..........................-----------------------------------------....--.......                                       262, 870



                                                              CONTRACT IN FORCE.

  With Atlantic Dredging Company, for dredging, dated February 5, 1909; date for
commencing work, February 15, 1.909; date for completing work, May 15, 1909 (time
limit waived). ,Price: 17 cents per cubic yard, place measurement.



                                                          COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statistics were compiled from a statement furnished by the Lake
Drummond Canal and Water Company, and indicate the traffic through the Dismal
Swamp Canal, Virginia and North Carolina, during the calendar year 1908:

                                                             Articles.                                                                  Quantity.       Value.

                                                                                                                                      Short tons.
Forest products............2                                   ......................................                                   200,515         $1,510,40
Miscellaneous .................................--......--                                    .........................                    119,058       4,103,060

          Total..-----------------........--..       ...-----------------------------------                                               319,573       5,613,700



                                                                                  Vessels.


                                                           Class.                                                                 No.      Average      Average
                                                                                                                                            draft.      tonnage.

                                                                                                                                             Feet.        Tons.
Steamers ...............................................................                                                          2,082            7           67
Sail...........           ......................                         .............................                              692            7           40
Barges and lighters.............................................. ..............                                                  1,093            82         221
Launches... .... ..........                   .........-------.....................                    ......... .........    .     225 .........               8
Torpedo boats....................................................                                                                     6 ..........            119
Rafts..................................                   ........................................                                   98....................
Miscellaneous..............                        ....        ..... ......................                   ............... .      11 ..........                91



   Approximate amount of freight shipped and received by water during various years.

                                                                          Year.                                                                      Quantity.

                                                                                                                                                     Short tons.
1907 ................................................................                                                                                    366,339
1908............ ..........................................................................                                                              319,573


   Until the calendar year 1907 it was not practicable to compile the commerce in tons.
             9001-ENG 1.909-                          80
1266          REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS,                                     U. S. ARMY.

                                                        L 9.

IMPROVEMENT OF INLAND ROUTE FROM NORFOLK HARBOR, VIR-
  GINIA, TO ALBEMARLE SOUND, NORTH CAROLINA, THROUGH CUR-
  RITUCK SOUND.

   The U. S. snag boat Roanolce was employed at various times dur-
ing the fiscal year on different portions of this route, removing ob-
structions impeding and endangering navigation.       The total num-
ber of obstructions removed were 286 logs, 7 snags, and 7 piles.
The total cost of the removal of the obstructions was $1,478.10.
   The dredged channel through Currituck Sound is showing signs of
deterioration between light beacons 6 and 8, due to barges and tugs
getting out of the channel and pulling material into the dredged
cut. Dredging will be necessary to restore the channel at a number
of places, and the estimate for maintenance will mainly be used to
restore the channel at the locality mentioned to the dimensions
required by the adopted project.
                                  Estimate of additionalfunds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30,
  1911, exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for mainte-
nance of improvement.............................. ................... $10, 000. 00
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June
4, 1897, and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899.



                                             APPROPRIATIONS.

For Southern Branch Elizabeth River, Virginia: Appropriated from 1873
  to 1878 (see H. Doc. No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.).................... $40, 000. 00
For North Landing River, Virginia and North Carolina: Appropriated
  from 1879 to 1882 (see H. Doc. No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.)-...........                                  55, 500. 00
For Currituck Sound, Coinjock Bay, and North River bar, North Carolina:
  Appropriated from 1878 to 1888 (see H. Doc. No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d
  sess.)...............                .......................................                              142, 500. 00
For inland water route, etc.:
     September 19, 1890 ...............                            .....................$10, 000. 00
    July 13, 1892..........................                                    ............ 9, 000. 00
     August 18, 1894.........           .. ................                      .........    . 10, 000. 00
    June 3, 1896...-------....-----------...........--....---------.................----------- 10, 000. 00
     March 3, 1899........-----------------..---........-------..................----------..    8, 000. 00
     June 13, 1902--------.........--......--------....----.....---------..........------....   23, 400. 00
     March 3, 1905..........................................                                    22, 000. 00
     March 2, 1907.--...--.......           ...........................                          3, 000. 00
                                                                                                             95, 400. 00
"Preservation and Maintenance of River and Harbor Works:"
     Act of March 3, 1909, allotment of April 10, 1909 ...................                                    1, 500. 00

    Total....................................................................                            334, 900. 00
Amount received from sale of property ..............................                                       2, 340. 69

        Aggregate........................... ...........................                                 337, 240. 69
                                     APPENDIX L--REPORT OF MAJOR KUHN.                                                                     1267
                                                 COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statistics relative to the commerce of the inland water route from
Norfolk Harbor, Virginia, to Albemarle Sound, North Carolina, during the calendar
year 1908, were compiled from statements furnished by the Albemarle and Chesapeake
Canal Company:




                                                                      Vessels.


                                                  Class.                                                          No.      Average Average
                                                                                                                            draft. tonnage.

                                                                                                                               Feet.        Tons.
Steam....       .... ................                  ...........................                               1,957            1-9             65
Sail.......................... .............................................                                       399            1-9             53
Barges and lighters ..................................        .....................                                424     ..........            161
Rafts.........................                                   ..     ...................                        220



       Approximate amount of freight shipped and received by water during various years.
                                                          ,                  .

                                 Year.                        Quantity.                                Year.                            Quantity.
                                                          SII                                                                           ___________________________

                                                              Short tons.                                                                 Short tons.
1900..................................                           195, 958        1905................................. 88,580
1901......                 ...------.--...........--             210, 264        1906.....                .....................               100, 000
1902.........................                                    199, 062        1907... ...........                            .........     188,543
1903........--................                                   203,812         1908............................                             133, 081
1904........--...........--.--.                      ..          144,041



                                                                       L Io.

            IMPROVEMENT OF PERQUIMANS RIVER, NORTH CAROLINA.

  No operations were carried on during the fiscal year, and no
expenditures were incurred.
  The project is considered as having been completed, but work of'
maintenance will be required from time to time to keep the improve-
ment available.

                                                          APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriated in 1876 (see H. Doc. No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.)............. $2, 500
March 3, 1905.........   ............................................     . .. 11, 250

             Total...................--..................................---                                                               13, 750
1268             REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                              COMMERCIAL                                STATISTICS.

   The following statistics relative to the commerce of Perquimans River, North Caro-
lina, during the calendar year 1908, were compiled from statements furnished by the
shippers making shipments over this stream:

            Articles.                    Quantity.              Value.                                 Articles.                        Quantity.              Value.

                                         Short tons.                                                                                   Short tons.
Cotton. ..............              ..        1,000              $200, 000              Peanuts .................                              900               $80,000
Cotton seed................                   1, 500                 30,000             Truck....................                                2,500           190,000
Fertilizer ...........      ....              3,000                  60, 000            Miscellaneous..........   ....                             500            25, 000
Fish ......................                      200                 40,000
Lumber...            ............                 500                35,000                          Total...............                      13,100            660, 000


                Approximate amount offreight handled by water during various years.

                         Year.                                Quantity.                                            Year.                                     Quantity.
                                                                                  -ii                                                                    i
                                                          i



                                                              Short tons.                                                                                    Short tons.
1904....................................                            38,300              1907...............................                                       69,600
1905..................                   .............              50,375              1908....... ..................                    ..........              13,100
1906..................................                             108,570



                                                                            L II.

                 IMPROVEMENT OF BLACKWATER RIVER, VIRGINIA.

   The U. S. snag boat Roanoke was employed on this improvement
from March 8, to April 3, 1909. During this period the snag boat re-
moved 272 logs, 3 trees, 2 snags, 2 stumps, and 7 pieces of an old
wreck from the channel.
   The entire distance of the river covered by the project has been
cleared of obstructions, but it will be necessary from time to time to
remove logs which become detached from rafts and sink in the chan-
nel, and the available balance should be retained for that purpose.
   The cost of the work done during the fiscal year was $1,011.66.
                                                              APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriated from 1878 to 1882 (see H. Doc., No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.).. $14, 000
March 2, 1907.............................................................             8, 000
Received from sales----....................---------................................ -     15

           Total...............................                                                                   .................................             22, 015



                                              COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statistics relative to the commerce of Blackwater River, Virginia,
during the calendar year 1908, were compiled from statements furnished by the ship-
pers making shipments over this stream:

                                                  Articles.                                                                             Quantity.              Value.

                                                                                                                                        Short tons.
Miscellaneous ...............                           .... .....................................       ............             ..             5,390          $862,400
                                          APPENDIX L--REPORT OF MAJOR KUHN.                                                                   1269
             Approximate amount of freight handled by water during the various years.

                              Year.                                          Quantity.                           Year.                     Quantity.

                                                                             Short tons.                                                   Short tons.
1906...................................                                           5,200           1908........................    .... .          5,390
1907 ...............................                                              5,300



                                                                                            L     12.

                IMPROVEMENT OF MEHERRIN RIVER, NORTH CAROLINA.

   The U. S. snag boat Roanoke was employed on this improvement
from January 21 to February 3, February 11 to March 3, and April 21
to 30, 1909. During these periods the snag boat removed 225 logs
and 1 tree, and the crew took soundings over a distance of 3,000 feet
in the portion of the river known as "Darden reach." The work
done cost $1,412.42.
   The entire distance of the river covered by the project has been
cleared of obstructions, but it will be necessary from time to time to
remove logs which become detached from rafts and sink in the chan-
nel, and the available balance should be retained for that purpose.


                                                                           APPROPRIATIONS.

Appropriated in 1882 (see H. Doc. No. 421, 57th Cong., 2d sess.)............a $5, 000
March 2,1907.......................................... .............. ...... 6, 000
Received from sales .........................................................      10
              Total........                      ....................................................                                         11,010



                                                               COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

  The following statistics relative to the commerce of Meherrin River, North Carolina,
during the calendar year 1908, were compiled from statements furnished by the
shippers making shipments over this stream:

                                                                   Articles.                                                 Quantity.       Value.

                                                                                                                             Short tons.
Lumber..........................................                                ... .... .........                                   150        $1,000
Logs....................................... ...................................                                                      200         1,500
Miscellaneous........                                ..........................................                                   8,340      1,084,200
          Total ....................................................................                                              8, 690     1, 086, 700


                Approximate amount of freight handled by water during the various years.

                              Year.                                          Quantity.                            Year.                    Quantity.

                                                                             Short tons.                                                   Short tons.
1906.........                    .....................                                 8,900 1908.................................               8,690
1907-.......-.......................                                                   9,321

                              a Of this amount $415.47 was carried to the surplus fund.
1270                REPORT OF THE CHIEF OF ENGINEERS, U. S. ARMY.

                                                            L 13.

              IMPROVEMENT OF ROANOKE RIVER, NORTH CAROLINA.

   The U. S. snag boat Roanolce was employed on the improvement
from December 1, 1908, to January 15, 1909, and removed 19 trees,
2 logs, and 1 snag from the channel, and 13 trees overhanging the
stream were cut up in pieces and the latter placed on the bank. The
d6bris from caving banks where the overhanging trees were found
was also removed.
   From May 12 to 25, 1909, the snag boat was under repair at Norfolk,
Va., and on the date last named was ordered to this improvement
to remove 3 trees which had been blown into the river during a
storm. The obstructions mentioned were located about 12 miles
above Williamston, N. C., and removed on June 3 and 4, 1909. The
snag boat was delayed in arriving at the locality due to unfavorable
weather for navigation in Albemarle Sound and a freshet in the river.
After the work had been completed the snag boat returned to Great
Bridge, Va., arriving there June 6, 1909.
   The cost of the work done, including a portion of the repairs made
to the snag boat was $1,616.15.
                                   Estimate of additional funds required.
Amount that can be profitably expended in fiscal year ending June 30, 1911,
  exclusive of the balance unexpended July 1, 1909, for maintenance of im-
  provement------
               ................----------------------------------------------- $5, 000
Submitted in compliance with requirements of sundry civil act of June 4, 1897,
  and of section 7 of the river and harbor act of 1899



                                                APPROPRIATIONS.

March 3, 1871 ..-.........-..                  $20, 000. 00    August 18, 1894-............. $30, 000. 00
June 10, 1872...----..-------........           10, 000. 00    June 3, 1896................    10, 000. 00
March 3, 1873 ..............                    10, 000. 00    March 3, 1905 ..............    10, 000. 00
June 23, 1874.-------............----.           5,000.00      March 2, 1907 ........----.....  3,000.00
August 2, 1882--...............                  5, 000. 00
July 5, 1884--....---....----...-------.....     3, 000. 00         Total................. 241, 000. 00
August 5, 1886-----............                 20, 000.00     Amount received from sales
August 11, 1888..-.....-......                  40, 000. 00     of property-................ 1, 355. 00
September 19, 1890- ........                    25, 000. 00
July 13, 1892................                   50, 000. 00            Aggregate............. 242, 355. 00



                                        COMMERCIAL STATISTICS.

   The following statistics show the commerce of Roanoke River,
North Carolina, during the calendar year 1908, and were compiled
from statements obtained from the shippers:

              Articles.          Quantity.         Value.              Articles.            Quantity.     Value.

                                 Short tons.                                                Short tons.
Cotton ....................           1,250        $250, 000   Shingles..................        1,250     $50,000
Fertilizer .................           3, 000        60, 000   Miscellaneous............        13,425     523, 580
Logs....................- .            4, 800        24,000
Lumber ..................             51,450        314,500          Total...............       78,775    1,402,080
Peanuts..................              3,600        180,000
                                     APPENDIX L--REPORT OF MAJOR KUHN.                                                                         1271
               Approximate amount of freight handled by water during the various years.

                             Year.                                        Quantity.                         Year.                          Quantity.

                                                                          Short tons.                                                           Short tons.
1870.....................                           .............            150,000    1903......................................                  115,875
1890..................................                                       182,000    1904................ ............                            32,790
1891....................................                                    376,181     1905...................................                    (a)
1900...----------.......              .................           ..          27,432    1906.................                   ........... ...      88,508
1901.................................                              ....     226,736     1907...............................                          61,108
1902............                 ...................                         163,564    1908.....................................                    78,775

                                                                             a Not complete.

                                                                                 L I4.

REMOVING SUNKEN VESSELS OR CRAFT OBSTRUCTING OR ENDAN-
                GERING NAVIGATION.

    Wreck of sloop Haze.-This sloop sank in James River, Virginia,
near Nansemond River light. Its removal was authorized July 14,
1908, at a cost not to exceed $300.
   Proposals were invited for destroying the wreck, but prior to the
date of opening the wreck was removed by private parties.
   Logs, Mackey Creek, North Carolina.--These logs sank in the cut
approaching Mackey Creek, North Carolina, having been dropped
from time to time from rafts being towed to sawmills located on the
creek. Their removal was authorized January 27, 1909, at a cost
not to exceed $300.
   The U. S. snag boat Roanoke removed 47 logs and 1 stump from
the navigable channel during the month of February, 1909. The
total cost of the work was $252.62.
    Wreck of schooner Bismarck.-The schooner sank in Hampton
Roads, Virginia, about 1 mile from Pig Point light-house. Its
removal was authorized April 15, 1909, at a cost not to exceed $400.
   Proposals were invited for destroying the wreck and the work was
awarded to the Coastwise Dredging Company, the lowest bidder.
   The wreck was destroyed by the use of explosives in April, 1909.
The total cost of the work was $250.
                                                        INDEX.

                 [The references in roman are to part (or volume) and those in arabic to page.]

                                                                   A.
                                                                                                                                  Page.
Aberdeen, Wash. See Chehalis River and Grays Harbor.
Absecon Inlet, N. J.:
    Harbor lines established in .............................................                                                        I, 910
    Wreck in....          ....................................................                                                I, 224, 1184
Academy Creek, Ga. See Brunswick Harbor.
Acts of 60th Congress, 2d session, and 61st Congress, 1st session, affecting Corps
  of Engineers..........................................................                                                     --     , 2527
Acushnet River, Mass. See New Bedford Harbor.
Adams Creek, N. C., waterway via. See Beaufort Inlet.
Agate Bay Harbor, Minn., improvement of . .......                                              ............              I, 660; II, 1901
Ahnapee (Algoma) Harbor, Wis. See Algoma Harbor.
Alabama River, Ala.:
    Examination and survey from Montgomery to Coosa River ...............                                                            I, 409
    Improvement of....................                        .....           ......................                     I, 404; Ii, 1401
Alameda, Cal. See Oakland Harbor.
Alaska, improvement of St. Michael Canal ................                                                     . .. I, 891; III, 2264
Albemarle and Chesapeake Canal, N. C. See Albemarle Sound-Norfolk water-
  way.
Albemarle Sound, N. C.:
    Improvement of waterway to Norfolk, Va., via Currituck Sound.... I, 284, 1266
    Improvement of waterway to Norfolk, Va., via Pasquotank River... I, 282, 1264
Alethea (schooner), wreck of. ..................                                     .............             ...........           I, 247
Alexandria, Va.:
    Harbor lines in Potomac River at........................ .............                                                           I, 910
    Wreck in Potomac River at ......................................                                                          I, 272, 1249
Algoma Harbor, Wis., improvement of ..........................                                                           I, 690; II, 1958
Allegheny River, Pa.:
    Construction of locks and dams.................................                                                      I, 618; Ii, 1770
    Harbor lines from Lock No. 2 to upper end of Brilliant pumping station.. I, 911
    Improvement by open-channel work .......................                                                             I, 617; Ii, 1768
    Improvement of Pittsburg Harbor. ...............                                                .........            I, 625; II, 1785
    Operating and care of locks and dams.........                                          .................. I, 620; II, 1772
Allouez Bay, Wis. See Duluth Harbor.
Alloway Creek, N. J., improvement of .................................                                                        I, 205, 1163
Alpena Harbor, Mich.:
    Improvement of ...........                          ...............................                                  I, 763; It, 2097
    Wreck in..................................................                                                           I, 780; iI, 2119
Altamaha River, Ga., improvement of...........                                           .............                   I, 343; Ii, 1338
Ambrose channel, New York Harbor, N. Y., improvement of, including dredge
  construction.................................................. I, 159, 1092, 1154
Amelia River, Fla. See Fernandina.
Amite River, La., improvement of ..............................                                                  I, 454, 458; II, 1475
Anacostia River, D. C.:
    Improvement of ...                      .......................................                                           I, 252, 1217
    Wrecks near James Creek Canal ...............................                                                             I, 272, 1249
Anahuac channel, Tex., improvement of.................                                              ........     I, 478, 480; II, 1502
Anclote River, Fla.:
    Improvement of .............................................                                                         I, 379; II, 1380
    Wreck in anchorage. ........                         .......        .........................                                 . I, 384
           9001-ENG 1909-1
II                                                        INDEX.

                                                                                                                Page.
Anita rock, San Francisco Harbor, Cal., examination and survey................ , 834
Ann, Cape, Mass., harbor of refuge. See Sandy Bay.
Apalachicola Bay, Harbor, and River, Fla.:
    Improvement of harbor in bay. ...................                       ...........         . i, 388; ii, 1387
    Improvement of river, including the Cut-off ................. I, 390; ii, 1388, 1389
    Regulations governing navigation of inner channel .. .....................                                  I, 911
Appomattox River, Va.:
    Improvement of (general) ................................                                 ....... I, 279, 1258
    Improvement of, at Petersburg, Va ............                           .........                  I, 280, 1260
                                                                                                        I..
Appoquinimink River, Del., improvement of. ....................                                ........ I, 214, 1172
Appropriations:
    Fortifications................................... .....................                                  I, 11, 19
    Rivers and harbors...............................................                                       I, 28, 904
Aqueduct Bridge, Washington, D. C., repair of. .......                             ....... ... , 921; ur, 2301
Aqueduct, Washington, D. C. See Washington.
Aransas Bay and Pass, Tex.:
    Improvement of channel to Pass Cavallo, to Victoria (on Guadalupe River),
       and to Corpus Christi (via Turtle Cove)......................                                I, 488; II, 1508
    Improvement of pass..........................................
Arcadia Harbor, Mich., improvement of ............................
                                                                                                    I, 493;       1512
                                                                                                    I, 748; Ii, 2050
                                                                                                                      11,
Arcata, Cal. See Humboldt Harbor.
Arkansas River:
    Examination and improvement at Pine Bluff, Ark.. I, 538, 539, 548; in, 1581, 1583
    Examination at Douglas, Ark.........................................                                        I, 548
    Examination to Muskogee, Okla.........................._                                .............       I, 548
    Improvement of .........................................                                        I, 532; ii, 1573
Armament. See Fortifications.
Army War College, Washington, D. C., erection of buildings for.................. I, 946
Arroyo Colorado, Tex., examination and survey from Harlingen to Point Isabel,
  on Laguna Madre.........................................................                                      I, 497
Arthur Kill, N. Y. and N. J.:
    Harbor lines around Buckwheat Island and Morse Creek, N. J............ I, 910
    Improvement of ................................................                                     I, 168, 1108
Arthur Lake, Mermentau River, La. See Mermentau River.
Ashland Harbor, Wis., improvement of.............................              ...........          I, 669; i, 1917
Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio, improvement of ............................                                 I, 794; nI, 2138
Assistants:
    Civilian, to engineer officers..............................................                                  I, 27
    On duty in office of the Chief of Engineers.........................                                         , 952
Atchafalaya River, La., rectification of mouth by Mississippi River Commis-
  sion...    .................................................                                     I, 909; III, 2641
Atlantic City, Absecon Inlet, N. J., harbor lines at ..........................                                 I, 910
Atlantic Ocean, wreck at entrance to Hereford Inlet, N. J ................ I, 224, 1183
Augusta, Ga. See Savannah River.
Augusta Narrows, White River, Ark., examination and improvement
  at......           ..           .......................................                           I, 548; i, 1583
Aux Bees Scies Lake, Mich. See Frankfort Harbor.

                                                                 B.
Back Bay of Biloxi, Miss.:
    See also Biloxi Harbor.
    Examinations and survey ...........................................                                                    I, 439
Back Cove, Portland Harbor, Me. See Portland Harbor.
Back (Weymouth) River, Mass. See Weymouth River.
Bagaduce River, Me., improvement of.........                                          ...................              I, 34, 969
Ballard, Wash. See Puget Sound-Lake Washington waterway.
Baltimore Harbor, Md.:
     Defenses of .....................................................                                                       I, 10
    Harbor lines in Curtis Bay.................................................. . , 910
     Improvement at Spring Garden..................................                                                 I, 228, 1189
     Improvement of channel to. ...                                            .......................
                                                                      .....................                         I, 224,1185
     Improvement of channel to Curtis Bay ..............................                                            I, 227, 1188
Bangor Harbor, Me. See Penobscot River.
Bar Harbor, Me., construction of breakwater ..................                                            .........    I, 31, 966
Bar Lake, Mich. See Arcadia Harbor.
Barracks, Washington, D. C. See Washington Barracks.
                                                               INDEX.                                                                   III

                                                                                                                                     Page.
Barren River, Ky., operating and care of lock and dam............                                                    I, 656; II, 1884
Bartholomew Bayou, La. and Ark., improvement of ...............                                                       , 519; In, 1560
Bastrop Bayou, Tex., improvement of ............                                      .........              I, 478, 484; Ii, 1505
Battalions of Engineers, equipment of ...                         ................................                                       , 25
Batteries, gun and mortar. See Fortifications.
Battery, the, New York Harbor, N. Y. See New York Harbor.
Battles:
     Of Kings Mountain. See Kings Mountain.
    Of New Orleans. See New Orleans.
     Of Point Pleasant, W. Va. See Point Pleasant.
Bay Ridge channel, New York Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ........                                                         I, 162, 1095
Bayside channel, New York Harbor, N. Y. See New York Harbor.
Beaufort Harbor, N. C.:
     Examination and survey of channel across the bar. . ...................                                                          I, 315
     Improvement of ..........................................                                                         , 300; in, 1285
     Improvement of waterway to Newbern ..............                                                   .....       I, 299; in, 1284
     Improvement of waterway to New River ...........                                   ......               I, 303, 304; ii, 1289
Beaufort Harbor, S. C. See Beaufort River and Harbor.
Beaufort Inlet, N. C.:
     Improvement of .....................................                                                     .      I, 302; i, 1286
     Improvement of waterway to Pamlico Sound.................. I, 298; I, 1281
Beaufort River and Harbor, S. C.:
     Waterway to Savannah (see Savannah Harbor)................ , 333; ir, 1319
    Wreck in..............          ...                                               . .........                    I,  332; i, 1316
                                                                                                                     I...............
Bee Tree Shoals Canal, Tennessee River, Ala. See Tennessee River.
Bellingham Bay and Harbor, Wash.:
     Examination and survey of harbor .........                                       .......          ..... ......               .. I, 893
     Improvement of Whatcom Creek waterway (New Whatcom Harbor). 1,887; InI,2260
Bennie (barge) wreck of .........                        ..........................                                        I, 224, 1183
Benton Harbor Canal, Mich. See St. Joseph Harbor.
Bessie (barge) wreck of .................................................                                                  I, 157, 1090
Beverly Harbor, Mass., improvement of .............                                       ................                     I, 55, 986
Big Barren River, Ky. See Barren River.
Big Kanawha River, W. Va. See Kanawha River.
Big Sandy River, W. Va. and Ky.:
     Improvement of, incluing Tug and Levisa forks ..............                                                    I, 638; n, 1825
     Operating and care of locks and dams........                              ...............                       I, 640; ii, 1829
Big Sarasota Bay, Fla. See Sarasota Bay.
Big Sioux River, S. Dak., ice harbor at Sioux City, Iowa. See Missouri River
  improvement.
Big Stone Lake, Minn.:
    See Ottertail Lake and River, Minn ...............                                       ..........            . I, 573; ii, 1652
     Survey of (hydrological observations) ....................                                                 .. I, 573; in, 1652
Big Sunflower River, Miss.:
     Examination and survey from near Baird to mouth of Hushpucena River.... I, 532
     Improvement of ...........................................                                              I, 526, 529; II, 1567
Biloxi Harbor, Miss.:
     Examination and survey, including Back Bay.........................                                                              I, 439
     Improvement of........................................                                                       . I, 431; I, 1431
Birmingham, City of (steamer), wreck of ...........................                                                          I, 77, 1002
Biscayne Bay, Fla., improvement of...........................                                                        I, 368; i, 1364
Bismarck (schooner) wreck of.................                               ........................                       I, 288, 1271
Bismarck Harbor, N. Dak. See Missouri River improvement.
Bissell, Harvey, wreck of.....             ...............                     ....             .......               , 780; in, 2119
Blackfish Bayou, Ark., examination and survey from mouth to Fifteen Mile
  Bayou.....................                       .....................................                                             I, 548
Black Lake, Mich. See Holland Harbor.
Black Mingo Creek, S. C. See Mingo Creek.
Black River, Ark. and Mo., improvement of ........................                                                   I, 542; ii, 1588
Black River, La., improvement of.................................... I, 515; in, 1554
Black River, Mich.:
     Improvement at mouth........................................                                                     , 769; i, 2104
     Improvement at Port Huron..................................                                                     I, 774; I, 2108
Black River, N. C., improvement of .........................                                                 I, 307, 308; i, 1291
Black River, Lorain, Ohio. See Lorain Harbor.
Black Rock Harbor, Conn. See Bridgeport Harbor.
IV                                                         INDEX.

Black Rock Harbor, N. Y.:                                                                                               Page.
     Improvement of, including lock construction ...................                                        I, 804; 11, 2155
     Improvement of Buffalo entrance...............                                   .............         I, 803; II, 2154
     Improvement of Lake Erie entrance............................. I, 802; ii, 2153
Black Warrior River, Ala.:
     Improvement above Tuscaloosa ..............................                                            I, 414; 11, 1412
     Improvement below Tuscaloosa.......................... I, 414, 415; ii, 1414
     Operating and care of locks and dams........................                                           I, 423; 11, 1421
Blackwater Creek, or River, Va., improvement of......................                                            I, 286, 1268
Blackwater River, Fla., improvement of ........................................                             I, 399; II, 1397
Block Island, R. I.:
     Construction of harbor of refuge..................................... I, 97, 1022
     Improvement of Great Salt Pond.............                            .........................              , 98, 1023
Blood River, La. See Tickfaw River.
Boards (see also Commissions):
     National Coast Defense Board...........................................                                               , 10
     Of Engineers for Rivers and Harbors. ..........................                                       I, 898; ni, 2277
     On Fortifications or other Defenses (Endicott Board)......................                                          I, 10
     The Board of Engineers............................................. I, 10, 955
Boats. See Dredge boats and Wrecks.
Boca Ceiga Bay, Fla., examination and survey from Clearwater Harbor to
  Tampa Bay, including ...................................................                                              I, 385
Boeuf River, La., improvement of .............................                                        I, 519, 520; Is, 1560
Bogue Chitto, La., improvement of...............................                                            I, 454; 11, 1470
Bogue Falia, La., improvement of .............................                                         , 454, 455; 11, 1471
Bogue Sound, N. C., improvement of waterways via. See Beaufort Harbor-
  New River waterway.
Bonita channel, San Francisco Harbor, Cal., examination and survey of rocks
  near.....................................................................                                             I, 834
Booms, building of.............................................................. I, 920
Bordentown bar, Delaware River, improvement of ....................                                              I, 194, 1148
Boston Harbor, Mass. (see also Dorchester Bay and Malden, Mystic, and Neponset
  rivers):
     Defenses of.................................................................... I, 10
     Improvement of....................................................                                             I, 60, 990
      Wreck near Castle Island..........................................                                            I, 77, 1002
Brandywine Creek, or River, Del. See also Wilmington Harbor.
Branford Harbor, Conn., improvement of............................                                                     I, 107, 1035
Brazos River, Tex.:
    Examination and survey of mouth................... .....                                                ............     I, 497
    Improvement between Old Washington and Waco............... I, 503; 11, 1533
    Improvement between Velasco and Old Washington. ............                                               I, 505; 11, 1534
    Improvement of mouth...................................                                                    I, 492; 11, 1511
    Improvement of West Galveston Bay and Brazos River Canal...........                                                      , 478,
                                                                                                           486, 487; 11, 1507
    Operating and care of Galveston and Brazos Canal. ............... I, 491; 11, 1511
Brazos Santiago Harbor, Tex., improvement of .......................                                           I, 495; 11, 1514
Breton Bay, Md., improvement of.........................                                             ....       . I, 254, 1221
Bridge Creek Landing, Va., wharf and monument. See Wakefield.
Bridgeport Harbor, Conn.:
    Improvement of.................................................                                                   I, 114, 1043
    Wreck in............            ..........................................                                        I, 124, 1054
Bridges:
    Alteration of, obstructing navigation ....................................                                                , 919
    Acqueduct Bridge, Washington, D. C ........................                                               I, 921; III, 2301
    Construction of, across navigable waters ...                            .........................                        I, 912
    Highway bridge, Washington, D. C......................                                            I, 923; II, 2303, 2354
    Mississippi River between Fort Snelling and St. Paul, Minn... I, 948; Ini, 2515
    Niobrara River, Nebr............................................ I, 948; Ir, 2517
    Roadway at tidal reservoir, Washington, D. C.............. , 248, 1211; iii, 2329
    Rules governing opening of draws......................................                                                   I, 911
    Yellowstone National Park ....................................                                            I, 942; nI, 2509
Broad Creek River, Del., improvement of............................                                                   I, 244, 1204
Broadkill Creek, or River, Del., improvement of .........................                                             I, 222, 1180
Broad Sound, Boston Harbor, Mass. See Boston Harbor.
Bronx River, N. Y.:
    Improvement of ..................................................                                                 I, 129, 1059
    Wreck in...........         .....                ........          ................................... I, 157, 1089
                                                                   INDEX.

Brooklyn, N. Y. See East River, Gowanus Bay, and Newtown Creek.                                                                                Page.
Brothertown Harbor, Wis. See Fox River.
Browns Creek, N. Y., improvement of............................                                                                      I, 145, 1075
Brunswick Harbor, Ga., improvement of ..-..-..........                                                 ..-..----.             I, 350; i, 1344
Brunswick River, N. C. See Cape Fear River below Wilmington.
Brush (or Bush) Creek, Va., dredging of, in connection with Jamestown Expo-
  sition.........................                                       ............................                                 I, 271, 1248
Buckwheat Island, Arthur Kill, N. J., harbor lines around.................... I, 910
Budd Inlet, Wash. See Olympia Harbor.
Buffalo Bayou, Tex.:
     Improvement of..........                              ...............................                                    I, 475; ii, 1496
     Regulations governing navigation of .................                                                           .......                   , 911
                                                                                                                                              I...
Buffalo Creek, or River, N. Y. See Buffalo Harbor improvement.
Buffalo Harbor, N. Y.:
     Improvement of.............................                                                 ..............               I, 800; Ii, 2148
     Improvement of Black Rock Harbor and channel .........                                                        . . . . . I, 804; i, 2155
     Improvement of Buffalo entrance to Erie Basin and Black Rock Har-
       bor.........................................                                          ......        ..... ..... I, 803; i, 2154
     Improvement of channels in waters connecting Great Lakes..... i, 753;                                                             i,       2059
     Improvement of Lake Erie entrance to Erie Basin and Black Rock Har-
        bor.....                  .........................................                                                   I, 802; in, 2153
Buffalo River, or Creek, N. Y. See Buffalo Harbor improvement.
Buildings:
     Army War College, Washington, D. C.........                                                          ................................... I, 945
     Engineer Post and School, Washington, D. C.............................                                                                  I, 945
     Public, District of Columbia........ ..............                                                .......           . I, 929; iiI, 2329
Bulkhead lines, establishment of ...................................                                                                        I, 910
Bullis, Spencer S., contract with. See Gulfport Harbor.
Burlington Harbor, Vt.:
     Examination and survey. .........................................                                                                       I, 78
       Improvement of..............                                                                                                I, 75, 1000
Burr Creek, Conn. See Bridgeport Harbor.
Bush (or Brush) Creek, Va., dredging of, in connection with Jamestown Expo-
sition......... .................. ................   .. .............. I, 271, 1248
Byram River, N. Y. See Port Chester Harbor.

                                                       C.
Cable galleries. See Fortifications.
Cache River, Ark., improvement of. .................                            ......   ...        I, 541; in, 1587
Caddo Lake, Tex. and La., improvement of Cypress Bayou........... i, 507; i, 1543
Calaveras River, Cal. See Mormon Channel.
Calcasieu Pass and River, La., improvement of .....................
California Debris Commission....................                       ....................
                                                                                                    I, 452;      1468
                                                                                                   I, 905; II, 2295
                                                                                                                                       i,
Caloosahatchee River, Fla., improvement of. ...................
Calumet Harbor, Wis. See Fox River.
                                                                                             I, 371, 372;        1370                  i,
Calumet Harbor and River, Ill. and Ind.:
     Improvement of harbor (South Chicago Harbor) .................                                 I, 711; i, 1995
     Improvement of river .....................................
     Reversing flow of river .........................................
                                                                                                    I, 713;      1997
                                                                                                    I, 715; i, 1998
                                                                                                                                       i,
     Wrecks in river near Ninety-third street......................... I, 718; ii, 2002
Cambridge Harbor, Md., improvement of ......................                                   . I, 231, 235, 1195
Cambusdoon (bark), wreck of ....................................                                .,     332; in, 1315
Camden Harbor, Me., examination and survey....                            ...............            .......     I, 47
Camden Harbor, N. J. See Cooper Creek and Delaware River.
Canada, Dominion of:
     Commerce through St. Marys Falls Canal, Ont. ...............
     Transmission of electrical power into U. S. at Niagara Falls. I, 939, 941; i, 2503
                                                                                                    I, 759;      2072                  in,
Canals, locks, and dams (see also Waterways):
     Albermarle and Chesapeake Canal, N. C. See Albermarle Sound-Norfolk
       waterway.
     Allegheny River, Pa., locks and dams. See Allegheny River.
     Appropriation for operation and care..................................                                  i, 28, 29
     Barren River, Ky., lock and dam. See Barren River.
     Bee Tree Shoals Canal, Ala. See Tennessee River.
     Benton Harbor Canal, Mich. See St. Joseph Harbor.
     Big Barren River, Ky., lock and dam. See Barren River.
     Big Kanawha River, W. Va., locks and dams. See Kanawha River.
VI                                        INDEX.

Canals, locks, and dams-Continued.                                                        Page.
    Big Sandy River, W. Va. and Ky., locks and dams. See Big Sandy River.
    Black Rock Harbor, N. Y., lock. See Black Rock Harbor.
    Black Warrior River, Ala., locks and dams. See Black Warrior River.
    Brazos River, Tex., locks and dams. See Brazos River.
    Brazos River, Tex., to Galveston. See Galveston and Brazos Canal and
       West Galveston Bay.
    Caddo Lake, Tex. and La., dam. See Caddo Lake.
    Calaveras River, Cal., to Mormon Channel, San Joaquin River. See Mor-
       mon Channel.
    Canadian Canal, St. Marys River, Ont., commerce. See St. Marys Falls
       Canal.
    Cape Fear River above Wilmington, N. C., locks and dams. See Cape Fear
       River.
    Care and maintenance, appropriation for..............................            I,   28, 29
    Cascades Canal, Columbia River, Oreg. See Columbia River.
    Chicago (Lockport), Ill., to St. Louis, Mo., and the Gulf, 14-foot waterway.
       See Chicago Harbor.
    Club Creek, Ga., to Plantation Creek. See Club Creek.
    Clubfoot and Harlowe Canal, N. C. See Newbern-Beaufort waterway.
    Colbert Shoals Canal, Ala. See Tennessee River.
    Columbia River, Cascades Canal. See Columbia River.
    Columbia River, The Dalles Rapids to Celilo Falls, locks and canal. See
       Columbia River.
    Congaree River, S. C., lock and dam. See Congaree River.
    Coosa River, Ga. and Ala., locks and dams. See Coosa River.
    Cumberland River, Tenn. and Ky., locks and dams. See Cumberland
       River.
    Dams, permits for erection of....................       ........................      , 920
    Des Moines Rapids Canal, Mississippi River. See Mississippi River.
    Des Plaines River, Ill., 14-foot waterway via. See Chicago Harbor.
    Dismal Swamp Canal, Va. and N. C. See Norfolk-North Carolina sounds
       waterway.
    Duluth Canal, Minn. See Duluth Canal.
    Elk River Shoals Canal, Ala. See Tennessee River.
    Estherville-Minim Creek Canal, S. C. See Estherville-Minim Creek Canal.
    Expenditures for operation and care ..................................           I,   28, 29
    Fox River, Wis., locks and dams. See Fox River.
    Galena River, Ill., lock and dam. See Galena River.
    Galveston, Tex., to Brazos River. See Galveston and Brazos Canal and
       West Galveston Bay.
    Gordon Lake, Del., via. See Gordon Lake.
    Grays Harbor, Wash., to Puget Sound. See Grays Harbor.
    Great Kanawha River, W. Va., locks and dams. See Kanawha River.
    Green River, Ky., locks and dams. See Green River.
    Hales bar, Tennessee River, lock and dam. See Tennessee River.
    Illinois and Mississippi Canal, Ill. See Illinois and Mississippi Canal.
    Illinois River, Ill., locks and dams. See Illinois River.
    Illinois River, Ill., 14-foot waterway from Lockport (Chicago) to St. Louis,
       Mo., and mouth of the Mississippi. See Chicago Harbor.
    Kanawha River, W. Va., locks and dams. See Kanawha River.
    Kentucky River, Ky., locks and dams. See Kentucky River.
    Keokuk (Des Moines Rapids) Canal, Mississippi River. See Mississippi
       River.
    Keweenaw Bay to Lake Superior. See Keweenaw Bay-Lake Superior.
       waterway.
    Lake Washington Canal, Wash. See Puget Sound-Lake Washington water-
       way.
    Levisa Fork, Big Sandy River, Ky., locks and dams. See Big Sandy River.
    Little Kanawha River, W. Va., locks and dams. See Little Kanawha River.
    Lockport, Ill., to St. Louis, Mo., and mouth of the Mississippi, 14-foot water-
       way. See Chicago Harbor.
    Louisville and Portland Canal, Ky. See Ohio River.
    Michigan Lake to St. Louis, Mo., and the Gulf, 14-foot waterway. See
       Chicago Harbor.
                                                INDEX.                                                   VII

Canals, locks, and dams--Continued.                                                                    Page.
   Michigan Lake to Sturgeon Bay. See Sturgeon Bay and Lake Michigan
      Canal.
    Minim Creek-Estherville Canal, S. C. See Estherville-Minim Creek Canal.
    Mississippi River, Des Moines Rapids Canal. See Mississippi River.
    Mississippi River to Illinois River. See Illinois and Mississippi Canal.
    Mississippi River, Moline, Ill., lock and dam. See Mississippi River.
    Mississippi River, reservoirs. See Mississippi River.
    Mississippi River, St. Paul to Minneapolis, locks and dams. See Missis-
      sippi River.
    Mississippi River, 14-foot waterway from mouth to St. Louis, Mo., and
      Lockport (Chicago), Ill. See Mississippi River.
    Moline Harbor, Ill., lock and dam. See Mississippi River.
    Monongahela River, W. Va. and Pa., locks and dams. See Monongahela
      River.
    Morgan Canal, Tex. See Morgan Canal.
    Mormon Channel, San Joaquin River, Cal., to Calaveras River. See
      Mormon Channel.
    Mosquito Creek Canal, S. C. See Santee River.
    Muscle Shoals Canal, Ala. See Tennessee River.
    Muskingum River, Ohio, locks and dams. See Muskingum River.
    Navigation of, regulations for...............................................                      I, 911
    North Carolina Cut, N. C., waterway via. See Norfolk-Albemarle Sound
       waterway.
    Ohio River, locks and dams. See Ohio River.
    Ohio River, Louisville and Portland Canal. See Ohio River.
    Operation and care, appropriation for................................                         r,   28, 29
    Osage River, Mo., lock and dam. See Osage River.
    Ouachita River, Ark. and La., locks and dams. See Ouachita River.
    Permanent appropriation for operation and care ...........                         ..........       I, 28
    Plantation Creek, Ga., to Club Creek. See Plantation Creek.
    Plaquemine Bayou, La., lock. See Plaquemine Bayou.
    Portage Lake canals, Mich. See Keweenaw Bay-Lake Superior waterway.
    Port Arthur Canal, Tex. See Port Arthur Canal.
    Potomac River at Washington, D. C., lock and tidal reservoir. See Potomac
       River.
    Puget Sound, Wash., to Grays Harbor. See Puget Sound.
    Puget Sound-Lake Washington waterway. See Puget Sound-Lake Wash-
       ington waterway.
    Regulations for navigation of.......................                    ..............             I, 911
    Rock River, Ill. See Illinois and Mississippi Canal.
    Rough River, Ky., lock and dam. See Rough River.
    Rules for navigation of................................................                             , 911
    St. Clair Flats Canal, Mich. See St. Clair Canal and River.
    St. Louis, Mo., 14-foot waterway from Lockport (Chicago), Ill., to, and
       mouth of the Mississippi. See Mississippi River.
    St. Marys Falls Canal, Mich. See St. Marys River, etc.
    St. Michael Canal, Alaska. See St. Michael Canal.
    Salmon Bay, Wash., waterway via. See Puget Sound-Lake Washington
       waterway.
    San Joaquin River, Cal., Mormon Channel to Calaveras River. See Mor-
       mon Channel.
    Scott Point, Tennessee River, lock and dam at Hales bar. See Tennessee
       River.
    Seattle Canal, Wash. See Puget Sound-Lake Washington waterway.
   'Shilshole Bay, Wash., waterway via. See Puget Sound-Lake Washing-
       ton waterway.
    Sturgeon Bay and Lake Michigan Canal, Wis. See Sturgeon Bay and Lake
      Michigan Canal.
    Superior Lake to Keweenaw Bay. See Superior Lake.
    Teche Bayou, La., lock and dam. See Teche Bayou.
    Tennessee River, canals, locks, and dams. See Tennessee River.
    Tombigbee River, Ala., locks and dams. See Tombigbee River.
    Trinity River, Tex., locks and dams. See Trinity River.
VIII                                                       INDEX.

                                                                                                                            Page.
Canals, locks, and dams-Continued.
    Tug Fork, Big Sandy River, W. Va. and Ky., locks and dams. See Big
       Sandy River.
    Turners Cut, N. C., waterway via. See Norfolk-North Carolina sounds
       waterway.
    Union Lake, Wash., waterway via. See Puget Sound-Lake Washington
       waterway.
    Wabash River, lock and dam. See Wabash River.
    Warrior River, Ala., locks and dams. See Warrior River.
    Washington, D. C., lock at tidal reservoir, Potomac River. See Potomac
       River.
    Washington Lake to Puget Sound, waterway. See Puget Sound-Lake
       Washington waterway.
    Washita (Ouachita) River, Ark, and La., locks and dams. See Ouachita
       River.
    West Galveston Bay and Brazos River Canal, Tex. See West Galveston Bay.
    White River, Ark., locks and dams. See White River.
    Yamhill River, Oreg., lock and dam. See Yamhill River.
    Yuba River, Cal., restraining dam. See California Debris Commission.
Canarsie Bay, N. Y., improvement of...............................                                                 , 132, 137, 1067
Cane River, La., improvement of................................                                                     I,514; II, 1553
Caney Fork River, Tenn., improvement of .......................                                                     I,591; II, 1687
Cape Ann, Mass., harbor of refuge. See Sandy Bay.
Cape Charles City Harbor, Va., improvement of..............                                       ........ . . . I,281, 1263
Cape Fear River, N. C.:
     Defenses of... ............            .........               ...............................                             I,10
     Improvement above Wilmington ...........                             .. ......           .         . I,307, 310; II,      1292
     Improvement at and below Wilmington .......... ..............                                                  I, 311; II,1293
     Improvement of Northeast Branch ............................                                                   I,307; 11, 1290
     Wrecks near Fort Caswell ...................................                                           ..........        I,315
Cape May, N. J. See Cold Spring Inlet.
Cape May Real Estate Company. See Cold Spring Inlet.
Cape Porpoise Harbor, Me.:
     Improvement of..................                                         .....      ......................            I,44, 976
    Wreck in..................                             .............................                                   I,47, 979
Cape Vincent Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ............ .........                                                 I,813; III, 2172
Capitol, Washington, D. C., telegraph line. See Public buildings and grounds.
Carquinez Strait, Cal., examination and survey from San Francisco Bay to
  Stockton, including .............................................                                                            I,834
Carrabelle Harbor and River, Fla., improvement of ..........                                         . . . .. I,386; I, 1385
Carriages, gun and mortar. See Fortifications.
Carters Creek, Va., improvement of ...............                                   .
                                                                                    ........          . . .. I,256, 261, 1232
Cascades Canal, Columbia River, Oreg.:
     Construction of ..............................................                                              I,852; nI, 2218
    Operating and care.. ..........    ....                              .................... I, 854; I,2218
Casemates, mining. See Fortifications.
Castle Island, Boston Harbor, Mass., wreck near ......................                        I,77, 1002
Castlerock, Wash., examination and survey of Cowlitz River up to...........                        I,871
Caswell, Fort, N. C., wrecks near ........................................                         I,315
Cavalla, Pass, Tex.:
    Examination and survey of channel to Port Lavaca.. ................                            I,497
    Examination and survey to Port O'Connor (on Matagorda Bay) for harbor.. I,497
    Improvement of channel to Aransas Pass                   .....       ... .......      I,488; i, 1508
Cedar Bayou, Tex., improvement of ......                  ..........          ....   I,478, 481; II,1504
Cedar Creek, Conn. See Bridgeport Harbor.
Centissima rock, San Francisco Harbor, Cal., examination and survey......... I,834
Chalmette, La., monument to memory of soldiers who fell in the battle of New
  Orleans.....       ...................................                                 I,949; iii,2519
Chambersia (Anahuac) channel, Tex. See Anahuac channel.
Champlain Lake, N. Y. and Vt.:
    Burlington Harbor, Vt. See Burlington Harbor.
       Narrows, improvement of .....                         .................... .......                           I,76, 1002
       North and South Hero islands channel (The Gut), Vt., improvement of... I,74
       North and South Hero islands channel (The Gut), examination and survey. I,78
       St. Albans Harbor, Vt. See St. Albans Harbor.
       Wrecks in Narrows of .........................     .............    I,77, 1003
Channels.         See Rivers and harbors.
                                                                   INDEX                                                                         IX

                                                                                                                                             Page.
Charles River, Boston, Mass., improvement of .............................                                                          I, 63, 990
Charleston Harbor, S. C.:
    Defenses of..........                    ...................................                                                      I, 10, 15
    Improvement of .........                            ....................                                               I, 330; In, 1314
    Improvement of waterway to McClellanville ..................                                                      . , 329; II, 1312
    Wrecks near entrance. .I..............                                          ..............                           , 332; In, 1315
Charlevoix Harbor, Mich., improvement of .................                                                     ....        I, 750; In, 2053
Charlotte Harbor, Fla., improvement of .............................                                                       I, 372; i, 1370
Charlotte Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ............................. I, 806; III, 2163
Charts. See Maps.
Chattahoochee River, Ga. and Ala., improvement of .............                                                            I, 395; in, 1393
Chattanooga, Tenn. See Tennessee River.
Cheboygan Harbor, Mich., improvement of .......................                                                            I, 761; II, 2096
Cheesequake Creek, N. J., improvement of .......................                                                        I, 174, 182, 1126
Chefuncte River, La., improvement of .....................                                                        I, 454, 455; In, 1471
Chehalis River, Wash.:
    Examination and survey up to Montesano ...........................                                                                    I, 893
    Improvement of ............                            .....               .................                         I, 875; III, 2251
Chelsea Creek, Mass. See Boston Harbor.
Chequamegon Bay, Wis. See Ashland Harbor.
Chesapeake Bay, Md. and Va.:
    Defenses at entrance..................................................                                                                   I, 10
    Waterway to Albemarle Sound. See Norfolk-Albemarle Sound waterway.
    Waterway to sounds of North Carolina (to Pamlico Sound). See Norfolk-
       North Carolina sounds waterway.
    Wreck near Sevenfoot Knoll ........................................                                                                   I, 247
    York Spit, shoals opposite. See Patapsco River channel to Baltimore.
Chester River, Md., improvement of .........................                                                            I, 231, 236, 1196
Chicago Harbor and River, Ill.:
    Calumet Harbor and River. See Calumet Harbor and River.
    Channels in waters connecting Great Lakes, improvement of ..... I, 753; ni, 2059
    Improvement of harbor......................                                          ..............                    I, 706; In, 1987
    Improvement of river......                        .............                           ...........                  I, 708; nI, 1990
    South Chicago Harbor. See Calumet Harbor and River.
    Survey for 14-foot waterway from Lockport to St. Louis, Mo., and the
       Gulf, including report on water power and land drainage.............. I, 908
    Wrecks near South Chicago Breakwater light-house, and near Fullerton
       avenue and Davidson street......................                                                          I, 718; nI, 2002, 2003
Chickasahay River, Miss., improvement of................. I, 427, 428; In, 1428, 1429
Chief of Engineers, officers on duty in office of the..........................                                                           I, 952
Chincoteague Inlet, Va., wreck in ....................................                                                          I, 223, 1182
Chipola River, Fla.:
    Improvement of lower river .................                                         ..          .........             I, 390; In, 1389
    Improvement of upper river ..............................                                                     I, 390, 391; In, 1389
Chitto, Bogue, La., improvement of ..........                                  ...................                         I, 454; I, 1470
Chocolate Bayou, Tex., improvement of .....................                                                        I, 478, 485; ni, 1506
Choctawhatchee River, Fla. and Ala., improvement of ...............                                                        I, 397; II, 1395
Choptank River, Md.:
    See also Cambridge Harbor.
    Improvement of.               ......
                                      .....          .... .......................                                       I, 231, 237, 1198
Christiana River, Del., improvement of Wilmington Harbor .............                                                          I, 212, 1168
Cincinnati, Ohio. See Ohio River.
City of Birmingham (steamer), wreck of ...............................                                                            I, 77, 1002
Civilian assistants:
    To engineer officers ..................................................                                                                  I, 27
    To the Chief of Engineers...................... ...............                                                   ......      ..... I, 952
Claiborne Harbor, Md., improvement of .........................                                                         I, 231, 233, 1194
Clark Creek, or River, S. C., improvement of..........                                            ..         ...... I, 319; In, 1303
Clark Fork, Columbia River, Wash. See Pend Oreille River.
Clatskanie River, Oreg., improvement of ...........................                                                      I, 865; III, 2239
Clear Creek, Tex., improvement of..                                   ....................                         I, 478, 482; In, 1504
Clearwater Harbor, Fla., examination and survey, including Boca Ceiga Bay,
  to Tampa Bay-.-. .....                    ......                                                                                              385
                                                                                                                                          I,I.............................
Cleveland Harbor, Ohio:
    Improvement of .................                              .........................                                I, 789; ni, 2132
    Wreck in...................................................                                                        - I, 797; i, 2141
                                                               I1NDEX

                                                                                                                                    Page.
Clinch River, Tenn., improvement of .............................                             I, 602; I, 1711
Clinton River, Mich., improvement of ...............                       ..... . . . . . . I, 776; II, 2109
Club Creek, Ga., improvement of .................................                             I, 349; Ii, 1344
Clubfoot and Harlowe Canal, N. C., waterway via. See Newbern-Beaufort
  waterway.
Clubfoot Creek, N. C., waterway via. See Newbern-Beaufort waterway.
Coanjock Bay, N. C., waterway via. See Norfolk-Albemarle Sound waterway.
Coast defenses. See Fortifications.
Cocheco River, N. H., improvement of ...................                           ......        . I, 46, 978
Cohansey River, N. J., improvement of.................................                            I, 207, 1164
Coit (Shaws) Cove, New London Harbor, Conn. See New London and Thames
  River.
Colbert Shoals Canal, Tennessee River, Ala., improvement of ......... I, 596; 11, 1705
Cold Spring Inlet, N. J., improvement of ...............................                          I, 210, 1167
Coldwater River, Miss., improvement of. ......................... I, 526, 527; in, 1567
Cole, Addie F. (schooner), wreck of .......................................                              I, 384
College, War, Army, Washington, D. C., erection of buildings for.............. I, 945
Colorado River, Tex., examination and survey................................                             I, 497
Colorado (Arroyo) River, Tex., examination and survey from Harlingen to
  Point Isabel, on Laguna Madre .........................................                                I, 497
Columbia River, Oreg. and Wash.:
     Cascades Canal, construction of ....................                      .........     I, 852; In, 2218
     Cascades Canal, operating and care...........................                           I, 854; iI, 2218
     Celilo Falls to Snake River, including tributaries, improvement from..... I, 848;
                                                                                                                                III, 2213
    Celilo Falls to The Dalles Rapids, improvement from........... I, 850; nII,2214
    Clark Fork. See Pend Oreille River.
    Gauging.....................................................                                                      I, 870; iI, 2243
    M outh, defenses at....................................................                                                             I, 10
    Mouth, improvement at......................................                                                       I, 862; nI, 2236
    Mouth to Willamette River, improvement from, including dredge con-
      struction.................. ............                                  ............................                         I, 859,
                                                                                                               1153; In, 2211, 2230
    Regulations governing navigation of .........                                     .........................                      I, 911
   Threemile Rapids, improvement at. ............................                                                     I, 850; is, 2214
    Vancouver, Wash., to Willamette River, improvement from.... I, 854; Ii, 2223
   Wenatchee, Wash., to Bridgeport, improvement from......... .,                                                          888; iI, 2261
Commencement Bay, Wash. See Tacoma Harbor.
Commissioned officers. See Corps of Engineers.
Commissions (see also Boards):
    California D4bris Commission ..................................                                                    , 905; ii, 2295
   Mississippi River Commission.............................                                                        . , 909; in, 2641
    Permanent International Commission of Congresses of Navigation.......... I, 910
Compton Creek, N. J., improvement of. ..........                                         ..................1, 174, 181, 1124
Conecuh River, Ala., improvement of....................                                                     ..... . I, 403; 11, 1399
Coney Island channel, N. Y., improvement of............................. I, 155, 1088
Congaree River, S. C.:
    Improvement of. ..........................................                                                   I, 323, 326; in, 1310
    Operating and care of lock and dam............................                                                      , 329; i, 1311
Congress, 60th, 2d session, and Sixty-first Congress, 1st session, laws of, affecting
  Corps of Engineers ..............                          ......................                                  ....          I..i,2527
Congresses of Navigation, Permanent International Commission of............                                                ..         , 910
Conneaut Harbor, Ohio, improvement of............................                                                      I, 795; 11, 2140
Connecticut River; Mass. and Conn.:
    Improvement between Hartford, Conn., and Holyoke, Mass_......... , 103, 1032
    Improvement below Hartford, Conn.. .........................                                                          . I, 104, 1032
    Survey between Hartford, Conn., and Holyoke, Mass..................... I, 100
Connor, Wm. H. (barge), wreck of .............................                                    ...........                I, 164, 1100
Contentnia Creek, N. C., improvement of...........................                                                     I, 293; in, 1276
Contingencies:
    Engineer department, Philippine Islands ..............................                                                              r, 27
    Of rivers and harbors, estimate of appropriation for..................                                                      1, 28, 904
Continuing contracts:
    Ahnapee (Algoma) Harbor, Wis................................                                                       I, 690;  11,
                                                                                                                       I, 690; 11, 1958
                                                                                                                                        1958
    Algoma Harbor, Wis .................                                     ......................
    Allegheny River, Pa., locks and dams.......................... , 618; i, 1770
                                                           INDEX.                                                              XI

Continuing contracts-Continued.                                                                                                Page.
   Ambrose channel, New York Harbor, N. Y ..............                                             .        , 159, 1092, 1154
   Ann, Cape, Mass., Sandy Bay, harbor of refuge. See Sandy Bay, infra.
   Appomattox River, Va ................ .......                                        ..............                I, 280, 1260
   Appropriations, estimate for.....................................                                                      I, 28, 904
   Aransas Pass, Tex .......................................                                                      I, 493; Ii, 1512
   Aransas Pass, Tex., to Corpus Christi, channel from...........                                            . I, 488; ii, 1508
   Arthur Kill, N. Y. and N. J ....................                              .....        ......... .... r, 168, 1108
   Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio..................................                                                       , 794; II, 2138
   Back Cove, Portland, Me. See Portland Harbor, infra.
   Baltimore Harbor, Md., Patapsco River and channel to........                                                       I, 224, 1185
   Bay Ridge channel, New York Harbor, N. Y......................                                                     r, 162, 1095
    Beaufort Inlet, N. C., to Pamlico Sound, waterway............. .I, 302; I, 1.286
   Bee Tree shoals, Tennessee River, Ala .........................                                                 , 595; ii, 1705
    Big Sandy River, W. Va. and Ky..............                                    ................. I, 638; n, 1825
    Biscayne Bay, Fla.........................                                  ...............                   I, 368; n, 1364
    Black Lake Harbor, Holland, Mich. See Holland Harbor, infra.
   Black River, La ...........                 ............................                                       I, 515; n, 1554
    Black River (Lorain) Harbor, Ohio. See Lorain Harbor, infra.
    Black Rock Harbor, Buffalo, N. Y.. ........                            ........               .....           I, 804; I, 2155
    Black Rock Harbor, Buffalo, N. Y., Lake Erie entrance......... I, 802; nI, 2153
    Black Warrior River, Ala., above Tuscaloosa ...................                                               I, 414; II, 1412
    Black Warrior River, Ala., below Tuscaloosa ....... . . ...                                         r, 414, 415; n, 1414
    Boston Harbor, Mass................                           ..........................                              I, 60, 990
    Brazos River, Tex., at mouth.................................                                                 I, 492; in, 1511
    Brazos River, Tex., Old Washington to Waco..........                                       .......            I, 503; I, 1533
    Brazos River, Tex., to Galveston, waterway..................... I, 487; TI, 1507
    Bridgeport Harbor, Conn.........................................                                                    , 114, 1043
    Brunswick Harbor, Ga................................................ , 350; Ii, 1344
    Buffalo Bayou, Tex............................................                                                I, 475; ii, 1496
    Buffalo Harbor, N. Y...........................................                                               I, 800; I, 2148
    Buffalo Harbor, N. Y., Black Rock Harbor .............                                             ...... I, 804; I, 2155
   Buffalo Harbor, N. Y., Lake Erie entrance to Erie Basin and Black Rock
      Harbor.................................................................                                     I, 802; II, 2153
   Burlington Harbor, Vt.................                                   ........................ I, 75, 1000
   Calumnet River, Ill. and Ind................................                                                   I, 713; ni, 1997
   Cape Ann, Mass., Sandy Bay, harbor of refuge. See Sandy Bay, infra.
    Cape Fear River, N. C., at and below Wilmington................ I, 311; II, 1293
    Cavallo, Pass, Tex., to Aransas Pass, channel from............... , 488; I, 11508
    Champlain Lake, Burlington Harbor, Vt. See Burlington Harbor, supra.
   Chicago, Harbor, Ill., Calumet River. See Calumet River, supra.
   Cleveland Harbor, Ohio......................................                                                   I, 789; n, 2132
    Colbert shoals, Tennessee River, Ala ............................                                             i, 596; n, 1705
   Cold Spring Inlet, N. J...........................................                                                  I, 210, 1167
   Columbia River, Oreg. and Wash., at the mouth........ . .. . ....                                            I, 862; II, 2236
   Columbia River, below mouth of Willamette River... I, 859, 1153; in, 2211, 2230
   Columbia River, The Dalles Rapids to Celilo Falls.. ............ I, 850; III, 2214
   Corpus Christi, Tex., to Aransas Pass, channel from............. I, 490; n, 1510
   Cumberland River above Nashville, Tenn. (Locks 3-7 and 21).. I, 588; n, 1680
   Delaware River, N. J., Pa., and Del.....                              .........................                     , 188, 1131
   Detroit River, Mich ........................................                                                   I, 777; n, 2110
   Duluth Harbor, Minn......................................................... I, 661; n, 1902
   East (Ambrose) channel, New York Harbor, N. Y. See New York Harbor,
      infra.
   Erie Basin, Buffalo, N. Y., Lake Erie entrance........... .....                                                I, 802; n, 2153
   Estimate of appropriations for ......................................                                                  I, 27, 904
   Fairhaven Harbor, Mass.................................................. I, 83, 1010
    Franklin, La., to Mermentau, waterway ........................                                                I, 451; ni, 1467
    Galveston and Brazos Canal, Tex...........................                                                 . I, 487; n, 1507
    Galveston Harbor, Tex...... ......                                     ...........
                                                        .....................                         i, 469, 1154; n, 1488
    Galveston-Brazos River waterway, Tex.......................... I, 487; n, 1507
    Galveston-Houston waterway, Tex..                        ........................ . .. I, 475; n, 1496
    Gloucester Harbor, Mass ...........................................                                                   I, 54, 985
    Gowanus Bay channels, New York Harbor, N. Y......................                                                 I, 162, 1095
    Grays Harbor, Wash..........................................                                                 I, 873; III, 2246
    Great Lakes, channels in connecting waters of. See Northern and North-
      western Lakes, infra.
XII                                                       INDEX.

Continuing contracts-Continued.                                                                              Page.
   Great Pedee River, S. C...............                    ........................             I,319; Ii, 1304
   Guadalupe River, Tex .........................................                                 I,489; ii, 1509
   Hales bar lock, Tennessee River. See Tennessee River, infra.
   Harbor Beach, Mich....................................
   Hay Lake channel, St. Marys River, Mich ..................
                                                                                                  I, 768;     2101
                                                                                                  I, 760; II, 2092
                                                                                                                    11,
   Hillsboro Bay, Fla .............................                                   ..........  I, 377; ii, 1376
   Hilo Harbor, Hawaii .......................................... I, 895; In,2270
   Holland Harbor, Mich........................................                                   I,730; II, 2026
   Honolulu Harbor, Hawaii............................................                           I,894; ii, 2267
   Houston-Galveston waterway, Tex...................................                             I,475; II, 1496
   Huron Harbor, Ohio ..........................................                                  I,785; II, 2127
   Illinois and Mississippi Canal, Ill............                     ....................      I,720; iI, 2010
   Judith, Point, R. I., harbor of refuge ..............................                               I,93, 1019
   Kalamazoo River, Mich ........................                                .............    I, 728; II, 2024
    Kennebec River, Me ...............................................                                  I,39, 972
    Kentucky River, Ky........... ................................. I,641; II,1833
   Levisa Fork, Big Sandy River, Ky .......................                                       I,638; iI, 1825
    Lorain Harbor, Ohio        ...................                    ......           .........  I,787; Ii, 2129
   Ludington Harbor, Mich               ......             .......................................I,742; II,2042
   Lynn Harbor, Mass .....................................................................              I,56, 987
   Manitowoc Harbor, Wis.........................                                ..............   I,693; II,1962
   Marquette Harbor, Mich................                       ......................... I,677; II, 1934
   Maumee Bay and River, Ohio. See Toledo Harbor, infra.
   Mermentau, La., to Franklin, waterway... ......................                                I,451; iI,1467
   Michigan Lake-Sturgeon Bay Canal, including harbor of refuge .. I,688; ii, 1951
   Milwaukee (inner) Harbor, Wis .................................                                I, 699; II, 1972
   Milwaukee Harbor, Wis., including harbor of refuge.............                               I,698; II, 1970
    Mississippi River, Head of Passes to Ohio River...... I,909; III, 2641, 2676, 2843
    Mississippi River, between Missouri and Ohio rivers ............ I, 550; II,1598
    Mississippi River, between Missouri River and Minneapolis ......... , 554, 560;
                                                                                                            ii, 1621, 1641
      Mississippi River at Moline, Ill..............................                                           I,558; ii, 1635
      Mississippi River, Plaquemine Bayou, La.......                                       ..........          I,445; II, 1460
      Mississippi River, between St. Paul and Minneapolis ............                                         I,560; II,1641
      Mississippi River, South Pass..........                   ...........                             .. . I, 442; Ii,1451
      Mississippi River, Southwest Pass .....                   ....................                        . I,439; Ii,1441
      Mobile Harbor, Ala...........................................                                            I,558; II,1635
      Moline Harbor, Ill.................................................                                      I,558; II, 1635
      Monongahela River, W.Va. and Pa ...................                                           I, 612, 613; i, 1753, 1754
      Mormon Channel, San Joaquin River, Cal. .....................                                           I,827; Iii, 2191
      Narragansett Bay, R. I ..........................................                                               I,90, 1016
      Neches River, Tex., at mouth ............                               .................                 , 498; iI,1526
      Neebish channels, St. Marys River, Mich ........................                                         I, 760; II,2092
      Newark Bay, N. J..............................................                                               I,165, 1101
      New Bedford Harbor, Mass......................................                                                   , 83,1010
      New Haven Harbor, Conn., breakwater construction.. . . . . . .......                                         I,110, 1038
      New Haven Harbor, Conn., dredging, etc .........................                                             I, 108, 1036
      New London Harbor, Conn......................................                                                 I,102, 1029
      Newport Harbor, R. I..........                         .............................                           I,92, 1018
      Newtown Creek, N. Y ............................................                                              I,143, 1073
      New York Harbor, N. Y., Ambrose                    Channel.                 ............               I, 159,  1092, 1154
      New York Harbor, N. Y., Gowanus Bay channels .................                                                I,162, 1095
      Norfolk Harbor, Va.- ............. ...............                                              . I,273,274, 1251, 1252
      Northern and Northwestern Lakes, channels connecting......... I,753; II,2059
      Oakland Harbor, Cal.........................................                                            I,822; iin, 2185
                                                                                                          .....
      Ohio River, Dams Nos. 2-6 ..................................                                             I,621; iI,1776
      Ohio River, Dams Nos. 8, 11, 13, 18, and 26 ....................                                         I,627; II,1787
      Ohio River, Dam No. 37..................................... I,609; II, 1743
      Osage River, Mo..............................................                                            I,579; iI,1669
      Oswego Harbor, N. Y.....................................                                                I,811; In, 2170
      Ouachita River, Ark. and La . ...............................                                            I,515; iI,1554
      Pamlico Sound, N. C., to Beaufort Inlet, waterway ............                                           I,298; i, 1281
      Passaic River, N. J........                    ................................................                , 165, 1101
      Pass Cavallo, Tex., to Aransas Pass, channel from..... . . . .....                                        , 488; i, 1508
      Patapsco River, Md., and channel to Baltimore ...................                                             I,224, 1185
      Pedee River, S. C. See Great Pedee River, supra.
                                                      INDEX.                                                       XIII

Continuing contracts-Continued.                                                                                  Page.
   Philadelphia, Pa., Delaware River ..............                                 .......    .. ... , 189, 1131
   Plaquemine Bayou, La ..................                                 ................         I, 445; I, 1460
   Point Judith, R. I., harbor of refuge .............................                                     I, 93, 1019
   Portland Harbor, Me..............................................                                         I, 41,974
   Providence Harbor and River, R. I...............................                                        I, 90, 1016
    Rappahannock River, Va... . . . ..............................                                        , 264, 1235
    Red Hook Channel, New York Harbor, N. Y......................                                        I, 162, 1095
   Sabine Lake and River, Tex ........
    Sabine Pass Harbor, Tex.........
                                                              .........................
                                                        ........ ..................
                                                                                                    I, 498;    11,1526
                                                                                                      , 501; iI, 1530
    St. Johns River, Fla., Jacksonville to the ocean................. I, 359; Ii, 1355
    St. Marys River, Mich., at the falls........ ..................                                 I, 755; ii, 2060
    St. Marys River, Mich., Hay Lake and Neebish channels....... I, 760; 11, 2092
    St. Michael Canal, Alaska ..................................                                   I, 891; III, 2264
    Sandbeach (Harbor Beach) harbor of refuge, Mich. See Harbor Beach,
      supra.
    Sandusky Harbor, Ohio....... ..............                                  ............        I, 783; Ii, 2125
    Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Mass., harbor of refuge .....................                                       I, 52, 984
    San Joaquin River, Cal., Stockton and Mormon channels...... I, 827; IIi, 2191
    San Juan Harbor, P. R .. . .................................                                   I, 897; III, 2273
    San Luis Obispo Harbor, Cal ...............................                                    I, 820; IIi, 2183
    San Pablo Bay, Cal............ ............................                                    I, 825; in, 2189
    San Pedro, Cal., Wilmington inner harbor ...................                                   I, 818; III, 2179
    San Pedro Bay, Cal., Wilmington outer harbor .......... .......                                I, 816; in, 2178
    Saugatuck Harbor, Mich........................................
    Savannah Harbor, Ga..................................
                                                                                                     I, 728;   11,2024
                                                                                              I, 333, 1155; II, 1319
    Scott Point, Tennessee River, Ala., lock at Hales bar. See Tennessee
      River, infra.
    South Pass, Mississippi River ...........................                                        I, 442; i, 1451
    Southwest Pass, Mississippi River .............................                                  I, 439; i, 1441
      Staten Island Sound, N. Y. and N. J .......                         . . . ..... . ....   . . . . . . I, 169, 1111
    Stockton channel, San Joaquin River, Cal .....................                                     I, 827; III,.2191
    Sturgeon Bay Canal, Wis., including harbor of refuge.......... I, 688;
    Superior Harbor, Wis........................................
                                                                                                               11,   1951
                                                                                                        I, 661; Ii, 1902
    Tacoma Harbor, Wash.............                        .......................                    I, 880; II, 2255
    Tampa Bay, Fla .. ...       ..........................................                              I, 376; iI, 1374
    Tampa Harbor, Fla., Hillsboro Bay............................                                       I, 377; Ii, 1376
    Tennessee River, Ala., Colbert and Bee Tree shoals............. I, 595; II, 1705
    Tennessee River, Ala., Hales bar lock, near Scott Point........ I, 596; n, 1693
    Toledo Harbor, Ohio ..........................................                                      I, 780; II, 2121
    Tombigbee River, Ala., between mouth and Demopolis ........                                         I, 416; II, 1414
    Trinity River, Tex., locks and dams ............................
    Tug Fork, Big Sandy River, W. Va. and Ky...................... I, 638; II, 1825
                                                                                                        I, 506;11,   1.536
    Turtle Cove Channel, Tex............                      ..... .................                   I, 490; I, 1510
    Warrior River, Ala., above Tuscaloosa ..........................                                    I, 414; Ii, 1412
    Warrior River, Ala., below Tuscaloosa......................... I, 415; II, 1414
    Washita (Ouachita) River, Ark. and La. See Ouachita                                    River,    supra.
    West Galveston Bay and Brazos River Canal, Tex...............                                       I, 487; i, 1507
    Willamette River, below Portland, Oreg............. I, 859, 1153; rii, 2211, 2230
    Wilmington, Cal., inner harbor ................................                                    I, 818; IIi, 2179
    Wilmington, Cal., outer harbor ..................................                                  I, 816; II, 2178
    Wilmington, N. C. See Cape Fear River, supra.
    Winyah Bay, S. C................................................                                    I, 321; i, 1305
    Withlacoochee River, Fla .....................................
    Woods Hole Channel, Mass ........................................
                                                                                                        I, 382;11,   1382
                                                                                                         .. I, 82, 1009
Cantracts, continuing. See Continuing contracts.
Cooper Creek, N. J., improvement of. ................                                 ..............        I, 199, 1157
Coosa River, Ga. and Ala.:
    Examination and survey at Horseleg Shoals............................... I, 409
    Examination and survey for location and construction of Dam No. 5.....                                         I, 409
    Examination and survey from Wetumpka, Ala., to mouth................. I, 409
    Improvement above East Tenn., Va. and Ga. R. R. bridge...... I, 408; i, 1404
    Improvement below East Tenn., Va. and Ga. R. R. bridge....... I, 406; II, 1403
    Operating and care of locks and dams.                       ......      ........                 . I, 408; II, 1405
Coos Bay, Harbor, and River, Oreg.:
    Construction of dredge for Oregon coast harbors................ I, 844; III, 2211
    Improvement of entrance to bay and harbor.................... I, 840; ii, 2205
    Improvement of river .....................................                                         I, 842; III, 2208
XIV                                                                                 INDEX.

                                                                                                                               Page.
Coquille River, Oreg., improvement of, including dredge construction,
                                                                                         I, 838; III, 2203, 2211
Core Creek, N. C., waterway via. See Beaufort Inlet.
Corney Bayou, La., improvement of .........................                                  I, 519, 522; Ii, 1561
Corps of Engineers:
    Civilian assistants to engineer officers....           ..........         ...................... I, 27
    Duties.....................................                       ......................                 I, 3, 4
    Engineer depots ......................................                          I, 23, 24, 25, 957, 961, 963
    Engineer equipment of troops. .................................                            I, 25, 958, 961, 963
    Engineer School and Post, buildings for................................                                  I, 945
    Laws of 60th Congress, 2d session, and 61st Congress, 1st session, affecting
          the....................................................................                              ..              , 2527
      Officers on duty in Office of the Chief of Engineers. .................                                       ........   I, 952
     Personnel, commissioned, number, distribution, and changes during the
       year........            ...............................................                                                  I, 3,4
     Personnel, commissioned, proposed increase in ................                                             . . . .. I, 4, 5, 6, 7
     Personnel, noncommissioned, proposed new grades .......................                                                        I, 8
Corpus Christi Bay and Harbor, Tex., improvement of channel from Corpus
  Christi to Aransas Pass via Turtle Cove..................                                             .......     I, 490; II, 1510
Cowlitz River, Wash.:
     Examination and survey up to Castlerock ..............................                                                     I, 871
     Improvement of..............................................                                                  I, 866; III, 2240
Craft, water. See Dredge boats and Wrecks.
Crisfield Harbor, Md., improvement of................................                                                    I, 246, 1207
Croatan Sound, N. C., waterway via. See Norfolk-North Carolina sounds
  waterway.
Crockett, Fort, Galveston, Tex., sea wall, embankment, and fill...... I, 496; ii, 1515
Crooked (Carrabelle) River, Fla. See Carrabelle Harbor.
Crystal River, Fla., improvement of.................................. I, 379; I, 1379
Cuba, defenses of Guantanamo Bay.................                                            .................                     , 17
Cumberland River, Ky. and Tenn.:
     Improvement above Nashville, Tenn............................ I, 588; II, 1680
     Improvement below Nashville, Tenn .......................                                                      I, 585; II, 1678
     Operating and care of locks and dams..........................                                                 I, 591; Ii, 1686
     Preliminary report of survey below Nashville, Tenn., for extension of
       slack-water system......                  ............                     .......................                       I, 592
Cumberland Sound, Ga. and Fla.:
     Improvement of..................                      ............................                             I, 355; I, 1351
     Improvement of waterway between Savannah and Fernandina.. I, 353; ii, 1348
Current River, Ark. and Mo., improvement of......................                                            I, 542, 543; ii, 1588
Currituck Sound, N. C., waterway via. See Norfolk-Albemarle Sound water-
  way.
Curtis Bay, Baltimore, Md.:
     Harbor lines in........................................................                                                    I, 910
     Improvement of channel to..................................                                                         I, 227, 1188
Cuyahoga River, Ohio. See Cleveland Harbor.
Cypress Bayou, Tex. and La., improvement of, including connecting lakes
  between Shreveport, La., and Jefferson, Tex. .....................                                                 I, 507; i, 1543
Cypress Top Outlet, Choctawhatchee River, Fla. See Choctawhatchee River.

                                                                                      D.
Daghestan (steamship), wreck of...................................                           I, 164, 1099
Dalecarlia reservoir, Washington Aqueduct, D. C. See Washington.
Dams. See Canals, Rivers and harbors, and Waterways.
D'Arbonne Bayou, La., improvement of. ......................                      I, 519, 522; II, 1561
Darien Harbor, Ga., improvement of ...............................                       I, 341; II, 1336
Dead Horse Inlet, N. Y., examination and survey of waters having outlet in.... r, 158
D6bris, mine, in California. See California D6bris Commission.
Deep Creek Branch, Elizabeth River, Va., waterway via. See Norfolk-North
  Carolina sounds waterway.
Defenses, seacoast. See Fortifications.
Delancey Cove, N. Y. See Larchmont Harbor.
Delaware Bay and River, N. J., Pa., and Del.:
    Bordentown bar, improvement of............................                         ... I, 194, 1148
    Defenses of................................                    ... ...............               i, 10
    Delaware Breakwater, Del., maintenance and repair of ............                        I, 196, 1151
                                                              INDEX.                                                                 XV

                                                                                                                                     Page.
Delaware Bay and River, N. J., Pa., and Del.-Continued.
     Examination of river at and near mouth of Neversink River, N. Y., in con-
       nection with examination of the Neversink. ............................                                                      I, 198
     Harbor lines at Philadelphia, Pa........................................                                                       I, 910
     Harbor of refuge in bay, construction of ........................                                                       I, 196, 1151
     Improvement of river. ..........................................                                                        I, 188, 1131
     Lewes, Del., iron pier. See Lewes.
     Marcushook, Pa. See Marcushook.
     Perriwig bar, improvement of .......................                                            ............            I, 193, 1147
     Philadelphia and Camden harbors, improvement of .................... I, 189, 11.31
     Wrecks in river.............................................                                                     , 198, 1152, 1153
Delaware Capes, N. J., wreck off ..............                                          .................                   I, 224, 1183
Departments, Executive, Washington, D. C., telegraph line. See Public build-
  ings and grounds.
Depots, engineer........................................ I, 23, 24, 25, 957, 961, 963
Derelicts. See Wrecks.
Deschutes River, Wash. See Olympia Harbor.
Des Moines Rapids Canal and dry dock, Mississippi River, operating and
  care...... ............................                          .......................                               I, 558; 11, 1633
Des Plaines River, Ill., survey for 14-foot waterway via, including report on
  water power and land drainage. See Chicago Harbor.
Detroit River, Mich.:
     Improvement of .................................................                                                    I, 777; 11, 2110
     Improvement of channels in waters connecting Great Lakes.... I, 753; 11, 2059
     Surveys, etc. See Northern and Northwestern Lakes.
Dickinson Bayou, Tex., improvement of.......................... I, 478, 483; II, 1505
Disappearing gun carriages. See Fortifications.
Discharge measurements. See Water levels.
Dismal Swamp Canal, Va. and N. C., waterway via. See Norfolk-North Caro-
  lina sounds waterway.
District of Columbia. See Washington.
Dividing Creek (La Trappe River), Md. See La Trappe River.
Division engineers....                 ..............................                                      .............               , 29
Divisions, engineer.....................................................                                                              I, 29
Doboy bar, Ga., improvement of ...................                                             ........           , 341, 342; 11, 1336
Dock lines, establishment of ..............................................                                                         I, 910
Dog Island Harbor, St. George Sound, Fla. See Carrabelle Harbor.
Dog River, Miss. (see Pascagoula River) ....................                                                . . . . I, 425; Ii, 1426
Dolphins, building of ................................................                                                              I, 920
Dominion of Canada:
    Commerce through St. Marys Falls Canal, Ont................                                                          I, 759; II, 2072
    Transmission of electrical power into United States at Niagara
       Falls ......................                              ......................                         I, 939, 9411; I, 2503
Dorchester Bay, Mass., improvement of ........................                                              ...........         I, 67, 996
Double Bayou, Tex., improvement of ..........................                                                    I, 478, 479; II, 1502
Dover, Del., examination and ,urvey of St. Jones River up to................                                                        I, 224
Dows, David (schooner), wreck of. ..............................                                                         I, 718; Ii, 2002
Drawbridges:
     See also Bridges.
     Rules for opening of ..................................                                                   ............         I, 911
Drawings. See Maps.
Dredge boats:
     Columbia River, Oreg. and Wash., mouth to Willamette River (sea-
          going)............               .........                  ....             ...       I, 859, 1153; III, 2211, 2230
      Galveston, Tex., engineering district, operation of ...................                            11, 1516
      Galveston Harbor, Tex. (seagoing)....                  ......................      .........        , 1154
      Gillespie, east shore Lake Michigan harbors ..................                            I, 753; II, 2056
      Mississippi coast harbors. .............................                        ......... I, 438; II, 1436
      New York Harbor, N. Y. (seagoing)......... ...................                                I, 158, 1154
      Oregon coast harbors (pipe-line suction)......................... I, 844; III, 2211
      Pensacola Harbor, Fla. (seagoing) .........                   ...............             I, 400; II, 1397
      Savannah Harbor, Ga. (nonseagoing)....................                        I, 333, 1155; II, 1319
      Seagoing hydraulic, performances of.......................................                            I, 899
      Washington State coast harbors (pipe-line suction)................ I, 844, in, 2211
      Willamette River, Oreg., below Portland (seagoing).., 859, 1153; in, 2211, 2230
XVI                                                       INDEX.

                                                                                                                          Page.
Duck Creek (Smyrna River), Del. See Smyrna River.
Duck Island Harbor, Conn., construction of harbor of refuge................  I,106, 1034
Duluth Canal and Harbor, Minn.:
   Channels in waters connecting Great Lakes, improvement of ..... I, 753; ii, 2059
   Harbor lines in front of Minnesota Point ............................ ....I, 911
    Improvement of ...... ..... ..                  ................. r,    661; i, 1902
                                                                          I...........
    Regulations governing navigation of ................................... I,911
Dunkirk Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ......................... r, 798; ii, 2146
Dutch Island Harbor, R. I. See Narragansett Bay.
Duwamish River, Wash., improvement of. See Puget Sound and tributaries.

                                                               E.

Eagle Harbor, Green Bay, Wis., wreck at ...........................                                                            , 706; i, 1986
Eagle (steamer), wreck of ..........                         ..........................                               ... I,718; i, 2003
East Bay Bayou, Tex., improvement of..............                                    .................... rI,479; i, 1501
East (Ambrose) channel, New York Harbor, N. Y. See New York Harbor.
East Chester Creek, N. Y.:
    Examination and survey.....                                  ........... ...............                           ..........        r., 158
    Improvement of ................                         ...........................                                     I,129, 130, 1060
    Wreck in.................................                                                                                      , 157, 1090
Eastern Bay, Md. See Claiborne Harbor.
Eastern Branch (Anacostia River), D. C. See Anacostia River.
Eastern Branch, Elizabeth River, Va. See Elizabeth River.
East Norwalk Harbor, Conn. See Norwalk Harbor.
East Pass, Carrabelle Harbor, Fla. See Carrabelle Harbor.
East River, Ga. See Brunswick Harboi.
East River, N. Y.:
    Examination and survey between North Brother and South Brother
       islands...........................................................                                                                I,157
    Improvement of ...........................................                                                                     I,139, 1068
    Resurvey of East River and Hell Gate, N. Y.                                                        ................ ........            , 158
             in.. ....................................... ...I,157,
    W reck in-------------------------------------------------------i,
    Wreck                                                                                                                                     1089
                                                                                                                                      157, 1089
East Twin River, Wis. See Two Rivers Harbor.
Echo Bay Harbor, New Rochelle, N. Y.:
    Examination and survey....                            ....................                                   ..............           I,158
    Improvement of .... ...........................................                                                               I , 127, 1058
Eden (schooner), wreck of ................                                           ....................                           , 198, 1152
Eel River, Mass. See Plymouth Harbor.
Electrical power, Niagara River, N. Y., control and regulation of.... I, 939; Ii, 2503
Elizabeth River, N. J., improvement of............................                                                           , 174, 180, 1123
Elizabeth River, Va.:
    Improvement of Norfolk Harbor and its approaches, including Hospital
       Point and Eastern and Southern branches..... .......                                                     I,273, 274, 1251, 1252
     Improvement of waterway to Albemarle Sound, via Currituck Sound. I,284, 1266
     Improvement of waterway to sounds of North Carolina, via Pasquotank
       River.......                  ...............                         ......................                                I,282, 1264
     Improvement of Western Branch...                                   ...........................      ..... ........            I,276, 1254
Elk Point, S. Dak. See Missouri River.
Elk River, Md., improvement of.....................................                                                                 , 229, 1190
Elk River Shoals Canal, Ala. See Tennessee River.
Elwood, Kans., improvement of Missouri River at...... I, 29, 577, 578; in,1655, 1661
Embankments. See Fortifications.
Emplacements. See Fortifications.
Employees, civilian assistants to engineer officers..............................                                                             I,27
Endicott Board.......................................................                                                                          , 10
Engineer depots.....................                                       ............                  I,23, 24, 25, 957, 961, 963
Engineer divisions....................................................                                                                        I,29
Engineer officers, civilian assistants to ...............                                           ....................                       , 27
Engineer Post and School, Washington, D. C., buildings for.................                                                               I,945
Engineer troops, equipment of ..........................                                                          I,7, 25, 959, 961, 963
Engineers, Boards, etc., of. See Boards and Commissions.
Engineers, Corps of. See Corps of Engineers.
Engineers, division .............................--------------------------------------------------...                                        I,29
Engineers, Office of the Chief of, officers on duty.........-----------------------....                                                     , 952
Engineers, The Board of ................................                                                                         . I,10, 955
                                                               INDEX.                                                               XVII

                                                                                                                                        Page.
Equipment, engineer, of troops...........................                                                            I, 25, 959, 961, 963
Erie Basin, Buffalo, N. Y.:
    Improvement of Buffalo entrance ..............                                            ............                I, 803; in, 2154
    Improvement of Lake Erie entrance...........................                                                          I, 802; i, 2153
Erie Harbor, Pa., improvement of. ...............                                       . ..............                  I, 797; in, 2143
Erie, Lake:
    See Northern and Northwestern Lakes.
    Wreck in........                     .....................................                                             , 780; n, 2120
Escambia River, Fla., improvement of ............ ................                                                        I, 403; I, 1399
Esopus Creek, N. Y. See Saugerties Harbor.
Essex River, Mass., improvement of. .................................                                                             I, 51, 984
Estero Bay, Fla., examination and survey......................                                                  .......         .... , 385
Estherville-Minim Creek Canal, S. C., improvement of .......                                                 .,        323, 326; n, 1307
Estimates of appropriations required:
    Fortifications .......................                               ..          .........................                           1,23
    Rivers and harbors, etc.............                      .................                             ...........            , 27, 904
Eureka, Cal. See Humboldt Harbor.
Everett Harbor, Wash., improvement of ..........................                                                         I, 884; ir, 2259
Examinations of rivers and harbors:
    Estimates of appropriation for.......................                                                  .. .. ....         . i, 29, 904
    Reports made in compliance with river and harbor act March 3, 1909...... I, 29
Executive departments, Washington, D. C., telegraph line. See Public build-
  ings and grounds.
Executive Mansion and office, Washington, D. C. See Public buildings and
  grounds.
Expenditures:
    Fortifications........                      ....................          ......          .............               , 19, 20, 21, 22
    Rivers and harbors...............................................                                                               I, 28, 29
    Under section 14 of river and harbor act of March 3, 1909.................                                                           , 30

                                                                    F.

Fairhaven Harbor, Mass., improvement of ................                                     ..........           I, 83, 1010
Fairport Harbor, Ohio, improvement of. ......................                                                I, 792; in, 2136
Fairy (Caddo) Lake, Tex. and La. See Cypress Bayou.
Falia, Bogue, Ia., improvement of .......                                    ..........              , 454, 455; n1, 1471
Falls of Ohio River, Louisville, Ky. See Ohio River.
Feather River, Cal.:
     See also California Debris Commission.
     Examination of, from the mouth to Marysville .........................                                            I, 834
     Improvement of ......................................                                                 I, 835; un, 2199
Fernandina Harbor, Fla.:
     See also Cumberland Sound.
     Examination and survey of waterway to Savannah, Ga.................                                               1, 358
     Improvement of ........        ......................................                                    , 357; 11, 1353
     Improvement of waterway to Savannah, Ga....................,                                               353; I, 1348
Ferry (Caddo) Lake, Tex. and La. See Cypress Bayou.
Fifteen-foot rock, San Francisco Harbor, Cal., examination and survey....... x, 834
Filtration plant, Washington Aqueduct, D. C. See Washington.
Finance (steamship), wreck of ...............................                                     ....... , 164, 1099
Finders, range and position. See Fortifications.
Finns Point, Delaware River, wreck near................... ......                                         .. . , 198, 1153
Fire control at fortifications. See Fortifications.
Fishing Creek, N. C., improvement of. ..............                               ............. I, 290; in, 1274
Fish traps, or weirs:
     In Puget Sound, Wash., inspection, etc., of ....................                                       , 879; nxi, 2253
     Permits for construction of-.-.............................                              ..............            I, 920
Fivemile River Harbor, Conn., improvement of ....... . . . . . . ............                                    , 118, 1048
Flag River, Wis. See Port Wing Harbor.
Flat Lake, La. See Grand River.
Fleming Key, Fla., wreck in Man-of-War Harbor........... ................                                               , 385
Flint River, Ga., improvement of ...................................                                        I, 394; I, 1391
Florida, water hyacinths in.....................                           .................                I, 383; Ii, 1383
Florida East Coast Railway Co., basin at Miami. Fla. See Biscayne Bay.
          9091--ENG 1909-2
                                                                   INDEX.

Flushing Bay, N. Y.:                                                                                                                         Page.
     Improvement of .......                        .............................                                            I, 132, 136, 1066
     W reck in...............................................                                                      ........ I, 157, 1090
Fond du Lac Harbor, Wis. See Fox River.
Foreign possessions. See Alaska and Insular possessions.
Fore River, Portland, Me. See Portland Harbor.
Fore (Weymouth) River, Mass. See Weymouth River.
Forked Deer River, Tenn., improvement of ...................                                                          I, 582, 583; 11, 1676
Fort Caswell, N. C., wrecks near ...........                                             .................                         .....    I, 315
Fort Crockett, Galveston, Tex., sea wall, embankment, and fill..... I, 496; n, 1515
Fortifications:
     Appropriations............ ...............................                                                                          I, 11, 19
     Batteries........................................ .................                                                             , 10, 11, 12
     Batteries in insular possessions.............                                                  ..................                        r, 17
     Board of Engineers, The .............................                               .......................                              I, 10
     Board on Fortifications or other Defenses (Endicott Board) .................                                                             I, 10
     Electrical installations ...............................................                                                                 I, 13
     Electrical installations, insular possessions ................................                                                           I, 18
     Emplacements, modernizing the older..........                                                ...................                         I, 13
     Estimates of appropriations required .........................................                                                           I, 23
     Fire control.......          .................................. ..................                                                         , 13
     Fire control at batteries in insular possessions ...........................                                                             I, 18
     General statement and progress of work .................................                                                                 I, 10
     National Coast Defense Board ...........................................                                                                 I, 10
     Preservation and repair of .........................................                                                                     I, 14
     Preservation and repair of torpedo structures.............................. I, 17
     Preservation and repair of fortifications in insular possessions ............                                                            1, 18
     Preservation and repair of torpedo-defense structures in insular possessions. I, 19
     Projects........................................                                         ...              ...         .....              I, 10
     Repairs and protection at defenses of Charleston, Pensacola, Mobile, and
        New Orleans .......                             .......                         ................................. ..... ....... I, 15
     Reserve lights ............               ..............................................                                                 I, 16
     Searchlights ...........                            ..................                               ...................                 I, 14
     Searchlights, insular possessions.........................................                                                               I, 18
     Sea walls and embankments................................................                                                                 , 16
     Sea walls, defenses of Galveston, Tex ......................                                                       I, 16, 496; 11, 1515
     Sites............. .................................................                                                                     I, 14
     Sites, insular possessions, procurement of ...............................                                                               I, 18
     Submarine mines .....................................................                                                                     , 17
     Submarine mines, insular possessions ..................                                              ................                    I, 18
     Supplies for seacoast defenses..........................................                                                                 I, 19
     Supplies for seacoast defenses, insular possessions.........................                                                             I, 19
Fort Leavenworth, Kans., engineer depot...........                                             ................                   ..      , 24, 26
Fort Mason, Cal., engineer depot...........                                       ......... ...........                            I, 24, 25, 26
Fort Mott, N. J., wreck near........                                   .........................                                   I, 198, 1152
Fort Pierre, S. Dak. See Missouri River.
Fort Point channel, Boston, Mass. See Boston Harbor.
Fort Riley Military Reservation, Kans., examination for protection of bank
  line of Republican River in front of...............................                                                          I, 582; in. 1674
Fort Snelling, Minn., bridge across Mississippi River to St. Paul.... I, 948; In, 2515
1E)x River, Wis.:
     Improvement of ...............                                ..................                              ...... I, 704; 11, 1979
     Improvement below Depere, including Green Bay Harbor..... I, 687; Ii, 1950
     Operating and care of locks and dams......................                                                                I, 706; 11, 1981
Frankfort Harbor, Mich., improvement of ......................                                                                 I, 749; n, 2051
Franklin, La., improvement of waterway to Mermentau.............. I, 451; I, 1467
French Broad River, Tenn., improvement of .......................                                                              I, 601; I, 1709

                                             G.
Gaging. See Gauging.
Galena River, Ill.:
     Operating and care of lock and dam...........................                I, 560; 11, 1639
     Regulations to govern operation of drawbridges........................... , 912
Galleries, cable. See Fortifications.
Galveston, Tex., engineering district, operation of dredge boats............ n, 1516
Galveston and Brazos Canal, Tex.:
  L Improvement ofT....               ......   .. ..           ........ I, 478, 486, 487; 1i, 1507
       Operating and care.........                               ..........                .............                  1, 491; n, 1511
                                                              INDEX.                                                               XIX

Galveston Bay and Harbor, Tex.:                                                                                                     Page.
    See also Galveston and Brazos Canal.
    Construction of sea wall, embankment, and fill at Fort Crockett and of sea
      wall from Thirty-ninth to Forty-fifth streets ........                                                  ..... I, 496; Ii, 1515
    Defenses of (see also construction of sea wall, supra) -.................                                                  I, 10, 16
    Dredges in Galveston engineering district, operation of...............                                 ---         ---        , 1516
    Improvement of channel across Hanna reef, Ladies Pass.... I, 478, 479; 11, 1501
    Improvement of Galveston channel from inner bar to Fifty-sixth
      street------------------------------------------......................................................          I, 471; in, 1491
    Improvement of Galveston-Texas City channel......                                                 .......         I, 473; In, 1494
    Improvement of harbor entrance, including dredge construction,
                                                                                                             I, 469, 1154; ii, 1488
    Improvement of Port Bolivar channel-...-......---............                                                     I, 474; ni, 1495
    Improvement of waterway to Houston......................... I, 475; IT, 1496
    Improvement of West Galveston Bay and                                                   Brazos River Canal,
                                                                                                      I, 478, 486, 487; i, 1507
    Operating and care of Morgan Canal........................... I, 477; I, 1501
Gasconade River, Mo., improvement of. ...................
Gascondy, Mo. See Gasconade River.
                                                                                                      .......      . I, 580; in,     1672

Gauging:
    Columbia River, Oreg. and Wash.............................                                                      I, 870; i, 2243
    Hydrological observations, Ottertail Lake and River and Red Lake and
      Red Lake River, Minn., and Big Stone Lake and Lake Traverse, Minn.
      and S. Dak               ..........................................                                     ....    I, 573; II, 1652
    Michigan Lake, variations in surface level on east shore .................                                                     i, 723
    Mississippi River and principal tributaries....................
    Northern and Northwestern Lakes, levels............... I, 939; ni, 2477, 2499
                                                                                                                      I, 573; i,     1653
Gedney channel, New York Harbor, N. Y. See New York Harbor.
Genesee River, N. Y. See Charlotte Harbor.
George Lake, St. Johns River, Fla. See Volusia bar.
Georgetown Harbor, D. C. See Washington.
Georgetown Harbor, S. C. See Winyah Bay.
Gladstone Harbor, Mich., improvement of .......................                                                       I, 684; ii, 1947
Glencove Harbor, N. Y., improvement of. ......................                                                      I, 132, 135, 1065
Gloucester Harbor, Mass.:
    Examination and survey............................................                                                                , 78
    Improvement of ..................................                                                    ..... ......        I, 54, 985
Gosport Harbor, N. H. See Isles of Shoals Harbor.
Government Printing Office, Washington, D. C., telegraph line. See Public
  buildings and grounds.
Government telegraph line, Washington, D.C. See Public buildings and grounds.
Governors Island, New York Harbor, N. Y., enlargement of, etc...... I, 163, 1097
Gowanus Bay, N. Y., improvement of ...............................                                                         , 162, 1095
Granby, S. C. See Congaree River.
Grand Calumet River, Ill. and Ind. See Calumet River.
Grand Haven Harbor, Mich., improvement of ..................                                                          I, 732; i, 2030
Grand Lake, Mermentau River, La. See Mermentau River.
Grand Marais, Mich., improvement of harbor of refuge .............                                                    I, 681; i, 1937
Grand Marais, Minn., improvement of harbor.......................                                                     I, 658; i, 1899
Grand Rapids, Wabash River, lock and dam. See Wabash River.
Grand River, La., improvement of................................
Grand River, Mich.:
                                                                                                                      I, 445;IT,     1460

    See also Grand Haven Harbor.
    Improvement of......................                                               ..............                   , 734; II, 2033
Grand River, Ohio. See Fairport Harbor.
Grand View, N. Y. See Hudson River.
Grays Harbor, Wash.:
    Improvement of entrance..............                                   ..................                        I, 873; xIn, 2246
    Improvement of, between Aberdeen and the entrance, including dredge
      construction.......................................... I, 875; mI, 2211, 2250
Grays River, Wash., improvement of................................. I, 869; Ii, 2242
Great Kanawha River, W. Va. See Kanawha River.
Great Lakes. See Northern and Northwestern Lakes.
Great Pedee River, S. C.:
    Examination and survey from Georgetown to Pedee Station ..............                                                         I, 333
    Improvement of ...... .........                   ......................                      ..........           I, 319; ii, 1304
    Wreck in....................................................                                                       I, 333; , 1317
Great Salt Pond, Block Island, R. I., improvement of....................                                                 I, 98, 1023
XX                                                              INDEX.

                                                                                                    Page.
Great Sodus Bay, N. Y., improvement of harbor .....................                    I, 808; In, 2167
Great South Bay, N. Y., improvement of.............................                          I, 146, 1076
Green Bay Harbor, Wis.:
    Improvement of.....           -....................................                 I, 687; 11, 1950
    Wreck in Eagle Harbor .................................                              I, 706; i, 1986
Green Jacket shoal, Providence River, R. I., removal of .......                     . I, 90, 91, 1016
Green River, Ky.:
    Improvement above mouth of Big Barren River .................. I, 655; i, 1883
    Operating and care of locks and dams............................. I, 656; 11, 1884
Greenwich Harbor, Conn., improvement of.........................                     I, 118, 122, 1049
Grounds, public, District of Columbia. ..-...                    ..................    I, 929; In, 2331
Guadalupe River, Tex., improvement of, from Victoria to Aransas Pass-Pass
  Cavallo channel         ..........................................
                        -......                                                          I, 489; 11, 1509
Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, defenses of.......................................                            I, 17
Gulf of Mexico, survey for 14-foot waterway to St. Louis, Mo., and Lockport
  (Chicago), Ill., including report on water power and land drainage.........                       , 908
Gulfport Harbor, Miss.:
    Diversion of improvement funds to construction of dredge for coast har-
      bors............................... .........................-                     I, 438; 11, 1436
    Improvement of channel to Ship Island Harbor......... .......                       I, 432; 11, 1432
Gulf Stream (steamship), wreck of ..........................                          ... I, 224, 1183
Gull Lake, Minn., reservoir dam. See Mississippi River reservoirs.
Gun batteries. See Fortifications.
Gut, The, Lake Champlain, Vt. See Champlain Lake.

                                                                    H.

Hales bar, Tennessee River, lock and dam. See Tennessee River.
Half Moon Shoal, Nantucket Sound, Mass., wreck in..................... I, 100, 1024
Hall, Horatio (steamer), wreck of-..................                                     ..................                      I, 99, 1024
Hampton Roads, Va.:
     Construction of piers and dredging at Jamestown Exposition grounds.. I, 271, 1248
     Defenses of...........................                          ..........            .......... ............                       I, 10
     Improvement of ..................                         ......... ........................                              , 277, 1255
     Improvement of approaches to Norfolk Harbor............ I, 273, 274, 1251, 1252
     W reck in...... ..........             ..............................                                     .......        I, 288, 1271
Handkerchief Shoal, Nantucket Sound, Mass., wreck in .................                                                            1, 99,1024
Hanna reef, Ladies Pass, Tex., improvement of channel.......... I, 478, 479; 11, 1501
Harbor Beach, Mich., improvement of harbor of refuge.............                                                       I, 768; ii, 2101
Harbor Cove, Gloucester, Mass. See Gloucester Harbor.
Harbor lines, establishment of ...-...........                           ............                    ..............                I, 910
Harbors and rivers. See Rivers and harbors.
Harlem (Bronx) Kills, N. Y. See Harlem River.
Harlem River, N. Y., improvement of ...........                                           ...............                     I, 141, 1070
Harlingen, Tex., examination and survey of Arroyo Colorado to Point Isabel, on
   Laguna Madre ..................                 ................................                                      .......       I, 497
Harlowe Creek, N. C., waterway via. See Newbern-Beaufort waterway.
Havre de Grace, Md. See Susquehanna River.
Hawaiian Islands:
     Defenses of ..................                  ... ..........                    .....       ...           ....        I, 17, 18, 19
     Ililo Harbor, improvement of.................................                                                     I, 895; II, 2270
     Honolulu Harbor, improvement of.............................                                                      I, 894; III, 2267
     Honolulu Harbor, reclamation of Quarantine Island............. I, 895; Ii, 2270
     Pearl Harbor, improvement of.................................                                                     I, 893; nI, 2267
Hay Lake channel, St. Marys River, Mich.:
     Improvement of. ................                      .........              .................                     I, 760; 11, 2092
     Improvement of channels in waters connecting Great Lakes...... I, 753; 11, 2059
Haze (sloop), wreck of. .........             .....-.......... ...... ........ .........                                      I, 288, 1271
Hedges, H. T. (schooner), wreck of ............                             : ...........                  .........          I, 157, 1089
Hell Gate, East River, N. Y. See East River.
Hempstead Harbor (north shore of Long Island), N. Y. See also Glencove
   Harbor.
Henderson, Annie L. (schooner), wreck of ...............                                            ..............                 I, 47, 979
Hennepin Canal, Ill, See Illinois and Mississippi Canal.
Hereford Inlet, N. J., wreck at entrance...................                                                  ........          , 224, 1183
Itiggie, J. . (tug), wreck of . ....... .... ................... .........                                              I, 780:n , 2119
                                                                INDEX.                                                                XXI

Highway bridges, Potomac River, Washington, D. C.:                                                                                     Page.
     Aqueduct Bridge.........-................................. ... I, 921; III, 2301
     Replacing Long Bridge .......................................                                                       I, 923; IIn, 2303
     Roadway at tidal reservoir, Potomac Park, D. C...--..-.....                                                        i, 248, 250, 1211
Highways. See Roads.
Hill, Cecelia (steamer), wreck of................................                                                          I, 706; ii, 1986
Hillsboro Bay and River, Fla.:
     Examination and survey of bay from turning basin to head of the estuary
       toward Ybor........................................................                                                             I, 385
     Improvement of..............................................                                                          I, 377; n, 1376
     Wrecks in river. ............ ....................................                                                       . Ir, 384, 385
Hilo Harbor, Hawaii, improvement of.........................                                                             I, 895; nr. 2270
Hingham Harbor, Mass., improvement of ................................                                                             I, 70, 998
Hiawassee River, Tenn., improvement of ........................                                                  I, 602, 603; In, 1712
Holland Harbor, Mich., improvement of.......-.................                                                      .. I, 730; Ti, 2026
Holmes River, Fla., improvement of.................................                                                        I, 398; in, 1396
Holston River, Tenn., improvement of . ......................                                                    i, 602, 605; ii, 1714
Homeward Bound (barge), wreck of....................................                                                           i, 224, 1183
Hornochitto River, Miss., improvement of ..........                                     ...............                    I, 464; I, 1481
Honolulu Harbor, Hawaii:
     Defenses of...........................                             ..........            ...       ............ I, 17, 18, 19
     Improvement of..............................................                                                        I, 894; ir, 2267
     Reclamation of Quarantine Island ........... ..... . . . . . . . . . .... I, 895; ni, 2270
Hookton, Cal. See Humboldt Harbor.
Hoquarten Slough, Oreg. See Tillamook Bay.
Horn Island -Harborand Pass, Miss.:
     Improvement of harbor (see Pascagoula River)...................... i, 425; 1426
     Improvement of pass..........................................                                                         I, 430; n, 1430
Horseleg Shoals, Coosa River, Ga.. examination and survey.....-............. 1, 409
Horse Shoe Shoal, Nantucket Sound., Mass., wreck at eastern end of.... I, 100, 1024
Hospital Point, Norfolk Harbor, Va., removal of...........-.                                                 I, 273, 274, 1251, 1252
Housatonic River, Conn.:
     See also Milford Harbor.
     Improvement of..                       -.......... ..............               ............              ........ I, 113, 1041
Housatonic (steamer), wreck of......................................                                                        , 332; i , 1315
Houston, Tex., waterway to Galveston. See Galveston Bay and Harbor
Howard TTniversity reservoir, Washington Aqueduct, D. C. See Washington.
Hudson River, N. Y.:
     See also New York Bay and Harbor.
     Harbor lines at Troy ............ ... ................                                       ....       ...............            I, 910
     Improvement of.................                          ....       ...........           ...............                 I, 148, 1078
     New York Harbor, reef off Pier A. See New York Harbor.
     Peekskill Harbor. See Peekskill Harbor.
     Rondout Harbor. See Rondout Harbor.
     Saugerties Harbor. See Saugerties Harbor.
     Stonehouse bar, New Baltimore, removal of...................                                                  ...... I, 148, 1078
     Stuyvesant Harbor. See Stuyvesant Harbor.
     Tarrytown Harbor. See Tarrytown Harbor.
     Wrecks in...--.......................-............-.........                                                     I, 157, 1089, 1090
Humboldt Bay and Harbor, Cal., improvement of. .............                                                              I, 832; IuI, 2196
Huntington Harbor, N. Y., improvement of................                                                   .... . I, 132, 134, 1064
Huron Harbor, Ohio, improvement of-.............................                                                           I, 785; In, 2127
Huron Lake:
     See also Northern and Northwestern Lakes.
     Wrecks off Lexington, Mich .......                                  ......... ..            .........             . I, 780; n, 2119
Hutchinson River (East Chester Creek), N. Y. See East Chester Creek.
Hyacinths, water, removal of:
     From Florida waters................................                                        ...........                I, 383; in, 1383
     From Louisiana waters .........                    ............................                                       I, 466; II, 1484
     From Texas waters................................................ I, 477; is, 1500
Hyannis Harbor, Mass., improvement of harbor of refuge at..............                                                          I, 78, 1005
Hydraulic dredges:
     Construction of. See Dredge boats.
     Performances of ...............                     ........................................                                      I, 899
Hydraulic mining in California. See California D4bris Commission.
Hydraulics. See Water levels.
Hydrology. See Water levels.
XXII                                                        INDEX.

                                                                 I.                                                          Page.
Illinois and Mississippi Canal, Ill.:
      Construction of, with descriptive and historical sketch.......... I, 720; In, 2010
     Improvement of pool between Locks 29 and 35, Rock River. .... I, 559; 11, 1638
     Operating and care of Milan section----------... --------- ----..                                     I, 559; n, 1637
     Operating and care of Eastern section---...-...--- -.----...-....                                     I, 722; n, 2014
Illinois River, Ill.:
     Improvement of (below Copperas Creek) .-.--......-----... -                                    .-. I, 718; ii, 2005
      Improvement of (Copperas Creek to La Salle)--....-.-----                                     -..       , 719; n, 2006
      Operating and care of locks and dams-...--------------------..                                       I, 720; In, 2008
      Operating snag boats and dredge boats........--                  ......--.........                   I, 553; II, 1617
      Survey for 14-foot waterway from Lockport (Chicago), Ill., to St. Louis,
        Mo., and mouth of the Mississippi, including report on water power and
        land drainage ...........................                      ....... ...................                     I, 908
Illinois (dredge), wreck of....----------.......---------........------...............----------.. i, 718; i, 2003
Indiana chute, Falls of Ohio River, improvement of ...-...........                                         I, 645; In, 1857
Indiana Harbor, Ind., examination and survey...--                           .........--............--... I, 718
Indian River, Fla.:
      Examination of, from Fort Pierce to Sewalls Point.......................                                         I, 386
      Improvement of------......------........-------............------..............--------------- I, 366; In, 1363
"Inland Route" and connecting waters between Cheboygan and Conway,
   Mich., to govern floating of loose logs...             --------------------------------- I, 912
Inland waterways. See Canals and Waterways.
Inside routes. See Canals and Waterways.
Insular possessions:
      See also Alaska.
      Defenses of...............................----------------------------.............---......               , 17, 18, 19
      Hilo Harbor, Hawaii, improvement of ..-.......................                                        , 895; in, 2070
      Honolulu Harbor, Hawaii, improvement of...-.................. I, 894; III, 2267
      Honolulu Harbor, Hawaii, reclamation of Quarantine Island.... I, 895; In, 2270
      Pearl Harbor, Hawaii, improvement of ....................                              .....        I, 893; in, 2267
      Porto Rico, erection of structures in navigable waters of............. ..... I, 912
      San Juan Harbor, P. R., improvement of.........-..........-... I, 897; in, 2273
International Commission, Permanent, of Congresses of Navigation..---------..........                                    , 910
Invincible rocks, San Francisco Harbor, Cal., examination and survey........ I, 834
Iron Age (steamer), wreck of.....---------------------------------- I, 780; ii, 2020
Irwin, E. G. (schooner), wreck of...........------..............------------------.....--------...              I, 272, 1250
Isabel, Point, Tex., examination and survey of Arroyo Colorado from Harlingen
   to, on Laguna Madre--------.........----------..............-----------...........----------......-------.......     , 497
Island End River, Mass. See Mystic River.
Island possessions. See Insular possessions.
Isles of Shoals Harbor, Me. and N. H.:
      Examination and survey........ ......................                                .................              I, 48
      Improvement of..................................................                                             I, 45, 977
Istokpoga Creek, Fla. See Kissimmee River.

                                                                       J.
Jacksonville, Fla.:
     See also St. Johns River.
     Improvement of St. Johns River opposite .......................                                                 r, 362; iI, 1358
Jacksonville, N. C., examination and survey of New River up to-..-.....-..- . I, 315
Jamaica Bay, N. Y., examination and survey, including entrance at Rockaway
   Inlet and waters having outlet in Dead Horse Inlet.........................                                                  I, 158
James River, Va.:
     See also Hampton Roads.
     Construction of permanent landing pier at Jamestown Island........ I, 271, 1248
     Improvement of .............                         ........         ...........................                   I, 269, 1242
     Wreck near Nansemond River light ................................                                                   I, 288, 1271
Jamestown Exposition, Va., construction of piers and dredging in connection
   with ------.........------------..................................--------------------------.....--------........     I, 271, 1248
Jamestown Island, James River, Va. See James River.
Jefferson, Tex. See Cypress Bayou.
Jekyl Creek, Ga., waterway via. See Savannah-Fernandina waterway.
Johnsons Bayou, La., improvement of.............................                                                     I, 497; In, 1525
Johnsons Creek, or River, Conn. See Bridgeport Harbor.
Joint resolutions of 60th Congress, 2d session, and 61st Congress, 1st session, affect-
   ing Corps of Engineers ............. .......................                                              ..... ...... i , 2527
                                                             INDEX.                                                             XXIII

                                                                                                                                Page,
Jordan River, Miss., improvement of ........             ..................... , 434; Ii, 1433
Judith, Point, R. I.:
    Construction of harbor of refuge.............       ... ....................      I, 93, 1019
    Examination of harbor of refuge, with plan and estimate for improvement.. I, 100
    Improvement of pond entrance        -..............                               I, 96, 102.1
                                                                                  ...............
                                                  K.
Kalamazoo River, Mich.:
    Improvement of...............................    .... ...  . I, 728; ii, 2024
    Regulations to govern operation of drawbridges over, between Douglas
         and Saugatuck, Mich .................................................                                                   , 912
Kampsville lock and dam, Illinois River, Ill. See Illinois River.
Kanawha River, W. Va.:
    Improvement of...........................                                ...................                    , 635; i, 1801
    Operating and care of locks and dams .........................                                                 I, 635; I, 1802
Kansas River, Kans., harbor lines at .............................                        .      ...                , 577; In, 1665
Karquines (Carquinez) Strait, Cal., examination and survey from San Francisco
                                                                                                     ................ , 834
  Bay to Stockton, including.............................
Kate (barge), wreck of................................
Kennebec River, Me.:
                                                                                             ....         . ....         I, 157, 1089
    Defenses of .............................                               ................                ...........        . I, 10
    Improvement of.....................................                                                    -............. 1, 39, 972
Kenosha Harbor, Wis., improvement of .............................                                                 I, 702; In, 1975
Kentucky River, Ky.:
    Improvement of ...............                       ..............................                            I, 641; in, 1833
    Operating and care of locks and dams ..........................
Keokuk (Des Moines Rapids) Canal and dry dock, Miissssippi River. See
                                                                                                                   I, 643; i,     1836
  Mississippi River.
Kewaunee Harbor, Wis., improvement of.........................                                                     I, 691; in, 1959
Keweenaw Bay-Lake Superior waterway, Mich., improvement and care.... I, 674,
                                                                                                                        677; i, 1925
Keweenaw Canal, Mich. See Keweenaw Bay-Lake Superior waterway.
Keweenaw Point waterway, Mich. See Keweenaw Bay-Lake Superior water-
way.
Keyport Harbor, N. J., improvement of............................                                                         , 174, 1115
Key West Harbor, Fla.:
    Defenses of ...........................................................                                                       I, 10
     Improvement of-------.....-----...------............--------......--------.......-----........ I, 369; in, 1366
Kill van Kull, N. Y. and N. J., improvement of Staten Island-New Jersey
               ----------------------------------------------------.....
  Channel .................                                                                                                , 169, 1111
King County, Wash, See Puget Sound-Lake Washington waterway.
Kings Mountain battle ground, S. C., erection of monument......... , 950; I, 2521
Kingston, R. I. See Point Judith Harbor and Pond.
Kinnikinnick River, Wis. See Milwaukee Harbor.
Kissimmee Lake and River, Fla., improvement of ..................                                                   I, 370; in, 1368
Kuhului Harbor, Hawaii, harbor lines in.....-..........                                               ...      ........... I, 911

                                                                 L.

La Conner, Wash. See Swinomish Slough.
Ladies Pass, Tex., improvement of channel across Hanna reef... I, 478, 479; in, 1501
Lafayette, La., examination and survey of Bayou Vermilion to...............                                      1, 469
Lafourche Bayou, La., improvement of....                                ........................      I, 465; I, 1482
Lagrange Bayou, Fla. See Holmes River.
Lagrange lock and dam, Illinois River, Ill. See Illinois River.
Laguna Madre, Tex., examination and survey from Harlingen, on Arroyo
  Colorado, to Point Isabel ....... .........................................                                    I, 497
Lakes, Great. See Northern and Northwestern Lakes.
Lake Survey. See Northern and Northwestern Lakes.
Lake Washington Canal, Wash. See Washington Lake.
L'Anguille River, Ark., improvement of.............                                ............ I, 545, 546; In, 1590
Larchmont Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ............................                                       , 127, 1057
La Trappe River, Md., improvement of. ...........................                                   I, 231, 240, 1201
Lavaca Bay, Tex., examination and survey of channel from Pass Cavallo to
  Port Lavaca.....................................................                                               I, 497
Laws of 60th Congress, 2d session, and 61st Congress, 1st session, affecting
  Corps of Engineers.......                     .............................                      ........ Iii, 2527
XXIV                                                        INDEX.

                                                                                                                              Page.
Leaf River, Miss., improvement of. -.........................I,427, 428; n, 1428
Leavenworth, Fort, Kans., engineer depot--.............................. I,26
Leech Lake, Minn. See Mississippi River reservoirs.
Lee Slough, Apalachicola River, Fla. See Apalachicola River.
Legislation of 60th Congress, 2d session, and 61st Congress, 1st session, affecting
  Corps of Engineers.........................                                        .....     n......2527
                                                                                               III,
Lemon Creek, N. Y. (see Staten Island-New Jersey channel)............. I,169, 1111
Leonardtown Harbor, Md. See Breton Bay.
Leonora, wreck of ..........................                                ....     I,332; i, 1317
                                                                   .....................
Levels, water. See Water levels.
Levisa Fork, Big Sandy River, Ky., improvement of.................... I,638; n, 1825
Lewes, Del., iron pier in Delaware Bay, maintenance and repair.......                      I,195, 1151
Lewis River, Wash., improvement of .....................                        I,866, 867; in, 2241
Lexington, Mich., wreck off.......................................                   i, 780; ii, 2119
Life-saving exhibit, Jamestown Exposition, Va., dredging of Bush Creek for
  accommodation of............................................                             I, 271, 1248
Lillie (schooner), wreck of.........                       ............................... I, 797; In,2141
Lingo, John A. (flat boat), wreck of................................                                                      , 198, 1153
Little Annemessex River, Md. See Crisfield Harbor.
Little Bay de Noc, Mich. See Gladstone Harbor.
Little Black River, Ark. and Mo., examination of ................                                             ...........       I,548
Little D'Arbonne Bayou, La. See D'Arbonne Bayou.
Little Harbor, Woods Hole, Mass. See Woods Hole Harbor.
Little Harbor, N. H., improvement of harbor of refuge................... I,47, 978
Little Kanawha River, W. Va.:
     Improvement of.........................................                                                         I,631; in,1796
     Operating and care of locks and dams........... ...........                                                      , 634; ni,1798
Little Mud River, Ga., waterway via. See Savannah-Fernandina waterway.
Little Narragansett Bay, R. I. and Conn. See Pawcatuck River.
Little Pass, Soda Lake, La. See Cypress Bayou.
Little Pedee River, S. C., improvement of ..................                                                 I,315, 317; in,1302
Little Pigeon River, Tenn., improvement of . . ....................                                                  I, 601; is, 1709
Little River (part of Red River), La. See Red River below Fulton.
Little Sarasota Bay, Fla. See Sarasota Bay.
Little Sodus Bay, N. Y., improvement of harbor...... .........                                              . . I,809; i, 21.68
Little Tallahatchie River, Miss. See Tallahatchie River.
Little Tennessee River, Tenn. (see Tennessee River above Chattanooga) I, 593; n, 1689
Livingstone Channel, Detroit River, Mich. See Detroit River.
Lockport, Ill., survey for 14-foot waterway to St. Louis, Mo., and mouth of the
  Mississippi........................................................                                                           I,908
Locks. See Canals, Rivers and harbors, and Waterways.
Lockwood, Florence I. (schooner), wreck of .........................                                                     I,223, 1182
Log booms, permits for construction of. .............                                       .. ..............                   I,920
Logs, removal of, from Mackey Creek, N. C......................... I,288, 1271
Long Bridge, Potomac River, Washington, D. C., highway bridge, replac-
  ing.....................................                                ......... ............                   I,923; III, 2303
Long Cove, Me., examination and survey of Penobscot Bay from Macks Point
  to Cape Jellison........                         ......................         .......................                         I,48
Long Island Sound, N. Y. and Conn.:
     Defenses of eastern entrance ........................................                                                        I,10
     Wreck in, off Peacock Point........................                                                .............. , 157, 1090
Long Tom River, Oreg. See Willamette River above Portland.
Lorain Harbor, Ohio, improvement of ............................ ,787; n1,2129
Los Angeles River, Cal. See Wilmington Harbor.
Louisa, Ky. See Big Sandy River.
Louisiana, State of, water hyacinths in.................
Louisville, Ky. See Louisville and Portland Canal.
                                                                                             ...........                  11,
                                                                                                                     I,466;       1484

Louisville and Portland Canal, Ky.:
     Enlargement of .......                      ..............                  ..........................          I,644; nr,1857
     Operating and care.......................................                                                       I,649; In,1871
Lowell, Wash., examination and survey of Snohomish River up to.............. I,893
Lower Chipola River, Fla., improvement of....................                                                        I,390; nr,   1389
Lubec Channel, Me., improvement of.................................                                                          , 30, 965
Ludington Harbor, Mich., improvement of..............                                           ........             I, 742; is, 2042
Lumberton Branch, Rancocas River, N.:J. See Rancocas River.
                                                              INDEX.                                                            XXV


Lynch River, S. C., improvement of............ ...... ..........
Lynn Harbor, Mass., improvement of ................................
                                                                                                                 1,            Page.
                                                                                                                    319; ii, 1303
                                                                                                                       r, 56, 987

                                                              M.
Mackey Creek, N. C.:
    Regulations to govern operation of drawbridge .......... . ..........                                                   ..-. I, 912
    Wreck in ........ .              ...... .......                  .................                        ..      . I, 288, 1271
McClellanville, S. C., improvement of waterway to Charleston-........ I, 329; Ii, 1312
Macon Bayou, La., improvement of .........                                  .............                    I, 519, 521; 11, 1561
Madre, Laguna, Tex., examination and survey from Harlingen, on Arroyo Colo-
rado, to Point Isabel ....................................................                                                       I, 497
Mail Dock, Bonita Channel, San Francisco Harbor, Cal., examination and survey
of rocks near. ..............................................................                                                    I, 834
Main Ship Channel, New York Harbor, N. Y. See New York Harbor.
Malden River, Mass., improvement of .                                  .............       ...... - ...... .-. 1, 57, 58, 988
Mall, the, Washington, D. C. See Public buildings and grounds.
Mamaroneck Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ............                                            ..........               I, 126, 1057
Manasquan River, N. J., improvement of................................                                                    I, 1.86, 1129
Manatee River, Fla., improvement of .............................                                                   I, 375; ni, 1373
Manchac Bayou, La., improvement of...........................                                                  , 454, 458; ii, 1475
Mandeville, La. See Pontchartrain Lake.
Manhattan Borough, N. Y. See New York Harbor.
Manila Bay, Philippine Islands, defenses of .........                                   ... ........ . ...                I, 17, 18, 19
Manistee Harbor and River, Mich., improvement of harbor...... .... .,                                                    744; in, 2046
Manistique Harbor, Mich., improvement of ...............                                                  ...... I, 683; iI, 1945
Manitowoc Harbor, Wis.:
     Harbor lines at Manitowoc .................................................                                                  I, 911
     Improvement of...............................................                                                    I, 693; Ii, 1962
Man-of-War Harbor, Fla., wreck in .........................................                                                       I, 385
Manokin River, Md., improvement of ............................                                                   I, 231, 241, 1201
Mantua Creek, N. J.:
     Improvement of................................................                                                       I, 200, 1158
    Wreck in ...................                             ............................                                 I, 224, 1183
Maps and charts:
    Military and other.........                       .....................................                                       I, 945
    Northern and Northwestern Lakes ............................                                                     , 931; III, 2477
Marcushook, Pa., improvement of ice harbor in Delaware River .... I, 189, 195, 1150
Marquette Bay and Harbor, Mich.:
     Construction of harbor of refuge in bay......................
     Improvement of harbor......................................
                                                                                                                            11,
                                                                                                                       , 679;       1936
                                                                                                                      I, 677: 11, 1934
Marthas Vineyard, Mass. See Vineyard Haven Harbor.
Mason, Fort, Cal., engineer depot ..................................                                                      I, 24, 25, 26
Massachusetts Bay, Mass. See Boston Harbor.
Matagorda Bay, Tex.:
     Examination and survey from Pass Cavallo to Port O'Connor for harbor... I, 497
     Examination and survey of channel from Pass Cavallo to Port Lavaca .... I, 497
     Improvement of channel from Pass Cavallo to Aransas Pass...... I, 488; i, 1508
Matawan Creek, N. J. (see also Keyport Harbor), improvement of... I, 174, 176, 1117
Mattaponi River, Va., improvement of ............................                                                 I, 256, 257, 1224
Mattituck Harbor, N. Y., improvement of .........................                                                 I, 132, 133, 1063
Maumee Bay and River, Ohio. See Toledo Harbor.
Meherrin River, N. C., improvement of.........................                                                    ...      , 286, 1269
Memorials, statues, etc. See Statues, memorials, etc.
Menawa (schooner), wreck of...........................................                                                    I, 124, 1054
Menominee Harbor and River, Mich. and Wis., improvement of . ....                                                     , 685; n, 1948
Menominee River, Milwaukee, Wis. See Milwaukee Harbor.
Mermentau, La.              See Mermentau River.
Mermentau River, La.:
    Improvement of, including tributaries .....................                    , 460, 462; I, 1479
    Improvement of waterway to Franklin .......................                         I, 451; I, 1467
Merrimac River, Mass. (see also Newburyport Harbor):
    Examination and survey for locks and dams up to Haverhill.............                           I, 78
    Improvement of.................................                     ....... .......... I, 50, 983
Messer, Harry (schooner), wreck of ....................................                      I, 99, 1024
Mexico, Gulf of, survey for 14-foot waterway to St. Louis, Mo., and Lockport
 (Chicago), Ill., including report on water power and land drainage .........                      I, 908
XXVI                                               INDEX.

Miami. Fla. See Biscayne Bay.                                                                                Page.
Michigan City Harbor, Ind., improvement of ........................                              I, 716; II, 1999
Michigan Lake (see also Northern and Northwestern Lakes):
    Canal to Sturgeon Bay, improvement of, including harbor of refuge. s, 688; II, 1951
    Canal to Sturgeon Bay, operating and care ...................                        ... I, 690; n, 1957
    Datum plane at all harbors on western shore of ...........................                               I, 683
    Gillespie, dredge, operations in east-shore harbors................ I, 753; In, 2056
    Water levels on east shore, variations in ................................                              I, 723
    Waterway 14 feet deep from Lockport (Chicago), Ill., to St. Louis, Mo., and
        the Gulf, survey, including report on water power and land drainage... I, 908
    Wreck off Thirty-first street...................................                             I, 718; In, 2003
Middle Neebish channel, St. Marys River, Mich., improvement of... I, 760; In, 2092
Milan, Ill. See Illinois and Mississippi Canal.
Milford Harbor, Conn., improvement of..................................                               I, 111, 1040
Milford Haven, Va., improvement of harbor at ......................                                   I, 267, 1241
Mill Creek, or River, New Haven, Conn. See New Haven Harbor.
Mill Creek, Southport, Conn                        See Southport Harbor.
Miller Bay, Lake Winnebago, Wis. See Fox River.
Mill River, New Haven, Conn. See New Haven Harbor.
Mill River, Stamford, Conn. See Stamford Harbor.
Milwaukee Bay, Harbor, and River, Wis.:
    Improvement of, including harbor of refuge ....................                         .. , 698; In, 1970
    Improvement of inner harbor ......................................                            , 699; in, 1972
Mines, submarine. See Fortifications.
Mingo Creek, S. C., improvement of ..................                    ............            I, 323; II, 1306
Minim Creek-Estherville Canal, S. C., improvement of ..........                         I, 323, 326; In, 1307
Mining casemates. See Fortifications.
Mining, hydraulic, in California. See California Debris Commission.
Minneapolis, Minn. See Mississippi River.
Minnesota Point, harbor lines in Duluth-Superior Harbor, Minn. and Wis..... I, 911
Minnesota River, Minn., improvement of. ...........                      .... ......... I, 568; n, 1649
Mispillion River, Del., improvement of...........................                              I, 214, 217, 1175
Mission Bay rocks, San Francisco Harbor, Cal., examination and survey ...... I, 834
Mississippi coast, construction of dredge for harbors on..............                           I, 438; In, 1436
Mississippi River:
    Brainerd to Grand Rapids, Minn., improvement from....... I, 562, 564; I, 1644
     Cairo, Ill., to Head of Passes, improvement, surveys, etc................ I, 909;
                                                                                       III, 2641, 2676, 2843
    Cairo, Ill., to Missouri River, improvement from ...........                              . I, 550; I, 1598
     Cape Girardeau, Mo., to Head of Passes, levees............. I, 909; in, 2641, 2843
     Chicago (Lockport), Ill., to St. Louis, Mo., and the Gulf. See St. Louis,
        infra.
     Cubits Gap to Head of Passes, dredging shoals ............                        ....      I, 439; n, 1441
     Dams, between St. Paul and Minneapolis. See St. Paul, infra.
     Des Moines Rapids Canal and dry dock, operating and care...... I, 558; in, 1633
     Discharge measurements, including tributaries. See Gauging, infra.
     Dredge and snag boats above Missouri River, operation of ........ I, 553; in, 1617
     Dredge and snag boats below Missouri River, operation of......... I, 549; I, 1593
     Fort Snelling, Minn., bridge to St. Paul ........................                          I, 948; III, 2515
    Gauging, including tributaries........ ........                          .........           I, 573; i, 1653
    Grand Rapids to Brainerd, Minn., improvement from ....... I, 562, 564; in, 1644
     Gulf of Mexico to St. Louis, Mo., and Lockport (Chicago), Ill. See St.
        Louis, infra.
    Head of Passes to Cape Girardeau, Mo., levees............ I, 909; III, 2641, 2843
    Head of Passes to Cubits Gap, dredging shoals ..................... I, 439; i, 1441
    Head of Passes to headwaters, surveys from.......... I, 909; nin, 2641, 2676, 2843
    Head of Passes to Ohio River, improvement, surveys, etc ................                                I, 909;
                                                                                        iI, 2641, 2676, 2843
     Illinois and Mississippi Canal, Ill. See Illinois and Mississippi Canal.
    Illinois River, survey for 14-foot waterway from Lockport (Chicago), Ill., to
        St. Louis, Mo., and mouth of the Mississippi, including report on water
        power and land drainage...........................................                                    , 908
    Keokuk (Des Moines Rapids) Canal and dry dock, operating and
        care.......................................................                                 , 558: iT, 1633
     Levees, Head of Passes to Cape Girardeau, Mo............. I, 909; II, 2641,2843
     Lockport (Chicago), Ill., to St. Louis, Mo., and the Gulf. See St. Louis,
        infra.
                                                          INDEX.                                                        XXVII

Mississippi River-Continued.                                                                                  Page.
    Mexico, Gulf of, to St. Louis, Mo., and Lockport (Chicago), Ill. See St.
       Louis, infra.
    Michigan Lake to St. Louis, Mo , and the Gulf. See St. Louis, infra.
    Milan section of Illinois and Mississippi Canal, Ill., operation and
       care........................................................                             I, 559; IT, 1637
    Minneapolis, Minn., to St. Paul, improvement from........... .. , 560; II, 1641
    Minneapolis, Minn., to St. Paul, operating and care of Lock No. 2 I, 562; ii, 1643
    Missouri River, above, operation of snag and dredge boats....... I, 553; I, 1617
    Missouri River, below, removal of snags and wrecks...........                               I, 549; Ii, 1593
    Missouri River to Ohio River, improvement from ............... I, 550; i, 1598
    Missouri River to St. Paul, Minn., improvement from........... I, 554; In, 1621
    Moline, Ill., improvement at.............................                       .....     . I, 558;        1635    In,
    Moline, Ill., operating and care of lock......................                                , 559; iI, 1636
    Mouth to St. Louis, Mo., and Lockport (Chicago), Ill. See St. Louis, infra.
    New Orleans, La., defenses of.................                  .........................                  I, 10
    Ohio River to Head of Passes, improvement, surveys, etc ................                                i, 909;
                                                                                          nI, 2641, 2676, 2843
    Ohio River to Missouri River, improvement from................. I, 550; I, 1598
    Plaquemine Bayou, La., construction of lock_.................... I, 445; n, 1460
    Pokegama Falls, Minn., reservoir dam. See Reservoir dams, infra.
    Regulations governing navigation of Southwest Pass..................... I, 911
    Reservoir dams at headwaters, construction of.................... I, 562; I, 1644
    Reservoir dams at headwaters, operating and care ..............                              I, 565; II, 1646
    St. Louis, Mo., survey for 14-foot waterway from Lockport (Chicago), Ill.,
       to the Gulf, including report on water power and land drainage ........ I, 908
    St. Paul, Minn., bridge to Fort Snelling ..................                        ...... I, 948; in, 2515
    St. Paul, Minn., gauging ......................................                              I, 573;       1653     I,
     St. Paul, Minn., to Minneapolis, improvement from.............. I, 560;                                    1641    I,
    St. Paul, Minn., to Minneapolis, operating and care of Lock No. 2. I, 562; I, 1643
    St. Paul, Minn., to Missouri River, improvement from........... I, 554;                                     1621    TI,
    Snag and dredge boats above Missouri River, operation of ....... I, 553; is, 1617
     Snags and wrecks below Missouri River, removal of .............                               , 549; In, 1593
     Snelling, Fort, Minn., bridge to St. Paul............... .....                             I, 948; In, 2515
     South Pass, examinations and surveys .........
     South Pass, maintenance and improvement of channel ..........
                                                                          ...........              , 444;       1459
                                                                                                 I, 442; II, 1451
                                                                                                                        I,
     Southwest Pass, improvement of, including shoals between Cubits Gap and
        Head of Passes.................................................. I, 439; I, 1441
     Vicksburg Harbor, Miss., improvement of ......................                              I, 524; i, 1564
     Water-level observations, including tributaries-....................                              I, 573, 909;
                                                                                      ii, 1653; nII, 2641, 2843
     Wrecks, etc., above Missouri River, removal of ...............                                 , 553; nt, 1617
     Wrecks, etc., below Missouri River, removal of ...............                              I, 549; In, 1593
Mississippi River Commission:
     Improvement of Mississippi River. ..............                          , 909; III, 2641, 2676, 2843
     Levees, Head of Passes to Cape Girardeau, Mo............. I, 909; i, 2641, 2843
     Survey for waterway from Lockport, Ill., to St. Louis, Mo., and the Gulf... I, 908
Mississippi Sound, Miss. and Ala.:
     Dredge boat for harbors on coast of Mississippi. See Mississippi State.
     Gulfport-Ship Island Harbor channel, and Ship Island Pass. See Gulfport
        Harbor.
     Horn Island Harbor. See Pascagoula River.
     Horn Island Pass. See Horn Island Pass.
Mississippi, State of, construction of dredge for harbors on coast of.... I, 438; I, 1436
Missouri River:
     Contributions from private agencies for improvement at Elwood,
          Kans...................                          ...............              I, 29, 577, 578; In, 1655, 1661
   Examinatiosr and survey up to Sioux City, Iowa ...........                                                ...   .......    I, 582
   Improvement of.................                          ........................                                , 573; an, 1655
   Harbor lines at Omaha, Nebr...............................                                                      I, 911; In, 1662
Mobile Bay and Harbor, Ala.:
   Defenses of.....          ..............                .       .........................                               I, 10, 15
   Harbor lines at Pinto Island.................................................                                               , 910
   Improvement of ...             ......................................                                           I, 409; n, 1407
   Improvement of bar at entrance to bay .......                                    .       .....................  I, 413; iI, 1412
   Removal of sunken dry dock at Mobile................                                                    ....... , 438; n, 1437
Moccasin River (Contentnia Creek), N. C. See Contentnia                                    Creek.
XXVIII                                                        INDEX.

Mokelumne River, Cal.:                                                                                                        Page.
    Improvement of ..............................................                                                 i, 828; In, 2192
    Wreck in Sycamore Slough. ............                               ..............                           I, 834; iI, 2197
Moline Harbor, Ill.:
    Improvement of.......                     .................................                                    I, 558; i, 1635
    Improvement of Mississippi River between Missouri River and St.
      Paul.------------------------------------------------..
    Operating and care of lock .............                                  ................
                                                                                                                        11,
                                                                                                                   I, 554;      1621
                                                                                                                   i, 559; nI, 1636
Monongahela River, W. Va. and Pa.:
    Harbor lines from Lock No. 5 to Lock No. 6..........................                                                      I, 911
    Improvement of, in Pennsylvania (at Locks 2, 3, 5, and 6)....... I, 613; II, 1754
    Improvement of, in West Virginia (Locks Nos. 8 to 15) ..........                                               I, 612; II, 1753
    Improvement of Pittsburg Harbor-.....-................                                                  .      I, 625; ii, 1785
    Operating and care of locks and dams--..                                                 ..
                                                                                       .......         ....        I, 616; 11, 1758
Monroe Harbor, Mich., improvement of ....                  __             .............                   - 769, 772; II, 2106
Monroe Lake, St. Johns River, Fla. See Volusia bar.
Monterey, Cal., monument at-.... .............                                  ..... ...                       . I, 951; III, 2523
Montesano, Wash. See Chehalis River.
Monuments, statues, etc. See Statues, memorials, etc.
Moore, James A., construction of Puget Sound - Lake Washington Canal
      by...---....... ....... .......................                               ...............               I, 882; ii, 2257
Mooringsport, La. See Cypress Bayou.
Morgan Canal, Tex., operating and care.......................                                               .... I, 477; Ii, 1501
Mormon Channel, San Joaquin River, Cal., improvement of. ........I,                                                  827; III, 2191
Morse, Winslow (schooner) wreck of ..........                         ....               .............                 I, 157, 1090
Mortar batteries. See Fortifications.
Mosquito Creek Canal, S. C. See Santee River.
Mott, Fort, N. J., wreck near.........                          .........................                              I, 198, 1152
Mount Desert, Bar Harbor, Me., constructionof breakwater........................ , 31, 966
Mount Holly Branch, Rancocas River, N. J. See Rancocas River.
Mount Hope Bay. Mass. See Fall River Harbor.
Mount Rainier National Park, Wash., construction of road.......... 1, 944; III, 2513
Mud Lake, La. See Mermentau River.
Mud River, Ga. See Savannah-Fernandina waterway.
Mud River, S. C. See Savannah-Beaufort waterway.
Murderkill River, Del., improvement of.............                                        ............ I, 214, 216, 1174
Muscle Shoals Canal, Tennesse River, Ala.:
    Construction of...............................................                                                 I, 595; ii, 1693
    Operating and care.................................                                   ............             I, 600; 1i, 1705
Muscogee (Muskogee), Okla. See Muskogee.
                                              -..-..-......
Muskegon Harbor, Mich., improvement of ........--   ...                                                        , 736; 1i, 2036
Muskingum River, Ohio:
   Harbor lines at Zanesville, Ohio...............................     .............          I, 911
   Improvement of...         ......................................                I, 636; II, 1809
   Operating and care of locks and dams........................... I, 637; ii, 1811
Muskogee, Okla., examination of Arkansas River to....................                  . .. I, 548
Mystic River, Mass.:
   Examination and survey ---.........................................                          I, 78
       Improvement of_...................................................                                             I, 57, 987
       Improvement of, below mouth of Island End River................                                            , 57, 59, 988

                                                                   N.

Nansemond River, Va., improvement of............                                . . . . . ...........       , 278,           1256
Nanticoke River, Del. and Md., improvement of.............                                     .........   I, 243,           1203
Nantucket Harbor, Mass., construction of harbor of refuge..............                                  , 78, 79,           1007
Nantucket Sound, Mass., wrecks in .......................                                       I, 99, 100, 1024,            1025
Napa River, Cal., improvement of................                                ..............     ,829, 831; IIn,           2195
Narragansett Bay, R. I.:
    See also Wickford Harbor.
    Defenses of................................................................                                              I, 10
       Improvement of ................................................                                              I, 90, 1016
Narrows of Lake Champlain, N. Y. and Vt.:
    Improvement of.................................................                                                 I, 76, 1002
    Wrecks in........................................................                                               I, 77, 1003
Nasel River, Wash. See Willapa River.
Nashville, Tenn. See Cumberland River.
                                                                   INDEX.                                                                 XXIX

Natalbany River, La. See Tickfaw River.                                                                                                       Page.
National Coast Defense Board........                             ...................                       ...         ....       .......        ,10
National parks. See Parks.
Navesink (North Branch of Shrewsbury) River, N. J. See Shrewsbury River.
Navigable waters. See Bridges, Rivers and harbors, and Wrecks.
Navigation, Congresses of, Permanent International Commission ..............                                                                 I, 910
Neches River, Tex., improvement of...........................                                                                 I, 498; 11, 1526
Neches-Sabine Canal, regulations governing navigation of-.................... 1, 911
Neebish channels, St. Marys River, Mich., improvement of.........                                                              I, 760; 11, 2092
Neenah (Fox) River, Wis. See Fox River.
Neponset River, Mass., improvement of....... ...........                                                    ............                  , 67, 996
Neuse River, N. C.:
    Improvement of ..                      ..........                 ...............                    .......              I, 294; i, 1278
    Improvement of waterway between Newbern and Beaufort ...... r, 299; ir, 1284
Neversink River, N. Y., examination and survey...........................                                                                      , 198
Newark Bay, N. Y. and N. J. See Arthur Kill and Passaic River.
New Baltimore, N. Y. See Hudson River.
New Bedford Harbor, Mass.:
     Defenses of........................................                                                              .....          ....       I, 10
     Improvement of ............                      ......................................                                            , 83, 1010
Newbern, N. C.:
     See also Neuse and Trent rivers.
     Improvement of waterway to Beaufort, N. C....................                                                              , 299; I, 1284
Newburyport Harbor, Mass., improvement of ..........................                                                                     I, 48, 981
New Haven Harbor, Conn.:
     Construction of breakwaters .. ....................                                                .............               I, 110, 1038
     Examination and survey, including Morris Cove... .....................                                                                    , 100
     Improvement of, by dredging, etc ...............                                                  ..... ...........              , 108, 1036
     Improvement of West River. ....................................                                                                  , 108, 1036
     Wreck in................................                                         ....................... I, 124, 1054
New Jersey-Staten Island Channel:
     Harbor lines in Arthur Kill around Buckwheat Island.................. I, 910
     Improvement of ..............................................                                                          I, 168, 169, 1111
New London Harbor, Conn., improvement of, including Shaws and Winthrop
  coves.......................................                                            ......................                    I, 102, 1029
New Orleans, battle of, monument to the memory of soldiers who fell in. I, 949; nI, 2519
New Orleans Harbor, La.:
     Defenses of...            .. ...... ........................................                                                  ...... , 15
    Improvement of. See Mississippi River, Head of Passes to Ohio River.
Newport Harbor, R. I., improvement of .............................                                                                    I, 92, 1018
Newport River, N. C.:
    See also Beaufort Harbor.
    Improvement of waterways between Beaufort and New River.... I, 303;
    Improvement of waterway between Newbern and Beaufort....... r, 299; 11, 1284
                                                                                                                                        11,     1287

New River, Fla., examination of. .........................                                                           .............            I, 386
New River, N. C.:
    Examination and survey up to Jacksonville. ........                                             ...................                        , 315
    Improvement of.................                              ............................                                   , 303; I, 1287
    Improvement of waterways to Swansboro and Beaufort.. I, 303, 304, 306; i, 1.288
New Rochelle, N. Y. See Echo Bay Harbor.
New Shoreham, Block Island, R. I. See Block Island.
Newton, Ala. See also Choctawxhatchee River.
Newtown Creek, N. Y., improvement of................                                                     ...............            I 143, 1073
New Whatcom (Bellingham) Harbor, Wash.:
     Examination and survey...................                                              ...                ...............                 , 893
    Improvement of Whatcom Creek waterway..................... , 887; I, 2260
New York Bay and Harbor, N. Y.:
    Ambrose Channel, improvement of, including dredge construction...... 1, 159,
                                                                                                                                       1092, 1154
    Arthur Kill. See Arthur Kill.
    Battery, the, removal of shoal in Hudson River off Pier A...... I, 158, 160, 1093
    Bay Ridge Channel. See Bay Ridge Channel.
    Bayside Channel, improvement of ..........................                                                                     I, 158, 1091
    Bronx River. See Bronx River.
     Brooklyn. See East River, Gowanus Bay, and Newtown Creek.
     Coney Island Channel. See Coney Island Channel.
XXX                                                              INDEX.

New York Bay and Harbor, N. Y.-Continued.                                                                                              Page.
    Defenses of...............................................                                                                         I, 10
    Dredges, construction of............                            . .................                             I, 158, 1092, 1154
    East (Ambrose) Channel. See Ambrose Channel, supra.
    East Chester Creek. See East Chester Creek.
   East River. See East River.
    Flushing Bay. See Flushing Bay.
    Gedney Channel, improvement of. ................................                                                          I, 158, 1.091
    Governors Island, enlargement of................................                                                          I, 163, 1097
    Gowanus Bay. See Gowanus Bay.
    Harlem River. See Harlem River.
    Hell Gate, East River. See East River.
    Hudson (North) River, removal of reef off Pier A.............                                                     I, 158, 160, 1093
    Hudson River, wrecks in .................                                             ..........                 , 157, 1099, 1100
    Hutchinson River (East Chester Creek). See East Chester Creek.
    Improvement of, including dredge construction ...............                                                    , 158, 1091, 1154
    Kill van Kull. See Kill van Kull:
    Lemon Creek. See Lemon Creek.
    Main Ship Channel, improvement of.............................                                                            I, 158, 1091
    Narrows to the sea, improvement from, including dredge construction... I, 158,
                                                                                                                                1091, 1154
    Newark Bay. See Arthur Kill and Passaic River.
    New Jersey-Staten Island Channel. See New Jersey-Staten Island Channel.
    Newtown Creek. See Newtown Creek.
    North (Hudson) River. See Hudson River, supra.
    Red Hook Channel. See Red Hook Channel.
    Red Hook Point, New York Harbor, modification of harbor lines......... , 910
    Regulations to govern navigation of....                                     .........                                                 160
                                                                                                                                      I..........,
    Spuyten Duyvil Creek. See Spuyten Duyvil Creek.
    Staten Island-New Jersey channel. See Staten Island-New Jersey Channel.
    Staten Island Sound. See Arthur Kill.
    Supervision of .......................                           ......                      ................        I, 904; III, 2281
    Wrecks in.......................................                                                        I, 164, 165, 1099, 1100
Niagara Falls, Niagara River, N. Y. See Niagara River.
Niagara River, N. Y.:
    Black Rock Harbor and Channel, improvement of.............                                                            I, 804; r, 2155
    Buffalo Harbor, improvement of. ............................                                                          I, 800; II, 2148
    Control and regulation of waters of, and preservation of the falls.. I, 939; III, 2503
    Erie Basin and Black Rock Harbor, improvement of Buffalo en-
       trance ...............                  ....         ....................................                                     I, 803;
                                                                                                                                    II, 2154
    Erie Basin and Black Rock Harbor, improvement of Lake Erie en-
       trance....... .......                  .............................                              ......           I, 802; nI, 2153
    North Tonawanda to Lake Erie, including Tonawanda Harbor, im-
       provement from .............................                                                          .....        I, 805; I, 2160
    Surveys, etc. See Northern and Northwestern Lakes.
    Wreck of scow Trader off Strawberry Island..................... i, 806; ii, 2161
Nimick, Alex (steamer), wreck of.............................                                                             I, 683; In, 1939
Niobrara River, Nebr., construction of bridge across ................                                                     , 948; III, 2517
Nolin River, Ky. See Green River.
Nomini Creek, Va., improvement of .................                                            ............... I, 263, 1234
Noncommissioned officers. See Corps of Engineers.
Nooksak River, Wash., improvement of. See Puget Sound and tributaries.
Noonday rocks, San Francisco Harbor, Cal., examination and survey....... I, 834
Norfolk Harbor, Va.:
     Improvement of, and approaches, including Hospital Point. I, 273, 274, 1251, 1252
     Improvement of waterway to Albemarle Sound, via Currituck Sound. I, 284, 1266
    Improvement of we te "way to sounds of North Carolina (to Pamlico Sound),
       via Pasquotank hiver.......................                                            ..................               I, 282, 1264
     Improvement of Western Branch, Elizabeth River..................                                                          I, 276, 1254
    Jamestown Exposition grounds, pier construction and dredging..... I, 271, 1248
    Wrecks in ................................................                                                     .....       I, 288, 1271
North Branch, Chicago River, Ill. See Chicago Harbor and River.
North Branch, Shrewsbury River, N. J. See Shrewsbury River.
North Brother Island, East River, N. Y., examination and survey between
  South Brother Island and..............................................                                                                , 157
                                                            INDEX.                                                          XXXI

                                                                                                        Page.
North Carolina Cut, N. C., waterway via. See Norfolk-Albemarle Sound water-
way.
North Carolina sounds, improvement of waterways to Norfolk, Va... I, 282, 284, 1264
Northeast River, N. C., improvement of ........................                              I, 307; n, 1290
Northern and Northwestern Lakes:
    Channels in waters connecting, improvement of.............                               I, 753; In, 2059
    Commercial statistics, Sault Ste. Marie canals, Mich............. I, 759; In,2072
    Control and regulation of waters of Niagara River, and preservation of
      Niagara. Falls ....................................                 ..........        I, 939; i , 2503
    Surveys, charts, etc ....................................                              I, 931; in. 2477
    Water levels..................... ......................
    Water levels on east shore of Lake Michigan, variations in.............
                                                                                     I, 939;      2477, 2499
                                                                                                        I, 723
                                                                                                               in,
North Fork, Forked Deer River, Tenn. See Forked Deer River.
North Fork, Skagit River, Wash. See Puget Sound and tributaries.
North Hero Island channel (The Gut), Lake Champlain, Vt.:
    Examination and survey ..............................................                                I, 78
    Improvement of ......................................................                                 I, 74
North Landing River, Va. and N. C., waterway via. See Norfolk-Albemarle
  Sound waterway.
North (Hudson) River, N. Y. See Hudson River, under New York Bay and
Harbor.
North River, N. C., waterway via. See Norfolk-Albemarle Sound waterway.
North River, Wash. See Willapa River.
North Tonawanda, N. Y. See Tonawanda Harbor.
Norwalk Harbor, Conn., improvement of..............................                              I, 117, 1046
Nyack, N. Y. See also Hudson River.
                                                                  0.
Oakland Harbor, Cal., improvement of ..............................                                            I, 822; in, 2185
Obion River, Tenn., improvement of ..........................                                                    I, 582; II, 1675
Occoquan Creek, Va., improvement of .....................                                                    I, 256, 260, 1230
Ocean City, N. J., wreck off .....                    .............................                                    I, 224, 1184
Ocklawaha (Oklawaha) River, Fla. See Oklawaha River.
Ocmulgee River, Ga., improvement of .......................                                             I, 343, 346; n, 1341
Oconee River, Ga., improvement of ........................                                              I, 343, 344; n, 1339
Oconto Harbor, Wis., improvement of..............................                                                I, 686; ii, 1949
Office of the Chief of Engineers, officers on duty in.........................                                                I, 952
Officers, engineer, civilian assistants to..................                                 ................                   I, 27
Officers of the Corps of Engineers. See Corps of Engineers.
Ogdensburg Harbor, N. Y., improvement of........................                                               I, 814; III, 2174
Ohio River:
     Falls at Louisville, Ky., improvement at.............                                 I, 644, 649; nI, 1857, 1871
     General improvement             ................................                                       . I, 606; ii, 1717
     Harbor lines from Dam No. 3, at Glen Osborne, Pa., to Dam No. 5, near
       Rochester, Pa........ .............. ...............................                                                   I, 911
     Indiana chute, Louisville, Ky, improvement of .................                                             I, 645; II, 1857
     Locks and Dams 1-6, operating and care........................ I, 624; II, 1779
     Locks and Dams 2-7, construction of.........................                                               I, 621; II, 1776
     Locks and Dams 8, 11, 13, 18, 19, 26, construction of...........                                            I, 627; In, 1787
     Lock and Dam 37, construction of.............................                                               I, 609; i, 1743
     Louisville and Portland Canal, Ky., enlargement of. ...........                                             I, 644; In, 1857
     Louisville and Portland Canal, Ky., operating and care......... I, 649; nI, 1871
     Pittsburg Harbor, Pa., improvement of .......................                                               I, 625; II, 1785
     Pools 3, 4, and 6, dredging in ..................................                                           I, 623; In, 1778
     Snag boats, operation of..................................... I, 611, 623; II, 1751, 1778
Okanogan River, Wash., improvement of .........................                                                I, 889; in, 2262
Oklawaha River, Fla., improvement of ................                                       ...........          I, 365; nI, 1362
Oldmans Creek, N. J.:
     Examination and survey .....................                                                   .....................     I, 224
     Wreck in ......................          ..................................                                       I, 224, 1183
Old Tampa Bay, Fla. See Tampa Bay.
Olympia Harbor, Wash., improvement of .....                                  .................                 I, 879; ni, 2254
Ontario Lake. See Northern and Northwestern Lakes.
Ontonagon Harbor and River, Mich., improvement of................ I, 673; in, 1923
 XXXII                                                            INDEX.

                                                                                                  Page.
Orange Mills flats, St. Johns River, Fla., improvement at........... I, 363; n, 1359
Orange River, Fla., improvement of- ------. .                                         I,371; n, 1369
                                                                                 -............-----
Ordnance. See Fortifications.
Oregon, dredging plant for harbors on coast ......................                    I,844; nI,  2211
Osage River, Mo., improvement of ......             ..........     .......          . I,579; n, 1669
Oswegatchie River, N. Y. See Ogdensburg Harbor.
Oswego Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ........     .           .........      ....... I, 811; III, 2170
Ottertail Lake and River, Minn., survey of (hydrological observations). I, 573; II, 1652
Ouachita River, Ark. and La., improvement of..........                   .....        I, 515; n, 1554
Oyster Creek, Tex., improvement of............................                        I,478; ii, 1501
                                                                      P.
Pacific coast, monument at Monterey, Cal., to commemorate the taking posses-
   sion of, by Commodore Sloat...................................                                                             I,951; in, 2523
Packard rock, San Francisco Harbor, Cal., examination and survey........... I, 834
Pagan River, Va., improvement of..............                                                 .......        ...         .....    I,278, 1257
Pamlico River; N. C:, improvement of......................                                                    . . ....          I,291; II, 1275
Pamlico Sound, N. C.:
      Improvement of waterway to Beaufort Inlet ..................                                                              I,298; ii, 1281
      Improvement of waterway to Norfolk, Va..........................                                                             i, 282, 1264
Pamunkey River, Va.:
      Improvement of..........                                     ...........................                               I, 256, 258, 1228
      Wreck in....                 ...........................................                                                       , 272, 1249
Parks, public:
      District of Columbia, improvement and care.............. I,248, 929; III, 2329
      Mount Rainier National Park, Wash., construction of road...... I, 944; ii, 2513
      Potomac Park, D. C., roadway at tidal reservoir...............                                                  ......       I,250. 1211
      Yellowstone National Park, improvement of .................                                                             I,942; n, 2509
Pascagoula River, Miss.:
      Improvement above Dog River...............................                                                               I,427; ii, 1428
      Improvement below Dog River.............................                                                                 I,425; n, 1426
      Improvement below Dog River, diversion of funds to construction of
         dredge for coast harbors .................                                               ................              I,438; nI,1436
Pasquotank River, N. C., waterway via. See Norfolk-North Carolina sounds
  waterway.
Passaic River, N. J.:
      Examination of....................................................... I,187
      Improvement of ................................................                                                              I,165, 1101
      Wreck in................................................. I,187, 1130
Pass Cavallo, Tex.:
      Examination and survey of channel to Port Lavaca .......................                                                             I,497
      Examination and survey to Port O'Connor (on Matagorda Bay) for harbor.. I,497
      Improvement of channel to Aransas Pass......................                                                              , 488; ii, 1508
Patapsco River, Md.:
     Improvement of, and channel to Baltimore.... ....                                                   ....      ....... I,224, 1185
     Improvement of channel to Curtis Bay.............................                                                              , 227, 1188
     Improvement of harbor at southwest Baltimore (Spring Garden)..... I, 228, 1189
Patchogue River, N. Y. (see Great South Bay) .........................                                                             I,146, 1076
Pawcatuck River, R. I. and Conn., improvement of ....................                                                              I,100, 1027
Pawpaw River, Mich. See St. Joseph Harbor.
Pawtucket (Seekonk) River, R. I., improvement of..................... , 88, 1014
Peace Creek, or River, Fla. See Charlotte Harbor.
Pearl Harbor, Hawaii:
     Defenses of...................................................... , 17, 18, 19
     Improvement of ................                                          .......................                        I,893; ii, 2267
Pearl River, Miss.:
     Improvement between Edinburg and Jackson ..................                                                              Ir436; ii, 1435
     Improvement below Rockport..........                                        ..................                  ... I,435; IT, 1434
Pedee rivers, S. C. See Great Pedee and Little Pedee.
Peekskill Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ....................... , 151, 152, 1085
Pend Oreille River, Wash., improvement of..................                                                         , 889, 890; in, 2262
Penobscot Bay, Me., examination and survey from Macks Point to Cape Jelli-
  son ..................................................................                                                                   I, 48
Penobscot River, Me.:
     Improvement of ..........                                 ..................................                                      , 35, 970
     Wreck in ....................                                       ................                     ...........             I,47, 979
                                                             INDEX.                                                         XXXIII

                                                                                                                                Page.
Pensacola Bay and Harbor, Fla.:
     Defenses of .....              .................................                                                             , 15
                                                                                                                                 I...
     Improvement of harbor, including dredge construction.....                                              . i, 400; i, 1397
Pentwater Harbor, Mich., improvement of-....
Pepperell Cove, Me., examination and survey-..-.----------------------
                                                                                                         I, 738, 740;
                                                                                                      ...-............      11, 2040
                                                                                                                                 I, 48
Pequonnock (Poquonock) River, Conn. See Bridgeport Harbor.
Pere Marquette Lake, Mich. See Ludington Harbor.
Perkins, J. H. G. (schooner), wreck of ...........................                                             ...... I, 47, 979
Permanent International Commission of Congresses of Navigation-..........--                                         ..-        , 910
Permits:
     For construction of bridges------------.........-------................................ I, 912
     For diversion of water from Niagara River, N. Y., and for transmission of
         electrical power from Canada................................                                         I, 939; III, 2503
     For erection in Porto Rico of structures other than bridges................                                              I, 912
     For erection of structures other than bridges...........................                                                 I, 920
Perquimans River, N. C., improvement of .............................                                               I, 285, 1267
Perriwig bar, Delaware River:
     See also Delaware River.
     Improvement of..............................................                                                   I, 193, 1147
Petaluma Creek, Cal., improvement of ........................                                             . I, 829; IIr, 2193
Petersburg, Va. See Appomattox River.
Petoskey Harbor, Mich., improvement of...........................                                              I, 752; II, 2055
Philadelphia, Pa., improvement of Delaware River at...................... I, 189, 1131
Philippine Islands, defenses of........................................                                             I, 17, 18, 19
Pierhead lines, establishment of............................................                                                  I, 910
Piermont, N. Y. See Hudson River.
Pierre, S. Dak. See Missouri River.
Pierre, Fort, S. Dak. See Missouri River.
Piers:
     Construction of, at Jamestown Island, James River, Va..........                                              . I, 271, 1248
     Permits for construction of............                      ...............................                             I, 920
     Permits for construction of, in Porto Rico.............................                                                  I, 912
Pigeon Bayous, La., improvement of.............................                                                I, 445; ii, 1460
Pike Creek, Wis. See Kenosha Harbor.
Pine Bluff, Ark., examination and improvement of Arkansas River
  at.........................             .....................                           I, 538, 539, 548; I, 1581, 1583
Pine Island Sound, Fla.:
     See Charlotte Harbor.
     Examination of, from Wulfer bulkhead to Blind Pass, etc., and to Captiva
         bulkhead ...............................................................................                               , 386
Pine Lake and River (Charlevoix Harbor), Mich., improvement of... I, 750; 11, 2053
Pine River, Minn. See Mississippi River reservoirs.
Pinto Island, harbor lines in Mobile Harbor..........................                                                     . I, 910
Pittsburg Harbor, Pa.:
     See also Allegheny, Monongahela, and Ohio rivers.
     Improvement of..........................................                                                  I, 625; II, 1785
Plantation Creek, Ga., improvement of ...........                                   ...............            I, 349; 11, 1344
Plaquemine Bayou, La., improvement of...                                   ...............
                                                                                        .............          I, 445; in, 1460
Plymouth Harbor, Mass.:
     Examination and survey..-..........................................-                                                        I, 78
     Improvement of ......................                           .....                                              I....................
                                                                                                                        I, 71, 998
Pocomoke River, Md., improvement of ............................                                              I, 231, 239, 1200
Point Harbor Channel, N. C., examination of................................... I, 289
Point Isabel, Tex., examination and survey of Arroyo, Colo., from Harlingen to,
  on Laguna Madre.............                        ....... ..............................                                  I, 497
Point Judith Harbor and Pond, R. I.:
     Construction of harbor of refuge...............................                                                  I, 93, 1019
     Examination of harbor of refuge, with plan and estimate for improvement.. I, 100
     Improvement of pond entrance. ..............                             ......... ..          . .....           I, 96, 1021
Point Pleasant, W. Va., monument to commemorate battle of revolution fought
  at ..............................               ...............................                              , 952; II, 2525
Pokegama Falls, Mississippi River, Minn. See Mississippi River reservoirs.
Pollock Rip Slue, Nantucket Sound, Mass., wrecks on and near.._.......                                                I, 99, 1024
Ponchatoula River, La. See Tickfaw River.
Poquonock River, Conn. See Bridgeport Harbor.
Porcupine Island, Bar Harbor, Me., construction of breakwater............ I, 31, 966
          9001-- NG 1909-3
XXXIV                                                           INDEX.

                                                                                                                                    Page.
Portage Lake and Lake Superior canals, Houghton County, Mich. See Kewee-
  naw Bay-Lake Superior waterway.
Portage Lake, Manistee County, Mich., improvement of harbor of refuge.... I, 746;
                                                                                                                                   in, 2049
Portage River, Houghton County, Mich., waterway via. See Keweenaw Bay-
  Lake Superior waterway.
Portage River, Ohio. See Port Clinton Harbor.
Port Arthur Canal, Tex.:
     Improvement of (see Sabine River) .................                                       ..........              I, 498; ii, 1526
     Operating and care of ..........................-----------------------------------.                               , 500; ii, 1529
     Regulations governing navigation of .............. . ....................                                                        I, 911
Port Bolivar, Tex., improvement of channel to..-..-.........-....-.. I, 474; i, 1495
Port Chester Harbor, N. Y.:
     Examination and survey of ..............                             ..-..           ... .             ............. I, 158
     Improvement of_ ..... .-.................................                                                               I, 124, 1055
Port Clinton Harbor, Ohio, improvement of ..........................                                                   I, 782; ii, 2124
Port Harford, Cal. See San Luis Obispo Harbor.
Port Huron, Mich., improvement of Black River at..................~,                                                       774; nu, 2108
Port Jefferson Harbor, N. Y., improvement of                             -..........................                          , 132, 1061
Portland, Ky. See Louisville and Portland Canal.
Portland, Me.:
     Defenses of......................                 .. ...............                    ..................                         I, 10
     Improvement of harbor.............................................                                                         I, 41, 974
Port Lavaca, Tex., examination and survey of channel to Pass Cavallo......... I, 497
Port O'Connor, Tex., examination and survey of Matagorda Bay from Pass
  Cavallo to, for harbor.....................                      ......          ... .......          ..............                I, 497
Porto Rico:
     Erection of structures in navigable waters of............................                                                        I, 912
     Improvement of San Juan Harbor.............................                                                     I, 897; III, 2273
Port Royal (Beaufort) River, S. C., waterway between Beaufort, S. C., and
  Savannah. See Savannah Harbor improvement.
Port Royal Harbor, S. C., wreck at naval station................... I, 333; n, 1317
Port Royal Sound, S. C., defenses of.......................                                          ...............                     , 10
Portsmouth Harbor, N. H.:
     Defenses of..............            .....................................                                                     . r, 10
     Examination and survey of Pepperell Cove-........ .....................                                                            I, 48
Port Tampa, Fla. See Tampa Bay.
Port Washington Harbor, Wis., improvement of....................                                                       I, 697; in, 1969
Port Wing Harbor, Wis., improvement of--..........................                                                    I, 667; ii, 1916
Position finders, range and. See Fortifications.
Post, engineer, Washington, D. C., buildings for.............                                                   ..........       ... I, 945
Potomac Park, Washington, D. C.:
     Improvement of..................................                                          I, 248, 929, 1211; III, 2355
     Roadway across inlet gates at tidal reservoir ...................                                           .. .. I, 250, 1211
Potomac River:
     See also Washington, D. C.
     Aqueduct Bridge, Washington, D. C., repair of.............                                                      I, 921; in, 2301
     Examination and survey at Alexandria, Va............................                                                             I, 273
     Harbor lines at Alexandria, Va........................................                                                           I, 910
     Highway bridge at Washington, D. C.........................                                                     I, 923; I, 2303
     Improvement at Washington, D. C................                                        ..............                  I, 248, 1209
     Improvement below Washington, D. C...........................                                                          r, 252, 1.216
     Potomac Park, D. C., roadway across inlet gates at tidal reservoir ........                                                     I, 248,
                                                                                                             929, 1211; itr, 2355
     Wreck at Alexandria, Va..........................................                                                        , 272, 1249
     Wreck off Point Lookout, Md..........                        ......          .........                                 I........,
                                                                                                                                272, 1250
Potter, Jennie French (schooner), wreck of ..........                                .......          ......           . I, 100, 1024
Power, water, Niagara River, N. Y., control and regulation of ...... I, 939; III, 2503
Preliminary examinations and surveys .....................................                                                           I, 29
Presque Isle Harbor, Marquette, Mich. See Marquette Bay.
Presque Isle Peninsula, Erie, Pa. See Erie Harbor.
Printing Office. Government, Washington, D. C., telegraph line.                                                 See Public
  buildings and grounds.
Projects. See Fortifications and Rivers and harbors.
                                                        INDEX.                                                          XXXV

                                                                                                                          Page.
Providence Harbor and River, R. I.:
      Improvement of .......................... . ......                                ..         .........      . I, 90, 1016
      Improvement of Pawtucket (Seekonk) River ..............                                ..........             I, 88, 1014
    Removal of Green Jacket shoal .....................................                      I, 91, 1016
Provincetown Harbor, Mass., improvement of ........................                       I, 71, 73, 999
Public buildings and grounds, District of Columbia.-....           -.--       .. .-.-. I, 929; III, 2331
Public parks. See Parks.
Puget Sound, Wash.:
    Defenses of....................   ......................................-                        , 10
    Improvement of, and tributaries, including dredge construction,
                                                                                                  I, 876; in, 2211, 2251
    Improvement of waterway to Lake Washington, by United States and by
       James A. Moore-----------...............------------.............--------------..............        , 882; in,     2257
    Inspection, etc., of fish traps---...................                        .... -.               . I, 879; in,       2253
Pultneyville Harbor, N. Y., improvement of...................                              ....           I, 808; In,      2166
Punta Gorda, Fla. See Charlotte Harbor.
Purification of water supply of Washington, D. C. See Washington.
Puyallup River, Wash.:
    See also Puget Sound and tributaries and Tacoma Harbor.
    Examination and survey up to Puyallup..................                                       ...........             , 893

                                                             Q.
Quarantine Island, Honolulu Harbor, Hawaii, reclamation of. .......                                             I, 895; iI, 2270
Queenstown Harbor, Md., improvement of ......... ...... .. .....                                               I, 231, 232, 1193
Quinnipiac River, New Haven, Conn. See New Haven Harbor.
                                                      R.
Raccoon Creek, N. J., improvement of................................                                     I, 202, 1159
Racine Harbor, Wis., improvement of.............                                ..............       I, 700; 11, 1973
Rainier, Mount, National Park, Wash., construction of road ........                                 I, 944; In, 2513
Raisin River, Mich. See Monroe Harbor.
Range and position finders. See Fortifications.
Rappahannock River, Va., improvement of .......                                .... .............          , 264, 1235
Raritan Bay and River, N. J.:
    See also Keyport and Shoal harbors.
    Improvement of bay ..............                    . .......................                       i, 173, 1113
    Improvement of river...................................                                        I, 174, 177, 1119
Red Hook Channel, New York Harbor, N. Y.:
    Harbor lines, modification of.................                           ...................                 I, 910
    Improvement of.............                     ...          ............................. I, 162, 1095
Red Lake and Red Lake River, Minn.:
    Improvement of (see Red River of the North) ...................                                  I, 569; II, 1.650
    Survey of (hydrological observations) .........................                                  I, 573; i, 1652
Red River, La., Ark., Tex., and Okla.:
    Cypress Bayou and lakes to Jefferson, Tex. See Cypress Bayou.
    Examination between Fulton, Ark., and the Washita, Okla ..............                                       I, 548
    Improvement above Fulton, Ark............... ...............                                     I, 509; 11, 1543
    Improvement below Fulton, Ark.............................                                       I, 511; 11, 1547
    Rectification of mouth by Mississippi River Commission .......                                  I, 909; in, 2641
Red River of the North, Minn. and N. Dak., improvement of........ I, 569; n, 1650
Regulations and rules:
    For navigation of canals ...............................................                                     I, 911
    For opening of drawbridges...........................................                                        I, 911
    For floating loose timber and logs, etc_................................                              ..     I, 912
Republican River, Kans., examination of bank line in front of Fort Riley
  Military Reservation ............                     ..................... .....               . I, 582; ii, 1674
Reservations, public. See Parks.
Reservoirs:
    Mississippi River, headwaters. See Mississippi River.
    Tidal reservoir, Potomac River, D. C. See Potomac River.
    Washington Aqueduct, D. C. See Washington.
Resolutions of 60th Congress, 2d session, and 61st Congress, 1st session, affecting
  Corps of Engineers............................ ........................                                     in, 2527
XXXVI                                                            INDEX.

Richmond Harbor, Va. See also James River.                                                                    Page.
Riley, Fort, Kans., examination of bank line of Republican River.... I, 582; In, 1674
Rivers and harbors:
    Appropriations for operations during the past year-......-................                                 I, 28.
    Board of Engineers for- --------.......................                                      I, 898; III, 2277
    Board of Engineers, The.... ... ........                   .. ......................                I, 10, 955
    Bridges, construction and alteration---...             ----------.....           -----...- .     . I, 912, 919
    Bridges, regulations for opening of draws---......-                  --......--   .....            .---- I, 911
    Engineer divisions ......................------------------------------------------...                     I, 29
    Estimate of appropriations for--..........--------------------------------.                          I, 29, 904
    Expenditures during the past year --......................-----------------------------...            i, 28, 29
    Harbor lines, establishment of ..... .................................
                                                      -          -                                           I, 910
    Regulations for navigation of canals ---...--------------.--....                     ---.-                I, 911
    Regulations for opening of drawbridges ............                             ....... ........          I, 911
    Regulations governing the running of loose logs, steamboats, and rafts on
          certain streams--..-------------...----.................---------------.........------...............--------------......       I, 912
   Status of works ----............................................----------------------------------------.....---....---     I, 28
   Structures other than bridges, permits for erection of-......-..............                                              I, 920
   Structures other than bridges, permits for erection of, in Porto Rico ...... Ir, 912
Roads:
   At tidal reservoir, Potomac Park, D. C., across inlet gates.....-..--........ , 248,
                                                                                                        929, 1211; III, 2355
   In Mount Rainier National Park, Wash -.---..-...-....--...                       -.--                       I, 944; III, 2513
    In Yellowstone National Park-....--...-.....           - -- - - - -           -...- ..    .     ...        I, 942; in, 2509
Roanoke River, N. C., improvement of................................                                                  I, 287, 1270
Roche Harbor, Wash. See Puget Sound and tributaries.
Rockaway Inlet, N. Y., examination and survey of entrance to Jamaica Bay at. I, 158
Rock Creek, Md., wreck in--................................-----------------------------------------. I, 247
Rockhall Harbor, Md., improvement of----------------------------................................ I, 231, 1192
Rockhaven, N. Dak., ice harbor. See Missouri River improvement.
Rockland Harbor, Me., improvement of.                                   .................................                             I, 36, 971
Rockport, Mass., harbor of refuge in Sandy Bay. See Sandy Bay.
Rock River, Ill. See Illinois and Mississippi Canal.
Romerly Marsh, Ga., waterway via. See Savannah-Fernandina waterway.
Rondout Harbor, N. Y., improvement of---------.............------------......----...... I, 151, 1084
Root River, Wis. See Racine Harbor.
Rouge River, Mich.:
    Improvement of..--...---------------...........---------------........---.....--          I, 769, 770; Ii, 2105
    Wreck in---------------............----------....---...............----------------...--..... I, 780; 11, 2119
Rough River, Ky., operating and care of lock and dam -.............                                I, 657; Ii, 1897
Round Lake, Mich. See Charlevoix Harbor.
Rules and regulations. See Regulations and rules.

                                                                       S.
Sabine Lake, Pass, and River, Tex.:
    Improvement of mouth of river and of channel through lake..... I, 498; In, 1526
    Improvement of Sabine Pass Harbor...........................                             I, 501; in, 1530
Sabine-Neches Canal, regulations governing navigation of.................                                  I, 911
Saco River, Me., improvement of ......................                       ............              I, 43, 976
Sacramento River, Cal.:
    See also California D6bris Commission.
    Examination and survey up to Feather River........................... I, 838
     Improvement of....                 ....................................                I, 835; III, 2199
Saginaw River, Mich., improvement of ................................ I, 765; it, 2098
St. Albans Harbor, Vt., examination and survey...................                         .........          I, 78
St. Andrews Bay, Fla., examination and survey............................. I, 409
St. Clair Canal, Lake, and River, Mich.:
     Improvement of channels in waters connecting the Great Lakes.. I, 753; i, 2059
     Operating and care of canal....................................                         I, 775; Ii, 2109
    Regulations to govern navigation of river..................................                            I, 911
St. Croix Lake and River, Wis. and Minn., improvement of.........                            I, 566; in, 1648
St. Croix River, Wis. and Minn., regulations to govern navigation of draw-
  bridge over....................................................                                 ........ , 912
St. Francis River, Ark., improvement of ..............................                       I, 545; in, 1590
St. George Sound, Fla. See Carrabelle Harbor.
                                                          INDEX.                                                     XXVII

St. Johns River, Fla.:                                                                                                                       Page.
      Examination and survey from Jacksonville to Sanford..........---.......... , 385
      Examination and survey from Sanford to Lake Harney -..-..........-... I,385
      Improvement at Jacksonville------........-------.......................---------------- I,362; 11, 1358
      Improvement between Jacksonville and the ocean-....---..~... . I,359; ii, 1355
      Improvement between Jacksonville and Palatka, including Orange Mills
        flats..........................-----------------------------------------------....                                     , 363; ii,1359
      Improvement of Volusia bar, and between Volusia bar and Lake Mon-
        roe.....------------...................----------------------........................---------------- I,364; 11,1360
St. Jons River, Del.:
      Examination and survey up to Dover..-...............-........-..-.....-.                                                               , 224
      Improvement of........ ............ .................... .........                                                           I,219, 1177
St. Joseph, Mo., improvement of Missouri River............. .. ..... I,573; iI, 1655
St. Joseph Harbor and River, Mich.:
      Improvement of harbor........---------------....-----...........--------.......------........                            , 723; 11, 2019
      Improvement of river......................................                                                     I, 723, 725; Ii, 2020
St. Lawrence River, N. Y. See Cape Vincent and Ogdensburg harbors.
St. Louis, Mo. See Mississippi River.
St. Louis Bay and River, Minn. and Wis. See Duluth Harbor.
St. Lucia (Lucie) Inlet, Fla., examination and survey...................                                                                     I,386
St. Marys River and St. Marys Falls Canal, Mich.:
      Channels in waters connecting the Great Lakes, improvement of. I, 753; 11, 2059
      Commercial statistics........................................                                                          I,759; 11, 2072
      Improvement of Hay Lake and Neebish channels. .............                                                            I,760; I, 2092
      Improvement of river at the falls.................                                          .............              I,755; 11, 2060
      Operating and care of canal............................................ I,758; I, 2067
      Surveys, etc. See Northern and northwestern lakes.
St. Michael Canal, Alaska, improvement of ....................... I,891;                                             in,                      2264
St. Paul, Minn.:
      See also Mississippi River.
      Bridge across Mississippi River to Fort Snelling................. I,948; in, 2515
      Gauging Mississippi River at.................................                                                          I,573; Ii, 1653
St. Peters River, Minn. See Minnesota River.
Sakonnet Harbor and River, R. I.:
     Improvement of harbor.............................................                                                               I,85, 1011
     Improvement of river....................................................... I,87, 1014
Salem River, N. J., improvement of..........................                                                  .........             I,204, 1161
Saline River, Ark., examination and survey                                            ..............................                         I,547
Sally (barge), wreck of ..............................................                                                               , 224, 1183
Salmon Bay, Wash. See Puget Sound-Lake Washington waterway.
Salmon Creek, N. Y. See Pultneyville Harbor.
Sampit River (Georgetown Harbor), S. C. See Winyah Bay.
San Antonio Bay, Tex., channel from Aransas Pass-Pass Cavallo channel to
   Victoria, on Guadalupe River, via. See Aransas Pass.
San Antonio estuary, Cal. See Oakland Harbor.
Sandbeach (Harbor Beach), Mich. See Harbor Beach.
San Diego Harbor, Cal.:
      Defenses of-----------------.................-------------...............                                                               I,10
      Improvement of.............                                ..........   .......................                       I,815; nI, 2177
Sandusky Harbor, Ohio, improvement of............................                                                             I,783; 11, 2125
Sandwich Islands. See Hawaiian Islands.
Sandy Bay, Cape Ann, Mass., construction of harbor of refuge............. I,52, 984
Sandy Lake, Minn. See Mississippi River reservoirs.
San Francisco Bay and Harbor, Cal.:
      Defenses of...............................................................                                                               , 10
      Engineer depot at Fort Mason...                                 .............................                               I,24, 25, 26
      Examination and survey of Mission Bay, Packard, Whiting, Invincible,
        Noonday, Anita, and Fifteen-foot rocks; also Centissima and Sears rock
        and rocks near Mail Dock in Bonita channel.. -.......................                                                                I,834
      Harbor lines between Point San Pablo and Castle Rocks, modified.......                                                                 I,911
      Improvement of Oakland Harbor...... ......                                                                              , 822; II,2185
                                                                                                                            I...............
Sanitary District of Chicago, Ill., application to reverse flow of Calumet
   River........................................................... , 715; I,1998
San Jacinto River, Tex. See Galveston-Houston waterway.
San Joaquin River, Cal.:
      See also California Debris Commission.
      Examination and survey of, and Stockton Channel, from San Francisco Bay
        to Stockton.. ......................................                                                       ............              I,834
XXXVIII                                                     INDEX.

San Joaquin River, Cal.-Continued.                                                                                      Page.
    Improvement of--------------------....-------- ---....                                                -I,   826; nI, 2190
    Improvement of Stockton and Mormon channels- -.-.-.......- -                                            . , 827; II, 2191
San Juan Harbor, P. R.:
      Improvement of .....................-..-.....                                                  --      I, 897; II,         2273
    Regulations to govern navigation of -.--....                        ..........                       ........-----.       i, 911
San Leandro Bay, Cal. See Oakland Harbor.
San Luis Obispo Harbor, Cal., improvement of .....                                    ---................        I, 820; II, 2183
San Pablo Bay, Cal.:
    Examination and survey from San Francisco Bay to Stockton, including.... I, 834
    Improvement of----------......---.....--------........-----------................-------.....                 , 825; III, 2189
San Pedro Bay and Harbor, Cal.:
    Construction of deep-water harbor......-....................... , 816; III, 2178
    Examination and survey of Wilmington inner harbor for increase of depth. I, 822
    Harbor lines in inner harbor---------........----------..................-------........-----..------.....                  , 911
    Improvement of Wilmington inner harbor....................... I, 818; TI, 2179
Santee River, S. C., improvement of.......--.....-----................. , 323; in, 1307
Sarasota Bay, Fla., improvement of--..-............................. I, 373; in, 1371
Sasanoa River, Me., improvement of..................-------------------------------.................. I, 37, 971
Saugatuck Harbor, Mich., improvement of................ ..-------..... I, 728; ii, 2024
Saugatuck River, Conn., improvement of .............                                     . . . ........ I, 118, 122, 1050
Saugerties Harbor, N. Y., improvement of..-..-........... --........-...                                                 , 150, 1083
Saugus River, Mass. See Lynn Harbor.
Sauk River, Wis. See Port Washington Harbor.
Sault Ste. Marie, Mich. See St. Marys River.
Sausal Creek, Cal. See Oakland Harbor.
Savannah Harbor and River, Ga.:
    Defenses of-------------------.........................-------------......--------......---...........     --------- , 10
    Examination and survey of waterway to Fernandina, Fla.............                                                         I, 358
    Improvement of harbor, including dredge construction and waterway to
       Beaufort, S. C--------.........----......----------................-----------.......--. i, 333, 1155; i, 1319
    Improvement of river above Augusta................ ..........
    Improvement of river between Augusta and Savannah........... I, 337;
                                                                                                                         i,in,
                                                                                                                   I, 339;       1335
                                                                                                                                 1333
    Improvement of waterway to Fernandina, Fla.................                                                          in,
                                                                                                                   I, 353;       1348
Saybrook Harbor, Conn. See Connecticut River.
Sayville, N. Y. See Browns Creek.
Schodack Creek, N. Y. (see Hudson River)............ _...............                                                   I, 148, 1078
School of Application, Engineer, buildings for................                                               .........         I, 945
Schuylkill River, at Philadelphia, Pa., harbor lines at......................                                                  I, 910
Scott Point, Tennessee River, Ala., lock and dam at Hales bar. See Tennessee
  River.
Scuppernong River, N. C., improvement of --........................                                                      in,
                                                                                                                     , 289;      1273
Seacoast defenses. See Fortifications.
Seagoing dredges:
     Construction of. See Dredge boats.
    Performances of..............................................                                                              I, 899
Searchlights. See Fortifications.
Sears rock, San Francisco Harbor, Cal., examination and survey.............. I, 834
Seattle, Wash. See also Puget Sound-Lake Washington waterway.
Sea walls. See Fortifications.
Sebewaing River, Mich., improvement of...........................                                                        in,
                                                                                                                   I, 767;       2100
Secretary Creek (Warwick River), Md. See Warwick River.
Sedro-Woolley, Wash., examination and survey of Skagit River to.......--...... I, 893
Seekonk (Pawtucket) River, R. I., improvement of -................                                                  ... I, 88, 1.014
Sevona (steamer), wreck of.........................................                                                I, 683; in, 1940
Shallotte River, N. C., improvement of .............................                                                     in,
                                                                                                                   I, 314;       1299
Shaws Cove, New London, Conn. See New London and Thames River.
Shears, The, Delaware Bay, Del., harbor of refuge. See Delaware Bay.
Sheboygan Harbor, Wis., improvement of ..................                                             ........ I, 695; i, 1965
Shilshole Bay, Wash. See Puget Sound-Lake Washington waterway.
Ship Island Harbor and Pass, Miss., improvement of pass, and channel to Gulf-
  port ......    ...............................................                                                   I, 432; i, 1432
Shoal Harbor, N. J., improvement of ..........................                                                  I, 174, 181, 1124
Shreveport, La. See Cypress Bayou and Red River.
Shrewsbury River, N. J., improvement of.........                                  ......           .
                                                                                                 .........              I, 184, 1127
Shultz, N. D. (deck scow), wreck of.........------------------------------- .. I, 187, 1130
Silver Springs Run, Fla., improvement of. See Oklawaha River.
                                                          INDEX.                                                XXXIX

Sioux City, Iowa. See Missouri River.                                                                               Page.
Sioux River, S. Dak., ice harbor at Sioux City, Iowa. See Missouri River im-
  provement.
Sites for fortifications. See Fortifications.
Skagit Bay, Wash. See Swinomish Slough.
Skagit River, Wash.:
     See also Puget Sound and tributaries.
     Examination and survey to Sedro-Woolley..                     ....            ................               . I, 893
Skidaway Narrows, Ga., improvement of ..... ......                        ... ...        .......       I, 354; 11, 1350
Slack-water systems. See Canals and Waterways.
Sloat, Commodore, monument at Monterey, Cal., to commemorate the taking
  possession of Pacific coast by............. ......................                                  I, 951; II, 2523
Smyrna River, Del., improvement of ...................                               ...........             I, 220, 1178
Snake River, Idaho, Oreg., and Wash., improvement of ..........                                       I, 845; II, 2211
Snelling, Fort, Minn., bridge across Mississippi River to St. Paul.... I, 948; II, 2515
Snohomish River, Wash.:
     See also Everett Harbor and Puget Sound and tributaries.
     Examination and survey up to Lowell.......................                                     ........        I, 893
Snoqualmie River, Wash. See Puget Sound and tributaries.
Soda (Sodo) Lake, La. See Cypress Bayou.
Somers Cove, Md. See Crisfield Harbor.
South Branch, Chicago River, Ill. See Chicago Harbor and River.
South Branch, Shrewsbury River, N. J. See Shrewsbury River.
South Brother Island, East River, N. Y., examination and survey between
  North Brother Island and.........................                               .....               _........ . I, 157
South Chicago Harbor, Ill. See Calumet Harbor.
Southern Branch, Elizabeth River, Va. See Elizabeth River.
South Fork, Forked Deer River, Tenn., improvement of Forked Deer River.. I, 582,
                                                                                                            583; II, 1676
South Haven Harbor, Mich., improvement of ... ......                         ... ........               I, 726; II, 2022
South Hero Island Channel (The Gut), Lake Champlain, Vt.:
     Examination and survey .............................................                                             I, 78
      Improvement of........................................                                   ........              I, 74
South Kingston, R. I. See Point Judith Harbor and Pond.
South Norwalk Harbor, Conn. See Norwalk Harbor.
South Nyack, N. Y. See Hudson River.
South Pass, Mississippi River:
    Examinations and surveys...............                 ....... ...... ...... I, 444; ii,                        1459
    Maintenance and improvement of channel...................                         I, 442; II,                    1451
Southport.Harbor Conn., improvement of ......................                      I, 118, 120,                      1049
South River, N. J., improvement of .............................                   I, 174, 178,                      1121
Southwest Baltimore, Md., improvement of harbor of .............                 ....     I, 228,                    1189
Southwest Pass, Mississippi River:
    Improvement of, including shoals between Cubits Gap and Head of Passes. I,                                       439;
                                                                                                                II, 1441
     Regulations to govern navigation of.............                   .....................              I, 911
Spa Creek, Md., between Annapolis and Eastport, regulations to govern opera-
  tion of drawbridge.......................................................                                I, 912
Sparkill River, or Creek, N. Y. See Hudson River.
Spring Garden, Baltimore, Md., improvement of harbor at... ........... I, 228, 1189
Spuyten Duyvil Creek, N. Y. See Harlem River........... ...........                                 I, 141, 1070
Squan (Manasquan) River, N. J. See Manasquan River.
Stamford Harbor, Conn., improvement of.........................                               I, 118, 119, 1048
Staten Island, N. Y. See Lemon Creek and Staten Island-New Jersey channel.
Staten Island-New Jersey Channel:
     Harbor lines in Arthur Kill, around Buckwheat Island................... I, 910
     Improvement of........       ........................................                          I, 169, 1.111
Staten Island Sound (Arthur Kill), N. Y. and N. J. See Staten Island-New
  Jersey Channel.
Statues, memorials, etc.:
     In public grounds, Washington, D. C..........................                             I, 929; III, 2359
     Monument marking battle of revolution fought at Point Pleasant, W. Va_ . I, 952;
                                                                                                                II, 2525
      Monument marking birthplace                    of George Washington ........... I, 929;                  III, 2367
      Monument on Kings Mountain                     battle ground, S. C.............. I, 950;                 in, 2521
      Monument at Monterey, Cal.,                     to commemorate the taking possession                     of
       Pacific coast by Commodore                    Sloat........... . ...... ........ I, 951;                ir, 2523
XL                                                               INDEX.

Statues, memorials, etc.--Continued.                                         Page.
    Monument to memory of soldiers who fell in the battle of New Orleans... I,949;
                                                                                                                               in, 2519
Statutes of 60th Congress, 2d session, and 61st Congress, 1st session, affecting
  Corps of Engineers---..                     .........               ............                       .........-------------------------------------------.
                                                                                                                                      , 2527
Steamboats, etc. See Dredge boats and Wrecks.
Stilaguamish River, Wash. See Puget Sound and tributaries.
Stillwater Harbor, Minn. See St. Croix River.
Stockbridge Landing, Lake Winnebago, Wis. See Fox River.
Stockton Channel, San Joaquin River, Cal.:
     Examination and survey of San Joaquin River and, from San Francisco
        Bay to Stockton.....................................                                     ..................                 . ,834
     Improvement of. ...........................................                                                          I, 827; Ii, 2191
Stockton Harbor, Cal. See Stockton Channel.
Stockton Harbor, Me., examination and survey of Penobscot Bay from Macks
   Point to Cape Jellison...............                                   .............. .......................                        I,48
Stonehouse bar, Hudson River, New Baltimore, N. Y. See Hudson River.
Strong, Eliza H. (steamer), wreck of................................ . I, 780; ii, 2119
Structures, bridges and other, erection of. See Bridges, Buildings, Piers, and
   Rivers and harbors.
Sturgeon Bay and Lake Michigan Canal, Wis.:
     Improvement of, including harbor of refuge...................... I, 688; ii, 1951
     Operating and care...........................................
Subic Bay, Philippine Islands, defenses of .............                                                    .............
                                                                                                                                11,
                                                                                                                           I, 690;       1957
                                                                                                                                I,17, 18, 19
Submarine defense. See Fortifications.
Suisun Bay, Cal., examination and survey from San Francisco Bay to Stockton,
   including..............................................................                                                             I,834
Suisun Creek, or channel, Cal., examination and survey................ ..... . I, 834
Sullivan Falls Harbor, Sullivan River, Me., improvement of ...... ....... I,32, 967
Sulphur River, Ark. and Tex., improvement of .............. .....
Sunflower River, Miss. See Big Sunflower River.
                                                                                                                  _             1i,
                                                                                                                           I, 510;       1545
Sunken craft. See Wrecks.
Superior Bay and Harbor, Wis.:
     Harbor lines in front of Minnesota Point-.......... .................                                                              I,911
     Improvement of.............................................                                                           I,661; i, 1902
     Regulations governing navigation of.................................                                                               I,911
Superior Lake:
     See also Northern and Northwestern Lakes.
     Improvement and care of waterway to Keweenaw Bay....... I,674, 677; i, 1925
     Wrecks in............                         ..........           ...................                             11,
                                                                                                                     , 683;       1939, 1940
Supervision of New York Harbor, N. Y .........                                                                            i, 904; Ili, 2281
Surface levels. See Water levels.
Surveys:
     Made in compliance with river and harbor act March 3, 1909-............. I,29
      Of Northern and Northwestern Lakes.......................... i, 931; iii, 2477
      Of rivers and harbors, estimate of appropriation for...................                                                      I,29, 904
Susquehanna River, Md., improvement of .............                                                           ...........      I,230, 1191
Suwanee River, Fla., improvement of............................ I,379, 380;
Swan Creek (Toledo Harbor), wreck in.............................
                                                                                                                                11,      1381
                                                                                                                            I,797; ii, 2141
Swansboro, N. C., waterway to New River and Beaufort.... , 303, 304, 306; I, 1288
Swinomish Slough, Wash.:
     See also Puget Sound and tributaries.
     Harbor lines at La Conner, Wash..................................                                                                  I,911
      Improvement of................                            .....................                                      , 885; , 2259
Sycamore Slough, Mokelumne River, Cal., wreck inI...............                                                          I,834; IiI, 2197
Syracuse (sand sucker), wreck of .............                                           ...............                    I,797; 11, 2141
                                                                        T.
Tacoma Harbor, Wash., improvement of .............     ..........    I, 880; II, 2255
Tallahatchie River, Miss.:
    Improvement of, to mouth of Coldwater River-.... .... ....    1,526, 527; 11,1567
    Improvement above mouth of Coldwater River to Batesville. i, 526, 528; ii, 1567
Tampa Bay and Harbor, Fla.:
       Defenses of..........................            ...................                    ..................                     , 10
       Examination and survey from Clearwater Harbor, including Boca Ceiga
         Bay.................... . .................... ..... . ...... ...... .... i, 385
                                                            INDEX.                                                             XLI

Tampa Bay and Harbor, Fla.-Continued.                                                                       Page.
    Examination and survey of Hillsboro Bay from turning basin to head of
      estuary toward Ybor........................ .. ............ .........                                I, 385
    Improvement of bay_.........................................                              I, 376; ii, 1374
    Improvement of Hillsboro Bay and River-....................... I, 377; n, 1376
    Regulations governing navigation of..-----------..........------------......................--------- I, 911
    Wrecks in Hillsboro Bay and River...........-------------------.....--.....------......            , 384, 385
Tar River, N. C., improvement of .....-.......-....---..---            .........              I, 291; I, 1275
Tarrytown Harbor, N. Y., improvement of ......--.........           --       ....--....             I, 154, 1087
Taunton River, Mass.:
    See also Fall River Harbor.
    Improvement of.................................................                                   I, 86, 1012
Taylors Bayou, Tex. See Sabine River and Port Arthur Canal.
Tchefuncte River, La. See Chefuncte River.
Tchula Lake, Miss., improvement of ..........................                         I, 526, 530; ii, 1568
Teche Bayou, La.:
    Improvement of...........................................                                 I, 449; In, 1466
    Improvement of waterway from Franklin to Mermentau .......                                 I, 451; In, 1467
Telegraph line, Government, Washington, D. C. See Public buildings and
  grounds.
Tennessee River:
    Bee Tree Shoals Canal, Ala., improvement of................                                I, 595; In, 1705
      Chattanooga, Tenn., improvement above......................                                              I,   593; II,   1689
    Chattanooga, Tenn., to Riverton, Ala., improvement from ._ ... _ I, 595; In, 1693
    Colbert Shoals Canal, Ala., improvement of ....................                  I, 595; in, 1705
    Elk River Shoals Canal, Ala., operating and care................. I, 600; In, 1705
    Hales bar (near Scott Point) lock and dam, construction of ....... I, 595; In, 1693
    Muscle Shoals Canal, Ala., operating and care................ I, 595, 600; IIn,1705
    Riverton, Ala., improvement below .............................                  I, 599; In, 1703
Tensas River, La., improvement of ............       ................            , 519, 521; in, 1561
Terraceia Cut-off, Fla. See Manatee River.
Terrebonne Bayou, La., examination and survey............................ I, 469
Texas City Harbor, Tex., improvement of channel to Galveston...... I, 473; ii, 1491
Texas, State of:
    Improvement of inland waterways along coast .................                    I, 486; In, 1507
    Removal of water hyacinths in................                 ................. I, 477; In, 1500
Thames River, Conn.:
    See also New London Harbor.
      Improvement of...............................................                                                  I, 102, 1030
The Board of Engineers................................................       I, 10, 955
The Gut (between North and South Hero islands), Lake Champlain, Vt. See
  Champlain Lake.
Threemile Rapids, Columbia River, Oreg. and Wash. See Columbia River.
Thunder Bay Harbor and River, Mich. See Alpena Harbor.
Tickfaw River, La., improvement of, including tributaries....... I, 454, 457; In, 1473
Tidal reservoir, Potomac Park, D. C., roadway across inlet gates............     , 248,
                                                                                                        929, 1211; III, 2355
Tillamook Bay and bar, Oreg., improvement of, including dredge construc-
  tion...........                                                                            I................................,
                                                                                                 843, 844; III, 2209, 22].1
Tinicum Island and Tinicum Island range, IDelaware River, wrecks near.. I, 198, 1152
Tiverton, R. I. See Sakonnet River.
Toledo Harbor, Ohio:
     Improvement of .........................................                                                   I, 780; In, 2121
     Wreck in Swan Creek ......................                          ...................                    I, 797; In, 2141
Tombigbee River, Ala. and Miss.:
     Columbus to Walkers Bridge, Miss., improvement from...... ... .,                                               421; In, 1420
     Demopolis, Ala., improvement below (construction of locks and
        dams).......           ........................................                                          , 416; In, 1414
     Demopolis, Ala., improvement below (maintenance of channel).. I, 418; In, 1417
     Demopolis, Ala., to Columbus, Miss., improvement from.......                                           . I, 420; In, 1419
     Operating and care of locks and dams..........                              ...............                I, 423; in, 1421
Tonawanda Harbor, N. Y., improvement of. ......................                                                 I, 805; i, 2160
Torpedoes. See Fortifications.
Townes, J. A. (steamer), wreck of ............                          ........................                                I, 531
Townsend, Adeline (schooner), wreck of..............................                                                   I, 224, 1183
Trader (scow), wreck of...........................................                                               I, 806; i, 2161
Trail Creek, Ind. See Michigan City Harbor.
XLII                                                      INDEX.

                                                                                                                        Page.
Trappe River, Md. See La Trappe River.
Traps, fish:
    In Puget Sound, Wash., inspection, etc., of ................                                       . I,879; .II, 2253
    Permits'for construction of. .....                        .................................                        I,920
Traverse Lake, Minn., survey of (hydrological observations)......... I,573; ii, 1652
Trent River, N. C.:
    Examination and survey from Newbern to Trenton-..................... I,315
    Improvement of.......................................
Trinity River, Tex.:
                                                                                                    r, 294, 296;     11, 1279
    Improvement above mouth.. ......                               .............              . ...... I,506; ni,1536
    Improvement of mouth...... ......                         .................                     I, 478, 481; ii, 1503
    Operating and care of Lock and Dam No. 1...................                                             I,507; ii, 1541
Troops, engineer, equipment of. ...........                         ...................               I,25, 959, 961, 963
Troy, N. Y.:
    See also Hudson River.
    Harbor lines at ..................................................                                                 i , 910
Tuckahoe Creek, or River, Md., examination and survey from Wayman's
  wharf to Hillsboro........ ....                    ........                ..........                ..........       I....248
                                                                                                                        I,
Tuckerton Creek, N. J., improvement of..............................                                              I,208, 1165
Tug Fork, Big Sandy River, W. Va. and Ky., improvement of .. ....I, 638; 11, 1825
Turners Cut, N. C., waterway via. See Norfolk-North Carolina sounds water-
  way.
Turtle Bayou, Tex., improvement of...........................                                               I,478; ii, 1507
Turtle Cove, Tex., improvement of channel via .....................                                          , 490; n1,1510
Turtle River, Ga. See Brunswick Harbor.
Twelvemile Bayou, La. See Cypress Bayou.
Twelvemile Creek, Fla. See Orange River.
Twin rivers, Wis. See Two Rivers Harbor.
Two Harbors, Minn. See Agate Bay.
Two Rivers Harbor, Wis., improvement of ............................                                         , 692; ii, 1961
Tyaskin (Wetipquin) Creek, Md., improvement of.................                                           I,231, 242, 1202

                                                               U.

Union Lake, Wash., improvement of waterway via ................                                 I,882; In, 2257
Union River, Me., improvement of....................................... , 33, 968
Upper Chipola River, Fla., improvement of..................                                 I,390, 391; ii, 1389
Upper White River, Ark.:
   Improvement of ...........................................                                    I,539; ii, 1584
    Operation of locks and dams. .....                  ............................             I,540; ii, 1585
Upper Nyack, N. Y. See Hudson River.
Urbana Creek, Va., improvement of.......................                             .........      I,266, 1239
                                                               V.

Vancouver Barracks, engineer depot ...............................                         I,24, 26
Vancouver, Wash. See Columbia River.
Vermilion Bayou, La.:
    Examination and survey to Lafayette................              ...................      I,469
    Improvement of channel, bay, and passes ....................                    , 460; 11, 1477
Vermilion Harbor, Ohio, improvement of...........                                  I,786; ii, 2128
Vessels. See Dredge boats and Wrecks.
Vicksburg Harbor, Miss., improvement of ...........................                I, 524; ii, 1564
Victoria, Tex., improvement of channel to Aransas Pass............                 I, 489; ii, 1508
Vineyard Haven Harbor, Mass., improvement of ......................                     i, 82, 1008
Viva (steam yacht), wreck of........................................                   I,224, 1184
Volusia bar, St. Johns River, Fla., improvement of .............               . . i, 364; ii, 1360
                                                     W.
Wabash River, Ind. and Ill.:
   Improvements above Vincennes, Ind.........................                                              I,652;    ii, 1879
   Improvement below Vincennes, Ind... .........................                                           I,651;    ii, 1879
   Operating and care of lock and dam .......................                                         .    I, 653;   ii, 1880
Waccamaw River, N. C. and S. C., improvement of .................                                          I,315;    ii, 1301
Wakefield, R. I. See Point Judith Harbor and Pond.
Wakefield, Va., monument and wharf............ .................                                          i, 929; ii, 2367
Wallabout Channel, N. Y........................................                                                I,144, 1074
                                                 INDEX.                                              XLIII

                                                                                               Page.
Wappinger Creek, N. Y., improvement of-..--............                ...--.......... , 153, 1086
War College, Army, Washington, D. C., buildings for----...---..................... I,945
War Department maps...........................---------------------------------------------- I,945
Warrior River, Ala.:
    Improvement above Tuscaloosa.......                                              I,414; II, 1412
                                                                                   ..-..-..-..........-.-
    Improvement below Tuscaloosa----...           ..           --...--.......-.i, 414, 415; In,1414
     Operating and care of locks and dams....                                             I,423; II,1421
                                                                                          T.................
Warroad Harbor and River, Minn., improvement of-...........-...-.                                        I,572; In,1651
Warwick River, Md., improvement of ...............--------------------------                         . , 231, 238, 1199
Washington, D. C.:
    Aqueduct Bridge across Potomac River, repair of ............. I,921; III, 2301
    Aqueduct, filtration plant             ................           ..................-- . I,927; III, 2316
    Aqueduct, maintenance and repair..............----------------..........---------. I,923; III, 2305
    Army War College, buildings for......----------------..------------.........-------                ........      , 945
    Barracks. See Washington Barracks.
    Defenses of------......---.......................---------------------------------------.........----             I,10
    Engineer depots---------..---.......------................-----------------.........----..----           I,24, 25, 26
    Engineer Post and School, buildings for--...-..-.......                                ..-...-.......... I,945
    Executive mansion and office-.....                     -.
                                              ---.....-...-....-...                               I,929; III, 2332, 2334
    Highway Bridge, Potomac River.........-                                   . . . ........ i, 923; In, 2303, 2354
    Improvement of Anacostia River at.-.....-...                      __.. ...          ......
                                                                                            .....          . I,252, 1217
    Improvement of Potomac River at ................................ I, 248, 1209
    Improvement of Potomac River below...-...-..- ...-................ i, 252, 1216
    Potomac Park, improvement of ......                  ............... I,248, 929, 1211; III, 2355
    Potomac Park, roadway across inlet gates at tidal reservoir.....                               - -... I,250, 1211
    Public buildings and grounds, and Washington Monument- . . . .. I,929; in, 2329
    Statues and memorials in public grounds-..-.---..........                                      ....i, 929; i, 2329
    Telegraph line connecting executive departments- .--.....-.-.-                              -     . i, 929; II, 2353
    Wrecks in Potomac and Anacostia rivers......-................               -,                       272, 1249, 1250.
Washington, N. C. See Pamlico and Tar rivers.
Washington Barracks, D. C.:
    Engineer depot_........................                         .......                            i, 22, 23, 24, 957
                                                                                             -.....-....
    Engineer Post and School, building for--------..............--------------....                                  I,945
    War College buildings --------................----------------........                                           , 945-
Washington, George, monuments to:
    At Wakefield, Va....-----...----.............----------------.......-------------......... I,929; III, 2367
    At Washington, D. C----------....-.......---.....----...............-----------.......-----------. I,930; in, 2347
Washington Lake, Wash., improvement of waterway to Puget Sound. I, 882; Ii, 2257
Washington State, dredging plant for harbors on coast........ ...... I,844; in, 2211
Washita (Ouachita) River, Ark. and La. See Ouachita River.
Watch Hill Harbor, R. I. See also Pawcatuck River.
Water craft. See dredge boats and Wrecks.
Wateree River, S. C., improvement of .........................                                      I,323, 325; in,   1308
Water hyacinths, removal of:
    From Florida waters.............. ....                               .. ... ..........               I,383; In,1383
    From Louisiana waters......................................                                           I,466; i, 1484
    From Texas waters................ ....                        ........................                I,477; ii, 1500,
Water levels:
    Columbia River, Oreg. and Wash., gauging ....................                                        I,870; in, 2243.
    Datum plane at all harbors on western shore of Lake Michigan............. I, 6831
    Hydrological observations, Ottertail Lake and River and Red Lake and
      Red Lake River, Minn., and Big Stone Lake and Lake Traverse, Minn.
      and S. Dak................................................. i,573; 1, 1652
    Michigan Lake, variations in surface level on east shore ...............                                        I,723.
    Mississippi River and principal tributaries, gauging .............. I, 573; ii, 1653
    Northern and northwestern lakes, levels, etc............... i, 939; II, 2477, 2499
Water power, Niagara River, N. Y., control and regulation of....... i, 939; II, 2503
Waters, navigable. See Bridges, Rivers and harbors, and Wrecks.
Water supply, Washington, D. C. See Washington, D. C.
Waterways (see also Canals):
    Beaufort, N. C., to Newbern. See Beaufort Harbor.
    Beaufort, N. C., to New River. See Beaufort Harbor.
    Charleston to McClellanville, S. C. See Charleston Harbor.
    Chicago (Lockport), Ill., to St. Louis, Mo., and the Gulf, via Illinois, Des Plaines,
      and Mississippi rivers. See Chicago Harbor.
    Franklin, La., to Mermentau. See Mermentau River.
    Galveston to Houston, Tex. See Galveston Bay.
XLIV                                                                    IN DEX.

Waterways-Continued.                                                                            Page.
     Keweenaw Bay to Lake Superior, Mich. See Keweenaw Bay.
     New River, N. C., to Swansboro and Beaufort. See Beaufort Harbor.
     Norfolk, Va., to Albemarle Sound, N. C. See Norfolk Harbor.
     Norfolk, Va., to sounds of North Carolina. See Norfolk Harbor.
     Pamlico Sound, N. C., to Beaufort Inlet. See Pamlico Sound.
     Portage Lake and Lake Superior canals. See Keweenaw Bay.
     Puget Sound to Lake Washington. See Puget Sound.
     Savannah, Ga., to Beaufort, S. C. See Savannah Harbor improvement.
     Savannah, Ga., to Fernandina, Fla. See Savannah Harbor.
     Swan Quarter Bay, N. C., to Deep Bay. See Swan Quarter Bay.
     Texas coast. See Texas.
Watkins, J. E. (schooner), wreck of       .....................    .... ...........            I, 247
Waukegan Harbor, Ill., improvement of ............................                  I, 703; II, 1977
Waverly Creek, S. C., examination from mouth to Waverly Mills....... . . . ... I, 333
.Weirs:
     Fish, in Puget Sound, Wash., inspection, etc., of............             . I, 879; III, 2253
     Permits for construction of................................................... I, 920
Western Branch, Elizabeth River, Va., improvement of ................                  I, 276, 1254
West Fork of South Branch, Chicago River, Ill. See Chicago Harbor and River.
West Galveston Bay, Tex.:
     Improvement of West Galveston Bay and Brazos River Canal-........... I, 478,
                                                                                                  486, 487; II, 1507
    Operating and care of Galveston and Brazos Canal................ I, 491; II, 1511
West Galveston Bay and Brazos River Canal, Tex. See West Galveston Bay.
West Haven Harbor, Conn. See West River.
West Neebish Channel, St. Marys River, Mich., improvement of ..... I, 760; iI, 2092
Westport Harbor, Conn., improvement of .................                                     ..... I, 118, 122, 1050
West River, Conn., improvement of...........................................                                 I, 108, 1036
West Twin River, Wis. See Two Rivers Harbor.
Wetipquin (Tyaskin) Creek, Md. See Tyaskin Creek.
Weymouth Back River, Mass., improvement of ..........................                                            I, 69, 997
Weymouth Fore River, Mass., improvement of........................                                               I, 68, 997
Wharves:
    Permits for construction of...........................................                                           I, 920
    Permits for construction of, in Porto Rico ..............................                                        I, 912
Whatcom (Bellingham) Harbor, Wash.:
    Examination and survey.............                       ............................                           I, 893
    Improvement of Whatcom Creek waterway ...... . .......                     ..                    . , 887; III, 2260
Whitehall, N. Y., Narrows of Lake Champlain. See Champlain Lake.
White House, Washington, D. C. See Public buildings and grounds.
White Lake Harbor, Mich., improvement of .....................                                           I, 738; In, 2039
White Oak River, N. C., waterways to Beaufort, N. C., and New River. See
Beaufort Harbor.
White River, Ark.:
    Examination and improvement at Augusta Narrows.... I, 538, 539, 548; Ii, 1581
    Improvement by open-channel work. ......................                                             I, 536; II, 1579
    Improvement of upper river by locks and dams.............. . 1, 539; iI, 1584
    Operating and care of locks and dams............................ I, 540; II, 1585
White River, Ind., improvement of ....................                          . . .. . . . . .. . . . I. 654; II, 1882
Whiting rock, San Francisco Harbor, Cal., examination and survey............ I, 834
Wicomico River, Md., improvement of......_.........                            ... ............               I, 245, 1205
Willamette River, Oreg.:
    Improvement above Portland ................................                                         I, 856; III, 2225
    Improvement below Portland, including dredge construction-............ r 859,
                                                                                               1153; III, 2211, 2230
    Regulations governing navigation of...................  ............... I, 911
Willapa Harbor and River, Wash., improvement of, including dredge construc-
          tion.......................................................                                I, 871; III, 2245
Wilmington, Cal.:
    Construction of deep-water harbor in San Pedro Bay. ............ I, 816; III, 2178
    Examination and survey of inner harbor for increase of depth............. I, 822
    Improvement of inner harbor.................................            I, 818; II, 2179
Wilmington, Del., improvement of harbor ...................................... I, 212, 1168
Wilmington, N. C. See Cape Fear River.
Winnebago Lake, Wis. See Fox River.
-Winnibigoshish Lake, Minn. See Mississippi River reservoirs.
                                                                 INDEX.                                                                   XLV

Winthrop Cove, Conn. See New London Harbor.                                                                                                  Page.
Winyah Bay, S. C., improvement of...............                                                 ............                  I, 321; 11, 1305
Wire Creek, wreck in East Chester Creek, off ......................--...                                                            I, 157, 1089
Wisconsin Entrance, Duluth-Superior Harbor, Minn. and Wis. See Duluth
Harbor.
Withlacoochee River, Fla., improvement of ................                                                    ......           I, 382; I, 1382
Wolf River, Miss., improvement of. ...............................
Wolf River, Memphis Harbor, Tenn. See Mississippi River Commission.
                                                                                                                                     11n,
                                                                                                                               I, 434;        1433

Wolf (Ahnapee) River, Wis. See Algoma Harbor.
Wolf River (tributary of the Fox),.Wis. See Fox River.
Woodbridge Creek, N. J., improvement of ..............                                                    ..........                I, 171, 1112
Wood, S. A. (schooner), wreck of ...............                                         ..............                        I, 718; 11, 2003
Woods Hole Harbor, Mass., improvement of ..............                                                      .... ......               I, 82, 1009
Wrecks, etc., removal of:
    Absecon Inlet, N. J..............................................                                                               I, 224, 1184
    Alexandria Harbor, Va .........................................                                                                 I, 272, 1249:
    Alpena Harbor, Mich........                       ..............                     ..............                        I, 780; in, 2119
    Anacostia River, D. C.........................................                                                                  I, 272, 1249
    Anclote River anchorage, Fla. .......................................                                                                   I, 384
    Appropriation for...................................................                                                                      I, 28
    Bayside Channel, N. Y .......................                                             .................                     I, 164, 1099
    Beaufort River, S. C .......................................                                                               I, 332; 11, 1316
    Boston Harbor, Mass..............................................                                                                 I, 77, 1002
    Bridgeport Harbor, Conn .............................................                                                           I, 124, 1054
    Bronx River, N. Y.............................................                                                                  I, 157, 1089
    Calumet River, Ill., near Ninety-third street........ ..........                                                           I, 718; ir, 2002
    Cape Porpoise Harbor, Me.........................................                                                                   i, 47, 979
    Castle Island, Boston Harbor, Mass........... ..................                                                                   , 77, 1002
    Caswell, Fort, N. C ............................................                                                               ..... I, 315
    Charleston Harbor, S. C.........................................                                                           I, 332; iin, 1315
    Chesapeake Bay, Md., near Sevenfoot Knoll............................. , 247
    Chicago River, Ill..             ....................                    ...............                       I, 718; Ii, 2002, 2003
    Chincoteague Inlet, Va.........................................                                                                 I, 223, 1182
    Cleveland Harbor, Ohio... .......................................                                                          I, 797; ir, 2141
    Delaware. Capes, N. J............................................                                                               I, 224, 1183
    Delaware River.......................................                                                                 I, 198, 1152, 1153
    Eagle Harbor, Green Bay, Wis ............                               ......................                              I, 706; 11, 1986
    East Chester Bay, N. Y......................... ..................--                                                            I, 156, 1090
    East Chester Creek, N. Y ..........................................                                                             I, 157, 1090
    East River, N. Y..................................                    .....                 .............                       I, 157, 1089
    Erie, Lake .....................................................                                                            I, 780; ir, 2120
    Expenditures during the year.................................                                                       ............. I, 28
    Finns Point, Delaware River, wreck near........................                                                                  , 198, 1153
    Flushing Bay, N. Y...............................                                               ..............                  I, 157, 1090
    Fort Caswell, N. C..............................................                                                                         I, 315
    Fort Mott, N. J...........................                                      .............               .. ........         I, 198, 1152
     Great Pedee River, S. C.................................................. , 333; in, 1317
    Green Bay Harbor, Wis., at Eagle Harbor........................                                                             I, 706; in, 1986
    Half Moon Shoal, Nantucket Sound, Mass-.......... .......                                                          ......       I, 100, 1024
    Hampton Roads, Va..............................                                                     .............               I, 288, 1271
    Handkerchief Shoal, Nantucket Sound, Mass.... ..................                                                                   I, 99, 1024
    Hereford Inlet, N. J., Atlantic Ocean entrance ...............                                                        . . .... I, 224, 1183
    Hillsboro River, Fla .............................................                                                                 I, 384, 385
     Horseshoe Shoal, Nantucket Sound, Mass.......................... I, 100, 1024
    Hudson River, N. Y.................................................... I, 157, 1089, 1090
    Huron, Lake, Mich., Lexington..............................                                                                 I, 780; in, 2119
     Illinois River, Ill., operation of snag and dredge boats........... I, 553; ii, 1617
    James River, near Nansemond River light.......................                                                                    , 288, 1271
     Lexington, Mich.............................................                                                               I, 780; ni, 21.19
     Long Island Sound, N. Y....                          ...............................                                            I, 157, 1090
    Mackey Creek, N. C...............................                                                            ........           I, 288, 1271
    Man-of-War Harbor, Fla ..............                             ............................                                            , 385
    Mantua Creek, N. J .......................................                                                                      I, 224, 1183
     Michigan, Lake, Ill., off Thirty-first street, Chicago, Ill .... ..... I, 718; in, 2003
     Mississippi River above Missouri River ......................                                                              I, 553; i, 1617
     Mississippi River below Missouri River.......................                                                              I, 549; n, 1593
     Mobile Harbor and River, Ala..........                                     .....             ............                  I, 438; ii, 1437
XLVI                                                       INDEX.

Wrecks, etc., removal of-Continued.                                                                                          Page.
    Mokelumne River, Cal., wreck in Sycamore Slough-.............. I, 834; iii,                                              2197
   Mott, Fort, N. J.................                  -..............................     I, 198,                            1152
    Nantucket Sound, Mass.........       ...      . . ..---........... I, 99, 100, 1024,                                     1025
    New Haven Harbor, Conn..........................................                      I, 124,                            1054
    New York Harbor, N. Y..----------.............----------------............ , 164, 165, 1099,                             1100
    Narrows of Lake Champlain, N. Y-................................                        I, 77,                           1003
     Naval Station at Port Royal, S. C...............................                                         I, 333;    11,1317
      Niagara River, N. Y., off Strawberry Island.................... I, 806; ii, 2161
      Ocean City, N. J., three-fourths of a mile off......................       I, 224, 1184
      Oldmans Creek, N. J............................................            I, 224, 1183
      Pamunkey River, Va..........................................               I, 272, 1249
      Passaic River, N. J..............................................          i, 187, 1130
      Penobscot River, at Bangor, Me_.....................................          I, 47, 979
      Permanent appropriation for..........................             .............     I, 28
      Pollock Rip Slue, Nantucket Sound, Mass........................... , 99, 1024
      Potomac River, at Alexandria, Va................................... I, 272, 1249
      Potomac River, Md., off Point Lookout........................... I, 272, 1250
      Port Royal, S. C., at naval station..............................                                       i, 333; in, 1317
      Rock Creek, Md....................................................                                    I, 247
      Rouge River, Mich.............................................                            I, 780; Ii, 2119
      Strawberry Island, Niagara River, N. Y., wreck off............. I, 806;
      Superior, Lake, south shore-.............................                       I, 683; In, 1939, 1940
                                                                                                              2161       11,
      Swan Creek (Toledo Harbor), Ohio_................                  ...........             I, 797; In, 2141
      Sycamore Slough, Mokelumne River, Cal ..........                      ......... I, 834; III, 2197
      Tampa Harbor, Fla., Hillsboro Bay and River........................                             I, 384, 385
      Toledo Harbor, Ohio (Swan Creek)_............................ I, 797; iI, 2141
      Tinicum Island and Tinicum Island range, Delaware River......... I, 198, 1152
      Wire Creek, N. Y., wreck in East Chester Creek-..................... I, 157, 1090
      Yazoo River, Miss--...........................                          ..................            I, 531

                                                                 Y.
Yamhill River, Oreg.:
    Improvement of.............                                  ..............................                    I, 856; III, 2225
    Operating and care of lock and dam........................                                                     I, 858; III, 2229
Yankton, S. Dak. See Missouri River.
Yazoo River, Miss.:
    Improvement above mouth....................................                                                     I, 526; II, 1566
    Improvement of mouth, including Vicksburg Harbor............ I, 524; II, 1564
    W reck in..............................................-...............                                                    I, 531
Ybor, Fla., examination and survey of Hillsboro Bay from turning basin to
  head of estuary toward...........................                                       ........................             I, 385
Yellow Mill Pond, Bridgeport, Conn. See Bridgeport Harbor.
Yellowstone National Park, improvement of......................... I, 942; III, 2509
York River, Va., improvement of... ............                                          .................              I, 256, 1222
York Spit, Chesapeake Bay, Va., shoals opposite. See Patapsco River channel
  to Baltimore.
Yuba River, Cal. See California Debris Commission.

                                                                O
